Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2025-03-19, recording 1 (started 08:59) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2025-03-19/ [0:01:02] Good morning ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the March 19th 2025 Special City Council [0:01:09] meeting. [0:01:10] I want to confirm we have a quorum. [0:01:12] We have six members present in chambers and Jason Brown is on the phone. [0:01:17] First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:01:20] If you wish to join me please rise. [0:01:40] Thank you. [0:01:41] We have one action item under items of consideration today. [0:01:46] Consider a request to approve a development agreement [0:01:50] for an industrial expansion, [0:01:52] and we have our URA Executive Director, Sean Berriger. [0:01:55] Welcome, Sean. [0:01:57] Thank you, Mayor and Council. [0:01:58] Good morning. [0:01:59] So exciting day today for us. [0:02:03] This morning, I'm here to provide an overview [0:02:06] of an expansion project development agreement [0:02:09] is a three-way agreement between the City of Twin Falls, the Urban Renewal Agency, and Chobani, [0:02:15] LLC. The agreement outlines responsibilities, financial commitments, and infrastructure improvements [0:02:22] necessary to support Chobani's planned $500 million expansion in creation of 150 new jobs [0:02:30] at their Twin Falls facility. The proposed infrastructure improvements will support broad [0:02:35] economic growth and job creation throughout the region. [0:02:39] This expansion builds upon the original 2011 development agreement, which established revenue [0:02:44] allocation area, 4-3, to fund eligible components, Perchovani's initial project, as well as contemplated [0:02:53] future expansion opportunities within the life of that revenue allocation area, which runs [0:02:58] through September of 2032. [0:03:02] The Urban Renewal Agency issued bonds to finance some of those initial infrastructure improvements. [0:03:08] Bond payments are made from revenue allocation revenues from Area 4-3. [0:03:14] Additional initial investments in 2011 were also made by the City of Twin Falls. [0:03:20] Community development block grants for the State of Idaho, community contributions and [0:03:24] Chobani itself. [0:03:27] Further expansions of Chobani's facilities and associated water and wastewater improvements [0:03:31] were made through amended agreements in 2016 and 2019. [0:03:36] Those agreements were between the agency and Chobani [0:03:38] for construction and reimbursement agreements. [0:03:42] These improvements were funded by Chobani. [0:03:44] They are eligible for reimbursement [0:03:46] from available revenue allocation revenues [0:03:49] after meeting the bond obligations. [0:03:53] This current expansion project that we're talking [0:03:55] about today requires additional upgrades [0:03:58] to the city's water and wastewater systems [0:04:00] to accommodate an additional 1 million gallons per day [0:04:03] of hot water and 1 million gallons per day [0:04:06] of additional wastewater flow, [0:04:08] as well as improvements to the electric power system. [0:04:12] As a continuation of these previous commitments, [0:04:15] these additional public improvements are eligible [0:04:17] for funding from anticipated new revenue allocation [0:04:22] based upon the increased access value [0:04:24] of these new facilities through the term [0:04:26] of revenue allocation area 4-3. [0:04:28] So, to summarize the responsibilities of the three parties in this, first, the City of Twin [0:04:37] Falls, there are water system upgrades which include the construction of Southwell No. 5. [0:04:43] As you are aware, this is a long planned project by the City of Twin Falls, and it is ready [0:04:50] to move forward. [0:04:52] In addition, there are sewer system upgrades to install a new wastewater gravity mainline [0:04:58] along Pull Line Road from about Eastland and Pull Line, kind of through the mall property, [0:05:03] that is estimated to be 7 to 9 million dollars. [0:05:09] This agreement has 50% of that being funded by the city, as well as 50% by Chobani. [0:05:17] In addition, the agreement contemplates that the city would cover up to $1.5 million in additional funds for that. [0:05:26] that should there be cost overruns, since that project has not been designed yet, the [0:05:32] seven to nine million dollars is a best estimate that we have currently. [0:05:38] Chobani's responsibilities would be the power system upgrades, so that's the installation [0:05:43] of new transmission lines from the Pillar Falls ad-ho power substation that's estimated [0:05:48] at a $3.5 million cost that would be fully funded by Chobani and then eligible for reimbursement [0:05:55] from the urban renewal agency tax increment funds. [0:05:59] Sewer system upgrades, as I mentioned, again 50% funded [0:06:03] by the city and then 50% up to $4.5 million funded [0:06:07] by Chobani, eligible for reimbursement. [0:06:12] In addition, Chobani would pay approximately $3.7 million, [0:06:17] which is the current industrial wastewater discharge fee. [0:06:20] That would be for the expanded use [0:06:22] at the wastewater treatment plant capacity. [0:06:25] There are pre-treatment facility upgrades required as part [0:06:29] of this expansion, estimated to cost $25 million. [0:06:33] That would be funded by Chobani, and again, [0:06:36] potentially eligible for reimbursement, [0:06:40] though there is some discussion about whether that would be a [0:06:43] project that would be included in a revised reimbursement [0:06:47] agreement, but again, fully funded by Chobani and potentially [0:06:51] eligible for reimbursement. [0:06:53] And then permit and impact fees, Chobani would pay their building permit fees, they would advance [0:06:58] fund impact fees, which again would be eligible for reimbursement. [0:07:03] The urban renewal agency responsibilities, the agency will reimburse Chobani from available [0:07:09] additional revenue allocation revenues for the sewer system upgrades of 4.5 million. [0:07:17] impact fees of approximately 700,000 power system upgrades of $3.5 million and then potentially [0:07:25] pre-treatment facility upgrades of 25 million. [0:07:30] Overall the total estimated cost for the improvements is $45.75 million with $8 million coming from [0:07:41] the City of Twin Falls, potentially an additional $1.5, should there be overruns on the sewer [0:07:46] There are a criminal agency through tax increment financing, up to $33.7 million, and Chobani, [0:07:53] up to $29 million if there is no reimbursement requested from the pre-treatment facility upgrades. [0:08:02] So the reimbursement from the revenue allocation revenues will be subject to the bond obligations [0:08:08] that the agency has. [0:08:09] Those will be a priority first, and then additional funds would be available for reimbursements. [0:08:15] In addition, the three parties agree in this agreement to seek working good faith and to [0:08:22] explore additional funding opportunities for these improvements through potential grants [0:08:28] from the state or federal allocations or other opportunities. [0:08:33] The next steps in this, the Urban Renewal Agency Board, met just prior to this meeting. [0:08:38] They did approve of the agreement and have signed. [0:08:42] Council will consider the agreement now. We will develop any amendments to the [0:08:49] current construction or reimbursement agreements that are in place between [0:08:53] the agency and Chobani as needed for these additional utility service agreements [0:09:00] and coordinate the construction schedules between the city Chobani and [0:09:04] the utility providers. With that I would stand for any questions you may have we [0:09:09] also have the city manager here who has been involved in these discussions as [0:09:14] well and certainly can answer any questions. Thank you Sean and thank you [0:09:18] for all your hard work on this and Travis as well and city staff I know [0:09:23] you've been working on this for a while so we appreciate that any questions for [0:09:29] Sean or Travis this morning Chris Reed. Could you give us a time frame on these [0:09:36] types of the time in which this would take to fully fulfill. [0:09:42] So currently, Chavani's intent is to begin immediately on construction of their facilities [0:09:48] with anticipation of being operational toward the end of the year or the first of 2026. [0:09:54] Currently, our systems are able to accommodate the flows that they will need for their ramp [0:10:01] up by committing, by utilizing previously committed capacity that is not yet being used. [0:10:08] In anticipation that these improvements would be made to offset those commitments, there [0:10:14] will be varying timelines for those and Travis may be able to speak those. [0:10:21] So in terms of the water and the sewer improvements, as Sean had shared and as the council knows, [0:10:30] 12th, number five has been our proverbial can that we have kicked down the road the last [0:10:37] three fiscal years where we've taken the funding and we've had to replace it with another project [0:10:43] that became more pressing at that time. [0:10:49] We have that project budgeted for fiscal year 26th, it was already slated. [0:10:54] By advanced funding it, our intent would be to bring a proposal to the council on March [0:11:00] 31st at your next regular meeting to move funds from cash reserves and the water fund to fund [0:11:09] that project and then we would essentially bank the savings in fiscal year 26 by not forwarding [0:11:16] that project and having those funds then fall back into cash reserves would be a temporary [0:11:21] allocation there. [0:11:23] In the sewer fund I plan on doing the same on the 31st coming in asked to have our engineering [0:11:28] team begin that project and moving forward. Both timelines are estimated to take, so the [0:11:36] South One Number Five is already designed. And so that is a construction project and we [0:11:41] believe that that is under a year. We will have to go through the design of the North [0:11:49] East Shore Line segment along Pole Line. We estimate that will take about a year to fully [0:11:54] design and to bid to work through all the appropriate negotiations, then probably a [0:11:59] like time to construct. Right now, we're contemplating a 48-inch [0:12:04] sewer line, and so we'll probably do some advanced acquisition of the pipeline material like we [0:12:10] did on the original Chibani project. So, like Sean said, we'll be able to use the available [0:12:15] capacity with target anticipation of having both infrastructure completed within the [0:12:20] the next 18 to 24 months and then just on a quick side note so the pre-treatment [0:12:26] facility improvements I believe those will advance along with Shobani's [0:12:31] construction. Idaho Power improvements will be over the course of the next couple [0:12:37] two or three years. Okay understanding that the the citizens of Twin Falls [0:12:43] are going to be the city itself is going to be putting in a substantial [0:12:49] amount. Could you speak to the improvements and how it doesn't just [0:12:52] benefit this one user but all citizens in the community itself. Certainly so I [0:13:00] think when you go back even to the original 2011 agreement the private [0:13:07] investment by Chobani allowed for improvements to the public system more [0:13:14] broadly than just running the waterline and the sewer line to a single user. So the [0:13:19] improvements that have been made since that time really have benefited the [0:13:24] broader wastewater and water systems. Same is true for power upgrades and those [0:13:30] types of things. So again it's really the opportunity that we have through the [0:13:35] city's use of funds as well as the tax increment financing that's available [0:13:39] through the urban renewal agency. We take those dollars invested in public [0:13:44] systems that more broadly support the city. [0:13:49] As an example, when you look at the anticipated wastewater sewer line improvements, [0:13:55] those are to serve not only this increased flow, but address that entire flow from that whole side of town. [0:14:05] Thank you. [0:14:06] Thank you. [0:14:07] Any other questions for Sean or Travis? [0:14:13] Okay. [0:14:14] I would entertain a motion then. [0:14:17] And if you would like, I can give you a recommendation, so the staff recommends approval of the expansion project development agreement among the urban renewal agency of Twin Falls and Shobani. [0:14:30] Thank you. [0:14:31] We'll try to do it on one shot. [0:14:41] Yes. [0:14:43] Here, I move that we approve the expansion project development agreement among the urban renewal agency, the city of Twin Falls and Shobani as presented. [0:14:52] Thank you, Grayson Stone. [0:14:54] Thank you, Madam Mayor. [0:14:55] motion to approve the development agreement among the City of Twin Falls, [0:15:01] urban renewal agency and Chibani, in motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Grace [0:15:08] and Stone. Any further discussion? Glory, Rokalvo please. [0:15:15] Chris Reed, Ruth Pierce, Jason Brown, Spencer Cutler, [0:15:27] Yes. [0:15:28] Very Volmer. [0:15:29] Yes. [0:15:30] And Grayson Stone. [0:15:31] Yes. [0:15:32] Thank you. [0:15:33] Motion passes seven to zero. [0:15:34] Thank you, Sean. [0:15:35] That is all the items on today's agenda. [0:15:39] So we are adjourned. [0:15:40] Thank you, everyone. [0:15:41] And thank you, team. [0:15:47] Thank you. [0:15:49] Thanks, Jason.