Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2025-04-14, recording 1 (started 16:59) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2025-04-14/ [0:00:34] Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the April 14th 2025 City Council meeting. [0:00:48] I want to confirm we have a quorum. [0:00:51] We have all seven members present in chambers tonight. [0:00:55] First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:00:57] If you wish to join me please rise. [0:01:19] Thank you. [0:01:20] I might remind everybody that if you could turn off your cell phone if you are at least [0:01:23] put it on silent tonight. [0:01:26] We had a few interruptions last week, [0:01:28] and so I just wanted to remind everybody. [0:01:31] Next on the agenda is a proclamation, [0:01:33] and it's for Youth Appreciation Week for 2025, [0:01:38] whereas the vast majority of youth are concerned, [0:01:41] knowledgeable, and responsible citizens, [0:01:44] and whereas Optimus International, [0:01:46] and the Twin Falls Optimists Club, [0:01:49] have developed and promoted a program [0:01:51] entitled Youth Appreciation Week, [0:01:54] and whereas the citizens of Twin Falls [0:01:56] indicated a desire to join the optimist in expressing appreciation and [0:02:01] approval for the contributions of youth. Therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, Mayor of the [0:02:06] City of Twin Falls, proclaim the third week of April as Youth Appreciation Week. [0:02:11] By this action, let it be known that we have faith in the ability of today's [0:02:16] youth as they assume responsible roles in the future of mankind. [0:02:21] What's up, Stephanie? [0:02:52] Thank you. [0:02:53] I just appreciate you recognizing how important our youth are in the community, and we as an [0:02:59] optimist club always appreciate your partnership on this event, and I also brought invitations [0:03:04] for our luncheon for all of you on Thursday. [0:03:08] So if you can make it, Ruth, I think I forgot to give you the date. [0:03:12] You did. [0:03:13] I did. [0:03:14] I was thinking about that at five o'clock this morning. [0:03:15] No. [0:03:16] I'm so sorry. [0:03:17] Okay. [0:03:18] leave them here but if you could make it we would love to have you it will just be [0:03:22] at the Stone House so again thank you so much for your support appreciate it. [0:03:26] Okay next on the agenda we have the consent calendar council wishes move to [0:03:36] approve the consent calendar is published. Thank you to have a second. [0:03:39] Thank you motion by Chris Reed seconded by Greg Hawkins to approve the consent [0:03:45] calendar as written. Amy Roll-Calvo please. Ruth Pierce, Chris Reed, Greg Hawkins, Jason Brown, Spencer Keller, Sherry Filmer, St. Grayson Stone. [0:03:58] Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. Okay, first under items of consideration we have an action item, a request to approve resolution number 2025-007, [0:04:12] Committee and local match for federal 5307 transit funding and we have Mandy Thompson [0:04:19] assistant to the city manager. Welcome Mandy. Good morning. Good morning. Good morning. Good [0:04:24] morning. Good evening Madam Mayor and Council. So this is a little bit of a housekeeping item. [0:04:32] I'm if you recall at the end of December we passed a resolution essentially assigning [0:04:38] roles, various different roles in our organization to so that we could gain access to trams, which [0:04:46] is the portal for federal transit administration funding that we'll be applying for for right TFT. [0:04:54] One of the documents that we receive from FDA to return assigned was what was called an opinion of [0:05:00] council that our city attorney Bruce Castleton had signed, but one item in there asked for [0:05:08] or some level of documentation that we had allocated local match for these FTA funds. [0:05:18] And because we didn't have anything in our current fiscal year budget, it took a little [0:05:21] bit of back and forth with FTA to come up with a solution of what we could do. [0:05:26] So working with the city manager and the city attorney, we drafted this resolution [0:05:32] because you'll be the same council that will be approving the upcoming fiscal year [0:05:37] 2027 budget, which is where we'll be placing this local match, [0:05:41] both felt that it was appropriate that you couldn't make them, [0:05:45] that you could pass this resolution stating that you will be including local match [0:05:49] for right TFT in the FY27 budget. [0:05:53] Okay. Any questions for Andy on this? [0:05:59] Well, if we had to put this down third and final? [0:06:04] No, I don't think so. It's just a resolution. So we're good. So I will read the resolution number 2025 [0:06:11] dash 007, a resolution of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho committing to fund the local [0:06:19] match in support of its local micro transit. That's there's a typo in that. Oh, no, I said, um, if I said [0:06:28] fiscal year 27 I apologize it's fiscal year 26 that will be placing the funds [0:06:33] into the upcoming budget here okay my apologies okay so supportive it's local [0:06:42] microtransit program in fiscal year 25 26 you have a motion to approve [0:06:49] Grayson Stone thank you Madam Mayor I'll make a motion to approve their [0:06:54] I will make a motion to approve resolution 2025-007, committing local match for federal [0:07:09] 5307 transit funding. [0:07:11] Thank you. [0:07:12] Do I have a second? [0:07:13] Jason Brown? [0:07:14] Thank you. [0:07:15] Motion by Grayson Stone. [0:07:16] Seconded by Jason Brown. [0:07:18] to approve resolution 2025-007, [0:07:22] committing local match for federal 5307 transit funding. [0:07:27] Any further discussion? [0:07:31] Rachel Roquevo, please. [0:07:32] Greg Hawkins? [0:07:33] Yes. [0:07:34] Jason Brown? [0:07:35] Yes. [0:07:36] Spencer Keller? [0:07:37] Yes. [0:07:38] Harry Holmer? [0:07:39] Yes. [0:07:40] Grayson Stone? [0:07:41] Ruth Pierce? [0:07:43] Yes. [0:07:44] And Chris Reed? [0:07:45] Thank you. [0:07:46] Motion passes 7-0. [0:07:47] Okay. [0:07:48] action item, request council consideration to adopt the title six plan and procedures as [0:07:56] required by FTA for federal transportation funding and Mandy, Europe. [0:08:03] Thank you again. [0:08:06] So again, a little bit of a housekeeping item. [0:08:09] The requirement by the FTA for to receive federal funding is that we have a detailed title six [0:08:17] Plan, Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 protects people from discrimination based [0:08:23] on their race, color, and national origin, and programs and activities receiving federal [0:08:28] financial assistance. [0:08:30] The FTA requires that all direct recipients, which we are, are federal transit funds adopted [0:08:36] Title VI Plan in order to ensure non-discriminatory transportation. [0:08:41] The plan has to be improved by council and then we'll have it updated every three years [0:08:45] and compliance with FTA. [0:08:47] So this plan will be valid for 2025 through 2027. [0:08:52] And if you had a chance to read through the document, essentially just create skylines by [0:08:57] which we'll operate. [0:08:58] And then really it's a process and procedures for anyone who would like to file a complaint [0:09:08] with the city if they feel that they were discriminated based on their race, color, and [0:09:12] national origin. [0:09:13] So it just lays out those steps. [0:09:15] And then in addition to that, it also includes a limited English proficiency plan that outlines [0:09:24] how the City of Twin Falls works to communicate with individuals that speak limited English. [0:09:29] So those, the information in the plan are based upon our 2020 census numbers and the only [0:09:35] additional language that were required based upon census data that were required to provide [0:09:42] information in this Spanish. [0:09:44] However, in the plan, we outlined some of the various ways in which members of the team city-wide [0:09:51] work to communicate with residents in the City of Twin Falls that do not speak English. [0:09:57] So those were outlined in the plan and that will be, again, what we going forward if we [0:10:01] have any sort of a language barrier or breakdown in communication due to language, we can fall [0:10:07] back on that plan to help assist riders on ride TFT. [0:10:12] And really, this plan is being required by FTA, but it's really for any department within [0:10:20] the city, and if there were other funds that required this, then we obviously, this would [0:10:25] fulfill that requirement as well. [0:10:28] Okay. [0:10:31] Any questions for Mandy on this? [0:10:34] Okay. [0:10:39] Craig Hawkins. [0:10:40] Make a motion if we're ready. [0:10:42] Jason, is that good? [0:10:44] Okay. [0:10:45] I move that we approve the request council consideration to adopt the Title 6 plan and [0:10:53] procedures as required by the FTA for Federal Transportation Funding. [0:10:57] Thank you, Jason Brown. [0:10:58] Second. [0:10:59] Thank you. [0:11:00] Motion by Craig Hawkins. [0:11:01] Second by Jason Brown. [0:11:02] To approve adoption of the Title 6 plan and procedures as required by FTA for Federal [0:11:08] Transportation Funding. [0:11:11] Any further discussion? [0:11:14] Amy Rokov. [0:11:15] sorry Rachel sorry you guys yes yes yes yes yes thank you motion passes [0:11:29] 70 0 thank you hey next on the agenda is a action item a request to approve [0:11:38] resolution 2025 dash 003 authorizing the destruction of records and we have [0:11:45] of our city clerk, Amy Luna, welcome, Amy. [0:11:48] Thank you, Mayor and Council. [0:11:51] I am here tonight to request a destruction of records, [0:11:54] which I do typically on an annual basis, [0:11:58] pursuant to Idaho Code 59074, [0:12:02] it requires city council to authorize [0:12:04] the destruction of any records. [0:12:07] With that, I stand for any questions. [0:12:11] Thank you, any questions for Amy on this? [0:12:13] Sherry Volmer? [0:12:16] to make the motion if there's no questions? [0:12:18] That doesn't look like it. [0:12:19] I do have a quick question. [0:12:22] Under the public library, we have building insurance inventory [0:12:26] values from 1939. [0:12:30] We just, a few years ago, just, you know, [0:12:33] I don't use every year. [0:12:35] Is this something that we've held on to and just noticed, or? [0:12:39] So we don't have, we haven't typically done this [0:12:43] for the library and this deal. [0:12:45] So these are all new things that they're cleaning up, [0:12:47] That was one that stuck out everything else is 2000s and maybe we should put that in the library. [0:12:55] I mean it seems like it seems like it is going to destroy it. [0:13:00] Craig what are you guys thinking when you pass those? [0:13:06] Let's get a grip here. [0:13:10] Okay. [0:13:11] Sherry Vomer. [0:13:12] I will move to approve resolution number 2025-003 authorizing the destruction of records. [0:13:20] Thank you to have a second, Chris Reed. [0:13:22] I'll second that. [0:13:23] Thank you. Motion by Sherry Volmer. Second by Chris Reed to approve resolution 2025-003 authorizing the destruction of records. [0:13:33] Rachel Rojo, please. [0:13:35] Ruth Pierce. [0:13:36] Yes. [0:13:37] Chris Reed. [0:13:38] Yes. [0:13:39] Jason Brown. [0:13:40] Yes. [0:13:41] Yes, yes, thank you. Motion passes seven to zero. Okay. Next item on the agenda is a consideration of resolution 2025 dash [0:13:55] zero zero five authorizing the lease of watersheds and we have our city manager Travis Rothweiler. Welcome, Travis. [0:14:02] Good evening, Madam Mayor, members of the Council. [0:14:05] This is the annual resolution that we've been bringing to you since 2021, asking for [0:14:11] permission to lease surplus water shares. [0:14:17] Prior to 2021, we just did this through an administrative action in consultation with [0:14:24] the city attorney. [0:14:25] At that time, he said it's an administrative process. [0:14:28] So we handled it entirely internally in 2021, the city attorney at the time, recommended [0:14:35] that we go through a resolution because this is an asset of the city to be able to go forward [0:14:39] and to lease. [0:14:40] So that resolution has been coming to you each and every year since 2021. [0:14:45] And tonight, it's the same resolution that we have about roughly a thousand watersheds [0:14:50] I believe it is that we find that are in surplus. [0:14:54] They are not needed to be able to support the routine operations of the system. [0:15:01] They have come as we continue to grow as part of a community. [0:15:04] We capture those water shares and as those water shares then become part of our total [0:15:10] inventory of shares that we have. [0:15:13] And just speaking clearly, these are surface water shares through the Twin Falls Canal [0:15:18] Company. [0:15:19] These are not anything that comes from the groundwater, but these are all surface water [0:15:23] shares. I have an annual conversation with my good friend at the canal company, Mr. Brown, [0:15:33] and I ask him what is the status of the reservoir, what is the status of our shares, in the event [0:15:42] that we would have to use any portion of these on drier years to augment our normal supply. [0:15:49] And based upon what we're seeing right now, we believe that these shares will be in surplus. [0:15:56] And so we will lease them again to different irrigation districts and to different individual [0:16:05] groups that may need them. [0:16:08] Historically, it's been to the Southwest irrigation district in bulk at a market rate. [0:16:13] funds then fall into the water department as on anticipated revenue and goes to [0:16:19] support the creation of capital projects in the future and with that I'm happy to [0:16:24] stand for any questions. Thank you Travis any questions Chris? I don't have [0:16:28] questions we've done this a few times. Any questions anybody? Okay Chris go [0:16:32] ahead. Move to approve resolution number 2025-005 authorizing the lease of [0:16:38] of water shares. [0:16:39] Thank you, Sherry Vomer. [0:16:41] I'll second. [0:16:41] Thank you, motion by Chris Reed, second by Sherry Vomer, [0:16:45] to approve resolution 2025-005, [0:16:50] authorizing the lease of water shares. [0:16:54] Any further discussion? [0:16:57] Rachel Roll call vote, please. [0:16:59] Ray Cockans? [0:17:00] Yes. [0:17:01] Jason Brown? [0:17:02] Yes. [0:17:03] Spencer Cutler? [0:17:04] Yes. [0:17:05] Jason Stone? [0:17:06] Yes. [0:17:07] Sherry Vomer? [0:17:08] Yes. [0:17:09] Thank you, motion passes seven to zero. [0:17:12] Okay, next on the agenda is an action item. [0:17:15] Are we quest to adopt resolution 2025-006, [0:17:21] declaring city-owned property located at 929 Washington [0:17:25] Street South as surplus to the city needs, [0:17:29] and the city's intent to dispose of that property [0:17:33] via public auction. [0:17:34] And we have our deputy city manager, Mitch Humboldt, [0:17:37] welcome Mitch. [0:17:38] Thank you. [0:17:39] We have a lot of resolutions for you guys. [0:17:42] So this is our fourth and I think final resolution. [0:17:45] So as you're all aware, we recently moved out of Fire Station number three and into the [0:17:50] new one, leaving the former Fire Station kind of surplus to our needs. [0:17:55] A couple of months ago, we went and had that appraised, came in and appraised, actually [0:18:00] back up a few months ago, we rezoned that property to commercial. [0:18:05] And then after that we had it reappraised and it came into a appraisal value of $535,000. [0:18:13] As a surplus property, the state has a fairly well-doubt process for us to go through in [0:18:18] order to dispose of that property. [0:18:21] The first step would be this resolution. [0:18:23] This resolution does a couple of things that declares the value, or the property as surplus, [0:18:28] and then it sets up a public hearing date. [0:18:30] And after tonight, if you choose to adopt this ordinance, we'll publish this resolution [0:18:34] in the newspaper to let everybody know that on May 5th, [0:18:37] we're gonna have a public hearing, [0:18:39] the opportunity for the public to come share their thoughts [0:18:41] about why we should or shouldn't dispose of the property. [0:18:44] At that point, then we can take action after the public hearing [0:18:48] to actually dispose of the property. [0:18:50] So tonight is not that decision. [0:18:52] Tonight is just, we're gonna move forward with public hearing. [0:18:57] And so that's really it. [0:18:59] We've done this a few different times. [0:19:01] On this property, I do wanna talk about one thing [0:19:03] that's a little peculiar about this property [0:19:04] that we haven't really seen before. [0:19:07] We own a cell tower on this property. [0:19:10] We own the tower and we lease space on that tower [0:19:13] to, I want to say, it's AT&T. [0:19:15] And they have antenna on the tower that we own. [0:19:19] They're, we're going to be investigating this, [0:19:22] if you'll recall, a few meetings ago. [0:19:24] We signed a contract with a group that's [0:19:26] going to help us renegotiate a bunch of cell tower leases. [0:19:29] It's going to be working with those guys [0:19:31] to investigate this particular tower and see what that might do to this disposal process. [0:19:38] There's a thought that we might be able to grant an easement to ourselves so that we would [0:19:46] retain ownership of the tower on an easement and then sell the property and then we can [0:19:51] continue to work on that lease for the cell tower. [0:19:55] I think when we come back on the 5th, we'll have a bit more information about that. [0:19:58] this one. You do know that's in the works. There could be potentially [0:20:01] significantly more value for the city to do that, to retain the tower, and then sell [0:20:08] the property. We're working on that more to come on that on May 5th. [0:20:15] That's really what I have for you tonight if you're any questions I'm [0:20:21] happy to answer for you. Thank you. Any questions for Mitch on this particular [0:20:25] item. I'd entertain a motion, Sherry Vomer. I would move to adopt resolution 2025-006. [0:20:38] Yeah, go ahead. All right, go ahead. I'll take care of the letter. Okay. Okay. Yeah. [0:20:44] Is there a second? Second. Thank you. Motion by Sherry Vomer, seconded by Chris Reed to adopt [0:20:51] resolution 2025-006 declaring city-owned property located at 929 Washington [0:20:59] Street South as surplus to the city needs and the city's intent to dispose [0:21:04] of that property via public auction. Any further discussion? Rachel Roquevo, [0:21:11] please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Jerry [0:21:18] Bulmer. Yes. And Grayson Stone. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero. [0:21:23] Okay. That is it for our regular meeting. We have a public hearing here in a minute, [0:21:30] but next on the agenda is time for general public input. This is a time for [0:21:36] Anybody in the audience who wishes to address City Council on an item not on [0:21:43] today's agenda and not the public hearing please come forward and you have [0:21:49] two minutes. Madam Mayor. Yes. Never mind. Okay. Okay. I like that. Okay. Anybody [0:22:00] that wishes to give input on an item not on today's agenda. Okay. See no one [0:22:06] advisory board reports. Yes, that's right. Mayor, we had a library board meeting last [0:22:13] week and things are going well over there. A couple things to mention, [0:22:17] Western Days is coming up, not too far from now, and the board approved closing [0:22:21] the library on that day. They found in the past that normal patrons avoid that, the [0:22:26] library on purpose, and so it becomes a place for people to escape the heat, use [0:22:32] is a restroom. Basically it's not serving the general purposes, so it'll be closed that [0:22:38] day. Working on their budget requests for the upcoming fiscal year, that type of stuff. Nothing [0:22:45] overly exciting, but I haven't spoken about the library for a couple months, so I want [0:22:48] to let you know they're still there and it hasn't moved. [0:22:51] Thank you, I appreciate it. [0:22:52] I got rid of some old records, finally. [0:22:53] Yep, sounds like it. Any other advisory board reports? [0:22:58] Madam Mayor, if I can. [0:23:00] Sure the chamber breakfast is April 24th. I think it starts at eight o'clock [0:23:06] It's always a great event for networking and to get caught up. They've got a great speaker coming in so I would encourage people to participate in that [0:23:13] Thank you. Jason Brown. You know, you have the greater Twin Falls transportation and the Magic Valley Metropolitan Planning Organization meetings this last week [0:23:24] Really just talking about traffic. There's a couple of traffic studies [0:23:27] getting ready to go out for qualifications for engineering firms to do [0:23:34] some traffic studies particularly the Hanson Bridge corridor. Old Line Blue Lakes [0:23:41] intersection is on that and then there's an ongoing environmental study for the [0:23:47] third bridge crossing that is being worked on. The Metropolitan Planning [0:23:53] organization it continues to look at building the documents that to help [0:24:01] facilitate the program getting closer we've been approved for some some funding [0:24:08] on some local projects and so here to move within the next six months to a [0:24:14] year we'll have a list of projects ready to go for that organization [0:24:19] And then there's a meeting tomorrow night? [0:24:24] Yeah, so the next, there's three meetings that we'll be talking about or asking for public input. [0:24:32] Starting tomorrow at Reform Church, thanks Travis, [0:24:39] Rock Creek, Fire Station, and then Con-Paulos on the north side. [0:24:45] on the north side. So they're trying to collect areas where people can come and give some general public input on transportation and the planning of transportation. [0:24:56] Well that's Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday and those three locations. Okay. Thank you. [0:25:00] And they believe the meeting time on all of those is about 430 to 630. [0:25:05] Right. Yeah. Hey, that it from Council? Anything from the city manager office? Travis? [0:25:13] Just for the council, we're going to have another council workshop on May 5th, and so we'll have [0:25:20] staff presentation that will not be a routine normal meeting, but we're going to have just [0:25:26] some open dialogue with the city council about some different ideas and projects that the [0:25:31] staff has been working on to get your input and guidance and direction. [0:25:37] Perfect, thank you. [0:25:39] Can I add something to you? [0:25:40] Yes, you may. [0:25:41] I'm glad the Spencer brought up the library. [0:25:45] One other thing that I think the board did at their meeting was, you'll all recall we [0:25:48] had some money in the budget this year to replace the elevator and the board awarded a [0:25:53] contract to a young elevator company to get started with that work this summer. [0:25:56] So it's another good update. [0:26:01] Thank you. [0:26:02] Anyone else? [0:26:03] Okay, next we'll move on to the public hearing. [0:26:09] This is an action item. [0:26:11] The request for an amendment to the Sun West Lazy JPD to allow outside storage and display [0:26:18] of products on property generally located on the southeast corner of Poline Road and Washington [0:26:26] Street North, Cara of Gerald Martins, MPZ 25-0016. [0:26:35] We have our city planager. [0:26:39] City Planner, Lisa Strickland. [0:26:42] Okay, did we need to go over the rules for a public hearing? [0:26:47] I will do that right now. [0:26:49] The council will follow these steps for each request listed on public hearing portion of the agenda. [0:26:55] First City staff will present the request and analysis. [0:26:59] The applicant will then present their request. [0:27:02] The council will ask questions of the applicant or staff. [0:27:08] After questions have been asked, the public hearing will be opened during that time. [0:27:13] Anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions about the request being [0:27:20] considered. When giving testimony, please step up to the podium, state your name and address, [0:27:26] present your comments or concerns. After giving testimony, please sign the public [0:27:31] record sheet located in the lobby with your name and address for the record. [0:27:36] After public comments are concluded the applicant will be invited to answer any [0:27:41] questions and make a closing statement staff will then answer clarify any [0:27:46] comments after these closing statements the public hearing will be closed and [0:27:51] the council will have open discussion and take action after the public hearing [0:27:57] is closed no further testimony or comments from the applicant or audience [0:28:02] will be allowed. Now Lisa. Madam Mayor, before Mr. [0:28:07] Klinkit's going, I've got a direct conflict of interest on the [0:28:11] agent of record on the property and represent the seller. And I've [0:28:15] been acting as a consultant for the buyer, so I'll be recusing [0:28:18] myself and stepping off the dice. Okay, thank you. Okay, now Lisa, [0:28:25] you're up. Good evening, Madam Mayor and Council. This is a [0:28:29] request from Gerald Morten's to amend the Southwest, our son [0:28:33] West Lazy Chay Plan Unit Development Agreement, or PUD, to allow outside storage and display [0:28:41] of products. For City Code 10-6, a PUD shall conform to all sections of Title 10, unless [0:28:49] otherwise identified in the plan, and approved by the city. In order to amend a plan of preliminary [0:28:56] presentation to the Planning and Zoning Commission is required, followed by a public hearing, [0:29:01] and the commission's recommendations are sent to council. [0:29:04] The council then holds the public hearing [0:29:06] and makes the final decision. [0:29:07] The preliminary presentation for this request [0:29:10] was on February 25th, 2025, [0:29:13] and the public hearing was on March 11th [0:29:15] with a recommendation to approve the request [0:29:18] with amended conditions. [0:29:21] The property is located at the southeast corner [0:29:24] of Poline Road and Washington Street North, [0:29:28] close to Tommy's Car Wash and Mountain West Motors. [0:29:33] The PUD agreement includes approximately 70 acres [0:29:37] that was annexed with the C1 PUD zoning designation in 2011. [0:29:42] In 2018, the Sun West subdivision number one, [0:29:46] consisting of approximately three acres, was recorded. [0:29:50] In 2022, Sun West subdivision number two, [0:29:54] consisting of 12 acres, was recorded, [0:29:57] leaving approximately 55 acres unplatted. [0:30:00] While a PUD agreement does offer custom regulations [0:30:04] for development, predicting the future [0:30:06] when these documents are created is difficult. [0:30:09] And currently, most of the property is still undeveloped, [0:30:12] and this agreement is almost 15 years old. [0:30:15] Within the timeline of this approval in 2011 [0:30:20] to now Washington Street North, [0:30:22] Poline Road was reconstructed, Chaney Drive was built, and Walmart developed the site west [0:30:29] of this property, significantly changing the entire character of the area. [0:30:34] The reason for this request is related to a new interest in the Sun West development [0:30:38] by a business that would like to have outside storage and display. [0:30:43] For clarification, per the PUD, outside storage yards are not permitted. [0:30:51] In C1 zoning, outside storage yards are also not permitted, so the intent of this verbage [0:30:57] was not clear. [0:30:59] City Code 10714 does allow for some outside storage and display with certain conditions [0:31:05] related to screening. [0:31:07] Items allowed to be displayed without screening includes items as vehicles, motor homes, travel [0:31:14] trailers, and seasonal materials such as plants, pumpkins, Christmas trees, etc. [0:31:20] where all other items must be screened from view. [0:31:25] Outside storage and display can be seen throughout the city and concerns were raised by the public [0:31:30] at the March 11th planning and zoning public hearing. [0:31:34] However, it's clear that this property would be very attractive for development because [0:31:38] it offers good visibility and forbidding outside storage and display completely did [0:31:44] not seem reasonable to the commission. [0:31:47] While other businesses within the same general area follow the 10-7-14 city code, and are [0:31:53] also allowed to have outside storage and display with the same restrictions, the applicant [0:31:59] proposed that the PUD be amended to stay outside storage yards shall be permitted, provided [0:32:05] said storage is located in a manner that does not interfere with designated parking, and [0:32:11] it's maintained in an orderly manner. [0:32:14] consideration of the applicant's testimony and public comment, the commission's recommendation [0:32:21] is to amend the verbiage to state that the PUD will allow for the outside storage and distillay [0:32:27] per city code 10, 7, 14 as presented and that the amendment be limited to sun west subdivision [0:32:34] number one and two, recognizing that these changes may not be appropriate for all 70 acres. [0:32:45] The zoning for this property, again, is C1PUD. [0:32:50] The future land use map calls this area out as mixed use with some CSI designation on the [0:32:57] south end of the property. [0:33:00] Mixed use usually serves a local and regional commercial development and residential uses [0:33:08] such as allowing for retail, offices, different things. [0:33:13] The CSI typically serves our region for educational needs. [0:33:20] The applicant is here to answer any questions and present and I will stand for any questions [0:33:25] as well. [0:33:30] Thank you, Lisa. [0:33:31] Any questions for Lisa at this point in time? [0:33:33] Yes, sir. [0:33:36] Sorry. [0:33:37] Quick question. [0:33:38] So, I guess I'm not clear. [0:33:39] Is it for, can you show me with the map we have up? [0:33:43] Is it only for the western portion or the entirety of that purple boundary line? [0:33:48] So the applicant did not clarify in their request. [0:33:52] They called it an amendment to the PUD. [0:33:56] When we went through the public hearing, the commission felt like because the other portion [0:34:01] of the property has not been plotted that it might not be applicable to the other acreage. [0:34:09] So they suggested that it be limited to the plotted area of the PUD, which is Sunwest subdivision [0:34:16] 1 and 2. [0:34:17] which is where on the map, which is the area that's highlighted here at the grid. [0:34:25] Other questions for you, sir? [0:34:30] Okay. [0:34:31] Thank you, Lisa. [0:34:32] Next is the applicant. [0:34:33] My name is Gerald Martin for the record. [0:34:43] I'm here representing the owner, which is being the developer, which was made for the [0:34:49] use of tractor supply company that's going to go on that property that has made this [0:34:54] request. [0:34:55] They have the property under contract for a portion of the property. [0:35:01] Staff, I think, has done an excellent job in summarizing it. [0:35:05] This project was a plot. [0:35:08] The PUD was developed many years ago with a different vision for this property since [0:35:15] that time. [0:35:16] We've had Costco and Walmart develop and all of the other development to the west of this. [0:35:26] car wars, car dealerships up and down the road to display vehicles and other such things. [0:35:34] We are just requesting that the SPD amendment for the area dictated above the first two subdivisions [0:35:42] be brought in line with the city ordinance for outside storage and C1 zones. [0:35:49] I can specify that the CCNR is for the development, which is in, will specify clearly that display [0:36:02] of the seasonal products that are allowed under the code would be in designated areas that are [0:36:09] shown on the approved site plan and not in any designated parking areas or any traffic areas. [0:36:17] So although the subdivision or the development as our CC&R's are restrictive [0:36:28] covenants that address landscape maintenance and all of those things will [0:36:34] enforce that that display is restricted to those areas and if that should fail [0:36:40] of course city code is also there to enforce it but with that we request [0:36:47] approval for that change to the that portion of the PD depicted by the [0:36:54] some with subdivisions one and two only thank you thank you Gerald any questions [0:37:00] for Gerald at this point anybody thank you okay thank you okay any questions [0:37:16] for either staff or the applicant before I open up the public hearing thank you [0:37:24] Jason. So Lisa you said that this was originally [0:37:28] platted in 2011. That correct? The PUD was approved in 2011 when it was [0:37:37] annexed in rezone to C1 and then in 2018 they platted the first three acres [0:37:45] which is Sun West subdivision number one and then in 2022 they platted another [0:37:52] 12 acres and it is C1 also. [0:37:57] Okay. [0:37:59] Thank you. [0:38:00] Thank you. [0:38:01] Lisa. [0:38:02] Any other questions before I open the public hearing? [0:38:07] Okay. [0:38:08] I'm opening up the public hearing. [0:38:11] When you come down to testify, please come to the podium, state your name and address and [0:38:18] present your comments or concerns again. [0:38:21] Once you've finished, please sign the signing sheet up there so we have your name for the record, [0:38:27] and I'm limiting each public input to three minutes. So is there anybody in the audience [0:38:34] that wishes to address public input? Welcome. Thank you. Good evening, Mayor and Council [0:38:44] members. My name is Lexi Pyatt, and I'm an attorney with Wright Brothers Law Office, [0:38:49] and I represent KLSM and Family Limited Partnership, Linda Wills, [0:38:54] Kenya Vista Family Limited Partnership, and Lazy J Ranch, Inc., [0:38:59] who are neighboring property owners directly affected by this application. [0:39:04] These folks are the folks that set up the putt agreement in 2011, and is that issue here. [0:39:11] This putt was carefully and clearly negotiated with the city to meet the city's desires as well [0:39:17] as the owner's long-term vision for the area. We previously submitted written [0:39:21] objection on March 10th 2025 and have renewed those objections in our most [0:39:27] recent letter submitted today. The proposed amendment violates section 5E2 of the [0:39:33] recorded putt agreement which clearly prohibits outside storage yards. This was [0:39:38] a critical negotiated term intended to maintain the quarter's visual integrity [0:39:44] and commercial quality. Mr. Martin seeks to amend that and instead apply city code 101714, [0:39:52] but even under that code, the use isn't permitted. Outdoor storage is only allowed in M2 zones or [0:39:59] uses like vehicle or trailer sales, which aren't permitted in C1. Approving this would [0:40:05] in effect rezone the property from C1 to M2, which is incompatible with every surrounding [0:40:12] zoning code. The purpose of putt agreements is to predict the land usage in the future. [0:40:23] It tells current and future property owners that putt terms may change. If we, this is [0:40:29] a bad precedent, if every time a new user comes to make a putt agreement change and you [0:40:36] amend that, we don't know or have any predictability of how that land may be developed. If you [0:40:46] If you would like to look at a real world example, you don't need to look very far. [0:40:50] You can look at the Lowe's parking lot to visualize the operational problems the outdoor [0:40:55] storage creates when it's not fully screened. [0:40:58] We've submitted photos and as exhibit A to our letter to illustrate this issue. [0:41:03] While our clients remain opposed to the amendment, if the council chooses to approve it, we ask [0:41:08] that any approval be conditioned upon an installation of a 14 foot solid block wall enclosure on [0:41:14] any outdoor storage. [0:41:16] This is consistent with what is used at Home Depot, Sportsman Warehouse, and St. Luke's. [0:41:23] We respectfully request that you deny the application or an alternative imposed strict [0:41:28] screening requirements to preserve the integrity of the development and to protect the surrounding [0:41:35] landowners. [0:41:36] Thank you. [0:41:37] Thank you. [0:41:38] Is there anybody else in the audience that wishes to address City Council on this issue? [0:41:50] issue. Okay, any comments either from staff or Gerald, do you have any comments? [0:42:06] Thank you. I guess I just want to remind you this is C1. We will intend to follow the City [0:42:16] Code requirements for up-door storage in C1. We will preclude any storage on designated [0:42:24] parking that I will admit does happen. We have CC&Rs in here that would be clued that, but [0:42:33] I think the underlying request is to bring this project into conformance with city code [0:42:39] for C1 uses, which this is, it's zone C1 and the use proposed to C1. [0:42:48] So we'll be in total conformance with city code once we, as change is made and we construct [0:42:55] this facility. [0:42:56] The outdoor storage is limited in the space that's allowed. [0:43:02] It is seasonal product. [0:43:04] It will follow the allowed uses like Christmas trees and lawn mowers, plants. [0:43:09] In this case it's primarily hand tools and lawn mowers. [0:43:14] They don't sell plants, but they do have the product. [0:43:23] more ag-urban face type products that tractor supply will bring to this market and it would [0:43:32] be, but it is seasonal and they recognize that. [0:43:35] There will be additional storage behind the 14-foot screen area that's totally screened [0:43:43] in the product, but this is product that's visible from the parking areas and adjacent to [0:43:51] private street. [0:43:52] Thank you. [0:43:53] Okay. [0:43:54] I will then close the, do you have anything to add, Lisa? [0:44:08] Just clarification. [0:44:10] The outside storage and display, it is allowed in C1 with screening restrictions. [0:44:18] It is outright permitted in M2 without screening restrictions. [0:44:23] That's the difference. [0:44:25] Okay. [0:44:26] Thank you. [0:44:27] Thank you very much. [0:44:28] Okay. [0:44:29] Given that, I am going to close the public hearing and council can [0:44:35] deliberate any comments or anything you'd like to say. [0:44:41] Sherry. [0:44:45] What are a couple of them? [0:44:48] What are the screening requirements in C1 and how close? [0:44:54] Is there any restriction to how close to a main thorough [0:44:58] ferro streak that they can be displayed? [0:45:03] There's a couple of restrictions. [0:45:05] If they want to display the items in the required landscaping, which per our code required landscaping [0:45:14] is along the arterials, Washington Street North and Pull Line Road would qualify as a gateway [0:45:20] arterial. The only way they can display items in those locations would be to have a special [0:45:25] use permit approved by the Planning and Zoning Commission. As far as screening requirements, [0:45:30] It can be landscaping, it can be fencing, but it has to be a minimum of six feet tall, [0:45:43] and it can be a combination of both. [0:45:46] The material is not completely specified. [0:45:51] It just has to be that it has to obscure what's there. [0:45:55] Okay. [0:45:56] Thank you. [0:46:00] other comments or questions, deliberation? [0:46:14] To me, this is with a development with Walmart and so forth around there, it really is turning [0:46:22] commercial. [0:46:25] I can see with the pictures that were in there earlier than what we got today that the storage [0:46:31] part could be visually and also then you need to look at the property rights of the individual [0:46:39] also so it's kind of a conundrum. [0:46:44] I would be tend to be in favor of any other comments. [0:46:51] Sure. [0:46:52] Is that you again? [0:46:52] Yeah. [0:46:53] Somebody else has. [0:46:55] Chris, did you have something? [0:46:56] Yeah, I can jump on in. [0:46:59] The entire time I have lived in Twin Falls, [0:47:01] this has always just been a field. [0:47:03] You know, it is exciting to see something starting to move [0:47:06] in this area besides just the dirt when the wind blows. [0:47:12] I understand the concern completely. [0:47:15] I think that with the recommendations of only making [0:47:20] change into area one and two it does there's some middle ground there where [0:47:26] it's keeping it on that far side where there are residential property to the [0:47:32] east of it so I'm in favor of this. Thank you. Anyone else comments? Sure. It was good to [0:47:44] hear from people that originally set up the PUD. Sometimes we don't hear from them [0:47:51] or it just doesn't matter anymore from the original PUD. [0:47:54] But I did appreciate that if allowed that they came [0:48:00] up with a solution of the, is it the 14 feet wall? [0:48:06] Is that allowed? [0:48:07] That's a recommendation from the citizen [0:48:13] who's done the public comment. [0:48:15] Yes. It is not been a recommendation in the staff report. [0:48:19] That would be something you guys would have to add [0:48:21] as a condition if that's what you wish. [0:48:23] Okay, I'm wondering though that so if we do make that as a condition that's not something that's we have any [0:48:29] statute or anywhere that's not allowed to be that high [0:48:33] What I'm wondering you can designate the screening material height that is your [0:48:39] Prorogative, it's just that staff is only allowed to make a recommendation that be not more than you know at least six feet tall and could be [0:48:46] Yeah, a fence or landscaping [0:48:49] Typically over six feet has to be engineered [0:48:51] Yes, over seven feet does require engineering and approval permit from the [0:48:58] building department as well. Right, okay. I like the idea of bringing this kind of [0:49:07] business into Twin Falls, so I'm on the fence, no pun intended, but also [0:49:16] respect a PUD that was initiated with with future thought process of it. So I'll [0:49:25] still thank you. Thank you. Spencer. Hi mayor. I think that some of the conditions [0:49:31] that were talked about by the applicant and then in the planning and zoning committee [0:49:36] address some of the concerns. The fact that it's only the Western portion if [0:49:40] there's an insulating barrier between the property owners to the east. I'm also [0:49:44] So requiring them, while the municipal code of section 10, 714, does a lot. [0:49:52] I worry about specifying an exact wall. [0:49:54] That could be other negative implications that actually lessen the overall visual appeal. [0:50:00] And then the fact that it is pull line in Washington and that is that special corridor [0:50:05] does have unique requirements for landscape buffer. [0:50:08] So maybe what I could do is I could make a motion and then if there's a discussion based [0:50:12] on that, we could talk about it or we could have a vote. [0:50:14] Okay. [0:50:15] Any, is that okay? [0:50:16] Yeah. [0:50:17] Yeah. [0:50:18] My comment would be applicable to after the motion. [0:50:20] Okay. [0:50:21] And Chris, you're good. [0:50:22] Go ahead, Spencer. [0:50:23] Okay. [0:50:24] Mayor, I move that we approve the request for amendment to SunWest LazyJ-PUD to allow [0:50:31] outside storage and display of products. [0:50:34] Let me subject to recommendations put forth that it's only SunWest 1 and 2 and that it [0:50:41] it complies with municipal code 10, 7, 14. [0:50:47] Thank you, do I have a second? [0:50:49] I'll second that. [0:50:50] Thank you, motion by Spencer Cutler, [0:50:51] second by Jason Brown, to, sorry, Chris Reed, [0:50:57] it said Jason Brown, to prove an amendment [0:51:00] to the Sudden West Lazy JPUD, [0:51:03] to allow to outside storage and display [0:51:05] of products on property generally located [0:51:08] on the southeast corner of Poe Line Road [0:51:10] in Washington Street and North. [0:51:12] subject to [0:51:14] Complying list code section 10s dash 714 and only being [0:51:20] Sunway subdivision 1 and 2. Thank you [0:51:25] discussion [0:51:27] Jason yeah, I I mean, I don't really have a lot of hard burn about [0:51:33] You because it would apply to that, but I look at that corridor. I look at Walmart and Jonathan or Lisa [0:51:41] That's commercial correct [0:51:43] the fence the fence that's running along pole line I'm assuming is roughly six [0:51:48] foot tall behind the trees. So Walmart is zoned C1 but it is under a [0:51:55] planned unit development. So that was clarified and required in their PUD [0:52:01] amendment and our development. So let's go down to latitude 42 more recently [0:52:09] what is that zoned? That is C1PUD also. So it has its own [0:52:14] own PUD also. Yeah. Okay. [0:52:17] Er regardless I guess of where I was trying to go or looking at it, I'm [0:52:22] comfortable with making the modifications to that area. So just for [0:52:30] some clarification, the lot that the tractor supply is actually looking at is [0:52:35] is not on the main corner. [0:52:38] It's interior in this development. [0:52:41] If that makes a difference for you guys, I'm not sure, but. [0:52:45] So which direction maybe if you could, in the red area [0:52:49] on that map, it's within that area, correct? [0:52:58] The way the property is plotted, you [0:53:01] have the two lots here, which are [0:53:03] Tommy's and Mountain West. [0:53:06] Then there's another, there's a little road here. [0:53:09] There's a lot here, a lot here, a lot here, [0:53:14] and then a bigger lot across here. [0:53:17] They are looking at going in this lot right in here. [0:53:21] So they will be behind another development. [0:53:25] Can you say what block that, which lot in block? [0:53:45] The one on our map it says, Sun West Way. [0:53:48] Is it off of that area, do we? [0:53:53] Yes, that's correct. [0:53:54] on just a second. Gerald said he can help me with it. I'm going to pull up the vicinity [0:54:11] map that may be helpful. So this is Tommy's. This is Mountain West. They're looking at [0:54:26] this, this, this, this one here portion of the next slide just about 50 feet of the next [0:54:44] slide. So it's totally internal. Does not front immediately Washington or Paul set back. [0:54:52] Thank you Lisa. Let's see. Jason, you said what you did to say. Sherri, did you have something else? [0:55:04] Okay, so there's a motion on the floor. It's been seconded. Any further discussion? [0:55:13] Okay, so the motion reads approve amendment to the Sun West Lazy JPUD to allow outside storage [0:55:22] and display a product, some property generally located in the southeast corner of [0:55:28] Pole Line Road and Washington Street North, specifically Sun West, subdivision 1 and 2, [0:55:37] subject to the code 10-714. [0:55:40] That's how it sounds, right? [0:55:45] Okay, any further discussion? [0:55:48] Rachel Rojo, please. [0:55:49] The Ruth Pierce. [0:55:50] Yes. [0:55:51] Chris Reed. [0:55:52] Yes. [0:55:53] Great Hawkins. [0:55:54] Yes. [0:55:55] Jason Brown. [0:55:56] Yes. [0:55:57] Spencer Cutler. [0:55:58] Yes. [0:56:00] And Sherry Vollmer. [0:56:03] Motion passes six, yes, and one abstention. [0:56:07] So motion passes. [0:56:08] Okay. [0:56:09] That is it for our meeting tonight, and so we are adjourned. [0:56:14] Thank you, everyone.