Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2025-09-29, recording 1 (started 16:59) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2025-09-29/ [0:00:01] 25 City Council meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum, barely. Four members, [0:00:08] President Chambers, and Jerry Moomer, Chris Reed, and Grace and Stoner, all [0:00:13] excused tonight. First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. If you wish to [0:00:17] join me please rise. [0:00:32] Thank you. We have no proclamations tonight. So on to the consent calendar. [0:00:43] Council wishes. Craig Hawkins. We'd like to approve the consent calendar is written. [0:00:47] Thank you. Do I have a second? Motion by Craig Hawkins second by Jason Bound to [0:00:54] approve the consent calendar as written. Rachel Rokalvo please. Ruth Pierce yes [0:01:02] Greg Hawkins, Jason Brown, and Spencer Cutler. [0:01:05] Yes. [0:01:06] Thank you. [0:01:07] Motion passes 4-0. [0:01:08] Okay. [0:01:09] Next, under items of consideration, request approval of the collective bargaining agreement [0:01:15] between the City of Twin Falls, the City and Twin Falls Firefighters, Local 1556, and we [0:01:22] have, who's, who gets to do that? [0:01:27] Good. [0:01:28] Okay. [0:01:29] So we have Lauren Nicholson, Assistant HR Director. [0:01:32] Welcome Lauren, turn on your mic, push the, oh, yep, thank you, yep, good evening, mayor [0:01:42] and council members. [0:01:43] I'm here to present the proposed updates to the collective bargaining agreement between [0:01:47] the City of Twin Falls and the Twin Falls Firefighters Local 1556. [0:01:52] As always, we want to express our appreciation for the strong professional partnership we [0:01:56] have with Local 1556. [0:01:59] Our firefighters continue to serve the community with dedication, skill, and integrity, and [0:02:06] we value the collaborative relationship that makes the agreement like this possible. [0:02:10] This year's update to the CVA includes two key changes, both of which are straightforward [0:02:16] and mutually agreed upon. [0:02:17] First, we've added a new section, Section 28, Lateral Recruits. [0:02:23] This section provides a framework for hiring experienced firefighters from other agencies, [0:02:28] commonly referred to as lateral recruits here. [0:02:31] These individuals bring prior training [0:02:34] and valuable on-the-job experience, [0:02:36] and this addition allows the city to onboard them efficiently [0:02:39] while recognizing that experience appropriately [0:02:41] in terms of classification and compensation. [0:02:45] The language ensures fairness, clarity, [0:02:47] and flexibility as we work to keep our department [0:02:50] well-staffed and responsive to community needs. [0:02:54] Second, the updated agreement includes a revision [0:02:56] the pay table to reflect a 4% increase in monthly salaries from the previous CBA. [0:03:03] This adjustment was negotiated in inflationatory pressures, recruitment competitiveness, and [0:03:11] to ensure that our compensation remains fair and aligned with comparable departments. [0:03:17] The new pay rates are reflected clearly in the updated wage schedule, effective upon [0:03:21] the adoption of this agreement. [0:03:24] Aside from these two updates, Section 28, [0:03:27] regarding lateral recruits and the 4% salary adjustment, [0:03:31] no other changes have been made to the agreement. [0:03:34] All other terms and provisions from the existing CBA [0:03:37] remain in place. [0:03:39] We believe these changes support the long-term operational [0:03:42] and financial health of the fire department [0:03:45] while continuing to respect the values and needs [0:03:47] of both the city and our dedicated firefighters. [0:03:50] Thank you again for your time and thoughtful consideration. [0:03:53] I respectfully request your approval of the updated collective bargaining agreement [0:03:58] between the City of Twin Falls and Local 1556 as presented. [0:04:04] I'll pause and turn to Kyle Eldridge, President of the E-Board, to see if you would like [0:04:08] to make any comments. [0:04:11] I'll leave you. [0:04:12] No. [0:04:13] He paused, too. [0:04:15] Yep. [0:04:16] Okay. [0:04:17] Spencer, did you have a question? [0:04:19] I was just going to say the Association President looks really good in a suit and tie. [0:04:23] I can offer a motion if you're ready. [0:04:26] Yes, that'd be great. [0:04:27] Spencer, go ahead. [0:04:29] I've moved to approve the collective bargain agreement [0:04:32] between the city and Twin Falls firefighters local 1556. [0:04:36] Thank you, Jason Brown. [0:04:37] Second. [0:04:38] Thank you. [0:04:38] Motion by Spencer Cutler, seconded by Jason Brown, [0:04:41] to approve the collective bargaining agreement [0:04:44] between the city and Twin Falls firefighters local 1556. [0:04:49] Rachel Roll, call vote, please. [0:04:52] Okay. [0:04:53] Yes. [0:04:54] Yes. [0:04:55] Yes. [0:04:56] Yes. [0:04:57] Yes. [0:04:58] Yes. [0:04:59] Yes. [0:05:00] Yes. [0:05:01] Yes. [0:05:02] Yes. [0:05:03] Thank you. [0:05:04] Motion passes four to zero. [0:05:05] And I want to thank everybody for their part in this, including city manager's office and our union and our HR. [0:05:13] Everybody worked really hard and it's nice to see this move along. [0:05:18] Okay. [0:05:19] Next is a presentation employee recognition committee. [0:05:21] ever-solved committee chair for the employee recognition committee. Welcome Kelly. [0:05:27] Thank you. Just going to pull up our values real quick. Okay so tonight we're [0:05:48] here for something special. So I want to give a little history on our employee [0:05:52] recognition committee. So the one city values were established and chosen by the [0:05:56] employees of Quinn Falls in 2016. Those values up on the board are integrity, [0:06:04] honesty, commitment, connection, and teamwork. In 2017 the Employee Recognition [0:06:10] Committee was formed as an effort to recognize the outstanding acts of public [0:06:15] service by its employees. Nominations are submitted by city employees for [0:06:20] someone who they have witnessed doing something that exemplifies one of the [0:06:23] values up on the board. It is quite an accomplishment to receive one of these tokens, let alone [0:06:30] receive one for each value. Tonight we're here to recognize the first two employees to receive [0:06:37] all five value tokens as well as the one city token for completing the one city training class. [0:06:44] Lisa Strickland and Jonathan Spinnlev are those employees. Their dedication to the city of Twin [0:06:49] Falls is unmatched and I am privileged to say I get to work with them and witness their dedication [0:06:54] on a daily basis. The ERC committee is here to present a plaque to each of them recognizing [0:07:01] this accomplishment. These plaques were handmade by our senior building inspector Jared Boardy. [0:07:07] Please join me in congratulating them both for this award. [0:07:10] So I made them from the beach, beach, beach guys. Your family's here. [0:07:53] Thank you Jonathan. [0:07:54] I'll take this one. I don't know if Lisa would want to. What would you like me to say? [0:08:01] I can remember, I'm going to be honest with you, I remember every token I got, but I remember [0:08:05] the first one was for connection when we finished, it was nine years ago, when we finished the [0:08:11] comprehensive plans. [0:08:12] I remember that one and I remember the last one. [0:08:16] I am privileged to work with Lisa as well as an example for me who do what's right and [0:08:22] my team and I'd say that we try to do that through our department and also throughout [0:08:27] the entire city. [0:08:28] honestly, VRC group. I should receive a lot of it because they push for us to look for [0:08:33] these good things to happen. And we hope to keep doing that. And yeah, we'll do our best [0:08:39] to keep doing it. Congratulations. You said do you have something you want to say or perfect? [0:08:49] I was lucky enough to serve on the Employee Recognition Committee as the very first member. [0:08:55] And I remember us talking as a group about how it would be kind of cool to have somebody [0:09:00] I think it's all five, not knowing that it was going to be me and Jonathan. [0:09:05] So I appreciate the time I got to spend on the committee and I enjoyed listening to all [0:09:09] the stories that come across those nominations are really cool. [0:09:14] So thank you very much for this. [0:09:16] Thank you. [0:09:17] Welcome. [0:09:18] Congratulations to both of you. [0:09:19] Okay. [0:09:26] Moving on to the next item, it's an action item, request to confirm the mayor's reappointment [0:09:32] of JPO Donald for a second term on the airport advisory board [0:09:36] and we have our airport manager Bill Carberry. [0:09:39] Welcome, Bill. [0:09:40] Thank you, Mayor. [0:09:41] Good evening, all. [0:09:44] Airport board members are allowed to serve up to two, three-year terms. [0:09:47] So JPO Donald is here tonight. [0:09:51] Mayor asking for your confirmation of his reappointment. [0:09:54] JP, as many of you know, he's a retired city police officer. [0:09:57] He works for the county now. [0:10:00] He's a pilot. [0:10:00] these as a based aircraft at Jawsland Field. [0:10:04] And I think the latest thing he got thrown into [0:10:06] was being co-director of the Magic Valley Air Show, [0:10:09] which he'll hear a little bit more [0:10:11] about and he did a fine job. [0:10:14] So it's my pleasure to recommend the approval [0:10:19] of the mayor's appointment of JP [0:10:21] for a second term on the airport board. [0:10:24] Thank you. [0:10:25] Any questions for Bill or JP? [0:10:29] Jason? [0:10:30] I'm ready to confirm the reappointment. [0:10:33] Okay, go ahead. [0:10:34] I'd move to confirm the mayor's reappointment of JPO [0:10:36] Donald for a second term on the airport advisory board. [0:10:40] Thank you. [0:10:41] Do I have a second? [0:10:43] Thank you motion by Jason Brown, second by Craig Hawkins [0:10:46] to confirm the mayor's reappointment of JPO Donald [0:10:49] for a second term on the airport advisory board. [0:10:53] Any discussion? [0:10:55] Rachel Roquavo, please. [0:10:57] Spencer Cutler. [0:10:58] Yes. [0:10:59] Yes. [0:11:00] Thank you. Motion passes 4-0. [0:11:05] I thought I'd raise this up and invite. [0:11:08] That's what I was just going to say. [0:11:11] I'm on down, JP. [0:11:14] First of all, I thank you for your trust in this last three years. [0:11:18] This has been great. [0:11:19] Aviation is a passion of mine. [0:11:21] And I love to be able to serve and help our community where we can. [0:11:24] Thank you very much. [0:11:25] Thank you. [0:11:26] Thank you for working so hard. [0:11:31] Okay, the next item is a presentation and it's the highlights of the 2025 Magic Valley air show and [0:11:40] Jim O'Donnell, I'm [0:11:42] air show director and his sidekick [0:11:47] Have a presentation to make welcome [0:11:50] Thank you, mare. We have one more person. We want to invite down. We have a tried directorship and so [0:11:57] So I want him to hear, we've had a great air show and I'm trying to feel time while [0:12:03] to get it ready to go for you. [0:12:05] Okay. [0:12:06] So you can see some pictures showing tell time and now I won't show you all the pictures. [0:12:09] We've got about two hours worth. [0:12:11] I'm sorry. [0:12:12] Magic Bailey Air Show, kind of summary report for you, which one do I do, okay, change. [0:12:19] We started by going to the International Council Police Chaplains, I have a conference for [0:12:23] Please have a wrong group. [0:12:24] The house of air shows. [0:12:28] I go to many meetings. [0:12:30] And there we meet people from around the globe [0:12:33] who are part of air shows. [0:12:35] And as co-director, we went down together [0:12:38] to try to build an air show for us. [0:12:42] We took a couple of plans with us. [0:12:44] We had plan A and plan B. While we're there, [0:12:47] they introduced the primary performers, [0:12:50] such as the Blue Angels, the Thunderbirds, all these others, and they announced their schedule. [0:12:55] And as you can tell by the slide, Twin Falls, Idaho was the site for the August 16th and 17th [0:13:01] location of Blue Angels. Then we also had another surprising announcement, and that is that Twin Falls [0:13:11] Idaho would also be the place of the Air Force F-35 demo team. Pretty amazing, because when we get [0:13:18] get those two teams together, we become a world-level air [0:13:22] show. [0:13:25] Well, with the announcement of those two, of course, [0:13:27] we become, we're going on Plan B. Plan B is Blue Angels. [0:13:33] We also light up several of the top performers [0:13:35] in the nation and the world to come with us for our air show. [0:13:39] Got some pictures of them. [0:13:41] One of them is actually the chairman [0:13:43] for the International Council of Air Shows, Nathan Hammond. [0:13:47] And so, like I say, we have some great people. [0:13:51] we organized. This chart gives an idea of the organization it takes to make it this kind [0:13:57] of the top of the iceberg. And at this time, I'm going to, if you don't mind, indulge me. [0:14:01] I'd like to have all the people here who are part of the air show team please stand. Would [0:14:09] you join me in giving them a round of applause for their work? Well, the next step is have [0:14:21] meetings and meetings and more meetings. And after that, some more meetings. It takes a [0:14:27] a lot of planning, a lot of preparation with it. [0:14:31] The planning overview includes how do you park them, [0:14:33] where do you put them, how do you get them in, [0:14:35] how do you get them out, all those kind of things. [0:14:37] It takes a lot of logistical efforts, [0:14:39] and it also takes a lot of support from our community [0:14:43] for this all to come together and take place. [0:14:45] As you can kind of gather, it's a huge, huge effort, [0:14:50] but because of the support we have in the community, [0:14:52] it was a successful effort. [0:14:54] Here are some of the sponsors we had. [0:14:58] We had close to 60 sponsors step up to help sponsor provided both monies, but a lot of [0:15:03] in kind things they did. [0:15:06] Many of the media, the local media, were all involved. [0:15:08] Basically, they provided support and advertising. [0:15:12] And so you kind of get an idea who's some of them are on this one, but I had too many [0:15:16] in for one slide. [0:15:18] So here's some more of them. [0:15:20] And as you look at that, you see just the variety of people in the community who help [0:15:25] us out. [0:15:26] Well, then the show starts. [0:15:29] And on the left side, you see a picture of the dinner. [0:15:33] Most of you are part of that. [0:15:35] On Friday night is a special time [0:15:38] because on Friday we do several extra things. [0:15:42] We start out with an educator's breakfast, [0:15:44] which we had represented some about every school district [0:15:46] in the Magic Valley 10. [0:15:48] We also then have a veteran's luncheon. [0:15:50] We had over 300 participate in that. [0:15:53] We have youth events, including a luncheon [0:15:55] with about 115 served that. [0:15:58] We also have what's called Elevator Life Program [0:16:01] in which young people exposed aviation. [0:16:03] We had 15 that were giving flights. [0:16:06] The most that program has ever given it one town before [0:16:09] in the 23 year history. [0:16:11] And then that evening we have the night show. [0:16:14] The night show is reserved for sponsors, VIPs, [0:16:18] and the volunteers. [0:16:19] It's our way of saying thank you [0:16:21] for the work you put in, support you do. [0:16:24] And I tell them it's okay to watch that one because on Saturday and Sunday, I want you working. [0:16:32] As you look around the ramp, you see a lot of people, a lot of things going on. [0:16:35] We had Smokey the Bear there, among others. [0:16:39] A lot of things that were not in the air were also on the ground. [0:16:42] Things for people to see and do, post or pictures, go up and visit some of the static aircraft. [0:16:48] We had a couple of very unique aircraft with us and some of the most rare aircraft in the world [0:16:53] with us that day. And then of course the show itself. Until [0:16:59] up the show we had a little bit of a flag presentation. That's [0:17:03] called the Sergeant Flag. It's not quite as big as the one [0:17:06] into the bridge, but it kind of gives you an idea of what's [0:17:08] going on. We had performers entertaining people before it [0:17:12] started and just a lot of things, a lot of activities making for [0:17:16] a very, very special and memorable occasion. And then we had a [0:17:21] ribbon cutting which helped have something like that and you get [0:17:23] an idea of the crowds from these pictures. [0:17:28] The crowd estimates were for Saturday over 20,000 people, [0:17:32] and for Sunday, 16,000. [0:17:34] That's a whole lot of folks that are sure of you. [0:17:37] Where did all those people come from? [0:17:40] Well, the answer to that question is from 37 states. [0:17:44] Now, we know that because we had everything was on say, [0:17:50] all the tickets were online, and so we could track [0:17:52] where they came from. [0:17:53] And so I was surprised, that's about 30 more nights [0:17:57] expected, quite frankly. [0:17:58] But 37 states were represented in our air shell. [0:18:02] We also had nine foreign countries attending an air shell. [0:18:08] The family that you see me with up on the upper left part, [0:18:11] they are from Luxembourg. [0:18:13] And the young girl below that is from Poland. [0:18:16] I also met a couple from Japan and talked to couples [0:18:19] from Canada. [0:18:21] Toss in Australia, England, Germany, Ireland, and Scotland for good measure, so it says a [0:18:27] lot about the airshow, what happens when you have the Blue Angels and the F-35 here, and [0:18:32] I'm thankful our team treated them all well. But there's something else we want to do, and [0:18:38] that is this. I describe the airshow as a three-legged stool. We need the City of Twin Falls, Twin [0:18:45] Falls County, and Reader Jet Service to make it happen. Without that support, this could [0:18:50] not take place. And so I want to make sure we acknowledge and thank you for the city [0:18:55] and all the city employees for all the efforts you put in and the labors you [0:19:00] provided to help us make this events so special. And so thank you for your [0:19:06] support and let's do it again. Thank you. Do you have any questions for Jim? Anybody? [0:19:15] Craig. I just like to comment and just say that the show is amazing. It seems like [0:19:19] it's better every time we have one year. People are so excited. It was thrilling. It was interesting. [0:19:28] It moved along quickly. I can't say enough good about it. I've heard nothing but good. [0:19:33] Thank you very much. [0:19:35] And a special shout out to your committee. We know how hard everybody worked and I would like to give [0:19:41] them another round of applause if they want to stand up one more time. Thank you. [0:19:58] Thank you. [0:19:59] Okay. [0:20:04] Next item on the agenda is an action item. [0:20:08] Maybe I'll take a minute if you guys feel like you want to leave, you don't have to [0:20:12] stay for the entire meeting. [0:20:14] We do have a couple more airport things that might be interesting. [0:20:17] So yeah. [0:20:18] Okay. [0:20:19] So the next is a request to approve the airport board's recommendation to select JUB engineers [0:20:27] for FAA airport improvement projects, and Bill is back. [0:20:33] I am back. [0:20:34] Thank you. [0:20:35] And yeah, I can't say enough good things about all the folks and just to throw another [0:20:40] number, I think the week of there were like 400 volunteers that helped in some way shape [0:20:45] or form. [0:20:46] So, bravo. [0:20:49] So on the airport business, and this is certainly one here, and this is a selection of our airport [0:20:55] FAA engineering consultant firm. [0:20:58] So every five years at a minimum, the FAA requires the airport to sponsor, to put out an RFQ, they've [0:21:07] got a lot of guidance about the process and how to handle that, and request qualifications [0:21:12] to be submitted from interesting airport firms that would like to support the airport and the [0:21:19] city in the planning and development of the airport. [0:21:22] So we followed their guidance, and an RFQ was advertised widely in the local newspaper, [0:21:28] the city website, industry trade associations. [0:21:32] This was last, just the past spring, however, even though we got that out, we only had one [0:21:38] response statement of qualification to the RFQ, and that was our incumbent firm, if you [0:21:44] will, JUV Engineers. [0:21:46] So the airport board, to follow this process, appointed a review committee to review and rank [0:21:53] the statement of qualification responses to our RFQ. [0:21:57] So that was composed of three individuals, Assistant City Public Works Director Aaron Steele, airport [0:22:03] operations supervisor Matt Barnes, and airport board member J.P.O. Donald sat on that review [0:22:09] committee. [0:22:11] They reviewed the JUB statement of qualifications and they were impressed as they are typically [0:22:18] day in and day out with their good work and they recommended to the airport board at the [0:22:22] June meeting that the airport board recommend to the city council the adoption of the five [0:22:31] year term for JUB moving forward. [0:22:37] From a budget standpoint, the airport consulting engineer, they're contracted for FAA projects [0:22:43] which are paid out at 95% of the fees associated with their work. [0:22:49] And as an aside, they provide great assistance with funding strategies for the airport. [0:22:54] I talked about a good consultant as an extension of your staff and when you're a couple of folks [0:23:00] in the administration office, you certainly need all the help you can get and they provided [0:23:05] a great deal of help over the years. [0:23:06] So with that, and on behalf of the airport board, staff requests the city council to approve [0:23:12] the airport advisory board recommendation to select JUB engineers for FAA airport improvement [0:23:19] projects for the next five years. [0:23:22] Thank you Bill. [0:23:23] Any questions for Bill on this particular item? [0:23:26] Anybody? [0:23:27] Pretty straightforward. [0:23:28] Jason Brown. [0:23:29] I don't have a question, but as a question, I'll wait to make a motion. [0:23:36] I'd move to approve the airport board recommendation [0:23:39] to select JUB engineers for the FAA airport improvement [0:23:44] projects. [0:23:45] Greg Hawkins. [0:23:48] Thank you. [0:23:48] Motion by Jason Brown, second by Craig Hawkins, [0:23:51] to approve the airport board's recommendation [0:23:54] to select JUB engineers for FAA airport improvement projects. [0:24:00] Any discussion? [0:24:03] Rachel Rokow, please. [0:24:05] Ruth Pierce? [0:24:06] Yes. [0:24:06] Thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank [0:24:11] you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank [0:24:13] you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank [0:24:14] you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, [0:24:15] thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, [0:24:16] thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, [0:24:17] thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, [0:24:18] thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, [0:24:19] a request to approve a resolution adopting Magic Valley Regional Airport's air carrier [0:24:26] in sending program and authorized the mayor to sign the resolution. [0:24:32] Thank you, Mayor. [0:24:33] Yes, but the last item tonight is something that I think is a good improvement for really what we're looking at [0:24:41] in our strategic plan to try to improve air service, and that's an air carrier incentive program. [0:24:46] program. So they've been around for a while. The FAA has provided guidance within the last [0:24:51] couple of years to update those programs. So I've been working on the Care Area Incentive [0:24:58] Program to assist with recruiting new and expanded air service. The goal of the program [0:25:03] is to increase nonstop scheduled air service and passenger traffic at Twin Falls and to [0:25:09] sustain the service over the long term. The Air Carry Incentive Program helps maximize [0:25:14] available commercial air service that supports economic growth, stability, and quality of [0:25:19] life in our region. [0:25:21] So the program sets levels of incentives for abating airport fees that air carriers would [0:25:27] have and also provides some funding to assist with marketing based upon prescribed eligibility [0:25:34] requirements from the air carriers for new or expanded service. [0:25:38] We'll have an application, an MOU that goes with it, so the program has levels of assistance [0:25:44] For instance, seasonal service would receive a lower marketing amount, a lower fee of Amazon, [0:25:49] and something like a new destination, that type of thing. [0:25:52] So this is open to incumbent air service carriers like Delta and SkyWest, as well as any new [0:25:57] entrance that might be interested in serving our community. [0:26:02] So we do have marketing money, we have $60,000 in marketing funds, if we have the opportunity [0:26:08] to provide these incentives, and the program is compliant with all the guidelines set [0:26:16] by the FAA. They have a very good platform of guidance for how you go about this. I've also [0:26:24] researched many communities across the nation and know what their programs look like, particularly [0:26:30] small non-hove airports like ourselves. So in conclusion, I would recommend the City Council [0:26:36] approve resolution 2025-015 and authorize the mayor to sign that resolution adopting the [0:26:45] or carrier incentive program. [0:26:47] We're happy to stand for any questions. [0:26:49] Any questions for Bill on this particular item? [0:26:53] We do need to put it on third and final, isn't that correct? [0:26:57] Okay, not a resolution, okay, good. [0:27:02] Okay, just want to make sure. [0:27:05] Any questions for Bill? [0:27:08] I would, Jason Brown. [0:27:11] I'd move to adopt resolution with 25, 15. [0:27:17] So resolution 2025-015 for the Magic Valley Airport, [0:27:28] Airport's Air Carrier Incentive Program and authorize the mayor to sign. [0:27:33] Thank you. [0:27:34] Have a second. [0:27:35] Second. [0:27:36] Thank you. [0:27:37] Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Spencer Cutler to approve resolution 2025-015, [0:27:45] adopting Magic Valley Regional Airport's Eric Carrier and Cine Program and authorize the [0:27:50] mayor to sign the resolution. Any further discussion? Rachel Roquevo, please. [0:27:57] Craig Hawkins. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. And Ruth Pierce. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes [0:28:05] 40-0. Thank you. Okay, that's it for airport business. If you guys want to wait at just a [0:28:13] a minute, let you rush out. Thank you again, everybody for your hard work. No, we got [0:28:26] them. We all got one. There's only four of us. Yep. Okay. Our next item is an action item, [0:29:57] a request to approve the guaranteed maximum price or GMP of 1,401,246 for the remodel of [0:30:07] the former city council chambers building located at 305 third Avenue East and we [0:30:13] have Mandy Thompson assistant to the city manager welcome Mandy. Thank you Mayor [0:30:18] Council. So tonight I bring to you a GMP that will be used for the construction or [0:30:26] the renovation of the former city council building chambers building. So in [0:30:31] fiscal year 2023 the city hired Laughlin lyrics architecture to design a [0:30:35] remodel of that building that that would include space for both the city's gym as [0:30:41] well as much needed space for our growing legal department. [0:30:46] And we're last when Rick's was able to design the [0:30:49] and then in addition they were asked to design a replacement lift over at the [0:30:53] police department that has been non-functioning for a little bit a while [0:30:59] now and so because of the close proximity of the two projects the decision was made [0:31:05] to combine them both just for ease of getting the work done and also because there was some [0:31:10] concern that if we had the police department, the lift of the police department as its own [0:31:15] project we may not be able to receive any competitive bits. [0:31:19] So those two projects were combined and the design was completed and there is money in [0:31:30] the current FY 2025 budget for the construction of both of these projects. [0:31:38] Earlier this year, the City Hire Star Corporation to serve as the CMGC for this project, started [0:31:45] recently completed the bidding process for the various bid packages for the project and [0:31:53] attached to your council packet is the guaranteed maximum price that was set based upon those [0:32:02] bids. [0:32:05] It also includes the project schedule which we anticipate come beginning construction on [0:32:11] October 20th and the estimated completion date of May 22nd, 2026. [0:32:16] So again, the project is the remodel of that building. [0:32:19] We'll do it in two phases. The first phase will be the city gym. [0:32:23] It will go on the back half of the building and then once that is complete, [0:32:28] then they can come in and do the renovation of the attorney's offices so that we, [0:32:32] there's not any disruption to the attorney's work. We decided to do the gym [0:32:38] first and then do the legal office suite second. [0:32:43] So, it was a nice surprise, most times when I come up here and present a GMP to all of you. [0:32:53] It is in recent years it's been for considerably more than we were anticipating. [0:32:58] And so it was a nice surprise I went over into the bid openings with Michael Arrington, who [0:33:03] was here with us tonight. [0:33:05] And we came in significantly under budget. [0:33:07] So we had originally budgeted for $275,000 for the lift at the police department, and then [0:33:13] $1,810,000 for the legal offices and the city gym. [0:33:19] The combined budget for both projects was $2,085,000, and the GMP that is presented to you tonight [0:33:27] is, as the mayor said, $1,401,246, so $683,75400 budget. [0:33:36] That was a welcome change, and I'm really hopeful that we'll start to see a leveling off of construction costs moving forward. [0:33:44] So the budget was also intended to cover some of the cost of furniture and equipment in the building. [0:33:52] Those costs have not been estimated yet, so we were not able to include that in this presentation tonight in this request, [0:33:58] but we expect that the amount that is remaining is more than a match to cover what will be needed for the FFE in the building. [0:34:05] buildings. So we will come back to Council at a further date when we have an [0:34:10] estimate and an idea of how much the FF&E will cost. But in a nutshell that is [0:34:16] what we're presenting here tonight and Michael Arrington with Star Corporation [0:34:19] is here if you have any questions. Thank you, Mandy. Any questions for Mandy or [0:34:23] Michael that I tell you I'm thrilled. It's great to see this. I appreciate it so [0:34:31] Thank you so much. [0:34:32] Spencer. [0:34:33] Thanks, Mayor. [0:34:34] Not a question for Mandy, but just a comment. [0:34:37] So I'll be voting on this item tonight, but out of full transparency, I do have family members [0:34:41] that are employed at Star Corporation. [0:34:45] That said, there's two facts I want to highlight. [0:34:47] One, this is not approving their contract. [0:34:50] This is agreeing with the price, which is well below budget. [0:34:53] And the second fact is I voted in favor of contracts for at least three of their competitors. [0:34:59] So I just want to be transparent, but I think this is a great thing. So thank you. Thank you. It's been sir Jason [0:35:06] I'll go ahead and make the motion then okay perfect [0:35:10] I'd move to approve the guaranteed maximum price of 1,401,246 for the remodel of the former city council chambers building located at [0:35:22] 305 third Avenue East [0:35:23] Thank you to have second Craig Hawkins second. Thank you motion by Jason Brown second by Craig Hawkins [0:35:30] To approve the guaranteed maximum price of one million four hundred one thousand two hundred forty six dollars [0:35:37] For the remodel of the former City Council chambers building [0:35:41] Located at three oh five third Avenue East [0:35:45] Rachel Rolkovo, please Jason Brown. Yes, I'm Sir Cutler. Yes, Ruth Pierce. Yes [0:35:51] Thank you. [0:35:53] Thank you. [0:35:54] Motion passes four to zero. [0:35:56] Thank you. [0:35:57] Michael. [0:35:58] Hey. [0:35:59] Next item is an action item appointment by the city manager and confirmation by the council [0:36:05] of Amy Luna to the position of city clerk followed by the administration of both of office for both [0:36:12] the city clerk and the deputy city clerk. [0:36:14] We have our city manager, Travis Rothweiler. [0:36:17] Welcome, Travis. [0:36:18] Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of the council. [0:36:20] So a few weeks ago, I was up here sharing with you [0:36:25] that the council has the regulatory responsibility [0:36:30] as shared in Idaho Code to appoint repositions. [0:36:33] And on that evening, we renewed the contract [0:36:37] that we had with Bruce Council [0:36:39] and to serve as our city attorney. [0:36:42] One of those other positions that you have here [0:36:44] is the city clerk position. [0:36:46] And while the City of Twin Falls has had a city clerk [0:36:51] in which those duties were assigned and then delegated, [0:36:56] oftentimes to the city CFO who also serves [0:36:59] as the city's treasurer, they became very apparent [0:37:02] as we were going through the last couple of years [0:37:04] that we really needed to have a city clerk mentioned [0:37:08] very specifically because of the duties and requirements [0:37:10] that are described in that role through Idaho Code. [0:37:14] And so it assists us not only with transparency, [0:37:17] but also when the citizens need to reach out to the city clerk, [0:37:21] they understand who they need to reach out to [0:37:23] without that question of, well, why am I talking to the CFO? [0:37:27] And so while there is no issue, [0:37:29] while we've done it in the past, [0:37:31] we believe this creates greater clarity. [0:37:33] So as we were going through the budget process, [0:37:36] we asked the council to confirm a position upgrade. [0:37:39] Those funds were provided in that budget. [0:37:42] And then we're asking you tonight to appoint Amy Luna [0:37:46] to that position of City Clerk. [0:37:49] And then with that, we're asking you also to appoint [0:37:55] Rachel Long to the position of Deputy City Clerk. [0:37:59] And then following that confirmation, [0:38:02] we would ask that the mayor prescribed the oath of office. [0:38:08] And I'm happy to answer any questions. [0:38:10] And it would be nice if you asked hard questions [0:38:12] the two of them who usually don't have an opportunity to answer them. Yeah that's on the list next so [0:38:20] any questions for Travis first? So do you want those in one motion? You can do it in one motion. Yes. [0:38:29] Okay. So anybody like to take a shot? I'll give it a shot. Okay. [0:38:36] Okay. [0:38:37] Move to a point and confirm Amy Luna to the position of City Clerk and to confirm and appoint [0:38:52] Rachel Long to the position of Deputy City Clerk. [0:39:00] Thank you. [0:39:01] Do we have a second? [0:39:02] Second. [0:39:03] motion by Jason Brown second by Craig Hawkins to approve the appointment and [0:39:08] confirmation of Amy Luna as City Clerk and Rachel Long as Deputy City Clerk. [0:39:14] Any further discussion? Rachel Rokavo please. [0:39:22] I just wanted to give you a pause. [0:39:30] Yes. [0:39:31] Great talking. [0:39:32] Yes. [0:39:33] Jason Brown. [0:39:34] And Spencer color. [0:39:36] Yes. [0:39:37] Thank you. [0:39:38] Motion passes four to zero. [0:39:39] Hey. [0:39:41] Let's give those to a little round of applause. [0:42:21] Putting up with all of us. [0:42:25] Okay. [0:42:26] So that is all for the agenda. [0:42:30] agenda. We do have a public hearing here in a minute. But first I want to open it up for [0:42:37] general public input if there's anybody in the audience that wishes to address City Council [0:42:43] on an issue not on today's agenda. Please come up to the podium. May seeing no one advisory board [0:42:56] reports. Pretty quiet week right at the end of the month. I mentioned that AIC is holding their [0:43:05] their district meeting on the 20th. [0:43:09] It's, I'll be over in Burley or schedule, so. [0:43:12] Okay, thank you. [0:43:14] You have anything, Jason? [0:43:16] City manager's office. [0:43:17] Hey, all right. [0:43:20] So next on the agenda is our public hearing. [0:43:25] It's an action item and what I will do [0:43:28] is read the public hearing rules [0:43:30] and then I'll, we'll move into the public hearing. [0:43:34] The council will follow these steps [0:43:38] under the public hearing portion of the agenda. [0:43:40] City staff will present the request and analysis. [0:43:44] The applicant will then present their request. [0:43:47] The council will then ask questions of the applicant [0:43:49] or staff. [0:43:51] After those questions have been asked and answered, [0:43:54] the public hearing will then be open. [0:43:57] During that time, anybody in attendance [0:43:59] has given the opportunity to comment, ask questions, [0:44:01] et cetera. [0:44:03] When the giving testimony, please step up [0:44:06] to this podium state your name and address [0:44:09] and present your comments or concerns. [0:44:11] After giving testimony, please sign the public input sheet, [0:44:14] which is at the top of the table up in the lobby [0:44:18] with your name and address for the record. [0:44:20] After public comments are concluded, [0:44:23] the applicant will be invited to answer any questions [0:44:25] and make a closing statement. [0:44:27] Staff will then answer, clarify any comments. [0:44:31] After those closing statements, [0:44:32] the public hearing will be closed. [0:44:34] no further testimony or comments from the applicant or audience will be allowed and then council [0:44:39] will have open discussion and take action. So our, we have Lisa Strickland for this action [0:44:47] item. It's a request to amend the East Park Professional ZDA to allow a drive-through [0:44:53] facility on lot 11 of the master development plan and amend the development standards to [0:45:00] to allow the maximum allowed building square feet per lot [0:45:05] to be combined if the lots are commonly owned. [0:45:08] And this is Cara of Dave Tebow EHM engineers [0:45:12] on behalf of TD Riddle, Barbara, Sonya Real Estate, [0:45:16] LLC, PZ, 25-0059. [0:45:20] So we have our city planner Lisa Strickland, [0:45:23] award-winning Lisa Strickland. [0:45:27] Good evening, council. [0:45:28] So, this is a request to amend the East Park Professional ZDA that is located at the Northwest [0:45:34] Corner of Madrona Street North and Chaney Drive East. [0:45:40] This was part of the original East Park PUD, which was established in 1998 and still is [0:45:47] active in the properties northeast and west of this property. [0:45:59] The 7.5 acres was rezoned in 2017 under a zoning development agreement with an R2 Pro designation. [0:46:07] The ZDA allowed for certain modifications to be made to the base zoning districts and design [0:46:13] standards for the development. [0:46:15] The East Park Professional ZDA allows for a limited list of permitted land uses along [0:46:19] with a limited list of special uses for lots one through five in the Master Development Plan, [0:46:26] none of which include an eating place or a drive-through. [0:46:39] As for the development standards, the East Park ZDA [0:46:43] has restrictions related to height, architectural design, [0:46:46] and building size within the boundaries of the agreement. [0:46:49] Lots located on the south boundary [0:46:51] were limited to a maximum of 6,000 square feet per building. [0:46:56] While lots along the north boundary [0:46:58] were limited to a maximum building size of 10,000 square feet. [0:47:01] The buildings are also required to have a residential cell architecture and are limited to one story. [0:47:07] The lots that are currently developed in the ZDA have followed these standards and demonstrate [0:47:14] that with strategic planning and design standards, professional development offers not only a buffer [0:47:19] for the neighborhood but is a good solution for transition from residential to heavy commercial [0:47:24] development. [0:47:26] In the future land use map, the property carries two comprehensive plant designations on there. [0:47:37] Mixed use and town neighborhood. [0:47:40] The mixed use designation was generally applied to lots one through seven on the master development [0:47:46] plan, which is the northern portion, and lots eight through eleven, which is the southern [0:47:52] portion, would be town neighborhood. [0:47:54] The agreement listed land use is permitted within both designation, allowing for more [0:47:59] intensive land use of the special use permit in the mixed use area. The shift [0:48:04] from town neighborhood to mixed use provides a more comprehensive land [0:48:08] use transition and is supported by good planning practices. Tonight's request is [0:48:14] to amend the land uses and to develop and the development standards put into [0:48:19] place from the ZDA was approved in 2017. The first change being requested is to [0:48:25] allow a lot 11 within the Master Development Plan to operate with an approved [0:48:31] special use permit, a pharmacy with a drive-through, or a cafe slash coffee [0:48:37] shop with a drive-through. Lot 11 is this lot at the corner of [0:48:48] Madonna Street North and Chaney Drive. The staff, while an approved special use [0:48:55] permit would be required to operate either land use, neither of these land uses are currently [0:49:01] permitted with or without a special use permit within the R2 or professional office overlay. [0:49:08] So approval of this land use would be a deviation from city code as well as the agreement. [0:49:14] Staff presented this request to the Planning and Zoning Commission and after careful consideration, [0:49:19] the commission made several motions. [0:49:21] The motion to approve a cafe or coffee shop with a drive-through to be added as a special [0:49:26] use permit for a lot 11 failed. [0:49:29] A motion to approve a pharmacy with a drive-through to be added as a special use permit for a [0:49:34] lot 11 passed with several conditions. [0:49:38] One it could be a pickup window only. [0:49:41] There could be no order boards or amplified sound systems and no extended hours. [0:49:47] The second change being requested is to allow lots that are commonly owned to combine the [0:49:52] maximum building square footage to allow for larger buildings. [0:49:56] Within the master plan, lots identified as two through six have not been developed. [0:50:02] Two through six is all of these right here. [0:50:09] If approved, this change will allow an individual to purchase all the remaining lots and construct [0:50:14] a building up to 52,000 square feet in size. [0:50:19] Using a mixed-use designation on the comprehensive plan could support a larger building footprint, [0:50:24] staff presented the request to the Planning and Zoning Commission, and after discussion, [0:50:29] a motion to approve the request was passed with a condition that the maximum building [0:50:34] square footage is be limited to 18,500 square feet. [0:50:40] A full review of the request and the recommendations made by the Planning and Zoning Commission [0:50:44] have been provided in the staff report packet. [0:50:47] as in support of the Planning and Zoning Commission recommendation sent forward on the [0:50:50] request and additional public comments were submitted after the packet was compiled and [0:50:57] those were sent to you prior to this meeting. Upon conclusion, the Council is charged with [0:51:03] making the final decision. If changes are approved, the amended CD agreement will be [0:51:07] brought forward to the Council along with an ordinance to final approval and recordation. [0:51:15] So I did, just for simplification, I did a list of showing what the applicants requesting [0:51:21] and what the Planning and Zoning Commission recommended. [0:51:29] So currently, if you look on the left, this is what is currently allowed in the PUD for [0:51:35] land uses and special uses that are limited to lots two, three, four, and five. [0:51:42] And then they would like to add that lot 11 be allowed with a special use permit to have [0:51:48] either a cafe, coffee shop with a drive-through, and a pharmacy with a drive-through. [0:51:54] The second that piece of it, the Planning and Zoning Commission, they reviewed the request [0:52:01] and their recommendation was that the amendment be that land use lots on lot 11 only be allowed [0:52:07] for a pharmacy with a drive-through, no amplified sound, no order menu board, and no extended [0:52:13] hours of operation. [0:52:16] The development standards, these are the current standards for the ZDA, and they would like [0:52:22] to add, in addition with lots are, when lots are under own common ownership, the limitation [0:52:28] for square footage of building structure shall be the total combined value for the square [0:52:32] footage for each lot owned. [0:52:35] So the Planning and Zoning Commission, they heard the request and they added that this [0:52:41] would be okay as long as the largest, the footprint of the building does not exceed 18,500 square [0:52:49] feet at ground level. And mostly that was because when you go from 2,000 square foot residential [0:52:57] home to a 6,000 square foot professional office and then to a 50,000 square foot building there's [0:53:03] quite a jump in size so they felt like it would be better to have a little bit of a limitation [0:53:10] between the two, so to provide a more cohesive transition. [0:53:17] And that is the presentation. [0:53:19] If you have any questions, I'll stand for questions. [0:53:23] Lisa did affect the height at all. [0:53:25] No, they did not request any changes. [0:53:28] It will still be required to be one story [0:53:31] with a residential architectural style building. [0:53:36] So the buildings that are developed right now, [0:53:39] if you go back to that map you had. Right, so the ones that are already other [0:53:47] 6000 square feet, that was my question. Yeah, so all of the ones that are abutting [0:53:52] Cheney drive and are closest to the residential area, all of them have been [0:53:58] expelled except for a lot 11 and that's probably because of this request to see [0:54:02] if they can have a drive-through and they're limited to 6000 and then this [0:54:08] This one has been developed and these are the remaining lots that have not been developed [0:54:13] and the request came from a property owner who is looking to purchase this lot, this lot [0:54:21] and this lot and would want to, wanted to combine the square footage so that they could [0:54:26] have a bigger building and their building is about 18,000 square feet so that's I think [0:54:35] and Cal the Commission came up with their square footage, [0:54:38] originally staff recommended 20, [0:54:41] so that could be an option for you guys as well. [0:54:44] That's what's generated that request. [0:54:47] Thank you, Jason. [0:54:49] Yeah, Lisa, I just wanna make sure I, [0:54:53] so what is the current zone right now? [0:54:57] So the current zone is, it's a ZDA with a R2, [0:55:02] which is a residential zone. [0:55:04] with a professional office overlay district the plan was for this to be [0:55:10] professional office so that's where the list of land uses and the request [0:55:17] would tonight's request is only for that lot 11 to change to allow drive a drive [0:55:27] to allow for a drive-thru event and they they had specific drive-thru types one [0:55:34] would be for a cafe or coffee shop or they would like it to be for to allow a [0:55:39] pharmacy with a drive-thru which when we did our review with the Planning and [0:55:44] Zoning Commission it was recognized that they are very different. A pharmacy [0:55:49] typically operates normal business hours, has limited traffic at peak hours, [0:55:56] where a coffee shop has higher traffic at peak hours. [0:56:00] They typically have hours from 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. [0:56:04] Most of them have extended because they want to be open prior to people heading to work. [0:56:08] And they have a lot higher volume traffic. [0:56:12] This intersection is a collector, Madrona [0:56:16] and Cheney, but they are not built to collector standards that we have [0:56:20] now. So it, staff felt like the volume of traffic might not be, that area might not be [0:56:28] conducive for that, but the planning and zoning commission felt the same way. [0:56:33] I may have some more questions, but we'll listen to the applicant again. [0:56:40] Sure. Any other questions for Lisa before we bring up Dave? [0:56:45] Hey. Thank you, Mayor. Members of Council, my name is David Tebow with EHM Engineers representing [0:56:57] the applicants in their presentation tonight. [0:56:59] So I actually have two clients. [0:57:01] One of my clients owns Lot 11 and is courting [0:57:05] two potential users for that building. [0:57:07] One user would be the cafe coffee shop, [0:57:09] the other user would be the pharmacy. [0:57:11] Inside the original ZDA that's prepared [0:57:14] and adopted an end of force right now, [0:57:17] we had identified some retail uses, specifically bakeries, [0:57:20] thinking that it might be nice to have [0:57:22] like a neighborhood type bakery in this area. [0:57:25] Obviously, we weren't successful in getting anybody to come and occupy that space as a [0:57:30] bakery. [0:57:31] However, we do have a user that would potentially be able to do a cafe and coffee shop type use. [0:57:37] So that necessitates a change to the ZDA, and that's one part of our request is to allow [0:57:43] that. [0:57:44] The other user, if we look to the west of this development, we have an IA surgery center or [0:57:49] at the Donist office, a title company, frontier pediatrics, an oral surgeon, and those uses [0:57:57] all end up writing prescriptions from time to time. [0:58:00] So a pharmacist on this side of town and this general quadrant of the city has been a use [0:58:05] that we're also looking at and they would desire to have drive up windows surface similar [0:58:09] to a coffee shop, obviously not to the extent because there are definitely some volume differences [0:58:14] and impact differences there. [0:58:16] Regardless, Madrona and Cheney, both are collector streets and were built and constructed to this [0:58:21] collector standards that were in effect at the time this subdivision was developed. [0:58:25] It was resubdivided in and around 2016 and 17 when our office became involved. [0:58:31] This body obviously reviewed that final plan and approved it and that's the configuration [0:58:35] you see today. [0:58:37] Lot one of this project is a CPA office. [0:58:41] We developed that. [0:58:42] It's just shy of 10,000 square feet. [0:58:44] I was involved with the ownership of that and built that to 10,000. [0:58:49] And within the existing ZDA, lots one, two, three, four, and five are all permissible [0:58:55] to have up to 10,000 square feet of building footprint above ground, not including basement [0:59:01] space, limited to single story and residential type architecture. [0:59:05] Dr. Nathan Welch happens to be my other client who has now acquired lots four, five, and [0:59:11] six. [0:59:12] Dr. Welch operates surgeries at the surgery center just to the west down the lane and has [0:59:19] acquired this property in hopes that he could combine his practice and bring on some new [0:59:23] providers, which is why we prepared the master plan that has to go with the ZDA to kind of [0:59:29] reflect his footprint here and then a parking field here. [0:59:33] You'll notice we're reducing a building footprint from 26,000 above grade potentially to this [0:59:40] This footprint is approximately 18,350 square feet above grade, but does include a basement [0:59:46] bringing the total square footage to around 23,000 square feet. [0:59:50] For simplicity's sake, we would request that should the council determine that this portion [0:59:57] of the request is acceptable, that the aggregate total for each lot be utilized so that would [1:00:03] permit him to build up to 26,000 square feet instead of the limitation of 18.5, which could [1:00:09] lead to some confusion in the future on maybe this lot or these two lots are [1:00:14] presently owned by the same individual as well. So we wouldn't want to mislead them [1:00:20] thinking they could build up to 18,500 there when we're looking at 16,000 in [1:00:26] reality with our request. I think that other than that we're fairly [1:00:34] comfortable with the staff report. Obviously we have our request before you [1:00:38] that is the entirety of the request to allow all of the uses which we've described, should [1:00:43] the council determine that only partial part of that request be acceptable in your deliberations? [1:00:51] We are comfortable with the staff recommendations, with the exception. [1:00:54] We'd request that you go to the aggregate total on the building square footage above [1:00:58] grade so that we're not having an issue. [1:01:03] If this patio gets covered and exceeds $18,500 because that was an arbitrary number that I [1:01:11] requested just to give me some extra room above the $18,350 that we think is that footprint. [1:01:19] With that, I'd stand for any questions that you might have tonight. [1:01:22] I did want to mention one more thing, if I could, if I may. [1:01:26] The history of this property was once owned by Interstate Amusement Theatre. [1:01:31] The restrictions of this ZDA as it's currently composed [1:01:33] do include restrictions from the prior ZDA [1:01:36] that were really intended to prevent the construction [1:01:39] and development of a movie theater. [1:01:42] And that was a real concern for the residents. [1:01:45] The movie theater would operate late into the evening hours. [1:01:47] Obviously have an associated parking lot [1:01:50] that was of significant size [1:01:51] and dealing with the comings and goings [1:01:53] that are natural part of operating a movie theater. [1:01:57] I think we've successfully eliminated that concern. [1:02:00] And we've developed an office park and a professional office [1:02:04] park that blends well with the neighborhood. [1:02:07] And these uses, we think, would complement [1:02:10] what we've already established there. [1:02:12] Thank you. [1:02:14] Questions for Dave before we open up our public hearings? [1:02:17] Jason? [1:02:19] Yeah, Dave. [1:02:20] So I guess you mentioned the thing here [1:02:24] that I'm looking at or struggling with [1:02:26] is so in that that lot of leaven there would potentially be the option to have a drive-through [1:02:35] window for the pharmacy and a cafe coffee shop at the same time is that correct or am [1:02:43] I it will be one or the other okay our request includes both because you know we don't have [1:02:48] the deal done until you sign on the line you can sign on the line to we have the special [1:02:52] used permitted, so we're looking at that. [1:02:57] This corner really is the best geometrically for stacking. [1:03:01] We can stack internal to where we're not impacting the roadway network. [1:03:07] Pretty significant stacking is available. [1:03:09] We really don't expect that this type of use, even with a coffee shop, is going to generate [1:03:13] the traffic similar to what you might see on pole line or on blue legs boulevard because [1:03:18] of the nature of its location, right? [1:03:20] It's really not on an arterial, but you know, if you build it, sometimes they come, so. [1:03:28] Really that's the request. [1:03:30] It is probably in either or depending on how successful we are. [1:03:33] And I guess that was maybe one of the questions that I had is if we make a motion or if we [1:03:39] choose to go this way, do a motion with either or is that something, we'll have that conversation. [1:03:46] But the other question I have is, so then your other client, Dr. Welch, he's asking, [1:03:53] so is it just this building here? [1:03:54] I wanted to make sure I understood what you were. [1:03:57] So the building there that's being highlighted, that one is you're requesting 24,000 square [1:04:03] feet above and below ground or all above ground. [1:04:07] He owns Lot 4, Yup, Lot 5 and Lot 6, and under the current ZDA that would allow for 10,000, [1:04:14] 10,000 and 6,000, a total of 26,000. [1:04:17] Okay. [1:04:18] We feel like that's easier to manage from a staff and from just straight-up disclosure [1:04:23] in the documents, and this is how much square footage you can have, where the condition is [1:04:29] written 18,500, but then that would lead me, okay, if I own these two, then I'm allowed [1:04:35] 18,500 as a maximum, but that really wasn't the intent. [1:04:39] We want the aggregate of what's still there, so that if these buildings are closer together [1:04:43] or connected as you see here, that would be an acceptable option to potential owners and [1:04:51] purchases of that property. [1:04:53] Right now, Commissioner Brown or Councilman Brown, we believe this is about 18,350 above [1:04:59] grade and it will have a basement for the equipment associated with his business practice and mechanical [1:05:06] equipment in the basement that would bring the total square footage close to 23,000 square [1:05:11] feet. [1:05:12] but that would be below grade the difference. [1:05:19] Anybody else have any questions for Dave? [1:05:23] We did reach out to some neighbors and neighboring persons [1:05:26] and you'll see letters in your staff report of support [1:05:30] for some of the uses that we've described here. [1:05:36] Thank you, Dave. [1:05:41] OK, so there are any other questions before I open for staff [1:05:47] or before I open up the public input or public hearing? [1:05:54] Okay, then I will open up the public hearing if there's anybody in the audience that wishes [1:06:00] to address City Council on this particular issue. [1:06:03] Remember, step up to the podium, state your name and address, present your comments or [1:06:09] concerns. [1:06:11] You will have three minutes to testify. [1:06:14] Once you do that, please sign the sheet in the back. [1:06:18] So is anybody here that wishes to address City Council on this issue tonight? [1:06:21] Come on down. [1:06:25] Good evening, Council. [1:06:38] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:06:39] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:06:43] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:06:48] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:06:54] And I think that if you were to stack all of these buildings in this development vertically, [1:07:02] you would certainly have a higher building, one building, and you'd have retail and restaurant [1:07:08] and different things, servicing the entire population [1:07:10] for the workers in that area and in that one building. [1:07:14] So why not service all of these buildings [1:07:17] and all of your employees with one location [1:07:21] in the development as well as locust businesses [1:07:26] and Home Depot and other places like that. [1:07:28] I think it's a reasonable thing to offer a pharmacy [1:07:31] and or a coffee shop. [1:07:33] And the neighborhood would probably have a lot of walk [1:07:35] into the coffee shop if that was the choice. [1:07:38] I like to stay to the end of these meetings [1:07:40] because you always learned something. [1:07:42] I had no idea that was gonna stand up. [1:07:44] But I really liked the idea of including that space [1:07:46] in that area. [1:07:48] But whatever you decide, you decide. [1:07:50] But I support it entirely the way it's presented. [1:07:53] And I think the presentation was very, very adequate [1:07:56] and very thorough and very good. [1:07:59] Thank you. [1:08:00] Thank you Ron. [1:08:01] Is there anybody else in the audience [1:08:03] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:08:14] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:08:21] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:08:27] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:08:33] built the surgery center down on the corner and developed the first section of this and [1:08:37] And I think anyone that's been down there can attest. [1:08:40] It's been a well done and a good neighbor development. [1:08:47] We have all those residential type buildings [1:08:49] along the side that borders the residents. [1:08:51] And then this, as we get closer to the giant building [1:08:54] of Home Depot, will be larger. [1:08:56] But it will certainly be a beautiful building. [1:08:59] I live just about a block or two away. [1:09:02] So certainly would not want to do anything that would not enhance [1:09:05] the experience of the neighbors in that area, [1:09:10] having lived near some other doctors' offices [1:09:13] that are down just a little bit further to the east. [1:09:16] I mean, these are the best neighbors to have. [1:09:18] They're not open at night. [1:09:19] There's no late night things going on [1:09:23] at these events or at these locations usually. [1:09:26] And so I would encourage you to support our petition [1:09:30] to allow us to combine the allowable square footages [1:09:36] on the on the parcels that we purchased [1:09:38] so that we can do the building that we need to do [1:09:40] to serve the people of Twin Falls. [1:09:43] Thank you. [1:09:44] Thank you. [1:09:48] Anybody else in the audience that wishes [1:09:50] to address city council on this particular issue? [1:09:57] Hey, going once? [1:10:01] Hey, there's any additional comments, Dave, or? [1:10:08] Thank you. [1:10:09] Thank you. [1:10:10] Thank you. [1:10:11] Anything? [1:10:12] Okay. [1:10:13] Then I'm going to close the public hearing and give council an opportunity to talk about [1:10:24] open discussion. [1:10:25] Craig Hawkins. [1:10:26] To me, it makes sense. [1:10:28] I would be in favor of it. [1:10:31] Questions? [1:10:32] Yes, sir. [1:10:34] It sounds like there's two conditions that we need to vote on, [1:10:37] and we could combine those together [1:10:39] unless any customer members think we need to separate it, [1:10:42] but I propose combining them together. [1:10:46] Yeah, I'm fine with that. [1:10:47] I just want to make sure, yeah, I guess for me, [1:10:52] the medical professional building combining that, [1:10:54] I just want to make sure in any type of motion [1:10:57] that the other buildings that are not included [1:10:59] in that remain similar to the size of what they are. [1:11:04] I think that was the request by the applicant is sure that we clarify some of that. [1:11:10] But I also, I like the and or type of recommendation for the coffee shop or the pharmacy. [1:11:19] So I do have a question on the coffee shop concept. [1:11:24] P and Z has said no coffee shop. [1:11:29] Let me make sure these guys are. [1:11:31] I'm looking for the actual documents. [1:11:35] Okay, make sure it's good. Okay. Wait a minute. And that was the other thing. [1:11:41] I want to make sure we understand everything that we're looking at here. [1:11:45] Is my understanding of reading and planning and so needs of what they pass. [1:11:50] They only pass the pharmacy and the concerns. Correct. [1:11:56] Yeah. And the concern is sound reader board lights, [1:12:01] extended hours of a coffee shop. You know, a cafe might be different, but if it's a [1:12:07] cafe without a drive-in, I mean, I don't know what I just want to make sure we [1:12:14] don't. Okay, so this document showing in red is what the applicant gave us. The [1:12:26] plain language is to add on lot 11 these two items. This is as requested and [1:12:33] presented by the applicant. H, which is below, is going to be applying to anybody. So any [1:12:40] of the lots in the entire ZDA could combine and have the combined value for the square [1:12:47] footage of the building. Now, we understand that most of those buildings already built, [1:12:53] and it's super rare for some of the tear down two buildings that are just a couple of years [1:12:56] old to combine them but in the future that might be a thing. From a staff's [1:13:01] perspective the reason we brought it up to P&Z was just to put a maximum just so [1:13:07] you had one. Not required to because the maximum per the development plan would be [1:13:11] in the case of these three lots from Dr. Welch it's 26,000 square feet. It [1:13:17] couldn't build any bigger because that's what the original had right so that's one [1:13:22] item, the commission just limited it to 18-5, no matter how many lots you have, no building [1:13:29] can be bigger than 18-5, period. So that was kind of going to set that aside. That's their [1:13:35] recommendation to you. You can approve it in either way or a third way making your own. [1:13:42] And then a lot of leavens shows both of these, the recommendation from the planning and zoning [1:13:47] commission is only a pharmacy operating a certain way. I don't know if I clarified it or made [1:13:55] it worse, but this is the, this is the, basically the governing document and how it would be applied. [1:14:01] And I will stand for any clarifying for the document if you need. [1:14:05] But Mayor, can I ask a question? So the concern on the coffee shop would be hours of operation [1:14:15] and you know, reader board or sound noise in, is that correct? [1:14:21] Is that what the minutes you received from the Plumbing [1:14:23] and Zoning Commission are in there? [1:14:25] And that was what I would refer you to as those items. [1:14:29] That's why they voted that way. [1:14:30] I can only give you what the recommendation is. [1:14:32] Yep. So I guess my question is are we talking a, [1:14:38] when we say cafe, flash coffee shop, are we talking one [1:14:44] that could have not have a drive-through? [1:14:47] we could allow a cafe without a drive-through versus, I mean. [1:14:55] These are the other items that are permitted by special use. [1:14:58] Okay. [1:14:59] So what this is doing is this is adding those two just for a lot of 11. [1:15:06] Right. [1:15:07] So these are the other items that are permitted [1:15:13] and they would need special uses for these two additional items, [1:15:16] what they requested. [1:15:17] In terms of whether it could be done without a drive-through, [1:15:21] administrative determination, I probably would say yes, [1:15:23] because the drive throughs are usually more intense, right? [1:15:28] So I think the whole point of P and Z was the noise, [1:15:32] the lights right up to on that corner in the hours. [1:15:40] Yeah. I mean, if I understand that correct, that correct? [1:15:48] Yes, that's correct. [1:15:51] So there's a couple of things. [1:15:54] the original East Park PUD had in their language that all of the parking and [1:16:02] maneuvering area would be on the north side of those buildings that are [1:16:06] abutting the residential area to minimize the traffic impact. When they [1:16:13] rewrote the ZDA for this portion that was not included. So technically they could [1:16:21] have cars parked there, or it could be a drive-through if it gets approved through this evening. [1:16:27] But the concern, I guess, from the Planning and Zoning Commission was the impacts of the [1:16:31] cars stacking, ordering from a menu board the lights that are illuminated from the menu boards [1:16:39] and just the impacts to the neighborhood that's used to this area being done at six o'clock [1:16:45] in the evening. [1:16:46] Okay. Okay. Spencer, did you have something else? [1:16:56] No. [1:16:57] Maybe, if I could add, maybe I, this one may be an interesting one, but I, back to maybe [1:17:04] what Spencer was talking about. [1:17:06] I wonder if we should approve these in two different motions for the simple fact that [1:17:12] I think, I guess from my perspective, I'm far more comfortable with the doctor's office [1:17:17] that medical building and the square footage and then still trying to wrap my [1:17:23] thoughts around the the coffee shop pharmacy type of deal and so I guess my [1:17:26] request would be to maybe approve them in two separate motions. Not to [1:17:32] contradict Spencer but I think that helps maybe clarify exactly what we're [1:17:38] doing. Sure. Can I offer a little bit more? Sure. When you look at the future land use [1:17:45] map and you look at the special uses that are currently listed in the ZDA as it stands [1:17:53] right now, they have outlined those uses to be a little more intensive because they're [1:18:02] allowed on lots two, three, four, and five, which is the north boundary of the ZDA and [1:18:10] which is in the mixed use land use category [1:18:14] of the comprehensive plan. [1:18:17] The land uses that are permitted in the town neighborhood [1:18:21] portion or the south portion are not as intensive. [1:18:25] They're lower traffic doctor's office, photography studio, [1:18:31] beauty barbershop professional office. [1:18:34] So I think that was another consideration [1:18:37] that the zoning commission were taking [1:18:39] into into consideration is compatibility [1:18:43] with the conference of plan. [1:18:50] To answer your question, that's what the commission did. [1:18:51] They had, as you see, their minutes [1:18:53] had four basic motions, starting with just basically [1:18:58] approving the size of the building, [1:19:00] and then they moved to the other items [1:19:01] as basically conditions of approval, [1:19:03] and then they had the overall motion at the end [1:19:05] to approve the whole thing with those added conditions in a row. [1:19:09] Thank you, Simon. [1:19:10] You know, I'm ready to make a motion on the, [1:19:11] on the combining of the buildings. [1:19:14] I'm personally, I'm okay with the 26,000 square foot, [1:19:20] but I wanna make sure I'm trying to figure out [1:19:22] how to craft the motion that it doesn't include, [1:19:27] I'd like to make sure that we're not doing something [1:19:31] that allows somebody else to come in [1:19:33] without having a bit of a conversation [1:19:35] before they go and plop a building there. [1:19:48] We hope. [1:19:49] Okay, so planning and zoning is limiting that particular building to 18.5 is that all buildings [1:20:01] within that they just they just put the whole thing on the whole ZDA so no building could [1:20:06] be bigger and I put that condition up here it applies to all the buildings essentially. [1:20:12] So if you have a lot with a building that's 10 and 6 they could still build 18. [1:20:18] Okay, I mean they can still build 16 turn. Oh, so it's the combined no more than basically [1:20:25] Yeah, you can combine them, but you can't go bigger than okay, put a cap [1:20:29] That makes that makes it that makes it way easier because I think if [1:20:34] Again, if we combine those three lots, that's 26,000 [1:20:37] But if the other ones are combined that's 16,000 or whatever that combination of a lot would be just whatever the combined was [1:20:44] But not to exceed that's for this boarded this wording came from and he said staff recommendation on that particular one was [1:20:52] 20 yeah, actually our [1:20:54] Presentation we put 20 and they just went with the testimony so the 18 [1:21:00] plus a little bit a rounded yeah, so [1:21:04] third twenty six thousand dollar twenty six barefoot building [1:21:08] That's pretty big, big bill. [1:21:10] Twenty thousand or twenty six. [1:21:14] But that would be, I guess, from the applicants' testimony, that would be an aggregate size [1:21:19] with basement included and some of that type of stuff is very anticipated. [1:21:23] But, but anticipated. [1:21:24] I mean, with that ruling, it wouldn't stop any from building a twenty six thousand square [1:21:30] foot building. [1:21:31] Yep. [1:21:32] Right. [1:21:33] Okay. [1:21:35] Okay. [1:21:38] Do you want to say something? [1:21:42] I don't think I'm too concerned about the aggregate size being up to 26,000. [1:21:46] They still have to fit parking and minimum landscape requirements. [1:21:51] And yeah, I'm not too concerned. [1:21:54] Okay. [1:21:55] I guess, can I guess I'll just make a motion? [1:21:58] Let's go for probably blunder it a little bit and we'll, your arrest for the council will help me do it. [1:22:04] So I'll address that first. [1:22:07] I would say make a motion to pull up some document just so I you can you can do just adding conditions at a time [1:22:17] And then do the last at the end if you want to can you pull up that one that had the the changes? [1:22:22] The red-lettered one I want to look at that one. Yes that one [1:22:26] So the really the one we'd be addressing would be H in this that that one correct correct [1:22:31] So I would would move to amend [1:22:41] I'm going to send DDA to a second, let me make sure I get this right because I want to make sure I'm putting the language together. [1:22:57] I'm in the development standards, so if you look at the public hearing description on our agenda. [1:23:05] Maybe that's what I'm struggling with is finding that language a little bit. [1:23:10] If you're going to do one by one, you just motion to add a condition number one and then say what you want this to say. [1:23:17] to vote on condition number one, and then you'd add [1:23:20] condition number two, and then if it passes, it would be added [1:23:22] or not. [1:23:23] And then at the end, you would then motion for the whole thing [1:23:25] with the amended conditions. [1:23:28] Right there, it describes both options. [1:23:32] You could just use the maximum allowed buildings for a put. [1:23:36] Is it at the top of that? [1:23:39] You go up to the very top. [1:23:41] I got you. [1:23:43] Well, that's the. [1:23:44] That's the staff report. [1:23:45] Council Member Brown, I could offer a motion that I think is [1:23:48] line with what you want. Yeah, that's fine Spencer. I'm just looking, but yeah, go ahead. [1:23:52] Okay, so I'd move that we had a condition being that when the lots are under common ownership, [1:23:59] the limitation for square footage of building structure shall be the total combined value [1:24:04] for the square footage of each lot owned. Okay, second. Okay, there's been a motion as second [1:24:14] to allow for the East Park Professional ZDA [1:24:21] to amend the development standards [1:24:22] to allow the maximum allowed building square foot per lot [1:24:25] to be the combined total of those lots. [1:24:31] Not good. [1:24:32] Yep, just adding the first condition [1:24:33] and then we'll go to the next one. [1:24:34] Right, yep, this is the first condition. [1:24:35] So any- [1:24:36] We'll vote on the overall ZDA [1:24:38] after we've approved or declined the conditions. [1:24:41] So this is just the first condition. [1:24:43] Okay, perfect. [1:24:45] Any other discussion? Hey, Rachel Rokov. Oh, please [1:24:52] Yes [1:24:54] Yes, Jason Brown yes, yes, yes [1:24:57] Okay, motion passes 4 to 0 [1:25:00] Okay [1:25:01] next condition a quick question for staff before we [1:25:13] Move for condition [1:25:15] What are the current operating hours that are allowed with the zda is it 7 to 10? It's just normal operating hours. Yes [1:25:21] I don't believe that they added any others, but what seven to tell me it's something different [1:25:42] I don't believe so, but I can, normal code is 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. [1:25:54] This is the original, yay, just normal hours, whatever we have normal retail hours of operation. [1:26:16] Okay, Betty, why don't I attempt the next motion? [1:26:29] I'll just make it, I'll just make a motion and then we'll go from there. [1:26:33] I'd move to a to allow a drive-through coffee shop on on lot 11 and then or on [1:26:41] lot 11 that's that that in condition number two to allow okay adding condition [1:26:48] number two to allow a drive-through coffee shop period coffee shop yep okay [1:26:55] for a second a second okay motion by Jason Brown second by Craig Hawkins to [1:27:06] allow a drive-through coffee shop cafe on lot 11 of the master development plan. [1:27:13] Is that right? Any discussion? Do you have anything to say? I'm still not convinced to [1:27:31] drive through. I'm sorry. It's gonna work in that corner. I know I'm on the fence [1:27:35] from this one. I'm not sure. I'll take a vote. I'll share with Council. I'm not so [1:27:48] concerned about the extra traffic. It's the noise in the early morning hours. [1:27:53] We can't ten o'clock at night. [1:27:56] There are some older people that live over in that neighborhood, for sure. [1:28:01] Any other comment before we take a vote? [1:28:08] Hey, Rachel Rocha vote, please. [1:28:11] Uh, Ruth Pierce? [1:28:13] No. [1:28:14] Ray Hawkins? [1:28:16] Nope. [1:28:17] Jason Brown? [1:28:18] No. [1:28:21] And Spencer Cutler? [1:28:24] Uh, no. [1:28:25] Hey, motion fails. [1:28:27] Okay. [1:28:29] Next motion. [1:28:31] So, we could adopt the condition to that the pharmacy with the drive-through, is that correct? [1:28:40] If that's what everybody chooses? [1:28:43] Yeah, that was the direction the commission took, and that was the recommendation that's shown on the screen on the, what does my, yeah, the right side is condition number two. [1:28:51] Okay. [1:28:52] So, is there somebody, I can't make any motions, so. [1:28:56] Yeah, I move [1:28:59] To add a condition that an approved use would be a pharmacy with the drive-thru [1:29:05] You want to add no speakers probably could dress? Oh? [1:29:13] Yes, and those were outlined good in the planning and zoning minutes. Um, yeah, it's right up on the screen right here [1:29:22] On item two under conclusion [1:29:27] Yeah, this is the planning zone and commission. Oh, okay. Thank you. So I'll amend my motion. So I move [1:29:35] that a condition be added to allow for a pharmacy with a pickup window, only on law 11, with no [1:29:42] speaker's public address, order board, and no extended hours. [1:29:46] Thank you. [1:29:47] Do I have a second? [1:29:48] A second. [1:29:49] Thank you. [1:29:50] Motion by Spencer Cutler, second by Craig Hawkins to add a condition to allow for a pharmacy [1:29:55] with a pickup window only on law 11 with no speakers, public address or order board and [1:30:01] no extended hours. [1:30:04] Any further discussion? [1:30:07] Rachel Rocha, please. [1:30:09] Jason Brown. [1:30:10] Yes. [1:30:11] Senator Cutler. [1:30:12] Yes. [1:30:12] Ruth Pierce. [1:30:13] Yes. [1:30:13] And Craig Gaughan. [1:30:14] Yes. [1:30:15] Thank you. [1:30:15] Motion passes 4-0. [1:30:18] Hey, now, what do you want? [1:30:20] We're combined. [1:30:21] Yeah, you just say the whole thing with these added conditions. [1:30:24] OK. [1:30:24] Sending it. [1:30:26] Somebody want to attempt that? [1:30:28] I'll try that, Mayor. [1:30:30] Thank you, Councillor. [1:30:31] So I moved to amend the East Park Professional ZDA [1:30:35] to allow the conditions approved. [1:30:41] Do I need to add anything beyond that? [1:30:46] Unless you know that you're amending the whole ZDA [1:30:48] with these are the only things you're amending for that. [1:30:51] It's these two conditions. [1:30:52] I hope you added it. [1:30:54] Do I have a second? [1:30:55] Second. [1:30:56] Thank you. [1:30:57] Motion by Spencer Cutler, seconded by Jason Brown [1:31:00] to amend the East Park Professional ZDA [1:31:03] to include the two conditions devoted on previously. [1:31:09] That work? [1:31:10] Okay, any further discussion? [1:31:13] Rachel Roquevo, please. [1:31:15] Craig Hawkins? [1:31:16] Yes. [1:31:17] Jason Brown? [1:31:18] Yes. [1:31:19] Spencer Cutler? [1:31:19] Yes. [1:31:20] And Ruth Pierce? [1:31:21] Yes. [1:31:22] Thank you. [1:31:23] Motion passes seven to zero. [1:31:24] Okay. [1:31:25] Thank you, everybody. [1:31:26] Eating as adjourned.