E-03 Documented · A (method 2020-25) / B (no vote)
City Manager raises 2016-2025: all but one set outside any located open-session vote
Rule at stake: City code, policy or contract; possibly state law how findings are ranked
The City Manager's pay was raised seven times from 2016 to 2022, and again in 2023 and September 2025, with no Council vote located in any open meeting. The one raise approved in open session was January 2025's, set by the December 2024 contract amendment. The City's adopted budgets never state his salary, so adopting a budget did not approve it, and the City's own Financial Policies require base-budget increases to be approved at a Council meeting.
City of Twin Falls · Possible open-meeting (I.C. 74-203, 74-206(3)); contract; City Code 1-2-1, 1-2-3
Why it matters
The City Manager's pay is one of the largest personnel decisions the Council makes, and residents are entitled to see it made. Raises set outside an open vote leave no way to know who decided, or why.
What the records show
Only three public Council actions on the City Manager's pay or agreement were located for 2014-2026: Feb 2, 2015 (Service Agreement approved 7-0); Apr 20, 2020 (agreement update; the staff memo says "The rate of compensation is not changed by this agreement" and states current pay as $169,124); and Dec 9, 2024 (amendment, 7-0). The Dec 2024 amendment set his pay at "an annual base salary of $239,560 and $22,600 into an IRS qualified deferred compensation plan" (EX-A12), and the Mayor read both figures aloud before the vote (Meeting 2024-12-09 at 0:08:38). His January 2025 rate of $115.17 an hour (about $239,554 a year) matches it, so the January 2025 raise is the one raise from 2016 to 2025 that the Council approved in open session. The Feb 2015 agreement was also discussed and approved as its own agenda item. None of these three actions was placed on the consent calendar, and no consent calendar from 2016 to 2024 lists payroll. Every other change has no located motion: Oct 2016 ($145,002), Oct 2017 ($158,002), Oct 2018 ($164,996), Oct 2019 ($169,125), Jan 2021 ($185,000), Oct 2021 ($193,336 + 5% deferred), Dec 2022 ($226,000 + $2,000), Dec 2023 (10% deferred = $22,600 + $1,500) and Sept 2025 ($272,650 total). The 2020-2025 changes were directed by Mayor and Vice Mayor emails and letters.
Citywide raises in each adopted budget: FY2018 3.5% + 5% table (FY2018 budget p57); FY2019 3% across the board + 1% table (FY2019 budget p55); FY2020 3% + 3% table (FY19-20 budget p20); FY2021 2% + 2% table (FY2021 budget p21); FY2022 4.5% + $2,000 one-time (FY2022 budget p24); FY2023 5% + 2% table + $2,000 one-time (FY2023 budget pp25-26).
City Manager base increases: Oct 2017 +8.97%; Oct 2018 +4.43%; Oct 2019 +2.50%; Jan 2021 +9.39% (mid-year); Oct 2021 +4.51%; Dec 2022 +16.90% (base only; the separate $2,000 equals the citywide one-time payment). The Oct 2019 raise was below the citywide raise and the Oct 2021 raise equaled it, so those two were not above the citywide rate. [Deduction] Compounding the citywide raises for FY2018-FY2023 gives about +23%; the City Manager's base rose about +56% from Oct 2016 to Dec 2022.
Context: under the agreement approved 7-0 on Dec 9, 2024, severance for termination without cause is twelve months of the "total compensation package, which is defined as the Employee's rate of pay, deferred compensation package, other compensable pay or benefits extended the Employer, and Employer offered insurances." The April 2020 agreement based it on "the Employee's then existing rate of pay" (EX-A11, EX-A12). [Deduction] Each later pay adjustment therefore also raises the severance amount.
Rule it is measured against
I.C. 74-203(1) (deliberations and decisions in open meeting); 74-202(1) ("decision"); 74-206(3) (no final action in executive session); CM Agreement sec. 3 and sec. 8.; Financial Policies (eff. 10-1-13) pp11-12, repeated in each budget's policy appendix. City Code 1-2-3 (Ord. 3106, 2015): the Council and its members deal with the City's administrative services "only through the city manager, except for the purpose of inquiry, and neither the city council nor any member thereof shall give orders to any subordinates of the city manager." City Code 1-2-1: the mayor performs "such other duties consistent with his office as may be imposed by the council," and signing contracts or legal instruments by title "shall not be construed as conferring upon him/her administrative powers or functions" (the same rule as I.C. 50-810). The Dec 2022 and Sept 2025 letters say "I am directing the Human Resources staff" (EX-A07, EX-A09).
Explanations we checked
We searched every set of Council minutes from 2006 to 2026 for a motion on the City Manager's pay. Before 2015 the only open actions on the position are his appointment (Nov 15, 2010, effective April 1, 2011) and the 2014 evaluation committee. So setting the City Manager's raises without an open vote did not start in 2016; the records show it as the long-standing practice.
What would change this finding
This finding would change if records from the time show the Council approved each raise in an open meeting, or adopted a formula that produced these amounts. Those would be Council minutes, a resolution, or the 2015 City Manager agreement, which the City has not produced (E-11). A budget line naming the City Manager's salary would also count; the budgets the City posts show department totals only, and its fiscal 2024 budget is not posted.
We aren't alleging that anyone acted in bad faith. A record made at the time could explain what's shown here. If the agency holds one that it didn't produce in answer to an earlier request, it can still release it, and we'll update this finding. A record made now carries today's date.
Records
- EX-A03 City Manager payroll register detail, Oct 2015 - May 2026 (full) · PRR #4814
- EX-A04 City Manager compensation documents (HR compilation) · PRR #4869 ↓
- EX-A05 2020-12 Compensation email (Mayor/HR) for 2021 raise · PRR #4869 ↓
- EX-A06 2021 City Manager compensation (Oct 2021 raise and one-time 5% PERSI contribution) · PRR #4869 ↓
- EX-A07 Compensation memo, fiscal year 2023 · PRR #4869 ↓
- EX-A08 2023-2024 compensation direction (10% deferred comp) · PRR #4869 ↓
- EX-A09 2025 compensation letter signed by the Mayor · PRR #4869 ↓
- EX-A10 FY 2025-26 salary adjustment · PRR #4869 ↓
- EX-A11 City Manager Service Agreement, April 2020 · PRR #4869 ↓
- EX-A12 City Manager Service Agreement, 2024 (signed) · PRR #4869 ↓
- EX-A13 Amendment to the Agreement with the City Manager · PRR #4869 ↓
- EX-A21 Executive base and additional pay summary · PRR #4729 ↓
- EX-A26 History of hourly rates (spreadsheet) · PRR #4729 ↓
- EX-B02 2015-02-02 minutes - City Manager Service Agreement approved 7-0 · Council minutes ↓
- EX-B07 2020-04-20 packet - City Manager agreement update (excerpt) · Council packet ↓
- EX-B08 2024-12-09 minutes - City Manager agreement amendment approved · Council minutes ↓
One file with a plain-text summary of this finding (what the records show, the rule, what we checked, what would change it, and the transcript lines around each meeting moment it cites), 16 records, their SHA-256 fingerprints (checked in your browser as the zip is made) and where each record came from.
Page-level citations
Minutes 2015-02-02 p8; 2020-04-20 packet pp74-77; 2024-12-09 minutes pp1-2; HR production #4869; payroll register. Adopted budgets FY2017-FY2023 and FY2025-FY2026 (FY2024 not posted) compensation sections (pages above); Financial Policies pp11-12 [City website, saved 2026-11-07].; City Code 1-2-1, 1-2-3 (online code, current through Ord. 2026-007).; EX-A12 sec. 3; Meeting 2024-12-09 at 0:08:38 (recording).
Records asked for
Requests already made that bear on this finding:
- Request #4729: ELT compensation records FY21-FY26 (filed 2026-08 (approx.)). Produced HR documents
- Request #4814: Finance payment summaries FY16-present (filed 2026-09). Payroll registers; "no FY subtotal"; AP to come separately
- Request #4869: CM contract versions + handbook exceptions (filed 2026-09). Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives
More records that could explain this finding, show that it was authorized, or change it have been identified, and requests for them are planned. Each is listed here once it is filed.
A complete answer depends on the agency responding to these requests as the Idaho Public Records Act requires.
How to read this finding
This page states what the records obtained so far show and the rule they are measured against. Its grade says how firmly the records show it, "Rule at stake" says what kind of rule is involved, and the labels under "Why it matters" say who bears the cost (more on the three labels). It is not an accusation, not a legal conclusion and not the whole story. A record we don't have could explain what is shown here or add to it, and we update a finding when new records arrive. Citations to a recording link to that moment in the audio. Transcripts and the searchable text of scanned documents are made by software, so listen or open the file before you quote. If this finding concerns you, ask the governing body to answer it in public, or ask an office with the authority to investigate.
Tell the City Council
The City Council answers to residents, and you don't have to attend a meeting to be heard. Send a written comment through the City's own public comment form, or write to members directly (addresses on the City's site). Point them to this finding and its records so they can check for themselves.
A starting point to put in your own words
I'm writing about a matter shown in the City's own records: City Manager raises 2016-2025: all but one set outside any located open-session vote (Oversight Archive E-03). The records are at https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/findings/e-03/. I'm asking the City Council to [explain in an open meeting how this was decided / place it on a public agenda / tell residents which policy applies].
This is not anonymous. Comments sent to the City become public records. They can be shared in a meeting packet and released to anyone who asks, and the form may ask for your name and address. If you'd rather not be identified, use our tip line instead.
Who to contact: the City staff directory published by the City of Twin Falls. The City's own list of departments and staff, with phone numbers and email addresses. It isn't dated and may be out of date in places, so confirm with the office before relying on a name or title.
The City Council can act only on items on a posted agenda (upcoming meetings), so asking for a matter to be placed on one is often the most useful request. Your own words carry more weight than a copied letter. Stick to what the records show. More ways to take part: Make a difference.