Records requests: Twin Falls, Idaho
What has been asked of City of Twin Falls, how it answered. Faults found in how Twin Falls, Idaho handles requests →
Requests filed and the agency's responses
| Request | Subject | Filed | Agency response | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #3946 | Market Analysis keyword, 5 custodians | 2026-05-31 | Partial; late; 109/117 withheld as "proprietary" | E-12 |
| #4729 | ELT compensation records FY21-FY26 | 2026-08 (approx.) | Produced HR documents | E-01 E-02 E-03 E-04 E-05 E-06 E-07 E-08 E-09 |
| #4814 | Finance payment summaries FY16-present | 2026-09 | Payroll registers; "no FY subtotal"; AP to come separately | E-14 |
| #4869 | CM contract versions + handbook exceptions | 2026-09 | Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives | E-11 |
| #4940 | Follow-up/deficiency memo to #4814/#4729 | 2026-10-05 | No response after 26 working days as of Nov 10 (deemed denied Oct 20); five follow-ups unanswered | E-14 |
| #4953 | All executive exceptions to handbook | 2026-10 | Denied: non-compliance with 74-102(4) | E-15 |
| PTO x3 | Hours worked and leave usage, ELT | 2026-10 | Denied three times | E-21 |
| Market Analysis Cost | Payments to HUB / study cost | 2026-09 | Denied (response not in folder) | E-18 |
| #5061 | Copies of all PRRs Jun-Oct 2026 | 2026-10-20 | Denied: "not a record held" (Nov 2); second request denied Nov 3; third request filled as #5162 | E-13 |
| #5162 | Copies of records requests (third attempt) | 2026-11-03 | Filled Nov 5, 2026: 1,183 request forms, no fee; extension notice sent Nov 6 after closure | E-13 |
| #5254 | Accounts payable payment register and Council AP reports, fiscal year 2026 (Oct 1, 2025 to Sep 30, 2026) | 2026-11-15 | Produced Nov 17, 2026, inside the 3 working days, with no fee: the FY2026 Invoice Distribution Report (.xlsx, and the same report as a 292-page PDF) and weekly check-run, payroll-remittance and prepaid proof lists (PDF). No invoices. A 10-working-day extension notice followed at 10:06 PM the same day, after delivery. | E-31 E-14 |
| #5290 | City Manager employment agreements and written amendments since Oct 2014; City Attorney agreement | 2026-11-18 | Nov 18: City Attorney reviewed, access granted, but records offered only by in-person pickup at City Hall "due to the substantial volume of records requested"; no date. Nov 19, 8:11 AM, after the requester asked for email delivery: "Per our City attorney" a signed residency declaration under penalty of perjury, with printed name and home address, is required "before we can move forward." No statute cited; the delivery question not answered. | |
| #5293 | Council committee for City Manager / City Attorney evaluations: membership, rules on committees, notices and minutes, compensation recommendations, minutes of 14 executive sessions (2014-present) | 2026-11-17 | Denied Nov 20 (within 3 working days), one page: "not in possession of a report or record of that nature" and "denied under Idaho Code 74-102(4" (cut off). No item-by-item answer; no statute tied to any item; nothing was asked of the requester first. The City's delivery folder held only the denial and its own copy of the request. | E-06 E-22 E-05 |
| #5299 | Accounts payable register, fiscal years 2020-2025 (follow-up to #5254) | 2026-11-17 | Nov 18: aggregated with #5254 under I.C. 74-102(11), 12 hours / $567.48 advance payment (Budget Coordinator $47.29/hr), though the City says it is 'not suggesting' fee avoidance. Requester narrowed to the Excel report only. Nov 19: 1.5 hours / $70.94 ('report generation and legal review'), billed at the Budget Coordinator rate. Nov 20, 3:24 AM: requester asked the City to reconsider (aggregation needs a reasonable belief of fee avoidance; Resolution 1912 Section 5) or confirm in writing. Nov 20, 9:19 PM: 10-day extension notice (ends Dec 3). | E-31 E-14 |
Idaho deadlines: for an Idaho resident, an agency must grant or deny within 3 working days, or, if it gives written notice that it needs more time, provide the records within 10 working days of the request. For a non-resident who isn't working for an Idaho resident, the limits are 21 and 35 days (I.C. 74-103(2)). No response by then is a denial by law (74-103(3)). A denial can be appealed to district court within 180 days (74-115).