OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

Timeline: Twin Falls, Idaho

Key events from the records, in date order. Each entry links to the records it rests on and says why it matters.

  1. Council passes Resolution 1897, the employee rules, including the vacation sell-back limits

    Why it's here: Sets the rule at the center of the sell-back findings: no more than 40 hours of vacation sold a year, once a fiscal year, and only after taking 80 hours of vacation in the prior 12 months. The City's 2020-2021 sell-back form and later handbooks lowered the vacation-taken test to 40 hours; the 40-hour yearly limit stayed the same.

    Source: Res. 1897 text in 2018-10-29 packet

    Records: EX-B06; Finding E-02

    E-01 E-02 Executive Pay & Leave

  2. Council adopts Resolution 1912, "Transparency in City Government," 6-1. Section 5 says the City "will provide access to the annual budget, monthly financial reports, accounts payable, financial dashboard ... on the City's website."

    Why it's here: The Council's own written promise to post every payment the City makes.

    Source: Agenda 2013-12-02 pp19-27 (resolution as presented, Section 5 on p23); Minutes 2013-12-02 pp3-5 (vote 6-1)

    Records: EX-B40; Minutes 2013-12-02 (EX-B40); Finding E-31

    E-31 Financial Transparency

  3. Council amends Resolution 1912's rules on committees, 4-3. The accounts payable promise in Section 5 stays.

    Why it's here: The promise survived the first rewrite.

    Source: Packet 2014-04-07 p119 (Section 5 text); Minutes 2014-04-07 pp6-7 (vote 4-3)

    Records: Finding E-31

    E-31 Financial Transparency

  4. Council adopts Second Amended Resolution 1912, 7-0. Section 5 still promises accounts payable, monthly financial reports and a financial dashboard on the City website.

    Why it's here: The version in force. We found no later Council action changing or repealing it.

    Source: Agenda 2014-04-21 pp73-76 (Section 5 on p75); Minutes 2014-04-21 p5 (vote 7-0)

    Records: EX-B41; EX-B42; Minutes 2014-04-21 (EX-B42); Finding E-31

    E-31 Financial Transparency

  5. Council approves a new City credit card process 5-0, with a six-month update promised; a bank representative says the card bill is paid by automatic debit

    Why it's here: The start of the Wells Fargo commercial card program the Council now approves monthly.

    Source: Minutes 2014-06-23 pp3-4 (Item 4)

    Records: EX-B47; Minutes 2014-06-23 (EX-B47); Finding E-32

    E-32 Financial Transparency

  6. Council votes 7-0 to let the Mayor form a committee (Hall, Hawkins, Talkington) to evaluate the City Manager and City Attorney

    Why it's here: The only public record creating an evaluation committee. Later pay letters cite "the performance review committee" as their authority, but no later motion creates one or names its members.

    Source: Minutes 2014-09-02 pp14-15

    Records: EX-B01; Finding E-06

    E-06 Open Meetings

  7. Council approves the City Manager's service agreement, 7-0

    Why it's here: The agreement the Council approved in public. It requires changes in writing signed by both parties, the standard every later pay letter is measured against.

    Source: Minutes 2015-02-02 p8

    Records: EX-B02; Finding E-07

    E-07 E-03 Executive Pay & Leave

  8. A City staff memo cites "the City's January 2015, Financial Dashboard."

    Why it's here: Shows the City did keep a financial dashboard at the time. None is on the website today.

    Source: Agenda 2015-04-13 p46

    Records: Finding E-31

    E-31 Financial Transparency

  9. Last Council minutes that state the weekly accounts payable total ($1,102,058 for July 28 to August 3, 2015). From August 10, 2015 on, the minutes give only the date range of the payments approved.

    Why it's here: Instead of putting the payments online, the public record began showing less: not even the total.

    Source: Minutes 2015-07-20 p2 and 2015-08-03 p2 (totals); Minutes 2015-08-10 p1 and later (date range only)

    Records: EX-B43; EX-B44; Minutes 2015-08-03 (EX-B43); Finding E-31

    E-31 Financial Transparency

  10. Council re-enacts Title 1 of the City Code (Ordinance 3106). City Code 1-2-1 says the mayor has no administrative powers; City Code 1-2-3 says Council members deal with administration only through the City Manager and may not give orders to his staff.

    Why it's here: The City's own code rules that the Mayor's later pay letters run up against.

    Source: City Code 1-2-1, 1-2-3 (history notes: Ord. 3106, 10-5-2015)

    Records: Finding E-01; Finding E-03; Finding E-07

    E-01 E-03 E-07 Executive Pay & Leave

  11. Council holds a closed evaluation session under 74-206(1)(b)

    Why it's here: An evaluation session. Closed sessions may discuss evaluations but may not be used to make final decisions (I.C. 74-206).

    What followed: Eleven days later, the October 23 check raised the City Manager's hourly rate 3.0% (see 2015-10-23). The minutes we have record no open vote on it.

    Source: Minutes 2015-10-12

    Records: Meeting 2015-10-12: audio and transcript; Finding E-05

    E-05 Open Meetings

  12. City Manager's hourly rate rises 3.0%, from $60.66 to $62.49 (about $129,974 a year), on the October 23 check; the same check sells 40 hours of vacation

    Why it's here: The first change in his pay after the October 12 evaluation session. No open-session vote on it was located. We could not compare it with the citywide raise because the City does not post its FY2016 budget. The 40-hour sale is within the yearly limit; the register does not reach back far enough to test the vacation taken before it.

    Source: Payroll p1

    Records: EX-A03 p1; Finding E-03

    E-03 Executive Pay & Leave

  13. Council adopts Resolution 2016-02, 7-0, authorizing destruction of Finance Department records including "Check Registers 2007-2015."

    Why it's here: Check registers are the payment lists Resolution 1912 promised to post. Whether electronic copies were kept is not stated.

    Source: Agenda 2016-04-04 p40 (list); Minutes 2016-04-04 p5 (vote 7-0)

    Records: EX-B45; EX-B46; Finding E-31

    E-31 Financial Transparency

  14. City Manager's base pay raised to $145,002; no vote found

    Why it's here: A raise paid with no open-session vote found in the minutes.

    Source: Payroll register

    Records: EX-A03; Finding E-03

    E-03 Executive Pay & Leave

  15. City Manager sells 80 hours of vacation: twice the 40-hour cap, after taking 76.75 hours of vacation when 80 were required

    Why it's here: Twice the 40-hour cap. He had used 76.75 hours of vacation in the prior 12 months; Resolution 1897, in force then, required 80. (He would have met the later 40-hour test.)

    Source: Payroll p10

    Records: EX-A03 p10; Finding E-02

    E-02 Executive Pay & Leave

  16. At the City Manager's request, the Council adds an evaluation session at the start of the meeting, 5-0

    Why it's here: The City Manager asked that an evaluation session be added; the posted agenda listed only a real-property session.

    What followed: Further evaluation sessions on Aug 28, Sept 5 and Sept 18. Then the October 20 check raised the City Manager's base pay 8.97%, to $158,002 (see 2017-10), and sold 80 hours of his vacation (see 2017-10-20). No open-session vote on either was located.

    Source: Minutes 2017-08-07 p1

    Records: Meeting 2017-08-07: audio and transcript; Finding E-17

    E-17 Open Meetings

  17. City Manager's base pay raised to $158,002; no open-session vote found

    Why it's here: A raise paid with no open-session vote found. The Apr 24 to Dec 4, 2017 minutes record no action on the City Manager's pay.

    Source: Payroll register

    Records: EX-A03; Finding E-03

    E-03 Executive Pay & Leave

  18. City Manager sells 80 hours of vacation, twice the 40-hour cap, after taking 49.25 hours of vacation when 80 were required

    Why it's here: Twice the 40-hour cap, after 49.25 hours of vacation in the prior 12 months when Resolution 1897 required 80. (He would have met the later 40-hour test.)

    Source: Payroll p18

    Records: EX-A03 p18; Finding E-02

    E-02 Executive Pay & Leave

  19. At the City Manager's request, the Council adds a legal-counsel session at the start of the meeting, 6-0

    Why it's here: The posted agenda listed only a real-property session; no reason for the addition is recorded.

    What followed: The minutes do not say what the legal matter was, and no related action appears in them.

    Source: Minutes 2017-11-13 p1

    Records: Meeting 2017-11-13: audio and transcript; Finding E-17

    E-17 Open Meetings

  20. At the City Manager's request, the Council adds an evaluation session at the start of the meeting, 5-0

    Why it's here: The evaluation session was added mid-meeting at the City Manager's own request, so it never appeared on the public agenda.

    What followed: The payroll register shows no change in the City Manager's pay after this session; his next raise came in October 2018 (see 2018-10). Evaluation sessions can also concern other employees.

    Source: Minutes 2017-12-18 p1

    Records: EX-B03; Minutes 2017-12-18 (EX-B03); Finding E-17

    E-17 Open Meetings

  21. City Manager's base pay raised to $164,996; closed evaluation sessions follow on Oct 29, Nov 5 and Dec 3

    Why it's here: A raise paid with no open-session vote, alongside a run of closed evaluation sessions.

    Source: Payroll; minutes

    Records: EX-A03; EX-B05; EX-B11; EX-B12; Finding E-03; Finding E-05

    E-03 E-05 Executive Pay & Leave Open Meetings

  22. Council approves the retention pay program proposed by the City Manager and the HR Director, 7-0

    Why it's here: Context: the retention program was approved in public and open to eligible employees; the City Manager later took part in it (E-09).

    Source: Minutes 2018-10-22 p3

    Records: EX-B04; Finding E-09

    E-09 Executive Pay & Leave

  23. Resolution 2018-012 hands the employee handbook to the City Manager, 5-0; a closed evaluation session follows the same night

    Why it's here: The Council stopped adopting employee rules itself and let the City Manager issue the handbook. From then on he wrote the rules and was the only one who could grant exceptions to them.

    What followed: Four days later, the November 2 check sold 80 hours of the City Manager's vacation (see 2018-11-02). His October raise had already been paid from the October 19 check (see 2018-10). More evaluation sessions followed on Nov 5 and Dec 3.

    Source: Minutes 2018-10-29 p2

    Records: EX-B05; EX-B06; Finding E-10

    E-10 Executive Pay & Leave

  24. City Manager sells 80 hours of vacation after taking 46.5 hours when 80 were required

    Why it's here: Twice the cap, after 46.5 hours of vacation in the prior 12 months when the October 2018 handbook required 80. (He would have met the later 40-hour test.)

    Source: Payroll p26

    Records: EX-A03 p26; Finding E-02

    E-02 Executive Pay & Leave

  25. First monthly "Wells Fargo Commercial Card" approval appears on the Council's consent calendar (for January 2019)

    Why it's here: From here on the Council approves card spending monthly; the report itself is not in the posted packets.

    Source: Minutes 2019-03-18 p2

    Records: EX-B48; Finding E-32

    E-32 Financial Transparency

  26. Closed evaluation sessions on Sept 16, Oct 7 and Oct 28

    Why it's here: Closed evaluation sessions, followed that fall by a raise with no open vote.

    What followed: The October 18 check, between the Oct 7 and Oct 28 sessions, raised the City Manager's base pay 2.5%, to $169,125 (see 2019-10), and the November 1 check sold 80 hours of his vacation (see 2019-11-01). No open-session vote on either was located.

    Source: Minutes

    Records: EX-B13; EX-B14; EX-B15; Finding E-05

    E-05 Open Meetings

  27. Council passes Ordinance 2019-009 creating the Public Art Commission. The code text presented requires its meetings to follow "Second Amended Resolution 1912."

    Why it's here: Five years later, the City was still writing Resolution 1912 into its own code.

    Source: Special meeting packet 2019-09-23 p6 (code section 2-13-10); Minutes 2019-09-23 p1 (ordinance passed)

    Records: EX-B49; Finding E-31

    E-31 Financial Transparency

  28. City Manager's base pay raised to $169,125

    Why it's here: A raise with no open-session vote found. At 2.5% it was below the citywide raise that year.

    Source: Payroll register

    Records: EX-A03; Finding E-03

    E-03 Executive Pay & Leave

  29. City Manager sells 80 hours of vacation after taking 76 hours when 80 were required

    Why it's here: Twice the cap, after 76 hours of vacation in the prior 12 months when the handbook required 80. (He would have met the later 40-hour test.)

    Source: Payroll p35

    Records: EX-A03 p35; Finding E-02

    E-02 Executive Pay & Leave

  30. Council adopts Ordinance 2020-007 giving the City Manager emergency powers, including authority to waive internal rules to protect employees' health during a declared public health emergency (City Code 1-5-8).

    Why it's here: Context: a possible basis for exceptions to leave rules in 2020-2021, if an emergency order and a written waiver exist.

    Source: City Code Title 1, Chapter 5 (history notes: Ord. 2020-007, 4-6-2020)

    Records: Finding E-02

    E-02 Executive Pay & Leave

  31. Council approves an updated City Manager agreement, 7-0; the staff memo says his pay is not changed

    Why it's here: The Council wrote the City Manager's then-current $169,124 salary into his agreement. Every raise after this, until December 2024, was paid above that approved figure without another open vote.

    Source: Apr 20, 2020 packet pp74-77

    Records: EX-B07; EX-A13; Finding E-07

    E-03 E-07 Executive Pay & Leave

  32. Closed evaluation sessions on Dec 7, 14 and 21; the Mayor emails HR that "the Council is unanimous" on the City Manager's pay

    Why it's here: The Mayor wrote "The Council is unanimous" about a raise that appears in no open-meeting minutes. Closed sessions may not be used to make final decisions.

    What followed: The January 8, 2021 check paid the raise to $185,000 with $4,274.09 in back pay to October, and sold 100 hours of the City Manager's vacation (see 2021-01-08).

    Source: Minutes; #4869

    Records: EX-B16; EX-B17; EX-B18; EX-A05; Finding E-05

    E-05 E-03 Open Meetings Executive Pay & Leave

  33. City Manager's raise to $185,000 is paid back to October; the same check sells 100 hours of vacation after 12 hours of vacation taken in the prior 12 months

    Why it's here: The raise was paid back to October with no open vote, and the same check sold 100 hours, two and a half times the 40-hour cap. He had used 12 hours of vacation in the prior 12 months (21.75 in calendar 2020). That fails the 80-hour test in the 2018 handbook and also the 40-hour standard printed on the City's own 2020-2021 sell-back form (EX-A30).

    Source: Payroll p45

    Records: EX-A03 p45; Finding E-03; Finding E-02

    E-03 E-02 Executive Pay & Leave

  34. Closed evaluation session; the next day the Vice Mayor emails a 4.5% raise and a 5% retirement contribution for the City Manager

    Why it's here: The day after a closed session, the Vice Mayor's email set a raise and a one-time retirement contribution. Neither went to an open vote.

    What followed: The raise was paid as back pay on the November 29 and December 23, 2021 checks and at the new rate ($92.95 an hour) from January 7, 2022 (EX-A03 pp52-53). The November 29 check also sold 100 hours of his vacation (see 2021-11-29).

    Source: Minutes; #4869

    Records: EX-B19; EX-A06; Finding E-05; Finding E-04

    E-05 E-04 Open Meetings Executive Pay & Leave

  35. City Manager sells 100 hours of vacation after taking 31.25 hours when 40 were required

    Why it's here: 100 hours sold, two and a half times the 40-hour cap. He had used 31.25 hours of vacation in the prior 12 months. The City's own sell-back form then in use required 40 hours in the preceding calendar year (he used 21.75 in 2020), and later handbooks require 40 in the preceding 12 months, so the sale falls short either way (EX-A30).

    Source: Payroll p52

    Records: EX-A03 p52; EX-A30; Finding E-02

    E-02 Executive Pay & Leave

  36. City Manager emails his two deputies' new salaries, set as a percentage below his own: "Will you do the forms for me?"

    Why it's here: The City Manager set his deputies' pay as a percentage of his own and asked the HR Director, one of the two, to process it. (Their later raises matched other executives' raises, not his.)

    Source: EX-A27

    Records: EX-A27; Finding E-27

    E-27 Workplace Conduct & HR Independence

  37. Council confirms Gretchen Scott as Deputy City Manager, 5-0

    Why it's here: The Council confirmed the appointment in public; the minutes state no salary.

    Source: Minutes 2021-12-13

    Records: EX-B35; Finding E-27

    E-27 Workplace Conduct & HR Independence

  38. At the City's request, the Council makes the vacant Economic Development Director post a department head (Ordinance 2022-013), so the appointment needs Council confirmation. Council Member Barigar recuses and leaves the dais; 5-0.

    Why it's here: Context. One week before he resigned to apply for the post.

    Source: Packet 2022-07-18 pp20-22; Minutes 2022-07-18 (approved in the 2022-07-25 packet, pp4-5); City Code 1-2-4

    Records: EX-B50; EX-B51; Finding E-28

    E-28 Workplace Conduct & HR Independence

  39. Council Member Barigar resigns to apply for the Economic Development Director job (accepted Aug 1, 5-0)

    Why it's here: Context. A council member resigned, saying he intended to apply for a City job. It was handled in public.

    Source: Minutes 2022-07-25, 2022-08-01

    Records: EX-B36; EX-B37; Finding E-28

    E-28 Workplace Conduct & HR Independence

  40. Fiscal 2022 ends: the audited schedule later shows Janitorial, Fire and Animal Control over their final budgets; the audit's "excess over appropriations" note no longer appears

    Why it's here: First year the audit stops disclosing overspending that its own schedules show.

    Source: 2022 Financial Statements pp53, 79

    Records: Finding E-36

    E-36 Executive Pay & Leave

  41. Council confirms the Economic Development Director appointment, 7-0

    Why it's here: Context: the appointment was confirmed in public.

    Source: Minutes 2022-10-10

    Records: EX-B38; Finding E-28

    E-28 Workplace Conduct & HR Independence

  42. Closed evaluation sessions on Dec 5 and 12; the Mayor's Dec 8 letter sets the City Manager's base pay at $226,000, gives him the $2,000 citywide one-time payment, and lifts his sell-back limit

    Why it's here: The letter lifts the sell-back cap so the City Manager "may realize the benefit of vacation time that you have been unable to take." The payroll register says otherwise: in the 12 months before the letter he used 96 hours of vacation plus 40 of executive leave, more than in the same period of any year since 2016, and he had already sold 80 or 100 hours at a time six times since 2016. Neither meeting recorded a vote.

    What followed: The December 23, 2022 check paid the new rate ($108.65 an hour) with $6,281.54 in back pay, the $2,000 payment, and a 100-hour vacation sale (see 2022-12-23).

    Source: Minutes; #4869

    Records: EX-B09; EX-B10; EX-A01; Finding E-01; Finding E-05

    E-01 E-05 E-03 Executive Pay & Leave Open Meetings

  43. City Manager sells 100 hours of vacation

    Why it's here: 100 hours sold, two and a half times the 40-hour cap, in the same pay period he used 36 hours of vacation.

    Source: Payroll p61

    Records: EX-A03 p61; Finding E-01

    E-01 Executive Pay & Leave

  44. Deputy City Manager Scott files and approves, as both "City Manager" and HR, an employee's promotion to Acting HR Director in 77 seconds; the City Manager's letter that day sets the pay

    Why it's here: One person filled all three approval roles (requester, "City Manager" and HR) in 77 seconds, for an employee she supervises.

    Source: EX-A24 p29; EX-A28

    Records: EX-A24 p29; EX-A28; Finding E-26

    E-26 Workplace Conduct & HR Independence

  45. Closed evaluation session; the Mayor's Dec 6 email gives the City Manager 10% deferred compensation and a $1,500 payment

    Why it's here: Two days after a closed session, the Mayor's email set $22,600 a year in deferred compensation and a $1,500 payment. The Council first approved deferred compensation in public a year later.

    What followed: The December 15 check paid the $1,500 and a $5,000 retention payment (see 2023-12-15); the December 22 check sold 100 hours of his vacation (see 2023-12-22).

    Source: Minutes; #4869

    Records: EX-B20; EX-A08; Finding E-05; Finding E-04

    E-05 E-04 Open Meetings Executive Pay & Leave

  46. Council confirms the HR Director appointment, 7-0

    Why it's here: Context: the appointment was confirmed in public, two months after the acting appointment above.

    Source: Minutes 2023-12-04

    Records: EX-B39; Finding E-26

    E-26 Workplace Conduct & HR Independence

  47. City Manager receives a $5,000 prepaid retention payment under the citywide retention program

    Why it's here: Context: retention pay was open to eligible employees, and his agreement extends employee benefits to him (E-09).

    Source: ERP agreement

    Records: EX-A16; Finding E-09

    E-09 Executive Pay & Leave

  48. City Manager sells 100 hours of vacation

    Why it's here: 100 hours sold, two and a half times the 40-hour cap.

    Source: Payroll p70

    Records: EX-A03 p70; Finding E-01

    E-01 Executive Pay & Leave

  49. Mayor Pierce steps aside on a Suburban Construction Management item, saying "she does accounting for" the firm

    Why it's here: The Mayor said she does accounting for the firm and stepped aside. On later votes involving the same firm, the minutes record no recusal.

    Source: Minutes 2024-10-07 p1

    Records: EX-B28; Finding E-25

    E-25 Contracts & Ethics

  50. City Manager paid 89 hours in an 80-hour pay period (80 regular + 9 Veterans Day holiday), $977.88 over salary

    Why it's here: Holiday hours elsewhere replace regular hours; no reversal appears through May 2026.

    Source: Payroll p78

    Records: EX-A03 p78; Finding E-35

    E-35 Executive Pay & Leave

  51. Council approves an amendment to the City Manager's agreement, 7-0

    Why it's here: The first public vote on the City Manager's pay since 2020: $239,560 base plus $22,600 a year in deferred compensation, which had already been paid for a year.

    Source: Minutes 2024-12-09

    Records: EX-B08; EX-A12; Finding E-04; Finding E-07

    E-04 E-07 Executive Pay & Leave

  52. City Manager sells 100 hours of vacation

    Why it's here: 100 hours sold, two and a half times the 40-hour cap.

    Source: Payroll p78

    Records: EX-A03 p78; Finding E-01

    E-01 Executive Pay & Leave

  53. SuburbanCM ranked first for the City Park Restroom project; Mayor Pierce present, 6-0, no recusal recorded

    Why it's here: The City Park Restroom is a federally funded (CDBG) project. The Mayor was present for the vote ranking the firm she had said she does accounting for; no recusal is recorded.

    Source: Minutes 2025-02-18 p2

    Records: EX-B29; Finding E-25

    E-25 Contracts & Ethics

  54. $1.6 million in reserves and a construction contract with Suburban CM, plus the City Park Restroom contract; Mayor Pierce present, 6-0, no recusal recorded

    Why it's here: The contract with the same firm was approved with the Mayor present and voting; no recusal is recorded.

    Source: Minutes 2025-03-17 pp2-3

    Records: EX-B30; Finding E-25

    E-25 Contracts & Ethics

  55. Payroll takes back an 18-hour overpayment from the June 6 check

    Why it's here: Context: the City reverses payroll errors it catches; the November 2024 one was not reversed.

    Source: Payroll pp82-83

    Records: EX-A03 pp82-83; Finding E-35

    E-35 Executive Pay & Leave

  56. Closed evaluation session; the Mayor's letter the same day sets the City Manager's pay at $272,650 in total

    Why it's here: A closed session and a pay letter on the same day: $272,650, described as "a market-based adjustment." That is $10,490 a year above the pay the Council approved in December 2024, with no open vote.

    What followed: The new rate ($120.22 an hour) appears from the October 10, 2025 check (EX-A03 p85), and the November 21 check sold 100 hours of his vacation (see 2025-11-21).

    Source: Minutes; #4869

    Records: EX-B21; EX-A09; EX-A10; Finding E-05; Finding E-03

    E-05 E-03 Open Meetings Executive Pay & Leave

  57. Fiscal 2025 ends: the audited schedule later shows the Council's own budget over for a third straight year, with Recreation and Public Transportation

    Why it's here: The overruns continue, still without the disclosure earlier audits carried.

    Source: 2025 Annual Comprehensive Financial Report p86

    Records: Finding E-36

    E-36 Executive Pay & Leave

  58. Deputy City Manager Scott files and approves, as both "City Manager" and HR, the HR Director's raise to $73.00 an hour

    Why it's here: The same one-person approval pattern, for a raise to the employee she supervises.

    Source: EX-A24 p38

    Records: EX-A24 p38; Finding E-26

    E-26 Workplace Conduct & HR Independence

  59. $2,395,826 Well #5 contract to Suburban Construction; Mayor Pierce present, 6-0, no recusal recorded

    Why it's here: A $2.4 million contract to the firm, approved with the Mayor present; no recusal is recorded.

    Source: Minutes 2025-11-17

    Records: EX-B31; Finding E-25

    E-25 Contracts & Ethics

  60. City Manager sells 100 hours of vacation

    Why it's here: 100 hours sold, two and a half times the 40-hour cap.

    Source: Payroll p86

    Records: EX-A03 p86; Finding E-01

    E-01 Executive Pay & Leave

  61. City Manager emails that the Council "authorized" a $2,500 stipend for the Deputy City Manager; paid Apr 24

    Why it's here: The email says the Council "authorized" the payment, but none of the Council's meetings that spring record a vote on it.

    Source: Stipend - Gretchen Scott

    Records: EX-A18; EX-A19; EX-B22; EX-B23; EX-B24; EX-B25; EX-B26; Finding E-08

    E-08 Executive Pay & Leave

  62. Request #3946 filed for the City's market analysis

    Why it's here: A request for the consultant's market analysis, the data behind executive pay.

    Source: Completion notice

    Records: EX-C01-1; Request #3946; Finding E-12

    E-12 Public Records Compliance

  63. The City Code, as supplemented through Ordinance 2026-007, still requires Public Art Commission meetings to follow "Second Amended Resolution 1912" (City Code 2-13-10).

    Why it's here: The resolution that promised online accounts payable is still cited in the City's current code.

    Source: City Code 2-13-10 (online code, current through Ord. 2026-007, passed 6-22-2026)

    Records: Finding E-31

    E-31 Financial Transparency

  64. Request #3946 answered with a few items; most of the rest were later said to be withheld

    Why it's here: Nearly everything was withheld as the vendor's "proprietary" material, without the explanation the law requires.

    Source: #3946 response

    Records: EX-C01-3; EX-C01-4; Request #3946; Finding E-12

    E-12 Public Records Compliance

  65. Request #3946: Deputy Clerk says 109 of 117 entries were withheld as "statutorily excluded"

    Why it's here: The completion notice gave no statutory reason for each withheld item.

    Source: PRR #3946 correspondence (7/13/2026)

    Records: EX-C01-4; Request #3946; Finding E-12

    E-12 Public Records Compliance

  66. Council approves negotiations with Suburban Construction Management for a park project; Pierce present, 6-0, no recusal recorded

    Why it's here: Another vote on the same firm's work with no recusal recorded.

    Source: Minutes 2026-08-17 p2

    Records: EX-B32; Finding E-25

    E-25 Contracts & Ethics

  67. Request about the cost of the market analysis denied for "failure to comply with 74-102(4)"

    Why it's here: The same requester had corresponded with the City for months without an identity question, until pressing for the withheld records.

    Source: Denial notice (9/24/2026)

    Records: EX-C02-2; Finding E-22; Finding E-18

    E-22 E-18 Public Records Compliance Contracts & Ethics

  68. $486,013 contract with Suburban Construction; Council Member Pierce seconds the motion, 6-0

    Why it's here: The motion was seconded by the Council member who had said she does accounting for the firm; no recusal is recorded.

    Source: Minutes 2026-10-05 p2

    Records: EX-B33; Finding E-25

    E-25 Contracts & Ethics

  69. Request #4869 answered: no 2015 City Manager agreement produced

    Why it's here: The Council approved a 2015 agreement in public, but the production skipped it with no denial notice.

    Source: PRR #4869 production

    Records: EX-C05-3; Request #4869; Finding E-11

    E-11 Public Records Compliance

  70. Request #4814 answered with HR payroll registers; accounts payable reports not produced

    Why it's here: The City said reimbursements "will therefore appear on separate reports"; none came.

    Source: PRR #4814 response

    Records: EX-C04-3; Request #4814; Finding E-14

    E-14 Public Records Compliance

  71. Three requests for leave and sell-back records denied, two of them within 16 and 69 minutes: "please stop requesting"

    Why it's here: Each denial cited only the personnel-records exemption (74-106(1)); the third added "Per our City Attorney, please stop requesting the same information."

    Source: Denial notices (10/15 and 10/16/2026)

    Records: EX-C08-2; EX-C09-2; EX-C10-2; Finding E-21

    E-21 Public Records Compliance

  72. $900,000 change order with Suburban Construction; Council Member Pierce makes the motion, 6-0

    Why it's here: The change order was moved by the Council member who had said she does accounting for the firm; no recusal is recorded.

    Source: Minutes 2026-10-19 p1

    Records: EX-B34; Finding E-25

    E-25 Contracts & Ethics

  73. Request #4940 passes 10 working days with no response: deemed denied by law

    Why it's here: Five follow-ups through Nov 5 went unanswered.

    Source: PRR #4940 correspondence

    Records: EX-C06-2; Request #4940; Finding E-20

    E-20 Public Records Compliance

  74. Request #4953 denied for "non-compliance with 74-102(4)"; City Attorney questions the requester's identity

    Why it's here: The request asked for every handbook exception granted to executives.

    Source: PRR #4953 response and correspondence

    Records: EX-C07-3; EX-C07-4; Request #4953; Finding E-15; Finding E-22

    E-15 E-22 Public Records Compliance

  75. Request #5061 for copies of records requests denied: "not a record that is held"

    Why it's here: Every City response attaches the requester's own request form, and request numbers pass 5,000.

    Source: PRR #5061 response

    Records: EX-C11-3; Request #5061; Finding E-13

    E-13 Public Records Compliance

  76. Three days after denying it holds copies of records requests, the City delivers 1,183 of them (#5162), three hours after writing that it would take IT "days" and "a large charge"

    Why it's here: The first two requests for the same records were denied on Nov 2 and Nov 3.

    Source: Records request #5162 correspondence (Nov 5-6, 2026)

    Records: EX-C13-3; Request #5162; Finding E-13

    E-13 Public Records Compliance

  77. The City website's site map lists no accounts payable, check register, monthly financial report or financial dashboard. Its Finance links are the City Budget, the Master Fee Schedule and building permit fees.

    Why it's here: What Resolution 1912 promised is not there.

    Source: tfid.org/SiteMap and tfid.org/161/City-Budget (checked 2026-11-10)

    Records: Finding E-31

    E-31 Financial Transparency