OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

E-06 Indicated

The "performance review committee" was publicly created once (2014) and never again

Rule at stake: Possibly state law how findings are ranked

City of Twin Falls · Possible open-meeting (subagency) / authority

Why it matters

A committee that decides an executive's pay is doing public business. If it meets without notice, open meetings or minutes, the public can't tell who decided or on what basis.

Hidden decisions

What the records show

On Sept 2, 2014, the Council voted 7-0 to let Mayor Hall form a committee (Hall, Vice Mayor Hawkins, Councilmember Talkington) "to complete the annual performance evaluation of the City Manager and City Attorney." No later motion naming a committee or members was found in any minutes 2015-2026. The 2022-2025 pay letters rely on "the performance review committee." The wording changed between the two letters. Dec 8, 2022: "The Twin Falls City Council designates an evaluation committee to conduct performance reviews and to discuss compensation increases." Sept 8, 2025: "The Twin Falls City Council conducts performance reviews and discusses compensation increases." Both letters then say the pay direction is "Based on the direction of the performance review committee" (EX-A01, EX-A09).
From the City's own recordings (machine transcripts; each reference plays that moment): at the 2014 vote the Mayor says that forming such a committee has to come before the Council under the City's transparency resolution (Meeting 2014-09-02 at 4:12:48).
Who was on it: none of the three 2014 members was on the Council when the pay letters were signed. Don Hall is last listed on the Council in the Minutes 2017-01-09 p1, Chris Talkington's last roll call is in the Minutes 2020-01-06 p1, and Suzanne Hawkins's last roll call, as Mayor, is in the Minutes 2022-01-03 p1. The Council on Dec 5, 2022 was Mayor Ruth Pierce, Vice Mayor Christopher Reid and Council Members Craig Hawkins, Jason Brown, Spencer Cutler, Nikki Boyd and Alexandra Caval (EX-B09); on Sept 8, 2025 it was Mayor Ruth Pierce, Vice Mayor Jason Brown and Council Members Craig Hawkins, Christopher Reid, Spencer Cutler, Cherie Vollmer and Grayson Stone (EX-B21). Council Member Craig Hawkins is not the Suzanne Hawkins named in 2014.

Rule it is measured against

AG Open Meeting Law Manual p.4, Questions 3-4: a subagency created by or pursuant to a legislative act with authority to make decisions or recommendations is a governing body subject to notice, open-meeting and minutes rules.

Explanations we checked

Re-checked on Nov 9, 2026 across all minutes, agendas and packets from Sept 2014 to Nov 2026: no other mention of a committee to evaluate the City Manager.
We searched machine transcripts of 529 City-posted Council recordings (2013 to November 2026) for an evaluation, review or compensation committee for the City Manager. Only the September 2, 2014 meeting mentions one. Machine transcripts miss words, so this is a search result, not proof.

What would change this finding

This finding would change if a Council motion or resolution after 2014 created a standing evaluation committee or named its members. It would be in the minutes. None appears in any minutes from 2015 to 2026, and all three members named in 2014 had left the Council by January 2022.

We aren't alleging that anyone acted in bad faith. A record made at the time could explain what's shown here. If the agency holds one that it didn't produce in answer to an earlier request, it can still release it, and we'll update this finding. A record made now carries today's date.

Records

  • EX-A01 2022-12-08 Mayor letter lifting City Manager sell-back limit, with HR emails · PRR #4869 ↓
  • EX-A09 2025 compensation letter signed by the Mayor · PRR #4869 ↓
  • EX-B01 2014-09-02 minutes - Council creates City Manager evaluation committee (excerpt) · Council minutes ↓
  • EX-B09 2022-12-05 minutes - evaluation session, no motion on City Manager pay · Council minutes ↓
  • EX-B21 2025-09-08 minutes - executive session under 74-206(1)(b) · Council minutes ↓
  • EX-C15-1 Requester's copy of the submitted request form (Nov 17, 2026) · PRR #5293 (requester's copy) ↓
  • EX-C15-2 City notices, Nov 17-20 2026 - received, processing, final review, result · PRR #5293 ↓
  • EX-C15-3 City response, Nov 20 2026 - not in possession, denied under I.C. 74-102(4) · PRR #5293 ↓
Page-level citations

Minutes 2014-09-02 pp14-15 (Item II.10). EX-A01 (Dec 8, 2022 letter); EX-A09 (Sept 8, 2025 letter).; Minutes 2017-01-09, 2020-01-06, 2022-01-03 (roll calls); EX-B09, EX-B21 (roll calls).

Records asked for

Requests already made that bear on this finding:

  • Request #4729: ELT compensation records FY21-FY26 (filed 2026-08 (approx.)). Produced HR documents
  • Request #4869: CM contract versions + handbook exceptions (filed 2026-09). Produced 2020/2024 agreements, letters; no 2015 agreement; no Council exception directives
  • Request #5293: Council committee for City Manager / City Attorney evaluations: membership, rules on committees, notices and minutes, compensation recommendations, minutes of 14 executive sessions (2014-present) (filed 2026-11-17). Denied Nov 20 (within 3 working days), one page: "not in possession of a report or record of that nature" and "denied under Idaho Code 74-102(4" (cut off). No item-by-item answer; no statute tied to any item; nothing was asked of the requester first. The City's delivery folder held only the denial and its own copy of the request.

More records that could explain this finding, show that it was authorized, or change it have been identified, and requests for them are planned. Each is listed here once it is filed.

A complete answer depends on the agency responding to these requests as the Idaho Public Records Act requires.

How to read this finding

This page states what the records obtained so far show and the rule they are measured against. Its grade says how firmly the records show it, "Rule at stake" says what kind of rule is involved, and the labels under "Why it matters" say who bears the cost (more on the three labels). It is not an accusation, not a legal conclusion and not the whole story. A record we don't have could explain what is shown here or add to it, and we update a finding when new records arrive. Citations to a recording link to that moment in the audio. Transcripts and the searchable text of scanned documents are made by software, so listen or open the file before you quote. If this finding concerns you, ask the governing body to answer it in public, or ask an office with the authority to investigate.

Tell the City Council

The City Council answers to residents, and you don't have to attend a meeting to be heard. Send a written comment through the City's own public comment form, or write to members directly (addresses on the City's site). Point them to this finding and its records so they can check for themselves.

A starting point to put in your own words

I'm writing about a matter shown in the City's own records: The "performance review committee" was publicly created once (2014) and never again (Oversight Archive E-06). The records are at https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/findings/e-06/. I'm asking the City Council to [explain in an open meeting how this was decided / place it on a public agenda / tell residents which policy applies].

This is not anonymous. Comments sent to the City become public records. They can be shared in a meeting packet and released to anyone who asks, and the form may ask for your name and address. If you'd rather not be identified, use our tip line instead.

Who to contact: the City staff directory published by the City of Twin Falls. The City's own list of departments and staff, with phone numbers and email addresses. It isn't dated and may be out of date in places, so confirm with the office before relying on a name or title.

The City Council can act only on items on a posted agenda (upcoming meetings), so asking for a matter to be placed on one is often the most useful request. Your own words carry more weight than a copied letter. Stick to what the records show. More ways to take part: Make a difference.