OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, June 24, 2013

Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

The audio for this recording isn't posted yet. It's being held back until a privacy review is finished. The transcript below is complete apart from marked passages.

Transcript

0:00:00 No, this is the one this is the one.

0:00:03 Like, please, like, these are always feel good meetings.

0:00:18 They are.

0:00:19 It just sets the whole tone doing it at the beginning.

0:00:21 It picks everything else.

0:00:46 You can see again.

0:00:58 Okay.

0:00:59 Are we ready?

0:01:00 One.

0:01:03 I'd like to call the June 17th, 2013 meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order our first item of businesses to pledge.

0:01:10 All those like to join us, please stand.

0:01:17 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:01:48 I affirm we do have a clarm six to the seven are here.

0:01:52 Councilman or vice mayor Don Hall was in Boise.

0:01:55 His program was receiving an award today and that's certainly

0:01:59 an excused absence, I believe.

0:02:02 Next introduction of staff, city manager Travis Wossweiler,

0:02:05 City Attorney Fritz Wonderlook, Community Development Director Mitch Humble, Deputy

0:02:10 City Clerk, Recording Secretary of the Senate, she has the bills of airport manager Bill

0:02:15 Harbury, Sergeant Ryan Howe, Chief Brian Pike, Captain Anthony Barnite, Lieutenant Craig Stott's,

0:02:21 Fire Chief Ron Clark and Battalion Chief Ron Aguera, who I'll be presenting tonight.

0:02:28 Travis, do we have any amendments to the agenda?

0:02:32 Mr. Mayor, members of the council staff would ask that you consider two amendments, and I believe it's on your amended agenda that's in front of you the copy.

0:02:40 The first, okay, so Lee Eilay says that you have the documentation in front of you.

0:02:47 The first one is to provide the city council with an update on the police department's effort to curb the use of unsafe illegal fireworks in the city.

0:02:57 This is an agenda item that should have appeared on our agenda and for some reason it was inadvertently

0:03:04 left off.

0:03:05 We had made the commitment to come back to you tonight to have this conversation and in some

0:03:09 of the conversations I've had with some of you it sounds like it is an appropriate timing

0:03:14 for that.

0:03:15 So we would ask that you add that.

0:03:16 The second is Mr. Mayor how you want to roll that that is.

0:03:30 I think it makes sense we go ahead to the police of the first three items, so let's make it 3-8.

0:03:39 And then Mr. Mayor and members of the Council should you also see FET staff is requesting an executive session under 672345 subsection 1e to consider preliminary negotiations involving matters of trade or commerce in which the governing body is in competition with governing bodies in other states and or nations.

0:04:02 came out of a conversation that staff had on Saturday afternoon with a series of

0:04:07 site consultants. So that would just be in addition to the other two that we

0:04:12 already have on the agenda. Yes sir. Move for the amended attendance as proposed

0:04:18 by the city manager. Second. Been moved by Chris Tockington and seconded by Rebecca

0:04:23 Milsoyka that we amend the agenda as described by our city manager

0:04:29 President Twethweiler, any questions?

0:04:32 Seeing none, Leila Roapova.

0:04:34 Sean Barroker.

0:04:35 Yes.

0:04:36 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:04:37 Yes.

0:04:37 Greg Lantine.

0:04:38 Yes.

0:04:39 Jim Mon.

0:04:40 Yes.

0:04:41 Ritekamil Suica.

0:04:42 Yes.

0:04:43 Quiz Chon.

0:04:44 Yes.

0:04:45 Motion passes six to zero.

0:04:46 We have no proclamation tonight.

0:04:48 The next item would be the consent calendar.

0:04:50 Council wishes.

0:04:52 Move approval.

0:04:54 Second.

0:04:55 Then moved by Suzanne Hawkins.

0:04:57 Seconded by Sean Berger to approve the consent calendar

0:05:02 as printed, see no lights for conversation.

0:05:06 We have a roll call vote.

0:05:07 Susan Hawkins?

0:05:08 Yes.

0:05:09 Greg Lanthine?

0:05:10 Yes.

0:05:10 Jim Mon?

0:05:11 Yes.

0:05:12 Rebecca Mills-Smechka?

0:05:13 Yes.

0:05:14 Tess Tawkington?

0:05:15 Yes.

0:05:16 Sean Berger?

0:05:17 Yes.

0:05:18 Motion passes six to zero.

0:05:19 Moving on to items for consideration.

0:05:22 First item is, I believe we're going to switch this round.

0:05:25 First item, we will have a swearing-in son of a boy,

0:05:28 but we're gonna have presentations to officers,

0:05:30 Sean Applewhite, Christopher Hart,

0:05:33 Tyler Rutkin, and their basic certifications,

0:05:37 and Officer Dallas Garner for his intermediate certification,

0:05:41 and also a presentation to dispatcher Tina Kelly,

0:05:45 with her level three communication specialist certification,

0:05:49 Captain Barnard.

0:05:51 Good evening and thank you, Mayor and City Council,

0:05:53 for giving us this opportunity to recognize

0:05:55 and honor the achievements of our employees tonight.

0:05:58 It is vitally important to us that we have a well-trained

0:06:01 professional police department to provide the best possible

0:06:04 public safety to our community,

0:06:06 and I think that everyone would agree with that.

0:06:08 Tonight, we're gonna recognize Officer Sean Applewhite,

0:06:11 Ty Rutkin, and Chrissy are with their basic certificate.

0:06:16 It takes hundreds of training hours and time and service

0:06:18 to achieve these certificates.

0:06:20 I would ask that the officers please come forward now.

0:06:26 I would also ask that Chief Pike and Mayor Lanting

0:06:29 please come forward to help present the certificates.

0:06:38 First one will be for Shawn Applewhite.

0:06:40 Shawn was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department

0:06:42 on December 6, 2011 as a full-time police officer.

0:06:46 Shawn was born in Pomona, California.

0:06:50 He and his family moved to the Magic Valley in 1984.

0:06:53 Shawn graduated from Jerome High School

0:06:54 and then attended the College of Southern Idaho.

0:06:57 In 2003, he received his real estate license

0:07:00 Prior to his employment, he worked for Magic Valley Realty for seven years selling residential,

0:07:07 commercial, and new construction.

0:07:10 Sean participated in our reserve program in 2001.

0:07:14 In 2011, Sean successfully attended and graduated from the Post Basic Patrol Academy.

0:07:19 It is with great pleasure that we present Sean with the basic certificate from the State of

0:07:25 Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training Council.

0:07:49 Next is Ty Rutkin. Ty was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on May 14, 2012 as

0:07:55 a full-time police officer. Ty was born in Norwich, Connecticut, where his father was

0:08:00 stationed with the United States Navy. Because of his father's military service, Ty has lived

0:08:04 in Idaho, Washington, Connecticut, and Georgia. After completing his high school, he attended

0:08:10 Arizona Western College, where he graduated with an associate's degree in mathematics and

0:08:14 engineering. He then continued his education at Boise State University, where he reached

0:08:18 received his bachelor's degree in criminal justice.

0:08:22 He plans to continue his education

0:08:24 at a graduate level in a related field.

0:08:30 Ty successfully attended and graduated

0:08:32 from the Post Basic Patrol Academy.

0:08:34 It is with great pleasure that we present Ty

0:08:37 with the basic certificate from the State of Idaho

0:08:39 Peace Officer Standards and Training Council.

0:09:02 Next is Christopher E. Hart.

0:09:04 Chris E. Hart was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department

0:09:07 on May 14th, 2012 as a full-time police officer.

0:09:11 Chris was born in Idaho Falls and grew up in Shelley, Idaho.

0:09:14 He attended the Idaho State University Law Enforcement Program

0:09:17 and graduated on May 2, 2012.

0:09:21 Prior to his employment with the Twin Falls Police Department,

0:09:24 Chris was employed in jewelry sales.

0:09:27 Over the past year, Chris and his family

0:09:30 have built their home here in Twin Falls

0:09:32 and have really grown fond of the community.

0:09:35 It is with great pleasure that we present Chris

0:09:37 with the basic certificate from the State of Idaho

0:09:40 peace officers, standards, and training council.

0:10:00 That concludes the certificates.

0:10:14 I have the privilege of continuing tonight

0:10:16 by swearing in one of our newest officers, Stuart.

0:10:19 Burnham, I'd like Stuart to come up.

0:10:25 Stuart's been on the range all day.

0:10:27 I'm sure he's had an interesting day,

0:10:30 but Stuart, this is where the journey begins for you.

0:10:35 The road ahead is challenging.

0:10:36 You're about ready to leave and to attend the post academy

0:10:40 for the next 10 weeks.

0:10:42 You've finished the academy learning your lawn theory.

0:10:44 come back to the police department where you'll start your 16 weeks of field training. It's

0:10:49 there that you'll forge the two of the law and theory into a practical application of knowledge.

0:10:55 All this while being evaluated on a daily basis until you possess the skills and professionalism

0:11:01 that this field demands. The ultimate destination is to reach a point of competence and professionalism

0:11:07 to serve our community here in Twin Falls. With that council, I'd like to introduce you and our

0:11:12 community to their newest officer. Stewart was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department

0:11:17 on May 28. He was born and raised in Rock Springs, Wyoming. He graduated from Rock Springs

0:11:22 High School in 2009. He went to serve an LDS mission in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, where

0:11:28 he learned to speak Spanish while serving the Hispanic people of that area. After his mission,

0:11:33 Stewart attended Idaho State University while attending ISU. He worked with Public Safety

0:11:38 Department and it was there that he found and had a desire to seek a career in

0:11:44 law enforcement. In January of 2013 he began with the ISU law enforcement program

0:11:50 where he attended one semester before being hired by our department. Stuart is

0:11:54 married to his wife Stephanie and he's looking forward to serving the citizens

0:11:57 of Twin Falls. Tonight the ceremony really consists of two parts, the pinning of the

0:12:03 police badge and the oath of office administered by Mayor Lanting. Stuart the

0:12:08 The oath that you are about to take tonight represents the heart of everything that we stand

0:12:12 for in law enforcement.

0:12:15 These are more than words repeated and a paper signed.

0:12:18 This badge that you'll receive tonight represents that commitment.

0:12:21 It's the symbol of your office and the trust the community has given you to perform your

0:12:26 job.

0:12:27 By raising your hand and affirming your commitment to provide public safety to our community, you

0:12:32 will be empowered to perform the functions of your job.

0:12:35 My charge to you is to be always mindful of the community's trust and ever diligent in

0:12:41 your duties.

0:12:42 This time I'd like to invite the mayor down for the swearing-in and I'll be on the shield.

0:12:46 To make sense, the third S-bird of the United States of America Constitution and law of the State of Idaho,

0:13:32 and the City of Twin Falls regulation, the Twin Falls Police Department,

0:13:45 and faithfully discharged the duties of the office of police officer,

0:13:58 the Twin Falls Police Department, to which I have been appointed,

0:14:04 and I have been appointed according to the law.

0:14:58 Yes, Jim.

0:15:00 Oh, thank you, Mayor. I wanted to express to the police department

0:15:03 department on behalf of Don Hall as a mayor indicated he was in Boise today

0:15:07 receiving a reward for the law enforcement program at the

0:15:11 professional technical education association meeting

0:15:15 we want to congratulate everyone for your appointment here and

0:15:19 job well done. So thank you chief.

0:15:24 Chris, I don't think there's anything to the rumor that

0:15:28 you're going to put Officer Garner on the roughest route in

0:15:32 falls and that's dealing with fireworks control isn't that's just a rumor okay

0:15:37 all right item number two sit rest in a quest by

0:15:42 Robir Drtavik a representative the Miladi Behar group to provide a bus Bosnian

0:15:51 dancing event at the senior center located at 530 show street west on June

0:15:56 29th 2013 Sergeant Hal. Mayors City Council appreciate you taking the time. We received

0:16:03 a request from Ramiz Dura Tovic have the Mladi Bahaarg Group come and perform in these

0:16:13 Twin Falls Senior Center. The event is not an annual event. It's occurred once here before,

0:16:21 What he's requesting is that they be allowed to sell, consume and have alcohol on the premise.

0:16:29 They have obtained a nonprofit alcohol license, which I have a copy of that came in today.

0:16:37 They plan on having security, which ensures that the alcohol is kept only to the adults,

0:16:45 and the security that they're going to have is just checking identification.

0:16:48 they are going to have a armed security or anything like that there.

0:16:53 It's going to go from 7 p.m. until 12 a.m. or midnight and they're going to be using wrist

0:16:59 fans for the security of the alcohol.

0:17:04 Because it's a city center, because we're requiring a certificate of liability insurance

0:17:11 for the event and that has been obtained.

0:17:15 Are there any questions?

0:17:16 Any questions for Sergeant Hal?

0:17:18 I would like to make a comment.

0:17:20 Thank you, Mayor.

0:17:21 This may be a question for the City Manager, I'm not sure.

0:17:24 But I know we've talked about serving alcohol

0:17:27 at the senior center before.

0:17:29 So my question is just why this might come to the council

0:17:33 because I think we've pre-approved events

0:17:35 with alcohol there before.

0:17:37 You have, and this is a wonderful example

0:17:40 of how we need to enhance communication

0:17:42 in our organization.

0:17:43 This is an event that I could have signed off on, but in all honesty, there's also, when

0:17:52 we had the conversation about events in the senior citizen centers, I said that if there

0:17:57 were events that I may not be just comfortable in signing and moving forward, that I would

0:18:02 bring to the council for their blessing.

0:18:04 And in reviewing this after the agenda was published, this is one that I would have asked

0:18:11 sergeant how to send to you guys for your review because I think it is maybe different

0:18:17 and out of the ordinary of what we've typically gone forward in the past.

0:18:21 The council has said through the special event process and the securing of a company to dispense

0:18:34 of the liquor that the council would be welcome to those ideas and suggestions.

0:18:39 Great. Thank you. And I don't mind that it comes to council at all. I was just curious

0:18:45 because I thought we had had that conversation, but so that's my only question. It sounds

0:18:50 like a great event and glad that we're getting events of different ethnic backgrounds in Twin

0:18:56 Falls. I think that adds a lot to our community.

0:18:59 Absolutely. I think it starts with how, from our past things, it seems like the first time

0:19:04 something comes to us, we usually like to take a look at it anyway. I think that's

0:19:09 probably what Travis is referring to since it's the first annual for them or

0:19:14 personally.

0:19:15 Possibly annual that we'd usually see them so that's right.

0:19:20 Thanks.

0:19:21 Jim.

0:19:22 Well thank you Mayor.

0:19:23 I also like the idea of bringing these forward to council when they're being conducted in buildings

0:19:27 that we own and it's a city-owned building and I think that in my opinion anytime we

0:19:33 would have any event in a city building where there would be alcohol or a police analysis

0:19:38 security and we'd be nice just to just to hear about it. Thank you.

0:19:42 Just talking. Ditto on that. I think whether responsibility, no. Yeah. I would move to

0:19:50 approve the request for the Bosnian Dancing event at the senior center on

0:19:54 the described date subject to the requirements of the police department.

0:19:58 Second. I've been moved by Chris talking and seconded by Rebecca

0:20:02 the event be approved with police restrictions has known it.

0:20:10 Seeing no lights.

0:20:12 The roll call vote.

0:20:13 Mr. Glantane.

0:20:14 Yes.

0:20:15 Jim Mon.

0:20:16 Yes.

0:20:17 Rebecca Milsica.

0:20:18 Yes.

0:20:19 Yes.

0:20:20 John Berriger.

0:20:21 Yes.

0:20:23 Suzanne Hunt.

0:20:24 Motion passes six to zero.

0:20:26 Moving on to the next item I believe Sarge Tal is that one as well.

0:20:31 as well. Consideration of request by Sam Salataga, owner of the Europe Bar and

0:20:36 Deli to approve a July 4 celebration to be held at the parking lot of 677 and 678

0:20:43 Father Avenue on July 4 2014. I believe we had a an addendum that was

0:20:49 presented to us with the permissions by those businesses and

0:20:55 members, we have that. So just now. Yes, thank you, Mayor, City Council. The

0:21:03 addendum was the letters from the businesses that were hereby that granted their permission

0:21:08 to approve the event and those were given to us a little bit later than the agenda, so

0:21:13 that's why they were like, I apologize for that. The Europe Bar and Delhi is located

0:21:20 in the corner of filer and film work and the owner of that Sam Seltaga has requested

0:21:28 that he be allowed to have a live music or amplified music on that area before the fireworks

0:21:36 that occur on the 4th of July.

0:21:38 He's planning on having the music played in a moderate level from 6 p.m. until 9 p.m.

0:21:45 after which he will be cleaning up the area.

0:21:47 Again, this is private property.

0:21:49 The only reason that this is coming to counsel is because of the amplified music and the chances

0:21:56 of possibly receiving complaints from the neighborhood.

0:22:01 Are there any questions on this one?

0:22:03 There will be no alcohol, sir, I'm sorry.

0:22:06 And he wanted to make sure that part of the requirements were, he was going to post signs

0:22:12 saying that no alcohol would be allowed on the premise, and that would be in that parking

0:22:16 lot.

0:22:17 I'm assuming there'll be a lot all out inside though.

0:22:20 Since they are a bar.

0:22:20 I believe inside the bar there'll be alcohol.

0:22:22 Okay.

0:22:23 All right.

0:22:24 We're back missing.

0:22:25 Thank you, Mayor.

0:22:26 That was my question.

0:22:27 I just wondered, I'm, there are businesses in that mall that serve alcohol.

0:22:32 So our alcohol will be served nearby at the event or?

0:22:36 Yes, my, we have, uh, Garrett Baldy's which is close to there and we have your bar and

0:22:42 road bridges, which is right there and I believe that they will be allowed to continue

0:22:46 of serving alcohol in their premise,

0:22:48 it will not be allowed outside and into the parking lot.

0:22:51 Okay, thank you.

0:22:53 Suzanne Hockens.

0:22:54 I know they contacted the other business owners

0:22:56 in the parking lot.

0:22:57 Did anybody reach out to the neighbors right across the street

0:22:59 there on Fillmore, do you know?

0:23:01 I do not know if they did or not.

0:23:03 I'm sorry.

0:23:03 Okay.

0:23:06 We do have a, is there just saying,

0:23:10 if Sam or Mrs. Tucker, are you, could you answer that?

0:23:14 I just wanted to say, yeah, I didn't know the neighbors,

0:23:16 that these are actually the owners of the buildings.

0:23:18 There's three different buildings on the parking lot,

0:23:21 and all businesses are actually

0:23:23 in the full-down area more than before.

0:23:37 But your business is across the street

0:23:39 from the houses on Fillmore, correct?

0:23:42 I was just concerned about the neighbors

0:23:44 across the street with the noise.

0:23:49 Oh, okay.

0:23:56 So the speakers will be facing the filers.

0:23:59 Perfect.

0:24:00 Thank you very much.

0:24:01 Jim, I might as more questions

0:24:03 and just maybe answers to that report,

0:24:04 is the, how late is the music playing?

0:24:07 Nine PM.

0:24:08 Nine PM, okay.

0:24:12 And so I'm just having a little experience in this regard.

0:24:17 When Mr. Sultaga indicates that there's no alcohol

0:24:21 allowed outside, there's no way to enforce that.

0:24:24 If you walk out of the bar with the drink,

0:24:26 you can't lock them up, you can't do anything with them.

0:24:28 So we're just gonna have to make a presumption here

0:24:30 that everybody can drink out in the parking lot, right?

0:24:33 I mean it's private property,

0:24:34 there would be no reason why they can't drink.

0:24:35 Let's get right to reality here. So I think we're proving this with the with the with the understanding that you'll walk out of Gary Baldy's

0:24:43 Have a beer or the whatever the European bar, and I'm not I don't have a problem with that

0:24:49 I guess but

0:24:51 The saying you're not allowed to bring have alcohol in the parking lot

0:24:55 Enging happen

0:24:58 I would certainly wouldn't be allowing you know, I mean you can't walk out of care Baldy's with the

0:25:03 How are you going to Skype off glass of glass they don't they don't just give me a

0:25:08 go-up I understand I agree with you yeah so I mean I guess it's fine but I would

0:25:15 submit there will be drinking the parking lot right Sam I would I'm going to

0:25:23 leisure Sam we should have you come to the mic it is a televised meeting and I

0:25:30 can't see it back there well anyway but again I'm understanding is that goes

0:25:37 under the open container rule.

0:25:39 So that would not, because you could have an open container

0:25:42 in a private parking lot.

0:25:43 On the parking lot.

0:25:44 Sure.

0:25:44 No.

0:25:44 You could have open containers in a private parking lot

0:25:48 that's open to public use.

0:25:50 There's nothing to prohibit it, I don't think.

0:25:55 Right.

0:25:55 OK, then that would answer that question.

0:25:58 Right.

0:25:58 OK.

0:25:59 All right.

0:26:00 Kristine.

0:26:01 I'd just like a little clarification from Fritz.

0:26:04 What we're really authorizing in a dance

0:26:06 where there may or may not be alcohol that's currently served

0:26:09 the adjacent private property establishment is a city's liability impacted one way or

0:26:16 the other by authorizing this?

0:26:18 No, no.

0:26:19 And Councilman Mine is right, as long as they are on the private property, we don't have

0:26:24 anything to regulate them until they get inside a car or they get out under the public

0:26:29 sidewalk.

0:26:30 Right.

0:26:31 Thank you.

0:26:33 Rebecca Milsley.

0:26:34 Thank you, Mayor.

0:26:36 I just wanted to comment.

0:26:37 I agree with Councilman Mine.

0:26:38 It might be an issue, but I appreciate that in the report it does say that if continued police responses occur,

0:26:45 Mr. Salthaga may be billed for the use of extraordinary resources.

0:26:49 And I would recommend that at the end of the event we evaluate if we had to have police presence or extra security.

0:26:59 Just in case they do it again, which is great, but usually we do require security at events with alcohol.

0:27:06 just as a practice, but I feel comfortable allowing them

0:27:12 to have the event and seeing how it goes

0:27:14 and perhaps reevaluating at the end

0:27:17 to make sure that there isn't a need for security

0:27:19 or place presence, but thank you.

0:27:23 All right, sounds like we're probably ready for a motion.

0:27:29 Oh, Mayor, I have moved to approval of the request

0:27:32 as described and pinned by Sergeant Howell.

0:27:36 Okay, second.

0:27:38 And then moved by Jim on second by Sean Berger

0:27:41 that we approved the request made by Sam Salataga

0:27:45 as the owner of the Year Bar for a July 4 celebration

0:27:48 in the parking lot of 677 and 678 Fiverr Avenue

0:27:51 on the 4th of July.

0:27:54 So you know, Licely had a roll call vote.

0:27:56 Jim on.

0:27:57 Yes.

0:27:58 Or if I can else like that.

0:27:58 Yes.

0:27:59 Has Tocquenten.

0:28:00 Yes.

0:28:01 Sean Berger.

0:28:02 Yes.

0:28:03 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:28:03 Yes.

0:28:04 Great Lansing.

0:28:05 Yes.

0:28:06 Motion passes six to zero.

0:28:08 Moving on to item 3A, which is a discussion about our ordinances and concerning illegal fireworks.

0:28:17 And I assume since Captain Barnhart is the one who stepped up, he's the one who we can't leave it.

0:28:22 Thank you.

0:28:23 Captain Barnhart.

0:28:24 Thank you, and good evening.

0:28:25 At the July 9th 2012 City Council meeting, Councilman Chris Talkington brought for discussion

0:28:30 the 4th of July, specifically noise disturbances associated with illegal fireworks, and the

0:28:36 Fireworks Ordinance. On November 19th, 2012, amendments to the City Ordinance 6-9-2 pertaining

0:28:46 to fireworks was presented to the Council for their consideration. The amendments specifically

0:28:51 address permit requirements and fees, authorized dates of sale and hours of use, short-term

0:28:58 storage of fireworks, compliance with the State Fireworks Act, confiscation of illegal

0:29:04 fireworks by police and penalties for possession and use of unsafe fireworks.

0:29:08 The amendments were adopted. As part of the plan to have a safer 4th of July, we

0:29:14 committed to a strong campaign during the month of June to educate our community

0:29:17 about the amendments made to the fireworks ordinance. Followed up with the campaign

0:29:22 regarding enforcement action that will be taken by our police department in

0:29:26 accordance with the ordinance. We are currently in the campaign to educate the

0:29:31 citizens about safe and safe fireworks. The campaign is a series of messages that escalated

0:29:37 frequency beginning June 3rd and ending July 5th. The campaign uses social media, local

0:29:42 media outlets and scenic communication platforms such as the website and utility billing statements.

0:29:49 The educational information consists of what safe and safe fireworks are, what are the

0:29:55 legal times and dates to use safe and safe fireworks, why the city revised its fireworks

0:30:00 ordinance and what the city is doing to enforce the ordinance. Media releases were

0:30:06 issued to local media on June 3rd which outline safe insane fireworks and legal

0:30:12 time to use them into in falls. A second media release will be issued on June 26th

0:30:18 regarding increased enforcement of the fireworks ordinance this 4th of July.

0:30:22 In addition to these media releases public service announcements are being

0:30:27 broadcast on KVT. Many local media outlets have helped by broadcasting or

0:30:34 publishing news stories on this topic. During the week of June 17, citizens will

0:30:40 receive their utility billing in their utility billing, a brief description of

0:30:44 safe and safe fireworks as well as legal times to use fireworks. On June 3rd, the

0:30:49 city launched its It Will Cost You campaign on Facebook and Twitter, mainly

0:30:55 consisting of visual posts and education through questions and comments, the feedback from

0:31:00 the citizens on social media boards has been mostly positive.

0:31:06 The ITO Transportation Department will post a message board at the prime bridge entrance

0:31:10 on July 2nd through the 4th the board will read, illegal fireworks will cost you.

0:31:19 We've also completed a PSA and media releases which are being posted to our website and Channel

0:31:24 17.

0:31:26 The Police Department has briefed all patrol officers about the ordinance and our plans

0:31:31 for enforcement.

0:31:32 We've also made appearances on local radio talk shows and television shows addressing

0:31:36 the issue with unsafe fireworks.

0:31:39 The educational campaign will be followed up with three nights of dedicated illegal fireworks

0:31:45 enforcement on July 3rd, 4th, and 5th.

0:31:49 The last thing that I would add to this is that this has really been a city initiative

0:31:53 as opposed to a police department initiative.

0:31:57 for your time this evening, are there any questions?

0:31:59 Chris, thank you.

0:32:00 Job well done, Captain, really like to see the positive

0:32:03 of the 30 missed apartments taken under direct control

0:32:08 of prevention of unnecessary fires,

0:32:12 not only just the legality.

0:32:14 I think the council recalls I brought this up

0:32:17 after a friend had a smoldering illegal firework

0:32:21 in their unprotected roof or semi-protected roof last year.

0:32:26 So, I'm most concerned about the fact that we're almost three inches under our normal precept for

0:32:33 a normal year. We have an increasing number of yards that are no longer even being watered.

0:32:39 And I think this is a matter of necessity as much as common sense and safety. Job well done.

0:32:45 Jimin.

0:32:48 Thank you, Mayor. I think I sent an email to the Chief and the City Manager this morning.

0:32:53 I had two complaints this week and one over on Julie Lane.

0:32:56 Another gentleman called me at my office this morning about fireworks late into the evening, starting up already, and it sounds like they have a plan of attack.

0:33:07 One thing that I want to note is Vice Mayor Hall has been having some discussions with Charlie Howell, the Commissioner of the Jerome County Commissioner,

0:33:15 who has been very, very responsible and in fact asked for a copy of our city ordinance because these illegal fireworks are apparently legal in the county of Jerome.

0:33:23 And they buy them there, come over here and they ignite them.

0:33:26 And I was happy to hear that Don did get a positive response from the county commission in that regard.

0:33:32 And they may be working in the future to at least get them further away from us before you can purchase them.

0:33:37 So that's a good point and a good step forward.

0:33:40 So and enforcement, I think that's why I think our culture and

0:33:44 our community is such now that it's the okay corral on those those nights until we enforce this, it'll remain that way.

0:33:54 Thank you very much.

0:33:55 Thank you.

0:33:56 Thank you for your presentation.

0:33:57 Kevin Barnhart.

0:33:58 Have you or the police department given out any tickets or fines so far this year?

0:34:04 I checked on that today.

0:34:06 As of May 1st, we've received 167 noise disturbances, five of which have been related to fireworks.

0:34:12 We have not issued any citations yet.

0:34:14 Okay.

0:34:15 Thank you.

0:34:16 I know that in our conversations about it, we were talking about having to issue those

0:34:22 citations, possibly more just to kind of back up our campaign.

0:34:28 And so I hope that you're able to do that.

0:34:32 But hopefully that education and awareness

0:34:34 will discourage people from lighting them off.

0:34:37 But I have seen them already around town.

0:34:40 So I was just curious if we had given any citations.

0:34:42 No citations yet.

0:34:43 I do think that this will probably take more than one year

0:34:46 to really get this point across.

0:34:47 we'll be in this effort for two to three to four years to get what we really want.

0:34:56 Thank you.

0:34:57 Okay.

0:34:58 Thank you, Captain Barnhart.

0:34:59 I don't have any additional lights and we'll probably ask that maybe sometime after the fourth

0:35:03 you give us a little recap of how things went this year.

0:35:07 Absolutely.

0:35:08 Thanks for next year.

0:35:09 Okay.

0:35:10 Thank you.

0:35:11 Okay.

0:35:12 Moving on to item number four, consideration of the request to award a bid to Western Construction

0:35:17 Incorporated for FAA, IAP Days 35, Air Force, Ramp, and Taxi Lean Reconstruction Progress

0:35:25 Projects, excuse me, for the bid amount of $2,541,111, contingent upon concurrence and funding

0:35:35 a keyword from the Federal Aviation Administration.

0:35:40 Our airport manager Bill Harber.

0:35:42 Thank you, Eric.

0:35:43 Thank you.

0:35:44 Good evening, counsel.

0:35:45 In addition to the runway seal coat project, which we awarded the bid to conditional award

0:35:51 last week to straight-stripe to seal coat the runway, we're also working with the FAA and

0:35:57 have been for about three years now to try to get to this point, particularly with the

0:36:02 funding, to take care of some of the areas that are most in need of rehabilitation.

0:36:10 would be these hanger taxi lanes in this area marked in yellow, as well as the airline terminal

0:36:18 ramp right in here.

0:36:20 We're also looking at a small concrete pad to park the static aircraft overnight there.

0:36:27 This is the east ramp of the general aviation, this would be a reader east here.

0:36:32 This will be some sections, I'd say from this section back, will be reconstructed as the plan

0:36:37 and a mill in over leg here.

0:36:40 We've also broken out a little bit of additional ramp development here, particularly for transient

0:36:45 helicopter activity.

0:36:47 Often during fire season we get large transient helicopters, so we're looking at a small expansion

0:36:53 of the ramp here as well.

0:36:56 So what we've done is we've broken out a bid and recently bid this and there are five schedules

0:37:01 and one of the reasons we've broken these out with different components is really because

0:37:05 funding is somewhat uncertain.

0:37:08 So it's really a budget-based project to see what we can move forward with.

0:37:13 So we did put together this bid packet and back on June 6th, we opened the bids for the

0:37:20 entirety of this work.

0:37:35 So this is the letter for bid recommendation from Kent Atkins and project manager with Rita

0:37:41 Selk.

0:37:42 We received three bids for all of this work.

0:37:45 The engineer's estimate was just a tick above $3 million.

0:37:50 Idaho Sanding Ravel came in at $3.5 million, Clef Rink came in at $3.3 million, and Western

0:38:00 Construction who has mobilized into our community for the interchange work on I-84 felt this

0:38:06 was an opportunity for them to bid as well.

0:38:09 And they came in as a low bidder at $2,541,111, so an attractive bid from Western there.

0:38:19 This will be financed by the FAA at 93.75% as all other federal projects are, the 6.25%

0:38:29 city county match is within the construction fund, the airport fund to do the match on this.

0:38:37 Standard regulatory impacts and agreements with any other FAA project.

0:38:43 So in conclusion, I would recommend that the city council award the bid to West and construction

0:38:49 ink, not to exceed the bid amount of $2,541,111, and also authorize the mayor to sign the pending

0:38:57 contract with Western construction contingent, as always, with these projects on concurrence

0:39:03 and funding from the Federal Aviation Administration.

0:39:06 I'd be happy to answer any questions.

0:39:08 Senator Cruz, thank you.

0:39:09 Yeah, as always Bill, we're interested in the spread of these bids.

0:39:13 low bid is up to 20-25% below par of the other's engineers still thought it

0:39:21 was a responsive bid. Yes and I'd be happy to invite Ken Attkin to project

0:39:26 matters to answer any questions about the specifics of the bid that you might

0:39:30 have. So Ken? Good evening and I'll try to talk into the microphone a little bit

0:39:40 better. So the bids that we received the primary and there's a lot of differences

0:39:46 Because on a whole western was lower in their unit costs pretty much across the board.

0:39:53 I think that two things that I could point to specifically was one would be their aggregate

0:39:59 costs or substantially less than the other two bidders.

0:40:03 And then I think along with that would be your mobilization costs is when they're already

0:40:07 in business and making this type of source of gravel meeting federal specs with the interstate

0:40:13 change.

0:40:14 The FAA specs are similar, so they've already got some of that mobilization built in and taken care of.

0:40:20 So does that answer your question?

0:40:23 Yeah.

0:40:24 So in other words, if they hadn't been doing the energy, they probably wouldn't have been able to bid that low,

0:40:30 because they already have some of the materials of hand for that project.

0:40:35 So this crystal ball statement that I'll make is, I think your price removed Western construction is about a $3.3 million project.

0:40:44 And I think we're in a position if we can get the FAA and the funding to get a good project

0:40:50 for a good value with a reputable contractor.

0:40:54 Although all three of them are reputable, but I think there's a good alignment of the moon

0:41:01 and the stars on this.

0:41:02 And if we can just get one more with the FAA, I think we've got a good project.

0:41:05 So.

0:41:06 All right.

0:41:08 Thank you.

0:41:09 Any other questions?

0:41:10 Can't point if I might about the funding.

0:41:13 We'll see.

0:41:14 We've really got a very attractive bid and if the FAA can ever find discretionary dollars

0:41:20 or this would be a very good opportune time, but it's a process that goes all the way back

0:41:26 to Washington, D.C. As you know, they're moving money in accounts left and right with sequestration

0:41:32 and those types of things in the FAA. It was not immune to some of that jockeying that went

0:41:36 on with funding, so it's really going to be interesting to see. But we'll certainly emphasize

0:41:43 the opportunity that we have here.

0:41:45 They have one additional license in Hawkins.

0:41:47 What kind of time frame do you expect to hear back from the FAA

0:41:50 on the project?

0:41:52 Well, tomorrow morning we'll be writing a grant application.

0:41:56 And with any luck, the sooner the better, it's hard to say.

0:42:03 OK.

0:42:05 Jim, I'm all ready to make a motion.

0:42:09 I would move to award the bid to Western Construction

0:42:12 Inc. for FAA AIP-35 airport ramp and taxi lane reconstruction project in the amount of $2,541,111.

0:42:23 I want you to put that contingent on.

0:42:25 Contingent on FAA funding.

0:42:27 Second.

0:42:28 It's been moved by Jim Munn and seconded by Chris Tockington to approve the project as presented.

0:42:35 Any additional lights?

0:42:37 Any questions?

0:42:38 Seeing none.

0:42:39 We have a roll call vote.

0:42:40 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes

0:43:15 Yes, you did. That's why I'm here to correct you. Good evening Mayor and Council.

0:43:23 Battalion Chief Ron Geary, and I are here this evening to provide information and to seek some advice regarding the disposal of a fire truck.

0:43:34 We currently have two reserve fire trucks. For some time, the city shop has been helping us assess which one of these two trucks is disposed of.

0:43:43 of. Both trucks have engine problems. They're over 20 years old. And after the

0:43:50 shop has thoroughly assessed the options, they recommend that we dispose of a

0:43:54 1994 fire truck and that we keep the 1992 fire truck. Although the 1992, like I

0:44:04 said, they both have engine problems, the 1992 is going to cost approximately

0:44:09 $10,000 to fix the engine on it.

0:44:12 The 1994 that we would like to dispose of,

0:44:16 dispose of, could cost up to $30,000 to fix.

0:44:23 So we've considered the viable options in our consideration.

0:44:28 And we think that there's basically only three of them.

0:44:31 And one of them is to gift the truck to another department,

0:44:35 a needy department, which battalion chief of Gary

0:44:37 has done some research on.

0:44:40 or to attempt to sell the truck for whatever we could get out of it, or frankly, to scrap

0:44:46 it if it came down to that.

0:44:49 You have to realize this is a 20-some-year-old truck.

0:44:53 I don't remember what the price was that we gave at the time, but it was less than the

0:44:58 trucks of today if that lessens the pain, Annie.

0:45:04 But that's the position we're in, and we are seeking any advice that you may or feedback

0:45:09 that you may want to present and Mr. Geary being the apparatus individual for our department

0:45:16 would be more than happy to answer any of your grilling type questions.

0:45:21 I have Travis, Ross and I see a manger get his finger up first before I head light on.

0:45:28 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, so Ron and I have been having the conversation about

0:45:32 what do we do with this fire truck.

0:45:34 So as you're aware, the lifespan of a fire truck in our organizations typically 20 years.

0:45:40 And we have them on what we describe as a front line for a period of 15 years.

0:45:46 And then they go into a position of reserve status for a period of five years.

0:45:51 In the last fiscal year, we acquired a new pumper.

0:45:56 That allowed us to have one additional pumper.

0:45:59 And as Chief Clark went through, he and his team in conjunction with the shop have really

0:46:05 been going through which one do we dispose of because both of them are not necessarily

0:46:10 without issues.

0:46:14 We wanted to come to the council and say there's really maybe an opportunity for us to help

0:46:18 out another community.

0:46:20 So although it may not be fit within our fleet and in our process, there may be some communities

0:46:27 out there that would be grateful to receive a fire truck, as is, and only have to put $30,000

0:46:36 or whatever those costs are into fixing it.

0:46:39 I think Battalion Chief Aguirre could probably talk about, but know that that's why that decision

0:46:43 is before you.

0:46:44 Legally, the City of Twin Falls can dispose of an asset free of charge to another public

0:46:51 entity so we can we can just pass that along to the appropriate

0:46:57 fire station but we want to do today is seek your guidance on what you felt

0:47:01 was the best method moving forward so Ron

0:47:10 John G. Ron what's bad is I had all these brothers and sisters in class too I said

0:47:15 it wrong all those years the number say they that's what I'm scared about

0:47:18 Do you have information for us about who might be interested in?

0:47:25 Yes, he does.

0:47:26 Okay.

0:47:27 Yeah, there are a couple of departments that I've been talking with, one of them being

0:47:31 the Shoshone Fire Department, that are interested, however, for the $30,000 repair cost, I mean,

0:47:38 that's even a stretch for some of the departments.

0:47:41 We've currently, I've got emails out to several of the small departments locally, I mean the

0:47:45 ones that we would go out and mutual aid with or they'd mutual aid back with us.

0:47:50 I thought, you know, if we kind of tried to keep it as local as possible.

0:47:53 You know, close so that, you know, when we are in need of an engine to come and

0:47:58 help us or we go help them, it would be nearby.

0:48:01 I haven't heard back from everybody, but we have heard from at least one department.

0:48:07 And they're interested.

0:48:08 They're trying to acquire the funds that it would take to actually fix this apparatus.

0:48:15 because it could actually skyrocket above 30,000 to fix it.

0:48:19 We're still waiting on some bids.

0:48:20 They won't really know until they get the frame off,

0:48:22 the engine out, get it all torn apart.

0:48:24 I mean, one cylinder on those big AB-92s are $7,000 for one.

0:48:30 And there's eight of them.

0:48:31 So if there's one that's cracked, that's another 7,000.

0:48:35 So do we strip apparatus off of these places?

0:48:39 These other agencies would have to be buying apparatus

0:48:41 to put on as well?

0:48:43 Some of the equipment, some of the older equipment,

0:48:46 when we've sent apparatus down the road,

0:48:48 we've put what we can on there for them to help them out.

0:48:52 But usually what's happening is they're trying

0:48:53 to replace something even older, like in 1947, La France.

0:48:58 So they take their equipment, their existing equipment

0:49:01 that they have, and then they outfit the new truck with it.

0:49:03 OK, well, they do have a light, Chris, talking to us.

0:49:05 So if we can't find a need within existing fire organization,

0:49:11 can we at least find a way to dispose of it?

0:49:13 where it will not cost any money and won't be illegal,

0:49:16 can't drive off the chain.

0:49:17 Yeah, I've actually put my, you know, I've talked to BME,

0:49:21 which is the ones that manufactured our last two trucks.

0:49:25 They recommended to go through a truck broker.

0:49:28 The problem with going through a truck broker,

0:49:30 even if we were to give it to another public entity,

0:49:33 is they don't want to touch it, it's broke.

0:49:36 You know, after 9-11, the grant process,

0:49:41 federal grant process, I mean,

0:49:42 they gave away trucks like crazy, I mean, every small department that could write a grant

0:49:48 got a new truck. So there's a lot of them out there that have trucks that are actually

0:49:54 newer than the one that we're trying to get away. So even if it were in good shape and

0:49:58 good running condition, and by the way, the condition that we have it with it now is a

0:50:03 new condition. It's something that's just happened in the last couple of months, whereas

0:50:08 we got a bunch of antifreeze, water in the oil, rent through the bearings, and it basically

0:50:14 ruins the engine.

0:50:15 So we're still trying to do some research with truck brokers and finding an avenue to

0:50:26 get rid of the truck.

0:50:27 We're back in about a second.

0:50:30 Thank you, Mayor.

0:50:32 You've replaced one of these pumpers.

0:50:34 When do you expect to replace the other one?

0:50:37 So you'll see in the budget that we are requesting another main line bumper to come in this upcoming

0:50:50 budget as well.

0:50:52 So we will begin that process to make sure that we're replacing fire trucks on a rotational

0:50:58 basis.

0:50:59 It is actually the appropriate time to do so, even though that window is really small because

0:51:05 We're trying to look at how we've replaced apparatus in the past,

0:51:10 as both Chief Clark and Battalion Chief Aguirre stated,

0:51:14 one is a 92, the other is a 94.

0:51:18 So we missed that five-year window,

0:51:20 so we kind of have this cycle where they're kind of piggybacked.

0:51:24 And it is important that we try to fix that.

0:51:27 But what that means is an acceleration

0:51:31 of acquisition of pumpers.

0:51:33 So in this budget, you will see that we're requesting $500,000 for the acquisition of a brand new bumper.

0:51:41 That's a pumper, not a ladder.

0:51:43 Pumper, not a ladder.

0:51:45 Suzanne Hoggins, Rebecca, will you finish that?

0:51:48 Thank you.

0:51:51 You guys do a wonderful job educating our kids and giving them tours.

0:51:55 If nobody wants the truck, is it something possible that could be put somewhere for

0:51:59 tours with the kids or a way that the kids could have hands-on experience with it somehow?

0:52:05 Or is that just a nightmare?

0:52:08 Well, yeah, right now as it sits, we can't actually start this truck and drive it.

0:52:14 We don't dare start it driving, because what it does, we had the oil changed, so right

0:52:18 now it's sitting with clean oil in it.

0:52:20 As soon as we start it up, it starts pumping water back into that crankcase.

0:52:25 Well, you know, I have the thought of the old tank at Harman Park and see something great

0:52:29 with a fire truck for the kids if nobody wants it.

0:52:32 I don't know.

0:52:33 So what we're trying to do is keep it as pristine as possible so that when someone does step

0:52:37 up to the fight and want it, they can just take it to their team.

0:52:40 You're thinking of an option number four.

0:52:42 I am.

0:52:43 I'm going to disrupt my two cents for it.

0:52:48 I really do enjoy helping our local, other fire districts.

0:52:53 And because if we ever had something major,

0:52:56 I know they'd come and help us.

0:52:58 And I would like to say,

0:53:01 and maybe this in the council certainly changes,

0:53:03 I would like to say if we have somebody within county,

0:53:06 that would be our first choice.

0:53:08 And if it isn't within county,

0:53:09 then show shown certainly isn't out of the realm

0:53:12 of possibilities either,

0:53:13 if they can come up with the funds to get it fixed.

0:53:15 I don't want to just go up there and set.

0:53:17 I would like to think that they had the funds to fix it.

0:53:20 But that's my personal thoughts.

0:53:21 But it'd be, obviously, we do mind.

0:53:24 Oh, I'm sorry, we're back.

0:53:25 We'll be back first.

0:53:26 Thank you, Mayor.

0:53:28 So Fritz, we need an action to approve disposal.

0:53:33 Is that correct?

0:53:36 Actually, you don't have to do anything.

0:53:39 But I talked to Ron about it.

0:53:40 Ron talked to Travis about it.

0:53:43 And we thought you guys ought to decide.

0:53:44 So they do want you to vote on what ought to happen, because we don't want to take the responsibility.

0:53:51 Right, I agree.

0:53:53 Well, I think that your presentation is sound and I appreciate the fire department for your conservative approach.

0:54:01 I know that you really take care of the equipment.

0:54:04 In fact, I had a community member who had gone on a tour to stop me and say thank you.

0:54:09 You can just see the pride that the fire department has in their equipment, the way they take care of it.

0:54:14 everything in the fire house is pristine down to the kitchen sink and so she was she was very impressed

0:54:20 But I think that that your options that you've laid out are our good idea

0:54:25 And I would move that we allow the fire department to dispose of the 1994 e1 pumper as

0:54:33 They see fit, you know it with concurrence with the city manager

0:54:38 I think they want us to do it though.

0:54:41 Actually I think that works.

0:54:43 Does that cover it?

0:54:44 Yeah, because I think it goes through those avenues.

0:54:48 Well, I'll second that much.

0:54:50 Okay, we got the motions on the floor and then we can still have discussion here.

0:54:53 Rebecca Milsoika has moved and seconded by John Berger to allow the fire department to dispose of the as they see fit.

0:55:05 if we have some other direction for them, Jim.

0:55:08 Thank you, Mayor.

0:55:09 We're not leveraged very well in regards

0:55:11 to the disposal of this vehicle, $30,000.

0:55:15 I think the motion's fine, but I would maybe,

0:55:19 we may want to consider an amendment that says,

0:55:21 dispose of it as you deem appropriate as a fire

0:55:25 professional with a caveat that it doesn't cost us any money.

0:55:31 I could almost guarantee you we can get rid of it

0:55:35 without, if we have to scrap it, we can get rid of it

0:55:38 without cost us any money, but I would really appreciate

0:55:40 the latitude for us to dispose of it,

0:55:43 and any means that we see fit, because I think something

0:55:48 that Batani and she said that's really important

0:55:50 to understand is you would think that you could easily gift

0:55:55 a fire truck or sell it for something, but I'm telling you,

0:56:00 there isn't much of a market for them,

0:56:02 and particularly one that's broken,

0:56:04 And maybe to use a poor analogy,

0:56:07 but Greg would be able to, the mayor would be able

0:56:09 to relate to this really easily.

0:56:11 We gift this truck, for example, to Hollister Idaho.

0:56:16 And we say, and I mean, they would be most appreciative.

0:56:19 How do they sustain?

0:56:21 How do they fund a $30,000 repair?

0:56:24 These fire trucks are expensive.

0:56:26 We have a city shop that believe me,

0:56:28 works on fire trucks all the time.

0:56:30 Diesel Motors, that kind of thing.

0:56:32 I mean, they're a high maintenance item, they really are.

0:56:35 So my fear in giving it to small departments is,

0:56:39 yeah, okay, it's neat that they got it,

0:56:41 but they can't, they don't have the funds

0:56:43 to make it work and to maintain it.

0:56:46 So if you just suppose of it as you deem fit

0:56:50 as a fire chief and your professional staff

0:56:52 with the caveat it doesn't cost us any money,

0:56:55 I think that gives you all the latitude in the world.

0:56:58 So I guess I'm gonna, how do I do that?

0:57:00 Do I make an amendment to her motion?

0:57:02 I think the intent is there, for instance.

0:57:04 Well, I think they want more direction than just.

0:57:08 I'd really appreciate the latitude, is all I'm saying.

0:57:10 Sure.

0:57:11 I would agree with that.

0:57:15 OK.

0:57:16 Right on.

0:57:17 I'll just add it to the motion.

0:57:19 Chris, I can then remind myself.

0:57:21 Well, I'll second remember our amendments on the floor.

0:57:24 There's no amendment on the floor.

0:57:25 We just heard.

0:57:26 Well, maybe I'd put on the amendment

0:57:27 then that we tow it to Suzanne's house.

0:57:31 Not Harman Park.

0:57:32 That's good for our department latitude.

0:57:34 If they have an opportunity to give them some needful group, I'm sure they would and they

0:57:39 are not going to come to the city with cost on that.

0:57:41 Sure.

0:57:42 I'm sure.

0:57:43 Thank you, Mayor.

0:57:44 And I just wanted to clarify on my motion that it's based on the presentation that you've

0:57:50 done tonight and I think that the options that you've laid out are quite acceptable and of

0:57:55 sound plan.

0:57:57 One had said that West Magic, or if I'm saying that right, West Magic where you go fishing,

0:58:04 but that was another example of, yeah, that's great, but I'm telling you, $30,000 fix and

0:58:11 maintaining to sustain the fire engine.

0:58:14 I have a contact up there, Chief, if you want me to see if they want it.

0:58:18 Hey, but Tain Chief of Geary is all over this.

0:58:21 We're trying to find someone.

0:58:22 And like you said, Shoshone may say, hey, we'd love to take it, and we can come up with

0:58:27 the money to fix it and they're off and running and we wish them nothing but the best.

0:58:31 Just for a reference standpoint, the last fire truck the City of Twin Falls sold, we sold

0:58:36 it to a civilian for $1,000.

0:58:40 And that was the question I was going to have because I was on council when we did that.

0:58:45 And it was down at the country called the States over there on the other side of the social

0:58:49 fault.

0:58:50 Were they able to get it running and keep it up running and things or not?

0:58:53 You know, I couldn't factually tell you this, but here's the rumor I heard.

0:58:57 I heard that that fire truck is in Nevada somewhere, and he made a little bit of a profit

0:59:01 when he re-sold it.

0:59:02 Well, he probably scrapped it.

0:59:06 I don't know what that is.

0:59:07 All right.

0:59:08 But it's the same thing.

0:59:09 It's one thing to have a fire truck.

0:59:10 It's a different thing to maintain it, and it's certainly a different thing to operate

0:59:13 them.

0:59:14 Right.

0:59:15 And that brings a good point that you both of you have brought up about the fact that

0:59:17 whether they can actually be able to maintain it.

0:59:21 Because I remember one of the last one,

0:59:23 we got several offers from fire districts

0:59:26 around the Midwest saying, well, we can't afford

0:59:29 to give anything, but I make fly rods.

0:59:31 Can we give you a fly rod for you?

0:59:33 One of them offered two fish fly rods for the northern item.

0:59:35 What makes you worry about just what you're saying,

0:59:37 being able to fix it as well as repair it.

0:59:40 Keep it operational.

0:59:42 Because it doesn't think good if it's not operational

0:59:44 for the house house to help us in the future at some point.

0:59:46 But we certainly don't want to collect fire trucks,

0:59:49 and we really appreciate the effort the city shop

0:59:52 is put in these because the type of motor these trucks had

0:59:56 back in those days, if you will, 20 something years ago.

0:59:59 Extremely difficult to fix nowadays,

1:00:01 even to find someone to work on them nowadays

1:00:04 is almost an impossibility.

1:00:06 So I appreciate the latitude for us to get rid of it

1:00:08 so that we're not collecting them to in whatever manner

1:00:11 we feel is appropriate.

1:00:12 Okay, right.

1:00:13 Thank you.

1:00:14 We still need to vote on this, but I appreciate it.

1:00:16 No judicial license on the roll call vote yes

1:00:23 Yes, Greg Lansing yes

1:00:27 Yes motion passes six to zero thanks

1:00:39 All right, I remember six this consideration a request to adopt ordinance 30 52 for the vacation of 15

1:00:47 125 Allie located west of 300, 303,

1:00:51 Show Show Street north of behalf of first federal

1:00:53 savings bank.

1:00:54 This is the same thing we saw last week.

1:00:57 It was the last week or two.

1:00:58 I gave my whole presentation.

1:00:59 Oh, sorry.

1:01:00 Very good.

1:01:02 Yeah, this is the vacation we had last week for first fed.

1:01:04 This is the ordinance that accomplishes the vacation that

1:01:07 was approved last week.

1:01:09 It is an ordinance.

1:01:10 It's 30-52 of the number.

1:01:12 We do need to go if you want to adopt it tonight to third and final

1:01:14 with the waiver of the rules and all that good stuff.

1:01:17 We'll try to answer your questions if you have any questions.

1:01:21 Rebecca, we'll see you later.

1:01:22 Thank you, Mayor.

1:01:24 Thanks, Mitchell Humble.

1:01:27 Has the new easement been dedicated?

1:01:29 And if not, when will that be dedicated

1:01:31 to wherever they're moving all of these lines?

1:01:38 I'm going to come up and talk about the new lines.

1:01:42 Thank you.

1:01:45 This is an easement that wasn't being used, no longer necessary.

1:01:52 In the redesign of the facility, the water main is rerouted

1:01:57 in a different route through existing easements

1:01:59 and in the right of way.

1:01:59 So there is a easement.

1:02:04 Several years ago, the easement that

1:02:07 runs the other direction behind First Federal

1:02:09 was also vacated.

1:02:12 So the alley went away, but an easement

1:02:14 was granted back for just a water line.

1:02:17 No longer an alley, but an easement, so.

1:02:20 Okay, so they've been rerouted to already existing easement.

1:02:22 So there is no need for this easement.

1:02:24 Thank you.

1:02:25 And all of the other easement's in that block

1:02:26 have been provided.

1:02:29 Chris Tiger.

1:02:29 Have moved to place ordinance 305-2 on third and final

1:02:32 by title owners suspension rules.

1:02:35 Let me see.

1:02:37 And then move by Chris Tiger and seconded by Jim

1:02:41 to suspend the rules of place or does 3052

1:02:44 on third and final by title only.

1:02:49 Seeing the lights, do we have a roll call vote?

1:02:51 Sean Berger?

1:02:52 Yes.

1:02:53 Susan Hawkins?

1:02:54 Yes.

1:02:54 Ray Fante?

1:02:55 Yes.

1:02:56 Jim Vine?

1:02:57 Yes.

1:02:58 Rebecca Nelson again?

1:02:59 Yes.

1:03:00 Chris Tockens.

1:03:00 Yes.

1:03:01 I'm gonna pass the six to zero now we would be moving on to,

1:03:05 oh excuse me.

1:03:06 Leanna would you please read the title of course?

1:03:09 ordinance of the mayor and the city council of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho,

1:03:12 vacating the real property described below and providing for besting the title to the

1:03:16 property so vacated. Now we need motion concerning ordinance 3052 move approval

1:03:26 second then moved by Sean Burger and seconded by Susan Hawkins to approve

1:03:32 ordinance 3052 seeing the lights we have a roll call vote. Susan Hawkins yes Greg

1:03:39 Yes Jim Munn yes Rebecca Milsoyka yes yes Sean Berger yes motion passes six to

1:03:47 zero thank you very much I have seven which is a consideration request to

1:03:55 adopt ordinance 3053 for the zoning district change and zoning map amendment

1:04:00 C1 PUD to C1 PUD West Park commercial number seven PUD again I won't steal your

1:04:07 It's also as last week's hearing on the zoning change for the hotel use at the corner of Washington

1:04:15 in Poline.

1:04:16 We've prepared the PUD ordinance in accordance with the approval from last week and it's ready

1:04:22 for adoption tonight.

1:04:23 Ordinance number 3053 and it also makes you third and final and all that good stuff if

1:04:30 we want to adopt it tonight.

1:04:34 one particular I believe the applicant is here and might like to say something if

1:04:40 you're okay with that Mayor. Certainly the owner of the hotel step forward and

1:04:44 [Muted for privacy: street address]

1:04:50 [Muted for privacy: street address]

1:04:56 [Muted for privacy: street address]

1:05:01 some latitude here.

1:05:03 My presentation in two minutes here

1:05:06 is not about zoning, so it really doesn't affect

1:05:09 what is before you tonight.

1:05:11 Do you have a question regarding impact fees?

1:05:13 And so I'd like to take a couple minutes on that.

1:05:15 Quick background, we're a very small firm.

1:05:19 It is a Marriott hotel, which everybody knows Marriott,

1:05:22 but we're a franchisee.

1:05:24 We have three hotels.

1:05:25 This would be our fourth impact fee of $90,000.

1:05:29 It's killing us.

1:05:30 I mean, just to put a frank.

1:05:32 And so my question of coming tonight

1:05:36 is not that I think impact fees are wrong.

1:05:38 I think they're right.

1:05:40 My question is the delineation that hospitality

1:05:43 be put within the retail use of the impact fee.

1:05:46 So as you know how your impact fee works,

1:05:48 obviously, but an idea.

1:05:49 You have the police section, you have the fire section,

1:05:52 and those are delineated simply by residential

1:05:55 or non-residential use.

1:05:57 However, street impact is delineated by actual use,

1:06:02 whether it be retail, office, multi-family, and whatnot,

1:06:07 warehouse space.

1:06:09 So within your code, it stipulates

1:06:11 that hospitality land within the retail use,

1:06:13 which is the highest use as far as the impact fee.

1:06:16 It's $1.30 per square foot.

1:06:18 From our perspective, these are all calculated

1:06:21 based on trip generation.

1:06:23 We think trip generation for hospitality is way lower

1:06:27 then retail. We've talked to a number of consultants and our request tonight is that

1:06:31 you allow us to go through that process to basically amend the code to not change in

1:06:35 your numbers. We're fine with your numbers where they are, but we'd like to pull hospitality

1:06:40 out of the retail section and drop it in either to the office section, which we think

1:06:44 is a closer approximation of what the real trip generation is. Again, just to reiterate

1:06:49 this doesn't affect police, it doesn't affect fire, it's only on street impact. So that

1:06:55 That said, just a simple example, and we can go through this with consultants or whatever

1:07:00 you request of us to do, as a simple example, our hotel is a 92 room hotel.

1:07:07 Typical occupancy is about 60%.

1:07:10 So obviously, that means some nights we're 100% and we bless those nights and some nights

1:07:14 we're 10%.

1:07:15 But on average, it's about 60% is what we estimate.

1:07:18 We will be, and that's really where all the rest of the hotels in the area are kind of falling

1:07:22 then.

1:07:23 That's 55 cars based on one car per room.

1:07:26 Some families come and they will have two rooms, so I think we're even being a little

1:07:31 bit aggressive there.

1:07:32 But 55 cars based on a 60% occupancy as far as trip generation for that hotel on a typical

1:07:38 night.

1:07:39 If you compare that to a 50,000 square foot retail space, which is how we're being shown

1:07:44 as far as the impact fee, we believe that is very, very low compared to what a retail

1:07:50 space would actually generate as far as trip generation.

1:07:53 So we're more than willing to go through that with consultants, again, to reiterate

1:07:56 we're not against the impact fee.

1:07:58 This is a new thing since 2009, we are the first hotel to come before you.

1:08:02 We will be the first hotel to have the impact fee put upon them.

1:08:06 We just don't think it's the right spot.

1:08:08 We think it's artificially high for the trip generation for hospitality use.

1:08:13 That said, we're very close to wanting to start construction.

1:08:17 So I'll show you my cards.

1:08:18 We're going to go.

1:08:19 We're going to do this regardless.

1:08:21 We can't wait.

1:08:22 As we talk to the staff, this will be months and months process to go through this.

1:08:28 What we would ask is that we pay the impact fee more or less at our protest that if we

1:08:34 do go through this process and it is amended simply to pull the hospitality sector out of

1:08:39 retail that we would then receive a refund once that process goes through.

1:08:44 City staff has mentioned that it's up for a five-year review anyways, that it's time to

1:08:49 do the review of the impact fees and so we would ask that this be part of that review

1:08:55 as well.

1:08:56 So more anything we're just trying to be upfront with you that this is it's onerous to a small

1:09:01 business like ourselves.

1:09:03 We don't debate the fact we got to pay something we just think it's the wrong fee assessed hospitality.

1:09:09 So with that answer any questions or anything you might have.

1:09:12 Mike is right Mike.

1:09:13 What do you do like Chris?

1:09:14 Yeah, I'm on that impact advisory committee and if it's a time for review, it would be appropriate to study it.

1:09:22 I certainly would not suggest that Council waive change, modify it right now, pay it under protest, would make sense.

1:09:30 The question though is I think your proposal currently is $1.30 a square, you said?

1:09:38 For the street and in part out of the one category would take it down to what?

1:09:43 to the office's point forty cents I believe and again we're not opposed to if

1:09:47 yeah after through consultants such you create a new category if you want to create

1:09:51 a hospitality category

1:09:53 we're just so confident that the trip generation is so much lower than retail

1:09:57 that it will land at least you know forty cents on office or somewhere in

1:10:01 between there to the buck thirty which is where retail is we just we've got two

1:10:05 thirds request but two thirds uh gate grace but you're

1:10:09 amenable to something in between there you know what based on the trip generation

1:10:13 There's a lot of reports out there on a national basis and if we go through that process and you guys determine or council determines

1:10:18 Hey, this is where we need to be we're open at that

1:10:20 But $90,000 we just think is artificially high for our use and if I could just address the council we would request Mitch to get

1:10:30 Impact the information from other jurisdictions so it could do a comparative analysis and see how that really measures up realistically on the impact

1:10:39 Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, staff has been engaged in the conversation with the

1:10:49 developers and in our conversation so far, Mitch has already began that process of doing

1:10:55 some preliminary research and development to see does this necessarily make sense.

1:11:01 Staff perspective, we would agree that it's probably the appropriate time to look at these

1:11:06 things as Councilman Tawkinton had shared. Our five-year review of the capital improvement

1:11:12 piece is under review right now. The commission has asked staff to take a look at projects

1:11:21 that were included in the original capital improvement list. We are going through the

1:11:24 process of vetting those and also looking at including other projects and also at the

1:11:29 at the same time taking a look at those overall fees.

1:11:33 And so from a staff perspective, we think that the timing is appropriate and

1:11:38 have no problem with working through with the development team on their request.

1:11:44 Should that be the council's direction?

1:11:47 My question for Fritz would be, is there a way we can do what they're asking us to do?

1:11:51 That if we did end up choosing to lower it, that they could get a refund,

1:11:56 should they say under protest or where the geese make it?

1:11:59 And Mitch and I have talked about it.

1:12:01 Mitch, I think, from his preliminary review of it,

1:12:05 thinks that what's being represented to you is probably

1:12:08 right and that the trips are a lot less than retail.

1:12:13 So it would make sense to do that.

1:12:15 And we would just amend it effective at the beginning.

1:12:19 It was just an error in the original.

1:12:21 So go all the way back to the beginning.

1:12:23 OK, so that would be, thus they would

1:12:25 be eligible for a refund based on that fact, okay, all right.

1:12:30 Does anyone having done, I want it to be fair, obviously we need, we need the impact fees

1:12:36 to finish some of the projects that we need to do for both retail and cost everybody everything,

1:12:43 but we certainly want it to be fair, or that's who we are as a community everybody.

1:12:48 And so.

1:12:49 And I appreciate that, very much, I mean, honestly, and if I can brag a little bit about your

1:12:53 You know we do present a lot of cities and this is our second city council meeting and second planning commission meeting

1:12:59 You have a great staff be very efficient very professional. So just want to let you know

1:13:06 Thanks, thank you moving back to the matter at hand. We need a third and final four thing

1:13:15 Okay, I would move to place ordinance 3053

1:13:19 suspend the rules in place orders 3053 on third and final reading by Patilow.

1:13:26 Second that.

1:13:27 I remember by Jim Allen second by Chris Tack to suspend the rules in place.

1:13:32 You're in some third and final by title.

1:13:35 I've seen the lights.

1:13:36 The other roll call vote.

1:13:37 Greg Lanci.

1:13:38 Yes.

1:13:39 Jim Allen.

1:13:40 Yes.

1:13:41 Rebecca Milsnechka.

1:13:42 Yes.

1:13:43 Chris Tacken.

1:13:44 Yes.

1:13:45 Sean Burger.

1:13:46 Yes.

1:13:47 passes six to zero. Did you read the title, Leo?

1:13:51 An ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls Idaho.

1:13:54 Rezoning real property below described. Providing the zoning classification

1:13:58 therefore and ordering the necessary amendments to the area of impact and zoning

1:14:03 districts map. Okay, Council wishes. Schumber move approval of ordinance 3053.

1:14:11 Second. I think we're back in my head or why not.

1:14:15 No, she can second.

1:14:16 She can second.

1:14:17 All right.

1:14:18 And it's been moved by Schonberg and second by Susanne Hockens to approve ordinance 3053.

1:14:23 Rebecca Mills-Leck.

1:14:24 Thank you, Mayor.

1:14:26 Just more of a comment.

1:14:27 I'm still a little bit puzzled by the building heights being above the stated allowed building

1:14:34 height.

1:14:35 And so just a comment that maybe we might look at defining parapet better or regulating edge.

1:14:42 And it just doesn't make sense to me that we would regulate building heights but then not regulate the height at which the building stands.

1:14:49 I mean, and it just seems like there should be some sort of oversight of the parapet allowance.

1:14:55 And I realize it's part of the code and it's allowed at this time.

1:14:57 And so I don't oppose this particular project or the PUD, but just as a comment on our process.

1:15:06 But I think maybe if we're going to have a building height we might as well also have

1:15:12 some sort of regulation over parapets because historically they're there to defend against

1:15:17 military attacks but obviously now they're just used for architectural enhancement which

1:15:23 is fine but I believe that we probably should have a better definition or understanding of

1:15:30 what should be allowed or shouldn't be allowed.

1:15:32 I know we do have a committee that's going through some of our

1:15:36 things in the last I could maybe to at least talk about that

1:15:40 stick there. Thank you. That would be great. All right.

1:15:42 Seeing other lights.

1:15:45 Roll call vote for the other. Jim mine. Yes. Yes.

1:15:49 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

1:15:53 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

1:15:56 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

1:16:00 May I just make a comment?

1:16:03 Sure.

1:16:04 My back of the hand calculation, the current structure for the impact fee would net about

1:16:09 90,000 and about 28,000 or so under a proposal all the way down to 40, so it would be a substantial

1:16:19 decrease in net dollars to the impact fund.

1:16:22 That's for sure.

1:16:23 If it would.

1:16:24 Yeah.

1:16:25 Go all the way down.

1:16:27 All right.

1:16:28 Thank you.

1:16:30 Moving on to item number eight public input.

1:16:33 Does anyone have the audience have something they would like to discuss that was not brought up earlier today?

1:16:39 So, you know, the audience will move to council, Jim Munn.

1:16:42 Thank you, Mayor. I would like to let everybody out there in the community know that tomorrow night we are going to have the, we call it council hours between 5.30 and 7.

1:16:54 We'll do it right here at the council chambers.

1:16:56 There'll be several council people present

1:16:58 to answer any questions or concerns that you might have

1:17:01 in a non-threatening way.

1:17:03 And this is a bit imposing coming here sometimes.

1:17:06 So we'll be here at the council chambers tomorrow night.

1:17:09 Rebecca and I at least from 5.37.

1:17:13 Thank you, Jim.

1:17:14 I would also like to comment, I mean, councilman Hal brought

1:17:18 up last week, and I'm sure you're bringing up

1:17:20 in this week, we are still looking members

1:17:22 for members on the historical commission.

1:17:25 There are three openings and so if you've had a chance to serve your community, this is your chance. We need some members to on that commission.

1:17:33 Rebecca, we'll show you.

1:17:35 Thank you, Mayor. I was waiting for Shonda report on fire ops for us, but I guess I will. I just want to say.

1:17:44 It was difficult. I just want to report that Councilman Berger and I attended fire ops 101 and I just want to recommend the experience to the rest of the Council if you have the opportunity.

1:17:55 It's put on the by the professional firefighters of Idaho and they have about 60 to 80 volunteers

1:18:02 and they recreate the training experience for you so that you understand

1:18:07 at a very intense level what it's like to do their job and the reasons for their equipment needs

1:18:13 and their personnel needs and also want to thank our local firefighters.

1:18:18 We were given a shadow from the local 1556 and they accompanied us up there and did an outstanding job.

1:18:25 I know the mayor has been there before and our shadows got to do the training exercise with us this year.

1:18:31 And I know in my experience, and I think in Shawn's, we were saved several times throughout the day by the leadership

1:18:38 and the skills and the wisdom of our shadows.

1:18:41 As my shadow is Scott Seagworth and just want to commend his ability to lead and assist in

1:18:48 a very professional and skilled manner.

1:18:50 And it was recently given a promotion to Captain.

1:18:55 So I want to congratulate Captain Seagworth on that well-deserved promotion and also thank

1:19:00 the local 1556 for the opportunity.

1:19:03 Thank you, Mr. President.

1:19:05 I'd like to give a real brief update on the electric bookmobile, as we will call it.

1:19:11 that here after, just to let you know how aggressive the library is, if you recall the

1:19:17 Manninget with the same staff they've utilized before. The new bookmobile is making the rounds

1:19:26 of I think could be 25 different locations on a repeating basis now. They are almost

1:19:34 inundated. It's almost like a pied piper when they come into a retirement home or one

1:19:40 of the schools like Lighthouse.

1:19:42 To show you the impact, right now the library is planning

1:19:46 on issuing as many as 600 temporary book summer book passes

1:19:52 for kids who have not been introduced to regular reading

1:19:57 habits and hopefully they'll get the parents in to sign

1:20:01 up for a full time membership in the library.

1:20:05 But the bookmobile has been a little bit of a wild card.

1:20:08 We're not sure how it was going to be received.

1:20:11 There have been a few bugs, bugaboos,

1:20:13 like driving through our cities with the valley gutters

1:20:15 and scraping the bumpers,

1:20:17 because we don't have a real storm drain system.

1:20:21 But overall, it's just been amazingly well received.

1:20:25 And so luck with the bookmobile in the neighborhood.

1:20:28 Working a lot nearer you, probably.

1:20:30 Thank you, Chris.

1:20:31 Anyone else?

1:20:34 Travis, do anything?

1:20:36 All right.

1:20:37 move on to our next item, which is we'll leave a motion and a vote on executive session

1:20:45 67234518, 6723451B, and 6723451E, which covers all the way from hiring of a public official

1:20:58 to evaluation of this missile as well as where we're competing with someone from a foreign

1:21:07 land and or the Chris I would move so moved to a turn for exactly a session

1:21:14 pertinent to section 6723 4 5 1 a b and e second

1:21:22 Oh back again the move by Chris dying and second by Rebecca milsica to move in

1:21:28 exactly session for the reason stated as you want to see no whites we have a

1:21:34 the roll call vote.

1:21:36 Yes.

1:21:37 Yes.

1:21:38 Yes.

1:21:39 Yes.

1:21:40 Yes.

1:21:41 Yes.

1:21:42 Yes.

1:21:43 Yes.

1:21:44 Yes.

1:21:45 Motion passes six to zero.

1:21:47 The journey will not be coming out and making any decisions.

1:21:51 The meeting general meeting itself is adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, June 24, 2013. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:22:11.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    e5b9ea2af1d328972b72a0999facdf071e78f8eca4e9144701dbff942473ee34
  5. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 3 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    e0fe09d5b144acc44b7b4c8bef429d3e93000fc47a48a5074143b0e83db8716e

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file