City Council meeting
Monday, July 8, 2013
Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:00:00 Travis is now seeking out the rate increase in that bill, a lot of the way I think I have some.
0:00:06 I know what I can read on it.
0:00:10 I'm sure you do.
0:00:12 No, I'm not.
0:00:13 No, I'm not.
0:00:14 And Lee Will is only, you said, Phil.
0:00:16 I get it.
0:00:19 That's why I'm looking for you.
0:00:21 I mean, I couldn't have serious all that out.
0:00:24 Well, I'm sure.
0:00:25 You don't have that much time on your hands.
0:00:30 So now I'm working on the survey and I'm using the survey.
0:00:37 We'll find out a lot next Monday.
0:00:41 And you're doing a better job.
0:00:44 But it's done on a tonic basis, so it doesn't matter.
0:00:50 But it's a fair change in the department.
0:00:53 What they do is they're trying to prepare.
0:00:56 We'll tell a lot by what it is or if not said.
0:02:06 We don't get it going this next year, we don't have the reason to keep some money on them.
0:02:11 I'd like to have the opportunity to meet you if you're interested in fighting.
0:02:15 Okay, so we have a meeting for the 27th of July, 1.30 in the afternoon, so bring your crew welcome.
0:02:21 I think I'm okay with this going on with this big bike.
0:02:24 It was up a minute ago.
0:02:26 Sure, it's awesome.
0:02:30 It's coming to it.
0:02:32 Yeah, you just have to unplug it and refresh it.
0:02:34 I know.
0:02:35 I know.
0:02:36 I know.
0:02:37 I know.
0:02:38 I know.
0:02:39 I know.
0:02:40 I know.
0:02:41 I know.
0:02:42 I know.
0:02:43 I know.
0:02:44 I know.
0:02:45 I know.
0:02:46 I know.
0:02:47 I know.
0:02:48 I know.
0:02:49 I know.
0:02:50 I know.
0:02:51 I know.
0:02:52 I know.
0:02:53 I know.
0:02:54 I know.
0:02:55 I know.
0:02:56 I know.
0:02:57 I know.
0:02:58 I know.
0:02:59 I know.
0:03:00 I know.
0:03:01 I know.
0:03:02 I know.
0:03:03 I think that's how it works.
0:03:18 I go ahead and donate $100 to support it.
0:03:21 Are you telling me you're ready to go?
0:03:32 I'd like to call to order the July 8, 2013 meeting at Twin Falls City Council.
0:03:38 First item of business as usual is the Pledge of Allegiance.
0:03:42 All those would like to join me please rise.
0:03:44 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:04:03 I would like to stay away from the limits.
0:04:09 Confirm, we do have a quorum of six to seven.
0:04:14 Rebecca Milsoyke is out of training in Boise, I believe it's in Boise this week.
0:04:19 We have several staff members here and I'll highlight the ones she has for me because if I don't, I'll mess somebody up.
0:04:26 So you married your Travis Rothwethery and Deputy City Clerk, recorded Secretary Leila Sanchez.
0:04:31 Media responsible this week, Suzanne, I have you through a radio on Wednesday, and I have myself for the television on early morning hours of Thursday.
0:04:43 Lucky me.
0:04:44 Alright, Mr. Rothwethery, do we have any amendments to the agenda?
0:04:49 We do not.
0:04:50 Okay.
0:04:51 There are no proclamations.
0:04:53 So we're all the way to consent calendar, council wishes.
0:04:57 Move approval.
0:04:58 To move by Suzanne Hagen.
0:05:00 Second by Don Hall.
0:05:03 To prove the consent calendar has been seen no lights.
0:05:08 We have a roll call vote.
0:05:11 Yes.
0:05:12 Yes.
0:05:13 Yes.
0:05:14 Yes.
0:05:15 Yes.
0:05:16 Yes.
0:05:17 Yes.
0:05:18 Yes.
0:05:21 on here. Motion passes six to zero. Item consideration, we only have one item under
0:05:31 the consideration and that's Travis Wasweiler introduction of city manager's recommended
0:05:36 budget for the upcoming 2013-2014 fiscal year. Travis Wasweiler, Mr. Mayor, members of the
0:05:45 Council. Good evening. Before we begin, the first thing I want to do is obviously introduce
0:05:53 and thank the folks behind me. We will have more trickle in, but the city's management team
0:06:00 as a whole from the department head level and really at the employee level all the way through
0:06:03 our process have been intimately engaged in the budget conversation since about early March.
0:06:10 where we begin taking a look at the strategic plan and moving forward and
0:06:14 beginning to describe and create the list of needs and projects that we'd like to
0:06:20 go forward until really the product of work that you see is presented by me but
0:06:25 it is a labor and I use love loosely by many many many people and in
0:06:32 particular I want to thank Lori Reyes Mike Williams and Hattie Lehman for the
0:06:39 hours that they spent going through the process, compiling the information, really refining
0:06:45 the expenditure and the revenue data, and then putting it into a manner that is just
0:06:52 more than a series of Excel expressions, putting it into a document that actually might mean
0:06:57 something to our average reader.
0:07:00 So this is one of the responsibilities that is described in Title 50, Chapter 8 of the
0:07:06 and they said each year the city manager shall present his or her recommended budget to the
0:07:13 council for their deliberation and for their review and so in honor of that we begin that
0:07:19 process tonight but in all honesty we started that process several months ago and we engaged
0:07:25 in a series of internal conversations and public conversations and then also a public
0:07:30 open house about what should be included in this budget.
0:07:35 And we started every conversation off with the same first slide.
0:07:41 And that first slide is, again, our mission statement.
0:07:46 And our mission is stewards of the public trust is to meet the current and future needs
0:07:49 of the community, promote citizen input, preserve our heritage, conserve and protect our social
0:07:56 and physical resources and enhance the quality of life in the city and police laws.
0:08:00 It is the reason why we exist, it is the structure that helped create our strategic plan, and
0:08:07 this budget begins that process of funding a strategic plan that creates some very serious
0:08:16 vision statements for the year 2030.
0:08:20 This budget is also very different than budgets that we have in the past, and that is because
0:08:25 this budget last year, and that we'll actually be able to put a front cover this year, illustrates
0:08:32 our commitment to improving our financial vehicles. Our budget last year, this budget is
0:08:37 in the same format. It was recognized by the Government Finance Officers Association and
0:08:42 it received a distinguished budget award. And in that award, it really illustrates that
0:08:47 we as an organization are following the best practices that we can in the area of managing
0:08:53 the people's money to ensure the effective delivery of services for them.
0:08:58 This is a war that only three other cities in the state of Idaho have been able to capture,
0:09:03 and we were able to capture that last year on our first submittal, and we will continue
0:09:07 to strive every year to meet those standards so that every year that we can receive the
0:09:12 GFO and Distinguished Budget Award.
0:09:14 The value of this war is it shows people that we understand the value of communicating a budget,
0:09:20 But it also illustrates to bondholders and prospective bondholders that the financial
0:09:25 management and the affairs of the city have been reviewed by a third-party professional
0:09:28 entity and that we have scored favorably in their eyes of the reviewers.
0:09:36 So our budget follows some very key tenets and some of these things will remain the same
0:09:42 because those tenets are always very, very similar.
0:09:46 We want to make sure that we are prudently managing the people's money.
0:09:51 It is part of our fiduciary responsibilities.
0:09:54 We want to make sure that we are effectively delivering services to our citizen, and at
0:09:59 the end we want to make sure that all of the goods and services that we provide are
0:10:04 helping further the city from the form of its mission.
0:10:07 So we allocate resources to the public health and public safety.
0:10:11 We allocate funding to create and preserve initiatives that enhance quality of life.
0:10:18 We develop these programs and services based upon the express needs of our community.
0:10:23 We do that through surveying, we do that through our citizen advisory groups, we do that through
0:10:28 a series of open houses, we do that and did that through our strategic planning process.
0:10:33 We want to make sure that the municipal government is well funded and we want to make sure that
0:10:38 we allocate resources in a thoughtful way.
0:10:42 And then we all work collectively to achieve and establish goals within the recognition
0:10:51 that resources have constraints.
0:10:54 That there is a responsibility that we have to make sure that we are allocating money in
0:11:00 the most efficient and effective way possible.
0:11:04 So this budget has basically those four strategies.
0:11:10 We want to make sure that we funded the city's 2030 strategic plan and in the document you
0:11:15 can see in the various department narratives, the various initiatives that we have been off
0:11:21 in this year's budget.
0:11:23 Some of them are ongoing.
0:11:24 Some of them are level one reserves or level one projects and priorities and we will continue
0:11:29 to move forward.
0:11:31 We want to make sure that our budget outlines the function of our government and talks about
0:11:35 the things that we do and why we do that, and that we also want to be very mindful that
0:11:41 the dollars that we allocate here often will impact us beyond the limitations of a single
0:11:46 fiscal year.
0:11:47 That we want to make sure that we are providing funding to meet the future capital needs of
0:11:52 our community, that we're investing in our systems, and that we're not having deferred
0:11:57 maintenance or issues in the areas of compensation, making sure that those things maintain a market
0:12:03 status, so on and so forth.
0:12:06 So everything that we do, in a sense,
0:12:08 is a series of building blocks to help us reach
0:12:11 that 2030 vision.
0:12:14 So let's kind of talk about the 2014 recommended budget.
0:12:19 As you'll recall, this grew out of a series
0:12:22 of conversations that we had,
0:12:23 and again, with the very first public open house that we had.
0:12:27 And to achieve our focus areas from the conversations,
0:12:30 we said that we are going to take the statutory
0:12:35 allowances. That means that the 3% in the new construction tax revenues have been incorporated
0:12:41 into this budget. But it does not require any of the use of the city's foregone balance.
0:12:47 That entire foregone balance of $1,478,577. He is preserved and it is there as an opportunity
0:12:59 at the right time that we are going to move forward with Phase 2 of the city's compensation
0:13:05 plan and strategy, and we'll outline what that looks like here, that we're going to continue
0:13:10 to work and develop funding solutions to ensure that our infrastructure systems are well-maintained,
0:13:17 and in particular our water system, we begin that process to ensure that we have redundancies
0:13:23 to avoid some of the issues that we had last summer.
0:13:29 And then we obviously want to continue to make sure that the strategies that we incorporated
0:13:35 that we're incorporating best practices into our management philosophies,
0:13:40 that we're always looking at new ways to deliver services,
0:13:44 that by maximizing the amount of monies that we have,
0:13:48 those scarce tax resources which in particular we are able to better accomplish the people's needs.
0:13:54 So, the numbers.
0:13:58 And before we begin the numbers, let me throw out
0:14:03 that it is really, really early in the process.
0:14:09 And I think a couple of years ago,
0:14:10 the Times News referred to me as the negative no stardomist,
0:14:14 because when we were projecting the values of the community,
0:14:21 we obviously want to project them very, very conservatively,
0:14:25 because it's better to be surprised on the other end
0:14:28 than to get far down the trail
0:14:30 and realize that the situation may be worse
0:14:33 than what you anticipated.
0:14:35 So we take a very conservative approach to budgeting.
0:14:38 And what we do to create this document
0:14:41 is we take a time out.
0:14:44 And we stop and we build and we construct
0:14:48 a balanced budget document.
0:14:50 But our work and refinement of the numbers contained here in
0:14:54 do not stop when this is published.
0:14:57 We need that later.
0:15:00 In fact, we continue to review those all of the time.
0:15:04 We will continue to offer some additional suggestions to you,
0:15:09 especially when we talk a little bit later about water and sewer rates.
0:15:14 That there may be some strategies that we can lay out to the council tonight
0:15:18 and begin considering those conversations that were not fully developed
0:15:25 when we published the budget.
0:15:28 Because to be able to get to a place to construct this document,
0:15:33 We really have to stop mining the data and perfecting the revenues to build this,
0:15:39 but once this effort is done, we still continue to go through that effort to make sure
0:15:43 that the revenues and the projections that we're making are absolutely solid.
0:15:49 So, the early numbers is right now that this budget, the total net budget for fiscal year 2014,
0:15:58 is estimated to be $52,913,876, which is an increase of $3,659,000, or 7.43%.
0:16:11 And you'll notice that one of the most significant increases is when you look down at the enterprise
0:16:19 funds is we have a new debt service payment that the citizens voted in a $38 million revenue
0:16:27 bond will talk a little bit more about that. And we incorporated the very first of potentially
0:16:33 20 years of debt service payments associated with that note to occur in fiscal year 2014.
0:16:42 You'll notice that there is an increase in total government funds, which are the tax-supported
0:16:46 funds. The recommended budget here is $31,395,000 for fiscal year current, which is 2013. It is
0:16:56 is $29,536,459.
0:17:02 We will explain in this process what
0:17:05 is causing the increase in those funds.
0:17:08 And we're also looking at a total taxable increase,
0:17:11 a very, very small increase in our community, of about a half
0:17:16 a percent, which is significantly different than what
0:17:18 we talked about earlier, right?
0:17:21 So this is where we're starting really, really early.
0:17:25 Because as we were talking in my office,
0:17:28 the mayor was there in glory,
0:17:29 and we were really trying to just talk about this,
0:17:33 it all sudden dawned on us that,
0:17:35 there's a new piece of legislation that entered in,
0:17:39 and the first $100,000 of taxable value
0:17:43 on all business equipment is now exempt from property tax.
0:17:50 And that that money is going to come back in
0:17:52 in the form of repayment from the state.
0:17:57 And we started to think about what that means and that impact.
0:18:00 And so it makes sense to us that our taxable value would go down.
0:18:06 Because there are a significant number of businesses
0:18:09 in our community that are no longer
0:18:11 going to be paying personal property tax.
0:18:13 In fact, the first 100,000 of every single business
0:18:16 is now exempt.
0:18:19 And this is really important for us
0:18:21 to try to grab our arms around because the increase here
0:18:26 is just slightly less than a million dollars.
0:18:30 But here's what has occurred in our community
0:18:32 over the course of that time.
0:18:35 We know in talking to individual property owners,
0:18:38 realtors, and the like, that we are starting to see
0:18:41 a good return on valuations of property,
0:18:45 that they are beginning to slowly climb up
0:18:48 as the market begins to absorb the inventory
0:18:52 of properties that are up there.
0:18:55 We also know that the homeowner's exemption decreased.
0:18:58 It went from about 84,000 to 81,000.
0:19:04 There's a $3,000 decrease in the homeowner's exemption
0:19:09 of every occupied home in the city of Twin Falls.
0:19:14 And so that is also another significant number, right?
0:19:17 And we had $25 million of new construction activity.
0:19:22 And our net after all of that was less
0:19:25 than a million bucks.
0:19:27 And so we started to say, why?
0:19:30 And then all of a sudden, it was this light bulb moment
0:19:34 where we said, aha.
0:19:37 The problem is, is this is a brand new playing field.
0:19:41 And we're not familiar in calculating a tax rate based
0:19:45 upon the new playing field, because we
0:19:47 don't know the revenues coming in to offset that.
0:19:51 So the tax rate that you see in here
0:19:55 is probably much higher than what we would otherwise expect.
0:20:02 In fact, as we get closer, I'm willing to suggest
0:20:08 that the $185 million difference in this number
0:20:12 in comparison to the first number we received
0:20:14 from the county is probably the amount
0:20:18 of personal property tax value in the city
0:20:21 that will come in another revenue source.
0:20:24 And that will have implications to the tax rate.
0:20:28 Because that has to be incorporated into the formula,
0:20:31 and it will cause the tax rate to go down
0:20:33 by comparison to what we illustrated here.
0:20:36 Unfortunately, this is the first year of that system.
0:20:38 So we don't know exactly what that looks like.
0:20:41 And the county is not required to provide us
0:20:44 additional information on the value of the city
0:20:47 until the end of July.
0:20:50 And we obviously are starting our conversation
0:20:53 about three weeks before they will give that.
0:20:55 So continue to work with us if you will,
0:20:59 and we'll continue to refine those numbers,
0:21:01 and we'll continue to present that information.
0:21:03 But again, tonight, we wanted to make sure
0:21:05 that we are providing you with what is the,
0:21:08 what we believe to be the worst case possible tax rate,
0:21:12 right now based upon our knowledge of the system
0:21:15 and how revenues and expenditures will be made.
0:21:20 So last year, again, we adopted a budget,
0:21:22 about 49.2 million. This budget is 52.9 million. And you'll see that it is slightly larger than
0:21:30 the budget that we issued back in 2009. Over that same period of time, the cost or the cost
0:21:36 of doing business or the municipal cost index has grown by about 12.9%. And so we're starting
0:21:42 to see the impacts of inflation on our budgets as we continue to move forward.
0:21:49 that the budget is balanced and that's a really important thing. Our budget has to be balanced,
0:21:54 but this budget is balanced and it adds 695,000 of new property tax revenues. That means that
0:22:00 that difference of total government fund spending is coming from other sources other than the
0:22:06 property taxes. We are receiving an increase amount of money from state shared revenues.
0:22:11 We are receiving an increase amount of money in franchise fees and so we are projecting
0:22:16 to have additional monies, which is not indication of an increase in the tax rate.
0:22:22 But speaking of the tax rate and based upon the formulas of the past, and if our taxable
0:22:27 value remains the same without the credit of the $100,000 exemption from the state, our
0:22:33 tax rate will be $8.03 per $1,000 of taxable value, and last year's tax rate was $7.71.
0:22:42 important to note is that the tax rate is a multiplier and the tax rate does not
0:22:47 necessarily indicate that taxes are going to go up. And last year we went
0:22:51 through a series of examples of not only residential properties but
0:22:54 commercial properties and we illustrated and made that case. As we're able to
0:22:59 fine-tune that tax rate information and incorporate the new $100,000
0:23:06 personal property tax exemption, we will go through those same examples so that
0:23:10 You have a good idea and an understanding of what happens to our property taxpayers both on the residential site and the commercial
0:23:17 Industrial site. But Travis, let me understand you think that 803 per thousand would be on the high end right now. Right now
0:23:24 We believe that's the high end. Thank you
0:23:29 And it would almost have to go down unless the state decides the wealth on their deal and not return to state funds
0:23:36 So the Idaho legislature has already appropriated the $20 million associated with the program.
0:23:44 My understanding is they're still going through how this process is going to work.
0:23:49 And there's a recognition that it needs to be done prior to the adoption of municipal
0:23:55 budgets because there's a deduction piece, I believe, that there's a credit, right, that
0:24:02 we receive that we don't count as personal property tax.
0:24:04 So we're all kind of waiting for, I believe, the tax commission to complete the process.
0:24:10 And I don't know if Sean has the chamber executive director and president has any additional information
0:24:19 on that.
0:24:20 I don't have any additional information on the relationship between cities and local
0:24:24 units of government, but I can tell you that they are still drafting the rules for taxpayers
0:24:30 to actually figure out how to apply the exemption
0:24:34 that those have not been adopted yet.
0:24:41 So we're all very much in this wait and see.
0:24:44 Thanks Sean.
0:24:46 So you can as illustrated,
0:24:48 when we do a side by side comparison
0:24:50 of the fiscal year 2013 budget
0:24:52 and the fiscal year 2014 budget,
0:24:54 the total that increases $3,659,000.
0:24:59 And again, tax increases only equal $695,000 of that.
0:25:04 And that is by incorporating the 3% allowed,
0:25:08 a statutory allowed adjustment, as well as the new construction
0:25:11 and annexation values.
0:25:13 The new construction was about $25 million
0:25:15 and the annexation was nominal.
0:25:23 We also incorporate about $1.3 million of cash reserves
0:25:27 to cover projects that are truly one time in nature.
0:25:30 We have cash reserves.
0:25:32 The purpose of cash reserves is to make sure
0:25:34 that the organization remains solvent.
0:25:36 but it is also important that we allocate those resources
0:25:41 in a manner that is thoughtful and makes sense.
0:25:43 That without incorporating cash reserves
0:25:45 for specific one-time projects,
0:25:47 these projects would have to be either absorbed
0:25:51 in a normal operating budget,
0:25:53 would cause tax rate adjustment or other adjustments,
0:25:56 or it can be use of cash reserves,
0:26:00 savings that we've had for specific one-time capital projects.
0:26:04 So you can see in here that we have a series of capital improvements that we have $136,000
0:26:10 of a fire truck.
0:26:12 The fire truck costs us approximately $500,000, but the balance is being funded out of capital
0:26:19 fund.
0:26:20 We like to keep that at about $1.8 million a year.
0:26:23 We have new funding coming in there from the library, their request for a garage for the
0:26:30 a bookmobile, which might be something that Councilman
0:26:34 talking to and I were talking about a little earlier,
0:26:36 as well as windows and upgrades for those type of things.
0:26:40 There's $800,000 for general fund money,
0:26:45 and I think, is it water, water fund money, excuse me,
0:26:50 for the water system improvements at the Blue Lakes pump.
0:26:53 These pumps are going, as you'll know,
0:26:56 we put in a generator to make sure
0:26:58 that we have that redundant application.
0:27:00 These pumps will be a lot more efficient
0:27:02 and will allow us to pump our full water right
0:27:04 as we go through that.
0:27:05 So we're able to capture the full water right
0:27:07 as we continue to provide for the needs of the community.
0:27:11 We have some money in there associated with their geese
0:27:14 and Chishon Falls.
0:27:15 Those are dedicated resources that can really only be used
0:27:19 for those processes.
0:27:21 We have $100,000 for Baxter's Park.
0:27:23 That $100,000 has actually come from donations.
0:27:27 And so we put those into Special Reserve accounts
0:27:29 and then those kind of flow out for special donations.
0:27:33 And then $45,000 for a community park,
0:27:37 and I believe that's coming out.
0:27:38 Can I do a query on that, Greg?
0:27:40 Sure.
0:27:42 The 45 that were setting aside for the community park,
0:27:46 but that result then in a usable community garden
0:27:50 for this coming year, or is that only a piece
0:27:53 of the larger construction upgrade cost associated
0:27:58 with making a garden usable and feasible
0:28:03 for actually growing in next year.
0:28:04 Yes, I believe that would be enough money,
0:28:06 you know, to get the, mostly part of it
0:28:09 is just getting water to the side,
0:28:11 because we're looking at the fighter app
0:28:12 in the West property, that's west of window
0:28:14 and east of Grandview on the north side
0:28:18 that was donated by, I think, Joe Mardt
0:28:21 earlier this year.
0:28:22 So just get the water as some piping into it,
0:28:24 some irrigation ready for it.
0:28:26 You know, down the road, maybe eventually do some,
0:28:28 additional work on that site there like curve veterans I walk along that area
0:28:33 develop a more I guess Dennis and the query is that this is related to the
0:28:38 timeliness of providing the water and if we bring it to them in September it's
0:28:43 not going to be any help right the next year so the idea is to get it usable
0:28:48 early in the water delivered in time for planting yes it is all right thank you
0:28:53 Okay.
0:28:55 Good question.
0:28:56 Yes.
0:28:57 Thank you.
0:28:58 Oh, Donald.
0:28:59 Travis, how far should we drill down now?
0:29:00 Is this going to be an overview and then we drill down later?
0:29:03 What's the fits really, whatever, and that this is really your process.
0:29:09 Over the course of the next several weeks, we will be having a conversation about the
0:29:12 budget.
0:29:13 So tonight is what we'll describe as a larger overview of the budget.
0:29:18 In the next week, we'll have a conversation specifically about the tech-supported funds.
0:29:24 The following week, we'll talk very specifically about those enterprise or user-related funds.
0:29:30 We reserve the evening of the 29th, I believe it's the 29th, as an opportunity, as a catch-all,
0:29:36 if you will, to talk about all of the funds, one more overview, prior to the adoption of
0:29:43 of the tentative budget and the public hearings
0:29:45 for the different rate adjustments associated
0:29:48 on August 5th.
0:29:50 And then on August 19th, we'll ask you to adopt
0:29:53 the budget by ordinance and that we will submit
0:29:55 all of the required forms to the county.
0:29:58 Maybe I could ask a, I don't know if Chris wants to answer
0:30:01 to you do regarding the garage for the book mobile,
0:30:05 give me some dynamics about that.
0:30:07 I first, I've heard of it so I can start processing it.
0:30:10 If this is appropriate time,
0:30:12 Gelt Klinekop is the foundation president for the library, approached me last week just
0:30:20 about a week ago, and because Travis was tied up in getting this budget to this point, I didn't
0:30:25 bother him until today.
0:30:28 The particulars are that the foundation has met, tentatively met, I think, unofficially
0:30:35 with a citizen of the library to explore the potential for having a permanent housing for
0:30:44 their use books, for the use books say all that goes directly to the support of the library.
0:30:50 The foundation has been unsuccessful.
0:30:53 The six or eight different venues have not worked out for them to secure a place for
0:30:58 their book storage.
0:31:01 They, I think, wisely thought that this would be a time to consider since we were putting
0:31:07 up a garage to house the bookmobile to attach a permanent fixture of no more than 2,000 feet.
0:31:15 That was a figure thrown out and, I guess, that's simply dictated by the thought that
0:31:20 there would be a lot of boxes of books in there.
0:31:24 It would be wired and heated and lit and probably used on an ancillary basis by the library
0:31:30 either for their IT or some other portion, and it would be a fixture, a permanent improvement
0:31:43 for the library, and it would be in the library's name and ownership.
0:31:48 More importantly though, the foundation is willing to put money toward it.
0:31:52 So talking with Travis today, we were conceptualizing how this might come about, and we would probably
0:32:01 Use the city's available resources for architects to come up with some drawings that the foundation,
0:32:10 the library board, but starting with the council could agree that this looks like a reasonable
0:32:14 project, deliver some square footage costs, and use capital available but outside of this
0:32:22 current budget to fund and be reimbursed by the foundation.
0:32:27 I think this is a real important breakthrough, if you will, because relations between the
0:32:33 foundation and the library board have done somewhat strained, he said, understating it.
0:32:40 For several years, the fact that there's been a reproachments on both sides and see something
0:32:45 that they can commonly gain in, helping fund the library to the tune of anywhere $40,000
0:32:51 $18,000 a year, I think it would be worth the consideration of the council to do this.
0:32:58 Do we have a location or anything?
0:33:00 Yeah, it's behind the library.
0:33:02 It's in that vacant lot.
0:33:04 Kind of where a building is now that is kind of sitting out in the middle of things.
0:33:09 I can't tell you that that building is going to be removed, but it's unavailable property.
0:33:17 And I'm guessing that the cost and they have no real cook on it would be somewhere between
0:33:22 50 and 75 a square, 50 and 70 I think.
0:33:26 So that'd make it 100 to $140,000 project.
0:33:34 So I would ask for the current, the concurrence or at least the thought of the council to agree
0:33:38 with this.
0:33:39 We wouldn't have to make a decision until August or afterwards or what.
0:33:44 Right.
0:33:45 First threshold would be on August 5th when you set that tentative budget with the maximum.
0:33:50 Maybe to just expand a little bit on what Councilman Talkington is talking about.
0:33:57 The library, these would be cash reserves from the library fund.
0:34:02 Cash reserves that they've accumulated over a period of time.
0:34:05 And right now at the end of the last fiscal year, which is the benchmark through the audit
0:34:10 that we like to look at.
0:34:11 they had $1,122,000 available in library fund cash reserves
0:34:17 that could be used to the allocated of one-time capital
0:34:20 projects which allows us not to spend other incoming
0:34:23 tax resources on one-time projects,
0:34:26 and we can use those to fund ongoing operations
0:34:30 of our system.
0:34:31 Thank you.
0:34:36 So as we go through the budget,
0:34:38 we're going to kind of break this down
0:34:40 and kind of hit some of the highlights right now.
0:34:42 We'll focus on the personnel costs.
0:34:44 These are the total personnel costs associated with the budget.
0:34:48 They are not just tax-supported funds.
0:34:51 They're not enterprise-supported funds.
0:34:52 These are total personnel costs.
0:34:56 The total personnel costs in this budget are expected to increase by 923,946 or 4.6%.
0:35:06 And what we're doing is it provides the advancement of the second phase of our compensation model.
0:35:13 It calls for moving our table 2%.
0:35:17 And so as you recall, you moved that table last year.
0:35:20 And this moves it that comes up to that 10% mark
0:35:25 that we were deficient in the prior year.
0:35:29 And it is also one of those things
0:35:31 that allows us to continue to evaluate.
0:35:33 And I will tell you that we will probably,
0:35:36 and we should always look at moving that table.
0:35:39 That table really does begin to create
0:35:41 those starting benchmarks, as well as those market positions,
0:35:45 and that table should be moving to reflect the market
0:35:48 adjustments.
0:35:50 That cost of moving the table 2% is $18,000.
0:35:54 And basically, that means that there
0:35:56 are individuals that would not be on the table,
0:36:00 that they would be caught up, and so that they still
0:36:02 fall on our salary matrix and our table is removed.
0:36:06 The second is that we continue to move forward
0:36:08 with those compression ratio adjustments.
0:36:10 What I really, and that is the piece that I think is probably the most genius of the plan that we created.
0:36:17 And that helps move people through our system based upon competent performance and tenure.
0:36:25 And we have the expectation that our current model that employees with competent service should be at a market position within 10 years.
0:36:34 And that gives us the opportunity not to have a large cluster of people at the front end of
0:36:40 the scale, where after four, and as you recall, people with three and four years of experience,
0:36:46 we're being compensated at the same levels as the other.
0:36:49 And then this plan also calls for a three and a half percent compensation adjustment for
0:36:54 employees with a good quality performance valuation from their supervisor.
0:37:02 The two and a half percent this year and the three and a half percent that's proposed
0:37:06 averages to be about a three percent on the average over the course of the last few years.
0:37:12 Last year most of those surrounding entities provided a three percent compensation adjustment
0:37:17 and we provided two and a half this year we're trying to make sure that we can cover and
0:37:22 so over that two year window should they also provide three percent again which seems
0:37:27 to be the typical norm, that we are not any worse off.
0:37:34 The other important thing, and it's something to consider, and it's probably really no fault
0:37:38 of our own, but we provided a 2% adjustment to employees, and they received a 2% adjustment
0:37:44 if they were above that market.
0:37:46 That's what they received, and their performance was of a good, competent level as evaluated.
0:37:53 And you all recall the Social Security, the holiday, went away.
0:37:58 And so that 2% of the 2.5% was now returned back to the federal government.
0:38:04 And that other half percent effective earlier last week now went to Percy.
0:38:09 Percy has increased their rates, and it's about a half a percent, and that so the functional
0:38:14 increase of 2.5% that was provided by the city to its employees was diverted to other
0:38:21 sources.
0:38:22 what we're trying to do is to make sure that this year, that three and a half percent is
0:38:29 something that he also tries to catch up for a little bit of that as well.
0:38:35 When we take a look at the total number of individuals in the budget, you can see that
0:38:41 we're looking at having about 274 full-time equivalents, and you'll see that that is similar
0:38:49 to where we were at in 2011, and as we continue to go forward, it adds night full-time positions,
0:38:56 and it does also have some offsetting funds associated with those positions.
0:39:01 As we talked about, we have submitted an application for a COPS grant, and in that COPS grant we
0:39:07 hope to be awarded additional police officers that we've again partnered with the school
0:39:13 district and we have a proposal from the district to add another SRO position into the budget
0:39:20 and that SRO position would be funded in accordance with the current formula with the Twin Falls
0:39:26 School District.
0:39:27 We're adding an administrative position back into the engineering department.
0:39:32 That position was removed and it really should be brought back in.
0:39:38 It's not allowing us to maximize the use of that staff's time until we're really working
0:39:44 and kind of moving forward.
0:39:46 So, those are the new positions that we're kind of looking at moving forward.
0:39:50 We also have what I would say some upgrades to some positions that we're looking at trying
0:39:56 to move people into different places into our organization to create some better efficiencies.
0:40:01 And that is all included in that $523,000.
0:40:04 $23,000.
0:40:05 Never a question.
0:40:07 Grant.
0:40:08 And then here are the positions at a glance until we're done.
0:40:14 So Travis, you say nine positions, but from 2011 until present, excluding 12 and 13, it's
0:40:21 really a position and a half.
0:40:22 Am I right there?
0:40:23 That is right.
0:40:24 Okay.
0:40:25 And that's it.
0:40:26 Thank you.
0:40:32 And so then here's the individuals in the positions that we're looking at.
0:40:38 One is the grant writer, that grant writer position will fall into the office of the city manager
0:40:43 currently.
0:40:45 We have the three police officer positions and the one SRO.
0:40:49 Again, two of those police officer positions would be funded with a COPS grant.
0:40:55 Should we be successful?
0:40:56 And half of the SRO position, I believe it's roughly half.
0:40:59 And according to what the formula will be provided there, administrative assistant, the plant examiner
0:41:03 position is already in the budget.
0:41:04 Where would the SRO go?
0:41:07 I believe that it
0:41:15 Captain Matt Hicks of the police department
0:41:17 I appreciate you asking that we're actually meeting with Carl Boyd the operations director of the school district next week to talk about their expectations
0:41:23 I haven't made any final decisions yet, but I'm bringing that back full circle from our discussions earlier this year about school safety
0:41:30 That's obviously gonna be the primary concern
0:41:32 but potentially the
0:41:35 The school on Main Street what's alternative school. Thank you. Yeah, that's that's one of the most valuable options
0:41:42 possible options. I think that this person is going to fill
0:41:45 multiple roles at several schools, but they can be housed in that school. That's very
0:41:48 valuable. Thank you. Travis, how will we judge the success of a grant writer? I know we
0:41:56 discuss this enough, whether to get a new one or how much training is going to go in
0:42:01 or how much they write in a year. I'm a little bit nervous about that position.
0:42:07 Yeah, I think that's a wonderful question. And part of the resistance that we've had
0:42:12 in the past is exactly not only how do we measure the success,
0:42:16 but the other part of that is making sure that as we move
0:42:21 forward, that is something that we can support
0:42:24 into perpetuity.
0:42:26 I think that part of that success is
0:42:29 we've seen what a lot of organizations
0:42:31 are able to do in the area of grants and grant writing.
0:42:35 And they are able to take and really expand
0:42:40 upon the capital resources that they allocate, and so that they have funding coming in to help
0:42:47 and to offset otherwise capital improvements that would have to be absorbed into our normal
0:42:53 operating budget. One of the things that's important is that there are no direct appropriations
0:42:59 or earmarks any longer, but that does not mean that there are not grants that are being offered
0:43:06 regulatory agencies for projects. And I think the mayor just recently came back from Washington,
0:43:12 D.C., where there's a group that has monies available for projects and projects that allows
0:43:17 us to access. But we have to write a grant for it. And so when we start measuring the
0:43:23 success, I really don't want to measure it in dollars. Because I don't want us to go
0:43:30 out and supply and try to get every grant that we possibly can to be able to capture
0:43:35 every widget into our organization, but at some point in time, it's a liability for
0:43:40 us to have to buy in the future.
0:43:43 And so I really like the idea of really one time large capital projects, maybe it's trail
0:43:50 systems, maybe it's efforts to support economic development initiatives through accessing
0:43:57 CDBG dollars independently on our own.
0:44:02 may be accessing some of the grants that are available
0:44:08 through the Environmental Protection Agency
0:44:11 or the Economic Development Administration.
0:44:15 I really believe that if we don't have a grant writer,
0:44:23 we won't be writing grants, because we do not
0:44:26 have enough available staff time right now
0:44:29 to focus that effort we tried.
0:44:32 And in fact, I think I even offered the services of the assistant
0:44:37 to the city manager, Mike Williams.
0:44:40 And it was something that he wanted to do.
0:44:42 But when we started focusing on tracking the strategic plan,
0:44:45 started beginning the process now of doing performance management
0:44:49 measurement, overseeing the communications aspects
0:44:54 of our organization and other parts of the budget,
0:44:59 There's just not enough time for him to get grant training, to become certified and
0:45:04 to be able to move forward.
0:45:06 The other thing about the grant writer that I've come to appreciate is it's really an
0:45:10 art.
0:45:11 Writing grants is really an art, but the value of the grant writer is on the back end on
0:45:17 the compliance side, because it is through the compliance and the reporting where most
0:45:22 of those firms are costs come from.
0:45:29 is to brief comment I'll add here and I think I mentioned this before when we've
0:45:34 discussed this position I think based upon our strategic plan initiatives and
0:45:38 the value of partnerships with others in the community to accomplish our goals
0:45:43 whether it lives in this position or or because of things that the grant writer
0:45:49 could do it could free up time for other people I think continuing to build
0:45:53 those relationships and find partnership opportunities to help stretch the
0:45:58 dollars or achieve goals more quickly is a value in that position as well.
0:46:12 The next thing we want to spend a little bit of time in is illustrating in the maintenance
0:46:17 and the operational costs and all funds and you'll notice that there is continues to be
0:46:21 an increase.
0:46:22 In fact, as you track those increases from 2012 to 2014, it really does begin to jump
0:46:28 out graphically and when we take a look at that, you can see that there's a 725,000
0:46:35 almost $726,000 increase in the total operation of maintenance costs this year.
0:46:42 And remember, Idaho Power is coming in with a freight train of a power cost adjustment
0:46:50 that's going to impact us anywhere between 16 and 21%.
0:46:54 And when we have a water system that is very electrical, dependent, and a wastewater system,
0:47:01 that is the same, we start seeing significant costs and increases.
0:47:04 And so although heat, lights, and utilities
0:47:07 is something that is across all of our funds,
0:47:10 most of those power rate increases
0:47:12 are associated and borne by the enterprise funds.
0:47:17 We're also seeing an intentional effort
0:47:20 to spend more money in the areas of training.
0:47:22 And we're also spending additional monies
0:47:25 to make sure that we have the right resources
0:47:31 to assist with contracts and support
0:47:32 professional management services and the like.
0:47:38 The next funded a glance is the capital fund.
0:47:42 And you'll notice that in all of the funds,
0:47:44 in the government type funds that we're looking at,
0:47:45 an increase of about $228,000 or 4% increase
0:47:50 in the total spending for the capital funds.
0:47:54 And in the non-supported funds,
0:47:57 you're seeing a decrease of about $47,324.
0:48:01 What this does not reflect is a $38 million increase
0:48:05 into our wastewater treatment system.
0:48:07 that those revenues and that bond, which we believe will be sold in October, and those
0:48:12 projects will begin to get underway, have not been included into this budget.
0:48:18 When we go forward, and the way we go forward with our process is that we will illustrate
0:48:22 the debt service payment, but because of, as Lori would describe as a double accounting,
0:48:28 we do not put in bond revenues and we do not put that into the budget process, it is actually
0:48:33 reflected and captured in the audit process when we look at the values of those systems.
0:48:38 So there's an additional $38 million that will be expended here in addition to the CSI
0:48:44 safety initiative has also been stripped out.
0:48:48 We recognized early on that a few of you would not be able to vote on the budget.
0:48:54 If we can contain $2.1 million of CSI safety money in this budget, that money has been
0:49:00 stripped out.
0:49:02 We will track that as we normally do, and then we will go through a series of budget amendments
0:49:11 that are very, that are allowed under law and that we will do the last budget amendment next
0:49:19 year in September that incorporates the $2.1 million CSI safety money or whatever is being
0:49:26 expended so that the members of the council who have a conflict can vote on the single
0:49:31 most important decision that I believe that any council makes any given year, and that's
0:49:35 the allocation of its resources to goods and services.
0:49:38 So there's about $30 million of projects that are not included in this capital fund.
0:49:44 And so if you think about the level of investment that we're making in our capital system, is
0:49:48 it really is significant?
0:49:49 And if you think about the level of effort that the engineering and public works department
0:49:53 has undertaken over the course of the last three years, starting with water, arsenic, and moving
0:49:58 forward with all the improvements, public improvements
0:50:01 associated with Chibani, all of the increased number
0:50:05 of road constructions, water line, sewer line, all of the work
0:50:09 that they've undertaken, we've really made a lot of significant
0:50:13 investment in our capital system.
0:50:15 And we will continue that in this upcoming year
0:50:18 and the years to come.
0:50:20 So this graph doesn't really illustrate
0:50:23 what we're spending on capital.
0:50:25 It is actually a reflection that if you look at 2010
0:50:28 In 2011, those are audit numbers, right?
0:50:31 And so those numbers reflect the arsenic project.
0:50:34 The arsenic project wasn't necessarily balanced,
0:50:36 but we go back, we hit the actuals by reviewing the audit,
0:50:40 and then we'll incorporate those moving forward.
0:50:43 And so you'll notice that the fiscal year 2014 budget,
0:50:47 when you incorporate the amount of money
0:50:49 that we'll spend on those other projects,
0:50:51 will grow significantly higher than $10 million.
0:50:56 A number that stood out to me is the $91 million of capital investment in our systems since
0:51:02 2008.
0:51:03 That is seismic.
0:51:06 And that is something that I think the Council really deserves the credit to be able to recognize
0:51:12 the importance of spending those.
0:51:14 But that $91 million really illustrates the effort and the energy put forward by our engineering
0:51:21 And those in public works are really into hats off to them for being as successful as
0:51:27 they've been over the course of the last few years.
0:51:32 So drilling down into some of our revenues, property taxes is the thing that we often think
0:51:37 about most when we think about local government services.
0:51:40 And in the total government supported funds, about 55% of the total tax supported funds
0:51:46 is derived from property taxes.
0:51:49 And this budget again incorporates the 3% and the annexation.
0:51:53 And that is going to trigger this potential tax rate.
0:51:58 And again, it is one of those things that we're just trying to feel our way through.
0:52:03 But this is a comparative and an illustration of the tax rates that have been assessed.
0:52:09 Based upon the city of Twin Falls spending and the value of the city of Twin Falls tax base.
0:52:16 And this is the tax rate that moves forward.
0:52:19 Again, we believe that the 2014 with the estimated max
0:52:24 in parentheses probably needs to be bold,
0:52:27 it needs to be flashing, because that is really,
0:52:30 really, really a maximum that we're anticipating.
0:52:34 In fact, as you'll recall, we were illustrating when we got
0:52:37 the first number of $2.3 billion that we're talking about
0:52:42 driving the tax rate down, and so we anticipate that that number
0:52:46 number of $8.03 per thousand dollars of taxable value will decrease as we learn more about
0:52:52 the new property tax system that we're operating in.
0:52:58 Total property tax collections, this is the illustration and you can see that as we continue
0:53:05 to grow that reliance upon property tax to support general operations continues to increase.
0:53:11 Last year, we collected $16,600,943 in total property taxes.
0:53:19 That's what we budgeted, and this for fiscal year 2014, that number is nearly $17.3.
0:53:29 So what we wanted to do is we wanted to compare what does this look like.
0:53:35 And starting off at this point, as we did last year, we wanted to illustrate what the
0:53:40 potential difference would be and the monthly difference on a median valued home
0:53:44 inside the city of Twin Falls would be $1.89 per month is what that impact of
0:53:49 that tax rate looks like or $22.73 per year. Again we think that that tax rate
0:53:55 that we presented to you is inflated but we wanted to illustrate what that
0:53:59 maximum could be should it actually hold and again we don't believe that to be
0:54:04 the case. I wanted you to say we think we'll have that number especially the
0:54:10 It's a little concerning here.
0:54:12 Sean's saying that they would set up the rules on
0:54:14 how much you take out.
0:54:15 So the county has just made an estimated estimate
0:54:18 of assuming based on last year.
0:54:20 And we don't know.
0:54:21 So we continue.
0:54:22 So we received the first number of $2.3 billion
0:54:26 from the county.
0:54:28 Lori called them back and received.
0:54:29 We incorporated and made the change into the budget
0:54:33 that we have now of $2.153 billion.
0:54:37 It's $185 million difference.
0:54:40 And the impact to the tax rate, I would describe
0:54:43 as seismic, it's a 60 cent swing for $1,000 in value
0:54:48 based upon how these formulas work.
0:54:51 And so we know that the county owes us
0:54:55 the final taxable value number by the end of July.
0:54:59 That is the number.
0:55:02 And so we'll not actually be until the end of July
0:55:04 that we have a good understanding
0:55:06 of what that tax rate is going to be.
0:55:09 In fact, I may even argue that we may actually go through a budget,
0:55:13 that we may not understand the tax rate,
0:55:16 especially if the implications are that they don't have a system in place.
0:55:23 That's why I think it's really important, and maybe this is a good exercise,
0:55:27 for us to focus on what we're doing, and the value of what we're doing,
0:55:33 and to determine if what we're doing is truly in the best needs of our citizens,
0:55:37 rather than focusing in on single numbers moving forward.
0:55:42 At the end of the day, the citizens expect certain
0:55:45 service and deliveries and the budget that we have presented
0:55:48 reflects the cost of delivering those services as expected
0:55:51 and delivered and described by the strategic plan.
0:55:54 Is there a chance, I'm just kind of thinking out loud here,
0:56:00 that the county's not really gonna know what the number is
0:56:05 and we're gonna end up taxiing at a higher rate
0:56:07 than we need to per year and then the return it.
0:56:11 So remember, you don't ever set tax rate.
0:56:15 The tax rate is not something that you set.
0:56:18 The only piece of the mathematical formula that we have
0:56:22 is the piece related to spending.
0:56:25 And the spending in here says that we're
0:56:27 going to take 3% more revenue than what we took last year.
0:56:33 So when you're looking at property taxes,
0:56:35 That's what we've said 3% plus the value of new construction and annexation.
0:56:39 That is the parameters that we've set moving forward.
0:56:45 We submit an L2 form.
0:56:47 And on that L2 form, that is the documentation that we've supplied to the county that says,
0:56:52 these are the total resources that we are expecting for you to collect.
0:56:57 They take that and they actually will compute the tax rate.
0:57:02 But that tax rate certification, I don't believe occurs until like December.
0:57:08 So there's actually a really, really long window.
0:57:12 We can build what we believe to be the tax rate based upon our knowledge of how the system works.
0:57:22 But this is a new playing field, and so we're still trying to navigate that.
0:57:26 And again, it could be the case that we have no idea what that tax rate looks like
0:57:32 when we adopt the budget because the system may not have been put in place yet.
0:57:36 So from the tax payer side, individual tax payers had to file some form
0:57:44 and I'm going to screw up what it was called, but it was like the intent to take the exemption
0:57:52 a few months ago. So there is some process that's occurring.
0:57:56 So the county assessors have been notified by the taxpayers
0:58:00 As fairs have said, yes, Ganny Sesser, I intend to take this exemption, but how that process
0:58:08 actually works, those rules have not been finalized.
0:58:11 So, and again, they do have some time, because they won't send initial tax notices till December.
0:58:20 Well, it seems like the largest unknown or potential variable will be the impact of
0:58:26 a hundred thousand exemption on personal property. I mean they don't even have a
0:58:31 really a handle on how many businesses yet that that might impact. Well they would
0:58:37 because they would have the last year's numbers and they would have this notice
0:58:41 of intent to file so they can. But it would not be new. The personnel or the
0:58:48 program that will collate all that. They'll be sitting in raw form but that's where I
0:58:54 think we're going to get surprised. We're not formed through a fax machine, so it's a big
0:58:59 pile of them down there. And any surprise we get I guess probably will work against us
0:59:05 more than before us. I think it, well based upon this here, I think it'll actually work
0:59:10 in favor of us. The tax rate that we've provided here is based upon the value that's been provided
0:59:17 to us by the county. And based upon, and I'm just surmising here, I could be, I reserved
0:59:23 to the right to be 100% wrong.
0:59:26 Because I really, with these intent to declare forms,
0:59:30 is part of the logic that I'm using to say,
0:59:33 that's how they came from 2.3 billion to 2.15 billion.
0:59:36 That's how that decrease occurred.
0:59:38 Because logically, we grew by $25 million.
0:59:42 If you take a look at your individual tax statements,
0:59:45 what we've been told by everyone that we spoke to
0:59:47 is that at the worst case, it remained the same,
0:59:51 in your total taxable value.
0:59:53 But your homeowners exemption decreased.
0:59:56 So that means the amount of taxable value of your structure
1:00:00 under residentially occupied house grew.
1:00:04 Since it has for about the last five years.
1:00:07 60% of all the residents in Twin Falls own their home.
1:00:12 And so you start thinking about all of those numbers, right?
1:00:16 And there has to be some logical explanation
1:00:19 that we're just not aware of yet,
1:00:21 to cause the city to only grow by $977,000.
1:00:36 That doesn't include the new construction,
1:00:37 the new businesses and all of that.
1:00:39 So I think that here, if we start with a worst-case scenario,
1:00:45 I think that we really do begin to refine that
1:00:47 and move that forward.
1:00:50 And again, the tax rate, and here's the other thing.
1:00:52 If the tax, if the community,
1:00:56 with the increase in the homeowner's exemption
1:00:58 and the increase in the new construction activity
1:01:01 only increased by $987,000.
1:01:06 Then that means the average property value decreased.
1:01:09 And the average property value calculated
1:01:11 with a new tax rate, their tax burden
1:01:13 should remain about the same.
1:01:15 Because it should be all proportionate.
1:01:18 This is math and it should be constant.
1:01:20 We're going to believe that you say that that 803 is too high and it'll actually go
1:01:29 down and we'll believe you.
1:01:31 I am.
1:01:32 How's that sound?
1:01:33 Well, and that's really, that's the best that we can project right now.
1:01:36 And again, we could be completely wrong.
1:01:38 But based upon our knowledge of the system and the team that's been working on the budget,
1:01:44 we have confidence that we'll see that trickle down.
1:01:49 So we're often asked how do we compare to other cities in Idaho?
1:01:53 What we did was we took the fiscal year 2013 tax rate.
1:01:57 We received that from the associated taxpayers of Idaho.
1:02:01 We put that in, and we used the 2010 median home value.
1:02:04 That is the truest best number that we have out there.
1:02:07 We were unable to find the median values
1:02:10 for the communities for 2012.
1:02:12 So we used the 2010, and you can notice
1:02:15 that the tax rate is, you know,
1:02:19 sizeably different from the city of Twin Falls,
1:02:23 moving all the way down the line.
1:02:25 And again, we exclude the city of Boise,
1:02:28 and we exclude the city of Meridian,
1:02:30 because those communities have the ADA County Highway District.
1:02:34 And about 17% of our budget this year
1:02:38 is associated with roads and road maintenance,
1:02:41 which is covered independently outside of the city of Boise.
1:02:45 And so their tax rates are not necessarily reflective
1:02:48 of the tax rates that we would have.
1:02:50 These are a more true comparison.
1:02:53 And so it's an illustration that, especially when you look at
1:02:56 court-of-line, a lower tax rate does not necessarily resemble or
1:03:00 mean a lower tax placed upon the individual structures.
1:03:04 And that's how that mathematical formula works.
1:03:08 But all things being equal, you can see that the city of
1:03:10 wind falls at the major cities in Idaho, that are of
1:03:13 comparison, still has the lowest individual taxes based on a
1:03:20 median value at home.
1:03:21 And this is what that would look like, graphically.
1:03:26 But there is, as you noticed, quite a spread
1:03:29 in the median value of those homes in those seven communities.
1:03:36 There's a lot of, you got some extremes on the high and low,
1:03:40 but if you look most of them are clustered between the mid-140s.
1:03:45 So you got between 126, 127 going up to as high as 158
1:03:49 in that median cluster.
1:03:52 Clearly, the high is Cordellane at 202,
1:03:55 and the low is going to be either a combination of either
1:04:00 Caldwell or Pocatello.
1:04:01 But you still have a bulk in that 140 range.
1:04:07 Very, very similar to Idaho Falls.
1:04:08 Very, very similar to them.
1:04:11 Who did that tax rate for Caldwell?
1:04:12 That's scary.
1:04:13 Yeah.
1:04:13 It really was.
1:04:15 Well, they've got to be having towards the tax seed maximum.
1:04:18 So we homeballed.
1:04:19 We think that several of them hit that.
1:04:29 To put it in comparison, the city of Caldwell,
1:04:32 the flexible value last year, was about two times greater
1:04:38 than the Jibani plant.
1:04:41 Their total taxable value was $991 million,
1:04:44 the Jibani facility is estimated after moving forward
1:04:48 to be an excess of 400 million.
1:04:52 So here's some other significant resources,
1:04:54 obviously we're talking a lot about single family permits,
1:04:57 we're seeing a boom in the construction in a return.
1:05:01 So, this is an illustration of how those permit issuance have gone forward.
1:05:05 The 190 is a projection, and so is the commercial that we're projecting for fiscal year 2013.
1:05:12 Those numbers are what we use to derive projections for fiscal year 2014, as well as what that new construction value will be for the following budget.
1:05:24 And so, on that construction role in new annexation, we're seeing healthy growth.
1:05:28 We don't anticipate any annexations occurring this year.
1:05:31 We haven't been notified of any requests for indexations
1:05:34 that would be owner initiated,
1:05:37 but we do see that increase in commercial activity.
1:05:42 And so here's those construction values.
1:05:48 And the last note, I think, is probably one of the most
1:05:50 important is that this is the first time in almost five years
1:05:53 that we've seen back-to-back increases
1:05:56 in the new construction role.
1:05:57 And that is the first time since fiscal year 2009 and 2010.
1:06:04 We're projecting that we'll continue
1:06:06 for fiscal year 2014 as well as 2015.
1:06:12 State shared revenues is another source of money
1:06:14 that comes in.
1:06:15 You'll notice that there's about a 5.77% increase
1:06:18 associated with that.
1:06:20 There are a series of reasons why that occurs.
1:06:24 Number one, the state shared revenues is, again,
1:06:28 another math formula.
1:06:29 And they take the population of the community,
1:06:31 and they take the total taxable value.
1:06:34 And they use that in a formula.
1:06:36 And that is how they create the formula to distribute the sales tax, or the state shared
1:06:43 distribution.
1:06:44 Again, similar community value formulas go into the county distribution.
1:06:49 The gas tax dollars is distributed based upon population and road miles.
1:06:55 The M&O revenue is the road and bridge tax, and that's part of the share that we get with
1:06:59 the highway district.
1:07:01 Then the liquor apportionment is our share of liquor sales
1:07:07 that occur in the state.
1:07:10 You'll notice that of these monies that come from the state,
1:07:14 they constitute about 19%.
1:07:17 All of those fall into the general, or the government fund.
1:07:22 And the last two at the bottom specifically
1:07:25 are dedicated to the street fund.
1:07:34 So the water fund at a quick glance,
1:07:37 We're looking, again, this is one of those examples
1:07:41 that we'll kind of lay out to you.
1:07:43 And when we were creating this budget,
1:07:45 we were looking at having about the need
1:07:48 for about a 4% rate adjustment in moving forward.
1:07:53 We believe that we found a strategy
1:07:56 that will allow us to decrease the need
1:08:00 to cover operational costs.
1:08:04 And we'll kind of preview that strategy.
1:08:06 And if there's enough nods, we'll
1:08:08 go perfect what that strategy looks like.
1:08:12 It has to do with the arsenic fee.
1:08:15 And we set a flat arsenic rate of $11.15
1:08:20 for every customer in our community.
1:08:22 Because when we created the rate,
1:08:24 we said that it was about water quality, not
1:08:28 water quantity.
1:08:30 And whether you were the first drop or the 26th millionth drop
1:08:34 of water to come out of our system.
1:08:37 It was all about making sure that the quality was available.
1:08:41 And we set a flat rate of $11.15.
1:08:44 And we expected it to create a certain amount of revenue.
1:08:49 It would create the amount needed
1:08:51 to make the debt service payment.
1:08:53 But it would also create an amount
1:08:55 that allowed us to create this escrow count or bank account
1:08:58 to pay off that bond and that debt early.
1:09:02 revenues are coming in better than what was anticipated.
1:09:05 In fact, right now we're collecting between
1:09:08 ninety two and a hundred thousand dollars
1:09:12 more than what is needed to satisfy and pay off the debt early.
1:09:18 And what we can do is because those funds are specifically earmarked for
1:09:23 that. We don't let those funds and we
1:09:25 potentially try to keep those funds from entering into that
1:09:29 operational costs, we would be able to decrease the amount that we're paying,
1:09:34 everybody pays on a flat rate associated with arsenic, and we would be able to
1:09:38 shift and move that over, and that balance could decrease the overall rate
1:09:45 adjustment that's needed for operations. The harm is, we're trying to analyze the
1:09:53 harm, and it just means that we won't pay off the debtors on the same schedule
1:09:59 that we're at, but we'll meet the schedule that we committed to, and that the rate, we're
1:10:04 maximizing our money, and that the rate will be more reflective of what we need to operate
1:10:09 the system, because we're going to transfer from the flat, and we're going to put it into
1:10:12 the operation on the per-gallon site.
1:10:15 So if the council is interested in that, we would decrease the arsenic, and we would shift
1:10:20 those funds and it allows us to decrease the 4% a little bit lower for all of our users.
1:10:29 What kind of, what interest rate would it be? On the RST, a revenue box?
1:10:39 Yeah. And at the rate that we're painted off early, how much earlier are we going to pay it off estimate?
1:10:47 So right now, we're generating about $100,000 a year,
1:10:52 and it's about 380, so it might be two years.
1:10:57 Two years might be on the long side.
1:10:59 Well, would you make an essence give a little bit of a rate
1:11:02 reduction to people right now?
1:11:06 And not get increased.
1:11:08 And to offset some of the rate increase.
1:11:11 Right.
1:11:12 Mitigate the increase.
1:11:13 Because at the end, when you look at,
1:11:14 so we're trying to think of the customer, right?
1:11:16 When you look at the total impact of the water bill, we wanted to make sure that that bottom
1:11:21 line reflected everything that we were trying to do.
1:11:23 So it was one of those strategies that after we published the budget, we said this might
1:11:27 be an opportunity to see if it was something that you wanted us to continue.
1:11:31 It has my right question.
1:11:35 So, I didn't mean to tear that up.
1:11:40 So when we purchased pristine springs, that was for 15 years, and that's 3.66% roughly.
1:11:49 Okay. And then for the arsenic, there are two bond issuances.
1:11:54 One of them was with Build America Bonds, so the rate's a little bit higher
1:11:58 that we pay, but we get a credit back from the federal government.
1:12:02 The other portion of those bonds is a reduced rate, and it's just a tick under 2%.
1:12:08 And then the portion with Build America Bonds is a little over 3.3%.
1:12:15 So 3.3% is not the net. That actually goes down when you take the credit and you apply the credit that 3% and you'll
1:12:27 interest rate actually decreases.
1:12:29 Okay. I just didn't want it to be a 10 or something. I want people to think it was a 10. I knew it wasn't a 10.
1:12:37 Well, and rate increases are going up on the street too. So, it can factor that in of the rate that we have now, whether that's below market.
1:12:46 I will not buy yet that I believe we should go for it because I think I'd be interested in seeing what the impact
1:12:54 Are but the impact is okay
1:12:57 Yeah, I want to see some real figures, okay, but I think you're spot on it's the bottom line number that matters to the
1:13:05 All pieces in between so you get enough head if we can find a way to make that. I saw five tolerable
1:13:18 And again, it's one of those examples that will continue to perfect this process as we
1:13:23 move forward and we'll continue to present additional ideas.
1:13:28 So this kind of illustrates when we take a look at the debt service, that decrease of
1:13:33 $2.7 million, the decrease of $205,000 is a direct result of the refinancing effort.
1:13:41 The transfers are just those increased costs.
1:13:43 The transfers, the best way to look at that is a rent.
1:13:47 Each one of these enterprise funds operates like an independent business, and so it procures
1:13:52 services and rents from the other, and so that's what that transfer represents.
1:13:57 There's the operational increases.
1:13:59 The operational increases here include both personnel as well as the O&M, so that what
1:14:09 is needed to operate that system, and then the capital you can see is increased by $474,500.
1:14:17 a note there though that I think I really need to share with you and that is the net
1:14:22 amount of money that we're allocating towards water improvements is actually lower. That
1:14:28 we're actually incorporating about $800,000 of cash reserves in this budget this year for
1:14:35 those pumps and those improvements to be able to move forward. So when you start thinking
1:14:40 about net capital investments and those type of things, we have the cash reserves today to
1:14:46 be able to support this, but this as well as in the street fund, we need to continue to
1:14:52 make advances in those revenue streams to be able to not run into the places that we're
1:14:59 trying to come out from, that those concepts of deferred maintenance and holding go away
1:15:06 and that we're funding projects moving forward based upon Jackie and the engineering department's
1:15:13 development of that eight-zone matrix that we fix those projects within that, so we really
1:15:19 want to be cognizant of that.
1:15:21 This budget is smart for this year.
1:15:24 We think it makes good use of resources and sensitive to rates, but it is also not something
1:15:29 that we can continue to rely upon cash reserves to support levels of funding because at some
1:15:34 point in time, if you're spending more than what you're bringing in, you run into a very
1:15:40 ugly problem.
1:15:43 We are in a good financial position and we have the ability to spend cash reserves for
1:15:49 these types of projects to be sensitive for rate adjustments.
1:15:52 I was one for question on the water line, main water line replacement that's not related
1:15:58 to extending to pristine springs.
1:16:01 That is the water line replacement is specifically related to replacing water lines that our
1:16:07 our engineering and public works departments identify in the zones that are maybe not of
1:16:14 the right line size capacity or they're leaking, they're deficient in some manner, need to
1:16:19 be replaced as part of overall road construction, that is what that's for.
1:16:23 The cost to incorporate pristine springs is really probably two more zeros behind that.
1:16:36 So the sewer fund, the sewer fund, you'll notice that there are some increases.
1:16:42 And in here, we are stating that it needs a 29% rate adjustment, and that's changed.
1:16:49 We've got some changes.
1:16:51 Again, we continue to perfect this process as we move forward.
1:16:55 27% of the 29, or was that's not, we don't, I mean, right?
1:17:03 All but 2% of the adjustment is associated with the new debt service that we're anticipating
1:17:09 coming on into the system.
1:17:11 the balance is associated with increased operational costs.
1:17:15 We've continued to look at those expenses,
1:17:18 and we are going to recommend that the rate adjustment here,
1:17:22 the 27%.
1:17:25 We believe that after looking at that,
1:17:28 that there are some additional considerable opportunities
1:17:32 when it comes to revenue sources that will allow us
1:17:35 to only increase the sewer budget to cover the costs
1:17:40 associated with the anticipated new debt service.
1:17:42 And as we illustrated, that's about $5.21 or 27%
1:17:47 to those users.
1:17:50 And really, it comes from a product of lots of different
1:17:56 things.
1:17:57 You'll recall that we went through a refinancing effort that
1:18:00 generated some savings.
1:18:01 But we're going to put in a sizable debt that's going to
1:18:04 cause an increase.
1:18:05 That is the net increase.
1:18:07 And we're able to take some of those different savings that
1:18:09 we've talked about, we're able to kind of move them
1:18:12 within the fund, and we believe that this fund
1:18:14 would be well supported by just covering the increased cost
1:18:17 associated with the debt service.
1:18:19 And so the 2% for operational costs
1:18:22 will continue to refine, and that will be removed.
1:18:25 And this illustrates kind of what we're moving forward
1:18:29 with in terms of the significant capital projects.
1:18:33 The one thing they do want to point out
1:18:35 is the $200,000 sewer collection modeling system.
1:18:39 That piece will actually be used to determine what collection
1:18:44 lines will be constructing that were part of that bond effort.
1:18:49 So remember, we built that list of potential improvements
1:18:52 off of the 2009 collection report.
1:18:56 And so this is to update that report
1:18:58 and that we want to knock off those that are most efficient
1:19:02 and be able to validate and justify
1:19:05 why we've selected the capital improvements
1:19:08 to the collection line systems that we did.
1:19:13 Quick questions.
1:19:14 In the 350,000 for sewer line replacement,
1:19:17 that would be more routine sewer line stuff outside of the.
1:19:24 Yep.
1:19:24 Yep.
1:19:25 And that will fall into the next zone, similar to the water.
1:19:27 Right.
1:19:28 Thank you.
1:19:39 So the sanitation fund, the sanitation fund,
1:19:42 there are a series of lots of different parts of moving pieces
1:19:45 associated with the sanitation fund.
1:19:48 And when we think of the sanitation fund,
1:19:49 we often think of our service provider.
1:19:52 And our service provider at PSI is requesting
1:19:55 a 1.3% increase.
1:19:57 And you'll notice that their increase
1:19:59 is about 13 cents per month, 13 cents of the total of 46 cents
1:20:07 per month increase that we're recommending on the sanitation.
1:20:10 And you're probably saying, well, why is that?
1:20:12 Some of the things that we've done differently
1:20:14 is we've modified code enforcement.
1:20:19 We've taken that sanitation and code enforcement has been there.
1:20:22 We shifted its housing, if you will,
1:20:26 and it now reports under a new location.
1:20:29 We have increased costs associated with the sanitation.
1:20:35 We're looking at increased billing costs and other types
1:20:38 of costs.
1:20:39 And so what Lori did this year is they really went through
1:20:42 and they identified the true costs and aligned those costs
1:20:46 as a, to truly reflect the operations.
1:20:50 So 13 cents of the 46 cents is associated
1:20:54 with our service provider.
1:20:55 The balance is associated with internal changes
1:21:00 in improvements and realignments that have occurred with us.
1:21:05 We have a speaking of code enforcement.
1:21:07 We have a much more aggressive code enforcement program now
1:21:10 than what we've ever had.
1:21:12 And you may be getting calls occasionally
1:21:15 on the aggressiveness on our code enforcement.
1:21:19 When we received the 2011 survey, code enforcement
1:21:25 was one of those areas that we really needed to enhance.
1:21:28 With our code enforcement,
1:21:29 we've also placed under water conservation.
1:21:32 So they have that responsibility.
1:21:34 We re-aligned the activities and the priorities
1:21:36 of those in the meter reading department.
1:21:38 And now, we took Woody who was doing our parking
1:21:43 attendance stuff, and now we have three individuals that are completely dedicated to all types
1:21:48 of code enforcement within our community, whether that be downtown parking, weeds, abatement
1:21:55 issues, or whether that be associated with water conservation.
1:22:01 And all of those responsibilities now fall under the Planning and Zoning Department.
1:22:10 So one of the things that we wanted to point to illustrate, and again, there's going to
1:22:13 There'll be some modifications here, there'll be a modification of 2% in the sewer, and there'll be some modifications potentially, what could be in the water, and we're also anticipating some potential modifications to the tax rate.
1:22:30 And all of those are going to drive the cost, but we wanted to start off with this benchmark.
1:22:34 mark is the annual difference to live in Twin Falls is $9.41 difference and
1:22:40 remember $5.21 cents of that is associated directly with the bond payment
1:22:46 that was approved by residents on a 70-30 margin and our hope is it will only go
1:22:55 down from there right yes and you know we want to be sensitive this is I think
1:23:04 this illustrates, so the positive of this effort is that every conversation that we're
1:23:12 having right now is being streamed over the internet. You can watch it on channel 17,
1:23:17 it will be reported on. Everything that we're doing when it comes to the creation of our
1:23:22 budget is done in a manner that is incredibly transparent. And yet at the same time, we know
1:23:31 that there are going to be changes.
1:23:33 And the disadvantage of starting early is we don't necessarily
1:23:38 have all of the information we need to present.
1:23:42 And, patically, this is what it's going to be.
1:23:46 I think being transparent so long is it doesn't run out
1:23:53 that next, you know, in tomorrow's newspapers or on the radio
1:23:56 that the City of Twin Falls City Manager is recommending
1:24:00 this significant tax adjustment when the case of the matter
1:24:05 is going to be at this point, don't know.
1:24:08 Travis, one point I think we need to emphasize
1:24:10 that 941, 5, 7, 10, did you say for the sewer bond?
1:24:18 $5.21.
1:24:20 521 of the $9.41.
1:24:24 And all of that burden is not being placed on the homeowner.
1:24:27 That's spread across to all users.
1:24:31 That's right.
1:24:31 Absolutely, so we want to make sure the public knows.
1:24:34 Jimma.
1:24:39 Thank you, Mayor.
1:24:40 The plan is I recall from last year.
1:24:42 The plan of attack now is after year overview today, we take the preliminary budget, we review it, and then we're going to have some subsequent meetings.
1:24:48 How are those laid out?
1:24:49 So the next meeting we're going to talk about those that are in the tax-supported funds.
1:24:53 So those are going to be all the general fund, the street and the airport.
1:24:59 This will cover next week.
1:25:02 The following week, we'll have the conversation about all of those enterprise funds, everything
1:25:07 that you pay user for your water, sewer, sanitation, and also those things that you may not often
1:25:12 think of.
1:25:13 But they're dedicated funds that come in for a specific purpose, like search and seizure.
1:25:19 On the following week, you'll be kind of that catch-all to make sure that when you move forward
1:25:24 and you adopt a tentative budget that you feel like you have all of the information to take
1:25:27 that first step in the budgeting process.
1:25:32 The point of no return, if there is one, is not until August 19th, when you vote on that
1:25:39 budget and you say this is what that is.
1:25:41 In that meantime, we continue as a staff to perfect the information to make sure that on
1:25:46 the 19th you are voting on a budget that has absolute very best information.
1:25:51 I would describe this as probably about 70% there on terms of the information.
1:25:56 We have some holes.
1:25:57 identified those holes and we'll continue to work to expand our knowledge and how
1:26:02 to fill those.
1:26:05 Susan, I know it's early but I just want to throw out I didn't see anywhere in the
1:26:12 budget for addressing parking lots at the golf course or Oregon Trail or some of
1:26:17 the things that we discussed last week and I just would like to put that in
1:26:22 everybody's mind again that I'd really like to see those issues address this
1:26:26 share. There's absolutely, there is no funding provided for those projects. There
1:26:35 are a series of alternatives I've asked, in fact I think we have set up that meeting
1:26:39 to meet with our Parks Department, our Engineering Department, our Public Works
1:26:43 Department to describe and come up with some strategies that allow us to honor
1:26:49 our codes. Thank you. Just talking. And as a final outside the book comment on my part
1:26:57 Anyway, the discussion we had last week at GIS, the system, John Caton got back with me and
1:27:05 you and he had talked, I think that would be worthwhile sharing of counsel what you decided
1:27:10 to do to pursue a usable system in the street, the purchase of the, I'm looking for John.
1:27:22 He's not here.
1:27:25 Help me out.
1:27:28 Well, I think that you bought some mobile units in my pads so that the
1:27:34 City crews that are in the street can actually pull up and use the maps available to see where the actual as-belts are for city utilities and
1:27:44 the cost of that was
1:27:46 Significantly higher a year or so ago
1:27:48 But do you bet the bullet might think off their eyes purchase of a dozen or 15 of them and John was real excited
1:27:54 I thought that that's really going to be
1:27:56 A quick learning curve for the people to make use of them and the cost savings on operator
1:28:03 errors and cutting in the wrong place or whatever.
1:28:07 I think we'll see some real demonstrated value out of that.
1:28:12 And thank you.
1:28:13 One of the things that we recognized, we've had a series of conversations of not only about
1:28:18 GIS but also about city works.
1:28:21 And we've had many conversations, is city works truly something that we want to move forward
1:28:28 with and taking that data to really help make better decisions as an organization?
1:28:34 And there's no question that for some of us that have gone to city works conferences and
1:28:38 seen it.
1:28:39 The city works is a very, very good application.
1:28:42 The question that has arisen is, is it good for us?
1:28:46 And I think that John and his team are beginning to really incorporate some of those things.
1:28:52 John went down to the user's conference this year with other members of our team.
1:28:57 And one of the things that became very apparent is we called it a meeting, a huddle.
1:29:02 And in our huddle we brought the consultant into town and we talked about why aren't we
1:29:07 as successful as what other people are with this program.
1:29:11 And one of the things that became very apparent was that we were not investing in the equipment
1:29:17 to allow it to be successful.
1:29:20 That in order to be able to do the things on the street,
1:29:23 we had to equip our employees with the tools
1:29:25 to make it possible.
1:29:27 That if we weren't equipping them with the tools,
1:29:29 we couldn't expect the results
1:29:30 that all these other places were moving forward with.
1:29:34 And then when it comes to that entire application,
1:29:37 it really is incorporating those philosophies
1:29:41 into our workload.
1:29:42 And I think that's exactly the demonstration.
1:29:44 Because after that, on the following Tuesday, John did come into my office and said, you
1:29:50 know, I think that we did GIS an incredible disservice and we have a phenomenal program
1:29:55 and I want to reach out to Councilman Talkington to show him what we're doing and I said, do
1:30:01 that.
1:30:02 But that's important.
1:30:03 I think a field demonstration for anyone who would be interested may be something that
1:30:08 you would really like to see and I think Councilman Talkington for going with John and spending
1:30:14 any additional questions for Travis it sounds like we have lots of busy weeks ahead of us
1:30:23 with additional information. So one of the things that kind of help us out in that process
1:30:30 is as you have questions you don't have to wait till Monday. So as you have questions about the
1:30:37 budget or strategies you can come in and talk with us you can send us emails whatever works for
1:30:42 you, then we can be preparing over that week to get that information back out to you so that
1:30:48 we can report that back.
1:30:49 And our manner has typically been when if one member of the council has a question, there
1:30:54 may be more than one, so that we will send those responses to the entire group and we'll
1:31:00 talk about what that looks like.
1:31:01 So, if you have questions, please feel free to feed those in between the meeting times.
1:31:07 And then we can be in a better position to respond.
1:31:11 There's 200-ish pages in this document, and what constitutes all of the items in a single
1:31:19 line item is probably not going to be information that we can just roll off the tip.
1:31:24 At least I can't.
1:31:25 Lori, but I am not capable of it.
1:31:33 All right.
1:31:34 Thank you, Travis.
1:31:35 The next item is public input, anyone in the public who has information that they would
1:31:41 like to spite us and I think you're the only actual public person here is
1:31:45 shorty you know shorty doesn't seem to be coming to the mic so there's no
1:31:49 public. Give them a minute.
1:31:52 City major anything additional? Do you want to cover Council? Do we have
1:32:00 something Donald? Maybe for the Chief. Do you think that you could have someone
1:32:06 from your staff give us a report in the next few weeks sometime during City
1:32:10 council about what happened during the fourth and citations given what was the
1:32:16 feeling of the officers on the enforcement side of the fireworks how
1:32:22 we stepped that up do you think that would be possible Brian perfect thank you
1:32:28 thank you any others seen them advisory reports or other announcements
1:32:38 So as the next item on the agenda is adjournment to the executive session 6723451A and B, one
1:32:50 is the hiring a public officer employee staff member or individual agent, this program does
1:32:55 not apply to fill in the vacancy in the elective office.
1:32:59 And B is considered evaluation dismissal discipline or here complaint for changes brought
1:33:03 against a public officer, employee, staff member,
1:33:06 or individual agent, and I always leave a public.
1:33:11 So moved.
1:33:12 So moved my shot here, seconded by Don Hall.
1:33:15 Then we move into the executive session.
1:33:18 I'll be out of the seat in the light for discussion.
1:33:20 Rob, I'll vote.
1:33:22 Yes.
1:33:23 Yes.
1:33:25 Yes.
1:33:26 Yes.
1:33:28 Yes.
1:33:29 Yes.
1:33:30 Motion passes 7-0.
1:33:32 We will not be coming back out and making any decisions.
1:33:35 We're adjourned.
Download
- Transcript (text) 89 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 119 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 162 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.2 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 870 KB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, July 8, 2013. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:33:36.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
b6e1d61d43ee1e2acc188193104bfab88ab1ea82585703e25b6f63fbd87b8b50 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 296b856396c7276ee24d73df56afdbdf571904a46d8f34903108e7c75082384d
part02.m4a 4a04531cddf4db10841989d965a0f0ed773a68ebdb5f4706d83f38a48bc1339e - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
ee71c4a7b6e2515e27fb8f5caf8b5d20b9a30b0be1d5fc2fda2ae8669c779902
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file