City Council meeting
Monday, July 22, 2013
Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:00:02 This is just the one for high school sports
0:00:44 Okay.
0:00:45 Next week's the next question, do you not want to sign us?
0:00:49 No.
0:00:50 I'll say hi.
0:00:51 Oh, can I get there like you want to sign?
0:00:53 Yeah.
0:00:54 Oh.
0:00:58 She needs to stand up for that.
0:01:07 I mean, is it a big secret?
0:01:10 I think it's a big secret.
0:01:12 That's the bathroom bridge.
0:01:14 We went to the full meeting last time without a break.
0:01:18 Dots will use a Dots of Anybody Butter guy.
0:01:21 Okay.
0:01:22 Okay.
0:01:23 Okay.
0:01:24 Okay.
0:01:25 Okay.
0:01:26 Okay.
0:01:27 Okay.
0:01:29 Okay.
0:01:30 Okay.
0:03:45 Okay.
0:03:46 Okay.
0:03:47 Okay.
0:03:48 Okay.
0:03:49 Okay.
0:03:50 Okay.
0:03:51 Okay.
0:03:52 Okay.
0:03:53 Okay.
0:03:57 Okay.
0:03:58 Okay.
0:03:59 Okay.
0:04:00 Okay.
0:04:01 Okay.
0:04:02 Okay.
0:04:03 Okay.
0:04:04 Okay.
0:04:05 Okay.
0:04:06 Okay.
0:04:07 Okay.
0:04:08 All right.
0:04:09 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:10 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:14 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:15 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:16 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:17 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:18 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:19 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:21 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:22 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:23 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:24 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:25 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:26 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:27 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:28 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:29 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:30 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:31 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:32 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:33 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:34 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:35 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:36 I'm going to go ahead and
0:04:37 Travis, do we have any amendments to the agenda?
0:04:45 Mr. Mayor, members of the council,
0:04:47 since you're going into an executive session,
0:04:49 staff would ask that you also add a 67-235-subsection 1E
0:04:55 as an elephant under economic development.
0:04:58 Chris, can I sum a second?
0:05:09 We'd like Chris dying to say quid.
0:05:11 Don Hall to add an additional section to our executive section
0:05:16 for one six sixty seven two three four five one
0:05:19 one
0:05:21 I think some of that could be a little hard to see.
0:05:23 See no lights.
0:05:25 We'll have a roll call vote on the amendment to the agenda.
0:05:29 Sean Berger.
0:05:30 Yes.
0:05:31 Don Hall.
0:05:32 Yes.
0:05:33 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:05:34 Yes.
0:05:35 Greg Lanting.
0:05:36 Yes.
0:05:37 Jim Munn.
0:05:38 Yes.
0:05:39 Rebecca Milsoica.
0:05:40 Yes.
0:05:41 Chris Talkington.
0:05:42 Yes.
0:05:43 Motion passes seven to zero.
0:05:44 Chris Talkington.
0:05:45 Travis and Fritz a question.
0:05:47 I haven't done this enough.
0:05:48 But I'm always marginally bothered
0:05:53 by the number of executive sessions I have.
0:05:55 Now, does the amendment deny one economic development?
0:05:59 Items might be discussed that are truly either
0:06:04 copyrighted, confidential, competitive, and nature
0:06:08 cannot be discussed in an open meeting?
0:06:12 That is correct.
0:06:13 So part of the purpose of an executive session
0:06:16 is allow us to have conversations that may not
0:06:21 be ripe for public disclosure at this time.
0:06:24 Under the economic development one,
0:06:26 we are in or being considered in competition with other states.
0:06:30 And so we sign non-disclosure agreements,
0:06:33 and part of those non-disclosure agreements
0:06:35 state that we will not discuss openly any aspect
0:06:38 of those potential opportunities.
0:06:42 So that is the purpose of the executive session tonight.
0:06:44 Thank you.
0:06:45 Appreciate it.
0:06:48 There are no proclamations.
0:06:49 The first item on the agenda is the consent calendar.
0:06:53 Rebecca, do I have a second?
0:06:55 Can I remove council payable for a quick question?
0:06:57 Okay.
0:06:58 Why don't we just go in?
0:06:59 Since there's only two items on here, maybe we should just discuss that and then vote on it.
0:07:04 Councilor, I would rather than try to remove one of two.
0:07:06 Sure.
0:07:07 Go ahead and ask you a question.
0:07:08 Sure.
0:07:09 That's fine.
0:07:10 There's a payment, a reimbursement for Suzanne Hawkins on 37 and 50, and so I talked to her
0:07:18 previously, but I just wanted her to share about that event, and I assume it was on City Business,
0:07:23 and so I just would like to share with the council.
0:07:25 I'm sorry, my answer to you wasn't enough to satisfy you today since we've already gone
0:07:29 over this.
0:07:30 I have a presentation for the council tonight at the meeting.
0:07:34 I was asked on behalf of the mayor to welcome a group to the city, and there was a gift exchange,
0:07:40 And so the gifts were purchased for three other countries who brought gifts back to us and I
0:07:44 have those gifts to present tonight at the end of the meeting.
0:07:47 Thank you.
0:07:48 And as our call says and asked me about it and I approved saying that I thought that was
0:07:53 appropriate.
0:07:54 Thank you for covering that event for me.
0:07:57 Appreciate it.
0:07:58 All right.
0:07:59 So this is although as we have a motion for the consent calendar move approval of the consent
0:08:05 calendar.
0:08:06 Second.
0:08:07 The move by Sean Berger and seconded by Jim Munn
0:08:12 to approve the consent calendar.
0:08:14 Seeing the lights, the other roll call vote.
0:08:17 Don Hall.
0:08:17 Yes.
0:08:18 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:08:19 Yes.
0:08:20 Greg Lanthine.
0:08:21 Yes.
0:08:22 Jim Munn.
0:08:22 Yes.
0:08:23 Rebecca Milsoica.
0:08:25 Yes.
0:08:25 Chris Tawkington.
0:08:26 Yes.
0:08:27 Sean Berger.
0:08:28 Yes.
0:08:29 Motion passes 7-0.
0:08:32 The item is for consideration number one
0:08:35 is discussion of possible action regarding
0:08:36 the assignment of council members to be lay-as-ons
0:08:40 to the Planning and Zoning Commission,
0:08:43 Disgusting and Possible Action Mitch Humble
0:08:46 is the listed, I see Renee in the audience as well.
0:08:53 So the only thing I was gonna share was I tried
0:08:55 to recap the summary from last week
0:08:57 so we could kind of get back up to speed.
0:09:00 Renee's here since she attends most of those PNC meetings,
0:09:03 we also asked Chairman Frank to be here
0:09:05 but he's out of town this week
0:09:06 So we ask Lee to vote who's the vice chairman of the planning
0:09:09 of the planning of the commission to come.
0:09:10 And I'm here as well.
0:09:11 We can all help answer your questions if you'd like to.
0:09:13 But other than that, we're just looking forward
0:09:15 to your discussion and direction.
0:09:17 I believe we all received an email from the chairman
0:09:20 Frank as well.
0:09:21 I forgot to get it attached to the staff report
0:09:23 that I put together as well.
0:09:24 He did have some thoughts.
0:09:26 OK.
0:09:27 So there you go.
0:09:28 All right.
0:09:32 Don, you were the one that brought this to us originally.
0:09:35 So you want to start us out?
0:09:36 Sure.
0:09:37 Again, the reason that I brought this up
0:09:39 because as we act in a quasi-judicial manner on many things,
0:09:44 both entities, the commission as well as council,
0:09:47 I've always just had kind of a bad taste, I guess,
0:09:52 that certain members of the council get different testimony
0:09:56 and or more testimony than the rest of the council.
0:10:00 And so I think that that could skew us a little bit.
0:10:03 And I think probably some of the more dynamic information
0:10:07 that I received last week when we discussed this was actually from one of our council liaisons
0:10:11 where councilwoman Hawkins said that it, you know, being involved and stopped me if I quote
0:10:19 you wrong because being involved and going to those meetings influences her differently
0:10:25 than actually this meeting. And then I think Sean said those emotions actually have influenced
0:10:32 him here and I think that was probably even more dramatic to me.
0:10:36 I certainly appreciate the idea that council and P&Z need to have this relationship and understanding
0:10:45 of each other because sometimes we overturn or go a different direction than P&Z does and
0:10:52 I think that the relationship piece of our liaison position is very important, absolutely.
0:10:59 But I think that I still stand pretty firm on how I believe that we shouldn't go to both.
0:11:05 And I think probably a direction that we might be able to take is P and Z still does
0:11:11 what they call work sessions.
0:11:12 They're not really work sessions.
0:11:13 They're more like training sessions.
0:11:15 And I think that we could attend those because they're not deliberating anything that's going
0:11:20 to be coming in front of council.
0:11:21 And that could continue that relationship.
0:11:25 And in fact, I was talking to actually Lee Devore about this, and as I was talking I thought,
0:11:31 you know, maybe that's an opportunity for us as a council to take turns going to those
0:11:36 events so that P&Z gets to know us a little bit better, we get to know them, and I think
0:11:43 that might be beneficial.
0:11:44 But you know, I haven't heard anything including the letter and I've talked to Tom Frank about
0:11:49 but as well that has persuaded me to change my mind
0:11:54 that I think it's although legal, we can go to both.
0:11:59 I just don't like it.
0:12:02 Do we have a date at all on or an day
0:12:04 or Mitch might be able to help us on this?
0:12:07 I don't remember Council liaisons
0:12:11 when I was on panning a zoning.
0:12:13 At least for certainly not the first time
0:12:15 and I can't remember the last time if we had some
0:12:18 And when did we start having liaisons to the,
0:12:21 I was on from 1996 to 2003 or something, no, wasn't that,
0:12:29 even earlier than that, for a seven year period anyway,
0:12:32 and I guarantee there weren't any then,
0:12:34 I can't really remember from the year,
0:12:37 I was on the Council on the Planning and Planning Commission
0:12:40 at the year 2005, and I can't remember one then,
0:12:43 but I'm not certain.
0:12:46 So, Renee, can you clarify for us?
0:12:49 Good evening.
0:12:50 We just think your name is, that's all the people on the television of who you are.
0:12:55 Not Jane Doe?
0:12:56 No.
0:12:57 Haha.
0:12:59 Planning and zoning.
0:13:00 I've been with the city since 1985.
0:13:04 I do not recall a time when we didn't have liaisons.
0:13:07 I think there has been better attendance than that other times.
0:13:12 So I don't have a time.
0:13:13 And I kind of looked through some old minutes and I couldn't see them, and I don't know, you know, but that's my main thing.
0:13:19 I can assure you that goes back before your tenure.
0:13:22 I just don't remember them, I guess.
0:13:24 I think Renee is right. At times we have had not good attendance, so it may have seemed like we did.
0:13:31 Okay.
0:13:32 All right, appreciate that, Fred. And just pour a memory on my part, I guess, because when I stand, I kind of get the numbers straight from 86 to 93 when I was on there.
0:13:42 on there. I truly don't remember anybody ever coming to a single council member ever coming
0:13:48 to me other than Lance clock coming to a meeting for something for the band. That's you know
0:13:54 one I can remember. I'm Ken I'm telling you that you're a new beat of this and I can remember
0:14:01 what are you saying? When you were just getting out of training diapers. Okay. I'm just saying
0:14:07 I'm trying to say it from my time spent when I was on the point of his own commission, and I don't remember that's what he's saying
0:14:16 Okay, any other discussion
0:14:20 Chris was your light already on no, I think
0:14:25 Rebecca, I'm sorry Rebecca. I'm sorry. Thank you mayor
0:14:27 I just have a question for Fritz. I know that his opinion is that it's there's no conflict in
0:14:32 having a liaison and so can you just explain why you feel that way? Yeah so
0:14:38 all of everything that comes before you comes with the entire record below and
0:14:43 I know as a practical matter it's not like members that haven't been to the
0:14:49 P&Z meetings probably don't listen to the entire recording or read the entire
0:14:55 but it is part of that record, so at least constructively each of you have the entire record of P&Z plus whatever comes before you.
0:15:10 It would be a different matter, it would be a problem if applicants were required to present completely new evidence at the hearings before city council and that you were prohibited from considering anything.
0:15:24 anything, and P and Z, then obviously you would have heard things outside of the record that
0:15:30 you should have been considering, and in that case it would be a problem. But with our ordinance,
0:15:37 it absolutely is not a conflict because it's implied that you have everything that P and
0:15:44 Z had when you make a decision as city council.
0:15:47 In the Land Use Planning Act, it actually requires you to have a recordable verbatim record.
0:15:54 Right, right, so we're required.
0:15:58 So I guess I look at it differently.
0:15:59 I kind of, from Frist's perspective, you know, I think of the quasi-judicial issues.
0:16:06 The reason why the ex-parte contact is forbidden is because it's more of something that would
0:16:13 be done in private, you know, it's someone pulling you to the side and talking about an
0:16:17 issue or taking you out to lunch and saying, you know, here's my perspective.
0:16:22 And so that's the actual ex parte conversation that you shouldn't be having.
0:16:27 But I see any information in the public meeting as just that, it's public.
0:16:32 And I don't think removing a liaison position is going to help with communication even in terms of the meetings.
0:16:40 I think that it's good for the council to be there and to just be aware of what's going on.
0:16:46 and whether they listen to that record for BEDOM through audio or through the streaming
0:16:52 of the meetings, I don't think it matters whether they're there in person or not.
0:16:58 And I'm not sure about the whole emotional concept of people's emotions because I think
0:17:03 really what bias as a council member is, you know, things that we all have, you're upbringing,
0:17:08 you're socioeconomic status, you're race, you're gender, I mean those are true biases and you
0:17:13 You can't get rid of those, but as elected officials and people know those biases, that's
0:17:20 why they elect you because they're aware of them.
0:17:23 So I'm actually more concerned about ex-partay communication and the reason for the quasi-judicial
0:17:29 process that I think is more of a danger than any information given or received at a public
0:17:37 meeting.
0:17:41 Chris, talk.
0:17:42 back in the 90s, and again, I don't know exactly the time,
0:17:47 came up before council in some context and went back through minutes
0:17:54 and looked at our decisions as a council taken vis-a-vis those at P&Z
0:17:59 on a specific issue.
0:18:03 It serves my memory that does about 85 to 90 percent of the time
0:18:08 Council votes the same way or to uphold P&Z's decision.
0:18:15 That is a factor that shows four out of five times
0:18:20 without a lot of feedback from the liaison,
0:18:24 who's traditionally not been very vocal at council meetings,
0:18:28 usually responding to queries by the council.
0:18:32 But I think it shows the validity
0:18:33 of having a friendly wall of separation, if you will,
0:18:38 that independent decision-making, that the validity of the decision made by P&Z is most
0:18:45 generally upheld by the Council. I'm probably almost a purer spring than dawn for a feeling
0:18:55 that we should not have the cross-information and breeding of conflicting points potentially
0:19:03 coming up by having the council liaison there.
0:19:08 If the argument is that we want all the people to have the same information on the council
0:19:14 before they make a decision and it's only done through the P&Z's liaison report to us, that's
0:19:21 going way too far.
0:19:23 But let's talk about council people who may not have been present at one of the hearings
0:19:31 and didn't hear the original testimony and come in on a second or third hearing.
0:19:36 Should they not be able to vote because they didn't hear all the original testimony provided
0:19:41 to us?
0:19:43 You can argue this almost any way you want to and come up with the answer you want, but
0:19:49 I suggest that we consider it as a temporary or a trial position and see if we have any end
0:19:58 result difference over what we do right now of the PNC's decision, having a great deal
0:20:05 of merit most of the time and up held by the Council.
0:20:09 I don't think that we gain any additional information by the liaison attending, but they
0:20:15 may change their mind or be influenced by what they do here in that first opening door scenario
0:20:23 with PNC.
0:20:24 So, and if we're of a split decision what to do,
0:20:28 we might see if there is a prevailing thought
0:20:32 among other Idaho communities with PnZ liaisons.
0:20:38 Jim, what?
0:20:39 Thank you.
0:20:41 I also, I agree that it's probably cleaner for us
0:20:44 to look at this independently without,
0:20:46 you know, it's like the district court judge
0:20:49 sitting in magistrate court all day listening to cases
0:20:52 and then, you know, something's appealed or whatever.
0:20:54 listen to a case, just cleaner I think,
0:20:57 resolivated independently with evidence.
0:20:59 But I'm trying to look at the mechanics of this.
0:21:02 If we eliminate, officially eliminate the liaison position,
0:21:08 that certainly doesn't prohibit anybody.
0:21:10 Rebecca would say, I'm going.
0:21:12 And she has every right in the world
0:21:14 to go to those meetings for every single meeting
0:21:16 the rest of her term.
0:21:19 So, if we would vote on a majority
0:21:24 to eliminate the official liaison position,
0:21:28 it really doesn't change anything
0:21:30 except give choices to people on the council, correct?
0:21:35 So, I guess that's kind of much to do about nothing, really.
0:21:39 To me.
0:21:40 We're back, Ms. Lick.
0:21:42 Oh, thank you.
0:21:43 I had a similar question along the lines of Councilman Munn.
0:21:46 You know, if we just the mechanics of it,
0:21:48 So if we eliminate the official liaison position, you know, how does that work for appointments
0:21:54 of the P&Z Commission, you know, who is involved in those proceedings or do the liaison positions
0:22:00 stay in that position or how does that work?
0:22:04 Because I mean really when you take out the quasi-judicial and however you define that,
0:22:09 I guess each person will define it differently.
0:22:12 It's really no different than Parks and Rec or the airport board or any other commission
0:22:17 because certainly if I sit in on a Parks and Rec meeting
0:22:21 and they're talking about dog parks and people are, you know,
0:22:24 testifying, I might have a different perspective
0:22:27 than someone who didn't.
0:22:29 So I just don't see the value in eliminating the position.
0:22:32 And then my question is how will appointments work
0:22:36 for the liaison position?
0:22:38 Jim?
0:22:41 Susan Hawkins?
0:22:44 First of all, I want to address one
0:22:45 of Commissioner Frank's comments in his letter.
0:22:49 He talked about he didn't see it as a conflict
0:22:52 because the applicant has the right to take it
0:22:54 to magistrate court if they're unhappy.
0:22:58 But at the same time I believe, and correct me
0:23:00 if I'm wrong, I host state law changed.
0:23:02 And before it can go on to court,
0:23:04 it does have to come back to the council now
0:23:05 for a second hearing, is that correct for it?
0:23:08 If there's, so P&Z makes a judgment,
0:23:13 the applicant doesn't like it, it comes to council,
0:23:15 council upholds it, the applicant doesn't like it,
0:23:18 it comes back to council the second time before it goes
0:23:21 to the courts now, is that correct?
0:23:22 That's not correct, but they do have the right
0:23:26 to have a mediation before it goes on to district court.
0:23:32 Okay, what was the change that the state made this year then?
0:23:36 Do you know?
0:23:38 You mentioned it to the state of the day for itself.
0:23:41 Okay, while you're looking at that, an answer to Rebecca, I believe, Don had mentioned that
0:23:46 having the liaison still go to the worker training sessions, so that would still give
0:23:50 the liaisons contact with the P&Z and that way we could still work on replacing positions
0:23:55 when they become available and would still have that.
0:23:59 And while Fritz is looking at that, my other comment is, I don't know that it's as much
0:24:03 the information we hear from the applicants and the conversations that happen in those
0:24:08 meetings.
0:24:09 And I know for me personally, I feel sometimes the need to defend the planning and zoning commission
0:24:15 because I hear their hearts when they're talking about issues.
0:24:22 And it's hard for me sometimes, even if I'm not sure I agree with them, to disagree with
0:24:27 them up here publicly because I feel like that's telling them we don't support the decisions
0:24:33 they're making.
0:24:34 And I think it's more of that personal relationship
0:24:37 than maybe the legal relationship
0:24:40 that kind of clouds opinions, for me personally anyway.
0:24:44 So, whenever Fritz can get that, that'd be great.
0:24:47 Thank you.
0:24:47 And while Fritz is looking at it,
0:24:48 I've lead a board of the vice chairman.
0:24:51 Did you want to say anything?
0:24:55 Well, come on up then, Lee, and I'm inviting you to, how's that?
0:25:04 Renee just told him, two minutes, Renee.
0:25:07 I'm Lee Dzlor, I live in 4128 meta-read circle, Twin Falls, area of impact, and I told Renee
0:25:17 at 40 minutes.
0:25:18 I guess not.
0:25:19 So let me start with a little truth in advertising disclaimer before I talk about what I want to
0:25:26 talk about tonight, and that is that everybody's aware I'm sure of the Consul, but not everybody
0:25:31 out here maybe that I am the Vice Chairman of the Twin Falls City Planning and Zoning Commission,
0:25:36 So everything I say is going to come from that perspective and from my conversations with
0:25:41 the commissioner Tom Frank who couldn't be here because he was on vacation, he was smart
0:25:46 enough to get out of town.
0:25:47 So I am here in his step but also from my four and a half years of experience on the
0:25:54 commission and this is something I was listening to tonight when you're talking about the two
0:25:59 quasi judicial groups and truly that's what they are but they're different.
0:26:05 And one of the things that I've discovered in the last four and a half years is that the
0:26:11 Commission is much more limited on what actions we can take.
0:26:16 We can't make a lot of the decisions you can make.
0:26:18 We can't make a lot of the changes that the Council can make.
0:26:21 So there's a purpose for having the two groups.
0:26:24 It isn't just we're listening to the same thing over again and there's not going to
0:26:29 be any change.
0:26:30 thing that I've found is that even our role is much more limited than yours. And so oftentimes
0:26:42 what we'll do is, then the only thing we can do is look at an issue and make a decision
0:26:47 of whether to send it on to the Consul or not send it on to the Consul. It's simply that.
0:26:52 So you have a much broader role in this and rightfully so you should have. One of the things
0:26:58 as it was mentioned earlier, is that sometimes people on the commission take offense to that
0:27:05 because occasionally, and as cosmopolitan went out, it's not that often that it happens,
0:27:11 but every so often the costs will make a different decision than we are.
0:27:16 And I think that's right.
0:27:17 I think that's the way the system is set up.
0:27:20 I think that oftentimes you have more information than you have in that perspective.
0:27:24 you have a big picture view of it, where we're very structured in what we do as a commission.
0:27:31 So that's one of the reasons I think it's helpful to have a constiperson there because
0:27:36 they can list some of that and they know where we're restricted and where we're not and the
0:27:43 consul can do a lot more.
0:27:45 So there's two other things that I think are good reasons or at least benefits of having
0:27:51 a constiperson there.
0:27:52 One is, and this was also mentioned, that's maintaining a good relationship with the commissioners
0:27:59 because there was a period of time and not too far past when there was really kind of
0:28:05 a bad relationship between the two commissioners mainly because people on fighting the zoning
0:28:12 commission didn't understand the role of the two different groups, and they are different.
0:28:17 And so I think once you understand that as a commissioner,
0:28:22 that you understand that the council may make different
0:28:25 decisions for different reasons.
0:28:26 And that's exactly what you're supposed to be doing.
0:28:30 So I personally don't have a problem with that.
0:28:33 But it's important to have somebody there from the council
0:28:37 that they can vet you.
0:28:39 And it's able to discuss the reasoning of why the council
0:28:42 made a different decision than the board did.
0:28:46 And we've often seen that.
0:28:49 And I know the concept of people that are there
0:28:52 get hit up on that stuff probably quite frequently.
0:28:55 Not so much by me because I think I understand
0:28:58 the situation.
0:28:59 The second reason is that I think in the P&Z hearings,
0:29:05 it does give the council representing kind of a chance
0:29:09 to gauge the reaction of the community
0:29:11 and what's important to the community.
0:29:14 And since you're all elected officials,
0:29:15 I think that's probably of a primary importance.
0:29:18 You know, you should be listening to the community.
0:29:22 We're appointed, and we're not as responsive.
0:29:25 And I've noticed that in my tenure on the commission,
0:29:28 we're not as responsive to the community as the council is.
0:29:32 And I think that's just the nature of it.
0:29:35 So having a council person there where they can hear
0:29:40 some of that exchange and understand
0:29:43 where the commission's coming from, I think, is important.
0:29:45 So anyway, another factor was also mentioned tonight,
0:29:50 that I was thinking about when I was thinking about this,
0:29:52 and that is that our medians are public,
0:29:55 meeting anybody can come anyway.
0:29:57 So you're all invited and come anytime you want to.
0:30:02 Don and I talked a little bit about the fact that
0:30:07 if they could maybe have the place on,
0:30:08 even if that decision is made,
0:30:10 did not happen to come to the medians
0:30:11 that come to the planning session.
0:30:13 And I really think that is a good idea,
0:30:15 that we should even increase the number of five sessions
0:30:18 so that and have more constant people get involved in that
0:30:22 because for that first reason that I mentioned,
0:30:27 keeping that relationship open is really important.
0:30:29 So I know I haven't anything new,
0:30:33 but I appreciate the ability to get up here
0:30:38 and talk to you about it.
0:30:40 Also, thank you for allowing me to be on the commission.
0:30:43 It's an honor and a privilege and I enjoy it, thank you.
0:30:46 Well thank you very much, but thank you, Lee.
0:30:48 We certainly, any chance we get to thank those who are
0:30:53 on the different commissions and boards in obviously years
0:30:56 is one of the most important that we have out there.
0:30:59 And we do thank you for your service.
0:31:02 And most people don't probably don't understand.
0:31:03 It's strictly voluntary.
0:31:05 I mean, you used to have work sessions,
0:31:07 or at least you don't want you out of it.
0:31:08 But the old days, but I think we have another,
0:31:11 like Chris talking to you.
0:31:13 Lee, I'm wondering in your role on PNC.
0:31:15 Are you aware of any communities in the state that Council does not send or have a liaison
0:31:21 to PNC?
0:31:22 Not that I'm aware of, but I really don't know.
0:31:25 Travis, are you aware of any situations?
0:31:32 I'm not aware of any other city that has Council liaisons to the different committees
0:31:38 that we have in general.
0:31:41 And I think that's largely in part because of our form of government.
0:31:45 We are unique in Idaho, there's one of three cities that follow a council manager form.
0:31:53 And I think that the liaison piece, as I understand, as people have tried to share with me, is
0:31:59 to try to create that bridge between the advisory committees who report and work on behalf of
0:32:05 the council and provide an additional thing to the community.
0:32:10 Another opportunity or tentacle to reach out into different areas and groups.
0:32:14 I think that what we do into involves is fairly unique and but we can verify that if the council's
0:32:20 interested.
0:32:21 You say it's more of a function of being the city manager, former government.
0:32:25 That's what I've been told that this is true to me too.
0:32:28 Well, thank you, Lee, I appreciate you, Mayor.
0:32:31 Thank you, Chief.
0:32:32 Fritz, did you find you, I wanted to add one and Fritz, you know, the Fritz is the city
0:32:37 attorney for other cities around, doesn't file, or isn't the city, can't.
0:32:41 Well, but on one point where they the actual planning and zoning commission they are the actual they don't have a light
0:32:48 I he's on because they don't have a peensie. They are the peensie
0:32:54 Suzanne I wasn't able to put my fingers on it, but I know what you're Mitch came up and reminded me what you're talking about
0:32:59 It's the statutory right to a reconsideration of a decision
0:33:03 So if they are happy with you your decision
0:33:06 And they can take it to court.
0:33:09 They don't have to ask for recon, they're not required to reconsider, but they can reconsider.
0:33:15 Right.
0:33:16 Shumber.
0:33:17 Well, based on some of the feedbacks, they truthfully, I'm inclined to just leave this
0:33:21 as it is with the liaisons.
0:33:24 Fritz's reminder that the whole record follows this to us, not just what we read in the minutes.
0:33:31 Truthfully, I think if I were to sit and watch an entire planning and zoning commission meeting
0:33:35 before ever hearing, first of all, I would have a difficult time staying awake, because
0:33:39 they do run into the evening many times, but no, they do the yeoman's work.
0:33:46 I'm trying to apologize to Renee for you.
0:33:49 You guys do the yeoman's work on all of that.
0:33:51 They are lengthy meetings, and it's important information, but what I'm saying is to sit
0:33:57 and listen to that entire testimony would also convey, I think, the same emotions and feelings
0:34:04 that I talked about.
0:34:05 week that I feel are sometimes conveyed from the liaisons and so that's just part of the
0:34:10 process. Also Commissioner Frank's comments about the online recordings and having the ability
0:34:16 to go check those out and really Jim's point that we can say we don't have liaisons anymore
0:34:23 but that isn't stopping you from the council going to the meeting so that's my inclination
0:34:28 is to just leave it as it is and move on with our day on this issue.
0:34:36 Donald, since I'm the one that brought this up, the reason I brought it up is because honestly
0:34:41 I don't think it's, I still don't, it doesn't pass the smell test for me.
0:34:46 But this isn't a hill that I'm really excited about dying on.
0:34:52 It's not that big of a deal to me.
0:34:54 It's just for me personally, I don't think it's the right thing for us to do.
0:34:57 And if and when I would ever be asked to serve on that in that capacity, I would decline it.
0:35:04 I wouldn't do it because I don't believe that we should.
0:35:06 So I don't think we probably have the temperament and the council to make a decision or make
0:35:13 a change right now.
0:35:15 And I'm okay with that too.
0:35:17 I'm just I wanted to have the conversation with the council to see how they felt.
0:35:23 All right, seeing the lights for a motion,
0:35:26 I'm going to move on to item number two.
0:35:29 It's continued discussion on the city manager's recommended
0:35:32 budget for the upcoming 2013-14 budget year.
0:35:37 And this packet is much smaller than last week's travel.
0:35:42 And I wanted to make note to the public here.
0:35:45 Apparently, I was taking the task on the radio
0:35:47 last week on my ability to pass that budget.
0:35:50 So, or she'd be to have bathroom breaks.
0:35:53 So we will be breaking it.
0:35:55 If we, this goes past 6.30,
0:35:56 we will be breaking it at 6.30 for a.
0:35:58 Here, here, bathroom break.
0:35:59 Bravo.
0:36:00 All right.
0:36:01 Thank you.
0:36:02 Thank you.
0:36:02 Can we return to the past time that break?
0:36:04 It was a win for the day.
0:36:08 Seconded by Don Hall.
0:36:12 More thing, we could agree on that.
0:36:13 I thought it was a citizen watching out there streaming video.
0:36:16 They're getting frustrated that we weren't taking enough breaks.
0:36:19 So Mr. Mayor, members of the council, tonight's purpose is to talk about the Enterprise Fund.
0:36:29 And those Enterprise Funds are those pieces of the budget that have a dedicated revenue source.
0:36:37 So again, some of this seems like repeat, but we never know when people are going to join us.
0:36:44 And so we want to try to get them up to speed quickly.
0:36:47 Everything that we do in the City of Twin Falls is directly tied to our mission, or at least
0:36:51 we're trying to align it with our mission.
0:36:53 Our strategic plan is designed to further the vision that we've created, and that mission
0:37:00 is really designed to describe what we stand for as an organization, those value sets that
0:37:06 we deem to be important.
0:37:08 Early on in the process, starting in April, we began the conversation and we had three
0:37:14 meetings where you established key budget drivers. Those were to make sure that what
0:37:19 we were moving forward in the areas of tax increases were smart, they were sensible, and
0:37:25 they could be sustained by those who are paying the bill.
0:37:28 Number two, we wanted to make sure that we were continuing with our compensation strategy
0:37:33 that we started last year. We wanted to make sure on number three that we were investing
0:37:37 in our infrastructure and primarily we were looking at trying to enhance water redundancy
0:37:43 And the last was to make sure that we were finding
0:37:46 innovative strategies on how to go forward with business
0:37:49 and create more efficient outcomes
0:37:51 for the citizens and the taxpayers.
0:37:54 We talked about how this is a balanced budget.
0:37:57 It is something that we're required to do.
0:37:59 And many of us probably saw the headlines
0:38:02 over the course of the weekend about the city of Detroit.
0:38:05 And the city of Detroit being the largest single
0:38:08 municipality in the country to declare bankruptcy.
0:38:14 The City of Twin Falls is financially solvent.
0:38:16 We're financially solvent and we're financially viable
0:38:20 because of this process.
0:38:22 Because of trying to create a very transparent, open budget
0:38:26 where we illustrate our checkbooks online,
0:38:29 where we provide a financial dashboard,
0:38:31 where we always provide access to our citizens
0:38:33 to understand where we stand financially.
0:38:36 The City of Twin Falls is completely on the other end
0:38:39 the spectrum from declaring any sort of financial bankruptcy or having being in a place of financial
0:38:46 chaos. And unfortunately, there are many financial problems and woes being experienced by many
0:38:53 cities in the country, including some of our neighbors in Idaho. I'm happy to report that
0:38:58 we're not one of them. This budget also moves forward to ensure that we're promoting those
0:39:03 basic cardinal things that we do as a city, public health, public safety, and ensuring
0:39:08 that we're doing things in the area of quality of life.
0:39:11 It recognizes that our economy isn't completely healed.
0:39:15 It recognizes the fact that the cost of us doing business,
0:39:18 those inputs have increased about 1.9%
0:39:21 if you compare the municipal cost index from April 2012
0:39:25 to April 2013, and it follows a series of best practices.
0:39:29 Those best practices created
0:39:31 by the Government Finance Officers Association.
0:39:35 So, this budget is $3,656,000 larger than the past budget,
0:39:42 and that is the budget entirely.
0:39:44 We talked about how the taxable value actually grew
0:39:47 by $183 million, and our projections illustrate
0:39:51 that the tax rate in the City of Twin Falls
0:39:54 is going to decrease from $7.71 to $7.41,
0:39:59 $7.41, a savings of about $0.30 per $1,000 in taxable value.
0:40:06 We also noted that the homeowner's exemption is also going to decrease.
0:40:12 We talked about some of those things in the overall recommended budget in terms of what it looks like for rates and rate adjustments.
0:40:20 We'll spend a lot more time on that this evening.
0:40:23 So when you do a side-by-side comparison of the budgets, those parts of the direct graph that are illustrated
0:40:29 that are illustrated in blue are those associated with those government funds and
0:40:34 we spent a lot of time last week talking about it. This week we are going to focus
0:40:38 primarily on the red section of the bar graphs and that is going to be those
0:40:45 enterprise funds which total 21,518,781 dollars. So when we do a side-by-side
0:40:55 So by side comparison of the budget, you can see that the total taxable value is increased
0:41:00 by that $183 million.
0:41:03 You'll notice that the total net revenues in the budget are growing by approximately $3,700,000.
0:41:12 You'll notice that in the tax-supported funds that there's an increase of about $1.5 million.
0:41:20 important to note about that increase is just a little bit less than $700,000, about
0:41:26 $695,000 is coming from revenues associated with property taxes.
0:41:32 All other forms of revenues that we have from building permits, state shared revenues, and
0:41:37 the many, many other sources are causing the largest source and the increases associated
0:41:41 with them.
0:41:42 You'll also notice that the expenditures for the non-tech supported funds or the enterprise
0:41:46 funds are also going up.
0:41:47 And that's what we'll talk about.
0:41:49 And the largest source of that is going to be the debt
0:41:52 instrument.
0:41:52 If you look at a single largest source,
0:41:55 that is the new debt instrument that was
0:41:56 aboted by our citizens.
0:41:58 And we'll talk about that.
0:42:00 You'll notice that tax collections are going up by that $695,000.
0:42:04 And actually, because of the growth of the community,
0:42:07 we're actually going to see a projected decrease
0:42:10 in the tax rate from $7.47 to $41.
0:42:15 Now remember, when we talk about the tax rate,
0:42:17 It does not necessarily mean that all taxes for all in the community, really it is a multiplier
0:42:22 and it's a multiplier that is leveraged against each individual property.
0:42:28 Any questions on the recap?
0:42:32 No lights.
0:42:36 So now we're going to spend some time talking about the enterprise funds and why do we call
0:42:40 them enterprise funds?
0:42:41 Oh, Chris, I'll remind us again that estimate at a valuation per thousand will be refined
0:42:51 sometime late August doesn't that is about as refined as we're going to be able to get it
0:42:57 The reason it is refined is because we have a
0:43:00 When we were talking earlier
0:43:02 We shared with you that the county had provided a different taxable value and there was going to be a process that would that would be refined
0:43:09 And typically the county is not responsible to provide that to us until the last week of
0:43:15 of July. We were able to work with them and the county assessor provided that
0:43:19 information to us a little earlier than what they are legally required. The taxable
0:43:23 value of the community is the number that we received by the assessor and so we are
0:43:27 able to say the recommended spending in this budget is $17,296,000 of property
0:43:33 tax dollars and since the tax rate is just a mathematical equation that we
0:43:38 believe is going to be the tax rate that is imposed upon all properties in the
0:43:43 fiscal year 2014. So the refinement period is complete.
0:43:48 Thank you. Thank you, Jeff. So one of the questions you may have is why do we call these an enterprise
0:43:56 fund? And I think it's important to recognize that where we take those property tax dollars
0:44:01 and we'll put a little bit in the streets, a little bit in police, a little bit in fire,
0:44:05 move some to capital, do something for airports. And we're able to use those dollars with some
0:44:11 flexibility. The process of collecting fees for services is much more, it's
0:44:17 different. And what we're able to do here is we collect fees in a business like
0:44:21 manner to support the operations of those specific purposes. So we collect water
0:44:27 fees to support the water fund, which supports water operation. Same thing
0:44:32 with sewer, same thing with sanitation. So we have several different enterprise
0:44:38 funds or business-like funds or dedicated funds. Tonight we're going to, and there's a list of them
0:44:43 there, but tonight we're going to focus on the three largest, because the three largest really do
0:44:47 help drive that budget. It's going to be water, sewer, and sanitation. It's also the only three that
0:44:53 are directly paid by all of our customers. The rest of them are dedicated funds that may come in.
0:44:58 So for example, the golf course, although it is a business-like fund and enterprise fund,
0:45:03 not all city residents pay into the Gulf Fund.
0:45:07 It is paid for, obviously, by those who participate.
0:45:10 The Durkeys Lake and Chisholle Fund is another example
0:45:13 where dollars collected for the very specific purpose
0:45:15 of Durkeys Lake and Chisholle falls to fund the operations
0:45:19 and the capital improvements there.
0:45:26 So when you take a look at our strategic plan
0:45:29 and really trying to marry the strategic plan
0:45:31 with the upcoming budget, you'll notice
0:45:34 that the city's strategic plan calls out
0:45:36 for a healthy community.
0:45:37 And part of that health economy really talks specifically to water and to sewer and to make
0:45:43 sure that all of our public facilities are functioning at a high level to ensure the health
0:45:47 of our community, to ensure the health of our environment, and to make sure that what we're
0:45:51 doing makes good sense for the long-term future of our community.
0:45:56 The Water Fund was also one of the primary budget drivers in this year's budget.
0:46:01 We talked a lot about water redundancy, and we also talked a lot about the importance of
0:46:06 maintaining quality infrastructure systems.
0:46:09 You know, last year it was a bit of a tough year
0:46:13 when we had the water conversations.
0:46:15 There were one significant or longer-term duration power outage
0:46:21 where we actually had to work with our business partners
0:46:23 to shut down production because of real concern
0:46:27 that we may not have enough water to support
0:46:30 the basic life necessities and fire flow
0:46:32 in public of the community.
0:46:34 we're hoping through this budget in those processes,
0:46:37 we are beginning to take steps to alleviate that.
0:46:40 This budget doesn't completely get there,
0:46:42 and we'll share some of those things in the future,
0:46:44 but it does take good strides.
0:46:46 One of the things that we've done in this fiscal years,
0:46:48 we put a generator on site.
0:46:50 That work is under construction,
0:46:52 and John Caten could give you an update on that
0:46:54 if you were interested.
0:46:55 We're also talking in this budget
0:46:57 about making sure that we have redundancies in our system.
0:47:01 So when we look at the Water Fund,
0:47:03 It supports basically the water supply, water distribution, pressurized irrigation, and utility
0:47:08 building.
0:47:09 Those are the four business like functions that are going to be funded or fall under the
0:47:13 water fund umbrella.
0:47:15 You'll notice that the total increase in this year is $682,115 or $7.49 compared to the
0:47:28 allocation of the prior year of $9,101,000.
0:47:34 The budget that we have calls for a 4% operational increase, and we want to spend some time talking
0:47:42 about that for a minute because this really isn't a smoke and mirrors thing that sometimes
0:47:47 you will see or hear about in government, but we want to illustrate what this budget recommends.
0:47:55 So going back in time, Council followed the recommendation of staff to create a flat fee
0:48:02 for arsenic. And what we did was we set a dollar amount that we knew we needed to collect on
0:48:10 an annual basis to make the debt service payment on the EPA mandated arsenic project. And we
0:48:17 said the amount that we need to collect from all users alike is $11.15 per month. And we
0:48:24 didn't go through a volume charge but more of a connection charge because it wasn't a
0:48:32 water quantity issue that we were trying to solve.
0:48:35 We were trying to solve a water quality issue.
0:48:38 And it didn't matter if you got the first drop or the last drop,
0:48:43 we needed to comply with a brand new, much more rigid,
0:48:47 arsenic standard.
0:48:48 And so the staff recommended and the council
0:48:51 supported a flat rate in that arsenic feed.
0:48:55 And when we built that flat rate, we also
0:48:57 build the opportunity to take the additional extra 25% that we are required by bond covenants
0:49:05 to collect and place that into a dedicated escrow account. And with that dedicated escrow
0:49:11 account, we would be able to buy off the years of that debt early. So one of the things that
0:49:20 we started to do was to see how much revenue the fund was collecting. And was it collecting
0:49:26 at least the additional 25% that we could place into the escrow fund.
0:49:31 And when Lori and her team did the analysis,
0:49:34 we determined that we are collecting actually about $93,000
0:49:38 above the 25% that was needed.
0:49:43 About 392,000 is what we expect to create above the annual debt service payment
0:49:48 that we lock away.
0:49:50 And the reason is because of the number of new customers that we've connected.
0:49:55 So, it wasn't necessarily a math problem on the front end, or it was because it never
0:50:03 considered the growth of a community.
0:50:06 It assumed that the number of people inputting into the system would be static.
0:50:12 And that wasn't necessarily the case.
0:50:14 So, what we are recommending as a staff is that we shift that arsenic fee because it truly
0:50:24 been designed to collect for a specific purpose, arsenic debt repayment.
0:50:30 And we didn't feel good about taking some of that money and incorporating it into operations.
0:50:36 When the citizens and we advertise on our water bill, we collect that for a specific purpose.
0:50:42 And so what we did was we tried to find what does that look like.
0:50:46 And what we can say is that every single water customer in the city will see a decrease in
0:50:54 their water rate, by reducing the flat rate.
0:50:58 So the 4% increase in operational costs
0:51:02 would be applied to the smallest of our users,
0:51:08 all the way to the largest of our users.
0:51:10 And so the largest increase that anyone would see is 3.999
0:51:14 repeated for a really long time, if you
0:51:16 are a significant water user, right?
0:51:19 But for those smaller water users, those water users
0:51:23 that use 5,000 to 7,000 gallons, their net adjustment
0:51:29 would be less than a percent.
0:51:31 It would be 0.72.
0:51:33 Because when you take a look at the volume
0:51:35 and by comparison of the reduction of the rate,
0:51:38 you come up with a net adjustment.
0:51:41 And the net adjustment for the average water user,
0:51:44 the average water user in the city of Twin Falls
0:51:47 is defined by someone who uses 18,000 gallons a month.
0:51:53 the net adjustment after you remove some of the arsenic
0:51:56 and take the 4% operational increase
0:51:59 would be a functional adjustment of 2.2% or $1.03 per month.
0:52:06 And I apologize for the really long winded explanation,
0:52:15 but as part of that transparency,
0:52:18 we wanna make sure that the citizens recognize
0:52:20 when we collect a fee for a specific purpose
0:52:23 that we apply to that purpose.
0:52:25 And if we're going to deviate from that purpose,
0:52:28 we want to have a conversation about it.
0:52:31 Well, I think it's worthwhile, we're streaming now
0:52:32 and we want the public to hear this.
0:52:37 So the functional net adjustment,
0:52:39 the bottom line on their water bill will be 2.2%
0:52:44 for the average water user.
0:52:46 And in no case, will it be more than 4%.
0:52:50 We're back in this slide.
0:52:51 Thank you, Mayor.
0:52:53 I have another question about the arsenic rate.
0:52:56 I know in the past, we've had conversations about the flat fee is per connection, correct?
0:53:04 So, say you have an apartment complex or mobile home unit and they're all connected
0:53:11 to one hookup.
0:53:13 If this is a user fee per user, how would that affect the payback rate if we were to charge
0:53:22 per user, not just per single hookup, meter.
0:53:30 Right, so what it would do is it would actually,
0:53:35 we would have more people paying the flat fee
0:53:41 than what we have right now.
0:53:44 So when you have, and we have maybe duplexes,
0:53:50 or we might have large
0:53:52 manufactured home parks who may be connected to a single meter.
0:54:00 They receive an $11.15 bill right now to cover that arsenic feed.
0:54:08 If you went back and you tried and you counted every resident that it was serving above and beyond the meter and you placed that on to that, clearly we'd be collecting more money
0:54:20 And following this same concept, that flat fee of $11.15
0:54:27 or the proposed fee of $10.70 would be able to continue
0:54:34 to be further reduced.
0:54:36 I'm not certain that we have an audit on the total number
0:54:40 of customers versus the total number of connections
0:54:43 that I'm aware of.
0:54:46 John is saying that he's not aware of that.
0:54:48 Jackie is not aware of that either.
0:54:54 But we can do some checking and look at that.
0:54:56 Well, I know that some people struggle to pay that flat fee,
0:55:00 and some people don't.
0:55:01 So it's a bigger deal to some users.
0:55:02 But the thought, actually, that that brought to my mind
0:55:06 was that if it's spread out over the actual users,
0:55:10 if it's a true user fee, that might
0:55:14 help the entire community in having it be the arsenic
0:55:17 payment be a little less burdensome.
0:55:19 So absolutely for some who have maybe been paying the $11.15
0:55:27 every single month, they might see a reduction.
0:55:31 But for those connections who maybe haven't been paying,
0:55:35 you're going to see them now paying that.
0:55:37 Correct.
0:55:37 And so I guess the perspective is really
0:55:41 dependent if you've been paying it or not.
0:55:43 Right.
0:55:43 But everyone would be paying equally
0:55:45 instead of some not paying and some paying a lot.
0:55:48 And we think that there's probably, probably far fewer,
0:55:54 but it's probably worth looking at.
0:55:55 Probably far fewer not paying it.
0:55:58 And clearly the over 14,000 customers that we have
0:56:01 that are paying it.
0:56:04 It's something that Lori and her team can look at.
0:56:08 Thank you.
0:56:09 Well, just an example, I live in a condo building.
0:56:12 And I think we have four meters,
0:56:15 because we have four buildings, and each building
0:56:18 has one meter.
0:56:19 And so it would affect that.
0:56:21 But then again, obviously I think I could probably pay
0:56:25 the extra $10 a month or whatever.
0:56:27 We would have to change our condo fee,
0:56:29 but most people in there are retired on a fixed income,
0:56:33 and they've set their budget for the future based on,
0:56:37 so it's going to affect some people just the same way,
0:56:39 I'm sure.
0:56:40 Thanks, Chris talking.
0:56:44 What about common areas and PUD type of homes?
0:56:50 I come to mind with Stony Brook, and I'm not sure if I use a pressurized irrigation system
0:56:55 or not.
0:56:57 They do.
0:56:59 There may be others, though, that have a common area of watering.
0:57:03 I'm wondering if those are metered separately for the watering.
0:57:09 You would think they would be since the housing units would be on their own meters.
0:57:17 I can only speak for the kind of association.
0:57:19 I'm in that has a common area.
0:57:21 It is actually hooked up to our meter on the building.
0:57:24 I mean, for whatever reason it comes through on our.
0:57:28 So you pay part of that?
0:57:29 Well, the whole condo association pays it.
0:57:32 But it goes through somebody's meter.
0:57:34 It goes through the meter on my building, the building I mean.
0:57:37 So we'll through building.
0:57:38 So there's not an extra meter.
0:57:40 I'm sure there's some of them that probably have
0:57:41 an extra meter, I would think.
0:57:43 You're probably right, Chris, I would assume.
0:57:46 I guess I'm bringing that up to make sure
0:57:48 that we're getting collection where we should.
0:57:50 Right.
0:57:52 I'm sure it's all meters, just whether they have a separate one
0:57:55 or not.
0:57:56 I don't think we're giving any free water away.
0:57:59 That way, Dr. Kupkopi, I don't know where it would be.
0:58:04 We're going to look into that.
0:58:07 That is a great stump the staff question.
0:58:09 We don't know that one.
0:58:10 So we'll look into that, and we'll get a response back.
0:58:14 We did it.
0:58:15 Well, the question I would have for John,
0:58:16 maybe Lori or Jackie the part part goes to this conversation any water that goes
0:58:24 to any customer in the city when falls is going through a meter correct at least
0:58:31 we hope it is right I don't like that's a goal I think I just lost my coffee up
0:58:37 here I know we were at one point we found that we were there was a one
0:58:42 tap that was being any utilized near the golf course for for supply trucks and we
0:58:48 started metering that and people paid on a basis for that but that is the goal
0:58:53 though that everyone ever we meet or everything everything all the water
0:58:57 that sold to users is metered you know of course there's some parks city parks
0:59:03 that's unmetered and eventually we even want to meter that just so we can see
0:59:06 how much the water balance okay thank you John so what this provides here is a
0:59:17 breakdown of the water fund in the budget and so when you take a look at the
0:59:22 $9,783,338, these are going to be those general components and it reflects either an increase
0:59:31 or a decrease over the fiscal year 2013 allocation.
0:59:37 You'll notice that there is an increase associated with the operational budget.
0:59:43 The operational budget in this case is personnel as well as operational costs.
0:59:49 And remember, like we shared last week, the single largest influencing factor on these funds
0:59:55 is the power cost adjustment imposed by the Idaho Power Company.
1:00:01 They are the enterprise funds, namely water and sewer, consume incredible amounts of electricity.
1:00:09 That's why when we try to find more efficient ways from variable speed drives and take advantage
1:00:14 of other Idaho Power Saving initiatives, it's quite so important for us to do those
1:00:19 type of things because those power costs adjustment this year are sizable and significant.
1:00:25 Jim Mon?
1:00:26 I think you've answered my question, Travis.
1:00:30 The increase in operation, the $314,000 increase in operations this year was primarily due to
1:00:36 energy costs.
1:00:37 And we didn't we add a, we're proposing adding some personnel in that regard?
1:00:41 Not in the water.
1:00:42 Okay.
1:00:43 That's primarily just due to energy cost increases.
1:00:45 We have some increases and we have.
1:00:48 I'm too too I guess like for no other better term too lazy to get in the big book here, but
1:00:55 Okay, on page 45 you'll notice that we if the personnel and the operations line are combined to form this total because it really is
1:01:04 Primary driver and input you notice that personnel cost in the water fund budget actually down by 1.16%
1:01:11 Right, but the increase in the M&O budget is up 15.34%
1:01:16 And the M&O is the single largest driver as this part of the budget and so
1:01:23 you when you take the 314 and you subtract the 20,000 you get a net of about
1:01:28 314,000 and that is really all associated with the M&O costs and the
1:01:33 increase associated with that budget. The decrease in the debt service is a
1:01:38 result of our effort to go through and refinance that water debt so we're
1:01:42 starting to see a savings as a result of that, that $205,000
1:01:46 translated into real savings this year.
1:01:48 And then there's an increase in the transfer.
1:01:51 Part of that transfers the 1.9% cost of doing business.
1:01:55 Remember it transfers that rent, the rent that is assessed
1:01:58 to all the other funds because it has to operate
1:02:00 like a private business.
1:02:02 But the other side of that is that there's additional staffing
1:02:05 and some reallocation in there.
1:02:12 It transfers dollars to the shop to support the additional labor and manpower needed in
1:02:21 the shop to cover all the equipment and assets that we have.
1:02:26 We highlighted the capital.
1:02:27 One more question quickly.
1:02:32 One of them is the $800,000.
1:02:34 We're looking at replacing the four pumps down at blue lakes.
1:02:37 Those four pumps will allow us to have a more efficient and more effective pumping strategy.
1:02:42 We'll be able to believe we'll be able to pump our entire water right to 52 and a half CFS
1:02:47 Out of the blue-eggs water supply right now our pumping capacity is eliminated or is limited by the pumps that we have
1:02:54 We're looking at three hundred fifty thousand dollars for mainline replacement and another
1:02:59 Three hundred fifty thousand dollars for beginning that process of investigating future lands for a
1:03:06 Storage reservoir and facility
1:03:08 So my question is specific to pressurized irrigation so I don't know where it fits in
1:03:17 the slides here so I'm just going to ask it now.
1:03:19 So in the big book when we talk about revenue sources, they have water fees and pressurized
1:03:24 irrigation lumped together on page 39.
1:03:30 Would you have a breakout of what the pressure irrigation fees only are?
1:03:36 That's my first question.
1:03:39 My second question is back on page 151,
1:03:43 where it talks about the pressurized irrigation budget
1:03:46 itself.
1:03:48 I'm going to actually jump back here.
1:03:50 So we had a $200,000 jump in the operations budget
1:03:55 for pressurized irrigation between fiscal year 12 and 13.
1:04:00 And then 13 and 14 are actually reduction
1:04:04 in the operation cost there.
1:04:06 Off the top of your head, do you know what that big jump was?
1:04:11 because it doesn't show because it doesn't show a bunch of capital.
1:04:14 This is race will have the answers.
1:04:16 Okay. Thank you.
1:04:20 It would be a minute warrior do we need to go move on to the questions or?
1:04:26 Okay.
1:04:29 All right.
1:04:30 So thanks for the back.
1:04:31 We'll make sure we get back to them.
1:04:34 Thank you.
1:04:35 I just had a question about the replacement of the four pumps at Blue Lakes.
1:04:40 With that also create a building for those pumps or would they be out in the open like they are now?
1:04:46 Okay. And is that the ideal way for them to exist?
1:04:52 I guess. Thank you.
1:04:54 And a question I would have that follows that one up to John.
1:04:58 When we were doing our tours of those facilities,
1:05:04 and you were even remarked on it, those pumps were cavitating quite a bit.
1:05:08 Will these new pumps take care of that or is that an issue beyond this?
1:05:12 What's going on here is the line going across.
1:05:14 Yes, that it'll address efficiency and cavitation.
1:05:19 Okay, all right, thank you, John.
1:05:27 Laurie, are you ready to end?
1:05:30 Oh, yeah, side bar first.
1:05:33 So while they're working on that, I will tell you one of the things that we do is obviously
1:05:36 we have to try to estimate the growth of the system, and we're fairly conservative when
1:05:41 we estimate the growth of the system.
1:05:43 This year we are also anticipating a relatively flat customer rate increase of about a half
1:05:51 percent and we think that's just good, prudent government because we want to make sure that
1:05:56 the revenues coming in equal the expenditures and if we miss the number of new customers that
1:06:02 means that we just add additional revenues into the system and the revenues would actually
1:06:06 be paid by those new customers.
1:06:09 If we undershoot it that means that we fall into a place of having to use cash reserves
1:06:13 to subsidize operational costs because it's really kind of tough to back up when you've
1:06:17 started significant capital projects and so we like to be fairly conservative in
1:06:22 this approach but when you take a look at our growth trends as of late that
1:06:26 half a percent to one percent tend to be very close to the actual ballpark of
1:06:32 what we're experiencing. I think you're still looking for Travis if you want to go
1:06:39 on and we'll make sure that since you're still water we'll still we're still good
1:06:43 to say but so if you take a look at the total expenditures in the cap of on this
1:06:47 year, you'll notice that we're spending about $474,500 more on capital projects this year
1:06:54 than what we did last year. But it's important to note that remember we're spending $800,000
1:07:01 in cash reserves. And so the true revenues coming in to support the system are not, in
1:07:08 terms of capital, are not necessarily the same as what they have been in the past. We
1:07:12 We have good reserves, and it's okay to spend reserves on one-time capital projects.
1:07:19 I would caution the council, however, relying on our bank account to make needed capital
1:07:26 improvements in our system is probably not the wisest of opportunities and investments.
1:07:33 So as we move budgets forward, I think it's going to be important that we make sure that
1:07:38 The amount of money that we're placing into our infrastructure
1:07:42 represents the true cost of paying for that.
1:07:46 We've found our place in the community,
1:07:49 in an area sometimes of deferred maintenance,
1:07:51 and we're trying to work through that.
1:07:53 We're not going to get through that in a year.
1:07:55 We developed a strategy with streets,
1:07:57 and we're able to build more money into streets.
1:08:00 And so now, although I have not arrived in the street
1:08:04 to fund either, we are probably far closer today
1:08:08 than where we have been and we talked about the need
1:08:11 to do some overlay projects more than what we're doing.
1:08:13 But every year we tend to get a little bit closer
1:08:16 to the true cost of what it is.
1:08:20 I think Lori's ready.
1:08:26 So Sean, you were asking if we broke out
1:08:30 the pressurized irrigation revenues.
1:08:33 Okay, so in the current year, they're estimated to be
1:08:38 about 491,000 and next year they're projected with the way those revenues are coming in and
1:08:49 applying the rate increase they're expected to be about 529,000. And you were asking about
1:08:59 the expenses on the PI side?
1:09:02 Yeah, and actually so what I was looking at was between fiscal year 12 and 13, it's on
1:09:08 on page 151, it went from $92,000 a year to $297.
1:09:13 And bless Jackie, he's hard,
1:09:15 she had the answer right there.
1:09:16 So we transferred an expense for water shares
1:09:20 into pressurized irrigation,
1:09:22 because that's what those were for.
1:09:24 Thank you.
1:09:25 You bet.
1:09:27 Good question, thank you.
1:09:28 Chris, thank you.
1:09:29 And Travis back on the previous page
1:09:31 when you were talking about the significant increases
1:09:34 in power rates brought to mind my personal power bill
1:09:38 in early double this month, because I hope there are one-time charges.
1:09:43 Does that extend the municipalities, too?
1:09:45 Have we seen that much of an upturn and Idaho powers charges to us?
1:09:51 Not 100%.
1:09:54 No.
1:09:56 Most of our cost adjustment.
1:09:58 So one of the advantages that we have as being a significant user is the account representatives
1:10:04 really do spend some time with us.
1:10:06 They understand our billing process.
1:10:08 understand our power consumption and they're really able to share with us what those anticipated
1:10:13 costs are. Michael Honka with the Idaho Power Company spent some time with Pat Lehman to
1:10:19 really hone in on what those additional costs would be. From there we're able to determine
1:10:25 it's going to be, I think it's about a net adjustment of about 18.7%. I think the net
1:10:33 adjustment is 18.7. That's a permanent adjustment? It is it is a permanent adjustment until the PUC
1:10:46 right reduces it at the recommendation of the id of a power company. So what we have to do moving
1:10:51 forward is assume that it's not going to go down. So it's a largely 17 is the net substantially
1:10:59 a different rate increase from the PUC for residential versus municipality on
1:11:04 an honestly industrial use. The industrial folks were by far the heaviest hit.
1:11:08 Anybody else's power rates go off this month?
1:11:11 My act, my bill actually went down. Oh, I'm paying for it, so I was out of town
1:11:17 three separate times during that month, so that could have had something to do,
1:11:21 because they usually turn it way out during the time of the year.
1:11:24 If you feel bad, I'll send you my interest in getting an hour or so that was probably one of the best.
1:11:29 Good, Travis, thank you.
1:11:34 So one of the things that I kind of want to share with you is that in this fiscal year,
1:11:40 we commissioned a series of studies.
1:11:42 One of the studies that we commissioned was a water facility plan,
1:11:46 and that water facility plan is in that final stages.
1:11:50 And that water facility plan is really designed to talk about the improvements based upon current
1:11:56 growth and future anticipated growth of what we can expect in terms of improvements that
1:12:01 need to be made to the system.
1:12:03 And it kind of, it talks about triggers and it talks about opportunities and what that
1:12:08 looks like.
1:12:09 We know from some of our early conversations that in a 20-year window that we're probably
1:12:15 going to have to add about 10 million gallons of storage capacity into our system based
1:12:20 upon how we're projecting we're going to grow. That we're going to need to develop some additional
1:12:25 power redundancies, which also means changing out possibly some of the pumps and drives
1:12:31 out of the Canyon Springs facility. And we also know at some point in time, maybe at the
1:12:38 latter part of this, we may have to incorporate the Sunnybrook Springs project
1:12:45 into our water system. That Sunnybrook Springs project was something that we
1:12:49 had captured as a part of the arsenic project. It has a paper right of about
1:12:55 40 CFS and it is the cities. In the meantime we're looking at making sure
1:13:02 that we're maximizing the current water rights that we have so that we can
1:13:06 and defer this improvement for as long as we can.
1:13:12 Sean Berger.
1:13:13 I'm sorry to belabor the pressurized irrigation question,
1:13:16 but so when you talk about a 2.2% increase,
1:13:20 is that, so is there an increase on the PI fee,
1:13:23 on the my pot of the water fee?
1:13:25 Yeah, everything.
1:13:27 Anything associated with what?
1:13:28 Like smoke up fees, those kinds of things,
1:13:30 or just the usage fees.
1:13:41 So when you look at your net bill and you pay,
1:13:44 It's netting out at this.
1:13:45 It's the net 2.2.
1:13:46 2.2%.
1:13:48 Thank you.
1:13:52 Going forward.
1:13:55 Any more questions about water?
1:14:02 OK, so moving on to sewer.
1:14:04 Again, I think that we demonstrated
1:14:06 this connection to the strategic plan
1:14:07 when we talked about the water.
1:14:09 This really is a component of the healthy community.
1:14:13 You'll notice that this budget calls for a sewer budget of $9,336,793,
1:14:21 which is an increase of $2,006,301 in comparison to the budget
1:14:30 of revenues of last year.
1:14:32 And really, the driving factor and the only cause
1:14:36 of the rate adjustment is the citizen support
1:14:39 of the bomb proposal that we had supported.
1:14:41 You'll notice that the rate adjustment in here is 27%
1:14:45 at 27% translates to a $5.21 maximum charge
1:14:51 to our residential customers
1:14:53 because we cap sewer at 8,000 gallons.
1:14:57 And so the functional net adjustment is about 27%.
1:15:02 And that is associated with the revenue bond
1:15:05 that was approved by a 73rd margin by our citizens this May.
1:15:12 And this kind of talks a little bit about that project.
1:15:14 It's a $38 million project.
1:15:17 $32 million of the project is directly at the city's waste
1:15:21 water treatment facility.
1:15:23 And this talks about some of those projects that will be
1:15:26 included in that the total budget, you'll notice,
1:15:33 is that is $9 million, again, $336,000.
1:15:39 There's a $34,000 increase associated
1:15:43 at the operational cost.
1:15:45 You'll notice that there's a capital budget decrease of about 158,000.
1:15:51 What's important in that decrease number is the 32 million
1:15:55 on the wastewater treatment and the 6 million on the collection is obviously not included
1:16:00 in the 1,179,000 that we're going to invest in capital.
1:16:05 And so that represents the capital outside of those projects.
1:16:09 These improvements will really allow us to make substantial capacity improvements
1:16:14 in some of our collection systems
1:16:16 in our wastewater treatment plant.
1:16:18 But just because we passed a bond doesn't mean
1:16:20 that we've arrived.
1:16:22 There's going to be continual improvements
1:16:25 in our collection system as we go forward
1:16:27 and we make improvements that are outside of that $6 million
1:16:30 that's something that we want to be very cognizant of
1:16:34 that passing a $38 million bond does advance us forward.
1:16:39 But it doesn't eliminate the need
1:16:41 for all capital improvements in parts of our system.
1:16:45 You'll notice there's a $400,000 for the construction
1:16:48 of an industrial sledge tank.
1:16:50 You'll notice $350,000 again, same as the water
1:16:54 for sewer-lined replacement.
1:16:56 $200,000 for a collection model.
1:16:59 This is a model that really allows us to examine the flows
1:17:03 in our collection system, and that will be used
1:17:05 to help revise the 2009 study to highlight and determine
1:17:10 those parts of our collection system that are in most need of repair and that's where
1:17:15 we will begin allocating that six million dollars first and then a hundred thousand
1:17:19 dollars for some possible anticipated cost overruns with the Auger Falls project that
1:17:24 we have in there right now should those costs overruns not materialize that hundred thousand
1:17:30 dollars would go into cash reserves or be able to be allocated for another project.
1:17:36 Thank you, Mayor.
1:17:39 Can you or John maybe talk more about the industrial sludge tank?
1:17:44 I know that we're changing our process.
1:17:47 Is that going to create any changes to how we deal with?
1:17:53 I know that we kind of end up with some sort of fertilizer that we truck out from our plant.
1:17:59 I'm sure that's really inaccurate summarization.
1:18:03 So, my question just is, is this going to change our process?
1:18:06 Is there a new way that you have to store sludge or get rid of sludge or what does this mean for the plant?
1:18:13 Okay. There's two separate topics.
1:18:17 The sludge tank in the budget for $250,000 is the sludge tank,
1:18:23 is $400,000. Thank you.
1:18:29 is for pre-treatment at Conanger.
1:18:33 The existing sledge tank there is beginning to fail
1:18:37 and needs to be replaced.
1:18:39 But I think your question is more
1:18:41 on the wastewater treatment upgrades, and is that,
1:18:44 is that, anyway?
1:18:46 Yeah, that's fair.
1:18:47 I think that's a good description of,
1:18:50 so that's a specific project with the sledge tank,
1:18:52 but with the new biofilm, is there any different process?
1:18:57 You know, it is a different process, it's more current.
1:19:02 But how it creates solids is very similar to what we're doing now.
1:19:09 I think that's why Bill Leif with CH2M, he'll recommend it.
1:19:14 Is it dovetails well with what we have and optimizes what we have
1:19:20 without radically changing our process?
1:19:22 So at the end of the day, we're still going to have sludge.
1:19:25 We're still going to have the sledge that actually does turn into fertilizer that we take out
1:19:31 to farmers.
1:19:32 Okay.
1:19:33 Thank you.
1:19:38 Appreciate it.
1:19:39 No more likes.
1:19:42 So obviously we're going to get through a process.
1:19:44 We're going to have additional capacity at the wastewater treatment plant.
1:19:46 The functional capacity will be right around 16 million gallons.
1:19:51 When we operate chemically enhanced treatment, it'll go up to about 18 and a half.
1:19:55 Chemically enhanced treatment is not something we want to operate or manage all the time
1:20:00 because of its cost of the chemicals associated with it.
1:20:02 It kind of talks about the capacities of what we're going
1:20:05 to be able to grow to at that 6 million gallon number
1:20:08 on a daily inflow basis associated with this phase.
1:20:12 Restimating that about 13 million gallons will be available
1:20:15 for additional expansion and opportunities
1:20:19 in the second quarter of 2015 with the balance
1:20:24 of the capacities being completed
1:20:26 at the wastewater treatment plant in the last quarter of 2015.
1:20:30 And those are the 10 different schedules that we're working on.
1:20:32 We're very early on in that process right now.
1:20:35 We've been working with the bond bank to try to get
1:20:37 through the process of selling those bonds.
1:20:39 By working with the bond bank, we're able to take advantage
1:20:42 of the state's credit rating, which gives us a much more
1:20:46 favorable interest rate as if we were to go out alone.
1:20:49 And then we're also in the process of making sure
1:20:51 that we get our facility plan done, that we get this thing
1:20:53 design that we move forward with bidding and construction and there's a lot into that back
1:20:59 end timeline that has to be perfected but at least that is the target that we've set today.
1:21:08 And then the six million dollars improvement to our collection system again will be determined
1:21:13 as we move forward this year.
1:21:15 The primary purpose and the primary part of the bond is to make sure first that the wastewater
1:21:22 treatment plant piece is completed.
1:21:24 is by far the most important piece moving forward. The collection piece is what we would describe
1:21:30 important, but more of a secondary project to see what funds are available thereafter.
1:21:35 Chris, I can ask a question on our expansion of the wastewater plan. EPA and DEQ have bought
1:21:46 in totally on our plans, or is it a work in progress? Is there any surprises or any change
1:21:54 and permit standards that are going to accompany those
1:21:59 that the council should be aware of.
1:22:02 So I'm going to turn it over to Jackie.
1:22:06 You don't need to hear us twice, did you?
1:22:10 Good evening.
1:22:11 We have a draft facility plan that is ready for submittals
1:22:15 to DEQ and the conversations will occur then
1:22:20 to confirm acceptance as it were.
1:22:27 So EPA will address our permit and we don't anticipate
1:22:37 problem on the permit end because we are holding our loads
1:22:42 to the parameters that are currently in the permit.
1:22:46 Okay, so we're not making a volume change,
1:22:48 but we're not making an output change on the constituents
1:22:54 in the wastewater.
1:22:55 And when we complete the line-dogger falls
1:22:59 take that post-treated ready to dump into the Snake River water and put it into the
1:23:05 settling ponds. Will that affect us in any favorable way that we can foresee now so far
1:23:12 as credits, pollution credits?
1:23:20 I don't know that it has a positive effect for us in terms of pollution trading as it
1:23:27 were.
1:23:29 The water going into the river will be cooler and as I understand the percolation through
1:23:34 the soil column will remove additional phosphorus.
1:23:38 It is cooler for about half the year and then for the other half the year we actually
1:23:45 kind of cool the water.
1:23:47 We tested it because we're afraid of temperature becoming a criterion on the on the mid snake.
1:23:54 So we went out to find out what we do to the river water and we affect the water in a cooling
1:24:02 manner for part of the year, and a warming manner for the other part.
1:24:07 As far as that infiltration goes, at Otter Falls, we haven't tested the opportunity in
1:24:18 the State River for whether or not that wetlands will actually have removal all the time.
1:24:25 So, as well as we're interested in, as all the time removal, we can't have a wetland let
1:24:30 go of a phosphorus load because that could put us in a spot where we violate our permits,
1:24:34 So we need to move through that.
1:24:37 The reason I bring this up, talking with people
1:24:40 that were involved with the much earlier use of that same land
1:24:45 by Conagra's predecessor for treatment of their waste
1:24:53 loads.
1:24:55 And they are thinking that their ground
1:24:58 has a pretty high phosphorus loading in it now.
1:25:03 And it's very possible that it's just going to have negligible or even negative effect.
1:25:10 And do we know anything of that or I mean, I'm speaking out of bounds from a knowledge basis,
1:25:17 but I certainly think we are all aware that that land that we intend to use as settling
1:25:24 ponds has had a prior use to remove phosphorus.
1:25:29 You're right the prior use was to remove phosphorus and in the context that we are utilizing the ground
1:25:41 I think we're doing all right. So the auger falls tag project that has the
1:25:48 that has the line item for next year creates wetlands in Parkland and
1:25:54 The specific purpose of that facility isn't to prove a phosphorus reduction
1:26:00 That's not to say that we won't choose to address that at a later time, but the original intent
1:26:08 of this project was to create wetlands in a parkland.
1:26:11 The TSS removal project that we have a little farther towards Rock Creek and the Talislope
1:26:18 is doing a wonderful job because it doesn't outlet, so we have 100% TSS removal from the
1:26:26 Snake River and 100% foster removal as well.
1:26:32 So that, for the purposes of our NPDS permit,
1:26:35 we're showing success on the TSS component
1:26:39 that was the reason that we built that one.
1:26:42 Well, my final question, Jackie, is the comment first of all,
1:26:49 none of us want to have any unpleasant surprises.
1:26:52 The time and the effort, the money we're putting
1:26:54 end of that agar falls project. Is it possible for us to get an independent chemists evaluation
1:27:05 of the soil columns there and to see if there could be a detrimental effect that's going
1:27:11 to get us into a whole new series of negotiations with the DEQ? I guess what I'm saying, look,
1:27:21 is better to do it now than be surprised when something unportold develops by that.
1:27:27 I don't know if a phosphorous loading would mean that the water would no longer percolate
1:27:32 or if it would react with other substances.
1:27:36 I guess I'm just saying that I think a little bit of caution on our side right now by somebody
1:27:43 who is a soil chemist may be of some value to us.
1:27:50 And is that a possibility that we wouldn't think the cost would be?
1:27:58 You bet.
1:27:59 But before we run out and do it, I want to wait for Lee to come back from vacation and
1:28:05 have him review what he has already done because we did a tremendous amount of work on infiltration
1:28:09 rates, on whether or not we wanted to look at this as a permit offset or a secondary
1:28:15 permit location, and why and I am not intimately familiar with that.
1:28:21 Okay.
1:28:22 Sounds nice to me when Lee does get back in the chat.
1:28:25 Sounds appropriate.
1:28:26 That's a discussion to provide us with that information.
1:28:28 Yes.
1:28:29 Thank you, Jagged.
1:28:30 So that is the conversation about voice water as we move forward not only this year but also
1:28:42 in subsequent years.
1:28:43 And the last one that we want to talk to you tonight, the last of the big three of enterprise
1:28:48 funds is going to be the sanitation fund.
1:28:50 The sanitation fund is obviously one of those things that we've actually made some good advances
1:28:55 is over the course of the last few years.
1:28:58 In fact, when you take a look at our Citizen Survey,
1:29:01 our recycling program is one of those things
1:29:03 that has received by far probably the largest growth
1:29:06 and support.
1:29:08 Over its life, we've diverted over 5,000 tons
1:29:13 from entering into the landfill.
1:29:15 And that really does give us an opportunity.
1:29:19 It hasn't quite always, I think it meets our expectations,
1:29:24 It meets our expectations, but I think that we've talked internally, we've worked with
1:29:28 PSI, and we've always wanted to find a way to increase the number of pounds per capita
1:29:33 that are recycled by the number of residential units.
1:29:39 And that is one of the goals that we've talked about.
1:29:42 We're going to be utilizing again PSI, and we've had those conversations as well as with
1:29:47 Josh in trying to find ways to get a good message out, to really strengthen and reinforce
1:29:54 that importance and value set of recycling, even without the incentive-based piece.
1:30:02 In fact, one of the things that we found is even though there has been a slight decline,
1:30:07 the slight is probably something that is probably has more to do with needing to get
1:30:15 a reminder out so that we're constantly changing a behavior pattern as opposed to the incentive
1:30:24 piece that wasn't necessarily there. I think I'm still not in the position where I say losing
1:30:29 that incentive piece has really been that detrimental to the program. In fact, I believe that it's
1:30:35 just a handful of people that have said, well, if you're not going to give me my incentive,
1:30:39 you can take my my can back. Most people are still by census moving forward. It's just the
1:30:45 volumes is something that we need to work on.
1:30:49 Thank you, Mayor, and I think another thing that we talked about when we're talking about,
1:30:55 you know, do we need this incentive program, we were talking about doing, you know, spending
1:31:00 some money on our own advertising, because that's one thing that the recycle bank was
1:31:05 doing for us, is that they were doing some, you know, advertising.
1:31:09 So I think that as we do, you know, we might need to spend some money on advertising or
1:31:15 or just utilize our PIO office, you know,
1:31:18 and I think that works really well.
1:31:21 So I think that's a great idea as we continue to,
1:31:25 you know, move forward with the program
1:31:27 to continually remind people in a different way
1:31:31 how they can recycle or how easy it is to recycle.
1:31:35 And sometimes they'll just remember,
1:31:37 oh yeah, you know, maybe I can recycle this
1:31:39 instead of throw it away.
1:31:40 But yeah, I think definitely the intent was
1:31:42 to continue to advertise on our own.
1:31:47 So when you look at the sanitation fund,
1:31:50 the sanitation fund is provided by a service contract provider.
1:31:54 A service contract provider contract
1:31:57 was renewed through a competitive process,
1:32:00 and we're in the second of a five-year contract with that.
1:32:04 The total adjustment in the sanitation fund
1:32:08 is 46 cents or 2.79%, only 13 cents of that,
1:32:13 or 1.3% is associated with PSI.
1:32:17 The other causes are more internal,
1:32:20 and we tried to describe what happened.
1:32:22 And so you're probably looking at this and you're saying,
1:32:25 there was a decrease of $200,000,
1:32:28 but you're increasing the rate.
1:32:29 How does that work?
1:32:32 And it really boils down to a series of revenues versus expenses.
1:32:38 So the revenues needed to operate the system,
1:32:42 need to grow by 2.79%.
1:32:46 The $291,000 is represented of expenditures.
1:32:52 And that money that we put in there last year
1:32:55 was actually far greater than what we needed to move forward.
1:32:59 And so that's why you're looking almost at two things.
1:33:02 Remember, 2.79% is the revenue function.
1:33:07 The decrease of $200,000 is the expense function, and we want to try to make sure that revenues
1:33:15 equal expenses had revenues equal expenses last year, we'd still need 2.79%.
1:33:22 So one of the main causes is that we're looking at, we shifted obviously sanitation from the
1:33:28 planning, from, we shifted code enforcement from sanitation to the planning and zoning,
1:33:34 That is a cause for some of the increases associated with the transfers because we want
1:33:39 to make sure that those staff rents truly represent those costs.
1:33:43 And then also we wanted to make sure that we were right sizing those budgets.
1:33:48 And so we continue to go in there.
1:33:50 We want to make sure that the actual expenditures are representative of the expenditures and
1:33:54 that's why you see a decrease.
1:33:56 But the revenues needed to support the total level of expenditures of $2,630,000 require
1:34:03 us to raise rates by 2.79%. Clear as mud, right? Remember, it's just a one's a
1:34:10 revenue, one's an expense, and if you look at it, it's like, how does that work? And
1:34:15 that's really got to be explanation.
1:34:17 Any questions? Any that he's done for tonight? One last wrap-up question that's
1:34:27 pertains to our meeting with Commissioner Yuri last week. Do you envision
1:34:33 any changes in how we notice contractors, demo contractors on how to dispose of their
1:34:44 waste and to make sure that they're not dumped in as the allegations stated city or vacant
1:34:50 property.
1:34:51 So we've had conversations with Fritz and correct me if I'm wrong Fritz but we're under
1:34:57 not necessarily an obligation to enforce the county's code.
1:35:01 But what we are going to do is we are going to provide information to our customers who
1:35:07 pull a building or demolition permit.
1:35:10 We will share what the county code is with them so that they have a better understanding
1:35:14 of the rules and regulations that they have to follow.
1:35:18 And so in our conversation with Commissioner Yuri shortly thereafter, we met with Fred Smith
1:35:23 and I talked about the development of an informational piece and we think that's pretty easy to do.
1:35:28 And as I recall, that demo of materials to be transferred to HUB view, as opposed to the
1:35:35 solar plan or disposed of in any other place that the commissioner was concerned about.
1:35:41 Yeah.
1:35:42 Thank you.
1:35:43 So you know, additional, I think we're, I'd take a few, if I try to switch you up something
1:35:48 else.
1:35:49 So just to kind of give a preview of what happens next, if you thought that this presentation was
1:35:56 slightly shorter. Next week is the first eight pages. And so if you bring this, I
1:36:02 don't have to print out this again. It will be really literally the eight pages
1:36:06 and we will do our part in conserving paper, but yet the same time it will be
1:36:12 more of a general. This is where the budget stands. We will also be in a
1:36:16 position to report on the parking lots and some strategies that we have. It is
1:36:20 are meeting to have a conversation about the fuel efficiencies of the SUVs versus the other
1:36:28 cars.
1:36:29 And so the meeting is designed on the 29th, they're going to be a catch-all to cover those
1:36:34 pieces of questions that you've asked.
1:36:37 And then it's really more driven by the council in terms of questions that you might have on
1:36:43 other parts of the budget.
1:36:44 Like always, if you have questions now, please feed those to us so that we can be better
1:36:49 prepared to respond. That was a big help to us. The other thing is on the 5th of August
1:36:58 is when we will have a public hearing. That public hearing is going to really describe
1:37:03 the rate adjustments that we recommended in the budget. There is only one public hearing
1:37:08 that we have to have a conversation about and that is the sewer fund because it is increasing
1:37:13 more than that 5% as a result of the citizens approval of the bond.
1:37:21 We've asked that the council keep flexible on the 12th because we feel that there probably
1:37:25 will not be a quorum on that evening and that on the 19th we will come back, we will hold a
1:37:32 public hearing at 6 o'clock on the budget.
1:37:35 You will adopt the final budget.
1:37:37 Let me back up one step on the 5th.
1:37:39 The fifth is that meeting where you will create that maximum spending.
1:37:44 You'll adopt the preliminary budget.
1:37:46 From that point forward, you can't increase the budget.
1:37:49 You can only drive that budget down.
1:37:52 So that kind of gives an idea of the next four weeks of the budget conversation for this
1:37:59 fiscal year.
1:38:00 Rebecca, I'll select it.
1:38:02 Thank you, Mayor.
1:38:03 So you asked us to feed you some questions.
1:38:05 So I was actually going to hold the questions for the catch-all, but I'd like to just kind
1:38:11 of ask two simple questions.
1:38:14 One is under the capital highlights for the parks on page 27.
1:38:20 There's $10,000 for landscape improvements examining low-water use alternatives.
1:38:25 At the pool.
1:38:26 Yeah, at the pool.
1:38:27 So I was just wondering if someone could come talk about that and exactly.
1:38:31 That would be great.
1:38:33 The other question I had was on the impact fee section, I'm not sure what page it's on,
1:38:37 but in the summary, there's really no anticipated revenues in that section or are there for the
1:38:46 impact fees.
1:38:47 So what the impact fees are collected for very specific purposes, they're outlined within,
1:38:55 they're described as part of the comp plan and they're part of the overall improvements
1:39:01 that need to be made as associated with community growth.
1:39:04 There is considerable dollars that are in the impact fee.
1:39:08 One of the things that we do is we ask the impact fee advisory committee
1:39:13 to share with us which projects in moving forward in terms of funding.
1:39:17 And we have a traffic signal for $392,000.
1:39:23 I believe that's the traffic signal at Fillmore
1:39:25 that's being constructed this year.
1:39:27 And we've talked about that as meeting the warrants.
1:39:31 There aren't no intended or proposed impact fee projects for fiscal year 2014.
1:39:39 Okay, so you will continue to collect the impact fees.
1:39:42 It's just there's nothing written there because it's not intended to be used.
1:39:47 There's no proposed expenditures for fiscal year 14, that's correct.
1:39:52 Thank you.
1:39:53 All right.
1:39:54 Thank you, Travis.
1:39:55 I think we can, we might be able to wrap this up,
1:39:58 but if we, are you done?
1:39:59 I should say.
1:40:00 I think it's fine.
1:40:01 If you have no further questions.
1:40:03 I have no further likes.
1:40:04 I'm just getting past my self-imposed 6.30.
1:40:07 As we just have a few, just some public info left.
1:40:11 I hope we can make it to that, then have a break.
1:40:13 I think we're going to be able to do that.
1:40:16 Yeah.
1:40:17 You think that there's going to be some public info?
1:40:23 Only if I only give them two minutes, or good luck with that.
1:40:26 All right, we'll take a five-minute break then.
1:40:29 Let's be right was please be back within five minutes so we can all time it. I'll be the timer
1:40:52 The next item on the agenda is public input
1:40:56 Start out with the we usually do it this sort of city manager. Do you have anything additional to add tonight?
1:41:01 I do mr. Mayor members of the council we have two events that we want to spotlight and bring to your attention
1:41:08 I'll only do one.
1:41:13 I believe Vice Mayor Don Hall would like to do the other.
1:41:17 But on Wednesday evening, it's an opportunity to really fellowship and share time with our city employees.
1:41:26 Those on the front lines, the city picnic is going to be at Candy Cane Park.
1:41:31 Starting at five o'clock on Wednesday, we encourage the council to attend.
1:41:35 I'll defer the other one to Vice Mayor Hall.
1:41:37 I can wait for our turn.
1:41:42 He's done.
1:41:43 City manager's done.
1:41:44 Council?
1:41:45 Go ahead, Doug.
1:41:46 Well, I would just want to highlight the third annual National Night Out.
1:41:52 This is a yearly event that our wonderful police department has put together to really highlight some of their services who will be in attendance.
1:42:01 It's tomorrow night from five to eight City Park, and who will be in attendance where all
1:42:07 of our really cute and sexy things like SWAT and bomb squad and traffic team and bike team
1:42:13 and crime lab and all those folks, but we also will have the St. Luke's Paramedics, Safe
1:42:18 Kids, Boys and Girls Club, as well as the phenomenal College of Southern Idaho law enforcement program
1:42:25 will be highlighting their program out there as well.
1:42:29 Oh, hot dogs and drinks and snacks will be provided.
1:42:33 So bring your kids,
1:42:34 because I'm going to be bringing mine.
1:42:37 And Target, thank you, Jim.
1:42:38 Target will be hosting this again.
1:42:40 They've done this for three years with us.
1:42:44 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:42:46 Okay, I have three quick things.
1:42:48 First of all, I would like to remind the council
1:42:51 that we were invited to the municipal band's annual
1:42:55 picnic on August 1st at six o'clock.
1:42:57 And they meet on the south side of the park, I believe.
1:43:02 So I just wanted to make sure everybody got their invitations.
1:43:05 Secondly, while we're being aired,
1:43:07 I would like to invite everybody with children
1:43:09 next Monday morning at 1030 to the public library.
1:43:12 I get to be the guest reader for rhyme time.
1:43:15 So bring your kids and we're gonna have a good time.
1:43:18 And lastly, going back to Rebecca's question earlier,
1:43:23 last week I had the honor of being the welcoming committee
1:43:26 for the City of Twin Falls and hosting an MCing,
1:43:30 the first time to Twin Falls,
1:43:32 the International Summer Festival.
1:43:35 They've been in Idaho for 30 years
1:43:37 and they've never come to Twin before.
1:43:39 And we had dancers and musicians
1:43:42 and singers from China, South Korea and Israel.
1:43:46 Along with that, the Rocky Top cloggers performed.
1:43:49 And it was a fun night at Canyon Ridge High School.
1:43:52 Part of the event they asked if we could do
1:43:55 a gift exchange with them.
1:43:56 So, on behalf of the mayor, we got all kinds of goodies.
1:44:02 Well, we just should tell us what we gave them.
1:44:04 What did we give them?
1:44:05 Where did you get it at?
1:44:07 We did do our shopping at the visitor center, yes.
1:44:10 And the young lady working there was very helpful, by the way.
1:44:13 And we did coffee mugs that had the prying bridge on them
1:44:16 with all the facts, the height, the length, so that they had that.
1:44:20 And then we did posters of Shishone Falls,
1:44:24 because earlier that day they too were Shishone Falls.
1:44:26 So it meant something to them.
1:44:28 So each country did receive those from China.
1:44:32 Got a beautiful set of chopsticks.
1:44:35 I'll just pass those down.
1:44:37 So where do they end up in?
1:44:40 We don't have a cafeteria so we can't be there.
1:44:43 We're going to have a beautiful display here somewhere, right?
1:44:45 So from Israel, we got a banner with a postcard
1:44:49 and a lapel pen.
1:44:52 And while I'm thinking about it, too, a lot of the performers
1:44:55 who were as young as nine years old.
1:44:57 The oldest there was 40.
1:44:58 They did have a girl from China
1:45:01 who did an operatic solo that was really neat.
1:45:04 The South Korean kids did a lot with drums.
1:45:06 So it was just a unique night.
1:45:09 And then from South Korea, this is called the Korean masks.
1:45:14 And so that was our good for now.
1:45:17 And thank you for letting me go.
1:45:19 It was a really good evening.
1:45:21 Oh, in addition to that,
1:45:24 I would like to mention that La Fiesta, tomatoes, and Chick-fil-A donated the meals for all the performers.
1:45:31 So thank you to our businesses who help support our community as well.
1:45:35 Well, thank you for representing the city of this function, and well, this is heavy.
1:45:42 That's going to take a bigger meal, but that'll be awesome.
1:45:46 Wow, okay, so, cool.
1:45:49 Thank you, Suzanne, for representing this.
1:45:53 Thank you, Madam Mayor.
1:45:55 Thank you, Mayor.
1:45:56 I wanted to report on the fire department.
1:45:58 This week they participated in paint magic and they finished up recoding someone's house in the community with paint and cleaning it up and sprucing it up.
1:46:09 So I just wanted you to know that that is something that they've done on an annual basis.
1:46:14 And it really demonstrates our motto of people serving people.
1:46:18 And so I'm very proud of the fire department for doing that.
1:46:21 And they were literally helping their neighbor.
1:46:24 I think the house was a few blocks down from the station,
1:46:27 the station that's connected to city halls.
1:46:28 So I appreciate that and wanted everyone to know
1:46:32 that they're out there serving the community.
1:46:34 Thank you, Rebecca.
1:46:36 See, no others, anyone in the public
1:46:38 have something they would like to cover,
1:46:41 something we didn't cover in a tonight's meeting?
1:46:44 All right, what?
1:46:46 The eyes are wrong, but you know, you don't want to meet.
1:46:50 It's too close to the way out of it, let's just do this.
1:46:54 I can only get one name down, apparently.
1:46:55 Yes, what would you like to talk to us about?
1:46:57 We usually try to limit these conversations, but go for it.
1:47:01 What is my time frame?
1:47:04 Well, is there anyone else that plans to speak?
1:47:07 I guess that would be the question I have.
1:47:08 So I'll give you five minutes.
1:47:10 Five minutes?
1:47:11 Can I negotiate 10 minutes?
1:47:14 Well, it's one of the things we usually want to give, too.
1:47:17 So five is already a two and a half.
1:47:19 Well, I'm going to assume that you all click on the link that I sent to your email in regards
1:47:25 to the Idaho mainstream program, and so we'll keep it at five minutes if you actually went
1:47:30 on that link.
1:47:31 Leah, could you introduce yourself, tell us where-
1:47:35 My name is Leah Babbain, and I'm a citizen here in Twin Falls.
1:47:39 I'm also a business owner in downtown Twin Falls, and so I'll pick up from, I'll try
1:47:45 to do this as quick as possible.
1:47:49 So Idaho Main Street Program, it's a state level for the National Main Street Program.
1:47:56 The goals are pretty easy.
1:47:58 They're economical, political, aesthetics, and also promotion of local downtowns.
1:48:06 So I'm just going to read you a couple things quickly, and I want to stay within that five-minute
1:48:12 time frame.
1:48:15 So the Idaho Main Street Program is a state level entity that promotes and assists local
1:48:21 communities in Idaho, downtown communities, of various sizes to promote and revitalize their
1:48:29 efforts in revitalizing their downtown.
1:48:33 The key function is to coordinate, assist, and deliver technical services, help find local
1:48:39 services and also train the participants to reach that goal.
1:48:46 The underlying premise of the main street program and the approach is to sum up the
1:48:51 program's goals and encourage economic development within the context of also historic preservation.
1:49:00 So it's a balancing act.
1:49:02 The approach advocates a return to the community's self-reliance, empowerment, and the rebuilding
1:49:08 of commercial districts based on traditional assets,
1:49:11 unique architecture, personal services,
1:49:14 local ownership, and a sense of community.
1:49:17 It is exactly what we need here downtown,
1:49:19 and it's exactly what we're missing,
1:49:21 and it's also exactly what we have been working on
1:49:24 on a merchant level down there.
1:49:28 It's not designated to tackle on big issues
1:49:31 of the entire community, the only focus of it
1:49:33 is the revitalization of the central business district,
1:49:39 And it does take into account that a healthy heart of the city economically is also an attractive
1:49:46 downtown is important to the whole community's overall health and vitality.
1:49:52 So Main Street, this program, Main Street program throughout the United States, it has
1:49:57 a very strong reputation for utilizing modest resources, expending local economics, and
1:50:03 strengthening the community's pride.
1:50:05 These actions provide the inspiration that attracts additional involvement and participation
1:50:12 from further investments.
1:50:14 So there's a four-point approach, organization, promotion, design, and economic restructuring.
1:50:22 I'm going to hurry along into kind of addressing some of the things, so organization helps to
1:50:29 provide effective ongoing management and advocacy for the downtown.
1:50:34 the governing board of directors, standing committees.
1:50:38 So this is in theory what we are looking to then
1:50:41 better form through this program.
1:50:44 The governing bodies and committees
1:50:46 make up the fundamental organization structure
1:50:49 of a volunteer-driven revitalization program.
1:50:55 It also builds senses and cooperation
1:50:57 among all the different stakeholders.
1:51:00 The promotion is to then promote a positive image,
1:51:03 Kindle, Communities Pride, and improved consumer and investor confidence in the commercial district.
1:51:10 The design part of it is getting Main Street to its top physical shape and create a sense of a safe, inviting environment for shoppers, workers and visitors.
1:51:22 And again, that does go on conside with pride, a downtown pride and morale public.
1:51:30 So it also helps locate the assets, the historic assets that are already there and drive public
1:51:38 and private interest towards those areas to improve buildings, storefronts, signs, public
1:51:44 spaces, parking areas, street furniture, public art, landscape, everything that we are needing
1:51:52 and missing and working towards and then the fourth, the fourth tier is economic restructuring.
1:52:00 So this part of it is, this part of it is, um, he's adjusting your time. That's why I'm
1:52:08 grinning. What's my timeline? You've got about 30 seconds left, but we gave you another
1:52:12 minute. Okay. Thank you. I appreciate it. This is it. This is important stuff right here.
1:52:17 So another minute earned is good. Well, the other one, the, the point I said, we, we, we,
1:52:23 We had you had information already, you had already passed it, or we were hoping that you're moving forward to what you need.
1:52:30 Okay.
1:52:31 So, well, all right.
1:52:33 So what we need is we have an application here, it's ready.
1:52:36 This application is accurate.
1:52:38 It is accurate because we went to each place that is downtown, either if they were there or we have there in the data.
1:52:47 who is what type of business and what's missing, what area is vacant, what's not vacant, commercial, residential.
1:52:53 We also went off of what's historic information available to the public, also with the city.
1:53:00 We called off the different places in the city to try to get number statistics.
1:53:04 And so the application itself can be reviewed, but we basically need you to endorse it.
1:53:12 We need the mayor to sign on it and at the same time hopefully you guys sent in your letters
1:53:19 and if you haven't sent in your letters the end of today is the deadline for this as long
1:53:24 as it's in the mail or digitally sent in and in the mail first thing in the morning we meet
1:53:31 the deadline for them to consider Twin Falls as a pilot project for this main street program.
1:53:38 So the state is still adopting it and working out the details.
1:53:42 So we do have a lot of room for also providing more information upon the review.
1:53:49 And so basically what I'm asking for is for you guys to review it and to sign it and support
1:53:54 this initiative in order for us to be considered for the Idaho Main Street Project.
1:54:03 Yeah, I do have a lot of lights on up here.
1:54:06 So I will, and those don't count towards your time, all right.
1:54:10 Perfect.
1:54:10 That's a lot of questions so I can fill in the rest of the information.
1:54:13 Don Hall.
1:54:15 I'm not sure what we're signing.
1:54:18 What do you want us to serve?
1:54:20 What are we going after?
1:54:22 I kind of understand that it supports downtown,
1:54:26 and we all support downtown.
1:54:27 But what are we signing?
1:54:29 OK.
1:54:29 So what you're signing is the basic first step
1:54:33 of the merchants collectively applying to be considered
1:54:41 for this program on a state level?
1:54:43 What is the program?
1:54:44 OK.
1:54:45 Very good.
1:54:45 Good question.
1:54:46 So there are four levels that a downtown in Idaho
1:54:50 can qualify in its level 1, level 2, level 3, level 4.
1:54:57 And is the projector working?
1:54:59 I can show you.
1:55:03 So they're getting it ready for you anyway?
1:55:05 Okay, I can tell you, level one is basically the lowest
1:55:10 of the lowest of vital downtown you can imagine.
1:55:15 So, we've all lived here long enough time
1:55:18 to kind of know when downtown has been
1:55:20 at what points or what peaks.
1:55:22 So, if you think of downtown two to three years ago
1:55:27 where businesses were pulling out,
1:55:29 buildings were abandoned, distressed,
1:55:32 the economy down there was really suffering,
1:55:34 foot traffic was not something you'd see on a regular basis. So that would be a level one.
1:55:41 And also on an organized level, it would also be a level one because the ID kind of dismembered.
1:55:48 There was no organized efforts. There were no consistent meetings being done or events
1:55:54 being promoted at that time. So the level one category is a very, very
1:56:01 of assistance downtown.
1:56:03 Okay, let me stop you.
1:56:04 So level one is this real need,
1:56:07 but what is it?
1:56:08 I mean, what's coming out?
1:56:10 It's an accreditation?
1:56:12 Right.
1:56:13 What does that do for us?
1:56:14 Okay, so what happens is you apply for a level
1:56:17 depending on how much you've already done
1:56:19 and what you qualify for.
1:56:21 So the requirements, so I'm gonna skip to level three
1:56:24 because our downtown, whether you know it or not,
1:56:28 is at a level three.
1:56:29 And this is because we, as of beginning of this year,
1:56:34 this all, the efforts began last year,
1:56:35 but as of beginning of this year,
1:56:37 let's say the six, seven months,
1:56:39 we have merchant collective meetings on a regular basis.
1:56:42 The numbers vary, but they're on a regular basis,
1:56:45 events that we're working on and promoting.
1:56:48 We have a non-profit form, so we can,
1:56:50 that's the level three requirement is non-profit,
1:56:53 as far as the business part of it.
1:56:55 The difference between a level three
1:56:59 And a level four is a full time or part time paid position.
1:57:04 Okay, that's the only major thing.
1:57:06 Everything else on a level three can be either already met
1:57:12 as a requirement or it can be a working towards status.
1:57:16 So for example, we do not have an official board
1:57:19 of directors because we've just chosen so far not to.
1:57:24 Our next meeting will have committee leaders for certain different committees within the
1:57:32 function of the group and then we'll delegate and redesign those committees as certain issues
1:57:38 or events come to the table.
1:57:41 But as far as having like a president and vice, we decided to steer away from that.
1:57:45 Because you have to understand, we're working with a very raw environment there still.
1:57:50 There's a lot of history, there's a lot of people that are skeptical still or unsure
1:57:56 if they want to join on an effort, but the need is there.
1:58:00 And not only is the need there, the need is for the whole City of Twin Falls.
1:58:05 Our clients at this point, maybe two years ago, there's like a normal healing period
1:58:13 when anything changes.
1:58:16 So let's say the downtown had this divorce and there's this trauma from BID, okay?
1:58:21 So there's this healing period that's appropriate and then it gets to the point where you're
1:58:25 like, all right, let's start, you know, we still have work to do.
1:58:28 So that happened maybe last year.
1:58:30 At this point our clients expect us our business traffic down there, the people that support
1:58:37 and shop downtown, they expect us to be responsible and to form an organized group and to work
1:58:44 as a unit.
1:58:45 This program would really assist that because it basically does exactly that.
1:58:49 It helps organize.
1:58:52 It doesn't solve anything.
1:58:53 It helps you as leaders, not you as leaders, us downtown as leaders, put all of our tools
1:59:00 together, pull all of our resources together, get training when we're lacking training and
1:59:07 move as an organ, as a big downtown family.
1:59:12 So get back to level three.
1:59:16 The non-profit was the major point that is different from level two to level three for
1:59:21 a downtown.
1:59:24 An adequate operating budget, paid professional, participation in training, leadership training
1:59:29 for downtown is all a work, either a work in progress or working towards or committing
1:59:36 to, that's the pending status that is required in order to qualify for the level two.
1:59:43 three. And so that's what we're applying for is for a level three acceptance into this program.
1:59:53 With hopes that it will challenge us and that we will meet the level four requirements in
2:00:03 one to two years and then be certified under the Main Street program, which is kind of the
2:00:09 graduation point for a Main Street.
2:00:12 Okay, we got a couple other questions here, so we're you're applying to be at level three and then maybe these questions will cover
2:00:18 It's all the way to mine. I think we're back with first and then okay
2:00:22 Thank you just two quick questions one. How can we get a copy to review your application? Okay, and
2:00:30 So that if we choose to support it we can send the letter by this evening
2:00:34 And then my second question is what does the certification gain for you? Is it funding?
2:00:40 is it a set amount of funding? Is there funding attached to this? I know Jerry Miller is with
2:00:45 the Department of Commerce. So what does the certification do for you? For downtown?
2:00:52 Okay, that's a good question. It's not so much a funding, it's not really a request for funding,
2:01:03 it's a request for a program that works, a manual that works, a handbook that works for
2:01:09 or downtowns throughout the United States
2:01:11 that have been hit by a plunging economy.
2:01:13 And everybody knows with anything kind of like that,
2:01:18 with the economy getting the hit like that,
2:01:21 the local downtowns usually suffer first,
2:01:24 because they are the Malan pop shops,
2:01:26 and they are day-to-day operations,
2:01:30 measure and matter a lot more
2:01:34 than I guess the big stores that can tap into a bigger
2:01:39 budget and keep stores afloat.
2:01:41 So anyways, this program is more like a handbook, it's to be accepted into this template that
2:01:48 has worked in other places in the United States of different types of downtowns that have
2:01:54 suffered from the same backlash of economical difficulties.
2:01:59 And so what we would be asking, what we're requesting for is for them to consider us
2:02:03 to get into the program and then what we would be receiving is all this guidance and support
2:02:11 and knowledge and help with connecting resources in ways that perhaps day to day business owners
2:02:17 don't know how to so we would do is there a cost for that or the cost is okay just get
2:02:25 it for free.
2:02:26 So the participant rates are assessed depending on the population of the community participation
2:02:31 Participation rates for cities 2000 and under a population will pay a minimum of $1,000 cities above 2,000
2:02:40 Pay five cents per person based on the community's population or a maximum of 2,500
2:02:46 So you're asking the city to pay this no I'm asking the city to I if the city
2:02:53 endorses and signs
2:02:55 the mayor if the mayor in the city signs and gives us a chance to
2:03:01 be considered in this program. We will do the footwork. We will raise the funds. We're not asking you guys for funds.
2:03:07 So far in the last six months, we have raised, well, most of the months except for January, we have raised $600 collectively to do collective marketing.
2:03:18 And the collective marketing has been grassroots, merchant to merchant level, collect the money in order to promote downtown as a destination.
2:03:28 Now, for our own selfish needs to promote just my business, but to promote the neighboring
2:03:33 businesses, recognizing the integration and how everyone is connected down there, even though
2:03:40 it's a two to three or four block proximity.
2:03:43 And so, yeah, we're not asking you guys for funding.
2:03:47 We will work on the funding.
2:03:49 We can raise the funding ourselves, and we've kind of proven that to each other by doing
2:03:55 it already.
2:03:56 I mean, those are little numbers compared to how much downtown merchants are dishing out
2:04:00 for events or for any other marketing that they're doing.
2:04:05 You were asking me about, okay, services provided the Main Street communities based on
2:04:12 a level of participation.
2:04:14 So there's initial visits and assessments done by the Commerce staff so that they can
2:04:19 come down here and really evaluate the community's needs and know what exactly is best fitted
2:04:25 for the better impact that community.
2:04:29 Then there's continual visits, so kind of evaluations and making sure that we're doing
2:04:34 what we need to do as merchants and leaders down here in order to keep the goal and the
2:04:40 ends in sight.
2:04:44 Main Street 101 training sessions, these are sessions that the staff of the program
2:04:50 or the specialist will provide us in order for us to kind of gain more knowledge on what
2:04:57 we can do in the areas of organization, design, promotion, and economic restructuring.
2:05:03 So the program itself provides all this.
2:05:07 Assistance and hiring a downtown manager down the line.
2:05:10 So a year or two from now, if we go from a level three to a level three and a half or
2:05:16 level three, you know, 75, they will start working with us in order to hire a part-time
2:05:22 or a full-time manager so that there is someone that is overlooking the rest of the committees
2:05:30 that are working, making sure that the work is done.
2:05:34 Program manager development, develop a mission and a vision statement, board rules, responsibility
2:05:41 training, committee training, develop a first-year work plan for downtown.
2:05:45 This is what they will do since we don't have that right now.
2:05:50 So this program is to fill the gaps of where you are and where you need to be.
2:05:56 And sometimes it's hard for us as full-time business owners and full-time human beings
2:06:01 and mothers and whatever else people are doing that are working down there to do this to fill
2:06:07 the gaps.
2:06:08 We do as much as we can, but there does need to be an over, I guess, an oversight of what's
2:06:17 happening and so that it is more uniformed and more effective.
2:06:22 They will provide us with assistance in forming a non-profit corporation, which they don't need
2:06:27 to do that because we've already, that's been done before even my time.
2:06:33 That's part of Old Town's Incorporated Parent Branch.
2:06:36 So that's been done and a lot of the activities that you'll see downtown and a lot of the sponsorships
2:06:41 that are asked for downtown events, they channeled through that nonprofit status in order to get
2:06:48 better marketing and also be a little more efficient with funding.
2:06:54 So there's three to five year work plans.
2:06:56 Once you are accepted into the program, there's resource team visits, telephone consultation,
2:07:03 technical assistance, year-end program assessment, which
2:07:06 done at the end of every year, membership
2:07:09 into the national mainstream program.
2:07:11 And that's, I believe, after you are officially
2:07:14 a graduate of it at the end of level three.
2:07:18 Training sessions is an ongoing thing
2:07:20 that they'll provide to local volunteers, board members,
2:07:24 leaders in the community, and even merchants.
2:07:26 So this isn't just for merchants, but it's
2:07:28 for anybody that's invested in the downtown area.
2:07:31 Before I forget, I don't want to take up any more of your time.
2:07:34 Oh, we have more questions.
2:07:35 OK, OK.
2:07:37 Ask me more questions because I don't want to forget
2:07:39 and let you know that I do have the application.
2:07:41 I can send you all so copies of it via email.
2:07:45 And yeah, what's your question?
2:07:49 Just talking to me.
2:07:51 I assure you that the city councils for at least 30 years
2:07:56 have been wanting to accomplish what you're trying to do now.
2:07:59 Everything from hiring consultants for hundreds of thousands
2:08:02 dollars to formation of the business improvement district. There have always been problems of
2:08:09 participation in some people pulling more than their weight and others not. But I have no
2:08:16 problem with the concept as I've read it and as you've explained it, I would just draw
2:08:21 the line that we cannot or I would not endorse anything that obligates the city for expenditure
2:08:27 of public monies. That said, if it's looking just for an endorsement of the body of representing
2:08:34 Twin Falls, the city council, I would authorize mayor to sign it right now. Okay.
2:08:40 Can we ask our lawyer first? Can I answer? Chris, that's what's pretty awesome about this
2:08:51 program is that it takes government out where it doesn't need to be to begin with. I think
2:08:57 the downtown area, it's been pretty evident that it needs to function on its own. Like
2:09:04 other districts, they have to be organized from bottom up. There's only so much that
2:09:11 a government should do. I'm not even going to say could do, because I last, I checked or
2:09:18 remember the United States government doesn't facilitate or shouldn't facilitate with business
2:09:23 or organizing or associations or anything like that that's outside of public allocation
2:09:31 of funding.
2:09:33 So the downtown area does need to, it puts the responsibility even in the funding part
2:09:38 of it into the hands of the people that are down there.
2:09:43 And community members, citizens if they wish to, like volunteers, but for the most part
2:09:49 it does. It takes the role of the city government out. Now if there's, I can't
2:09:56 answer that fully without saying if there is a resource that the city obviously can't
2:10:01 provide or networking that the city obviously can help make better for us
2:10:06 merchants downtown. So if someone, you know, there's relationships that need to be
2:10:11 bridged and worked on and so if the city is asked for cooperation in that form,
2:10:18 that's just normal business. I mean that would happen even without this program.
2:10:22 If someone from downtown had an issue and needed to come here and say we would
2:10:26 like cooperation in this or endorsement of this or the city to advocate for us or
2:10:34 you know if there was anything like that we would do that anyways. Doesn't need to
2:10:38 be under this program in order for that dialogue to occur.
2:10:41 I mean to keep moving on the questions. Okay. So first of all I commend you and
2:10:47 the efforts of everyone downtown because I think, as Chris said, this is what everybody
2:10:54 has hoped and dreamed and hopefully will not have to open dream about some more to happen.
2:10:59 However, I do have a couple of questions related to these specifics of the application before
2:11:04 I'm super comfortable signing off on it.
2:11:07 So you're talking about a level three application, correct?
2:11:11 Yes.
2:11:12 So that talks about having things like
2:11:17 a adequate operating budget and non-profit status.
2:11:22 So you said you're sort of living under the Old Town
2:11:27 non-profit, Old Town Incorporated non-profit
2:11:30 that does or doesn't have a board of directors.
2:11:34 It does.
2:11:35 Pretty loose one though,
2:11:37 because it's been a pretty inactive group for a while.
2:11:40 Okay, so the quick history on it is-
2:11:43 I know the history, but I want to know what it is today.
2:11:46 Because this application is saying we have a non-profit.
2:11:48 Right, so to answer your first part of your question,
2:11:51 as far as an operating budget in a non-profit status.
2:11:57 Under level three, and I don't know if you're looking at it,
2:12:00 or not, under level three it says working towards.
2:12:04 So the non-profit status is established.
2:12:08 It's been in working established condition over the last years.
2:12:13 So one example of that is the Twin Falls tonight that many of you know about that has been going
2:12:20 on for the last several years down there.
2:12:22 The funding for that, the umbrella for that is the same nonprofit that I'm talking about
2:12:28 and referring to.
2:12:29 Right.
2:12:30 So my concern though is so if you back up to level two, in my opinion, what you're talking
2:12:35 about right now is a Level 2 application.
2:12:38 You're talking about a commitment to using the Main Street approach, but having not yet
2:12:44 developed all of the resources needed to meet most or some of the 10 national accreditation
2:12:49 standards such as developing broad-based support.
2:12:53 I think you've done that, an adequate operating budget and nonprofit status.
2:12:58 And I'm just telling you from experience downtown, you don't want to get so far down the road
2:13:04 on this that it isn't successful because you're going to take 10 steps back if it's not.
2:13:11 What I'm saying is I am more than happy to be supportive of this but I want to make sure
2:13:15 that it's jumping in at the right level so as not to get in over your head.
2:13:21 And again, to me an adequate operating budget isn't we have successful events and they pay
2:13:27 for themselves.
2:13:28 An adequate operating budget is if your goal is to have a main street manager, what's that
2:13:33 going to cost and what's your overhead for an office and those kinds of things and of
2:13:39 course I haven't seen the application but I'm struggling a bit with this being this far
2:13:46 down the road with this. Sure and I can respect that because you do have the experience so
2:13:54 level three is work towards completion of a non-profit organization or form an independent
2:14:00 nonprofit organization which we have already, we have that done. It's
2:14:05 check marked as of years ago. It's done. Maybe it's a resource that has not been
2:14:10 properly used but so far not only the events but even promotions, the website,
2:14:18 anything that's happening down there is happening under that nonprofit status.
2:14:23 Okay and then as far as paid professional commit to or already higher
2:14:29 And level three, that's what it's talking about, but that is what the program is there to help get you to.
2:14:36 So one of the things that I want to mention is change is something that is going to have to be seen more of a challenge in this program.
2:14:46 So the changes will have to also be challenges.
2:14:50 And the attitude and the practices, they'll have to all change.
2:14:54 And part of that is to set yourself towards goals.
2:14:58 So if we set ourselves into a level two, and most of that has already been accomplished,
2:15:04 then what we're doing is just going backwards.
2:15:08 Level three gives us aim to go forward and work on things.
2:15:13 And just to give you a little bit of perspective, when I spoke to Jerry Miller
2:15:19 about this program to just get a better idea of it and
2:15:23 and told him what is going on currently and told him what has not happened
2:15:29 He also recommended that we apply for a level three and so and that's him, you know recommending it from
2:15:38 His white scope and understanding of this program and what it could potentially do for what we have down here
2:15:46 Did that answer
2:15:48 Yeah, I appreciate your response, but I'm going to respectfully disagree with you because it
2:15:55 talks about these 10 standards of performance.
2:15:59 Has broad-paced community support, so I believe you have that one.
2:16:02 Has a developed vision and mission statement relevant to community conditions and to the
2:16:06 local Main Street programs organizational state?
2:16:10 Has a comprehensive Main Street work plan?
2:16:14 Possess a historic preservation ethic, I would agree that that exists.
2:16:19 as an active board of directors and committees,
2:16:22 as an adequate operating budget,
2:16:24 has a paid professional executive director.
2:16:26 And again, it says level two is some or most of these.
2:16:30 So in my mind, not having three or four of 10 is some.
2:16:35 And again, I just don't want to,
2:16:38 I just don't want to, I'm looking at the 10
2:16:41 performance standards that it talks about
2:16:44 for local main street programs.
2:16:45 So, I understand applying for participation in the program, I understand the support that
2:16:53 the state can give.
2:16:54 I just don't want to jump into it at a point where we're not.
2:16:58 So my response to that, respectively, would be that even the city is working on certain
2:17:03 master plans, but it still doesn't hinder the progress and the development, and that's
2:17:09 what this program is supposed to do.
2:17:11 It's held assistance with the development, with the progress.
2:17:14 It's not, you know, you match these things and you check mark these things and you are
2:17:20 level three.
2:17:21 It's asking, are you working towards it?
2:17:24 Are you, is there effort there?
2:17:26 Is it working?
2:17:29 And I mean, you could, I'm sure agree with me that the downtown today and the downtown
2:17:36 exact date today of last year is different.
2:17:40 different and not only is it different visually and also commercially, but it's
2:17:46 changing in many ways and that needs to be fostered and nurtured and there's only
2:17:53 so much that the merchants can do on their own. So instead of going backwards I
2:17:57 really encourage you guys to help us go forward. I understand what
2:18:03 you're saying that there needs to be more. There needs to be more
2:18:08 organization on our behalf before we could maybe apply for something bigger or
2:18:15 whatever, but we're trying and there's only so much that the downtown merchants
2:18:20 can do without assistance. There's only so much that three individuals or four
2:18:26 individuals or six individuals can do to try to save this thing that was really
2:18:32 in despair several years ago and today you go down there and people that have
2:18:36 never been down here would never even know or believe if we told them how how it was years ago.
2:18:44 On the paper that I have in front of me, I know what you're reading to me, the guidelines,
2:18:47 but on the paper I have in front of me and I can put on the projector, but all of the things you mentioned,
2:18:53 the wording under them is work towards commit majority, meaning majority complete, work towards
2:19:02 majority, and a lot of it is a progress measure, it's not a check mark, it's more they want
2:19:12 to know what progress has been done.
2:19:15 Active Board and committees work towards completion.
2:19:20 Like I said, we've had meetings since the beginning of the year, we have minutes, we
2:19:25 try to keep them as formal without actually forming an organization that then requires
2:19:30 us to do work under a certain limited variety, I guess.
2:19:36 Can we get some more?
2:19:40 Travis, Travis has a common, I have a lot of lights on up here.
2:19:44 And this five minutes has become 45, and so we need to keep moving here if we can.
2:19:50 Travis, did you have a common?
2:19:52 I apologize for taking up so much time, but if it's five minutes for every 30 years that
2:19:57 nothing's been done down there, I think we're pretty good.
2:20:01 I think the concern we're having here is that we're all getting hit fairly cold with this
2:20:06 This is a type of thing that would normally need to be scheduled weeks in advance beyond the budget be on our agenda
2:20:11 Okay, have staff input
2:20:14 Is it we're not used to being hit with things last minute? We that makes us all very nervous. Okay, I understand that
2:20:21 So mr. Mayor members of the council one of the things it asks on page four is that
2:20:32 that in it reads, as the representative of the local governing body of Twin Falls, I hereby
2:20:44 certify that the information and the application is accurate and correct, signed by the chief
2:20:50 elected official.
2:20:51 It is, I've glanced through the application, and in all fairness, there is no way that
2:21:04 And I can advise you that the information in here is correct.
2:21:08 In fact, I can probably point out a couple of places that might not be significant changes,
2:21:15 but there are a few inaccuracies.
2:21:22 Here's the challenge.
2:21:24 We have a group of citizens that want to do something and they're passionate about making
2:21:30 improvements in downtown.
2:21:34 And you never want to do anything that dampens, that fire, or that enthusiasm.
2:21:44 And I really appreciate that.
2:21:47 At the same time, and Pritz and I have had a couple of, we can't advise you to sign a document
2:21:56 that has not been reviewed for its accuracy by staff.
2:22:03 And we want to.
2:22:06 We want to be able to say this sounds like a great opportunity.
2:22:11 I don't understand fully the different layers and levels of requirements that are needed
2:22:18 for the certifications and what that means for us as an organization, yet at the same
2:22:30 time I don't want to do anything to dampen the enthusiasm.
2:22:34 So that's really the rock and the hard spot that we're finding ourselves in.
2:22:40 We're happy to do what we think, what we're able to do, we're just in a bit of a struggle
2:22:52 here.
2:22:54 So most of the information, there's opinion questions on there that are based on the merchant's
2:23:01 reality, that are not, there's no way to measure if you try to measure it through the city because
2:23:09 there's a disconnect of what's going on down there and what's measured.
2:23:13 So the information that's on there, the numbers, the stuff that is accurate, because I got it
2:23:19 from city employees, city agencies, directed by Melinda Anderson, directed, I was directed
2:23:27 where to look, directed, she confirmed some of the information for me, Mr. Baxter, Kelly
2:23:33 Weeks.
2:23:34 These are the people that as of last week have been working on this, and even if they did
2:23:38 not have an answer, they would direct me to the right place to have an answer.
2:23:42 I've got their emails, I've got whatever it is that is needed to prove that the information
2:23:48 is on their accurate.
2:23:49 Now unless the Idaho Census has the wrong information for 2010, for 2000, well then that's
2:24:01 the information that's on there.
2:24:04 We call planning and zoning.
2:24:05 We, Sarah Taylor here, went by foot to look and see and count the buildings and the vacancies
2:24:13 that even planning and zoning and city employees have no idea about it because no one's down
2:24:17 there taking the measure.
2:24:19 So that information that's on that application is far as the statistics for what is downtown
2:24:27 and what buildings are down there, that's probably more accurate than what the city could
2:24:32 to provide for today in 2013, because there's not anybody
2:24:38 down there that's measuring these things.
2:24:40 And if there are, then I'm very surprised,
2:24:42 because I pretty much called every employee,
2:24:45 and it seems like nobody knew, in planning and zoning,
2:24:50 in Twin Paul City, so I'm surprised, or the manager's
2:24:55 office, so I'm surprised if we did not
2:24:57 locate the correct information, then I'm really curious
2:25:00 to know who I'm supposed to ask for that information.
2:25:04 How about I hit some lights before I get back to you Travis
2:25:06 when we move this along.
2:25:08 Rebecca, we'll slide here like it was next.
2:25:10 Oh, thank you.
2:25:12 Yes, I just wanted to say that I certainly
2:25:14 want to support the application.
2:25:17 And is there some sort of room on the deadline?
2:25:21 Because I do think it's important for us
2:25:23 to have staff review at half our lawyer review
2:25:26 and make sure we know what we're signing.
2:25:28 So, I certainly support this effort and I don't blame you.
2:25:34 I understand how, you know, it says public input
2:25:36 at the end of our meetings and so there's nothing
2:25:38 that should tell you you had to schedule ahead
2:25:41 or get on the agenda.
2:25:42 So, I think that's fine.
2:25:43 I think what we're struggling with maybe is the timeline
2:25:46 of needing to send it tomorrow, but we do need time
2:25:50 for staff review and to talk about it.
2:25:52 And so, maybe we, if it's possible, I'm not familiar
2:25:56 with the program deadlines, but maybe we can put it on a future agenda and apply after and
2:26:03 support and sign after we've done that.
2:26:05 That would be 18 months from now, 12 to 18 months from now, that that would happen.
2:26:10 Just to clarify, because I don't want to give you the wrong impression that I'm a person
2:26:13 that's not prepared.
2:26:15 About four months ago, Melinda Anderson brought this program to my attention.
2:26:20 I never heard of it.
2:26:21 And if anything, I would think you guys would hear about it before I would, because it's
2:26:25 It's a national program, the state's adopting it, so I figured somebody would hear about
2:26:29 it and it would come up in conversation.
2:26:31 I didn't hear about it until Melinda brought it to my attention.
2:26:34 At that point at one of our meetings, I brought it up and I said, we should consider this,
2:26:39 we should apply for this, okay?
2:26:40 We would have plenty of time to do it.
2:26:43 At that meeting, a person told me and assured me that we already applied for this program,
2:26:50 and so I figured that human knows a little more.
2:26:53 been doing these things a little more and either because of miscommunication or
2:26:59 whatever other personal thing that could have occurred there in that meeting, it
2:27:05 obviously was not done. Was it done? And I don't think you're not prepared at all.
2:27:11 I just know that we've the staff letters were sent in. I just know that
2:27:16 we're not at a point where we can or I'm not at a point where I can sign so
2:27:19 but I don't, that doesn't reflect on you at all and I'm sorry if I'm really asked that
2:27:23 to help me, you point out to me the areas that are not accurate, that I can go back to the people that
2:27:30 provided that information to myself and to Sarah who we've kind of been working on this
2:27:36 as a collaborative effort and that way we can validate either why the information was not accurate or
2:27:43 where to find the right information. So that would help. The application is due,
2:27:48 I mean, that's nothing that I can work with, I don't think.
2:27:53 Now, maybe as City Council, you could connect with Jerry Miller and ask for a couple of
2:28:00 day extension, and that way we could be a little more accurate.
2:28:04 And perhaps because they're also working on their end of it being, you know, it's a test project.
2:28:10 They are not fully adopted. They're still working on it. They're still things that they're trying to smooth out.
2:28:15 So, with that understanding, perhaps they will give us a two or three or five day, whatever
2:28:22 is the minimum time frame.
2:28:26 So that, I mean, that part I think more up to you guys, you could maybe advocate, could
2:28:31 begin by advocating for us to get an extension.
2:28:35 I could also contact him, I'd been in dialogue with him all day just to kind of give him
2:28:40 current on what's happening.
2:28:42 So we could try.
2:28:45 Let's go through these other lights here and then we'll see what our options might be as Suzanne Hawkins.
2:28:50 I too support what you're trying to do, but you know even from the original email I'm looking that you sent I got left off that email.
2:28:58 And so you know I haven't had access to this and I've noticed that people you sent it to are no longer on City Council or City staff.
2:29:08 So that worries me that those kind of mistakes are here,
2:29:11 and yet you're so certain that there aren't mistakes
2:29:14 in the application, just to be honest.
2:29:17 So from my point of view, I would definitely, you know,
2:29:21 need time to go through it.
2:29:22 But for me, this is something I had no idea
2:29:24 because I was left off the email.
2:29:26 So I've had no chance to prepare for this at all,
2:29:29 and I can't endorse something I don't know.
2:29:32 I'm sorry.
2:29:32 Well, I kind of thought that, you know,
2:29:34 your colleagues would either forward it to you
2:29:36 or get it to the right people.
2:29:37 They did late.
2:29:38 And the person that was sent in email.
2:29:39 It's not their job though.
2:29:40 You're the one trying to do this.
2:29:41 The person that was sent the email that is no longer on the council is still a community
2:29:45 asset to the community and could still write a letter in.
2:29:48 There are people on that email list that are non-accountable.
2:29:50 But I think it's important that you hit all the council members when you're trying to
2:29:53 get our support on something that, you know, that's-
2:29:56 No, ma'am.
2:29:57 Oh, thank you.
2:29:58 First of all, I'm kind of like Suzanne here, I don't, I saw an email from you wanting me
2:30:05 to sign a letter that's a letter like that. I have been listening to all of this. I cannot,
2:30:13 I won't support signing your application until I've had a chance to review it. If your deadline
2:30:19 is today, then you're not going to get my support, period. If we can't advocate, we can,
2:30:26 but get a couple days extension, I don't even know if that's reasonable or not. You're asking
2:30:31 is to do something, asking me to do something that I am absolutely not comfortable with,
2:30:37 okay? That's the bottom line here. So I guess I'll make a motion that, I don't even know
2:30:44 if we need a motion, right? Oh, okay. Then I guess I can't support you.
2:30:49 Don't know. Leah, as my former DARE student, I just want to tell you that I'm very proud
2:30:55 of you. Would you've done with your business, how strong of an advocate you are from downtown?
2:31:00 always have them and how strong of a person you are. So I appreciate you bringing this
2:31:08 to us. You bring it to us with passion. I share Travis's challenge with we have a diligence,
2:31:16 a due diligence that we need to hold up here without trying to temper your enthusiasm. But
2:31:23 you know I'm struggling here too. This is the first relay that we've seen it and diving
2:31:28 into it. I know that what you put in there and what Sarah's worked on, you've done your
2:31:33 best in a limited amount of time and maybe there was some miscommunication and with City
2:31:39 Staff or whoever that was. But it's only coming to us tonight and for me personally I guess
2:31:46 I'm just going to talk about me. I can't support it until I have my City Staff that are experts
2:31:52 and trained and educated to look at these kind of things, review it and then with my own understanding
2:31:57 review it as well, so that I can buy off. I mean, I have to, when I put my signature on
2:32:03 something, I believe in it, and I believe that it's accurate and all those things. Again, that's
2:32:08 not a reflection on you. You've done the best you can and limited amount of time, okay? So
2:32:13 I appreciate what you've done, but again, I just can't. Now, if we can advocate for an
2:32:18 extension, I certainly would like to see us do that. But tonight, I can't do it.
2:32:23 And not only that, but I want you to understand the difficulty in gathering the information that is needed for this application.
2:32:31 I understand.
2:32:32 And it's not even, almost not even available, you have to go and get it, you have to go and track it yourself, you have to call people and find out what type of business they are, where they are, or they relocated.
2:32:47 Do they have someone living above them?
2:32:49 do they have someone doing something
2:32:50 in the basement of the building?
2:32:51 It is the owner from here, it's the owner from out of town.
2:32:55 There's only so much that can be measured,
2:32:58 and especially since, in Twin Falls,
2:33:00 I don't think every business needs a functioning license
2:33:03 to have a business, so it's hard to really account
2:33:08 for everybody that's in that area.
2:33:11 So I'm not gonna waste any more of your time.
2:33:14 But the fact that this was in this communication
2:33:19 And it became a last minute effort,
2:33:22 should explain to you how much of assistance
2:33:25 we need down there.
2:33:27 So I'm not discouraged by the fact
2:33:32 that you guys can't sign it.
2:33:34 I mean, that's details.
2:33:35 That's legal details.
2:33:36 I understand that.
2:33:37 I wouldn't sign something that I didn't feel 100% about either.
2:33:41 But at the same time, I hope that there
2:33:43 are steps that we can do.
2:33:45 Mr. Munn, you said you got the email
2:33:47 and you're just hearing about this for the first time,
2:33:50 but the link I sent to you guys,
2:33:52 you could have updated yourself, found out more,
2:33:55 and if your area had information that could help
2:33:58 or provide me with the information I did for the application.
2:34:01 Wrong answer.
2:34:02 Wrong answer, okay?
2:34:04 I'm not gonna sit here and argue with you about this, okay?
2:34:06 I think we've been very, very patient with you
2:34:08 in regards to this matter,
2:34:09 and I do appreciate your enthusiasm,
2:34:12 but don't put this back on me, okay?
2:34:14 Well, I'm not for a second.
2:34:16 Everyone has a responsibility.
2:34:18 A citizen has a responsibility and then a person that
2:34:21 is in a certain position also has a responsibility
2:34:24 to help, to guide, to provide the right information.
2:34:27 I'm not arguing with you, but we all
2:34:28 have a responsibility to do what we need to do in regards
2:34:32 to this kind of process.
2:34:33 So I would like some guidance from you guys.
2:34:36 I would like to know what information needs to be accurate.
2:34:39 And if you could point me in the right direction,
2:34:41 I will do the footwork, try to get us an extension and hopefully get this on the agenda and see
2:34:48 what else we can do.
2:34:50 I think my biggest concern and maybe different together because I looked at your email and
2:34:54 I did do the link things.
2:34:56 I hadn't seen the application and then just getting the application denied is my biggest
2:35:01 concern.
2:35:02 I certainly support what you're trying to do.
2:35:04 I want to sign it.
2:35:06 I want to sign it but I'm certainly not going to sign it without support of my counsel and
2:35:10 And I can't sign it until one my attorney is signed off on it and one my staff is signed
2:35:16 off and said it's accurate.
2:35:17 Okay.
2:35:18 So who do you advise I work with?
2:35:20 Who do you advise?
2:35:21 I would have heard that the application has to go to the attorney before I can sign it.
2:35:27 Well first of all you need to get an extension as far out as you can.
2:35:30 Okay.
2:35:31 And not five days, like a month of 60 days, that's just the process, speed that we work
2:35:35 through.
2:35:36 Right.
2:35:37 will be full steam ahead and you'll have most of the work done for next year if
2:35:43 application is accurate and approved by both of them will you guys sign it the
2:35:49 next meeting if we can get the extension sure I will anyway I will say yes okay
2:35:55 I'll have to read it and consider that okay I'll do the work I mean this is all
2:35:59 my time this is all my volunteer work I'll do it I'm committed I'm committed to
2:36:04 of the city I'm committed to downtown. It's not my passion. Trust me, I'm a young and energetic
2:36:12 and a pretty girl. There's a lot of other things I'd rather be doing than working on
2:36:15 this kind of stuff. But I am passionate about this area and the downtown area. So thank
2:36:21 you for listening to my presentation. I'm pretty much hearing the same thing. If we
2:36:27 by off by the, you get an extension, which is,
2:36:30 I assume it's gonna be tough to do.
2:36:32 And we can certainly provide the information
2:36:35 that we would like an invitation.
2:36:38 I'll certainly sign that though,
2:36:39 we would ask for the extension.
2:36:42 And then if we have by off by our city manager
2:36:45 and our city attorney,
2:36:47 then I would be willing to support sign it.
2:36:49 But we're a different system of government here
2:36:52 in Twin Falls than most cities.
2:36:53 I don't have the same powers that the city of Kimberly has,
2:36:56 as far as the mayor.
2:36:57 If I said the mayor, I might just walk down there
2:36:59 and sign it, be done with it.
2:37:01 But I have to have support from this group
2:37:03 before I'm gonna be signing anything.
2:37:04 Of course.
2:37:06 Also, I would advise you to work with Travis.
2:37:08 I mean, he is our city manager.
2:37:09 And so, you know, I understand that you are going
2:37:11 to the different departments.
2:37:13 And that actually might help clarify
2:37:15 some of the miscommunications is definitely
2:37:17 whenever we have a citizen bringing an initiative,
2:37:20 we always have them work with Travis
2:37:21 and he can coordinate and also he can make you aware
2:37:24 of any information or limiting factors,
2:37:29 so that it's not frustrating to you,
2:37:31 and so that you get the correct information.
2:37:34 Yeah, this is, not at all, it has been frustrating.
2:37:37 I think anything, it's really given me
2:37:39 a better perspective on the many resources and assets
2:37:45 that are here, that are the missing pieces,
2:37:48 they're not connected, or there's a lack of communication
2:37:52 or transparency in certain things,
2:37:54 But there's definitely a richness here that is available
2:37:58 and can be connected and nurtured.
2:38:00 And I hope that that is the future of not only downtown,
2:38:03 but all the areas in this town that need a little boost
2:38:07 and need a little better progress.
2:38:10 All right.
2:38:11 Thank you.
2:38:12 Thank you.
2:38:13 Moving on to the next item, which is the executive section,
2:38:17 67-2345-1 F and also 67-2345-1 E, move approval, move into it.
2:38:24 Seconded by John Hall to move in the executive session for those two items.
2:38:34 Seeing the lights of the other roll call vote.
2:38:36 Susan Hawkins.
2:38:37 Yes.
2:38:38 Greg Lanting.
2:38:39 Jim Mon.
2:38:40 Rebecca Milsoka.
2:38:41 Yes.
2:38:42 Chris Tockington.
2:38:43 Sean Berger.
2:38:44 Yes.
2:38:45 motion passes seven to zero we're adjourned to executive session
Download
- Transcript (text) 154 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 206 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 282 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.2 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 16.3 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, July 22, 2013. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:39:04.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
de7675138573838b6356347e16a6d4266b1d69ff90e18dc5a1685cb5db33d0b1 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a c064935c4ebd00c93bbf931a14a6826b82981db5798f49c0c362951589e34c85
part02.m4a 26fc32e37945638f0a73d2909ccd1c22a2607a09ec29d989f1fdd6cd662e96f5 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
e406c0a1e6f19c2545225fe17f556bc30bbabf08d006cd1885ff9692a43b80aa
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file