City Council meeting
Monday, October 7, 2013
Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:00:51 I'd like to call the meeting of the
0:02:08 The Twin Falls City Council to order today is October 7, 2013, and welcome to everyone.
0:02:15 For those of you wishing to join us, please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance.
0:02:18 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:02:38 Thank you all and welcome again to our City Council meeting.
0:02:42 Rebecca Milsuk, has her light on it.
0:02:45 Thank you, Mayor.
0:02:46 I just wanted to announce a group of ladies that we have in the audience tonight.
0:02:50 They are international exchange students, primarily from Eastern Europe and Western and Eastern
0:02:57 Europe.
0:02:58 And they are on an exchange program with a scholarship from their government.
0:03:03 And so as part of that requirement, they are to meet with their local leaders and learn
0:03:08 about the local government here.
0:03:09 And so I just wanted to welcome them to our meeting tonight.
0:03:13 Thank you. We're back again on behalf of the City of Twin Falls. Welcome. And if you have any questions, please let us
0:03:21 Next item on the agenda
0:03:22 We always want to confirm that we do have a quorum and we have six members of the council here this evening our mayor is out of town
0:03:31 Travis Rothwiler our city manager. Do we have any amendments to the agenda?
0:03:36 There are no amendments this evening. Thank you, sir, and there are no proclamation
0:03:40 So we'll move into the consent calendar before we get into the consent calendar
0:03:44 I do have a quick question, I don't think we need to pull it off the agenda, but I don't see Troy Vitec here.
0:03:52 Oh, there he is.
0:03:53 Troy, I have a real quick question on number four.
0:03:56 It's consideration to request to accept a three-year stage deferral of payment or paving for a business.
0:04:04 The only question I have, it makes sense to me, but how do we ensure that this third of it every year,
0:04:12 for three years, is actually going to be done?
0:04:14 What's the mechanism there?
0:04:16 I guess we kind of use a lot of trust in this.
0:04:19 The developer come forward.
0:04:21 It's an opportunity for him to go and complete his business
0:04:26 and not have an exacerbated on site.
0:04:30 It's a thing about city code.
0:04:32 And so he is asked, there's an opportunity for him
0:04:36 to defer and stage over three years.
0:04:38 He's proposed a solution.
0:04:40 I guess we could put on one of our tasks to do
0:04:43 to make sure he's keeping up with this commitment on that end,
0:04:46 but I guess our repercussions would be in the future,
0:04:50 you wouldn't be able to obtain the thought of building permit.
0:04:53 It's also a special use permit, which I believe
0:04:55 has the right to come before the PNC be removed.
0:05:02 I know similar things have come up like this in the past,
0:05:05 and we've always kind of asked,
0:05:08 is there any kind of a tickler file of some sort
0:05:11 to make sure that folks are doing what they say
0:05:14 they're going to do, or they're just kind of out there.
0:05:18 So I don't know if anybody else can answer that question,
0:05:20 or have we given that more thought?
0:05:33 Good evening.
0:05:34 So once again, we're on a spot where you
0:05:42 know that I advocate for GIS, and I do that,
0:05:44 so that you can have data attached to a map,
0:05:47 and you can have things like deferrals attached to a parcel.
0:05:51 So you can find that when people are
0:05:54 trying to pull a building permit, you can actually look at the information associated
0:05:58 with the land.
0:05:59 You can get all kinds of handy things like reversements, deferrals, you know, whether or
0:06:04 not it's a non-conforming structure or a non-conforming lot or, you know, all kinds of handy pieces
0:06:10 of information that help you deal with the permit.
0:06:14 The other mechanism that we have is that we record those deferrals and so they show up
0:06:19 as an obligation that's associated with the land
0:06:24 so that the obligation travels with the land.
0:06:30 And then we remove them, you write letters to remove them
0:06:33 when the obligation is fulfilled.
0:06:34 So this gentleman, for instance,
0:06:37 is trying to run a business that has no intention of moving.
0:06:40 If he did, he would want to clear the deferral on the land.
0:06:47 In the GIS, would it pop up when due dates are due?
0:06:52 so that we could have some kind of compliance check.
0:06:55 It is possible.
0:06:58 So we haven't actually arrived at the place where we said that we want that to occur.
0:07:03 Okay.
0:07:04 Do you think that's a good idea?
0:07:07 Sure.
0:07:08 So, you know, there's always a fine balance between enforcement actions, you know, at the request
0:07:18 by complaint and enforcement attitudes because of the right thing to do.
0:07:23 Right.
0:07:24 Okay, we try to wait gracefully through that and for everyone at home swatching. This was Jackie Fields our city engineer
0:07:31 I apologize. No, no sweat. All right. Thank you
0:07:35 Council do you have any other questions and or is there a motion?
0:07:39 From you about the consent calendar
0:07:41 Sean Barretter move approval of the consent calendar second that we have a motion on floor by Sean Barreger
0:07:47 seconded by Chris talking tend to approve the consent calendar anything further on
0:07:53 that motion council I see no lights the island roll call vote please Suzanne
0:07:58 Hawkins yes Greg Lantine I'm sorry Jim on yes Rebecca mainsuica yes
0:08:06 Chris talking to us Sean Berriger yes Don Hall yes motion passes 6 to 0 we're
0:08:15 moving down to items for consideration.
0:08:17 The first item on the agenda is consideration of a request
0:08:21 to present a certificate of appreciation to Darryl Buffalo
0:08:25 in recognition of his service on the Twin Falls Historic
0:08:28 Preservation Committee.
0:08:30 And I think Mitch is going to start this,
0:08:32 but turn it over to Randall Watson, our chairperson.
0:08:37 Yeah, the chairman of the historic preservation commission
0:08:39 asked if he could come and make this presentation.
0:08:41 So I'm going to just step aside and let Randall come up
0:08:43 and talk to you all.
0:08:44 very good. Thank you. Mr. Watson, welcome.
0:08:50 Thank you. I'm Randall Watson.
0:08:52 Darryl recently resigned due to a conflict with one of his
0:08:58 schedule, but we'd like to give him a certificate of
0:09:03 appreciation. Darryl is a man of many talents, and
0:09:08 historic preservation is one of them. He has a vast
0:09:12 of preservation of buildings along with historical aspects.
0:09:17 Since my involvement on the commission, Darryl has led and
0:09:21 mentored the other members by serving as chairman, helped secure a grant to publish
0:09:27 historic preservation guidelines for the warehouse district, organized historic
0:09:33 walking tours, developed a five year plan to establish guidelines for
0:09:39 three other historic districts such as the City Park,
0:09:44 and is continually sinking grants
0:09:46 to preserve the history of Twin Falls.
0:09:50 The biggest thing that Darryl does
0:09:52 is to make historic preservation
0:09:55 a positive experience for the people
0:09:58 in the city of Twin Falls.
0:10:01 We'd like to thank Darryl.
0:10:03 If we could have Darryl come up.
0:10:29 Give it one second.
0:10:35 I appreciate it.
0:10:36 This is really an honor to get this.
0:10:38 It's pretty good and honored to serve.
0:10:40 I know when I first joined the commission about four and a half years ago, Mr. Talkington was
0:10:44 my mentor that really got the enthusiasm and excitement going and just a lot of funds, good
0:10:50 commission.
0:10:51 I'd really like to compliment the City Commission for Wood and the City Council for your support
0:10:55 of the historic preservation.
0:10:56 We know that the preservation of our cultural history is really something that means a lot
0:11:02 to people, even though they don't often express it, but if the tours we've had and people
0:11:06 talking to us about various places in the history of Twin
0:11:09 Falls.
0:11:10 You know that it's a deep rooted love of this community, which
0:11:13 is obvious.
0:11:15 A funny experience we had two years ago,
0:11:16 and we had the walking tour, and the tour of the grain
0:11:20 site was down there.
0:11:21 We had the Eastern Idaho Railroad that provided all
0:11:24 local boaters out there just about exploded, I guess,
0:11:26 to tell you that's tour-y, but there's a phase of a blowup
0:11:29 like Tommy got there.
0:11:30 But it was a lot of fun to have them come,
0:11:32 because they did not understand the history of the
0:11:34 the railroads of the community and the executive director of the Eastern Idaho Railroad thanked
0:11:40 us. In fact, we got a national letter from the National Corporation of Waco thanking us
0:11:44 for what we get and allowing him to be part of it. Because the railroad is a major, major
0:11:48 part of this community. It developed as a result of it coming through in 1905. So, anyway, just
0:11:54 a lot of fun things like that that come up that people now are learning to enjoy. That's
0:11:59 the mission of the historical preservation commission. It's not just the preservation of
0:12:03 the historical warehouse district, but to preserve the history of the entire city.
0:12:07 And that's the vision they have now, and there's a great commission of seven people
0:12:10 down there now. You couldn't get better seven than seven. And there's a new member
0:12:14 going to join tonight and on French her resume, and it's going to be a great addition to the commission.
0:12:18 And so I just like to thank you for what you're doing to the community.
0:12:21 I'm not out of it yet. I'm down as an interested citizen.
0:12:24 I'm still going to be very much involved in it that way. So I thank you very much.
0:12:28 Thank you. Thank you.
0:12:30 Chris Stocky.
0:12:35 Well, Daryl, our time we spent together in the historic preservation convinced me that
0:12:40 you don't need to have a bunch of old homegrown fogies to show what we need to preserve.
0:12:45 Your influence coming from out of town from Pocatello actually was a real incentive for
0:12:50 us to see things a bit different.
0:12:52 And having lived in Pocatello, I had the right to say this.
0:12:55 I think you're the best thing to ever come out of Pocatello.
0:12:58 I just want to reiterate that I'm the liaison currently to the historic preservation committee
0:13:07 and it's been a pleasure working with Darryl there.
0:13:10 He's always given 110 percent.
0:13:12 So we really appreciate you Darryl and you're not off the hook.
0:13:15 We're going to hook you some other way.
0:13:17 So we appreciate you.
0:13:19 Moving now to the next item on the agenda which is consideration of a request to appoint
0:13:24 Kerry Hall to the Twin Falls City Historic Preservation Committee. Again, Mitch Humboldt.
0:13:29 So I'd like to thank Darryl for stealing my thunder just now. But we do have what Darryl's
0:13:35 resignation, a vacancy on the Historic Preservation Commission. You know, we had three vacancies
0:13:41 back in July, you'll all recall, and we had eight applicants for three positions. And
0:13:45 so we were struggling when I say we I wasn't really on that committee, but I've heard the
0:13:50 right? Don, you were on that committee and my understanding was there was eight really
0:13:56 well-qualified good people for these three positions and it's a shame that you can't
0:14:01 just appoint all eight of them. Well we have an opportunity to go back and grab one
0:14:05 more from that pile. That's what we decided to do since we had those recent
0:14:08 applications. Went back to our vacancies from July and we picked one more from
0:14:13 that group and that individuals Kerry Hall, her resumes in the package and I
0:14:18 I would like to recommend that we appoint Carrie Hall for,
0:14:21 I think it's a two year deal, right?
0:14:23 So to July 1st of 2015, she would fill out the remainder
0:14:27 of Darryl's term.
0:14:30 At that point, she'd be eligible for a couple
0:14:31 of full terms of her own.
0:14:33 So with that, we make that recommendation,
0:14:37 certainly willing to answer questions you might have.
0:14:40 And Carrie's here, by the way, too.
0:14:41 So if you want to wave, Carrie.
0:14:44 Why don't we have Carrie come up?
0:14:45 If you wouldn't mind, just share with us just for a moment.
0:14:50 Welcome.
0:14:51 Hi.
0:14:52 So it was brought to my attention that this position was open.
0:14:57 And back when the first round of applications
0:15:00 went through, we were being considered for adopting.
0:15:04 And so I wasn't able to make it.
0:15:05 I was very thankful that the opportunity came up again.
0:15:09 I'm really excited to be on this committee.
0:15:11 I'm really excited to work with everyone and learn as I go.
0:15:15 And I'm excited about preserving the character of our community.
0:15:20 Come on.
0:15:21 Appreciate that.
0:15:22 Any questions?
0:15:23 Well, do you have a certain perspective you bring to the job carry?
0:15:28 Or how long have you been in Twin Falls area?
0:15:30 I've lived here 13 years.
0:15:32 And what is it that strikes you about missing or needs pushed?
0:15:37 Give us an idea what your personal bias might be.
0:15:40 I come from Seattle and I love the history here.
0:15:45 year. I love the buildings. I love the community mindedness. I love the idea of
0:15:51 the walking tours and things of that nature really getting people excited
0:15:55 about what this community has to offer. Thank you.
0:16:01 Susanne. I'm ready to make a motion. Let's do it. I move that we appoint Carrie
0:16:06 Hall to finish out the two-year term left that Darryl's vacating effective
0:16:11 We have a motion on four by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Sean Berrigger.
0:16:20 Is there any further on this motion, Councilor?
0:16:24 The aye, roll call vote, please.
0:16:26 Jim?
0:16:27 Yes.
0:16:28 Rebecca Milsoyka?
0:16:29 Yes.
0:16:30 Chris Talkington?
0:16:31 Yes.
0:16:32 Sean Berrigger?
0:16:33 Yes.
0:16:34 Don Hall?
0:16:35 Yes.
0:16:36 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:16:37 Yes.
0:16:38 Motion passes, six to zero.
0:16:39 And Kerry, welcome aboard.
0:16:40 Look forward to serving with you.
0:16:42 to the next item on the agenda. Number three looks a little familiar to us, but
0:16:46 consideration of a request to award a contract for installation of a traffic
0:16:51 signal at Fillmore Street and North College Road to balanced rock electric in
0:16:55 the amount of 351,711 dollars and we have our esteemed city engineer Jackie Fields.
0:17:03 Good evening. Tonight with us are the engineer of record Joel
0:17:11 ground. He is the individual from precision engineering that designed the plants and also
0:17:18 Sean from Ballast Rock this year as well. So the signal at Fillmore and North College
0:17:32 has become necessary as a result of growth in the area. And we budgeted $392,000 to address
0:17:43 this project in the budget last year.
0:17:47 So that includes survey, design, construction.
0:17:54 So that is a number that I typically use $400,000.
0:18:00 It's a good rule of thumb and it deals with any kind
0:18:02 of width consideration, any really weird things
0:18:05 that are going underground or typical to manage.
0:18:10 And it also addresses, it ends up being a fairly stable
0:18:14 that number usually once that number has been exceeded.
0:18:20 And that's it.
0:18:22 So it provides a good boundary number
0:18:25 for being able to accomplish the job.
0:18:30 This job was designed as a signal only
0:18:32 without major whitening.
0:18:34 I did not plan or estimate to acquire
0:18:39 the landscaping strips and portions of the parking
0:18:41 and stormwater retention off of the adjacent properties.
0:18:46 I believe that the capacity challenge that exists at that intersection can be addressed
0:18:53 with the signal.
0:18:58 And then when we bid the job, we had one bidder, and that bidder was balanced rocket
0:19:02 electric.
0:19:03 They've been producing signals in this area for years.
0:19:06 They maintain our system and have an awareness of the types of needs that we have, and any
0:19:13 training.
0:19:14 Mike doesn't need very much training, but you know, any training needs that we might
0:19:19 have based on changes in the equipment, let's see. There aren't a tremendous number of close
0:19:33 contractors that install signals. So, with that being said, when Joel produced an estimate,
0:19:39 an engineer's estimate that was substantially different than what I planned for the budget
0:19:43 of the job, I accepted that because I know that he sees that price. He has seen that price
0:19:51 in the Twin Falls area during the construction of the St. Luke's Hospital, and he sees that
0:19:55 price in Boise. So our goal was to attempt to have the job award in the last fiscal year
0:20:08 to avoid a budget amendment, which probably isn't that big deal, but more so to actually
0:20:14 get the project to go under construction and to be built before winter. We had a conversation
0:20:22 was balance rock electric and they still believe that they can accomplish the work this fall.
0:20:30 But our window is like really tight at this point in time.
0:20:34 That's not here nor there.
0:20:38 We believe that he has a responsive bin and I think that's really all I have to add to
0:20:50 the conversation or the monologue at this point in time.
0:20:54 So staff's request is that the council authorized the mayor
0:20:58 to sign the contract for the installation of the traffic
0:21:01 signal at Fillmore North College to balance
0:21:03 rock electric in the amount of $351,711.
0:21:09 And we are here to answer other questions, you may have.
0:21:14 Thank you, Jackie.
0:21:14 Chris, talking to you.
0:21:16 Jackie, I was the culprit that suggested we table this.
0:21:20 I don't know what the questions other council had,
0:21:22 but minor specifically, you don't think it's short-sighted
0:21:26 by not pursuing additional right-of-way acquisition
0:21:31 at this time.
0:21:32 I mean, five years from now, if we have to come back
0:21:34 and readjust the thing, we're all going to look like fools.
0:21:38 You think that's going to be at or near capacity
0:21:42 without the call for additional widening.
0:21:48 That's my first question.
0:21:49 Okay, so when we install a signal
0:21:59 that kind of changes the way the road's gonna behave.
0:22:04 So I believe that, and I try not to do anything,
0:22:09 when I'm gonna have to come back and do it again.
0:22:11 It's an endless search of frustration to me
0:22:13 that I have to touch any section or road
0:22:15 or any piece of project more than once.
0:22:18 It's, so I honestly believed,
0:22:22 even with the projections for the traffic load,
0:22:25 But that intersection would function in its current configuration, and function as well
0:22:35 as a signalized intersection is going to function.
0:22:38 So we may end up in a spot in our future where a right turn may is handy, but we have
0:22:44 many places where it doesn't exist and our intersection still function according to the
0:22:52 level of service that were after, you know, A and B.
0:22:56 Thank you. The second question had to do with only having one competitive bed is not that
0:23:02 unusual, but the 40% discrepancy. Rather just caught up my throat on the thing because usually
0:23:09 the engineers estimates are within a few percent. I think you explained why, but maybe the best
0:23:16 way to do it is to reference the last similar intersection, do you recall what the cost was
0:23:22 on that was a closer to 250 or 350.
0:23:28 It was closer to 350, it was on a state highway,
0:23:32 and you know, and the road was a little wider.
0:23:36 We had some signals done in 2008.
0:23:40 Associated with St. Luke's, the electrical contractor was
0:23:44 at the location, those were closer to 250.
0:23:48 The conduit was already in on the state highway underneath the concrete.
0:23:52 The market was beginning to take, and so there were a lot of people looking for work.
0:24:00 We built a signal on I.T.E.
0:24:04 built a signal at on Blue Lakes and Orchard, and that was much closer to $400,000.
0:24:11 So we believe that the price would be a little bit lower than it is.
0:24:20 We also have been in conversation with Ballastrock Electric about entertaining some change orders
0:24:28 that will address some of the work that he wants to do and that will, for instance, John
0:24:35 wants to bore instead of excavate and that will address a fair part of the price differential.
0:24:44 Thanks.
0:24:45 So boring instead of excavating,
0:24:48 we'll also, there won't be disrupting the pavement
0:24:52 basically as well, right?
0:24:54 There'll be a little bit of pavement disruption
0:24:56 because we have some failing valley getter,
0:25:03 you know, and it's, we need to fix it, so.
0:25:06 But we won't be paving the whole intersection
0:25:08 at this point in time, and apparently,
0:25:10 we're going to be involved in a conversation
0:25:13 for mitigating trench width as well,
0:25:15 because Sean would like to bore you.
0:25:18 Excellent.
0:25:19 Appreciate your report.
0:25:20 Rebecca Mills, so I can.
0:25:22 Thank you, raise mayor.
0:25:24 A similar question to Councilman Talkington,
0:25:26 other than the boring and instead of excavating,
0:25:30 what about this project?
0:25:33 Do you think causes the cost difference above 350?
0:25:41 Well, the cost difference isn't above 350.
0:25:46 So I think it can drop a little bit.
0:25:50 Okay, so you're saying it'll drop from there?
0:25:51 Yes.
0:25:52 Okay.
0:25:53 I am not anticipating additional costs.
0:25:56 Okay.
0:25:56 In fact, I'd be shocked and horrified
0:25:58 if we had additional costs.
0:26:00 Okay.
0:26:01 So I think, you know, the bit set was pretty tight.
0:26:06 There were plenty of opportunities
0:26:10 to make sure that, you know, a cost could be covered.
0:26:15 You know, so sometimes we let jobs that are,
0:26:18 you know, we're missing some items, not on this one.
0:26:21 So the fact that it is above the engineer's estimate
0:26:25 doesn't alarm you and you feel confident
0:26:27 that it's a fair bit, that's accurate.
0:26:33 Okay, thank you.
0:26:37 Council, I see no further lights.
0:26:39 Stand for a motion.
0:26:41 Chris Talkington.
0:26:43 Precisely resurrected.
0:26:46 I don't know if we make a new motion after tabling.
0:26:49 What would you suggest best way of doing that?
0:26:53 I think a motion would be appropriate
0:26:55 then followed by a second and then you could move forward
0:26:58 with your normal course of debate,
0:27:01 should that choose followed by a vote
0:27:05 or an action taken on that item?
0:27:08 I'm not sure I understood that.
0:27:10 We don't have to do anything with the tabling,
0:27:12 just a new motion.
0:27:15 I would move to accept the low bid for the traffic signaling
0:27:21 at the North College Road and Fillmore intersection
0:27:25 in the amount not to exceed the bid price.
0:27:28 Is that it?
0:27:29 motion on floor by Chris talking in seconded by Jim Mon to accept the bid for the Fillmore
0:27:36 Street North College Road traffic signal installation not to exceed $351,711.2 balanced
0:27:49 Thank you.
0:27:50 Is there anything further on that motion council?
0:27:53 The aye.
0:27:55 The roll call vote, please.
0:27:56 Rebecca Milsoica.
0:27:57 Yes.
0:27:58 Chris Tawkins.
0:27:59 Yes.
0:28:00 Sean Berriger.
0:28:01 Yes.
0:28:02 Don Hall.
0:28:03 Yes.
0:28:04 Susan Hawkins.
0:28:05 Yes.
0:28:06 Jim Mann.
0:28:07 Yes.
0:28:08 Motion passes.
0:28:09 Six to zero.
0:28:10 Thank you, Jackie.
0:28:11 Thank you.
0:28:12 Moving to the next item on the agenda is a consideration of a request to approve a request for
0:28:17 qualification process in order to gather information for use in evaluating proposals related to
0:28:24 a proposed jump from city property across the Snake River Canyon, commemorating the 40th anniversary
0:28:32 of the attempt made by Evil Knievel in 1974.
0:28:36 And we have our city manager, Travis Rathweiler.
0:28:39 Welcome, Travis.
0:28:40 Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council.
0:28:42 About three weeks ago, we came before the council and we had a general conversation and at that
0:28:50 conversation we shared that the state was going to go through a formalized bidding process.
0:28:54 And as a part of that formalized bidding process, we wanted to have a conversation with the council
0:29:00 to see if there was any interest from the council in, even at some point, allowing for
0:29:06 the consideration, the use of our property to move forward with any type of a jump.
0:29:13 The council said at this point in time we would be interested in exploring what those
0:29:18 opportunities would look like and over that course of time from the time that we met with
0:29:26 the council through this evening, there has been a series of either large committees or
0:29:32 subcommittee meetings that have occurred and we've had a series of conversations and a lot
0:29:37 of that has been reported by local media outlets. And our, we started with some general philosophies
0:29:45 that we felt were very, very important and we think that we took that original guidance
0:29:50 number one from the council what we felt was important. Number one, we want to make sure
0:29:55 that this is a very safe event.
0:29:59 We want to make sure that public is safe.
0:30:03 The visitors who attend their safe,
0:30:06 that the individual who receives the right
0:30:09 to utilize city property and use that as a jump site,
0:30:13 is taking reasonable safety precautions.
0:30:16 And that as we move forward, we're
0:30:21 honoring our commitment to public health and public safety.
0:30:24 And so we've engaged the Police Department, the Fire Department, partners with EMS, and
0:30:29 we've even had a conversation, invited one of them from folks with the hospital.
0:30:34 The second is we want to make sure that the use of tax paying dollars is limited and only
0:30:43 spent when authorized by the City Council.
0:30:45 And I say limited because obviously with the amount of staff time that we've already invested
0:30:50 in this process, we are investing part of our effort and part of our day in that place.
0:30:54 process, but we do not are and we are not looking at this point to make any direct financial
0:31:01 allocation, whether that be through a direct contribution or an indirect contribution through
0:31:05 the use of our labor to serve whether the security or whatever those things look like.
0:31:11 So we want to make sure that our tax paying citizens are protected and that there is no financial
0:31:19 risk or burden placed on to them.
0:31:23 And then the third is we want to make sure, as a group,
0:31:26 as we've talked about, that our brand, our image,
0:31:29 those things that we hold dear about Twin Falls
0:31:32 is reasonably protected.
0:31:35 You know, this is our home.
0:31:36 This is a place that we live.
0:31:38 This is the place that we have chosen to raise our families.
0:31:42 This is the place that we're not going to leave
0:31:48 following an event, that at the end of the day,
0:31:51 we are going to continue to be here.
0:31:55 And Twin Falls has a tremendous amount of value
0:31:58 that we don't want to see necessarily cheapened by a process.
0:32:03 We also don't want to see anything horrific,
0:32:07 heaven forbid, occur that transforms the image
0:32:12 of what is Twin Falls today,
0:32:14 the vibrant, successful, well-run community,
0:32:19 a place of family values,
0:32:21 to being a place of a very different collection of memories.
0:32:25 Because I think that as it has been said,
0:32:28 we believe that this is going to be a well-tended, well-viewed
0:32:33 event.
0:32:34 There's a lot of interest.
0:32:36 Sean has shared, as we've had these conversations,
0:32:38 that one of the most frequent-asked questions
0:32:41 at the visitor center today is where did Evil Knievel jump from.
0:32:46 And obviously, there's a tremendous amount of interest
0:32:48 moving forward.
0:32:50 And there's a tremendous amount of interest
0:32:53 of making sure that we get it right.
0:32:56 And as we started having these conversations
0:32:59 and it was wrapped around maybe those three value sets,
0:33:03 we really recognized that we don't know a lot about this.
0:33:08 That we're not experts in all things related to this.
0:33:12 In fact, we found ourselves at times
0:33:15 wondering if we even knew what were the right questions
0:33:18 to ask.
0:33:20 And this is incredibly important that we get it right.
0:33:27 You know, you really don't get a second chance
0:33:28 if this thing goes wrong, right?
0:33:31 So what we've done is we felt in order to help us go forward
0:33:35 with a process and help us seek some of those answers
0:33:38 is that we would start seeking information
0:33:42 from other people.
0:33:43 And that is embodied in the request for qualifications
0:33:47 that is contained in your packet this evening.
0:33:50 we believe through this process,
0:33:52 we are going to be able to capture information
0:33:55 to help the committee that has been diligently working
0:34:00 on this project to be able to make a solid recommendation
0:34:05 to the council who will then be able to take
0:34:08 all of that information as they evaluate
0:34:12 possible applications to utilize city property
0:34:15 to move forward with a jump site.
0:34:18 You'll notice that we have some fairly quick turn
0:34:21 time table turn around and the reason that we have that is because we recognize that there
0:34:28 are timelines that have been imposed upon this process as well and so we're trying
0:34:33 to do what we can as fast as we can to educate ourselves on what this looks like.
0:34:40 We believe that this process will help us move forward.
0:34:44 You'll notice that it's fairly vague, right, and it's vague by design because what we're
0:34:50 trying to do is solicit a whole bunch of responses that allows us to go forward and to make an
0:34:56 initial evaluation. And from there, we will move out and we will ask additional, we will
0:35:02 reserve the right to ask additional questions, supplemental questions, asking for more data,
0:35:08 asking for individuals to assist us in finding experts, maybe calling people in to interview
0:35:16 them and have a conversation to make sure that they understand how important this event
0:35:21 is to us.
0:35:23 And so the request for qualifications is before you.
0:35:27 Our intent should the council approve this, he is to take it to publish it and then start
0:35:33 collecting those.
0:35:34 Those applications are due attention to my office by October 18th.
0:35:39 Close the business.
0:35:40 We will aggressively begin working on those.
0:35:43 You'll see the members of the committee and under the review in sections, we talk about
0:35:49 what this looks like.
0:35:50 What we want to understand is what does this event mean to them?
0:35:54 How are they defining this event?
0:35:57 Because the event itself has been defined from something very, very small and concentrated
0:36:03 to a single jump, to something that may be much larger with other opportunities of community
0:36:12 involvement in community engagement and depending upon the size and the scope of
0:36:16 the question really depends upon the size and the scope of how we want to move
0:36:21 forward. We want to understand how they're going to utilize our city properties. We
0:36:26 want to have a understanding of the type of vehicle that they're going to use and
0:36:29 move forward and we recognize that some of that information is probably going to
0:36:32 be proprietary but we also want to make sure that the technology that they're
0:36:37 going to use is safe. I mean, at the end of the day, we're trying to make sure that again
0:36:44 safety is protected, that there's very limited use of public resources other than these review
0:36:53 type processes, and that our brand and our image is upheld. We believe that the RFQ, although
0:37:00 BEG, gives us that opportunity to at least educate ourselves and begin asking a series
0:37:05 questions. And with that, I'll stand for any questions that you might have.
0:37:09 Council, any questions? Move back and we'll circle.
0:37:14 Thank you, Vice Mayor. It's kind of interesting to see a request for
0:37:20 qualifications, because normally when we use that, there are several applicants intended.
0:37:26 And my question is just since there was one lease holder, one winner,
0:37:32 who is the intended audience, who are the intended applicants, and so I'm kind of confused on how this process will help us move forward as far as there's really only one person who can land on the other side of the canyon.
0:37:48 I think it's important to recognize that even though there may be one individual that has won the right to sign a lease on state lands,
0:37:57 that does not necessarily mean that the city has to support and recognize that one individual as the only person.
0:38:04 In fact, I think that just because the state of Idaho has selected a process and used a process does not necessarily mean that we have to be beholden to it.
0:38:17 I believe that the city of Twin Falls needs to make sure that our interests are best represented and best preserved.
0:38:26 And as I've said, I think that we need to have the courage to say no if we do not believe
0:38:32 that this is in our best interest.
0:38:35 This entire process, this entire time what we have shared with people is go utilize the
0:38:41 state land process because they have a process.
0:38:45 But at no point were we sending them to the state lands process and by a we will accept
0:38:51 whatever comes.
0:38:53 Because we need to do what we can to preserve and protect what we are and this state lands
0:39:00 process really resulted in the highest bidder process, the one who had the most money to
0:39:06 financially put forward to this process.
0:39:09 And you can see in our conversation, we're not talking about money.
0:39:14 We're not talking about what do we get.
0:39:16 We're talking about what can we preserve.
0:39:19 Correct, and I would agree that our process needs to be its own independent process.
0:39:24 I was just curious how that would work as far as...
0:39:31 And know that we're not saying that Mr. Beckley, who is the winner of that process, doesn't
0:39:39 have a reasonable opportunity here.
0:39:43 But we're also not saying that we are just going to move forward without some sort of
0:39:49 review and vetting process of him and other proposals and other ideas, we think that's
0:39:55 important.
0:39:56 Okay.
0:39:57 And my other question would be, are we still going to set out our requirements for whoever
0:40:06 does if they win the approval of getting to use the land, are we setting out our requirements
0:40:13 of what the city is asking for and up front and in writing and not after vetting the person.
0:40:21 Are we still working on that list so that we are presenting our requirements up front to
0:40:28 the applicant?
0:40:29 I feel like that would be fair.
0:40:30 So the way a typical RFQ process works is that you will go forward and you will review
0:40:38 all of the applications that go through a process and you'll go through a series of vetting
0:40:43 and that might be the interviews, that might be the supplemental questions, that might be
0:40:46 the call for experts, whatever that looks like.
0:40:48 At some point in time you come to a prioritization list and you negotiate with the one who you
0:40:56 believe fits that process.
0:41:01 And if you can't come to an agreement on number one, you work with number two.
0:41:06 I think that it's important that when we're looking at public, our conversations so far
0:41:13 have been fixed on public health, public safety, limited use of taxpayer dollars, effect none,
0:41:23 and the protection of the image in the brand of Twin Falls.
0:41:29 We've never said, and we want money improvements, what we said is in our conversations, if there
0:41:40 are improvements that you have to make that are part of the need to utilize the jump site
0:41:47 to help you be successful, then we want them done in a manner that allows us to retain and
0:41:52 keep that.
0:41:54 We think that once we get to a place of qualifications, it is appropriate to then begin asking the
0:42:02 council about what does that look like.
0:42:05 When we had the conversation, there were some individuals that felt that the city should
0:42:10 receive some portion of financial benefit or contribution in some endowment.
0:42:16 There were some that didn't feel that.
0:42:20 Our group has not had a conversation about monies to be handed, but if there are parts
0:42:29 of the conversation that the Council agrees on that we could forward as part of that, we'd
0:42:34 be happy to do so.
0:42:35 We just didn't think that the Council had got to that place yet.
0:42:38 Thank you.
0:42:39 Chris Dockington.
0:42:40 Thanks, Tom.
0:42:41 It's somewhat of a legal question, Fritz.
0:42:44 So you and Travis could give you a input.
0:42:48 The only thing I have to go on is what happened 40 years ago where there was extensive collateral
0:42:54 damage not directly the result of Mr. Knievel.
0:43:00 How much flexibility do we have or should we have in setting a performance or a charity
0:43:06 bond for the direct activity for anything that may happen, say, at Shoshone Falls?
0:43:12 So we have as much flexibility as you want.
0:43:17 Ultimately, we will negotiate a contract in a way that you'll need to approve, and it'll
0:43:24 include whatever protections that you feel are necessary.
0:43:28 So for whatever collateral damage for what?
0:43:30 For why a third party makes no difference.
0:43:33 Thank you.
0:43:34 Sean Barrier.
0:43:35 So I just want to say thanks to Fritz for putting together this detail, the two or three meetings,
0:43:43 I guess that's all the meetings it was last week,
0:43:46 felt like a whole week long of meetings trying to wrap our minds around this whole process
0:43:51 because there isn't a process.
0:43:54 I think where we came to a conclusion finally last week was we don't know what we don't know
0:44:00 and so it's probably easier to go ask what are you actually talking about doing
0:44:05 put it on paper and let's go from there because, you know, I've been taking phone calls for
0:44:10 almost nine years at the Chamber office and it's everything from ideas to plans to here
0:44:18 I am and I'm important and what do you do for me and until somebody actually puts down
0:44:23 on paper this is my plan I'm going to make this vehicle go from point A to point B and
0:44:29 I plan to have all of these things happen around it I think it's difficult for us to
0:44:33 evaluate what it is we're evaluating.
0:44:36 So I think this will be a good process to gather that information and leave flexibility
0:44:42 to get to the points that I think both Chris and Rebecca have made that at the end of the
0:44:46 day it's not just about not putting the taxpayer on the hook for this, it's about getting something
0:44:53 with a lasting legacy that serves the public need.
0:44:57 And so what exactly that is, who knows, but let's get some proposals and look at them.
0:45:03 I did have two minor tweaks that I wanted to throw in.
0:45:08 While I appreciate we are in the process of annexing those city properties out on that end of town, we're not there yet.
0:45:16 So it talks about your intended use of lands within the city limits.
0:45:21 So today there may be lands out there that aren't in the city limits.
0:45:25 And so if someone doesn't address those, but that's the land they want to use.
0:45:29 So I wanted about saying something like within the city limits are owned by the City of Twin
0:45:33 Falls.
0:45:36 And then I think we should maybe put Mike's title in there so they knew who Mike Williams
0:45:42 is or at least that he's with the office of the city manager.
0:45:46 Those were my only two minor tweaks.
0:45:48 Who's talking to?
0:45:57 One other little follow-up is there a proposed time of this contract at beginning and end?
0:46:05 the advanced work could begin tomorrow. It could extend for six months after the actual jump. Is
0:46:12 it wise to entertain a proposed beginning finite life for this?
0:46:17 You know, we could talk about that. Chris, it's just a little, I mean, like Sean said, we don't know
0:46:28 what we know yet. And so I think as we become educated, if we think that there need to be some
0:46:34 time parameters for this, then we can attach those for sure.
0:46:37 So who's going to educate us on something of that nature?
0:46:41 Everybody that makes a presentation is going to tell us what they've got in mind and what
0:46:45 their event looks like and when the event starts and when it's all done.
0:46:49 And so those might set the parameters for that.
0:46:52 What I'm concerned about and so far only what I've read that press, it looks like Mr. Beckley
0:47:00 may have some skill at organizing an event like this, but until we have a party that
0:47:06 specifically named for liability or encompassing what the event is, a party, a third party
0:47:14 that comes and claims they're working with Mr. Beckley with no trial of a direct organization.
0:47:20 Those sorts of things can just get out of quipso, doggone.
0:47:23 There will be one person, one entity that we will deal with.
0:47:29 And if they manage their subcontractors or whatever, that's between them, but we will deal with
0:47:34 one entity. Very fun. Thank you, Chris. Sean Berger. I was just going to mention so the truthfully,
0:47:43 the state's process was a little bit similar to this in that they communicated with the
0:47:48 five applicants who had made application and gathered information from them about what they
0:47:54 were proposing, what kind of business plan they might have attached to it, and then the
0:47:58 state utilized that to refine one lease that then went back to these groups and it sort
0:48:04 was a, I don't want to say it was an average, but it sort of was picking parts and pieces
0:48:09 of everybody's proposals to put that on paper. So I see that being a little bit of what we're
0:48:14 talking about here. Let's get all the information from everybody. Let's see the ones that fit
0:48:18 with our vision and our qualifications criteria that we've set out there and sort of sort
0:48:24 of go from there.
0:48:25 Thank you, Sean. I just wanted to agree with what Sean said about adding those two items.
0:48:33 I'm in support of that.
0:48:35 I think it makes sense to say something
0:48:36 about within the city limits and or city owned property
0:48:40 and as well as Mike's title.
0:48:42 I think that was a good catch.
0:48:44 With that being said, Jim.
0:48:48 Thank you, Vice Mayor.
0:48:49 I would move to approve a request for qualifications process
0:48:54 in order to gather information to use
0:48:56 and evaluate and propose those ways to the jump from the city
0:48:59 property across the Snake River Canyon commemorating
0:49:02 the 40th anniversary attempt made by Evil Kneel in 1974.
0:49:07 Second.
0:49:08 We have a motion on four by Jim Munn, seconded by Sean Berriger.
0:49:13 Just a clarification with those adjustments that Sean made.
0:49:18 Yes, Vice Mayor, with you two adjustments that were suggested
0:49:22 in regards to city owned property and Mike's title.
0:49:28 Second good with that.
0:49:30 All right.
0:49:31 We have a motion on the floor to counsel.
0:49:34 Any questions or comments?
0:49:36 Rebecca Milsoyka.
0:49:37 Thank you, guys, Mayor.
0:49:38 Just a quick comment.
0:49:39 And I'm not necessarily opposed to the request for qualifications.
0:49:45 I'm just wondering how it would work if you find an applicant that
0:49:52 doesn't hold that lease.
0:49:54 And what are the repercussions for the person
0:49:59 that paid almost a million dollars for his lease and you know what I'm saying it seems
0:50:05 like a strange process for the pieces that are in place.
0:50:08 Yeah it is and it's been all along and we've had that discussion with Department of Lands
0:50:13 but they were full speed ahead.
0:50:16 As Travis said we don't want them to drive our process because I don't think any of you
0:50:22 are saying you want the highest bidder but that's what they got because that's what the address
0:50:29 of the Department of Lands is to make as much money as possible.
0:50:32 Ours is not that.
0:50:34 So there are a number of possibilities,
0:50:36 but Mr. Beckley may make a great presentation,
0:50:41 and he may very well be it.
0:50:42 But he may make a presentation that you say,
0:50:45 we don't want anything to do with this.
0:50:47 And if no one else is able to take an assignment
0:50:51 of that lease, there won't be an event.
0:50:54 That's a possibility.
0:50:56 Or there are some, I've heard rumors
0:50:58 that there's some other parcels that can be used.
0:51:01 And that's another possibility.
0:51:03 Okay.
0:51:04 It is a little sticky problem that Mr. Beckley is out ahead
0:51:08 of this because the highest bidder,
0:51:10 but we have a different criteria on this side of the canyon.
0:51:14 Right. And I would agree that we don't want to let anyone else
0:51:17 run our priorities and run our process.
0:51:20 But I also just think that using the pieces that are in place,
0:51:24 It's like we can say these are our priorities, here's our criteria, this is what we're looking
0:51:30 for as far as protecting the citizens, protecting health and safety.
0:51:35 But again, I'm not against the process.
0:51:38 It just puzzles me a little bit.
0:51:40 I'm not really sure how it fits.
0:51:42 It puzzles us too.
0:51:43 Okay.
0:51:44 It puzzles me is a great word.
0:51:45 I would say I was in this committee and we've been puzzled the whole time.
0:51:49 I'm a bit puzzled.
0:51:50 Chris Stockington.
0:51:51 Final question, what's the status on our annexation
0:51:55 of the public right away there?
0:51:56 Where are we in that hearing process or publicizing?
0:52:03 We got a scheduled hearing for the planning zone
0:52:05 in commission on the 22nd, I think, 11th, yeah,
0:52:09 it's 22nd of this month.
0:52:10 And then we're scheduled to come here
0:52:13 for public hearing on the River Fourth.
0:52:17 Very good, I see no further lights.
0:52:19 Leila, roll call, vote on the motion.
0:52:22 Chris talking to yes. Sean Burger yes. Don Hall yes. Suzanne Hawkins yes Jim
0:52:29 on yes. Rebecca Mills weka motion has passed five in favor one against and I
0:52:43 just want to make comment thank you to the committee that has been meeting on
0:52:46 this and in the city staff it's been a few interesting meetings so appreciate it
0:52:52 next item on the agenda is public input and or items from city manager and city
0:52:59 council so I'll start with public input is there anyone in the audience that
0:53:04 would like to address the council on a subject that we haven't really dealt
0:53:08 with this evening I see no one running for the mic so I will then turn it over
0:53:15 to city manager anything further city council anything further that was easy
0:53:21 so we are going to move to the last item on our agenda this evening this is
0:53:27 It's going to be a unique situation because we are going to, if the council approves it,
0:53:32 move into executive session, I'll read through that in a minute.
0:53:36 Once we do that, we are going to then step down from the dais and invite the urban renewal
0:53:42 agency and their members, their chairperson and their members to come up and do the same
0:53:46 thing because it's going to be a joint meeting together.
0:53:49 We're going to clear the council chambers, we're not going to kick you out right away,
0:53:53 eventually, because it's going to be an executive session this evening.
0:53:57 So, moving to our last item, and it is adjournment to Executive Session 67-2345-1c to conduct
0:54:06 deliberations concerning labor negotiations or to acquire an interest in real property,
0:54:12 which is not owned by a public agency and 1e to consider preliminary negotiations involving
0:54:19 matters of trade or commerce in which the governing body is in competition with governing
0:54:25 bodies in other states or nations.
0:54:27 Stand for a motion, council.
0:54:29 So moved.
0:54:31 I have a motion on the board by Sean Berger.
0:54:33 Second.
0:54:34 Seconded by Suzanne Harris.
0:54:35 What?
0:54:36 What did I get that?
0:54:38 Hawkins.
0:54:39 Anything further on that motion, council?
0:54:45 Rebecca Milso.
0:54:46 Thank you, vice mayor.
0:54:47 Just a question for staff, all of the meeting of the URA executive session was posted in
0:54:53 the proper timeframe.
0:54:56 It was.
0:54:59 And they, after the point where you adjourned to executive session, they will then come up
0:55:04 here.
0:55:05 They will be required to then call their meeting to order, and then they will go into executive
0:55:09 session shortly thereafter.
0:55:12 We published their special meeting to begin at six o'clock, so at six o'clock they will
0:55:17 will actually come up and they will take the dais momentarily
0:55:22 while they go forward with that process.
0:55:23 Okay, thank you.
0:55:24 I just want to make sure all the public notices have been moved.
0:55:27 Excellent, Rebecca, thank you.
0:55:29 Anything from the council?
0:55:32 The aye, little roll call vote, please.
0:55:35 Yes.
0:55:36 Yes.
0:55:38 Yes.
0:55:39 Yes.
0:55:40 Yes.
0:55:41 Yes.
0:55:43 Motion passes six to zero.
0:55:45 And I just wanted to mention that we will not
0:55:47 be making any decisions in the executive session,
0:55:50 Nor will we be coming back out and reconvening
0:55:53 a city council meeting this evening.
0:55:55 We will be finished after the executive session.
0:55:57 So with that, we are adjourned into executive session.
Download
- Transcript (text) 52 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 69 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 95 KB
- Audio (M4A) 13.2 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, October 7, 2013. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:56:03.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
5ef6abcc83f23657c1935a271c266b0dbb53f731efb4e5c11dbb893b5a0b655b - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a dd65c3bd01bd8903b7dbaa3ec0705d9fd6619603c244a2ed30b9988f9ec41b67 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
f03b6d30997ff8359db6ec0fdc15f17e4702c60839f628bfe810eacaa8c8e687
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file