OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, December 9, 2013

Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Part 3 (from 3:00:00)

Transcript

0:05:23 I'd like to call the December 9th, 2013 meeting

0:05:26 that's from Falls City Council to order.

0:05:28 Our first item is business, as always,

0:05:30 is the pledge of the flag.

0:05:32 Would you like the Jones, please rise?

0:05:37 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:05:56 Well, from everyone, what would confirm

0:05:57 we do have a full quorum.

0:05:59 I believe that Sean Berger has joined us either radio, are you there Sean or be the telephone?

0:06:05 I am here.

0:06:06 All right, thank you Sean.

0:06:07 Thank you.

0:06:08 The introduction of staff, at least a partial introduction of City Manager, Travis Rothwiler,

0:06:13 City Attorney, Fritz Wonderlich, Community Development Director Mitch Humble, Deputy

0:06:17 City Clerk, Recording Secretary, Leo Sanchez, Mr. Rothwiler, do we have any amendments to

0:06:25 the agenda?

0:06:26 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, we would have two amendments to the agenda for your consideration.

0:06:31 This evening, the both would be on the consent calendar.

0:06:34 If you look at item number two, consideration of the meeting minutes of November 12th,

0:06:40 there was an addition that was put in to those meeting minutes upon review of the council and

0:06:46 that addition in those corrected minutes are on, have been placed before you, and that should say as revised.

0:06:54 The item four that would appear would be the meeting calendar

0:06:58 that we have for the city council for calendar year 2014.

0:07:03 That was placed in an effort to just publish that

0:07:08 and put that as part of our official packet.

0:07:09 We'd ask that that be considered

0:07:11 as part of our consent calendar.

0:07:13 Good start.

0:07:15 Mayor, I'd like to discuss that meeting calendar rather

0:07:19 than just building the whole package up or down.

0:07:22 Right, so I would suggest then we if one of you make a motion for the

0:07:26 Minute says

0:07:28 Well, I guess we can actually approve it and then you can pull it off. It's easy. So whichever

0:07:33 Sure, we'd like to do do I have a motion to accept those two amendments move approval

0:07:42 Jim on second place taking my Suzanne Hawkins to

0:07:47 amend the consent calendar to

0:07:50 provide as

0:07:52 Revised on item number two and then add a item for which is the calendar and

0:07:58 It appears we'll be pulling it off before the final vote on the calendar part, but they have to go have a roll call vote on the amendment

0:08:04 Rebecca Mills-Sueger. Yes

0:08:07 Kristoffi Tatch

0:08:09 Schonberger

0:08:10 Yeah

0:08:11 Don Hall. Yes

0:08:13 Suzanne Hawkins. Yes, Greg Lansing. Yes Jim on. Yes

0:08:17 Okay, that motion passes 7-0.

0:08:21 Because of Chris's wanting to talk about the calendar separately, I would now entertain

0:08:28 a motion on just the first three items, and then we'll actually, which would we rather

0:08:33 do, just talk about the calendar now for it or go ahead and make the most two separate

0:08:38 motions.

0:08:39 Alright, let's go ahead and just talk about the calendar, and then maybe it should be one

0:08:42 motion.

0:08:43 Chris, how are you?

0:08:44 And again, reflecting back on the previous times I served on the council, we never, to

0:08:52 the best of my knowledge, had a full years printed out as we do now.

0:08:56 So I applaud this.

0:08:57 I think it's transparent.

0:08:59 How's that the word that is pertinent?

0:09:02 I do take exception of it only having four meetings for all the months and taking four

0:09:10 meetings 4 out of 52 off without discussing why I found the fifth meeting Monday time to

0:09:19 be in particularly useful to provide additional information to have a department's operations

0:09:25 discussed to us.

0:09:28 I look at as necessary council education time if there is no record business.

0:09:35 So I accepted the last year because I thought I might have missed a motion setting the 48

0:09:42 rather than 52 meeting days, but I don't feel comfortable not giving the taxpayers a full

0:09:49 52 weeks service of the council.

0:09:52 Any other discussion concerning the scheduled regular meetings?

0:09:59 Rebecca?

0:10:00 Thank you, Mayor.

0:10:01 I can support adding in those four meetings.

0:10:04 I have no opposition to that.

0:10:08 the advantages if we do not choose to do anything,

0:10:10 we could cancel it, require the publication,

0:10:12 but I'd rather not write them all.

0:10:15 That's my final.

0:10:19 Well, I'm not sure either way,

0:10:22 if it's one of those things where we've added them back in,

0:10:25 should we have something for them,

0:10:28 which usually means about two of the four

0:10:30 get added back in, as I recall.

0:10:32 I'm not sure, somewhere during my last eight years

0:10:36 is when we changed that, it was prior to that,

0:10:39 I mean, I remember for a while for many years,

0:10:42 and Chris, you were probably remember even better than I

0:10:44 did, but there used to only be two council meetings a month

0:10:47 at one point in the 10 years from Fall City Council.

0:10:51 Not during my time.

0:10:54 Work sessions, I think you're talking about.

0:10:56 All right, anyway, so whatever the council wishes

0:11:01 on the county, we probably need to have a motion

0:11:04 so that you come back with it.

0:11:08 Well, oh, okay.

0:11:09 I will move that we approve the calendar with the change of adding in March 31st, June 30th, September 29th, and December 29th of 2014.

0:11:23 Seconded.

0:11:24 Just to speak to the motion, even before we got rid of the fifth Monday, we rarely, we haven't ever in eight years that I've been on council have we met on the Monday between Christmas and New York.

0:11:45 in Christmas and New Year's, so that's the point of view

0:11:50 would be concerned about that particular one, Donald.

0:11:54 Well, I mean, it really doesn't matter to me.

0:11:56 I think that if we find that we don't have enough agenda items

0:11:59 for our fifth money, we can certainly notice that.

0:12:03 So I'm okay with the motion.

0:12:08 All right, so you know, lights,

0:12:09 we have a roll call vote on whether or not to add

0:12:12 the fifth mundies back into the schedule

0:12:16 that you published for us.

0:12:19 Chris Talkington.

0:12:20 Yes.

0:12:21 Sean Baraker.

0:12:22 Yes.

0:12:23 Don Hall.

0:12:24 Yes.

0:12:25 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:12:26 Yes.

0:12:27 Greg Lanting.

0:12:27 Yes.

0:12:28 Jim I.

0:12:29 Yes.

0:12:29 Rebecca Mills-Suechka.

0:12:30 Yes.

0:12:33 Mason Passes.

0:12:34 7-0.

0:12:36 Again, we will probably look at those on whether there's

0:12:40 enough things for me and we'll help you.

0:12:42 OK.

0:12:47 So now we need a motion on the all four

0:12:50 of the consent calendar move passage second and move by Chris talking second

0:12:57 my Suzanne Hawkins to move the passage of the consent calendar we have a roll

0:13:03 call vote Sean Burger yeah Don Hall yes Suzanne Hawkins yes Jim on yes

0:13:11 Rebecca Masuega yes let's talk again yes that's the 7-0

0:13:17 So, moving on to item number one,

0:13:19 which is a presentation of item number one

0:13:23 of the items for consideration.

0:13:26 Presentation of municipal powers,

0:13:28 outside grant, recipients on the use of funds

0:13:32 received last physical year.

0:13:34 Pat Lehman is gonna be directing that

0:13:36 from our city staff from our finest department.

0:13:47 Good evening, honorable mayor and city council.

0:13:51 For a background on this, the 2013 M-PAL grants

0:13:55 awarded at the June 3rd, 2013-12 City Council meeting.

0:13:59 At that meeting, the City Council requested that the MPOG grant recipients return the first

0:14:04 part of December to give a report on what they use their funds for and what goals they were

0:14:10 able to accomplish.

0:14:12 So tonight we have with us five of the ten municipal grant recipients to present the

0:14:19 reports.

0:14:20 The remaining five will be presenting their reports at next week's City Council meeting.

0:14:27 A schedule for the presentations and copies of the reports have been included in your agenda.

0:14:32 And if you don't have a copy of the schedule, I've got another one here if you need it otherwise.

0:14:40 I'll turn it over to our presenters.

0:14:43 All right. First one is, I'm assuming we're going the order that is in your crisis center.

0:14:47 Yeah, I showed the first one was the crisis center.

0:14:49 The crisis center of Magic Valley, who received 15,000.

0:14:54 We've been, how long did we stake for these?

0:14:57 Does anybody around some like five minutes

0:14:58 or was there a different time?

0:15:00 Yeah, five minutes.

0:15:01 Yeah, five minutes.

0:15:02 Five minutes, I think, is what we're expecting.

0:15:04 All right, and I'll give you the two and 30 second mark.

0:15:10 Don't freak out when I hold this out.

0:15:11 And I'll probably forget what I was talking about,

0:15:14 but just kind of put me back on track.

0:15:16 But you don't have to take five, what's we?

0:15:18 Okay, I hope that each and every one of you

0:15:21 have had the opportunity to read the report

0:15:23 that I submitted to you.

0:15:26 One of the things that we're excited about at the Crisis

0:15:29 Center is that we have never really

0:15:31 been able to do too much on the preventive end

0:15:34 of domestic violence.

0:15:35 We're always dealing with the funds

0:15:38 that are important to support emergency care

0:15:44 for the victims that we serve this year

0:15:47 because of our wonderful collaboration

0:15:51 that we have with the Twin Falls Police Department, the captain and the chief of police, we have

0:16:03 been able to increase what we consider that outreach to folks that we're hoping will not

0:16:12 end up being past the misdemeanor state but hopefully touch them before they get to the

0:16:17 the felony problem. Typically, domestic violence does escalate. It's something that doesn't

0:16:25 go away in this day and age with the economy being as it is. People not being able to find

0:16:32 housing there is more and more, unfortunately. I don't think I could ever work myself out

0:16:38 of a job and certainly with the increase of folks in our community, we have seen an increase

0:16:44 of the Crisis Center of Folks that we need to help.

0:16:51 I have given you the statistics.

0:16:52 The Crisis Center helped 1899 individuals last year.

0:16:58 We provided a myriad of supportive services to folks.

0:17:03 Our shelter number actually was down a little bit, but actually we sheltered more days than

0:17:09 ever before.

0:17:10 Some of the folks that, some of the women I should say instead of folks, some of the women

0:17:14 that we helped with their children actually stayed longer.

0:17:18 And this year we were so excited

0:17:21 about having almost a 50% rate of the success,

0:17:30 which has not always happened.

0:17:33 When we were sheltering three days and two weeks

0:17:35 and our sheltering was limited, we didn't have that success.

0:17:40 So we're excited that our grant funding has, you know,

0:17:44 eased up a bit and allowed us to shelter longer.

0:17:49 People have so many problems when they come to us.

0:17:52 Sometimes if they have a job and they have transportation,

0:17:56 certainly they can go out into the community sooner,

0:17:59 but many times the people that we help

0:18:01 don't have those resources.

0:18:03 So, you know, we help with getting them into college

0:18:08 or getting their GED, getting their first job.

0:18:11 I don't know how many times we've celebrated people

0:18:14 getting their first paycheck at the crisis center,

0:18:17 and there's nothing more rewarding than seeing someone

0:18:21 who's actually being able to provide themselves

0:18:26 with the funds that they're gonna need

0:18:28 to support themselves.

0:18:29 Success is measured at the crisis center

0:18:32 when people are able to go out on their own,

0:18:36 go to school, go to college, have transportation,

0:18:41 and have housing.

0:18:42 That's what we say is a success story.

0:18:46 Of course, many people do have success.

0:18:50 And maybe it would be what we would consider baby steps,

0:18:53 but it is success.

0:18:57 I've given you the stats for the crisis center

0:19:00 and the services that we've provided.

0:19:02 I'm wondering if any of you had any questions on that.

0:19:06 We really break down, because of our federal funding, we receive, we really break down everything

0:19:14 very statistically at the crisis center because statistics run grants.

0:19:20 And so I have with me today Lori Palmer, who's our shelter manager, and really in charge of putting those together.

0:19:28 So if any of you have any questions on those.

0:19:32 As you can see, the crisis center used our $15,000 for very basic needs at the crisis center.

0:19:43 The, I'll tell you, I can't even thank you enough for the generous gift that you gave

0:19:50 us.

0:19:51 Typically, we have had two breaks in funding for a year.

0:19:58 This year, we had three breaks in funding.

0:20:01 So we had three different months that we had no funding coming in to support us.

0:20:06 So the $15,000 that we received from you, actually, as it looks, as I show on my report,

0:20:14 actually kept those lights on at our shelter.

0:20:16 They helped us provide medical support and all those other individual counseling things,

0:20:23 food, transportation, and bus tickets.

0:20:26 Do you have any questions of me?

0:20:28 Well, your five minutes is up. I don't have any lights. I appreciated some of those numbers or

0:20:33 I mean, the other numbers are large, but you show 1,723 domestic violence. That's pretty staggering to me that you would be able to get in that many.

0:20:43 I know, and to consider that a thousand plus identified themselves as living within the Twin Falls City limits, that's even more disconcerting.

0:20:53 But we have a wonderful police department that's working diligently to address those issues.

0:21:04 We have community resources that we depend on.

0:21:08 So thank you very much.

0:21:09 Thank you for your efforts for our community.

0:21:11 Well, thank you.

0:21:13 All right.

0:21:14 Next up is the Twin Falls Senior Center.

0:21:24 Good evening.

0:21:25 I'd like to thank each of you, especially the Mayor and the City Council for your support at the Twin Falls Senior Center.

0:21:32 The grant funds that we were given and the support that we have, we were able to get all of our electrical improvements done at the building, which makes it great.

0:21:42 A wonderful thing, we no longer lose or have fire hazards or we don't have switches flipping

0:21:47 all the time.

0:21:48 And so those improvements have helped very much in improving the atmosphere and the safety

0:21:55 environment that I have.

0:21:57 Also now with our breakfasts we have a poll that has four electrical plugs and we receive

0:22:03 a steamer table that's everything's remote.

0:22:06 We just have to use one of the 220 plugs so that makes everything so nobody's walking

0:22:11 over courts any longer and things that way so it works a whole lot better.

0:22:14 I provided pictures in my report that shows some of the things that have transpired.

0:22:20 We were able to do the data upgrades to our computers and our patch panel in the back where

0:22:28 we had wires hanging and it was causing interference with the telephone lines.

0:22:32 All that's been taken care of.

0:22:35 All the electrical plugs in the flooring, we were able to put our new steam kettle to

0:22:39 work and get all that done. And then the computer room has the wall all put in back with all

0:22:47 the new, there was four different electrical plugs that were put on one side and four on

0:22:54 the other side for the quilt ladies. And then we were able to put our computer station in

0:22:58 so we now have seven computer stations for the seniors to use. We used a lot of those

0:23:03 during our Medicare Open Enrollment for SHIBA that we helped volunteer services were and

0:23:08 and helping people getting their prescription Part D enrollments.

0:23:12 So that was very good.

0:23:14 Basically, I just broke down some of the expenditures

0:23:16 and things that we had done.

0:23:18 We've well went over the funding

0:23:20 that the city had given to us,

0:23:22 but the improvements have basically finished all of my rooms

0:23:26 in my center, except for the main hall,

0:23:28 which will now have to be painted and things that way

0:23:30 that I'm working on towards applying

0:23:34 for another block grant with the city's approval.

0:23:37 in the 1st of March, but I had an energy audit done on Saturday and we're moving forward

0:23:42 with looking at seeing where the energy efficiency is and things doing that way, as well as the

0:23:47 handy-cap accessibility issues.

0:23:50 Is there any questions?

0:23:51 I'm not seeing any questions for Jeanette.

0:23:55 I want to let you also know that at the last minute it had put in the number of meals that

0:23:58 we've served as of the end of November, which this year today we've served 42,375 meals,

0:24:05 28,818 were from all-meal delivery and the rest were at the center.

0:24:10 We're averaging about two hundred and seven different individuals eating at the center

0:24:15 itself with approximately 130 home delivered meal clients.

0:24:20 Right now we're at about 142.

0:24:22 So the great need the last three months we've seen the all-time record high since I've

0:24:26 been there in two years and in October we serve 4,195 total meals.

0:24:33 I know some of the other council members got the opportunity as well, but I remember last

0:24:37 year of the dream, whatever week it was, I had the opportunity to ride along with the

0:24:41 Sniders and to see the, it's more than just the meal you're delivering to those people.

0:24:50 And the Sniders, speaking of them, we had a couple and they went to their house and

0:24:56 we have somebody that's willing to help us with the homebound have something for Christmas,

0:25:00 people who are not financially able to have a Christmas or have no people to come see them

0:25:05 at Christmas.

0:25:06 So we've been making sure that we have a list and have all that taken care of and they went

0:25:09 to this people's house and when they got there to ask them if they needed anything, the woman

0:25:17 went to crying and took a long while to figure out what was going on and she says, last year

0:25:20 all we asked from our children was for them to take the Christmas tree out of the basement

0:25:25 and bring it upstairs so we could enjoy it and they refused.

0:25:30 So the Sniders went back after they delivered their route and they put their tree up.

0:25:34 And this year they will have something at Christmas.

0:25:36 Okay.

0:25:37 Well again, thank you for your support of our community.

0:25:41 It takes a lot of people to make community whole.

0:25:45 It does.

0:25:46 And a lot of people think, do you still need drivers, do you still need volunteers, as

0:25:49 much as the demand does, yes we do.

0:25:51 We have 12 new drivers and we still don't have enough.

0:25:55 And I have to have more hot food containers and more things to put in the coolers to keep

0:26:01 the cold product.

0:26:02 Like I said, we're at that busting point where it's really starting to take off and

0:26:07 the meals counts are really going up.

0:26:09 So I said, I appreciate all the support I get from you.

0:26:13 You guys, the 3000 was your share of this and it seemed like you did a lot with our 3000.

0:26:19 Okay.

0:26:20 It was well spent.

0:26:21 Thank you.

0:26:22 Next up is a CASA court appointed special advocates who received 6,000 this last year and if you

0:26:32 Apologize we know most to be with the people the public watching on the internet and I'm saying probably don't so if you give us your name

0:26:39 No problem. Tana Barton

0:26:42 I'm the executive director at the 50 digital district CASA program in our report as you'll see

0:26:49 We have an outline of what we've done since we received this money about five months ago

0:26:54 since then we have recruited eight volunteers to start training. They've gone

0:27:01 through 240 hours of training. Six of the volunteers have now taken a case and

0:27:06 are representing 14 abused children within the Twin Falls City limits. They

0:27:12 have at this point spent 84 hours with the children. They've spent 12 hours

0:27:19 writing reports to the courts, and an additional 36 hours sitting in the

0:27:25 court advocating for those children. They have driven over 800 miles, and if

0:27:33 you were to take that and put a dollar amount on those volunteers, paying them

0:27:38 $15 an hour on the average, we would have paid out $5,898. So you can see

0:27:46 with the money that we've spent in the grant thus far, we have doubled the services for

0:27:52 that. Do you have any questions?

0:27:57 Have any questions of Chris talk?

0:27:59 Maybe I misunderstood. Did you only receive the city's distribution five months ago? Did

0:28:06 I understand you to say that?

0:28:08 No, this is the, when did we receive? I can't tell you when we received it. Same time everyone

0:28:13 else did.

0:28:14 Okay.

0:28:15 This is the past five months.

0:28:16 Thank you.

0:28:17 All right.

0:28:19 And I'll use this moment since you didn't use your whole time.

0:28:22 I don't have any other questions that, again, thank you.

0:28:24 I'm sure it's neat.

0:28:25 The numbers of the children being served and those kind of things that certainly, again,

0:28:31 takes a lot of people who are on a community and you're certainly part of it.

0:28:35 For those I didn't really explain.

0:28:36 The money that we're talking about here, we'll do five this week and five next week is the

0:28:40 municipal outport outsourced grants.

0:28:42 We give about 100,000 each year on a competitive grant basis from city funds for things that

0:28:49 the city could buy lobby construed as something we should be providing on our own.

0:28:56 And so we provide these grants to help others provide them for us.

0:29:00 For instance, I say that anywhere close to the work is, I appreciate it.

0:29:04 And so that's what we're going through.

0:29:06 We're having the people talk to us about what the how they use our city funds.

0:29:11 City taxpayer funds, general fund money this past year.

0:29:15 And we do, we have 289 children that we're representing right now in the 50 judicial district.

0:29:21 About 70% of those are here in the Twin Falls area.

0:29:25 Okay, all right.

0:29:26 Thank you very much.

0:29:28 Yes, Rebecca.

0:29:30 Thank you, Mayor.

0:29:30 I have a legal question for Fritz.

0:29:34 I have a conflict when it comes to the Twin Falls city beyond my husband plays in it.

0:29:37 Do I need to step down for this presentation or am I okay?

0:29:40 decision to be made tonight. You may not want to comment, but there's no decision to be made, so you won't have to step down.

0:29:46 Great. Thank you. I just wanted to disclose that, and I will not make any comments.

0:29:51 Thank you, Greg. Next up is Twin Falls Municipal Band, $21,200.

0:30:00 And a fine drummer, he is, by the way.

0:30:03 Thank you.

0:30:04 Yes, he is. That's what I can take credit for.

0:30:07 Good evening. I'm Sandy Hacking. I'm from the Twin Falls Municipal Band and I want to thank you for this opportunity to present our financial report for this summer.

0:30:35 I just wanted to kind of touch on a little bit of the history. Our band started somewhere about 1904-1905 in a gazebo in the city park.

0:30:50 Park. And thank you for our forefathers for having the insight to create such a beautiful

0:30:57 setting for many of the communities, events that we hold there at the City Park. In the

0:31:05 early years, the band was funded by a tax levy at the state of Idaho level. And at some

0:31:10 point in the early to mid 60s, that changed to the local level. It's been said the pictures

0:31:16 speak a thousand words, so with that in mind I've made a collage of some of the

0:31:20 pictures from this past summer. Everything from the ban shell cleaning

0:31:24 immediately after the western days parade to our concert with Idaho Army Band, the

0:31:35 teddy bears parade at one of our concerts. You can see how the park fills

0:31:40 up with all of the members of our community and the taxpayers that enjoy

0:31:47 this service that we provide to them every summer.

0:31:52 This year, our band consisted of 58 playing musicians,

0:31:56 one full-time MC, two part-time MCs,

0:31:59 that basically auditioned for the vacancy left by Bird Hue-ish,

0:32:03 one sound technician, and one full-time conductor,

0:32:06 musical director.

0:32:08 We had 12 Tuesday evening rehearsals, 10 regular concerts,

0:32:13 which included the Fourth of July celebration at CSI,

0:32:16 And one additional performance at the Magic Valley Arts Center.

0:32:19 So we had 11 concerts this summer.

0:32:23 Our payment scale for this year was $15 for rehearsals,

0:32:27 $15 for concerts, $5 for guest conducting,

0:32:31 $5 for soloist performance, $30 for perfect attendance,

0:32:35 and $10 for the Magic Valley Arts Council concert.

0:32:40 To qualify for a payment, each musician

0:32:42 must pay three rehearsals and three concerts.

0:32:45 A rehearsal and concert must be in the same week

0:32:47 to qualify of a musician played all ten rehearsals and concerts that qualified for the perfect

0:32:52 attendance allowance.

0:32:55 Adiraxes did a fundraiser for us, they sold water and popcorn in the park one evening.

0:33:02 Their total take on that donation was 153.75, it is notated in the schedule that I sent

0:33:12 to you previously.

0:33:14 The Rotary Club donated $500 for music.

0:33:18 We belonged to the Twin Falls Chamber and the Magic Valley Arts Council and we paid dues

0:33:22 to both of those entities.

0:33:25 Our band is a tradition that most communities don't have.

0:33:28 This is a part of what makes Living in Twin Falls unique.

0:33:31 This summer will be our 109th concert season.

0:33:35 We provide a series of concerts that focus on keeping this tradition alive.

0:33:41 We performed 118 separate selections this last summer.

0:33:46 We collaborate with other entities and to involve to support the availability of social,

0:33:50 cultural and recreational opportunities to reflect the Twin Falls unique sense of community.

0:33:59 Continually provide quality concerts to the citizens of Twin Falls from all walks of life.

0:34:04 We maintain a safe and clean environment for residents and visitors utilizing our beautiful

0:34:10 city park.

0:34:11 As stewards of the public trust, we strive to meet the current and present needs of the

0:34:17 community, promote citizen involvement, preserve our heritage and protect our social and physical

0:34:23 resources and enhance the quality of life in Twin Falls.

0:34:27 The workforce development, Chamber of Commerce and many other entities, recruiting businesses

0:34:32 to our area show off the Twin Falls Municipal Band concerts and their promotions.

0:34:37 It shows that although we are a growing community,

0:34:40 we strive to preserve our traditions and our heritage.

0:34:43 From all the band members, the Board of Directors and myself,

0:34:47 thank you for your continued support.

0:34:50 Jay, how many of you like?

0:34:51 I don't know.

0:34:53 Can we have popcorn more often?

0:34:55 Sure.

0:34:56 Do you want microwave or the regular?

0:34:59 I don't care.

0:35:00 Just any, you may know Sandy, there's a kind of a classy

0:35:03 picture of the concert. We're going to have a couple of kids that are up in a

0:35:09 crook of a tree that we that we every time we have an economic development

0:35:15 opportunity and we're trying to convince them to come to different falls that's

0:35:18 part of the community that we show show them to show a portion of our

0:35:24 community so again we understand the importance of a municipal band and in a

0:35:29 total community I think Travis is trying to look that picture up quickly but I

0:35:33 I can't stall long enough for you to find it, so.

0:35:36 I know exactly which one you're talking about,

0:35:38 and I have enlarged it and have it in a frame at home.

0:35:41 All right, thank you.

0:35:42 Yeah, it certainly looks like a piece of American.

0:35:45 It doesn't matter.

0:35:46 The original ban show mayor was constructed by the WPA

0:35:50 to an impressioner.

0:35:52 Yep, the one we're still using, WPA projects.

0:35:55 Well, it's an added to a modified.

0:35:57 Thank you, Sandy.

0:35:58 Come on.

0:35:59 Come on.

0:36:01 Next up is the Boys and Girls Clubs of Magic Valley.

0:36:03 They received $11,150 last year.

0:36:07 And if you identify yourself, I don't know where I think I know her.

0:36:12 Hi, my name is Lindsay Westbrook, and I'm the new executive director

0:36:16 at the Boys and Girls Club.

0:36:17 And it's a pleasure to be in front of you guys today, especially you.

0:36:22 So the Boys and Girls Club, as many of you know,

0:36:25 has been in existence for over 18 years, providing after school

0:36:29 and now during the day services for kids 5 to 18.

0:36:33 We, our programs provide education, character and

0:36:37 literacy leadership, healthy life choices, the arts,

0:36:40 and sports and fitness.

0:36:41 So through these funds, the Boys and Girls Health is now

0:36:45 serving nearly 1,400 kids per year.

0:36:49 So 69% of those kids are come from free and reduced lunch

0:36:53 families.

0:36:54 So through these funds, we're able to provide.

0:36:57 We've applied for money to provide the arts,

0:37:02 our fitness program, and our program.

0:37:05 So these programs are essential for kids for after school.

0:37:10 And so through these funds, we were

0:37:12 able to provide coordinators.

0:37:14 Our coordinators at the Boys and Girls Club

0:37:16 are the people who actually put these programs together

0:37:19 and are in with the kids each and every day.

0:37:21 So they're providing services to help kids.

0:37:24 And so for our after-school program, this program is for kids,

0:37:32 as I said, for kids that are 5 to 18 that don't have anywhere to go after school.

0:37:37 So it's essential for the club to be in existence to help provide those services for kids.

0:37:43 So through these programs, our fitness program, we were able to

0:37:47 expend $1375, our music program $2,000, our art program $1,375, and for the coordinators

0:37:58 $6,471. We were also able to provide staff communications systems, which is essential

0:38:06 for our safety for our children and parents to be able to find kids and be safe, so that

0:38:13 was another $279. Through our fitness program, we had 117 kids that participated. That program,

0:38:24 they were able to provide all sorts of fitness for kids, which was goal oriented, that they

0:38:29 were able to start at one place and end at another place. And those were tracked through

0:38:35 some of our outcome measurements. So our music program, we did actually a flash mob

0:38:47 with our kids this year. For those of you that are not familiar, they were taught a dance

0:38:58 and a song and they were tasked with going out into the community and doing a flash mob.

0:39:05 So if any of you were at the Magic Family Mall about a month ago, then you might have seen it.

0:39:10 So 75 kids were able to participate in that program.

0:39:14 And 54 kids were affected by our program.

0:39:19 And that is for our first and second quarter of just this year for our after school program.

0:39:24 So yes, we are very, very grateful for these funds.

0:39:29 Does anyone have any questions for Lindsey?

0:39:31 Rebecca Mills for you.

0:39:33 Thank you, Mayor.

0:39:34 Thank you for your presentation, Lindsay.

0:39:36 I was just wondering, you mentioned kind of how you measured their progress and how you

0:39:41 tracked that.

0:39:42 Could you just kind of go into a little bit more detail there on how you measured their

0:39:47 progress through whether sports or art or dance?

0:39:51 Sure.

0:39:52 Well, it's different for each program.

0:39:53 So for instance, for a fitness program, we would probably do a pre-test at the beginning.

0:39:59 So whether that was how many sit-ups you could do then and how many sit-ups you could do later.

0:40:04 That's just an example of how we might track that.

0:40:07 And then we would do a post-test at the end of the program and that would tell us if the

0:40:12 kids were able to reach their goals and our goals.

0:40:16 Thank you.

0:40:17 Yes.

0:40:18 Chris?

0:40:19 I'll let you look at the comment.

0:40:21 As former juvenile administrator of the county, it became intimately aware of juvenile crime.

0:40:28 And I'm sure that your program is instrumental in closing that window of opportunity, which

0:40:34 usually happens right after school until the parents get home by providing a safe and

0:40:40 a monitored play area for the kids.

0:40:42 Could you speak to that a little bit?

0:40:44 Absolutely.

0:40:45 Well, the stats can't speak for themselves on that, as you know, and as you just said,

0:40:50 the juveniles between the hours of 3 o'clock when school gets out in 630 is the most prime

0:40:56 time for them to be getting into trouble. So for us to be able to provide this safe place

0:41:01 and the funds that we provided for were just for our club view program. But the club is

0:41:06 open until 10 o'clock. We are providing new sports programs. So it's not just, it goes

0:41:13 beyond 6.30. Anytime you go by the club you're going to see vehicles there and we're providing

0:41:19 a team group. So we're providing essential services that we need in this community.

0:41:25 Okay, thank you, Lindsey.

0:41:30 One of the things that probably one of the rewards that a person gets when you

0:41:34 hear a teacher and later in principals, you get to see your former students

0:41:38 grow up and be leaders in our community and we appreciate it. Well, thank you

0:41:42 and I appreciate this opportunity and thank you.

0:41:46 Alright, thank you. Alright, that's the first five. We'll hear

0:41:50 from the next five next week, the other five recipients.

0:41:54 recipients. Moving on to item number two, oh I'm sorry Donald. Well I just want to

0:41:59 say you know to see these five groups come up here and testify in front of the

0:42:04 first of all you get nervous when you come up here I understand that it's not

0:42:08 the most comfortable position right there I've been there many times but I'm

0:42:12 proud of each of these five organizations and what they do for our

0:42:15 community they're really touching people's lives and so I wanted to say you said

0:42:20 Thank you to us. I want to say thank you to you. Thank you. All right. Thank you, Don. I

0:42:26 move it on to item number two consideration of the creation establishment of various committees

0:42:31 of the city council of the city of Twin Falls to ensure the city operating compliance with

0:42:35 resolution 1912, which we passed last week. Transparenting and government resolution.

0:42:42 Travis Rothweiler. Mr. Mayor members of the council, before you are a series of different

0:42:48 opportunities in these different community work groups and committees that we've

0:42:53 discussed over the course of the last few weeks and now it is incumbent upon us to

0:43:00 make sure that we take these committees in some form and that we turn them into

0:43:05 officially recognized groups of the council. And part of that this evening is

0:43:11 going to be that exercise to talk about what those look like. Tonight we're not

0:43:16 going to go forward and create the resolution, but we're hoping that you provide the framework

0:43:21 for that resolution, and then that resolution will appear at your council meeting next week.

0:43:25 And so what we're hoping to do is to receive bad guidance from you tonight as we kind of

0:43:30 go forward.

0:43:32 Staff is provided and outlined of some of the thoughts and concepts that we have, and by

0:43:36 no means is it designed to be an end all and be all, but it is certainly designed hopefully

0:43:42 as a conversation starter, and we're happy from a staff perspective to have a conversation

0:43:47 from our perspective about the value and the nature of these different work groups.

0:43:51 One of the things that you'll see that is different or is missing from this is our council

0:43:56 appointments to council advisory commissions.

0:44:00 Really that is the place of the council.

0:44:02 These are advisory commissions that serve a function of advising the council on a myriad

0:44:07 of different issues.

0:44:08 is happy to participate in any role of what that looks like, but we really didn't define

0:44:14 that as part of a process this evening. We recognize that the Idaho Code already does provide guidance

0:44:19 on that matter, and with Idaho Code providing that guidance, we felt that from a staff perspective

0:44:26 we would focus on those areas where maybe the Idaho Code is less clear and maybe on those

0:44:32 areas that are more specific to the City of Twin Falls.

0:44:37 There are a series of ways in which we can approach this and tackle this.

0:44:40 I can outline all of the different work groups that we've had over the course of the last

0:44:45 few, at least one that we've had conversations about, and we can hit them individually, or

0:44:51 I could present them all in a single go, and we can have a question and answer at the conclusion

0:44:59 whatever is easiest for the Council in the conversation.

0:45:02 Council issues?

0:45:03 Just talking?

0:45:04 Well, I have nothing but compliments. I think that identifies at least these four

0:45:10 agencies goals, the structure, how it operates, and

0:45:16 with the problem, there being more than two councils, and some of them we can deal with a little bit downstream.

0:45:22 I have no questions. I think it provides a council with

0:45:26 important guidance.

0:45:28 And so I would you want just outline them in maybe just by title only if there's any questions

0:45:34 So we've been with the four four committees that were referring to because I do it's our only four committees at this time that we have

0:45:42 There's no appointments that this time of year

0:45:46 and things so

0:45:47 Certainly mr. Mayor members of the council the first is going to be the economic development ready team the purpose of that

0:45:53 That group is to assemble those key economic development partners and to talk about economic

0:46:00 development strategy and opportunities that we have in really furthering the strategic

0:46:07 plan of the city.

0:46:08 I do have one light.

0:46:09 I may have ever catch it before.

0:46:11 We get too far into this.

0:46:13 Suzanne.

0:46:14 Thank you.

0:46:17 Try to gather my thoughts and do this.

0:46:19 In the economic development team, first was created, it was your committee, correct?

0:46:25 And so you could invite who you wanted to that.

0:46:29 In the process of last week's motion, when Chris mentioned only having two council members

0:46:34 on a committee, I wasn't thinking through with the economic development team, and here's

0:46:39 my concern.

0:46:42 On the economic development team, of course, the mayor has a place at that table because

0:46:46 because he is the signing, he or she is the signing figure for the city.

0:46:51 And with no disrespect to Sean not being here tonight with him being the CEO of the Chamber

0:46:55 of Commerce, he's included in a lot of those things in that position.

0:47:00 So that really locks the other five of us out of any opportunity for economic development.

0:47:05 And I think I made it really clear during my election this last year that I'm very interested

0:47:09 in economic development and would like a bigger piece at that table.

0:47:13 And I'm afraid maybe by having only two members and because of Sean's dual role that we didn't

0:47:19 think this committee through all the way because I don't want to be excluded from economic

0:47:22 development in the future.

0:47:24 So I don't know how or where we can, what we can do with this.

0:47:28 Start making exception for this one, where do we stop then?

0:47:32 I mean that's what we're paid to do, our homework and see the consequences on it, Susan.

0:47:38 At that time I didn't see this as a committee of the Council, I thought it's Travis's committee,

0:47:42 it when it fall under those guidelines. Now that we're taking the next step, that's why

0:47:49 I'm addressing it now before we decide what to do with the committee. I don't think it's

0:47:52 fair to lock five council members out of any opportunity of economic development in

0:47:57 that position. I just don't know what we do with it. That's why I'm throwing it out there

0:48:01 to see if anybody has any suggestions.

0:48:03 Thank you, Mayor. I actually had taken note of that because of the way that membership

0:48:10 is designed, I think a simple fix would be to have a rotation and take turns in and you

0:48:17 might need another representative from the Chamber of Commerce because I do believe that

0:48:22 even though, you know, Councilman Berger wears two hats, he's always a council member and

0:48:29 so even when he sits on the committee as a chamber president, it does violate our rule

0:48:34 if we have more than two.

0:48:36 But rather than make an exception to the rule, I would just advise us to maybe have rotating

0:48:42 seats on that or take part in a different way or maybe have a representative from the

0:48:49 chamber instead of limiting ourselves to that one particular position in that organization.

0:48:57 But I also don't have a problem with just the mayor and another council member because

0:49:03 As we know, the council deals with these step-by-step

0:49:06 in executive session, so we all do participate

0:49:10 and we get to have obviously the driving force

0:49:14 behind these development deals

0:49:16 and that we get our voice in there.

0:49:18 So I'm comfortable, but I feel like we should

0:49:22 stick to our resolution and just make sure we're careful

0:49:24 to have two sitting members of the council on that team.

0:49:28 Just to follow up Susanne a little bit, no due respect to your concern, but I would guess

0:49:34 that most of the Council are interested in the economic development. We'd all like to

0:49:39 serve. I still go back to the original argument. I had that three gets uncomfortably close

0:49:45 to a working majority and that two was a limit. If we can do something as Rebecca suggested

0:49:53 or may or not serving in all the time,

0:49:56 and I think it would serve their purpose,

0:49:59 and also to rotate maybe membership

0:50:01 on some of these groups too.

0:50:04 I'm gonna chime in here a little bit.

0:50:10 Two of the people back to this is back to Suzanne's concern.

0:50:16 It may be since I've, for the last two years,

0:50:18 have been being able to be very, very close

0:50:20 to the economic development serving on this,

0:50:22 plus our recent successes.

0:50:27 The President's CEO of the Chamber is incredibly important on this committee, especially going

0:50:33 forward when we start crafting the deals and the outside.

0:50:37 I just don't see how you leave that person off the committee.

0:50:41 And to be quite honest with you, these groups want to talk to the mayor.

0:50:46 They do.

0:50:47 I mean, we don't have the same form of government that other cities have, but they don't know

0:50:54 that.

0:50:55 You can tell them, but they really don't know that.

0:50:56 used to the mayor being somewhat all powerful and they wanted if they want the

0:51:03 mayor telling them that this is what this is going to happen or they don't

0:51:06 believe that it's going to happen and so I'm really concerned about those those

0:51:11 two I don't know how we get around it with the with our two members but be

0:51:14 honest with you I know obviously I'm only got a couple few weeks left as being

0:51:18 mayor and obviously I will be coming off that committee but whoever's secedes me

0:51:23 is mayor from this group. People are going to want to talk to them. That's all there is to it. Now, maybe they can come in later at the deal portion of it or something that that's

0:51:34 going to put those are two pretty critical people. And it does point to the problem. This committee, to be honest with you, was my only concern about the limit of two. And so I'm not sure where we go. I'm just putting forth my thoughts on

0:51:53 Maybe supporting Suzanne's thoughts on this matter, but

0:51:57 Obviously it's gonna be a group decision. So we may have to work that out later. I think I think it should become a

0:52:04 big committee of the council and it has not been before but I think it should be so that we can be open and transparent

0:52:13 When we get down to talking names, and I think the media understands that though

0:52:17 We're gonna probably have to

0:52:18 The committee the ready team itself is going to have to go into executive session at certain points. We just don't have a choice

0:52:28 Certainly Sean. Thank you. Hi, and can everyone hear me there? All right. Yes, the baby's talking a little louder if you can

0:52:38 Okay, well I'm just a second here. I

0:52:43 Have the concerns that are expressed with my dual role

0:52:49 But I might mention as well that when the economic development ready team is dealing

0:52:57 with companies, as long as those companies are still looking in other locations, those

0:53:06 actually qualify under the open meeting and the executive session type.

0:53:15 And really at that point, the counsel, the full counsel is typically engaged in that

0:53:21 as well, and the ready team really becomes kind of the planning, those types of things,

0:53:35 and those types of things, of too many council people on that team.

0:53:49 And it's...

0:54:08 Thank you, John.

0:54:09 Rebecca, may I say it?

0:54:11 Yes, thank you, Mayor.

0:54:12 Just a follow-up comment on your suggestion, Travis, to keep the location of the committee

0:54:20 in the overflow room in St. Luke's.

0:54:22 I can support that with the size of the committee and the nature of the discussions.

0:54:27 I really appreciate bringing this committee out in the public eye, and I think the public will appreciate it.

0:54:34 Because I think a lot of concerns and questions I've gotten have been, how do I participate?

0:54:40 If I have a concern or I have a comment, where do I go?

0:54:43 You know, these things seem so, you know, they lay low for so long and they're just there, and people want to participate.

0:54:51 want to participate. So I think this is a really great move of the Council and I

0:54:56 appreciate it. Just a quick comment. I know I'm jumping ahead a little bit with

0:55:02 the Zoning Ordinance Amendment Committee. I know there's a recommendation to also

0:55:06 keep that meeting place in the side room. But with the nature, I think the nature of

0:55:10 the discussions are a little bit different for the ZOAC Committee because

0:55:14 those discussions should be public and I think there's really no

0:55:19 difference in in streaming a meeting like that and then when you come to a

0:55:25 recommendation and and I think that the more public input and awareness on that

0:55:29 committee is really positive things especially because it's a small committee

0:55:32 there are six seats here and and everyone can have a mic at the table but

0:55:38 but I understand the nature of economic development and and the large group that

0:55:42 meets and so I support your recommendation there. Mr. Mayor,

0:55:47 Okay.

0:55:48 Sure.

0:55:49 Just so that, so in the event that individuals don't have access to the agenda, the idea is

0:55:55 because of the size of the committee, you're talking that ranges in place of up to, from

0:56:02 my bike, I believe it's about 12 upwards to sometimes beyond 40 when you get both groups

0:56:09 together.

0:56:10 And so it's very large.

0:56:11 And trying to get 40 people on the dais might be a little cramped.

0:56:17 But know that we will publish it.

0:56:20 And so that there will be open access, it will be published, it will be the location

0:56:25 will be described, we will take meeting minutes, we will place those meeting minutes online

0:56:31 as we do all of our other groups.

0:56:34 The only difference is it will probably, like in this case it would fall more in line like

0:56:38 with our airport and advisory group because they are the only one that also meets outside

0:56:43 where it won't be streamed.

0:56:45 that is the only general exception and I appreciate the consideration on that and

0:56:50 certainly recognize on the ZOAC rather than need to have that up here.

0:56:55 Well I'm not even thinking up here Travis what really what I'd like to see is these

0:57:00 working groups many times it's it's good to be down on a table on the flat

0:57:04 ground looking at each other eye to eye and discussing issues so I would

0:57:09 encourage us as a city to figure out how we can stream down here as well or in the overflow

0:57:15 or you know I don't know if there's a such thing as a mobile streaming unit okay I'm not

0:57:20 smart enough to figure out all that stuff.

0:57:22 Thank you, you know.

0:57:23 In terms of moving over.

0:57:24 Here's what you want to pay for it.

0:57:26 But those type of activities because a lot of the good work that's done isn't you know

0:57:32 people come here and talk to the council and they stand at that podium and they get nervous

0:57:38 And it just doesn't seem as much of a free-flowing ideas

0:57:43 and questions and answers as it is down on a table.

0:57:47 But we still want to have access for the community.

0:57:50 So.

0:57:51 Yeah, so there is a way to, basically,

0:57:53 we connect multiple cameras to it.

0:57:55 It comes at a pretty hefty price tag.

0:57:57 And it's one that I think because of the price tag

0:58:00 and the fact that we've just immersed ourselves in this system,

0:58:02 we haven't really explored fully.

0:58:05 But if there's the possibility to do it remotely,

0:58:09 we'll be, which to do another location

0:58:12 essentially other than the city council chambers

0:58:13 would be extremely expensive.

0:58:15 Now, where's it like $40,000 plus $1,000?

0:58:17 But here, if we got another camera or move the camera,

0:58:21 or is there possibility that we could do more

0:58:24 in the overflow or get another camera?

0:58:28 Couldn't we do it right here and just get everybody a mic?

0:58:30 You can add multiple cameras,

0:58:31 which would change those angles up.

0:58:33 It might be nice to create that atmosphere.

0:58:35 And the reason, because I know people are probably watching this,

0:58:38 the reason that price tag is so heavy

0:58:40 is because we protect the integrity of all those videos

0:58:43 we record, we have to keep them in perpetuity.

0:58:46 So that's why there's a heavy price tag on it.

0:58:48 It's a system that with a Columbia

0:58:51 basically archives that it stores it

0:58:53 and on multiple servers.

0:58:55 Well, I was just thinking another camera,

0:58:56 and that would be the camera on a table down below

0:59:00 or something, Josh.

0:59:01 I don't know how all that works, but that kind of makes sense to me.

0:59:05 If there's direction on that, I can certainly explore that with...

0:59:09 I would be interested in that person. I don't know how the rest of the room...

0:59:12 Yeah, suppose to the overflow room?

0:59:14 Overflow or down here? You know, we could set tables up down here and have that

0:59:19 streaming there. Because again, I think, honestly believe that the face-to-face

0:59:24 around a table discussion is really important for human beings. This is

0:59:28 plastic and little different in conversation. I think you'll find you'll

0:59:34 have as much problem or more with the audio than the video. The camera can do

0:59:37 a crowd shot fairly easy but to get an adequate audio level will be a little

0:59:42 difficult if we have a large table.

0:59:46 We'll have some ideas. We'll have some ideas and bring them back.

0:59:48 We're back in Melsoik and then Suzanne Hocken.

0:59:50 Thank you Mayor. Yeah I would be interested in exploring that but depending

0:59:55 on the price tag I think if there's a way we can accommodate you know even if

0:59:59 If we maybe just use this area depending on the cost to the taxpayers, I think if we can

1:00:05 utilize what we have it, it would probably be best.

1:00:08 One of the things that Josh and I've already talked about is the opportunity to kind of

1:00:12 do more of a split screen when we're for those that are viewing it, because oftentimes what

1:00:17 happens is we will direct individuals' attention to the screen, and that screen is not something

1:00:24 that is visible when you try to observe that online and really is only visible when you're

1:00:31 here and when you're going forward with the presentation, maybe something complex like

1:00:36 our budgeting process, something like finance report or something that is intensive where

1:00:41 you're talking and illustrating a story using other means of technology and that is not showing.

1:00:48 It really does maybe lose that to the viewer.

1:00:51 So we've talked about what that looks like and we'll continue to explore that.

1:00:55 We certainly want to make sure that the committees that are created have the easiest of working conditions

1:01:04 per se, so we'll continue to explore what those technology opportunities are and we'll

1:01:09 bring those back to you.

1:01:10 All right.

1:01:11 So Travis, you want to talk about the second committee?

1:01:14 So the second is really up to the council.

1:01:17 The Council is going to be the wastewater plant operator extension contract.

1:01:21 We've had conversations about and staff has made the presentation to the Council in an

1:01:28 executive session on why we believe that it's important to look at renegotiating a contract

1:01:34 with the OMI, the city's wastewater plant operator now known as CH2M Hill.

1:01:40 It's always been part of the parent company, but they're all now merging in.

1:01:45 And really, we have a couple of options.

1:01:47 They're at my request again, this was a group

1:01:50 that was in a sense created by me,

1:01:53 because after that conversation, the council said,

1:01:55 yes, please go forward and negotiate the contract.

1:01:59 I really wanted to be inclusive in that process.

1:02:02 And so I asked the mayor to assign a couple of council people

1:02:07 to this to assist me.

1:02:08 And now we reach this place where we can continue

1:02:12 to move forward and if a committee is created, I can explain how that would work.

1:02:18 That would be is that because of the term agent and how agent is defined, it is eligible

1:02:25 to go into an executive session and so this group would meet.

1:02:29 They would convene an executive session.

1:02:32 We would continue the negotiations when we reach a place that we were reaching tentative

1:02:36 agreement.

1:02:38 We would come out either I or another member of the staff would make a recommendation to

1:02:46 this committee.

1:02:47 The committee's recommendation would be done in an open session.

1:02:51 That was noticed in accordance with the open meeting clause.

1:02:55 That notice then or that recommendation would then be forwarded to the City Council and

1:03:00 the City Council would consider that item at a subsequent City Council meeting.

1:03:08 And even they may hear the item in one evening, delay action until a subsequent meeting, just

1:03:15 to ensure that there was enough time in between the two public presentations, if you will,

1:03:24 and the Council's decision moving forward.

1:03:27 The other piece of that is, in accordance with the Idaho Code, part of my responsibility is

1:03:32 to negotiate those contracts and then present that tenant of agreement to you for your consideration.

1:03:37 And in that, we would still recommend that we would present the merits of that tenant of

1:03:42 agreement to you and upon that presentation, staff would ask on the agenda item that you

1:03:49 did not take Council action on that evening, that you would delay any Council action for

1:03:54 a week or longer depending upon which you felt the appropriate public notice period was and

1:04:00 then to be able to move forward with hopefully clear direction from the council on the steps

1:04:08 that need to go forward with that agreement.

1:04:11 I'm going to select.

1:04:12 Thank you, Mayor.

1:04:13 I actually appreciate the second alternative that you've proposed.

1:04:17 I think it's a little bit simpler and just as good at accomplishing the goals as far as

1:04:24 going into executive session, getting direction from the council, negotiating the contract and

1:04:29 then having us look at that. But I'm open to a committee as well. I just think that the second

1:04:36 alternative that you outlined is maybe a little more efficient.

1:04:43 Greg, I'm certainly willing to drop off that committee to bring it down to two.

1:04:49 All right, well, what's the council wishes Rebecca is,

1:04:52 that's obviously, and obviously,

1:04:54 has brought forth possibilities.

1:04:56 She actually prefers that maybe the city manager

1:04:58 just to negotiate the contract, bring it back to us

1:05:01 in one meeting, and then in a subsequent meeting,

1:05:04 maybe one week, maybe two weeks,

1:05:06 we then give the public a chance to look at the contract

1:05:13 and then maybe if there seems to be some controversy about it,

1:05:18 about it, we can always have a public hearing,

1:05:21 and let that second meeting for people to give their chance

1:05:24 for them to state their views.

1:05:27 I'm agreeing with Rebecca.

1:05:30 I think that maybe these types of things,

1:05:35 very technical in nature, we've sat in on these,

1:05:38 very technical in nature staff, especially engineering staff,

1:05:43 has far more input than counsel does on them

1:05:45 because they know what they need,

1:05:47 they know what the permit requirements are.

1:05:50 I think I'm going to review for a back.

1:05:52 I think we just need to make sure,

1:05:54 once brought back, we give plenty of time

1:05:56 for it to be digested by the public

1:05:59 to take a look at what's going on,

1:06:01 rather than having to try to go in the executive session.

1:06:04 That time we'll just have you negotiate it

1:06:06 and then bring it back and we'll make sure

1:06:08 we give plenty of opportunity for public

1:06:10 to not only digest it, but also to comment on it.

1:06:14 should we need to.

1:06:15 Is that, I think I'm getting kind of a consensus on that Travis,

1:06:20 that this will not actually be a committee,

1:06:22 it will just be.

1:06:23 Jack gives a lot work to do now.

1:06:25 So, all right.

1:06:28 Next one is the Zoni Ordinance Amendment Committee.

1:06:31 And this is a group that was created to review a series of Title

1:06:36 10 questions that really arose through the development

1:06:42 and the change of our comprehensive plan.

1:06:45 And I know that the members of the Zowak committee

1:06:49 have really been diving into some of those issues.

1:06:54 And really making that public going ahead and staffing that

1:07:00 is probably a very appropriate decision.

1:07:04 And here it does have only two members of the city council.

1:07:08 It also has two members of the Planning and Zoning Commission.

1:07:12 And it has two members of the community at large that are associated with that.

1:07:19 This is one of the committees that I would speak first and Chris should be up next.

1:07:26 It was always open.

1:07:27 It just wasn't posted.

1:07:28 This is one that we would now be posting and since we seem to be able to hopefully work out something down here where we can stream it at the same time.

1:07:38 This is obviously one where we want as much public input

1:07:41 as we can on it.

1:07:42 And so I would say that my preference would be that we,

1:07:48 obviously we form it as an official committee.

1:07:51 We have two members of the council on it,

1:07:53 along with two members of the planning and zoning commission

1:07:55 as it currently is.

1:07:57 They've been calling in people as necessary from the community.

1:08:01 And then we try to stream it here

1:08:02 and because it already had minutes,

1:08:04 it already had, it was already open,

1:08:07 It just wasn't posted.

1:08:09 And so that would be my dr. Chris talking.

1:08:11 Yeah, first of all, it's horribly cold room up there.

1:08:14 The public's invited, but I think we just wait there.

1:08:17 Participation, but in the year,

1:08:20 so we've been meeting maybe it's 11 months down.

1:08:22 I figure we put in about 40 hours of contact work.

1:08:26 It's an incredibly detailed type of work.

1:08:29 It's not something where you can give it 10 minutes

1:08:31 and forget you have to pick up where you left off.

1:08:35 We're looking at revisions to channel for Title 10 from all across the Western United

1:08:41 States at least, and gotten some really good input on the research that we've been doing.

1:08:47 We have had floating members of the public in, we've had members of the building community

1:08:54 and the business committee who are regular attendees.

1:08:58 And I think we're getting a fairly new look that is going to be a lot more customer friendly

1:09:03 both to the applicants that come in, as well as the public, perhaps, to be able to online

1:09:09 look at Channel Title 10 through some sort of a touchscreen one or two page instead of 50

1:09:17 pages.

1:09:18 But I have to say this is the most intensive committee work I've been involved with, and

1:09:22 it's not for the faint-hearted.

1:09:24 Donald?

1:09:26 You know, I'd agree.

1:09:27 This is one of those work groups that was always open.

1:09:32 We just didn't think through the openness of inviting a bunch of folks.

1:09:37 We purposely went out and invited certain members of the public that were interested

1:09:42 in the discussion that we were having on that particular day.

1:09:46 And we also sent out to the Realtors Association, others that asked for when we were going

1:09:53 to meet, we let them know as well.

1:09:56 So this is just an evolution to move us towards being a little more open.

1:10:01 and taking minutes or recording minutes

1:10:05 and having it live streamed here.

1:10:06 So this is a kind of to me and no brainer.

1:10:09 Let's just make it a committee.

1:10:11 Fish and committee.

1:10:12 Yeah, we're likely to continue for some time too.

1:10:14 Oh, yeah.

1:10:15 Plenty of work to do.

1:10:16 A lot of updating needed to occur.

1:10:19 And that's one of the things we're finding

1:10:22 on almost all of our codes.

1:10:23 We were at the AIC meeting last week,

1:10:27 legislating even one of the ways that they're trying

1:10:30 to streamlining things a little bit as they're dropping off a lot of what are maybe are Mr.

1:10:36 Meaners now and does require public defenders.

1:10:41 It should somebody be accused of them, but they're actually in a fraction level of things.

1:10:46 And so in order to actually increase public defenders to a high higher level and yet keep

1:10:52 the cost at a reasonable level, they're asking, they're looking at a whole variety of state

1:11:00 code to drop from misdemeanor to

1:11:02 infraction. They're asking that each

1:11:04 city look at their own code and reach

1:11:06 county look at their own code to make

1:11:09 sure that we have things we have things

1:11:11 that are misdemeanors that should be

1:11:12 things. So I see that as another

1:11:14 committee that's probably going to be

1:11:16 burgeoning for at some point if we

1:11:18 have very many. I don't know how many

1:11:20 we have that's something we'll have to

1:11:21 please cancel on. But so yes, I would

1:11:25 agree with what we've talked about this

1:11:26 should be a committee and don't like I said I think the only thing we're

1:11:31 changing is posting because I think we have been keeping minutes because every

1:11:34 time you've made a change you've had the detail what that change was kind of so

1:11:39 favorite deep more detail better minutes could be taken so Mr. Mayor members of

1:11:44 the council has for the information that's presented in here the only change

1:11:48 that I am hearing from the council is you would like to have the meeting occur

1:11:52 on the dais or down here if I'm let's be where it can be heard from the public

1:11:59 and like correct and correct and don don's turn is noted the face to face on

1:12:04 some of these certainly does work better well and also just for the public I

1:12:08 mean most folks that come talk to me hate talking up to that podium it's

1:12:14 just nice to sit around the table and talk about issues I will say it never

1:12:18 really gets comfortable. It doesn't and I have to do it once in a while because I

1:12:22 sit on some other committees and it's uncomfortable. Okay, the next one is the

1:12:26 Ureverger Middle Agency Downtown Improvement Committee. This is not

1:12:29 actually our committee but we have a couple we have members on it. Yeah, Mr.

1:12:32 Mayor members of the Council. This is not a committee of the city but members of

1:12:38 the city council have been asked to serve to assist reviewing potential

1:12:45 downtown infrastructure improvements on another note at action today taken by the urban renewal

1:12:50 agency.

1:12:51 They have taken the steps to follow similar processes as the, and following the city council's

1:12:59 lead on their processes as well.

1:13:02 So right now in accordance with the resolution, you have three members that have been selected

1:13:09 to attend those meetings and really the only change that I see here is that you need to

1:13:14 have a selection of two of those members as opposed to.

1:13:18 I might say the first contact meeting, maybe it's the second one. Can't remember. It became

1:13:29 very apparent that you have with the downtown improvement proposals and the money available

1:13:36 of wide spectrum and difference of ideas of how that money to be used. The engineers

1:13:43 want to put in all below ground infrastructure improvement to build the city out to 150,000,

1:13:48 but you wouldn't see anything that's done downtown business want to have things that are sidewalk

1:13:55 up and urban renewal appears to be in the center and I think the council balancing that with

1:14:02 the citizens expectation of getting something that they can see for the money expended is

1:14:07 to really important here.

1:14:10 I wouldn't want to have blessed their hearts.

1:14:13 I will probably irritate every engineer in the world.

1:14:16 I don't want the engineers to direct this solely.

1:14:19 There has to be citizen and user impact on that.

1:14:24 Rebecca, Ms. Lee.

1:14:25 Thank you, Mayor.

1:14:26 I agree.

1:14:26 I sit on that committee with Councilman Talkington

1:14:28 and Councilman Hall.

1:14:29 And I agree that conversations, and I think we've only

1:14:32 had one meeting so far.

1:14:33 So that would be the first.

1:14:35 They were interesting and productive, and I think that this is a very good committee to

1:14:41 have open to the public, because one of the most common questions that I get asked and

1:14:45 that I think the Council gets asked is, what are you doing about downtown?

1:14:48 What's going on downtown?

1:14:49 And I think it's eye-opening, it would be great for the public to know what needs done

1:14:55 underneath the ground, things that you can't see, but are valuable and necessary to do

1:15:02 to move forward and get the end results that we all want for downtown.

1:15:06 So I completely support this being an open meeting and I think it will be a great committee

1:15:13 for people who are interested to come and to watch and even have time to comment to know

1:15:19 that we do get that mix of what the citizens want to see and what they want to have happen

1:15:26 with this money because it, as Councilman Talkington stated, it's very possible that all of the

1:15:33 improvements that are done might not be visible.

1:15:38 So we want to have a good mix of both visible and underground improvements.

1:15:45 I agree, we certainly would like to have pretty sidewalks and trees, but we also want to flush

1:15:54 our toilets.

1:15:55 That's kind of important too.

1:15:56 So you've got to have that underground stuff.

1:15:58 I would just mention to the council that traditionally,

1:16:01 when the incoming mayor comes in, he or she

1:16:07 will contact the rest of the council,

1:16:08 start making different choices on liaison positions,

1:16:12 different choices on these committees as well.

1:16:16 So there's going to be probably some change up

1:16:18 first of the year and some freshening of these committees

1:16:22 anyway.

1:16:23 So to continue this conversation,

1:16:26 I will, since I'm already the liaison to the Urban Renewal Agency, at least right now,

1:16:31 I'll go ahead and drop off this committee, and that way it makes it two that are left currently, Rebecca, as well as Chris.

1:16:39 Thank you, Mayor.

1:16:46 So for the purpose of this evening, I would move that we establish an Economic Development Ready Team Committee,

1:16:54 And a zoning ordinance amendment committee and not form a waste water treatment plant operator contract committee.

1:17:07 I think that's going to be hand-to-hand by staff.

1:17:10 And that we assign only two members of the city council to the Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency Downtown Improvement Committee.

1:17:19 All of this is pursuant to resolution number.

1:17:22 1912.

1:17:23 1912?

1:17:24 1912.

1:17:25 second that. All right I've been moved by Jim Munn and seconded by Chris

1:17:33 Togington that we establish a subcommittee called the economic

1:17:40 developer ready team the one called also that we officially recognize the zoning

1:17:47 ordinance amendment committee and that we only have two members on the urban

1:17:53 renewal downtown improvement committee because it's not actually our committee

1:17:56 So, yes, Donald.

1:17:59 Do we even say two members because it has to be two members, regardless.

1:18:03 And so two of these committees will drop down to two members and then the assignments will

1:18:09 be made.

1:18:10 Up to two members.

1:18:12 Up to, yes.

1:18:13 No more than two.

1:18:14 No more than two.

1:18:15 And I will volunteer since I have already said I'm stepping down as mayor in January 6th

1:18:24 and there will be someone else in the mayor.

1:18:26 If the ready team decides to meet in the meantime,

1:18:28 I will step down from the ready team

1:18:30 to make that down to two members.

1:18:32 And so that we will not be breaking

1:18:34 our that resolution in that manner for that.

1:18:37 If the ready team does meet between now and the end of the year,

1:18:39 I don't know the will, but if it does,

1:18:41 I got one last meeting to go to.

1:18:43 So, I'll all of you.

1:18:45 All right, any other discussion?

1:18:49 We have a roll call vote?

1:18:50 John Hall.

1:18:51 Yes.

1:18:52 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:18:53 Yes.

1:18:54 Greg Lansing.

1:18:55 Yes.

1:18:56 Jim Mon.

1:18:57 Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, just a point in terms of what the next meeting looks

1:19:10 like, we will bring two resolutions back to you for consideration. One on the economic

1:19:15 development ready team. The second will be on the ZOAC committee. Those are our two committees.

1:19:21 The one that you said, and this will be in accordance with Mr. Munn's motion that was passed,

1:19:29 the negotiations will occur and then we will follow those processes as I outlined before.

1:19:34 And then as you're thinking about those appointments to assist the Urban Renewal Agency in that very

1:19:41 worthwhile project, we'll need to have two members at some point to point it to that process.

1:19:47 I don't believe, I don't believe that they're planning on meeting before the first of the

1:19:52 year again.

1:19:53 So there will not be any meetings of that committee until after the holiday season has

1:19:58 concluded.

1:19:59 Thank you, Travis.

1:20:00 Moving on to item number three, consideration of a request submitted by Mr. Timothy Okel

1:20:07 of REO development group LLC to have the city council reconsider its actions on November

1:20:13 25th 2013 to begin negotiations with Beckley Media and complete negotiations with Beckley Media by January 31st

1:20:22 2014 and to be brought to council for consideration the later than February 3rd 2013 Travis Rothwell

1:20:29 I was sitting in there. It should be 2014 because it's 14. I'm sorry. You're right

1:20:34 Mine says 13. I should have caught that myself. Thank you

1:20:36 Mr. Mayor, members of the Council,

1:20:39 and there has been some conversation about this item,

1:20:42 and especially maybe a bit of confusion.

1:20:46 And so what I thought I would do is maybe walk through

1:20:49 the action that you're being asked to consider this evening.

1:20:54 Mr. Wonderlick is here,

1:20:55 and obviously can help guide through this process.

1:20:58 So the first question is,

1:20:59 is why is this issue coming before the city council this evening?

1:21:04 And this issue is coming before,

1:21:06 because the request was made to you.

1:21:09 It was done in a written format,

1:21:12 and it was sent by Mr. Tim Okel

1:21:14 on behalf of REO Development for your,

1:21:19 their request is for you to reconsider that action.

1:21:22 And in order for you to determine

1:21:25 whether or not you're going to reconsider that action,

1:21:27 you must do so in a public setting.

1:21:29 You can't respond to an email that says,

1:21:33 no, we're not going to do it.

1:21:35 the city manager certainly isn't going to stand up and say the council is not going to

1:21:38 reconsider here a reconsideration of that.

1:21:42 So tonight really is just answering the question that has been asked of you and that is do

1:21:49 you want to go forward with a reconsideration hearing?

1:21:56 That is the only question before you.

1:21:57 This is not the time for the actual hearing and to move that forward.

1:22:04 Would you elect to grant Mr. Okel's request staff's recommendation because of the timelines

1:22:12 that have been noted would be to hear this next week at our December 16th regularly scheduled

1:22:19 meeting.

1:22:21 So the action before you this evening is really to debate among yourselves and to determine

1:22:26 whether or not you believe that Mr. Okel and REO development request should be granted.

1:22:35 Staff is here to assist in answering any questions that you might have.

1:22:42 Know that there are representatives of REO development and Mr. Beckley and his team with

1:22:51 back to the media are also available as well.

1:22:58 We turn that over to you.

1:23:01 All right Council and Sean,

1:23:03 make sure that you know that any time you want to speak,

1:23:07 let me know and we'll get you on the list here.

1:23:12 I'm gonna cap this in my thoughts about it.

1:23:15 And for me to consider a reconsideration,

1:23:19 I would have to have in my mind additional information,

1:23:24 critical information that I did not have available to me last time around.

1:23:30 And I'll be honest, I haven't received any critical information that I believe changes

1:23:38 my decision from last time.

1:23:40 That's what we've used in the past if we're going to reconsider a action of the Council

1:23:48 is because we received new information that maybe made the Council decide that they would

1:23:52 like to relook at an issue. That being said, others may have have a different thought process

1:23:58 and I haven't got any lights yet, so if you're just talking to them.

1:24:02 I'll be the sacrificial lamb at this time. When we first brought this to the public's attention

1:24:10 of the meeting here, what was it, two weeks ago now, we were all searching for a procedure,

1:24:17 a process, if you will. If you recall the first step that we took was would we allow a proposed

1:24:24 jump to which we unanimously agreed? As a follow-up, I put the unsuccessful motion up that I would

1:24:34 think the council might at least reconsider at this time to not limit if we're going to

1:24:39 allow not limit proposed jumps to only one. There could be more than one, but to follow

1:24:48 a procedure, starting with Beckley, followed by REO and then the two subsequent groups.

1:24:58 I still think that it does have merit, and I think there could be a little bit of a victory

1:25:04 for everyone, including the citizenry at Twin Falls, if we recognize that we asked Mr.

1:25:11 Bakley to negotiate for landing rights and state property on the north side to which

1:25:17 he didn't pay to fee, and I would agree that that gives him a precedence on the first shot

1:25:24 at a jump. But I do not see personally any reason why REO and the other two applicants

1:25:31 could not follow at some time interval with their own

1:25:37 jump utilizing the city property. So I'll stop talking

1:25:41 right now. But I'm in favor of having more than one allowed

1:25:45 to do it. If they meet the city criteria that we've still

1:25:49 not formulated.

1:25:51 Thank you, Mayor. I'll go ahead and speak to this. I know that

1:25:57 But it's been a long and convoluted process to go through an RFQ, and it has been lengthy,

1:26:06 and so where it stands right now, and I appreciate the request for reconsideration, but I just

1:26:13 can't see the value in starting back over at the RFQ beginning.

1:26:20 And as you may have seen the meeting, we talked about the reasons why we chose Beckley

1:26:25 media, they had a landing site, they followed the process that was outlined and that they

1:26:32 were directed to by the city officially or unofficially.

1:26:38 They went through the correct steps that they were asked to go through and Beckley Media

1:26:45 has demonstrated a financial commitment to the jump to the project.

1:26:53 all of the teams were highly qualified. All of you came with great credentials and credentials

1:27:00 that we can feel confident in and we appreciate all of the applicants. But at this point, I

1:27:07 feel like we need to go through the process that we've committed to. We committed to allowing

1:27:12 Beckley Media to negotiate for around 45 days. If those negotiations aren't fruitful, the

1:27:21 The next strength group will come through, so you still have an opportunity speaking directly

1:27:28 to REO if the negotiations don't work out.

1:27:34 But I feel right now we haven't given time for the process that we've committed to to

1:27:39 see if it is going to accomplish a successful plan for a jump event in 2014.

1:27:48 At this time, I won't be in support of reconsideration.

1:27:52 But as we move forward, keep that in mind that you are the second-rate group and you still

1:28:00 have an opportunity and I think we need to keep our word and we just made this decision

1:28:07 two short weeks ago.

1:28:10 So I think we need to allow time for the negotiations to take place.

1:28:14 It does appear that there's a group forming that involves every agency that permits are

1:28:25 required from and everyone is communicating together and they're moving forward in a positive

1:28:30 manner.

1:28:31 So I'd like to continue on with that commitment.

1:28:34 Sean, I have you down next.

1:28:36 Do you want to speak?

1:28:41 Sean?

1:28:43 We want to speak.

1:28:44 Okay, a couple of things.

1:28:45 Sure.

1:28:46 We can barely hear you though, so if you can speak up, we'll appreciate it.

1:28:50 Yeah, actually, can you ask me, I live?

1:28:52 She can turn her microphone off because I'll like to hear her type.

1:28:55 Okay, so everybody turned her mic off and maybe we can get this point.

1:29:01 Well, I just want to say that I appreciate the request coming in to a really question how we went about,

1:29:13 but it's been over a couple of weeks ago.

1:29:15 I just want to restate that my position really was to try to establish criteria first before

1:29:22 we did the ranking.

1:29:25 And again, I ran through a list of items at that meeting talking about public health

1:29:30 and safety protection and of the marketing image and safe and sane events.

1:29:37 And while I agree that all of the applicants did a great job of presenting a lot of information

1:29:45 from a lot of quote experts, I really did feel that REO's group had the type of skills

1:29:54 that would be associated with the scope and scale of events that they were proposing.

1:29:59 I would be supportive of making sure we get this event right from our side,

1:30:09 from the city side, from the kinds of things that we need to ensure we're protecting

1:30:14 so that we don't have the challenges that we experienced

1:30:18 40 years ago with such an event.

1:30:22 And while I also don't think you've received

1:30:27 a lot of additional information,

1:30:29 if you think that the memorandum from Mr. Beckley

1:30:32 that was sent just prior to the last council meeting

1:30:36 with some threats of legal action may have caused

1:30:48 some council people to make a decision that he was the prepared candidate because of that.

1:30:56 I would be curious to hear from my fellow council members if they were making a decision based

1:31:04 upon that memo that was sent to them.

1:31:09 Thank you, John.

1:31:12 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:31:13 To answer Sean's question, my decision was not based on that letter.

1:31:20 I think it, I made it clear two weeks ago that it was gut wrenching to decide because I

1:31:26 think both groups were equal in their presentations.

1:31:30 But the final sway for me was the fact that they did hold the rights to the landing area.

1:31:34 And that's really, if you look at it, there's no way to compare it apples for apples.

1:31:39 But in my mind, it was as close as it could be.

1:31:42 And the only thing that swayed my decision was the lease with the state, to be honest.

1:31:48 I'll answer your question, Sean, the memorandum, the legal threat, played no part of my decision.

1:31:58 What I was looking for was a good plan, at least on my level, I guess it's a good plan.

1:32:06 You know, I've never jumped to Canyon, so I'm assuming that it's a good plan, but at least

1:32:10 on the surface it looked good.

1:32:11 I was looking for good teams brought together that seemed to address the concerns that I

1:32:17 personally had about safety and about making sure that our images is cared for, and that

1:32:25 financial obligations would be met, those kind of things. And so that was paramount.

1:32:31 And then the reason that I ranked it personally the way I did is because we had two of the

1:32:36 top candidates with a great team, with a great plan, at least again as I could see. They both

1:32:44 had to place the land. It's kind of hard to make a jump and not land somewhere. You've

1:32:48 got to have to place land. So both those entities did. And so that's why personally I ranked it

1:32:53 the way that I did or I agreed to the ranking the way that I did. And I'm not in support

1:33:00 of opening this back up. We have a process that I feel that we can work through. We have

1:33:07 45 days to walk through with Mr. Beckley and his team. And if we're not satisfied at

1:33:13 At the end of that, we can certainly open it up to the next in line, Ariel.

1:33:17 That's how I feel.

1:33:18 Jim Hunt.

1:33:19 Thank you, Mayor.

1:33:23 Just have a few notes here.

1:33:24 Several weeks ago, over the last month, we provided, I believe, effective time in the community

1:33:31 to engage us, for the community to engage us in these concerns, and they did.

1:33:36 We also provided, I believe, ample time for the applicants to provide an overview of their

1:33:41 plan.

1:33:42 deliberately, I believe, on the matter, and we made a decision several weeks to go to offer

1:33:48 that first application opportunity to Ed Beckley, and as I indicated there, I based my decision

1:33:54 on the fact that he does have a landing site and that his plan was fine.

1:34:00 I did not make a decision in regards to a lawsuit in my prior life if I had managed a

1:34:05 police organization based on getting sued or not sued all the time, I wouldn't get anything

1:34:10 done.

1:34:11 So, that was not influential in my decision.

1:34:16 I believe that we have an obligation to negotiate in good faith with Ed Beckley based on our decision.

1:34:23 This is a situation now where we become leaders, not politicians.

1:34:27 We have a lot of people in the community who do not agree with our decision and would rather have gone with REO.

1:34:32 We've made the call. We have an obligation to work with him in good faith.

1:34:36 We have already provided staff with direction and they're moving forward with their

1:34:42 Work and their assignments to get this thing done and for us to waver and get sick at sea

1:34:47 Would be the wrong thing to do at this time. So I am not going to support a re

1:34:53 examination of the ariel application

1:34:56 To do that to do so would be unfair. Thank you

1:34:59 Thank you.

1:35:00 Travis.

1:35:01 Mr. Mayor, members of the Council and maybe just so it would be remiss if I didn't share,

1:35:07 because lots of individuals had submitted information and I want to make sure that that information

1:35:11 did get to you.

1:35:14 So just because, you know, I want to, they submitted information to us.

1:35:19 So, Ms. Cheryl Wheeler had submitted a petition and in that petition we scanned that in earlier

1:35:25 today and we provided that copy to you and I just wanted to-

1:35:28 We saw that.

1:35:29 Yep.

1:35:30 And that is made for the record.

1:35:31 You also received other numerous letters and pieces of correspondence in addition to legal

1:35:37 briefs and memorandum that were submitted by both Beckley Media as well as REO Development.

1:35:42 So I just wanted to make sure that individuals who may not have access to your packets or

1:35:49 realize that we had sent this, understood that the information that was sent to you in this

1:35:57 process. So for example, Ms. Wheeler did come into my office and she did give me her

1:36:04 petition and I wanted to make sure that she understood that I was going to provide

1:36:07 that to you and because I didn't mention it, I didn't want you to think that you know I...

1:36:10 Can we put that out on our website? Can we scan all that information, put it out for

1:36:14 the community? Certainly our intent and we can certainly put all the public

1:36:18 comments out there, we can put all... What about correspondence with these different

1:36:21 groups with us? In fact, we've received correspondence from several

1:36:25 Well, Mr. Beckley's legal team, REO's legal team, is that public information?

1:36:30 Yes.

1:36:31 I think that should also be put out there for the community to digest.

1:36:34 We can certainly place.

1:36:36 I know a benefit of this public interest.

1:36:39 Absolutely.

1:36:40 They need to see all the information that we see.

1:36:41 We can't do a few extra trays to scan it in on that.

1:36:45 It's all recycled.

1:36:47 I would think it'd be no trees.

1:36:48 I think that's really important.

1:36:49 We do have a different dish to the light for Beckley.

1:36:52 Thank you, Mary.

1:36:53 Thank you for mentioning that, Travis.

1:36:55 I did want to mention, I only received two letters of input,

1:36:59 one the petition from Cheryl Wheeler,

1:37:01 and then a letter that I believe the entire council got

1:37:03 from Mr. Francis Florence.

1:37:05 And I would like that to be in the record,

1:37:08 just so that the public can view that as well.

1:37:11 So I think it's a great idea.

1:37:12 Thank you, Councilman Munn.

1:37:14 I must have, and I maybe I should have,

1:37:17 I assumed that they were sending them to all councilors.

1:37:19 I did receive a few other emails mostly last weekend,

1:37:23 will make sure to get them to make sure that they are in the public record as well.

1:37:28 I tried to answer many of them and I tried to answer almost all of them with the same thing

1:37:37 and I'm stealing this from Suzanne because she was one of the come up with this is that

1:37:45 if I'm choosing with my heart I'm choosing Mr. Dasher. I know Mr. Dasher and I know what he's done for

1:37:50 our community, but I chose with my best

1:37:53 Jasmine and that best Jasmine felt that

1:37:55 Mr. Beckley had the, not only did he

1:38:00 have the landing site, but there was some

1:38:03 members of his team that just made me

1:38:04 feel better about the possibility of

1:38:06 this being a effective jump with least

1:38:09 amount of effect upon our community and

1:38:12 so that's the reason I chose as I did.

1:38:14 To be honest with you, the letter tried

1:38:17 to sway me the other direction. It almost

1:38:20 made me want to vote against Mr. Spector's group just because I got the letter about the

1:38:25 threatened lawsuit. So I guarantee it didn't have any effect on me, but anything, it softened

1:38:30 my stance going in following the presentation. And some of the other ones that we received

1:38:36 that Jim was talking about that we need to put on for both teams. Yes, I think the public

1:38:40 needs to be able to have a look at all the information that we've been provided. And I

1:38:44 will not be voting for a reconsideration, but I also will put it out there that and I think

1:38:51 everybody in the council feels the same way. If we're not fruitful, we're coming to you

1:38:56 guys and have something ready for us because if we don't get to where we need to and Mr.

1:39:00 Beckley, that's not an open thing that well we're just saying that to make everybody

1:39:07 feel good. If we're not where we need to be in 45 days, we're going to look for somebody

1:39:12 who will get us where we need to be, okay?

1:39:15 And that's, I think Mr. Bakley has made a lot of strides

1:39:18 towards that that won't happen,

1:39:21 but that's where we're at at this point.

1:39:23 Chris, do I?

1:39:24 A little extra food for a thought,

1:39:26 clearly my idea to allow more than one

1:39:29 in some subsequent time schedule

1:39:31 is not acceptable by the council.

1:39:34 Let's look at it this way.

1:39:37 If an applicant comes to us in 60 days, 90 days, 180 days,

1:39:41 are we going to say no?

1:39:42 because we had chosen to only go with Mr. Beckley.

1:39:47 What is so sacred about September 9th to 14th,

1:39:50 whatever the date is?

1:39:52 Who knows if the Zebel Kniebel may be the next hot spot

1:39:56 for everybody to try to make their reputation, if you will?

1:40:02 Are we going to, because we said no to REO,

1:40:05 the night to follow up with Beckley,

1:40:08 say no to all subsequent applicants?

1:40:12 I thought the case, but Mr. Beckley also has a two-year lease on the landing area.

1:40:17 So that that the boy's into my thoughts a little bit on it.

1:40:21 Well, if he wants to sublet it, then I suppose somebody may be coming to talk to us.

1:40:26 Jim, what?

1:40:27 He doesn't have a lease on the on the launch site.

1:40:31 But he does on the landing area.

1:40:33 There are other landing areas.

1:40:37 Anyway, I just put that out for food for thought.

1:40:39 So we're not going to allow it again for anyone.

1:40:42 I don't think for perpetuity, but at least until this particular jump is taken, that's my thoughts, but I'm only one person.

1:40:49 I'm going to defer my time to Suzanne. Suzanne Huygens.

1:40:53 I just want to reply to Chris real quick. I don't think we want to turn that jump site into a public spectacle, and no, I don't think I would consider another group for quite some time.

1:41:02 I think it needs to be something done that is special and unique and not run it into the ground personally.

1:41:12 It was built to be a spectacle, Susan.

1:41:14 Oh, Chris, I think you have a valid point.

1:41:18 The way I look at it, and I think Sean probably swayed me a little bit last time we were discussing

1:41:23 this, that this type of event needs to have momentum, it needs to have the financial resources

1:41:29 to make it successful.

1:41:30 I'm not going to tell you that I wouldn't be interested in the future, and I don't know

1:41:34 how far out that is, but I think that's a valid point.

1:41:39 I don't know if we want to have a jump a year, but I'm certainly open to what's up the 50th anniversary

1:41:46 Yes, what's magic about this 40th anyway? Yeah, I don't disagree. I doubt if any of us will be on the council for that you will Chris

1:41:57 Okay, I guess I'll do it

1:41:58 I will I'd make I would move to deny the request made by mr. Timothy Okel of the area

1:42:03 REO development group to have the City Council

1:42:06 reconsider actions of 25 November 13th.

1:42:10 Second.

1:42:11 It's been moved by Jim on the second by Rebecca

1:42:13 Ms. So I can do to deny the request of Tim

1:42:16 of the Oak Library of Development

1:42:18 to reconsider our actions of November 25th.

1:42:25 I'm gonna vote in favor, but you need to know

1:42:27 that I'm not voting in favor against you.

1:42:29 I just think we need to go through the process.

1:42:32 I think that you had a fine team and miles and what you do for our community is commendable,

1:42:38 but we made our choice to go this direction and we'll see what happens in 45 days.

1:42:47 Leah, let's see no more, we're likely to have the Rocco vote.

1:42:51 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:42:52 Yes.

1:42:53 Greg Lanstein.

1:42:54 Yes.

1:42:54 Jim Biden.

1:42:55 Yes.

1:42:55 Rebecca Melsweka.

1:42:56 Yes.

1:42:57 Chris Talkington.

1:42:57 No.

1:42:59 Sean Berger.

1:43:00 No.

1:43:01 Don Hall.

1:43:02 Yes.

1:43:03 Motion passes five to two.

1:43:07 Hey, moving on to item number four,

1:43:10 which is an opportunity for public input input.

1:43:16 Oh, actually, I take that back.

1:43:17 I remember for discussion on the Canyon jump process.

1:43:20 I just missed one.

1:43:21 Go ahead.

1:43:21 Mr. Mayor, members of the council,

1:43:22 will it be possible to read a five minute recess?

1:43:25 I believe so.

1:43:26 We've almost been here two hours, so yes.

1:43:28 Five minute recess.

1:43:33 Oh, got a message already.

1:51:16 Somebody watched and told me I did, bro.

1:51:20 Travis, are we ready?

1:51:23 Liala, you wanna turn us on?

1:51:25 You're on?

1:51:26 All right.

1:51:28 Reconvening the December, what is this,

1:51:32 ninth meeting of the Football City Council.

1:51:35 And if you'd Travis Roth,

1:51:37 whether you're talking about discussion on jump,

1:51:39 can you jump process?

1:51:41 So Mr. Mayor, members of the Council,

1:51:42 what I wanna do is I really kind of want to share the steps

1:51:46 that we've taken over the course of the past week,

1:51:49 and then really engage and ask the council

1:51:53 on how you would like to see this process continue

1:51:56 to move forward and to involve as we discussed

1:51:59 and shared with you last week.

1:52:02 We have a series of folks that I think it's important

1:52:04 that you hear from this evening.

1:52:06 In terms of our process,

1:52:07 I want to provide just maybe a general outline,

1:52:10 and then I'm going to turn some time over

1:52:13 to Mr. Beckley and his team.

1:52:16 which includes John Simmons and his legal counsel.

1:52:19 In addition to that,

1:52:21 Patrol Captain Anthony Barnhart

1:52:23 with our police department,

1:52:25 who has been designated as our primary liaison

1:52:27 when it comes to public safety.

1:52:30 So over the course of the last week,

1:52:35 we've been in exchange and had a series of conversations.

1:52:40 We've supplied a member of Mr. Beckley's team

1:52:44 with a list of just general contacts that we have

1:52:49 and who people who may be available for them

1:52:53 to begin that communication process.

1:52:55 We've also reached out to some of them as well.

1:53:00 We believe that they had a series of meetings today

1:53:02 and maybe Mr. Simmons can describe

1:53:05 what those meetings look like and how they transpired.

1:53:09 Also, they met with our patrol team,

1:53:14 specifically Chief of Police Brian Pike and, again, Anthony Barnhart, and they can talk about

1:53:19 that aspect of the project.

1:53:21 We continue to dialogue with ICRIMP, and one of our purposes of meeting with ICRIMP is to

1:53:26 make sure that there is no transference or possible transference of liability.

1:53:31 We want to make sure that this is not an event that is seen to be cities, and therefore it is

1:53:37 not something where liability is transferred directly or indirectly to us.

1:53:43 So we've asked them because they really are our liability experts to assist us in building

1:53:50 a list of considerations in terms of things that we may need to protect the city, to protect

1:53:57 our residents, to ensure that from a liability perspective, we don't necessarily have that

1:54:02 exposure.

1:54:04 Mr. Beckley's team has provided us with a series of contracts and agreements for us to

1:54:10 review of events that have transpired at other places, and we'll look at those for guidance

1:54:17 and we'll incorporate also language from the state lease.

1:54:21 We think that the state lease is very thorough, and we will utilize some of that information

1:54:30 as we go forward and construct that.

1:54:34 We've had a considerable request, and they've been more coming in the form of question and

1:54:45 comment in terms of what does public involvement look like?

1:54:50 How are we going to accept public comment?

1:54:52 How can the public be infused and their thoughts and their comments be incorporated into this

1:54:58 process aside from just maybe submitting an email or a letter or a petition but actual true

1:55:06 involvement I think it's important to recognize that this area has significantly transformed

1:55:13 since 1974 and there are a lot of members out there that have an interest and it's a private

1:55:23 property interest but I think beyond that this is my home interest and I

1:55:28 think that they would appreciate more than just a couple of minutes of

1:55:32 dialogue to air their thoughts and concerns but really possibly be engaged

1:55:38 in that process and so finding some way to ensure that it was inclusive I think

1:55:43 is going to be important and then really I know that or at least I don't know but

1:55:48 what I suspect with some degree of great certainty that you've probably been contacted by members

1:55:54 of the community as well in terms of what they would like to see and so really when the council

1:56:00 went forward and they made their selection and we started that process we did not spend

1:56:07 a lot of time talking about that public involvement piece and I think that that needs to be probably

1:56:13 we want of those those those cornerstones of what this looks like in moving forward.

1:56:18 So as you're thinking about that and hearing I'd like to now turn some time over to our

1:56:23 chief of police and Captain Anthony Barnhart to talk about their meeting today and in terms

1:56:28 of what they learned and then after that we'll turn it over to Mr. Simmons and Mr. Beckley.

1:56:46 Good evening Mr. Mayor and City Council.

1:56:49 we did meet with Mr. Simmons and Mr. Beckley and really it was just a starting point, an

1:56:54 introduction for us to get to know each other. For us at the Police Department we really view

1:57:01 this event kind of as a two-pronged approach. We have the public safety as far as maintaining

1:57:07 our service levels that we're going to have to do during the event while at the same time

1:57:12 trying to work on providing a safe atmosphere for the event. So it is definitely going to stretch

1:57:18 our resources. Today's meeting, however I thought went well, there are no solid plans

1:57:24 in place, so it's a little bit hard to come up with specific details as far as public

1:57:29 safety is concerned, but we shared some philosophies with them, and primarily the fact that our overriding

1:57:36 concern is that we have a safe event, and at the same time are able to maintain providing

1:57:45 that service that our citizens have come to expect.

1:57:49 They did share with us the fact that they envision a good majority of the events on this

1:57:58 particular day to take place on the north side of the canyon as opposed to the south side

1:58:03 to the Falls County side and we can understand that due to the size of the land and some of

1:58:10 the space issues that they may be facing.

1:58:16 We also shared with them that our vision of really leaning heavily on private security

1:58:22 as opposed to sworn uniform police officers for event security and crowd management.

1:58:29 I think that one of the roles that the police will have at the event would be to address

1:58:36 any type of incidents that are criminal in nature while the private security would man

1:58:43 fences, accept tickets, and possibly deal with cash while the police would primarily deal

1:58:52 with any type of criminal event that may take place at the event.

1:58:58 Overall I thought that the meeting went well, visiting with Mr. Simmons and Mr. Beckley,

1:59:04 And we did make arrangements to meet with their person, Rod Woodruff, who will be in

1:59:10 charge of their security.

1:59:11 I also provided Mr. Simmons with a checklist that I found on the FEMA website that basically

1:59:19 has everything that you could possibly think of that could or possibly go wrong at one of

1:59:24 these special events.

1:59:26 And we asked Mr. Simmons to share that with Mr. Woodruff and hopefully get the majority

1:59:32 of those questions on that checklist answered.

1:59:34 And we are also working off of a FEMA checklist.

1:59:39 So we have done, we have been doing our research

1:59:42 and trying to get up to speed and dealing

1:59:44 with these types of events.

1:59:48 If you have any questions, I'll stand for those.

1:59:54 Thank you, Mayor.

1:59:55 Thank you, Captain Barnhart.

1:59:58 I just wanted to add with the FEMA concept

2:00:02 of hazardous conditions.

2:00:03 Are you also incorporating the county,

2:00:08 I think it's like an emergency planning coordinator,

2:00:11 it's for the county wide,

2:00:14 but they, I believe, meet monthly

2:00:16 and plan for these types of hazard events,

2:00:18 and it might be a benefit to include,

2:00:21 I think, Jackie Fry in on those conversations.

2:00:24 Absolutely, as a matter of fact,

2:00:25 Jackie Fry has already contacted us

2:00:28 and offered her support,

2:00:29 and that's actually one thing that I forgot to mention

2:00:31 that we are going to reach out.

2:00:33 We've started that process,

2:00:35 but we'll get more of these meetings going in the near future,

2:00:39 but we've already started to reach out

2:00:40 to other law enforcement agencies.

2:00:43 And the initial plan right now is to really build

2:00:46 a command staff or an executive group made up

2:00:49 of the chiefs of the sheriffs

2:00:51 and kind of brainstorm this and work through it together,

2:00:54 which would also include our county emergency management.

2:00:58 Great, thank you.

2:01:00 We'll play the north side too.

2:01:02 Absolutely.

2:01:03 They have one as well.

2:01:04 Right.

2:01:10 Seeing none of our lights here, I guess, Travis.

2:01:12 We'll move on to Chief Pankmana.

2:01:14 Talk a little bit first.

2:01:18 I think that Captain Barnhart's probably

2:01:20 giving you a really great overview.

2:01:21 The only thing I would like to add is, and he did mention this,

2:01:24 is that we've been, we had a nice preliminary meeting

2:01:29 with the Beckley Media Group.

2:01:31 And that's really what it was, it's a preliminary meeting.

2:01:34 And we've been waiting along with others to see what this plan looks like and how it develops.

2:01:39 I think we're ready to move forward and part of that would be obviously working with all

2:01:43 the agencies that will be involved, law enforcement, the St. Luke's and the majority of everyone that

2:01:51 would be impacted by this.

2:01:53 So we're really just kind of like everyone in the waiting stages to see what direction

2:01:57 the council is moving.

2:01:58 Once we know what the direction that it is that you're going to move, we're ready to go

2:02:03 to work. We're just assuming now that we'll have some event in September of 2014, so thank

2:02:11 you.

2:02:13 Thank you.

2:02:14 Could I, Chief or Captain, like to make sure that we're aware that the bidding rights for

2:02:21 Mr. Backley included some airspace protection, but I think bringing in our airport manager

2:02:28 to have him ascertain the extent of airspace security.

2:02:34 There are going to be a hell of a lot of choppers and private pilots

2:02:38 and there could be a chaotic mess from a couple hundred feet up on for miles extending.

2:02:46 So I'd like to get that locked up right away to know how you're going

2:02:51 to prevent people from flying there and be identified and tagged afterwards.

2:02:57 We will do that. We, like I said, we are just starting that process, but we will form kind

2:03:03 of an executive planning committee that all those players will be at the table as we move

2:03:08 forward. So we're seeking a lot of input and a lot of help from all the agencies around

2:03:14 the area.

2:03:16 Thank you, Chief Pike. Mr. Rothfiler?

2:03:20 The next group is going to be representatives from Beckley Media and I'll let them determine

2:03:28 which one is going to approach first.

2:03:30 But one of the questions that Mr. Simmons has asked,

2:03:33 and I did forward that on when we talked about last week,

2:03:37 is how big of an event does this look like.

2:03:40 And one of the comments that I shared with Mr. Simmons was

2:03:44 that we didn't really, or I didn't believe,

2:03:46 that the size of the event was really something

2:03:49 that I could dictate.

2:03:51 And I felt that the size of the event that is moving forward

2:03:55 really needs to be part of that public conversation, but more importantly, it needs to be regardless

2:04:01 of the size of the event, it needs to be safe.

2:04:04 That our citizens need to be safe, that the spectators need to be safe, because I think

2:04:07 what is important is that the City of Twin Falls is not going to shut down as a medical

2:04:14 center, as a learning center, as a place of commerce for a geographic area, and we will

2:04:19 still have a level of service that we need to provide to those patrons who routinely come

2:04:24 who are community outside of the opportunities to participate or to observe the events of the day.

2:04:33 So with that I'm going to talk about.

2:04:34 Well I've got a couple of lights that came on since Rebecca was looking.

2:04:37 Thank you Mayor. Thank you for the second question. Before you kind of threw that one out,

2:04:43 I was going to answer your first question about public input before we move on if that's okay.

2:04:48 I think that most of the comments that I've received are homeowners, property owners,

2:04:55 concerned about their property being invaded or people trespassing.

2:05:00 And I like the idea of public input at every meeting that we talk about it.

2:05:07 I mean, every time we talk about this permitting process,

2:05:10 I would like there to be publicized and known to the public that this is your time

2:05:15 to get your concerns in on the front end and perhaps we can make a checklist, you know,

2:05:22 take those names in the locations of those properties that need protection, identify, you

2:05:27 know, routes to and from those places and depending on what the property owners want,

2:05:33 if they want their streets barricaded, if they feel like that would protect them, have

2:05:39 a response plan for each concerned citizen so that they know that they're going to be

2:05:46 protected throughout this event.

2:05:47 And I know that might be a large process, but as we, as specific citizens, come to us and

2:05:56 want to know what are you going to do to protect me during this event?

2:06:02 I just wanted to add that I think we should address each situation and have a plan for

2:06:11 how we're going to protect those citizens and that I'd like to have public input every time

2:06:16 we talk about it.

2:06:17 That's one of the paradoxes of this particular jump site is that most of the nearest neighbors

2:06:22 aren't citizens of the Twin Falls city of Twin Falls yet we were going to need to take

2:06:26 care of it.

2:06:27 I understand that but that is the paradox.

2:06:29 They have chosen to be outside the city for tax reasons, but they're going to be looking

2:06:33 for support from us.

2:06:36 And I think that that's a really good question for the Beckley Media Group.

2:06:42 I mean, really at the end of the day, this is their event.

2:06:48 And I think that it's important that while we have a responsibility to ensure the event

2:06:51 is safe, I think that as we've said all along, we want to make sure that the use of public

2:06:56 dollars in resources for those staffing and those issues is completely contained to the

2:07:02 Beckley Media Group. I think that we as a city need to be a partner. I think that we need

2:07:07 to look at that, but I think that if there are enhanced levels of security that are needed

2:07:16 in these areas and those are areas that are serviced by the Twin Falls County Sheriff's

2:07:21 Department, I think that accommodations need to be made to assist the Twin Falls County

2:07:25 and their deployment of activities and resources.

2:07:28 Just like I don't think that personally,

2:07:30 I don't think that any single entity should feel like

2:07:34 they have to take this on as their own task and project.

2:07:39 Like I think Captain Barnhart stated,

2:07:42 the staffing levels that we enjoy in our different law enforcement

2:07:46 groups in the area are not sized to be able to undertake

2:07:52 undertake a significant process outside of normal scope

2:07:57 and duties and activities.

2:07:59 We are not, we've not been built for these types

2:08:03 of organizations.

2:08:04 In fact, when you look at events that occur at Sturgis,

2:08:08 where I think that Mr. Woodward has his experience,

2:08:12 the city of Sturgis, South Dakota,

2:08:15 doesn't do this on their own either,

2:08:17 that there's lots of assistance that comes in globally.

2:08:22 to assist in the process.

2:08:23 Correct, and let me clarify that definitely the response needs

2:08:27 to be by Beckley Media, and so I just want to make sure

2:08:30 that we're requiring that plan in that response.

2:08:33 Absolutely, and I think that so in terms

2:08:36 of that public response, I believe that we're going

2:08:38 to be bringing this before you every single meeting

2:08:42 to give you an updated public process of where we were.

2:08:46 Some of those updates may be large,

2:08:48 and some of them may be very, very short,

2:08:50 and say that we didn't make much progress this week.

2:08:54 But we always have the end date and the sites

2:08:59 in our targets of when we have to complete that.

2:09:02 I think it's probably also important

2:09:04 that as these different work groups meet,

2:09:07 where there's the true conversation on the front end

2:09:11 of those strategies, it may be an opportunity.

2:09:14 We would encourage anyone watching.

2:09:16 We would encourage anyone listening.

2:09:18 We would encourage our media partners to share that,

2:09:22 to get their names to us so they can be included

2:09:25 on those meeting notification lists

2:09:27 so that we can do everything in our power

2:09:30 to notify those individuals who want to participate

2:09:33 in this process.

2:09:35 We think that that's really important

2:09:37 and we want to make sure that every opportunity

2:09:40 is afforded to those who want to participate.

2:09:43 At whatever level they want to participate.

2:09:46 Travis, can we get a flow chart of some sort,

2:09:50 both our website and just a visual of significant events

2:09:57 through time, or this is now resolved.

2:10:00 You follow what I mean?

2:10:01 Sometimes a very simple type of an idea,

2:10:06 indicating our progress shows us how far we have to go

2:10:09 or other we are making progress.

2:10:11 It might help the public's understanding a little bit.

2:10:14 I think that's something that we can certainly work on and try to put something together that

2:10:20 makes sense so that people can follow.

2:10:21 The next slide, Suzanne Hockens.

2:10:24 I'm not sure if this is for you, Travis or for Fritz.

2:10:27 I know we've said over and over, we're very concerned about not spending taxpayer money

2:10:31 on somebody else's event, but the more we talk, the more staff hours are getting adding

2:10:37 up here.

2:10:39 Do we have a way to collect for the hours we're putting into this?

2:10:44 I don't want to see staff, you know, overwhelmed with this one project at the taxpayers expense

2:10:49 and your normal day-to-day work not getting accomplished because of that.

2:10:53 If you direct us to start keeping track and estimate that, to be able to require that to

2:11:00 be paid by Beckley Media, we can do that.

2:11:03 That would be my feelings on it.

2:11:05 I don't know how the rest of the council feels, but I've seen a lot of dollar signs in man

2:11:10 hours from city staff.

2:11:11 I'd like to be conscientious of that. All right

2:11:17 Mayor, can I chairman sure?

2:11:20 Thank you. I'm sorry. I would flip my light on but it's hard to do that. Yeah, I didn't come on down here

2:11:26 I need to check it. I guess

2:11:28 Jim just turned it on for you. You're good to go. Oh perfect. I you know in addition to the to the public safety

2:11:36 Review and efforts that the police department is gonna be doing

2:11:39 who will be the staff person, or is there a staff person,

2:11:44 or will there be a council decision

2:11:46 talking about potential compensation and improvements

2:11:50 to the actual chump site property as part of the land use?

2:12:00 Please probably ask you new travels.

2:12:08 And to the stand's comment, I think we need to begin

2:12:13 discussing what other compensation there may be

2:12:16 for use of the property.

2:12:20 And I understand your comments, Sean,

2:12:22 because we did not follow the same process as the state.

2:12:26 We did not go into a competitive bed

2:12:28 for the use of our facility, our property.

2:12:31 And so I certainly think that that will be something

2:12:35 that needs to be in considerations

2:12:38 to make sure that the city comes out of this better

2:12:41 than we went in the way I'll put it.

2:12:44 Rebecca Milsoy.

2:12:45 Thank you Mayor.

2:12:46 Perhaps each week in response

2:12:48 to Councilman Berger's comments,

2:12:50 We can address certain aspects of the jump and one being compensation.

2:12:54 I think that's a conversation that Council needs to have.

2:12:57 And I think it would be great to have each update kind of topic related and let the public

2:13:03 know if they have input on what compensation should be given to the citizens that they'll

2:13:09 know that's what we're going to discuss that week and they can come give input.

2:13:14 So that's just a suggestion.

2:13:16 But I think it's a good idea that it's something that we should have discussion about.

2:13:21 Okay, good travel side, we're out of lights, finally.

2:13:24 Next week, we will be asking the council to consider compensation related issues, and

2:13:29 in terms of what that looks like, we recognize that when this issue, when we first asked the

2:13:36 council prior to anyone working with the state and in that process, we asked the very question,

2:13:44 as the council even want to do this.

2:13:48 Do you want to consider this?

2:13:49 And the general response to the council at that time was,

2:13:53 we will, but we want to make sure that we reserve

2:13:56 our opportunities to ensure public health and public safety

2:14:00 is first.

2:14:01 At that meeting, I believe that there

2:14:02 was some very different opinions in terms

2:14:05 of financial compensation.

2:14:08 Should it be provided in the form of a direct compensation

2:14:14 and compensation into perpetuity as something similar

2:14:19 to the state's contract, or would the city's compensation

2:14:24 be in more in lieu of type gifts,

2:14:26 such as trailhead access, trailhead improvements,

2:14:29 trailhead expansion, and I think that the palette

2:14:33 of options really is that of the council,

2:14:35 and so we will make sure that from a topical standpoint,

2:14:38 that is what is out there.

2:14:41 We would encourage you to think about that over the course of the next week.

2:14:45 I think that Rebecca's thought in terms of trying to hit these from a position of topic

2:14:51 and interest, I think, is good.

2:14:53 I would ask that as you think about those additional topics of interest and concern, I think that

2:14:58 those need to be laid out.

2:15:01 I think when it comes to public safety, really it comes to the hands of those public safety

2:15:07 professionals where we're going to share with you what we're doing and the public safety

2:15:11 plan is probably is going to probably be more described as opposed to debated in comparison

2:15:19 to the level of compensation which probably deserves to be more debated than described.

2:15:26 And as you think about those different topics and what you would like to have included, continue

2:15:31 to include those. We are going to be working over the course of the next week, possibly

2:15:39 to, but certainly prior to with the intent, hopefully, on the 23rd that we hope to maybe

2:15:47 have some form of what a template of an agreement may look like. Hopefully we'll have the I-Crimp

2:15:54 piece back. We're going to be able to utilize the state lands piece. We'll be able to

2:15:59 kind of move that forward.

2:16:02 You said in two weeks?

2:16:04 With the hope on the 23rd of December.

2:16:07 Great.

2:16:08 Mayor, this is Sean, just once more. Just to let you know, I have another obligation

2:16:15 that in 20 minutes, so I will stick around. I'm going to call as long as I can.

2:16:20 All right. Thank you, Sean.

2:16:24 to do you want to introduce your somebody from their team to begin or do they have their own order figured out?

2:16:30 Mr. Johnson, who's legal counsel for Beckley-Bedia, an attorney based out of Boise, I believe is approaching.

2:16:36 All right. Welcome, Mr. Johnson.

2:16:38 Thank you very much, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council.

2:16:41 We certainly appreciate the opportunity to appear and discuss these issues.

2:16:48 We had kind of a madcap day today.

2:16:52 We had a, what I think is a very good meeting with Captain Barnard and Chief of Police Pike.

2:16:59 I think it was a very good initial meeting.

2:17:01 We shared some thoughts, some ideas.

2:17:06 The morning started with meeting with the Jerome County Commissioners and representative of the Jerome County Sheriff's Department.

2:17:16 That was a very productive meeting.

2:17:18 I believe we met with members of the Department of Fish and Game, the local office.

2:17:23 We met again with the Department of Lands, and the common theme from these meetings I

2:17:31 think is that there's a lot of work to be done between now and September.

2:17:36 September may seem like it's a long ways off, but it's really not.

2:17:40 When we're talking about an event of the size of this magnitude in trying to keep the paramount

2:17:47 issue of the safety of the community in mind, it's not much time at all.

2:17:56 On the public aspect of our event, one of the reasons I asked Mr. Rothweiler to present

2:18:07 the question that we had, at this juncture we have a good deal of control over how large

2:18:16 of a crowd we might expect to see live here in town.

2:18:23 And as we've said from date one, what we don't want to do is

2:18:28 to create something that is inconsistent with the council's view

2:18:34 of what this project should be.

2:18:38 You know, if we have a mob of 50,000 people, 60,000 people show

2:18:42 up, and that's really not what the community wanted to see. That's not what we're interested

2:18:47 in doing. If we want to limit the folks that show up live at this event and focus on other

2:18:53 aspects, the televised aspects, the internet viewing capabilities, that's a decision we

2:18:59 can make. And I think that perhaps the appropriate thing to do would be to engage the public,

2:19:07 And I'm just throwing this out as an idea in a town hall format.

2:19:12 We would welcome input directly from the community

2:19:16 on what the community would like to see from us.

2:19:21 Undoubtedly, members of the community

2:19:23 have questions that they would like to ask,

2:19:25 and we would like to answer those.

2:19:26 And I think a series of town hall meetings

2:19:29 might be a very good format to do that.

2:19:33 And with those thoughts, I will stand for questions.

2:19:37 So I guess my question would be kind of too pronged here.

2:19:44 Did you have a thought process?

2:19:47 I mean, you just asked us how big we want it to be.

2:19:50 I guess I'm not sure I know how big it could be.

2:19:54 And then I think of all the areas that concern me.

2:19:58 We have a lot of land that's undeveloped

2:20:01 along the canyon rim that is going to be a potential viewing

2:20:07 area.

2:20:08 And how do we handle the safety on them?

2:20:13 We have our own trail that's over the part of that.

2:20:15 We have vacant land between the people in the audience

2:20:19 are going to know where I'm talking about,

2:20:20 between Todd Glass's house and say the corner of where

2:20:23 Maryhouse Lake, the corner of Pauline and Eastland.

2:20:30 That vacant land there, those are all issues

2:20:35 that I think we're going to have to decide

2:20:37 whether to for safety reasons.

2:20:39 And then the second one, and Mr. Beckley,

2:20:41 you called me not long after we awarded it,

2:20:44 or we ended up talking on the phone.

2:20:46 I don't think you actually called me,

2:20:47 but we ended up talking on the phone.

2:20:50 And you asked me the question about image and brand

2:20:55 and those kinds of things.

2:20:56 And maybe I received a letter today

2:20:59 from one of our citizens, and this is the kind of stuff

2:21:03 that I think concerns them and concerns me.

2:21:05 And he was referring to your quotes concerning an event in Cheyenne, Wyoming, where it was

2:21:11 going to be called the Red Necnostals, where you were reccon racing and wrestling.

2:21:15 That's not our brand, kid.

2:21:17 That's what I'm talking about.

2:21:20 Okay.

2:21:21 Casper, I don't Casper, right?

2:21:23 Yeah.

2:21:24 You're going to need to come for a broadcast live and they can't really see you back there.

2:21:32 So, that's the kind of thing as far as image of Brandon.

2:21:37 know we're kind of getting off from where Mr. Johnson was, but he was ready for questions,

2:21:41 so.

2:21:42 You know, in my business, we do all sorts of different events inside venues like, for instance,

2:21:48 Holle and Reena and stuff like that, whether it be our monster truck nationals or our

2:21:52 no limits deal or something like that.

2:21:56 We frequently go to the same venue a couple different times a year, so we twist that a

2:22:01 little bit.

2:22:02 In other words, not bringing monster trucks.

2:22:03 We can't keep feeding the monster trucks in it, so you've got to have something different.

2:22:08 So we had to see when we were talking about it, the manager and I, excuse me, the venue

2:22:13 manager and I, we're talking about it and I said, well, we've got Demolition Derby.

2:22:17 He said, well, is this going to be a fun event?

2:22:19 Oh, I asked him, think about it.

2:22:21 We've got Demolition Derby, we've got Mudbog, and he said, well, we've had that.

2:22:25 And I said, then we want to put a professional wrestling pack in here.

2:22:28 We've done it before.

2:22:30 And their Facebook message is, you know, just like you all, you get input from the public,

2:22:37 was why don't you bring wrestling back?

2:22:39 I hadn't been in there for three or four years, so that's what we did.

2:22:42 So of course, my take on it was, you know, tongue and cheek, we got reccon, basin, and

2:22:48 wrestling.

2:22:49 You know what?

2:22:50 That has nothing to do with this job.

2:22:51 But I appreciate it.

2:22:52 You have, well, you should not even have, you have, I believe, did they get the, you know,

2:23:00 You see anything about wrecking and racing and racing?

2:23:07 Let's hope you don't see anything about wrecking for sure.

2:23:11 As I recall you asked me about the branding on that particular call.

2:23:17 I told you don't die, it was one of my first things.

2:23:21 Yeah, exactly.

2:23:23 I kept going, what is the branding of it?

2:23:27 on your website, I looked on everything, and finally Travis I believe Senator

2:23:32 Mr. Williams I think Senator just this week and so you know it's not easy coming

2:23:41 up with those you know with that I'm sure took you all well you got to project

2:23:48 at what year 2001 20 so it's out of 2020 you're talking about our 30 years

2:23:54 30, I guess, actually.

2:23:56 2030, yeah.

2:23:58 So, you know, to have that vision for that long, it's awesome.

2:24:02 I deal with a lot of cities, municipalities, and stuff like that.

2:24:06 I don't think anybody's got thinking about 230 that much like you guys are.

2:24:10 2030. So, I come in and join that.

2:24:14 So, now that we know what the branding is, oh, we got that.

2:24:18 You know, our event. Everybody's going, are you having a rock concert?

2:24:22 Gene Sullivan who's an evangelistic motorcycle jumper with his group singing a bunch of songs

2:24:29 about Jesus and Lord, a rock concert.

2:24:34 He's 66 years old, still doing motorcycle jumps, and he goes through a fire wall, and

2:24:42 that's him going through the gates of hell, and he stands up and talks about all that.

2:24:46 And he was Knievel's bodyguard.

2:24:48 And as he said, he saw evil, can evil, a lot of places, people, and evil, can evil set himself.

2:24:56 You know, I'm sorry, he will, can evil a lot of people.

2:24:59 So Jesus, nothing like that.

2:25:00 He's in a band, so he's been on all sorts of programs.

2:25:04 So that's him.

2:25:05 Then I talked to Troy Hartman, who is one of the guys of the day about having a bass

2:25:11 jumping off of the North Rim, fixing up a platform and stuff into a base jumping competition

2:25:19 off of there so that you can have other places to do that up and down the area.

2:25:27 And so when we talked to our land's guy, he was liking that.

2:25:31 He thought that was a pretty good deal.

2:25:33 So that's, I mean, we don't have the festival as we say it.

2:25:38 People keep saying festival.

2:25:39 I'm not saying festival.

2:25:41 My concentration is do this event and come here and buy house and say you're long enough

2:25:48 to be elected mayor.

2:25:49 Well you got to get council first we do it a little different here.

2:25:54 Exactly.

2:25:55 I got told you back to this river I don't want to be burned it's a sake when this thing's

2:26:00 over.

2:26:01 Another thing too is just for the record as Chris brought up here and as you guys said

2:26:06 too and we got this thing for two years.

2:26:10 When we were talking to our police people here, I think they just left.

2:26:15 Oh, that is my turn.

2:26:16 We said we'd like to talk about doing another event next year.

2:26:21 So we want everybody happy so we can do this too.

2:26:25 We got a lot of money out on the line, a lot of stuff.

2:26:28 And we have to pay that rent for next year.

2:26:30 I don't want to do this jump on September the 7th or 8th, whichever TV tells us.

2:26:34 And then we go scratch our little heirs and look at that rent.

2:26:40 We just paid for that of the piece of that land for a year.

2:26:42 So hopefully, you all, after we do this,

2:26:46 you'll embrace the thought of giving us a second year there.

2:26:49 Well, we'll talk about that later.

2:26:50 We do have a like, Chris talking.

2:26:52 I have a question for your council, Mr. Johnson.

2:26:56 It's September, mid-September can be very warm.

2:27:01 It can be excessively warm.

2:27:03 Dry air and heat, alcohol.

2:27:06 People running around acting like chickens

2:27:08 with their heads cut off.

2:27:10 strongly suggest that you coordinate on the North

2:27:14 and South side some mobile emergency,

2:27:17 tense with staff, not to transport everybody to the hospital.

2:27:21 There will be people, feigning who knows what other sort

2:27:25 of the thing.

2:27:27 This is John, you might want to answer the travel.

2:27:29 So it's John Simmons.

2:27:31 I might have, I might have not.

2:27:34 You're not the John Simmons.

2:27:35 really quick.

2:27:36 Did you say Gene Simmons?

2:27:37 Mr. Simmons, my apology, I started that, that's my thing.

2:27:43 I carried it on.

2:27:45 Mr. Simmons, do you want to comment on that?

2:27:47 I'm sure.

2:27:48 Mr. Hall has been looking at my Facebook page.

2:27:49 I dressed my children up as one of them as Gene Simmons for Halloween.

2:27:52 I apologize about that.

2:27:54 And yes, I think that's a fabulous idea and it's something we've considered already.

2:28:02 Mr. Woodland has to deal with similar issues with his menu.

2:28:07 And that's certainly one of the things we've thought about.

2:28:11 And I think, as a result of our meetings today,

2:28:15 the notion of this committee, this multidisciplinary,

2:28:18 multi-agency group is really a good one.

2:28:22 And coming up with a comprehensive plan

2:28:25 to deal with these very types of issues

2:28:27 is a great, great start and great idea.

2:28:30 Good idea.

2:28:32 Next slide, Donald.

2:28:33 I was just going to say, most of these things are going to be covered with the people that

2:28:35 you get in the room together because they're going to talk about not only that, but wild

2:28:39 land fires in September on that side of the bridge.

2:28:42 It's pretty dry over there.

2:28:44 We don't need another one.

2:28:47 So Jackie Fry's counterpart for Jerome County will be involved in this and there will be a

2:28:52 lot of folks at the table discussing all these issues.

2:28:55 Well, I know I'm should, but should I give you a few little heads things that we'd got today out of our land meeting?

2:29:02 Sure, I think it'll be more we know the more better. I understand that we're not we're not holding thing back for sure

2:29:08 But that just happened a couple hours ago

2:29:10 We need to have time to type anything up or anything

2:29:14 When we met with him one of the main things that was our goal was to try to make sure that we didn't bind up

2:29:21 The public roads and all this stuff

2:29:23 We've got an area now to park people and we will park them and then transfer them to a landing site

2:29:33 To with buses and stuff like that. We'll do that

2:29:38 Okay, it's the first the first main road that when it goes east and west past the

2:29:44 Past the site. Mm-hmm. Golf course, right? I don't know. It's a one no on on the on the state site

2:29:51 When you go across the bridge. Oh, okay, the devil's crow road. Okay. It goes back

2:29:59 Over to the land of the housing element and all that stuff down at the falls

2:30:08 Yeah, so anyway right there is where we're gonna park on that get off the highway

2:30:14 Parking you know at that time so to say we'll have we could take care of people like that

2:30:19 Here's the thing, we don't anticipate selling alcohol beverages.

2:30:29 With doing what we're doing, by taking this parking and putting them in a bus and bringing

2:30:36 them over there, we can control the coolers too.

2:30:40 Oh, you won't?

2:30:42 You can't?

2:30:43 You can't.

2:30:44 Sir?

2:30:45 Chris?

2:30:46 I do this all the time.

2:30:47 I bet they're in the small other one.

2:30:48 Don't let coolers go into that whole arena if you've got 50,000 people there and bring in their own coolers

2:30:54 They have 50,000 people

2:30:56 Yeah, I have 10,000. Okay, 50,000. Yeah, it's not a problem. Do it 14,000

2:31:02 Well, I think what he's saying Chris is that they won't allow them to get on to the bus

2:31:06 That's allowed to get on the bus of the cool

2:31:07 Yeah

2:31:08 Unless it's got water and or and or baby needs

2:31:13 Yeah, you know yeah

2:31:15 Yeah, I'll give you that point you can control the bus who comes on with what but outside of that will be a free for all

2:31:23 Well, yeah, but nobody can get to those the watch area without

2:31:28 Get it on the bus. Yeah, some of them will be flying on their own

2:31:33 Okay

2:31:35 We'll let you we'll let you count

2:31:38 on them, so I think we'll see it.

2:31:41 It'll be a easy count, do you know?

2:31:43 Well, I mean, in an effort,

2:31:45 I don't have any more lights

2:31:46 than an effort to kind of wrap this up.

2:31:47 Travis, did you have any additional thoughts for tonight?

2:31:50 And we can feel the, get the feel that we're moving forward.

2:31:55 Yes, yes, so I think that one of the things

2:31:58 we'd also like to give a little bit more time to chief bike

2:32:01 because I think that there are some additional considerations

2:32:04 that you need to be aware of, not that maybe not necessarily

2:32:09 associated with Mr. Beckley and his group

2:32:11 and what they're trying to go forward with,

2:32:13 but know that this is also causing additional requests

2:32:18 and additional things coming in for special events

2:32:22 that are trying to be run in coordination and conjunction.

2:32:25 So Chief Pike wants to take a couple of minutes

2:32:27 to talk about that.

2:32:29 Yeah, if you'd find a seat, we'll appreciate you being here

2:32:32 to answer questions.

2:32:35 Thank you, Mayor, and members of the Council.

2:32:37 One thing, there's just two things I'd like to add.

2:32:39 One, I think it's really important to understand

2:32:41 that we had a very preliminary cursory meeting

2:32:45 with Beckley Media today.

2:32:47 We have no definitive plans on any of this.

2:32:49 There's nothing, there's not a planning document.

2:32:52 We haven't been presented with a planning document.

2:32:54 I believe that that's to be expected in the future.

2:32:58 The second thing I would like the Council to consider

2:33:00 as we move forward is ancillary events taking place

2:33:03 during this time.

2:33:05 So our approach right now is to make sure that, number one, first and foremost, we continue

2:33:10 to provide public safety service to the citizens of Twin Falls.

2:33:15 Secondly, right now we're focused on the event, but I've already received a number of special

2:33:22 event applications for ancillary events taking place, festivals taking place during this time

2:33:27 and other events.

2:33:29 So I would just ask that the council be mindful.

2:33:32 There will be a limit to what the City of Twin Falls will be capable of providing the service

2:33:37 providing for that week.

2:33:39 So as we move forward and these events continue to come forward, I expect to see a number of

2:33:45 especially events application for this time period.

2:33:48 So I would just ask you to be mindful of that and at some point, I may appear before you

2:33:52 and say our couple is full and this is all that we can do.

2:33:58 Thank you, Brian.

2:33:59 Travis.

2:34:00 And then we have, we'll do that one right.

2:34:02 I know I think the Chief Pike said it very, very well,

2:34:05 is that the size of the event, you know,

2:34:10 as Mr. Simmons and Mr. Beckley are trying to control,

2:34:15 may be something that they control when it comes directly

2:34:18 to their event, but groups that come forward that

2:34:24 want to do additional things in conjunction that

2:34:28 may not be directly associated, will strain public safety services at some point in time.

2:34:38 And I think it's important to recognize that all of those will be presented to you utilizing

2:34:44 our processes, but know that as this thing continues to grow, the number of moving parts

2:34:54 continues to to grow as well and looking at the number of specific safety plans to accommodate

2:35:02 everything from different types of festivals to campsites to everything else that is trying to be

2:35:09 done in conjunction is really taking up an inordinate amount of time.

2:35:17 Well I would think I'm just again I'm only one person but on the council but I would think

2:35:22 because these special permit, these other special event permits come forward.

2:35:27 Each and every one of them better be planning to pay their own way.

2:35:31 In other words, that would be my thought process.

2:35:34 If that includes staff time, they need to be know they're going to be charged for staff time.

2:35:38 Because we still have to be a city as this moves forward.

2:35:44 I do have a couple of lights that I would like to make in a second.

2:35:46 Thank you Mayor.

2:35:48 I appreciate the comment from Chief Pike.

2:35:50 I know that there have been discussions a long time ago

2:35:55 on all of the organizations, the service clubs,

2:36:00 into and falls to have an opportunity

2:36:02 to participate in some sort of festival or event

2:36:06 that coincides with the jump.

2:36:08 And I just would recommend that maybe we do some coordination.

2:36:11 And instead of having everyone do their own event,

2:36:14 maybe, obviously it's an option open to them to work together.

2:36:19 but I think it would be much more organized

2:36:22 and beneficial to everyone and give everyone the opportunity

2:36:25 instead of maybe limiting it to first-come, first-serve.

2:36:30 Maybe we can look at it more holistically

2:36:32 for the community and see how we can provide opportunities

2:36:35 to the entire community for those who want to participate.

2:36:40 Jima.

2:36:41 Thank you, Mayor.

2:36:43 I guess I don't know if we need to put this in the form of emotion,

2:36:46 But anything besides de minimis time,

2:36:50 it might be just quick phone calls and so forth.

2:36:53 I would move that we would direct staff

2:36:57 to keep track of those hours beginning today,

2:36:59 or whenever, probably today, or,

2:37:02 because I guess we're kind of getting into preliminary stages.

2:37:05 And then, in the event that Mr. Beckley is approved

2:37:09 to use our land, those monies would be captured from him.

2:37:16 You can start managing all the, we need to know how much staff time is involved here.

2:37:24 If he's approved, he needs to pay for that time because I know exactly what these guys

2:37:27 are going through in terms of the staff time and the police officer time and everybody else

2:37:32 that's taken away from their normal duties.

2:37:35 I would agree with, I don't know, called a caveat, but maybe a recognition that not all

2:37:45 all the time and the effort that we're spending on the event is necessarily caused by Mr. Beckley and his group.

2:37:51 So as you're complying with public records requests, as you are doing lots of design

2:37:58 that might be related or on that topic may not be directly caused by Beckley Media Group.

2:38:10 Would you argue that as we proceed from this evening on, you will probably also receive some

2:38:16 of those public workers, but the wheels are going to be in motion big time for staff to

2:38:22 work with Mr. Beckley.

2:38:24 We will come to a decision point time where we say yes or no on his plan within 45 days.

2:38:34 If we approve his plan, the hours that we spend working with him to get there, he should pay

2:38:41 for that. Absolutely. And I believe that's something that just so that there's a recognition

2:38:45 that there's a lot of whole moving different ways associated with this that the number of

2:38:53 hours that we may spend in total on the topic will be greater than maybe the number of hours

2:38:59 that we're spending with Mr. Beckley. That's on his dime. When staff is having meetings

2:39:07 developing a plan to do his event

2:39:09 he needs to be charged with a reason or not

2:39:11 i mean right

2:39:13 and i don't know why you wouldn't because

2:39:15 that's the time that they're going to be taken away from

2:39:18 talking about police and matters and other matters in the community

2:39:21 that everybody out here expects them to do

2:39:24 he's got to pay for all this stuff

2:39:27 talk to bottom

2:39:28 less public things that are just

2:39:31 not yet i mean that's

2:39:33 that's the only way i would even remotely approve this

2:39:37 Thank you, Mayor.

2:39:40 I understand Councilman Munson's concern, and I think I would recommend keeping track

2:39:46 of those hours, but instead of, I think it will be very difficult to build, you know,

2:39:50 how much each individual staff member makes per hour in setting that amount.

2:39:56 I think that we should track the time and then make the permit fee commensurate to the time

2:40:02 involved by staff, or something of that nature.

2:40:04 I mean because we have not set any sort of compensation or permit fee and I think that

2:40:11 we should maybe use that as a gauge of what kind of permit fee that we would use.

2:40:18 I don't know if you think it's if staff believes it's doable to charge per hour.

2:40:25 I'm just not not sure I'm comfortable with that but I think that we should keep track

2:40:29 and to maybe recoup some of those costs through the permit fee.

2:40:34 But that's just a suggestion.

2:40:36 Jima.

2:40:37 Well, I was just going to say, is it cumbersome for us,

2:40:40 I know it's not in the legal world,

2:40:42 to maintain a good tracking on billable hours?

2:40:47 No, I don't.

2:40:49 I don't believe that would be difficult for us to do.

2:40:51 Okay.

2:40:52 Great.

2:40:53 And that would get to the true cost of the hours that would be

2:40:58 associated with I think the challenge honestly is for us to get into that

2:41:06 habit because that is not the world in which we operate and so there will probably

2:41:12 be times in which we forget to to include those hours just because it's not in our

2:41:16 habit we we attend meetings on a regular basis public services is there to serve

2:41:22 the public and typically in the commissioning a public service we don't

2:41:28 have billable hours that we then turn around and assign to someone who provide

2:41:33 those services to. So if you'd be patient with us as we kind of learn a new new

2:41:37 process associated with that, that would be helpful.

2:41:41 I just can't help but think that we've got to be

2:41:44 fair about this and as balanced as we can. I don't remember anybody talking about

2:41:49 keeping track of our hours when it came to the air show.

2:41:52 That was a community event. The breakfast of champions.

2:41:57 Well, yeah, they did, but some of these other events,

2:42:01 so I think we need to be as fair as we can

2:42:03 about this process as well and be balanced.

2:42:06 One question I do have for Chief Pike, if I could.

2:42:11 Chief, you're talking to us about some of these other events

2:42:14 starting to crowd in on that day

2:42:17 because they could see some opportunity,

2:42:19 and if I was a business person, had a business,

2:42:21 I'd be interested in it as well.

2:42:24 And I kind of like some of the comments

2:42:27 that Rebecca said, is it time for us to set back,

2:42:30 and I don't want to say a moratorium

2:42:33 of special events around there,

2:42:34 but at least figure out some way to say,

2:42:37 let's stop, let's think about this a little bit,

2:42:39 let's figure out how we can coordinate this,

2:42:44 because again, you're right,

2:42:46 you're going to come to us eventually and go, we're done,

2:42:48 we don't have any more staff time,

2:42:50 we've already got these 15 other events

2:42:52 that's going alongside of the jump,

2:42:54 And so I'm just not sure exactly how to handle that,

2:42:58 other than stepping back.

2:43:00 You know, I wonder if maybe Fritz could comment on this.

2:43:03 One of the things that I started to do

2:43:05 was just to kind of hold these special events

2:43:08 as they come in.

2:43:10 And maybe that would give us an idea.

2:43:12 I don't know how the council would fill without that,

2:43:13 but that would give us an idea of what that time period would

2:43:16 look like, and then maybe there's a way

2:43:18 to proceed forward from there.

2:43:20 But right now, our process is that we will receive a special event,

2:43:24 no later than 45 days, and then you can submit your application a year out.

2:43:31 So I am anticipating and have actually received and sent a special application back, but at

2:43:37 this point I'm moving forward in receiving those, especially then applications.

2:43:43 It's a little difficult because we're not, I think that we'll be able to have a better

2:43:46 picture, maybe 45 days from now when we have a plan, a specific and detailed plan from

2:43:51 on what their event looks like.

2:43:54 I mean, we could hold the special events

2:43:58 and start dealing with them on a case-by-case

2:44:02 individual basis, or we could pull them into a group

2:44:04 and present them on the council.

2:44:06 You know, I'd kind of like to hear from the council on this

2:44:08 because we need to be fair to those putting in special

2:44:12 event permits as well, and we need to be fair to our staff

2:44:15 time and all those other dynamics.

2:44:18 You start looking at big events like Sturgis, I know we have Woody coming in to help with on

2:44:24 Ed's team, but they have a huge, huge organization behind that whole Sturgis event where they have

2:44:31 a police department, the size of Boise's for a little town the size of Gooding that swells

2:44:38 during that time because they have this well-oiled machine of how to deal with it.

2:44:42 We don't have that.

2:44:43 We don't have the mechanism or logistics of bringing at least at this point 25 police officers

2:44:50 from Salt Lake Valley and folks from Boise and all these other folks that we might end

2:44:54 up needing.

2:44:55 So I just don't want to shoot ourselves in the foot.

2:44:58 You're back in this way.

2:45:00 I agree.

2:45:02 I think that's a great suggestion to maybe pool events that are happening on that day

2:45:06 or on that I don't know if it's a weekend or not.

2:45:09 But I am aware of two annual events that happen, I believe it's that same weekend and they just happen if all that optimist wings and things usually is held in the city park.

2:45:18 And then the prime bridge festival for the past three years have coincided and been held that weekend.

2:45:25 So maybe giving special consideration to events that are annual events.

2:45:31 But certainly I think that it's a good idea to hold them and pool them and have that conversation with those organizations with our

2:45:39 service groups and with the council and decide what's best for the community so that as you

2:45:45 guys have said we can still be a city and people who aren't participating can still get from

2:45:50 A to B and they can do what they need to do on that weekend.

2:45:55 I believe the actual university is actually a Tuesday as I recall and since with the one

2:46:01 of the changes that's happened in the last 40 years is the emergence, I don't know you

2:46:07 don't care done, but the emergence of college football was that on the on the

2:46:12 weekend. So I'm sure they're probably TV was probably going to want it on that

2:46:16 Tuesday or that Tuesday night. So maybe some of the weekends they won't be

2:46:20 quite as critical Chris. Well I think we're gonna have to start making some tough

2:46:23 decisions and we can't have both sides of the river covered on this so to speak.

2:46:28 I'm just gonna suggest we consider a time moratorium. I'll just throw

2:46:35 something out put it out in the motion that no special events be authorized

2:46:39 utilizing the city resources are closer than 10 days to the event that motion

2:47:00 doesn't have credibility but there was no second concerning it just for the fact

2:47:04 I'm not sure but he knows enough right now to vote on it that would be my

2:47:09 thoughts anyway Jim I yeah I think right now you know we're now we're

2:47:13 starting to get down into the engine room on this same big time. And I think that we

2:47:17 need to kind of back away from this thing right now, let staff do their work. So I

2:47:22 wouldn't support the motion. I think that I would be better prepared to have a

2:47:26 discussion in regards to moratoriums and so forth at the time that you see a plan

2:47:33 and that you see a full picture of what different events you're going to have

2:47:38 to manage as a police chief. So I think we're starting to get down in the engine

2:47:42 here all of a sudden.

2:47:43 That's one of those long late items, though, Jim.

2:47:44 I thought that we could deal with it might prevent a problem that we could take care

2:47:49 of now.

2:47:50 I mean, not much about 10 days, but if we're going to let them continue to have uninterrupted

2:47:56 special events the night before, then what are we saying?

2:47:59 I think that in 45 days we're going to see, I think we're going to, the mist and the fog

2:48:04 of this matter will probably be somewhat clear, and we'll get to see at that time special

2:48:09 of all the special events, probably, or the majority of those that are going to be associated

2:48:13 with this event. And I think we would be in a better decision either to say yay or nay

2:48:18 on those special events at that time.

2:48:20 And just to carry this on, my sense isn't quite done. I'll just argue that after this

2:48:27 discussion, I'd just hit the paper in the newspaper. We may be inundated in the next 45

2:48:32 days for a lockup of a special event. I'm just trying to get along with that.

2:48:35 I understand exactly what you're saying, and I think that the police chief is going to have to at least entertain those special events,

2:48:41 incorporate them all into the big plan.

2:48:45 But let's just wait.

2:48:47 I believe.

2:48:48 Let's just wait another 45 days or however long until that application is completed.

2:48:54 And then we can look at this thing from 10,000 feet rather than down in the trench.

2:49:00 I know Travis wants to say something but I just have cool when we don't have any idea exactly what day

2:49:06 We're looking at do we do the ad?

2:49:25 Anyway, we have like five different networks that we're talking to right now

2:49:30 and

2:49:31 And which are going to be very happy that what you guys went like that.

2:49:35 So we can go forward with this a little bit.

2:49:38 That's going to be a big thing.

2:49:39 But anyway, out of those five, one, one is Monday, which is the eighth.

2:49:46 OK.

2:49:46 And that's the actual anniversary.

2:49:48 Everybody else is thinking Sunday, which would be September the 7th.

2:49:52 And September the 8th was the 40th year.

2:49:55 And that one network has talked about going against Monday night football,

2:50:00 would have in this early enough where it could still get East Coast and West Coast

2:50:05 somewhat prime. You don't want stuff like that. A TV spot on Sunday night, just so

2:50:11 you know, sells for about what it does on best night is Thursday. Thursday and Sunday nights

2:50:18 you're too much watch to television nights. And so, of course, they want to get their

2:50:23 money back from what they've paid us and stuff like that. So, whether they can sell

2:50:29 Monday, one of them thinks they could get more out of it. I'm not convinced of that, you know, but my target is September the 7th, so it's either the 7th or the 8th, potentially, strong, strong potential there. So maybe we pull the the events around that time, at least in the meantime, Brian, so that we can start working through this.

2:50:55 And we'd be glad to help you with those special events, too, if there's something we can help you with.

2:51:01 Okay, thank you.

2:51:02 Okay.

2:51:03 I feel really comfortable going ahead and accepting special events and just holding them.

2:51:08 And then ultimately pooling them and then maybe bringing them back to the council to decide what your preference would be on the special events.

2:51:15 And obviously communicating with those folks saying that we have this big deal coming up, please work with us.

2:51:21 Travis.

2:51:22 And that was, sometimes when staff takes an action and we're going to hold these applications,

2:51:28 the whole purpose of this was to let you know that the idea is to hold them.

2:51:33 And you may get phone calls that were not being responsive in that.

2:51:36 So then you have a good understanding of, and we've carved out the action collectively that we're going to take in moving forward.

2:51:43 I think that's easily defensible.

2:51:45 We can visit with them.

2:51:46 But on the front end, as you gather them, obviously, you're going to let them know this is a big weekend.

2:51:52 the parties that I've been working with it they're very understanding they realize

2:51:57 this so perfect thank you sir all right

2:52:02 dr. or that discussion then moving on to item number five which is a chance for

2:52:10 public city manager city council to give us input do we have anyone from the

2:52:15 public that wants to maybe mr. mayor before you go to item number five maybe

2:52:22 maybe as an extension of item number four.

2:52:27 We could have any public comment on that particular item because typically you have that place where

2:52:40 any item that typically was not discussed during the event or the evening.

2:52:43 Right, that's true.

2:52:45 All right, so first, I guess, first,

2:52:47 the, under Travis's recommendation,

2:52:50 anybody in the public that want,

2:52:53 two minutes max is gonna be what our normal is.

2:52:55 Anybody that wants to speak on the item

2:52:58 we just got through discussing.

2:53:03 First we have someone coming forward.

2:53:04 Please identify yourself and what,

2:53:06 you don't need to give your full address

2:53:08 for what town you're from, what city you're from.

2:53:11 My name is Cheryl Wheeler, I'm from Twin Falls.

2:53:13 Okay.

2:53:15 Over the past two weeks, I have asked people around town

2:53:18 about their thoughts on the jump.

2:53:24 There was zero community support for Ed Beckley.

2:53:30 In fact, it goes beyond that to negative sentiments.

2:53:35 People know he threatened to sue the city

2:53:39 and they were not pleased with that.

2:53:41 I have no desire to participate in a Beckley event

2:53:52 and I will not do so.

2:53:56 I hope you people are satisfied with your choice

2:54:01 because I am cringing at the thought

2:54:05 and on behalf of my city.

2:54:08 You have done a grave disservice to Twin Falls.

2:54:13 Thank you.

2:54:13 Thank you.

2:54:14 Anyone else?

2:54:19 Seeing none, move on to public input on other items

2:54:22 that were not covered tonight, Donald?

2:54:24 I would just add that obviously,

2:54:26 especially folks that are listening,

2:54:28 There's going to be ample time to still communicate with us as this goes on.

2:54:33 It's not just about tonight, in the two minutes, so.

2:54:36 All right, that'll be others.

2:54:37 Each time we discuss this, I'm sure we're going to get comets.

2:54:41 Hey, no one else on other items? City, banger?

2:54:47 Oh, Chris. No, we'll do the council afterwards.

2:54:50 Go ahead.

2:54:51 What did the council have for the city manager?

2:54:53 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, just two quick items for you.

2:54:56 one more of a heads up and one a reminder.

2:55:01 The first is the reminder.

2:55:03 Again, we'll meet on the 16th.

2:55:06 We will have the conversation each and every week

2:55:10 about this process as we continue to move forward.

2:55:13 And the topic of the conversation will be compensation

2:55:17 and what that picture may look like as we move forward.

2:55:21 I would invite members of the public

2:55:22 to submit through the Jump website.

2:55:25 I believe the jump address is still up and that.

2:55:29 Would you repeat that exact address?

2:55:31 Jump j-u-m-p at t-f-i-d.org to continue to share their thoughts,

2:55:38 if they have any related to the compensation that you might

2:55:41 be able to utilize and incorporate into your process.

2:55:44 That website or excuse me, that email address

2:55:47 will continue to remain open throughout this process.

2:55:54 And then on the 19th, December 19th, which is a Thursday, at 3.30 we're going to have a special workshop conversation with the members of our local legislative delegation.

2:56:10 We've had a pretty good response of those who are going to be in attendance.

2:56:14 We're learning and continuing to understand the legislative issues that are coming up in this legislative session.

2:56:21 The first was with our Association of Idaho Cities, and then the second piece of that will

2:56:28 be the Idaho Association of Tax Affairs, which is going to be on Wednesday.

2:56:32 There are, I would describe some emerging issues that from a staff perspective will be

2:56:37 in a position to communicate through a series of presentations, and it's always the same.

2:56:43 We want to make sure that there is no harm to cities.

2:56:46 We want to make sure that the opportunities of urban renewal and economic development

2:56:50 are well-preserved and then there are some issues like

2:56:53 Maryland and it talked about when it comes to prosecution

2:56:57 and prosecution fees and what that looks like by the number

2:57:00 of misdemeanors that are maybe placed into codes as opposed

2:57:03 to the number of infractions and what that may look like.

2:57:07 So with that, those meetings are coming up and then there will

2:57:12 also be an opportunity for the members of our legislative

2:57:14 delegation to share what they believe to be those upcoming

2:57:19 and emerging issues for us are to really kind of begin that dialogue and move forward.

2:57:26 One of the quick hits maybe when it comes to personal property tax is Speaker Betkey did

2:57:32 say that he believed that they might be having personal property tax fatigue I think is the

2:57:38 term that he used and that he did not see any significant personal property tax legislation

2:57:43 at this point in time going through the legislative process this year.

2:57:50 Earlier today, I wanted to make you aware and essentially a quick email as we continue to

2:57:55 work with the Bond Bank and moving forward.

2:57:59 We wanted to make sure that the Council had awareness of that process and of where it's

2:58:05 going and we think that it's been very positive in our conversations with the Bond Bank.

2:58:10 In those positive conversations, it's important that we access the Idaho Bond Bank because

2:58:15 we get to use the state's credit rating, and that state credit rating could enhance our

2:58:21 credit position by almost 100 basis points, and that enhancement of 100 basis points on

2:58:27 a potential $38 million bond issuance over 20 years is significant to our ratepayers.

2:58:34 Part of that process and part of our covenants codes, our covenants of the bond state that

2:58:40 we'll have a third party review of our rates and as you know we impose a 27% rate adjustment

2:58:45 to cover these costs and as we've continued to go forward CH2 was the third party reviewer

2:58:52 and CH2 did a conservative third party review of our rate analysis that we had assessed

2:58:58 And their thought right now is that we may have to enact a 4% rate adjustment on October 1st

2:59:07 of 2014, which would be the beginning of the subsequent fiscal year, to ensure that we're

2:59:12 in compliance with a 1 to 1 coverage ratio, which is a standard bond government.

2:59:17 I think it's important to note that even if you went to the bond bank or we tried to

2:59:22 to go it alone at one to 125 coverage ratio is something that is very common.

2:59:30 What I will also tell you is that it's not uncommon to our practice that we normally go

2:59:34 forward and follow.

2:59:36 When we look forward at revenues and we track expenditures and we look at what, how things

2:59:41 are moving forward on the first of July or the first week in July, we present a balanced

2:59:48 budget to you.

2:59:49 share and have a conversation with you, the rate adjustment based upon revenues coming

2:59:53 in that are going to be needed to cover those costs.

2:59:58 And if the fiscal year can be measured in a single month, which we know it can't, right,

3:00:03 because not one month does not intend to make, we're seeing significant increases, especially

3:00:10 in our industrial revenues, to the point that we're significantly unanticipated.

3:00:19 And it's not because of the rate adjustment that's in part, but it's larger in part because

3:00:24 of the levels of BOD and TSS and we're saying BOD, TSS and flows from industrial customers

3:00:31 is a sign of increased production.

3:00:33 And that's really what we're starting to see from our industrial customers.

3:00:37 And as our industrial customers produce more, it's probably highly likely that those rate

3:00:42 adjustments are absorbed.

3:00:44 So, at this point in time, Lori and I have had many, many conversations with the folks

3:00:50 at the Bond Bank.

3:00:53 We're actually very confident in the numbers that Lori produced.

3:00:57 We believe that they more accurately reflect reality as opposed to a conservative approach

3:01:02 that had to go through a myriad of processes, including legal counsel and risk management

3:01:07 before they signed a sheet of paper.

3:01:09 And so I just wanted to give you that heads up that the bond bank is going to be considering

3:01:14 our application and that CH2 report is out there.

3:01:20 They consider our application next Monday in the afternoon and we will be in a position

3:01:25 to share with you what that looks like in moving forward as we fund the wastewater treatment

3:01:31 plant project.

3:01:32 If you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer.

3:01:36 I don't have any questions. I think there's some counsel that have their input, but Krista, do you have a question for him or you?

3:01:43 I have another subject, but I would ask that that potential of 4% bump next October would be just to take it to that one to 125.

3:01:53 That does not mean that there would not be additional great increases, so it could be 4% plus in the worst of situations.

3:02:03 The worst of situations, in fact that's what Lori and I've talked about when we've tried

3:02:06 to really convey that to the Bond Bank, is that we believe that we can do everything on

3:02:13 our anti-control costs and we think that we've demonstrated that really well.

3:02:16 For example, last year the only rate adjustment that we assessed was that to cover the anticipated

3:02:24 debt service that we're going to be moving forward with.

3:02:29 As we look at future rate adjustments, I think it's important to recognize that we have some

3:02:34 control over that.

3:02:35 We have some control over what we do in the areas of capital improvement.

3:02:41 We have some control in the areas of everything from employee and personnel decisions that

3:02:50 we make to operational costs.

3:02:54 You know, as entities like Jibani continue to flow more when the pretreatment facility

3:03:00 is done, that's only going to further enhance our revenue stream.

3:03:04 So I think it's important to recognize that what I want to do is just communicate this

3:03:11 with you.

3:03:12 I think it's important to recognize that at every point in any time, in any fiscal year,

3:03:18 we are, because of the bond covenants that we already have, we're required to meet a

3:03:22 125 coverage ratio and that is absolutely required.

3:03:26 We signed on to that at the very first bond covenants and declarations that we agreed to.

3:03:32 And on an annual basis, it's part of that operating process that we go through this year

3:03:37 that we're in compliance.

3:03:39 I hope our production levels week continue.

3:03:43 Yeah.

3:03:45 We believe that there's a basis and again, one month does not a trend make, but we believe

3:03:52 The status of the wastewater fund is healthy.

3:03:55 In fact, Lori and I are having different conversations

3:03:59 than what actually might be having it with the bond bank.

3:04:05 All right.

3:04:05 Thank you, Travis.

3:04:07 Chris, how are you?

3:04:10 Hour is getting late.

3:04:11 I'd like to take just a couple minutes

3:04:13 to hear the council's input of my suggestion

3:04:17 to consider e-cigarettes.

3:04:22 As we know, the major cigarette companies are producing these as a safe way to enjoy the

3:04:30 effects of nicotine.

3:04:32 And as you may or may not know, there's a nicotine solution that goes out through longs

3:04:39 and into the public air.

3:04:41 I'm concerned that e-cigarettes are kind of under the radar way to affect the air quality

3:04:50 of public institutions and I would sure like to have the council's thoughts.

3:04:56 I would support asking the city attorney to draw out some ordinance that deals with prohibiting

3:05:03 e-cigarettes and a public place or any institution that we now regulate with smoking.

3:05:09 Donald?

3:05:11 I guess I would like to see that as an agenda item in the future and information brought

3:05:17 to us. I'm sensitive about that. I think it's a good idea for us to discuss it. But I think

3:05:24 it's a good idea to discuss it as an agenda item in future. Jim Munn.

3:05:30 Yeah, me too. I guess we've been here for three hours and talking about e-cigarettes

3:05:36 is very low on my priority. So yeah, bring it back in a month. No, I'll just come up with

3:05:42 I'd like to see research around it.

3:05:49 I have not seen the same things that you've seen, obviously, and so I'd like to have a

3:05:54 chance to not only have a personal research, but also maybe bring in some people at a future

3:05:59 date to doctors about the issue.

3:06:03 And obviously I don't use them, so I know how they work, but I don't really know anything

3:06:09 about them.

3:06:10 And I'm assuming that hopefully the state's going to be,

3:06:13 if there is something along that line,

3:06:15 the state will be giving you some direction as well.

3:06:17 I'm not saying I'm waiting on the state,

3:06:18 but I'd certainly like to have their thoughts

3:06:21 as we go along.

3:06:23 Any other council input?

3:06:26 Seeing none, we're adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, December 9, 2013. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 03:06:42.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    6141fd97f52663c8adddf640826655f9c4b3e98a3281436630b1dd153091e258
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 5990a1e929611c8e3843b7ea683ced72c4be4a038bb46a2778eb00348b2b2dba
    part02.m4a a7579b82b5d9d8fb343e1940d5b076acfbbe3687c0f7e4067d1eaacbaedd0814
    part03.m4a 88eaa47607fda5d58076d2a0cb9c7832f6b782274b861203b5baec4661ce82be
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    818ccb9e41ae22d2802c1e0a61d709d64959e106e15dc532b96f643821fb624b

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file