OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, February 3, 2014

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Minutes on fileExecutive session: f

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:00:01 I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, I just, just,

0:00:36 I'm going to do that, I don't know.

0:00:46 Council, I think it's about time we're getting close.

0:00:59 There's Sean coming tonight, do we know?

0:01:01 Chris is not.

0:01:01 Sean is calling in, he said.

0:01:03 He's in California.

0:01:04 OK.

0:01:05 Jim will be here later, but just not to this.

0:01:09 OK, I doesn't say because Jim's not here,

0:01:11 and Sean's not here.

0:01:12 I'm moving down.

0:01:13 I'm not going to sit over here for myself.

0:01:15 That's where people leave space straight.

0:01:16 Let's run them in.

0:01:18 Get some stuff done.

0:01:21 What do you two think?

0:01:22 Sounds good to me.

0:01:23 Let's move on.

0:01:27 You know, there's some strength to that.

0:01:29 We only have to make one other person's mind out.

0:01:32 Okay, so we are exploring new chairs, ladies.

0:01:40 So, um, well, no, we're just exploring.

0:01:45 So I'm going to probably, if you guys get a chance to sit in this one,

0:01:48 then we're going to have other ones that we're going to check out.

0:01:51 These things are trash.

0:01:54 There's all the commissions and everybody that sits in on them.

0:01:58 So we'll just start the meeting and adjourn it out to our tour and then come back.

0:02:39 I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order.

0:02:42 It's February 3rd, 2014.

0:02:45 It is 4 PM.

0:02:46 Five members of the City Council are here.

0:02:49 Jim Munn is not able to be here right now and I think Sean will be calling in later and

0:02:53 won't be going on the tour as well.

0:02:56 So we are going to go ahead and adjourn this meeting for our tour of the Canyon property.

0:14:50 I'd like to reconvene in the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council.

0:14:53 It's February 3rd, and it's 5.20 just for folks to know.

0:14:58 We met earlier at 4 o'clock, and I said adjourned.

0:15:02 I meant to say recess, because we were coming back,

0:15:04 and we went out to the jump site, and we toured that.

0:15:07 We were supposed to be back by 5.

0:15:09 Obviously, we were not successful at that.

0:15:12 The next item on the agenda is for us to go into executive session.

0:15:16 So we're going to be doing that if council desires,

0:15:20 in just a minute and going into executive session.

0:15:22 So I wanted to make sure I let everybody know that

0:15:25 and I'll stand for a motion council.

0:15:29 Move to the executive session

0:15:31 for all the reasons you're gonna lift their way.

0:15:33 Very good.

0:15:34 We have a motion on the floor to go into executive session

0:15:37 by Greg Lanting, seconded by Jim Munn

0:15:40 and just to read this to the audience as well

0:15:43 as get this on record.

0:15:45 Executive session 6,700, 3, 3, 45F

0:15:48 to communicate with legal counsel for public agency

0:15:51 to discuss the legal ramifications and legal options

0:15:54 for pending litigation or controversies,

0:15:57 not yet being litigated by eminently,

0:16:01 but eminently likely to be litigated.

0:16:04 The mere presence of legal counsel

0:16:06 at an executive session does not satisfy this requirement.

0:16:10 Council have anything on this motion before we go to a vote.

0:16:13 I see no lights, so the aye la, roll call vote please.

0:16:17 Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Jim. I. Yes. Sean Berger. Sean. Are you on? That's right. Oh, and good. Chris

0:16:28 talking 10. Greg Lanting. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Rebecca Mills, Micah. Yes. Motion passes 60

0:16:37 to get zero. Ladies and gentlemen, we're going to be going into executive session to discuss

0:16:42 some items and we will not be making any decisions while we're back there. And we will be coming

0:16:48 back out here in just a few minutes. With that, recess into executive. I'd like to

0:17:22 reconvene the City Council meeting for Monday, February 3rd, 2014. We're just

0:17:29 coming out of executive session and going into our regular meeting. As always, we

0:17:35 generally start our meetings off with the Pledge of Allegiance, so do we have any

0:17:39 Boy Scouts in the audience, I didn't see.

0:17:41 Our Girl Scouts, well, come on up.

0:17:46 Generally what we do is we always encourage

0:17:49 our Boy Scouts or Girl Scouts to come up

0:17:51 and lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:17:53 So if you'll just stand right there, start us off,

0:17:55 and we'll go from there, all of those wishing

0:17:58 to join us, please rise.

0:18:06 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:18:21 Well, thank you.

0:18:22 Welcome everyone and young man.

0:18:23 If you wouldn't mind, young man, scout, scout.

0:18:27 The microphone pull it back towards you

0:18:32 and then face this way and you're on TV.

0:18:35 You need to tell us if you would, give us your name,

0:18:38 what troop you're with, what merit badge you're working on

0:18:41 this evening.

0:18:42 If you wouldn't mind, please.

0:18:44 Jesse Hobson and I'm in troop 60 and I'm here working on the

0:18:48 City System in the Community Mayor badge.

0:18:50 Jesse, did you have any idea I was going to do this to you?

0:18:53 No.

0:18:54 It's probably better that way, right?

0:18:57 Thank you very much.

0:18:59 I appreciate you coming up.

0:19:05 Again, welcome to everyone in the audience.

0:19:06 Obviously, there's some folks that there must be an agenda item

0:19:09 on tonight that you're interested in.

0:19:11 So we do have a quorum of the council.

0:19:15 Actually, all seven members are here in either spirit

0:19:18 or on the radio or on the telephone.

0:19:23 Travis, do we have any amendments to our agenda?

0:19:27 We do not. I do want to note for the record that we did send out an amended agenda earlier today.

0:19:35 Under that, it would be listed under the public hearing section where it notes the PH for the term public hearing

0:19:43 and underneath that, it notes the opportunity for action.

0:19:47 Should the council choose to take that this evening?

0:19:49 Thank you, Travis.

0:19:51 We have no proclamations.

0:19:53 We have started in a new tradition with City Council

0:19:55 in allowing public to come and make comments

0:19:57 right on the front end if it's not something

0:20:00 that's already on the agenda.

0:20:01 So if there's anyone that's interested

0:20:03 in talking to us on the front end

0:20:05 so you don't have to stay through the whole meeting,

0:20:07 that's not something on the agenda,

0:20:09 then this is your opportunity to come on forward.

0:20:14 I am not seeing a mad dash for the microphone.

0:20:17 So just to remind folks, if you're here to talk

0:20:20 on the public hearing this evening,

0:20:21 there should be a signup sheet in the back.

0:20:24 Please sign up so that we can have an orderly way

0:20:26 to call you up when that time comes.

0:20:29 We're moving down to, if you do have an agenda

0:20:31 in front of you, the consent calendar,

0:20:33 and I'll turn that over to Council wishes.

0:20:38 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:20:39 I move that we approve the consent calendar as printed.

0:20:43 Second.

0:20:44 We have a motion on the floor by Suzanne Hawkins,

0:20:46 seconded by Chris Talkington to approve the consent calendar as printed.

0:20:51 Anything further on that motion council?

0:20:54 I see no lights.

0:20:55 Lee Alec, can you do a roll call vote please?

0:20:57 Jim Lee?

0:20:57 Yes.

0:21:00 Yeah.

0:21:01 Chris Talkington?

0:21:02 Yes.

0:21:03 Greg Lanting?

0:21:04 Yes.

0:21:05 Don Hall?

0:21:06 Yes.

0:21:07 Rebecca Milsoyka?

0:21:08 Yes.

0:21:09 Motion passes, seven to zero.

0:21:12 I'm going to say yes to.

0:21:14 Oh, we missed you.

0:21:15 Suzanne Hawkins?

0:21:16 Yes.

0:21:17 I didn't feel right, Suzanne, thank you.

0:21:20 So we do have seven to zero on the consent calendar.

0:21:23 Moving under area number two items for consideration.

0:21:28 The first item that we're going to discuss this evening is consideration of a request to adopt a resolution declaring the city's intent to dispose of real property and setting a date for a public hearing.

0:21:40 We have Melinda Anderson.

0:21:43 Welcome, Melinda.

0:21:45 Thank you, Mr. Mayor and Council, good evening.

0:21:47 I'm Melinda Anderson, the city's economic development director.

0:21:51 I think I've started to lose my voice,

0:21:53 so please bear with me.

0:21:54 I'm here representing the Urban Renewal Agency

0:22:00 following on the request that was made

0:22:02 at the Council last Monday evening

0:22:04 for asking the Council to transfer a parcel

0:22:09 of city owned property to the Urban Renewal Agency.

0:22:11 As you recall, the property is on the 200 block of 2nd Avenue South.

0:22:34 It is blocked, or lots, one, let's see, 9 and 10 of block 119 is adjacent to Urban

0:22:45 Mental Agency owned property at 242 2nd Avenue South.

0:22:49 And the reason, as Dr. Bond told you last week, was that the agency would like to offer both

0:22:57 the building for redevelopment and put in this property, which is outlined in red for use

0:23:05 to go with that site.

0:23:07 And we've been, the agency has owned this property at 242 Second Avenue South for about four years,

0:23:15 And it's been vacant since it's been marketed every time that we get any interested party.

0:23:22 They're also interested in the adjacent property to the building.

0:23:27 So I just wanted to remind you that this, that's the building right there, the property

0:23:40 just to the right of it, and this is a shot directly across 2nd Avenue Souths looking into

0:23:50 but it looks to be an alley but it's actually the vacant dirt undeveloped property owned

0:23:55 by the city adjacent to the building on the left.

0:24:01 So I understand that this is basically is the first step in that process for housing, the

0:24:08 agency is asking the council to approve a resolution that would declare the city owned property

0:24:15 as access and to also set a public hearing date for February 24th, 6 p.m. here in the

0:24:21 city council chambers.

0:24:25 Thank you. The other, do we have a resolution number in case we get there?

0:24:29 1918. 1918. Thank you. Suzanne Hawkins.

0:24:36 If we go through with this process and the land becomes available, would you bring it

0:24:41 up to city code as far as paving and stuff before you market it or would that be up

0:24:45 to the new tenant of the building.

0:24:46 The thought by the agency has been to offer the property as is

0:24:50 and let the whoever may become the new owner bring it up to code.

0:24:55 Okay. Whatever that would be based on the use of the property.

0:24:58 Thank you.

0:25:00 Do we have any other questions, Council?

0:25:02 Chris, talking.

0:25:03 Well, and do you take a moment and explain to the public

0:25:06 that may not be aware that if we do transfer the land urban renewal,

0:25:11 how property taxes may or may not be assessed on that?

0:25:16 How property taxes may be assisting on this is a sense.

0:25:19 A sense there.

0:25:20 A city property is accepted now.

0:25:22 Correct.

0:25:23 So currently both the city owned lot and the urban renewal lot are public owned by a public

0:25:28 agency.

0:25:29 And in that in that case neither of these properties are generating any property tax because Idaho

0:25:36 does not tax public agencies on real and personal property.

0:25:39 So currently and for quite a while these properties have not provided any property tax income

0:25:45 tax income to any of the taxing agency, taxing districts within the city of Twin Falls.

0:25:52 So once these get into private hands, the assessor would then reassess the value of the property,

0:26:00 come up with a market value, and then that property owner would then begin paying property tax on

0:26:07 both the real property and whatever personal property may be inside the buildings.

0:26:12 Thank you.

0:26:13 Thank you, Melinda.

0:26:16 Council wishes.

0:26:17 Great landing.

0:26:18 I've moved that we approve a resolution last February 24th.

0:26:23 1918 to disposal of real property

0:26:27 and setting a date of February 24th.

0:26:29 Yes.

0:26:30 For as a public hearing.

0:26:31 16, 6 p.m., 6 p.m.

0:26:33 Second.

0:26:34 I have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanthine,

0:26:37 seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.

0:26:39 Rebecca Mills second.

0:26:41 Thank you, Mayor.

0:26:42 Just for discussion, and I know I mentioned this before,

0:26:45 but I think one of the great struggles downtown has had

0:26:48 is taking places where the public can park

0:26:51 and making it private.

0:26:52 And so it's just been a very difficult situation downtown

0:26:56 and having places where people can park.

0:26:59 So for that reason, I can't support it,

0:27:01 but I certainly do support the redevelopment

0:27:04 and the efforts of the URA.

0:27:06 I think I could support it if I knew what the plan

0:27:09 would be for this piece of property

0:27:12 and that my hope would be that it would continue

0:27:15 to be public parking just because we obviously

0:27:19 have an issue that still needs addressed

0:27:21 and we continue to try to address it downtown.

0:27:23 But so for that reason, again, I'll be voting for, no.

0:27:28 Thank you, Rebecca.

0:27:28 Great planning.

0:27:29 I'll be voting yes, mostly because,

0:27:33 be honest with you, we can't legally use it

0:27:35 as public parking right now anyway.

0:27:37 It's not to our code.

0:27:38 It's a dirt lot.

0:27:39 And the cars that were parked there

0:27:41 are actually parked there illegally.

0:27:43 And so there is no actual public parking

0:27:46 that is being given up because it's not paved.

0:27:49 It's not striped.

0:27:50 It's not ready for public access at this point.

0:27:53 So I'll be going forward with it.

0:27:56 Anything we can do to help downtown to keep revitalizing

0:27:59 if we get another business down there and they pave it

0:28:02 and get jobs down there, it benefits downtown in that way.

0:28:07 I'll just add that I'm in support of this motion as well because I can't imagine them not wanting to keep that as parking because that's got to be beneficial to anyone that would want that site as a business for their own employees to be able to park there.

0:28:25 So I'll be in support.

0:28:27 Chris talking.

0:28:28 One question just comes to mind, since that's the site of the old original fire station.

0:28:33 Has there been a soil analysis done of that, does it represent any public health or reclamation

0:28:41 project requirement?

0:28:42 So I'm not aware of a level two having been done.

0:28:45 I haven't even seen a level of the environment, assessment level one or level two done on this

0:28:50 particular site.

0:28:51 And as the mayor noted, and the Councilman Lanning noted,

0:28:58 most of the folks who have approached us

0:29:00 for interested in the building

0:29:02 have wanted to use this for parking.

0:29:04 So if there were contamination,

0:29:06 and I'm not saying that there's,

0:29:07 because I don't have that information,

0:29:10 using it as a parking lot would be perfectly acceptable

0:29:13 as a use, and there would not be need for cleanup

0:29:16 because it's going to be as faulted over.

0:29:18 Thank you.

0:29:20 Any other on this motion, Council?

0:29:23 The aye, the roll call vote, please.

0:29:25 Sean Berger.

0:29:27 Yes.

0:29:28 Chris Tawkington.

0:29:29 Yes.

0:29:30 Greg Lanting.

0:29:31 Yes.

0:29:32 Don Hall.

0:29:32 Yes.

0:29:33 Rebecca Melsoika.

0:29:34 No.

0:29:35 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:29:36 Yes.

0:29:37 Jim Munn.

0:29:38 Yes.

0:29:39 Motion passes six to one.

0:29:42 Thank you very much.

0:29:43 And also for your questions and comments, appreciate it.

0:29:45 Thank you, Melinda.

0:29:47 We're going to a consideration of the request to approve the airport advisory board's recommendation

0:29:54 to renew on airport car rental lease agreements.

0:29:58 We have our airport manager Bill Carberry.

0:30:01 Welcome, Bill.

0:30:02 Thank you, Mary.

0:30:03 Good evening, council members.

0:30:07 Also tonight, Jim O'Donnell, the airport board chairman, is in attendance if you have

0:30:11 any questions for him at any time for a presentation.

0:30:16 all of our car rentals in the community that are represented here.

0:30:25 Just want to take you out to the airport here a little bit with this photograph into the terminal.

0:30:30 We have four rental car count locations out at the airport.

0:30:35 The terminal building was built in the mid-90s.

0:30:39 The car rental lease agreements have been typically five-year terms, and they've been renewed

0:30:44 with these operators for well beyond my time in 2001 and probably back into the days of

0:30:50 the old terminal.

0:30:52 So the four current agreements expire this spring,

0:30:55 early summer time.

0:30:57 Enterprise Car Rail, which has a location on Blue Lakes,

0:31:01 and has historically been focused on the auto body replacement

0:31:05 market, has been operating on Blue Lakes

0:31:08 and has not had an interest in the airport or a location.

0:31:12 But in 2001, that changed.

0:31:14 They started to verbalize their interest

0:31:16 in an encounter position out of the airport.

0:31:19 So with this and the complexities involved,

0:31:22 I got together with three volunteer airport board members

0:31:25 to start researching this during the fall months

0:31:28 to take a look at the rental car market.

0:31:30 So I'd like to give you a little snapshot

0:31:32 on some gross revenues and also some other things.

0:31:38 This is a little bit of a snapshot on collectively

0:31:41 all of the car rentals over the old since 2009,

0:31:44 the airport, gross revenues that through the garage business

0:31:49 business at the airport, as well as the off-airport car rental agreement that enterprise has.

0:31:55 They do have access to the market enterprise when they have rentals of reservations that

0:32:00 can come out, pick up a reservation so they have access to the market.

0:32:04 They just don't solicit at the airport or have a position.

0:32:07 So, looking at this, and the trend line back back before 2009 was also pretty flat.

0:32:13 So really the thing here, we love the uptick over the last year, but we don't necessarily

0:32:18 considered a trend at this point, it's certainly encouraging, but really the

0:32:22 broadest scope here in back before nine is that we've had a fairly flat

0:32:26 coronal business out of the airport. So with the airport board members, we also

0:32:38 took a look at similar size airports in the region. And the things the the

0:32:44 group was curious about, how many rental brands are out there, it's small non-hub

0:32:49 airports like ourselves, how many counter physicians do they have off

0:32:53 of airport agreements as well.

0:32:55 And have they renewed or bid for these positions

0:32:59 the last time they came about?

0:33:03 So this is sort of an informal survey,

0:33:07 smaller airports, excepting perhaps Idaho Falls,

0:33:11 which has significantly more

0:33:13 in claimants, Sun Valley has some brisk activity.

0:33:17 But you can see the smaller airports

0:33:19 like Yakima, Butte, Pullman, Lewis, Findley,

0:33:22 Pocatello, they're very similar to the activity that we have there, so what we found out is

0:33:28 we have quite a few rental brands on airport. We have more counters than most. Looking back

0:33:37 at 1996, 1995 when the airport was rebuilt and designed, we had two airlines at that time.

0:33:46 We had Horizon Airlines, we had SkyWest as well, so the thinking was there'll be growth

0:33:51 in the community, there will be more opportunities, more airlines, so understandably they'd have

0:33:55 those four counties designed into the building.

0:33:58 But interestingly, when we took this informal telephone survey, we found out that most have

0:34:03 either three, in some instances too.

0:34:06 It was interesting to see most of them had enterprise with an off-airport agreement,

0:34:12 with access to their markets, but they were at an off-airport location.

0:34:16 Valley has just allowed Enterprise on airport and they've teamed with the National brand

0:34:22 as well.

0:34:23 So as Enterprise and National up there and that's just happened recently.

0:34:26 They had an open counter and created a lease agreement with Enterprise.

0:34:42 So with this type of activity that they looked at, they also looked at what are options through

0:34:47 Enforg.

0:34:48 They talked about renewal with the incumbents like they've done historically.

0:34:53 They talked about possibly getting these counter locations.

0:34:57 There's a mechanism that some airports use, well,

0:35:00 they'll bid counter locations.

0:35:03 And the bids are awarded based on minimum manual guarantees,

0:35:07 where they either provide 10%.

0:35:09 That's the standard industry percentage

0:35:11 of take for the airport, from the activity,

0:35:14 or the minimum guarantee, whichever is greater.

0:35:19 They also looked at possibilities of consolidation

0:35:23 of the Avis and budget to one counter position,

0:35:25 opening a counter position,

0:35:27 and perhaps inviting enterprise in as well.

0:35:30 So these were the types of things that the group looked at.

0:35:33 Then they decided, hey, we want to be inclusive.

0:35:36 Let's invite each one of these car rental operators in,

0:35:39 with our small group.

0:35:40 Let's have some candid discussions.

0:35:42 Let's see what their concerns are on their issues.

0:35:44 So back in October and November, they had two meetings,

0:35:48 they invited all of the operators in,

0:35:50 and we had conference calls with some

0:35:51 of their regional representatives.

0:35:53 So they were all able to talk about what their concerns were.

0:35:57 Beyond airport operators, which were represented by Leanne

0:36:01 Watkins, who's here this evening with Ava Spudget,

0:36:04 she is their manager.

0:36:06 They all talked about their longevity.

0:36:08 Leanne's been at the airport for 34 years.

0:36:11 National Alamo Manager, Pam Ritter,

0:36:13 has been there for 30 years.

0:36:15 And Hertz Manager, Sarah Nelson,

0:36:17 has been operating at the airport for 12 years.

0:36:20 So all of them similarly talked about their consistent customer service to the airport over a long tenure.

0:36:27 In support of their operations, they made note of the significant investments at the airport with their car wash facilities, their fueling facilities,

0:36:38 all of that infrastructure that they put in as well.

0:36:41 And lastly, I think one of the things that concerned them the most were the size of the market.

0:36:47 are an uptick there, they all conveyed that it's been a relatively flat market with a lot

0:36:53 of brand names and a lot of saturation, a lot of competition. And they felt that with

0:36:58 that type of competition, what it's done is lowered the average rental rates and the overall

0:37:04 revenues to the airport and to their operation. So what they all felt in unison was that they'd

0:37:10 like to see their lease agreements renewed for another five-year term. So with this research

0:37:15 under their belt committee said let's go to the full board in January let's

0:37:19 really voice let's have this exercise and voice these these concerns to the

0:37:24 full board so they did that in January they met with the full board and after

0:37:29 much discussion the board voted six to zero to recommend to the city council to

0:37:35 renew with the incumbents they appreciated enterprises interest in being out at

0:37:41 the airport, but they cited several reasons for their decision.

0:37:46 They talked about the long history of the incumbents.

0:37:49 They talked about the investment that they made over the many years out at the airport

0:37:52 and their facilities.

0:37:55 And they also felt that the four counters and five round-car brands were more than at

0:38:00 most airports our size.

0:38:03 And they were also concerned with the flat market out there and what that meant for opportunities.

0:38:08 So with that, I'm bringing to you the board's recommendation.

0:38:14 It was a difficult issue when they took a very deliberate, slow pace and examining with everyone involved.

0:38:21 So with that, they voted six to zero as I mentioned to recommend renewing with the current operators.

0:38:32 If the city council does concur with their recommendation, they welcome enterprise to continue as an on-fairport operator.

0:38:40 So with that, I'll stand for any questions.

0:38:43 and also one of my counsel that we do have our

0:38:47 airport chairperson, committee chairperson,

0:38:49 Jim O'Donnell, the audience.

0:38:52 Greg Lanning.

0:38:53 I think Chris Curtis is doing this.

0:38:54 Well, you just answered my question.

0:38:56 Enterprise will continue to operate.

0:38:58 There is invited to continue to operate as an off-base operator.

0:39:03 That's correct.

0:39:05 So how does that, we're talking about counter space,

0:39:08 but I know that there's having rented cars out there,

0:39:11 mostly for athletic events for high schools.

0:39:15 How does it work with the space outside?

0:39:17 Is that also do we do it up by their counter space?

0:39:19 Or how does that work?

0:39:20 Because I know they have spots to the west of the terminal.

0:39:25 Each counter has 10 parking ready positions,

0:39:28 just outside the terminal building.

0:39:29 So they each have 10 of those.

0:39:31 And they also have ground for their car wash facilities.

0:39:34 Avis budget is consolidated into one car wash facility.

0:39:39 has theirs as well as national.

0:39:41 Okay, thank you.

0:39:44 So would those spots be divvied up if it was?

0:39:47 There were another entity added.

0:39:50 They'd all have seven then?

0:39:52 I think we would still look perhaps at 10 per counter.

0:39:55 Okay.

0:39:56 You still have room for that.

0:39:58 Well, right now, well, yeah, we would

0:40:00 divvied up 10 per counter.

0:40:01 Thank you.

0:40:03 Suzanne Hopkins.

0:40:04 Since they took the time to come,

0:40:05 can we be introduced to the counter managers?

0:40:08 Because I would be interested.

0:40:09 Thank you.

0:40:10 I'm happy to.

0:40:11 Thank you.

0:40:12 I work very closely with her.

0:40:13 Cam Ritter, would you please stand?

0:40:15 Cam is the manager with National Alamo.

0:40:18 Next to her is Leanne Watkins.

0:40:20 Been there for 34 years with Ava's budget.

0:40:24 Then her two daughters, Bridget, and Jamie to her left.

0:40:30 Also Justin Maddox with Enterprise Car, and I was here to see what I was talking about.

0:40:34 Thank you.

0:40:35 Oh, and Sarah.

0:40:37 I'd just like to say thank you guys for coming.

0:40:44 Chris talking.

0:40:47 Well, I would move the council concur with the agreement of the airport advisory board on recommending the.

0:40:55 The airport car rental lease agreements.

0:40:59 Second motion on floor by Chris talking and seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to concur with the recommendations.

0:41:10 of the, as stated earlier.

0:41:13 Rebecca, I'll sort that out.

0:41:14 Thank you, Mayor.

0:41:17 I think that I would actually support a competitive bit

0:41:21 in RFQ process.

0:41:22 I think that definitely I appreciate the long service,

0:41:26 the long-term commitment of these companies,

0:41:29 but regarding what's in the best interest of the airport

0:41:32 and the best interest of the citizens who own the airport,

0:41:36 it would make sense to me to create a competitive process

0:41:40 And one thing, if you're concerned about having too many counters,

0:41:46 that one thing you might do is restrict the number of counter applicants

0:41:53 that you will accept after you go through this competitive process.

0:41:57 In the report, it says that you accept 10% or the minimum annual guarantee,

0:42:05 which historically in our case has been $4,200,

0:42:11 but the on-airport and the off-airport agreements

0:42:15 are required to pay either that or 10%,

0:42:18 and historically they pay the 10%,

0:42:21 so it seems that even if you are an off-airport company,

0:42:26 you're paying the same, but you don't have.

0:42:28 I may be working on that awkwardly and the other.

0:42:30 Is that incorrect?

0:42:31 I apologize if I do, the off-airport,

0:42:32 do not have a minimum requirement,

0:42:35 just the on-air court have a minimum.

0:42:37 But they also pay 10%.

0:42:38 They do pay 10% of their business.

0:42:40 So they're all paying 10%.

0:42:43 So it seems equal.

0:42:44 So I would be in support of a more competitive process.

0:42:49 I think it's a healthy step to take.

0:42:54 Thank you, Rebecca.

0:42:55 Any further on this motion, counsel?

0:42:58 Lee, Iler, roll call vote.

0:43:00 Chris, talking to him?

0:43:01 Yes.

0:43:02 Greg, Lansing?

0:43:03 Yes.

0:43:04 Don Hall?

0:43:05 Yes.

0:43:06 Rebecca Milseika, no.

0:43:09 Suzanne Hawkins?

0:43:10 Yes.

0:43:11 Jim An?

0:43:12 Yes.

0:43:13 Sean Berriger?

0:43:14 No.

0:43:17 We motion passes 5 to 2.

0:43:20 Thank you, Bill.

0:43:21 And we're moving on to the next item on the agenda, which

0:43:23 is Bill Carberry again.

0:43:26 Yes.

0:43:26 Thank you.

0:43:28 Did you want to add something to that?

0:43:30 No.

0:43:30 OK, very good.

0:43:32 Consideration of a request to utilize a $25,000 ITD

0:43:36 state grant to purchase an airport maintenance truck and flatbed.

0:43:41 It's yours again, Bill.

0:43:42 Thank you very much.

0:43:43 And I appreciate everyone's patience this evening.

0:43:45 I know we're all waiting on the public hearing.

0:43:48 I was here in December with an Idaho Transportation Department

0:43:52 Division of Aeronautics Grant for $25,000.

0:43:55 And at that time, we spoke about utilizing it

0:43:58 for a capital improvement at the airport.

0:44:00 The difficult thing with these grants

0:44:02 is you can never budget this revenue,

0:44:03 because you just really don't know

0:44:04 if you're going to get one.

0:44:06 I've been working with IITD for several months.

0:44:08 I anticipated it back in the spring or summer,

0:44:11 and it didn't materialize till December.

0:44:13 So I'd like to invite you to take a look at an idea staff

0:44:17 has for utilizing that for a very practical purpose.

0:44:21 The grant was awarded based on our matching dollars

0:44:25 that we interrears, it's sort of a grant consideration

0:44:28 interrears for the matching dollars

0:44:29 that we've spent on federal projects.

0:44:31 So we've signed that grant, and those dollars

0:44:35 will be coming. What staff would like to do is make two purchases. One would be a new three

0:44:45 quarter Ford pickup truck, like the one here. This is our 2004. What they'd like to do, and

0:44:52 follow me, it gets a little convoluted, but it doesn't make sense in the end if I can do

0:44:56 this. They'd like to use that utility box on the back from the 2004 range, which now is

0:45:03 again on 140,000 miles, place that utility box onto the new truck platform and then

0:45:11 they'd like to take the new flatbed, which they have a bid from utility truck

0:45:16 equipment in Boise, put the new flatbed on here. Once the new flatbed is installed

0:45:21 there, they like to take this spray equipment from our 1985 Congo truck that

0:45:31 we inherited I think from the Mountain Home Bomb Squad some years ago. You did

0:45:34 They'd like to take the spray equipment and put it on that new flatbed.

0:45:39 So then we'll have two improvements, then we'll have a new truck with the utility box

0:45:43 on it, and the 2004 will move more into a specialized role with its flatbed and the spray

0:45:49 equipment to enable us to spray weeds, spray some deicing fluid.

0:45:54 So the staff's really excited about trying to get a two-for-one out of the deal here.

0:45:59 So with that, I'll just put some of the costs up, and I don't have my pointer, but the

0:46:07 The truck without a bed, it's at $22,680, the flatbed purchased separately from the utility

0:46:15 truck equipment in Boise is $1750.

0:46:18 So total costs are $24,430 with a grand amount of $25,000.

0:46:25 So this, like I said, this will enable us to accomplish some specialized stuff as well

0:46:30 as our day-to-day operations with the new truck.

0:46:33 So with that, I'll try to answer any questions you might have.

0:46:37 I can see that you have a fondness for that paint job.

0:46:39 Is that what you're going to paint this new vehicle?

0:46:42 I'll have to talk it over a little bit.

0:46:45 Council have any questions for Bill?

0:46:49 Council want to make any decisions?

0:46:53 Great.

0:46:54 I move that we accept the request of consideration

0:46:58 of utilization of 25,000 ITT state grant

0:47:01 to purchase an airport maintenance truck and flatbed

0:47:07 And as described by Bill Carver.

0:47:13 Second.

0:47:14 We have a motion on floor by Greg Lanting,

0:47:16 seconded by Rebecca Melsoica, as stated and presented.

0:47:21 Anything further on that motion council?

0:47:25 Leanna Rokal-Bolt, please.

0:47:27 Greg Lanting.

0:47:28 Yes.

0:47:29 Don Hall.

0:47:29 Yes.

0:47:30 Rebecca Melsoica.

0:47:31 Yes.

0:47:32 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:47:33 Yes.

0:47:34 Jim Mann.

0:47:34 Yes.

0:47:35 Sean Beriker.

0:47:37 Yes.

0:47:38 Chris Tockington.

0:47:38 Yes.

0:47:39 motion passes seven to zero.

0:47:42 Thank you.

0:47:43 Good evening.

0:47:44 Thank you.

0:47:46 Next item on the agenda is public input and or items from the city manager and city council.

0:47:50 Now this gives the public a chance to come and have some input again as long as it's not

0:47:56 something that's already been on the council or or on our agenda or what's coming up.

0:48:01 We still have a public hearing that is coming up where you'll have a chance to make comments

0:48:06 regarding the canyon jump.

0:48:09 next. So first, we'll start with the public. Is there anyone from the public that would

0:48:14 like to come forward? Again, no mad dash. City manager, anything further?

0:48:24 Mr. Mayor and members of the Council, just by way of notification, our citizens that have

0:48:30 been selected to participate in our bi-annual survey should have received a postcard or will

0:48:37 be in the process of receiving those postcards.

0:48:40 That means that they've been selected in a random sample by the National Citizen Survey

0:48:44 to complete the survey that should be arriving in their mailboxes over the course of the

0:48:50 next week.

0:48:51 We have sent out and started our internal communications to work with our media partners and to communicate

0:48:58 also with those directly that have subscribed to our news systems, letting them know to complete

0:49:06 those surveys as they are as they can as they're delivered.

0:49:12 So we would encourage citizens to be on the lookout for postcards and then also the survey

0:49:17 they really do help us help guide and move the organization forward.

0:49:22 Those results we will be presenting to the council once complete which we anticipate to

0:49:27 be late spring.

0:49:31 I'll just reiterate what Travis said.

0:49:32 We really do take a look at those surveys, and it's very meaningful to us, it gives us guidance.

0:49:39 So please, if you've been selected, please fill those out because we want a really good sampling coming back to us.

0:49:45 So we understand what the community is thinking.

0:49:48 Travis, aren't there like 1500 or so of those that are sent out?

0:49:52 We will send out 1200?

0:49:54 12.

0:49:55 Okay.

0:49:56 So to represent the section, I think it's also pre-sorted so far as geographic area.

0:50:02 and some demographics.

0:50:05 That's right.

0:50:06 So we will break the community into three sections,

0:50:08 and then we will, they will go forward

0:50:10 and they will ensure that they're waiting the survey

0:50:13 to reflect the demographics of the community

0:50:16 determined by the 2010 census.

0:50:20 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:50:22 I'd like to remind everybody

0:50:23 if they haven't purchased their tickets

0:50:25 for the policeman's ball this Saturday night.

0:50:27 They're still for sale at the police office.

0:50:29 It's a great chance to support Camp Rainbow Gold

0:50:31 and our police officers, it's gonna be at Canyon Crest

0:50:35 and it's a lot of fun.

0:50:37 Thank you Suzanne, anything else from council?

0:50:41 All right, moving on to what I'm assuming most of you

0:50:44 are here for the public hearing.

0:50:47 Consideration of a request to approve the agreement

0:50:50 with Beckley Media to use Twin Falls City property

0:50:53 in his effort to jump the Snake River Canyon.

0:50:57 So we'll start off with our city manager, Travis Rontweiler.

0:51:02 Mr. Mayor, members of the Council,

0:51:03 you have an agreement before you

0:51:05 that has been probably the source of a significant effort

0:51:08 that we've collectively had the conversation

0:51:11 over the course of the last several weeks.

0:51:14 As we've continued to go forward,

0:51:16 we in and week out with the conversation,

0:51:18 there have been changes that we have made

0:51:22 and moved to kind of forward into the agreement.

0:51:26 Mr. Mayor, members of the Council,

0:51:28 this is the time that we have set aside

0:51:29 for that public hearing to review and to share their comments in general about the agreement.

0:51:38 We can really move this forward in many different ways.

0:51:42 I can step aside and we can begin to hear from the citizens where they can share their

0:51:46 thoughts and their concerns.

0:51:48 I could go through the agreement and then have the citizens come up really at whatever

0:51:54 you feel is most advantageous.

0:51:55 We're happy to take those steps.

0:51:58 You know, I think it might be beneficial to at least go through the agreement to a certain

0:52:03 point so that folks can have a chance to hear that.

0:52:06 Let me introduce, uh, Prince, when you're like, I said hi, you were going to do that.

0:52:12 So we're a team.

0:52:14 Welcome, Fritz.

0:52:17 Mayor Council, first I want to point out the changes that you've seen on the most recent

0:52:25 version.

0:52:26 Actually, I sent one out this afternoon and I don't know if you've seen that with, uh,

0:52:31 just a couple of changes. It corrects the event date to September 7th instead of September 8th

0:52:39 and then it removes all the highlighting and the watermark. You do have a staff report that

0:52:47 indicates the changes from last week. There was a special events permit fee which was removed.

0:53:01 We had a discussion about Mr. Beckley upgrading the roadway.

0:53:08 We changed the language for the development of the roadway to the city standards required

0:53:13 for rural roadways.

0:53:16 We modified the description of the parking lot to add a statement that the size and configuration

0:53:22 of the parking lot shall require the approval of the city council to recall there was quite

0:53:28 a discussion about how big is that going to be? What is it going to look like? So that

0:53:33 would be left for a future decision. On the Canyon Rim Trail, we deleted the option of them

0:53:39 building the trail, rather that they would be required to pay the $51,000 estimated cost

0:53:48 to construct the Canyon Rim Trail, allowing them 180 days and to post a bond in order

0:53:55 to ensure that payment.

0:54:00 Also, there were some changes requested by Beckley,

0:54:05 including the timing of the insurance requirement.

0:54:09 And now that matches what they negotiated with the state.

0:54:17 Also changed the date for posting the bond from April 1 to May 1.

0:54:23 And added a force measure language.

0:54:28 You've probably seen that before in boilerplate.

0:54:31 It comes at the end of lots of agreements.

0:54:33 And basically it's a provision that says circumstances beyond

0:54:38 the control of any of the parties occur,

0:54:41 then the terms of the lease can be suspended

0:54:45 until that condition is gone.

0:54:50 So those are the changes.

0:54:52 If there are questions about changes,

0:54:54 I can talk about those.

0:54:55 And then I'll briefly go through the entire lease agreement

0:54:58 what we have.

0:54:59 Very good.

0:55:00 It looks like we have at least one question.

0:55:02 We're back in the middle, so I can.

0:55:03 Thank you, Mayor.

0:55:04 My question is not on any of the changes, but as we were taking a look at the jump site this

0:55:09 afternoon, my question was on E, the fencing requirement.

0:55:15 And I was wondering where it says, lessee shell construct fencing as designated by the less

0:55:20 sore along both the easterly and westerly boundaries of the lease premises.

0:55:25 I understand that we have an agreement to create fencing on the eastern side, and that's why

0:55:31 we're doing it.

0:55:32 But I had a question of why the other side and the applicant has indicated that they may or

0:55:39 may not need to construct fencing.

0:55:42 In our discussions with the Beckley and Mr. Simmons, they do intend to fence along the

0:55:48 the west side to help protect that, I think from when, probably from spectators as well.

0:55:56 That fencing, the idea is we would come to an agreement so that whatever it is they put

0:56:02 in there will be put in a way that will be reusable by us.

0:56:07 So that's the intent of that provision.

0:56:10 Okay.

0:56:11 Travis, would you like to ask?

0:56:15 Mr. Simmons, who is legal counsel for Mr. Beckley,

0:56:18 might be able to expand on the fence piece as well.

0:56:22 My understanding is there might be a quick change that occurred

0:56:28 while we were out of the two-earth jump site, but I might add.

0:56:31 Mr. Simmons, welcome.

0:56:33 Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the council.

0:56:35 My understanding was that we were,

0:56:37 my understanding until earlier today,

0:56:39 was that we were going to construct fencing on both sides.

0:56:43 I heard Mr. Beckley say earlier today that we don't need it on the west side, and so that's

0:56:52 a change that I was unaware of.

0:56:55 But we, I think, stand ready to construct a fence either way, it's up to the council.

0:57:00 Thank you.

0:57:01 Okay, great.

0:57:02 I just didn't want to include it in the agreement if it wasn't necessary, and if really neither

0:57:05 party wanted it, I wanted to make sure it's absolutely necessary if we're going to require

0:57:10 it in the agreement.

0:57:11 Thank you.

0:57:13 Back to you, Mr. Woodland.

0:57:19 Okay, we'll get back to the agreement.

0:57:21 So let's just start on the face page.

0:57:23 Again, if we have a hard copy so that the audience can see it as we go through.

0:57:52 So the, as of today, the commencement date is today, February 3rd, expires September 30th

0:58:00 of this year.

0:58:04 The legal description is referred to inside the document.

0:58:09 The bonding requirement is $1 million, and that's further described inside the agreement.

0:58:16 Insurance requirements $10 million, and it's further described inside the agreement.

0:58:23 And then there are three attachments, special terms, the actual legal description and an aerial map.

0:58:32 On page one, it describes how the property can be used.

0:58:37 It can be used to conduct a vehicular jump over the Snake River.

0:58:44 Basically, it talks about what they cannot do after that.

0:58:49 They can't use it for any other purpose unless they get our agreement.

0:58:53 They won't damage the property.

0:58:56 They'll acquire all permits that are required.

0:58:59 that this lease will act as the special event permit,

0:59:03 and they'll furnish us with any technical reports

0:59:06 that we request regarding the event.

0:59:10 Starting on paragraph two, the lease is divided into three phases.

0:59:17 The first phase is planning and permitting.

0:59:21 As we discussed earlier in 2A1,

0:59:28 There will be a separate agreement with Twin Falls County to deal with their concerns regarding

0:59:33 a potential law enforcement issues.

0:59:39 Number two, they'll obtain all required government approvals for all activities for all phases.

0:59:47 Number three, if you can zoom that in a little bit, Travis.

0:59:56 That first paragraph describes all of the areas that their plan is required to have.

1:00:04 That plan is required on April 1, includes proof of the government approvals, launch site

1:00:12 development and modifications, existing planned access, access controls, lateral roles, location

1:00:20 of sanitary facilities, location of supporting facilities.

1:00:25 of potential surface disturbance traffic and this is the biggest one, probably the biggest

1:00:31 one that the council has talked about, the traffic, public safety control measures including

1:00:36 spectators located on the river in the canyon on any bridges where spectators might want

1:00:41 to view the event. Emergency first responder locations, fire prevention, identification

1:00:49 of hazardous storage and maps, providing sufficient detail to include, and then you'll see a number

1:00:58 of other items, administrative information, facilities, and improvements, and that goes

1:01:06 on for a ways. Phase 2 is over on page 5. That's actually the staging and performance,

1:01:14 so as soon as we finish the planning phase, they are permitted to begin the staging and

1:01:20 performance of the event and we'll talk about a little bit later what that will

1:01:26 include on the site but we know it includes a road parking area and related

1:01:34 improvements on the site. That phase runs all the way up to the event on

1:01:42 September 7th. Phase three is the Reclamation and that runs until the

1:01:50 expiration of the lease or until the

1:01:53 reclamation has been completed. They're

1:01:55 required to return the plan, the site to

1:01:59 us with restored to the condition it was

1:02:04 in with the exception of the road, the

1:02:06 parking area, trail, and the fence.

1:02:10 Over on page six paragraph three is the

1:02:18 bonding requirement that as we noted

1:02:20 before that date has changed to May 1st

1:02:23 when they're required to pose the bond.

1:02:26 It's to protect the city and the public against any loss due

1:02:30 to any violation of the provision of this lease.

1:02:34 And as we'll discuss a little bit later,

1:02:36 there'll be a bonding requirement

1:02:37 for the public improvements the road to parking lot.

1:02:42 And those are 125% of the estimated cost.

1:02:47 Paragraph 4 prohibits the sub-leaser assignment.

1:02:51 We had a discussion at one of the meetings

1:02:53 about allowing substitutions, and you'll see that provision in there in the case of unforeseen

1:03:07 emergency circumstances, and in that case there are two substitute jumpers.

1:03:18 Paragraph 5 basically says that they'll comply with all applicable laws and rules.

1:03:25 They're responsible for informing themselves of all applicable rules that might affect

1:03:32 the jump, and also that they cannot commit any waste or nuisance on the side.

1:03:38 Paragraph 6, Environmental Safety and Sanitary Requirements, again as we'll talk about a little

1:03:47 bit later, this lease limits the use of the site to the lessee and any required crew.

1:03:56 So no public will be allowed on the site.

1:04:00 So this, the sanitary requirements are probably not that much.

1:04:04 They need to show us that they do have garbage cans,

1:04:08 port of bodies and things like that.

1:04:13 Paragraph seven on page eight.

1:04:20 We're offering no warranty of fitness for any purpose.

1:04:25 The lessee Beckley media has examined the site.

1:04:30 They've examined the condition of the property.

1:04:33 They've examined all laws and regulations.

1:04:36 rules, anything else that might affect their ability to do what they want to do, they take

1:04:40 it as is, and as is condition.

1:04:43 So basically we're saying this is our property, we're not telling you anything beyond that,

1:04:48 you need to do your own due diligence.

1:04:55 paragraph 8, we don't know between them and the state tax commission whether there will

1:05:01 be taxes imposed on this, when it's a lease or not, they'll have to find that out.

1:05:11 paragraph nine, mostly that's telling them what they can't do on the property.

1:05:18 And again, we'll talk about it later.

1:05:20 We've told them what they can do on the property.

1:05:27 Oberon page 10 paragraph 10 are the insurance requirements.

1:05:33 And as I said before, minimum requirement is $10 million.

1:05:39 They already have a $10 million policy to cover all of these same things on the state lease.

1:05:46 So we'll be added as an additional insured to that policy.

1:06:05 Paragraph 11 on page 14 describes the requirements

1:06:13 for the bonds that is required here.

1:06:18 Paragraph 3 was the condition.

1:06:20 This states the technical requirements of the bonds.

1:06:27 Paragraph 12 on page 15 is a release and indemnification

1:06:33 from Beckley media to the city.

1:06:41 Paragraph 13 on page 16 allows us to inspect the site

1:06:47 to make sure that they're doing what they promise

1:06:49 to do under the lease.

1:06:55 Paragraph 16, starting on the bottom of page 16,

1:07:00 talks about terms of default and paragraph 17,

1:07:06 the provisions for termination of the lease

1:07:09 in case of a default.

1:07:22 And after that, there's a lot of boilerplate standard provisions

1:07:28 that are included in most agreements to handle all the miscellaneous legal matters.

1:07:38 One of the new one that has been added at the bottom of that, bottom of paragraph 22 on page 21,

1:07:47 That's the force-measure provision, any cause beyond the control of the less or less

1:07:58 ease, despite the exercise of due diligence, they're unable to prevent or overcome.

1:08:04 And it gives examples of that.

1:08:12 And you'll see that if either party is rendered wholly or in part unable to perform its obligations

1:08:17 under the agreement because of an event, a force-measure, both parties shall be excused

1:08:23 from whatever performance is affected.

1:08:27 And that's conditioned.

1:08:28 It's conditioned on the non-performing party

1:08:31 to notify the other party.

1:08:35 The suspension is only as great as necessary by the event.

1:08:41 And if any obligation was prior to the time of the occurrence,

1:08:45 that is not suspended.

1:08:50 If you'll turn over to attachment A, page 25,

1:08:55 those are the special terms and conditions.

1:09:06 paragraph one. Again, this is like the earlier one, no warranty of fitness for purpose or anything

1:09:15 else. They're aware of the conditions of the property. And in addition to that, the use of

1:09:24 the property shall be restricted to the lessee. And those persons necessary to stage the event.

1:09:30 The lessee shall not sell tickets for admission on to the lease premises or otherwise permit

1:09:34 public onto the lease premises for any reason whatsoever, including viewing the event.

1:09:41 In addition, lessation shall not permit either the possession or consumption of alcohol in

1:09:45 the lease premises.

1:09:47 Just for a moment, if you'll turn over to the last page with the map.

1:10:01 So as you'll recall, this is a very long, skinny piece of property.

1:10:06 It's fifty feet wide, most of the length.

1:10:11 There is no room for the public, there's probably barely room for the, for the, uh,

1:10:18 Beckley media and their crew, whatever trucks that they need on there, so, uh, that, that

1:10:25 is the reason for that provision that does not allow the public government property.

1:10:32 Paragraph 2 says, uh, that's on page 25, this is not a partnership, this is simply a lease,

1:10:46 This is not our event, directly media's event, in case anyone gets confused about that.

1:10:54 So this specifically says we are not.

1:10:58 There's another section on sanitation, paragraph four.

1:11:01 We talked about it in earlier meetings, the requirement that they reimburse the city for

1:11:07 staff costs that are directly related to this event.

1:11:14 Paragraph five on page 26.

1:11:18 We know that an event like this will result

1:11:22 in additional law enforcement costs.

1:11:24 We know that our city police, probably every officer

1:11:27 available, will not be allowed to go on vacation,

1:11:30 will not be allowed to take leave.

1:11:33 Everyone will be on duty, and we know that won't be enough.

1:11:36 We know that other law enforcement, County Sheriff,

1:11:40 ISP and others will also be required. The lessee will be responsible for those costs.

1:11:50 Paragraph 6 is the paragraph that talks about them helping to promote the area. Paragraph

1:12:02 7 is the consideration paragraph. Consideration is what they're giving in order to get the

1:12:11 and what they're getting is a special events permit fee.

1:12:18 They're gonna construct a road

1:12:19 that will eventually serve as our road

1:12:22 into the park and trailhead parking lot.

1:12:30 They will construct the Canyon Rim Trail

1:12:34 from the East Early Terminus to the property line,

1:12:43 the fencing and then all of that construction

1:12:47 It's required to be approved in writing by the city prior to the construction

1:12:55 Attachment be is a legal description and then the attachments see is

1:13:01 So that's a summary

1:13:07 Try to answer any other questions. Do you have any questions for our council? I'm not seeing a lot of lights

1:13:17 Blicker on here ladies and gentlemen also remember we're going to be opening up to the public here soon

1:13:21 So if you're interested in in testifying this evening and be really

1:13:26 Appreciated if you go in the back of the room and sign up so that we can call you up here orderly

1:13:30 Travis

1:13:31 And we do encourage public testimony, so please come forward this evening. We want to hear from you. Mr. Mayor members of the council in

1:13:41 We have received three pieces of correspondence that the individuals had submitted prior to the public hearing that

1:13:48 but I do not believe they're able to attend

1:13:51 and so we will also flash those up

1:13:52 on the projector for the audience

1:13:55 and for the council's viewing.

1:13:57 Was that some of them coming from council members to you

1:14:00 as well?

1:14:01 Yes.

1:14:02 I know I sent it.

1:14:03 Okay, perfect.

1:14:04 Yes.

1:14:06 All right, at this point,

1:14:08 if council does not have any further questions of staff,

1:14:13 we are going to open the public hearing portion

1:14:16 of this meeting this evening.

1:14:17 And if someone could go back and get the list

1:14:19 so I could call folks up,

1:14:21 we're gonna probably be a low liberal tonight with time,

1:14:26 probably three, four minutes.

1:14:27 We generally go two minutes, but if you go beyond that,

1:14:30 we'll probably gently persuade you to wrap it up,

1:14:35 if you would.

1:14:40 Thank you, Josh.

1:14:48 Bridget Clark, I think you were here for the car rental.

1:14:52 Okay, thank you.

1:14:55 All right, it looks like, and if you would,

1:14:58 if you haven't, when you come up for it,

1:14:59 If you'd state your address because some of you folks did not put that on here, appreciate

1:15:04 it.

1:15:05 I'll start off with Jill Devries.

1:15:08 Devries?

1:15:09 Devries?

1:15:12 Certainly.

1:15:13 I'll bring you back, okay?

1:15:15 Yeah, certainly.

1:15:18 The next person is Seth Wheeler, I believe.

1:15:24 And straighten me out on names when you come up, folks, because I'm not beyond butchering

1:15:28 your name.

1:15:34 Welcome, Seth.

1:15:35 Thank you, sir.

1:15:36 My name is Seth Wheeler.

1:15:38 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:15:41 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:15:46 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:15:47 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:15:54 So I've been following this with some interest for quite some time.

1:15:58 I have not been able to come to the previous meetings, other obligations, sorry I didn't

1:16:05 addressed the part today, where in my work a close.

1:16:10 The document that we saw, the agreement

1:16:13 looks very fitting, very well drawn up.

1:16:18 But I'm a little bit concerned about the things that are not

1:16:20 in the agreement, in particular the aesthetics of this event.

1:16:27 As I understand it, one of the stated goals early on

1:16:31 was to protect the City of Twins image and branding

1:16:36 afar.

1:16:38 And I'm a little worried that this is not going to give us

1:16:41 anything in a black eye.

1:16:45 I'm, number one, I'm concerned about the ability

1:16:48 of this jump to be performed safely.

1:16:53 And I'm a little bit worried about having 30,000 people,

1:16:58 was it?

1:16:59 On the other side of the canyon,

1:17:02 we're a big rocket-propelled missile is gonna be aimed.

1:17:09 I think that has a major league potential

1:17:11 to give us a black eye.

1:17:14 I don't think that the way this event is going

1:17:16 is going to be well-pulled up,

1:17:19 and I don't think it's gonna be a very good thing

1:17:21 for me to have in my backyard.

1:17:24 I think that frankly, things should have gone differently,

1:17:28 and I think a different horse should have been chosen.

1:17:32 Thank you very much.

1:17:33 Thank you, Mr. Wheeler.

1:17:37 Mark Lambert.

1:17:43 Similar looking clothes.

1:17:45 Welcome, Mr. Lambert.

1:17:48 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:17:52 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:17:52 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:17:56 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:17:58 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:18:00 That's my backyard.

1:18:00 It's where I've chosen to raise my family.

1:18:03 I too am concerned about the image that will be projected

1:18:07 about Twin Falls with this event.

1:18:09 I've read through the draft on the City Council's website

1:18:12 website today.

1:18:14 I've found several things to be kind of lacking in it.

1:18:18 One thing is that if you look at Big Ed's website, his own,

1:18:25 he says there will be hundreds of thousands of people coming

1:18:28 to the event.

1:18:30 There's no place for them to go on the launch site.

1:18:34 They estimate a much smaller number on the landing site,

1:18:36 apparently.

1:18:37 I wasn't aware of that.

1:18:38 But I didn't understand how we were prepared for infrastructure for hundreds of thousands

1:18:44 of people.

1:18:45 And the draft does not explain how that would be handled.

1:18:49 On the video on his site, it's a simulation and I understand it's a simulation.

1:18:52 It's not an actual event.

1:18:54 The rocket bike launches off, flies, parachute deploys, pretty easy please.

1:18:59 He lands on the X and great land and great.

1:19:03 As he said, what if they miss?

1:19:06 As anybody who's ever jumped out of an airplane knows,

1:19:09 you're at the mercy of the wind when you have a parachute

1:19:11 deploy.

1:19:12 And if you ever attend a youth soccer game or outdoor event

1:19:17 in Twin Falls, you know there's going to be wind

1:19:20 on your outside.

1:19:22 So I don't know about the safety.

1:19:23 How can you plan for that?

1:19:24 How to predict the wind where you're

1:19:26 going to land and point, land that missile, as he said?

1:19:33 I just want to express my concern, and my neighbors,

1:19:38 about how this is to be pulled off or how the planning is going.

1:19:43 I would encourage the council to not go forward with this plan,

1:19:47 but perhaps look into another participant,

1:19:51 whoever you have as your second, and see what they have,

1:19:54 and give them enough time to properly plan,

1:19:56 because I think if this gets further down the road

1:19:59 and you go, you know what, this isn't right,

1:20:00 we're not going to do it, you will not have enough time

1:20:02 to properly put an event into place safely

1:20:05 to have it done right.

1:20:07 Thanks for your time.

1:20:08 Thank you, Ms. Muymer.

1:20:13 Next on the list, I believe is Victoria.

1:20:17 Thank you, Victoria, Wakewood, welcome, Mrs. Wakewood.

1:20:34 Thank you, and I'm here again.

1:20:37 And as we go on, my concerns get greater and greater.

1:20:45 Because what I am seeing is the state is caring about a least,

1:20:50 City Council is caring about a lease. Everything else is being dropped in between. I see nothing

1:20:57 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:21:08 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:21:19 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:21:25 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:21:31 of occasions and somehow it feels as if my written comments are going lost in cyberspace.

1:21:39 I'm not getting anything back. And I'm feeling as if nothing is being reflected in anything

1:21:46 but a lease. And I'm telling you there's more than a lease that's at, somebody's got to take

1:21:53 responsibility for more than a lease, okay? I have some additional concerns in that my

1:22:03 feeling is quoting from Big Ed. He thinks that this is going to be ten times the episode

1:22:17 of a Jerry Springer. Excuse me. I don't want to be on Jerry Springer, okay? That's not

1:22:27 why I moved to Twin Falls, Idaho. And I'm feeling as if there's a huge part of City,

1:22:35 the people that are in the County, even though we are in the County, we are of interest of

1:22:42 the city, we're not, our concerns aren't being specifically addressed. You had in the

1:22:49 last meeting, I was not here, and I'm telling you I wanted to jump through my TV and shake

1:22:55 somebody because when Ed Beckley said, well I may not be there, somebody responded and

1:23:02 said, well we hope we see your shining face. Where's the accountability? The man says he's

1:23:07 going to jump, making jump. If he's going to fling himself over the canyon, let's do

1:23:15 it safely. Let's do it by somebody that says they're going to do it. Let's get this down

1:23:21 the paper of what we are doing. So far it looks like we're moving into something that

1:23:26 is just going to be horrific. I don't want to be back here afterwards saying, I told

1:23:34 those are horrible words to come out and say to anybody, to anybody that's lost

1:23:41 somebody, lost property, lost alive, lost a limb. So I really implore that this

1:23:49 council, even though it's a city, take the consideration of the entire city, the

1:23:55 county, and the consideration of this proposal to go on beyond just being a

1:24:01 It's not just a lease, okay?

1:24:04 It should be something far more than that.

1:24:07 And the citizens of the city should get more than some kind of path, a walking path.

1:24:14 We need something that's going to make this worthwhile.

1:24:20 Thank you for your time.

1:24:22 Thank you, Mrs. Wakewood.

1:24:23 Next on the list, I believe is Justin Maddox?

1:24:27 Justin or Justin?

1:24:38 Oh, it's useful.

1:24:40 Is there Justin Maddox here?

1:24:41 It would be an enterprise.

1:24:45 Thank you, Bill.

1:24:45 Thank you.

1:24:47 Lawrence, floor away, flower away.

1:24:51 Four million.

1:24:53 Floor away?

1:24:54 Oh, yeah, there's two of us.

1:24:57 Welcome, Lawrence.

1:24:58 And floor-noise.

1:24:59 Lawrence, floor-noise.

1:25:01 I messed it up, sorry.

1:25:03 No, I appreciate it.

1:25:08 I have a lot of thoughts tonight.

1:25:09 I try to boil it down here in a few minutes.

1:25:11 I don't want to bore anybody.

1:25:14 You know, I think a lot of us, some of the people were here the last time we had an event

1:25:20 like this, a lot of us were not.

1:25:23 I spent a lot of time with my neighbor when she was live, the field hankers, and we talked

1:25:29 about, a lot about this event when I would knew her, and some of the things that I can

1:25:36 recall were some very funny stories about the event.

1:25:44 But there was nothing really that I would say was positive that she had to say about

1:25:47 this event.

1:25:48 And I know she was here tonight, she would urge you to consider and reflect upon the experience

1:25:55 of the town and the things that happened in the past during that event.

1:26:01 I think Lucille would urge you to probably not proceed with this event and take a pass

1:26:10 on it.

1:26:12 Because in the reality, there's really a small group of people that are going to benefit

1:26:16 from this event.

1:26:17 And there's a large majority of people that are either not going to benefit from it or

1:26:22 probably stand even worse to have something happen because of the event that's totally

1:26:29 beyond your control.

1:26:32 I think the City Council and I think you have to admire the amount of time the City Council

1:26:37 spent on this event, and certainly city staff, certainly the city attorney.

1:26:45 It's a well-written document.

1:26:47 I reviewed this document.

1:26:50 It's a nice package that we like to put things in that exhibits control over this event, force

1:26:59 major. But this vent, if it's approved by the City Council, will be like tossing a pebble

1:27:07 into a pond. There will be waves that you have no control over, and no one knows where

1:27:13 that will end up. There's, as far as the other, I try to look at the other on positive implications

1:27:24 of this event and again I would look back on some of the things that Lucille told me.

1:27:30 I think really the city has spent the last 40 years trying to get out of the joke that

1:27:38 evil people kind of played on us at that period of time.

1:27:41 I think that's what most people in both in the city and in the nation recall from that

1:27:47 event.

1:27:48 So I really don't see any socially redeeming outcome coming out of this event.

1:27:55 I think it's a great exhibit of energy that I wish that we could put into something else

1:28:03 and be positive for youth or something that would have some long-term benefit of our city.

1:28:12 Instead, you know, everybody loves apple pie and when we were young we all wanted to go

1:28:19 to space and, you know, shooting across the canyon plays the media and everything like that.

1:28:24 But when you boil it down to the reality, I can think of no good positive outcome to come

1:28:28 out of this.

1:28:29 I appreciate your time.

1:28:30 Thank you, Florence.

1:28:32 Fran Florence.

1:28:37 Welcome, Mr. Florence.

1:28:39 Thank you.

1:28:40 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:28:41 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:28:45 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:29:03 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:29:10 year.

1:29:12 The first paragraph of that request for qualifications is highlighted, a section of that.

1:29:19 It says the city is willing to consider permitting this event but only under such circumstances

1:29:26 and with conditions that will fully protect the public's health and safety, and I underline

1:29:32 this section, in a way that will protect the city's brand and image and create positive

1:29:38 marketing image for the area.

1:29:43 Well I believe that the lease certainly focuses on the safety and health of the public.

1:29:53 I think the lease almost ignores the brand and image part of this event.

1:30:03 And I believe that, well at least in my opinion, the most important thing that comes out of this

1:30:11 is the brand and image after we take care of the safety.

1:30:15 And I think you put that in the document paragraph one.

1:30:19 stated a very clear and concise and I think appropriate message. I'm going to

1:30:27 put this next thing on up and I'm going to read along and some of you are

1:30:31 familiar with that I've modified it somewhat, but I'd like to read this. It

1:30:35 put my thoughts together in a much more maybe logical way. I'm going to read

1:30:43 this. Get a load of this. We'll have mud bog-gracing, a demolition derby,

1:30:49 professional wrestling, including women and midgets, all going on at once, he said,

1:30:54 I call it the Redneck Nationals. It's Reckon, Racing, and Rassley. That quote is

1:31:03 not a punch line taken from a fictional movie about an event in

1:31:08 small-town America in 1970. This is a quote from Big Ed Beckley describing his

1:31:14 planned event in Cheyenne, Wyoming several weeks ago. The quote comes from

1:31:19 an interview that was published with obvious amusement by the Boise Weekly on November 22,

1:31:26 2013. Unbelievably to me, Big Ed is now the number one candidate to reenact an event that

1:31:33 for much of the last 40 years is divine twin falls to those who aren't familiar with our

1:31:38 city. As the promoter of events that are self-described as Redneck and with the backwoods

1:31:44 persona that Big Ed projects, he will do significant damage to our city's brand and image, if

1:31:52 allowed to represent us to the world. Over the last several decades, our city leaders,

1:31:58 present and city council included, have shown vision and fortitude culminating in significant

1:32:03 achievements to the benefit of our community, and you should be commended for that.

1:32:09 Twin Falls has grown as an economic hub of southern Idaho and northern Nevada. We've

1:32:13 evolved as a leader in high-tech food production and manufacturing. Our success in maintaining

1:32:19 and attractive and innovative food processing companies is unmatched and other industries

1:32:25 as well. We have an extraordinary community college, first-class medical facility, and a

1:32:30 burgeoning culture that includes a vibrant embrace of family, active lifestyle, and pride

1:32:36 in where we have, but more importantly where we are going. Consequently, our community has

1:32:42 made great strides in becoming more appealing to the young and educated, which is essential

1:32:49 to the continuance of our growth. Big Ed and his image are totally at odds with progress

1:32:56 we have made. Big Ed in the 70s, maybe. Big Ed in 2014, a major setback. The council

1:33:07 did not create the dynamics that have resulted in eliminating more qualified applicants from

1:33:12 process and I sympathize with the Council's position.

1:33:19 The lack of foresight from the State Land Board and recent heightened media attention

1:33:24 and implied questions of the Council's personal integrity contribute to where we are today.

1:33:31 I respectfully suggest that the Council review the first paragraph in the REQ wherein you

1:33:37 clearly define what's important to our community.

1:33:41 You should note that the three conditions you indicated would be the basis of a decision

1:33:45 are to fully protect the public safety and health, protect the city's brand and image

1:33:50 and create positive marketing image for the area.

1:33:55 Please reopen the process and make a decision based upon qualified applicants that share

1:34:02 your vision.

1:34:05 Thank you.

1:34:06 Thank you, Mr. Farts.

1:34:10 Brent Wright, please.

1:34:12 White.

1:34:13 Sorry Brent.

1:34:18 Welcome, Brent.

1:34:21 Thank you, Mr. Mayor and members of the council.

1:34:25 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:34:26 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:34:29 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:34:30 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:34:33 as a citizen, I'd favor this event.

1:34:36 But honestly, I'm quite persuaded by what my fellow citizens

1:34:39 have had to say this evening.

1:34:42 I suppose if all of the citizens express their voice,

1:34:45 we might hear different than what we've heard this evening.

1:34:48 But the comments by those who feel most strongly

1:34:51 are willing to share their time with you

1:34:52 have been, they speak for themselves, I think.

1:34:56 And so I appreciate my fellow citizens' comments.

1:35:00 I came this evening rather to speak more directly

1:35:02 to our concerns as a property owner representing

1:35:06 the Woodbury Corporation.

1:35:09 And I appreciate the time I've been

1:35:10 able to spend with our chief and city manager

1:35:14 and members of staff because it is our desire as a property

1:35:18 to be supportive of whatever decision the city makes in this regard.

1:35:23 Let me share with you just a couple of, I think, pieces of information that maybe can put in some context

1:35:28 the impacts beyond the least premises and site that I think are of importance.

1:35:36 Our properties which include the Magic Felling Mall, the Barnes & Noble Shopping Center, the Target Shopping Center

1:35:42 and the Best Buy Shopping Center.

1:35:44 I also was asked to speak and address you this evening representing Rainnills and the

1:35:48 owners of Canyon Park West.

1:35:52 We accommodate about 8 million visitors per year to our shopping centers.

1:35:58 I'm honestly pleased and almost astounded to think in the 20 years I've been here that's

1:36:02 well over 100 million visits without a single incident of violence or the tarnished images

1:36:09 as our properties that might have occurred.

1:36:15 And a significant part of that fact

1:36:16 is that we've had good cooperation from the city,

1:36:19 and we have a good partnership in trying

1:36:21 to protect public safety, which honestly is the number one

1:36:24 daily concern of our, that we have as property owners.

1:36:29 Our retailers work very hard to generate retail sales.

1:36:31 Our job is to create an environment

1:36:33 which they can do that, which is a safe environment

1:36:35 that the public enjoys being a part of.

1:36:37 We kind of did a little informal survey.

1:36:39 We want you to know that we serve 180,000 residents

1:36:44 that live within one hour of the bridge.

1:36:51 And we asked people, just generally,

1:36:53 would you be inclined to come and see the canyon jump?

1:36:56 And about 7 out of 10 said, yeah,

1:36:58 that would be interesting to do.

1:37:01 I think it's a spectacle.

1:37:02 It's the ones in a lifetime, whether it's a good thing

1:37:04 or night might be a completely separate issue.

1:37:06 but we don't have events like this every day.

1:37:09 So seven out of 10 that we talked to said,

1:37:10 will we come?

1:37:11 Well, pretty soon you can see that that's well

1:37:14 over 100,000 people who could possibly reasonably attend

1:37:18 the event.

1:37:18 At the same time we said to them,

1:37:19 how many of you would be inclined to shop

1:37:21 at our shopping centers that day?

1:37:23 And the answer was seven out of 10 said,

1:37:24 no, I'm not gonna come and fight with that traffic

1:37:26 to do that on that day.

1:37:29 We want you to be aware that at stake for us

1:37:32 in our businesses on a single day

1:37:33 is about $750,000 on a weekend.

1:37:37 And so we honestly think, although we appreciate the opportunity

1:37:41 to perhaps do some promotion, that we're

1:37:45 going to see a significant net loss of business that day.

1:37:47 Because it's just a difficult notion

1:37:49 to come and shop during the middle of that kind of activity.

1:37:52 And so we think it will cost us several $100,000

1:37:56 in business on that single day.

1:37:58 Nonetheless, we don't feel it's our place to say,

1:38:00 no, the city shouldn't do this.

1:38:02 this is the cities to say, it's a community to say.

1:38:06 Our desires to support whatever will come about

1:38:09 in the best way that we can.

1:38:12 We are concerned that the lease does not address

1:38:17 the impacts on private property directly.

1:38:21 If 60 or 80 or 100,000 people come,

1:38:27 and 40,000 can be accommodated, which is the number

1:38:29 that I was told by Mr. Bagley's representative,

1:38:34 I'm sorry, the name escapes me, Mr. Wolfsack.

1:38:38 There could be overflow need for tens and thousands

1:38:41 of parking stalls and means of people

1:38:45 to come into the community and then get to the jump site.

1:38:48 Our properties become ground zero for those

1:38:52 who are seeking a place to park.

1:38:54 Particularly, we are concerned for those

1:38:56 who don't want to do it within the coordinated structure

1:39:01 of bus parking, those who don't want to pay that fee, those who may want to simply find their way to the canyon rim somehow.

1:39:08 And if that number is 10,000 or 20 or 30 or 5,000 or 2,000, every one of those persons who's trying to go outside of the process becomes a problem not only for ourselves, but also for the city, the police department and others who are trying to manage the whole circumstance.

1:39:27 And so our request is that if you do approve the permit and grant permit, that you might take three or four specific steps.

1:39:37 First of all, it would be that you designate our property as a remote parking location.

1:39:42 In doing so, we would be willing to enter an agreement with the promoter to allow some portion of our parking to be used for event parking.

1:39:52 We think it's rather impractical, as several thousand people arrive at our property, to expect

1:39:58 by simply asking, are here to shop that they're all going to tell us the truth.

1:40:04 So we think it's more sensible to allow them a location designated an area where they can

1:40:08 park on our properties.

1:40:10 In doing so, by entering an agreement where we are a remote parking location, then we would

1:40:15 ask that the insurance provisions of the contract be extended to cover our properties as additional

1:40:20 insurance. We would also ask that we would be able to submit to the Chief of Police a list

1:40:28 of public safety requirements to maintain public safety on our properties. We expect,

1:40:35 and I'm sort of the impromptu tent camping and RV camping, we expect that there will be the

1:40:41 occasional person who doesn't want to follow our requests and wishes to do what they wish

1:40:46 on our properties. So we expect that we'll have to have 24-hour public safety care for

1:40:53 all of our properties for approximately four days before the event and the date of the event.

1:40:59 We would request that all of the costs associated with maintaining public safety on our properties

1:41:05 would be included within the public safety portion of the lease contract subject to the

1:41:10 the chief's approval and paid for by the promoter.

1:41:14 We anticipate on the day of the event,

1:41:17 we have over 4,000 parking stalls,

1:41:19 we have 19 different entrances to our properties

1:41:22 that it would take approximately 50 trained public safety

1:41:27 persons to manage that area,

1:41:29 we're aware of a company in Boise that could perhaps

1:41:32 help us with that,

1:41:33 but we're talking about many thousands of dollars,

1:41:35 not just to employ them for a day,

1:41:37 but probably also to house them overnight,

1:41:39 because our need for public safety

1:41:41 will be early in the morning on the day of the event

1:41:43 and continuing throughout the event.

1:41:46 And so, as I said, to reiterate,

1:41:49 we'd make three requests first that our properties

1:41:52 be designated as remote parking,

1:41:54 and we would designate the areas within our properties

1:41:56 that could be available for that purpose.

1:41:58 Secondly, that any insurance coverages

1:42:00 be applied to our properties.

1:42:01 And thirdly, that whatever requests we make,

1:42:04 which are approved by the chief in the safety element

1:42:09 of the lease be funded and paid for by the promoter.

1:42:13 Thank you.

1:42:14 Thank you, Mr. Wreck.

1:42:17 Last on my list is Katie Breckenridge.

1:42:20 Actually, and then we're gonna come back to Jill

1:42:22 if Jill really wants to come up.

1:42:25 Welcome, Katie.

1:42:27 Thank you, Katie Breckenridge.

1:42:29 I have been at every single meeting,

1:42:31 as you know, with the exception of one.

1:42:33 We've exchanged emails, we've had a lot of talking,

1:42:36 so I'm very familiar with the whole event,

1:42:39 and I'm very glad to hear some of the people

1:42:41 that just spoke because they talked about what I was trying to say all along and it's

1:42:46 very, it's really good to hear them articulated in a really good way.

1:42:51 I do have some very strong concerns.

1:42:55 My first concern is September 8th, the day is over, it's gone.

1:43:00 And we are left as a community in Magic Valley with whatever happened.

1:43:06 We have to pull it back together.

1:43:08 So in thinking that, I think we have to prepare for the worst and hope for the best and the

1:43:13 very thing that I am most concerned about is public safety and I'm going to deal on

1:43:19 one particular issue and that is fire.

1:43:24 My first recollection of fire in the canyon was when I was three years old, 1948, so I

1:43:32 was three years old, and I, B. Perrine, was burning weeds in the canyon. And the canyon

1:43:38 winds came up. And with inside of 20 minutes, the fire climbed the canyon wall and set our

1:43:46 lambing sheds on fire. And as a three-year-old little girl, my mother told me to sit and

1:43:52 stay on our lawn, which is now target, and watch as volunteer people came all over because

1:43:59 inside a half an hour, all of our lamb and sheds have burned to the ground and our grain

1:44:06 fields were on fire. That's the danger of fire. And if you fast forward to just a few years

1:44:13 ago when auger falls caught on fire and how quickly that fire climbed the canyon wall

1:44:19 and fire people couldn't get there in time, homes were saved or saved by the neighbors

1:44:25 with hoses. Fire is a huge danger. And for that reason, I'm very concerned about fire

1:44:33 in the canyon and fire in the canyon well. As you know, I am on the opposite side of the

1:44:39 same canyon for my concern is, and that is on the Jerome side. And you have specifically

1:44:45 asked me not to talk about the Jerome side. And I understand all of that. But again, fire

1:44:53 It's safety. It's not about guns. It's not about alcohol to me. It's about cigarettes.

1:45:00 And one cigarette and the winds and all of a sudden, the desert is on fire. And for those

1:45:09 of you who have ever been in the middle of fire, it's the scariest thing there is. It swirls

1:45:14 and it goes rapidly. What we have done as private property owners, which was addressed

1:45:19 today earlier was the cost to private property owners.

1:45:24 What we have done, again, we're on the opposite side of the canyon,

1:45:27 but again, it's our cost, is that we have burned the perimeter of our 13 acres.

1:45:32 And in the next two weeks, when it dries out enough,

1:45:36 we will burn the interior of that 13 acres.

1:45:40 And what we're doing is being responsible because we are trying to reduce as much

1:45:45 fire fuel as possible so that next summer hopefully we won't have the build up of fire there all right

1:45:55 that is a cost to us it's a major cost to us we had to hire firemen to go out and do that

1:46:00 it is a cost to us for robin me to come to every single meeting we leave the ranch at three o'clock

1:46:06 in the afternoon we get home at ten o'clock at night and you know how many times we've been here

1:46:12 There's incredible costs involved in this scenario.

1:46:17 And the next one of the next to the last things I'd like to say is liability.

1:46:23 Are we liable if there are people involved on our private property who render our property

1:46:31 and are heard? Where does the liability stand?

1:46:34 The state lease, they don't have liability.

1:46:37 And where do those of us that own private property?

1:46:41 I wanted to go on record that we feel that there is a deep, deep need and a huge hazard

1:46:48 in fire in this scenario.

1:46:51 And if somebody has heard, God willing, that desert doesn't catch on fire.

1:46:56 But if it does, there's going to be a massive lawsuit and they will name everybody that they

1:47:02 can think about naming.

1:47:04 So we too would like to be protected in some manner.

1:47:09 My last thing is ticket sales.

1:47:11 One of the things that we have been hearing is that this event, the numbers that are coming

1:47:17 will be based on ticket sales.

1:47:19 Do you know anybody that's going to buy a ticket?

1:47:23 Because you can go anywhere you want to go along that canyon rim and watch the event.

1:47:30 So I question ticket sales as being something that you can base the numbers of people that

1:47:37 are coming to the event.

1:47:42 Finally, I was addressed in one of an e-mails, and that e-mail circulated amongst all of you.

1:47:52 I want to make it very, very clear that I do not feel that Rob and I have ever put any heat

1:47:59 on you for any reason at any time.

1:48:03 We have a history of having disagreements, we have a history of having discussions, but

1:48:10 But at no time did I feel I could heat on any of you.

1:48:15 And also at no time have I ever felt that I have been victimized because I have not been.

1:48:22 I deeply respect all of you.

1:48:25 I hope we can continue with these conversations.

1:48:28 And I wanted to clarify that point very, very strongly.

1:48:33 Thank you.

1:48:35 Thank you, Katie.

1:48:38 Jill, Jennifer, I don't think I have you on here.

1:48:46 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:48:51 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:48:55 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:48:57 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:49:01 I'm a family doctor in the community. I've been working in Twin Falls for 14 years,

1:49:05 and health and safety is of most importance to me for both the communities and the individuals that are involved in this event.

1:49:12 You voted to give Beckley Media the first chance to negotiate an agreement with the city with

1:49:17 the deadline of January 31, 2014.

1:49:20 Quoted from the city, the city is willing to consider permitting this event, but only under

1:49:25 such circumstances and with conditions that will fully protect the public's health and

1:49:29 safety in a way that will protect the city's brand and image and create a positive marketing

1:49:34 image for the area.

1:49:36 Under the proposed agreement to be voted on this evening, Beckley Media was be given until

1:49:41 April 1, 2014, another two months past the deadline just to come up with their

1:49:45 health and safety plan. We still don't know and the City Council has never been

1:49:49 shown how Ed Beckley has himself capable of doing this jump. Ed Beckley is trying

1:49:54 to do something he's never done before. Five quarter miles, several hundred miles

1:49:59 above the ground and use a parachute to land himself and his motorcycle on the

1:50:03 ground. Furthermore, we have not seen anything regarding exactly what

1:50:07 the city's brand and image or create a positive marketing image for the city of Twin Falls.

1:50:14 The deadline has come and gone and Bechler Media has not met the city's conditions.

1:50:18 You gave Bechler Media first chance at negotiations in good faith.

1:50:22 And now let's hold them accountable to the deadline that they did not meet for health and safety.

1:50:27 Please decline the request from an extension and move on in the process.

1:50:31 Thank you.

1:50:32 Thank you, Jennifer.

1:50:34 Jill?

1:50:39 Debree, so did I do that right?

1:50:41 Welcome, Jill. I'm Jill de Brace, 3178 south, 2000 east of Wendell. I didn't come with any prepared speech or writing or anything.

1:50:50 I've heard all the concerns, and I understand them, respect each one. I'm just in favor of it, and I just wanted to let you guys know.

1:51:01 I think the Magic Valley is a beautiful area. It's known for its recreational. Everything has to do with the Snake River.

1:51:09 wrapped on it, they canoe on it, they golf near it. Restaurants, they hike around it. So we have

1:51:16 someone that's capable and brave enough to jump it and I think it would be a great opportunity for

1:51:21 our Valley to experience something different. We've got the beautiful canyon and I can't see

1:51:28 why we shouldn't use it. Thank you. Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, that's all I have written,

1:51:33 Travis, do we have any others? Is there anyone else in the audience that would like to

1:51:38 to come forward and share your thoughts.

1:51:47 I'm going to close the public input portion

1:51:50 of tonight's hearing and turn it over to Council

1:51:52 for their deliberations.

1:51:56 Rebecca Mills-Sueger.

1:51:58 Thank you Mayor.

1:51:59 I actually have a question that was based

1:52:01 on some of the input that we received.

1:52:04 A couple of people, and perhaps this is a question

1:52:06 for our attorney Fritz, or I'm not sure who,

1:52:10 The several questions were raised about being covered by the insurance and just so that we

1:52:17 all understand that there's insurance and then there's a bond.

1:52:22 Can you go through those amounts and who is qualified to, what that covers, if property

1:52:28 owners that are affected are covered by these requirements?

1:52:33 Yeah, so the bonding is to ensure that any payments, any promises that are made in terms

1:52:41 of the improvements, anything else that involves cost to the city, that's what the bonding is

1:52:47 for.

1:52:48 The insurance is liability insurance, it's like you have on your car.

1:52:53 We're named as an additional insured, so that ensures us in case there is an injury, there's

1:53:00 damage to property and someone thinks that the city has responsibility then the insurance

1:53:07 company represents us on the insurance and pays the claims. It does not directly protect

1:53:17 if someone else has damage and they can't necessarily pinpoint who the cause was or what

1:53:26 the cause was that it would not come to that.

1:53:29 would have to be proof of cause but if it were directly related to the event and

1:53:33 caused by the event it would be they would be covered if it were if it were

1:53:39 caused by Beckley media or they alleged that it was caused by the city then there

1:53:45 would be insurance coverage. Okay thank you. Thank you for the comments or

1:53:56 the Liberation Council. Chris, talking to me.

1:54:00 Well, it's one of the old dinosaurs that saw the, uh, the

1:54:04 travesty that, uh, Knievel's flop in the canyon created for this area. And, uh, the time I've

1:54:11 met Mr. Berkley, uh, I've been a complete separation of my mind. You're a different individual. You're

1:54:16 still a promoter, but you are a different, uh, person than, uh, Mr. Knievel. By his action,

1:54:24 have showed the city and the county that he was.

1:54:28 Nonetheless, when the council asked you to go to the state,

1:54:34 as a first step in our negotiations, secure a permit

1:54:38 to use the city, the state property, and the federal property,

1:54:43 coming back to the city, I think energized both your side

1:54:49 in order to enter into active negotiations.

1:54:54 The city has forced, I think, a fair, a lot of boilerplate, but still a fair beginning proposal

1:55:04 for these negotiations, Mr. Backway.

1:55:09 We are at the deadline that we set for ourselves, and frankly, I think we wasted a lot of time.

1:55:15 I have to tell you that, as was identified by several of our commentators tonight, the

1:55:24 primary opening paragraph stressing the need to protect the public health and

1:55:30 safety has not been met by this agreement. I cannot and will not support it.

1:55:39 Thank you, Chris. Anything further from Council?

1:55:42 Mayor, I have a comment if I may.

1:55:45 Sean Barrier, go ahead.

1:55:47 Can you hear me? All right. I can hear you just find audience.

1:55:51 We're getting a lot of head nods.

1:55:52 John, go ahead.

1:55:53 Thank you.

1:55:54 Thank you.

1:55:55 I apologize for not being able to be there tonight, but I appreciate the opportunity to

1:55:59 be connected in on this.

1:56:01 As I've said many times, I probably have dealt more with Canyon Jump scenarios than perhaps

1:56:12 more than anyone besides Mr. Knabel himself over the past nine years dealing with these

1:56:19 inquiries.

1:56:20 I'm impressed by some of the comments tonight from the public, reminding us what we started

1:56:31 back in October with the RSU process on this in outlining some overarching items that were

1:56:40 important to the community, not to us as city councilors, but to the community.

1:56:45 And that's protection of the public's health and safety, protection of the city's brand

1:56:50 and image positive marketing opportunities, and one that wasn't written in there, but I

1:56:56 know that we discussed almost to do all of that in the safe and safe fashion at no cost

1:57:00 of the taxpayers.

1:57:02 And while I feel that the agreement that's been negotiated over the past several weeks,

1:57:11 ten weeks actually since we made the ranking back in November, while some of those items

1:57:20 are dealt with, like compensation, the ability to pay for police services, reimburse for staff costs,

1:57:30 those types of things. I think those key points are not addressed. One, the public health and safety plan.

1:57:40 I know several weeks ago at a council meeting, I made the comment of, are we going to have a plan on

1:57:49 February 3rd, because I don't want to hear once again, yeah, yeah, yeah, we'll do that.

1:57:55 Because we've been hearing that for years from everyone who comes to us.

1:58:00 I know that Councilman Tockenton has made that a pretty critical issue as well, and I

1:58:05 think that that is the paramount item that we need to deal with, and I'm concerned that

1:58:11 we don't have that.

1:58:13 we may have some progress and some discussion. There's been a fair amount of time for this.

1:58:20 One of the speakers earlier talked about safety and integrity. And those two words are

1:58:27 important. And I think from an integrity standpoint, we have an obligation as the City

1:58:33 Council to stand by the process that we laid out collectively from October with RFPs to

1:58:42 to November when we heard from the applicants to our decision to say if we don't have an agreement

1:58:51 reached by the end of January for consideration, no later than tonight, we would move on, negotiate

1:58:57 with the next group.

1:58:59 It's no secret that I did not support Beckley being in the first position on this ranking.

1:59:06 I do feel that the REO group and Miles Dasher and the partners that they brought to the table

1:59:13 really did have a better ability to address those overarching goals.

1:59:20 They actually included in their presentation.

1:59:23 They brought those partners to the table who demonstrated experience dealing with these types of events

1:59:30 in open space, large, out more venues,

1:59:34 many in much more complicated cities than Twin Falls, Idaho.

1:59:39 And I think that we should take the action time to move

1:59:44 to the next applicant, which was REO,

1:59:49 because I'm confident that they can come back addressing

1:59:52 the issues that are important to us in a timely fashion

1:59:56 but the solid plan and move forward with this.

2:00:00 Thank you.

2:00:01 Thank you, Sean.

2:00:02 Rebecca Milsica.

2:00:03 Thank you, Mayor.

2:00:06 I'll just add some thoughts on tonight's public hearing.

2:00:09 I appreciate everyone who came forward to share their concerns.

2:00:13 And I truly think that many of these concerns are actually addressed in this lease.

2:00:18 And the lease is the only legal way that we can hold the applicant accountable.

2:00:25 And I think the issues that don't pertain to the legal issues,

2:00:29 I think are more subjective.

2:00:32 The issues of branding and imaging.

2:00:35 We're all going to have a different perspective.

2:00:38 That's why I struggle to use that as really a set criteria,

2:00:42 because by design we all have different ideas of what is a good image

2:00:46 or what is a good brand.

2:00:49 But I think that going through this process,

2:00:54 know we've asked the applicant everything that we've asked of him. He has come through

2:01:00 and been able to provide and he certainly stepped up and provided some financial backing for

2:01:09 that. So I think that we at least owe him a vote and I think that we should at least try

2:01:15 to move forward in good faith.

2:01:17 Thank you Rebecca. The way I look at what we have, we have a decision tonight Council.

2:01:23 We have a decision of doing nothing, which keeps the ball, I guess, kicks the can down

2:01:30 the road, or we have an up and down vote this evening that we can make.

2:01:36 And I would encourage the council to, if they do make a motion, that they do it in the affirmative

2:01:42 so that we can vote it up or down.

2:01:46 But that's kind of the two choices that we have this evening.

2:01:50 And I would encourage us to maybe talk about that.

2:01:54 Greg Lanning.

2:01:55 Well, I think that we don't truly follow Robert Schruill's

2:01:59 borders, but I think to actually debate this issue,

2:02:02 we probably should have a motion on the floor

2:02:04 to talk about other possible scenarios,

2:02:08 whether we wait to the vote B, we could table it

2:02:11 for a future date until we have the plan,

2:02:13 the safety plan in place.

2:02:15 But I'm going to go ahead and move

2:02:16 that we approve the agreement as negotiated

2:02:19 with Beckley Media to use the Twin Falls City

2:02:22 Crawford property on, I believe, the new day to September 8th.

2:02:27 7th, excuse me, on September 7th to jump

2:02:30 for a proposed Snake River Canyon jump.

2:02:34 Second.

2:02:35 We have a motion on floor by Greg Lanning,

2:02:37 seconded by Rebecca Mills, Suica.

2:02:40 Travis, you were making your way before

2:02:42 that motion was made, so I'll allow you to ask

2:02:45 a member of the council and also for the audience

2:02:48 I just wanted to remind you that both Mr. Simmons

2:02:50 Mr. Beckley are here in the event that you have questions for them.

2:02:55 I didn't know if you were also going to extend them the opportunity to public comment publicly on the process.

2:03:04 So I just wanted to remind you that they're here.

2:03:07 Thank you, Travis.

2:03:08 Suzanne Hawkins.

2:03:11 If it's possible, I'd like to have our here a safety update from our police staff before we go any further with this. Is that okay?

2:03:18 Yes, absolutely.

2:03:20 I'll turn mine on.

2:03:21 Either Chief Pike and or Captain Barnhart.

2:03:24 Welcome.

2:03:35 Council, along the lines of the Safety Plan update, there's really not an update.

2:03:43 We have met with a number of our partners.

2:03:46 We met with the Sheriff of Twin Falls County, Sheriff Jerome County, met with Idaho State

2:03:51 Police.

2:03:52 We did have a conversation, as I mentioned last week, about a multi-jurisdictional approach

2:03:58 to the safety plan.

2:03:59 And one of the concerns that came up as we move forward with the event planning on our

2:04:04 side, there seems to be some inconsistencies with what's taking place on the north side.

2:04:10 So we met collectively and decided that, and I've sent an email related to this, that probably

2:04:16 one, as we move forward we'd like to move forward collectively so that we all have the

2:04:22 same information.

2:04:23 We can share the same information.

2:04:26 We know what those plans look like on the south side and what those safety plans look like

2:04:29 on the north side of how they work together.

2:04:32 Regardless, we can have the best safety plan in place

2:04:35 for the south side if there's something that doesn't meet

2:04:39 the standard on the north side, it will still impact us.

2:04:42 And so we decided as a group, as we

2:04:45 decide to move forward, that we would like to do that

2:04:47 collectively and together.

2:04:49 So that's really the only update.

2:04:50 We have not, at this point, we do not

2:04:52 have a complete or executable safety plan in place.

2:04:57 certainly not one that we're comfortable with.

2:05:00 Captain Barnard has addressed the safety plan,

2:05:03 the last draft of the safety plan that we've received.

2:05:06 He supplied Jim Walzick with a number of recommendations

2:05:11 based on that plan, but we have not seen

2:05:14 any additional work.

2:05:19 Thank you, Chief.

2:05:21 Chris talking.

2:05:22 I would move to amend the motion

2:05:25 that approval, I think,

2:05:30 and restating correctly that the lease would be approved

2:05:34 was up your motion and the affirmative.

2:05:37 Be approved if an acceptable public health

2:05:43 and safety plan is provided in the agreed upon

2:05:46 by Jerome County Twin Falls City

2:05:52 and County by March 10th.

2:05:58 Second.

2:05:59 We have a motion on forward by Chris Tawkington,

2:06:02 seconded by Rebecca and also sort of get to amend the motion. So that the the main

2:06:10 motion would carry as long as we had a safety plan in place approved by the

2:06:17 City of Twin Falls, Jerome County, the City of Twin Falls County by March 1st

2:06:22 10th, 10th that I state that right March 10th. Okay, go ahead. Chris just

2:06:31 I just want to make sure I know what I'm voting on here.

2:06:34 If I voted in a affirmative for your amendment and then the main motion passed,

2:06:39 that you would be saying that we are approving the lease as long as we come up with a satisfactory safety plan by that date.

2:06:50 As long as the applicant does, one that is approved by the three parties.

2:06:54 And that's what I do by the app.

2:06:55 All right, thank you.

2:06:57 We're back in the second.

2:06:59 Thank you, Mayor, while I second at the amendment for discussion, I think I need it some more

2:07:03 time to think about it.

2:07:05 It is quite restrictive to include those three different jurisdictions, but I'm not necessarily

2:07:13 against it.

2:07:14 I have a question for our legal counsel.

2:07:16 The date and the agreement to provide a safety plan is April 1st.

2:07:23 So is that the approval of that plan is basically a contingency to this lease, is that be correct?

2:07:34 So let's not mix up our terms.

2:07:37 So what Chief Peicke was talking about and I think what Councilman talking is talking about

2:07:43 is a multi-jurisdictional agreement among law enforcement.

2:07:47 That's not the same as the April 1 safety and security plan because that has to, that deals

2:07:53 with overall safety and security of the entire event.

2:07:58 So would this be a separate document, then I guess a question for the motion maker or?

2:08:03 No, no, the secretary of it's not intended to in any way involve a meeting of the three

2:08:09 law enforcement groups for other duties other than to act upon the safety health plan provided

2:08:20 by the applicant. That's to put the onus of responsibility solely upon the applicant to

2:08:29 move in a fast forward position to provide us a safety plan that the three jurisdictions

2:08:35 can agree upon.

2:08:43 Mr. Mayor.

2:08:44 Go ahead, Sean.

2:08:45 So I appreciate where Councilman Talkington is trying to go with this. I will say this whole

2:08:57 process has been going on since August or September, at least for the state auction of

2:09:07 the I don't know, Department of Lands property.

2:09:11 I'm continually frustrated that the City of Twin Falls keeps hitting put in the driver's

2:09:15 seat on this thing when we have a request to us by an applicant asking to do something

2:09:22 And the burden continues to fall upon our city staff and now other agencies to craft a plan

2:09:31 that in all honesty, Beckley Media has had several months to put together for as much

2:09:40 passion and energy as was put behind the lobbying effort to get people excited about this jump

2:09:48 by basically media as well as the other applicants.

2:09:51 There seems to be, it's like we have to keep lighting a fire

2:09:55 under people to get deliverable products from them.

2:09:59 And again, while I appreciate the attempt

2:10:04 to light that fire yet again and get something in hand

2:10:08 by March 10th, my inclination is they've had plenty

2:10:11 of opportunity for this.

2:10:13 And I think they're done and it's somebody else's turn.

2:10:18 Thank you, Sean.

2:10:20 Greg Lanning.

2:10:22 Well, I really don't want to argue the point, but to me,

2:10:26 the April 1st date was we made that date.

2:10:31 They didn't make that date.

2:10:32 We gave them that additional time by vote

2:10:36 or by just conversation here amongst council.

2:10:40 So I'm not sure that we, I think,

2:10:43 well, I think I'm going to support Chris's motion

2:10:46 because it does move up the time span.

2:10:47 I don't know that I blame Beckley Media

2:10:50 for not having the plan completed at this point.

2:10:53 We gave them the additional time for April 1st.

2:10:56 I think that onus falls upon us.

2:11:00 So I will be supporting Chris's amendment there.

2:11:07 Thank you, Greg.

2:11:09 Council, any further on the amendment to the main motion?

2:11:16 So again, first one question.

2:11:20 If the amendment is passed and then the main motion is passed,

2:11:24 We have until March 10th to have an acceptable plan to those three entities and if not, the

2:11:33 motion, the main motion is void.

2:11:35 Yeah.

2:11:36 As I understand the motion, there is not to be an execution of the lease unless on March

2:11:44 night they come up with the multi-jurisdictional plan approved by the chief.

2:11:50 So my indication would be that it was intended to be that if we got the nod from Chief Pike

2:11:58 and the two respective sheriffs with the concurrence of the city manager that this is acceptable

2:12:03 from our perspective of protecting the public safety and infrastructure, that would satisfy

2:12:10 the need or satisfy the motion.

2:12:12 I guess the point being we wouldn't be building another provision into this document.

2:12:17 be holding off on executing pending on whether they were able to come up with it or not.

2:12:24 So again, I guess my question, Chris, is that we're putting all the responsibility on our

2:12:31 public safety individuals to tell us it's acceptable or not.

2:12:35 Is that partly our responsibility safe?

2:12:38 And so it's right to you, Chris.

2:12:40 So go ahead and answer that.

2:12:41 I just want to understand the motion.

2:12:44 If the applicant provides a 20 page plan out of the briefcase tonight that the Chief can

2:12:50 start working on, how is that putting the burden upon us that wouldn't already be honest

2:12:54 to review a document?

2:12:56 I'm not suggesting the least that the three parties in my amendment, the two counties and

2:13:02 the city, craft the document.

2:13:06 They are to act upon the document provided to them, have back and forth discussion, negotiation

2:13:14 and come back with a an acceptable document to us by that deadline.

2:13:18 So it's acceptable to us, it's not acceptable to the law enforcement agencies that you just

2:13:23 spoke.

2:13:24 I'm not trying to argue with you, I'm just trying to understand.

2:13:26 Well I would sure hope that the council would never accept a public safety document without

2:13:31 getting the input from our co-shop.

2:13:33 Okay well I appreciate that but is it the police law enforcement agencies giving us this input

2:13:41 that say it's a thumbs up and then we we stamp that or is it also the the governmental agencies,

2:13:49 the county commissioners and those folks that will say they believe that it's good for, you know,

2:13:56 as far as their concern. I just want to make sure I understand who who's going to have the final say.

2:14:01 I guess the answer is yes, I mean, I'm not sure, but would you like to weigh in?

2:14:09 Well, maybe just a little clarification, so that I make sure that I understand exactly

2:14:14 what you're asking from us and maybe a little commentary.

2:14:19 When we started this process, it was our intention to basically have Beckley Media present us

2:14:27 with a public safety plan, and the presentation of that plan would be, we'd look at that plan,

2:14:32 we may make a few adjustments, maybe not, but the plan would be executable, you'd be

2:14:38 be able to use it, be able to put it to practice.

2:14:41 And the reality of that is the first draft that we received

2:14:43 from Beckling Media, which is the draft that our partners

2:14:47 in Jerome County are working on, was extremely vague

2:14:52 and not close to probably representing what we needed.

2:14:55 That led us to having a number of conversations

2:14:59 with Beckling Media and actually requesting

2:15:01 that they come out here and have a presence here in Twin Falls

2:15:04 to look at all the dynamics.

2:15:06 This isn't a static event.

2:15:07 There are lots of pieces to this plan,

2:15:12 which ultimately led to the drafting

2:15:14 of the Second Public Safety Plan, which is still not adequate.

2:15:18 So we can, if I'm hearing Councilman talking correctly,

2:15:23 we can work together as a multi-jurisdictional approach

2:15:26 to this, but I think it's important to realize

2:15:28 that we will continue to commit resources

2:15:31 to the development of this plan.

2:15:34 And to probably at this point, expect that Meckling Media

2:15:37 will present us with the final draft.

2:15:40 That will be something that we can execute.

2:15:41 I don't think is realistic.

2:15:43 I think we're going to, whether we like it or not,

2:15:46 as we move forward because of the dynamics that

2:15:49 are associated with the plan, because of all the concerns

2:15:51 that were mentioned here tonight, which I think,

2:15:53 by the way, are valid concerns.

2:15:55 I think the description of the pebble

2:15:57 being thrown upon the ripples and the waves.

2:16:00 And there's probably lots of unforeseen.

2:16:02 And because of that, we really, in some ways,

2:16:06 on the public safety side of it,

2:16:07 whether we like it or not,

2:16:09 have to take control of the event.

2:16:11 And we'll have to commit and continue to commit resources

2:16:15 to the development and the maintenance

2:16:17 and the implementation of that plan.

2:16:21 Thank you, Chief.

2:16:22 I have several lights on.

2:16:24 Suzanne Hawkins.

2:16:26 I appreciate the direction again

2:16:28 that Councilman Talkington's trying to go with this,

2:16:30 but as I think about where we started

2:16:33 where we're at today. I know that Beckley Media has made it very clear to us that until they have

2:16:39 a lease signed and ready to go they cannot deal with the marketing portion of this event. So if we

2:16:46 decide to give them until the March 10th date then that's going to push that portion of their plan

2:16:51 further down the road as well. And in addition to that the actual specifications of the jump and

2:16:58 in the bike that are not being released to us yet

2:17:00 until we get all of this done.

2:17:02 So I like the idea of trying to work with them,

2:17:06 but I really feel like we need to make

2:17:07 a more direct decision tonight

2:17:09 because there's too many moving pieces

2:17:11 that along with the safety plan

2:17:14 are getting moved down the road with it.

2:17:16 And I think we're just playing up time.

2:17:19 Thank you, Suzanne.

2:17:20 Rebecca, may I'll sorry?

2:17:22 Thank you, Mayor.

2:17:25 I think we only concern with the amendment.

2:17:27 One, I guess the Chief just added

2:17:29 that it's really not time-wise, very feasible.

2:17:34 But two is authorizing other jurisdictions

2:17:38 to approve or not approve our plan and our lease.

2:17:41 And I think I'm uncomfortable with that.

2:17:46 I think that I'm comfortable.

2:17:48 We as a council have set this date of April 1st

2:17:51 of having this plan in our hands and approved

2:17:54 has to be approved by, thus the lease is contingent,

2:17:57 upon an approved safety plan if Beckley cannot come up with this plan.

2:18:03 They will then forfeit the lease at that time.

2:18:06 I think it would be premature to move that date other than any other that we've set forward.

2:18:13 We have set this date ourselves and I think we need to honor it.

2:18:20 Okay Council, we have an amendment to the main motion on the floor.

2:18:23 I see no further lights.

2:18:26 The other will call vote please.

2:18:28 Don Hall.

2:18:30 No.

2:18:32 Rebecca Millsweka?

2:18:33 No.

2:18:34 Suzanne Hawkins?

2:18:36 No.

2:18:37 Jim Munn?

2:18:38 No.

2:18:39 Sean Berreber?

2:18:41 No.

2:18:43 Chris Talkington?

2:18:44 Yes.

2:18:45 Greg Lanting?

2:18:46 Yes.

2:18:47 Motion fails 2 to 5.

2:18:51 Now onto the main motion.

2:18:53 Anything further on the main motion council?

2:18:56 Mr. Mayor?

2:18:58 Go ahead, Sean.

2:19:00 So perhaps to a point that Councilwoman Millsweka just

2:19:04 that we set this date and we ought to stick to that, I would remind us that we voted on

2:19:11 a date of tonight and I believe that the agreement in front of us has big giant holes in it related

2:19:20 to a public health and safety plan and addressing some of the overarching goals of this. We

2:19:29 We can debate all day what the brand and image of the community is, but the sheer fact that

2:19:36 it's not addressed, short of saying let us know who your media partner is, is a whole.

2:19:43 And I believe that we will be approving an agreement that leaves a lot of negotiations

2:19:52 still to happen about some of the most important things that we've heard from our citizens.

2:19:57 So I do not believe we should be supporting the approval of this agreement and we ought

2:20:05 to be moving forward with our second group to negotiate with.

2:20:11 Thank you, Sean.

2:20:12 Jim.

2:20:13 Thank you, Mayor.

2:20:15 I've listened and talked to many people in the community and staff in this regard and

2:20:24 I guess I'm going to talk from the heart from the gut here.

2:20:27 Because I think as a police officer you have to think from the gut.

2:20:31 And in my heart, I think that this situation, this attempt, this entire event is going to

2:20:39 overwhelm our public safety officials extraordinarily.

2:20:43 I believe that they're going to be placed in an unwinnable situation where if something

2:20:50 happens, the city and the police sheriffs officers are going to be encumbered with taking the

2:20:58 they can hit. They can't, the police cannot guarantee the safety of people in those neighborhoods

2:21:04 out there. That's just Jim Mundtocking, but I'm telling you. They can do everything they

2:21:10 can, but the ripple and the water affected the gentleman so eloquently posed to us is

2:21:18 true. I go back to my dad and he worked on the 1974 event and all the things that happened

2:21:25 there, you know, this is a different event, I understand that.

2:21:29 But I think what we're asking Chief Pike, Captain Barnhart, Sheriff Carter and Sheriff McFalle to

2:21:34 do here is something that they just simply don't have the resources to do.

2:21:41 And to ask them to do this is an injustice.

2:21:47 Secondly, this event has nothing, the idea of jumping something over the canyon, has nothing

2:21:55 to do with our strategic plan. And a strategic plan is developed to keep us moving up the

2:22:02 beach towards the hedge rows, okay? It doesn't let us get off worried about something over

2:22:06 on the sides. It keeps us going up the beach. We have a new strategic plan that was based

2:22:13 on what the community really felt was important to us, languishing right now, because our city

2:22:18 staff is spending hordes of time on this event. And we're not getting off the beaches and

2:22:26 into the hedgerows.

2:22:28 So, you know, in summary, I just think that the public safety

2:22:33 issue coupled with our inability to move this community

2:22:36 forward with our strategic plan is just something I just

2:22:39 can't support from my heart.

2:22:42 Thank you, Jim.

2:22:42 Rebecca, may I also like to?

2:22:45 Thank you, Mayor.

2:22:47 I just want to talk a little bit about the process that we've

2:22:49 been through.

2:22:49 And it's interesting, because we've had this conversation

2:22:52 about is a jump event good for this community.

2:22:55 And we've had it for several months.

2:22:58 And we've had several public hearings.

2:22:59 And before we chose an applicant, 75% of the community

2:23:05 said they were for it.

2:23:06 And one of the applicants said that was an official survey

2:23:11 that they had done, and everyone was for it.

2:23:14 So I at least want to remind us that if this lease

2:23:19 set before us is not a proper document for Ed Beckley,

2:23:24 then it is not a proper document for any applicant.

2:23:27 And so it would be wrong of us to move forward with someone else

2:23:30 if we're not going to allow Mr. Beckley a chance

2:23:33 to fulfill these obligations, which he has not had the opportunity

2:23:36 to do.

2:23:38 So if the issue is to not have a jump, I can support that.

2:23:42 I think that there are valid reasons

2:23:43 and there are good arguments against doing a jump at all.

2:23:47 But I would hate for it to be about personalities

2:23:50 and some of the comments that were made tonight

2:23:53 were flat-out character assassination.

2:23:56 And I don't think that has anything to do

2:23:58 with this legal document that will protect

2:24:01 the citizens of our city.

2:24:03 I think staff has done an excellent job,

2:24:05 and I think that if it really is our intent

2:24:08 to not have a jump at all,

2:24:09 then it was a grave disservice to the city

2:24:12 to allow this much staff time to be put forth

2:24:15 and exercised on this project.

2:24:19 And we should have made that decision a while ago.

2:24:24 Thank you, Rebecca. Great landing. Obviously, this is hard. We've heard from people tonight who are very concerned about their property and things.

2:24:39 We did make a decision to back a little bit where Becca said we did make a decision back before, ever before we had the the RFQ to go ahead and allow a jump.

2:24:51 We said we were going to allow a jump and then we made the decision to go with Mr. Beckley

2:24:59 because to be honest with you, I chose Mr. Beckley not because of Mr. Beckley, and I chose Mr. Beckley

2:25:04 because I thought his team provided us with the best chance of putting forth a safe jump.

2:25:10 And that was the reason I chose his team over other teams that I probably had more personal

2:25:17 to be a personal heart-string tugs to because they are members of our community.

2:25:21 I chose it based on that and if I'm going to ask that we chose Mr. Beckley as an opportunity

2:25:30 to come forth and to put forth a document that we as a staff, our staff would work on

2:25:38 and Mr. Beckley has done that.

2:25:41 So I will be voting in favor of the document and in the back of my mind as we have other

2:25:47 other people in the audience or the back of my mind.

2:25:50 We have another jump proposed that we have no control over

2:25:53 whatsoever.

2:25:55 And so I would like to at least control this one

2:25:58 if there's going to be one.

2:25:59 And so as far as the image and branding, I mean, I've got

2:26:04 relatives all over the country and I was here 40 years ago.

2:26:07 I mean, I'm not as old as Chris when I'm close.

2:26:11 And thanks, Junior.

2:26:14 I think it's a bad taste in our mouth because some of the way things were handled here 40

2:26:22 years ago and the security team was the held angels and all those different things that really made

2:26:28 the jump worse than it could have been if things could have been handled more properly at that point

2:26:34 and I don't think our image or our brand from this event around the country is negative at all

2:26:42 Mr. Knievel's jump, but why is it the most still the most requested or one of the most requested things that our visitor center is where where was the jump site?

2:26:52 So I don't think there's a negative

2:26:55 connotation from that at least the people I talked to relatives and things around the country, you know, the

2:27:02 The I don't believe that's it's negative at this point. I just believe we we selected mr. Backlake as we felt he had the best team we decided

2:27:10 decided here back when we started this event that yes we were going to have a jump and it

2:27:19 was good for the community to have a jump and so I'm ready to vote yes to get this started.

2:27:26 One of the way in and my recollection is never that we decided we were going to have a jump.

2:27:32 We were going to allow the process to see if we were going to have a jump. Nowhere that

2:27:38 I recall or at least in my heart that I ever say we were having a jump we were going to

2:27:43 go through the process so I want to make sure I said that.

2:27:47 And I think that Councilman Munn hit it on the head I had written these no-down strategic

2:27:51 plan.

2:27:52 I keep seeing us do mission drift.

2:27:55 We're drifting away from the mission that we have as a city and certainly those things happen

2:28:02 from time to time.

2:28:03 This is like a 90 degree mission drift.

2:28:07 Our staff don't have the time to do the jobs

2:28:10 that we've asked them to do.

2:28:11 We've asked them to propel us into the future.

2:28:15 We've asked them to work with our community

2:28:18 on our strategic climate, health and safety

2:28:22 in and our economy and a place that we can have good quality

2:28:29 of life and we keep getting to rid of it off again.

2:28:33 You know, I'm the first one to say that I think

2:28:35 the idea of having a jump is cool.

2:28:38 It absolutely is cool.

2:28:39 I've been quoted saying that's a really cool mound

2:28:41 of dirt out there and I agree with that.

2:28:43 But it keeps pulling us away from what we're supposed

2:28:47 to be doing and I don't feel comfortable

2:28:51 where we are with public safety.

2:28:53 And I think we also have an obligation to work

2:28:56 with our neighbors, the drone neighbors and county neighbors

2:28:59 and all these other folks, and I'm going to tell you,

2:29:03 the other jump is weighing heavy on my mind

2:29:05 is because now we've got another jump

2:29:07 that's potentially going to happen.

2:29:09 We've got the fair that's going to happen that same weekend,

2:29:12 and you can't tell me that our resources aren't going

2:29:15 to be drawn to those events if they're both happening

2:29:17 at the same time.

2:29:18 And then the following weekend, we would have

2:29:20 another jump, so to me, this is overload.

2:29:24 Absolute overload, and it's taken away

2:29:28 from what we should be doing.

2:29:31 Suzanne Hollins.

2:29:33 I was headed down that same direction.

2:29:35 My recollection is we decided to investigate

2:29:39 the possibility of a jump.

2:29:40 We looked at different candidates for that.

2:29:43 We've worked diligently at trying

2:29:46 to sort through the information.

2:29:48 And I believe that we have, in good faith,

2:29:51 negotiated and done what we said we would do as a council

2:29:55 and working with the Beckley media team.

2:29:58 I know we went to the extent of labeling the next few teams.

2:30:02 In my opinion, with the work we've done on this,

2:30:05 I don't see how any of the teams or applicants

2:30:09 could meet what this jump is going to entail.

2:30:12 And even though I know we said if tonight,

2:30:15 Beckley Media did not meet our requirements,

2:30:18 we would move on to number two.

2:30:20 I would be in favor of not holding a jump this year at all.

2:30:25 I don't think it's in our resources.

2:30:27 Again, I don't think it's in our strategic plan.

2:30:30 I think we have looked at a lot of options.

2:30:32 I know that city staff has put a lot,

2:30:35 a lot of time and energy into this.

2:30:38 And I just, I don't think it's feasible at all.

2:30:41 I don't think it's fair to our citizens.

2:30:42 I don't think it's fair to our community.

2:30:44 And I'm sorry for all the work we've put everybody through,

2:30:47 but I really believe we have done what we said we would do,

2:30:50 which is research it, work through it,

2:30:52 and see what we could come up with.

2:30:54 I just don't see how it's feasible.

2:30:58 Thank you, Suzanne.

2:30:59 If there's nothing further on this motion council,

2:31:02 I'm gonna move it to a vote.

2:31:04 Leila, roll call vote please.

2:31:06 Rebecca Milsoka, yes.

2:31:09 Suzanne Hawkins.

2:31:10 No.

2:31:12 Jim Mudd.

2:31:13 No.

2:31:14 Sean Barrigar.

2:31:16 No.

2:31:18 Chris Talkington.

2:31:19 No.

2:31:21 Greg Lanthine.

2:31:22 Yes.

2:31:24 Don Hall.

2:31:24 No.

2:31:25 Motion fails.

2:31:27 Two to five.

2:31:32 Council I believe that is the end of our agenda this evening so I will be closing our meeting.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, February 3, 2014. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:31:44.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    4e0afc9eacf63df967ed5d8ecdf6f0dde91bff9771c206ff8eecd53f34eaffa8
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min, with 6 passages muted for privacy. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a ec3890a39da55e708a1b7b72c160fb55fdf4646259690e204bd4722411c3b4be
    part02.m4a 5b13d1e612a33624f7a90c1599587aac0947e4db9f7b41fae8099e779d194d2e
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 25 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    fd5ab709f2ca66fc4b7c0cb6305778544e9af2e0caf935c59a0aa8a90c1acc47

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file