City Council meeting
Monday, April 21, 2014
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Minutes on file
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Moments cited in findings and the timeline
Transcript
0:07:49 Like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls Council to order. It is Monday April 21st 2014
0:07:54 Welcome everyone first thing on our agenda as always is our Pledge of Allegiance those of you wishing to join us please rise
0:08:01 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:08:21 Again, welcome everyone.
0:08:22 We do have a quorum of the council, all seven members, here this evening.
0:08:26 Turn it over to our city manager.
0:08:28 Do we have any amendments to our agenda this evening, Travis?
0:08:31 There are no amendments this evening.
0:08:32 Thank you.
0:08:33 Next item's on the agenda.
0:08:35 I have the opportunity and pleasure to read a couple of proclamations.
0:08:38 First one being better hearing month from the Office of the Mayor, Twin Falls, Idaho.
0:08:46 Whereas audiologists in Twin Falls, Idaho and
0:08:50 nationwide observe and celebrate better hearing month each year during the month of May.
0:08:56 And the Twin Falls City Council recognizes and
0:08:59 values the efforts of all who work to eliminate or
0:09:03 minimize the isolating effects of communication disorders in the one in five families affected
0:09:10 by them.
0:09:11 And more than half of the people with hearing loss are younger than age 65.
0:09:17 And hearing loss is the third most common health problem in the United States.
0:09:23 And our citizens who have overcome communication disabilities through the services of audiologists
0:09:30 are now able to lead independent, productive, and fulfilling lives, and audiologists have
0:09:36 attained the highest level of education for hearing and balance disorders and Twin Falls
0:09:42 is proud and honored to have audiologists offering quality, education, and healthcare services
0:09:49 to its citizens. Now, therefore, he had resolved that I, Don Hall, Mayor of Twin Falls, do hereby
0:09:57 proclaim May as Better Hearing Month and encourage all citizens to recognize the achievements of
0:10:03 audiologist in improving the quality of life for people with communication disorder.
0:10:10 We do have Amy that's going to come in and receive the proclamation.
0:10:13 I just want to take the opportunity to thank the City Council for the recognition for making
0:10:28 May a better hearing month.
0:10:31 My name is Amy Spalding.
0:10:32 I work at the Hearing Councilors.
0:10:33 here in Twin Falls, this is Spencer, he also is one of the new members of the audiologist,
0:10:38 the providers and our staff. Our mission at Hearing Counselors is to improve our patient's
0:10:44 life, their quality of life through better hearing. There's a lot of patients that go
0:10:49 years and years without treating a hearing loss, whether it's monetary issues, whether
0:10:53 they just don't want to wear a hearing aid. There's a lot of counseling that goes into
0:10:57 getting patients to recognize and treat their hearing loss. And so we're just, we're very
0:11:01 I'm very honored to be in to receive this proclamation.
0:11:06 And if you ever have any questions about how we can treat a hearing loss for your family members, your friends, anyone in the community, we'd be more than happy to do that for you.
0:11:16 So, thank you very much.
0:11:17 Well, it was a pleasure.
0:11:18 I'm and thank you for bringing this to our attention.
0:11:20 Thank you.
0:11:21 Appreciate it.
0:11:23 Next item on the agenda is another Proclamation.
0:11:26 It's Arbor Day Proclamation.
0:11:28 Whereas, in 1872, J. Stirling-Morton proposed to the Nebraska Board of Agriculture that
0:11:35 a special day be set aside for planting of trees, and this holiday, called Arbor Day,
0:11:40 was first observed with the planting of more than one million trees in Nebraska.
0:11:46 And Arbor Day is now observed throughout the nation and the world, and trees can reduce
0:11:55 the erosion of our precious tops out soil by wind and water, cut heating and cooling costs,
0:12:02 moderate the temperature, clean the air, produce oxygen and provide habitat for wildlife, and
0:12:10 trees are a renewable resource giving us paper, wood for our homes, fuel for our fires and countless
0:12:17 other wood products, and trees in our city increase property values, enhance the economic
0:12:24 vitality of business areas and beautify our community and trees wherever they are
0:12:31 planted are a source source of joy and spiritual renewal.
0:12:36 Now therefore, I don Hall Mayor of the City of Twin Falls do proclaim Friday, April 25th,
0:12:41 2014 as Arbor Day in the City of Twin Falls and I urge all citizens to celebrate Arbor
0:12:48 day and to support efforts to protect our trees and woodlands and I urge all citizens
0:12:54 to plant trees to gladden the heart and promote well-being and the future well-being and this
0:13:01 for future generations. I believe we have Dennis Boyer coming forward.
0:13:16 Well thank you Mayor and Council for providing our day of proclamation. This is the City of
0:13:21 Twin Falls 16th year that we have been a tree city USA through the National Arbor Day Foundation.
0:13:27 And I believe looking at some old records, this is our 18th year of celebrating Arbor Day.
0:13:31 Before we became free city USA, we had a couple of individuals that want to celebrate Arbor Day.
0:13:38 So we did that even before we became free city USA.
0:13:42 Our ceremony is four o'clock out at Vista Benita Park, part of town.
0:13:46 Anyway, and hope any and all of you can be there.
0:13:50 We have members from the Boys and Girls Club, they're always great to help out.
0:13:53 We get them shovels and they start digging.
0:13:55 And also, the past several years,
0:13:57 we have had employees from cactus peats come down
0:14:00 and help us celebrate in decals, too,
0:14:02 and cactus peats, again, has donated $500
0:14:05 for this effort to help buy the trees.
0:14:07 We are planting four trees out there,
0:14:09 no matter what the weather is.
0:14:10 Last year, we had beautiful weather.
0:14:12 I don't know about this Friday,
0:14:13 it looks like maybe a little rain,
0:14:14 but it's better than the cold, wet, windy other.
0:14:18 We've had that day out there.
0:14:20 All of you probably have to celebrate
0:14:21 some of those fun days with this, anyway.
0:14:23 But like we always do, we pre-drill the holes,
0:14:26 so it's a lot easier digging,
0:14:28 because our ground, as you know,
0:14:29 after about a foot and a half, you get hard pants.
0:14:32 So we'll have those holes pre-dug,
0:14:34 we just have to remove the dirt, plant the trees,
0:14:36 celebrate it, and enjoy the day.
0:14:39 So again, thank you for allowing to have our Arbor Day
0:14:42 proclamation, and hopefully you will see
0:14:43 the majority of you out there this Friday.
0:14:45 Dennis, could you tell us where is this of Bonita Park?
0:14:49 Okay, so if you go out on South Washington, you go past the fire station on Orchard, right
0:14:56 past the New Swintz, I still call it the New Swintz and store out there for five years
0:15:00 or something.
0:15:01 Nuda.
0:15:02 Right after you pass the Swintz and complex, anyway, there's a left called El Camino, take
0:15:07 that first left and then the very first left again is Caliente, you take that and you drive
0:15:13 right into the park.
0:15:15 And what time is it again?
0:15:16 Four o'clock in the afternoon.
0:15:17 Perfect.
0:15:18 the youth council are coming out as well, aren't they?
0:15:20 Yes, oh, yes, they are.
0:15:22 And which one of you two, one of you two
0:15:24 will be reading the pollination?
0:15:26 You know, flip a coin or whatever.
0:15:29 I might have one of the youth council and read it.
0:15:32 That might be fun.
0:15:33 They all right.
0:15:33 And I did not read the pollination,
0:15:35 so I know it's a really tough one to read,
0:15:37 but it's been like that forever and ever as far as I know.
0:15:41 Thank you.
0:15:42 Thank you, Dennis.
0:15:42 Appreciate it.
0:15:44 The next item on the calendar is always general public input.
0:15:48 Amy, you two, if you want to stay, you certainly can,
0:15:53 but sometimes it feels uncomfortable,
0:15:54 late when we're in the middle of a proceeding,
0:15:57 don't feel uncomfortable.
0:15:58 Okay, you can leave at any time,
0:16:00 but I just wanted to open up for general public input,
0:16:03 if there's anyone here that would like to address the council,
0:16:07 I drive them away, I don't drive them forward,
0:16:09 so I see no one coming forward,
0:16:11 so the next item is the consent calendar,
0:16:14 I'll turn that over to council and Chris talking.
0:16:17 I'd like to make a little statement, and I have a question.
0:16:20 Today was the running, the annual running of the Boston Marathon.
0:16:23 Of course, this is a year after the infamous bombing.
0:16:26 It's one of the celebrate Fred Swenderlick,
0:16:28 who ran in the Boston Marathon how many years ago was it?
0:16:34 He was a much, much younger person, but our own celebrity.
0:16:40 My question is pertaining to the payables,
0:16:46 The I-Crimp second half payment of $175,000.
0:16:51 You may want to discuss this during your budget deliberations, but I'm curious on an annualized
0:16:57 basis, that's over a third of a million dollars, what effect the Affordable Care Act we anticipate
0:17:02 having or has had or is having?
0:17:07 Mr. Mayor, I'd like to answer that now, or I could do it during the budget, however you'd
0:17:12 like to carry the conversation.
0:17:13 I think, why don't you do it now?
0:17:16 So the I-CRIM policy is going to be our liability policy, and it's not going to have a general
0:17:20 connection to the Affordable Care Act.
0:17:24 Our I-CRIM policy is going to be for errors, omissions, property damage, so that's going
0:17:30 to be our general property and cash relief insurance.
0:17:34 The Affordable Health Care Act, in terms of our overall health insurance, is still, I think,
0:17:43 generally uncertain.
0:17:44 we've seen, we've heard some different things.
0:17:46 I know Susan Harris is here, and during maybe the budget portion of the presentation,
0:17:52 we can have Sue kind of explain some of the things that she has heard through the process
0:17:58 about what the potential impacts of affordable health care to overall employee health insurance
0:18:03 may be.
0:18:04 All right.
0:18:05 Thank you, Travis.
0:18:06 Thank you, Chris.
0:18:07 So, waiting on the consent calendar, Greg Lanning, we have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanning.
0:18:15 seconded by Jim Mundt to approve the consent calendar as posted.
0:18:19 Anything further on that council?
0:18:21 Rebecca Melsoik?
0:18:23 Thank you Mayor.
0:18:23 Just a quick question.
0:18:25 The $45,000 that is in there marked for the Northeast sewer odor control.
0:18:33 What account does that come out of?
0:18:34 Does that come out of just the general wastewater treatment funds or?
0:18:38 Yeah, those are all being paid for with Chibani Bond proceeds.
0:18:45 And so.
0:18:46 So you are a.
0:18:47 Yeah.
0:18:48 Yep.
0:18:49 So the way it works is the city has entered into the contract.
0:18:52 Those contracts then because our engineering department has oversight.
0:18:57 As you approve those bills, there's a simultaneous transfer that we pay those payments to the
0:19:04 vendor and we request payment through the Urban Renewal Agency and we capture it from
0:19:11 the bond through a transfer that's performed by Lori Race and her team.
0:19:15 Thank you.
0:19:16 Anything further on the motion, Council?
0:19:20 Leela Rokalvo, please.
0:19:21 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:19:23 Yes.
0:19:24 Sean Berriger?
0:19:25 Yes.
0:19:26 Jim Munn?
0:19:27 Yes.
0:19:28 Greg Lanthine?
0:19:29 Yes.
0:19:30 Don Hall?
0:19:31 Yes.
0:19:32 Chris Tawkins?
0:19:33 Yes.
0:19:34 Rebecca Milsoika?
0:19:35 Yes.
0:19:36 Motion passes 7-0.
0:19:37 Moving down to items for consideration.
0:19:38 The first item is consideration of a request to confirm the appointment of Christopher
0:19:41 read and the appointment, reappointment, excuse me,
0:19:45 of Jody Tatum to the Planning and Zoning Commission.
0:19:48 Just bring to the council's attention that Chuck Sharp
0:19:52 recently completed his term on Planning and Zoning Commission.
0:19:56 He turned out, I believe, and no, okay,
0:20:00 didn't request a reappointment.
0:20:04 And just wanna let folks know how much we truly value
0:20:08 our commission and committee members,
0:20:10 and he was a valued member of that commission.
0:20:13 So we had one spot that we needed to fill,
0:20:15 and then Jodi Tatum,
0:20:18 her term was expired as well,
0:20:21 but she wanted to be reappointed.
0:20:23 So there was a committee put together
0:20:25 of the P&Z chairperson, Tom Frank,
0:20:29 our liaison from council, Rebecca Melsoica,
0:20:33 zoning and development manager, Renee Caraway, and I,
0:20:36 and we had the opportunity and the privilege
0:20:38 to interview six different individuals, which is kind of nice,
0:20:42 six for either one or two positions,
0:20:46 not too many months prior, we didn't have enough
0:20:50 for these commission positions.
0:20:54 And Rebecca made sure that she asked every person
0:20:59 that we interviewed, how did you hear about the position
0:21:05 being open. And most of them said it was through KMBT. And so kudos to Tom Frank who really got
0:21:12 a hold of us and then made sure that we broadcasted that on there. But just a side note, we had
0:21:17 pretty good conversation about this saying that we need to continue those efforts when
0:21:22 we have those commission committee members open to not only times news and KMBT, but our
0:21:30 other our website and in the other ways that we can communicate with our citizens
0:21:34 but anyway we have the opportunity to be able to interview six different
0:21:38 individuals and the majority of the panel recommended Christopher Reed to be
0:21:44 appointed to the Commission so I'll turn that over to council.
0:21:47 Do you need to make them separate or together?
0:21:50 I'm probably separate why don't we do a separate
0:21:53 weekend to see me? We're back on Mel's site.
0:21:56 Thank you, Mayor.
0:21:58 As the Mayor stated, I had the opportunity to sit on the interview committee and really appreciated that opportunity.
0:22:03 And I would agree we had six well qualified applicants and it was a difficult choice.
0:22:10 And I appreciate everyone who applied and we had three men and three women, which was a great turnout because I've been an interview where we haven't had any women apply.
0:22:20 Currently, the commission has seven men and two women, and I agree that Jody Tatum has been a quality
0:22:30 participant on the commission.
0:22:33 And so I would move that we reappoint Jody Tatum first to a term of three years on the planning and
0:22:40 zoning commission beginning retroactively in March 2014.
0:22:46 Second.
0:22:47 We have a motion on the floor by Rebecca Mills-Soyka,
0:22:52 seconded by Suzanne Hopkins to reappoint Jody Tatum,
0:22:56 moving it backwards to March 31st,
0:22:59 the next three years.
0:23:00 You're right, that's what it is.
0:23:03 So retroactive.
0:23:05 So anything further on that motion council?
0:23:07 Leila Rokomo, please.
0:23:09 Sean Berger.
0:23:10 Yes.
0:23:11 Jim Young.
0:23:11 Yes.
0:23:12 Greg Lanti.
0:23:13 Yes.
0:23:13 Don Hall.
0:23:14 Yes.
0:23:14 Chris Talking.
0:23:15 Yes.
0:23:16 Yes, yes. Motion passes seven to zero. Jim. Thank you, Mayor. I would move to a
0:23:25 point, Chris, for read to a planning and zoning commission to serve a three year
0:23:30 term, which would commence when? March 31st. March 31st. We're retroactive. Motion on
0:23:39 floor by Jim. Seconded by Greg Lanting. Anything further on that motion council?
0:23:43 Rebecca Mils
0:24:06 that led me to look at the land use planning act which governs the creation and policies
0:24:11 of planning and zoning commissions, and it states that governing the governing board creating
0:24:17 a planning and zoning commission, quote, shall provide that the area and its interests within
0:24:21 the jurisdiction are broadly represented on the commission.
0:24:25 Currently on our commission we have two commissioners in real estate, two in construction, three from
0:24:31 local various businesses, and one from the banking industry.
0:24:36 And again, there are seven men and two women.
0:24:38 So in the interest of diversifying the commission,
0:24:42 I actually felt that we should recommend Sheri Condi.
0:24:46 Like Chris Reed, she's been really involved in the community
0:24:49 and the political process.
0:24:51 She represents the citizens that were involved
0:24:53 in the canyon, citizens for the canyon.
0:24:57 And according to our strategic plan, our comp plan,
0:25:01 and even the citizen survey, the views that they hold
0:25:06 are widely supported in the community of preservation, sustainable and environmentally sustainable building practices.
0:25:14 So I really felt that she would add to the diversity of the commission and add to the representation on this body.
0:25:22 Well, once again, I don't disagree that Chris Reed is also an excellent candidate, but I feel that adding to the female representation
0:25:32 to the board and adding to that that voice that is you know pretty broadly supported in our
0:25:40 community I think would be good to appoint Sherry Condy.
0:25:45 Thank you Rebecca just as one of the members of the selection committee and then of course
0:25:51 I'm bringing the names to the council this evening.
0:25:54 Rebecca brought this point up to us and it was a good point about diversity and talking
0:26:00 about one of the other members currently on the commission is in the banking industry.
0:26:06 But it was shared that that person is actually in the IT department of the banking industry,
0:26:13 which is you IT people, you know, we love you, but I'm looking at one of ours, folks.
0:26:21 So we felt that, you know, that's a diverse group.
0:26:24 So a banker is different than an IT person, so we felt that Christopher Reed's involvement
0:26:31 in the community, his ability to go out and talk to the community and be involved, basically,
0:26:39 would bring considerable amount of experience and dedication to our commission.
0:26:45 So the other members of the committee selected Christopher.
0:26:49 So we have a motion on the floor, Chris, Chris talking.
0:26:53 I'd like to amend that though, that Sherry Conde would be appointed an alternate so that
0:26:58 if there are any resignations that she would have a chance to step up, she has had experience
0:27:05 and been active in zoning and I think we need to hear her voice from a different perspective.
0:27:11 I'll second that.
0:27:12 We have a motion on floor to list Sherry Conde as the alternate, seconded by Rebecca Mills-Soyka.
0:27:19 I will share with the council that the committee did do a selection of an alternate to just
0:27:29 in case someone didn't make it through the background or something else because as we
0:27:34 all know we do backgrounds on our selection process of our committees now.
0:27:40 And we chose, what was the gentleman's name, Mitch, do you remember?
0:27:45 We chose a different candidate to be the alternate from the committee.
0:27:49 Right, and I am not recalling what his name was right off top of my head, but I can find it for you because I have it in my email.
0:27:57 If you find that, that way we can share it because it's Robert Spear.
0:28:00 Robert Spear. Thank you, Robert Spear.
0:28:03 And so I'm not going to be in support of this motion because the selection committee already made their selection for the second, the second tier, if you will.
0:28:13 It wasn't mentioned though.
0:28:15 Sure.
0:28:16 Was it mentioned just now?
0:28:17 Right.
0:28:18 No, it wasn't.
0:28:19 But it was just now after you made the motion, Chris.
0:28:25 Sean Berger.
0:28:28 So I'm not familiar with having alternate positions appointed for commissions and committees.
0:28:35 Does that occur?
0:28:37 Does that happen?
0:28:38 Is that in the code?
0:28:43 We're not aware of an occurrence.
0:28:47 It would seem to me if the time arose where we had a vacancy come up, suddenly we would
0:28:53 just go through the process of appointment rather than having a list of alternates.
0:28:59 I know certainly in the commissions I've been involved in, in the interviews we are very encouraging
0:29:05 of others who aren't selected to stay engaged and look for other opportunities to apply for
0:29:10 positions and I just think that it would be premature to list out alternates if
0:29:17 that's not something that we typically do.
0:29:19 Rebecca Milsoy.
0:29:21 Thank you Mayor and that's a good point Council Member Berger and the Mayor's right we
0:29:27 did choose an alternate the committee as a whole chose Robert Spear but I do support
0:29:32 Sherry Condi as an alternate she has applied to I think two different
0:29:38 And I think this is the second time she has applied to P&Z, I'm not sure.
0:29:43 But I do support it because the more I thought about the makeup of the commission, the more
0:29:46 I thought about the land use planning, X direction, I really felt that with all other things being
0:29:54 equal, being well qualified candidates, I really believe that we should take advantage of the
0:29:59 opportunity to have another female voice on the commission.
0:30:04 So I am in support of it.
0:30:07 Greg Lanning.
0:30:09 Well, I I'm kind of torn on this on the amendment
0:30:14 Obviously, I think it we probably need to look at times for
0:30:20 sometimes the
0:30:22 Voice that is not the same as everyone else has its barets without a doubt and I believe sure would in some instances would fill that role and
0:30:32 Slow down the process and not in that solo process, but give the process a wider spectrum
0:30:37 but I'm going to approach this in a slightly different direction.
0:30:41 It's a little bit the same as Shawn's.
0:30:43 I've been on ones where we were doing several members and then we weren't sure,
0:30:49 we wanted to make sure that we didn't have to start over the process
0:30:53 if we, somebody didn't pass the background text that we had somebody else to put forth
0:31:02 so we didn't have to start the interview process over again.
0:31:04 I think I'm a little like Shawn.
0:31:06 I'm a little apprehensive to start a list of our order at this point and plus to be honest with you
0:31:15 I still think that motion probably usurps some of the mayor's power. Unduly it says the mayor
0:31:25 will appoint and if the mayor and the board you have people actually have a different candidate
0:31:30 in case they didn't pass the background I'm not sure how I can vote to have a separate candidate
0:31:36 be the alternate should one of them pass the background test.
0:31:41 So I will be voting against amendment, but for the motion.
0:31:45 Suzanne Hock.
0:31:47 A couple of things real quick.
0:31:49 I hate when we separate categories by men and women.
0:31:52 We're all human, we're all here to serve together, we're all a team we work well.
0:31:56 And I don't think counting heads of men and women make a good committee personally.
0:32:00 I think it's the most qualified person and that really by doing it that way,
0:32:05 you're reverse discriminating sexually and I would just as soon we try to keep the male
0:32:11 female thing out of our decision making for the most part.
0:32:15 And I think if we start picking alternates now, there could be somebody else out there
0:32:19 we're not aware of that might be a stronger candidate down the road and I hate to put ourselves
0:32:24 in a box and miss an opportunity.
0:32:26 So I will be voting against the amendment.
0:32:30 Chris Dockington.
0:32:31 clarification the mayor may appoint but that's a concurrence of the council.
0:32:36 We spent most of one evening hashing that out. Second of all, I don't know anything about it being a woman. Sherry could be a man except I know her and she is a woman.
0:32:44 She served over six months on her zoning committee and has a lot of experience.
0:32:49 And I would assume that this amendment fails and that means that the P&Z's decision for a Auburn that is no longer valid.
0:32:57 Well, let me clarify something, the Robert Speer was not our alternate if somebody dropped off the commission.
0:33:05 Robert Speer was the alternate in case Christopher Reed didn't make it through the background check only.
0:33:12 And I feel very strongly that for us to sit up here and choose an alternate out of the group without having the consent or
0:33:21 the input from the actual committee that we put together,
0:33:26 the group of people we put together to do the interviews,
0:33:29 is usurping the whole process of what we've put together
0:33:33 in the past.
0:33:34 So again, I won't be voting in support of the amendment.
0:33:41 So.
0:33:46 I don't know if it's totally relevant or not,
0:33:47 but Friday we heard back from the police department
0:33:49 they've cleared Chris Reed.
0:33:51 He's cleared the background check.
0:33:52 And thank you for sharing that.
0:33:53 And Christopher Reed told me he wanted to be here
0:33:56 this evening, but he was not able to be here
0:33:58 because of a family emergency.
0:34:00 And I will ask him if he wouldn't mind coming
0:34:02 to the next week's council meeting,
0:34:05 just so that we can,
0:34:08 I think it's always best when we appoint people
0:34:10 to committees that they come forward
0:34:12 and see the council that evening,
0:34:13 but because of a family emergency,
0:34:15 he was not able to be here this evening.
0:34:17 So with that, roll call vote on the amendment
0:34:21 to make Sherry Connie be the alternate from P&Z in case
0:34:26 someone drops off.
0:34:28 We have a roll call vote, please.
0:34:30 Jim Munn.
0:34:31 No.
0:34:32 Greg Lanti.
0:34:33 No.
0:34:34 Don Hall.
0:34:34 No.
0:34:36 Chris Talkington.
0:34:36 Yes.
0:34:38 Rebecca Milsoica.
0:34:39 Yes.
0:34:40 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:34:42 No.
0:34:43 Sean Berriger.
0:34:44 No.
0:34:45 Motion fails 5 to 2.
0:34:48 Now to the original motion to bring Christopher Reed on as the planning and
0:34:54 zoning commission member retroactive to March 31st, the other roll call vote, please.
0:35:01 Greg Lansing?
0:35:02 Yes.
0:35:03 Don Hall?
0:35:04 Yes.
0:35:06 Ms. Tocquentes?
0:35:06 Yes.
0:35:08 Rebecca Milsoyka?
0:35:09 No.
0:35:10 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:35:11 Yes.
0:35:13 Sean Berriger?
0:35:14 Yes.
0:35:16 Jim Mun?
0:35:17 Yes.
0:35:18 Motion passes, six to one.
0:35:21 Moving on to the next item on the agenda and its consideration of a request to seek direction
0:35:27 on the process of awarding the municipal powers outsourced grant, and POG, as we love to call
0:35:34 it, funding for the current 2014 fiscal year.
0:35:38 Mandy Thompson.
0:35:39 Welcome, Mandy.
0:35:41 Thank you, Mayor, members of council.
0:35:46 So I've inherited the MPOG for back of a better term.
0:35:51 I actually volunteered to help Patti with it, and so as we were discussing last week what
0:35:58 we needed to do in order to get things moving, the first item that we had to accomplish was
0:36:05 to come before council and ask your direction on how you want to proceed with the actual
0:36:11 process.
0:36:13 If you'll recall, in 2013, the process included an application process in which all interested
0:36:21 parties submit an application to the city, those applications were turned over to Fritz
0:36:27 for him to determine that they were indeed eligible under the city statute.
0:36:33 He then returned those to the city staff who then gave those to council.
0:36:39 And then all of those that were approved as eligible gave a five minute presentation to
0:36:44 you all, and you scored them with this matrix during those presentations.
0:36:51 It's my understanding that then Patty and Lori race frantically tried to calculate all
0:36:57 of your scores and then come up with a ranking.
0:37:02 It is my suggestion that you all just put one more step in that process and you actually
0:37:08 do your ranking of the applications based on their paper applications that they do submit
0:37:14 to the city. That would give us a chance to then create a ranking of scoring of all of
0:37:23 the applicants. And then when they come in for their five-minute presentations, you'll
0:37:27 have an opportunity to listen to what they're saying and not necessarily have to be frantically
0:37:31 scoring them at the same time. And I think it can kind of streamline the process. If you
0:37:36 have any changes you would like to make to your original scores, we can make those changes
0:37:41 during the brief recess, but I think this might make it run a little bit smoother.
0:37:45 Any questions for Mandy?
0:37:50 Chris Dockingen.
0:37:52 Not a question for Mandy, but that one, Mandy, you'll guess a little bit of background before
0:37:57 you joined us.
0:37:59 In the M-POG discussions last year toward the end, or maybe it was at the end, there
0:38:05 was, if not a consensus of four of us, there were certainly several of us were interested
0:38:11 in removing Twin Falls Band and putting it in a regular appropriation, I think it's
0:38:19 about 21,005. Do you have the amounts for input?
0:38:23 I do not have the amounts that were one of us.
0:38:25 Which would allow you about 7,995. I'm very supportive of putting the band in a regular
0:38:34 annual appropriation and not make it a subject to discussion of whether we're going to chop
0:38:40 the head off of the United States first or second oldest municipal band.
0:38:47 I have a question regarding that, Travis.
0:38:49 Well, I guess it really goes towards Rebecca because your husband, does he still play for
0:38:55 the band?
0:38:56 He does.
0:38:57 And is he paid?
0:38:58 I know it's not much, so you're not going to the bank with it, that's for sure.
0:39:03 He is, it is optional, so he doesn't have to apply for the money.
0:39:10 But I'd rather recuse myself on the issue all together, but-
0:39:15 Well, the challenge though, Rebecca, what I was really going after is that if it's in the full budget,
0:39:21 then she can't vote on the full budget, that's the only challenge.
0:39:24 Because I support personally that we pull it out and put it into the budget as well.
0:39:30 But we have a council member that it's going to.
0:39:33 Right, so I have a question of Fritz.
0:39:35 That's actually what I was going to follow up with.
0:39:37 Is there an opportunity to put it in its own category
0:39:42 that I might not, kind of like MPOG.
0:39:44 I mean, MPOG is in the budget, but we vote on it separately.
0:39:48 Is that a possibility to put it in a different category
0:39:51 so that I may recuse myself as needed?
0:39:56 It's outside the other six vote for, but you can recuse some friends.
0:40:05 I have to tell you, I'm not sure what the band is.
0:40:09 It might be a separate nonprofit.
0:40:12 I don't know if anybody knows that.
0:40:13 Maybe we need to investigate that for you and report back to you.
0:40:17 Because it may be you're just fuddling money to a nonprofit.
0:40:22 And if he's employed by the nonprofit, it's not a direct conflict that way.
0:40:27 you mean under a 501c3 classification?
0:40:31 An entity of the city have that separate.
0:40:34 It may be it's own 501c3 already, I don't know.
0:40:40 Well, well, Fritz, just clarification there.
0:40:42 The reason that MPa came together was because of me,
0:40:45 and I was the director of the Boys and Girls Club,
0:40:48 which is a non-profit 501c3.
0:40:50 So I'm not sure how this makes any,
0:40:53 if it's a 501c3 or not.
0:40:55 Did you want to add something, you keep, Travis, jump in, jump in.
0:41:02 So we can look at that and we can find an opportunity because I think the last thing we
0:41:08 want to do is to have a council person not be able to vote on a significant budget as
0:41:14 a result of a modest contribution to a very significant worthy cause in the band.
0:41:20 Our recommendation tonight would be to strip out what amount you would feel appropriate
0:41:24 It would be from the municipal band of the $100,000 that you have eligible for other grant recipients
0:41:32 tonight.
0:41:34 And then we can move forward and publish, this is the amount that we have available, and these
0:41:40 are the entities that we can move forward with.
0:41:43 If the nonprofit thing works, there are a series of nonprofits that we can make that contribution
0:41:50 to and have them make a direct contribution to them.
0:41:54 That's not something I've heard of before, though.
0:42:00 See, you are an ongoing employee at Boys and Girls Club.
0:42:03 I was.
0:42:03 Rebecca's husband may or may not be like day labor.
0:42:09 It's not the same.
0:42:11 I trust what you're saying.
0:42:13 I've just never, this has never come to our attention.
0:42:14 Well, but I think I've seen something recently.
0:42:17 And I don't know when it was that caused me to believe
0:42:20 that the band is something different than I thought it was.
0:42:23 Okay.
0:42:24 And I don't know, I just don't know what they are.
0:42:26 Okay, so it's going to take a little further research because I think Chris' point is right.
0:42:31 There were a few of us that wanted to talk about stripping it out.
0:42:36 So, Greg Lanning.
0:42:37 Well, one of the things that conversation just came up as a possibility, I was thinking
0:42:42 of ways of my will do it, is there a way that we can donate?
0:42:47 We send the $22,000 for the band to the Community Foundation,
0:42:54 then Community Foundation then funnels it to the band,
0:42:57 and since none of us are employees
0:43:01 of the Community Foundation, but I guess,
0:43:05 whether that, maybe that just stickies
0:43:07 the way it could even more, I'm not sure.
0:43:10 I don't think you can do that,
0:43:11 because they can do a whole lot of other things
0:43:14 with that money, and you're designating
0:43:17 that for part of your, either your recreation
0:43:22 or arts part of your.
0:43:24 I see what you're saying.
0:43:25 Well, a couple of things for us.
0:43:26 I wanted to add, I think that muddies the water
0:43:29 a little bit and also I think that there's a fee attached
0:43:31 to the community foundation as well.
0:43:33 So I don't want to see a fee taken out of our 21,000
0:43:37 and now it's 19,000, not that that would be the fee.
0:43:40 Yeah, but I don't think we can do it that way.
0:43:41 Okay, so that's gone.
0:43:42 Number two is that we also, this line of thought,
0:43:46 I mean, I wasn't able to vote on a MPOP one time because I was a board member of a non-profit.
0:43:56 I wasn't even being paid, but I was a board member of a non-profit that was asking for
0:44:01 money.
0:44:02 So I'm really confused now with your statement, to be honest with you.
0:44:08 So sometimes they are, actual legal conflicts of interest when we talk about this council
0:44:16 voting to employ somebody that they're related to.
0:44:20 I mean, we have a statute that says you can't do that.
0:44:24 We have what appear to be conflicts of interest.
0:44:28 And the example you just gave, how does it look for a board member, even if it's a non-profit,
0:44:34 of a board member coming to this council
0:44:36 and voting to benefit an organization
0:44:40 that they sit on the board.
0:44:44 Can I jump in?
0:44:45 Sure, I'm not.
0:44:46 I don't see Rebecca's husband who might or might not
0:44:49 get paid to play some, some bad nights
0:44:53 and not other bad nights, he might or he might not
0:44:56 is being in the same category.
0:44:57 Well, if he's paid, then there is a conflict in my mind.
0:45:00 He's not, he is not currently an employee of the,
0:45:04 I don't think they have any employees.
0:45:09 Okay. Suzanne Hawkins.
0:45:12 If it matters, the city band is a 501c3.
0:45:15 How about if we take a look at it report back to you?
0:45:20 Yeah, please, because I'm more confused than it was at the beginning.
0:45:23 So I heard Travis ask a question about,
0:45:29 could we come up with what the amount is we'd like to leave in the MPOG process?
0:45:35 So, I'm all for supporting the band, however, I think if we're going to make it a line item in the budget or treat it for all intents and purposes like that,
0:45:49 I think we need to have whatever appropriate oversight into that rather than just pulling a number out of the air.
0:45:56 So, one, we haven't heard from the band what that number is.
0:46:00 We only know what last year's was.
0:46:02 Two, if it's going to live in some part of the budget,
0:46:07 should that department that it lives in not have some oversight
0:46:11 into how those funds are spent?
0:46:14 So I think it's difficult to sort of arbitrarily pick
0:46:17 that number tonight.
0:46:20 Now, I would venture to guess it's in the ballpark
0:46:23 of what it's been the last couple of years,
0:46:25 and I don't think there's been significant change to that,
0:46:28 but I don't recall what that number is.
0:46:31 Travis?
0:46:32 So what we can do is if you like the outline
0:46:34 that has been recommended by Mandy,
0:46:36 we can follow that outline.
0:46:38 We have $100,000 that has been earmarked
0:46:42 for MPOG style projects.
0:46:46 We can have the band and all of the other applicants
0:46:49 submit their materials in accordance with the schedule
0:46:52 and we can review the band first, if you will,
0:46:57 for a determination of what may be left in the pot
0:47:02 for grant opportunities after the conversation
0:47:05 about the band.
0:47:06 In the meantime, we can do our research.
0:47:08 We'll give us some time between now and prior
0:47:12 to the May 19 anticipated award date,
0:47:16 where we can share with you 501c3 status,
0:47:21 if that matters and at the end you may just elect to say
0:47:25 we believe that this is important and you're going to follow the typical steps
0:47:29 that we hear that we started with last year
0:47:32 by having one member recuse themselves if they have a conflict
0:47:36 with a particular
0:47:38 donation because what you did was you took them each in separate motions last
0:47:42 year
0:47:43 allowing you to
0:47:44 not vote on the whole but rather to vote on the sum of the parts
0:47:51 And the only other comment I would add,
0:47:53 and I kind of follow Fritz's logic about employees or not.
0:47:58 But the fact of the matter is, is that almost the entirety
0:48:01 of the city band request is to stipend the performers.
0:48:07 So whether they're employees or not,
0:48:09 if we want to talk about perceptions,
0:48:11 it's exactly what it is is stipending the participants.
0:48:19 Great landing.
0:48:20 Well, I guess I'm a little confused.
0:48:23 On one part is we just talked about,
0:48:25 well, if we separate that out,
0:48:27 then we're making not build on the whole budget.
0:48:29 But the year that we had so many conflicts up here,
0:48:33 the impacts part of the budget,
0:48:35 then we vote on entity and with the impact as part of it.
0:48:38 No, it's separate.
0:48:40 Okay, you get my question then.
0:48:42 Yeah, so just for clarification,
0:48:44 the council set a total size of the award
0:48:49 during the budget process.
0:48:51 There is not an allocation to any entity made
0:48:54 at the time and would you create the allocation.
0:48:57 So you are doing this allocation process
0:49:00 for the current year budget,
0:49:02 not the one that will start on October 1st.
0:49:04 This is for funds that we have in the bank
0:49:08 and ready to go today.
0:49:10 Okay.
0:49:11 Rebecca Mills-Sleica.
0:49:13 Thank you, Mayor.
0:49:14 I just want to say a general comment about MPOG.
0:49:17 And I appreciate your input, Mandy, on the new process.
0:49:21 I think that's a good idea.
0:49:23 But honestly, I started out on council
0:49:26 being a really strong supporter of MPOG.
0:49:28 And then as we kind of muddled our way through it
0:49:32 in the past three years, I participated in two
0:49:35 of the last three MPOG processes.
0:49:39 And I'm just, I grow less and less convinced
0:49:43 that it is a legitimate grant process,
0:49:47 with all the other foundations that I'm aware of
0:49:50 and their stringent rules and their stringent oversight.
0:49:54 You know, we have a couple of five minute presentations.
0:49:58 And I agree with the causes.
0:50:00 I agree that there were the causes,
0:50:02 but you know, there are needs in the city budget,
0:50:07 needs for infrastructure, needs for necessities
0:50:11 that are deferred, you know,
0:50:13 while we separate this money out for MPOG.
0:50:16 And so I just wanted to share that I think I'm less
0:50:19 unless a supporter of the whole impact process.
0:50:23 I know that we had, we created a matrix last year,
0:50:27 and we had it, I don't know that we used it,
0:50:30 but I mean, when you look at the scores
0:50:32 and the appropriations, and so, I don't know,
0:50:36 I'm just a little uncertain about the whole process,
0:50:38 and I guess I wouldn't mind not having MPOG altogether.
0:50:44 not having M-POG altogether.
0:50:47 So let me clarify, Rebecca,
0:50:49 so not giving the money to nonprofits
0:50:52 and these entities, is that what you're saying?
0:50:54 Right, and it's just the process that I'm bothered by.
0:50:56 It's just the way that we go about it.
0:50:58 I don't feel like, you know, in learning more about
0:51:02 health initiative trust, which is a grant program,
0:51:06 the stringent questioning and oversight
0:51:09 for a lot of these grant programs.
0:51:11 I just don't think that we are in a position to scrutinize the applicants as much as other grant programs do.
0:51:22 Chris, talkie, thank you.
0:51:23 Well, I think we're getting on a tangent.
0:51:25 I think that could be a discussion for another time, but I have to put my two bits in that as I understand the structure of the MPOG grantees,
0:51:35 they provide a service that if the city were to do it probably would cause considerable more money.
0:51:42 And I can think of most of them that have applied in the past few years that have and do an incredible city mandated type of a function that allows us not to incorporate the reoccurring cost for it.
0:52:02 I find more and more credibility for the use of it.
0:52:07 But when it all comes down to it,
0:52:09 when the people file their presentation with the council,
0:52:14 that would be the time to say yay or nay on specifics.
0:52:17 But to throw them all out in the bath water,
0:52:19 I wouldn't support that.
0:52:23 I want to tell you, thank you for bringing it.
0:52:24 I think generally we like the direction,
0:52:27 am I getting the head not, that you put together,
0:52:30 I like that.
0:52:31 The only struggle that I have personally with this whole process is we go through the process,
0:52:36 we score, and then we figure out how much money we're going to give them.
0:52:38 It doesn't give us any guidance on the delivery of money towards each individual.
0:52:44 And frankly, I don't have a recommendation for that.
0:52:47 I mean, because each one of them ask, they have different allocations that they're asking
0:52:52 for and the matrix and how all that works.
0:52:55 I think it's a good process to go through.
0:52:58 I don't want to just see it on the rubber stamped every year because I want to see these folks come in front of us and us be able to see where our money's going and making sure that it's going to a direction that a city might do anyway because that's the, as Chris said, that's the criteria.
0:53:17 But I still don't have my head around exactly how to give the money out percentage wise with the matrix and all those dynamics.
0:53:28 I would say exactly that because last year we ranked somewhere ranked higher and got less of their requests than those who were ranked lower and we just kind of made sausied all over the place that we did on the floor and it was on the walls.
0:53:45 And it's one of the messiest things that we do up here, Travis.
0:53:50 What we can do in preparation is on the evening of the 12th of May,
0:53:59 between now and then I've asked Mandy and she believes that she can come up with some sort of scoring system
0:54:06 that you guys could utilize to determine total scores and how that may translate to funding.
0:54:14 Just to remind you, one of the challenges that we had is that sometimes that numeric score doesn't necessarily translate to a value.
0:54:27 And so we're happy to develop that for you, but last time there was a bit of resistance in terms of not being able to be flexible
0:54:39 and be held more captive to a matrix-style system as opposed to to another process.
0:54:45 But if you would like, yeah, we can use Mandy's expertise,
0:54:49 because she's on the other side of that scoring system.
0:54:53 We can utilize Mandy's expertise to try to put together some samples of ones that you may like.
0:55:00 And if you like them, we'll roll with it.
0:55:02 And if you don't, we won't.
0:55:04 If you think it's going to make it worse, we won't even.
0:55:09 We won't even touch it, so really whatever the council's pleasure is.
0:55:12 Shumbearer.
0:55:14 So I think as much as we would love this not to be, this is a subjective process.
0:55:19 And it's going to be a subjective process.
0:55:22 I will tell you that, so in the past I've had the privilege of serving on the United
0:55:27 Way Allocation Committee, which is the most miserable volunteer job you can possibly imagine
0:55:33 because there are way more requests than there are funds.
0:55:37 But at the end of it, if it were just a formula that spit out the number at the end, and that's what you gave people,
0:55:45 I don't think that serves the purpose.
0:55:48 So what I experienced with the ranking system, while it's not perfect, it did allow us to sort of get a general idea of priorities.
0:55:59 And then it's going to be subjective, and it's going to be lobbying back and forth amongst the seven of us to figure out who gets the money.
0:56:07 I think if we try to make this so objective that it's just a formula, I think it's going to be a tremendous waste of time on Mandy's part to try to put that together, and I don't think we're going to feel comfortable with it.
0:56:19 I agree.
0:56:20 I think that my suggestion that you do the ranking prior to the council meeting, you can
0:56:27 look at where they call numerically, then you can listen to their presentation, and then
0:56:31 if you can insert that subjective portion of the process into it.
0:56:39 I guess I was just thinking when I had what happened last year explained to me, and my
0:56:44 experiences of sitting on grant evaluation committee, I thought I said it a little bit
0:56:48 like a nightmare.
0:56:49 It was.
0:56:50 It was.
0:56:51 I think just, you know, in hoping to just make it a little bit more of a stream-blind
0:56:56 process, and so that you all can, like I said, maybe give a little more thoughtful consideration
0:57:02 to anything that they might have to add in addition to what they put on paper, and again,
0:57:08 I'm new to this, and the grant-writer-administrative side of me is a little bit surprised that there
0:57:16 isn't any sort of reporting or accountability to the grantees only because I spent the better
0:57:21 part of a day-to-day, just putting together all of the paperwork required for a particular
0:57:28 grant.
0:57:29 And, well, that's considerably a larger amount of money, I think.
0:57:32 Perhaps we need to discuss if, you know, and then as the process moves forward about having
0:57:38 some sort of reporting of what they're doing with their funding and showing us how they're
0:57:42 actually using that money so that we can, when it comes back around and they ask for, you
0:57:48 know what they reapply, that could be part of their application. If you have been awarded
0:57:52 these funds in the past, please submit as part of your application your final report
0:57:56 and how you use those funds and so that we know, because I think I agree that there
0:58:01 are a lot of, potentially a lot of non-profits out there that may not be aware of the MPA
0:58:06 program or if they are, you know, there might be some preconceived notions that it's, you
0:58:11 know, that we've kind of already have it in our mind who is going to get them. So if we
0:58:16 We can make it a little bit more of a formalized process so that we, those people that are awarded the grants,
0:58:22 we're assured that they're using those funds, you know, to the best use.
0:58:29 That would be my suggestion that we insert that into this process so that we can see on paper what they're doing with it.
0:58:36 I think you're going to hear that exactly.
0:58:38 Chris Stockington.
0:58:39 Well, I can offer a simple solution.
0:58:41 We all served on this commission last year,
0:58:45 why we even invented the process work reasonably well.
0:58:50 We have on our own minds an idea of those
0:58:52 that are probably most related to public safety
0:58:57 and health and those that are less than a number
0:58:59 of people that are impacted.
0:59:02 You know, those are variables that are not likely
0:59:04 to change dramatically.
0:59:06 I'd say the quick suggestion would be to take the distributed funds from last year and tweak
0:59:12 them visually here or verbally before the community.
0:59:19 There's a vast difference between a lot of non-profits applying and what we're trying to
0:59:24 do.
0:59:25 We're dealing with domestic violence that results in police or medical calls.
0:59:29 We're dealing with addictions that relate to police calls and neighborhood stripe all the
0:59:35 way down to presentation for supporting the arts, so there's a white variance there, but
0:59:43 I'm saying why in reinvent everything this next year?
0:59:46 My only concern with that is that I've been contacted by at least one group that has not
0:59:52 requested funding in the past.
0:59:54 They could do that.
0:59:55 They would like the opportunity because their funding has been cut, their federal funding
0:59:58 has been cut, so they're scrambling looking for ways to.
1:00:00 And we wouldn't say no to anybody new applying, whether they make the cut though is just
1:00:05 I'm just saying I think our rationale among the Council for supporting who we did last year
1:00:11 is going to dramatically change this year, I would guess.
1:00:14 So Mandy, I think what I'm hearing Chris say is that we're going to do this similar process
1:00:19 where we put it out, receive grant requests coming in from the ones that put in possibly
1:00:26 last year and new ones and go through that process.
1:00:30 screen by Fritz first, seeing if they even need the criteria of being able to ask for
1:00:35 money in this impact system.
1:00:37 So.
1:00:38 Okay, I guess I'm going to send her back.
1:00:40 Am I correct, Chris?
1:00:41 Rebecca.
1:00:42 Thank you, Mayor.
1:00:43 Well, in my perspective of last year, kind of as Mandy suggested, I think it was in need
1:00:49 of improvement.
1:00:50 So I welcome your suggestions, especially, you're the expert on grants and we're not.
1:00:57 And so I actually would welcome any suggestions or improvements to the process because I really
1:01:03 think that we could stand to implement them.
1:01:07 I agree it's a subjective process.
1:01:09 I agree that it's not going to be pretty, but I think we can do a better job of standardizing
1:01:15 our process and the applications and really adding that element of, and maybe that's where
1:01:22 I, my support for M-POG waivers is the lack of accountability, I feel.
1:01:26 And so I really appreciate those suggestions for accountability.
1:01:30 I would, you know, I mean, people come and say,
1:01:32 always spent this much here and there.
1:01:33 We never see receipts.
1:01:35 We never see actual proof of where the funds have gone.
1:01:40 And I know that that creates bureaucracy and difficulty,
1:01:44 but it also creates a little bit more accountability.
1:01:48 And we are spending tax dollars.
1:01:51 And so I think that that's really important to the process.
1:01:54 So I would welcome your suggestions.
1:01:57 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:01:58 I just wanted to make sure that since we are being aired,
1:02:01 that it does go on record, that everyone we did give money
1:02:04 to did have to come back to us with the financial statement
1:02:07 showing how they spent the money and how it actually
1:02:11 attributed to the cause that they told us
1:02:14 they were going to spend it on.
1:02:16 So I just want to make sure that our citizens know
1:02:19 We're just not writing a blank check and not doing any check up or follow up.
1:02:23 Yes, there could be more, but at the same time we are following through on the second half and
1:02:28 checking and making all of those groups come back and give us financial statements as well as present to us on the outcome.
1:02:37 Give us some, yeah, no, and this isn't directed at you.
1:02:41 I just want to make sure people know that they had to give us some measurable way to see that there was a tangible good for what we had supply.
1:02:47 Absolutely, a performance measure of how it says.
1:02:50 And I'm just furthering the mission of what they're trying to accomplish.
1:02:52 Exactly.
1:02:53 So I just want to make sure people don't think we're writing a blank check and then a year
1:02:56 later doing it all over again and not following it because we are.
1:02:59 Okay.
1:03:00 I'll add to that the process has actually evolved back and forth for a while.
1:03:05 There was some accountability in this respect and then it kind of remember it kind of just
1:03:09 was if you were in last year, you're in this year and I never felt comfortable with that
1:03:15 and ask for a report coming back.
1:03:18 Now, the report coming back to us,
1:03:20 we really need to give these nonprofits
1:03:22 a guidance of what we're asking.
1:03:24 So please, however the process is,
1:03:26 it's not fair to them, they come up here
1:03:28 and they really need to understand what the process is,
1:03:31 just like they need to understand what we're looking for,
1:03:34 you know, the question, the matrix that we have,
1:03:36 I think that's great.
1:03:38 But they need to understand-
1:03:38 And they need to know, yeah, exactly.
1:03:40 I've written grants and been recipients of them.
1:03:42 You've done that.
1:03:43 And that's what we need as an entity looking for funding to further our mission.
1:03:49 So I think we're on a good track.
1:03:51 I think with your guidance in the future, maybe you'll get us to a place where it's better than it is today.
1:03:57 So, Rebecca.
1:03:58 Thank you. And to clarify, we did have presentations, but they were five minute presentations.
1:04:03 And I mean, we got some ink on paper about expenses, but they were not.
1:04:09 I mean, I didn't see any receipts or valid financial statements.
1:04:13 I mean, I didn't see any of that in the past three years.
1:04:16 So, you know, I mean, a five-minute speech
1:04:18 about what they're doing, I think there needs
1:04:20 to be more accountability.
1:04:23 Is that Claire's mud, Mandy?
1:04:24 Absolutely.
1:04:25 All right.
1:04:27 Anything else?
1:04:29 Well, I guess I just want to clarify that muddy water
1:04:32 that I can go ahead and working with Josh.
1:04:35 We can start publicizing that the funding is available.
1:04:38 That's what I heard from Council Council, am I wrong?
1:04:42 Okay.
1:04:43 Go for it.
1:04:44 Okay. Thank you.
1:04:45 Thank you, Mandy. Appreciate your presentation tonight.
1:04:47 Next item on the agenda is consideration
1:04:50 of request adopt ordinance 3069 to vacate a portion
1:04:54 of 23 give or take acres.
1:04:57 No feet, excuse me, platted utility drainage access
1:05:01 and irrigation easement on property located
1:05:04 at 1662 Park View Drive for Castle Twin Falls,
1:05:08 LLC, Mitch Humble is making a presentation and it is not acres.
1:05:12 I want to repeat its feet, Mitch.
1:05:14 Yes, its feet.
1:05:17 This ordinance follows up a decision that we heard and made
1:05:21 on March 31st of this year.
1:05:24 After a public hearing, we approved the request
1:05:26 that they came this evening.
1:05:29 The vacation ordinance has been prepared.
1:05:31 We've received all the letters that we were waiting for last week
1:05:34 while we pulled it off the agenda, so we're ready to go tonight.
1:05:37 It is an ordinance and if you want to adopt it tonight, we do need to put out a third and final and leave the rules and all that good stuff, so any questions on it?
1:05:44 Thank you, Mitch. What's the ordinance number, Leila?
1:05:47 3069.
1:05:48 3069?
1:05:49 Yeah.
1:05:50 Thank you.
1:05:51 Greg Lanning.
1:05:52 Mayor Hall, I move that we suspend the rules and place ordinance 3069 on third and final by title only.
1:06:00 Second.
1:06:01 We have motion on floor by Greg Lanning, seconded by Chris talking into place.
1:06:05 Ordinance 3, 69 on third and final suspending the rules
1:06:10 Title only I said you did I was repeating it for my own sake anything further on that motion council
1:06:17 The other roll call vote, please. Don Hall. Yes, Chris Tockington. Yes, Rebecca Mills, Wica. Yes
1:06:24 Suzanne Hawkins. Yes, Sean Berriger. Yes, Jim on yes
1:06:29 Yes, motion passes 7 to 0 could you read the ordinance? Yeah
1:06:33 In ordinance of the mayor and the city council of the city of Twin Falls
1:06:37 I don't know they cating the rail property describe below
1:06:41 Providing for besting a title to the property so they cated
1:06:44 council wishes
1:06:47 Move approval of ordinance 30 69
1:06:51 Second I have a motion on the floor by Greg landing seconded by Sean burger to approve ordinance 30 69 anything further on the motion council
1:06:59 Lee either roll call vote, please. Chris talking ten. Yes
1:07:03 Yes. Rebecca Mills-Wiecka. Yes.
1:07:06 Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Sean Berriger. Yes. Jim Bond. Yes. Greg Lanthine. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Motion passes 7-0.
1:07:15 Next item on the agenda is a presentation regarding potential private property improvement
1:07:21 encroachments onto the city property. Mitchell Humboldt again. Welcome Mitch.
1:07:28 Thanks. Let's see if this is going to work for me.
1:07:31 Now pictures I can use the little thing or two, but I don't know if I have to do for your presentation.
1:08:16 So, all right.
1:08:19 You just have to hurry and wait longer.
1:08:22 So in December, we had a request, if you all remember, from a property owner to purchase about seven feet of property from the city,
1:08:30 because some of the improvements that were put on that lot by the prior owner had encroached on to the city's property next door.
1:08:38 up here is that property, the one that kind of started it all.
1:08:44 So the property to the left, you see kind of a blue line there.
1:08:48 The property to the left is a city retention pond,
1:08:50 a retention lot.
1:08:52 And then there was about seven feet or so
1:08:53 where they had a fence and some parking pads
1:08:55 that were put on the city's property.
1:09:00 In this case, we ended up granting easement to the owner
1:09:02 and then we're all happy and we have all moved on.
1:09:05 But back in December when this came up,
1:09:07 I think I put a staff report together that said this kind of thing has happened before
1:09:11 and it will probably happen again or some statement like that.
1:09:14 And I think the request from the council was, well, how often, where are they,
1:09:19 those kind of questions.
1:09:20 And so, what we've done is I've put together several slides here where we've done exactly
1:09:25 this kind of thing, we've just kind of zoomed in with an arrow photo on a property
1:09:28 that we believe, and I'm going to say it that way often we believe this is an encroachment
1:09:33 because without a survey of the property with a survey you're going out there
1:09:36 and finding some property pins.
1:09:37 And we don't know exactly because there's
1:09:39 some technical things with aerial photos and grids
1:09:42 and things like that.
1:09:44 We can identify pretty darn close to within a few feet.
1:09:50 In this case, we can see here that
1:09:52 looks like it's about seven feet-ish, maybe.
1:09:55 And when we go out with the survey, which we had in this case,
1:09:58 it was about seven feet.
1:09:59 So we got kind of close.
1:10:01 And as you move further away from the center of town,
1:10:03 that variance gets a little bit bigger and the bigger
1:10:06 of further you go. So what I'm going to show you is places that we feel are
1:10:10 encroachments. We won't be able to know for sure on the close ones until we get
1:10:15 out there and look exactly. And then we won't be able to tell you the extent
1:10:19 exactly until we get out there with a survey if that's where we decide to go
1:10:23 with it. But anyway my intent tonight was just to kind of show you these describe
1:10:29 what we're looking at and then move on to the next one. If you have questions
1:10:32 stop me. We can certainly try to talk about each one, but this one here is actually the
1:10:43 next street over from the one we just looked at. This is the other end of the same block
1:10:48 at paintbrush and trotter, and we think we have exactly the same thing going on here.
1:10:52 We have another retention lot. We think the fence, in this case, probably not anything more
1:10:57 than the fence, but the fence and maybe some landscaping inside the fence are actually
1:11:00 on city property. I mean, I guess this one's about three or four feet. This one is down
1:11:08 by the falls, the ticket booth. You can see kind of on the right side of the picture. There's
1:11:14 a home up. It's uphill actually from the ticket booth and this guy has got some things going
1:11:22 around in his backyard. There's no real improvements necessarily but just like a use of the property
1:11:29 I guess and if you'll agree, maybe not all of you, but some of you might remember we did a trade with this guy
1:11:37 Closer to the rim there you can see a little hot tub in the ground and that was on city property
1:11:42 We've we've accomplished a trade for that part of it
1:11:45 But but the rest of it stayed as city property and and it has still continues to use that little bit in the blue there
1:11:56 Was that the bitch
1:11:58 We were actually, our parking lot was partially on his property and his hot tub was on our
1:12:05 property.
1:12:06 Exactly.
1:12:07 Exactly.
1:12:08 Yeah.
1:12:09 And so we traded kind of a foot for foot sort of a thing out there.
1:12:11 And that's how far back we got when we traded foot for foot.
1:12:14 If we had kept going, we would have got maybe the rest of the encroachment taken care of.
1:12:20 But that's all the property we had that we were using of his for the parking lot.
1:12:28 This is just across the road from that same scenario and in this one this is a little this might be the most
1:12:36 Concerning one for me because there's actually very likely a part of this guy's house. That's on city property
1:12:44 And it's again just above the just above the ticket booth going down the cell phone falls
1:12:57 So this property here is at the south
1:13:02 east corner of
1:13:04 candy cane or Cascade Park. That court, I need a point area. Sorry.
1:13:10 That was point area. So this fenced in area here, is that a basketball court?
1:13:20 That's the basketball court there at Cascade Park. So there's a little bit of
1:13:24 encroachment here with fences again from the property owners to the east of the
1:13:29 park. And Cascade actually will look at more Cascade stuff. This is the other
1:13:35 side of the park. So in that case, I mean some of these, this is really old. Yeah, these
1:13:40 are old. These are not like 60s. Okay. When these happened. In fact, a lot of these so
1:13:44 far have been pretty old. So we'll get to the newer ones later. This keeps happening.
1:13:50 So this is on the west side of the park and this one's actually a bit more of an encroachment
1:13:55 than we saw on the other side where the backyard and the landscaping, the fencing is on to the
1:13:59 city property. Right here, this house that's just kind of covered up by the label there.
1:14:05 That one actually encroached pretty good too, but we did a land swap with that guy to fix
1:14:08 it like in the 70s, a while ago.
1:14:11 So we knew about it there.
1:14:13 We had a willing partner to kind of do something with, but the two on the south of that one didn't
1:14:19 get fixed at the time.
1:14:20 So there's still a pretty good encroaching going on there.
1:14:23 Okay, Mitch.
1:14:24 It's only 20 feet.
1:14:25 A question on these 19 slides.
1:14:27 In every case, there is private encroachment on city right away.
1:14:31 To some extent, yes.
1:14:33 Varying sorry city property. This isn't right away like um
1:14:38 Roadways, right? This is or parcels with with our bt numbers and things like that
1:14:44 Well, but it is public property publicly owned city owned property and
1:14:50 This deals with no circumstances where we're encroaching on private property all I'm showing you is private encroachments on city property
1:14:58 Thank you, right. I think maybe some of those do exist though, too
1:15:05 the flip side of them. Right, but that wasn't what we asked. So subject for another conversation.
1:15:15 Okay, so here we are. This is fairway of states. So this is the subdivision that is west of the
1:15:22 golf course, across Granby from the golf course. And you can see it's kind of not really easily
1:15:29 identified, but you can see kind of a strip through here where you can kind of see some lack of
1:15:33 of improvement, maybe a space between fences.
1:15:37 There's a drainage piece of property
1:15:40 that was dedicated to the city
1:15:41 that contains an underground drainage pipe
1:15:44 that carries drainage from the east end
1:15:48 of the subdivision to the retention pond
1:15:49 on the west end of the subdivision.
1:15:51 And for some reason that was dedicated to the city
1:15:54 and for some reason the city accepted it.
1:15:56 And now we have properties like this
1:16:00 that we have a difficult time maintaining
1:16:02 and doing something with.
1:16:04 And, but there's a pipe under the ground so we can just give it away, but in some places folks have actually landscaped across it or fenced across it or in those kinds of things.
1:16:13 And, and that's happened in a few cases here.
1:16:15 The blue ones are the part of those that we've highlighted here and here.
1:16:22 So, now we're working our way to actually that, that one was sort of when they were one from a hater 10 years ago, morning sun trail.
1:16:30 This is also, actually there's going to be several from the morning sun trails, this was a tricky one.
1:16:33 This is the trail that goes along the Cooley, that runs kind of north and south through
1:16:38 morning sun.
1:16:41 And there are several from the east side, homes on the east side of the trail that have encroached
1:16:48 with improvements into the trail property or where the HOA common kind of landscaping,
1:16:57 not necessarily an individual property owner has encroached into the trail right of way.
1:17:01 And some of these are probably not significant amount.
1:17:04 In fact, this one may be that when we get out there
1:17:06 with a survey, or it might not be an encroachment at all.
1:17:08 This is close enough to where it might be.
1:17:11 It's worth checking into maybe if we decide to do that.
1:17:15 And as we run on a trail, here's one
1:17:17 where you can see the fences are back here.
1:17:20 But there's been some improvements made out here.
1:17:22 These are improvements by, again, by the HOA.
1:17:25 And the HOA goes in there and takes care of it.
1:17:27 And maybe that's not that big of a deal after all.
1:17:31 Here's another one where we do see
1:17:34 Where the fence line comes in this way and part of the part of the trail property is actually in a backyard here
1:17:41 And then again with some of the common HOA type encroachment
1:17:45 All of these are long morning Sun trail again here more of the
1:17:58 Thank you mayor
1:18:00 If you could get back to the number 10, why the odd shape for city property?
1:18:07 I'm going to get this to come back and then I'll show that up for everybody.
1:18:11 So this weird triangle thing, I think there's, it's just probably a remnant left over from some original parcels and then the new plating kind of a thing going on there.
1:18:27 the property lot is going to be roughly that blue line.
1:18:34 So the homeowner's lot is pretty much a straight line here,
1:18:38 and then the remnant parcel kind of got lumped in with the trail
1:18:42 in a lot of places, and that's not totally uncommon for you to have that.
1:18:47 Right, so in most of these cases, I mean, it's not city property that we need
1:18:53 or need to utilize, it just is.
1:18:56 A lot of the ones that we've shown are park properties, right, and the trail one along
1:19:03 the Coulee is kind of a trail because the Coulee is there and they have to do something
1:19:07 with it, right?
1:19:08 So they put a trail made dedicated to the city and we actually have a trail plan that
1:19:12 shows a trail on the Coulee anyway, so it kind of works out beneficial for everybody
1:19:16 involved, and the homeowners get to have access to this trail.
1:19:19 It's a good deal.
1:19:21 The park with Cascade or Candy King Park.
1:19:24 Again, it's park property was city acquired like I said back in the 60s, I think it was.
1:19:31 And just over time, a fence gets put in and somebody misses the mark.
1:19:36 So unlike the retention areas where there's some utility to the property and
1:19:42 maybe the improvements create an issue, do you see any issues created by landscaping or
1:19:48 fences or things on the park or trailways?
1:19:52 the potential enjoyment of the public park by the public.
1:19:56 I mean, I'm going to show you another one up here.
1:19:58 I'm going to fast forward a little bit,
1:20:00 because this is a lot of the same kind of a thing, right?
1:20:02 So here's a pretty good one, where this guy is using
1:20:07 a North End here, probably 18 or so feet
1:20:11 in his backyard that is part of the trail property.
1:20:15 In fact, this guy's got some significant improvements
1:20:18 in the backyard.
1:20:18 I think you put in a bachie court, which Dennis got invited to go play, I think, right?
1:20:25 Yeah, he should get his head.
1:20:26 So there's some of that, and then another one, okay, so this tree right here is actually
1:20:35 a tree located on public property.
1:20:41 The homeowner actually called up Dennis and said why don't you guys come out and maintain
1:20:44 your tree?
1:20:45 It's on your property.
1:20:46 And when Dennis went out there walking up and down the trail,
1:20:50 what tree is he talking about?
1:20:51 There's no tree there.
1:20:52 That's in that guy's backyard.
1:20:54 Goes and talks to him and he takes him into the backyard
1:20:56 and says, that tree in my backyard is on your property.
1:21:01 And he's expecting us to maintain our tree in his backyard.
1:21:07 So there are issues like that that'll come up.
1:21:11 And really, again, the trails and the parks
1:21:13 are dedicated for the public at large.
1:21:15 In fact, I honestly would probably
1:21:17 have a bigger problem with the encroachment into park properties than the one that started
1:21:21 this all with the little 7 foot encroachment onto the retention property because really
1:21:26 that is, no, I mean it was outside the retention pond itself, right? So it didn't affect the actual
1:21:34 drainage capacity that is built into that facility. It has really no use for anybody except for
1:21:40 that person that has the fence and the parking pad on it. And here we potentially have use
1:21:46 for the public at large because they're park properties.
1:21:49 But in these small strips and stuff, I mean this one is larger so it makes more sense but
1:21:54 in the tiny strips or areas, I mean, is there really any utilitarian use for going in and making
1:22:03 a move there fence, move there, you know, I mean, how much can people really use that,
1:22:08 exactly how much more utility can a public get out of it?
1:22:12 I stop short and you guys know this because you've read it.
1:22:14 I stopped short of saying, here's what we should do about it,
1:22:17 because I don't know what we should do about it.
1:22:19 And you guys get paid the big bucks
1:22:21 to make those kind of decisions.
1:22:22 I would just curious on your take on that.
1:22:28 One potential, I know that Dennis and Fritz
1:22:30 had had this exact conversation.
1:22:32 And I think Fritz, I might be speaking through for you
1:22:34 a little bit on behalf here, but Fritz kind of said,
1:22:35 why don't we write them all letter and said,
1:22:37 hey, by the way, you're on our property.
1:22:38 We're not necessarily asking you to do anything,
1:22:40 but just to know.
1:22:42 and maybe that's a reasonable step.
1:22:46 Mitch, I have two lights, Schumburg.
1:22:51 Yeah, I was, let me see.
1:22:54 I think we're pretty much at the end of the pictures,
1:22:56 all right, they're all sort of trail pictures after that.
1:22:59 So go ahead.
1:23:02 So maybe a bit to what I think Rebecca was kind of getting
1:23:05 at too, so first of all, thanks for identifying these,
1:23:09 because I think I'm one who asked to.
1:23:11 And then maybe more of these, right?
1:23:13 There may be more of these, these are the ones that we thought we could find and see, but
1:23:18 I don't believe there are more.
1:23:21 So I guess my, I have two questions.
1:23:24 One is, what might this mean to us in the future, i.e. are we going to get the same kind
1:23:31 of a request that we had come through of him trying to sell my property, and I can't
1:23:36 because x, y, and z has happened.
1:23:40 So that's one question and then the second is, is the process that we used for this last one, this easement process, the solution to most of these?
1:23:52 Absolutely a potential solution. What might happen, I think, and I went back to this picture to kind of help illustrate that.
1:24:00 property owners sites to sell this house and somebody says I'm going to do a
1:24:07 title report on that and then they have a way in a minute like that corner of the
1:24:11 house is not on property that you own how can you sell that and then it will
1:24:15 become our problem if we don't try to do something about it earlier they're gonna
1:24:19 come to us much like Miss Real did I might be saying that wrong but back in
1:24:24 December saying can you help me fix my problem and maybe it's
1:24:30 appropriate to do an easement, maybe it's appropriate to say, get your fence off our property.
1:24:35 No, it's Mrs. Ronald's property.
1:24:37 Mrs. Raule, right?
1:24:39 And maybe we can't say get your house off our property.
1:24:42 That's a little harder to say.
1:24:45 But this property has been ours since the 30s, long before the house was built.
1:24:50 This was part of the original donation from the Adams for the park property at the Schonfals.
1:24:58 So potentially some significant problems, maybe not for us,
1:25:05 because honestly, area of photo doesn't show it real good,
1:25:09 but there's a pretty good cliff right here.
1:25:11 I mean, we don't really have a good way to access
1:25:13 this little blue strip of property for the use of the public,
1:25:18 even though it's part of the public park.
1:25:19 So maybe it's not a huge issue for us,
1:25:21 but it's going to be a problem for that guy someday
1:25:25 if he tries to sell his house.
1:25:27 And then we're going to be asked to help be part of the solution.
1:25:30 And for some other words, it might not be a big deal.
1:25:33 Some of the HOA type improvements along the trail and morning sun,
1:25:38 honestly, I can see that kind of being happening all day long
1:25:42 because it's somebody else landscaping and maintaining our trail property.
1:25:46 So we don't have to do it. Fantastic.
1:25:48 Yeah, I mean, to a certain extent,
1:25:51 it's beneficial maybe along those trails.
1:25:54 So you don't have a strip of kosher weed going between the trail
1:25:57 on the private property.
1:25:59 And in fact, and I don't show you these
1:26:01 because they're not really encroachments,
1:26:03 but we have a few properties along the Canyon Ren trail,
1:26:06 where we have my agreement kind of legitimized
1:26:10 exactly that thing with Canyon Crest,
1:26:13 because it's a good example where we have landscape.
1:26:15 Canyon Crest is landscaped and have improvements
1:26:17 right up to the trail.
1:26:19 And we allow them to do that,
1:26:21 and then they have agreed to maintain
1:26:22 and take care of the trail property there.
1:26:25 And so it's mutually beneficial.
1:26:28 So we're right in some cases, particularly
1:26:30 on those trail type things.
1:26:31 Maybe it's mutually beneficial.
1:26:34 The guy with the bocce court in his backyard
1:26:36 has something to lose or opens it up to the public.
1:26:41 And we have a public bocce court.
1:26:44 And maybe just one last question, then I'll
1:26:45 shut up because there are other lights.
1:26:47 The is really the only way to do this,
1:26:52 to find these, to just go hunting and packing for them?
1:26:58 Yeah, or wait for them to come up.
1:27:00 Here's what we did.
1:27:01 We have a GIS program.
1:27:03 And I don't know how to do this, but I know people that do.
1:27:06 So that's helpful.
1:27:08 They can get on the GIS program.
1:27:09 They can search for city parcels owned by city twin
1:27:13 falls or whatever other.
1:27:15 However, there's a few different ways
1:27:17 that shows up on the tax rules.
1:27:19 We can search for those.
1:27:20 And we can identify those.
1:27:21 we can kind of zoom into those and then we can look for this kind of stuff. But it is,
1:27:26 it is identifying our properties and then looking at each one to see if it, if there
1:27:30 is an encroachment. And then to actually figure out how bad it is, we'd have to actually go
1:27:36 out there with a crew, a survey crew and look for pins and things like that. It's going to
1:27:42 be kind of a complicated process to get them all addressed if that's where we go.
1:27:47 is talking to.
1:27:48 Kind of a legal question, Fritz.
1:27:50 When you have two adjacent properties, private properties, and one is inadvertently or purposefully
1:27:57 even using their neighbors, if you use it, you own it after a certain amount of time.
1:28:04 Does that apply here, and do we even probably have legitimate claim to any or all these
1:28:10 properties?
1:28:11 No, we own those properties, and they cannot be claimed as against us, because you can't
1:28:16 against public publicly owned private.
1:28:19 Not the same rules for public on private on the public.
1:28:22 That's right, the question.
1:28:24 Craig Manning.
1:28:27 Mitch, I think I probably concur with at least sending them
1:28:32 a letter and then maybe in that letter,
1:28:34 we explore with staff if you would like to come up some way,
1:28:41 especially the gentleman there, where he probably
1:28:42 houses on our property.
1:28:44 I would think he would want to figure out something with us.
1:28:47 Either buy that property from us or trade
1:28:48 for something or or something along that line. You may not even know. Yeah, he probably doesn't
1:28:54 know it would have been when he'd hate to have even decide he wants to sell and then he finds out.
1:28:58 Mrs. Rail. Rail didn't know. Right and things. So I so I would be supportive of at least contacting
1:29:06 these neighbors so that at least they are aware of it and things along that line. I had a second
1:29:12 part of my question and to be honest with you it went far enough. I totally lost to this point.
1:29:16 So, maybe I'll catch it later.
1:29:18 Rebecca, may I else like it?
1:29:19 Thank you, Mayor.
1:29:21 Quick question on this slide, number four.
1:29:24 Do we know when that house was built?
1:29:26 So, I just asked Mr. Wonderlick and he is saying
1:29:29 in the 50s or 60s.
1:29:31 Okay, so quite some time.
1:29:33 It wouldn't be in our records.
1:29:35 So, if we issued the permit,
1:29:36 I could tell you probably when it was built.
1:29:38 It was built long enough it go to,
1:29:39 and it's not in the city limits.
1:29:41 So, it predates our permitting for the area of impact.
1:29:46 Which brings you to my follow-up question, you know, more to Councillor
1:29:49 Beregor's point, how do we avoid this currently? What's our process now so that we
1:29:54 we don't have these issues? Is it GIS? Is it, you know, the title companies? How do we
1:29:59 properly permit private improvements? Well, for a home, we'll catch it when you submit a
1:30:07 building permit because we require a site plan for every building permit that comes
1:30:10 in and we'll look for setbacks and those kind of things. For fences, though, and
1:30:15 In line-scaping, we don't require permits,
1:30:17 unless your fence is taller than six feet, I think it's,
1:30:21 and then we'll require permit for it,
1:30:22 but most fences aren't taller than six feet.
1:30:24 So a lot of those kind of things in a botche court
1:30:26 and planning a tree, those kind of things don't,
1:30:29 they don't ever have to tell us they're doing it.
1:30:32 So unless we started re-re-re-re-re- permits for all fences,
1:30:36 that would be the way to have the city staff
1:30:39 kind of catch it, because we would look for property lines.
1:30:42 And even then, not necessarily to catch all of them,
1:30:45 because you don't always see a property corner pin
1:30:49 on the ground when you go out to put a fence down.
1:30:52 And sometimes you will, and sometimes we'll stick up
1:30:54 a few inches, but sometimes it's buried a few inches,
1:30:56 and sometimes it's removed.
1:30:58 And so it's a little bit of a guesswork.
1:31:02 But a lot of fence companies kind of do their best
1:31:07 to keep it on the lines.
1:31:09 Right, and it may be fair to say that maybe the buildings
1:31:14 are the larger issue, you know, when you build those buildings.
1:31:17 And maybe the landscaping, in a lot of cases,
1:31:21 actually does us a favor.
1:31:23 So I wouldn't mind sending a letter just
1:31:27 for their information as long as it's very clear.
1:31:29 This is just for your information.
1:31:31 We don't want to alarm anybody that they need to do anything.
1:31:33 But then, really, I envision dealing with it
1:31:36 on a case-by-case basis.
1:31:38 Because like you said, you know, depending
1:31:39 on the property owners need depending on the encroachment
1:31:45 and in what particular improvement it is.
1:31:48 You know, we may or may not need to address it.
1:31:51 Sean Berger.
1:31:53 I was just gonna suggest too that perhaps talking to
1:31:57 at HOA's, so for example, I live in Morningsun,
1:32:01 I don't live along the trail, but so I know
1:32:06 when my house came in, it went through
1:32:08 the building permit process,
1:32:09 but when I went to do my fence,
1:32:11 I actually had to submit to the Homeowners Association
1:32:13 a site plan for my fence and landscape improvements.
1:32:16 So I wonder if some communication
1:32:18 with the various HOAs as well,
1:32:21 simply to make them aware of the potential
1:32:24 that this might happen at that point,
1:32:27 that maybe they could be maybe a little less concerned
1:32:31 about what color the slats on the wood are gonna be
1:32:33 and a little more concerned about
1:32:34 where the posts get stuck actually is.
1:32:37 Just a suggestion.
1:32:41 Well, I know on fences, I mean, I know of some people that were building out Settler's
1:32:47 Ridge, which is a brand new subdivision that already has the fences installed.
1:32:51 And when they turned their site plan into the city, the city went out to check.
1:32:56 And because things just weren't matching up, one fence had to be moved 18 feet.
1:33:01 That's how far the fence people, in the corner.
1:33:04 In other words, it went on a wrong angle.
1:33:06 The back corner was on a wrong angle.
1:33:09 I could probably pick the wrong pins.
1:33:11 Right, probably one for the lot behind it, probably, or something.
1:33:14 So I can see how these mistakes could be made,
1:33:16 but I also feel like we, at some point, you don't want to end up like,
1:33:20 and I'll use the gentleman's name because he's been carried
1:33:25 a gentleman from North Idaho when he didn't build a house on state property,
1:33:28 just because he didn't figure anybody was going to stop him,
1:33:31 and he was a state senator.
1:33:32 And so at some point, you decide you've got to go ahead and protect your property
1:33:38 to a certain degree, but I like the letter letting him know it's occurring and then anything
1:33:43 like the house, obviously, we probably have to see something coming through on that unless
1:33:49 he doesn't care until he builds and we don't make him, because I don't see us making him
1:33:52 tear it down. So like the house out towards that we had to move, they keep the street
1:34:00 because they missed the pen and you can see exactly how they did. They got the wrong pen.
1:34:06 We got the whole pin on the wrong side of the street.
1:34:08 I can measure the wrong pin.
1:34:12 Anything further council?
1:34:14 Anything further from you, Mitch?
1:34:15 Do you have some guidance?
1:34:17 For like from you or you?
1:34:18 Yeah, I think we're good.
1:34:21 We'll go start drafting some letters.
1:34:24 Very good.
1:34:25 I'm ready to go.
1:34:26 Thank you.
1:34:27 Councilor, it's 6.30, so I'm going to take a five minute break.
1:34:31 Tammy, can I talk to you?
1:34:33 Tammy.
1:41:22 We're reconvening the Twin Falls City Council
1:41:24 meeting for Monday, April 21st, 2014, moving on to the next item under items of consideration.
1:41:33 And that is consideration of a request to amend Twin Falls City, amended Transparency Resolution
1:41:40 1912.
1:41:41 Fritz Wonderlet.
1:41:42 We've talked about this at the last council meeting, this arose because occasionally, a
1:41:54 Quorum of the City Council may appear at a meeting actually sponsored by someone else
1:42:00 under the existing transparency ordinance. You can't do it unless you can stream the meeting.
1:42:07 So what you have before you as a second amended transparency resolution, you'll see a change
1:42:13 in section four that applies another exception to the streaming and video recording requirement.
1:42:22 The existing exceptions are council executive sessions,
1:42:27 airport advisory commission meetings,
1:42:30 economic development ready team, and youth council.
1:42:33 This would add one more, a quorum of the city council
1:42:37 attending a meeting held by another entity.
1:42:40 So this would, for example, the economic development ready team
1:42:44 meeting next week.
1:42:46 If a quorum of you, four or more of you happen to want
1:42:49 to attend that, it's not your meeting,
1:42:51 but you'd be allowed to do that without us
1:42:55 streaming requirement.
1:42:59 That's it.
1:43:00 Thank you for it.
1:43:01 Any questions?
1:43:03 Any direction?
1:43:05 Council?
1:43:05 Chris talking.
1:43:06 I would move to Selma and then to get friends
1:43:09 from the 2012 so described changes.
1:43:15 Second?
1:43:16 We have motion on the floor by Chris talkington.
1:43:18 Seconded by Jim Mon to make the amendments
1:43:21 as presented by our city attorney this evening.
1:43:24 Anything further on that motion?
1:43:26 Council. The aye the roll call vote please.
1:43:29 Rebecca Milsweka. Yes.
1:43:31 Suzanne Hopkins. Yes.
1:43:33 Sean Berger. Yes.
1:43:35 Jim Mundt. Yes.
1:43:36 Greg Lantine. Yes.
1:43:37 Don Hall. Yes.
1:43:39 Chris Hoppington. Yes.
1:43:41 Motion passes. Seven to zero.
1:43:43 Moving on to the next item presentation by the city manager,
1:43:47 followed by general discussion and public input about the city's
1:43:52 Council's fiscal year, 2015 budget, priorities and philosophies.
1:43:58 Our city manager, welcome.
1:43:59 Travis?
1:44:00 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, tonight I'm going to go through a semi-abbreediated version
1:44:07 of the presentation that I gave to you last week.
1:44:10 And I will highlight some of the changes and updated information that we have in this process.
1:44:15 But really, to kind of set the stage, this is the second public conversation that we've
1:44:21 had about our budgeting process for the fiscal year 2015 that will begin on October 1st of
1:44:27 2014, run through September 30th of 2015. After these conversations and the conversations
1:44:34 that I've had independently with you, the information that you've received from the long-term planning
1:44:40 group, we will then go into a series of budgetary conversations internally to really begin to
1:44:45 construct those budgets and what they look like. We are then scheduled to come back to
1:44:49 on June 2nd to share with you what we believe were the thoughts, the comments, the opportunities
1:44:56 to really move forward and to see what strategic planning objectives have been able to move forward
1:45:06 and go forward in the upcoming fiscal year.
1:45:09 So just as we do at every one of these conversations we started out with the mission statement, I
1:45:14 think it's really good reminder because this is why we are here. This describes our role and what we
1:45:21 are supposed to do. The other thing is we talked about linking our strategic plan and our budget and
1:45:29 our mission into a full package. And so as we've gone forward as you know we spent well over a year
1:45:38 really working, creating a strategic plan.
1:45:41 We've had a couple of, I think, very good presentations
1:45:45 with more to follow at the beginning of May,
1:45:48 where we've taken conversations with our shareholders,
1:45:50 our stakeholders, our partners, internal and external,
1:45:53 and we've began to talk about how we want to move forward.
1:45:57 And we highlight our strengths.
1:45:58 We look and recognize our opportunities to grow.
1:46:01 We identify those areas that need a level of enhancement,
1:46:05 whether that be from funding or just peer service,
1:46:08 are in efficiency and we develop a comprehensive vision for the community.
1:46:12 So by linking our resources strategically, the strategic plan drives our budgeting processes.
1:46:20 In budgeting our processes, we ask that it kind of fit within these eight areas.
1:46:25 The first seven that appear really talk about those community partnerships and then this
1:46:31 plan is unique in the fact that it recognizes the value and the importance of our city employees
1:46:37 because it has a section about the internal organization.
1:46:41 The long-term planning committee then made a presentation
1:46:44 to you that we talked about and celebrated last week
1:46:48 on the 31st, and in this, they talked about the need
1:46:53 for hiring talent into our organization
1:46:55 to meet the anticipated workloads and opportunities
1:46:59 as we continue to grow and as we continue to expand.
1:47:02 They talked about dressing facility needs.
1:47:04 We took tours of our buildings, took tours of our facilities
1:47:08 to really accommodate the staff and the public.
1:47:11 They talked about investing in equipment and technology
1:47:14 so that we had the opportunity to create better processes
1:47:18 and to deliver better outcomes.
1:47:20 They talked and made sure that we are continuing
1:47:22 to keep pace in providing the most current of equipment
1:47:27 so that as it went out of its useful life
1:47:29 that we had the opportunity to replace it
1:47:31 to continue to be efficient.
1:47:33 And then always and importantly, we want to make sure that we're employing new technologies,
1:47:38 new best practices, new opportunities that we can learn from both public and private partners
1:47:44 on how we can deliver better services to our citizens.
1:47:49 We do that through the review of performance measurement system.
1:47:51 That report has been submitted to the Center for Performance Management and we are anticipating
1:47:56 results to occur to be included in this year's budgets as well as having a citizen survey.
1:48:03 We are out surveying and sampling with our citizens, and again, we anticipate those results
1:48:08 coming within probably the next six weeks.
1:48:11 Once those results are available, we will present them.
1:48:14 We've often said that the budgeting is the lifeblood of government, because really what
1:48:18 we're doing is we're mobilizing financial resources, time, talent, energy, and we're turning that
1:48:24 into a tangible collection of services.
1:48:27 In that, we want to make sure that what we do is balanced,
1:48:31 that is fiscally responsible, and is something that we can sustain long term.
1:48:37 Many cities across this country over the course of the Great Recession
1:48:42 found that their levels of services were not sustainable
1:48:46 because of the impacts and the causes of the global economy and their local economy.
1:48:51 We in the city of Twin Falls have been able to be strong both financially and in our
1:48:56 process because I think of the foundation that was set by Tom Courtney and others before him,
1:49:01 that we really do follow conservative processes when we go into budgeting.
1:49:07 We want to make sure that we are carrying out the basic responsibilities that's public
1:49:11 health, public safety, enhancing quality of life, doing what we can to spur continued
1:49:18 economic growth, recognizing that that is where probably some of our greatest partnerships
1:49:23 occur.
1:49:24 We recognize that our budgets again need to be sustainable and that there is a direct
1:49:30 correlation between a level of funding and a level of service delivery in most cases.
1:49:36 And so we want to be cognizant of that link to ensure that there is not a disconnect between
1:49:43 the amount of funding that we're able to provide and the level of service that we're
1:49:47 expecting or anticipating we can deliver.
1:49:51 So when we go through this process, we started some very unique items here.
1:49:57 Our budgeting process is very, very inclusive.
1:50:00 In fact, it now involves every single member of our department leadership as well as individuals and
1:50:09 supporting staffs prior to where we come and we have a conversation and talk about the overall budget collectively as a leadership team as opposed to individually.
1:50:20 Some of the members of the senior staff are here,
1:50:23 and when we have those conversations, they are robust,
1:50:26 and they include upwards of 30-ish people
1:50:31 that are in the room talking and vetting and moving forward.
1:50:34 And there is conversation also about inviting the members
1:50:37 of the long-term planning committee to that.
1:50:40 From that process, we are creating a much more robust,
1:50:43 much more thoughtful budgeting document than one,
1:50:46 if I were just to develop it in a vacuum.
1:50:49 So from that and from this budgeting for outcomes,
1:50:52 we take a look at making sure that strategic planning objectives
1:50:56 can be met.
1:50:58 And through that process, we are making sure
1:51:00 that we are trying to find opportunities to engage
1:51:02 our citizens.
1:51:03 Tonight is that opportunity.
1:51:04 Last week was that opportunity that some took advantage of.
1:51:09 This process has allowed us to transform our government
1:51:12 and engage our employees just like I talked about.
1:51:14 And then it also brings an element of common sense
1:51:16 to our budgeting process.
1:51:17 that element of common sense is because of the collective talents that are there.
1:51:24 So last year, we went through a very, very similar process, and these were the defined
1:51:30 broad range goals that were created that were hoping to provide some generalized level of
1:51:36 direction from you as we began the internal next step in this process.
1:51:42 You can see that there are continued implementation of the strategic planning objectives.
1:51:47 We had conversations about limited tax increases to the statutory allowed and then also being
1:51:51 recognized that the levels of fees were also important because our citizens usually have
1:51:57 just one checkbook when they're writing out their water bill utility bills and their property
1:52:02 taxes.
1:52:03 But we wanted to make sure that we were continuing to move forward with the compensation strategy
1:52:07 that was implemented prior.
1:52:09 We wanted to make sure that we are finding ways to enhance our water system and infrastructure,
1:52:14 specifically mentioned was water redundancy, and again, that pursuit of being more efficient and more effective.
1:52:21 This is an example of a side-by-side comparison of what the budgets look like in total taxable value.
1:52:28 We are anticipating a total taxable value slightly larger, but we're not expecting that thing to rise astronomically.
1:52:36 We do not believe that we're going to see an increase or return to values that we saw in 2009 right away.
1:52:44 It will be a slow, steady trend, but this is an example of a side-by-side comparison of the net budgets that were collected,
1:52:51 the total taxes that were collected, and the taxable and the tax rate per 1,000 value inside the city of Flint Falls.
1:52:59 This is a graphical comparison of the different budgets that we have passed since 2007.
1:53:05 The blue reflux, those enterprise funds, those that we charge the respective fees for.
1:53:11 Green represents the property tax dollars that we have collected.
1:53:16 What's important to note in the enterprise funds as they have grown, it has not necessarily
1:53:23 grown because we are putting more money into ongoing maintenance activities.
1:53:28 It has grown because we have taken on significant levels of debt to make significant capital improvements
1:53:37 to both water and wastewater systems.
1:53:40 That does not take away the need to continue to find additional monies and additional resources
1:53:45 to continue to put more pipes in the ground to make sure that the levels of service to
1:53:52 those different areas of our community fit the demand and the growth of potentials.
1:53:58 Question of the vote.
1:53:59 But this does not have also included the addition of your array funding for city infrastructure.
1:54:04 Yes, so we don't budget anything for urban renewal.
1:54:07 That's correct.
1:54:13 So last week I talked about the different statutory options that you would have available and this is pretty easy math.
1:54:20 If you take a look at the $17,200,000 roughly that we collected,
1:54:26 an additional 3% on that might equal just shy of $520,000.
1:54:33 We're estimating that, and again, the construction roll right at this point in time is very much a level best
1:54:40 Yes, we'll get a better number from the county assessor over the course of the next few weeks as we go through this process.
1:54:47 But 22 million is probably a good, safe number for the total numbers of new values coming onto our system.
1:54:55 If you take the 3% of the new construction, we're estimating amount just shy of $700,000.
1:55:01 And then the city's foregone balance is $179,000.
1:55:06 That foregone balance remains intact and will remain unchanged unless the specific action
1:55:11 is taken by the city council.
1:55:13 If you elect not to take 3% or the new construction, that will grow.
1:55:18 You at any point that the legislature has the code allowance there, you can take that foregone
1:55:25 to incorporate moving forward.
1:55:27 It is not a retro-tax, it does not cause tax issues and the rear is just moving forward.
1:55:37 So this gives you an example of some of the probably
1:55:40 literally maybe hundreds of different
1:55:42 of options that you may have as we move forward,
1:55:47 ranging from having a total increase of $176,000
1:55:53 if you only took the growth formula to $2,174,000
1:55:58 if you took foregone as well as 3% moving forward.
1:56:05 We often talk about what's the cost of doing business
1:56:09 and how does that compare.
1:56:10 We want to be cognizant of that.
1:56:13 And so when we take a look at the municipal cost index,
1:56:16 it's important that we recognize that that impact
1:56:20 has gone up a bit.
1:56:23 Building permit activity.
1:56:24 Revenues are up 47%,
1:56:26 but I think that takes just a minute to talk about
1:56:30 because we assessed a new fee at the beginning
1:56:35 of this process, it's a plan review fee, that we dedicate those funds to a plan reviewer.
1:56:41 So that does not necessarily mean that that 47% increase in revenue is just going unaccounted
1:56:48 for.
1:56:49 It was a deliberate step that we took to get an additional body to help our building department
1:56:54 out.
1:56:56 If you look at the total permits, all permits through March were up 10.8%.
1:57:04 If you take a look at residential, they're up one and a half commercial models, 8.9.
1:57:11 Miscellaneous was up 31 percent, electrical 11, mechanical 10, plumbing 2.
1:57:18 And then if you take a look at commercial, it's down 44 percent.
1:57:23 What's important to recognize is that we do separate commercial remodel permits,
1:57:27 which is individuals taking advantage of existing spaces and making improvements and
1:57:32 to those spaces and facilities, as opposed to starting construction from that ground up.
1:57:39 The new commercial piece we anticipate will continue to move forward.
1:57:44 We've had conversations, but it does not appear that we will see a significant commercial season this year
1:57:51 by comparison to what we've had in prior years.
1:57:55 This gives you an idea of the value of the work that is there.
1:58:00 The value of the work is important because that helps determine future-anticipated new
1:58:06 construction values.
1:58:08 So when you take a look at the single family, you can see that the values of those total
1:58:13 permits for the year is up about 12.5 percent.
1:58:18 But what's important to remember is not all of that value is considered taxable.
1:58:23 If it is owner occupied, it is probably a safe bet that at least about half of that value
1:58:31 goes into property taxes, the other would be applied to a homeowner's exemption.
1:58:36 However, when you take a look at a new commercial activity, you can see that the values there
1:58:41 are significantly lower, but just below that, you can see that the commercial remodel is
1:58:47 up 262%.
1:58:49 When you add the total commercial activity of both the remodel and the new commercial,
1:58:53 we are about at the same pace in terms of total taxable value and value to our community
1:58:59 that we were the prior year, with a total increase of about 15.2%.
1:59:03 Again, this is information compiled by our building department, and it is good through
1:59:09 March 31st.
1:59:10 The next report will come out sometime in the first week of May.
1:59:15 So again, back to the Municipal Constance Index, just real quick reflection, it's about 1.8%
1:59:21 this year over last by comparison, the CPI is about 1.1%.
1:59:29 This is based upon February information.
1:59:32 If you take a look at just to keep up with inflation, that increase of new monies that
1:59:36 we need to bring into the system is about $952,000.
1:59:41 That is to keep dollar for dollar moving forward.
1:59:45 That $952,000 does not do any advancements in our compensation piece for our employees, which I believe is important.
1:59:53 It does not do anything as we move forward for additional fleet maintenance or fleet repair.
2:00:00 It assumes that we will replace the same number in the same types of vehicles as we move forward on an annual basis.
2:00:07 We have broke those out generally.
2:00:09 would be a $565,000 increase needed in the tax supported funds and a $387,000 increase
2:00:19 needed in the collective enterprise funds.
2:00:24 Property tax values, again, we believe that we started to see some level of increase and
2:00:29 we believe that that's going to continue this year.
2:00:32 That's based upon conversations that I've had with some of the individuals who are in real
2:00:38 state in that marketplace. What's important is our tax year often likes behind and so
2:00:44 when the housing values were beginning to slide you'll remember in 2011 we were surprised
2:00:51 to see them still very much afloat and that was because we're in the rear. That's right
2:00:57 and so kind of like on that caboose you're last to go down the hill but that means you're
2:01:03 last to begin to climb out. So we're starting to see some return and one good
2:01:09 place to recognize that is in the homeowners exemption which is indexed to
2:01:14 all state values and the homeowners exemption according to the Idaho State
2:01:19 Tax Commission is going to go up 3.6 percent. So the maximum value is going to
2:01:23 go from $81,000 to $83,920 or 50 percent whichever is the lower of the two. This
2:01:31 This is a reflection of what has occurred globally in the Idaho housing market.
2:01:36 You can see in 2009, it reached a peak of nearly $104,500.
2:01:43 And last year, it was the low since they began indexing them.
2:01:49 Prior to 2005, it was always 50,000 or 50%, whichever was last.
2:01:56 the first hurdle went up to 75 and then thereafter it was indexed.
2:02:02 This is new information.
2:02:04 This just came out on Friday and it reflects where we're at in terms of unemployment.
2:02:09 You can see about a 90 basis point improvement on the overall employment from last year this
2:02:18 time, we did gain about a tenth of unemployment from 5.1 in February 2014 to 5.2.
2:02:31 You can see that we're on par with both the state as well as the nation.
2:02:36 One of the things as we shared last time is it was the fewest, the federal government
2:02:41 had reported the fewest number of new first time families going for unemployment benefits
2:02:47 since 2007, and that is a sign of maybe things that are occurring nationally.
2:02:56 This is not a very good slide, I apologize for that.
2:03:00 But basically what this is is our financial dashboard, because one of the things that
2:03:03 I think is often not spoke about is the opportunity to maybe apply cash reserves to one-time projects.
2:03:14 It is a complete recipe for financial disaster for local governments or any government or even our own personal household incomes to apply one-time money to ongoing expenses.
2:03:25 But there may be real opportunity to apply some of the cash that we have to support some of the one-time projects that have been discussed by this council and discussed by members of the community.
2:03:40 will say that we do not have enough money to do it all. Even if you take all of the
2:03:46 cash reserves, we probably do not have enough liquid cash to be able to do everything that
2:03:54 we may want to do or the community may want for us to do. And that is why we go through
2:04:00 these processes to really allocate dollars to the highest and best use opportunities.
2:04:06 This is a copy of the dashboard. Cited in E-31
2:04:07 It is available online.
2:04:10 We'll get copies, we'll email copies out to members of the council, but any member of our
2:04:14 citizen can go take a look at our dashboard every single month, and they can reflect upon
2:04:19 the levels of cash or levels of investment and checkbook in terms of how we move and expand
2:04:25 cash and the advancement of our strategic plan and the day-to-day activities to support the
2:04:31 supplying of local goods and services.
2:04:35 So I'm going to quickly go forward and talk about some of the things that I believe to
2:04:39 be priorities or should be considered, hopefully priorities.
2:04:44 And again, like I shared last week, these are not necessarily of my own thought, but several
2:04:49 of these came from conversations with many of you.
2:04:52 In fact, many of you had approached me after and said, wow, you got my whole list.
2:04:57 And I said, well, that was hopefully the idea from having the conversation, but I was able
2:05:01 to include, at least most of what was on my mind with yours and to really kind of bring
2:05:08 that together.
2:05:09 So obviously we want to continue to make advances in the strategic plan.
2:05:13 We want to move that document forward as we recognize where we want to be by the year
2:05:18 2030.
2:05:19 It's almost like a spiral staircase that every year we're going to continue to hopefully
2:05:23 hinge a little bit closer to the vision that is created by the community for the year 2030
2:05:29 or our planning horizon.
2:05:31 And we want to make sure that we're following probably the long-term planning's sentiment
2:05:39 that we may have bitten off a little bit more than we could chew in this little first section
2:05:46 of the strategic plan.
2:05:47 And if you go back and look at it, if this truly is a 17-year document, and 85% of the
2:05:53 things that we want to do are accomplished in the first five years, it might be a bit
2:05:59 offset.
2:06:00 The other thing we always said about the strategic plan was it was not cast in stone.
2:06:08 It was designed to be reflecting of an ever-changing environment that some things that may be priority
2:06:16 once today may be able to be shifted because they're not as critical as what we were believing
2:06:23 they were when we were having a conversation 18 months ago.
2:06:28 Next is the case that there are always emerging issues and concerns that may come up depending
2:06:34 upon a never changing landscape or request from our community.
2:06:39 So we will continue to fund all of the strategic planning objectives that we possibly can and
2:06:44 we certainly want to fund those things that are considered ongoing.
2:06:48 We want to continue to build those collaborative partnerships with all of our community partners
2:06:52 and I think that we have some really good opportunities to do that.
2:06:56 But building those collaborative partnerships takes a resource of talent, and it also takes
2:07:01 a resource of time.
2:07:02 And I think that is important to recognize that as we work to create a more sustainable
2:07:07 twin falls, which is a great product that we'll talk about a little bit later during the managers
2:07:13 report, or looking to expand our local economy or activate the Magic Valley, which is maybe
2:07:18 another possibility that is very much in its infancy.
2:07:23 We have the opportunity to collaborate, but the resources that we take and bring to those
2:07:27 meetings require us to be able to justify that time here as opposed to spending it over here.
2:07:36 I believe that we need to continue to invest in our employees to ensure that we're providing
2:07:41 competitive compensation and benefits of advanced training opportunities.
2:07:47 Really those best practices are born by our employees.
2:07:49 They're born by our employees when we give them the opportunities to expose themselves to
2:07:53 new ideas and new opportunities. So, training our employees, I believe, is something that
2:07:58 we need to continue to do. I believe that we need to continue to provide a level of compensation
2:08:05 that resembles what other organizations are doing so that we can keep up with the marketplace,
2:08:11 but also that it is reflective of the efforts that they give day in and day out. This council
2:08:18 said that we wanted to essentially be an employer of choice, that we weren't necessarily satisfied
2:08:23 with just being average and among the others. I think that comes in this how internal aspect,
2:08:32 that entire section 8 of our strategic plan and how we're able to move forward with that.
2:08:39 We shared with you that it is important to continue to move that competition plan forward
2:08:44 even incrementally on an annual basis so that we do not fall into the same tracks that we
2:08:50 have fallen into in the past.
2:08:53 And then also one of the things that I think that we need to pay particular attention to
2:08:57 this year is compression ratio adjustments for more tenured employees in our organization.
2:09:05 We did a really good job in the beginning of building a compression ratio adjustment and
2:09:10 And we moved that starting wage forward.
2:09:15 And we set a market number at 10 years.
2:09:18 And we said that was a first step with every year hoping to slide that down, ultimately reaching
2:09:25 five.
2:09:26 This year we hope to reach five.
2:09:29 Because what is happening is those employees with five or more years of experience are the
2:09:33 ones that we are hoping that will lead our organization and we need to do what we can,
2:09:39 least from a financial perspective to make it difficult for them to leave.
2:09:44 I recognize and I think many of the members of the team behind us recognize that compensation
2:09:51 is not the only reason why employees stay or why they leave.
2:09:56 But if we can make it more difficult and remove that from that process, I think we'll be better
2:10:03 off.
2:10:05 We need to continue to find ways to invest in our infrastructure.
2:10:10 well as our facilities and I kind of lump those two items into what I would refer to as deferred
2:10:17 maintenance. Over a long period of time we have deferred maintenance on assets and that
2:10:25 deferred maintenance on our assets eventually comes home to roost. And several years ago
2:10:33 members of the council recognized the conditions of our roadway and they significantly elevated
2:10:39 the funding and enhanced roadway dollars.
2:10:43 We recognized last year that water redundancy was something of importance and we invested
2:10:49 cash reserves in water redundancy.
2:10:52 We followed that up within our Cliffbar commitment of paying a proportionate share of an additional
2:10:59 water tank and facility.
2:11:01 We have made a commitment towards enhancing the safety and reliability of our water system.
2:11:07 And we're about to make a $38 million investment in our wastewater treatment plant system, a wastewater
2:11:14 collections and treatment system, $32 million approximately for a wastewater treatment plant,
2:11:21 $6 million for collection lines and systems.
2:11:27 And then our structures.
2:11:30 We've talked at the last budget about the importance of sharing and creating quality locker rooms
2:11:37 and meeting spaces for our police employees, that in every single one of our buildings today,
2:11:44 we are at capacity.
2:11:46 That the ability to create synergistic opportunities with people spread out in different areas can
2:11:56 be challenging, and one of the things that we want to do is try to find a long-term solution
2:12:01 that allows us to bring everybody that we possibly can
2:12:06 under a single roof.
2:12:08 I think it provides much better customer service
2:12:11 as a one-stop shop, but I believe it will also help provide us
2:12:15 for the next 50-year solution in terms of our facilities
2:12:18 of what that is.
2:12:20 And we say does it really last 50 years?
2:12:23 The building that we're in right now, I can't remember
2:12:26 who, but was it Sean I believe provided a brochure
2:12:29 from 1961 that talked about the new city hall.
2:12:34 And so it was new in 1961 and I think it has some really good bones to be remodeled,
2:12:40 but it is really not large enough for future opportunities.
2:12:47 And then last week and I kind of, we had a whole series of different conversations that
2:12:51 occurred.
2:12:52 We had one group for the record that really came forward during that budget process like
2:12:57 like they did last year, and that's the Magic Valley Trail Enhancement Committee.
2:13:00 And talk about a really good group that's fired up.
2:13:02 They are just both personally as well as financially invested in the expansion of our trail system,
2:13:12 and what's really good about them, like they shared, is we don't just come with a handout or a request.
2:13:18 We are here also bringing skin into the game and moving forward, and we heard a lot of their exciting projects.
2:13:25 And then investing in our facilities was not necessarily said during the budget process,
2:13:29 but it was right before that, where we had collections of individuals from members of
2:13:34 the community talk about the need to look at facilities as a chance for something to
2:13:42 do, so I included that here just because it was mentioned.
2:13:49 So really now it's your opportunity to provide us that guidance, the members of the team
2:13:54 are here, we're here to answer questions and the first question that has not been forgotten.
2:13:59 What is health care? What is the Affordable Care Act possibly going to do to health insurance?
2:14:04 And so Mr. Mayor, members of the council, if it's okay before we get into the thoughts,
2:14:08 I thought I'd turn a little bit of time over to Susan Harris.
2:14:10 Okay.
2:14:11 We're sprups.
2:14:19 The bus is up here.
2:14:20 They're showing you.
2:14:21 Yes.
2:14:22 I thought here in the headlight came to my mind.
2:14:26 There you go.
2:14:27 Welcome, Susan.
2:14:28 Thank you.
2:14:29 Thank you.
2:14:30 Actually, I'm going to attend an Affordable Care Act seminar tomorrow afternoon, so I'll
2:14:36 probably have more specifics that I can present when we do our department updates.
2:14:43 Right now, obviously, there's a schedule that's been put out by the Affordable Care
2:14:50 Act.
2:14:51 2015, we will have to start complying with, I think, some more regulations that will impact
2:14:59 us as an organization. Obviously, we've had the change that included covering dependence
2:15:08 up until age 26. We've had the preventable care coverage that has come into play. But
2:15:17 In 2015, we will really see some things.
2:15:21 There are fees that have to be paid.
2:15:24 They've transferred through our carrier,
2:15:28 and they will apply to our group.
2:15:31 Obviously, the premium will increase to provide coverage
2:15:37 for the limitations that are being taken off healthcare.
2:15:43 And so, we'll see some impacts,
2:15:46 But at this point, to give you an actual amount, I can't do that.
2:15:53 I think last year when Blue Cross quoted us, they said that there was about a 2% to 3% premium
2:16:01 increase that they were recommending to address affordable care act issues.
2:16:06 You were speaking in 2015, you referred to that in our upcoming budget year then, not
2:16:12 calendar 2015.
2:16:14 Well, in calendar year 2015, we'll have reporting requirements that have to be provided to the
2:16:25 government.
2:16:26 We will have some situations where we may have, currently, people we consider seasonal, if they
2:16:33 work so many hours a week for an extended period of time, we will actually have to be providing
2:16:38 coverage.
2:16:39 years starts three months earlier, we're still covered under most of that upcoming, okay.
2:16:46 But I will have some more information and some updates later on as we get into the budget.
2:16:54 Okay. Thank you, Susan. So as the agenda item said, it was going to be a presentation by
2:17:07 our city manager, followed by general discussion, philosophies, thoughts from the council, but
2:17:14 said public input as well. And I don't, did you want to come up?
2:17:19 Shorty, did you want to come up and visit with us about the
2:17:21 budget? You certainly can. I'm not trying to call you. But what
2:17:25 I'm just trying to highlight for folks listening at home that we
2:17:28 don't have public here tonight, and we would love to have public
2:17:31 here. And there's seven of us are always available. So please
2:17:35 contact us. This is I dare say the most important thing that we
2:17:39 do as a city council representing you as the public is set this
2:17:44 budget because it sets the guidelines and the direction and funding streams of what the
2:17:52 citizens would like in their city government. So with that being said, I'm going to open up for City Council. Chris, talking
2:18:00 well, and she well stated the dollars drive everything. And I think at some point the council needs to come to a consensus to
2:18:09 to relate to the city manager and the staff
2:18:12 of the they all important, 3% in growth and foregone.
2:18:18 And I don't suggest we make sausage tonight on that,
2:18:22 but I think that is personally what I see the priority
2:18:25 to give guidance to the council, to the city's manager.
2:18:30 Thank you, Chris.
2:18:31 Greg Lanning.
2:18:32 And I would agree with Chris,
2:18:34 they would go with under again.
2:18:37 But obviously that's one of the things
2:18:39 if they would need to know as soon as possible for them to fit the budget.
2:18:43 I think he's ever since made out of the blueprint for us some of the needs of those particular
2:18:52 funds and we always kind of like to hedge on a little bit and see what it's going to cost
2:18:58 and what does it do to our, based on our final numbers, what does it do to that monthly rate
2:19:07 or that yearly rate per thousand that we look at so closely.
2:19:12 We may not know that for a little while,
2:19:13 but I'm the one, you know, I don't know about making sausage
2:19:17 with fish, but we have a lot of priorities.
2:19:20 We, as a council and we included it,
2:19:24 and even previous council, we maybe,
2:19:28 we starved the horse a little at times
2:19:30 when we felt we were, it was necessary,
2:19:32 and I would be in favor of taking the new growth
2:19:35 and the expansion.
2:19:37 John Barrier.
2:19:38 So I'll just make a general comment that I think comes at that from the exact opposite
2:19:46 side but gets around there too.
2:19:49 I think as we look at some of the priorities we've laid out, we do need to be thinking about
2:19:54 what it costs to provide that level of service and I think approaching it that way as opposed
2:20:01 to here is how much money we can put in the pot.
2:20:04 How do we spend that?
2:20:06 So if we look at some of these generalized priorities,
2:20:08 I mean, the strategic plan in and of itself
2:20:10 is a lot of very ambitious investments
2:20:15 in people and projects that helped drive the service.
2:20:22 People, staff, was a theme we heard
2:20:24 from the long-term planning committee.
2:20:27 Again, I think looking to provide that service to the citizens.
2:20:33 I think as we talk about facilities and investment
2:20:35 those assets. I think there is efficiency and effectiveness. We can gain from co-locating,
2:20:41 but I don't think we gain $900,000 in just keeping up with inflation efficiency by plugging
2:20:49 people in the same building. So we have sort of some built-in cost to providing even an
2:20:58 equal level of service. So again, I'm not advocating that we have a lengthy debate of
2:21:04 this tonight, but I think we need to contemplate looking at the foregone balance as well, perhaps
2:21:14 framed around very specific projects.
2:21:18 So almost as if it's a, we're going to look at this piece of money, but that's going to
2:21:25 be committed to whatever it is.
2:21:29 Similar a bit even though I realize it's it has the potential to be ongoing funding
2:21:34 It's similar to maybe the way we look at reserves
2:21:37 That reserve funds are available for one time expenses not reserve funds toward an ongoing experience
2:21:44 and maybe if we think about the
2:21:48 Foregone balance with some time frame on it tied to project specific that's something we should
2:21:56 and think about not just let's throw some more money in the hopper and see where it goes.
2:22:02 Jim, Jim, I think you Mayor.
2:22:06 I too agree with Sean in that.
2:22:09 This may be the year that given some very, very narrowly focused specific projects that
2:22:16 need to be resolved, frankly about the Canyon Springs Road is one of them it's going to
2:22:22 have to be.
2:22:24 We have to do something there.
2:22:26 not just for the walkers and the golf course, but we have significant infrastructure down
2:22:32 there that we have to have proper and sufficient transportation access.
2:22:39 So I think that's a big deal and I would also support us looking very closely at the four
2:22:45 guard in that regard.
2:22:47 But also, we, you know, regardless of the fact that we have $5 million in held in, I guess,
2:22:54 advanced to handle three months of operating, we have $11 million in unrestricted cash in
2:23:00 the bank.
2:23:03 Our private partners in the community have made a big investment in our downtown area,
2:23:10 Glandia, First Federal.
2:23:13 Are we ready to make an investment in our downtown and become a partner in that downtown
2:23:18 area?
2:23:19 Not only be a partner, but we understand that you have a significant problem bringing your
2:23:26 staff together and creating a synergy to get things done properly.
2:23:32 We have the hands and building and city hall coupled with that, we have a public safety
2:23:38 complex issue that needs addressed.
2:23:42 And I'm not saying let's do it right now, but I'm posing, do we have the courage as a
2:23:48 city council to spend some of that unreserved, unrestricted cash to make these improvements
2:23:54 that really need to be done.
2:23:56 And that's kind of where I'm going with this now.
2:24:00 Rebecca Milsock.
2:24:01 Thank you, Mayor.
2:24:03 Just some general comments on the presentation tonight.
2:24:07 I agree with the priority of compensation strategy.
2:24:13 But I do think, as you stated, we should resemble other organizations, and I think we still need to be conservative and realistic in our approach.
2:24:23 A lot of the taxpayers that are going to be bearing the brunt of that aren't getting raises or make it minimal raises.
2:24:30 So in our strategies, I just would ask us to be thoughtful and considerate of what's going on for the taxpayers,
2:24:38 as well as, you know, the city employees that need those adjustments.
2:24:44 I do agree that we should focus on the Canyon Springs grade.
2:24:47 I think that should be a priority if it's well within the strategic plan.
2:24:52 I wouldn't be supportive of taking any foregone balance.
2:24:56 I guess I would say I would need to be very convinced of taking the foregone balance for
2:25:04 the very specific reason of the impact on people's daily budgets and daily lives.
2:25:09 3% and the growth formula, I think, are reasonable,
2:25:14 increases reasonable increments to keep up with the cost of inflation.
2:25:21 But the foregone balance does have a significant impact on people's lives.
2:25:28 I also just wanted to mention, like Councilman Berger,
2:25:33 I'm not convinced of the cost versus benefit analysis of putting everyone under one roof.
2:25:42 It's quite an investment and we did have that discussion.
2:25:46 I think it was last fall or sometime during the strategic plan and it was with staff and
2:25:50 with council.
2:25:51 We actually took that objective out of the strategic plan and so we're saying one of
2:25:55 our budget priorities is to implement the strategic plan but I struggle with that because we took
2:26:01 the new city hall out of our strategic plan and we turn down an opportunity to have a larger
2:26:08 building downtown. I'm not convinced that the circumstances have changed so dramatically
2:26:15 that all of a sudden we need to build a new city hall downtown. We turned down the group
2:26:23 that was advocating for a rec center because we said, hey, we can't afford it. So I'm
2:26:31 I mean, I would advocate for a rec center downtown before I would a new city hall.
2:26:37 And that's just because of the impact on the greater community.
2:26:41 And for that reason, I would prioritize Canyon Springs grade because it impacts
2:26:48 a greater amount of the community, more people.
2:26:53 And I think that our tax dollars need to be spent on things that benefit
2:27:00 community as a whole. But otherwise, I completely support the other priorities, especially in
2:27:08 finding efficiencies, really appreciate the reports, whether you come to us and say, you
2:27:12 know, here's where we saved X amount of dollars, for example, the Cured in Place piping. I mean,
2:27:18 that was great investment in technology and best practices. And so I would completely support
2:27:26 continuing those investments, especially as we heard from the long-term planning committee,
2:27:33 I really appreciated their input on investing more in departments that maybe kind of have
2:27:40 taken a backseat in the past.
2:27:42 For example, the IS department, the parks department.
2:27:45 We've been increasing our parks.
2:27:47 We've added a dog park, Tom Courtney Park, all of Augur Falls.
2:27:52 So, if they need personnel or better equipment, I would like to implement their suggestions,
2:28:00 especially from the employees on the ground floor who know day to day what they need and
2:28:05 what would better suit their needs.
2:28:08 And so, I would support their suggestions as far as adding equipment and personnel in
2:28:16 the parks department and especially IS, because it better serves the organization.
2:28:21 Suzanne Hawkins.
2:28:26 Well with the cost of doing business going up like everything else, I think it's pretty
2:28:30 much a conclusion that we are going to have to take the 3% and the new construction growth.
2:28:37 I would be open to exploring what's in the foregone balance, but again it would have to
2:28:42 be in a very structured situation.
2:28:45 The last couple of weeks I've read and reread the strategic plan and there is so much in
2:28:49 there that I wish we had the money to do today.
2:28:53 everybody, but I know we have to pick and choose and do the best we can do with what
2:28:59 we have available to us.
2:29:02 I'm very supportive of making sure we keep the pay raise and the structure on how we
2:29:10 pay our city employees moving forward.
2:29:12 I don't want to see that even stand still let alone slide backwards.
2:29:16 So I would really want to take a strong look at that.
2:29:19 I would love to have a rec department too, but I think until we take care of our internal needs first,
2:29:26 it's really hard to take that money and put it to a structure that some of the citizens would use and
2:29:32 some wouldn't when everybody needs to be able to contact us to pay their water bills and help with those things.
2:29:39 And that's a service we offer to all of our citizens across the board.
2:29:43 So to me that would be a higher priority item than looking at something that some people would use and some people wouldn't use.
2:29:50 My turn, Canyon Springs Road is a priority to me.
2:29:55 And I remember when we were having the discussion about roads,
2:29:58 not too many years ago, the council made a courageous decision
2:30:03 to dedicate money towards the roads.
2:30:07 And as I talk to people in the community,
2:30:09 and when we start talking about raising taxes for that,
2:30:13 the majority of the people that talked to me engaged me,
2:30:17 we can buy understanding that our taxes will be raised if it goes towards something that we can see,
2:30:25 not just into the general fund, but goes towards something that we can see.
2:30:29 So at this point, I'm a proponent of looking at the foregone for Canyon Springs Road
2:30:35 and figuring out what we're going to do with that.
2:30:38 I think Jim landed out very well that it's not only just a public safety issue with walkers,
2:30:44 but with and with drivers, but it's also a transportation issue.
2:30:48 We have to be able to reach that canyon for our infrastructure issues,
2:30:53 our wastewater treatment plant and all those other dynamics.
2:30:56 So to me, I'm open to that.
2:31:01 I think at this stage, I'm open to look at all the different revenues,
2:31:05 and then we kind of melt it down as we work through these issues.
2:31:09 But I'm extremely concerned about the space needs of our city.
2:31:14 We are in a city hall that was built, I don't know if it was new in 1961.
2:31:19 I just know in that, 53, we were fairly new to the building built in the 50s,
2:31:25 and it served our needs then.
2:31:28 It does not serve our needs anymore.
2:31:30 And I want to look at and explore some option of being,
2:31:34 would bring our city staff together not for them, I like you guys, but for our
2:31:41 citizens so that they can be in the same place and that you can be more effective
2:31:45 and more efficient for our citizens. I think that's the end result here. It's
2:31:50 not just for you although it is for YouTube. It's for our citizens and being
2:31:55 able to be more effective and more efficient in the same place. The
2:31:59 The synergy, the ability for me as a citizen to go pay my water bill and go talk to a city engineer in the same building, I think is imperative.
2:32:09 I think that's extremely important.
2:32:13 By being able to do that, looking at another city hall downtown, it also opens up the opportunities for our police department, our public safety.
2:32:22 Again, Jim, hit it on the head for me.
2:32:26 If you walk through that police department that was built in the 70s,
2:32:32 our police department is twice as big now?
2:32:36 At least twice as big now than it was then.
2:32:39 And we have officers that have offices in closets.
2:32:45 And it is not serving our community well.
2:32:49 The lobby way there is, I mean, you can get half a dozen people in the lobby way
2:32:54 to wait to see a detective or in to see an officer,
2:32:57 but no more than that.
2:32:59 And the locker rooms and the restrooms
2:33:02 and everything else that that building absolutely needs.
2:33:05 So when I say that we start talking about space needs
2:33:08 in another city hall, I also,
2:33:11 you're killing two birds with one stone.
2:33:14 Being able to turn that location into a public safety complex
2:33:19 for our citizens, for our police department,
2:33:21 but for our citizens that will take care of us for the future.
2:33:27 Compensation is big on my list as well.
2:33:30 We cannot retain, I mean, we're always talking
2:33:33 about recruiting, but a huge part of what we should be doing
2:33:37 as an organization is retaining as well.
2:33:39 That's arguably maybe even more important, okay,
2:33:44 to retain these qualified employees,
2:33:46 and the only way you can do that,
2:33:47 or one of the methods of doing that
2:33:50 is the compensation package.
2:33:52 And lastly, I'm interested in furthering the conversation
2:33:57 in the future about more water storage.
2:33:59 I know that we're going to make some significant improvements
2:34:02 in that area to the east of town through the development
2:34:06 that we've had.
2:34:08 But in my opinion, it's not enough.
2:34:10 I think that we need to continue that conversation
2:34:12 about water storage as well.
2:34:14 And so I'm open to look at all these different funding,
2:34:18 revenue sources to be able to accomplish these goals and again that's our job to
2:34:22 go through all those. Greg Rining.
2:34:25 Well I started to have the conversation with you talking about the funding side
2:34:28 and obviously I should have expanded into the other side but Don, if you do an
2:34:33 excellent job I'm just going to say, you know, wow, you want to go to coffee?
2:34:38 Yeah. Chris talking. Well my business background forces may look at it from
2:34:43 what's available further than what we'd like to do. I think the trust that
2:34:47 public has placed us with the passage of the $38 million wastewater bond drives my decision
2:34:54 so what is feasible for this year.
2:34:58 That combined with additional water storage and about four or five other projects, I don't
2:35:03 think that we have room on the plate let alone money to get a lot more dramatic with what
2:35:12 we'd like to do.
2:35:13 downtown renovation is going to be a major project, absolutely,
2:35:17 multi-year and major.
2:35:20 And I'm just saying that I can find no reason to dip into the
2:35:27 foregone balance, which is twice as much as the growth and the
2:35:31 3% provides.
2:35:33 What I don't know, and you might explain this to the council,
2:35:37 should the council decide to take that foregone balance, is
2:35:41 Is that a finite amount in an account or does that affect the tax rate for this year
2:35:46 and ensuing years?
2:35:49 Only ensuing years.
2:35:50 So the years, any year that you incur, so let me back up.
2:35:58 Remember the tax rate is just a product of a simple math formula where on an annual basis
2:36:05 We are going to take a look and we are going to say the $17.296 million is what we're going
2:36:15 to spend against a total taxable value of $2,153,000.
2:36:20 That translates and creates a property tax rate of $8.03 per thousand in taxable value.
2:36:28 The growth of the tax rate or the shrinking of the tax rate depends upon the numerator
2:36:36 and the denominator.
2:36:38 So if you add an additional $1.4 million in the spending side to the $17.2, in order for
2:36:48 that to be equal, there has to be an equivalent value in growth, the total taxable value.
2:36:54 In any time in which the taxable value grows faster than spending, you see the tax rate
2:36:59 decrease and conversely the opposite.
2:37:04 I will say that I'm a bit gun shy to project a tax rate for you guys.
2:37:13 I've done it twice last year and I'll own the first year.
2:37:18 I'm not going to necessarily be able to own last year because that was a product of a
2:37:23 whole different collection of circumstances.
2:37:27 But when we start looking at the tax rate, the unfortunate thing is our process because
2:37:31 we started so early and it's much more robust, that tax rate number is going to be very, very
2:37:40 late in our process. But yet, I also recognize that it's an important part of the consideration.
2:37:48 So what I don't want to do is I don't want to completely miss that number like we've
2:37:55 done the last two years. Because what happens is we get really excited about opportunity and
2:38:02 you pass a budget and we find that wrong information was provided and I have to call you in the
2:38:07 next day and we struggle in terms of what that looks like. So having a conversation about
2:38:17 projects and priorities is important and I'm going to ask you to be patient with me on
2:38:24 that whole tax rate number because I don't want to put you in a situation until that thing
2:38:30 is certified and maybe even a little bit later because last year it was a certified number
2:38:36 given to us and then three days later there was human error and human error happens and
2:38:41 you can't fault anybody. I probably made 50 mistakes today. So but really at least one
2:38:48 51.
2:38:49 51, okay.
2:38:51 But it was counting, right?
2:38:54 But when you're using that as part of that decision-making process, I think it's important
2:39:00 that we get that right.
2:39:02 So we'll give you some ranges and some estimates based upon what we're seeing, but calculating
2:39:08 that thing out, if you remember, the total taxable value of the city's number last year
2:39:13 went as high as nearly $2.4 billion, and it
2:39:19 rescinded almost below what was below that at one time.
2:39:23 It was like under $2.1 billion.
2:39:26 So.
2:39:27 OK.
2:39:31 Thank you for answering my question, sort of.
2:39:33 Kind of.
2:39:35 And do considerations.
2:39:38 A lot of things were beyond our control
2:39:39 on those taxing numbers.
2:39:41 They changed last year.
2:39:44 Don, so I just want to summarize it.
2:39:46 But I think with the extensive increases where people are going to see in their water bills,
2:39:53 that I would support the use of some of the reserve money for that King of Springs grade.
2:40:02 I would not tap in or vote for the use of foregone balance, but the $700,000 coming from the growth
2:40:10 the farming and the 3% I think that that's going to have to be the mainstay for our
2:40:14 funding from from my perspective anything from council I see no lights thank you
2:40:25 for the direction thank you thank you Travis for the presentation and city staff
2:40:29 thank you for being here again this evening appreciate you being here last
2:40:34 item on the agenda is public input and or other items from city council I see no
2:40:40 No one from the public unless Warren wants to come up.
2:40:44 City manager.
2:40:55 So one of the things we've started working on is the sustainability conference and we're
2:40:59 doing that in partnership with the College of Southern Idaho and the College's Sustainability
2:41:06 Group.
2:41:07 So tomorrow Josh has done a lot of really good work with this group and along the way when
2:41:15 they asked us to be invited into a process. Little did we know that we were going to own
2:41:21 the process a few short weeks later, but really it's a great partnership. And we would invite
2:41:26 you to come to the College of Southern Idaho as we really kick off a renewed partnership
2:41:32 in the area of sustainability. They've put together some vendors and some people. It's
2:41:37 from 10 to 2 and it's in the student union building or in the Taylor building in the lower section.
2:41:43 So we'd encourage you to go there.
2:41:44 Dennis talked about the Arbor Day celebration this Friday.
2:41:49 What's important is this is again the 16th consecutive year.
2:41:54 We received the award, the 18th year in which we've been celebrating Arbor Day in our community.
2:42:01 We're having a groundbreaking ceremony on Wednesday at 11 o'clock for the wastewater treatment plant.
2:42:07 I think that that is a great opportunity just for our community to talking about the growth
2:42:18 and where we're going.
2:42:19 It was 11 o'clock, 10 o'clock mentioned at one time.
2:42:23 It is 11 o'clock at the wastewater treatment facility.
2:42:31 Some of you have signed up for the Chamber Business Day Breakfast with the Governor.
2:42:37 That is at 8 o'clock at Canyon Crest.
2:42:40 And the last update I have is on the mountain bike slash BMX park.
2:42:46 Lots of great public comments.
2:42:47 I mean it was a great community build effort moving forward.
2:42:53 And then great job by Dennis and his team there.
2:42:56 They've accepted the ownership of that park and they're going to be moving forward and assisting
2:43:01 with some of that maintenance.
2:43:02 And so what we've done is we've turned a piece of scrub land essentially that had been coming
2:43:07 I'm invested with weeds and we're going to turn that into a community attraction which
2:43:10 is going to be probably very welcome to members of our community of all ages.
2:43:16 So I being a road bike guy probably will never go on it.
2:43:22 I don't like hills like that but I would encourage anyone else to take advantage.
2:43:26 Thank you Travis, anything from council?
2:43:29 Greg Lanney?
2:43:30 Well I wanted one of our most loyal visitors to our council meetings said that he'd want
2:43:35 Warren went out taking a look at the BMX park, but he said he hadn't tried it yet, so he didn't think he was going to try it.
2:43:43 He thought that was for younger people with different kinds of blacks, but he thought it looked great as well.
2:43:47 Excellent.
2:43:48 Thanks for going on.
2:43:50 Rebecca Mill, second.
2:43:51 Thank you, Mayor.
2:43:52 I just wanted to request a quick update, maybe in the future, on the different code amendments that are coming through.
2:44:01 I know that we had a discussion at P&Z work session back in February.
2:44:06 I think it was the first week of February.
2:44:08 And so I was just wondering, I see that the agenda is light this Tuesday, and just wondering
2:44:13 when those amendments are going to come through.
2:44:16 I know that they're a priority in our strategic plan, and so I'd like to see those, and we
2:44:21 talk about how we're growing and we're having a lot of new development.
2:44:25 So I think it would be a good idea to get those amendments through as we grow to make
2:44:30 sure we're using the best practices.
2:44:32 Thank you Rebecca. Anything further from council? We are adjourned.
Download
- Transcript (text) 148 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 196 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 265 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.2 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 17.6 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, April 21, 2014. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:44:44.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
20c7777b332cb2a2d5c389f6a62220ff1633e03976df14ff04cfd471455e8d82 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 24c32d813681c5dd32ce7dae65ebd8310a5f7c793e7a686b9a56cb570364b5cc
part02.m4a 18600f6cd69aaf3f4944d159993c2e0dc2a9b57afd569931fe80f8338fe0426d - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
da5fedf75381b8f81961928505c533ef5def6ce6891a7fed20a742812c6f5524
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file