City Council meeting
Monday, May 5, 2014
Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:00:00 were interviewed by chairperson of the committee, John Bonnet,
0:00:05 committee liaison from the City Council, Chris Talkington,
0:00:10 community development director, Mitch Humble and myself.
0:00:15 The interview panel recommended,
0:00:17 Gerald Martin, Susan Petruzelli, David,
0:00:22 to be appointed to the commission.
0:00:25 These appointments would be for a three-year term beginning
0:00:29 in April 2014 through March 2017.
0:00:33 Following these appointments, there's still going to be one more vacancy that we'll put
0:00:41 out again and see if we can get some interest on that.
0:00:43 So folks that are listening this evening or folks in the audience, if you know anyone
0:00:48 else that would be interested, please have them get a hold of us.
0:00:53 City code requires that at least four of the members of this committee be active in the
0:00:57 business development building or real estate industries.
0:01:01 With the department or departure of Kent, Doug, and Jeff,
0:01:05 the committee has only two members that currently meet these qualifications.
0:01:10 Gerald is a local civil engineer and is also a property developer.
0:01:15 Susan and her husband own and operate an electrical contractor business.
0:01:20 So both of those appointments will get us back to that four required in these industries, okay?
0:01:26 The members of all advisory commissions established under this title shall be residents under the city in the city of Twin Falls unless this is specifically waived by the council.
0:01:40 Now both Gerald and Susan live just outside of the city so this evening if the council will go forward with my recommendations this evening there will be a separate motion I believe.
0:01:56 Can it be part of the motion or make it part of the motion knowing that they're outside
0:02:01 the city limits.
0:02:02 So I will turn it over to council wishes or questions.
0:02:06 Great line.
0:02:07 Mayor, I move that we confirm the mayor's appointments of Gerald Martin, Susan, Petrizzelli and David
0:02:12 Gagliano.
0:02:13 Close enough, huh?
0:02:16 Yeah.
0:02:17 It's to the development impact the advisory committee and waive the out of city residency
0:02:23 requirement for or in city resident requirement for Gerald Martins and Susan
0:02:27 Petrucelli. Second. Have motion on the floor by Greg Lanning seconded by Suzanne
0:02:32 Hawkins. Anything further on that motion council. Once we vote I would like for
0:02:40 each of you if you wouldn't mind come forward just to say a couple words it's
0:02:43 always gives us an opportunity to see who's on our commissions and we'd
0:02:47 appreciate you don't have to give a five-minute speech or anything but if you
0:02:51 wouldn't mind coming forward. So I see no further lights. Sharon, could we have a
0:02:56 roll call vote, please?
0:02:57 Sean Baraker. Yes, Jim Mann. Yes, Greg Lanting. Yes, Don Hall. Yes, Chris
0:03:04 talking. Yes, Rebecca Mills, Soyka. Yes, Suzanne Hawkins. Yes, motion passes seven
0:03:11 to zero. So Susan, if you wouldn't mind coming forward first, they don't
0:03:19 anymore. I think it's just important for their council to get to know who's on
0:03:24 our commissions. Okay, I went to high school with, uh, so anyway,
0:03:30 did you have any questions for me?
0:03:31 Any stories about her that you could know?
0:03:36 We'll just leave it there.
0:03:41 I'm excited. I think it'll be fun and interesting and learn a
0:03:43 little bit more about the city. So it'll begin.
0:03:45 Very good. Chris talking.
0:03:46 Well, we, we admired your enthusiasm on the interviewing
0:03:50 Susan and I think that you're recognized and David not been too first with the
0:03:56 impact committees operations. How do you plan on getting up the speed before the
0:04:01 first meeting so that you can kind of come in with some knowledge base?
0:04:05 Okay we have a orientation would you call it tomorrow? So yeah, you should always
0:04:11 in the reading, so yeah.
0:04:14 Pass or fail grading, isn't it?
0:04:16 Yeah.
0:04:17 Okay, good.
0:04:18 Go ahead and say your apply yourself.
0:04:20 Okay.
0:04:21 Thank you, Susan.
0:04:22 Thank you.
0:04:23 David.
0:04:35 Welcome, David.
0:04:36 Thank you for the nomination and opportunity to serve in the committee.
0:04:39 I'm new to the community and I told them in the interview when I met some of you, it was
0:04:44 a thrill to come into the city and meet such a charming, hard-working, honest people and
0:04:51 proud to be part of this community and I have times since I've retired to be, uh, try to give something back so I'll serve at the pleasure of the console and do the best I can and hopefully at their little training session we're having tomorrow afternoon I'll get more grief than hopefully more qualified and be a benefit to the community.
0:05:09 So thank you.
0:05:11 Thank you, David.
0:05:13 No lights.
0:05:14 Thank you, sir.
0:05:15 Gerald.
0:05:16 You've been in that.
0:05:18 Location once or twice in your.
0:05:20 Yeah, that's what I was thinking. I've probably spent a lot of time standing right here. Again,
0:05:28 I have been actually involved in this, in fact, the committee meetings from day one,
0:05:37 sitting out here, rather than up on podium. Very interested in it from day one, not only
0:05:45 as a developer who has to pay the fees, but how determine how those fees are established.
0:05:53 I think that's really my interest to be in on the committee now, is to be able to share
0:05:57 with the other committee members how development costs are, where the development costs are,
0:06:04 and how these fees do impact development because at some level they discourage development rather
0:06:12 then encourage development and drain on the tax base.
0:06:17 So again, I will just move from up here to the front and I'll probably have to think
0:06:27 a little harder when I vote.
0:06:29 But I think it is important that the development community have a representative, but I think
0:06:34 that's recently structured why it is and I'm glad to serve in that capacity.
0:06:40 Thank you, Gerald.
0:06:41 I see no lights, thanks to all three of you
0:06:44 for stepping forward and serving.
0:06:46 Appreciate it.
0:06:47 Next item on the agenda is consideration of a request
0:06:50 to confirm the appointments of Joey Martin,
0:06:53 Mark Lambert, and the reappointment of Leah Babayon.
0:06:58 Babayon, thank you.
0:06:59 To the Parks and Recreation Committee.
0:07:03 Jeff, Blake, and Craig Manning both recently completed
0:07:06 their terms on Parks and Recreation Committee.
0:07:10 both provided valuable input to the commission
0:07:12 and had good attendance records.
0:07:15 Both will be missed on this committee.
0:07:18 Leah also recently completed her first term on the commission.
0:07:22 Leah is eligible and has requested for a reappointment.
0:07:27 She's had great attendance,
0:07:28 has been a valuable commission member.
0:07:31 City staff posted these vacancies as we have the others.
0:07:36 Staff received application from six individuals
0:07:40 with an interest in serving
0:07:42 on the Parks and Recreation Commission.
0:07:44 And an interview panel consisting of the
0:07:46 Parks and Recreation Chairperson, Kevin Dane,
0:07:50 Parks and Recreation Liaison,
0:07:52 Sean Barrigar, Community Development Director,
0:07:55 Mitch again, and myself interviewed all six candidates.
0:08:01 After the interviews and going through
0:08:04 deliberations, it's recommended by the Council, by this interview panel, I mean, to appoint
0:08:14 Joey Martin and Mark Lambert to the Commission and to reappoint Leah to her second term on
0:08:22 the Commission.
0:08:24 So this is also my request that the Council would confirm the individuals listed and I
0:08:30 will turn it over to Council Wishes.
0:08:33 Sean Barregger.
0:08:35 Mayor, I would move that to confirm the appointments
0:08:39 of Joey Martin and Mark Lambert and the reappointment of Leah
0:08:43 Bebein to the Parks and Recreation Commission.
0:08:46 Second.
0:08:47 Have a motion on the floor by Sean Barregger,
0:08:49 seconded by Greg Lanting to appoint both Mark and Joey
0:08:56 and to reappoint Leah.
0:08:58 Rebecca Milsoita.
0:09:00 Thank you, Mayor.
0:09:01 I just had a quick question for the council and the public.
0:09:04 Could you tell us who else applied who the six applicants were?
0:09:09 You have those in front of you, Mitch, that you could relate up.
0:09:18 I just got to open it up here because I'm going to butcher the names.
0:09:21 I think.
0:09:25 Let's see here.
0:09:38 It's the wrong one.
0:09:39 Hold on.
0:09:39 I'm going to find the right doctor.
0:09:44 OK, so we received an application from Jared Aslett, Brian Rice, Tom.
0:09:55 I'm going to get this name wrong one second.
0:09:57 Tom Young, and Galen Slatter.
0:10:03 Slatter.
0:10:04 Slatter.
0:10:05 Thank you.
0:10:08 To the two that were in the report.
0:10:10 Thank you.
0:10:11 And then in the future is it possible to get the letters of application and the resumes included
0:10:16 in the packet?
0:10:17 Just so that Council is all working with the same background information?
0:10:20 Travis.
0:10:21 So in the past, I think that the Council said that we should include that in a separate
0:10:29 not the agendas, if you'd like them included in the agendas, we can do that.
0:10:35 But our understanding from a staff perspective was to include those not, include the packet,
0:10:42 include the information of those who have been recommended for nomination in the agenda
0:10:47 packet and to have the other names available should the council request, we're happy to
0:10:52 do it anyway, whatever the council's pleasure is.
0:10:57 Well, I usually request it, but just for, I know when we were discussing the process
0:11:03 that we wanted to use for appointments, I think that the Council wanted to all have the same
0:11:07 background information as the committee.
0:11:10 So I don't mind if it's any email or the packet for them.
0:11:15 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:11:17 I was under the same impression that you were Travis, and that was because some people
0:11:22 who do not get selected really don't want their names in a public forum.
0:11:26 And so by having it separately where the council has information but not in the packet, then
0:11:30 it's not published on the web where people can say, oh, they didn't pick so and so.
0:11:34 And I think it was more of a privacy matter, from my opinion.
0:11:37 So I would prefer to keep it out of our packets so it doesn't become part of the public record personally.
0:11:42 Jim, come on.
0:11:46 Yeah, I agree, this is a balancing act between the public's right to know and
0:11:52 maintaining the dignity and privacy of people who are not appointed for some reason to a board.
0:11:56 So I think maybe just like an email or something,
0:12:03 just informally notifying us who did apply.
0:12:07 But I just think it would be the right thing to do,
0:12:14 to not run them through the mail out in the public site,
0:12:18 because they weren't appointed.
0:12:24 No one else is weighing in.
0:12:25 So I think that's probably the direction that will go.
0:12:28 Travis, is that clear enough?
0:12:30 Or thank you very much.
0:12:32 So we're going to go ahead and do a vote.
0:12:34 And then I would like to have both Mark and Joey come up
0:12:37 for a moment afterwards and just introduce yourselves
0:12:40 to the council.
0:12:41 Sharon, roll call vote please.
0:12:44 Yes.
0:12:46 Yes.
0:12:48 Yes.
0:12:49 Yes.
0:12:52 Yes.
0:12:54 Yes.
0:12:56 Yes.
0:12:57 Motion passes, seven to zero.
0:12:58 We'll start with you, Mark,
0:13:00 if you wouldn't mind coming forward.
0:13:03 You didn't know we were gonna do this to you, did you?
0:13:06 So yeah, I'm Mark Leibert. I grew up in Utah. I moved up here about five years ago. Just wanted to really just wanted to kind of give back to the community because this community has given a lot to me in the last five years since I moved here.
0:13:21 Mark, could you maybe share a little bit about some of the things you'd like to do recreationally that might bring a different perspective to our community?
0:13:28 I'm a bass jumper and skydiver so as like my big draw to Twin Falls was the bridge
0:13:34 So that's yeah, I jump off the bridge
0:13:39 With a parachute
0:13:41 Thank you. Thank you. Hey other questions. I don't see any others. I appreciate you coming tonight. Joy Martin
0:13:48 Well, I really appreciate this opportunity. I moved to Twin Falls in 1999
0:13:56 One of the first things I got involved with was with the recreation
0:13:59 and playing sports group with a lot of your children.
0:14:02 Then a full film.
0:14:03 And I love the Parks and the Town, world class stuff,
0:14:08 and I see a bright future for our Parks and Recreation Department.
0:14:11 And I really appreciate this opportunity.
0:14:13 Thank you.
0:14:13 Thank you, Joey.
0:14:15 Another just chance for us to say thank you
0:14:18 to the individuals that stepped forward this evening
0:14:20 to serve on our different commissions and committees.
0:14:23 We can't do our jobs without you, and we want that input.
0:14:26 So thank you for doing that.
0:14:28 Now, I will also let you know that it doesn't hurt our feelings if you stand up and leave
0:14:34 at this point.
0:14:35 I know sometimes it feels awkward to you, but it's not awkward to us.
0:14:37 We understand once the agenda item is over, you certainly can leave.
0:14:42 You can stay too.
0:14:43 We'd love for you to stay.
0:14:45 But, okay.
0:14:46 Bye, Susan.
0:14:47 And, Jody, would you like to come forward and say hello, if you will.
0:14:59 Yes.
0:15:05 reappointed you recently correct. Yes I believe you. Okay. Okay.
0:15:10 Okay. Um, I would say my name is Jolyne D'Tate of my reside. It's kind of what this microphone
0:15:17 does. I was a partial term on the planning and zoning commission previously and thank you
0:15:23 for being knowing that opportunity for me to continue to serve. I am learning a lot. I'm
0:15:28 enjoying it very much and I think as we as I launch forward into this full term now I'll
0:15:33 be much more value as we move forward and seeing some of the other commissions and the ones
0:15:37 that are appointed in these other offices, it has sparked my interest somewhat, so I'm going
0:15:41 to be watching and paying attention to see after this term has fulfilled and I can no longer
0:15:45 be other planning and zoning where my next steps are going to be, so I look forward to
0:15:49 that. Thank you for the opportunity again.
0:15:51 Thank you for serving. I appreciate you. Moving on to the next item is a consideration of
0:15:58 a resolution of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, supporting federal fair housing laws, and we
0:16:05 have our city manager, Travis Roth, and welcome, Travis.
0:16:07 Thank you, Mr. Mayor and members of the Council attached to the agenda statement is a fair housing
0:16:12 resolution. You'll notice that this resolution may appear to be a bit different in a different
0:16:16 format than what we're typically used to. This fair housing resolution was drafted to us, provided
0:16:22 to us by the Region 4 development.
0:16:25 And Kathy Euchar with Region 4 is here.
0:16:27 She can assist with any questions.
0:16:29 This is not only good for us to do and part of good government,
0:16:34 but it's also one of those requirements that we have
0:16:37 as we accept certain federal funds
0:16:39 that there are any litany of requirements.
0:16:42 And one of them is to ensure that we have an up-to-date
0:16:45 fair housing resolution.
0:16:48 Our last housing resolution was adopted in 2010
0:16:51 under Resolution 1841.
0:16:55 And since that time, the resolution
0:16:57 has changed in terms of form and format.
0:16:59 And so we have a new form and format with you this evening.
0:17:03 The largest change really is according to Kathy
0:17:06 in the last section in paragraph,
0:17:08 and that piece is a bit different.
0:17:10 So we're asking this evening that the council
0:17:12 support the Fair Housing Resolution
0:17:15 and allow the mayor to sign the document
0:17:20 so we can not only post it, but then also submit it
0:17:23 to agencies that require it.
0:17:25 Travis, so there'll be a different resolution number
0:17:27 correct?
0:17:28 No, this is it.
0:17:29 Same resolution.
0:17:30 And the reason the form looks different is because this
0:17:32 is the document that was provided to us for your adoption
0:17:36 this evening.
0:17:36 Thank you.
0:17:37 Chris, talking to you.
0:17:38 A question for Fritz, a fun passage of this, Fritz,
0:17:42 and a party could make a claim under any number of subparts
0:17:49 of this, but what might be the city's outside or total liability of violation of this?
0:17:58 What consequence could you imagine that the city, if they were found guilty, certainly.
0:18:05 But I think primarily, it comes back to the grants, if we agreed to do certain things
0:18:12 under these grants, and I suppose it would endanger any grants, and they would ask for
0:18:18 reimbursement for funding and would it be only a grants associated with housing or
0:18:24 is this one of the sweet things well I think there are grants that we get that
0:18:29 are tied to fair housing resolution okay and the last question is the burden of
0:18:38 proof and upon us to enforce it in private housing projects utilizing public
0:18:46 Do we have to extend our enforcement arm?
0:18:52 We don't directly enforce on private property.
0:18:58 But for, I guess, housing that utilizes public money,
0:19:04 we have culpability, liability.
0:19:07 Do we just wait for it?
0:19:08 If we were aware, and primarily where we'd become aware of that,
0:19:11 is probably through the building department,
0:19:14 we would notify the federal agencies,
0:19:18 but we would have direct authority to enforce.
0:19:23 Okay, somebody brings it to our retention
0:19:25 or through the building department.
0:19:27 Yeah, primarily, like I said,
0:19:29 it would primarily come through the building department,
0:19:32 maybe sometimes through police or fire,
0:19:34 but I would think primarily the building department
0:19:36 was where we'd become aware of those issues.
0:19:38 Okay, thank you.
0:19:40 Good questions.
0:19:41 Rebecca Milsica.
0:19:42 Thank you, Mayor.
0:19:44 I just have a question on the new portion of the details of how we're going to fulfill these requirements.
0:19:52 For example, where it will be publicized, where the, what prominent areas will the information be posted, and so on and so forth in the requirements.
0:20:05 So I'll answer a part of these and then in terms of preparing a fair housing assessment and declaring April's Fair Housing Month.
0:20:10 We do that historically through resolution and proclamation.
0:20:15 Publicizing the resolution, this is part of that.
0:20:18 We also, through our PIO, through Assistance of Region 4,
0:20:21 through our website, is easy to do.
0:20:24 Posting in a prominent location means in City Hall
0:20:27 on our bulletin boards at the public library
0:20:30 at the very typical and standard places that we're going
0:20:32 to be posting and notifying our agenda.
0:20:35 Providing fair housing information to the public.
0:20:38 Probably the best thing I could do is talk about maybe one
0:20:40 one of the most recent events from our building department that was passed on.
0:20:44 We recently had an individual and a group call talking about some of the issues that they're
0:20:49 having in terms of their process.
0:20:52 And Wayne and our building officials actually to go out on site, he was able to share in
0:20:56 a conversation that with the property owner, they provided information directly that is prepared
0:21:02 by the Attorney General's office about fair housing standards that was provided and they're
0:21:06 of working collectively on a resolution by May 7th, I believe,
0:21:10 to resolve some electrical and some plumbing issues.
0:21:12 So that is one of the issues, one of the examples I will continue
0:21:16 with that part of the gallery each.
0:21:18 The other thing that we've done is we've set up a series
0:21:21 of really good conversation pieces.
0:21:24 We are meeting with and have met with many
0:21:26 of the different groups.
0:21:29 Really mention Dwayne get the credit for taking the lead,
0:21:32 also with Captain Anthony Barnhart, who
0:21:35 have been working collectively with the, whether it be Valley House or the Crisis Center or
0:21:42 a whole litany of other groups. We are participating in their board meetings. I have attended South
0:21:50 Central Community Action Partnership meetings as well as I believe Duane has and representatives
0:21:56 from the Police Department have been there as well. So we're taking a much more active
0:22:00 aggressive place in that getting the information out to the public as well as
0:22:05 moving forward and in terms of preparing the Fair Housing Assessment I'm
0:22:09 going to ask Kathy to assist on that piece. Welcome Kathy. This is my first time in
0:22:17 front of you guys so if I shake a little bit don't laugh okay. As far as a fair
0:22:22 housing assessment we do those through Region 4. You do have a fair housing
0:22:26 analysis of impediments that we've already done for you and it's similar to
0:22:30 that only this time we include all the all the information that we believe off the
0:22:35 websites that we that we look at and we put them in a booklet that you can have
0:22:40 in City Hall if anybody wants to look at it and that's how the last piece of
0:22:44 furthering your fair housing is doing that assessment. Okay thank you and if
0:22:49 it's possible Travis to maybe get a copy of that sent to the council when it's
0:22:53 available.
0:22:57 Would everyone like to copy that? It might be good for information I guess you don't
0:23:01 have to, but I would like to read the analysis.
0:23:04 Yeah, yeah, maybe, maybe send it digitally to all of us through Travis, thank you.
0:23:12 Any other questions for Travis, Officer Resolutions member, 1841, Greg Lanning.
0:23:20 There are all I'd like to move that we adopt resolution 1841.
0:23:24 Second.
0:23:25 And motion on floor by Greg Lanning, seconded by Chris Tawkins, intent to adopt resolution
0:23:31 or 1841 anything further on that motion council?
0:23:36 Sharon Roll call vote please.
0:23:39 Yes.
0:23:41 Yes.
0:23:42 Yes.
0:23:44 Yes.
0:23:46 Yes.
0:23:47 Yes.
0:23:48 Yes.
0:23:51 Yes.
0:23:52 Yes.
0:23:53 Motion passes seven to zero.
0:23:55 And thank you Travis.
0:23:56 Thank you Kathy.
0:23:57 Come to see me.
0:23:58 Next time on the agenda is consideration request to allow greater than standard building structure
0:24:05 for a proposed addition and remodel on property located at 150 South Park Avenue
0:24:13 West in accordance with the Twin Falls City Code 10-7-3. Mitch Humble.
0:24:24 We've seen these requests before but it's not, I think it's been about a year or so since we've
0:24:28 had one. So let me just kind of refresh. City Code 10-7-3 is the code section that
0:24:37 Basically says that if somebody needs to request additional building height or structure height
0:24:41 We can come to the council with those requests given certain zoning districts and the M2 district is one of those that we allow it on so
0:24:50 Property property we're talking about here is the saranco
0:25:00 Property right here. This is south park Avenue and just right off the picture is Washington Street, South
0:25:06 And so right here at the corner
0:25:08 They're wanting to expand and add some bean storage tanks or bins, and I've got a picture
0:25:16 of those.
0:25:17 It would look something like that.
0:25:28 Max height on these things is about 71 feet.
0:25:33 And then how they fit, maybe from a site plan perspective, it would be in between the two
0:25:40 of the existing sets of buildings that are already there.
0:25:43 This is consistent with some of the other requests that we've seen and approved for these
0:25:47 these types of things from automated sugar,
0:25:49 for chibani, for a lot of our industrial type.
0:25:53 Users out there have these tall,
0:25:55 sometimes milk silos, sometimes beans silos,
0:25:58 those kind of things.
0:25:59 So the council has the opportunity to approve
0:26:02 this request for additional height to 71 feet.
0:26:05 And with that, I'll just turn it over to you guys
0:26:08 for questions and if you have any,
0:26:09 we can try to answer them for you.
0:26:11 Council have any questions?
0:26:13 Rebecca, no second.
0:26:15 I think you mayor, just a quick question on the fire marshals determination of not needing a fire suppression system are the contents of the silos flammable, and what would happen if by chance they were to catch on fire.
0:26:30 Well beans are flammable, so this is represented from the applicant here.
0:26:41 Hi, I'm Jim Saran.
0:26:43 Welcome Jim.
0:26:43 owner of the strangle beef products and petition for the variance.
0:26:47 Basically, to my knowledge, I mean,
0:26:49 you'd be hard pressed to get a bean to burn,
0:26:51 but, and bean, grain, dust, or chad
0:26:55 is not flammable like grain dust of that nature.
0:26:57 I mean, there's no tribal material in beans.
0:27:00 It's supposed to be just dust.
0:27:03 So, suppression system would cause us much more harm
0:27:06 that would ever do good because it would ruin anything
0:27:09 in the beans, in the process,
0:27:10 but they're just, they're not gonna burn yet.
0:27:13 Thank you.
0:27:14 The old fireman comes out and me, anything's burned, will burn if it's hot enough.
0:27:19 That's where I was coming from.
0:27:20 Yeah, they're technically flammable.
0:27:22 Jim's reaction to that request was he didn't think his precious system was needed at all.
0:27:27 So we've noted that in here.
0:27:29 Thank you.
0:27:30 Chris talking.
0:27:31 And I'm trying to really see what the height variance request amounts to.
0:27:35 It's about six feet is.
0:27:36 Well, the max height in the M2 is on its 50 feet and this is going to 71 to the extreme
0:27:41 high end of it.
0:27:42 I thought that it's had 65 feet, 10 inches, okay, all right, so it's a lot more than that.
0:27:56 Thank you.
0:27:57 Great landing.
0:27:59 Well, I also think the farm I show, I was going to comment on that question, well I think
0:28:03 the farm I show looks a lot upon that is, you know, will it be occupied and obviously
0:28:08 a bean bin, if it is occupied, it will only be like when I was a kid on the farm and you
0:28:13 jumped into the green bin to be able to jump and land and something.
0:28:17 Hopefully that will happen.
0:28:20 And I would also like to appreciate Mr. Schran and his family's continued investment in the
0:28:27 city of Twin Falls.
0:28:28 This is obviously an investment in his business which means an investment of a value added product
0:28:35 that we need to retain in this area.
0:28:37 part of the rotation of for a lot of the farmers and we appreciate that and I get to
0:28:44 see Jim or once block of heat so it's a lot to see does well look you do I might
0:28:49 have seen you too guys my question to you matches you know I read through the
0:28:53 report looks like it was recommended are we missing anything is there something I
0:28:59 mean I'm a big proponent of going up bad rather than out and I and and so are we
0:29:07 missing something that you can think of.
0:29:09 You know, this is similar to all kinds of other requests that we've had and that we've
0:29:14 approved before.
0:29:15 It seems pretty much in line.
0:29:17 It's in the M2 zone.
0:29:18 It's surrounded by a bunch of M2 type uses.
0:29:21 It is kind of close to the rock creek, if that's a consideration, but it's close to other
0:29:26 stuff that's close to rock creek that looks about the same.
0:29:32 And I would I repeat it, I don't know that I tell much differently.
0:29:35 Similar to what we have seen and approved in the past.
0:29:39 Thank you, Mitch.
0:29:40 We're back in that second.
0:29:41 Thank you, Mayor.
0:29:44 We have had similar, as you stated, we've had similar requests like this.
0:29:46 And there's clear utility in the additional height.
0:29:50 And it's been not uncommon for us to allow.
0:29:55 I did have a question about how it might impact our emergency service coverage.
0:30:02 In the past we've talked about how height affects our communication system.
0:30:07 And I know that we built in a fee or some sort of coverage to help cover those costs in the future for the height.
0:30:15 But this might not be a situation where you would need, does it come with a, maybe Travis can talk about the process.
0:30:21 Does it come with a building permit or how will this be affected?
0:30:25 Yeah, you'll get a building permit for this,
0:30:29 and we'll charge fees and those kind of things
0:30:31 associated with it.
0:30:32 But I'm not thinking these are even square footage
0:30:41 of buildings, these are structures.
0:30:43 They're not necessarily buildings.
0:30:44 And our code defines a building differently from a structure.
0:30:48 Since it's not necessarily a building,
0:30:50 we won't necessarily charge a building impact fee.
0:30:54 But I can tell you that our response equipment, where
0:30:57 We might have the height issue would be probably more in a rescue scenario than putting out
0:31:03 a fire scenario.
0:31:04 And we can park our ladder truck there, and with that truck, we can get to the top of a
0:31:08 71 foot tank with relative ease.
0:31:11 So I think we have the equipment to respond.
0:31:15 I don't think that adding this is going to add anything that we can't handle from a response.
0:31:21 And I think that's partly what Jim is talking about when he says, yeah, they're fine.
0:31:25 So, in terms of how it might impact our communication system?
0:31:30 And it shouldn't.
0:31:32 Most of the issues that we've had in the areas of communications and the abilities for our
0:31:38 firefighters or our police officers to communicate has to do almost with the density of the structure.
0:31:44 So you're looking at how thick the concrete walls are per se at schools, at hospitals,
0:31:51 hotel rooms in hotels, those type of things, where, and Chief Pike is here and he can probably
0:31:58 address that much better or Captain Anthony Barnhart is here as well.
0:32:02 This structure is, and again, we don't believe that anything in there is going to cause a
0:32:11 flammable situation.
0:32:12 If there were an annoying Jim O'Claire's, the fire marshal, there would be fire suppression
0:32:19 equipment placed onto this facility. The second thing in terms of communication, this structure
0:32:26 itself is not going to cause any impacts associated with our abilities to communicate
0:32:31 in those areas. If we don't have the ability to have good communications, they exist whether
0:32:37 this structure is in that place now or not. The radio waves are not going to be blocked
0:32:42 by the four silos and in all honesty like Mitch said,
0:32:48 it's not a building that we would define as,
0:32:51 it's not a structure that we define as a building
0:32:52 because it's not going to be inhabited.
0:32:55 So therefore, if there were an incident in this area,
0:32:58 it'd either be a confined space rescue on the outside
0:33:02 or the other side it would be something
0:33:05 that we would surround and drown from a fire perspective.
0:33:09 Okay, so your assessment is that it would have negligible impact on the communication system. Yeah, that structure is not going to have
0:33:17 Any no one
0:33:19 Communication problems that we have now if there are communication problems that exist they exist with or without the structure being in place
0:33:25 Thank you
0:33:27 Council I see no further lies. Do we have a motion for stocking? I would move to
0:33:32 authorized
0:33:34 variants
0:33:35 To allow up to a 75 feet for the structure at 150 South Park Avenue West in accordance with
0:33:43 The process of Twin Falls City code 1073
0:33:47 Say I'm most not born by Chris Todd Newton seconded by Jim Munn
0:33:53 Anything further on that motion council intent was to give a couple feet flexibility
0:33:59 I guess you can measure a different ground
0:34:01 on perspective using come up whether the six inches over
0:34:05 under I think that's what it's also putting an upper cap on
0:34:09 can you live with that very very very good point Chris thank
0:34:14 you Rebecca were you that was my question I the staff report said
0:34:17 71 feet so okay I understand anything further on that motion
0:34:21 council Sharon roll call vote please Don Hall yes Chris talking to
0:34:31 Yes.
0:34:32 Rebecca Mills-Zoika.
0:34:34 Yes.
0:34:35 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:34:36 Yes.
0:34:37 Sean Bericher.
0:34:38 Yes.
0:34:39 Jim Mann.
0:34:40 Yes.
0:34:41 Greg Lanthine.
0:34:42 Yes.
0:34:43 Motion passes.
0:34:44 Seven to zero.
0:34:45 And I too would like to thank you sir for your investment.
0:34:47 Thank you for bringing that up.
0:34:49 Next item on the agenda is consideration of a request to a law.
0:34:53 Excuse me.
0:34:55 Discussion with Sheriff Tom Carter and about possible Snake River Canyon jump.
0:35:00 We have our chief of police doing the introduction and maybe starting the presentation and then we have our steamed sheriff Tom Carter from the county.
0:35:10 Good evening.
0:35:11 Good evening.
0:35:12 Members of the council.
0:35:13 As promised as we work our way kind of weave our way through this canyon chum process.
0:35:18 We did state that we would provide updates to the council.
0:35:23 I think everyone is aware that Beckley Media continues to move forward towards a jump in
0:35:28 September 7, 2014, utilizing a piece of property that's now located in Twin Falls County.
0:35:35 And so with that in mind, obviously that would fall in the jurisdiction of Sheriff Tom Carter.
0:35:41 Good, strong partner of the city, and so I'd ask Tom to be here to share a little insight
0:35:47 on the jump and to answer any questions that you'd have.
0:35:51 Welcome, Sheriff.
0:35:52 Thank you.
0:35:53 I would like to just fill everybody's head full of good information that I know and you don't.
0:36:00 However, what I do know is that rather or not this thing is going to happen, we have to assume that it's going to happen, as far as myself and law enforcement goes.
0:36:14 I got a meeting tomorrow, oddly enough, with a gentleman from the Buffalo Chip.
0:36:21 Chief Pike and myself had met with a group two weeks ago.
0:36:26 That was in town. Some of them people were from New York.
0:36:30 They'd come a considerable distance, probably considerable expense to look at the jump site.
0:36:38 And I can't imagine that they would have done that unless they have something in mind on making this thing happen.
0:36:45 So I think the only way from a law enforcement standpoint, assuming that it does happen, that it will work is with teamwork.
0:36:55 I don't think any way that my department could handle this something of this magnitude, but I do believe with my department,
0:37:03 with Twin Falls City's department, Jerome's department, I don't state police.
0:37:08 I see no reason why we can't make the same work in a positive manner.
0:37:12 I certainly don't want to be an alarmist and say we're doing anything bad for the community with this.
0:37:18 Because, as you can imagine, I think all of our interests are with Twin Folds and the community.
0:37:26 So, I personally assume this is going to happen and if it does, I think it's all a teamwork between all the local law enforcement.
0:37:37 we can make it work.
0:37:40 I will certainly answer any questions
0:37:42 that I know if I'm capable of answering.
0:37:46 Thank you, Sheriff.
0:37:47 We're going to open it up to the council first,
0:37:50 and then as we've always stated about the jump, okay?
0:37:53 We're going to also open it up to the community
0:37:55 if there's anyone in the audience
0:37:57 that might want to ask a question.
0:37:59 We're certainly going to allow that this evening as well.
0:38:02 So I have Greg Lanning.
0:38:04 Chair Carter, I'm going to assume, and I hope I would assume you can maybe confirm it.
0:38:12 I'm assuming we're going to need to close pole line in Eastland at the day of the jump.
0:38:17 Would that be your thoughts?
0:38:19 You know, Ryan, Chief Pike and I were just discussing that this afternoon, you know, where
0:38:24 there are going to be routes that no doubt are going to have to be closed.
0:38:28 You know, what we can, I'm sure everybody will agree with is traffic going north and
0:38:33 south out the corridor across the bridge is going to be an issue. I was going north
0:38:40 the other day, 11 o'clock in the morning. They was changing a light bulb in one of the lights
0:38:45 and it was causing traffic issues. So my assumption, I don't think that's an insurmountable problem,
0:38:52 you know, is traffic control. That's kind of Police 101 there. So whatever roads is
0:38:59 going to have to be closed, I think we're going to probably have to wait until we're
0:39:03 closer to the event itself and figure that out.
0:39:08 And my follow-up would be they're now talking 10,000 on the other side as opposed to the
0:39:14 50,000 previously, of course that doesn't count all the people that won't want to watch
0:39:17 it for free, and then as I was reading about their listening, I guess it was on the KMT,
0:39:24 the soccer tournament that probably had 10,000 people in town just this weekend, and that
0:39:29 10,000 doesn't seem insurmountable, but again, that's just the paid audience, so.
0:39:34 My assumption is that the 10,000 is on the low end, you know, I don't know, I think Mr.
0:39:40 Beckley had said himself, he don't know how many people's going to come to this.
0:39:45 He says, can, but then he also says, well, maybe 20 will come, you know, but don't buy
0:39:49 a ticket, and I think he's probably exactly right.
0:39:53 I don't see any way we have during, well, the air show, for instance, you know, there's
0:39:59 a lot of people come into this community for the air show and we make it work between the
0:40:04 county and the city and other agencies.
0:40:08 As far as the 10,000, the bulk of what's going on according to them is going to be in Jerome,
0:40:16 Jerome's side of the canyon.
0:40:18 If that jump does occur, and if there are 10,000 tickets sold,
0:40:24 then they will probably be sold on the Jerome side of the canyon.
0:40:29 However, that's not my concern.
0:40:31 My concern is the days leading up to this, 10,000 tickets being sold.
0:40:36 I'm pretty sure that the bulk of those people are going to be on the Twin Falls side,
0:40:41 not the Jerome side.
0:40:43 They're going to be going to the Twin Falls restaurants,
0:40:47 Twin Falls bars, staying in the Twin Falls motels.
0:40:52 And the day of the jump, maybe they
0:40:54 will go across the canyon.
0:40:55 I don't know the answer to that.
0:40:57 But there again, I do know if we're all working together,
0:41:01 it's going to take a considerable amount of teamwork.
0:41:06 Chris, talking to you.
0:41:07 Sure, if you are aware, City had some negotiating problems
0:41:11 with Mr. Beckley and safety is our primary concern, as I'm sure it's yours.
0:41:18 Could we assume that you have a safety plan from them in hand at this point?
0:41:23 No, you cannot assume that.
0:41:26 Like I say, I am probably no less about this than what you guys do.
0:41:32 You've dealt with him, and if you speak with Mr. Beckley for any amount of time,
0:41:37 time he will tell you the issues that he had with Twin Falls City.
0:41:42 Well, I mean, that's an all-day respect with it.
0:41:44 Isn't it getting past the point of generalities and getting this specific?
0:41:47 Well, sir, you are exactly right.
0:41:49 It is getting late.
0:41:50 And our cop shop has to have specifics to deal with.
0:41:55 Okay, let's say they are doing, you know, let's say they're doing nothing illegal.
0:42:00 Let's say that if they're, they tell me on this property on Twin Falls side, they're
0:42:05 going to have less than 200 people and then judging from the size of the property, they're
0:42:10 probably that's probably right because there's not there's just not that much room over there.
0:42:17 You know, they seem to have answers for everything and like I said, I wish this meeting was a
0:42:22 week from now because I have a I have a meeting tomorrow with the gentleman from the Buffalo
0:42:27 Chip. There again, the Buffalo Chip, I don't know if you know of them, they're out of sturges.
0:42:34 You know, they deal with motorcycles, motorcycle activities, you know, I'm not one to say, games,
0:42:40 their deal is motorcycles.
0:42:42 I can't imagine that they would be involved in this thing without a plan.
0:42:49 And what their plan is, what I do know they're bringing in security out of Boise.
0:42:54 We're familiar with this firm.
0:42:57 It's a good firm.
0:42:59 However, what scares me, let's say they're not doing anything illegal, they come, they
0:43:04 make their jump, they have the security to keep people off private property. What do
0:43:09 we do as agencies to stop them from doing that? We are responsible to take calls for service.
0:43:21 That's kind of what we do as policemen. Consequently, I don't know if there is a way to stop this
0:43:28 from happening. And if there is, I don't know if we'd want to. I wish I had the answer
0:43:35 If we all had a crystal ball and we know come the 8th of September, we come the 8th of September, we know whether or not it was a success.
0:43:44 Sheriff, you made the comment that you wish this meeting was taking place after your meeting tomorrow. Actually, I'm going to take the office of view of that.
0:43:51 I think this is really good because it gives us an opportunity, the community opportunity to talk to our sheriff, give you our concerns so that when you meet with them tomorrow, maybe that can give you some ideas of what you can ask.
0:44:02 I think I look at this as a positive, sir, and anything we can do to help that.
0:44:10 I appreciate it.
0:44:11 I believe Captain Barnhart is going to attend it with me.
0:44:17 That was my one of the city I've invited the city administration and I believe Captain Barnhart is going to attend the meeting.
0:44:25 As I say, this is with Walley.
0:44:30 And I have no reason to believe that they have anything other than the best interest of our community in mind, you know, giving them the benefit of that.
0:44:42 We have a few more lights, sir. Sean Berger.
0:44:46 Sheriff, thanks for being here.
0:44:48 So you mentioned if they're not doing anything illegal, there's no way to put the kibosh on this.
0:44:55 The question is, is there some sort of a formal application and
0:45:00 approval process at the county, whether that's with your department or
0:45:06 with the commissioners, or is it basically, as a courtesy filling you in on what they're
0:45:12 already headed down the road to do?
0:45:14 To answer that question, you would have to talk to the commissioners about that.
0:45:20 I certainly don't want to put any words in the commissioner's mouth.
0:45:24 So for example, as far as I'm concerned,
0:45:27 my whole thing on this is safety.
0:45:32 Whatever else happens, we have to protect
0:45:35 the citizens of this community.
0:45:37 And that's just exactly what I plan on doing.
0:45:41 So as far as the sheriff's approval
0:45:43 or the sheriff's office approval and review,
0:45:46 there are certain thresholds for those kinds of things,
0:45:48 a number of people, and where those events are happening,
0:45:51 and those types of things.
0:45:53 and this doesn't seem to meet any of those,
0:45:55 at least with the knowledge you have so far.
0:45:57 With the knowledge I have so far, that is correct,
0:45:59 but there again, you guys probably know more
0:46:02 about it than I do at this point.
0:46:04 What I know is I know where it's at.
0:46:06 I know how many people they said was gonna be here.
0:46:10 I know who came here for a walk about on the property.
0:46:15 I know how much property is there, the distance.
0:46:21 But as far as any safety plans go,
0:46:25 I hope to know that tomorrow after my meeting.
0:46:29 Yeah, I guess my two cents for what it's worth is,
0:46:32 I mean, certainly understanding your role
0:46:35 in law enforcement and that protection of public safety.
0:46:39 I think, too, getting a clear understanding
0:46:41 of what they actually plan to do,
0:46:45 because we're now in May.
0:46:47 So we discussed this in the end of January
0:46:50 when we sort of put the February, I guess it was,
0:46:54 put the breaks on this.
0:46:55 So we're three months on,
0:46:57 I don't know that anybody has any clearer picture
0:46:59 of what's actually being proposed on either side,
0:47:02 whether it be back in the media or the community.
0:47:07 And everybody from what we continue to hear in the media,
0:47:11 which is the only place we seem to hear any information
0:47:14 about this is that it's happening and here we go,
0:47:17 but there seemed to be more and more cryptic details.
0:47:21 So my only suggestion would be asking those questions
0:47:25 and getting answers on paper,
0:47:28 because this is more of the same in my opinion.
0:47:33 It's my goal to ask all the hard questions.
0:47:37 That's kind of what I have to do.
0:47:41 So I appreciate any concerns that you have,
0:47:46 because trust me, I'll pass it along.
0:47:50 Rebecca Mills-Soyka.
0:47:51 Thank you, Mayor.
0:47:52 Thank you, Chair, for being here and keeping us informed.
0:47:55 My question is, you talked about the partnership.
0:47:59 So I assume that you're referring to the Twin Falls Police
0:48:03 Department's participation in this event.
0:48:06 And so my question is maybe first, Staff.
0:48:10 What are the plans for the city's involvement?
0:48:13 And who is in charge of covering the costs of any overtime
0:48:19 or additional staff needed?
0:48:23 As far as this thing could obviously very quickly run up
0:48:29 a lot of resources.
0:48:32 I still, I'll probably be a lot more comfortable.
0:48:36 I'll believe it when I see the name on the dotted line.
0:48:39 It's my opinion that it's, it's their intention for us to come up with whatever over time
0:48:47 cost that we deem is going to happen and they're going to pay that, you know, but there again until I see the check, you know, I
0:48:55 certainly won't count on that. So that being said,
0:49:03 still, if they are here and if things happen, we're still going to have to respond to the calls, you know, rather,
0:49:09 or, you know, no matter what, if Mr. Beckley, you know,
0:49:15 horribly, hope not, but if something would happen, you know,
0:49:18 we certainly, I don't think we would be trying to go
0:49:22 after his estate for any cost that he incurred
0:49:26 while he was here.
0:49:28 If you don't mind, Sheriff, if I could have maybe the chief
0:49:30 come up and weigh in, thank you, sir.
0:49:33 You know, honestly, what's amazing is our plan is we move
0:49:37 forward is really no different than what it's always been.
0:49:40 We are still, as the sheriff mentioned, focused on some kind of traffic mitigation plan, the
0:49:46 bridge and that north, east section of town is very concerned about how traffic will flow
0:49:51 there and what that will look like.
0:49:53 We're concerned about pedestrians from the bridge to Todd Blass's property all along
0:49:58 the ramp, still the same concerns that we've had since we started the process.
0:50:03 So in regards to any kind of cost recovery, what we're hoping is that we can enter an agreement
0:50:09 through the sheriff's office, probably prosecutor's office, Grant Loeb's for cost recovery on our
0:50:15 resources.
0:50:16 But I think the sheriff is right as we move forward, we'll do our best to be prepared.
0:50:21 It's hard to prepare for something when you're not quite for sure what it looks like.
0:50:26 Right.
0:50:27 So my question is just of the staff.
0:50:30 So if that funding is not available for Mr. Beckley, is that something we would have to
0:50:35 cover in our budget, our overtime budget or not?
0:50:38 Yes. We're going to turn that over to our. Yes. So, so, we've said all along that one of
0:50:46 the concerns and I think that everyone's echoing it is the citizen safety. It's the citizens
0:50:50 that are here, the citizens who will come and the citizens who may actually participate
0:50:57 in the jumping of the canyon. Yeah, I think the sheriff is right and we would echo it
0:51:05 that when calls are made, it is the duty to respond.
0:51:11 And we also recognize that in events like the air show,
0:51:16 which are contained in a single area,
0:51:18 there are significant overtime costs
0:51:20 that are paid not only by the City of Twin Falls,
0:51:23 but I think the sheriff could also recall.
0:51:25 The last time the Blue Angels were in town,
0:51:27 the costs that were absorbed by his office,
0:51:30 and we're hoping that through a cost recovery mechanism
0:51:33 and that the sheriff's ability to negotiate with Mr. Backley,
0:51:36 we will be included in those cost recoveries as well as ISP.
0:51:41 ISP when we were having the conversation was also very concerned
0:51:44 about cost recovery and their cost recovery also includes things
0:51:48 like per diem and hotel stays because they are going
0:51:51 to have to bring other officers into the area.
0:51:55 So this cost recovery aspect is something that remains out there.
0:52:00 where I think the Chief said it very, very well.
0:52:06 The central issues remain the same.
0:52:12 We're concerned about traffic mitigation.
0:52:16 We're concerned about pedestrian access
0:52:19 in and around the jump site.
0:52:21 And we're concerned about ensuring that this cost
0:52:25 isn't passed on to the tax being citizens
0:52:27 of Twin Falls City and Twin Falls County.
0:52:31 And I would agree, and I find that interesting because I know that our intent in turning the jump down was to not take over the resources in the police department's time,
0:52:41 but it seems like nothing has changed and that you're still just as involved as before.
0:52:46 And unfortunately, the citizens won't be getting that park or that $100,000 in renovations to our property.
0:52:54 But I do appreciate that you're still working on this and that we will keep the citizens safe
0:53:00 you know despite the jump. I think the the property is right absolutely next door to
0:53:08 the city property so all of this that is happening to the north. Everything is
0:53:18 happening here it's not like the city is not involved in it because it is it's
0:53:23 right there you know it is your next door. Any other questions? You know
0:53:30 Sheriff, I'm still at the same place, one of the questions that I always had was the technology of launching him across that canyon.
0:53:37 That actually is more brave now, in my opinion, because he has a smaller piece of land.
0:53:43 And he's 950 foot further?
0:53:47 Yeah.
0:53:48 Well, there you go, I wasn't even aware of that. So the technology concerns me at the very least,
0:53:55 But more than that is just the safety of our community.
0:54:00 And I know that you have the same goals that we do, that we want to keep our community safe.
0:54:04 We want to have any cost recovery because we all have limited budgets.
0:54:09 But primarily our citizens are safe.
0:54:13 So with that, we're charging you as our sheriff to look out for our interests.
0:54:19 And I know you will, and we will be right alongside of you working through these issues as best we can.
0:54:25 But I appreciate that you would do that,
0:54:27 and I have another light, Jim.
0:54:29 Oh, thank you.
0:54:30 Thank you, Sheriff, for coming here today.
0:54:32 You know, when Chief Pike and I had a lengthy discussion
0:54:35 at a council meeting several months ago,
0:54:37 in regards to health and safety matters,
0:54:41 there was a pretty clear understanding
0:54:44 that would take probably a year for us
0:54:45 to put together a plan that would work.
0:54:49 We have, I presumably moved this jumpsite closer
0:54:52 to the city, quite honestly.
0:54:55 closer to commercial areas and so forth.
0:54:57 So that does concern me.
0:54:58 The question I have was May,
0:55:00 this is going to have in September.
0:55:01 Do you have, is there a mechanism in place for you
0:55:04 to stop this, if it's not safe?
0:55:07 Not to my knowledge.
0:55:08 So this is, this can happen just in regards to whether.
0:55:10 That's what I see.
0:55:11 And maybe I don't know what that mechanism would be.
0:55:17 You know, the commissioners would probably be,
0:55:21 I spoke with Grant Loeb's today on it.
0:55:23 And he said if the commissioners don't come up
0:55:25 of some kind of an ordinance to prevent something
0:55:29 that they can't pass, I don't see what that would be.
0:55:32 Right, well I just find that really,
0:55:35 and I understand that the commission would have
0:55:37 to develop some sort of county orders,
0:55:38 but that does, this is a member of the city of Twin Falls,
0:55:41 and a member of Twin Falls County,
0:55:43 I would really hope that the commissioners,
0:55:47 in concert with you would develop an ordinance,
0:55:51 or some sort of plan that would allow you,
0:55:53 Because what I'm hearing is, it doesn't matter what you think, all right?
0:55:58 I mean, it doesn't matter if you say this is unsafe.
0:56:01 We have health and safety concerns.
0:56:03 If he says, you know, the health and safety concerns is, and Chief and I,
0:56:10 and I assure you, you know, the former chief understands what,
0:56:14 what scares me to death is somebody falling off that canyon, right?
0:56:18 Okay, the resources that we're talking about, now all of a sudden we got twin
0:56:21 We got my search and rescue people involved, and they're trying to get through what no doubt is going to be a huge amount of people.
0:56:29 Now what I'm hearing, I have no reason to doubt that Beckling Media doesn't have something in mind. They told me they do.
0:56:40 Because they were actually, from my understanding, they like it better where they are now from a safety viewpoint or standpoint than they did when it was out at that time.
0:56:50 was out of that from the closest part.
0:56:53 And I recognize that.
0:56:54 I respect that.
0:56:56 But my bigger concern, does it meet your standards?
0:57:01 I certainly can't answer that, Chef, until I know what that is.
0:57:05 And if it doesn't meet your standards, what kind of standing
0:57:11 do you have to stop it?
0:57:12 Where to change that plan?
0:57:13 And from what I'm hearing, you don't have anything right now.
0:57:16 Well, not that I know what I apologize.
0:57:20 That's a chief there.
0:57:21 No, you can't explain that all the time.
0:57:24 Call me, Jim.
0:57:24 So anyway, I just wanted to get that out.
0:57:27 This discussion is all somewhat elementary in that,
0:57:31 without any sort of ordinance or law or something
0:57:36 that would allow you to mitigate the health and safety
0:57:41 of our community.
0:57:43 This is a bad deal.
0:57:45 It is.
0:57:46 And unless they're doing something
0:57:48 the statutory legal, obviously, on whether that's on private property or private property, there's not a lot that law enforcement can do better just make the best of it and plan for it the best we can.
0:58:02 Okay. Thank you, Sheriff.
0:58:05 I guarantee that if there's anyone in their audience that would like to ask a question,
0:58:12 this is certainly your opportunity to ask questions of the sheriff or the council regarding this
0:58:20 event.
0:58:23 Again, I don't see people running towards the mic.
0:58:26 No, actually, that's good, yes.
0:58:29 Sheriff, again, we appreciate you coming this evening and sharing with us what you do know.
0:58:37 keep us in the light on this.
0:58:41 I would certainly would like to continue to come to these meetings.
0:58:46 This is a great venue to get out what knowledge that I have and I promise you I'll have more
0:58:52 knowledge the farther or the closer we get to the jump.
0:58:56 I'd like to know the sense you get a safety plan.
0:58:59 Pardon me?
0:59:00 I would like or have the city know it as soon as you get a so-called safety plan.
0:59:04 I certainly will and that there again that's something that I should know tomorrow she she passed the dig into it right away anyway
0:59:10 You see if it's a viable one
0:59:13 Travis did you want to wave? Yeah, just more for the individuals listening. There is a public hearing
0:59:20 in Jerome County
0:59:23 Tomorrow at 1 15. I believe the location is in the Jerome
0:59:29 home county courthouse.
0:59:32 I have interred that the meeting is in a different location.
0:59:34 Mike Williams, you all remember Mike,
0:59:38 I shared with me that the meeting was taking place.
0:59:41 And so we heard from Jerome City about the meeting.
0:59:45 And Chief Pike and I will be in attendance to observe.
0:59:50 And if there's anything to report after, we will.
0:59:55 I see no further lights.
0:59:56 Sheriff again, appreciate you coming this evening.
0:59:58 And I look forward to continuing this conversation with you for having me next item on the agenda strategic plan update on recycling pilot program that will be implemented at three neighborhood parks this summer we have Dennis Boyer.
1:00:13 Welcome, Dennis.
1:00:15 Thank you, Council.
1:00:17 Mayor, let's kind of give you an update what we've done this year so far on a recycling program.
1:00:22 Last year staff kind of worked with the commission to look at trying to do a recycling program in some of our parks.
1:00:29 And I'd be honest with you, I just ran out of time last year
1:00:32 to try to get something going in the summer.
1:00:34 So took it upon it, okay, we definitely
1:00:36 got a plan a little bit earlier for this year.
1:00:39 So I had less rights from PSI, he is in the audience,
1:00:42 so if you have any questions for him later on,
1:00:44 he is available.
1:00:45 We talked about kind of the questions
1:00:48 when we staff talked about with less is, okay,
1:00:50 is what parts should we implement for recycling program?
1:00:54 You know, of course you have your neighborhood parks,
1:00:56 you have your community parks,
1:00:57 and you have this kind of the sports complex parks.
1:00:59 So we looked at what would be the best areas to do with that, you know, the City Park, you
1:01:04 have a lot of big events in there.
1:01:06 You have how do we handle the recycling there?
1:01:09 Because some of those events, we allow them to set up whatever, you know, how to handle
1:01:13 the garbage.
1:01:14 Some of them go ahead and work with PSI.
1:01:15 Of course, you know, PSI has a contract of all our dumpsters in the community parks.
1:01:21 But also some of those large event users use someone else to handle their garbage.
1:01:26 So do we work with that other company?
1:01:27 Do we work with PSI or recycling our garbage contractor?
1:01:32 Also, how do we implement the cost of implementing?
1:01:35 Those bins do not less does not give up those out free.
1:01:39 Anyway, so how do we pass that on?
1:01:41 Do our, the city absorb those costs
1:01:44 that have those recycling bins in the park
1:01:46 and those events or those large events
1:01:48 we look at charging them?
1:01:50 And one of the big questions was how do we know
1:01:52 how many bins do they need out there?
1:01:54 That would just be a wild guess to try to implement
1:01:57 at first. Also, you know, if we look at charging them, that's a new fee we would add on to their
1:02:03 event. And any new fees we do have to have public hearings on any new type of fees that
1:02:07 we implement for our parks. And also, so we looked at do we just start a pilot program,
1:02:13 kind of start something small and then how well it goes, hopefully it does go well, that
1:02:18 we can kind of grow into it and look at, you know, for future years maybe expanding the
1:02:22 program and look at, you know, some of the other ones. So at our March meeting of the
1:02:28 Parks and Recreation Commission had less rights come to stock to the Commission to
1:02:32 kind of what his thoughts about a recycling program. He mentioned that he
1:02:37 has, you know, our same recycling bins, we have at our home, those big orange-led ones,
1:02:41 he can they put holes into the top of the carts kind of with a rubber gauntlet and
1:02:46 you saw that in the staff report kind of illustration. I do have, Mitch, you want to
1:02:51 get that done. So it's kind of this really the business look the same but also we want
1:03:00 to make sure we didn't get garbage in it. So they kind of modified that bin and has that
1:03:06 bar over that and has a lock on it so people cannot throw their garbage in the recycling
1:03:12 bin. To let you know these locks, the same locks a lot of our dumpsters we put locks on
1:03:16 throughout our park system because we have a lot of people, we have a lot of seems like
1:03:21 old garage cell stuff that gets in there, or sometimes we have construction and stuff that
1:03:25 gets dumped in our dumpster.
1:03:26 So some of our park dumpsters, we have locks at the same key that we have in our parks.
1:03:33 So we look at what can we do on recycling, how can we implement it?
1:03:37 So the commission really talked about, they like to see a recycling program up and running,
1:03:43 though they didn't know exactly which way to go, especially on the larger events, should
1:03:48 we try to implement that now or look at just neighborhood parks.
1:03:51 that the commission really encouraged staff
1:03:53 to pursue this recycling program.
1:03:55 So after that commission meeting, March,
1:03:57 staff sat down again with less,
1:03:59 and we did have the interested person
1:04:01 that really like to see us push recycling
1:04:03 further into our city facilities.
1:04:06 And we talked about what's the best way,
1:04:08 and kind of staff we looked at,
1:04:09 it's probably maybe start a little smaller,
1:04:11 look at a pilot program, that's what we've done.
1:04:13 Actually, these bins, I took that picture Friday
1:04:16 at that Harry Berry Park.
1:04:18 So the recycling bins were put out there Thursday or Friday, last Wednesday afternoon, I was
1:04:23 a couple of days late on the picture.
1:04:25 So those bins went out to three neighborhood parks, Harry Berry, Thompson, and Cascade or
1:04:30 people called the Cane Cane Park.
1:04:32 Why I picked those parks, those are the three most popular neighborhood parks we have in
1:04:36 our community.
1:04:37 Those are the ones that get more reservations for our shelters.
1:04:40 So what we did is, you know, we made a little sign on there.
1:04:44 says plastic bottles and aluminum cans recycling only type of deal so hopefully we
1:04:49 don't get a lot of trash in there. I know less one out there today just to look at
1:04:54 the results of the three days that we have the bins out there. Harry Berry was
1:04:58 used a little bit more because we did have a reservation there Friday night for
1:05:01 shelter so those people did use that and Cascade and Thompson did have some
1:05:06 recycling and not a whole lot. The recycling does you know they it's on just
1:05:12 I get your home every two weeks, and we worked out the schedule.
1:05:15 Harry Berry, I can't think of top of my head what day it is.
1:05:18 I think it's on a Friday.
1:05:19 Staff, you can see, it's kind of close by the shelter over there
1:05:23 at Harry Berry.
1:05:23 We just have to move it out to the roadside.
1:05:26 So the person that recycling that day in that area
1:05:30 can just go up there, unlock it, and dump the contents
1:05:33 for there.
1:05:34 So we thought that would be easy.
1:05:35 And we look at just three different areas.
1:05:38 One of the reasons why we did three, because the cost less
1:05:40 gave us, I believe, a good price for these recycling bins
1:05:44 that are only $6.50 per month per bin at each park.
1:05:48 So at the cost of the city is not a whole lot,
1:05:50 just about $80 cost to implement it.
1:05:55 And we're looking at the, like I said,
1:05:56 these were put out last week,
1:05:58 and we're looking at till Labor Day,
1:05:59 because that's really the majority of when we have
1:06:01 our reserve reservations for our shelters and large events,
1:06:04 you know, and other these neighborhood parks.
1:06:06 So we're looking at really about a four-month process,
1:06:09 I'm going to go to that only cost out of my budget $80.
1:06:11 I have these bins out there.
1:06:13 Time-wise for my staff to move them out there.
1:06:15 They're there every day of the week,
1:06:19 picking up garbage, cleaning the restroom.
1:06:20 So time-wise, just take the person
1:06:23 in the next 30 seconds to just drive that over there.
1:06:25 So at that time-wise, it'll be fine.
1:06:27 So we just implement that, just starting right,
1:06:30 just actually started right now.
1:06:31 Hopefully that's assessed how we advertising it right now.
1:06:34 I told staff that anytime anybody reserves
1:06:37 one of the three parts for the shelter, remind them that we have recycling bins out there.
1:06:41 We will get our facility use application modified where it says on these three parks, three parks,
1:06:48 recycling bins are available, and also I'll be working with our public information officers
1:06:52 or Josh and Palmer to try to get the word out some more.
1:06:55 And I'm hoping that really this would be a good success that it would get to implement
1:06:58 in other neighborhood parks.
1:07:01 The big community parks and sports complex is still kind of a question.
1:07:06 I can get some direction from the council is is it something like we want to host those
1:07:11 bands out there do we charge those events for those bands out there if we really want
1:07:15 to recycling or do we look at the city just eating that cost through through our budget
1:07:18 process so that's where hopefully I can get some direction from the council to let you
1:07:22 know that the Magic Valley Soccer Association they help host at their tournament this past
1:07:27 weekend on Friday and Saturday out of the Sunway Soccer Complex that you know I was talking
1:07:31 Chris Clark is one of the main people with the Magic Valley Soccer Association. They took it
1:07:37 upon themselves, they contracted with another garbage provider to have all their garbage cans out
1:07:43 there, and they did some recycling bins out there. I did not have a chance to contact him today to see
1:07:49 how their success of the recycling bins out there, but I will do. Once I hear information from him,
1:07:53 I will go ahead and email that to the council and staff to let you know if that worked or not,
1:08:00 or they had a lot of problems with garbage intermixing with their recycling.
1:08:04 But, you know, the three pictures that less than to me today about the recycling looked
1:08:09 like it was just all recycling in their life, just basically so people were using it.
1:08:14 They weren't taking advantage of trying to throw garbage in there, which is good.
1:08:18 So that's kind of our program.
1:08:19 We just wanted to start something small.
1:08:21 We got to implement in those three neighborhood parks and I just opened up for questions for
1:08:25 myself or less right.
1:08:27 So, but I would still like to have some direction to how,
1:08:30 if we're looking at these, like the big events at City Park
1:08:32 or some of our other large sports comp tournaments
1:08:36 where we have our sports complexes,
1:08:37 how should we absorb that cost?
1:08:39 Or should we pass that on to the users of the facilities?
1:08:43 So available for questions now.
1:08:45 Thank you, Dennis, Chris, talking to you.
1:08:46 Well, first of all, congratulations.
1:08:48 It's good that Twin Falls will start being known
1:08:52 as a recycling and repurposing community.
1:08:55 And I think people look at the Parks and Denison and say that's the city in this context.
1:09:01 I think it's absolutely vital for us to get that ethic down at the park level.
1:09:07 And I understand where you want to start low and slow to make sure we're doing it right.
1:09:12 My own thought is that the, make it as less cumbersome for your staff as possible.
1:09:19 And I would think that the sports complex is like I always go back to Harmon Park.
1:09:23 I don't know if there are 55,000, 500,000 aluminum cans
1:09:28 that go through there in a year, but there's going to be a heck
1:09:30 of a lot.
1:09:31 And I personally don't expect this to break even.
1:09:34 It'd be nice if eventually we could get some of the costs
1:09:38 borne by the public.
1:09:39 But we're also saving volume, which means transporting less
1:09:44 to the landfill through time.
1:09:47 I'm going to take a few years to build that up.
1:09:50 If you could try the three parks right down,
1:09:53 you could try on some experimenting basis
1:09:55 with the sports complexes.
1:09:58 I don't know a baseball attorney or a soccer attorney.
1:10:02 That might be the only suggestion I have.
1:10:05 And I really appreciate PSI for their help on the thing too.
1:10:12 I think we can be very successful in it.
1:10:14 The only other item I might mention is I think you've already done it,
1:10:18 but do other municipalities in Idaho have park recycling
1:10:22 and what their protocol or procedure might be?
1:10:26 I know there is other communities do have it,
1:10:28 but I have not, I know I've contacted a few of them,
1:10:32 but that was the thing.
1:10:33 You might get an idea or two of them.
1:10:35 It's not an idea.
1:10:36 But good job, appreciate that.
1:10:38 We're back in a second.
1:10:40 Thank you, Mayor.
1:10:42 Similarly to Councilman Talkington,
1:10:45 And I'm thinking that you're going to by default see greater participation at places
1:10:51 like City Park and places where there's an event where a mass amount of beverages are
1:10:57 being distributed or purchased.
1:10:58 And then, you know, so my thought is probably that's where the need is at least when I've
1:11:03 received comments from the community about why don't we have recycling in our parks.
1:11:07 It's usually a question related to City Park.
1:11:12 And I was wondering if you had considered a lot of bins that you see in other cities
1:11:18 are like, they're usually dark green, kind of wire, you know, bars on the outside, not
1:11:24 bars is not a good way to describe it, I'm not sure what it is.
1:11:27 But usually in cities, larger cities, I mean that I see that recycle, there's one receptacle
1:11:33 and it's divided.
1:11:35 The behavioral concept behind it is that you have to throw it in either side and so you're
1:11:41 you're going to do what's most convenient and if it's equally convenient you will recycle
1:11:46 just the same that you would throw it away.
1:11:48 So I see how this is a similar concept.
1:11:52 Is there a thought to maybe going to that type of receptacle?
1:11:58 I mean it's pretty common in other cities and I don't know how much more effort or
1:12:04 expense that type of bin would be.
1:12:08 I guess when I imagined recycling in the parks, I kind of thought of having the receptacle have a built-in recycling portion.
1:12:17 And since we do single stream recycling, it seems that you may only need two sides.
1:12:24 And I see how you've considered possibly the issue of having trash thrown into the recycle bin.
1:12:31 So I see how this option protects, I guess, the trash from getting into the recycle.
1:12:38 But I would encourage us to maybe take advantage of those locations where you're going to have greater participation in the recycling.
1:12:47 I think it's great in the neighborhood parks, but I would agree that maybe at Harmon or Sunway Soccer or the City Park.
1:12:55 There's a greater need.
1:12:57 As far as who pays for the cost, currently when you have a special event in the City Park, does the event organizer
1:13:07 their own trash services, is that part of the process right now?
1:13:12 A lot of them do that, so they absorb that cost themselves, and that's something that, you know,
1:13:17 besides if we implement this there, do we pass the cost on, or do we force these lords of end users
1:13:23 say you have to recycle? We don't care how you recycle, but you have to recycle and take care of yourself.
1:13:29 You know, with, I know Les talked about with these bins, if there's something to do at City Park,
1:13:33 would recommend having one by every trash can.
1:13:36 Taught my head, I say, during the summer we have three trash cans at City Park in our
1:13:40 guys who check those every day.
1:13:42 You know, these bins, we would have to move them every other week whenever that day is
1:13:46 pick up, pick a Thursday when they pick up guard the well.
1:13:48 Actually, I don't know what recycling day that is.
1:13:51 The Hairy Barrie for Service will do this writing.
1:13:55 Tom, we'll be next Tuesday.
1:13:57 Les, if you're going to speak, could you come forward because it's televised and folks
1:14:00 can't hear you?
1:14:03 With the city park, that would be a Monday service day.
1:14:07 We're originally looking at these at every other week's service.
1:14:11 We could add them into a weekly service.
1:14:13 We're there, it's not that far out of the recycled truck's route to get there on a weekly basis.
1:14:19 But kind of my thought with something like that size, if it's not convenient to wear garbage cans at, people aren't going to recycle.
1:14:25 If there's a garbage can here and a recycled cart over there, it's not going to work.
1:14:30 So we're going to have to have them either reduce the number of garbage cans to make them
1:14:35 walk a little further to reduce the number of recycled containers.
1:14:39 There's another thought.
1:14:40 But if we don't have one side by side, everything's going to go into the blue garbage can or
1:14:47 the blue barrel of the dentist has, as people have out the parks.
1:14:52 You're exactly right.
1:14:53 I think that is accurate.
1:14:57 If they're not side by side right there.
1:14:59 we'll just do what's more convenient but my my comment to Dennis just as a follow-up would be
1:15:06 you know I don't know if we could force people to recycle I mean if we're saying to them you're
1:15:10 responsible to arrange for your own trash slash recycle services I'm not sure we could force that
1:15:18 but we I believe we should have recycling and trash available in the city park if it fills up at an
1:15:26 an event, you know, it fills up and I guess that is tricky on how do you make them pay
1:15:35 for it because they are using the service, but I don't want that to be limiting of our
1:15:41 ability to recycle.
1:15:42 I mean, we may just have to incorporate it into our sanitation services.
1:15:50 Unless you might want to stay a little closer just in case, okay, because there might be
1:15:54 other questions to you but I thought I'd just give you a chance to sit down.
1:15:58 Greg Lanning. Dennis. I'm assuming that we're operating in the same rules of single stream
1:16:05 as for these pilot projects as we do with our neighbors or neighborhood pickups.
1:16:11 Yes. Because my thought process would be, you know, thinking back to some of the
1:16:16 large events in City Park, I'm pretty sure that the Bear Garden, they go ahead and
1:16:21 recycle their own because those are high value recycle because they're all a
1:16:25 little bit of cans and so they can they can they probably haul their own out
1:16:29 that's what I'm betting I don't know that for case but I think because you can't
1:16:33 leave there with the beverage and so there's a possibility there because that
1:16:39 that's the part I was trying to get to is I think they were looking at a
1:16:42 somewhat of a high value item on some of these events that they're gonna have
1:16:48 way more aluminum than our normal signal stream would have.
1:16:52 But I don't know anyway, I'm saying you're thinking in my mind, I'm not coming up with
1:16:56 a way to separate that out, have that go to some place so we can actually make some money
1:17:00 on it because PSI, they don't want to have two separate contracts I'm sure, and who they're
1:17:06 getting rid of it for.
1:17:07 So that was about what I thought, if there's a way to, because I think some of these are
1:17:11 probably going to be more high value recycling than our normal single stream, but how do
1:17:17 you separated, how do you make it work? I'm talking to Circle's Air, I apologize to
1:17:22 that. But I do like it. If possible, you know, I say if this is a pilot for this
1:17:28 year, I think the first place that I would suggest that we expand to would be
1:17:31 City Park as well if we can work out a way to make that work. That's our most
1:17:35 visible, less our most popular. Although I'm sure, because I think that the news
1:17:40 last night, I think that there were 2,000 soccer players for that tournament and
1:17:45 plus probably another 68,000 parents that came with those
1:17:50 2,000 kids and so, you know, that was a huge crowd out there
1:17:55 and if you showed the traffic driving in and out there,
1:17:58 it was a traffic nightmare of its own.
1:18:00 And so, the sun way again for those big events
1:18:05 would be another high value place.
1:18:08 But if they took care of it and recycled on their own,
1:18:11 great, that's what we'd like to even thank Chris for doing it.
1:18:15 I do know one thing, you know, like, especially at our
1:18:17 Speronos Sports Complex, it's, you know, we have a lot of
1:18:19 people that come in and collect aluminum cans, so usually,
1:18:23 they even dig through our garbage, they get aluminum cans.
1:18:26 So typically, like at Harman or Frontier, you know,
1:18:29 they're not.
1:18:30 Or the golf course.
1:18:31 Or the golf course, there's no aluminum cans that be
1:18:33 recycled because we have people out there collecting
1:18:35 what's going on here.
1:18:36 But some of the different parts, we don't get a lot there
1:18:38 just because you don't have a high volume, you know,
1:18:41 of trash or aluminum cans in there.
1:18:43 There's especially the fence at City Park. I've witnessed this more of the plastic bottles. That's where it seems like if you're selling water
1:18:50 That's what you're selling plastic bottle
1:18:52 That's where I see it. There's definitely a need at City Park for something for the recycle bottles
1:18:58 You know most of the bird guards they sell out of keg
1:19:01 So they don't have the aluminum cans
1:19:03 There's you don't see a lot of aluminum cans of City Park. It's more plastic bottles or the I guess I must be buying the gelato's and that's always
1:19:10 or you see more of the plastic cups or anything else.
1:19:15 Sean Verger.
1:19:17 So I was going to just say that I think piloting this
1:19:20 in these parks is a good idea.
1:19:23 I don't disagree with Rebecca that if it's successful,
1:19:26 that over time we should maybe look
1:19:28 at maybe a more permanent way of having those structures.
1:19:34 My concern with that though is it suddenly puts all
1:19:37 of the burden of the work on city staff,
1:19:42 because now you're taking bags out,
1:19:45 putting it in some place, getting it in some place,
1:19:47 whereas with this, it's the same as at home,
1:19:50 while your car to the curb,
1:19:51 and it'll get picked up and go back.
1:19:53 So I do think there is something
1:19:55 we need to keep in mind about convenience.
1:19:58 I also think that for Twin Falls residents,
1:20:00 we're trained to know that this bin is the recycling bin.
1:20:05 So I think keeping that same look
1:20:07 is a good function.
1:20:09 So I think until we see if it's successful,
1:20:14 we should keep going with the bins.
1:20:16 I'm only concerned with doing it at City Park
1:20:18 with 30 cans, is 30 bins and 30 cans
1:20:21 around City Park doesn't look great.
1:20:25 I mean, that's a lot of stuff scattered around City Park.
1:20:29 So maybe it's Oregon Trail Sports Complex
1:20:33 or Harmon or somewhere, maybe it can be tried to see if it works,
1:20:39 but I am concerned I don't want to create some giant new burden
1:20:43 upon park staff to be hauling trash around.
1:20:47 Another kind of trash around to get it.
1:20:49 And that was definitely one of my concerns about,
1:20:51 especially looking at how do we handle it?
1:20:54 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:20:59 I think you guys are on the right track
1:21:00 with your pilot program going the right direction.
1:21:02 Just a thought on City Park.
1:21:04 Maybe we could just put one or two recycling bins near the ban shell because that's where
1:21:08 most of the events happen and we'd still collect a large portion of it there and see
1:21:14 how it goes if we wanted to try City Park and that might just be a spot instead of trying
1:21:19 to cover the whole thing.
1:21:21 And the sporting events again, I think if you're going to do the baseball tournament, softball
1:21:26 tournaments type thing, to me that would be okay for the event organizers to either make
1:21:32 get part of the contract that they can buy that service from the city or provide their own at their discretion.
1:21:42 Dennis, I've heard all kinds of things from Council tonight, did you get any guidance?
1:21:46 I'm on the right track.
1:21:48 And see if we can somehow implement it, I do agree, somehow we can get something at City Park.
1:21:54 And the sports complex is see how we can implement that, but it's really not too much of an effort by city staff.
1:22:02 It's something that may be our recommendation of it,
1:22:04 but we'll be assembling in here and let's pass that cost
1:22:07 onto those vendors as they just know upfront.
1:22:10 They may have additional costs for the recycling programs.
1:22:13 And then you will, after the first year of each event,
1:22:16 you can kind of really, because first right now,
1:22:18 we're just going to be kind of a wild gas
1:22:21 about how many bands you need out.
1:22:23 I know what Western days, a lot of those garbage cans
1:22:26 fill up during the day, they take them
1:22:29 to the 30-yard dumpster they have rolled up,
1:22:31 and they dump them, and you know,
1:22:33 so in the other bands they roll them out
1:22:34 and they get picked up, you know, that next day.
1:22:37 So, some of those events, you know,
1:22:39 that the amount of garbage is tremendous out there,
1:22:43 but also it's a lot of the,
1:22:44 could be recyclable materials, too,
1:22:47 you could prevent from going to the landfill.
1:22:49 Well, I think we also endorsed
1:22:50 your neighborhood park concept, too.
1:22:53 Started low and slow, but work and build on what does work.
1:22:57 Yes.
1:22:59 Thank you, Dennis.
1:23:00 Thank you, Council.
1:23:02 We have two more items on our regular items
1:23:04 for consideration that includes our public input
1:23:07 and thank you last for coming this evening.
1:23:09 And then we have two public hearings.
1:23:10 The public hearing state that they will not start
1:23:13 any earlier than six.
1:23:14 We're really successful with that tonight
1:23:16 because it did not start any earlier than six.
1:23:19 But we do have two other items,
1:23:21 but right now I would like to take a seven minute recess.
1:23:29 We are going to the next item on the agenda,
1:23:32 which is number seven strategic plan update.
1:23:36 on a few of the police departments 2014 objectives,
1:23:40 and we have our disdain chief, Brian Pike, with us.
1:23:44 I don't want to take any of the glory,
1:23:45 but this is the good stuff, right?
1:23:48 Absolutely.
1:23:49 We're really proud of our men and women
1:23:50 what they're doing in the community and how they're doing it.
1:23:52 So tonight, we've got a number of them here, Captain Anthony
1:23:56 Barnard and Officer Steven Gassert.
1:23:58 And they're going to update you on some of the things
1:24:00 that we've been doing related to our strategic plan.
1:24:03 So you're going to hear a little bit about what we call
1:24:05 but we're really into acronyms and what that stands for is data-driven approaches to crime
1:24:10 and traffic safety. Captain Barnhart will explain that. We want to talk a little bit about our
1:24:15 involvement with the crisis intervention team or crisis intervention training related specifically
1:24:19 to what's happening with mental health in our community and Officer Gassert has been through
1:24:24 that program and he's going to talk a little bit about that. And then he would like to share
1:24:29 with you a focus that he has in the junior high right now and probably will continue to
1:24:34 develop. He's got an educational program focused around violence in school
1:24:39 bullying, which he calls a bully bucket, which I think you'll find really
1:24:44 informative. So with that I'll turn it over to Captain Martin.
1:24:49 Good evening, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council. Tonight I would like to update all
1:24:56 of you on our strategic plan objective related to DEDEX. And what I would like
1:25:01 to do tonight is basically just give you a brief overview of what DEDEX is
1:25:06 and then talk about what we are doing with it at the Twin Falls Police Department.
1:25:13 First of all, DDEX is an operational model.
1:25:16 DDEX was developed in 2008 by the Department of Justice
1:25:21 and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration,
1:25:24 and what it does is it takes our data related to vehicle crashes and crimes
1:25:31 and it overlays that information on a map,
1:25:34 helps us to deploy police officers in that area, a specific geographical area to address the
1:25:41 crime and crashes. The overall goal of DDACs is to reduce the incidence of crime and crashes
1:25:55 within a specific geographical area. So keep in mind that we're not talking about the entire
1:26:01 city, this is narrowed down to a specific geographical area. And what DEDEX does for
1:26:11 us is that it shows a clear relationship between crashes and crimes, it renews our emphasis
1:26:16 on traffic safety and provides flexible deployment strategies. Now here's where I really struggled
1:26:23 when I went to the formal training of DEDEX, was what is the relationship? I mean, how
1:26:30 How do we address crime and vehicle crashes at the same time within a specific geographical
1:26:35 area?
1:26:36 I was having a hard time really wrapping my head around that initially when I was sitting
1:26:40 through this training.
1:26:42 But the one common denominator is the vehicle.
1:26:45 So most of the times when people commit crimes, they will have to drive to a location, commit
1:26:51 the crime, and then leave.
1:26:53 Obviously, vehicle accidents, people are crashing while they're in their vehicle, if we can
1:26:58 employ high visibility patrol and high traffic stops within that area, maybe we can reduce
1:27:06 some of those crimes and some of those crashes.
1:27:20 So why DDACs?
1:27:21 DDACs is good because we have increasing demands and limited resources and DDACs shows us exactly
1:27:30 where we need to deploy.
1:27:33 We also have conflicting and competing demands for our service.
1:27:36 When crashes often occur in close proximity and crimes often involve motor vehicles, vehicle
1:27:42 stops can also yield very important information or intelligence.
1:27:53 The nice thing about DDACS is that really any police department or sheriff's department
1:27:58 can employ DDACS and there are several organizations across the nation that are currently using
1:28:03 DDACS.
1:28:04 It does not matter the size of the department or the setting.
1:28:09 I'll do a quick case study for you.
1:28:13 This comes out of the Shawnee Police Department, just outside Kansas City, Missouri.
1:28:17 They have a population of about 62,000 people, and they patrol 40 square miles.
1:28:24 In 2010, they had a rising crime rate.
1:28:28 Unemployment was around 6%.
1:28:29 They had 84 police officers.
1:28:32 And in July, they initiated their DDEX, their operational model.
1:28:39 They specifically focused in on the 75th Street Corridor.
1:28:43 Now they're running it a little bit differently
1:28:46 than we are, and I'll get into that
1:28:47 when I bring up the maps.
1:28:49 But they ran their operational model for one year,
1:28:53 and this is what they realized.
1:28:56 Decreasing residential burglary,
1:28:57 auto burglary, traffic, crashes, vandalism,
1:29:00 and all targeted crimes.
1:29:05 So what is the TFPD?
1:29:07 What is the Twin Falls Police Department
1:29:08 want to get out of this?
1:29:09 We want to have effective, inefficient deployment
1:29:13 of our police officers, and we want to reduce crime and social harm, and what have we done
1:29:19 so far? To date, six police officers have been trained at the formal DDEX training. Here's
1:29:26 an interesting piece is that all new officers when they attend the Patrol Academy in post
1:29:31 will receive a segment or a block of this training. Crime maps have been developed, and
1:29:36 I have to mention the city's GIS specialist, Robin Wilson, who helped me develop these
1:29:43 and really without her, this would not have gotten off the ground.
1:29:48 Hot spots have been identified, so the map that I actually handed out to you,
1:29:53 and we're going to look at it, they're called point density heat maps.
1:29:58 And the red spot would be the area that we would be deploying to to patrol,
1:30:05 and we call that a hot spot, or a point density hot spot.
1:30:09 And operational strategies have been discussed, and officers have currently been deployed.
1:30:15 We started this in February.
1:30:20 Now the idea is that you have to focus in on specific crimes.
1:30:24 Obviously crashes are going to be on the map, but we want to address crimes that we think
1:30:29 that we would be able to either displace or discourage someone from committing.
1:30:37 So for an example, if someone is in their home committing a domestic battery and a police
1:30:43 officer is driving down the road, the odds are that that couple is probably going to continue
1:30:48 to fight just because a police officer is driving through their neighborhood, may not persuade
1:30:54 them to stop fighting, but take for example vehicle or shoplifting or vehicle burglary.
1:31:03 If a police officer is in the area and a person that is about ready to commit that crime
1:31:07 sees a police officer that may persuade them not to actually commit that crime.
1:31:12 So we've actually targeted damage property to both private and businesses, bad checks,
1:31:17 bad credit card fraud, theft of services, petty theft, grant theft, and shoplifting and
1:31:23 vehicle burglary.
1:31:24 And if you want to pull up one of the maps that I gave you, specifically the October
1:31:34 through December.
1:31:45 So for the month of October, through December of 2013, between the hours of 8 in the morning
1:31:51 until 10 o'clock at night, we identified that most of our vehicle crashes within the city
1:31:57 and crimes keep in mind that they have to overlay to create the hotspot were occurring
1:32:03 around Washington and Poland.
1:32:08 We deployed officers into that area for a month and a half and I'll show you the results
1:32:12 of that in just a moment.
1:32:31 The map that we're currently working on is January through March of this year, and we
1:32:37 did have an effect on the original hotspot, and we have since moved to the area of blue
1:32:44 lakes and falls.
1:32:46 That's where officers are currently being deployed to.
1:32:50 The idea is that these maps are generated on a quarterly basis, and that officers will
1:32:55 spend 30 minutes of their 12-hour shift in this hotspot.
1:33:01 They are no longer in the call rotation.
1:33:03 This is dedicated time to this specific area,
1:33:06 and it's high visibility patrol,
1:33:08 and a lot of contacts through traffic stops.
1:33:29 Then the last map is comparison map.
1:33:33 So if you look over here to the right,
1:33:36 that is the October through December hotspot.
1:33:40 Those were the numbers from the hotspot.
1:33:43 Then to the left, the same area,
1:33:45 We see a reduction in periwglery shoplifting, vehicle burglaries,
1:33:51 effective services, and accident damage only.
1:34:03 And if you go down to the bottom of the map, the new hotspot
1:34:06 will show you the numbers compared from October through
1:34:11 December to 2013 through January through March of 2014.
1:34:23 So it's interesting.
1:34:24 I'm really excited about it.
1:34:25 Keep in mind that this is one tool.
1:34:27 We have several ways that we deploy our officers.
1:34:31 This is just another tool for us to use.
1:34:33 I really like it because it takes out any bias
1:34:38 by using the data.
1:34:40 It's clear, it's relevant, it's timely.
1:34:42 So I'm really excited to have the police department
1:34:47 operating this way.
1:34:50 So Captain, just that additional presence of that car
1:34:57 decreases the probability of vehicle accidents.
1:35:02 I think so. An example would be, what do you do
1:35:06 when you see a police car in your rear rear mirror? I know the first thing that I do, and I've been doing this for 21 years,
1:35:12 has taken my foot off the gas and checked my speed.
1:35:16 So that's kind of the effect that
1:35:19 and we realize that, we recognize that when you're in a marked patrol vehicle
1:35:25 and you're driving down the street,
1:35:26 you immediately recognize that people are driving slower.
1:35:30 They are paying attention to the terms that they make,
1:35:34 the traffic lights, they're behaving completely differently
1:35:37 than if no police officers were in the area.
1:35:43 How do you get people out there?
1:35:46 Captain, I have a question and maybe a point.
1:35:50 I know that random patrols through the Kansas City study
1:35:54 and others have been proven that random patrol
1:35:56 really doesn't work because people just wait until the police go by and then commit their
1:36:00 crime anyway. But this is concentrated and high visibility for extended amount of time
1:36:09 in areas that you're seeing problems. My question would be are we just pushing the crimes
1:36:14 to other areas or is it proven that it actually overall reduces crime because sometimes we
1:36:21 can move crime onto another area because we're concentrating one area. What's the research
1:36:27 around that?
1:36:30 They did not provide any specific research to that, but they, and we know this, that we
1:36:36 may just displace crime. I think that we will prevent some, but we also recognize that we'll
1:36:42 displace it to another location. Hopefully that location is outside the city of Twin Falls.
1:36:51 Sheriff might not agree with that.
1:36:55 OK, Greg Lanning.
1:36:57 I was also wondering on that displacement,
1:36:59 since you were concentrating, and you
1:37:01 know from data where these problems are occurring,
1:37:05 is a chance that that's because more people congregate there.
1:37:08 So thus, you really aren't displacing
1:37:10 that you're just having people, not just the crime,
1:37:13 but I'm thinking of the traffic accidents
1:37:15 that they're slowing down.
1:37:16 They're not going to necessarily go speed somewhere else.
1:37:18 The crime, I can see the possible displacement,
1:37:20 But I think on the, I don't know about accidents.
1:37:22 I think that just makes you more aware of how you're driving
1:37:25 and maybe for sure aren't texting or doing some of the things
1:37:29 that cause, you know, accidents through distraction.
1:37:36 I agree, I think that we are actually preventing the crashes.
1:37:39 The crime may be not, the crime may just be getting displaced,
1:37:43 but I would agree that the accidents,
1:37:44 we may be actually preventing accidents in that area.
1:37:48 And since we've had a little struggle with not only the pharmacies as well as the banks
1:37:55 of late ever, when I took my tour with Cameron Ariel up at the new branch of Zion's downtown
1:38:02 Boise, they actually designed their branch to cut down on the chance of a robbery.
1:38:11 If you go in there, they have this very large area and all their offices, you have to walk
1:38:15 through the building to get back to the bank tellers,
1:38:21 and their research had shown that they used to do that.
1:38:25 If you have to walk all the way in there
1:38:26 and all the way out, that's the branch you're just gonna skip
1:38:29 because too much chance for exposure,
1:38:31 too much chance for somebody to see you and things.
1:38:35 So they actually used research to design a bank,
1:38:39 to make sure that it would be less like to be robbed.
1:38:41 I think because they were downtown
1:38:43 is one of the reasons they used it.
1:38:44 Yeah, absolutely. There is a definite research that goes into engineering and design to prevent
1:38:51 crimes, absolutely.
1:38:55 Any further questions for Captain Arnhart regarding?
1:38:58 How long will the program go on?
1:39:01 Yeah, that is one of the things, Councilman, that I want to ensure is that this operational model is sustainable.
1:39:10 And until we show that it is no longer working, we plan on using it.
1:39:15 Okay.
1:39:16 Good.
1:39:18 Great report.
1:39:19 Thank you.
1:39:20 Thank you very much.
1:39:21 I believe that we have Officer Gassert next.
1:39:27 So welcome, sir.
1:39:29 Thank you, Mr. Mayor and Council.
1:39:31 I appreciate the opportunity to come here and some being in the schools.
1:39:36 I'm used to talking to the kids and teaching classes and when I was asked to come talk
1:39:40 to the City Council, I got a little nervous.
1:39:43 It's very similar, Stephen.
1:39:45 So don't bear with me through the nerves.
1:39:48 The first thing that I want to talk about is the CIT, the crisis intervention team training
1:39:53 that I had the opportunity to go to.
1:39:56 I guess my first thing is I wanted to say thank you to the city and the police department
1:40:00 for allowing me the opportunity to go to that training.
1:40:04 When I first heard about it, I'm like, yeah, it sounds like an interest training and I'd
1:40:08 love to go to that.
1:40:09 But I had no idea what I was going to retrieve from the training and the information that
1:40:14 I was going to be able to get out of it.
1:40:15 The crisis intervention training was a 40-hour training that myself and four other officers
1:40:21 attended that was put on by the local crisis intervention team.
1:40:27 And through that training, we received different training through the different diagnosis and
1:40:32 different crisis that people are diagnosed with and the different mental medical issues
1:40:39 that they go through, such as bipolar and other disabilities.
1:40:42 So we've achieved quite extensive training specifically in the field of law enforcement
1:40:47 on how to interact with those people that do have those diagnoses and how to better communicate
1:40:54 with them when they are going through those crises, to be able to talk to them and communicate
1:40:59 with them without having to result to other law enforcement measures or different situations
1:41:05 that might arise.
1:41:07 We were also given the opportunity to tour the Canyon View facility and kind of see exactly
1:41:12 the treatment in the different situations that they go through, which was a huge eye-opener
1:41:18 for me as a law enforcement officer.
1:41:19 I'm well versed in taking people in the protective custody, but it always felt like once I dropped
1:41:25 a Moffitt Canyon View, I didn't know where it went from there or the process that went
1:41:29 from there.
1:41:30 So we received quite a bit of training on the Canyon View side of things and the process
1:41:34 that they go through, and also the core side of things.
1:41:39 It was a huge eye-opener for me, and I hope during the future I get to attend more training
1:41:43 on it, and at one point possibly become certified as an instructor, be able to one point, be able
1:41:48 to teach the crisis intervention.
1:41:52 Even being in the schools, currently assigned to the schools, I've been able to start using
1:41:56 some of those tools and resources that I received through that training, working with the students
1:42:01 that some of them in my school being diagnosed with some of those diagnoses and being able
1:42:06 to effectively use those tools.
1:42:08 I've also utilized some of the contacts and the resources that I retrieve from that.
1:42:15 One of those being children's mental health, being able to contact them and use them as
1:42:19 a resource and really been able to build on that partnership, working with children's mental
1:42:24 health and health and welfare to be able to work with these citizens and people in the
1:42:30 public that have been diagnosed with these diagnoses.
1:42:35 That's been my experience.
1:42:37 The four other officers that did go to this training, all of us come from a different section
1:42:43 of the department, whether or not it's a different patrol platoon or one of the other SROs, including
1:42:49 myself.
1:42:50 So I do know that we have gone back to our work groups and explained to them some of the
1:42:54 different tools and resources that we retrieved to be able to communicate with these people
1:42:59 that are going through a crisis situation and different tools
1:43:02 and resources available to be able to help us
1:43:06 through the situations.
1:43:08 So I would love to open it up to any questions
1:43:12 from the Council on the training that I attended.
1:43:14 Rebecca Mills, so I call.
1:43:15 Thank you, Mayor.
1:43:16 Well, I just wanted to say that you're right, Chief.
1:43:20 This is good stuff because mental illness training,
1:43:24 I think, is one of the areas where in the past,
1:43:27 to society in general has really lacked, and I appreciate so much that you're putting forth
1:43:34 this training and educating our officers, and I think that it does so much good in our
1:43:40 community to have that understanding that people with mental illness are just people,
1:43:46 and knowing how to best approach a violent, and a volatile situation is really necessary
1:43:54 you know, to really gain the best outcomes.
1:43:58 So I just want to say thank you for working on this objective
1:44:03 and I fully support more training in this area
1:44:08 and I want to thank you for coming and sharing with us.
1:44:12 Jim Mutt.
1:44:13 Stephen, tell us a little bit about the bully bucket
1:44:16 and all the stuff you're doing there.
1:44:18 The bully bucket, we're getting in this school
1:44:21 One of my passions is trying to make the students feel safe at school.
1:44:28 I want to create a positive, safe learning environment for the students.
1:44:32 When I took the role as a school resource officer, that was one of the topics that I started noticing
1:44:37 becoming an issue.
1:44:38 When I would dive into a student who was having some behavioral issues or incorrigible or starting
1:44:44 to commit crimes in the school, everything kind of started resorting back to that student
1:44:49 and being bullied or being picked on by other students.
1:44:51 And so I kind of identified that as being a common denominator
1:44:55 with the students that I was interacting with day-to-day.
1:44:59 So one of the ideas that was created at Robert Stewart,
1:45:02 February, 2013, I launched the Bully Bucket program.
1:45:06 This is a bucket.
1:45:08 It's just a black paint bucket that sits in my library
1:45:12 at Robert Stewart.
1:45:13 And any student that is filling bullied
1:45:17 is witnessing bullying, a friend's being bullied,
1:45:20 or any type of bullying situation going on at Robert Stewart.
1:45:23 They go into the library and they fill out a slip
1:45:25 that has date, time, location, who's being bullied,
1:45:29 who might have witnessed it,
1:45:30 and a brief description of the bullying situation.
1:45:33 That slip goes into the bucket,
1:45:35 and no one's allowed to retrieve the slips
1:45:37 out of the bucket except for myself.
1:45:39 I go in and I retrieve them,
1:45:41 and I try to get on their average twice a day
1:45:44 to check the book bucket and see if there's any slips in there.
1:45:47 I then review those slips and it begin a mini investigation process.
1:45:52 I guess you could say, I look into the situation, I talked to any of the witnesses that might
1:45:57 be involved.
1:45:58 I talked to the student that reported it and then I investigate the person that was accused
1:46:04 of being the bully.
1:46:07 One of the things about the bully bucket is the students are made aware of that it can
1:46:10 be an anonymous situation.
1:46:12 They don't have to put their names on it.
1:46:15 And then through that investigation, I determine whether or not a minister, I need to work
1:46:20 with my school administration on administering school consequences or whether or not it rises
1:46:25 to the level to need to take criminal action on it.
1:46:29 I then take those slips and I enter them into a computer database so I can start tracking
1:46:35 certain locations, certain times, certain students, certain situations to be able to
1:46:41 redirect my focus and my attention and my downtime.
1:46:45 So if I need to be in the lunchroom during sixth grade
1:46:47 lunch, because that's where I'm getting the most reports,
1:46:49 it allows me to take that research
1:46:51 and direct my attention and my focus into those areas
1:46:55 that might direct my attention.
1:46:59 Last school year, there was, I want
1:47:02 to say, about 119 reports that were made to the bully bucket.
1:47:05 This school year alone, there's only been 29 reports to it.
1:47:09 The reason the drastic decrease in number,
1:47:12 I contributed to the students at Robert Stewart
1:47:15 have really taken this on as their own.
1:47:18 They really take on this bully prevention
1:47:19 and they've made it their own.
1:47:21 And they really started to kind of police themselves.
1:47:24 I see every day in the hallway a student go,
1:47:26 you need to stop picking on that kid
1:47:28 or else I'm going to report it to the bully bucket
1:47:30 or I'm gonna report it to officer gasser.
1:47:32 So they really have taken it upon themselves.
1:47:35 I also believe that it's made the students
1:47:36 feel more comfortable with myself.
1:47:38 They come directly to me and report directly to me
1:47:41 in my office, bullying situations that are going on
1:47:44 with themselves or their friends.
1:47:46 And I haven't started tracking the in-person ones
1:47:50 that are made to me directly in person,
1:47:52 which is my goal this next school year
1:47:54 is to start directly tracking those ones
1:47:56 that are made to me in person.
1:48:00 Thank you.
1:48:01 Thank you.
1:48:02 Chris, talking to you.
1:48:02 Yeah, when I worked with County Juby,
1:48:07 we had a status offender program
1:48:09 And I'm not sure if it's still in operation anymore.
1:48:12 You might check with Sam, whatever his name is at the county.
1:48:16 But those status offenses, like in core gibility and bowling,
1:48:19 there's a linkage to that.
1:48:21 And they're predictors to more serious problems,
1:48:26 the least of which is dropping out of the school.
1:48:28 But I sure hope you can expand this program
1:48:32 to the other middle schools.
1:48:34 And even down to the sixth grade, that sort of thing,
1:48:38 Are you getting the cooperation from the school district to have a mentor and teach to the other schools?
1:48:45 The program this school year was branched out to a Larry Middle School.
1:48:49 A Larry Middle School is doing it.
1:48:51 And then also I worked with the administration at the Oregon Trail Elementary to kind of pilot it at the elementary level.
1:48:58 They had a different program, a different bucket program to where they were using it from the positive things to where someone saw a student doing something good.
1:49:07 something good, they wanted to fill their bucket with positive things, so they currently are
1:49:12 trying to work, they don't want to confuse the students on two different bucket programs,
1:49:17 so they're trying to work on how to best correlate that into the elementary level.
1:49:23 The part of the thing that we're also working with them is educating the students on what
1:49:29 bullying is and the different forms of bullying.
1:49:32 being so close to Prine Elementary, I also work closely with their administration on any
1:49:38 type of bully prevention.
1:49:39 We in October did a United Against Bullying Day that I did at Robert Stewart, and I worked
1:49:44 in conjunction with Prine Elementary to provide at the elementary level.
1:49:51 I also, back in June, attended a conference and was able to present this program to other
1:49:59 local areas and have reached out and had other cities reach out to me to get them piloting
1:50:06 this program in their school.
1:50:08 So it's definitely something that.
1:50:10 Well, excellent job.
1:50:11 Just keep it up and don't take your foot off the gas.
1:50:15 You might get a speeding ticket.
1:50:17 But we got to take care of the other issue.
1:50:19 That bowling is a much more serious thing.
1:50:21 Most people realize good for you.
1:50:23 Thank you.
1:50:24 Chris, I think you're talking about SAM sites.
1:50:27 Yeah, sites, sites, SAM sites.
1:50:29 And the status offender program still is in place.
1:50:32 Very good.
1:50:34 If you haven't met and talked to Sam, I think it would be HUBA.
1:50:37 Thank you.
1:50:38 Rebecca Milsoyka.
1:50:39 Thank you Mayor.
1:50:40 Yeah, congratulations on your program.
1:50:42 I think that's excellent.
1:50:43 It's great to see that you're creating a community that's against bullying.
1:50:49 And I think really that's the heart of the issue.
1:50:52 So what do kids who are at other schools do?
1:50:55 What are the resources that they have if they don't have this bully bucket?
1:50:59 How do we spread this out to not just the grade schools,
1:51:04 but are you seeing bullying issues in the high schools?
1:51:07 Or how might we spread this program out
1:51:10 to all of the schools?
1:51:12 So I take all the information and training that I have
1:51:15 and I provide it to my other school resource officers
1:51:18 that I work with.
1:51:20 One of the big key factors is getting the administration
1:51:23 on board.
1:51:24 That was one of the biggest hurdles that I wouldn't,
1:51:28 didn't really have to overcome, but I kind of had to sell it to them, especially when it
1:51:32 comes to that whole interacting with the students and investigating those type of things, I kind
1:51:37 of had to sell it to them. Like, I'm not there to get anyone into trouble and take it on as
1:51:43 a disciplinary procedure. I wanted to take on this topic as more of a education and then
1:51:49 also approach to stopping those type of behavioral issues and letting it lead up to that. So the
1:51:56 The first key was getting the administration on board, and I have to say the school district
1:52:00 and the administration I work after explaining them to what I wanted to do, jumped on board
1:52:06 with it and allowed me to take it and run with it.
1:52:10 I do think that the bullying is an issue in all of the schools that we have, and at some
1:52:16 point I would love to branch it out to all the schools that we have in Twin Falls.
1:52:20 It is something that, and being in the middle school,
1:52:24 I take on the burden and all the work that goes into it,
1:52:27 not having school resource officers in the elementary schools.
1:52:31 You would really have to have that cooperation
1:52:34 with the administration to have someone on that site
1:52:37 going and checking the bully bucket every day
1:52:39 and investigating and administering any consequences
1:52:44 or any sanctions that might need to come from it.
1:52:46 So it would have to be approached
1:52:48 between the police department and the school district
1:52:51 to determine who at the elementary levels
1:52:54 would take on that burden.
1:52:58 Okay, I would encourage us to look into that.
1:53:00 You know, maybe it's the school counselor,
1:53:01 maybe it's someone there that can address this issue,
1:53:05 but I would encourage us to try to expand
1:53:09 this program in our schools.
1:53:10 Thank you.
1:53:13 Officer Gasser, I don't see any other lights.
1:53:15 I want to take time to say thank you to you
1:53:17 and also, Captain Barnhart, for your reports tonight.
1:53:20 And I have a quick question to the chief.
1:53:26 First, I want to say what a testament
1:53:28 to your department and the leadership from your department
1:53:31 to see these innovative, progressive tactics
1:53:35 that we're implementing in our police department.
1:53:40 So kudos to you and your leadership.
1:53:42 Thank you for both these officers coming this evening
1:53:45 and making these presentations.
1:53:47 We have one question about Officer Gassert's training that he's received.
1:53:51 Are we going to expand that training to other officers in the mental health capacity, the
1:53:58 realm?
1:53:59 Do you have plans for doing that in the future?
1:54:01 As a matter of fact, it's funny you would mention that because a meeting with Mandy Thompson
1:54:06 who is going to work with the Region 5 Mental Health Board on finding some grant opportunities
1:54:12 to help us.
1:54:13 One of the challenges is that because it's a 40-hour block, we would like to train all
1:54:16 of our police officers provide all this training.
1:54:19 The challenges is getting them there,
1:54:21 getting them away from their jobs
1:54:22 and their duties for 40 hours.
1:54:24 And then obviously back-filling their role.
1:54:27 So we believe that with the help
1:54:29 of the reached five mental health board
1:54:31 that we can make that reality.
1:54:33 And what I think is interesting,
1:54:34 and Officer Gassert is, he's very humble and he's very kind,
1:54:38 but he did have an opportunity to present statewide.
1:54:42 And while, as part of that presentation,
1:54:44 And he was awarded the Innovation of the Year award by the Idaho Council of Domestic Violence
1:54:49 and the Victim Assistance, so it's something that what Officer Gaster is doing is recognized
1:54:53 throughout the state.
1:54:54 Probably more importantly, all three examples that we're talking about tonight are really
1:54:58 just examples of good old fashioned problem solving.
1:55:01 So we're really proud of what the department's doing and we appreciate the opportunity to
1:55:04 share it with you tonight.
1:55:06 Thank you Chief, anything further from Council?
1:55:08 Mm-hmm.
1:55:09 Very well.
1:55:10 Again, thank you.
1:55:15 Thank you all three.
1:55:17 on to the next item on the agenda. It's public input and or items from City Manager City Council.
1:55:23 Anyone from the public would like to address the Council at this point. We do have two public hearings coming up and I might remind those that are in audience for those if you wish to testify.
1:55:33 If you're not one of the presenters, which is to sign up in the back. But is there anyone from the public that would like to address Council this evening?
1:55:45 see no one coming forward, city manager.
1:55:50 Mr. Mayor, members of the council just really quickly on the 20th at 1.30 to 3 o'clock, we
1:56:00 are going to be having a conversation with some of our community partners about the ADA
1:56:06 transition plan that was forwarded to you.
1:56:11 That will be here in this room and we will be having a conversation with them and then
1:56:17 And we will also be having a conversation with members of our community about the draft
1:56:21 ADA transition plan in hopes that we will be able to bring those comments to you as we hold
1:56:28 a community conversation about the need for improving ADA access and transitioning within
1:56:35 our community.
1:56:36 So, Mark, the calendar the 20th, 1.30 to 3 o'clock here for those community groups, and
1:56:44 if you're interested in coming, that would be great.
1:56:46 And then in addition to that, we'll be also working in setting up a subsequent meeting for
1:56:51 just members of the community who may not be specifically attached to one of those groups
1:56:56 that we've invited.
1:56:58 Thank you, Travis.
1:57:00 City Council, anything from our City Council?
1:57:02 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:57:03 Thank you.
1:57:05 I would like to take the opportunity to first of all remind any of my fellow council members
1:57:10 who've signed up to be judges for Kite Day, that it's coming up this weekend.
1:57:15 It is running Saturday from 10 to 5 and Sunday from 11 to 5 and real quick categories that
1:57:22 you can compete in.
1:57:23 The first day they're going to have kite fights where you can win a prize for knocking
1:57:28 other people's kites out of the air.
1:57:30 The longest line and the highest angle on Sunday since it is Mother's Day, the first
1:57:36 mother to get her kite up in the air will get a special prize.
1:57:39 The youngest and oldest competitors, the best homemade kite, and they have all kinds of great
1:57:46 things going on out there.
1:57:48 So come out and fly a kite and enjoy the wind.
1:57:52 Suzanne, could you remind us, those of us that have signed up and don't know what we're
1:57:56 supposed to do, how do we get tuned up?
1:58:01 It's my own fault, I'm sure.
1:58:02 But I said I would judge, but I don't know when.
1:58:05 I will call our Youth Council President and have her send out those emails.
1:58:09 I'm sure she has, and it's my fault, but if I could get tuned up on that, that'd be great.
1:58:13 All right, so it's good.
1:58:14 Thank you.
1:58:15 Anything else from council?
1:58:16 All right, we do have two public hearings coming up.
1:58:21 It looks like we are going to have the presenters make the first presentation, and then we will
1:58:30 turn it over to, it looks like Jonathan Spenlove will do the staff report afterwards.
1:58:35 So without further ado, we're going to move right into our public hearings.
1:58:39 One is request for zoning district change and zoning map amendment to rezone 0.83 giver
1:58:45 take acres from R6 Pro to C1 for property located on the south side of the 200 block
1:58:52 of Shoop Avenue West.
1:58:54 Cara of E. Dan Carter on behalf of cowboy investments and I believe we have E. Dan Carter here.
1:59:01 Welcome, sir.
1:59:02 Thank you.
1:59:04 I am Dan Carter, and I am here tonight to request a zoning change on a particular piece of property.
1:59:11 I own them just off a chute, it's actually a chute address, and it is the property, I guess,
1:59:21 better described as that property being directly behind and adjacent to the Rock Creek restaurant
1:59:28 and directly behind the A&W.
1:59:31 That property, I've had it since 2009.
1:59:33 I've used it a lot longer than that.
1:59:35 It's been used for truck parking for as long as I can remember.
1:59:39 And I've owned the property and I'm here to ask to rezone,
1:59:46 or a zoning change.
1:59:47 It is now zoned, our state residential, I believe,
1:59:50 and I would like to zone it commercial.
1:59:54 So, you know, the neighbors around that I've talked
2:00:01 talk to the Stan and Terry at the Rock Creek are firmly in support of it. Eric Wadi from
2:00:08 the Apollo's in agreement. He would be a big supporter. The only residence in the area
2:00:16 is right in the very corner. Everything else in that block is primarily commercial now.
2:00:23 And the only residence is right in the corner of that piece of property. In fact, at one
2:00:28 time, a property owner granted an easement I believe for a place for that person to park
2:00:34 their car and that residence is a rental. Everything else on that block fits in as a commercial
2:00:40 mode. I understand that I would have to get a special use permit but what I would like
2:00:51 to see happen to the property if I was not to sell it, what I have in mind is I would
2:00:57 I'd like to put in a nice RV park.
2:01:02 I think there's a great deal of the traveling public
2:01:05 that would like to experience downtown
2:01:09 windfall, so to speak.
2:01:11 And I would like to provide a park that
2:01:14 was nice, not crowded 12 to 15 units, grass, curbing,
2:01:21 those kind of things.
2:01:22 We're right straight across the street
2:01:25 from the new Baxter Dog Park.
2:01:27 I think that would be, I think there's a lot of the traveling public that probably
2:01:31 traveled with their dogs.
2:01:33 I think that would appeal to them.
2:01:35 And right out the gate is probably one of the finest restaurants in Twin Falls.
2:01:39 If you go out the gate to A&W, there's fuel, there's McDonald's,
2:01:44 everything within walking distance of this particular piece of property.
2:01:49 So that's kind of why I'm here.
2:01:54 I don't think there would be any kind of an adverse effect
2:01:57 to the city's comprehensive plan.
2:02:00 I don't think that they would, for example,
2:02:01 the compatibility with all the surrounding area,
2:02:06 I think would be fine.
2:02:08 So there's really, I think the property lends itself
2:02:12 a great deal more to be in a piece of commercial property
2:02:15 than it does residential.
2:02:17 So, thank you, sir.
2:02:19 Thank you.
2:02:20 It looks like we have a question, Chris, talking.
2:02:21 Yeah, just to reference the map,
2:02:23 and you said that the property is substantially all C1,
2:02:26 But the purple on the east and west of you, that is,
2:02:32 are six still, is it not?
2:02:36 I believe that is correct,
2:02:37 but there are commercial businesses that are there.
2:02:40 And how did that happen?
2:02:42 Well, they are, in fact,
2:02:44 I think you could probably answer the question better.
2:02:46 Okay, all right.
2:02:47 That's during your staff report.
2:02:48 Very good stuff.
2:02:49 And then what about the properties adjacent
2:02:51 to the mobile home park now,
2:02:53 the, that'd be the east side there?
2:02:57 you're going to cover that too.
2:03:00 I'll just shut up.
2:03:01 Thank you.
2:03:02 Thank you, sir.
2:03:03 Well, sir, I'm sure we'll have other questions for you.
2:03:06 If you want to have a seat, we'll turn it over to Jonathan
2:03:09 Spandler.
2:03:10 Welcome, Jonathan.
2:03:11 Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the council.
2:03:13 So this is, Dan, is talking about the rezone currently.
2:03:17 The map, it's hard to see this area is all zoned our six
2:03:20 with the professional office overlay.
2:03:22 So when he's talking about commercial uses,
2:03:24 office uses or a dental or medical. There's a day care over here, which is more of a commercial
2:03:31 type use, not necessarily residential use as far as the R6 goes. So the only property that
2:03:37 is currently zoned R6 that's using it as residential is the house immediately adjacent.
2:03:44 Also to the north, this is also a medical facility. I can't remember the name of its Canyon view
2:03:50 you, that's directly to the north, down the road a little bit where you get into the R6
2:03:55 with residential uses over here.
2:03:58 Further to the east is this mobile home park here.
2:04:03 That goes all the way to Washington with a few other McDonald's at the corner just off
2:04:09 the map here.
2:04:11 So those are the uses around it to the south, you mentioned A&W, the Apollo, some of the
2:04:18 and then that abuts right into that mobile home park.
2:04:21 So there's the general overview of what's around it.
2:04:25 This is just for the zoning district map change from R6 to C1.
2:04:30 If the zoning request is granted,
2:04:33 according to the narrative that Dan shared,
2:04:35 the RV park or Camp Park would require a special use permit
2:04:38 and he's very aware of that.
2:04:40 The property is currently undeveloped.
2:04:42 Sometimes it's been used as a semi-parking lot
2:04:46 parking lot for people to refuel or to get food there.
2:04:51 We've talked about the properties around it in the public hearing with the planning and
2:04:55 zoning commission.
2:04:56 It's a short staff report.
2:04:59 They determine, they have two tasks, determine whether the request is in conformance with
2:05:02 the comprehensive plan and two to evaluate the request to determine the extent and age
2:05:06 of the amendment.
2:05:08 During that, the planning and zoning commissioners determined that the comprehensive plan, it
2:05:12 was in conformance with the comprehensive plan that defines this area as commercial
2:05:22 retail. That designation defines it as areas that will come in large-scale commercial retail
2:05:28 light industrial office park in similar uses. I also found that the proposal for rezoning
2:05:33 of commercial uses on this site would be considered compatible with the adjacent uses in the area.
2:05:39 There's one single family residence to the west, however the remaining adjacent properties
2:05:43 have been developed with other commercial type uses and allowing this zoning change may
2:05:47 be compatible in nature with the existing land uses developed in this corridor and adjacent
2:05:52 to each other. This has already gone through the planning and zoning commission. They forwarded
2:05:56 the recommendation unanimously to approve this request as presented. Staff concurs with
2:06:03 that assessment and as a staff report.
2:06:07 Do we have any questions for staff this time? Okay. If we have no questions, Council, I'll
2:06:15 go ahead and open up the public testimony portion of this hearing and ask anyone that is interested
2:06:20 in testifying regarding this agenda item to come forward. I'm seeing no one come forward,
2:06:31 so I'll close the public testimony portion and turn it over to staff for council for
2:06:37 any further questions and eventual motion. I see no further questions so we'll close the
2:06:47 public testimony, turn it over to council for their recommendation, Chris talking to
2:06:53 move to authorizes on industry change and zoning map amendment to the 80.83
2:06:59 hundred acres from an RSX pro to C1 and the property on the south side of 200
2:07:07 blockers hoop Avenue West care of ownership of Denon Carter on behalf of
2:07:13 cowboy investments. We have a motion on the floor, seconded by
2:07:18 Kristoff, then seconded by Greg Lanting. Anything further on that motion council?
2:07:24 No, the only thing that bothers me is I don't like to do up-zoning where a person
2:07:32 might turn around and sell it and make a profit without putting the investment of
2:07:38 the property. But I think this has been undeveloped, underutilized, and an
2:07:44 I saw for so long that personally, I'm willing to give Mr. Carter a benefit of the doubt of his plans that he wants to make something but make him a lot of money without just pawning it off as a higher zoning.
2:07:58 So I think it's a good move on the council's part.
2:08:02 Chris, I want to just interject that I go to eat there once in a while, and I always call that the mud puddle parking lot.
2:08:12 There's lots of mud puddles out there when it rains and so I think that this I would really appreciate some development in that area
2:08:20 I think it would be conducive to the area be nice to have that across the way from Baxter Park
2:08:27 And I appreciate your investment in our community
2:08:31 Mr. Carter, so I see no further lights so
2:08:34 Roll call boat. Sure. Chris Hockington. Yes
2:08:39 Rebecca Mills, Ika yes
2:08:41 Suzanne Hawkins?
2:08:43 Yes.
2:08:44 John Bericher?
2:08:45 Yes.
2:08:45 Jim Mann?
2:08:46 Yes.
2:08:47 Greg Lanting?
2:08:48 Yes.
2:08:49 Don Hall?
2:08:50 Yes.
2:08:50 Motion passes 7-0, sir.
2:08:53 Thank you.
2:08:54 Very welcome.
2:08:55 Thank you.
2:08:56 Next item on the agenda is request
2:08:58 for a zoning district change and zoning map amendment
2:09:01 to rezone 6.9 plus or minus acres from R1 variable to SUI
2:09:09 property located west of 3236 Avenue Avenue East within the city's area of
2:09:15 impact CO Leon and Mary core and we have Leon here tonight so welcome sir this is
2:09:28 a resubmission this was submitted last year approximately 14 months ago it was
2:09:39 done asking for the zoning change from R1 variable to the SUI. If you look at the
2:09:52 zoning map virtually everything, every property contiguous to my pasture that
2:09:58 is in the red there is, well all of it is R1 or R2 but nevertheless even though
2:10:10 So it's all R1 and R2 virtually.
2:10:13 All of the property is consistent with SUI already.
2:10:19 Most of it is with the exception of Longbow.
2:10:24 Virtually all of it is one acre, septic, and well.
2:10:29 And that's all that I'm trying to do
2:10:30 is get a design and change request to take it back to that.
2:10:35 The problem is with it being R1 variable.
2:10:39 That's like the fact that it can be high density if it was left that way, but that's not my
2:10:48 concern as much as the city has let me know that there will not be any city services going
2:10:56 out that way in the near or distant future, and that is part of the stipulation of developing
2:11:04 it as far what variables you have to have city services.
2:11:09 So all I wanted to do is revert basically back to county regulations, except it can well
2:11:17 on one acre.
2:11:21 As far as, as I said the difference, R1 variable allows lot size as small as 8,000 square feet.
2:11:32 So as far as my neighbors, I'm sure that they would much rather look at six houses and
2:11:40 and besides them being six houses rather than possible 30 with the 8,000 square feet,
2:11:47 these lots are going to go for upwards of $50,000.
2:11:52 You're not going to file a lot for $50,000, $60,000 and drag a shack out there.
2:11:59 These are going to be nice homes, not ritzy homes, but they're going to be upscale
2:12:05 and they will be representative of what's already there in the neighborhood.
2:12:11 And so, in that pursuit, I did the zoning change request last year, we went through planning and zoning, they passed at seven and nothing, we came to you guys, you guys passed at seven and nothing, and then the county inexplicable, the county commissioners denied it.
2:12:31 And I was a bit, I was uneducated in the whole process, which was part of my problem.
2:12:39 And we didn't really know what angle to take as far as the denial.
2:12:44 By the time I did enough research as far as Idaho land use law, we found out that even
2:12:55 though we had good standing, we only had 28 days to have any action after the denial.
2:13:03 So by the time we got our act together and figured out what we needed to do, it was actually
2:13:08 getting to the point where now it's a year, and that I hope law states that I can just
2:13:15 read, submit the exact same request after it's been a year, so that's what I can do.
2:13:22 Thank you, sir.
2:13:24 Do we have any questions for the applicant?
2:13:26 Rebecca Milsoy?
2:13:28 Thank you, Mayor.
2:13:30 You maybe just answered this question, but I was wondering, is there anything different in
2:13:34 this application than your last application?
2:13:38 Exactly, it was last year.
2:13:40 Okay, and so the accesses, do you have some sort of diagram showing how the lots will be
2:13:51 divided in the accesses?
2:13:54 Would those be onto Addison Avenue?
2:13:57 I don't have an official Mark Jones headline drawn up with the plan that we had last year,
2:14:10 I had done a preliminary one myself where, yes, you can put six lots and a driveway that services all six lots with only one exit on the Addison.
2:14:25 So is that the plan? I recall before I think that the accesses were all going on to Addison and there was some concern about maybe the safety of that, the speed limit along Addison.
2:14:40 It can be done, right away serves single six lots.
2:14:47 Okay, so other than that, nothing is different.
2:14:51 Anything further for the applicant? Mr.
2:14:56 Corp, you'll have a seat. There might be some further questions, and I'll turn it over to Jonathan
2:15:00 Spandlock for staff report. I think Mr. Mayor, members of the council,
2:15:04 the history, Leon Corp did a very good job of summarizing the history.
2:15:08 This is the exact same application came through last year. What we have is reapplying,
2:15:12 which is creating a new set of record,
2:15:15 and what we're looking at is strictly a zoning change.
2:15:18 We didn't go into any sort of plat review on this one.
2:15:23 The exact same application basically was used last year.
2:15:26 Idaho State makes you basically wait a year
2:15:29 from a denial to reapproval.
2:15:31 We do that here in our city code as well
2:15:33 as the county, they do the same thing.
2:15:35 So what he's doing is basically just reapplying,
2:15:38 going through the whole process again
2:15:39 to get through that, those stages.
2:15:42 So this will be very similar to we had last year.
2:15:46 And the dates on those came through planning
2:15:48 and zoning commission last October.
2:15:51 The city council heard it on November 19th, 2012, not 2013.
2:15:56 And then on January 8th, that's when 2013,
2:15:59 he went to the county commissioners.
2:16:01 That's when he got the denial based on some things
2:16:03 that are in the staff report.
2:16:05 They've cited different codes and things like that.
2:16:08 This request is to rezone this area here,
2:16:11 I didn't read from R1 VAR, which requires city services to SUI, which would allow it
2:16:17 to be on wells and septics.
2:16:19 R1 VAR also allows for more homes to be built on more density in effect.
2:16:25 He's going for SUI, which requires one acre or ample amount for a well and septic per
2:16:31 cell center health district.
2:16:32 The closest facilities are located over here in this intersection, which is further than
2:16:38 What the engineering department requires them to hook up also we have some other
2:16:43 Information is the water service boundary is also on this road, which is Hankins road
2:16:49 So in order for this to come through for a plat under our one VAR
2:16:53 We'd have to change the comprehensive plan for the water service water and sewer service boundaries
2:16:58 And then go through the planning process as well as get infrastructure there
2:17:03 So that's why mr. Core has decided this is his course of action to rezone it to
2:17:07 and going through the public hearing process with the Planning and Zoning Commission.
2:17:19 They determined whether they have to determine whether it requests and conforms with a comprehensive plan and to evaluate the request as to determine the extent nature of the amendment requested.
2:17:29 A comprehensive plan denotes rural residential, which is what this is designated.
2:17:35 Actually, this whole area right here and the line comes up somewhere in here.
2:17:40 That is all designated rural residential.
2:17:45 It defines it as areas that provide transitions from agricultural land located on the outskirts
2:17:49 of the community to urban areas contained in the water limit boundary.
2:17:54 Large lot rural residential.
2:17:56 Landing designation this partial as suburban urban interface would follow that goal for
2:17:59 the area as stated in the Twin Falls Vision 2030 comprehensive plan.
2:18:04 In reviewing the extent, they found that the proposal of rezoning for large-lot residential
2:18:09 uses along Addison Avenue East would be compatible with the existing and adjacent uses in the
2:18:14 area.
2:18:15 The land to the north-south east and west has been developed in a similar way, so with
2:18:19 large lots on wells and septics, I don't have an average lot size, but there are large
2:18:25 lots.
2:18:26 They may not be one acre, but they're close to that.
2:18:30 They also said that allowing this zoning change
2:18:33 will not cause incompatible land uses
2:18:35 to be developed next to each other.
2:18:37 In amending Title 10 of Twin Falls Code,
2:18:40 public hearing was made to the Planning and Zoning Commission.
2:18:42 They make a recommendation to the City Council,
2:18:45 and as this is in the area of impact,
2:18:47 your recommendation will then be forwarded
2:18:48 to the County Commissioners as well.
2:18:52 So in conclusion, on April 8th,
2:18:53 the Commission unanimously recommended approval
2:18:56 of the request as presented.
2:18:59 Thank you, Jonathan.
2:19:00 Rebecca, Mel Suica.
2:19:01 Sorry.
2:19:08 You just talked about the comprehensive plan and how this would follow that, but it says
2:19:12 that specifically the Ag land located on the outskirts of the community to urban areas contained
2:19:19 in the water limit boundary.
2:19:22 So whereas this land is outside the water limit boundary, what does that imply for this
2:19:28 land?
2:19:29 I mean, it doesn't quite fit into that.
2:19:32 It doesn't fit in exactly.
2:19:33 There are multiple places that we have SUI outside the water service boundary.
2:19:39 As far as the way the comprehensive plan is written, we don't have a rural residential
2:19:43 zoning designation created.
2:19:45 So we use what's close.
2:19:47 SUI is the closest thing to that.
2:19:50 R2 doesn't fit.
2:19:51 R1 variable doesn't fit.
2:19:55 Agricultural could.
2:19:57 Agricultural limits what you can do and how many sizes and housing.
2:20:02 So this was the closest fit we have currently written to this
2:20:06 residential designation.
2:20:08 Okay. Thank you.
2:20:09 That would just be my concern that it states that it should be within that water boundary, and it's not.
2:20:16 Sean Berger.
2:20:17 Perhaps I'm reading this sentence differently.
2:20:19 So the sentence that I read says,
2:20:23 Rural Residential is the area that provides the transition
2:20:27 from Agland, which is located outside of the community
2:20:32 to urban areas that are within the water limit boundary.
2:20:36 So what's within the water limit boundary
2:20:38 is the urban area, and the rural residential
2:20:42 is actually outside of the water surface boundary,
2:20:46 but not yet agglant.
2:20:51 So it is that it would not be within the water boundary,
2:20:55 would be outside of the water boundary,
2:20:57 but not as far out as agglant.
2:21:00 Okay, and so my question for that,
2:21:02 Would that mean that suburban urban interfaces,
2:21:05 is that what it's suggesting then?
2:21:07 Is that SUI, is that transition?
2:21:10 That's what we believe it is, yes.
2:21:12 Okay.
2:21:13 Great planning.
2:21:15 Jonathan, in their denial a year ago,
2:21:18 the County Commissioners stated that it was not
2:21:20 within their comprehensive plan.
2:21:23 Do we have a conflict in their comprehensive plan
2:21:25 and our comprehensive plan?
2:21:27 And which one, there's not a conflict?
2:21:29 So we have the exact same comprehensive plan that they do.
2:21:32 So can I test the frets out of the recent designation
2:21:35 or do you have an idea why they did?
2:21:38 OK, thank you.
2:21:40 Just for the record, the case of people
2:21:42 that didn't hear our city attorney said
2:21:44 he had no knowledge about that.
2:21:49 Any other questions for either the applicant
2:21:52 or our city staff at this point before I turn it over
2:21:55 to public input?
2:21:58 I'll open up public input, portion of the public hearing
2:22:02 this evening and if you are interested in testifying this evening, please come forward.
2:22:10 I see no one coming forward so I will close the input and turn it over to council for further
2:22:16 questions and to our emotions.
2:22:23 Greg Lanning.
2:22:24 Mayor, I move that we pass or send a request on this request on to the I get it right here.
2:22:36 I've tried to word it how I would say we're going to send it on to the county, but I think it
2:22:39 gets the idea for zoning district and zoning map amendment to rezone 6.3, 6.927 plus my
2:22:47 acres from R1 variable to SUI for property located west of 3236 Avenue Avenue East within
2:22:55 the city's area of impact and I recommend that they pass it as well.
2:23:00 Second.
2:23:01 Second motion and four by Greg Lanning seconded by Sean Barrier
2:23:06 Anything further on that motion council?
2:23:09 Rebecca Mill so you thank you mayor
2:23:12 my only concern here is once again the if there's adequate infrastructure is talking
2:23:19 essentially about a subdivision of the land so in the rezoning
2:23:26 is it accurate to say that we would consider the streets and roads and the
2:23:32 transportation issues that might occur on Addison Avenue, or do we not consider that?
2:23:39 At this point, that's the question that we're directing towards our city attorney.
2:23:45 Okay, so you would consider that at the subdivision phase, whether there is adequate infrastructure
2:23:51 for what they're planning to do.
2:23:53 Okay, thank you.
2:23:55 Sean Berger.
2:23:57 So, can you put the map back up that has the R1's all right, the R1 variable?
2:24:14 So I'm supportive of this motion and moving forward with this zoning.
2:24:20 My concern is if the county commissioner's point is, if something's, or if the code says
2:24:28 if something's zoned R1 variable, it's anticipated it's going to be connected to city services,
2:24:33 We have a whole spot of our one variable out there that is even further away from
2:24:42 our water service boundary than what this is and do we need to be addressing
2:24:48 What we have the zoning designated on some of these things
2:24:52 If it's in conflict with what?
2:24:55 It's being defined to me
2:24:57 So, as you'll recall, the futures group has approached the city and they've asked us to
2:25:06 take a look at growth and growth opportunities, water service boundaries, where those areas
2:25:12 might be in conflict, where those opportunities may be to expand.
2:25:18 That may be an appropriate time to do that.
2:25:22 As we, and it's not something that we've started on, we have the presentation from the futures
2:25:28 group we have not moved forward on that and as I shared hopefully at some point in time
2:25:36 in this calendar year it's a conversation that we can pick up and move forward but until that
2:25:41 time you may choose at some point to logically extend the water service boundary or we may
2:25:48 want to move forward and recognize that there's a conflict and say that that zoning isn't necessarily
2:25:56 appropriate because we have no intent of extending services into that area.
2:26:01 Right, okay. So, yeah, I guess I had never really realized that our one variable sort
2:26:10 of had this built in, it means it's going to have city service someday connotation or
2:26:18 even code. And, you know, as you look at kind of natural growth of, you know, maybe lots
2:26:26 getting larger in that. I do think we need to address that because if you go further east
2:26:32 of this, then you sort of get dense development again. And I would assume that's in the Kimberly
2:26:39 area of impact once you get further east. You sort of start, you create this hopscotching
2:26:45 effect that we try to avoid within the city, but now it's occurring in the county. And I
2:26:51 don't think that's what we want. I think we want that nice, smooth transition. So again,
2:26:55 I'm very supportive of this and I just wanted to ask about that.
2:26:58 We're in the middle of our motion, sir.
2:27:00 I'm sorry.
2:27:02 Anything further on the motion council?
2:27:06 We'll call a vote, Sharon.
2:27:11 Yes.
2:27:14 Suzanne Hawkins.
2:27:15 Yes.
2:27:16 Sean Baraker.
2:27:17 Yes.
2:27:18 Jim Munn.
2:27:19 Yes.
2:27:20 Greg Lanting.
2:27:21 Yes.
2:27:21 Don Hall.
2:27:22 Yes.
2:27:23 Chris Talking.
2:27:24 Yes.
2:27:24 Motion passes 7 to 0, council.
2:27:27 Anything further?
2:27:29 No lines are coming on?
2:27:31 I would like to hear from the applicant his comment, not that the process is closed.
2:27:35 Thank you Chris.
2:27:36 Mr. Court.
2:27:39 If anybody have any doubts about that?
2:27:43 Like I said, I wasn't very educated about the whole process when we first submitted this,
2:27:48 but I'm a lot more educated than I ever wanted to be at this point.
2:27:54 Three points that the commissioners made to deny it in the first place.
2:28:03 I researched all three of those and they, I don't know why they came to that conclusion.
2:28:12 The first one that they said was it appears to be spot zoning.
2:28:16 Well, if you look in the Idaho and use a manual, it gives the definition of spot zoning.
2:28:24 that simply talks about zoning being that it's different
2:28:32 than the complexion of the neighborhood
2:28:34 has become over a period of time,
2:28:37 and that it is a viable option.
2:28:39 So they say, oh, it appears to be spot zoning.
2:28:42 Well, I know law states that there's nothing wrong
2:28:44 with spot zoning if it deals with that issue.
2:28:49 The other thing that they said was it doesn't adhere
2:28:52 to the comprehensive plan, but getting back to that again,
2:29:00 it does adhere to the comprehensive plan.
2:29:02 It's almost word for word,
2:29:04 but there are a couple of changes,
2:29:08 a couple of differences, nuances,
2:29:10 but it also states in the Idaho law
2:29:12 that complete coordination is not a requirement.
2:29:20 Just the letter of the, not the letter of the law,
2:29:24 but the idea, it doesn't have to be word for word,
2:29:29 it just has to be along those lines.
2:29:32 And so that's, if anybody had any issues with that,
2:29:37 that was like, John, what would be the other issue
2:29:41 that they brought up?
2:29:43 Decrease of value.
2:29:47 Oh, decrease of value.
2:29:48 And that, you know, I can't say anything more
2:29:52 than that's just ridiculous because, like I said,
2:29:57 We're not talking about selling the lots for $5,000 and dragging a double line on there.
2:30:03 These are going to go for $50,000, $60,000 and you're not going to deal a shack on a lot for $60,000.
2:30:10 It's going to be representative of the neighborhood.
2:30:14 So thank you.
2:30:17 Thank you, Mr. Court.
2:30:20 Ladies and gentlemen, we are adjourned.
Download
- Transcript (text) 150 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 201 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 273 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.2 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 14.3 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, May 5, 2014. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:30:33.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
1027b27f1e1dd8078569559a37d245a8db9b864ed4ecef28d299115ff253e4c4 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a a5d23a6494afe5cd7d30e9eae55808687c97c31bc9bd46c2907e279c2e31bc21
part02.m4a 0eb0dedfc021ce32474fe2d4522c7efe07f73a3556d4cb8dd638279a6db9deb0 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
5731c701e444612159c0c3c0378e8a939984592be24ce5338bbb72f85eb28337
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file