OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Tuesday, May 27, 2014

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Minutes on fileExecutive session: c,c*

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:07:34 I'm going to call to order the City Council meeting for September 27th, 2014, September.

0:07:58 After a good start, thank you, how about me?

0:08:03 All right, and first of all, we will start with the Pledge of Allegiance and it looks

0:08:09 like that there is no Boy Scouts with us tonight, so anybody who would like to join us, please

0:08:13 stand.

0:08:17 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:08:36 I would like to confirm that we do have a quorum with six out of the seven members here tonight.

0:08:41 Our Mayor Hall is home recovering from a small injury.

0:08:45 He will try to join us should we decide to have an executive session at the end of our meeting tonight.

0:08:52 And with that, do we have any consideration of

0:08:56 amendments to the agenda?

0:08:58 Madam Vice Mayor, there are no amendments to tonight's agenda.

0:09:03 Excuse me, there were some meeting minutes that were amended.

0:09:08 They're still here on your consent calendar, but those meeting minutes and those amendments

0:09:11 were reflected and were passed out to you earlier.

0:09:14 But in terms of items on the agenda, there are no official changes.

0:09:18 Thank you.

0:09:25 Okay, Chris.

0:09:30 to approve the amended consent calendar

0:09:32 including the amended minutes.

0:09:34 Okay, I'm gonna hold that for just a minute

0:09:36 because we're gonna take public input first.

0:09:38 Oh really?

0:09:40 Yes, that's good.

0:09:41 Oh yeah.

0:09:42 Tonight there are no proclamations.

0:09:44 And before we move on to the consent calendar,

0:09:47 this is the time where we do take public input

0:09:49 from anybody in the audience who would like to address

0:09:52 the council on any issue that is not on the agenda for tonight.

0:09:57 All righty, seeing no one moving forward.

0:10:00 Now, Councilman Talkington.

0:10:03 Move to approve the consent counter,

0:10:05 including the amended minutes.

0:10:07 Okay.

0:10:10 All right, we have a motion made by Chris Talkington,

0:10:13 seconded by Greg Lanting.

0:10:14 Is there any discussion or questions on that?

0:10:19 Beallak, we have a roll call vote, please.

0:10:22 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:10:23 Yes.

0:10:24 Senator Hucker.

0:10:25 Yes.

0:10:26 Jim Mudd.

0:10:27 Yes.

0:10:28 Greg Lanting.

0:10:29 Yes.

0:10:30 Chris Talkington.

0:10:30 Yes.

0:10:31 Rebecca Mills, like that.

0:10:33 Yes.

0:10:34 Motion passes six to zero.

0:10:37 We will move on to items for consideration.

0:10:40 Item number one is a consideration of a request

0:10:43 to adopt an ordinance amending the Twin Falls City Code

0:10:47 three dash 15-9 to discontinue the requirement

0:10:51 of fiduciary bonds for applicants

0:10:53 and private security license.

0:10:55 And I believe we have Officer Hicks.

0:10:58 Good evening.

0:10:59 Captain Hicks, sorry.

0:11:01 I apologize.

0:11:03 No problem.

0:11:04 evening members of the council. I have a minor issue, hopefully, to present you tonight, an

0:11:08 issue that was recently brought to our attention. And in doing some research, we would request

0:11:12 that you approve an ordinance amending the Twin Falls City Code section to the licensing and

0:11:17 private security companies. A little bit of history back in December of 2007, the City Council

0:11:22 approved an ordinance, regulating private security companies and their employees operating within

0:11:27 the city of Twin Falls. Part of that original code, we're asking you to amend tonight, and

0:11:32 regarding the language describing a fiduciary bond.

0:11:37 And we was recently brought to our attention

0:11:39 by one of the owners of the security companies

0:11:41 as he was renewing his license

0:11:43 and obtaining the bond from his insurance company

0:11:45 that it was their opinion, the owner and his insurance agent

0:11:49 that the fiduciary bond was not serving the purposes

0:11:51 I believe that were intended.

0:11:52 In researching this with the city attorney,

0:11:54 we've come to the same conclusion,

0:11:56 the fiduciary bond while well-meaning.

0:11:58 We don't think provides the city really any liability

0:12:02 and while the company still have to provide liability insurance as part of their application process,

0:12:09 we don't see the need for them to also produce a fiduciary bond as part of that licensing requirement.

0:12:14 So on the draft ordinance in front of you, we would simply ask to strike the sections highlighted there,

0:12:22 referring to the fiduciary bond, leaving the rest of section 15, excuse me, 315-9, regarding insurance and tax.

0:12:29 Do we have any questions? Jim Munn.

0:12:38 I was just going to ask, we have an ordinance number.

0:12:42 3071. Vice mayor, I would move to, what is it,

0:12:49 50s? I would move to adopt orders number 50s or 30s,

0:12:56 3071, amen City Code 3-15-9 to discontinue the requirement

0:13:01 of a judiciary bond for applicants of private security licenses.

0:13:06 Point of order men. I believe we may need a minimum vice chair like mayor

0:13:10 We may need to place that on third and final. Yeah

0:13:16 Fix that sure let me see if I remember how to say this I would

0:13:21 Move to place ordinance number

0:13:25 74

0:13:26 71 on

0:13:28 Third and final reading by title only

0:13:31 Wells my missing suspended rules. Thank you

0:13:37 We have a motion by Jim Mann, seconded by Rebecca Milsoyka.

0:13:44 Do we have any discussion or questions?

0:13:48 Chris Tockington.

0:13:51 Just a point of order for Councilman Munn.

0:13:53 You didn't have to place it on the third and final, but that's your intent.

0:13:57 My intent is resolved.

0:13:58 This is as quickly as efficiently as possible.

0:14:00 Okay.

0:14:01 It doesn't look like we're over a while in the public comment at this point.

0:14:04 I want to make a point.

0:14:05 You didn't have to move it to third and final.

0:14:08 I do have one question.

0:14:11 I was just curious what brought this to your attention at this point in time.

0:14:16 When we are doing this application process, we brought that to our attention discussion

0:14:21 with his insurance agency that was purchasing the fiduciary bond.

0:14:24 The insurance agency can question them as to the legitimacy of the need, so we began our

0:14:28 research in that point.

0:14:30 Thank you very much.

0:14:31 Biala, do you want to read the title with the vote on the list?

0:14:36 Oh, sorry.

0:14:37 Roll call vote.

0:14:38 Sean Berrigor.

0:14:39 Yes.

0:14:40 Jim Mun.

0:14:41 Yes.

0:14:42 Chris talking yes Rebecca Melsoika yes Suzanne Hawkins yes okay now we can read

0:14:49 the title and ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls Idaho

0:14:54 amending Twin Falls City Code Subception 359 requiring fiduciary bonds for

0:15:00 private security licenses Schomburger move approval of ordinance 3071 sorry we

0:15:12 have a motion from Schomburger seconded by Greg Lamting any questions or

0:15:16 discussion? Chris talking to I'm assuming Fritz that you're

0:15:20 concurring with us and there's no no risk and there's no harm in

0:15:25 dropping.

0:15:26 No, there is no harm ordinarily that bond would be to the benefit

0:15:30 of the city that the security companies don't do any work for us

0:15:34 for which we would need that bond. So there is liability

0:15:38 insurance in place for any damage or injuries they may cause

0:15:42 doing the work they do for the public. Thank you. Seeing no other

0:15:50 comments.

0:15:51 A roll call vote please.

0:15:52 Jim on.

0:15:53 Yes.

0:15:54 Greg Lanthane.

0:15:55 Yes.

0:15:56 Chris Chalkin.

0:15:57 Yes.

0:15:58 Rebecca Melsweicke.

0:15:59 Yes.

0:16:00 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:16:01 Yes.

0:16:03 Sean Berriger.

0:16:04 Yes.

0:16:05 Motion passes six to zero.

0:16:10 Next we have a presentation of a draft ADA transition plan and key points of interest to

0:16:15 the public and city council and the presentation is by Josh Baird.

0:16:20 Welcome Josh.

0:16:21 Thank you.

0:16:22 I want to make it to Council a brief presentation on what I've been working on for about a year

0:16:30 now.

0:16:31 It was one of my first assignments when I got here and that is the draft American with Disabilities

0:16:36 Act transition plan and the intent is to go over it very briefly here, kind of give you

0:16:43 the outline of the schedule, touch on the budget quickly, well hopefully that turns into a quick

0:16:50 item and then explain what the future process is and ask

0:16:55 answering any questions you might have.

0:16:58 So with that, the ADA transition plan

0:17:02 is a federal mandate that comes from the American

0:17:06 with Disabilities Act of 1990.

0:17:08 And there were four main components of it,

0:17:13 which is to identify physical objects

0:17:15 in the public entity's facilities,

0:17:17 assuming the public entity has 51 employees,

0:17:20 which the CF Twin Falls does, describe the details of the methods that will be used to

0:17:26 make those obstacles accessible, specify a schedule, and then identify an official responsible

0:17:34 for implementation plan, which is what we've done here in this plan.

0:17:40 There's two major items that we've gone over, which is public buildings number one, and

0:17:45 And then, curb ramps number two, which could be also,

0:17:50 or curb ramps could consist of as well as driveway approaches

0:17:54 or sidewalks that are not EDI compliant.

0:18:02 There are some mandatory items that need to be

0:18:05 in a EDI transition plan, including like who the ED coordinator is.

0:18:09 That's a still up for discussion.

0:18:12 Susan Harris was one who could potentially be a,

0:18:16 Currently, I think it's Mitch Humble, potentially John

0:18:21 Catons, since he's over Street.

0:18:23 So that's still to be discussed.

0:18:27 There's currently a grievance policy in place

0:18:30 if somebody has issues and sees a spot where there needs to be

0:18:34 more compliance and isn't there's a way for that to occur.

0:18:36 And we have an outline that's included in here.

0:18:41 As far as public involvement goes, last week we held a meeting

0:18:45 with what we thought were potential stakeholders.

0:18:49 We invited them and asked them if anyone else they could think

0:18:52 of, discuss the plan, explained how we see it moving forward

0:18:57 in the future and answer any questions they had.

0:19:01 Tonight I guess is the second piece of public involvement,

0:19:05 which is leading the City Council know.

0:19:06 Here in the future I anticipate in June we'll have a public

0:19:10 information meeting to open it up to the general public,

0:19:14 explain the plan, ask for any input and then later we will take those comments

0:19:20 incorporating the plan and bring what we hope is a final plan later to you for

0:19:25 formal adoption. In the document it it goes through what we've done since 1992 as

0:19:35 far as building goes back in 92 there was an initial assessment on buildings and

0:19:39 those have occurred since then the most recent was done in August of 2013.

0:19:46 It also has a preliminary condition report of all the curb ramps in the city.

0:19:54 Unfortunately, it doesn't necessarily discuss or talk about whether or not those curb wraps are ADA compliant.

0:20:02 So we pretty much need to go through and do an entire inventory of the city before we can determine what we're up against, I guess.

0:20:12 but that doesn't mean we still can't formalize the plan

0:20:14 and have a schedule that goes forth

0:20:17 without all those details in place.

0:20:21 Quickly on the curb ramp side, what we've done is we've created

0:20:28 what's called a scoring matrix and it goes through and it has a way

0:20:33 to determine which ramps are neat replacement the most

0:20:38 and or are in a location that requires replacement

0:20:41 better than other locations.

0:20:43 The intent there is to segregate the different curb ramps into high, medium, and low priorities

0:20:50 and to preferably tackle the high ones first unless in situations where there's a project

0:20:54 that's going through and it doesn't make sense to not construct that curb ramp.

0:21:02 In addition to the scoring matrix that we plan on putting together, there's the caveat

0:21:06 that public requests are available at any time and that those will be evaluated individually

0:21:12 and a determination we've made as to whether or not locations weren't immediate action.

0:21:17 We plan on updating the city standards as well so that they show a curb ramp that is 88 compliant,

0:21:28 our current standard drawing doesn't show a compliant 88 curb ramp.

0:21:34 And just as a caveat to what we're currently, we're in addition to the plan,

0:21:39 we're also trying to make it occur at the same time we're trying to implement.

0:21:43 So last year we applied for and received federal aid, or state, not federal aid,

0:21:49 state money to construct 11 curb ramps which we're moving forward with that this year.

0:21:55 And we have applied for those same state dollars again this year in anticipation

0:21:59 of getting potentially more funding next year for curb ramps.

0:22:02 So I think I'm done with my presentation.

0:22:07 Are there any questions you have?

0:22:13 Chris talking to.

0:22:13 Josh, there are an immense number of intersection, curb intersections that obviously are out of compliance.

0:22:20 Is it state only cost sharing on those where there's state highways?

0:22:26 In other words, let's say residential intersections that are in the old part of the town,

0:22:32 and the old high curb, is that all done at the city's expense?

0:22:36 As far as I know, the only reason the state would participate is if it was on a state route.

0:22:41 So those 11 ramps that we have scheduled for this year's construction budget are on the state ramp.

0:22:47 If it's in, like you said, a residential area that's not a state route,

0:22:51 it would either need to be city funds or some other mechanism that we haven't determined this time.

0:23:00 Well, before we get the mass transportation into Twin Falls,

0:23:03 well, we have to make all non-state residential intersections ADA compliant.

0:23:10 before we get mass transportation in the Twin Falls?

0:23:13 I don't know if I understand your question fully.

0:23:17 Go back to my question of the old part of town

0:23:21 with the high curbs and obviously not a graded ADA ramp.

0:23:26 Will the city have to assume the cost of retroing every one of those intersections

0:23:34 concurrent with the acceptance of federal and state money for a mass transit system?

0:23:41 No, we don't have to do it concurrently, but we do have to have a schedule in place, and

0:23:48 that's the anticipation in the transition plan to show when we plan on doing it.

0:23:55 I have been as loose as I could be in my proposed schedule, which is the schedule takes

0:24:02 us pretty much to the planning phase, and then says at that time we'll determine a further

0:24:06 schedule when the construction of all the ramps will occur.

0:24:09 And you have an inventory, I see, of how these measure on your scale, but have you done any preliminary total costing of that?

0:24:20 Did I overlook that?

0:24:21 You didn't overlook that. There was a very, well...

0:24:23 I looked for something with a lot of zeros behind us, lots and lots of them.

0:24:27 That would be Appendix E.

0:24:29 That's what I was afraid.

0:24:32 So the number that I threw out there was virtually $48 million.

0:24:38 That would be to retrofit sidewalk and curb ramps.

0:24:43 But I guess I wanted to let you know that that number is very, very rough draft because

0:24:49 I don't even know exactly what we have out there.

0:24:51 So I just kind of guesstimated, we'll assume this, this, this, and this,

0:24:55 and so all those assumptions make for the number that you're looking at.

0:24:59 Okay.

0:25:00 Get off a big project. Thank you.

0:25:02 Sean Bericher.

0:25:04 So, this talks, generally it talks about a lot of kind of accessibility issues, but then

0:25:14 the focus seems to be on curb cuts or on the ramps, so a sidewalk.

0:25:21 So if somebody has a sidewalk that I can't get my wheelchair over, would they follow this

0:25:28 complaint process, and then if it's a private property owner's responsibility, does that

0:25:35 get fixed at the private property owner's expense?

0:25:41 I think technically yes, I don't know if that's been the standard and getting the private

0:25:46 property owner to pay to fix it is the double lemon that we've run across.

0:25:51 They noticed that it mentions, I think, back in the 1992 assessment that it talked about

0:25:59 bad sidewalks all over town, which is true, so I was just curious how that process worked

0:26:06 that stuff that would be outside of sort of the city's scope of responsibility.

0:26:12 The item that we've discussed internally in order to alleviate some of the burden

0:26:17 of the funding would be potentially putting LID's on individual neighborhoods

0:26:24 and tackling it that way.

0:26:25 Right.

0:26:26 And then I have one other question.

0:26:28 So in the report, it shows the various assessments at different points of time.

0:26:34 So, I think the 1992 one had a rather long list,

0:26:38 and then the next time it was shorter,

0:26:40 does that mean we addressed all of the things

0:26:41 that were in the previous one?

0:26:42 As far as I know, yes.

0:26:44 Okay, perfect.

0:26:45 Thank you.

0:26:47 Rebecca Mills-Sueike.

0:26:49 Thank you, Vice Mayor.

0:26:50 Thank you, Josh, for your presentation.

0:26:52 It appears to be a lot of work that you've done.

0:26:55 And so my question you mentioned

0:26:57 that you haven't actually gone and surveyed each intersection.

0:27:01 And so is the 85% out of compliance, I think it's on your concept planning level cost estimate,

0:27:11 is that 85% just a guess or do we know how many curb ramps are out of compliance?

0:27:21 I would say it's a hopefully an educated guess.

0:27:25 Okay, thank you.

0:27:28 I have a couple quick questions also.

0:27:32 I see the form on here on how grievances can be filed.

0:27:37 Do we receive those monthly and about how many do you think we get and how quickly are

0:27:43 they processed?

0:27:45 I don't think we get that many.

0:27:46 I know of one this year.

0:27:49 Speaking with Mitch, you can tell me if I'm wrong.

0:27:51 I think we get maybe a couple a year or so and we had tried to address them as quickly

0:27:57 as possible.

0:27:58 Are they more building or are they more curb and getter?

0:28:02 Where do the complaints seem to fall?

0:28:04 Do you know?

0:28:05 You see some of the curb ramps.

0:28:07 Okay.

0:28:08 And then there was also a section in here that talked about the twin fall standard drawings.

0:28:14 Do not comply.

0:28:15 How are we addressing that?

0:28:17 Are we addressing that?

0:28:18 How quickly are we going to rectify that?

0:28:20 What we have the ability to do right now is use different standard drawings.

0:28:24 You can use standard drawings from the Idaho standards of Pope Works construction manual,

0:28:29 or we can use Idaho transportation department standard drawings in lieu of our own.

0:28:34 And we are currently also updating our standards to make them compliant.

0:28:42 So do we expect to complete that this year?

0:28:44 Is that like, when will we have our own standards?

0:28:48 We're hoping that's a good question.

0:28:55 the answer. We can do it this year. Okay and you'll come back and give us an update

0:29:04 and let us know that that's sure being addressed. All right thank you very much

0:29:08 Sean Beriger. He said one other question so looking at the curb ramp survey form

0:29:14 the example that you included so that doesn't seem like something that some

0:29:20 volunteers can go out and eyeball some curb cuts and see if they meet the

0:29:25 compliance. I mean, is this an engineered level type assessment of this multitude of

0:29:32 intersections? I don't know if I would consider it engineer level, but I don't

0:29:36 think it's quite volunteer level as well. Part of the reason, or part of the hope is

0:29:42 to get a few people or one person who can do it and understand all these details,

0:29:53 But also to make it as consistent as possible because that I would think would be a big factor in ensuring that from ramp to ramp

0:30:01 We're being we're comparing apples apples

0:30:04 Right because that's quite an undertaking in and of itself just to go out and assess

0:30:09 Yes, all of these things to even figure out how on earth we then go about

0:30:14 fixing them

0:30:15 To meet compliance

0:30:19 Thanks

0:30:22 So Travis and Josh, we're not approving this tonight.

0:30:27 This is just for our presentation, but in your notes to us,

0:30:30 one plan is adopted.

0:30:32 There will be an undetermined budget impact.

0:30:34 So I'm figuring that our approval is a tacit implication

0:30:39 that we are acknowledging our deficits will provide the schedule

0:30:45 and began a financial implementation of up to $47 million.

0:30:52 Right.

0:30:53 So 85% to 120% of $47 million.

0:30:58 Right.

0:30:59 So I think it's important to recognize that this is a transition plan.

0:31:03 This is a plan that takes where we currently are at in our inventory of infrastructure,

0:31:09 especially as it relates to the current grant.

0:31:11 And it develops a process or a path to become fully compliant with the standards that we have there.

0:31:18 The first thing is there are potentially $47 million worth of projects associated here.

0:31:26 That does not mean that we have to do $47 million worth of curb projects in a five-year window of time.

0:31:33 Right?

0:31:34 Correct.

0:31:35 So, what we do is it's important to recognize that when we go out and we rebuild streets

0:31:41 like Diamond Avenue, which is where our public works as crews right now, we will ensure that

0:31:49 the work that we do meets the current compliance and move forward.

0:31:53 When our team is working in the different zones, they will probably schedule additional

0:31:58 ADA works to knock out certain parts and pieces that would be most important or most highest

0:32:06 on this priority list.

0:32:07 And Josh describes in here how that priority is largely determined.

0:32:13 Public transportation at some point in time may play a role into that.

0:32:17 And so we'll continue to do our best to just chip those things off as we go.

0:32:29 And Mitch just shared with me that we'll also address those complaints as they come in

0:32:34 as well.

0:32:35 So the questions that was asked is, and maybe I think Josh said it, but let me say it a little bit more clearly,

0:32:41 the sidewalks are the responsibility of the individual property owners.

0:32:46 And the council today has the authority through its current ordinances to instruct property owners to go forward

0:32:55 and fix those issues and those deficiencies.

0:32:59 Now, we recognize from a staff level that is incredibly challenging or could be incredibly

0:33:05 challenging for some of those homeowners, and that's why Josh talks about the possibility

0:33:09 of an LID project.

0:33:12 But those are all things and tools and concepts that we can evolve and kind of move forward

0:33:16 as we cement this plan.

0:33:24 Rebecca Milsoica.

0:33:25 Thank you, Vice Mayor.

0:33:27 With that said, I did have a citizen ask me recently about is there a program?

0:33:33 where you could use some of your tax dollars or get some sort of credit for improving your sidewalk or constructing your sidewalk.

0:33:42 And I know that we currently don't have one, but is there a possibility with this situation to maybe create a small incentive for people to be able to improve their sidewalks if they want to but have the city participate in a small way using tax dollars?

0:34:03 So, Fritz just shared with me that we would have to convince the IRS that that is a tax

0:34:08 donation.

0:34:10 The advantage of an LID process is it allows that cost to be paid for over a period of time,

0:34:18 and so they would use the bonding and the credit worthiness of the city.

0:34:22 We would go through an LID process.

0:34:24 We would identify the public improvements and the areas for those public improvements.

0:34:29 We would be able to go out and sell a bond to cover the cost of those improvements and

0:34:35 that payment would be made through an annual assessment that is attached to the individual properties.

0:34:41 And it's typically 10 years.

0:34:44 In the past, I've seen where individuals are allowed to prepay and pay that off upfront.

0:34:50 So that they didn't have to have the interest expense.

0:34:53 Some other individuals would prefer to make a much smaller payment over an extended period of time.

0:35:00 I know that the city of Idaho Falls and maybe even Pocatello have a fairly decent

0:35:06 LID sidewalk replacement program that would be something that we could take a look at.

0:35:13 Okay, so one option that you're talking about is bonding for

0:35:17 the project, doing it, and then having it paid back through the LID.

0:35:21 Yes, so you would bond, the LID would be the bonding mechanism.

0:35:25 It wouldn't be a community bond, it would be an LID or an assessment.

0:35:29 So we would go through that similar LID process like we did for Chibani, where there is a petition.

0:35:35 That petition comes in, the council approves that petition, and then we would go out and move forward on those projects.

0:35:42 If that's something that we wanted to go forward with, we can certainly investigate it.

0:35:46 One quick thing is it's important to make sure that all the work is done in areas that make sense.

0:35:51 because where you get the greatest economies of scalars,

0:35:55 when you have full blocks of people wanting to pool together

0:36:00 and move forward, as opposed to a house here,

0:36:04 skip five lots, another house here,

0:36:06 it becomes a lot more expensive

0:36:07 when you start looking at mobilization and labor costs.

0:36:11 Okay, so what I was thinking of is just reserving

0:36:14 some of our money that we put towards streets and sidewalks,

0:36:17 and then having that available for partnerships

0:36:21 for sidewalk projects, but you're thinking more of a wide

0:36:25 scale like an entire street at one time.

0:36:30 Yeah, I think that's going to be the more

0:36:31 cost-effective approach.

0:36:33 OK.

0:36:36 Great, Lanting.

0:36:37 Well, this is in all, and I hope this is venturing

0:36:41 under the weeds here.

0:36:42 But I want quite a bit on the President's streets

0:36:46 for exercise.

0:36:47 And they're starting to be several houses where neighbors

0:36:53 get together and they're redoing their sidewalks and things because of the trees along there

0:36:58 have buckled a lot of them and things and I'm wondering if at some point during this

0:37:03 process we could make sure if those are those corner houses and that they know that they need

0:37:10 to do this ADA or it would behoove them to do it as ADA if they're going to go and replace

0:37:15 it anyway is there a way we can get that information out or is that you know done I haven't seen

0:37:20 like there's no sidewalks on Haybird, but there is there is

0:37:25 sidewalks on Addison, of course, and I haven't seen any of

0:37:28 those being replaced, but there's certainly been a lot of

0:37:31 them, you know, in the mid streets. And so, and that's

0:37:35 probably all over. Well, that's true. If you have to have a

0:37:39 permit to do that, then that would be the process we can

0:37:41 make sure that they do it 88. Got it. Good thought, Jim.

0:37:44 All right. Maybe I wasn't in the weeds as much as I thought it

0:37:46 was.

0:37:47 I'm just going to throw my old two bits in again.

0:37:57 I don't have problem accepting the report.

0:37:59 I appreciate the amount of incredible amount of detail work you've been through this last

0:38:03 year.

0:38:04 But I just want to remind people of my experience that probably the least popular local taxation

0:38:11 I've been up against as a local improvement district is the taxation on your property.

0:38:16 And when you have little if any perceived value come out of it, if you're paying for a corner

0:38:23 sidewalk ramp, I've known city council people have recall elections against them because

0:38:30 of LID as imposed on them.

0:38:32 I just want to make you aware there may be some economy of scale doing $47 million over

0:38:38 one big project or ten of them.

0:38:40 But the perception is there is no discernible value, it's an unfunded mandate, so to speak.

0:38:47 That would be very cautious before I'll vote for the voting for the proposal with this

0:38:54 implied city tax law funding.

0:38:57 That was supposed to...

0:39:02 Councilman Dockingdon is absolutely right.

0:39:05 Any time that you go enforce an LID, it is not politically popular.

0:39:12 Most any time, in fact my recommendation would be if you were to use the LID tool, it would

0:39:18 actually be generated at the neighborhood level and they would be approaching you to actually

0:39:24 create and cause the assessment much like Chibani did in their process.

0:39:30 No argument there if they come to us.

0:39:34 The line will be short, very short.

0:39:37 I have one more question, Josh.

0:39:39 I'm not sure if it's for you.

0:39:41 But I know there's whole sections of the city, for example,

0:39:44 on Crestview and Ridgeway where there are no curb getter or sidewalk.

0:39:48 The grass just grows up to the street and there's some gravel.

0:39:51 How do we address those neighborhoods too?

0:39:55 So as far as the ADA is concerned, it's only worried about those situations

0:39:59 where you have non-compliant.

0:40:01 So if there's no sidewalk, it's not required to put a new sidewalk in order to be able to plan.

0:40:06 Okay, thank you.

0:40:08 Makes it simple.

0:40:09 Any other discussion?

0:40:12 Thank you very much, Josh.

0:40:13 I appreciate your report tonight.

0:40:14 You're welcome.

0:40:15 I have a feeling we're going to address this again soon.

0:40:18 Yes.

0:40:20 Can I already wait for your next project?

0:40:22 Okay, next number three on our items for consideration is a discussion of a proposed draft agreement

0:40:32 between the City of Twin Falls and CH2M Hills, OMI, for the operation and management of the City's wastewater treatment plant.

0:40:41 And I showed Travis Ruffweiler.

0:40:43 Well, I wrote the agenda statement, but I was wondering if Mr. Caden was going to actually assist and he may.

0:40:54 What I want to do is maybe kind of go back and have a conversation.

0:40:57 I think it's important to recognize that tonight we are not asking you to take an action on this.

0:41:02 When we went through and had our conversation regarding the transparency resolution, I came

0:41:08 before the council with a series of committees that I was working on.

0:41:14 And one of those committees was the wastewater one, and the council said, Travis, you and

0:41:21 your team go and negotiate the agreement to the best of your ability, come back and present

0:41:27 us that agreement in an open session.

0:41:30 And then next week it is our intent to bring this forward for your hopefully ultimate approval.

0:41:38 Tonight we have Mark Bowen with CH and Sean Moffat with CH and specifically our project manager.

0:41:48 And they are also here to talk about any questions or to answer any questions or to provide any

0:41:56 information that you may want in addition to what is presented to you this evening.

0:42:04 So first I think it's important to recognize that our relationship with CH2M Hill has gone

0:42:10 on for the better part of 30 years.

0:42:14 That is a partnership and a relationship that really not many entities can really work and

0:42:19 enjoy.

0:42:21 And because of that relationship that we have, the agreement reflects the time almost that

0:42:27 we've spent together, because as you develop, you move from a peer contractual relationship

0:42:34 to a partnership, but it is still probably important to understand and define roles and

0:42:40 responsibilities.

0:42:41 And that's why this agreement is before you today.

0:42:44 The current agreement that we're operating under was extended for a three-year term,

0:42:50 it was extended because there was this new city manager coming in and the council at the time

0:42:56 wanted to give the city manager me the opportunity to kind of get my feet under me before I started

0:43:02 negotiating this agreement. That three-year extension is set to expire on October 1st

0:43:10 of 2014 and as we've shared with you in the past we are looking to continue that relationship

0:43:17 for an additional 10-year term.

0:43:20 In the agreement, we have made some, what I would describe,

0:43:24 key changes and some substantial changes that are probably

0:43:28 really based upon the partnership that we have.

0:43:31 And then others, because they resemble the best practice

0:43:35 or we're trying to forge and create a new best practice,

0:43:39 or they may even represent how we're actually

0:43:41 doing business today.

0:43:43 So with that, Madam Vice Mayor or members of the Council,

0:43:48 if there are no questions, I'll just kind of dive

0:43:50 into the contract.

0:43:52 We'll walk through the contract.

0:43:53 I would encourage that as we kind of go through the sections,

0:43:56 should you have questions, maybe interject at that time,

0:44:00 as opposed to waiting until the end.

0:44:05 I think that it's important to recognize

0:44:07 that the first general definitions in section one

0:44:11 are fairly standard.

0:44:14 And really we start rolling into section two.

0:44:18 Section two really kind of describes the roles

0:44:21 and responsibilities of OMI.

0:44:24 And one of the things that's important to look at

0:44:27 is if you take a look at sections 2.12 through 2.15,

0:44:34 there were some changes that have been

0:44:36 made to kind of illustrate and provide more documentation,

0:44:42 more accountability, more clarity.

0:44:46 So we're looking for things like a list of all improvements

0:44:50 that are made at the facility, a list of vehicles

0:44:53 and equipment that is used by the project,

0:44:56 oftentimes those items are acquired by the city.

0:45:00 We want to make sure that we're providing 24-hour access

0:45:03 or alternative access.

0:45:04 So one of the things that's important to recognize

0:45:07 getting responsible professionals to the plant in a timely manner so that they can continue to operate it.

0:45:15 So let's say we have another unfortunate rock closure.

0:45:19 We have a blizzard, a snow, a weather event.

0:45:23 We want to make sure that we have the ability other than the normal egress road that's down there.

0:45:37 We want to make sure in sections 1 and 4.2, where we really begin to talk about those direct costs.

0:45:46 Direct costs are the actual project costs.

0:45:50 And so when we use terms like direct costs or base fee, it is the actual cost that it takes

0:45:57 to operate the plant.

0:45:59 It is the cost of the chemicals, it is the cost of the labor, it is the cost of the materials,

0:46:05 the testing, the electricity, all of the inputs that take to run that facility.

0:46:12 And then there is a management fee or a markup fee that is placed on top of that fee.

0:46:19 In the past, the way that operated was we would have a conversation and we would look

0:46:26 in the back years and we would define what would those direct costs be.

0:46:31 then we would move forward and attach a 22% markup

0:46:36 and adjustment onto that.

0:46:38 And then Sean or another project manager would walk in

0:46:42 and they would present a rebate check.

0:46:43 And that rebate check was for the direct cost portion only.

0:46:48 It never included what was the maybe unused portion

0:46:54 associated with the markup.

0:46:56 And one of the things that we've agreed to here

0:46:58 is that the markup will be based upon the actual dollar spent,

0:47:03 not a budgeted dollar in the process.

0:47:06 So like in years where those direct costs

0:47:10 are significantly down, we wanna make sure

0:47:14 that we are paying a proportionate markup fee,

0:47:17 not a markup fee that would exceed that 22%.

0:47:21 The other thing in this agreement

0:47:23 is that the markup fee has been reduced.

0:47:25 from 22% to 20% of the actual direct costs.

0:47:32 In sections 4.1, 2, 3, and 4, we describe what those direct fees, how it's going to be calculated, and what that looks like moving forward.

0:47:47 Section 5.1 talks about how we're going to change how we move into our billing processes.

0:47:54 So rather, we're going to start paying on the first of the month.

0:47:58 And we will still in a fiscal year, we will have 12 payments in that time frame.

0:48:06 But they may be coupled really close together like we'll see the 30th and then the first.

0:48:13 And then there'll be a delay for 30 days.

0:48:16 And so what we want to do is we want to make sure that that was a change that would really

0:48:21 assist the folks at CH to lower the management fee.

0:48:26 And so we felt from our place that that was not doing anything

0:48:30 to jeopardize the city.

0:48:32 It's important to recognize that the city maintains two months

0:48:35 of operating revenue as well as other cash reserves

0:48:39 to help float as we move forward.

0:48:45 We removed the interest payment or the call for interests

0:48:50 associated with lay payments.

0:48:52 We couldn't find a time in which we were late in a payment,

0:48:56 and we also said, as your partner,

0:48:58 we know that you should know that we're going to pay you.

0:49:01 So we've agreed to move that.

0:49:04 We've changed the term of agreement.

0:49:06 You'll notice that that is a 10-year agreement

0:49:08 that's reflected in 7.1.

0:49:11 In 7.2, we talk about liability.

0:49:13 And what's important to note is that liability piece

0:49:16 was something that we had several conversations

0:49:19 about the liability amount in the agreement

0:49:22 has been elevated from $150,000 to $250,000.

0:49:27 We believe that that amount, in terms of liability

0:49:31 for penalties that may be paid by the company

0:49:36 for failure to operate our facility in a manner,

0:49:38 and according to our NPDS permit,

0:49:40 it is enough and should satisfy any regulatory calls.

0:49:48 You'll notice in section Appendix B,

0:49:50 We added auger falls to the list.

0:49:52 Auger falls is a place that is going to be also

0:49:56 assisted and managed because we intend to use

0:50:00 part of those ponds as a series of wetlands

0:50:03 and they will be assisting with that.

0:50:07 And then appendix G, we've never had to really use this,

0:50:13 but what's important is an appendix G says

0:50:16 that if the two sides cannot agree upon a direct fee

0:50:21 for the budget moving forward,

0:50:23 that we will use that formula

0:50:26 and be able to use that as we go forward

0:50:29 and we construct a budget.

0:50:32 One of the other things that's in the agreement

0:50:34 that is a bit different that I didn't mention on my notes

0:50:37 or I didn't spell it out clearly,

0:50:39 was the duty that we're going to have

0:50:41 as we look at our payments

0:50:43 and how those payments are being made

0:50:46 to OMI or CH as we move forward.

0:50:50 So in the first six months, we are going to pay 1-6th

0:50:55 of the contract at direct cost for that year.

0:51:00 And then we want to go and we want to do an evaluation

0:51:02 to see was the amount that we budgeted appropriate.

0:51:06 And like we did last year, we found that the amount

0:51:11 that we budgeted was slightly larger than the amount that was actually associated with

0:51:19 those direct costs. And so we made a reduced payment in working with CH so that the payments

0:51:26 that we were making truly reflected what the end of the year would be. And then we got

0:51:32 back together at the beginning of the fourth quarter, and we went through that same exercise.

0:51:39 And as we shared when Sean presented his rebate check,

0:51:43 that rebate check was much smaller than what we've typically

0:51:47 seen in past years.

0:51:49 But the rebate was actually considerably larger

0:51:53 because we actually reduced the payment that we made

0:51:56 over the course of that year.

0:51:57 What that means is we're holding on to our money longer.

0:52:00 And even though we're making a pittance at the state fund

0:52:04 in terms of interest, it is still interest

0:52:07 that we are earning in this project.

0:52:10 With that, I'll ask John Keaton if he has anything to add.

0:52:14 I did have one question, if I could.

0:52:17 Referring to all of my been responsible

0:52:20 for our order of falls extension.

0:52:23 Now that's post-treated F low.

0:52:25 And I mean, it's ready to go on the river.

0:52:27 We're just putting it in ponds.

0:52:29 But is there additional duty or work as so said with CH,

0:52:37 And in that once that water enters the pipe to go to agar falls, I mean, there isn't any

0:52:45 more treatment on it, I don't think, sir.

0:52:48 There is no more treatment, but there is oversight and Sean can talk about that.

0:52:52 To make sure that we make the TDS permit levels and everything.

0:52:57 Yes, that's correct.

0:52:58 There'll be, we've looked at it from the permit that's been issued by DQ.

0:53:03 there's some additional testing requirements that we have to do there.

0:53:08 Basically, it's looking at the nutrient uptake, phosphorus being one of them.

0:53:12 So the difference of what's going into that and what's coming out of it.

0:53:15 So those will be things that we'll monitor.

0:53:17 We'll be looking at the condition of the ponds.

0:53:20 There's quite a few different ponds, so we'll be shifting some of the water between.

0:53:23 So there'll be operators going out there every so often from the plant just to check it,

0:53:28 make sure that the ponds are doing all right.

0:53:32 Just gentle upkeep up, I might think, make sure that everything's okay, the gates, there's meter readings that'll be taking on how much flows out there, and then just the reporting will be handled by us.

0:53:44 And of course we're anticipating that would be a good return of that water through the soil column back into the Snake River.

0:53:52 Do you do any testing? What it enters the river again?

0:53:56 There's testing, I think, as it goes out,

0:53:58 there'll be testing on what it removes out, that's correct.

0:54:02 So they can get that of the additional treatment

0:54:05 that's happening there.

0:54:07 Thank you.

0:54:09 Any other questions from Council?

0:54:15 Did John Keaton have anything to add?

0:54:17 Are you good?

0:54:19 Okay.

0:54:20 So I made Mark drive down from Boise.

0:54:24 So let's make him stand up.

0:54:26 Hi, Mark.

0:54:32 Welcome.

0:54:34 Vice Mayor, members of council light.

0:54:36 I did want to take the opportunity and just say how much we value the partnership with

0:54:41 City of Twin Falls.

0:54:42 We're a very important client to us and we take this relationship very seriously.

0:54:49 Hopefully we've demonstrated we add a lot of value to the city and we appreciate the opportunity

0:54:55 to negotiate this contract with you.

0:54:58 And you know we've negotiated this contract and it was relatively easy negotiation for

0:55:02 for us because we have such a long standing relationship.

0:55:06 The city's worked hard to take the risk out for us.

0:55:09 And again, it's the partnership that we rely on,

0:55:13 and we highly value that and want you to know we appreciate it.

0:55:16 Thank you.

0:55:17 Any questions?

0:55:18 Great planting.

0:55:19 Well, I'm not sure I have a question.

0:55:20 We do tell Vice Being, so recognize

0:55:23 that this is Mark Bowen, the regional director for CH2

0:55:25 and a lot of Boise, so people know who's talking.

0:55:29 But I would like to thank you, Mark, that during my two years as mayor and we've involved in

0:55:36 a lot of different economic opportunities that some that come to futation, you guys were involved

0:55:41 in each and every one of them letting us know what we needed to do and whether or not we

0:55:46 even wanted to pursue a particular industry and things.

0:55:50 And so we appreciate that partnership on that level that most people probably don't realize

0:55:54 This is a big part of our process,

0:55:57 because we need to know whether that's somebody

0:56:01 we want to come to Twin Falls

0:56:03 and we realize you're a vast network of engineers

0:56:07 to do that for us, and we appreciate that.

0:56:09 Thank you.

0:56:11 Sean Berrigur.

0:56:12 I'd too like to echo some of the comments that Greg made.

0:56:14 I think when we were down at the groundbreaking recently

0:56:17 for the wastewater treatment plan improvements,

0:56:20 the level of excitement from you and your team,

0:56:23 I think was as high as it was from the city's team.

0:56:27 Absolutely.

0:56:28 And not because, and you guys have all the work ahead of you.

0:56:33 But what I took away from that and what I see in this agreement

0:56:36 is really shared values of what the city is after and what

0:56:40 you're after to provide effective and efficient service

0:56:44 to the citizens of the community and to do it in a way that not

0:56:49 only meets all the requirements but takes care

0:56:52 the environment. And I think that that's really outlined well in this agreement. I

0:56:58 appreciate the work that you and Sean and all the all the team do there. And I

0:57:03 think this is a great win-win for all of us to have another 30 or 40 or 50 or

0:57:10 100 years of working together. Thank you. Appreciate that. I'm gonna weigh in. I don't

0:57:16 want to reiterate everything they said but I do agree. I know as the newest

0:57:20 member to this council also that when I was learning your staff and your team gave me an

0:57:27 in-depth quick learning lesson on wastewater treatment plans and how they work and I appreciated

0:57:33 that very much.

0:57:34 Enough that I took my grandkids down for a tour and let them learn about it as well.

0:57:39 But you guys have been a great asset to our city and you help give back to our community

0:57:44 I know and you're one of the reasons why we are a successful community and thank you very

0:57:48 much.

0:57:49 We appreciate the attention down there, not many people like it.

0:57:54 Got to know what's happening.

0:57:55 Yeah.

0:57:56 It's an interesting summer vacation profile.

0:57:59 You've provided there.

0:58:00 That's right.

0:58:01 Any other comments?

0:58:02 Thank you very much, Wendy.

0:58:03 Thank you.

0:58:04 Travis, are you looking for something?

0:58:06 It says discussion on the agenda.

0:58:08 Did you need us to give you direction to keep going or?

0:58:13 No.

0:58:14 So this will appear.

0:58:15 There's one more item, and we like to tease Sean about it.

0:58:19 But it is actually a very, very important part of this agreement.

0:58:23 And we actually have the veto power over the plant manager,

0:58:29 which that's how we've defined it in here.

0:58:32 We called it the if Sean goes away, so does the contract phase.

0:58:36 Because he is such an integral part.

0:58:39 Even though Sean serves in works for a private company,

0:58:45 you wouldn't know it by the way he completely immerses himself

0:58:49 with our team and with our staff, and it's really people like Sean that build that relationship

0:58:56 until even though it enhanced that partnership that we have. So even though we kind of joke

0:59:01 and mock about it, it's really important that should we ever reach a place where Sean feels

0:59:07 like it's important for him to move on to other opportunities within the corporate structure

0:59:14 that is CH, should that ever happen?

0:59:17 We get a place at the table to help continue and foster that relationship with the plant

0:59:21 manager, which we think is not only important, but I think that if Mark would not, I think

0:59:28 that's fairly unprecedented in CH's entire corporate process, where they allowed that

0:59:34 much influence from a local department.

0:59:37 Great landing.

0:59:38 Great.

0:59:42 I was just wondering to ask Mark whether that added a zero to Sean's bonus or.

0:59:53 Thank you very much.

0:59:54 We appreciate you driving down from Boise as well.

0:59:57 Okay.

0:59:58 We are moving on now to public input or items from the city manager or city council.

1:00:05 If there anybody from the public that has anything they would like to discuss that's

1:00:08 not on the agenda and real quick at this time I would like to say we have a public hearing

1:00:12 scheduled for six o'clock.

1:00:14 We will not start before six o'clock, and if you are here to speak on that issue, there is a sign-in sheet in the back.

1:00:24 Anything from the City Manager?

1:00:26 All right, yes, ma'am, just a couple of quick items.

1:00:29 So one of the things that we're going to start doing is really celebrating the accomplishments of our teams.

1:00:35 And so you often get an email from me, and there's a nice concredgatory note often that is attached to the department that really took a leadership role in those items.

1:00:46 One of the things that I think that we need to do a better job as an organization is also communicating those things with our citizens.

1:00:52 And so with your acceptance, and if you'll just indulge me and give me a few minutes,

1:00:59 I'd like to maybe share some of the great accomplishments that occurred over the course of this last week and then also provide some information.

1:01:07 First piece of information is that collectively many departments are going to be assembling together to remove the pool bubble.

1:01:14 And so that is an annual event.

1:01:16 If you've never seen it, it's certainly one of those times

1:01:20 in which you see all of the city employees

1:01:23 across a spectrum really working to remove that bubble.

1:01:29 So if you haven't seen it, let us know

1:01:30 and we'll send out that date.

1:01:32 One of the great things, and I'm glad that John Catons here,

1:01:34 in fact, I'm doing this intentionally.

1:01:37 So John, who oversees the Public Works

1:01:43 operations of our organization, received information from Idaho Power.

1:01:50 And Idaho Power shared that the City of Twin Falls saved the most kilowatt hours of anyone

1:01:59 in the entire Idaho Power System.

1:02:02 In fact, collectively, we saved 4,556,000 kilowatt hours, which is roughly 1.6 million kilowatt

1:02:19 hours above second place.

1:02:23 That is from the work and the ingenuity of our teams trying to find better practices,

1:02:30 to find better pieces of equipment.

1:02:32 And we often wonder, what does that collaboration do?

1:02:37 How do we find innovative approaches

1:02:40 to ensure that we're managing rates?

1:02:43 The folks at the ground level in many places,

1:02:46 and tonight we highlight the folks in public works,

1:02:49 are doing that part and doing that role,

1:02:52 because it's six cents for every kilowatt hour saved.

1:02:55 That is a lot of money that's not passed

1:02:58 wrong in the form of future rate adjustments. How's that figured year to year, year versus

1:03:04 year? The year over year. My gosh. I joke with John and say, well why didn't you do this

1:03:10 sooner? But really, it just shows how folks on our teams are not just going to work and

1:03:19 trying to find innovative approaches. They're doing really, really good work. Another, I

1:03:25 I think in a project that shows a bit of ingenuity, and our building department is going to be partnering with the state,

1:03:35 other cities, and Home Depot, to have a one-stop permit process.

1:03:43 And so what's going to occur, and as I understand it, and some of our folks are going to go up and

1:03:49 that some training later this Thursday on the process is that when someone will buy a water heater or

1:03:56 some small appliance that needs a permit, that permit will be sold out at the counter of the private store and

1:04:04 those funds will be then transferred to the city.

1:04:08 It's going to ensure not only greater issuance of permits, but also which is the main reason that's public safety.

1:04:15 So we're really excited about working with Home Depot and other cities as we kind of unveiled

1:04:21 it.

1:04:23 And the last thing that I guess that's it, sorry, one more.

1:04:31 As you know, Duane Thompson is going to be retiring and he's announced that retirement

1:04:36 and over the course of the last week we held a series of interviews and we are in a position

1:04:45 to announce that Jared Brody, who is an internal candidate,

1:04:50 will be appointed to serve as the next building official

1:04:55 for the City of Twin Falls.

1:04:57 He competed against individuals from across the country,

1:05:02 and he was selected by an interview panel

1:05:08 that had representatives of the building community

1:05:11 and city staff working together to find the right person.

1:05:16 And so Jared will be moving into that role when Dwayne

1:05:22 officially retires at the end of next month.

1:05:26 He will be here next week talking about some of the code changes

1:05:31 that we have coming up in the building department.

1:05:34 So cool.

1:05:37 Anything from council?

1:05:39 Great.

1:05:40 got with us. Okay, Chris talking to me. Well, did I figure

1:05:43 that right? John, did you, did you save us 273,000 bucks in power

1:05:47 costs this year? Am I off a zero one way or the other?

1:05:51 That numbers right. Chris, the 176,000 was due to the Harrison

1:05:58 station has more efficient pumps, you know, so so part of it is

1:06:02 good design from JAB, but but really most of the incentive

1:06:09 from water last year, 176,000 of it was how Ryan was operating the system.

1:06:15 Typically, in the past, we would pump all that water out south through the network, massive

1:06:21 amount of head loss.

1:06:22 Now we have a dedicated transmission main.

1:06:24 Ryan recognized he can save a ton by sending it down the transmission main through the arsenic

1:06:29 line.

1:06:30 So that's what he did.

1:06:31 That's really Ryan and Rob, their group.

1:06:35 100,000 came from the wastewater treatment plant again another good design from CH2M

1:06:41 Hill that that's purely energy savings from efficiency of equipment cool

1:06:48 I don't know what to talk about

1:06:51 I'm going to topic for the radio

1:06:54 anything else from the council seeing nothing I think we're going to wait

1:07:03 about one minute and we'll move right into the public hearing but everybody I don't

1:07:09 want to recess for a minute is that bad no let's go so it's all six o'clock

1:07:14 yeah I think by the time you read it it'll be six are we good we six o'clock yeah

1:07:24 that's six okay we'll keep going then for anyone who did just come in there is

1:07:40 a sign-up sheet in the back if you would like to address the council tonight on

1:07:43 the public hearing we're getting ready to start please feel free to make your way

1:07:47 back there and sign up to speak to us.

1:08:00 Please go ahead and read it.

1:08:02 No.

1:08:03 I'll tell you open it up for the public.

1:08:06 Okay so tonight's public hearing is a request to establish two new odor reduction units on

1:08:12 the city sewer line on property located on the east side of Eastland Drive North and

1:08:17 on the south east side of Canyon Springs Road

1:08:21 and it looks like Troy Vitek and Mitch Humble

1:08:24 are going to start this for us.

1:08:31 Do I need to read the procedures for a public hearing?

1:08:33 Are we okay?

1:08:34 Good.

1:08:35 Okay.

1:08:35 Okay.

1:08:39 Good evening council.

1:08:40 Troy Vitek, assistant city engineer.

1:08:42 And I come before you tonight for a public hearing request.

1:08:47 Usually these would go before planning and zoning.

1:08:51 But since this is city infrastructure,

1:08:53 There was a change in code that allows us to bring it directly before the council here.

1:08:58 It's really the public's opportunity to come and be heard on projects that we're doing.

1:09:03 So this one tonight is to come before you to talk about two new pieces of equipment and

1:09:10 the equipment is essentially an order reduction units.

1:09:14 Now, if you guys remember last summer when you would go around Pole Line Road towards

1:09:21 Eastland right in this corner here

1:09:24 You would notice the considerable amount of odor associated with that new sewer line that we put in as part of the Northeast sewer

1:09:30 serving the Southeast portion of town

1:09:34 Tonight I come up for you to put in two units one at the corner of Eastland and Pauline and another one located down

1:09:41 Canyon Springs Road down in the canyon

1:09:44 About where the prying Cooley cut crosses there

1:09:47 There's a major box there.

1:09:50 It's a dissipation as the sewage goes over, the canyon rim, it gets turned up pretty good.

1:09:55 A lot of odors come off of that.

1:09:59 So we're posing to one at both locations to deal with those, to reduce those odors at

1:10:04 those locations.

1:10:05 Essentially, the unit looks like this.

1:10:18 This is a unit that is currently out of Chobani.

1:10:20 This thing is approximately 10 feet in diameter.

1:10:23 the main portion of his 10 feet with a couple of stacks sticking out.

1:10:27 This is ventilation, essentially a huge fan.

1:10:31 The sex air out of the, in this case

1:10:35 it is dissipation running for Chibani, but

1:10:39 this would be on the main sewer trunk line. It sucks the air out, puts it through this.

1:10:43 Now this inside of here, it's a large tank full of

1:10:48 like rubberized media, and there's a water

1:10:52 on the top of it and it causes that rubber to grow essentially mold on it and

1:10:58 that is where the bugs and have it as the air blows up from the bottom through

1:11:02 this those bugs eat the odor particulates out of the air and then it ventilates it

1:11:07 out into the natural air after that. A little bit of history here when we had

1:11:18 Shabani coming online we said well we're putting this new sewer main going

1:11:22 through a different part of the neighborhoods that has not

1:11:26 commonly experienced this.

1:11:28 And so we said, will there be odors associated with this?

1:11:31 And so we asked the question.

1:11:33 And our partners at CH2 and they have a program that they

1:11:36 can run that kind of guesses of what's in the waste stream

1:11:39 with Travani's help.

1:11:40 They kind of help this as well as Kimberly enters the

1:11:43 waste stream here and goes around the east side of town.

1:11:46 So this is Kimberly Road and it goes north here.

1:11:50 Well, as the product is in the pipeline with time,

1:11:55 the pipeline kind of turns into its own wastewater treatment

1:11:58 plan.

1:11:59 It starts kind of fermenting.

1:12:00 And as the longer the time period,

1:12:02 the more chances of it, those odors arising out of it.

1:12:06 And so the reason we picked these two spots

1:12:09 was one, the considerable odor that was noticed at those

1:12:15 and due to complaints associated with those.

1:12:18 There's a couple other reasons.

1:12:19 One is the property that we're looking at.

1:12:25 The pole line in Eastland intersection first

1:12:28 is approximately right here.

1:12:30 This is pole line.

1:12:30 This is Eastland coming up, and then it turns out

1:12:32 the pole line right through here.

1:12:34 This is pole line where it serves those private residences

1:12:36 in the back there.

1:12:38 There's a corner here that we're in discussions

1:12:42 with the Twin Falls Highway District.

1:12:45 The reason for this property is,

1:12:46 one, the sewer line comes right through here.

1:12:49 So it's close vicinity.

1:12:51 If it's way far away from it, it's large pipelines, so you have to give property for

1:12:55 it, stuff like that.

1:12:56 You also need, so you need one property able to put it on to access to the sewer system

1:13:04 and roadways in order to maintain the property and water system.

1:13:08 Here's a water line that's proposed to serve Gary's storage property as it develops, so

1:13:13 we have close water available to actually irrigate this product and keep it alive.

1:13:22 This is the one in the Canyon Springs area.

1:13:25 This is the Prent Cooley as it comes underneath the roadway here.

1:13:28 The main sewer line comes down.

1:13:30 The switch back is in this area.

1:13:33 It comes down the hill here.

1:13:34 It's this big energy dissipator.

1:13:36 And just kind of a lot of wooders are released right there at that point.

1:13:41 The sewer crosses here.

1:13:42 So we would put essentially the facility around this and it'll look like that.

1:13:51 There'll be a tank right here and this will be fenced.

1:13:54 The unit, the main sound of the unit is essentially about the same sound as an air conditioner.

1:13:58 somebody's house is not loud.

1:14:01 Both of these units will be screened and fenced,

1:14:04 and we'll have them paint them earth-tone colors

1:14:06 and use earth-tone slats in the fence.

1:14:12 I guess this time we would just like the council's approval.

1:14:15 Oh, funding, funding with this.

1:14:18 When we noticed that there was odors associated with this,

1:14:21 we set aside $535,000 of TIFF funding

1:14:26 with the Chibani project to pay for this.

1:14:28 So it essentially paid through the same proceeds

1:14:31 that we paid for the pre-treatment facility,

1:14:32 so this is funded through that.

1:14:37 And I guess we would come before the council tonight

1:14:41 to ask permission to install these two units.

1:14:44 I think the consequences of not installing essentially,

1:14:47 the owners arise like they did last year.

1:14:49 We're mitigating, best we can right now,

1:14:52 through addition of chemicals into the system,

1:14:55 and that's costly, and it's not really

1:14:58 a great long-term focus there.

1:15:02 So we've presented this with our partners at CH2M Hill,

1:15:07 and we found that this to be the most cost-effective one,

1:15:10 essentially you're running a fan that does the majority

1:15:13 that work in the bugs are free labor, I guess.

1:15:17 So if you have any questions,

1:15:20 and I know the public will have probably some more,

1:15:22 I'd be happy to answer them.

1:15:24 Rebecca Milsweica.

1:15:25 Thank you, Vice Mayor.

1:15:27 Thank you for your presentation, Troy.

1:15:29 You might have touched on this, but are there any other remedies for odors?

1:15:34 Is this the main method that sewage treatment plans to use?

1:15:41 There are additional ways you can do it, but like the addition of ferric chloride,

1:15:48 and it's very, very costly, is like what's unfortunate about that.

1:15:52 You can dose that way, but you're essentially wasting stuff that you have

1:15:57 to treat downstream anyway, and it's a lot more costly than just essentially

1:16:01 varying it. And you have to really be on the chemical, so there's transport associated

1:16:10 with the chemical cost itself.

1:16:12 Okay, and how does it differ from, we were getting odor complaints kind of closer to

1:16:20 Chobani and out by Hankins in that area. How does it differ from what methods we use

1:16:25 there, or did we employ some methods to deal with the odors there?

1:16:31 Okay, so the Chobani one was, there's soul fights in the waste stream, and those soul

1:16:38 fights as they come out, they turn to H2S, hydrogen sulfide gas, and that eats and croats

1:16:45 and causes most of the smells, it smells like rotten eggs.

1:16:51 the units, I don't want to lead you on and say it's complete, say you've all, this reduces

1:16:59 odors.

1:17:00 This doesn't eliminate odors and the units are supposed to be 99% efficient, but Chobani

1:17:05 when at that time they were leaving about 300 parts per million, that was in excess and

1:17:13 what was the plant was originally designed for and we work with Chobani and I think we've

1:17:17 work through that now.

1:17:18 They've worked with us and we've worked out some cleaning chemicals, type stuff, but that

1:17:24 300 parts of the milling, if you eliminate 99% of it, you're still at over a way, you're

1:17:31 detectable.

1:17:32 Human nose can notice up to one part per million of this stuff, so it doesn't go away but it

1:17:38 doesn't eliminate a vast majority of it.

1:17:41 Okay, and then just a couple more questions.

1:17:45 So we have the funding to build these units, but I assume that they're going to require some sort of annual power costs and maintenance costs.

1:17:54 Do you have an estimate on what those will be, and who will be paying for that?

1:17:59 Is that just going to add to the overall waste treatment plant costs, and what might those be?

1:18:06 So I'll let choice talk specifically about the cost, but I can talk about, or the cost

1:18:14 of operation, but in terms of the impacts to the budget, it's important to recognize

1:18:18 that the Northeast sewer line serves an entire Northeast section of our community.

1:18:26 And it is, in addition to that, so it starts with Kimberly, it has Chibani, but it also

1:18:34 has all of the commercial, residential and light industrial customers up that entire line.

1:18:42 So it would be appropriate to have those costs as part of the normal operations because

1:18:48 it is all of those collected waste streams that are flowing into that.

1:18:53 We are, in like Troy shared, working very closely with Chibani on restarting the UASB.

1:19:02 And in working with them, we were able to find that part of their cleaning solutions may have

1:19:07 been a contributing factor to the increased H2S gas production, which was outside of the

1:19:14 original design parameters, which is why we had the problems and issues.

1:19:18 Chibani has been working in identified additional chemicals that do not have the same sulfate

1:19:26 and sulfide compounds, and early tests have illustrated

1:19:30 that the odors have been way down.

1:19:33 Sean and his team continue to track the odors

1:19:36 through a series of machines that register the odors.

1:19:42 And since they made those changes

1:19:45 through their pilot programming,

1:19:47 we've seen an almost a non-detect level of odors coming

1:19:55 How do those areas.

1:19:58 Thank you.

1:19:59 My last question is quick.

1:20:01 Did we choose these locations because we already own the land?

1:20:05 Are we going to need to purchase the land?

1:20:08 No.

1:20:09 The one in the canyon here, to supply this,

1:20:12 we have to actually breed power and water

1:20:14 in from a Jason property owner, who

1:20:16 happens to be McCollum, who is in favor of us

1:20:19 doing something about the odors down there.

1:20:21 So he's on board with us.

1:20:22 We still have to, if this is approved,

1:20:26 We will still have to receive easements from him in order to do that.

1:20:29 The other location at Paul line in Eastland is actually owned by the Twin Falls Highway District.

1:20:40 And we would have to work with them and get their approved to essentially grant an easement

1:20:45 for the city of Twin Falls to own and maintain these.

1:20:50 Okay. So we're not looking at purchasing when I'm just granting easements.

1:20:53 Yes. Thank you.

1:20:56 Chris talking to.

1:20:57 Well, I do have a reservation about untested technology.

1:21:01 but I guess there's a reasonable due diligence that you're doing that this is not going to

1:21:07 be something that turns into six additional amendments with charcoal storage and somebody

1:21:15 dumping 50 pound bags in the middle of the night.

1:21:18 It's as a warranty that's going to work, right?

1:21:22 That's what they tell me.

1:21:23 Okay, I've heard that before.

1:21:26 The other thing back to your question, Rebecca, when I've been exercising in that kind of downward

1:21:31 Perrine Cooley comes under there just about sometimes a knock shot or feet, Sean, I can

1:21:36 see why you're a little bit cynical about going to work when you have to cross that place.

1:21:42 But there have been times where it's impacted Centennial Park and certainly the golf course.

1:21:48 So this appears to be the point of vulnerability so far as the odor.

1:21:54 But also what I think I heard you say about the odor, Troy, is that you can remove virtually

1:21:59 all of it but it is such a hydrogen sulfide is so what's the problem are strong strong permeable

1:22:09 something that you may not think anything's being done even though it's virtually already

1:22:13 moved so we don't want to get the impression it's going to be a miracle and it's going to

1:22:17 be smelling like a bed of flowers no anything else from council before I open it to the public

1:22:25 okay at this time we're going to go ahead and open up the public hearing did anybody

1:22:31 Check the sign in sheet.

1:22:36 Okay, first we have David Jones

1:23:08 You have nothing to tell us tonight

1:23:11 Okay, Terry Green

1:23:16 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:23:22 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:23:26 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:23:33 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:23:38 new sewer line.

1:23:42 But it occurs to me is why don't we just seal this baby up instead of letting the odor

1:23:47 out why don't we keep it in.

1:23:50 And then the other thing is, is in the proposal it shows and he spoke about slap and the

1:23:57 And so I envision chain link with light tan slats in front of one of the nicer subdivisions

1:24:08 in the area.

1:24:09 One of the subdivisions that has some huge property values due to its specific relationship

1:24:17 to the canyon and the ambabicinity.

1:24:22 So your proposing to put essentially a sewage treatment plant at the entrance to our subdivisions

1:24:30 division. I just put it at the entrance of somebody else's subdivision. Put it down the

1:24:37 road. There's you got a whole bunch of territory there between that corner and

1:24:43 pole line on pole line with the Home Depot. If you have to do it, if this is the only

1:24:49 solution, then why put it at the entrance to the subdivision? That doesn't make any

1:24:59 since to me. That's not a great entrance to a subdivision, but certainly it's going to

1:25:07 stick right out there. You're going to devalue all those property values back in there because

1:25:11 who on earth is going to want to drive by that to go home every night?

1:25:19 I don't think the odor is that bad living on that corner or near that corner. I don't

1:25:24 think it's that bad right now. Maybe it's because they're treating it effectively. Before

1:25:32 make that investment, why don't you try it down in the canyon and see if it works. Chris, you said,

1:25:39 this is proven technology. And you didn't get a yes. You did not get a yes. You got a, well, maybe.

1:25:55 So please, I would hope that you would reconsider at least this one location.

1:26:00 Thank you very much. That is all the names on our sign-up sheet, but at this time we'll open it up

1:26:07 If there's any video, it's in the audience who would like to address us with any comments or concerns.

1:26:14 See, no one, I'm going to close the public hearing before I go to you.

1:26:19 No, please.

1:26:20 I think for the record, I think that I'm going to ask that Mark Bowen was CH2, and he'll stand up and talk about the technology.

1:26:28 I think that the gentleman deserves a response.

1:26:32 Again, Mark is with CH, he leads the engineering group of it, and he's been involved with these projects.

1:26:40 Thank you.

1:26:41 And vice mayor, members of council,

1:26:44 this is a proven technology it's used quite often.

1:26:48 I think it works, but the issue is it won't remove.

1:26:52 It's 99% effective and you can count on it to do that,

1:26:56 but for that small margin, you can detect odor,

1:27:00 but it's certainly different than the untreated odor streams.

1:27:07 Can I have a smart question?

1:27:08 Well, I guess public hearing, I can't.

1:27:10 Okay, afterwards I can.

1:27:12 Thank you.

1:27:13 Thank you.

1:27:15 Sir, can you please state your name and address for the record?

1:27:18 My name is Scott Allen.

1:27:19 I'm the administrator for the Twin Falls Highway District.

1:27:23 Mr. B. Tech's been in front of our commissioners on two occasions, and the main concerns that

1:27:27 the Highway District has in allowing this unit to be constructed on our property is what's

1:27:32 been brought up here tonight.

1:27:33 Every time we ask a question, what's the background odor now?

1:27:37 What will it be?

1:27:38 I don't know how you monitor odor or put a number to it, but it's been very gray and the

1:27:45 answer is coming back to us.

1:27:47 We have a big concern of the people on the canyon rim since we do on the property that

1:27:54 if we do allow this to go in, then the highway district is the bad guy, not the city.

1:27:59 And so what we'd like to see is if there's any supported data as to what the current

1:28:07 background level is and what the anticipated or projected level of the orders would be after

1:28:12 this unit goes in.

1:28:13 And it's going to be a very difficult decision for our commissioners to allow us to go in and

1:28:18 they'll be very reluctant in granting it to go in until some type of data is presented

1:28:23 to them.

1:28:24 So I just want the council to be aware of that going forward, whether this is or is not the

1:28:29 right location, our commissioners have some very strong concerns about this unit this time.

1:28:35 Thank you.

1:28:37 Thank you very much.

1:28:38 I'm sorry, Chris, before I go to you.

1:28:45 Is there anyone else from the public that has any comments tonight?

1:28:50 See and then I'm going to close the public hearing and turn it over to the Council for

1:28:54 discussion and we're going to start with Chris talking to.

1:28:57 Troy, is there not readily available technology to measure the hydrogen sulfide cars per million?

1:29:02 We do.

1:29:03 We actually have a no-de-logger.

1:29:04 Well, then why can't we do that before and after on a trial basis, let's say the one in

1:29:09 the canyon to see the pre-treated or the post-treated one of my

1:29:15 translate before and the after. Okay we did the odor study and we have that data

1:29:23 available might be happy to show that with Scott since then last year the

1:29:28 smells went up considerably and Travis received a lot of complaints and we did

1:29:34 something about it we started dosing we've been trying to keep those smells down I

1:29:38 I guess we can elect to do nothing right now and see what happens, see if the report and

1:29:48 the actual infield testing match, and I believe they would, I think they would be on this verbatim.

1:29:55 And so we can share the report with them, which shows that this will reduce it considerably

1:30:00 99%, again not re-flowing it completely, but I would share that with the highway district

1:30:06 in our next meeting.

1:30:07 I'll just bring this up to council for consideration.

1:30:12 I think the safer, less risk for the neighborhood of Poline and Easton might be for us to consider

1:30:20 installing the one in the canyon, give it a trial run and then maybe come back to see

1:30:25 about it installing the other.

1:30:28 Greg Lanting?

1:30:29 Well, and I may agree with that.

1:30:32 I would only agree to it if we were no longer putting the chemicals in that we, the reason

1:30:38 we're doing this is to make the elimination of the chemicals and so we would have to show

1:30:43 that what it is going to be, how it's going to be and see whether they had a change of

1:30:47 attitude of where it should be treated and then the follow-up of that question would

1:30:54 be what other locations are available for this.

1:31:00 I mean you talked about this being a junction and that's the reason that we're looking

1:31:04 there is are there other locations in that in that line that where this would

1:31:11 be effective so what we're trying to do so the there's a hydraulic because it goes

1:31:16 down the canyon grade that water fills that pipe entirely so there's no air that

1:31:20 gets past it that's why it has to be at least above between this location and

1:31:25 here the city does a home property other than the roadway we don't have just

1:31:31 50 by 50 parts will out there so we'd either have to purchase property or find

1:31:36 somebody wearing a donate property at that. As you chase this down on carriage lane

1:31:42 here there's some we don't have water in this area so you can't breathe water to

1:31:46 the unit to be effective. So you're really back in Morning Sun's Park because the

1:31:51 hydrology of this it pulls the water pulls the air with it so if you put it

1:31:57 back in Morningsun Park, you're essentially pulling the air office at the water and then

1:32:01 you have to discharge at that location.

1:32:05 Again, that's the reason this location was determined to be like that.

1:32:11 To seal up the van holes, it will start to go down the tributaries and then we'll be

1:32:16 inside the rest of this area and every house is required to have a van so it's coming out

1:32:21 every house is very atmospheric,

1:32:24 it's sitting out of the street panels,

1:32:26 it's just where I'll naturally agree that.

1:32:29 It'll find an area there, slats or whatever.

1:32:33 We can probably work with our designers.

1:32:36 This isn't good yet.

1:32:37 We can change the design of if the slats

1:32:41 are undesirable to the local homeowners,

1:32:43 and we'd rather do something else.

1:32:49 I'll ask a question afterwards.

1:32:52 Rebecca Milsuyka.

1:32:54 Thank you, my smear.

1:32:55 Well I think the public comment brought up a good point.

1:33:00 Maybe they would like to see and the council should see that data that you have and maybe

1:33:05 we can talk more specifically about the details of the situation, how many complaints we've

1:33:10 been getting, you know, some evidence to show that this is necessary and needed before we

1:33:17 make a decision.

1:33:18 I'll just throw that out there because I believe that the citizens should have a good understanding

1:33:25 And I want to have a good understanding of the need for this, which I believe, you know,

1:33:31 I believe that there's a need there.

1:33:33 And then do you need to make a decision tonight or can you present additional information

1:33:42 that we can consider?

1:33:53 Yes, so you do not have to make a decision tonight, but if you wanted

1:33:58 to have additional information included, we would schedule an additional public hearing

1:34:05 so that that could be included into the record, and that would be information that you could

1:34:11 use in your decision in deliberating processes.

1:34:13 Okay.

1:34:14 Thank you.

1:34:15 Great.

1:34:16 Just an additional question, Troy, and this goes back to one, it seems to be that there's

1:34:23 There's a smidgen of, or more than a smidgen of a chance

1:34:27 that that piece of property is not gonna be available

1:34:29 to us if the highway district chooses to,

1:34:32 is it is their property?

1:34:33 I mean, I know there's a process for gonna be

1:34:36 another property, but it's probably pretty messy.

1:34:39 And so, if that available, one, do we have other sites

1:34:43 that we have looked at, see if there's a possibility,

1:34:46 I know you said you have purchase.

1:34:48 The second one, I know the geology of that right there

1:34:51 It's not good, but is there ability to take it down so that it is below or most of it is below ground level?

1:34:59 So thus there would be very little maybe just the stacks showing or something that you know

1:35:05 It's not you know agreed that that subdivisions

1:35:08 You know pretty pretty special because it's on the can't remember stuff, but that exact corner is not very special in itself. Yeah, okay

1:35:16 And so is there anything along that line that's possible?

1:35:20 I'm just trying to come up with solutions here,

1:35:22 and then they're totally off the wall just to tell me so.

1:35:25 I think we didn't look at putting it down

1:35:27 because we always worry about drainage

1:35:29 and putting something that's electrical inside of a bath.

1:35:32 That's difficult for most engineers.

1:35:34 You have to put some sort of pump system

1:35:36 or protect it with a roof.

1:35:38 The stack, usually you try to elevate your stacks

1:35:42 so it disperses more up, not in a walking distance.

1:35:47 As far as the locations, our next piece of property

1:35:49 we own is in the warning sun, that park there, again I think this is a better

1:35:56 location as far as hydraulics and we don't have any property downstream of

1:36:01 there and this is really the hot spot that CSG don't really thought that this

1:36:05 would come in. The reason for the the data that the highway district is when

1:36:13 the odors really came up serving in a barrel boat for people we did something

1:36:17 And so, by adding that ferric chloride at the Chobarni site, we mitigate it as somewhat.

1:36:24 There's a cost associated with that.

1:36:26 So, to say that this chain, that's not something we want to do forever.

1:36:32 And the original report didn't represent that.

1:36:34 That was just something we did on the fly because we felt we had to work with the citizens.

1:36:40 It's not the complaints coming in.

1:36:42 And so, and the report doesn't reflect any of that information being in there.

1:36:48 This is essentially, we wanted to do this because this is what the report recommended.

1:36:55 And they looked at several technologies and did recommend this because it was viable and

1:37:00 cost-effective.

1:37:01 Thank you.

1:37:03 Rebecca Mills-Suica?

1:37:05 Thank you, Vice Mayor.

1:37:07 So the report that you're saying was that from CH2M-HIL?

1:37:12 Yes.

1:37:13 And so maybe this is a question for them, maybe they can speak more specifically to the question

1:37:17 of cost and cost comparisons.

1:37:20 I mean, I think citizens might want to know what they can expect, how will it impact rates,

1:37:28 adding these two sites, if at all.

1:37:32 That's my question.

1:37:35 Okay.

1:37:39 I'm bringing the report with me and I've put these guys online.

1:37:43 Some of the things we looked at when we looked at cost associated with that is maintenance.

1:37:47 I mean, this is a fan in the minimal maintenance associated with that.

1:37:52 And cost, power cost there, is essentially really low.

1:37:57 Where it's very chloride, you have to bring the stuff and you have to dose the stuff.

1:38:02 You have to continue, you have to put on your waste stream, you have to put more or less.

1:38:07 So the worst thing about this is spikes, you know,

1:38:11 the media will grow so much to handle the odor.

1:38:14 If additional load comes down all of a sudden,

1:38:18 that media can't grow immediately.

1:38:20 And so it takes a week or two for it to grow.

1:38:22 But once it's averaged out and Chobarni's really shown

1:38:25 averages, they're pretty much baseline now.

1:38:28 It'll handle those, 99% of those.

1:38:33 Travis, did you have something?

1:38:34 Yeah, what's important when we're looking at costs?

1:38:36 I think it's also important to recognize

1:38:37 that there is a cost right now that's impacting our rate payers for the solutions that we have in place, and that's the use of FERIC.

1:38:44 And the use of that FERIC is fairly expensive, and not only that, but it tends to be fairly corrosive of our systems.

1:38:53 So there's a cost to the system and the preferred method, or I guess the only method that we have right now to remove those orders,

1:39:05 By comparison to what this is we can do a cost comparison. I would hate for us to just shut it off

1:39:13 Because I don't know I don't believe that is is necessarily fair

1:39:19 to the individuals who live along the line who want to go out and enjoy an

1:39:25 Evening or a barbecue and they they can't enjoy their backyards because of of some of the odors

1:39:31 associated with the line and it's not it's not Chibani I think it's important

1:39:36 piece to recognize is that it's a big line with low flow and velocity and as

1:39:43 that line because it's designed for the future growth and opportunities of our

1:39:47 community and as that area continues to grow you'll get more flow and you'll get

1:39:51 more velocity the question is when does that happen Rebecca thank you and and

1:39:58 And what neighborhoods are being impacted right now?

1:40:01 I mean, can you show us on the map or give us an idea?

1:40:04 I mean, how much of the community is being impacted right now?

1:40:16 Majority of the complaint, this location,

1:40:19 around carriage and falls and sums your morning sun itself,

1:40:24 that park can be.

1:40:27 When it was bad, I'm sure it was unbearable there at the time.

1:40:30 And with the heat of summer coming on,

1:40:32 I believe it all, it would get worse.

1:40:35 Okay, thank you.

1:40:38 Anything else from the council?

1:40:43 Well, I'd still like to know the council of things that is any merit in pursuing the one on the

1:40:48 Canyon Springs Road and

1:40:51 Putting this other one on hiatus until we get more data or find a better way to mask it or a different location

1:40:58 I don't hear any opposition of the one we're talking about on Canyon Springs

1:41:07 Well my question would be if you've got

1:41:10 six and a half miles of sewer line running and then you

1:41:15 treated for the last half mile to the plant, where are you cleaning up the odor from, the

1:41:22 last half mile or the other six and a half miles?

1:41:25 I apologize, Sean, I was talking to you.

1:41:30 Okay, so Chris had asked the question, you know, what if we just tried the one at Canyon

1:41:33 Springs Road and didn't do the other one?

1:41:35 So I guess my question is if you have one down at the bottom of Canyon Springs Road, aren't

1:41:40 you basically just treating the odor from that point to the end?

1:41:45 Yes.

1:41:46 It's certainly not treating the six miles that it took to get there.

1:41:49 Unfortunately, there's a hydraulic grade there. The water plugs up the entire pipe so you can't do anything above grade.

1:41:56 The one on the bottom of the king of screens will only affect the bottom between there and the planet.

1:42:04 Jackie, you want to give me a little bit more history here.

1:42:08 Some of these manholes were plugged when that order wasn't barrel.

1:42:12 That pushed it up into the subdivision.

1:42:15 The reason why, another reason why we chose that site was just because it was so unbearable

1:42:19 during that time, plugging the manholes is not a good practice though, it just pushes

1:42:24 the odors elsewhere and eventually if you get large suctions or something like that,

1:42:28 as it goes off the pipe when you can't implode pipes to cause damages to the sewer line, so

1:42:34 it's not something we want to continue on.

1:42:36 Yeah.

1:42:38 Thank you.

1:42:39 Great.

1:42:40 Well, I think I'm ready to move, I'd be honest with you Chris, I would possibly disagree with you.

1:42:46 I'm ready to move forward with both of them and then if we can come up with ways to

1:42:50 possibly either move the one on top or to me, they both have to go in.

1:42:57 It's just like Shonda said.

1:42:59 I mean, unless we're going to stop, if we're going to stop treating them, they both have to go in.

1:43:03 And so doing the one down on the bottom really only doesn't do good, we're still going to treat the other

1:43:08 line through there.

1:43:10 The only other property I can see that would be available

1:43:12 is the property, the empty property across the street

1:43:16 and whether we can run the line underneath

1:43:18 from the existing sewer line to that property,

1:43:21 to the south and by property there,

1:43:24 whether it's even available.

1:43:26 So I think we need to get the information

1:43:27 to the highway district that we need.

1:43:29 And we may do our best to make this look the best as we can.

1:43:33 I don't know that I see another place to put it.

1:43:36 Thank you, Vice Mayor.

1:43:43 Well, with the information that we've been given tonight, I see that these locations are

1:43:48 probably the most viable locations.

1:43:52 My only comment would be that if the complaints are coming primarily from farther up the line

1:43:58 carriage lane and sun, the morning sun area, my only alternative suggestion would be that

1:44:07 but maybe we find an alternative in that area.

1:44:09 I mean, if that's primarily where the complaints

1:44:11 are coming from.

1:44:14 To answer Councilman Tockingdon's question,

1:44:17 I wouldn't mind having more information,

1:44:19 some more data.

1:44:20 I think that's what the citizens have asked

1:44:21 in the public hearing.

1:44:23 I believe they're entitled to that.

1:44:24 I wouldn't mind having more information

1:44:27 instead of acting tonight.

1:44:29 But from the information we have tonight,

1:44:31 it seems that these two locations are the most plausible.

1:44:38 Great, Lanting.

1:44:39 Troy, did I hear you correctly that the reason it was

1:44:41 smelling farther up was because we had sealed some down below

1:44:45 in an effort to stop the odor there.

1:44:47 So it pushed it up the line.

1:44:49 Yes.

1:44:50 OK, if we hadn't sealed the sort of the manholes down

1:44:54 at this corner, it would have not

1:44:56 have been smelling up at morning sun and carriage

1:44:58 lane, correct?

1:44:59 It just faded more in the pole line portion of it.

1:45:03 OK.

1:45:04 Again, if we do put the odor unit at this location,

1:45:09 the vacuum on that pipeline will draw air

1:45:12 from a valve filer down.

1:45:14 And so it'll suck that air with it.

1:45:16 So it won't go out at those samples.

1:45:22 Council wishes?

1:45:26 I'm too close.

1:45:27 No, I close it.

1:45:30 Sean Berriger?

1:45:32 So I would agree with Greg.

1:45:35 I think that since the time we had acute odor issues last summer,

1:45:46 the staff in C.S. to Emhill have done a number of things

1:45:52 to try to address that.

1:45:54 And as we listened to all of that, talked about tonight,

1:45:58 I think it may have mitigated the concerns

1:46:02 of these two particular points on the system,

1:46:05 but they still exist.

1:46:07 They just pushed the smell around to someplace else.

1:46:11 I will say, personally, living in Morning Sun,

1:46:14 there were many times that it was literally unbearable

1:46:17 to the outside until the chemical treatment started.

1:46:22 And that whole area, clear around that corner

1:46:26 and up through carriage, I would hate

1:46:31 to go unseal the manholes in the pole line area

1:46:34 and wait for the folks there to decide

1:46:36 that it's going to smell bad enough that something be addressed.

1:46:39 And I think that putting one system in down at the bottom of the canyon

1:46:43 doesn't address the larger issue.

1:46:47 There is no question.

1:46:48 This is waste water.

1:46:52 It's flowing six plus miles.

1:46:55 It's a number of different users that are filling the system.

1:46:59 And it's going to smell.

1:47:01 Our job is to make sure that it doesn't smell and disrupt

1:47:05 the lives of citizens along this entire corridor, not just in one small area.

1:47:12 I really do think that there's been a pretty comprehensive strategy in trying to address

1:47:16 this, and from a cost perspective, it seems to me that these two units help with that certainly

1:47:26 not to abandon all the other strategies as well.

1:47:31 So I'd like to move forward with approving this tonight.

1:47:35 So I'll make that in the form of motion.

1:47:39 I was going to say, is that a motion?

1:47:41 So we have a motion actually is.

1:47:45 We have a motion by Sean Berger, seconded by Greg Lanting,

1:47:48 and Jim Munn is next.

1:47:50 Oh, thank you, Mayor, Vice Mayor.

1:47:52 I guess I'm getting the impression this discussion is somewhat

1:47:56 elementary, and that the Twin Falls High Area District

1:47:58 ain't buying this right now.

1:48:00 And they don't like so.

1:48:01 I would ask staff, what is our plan B if they don't approve this and is there a plan B?

1:48:08 Is there another location that you are exploring if they say no and from my understanding it

1:48:16 looks like it's a no until it's a yes.

1:48:19 Yes, the three chairman, they asked me to, I've been performed twice and they asked to

1:48:25 say, to come before a public forum and say, there's a public forum against it.

1:48:31 I think exactly what Scott said is they own the parcel. They don't want to be the bad guys

1:48:36 They want us to yeah, yeah, of course

1:48:39 But I but I think that's really about education who

1:48:44 Is this unit and we can do that in a form of a I guess a tasteful sign on or something like that if there's if there's

1:48:50 Problems, I'm sure the people are gonna find out exactly who to call okay, and it won't be so there's not a second. Okay

1:48:57 There is not a second location

1:48:59 Any other discussion from the council?

1:49:05 Rebecca Milsweka?

1:49:06 Thank you Vice Mayor.

1:49:07 Well, I would agree with Councilman Berger.

1:49:10 I mean, it seems from the information we have tonight,

1:49:13 even though I would be in favor of waiting and receiving more

1:49:17 detailed information.

1:49:18 But I do trust that CH2M Hill and staff have done their due

1:49:24 diligence and know that this is the best alternative.

1:49:29 So I'm willing to approve it tonight, and then obviously it goes onto the highway district, and

1:49:37 We can react to their decision after that. So we might as well move this option forward

1:49:44 Onto the next governing body

1:49:47 Chris talking to joy is there

1:49:49 An option other than a slotted chain link fence is that necessary for air circulation at the ground level? No, that is

1:49:57 Could there be a solid, and this thing's going to be 15 feet high, I'm not suggesting a wall that high, but something at road level.

1:50:07 No, no, a side of fence definitely isn't the only option in this. You can, we can ask for something else, and I'd be happy to put in a solid block wall or whatever, they're just a cause associated with that.

1:50:20 So, whatever you guys feel work better,

1:50:24 if really the aesthetics of it is unappealing,

1:50:28 then I'd probably go with the block wall.

1:50:30 There's just additional costs there.

1:50:33 And I'd make a amendment that the enclosure

1:50:36 of the Pissen pole line,

1:50:40 what do we call it, order control facility,

1:50:42 have a solid block wall,

1:50:45 extending as high as possible

1:50:47 to block view from road level.

1:50:51 We have a motion to amend the original motion and by Chris

1:50:59 Tockington and seconded by Greg Lanting and Jim on his next before I get

1:51:04 supported a minute like that I'd want to know what the cost where I would submit

1:51:07 that it would be significantly more expensive than a cycle and fence with

1:51:10 splats in it is that true I solid block wall really high so people can't see it

1:51:17 It's probably a factor of ten.

1:51:19 The total cost of the fence is not unbearable.

1:51:24 Okay.

1:51:25 Sean Beriker.

1:51:26 So I was going to simply suggest that that amendment

1:51:33 might be a little more flexibility with the staff

1:51:38 and designed to include aesthetically pleasing buffering

1:51:43 of the unit, as opposed to dictating what the construction

1:51:47 be from up here. I mean, could it have landscape buffering or those types of things? It just

1:51:54 seems to me that so we say put a block wall around it and then other neighbors come and

1:52:01 say I don't want to block wall around it. We don't leave any flexibility for staff to deal

1:52:06 with that.

1:52:11 Well, yeah, like we have a roll call vote on the amendment to the main agenda, please.

1:52:16 Very glancing.

1:52:17 Well, after shots come with them, I'm thinking to vote no.

1:52:22 Chris, talking to you.

1:52:23 Yes.

1:52:25 Rebecca Mills like them? No.

1:52:29 Suzanne Hawkins? No.

1:52:31 Sean Berriger? No. Jim Mann? No.

1:52:37 The motion fails. One to five.

1:52:41 Any other discussion before we move on? Roll call.

1:52:47 Oh. Okay. Roll call vote on the main motion.

1:52:51 Chris Tockeington? No.

1:52:54 Rebecca Mills like that? Yes.

1:52:57 Suzanne Hawkins? Yes.

1:52:59 Sean Berriger? Yes.

1:53:01 Yes. Great. Yes. Motion passes five to one. Great.

1:53:10 Lanting try help that you even though the amendment failed I think that there's

1:53:14 there seems to be quite a bit of entrance here to making that look as best possible

1:53:19 in Shawn's recommendations concerning landscaping and those kinds of things

1:53:23 well it's like those to heart and see what's possible. Yes. We'll do that because again we

1:53:29 You have to go before the highway district and they may have additional requirements.

1:53:32 So we have to, if they'll allow us on their property, then I'm sure we'll have to meet those two.

1:53:38 But yeah, we'll take that to heart and make it as attractive as possible.

1:53:42 All right, thank you.

1:53:43 Thank you, Vice Mayor.

1:53:46 Similar comments, perhaps when we go to the highway district, we can solicit input from the neighbors.

1:53:53 And maybe use that to build a consensus on what would be acceptable for the neighborhood.

1:53:59 Okay.

1:54:00 Thank you.

1:54:01 If the council approves.

1:54:02 Oh, thank you.

1:54:08 Seeing nothing else, we're going to move on to adjournment into executive session.

1:54:13 And it's 67-23451C to conduct deliberations concerning labor negotiations or to acquire

1:54:21 an interest in real property which is not owned by a public agency.

1:54:26 And I would like to say that if we do go into executive session, we will not be making

1:54:31 any final decisions, and we will not be coming back out to conduct business.

1:54:35 I would like to add that Mayor Hall will be joining us for the executive session, so we will have a full council.

1:54:42 So moved.

1:54:46 Second.

1:54:48 We have a motion by Greg Land-Teens, seconded by Sean Verigar.

1:54:52 Leila, can we have a roll call vote?

1:54:55 Yes.

1:54:57 Yes.

1:54:59 Yes.

1:55:00 Yes.

1:55:02 Yes.

1:55:03 Yes.

1:55:04 With that, I close the regular meeting.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Tuesday, May 27, 2014. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:55:18.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    7c1494bb6be5a9cfa4f6c1b1eafae1203d3b21d73fa96a256bf4d56fc959451a
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min, with 1 passage muted for privacy. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a e617cc4b39fd4a34d19df19250872a7c9e6128ae3c1d895d57bdceae6b2f6c2a
    part02.m4a b8a6c6a058b9c2f47e443bb08b48de5383518b39b32007225dcf2702346e2441
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 4 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    bc2b1350fd063de5ef6c06c4e498d745fa39d9800ec31821ac4bbf393fc6b348

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file