OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, June 30, 2014

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Minutes on file

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:02:15 When he doesn't like you, he's really only the person she's ever going to take care of.

0:02:20 I feel building all the trees you've killed.

0:02:22 I'm going to see a side.

0:02:23 A long time ago.

0:02:25 The water was like seven or something.

0:02:28 Very strong.

0:02:30 Yeah.

0:02:32 Hey, I've just been covering it.

0:02:34 She's a city, right?

0:02:36 You're thinking you're still here.

0:02:39 She pulled it.

0:02:40 She pulled everything.

0:02:41 And I discovered something that we've been putting a little plastic container right below our sink.

0:02:48 And so we just fill that up.

0:02:51 And I'm making it helpful on more trips.

0:02:53 I'm going to be siking twice as much as we did before.

0:02:56 But I wouldn't think something that simple could.

0:02:59 You know, it's behavior-wise, if it's just as easy to throw it away as a mystery cycle, you'll do it.

0:03:05 Yeah.

0:03:06 And we're filling that sucker almost to the tunnels.

0:03:10 I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order its June 30th, 2014.

0:03:45 For those of you wishing to join us, please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:03:48 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:04:05 Thank you all, and welcome to the City Council meeting.

0:04:10 We do have a quorum of the council.

0:04:12 All seven members are here this evening.

0:04:14 Acting City Manager Lori Race.

0:04:18 Do we have any amendments to our agenda this evening?

0:04:21 We do not mayor excellent. Thank you. We have no proclamations

0:04:26 And this is the time that we always allow

0:04:30 Members of the public that would like to address the council to come forward and dress the council on in a in a brief way

0:04:37 If you would if it's not something that's already on the agenda

0:04:40 So this is the time for members of the

0:04:44 Our citizenry if you could state your name sir and your address and welcome

0:04:49 Welcome very well. Good evening council members. My name is Eric Wadi, owner of New Leaf Properties

0:04:57 and owner of the old clinic building located in downtown Twin Falls here. I'm sure you're

0:05:02 all familiar with the building. It's kind of upsetting. So bear with me. On June 4th,

0:05:10 2014, Chris Talkington appeared on the radio talk show, Top Story, with Kelly Claus and

0:05:16 Jill Scheme. When Mr. Talkington was asked why the city turned down the old clinic building

0:05:22 which the county was willing to give it to them for free, he replied, it's full of asbestos.

0:05:27 The city would not be looking at it because of the asbestos and it would be a quote multi-million

0:05:32 dollar to remove the asbestos.

0:05:35 You can all go to dub dub dub newsradio1310.com mile marker 59 for your listening.

0:05:43 When I contacted Christock into to ask him what information he had to say about my building

0:05:49 that containing asbestos.

0:05:51 He skirted the issue and then, excuse me, he skirted the issue and said the city was interested

0:06:02 in purchasing my building for its new city hall.

0:06:06 My questions are what information did Chris talk into have to say publicly on air in detail

0:06:12 that the old clinic had asbestos?

0:06:14 Did this city use this information to not take this old clinic for its city hall based

0:06:18 upon the information?

0:06:20 This is very damaging to me and is preventing my ability to sell or lease the building.

0:06:27 According to my records and inspections and all due diligence prior to purchasing the building, there was no asbestos in the building.

0:06:36 I am asking the council tonight to reveal to me if they have any information regarding the old clinic that I am not aware of.

0:06:45 If they do not, I would like a public retraction on top story where these statements were originally made.

0:06:51 recorded for all time and eternity on the show's podcast forever and that's

0:06:55 damaging as well on the show's podcast forever that mr. Talkington misspoke and

0:07:03 that he had no knowledge of my building ever having asbestos I understand that

0:07:09 Chris Stockington will be on top storage a life second and I would like a

0:07:12 retraction at that time if no retraction is made I will go on here to defend my

0:07:18 building these off the cuff comments are damaging to me in my possible sale of

0:07:22 of my building and I would like it rectified as soon as possible since my building is currently on the market.

0:07:28 I would like an answer tonight, since Wednesday is almost here.

0:07:32 I will consider all options to right this wrong.

0:07:35 This is my livelihood.

0:07:37 I take these allegations very seriously.

0:07:39 I have made numerous attempts to contact Mr.

0:07:42 Talkington and talk about this in an open air, but this has pushed me to this point.

0:07:47 I am mad to say the least.

0:07:49 Thank you.

0:07:50 Thank you, Mr. White.

0:07:53 I just want to go on record to state that I'm not aware personally of any asbestos issues.

0:08:00 We have toured the building, I know I've toured at least once early on before you owned it, sir.

0:08:06 And the challenge is that I personally saw with it is the size and scope of the building.

0:08:13 Okay, because it's rather large.

0:08:15 And the remodeling issues regarding, I know that a lot of the different rooms have bathrooms and sinks and for the purpose of a city hall, I found that to be personally challenging.

0:08:27 You can come forward, sir, if you want an answer, because it's always, we're being taped and also there's people who are.

0:08:34 I understand, and that's a fair statement. So why would you say that, Chris? Why would you go in there and say that?

0:08:39 That's a fair statement. If it's too big or too small, that's fine. But why say it's got asbestos?

0:08:43 I'm not doing your dog and pony show here.

0:08:46 Mr. Wadi, he has every right to not get in a debate with you at Council.

0:08:54 That is fair, but I wanted to go on the record and make this statement.

0:08:58 Absolutely.

0:08:59 I made my point.

0:09:00 And you have and you have every right to do so, so thank you for coming to see.

0:09:03 Thank you.

0:09:04 Take care, sir.

0:09:05 Is there anyone else from the public that would like to address the Council to see?

0:09:08 I see no one else running towards the podium, so we are going to move to the consent calendar

0:09:15 and turn it over to council wishes.

0:09:21 Jim, you're going to make a motion?

0:09:24 You're going to make a motion?

0:09:25 No, go ahead.

0:09:26 Go ahead, after you.

0:09:27 Well, you need to.

0:09:28 Well, I just wanted to have a discussion

0:09:29 with Fritz in regards to Duncan.

0:09:31 Okay.

0:09:32 So my son plays, it has been employed

0:09:36 by the Magic Valley Beer Festival

0:09:39 in a band to play music.

0:09:42 And the question is, should I or shouldn't I vote

0:09:44 on that based on Duncan being employed

0:09:47 by the Magic Valley, I just wanted to go on the rec.

0:09:49 I think you should not vote on that.

0:09:51 Very good.

0:09:52 Very good.

0:09:53 We're back in the middle so I can.

0:09:56 Thank you, Mayor.

0:09:57 Just a quick comment or question on the accounts payable on page eight.

0:10:03 I see that we paid the contracts for the median maintenance on Poline in Washington.

0:10:09 And I just had noticed yesterday, actually, that there's a lot of weeds in that median

0:10:14 on polling right in between Costco and Target.

0:10:17 So I just wanted to ask maybe what services we're getting for this.

0:10:24 I mean, we're paying a little bit over $2,000 in just this one payment.

0:10:28 Is this a monthly payment?

0:10:30 And is there someone that checks up on these things?

0:10:33 I also notice on Washington, a lot of the plants are dead in the median.

0:10:37 I don't know if that's our fault for the watering, you know, a water issue.

0:10:42 but maybe we could check up on that contract

0:10:44 because I see that we're paying it.

0:10:45 Do you have any more information on that?

0:10:48 Rebecca, I turned around to see if Dennis was here,

0:10:50 but he's on vacation.

0:10:52 He would be the perfect one to answer that.

0:10:55 So I will send him an email,

0:10:57 and as soon as he returns, we'll get you an answer to that.

0:11:00 Perfect, but yeah, just a comment,

0:11:03 but I'll move approval of the consent calendar.

0:11:06 So we have motion on the floor by Rebecca Milsoka,

0:11:10 seconded by great landing and we have a light Suzanne Hopkins can I make an

0:11:16 amendment to that motion to pull item number three off the consent calendar or

0:11:22 how do we yeah we're just going to pull it okay okay and and then we'll so we're

0:11:29 only going the motion is only for one three and four okay and pulling number two

0:11:34 or no we need to hold number three one two and four pulling number three thank

0:11:38 Thank you.

0:11:39 Very good.

0:11:40 So we have a motion on the floor to approve the consent calendar without number three.

0:11:48 Anything further on that motion council?

0:11:50 The item?

0:11:51 Roll call vote please.

0:11:52 Yes.

0:11:53 Yes.

0:11:54 Yes.

0:11:55 Yes.

0:11:56 Yes.

0:11:57 Yes.

0:11:58 Yes.

0:11:59 Yes.

0:12:00 Yes.

0:12:01 Yes.

0:12:02 Yes.

0:12:03 Great landing.

0:12:05 Yes.

0:12:06 I'm sorry.

0:12:07 I thought I already said.

0:12:08 Did you?

0:12:09 I would like to make a motion that we approve the consent for the third annual Magic Valley

0:12:20 Beer Festival to be held at the Twin Falls City Park on Saturday, August 2nd, 2014.

0:12:28 So we have a motion on the floor by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Greg Lanting to approve

0:12:34 it separately.

0:12:36 there can could you oh you wanted him to be a vote on the rest of the consent

0:12:41 calendar no okay all right okay I was confused yeah I was confused as well

0:12:48 so okay all right you might want to share in the future anything further on

0:12:56 that motion council. Lee idler roll call vote please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion

0:13:16 passes six to with one abstention. I thought we were pulling it so we could have started

0:13:24 to pull up and talk to us. We could still do that. I did not have any questions. Very

0:13:31 Okay, thank you, Suzanne, thank you.

0:13:34 Now moving on to the items consideration,

0:13:37 those of you wishing to follow along,

0:13:38 there should be agendas in the back.

0:13:39 First item is consideration of request

0:13:42 to confirm the appointment of Dexter Ball,

0:13:44 Perry Gardner, and Bob Richards

0:13:47 to the Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency.

0:13:50 This is my presentation, so I'll make it fairly quick.

0:13:54 We, after two full terms by Cindy Bond,

0:13:59 Cindy Bond, our past president of the Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency, as well as I think

0:14:06 she was secretary and vice chair as well, served with distinction.

0:14:14 Her position came open because of doing two full terms, so we had a position open there.

0:14:22 So both Perry and Dexter's positions were rotated to this point where they would either

0:14:29 be reappointed or there would be new individuals for those two positions, both of which have

0:14:36 asked to continue serving on the Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency, both of which have been

0:14:42 active participants and good participants within the Urban Renewal Agency.

0:14:49 And so we did have staff fly the position for the Urban Renewal Agency.

0:14:58 We had three individuals that were interested in that position, and so we took those applications.

0:15:07 I actually sat down and talked to Greg Lanting because he wasn't able to come to the actual

0:15:13 interview process.

0:15:14 He is the liaison to the Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency.

0:15:18 through the three individuals with him because he was not going to be able to be in town for

0:15:22 that.

0:15:23 And then we put together a committee of the vice chairperson who is Leon Smith as well

0:15:29 as our executive director of their renewal agency, Melinda Anderson.

0:15:33 And we interviewed all three individuals.

0:15:36 I will say that all three were well qualified participants in our community and would have

0:15:43 have made great urban renewal agency members, but I think the thing that really made me think

0:15:52 about the choice is we were really trying to find some legacy, if you will, for the urban

0:15:59 renewal agency, someone that had some tenure and some experience, understanding of how the

0:16:05 URA works in the community, and you couldn't ask for a better person than Bob Richards,

0:16:11 In that respect, a past member of the URA, incredibly involved in our community, understands

0:16:18 economic development, understands a lot of issues.

0:16:21 So we as a group felt that he would be a good candidate to bring forward to the Council,

0:16:29 and for my appointment, but you to confirm the appointment, as well as to have Perry and

0:16:35 Dexter continue their tenure on the Ermural Agency.

0:16:39 So I turn it over to Council for questions.

0:16:42 Chris, talk.

0:16:43 Several questions.

0:16:44 I'd like to have the names of all three of the applicants and also would like to have

0:16:50 an understanding.

0:16:52 I think I remember Mr. Richards did resign from urban renewal to take position with a

0:17:00 development group in Jerome and it was done because of a conflict, perceived conflict.

0:17:06 So I'd like to have a little flushing out of these two articles absolutely those are good questions

0:17:11 one is that the other two individuals that applied were Gail Klinekop and

0:17:17 Wayne Borne both well qualified good

0:17:21 participants in our community and

0:17:23 And maybe I'll ask Bob to come forward and and explain the position that you had over in drone before and that it has

0:17:32 is terminated, maybe you could share that with Chris

0:17:36 and we'll go from there.

0:17:38 Well, hopefully to the council, not just to me.

0:17:41 Well, if you have to the council,

0:17:42 but your question, Chris, thank you.

0:17:44 Yeah, I can do that.

0:17:46 I have been the Economic Development Director

0:17:49 in Jerome for about six years,

0:17:51 part of my retirement from that position.

0:17:54 And when the city and county in Jerome

0:17:57 wanted to put together a new economic development position,

0:18:00 They ask if I would consider laying the foundation for that position.

0:18:06 I was willing to commit for a year to put that together, which I did.

0:18:12 And at the end of a year submitted my resignation, it took them about six months to find somebody

0:18:19 to fill that position.

0:18:21 I finally, in fact, had to say I'm leaving, whether you fill the position.

0:18:27 Because I wanted to get back over in the Twin Falls area.

0:18:31 I have great interest in Jerome, but I was born and raised in Twin Falls.

0:18:36 I've lived here most of my life, except for 13 years when I was away in Boise, UCL, Portland.

0:18:44 Always anxious to come back.

0:18:46 And one of my major focuses when I was on the Urban Renewable Board before was the revitalization

0:18:52 of downtown Twin Falls.

0:18:53 That's always been primary in my agenda, if you will,

0:18:58 and seeing that that is, again,

0:19:01 number one priority on the urban rule agency's agenda,

0:19:05 as well as I assume the city council.

0:19:07 I was very anxious to get back to that position,

0:19:10 so I applied for this position,

0:19:12 or at least made it known that I wanted to apply

0:19:15 for that position as soon as I was done

0:19:18 with my duties in Jerome.

0:19:21 That's about it.

0:19:22 Thank you.

0:19:24 We're back in mail, Suica.

0:19:26 Thank you.

0:19:26 This is just a question about the other applicants.

0:19:29 They didn't serve full three-year terms.

0:19:31 How long have the other two been on the board?

0:19:34 And then are they eligible for two more terms?

0:19:37 Or is it more like planning and zoning?

0:19:39 I was just curious about.

0:19:40 My understanding is they finished someone else's terms.

0:19:45 Because I think we had two folks drop off.

0:19:47 One was Bob, due to perceived conflict of interest,

0:19:50 as well as another gentleman, same issue.

0:19:53 And so they've fulfilled their terms,

0:19:56 but I believe they have two more terms

0:19:57 that they could possibly serve.

0:19:59 Okay, and they've served for how long so far?

0:20:02 Year and a half.

0:20:04 How long has it been, Melinda?

0:20:06 It's two through year.

0:20:07 They've served for approximately 18 months.

0:20:09 Year and a half. Yes, thank you.

0:20:11 Thank you.

0:20:12 Okay, thank you.

0:20:14 Any other questions from council or Greg Land?

0:20:17 Mayor Hall, I move that we confirm your appointments

0:20:20 of Dexter Ball, Perry Gardner, and Bob Richins

0:20:24 to three-year terms on the Twin Falls Urban

0:20:26 and Needle Agency Board.

0:20:29 We have motion on the floor by Greg Lanting,

0:20:30 seconded by Jim Munn to confirm the appointments as listed.

0:20:36 Anything further on that motion council?

0:20:39 The aye-la, roll call vote please.

0:20:41 Jim Munn.

0:20:42 Yes.

0:20:43 Greg Lanting.

0:20:44 Yes.

0:20:44 Don Hall.

0:20:45 Yes.

0:20:46 Chris Hockens.

0:20:47 Yes.

0:20:48 Rebecca Nussweiken.

0:20:49 Yes.

0:20:49 Yes?

0:20:50 Yes.

0:20:51 Motion passes.

0:20:52 Seven to zero.

0:20:53 I want to tell all three of you.

0:20:56 Thank you.

0:20:57 It's a volunteer position.

0:20:59 We do buy you lunch.

0:21:01 You do get lunch.

0:21:03 But we really truly appreciate your service in this way.

0:21:07 And what an exciting time to be on the URA.

0:21:10 We're getting some stuff done.

0:21:12 It's exciting time.

0:21:14 Thank you.

0:21:15 Moving on to the next agenda item.

0:21:17 It will be consideration of a request to adopt a resolution that approves participation in a state local agreement for construction to illuminate the intersection of or curve a pole line road and Eastland Drive and to authorize the mayor to sign the agreement.

0:21:34 We have our city engineer, Jackie Fields. Welcome, Jackie.

0:21:38 Thank you.

0:21:39 Our background is that this is one of three local highway safety improvement projects that

0:21:46 I've talked about a time or two, this is to install illumination generally from where the

0:21:53 road widens out at the curve on pull line around the corner as far as we can get for

0:22:01 the money that we put on to chaney drive, that was the rule.

0:22:05 And we got close with them for our lumenares.

0:22:09 So unlike our other project, we actually are being asked to write a check for $348 in

0:22:19 match in addition to what we've already paid.

0:22:25 And that's due to us trying to get really close to the estimate and just chitting it.

0:22:30 We just shaped onto the wrong side.

0:22:31 So we can fund that up to the street construction budget.

0:22:36 And I forgot to put the piece on here of the agenda item where I actually tell you what I want from you.

0:22:41 And what I would like today is for you to authorize the mayor to sign the agreement after you've adopted the resolution that approves participation in the state local agreement.

0:22:55 Do you have any questions on the agreement or-

0:22:58 Do we have a resolution number, not Leona?

0:23:00 1927.

0:23:02 1927, thank you.

0:23:04 Rebecca Milsoica.

0:23:05 Thank you, Mayor.

0:23:06 I'll move approval of Resolution 1927.

0:23:10 With the one clarification, there's 348, and then there's 384 in the report.

0:23:15 Do you know which one is?

0:23:16 It's okay.

0:23:17 I just want to make sure.

0:23:19 I have, it's 348 dollars as shown on exhibit A, so, and I can see my error there, so I apologize for that.

0:23:29 No, that's fine.

0:23:30 Second that motion.

0:23:31 We have motion on the floor by Rebecca Mills.

0:23:33 Second.

0:23:34 by Chris Tawkington to approve the resolution 1927.

0:23:39 We have a question, Sean Berger.

0:23:41 My only question is when might this be done?

0:23:44 Is it a this year project or a next year project?

0:23:48 Well, it'll happen in our current geological era.

0:23:51 Like all construction projects.

0:23:54 So when we send this in, we have about 100 days

0:23:58 from the time that it's submitted until the project is

0:24:00 imported.

0:24:01 And then there is lead time on these clothes.

0:24:04 So unfortunately, we will not make it in this current fiscal year.

0:24:11 And it's likely that it'll be late fall or perhaps early spring job.

0:24:18 Thank you.

0:24:19 It's kind of a bummer.

0:24:23 I see no further lights.

0:24:24 Leana, roll call vote, please.

0:24:26 Greg Lanting.

0:24:26 Yes.

0:24:27 Don Hall.

0:24:28 Yes.

0:24:28 Let's talk with you.

0:24:29 Yes.

0:24:30 Rebecca Nelsweicke.

0:24:31 Yes.

0:24:34 Yes.

0:24:34 Yes, please.

0:24:35 Yes.

0:24:36 Yes, yes.

0:24:36 Yes, yes.

0:24:37 Yes.

0:24:38 Yes.

0:24:39 Jim.

0:24:40 Yes.

0:24:41 Motion passes seven to zero to approve the resolution.

0:24:46 Now you needed a different approval process for me to sign it.

0:24:51 Is that what you said earlier?

0:24:52 The council needs to authorize the mayor to sign the agreement.

0:24:56 Normally we do this in one fell swoop.

0:24:58 I didn't get by it.

0:24:59 Oh, sir.

0:25:00 Did I forgot that?

0:25:01 Oh, okay.

0:25:02 So we'll do a different.

0:25:03 Okay.

0:25:04 All right, excuse me, Susanne, okay.

0:25:06 Okay.

0:25:07 I make motion that we authorize the mayor to sign the agreement to proceed with the contract.

0:25:12 Second.

0:25:13 I have a motion on board by Susanne Hawkins, seconded by Greg Lanting.

0:25:17 Anything further on that motion, council?

0:25:19 Leila, roll call vote, please.

0:25:21 Don Hall?

0:25:22 Yes.

0:25:23 Mr. Talkington?

0:25:24 Yes.

0:25:25 Rebecca Milsoica?

0:25:26 Yes.

0:25:27 Susanne Hawkins?

0:25:28 Yes.

0:25:29 Sean Berwicker?

0:25:30 Yes.

0:25:31 Jim Mann?

0:25:32 Yes.

0:25:33 Is there a thank you, Jackie.

0:25:35 Rebecca Milsuk.

0:25:36 Thank you, Mayor.

0:25:37 While we have Jackie, someone asked me about the timing

0:25:42 of the installation of the signal at Carriage Lane and Addison.

0:25:47 Do you know when that would be happening?

0:25:53 That's going to fall under the same parameters.

0:25:56 So in theory, the state will be able to award a contract 100

0:26:04 days, so three months after a couple of weeks ago.

0:26:08 And then signal equipment took us five months to get on our

0:26:15 North College and Fillmore job.

0:26:17 And the rumor out there is that it's not any faster for

0:26:22 anyone else.

0:26:23 So it is likely to be a spring job.

0:26:26 OK, so same spring, 2015.

0:26:27 Yeah, if we added up, we're looking at eight months before

0:26:30 we can see something that looks like action, although we

0:26:34 will have the opportunity to put in foundations early if

0:26:36 they want.

0:26:39 but the real signal won't be around for quite some time.

0:26:43 Okay, thank you.

0:26:44 I'm sure that's helpful.

0:26:46 Greg, Matt?

0:26:46 Jackie, just a follow-up question on that.

0:26:49 That's at the corner of East London,

0:26:51 and Addison, why is that a state project?

0:26:55 Let's see.

0:26:56 So East London and Polinra, is that what you're asking me?

0:27:00 Are you asking me?

0:27:01 Well, the question that the Rebecca did is that one.

0:27:04 Oh, Carri-Jin Addison, Carri-Jin Addison, I'm sorry.

0:27:08 Okay, so the local highway safety improvement program

0:27:13 is for local roads.

0:27:16 And so it can't be only on the state highway,

0:27:22 although it can intercept.

0:27:23 So we could do a job on file-arm blue lights.

0:27:27 Okay, all right.

0:27:28 Okay, but that is the question.

0:27:29 I just know for my Garmin,

0:27:31 you know, if you come off of the Hanson Bridge,

0:27:33 it'll, if you go, if you turn and go down Addison,

0:27:37 like you normally would to get in footfalls,

0:27:39 It'll tell you at every mile post, please turn around, please turn right because it doesn't recognize that as a road for some reason on garment.

0:27:47 So, because it's a county road, it's not a state road.

0:27:52 So, okay, that's my question.

0:27:54 The program specifically for local roads.

0:27:56 Appreciate that.

0:27:57 Thank you, Jack.

0:27:59 I see no further lies, Jackie.

0:28:01 Thank you.

0:28:03 Next item on the agenda is an update on the August falls.

0:28:06 Wetland construction.

0:28:07 We have Lee Glazeman.

0:28:08 Welcome, Lee. Good evening, Mayor, Councillor, and I just really wanted to stop by and let

0:28:15 everybody know what's going on down at Oggar Falls. We've been doing construction and everything

0:28:19 and I haven't visited with you in a while. And so I just wanted to tell you where we were

0:28:24 and so if anybody asks you any questions, you're updated. But first I'd like to kind of cover

0:28:30 some of the ground that we've gone over to get to this point. As everybody knows, back

0:28:42 back in 2002, the City of Twin Falls purchased the Agra Falls property. This is the St.

0:28:48 Cribber right along in here, Ana. Rock Creek comes in right here. The treatment plant is

0:28:54 right there, and all this property right here is the Agra Falls property. After we've purchased

0:28:59 the Agra Falls property, we put together a task force to come up with a conceptual plan

0:29:09 of all the different things that we wanted to do with it.

0:29:13 We have some places like Cluster Parking, which is now there,

0:29:19 and also a trail system throughout the park.

0:29:23 And we also have these areas right through here,

0:29:26 which are the old rapid infiltration basins

0:29:29 that we were going to develop into wet meadows.

0:29:39 Get a better look at it right here.

0:29:42 You can kind of see the basins in that area.

0:29:44 There's about 80 acres of them down at the site.

0:29:47 Some of the first challenges we had is how do we get pipeline

0:29:51 from the treatment plant down to the vasants?

0:29:54 We had to get down through this area right here.

0:29:56 We had some issues with access.

0:30:00 And so we acquired several parcels of BLM property, one here,

0:30:09 one up here, one over here, and over here.

0:30:12 We actually acquired those through a congressional conveyance.

0:30:15 It was actually an act of Congress

0:30:16 that got us those parcels of ground, so we had access.

0:30:21 And then the next part of it was to get clearances.

0:30:28 This is what the road looked like in 2008.

0:30:33 You're looking to the west, to the right-hand side,

0:30:36 over here at the Snake River, and then, of course,

0:30:38 you've got the talus slope going up on this side.

0:30:41 Some of the challenges that we had,

0:30:42 we wanted to run the pipeline down through the middle of the road.

0:30:45 But you really don't have enough room

0:30:47 to be able to construct a pipeline.

0:30:49 You also do not want to start putting dirt and stuff into the river and so there's some

0:30:55 permitting issues there.

0:30:57 And so the actual construction of the road, that is the same spot.

0:31:06 If you look very carefully, you can kind of see a little turnout right there.

0:31:20 The other dramatic change that we had, the first photo was in 2008 and we had the fire

0:31:24 in 2011, so that a lot of the brush is a lot different.

0:31:30 But we installed a pipeline underneath the road.

0:31:34 As you can see, we stabilized the slope.

0:31:36 We added some width for better maintenance access

0:31:39 and public access.

0:31:44 This is another example.

0:32:02 So as you all know, in the last year,

0:32:04 we've provided much better public access to the site,

0:32:07 and it was the construction of the pipeline

0:32:10 and several grants that allowed us to be able to do this construction.

0:32:22 The goal of the pipeline is to be able to access these rapid infiltration basins right here at this end.

0:32:28 Now the rapid infiltration basins were constructed back in 1980 as a potato processing plant's way to dispose of their wastewater.

0:32:37 What we really wanted to do is to be able to take our treated wastewater rather than discharging it to the Snake River

0:32:43 river to be able to land, apply it, and create wildlife habitat and put less water into the

0:32:49 river itself. So these are the basins that we were going to develop. You can't really see

0:33:00 it in here, but like this basin right here is being divided up into two basins, this one

0:33:05 right here is into two. We've got some monitoring wells around the outside because this is treated

0:33:10 wastewater. We're required a land application permit that they want to keep track of what's

0:33:16 what's happening with water and the groundwater quality.

0:33:24 This is a view of one of the basins

0:33:26 before we did any construction.

0:33:32 This is the same location as we were constructing one

0:33:36 of the ponds.

0:33:41 This is what it looks like as of a couple of weeks ago.

0:33:49 Here's another one of the basins.

0:33:52 It's kind of up through here.

0:33:53 And under construction, we're reconqued toward them.

0:34:00 The original basins were perfectly flat on the bottom.

0:34:03 and we added a little bit of contour to them.

0:34:07 Why did you do that, Lee?

0:34:08 Why the contour?

0:34:11 So part of the idea is, and I do have some slides

0:34:13 a little further on, but I can definitely cover it here,

0:34:16 is that different wetland plants like different water

0:34:21 deaths.

0:34:22 And if we wanted to have just one solid monocultural

0:34:27 over the entire site, you could just go ahead and lock it

0:34:29 in at one water level, plant one plant there,

0:34:32 What we're trying to do is put it a diversity of plant types and also different wildlife zones.

0:34:41 I've got a slide a little further on.

0:34:43 I'll show you.

0:34:44 But this one right here you can kind of see there's kind of a deep water, almost a stream

0:34:48 through it.

0:34:49 Oh, it's full, it looks like that.

0:34:54 You can see that there's some shallower areas on the edges here where one type of plant would

0:34:58 go and other plants would not be able to grow in the deeper areas.

0:35:02 So, during the first week when we were filling these ponds,

0:35:08 we were kind of, you know, just filling them with water,

0:35:11 see how much water they would take,

0:35:13 and kind of taking routine pictures.

0:35:15 And this is one of the routine pictures that was taken

0:35:17 about the third day that we were filling the ponds.

0:35:20 Now, when this photo was taken,

0:35:22 there was something that we didn't notice,

0:35:25 and that is shadow right there.

0:35:27 It's like, what the heck is that?

0:35:30 Well, shadow knows.

0:35:32 The next day, the pond had emptied.

0:35:37 Stink home.

0:35:39 That would explain it.

0:35:41 That's about 10 foot diameter, whole.

0:35:43 Basically shaped like a funnel.

0:35:48 It's like, wow, dolly.

0:35:51 So you go running around down the hills,

0:35:52 and where's this water all go?

0:35:54 And it would come out of the room.

0:35:55 It just went down.

0:35:59 So we put some bent night in, and everything plugged it back up.

0:36:03 Are you filled it?

0:36:04 It's holding water.

0:36:06 That one's taking a little bit more water than the others,

0:36:08 But it's good.

0:36:10 And because of that, this is number three.

0:36:13 We're a little bit nervous about whether or not

0:36:16 something like this would happen again.

0:36:18 And so we're holding off on planting this one

0:36:21 until next spring.

0:36:23 Just if you don't want to put thousands of dollars of plants

0:36:26 in there, and then all of a sudden have a go boom.

0:36:28 And so we're watching this one.

0:36:34 Now back to the question on the contours.

0:36:37 And this one right here, you can kind of see

0:36:38 there's the shallow area.

0:36:39 and there's a deep berry in here,

0:36:41 and there's another shallow area over there.

0:36:45 Now, this deep area is supposed to be for refuge for mollusks

0:36:50 and other types of things that birds like to eat.

0:36:56 And these areas over here are shallow areas

0:36:58 for different types of plants.

0:37:04 This is kind of a color diagram of the different ponds.

0:37:07 These represent really deep pooled areas, deep water areas.

0:37:11 and then all of the different elevations.

0:37:14 And you'll see up on the side here that each one of these colors represents a different depth of water.

0:37:19 And each of those different depths of water have different plant species mixes that go into them

0:37:24 to kind of create that diversity of plant life and also habitats.

0:37:33 Most of the ponds will be basically in your like your bull rushes and your grasses.

0:37:39 But also the one with the deep water ponds will have more of like willows and things like that

0:37:43 around them to create more of a diversity.

0:37:46 And so right now the schedule is that planting will start

0:37:51 in the 15th, I think it is 15th or 16th,

0:37:56 and will be planting, initially will be planting

0:38:01 this basin here, this basin here.

0:38:04 The secondary basins will be seeded,

0:38:07 but these will have actual actual plantings put in them.

0:38:10 The third one that that sinkhole was right there,

0:38:13 And so we're holding off on doing any planting on that one

0:38:16 until next spring.

0:38:19 And one of the other things that has occurred

0:38:22 within the last couple of weeks, it was the basis again.

0:38:35 We had a report that there was some water down in this area.

0:38:41 Well, one of the things that happens when you apply a lot

0:38:45 of water to the land is initially you

0:38:52 You have your ground water table be way down here, you know, the water soaks in and it makes

0:38:57 its way over towards the Snake River, but as you apply water, this ground water level

0:39:02 starts coming up.

0:39:04 After a while, it gets up high enough that it will actually come out of the slopes before

0:39:09 it makes it to the river, so we are actually starting to see springs on the side of the hill.

0:39:15 And right now we have like riparian areas down in here with willows and things like that,

0:39:19 That water will eventually cause those riparian areas to grow and fill in further up this little

0:39:26 and create additional wildlife area.

0:39:28 It also a little bit more interest for people that are hiking down there.

0:39:34 And with that, I guess I bring up one more item.

0:39:38 I know this has been a concern of mine.

0:39:43 You do occasionally see some of this.

0:39:45 You see some moss down there, but it comes and it goes.

0:39:48 kind of, I haven't really figured out the pattern, but generally speaking all the rest

0:39:54 of this is just big, you know, blue water. Some days it'll be a low cloud here. Some days

0:39:58 it'll be crystal clear and it just kind of goes back and forth. It doesn't seem to be

0:40:01 a rhyme or reason to it. But right now it doesn't seem to be like mosses or algae are going to

0:40:07 be a problem. Once we put the plants in here it might change up a little bit. Haven't had

0:40:11 any issues with mosquitoes. I've actually seen a lot of birds flying around, swooping

0:40:16 low over it, things like that. It's seen dragonflies, which eat mosquito larvae, so really haven't

0:40:23 had any mosquito issues that none as of yet. And so this is just basically the status of

0:40:32 things right now. Got ponds of water down there, so if the public goes by and say, hey,

0:40:36 what's going on with the ponds? We're getting ready to plant them, and as they fill in, you

0:40:40 Hopefully it'll be a much more attractive area for the public to enjoy.

0:40:46 Thank you, Lee. We have a couple questions. Chris, talking to you.

0:40:50 The water lead that is gravity piped down is all NPDs permit level.

0:40:58 Right. Has a low phosphorus attachment to it.

0:41:03 But I'm curious and I think that you went over this before.

0:41:07 the ponds that we are using now and the third one in the spring were recon toward which means

0:41:14 we probably removed some dirt but more dirt in certain places.

0:41:20 It was my understanding that the wastewater from the potato plants back in the 80s went

0:41:27 in untreated or virtually untreated I'm not sure and actually called a cause and I'm not

0:41:35 sure the chemical term of supersaturation of the phosphorus soil column. Am I correct

0:41:43 there? And does that present a problem for the water filtering out now? And is that adding

0:41:48 any phosphorus to the soil, to the water output?

0:41:52 Yeah. As far as exactly what is going to happen there, yeah, there were some nutrients that

0:41:59 were added to the soil and some of those may, in fact, leech out.

0:42:03 We went through DEQ that they had the same reports that we had back in 1997, CH2M Hill

0:42:12 was looking at it and everything.

0:42:15 And our plant application permit requires us to do the groundwater sampling.

0:42:19 We had to do sampling beforehand and twice a year and then annual reports.

0:42:27 Because our water meets our NPS permit requirements before it goes to the river, they basically,

0:42:40 just like this previous slide shows, they basically understand that this water met our

0:42:47 requirements of our NPS permit before we set it down there.

0:42:52 So even if it goes down and enters the river exactly the same way it's effectively a second

0:42:57 discharge.

0:42:58 It meant the requirements before it was the requirements.

0:43:01 So that phosphorous is staying attached to the clay or the soil then, huh?

0:43:05 Well, there may be some additional phosphorous is being discharged there.

0:43:11 There may or may not be will.

0:43:13 State's not worried.

0:43:14 When we do our future future samples, we'll be able to see what may be changed from before.

0:43:20 The state's not alarmed or curious or red flagging.

0:43:23 There weren't any concerns.

0:43:24 OK.

0:43:25 Thank you.

0:43:26 Thank you.

0:43:27 Thank you, Mayor.

0:43:28 Thanks for your presentation, Lee.

0:43:30 Because these are wetlands, are there any federal regulations

0:43:34 that are going to govern them now?

0:43:36 Or do they not count as natural wetlands?

0:43:39 Is there a difference between man-made and natural?

0:43:42 There is a difference.

0:43:44 Basically, yeah, anytime you get anywhere near wetlands

0:43:48 and things like that, you've got to go through all

0:43:49 these permitting processes.

0:43:51 And it's like, you have to do this,

0:43:53 you have to do this unless you're creating these wetlands

0:43:57 for another agency, so to speak.

0:44:01 So in other words, these are basically under EPA.

0:44:06 No, we're doing these as a treatment

0:44:10 or to protect the river.

0:44:12 And so because of that, you don't have to go

0:44:18 through the Army Corps of Engineer processes

0:44:20 to be able to do things in these wetlands

0:44:22 because they're basically serving another federal agency.

0:44:27 So it's kind of one of those areas that we can, you know,

0:44:30 we can do what we want in here as long as we're doing it

0:44:32 in accordance with what DEQ and the EPA,

0:44:35 and we don't have to also get permission

0:44:37 from the Corps of Engineers.

0:44:40 Okay, and so do we have to always continue

0:44:42 to keep these up as wetlands, or is it possible in the future?

0:44:45 I mean, if they're not working out, you can discontinue.

0:44:49 One of the issues that we have is that when we went down the road itself,

0:44:53 well, there's two things.

0:44:57 One of them we got the grants to specifically build these,

0:45:01 and so for us to decide not to, I don't know what that would ever sunset.

0:45:05 But the other issue is when we went down the roadway,

0:45:09 there were some areas where there were wetlands that we had to cross,

0:45:13 and when we widened the road we got rid of wetlands.

0:45:17 of engineers required us to create mitigation wetlands.

0:45:23 And so one of the things that we have to do

0:45:25 for at least five years is to monitor and send reports

0:45:29 to the Accord of Engineers to make sure

0:45:31 that we have provided the appropriate quantity of wetlands

0:45:37 to replace the ones that we're moving.

0:45:39 So we have to go at least five years

0:45:41 for the Accord of Engineers.

0:45:42 And then as far as the EPA grants, there was nothing

0:45:46 and there's specifically the said you have to do for 10 years or for a 10 or a

0:45:50 year or two years but obviously as long as possible and I think if we were to

0:45:55 discontinue them we'd have to have a conversation. Sure I was just curious I

0:45:59 don't really have any plans to take it real then but I was just wondering how

0:46:03 they were governed. You do these things you know you take for

0:46:07 no money to be able to create wetlands a little how long do I have to have wetlands

0:46:11 in case something but yeah.

0:46:13 Right, or something or is this.

0:46:14 We're, you know, at a minimum we have to continue

0:46:17 for at least five years.

0:46:18 Okay, thank you.

0:46:21 Sean Berrier.

0:46:22 Leah, thanks for the update.

0:46:23 I'm feeling guilty now for being lazy on Sunday

0:46:26 and not making it down to Hogger Falls.

0:46:27 That was on my plan, but I sat in the backyard instead.

0:46:31 When you presented this information to us a while back

0:46:34 when we were, when you were engineering

0:46:35 and designing this, one of the issues was sort

0:46:38 of the original concept of kind of flowing water

0:46:41 through these and then having it discharged to the river became impossible because ducks

0:46:47 and dogs might get in the water.

0:46:49 But that's not an issue if it's sinking into the ground and then ending up in the river.

0:46:56 It's about coliform, really.

0:46:58 Well there's a couple different issues.

0:47:02 The ducks and dogs and things like that has to do with coliform and E. coli.

0:47:06 In fact that's one of the reasons why we have to have the fences around the ponds is

0:47:10 because I are worried that somebody is going to get into water

0:47:13 and get sick from it.

0:47:15 You know, if you go down to Bluegill Pond

0:47:18 and looked at the levels of California

0:47:20 or even some other natural bodies,

0:47:23 I think you would see similar numbers to what we have here.

0:47:26 But because these come from a city's waste water plant,

0:47:30 it's human origin and things like that,

0:47:33 the requirements are a little bit higher.

0:47:36 Also, the way the EPA looks at discharges to the river,

0:47:41 they really look at direct discharges, surface water

0:47:44 discharges, there's the surface water connection.

0:47:48 And so if we would have wanted to flow through these ponds

0:47:52 and then into the river, they would

0:47:54 be looking at the quality of the water as it enters the river.

0:47:58 And then if you get any kind of natural biological decay

0:48:01 and your plants and things like that,

0:48:02 you could see spikes in your phosphorous, your nitrates,

0:48:06 and you can see all kinds of things.

0:48:07 Well, they don't look at natural, you know,

0:48:09 it's still regulated water until it reaches the river,

0:48:12 so you don't have to really control over nature.

0:48:15 But when it goes through the ground like this,

0:48:18 you know, the EPA, you know, this land application

0:48:22 is a DEQ activity, and it direct is charges an EPA activity.

0:48:28 And so it's kind of a, that's another one of those things

0:48:30 where it makes it really interesting

0:48:31 where we would hope that DEQ can get primacy

0:48:34 and actually be in charge of both of these things.

0:48:36 so it can be a lot easier to coordinate.

0:48:38 I think that's an added benefit of this project

0:48:42 to be able to enhance the riparian areas

0:48:45 along the river as well.

0:48:46 So again, kudos to you and the team

0:48:48 you've been working with on this.

0:48:51 Lee, I have a couple questions.

0:48:53 One is, can you explain to us just briefly,

0:48:57 how do you do the planting?

0:48:58 I mean, I'm just, when I plant my lawn,

0:49:01 it seems like it's a little simpler

0:49:03 than what you're going to do there.

0:49:05 Well, I haven't seen it yet, but on the 15th, 16th,

0:49:08 is when it's actually physically going to happen.

0:49:10 But a lot of the wetland plants are like tubers,

0:49:14 things like that, that they're actually rooted,

0:49:17 a rooted plant.

0:49:17 So is there going to be a swimmer planting?

0:49:20 No, we're going to dry them down.

0:49:22 We're going to drop the water out of them.

0:49:24 Oh, you're going to drop it all the way out, and then.

0:49:27 OK.

0:49:27 Yeah, and we want it to be wet, but not too wet.

0:49:30 They're going to go out there, and they're going to add

0:49:31 to each of these plants.

0:49:32 Jackie quit laughing at me.

0:49:33 You know, like a rice patty after you're a little girl.

0:49:39 I just didn't understand how you were going to do that.

0:49:42 Yeah, but they're going to go out there and they're going to re-brain them down and they'll

0:49:47 prep the ground and we just wanted to make sure everything is nice and wet for them and

0:49:51 they'll plant the different species and different plantings, spacings and things like that.

0:49:56 And it's going to be an interesting couple of days if they plan on getting planted in

0:50:00 about five days.

0:50:01 And then, secondarily, I would assume that this is never going to be ponds that will have fish, bass, those kind of things in it.

0:50:09 Or is that part of the natural cycle, or are there any DPADQ rules surrounding that?

0:50:18 Well, one of the problems is obviously that the public isn't going to be able to access them.

0:50:25 would be nice if the nutrients aren't too strong

0:50:29 to be able to purr perhaps with blue gill

0:50:31 or something like that in there.

0:50:33 Those are just kind of ideas.

0:50:35 And does that help with the whole?

0:50:37 Blue gill, from what I understand,

0:50:40 will help eat mosquito larvae and stuff like that.

0:50:44 The only place that those would probably be effective

0:50:46 is the one, the pair of ponds that have a really deep water.

0:50:50 The rest of these are gonna fill in right now.

0:50:51 They just look like big old lakes,

0:50:53 But we're going to fill in mostly with plants, except for a couple small areas, but it's something

0:50:59 that would be worth trying.

0:51:00 Okay.

0:51:01 I was just curious.

0:51:02 Great one.

0:51:03 Lee, one of your earlier slides showed what used to be that little lake there that looks

0:51:10 to be a lot bigger.

0:51:11 Are we now running Latvul 17 into that lake or what is going on there?

0:51:15 Are you talking about blue gulpondids?

0:51:17 Yeah, well, I guess that's what it's called.

0:51:18 I didn't know the actual thing.

0:51:19 one of your slides look like a pretty good sized thing of water south of the river.

0:51:27 Maybe I was, it's all south of the river, isn't it?

0:51:35 All right, so we had one time talked about possibly diverting lateral 17 into that blue

0:51:41 gold pond. Is that, at the end of the, what we used to be an old channel of the river

0:51:45 it looked like and making that pond larger, is that going to occur or not?

0:51:50 years ago in cooperation with the canal company, there's no ditch that comes right

0:51:56 through here that had breached and went this direction. The ditch was repaired

0:52:02 and the water was sent back over in this area and actually a second

0:52:06 lovely was built right here. So we have the original blue gill pond and then we

0:52:11 have kind of lower blue gill ponds so to speak. We also have water that still

0:52:15 discharges back through this existing one that comes through this area. So

0:52:20 So those are down there right now.

0:52:23 And in fact, Blueville Pond, before we had the BLM property, the actual berm that was

0:52:31 holding the water in there had breached and the whole pond had really drained down.

0:52:36 And in order to be able to repair that berm, it was another one of those practically inactive

0:52:41 Congress to be able to go in there and repair that berm because of all the different levels

0:52:45 you had to go through with the BLM.

0:52:47 And then once the ground got turned over to us,

0:52:49 it was ours, we could just go down there and fix it.

0:52:52 All right, thank you.

0:52:54 Well, Lee, I see no further lights,

0:52:55 but I just wanted to state that we're

0:52:58 so appreciative of a past council, one of the members

0:53:01 is here with us that made this decision, the city staff,

0:53:04 that were involved in it, and all the effort

0:53:07 between making the decision of buying this property

0:53:10 and where we are today.

0:53:11 I think this is going to be a legacy

0:53:12 and something that our grandchildren will enjoy.

0:53:16 Thank you.

0:53:17 Thank you.

0:53:18 Yeah, we had a lot of people involved with this through the years, I mean, going back

0:53:22 even prior to 2000, 2001, I mean there was a group of people that wanted this to be a

0:53:27 legacy from City of Twin Falls forever rather than have it turn into private property homeowners

0:53:34 that the whole community be locked out of forever.

0:53:37 And so, you know, social and falls didn't happen overnight, but as we continue to work

0:53:41 on it and improve it. We're actually trying to, Dennis, is working with somebody to maybe

0:53:46 come up with a plan to figure out how to deal with some of the weeds down there and make it

0:53:49 more natural and more desirable for the public over time.

0:53:53 Well, you know, I've been down there several times and the license plate numbers always kind

0:53:57 of blow me away of how many people from out of state have already figured this out and

0:54:01 they're here. So, kudos. Thank you.

0:54:04 Thank you.

0:54:05 Thank you.

0:54:06 Next item on the agenda is an update on the zoning ordinance amendment process and we have

0:54:10 Mitch Humble. Welcome, Mitch.

0:54:14 This is really a continuation from last week.

0:54:21 So we talked about the last week where we gave the update

0:54:26 on the process with the zoning ordinance.

0:54:28 And it turned into a bit of a conversation

0:54:30 toward the end of that item about how

0:54:34 to move forward with our continued need for amending

0:54:39 our zoning ordinance.

0:54:40 And we had some desire to delay it a week so that the mayor

0:54:47 and councilman could come back and join us.

0:54:49 And then also we've invited our chairman of the Clean Z.

0:54:53 So Tom is here.

0:54:55 And they have Renee over here as well.

0:54:56 So we can talk about how we proceed.

0:55:01 So I don't really want to do a ton of talking again, rather,

0:55:06 just kind of pick up where we left off.

0:55:09 And that was, again, how are we going to proceed with our continued zoning ordinance

0:55:13 amendments.

0:55:14 We have a list of 15 or 16 in there and, you know, 6 or 7 or 8 of those have some level

0:55:19 of work done on them and there's still a bunch that need to get done.

0:55:22 I talked about the, in the last several months that we've been sort of in limbo with the

0:55:28 Zawak Committee and the Planning and Zoning Commission and we've started doing our work

0:55:32 sessions with the Zoning Commission again.

0:55:35 And in those work sessions, we've been having these conversations about updating our zoning

0:55:40 ordinance and many of the commissioners have expressed great appreciation of having been

0:55:46 involved in those conversations that we're not able to be involved in the ZOAC conversations.

0:55:51 And it's like kind of throughout there, what about this idea of continuing to use a planning

0:55:55 and zoning commission in their work sessions or using the ZOAC or some combination of both

0:56:00 or maybe the council wants to be involved in that as well.

0:56:03 We have three, I don't know.

0:56:06 So really I was just throwing it out there

0:56:08 and looking for some feedback from the council

0:56:10 and how we want to proceed.

0:56:11 There's important work that we need to do.

0:56:13 And honestly, it's been sort of floundering a little bit.

0:56:17 We have some real progress coming, in fact, next week

0:56:21 at the P and D. We're having two hearings to adopt two of them

0:56:23 or to work through the adoption of two of those amendments.

0:56:27 But there's a lot more work to do behind that.

0:56:30 So we wanted to get your input on that and where do you want to go with that?

0:56:35 And some of you had asked what the commission thought.

0:56:38 So we asked Tom to come and we can all have this conversation.

0:56:44 So with that, I'll just sort of stop talking and let you guys.

0:56:47 Maybe what we should do is ask Commissioner Frank to come forward and give, give us his input.

0:56:53 Sounds like the council wanted that from before.

0:56:55 So Tom, welcome.

0:56:57 Well, thank you, Mayor and Councilman Persians.

0:57:02 I think we need to keep the conversation going.

0:57:05 What I'm finding, I think what other people are seeing is,

0:57:08 our code is what we refer to with every decision.

0:57:11 It's probably not keeping up with the needs of our community.

0:57:15 I can almost stay very evening during the public hearing.

0:57:19 I'm thinking to you, as I wish we had all the different code that,

0:57:22 it's just not me, the needs.

0:57:26 last week there was a parking question and stuff and we asked staff what the rest of the state was doing is completely different.

0:57:33 We're doing not to say that that's good or bad, but it shows that we need to be reviewing things on a constant basis.

0:57:39 That's not happening. I think we're reviewing it on a reactionary basis at times.

0:57:44 You know, and I think this process, once it starts, and I think P&Z is a good place for it,

0:57:51 Because all of our means are public, the fact of public,

0:57:55 our work sessions and stuff like that.

0:57:58 And I haven't heard what you've read here.

0:58:02 What I've read that perhaps that discussion might start

0:58:04 in a work session, you know, once a month or something

0:58:08 like that to start going through this list

0:58:10 and really start going through everything.

0:58:13 But that's my concern right now is a lot of things

0:58:15 that I've seen even through Zolac, or I see on this list now.

0:58:19 we need to review everything, to see if it's valid day,

0:58:24 it could be valid, but we don't know

0:58:25 unless we bring it up and go through it.

0:58:28 And if it's not valid, what can we do to make it meet

0:58:30 our community's needs today?

0:58:33 And there's a lot of people on the commission right now,

0:58:35 several people who are saying, gosh, just get to it.

0:58:38 I'm excited about talking about it.

0:58:40 Yes, sir.

0:58:41 You know, Tom, I have the question that if we decide

0:58:44 to not utilize ZOACN, or utilize P&Z,

0:58:48 One of the strengths that I saw with ZOAC is when it was a specific issue where we really wanted to reach out to the community and invite people in and talk to them, will we lose that?

0:58:58 Will we be able to do that with P&Z in your work sessions?

0:59:01 I don't think so. And again, I'm talking, I'm committed, you know.

0:59:06 But I don't think so, because our means are public means. And I think there's several different avenues for the public.

0:59:13 I don't think we'd ever talk anybody down at a public meeting, because it was a public

0:59:17 meeting.

0:59:18 And if it gets that far, we'd also have a public hearing for more public input.

0:59:23 You folks would have hearings for more public hearings for more input, so I could think of

0:59:28 probably at least three opportunities for the public to stay out and be counted.

0:59:32 But there were specific times, I believe, that we went out into the community and invited

0:59:36 people to come.

0:59:37 And I'm wondering if that's going to be kind of the same philosophy here.

0:59:40 I'm just thinking out.

0:59:41 I assume that the meeting would be noticed as it is public and the subject matter would

0:59:47 be noticed so people have an opportunity to show up.

0:59:52 On those meetings that we noticed during ZOAC, we had like two people during that one, maybe

0:59:57 three.

0:59:58 Correct.

0:59:59 And very valuable input.

1:00:00 In fact, it was crucial input to the discussion that we had and that input directly was reflected

1:00:07 in our work.

1:00:09 So that was valuable.

1:00:10 I don't see that diminishing in this at all.

1:00:14 We have several lights on, so I'm going to start addressing the lights.

1:00:17 So Suzanne Hawkins.

1:00:19 Thank you.

1:00:21 This question's for you, Tom.

1:00:22 Don't sit down.

1:00:23 So from working with Planning and Zoning in the past and knowing who is on that commission,

1:00:28 it is a great group of people who are also very, very busy with life and jobs and everything

1:00:35 else they have going on.

1:00:37 Is it fair for one lunch hour a month?

1:00:40 And I know there's other things you need to discuss during those meetings besides ZOAC

1:00:44 information, is that really enough time to drill down into this the way it needs to be?

1:00:50 Because to me, it doesn't feel like you're going to have enough time to get into the meat

1:00:54 of an issue before everybody has to get back to work at one o'clock.

1:00:57 Fair question.

1:00:58 PNC is completely different than my first term on PNC.

1:01:05 We used to have four meetings, not.

1:01:07 two work sessions and then the two public hearings.

1:01:10 And in the work sessions, there was a lot of ongoing

1:01:13 conversations about the subjects that were gonna come up.

1:01:16 That doesn't happen anymore.

1:01:18 So to the time aspect, I think yes, it can happen.

1:01:24 And I have brought up and I haven't gotten any feedback

1:01:26 from other people too, but maybe we could do two

1:01:30 work sessions a month.

1:01:31 I don't know, we'd have to talk about that.

1:01:33 But I do think we could devote one being a month,

1:01:37 And that's all Zowak ever was at its peak.

1:01:40 I don't think there's an issue.

1:01:41 Is one hour long enough, though?

1:01:43 Or do you really need a little more time than 60 minutes

1:01:45 to get into it, to get something accomplished before you break?

1:01:48 I just know by time.

1:01:49 It's a great question.

1:01:50 I think one hour is better than no hours.

1:01:52 OK.

1:01:53 Yeah.

1:01:54 Whether you might take multiple means.

1:01:56 Because what we found on Zowak a lot of these things

1:01:58 are pretty big.

1:01:59 Oh, yeah.

1:02:00 Yeah.

1:02:01 And they're pretty scary.

1:02:03 And it could take several means.

1:02:06 And they should, some of these, you know, I look at it as an evolutionary process, not a revolutionary process.

1:02:13 And so we just got to take small bites and just show some progress.

1:02:18 I think that's better than nothing.

1:02:20 And just in your opinion, to get more feedback from the community, do you really think lunch hour is the best time?

1:02:26 Or should we look at maybe moving that work session to a different time slot to encourage more attendance?

1:02:32 Or do you have any gut feeling?

1:02:33 I think people really care show.

1:02:35 I think you folks see that on a consistent basis, those who care, make the time to show.

1:02:41 Thank you.

1:02:42 I've got three other lights, Renee.

1:02:44 I would really like your input, but I'm going to go through the lights first, and then I

1:02:48 want to make sure that I call you up here.

1:02:49 And if there's something specific that you want to address, please let me know, please.

1:02:53 Sean Berriger.

1:02:54 I think I too was, last week when we discussed this, I think my biggest concern was time.

1:03:02 I think it, having this all presented, I think it makes sense for the Planning and Zoning

1:03:07 Commission to do this.

1:03:08 I think it sort of sits in your level of expertise as opposed to creating another level of meetings

1:03:16 to trickle it through.

1:03:17 However, if it's just more stuff to do and you can't get it all done and it doesn't get

1:03:23 done well, I don't think it serves the purpose.

1:03:28 So, I mean, I'm sixes on this one on how it gets accomplished, as long as it gets accomplished.

1:03:34 So, Tom, I appreciate your comments.

1:03:36 So, you know, I think the commission is a lot like the citizens, too.

1:03:41 Those who care will engage in it and get it done.

1:03:43 And those who are there for other things will get those things taken care of.

1:03:47 So, I think as long as we can keep forward momentum and not overwhelm, not only the commission,

1:03:53 but certainly the planning and zoning staff as well.

1:03:56 I think that's where the city staff is fantastic.

1:04:01 They don't allow us to get bogged out in other things.

1:04:05 From their body language to everything else, I could tell.

1:04:10 Then that becomes the chairman's job.

1:04:12 Let's move it on.

1:04:14 You're absolutely correct.

1:04:15 Because it starts bogging down the people who's interested.

1:04:18 It just won't work.

1:04:20 And so I look forward to hearing from Renee as well,

1:04:22 but perhaps it's even from a staff issue.

1:04:24 staff issue, maybe it's easier to not have to deal with yet another committee of putting

1:04:28 stuff together. I mean, it's not to put stuff together, but again, I think if it is possible

1:04:35 to do it within the Planning and Zoning Commission, it makes sense to just do it there.

1:04:40 Thanks, Sean. Chris Dockington.

1:04:42 Well, I think Susan and Sean and I are all nibbling around the same issue. The fact that

1:04:49 Title 10 was largely outdated, outmoded, non-accurate, and not adequate to meet our current zoning

1:04:58 needs, shows that the current process of the Council and P&Z has been inadequate.

1:05:06 And when we're dealing with citizen government with limited time, I'm not a saying one and

1:05:12 what is optimistic that this is going to work.

1:05:14 I'm totally supported through our transparency rules to send it back to P&Z.

1:05:21 But I think we need to give it a trial period, Tom, six months to a year to see if we make

1:05:26 progress.

1:05:27 As you recall, participating on this with ZOAC, we just hit the easy items and we barely nibbled

1:05:35 six of the 16, I think, is about all that we managed to forward to P&Z.

1:05:42 And now they're lost somewhere in the black hole between P and Z and counsel, and some

1:05:46 of them the counsel has turned down.

1:05:48 So I'm not as optimistic.

1:05:51 I don't see how people that are charged with the responsibility of receiving the application's

1:06:01 process are going to have time to do all this other stuff that requires legitimate in

1:06:08 in-depth research and input from outside people.

1:06:15 I guess unless we put you on the payroll full-time

1:06:18 or something, I don't see how it's gonna...

1:06:20 Don't do it.

1:06:22 Good intentions are not enough or it would have been done.

1:06:24 We failed and the P&Z has not been able to live up to it.

1:06:28 I hear what you're saying.

1:06:29 I think my frustration is that if we don't try,

1:06:33 then we know the results.

1:06:35 And we have to try this.

1:06:37 And it may be a short period of thing.

1:06:40 I think the staff has as much interest,

1:06:43 if not more interest in seeing something happen.

1:06:46 We do, because they live with the results every day,

1:06:50 you know, with the applicants coming in.

1:06:53 And so I think there's a will and desire

1:06:56 to make some kind of a progress.

1:06:58 But you're right, I think proof of performance,

1:07:01 we have to try, otherwise we know what we'll get.

1:07:06 But we had that need before Tom that didn't work until we...

1:07:10 We were moving along.

1:07:11 Now we responded to largely responded to requests, not trying to get ahead of the game is what

1:07:17 I'm talking about.

1:07:18 Sure.

1:07:19 We took the low hanging fruit.

1:07:21 We talked about that, but we did something and I think that's the important thing is to

1:07:26 try to do so.

1:07:27 Oh, you're fake the ZOAC.

1:07:28 Yeah, we did.

1:07:29 But before ZOAC, we did nothing.

1:07:30 Oh, we did nothing.

1:07:31 It was reactive.

1:07:32 I think that if there's any code changes,

1:07:34 it was probably based on reaction to problems.

1:07:37 And after the fact, you know,

1:07:40 and not really strategically planning down the line,

1:07:43 I think it was reactive, you know,

1:07:46 that'd be my observation, so.

1:07:49 The only disagreement I have with both of you

1:07:51 is I don't think we took just a low-hanging fruit,

1:07:54 because that can't even rim overlay things.

1:07:56 Yeah.

1:07:57 Yeah, I'll just throw that out.

1:07:59 Rebecca Milsoica.

1:08:01 Thank you, Mayor.

1:08:02 Well, I've been able to attend most of the work sessions that the planning and zoning has had.

1:08:07 And they only have one a month and they have to be there anyway.

1:08:09 So I mean, I know there's a question of is this too much work and they get it done.

1:08:13 But really, so since January, we've reviewed, they've reviewed two different,

1:08:21 maybe two or three different code amendments that had already been through ZOAC.

1:08:25 But those showed up once in February and then we didn't address it again until once in June.

1:08:30 So really, each month we could have, or they could have really addressed one, otherwise the

1:08:36 work sessions are pretty light.

1:08:38 Fritz will help us go through some of the laws and Mitch and Renee are there to help

1:08:43 them review some of the criteria that they should be using in going over the Land Use

1:08:50 Planning Act.

1:08:51 So they've been really productive, but honestly I think there's been a lot of room for more

1:08:56 issues and really I would encourage the staff who if we use a ZOAC committee or

1:09:00 some other formed committee the same people will be creating the agendas and

1:09:05 going to these meetings so really you're just creating an extra meeting and so I

1:09:10 don't know possibly it's it's maybe easier on the staff and and one thing you

1:09:14 know I mentioned last week was that there were a few issues that when they

1:09:19 went through ZOAC they weren't opened up to the public or somehow that message

1:09:23 didn't get out, they weren't really advertising, so some people were invited, but some people

1:09:27 weren't.

1:09:28 And so I kind of liked the idea of the public meetings, the work sessions are public, you

1:09:32 know, planning and zoning meetings are public, and that does give two different times.

1:09:36 If they can't make the new work session, they can come to a six o'clock meeting when it comes

1:09:42 to that public hearing process.

1:09:43 And I think it's better to invite everyone, invite the public, and notice it in that way,

1:09:49 the way a public hearing is noticed as opposed to a separate committee meeting, I think it's

1:09:54 more straightforward and less bureaucracy.

1:09:57 The commission has been doing a great job and several of the members like Tom express, several

1:10:03 of the members really are enthusiastic about it.

1:10:06 They really want to get into working on these zoning amendments.

1:10:11 And I believe that it's been working really well.

1:10:14 City staff has been doing a great job bringing those very specific, very targeted

1:10:21 Issues and they've been having very good discussions

1:10:24 And I think it's been working well and and for the public's information those

1:10:29 Public hearings are going to be July 8th at 6 p.m. On on our most recent

1:10:35 Code amendment proposals so so far

1:10:38 I think they're doing a good job and I think that it's working well and and I do want to give them a chance to

1:10:43 to work through these.

1:10:44 I think they can do some good work on it.

1:10:46 Thank you, Rebecca.

1:10:47 I think at this time we'd like to have an A come forward.

1:10:49 Do you have anything that you would like to add

1:10:51 or inspire us, Renee?

1:10:57 Thank you, Mayor Hall and Council,

1:11:00 for the opportunity to give you my opinion.

1:11:03 I have been with planning and zoning for many years,

1:11:07 and I would like to say first off,

1:11:09 that we all know our code is a living entity.

1:11:12 Our community changes all the time,

1:11:14 And I believe that the Planning and Zoning Commission

1:11:17 is a body that deals with these code issues

1:11:20 at every meeting that they have.

1:11:23 Years ago, the commission was the body

1:11:26 that did review questions that came up from staff

1:11:31 when people would come in and say,

1:11:32 this isn't working, how can we fix this?

1:11:35 And staff would talk to the commission

1:11:38 and the commission would put together a list

1:11:40 of different things that they could see

1:11:42 that needed some changing and updating.

1:11:44 And that's how our process went.

1:11:48 I feel the process is a good one to go back to the commission.

1:11:52 Like Rebecca said, this is a notice public meeting.

1:11:55 I think if we have the opportunity

1:11:58 to engage the full commission in these meetings that

1:12:01 are happening right now once a month,

1:12:04 we can be pretty specific and maybe some topics of discussion

1:12:09 when we have the code amendments that we're looking at

1:12:12 to bring forward.

1:12:14 The staff is now not just one, there's now three of us,

1:12:19 and that does also make a difference.

1:12:20 There's a couple of the two planners

1:12:23 are very involved dealing with people at the counter

1:12:26 that do have specific issues.

1:12:27 It's not always the big picture of the whole code,

1:12:31 the whole title of it.

1:12:34 Little steps at a time make huge differences,

1:12:36 and that's what I can see us doing.

1:12:39 I have a list personally from people who I've talked to.

1:12:43 I have probably 25 items on my list, little things that I've noticed over the years that

1:12:50 just consistently come up.

1:12:52 Those are the things I'd like to take to the commission and I think that's their role in

1:12:55 looking at.

1:12:56 So I'm extremely supportive and I think that they will be able to make a big difference.

1:13:02 I don't know if we'll go to two meetings a month or not.

1:13:05 Like we said, we used to do that because we've met the Tuesday before the public hearings and

1:13:10 kind of went over everything, but I would certainly like to give them an opportunity.

1:13:16 I know they have expressed interest in it.

1:13:18 I don't know if you have questions for that or?

1:13:21 It doesn't look like it, but your input is really valuable.

1:13:24 I appreciate that.

1:13:25 Thank you.

1:13:27 Do you?

1:13:28 She mentioned something there.

1:13:29 I just want to follow up a point on that I haven't thought about before until just now.

1:13:35 The City Code says we can initiate an amendment to the Title 10 in three different ways.

1:13:39 one would be there were the Council to take action to initiate it. Two was for the P&Z

1:13:44 to take action to initiate it or a third would be for an applicant from outside to make a request.

1:13:48 Nowhere in there does it say the ZOAC can do it and so Renee has mentioned that she's got

1:13:55 a list of 25 or so little tweaks and none of those have been officially initiated for change

1:14:03 So we can't really work on those and bring back an amendment to the whatever, but if we're

1:14:10 going to use a commission in this role, you know, we could at those meetings say here's

1:14:15 a list of more.

1:14:16 Do we want to add these to our list of 16 or not?

1:14:19 And that's a body that can actually do that.

1:14:22 Whereas before, I think we had this conversation one time in the ZOAC meeting maybe a year ago

1:14:28 An item came in front of the Zowak from outside and we talked about it.

1:14:32 Zowak Committee is this be something that we should be working on.

1:14:35 And really we as a Zowak we couldn't do that without first coming to the planning zone in

1:14:41 the council anyway.

1:14:42 In the end we didn't add that to our list.

1:14:47 So we didn't spend time working on it.

1:14:49 But using the commission in this capacity might give us that opportunity to say oh something

1:14:54 just came up and is that worth us, you know, taking a chance on.

1:14:58 The other thing I was going to say in response to the Christmas thing, I think the list of 16

1:15:02 that we have, probably half of those are reactionary, that's why they're on the list.

1:15:06 Some of those are a bit more forward thinking because

1:15:10 our comp plans suggest that we do some things, but really it's split.

1:15:14 You know, some of that. We're still kind of in that reaction mode.

1:15:18 So, anyway, those are my thoughts.

1:15:23 Thank you very much.

1:15:26 The way I look at this council is I think we've heard from a few members maybe a direction.

1:15:31 I think maybe if we spend a little bit of time sharing our personal direction, I think that

1:15:36 would be helpful.

1:15:37 What I see, well first of all, whatever we do, if we decide to take the trial time, which

1:15:43 I like what Chris said about maybe six months, see if it actually works, if it doesn't, maybe

1:15:47 we need to go back.

1:15:48 But we need to engage those ZOAC members.

1:15:50 Let me ask that question.

1:15:51 We engage them to let them know.

1:15:54 They're on hiatus right now.

1:15:56 Yeah, there's two ZOAC members who are not on the council

1:15:59 or on the P&Z already.

1:16:01 And so I had conversations with one of them

1:16:04 and they emailed two of the other saying, hey,

1:16:08 just working on it.

1:16:10 Okay, okay.

1:16:11 Hang on.

1:16:12 But the other thing I would say is that back in December,

1:16:15 when our transparency thing happened,

1:16:17 we disbanded the ZOAC, it was gone.

1:16:20 And then we did a resolution here at the council

1:16:22 where we created the ZOAC and then the mayor appointed

1:16:24 two council members to be on the ZOAC.

1:16:26 So essentially we have a ZOAC now with two members

1:16:29 and that's it.

1:16:30 So the rest of them were kind of let go.

1:16:33 And in a sense-

1:16:34 Did they do?

1:16:35 Remind me Mitch, did they know that?

1:16:36 Yeah.

1:16:37 Okay.

1:16:38 And that's been a while.

1:16:39 Okay.

1:16:40 Yeah.

1:16:41 So to use the ZOAC, if we want to go back down that path,

1:16:44 we would need to repopulate it

1:16:46 with an appointment process here at the council

1:16:48 that we haven't done yet with the exception

1:16:50 of the two council members.

1:16:52 So it would be a smooth transition

1:16:54 to be able to turn this over to the work sessions at P&Z

1:16:58 on a trial basis.

1:16:59 And if it didn't work, we could,

1:17:01 we already have a ZOAC committee in codified

1:17:05 that we could re-institute or.

1:17:14 I don't think it was codified.

1:17:15 Wasn't codified.

1:17:16 I think it was a resolution.

1:17:17 Yeah, a resolution.

1:17:18 Yeah, okay.

1:17:19 It was the same resolution where we created the tier one.

1:17:22 Okay.

1:17:23 Okay, but we could revitalize the resolution, I guess.

1:17:28 So my opinion is I like the idea, I don't want to look at a commission that says, give

1:17:35 us work, we want to do this and say no, so first of all, thank you to you and your commission.

1:17:42 And I think that we should give it a trial.

1:17:45 Chris talking.

1:17:46 Tom, Dr. Thicke, makes sense to try two meetings a month.

1:17:53 I'm going to get ahead of just your normal.

1:17:55 Yeah.

1:17:56 Well, I was trying to think, you know,

1:17:57 I think we had the ZOX, because it's like an hour and a half.

1:17:59 Yeah.

1:18:00 And, you know, I brought the two beings up from us,

1:18:04 because being an old fighter, I remember

1:18:06 what the old times were like.

1:18:10 Yeah, I think it was tried one minute a month.

1:18:13 And then if everybody is, part of me

1:18:17 is thinking this is, you know, that people

1:18:19 are going to be excited about this possibility

1:18:22 and that our attendance will, at those means will rise,

1:18:26 not that we're down, but I think people want to show up

1:18:29 because there's a, there were those people

1:18:31 who wanted to be involved with this.

1:18:33 And if there's really an upswell saying,

1:18:36 by Godless, bites more off this sandwich,

1:18:40 then I'm sure that we could sort of talk about that.

1:18:42 But if you wouldn't mind, let's go with the one a month

1:18:46 and see, I think we need to show progress.

1:18:49 and let's try it with one and go from there.

1:18:54 Rebecca, may I second?

1:18:56 Thank you, Mayor.

1:18:57 I completely agree with the Council

1:18:59 and the way that the direction that they're going.

1:19:01 And being a part of those meetings, like I said,

1:19:04 the agendas really are pretty light.

1:19:05 And we'll really have to rely on staff

1:19:07 to put on those agendas, the items.

1:19:11 And I think that's what will drive the forward movement

1:19:13 because the commission has really been great

1:19:16 in their discussions and moving forward.

1:19:18 So as long as they have something to discuss monthly,

1:19:21 I think the once a month really is plenty.

1:19:24 And some people stay longer.

1:19:26 So you'll have to go right at one o'clock.

1:19:28 But I've seen them go an hour and a half.

1:19:31 But they really do have healthy, diverse discussions.

1:19:35 And I've enjoyed watching that and hearing

1:19:38 from all of the different members.

1:19:39 And I do appreciate all of the commission members.

1:19:43 They're really a great bunch of people.

1:19:45 and they're willing to attack this big project.

1:19:49 So I think that they'll be able to have some progress

1:19:53 in the next few months.

1:19:56 I don't think we've heard from Jim,

1:19:57 Mon, Greg Lanting, or Suzanne,

1:20:00 I think you kind of express,

1:20:02 but I'm not sure what direction you want to get.

1:20:04 So let's start with Jim.

1:20:06 Do you have any?

1:20:07 I, no, I don't.

1:20:09 Zoning amendments are moving me towards unconsciousness.

1:20:13 quickly at however you want to proceed here very good so I'm going to put that as

1:20:17 being neutral on the subject Greg Lanning being an old seven year veteran

1:20:25 planning zone and I would certainly like to give them an opportunity to work

1:20:30 through this and maybe actually move it along better than we have very good

1:20:34 Suzanne Hawkins yes I would love to see the planning and zoning board take this

1:20:39 on like Chris though I would like you to really consider the twice a month

1:20:43 because I know personally, if you're in the middle of something and you're waiting 30

1:20:46 days to pick it back up, sometimes it's hard to pick up where you left off and keep things

1:20:52 moving.

1:20:53 So I'm very happy to give it a shot, but if you guys would consider twice a month instead

1:20:57 of once a month, I would be very supportive of that as well.

1:20:59 Thank you, Suzanne.

1:21:00 Chris, talking to you.

1:21:01 Well, just one more comment.

1:21:02 And I see reason now why the Council is not acquainted with the workings of ZOAC, but

1:21:08 I can assure you, it was very little of sitting around voicing opinions on the matter and much

1:21:13 more in-depth research that Mitch provided ordinances from around the country where he

1:21:19 worked, Renee speaking.

1:21:22 So it takes a certain amount of momentum to build up where you can start saying yes or

1:21:27 review these two different or three different proposals and what problems and Mitch should

1:21:35 have to go back and do more work.

1:21:37 It's going to take, don't you think, Tom, three months

1:21:40 to even build up any momentum?

1:21:42 I just don't want to make it seem easier than it really is.

1:21:45 Well, wait, is you and Don well know?

1:21:50 Yeah.

1:21:51 I think the positive to this is there's

1:21:55 no one on the plans on commission that

1:21:57 chis away from voice and commitment to their opinions.

1:22:01 And I think that speaking these thoughts

1:22:04 allowed and having that open and free discussion was very healthy and very healthy and you know

1:22:10 I'm hearing what Chris, what you and Suzanne are saying and I think what we do is Wednesday

1:22:16 we have our work session and should you folks give us guidance to proceed, let's ask, I want

1:22:22 to ask the folks, hey you guys want to just, we'll make it officially, we go an hour and

1:22:26 a half or get their feedback because I don't want to say this is what we're going to do

1:22:30 by golly and let me get their feedback and I know there's some people that are

1:22:37 excited about possibilities but you're right you know some of these are really big

1:22:41 big subjects there and they're gonna take several meetings to go through but

1:22:46 we just have to start someplace. Thank you Tom I think we have guidance

1:22:52 and should you feel, Tom, do you feel like?

1:22:55 Okay.

1:22:59 Thank you, Tom.

1:23:05 Okay, Renee just said for folks,

1:23:06 you're gonna have cookies with the,

1:23:09 I wanna go there.

1:23:10 Okay, I might show up to some of these.

1:23:12 So.

1:23:13 All right, Council, thank you for that input.

1:23:16 I think it was valued and appreciate the Council one,

1:23:19 bring it back when there was a full Council here too,

1:23:21 because this is a very important subject.

1:23:23 So thank you for that.

1:23:24 The next item on the agenda is public input and or items from City Manager and City Council.

1:23:28 So at the beginning, like at the beginning, at the end, we always give a chance for the

1:23:34 public to come forward and address the Council on any issues that they might have that weren't

1:23:39 on the agenda this evening.

1:23:41 Is there anyone from the community that would like to do that?

1:23:45 I see no one rushing for the podium, so we're going to turn it over to City Manager race.

1:23:52 Do you have anything further for us?

1:23:54 City Council, any issues, anything they'd like to bring to our attention?

1:24:00 Greg Lanning.

1:24:01 Well, I'm not sure I know the time, so I'm going to ask for some help.

1:24:04 Rebecca, since her husband plays the band, what time, like the band,

1:24:08 performs and things on the 4th of July at CSI and that kind of stuff.

1:24:12 If you could outline those for the public.

1:24:14 That is a good question.

1:24:15 I believe, don't mark my words, but I believe it's 8 o'clock on it.

1:24:19 They won't have their regular Thursday band concert in the park.

1:24:23 So don't go there on Thursday, it'll be Friday at CSI, but I think it's their regular time, 8 p.m. in front of the Fine Arts Center for 4th of July, right before the fireworks.

1:24:32 Thank you, Rebecca.

1:24:34 May you tell me to tell C, Casey, and you didn't know exactly that.

1:24:39 Excellent. Thanks for bringing that out. Anything else from Council? I see no further lights. So, Suzanne.

1:24:47 Sorry, I was trying not to take Christmas thunder.

1:24:50 Tomorrow is the open house at the airport at noon from 12 to 1 30, is that correct, Chris?

1:24:55 Go ahead.

1:24:56 I think you got the time better than I do.

1:24:58 Okay.

1:24:59 They're going to be, I believe, revealing the architect's drawings for the new expansion

1:25:04 going on at the airport, and we'd like to see lots of public come out and take a look

1:25:08 at what is being proposed to our airport.

1:25:11 Thank you, Suzanne, for that reminder.

1:25:13 Anything further?

1:25:15 I see nothing.

1:25:16 So we are adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, June 30, 2014. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:25:26.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    ab71b371fb972da0cfc0e646930342396bfbdda27c44a9aa4cd652b17ffcc07f
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 533b44b3ded3cfc580086672fa27d6146207894edfdcc9282d039eb2b01f0759
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    d57631eb9ae1a4c47ef03187d078df1491e76d8d21ceb9b05575ea48291e6e2d

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file