City Council meeting
Monday, July 21, 2014
Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
The audio for this recording isn't posted yet. It's being held back until a privacy review is finished. The transcript below is complete apart from marked passages.
Transcript
0:01:03 I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order. It is Monday, July 21st, and a little bit after five.
0:01:09 I see no Boy Scouts or Girl Scouts in the audience, so for those of you wishing to join us, please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance.
0:01:17 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:01:33 I'd like to welcome everyone to the meeting.
0:01:37 We do have a quorum of the city council.
0:01:40 Jim Mundt was not able to make it this evening
0:01:42 at prior engagements.
0:01:44 Mr. Rothwiler, do we have any amendments
0:01:46 to our agenda of evening?
0:01:48 There are no amendments this evening.
0:01:50 And we have no proclamations.
0:01:52 So the next item is public input, anyone from the public
0:01:55 that would like to address the council.
0:01:58 I know Mr. Johnson is going to adjust us just after the budget.
0:02:02 I don't see anyone else that looks like they're coming this way.
0:02:05 So before we go on to the consent calendar,
0:02:08 I did want to mention something I got.
0:02:10 I'm not sure how I got this if it was delivered to my doorway
0:02:14 or not, but Magic Valley Life and it's a well-written article.
0:02:22 And I just wanted to mention that two of our staff members
0:02:26 were highlighted within the pages here.
0:02:30 Lori Race as our CFO for the city.
0:02:34 And I learned a lot from this article, actually,
0:02:37 because it says, even with the current city manager,
0:02:41 John Caten, there's, so I don't know what happened,
0:02:45 is John and, did we promote John Caten recently?
0:02:49 And, sorry Travis.
0:02:52 It looks like Mr. Caten has a budget message
0:02:55 to deliver later this evening.
0:02:56 We'll let him know when he comes in.
0:02:57 Yes he does, yes he does.
0:02:59 Well, well written, and congratulations, Lori.
0:03:02 Really highlighted you well in there, very deservingly.
0:03:06 There was another article in here as well
0:03:08 about the economic development downtown
0:03:12 and how the URA has played such an instrumental role,
0:03:16 and our own Melinda Anderson was highlighted in that as well.
0:03:20 But you didn't say that we had a new city manager in Europe.
0:03:22 Oh, OK.
0:03:24 Good move on your part.
0:03:27 Moving on to the agenda is the consent calendar.
0:03:31 I'll turn that over to council wishes.
0:03:35 Move approval.
0:03:37 Greg Lanning.
0:03:38 Second.
0:03:40 Approval was moved for the consent calendar
0:03:43 by Greg Lanning, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.
0:03:45 Anything further on that motion council?
0:03:48 Leila, roll call vote, please.
0:03:50 Seidouan-Hockens?
0:03:51 Yes.
0:03:52 Sean Bericher?
0:03:53 Yes.
0:03:54 Jim Monich?
0:03:55 Not here.
0:03:57 Greg Lanci?
0:03:58 Yes.
0:04:00 John Hall. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes six to zero. Next item on the agenda is items
0:04:11 under consideration and that's consideration of request to confirm the appointment of Ruth
0:04:16 Pierce and the reappointment of Debbie Latin to the historic preservation committee. Just
0:04:22 make a quick presentation regarding this to the council. We had a resignation, John Polly
0:04:28 actually, in the audience from the historic preservation, John's commitments didn't
0:04:34 allow him to continue his service. He had great attendance and great
0:04:39 participation and will absolutely miss John, but we had an opening that we needed
0:04:46 to fill. So we advertised the city staff advertised for the position and we did
0:04:53 an interview process, just this last week where we interviewed four individuals, all well qualified, wonderful individuals.
0:05:02 I actually asked our vice mayor, Suzanne Hawkins, to assist in that because last minute we found out that Jim Mundt,
0:05:10 who was the liaison to that committee, had a conflict and wasn't able to be part of that committee.
0:05:17 So, after the interview process, and again it was a difficult choice, we came down to making
0:05:27 the recommendation from the committee to the council, through the mayor here, that we would
0:05:33 appoint Ruth Pierce as a commission member on our historic preservation commission, and we
0:05:41 We would like to reappoint Debbie Latin, who has just finished a term that she started,
0:05:49 or finished for someone else, so she actually has two terms that she could commit to.
0:05:54 She's very interested in staying on the commission, and has had great attendance and
0:05:58 participation as well, so I'll turn that over to council for their wishes.
0:06:03 Greg Lenny, Suzanne Hawkins.
0:06:06 Before I go ahead and make a motion if that's okay, I'd just like to say sitting in on the
0:06:11 interviews it was very interesting listening to all the perspectives and with Ruth's business
0:06:16 being in the downtown area and her knowledge.
0:06:19 Hello.
0:06:20 Please hold for the first available representative.
0:06:23 It's important that we speak with you.
0:06:25 We'll be with you shortly.
0:06:27 Thank you.
0:06:28 That's interesting.
0:06:29 Okay.
0:06:30 Before you go on I just wanted to mention our new city manager John Cateon just walked
0:06:35 in the door.
0:06:36 Okay.
0:06:37 Anyway, with Ruth's business experience and all of her years being involved in Twin Falls
0:06:49 and downtown and many committees and different activities around the valley, we felt that she
0:06:54 was a great fit for this committee.
0:06:56 She's going to bring a lot of knowledge and she's ready to do her homework and study
0:07:00 and learn and so I feel very confident with the interviews and the candidates we had and
0:07:05 the decision we made.
0:07:06 And with that, I would like to make the motion that we appoint Ruth Pierce to serve on the historic preservation committee.
0:07:12 And reappoint Debbie Latin for another term.
0:07:15 Greg Lenny.
0:07:20 Of course.
0:07:21 No.
0:07:22 Oh, yeah.
0:07:23 Yeah, she must be.
0:07:26 That just hit me.
0:07:27 I think she is fulfilling a term.
0:07:30 Yeah, John Paul's term.
0:07:32 Yeah, good point.
0:07:33 Thank you.
0:07:34 Greg, were you?
0:07:35 I was just a second, but I wanted to make sure that was part of the problem.
0:07:39 Very good.
0:07:40 with that motion maker.
0:07:42 Chris, talk?
0:07:42 Well, I certainly support Ruth because of what Suzanne indicated,
0:07:46 and she's a boots on the grounds
0:07:48 of the Personal Health History Commission.
0:07:51 I know three of the four applicants,
0:07:53 and all three are highly qualified.
0:07:55 I hope if they're listening or in attendance,
0:07:57 that they will stay as volunteers for a city committee
0:08:03 like this.
0:08:03 And I also hope that should there be future vacancies,
0:08:07 So these three would be the first logical choice
0:08:10 for any fulfilled, unfulfilled turns.
0:08:14 Thank you, Chris.
0:08:16 Anything further on the motion, Council?
0:08:19 Leila, roll call vote.
0:08:21 Sean Bericher?
0:08:21 Yes.
0:08:22 Greg Lanting?
0:08:23 Yes.
0:08:23 Don Hall?
0:08:24 Yes.
0:08:25 Chris Tockensky?
0:08:25 Yes.
0:08:26 Rebecca Melsweka?
0:08:27 Yes.
0:08:28 Suzanne Hopkins?
0:08:29 Yes.
0:08:30 Motion passes 60-0.
0:08:31 Now is the time, Ruth, would you mind coming forward
0:08:34 and just introducing yourself and any comments
0:08:37 that you'd like to make?
0:08:38 I do want to mention also we have Randall Watson, our chairperson of the historic preservation
0:08:43 committee in the audience, and he was a participant in these interviews as well.
0:08:49 So I'm Ruth Pierce, and I have lived in Twinge, or Magic Valley since 1978, been down town since
0:08:56 1978.
0:08:57 I am thrilled.
0:08:58 I am very excited.
0:08:59 I just finished a two-year stand as the president of Sedu, and I really would like to stay involved,
0:09:07 So I am really thrilled.
0:09:10 Thank you, Ruth.
0:09:11 Thank you, guys.
0:09:12 Nice things.
0:09:14 We appreciate your service.
0:09:15 Thank you very much.
0:09:18 I did want to mention, too, that during the interview process,
0:09:20 one of the gentlemen's that applied
0:09:23 is actually on the county's historic preservation committee.
0:09:26 And I found out some interesting things.
0:09:28 First of all, we came to the conclusion
0:09:30 that we need to get our commissions together
0:09:33 and start discussing what both commissions are doing,
0:09:36 because it really is in the Magic Valley,
0:09:39 Twin Falls County, Twin Falls City.
0:09:41 And I found it very, very interesting
0:09:42 when we were talking to this individual
0:09:44 of how much the Historic Preservation Committee,
0:09:47 I think they call it something different at County,
0:09:48 but Committee from the County has done so much work down
0:09:54 at Auger Falls with some signage and the like dentist.
0:09:56 Do you, can you maybe address that and how we can tie in?
0:10:01 Yeah, I've been working with the Twin Falls Historic
0:10:03 Preservation, Twin Falls County.
0:10:06 County, County, County Historic, working a lot of with Shawna Robinson, quite a bit, you know, about
0:10:12 we, hopefully in next year's budget we have money to do science. We want to do a lot of interpretive
0:10:16 science. Talk about the year he hopes that I talked about maybe the Bonneville flood. So I've
0:10:20 been working with them on science already planning that hopefully we'll have budgets past and then
0:10:25 we can start actually implementing install on some of those science late this fall. So I have been
0:10:30 working with them quite a bit on the whole because I thought there's the efforts on the history of the
0:10:35 area. I'm not. So I've been working with mostly Sean and some other groups of the historic
0:10:40 County historic preservation. It's city owned property, but it's actually in the county. So
0:10:46 that's where the tie in from the county district. And you know, and Sean, you remember quite
0:10:50 a bit when we have to refer spot auger falls. We have some I think some grants of our remember
0:10:55 they did some some studies that down there archaeological. So I just tapped into that
0:11:03 that wealth of knowledge.
0:11:04 Perfect.
0:11:05 Perfect.
0:11:06 Thank you, Dennis.
0:11:07 But again, I think this might be an opportunity for us to maybe work a little closer.
0:11:11 I'm going to definitely go out and talk to the county commissioners here soon and talk
0:11:16 to them about how we can tie in.
0:11:18 Next item on the agenda is consideration of request to accept the transfer of Twin Falls
0:11:23 Urban Renewal Agency-owned property located at 122-4th Avenue, South in parentheses, Dennis
0:11:30 Boyer Park to the City of Twin Falls and authorized the mayor to sign the company
0:11:36 maintenance agreement. Melinda Anderson welcome Melinda. Thank you Mayor. Good
0:11:42 evening Council. If we could put this photo up. Thank you. I'm here representing the
0:11:56 Twin Falls River Renewal Agency Board in this presentation and request to the
0:12:01 council. Excuse my voice. I had dental work done earlier today and I'm still
0:12:08 numb on one side of my face. So if I'm not making sense, please ask me to repeat
0:12:14 myself. So this is a culmination of a lot of work, as you all recall, on this piece
0:12:24 of property. This used to be what we called the hot sea building, where the hot
0:12:28 building was located probably in almost the middle of the U by 4th Avenue. So you'll see
0:12:34 the new Glamia building and the Glamia R&D Center CIC. And then the street is 4th Avenue
0:12:39 South and the park is directly across 4th Avenue from Glamia property. The Urban Renewal
0:12:50 Agency Board has been here in the past, in fact, both in September 23rd of last year and November
0:12:57 18 last year the board I think through Cindy Bond who was chair at the time came and requested
0:13:02 that the council accept this property once the park was completed into the park system
0:13:10 and at that point the council voted yes to approve and concept both times.
0:13:15 So this is as I mentioned the culmination of this long process.
0:13:19 The park was actually completed in early May of this year.
0:13:25 At the June 9th urban renewal board meeting, the board approved transferring the park to
0:13:32 the city and signed resolution 2014-1 to that effect, so the agency board has done their
0:13:40 part and now the board is asking the council to accept this park and to the city's park system
0:13:49 along with authorizing the mayor to sign a maintenance agreement and that has been part
0:13:53 of the discussion all along, but there would be a maintenance agreement between the Urban
0:13:58 Renewal Agency and the City Council.
0:14:00 So as you can see from your packet, the agency has been taking care of the park since it was
0:14:09 completed.
0:14:10 There are going to be obviously maintenance, certainly regular park maintenance along with
0:14:17 any repairs that might be needed and then also paying for power and water.
0:14:21 the agency transfers that to the city, the city would take on the responsibility, but the
0:14:27 urban renewal agency will continue to pay for all repairs, all maintenance, the power that's
0:14:33 consumed as well as the water that's used. Through December 31st of 2022, which is when
0:14:40 revenue allocation area 4-1, where this park is located, expires, and then all of the, at
0:14:50 At that point, there were no agencies, ceases to get any funds from the county for tax increment finance.
0:15:00 And so that is why the agency is asking the city council to accept this.
0:15:07 One more issue on the agreement, number five, the city agrees to contract routine landscaping and maintenance of the park through a contract substantially in the form attached.
0:15:17 which is that's the cover page and this is something that the City Parks and Rec Department
0:15:25 has developed for other properties in its portfolio.
0:15:31 So that's my request tonight is to represent the Urban and Eel Agency asking the city to
0:15:37 accept the park and to your park system and authorize the mayor to sign that maintenance
0:15:43 agreement.
0:15:45 Thank you.
0:15:46 Melinda, Chris, talkie to me.
0:15:48 Now Linda or Dennis, this certainly has no bearing on my support for making this proposal
0:15:57 and the fact that I have a concern about the lighting of the park.
0:16:02 In our recent customer survey that we'll be talking about later, there's a feeling of
0:16:09 a relative marginal safeness in the downtown area during certain times of the day and or
0:16:16 night.
0:16:17 And I was wondering in the construction of this park, did we use specific lighting standards
0:16:23 that are by virtue of witnessing it makes us a safe place in the dark?
0:16:32 I've been buying there several times and it looks damn spooky to me.
0:16:35 Oh, okay. I haven't actually seen it at night, so I don't have any personal experience of it.
0:16:41 We did put lighting, I believe, three separate light poles in the park itself
0:16:46 to ensure that there is lighting and so that it's not just a dark place at night.
0:16:53 I don't think three lights are enough, but that's all we have. That was my impression from
0:16:59 even four. I don't know about the candle wattage, candle light standards or whatever, but
0:17:08 before we get this fully integrated, I want to make sure we have a safe park and what has
0:17:13 is deemed to be a March my safe area. Nobody's been in the pointer. No, Bob, my
0:17:22 please get us that's right next to the there it is. Because I know in the whole
0:17:31 design of the park, you know, we talked about lighting safety at the park. So these
0:17:35 are the same type of decorative lights that we have along Social and Street or
0:17:38 in City Park. So, you know, we have one right here, one right here. I can't remember
0:17:45 if we had a third one off, but there is one in the sidewalk over over on this side
0:17:50 on 4th Avenue here. If you've been to City Park in the evening, these are the same type of lights you see at City Park and these, you know, be the same type of, you know, lighting as we have at City Park, but of course, this park does not have as many as we do have at City Park.
0:18:08 myself. I have not been down here in the evening so I couldn't tell you what it feels like.
0:18:12 I didn't encourage us to drive by in the evening and get our own impression because that park
0:18:17 is hidden back by buildings. It's not easily accessible by drive by police unless they turn
0:18:24 on the streets. And the last thing we want is to have it full of undesirable activity.
0:18:31 I do notice there is another street light right here. So there's kind of two lights on the north side
0:18:36 Well again it depends on what the wattage is and what the wattage per square foot of a
0:18:43 perc recommendation.
0:18:44 That's how I was trying to get.
0:18:45 I was assuming there was a standard that was used, but I like us just to check on that a
0:18:50 little bit further.
0:18:51 I think Greek lining liked it way in as well.
0:18:54 Yeah, I'm a little surprised by your comic crushes.
0:18:57 I've walked several times after dark.
0:19:00 Maybe you're going to go straight and be straight and walk through that park one night
0:19:06 I thought it was pretty well lit myself, but on foot now maybe in a car might not look quite the same
0:19:11 But on foot it seemed like it was good because we we actually walked around the whole thing as part of our
0:19:16 Loop on those city streets and with all the new glamby and everything else
0:19:19 I don't wear he is pretty well lit now, but but I certainly could take a look at it
0:19:23 I wasn't thinking that when I was there though
0:19:25 So I might want to take a look at it again as a with a different person. I'm sure it wasn't you
0:19:30 You know, maybe you speak about that crime prevention aspect of the park and how they
0:19:38 designed it with, you know, hiding places.
0:19:41 We looked at kind of an open area, so, you know, we have tried to work with a piece of
0:19:45 garment where we have developed parts, you know, they don't like a lot of burns, they
0:19:48 don't like a lot of shrubbery around areas where people could hide out.
0:19:51 So, you know, that's why this front area along Fourth Avenue is pretty well wide open.
0:19:57 Also, you know, the alley's back here. You get something a little bit of traffic in the alley not a whole lot
0:20:02 But you can see it's pretty well wide open. We do have some small shrub breeze around here
0:20:07 But we don't expect them to be very tall
0:20:09 So there's not going to be an area where you might say people could hang out and be out of out of view from anybody
0:20:16 That passed in by her the police department. Thank you, Dennis
0:20:20 Rebecca Mill second. Thank you mayor. I just have a comment and then a question. I
0:20:25 I really appreciate this park and I appreciate how it is diversifying our park system.
0:20:30 I think it's, you know, might be the first of its kind, we're just kind of a lunch, you
0:20:36 know, adult park.
0:20:37 And I hope that we can continue to put these throughout our city to kind of break up that,
0:20:41 you know, sea of developments and kind of provide a nice place for people to take a break.
0:20:46 And I also want to say thank you to the URA.
0:20:48 I noticed the first time I was down there was during Art and Soul.
0:20:51 And I noticed how you incorporated the council's input on making the landscape a little lower maintenance and a little more affordable to take care of.
0:21:00 So that leads to my question, do we know how much it would cost the city to internally take care of this park and do we have that number so we can compare it to any of the bids that come in and
0:21:12 make sure we're just choosing the most efficient way of maintaining the park?
0:21:17 I had someone in my staff kind of tried to figure that out how much I'm currently I didn't bring that paperwork
0:21:22 So I couldn't tell you sure but we it was close in the rain
0:21:26 I think five to six thousand dollars, and that's what we estimate up of maintaining it to contract it out
0:21:32 So I think our costs were similar
0:21:36 What we estimated of what it would cost us and also what we think it would
0:21:40 a contractor would be down
0:21:42 So I would say roughly around six thousand dollars
0:21:45 Okay, and I noticed that the contract, or the agreement says that we will contract the work out, so I just wanted to make sure that we had our options available if it ever becomes more expensive, that we have the freedom to take the less expensive option.
0:22:03 That's good enough, thank you.
0:22:05 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:22:07 Linda, this is for you, and I'm sure you answered this last year, but I don't remember,
0:22:12 so refresh me.
0:22:13 I hope I do remember.
0:22:16 What happens if that district sunsets early?
0:22:21 And so the URA is responsible until the district sunsets, which were estimating for a time period,
0:22:27 but if you sunset early, does that mean we take over those payments?
0:22:32 So theoretically, for maintenance, yes, the agency has a bond for 4-1 that won't be paid
0:22:40 off until the end of 2022.
0:22:43 So that's one of the primary reasons.
0:22:46 So you can't pay that bond off early?
0:22:49 It's not likely that the agency is going to do that.
0:22:53 But if you did?
0:22:54 I don't see the agency board doing it.
0:22:56 Okay, you know, maybe this agreement over the help that district didn't place longer.
0:23:03 Okay, thank you.
0:23:04 I think-
0:23:05 Travis, Master Williams.
0:23:06 So, a couple of things.
0:23:07 Number one, I think that should that occur, then it would be appropriate to probably do
0:23:11 an amendment to the agreement.
0:23:14 Or you could probably put in something at the end of paragraph three now that says, or upon
0:23:22 sunset, should it occur beforehand.
0:23:24 It's important to recognize that when the urban and rural agency closes, all of that taxable
0:23:29 value will be then returned to the proportionate property, local government units, and so that
0:23:36 those funds would then go into the system.
0:23:39 They'd go into the city's general fund and use to offset the cost of this.
0:23:50 I see no further lights.
0:23:51 Council wishes.
0:23:52 Greg Lanning.
0:23:53 Mayor Hall I'd like to move that we accept the transfer of the Twin Falls
0:23:59 Urban and Rural Area own property located at 122 4th Avenue South, aka Dennis Boyer
0:24:05 Park, to the City of Twin Falls and authorized the mayor to sign the
0:24:10 accompanying maintenance agreement. We have a motion on the floor by Greg
0:24:17 Lanning and seconded barely by Chris Stockington. Anything further on that
0:24:21 Motion Council.
0:24:24 Leila Rolkelbo, please.
0:24:27 Greg Lanting.
0:24:28 Yes.
0:24:29 John Hall.
0:24:30 Yes.
0:24:30 Chris Chalkington.
0:24:31 Yes.
0:24:32 Rebecca Milsuelica.
0:24:33 Yes.
0:24:35 Suzanne Hopkins.
0:24:36 Yes.
0:24:36 Sean Baraker.
0:24:37 Yes.
0:24:38 Motion passes 6 to 0.
0:24:40 Thank you, Melinda, for your presentation.
0:24:41 You're very welcome in the agency.
0:24:42 Thanks to Council for accepting it as well.
0:24:45 It is absolutely a beautiful park.
0:24:47 And it was needed down there.
0:24:50 I think I heard somebody in the community say,
0:24:52 Gone is the time where we threw a bunch of railroad ties down and grass seed for our
0:24:58 parks.
0:24:59 This is a sign of the future, I think, so good job.
0:25:03 Great lining.
0:25:04 My question, Melinda, would be, since we, you know, we accept you, the URA named the park
0:25:09 and we accepted a name park, our signage, what's the plan?
0:25:14 We will be working on signage.
0:25:15 We'd also like to have a ribbon cutting to actually initiate the park into it.
0:25:23 we'd like to do both of the same time. We're going to do a full life-size
0:25:26 bust in this or anything.
0:25:32 It's very tall. Thank you. Next time on the agenda is a presentation of the
0:25:42 City Pool Financial Report by the Aquatics Director of the YMCA John
0:25:47 Pauli. Welcome John. Thank you. Thank you Don. Well per agreement with the city every
0:25:54 year when it come in and do our annual report to you guys we did that with
0:25:59 Parks and Rec back in early June and now we're here to do it with you guys so I'll
0:26:03 just kind of get started and we'll go from there sorry guys yeah so I'm just
0:26:16 gonna go through each line item and then at the end we can we can discuss it if
0:26:21 that's okay with you guys absolutely so I'll start on the revenue side the
0:26:25 city of Twin Falls that's what you guys pay us to run the pool there's no you
0:26:29 surprises there. The reason it's a little lower is because Dennis deducts expenses for maintenance
0:26:35 types of repairs from that so it makes it easier to cut out a step and makes it a little
0:26:39 bit easier so that's why it's lower than the $120,000. Daily admissions, that's what we
0:26:44 earned through our daily admissions coming into the pool without a type of membership.
0:26:51 Pool rentals, those are our swim meets, parties, whatever types of events that are not a part
0:26:57 of our current program slate, sales are candies and drinks
0:27:02 and stuff like that.
0:27:03 Swim lessons is our revenue for all of our swim lessons
0:27:06 programs, excluding the Marlins.
0:27:07 That's not a part of us.
0:27:09 So they are more of a separate entity
0:27:11 that just basically goes off of membership.
0:27:14 So that would be in the membership category,
0:27:15 because basically they have memberships,
0:27:17 and we let them use the pool.
0:27:20 City Pool Revenue Other, that's really what that is,
0:27:23 is our lifeguard and our water safety instructor classes
0:27:25 that we taught last year, the revenue
0:27:27 we brought in from them.
0:27:28 It wasn't much, so that's why it was under other,
0:27:30 because there was no category allocated for it.
0:27:33 Membership City Pool, those are the membership revenue dollars
0:27:36 that were brought in from City Pool Members.
0:27:38 That's all the City Pool Members.
0:27:40 All that goes to this,
0:27:42 because that's the only facility they can use.
0:27:44 Memberships is the money we've allocated
0:27:46 for full YMC memberships.
0:27:48 This is when Greg Lanting was mayor.
0:27:50 We discussed this and came up with a format.
0:27:52 With $4 per member visit, we would allocate to that,
0:27:56 So we had a good way to, from year to year, compare.
0:28:01 So that's where that comes up from.
0:28:02 So basically last year we had, let me find it here,
0:28:09 16,099 member visits.
0:28:11 So we just took that times four
0:28:12 and that's how we got our $64,396.
0:28:16 And I'll go into that.
0:28:18 Reason why if you compare the year before with that,
0:28:21 we did go through a membership increase in that period.
0:28:24 And we do believe that's the reason
0:28:25 why that felt where it did.
0:28:28 And with the reason that the city pool members
0:28:30 going up where they did as well,
0:28:31 we feel that the city pool was a
0:28:34 amenity people still wanted.
0:28:36 And so I think a lot of them downgraded
0:28:40 from white memberships to city pool membership.
0:28:41 So that's why you saw the city pool memberships
0:28:43 go up through the roof.
0:28:44 And it always looks like it just
0:28:46 specifically flipped.
0:28:47 Yeah.
0:28:48 It was, I was really surprised to see that.
0:28:49 I was like, okay, well, cool.
0:28:52 I'll take a big flat.
0:28:54 So that works for me.
0:28:54 I don't care where it comes from as long as it's there, so.
0:28:57 And then that's for our income for last pool year,
0:29:01 was $470,850,72, which was about $18,000 more
0:29:06 than the year before, so we did pretty good
0:29:08 on the revenue side, we're doing better.
0:29:10 Where things got a little bit interesting
0:29:12 was our expense side, and I'll go into where things
0:29:15 kind of got a little bit different,
0:29:16 mostly through a lot of categories that aren't
0:29:19 in our control, accounting and legal,
0:29:21 pretty much the same as last year, bank charges.
0:29:24 That went down, well, that went down because we had fewer YMCA memberships, so fewer transactions,
0:29:29 fewer charges, made it even smaller.
0:29:32 The next pull report, I've pushed the I even going out further because we have a new bank,
0:29:35 a new deal in place so that should actually go down even further.
0:29:37 What that'll be, I don't know, but it should be even better for us as time goes on.
0:29:42 Repairs and maintenance, that's where funds that we've used of our own or whatever for
0:29:47 fixing pools, you know, pool equipment, little things, anything like that.
0:29:53 Food, that's the food we buy for,
0:29:55 the we'll take down and bubble put up.
0:29:58 Health insurance, that's our employees
0:30:01 that have health insurance that work at the city pool.
0:30:03 They didn't eat as much this year as they did last year?
0:30:05 We didn't do catering when we took it down that time.
0:30:10 We went back to catering, so that was the reason
0:30:12 why it was a little bit lower.
0:30:14 Pizza's a little bit cheaper than catering,
0:30:15 but we went back to catering
0:30:16 because catering goes over a little bit better.
0:30:18 Makes people a little bit nicer.
0:30:19 You'd rather have fried chicken and baked beans over pizza.
0:30:22 So it worked out pretty well.
0:30:25 Genitorial supplies, that's the supplies we use to clean the city pool.
0:30:29 Liability insurance, that did go up from the year before.
0:30:32 And that's just cost of doing business.
0:30:33 I mean, we've had some claims against us at the pool and other facilities.
0:30:37 So we did go up a little bit, which caused it to go up.
0:30:41 Slipping on the deck sometimes is one of those ones that can get you on that.
0:30:44 So it just happens with the cost of doing business, unfortunately.
0:30:49 Office expense is what we spend to use in our office.
0:30:53 Payment to our affiliate organization,
0:30:54 we didn't make any payments last year,
0:30:55 that's why that was zero,
0:30:56 so we are working on getting caught back up on that.
0:30:59 We had to, we were just a little bit behind on that,
0:31:02 our organization allows us to,
0:31:04 so I would imagine with our next report,
0:31:07 they're working on getting caught back up on that,
0:31:08 so you might see that being a little bit higher
0:31:10 than what it was last year because it was zero.
0:31:14 Professional salary, that includes mine,
0:31:16 and our former Aquatics Coordinator salary issue.
0:31:20 We no longer have that position,
0:31:21 she moved on to a different position,
0:31:23 So we've changed that to more of a office manager type of deal.
0:31:26 So we're still kind of a transition period,
0:31:28 but this period has that in there,
0:31:31 because she was still with us at that time.
0:31:33 Administrators with costs is that's our front desk wages.
0:31:35 That's pretty much the same.
0:31:37 The reason why that would be a little bit higher, 5,000.
0:31:39 We were decently busy in the summer,
0:31:41 and we usually try to have two people there during the busy
0:31:43 times, makes it a lot easier, better customer service.
0:31:48 Water instructor wages, those pretty much stay the same year
0:31:50 to year.
0:31:50 We don't make a lot of changes to our water fitness
0:31:53 and trucker slate because the classes are relatively successful.
0:31:56 So there's really no reason to mess with what already works.
0:31:58 So that stays about the same from year to year.
0:32:01 Clerical wages, oh, I apologize, administrative costs.
0:32:04 That's more of a, I can confuse those with our clerical wages.
0:32:10 If you go to our second page right here,
0:32:12 I'll put this on the screen for you.
0:32:19 Time, at that meeting, we allocated a certain percentage
0:32:22 for our administrative costs in our professional salaries.
0:32:25 Like, for example, for the professional salaries,
0:32:26 85% of mine, so you see that from year to year.
0:32:30 These both have the same percentages,
0:32:32 15% of the CEO, 33% for the bookkeeper,
0:32:35 membership coordinator, marketing director,
0:32:37 front desk supervisor, those are the percentages
0:32:39 we use to allocate how much of their time
0:32:41 was going towards the pool,
0:32:43 so because we have three different facilities,
0:32:45 three different breakdowns.
0:32:48 So that's what we did with that from year to year.
0:32:49 Both those years have that built into there,
0:32:52 so you're comparing apples to apples.
0:32:55 So, lifeguard wages is pretty self-explanatory,
0:33:04 what we paid our lifeguards.
0:33:05 The reason that was a little bit lower last year
0:33:07 is because when we brought on our aquatics coordinator,
0:33:09 she took on some lifeguard hours,
0:33:11 so that went into the professional salary part,
0:33:13 so that's why there's a $10,000 difference,
0:33:15 whereas when you look at the professional salaries,
0:33:20 that went up a little bit,
0:33:20 so that's where that disparity comes in at.
0:33:25 Some less than wages we went up by about $4,000,
0:33:27 well, because we did more in business,
0:33:29 We had to spend more on some less than instructors.
0:33:32 City pool other, we had no city pool other this year.
0:33:35 Payroll to expenses, payroll tax expenses, payroll taxes
0:33:38 on employment, that's what we paid our, the other expenditures
0:33:41 when it comes to having employees.
0:33:43 Pool chemicals went up by about $4,000.
0:33:45 That fluctuates year to year.
0:33:47 I've seen it down to 21 like it was the year before,
0:33:49 and it goes to 25.
0:33:50 And for all I know it could be back down to 21.
0:33:52 It's just depends on how much you use.
0:33:56 Program supplies, backboards, stuff like that,
0:34:00 toys for some lessons, all that type of stuff.
0:34:04 Advertising, that's our one-third breakdown
0:34:07 for how much we spend on our advertising retirement,
0:34:11 our employees that are eligible for retirement,
0:34:13 that's where that comes from,
0:34:14 that work for, with the city pool and, or,
0:34:19 sorry, that's what I meant.
0:34:20 Product supplies, that's the products we buy
0:34:23 to sell at the desk, uniforms,
0:34:25 where we spent on our lifeguard uniforms.
0:34:27 Utilities is the one that kicked us pretty bad last year.
0:34:31 Utilities went up, we've tripled and quite tripled check
0:34:34 that to make sure we were doing the right math.
0:34:36 And our gas bill just, an electric bill just went up
0:34:39 from year to year.
0:34:40 And it just kinda depends on what happens.
0:34:45 Colder times of the year or warmer times,
0:34:47 it's just hard to guess what it's gonna do from year to year
0:34:49 for all I know for next year it could be lower or higher.
0:34:52 But it did go up quite a bit from that year.
0:34:54 Our bookkeeper looked into that number quite a few times to make sure that was right.
0:34:58 That's from the city pool.
0:35:00 And workman's compensation is what we spent on workman's comp.
0:35:04 Not really need to, not really need to many if any workman's comp claims, but that's just
0:35:08 what we pay for that.
0:35:10 So we came up with net expenditures of $483,000 with quite a bit more from 443 the year before.
0:35:18 So we had a $20,000 change from about $85 to $12.3.
0:35:26 on the back and just one lesson that went up 4,000
0:35:30 because you're offering more swim,
0:35:33 swim lesson structure or has.
0:35:35 We, I would say it was more,
0:35:38 we had more participation.
0:35:39 We had more participation.
0:35:40 We offered more classes.
0:35:42 In that year, we introduced our lead swim lesson program
0:35:44 which now is actually our whole swim lesson program.
0:35:47 We offer basically one, right now we offer one to four.
0:35:50 We don't go above four kids per class
0:35:53 because it's a better learning environment, way better than one to six.
0:35:56 So.
0:35:57 But your revenue is up, so the expense is up.
0:36:00 Yeah, that caused it to go up.
0:36:02 I was happy to see that there wasn't tons more
0:36:05 some instructors than expenditures,
0:36:07 but it did go up with the revenue as well.
0:36:09 Well, my two-year-old granddaughter, thanks you.
0:36:11 Keep it up.
0:36:12 You're welcome.
0:36:13 Worth it right there.
0:36:16 That's my favorite program.
0:36:17 So you have the most fun with that.
0:36:20 Council have any other questions for John this evening?
0:36:22 Rebecca, no sir.
0:36:23 Thank you, Mayor.
0:36:24 Just a question about your professional salaries.
0:36:27 They went up about $18,000.
0:36:29 So is that a percentage raised that the Y gave
0:36:33 and what percentage is that?
0:36:34 Or did you add more staff?
0:36:37 What is the reason for that increase?
0:36:39 That's 85% of mine.
0:36:41 And our 100% of our then aquatics coordinator,
0:36:44 because that's all she did was work at the city pool.
0:36:46 She didn't work anywhere else within the Y organization.
0:36:50 OK, in the increase though, over last year?
0:36:52 Yeah, I'm sorry.
0:36:53 I actually see we're going.
0:36:55 She wasn't in it the year before.
0:36:56 There was no aquatics coordinator the year before.
0:36:58 So hence the.
0:36:59 OK, so you added.
0:37:00 Yeah, we added that to action.
0:37:02 And actually, since removed that position,
0:37:05 she moved on to a different position elsewhere.
0:37:07 So next year, that will be a decrease, probably.
0:37:10 A decrease?
0:37:11 Yeah.
0:37:12 Most likely, because we now have an office manager,
0:37:14 but she's working front desk hours whenever she's there.
0:37:18 So that'll probably go into our front desk department.
0:37:20 So you'll probably notice a decrease there
0:37:22 in the professional salaries, it'll probably just be mine.
0:37:26 Okay, and then in your utilities,
0:37:29 did you compare usage, are you using the same
0:37:31 or is it the utility rates?
0:37:33 I mean, we've seen at the city
0:37:34 that the utility rates have gone up,
0:37:36 but I don't think we've seen that same increase.
0:37:40 And maybe Travis, you can speak a little bit
0:37:42 to the increases that we've seen.
0:37:43 So I'm wondering about your usage, you know,
0:37:46 what's the comparison?
0:37:49 It, in certain times of the year,
0:37:52 it just gets colder out there. And when the bubble's not on, well, A, when the bubble is
0:37:57 on, you use a lot more gas when it gets cold. There was a part of the time there where even
0:38:01 for a couple of weeks, if it's 20 degrees colder than what it normally is, it takes that
0:38:05 much more to heat the bubble. So when you think about the utilities, you're thinking about just
0:38:09 heating the water, but you also have to heat the bubble nine months out of the year. So
0:38:13 when you're in those cold temperatures, because if I'm not mistaken, we really, the last couple
0:38:17 years we've had a few weeks of really cold weather that can really add up you
0:38:22 know a good example was at one point I saw it it was I think one time it was
0:38:26 around $13,000 for our utility bill for a winter month well in the summer it's
0:38:31 three so it's a big difference so that's really what it comes down to the weather
0:38:37 with the bubble because an extra 20 degrees lower makes that difference
0:38:41 bubbles all a two-door pressurize system can't just leave a door open I mean you
0:38:47 No, just the weather and beyond weather. It's the gas. It's really the gas more than electricity electricity stays pretty steady
0:38:53 From here to here, but it's the gas
0:38:55 So you didn't turn the pool up five more degrees because you were cold out there
0:39:00 No, the pool the pool in the winter feels great
0:39:02 I don't know if you ever been in the winter, but the pool feels almost I don't know
0:39:06 I think the pool feels better in the winter than it does in the summer
0:39:08 That's just my opinion because it's always the same temperature when the bubbles on
0:39:13 Travis did you want to weigh in I know that Rebecca maybe
0:39:16 You know, we can only speak to our experiences with natural gas.
0:39:21 We know that the power bills have typically gone up somewhere between, depending upon the
0:39:26 type and volume of use, but we've seen as high as 27% in the prior year.
0:39:31 Natural gas for us did not go up as dramatically.
0:39:35 We think that Lori and I were conferring.
0:39:37 We think natural gas rates generally went up somewhere between 7% to 9%.
0:39:43 It's about a 22% adjustment in utility costs associated with that.
0:39:49 So when you look at a combination of both power and natural gas that might be part of that explanation.
0:39:57 But we don't spend a lot of time looking at their utility bills.
0:40:01 We provide them that rate.
0:40:03 That rate was constructed based upon past utility bills and they're encouraged to use electricity effectively.
0:40:12 We do our best whenever there's a sun outside in the winter and there's no clouds, the light's
0:40:16 on and the bubble are off when five o'clock comes around and starts, the light's go back
0:40:21 on because it starts to lose some visibility in there.
0:40:25 But with the gas, the really the only way we can conserve on the gas is we keep the air
0:40:29 temperature at a comfortable temperature, we don't want it to get too cold, and we put
0:40:33 the tarps on at night and that's really the best we can do with the gas.
0:40:37 So we do our best to conserve, and when the staff forgets to turn off the lights or something
0:40:42 like that, then well, they hear about it, so.
0:40:45 Chris Toggian.
0:40:46 Well, I know there's no approval process on this presentation, but I'd like to certainly
0:40:52 endorse your management over this past year, John.
0:40:54 Well, I've not heard anything except compliments.
0:40:57 All the bills are being paid on time.
0:41:00 That seems the allocation for your expenses and for the pool split out seems to be making
0:41:06 the sands and so it should be pretty smooth sailing stone.
0:41:10 Very good, John.
0:41:11 Thank you.
0:41:12 And the only thing I would like to add is we're looking into some fee increases for October.
0:41:19 And we've already gone through the Parks and Rec Commission where we got a unanimous approval.
0:41:23 And I would like to request that the Council set a date for a public hearing on those proposed
0:41:27 increases.
0:41:28 I'm going to turn it over to Travis.
0:41:29 Did you want to weigh in on that?
0:41:32 Yeah, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council.
0:41:34 So what's important about those fee increases that are being proposed by the why they are
0:41:37 talking about the daily admission fees, that the why is looking, my understanding part of
0:41:43 their presentation was associated with additional lifeguards and the costs of lifeguards.
0:41:50 Because this is a fee that does not go through the city books and it's a fee that is not required
0:41:56 as part of our budgeting process, this does not need to be done by the August 4th deadline.
0:42:02 has not been set as a part of that hearing. We wanted to see if the council was in favor
0:42:09 of moving forward with the public hearing before we schedule that. If the council is in
0:42:13 favor of that, then we will go forward. We will schedule that for that public hearing.
0:42:17 Because the rates are greater than 5%, it will take about two weeks. And so we're thinking
0:42:20 the soonest that that could be on to the agenda would be about the 11th of August.
0:42:28 to cancel wishes regarding public hearing.
0:42:34 Greg Lanning.
0:42:36 Bear Hall, I move the lead and establish the public hearing
0:42:39 to consider an increase in public pool rates for August 11.
0:42:48 I'll hold the second then.
0:42:49 We have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanning.
0:42:52 Bless you.
0:42:52 Seconded by Sean Berger, who said a public hearing date of obviously 11
0:42:57 regarding the pool rate increases.
0:43:00 And the lights came on after that.
0:43:02 and Hawkins.
0:43:03 Thank you.
0:43:04 What night are we adopting our budget?
0:43:09 It would be no sooner than the 18th.
0:43:11 Okay.
0:43:12 Greg, I'm going to not vote in favor of your motion just because I think we should wait
0:43:17 until after our budget sets so we don't confuse the public on which numbers we're talking
0:43:22 out at what time and I'm in favor of having a public hearing but I would rather wait
0:43:26 until our budget set personally.
0:43:28 So, I'd certainly, if my second is really, I'd be willing to go afterwards.
0:43:34 Well, before we go on with the underlying lights, what's a good time afterwards in September?
0:43:38 Sometimes.
0:43:39 You can say September 2nd. That is a safe date.
0:43:41 Greg, would you like to change your motion to September 2nd?
0:43:44 September 2nd sounds good.
0:43:46 Sean? Yes.
0:43:48 The motion was made to change it to September 2nd by the motion maker, Greg Lanning, and seconded by Sean Berger, the second.
0:43:57 So I had the opportunity to listen to this presentation at the Parks and Rec Commission
0:44:04 meeting earlier and I do think that John and the team over at the YA have done an admirable
0:44:12 job of trying to manage the pool and the expenses and the revenue and some of it is truly just
0:44:18 out of your control.
0:44:19 I do think that the discussion of some of the changes they'd like to make related to life
0:44:25 And some of the safety issues over there is worthy of having a hearing.
0:44:29 And so I would encourage us to have that and certainly encourage the citizens to participate.
0:44:37 And if it's easier to do that outside of the rest of everything that's going on, I'm supportive of that.
0:44:42 But I do think it's worthy of the discussion.
0:44:44 Thank you, Sean.
0:44:45 Rebecca Milsock.
0:44:46 Thank you, Mayor.
0:44:47 Thank you for your presentation, John.
0:44:49 I think we definitely need more information during that public hearing.
0:44:53 I'd like to look at the utilities a little bit more and look at the usage.
0:44:59 I'd also maybe like to talk more about what percentage of the salaries we include.
0:45:08 We have the membership coordinator that we take a third of the costs and then a front desk supervisor.
0:45:16 Is that membership coordinator the marketing director?
0:45:19 How much time do they actually spend at the pool or with pool matters?
0:45:26 You know, I'd like to keep the cost down at the pool.
0:45:30 I think that's a reason why we subsidize it.
0:45:32 You know, we're paying 120 taxpayers.
0:45:35 We're paying $120,000 a year to support the pool.
0:45:38 And so if we can, I'd like to look at maybe some reductions, you know,
0:45:44 where we can instead of raising that.
0:45:46 in that because, you know, for some families, they have two to three kids, I mean, that gets
0:45:50 really expensive.
0:45:51 So that's kind of my input, but, you know, I'm willing to take a look at the numbers
0:45:56 and see what you need to keep going.
0:46:01 Because I, you know, like the rest of the council, I only hear positive feedback and my
0:46:05 experience at the pool has been very positive and so you guys are doing a great job.
0:46:11 I would just like to see us try to keep those daily admission fees low.
0:46:15 Rebecca, could you clarify on the utilities?
0:46:18 So John can go back and get that information for you.
0:46:21 What exactly are you looking for in that realm?
0:46:23 Sure, maybe just kilowatt usage.
0:46:25 We use such a one-year advantage.
0:46:26 Yeah, in comparison, we had to see how much is usage,
0:46:29 and how much is a rate increase from the utility company,
0:46:33 just for my personal information.
0:46:34 Absolutely.
0:46:34 I think that's valid.
0:46:35 I just want to make sure that John had some direction
0:46:37 when he goes back for your public hearing,
0:46:40 if this is approved this evening.
0:46:43 Anything further from council on this motion?
0:46:46 The island, roll call please.
0:46:48 Don Hall.
0:46:49 Yes.
0:46:50 Chris Talkington.
0:46:51 This is on the date.
0:46:53 September 2nd, yes.
0:46:54 Public hearing.
0:46:55 Yes.
0:46:56 Rebecca?
0:46:57 Yes.
0:46:58 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:46:59 Yes.
0:47:00 Sean Baraker.
0:47:01 Yes.
0:47:02 Greg Lanti.
0:47:02 Yes.
0:47:05 Motion passes 6 to 0.
0:47:07 John, thank you for your presentation tonight.
0:47:09 Do you think you have enough information
0:47:11 to bring back to us from what you heard from council
0:47:14 this evening?
0:47:15 what it sounds like some utilities information and the percentages on the
0:47:19 different different types of positions that we put in there so maybe maybe more
0:47:25 of a drill down on that so that we could understand that better sure no problem
0:47:30 excellent thank you sir thank you for coming this evening next item on the
0:47:34 agenda is consideration of a request to adopt an ordinance for a zoning title
0:47:38 amendment to amend Title 10, Chapter 4, Section 23.3, Residential Business District, Property
0:47:47 Development Standards. We have Renee Caraway. Welcome Renee.
0:47:53 Good evening Mayor and Council. On June 10th, the Commission held a public hearing for a
0:48:06 a zoning title amendment to amend development standards
0:48:09 of Title 10, Chapter 4, Section 23,
0:48:12 which is the residential business district
0:48:15 to property development standards.
0:48:17 There was no one that spoke at the public hearing,
0:48:20 and upon conclusion of that hearing,
0:48:22 the Commission unanimously recommended approval
0:48:24 of the amendment as presented.
0:48:26 On July 7th of this year, the U, the city council,
0:48:30 held a public hearing on this request,
0:48:31 whereby by a vote of six, four, and zero against,
0:48:36 You granted approval of the request as presented,
0:48:39 including an amendment to Section E,
0:48:41 which was the off-street parking,
0:48:43 that states that parking requirements
0:48:45 may be modified by the Planning and Zoning Commission
0:48:48 after a public hearing is held,
0:48:50 if it can be shown that strict compliance
0:48:52 with these development standards is not possible.
0:48:55 As directed by the council staff
0:48:57 has prepared an ordinance for your consideration
0:48:59 this evening, that is in your packet,
0:49:02 for your review and staff would recommend that you approve it.
0:49:06 the other do we have an ordinance number 3073 I'm sorry 3073 3073 thank you
0:49:13 council have questions Chris talking replacing organs 37 3 on 3rd and final
0:49:21 by title on my under suspension of rules motion on floor by Chris talking a
0:49:26 seconded by Greg Lanting to place ordinance 30 73 on third and final
0:49:32 all suspending the rules by title only.
0:49:35 Anything further on that motion, council?
0:49:39 Leila, roll call vote, please.
0:49:41 Chris talking, 10?
0:49:42 Yes.
0:49:43 Rebecca Milsoica?
0:49:44 Yes.
0:49:45 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:49:46 Yes.
0:49:46 Sean Berriger?
0:49:47 Yes.
0:49:48 Greg Lantine?
0:49:49 Yes.
0:49:50 Don Hall?
0:49:51 Yes.
0:49:51 Motion passes six to zero.
0:49:53 Could you read the ordinance?
0:49:54 In the ordinance of the city council of the city of Twin Falls,
0:49:58 Idaho, amending the property development standards
0:50:01 the RV residential business. So, Council wishes.
0:50:07 approval of ordinance 3073. Second have motion on the floor to
0:50:13 approve ordinance 3073 by Greg landing. Well, seconded by
0:50:16 Sean Berrigger. Don, he or Don, would you just make for
0:50:20 nobody in the audience wants to speak to this?
0:50:24 Certainly. Before we go on with the motion, is there anyone in
0:50:31 in the audience that would like to speak on this ordinance.
0:50:34 Thank you.
0:50:35 Okay.
0:50:38 Anything further from council?
0:50:40 The Allen Roll call vote on the ordinance please.
0:50:43 Rebecca Milsoyka.
0:50:44 Yes.
0:50:45 Suzanne Hopkins.
0:50:46 Yes.
0:50:47 Sean Berriger.
0:50:48 Yes.
0:50:49 Greg Lanting.
0:50:49 Yes.
0:50:50 Don Hall.
0:50:51 Yes.
0:50:52 Mr. Tocqueville.
0:50:53 Yes.
0:50:54 Motion passes six to zero.
0:50:57 Thank you Renee.
0:50:58 Next item on the agenda.
0:51:00 I'm gonna pass somebody else to come up here,
0:51:01 just throw you off again.
0:51:03 presentation of the results of the 2014 Citizen Survey presentation by
0:51:09 just Palmer opening by Travis Rothweiler. Thank you sir. So I thought I'd try to
0:51:14 find the new role since Mr. Kate and has been officially named by Idaho
0:51:20 magazine as Magic Valley Life magazine. So I will be talking with him about my
0:51:27 future opportunity after the meeting tonight. There are lemots on the earth.
0:51:32 more very limited. So what I want to do is really might be begin by setting the stage
0:51:46 and talking about the value of the citizen survey as we continue to move forward. So the
0:51:52 results are in and really I think when you take a look at them in their totality, there
0:51:58 are things that we did well and I think that there are some areas that we could grow and
0:52:04 to improve. And the value of that survey is just that. Without that knowledge, we don't
0:52:09 have that ability to have a better understanding of the sentiments of our citizens at a particular
0:52:16 period of time. And so what we're doing with the citizen survey is sharing those results
0:52:23 publicly with the council tonight. They're going to be placed on our website. Individuals
0:52:27 will have the opportunity to really review those and then our intent is to really dive
0:52:32 deep into those beginning in late September, early October, as we use that through a series
0:52:39 to focus conversations to help update our strategic plan that we have. Because what goes
0:52:46 into our strategic plan is part of that resource.
0:52:50 This is the third citizen survey that we've done. The first was done in 2009, the last was
0:52:56 done in 2012. And really, again, it provides sentiments at a very period of time. The value
0:53:04 of the survey is it helps us identify the questions that we need to ask in areas that we
0:53:09 need to focus. Unfortunately, the survey doesn't necessarily provide answers. And through that
0:53:17 process and through those community conversations, we hope to begin to answer those questions.
0:53:23 And then we also hope to use them to really initiate a good quality dialogue to help ensure
0:53:29 that we are meeting and honoring the expectations.
0:53:35 Josh is going to spend some time talking about an overview of that survey and then he's going
0:53:42 to be joined by both Dennis and Mandy to kind of share some of those things that we've done
0:53:48 almost while the survey was taking place.
0:53:51 I'm going to share some of my thoughts and perspectives as well.
0:53:55 But I think it's important that as you're going through this, it's important that we
0:53:58 remember that I think the first rating is rating ourselves to ourselves, seeing if we
0:54:04 are growing year over year and making sure that we continue to do that.
0:54:10 And in those areas where we have slipped, it is important for us to begin to ask those
0:54:14 questions as to why.
0:54:16 Next is to compare ourselves to others.
0:54:19 And we do that only in an effort to say, well, how does that compare?
0:54:24 It really is probably, in my opinion, the least of all of the indicators, because at the end
0:54:31 of the day, we want to reach excellence for our community, and less concerned about how
0:54:35 others are delivering their service.
0:54:38 So with that, I'm going to turn it over to Josh, and he's going to provide an overview
0:54:41 of the highlights, and we'll go forward from there.
0:54:46 Josh Palmer, welcome.
0:54:52 hall members of the council. It's interesting because I can talk to you individually and
0:54:56 I'm comfortable with that when you're collective, it's intimidating.
0:55:00 All right, so I think Travis did a pretty good summary of how we intend to use the Citizen
0:55:12 Survey. One of the J's, our Journalism School 101 lessons we always have is just as important
0:55:19 as releasing accurate information. You always want to explain how you obtain that information,
0:55:23 I want to spend some time with that.
0:55:25 I think Travis covered a lot of this,
0:55:27 but the National Citizen Survey identifies weaknesses
0:55:30 and strengths not only within your organization,
0:55:32 but also within the city.
0:55:34 And it provides several benchmark comparisons.
0:55:37 I was Travis stated, we can compare ourselves
0:55:39 to prior years, we can compare ourselves to up to,
0:55:43 I think it's about 500 communities across the US.
0:55:46 And most of our comparisons to benchmark communities
0:55:49 are to about 200 communities in the western United States
0:55:52 with the exclusion of, I believe, California and Oregon.
0:55:56 This gives us more of an apples-to-apples comparison.
0:56:00 The survey that we had, excuse me,
0:56:03 that was sent out earlier this year,
0:56:06 we sent it out to 1,200 households
0:56:08 that was weighted, so it was connected to the US Census
0:56:12 so that we were able to identify the various demographics
0:56:15 in our community, based on, it could be anything
0:56:18 from, say, education level to age, things like that.
0:56:21 We wanted to get – the National Citizen Survey wants to get an accurate gathering of
0:56:29 a feedback from basically all walks of life.
0:56:34 We did have some questions and concerns with citizens about why they couldn't request
0:56:37 to take the Citizen Survey, and it's directed to that, it's weighted.
0:56:41 But I would encourage those people who want to give us feedback or communicate with us
0:56:46 to do so and they can contact us and they can always go to www.tfid.org. We can talk to
0:56:52 them more about the survey and we can get some feedback from them. We had 373 respondents
0:56:59 which is a little bit lower than what we had in prior years. One of the largest reasons
0:57:04 because we received the surveys that are rejected or sent back were able to identify a lot of
0:57:12 those homes, that wasn't the current addressee or the home was vacant. I think I kind of covered
0:57:22 this but we'll talk a little bit about the comparisons. One of the other things I should
0:57:27 probably point out is as we go through later in this presentation the strengths and weaknesses,
0:57:32 there'll be a lot of caveats. I might say this is strength but it's a weakness in another
0:57:36 area and I'll explain more about that later. So the National Citizen Survey has an overarching
0:57:44 benchmark which is the quality of life. All 123 categories and features that the
0:57:48 respondents are asked to to vote on or rate all feed into this this quality of
0:57:54 life. You know how you perceive your community how you feel about the services
0:57:58 in your of your city government. So our quality of life hopefully this isn't
0:58:05 surprising to people but this is how our citizens rated our quality of life. We
0:58:10 We did pretty good.
0:58:11 We are similar to other communities.
0:58:15 I think in discussions with NCS, we were about 3 percentage points higher than the average.
0:58:23 They don't really include that because there's a 5 percentage point plus minus difference on
0:58:26 that.
0:58:28 So, one of the things I do want to point out is some of the numbers that they do have,
0:58:33 they include fair, excellent, good as one of those positively rated categories.
0:58:40 We have been committed to being a high-performance organization.
0:58:43 Fair under their questions means we're meeting with their minimum.
0:58:49 We've committed ourselves to going beyond that.
0:58:52 So I really want us to focus on the collection of excellent and good.
0:58:56 That's what we want to be.
0:58:58 Also in discussions with NCS, fair is actually a pretty malleable category because these
0:59:03 are citizens who are not exactly disappointed with their city government or their community,
0:59:07 but they recognize that there's improvements
0:59:10 that they would like to see,
0:59:12 but they possibly are seeing the government do it.
0:59:14 So we can, with that fair category,
0:59:18 that's when we can work with more easily.
0:59:23 So what are our strengths?
0:59:25 It's always good to celebrate our strengths.
0:59:29 As I say, as you go on with this,
0:59:30 there's gonna be questions that I'm sure you'll have,
0:59:32 but safety, 88% of our respondents said they feel
0:59:37 the safety in their neighborhood is excellent.
0:59:39 Good or excellent, we'll say.
0:59:40 84% ulcerated the safety of the places they shop and do business.
0:59:44 I think Chris brought up,
0:59:48 Councilman Tockington brought up a good point though.
0:59:50 We have subcategories within this overarching safety category.
0:59:54 We have citizens who say with city government,
0:59:59 they rate preventive crime prevention,
1:00:02 among other things as being fairly low,
1:00:06 especially in comparisons to the other 200 cities
1:00:08 that we're being compared to.
1:00:10 However, breaking that down a little bit further,
1:00:13 we have seen improvements.
1:00:16 I should point out out of the 123 categories and features,
1:00:19 only 16 of them saw declines,
1:00:22 and we'll get a little bit more into that
1:00:24 because we believe that we have actually known about these
1:00:28 issues for a while and are addressing them.
1:00:30 Josh, could you state that again about the crime prevention
1:00:32 that needed to sink in?
1:00:34 So in the citizen survey,
1:00:36 apologies I have to keep this up here with me.
1:00:38 could not remember all the percentages and figures. Under safety, which is this overarching
1:00:45 category, we had police, fire, ambulance, crime prevention, fire prevention, animal control,
1:00:50 emergency preparedness. Police, satisfaction rating with police was 69%. It's actually not
1:00:58 bad, but it is lower than the benchmark communities. There's some areas in there that improved.
1:01:05 I think people must love firefighters because across the board, they do well in almost every
1:01:11 community.
1:01:14 But we did have some declines in the area of crime prevention as one of them.
1:01:18 So when every one of those subcategories, one of those subcategories decline, that's when
1:01:23 you fall from, say, excellent to good, and hopefully not so far as poor.
1:01:31 So we had some recently released data from the FBI as well as Idaho State, and we'll talk
1:01:39 a little bit more about that, but our citizens should feel safer, because although our city
1:01:44 population is doing this, I'm sorry the numbers are hard to read, the number of crime incidents
1:01:49 is doing that, it's declining. I wish the chief could be here to talk a little bit more about
1:01:56 it, but we do know it is a national trend in most cities. However, we're seeing that here
1:02:01 as well. Natural environment. Okay, so we're going to get a little bit more complex here.
1:02:11 So we have typically been rated fairly well in terms of natural environment.
1:02:17 Our citizens, they appreciate our natural heritage here.
1:02:22 They want to conserve it.
1:02:24 But we slipped.
1:02:25 And there were some subcategories in here where we slipped.
1:02:27 One of them being, say, recycling, satisfaction over our recycling services.
1:02:32 However, our natural environment compared to most communities is extremely strong.
1:02:41 I should probably point out on that one as well.
1:02:44 We'll go a little bit more into that,
1:02:45 but we have known about,
1:02:47 we had concerns about recycling participation,
1:02:50 starting about one or two years ago.
1:02:53 We started what was called sustained twin falls
1:02:56 where we worked with the College of Southern Idaho
1:02:58 Sustainability Council,
1:03:00 which is a group that was already formed here
1:03:02 and already encouraging and wanting to teach
1:03:04 and promote recycling, water conservation
1:03:06 and things like that in this community.
1:03:08 So under the Strategic Plan we created a group,
1:03:10 It's just a partnership that we have, where really they are the ground troops and they
1:03:14 lead the charge on a lot of it, but we have participation and we provide all resources
1:03:18 and support that we can to them to try and promote participation in the recycling.
1:03:23 And recycling did, it declined about almost 10 percentage points from 80 to about 70 percent
1:03:32 approval.
1:03:34 We are working with Sustain Twin Falls to better educate the community over our recycling
1:03:39 program and to really promote it. That group is really still in its infancy. I think we
1:03:44 just kicked off right as just before to call it a southern Idaho, it went to summer break
1:03:49 and all our students, our ground troops went off to other endeavors. We'll pick that up
1:03:54 in mid-August again. The economy is, so economy and safety were the two highest priorities
1:04:04 to our citizens or their respondents in this survey. Those are the two things that they
1:04:09 value the most among all those categories that we have in the survey.
1:04:13 The economy, although the percentages do look low in comparisons to other cities across the
1:04:19 West, we're actually pretty good.
1:04:22 But there's always that area of improvement that we could have had.
1:04:25 So, 56% of the respondents rated the overall economic health of our community as good or
1:04:30 excellent.
1:04:31 Believe it or not, in other communities we're actually doing pretty good compared to them
1:04:35 and it could be the effects of the recession, I'm not sure.
1:04:38 More importantly, 66% rate of Twin Falls is an excellent place to visit.
1:04:42 And that question was really phrased as would you recommend Twin Falls to a family, a friend,
1:04:47 or somebody to visit?
1:04:48 That's a great calling card for our community, a type of promotional for our community, but
1:04:53 also falls into that quality of life.
1:04:55 There are people that recognize that it's a good place to live and to visit.
1:05:00 However, where we saw the most damage to our overall economic health rating was in downtown.
1:05:09 Majority of the respondents rated the vibrancy of our downtown is being poor.
1:05:13 It's not where we want to have it, obviously.
1:05:16 This had a significant impact on that overall economic health.
1:05:20 I would, you know, I'd like to point out, though, especially for those that are watching
1:05:24 the live stream, is that we are working with one of our partners that Twin Falls Urban and
1:05:29 New El Agency is committed up to $17 million in infrastructure improvements.
1:05:35 What we hope that will do is really lay the roots in that downtown area for maybe more
1:05:39 more businesses and to make it more vibrant.
1:05:42 How did that compare to previous years?
1:05:45 It was a decline.
1:05:46 A decline?
1:05:48 Great landing.
1:05:48 That's a question.
1:05:49 Well, that was exactly my thought process of all the new
1:05:53 restaurants and all the new stores and the whole thing that's
1:05:56 going on downtown.
1:05:57 Business is going on downtown.
1:05:59 I was a little surprised by it, too.
1:06:01 But you know, like I said, there's caveats with all this.
1:06:05 I don't know.
1:06:07 This was sent out, well, beginning about October.
1:06:11 I don't know, there may have been circumstances at the time that it's a snapshot.
1:06:16 It might have influenced people's decisions, I'm not quite sure.
1:06:18 But I felt the same way.
1:06:20 Well, ironically, I had lunch down there today and it's packed, so.
1:06:26 Trans-referral.
1:06:29 I think the other way to look at it as it maybe doesn't meet the current expectations
1:06:34 of what our citizens believe downtown could be.
1:06:38 It's not that, so I think it's important to remember
1:06:41 that when we're looking at this,
1:06:42 it's not necessarily always a reflection
1:06:45 on where we've come from, but it is maybe a reflection
1:06:50 of what they desire the community to be.
1:06:53 And I think that the time in which the survey is issued
1:06:58 is pretty important.
1:06:59 I think that actually if we go back,
1:07:00 we started the conversation with the National Citizen Survey
1:07:04 in October, but I don't believe we released it until after the first of the year.
1:07:08 So if someone is walking downtown in February and it's chilly out,
1:07:14 maybe they don't see the vibrancy that they're going to see today.
1:07:17 So, because remember, that is a snapshot in time.
1:07:22 And what we try to do over a period of time is to build those connections.
1:07:28 So it's a couple of things.
1:07:29 It might be situational based upon time.
1:07:31 It may be that we're not meeting the expectations.
1:07:33 may be that when they walk and they see raised sidewalks or other types of things that they
1:07:41 don't find visually appealing or maybe there's some vacancies downtown that they wish were
1:07:48 filled, that all could go into a part of it.
1:07:51 Again, we don't know why.
1:07:54 We just know the what and the what helps us begin to ask a series of questions to determine
1:07:59 What could we be doing different to create that downtown to their citizens want us to see?
1:08:06 Yeah, I should probably underscore this with that percentage based off of the citizens perception of downtown.
1:08:13 So, for time, I wanted to clump a lot of these together, but I think it's also good that we recognize our partners in the community for
1:08:23 our the call to Southern Idaho, the Twin Falls School District and some of the others.
1:08:27 So 62% of our respondents rated our recreational and fitness opportunities to be good or excellent.
1:08:33 This really bridged both what we do here at the City of Twin Falls, let's say the Parks and Recreation Department, as well as what other organizations are doing.
1:08:40 This was really high, this was, you know, almost as good as firefighters approval rating.
1:08:46 So, and then 67% of respondents said that there were, they positively rated the education and enrichment opportunities.
1:08:55 going to revisit this one and then you're going to question why I put this light up.
1:08:59 But I want you to keep this in the back of your mind that our citizens or the respondents
1:09:04 to this survey say those opportunities are out there for them.
1:09:09 So what are weaknesses?
1:09:13 As Travis said, these are really starting points for discussions, a lot of these categories.
1:09:20 Traveling by bicycle, and this is where we bring in Dennis Boyer and Mandy.
1:09:26 I believe traveling by bicycle was our lowest rated category if I'm not mistaken.
1:09:33 I'm being corrected by Travis so I was probably not right.
1:09:41 Excuse me.
1:09:42 Public transportation which may be in the address with the lowest.
1:09:46 This was one of our lowest rated categories.
1:09:50 And so what we thought would be beneficial is if we bring in the two individuals that have
1:09:55 been really working on these issues to talk to you a little more and provide some updates
1:09:59 on what we're doing with that, so, called Dense Cut.
1:10:03 Can I support you?
1:10:05 Welcome, sir.
1:10:06 Thank you, Mayor and Council.
1:10:08 Yes, a lot of you, but you should remember in our budget,
1:10:10 we do have some money to work on some bicycle trails.
1:10:14 We'll give you a quick update on our two Canyon Rim paths.
1:10:18 You know, I'm working with the EHM engineers
1:10:19 on designing the pillar falls trail
1:10:22 and I call it the Kinegal section trail.
1:10:24 So hopefully those two will come back here next month,
1:10:27 sometime with a bid opportunity to get those two.
1:10:30 which part of it is traveling by bicycle on our,
1:10:32 some of our Kenyan trail like this picture right here
1:10:35 along the, looks like in front of elevation 486 over there.
1:10:39 Anyway, part of our Kenyan trail.
1:10:40 But also we have, I have to agree,
1:10:43 bicycle trails along the streets.
1:10:45 We are lacking, and that's probably where I think
1:10:47 probably the survey kind of beat us up on a little bit.
1:10:50 I have been working with our engineering department,
1:10:53 you know, back in October we had that public forum
1:10:55 where we had 75 people show up to talk about
1:10:58 by trails along the streets, you know, and we had seven or eight large maps and they wrote
1:11:04 where they want to have trails at.
1:11:05 So we really looked at, you know, where are they going, you know, to work maybe to school,
1:11:11 to downtown and other places.
1:11:14 So from those maps we have kind of compiled, you know, some people had a map, I mean, had
1:11:19 a trail like almost on every road, so that we know that's not going to happen anyway.
1:11:23 I've been working with Josh Baird in engineering and in fact today we just had a meeting with
1:11:28 Jackie talk about some of these pathways because I was trying to get something really simple
1:11:34 let's just put some you know striping on the road and have bike you know kind of friendly
1:11:38 routes but it's not that easy because there's some routes and some involves that we don't
1:11:43 want people to basically you know for example the Lake's Boulevard or myself a rail on Addison
1:11:50 Avenue and that's not always the best place to ride a bike and I have sections of that as an avenue.
1:11:54 So we are looking at where we can have maybe off, you know, bike paths similar to what we have on
1:12:02 Washington Street next to the college. Also we looked at how can we have some of our bike lanes
1:12:08 that we have on Falls Avenue that, oh, what was it, about 20, 15 to 20 years ago? We've got some
1:12:13 federal grants that put some bike lanes on some of our roads on the west part of town over there by
1:12:19 Ivy, Brian, Sparks and Blake Street,
1:12:22 go by Harry, Harry, Harry, Parr,
1:12:23 and then we have a bike lane in the South Park of town.
1:12:27 I go by Oregon Trail Elementary School,
1:12:30 Oregon Trail Youth Complex,
1:12:31 I'm a little bit on Washington Street South there,
1:12:33 but we're getting closer.
1:12:35 What we're trying to do is develop something that's workable.
1:12:39 And look, we have to put these in phases.
1:12:42 One is trying to get the map meet after the public in,
1:12:45 to see if this is something they're really agreeable with
1:12:49 And once you go forward with, then we have to look at it.
1:12:52 What can the city do internally?
1:12:55 A lot of it's going to need a lot of help
1:12:56 from the street department.
1:12:57 They're going to be putting some lines on there
1:13:00 and paying some of those bicycle Sheryls.
1:13:03 Is that what they're called?
1:13:05 Jackie, thank you.
1:13:07 Working with them and also doing some signage.
1:13:09 And also eventually while having to have some signs out
1:13:11 there where you'll have it on your bike
1:13:14 and have an estimated amount of time in mileage
1:13:17 of where you go into a certain area.
1:13:18 So if you're in the north side of town
1:13:21 and also you want to go to downtown,
1:13:22 you'll be able to see a sign.
1:13:23 Although it takes me approximately 15 minutes
1:13:25 to get to downtown.
1:13:26 So that's where we're looking at,
1:13:27 and even eventually maps that we want to go out
1:13:31 into the general public and out to our hotel.
1:13:33 So our visitors know where we have areas
1:13:36 where they can ride their bikes comfortably on the street.
1:13:39 So they're still working in progress, not as fast as we hope.
1:13:42 I hope it will.
1:13:43 But just having to thank really the engineering department
1:13:47 or kind of setting some time to work on this for us,
1:13:50 for our community.
1:13:51 So that kind of is a quick update anyway.
1:13:54 Any questions for Dennis?
1:13:56 Rebecca and I'll sort.
1:13:57 Thank you, Mayor.
1:13:58 Do you anticipate that that map and some of that work
1:14:02 might be completed by the end of this fiscal year?
1:14:05 Or what are you projecting?
1:14:07 That's what we're really good at.
1:14:08 Because we do have some funds budgeted for this.
1:14:11 So we want to be able to, you know,
1:14:13 maybe a whole five or no if we can get some striping
1:14:16 on the road yet, but hopefully maybe if Dean needs
1:14:19 another thousand gallons of paint for striping,
1:14:21 we can get that purchase.
1:14:23 And also, if we don't know yet internally,
1:14:26 we're gonna do some science,
1:14:27 because the street department can do some cited,
1:14:29 or we'll look at maybe contracting that out
1:14:31 about purchasing some science in advance.
1:14:33 So we definitely know we're on a tight line,
1:14:37 but we'd like to have some of it out by this fiscal year.
1:14:41 In the fiscal year.
1:14:42 Great, and then a question, I don't know if this came up.
1:14:44 I think it might have come up at our big public hearing or something.
1:14:48 But are we going to, there was a concept of painting the lines a certain color based on
1:14:55 where they lead the destination.
1:14:57 So if you see a green path, that leads to City Park or downtown or something like that.
1:15:03 Did that concept come through it all in your planning?
1:15:06 No, and I honestly don't remember that concept Rebecca, but right now we're looking at just
1:15:13 if we're going to do some painting on our streets
1:15:16 it's going to be white.
1:15:18 OK, I was just curious.
1:15:21 And then just another comment, our strategic plan
1:15:25 kind of encourages us to update our codes based on being
1:15:29 more bike friendly.
1:15:30 And so this is just a comment for the council and staff.
1:15:34 Maybe we can be thinking about how we can update our code
1:15:39 to reflect our philosophy on bike trails, whether
1:15:43 This is probably not going to be on arterials in those state highways, but on the new roads
1:15:48 that are being built that are collectors or neighborhood streets, what kind of philosophy
1:15:53 do we have and how can we make our code reflect whatever pass or space that needs to be created
1:16:04 in our new infrastructure.
1:16:06 Thank you.
1:16:08 Thank you.
1:16:09 I was just going to make a comment and maybe you've addressed it so shame on me if I didn't
1:16:13 hear you say it.
1:16:14 But I know that when we do put bike paths and we paint them, we put them in areas.
1:16:20 That leads to the next step but we've got to keep them clean too.
1:16:23 So there's more money to sweep those areas and keep them clean because out of some of
1:16:28 the bike paths that we do have, I've heard some complaints about rocks and nails and debris
1:16:34 in the bike path itself for the bikes.
1:16:37 I know that that's got to be concerned as well. It is, you know, we have what I love to do is is once we kind of get these
1:16:45 Everybody's agreeable about where we want to put these at it put in phases, you know, work with Dean
1:16:50 Say, okay
1:16:50 How much does it cost for a street sweeper to come by and how often is our goal is to to sweep those, you know?
1:16:57 I can't tell you how often they come by my street to sweep
1:17:00 But you know how often do we want our bike, you know, bike areas to be swept?
1:17:05 And that's something that manages to add a cost and has something I know I'll be working with the street department and engineering department.
1:17:11 And try to figure those costs out and see what's the best effective way to do that.
1:17:15 So, Zahn Hockens.
1:17:17 Since you mentioned the bike paths by IB prying, maybe you can give us a quick update on the problems we were having earlier last year in the school year with parking and bike paths.
1:17:27 And there was kind of some congestion area is there?
1:17:30 Is that correct?
1:17:32 So I remember correctly what I've heard too is a lot of times I think by the schools where
1:17:37 you do have bike paths also south to this one of the two where you have a majority of the
1:17:42 parents picking up the kids or dropping out the kids.
1:17:44 I think a lot of parents are parking in the bike lane waiting for their kids.
1:17:50 So there's some concerns about having those bike, not concerns, having the bike lanes,
1:17:56 about how to prevent people from parking and that,
1:18:00 because if you know if you've been by any school
1:18:03 within the special elementary school,
1:18:05 but after school, there's a lot of cars there,
1:18:08 pick up kids, so that'd be great if we could get more kids
1:18:11 to walk to school, and I'd just, you know,
1:18:12 back and forth to get that, but that's a pipe dream
1:18:15 I'd like to.
1:18:16 Thank you.
1:18:17 Okay, thank you, Dan.
1:18:19 You're welcome.
1:18:25 Mandy Thompson.
1:18:27 Welcome, Mandy.
1:18:28 Thank you, Mayor.
1:18:29 Council.
1:18:30 Josh asked me to just give you a brief update on where we are with public transportation,
1:18:35 being apparently that it scored the lowest.
1:18:37 I didn't tell me that when they asked me to come tonight.
1:18:42 So as you know, this is a conversation that I've been a part of since I started here in
1:18:46 December, and I know it's a conversation that started long before I came.
1:18:50 As you know, we were awarded a grant through I-T-D to look at our public transportation system
1:18:56 to do a feasibility study, if you will, and help us create a plan of what our public transportation
1:19:02 system could look like, what it should look like. Those funds will be available for us
1:19:08 to begin spending in April of 2015. However, we can start the planning process prior to that,
1:19:15 and so this fall we will start looking at putting together a request for proposal from
1:19:20 consultants so that when the funding is available in April we'll be able to put
1:19:25 that out and hopefully hit the ground running and get started on that. Josh and
1:19:30 I've been, I guess, hitting the road the past few months, talking a lot about the
1:19:35 public transportation situation in Twin Falls. We've gone to various different
1:19:41 clubs, rotary, retired federal workers and anything that's some other groups we've
1:19:47 spoken to, but we've gotten out into the community and talked to a member of the community
1:19:52 to be about what we are doing and also looking for feedback.
1:19:56 And I got some very positive feedback from one group in particular, which is a social
1:19:59 service provider group.
1:20:02 They clearly serve a segment of our population that could be very, is very dependent on public
1:20:08 transportation.
1:20:09 So it could be something that could be of a great use to the public that they serve.
1:20:13 So I have really seen a lot of support for moving forward and looking at what our public
1:20:19 transportation system needs to be.
1:20:21 So I think we've all heard my spiel about when we hit the 50,000 mark with the next
1:20:28 census.
1:20:29 So we've got some time and I think that time is on our side in the fact that we have the
1:20:35 ability to plan well.
1:20:36 I've spoken with several different transportation leaders in various communities of our size
1:20:41 And a lot of them didn't have that luxury.
1:20:44 They either hit the ground running,
1:20:46 or they took it over, and made a lot of missteps
1:20:51 and mistakes along the way.
1:20:52 So I'd like to learn from those communities
1:20:55 so that when we make that decision,
1:20:56 whether we wait until we have the federal mandate,
1:20:58 or if we choose to move forward,
1:21:01 it's a bit sooner than the census.
1:21:06 We'll have the information to do so in that.
1:21:09 hopefully, you know, very fiscally minded manner.
1:21:12 Manny, this is something that's going to take more of the council's time as we get closer
1:21:18 to the census and that 50,000 mark.
1:21:21 I'm most interested and I hope you'll share with the council things the other communities
1:21:26 did wrong, shouldn't have done.
1:21:28 It's much easier I think when you're dealing with huge amounts of money that aren't really
1:21:32 your own to throw money willy-nilly and hope some of it sticks.
1:21:38 When you find out some of these gems or mistakes other communities may, I think we'd find an
1:21:43 effort statement.
1:21:44 Well, one off the top of my head I know of is the community of Lewiston.
1:21:47 Lewiston and Clarkson were lumped into an urban area in the 19, Lewiston 1990 census.
1:21:55 So even though Lewiston has been out and remained at about 35,000 people for the last 20 or
1:22:01 30 years because of their proximity of Clarkson, they were asked to or they were mandated
1:22:07 to provide public transportation, but they each have to do their own.
1:22:11 When the funding became available for the urban funds through the MAP-21 program, the city
1:22:19 essentially contracted with the equivalent of transfer, really, on demand service provider.
1:22:29 They contracted with them to take the funds and build this public transportation system.
1:22:34 And what they found out quickly was that the amount of paperwork and reporting that was
1:22:39 involved in accepting these millions of dollars was immense and that they were contracting
1:22:48 with this company who had that they were, they weren't beholden to the federal government.
1:22:54 They didn't have to provide the information.
1:22:57 It was the city of Lewston that was on the line.
1:23:01 And so it became a very contentious relationship very quickly.
1:23:04 So they are an example of doing it in that way, and I'm just kind of trying to stick with
1:23:11 the system and the provider they already had, and really, when you're talking about that
1:23:14 much federal money, and whoever the fiscal officer is, is essentially who's responsible
1:23:20 for that money.
1:23:21 And so they didn't have the information to report back to the federal government.
1:23:26 And they had a giant headache on their hands, essentially.
1:23:30 And so pretty much overnight decided to take over the public transportation.
1:23:33 Sounds like they didn't do their diligence.
1:23:35 They didn't, and they'll be the first to tell you that.
1:23:38 So they've been immensely, the woman
1:23:42 that I've been working with.
1:23:43 She's been immensely helpful in just saying,
1:23:47 well, everyone I've spoken with has said, wow,
1:23:49 I wish we had looked at this six to eight to 10 years
1:23:53 ahead of time, because I think everyone,
1:23:57 questions will arise along the way
1:23:59 that you don't necessarily think of in the moment.
1:24:03 But then we also have to realize that a lot can change in that time frame too.
1:24:07 And we get this plan, this transit plan, sometime maybe in 2015 or 2016.
1:24:14 Our community could look extremely different, you know, ten years later.
1:24:18 So.
1:24:20 I think I want you to also look for the successes.
1:24:22 I'm sure Chris meant that as well, not just look for the downside of what's happened out
1:24:27 there and learn from that, but also learn from the successes because there's plenty of those
1:24:30 out there.
1:24:31 And I have been very surprised at the number of small communities
1:24:35 that are offering public transportation, and not because they have a mandate for the federal government
1:24:43 based on their urban status, the city of, I believe it's, I'm going to miss speaking now,
1:24:49 so I probably had our butte for Billings, Montana, I can't remember which one, butte.
1:24:55 They have a very robust public transportation system for the size of the community they have.
1:25:00 So we absolutely will be looking at those types of communities.
1:25:04 Because honestly, even as a community of the same size as Twin Falls on the East Coast,
1:25:10 it's just demographically and spatially going to be much different than Twin Falls.
1:25:16 So we really need to look at the communities that are similar to us in size and even though
1:25:24 we will be considered urban, we're still going to be pretty rural.
1:25:27 Any other questions for Mandy?
1:25:33 I see field trips to butte and Lewis and coming in Travis's future here soon are yours.
1:25:38 Oh, we're going to take you with us.
1:25:41 Thank you, Mandy. Thank you.
1:25:44 I was going to try and delegate out this whole presentation.
1:25:47 I got two more.
1:25:50 That's cute.
1:25:52 So the third weakness that we had, that's part of the read.
1:25:57 The third, and this is a category, so the third category we had where we had a weakness was health and wellness.
1:26:06 So our community, our respondents perceive us as being unfit and unhealthy.
1:26:12 I asked you to kind of remember we have pretty good success rate or positive reviews on the opportunities that are out there.
1:26:20 But those respondents said that we're apparently not taking advantage of them.
1:26:24 So, this weekend, Travis Rothweiler is participating in the Spudman.
1:26:31 How many cannon pitches did you take of Travis right in his mind?
1:26:37 So, once again, partnerships.
1:26:40 We're working with the hospital.
1:26:42 In fact, having a hard time figuring what businesses and organizations we're not partnering with
1:26:47 to teach and promote healthy lifestyle changes.
1:26:51 This is very similar to the challenge we face with recycling, as we have those opportunities
1:26:56 for one reason or another people aren't taking advantage of them.
1:26:59 It's on our part to educate people, and hopefully encourage people to participate in that.
1:27:04 So we have activated Magic Valley, which if you watch KMT, they kind of had a preview on it,
1:27:10 but expected to come here and fall, and we really hope to accomplish that.
1:27:15 I think this is one of those things that would be delegated over to Mandy,
1:27:18 more physically fit than I am, and my heart's with conservation
1:27:21 so I'll stick with the sustainability council.
1:27:23 With that, I do want to raise, I know this is repetitive,
1:27:29 but these really generate a lot of questions,
1:27:31 and some of them we don't have answers to,
1:27:33 but we will work to answer the figure out how we can
1:27:36 improve the services.
1:27:37 So with that, I'm going to leave it to Travis.
1:27:39 He's going to talk about some of the organizational challenges
1:27:41 we face.
1:27:43 Thank you, Josh.
1:27:47 So I get the task of talking about those things
1:27:51 that maybe we fell down a bit in, and really not having a conversation in terms of why,
1:27:59 but maybe acknowledging, because I could stand up here and guess, and I think that a
1:28:03 lot of us could have a conversation, but I think that there were a couple of things
1:28:07 in here that really stuck out to me in terms of attention grabbing.
1:28:15 The first was customer service rating.
1:28:18 The customer service rating that is provided by a public entity needs to be high because
1:28:23 all we do is service.
1:28:25 And if our customer service rating is not meeting the expectations of our citizens, then
1:28:30 that is something that we need to spend time and focus on.
1:28:33 And really that whole process is all across the organization, at all levels of the organization,
1:28:41 we need to make sure that we have a couple of things down.
1:28:44 a good understanding of what customer service means to our citizens, and then finding a way
1:28:50 to deliver that. Because until we know what that is, we can't deliver what they're expecting.
1:28:57 The second is in interaction and engagement with our citizens, and there were some really
1:29:01 interesting things, especially in the survey, if you take a look at it, that most of the
1:29:06 individuals in our community did not physically come to a meeting. In fact, if you look at
1:29:12 the survey, 13% of the respondents said that they came to a meeting, 13% of, and it is connected
1:29:23 to the census.
1:29:24 So that means 13, and if it's representative of the community, 13% of a community of 45,000
1:29:33 attended our meetings.
1:29:35 And I think that if we start doing the math, that's about 5,000 people, and I think that
1:29:40 we would be challenged to recall significant public attendance in our meetings.
1:29:46 Now one of the things I think is important is attendance may not be physical.
1:29:52 Attendance may be virtual.
1:29:54 And as we watch Granicus and other forms of engagement and interaction that is in participation
1:30:03 may be that is continuing to grow.
1:30:06 Most of our citizens receive their information from local and traditional media sources.
1:30:11 The second is by word of mouth.
1:30:14 And their connection from social media to interaction with elected leaders to elected
1:30:21 interaction to appointed leaders are much, much lower than those two sources combined.
1:30:28 So if the word of mouth information that is being spread is not accurate or incorrect,
1:30:36 That perpetuates some of this.
1:30:39 So it's important for us to get engaged, to find those interactions with our citizens
1:30:44 better than what we have.
1:30:46 And we also need to find out how do our citizens want us to have conversations with them.
1:30:51 We right now tend to hit a very broad brush with that.
1:30:55 We try to send PSAs, we have a very robust website, we have a very robust and growing
1:31:02 social media site.
1:31:03 In fact, if you look at social media, it is probably one of the fastest growing forms of
1:31:07 communication that we have.
1:31:10 Traffic enforcement.
1:31:12 Traffic enforcement is an area that does not infell below where we were previously.
1:31:20 What's interesting is if you recall the chief was here talking about using data to help drive
1:31:27 this decision in terms of traffic.
1:31:30 That is a new program that was recently implemented.
1:31:33 was implemented if you remember the two quarters that we used after the survey was launched.
1:31:40 It will be interesting to see if that data-driven solution and approach the one that we won
1:31:45 the AIC award for really does prove to be beneficial in the eyes of our citizens.
1:31:53 Overall cycling, recycling.
1:31:56 This is one of the ones that was through the roof.
1:31:59 It had 83% of our citizens rated it as good or excellent in 2012 and in 2014 I believe the
1:32:08 number dropped to about 72.
1:32:12 72 is significantly higher than what our peers are but it was still a sizable drop that we
1:32:17 want to understand why.
1:32:19 And so we start thinking what has changed in the area of recycling?
1:32:25 Is it communication?
1:32:26 Is it how we're communicating?
1:32:28 Is it doing a better job?
1:32:30 Is it Recycle Pink?
1:32:33 What is one of the driving factors that has caused that?
1:32:37 And I don't think that we can stand here and say,
1:32:39 we know what it is.
1:32:41 But I think it's important to find out what it is.
1:32:44 Because the correlation is that we've also
1:32:47 seen the tons per capita in 2013 drop.
1:32:52 Now, interestingly, and as the reports illustrated in 2014,
1:32:56 we've seen them grow.
1:32:57 They are better than what they were in 2013 on the whole, but they have yet to reach 2012
1:33:03 results.
1:33:08 Snow removal and street cleaning.
1:33:10 I think Dennis talked a little bit about the importance of street cleaning, especially when
1:33:14 you look at its connection to trails and alternative transportation.
1:33:19 But snow removal was one of those ones that kind of flew out of nowhere, at least on my radar.
1:33:28 And we are, we can talk about it right, we can talk about selling snowplows to Jerome.
1:33:35 I will tell you that Mike didn't do a much better job removing snow in.
1:33:40 But in all reality, we have to understand why.
1:33:43 We are not meeting our citizens expectations when it comes to cleaning our streets and removing
1:33:48 the snow and we need to understand what that looks like.
1:33:51 We need to understand why.
1:33:53 partnering with them also in the areas of creation of open space, storm water, sidewalk
1:34:00 maintenance. Some of these become a little bit more of an understanding like sidewalks
1:34:07 and sidewalk maintenance. That becomes a little clearer as to why. And if you look around
1:34:12 our community, some of those sidewalks are in a state of disrepair. Those sidewalks and
1:34:19 and maintenance and care are the responsibility of the property owners.
1:34:25 So how do we work collaboratively in private property areas to ensure that we're creating
1:34:31 quality sidewalks, and what is the connection to that with ADA planning?
1:34:36 To ensure that if we're going to go forward with public transportation, which is no longer
1:34:41 going to be a dial and ride system, that individuals have the ability to make it from their house
1:34:49 to a bus stop.
1:34:57 So really, I don't know if we can answer any questions.
1:35:02 We got a lot of questions.
1:35:04 We got a lot more questions, and we really
1:35:05 do have answers, honestly.
1:35:07 But one of the things that, again, we
1:35:10 are committed to maybe killing a few birds
1:35:14 with a single stone.
1:35:16 Number one, having intensive community engagement
1:35:18 processes this fall around these questions
1:35:22 as we continue to use that to update the strategic plan, I think, is a good start.
1:35:29 The second piece is having intentional focus groups as to why.
1:35:33 And the third is doing some really good reflecting internally as to what part of the organization
1:35:40 is responsible for these things and how does it move forward.
1:35:44 Because snow removal and street sweeping, it may sound like it just falls under the jurisdiction
1:35:50 of the street department, but really it is much more than that because if it's not the
1:35:56 delivery of the service but how we're communicating it, that falls under my office.
1:36:02 And so really it's more of a partnership amongst all of our departments to find out how do we
1:36:06 find better solutions to those areas.
1:36:10 I want to end on this.
1:36:13 We're recognizing our weaknesses because it's important for organizations who want to
1:36:17 grow to do that. But like Josh said, 16 fell down. One was our community's view of how successful
1:36:26 our federal government is. I can't claim any way to fix that one. So there's 15 that I
1:36:35 think that whether through the City of Twin Falls or through our partnerships, I think
1:36:39 that we can find solutions. There were 10 that we grew. There were 10 areas on the survey
1:36:46 that we actually show in areas of improvement
1:36:50 in the sentiment of our community.
1:36:54 Chris talking.
1:36:54 One little anchor point just out of curiosity
1:36:57 that I find veracity for this whole process
1:37:00 is the library continues to have just about the highest marks.
1:37:04 I think 83% in that much above category.
1:37:09 And I think that's pretty close to what it was the last time
1:37:11 we did it.
1:37:12 So I think that shows that these are even
1:37:16 with a smaller statistical base, I think, 373 versus how much last year or last time?
1:37:23 I think it was 402, 406.
1:37:25 Oh, not significant.
1:37:27 It has validity.
1:37:32 I'm really a total agreement with you that rather than celebrating our successes that
1:37:39 we focus on areas of relative weakness on a comparative basis.
1:37:45 When I was in the banking business I remember because we had a startup bank we didn't know
1:37:50 about customer satisfaction and so we started looking at banks around the area and I'm guilty
1:37:57 of a little hyperbola right now but in essence they were asking their customers would you
1:38:02 rank our service great, outstanding or almost too hard to believe.
1:38:08 I think we need to take just the other attack where look for vulnerabilities, do those folks
1:38:14 groups, not feel defensive about it.
1:38:17 And if it causes us to get outside the box a little bit
1:38:22 and outside our comfort level, that's the business we're in.
1:38:25 So kudos and good job.
1:38:28 We're back in Mel's second.
1:38:29 Thank you, Mayor.
1:38:30 Thank you for your presentation, everyone.
1:38:33 Josh and Travis, Mandy and Dennis.
1:38:37 I did find these stats kind of interesting.
1:38:39 And I was surprised too in areas where
1:38:42 I thought we might have increased approval,
1:38:44 especially in engagement, civic engagement.
1:38:48 I noticed that those who had watched meetings,
1:38:50 really that stayed about the same, about 30%.
1:38:53 But yet, the participation, people coming to meetings,
1:38:57 has decreased, and so I think that's for the council to ask,
1:39:01 what can we do, what can we do to inspire
1:39:04 and engage the community?
1:39:06 So I also embrace the areas where we might make changes.
1:39:10 I just wanted to know a couple of things.
1:39:14 I noticed that since 2009, our sense of community
1:39:17 has actually gone down and is declining.
1:39:20 And so I wonder, what can we do in the realm of maybe finding
1:39:27 a larger city park, a place where we come together
1:39:30 as a community and how can we focus on those infrastructure
1:39:34 needs that allow us to come together
1:39:36 and have a sense of a community?
1:39:38 because as we get larger, we're going to need to find something, and so maybe we can focus
1:39:45 on that. Also, our natural areas preservation decrease slightly, and so maybe in our code
1:39:54 changes and in our updates to our comp plan, we can keep that under consideration that maybe
1:40:00 Maybe we aren't doing enough to preserve open spaces and green spaces.
1:40:06 Two other areas that we might ask, maybe look internally at what direction we're going.
1:40:13 I noticed that code enforcement and animal control, you know, those are two departments
1:40:19 where we made significant changes.
1:40:22 And then the approval there has decreased slightly, not significantly, but slightly.
1:40:27 And so maybe we can ask how we're doing there, maybe what changes we might make.
1:40:39 Comments, Trevitz?
1:40:40 You know, I'm going to take a look.
1:40:42 I don't remember those declining by comparison.
1:40:48 They are certainly not, I mean like Joshua, there's 123 statistical categories in this
1:40:53 thing.
1:40:55 I don't remember those specifically declining inside or outside of the margin of error that
1:41:05 is reflected within the reports.
1:41:07 But it's certainly one of those things that, like all services we want to take a look at.
1:41:11 I know that animal control, he received like a 48% approval rating, but that seemed to
1:41:16 to be about average to what we're similar to what we had experienced in prior years.
1:41:26 But those are certainly things that we want to take a look at, not only animal control
1:41:29 and code enforcement, but reflecting all the way through.
1:41:33 I think it's important that we want to drive to excellence.
1:41:38 What we want to do is we want to, some communities may be very satisfied with that fair.
1:41:45 You're just meeting that minimum standard,
1:41:49 but we've said, like Josh shared,
1:41:52 we want to be a high-performing organization.
1:41:54 And in being that, we want to drive to excellence.
1:41:58 And that is going to cause us not only to reflect on those things
1:42:02 that maybe we fell down a bit, but also to find ways
1:42:05 to continue to strengthen.
1:42:07 Because in that area of economic development,
1:42:09 like Josh had shared, it meets all of those expectations.
1:42:12 In fact, it's one of, it's higher by comparison to those cities in the west of regional and similar size,
1:42:19 but I don't think that we're satisfied with the 56% rating.
1:42:24 And if I could clarify Travis, the NCS didn't say that it was lower.
1:42:30 It kind of said similar because it didn't fall in that 7%.
1:42:33 But the specific numbers, animal control went from 52% in 2012 to 48% in 2014.
1:42:41 And then code enforcement went from 38% to 34%.
1:42:46 So, you know, four to five percent,
1:42:48 and not that significant, seven percent,
1:42:49 but still, yeah, within the margin of error,
1:42:52 but still something we can be looking at.
1:42:57 That's what we have.
1:42:58 All right, Council, I.
1:43:00 Oh, yes.
1:43:01 Real quick, these are on the web.
1:43:03 There are six reports in their totality.
1:43:06 There is a lot of information out there.
1:43:09 They're out there for individuals to review,
1:43:12 to look at the question, and we encourage individuals
1:43:17 to give us a phone call if they have questions about it,
1:43:20 to share their thoughts and their sentiments.
1:43:22 And again, we look forward to working with our community,
1:43:25 starting in September, moving forward.
1:43:28 Council I, Dean, we are going to take a quick recess.
1:43:32 Good idea.
1:49:31 I'd like to reconvene the meeting
1:49:33 of the Twin Falls City Council.
1:49:35 July 21st, it is now about 12 minutes to seven.
1:49:38 Next item on the agenda is presentation
1:49:41 of the enterprise type funds from the city manager's
1:49:45 recommended budget for fiscal year 2015, Travis Rothwider.
1:49:50 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, good evening.
1:49:53 And this is, I believe our seventh conversation
1:49:56 this year, formal conversation that we've had
1:50:00 with the city council on this budget moving forward.
1:50:03 Night specifically, we want to talk
1:50:05 about the enterprise type funds.
1:50:07 But before we begin, we want to maybe take just a quick minute to share how we start this
1:50:14 process.
1:50:15 And so one of the important things to remember is that we've talked earlier when we talked
1:50:20 about the city's citizen survey and its connection to our strategic plan, the value and the importance
1:50:27 that the strategic plan has in guiding our operations, so does our mission statement.
1:50:32 And those two in concert work collectively to help guide financial considerations that have
1:50:39 been placed into this budget for your review.
1:50:44 We started this conversation, like I said, and from those conversations we really built
1:50:48 out six overarching budgets and strategies tying to the strategic plan, making sure that
1:50:57 we're being sensitive about tax collections and the corresponding revenues that we have in
1:51:02 those enterprise type funds. We wanted to have a conversation about investing in our employees.
1:51:07 We wanted to make sure that we were continuing to invest in our systems to ensure that the
1:51:11 concept of deferred maintenance wasn't something that was perpetuated. We wanted to have a conversation
1:51:16 about investing in our structures and our facilities and we wanted to continue to find better ways
1:51:21 to serve the public at large. Of this list, five of the six are included in strategies
1:51:28 to move forward are present.
1:51:32 Investing in our structured facilities as we shared has been removed from this budget,
1:51:37 but it does not necessarily mean it has been removed from the public conversation.
1:51:42 Our facilities and our structures are important, but really we need to make sure that we're
1:51:47 focusing on the budget and we can engage in that conversation in the upcoming days and
1:51:55 weeks ahead.
1:51:57 Here's a graphical illustration of what the budget looks like.
1:52:03 The blue represents those funds that are supported by some level of property tax.
1:52:10 We refer those as the general or the government type funds.
1:52:15 The red are those enterprise type funds and those are the conversations that we're going
1:52:21 to be focusing on this evening.
1:52:25 As we've started the last two presentations, we wanted to really start this presentation
1:52:29 with this slide to put our spending in perspective.
1:52:34 And you can illustrate this many, many different ways, but what we've tried to do here is take
1:52:39 a look at that average person if that average person exists.
1:52:44 We're looking at the median property taxes on a house of $144,300.
1:52:50 an individual who consumes 18,000 gallons of water,
1:52:54 who provides 8,000 gallons of sewer,
1:52:59 and a sanitation, receives a monthly sanitation service.
1:53:04 So if you take a look at that,
1:53:06 the difference for the year is $22.85,
1:53:11 or $1.90 per month,
1:53:13 and the enterprise type funds are right around $14.
1:53:19 So tonight, the first enterprise type fund
1:53:21 we're going to talk about is going to be the Water Fund.
1:53:24 It's all things water, so it's going to talk about supply
1:53:28 distribution, pressurized irrigation.
1:53:30 And then we focus all the utility building out of the
1:53:33 Water Fund just for easy accounting purposes.
1:53:37 So the Water Fund this year calls for a 2% rate
1:53:40 adjustment, which is again similar to that municipal cost
1:53:44 index of 2.19.
1:53:46 And we're going to talk a lot about that.
1:53:48 That municipal cost index is that inflationary factor that local governments use to determine
1:53:56 how things and costs of providing like services grow.
1:53:59 And the municipal cost index is similar to a consumer price index, but it focuses more
1:54:05 on the basket of goods and services that we tend to use more of at the city.
1:54:10 That number, for our comparisons for this year's 2.19%, the rate increase in the water
1:54:15 fund calls for a 2% rate adjustment, $9 annually, or $0.75 per month for that average user who
1:54:23 uses 18,000 gallons per month.
1:54:28 The Water Fund total expenditures are up $32,000 or 0.33%.
1:54:34 And if you take a look at the operational increases, we're looking at about an 8% adjustment
1:54:39 there.
1:54:40 That is associated with power, pumping costs, professional services, and ensuring that we
1:54:44 we have the appropriate inventories on the shelves.
1:54:48 You can see that how we break that down,
1:54:52 the operational budget includes the personnel,
1:54:55 as well as the M&O.
1:54:56 That is an increase of $340,000.
1:54:59 A part of that increase is also the phase of the compensation
1:55:04 plan that we had talked about in great depth last week.
1:55:10 The capital budget is decreased about $345,000
1:55:14 this year compared to last.
1:55:16 But what is important to note is that was offset
1:55:19 by using $800,000 of cash reserves last year,
1:55:22 and we're using $360,000 of cash reserves this year.
1:55:26 So we're actually having more incoming revenue go
1:55:30 to help with our capital needs in moving forward.
1:55:35 Debt service is an increase of $70,289,
1:55:40 and then the transfer, which again is tied
1:55:42 to the municipal cost index.
1:55:44 That transfer is a rent that is assessed for the times across the organization.
1:55:49 Great learning.
1:55:50 Travis, did you give a couple of dates?
1:55:54 Yes, I have a freshman.
1:55:56 The arsenic amount is $10.00.
1:55:59 I know she's going to give you the number.
1:56:01 Are you the one of you?
1:56:02 Is $10.00?
1:56:03 What are we charging out for a month per year?
1:56:05 $10.00 and $75.00.
1:56:06 $10.00 and $75.00.00.
1:56:07 And when does that particular thing run out?
1:56:10 So what we'd like to do is maybe hold the series of questions about arsenic because
1:56:15 Councilman Tockington asked the series of questions about arsenic last week and Laurie
1:56:20 has prepared a special part of the presentation to get that.
1:56:24 I'm perfectly well.
1:56:25 I just you.
1:56:26 About 30 seconds.
1:56:29 We're asking for one edition.
1:56:31 I'm sorry, Rebecca Milsoyka.
1:56:33 One quick question, Travis, about the debt service increase.
1:56:36 What is that attributed to?
1:56:37 I mean, we haven't taken on new debt.
1:56:40 And you may, I'm sorry if you've covered that.
1:56:43 So Rebecca, when we had put that together, just regard, I was thinking of sewer, I apologize
1:56:51 for that.
1:56:52 So that's just simply an increase.
1:56:56 Debt service payments or bond payments and interest, and they are not level.
1:57:01 If you look at debt service, it changes a little bit each year.
1:57:04 So it's natural?
1:57:05 Yeah, it changes.
1:57:06 Okay.
1:57:08 Exactly.
1:57:09 Yeah, we're in the water fund.
1:57:10 thinking of sewer fund when I came up to originally answer. Sorry about that.
1:57:14 We're again looking at hiring a water operator to assist with the water
1:57:27 functions that we have. John Caten and Jackie Fields are both here to talk
1:57:32 about the specifics of the positions but again it's looking at as we continue to
1:57:37 grow that system as we continue to expand it making sure that we have the
1:57:41 available manpower to operate it. We've added additional water lines
1:57:46 associated with our SNCC with some of the economic development projects.
1:57:50 We're looking at adding a new water reservoir into the system, and it's important to make
1:57:53 sure that as we continue to grow the system from a capital perspective, that we have the
1:57:58 manpower from an operational perspective to be able to operate it.
1:58:02 The list of significant capital projects are included in here.
1:58:05 You'll see $250,000 for pump replacements at Canyon Springs, $360,000 for that ongoing
1:58:13 main line replacement that we have. That is another $225,000 for pressurized irrigation
1:58:20 station as the Castlewood subdivision and $160,000 for meter replacements.
1:58:27 Great, go ahead.
1:58:28 Travis, just only a citizen asked me about it over the weekend until it's fresh in my
1:58:33 mind and it kind of comes under capital highlights. Are we at some path along the way of ever
1:58:40 for establishing the generator at the Canyon Springs pump station.
1:58:44 You know, a separate generator for emergencies.
1:58:50 And I'd like to introduce to you your city manager, John Kayman.
1:58:54 To help with that.
1:58:58 Only one night of this, John, will we?
1:59:07 I'm going to delegate this question.
1:59:11 As far as backup power generation for Canyon Springs, we are looking at it. It's in our
1:59:16 plan or considering all the options and the plans not complete or even spot where we can
1:59:23 review it. So they're considering all sorts of things.
1:59:29 Okay. I remember being like the size of a semi or something was the part of it.
1:59:38 Yeah, if we were going to provide back of power for all the king spring pumps down there, it
1:59:44 It could be, yeah, it's the size of like a mobile home,
1:59:50 and it's anywhere from $500,000 to $100,000.
1:59:56 Yeah, hard to justify for once every few years,
2:00:00 that type of thing.
2:00:01 Okay, great, thank you.
2:00:11 So this is where Lori is gonna come up
2:00:13 and start talking about that arsenic debt
2:00:16 and the arsenic debt.
2:00:18 Rebecca has a question.
2:00:19 Oh, real quickly, Travis, before you move on,
2:00:22 I was hoping you'd talk more about that water meter replacement.
2:00:24 Is that just average maintenance that needs to be done, or are you implementing a new
2:00:28 technology?
2:00:29 John?
2:00:33 John?
2:00:34 Thank you.
2:00:35 It's a little bit of both.
2:00:36 So water meters over time lose accuracy, and not only do they fail, but they don't read
2:00:45 as much water.
2:00:46 So it's in the water balance, it's lost revenue.
2:00:49 So you need to have a replacement plan in place.
2:00:54 So we're always trying to replace them as part of our preventative maintenance.
2:00:59 Additionally, we are switching over to an automated meter reading system which they abbreviated
2:01:06 MR and it allows us to remotely read water meters.
2:01:10 So it helps us with our backlog and we can process more accounts more efficiently.
2:01:18 Perfect.
2:01:19 If this is approved at the end of that budget cycle
2:01:23 Would everyone's meters in the city be replaced or is it a portion? No, there's
2:01:33 This will
2:01:37 So it's something we need to do for
2:01:43 Okay, this will do 100 out of the 17,000 every meters a little bit different depends on on
2:01:51 on what kind of site work you have to do or I mean if it's simply dropping a meter in it's
2:01:57 a few hundred dollars but if you have to replace the meter tile they call it or dig it out and
2:02:03 replace shutoffs it can be as much as fifteen hundred dollars per.
2:02:10 Thank you.
2:02:18 Hello Lori.
2:02:19 So Chris this is what I heard you ask last week.
2:02:25 evaluate the feasibility of an early expedited payoff of federal unfunded
2:02:30 arsenic mitigation. That's correct. Okay, perfect. So I want to start out with just a
2:02:39 little bit of information for you because you know I knew right away we just
2:02:45 haven't been paying on those bonds long enough for it to be feasible but let me
2:02:48 give you a little information. So we issued $18,595,000 of bonds to the
2:02:55 bond bank in May of 2010.
2:02:58 They're 15 year bonds with the true interest cost of about 3.17% and we've only been making
2:03:04 debt payments for about 3.5 years and we'll be making another payment in August.
2:03:11 Now we are required to collect system net revenues at least equal to 125% of the annual payment
2:03:18 per our bond covenant requirement.
2:03:22 So based on customer counts when we talked to the council in 2010 and calculating 125%
2:03:29 of the annual debt payment, we began charging a monthly fee of $11.15 and we estimated we'd
2:03:36 only need to charge that fee for 12 out of the 15 years.
2:03:41 And then those accumulated funds could be placed with the trustee to pay off the remaining debt.
2:03:47 Last year we reduced that monthly fee from $11.15 to $10.75 and based on increased customer
2:03:53 counts, and we projected very little change in the extra money we would be receiving.
2:04:00 We would still be in compliance with our bond covenant requirement and the reduction helps
2:04:04 soften that 4% increase we asked for last year.
2:04:08 Through fiscal year 2013, we've collected $2 million over the total debt payments that
2:04:14 that we've made.
2:04:15 And while that sounds substantial, it's not enough to make that debt payment in 2025.
2:04:23 That debt payment is $2.4 million.
2:04:27 So based on recent projections, I believe we may be able to discontinue the mandated arsenic
2:04:32 compliance fee maybe a few months earlier than the projection I made in 2010.
2:04:41 if everything continues as is,
2:04:43 we should have enough funds collected by the latter part
2:04:46 of 2022 to discontinue this fee.
2:04:51 So good.
2:04:51 I won't even be on the council then.
2:04:54 Chris will be the only one still here.
2:04:58 So I just want to share with you
2:05:00 that it's not feasible to do it at this time.
2:05:05 Also these bonds have a 10 year call provision
2:05:08 and I did not remember that at the time.
2:05:10 really important.
2:05:11 Yeah.
2:05:12 And based on the current interest rates, Jess wouldn't be worth the risk and the issuance
2:05:18 costs to try to get a better rate.
2:05:21 In fact, I just visited with Cameron Ariel, the science bank, and he estimated it would
2:05:27 add about $1.3 million to try to do anything at this point.
2:05:33 Well, I appreciate that background.
2:05:35 That's, I wondered about that call provision.
2:05:39 Now, press, is there anything legally to prevent if the Council should desire to forward paying
2:05:47 that out of either cap, capital reserves to reduce the monthly impact to residents as
2:05:55 we did last year? We reduced it by $0.40 if that availability of money is decided, you
2:06:02 money is decided you could continue doing that yes you are able to do that okay
2:06:09 and there's any limitation on it besides the practicalities the practicalities
2:06:14 and will of the council thank you thanks Laurie Peralta research and answer
2:06:22 your questions so the next one that we want to talk about is going to be the
2:06:28 sewer fund the sewer fund he supports are not only our wastewater collections but
2:06:33 at all of our wastewater treatment plant efforts.
2:06:36 We're looking at a 1% increase system wide for the,
2:06:40 and so oftentimes we talk about that cap and that residence.
2:06:45 It's important to recognize that all non-residential
2:06:48 customers do not receive that cap,
2:06:50 and all of our non-residential customers
2:06:51 will see a 1% increase in accordance
2:06:54 with our rate resolution.
2:06:56 Should this budget be approved?
2:06:57 But for that average resident who contributes
2:07:00 8,000 gallons of wastewater,
2:07:02 they're looking at a maximum of $0.25 per month or $3.
2:07:08 The sewer fund expenditures are down $242,000 this year.
2:07:14 If you take a look, a large portion of that
2:07:17 is going to be found in a combination of the operational
2:07:21 costs, which is largely associated with the renegotiated CH2M
2:07:28 Hill contract.
2:07:30 And also the capital piece, there's a decrease there.
2:07:33 What's important to recognize is the $38 plus million
2:07:37 that we're paying into the improvements
2:07:39 that the wastewater treatment plant
2:07:40 are not factored into this overall project.
2:07:45 The debt service is, and like Laurie shared with you
2:07:48 last time, even though we have that flat debt
2:07:52 of over that entire life of the note,
2:07:55 the $228,000 increase was a result of what we had budgeted
2:08:00 and what we had actually seen at the marketplace.
2:08:03 And so, in subsequent years, you will see a fairly flat-lined budget amount over the course
2:08:09 of the duration of the debt, which is about 20 years.
2:08:13 Again, transfers are up.
2:08:15 Again, that is the rent that is paid by the wastewater treatment plant to support the operations
2:08:20 typically found in the tax-supported funds.
2:08:29 Like the Water Fund, we're looking at increasing for a collections operator, but specifically
2:08:37 this one is going to help in the area of stormwater. In that conversation that you saw in June,
2:08:45 we had a new street water operator that was proposed and that position was removed prior.
2:08:52 Dean was responsible for assisting with all stormwater compliance. We made the decision
2:08:58 to shift that responsibility under wastewater collections because of its relation and connection
2:09:03 to NPDS related issues, so that is going to be operating under and the need for this
2:09:09 position is to assist with greater storm water advances as we move forward.
2:09:15 It is important that Phase 2 of the storm water will also come into the community when
2:09:21 we see the 50,000 census population, and it's one of those things that we want to move
2:09:26 forward on.
2:09:27 We're back in Mel's second.
2:09:29 Thank you, Mayor.
2:09:30 Would that employee also be necessary, or is any part of that employee necessary due to the expansion at the wastewater treatment plan?
2:09:39 I mean, we're significantly expanding the plant, but so there's no more need for personnel.
2:09:47 So, that is all of the bodies are included in the CH2M-HEL contract,
2:09:54 and we pay an operational fee to them, and they cover all those personnel costs
2:09:59 under the direct cost perversion.
2:10:01 A part of this though, if you remember the bond, we are looking to also to expand
2:10:06 and to increase and to significantly enhance part of our collection system as part of that.
2:10:12 So it's part storm water and but this is really in the collection side, which is the responsibility of the city not under the treatment side.
2:10:21 Okay, thanks.
2:10:22 The capital projects are listed below.
2:10:33 The last one that we want to talk about tonight that has an impact on our citizens is going to be that sanitation fund,
2:10:40 which is going to be not only a garbage collection, but also the stream, the curbside single streamer cycle program.
2:10:48 And again, we talked about the success that the program has had, and we also kind of talked
2:10:52 about how we kind of maybe fell in the eyes of our service.
2:10:55 So again, this will be an area that we want to spend some time looking at.
2:10:58 But over the course of moving to single stream from the blue crate, we've diverted over 7133
2:11:06 tons.
2:11:07 And it is still, even with that drop, one of the highest rated city services that we have,
2:11:13 we're looking at a 19 cent increase to our residential customers.
2:11:17 And we provide sanitation services only to those customers that are residential in nature.
2:11:24 Commercial and industrial customers are responsible for their own sanitation services.
2:11:30 That increase represents about a 1.11% or 19 cents per month.
2:11:38 And again, the largest factor is the contract that we have with our hauler is going up 1.7%.
2:11:46 under that municipal cost index of 2.119.
2:11:53 Thank you, Mayor.
2:11:55 A few people have asked me why we don't recycle glass.
2:11:58 It's a great question.
2:11:59 Yeah, I don't know if PSI is here, but I didn't have the answer to that, so I was wondering.
2:12:04 So we have tried, and we've engaged in conversations.
2:12:09 There is no market for glass at this point in time, and we will continue to do what we can to find those opportunities and those markets.
2:12:17 Glass is a commodity that is not readily accepted by recycling entities.
2:12:24 There are a couple of different options that you have with glass.
2:12:28 One is kind of what Ada County Highway District had done for a little while,
2:12:33 and that is to collect glass and then to incorporate it into their road base.
2:12:39 And you can use about 10%, but the success of the glass program actually
2:12:43 because a significant growth of the amount of glass that was available, and now they have stacks of glass,
2:12:50 and they have a sizable yard of it that they'll be able to use into the long-term future.
2:12:57 The other side of the coin is that it is not something that is accepted here,
2:13:01 and it would significantly enhance the cost of our overall recycling program.
2:13:08 Some local communities, namely Blaine County, participate and they do glass recycling, but
2:13:15 the cost of their recycling program is significantly more than ours.
2:13:18 And one of the largest factors is that glass piece.
2:13:22 So besides Blaine County, do any other cities in Idaho recycle glass?
2:13:28 But I'm aware of, in fact, I believe that even the city of Boise, and
2:13:32 we look to Josh because he's been on the city of Boise, I believe, has also discontinued their collection of glass.
2:13:38 because of the cost and because it doesn't have a home.
2:13:41 Okay, thank you.
2:13:42 In fact, that Travis is in a fair assessment
2:13:45 that with no market, after market for a glass,
2:13:49 I think all the rest of our recyclables
2:13:51 are down in market recapture.
2:13:54 Yeah, we don't get it.
2:13:55 Including aluminum even.
2:13:56 That's correct.
2:13:57 We do not get a commodity benefit
2:14:00 from any of the recyclables now.
2:14:03 We continue to work with PSI
2:14:04 to find a achievable market
2:14:06 to earn a commodity return on that.
2:14:09 The challenges is that most of the recyclables
2:14:13 at one point in time were being sold off to other foreign countries
2:14:18 and then we would buy that back as a durable or other good.
2:14:23 They have also stopped accepting as much recyclables
2:14:27 as the past.
2:14:28 And so even though it is being collected,
2:14:30 it is not one of those things that is being actively sold.
2:14:36 The other thing is, because it is single stream,
2:14:40 that there is a labor component of separating that,
2:14:42 and if there was a commodity, that is probably
2:14:45 where some of that is getting a tippy part.
2:14:50 So we kind of want to leave where we started,
2:14:52 which is the increase is associated with this.
2:14:56 What's important is this might be slightly overstated,
2:14:59 because as we went forward and we looked
2:15:01 at the average water consumption,
2:15:03 we found that to be closer to 17,000 gallons,
2:15:07 at under 17,000 gallons as opposed to 18,000 gallons of consumption to the average person
2:15:14 in moving forward. So again, we're looking at about an annual increase of $22.85, which
2:15:21 includes property taxes assessed by the city, water, sewer, and sanitation for an entire
2:15:27 year, a monthly increase of approximately $1.90.
2:15:31 and 90 cents.
2:15:32 Great planning.
2:15:33 That would be the residential increase, so a business or a large user of water might actually
2:15:41 see a larger increase.
2:15:43 Well, they'll see a larger dollar increase, but it's still 2 percent, and for sewer, it's
2:15:50 1 percent.
2:15:51 Those are the percentage increases that are recommended in this budget, and those are uniform
2:15:59 for all customers, the exact dollar amount
2:16:02 is going to be very, very based upon customer type.
2:16:06 Thank you.
2:16:14 Just real quick, and then I understand
2:16:16 that there's a gentleman who would like to speak.
2:16:20 It's important to recognize,
2:16:21 so we've had the conversation.
2:16:23 Next week is designed to be more
2:16:24 of a free-flowing conversation.
2:16:27 We might have a couple of quick slides
2:16:29 to prime the conversation,
2:16:30 but we're really hoping that we are able to answer
2:16:33 the council's questions prior to the meeting on August 4th.
2:16:38 And as those questions come up,
2:16:41 please feel free to share what those are
2:16:43 so that we're able to be much more efficient,
2:16:47 much more productive and make sure
2:16:48 that we have the right team members here.
2:16:50 On the 4th, you're going to be asked
2:16:52 to adopt the tentative budget,
2:16:53 which sets the absolute maximum cap that you can have
2:16:57 in spending.
2:16:58 We'll also have a series of public hearings,
2:17:00 not public hearings as required by code on these,
2:17:03 but public hearings that we see in the airport
2:17:07 and the impact fees that we had talked about.
2:17:13 And then we're hoping to have again the budget adoption
2:17:17 to occur by the adoption of the ordinance
2:17:20 and the public hearing on August 18th.
2:17:23 So that kind of shares what the on upcoming calendar
2:17:26 looks like.
2:17:27 So Travis, to reiterate if there's some questions
2:17:30 that we have regarding the city manager's recommended budget,
2:17:33 that especially if it looks like it would take some research
2:17:37 and those kind of things.
2:17:38 Please forward that to you so that you can have the proper
2:17:41 person here that evening with the supporting documentation
2:17:45 behind, because nothing's worse than asking a question,
2:17:48 and then we have to wait a week.
2:17:50 One of the things we want to do is we want to make sure
2:17:52 that we have the right people at the meeting next week
2:17:56 and in the subsequent weeks.
2:17:57 So just an idea if you have questions about fire, police,
2:18:03 whatever those things may be, and also an idea of what they
2:18:07 might be so we can bring the supporting data to illustrate
2:18:10 what that looks like would be helpful.
2:18:12 Any questions for Travis before we move on to Chris talking?
2:18:18 I'd just like to sum up my feelings on the arsenic
2:18:21 with the fine background, dissuasion of hoping
2:18:25 we can retire the whole 16.5 million left.
2:18:30 My thought about it is the largest unfunded federal mandate I can remember since imposing
2:18:37 waste treatment standards back in the 70s.
2:18:40 This 18 million dollars has gone on the tax rolls of the public.
2:18:47 It's a significant cost to our residents.
2:18:51 I think a partial payoff as we did last year or a reduction in the debt is a good use of
2:18:57 our capital reserve funds.
2:19:00 And this $0.40 last year, I hope we could at least do that much even double at this next
2:19:06 year to take just a little bit symbolically out of the sting of this for the coming year.
2:19:13 So I would, without getting past a point with council discussion, I'd just ask for consideration
2:19:20 of just say a dollar reduction from the 1075 down to 975 and the budget
2:19:29 implications of that. It's not a motion. It's just something to build an argument
2:19:35 around.
2:19:36 Perfect. Thank you, Chris. Anything else from council? I have one item that I'd
2:19:43 like to bring to council's attention before we ask Mr. Johnson to come forward.
2:19:47 And that is under the City Council's budget.
2:19:52 We have a budget, we don't look at this very often,
2:19:55 but we have one.
2:19:57 Under training, it's kind of an odd thing on training
2:20:02 with Council, and this is probably more food for thought
2:20:05 too, Chris, just like what you're saying,
2:20:07 and maybe we can have further conversations about it.
2:20:11 But it's an odd thing when we talk about our budget
2:20:13 and training and who approves our budget for training.
2:20:18 I know that sometimes we ask Travis, hey I want to go to this training and Travis is like,
2:20:25 that's not my realm to approve what the council does or not.
2:20:31 Sometimes I know I've been asked as the mayor and I don't have the authority to approve any
2:20:38 expenditure of another council member.
2:20:40 So food for thought in the city manager's upcoming recommendation budget, it's proposed
2:20:47 to have about $12,000 in the travel and meetings budget.
2:20:54 That is really at that level because in the last several years we've spent, or we've had
2:21:02 more participation on council side going to the AIC meetings than we had in the past.
2:21:08 So that's really reflective of that participation,
2:21:13 which I think we should encourage,
2:21:15 I think that to be a better trained
2:21:19 and understanding of the issued council person
2:21:22 for our city, the training is very important.
2:21:25 So I'm just wondering if maybe we say
2:21:30 that each council member has about $1,500
2:21:33 they could spend towards training per year
2:21:36 as long as it's city related, anything over and above that amount needs to come to council
2:21:42 for approval of the full council. Just thought, just a thought process. Keeping in mind that
2:21:48 we do have from time to time council members that have more need in the training and travel
2:21:56 than others. For example, right now we have two members of our council. They're very
2:22:00 active in the AIC in the board and I can see that that would take more revenue to get them
2:22:08 back and forth to meetings in life. Anyway, food for thought and I saw some lights come
2:22:12 on and I'm not sure who I was first. Great landing.
2:22:16 Yeah, I totally agree on the confusion. I remember my two years as mayor. I actually approved
2:22:23 someone's because I didn't do what else was the other process. I did there wasn't a process. So I
2:22:30 approved someone to go to a particular train because it looked like it was would be valuable for
2:22:35 their education as a council member. But I don't know that I felt like I had the authority to do so.
2:22:41 And so I agreed and I was going to bring up that other point. I certainly a dollar amount makes sense
2:22:47 with those in the audience that don't know that I'm the current first vice president of the AIC
2:22:54 and Suzanne is a board member and we are called the Boise not often but certainly on occasion
2:23:03 for lobbying of the legislature and also for board meetings and you know that's how it's always
2:23:13 I see the participating city's board members paid city pays their way and so I would but I wouldn't have any trouble at all if it was a flat amount we started getting over that while I would come in and say,
2:23:26 here's why I need more than the 1500 because the three we had this board we need and we had this we were called to voice you to lobby on this particular issue.
2:23:35 Yeah, that I actually kind of I really thought of doing it that way, but I kind of like that possibility that
2:23:41 You know, at least we have a starting point
2:23:44 And Rebecca, I know you next but before I forget I meant to say this to it
2:23:48 It would also give us an opportunity that in the lean years when we've actually cut travel and training for our staff members
2:23:56 It would be a place where we could cut our own as well to
2:23:59 to be in that same room of what we're asking our staff to do.
2:24:04 Rebecca, Mel, so I can.
2:24:05 Thank you, Mayor.
2:24:07 I think that's a great idea, you know,
2:24:09 the dollar amount per council member.
2:24:12 I actually had noticed in our budget the increase,
2:24:15 and it seemed like the percentage was quite large,
2:24:18 the increase for traveling meetings in our council budget.
2:24:21 And so I appreciate you bringing that up so that we know
2:24:25 why that is.
2:24:26 And so I think it's a good idea to still come to council
2:24:29 and kind of discuss those opportunities
2:24:33 because we still want to be very careful about,
2:24:36 you know, use of public funds.
2:24:38 And that might be another thing to talk about.
2:24:40 I notice in most departments, the travel and meetings
2:24:45 line item has increased significantly
2:24:47 in many departments.
2:24:50 And so I certainly support training,
2:24:53 but we have seen some many travel requests
2:24:56 come across our desk in the last few weeks.
2:24:58 And especially when you see a lot of far distance,
2:25:02 going to the east coast and hotels can really add up
2:25:05 at $250 a night.
2:25:08 And so I just want to make sure that we're being as
2:25:11 conservative as we can and getting the training that we need.
2:25:16 But when we can do it more in the northwest or more locally,
2:25:21 I think that that would be wise.
2:25:24 Thank you, Suzanne.
2:25:25 How can you agree?
2:25:27 I think it's a great idea.
2:25:28 mostly because it's going to make us be public with what training we're taking and
2:25:33 the citizens will be aware of what we're doing to further our education and
2:25:38 how their money is being spent so I think it's a great idea to make it public.
2:25:41 Okay. I think that we have sufficient input on that and
2:25:47 I at this point as we always promise we open up for public comment anytime we
2:25:52 talk about the budget and I think that we have Mr. Johnston out there ready and
2:25:57 willing to come forward. So, sir, the podium is yours. If you come forward and
2:26:02 [Muted for privacy: street address]
2:26:09 [Muted for privacy: street address]
2:26:17 [Muted for privacy: street address]
2:26:21 here through the meeting night, got a whole page full of stuff.
2:26:27 You referred to this, I don't know, I shouldn't say all this stuff, but get off my mind.
2:26:34 You talked about the Hotsey Park place, I've always known that it was the Warburg place,
2:26:42 because that was Warburg moving in storage property for, since Twin Falls was, was built,
2:26:51 And I think possibly it should be a little black.
2:26:57 The building that was there was one of the first buildings that got, I don't know what
2:27:01 happened to it, but that tin building was one of the first buildings in Twin Falls.
2:27:10 And that got, I guess, crunched and out to the dump.
2:27:14 But anyway, I know it's too late now, but I know all the budgets have probably pretty
2:27:21 well and said I need 500 pens and this stuff's all been written down and talking
2:27:28 about enforcement and stuff part of what I've got to say is concerned with
2:27:35 enforcement I hate to pay another 22 dollars a year for water and sanitation
2:27:44 and stuff because I just got my bill for my water and for the month of June was
2:27:55 like $75 and I upped my sprinklers for this month of July so I can try to put a new lawn
2:28:08 in last year.
2:28:11 Anyway, some of the enforcement, 4th of July, I guess we were supposed to call in a complaint
2:28:22 for noise.
2:28:24 A dog got killed, not in front of my place, but in front of Columbia, who was there for
2:28:30 an hour, an half after a cut killed.
2:28:34 The dog enforcement, one of the dog catchers showed up, along with a patrol car.
2:28:41 There was fireworks going up in the house just right next to where they were picking
2:28:46 this dog up.
2:28:47 As soon as they got the dog picked up, the dog catchers off, the policeman's gone.
2:28:55 I mean, these things were going.
2:28:56 I think it was a better display than what the city had.
2:29:01 I had better display in South Park area for 4th of July
2:29:06 than you guys had at CSO.
2:29:08 I'm not kidding.
2:29:10 I don't doubt you.
2:29:11 My neighborhood was on display as well.
2:29:14 So I've heard that anyway, I mean, anyway,
2:29:20 I could have walked just right there,
2:29:26 written at a hundred dollar citation, paid his wages that night, but he took off and went
2:29:33 someplace else cruising around with his air conditioner on it.
2:29:37 I guess, I don't know.
2:29:41 I think that the police department could invest in another radar gun and instead of having
2:29:53 this, I don't know how many they've got, but he could pay for it, they could pay for it,
2:30:02 And I would let them sit in my driveway, sit on my porch, and watch the cars.
2:30:10 They could sit there and just do it.
2:30:12 I don't know if they do traffic checks, but on in front of my house, today the county is
2:30:22 hauling gravel someplace.
2:30:25 They could have gotten there.
2:30:26 One of those county tracks for doing excess of 35 miles an hour in a 35-minute zone.
2:30:33 They were doing, I know, expert on climate and cars,
2:30:38 but I guarantee they were going faster than 35 miles an hour
2:30:42 in the block that after the sign was there.
2:30:45 Mr. Johnson, could I kind of help redirect you?
2:30:47 These, you're bringing up some complaints
2:30:51 or some concerns?
2:30:53 And stay with me for a minute.
2:30:55 I think that those could be addressed directly
2:30:57 to the police department.
2:30:58 They'd be more than happy to talk to you
2:31:00 about traffic enforcement, speed enforcement,
2:31:04 and fireworks and those kind of things.
2:31:07 So tonight we really want to talk about the budget.
2:31:10 Yeah.
2:31:11 Anyway, what I was getting at, the extra gun
2:31:18 would help pay the budget for increased fees or fines,
2:31:29 parking in the bicycle zone.
2:31:35 I think there's ordinance on park in there.
2:31:38 Please sit there.
2:31:41 Get the mama for parking there.
2:31:43 Anyway, anyway, I think we could watch our budgets
2:31:52 a little closer instead of having,
2:31:57 and I noticed all the heads of departments took off,
2:32:01 But instead of just giving an employee a new shovel,
2:32:05 because he broke his shovel handle,
2:32:07 he isn't it for a pry bar, and they came by the handle.
2:32:12 They came by the shovel.
2:32:14 Here's some of this stuff.
2:32:16 I've worked a few places.
2:32:19 Here's your shovel.
2:32:21 And they might give you another one,
2:32:24 but the second one you buy.
2:32:27 There's some of that kind of stuff
2:32:28 that I think I'm working for the city.
2:32:30 I'm working for the state, just give me another one.
2:32:33 I think there's too much of that stuff, and I think these department heads can kind
2:32:38 of watch some of that kind of stuff, and I mean, I will probably be back, but I appreciate
2:32:52 what you guys do in a way I've thought about running, but I would hate to be up there at
2:33:00 time.
2:33:01 I appreciate it and it's time to get out of here. We've been here long enough. I know you got stuff to do. I'm
2:33:10 hungry
2:33:12 I appreciate it, but I will try to get hold of get hold of that mr. Holland find out
2:33:22 Mr. Baxter and I
2:33:24 How you doing that thing so I do
2:33:28 Anyway, appreciate this time and I hope I've left a few things that maybe get you thinking
2:33:36 on what best poor retired people are thinking about.
2:33:41 But every little penny increase does hurt our pocketbook and yet I know when we want
2:33:47 the service that some of that was shown to us here, where it's down, is, I mean, you know,
2:33:58 It could be, it could be up with just a little more, maybe a little more friendliness or certain
2:34:10 things.
2:34:11 And I would be willing to meet with any of you and give you a little more, I've got
2:34:20 written down and a few more things that come to mind that I've seen in the 70 plus years
2:34:30 of living here and having grandparents and great grandparents sitting up on top of the
2:34:37 mountains before there was anything down here in this valley and being some of the first
2:34:45 people to invest in the community.
2:34:48 So thank you for your time.
2:34:50 Mr. Johnson, I just want to tell you, all seven members of this council, any time you
2:34:53 wanted to go out and have a cup of coffee and talk further, I know that all seven of us
2:34:59 would be more than when you do that hopefully I wasn't talking about doing
2:35:09 jail but I know that's Mr. Mine Jim mine he was
2:35:15 cheap you're getting the two of us confused okay yeah stay here for just a
2:35:26 because I know Greg Lanning has a comment or two.
2:35:28 Well, actually, I just had a question.
2:35:30 You asked us a question about fines
2:35:32 and the possible use of funding,
2:35:34 and that's a little scary topic,
2:35:36 because we do like to do public service.
2:35:38 We're at maybe for its good answer.
2:35:40 Where do the fines go that are collected
2:35:42 on fractions in the city of Twin Falls or Travis?
2:35:46 They come back to the city of Twin Falls.
2:35:48 Okay.
2:35:49 So I thought percentage for speeding goes to the stage.
2:35:52 That's correct.
2:35:53 Yeah.
2:35:53 general infractions for fireworks and those type of things.
2:35:57 A large significant part of the funding comes back to the city, unlike county and state.
2:36:03 Thank you, Mr. Johnson, again, I want to tell you, thank you come every year.
2:36:07 You give us input and we truly do appreciate that.
2:36:11 So thank you again for coming this evening.
2:36:13 Take care, sir.
2:36:14 Just to put fine revenue in perspective,
2:36:18 it's a $33 million tax-supported budget.
2:36:23 It's about $250,000 to $250,000,
2:36:26 a total revenue that we'll collect and find.
2:36:28 Okay.
2:36:29 Thank you.
2:36:31 Council, is there anything further?
2:36:34 Suzanne Hawkins.
2:36:36 Thank you.
2:36:37 I think everybody on the council got a copy
2:36:39 of the letter we received from attorney-led Stone last week
2:36:43 regarding work he had done on his light
2:36:49 that now we are taking out and replacing
2:36:52 and refinishing on Lincoln Street.
2:36:54 And I was just curious what the council's feeling
2:36:57 was on that letter and how we should proceed with that.
2:37:00 Because I don't think there's been any official reply
2:37:02 from any of us to him.
2:37:04 Well, I think first maybe we have,
2:37:05 Fritz, maybe you could share with us
2:37:08 the legal perspective of the letter from Mr. Stone.
2:37:11 Yeah, and in my review of it,
2:37:13 there's no legal obligation.
2:37:15 So I was living in others who wanted to look at it
2:37:18 from a fairness standpoint.
2:37:20 Thank you, sir.
2:37:21 a great lining.
2:37:22 Could I add on that one?
2:37:24 The fairness would actually be to the contractor because Mr. Stone has not paid the contractor.
2:37:29 That's over a year old and maybe he's just watching his taking care of his own guild about
2:37:33 not paying a bill by having us pay it for him.
2:37:37 The contractor who I spoke to has actually written it off at this point because he's
2:37:42 passed the lean state.
2:37:43 So if we did repay it, I want to make sure we're paying it to the contractor, not Mr.
2:37:48 Stone because the bill has not been paid.
2:37:50 I think if you read the fine print on his letter, he says that.
2:37:55 He says that this would like us to reimburse this contractor,
2:37:59 a curry concrete to see people have their own.
2:38:02 And I thought process of it happens,
2:38:04 it needs to come out of the grant.
2:38:06 And if there's any excess funds in the grants,
2:38:09 or do we not have that ability?
2:38:13 Travis is, you got a real concern looking at Travis on that one.
2:38:16 I can't do that, Travis.
2:38:18 So when we capture grant funds, we capture them
2:38:20 to the very specific purposes and very specific timelines.
2:38:23 My recommendation if the council wants to provide Mr. Stone
2:38:27 with or the contractor with $150 that he is requesting,
2:38:32 we do so out of an operational expense
2:38:36 in the existing budget.
2:38:38 Travis, Rebecca, may I second?
2:38:40 Thank you, Mayor.
2:38:41 Just my thoughts on the letter that we received.
2:38:44 I thought it was a reasonable request,
2:38:45 and it actually kind of made me wonder
2:38:48 how we had been communicating with the residents, it sounded like he was surprised to find construction
2:38:54 going on in front of his house and the light being replaced and I'm sure that we, I hope
2:39:02 that we had communicated to residents and maybe just the signals didn't quite get all
2:39:07 the way through but my thought was that it was a reasonable request for $150 and the work
2:39:14 that he had done on his light and the maintenance that he had been, you know, bearing the cost
2:39:21 of for the past several years, I find it a reasonable request and if it's, you know,
2:39:26 something we can do, then we should pay that.
2:39:31 But, and maybe you, Travis, have some information for me on how we're communicating with those
2:39:35 residents or in the past how we communicated with this.
2:39:38 So, I'm aware that he was aware because he actually stood up at Kiwanis and thanked the
2:39:43 members of the council for moving forward with the project.
2:39:46 So that was fairly clear indication to me that he was aware of the project.
2:39:53 In fact, I know that Mr. Stone was one of the 10 residential individuals that were consulted
2:39:59 at the project and a lot of the conversation that moved forward was a result of those conversations.
2:40:05 Okay, and so the work that he's requesting reimbursement for works for the contractors.
2:40:10 From the prior years.
2:40:11 Right.
2:40:12 done before the project on the street. Okay, that was my
2:40:16 understanding. And I thought that that was reasonable.
2:40:20 He could be stuck. Well, I'm very unfair on that, because I
2:40:23 thought that he was doing work before we set standards or the
2:40:28 official project. And that did curry concrete come in later and
2:40:33 do additional work. I want to make sure if we pay it's up to
2:40:37 the standard. My understanding is that he contracted with the contractor prior to us moving forward
2:40:48 with the grant project. And by coincidence, we actually selected the exact same contractor
2:40:56 through our process moving forward with the grant. The work that Mr. Stone had done, the
2:41:03 or the light was relocated to help with uniformity and consistency of the other lights.
2:41:09 And so, the work that Mr. Stone had completed was done in advance of the project receiving
2:41:15 the grant and moving forward and being awarded by the council.
2:41:18 But it's still to the standard that can be maintained?
2:41:21 We actually moved it to a, my understanding is that we moved it to a different location.
2:41:25 I believe we undid what he paid to happen.
2:41:27 Whatever it had been done, we removed and replaced.
2:41:30 That is correct.
2:41:31 Yep.
2:41:32 But it was, it was, I mean, Mr. Stone is one of the individuals that really did care
2:41:37 for that light in that area.
2:41:39 He took great pride in that light and maintained it over the course of the times
2:41:45 in which, you know, as we shared, the city was noticeably absent.
2:41:49 Great, huh?
2:41:50 Oh, I agree with Rebecca that, you know, this is probably the reason why he has one
2:41:55 of the ones that's been trying to keep, he has paid for electricity to keep a lit.
2:41:59 We are not going to under this project have enough money to like them.
2:42:02 He will continue to probably be paid for the electricity light.
2:42:05 As long as we pay the contractor and not Mr. Stone, because the contractor has not been paid.
2:42:11 And so I'm not willing to run a check to Mr. Stone, but I'm willing to write a check to the career concrete.
2:42:16 Good, I'd like to weigh in real quick.
2:42:19 Okay, I have I've known the Stone family for many years.
2:42:23 So I don't feel comfortable weighing in on whether or not the reimbursement happens.
2:42:27 I just wanted to make sure we had somebody in contact with him that it didn't fall through
2:42:33 the cracks basically because I knew there had been lack of communication.
2:42:37 So I'm going to not give an opinion on whether or not the bill should be paid.
2:42:41 Sean, did you want to weigh in?
2:42:44 Yeah, absolutely.
2:42:45 I'd love to.
2:42:46 You know, my concern is that if we pay the bill, then what happens next year when we get
2:42:58 the letter that says, well, I've been paying the electric bill on this light that's yours
2:43:02 for a year and I want you to pay me back for it, or two years down the road, or some day
2:43:08 when we decide we can figure out how to get this back on the city's electric bill.
2:43:13 And again, $150, I think, is a relatively negligible item that we should be dealing with.
2:43:25 And I think that I know the Stone family as well, and I would hope that they could chalk it up as a contribution to the community along with the upkeep of the light that they've done and move on with our day.
2:43:37 I just, it makes me nervous that we're setting some precedent to reimburse people 12 months after the fact when they pay the bill, because they don't want to pay the bill.
2:43:50 Well, just to respond to that again, back to that would be a contribution by current concrete.
2:43:57 It's obvious that the whole year has transpired, he's not planning on paying the bill.
2:44:03 So it would be a current concrete contributing to the city.
2:44:07 I think I didn't like the flavor of the letter, frankly.
2:44:14 I didn't like the, this is not negotiable, but beyond that emotion.
2:44:22 I think we should pay Curry Concrete and move on.
2:44:25 It's $150.
2:44:26 I am somewhat concerned about a president,
2:44:28 but I think it would show good form
2:44:33 if we went ahead and paid that Curry Concrete.
2:44:39 I don't think we need a motion or a vote.
2:44:41 I think the majority, do you have enough direction?
2:44:44 Trustee?
2:44:47 Thank you.
2:44:49 Reg Lanning.
2:44:50 I've just rather things for concern,
2:44:52 not going to have to say concern the thing.
2:44:54 I've had an excellent turnout at the Friends of Muni tournament over the weekend.
2:44:59 They ended up having two shotguns.
2:45:02 The first time we've had to have that two shotguns, that many more people.
2:45:06 The Hizki family brought in a bunch of people as well.
2:45:10 I think they had six or seven teams there that were in conjunction with
2:45:14 their tournament that they had on Friday for some other concerns.
2:45:21 But part of the reason they brought up to this particular tournament is that some of
2:45:26 the excess funds that are made above what we normally make are going to be used by the
2:45:30 Hisky family to put in a fountain behind the 18th Green in honor of their brother Sonny
2:45:37 who was killed in a military training accident between World War II and the Korean War.
2:45:44 And we already have a fountain that is no longer in use dedicated to him there at the
2:45:52 golf course already.
2:45:53 So we're just kind of taking that one out and moving it over and putting in a decorative
2:45:57 fountain for the course.
2:46:00 And the rest of the funds will, as usual, be used right back on the golf course.
2:46:06 Several table T boxes that will be replaced or improved, as well as some additional cart
2:46:13 pass all things that are capital improvements that will stay with the golf course for many,
2:46:18 many years and I was hoping Dennis would be here. He'd give us maybe a rough number on how much we
2:46:23 made on the tournament but it was again well turned out. It's mostly the golfing community,
2:46:29 the people who play at me, or Twin Falls Golf Club giving back to Twin Falls Golf Club.
2:46:36 One way you'd look at it is most of them just put a four person team together, each put up
2:46:41 50 bucks. It's like they're each paying a $50 extra Green's fee or
2:46:46 Season past just to help the place they play. That's one must I enjoy being there?
2:46:51 Thank you anything further from our city manager
2:46:55 Just a quick reminder we have the city picnic
2:46:58 Coming up
2:47:00 So that's going to be on the 31st
2:47:04 I always thought it was this one
2:47:07 with us this Wednesday. Sorry, ours is this Wednesday and then also have the
2:47:12 bump confusing two picnics. ours is this Wednesday, right? And then the band has
2:47:17 invited you guys to be part of the band picnic and to celebrate another great
2:47:25 year of the band on the 31st. So you have two picnics coming up. Remind me on the
2:47:30 city picnic do we are we supposed to bring a side dish or anything no just bring
2:47:35 yourself big not okay all right thank you try the same thing further from
2:47:39 council meeting closed
Download
- Transcript (text) 162 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 217 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 296 KB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, July 21, 2014. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:50:35.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
202351a18ab0ced6ac4e546d6bade5ccfd6c1275db0d31680262d6ea7c791c2f - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 3 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
cdd98fa6a3d52829deed3a6eab605f8ebf6305dde8dc7f2440ae87a92e7dbcd5
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file