OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, September 8, 2014

Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:00:00 And as always, we start our City Council meeting off with the Pledge of Allegiance, so those of you wishing to join us, please rise.

0:00:07 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:00:23 Welcome everyone.

0:00:28 We do have a quorum of the City Council, all seven members are here this evening.

0:00:33 Do we have any amendments to our agenda this evening?

0:00:36 There are no amendments this evening.

0:00:37 Thank you, sir.

0:00:39 And at this point, we always want to open it up to the public.

0:00:41 If there's anyone that would like to come and speak to the city council about any issue, unless it's on the agenda, obviously we'll give you a chance to talk about something that's on the agenda later.

0:00:51 So is there anyone from the public that would like to address the city council this evening?

0:00:57 Nobody's rushing for the podium again.

0:00:59 So we will move on to the consent calendar.

0:01:01 I'll turn that over to the council wishes.

0:01:03 Okay, so we will pull that off.

0:01:05 So I think do we have a motion pulled off just without.

0:01:08 Just make the motion without the.

0:01:11 Pables.

0:01:12 I'd like to make that motion.

0:01:14 I move that we pull item number one off the consent calendar.

0:01:18 Okay.

0:01:19 So we will pull that off.

0:01:21 So I think do we have a motion pulled off just without.

0:01:24 Just make the motion.

0:01:26 Without the.

0:01:27 Pables.

0:01:28 I'd like to make that motion.

0:01:33 And what?

0:01:34 Approved.

0:01:35 And approved the rest.

0:01:36 Sorry.

0:01:37 Apologies.

0:01:38 Well, I thought you were going to take it separately.

0:01:39 Do we have a second on that?

0:01:40 Second.

0:01:41 We have a motion on the floor by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Sean Berger to approve the consent

0:01:44 calendar, minus the payables.

0:01:48 Anything further on that motion council?

0:01:51 Sharon?

0:01:52 Roll call vote please.

0:01:55 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:01:56 Yes.

0:01:57 Jim Mann?

0:01:58 Yes.

0:01:59 Sean Berger?

0:02:00 Yes.

0:02:01 Chris Talking?

0:02:02 Yes.

0:02:03 Greg Lanting?

0:02:04 Yes.

0:02:05 Yes, Rebecca Mills, Saika. Yes motion passes seven to zero

0:02:11 Greg why my question would be if we're gonna look at that separately and

0:02:21 So

0:02:24 The City of Twin Falls pays its bills on a weekly basis most of our contractors and most entities will pay them on a monthly basis

0:02:31 And so delaying it for one week

0:02:34 Won't necessarily be a big deal

0:02:36 What we will do, though, is we will look to see if there are any things that may result in penalties.

0:02:41 And with those items with penalties, we'll go forward on what's called a prepay process.

0:02:45 You've seen that in the past, and that will go forward with a prepay in the event that there are any of those items.

0:02:53 But upon my review of the accounts payable, and I know that Sharon is here, and she assists,

0:02:57 I don't recall anything of being significant, there's some travel vouchers in there in those types of things.

0:03:06 but we can for training, we can award those through a pre-pay.

0:03:13 Susan Hawkins lights on so I'm assuming.

0:03:15 Yeah, I'm just curious, did I miss it somehow in my notes?

0:03:19 Because I never got any payables this week at all, and I would just.

0:03:23 I got it.

0:03:26 Mine, OK, so it must have been something with my sink,

0:03:28 because mine didn't come through.

0:03:30 Jim's did not work either, so I don't know what happened,

0:03:35 but mine did not come through.

0:03:36 looking at them right now, I've got them.

0:03:39 Okay, so it sounds like we have a plan.

0:03:43 We'll just move on with the agenda this evening,

0:03:45 and if you get a chance to look through it,

0:03:47 and the rest of us get the chance to do it,

0:03:49 maybe we can approve them before the end of the meeting.

0:03:51 But, or for next week.

0:03:54 Next item on the agenda is items under,

0:03:56 items for consideration.

0:03:58 The first item is request from Dr. Wiley Dobbs

0:04:01 on behalf of the Twin Falls School District,

0:04:04 asking the city council to waive building permit fees

0:04:07 For the three new schools and exchange, it will provide the city, the Sunway Soccer Complex.

0:04:14 I have Mitch speaking, but before Mitch speaks, we're going to have our city manager Travis Rathwaite.

0:04:19 Mr. Mayor, members of the council typically, this would be an item that the city manager would carry.

0:04:23 But since my wife is an employee with the Twin Falls School District, I've been advised by legal counsel to recuse myself from the conversation.

0:04:31 So Mitch Humpel will be taking that motion forward.

0:04:38 Thank you, Travis, and welcome, Mitch.

0:04:42 All right, so first thing I wanted to just clarify,

0:04:45 there's one quick correction.

0:04:48 The heading on the Stafford Fort says

0:04:50 there's three schools that we're asking

0:04:52 for the permit waiver on, and there's,

0:04:54 there are in fact three new schools,

0:04:55 but there's also an addition to Can you reach

0:04:57 in a remodel at Twin Falls High School.

0:05:00 And all five of those are discussed

0:05:01 and Dr. Dobbs' letter to the council,

0:05:03 so just wanted to make sure that we,

0:05:06 you all know that we know there's actually

0:05:08 five schools being requested here.

0:05:09 If we choose to approve this this evening,

0:05:12 we'll need to mention all five schools.

0:05:15 Is that, yes?

0:05:15 I would, I would.

0:05:16 Yeah, I would because there are all five projects

0:05:19 gonna be coming in in the next, in the short while there.

0:05:21 So, so I don't really want to take much of the thunder

0:05:26 from Dr. Dobbs here, so I'll briefly touch on a few things.

0:05:29 We do value a partnership with the school district.

0:05:32 We have a history of even building fees for the district.

0:05:37 It goes back long before I even started working here.

0:05:40 But what I can tell you is when the big ones have come in,

0:05:43 like this one here, and then seven, eight years ago

0:05:47 when Cambridge was built when we're talking

0:05:49 on significant numbers, we have brought those specifically

0:05:52 to the council to discuss, and that's what we're doing

0:05:54 here tonight again.

0:05:55 So with that, I've given you some information

0:05:59 in the staff report, I'm here to answer questions,

0:06:01 but I'd like to turn it over to Dr. Dobbs here

0:06:03 and make his request.

0:06:05 Thank you, Mitch, and welcome Dr. Dobbs.

0:06:09 Thank you, Mayor Hall, members of the City Council.

0:06:13 It's privileged to be here this evening.

0:06:15 I know you have a copy of my letter,

0:06:17 and I know that you know I'm here to request a waiver

0:06:20 of the building permit fees.

0:06:22 For the Northwest Elementary School,

0:06:24 we have a little map up here to show you where these will be located.

0:06:31 The East Elementary School, South Middle School, Canyon Ridge High School expansion, and the

0:06:37 Twin Falls High School renovation.

0:06:40 We estimate the fees for these projects to be approximately 295,000.

0:06:46 So it is significant as Mitch had mentioned.

0:06:50 However, the Twin Falls School District is not requesting a waiver of the development impact fees estimated to be about 180,000 dollars.

0:06:59 Money from the waived fees will provide needed funds for direct building costs.

0:07:07 In addition, and if the city would like, the district is willing to give up ownership of the Sunway Soccer Complex to the city and return for these waivers.

0:07:19 The appraised value of this land is $320,000, the appraisal came in at $8,000 per acre.

0:07:26 And although we are anticipating, we are anticipating a higher value in the upcoming auction.

0:07:34 So with that, I do have our Director of Operations Brady Dickinson here this evening.

0:07:39 We have Brad Wells, who is working with humble architects as, or with us on these projects.

0:07:48 you have a handout or my letter, a copy of my letter.

0:07:53 So really what I would like to do is just stand

0:07:55 for any questions you might have.

0:07:57 Council have any questions this evening?

0:08:02 Rebecca Milsoy.

0:08:03 Thank you, Mayor.

0:08:04 Thank you, Mr. Dobs.

0:08:06 We do appreciate our relationship with the school district.

0:08:08 And so I think that this request is a great request

0:08:12 and I support it.

0:08:14 I did have a question though.

0:08:16 You own some more property.

0:08:18 I think it's just the south of the Sunway Soccer Complex.

0:08:21 Is that correct or is it to the north?

0:08:23 I believe it's to the south.

0:08:25 The total acreage there in that area, I believe, is 88 acres.

0:08:30 And the soccer field takes up if memory serves me 40 acres.

0:08:37 And I believe it is the acreage that we would continue to have

0:08:41 and would be selling this south.

0:08:44 So you're correct.

0:08:45 OK.

0:08:45 And so then I was going to ask what your intentions are

0:08:48 for that property there, are you just to sell it

0:08:51 or are specific development intentions?

0:08:54 We are going, we do have plans to sell it

0:08:57 with the exception of about 12 acres,

0:08:59 which we will keep back for a future site

0:09:01 for possibly an elementary school.

0:09:04 Okay, the reason I ask is just,

0:09:06 I think that's a great location where we're looking

0:09:08 at replacing our city park.

0:09:11 We need a larger city park for our community

0:09:13 to gather, to maintain our community spirit,

0:09:16 to stay connected with each other.

0:09:18 And so I just thought that right there next to those soccer fields would be a great location.

0:09:22 So if there is an opportunity in the future for the city to partner with the school district,

0:09:28 for that being a possible location, I would certainly appreciate the consideration.

0:09:33 Thank you.

0:09:35 Chris, talking?

0:09:35 Well, this sure makes sense not only because we've done it in the past.

0:09:39 It doesn't make any sense for one government agency to take money from another agency and

0:09:45 out of one pocket and put in another when it all comes back to same taxpayers but I think

0:09:50 it's important as Dr. Dobbs alluded to earlier that the school district will be paying us

0:09:56 impact fees of an estimated $180,000 as a lot of new growth is also paying and this

0:10:03 of course goes to four areas, fire police, streets and parks and wrecks.

0:10:09 So, I think they're paying their way on the thing, and I would so move that we waive the fees for the amount approximating, what was it, $395,000?

0:10:24 Second.

0:10:25 Second.

0:10:26 We have a motion on the floor by Chris talking and seconded by Greg Lanning.

0:10:30 Greg Lanning.

0:10:31 Thank you. Thank you for your leadership in the community.

0:10:34 And thank you for getting that bond passed to keep our community building forward.

0:10:41 And I will certainly be supporting this.

0:10:43 And is it suddenly soccer complex is a very important portion of our park system,

0:10:48 and we take a look at it for any reason.

0:10:50 So we do, I just want to say thank you for bringing it forward this way.

0:10:54 Thank you.

0:10:56 Fritz.

0:10:57 I just want to make sure you didn't feel the size of the field.

0:11:04 Was that intended by the maker of the motion?

0:11:07 I'm not sure what, I didn't quite hear a press.

0:11:09 If you wanted to have that as an exchange for the soccer team.

0:11:13 Including the waiver in exchange for the soccer land.

0:11:18 Second, good with that.

0:11:19 Thank you, Fritz, for the clarification.

0:11:21 Thank you.

0:11:22 I wanted to state a couple things, Mr. Dobbs.

0:11:24 Dr. Dobbs, first of all, I think when Rebecca said,

0:11:27 replace the city park, I don't think you mean,

0:11:29 replace this in addition to the city park.

0:11:32 Exactly, yeah.

0:11:32 That's a bigger venue because the City Park will always be the core of our community and that's where the van shell is, but she's absolutely right.

0:11:40 Sometimes we struggle with the size of the City Park with how big our community is now.

0:11:45 And I guess I don't have much more to add other than thank you for your leadership and we do truly appreciate the relationship between the City and the school district.

0:11:55 We could not run our Parks and Rec programs without you and our community really thanks you.

0:12:02 So with that, I see no further light.

0:12:04 Sharon, roll call vote please.

0:12:09 Jim Mann.

0:12:10 Yes.

0:12:11 Sean Barrieger.

0:12:12 Yes.

0:12:13 Chris Hawking.

0:12:14 Yes.

0:12:15 Greg Lanting.

0:12:16 Yes.

0:12:16 John Hall.

0:12:17 Yes.

0:12:18 Rebecca Milsoyka.

0:12:19 Yes.

0:12:20 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:12:21 Yes.

0:12:22 Motion passes, 7-0.

0:12:23 Congratulations, sir.

0:12:24 And thank you again.

0:12:25 Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, I know every superintendent in the state, some of them

0:12:33 really well, so we just sort of well.

0:12:36 None of them enjoy to the level that we do,

0:12:38 the relationship that we have with our city,

0:12:42 with our county, with our college,

0:12:45 and it's just a real privilege and an honor to work

0:12:48 in an area that understands that it's a mutual benefit

0:12:51 to a whole community that governmental agencies

0:12:55 work together, so thank you very much.

0:12:57 Thank you.

0:12:59 You can't breathe too pretty loud.

0:13:01 I was just playing over it.

0:13:02 Next item on the agenda is request from Robert and Daphne Mallory on a proposal to form an advisory group that represents senior citizens in our community and encourages senior citizens to be engaged in city of Twin Falls activity and objectives.

0:13:20 We have Robert and Daphne, welcome.

0:13:22 Thank you, Mayor, members of the Council.

0:13:25 I go by Bob actually, Bob Mallory, this is my wife Daphne.

0:13:30 We have lived in Twin Falls for the past four years now, formerly we lived in Alaska,

0:13:37 and Virginia for a brief stint before settling here in Twin Falls.

0:13:41 My personal background, I'm a former television news anchor for ABC News, now I'm my professional

0:13:47 writer, speaker and trainer, and I'll let my wife give a brief introduction of herself

0:13:52 as well so you know who we are.

0:13:54 Just briefly I used to be an attorney and I now also do a lot of speaking and training

0:13:58 alongside my husband as well.

0:14:01 We have had a couple of preliminary conversations with Mayor Hall with Mr. Rothweiler and other

0:14:09 folks in the city and we're here tonight to encourage the council to start consideration

0:14:16 of forming an older adult or senior citizen advisory committee to the council to offer

0:14:23 advice and input on issues related to the city's senior community and we'll get into

0:14:29 the reasons why we think that's a good idea and then take some questions from you.

0:14:34 There are two models of senior advisory committees that other communities across the country use

0:14:41 in communities that have formed these.

0:14:45 The one that's more common is the one that we are not envisioning and that is a senior advisory

0:14:52 committee that provides oversight and delivers services to seniors.

0:14:57 That's not what we have envisioned.

0:15:00 We're picturing the alternative model which some communities have used or are using, which

0:15:07 is strictly the advisory model.

0:15:10 A committee such as this could carry out objectives like you should have in a handout in front of

0:15:16 you.

0:15:17 I'll go through those briefly.

0:15:18 Some of the things that a committee could do potentially study issues related to seniors,

0:15:25 retirees and their families, submit findings and recommendations to the council to improve

0:15:30 the quality of senior living and twin falls, foster and provide leadership and engagement

0:15:36 opportunities for seniors at the city level, provide strategic planning and advice related

0:15:42 to the increase of retiring baby boomers in twin falls, which I'll talk about more in

0:15:47 a moment, have the committee be an information resource for seniors, ensure representation of

0:15:53 the senior community at council meetings and on the committee,

0:15:57 examine housing options, transportation, mobility issues,

0:16:01 and other issues related to seniors,

0:16:04 and make recommendations to the council based on those.

0:16:08 What we envision from these initial talks

0:16:12 is a small advisory panel, possibly five to seven members,

0:16:16 made up of older citizens who are not directly affiliated

0:16:20 with any existing service providers or agencies,

0:16:25 and that's in order to avoid conflicting agendas

0:16:28 or duplicative services.

0:16:31 Why?

0:16:33 That's the first question that we always get

0:16:37 when we visit with people about this idea of why us,

0:16:41 because we're obviously not in that demographic yet.

0:16:45 We've got a couple of years to go.

0:16:48 The reasons for that, first of all,

0:16:51 We as a family, we are motivated by our faith to honor our elders in the community and because

0:16:57 of that, our family over the past year has gotten a lot more involved with the senior community

0:17:03 to win balls and become familiar with some of the issues that seniors face.

0:17:09 I personally grew up in a very rural community in Oregon.

0:17:13 There was no local government structure.

0:17:16 It was so rural.

0:17:17 The county government seat was more than 75 miles away.

0:17:21 So in emergency situations such as a wildfire or a flood, the seniors in the community, like

0:17:28 my own grandparents and others, were looked to for leadership and input to organize the

0:17:33 response to those events simply because of their years of experience.

0:17:38 And so I grew up in a community where the seniors and the elders were looked to for their leadership

0:17:44 and experience.

0:17:45 in a sense the government and for lack of a better term simply because they've been there

0:17:51 and done that and so they were looked to very much for their leadership in those situations

0:17:58 and I'll let Daphne talk a little bit about some of her experience in the past working

0:18:03 with seniors as well. Sure, I've had the opportunity, my grandmother was a community

0:18:09 lender, she did a lot of micro lending, I'm originally from Liberia and the seniors in

0:18:15 In our community, we're always esteemed.

0:18:17 They were, like my husband's background,

0:18:20 they were the quote unquote government of the community.

0:18:23 And so we both come from a background of understanding

0:18:26 the roles that seniors can't play

0:18:28 in terms of leadership.

0:18:29 Myself, I think I included in the packet

0:18:32 have done some legal services on behalf of elderly affairs,

0:18:35 for the Department of Rhode Island,

0:18:36 and have just been engaged on this issue

0:18:39 because I do believe that it is central

0:18:41 to any planning that we may look to in the future,

0:18:44 that we absolutely need to include the voices

0:18:46 of seniors in our community.

0:18:49 So that's kind of why us, because we know that's the first

0:18:52 question that people always have is why are you guys talking

0:18:55 about this?

0:18:56 We also have a newspaper column, the aging and Idaho column,

0:19:00 and we're going to have a radio show in the community here

0:19:03 shortly talking, strictly about senior issues

0:19:06 and senior living.

0:19:08 So that's why us.

0:19:09 So why should Twin Falls consider this idea?

0:19:14 The main reason is that we're seeing a major demographic shift across America and here

0:19:19 in Twin Falls as our baby boomer generation is reaching retirement age.

0:19:24 Just to give you one example, the Twin Falls Senior Center has seen its membership increase

0:19:31 from 398 seniors two years ago to more than 1,600 seniors this year.

0:19:39 Their membership has increased 400% in just two years.

0:19:42 So our boomers are starting to retire and as you know Southern Idaho is a pretty good

0:19:47 retirement destination as well so we have more seniors moving into the area.

0:19:52 So that's a big issue that's going to be impacting countries or communities rather across the country

0:19:58 for the next few years potentially for the next few decades and as that number of retirees

0:20:04 continues to swell our communities could be facing issues that we can't even foresee at

0:20:10 at this point, but this change to the makeup of Twin Falls

0:20:14 is coming, whether we like it or not.

0:20:18 We've included a couple of examples in the handouts

0:20:21 for you of other communities that have adopted similar advisory

0:20:26 committees, like the one we've described to you here.

0:20:29 Those are in O'Fallon, Missouri, and Irvine, California.

0:20:34 The Irvine Senior Citizens' Council quote

0:20:37 It advises the Irvine City Council on City Policy Matters that affect older adults and their families in Irvine.

0:20:44 Very simple.

0:20:45 The O'Fallon Senior Resident Advisory Committee is to advise the Mayor, City Council, and City Administrator regarding issues affecting O'Fallon's senior citizens.

0:20:56 The committee studies, assesses, and renders advice on plans and city programs related to seniors and brings forth issues and concerns to the city's elected officials in order to better serve senior residents.

0:21:07 So our belief is that an advisory committee of this fashion of seniors would provide valuable input

0:21:15 leadership and wisdom to the council and to future councils. It would offer a growing demographic

0:21:23 in our city, a seat at the table if their city government to better address the specific issues

0:21:29 and concerns of seniors. And we would be happy to take any questions.

0:21:34 Very good. Thank you. Chris talking to us on the concept is is real great. I apply that Bob and Daphne couple of specific questions

0:21:43 Are you seeking funding from the city of Twin Falls at this point for anything and second how second how does this proposed?

0:21:52 Advisory committee structure

0:21:54 Interface relate with the senior center of Federation and all of us on aging as

0:21:59 So the second question is basically the advisory committee model is not the services and program

0:22:09 model.

0:22:10 So we're not suggesting that seniors form a separate entity that would be overseeing services

0:22:15 of programs, far from it.

0:22:17 We're saying provide a place for seniors to have input on the strategic planning and

0:22:22 other growth goals of the city.

0:22:24 And so they would perhaps be a liaison to those existing entities but they're not in

0:22:30 any way providing services or overseeing services or so no funding required other

0:22:35 than maybe traveling to centers to promote their message and what's happening with the city I

0:22:39 suppose and the first question was I'm sorry I was actually about the funding it was okay no

0:22:45 funding required at this time thank you for your honesty council I've had the

0:22:54 pleasure of meeting with both Bob and Daphne along with our city manager and our public

0:22:59 information officer on a couple different occasions and and the vision that I

0:23:03 started seeing really started laying out almost like what we have a youth

0:23:08 council that is to advise the council but what I'm wondering we should do and

0:23:13 and just maybe some conversation here this is a great idea and we do not take

0:23:17 forming committees like we look at that very carefully so I'm wondering if we

0:23:22 should form a couple council people to start meeting with neither city staff

0:23:27 and or Bob Daphne to really start formulating to see what this could look like in formation.

0:23:34 Because again, I think that if we're going to form a committee or a commission,

0:23:39 it needs to be well thought out and well defined on the front end as best we could.

0:23:44 So I throw that out just for conversation to see if we get your input.

0:23:49 Great learning.

0:23:51 Yeah, I would agree, I think there's certainly an idea that I think is,

0:23:56 could and should have value to the city.

0:23:59 I noticed they looked at you like Chris every time they said,

0:24:02 but I thought it was good, correct?

0:24:05 No, I'm going to say anything.

0:24:10 I would think that would be an excellent idea, Mayor Hall.

0:24:14 Rebecca, may I second?

0:24:15 Thank you, Mayor.

0:24:16 I think this is a great idea as far as engaging the senior community

0:24:19 and really soliciting their input, which is something that we want to do as a city anyway.

0:24:25 My question for you guys might be in for the council, you know,

0:24:29 because really this committee could go either way.

0:24:31 I know when it becomes a formal committee of the city council, you know,

0:24:35 there are more requirements and a little bit more red tape.

0:24:38 And so maybe Travis, you can remind us what our formal committees,

0:24:43 I think they have to meet at least once a month or they have some sort of requirements.

0:24:48 So, really the meeting schedule can occur based upon the frequency and the need and what

0:24:56 we would do is we would set that up in Title II.

0:24:59 If it was once a month, it was twice a month, if it was once a quarter, we could set that,

0:25:05 then obviously they could have meetings above and beyond that and as needed.

0:25:12 In terms of formalized requirements, with the exception of the airport advisory committee

0:25:19 and the economic development ready teams and the youth council, the committee meetings meet

0:25:26 in here.

0:25:27 They meet in here so that it is a common and known location and it also is something that

0:25:34 can be televised, can be recorded, can be placed upon, we can stream it onto our website so

0:25:43 that others can participate. That does not necessarily mean that that has to occur. And

0:25:49 I think that the idea is, as I understood it, is not only to find the need, but also

0:25:55 to define that structure, right? How often? Where would they meet? What would that look

0:25:59 like I think the idea is one to have engagement and it may be the case that in order to get

0:26:07 true engagement we may have to leave the confines of a city council chambers and go to a different

0:26:14 location so that we're meeting with groups that have maybe a more familiarity or easily

0:26:23 more accessible than a city council chambers would be in some cases.

0:26:28 And they would need to keep minutes correct, someone would need to keep minutes.

0:26:31 Yes, so if this became a recognized advisory committee of the city,

0:26:37 what we would do is we would find the most appropriate department that you would fill and place this under.

0:26:45 And then we would have a member of our city staff assist and

0:26:49 coordinate with the members of the committee to construct agendas.

0:26:54 would provide staff time to assist in necessary research projects, doing meeting minutes and

0:27:06 the like.

0:27:07 Right.

0:27:08 Okay.

0:27:09 So thank you.

0:27:10 I want you to maybe think about how you envision your group to, you know, if you want

0:27:13 to be more project based or issue specific focus, that will allow you more flexibility

0:27:22 to kind of just come in.

0:27:23 And I mean you don't have to be an official codified committee or

0:27:28 advisory group to provide input to the city council or to form this action group,

0:27:32 which I really appreciate that you're taking the time to form and

0:27:37 putting energy behind this focus on senior citizens.

0:27:43 I just don't want you to be bogged down by our process because I know we've had

0:27:48 kind of our golf advisory committee sometimes, you know, they don't need to meet as much as

0:27:53 they, you know, are required to by the code that they're under. But again, like Travis

0:27:59 said, you know, each committee kind of sets its own schedule but would love to, you know,

0:28:07 find out maybe what the council would like and what the group would like. But please know

0:28:11 that you don't have to form a formal committee just to have input. We have a lot of action

0:28:17 groups within the community that kind of form on their own, and then they're free to meet

0:28:21 where they want and that sort of thing.

0:28:25 Maybe you could address that because I know that in our conversations you're really looking

0:28:29 at more formalization, correct me if I'm wrong.

0:28:33 That's correct.

0:28:34 No, I definitely appreciate what you stated.

0:28:37 We're looking at providing not only a leadership opportunity for the seniors, but for the city

0:28:42 itself to make that statement that they're not invisible, that their issues are important,

0:28:47 they do have a seat at the table and that's why we were pursuing government

0:28:51 versus a community group or some other ancillary service. So I guess really the

0:28:58 question to council first of all is are we interested in at least marching down

0:29:03 this direction and secondarily if we are maybe we should put together some folks

0:29:08 to start exploring it and bring us back ideas really try to vet out all these

0:29:12 questions that we might have how formal it needs to be if it needs meet

0:29:17 monthly if we could put in that that it can meet wherever it needs to meet whether

0:29:22 that's in the senior center one week and bowling alley the next week that wherever

0:29:26 wherever we see the need to meet with the seniors so that's kind of what I was

0:29:33 thinking but I'd like to have some input from council on that. Chris talking to

0:29:37 our strategic plan certainly verifies what Bob and Daphne alluded to that the

0:29:42 Net immigration to this area is substantially retard people moving back to their families

0:29:48 or the quality of life.

0:29:49 So if you're right on target, I was surprised that senior federation is quadrupled.

0:29:55 I think you said they're membership because they're a stable institution for one of the

0:30:00 first times in a while and so that's good to hear.

0:30:04 I don't think the council should get on the way too much of what we expect of them.

0:30:11 I think the youth commission probably be inadequate template and I would look forward to them kind

0:30:17 of be driven by their own needs and what they see as the priorities and us to stay out and

0:30:22 see what we can learn from our elders.

0:30:25 Thank you, Chris.

0:30:27 Dr. I think continuing to explore the opportunity is certainly of value.

0:30:34 Maybe along with the strategic plan, we talk a lot about partnerships in there and different

0:30:39 organizations and entities that we might be involved in. And while I appreciate the concept

0:30:44 of not having, I don't want to call them competing organization, that maybe more service-driven

0:30:49 organizations that serve the same group, maybe on that committee. I do think it's important

0:30:55 to try to figure out how to partner with them. This would include, I mean, certainly healthcare

0:31:00 services, the office on aging, the senior center, and others. So I think maybe in the

0:31:04 expiration phase it's worth talking to those folks to about maybe gaps that they

0:31:11 see that that maybe this advisory group could address. I want to create

0:31:17 something that's competitive with or duplicate services that are already

0:31:21 available but I don't want to exclude all those folks to make them think well

0:31:26 we're coming in and creating something that's going to do a better job than you.

0:31:29 I would really love to have a couple volunteers that said they would work

0:31:41 I would like to be a volunteer to work alongside with Bob and Daphne their daughter is part of our youth council so they are active in other parts of our city they know how we meet and what we're up to so I feel like it's a great step and I would

0:31:57 like to see where it leads.

0:32:00 Okay.

0:32:01 There's one.

0:32:03 Thank you.

0:32:04 I'll volunteer.

0:32:06 We have Suzanne Hawkins and Greg Lenten that will volunteer to start working with the two of you.

0:32:11 I don't think we need to necessarily make a motion regarding that.

0:32:14 We've got a couple volunteers and I think they start meeting.

0:32:18 You know, in just because of the fact that we did pass resolution and any time in which we're going to create a committee,

0:32:25 I think that there should be just the formality of creating to for that insurance.

0:32:30 Because we said that any group of councils that will come back to advise the council in the future should be formally recognized.

0:32:36 It might be appropriate to have a formal recognition.

0:32:40 Okay, by that, thanks.

0:32:41 Thanks.

0:32:42 So moved.

0:32:46 We have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanting, seconded.

0:32:49 Vice-Mousin-Hockens to have Greg Lanting as his head hockey,

0:32:54 placed on a committee to work with Bob and Daphne Mallory

0:32:59 in the exploration of a senior advising group or committee.

0:33:04 Anything further on that motion council?

0:33:06 Sharon Rokolbo. Sean Bericher. Yes. Chris talking. Yes. Greg

0:33:14 Lanting. Yes. Don Hogg. Yes. Rebecca Milsoka. Yes. Suzanne

0:33:20 Hawkins. Yes. Jim Munn. Yes. Motion passes seven to zero. And I

0:33:25 look forward to the report coming back to us and thank you both

0:33:29 for the energy and time that you're putting into this. Thank you

0:33:32 Well, thank you very much.

0:33:34 Take care.

0:33:34 Thank you.

0:33:35 Say hi.

0:33:37 Oh, Suzanne Hawkins?

0:33:38 I just, I believe you guys have my email address and, and Greg's is on the city website

0:33:42 as well if you want to send us information on when you'd like to get together.

0:33:45 That'd be great.

0:33:46 So, Suzanne.

0:33:47 Thank you.

0:33:48 Greg just said he assumes Suzanne has become the chair.

0:33:53 At least on the city council side of things.

0:33:57 I don't think any of you will be shy about your opinions in this.

0:34:00 Next item on the agenda is request from the Twin Falls High School to remove a tree located

0:34:06 at the city slash YMCA swimming pole.

0:34:08 We have Mike Federico from the Twin Falls High School.

0:34:12 Nope, welcome.

0:34:13 Mr. Mayor, thank you members of the city council.

0:34:15 Appreciate your time in dealing with this issue.

0:34:19 Really this issue came about in 2012.

0:34:23 About every four years we're fortunate enough to be able to host the Iowa High School Activities

0:34:27 Association State Tournament at our facility.

0:34:30 We've got a great facility, thanks to a lot of work from the city and our coaches over

0:34:35 the years.

0:34:36 One of the issues that we face is adequate seating.

0:34:39 If you look behind the two back stops there, there's the building that's our concession

0:34:43 stand.

0:34:46 As we've hosted more and more tournaments, the area behind the seating, for seating has

0:34:52 really been a detriment to our ability to host these tournaments.

0:34:56 It's one of the things that, when we get feedback from the IHSAA, that we need to improve.

0:35:03 So our coach had an idea of moving the concession stand over where the circled tree would be,

0:35:08 would get it out of the area, we could add more seating, therefore be able to continue

0:35:13 to host these tournaments and things like that.

0:35:16 So I called Dennis at the city and he said they had been working on the same thing.

0:35:21 We don't want to just kill trees.

0:35:23 It's really limited in the space that we have.

0:35:27 We have a capacity to possibly add trees somewhere else

0:35:31 or to that effect, we raise money, but that space is

0:35:35 ideal for us to put our concession stand,

0:35:40 is what we're looking at. There are a lot of trees on the other side.

0:35:44 I know it's an important shade area. We've also talked about making that

0:35:48 a picnic type area where we could maybe provide some shade,

0:35:52 of a shelter or something to cover a seated area alongside the concession area, the district

0:36:01 would be responsible for moving the fence and all those kind of things in that area.

0:36:06 That's a request.

0:36:07 Questions?

0:36:09 I can move so I can.

0:36:10 Thank you Mayor.

0:36:11 Thank you Mr. Federico.

0:36:13 Had the privilege of being a student of Mr. Federico a few years ago, so.

0:36:17 Is that a conflict?

0:36:20 Not anymore.

0:36:23 But I was at the pool Friday and so I just happened to go over and look at the tree.

0:36:29 Whose property is it on?

0:36:30 Is that the city's property or do you have a schematic or something showing where you

0:36:35 want to replace the concession stand?

0:36:38 School district property is the entire.

0:36:40 Okay, so this is school district property.

0:36:42 The concession stand would go right next to the fence that is outside of this fence right

0:36:51 here.

0:36:52 That's where the front of the concession stand would be.

0:36:56 it would go back 15 feet here.

0:36:59 This area all in here, Dennis was talking about,

0:37:02 they were going to do some of that.

0:37:03 I'm not sure if you still plan on it.

0:37:06 We're going to concrete all that area.

0:37:08 Yeah, when they were going to remove the tree,

0:37:09 they were going to concrete this area.

0:37:11 We, if they're not going to do that,

0:37:15 we would probably keep it as grass

0:37:16 and create something as a shaded area there.

0:37:22 So that would open up all this space here

0:37:24 for bleachers in these areas behind there.

0:37:27 Okay, so this is your property, I mean, this is,

0:37:30 but you're asking the city if you can remove the tree.

0:37:33 I think the city's tree.

0:37:34 Okay, we own the tree on the school's property.

0:37:37 Okay.

0:37:38 I'm not sure who owns the tree.

0:37:40 I can't do this to find out if we can just cut it down.

0:37:42 You said, well, we better not, because we're not sure

0:37:46 who owns the tree, or who put the tree.

0:37:49 Because I think if memory serves me correctly,

0:37:52 this is our, the school district's property,

0:37:54 but the city did all the backstops.

0:37:56 We did the dugouts and things like that.

0:37:58 It's been a cooperative agreement to make sure this facility was built.

0:38:06 Travis, did you have more?

0:38:08 The city pool sits on property and the surrounding property.

0:38:14 Sits on property that is owned by the Twin Falls School District.

0:38:17 And the city has its assets in a long term lease arrangement

0:38:24 that we have with the school district moving forward.

0:38:27 Part of the reason that this is before you is because when we are having the conversation

0:38:32 as Mr. Federico had alluded to in terms of the tree and the conversations, as you recall,

0:38:39 prior budgeting conversations, this tree became one of the focal point of past budgeting conversation

0:38:45 as to whether or not it should be removed.

0:38:48 And we felt it was important because of that conversation that this issue come before the

0:38:54 City Council and the City Council have the opportunity to weigh in.

0:38:59 Okay.

0:39:00 Thank you.

0:39:01 Actually, that makes so much more sense now.

0:39:02 When I was standing there, I was thinking that that fence that's currently there was dividing

0:39:06 city property from the school district property and now that that information really helps

0:39:12 me.

0:39:13 I don't have any, just to add a thought on this tree, I don't have any particular affection

0:39:18 for this tree.

0:39:19 But I do like trees in general, and in light of the codes that we have just passed for landscaping parking lots,

0:39:27 I would hope that we would be able to replace this tree in some fashion and maybe to the right or to the left of whatever you're using for your space.

0:39:37 I think it would be a nice touch because there is that berm of trees on the north side of the pool.

0:39:43 looks very nice and then kind of just the sea of parking lot and the one lonely tree

0:39:47 on on the pool side. And I would say there's room in that area for the concession stand

0:39:52 and to replace a tree on the other side of that in discussion with Dennis we do want to

0:39:59 be careful of what kind of tree because it is close to the foundation of the pool and the

0:40:03 routing system we want to make sure that that I would think doesn't affect that at all so

0:40:08 So we would have to coordinate that, I'm sure.

0:40:10 Great, thank you.

0:40:11 Jim, ma'am?

0:40:14 Turn on.

0:40:15 So I guess, is this just like a political discussion here?

0:40:19 Because do we have any, I question whether we even

0:40:23 have jurisdiction here.

0:40:24 It's their tree to cut the tree down.

0:40:26 If you want to cut the tree down.

0:40:29 I mean, how are we going with this thing?

0:40:30 Because you may be way in on it.

0:40:33 So this is school district owned property,

0:40:36 but held under long term lease by the city.

0:40:39 So I guess technically the school district

0:40:44 just can't come in and.

0:40:45 Okay, well that's a great.

0:40:46 Okay, so we do have jurisdiction.

0:40:48 We are leasing the tree.

0:40:49 We are the lessee long-term lease, and I don't know.

0:40:55 Like a 99-year deal?

0:40:56 It's a 99-year lease, and we probably have eight.

0:41:00 80-some-odd years to go?

0:41:01 Yeah, yeah.

0:41:02 So virtually the owner.

0:41:04 So we should be, okay, let me see if I can go,

0:41:08 I hit around this.

0:41:09 I own a house that I lease to Fritz Wonderlick, and I decide as a homeowner that I want to go cut a tree down in the backyard.

0:41:20 Do I have to have the lease or permission?

0:41:25 I don't like that example.

0:41:29 Why not?

0:41:32 Well, because under a 99-year lease, you are virtually the owner with the idea that in

0:41:38 a hundred years it's going to go back to the original owner, but in the meantime you can

0:41:42 do whatever you need to do with it, so long as you don't devalue the property. The tree

0:41:47 is, I don't know, along the tree glass.

0:41:50 I just did, but the tree will be probably dead and gone before the lease runs out, so

0:41:57 it's probably not an issue for the school district.

0:41:59 I just kind of wonder if we're majoring in the minors here a little bit, so.

0:42:04 Chris, talking to him.

0:42:05 Well, I wonder if we can play a little bit of Solomon and split the baby, so to speak.

0:42:09 And why can't we trim the lower limbs in that tree up, keep it there and allow you to put

0:42:15 a concession stand in, wrap it around in a very innovative artistic way.

0:42:20 I don't see any damage of the tree roots on the curbside there, and I think that's closer to

0:42:27 the curb mark and it is the swimming pool.

0:42:31 I think the issue is to the east side of it, closest to the softball field, that is to closest,

0:42:41 that's where it's closest.

0:42:42 And that's where it's closest.

0:42:43 To get the size of it, it wouldn't fit.

0:42:44 Like I said, we could move or we could re-plan a different tree more to the west on the end

0:42:50 of the blocked area there.

0:42:52 See how it's the closest?

0:42:53 Well, you planted a 75 foot tree like that one.

0:42:56 We can't find a 75 footer right now, but this root system is real close to that fence,

0:43:01 and it wouldn't fit in there.

0:43:02 I want 40 footer off to the side, but one off to the side.

0:43:07 You know, planning a little twig is not a replacement.

0:43:09 It would take forever to get a comparable thing.

0:43:12 We do want to make sure and keep the area nice.

0:43:15 I mean, it's not something that we want to just take out.

0:43:19 We do want to have, make sure that all the ball field and the city area is part of the

0:43:24 the beautification process is just right in the way.

0:43:28 Now let's put in my two bits.

0:43:30 Great line.

0:43:32 Mr. Federico, one just a little information on the tournament.

0:43:36 Is it all four, all four classifications are here,

0:43:39 or are some at Canyon Ridge, or was it?

0:43:41 Just here.

0:43:41 All right, there are.

0:43:42 Just one classification of it.

0:43:43 Oh, one classification, all right.

0:43:44 That makes sense.

0:43:45 I was thinking of all the classifications, all right.

0:43:50 Like Chris, I guess what to do since I hate to see it leave,

0:43:53 But I also see that their Tunesville School District

0:43:57 is the owner, and I sense our Parks Department

0:44:00 already asks us to take it out.

0:44:03 I think that I'm gonna fall on the side of taking it out,

0:44:06 but please let's work to put in,

0:44:08 work with the school district and our Parks Department

0:44:13 to put in as large a tree as possible to replace it

0:44:16 so that we're at least providing the shade

0:44:19 that some of the letters that we received

0:44:21 from swim teams and things knowing that there's need of shade in general because shade on

0:44:28 the north side of a pool really doesn't do much. Probably something we should have thought

0:44:32 of a long time ago, maybe with the parking should have gone on the other side. But the

0:44:36 parking is also shared for use by the softball field so it obviously needs to be on the side.

0:44:41 I will be voting in favor of paying out the tree as long as we're replacing it with as

0:44:46 as large a tree as possible.

0:44:50 I gotta tell you, I'm struggling with this one

0:44:52 because really because of some of these letters

0:44:56 that we've received about the value of the shade

0:45:00 and the tree being there, it's really difficult for me

0:45:03 to justify cutting down and mature a tree

0:45:06 that provides that much shade to put in a concession stand

0:45:10 and then plan a smaller tree that will,

0:45:12 like Chris had it take 10, 20 years to get to this level.

0:45:16 So I'm really struggling with supporting this, just to let you know.

0:45:20 Jim.

0:45:21 I move to allow the school district to remove a tree from their property.

0:45:24 We lease from them for 99 years.

0:45:27 Second.

0:45:28 I have a motion on the floor by Jim.

0:45:29 I'm seconded by Greg Lanting to remove the tree.

0:45:34 Move to amend that that taking down the tree.

0:45:38 Chris, I already have a light.

0:45:39 So I'll let you go next after that if you'll turn your light on.

0:45:42 Rebecca.

0:45:43 Perhaps this is your amendment.

0:45:44 But, Chris, I was going to move to amend that the tree be replaced with as large a tree as possible to provide shade.

0:45:52 And that they work with parks, not officially in the amendment, but you work with parks and rec.

0:45:58 As you stated, there are types of trees that will work better planted next to pavement.

0:46:03 And so that it won't disrupt that pavement over the years.

0:46:06 I have a amendment to the main motion from Rebecca Milsoyka seconded by Chris

0:46:12 talking to replace the tree at a different location close by right as mature as

0:46:22 possible for that location. Question to the motion maker in the second

0:46:26 Chris did you say who was going to pay for that?

0:46:30 school district well it's got to be in the motion paid for by the school district

0:46:36 very good you good with that second you know that so paid for by the school

0:46:42 district anything further on the amendment we can certainly have you come

0:46:50 up Dennis just wondering if this motion passes exactly where I think that's a

0:47:01 Good question, Dennis.

0:47:02 I'd like to know because they're looking to remove the tree.

0:47:04 They're not to plant a tree in that area.

0:47:06 That's why I would not recommend to put a tree back in that area.

0:47:10 And if the swim team's looking for shade,

0:47:11 and put it somewhere in this area,

0:47:13 this is normally their games, or might say,

0:47:18 this is kind of a way of mission to get into their games.

0:47:20 So the better it's done to someone, it's open up.

0:47:24 Yeah, OK.

0:47:25 Excuse me.

0:47:25 I was just thinking, it might be a little tough

0:47:27 to get a tree in this area here just because of narrow ways.

0:47:31 You know, one of the reasons that we are originally looking

0:47:34 at to remove this tree, because we know someday this roof's

0:47:38 going to be buckling up the deck of the pool.

0:47:40 We don't know when, but it will happen.

0:47:43 So that's why, originally why we were looking at to remove

0:47:45 the tree in the first place.

0:47:47 You know, a replacement tree, you know, it's going to be,

0:47:50 like I said, it's going to be tough to put it

0:47:51 in this location here.

0:47:53 You don't want to put it inside here,

0:47:54 looking for shade, because the leaves,

0:47:56 we don't want that in the pool.

0:47:58 And so why, we don't have any trees in this grass area

0:48:00 directly north, but that's why part of our special use permit when the pool was built,

0:48:04 we had to have trees in this area here.

0:48:06 So location is going to be tough to get a tree close to this current location.

0:48:14 So you've just blown away the amendment.

0:48:16 I know, sorry.

0:48:17 Well, and maybe I would ask, since I made the amendment, maybe I'd ask Mr. Federico because

0:48:21 you mentioned that in replacing you might have some sort of table area where you would

0:48:26 put a tree.

0:48:27 Yeah, I would say we would.

0:48:29 So I would really leave it up to you.

0:48:30 So I would really leave it up to you.

0:48:31 So I would really leave it up to you.

0:48:33 So I would really leave it up to you.

0:48:34 So I would really leave it up to you.

0:48:35 So I would really leave it up to you.

0:48:36 So I would really leave it up to you.

0:48:37 So I would really leave it up to you.

0:48:38 So I would really leave it up to you.

0:48:39 So I would really leave it up to you.

0:48:40 So I would really leave it up to you.

0:48:41 So I would really leave it up to you.

0:48:42 So I would really leave it up to you.

0:48:43 So I would really leave it up to you.

0:48:44 So I would really leave it up to you.

0:48:45 So I would really leave it up to you.

0:48:46 So I would really leave it up to you.

0:48:47 So I would really leave it up to you.

0:48:48 Is there anywhere that you would want a tree and because we just said nearby?

0:48:53 For shade for the people watching the game or shade for

0:49:04 No trees out there and that would be an adequate spot. I'm not sure

0:49:08 Genesis plan for out there, but there's nothing out in this area here. I think we didn't put trees there because

0:49:15 Possibility of leaves going on the tennis courts

0:49:17 There's a space from about 20 yards here that the tennis courts

0:49:21 wouldn't be affected as much compared to the rest of the row.

0:49:26 Well, just to me that's not nearby, that doesn't meet the intent.

0:49:31 From what I can see, the two of you made the motion.

0:49:34 To your motion. Mike, what about the first base there on that bottom diamond?

0:49:38 Just passed the dugout. Right here. Yeah, somewhere in there.

0:49:43 Well, this is a row of trees right here we have now.

0:49:47 out. This is about 15 feet and this is a major walk path to all of our equipment

0:49:53 in our hitting areas down here. Most of this during the season is used for

0:49:57 seating so I think we run into the same issue that we take up all of our seat.

0:50:04 This area down here is not as much but again the gate for the pool is right

0:50:11 in here where they get to the shaded area. This from this area I mean I know in the

0:50:19 letter from the Marlins they talked about where if their officials of the swim meet primarily

0:50:25 use this area. I think the swimmers and things use this area and the officials had this area.

0:50:32 So this is about a 30 yard walk. Nearly as convenient as this, I agree, but it's much

0:50:40 much bigger area and multiple trees there.

0:50:46 So just one more question, where your concession.

0:50:48 Rebecca, we're moving on to someone else who can put you like back on a few bucks.

0:50:52 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:50:53 Thank you.

0:50:54 I appreciate the value of a tree in the shade, but this is a multi-use recreation area.

0:51:01 And we do have trees to the north.

0:51:03 If this maybe a compromise could be instead of planting another tree,

0:51:09 Like you said, building some kind of shelter in that area where there's still shade for

0:51:13 the people when they need it, but the tree isn't going to interfere with the other events

0:51:17 going on in the area.

0:51:19 And if as the motion plays out, we'll see how it goes.

0:51:22 I would be very supportive of a shelter in replacement of the tree.

0:51:28 Dennis, can I ask you a question?

0:51:31 I know that you say that you're worried about that location because the buckling of the pad.

0:51:36 But aren't there trees that provide shade that have less propensity to buckle concrete?

0:51:45 I know that we talk about that for downtown, having certain kind of trees alongside walks

0:51:50 in the line.

0:51:51 There are, you know, I couldn't tell you which ones they are, you know, there's pine tree

0:51:55 looking back at it, you know, we should have never planted, like I mentioned before, never

0:51:58 should have planted that tree.

0:51:59 Pine trees are known to be aggressive that way.

0:52:03 But I would have to just do a little more research on that because to see if you could put a tree

0:52:10 back in that area where hopefully in 30 years we don't have to worry about the roots there

0:52:17 because the lease started probably, well, the pool was open up in 89 so I'd say the tree

0:52:22 was planted sometime in 89 so it's been there for 25 years so far.

0:52:27 I have another light on but as the motion stands right now what I'm hearing, the motion,

0:52:32 amendment to the main motion is plant another tree nearby and I don't think

0:52:37 out by locus is nearby me so we're either going to have to adjust this

0:52:43 eventually or depends on what's going to fall down fall with both of these motions.

0:52:47 Jim I just want to make an argument that given what Dennis has now told us that

0:52:53 this tree is going to start causing infrastructure and structural damage to

0:52:57 that swimming pool in the future, why would we cause the school district to fix something

0:53:03 that's been there as part of our lease and that we would be taking it out anyway that's

0:53:07 going to cause us infrastructure problems.

0:53:10 We're asking them to fix something that is on our property that, I don't know if we planted

0:53:15 the tree or not did the city plant the tree, the city plant, so we planted a tree that is

0:53:20 causing damage to our property and now we're going to ask the school district to replace

0:53:24 it for us.

0:53:25 I submit, that's absolutely unfair.

0:53:28 Do we have anything further on the amendment, Council?

0:53:32 Sharon?

0:53:34 Roll call vote on the amendment.

0:53:36 We need to clarify what the amendment is.

0:53:38 The amendment is to replace the cut down tree nearby at the expense of the school district.

0:53:52 Thank you.

0:53:53 Okay.

0:53:54 What's that?

0:53:55 Yeah, yeah, and large of a tree as possible, basically.

0:53:58 So there's definition of nearby?

0:54:01 No, and that's why I asked, you know,

0:54:04 I mean, it would really be up to your plan

0:54:07 and what works for you and what will work for the school

0:54:08 district, or for Dennis and Parks and Rec,

0:54:12 really up to your discretion.

0:54:16 Is that what the second wanted from that motion?

0:54:19 Oh, sure.

0:54:21 OK, so nearby could be over on Filer Avenue, apparently.

0:54:26 So I'll just make mention of that.

0:54:29 She's sharing the role both of them, please.

0:54:34 Greg Lanting?

0:54:35 No.

0:54:36 Don Hall?

0:54:37 No.

0:54:38 Rebecca Milsoyka?

0:54:40 Yes.

0:54:42 Suzanne Hawkins?

0:54:44 No.

0:54:45 Jim Mann?

0:54:46 No.

0:54:47 Sean Berriger?

0:54:48 No.

0:54:49 Chris Cockington?

0:54:51 Yes.

0:54:52 Motion fails five against him.

0:54:56 Two, four, and that was the amendment.

0:54:58 Now on to the main motion.

0:55:03 Oh, please, Chris, talking to know Greg,

0:55:11 Lanting. Yes, Don Hall. No, Rebecca,

0:55:16 Miel, so I got no Suzanne Hawkins.

0:55:21 Yes, Jim, mine. Yes, Sean,

0:55:25 very good. Yes, motion passes four to

0:55:27 three. Lively debate. Thank you,

0:55:32 lots of luck. I hope you have a clear

0:55:33 direction. Well, it's to remove the

0:55:37 Next item on the agenda is request from Lea Babayon and Lea, you're going to have to tell me if I said that right, representing a group of downtown Twin Falls business owners to make changes to the downtown parking regulations and parking pass rates.

0:55:56 Lea, welcome.

0:56:10 Thank you. It's Lea Babayon, but you got it close.

0:56:14 Tom from Moose Hill is going to be Tom Newman.

0:56:19 Noonam is going to be talking on behalf of downtown merchant collective.

0:56:24 Thank you. Welcome Tom.

0:56:26 As you know, downtown is picking up.

0:56:31 We have more folks coming in.

0:56:33 It's looking awesome.

0:56:34 Now we got that rejuvenation plan going on.

0:56:38 That's looking awesome.

0:56:39 We do have parking issues which every city seems to have.

0:56:43 But we would like to ask that we need to change some parking if we could

0:56:52 As far as timing now the up front being in Main Street both sides of me is to our parking

0:56:58 That's ample enough people can come in go grab a drink

0:57:03 Maybe get their nails done something like that that's ample

0:57:06 But the back parking for the folks who want to do some long-term parking to go grab a bite get their hair down do some shopping

0:57:14 And three hours just does not seem long enough, so we are asking to lengthen the three hour

0:57:20 free parking back in the back to four, four and a half, five hours, four hours what we

0:57:26 have on the paper.

0:57:27 We have had customers come into every store stating that they're spending money downtown,

0:57:33 which is what we want.

0:57:35 But then they go out to their car and they have a ticket.

0:57:38 And then they come back in and they tell us they got a ticket and they're very upset

0:57:41 because they went and got a burger,

0:57:44 and then they came into my store and bought something.

0:57:46 They went into Leah's store and got this ticket.

0:57:48 Leah then forks out the money to pay for that ticket,

0:57:51 or the patrons will not come back downtown.

0:57:53 We've had that from several stores saying

0:57:55 that there's free parking down at the mall.

0:57:56 Let's just go down to the mall.

0:57:58 Our objective is to get more people

0:58:00 to be comfortable downtown, enjoy downtown.

0:58:05 So we'd like them to be able to come in

0:58:06 and feel comfortable about the parking situation.

0:58:09 We also are looking at each individual business paying a parking pass.

0:58:15 Now, that's a good idea.

0:58:18 However, more people are not using those passes because they have

0:58:21 to pay multiple parking permits for their employees.

0:58:26 I, for one, am not going to have my employees pay for your parking.

0:58:30 I'm going to wind up doing that.

0:58:31 So if I have multiple employees,

0:58:33 pretty soon it winds up being a very costly deal.

0:58:36 So also on the same deal, we're asking that we had

0:58:39 a very reduced for two parking permits per business, not per person, but per business that

0:58:47 we have down here $5 per month to do a parking for two people per business. It makes it easier

0:58:56 for me to pay for my employee to park and if there's additional then go up to $10 per month

0:59:02 or $100 a year. It makes it easier for us to park and have us park out by the seconds instead

0:59:08 that have been the free parking.

0:59:10 Tom, I'm trying to track with you and take no.

0:59:12 So you basically, each business, two employees,

0:59:16 $5 a piece per month.

0:59:17 Correct.

0:59:18 OK.

0:59:19 And go ahead to the microphone, Leah.

0:59:28 I'm just trying to keep track so that.

0:59:29 OK.

0:59:30 So from our perspective, from the business operation

0:59:35 perspective and the nature of small downtown related

0:59:38 businesses, there are some employees that

0:59:41 are there once a week or twice a week.

0:59:43 So it just doesn't make sense to purchase a year-long pass

0:59:48 for those once a week, maybe twice a month employees

0:59:52 on a rotating basis to come down there and park

0:59:55 in a least parking spot.

0:59:57 So in that two least or two,

1:00:02 I believe if you do all have the letters,

1:00:04 you should have a letter.

1:00:05 So I believe one of the things we're proposing

1:00:09 is that there's two spaces allocated to the business itself.

1:00:14 So there's, it lessens the abuse by former employees,

1:00:18 or by the employees that are currently there,

1:00:20 or spouses, or whatever, cleverly abuse

1:00:24 there could be from those passes.

1:00:26 So to the business, and then the additional passes

1:00:30 be purchased at a discount rate.

1:00:32 So to clarify, two allocated for free,

1:00:36 and then two at the reduced rate is what you're asking for.

1:00:38 Yes, two businesses per business.

1:00:43 If that business wants it, I mean, there's businesses down there that maybe they don't.

1:00:49 So what we did was we have a petition format, I guess, and we have businesses and employees.

1:00:59 There's pretty much every business, I'll say most businesses that are down there that

1:01:06 are represented and their signatures and their support to this letter which our group

1:01:12 has been working on since April and revived it and I believe we also followed a suggestion

1:01:18 letter from the maybe parking or zoning commission. I don't know if that's who it came from but

1:01:27 it came from it was a suggestion letter that we also kind of included in here to address

1:01:35 the different perspectives that are of the parking issue.

1:01:39 For example, the orange lot is like its own monster

1:01:43 that we don't even try to suggest a solution for

1:01:48 because the orange lot, if you understand,

1:01:50 is the one that's behind the cookie basket shared

1:01:53 by Charlie 3D nightclub and Tanson.

1:01:58 There's eight employee parking spots there,

1:02:01 the rest are for the public.

1:02:03 However, between slice, cookie basket, breast monkey,

1:02:07 kelly's, and hands on, and all those kitty corner businesses,

1:02:11 there's more than I think 23 passes that are issued out

1:02:16 for them to park in eight spots.

1:02:18 So it's pretty interesting, it's entertaining,

1:02:21 it's like reality to be to watch how those spots are used

1:02:26 and how they have their own system of exchanging them

1:02:30 so that they can actually park.

1:02:31 Let me that great way and he has a question.

1:02:34 The question I have is the letter says,

1:02:38 is exactly as Tom stated that two spaces

1:02:41 that five dollars a piece, but you're saying for free.

1:02:44 So what you're saying is actually different than the letter.

1:02:47 Yeah, that's correct.

1:02:49 Okay, thank you.

1:02:49 I should have read the letter.

1:02:50 No, that's what we discussed and that's what we discussed

1:02:55 and we're not sure if that's from a revenue perspective.

1:02:59 I don't know if that's something that the city or if that's even feasible, but that's

1:03:06 initially where the conversation began, but I think Tom knows a little more about what's

1:03:11 going on.

1:03:12 So to clarify, do you want me to pull that off from your suggestion to free to reduce?

1:03:18 Why doesn't Tom answer that?

1:03:20 How did the rest of the group feel about the free versus the discount?

1:03:25 I think what I remember being discussed is, I think what I remember is it being the two

1:03:31 free and additional spots for employees at a discounted rate, but maybe I missed something.

1:03:39 Tom.

1:03:40 I pulled the mic over to the police, thank you.

1:03:42 I believe we were sixes.

1:03:43 I believe we were.

1:03:44 Some of us wanted to go ahead and do, and the redo straight isn't going to kill us.

1:03:48 But, you know, the two free, we did talk about, and that would be a cool thing to do.

1:03:52 However, the conversation came up that there has to be revenue to take care of that lot.

1:03:58 So the reduced would be, I mean, I don't frown at a free spot, shirt.

1:04:04 We're trying to get our employees out of the park out by the seconds and our customers

1:04:08 parked closer, is the main objective.

1:04:11 Our employees right now, as well as business owners, are parking in the free parking, because

1:04:16 they don't have the means to pay for their employees to have parking permits.

1:04:21 Or like myself, I part as far down second as I can't,

1:04:24 because somebody else is part in second,

1:04:25 that's not part in a close.

1:04:26 I need to walk in.

1:04:28 Rebecca Milsoyke has a question, I think.

1:04:30 Thank you.

1:04:31 Yes, a question about, we got the copy of the letter,

1:04:33 but we didn't get the one with signatures

1:04:35 or showing who's a part of your group.

1:04:36 Is there a way we can get a copy of that?

1:04:44 Do you have it available so that she can put it out?

1:04:47 I didn't receive that.

1:04:48 Did anyone else have a copy of that?

1:04:49 They were emailed.

1:04:50 The reason why they were emailed earlier today,

1:04:53 And I let Lee Island know about that, that was going to happen.

1:04:56 It's because our meeting happened on Thursday,

1:04:58 and she needed to have the letter prior to that

1:05:01 to set it on the agenda.

1:05:02 So that's where we communicated it.

1:05:05 And so that other business owners could also

1:05:08 have a chance to sign it if they didn't make it

1:05:11 to a prior meeting, which is just once a month.

1:05:14 So we allowed them to sign it with their employees

1:05:17 this last Thursday.

1:05:19 One of them has signatures on the back

1:05:21 because they ran out of room.

1:05:23 OK, and about how many members do you have in your collective?

1:05:28 There's 54 signatures on there.

1:05:30 However, some of them, if you could tell, they're employees.

1:05:33 So if you want to count people in the collective,

1:05:37 or businesses in the collective?

1:05:38 Businesses.

1:05:39 So I would say, Tom, do you know the number?

1:05:47 I would say on any giving time that we meet,

1:05:49 we have between 12 to 26 businesses that are represented,

1:05:55 not people, but represented, and that rotates.

1:05:58 But from the signatures, I think that's a little more

1:06:01 accurate on who's involved, because it's all of them,

1:06:05 not the ones that come to the meetings often or all the time,

1:06:09 but who's involved in the dialogue.

1:06:11 Is there a second page?

1:06:12 Thank you.

1:06:13 There's 12 on that one.

1:06:15 12 different businesses.

1:06:21 So maybe if we could continue down the road of exactly what your request is this evening,

1:06:27 so that we can maybe start discussing that.

1:06:30 Rebecca, I'm so glad I cut you up.

1:06:31 Did you have any questions?

1:06:32 No, she answered my question.

1:06:35 So what we want that we would like to see is extended parking in the back.

1:06:42 Don't touch the parking in front, two hours is planned.

1:06:44 We get a lot of people coming in there, they can come in and go, so on and so forth.

1:06:48 But extend the parking in the back.

1:06:50 four hours, I'll go for four hours, we did talk about five.

1:06:55 We don't want it abused.

1:06:56 We don't want people parking there all day and go somewhere else, leave their car there

1:07:00 and so forth.

1:07:01 So four hours is good.

1:07:02 It gives them plenty of time to go get the burger of the hairdo, the nails, the go across

1:07:07 street to the jewelers and so on and so forth.

1:07:10 Also reduce parking for the businesses there so we can use the permit parking back there

1:07:15 like we should be doing and let the customers use the parking closer to the buildings.

1:07:20 That's what it always should be, it should never change.

1:07:23 So if we can permit parking along the back against second there, even if you want to add

1:07:28 more free parking back there for the consumers, that's fine.

1:07:31 But reduce the parking for the businesses and extend the hours for parking.

1:07:39 Fair.

1:07:40 Sure.

1:07:41 I have a question for Mitch.

1:07:43 Mitch, do you have a mic?

1:07:48 Wow.

1:07:49 Stereo.

1:07:50 So Mitch, I know that we're right in the midst of doing some really great work downtown.

1:07:56 And by the way, what a great problem to have.

1:07:59 That you don't have the right parking, because that means you have customers, right?

1:08:04 With this OTAC, talk about that a little bit.

1:08:08 Aren't there going to be some studies about parking downtown and

1:08:12 maybe some expertise that can help guide us in the near future?

1:08:15 Right, yes, not hired by the city, but yes.

1:08:19 The Urban Renewal Agency has recently signed a contract with OTAC, LLC or something like

1:08:26 that.

1:08:27 Any by OTAC is a group of consultants that are working with the Urban Renewal Agency on this

1:08:32 down to, well, on the main street, we'll call it the Main Street Redesign Project, or Street

1:08:37 Skate, kind of a thing, and part of their consultant team is a parking and traffic specialist engineer,

1:08:45 a traffic engineer that they've brought in to be on this team and part of the scope of that

1:08:49 project is to examine our downtown parking rules regulations. Is it in the right location?

1:08:57 Those kinds of just a real thorough kind of analysis of parking for Main Street. And the

1:09:04 result I would anticipate in the spring, I want to say mayish time frame, and that result

1:09:10 will give some recommendations on what the agency might be able to do to improve the downtown

1:09:17 public parking scenario.

1:09:19 And obviously that would come to our attention as well, and the business owners attention.

1:09:24 Right.

1:09:25 The city as you know, city council and mayor, the city is the management arm of the urban

1:09:31 renewal agency, so we absolutely have some, we're absolutely aware of what's going on

1:09:37 there and we'll have copies of this report.

1:09:39 Even though it's funded by the agency, we'll still have the ability to partner with the

1:09:44 and see if we choose to do so to make some of those things happen.

1:09:48 But right now it's very, very early.

1:09:50 They just last week started kickoff meetings for that project.

1:09:54 Thank you, Mitch.

1:09:55 Sean Berver.

1:09:56 So Mitch, my questions are probably for you too,

1:09:59 and I'm going to guess that you can't answer this one.

1:10:01 But do you have any idea how many tickets have actually been issued

1:10:05 for parking too long in the lots in the past several months?

1:10:10 Okay, so I tried to gather up some information and anticipation of some of the questions.

1:10:16 I didn't count numbers of tickets.

1:10:18 What I counted was revenue that we've received from tickets in this fiscal year.

1:10:24 And that won't be necessarily limited to the parking lots, but could also be the streets,

1:10:30 the on-street, so you have the two hour limit on street and then the three hour limit in

1:10:32 the parking lots.

1:10:34 So far as of August 31st

1:10:39 We've collected almost $14,000 in fines most of those are $35 tickets a few

1:10:47 5% 6 10% something like that have gone up to the $50 rate because they weren't paid on time

1:10:53 But most of it is a $35 fine. So to get to $14,000

1:10:57 $35 a pop takes a lot of tickets. I actually have a lot more

1:11:03 more fines than we had anticipated so far.

1:11:09 We're going to continue, hold on just a minute later, we'll call on.

1:11:12 So that's somewhat helpful.

1:11:17 I guess since one of the points that you're making is people are getting ticketed for

1:11:22 sticking around in the lots too long, I really would be curious to know what that

1:11:27 number is.

1:11:29 Is it 10 really vocal people who got tickets for being in the parking lot too long?

1:11:34 or is it 200 to put some perspective on it?

1:11:39 And then another question, so earlier you talked about

1:11:42 there are 20 some employees in the orange lot,

1:11:45 neighborhood and only eight spaces.

1:11:48 I thought our parking pass,

1:11:51 parking's weren't a lot specific.

1:11:53 They are not a lot specific.

1:11:55 Parking pass parks you in any one of the six main street lots

1:11:59 in any one of the parking pass designated lots.

1:12:03 Right, and in the orange lot there is only one row.

1:12:06 Every other lot has at least two rows I think.

1:12:08 Right, right, so I'm thinking for example,

1:12:11 the sandwich company, brass monkey, neighborhood there,

1:12:16 there is parking pass, parking available in the lot

1:12:21 to the south, yeah.

1:12:25 Okay, thank you.

1:12:27 Chris, talking to.

1:12:28 Yeah, 35 bucks a pop, that's over 400 tickets,

1:12:32 issued. That would be calendar year up through August or fiscal year from October

1:12:38 1 through August 31st. Okay. And we have a spreadsheet of all the entries and all

1:12:44 the entries also include sale of passes and there was 740 something records on

1:12:52 that list. It's a lot of tickets but we're being asked and I really to modify

1:12:57 ordinance 3038 I guess why isn't this in public hearing so we require a public

1:13:05 hearing when when there's a proposed amendment to title 10 of the city code

1:13:09 all these regulations are entitled nine I think yeah title nine and it does not

1:13:15 require public hearing but having said that the process to create 30 38 was a

1:13:23 a very open, very public process and even though it's not required, we did have several

1:13:30 public hearings.

1:13:31 And I think that's the same just by a simple motion we can modify 3038.

1:13:38 No.

1:13:39 What we're to modify an ordinance, we'll have to go forward and construct an ordinance.

1:13:46 What we did want to do was to presume that this council was going to fully accept the

1:13:53 proposal that was outlined tonight. So what we're hoping is that the Council would be in

1:13:59 receipt of the information at tonight's meeting and that they would instruct staff on how you

1:14:04 would like for us to proceed if there was a direction or any parts of piece of the proposal

1:14:09 that has been presented to you this evening.

1:14:12 Ms. Anne Hawkins.

1:14:15 Mitch, maybe you can kind of give us a brief update on what does it cost to maintain the

1:14:20 lots as far as, you know, painting, striping, patching, silcoding. What kind of budget do

1:14:27 we have for that on our lots?

1:14:29 So the only thing we actually budget for right now is snow removal. And it's a contract each

1:14:37 year that has a dollar amount. And I want to say it was about $4,500. And when it's

1:14:41 used up, it's done. And so if it's really snow a year, we use it up early and then we

1:14:46 just have snowy lots. And if it's a not so snowy year, we might have money left at the

1:14:50 the end of the year.

1:14:52 We have on occasion, and I don't remember when it was done most recently, like a chip seal

1:15:00 on a parking lot, and that just usually when it happens, finds its way into the streets

1:15:04 overall yearly chip seal budget, because we don't account for that anywhere else.

1:15:10 The revenue from parking isn't close to covering enough to maintain the lots.

1:15:15 That all gets spent on enforcement.

1:15:18 So the money that we do collect on selling passes or on tickets all goes back to enforcement

1:15:24 and nowhere else?

1:15:25 It all goes to enforcement and it's not enough to cover the cost of enforcement.

1:15:31 Okay.

1:15:32 Let's see.

1:15:35 I think that's it for now.

1:15:36 I think I'll think on the rest of this for a minute.

1:15:39 You know, I want the weigh in.

1:15:40 I'm going to give you a chance to speak to me.

1:15:41 I know you just a couple more things you want to say.

1:15:43 But the way I look at this is we've got, well, we've been intimate with parking.

1:15:48 in parking will bring out a lot of emotions with people. We've got a study

1:15:54 that's coming up that's going to look at this with some expertise that can give us

1:15:59 some guidance. I would like to see that before I weigh in or make any decisions

1:16:04 on what we're going to do here. This is just me personally. I would like to see a

1:16:09 little more information I'd also like to hear from more of the community as well

1:16:13 about this. Certainly if I got a ticket there, I wouldn't be happy, but maybe I

1:16:19 shouldn't have parked there too long too. So, you know, there's some personal

1:16:24 responsibility there. And also, and you mentioned this, and this is the same thing

1:16:28 that we heard when we were talking about taking the parking meters out and

1:16:32 everything else. Those, we have met the enemy and they are us when we start

1:16:38 talking about employees parking in places that they shouldn't and taking up

1:16:43 those free spots that take it away from the customers and that's why we have to have

1:16:51 enforcement. I was really hoping someday we could get to the point where we're generating

1:16:57 enough revenue and I'm not just saying from the fines but from the actual fees to actually

1:17:04 make a dent on the maintenance of the parking lots because right now that's on the city's

1:17:09 So people that have businesses at the mall that have to pay for the mall's parking lot, they have to pay for those.

1:17:17 How else will have to pay for the parking downtown for the downtown business people?

1:17:23 So I kind of like places to pay for themselves eventually.

1:17:28 I certainly understand that we're kind of hooked at the hip with downtown because of how it's developed and the way the city is.

1:17:35 I get all that, but someday I'd really like to see us get me on just the enforcement side,

1:17:42 but actually putting some money towards the maintenance and the snow removal and all those other things

1:17:46 so that other people don't have to pay for it.

1:17:48 It's the folks downtown that pay for that.

1:17:50 So Rebecca.

1:17:53 Thank you, Mayor.

1:17:54 Just a clarifying question, and then I'll make a comment.

1:17:57 You're talking about, is that common?

1:18:00 You're talking about extended parking in the back.

1:18:03 back. Can you just explain which which lots you feel are the back just so we know

1:18:10 what what lots you're talking about. We have second and second and we have me the

1:18:14 back I'm talking anything behind me to either second on any. Also both sides.

1:18:19 Both sides. Okay. It's it's it's the best place to park. I mean it's you're gonna

1:18:26 have everybody parking somewhere front is going to be too tight. So yeah in the

1:18:31 back. Okay. Well, I think you actually for providing us feedback, you know, when we did

1:18:38 the parking overhaul, we did say that we would review it and update it and see how it's working

1:18:43 for everyone downtown. So I actually really appreciate the feedback. I do like the concept

1:18:47 of so to me, when I think of the back parking lot, I actually think of the parking lots

1:18:53 that are on the south side of Maine, not the north side, because I think they're generally

1:18:58 less utilized and they're more empty and so kind of forming employee type parking back

1:19:04 there might be a good incentive for people to use those lots.

1:19:09 I do think that the cost of the past would need to be commensurate with the costs of enforcement

1:19:15 and the parking lot just so that we don't redistribute those costs on other people.

1:19:20 But I think it's good input.

1:19:22 My concern with making any changes before the study comes out is just the cost of signage.

1:19:28 I mean, we just redid all of the signage.

1:19:30 And I actually think that the four hour time limit

1:19:34 is a really good recommendation.

1:19:35 I think that's reasonable.

1:19:38 But I don't want to go through and redo all those signs.

1:19:41 And probably by the time we got it done,

1:19:43 we'd be about the time that this group, the Leland group,

1:19:48 and the OTAC group would have some recommendations for us.

1:19:52 And so it is a struggle, because I

1:19:54 don't know if it's fair to ask you guys to wait an entire year.

1:19:57 But then I don't know if it's worth the expense of taxpayer dollars to kind of resign everything in the meantime.

1:20:06 So, but I do appreciate the input and I think that they are good recommendations for us to implement when we redo downtown.

1:20:16 But I also, you know, if we want to have a public hearing on, if we want to make changes before then, I would encourage a public hearing to give everyone input.

1:20:26 and to hear from more people downtown.

1:20:30 But I do want to share that hesitation

1:20:32 to make any changes before the report.

1:20:36 Greg Lanning.

1:20:36 No, it's my main where I want a quick question

1:20:39 to mention in the comment.

1:20:40 Bitch, what's the name of the lot over by the Hanson building?

1:20:47 We call that one affectionately the green lot.

1:20:50 Green lot, all right.

1:20:51 Which is not really part of the parking pass system, though.

1:20:55 Right, and that's what I was going to bring up

1:20:58 Well, I take it back.

1:20:59 There's about 15 or 16 spaces in there that are in the parking pass.

1:21:04 I parked in one about five minutes to six one time in the parking force, but I said,

1:21:09 you don't have a pass.

1:21:10 And I said, all right.

1:21:11 I need drive down until six.

1:21:12 He goes, no.

1:21:13 As long as you understand it, it was earlier than the day you could park there.

1:21:17 The last route against the alley is parking pass, a lot of spaces.

1:21:22 My comment, Amir, is a lot of what they're saying.

1:21:25 I'm a little hesitant.

1:21:26 I like some of the ideas.

1:21:27 I truly do.

1:21:30 I would like to be a part of this entire process.

1:21:34 I know that maybe just different from Mayor Hall, just a little bit, we've created this

1:21:41 animal by the fact that we don't forever central business owners have not had parking requirements.

1:21:48 So, other areas we have parking requirements, we don't have them there, so we've kind of

1:21:53 created the animal with our own ordinances, but I would like to wait.

1:21:57 I would also like to think that maybe that a lot that I'm just talking about, the green

1:22:01 lot, may be one where if you wanted to buy even by a reduced or free, which you're winded

1:22:08 up being for your employees, maybe that's the lot that we would utilize.

1:22:13 That lot is certainly underutilized and that would even free up more spots behind your stores

1:22:18 for customers.

1:22:19 And so maybe that's my thought that, but again, we have a lot of different ideas floating

1:22:24 here. I think we need to make sure that this group has representation with the

1:22:28 OTAC group. I think you already do. You were with many of you were at the meeting

1:22:31 the other day. I saw you there. I didn't know. You were probably there at the

1:22:34 morning and one the next morning as well. I think we need to... I would prefer to

1:22:42 wait until we get the parking situation going but I do like your ideas. I think

1:22:46 there's merits there. I think there's for the one a little bit longer on the

1:22:50 customer parking as long as we can guarantee its customers and maybe by

1:22:53 by providing these lesson rates for employees

1:22:58 in some of the lots or areas, like the backs and lots,

1:23:01 I may be very willing to listen to that.

1:23:05 But right now, I think I wanna wait and tell,

1:23:07 see what the URAs group comes up with.

1:23:11 Because he'd do something now,

1:23:12 and then they say, no, you need to change it,

1:23:13 and then we have to change it.

1:23:15 And like Rebecca said, Chris talking it.

1:23:18 Just to reinforce the feeling,

1:23:20 I think we'd be wasting an effort

1:23:23 that we would have to rethink everything.

1:23:25 Once the study is done, the intensity,

1:23:30 seven to $15 million downtown renovation,

1:23:34 just going to eviscerate the area for a very short time

1:23:37 to make it better.

1:23:38 There's gonna be plazas perhaps that aren't here now.

1:23:43 Parking configurations are really going to change.

1:23:46 I think we would be short-sighted

1:23:49 to your ultimate aims of serving your customers better

1:23:52 if we made an interim move right now and have to revisit the whole thing.

1:23:57 So I really think that just to what you're talking about it will be probably conveyed in

1:24:04 the final ordinance changes, but right now I just wouldn't want to do anything.

1:24:09 So when we began this process, we actually, correct me if I'm wrong, we were going to

1:24:21 to start it as a public petition.

1:24:24 And then we figured that it would be cleaner and more

1:24:31 diplomatic to put the merchants on the petition first.

1:24:36 And their experience first, instead of making it a loud,

1:24:39 public messy thing, because everybody's got their same

1:24:43 experience down there.

1:24:44 So our next effort as a group, I understand the projection

1:24:49 of what the studies will bring and all that,

1:24:52 but our next effort as a group, I believe,

1:24:55 is going to be to get the public involved,

1:24:57 because at the end of the day, this is more for them,

1:25:01 because they, at the end of the day,

1:25:03 are the ones that are getting the $35 ticket

1:25:05 with only three business days to pay it,

1:25:08 or it becomes 55, and a lot of our clients are out of town,

1:25:12 or they're elderly on the fixed income,

1:25:14 or they forget about it,

1:25:17 And then it goes into the record or whatever happens,

1:25:21 but it's then $55.

1:25:23 And I believe at this time there's not even an option

1:25:26 for an appeal or a hearing to dispute that $35 or $55.

1:25:31 So we'll walk away today, still with a problem,

1:25:37 still with the dialogue out there, not just among the merchants.

1:25:43 We've just taken this upon ourselves

1:25:46 to put our energy, our grass root experience,

1:25:50 and hearing the feedback to bring it all together.

1:25:54 Everybody that's on that signature

1:25:57 has probably received half of the revenue

1:26:00 that Mitch is quoting is the tickets

1:26:01 that we've paid probably just from parking.

1:26:03 And we're picking up tickets not only that we receive,

1:26:07 but for our customers too.

1:26:10 Because just like with the meters,

1:26:11 we used to have a dish of quarters out there

1:26:14 to subsidize feeding the meters for our customers.

1:26:17 We're now paying $35 or $55 a ticket

1:26:20 to not lose a customer to downtown.

1:26:23 Because their experience with the ticket is our,

1:26:25 they're seeing our face.

1:26:27 They're not seeing who they're paying the ticket to.

1:26:29 It's basically they're being fined

1:26:32 for being a customer of downtown.

1:26:35 And they say exactly what Tom has voiced is

1:26:37 they walk away mad or they say they won't bring

1:26:40 their donations to their youth ranch

1:26:42 or buy a bunch of things there, or they won't go and eat at a restaurant if they have to

1:26:46 watch their clock and move their car to the next parking spot over.

1:26:51 So we're pretty much, I don't know what decision you guys want to make, or if you want to look

1:26:57 further into this.

1:26:58 The study that's going to happen is going to happen down the line, but between now and then

1:27:01 we have a lot of changes happening.

1:27:05 And while all this is going on, we're educating our customers to use the back parking lots

1:27:09 for when renovation occurs.

1:27:11 our strategy right now. And if we're doing that, and in three hours they're receiving

1:27:16 tickets, we still have a problem. So, if we walk, if we go back to our group, then what

1:27:22 do we take back to them, so that they feel like there was something done or considered

1:27:28 or something happening, or are we just going back to the same problem we had before we

1:27:33 came here?

1:27:34 I'll summarize at the end, but we have a couple more lights, so we'll do that first. Suzanne

1:27:40 Hawkins.

1:27:41 I guess I'm a little confused why you would be paying parking tickets when they can buy a daily pass for $2 instead of a $35 fine.

1:27:50 You know, we really put a lot of thought and energy into this to give in people options, and I know I go downtown very frequently.

1:27:58 I've never had a ticket, I've never had a problem finding a place to park and staying in that parking place the allotted amount of time and getting my shopping done.

1:28:07 If I know I'm going to be down there, a parking pass is an easy prospect.

1:28:11 So instead of running up fines and having people angry, I mean I think maybe educating

1:28:17 them that you can buy a pass for $2 for the day is a much better option than taking a

1:28:21 chance on parking illegally and paying a $35 fine.

1:28:26 So I mean to me that I'm having a hard time weighing this out in my mind because it doesn't

1:28:36 It makes sense to me.

1:28:37 So can I go ahead.

1:28:42 We had an elderly lady come into the store.

1:28:45 She's one of our regulars.

1:28:47 And we mentioned to her, I did not, one of our ladies did, that you can get a daily pass.

1:28:52 I want to come shop.

1:28:54 I want to park in one spot.

1:28:55 I don't want to have to go over here to grab a pass to come back and shop.

1:28:59 When I go downtown, I don't think about going.

1:29:01 It's her replies.

1:29:03 And I'm sure that's going to be all over the place.

1:29:05 And I have no idea where the passes are to begin with, if there was a place close by,

1:29:10 maybe that would be the way to go.

1:29:12 And I agree, $2 is better than $35.

1:29:15 So maybe the answer is education instead of changing the program,

1:29:18 then maybe we need to work on educating merchants on where they can get passes

1:29:23 and how they can do it to help their clients instead of revamping the whole program

1:29:27 at this point until we get more information.

1:29:29 So that would go to Leah's answer, what can she do?

1:29:33 Maybe we can work on the education piece as an interim fix until we finish the study next year.

1:29:39 Or more convenient as well.

1:29:42 You know, where do we get it the permits?

1:29:44 We have to drive from downtown to get the permit to go back downtown, correct?

1:29:50 I believe so, but I thought some business owners were buying permits to have it their businesses.

1:29:54 Mitch, could you weigh in on that?

1:29:56 The parking passes may purchase the city hall or at the Hanson building, either one.

1:30:01 But a business owner could buy five and leave at their store and then sell them to a client

1:30:05 when they came in to reimburse their costs or give them away or-

1:30:08 Don't the daily passes or weekly passes?

1:30:11 Yeah.

1:30:12 We don't- yes, you could do that.

1:30:15 The trouble we have is like what day is it good for kind of a thing, you know?

1:30:22 And so there's usually an expiration attached to a parking pass that's sold and if they

1:30:26 buy it today and then hand it to a customer a month from now, here use this for today, it's

1:30:31 probably expired by then. So we may be able to work through some issues on better how to deal with that, but to me that makes more sense.

1:30:39 To kind of clarify, I'm with a booth process, like in other cities where it's really organized and you go for your day and get your thing and stick it on your dashboard, that makes sense.

1:30:50 But for most people, especially out of town, or just last minute, show up downtown, park their car and start eating, start booking their appointments for whatever they're doing down there.

1:31:00 It doesn't make sense because if it made sense, Mitch, you would probably, I don't know if you have the numbers to show how many tourists or shoppers or patrons actually get those passes.

1:31:11 I can tell you that we've only sold three day passes in the fiscal year.

1:31:17 Six weekly passes sell a lot of monthly passes actually over 300.

1:31:21 And that's with signage and with the education that's out there.

1:31:25 So, I guess, Leah, maybe to answer your question of what are you supposed to go tell your group?

1:31:34 I would suggest that you go tell your group there's an entire public process that's going on right now

1:31:40 addressing downtown issues and parking as part of that,

1:31:44 and they need to be a part of that process to figure it out.

1:31:49 I think Councilman talking to made a good point.

1:31:52 If we just went in here and made a bunch of changes tonight,

1:31:55 And then in six months, there's a whole new plan, and then in six more months, there's a whole new plan when we're actually implementing changes downtown.

1:32:03 We're going to confuse your customers even more than they're confused now.

1:32:08 So that would be my suggestion to tell your group what the result of tonight was.

1:32:15 The other part too, and I'm certainly sensitive to your customers' needs, I really would like to find out how many of what kind of tickets are we asking?

1:32:24 tickets are we actually issuing because again it's very easy to have a few

1:32:31 experiences that then become a lot and I want to know if that really is a lot but

1:32:38 the other part that you talked about tonight is about your employees not about

1:32:41 your customers and in all honesty I think that's your problem to solve as merchants

1:32:48 if you have employees that are that are parking where they're not supposed to

1:32:53 be parking and taking that space away from your customers. We shouldn't be

1:32:57 changing the program to make it more affordable for them. That doesn't make

1:33:02 sense to me. There's a huge disconnect. And so you talked about two issues tonight.

1:33:06 One was time limits for parking in the lots, but the other really was about

1:33:11 accommodating employees. And I don't know that that's the city council's issue. In

1:33:18 fact, when we had this discussion before with the old ordinance, the old ordinance

1:33:21 was, you know, we were issuing tickets if an employee's car was parked on the street, which

1:33:27 was this giant enforcement issue of tracking down registrations and names, and you as an employer

1:33:33 had to make sure you kept a list of your employees' current. That's just a silly waste of taxpayer

1:33:39 dollars in my mind. Your employees should be responsible enough to not be taking up space

1:33:46 that should be used by other employees.

1:33:52 If you could do it briefly, we're running.

1:33:53 So briefly, with the employee situation, we do have very responsible employees.

1:33:57 In fact, they notify each other when the ticket people are out there so that we have a gypsy

1:34:03 telegram to move our cars.

1:34:06 The problem with the employee parking is that we do have these different businesses or the

1:34:12 academy in the school.

1:34:13 They do have these temporary employees where they're there once or twice a week.

1:34:19 So to pay $200 a year to get them a pass does not make sense.

1:34:25 So what happens is the whole enforcement effort is counterproductive because what happens is

1:34:30 the parking spots are pretty much switched.

1:34:34 Just by survival of the fittest in that parking lot I guess is that people don't want to buy

1:34:38 a $200 pass for working one day or two days a week or part time.

1:34:43 So they end up parking in a three-hour free parking.

1:34:46 And so that happens and the whole lease parking area is open with two or three cars and the

1:34:52 rest of the spots open.

1:34:54 So that's kind of the trickling down of the costs of the passes making the employees park

1:35:01 how they park.

1:35:02 That pattern happens due to cost.

1:35:04 If that explains it better.

1:35:05 I don't want to misrepresent the employees are being reckless over there.

1:35:11 We're doing the best we can to accommodate each other.

1:35:13 respect each other's space and when people need to load and load or whatever they need to do.

1:35:18 It's the cost that doesn't make it efficient for employees or business owners.

1:35:23 If that makes sense.

1:35:25 It does.

1:35:26 So tonight what I heard is I heard Council overall liking some of the suggestions that

1:35:31 you brought but we need more information and we would love to have someone that has better

1:35:35 expertise at parking than we have way into that and we are just blessed right now because

1:35:41 we have this study going on, please get involved, and I know you will, because you already are,

1:35:46 with this study that's coming through so that we can have some good advice to make some changes

1:35:51 and make them right when we make the changes.

1:35:53 Sure.

1:35:54 So that this effort and this energy, because this is a lot of coordinating with business

1:35:58 hours and a lot of, we've been working on this for a while, and if you would like, and

1:36:05 If the research group, if it benefits them, we can also come up with something like this

1:36:13 that shows how different is that finding if it's actually employees getting and owners

1:36:20 getting their tickets, or if customers are, we'd like to keep this process, you know, diplomatic

1:36:26 and clean, but at the same time we want to make sure that this stays a living document

1:36:30 and is also a part of the study.

1:36:34 So we can leave it with you guys. Yeah, we have plenty of bodies and then

1:36:41 Consider it please or let pass it down to the to the right avenues

1:36:46 So they do consider it and it would also help them minimize their cost in the research because we've we do our research

1:36:54 That's our research sure

1:36:56 Absolutely, you can you can count on that this is going to be passed and thank you for considering

1:37:00 I know you guys probably dream about parking, not in your sleep, so much talking about it

1:37:06 so much, but we hope that this is a good problem for us, we started out talking about that.

1:37:13 Right, right.

1:37:14 So thank you both.

1:37:15 Leave up with us, would you please or make sure we have a copy?

1:37:18 Yeah, I think.

1:37:20 Excellent.

1:37:21 Thank you very much.

1:37:22 Council, we are going to take a five minute break.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, September 8, 2014. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:37:28.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    91aae63a5003963e099f79162d20eb9fca2d790ecd5201bc958bc967cddf126b
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a aede5f7051a48e32bfe23ab77dfff7725128a0c9739bbcafa5c7f1d88fe40020
    part02.m4a 503226f1b5294792b52e2bd511487118c79016f44607e29362fab6623ff2358d
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    fb0681614d42f9a75a3335c58bd7d8e498bb8667803a47097c8f5189d7e951ef

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file