City Council meeting
Monday, November 3, 2014
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Minutes on fileExecutive session: a
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:05:37 Welcome everyone. I'd like to welcome you to the City Council meeting. It is Monday, November 3rd, 2014,
0:05:45 and the Council meeting is now open. As always, we tried to start our City Council meeting off with the Pledge of Allegiance,
0:05:52 and we have quite a few Boy Scouts in the audience that are going to come up and lead us in the pledge.
0:06:00 So, all of you wishing to join us, please rise.
0:06:19 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:06:33 Well, welcome young men.
0:06:34 If you wanted a time, go to the podium.
0:06:36 There's four questions, three questions for everyone after you, if you could tell us your
0:06:41 name, the troop you're with, where you meet, and what you're working on, actually, just
0:06:48 for the rest of you because if he's already said what troop and where you meet
0:06:52 I think we've got that company. I'm Chris Gilliland from troop 161. We meet at the
0:06:59 church on North College the LDS Church and we are currently working on the
0:07:03 citizenship in the community. Thank you Chris. Next. My name is Ethan Gadd and I'm
0:07:15 I'm in troop 161.
0:07:17 We meet, or I meet with at the LDS Church,
0:07:23 off of North College, and I'm also working
0:07:25 on the communications and citizenship in Mandy.
0:07:29 Perfect, and you have cool hair, good method.
0:07:34 My name is Kayta Smith, and I'm in troop 161.
0:07:36 We're on the LDS Church, on North College,
0:07:39 and I'm working on the community,
0:07:41 the citizenship and the community, Pedge.
0:07:44 Yeah, thank you, sir.
0:07:48 My name is Cowell Wickham and I'm from troop 161 and we meet at the LDS Church Building
0:07:58 at off North College and I work on the Association of the Community, Merit Bag and the Commentations.
0:08:08 Perfect, thank you.
0:08:11 Hello my name is Eli Brown and I'm from troop 161 and we meet at the LDS Church on North
0:08:18 in college and we're working on the communications Mayor Batch and the citizenship in the community
0:08:25 Mayor Batch. Thank you very much. My name is Justice and I'm at Justice Stocks and we're working on
0:08:36 on community citizenship in the community.
0:08:43 646 is our, our 160s are a cheer number, 61.
0:08:52 Very good.
0:08:56 We're working, oh wait.
0:09:00 You did good, thank you.
0:09:02 Good job.
0:09:03 My name is Scott Johnson, and I go, I meet at the LDS Church
0:09:09 off of North College.
0:09:11 and I'm working on the citizenship in the community
0:09:14 and my troop number is 161.
0:09:16 Very good, sir.
0:09:20 I'm Mitchell English and I guess you could say I'm in troop 161.
0:09:24 I am older than all of them, mostly.
0:09:26 I meet, of course, the same church on North College
0:09:29 and I'm currently working on communications.
0:09:32 Very good.
0:09:34 Thank you all and we, do we have one more?
0:09:38 Want to try to sneak away there?
0:09:39 You want to come forward?
0:09:41 I am Archer English, I am in troop 161 with Easton and we meet at the LDS Church off North
0:09:51 College and we are working on the citizenship in the community and the communications.
0:09:56 Excellent job, very good, all you gentlemen, now you've earned part of your badge already
0:10:02 for coming up here, now you have to listen to us, that's the rest of you earning to this
0:10:06 evening.
0:10:07 Special regard to the Order of the Earl, gentlemen, I still have my slash,
0:10:11 for all these years, too.
0:10:12 So if you can tell me the password sometime,
0:10:15 I can get back into one of your meetings.
0:10:17 Thank you.
0:10:19 Chris, what is the order of the year?
0:10:20 Stand up and show him the order of the Earl Sash.
0:10:27 Come to the, I don't know if I've heard that terminology.
0:10:35 To have word of the Earl, you pretty much get voted
0:10:38 by your, then you'll have to go to the camp
0:10:45 and can't really, you're not allowed to talk
0:10:49 and you have to fast
0:10:51 And you have to do service work in order to get it.
0:10:58 Very good.
0:10:59 Excellent job.
0:11:01 Now comes the bad time to Chris.
0:11:03 You actually earned that.
0:11:04 You weren't able to talk, Chris.
0:11:07 They took me out in the backwoods for two days,
0:11:09 and I couldn't talk except to the animals.
0:11:13 Wow, that's impressive.
0:11:14 Great landing.
0:11:15 Well, thank you, Chris.
0:11:16 I'm an Eagle Scout, and I had never
0:11:18 heard of the Earl of an Eagle Scout, so thank you.
0:11:22 Yeah, that's awesome.
0:11:22 Excellent job.
0:11:23 gentlemen, thank you for coming up forward.
0:11:26 Next item on the agenda is confirmation that we do have
0:11:29 a quorum of the city council.
0:11:30 All certain members are here this evening.
0:11:33 Now we have consideration of any amendments to the agenda,
0:11:37 and I ask our city manager, Travis Rathwaer.
0:11:40 Mr. Mayor, members of the council,
0:11:41 there are no amendments this evening.
0:11:43 Very good.
0:11:44 And next I have the opportunity of reading a proclamation,
0:11:48 and I think we have Officer Ben Hammer.
0:11:50 If you might come forward, Ben, and just have the seat,
0:11:53 I get to read this, hand it to you, and then if you would say a few words, sir.
0:11:58 This is a proclamation, no shave November 2014, whereas among American men prostate cancer is
0:12:05 both the second most commonly diagnosed cancer and the second leading cause of cancer deaths.
0:12:11 Although prostate cancer incidence and mortality rates have declined over the past two decades,
0:12:17 2014 alone and estimated 239,000 men in the United States will be diagnosed with the illness
0:12:27 and almost 30,000 men will die from this disease.
0:12:32 Whereas during National Prostate Cancer Awareness Month, we remember those lost to prostate cancer,
0:12:38 offer our support to patients and their families, and highlight our commitment to better prevention,
0:12:44 detection and treatment methods.
0:12:47 Whereas the Twin Falls Police Department has indicated
0:12:50 a desire to help support the treatment and awareness
0:12:53 of prostate and tistecular cancer
0:12:56 by promoting a program entitled No Shade November.
0:13:00 I, Don Hall, therefore proclaim the month of November
0:13:04 as No Shade November in Twin Falls.
0:13:07 By this action, let it be known that we,
0:13:09 the employees of the Twin Falls Police Department
0:13:13 citizens of the City of Twin Falls support research, awareness, and treatment of
0:13:18 prostate and tistecular cancer. And I've signed this along with Leidos
0:13:24 Sanchez and I'll hand this to Officer Hammer. Before I go into too many details
0:13:42 I've run, your official flyer. Started this last year as a program to raise money to help
0:14:11 support the St. Luke's County Mountain State Cancer Institute and we did pretty
0:14:15 If I do say so myself, especially for throwing it together as quickly as we've hit.
0:14:20 Basically, no shave November is a worldwide event and unique wage raised cancer awareness.
0:14:26 And what better way to do this than by growing out your facial hair?
0:14:30 The goal of no shave November is to grow awareness by embracing our hair, which many cancer patients lose by letting it grow.
0:14:36 You donate money you usually spend on shaving and grooming for a month to educate the community and the public about cancer prevention.
0:14:44 prevention, saving lives, and this aids those in fighting the battle.
0:14:49 The Twin Falls Police Department is partnering with the St. Luke's Mountain State Tumor Institute
0:14:54 the second year to raise money to give back to our community.
0:14:57 All the money raised will be donated to miss these emergency funds, which goes to support
0:15:01 cancer patients, transportation to and from treatment, any bills they may incur, excuse
0:15:07 me, any food that they may need, anything.
0:15:10 It helps out with everything that they need.
0:15:13 I'm asking that the Twin Falls community partner with us this year by growing out your beard and we're donating money to those who are fighting the good fight against this horrible disease.
0:15:23 We had a lot of participants last year and we were able to raise just over $2,700 to donate the Misty.
0:15:30 So please participate with us by either donating or growing out your facial hair and talking to those around you.
0:15:36 Thank you.
0:15:36 Officer Hammer, what is your goal this year? Do you have a Pacific goal?
0:15:40 Well, my goal this year is to, at the very least, be $2,700, but I think we can at least hit $4,000.
0:15:47 If this was a competition, I think Sean Berriger's winning at least up top here.
0:15:53 He's doing pretty good.
0:15:55 He swears to me, he didn't start until four out here.
0:15:58 I don't know.
0:16:00 Well, I just wanted to say thank you. You're the one that coordinated last year, put a lot
0:16:06 effort in, you presented it to your administrative staff at the police department and ran it up
0:16:11 the flagpole. And you're doing again this year and I really appreciate what you're doing.
0:16:15 Thank you. Thank you very much. Let's give him a hand. It is now time for general public input. If
0:16:26 there's anyone from the community that would like to address the council, if we try to stay off of
0:16:32 what's on the agenda, because we generally give time for those endeavors during the agenda. But
0:16:38 but if there's anyone that would like to address the council,
0:16:41 this is the time to do it.
0:16:45 I see Katie making her way up and Rob.
0:17:02 Katie Breckenridge and Rob Struthers-Pigboom.
0:17:12 We are here tonight for two very important reasons.
0:17:15 The first one is that last week I made a statement
0:17:20 about trust, and I was afraid after I left
0:17:24 that it was misinterpreted, and so that is the main reason
0:17:29 that we came tonight was to reinforce the fact
0:17:33 that we have tremendous trust in these people.
0:17:38 These people that get called staff,
0:17:41 we know them as individuals,
0:17:45 and we have tremendous trust in them.
0:17:48 And it is not that we don't trust them.
0:17:54 What we don't, I lose my trust in,
0:17:56 is the system that gives them the information
0:18:00 so that they can make the appropriate decision.
0:18:04 And so tonight it was very important to me and to Rob
0:18:09 that we start this comment by saying what I said,
0:18:14 by clarifying what I said wrong.
0:18:17 It's not about them, it is about the system, okay?
0:18:24 Very good.
0:18:25 So it was just important and you can see again,
0:18:28 emotion and it was very important that I clarify that.
0:18:37 Thank you.
0:18:38 The second thing that we did is we said we would bring information about a comment, about
0:18:45 what we were concerned about last week.
0:18:48 And because we don't trust the systems, I don't know how to do that computer stuff very well.
0:18:56 And so I have reams of information that back up what we commented about, and I want to
0:19:04 give that to Travis.
0:19:06 He said I could have mailed it to him, but I said no I couldn't.
0:19:11 And so we have a letter to Travis that states it.
0:19:17 As far as the Breckenridge Endowment Farm, we have the agreement between John and Mary
0:19:23 and Breckenridge and CSI.
0:19:27 We have a copy of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife map that shows CSI, the Endowment Farm, has
0:19:45 a wetlands there.
0:19:47 That's the one thing.
0:19:49 So that should clarify my concerns of the bike path through CSI.
0:19:55 I also want you to know that the next day after I stood up here and made those comments,
0:20:00 I call, I sent an email to President Fox and to Deb Wilson, who's head of the foundation
0:20:08 of CSI, and I told her what I had, I told them what I had said, and I have my annual meeting
0:20:16 with the President Fox on the 2nd of December, and they said they would discuss it further
0:20:21 with me there, so I wanted to know I did that.
0:20:25 And then I moved to the discussion on the bike path across our property on the rim.
0:20:33 And what I have found here, and there's lots more, but the basics that I'm giving to Travis
0:20:39 is the letter that started on April, the process started on 2000, and here is the letter with
0:20:47 the diagram of the map from Lamar Orton about the bike path.
0:20:53 The second thing that we have are the agenda and the minutes
0:20:57 when the agreement that was made between the two sisters, Katie
0:21:02 and Susan Breckenridge, IDT, and the City of Twin Falls
0:21:08 over what we, this whole agreement,
0:21:10 is what we came to as far as the abandonment of our right
0:21:15 to enter Twin Falls off of our property,
0:21:22 the agreement to build the bike path,
0:21:25 the agreement and what that all stood for
0:21:28 and who did what, okay?
0:21:30 It went in front of planning and zoning
0:21:39 and June 10th, 2004, okay?
0:21:43 They passed it, they passed the whole amendment.
0:21:47 It went in front of the city council on, I think it was in August,
0:21:53 no October of 2004.
0:21:56 And the reason that I mentioned Chris Tockington last time
0:22:00 was because Chris made the motion.
0:22:03 And I didn't mention you, Sean, last time,
0:22:06 because you weren't here, but you second the motion.
0:22:10 And so here are those minutes.
0:22:12 Here is the copy of the agreement
0:22:15 between those three parties.
0:22:18 Here is a copy of the easement of what we donated,
0:22:22 that my sister and I donated.
0:22:25 And just so all of that is here,
0:22:28 and I also had sent an email to Travis the next day,
0:22:32 and said I would gather this fax
0:22:34 and bring it down and give it to all of you.
0:22:38 So here it is, and here's why many of you didn't know
0:22:43 anything about it because you weren't here.
0:22:46 And so I honored what you said, Greg,
0:22:50 and that you'd never heard of anything like this.
0:22:53 Well, if you take 2014 minus nine is what I thought.
0:22:57 You said you were, you came on a year later.
0:23:01 So that's why.
0:23:03 And so this is the information.
0:23:05 And if you want any more, we would be glad to give it to you
0:23:09 because we have green, we tell them the white books.
0:23:13 And those are those folders that you buy that are white
0:23:17 and every group, thick ones.
0:23:20 We don't go out those.
0:23:21 And so we have all of that information,
0:23:25 if you want even more.
0:23:27 And so that's why I feel the way I do.
0:23:30 And I think we have grounds to make a discussion forward
0:23:34 about the bike path across our property.
0:23:38 And we also want to move forward and we want to work on correcting and finalizing this situation.
0:23:46 And you will read my dialogue about what I said when we asked for all of this to happen.
0:23:53 So if you don't have any more questions, we'll go away.
0:23:59 Well, Katie and Rob, first of all, I thank you for coming in front of us.
0:24:02 I've always felt since I've been on council anyway in 2006 with great,
0:24:07 that we've had a very good relationship.
0:24:09 And I thought that trust was there.
0:24:11 So I appreciate that you clarified that with us
0:24:16 because we're all together in this endeavor,
0:24:19 trying to guide and lead our city to prosperous things.
0:24:23 And also, I really appreciate you coming all the way here
0:24:25 and bringing that information and we'll review it
0:24:27 and really appreciate that.
0:24:30 Thank you, and thank you all.
0:24:31 I have to tell you, I was gonna tell Jack
0:24:35 but I have to test, she's the head engineer.
0:24:38 But when we passed that in front of planning and zoning,
0:24:43 it was such a win-win, everyone felt,
0:24:47 that Gary Young, who was the head of the engineer,
0:24:51 came around here, picked me up and twirled me around.
0:24:54 I want to see Jackie.
0:24:55 Thank you.
0:24:57 Thank you, thank you both very much.
0:25:01 Next item on the agenda is the consent calendar.
0:25:03 I'll turn that over to the council's wishes.
0:25:07 approval second we have motion on for the consent calendar by Greg landing
0:25:15 seconded by Suzanne Hawkins any questions comments on the consent calendar
0:25:21 I'm the motion the Adler will call vote for Suzanne Hawkins yes Jim yes yes
0:25:29 Sean Burger yes yes yes Greg Lansing yes Don Hall yes Rebecca Mills with that yes
0:25:37 motion passes seven to zero moving under items for consideration the first
0:25:42 item is a presentation of a green product usage award to the City Council
0:25:47 and presentation will be done or by John Kate so welcome John to mayor and
0:26:02 council tonight Mark Thompson and I are just gonna present the council with
0:26:08 of this award that we've received recently.
0:26:12 Mark is a street supervisor who wrote our street
0:26:15 carment dean, couldn't be here tonight,
0:26:17 but Mark was very much involved every year
0:26:22 on our seal coat projects.
0:26:24 Also engineering too, Christy Farringer could not be here,
0:26:27 and I was hoping she could be here to help present.
0:26:30 As you know, each year we have seal coat projects,
0:26:34 and as a part of our zone maintenance program,
0:26:36 we have several different tools
0:26:38 we can use to stretch our dollar.
0:26:41 You know, we do a chip seal, slurry seal, overlays.
0:26:45 And this past year we used fox seal.
0:26:49 We got almost 50 lane miles worth of fox seal done in zone two.
0:26:55 And we use it because it's a good product.
0:26:59 It's inexpensive.
0:27:01 And once it's inlay, it's free green.
0:27:03 So we earned an award for it.
0:27:06 and all the information's in here,
0:27:07 and once you have any other questions,
0:27:09 I guess we'll present this.
0:27:11 Do we have any questions from Council?
0:27:14 Chris, talk.
0:27:15 No, I just like to have a reiteration.
0:27:18 Maybe John, you can do that.
0:27:19 Of the impact upon the quote global warning
0:27:22 by the use of that product.
0:27:24 I think it's a public interest to know
0:27:26 how significant that is.
0:27:31 I can loan you my cover letter, if you like, yeah?
0:27:34 You got it?
0:27:34 There's a few things on here.
0:27:36 I can elaborate on the global warming.
0:27:39 49% potential reduction as compared to other asphalt products, acidification,
0:27:45 eutrophication, eco-toxicity, and smog, I'll have 49% reduction.
0:27:51 Some of those, I don't even know what they are.
0:27:54 Two on this.
0:27:58 You could have told us anything we would have.
0:28:03 Is this a product that has been used by other municipalities in highway districts?
0:28:08 It's been around for probably 20 years.
0:28:10 And it's cost-effective.
0:28:12 It is.
0:28:13 So why wouldn't everyone use it?
0:28:34 Come down.
0:29:02 Accept this on behalf of the city council, as well as the city.
0:29:05 So thank you very much, gentlemen.
0:29:07 Next item on the agenda is presentation
0:29:10 to the city council of two awards
0:29:12 for the, from the International Economic Development Council.
0:29:16 We have our city manager, Travis Rethweinner.
0:29:19 So I'm gonna present one award,
0:29:20 and then I'm going to ask Melinda to present the other one.
0:29:25 So we've often said that economic development is a team sport.
0:29:30 But at the front of every team, there's a leader.
0:29:33 And we had a project that received one of the highest awards
0:29:38 that a project can receive by the International Economic
0:29:41 Development Council, IEDC, which we're a member of.
0:29:45 Melinda Anderson, if you could please come up.
0:29:48 So Melinda, really led, spearheaded, guided,
0:29:53 and drove an agreement home that really caused not only the Glendia headquarters and cheese
0:30:02 innovation facility to be located downtown.
0:30:05 But I think that what we've seen also is really a resurgence of growth and opportunity because
0:30:13 of the number of people that have come downtown.
0:30:15 And again, even though we follow economic development as a team sport, Melinda was a champion and
0:30:21 that you really led this project from start to finish,
0:30:26 and it is incredibly successful today.
0:30:29 So if we could have the mayor come down.
0:30:34 And the plaque says 2014 International Economic Development
0:30:39 Council Gold Award presented to the City of Flint Falls
0:30:43 in recognition of its Columbia headquarters
0:30:45 and Cheese Innovation Center for business retention
0:30:48 and expansion single event category.
0:31:03 I'm John Schoske, peer of the royal board,
0:31:18 and I'm good on these slides.
0:31:19 And thanks everyone.
0:31:37 This was a real honor for the City of Twin Falls to get this honor.
0:31:43 This means that we have the best project for business retention expansion project in the
0:31:49 entire world since IEDC is an international organization.
0:31:54 So that means a lot to a community of 45,000 people.
0:31:59 We were up against all kinds of competition for this, and this really was really exciting
0:32:06 for me to be able to accept it on behalf of the city when we were in Fort Worth a couple
0:32:11 weeks ago.
0:32:12 So, it was a great project, as Travis mentioned, it has meant a lot to have Columbia, and their
0:32:22 employees downtown, it's really that along with St. Luke's and the expansion of First
0:32:27 and their bank has really led to a lot of new local small businesses opening up.
0:32:32 So that's what's really exciting about this.
0:32:34 And then their expansion will just lead to more redevelopment in downtown.
0:32:38 So this is such a win-win for all of us.
0:32:42 Greg Lanning.
0:32:44 Congratulations, one of the first.
0:32:46 I got to go back last year when you won a different award.
0:32:49 What week are you going to get to go this year?
0:32:51 I was asked to go, but I didn't want to.
0:32:55 I'm tight.
0:32:58 Just to a continuation of what you were saying, Linda, I was talking to one of the local business owners who has people contacting him often about finding space in downtown, and they really are running out of space downtown for new businesses, and that's exactly where we wanted to be when I got
0:33:19 on here nine years ago and I think well before that that was the goal so we
0:33:25 appreciate your efforts thank you well said Greg congratulations one and then
0:33:29 congratulations to the city and and the URA and everyone that has been involved
0:33:35 in this what an exciting time for us in the city I'm gonna present the same
0:33:40 award if it's okay with a council to the urban new agency next Monday at their
0:33:44 monthly board meeting.
0:33:45 Please do.
0:33:46 That sounds great.
0:33:48 So you're on next.
0:33:53 So we were double award winners in Fort Worth a couple of weeks ago.
0:33:58 We also had submitted an award application for the work that we did to help convince Cliff
0:34:06 Bar to construct their first bakery here in America here in Twin Falls.
0:34:13 As Travis mentioned earlier, this is a economic development is a team sport.
0:34:18 And this award really also really shows that as well.
0:34:22 This award from IEDC is a bronze award.
0:34:26 We got robbed, but it's a bronze award presented at the City of Twin Falls in recognition of
0:34:32 the Cliff Bar Campaign Special Purpose Prip-O-Shure.
0:34:36 So as you recall, we had two specific brochures were developed for that campaign.
0:34:45 was a community guide and one was a business guide. And folks like Josh Palmer, Travis, Sean
0:34:51 Berriger, and Jen Rogers were really instrumental in developing those two brochures. I should have
0:34:58 brought copies of those with me that I know you've seen them before. They're really amazing.
0:35:03 What's really amazing to me is we did this in-house. With us as a community, we were in
0:35:09 a competition of communities, a size of 25,000 up to 200,000.
0:35:15 And we still won an award for these great brochures,
0:35:20 because they were really, truly amazing.
0:35:22 One of the things that we loved about them
0:35:24 was it really showed how Twin Falls and our community,
0:35:29 as well as our seven parts of our strategic plan 2030 fit in
0:35:38 to help Cliff Bar understand how it fits their five aspirations.
0:35:41 So that was one of the things that this group that put it together
0:35:45 were really instrumental in helping Cliff Bar understand
0:35:48 how well we meshed together.
0:35:51 So I'd like to present this award to Joshua Palmer.
0:35:55 If you'd come up and accept it, please.
0:36:06 I should have really liked what you said, if you were to fuel it, please.
0:36:32 Look at some of us because we were, I remember I recall one point at like 2 a.m. one morning
0:36:36 we were all kind of in a room drinking down as much Starbucks copies, we couldn't stay
0:36:40 awake trying to figure out how we could translate, was it total Bailey solids or something, into
0:36:47 layman's terms and I shut down it was like you know see the city staff as hard as
0:36:54 they work late into the night and in early tomorrow early in the morning
0:36:59 and to really bring all this stuff together and to sacrifice a lot of time
0:37:03 from you know their personal lives and their families so we can benefit the
0:37:07 community is really an amazing thing to see from the inside and I think probably
0:37:10 one of the things I've said a few times over is I wouldn't mind being a reporter
0:37:14 again so I can write the story the way it went from the inside. So, sacrifice by the whole team.
0:37:21 Thank you Josh and thank you for your effort and you're exactly right. When you get to see this
0:37:28 from the inside, watch the dedication of our city staff in the many hours, many, many hours
0:37:35 that they dedicate to these endeavors. Folks, you don't understand. It's economic development is a,
0:37:41 I've heard you call it a different kind of sport before, but it is definitely a team
0:37:46 sport and it takes a lot of effort and we obviously have the best staff and the work
0:37:53 that we appreciate all their effort.
0:37:57 Sean Berner.
0:37:59 So congratulations to everybody on the team here for this.
0:38:02 I think it's also important to note that we weren't the only organization in the region
0:38:06 to receive awards at this conference.
0:38:08 Southern Idaho Economic Development Organization also received a Gold Award for the Operation
0:38:14 Facelift Program that they've been doing for several years, which for those of you who don't
0:38:19 know is a two-week regional downtown revitalization program.
0:38:24 We've had a couple of projects in our downtown that have been part of that in the past.
0:38:28 Truthfully, some of the smaller communities in the region really rally around that and
0:38:32 have done a great job.
0:38:33 So, CDU was recognized with the Gold Award for that multi-year economic development category.
0:38:39 Thank you for bringing that to our attention, John.
0:38:41 Absolutely well deserved on their behalf as well.
0:38:45 Moving to the next item on the agenda is consideration of a request from Jeff and Candy
0:38:49 Hanchey to waive the non-conforming building expansion permit process for our home located
0:38:55 at 3211B Falls Avenue East and we have Mitch Humble.
0:39:04 So, I don't really have any awards or anything to hand out, but this is fun stuff, too.
0:39:15 So, we have a home that was built out here on the falls.
0:39:18 You can see the home, the property boundaries that is in red around the property here.
0:39:22 Falls Avenue, this is about maybe an eighth of a mile east of Hankins.
0:39:29 So, this is in our area of impact. It's not in the city limits, but we do do building permits, stuff in our area of impact.
0:39:36 This home was built in 55 long before we had a zone where it set side yard and rear
0:39:43 yard setbacks.
0:39:44 And if you can see from the exhibit here there's two corners of the home that are kind of outlined
0:39:47 in red.
0:39:48 Those are places where this home, once we did get around to adopting setbacks where the
0:39:53 home was actually inside the setback.
0:39:56 And so this is what we're going to call a legal nonconforming building.
0:40:00 The owners would like to add on a 500 foot addition.
0:40:05 That's in the light blue there.
0:40:08 We can see from the exhibit here that the addition is going to meet the setback on the side yard.
0:40:14 And there's no problem with the addition of being permitted, except that it's an unconformed building.
0:40:20 And so we have a process center code that allows homeowners to come in and request that the council leave this lengthy hearing process to grant this permit.
0:40:30 And we've seen these before in fact, these have come in last week.
0:40:34 And this is the kind of homework,
0:40:36 traditionally the council has looked at these and said,
0:40:38 well, okay, it's not further encroaching.
0:40:40 There's no other encroachments being proposed here.
0:40:42 So we looked on this favorably in the past.
0:40:45 And I don't see this being any different.
0:40:47 So with that, we would just, right when the council
0:40:51 take a look at this and make a decision,
0:40:53 whether we want to wait this or not.
0:40:55 And I believe that happens.
0:40:59 Are they all right?
0:40:59 Yeah, I was told they were coming,
0:41:01 but I hadn't met with them.
0:41:02 Anyway, so I forget any questions we're happy to answer.
0:41:05 Just real quick again to clarify,
0:41:07 this isn't something that also needs
0:41:09 because it's out in the area of the impact,
0:41:11 it doesn't need to go to the County Commission.
0:41:13 We have a jurisdiction on these types of events, right?
0:41:16 So this is a permit action here,
0:41:18 and then we have jurisdiction for permits
0:41:20 in the area of impact.
0:41:22 Very good, thank you.
0:41:23 Chris, talking.
0:41:24 So Mitch on the one encroachment,
0:41:27 I guess it would be the West Boundary,
0:41:29 Does that actually about the property line?
0:41:34 It's, so I put a different exhibit up here for you.
0:41:37 It's a few feet off.
0:41:39 The dash line on the left side of the picture, there's the seven foot side yard building line
0:41:43 and you can see that the little tiny corner of the house goes into that seven feet a bit,
0:41:48 but it doesn't quite make it all the way to the property line.
0:41:51 So we're going to count, I would guess, here five ish, four or five feet off.
0:41:56 Thank you.
0:41:58 Jim.
0:41:59 May I move to approve the request from Jeff and Candy,
0:42:02 hand to you to waive the nonconforming building expansion permit?
0:42:05 Say, the motion on board by Jim Munn, seconded by Greg Blanting
0:42:10 to approve as presented, and Rebecca Nelson.
0:42:14 Thank you, Mayor.
0:42:16 I just wanted to add that I think it's a reasonable request
0:42:19 and appreciate the letter that you gave to us with more
0:42:22 information that you've informed your neighbors
0:42:25 and they're agreeable to it.
0:42:27 And boy, we better get this expansion for those four girls.
0:42:32 Has someone who grew up with three girls in the family,
0:42:35 non-nuff rooms and non-nuff bathrooms.
0:42:37 I completely support your expansion.
0:42:40 But I think it's reasonable as it doesn't further
0:42:43 encroach upon the setback and you are meeting the side
0:42:46 yard setback, so I'm in support of it.
0:42:49 Okay, thank you.
0:42:51 Anything further on the motion council?
0:42:54 The aye, the roll call, roll please.
0:42:56 Jim Mun?
0:42:56 Yes.
0:42:57 Yes.
0:42:58 Yes.
0:42:59 Chris Tockens.
0:43:00 Yes.
0:43:01 Greg Lenting.
0:43:02 Yes.
0:43:03 Don Hall.
0:43:04 Yes.
0:43:05 Rebecca Mills-Wikeens.
0:43:06 Yes.
0:43:07 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:43:08 Yes.
0:43:09 Motion passes.
0:43:10 Seven to zero.
0:43:11 Thank you folks for coming out.
0:43:12 And don't be shy.
0:43:13 You can leave it anytime.
0:43:14 So.
0:43:15 Yeah.
0:43:16 It's very exciting.
0:43:17 Yeah.
0:43:18 It's a pretty exciting year.
0:43:19 Yeah.
0:43:20 She sets up a good year.
0:43:22 Yeah.
0:43:23 We probably don't want.
0:43:24 I probably don't want no one.
0:43:26 Next item on the agenda is discussion and possible action
0:43:29 on an ordinance of the City Council of the City
0:43:32 of Twin Falls, Idaho, providing a local background checks
0:43:35 for all personnel serving as officers and or members
0:43:39 of all City of Twin Falls Advisory Commission.
0:43:43 Travis Roth, welcome back.
0:43:45 Mr. Members, the council before you
0:43:46 is the ordinance that we talked about last week,
0:43:49 placing the background requirement
0:43:52 into a code section under chapter two,
0:43:57 that section two of our current municipal code.
0:44:00 As the staff report indicates from council action,
0:44:03 we started doing background checks in May of 2012,
0:44:07 and we've continued that through as a matter
0:44:09 of practice and policy.
0:44:11 This ordinance simply formalizes that policy
0:44:14 that we've put into place.
0:44:16 Last week, we talked about what a background check does,
0:44:18 and it does talk about some of those larger incidents
0:44:22 is that would appear on those registry sectors as individuals who may be a sex offender and
0:44:28 the like.
0:44:29 So we also have members of our police department that can talk about those in greater detail
0:44:33 and I'm sure the councilman could also add to that as well.
0:44:36 So if there aren't any conversations, we would ask the council to consider this action
0:44:41 this evening.
0:44:44 Travis, before we go on, I'm just going to reiterate what I said to council before regarding
0:44:48 the background.
0:44:49 I really believe that this is the right thing to do.
0:44:54 First of all, it's the right thing to do.
0:44:55 It's to help protect our community and our children and others.
0:45:01 But I believe that we should do background checks
0:45:05 on not only the appointments, but the reappointment
0:45:08 whenever someone is reappointed as well.
0:45:11 So I'll just throw that out for discussion and possible action,
0:45:16 but I feel fairly strongly about that.
0:45:20 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:45:21 Thank you.
0:45:22 I haven't just curious how this is going to affect the Youth Council.
0:45:25 I don't think we want to do background checks on eighth graders.
0:45:36 There should never, there won't be background checks on anyone under 18 because there are
0:45:43 no crimes committed by persons under that age.
0:45:47 So it just goes without, it doesn't need to be clarified anywhere.
0:45:51 I don't think so.
0:45:52 I mean, if you want us to specifically do that,
0:45:55 but at least part of it will tell you
0:45:56 that we don't have anything left.
0:45:59 Thank you.
0:46:01 Question regarding that, what about the,
0:46:03 we do have youth council that are over 18 only,
0:46:06 that are still in high school?
0:46:07 Some of them do turn 18 that senior year before they graduate,
0:46:10 yes.
0:46:11 I might need an adjustment, I just thought.
0:46:14 Chris talking to me.
0:46:15 Ordinance number, I don't know.
0:46:18 3080.
0:46:19 Pardon?
0:46:20 3080.
0:46:22 What do you want done?
0:46:23 Well, I was hoping that we could have a little more discussion
0:46:26 before we make the motion, but...
0:46:28 We can always amend the Sherwin Ordinance.
0:46:31 I'd like to get on the board.
0:46:32 I would move to place ordinance, whatever it is,
0:46:35 at 40-80?
0:46:36 30-80. 30-80.
0:46:37 On third and final by title only under suspension rules.
0:46:42 Second.
0:46:43 From motion on the floor by Chris Daughigan,
0:46:45 seconded by Greg Lanting as stated.
0:46:51 Rebecca Melsoika.
0:46:53 Well, I can wait till after we vote on the third and final.
0:46:58 to discuss that.
0:47:00 Thank you, all of you.
0:47:01 So if we want to amend it, we can amend it after third and final.
0:47:05 OK, then I'm good with that.
0:47:08 All right.
0:47:09 I have lots of lights on.
0:47:11 I guess I'm going to wait on the lights and just go ahead
0:47:17 and vote on third and final.
0:47:19 Sean Berriger.
0:47:20 Yes.
0:47:22 Chris Chalkington.
0:47:22 Yes.
0:47:23 Greg Latin.
0:47:24 Yes.
0:47:25 Don Hall.
0:47:26 Yes.
0:47:27 Rebecca Nilsuica.
0:47:28 Yes.
0:47:29 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:47:30 Yes.
0:47:31 Jim Munn.
0:47:32 Yes.
0:47:33 Motion passes.
0:47:34 7-0.
0:47:35 Rebecca Milsoyka.
0:47:36 Thank you, Mayor.
0:47:39 I apologize.
0:47:40 I was out of town when I guess the Council first discussed this.
0:47:44 A couple of questions I have is, you know, what are we looking for?
0:47:49 You know, what disqualifies someone from, you know, I guess it would depend on the
0:47:54 committee that they want to be a part of.
0:47:58 You know, I don't really see any harm in doing these background checks, but I'm not sure I see a benefit either, especially for a larger committee, kind of like the one we had today, the facilities committee.
0:48:13 I mean, that's an advisory commission, so to speak, that has like 30 people.
0:48:19 And just doing all those background checks, I'm just not sure what the benefit of that would be or what we're looking for.
0:48:26 I mean, I understand, you know, people who work with kids,
0:48:29 we certainly want to screen those guys, but I'm not.
0:48:33 You'll see by the ordinance,
0:48:34 we didn't make any prejudge from about what would disqualify.
0:48:38 This information would go to you,
0:48:39 and you would use that information
0:48:41 to decide whether to vote for or against that appointment
0:48:45 or something.
0:48:48 So I would leave that up to you.
0:48:50 I don't know what you would vote for.
0:48:52 Right, yeah, and so I guess it's just a question
0:48:54 that I have in my mind for the council.
0:48:55 I certainly don't want to just go through the motions
0:48:58 to feel better about it, you know, I mean,
0:49:00 especially as there is staff time involved, you know,
0:49:04 like I said, you know, I don't think there's any harm,
0:49:06 but I really don't see the benefit either,
0:49:08 especially in our larger commissions, you know,
0:49:10 I'm not sure what would disqualify someone from,
0:49:13 you know, something like that.
0:49:15 On the, on the, like the,
0:49:17 Civilities Committee, no appointments I believe are made
0:49:22 to those, so there would never be background checks made
0:49:25 on those.
0:49:25 Okay, so this doesn't qualify for unless they elect some officers and then those persons would be checked
0:49:32 Today, I think they voted for
0:49:35 Chairman three chairman with that then those persons would qualify
0:49:39 Okay
0:49:41 Thank you
0:49:43 Jim
0:49:44 I thank you mayor and I did notice what is conspicuous in this absence this ordinance is any sort of
0:49:51 specifics on what would or would not
0:49:53 allow someone to serve in this capacity. I think that that gives us, I see a great
0:50:00 benefit in doing this. Having as a former police officer, we know that there are
0:50:08 people who may want to serve in certain capacities in city government, in city
0:50:11 commissions that may have a background check that would not make them suitable
0:50:15 for volunteering in that capacity. So I think it's absolutely, I see there's
0:50:22 great benefit. One of the issues I'm struggling with a little bit is the youth council issue.
0:50:29 The youth, if there's people who are on the youth council who are over 18 years old and
0:50:35 or I guess migrating out, one real quick question before I yield, is this, are you out of the
0:50:43 commission at a certain age, the youth council?
0:50:46 You're out on graduation your senior year. Some of them do turn 18 during their senior
0:50:50 year before they graduate. Not all of them, but some of them do.
0:50:57 Because I think if you're over 18 years old, you should be subject to the background. You
0:51:01 have to serve in the commission. You have to try to figure that out.
0:51:06 So with that, most of these kids have already served their five years, turn 18 and have a
0:51:10 month or two left and they're gone. So by that point, they've already done their service
0:51:15 and I don't see why we would pay for a background check when they've been there that many years
0:51:20 and they're moving out just personally.
0:51:23 I don't know what we're going to gain from that because they're waiting.
0:51:26 My only concern is unless they're committed to sex crime.
0:51:30 You know what I mean?
0:51:31 That's how you enter out here.
0:51:32 I mean, so I think I'm going to lean towards if you're over 18, you get checked.
0:51:38 Great whispered in my ear while we were discussing this.
0:51:40 Do we appoint them or are they just selected?
0:51:44 It's very similar to the way the senior citizens, committee was and so on and so forth.
0:51:51 Even our facilities group where it's we invite individuals of interest to participate and then their leadership is selected by those who are in attendance.
0:52:01 So the only person it would probably affect would be President, Vice President.
0:52:06 And if they're over 18, as Jim said.
0:52:09 Well, your president's going to be a senior.
0:52:11 So.
0:52:12 Potential that he's over 18, or she's over 18.
0:52:15 Jim?
0:52:16 Well, yeah, I just want to continue.
0:52:17 If we don't include those students or those kids
0:52:21 who are over 18 years old on this,
0:52:23 then it kind of nullifies or makes this ordinance
0:52:28 kind of useless.
0:52:28 But we're saying, if you're on the youth council
0:52:31 and you're over 18, you don't need the background check,
0:52:33 because we know you're only serving a couple of months,
0:52:35 regardless of what sort of criminal behaviors
0:52:37 you may or may not be involved in.
0:52:39 But everybody else has to.
0:52:41 So I think that it would be who of us
0:52:44 to include anybody over 18,
0:52:48 regardless of what commission you're on,
0:52:50 or it cheapens or makes the thesis
0:52:53 to have this ordinance in place at all somewhat weakened.
0:53:00 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:53:01 Thank you.
0:53:03 I don't have a problem with having our 18-year-olds
0:53:05 background check, but to me it seems like a really waste
0:53:09 of time and energy because they've already served five years
0:53:13 without being checked.
0:53:14 And now because they have a birthday,
0:53:15 we're going to check them before they go out the door.
0:53:17 I mean, for some of them, it could be a week or two
0:53:19 before they're graduating out and moving on.
0:53:22 They're really, by that point, just finishing to leave.
0:53:25 So it's kind of hard to justify how they can serve
0:53:29 for five years and now, oops, it's your birthday.
0:53:31 Go get checked.
0:53:33 I just kind of struggle with that.
0:53:35 Travis, you want to make comment?
0:53:37 I don't see this ordinance saying that the minute you turn 18,
0:53:43 we are going to give them a sheet of paper
0:53:45 to do a background check.
0:53:47 unless they are starting their appointment
0:53:49 for the very first time.
0:53:51 Because what it says is that all persons
0:53:53 proposed for appointment or election,
0:53:56 that tells me that those individuals
0:53:59 are just coming on, or in, as the mayor talked about,
0:54:03 maybe getting re-appointed to that position or that role.
0:54:07 And so if someone who's been serving for a period of time
0:54:11 turns 18 midway through their term,
0:54:14 I don't see us using this to then start a background check.
0:54:20 Greg Lenny.
0:54:22 Well, I figured I better talk since I'm kind of the one
0:54:24 to open up the scanner worms when I was elected to be mayor.
0:54:28 And I made the decision at that time
0:54:32 to have my appointment, any appointments
0:54:35 I made have a background check, because mainly
0:54:41 for the embarrassment of the city, as well as the safety
0:54:43 of those who were on Parks and Rec,
0:54:46 is what came to my mind, but also an embarrassment to me that if I appointed somebody that had
0:54:51 a sexual charge or whatever, and I was at that point since I was having it done before
0:54:57 I made the appointment, I guess I was making the decision whether or not it affected my
0:55:02 appointment and I would probably have taken it back to the committee that selected them
0:55:06 for the appointment because we always have a committee that helps the mayor and let them
0:55:10 know of that what we found out.
0:55:13 And plus it seemed, and as many had talked about it after talking to the chief and things,
0:55:18 well maybe I talked to the chief, I can remember, I seem like I did, that most people if they
0:55:24 had something on their record they really didn't want to expose would probably decline
0:55:28 the appointment if they knew there was going to be a background check.
0:55:31 And so there probably wouldn't even be that opportunity that we would actually find something
0:55:36 on people.
0:55:37 And there are things out there that would show up on a background check that I will use this
0:55:42 this example. When they first brought background checks into the schools for teachers and
0:55:48 administrators and things, they kind of did a funny reel. If you were less than three years,
0:55:54 then you got a background check for your more than three. They didn't. I never thought that
0:55:59 made sense, but that's the way it was. And then any new hires. And the only person that
0:56:03 came back with anything was a superintendent, because he was less than three years and things,
0:56:08 And it was a bar fight when he was in college.
0:56:11 And so I'm not sure that would disqualify somebody if I was making the appointment.
0:56:16 So I am, like Jim, I'm a firm believer that this is something that makes sure that we're
0:56:23 keeping not only the other members of commissions safe from people.
0:56:30 We don't want to be appointed.
0:56:33 And I was all right appointing if the one they turned 18, it was the officers, but if it
0:56:36 reach differently, I think I'm all right. I'm with Suzanne on that one. I'm good either way.
0:56:41 Chris, talking to me. Well, I work with this juvenile population. We're talking about
0:56:46 the good and the bad and the few bad apples can really taint a good program. I'm much
0:56:52 inclined to go on the edge of, in very cautious. And if an appointee turns 18 and he serves some
0:57:01 time with us, it would appear that we could just do a local background check since he has
0:57:06 not or she has not moved from Missouri instead of the full caliber one.
0:57:13 But I'm sorry for the naivety of my fellow council people that don't think this was any
0:57:17 problem.
0:57:19 Some of the charges that the juveniles have will not be expunged by the age and majority,
0:57:26 And those are the ones that were really focused on, not the ones who had a beer or two when
0:57:32 there were 16 or something.
0:57:34 But I really think we need to be extra cautious.
0:57:37 But again, if there are only a few months left on a person's term that served for a while,
0:57:42 the cursory and local check will take care of most of that.
0:57:46 Let's be careful.
0:57:47 John Bearer.
0:57:48 I think the general comment I would make is, I think, erring on the side of consistency is
0:57:54 probably better than trying to cherry pick which commission should or shouldn't have background
0:58:01 checks. A question I would have, so suppose a youth at 16 were charged as an adult and had
0:58:10 a criminal charge, would that show up on a background check even though they weren't 18
0:58:17 yet? Because I think the concern is, if they were
0:58:20 were waved into adult court, they would have it at the right.
0:58:23 So I guess the concern is we want to make sure
0:58:27 that we don't end up with someone on any commission,
0:58:31 but maybe in particular, the Youth Council,
0:58:33 who has crimes that might be dangerous to other members
0:58:38 of the commission or certainly in the work they do.
0:58:41 And this is a local check we're doing.
0:58:44 It's not like we're spending oodles of money to go out
0:58:47 and do it.
0:58:47 And if you punch in the kid's name
0:58:49 and they don't come up in the system, then there's nothing there.
0:58:52 Yeah, a little bit of danger there, though,
0:58:54 is some kids may come up in the system,
0:58:57 but they're handled through the juvenile court.
0:59:00 There could be an order from the juvenile judge
0:59:01 to see all the records, and it makes that difficult.
0:59:08 That would not happen if they weren't
0:59:09 waived into adult court to be tried as an adult.
0:59:13 And those are the ones we're talking about in a prodding.
0:59:16 I guess, again, my comment would be,
0:59:18 if we're going to have the ordinance,
0:59:20 If we're going to have the procedure and the policy, I think we ought to apply it consistently.
0:59:24 And for the Youth Council, it's really their elected officers because those are the only ones that we're approving.
0:59:29 And it's at the time of appointment not going and chasing them down afterwards.
0:59:35 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:59:37 I understand the concern, but at the same time, I want to respect our youth a little bit too.
0:59:43 And we do have high standards and qualifications before you can even apply to be a Youth Council member.
0:59:48 So we do head some of that off at the beginning.
0:59:51 You have to have a certain GPA.
0:59:52 You have to have recommendations from your principal, your parents, your teachers, and
0:59:57 other things that we have in place for that commission that no other commission has to
1:00:01 go through to be a part of.
1:00:03 And I can just tell you from past experience, those kids police each other.
1:00:07 They have high integrity and they want their group to be well respected.
1:00:12 And when somebody starts to step out of line, I've seen them correct each other.
1:00:16 And I mean, I'm talking little things, nothing major.
1:00:20 And I feel like they are already screened to get there because they do have certain standards they have to achieve before they can even apply for membership.
1:00:28 And I just, I don't see what we're going to gain from a background check with them.
1:00:34 You know, I'm listening to the comments tonight and I certainly appreciate it.
1:00:37 When we start talking about disqualifiers, I think about sex crimes.
1:00:40 I think about crimes of violence.
1:00:44 I think felony drug crimes and so to me those are disqualifiers.
1:00:50 the mayor when they come in front of me, if there was something like that, I would automatically
1:00:54 shut the process down because, again, it is our, my appointment confirmed by the council,
1:01:00 of course.
1:01:01 I guess when I start thinking about the youth, and especially in the leadership role, there's
1:01:06 one day difference between 17 and 18, okay, as far as a birthday.
1:01:13 I spent 12 years as a police officer, I ran the Boys and Girls Club where I was around
1:01:20 youth for years and I can tell you that we have some very serious crimes that take place
1:01:26 from kids all the way down to 12 years old, sex crimes, crimes of violence and so me I guess
1:01:34 As I probably am leaning more towards the consistency is that if they're an officer in any of our advisory capacities or the senior, I think that we need to have a background check.
1:01:51 I don't care if they're 14 or if they're 21 or 65.
1:01:57 I think we should err on the side of caution and to protect our community.
1:02:03 Again, I'm going to reiterate one more time that I believe that we should also
1:02:07 redo these background checks. Again, you're exactly right, they're local. They're
1:02:12 only local, but they do pick up sex crimes for reappointments as well. Because
1:02:19 all it takes is three years, it could be a sex crime or a crime of violence, and
1:02:24 then three years later when we reappoint, they could have done it within those
1:02:28 three years and it wouldn't be on the we haven't checked. So I think it's very
1:02:33 important to do the reappointment. Travis before I go on to council. Mr. Mayor, a
1:02:38 reappointment is considered an appointment because that term has ended so
1:02:42 individuals who would stand for reappointment would be subject to this.
1:02:45 I have to go through that. That works for me then. Travis I wasn't aware of
1:02:49 that so very good. Thank you. So if we want a background check on all people
1:02:54 over 18 the motion or the ordinance is clean at this point.
1:02:59 No, it's all people over 18 all people including when we start
1:03:08 talking about youth or the senior it's the officers.
1:03:11 It's all people either appointed to a board position or elected.
1:03:16 I'm comfortable with anything further on this motion.
1:03:22 further we need to make the vote. We've also got to read them. I've got to vote. I'm sorry. Could you?
1:03:28 Could you read the last year?
1:03:30 Go ahead, the island.
1:03:34 In the ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, lending the Twin
1:03:38 Falls City Code by the addition of a new section 2-1-2, providing for local background checks
1:03:44 for all persons serving as officers and or board members of all City advisory conditions.
1:03:49 It would be ordinance 3080 Greg Lanning move approval of ordinance 3080
1:03:56 We have motion on floor by Greg Lanning
1:04:00 Seconded barely by Chris talking to
1:04:03 Anything further on that motion council before we go to the vote I feel much more comfortable now
1:04:09 I'm glad that we had this
1:04:11 Bay and conversation about it
1:04:14 Makes me feel well
1:04:16 roll call please. Chris talking to us. Greg Lanting. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Rebecca Milsweka. No.
1:04:24 Suzanne Hawkins. No. Jim Mine. Yes. Sean Beroger. Yes. Motion passes. Five to two. Thank you Travis.
1:04:35 Next item on the agenda is brief update on public works projects specifically on the
1:04:41 Hankins Water Tank Project, I-F-A-S,
1:04:44 and Wastewater Treatment Plant Expansion Project,
1:04:47 Troy Vitek.
1:04:49 Vitek.
1:04:51 I would mess your name up, Troy.
1:04:52 I apologize.
1:04:53 And Lee, are you coming up as well, Blaisman?
1:04:56 We both got a process.
1:04:57 OK.
1:04:58 Well, I have Troy first, at least on the agenda.
1:05:01 You're on, Troy.
1:05:11 Evening, council members.
1:05:14 Travis asked me to give you a quick update on the wastewater
1:05:19 treatment plant and what happened on the big pore that I was taught telling you guys about
1:05:26 a few weeks ago. The big pore actually consisted of two. There was one. There were about 750
1:05:32 yards each. They started at the week. It went to one the first time and then did four and
1:05:39 I think they're off by 11 the second time. The slab is enormous. It's two feet thick. The
1:05:45 rebarring is six inches on center so it's easy to walk on. The rebar is one inch of diameter.
1:05:50 It's a massive amount of concrete and valve for the four.
1:05:54 If you went down there today, the picture on the left is actually, as the sun was coming
1:05:59 up on the first port, they have some pumper trucks out there, it's kind of hard to see.
1:06:03 Maybe you're that report, I'll show it a little better, but there's about four concrete trucks,
1:06:08 two pumper trucks, and then a ton of men out there working, they worked in two zones, screaming
1:06:14 that concrete, and it was quite fluent. They did an extremely good job at it. They had
1:06:21 people at the entrance that would tell which concrete truck to go to which
1:06:25 proper truck. They moved in and out very fast. There was a little bit of time lag
1:06:30 to begin with getting the concrete there fast enough, but the concrete
1:06:35 manufacturers overcame that and actually stepped it up and they got down. That's
1:06:39 why it was until one o'clock. So everybody appreciated you shutting down the
1:06:42 There was some pedestrians on it, and I don't think you can stop them all at the same time,
1:06:47 or small to begin with the second or the enlarges after I saw them.
1:06:51 I just didn't think of those were reasonable for people to see.
1:06:55 There were still walkers on the grade then too, but they were minimal, one or two.
1:06:59 And I think the police department was called in to assist in trying to keep people off,
1:07:05 just saying, you know, there was no tickets given, just, hey, can you help us out for today?
1:07:09 I think people generally try to do that.
1:07:13 So if you went down there today,
1:07:14 the picture on the right is what you can see.
1:07:16 They're actually starting to stand walls
1:07:21 with a closer picture of it.
1:07:23 These walls are enormous.
1:07:27 You can see the ground level,
1:07:29 and they have to be in order for the hydraulic gradient
1:07:32 of the water to flow through the plant like that.
1:07:34 They're focusing on the north walls
1:07:35 because they need to set, the concrete needs to set up
1:07:40 before they can start back-filming against it.
1:07:42 And the reason they're focused on those,
1:07:44 which is going to be a building dome adjacent to these north walls, and it's a blower building
1:07:49 that aerates the portion of the I-FAST, so the I-FAST is two systems. One has nowhere
1:07:57 and then the other portion has air, and there's a lot of chemical reasons for that, but that
1:08:02 allows it to go anaerobic in there where we get the same time, and it's very aggressive
1:08:09 technology and so as far as today they are moving and progressing pretty well
1:08:16 we've had minimal change orders construction package one it's completed
1:08:21 now other in some minor housekeeping items and we actually had some rock savings on
1:08:26 that so we're getting a change order executed that actually gives us money
1:08:30 back that money is kind of already allotted for a change in a water line
1:08:36 They water to the headworks building went right through the middle of this excavation.
1:08:43 So we had to find a temporary fix and it is temporarily fixed, but we're going to have
1:08:47 to put an additional water line down there.
1:08:50 So that will be a change order coming in on this project in the future, but it's not there
1:08:54 yet.
1:08:55 That's not the critical path item.
1:08:56 So the progress and great schedules looking pretty good.
1:08:59 They're on time.
1:09:00 I don't think they've, this was originally planned to be eight course for the floor.
1:09:05 minimized it too, but they did that because their schedule is so tight that
1:09:10 they feel that's the only way they can make it so I don't want to give you guys any
1:09:13 false hope that they're giving a head of schedule, but they are on schedule so
1:09:17 very pleased with them. Great contractor work with our construction team down there
1:09:21 CH2M Halo's doing a great job of managing the project and being on site
1:09:25 every day taking photos and making sure they're giving us a quality product at the
1:09:29 So, do you have any questions?
1:09:32 We do, I have one, but Chris talking to us.
1:09:34 I've tried just wondering the tower there,
1:09:37 that maybe already said that I might have missed it.
1:09:39 Does that actually sit on a rock cap?
1:09:41 Looks like a heck of a lot of weight to.
1:09:44 That actually isn't.
1:09:45 It is actually on sand.
1:09:46 Really?
1:09:47 We dug the entire thing.
1:09:48 We had one boulder that was outside of the area
1:09:53 that this was going to be.
1:09:54 That's where we ended up with rock savings.
1:09:56 So that happened to be complete, Sam.
1:09:58 We got extremely lucky that there wasn't even one boulder in all that area that they dug up.
1:10:03 The sand is supporting enough, has enough potential strength.
1:10:08 I think that's the reason why the slab is two feet thick, so it kind of floats at all.
1:10:14 Really, you're just holding it up.
1:10:16 Interesting.
1:10:17 The water above it.
1:10:19 Quick question, how's the road holding up?
1:10:22 The corners, I drove it.
1:10:24 The corners are looking a little bit like they may need to dress to some point that mean road hasn't really been affected at all
1:10:33 How many trucks do you think overall? We're there that day. Oh boy, I guess
1:10:47 So the corners probably could use a little bit they're not bad right now
1:10:51 You know, you're gonna see the normal running as they push around the corners
1:10:55 but not much more than what was originally there.
1:10:58 I think more damage was done when they brought in some big crane equipment in order to put the piles up to make the safe and secure.
1:11:05 They had to breathe some material down in that trailer that they brought it down on, actually kind of gouged.
1:11:12 So that probably did more damage than the trucks did, but the concrete is not done.
1:11:16 They have a mass amount of walls left the porch, so you see the slack going pretty fast.
1:11:23 The walls are slow to go because it's all vertical work.
1:11:26 You can see the guy hanging on the side there.
1:11:28 It's hard to get to your job and they're full safety, OSHA.
1:11:32 So you have to clip off. You never can do the dust up board.
1:11:35 It's really slow, but they're safe and it's a quality project.
1:11:40 Rebecca, may I strike?
1:11:41 Thank you, Mayor. Thanks, Trey.
1:11:43 Just wondering from the information, how tall is that?
1:11:47 I don't know the exact number.
1:11:51 to meet this 24-foot top base of the top.
1:11:57 I see no other questions.
1:12:02 Lee, did you have a portion this evening, sir?
1:12:08 I have a travis also asked if I could put a presentation
1:12:12 on the Hankins' tank on the progress of that,
1:12:17 just to remind everybody where we're at.
1:12:21 This is Kimberly Road.
1:12:22 This is Hankins Road.
1:12:25 Quick Mars way over here in the bottom, Giovanni.
1:12:30 This is our existing tank and reservoir and this is the site where we're building the new tank.
1:12:43 So here's the existing tank, the existing pump station, and this is the location of the
1:12:50 explanation.
1:12:51 Can you put that back up just for size comparison?
1:12:57 Quickly.
1:12:58 Wow.
1:12:59 Stop me whenever you want.
1:13:00 Well, I just think it's incredible the size difference.
1:13:03 Oh, yeah.
1:13:04 It's big tank.
1:13:05 a big tank.
1:13:06 Thank you.
1:13:07 If I move the gallons, I think we don't have another tank of damage, bigger than that, all
1:13:12 our biggest ones are at five.
1:13:16 Once again, the tank itself is mostly below the ground.
1:13:20 I think the exterior walls are somewhere between 15 and 20 feet tall.
1:13:24 When it's all done, we'll have dirt barmed up against it, and it'll be about two feet exposed.
1:13:28 So if you're actually looking at it, once it's constructed, you'll just see this berm
1:13:32 and on top of the tank.
1:13:43 So the most proceed was given on September 8th of 2014, they should be finishing June 2015,
1:13:53 which is still plenty of time to, or sufficient time to meet our agreement with Cliff Barham
1:14:00 Urban Renewal Agency.
1:14:01 This doesn't show up real well, but this is a picture when they start digging the hole.
1:14:06 You see a little berm right there in the center.
1:14:08 What they do is they actually set a center pin where the center of the tank is and they
1:14:16 basically measure off of that so as they're digging around it they move that pin up there
1:14:20 as they dig down around it.
1:14:21 It's kind of interesting look.
1:14:22 I'm hearing they're digging down a little bit further and I have plenty of pictures of
1:14:31 a little.
1:14:32 So you have to try to wind.
1:14:33 Not much rock.
1:14:34 Yeah.
1:14:35 We had a little bit of rock in the east side of the tank but it was anticipated.
1:14:41 We've actually, prior to digging and prior to sitting out to bed, we did a 50-foot grid
1:14:48 of four holes all through that area to know exactly where the rock was ahead of time so
1:14:52 we can measure it really well.
1:14:54 A lot of the projects, you really don't have that opportunity to do that much investigation.
1:14:58 You're doing a really long job, every couple hundred feet as bad as good as it gets, but
1:15:04 this one we did a nice tight grid.
1:15:08 Here's looking down into the hole, and you can see this is the bottom of the excavation,
1:15:14 and these little squares where there's going to be footings.
1:15:19 This lid on the tank doesn't span all the way across without some support, and actually
1:15:24 we'll have columns inside of the tank to help support it.
1:15:32 So this is last week.
1:15:34 They've started putting rebarcked mat down, and you can see along the edge here, they've
1:15:40 We've got the verticals for the walls and once again, so that other shot rush looking
1:15:48 into the bit and how they've got the actual floor and everything all tied up, three more.
1:15:59 Once again, this is going to be the exterior foundation and the wall that's wrapping around
1:16:05 right there.
1:16:07 And here's the really interesting part, this is the rebar.
1:16:12 The vertical rebar, they're actually an epoxy coated rebar.
1:16:15 You look along, this right here is what they call water stop, and everywhere where you have a joint, the tank, you can't pour a tank all in one shot, you're going to have seams.
1:16:25 And so they actually cast into the seams, into the joints, the water stop to help prevent it from leaking, so that's just one of the features.
1:16:33 On the structural side, you get into rebar. These are the footings, like what's in the mat. This is eight inches on center of rebar.
1:16:44 they're got to say there's tons of it as an understatement. There are many, many tons of rebar
1:16:50 in this. They're number five, number five stands for five eighths of an inch all the way through it.
1:16:56 I've got four inches of rebar. You know? You like rebar here. Well, it's interesting.
1:17:05 It is. You don't get to see it after it's built. And with that, any questions, they're on schedule.
1:17:12 They're asking the kind of questions you'd like to hear from a contractor, you know, every time the hard part about it is, is when they do a
1:17:20 porg, they've got to wait a little while before they can do the next porg and the next porg and the next porg.
1:17:24 And so some of the questions are asking right now, is instead of doing this home floor and eight porgs, do we do four?
1:17:30 One of the bigger pieces will bring in more people and it helps them work a little bit more efficiently.
1:17:36 They're trying to get a little head on the schedule, whether it buys them any time or not.
1:17:41 But those are the things that you like to see is that they're really, they're really
1:17:44 hitting hard, they're going fast because they know when the finish line starts coming, it
1:17:49 starts coming up on you quick so they're not hanging out.
1:17:52 They're working pretty diligently with that and any questions.
1:17:57 We have a couple of lights on Greg Lane.
1:17:58 Well thank you Lee.
1:17:59 It's always interesting when the engineers come to meet.
1:18:04 We always learn something without a doubt.
1:18:07 I always learned that I would appreciate that and then just as a general comment, this was
1:18:12 a cooperation between the city and the URA and the Cliff Bar project and it became so apparent
1:18:20 to us whenever we had the power outage about a year and a half ago now, I think it was that
1:18:27 we needed additional storage.
1:18:28 I think Jackie had been hammering us with that a little bit before that, that we needed additional
1:18:33 storage but it certainly became obvious at that point, as I remember Vice Mayor
1:18:38 then Hall and I were sitting in on those meetings trying to decide how long
1:18:43 industry had to stay down and all those kind of things. The overriding thing was
1:18:47 if we had more storage we would have had a lot more options and so I'm being able
1:18:52 to partner with the URA and the Cliff Bar project to bring this to the whole
1:18:58 city and that's what I love about the URA is that it not only helps the industry
1:19:03 you're bringing in but it helps the entire city with these projects and the
1:19:07 funds that we can utilize from that so thank you Lee for your presentation.
1:19:12 Chris talking it. Yeah can't say any better than you Greg that's fine. I'm
1:19:18 wondering about the temperature sensitivity of the concrete
1:19:21 personally are they going to be able to or will they have to halt here when the
1:19:26 ground temp.
1:19:27 No, they really wanted to get the base of it poured before the ground froze.
1:19:34 That was really their most critical piece, so they wanted to get the base completely poured.
1:19:38 You know, once the ground freezes, you start having problems getting defrost.
1:19:43 But once they start working the walls, they'll actually cover that.
1:19:48 No, they'll eat every and everything.
1:19:50 You don't want your temperature to fall below freezing because of the water in the cement.
1:19:53 But are they close to pouring the flooring?
1:19:56 They're looking at pouring this week on Wednesday.
1:20:02 Thank you.
1:20:04 I see no further lights.
1:20:05 Fascinating report from both of you.
1:20:07 Thank you for updating us on that information.
1:20:10 These are sizable projects for the City of Twin Falls.
1:20:14 Thank you for your dedication.
1:20:17 Public input, again, is there anyone here from the community
1:20:20 that would like to address the council?
1:20:22 This is time to do it.
1:20:24 See no one coming forward.
1:20:26 city manager anything further. Mr. Mayor, members of the council, just a quick update.
1:20:35 Today was the very first opportunity that we had to have the citizen facility committee
1:20:40 come and gather. I asked Lee Eilert to give a basic head count and we were thinking there
1:20:46 is somewhere between 35 to 40 individuals that had shown up and it was a good impressive
1:20:54 group and I think that we are going to be expecting really big and exciting things from
1:20:59 them as they continue their roles and continue to move forward. Staff has presented some basic
1:21:08 information today and now we will start sitting in the back rows and we will provide information
1:21:14 as requested moving forward and we hope that this committee, we really do believe this committee
1:21:20 will be able to provide a quality recommendation for the council to consider in the upcoming
1:21:25 weeks. The group set their meeting time. Their meeting times will be on Thursdays. Their
1:21:35 first Thursday that they will meet. It will be on November 13th from 11 30 to 1 o'clock
1:21:41 in this room. In accordance with our transparency, we will set all meetings here, but should there
1:21:48 be field trips and the like, we'll post that and we'll have agendas and we'll continue
1:21:53 to do what we can to notify those so that interested members can come observe, they can come and
1:22:00 participate, they can continue to move forward.
1:22:03 We would suggest that as this committee continues to go forward, should there be anyone else
1:22:08 of interest who wants to participate, it's not too late.
1:22:11 At some point in time, this committee will go down pretty far down the path, but we certainly
1:22:17 don't want to discourage anyone from participating at this early in the lecture.
1:22:21 Thank you, Travis.
1:22:22 And I'd like to call upon a councilman talking
1:22:24 and Chris, you made a suggestion today
1:22:26 because we were talking about council participation
1:22:29 on this committee.
1:22:31 Could you maybe walk through that with the council
1:22:33 and get all of our input on that?
1:22:36 Well, per our transparency, it's a problem.
1:22:40 Any time the majority of us, four of us get together
1:22:42 at any time.
1:22:44 And when Layala asked if we're going
1:22:48 to be at the meeting today and a couple of us responded
1:22:51 And I don't know if everyone that showed up did or not, but I felt very uncomfortable,
1:22:57 first of all, being there and giving the impression that we're trying to direct the conversation.
1:23:05 I think any time we opened our mouths as counsel, we might be confused with getting muddling
1:23:13 the mission of the public that's volunteered for this.
1:23:17 So I guess I just felt that I will back out for two weeks and make sure that there are
1:23:23 no more than three, because I want this really to be as pure of a publicly driven decision
1:23:30 that counts before us, that there are still accusations that the decision has already
1:23:36 been made.
1:23:37 And I had to fight that on radio the other day because of misinformation going out.
1:23:42 And any time that we get around this group, I think retaining the process.
1:23:46 Other than that, I have no opinion on that.
1:23:50 Thank you, Chris.
1:23:52 Rebecca, Bill Seidt.
1:23:53 Thank you, Mayor.
1:23:55 Well, I attended the meeting today,
1:23:57 and I actually think that the transparency resolution
1:24:01 solves the problem.
1:24:02 I think it's not a problem because it's a public meeting.
1:24:06 It's being broadcast online.
1:24:10 I think it's good for the council to be there.
1:24:12 And they asked the committee if anyone objects
1:24:14 or has any concerns with the council being there.
1:24:16 there wasn't any, so I don't really have any concern about it.
1:24:19 I agree with Chris that, you know, if the council is just in attendance, you know, we shouldn't
1:24:24 participate, but to just be there and to soak in the information, and I think the more we
1:24:30 know about it, I think the better.
1:24:33 I think sometimes it's a struggle when the council gets too much distance from a committee,
1:24:39 and we don't know where it's going, and, you know, sometimes the recommendations that calm
1:24:43 kind of take us off guard. So I think it's a good line of communication for the council
1:24:51 to be observing and not necessarily participating or influencing the committee. I agree with
1:24:59 what Don said earlier and Travis that it's a great group of people. I have complete confidence
1:25:06 in them. They asked a lot of good questions today. I know staff will be getting them more
1:25:11 information. So anyway, I don't have any concern with Council showing up because I
1:25:17 mean I don't know if it really matters if you you know watch it online or if
1:25:21 you're sitting there you know I don't think it makes a difference.
1:25:25 Well I chose to not go today on purpose obviously I could have been there I'm
1:25:31 retired and but I was following the same thing we did on the facilities
1:25:37 committee for what to do about our running out of wastewater treatment facilities and that
1:25:45 committee.
1:25:46 And I attended those as mayor but made very certain that I did not contribute in any way.
1:25:53 I wanted them to come forth with their decisions based on theirs.
1:25:57 I didn't want to be leading them now ever once in all somebody asked me a question in private
1:26:01 at the back of the room setting next to me and I rarely was able to not say something
1:26:06 back to them, but I think that's the important part of Council members to be there. I think
1:26:11 it's really important that they not be participating that that's the key part. And so I will choose
1:26:19 not to attend this one. I chose I went to the other one strictly because I felt that we should
1:26:24 have a Council presence of some variety and then I chose to go as the mayor. But this one
1:26:29 I will let them come forth with recommendations to us unfettered by my opinions at that time.
1:26:36 Suzanne Hopkins.
1:26:40 I am attended today's meeting because I was curious to see where this was going to start
1:26:44 and lead from sitting through it.
1:26:47 I kind of felt like maybe some people weren't comfortable opening up because council members
1:26:51 were there.
1:26:52 That was my intake just from watching.
1:26:53 I know a lot of them said that they liked having us there, but I just think sometimes
1:26:58 because it's kind of intimidating for people to speak from their heart when they feel like
1:27:02 they might be judged for what they're saying.
1:27:05 And so, you know, if the council wants participation there, I'm more than happy to attend the meetings.
1:27:11 But my gut feeling from leaving today was it's probably better to let them run it without
1:27:16 us intruding on their territory.
1:27:18 And so that was kind of my feeling on it.
1:27:22 You know, I personally will probably not go there to very many of these meetings because
1:27:27 because I think that it's very important for this committee to work through the issues.
1:27:33 We've had the opportunity to work through some of the issues already.
1:27:36 We've been discussing this for quite some time.
1:27:39 And we have more than a capable city staff to be able to bring them information because
1:27:45 us who brought us information when we were starting to go down the road regarding facilities.
1:27:50 I just think it's really important for this committee to be able to come to their conclusion
1:27:57 without too much input from the council.
1:28:02 I think we want to hear what they have to say and what their recommendations are.
1:28:08 And like Rebecca said, wow, and the two of you were there today.
1:28:12 What a great committee.
1:28:13 Honestly, great leaders of our community.
1:28:16 And I made the comment today, some faces that were unknown to me.
1:28:20 And I think that's a really positive thing, because it's usually the same suspects every
1:28:25 time.
1:28:26 They're the ones that step up and help us every time and God bless them.
1:28:29 But we have some fresh perspectives in the room, I think.
1:28:31 And I'm really looking forward to hearing what they have to say.
1:28:34 So I think it's a exciting, exciting process.
1:28:37 Rebecca Melsoica.
1:28:38 Thank you, Mary.
1:28:39 And I would add to that, I noticed the same thing to see new people.
1:28:42 People I didn't know their name or who they were.
1:28:45 And I think that is a great thing about having these open committees.
1:28:48 I think people feel more welcome.
1:28:50 I think they feel it's more accessible.
1:28:53 Like they're not gonna be put on the spot
1:28:54 like they can just attend and participate
1:28:56 as they feel comfortable.
1:28:59 But I like that.
1:28:59 I think that's what's really positive
1:29:01 about these kind of come one, come all meetings.
1:29:05 And I think it's really a good way to go.
1:29:07 I also wanted to mention that we have stated
1:29:12 to our community that you don't have to live
1:29:14 in the city of Twin Falls to attend these meetings.
1:29:17 And I think that's a positive.
1:29:18 I think that just because you're one foot outside the city limits,
1:29:23 doesn't mean that you have any less desire to help with this city.
1:29:28 And because it's important to you.
1:29:30 So we had many members from an area of impact and other communities
1:29:34 that I think that's a positive thing.
1:29:36 This is where people come and shop and entertain and restaurants
1:29:40 and those kind of things.
1:29:41 So I think this is an important thing for them as well.
1:29:45 Anyway, I've turned it over to Council anything further from Council before we move down the list here.
1:29:51 Rebecca, I'm out of sight.
1:29:52 Thank you, Mayor.
1:29:53 I wanted to update the Council as the P&Z liaison.
1:29:57 The P&Z, the Planning and Zoning Commission had a good discussion kind of in the last couple of meetings
1:30:03 about what is alternative landscaping.
1:30:06 So there's a section in our code that says that they can approve an alternative landscaping plan.
1:30:12 But what they found out is that in a board of nine very diverse people, very smart,
1:30:19 you know, well reasoned people, they really didn't know what an alternative landscape plan is,
1:30:25 you know, and I think the applicant is struggling just as much to kind of come up with,
1:30:31 well, you know, what qualifies as a reduction in the square footage of required landscaping.
1:30:37 is it something out of the box like an awning that kind of softens the commercial or industrial
1:30:44 look of a building. And so anyway, they were kind of discussing what they should do about
1:30:49 that and I shared this with the mayor. And so just so the council knows, maybe you can
1:30:53 all be thinking of what you think the solution is. I don't know if we want to have, you know,
1:31:00 not something in the code, but maybe just an example, a list of here are some options
1:31:07 to kind of give you some ideas, you know, pick two or three of these or something like that.
1:31:11 I think more for the applicant, something like that would be beneficial because I think the
1:31:16 commission and the applicant, I mean, no one really knows quite where to start and they
1:31:21 don't, I think what they're struggling with is what is adequate, you know, what is adequate
1:31:25 as an alternative landscaping plan and is it really beneficial if people put a couple
1:31:31 of potting plants out there but then let the plants die, you know, that they're trying
1:31:37 to think of what's a good long-term alternative landscaping plan, so just want to throw that
1:31:42 out to the council if anyone has any ideas or wants to share with Mitch or Travis or us,
1:31:49 if you have any solutions.
1:31:52 You know, they had a really great discussion.
1:31:54 In fact, it was really philosophical, you know, so it was kind of inspiring how deep the
1:31:59 commission went, but they're really trying hard to be fair and to be consistent, but
1:32:03 I think it's really broad and open.
1:32:06 I mean, they really don't have a lot of guidelines to use.
1:32:09 So I thought I'd share that with the council,
1:32:12 so I would love your input or your thoughts.
1:32:14 Thank you, Rebecca.
1:32:15 Before we go on to the next slide,
1:32:17 after Rebecca talked to me about this,
1:32:19 I thought, you know, this is a issue
1:32:21 that we probably should address,
1:32:23 and so I talked a little bit about it.
1:32:24 Could you briefly maybe give us an idea
1:32:26 of the potential direction we might go with this?
1:32:30 Which?
1:32:33 It's looking for direction.
1:32:36 So we did talk about it.
1:32:37 We have a current applicant who's kind of going through this right now with the commission and we've got a work session this Wednesday and we've placed that applicant back on the agenda.
1:32:48 He needs to find some resolution to his deal so he can get moving.
1:32:52 But when Rebecca says we don't have a lot of, I think that's where he works, a lot of direction, there really is no direction in the code at all.
1:32:59 It just says, here you go, you can, it was very generous, right?
1:33:03 Here you go, you can do an alternate, and then there's nothing after that.
1:33:07 And so, my thought was after this conversation on Wednesday that that's what these work sessions
1:33:15 are for, is for us and the commission to really talk about those kinds of issues, and my idea
1:33:23 would be to bring it up as we're talking about it with this particular applicant who, I mean,
1:33:28 It's going to be fresh to everybody's mind what the problem is and maybe ask the commission
1:33:34 what their thoughts are to maybe create a standard code.
1:33:40 I think about it a little bit like our historic preservation overlay district where we have a
1:33:46 code that says you shall come and get a certificate of appropriateness, but then period and then
1:33:53 we move on.
1:33:54 We don't talk about what you do or don't do to get a certificate of appropriateness.
1:33:57 as well as the Start Preservation Commission, in their case,
1:34:00 they created a set of design standards that's separate from the code,
1:34:04 but it's a book that was created by the commission,
1:34:08 and that was brought to the council,
1:34:09 and the council looked at that and approved it for implementation of sorts.
1:34:13 And so that's what the Start Preservation Commission will do now.
1:34:16 They'll review requests as they do or don't comply with these set of standards
1:34:22 that they've created to give people some direction.
1:34:24 And then maybe that's an approach that we can take
1:34:27 with the planning commission on the alternate landscaping.
1:34:30 And of course, we can only do another code amendment
1:34:34 and build it right into the code as well.
1:34:35 I mean, there's different ways you can go.
1:34:41 Some of the things that I thought was interesting
1:34:42 about that conversation was, in my mind,
1:34:45 and this just illustrates, I think, probably the problem.
1:34:49 I viewed the statement in the code
1:34:50 as an alternate landscape plan,
1:34:52 and the code requires some kind of landscape plan,
1:34:55 and we're going to prove a different kind of landscape plan.
1:34:58 But in my mind, it was still a landscape plan.
1:35:01 Well, then the commission talks about maybe you do something
1:35:04 else to beautify the property, like make the building more
1:35:07 interesting as an alternate to landscaping,
1:35:10 if landscaping doesn't work.
1:35:12 And I honestly never went there myself with it,
1:35:15 but it's probably a perfectly appropriate place to go with it.
1:35:20 Maybe landscaping doesn't work on that location,
1:35:22 but the next door location has some bare ground
1:35:26 and you can landscape your neighbor's property
1:35:28 and it might not be your specific,
1:35:30 but it helps in the neighborhood.
1:35:32 Maybe that's acceptable.
1:35:33 Maybe a right-of-way application of landscaping is okay
1:35:36 somewhere.
1:35:37 There's all kinds of alternates once you start thinking
1:35:39 about it and my idea would be to throw it back
1:35:42 on the commission, that's what we're using them for now anyway.
1:35:44 And maybe we can create a book of design standards
1:35:49 for ultimate or something like that
1:35:50 and we'll see where they go if it was my idea.
1:35:53 Thanks, man.
1:35:54 It's your book of ideas.
1:35:55 I think it's appropriate.
1:35:57 Chris, talking to me.
1:35:58 Well, we had quite an important impact advisory committee the other day, and Council needs to
1:36:02 be aware of it.
1:36:03 We have new fees for different classifications of building effective October 1st, I think,
1:36:10 starting everything from residential, not very significant, up to some office retail.
1:36:16 Quite a significant boost.
1:36:18 And I think these were reflective of building fees from around the Northwest, or the history
1:36:25 on that.
1:36:26 I mean, they weren't grabbed out of the air, but the increases represent what the Northwest
1:36:33 sees and theirs.
1:36:35 Well, I think you're talking about the impact fee committee and the fee increases are a direct
1:36:41 result of the projects that we've included in the capital improvement plans.
1:36:47 And it's just a math equation at that point that spits out a fee.
1:36:51 We weren't aiming for a fee, an output, when we went into this process,
1:36:57 we were aiming to make sure that we had the capital improvements that were necessary
1:37:00 to provide for the growth that's coming, and those were the way the fees came out.
1:37:04 But I'll say that with our fees the way they're at now,
1:37:07 they're very reasonable when compared to other communities that have adopted impact fees.
1:37:12 And as a consequence of that, the advisory commission decided not to take the annual CPI, I call it, I think it was a 1.6% bump on top of the building fee increases just too much for one year.
1:37:27 So we will not revisit that for another year. And then I think there are four vacancies now.
1:37:34 Yeah, so let me just clarify a little bit for you.
1:37:37 So the impact fee commission, we met last week
1:37:42 and part of that meeting,
1:37:43 or the reason they have that meeting
1:37:45 is to prepare the annual report
1:37:46 that will come to the council.
1:37:49 And one of the recommendations will be
1:37:51 that we do not increase the fees on January 1st.
1:37:55 And that actually will take an action by the council.
1:37:57 So no action by the council will let the fees increase
1:38:00 by the MCI, which currently sits about one, six or four.
1:38:03 And we brought to us.
1:38:05 My plan was second or third meeting in December sometime before the first of the year.
1:38:10 Would be to bring the people.
1:38:12 And then we'll have people turn out in one resign and I think we're three or four.
1:38:16 We do have four vacant.
1:38:18 This is a combination of people from the building trade as well as at large that are eligible.
1:38:23 So yeah, it's not strenuous work, but it takes a little bit of homework before you get up to speed on this.
1:38:29 anybody that's knowledgeable enough to get into this, they can contribute a lot to our
1:38:36 city process. And just to remind the council again, the concept of impact fees are defensible.
1:38:43 They've been court has stood and found to be legitimate.
1:38:49 We discussed this recently and that's going to be advertised if it's not right now.
1:38:55 which is part of those openings.
1:38:56 So those vacancies are, the appointments that we have
1:39:00 are technically in place like the February or time.
1:39:03 But they won't meet again until April.
1:39:04 So right after the first year,
1:39:06 we'll go through a publishing process
1:39:08 and try to gain some interest in those four seats.
1:39:11 Very good.
1:39:12 Anything further from council,
1:39:13 we do have an adjournment potentially
1:39:15 into executive sessions.
1:39:16 So with that, adjournment into executive session,
1:39:22 In 1967, 2345-1 to consider hiring a public officer, employees, staff member or individual
1:39:29 wherein the respective qualities of individuals are to be evaluated in order to fill a particular
1:39:35 vacancy or need.
1:39:37 This paragraph does not apply to filling a vacancy in an elected office or deliberations
1:39:43 about staffing needs in general.
1:39:44 Be it to consider the evaluation, dismissal or disciplining of or to hear complaints or
1:39:51 or charges brought against the public officer,
1:39:53 employees, staff member, or individual, agent,
1:39:55 or public school students stand for a motion from council.
1:39:59 So moved.
1:40:00 Second.
1:40:01 We have a motion, not a motion.
1:40:05 A motion to adjourn into executive session
1:40:08 by John Berger, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.
1:40:12 Anything further on that motion to council?
1:40:15 The aye of the roll call vote please.
1:40:17 Greg Lanting.
1:40:19 Yes.
1:40:20 Don Hall. Yes.
1:40:21 Rebecca Masleka, yes, Suzanne Hawkins, yes, Jim Munn, yes, Sean Barrier, yes, yes, yes,
1:40:28 yes, yes, motion passes seven to zero just to remind folks we will be going into
1:40:33 executive session, we will not be coming back out this evening and and
1:40:38 reconvening nor will we be making any decisions while we are in executive
1:40:42 session. We are adjourned.
Download
- Transcript (text) 94 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 125 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 171 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.2 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 2.6 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, November 3, 2014. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:40:53.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
bd0063b6fb349ae57139a8806fea4b141357e2ede10310c4c5e020608f697185 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a d77a6dbc37f6ce95f466372aa6bebadc38ad842c8c3f72d0f31dc3bff066ca79
part02.m4a 1002e032f6ec293afbc901e2135aba48b1ef7bfc7b51fc505ff1ea6a21670ee7 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
0a133240808ace430fce631f62507f7dc978553101ca6c3b6d42584769792492
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file