OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, December 1, 2014

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Minutes on fileExecutive session: a

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:10:25 I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order.

0:10:28 It is Monday, December 1st, 2014, and for those of you who join us, please rise for the

0:10:35 Pledge of Allegiance.

0:10:38 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:10:53 Thank you all and welcome.

0:10:56 The first item on the agenda is confirming that we do have a form of the City Council,

0:11:02 all seven members are here this evening.

0:11:05 Travis, do we have any amendments to this evening's agenda?

0:11:08 Mr. Mayor, members of the Council staff would ask that the Council consider going into executive session under 67-235-1A as an apple.

0:11:19 To consider hiring a public officer, employee, staff member, or individual agent,

0:11:24 in the respective qualities of the individual are to be evaluated in order to fill a particular

0:11:29 vacancy or need. This paragraph does not apply to the filling of vacancy of an elected official,

0:11:35 or deliberations about staffing needs in general.

0:11:37 Thank you, Travis. Do we have a motion? Chris. Yes, Travis.

0:11:45 Mr. Member, I'm just a council for the matters of structuring the agenda.

0:11:48 By looking at the agenda, we believe that there may be appropriate time

0:11:52 If there's a balance in between our regular order of business and the public hearing,

0:11:59 the executive session tonight should not take a significant amount of time.

0:12:03 Very good. Thank you for having us. We'll just ask him as a follow-up to the proposed advisory executive session.

0:12:12 This is something that cannot or should not be discussed in public form.

0:12:17 Yeah, it's not appropriate to be discussed in the public form at this point in time.

0:12:22 point in time because of the competitive nature of it or the personal. It's personnel. It's

0:12:28 under personnel.

0:12:31 Chris, this is a rhetorical question.

0:12:36 There is an exception for that. If you choose to vote to have an executive session, then you

0:12:41 are able to. Now, whether or not you want to, do you, I guess that's why you vote on it.

0:12:49 I just get tired of all the executive meetings and have this one that your judgment says,

0:12:54 Thank you Chris. Do we have a motion in that?

0:12:59 Sorry.

0:13:01 We have a motion on board by Chris Talkington.

0:13:03 We have a second by Greg Lanting to move into executive session or actually add the executive session to our agenda.

0:13:14 Anything further in that motion?

0:13:16 Will you add a roll call vote, please?

0:13:19 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:13:20 Yes.

0:13:21 Jim Mon?

0:13:22 Yes.

0:13:23 Sean Berger.

0:13:24 Yes.

0:13:25 Chris Talkington.

0:13:26 Yes.

0:13:27 Don Hall.

0:13:28 Yes.

0:13:29 Rebecca Milsway.

0:13:30 Yes.

0:13:31 Motion passes.

0:13:32 Set into zero.

0:13:33 We have no proclamations tonight and the next section of our meeting is for general public

0:13:39 input.

0:13:40 If there's anyone from the general public that would like to come forward and address the

0:13:43 council.

0:13:45 I see no one coming forward so we'll move on to the consent calendar.

0:13:49 Turn that over to council.

0:13:52 Greg Lai.

0:13:53 Move approval of the consent calendar as published.

0:13:56 Second.

0:13:57 Motion on 4 by Great Landing, seconded by Sean Barrett,

0:14:01 or if you do have a like, Chris Stuckey.

0:14:03 I do have a question on the payables

0:14:05 for the wastewater treatment plant.

0:14:06 There is a total of a million 215,000, this substantial amount.

0:14:12 I just want to have personal comfort

0:14:15 that this is in compliance with all of our contracts,

0:14:21 that there is nothing unusual.

0:14:22 No one will add items, and we're still within budget

0:14:26 of all areas. Yes, yes to all the questions. Thank you. That was a simple answer. Also, I

0:14:35 want to bring to the council's attention. There is an item on the payables that I know

0:14:41 that's on there every month. I guess I just missed it. But under city council budget for

0:14:47 signs. I don't know if any of you have been noticing that. But what that's all about if

0:14:53 If you don't know, because I call Travis today,

0:14:55 is that it's all the signs that we have

0:15:00 for the City Council chambers for the various buildings

0:15:03 for the city, that is the least maintenance option

0:15:07 with vital signs I call Travis today,

0:15:09 because that just hit me.

0:15:11 It's kind of a funny place, in my opinion,

0:15:13 for it to be under the City Council,

0:15:14 but it's got to be under some budget.

0:15:17 I guess that's where it's been forever.

0:15:22 It's Travis's understanding.

0:15:24 With that, I see no further lies.

0:15:25 the other roll call vote on consent calendar.

0:15:27 Jim Munn.

0:15:28 Yes.

0:15:29 Sean Berger.

0:15:30 Yes.

0:15:31 Mr. Houghington.

0:15:32 Yes.

0:15:33 Greg Lanthing.

0:15:34 Yes.

0:15:35 Don Hall.

0:15:36 Yes.

0:15:37 Rebecca Milsoica.

0:15:38 Yes.

0:15:39 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:15:40 Yes.

0:15:41 Motion passes 7-0.

0:15:42 Moving now to items for consideration.

0:15:43 The first item is consideration request to adopt a resolution to procure goods and services

0:15:48 on the open market for the city of Twin Falls 2014 modifications to the Canyon Springs

0:15:55 some vowel project. John, Kate, welcome.

0:15:58 Thank you, Mayor. Good evening. Two weeks ago, I was before Council on

0:16:03 requested Council to reject two bids for this project, which you did. It was 208,400 and the

0:16:13 other bid was 370,639, both of which seemed excessive to us and in conversation since that

0:16:20 time with another contractor PMF, they have submitted after understanding the project

0:16:26 a bid substantially less than the engineer's estimate of the engineer's estimate was 168,750,

0:16:37 and PMF Inc. has submitted a bid in the amount of 157,436.

0:16:46 So tonight I'm asking council to approve this resolution and allow us to contract this project

0:16:53 with PMF.

0:16:54 Great mining. I guess I'd ask for it's the way and I don't think I

0:16:59 What I understand is this allowed under the state bidding rules or he was ready for this question. You can tell I

0:17:12 Like the idea that it's cheaper. I don't want to make sure we do it, right

0:17:16 That's cheap

0:17:20 John while he's bringing that up did the other folks that did before they knew that they were rejected and that we were going

0:17:27 Yes, and they had the opportunity to sharpen their pencils as well. No

0:17:32 know the way it worked is we did not get a second chance. So what we did is we, it seems weird

0:17:40 doesn't it? I'll have friends walk us through it, but we bid it publicly formally. We got

0:17:45 the bids in. We didn't like them. We rejected them. And the option that the code allows us

0:17:53 is we went through the state statute that requires competitive bidding. We met that rule because

0:18:00 We met that rule because we advertised, but PMF can beat that.

0:18:06 So it's not that we've evaded the competition, it's we help.

0:18:15 So you have two questions there.

0:18:17 So this has been publicly been.

0:18:19 So everyone that wanted to do this project has had a chance to bid on it.

0:18:23 As John has told you, this came in way over engineers.

0:18:27 He went looking to see if we could do it by the purchase of goods and services on the

0:18:33 open market at a more reasonable price.

0:18:36 He found that under Idaho Code 672803, under projects that are $100,000 or more, you'll

0:18:45 see in subsection Roman numeral aid, in its discretion the governing board may reject all

0:18:51 bids and rebid or the request here is not to rebid or the governing ward may after finding

0:19:00 it to be a fact, pass a resolution declaring that the projects are to be accomplished by

0:19:05 the expenditure to be performed for more economically by purchasing goods and services

0:19:10 on the open market. You have done this before.

0:19:14 Just remember is getting bad, Fred, sorry.

0:19:17 So this is all perfectly legal.

0:19:19 Everybody's had a shot at this.

0:19:21 Okay.

0:19:23 Makes sense.

0:19:25 What's the resolution number, 1835?

0:19:28 It just seems awkward to reject it and then we go out and find someone and folks that made

0:19:36 the bid in the first place didn't have the opportunity to sharpen their pencils.

0:19:41 They wouldn't have needed a new pencil, Mayor.

0:19:43 They might have needed a new pencil, I would agree with that.

0:19:45 First place.

0:19:46 Over bed.

0:19:47 Hi, I love your pieces.

0:19:48 Rebecca Milsoy.

0:19:49 Thank you, Mayor.

0:19:50 they would move that we passed resolution number 1935.

0:19:55 So motion on four by Rebecca Mills,

0:19:58 so I could second it by Greg Lanting, as stated,

0:20:02 anything further on that motion council.

0:20:04 Chris, talk to you.

0:20:05 Well, just a kudos to the whole spouse running with you,

0:20:08 John, for saving the city so much money

0:20:10 on what appears to be quite in degrees

0:20:12 as a bed differential.

0:20:15 You paid for a few salaries on this thing.

0:20:19 All of the councils.

0:20:20 for a while anything for that motion council the other roll call vote please

0:20:29 Sean Verigurg yes because talking to him yes yes John Hall yes Rebecca

0:20:38 Milsoyka yes Suzanne Hawkins yes Jim mine yes motion passes 70 0 thank you John

0:20:45 next item on the agenda is consideration of a request to submit a

0:20:49 roadway project for local urban funding and we have our city engineer Jackie Fields.

0:20:54 Welcome. Now that Washington Street, North, Phase 3, and 1 are complete, we are the city is actually

0:21:06 eligible to apply for another local urban project if it so chooses. And before I went through the

0:21:15 exercise of developing an estimate that's robust enough to wait for 10 years and still be a good

0:21:21 estimate and I thought that we should check in and test the inclination of the council

0:21:30 to apply for a federal aid project with 7% match and also talk about what those a couple

0:21:41 of potential projects could be.

0:21:43 So none of this has to be answered right at this exact second but the first order of

0:21:50 businesses to even want to apply in the first place.

0:21:52 You know, at the end of the day, seven cents on the dollar,

0:21:56 even after the pain in the neck and the federal aid

0:21:59 and the environmental and most kind of thing,

0:22:01 still is, but still a lot of money available

0:22:05 that ends up in the roadway.

0:22:08 For Washington Street, North could not have occurred

0:22:11 in the three-year construction window

0:22:14 that it did between phase one and the extension of phase three.

0:22:21 in a normal funding scenario for the city,

0:22:24 because we've been working on Eastland,

0:22:26 you can see this as we've been working on Eastland,

0:22:28 and we have not accomplished that kind of mileage

0:22:34 within the normal budget.

0:22:37 There's two potential projects that come to mind,

0:22:40 and I'll start with the one that I submitted last time.

0:22:53 Okay, so the last time I made a submittal,

0:22:56 I submitted for a project on Pulling Road and Eastland,

0:23:00 that went from the intersection with the state highway,

0:23:03 Highway 93 of Blue Lakes, around to about the location

0:23:07 of the temple, and argued, you know, made the classic argument

0:23:11 because you need to have a destination.

0:23:12 Your roadway needs to go somewhere.

0:23:14 Is it hate, you know, is this important?

0:23:16 This is a destination.

0:23:17 There's a lot of people that come here.

0:23:20 And it gave me a limited, gave us a limited project

0:23:24 for the environmental work.

0:23:26 They gave us a limited project for a right-of-way acquisition.

0:23:30 And it potentially put us in a spot where we could rebuild the section of Pull Line Road

0:23:35 between Bridgeview and Blue Lakes, which, you know, the new sections are really old,

0:23:41 and the old sections are older than that.

0:23:44 So as well as doing major widening from Bridgeview around to about Toddbusses,

0:23:50 driveway or Meadowview extended.

0:23:52 And then if we need to revisit ADA issues or anything else on the curtling,

0:23:59 widen curve, then we'd have that opportunity as well.

0:24:02 So that's project number one.

0:24:06 It did not rate well on the last application, so it was not really perci-I was having trouble

0:24:18 making the argument that that was a destination.

0:24:25 There's a tremendous amount of truck traffic that goes much farther south.

0:24:31 I didn't want to do environmental on the whole route because we're currently constructing

0:24:35 other sections.

0:24:36 And so it was a little bit complicated, that's the first job.

0:24:41 Rebecca, did you want to wait until she was all done or do you want to buy?

0:24:49 Can I ask a quick question on this picture here, sorry, on the last picture that you had.

0:24:55 I noticed that most of the land around that section is undeveloped and there's actually

0:25:00 one parcel around the curve of Poline and Eastland that is going through the P&Z process right

0:25:06 now.

0:25:07 So when that is developed, my question is will it have to be widened to those standards anyway

0:25:16 when it's developed?

0:25:17 Yes, and further on, you know, when all of those kind of barren plots develop is at

0:25:29 at that time do those all of the state standards come in and they have to build the road out?

0:25:36 Okay, so if we don't accept state money, then the state standards don't apply and we just

0:25:41 use city standards.

0:25:42 Okay.

0:25:43 So in this section of road right here, we think that most of the road is right-sized

0:25:54 for our foreseeable future.

0:25:56 I mean, there's a lot of pavement out there.

0:26:00 on the intensity of the development, we might need things like right turn lanes to get people

0:26:05 out of the way.

0:26:06 But that's very minor compared to what happens down here.

0:26:10 Great, and that's the section I was wondering about too, because because further up it's

0:26:17 only two lanes.

0:26:18 So that's, that pavement is ancient, what was there, and the roadway ballast is even older.

0:26:26 So when those people come through and develop in this whole area, if they develop as a

0:26:35 I want to put a mansion on my property and they pull a building permit.

0:26:40 We do not have any way of addressing major widening other than to make a request by the

0:26:46 land or to have a donation and then build it ourselves.

0:26:49 If they go through a subdivision of land process, which, you know, a huge bulk of that section

0:26:56 would be, could be a subdivision of land process, then we can talk to the developers about building

0:27:02 road to a better width and certainly a better depth. That's that's part of the

0:27:09 subject of the process. Thank you. Thank you.

0:27:14 Thank you.

0:27:15 Jackie, but that would only be if they let's say the the we're talking the field

0:27:19 we're talking about there. I used to have a pointer who knows where we'll go. Yeah,

0:27:22 that that field there obviously you really have to go north with it and so

0:27:27 almost all have come this way and they're only gonna be responsible to the mid

0:27:33 Mentally on the road anyway, right?

0:27:36 So the development of that,

0:27:38 the development of that land, that development process

0:27:41 could include a conversation about living the entire roadway

0:27:46 south, that would be irregular, you know, normally do that.

0:27:51 Right, okay, all right, thank you.

0:27:54 I have no further light, you can continue, please.

0:27:56 All right.

0:28:03 Ready to go to 60.

0:28:12 Okay, so this route goes from West Five Points

0:28:17 all the way around to East Five Points.

0:28:20 Okay, so that goes from the intersection

0:28:21 of Washington and Addison on the left-hand side of the page.

0:28:26 Down Washington Street, sixth,

0:28:29 pasty pogrel in Minnadoka, and then ties in

0:28:33 where Blue Lakes, Kimberly Road, Main Street,

0:28:36 all of that come together.

0:28:41 There has been discussion over the years,

0:28:44 and it's been in place for a long, long time.

0:28:48 I first heard about it when I was an employee,

0:28:50 when there was a overture by individuals that were citizens of Twin Falls that wanted to

0:29:00 have the state consider some kind of trade of US 30 on the second street with this alignment.

0:29:09 And as a dutiful state employee, my response to the district engineer was that this alignment

0:29:19 was nowhere close to the state highway that the state already had in possession in terms

0:29:23 of right-away capacity, the depth ballast, utility conflicts, uncontrolled access, railroad

0:29:33 issues because over on Minidoka the railroad right-away extends towards the and into the

0:29:39 roadway in places. And I had to run a very rough cost and I was looking around for the

0:29:45 estimate, but I can't find it so I'm going to have to start over.

0:29:49 So it was a huge job.

0:29:51 It was larger than Washington Street Pays 3 and to just take on the roadway without having

0:29:59 those costs dealt with was not a recommendation that I made to the district engineer.

0:30:06 So as time as per that project is still here, there's still a desire to consider moving US

0:30:13 30 off of the seconds.

0:30:15 The state isn't necessarily opposed to trading highway,

0:30:22 but they need their highway to work for them

0:30:25 and have some limit on the costs.

0:30:26 So part of the proposal here is to develop this section

0:30:32 of roadway so that it is a road that the state could consider

0:30:35 taking as far as right-of-way environmental issues

0:30:39 taken care of.

0:30:41 the depth of the roadway, can it actually carry the truck load for a while, at least 20 years,

0:30:47 and with, so, now, regardless of what you actually see on the road, the right of way

0:30:57 is all over the place, out there. So, this job would be different than the Washington

0:31:04 Street North project in that we would anticipate that we would be touching the face or running

0:31:12 through the side of some of these structures with the road right away and potentially even

0:31:18 some of the roadway type things like sidewalks and elimination, those type things.

0:31:26 So it's a bigger job in terms of environmental, in terms of reconciling the survey and in terms

0:31:33 of right-of-way acquisition. For road construction, that becomes the easy part.

0:31:37 It's just built in a road. To frock with its own issues, stormwater and utilities and

0:31:48 controlling access. Because access would need to have some control on it. We have

0:31:55 a whole bunch of areas in here that are, you know, you just kind of drive off the

0:31:59 road and stop where you feel like it and drive back on and that doesn't work very well for

0:32:05 state highway.

0:32:06 So we would need to migrate through that as a process.

0:32:10 But this is a potential second job or an alternate project that could be submitted that could

0:32:20 potentially put us in a spot where we could engage the state in a conversation about taking

0:32:28 U.S. 30 off of the seconds and even if those discussions became unacceptable to a future

0:32:36 council and they chose not to do that, this project with local urban funds would put us

0:32:42 in the spot where we had an almost excellent roadway through this entire route.

0:32:48 Most excellent roadways are attractive to trucks and they tend to drive them and we're

0:32:53 seeing that on Eastland now.

0:32:56 some of that roadway is a beautiful width and the truck traffic there is actually larger

0:33:03 than we had estimated.

0:33:07 So those are the two projects I have estimated, neither of them, intuitively the one that is

0:33:14 less expensive for everyone in the long run is pulling, but I don't know that I can be

0:33:20 successful with that as that's currently defined logical termini and our rather

0:33:27 larger challenge is that there are sections of that roadway that we need to

0:33:31 work on before we can get the project to come all the way up into the into the

0:33:39 build. The state's program is at least seven years long and there's pieces of

0:33:43 that road that aren't going to make it for seven years. That's all there is to it.

0:33:49 This roadway will probably make it.

0:33:54 Chris Stockton has a question.

0:33:56 Mm-hmm.

0:33:57 Even if we proceed, or if we proceed with this alternative

0:34:01 and I-TD we're interested in negotiating them.

0:34:05 Wouldn't it mean just in essence rebuilding,

0:34:09 if not the Washington segment, the Minna-Doka,

0:34:12 is that not just such a substandard road surface

0:34:15 that would be an effect reconstructing everything?

0:34:18 I'm not even talking about the right-of-way issues.

0:34:20 actual road sub-surfacing. I mean, it's nowhere comparable to seconds, is it, Jackie?

0:34:26 That's an accurate understanding. That roadway is not even close. The only

0:34:34 thing that even comes close is where we did our arsenic trench patch. They came

0:34:38 off of Durkeys and hit six per bit. And what's the total length of that from the

0:34:45 five points down to where it goes off the map there and a mile and a half or two

0:34:51 miles. I'm thinking it's right in between there. So it'd be rebuilding or new

0:34:58 constructing a road for that like the distance. Sure looks good. Great landing.

0:35:06 Well, Trissa's product question actually changes my foot just a slightly as I

0:35:13 believe it was a year ago, maybe it was two years ago. We're getting ready to be in

0:35:16 the festival lights parade and you're setting already setting up on the big

0:35:21 fire truck there at the end of Maine and here comes this parade of trucks coming

0:35:26 down Main Street making a left-hand turn onto down there and then heading on

0:35:34 over to catch Minidoka so they can get to Glamby and get to everything out that

0:35:40 direction. It was a Tyson Motor Corner. Yeah right there at Tyson Motor's corner.

0:35:44 Yeah and so that road is already, I mean we can believe how many trucks were coming

0:35:49 down there and really of course it was really extra confusing since there's a

0:35:53 parade in the middle of it but they were already coming down there and making it

0:35:57 a left-hand turn right out in the middle of a main street and having to wait for

0:36:02 cars to go their way so they can make the turn because that's not a real wide

0:36:05 open corner and so to me this that some point probably does make sense because

0:36:11 If they were coming in Kimberly Road as it is, they would be able to, I would assume, work

0:36:15 it out some way to come straight.

0:36:17 I see your concerns about right away acquisition.

0:36:21 I think it would end up actually buying at least one building on Washington Street just said,

0:36:27 hey, we're just going to buy it because it was cheaper to buy it than it was to take the

0:36:33 road up to the front door.

0:36:34 And I see what's doing the exact same thing on this, on several, especially the part on

0:36:39 six they would think or Washington I mean the part of Washington I'm assumed

0:36:43 would be there's a couple buildings there that were already kind of right at the

0:36:47 corner we didn't even let one rebuild because of it so part of the reason a

0:36:51 person becomes an engineer is because they like problems to solve problems so

0:36:59 this one makes persons need not what the magnitude but it certainly is a

0:37:04 challenge and it doesn't just because it seems scary doesn't mean it's not

0:37:08 No, I'm with you there, I just, I just pitfall, start roaring through my head here, especially

0:37:15 in acquisition.

0:37:16 Here's another piece of information that may or may not be helpful, but the state has, on

0:37:21 its books, as part of the city's interest in doing improvements to truck flow through and

0:37:31 the downtown area, they have a, based on their program, project to work on that intersection

0:37:41 somehow.

0:37:42 And so, we currently have a revision of the southeast wood falls, ultimate city occurring,

0:37:49 and the hope or the potential is that there will be an outcome in that document that could

0:37:56 provide some direction with regard to that intersection.

0:38:00 or this project could help provide direction

0:38:02 for what we do in that intersection.

0:38:06 But they are, what ends up appearing

0:38:10 when you make a project's middle is that we have

0:38:13 companion projects to make a net better net to the system.

0:38:20 So the state's current, I guess it's their strategic plan

0:38:23 says that they need to support or address safety

0:38:27 And I forget what the other S was, but the last one is economic prosperity.

0:38:36 So this particular project lends itself well to safety and economic prosperity, particularly

0:38:45 if we ended up being able to make an extension that took the state highway away from Bitquil

0:38:51 and Lincoln.

0:38:52 We're back in Melsoika.

0:38:56 Thank you, Mayor.

0:38:57 Thank you, Jackie.

0:38:58 Actually, that leads into my comments.

0:39:01 To answer your first question, I hope that we would not repeat issues that we had with

0:39:06 Washington, but yes, I would like us to apply for this funding.

0:39:12 I think you're right that even though there are challenges and difficulties with the federal

0:39:16 funding, it's well worth the seven cents on the dollar.

0:39:19 And as far as the two projects, you know, reading your chart, I think you mapped it out pretty

0:39:25 well.

0:39:26 greater, I see greater economic opportunity and enrichment for the Washington, 6th, and

0:39:34 Minidoka project, mostly because in your chart the potential for subdivision development is

0:39:42 significant for pole line.

0:39:44 I think that those improvements are going to come.

0:39:46 I mean that undeveloped land is prime land in our community right now and it will be

0:39:53 developed. As for Washington, Minnidoka and Six, I think that's a project that is going

0:40:02 to only come by the way of the state or the city doing it, and I think it'll provide significant

0:40:11 economic opportunities in that area in terms of industrial and commercial, as you said.

0:40:17 And also I think the opportunity for pedestrian improvements, bike pathways, say for pedestrian

0:40:25 routes is significant.

0:40:27 And there has been a push even in the last four years I've been here to remove the truck

0:40:33 traffic from second.

0:40:34 And I think that this will help us to at least move in that direction.

0:40:39 I don't know if that's the answer, but it certainly can't hurt.

0:40:44 So I would be in favor of submitting the second project that you talked about, Washington,

0:40:52 6th, and Minidoka for those reasons.

0:40:56 Jackie, I ran for council in 2005, came on 2006, and from the beginning of being on council,

0:41:03 I've had nothing but comments about Minidoka 6, the Washington trying to move the truck

0:41:08 traffic off of the seconds, getting them away from the elementary schools, getting those highways

0:41:14 from dissecting our downtown.

0:41:18 And I think probably the safety issue concerns me the most.

0:41:23 When you have those three lane one way roads going through our downtown where kids are walking back and forth to those schools,

0:41:30 it causes me, I just worry about those kids getting across those roads, trying to get home,

0:41:39 because one car will stop, the child will start walking home,

0:41:44 And the next car doesn't see the child going across the crosswalk because of the width and

0:41:50 because of the type of traffic that are on those roads.

0:41:53 I just, the desire to move the highway off of the seconds hasn't diminished from the people I talk to in this town.

0:42:03 They still would like to see that not only for prosperity issues, but really more importantly to me, safety issues.

0:42:12 So, we'll state it tonight.

0:42:14 We'll demonstrate it.

0:42:16 My desire would be for us to move towards the

0:42:20 Minidocas 6th in Washington.

0:42:22 That's where I would encourage you to look at.

0:42:27 Sean Berger.

0:42:29 I too am supportive of that project,

0:42:32 partly because I know a lot more about that one

0:42:34 than I probably know about the other one.

0:42:37 The discussions of the Washington 6-Minidocas corridor,

0:42:42 I've been involved with, I think, probably since you were back at ITD and in chatting about those.

0:42:48 I'm not even as concerned about the second avenues component of that,

0:42:53 and the swap, as perhaps maybe all of us were years ago.

0:42:58 I think as we looked at it in the last several years,

0:43:03 to me it's more about making that safe route for trucks to get to their destination

0:43:09 without having to weave through a bunch of other stuff.

0:43:12 And while the getting the highway moved off the seconds would certainly be an advantage,

0:43:18 I think an improvement to this roadway would probably do a lot of that too.

0:43:21 It would move that traffic off the seconds, off of Shoshone Street, which there's a fair

0:43:27 amount of truck traffic on there now, because there's really not an adequate alternate route

0:43:33 around and with the improvements to North Washington.

0:43:36 If you coupled that with this, you really do make a little better North-South corridor,

0:43:40 on Eastland one over on Washington that gets kind of the trucks out of the middle of town.

0:43:46 I don't disagree that both of these projects probably need other help.

0:43:51 They're beyond the scope of how much can we throw out it on an annual basis in our budget,

0:43:59 but it might take would be the Washington 6-Minidoco project is never, ever, ever going

0:44:04 to happen without the help.

0:44:06 The Eastland one and Poleline, we may be able to chip away at that in pieces much like we

0:44:13 we have on Eastland further south.

0:44:16 So I would be supportive of moving ahead

0:44:19 with the Washington six minidoka project

0:44:22 as a potential application.

0:44:25 Greg Lanning.

0:44:27 Very much it did a one.

0:44:28 Sean's and they had one more point done.

0:44:30 I was on planning the zoning from 1976 to 1983.

0:44:33 It was already on Gary Young's radar bed

0:44:36 and we're talking was that 32 years ago minimum,

0:44:39 maybe as long as 35 years ago.

0:44:41 So obviously it's something we, if we were ever going to do it ourselves it's been around

0:44:47 for a long time so obviously Shawn said we're going to need help either done.

0:44:50 Chris, talk?

0:44:52 Well, when I was on the Transportation Committee we were talking about it and back Shawn and

0:44:57 I met with some interested parties and at that time it seems like the Transportation Committee,

0:45:05 the engineer for our area, committed to some sort of a study of East Five Point Area and

0:45:10 Is it 74, East and West, 74, which is south of that whole area?

0:45:15 I never did understand the tie in there,

0:45:18 but is there not already something in progress underway

0:45:22 or some paper sitting in the file somewhere showing something

0:45:27 about the East Five Point?

0:45:31 OK, so there is a study underway, so it's not a piece of paper.

0:45:36 There's an old study, which is currently sitting in a shelf

0:45:40 and provides the basis for the state planning

0:45:42 all kinds of improvement projects in this district,

0:45:45 or in this South area of the district.

0:45:48 So, ITD actually uses that study.

0:45:54 And so when it's revisited, they'll use it again

0:45:57 to project the next set of projects.

0:46:01 To the best of my knowledge,

0:46:03 there isn't a design at Blue Lakes in Kimberly Road.

0:46:06 Is that what you're asking me?

0:46:08 Seemed to be the end product of the study was the potential for perhaps allowing trucks westbound at East five points to proceed with some reconfiguration up Minidoka Avenue direct.

0:46:23 Oh, yeah, absolutely.

0:46:24 Okay.

0:46:24 So that's on a short term temporary, but still still a potential solution and the state has put a project in there in their planning horizon.

0:46:36 what they're calling it in this current era.

0:46:40 And so it's not funded, but it's there.

0:46:43 And in order to get it funded, it needs a scope.

0:46:47 And they're waiting for the scope,

0:46:50 based on what this report has to say,

0:46:52 and then hopefully on what we have to say.

0:46:59 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:47:00 Thank you.

0:47:01 I just wanted to, real quick, Jack,

0:47:02 you make sure you heard from all of us.

0:47:04 And yes, I support the same project as everyone else.

0:47:06 And I think it's wonderful that you've taken this on

0:47:09 after just completing the last one.

0:47:11 So you've got my support.

0:47:21 We're back in the middle of the second.

0:47:22 Jackie, do you need a motion or do you just need that direction?

0:47:25 Direction was good.

0:47:26 I think you kind of have a sense I would assume.

0:47:29 I have a pretty good sense.

0:47:31 Very good.

0:47:32 Thank you, Jack.

0:47:32 If I find anything along the way that causes me to really worry,

0:47:36 I'll say something before I submit it.

0:47:39 Thank you.

0:47:40 be real curious about what the cost estimates would be because I'm sure that's not going

0:47:47 to be cheap. We had some Boy Scouts sneak in and traditionally what we have our Boy Scouts

0:47:52 do when they come to our council meetings is come forward and introduce yourselves. The

0:47:57 reason we do that is because generally you're here because you're for your communications

0:48:03 or our government badge or something like that. So we citizens in the community so we make

0:48:09 you earn your badge. So if you five, five wouldn't mind coming up to the podium,

0:48:15 just giving me your name, your troop, where you meet and what you're working on.

0:48:19 Come on up forward. Don't look at each other. Everybody wants somebody else to

0:48:28 lead. Tallest to go first. Patrol leader goes first.

0:48:43 I'm working on communications, citizenship, and the community.

0:49:00 Very good.

0:49:01 Where do you meet Spencer?

0:49:02 Where does your troop meet?

0:49:08 Eastland building.

0:49:10 The LDS.

0:49:11 Okay.

0:49:12 Very good.

0:49:13 Thank you, Spencer.

0:49:14 I'm Brian Simpson, and I'm working on communications for troop 59.

0:49:25 We work, we meet in the Eastland LDS Church.

0:49:29 Thank you, sir.

0:49:31 Right?

0:49:32 Um, I'm Ben Shank, and I'm the quartermaster,

0:49:38 troop 59, meet at the Eastland LDS Church.

0:49:42 Working on the same badges?

0:49:43 Yeah.

0:49:43 Very good.

0:49:44 Thank you.

0:49:46 I'm Matthew Eliesin.

0:49:48 I'm working on the communications.

0:49:52 True, Ben.

0:49:54 Thank you, Matthew.

0:49:57 I'm Jace Wright, and I'm working on the

0:50:00 communications, budget, citizenship, and community action.

0:50:05 And it was Jason.

0:50:07 Thank you, Jason.

0:50:07 Thank you, five, for coming forward.

0:50:09 You feel like you're earning it now?

0:50:12 Very good.

0:50:13 Moving on to the next item on the agenda.

0:50:15 It's consideration of the request to adopt a resolution

0:50:17 for a comprehensive plan amendment from AG AG

0:50:21 to medium density and to extend the water service boundary

0:50:25 area, which would amend the future land use map.

0:50:28 2-4 of the Twin Falls Vision 2030,

0:50:33 a comprehensive plan for a sustainable future for 53 plus

0:50:39 or minus acres located on the east side of 500, 600, 700 blocks

0:50:45 of Hankins Road North, and we have Mitch Humboldt, welcome,

0:50:48 Mitch.

0:50:49 Thank you.

0:50:51 On the 17th of November, we had a public hearing

0:50:53 and the council approved a request from the school district

0:50:56 to make these changes to the compound.

0:50:59 I'm happy to have them change the boundary

0:51:02 and then take changes to the designation

0:51:04 on the land use designation.

0:51:07 This resolution will basically finalize that process,

0:51:11 make it effective.

0:51:15 So the resolution is repaired,

0:51:17 it just basically does what the council approved.

0:51:20 I believe that 236 would be the number,

0:51:23 and we'll just ask for your approval,

0:51:26 We've got any questions I can help answer them.

0:51:29 That is also here to speak to the district.

0:51:32 Very good. Thank you, Mitch.

0:51:33 Any questions, Council?

0:51:35 We have a motion regarding resolution 19-36-36.

0:51:42 Move approval resolution 19-36.

0:51:46 Second.

0:51:49 We have a motion on the floor to approve resolution 19-36

0:51:54 by Greg Lantane, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.

0:51:57 further on that motion council.

0:52:00 We either roll call vote please.

0:52:01 Ms. Talkington?

0:52:02 Yes.

0:52:04 Good Lansing?

0:52:04 Yes.

0:52:05 Don Hall?

0:52:06 Yes.

0:52:07 Rebecca Milsoica?

0:52:08 No.

0:52:09 Suzanne Hawkins?

0:52:10 Yes.

0:52:11 Jim Munn?

0:52:12 Yes.

0:52:13 Sean Bericher?

0:52:13 Yes.

0:52:14 Motion passes six to one.

0:52:16 Thank you, Mitch.

0:52:17 Next item on the agenda is consideration of your request

0:52:20 to adopt an ordinance for the annexation of 4.75 give or take

0:52:25 with a zoning designation of C1 and to proceed

0:52:30 with the development of a municipal water storage facility

0:52:34 on property located at 2951 Marie Avenue.

0:52:38 We have Jonathan Spemma, welcome Jonathan.

0:52:41 Thank you Mr. Mayor, members of the council.

0:52:43 This has gone through all the process

0:52:45 from planning and zoning city council

0:52:47 with the public hearings nobody spoke against it.

0:52:49 Either one of those, they took place October 14th

0:52:52 and November 10th respectively.

0:52:54 We've prepared the ordinance as rigged by a chemical.

0:52:59 You have the number, you'd have to suspend the rules

0:53:02 placed on third and final if you wanted adopted tonight.

0:53:05 What is that number, Leila, please?

0:53:07 3081.

0:53:08 3081, thank you, Leila, Christocchi.

0:53:11 That would move to place, ordinance 3081,

0:53:13 on third and final by Cottle owner,

0:53:15 only under a suspension on the rules.

0:53:18 Second.

0:53:19 We have a motion on four by Christocchi,

0:53:21 and seconded by Sean Beriger as stated.

0:53:24 I think further on that motion council.

0:53:27 Leila, roll call vote please.

0:53:28 Greg Lanting.

0:53:29 Yes.

0:53:30 Don Hall.

0:53:31 Yes.

0:53:32 Rebecca Milsoica.

0:53:33 Yes.

0:53:34 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:53:35 Yes.

0:53:36 Jim Munn.

0:53:37 Yes.

0:53:38 Sean Baraker.

0:53:39 Yes.

0:53:40 Motion passes seven to zero.

0:53:41 Leila, if you could read it.

0:53:42 In ordinance of the city council of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho, annexing certain real

0:53:47 property below described, providing the zoning classification therefore, and ordering the

0:53:52 necessary area of impact in zoning district's map amendment.

0:53:56 Stand for a motion.

0:53:59 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:54:00 I move approval of ordinance 3081.

0:54:06 Second.

0:54:07 Not everyone at the same time.

0:54:09 We have motion approval for ordinance 3081 by Suzanne Hawkins

0:54:14 seconded by Sean Barrier.

0:54:16 Anything further on that motion council?

0:54:19 Yeah, the roll call vote, please.

0:54:22 Yes.

0:54:25 Yes.

0:54:27 Yes.

0:54:28 Yes.

0:54:29 Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 7-0. Thank you. Next item on the agenda is a consideration

0:54:40 of a request to, excuse me, we're moving to public input and our items from city manager

0:54:48 and city council. Anyone from the public wishing to address the council at this time? City manager?

0:54:58 Excuse me, Mr. Mayor, members of the council, just three quick items. Excuse me. The first

0:55:05 This is just a reminder and an update of the next citizen's committees.

0:55:10 They evaluate our facilities.

0:55:12 They met the week prior to Thanksgiving, as you know, they meet on Thursdays and they elected

0:55:18 not to meet on Thursdays.

0:55:20 But they're going to kick their meetings back up.

0:55:24 At their last meeting, they toured three different places.

0:55:27 They toured the Latham property.

0:55:30 they toured the clinic on Chijon and they toured the banner building.

0:55:35 I've had an opportunity to review the agenda that was created by the co-chairs and I think

0:55:40 that they're making really good headway and I think that they're going to have a really

0:55:43 good robust conversation and I think that you're going to start to see additional motions

0:55:48 and as those motions are made I will continue to keep you up to speed and up to date.

0:55:56 From my perspective, they're doing great work, and I think that they're really getting a taste of what it's like to work through a very public process.

0:56:06 And so it's been hopefully very beneficial for them as well.

0:56:11 The next thing is the downtown has an advisory committee meeting that is open to the public, and that's in conjunction with the Urban Renewal Project.

0:56:20 Otec is in town and that meeting is going to be taking place in the police classroom

0:56:26 and it is scheduled to be at 9.30 in the morning on Monday December 8th.

0:56:31 They have a downtown advisory committee group that meets and that helps kind of help facilitate that project and so that is their next meeting.

0:56:39 Also on the 8th we're going to be reviewing the parking study at our council meeting that was developed by one of the Urban Renewal Sub-Consultants Kettleson Engineering out of Boyes.

0:56:50 Boise so we'll get that report to you so you have opportunity to review that by the presentation

0:56:54 will be made to the City Council on the 8th.

0:56:58 And then just a quick reminder and also a thank you.

0:57:04 The University of Virginia is in Twin Falls this week and we are having a series of training

0:57:09 opportunities for our employees.

0:57:11 The first group went through their one day session today, Jonathan Spinn Love was part

0:57:16 of that first group so was Leila and then the second group will start their four day

0:57:20 Intensive workshop piece starting tomorrow. Thank you anything from city council

0:57:28 Travis a place training buildings the old city council chamber. Yes, sir

0:57:35 I'm assuming this is still happening the parks and rec department is gonna host their kickoff on Wednesday evening this week for their

0:57:45 Parks and rec master planning process, so that's at six o'clock

0:57:49 here at the city council chambers and that is open to the public and folks are

0:57:54 encouraged to attend and participate. Thank you Sean. I just wanted to remind

0:57:58 the council that I think Friday at five Leila is the lights parade we meet at the

0:58:04 fire department. I think it's for this part. Six. Six p.m. For those of you

0:58:12 wishing to join and be on the fire truck for the lights parade and please let

0:58:18 I would know so that we know how many folks are going to be there and just a side note

0:58:23 during this time of celebration or

0:58:26 Thankfulness this this weekend

0:58:29 There was a fire over in my neighborhood

0:58:33 We heard

0:58:35 Sirens, I think it's Friday morning Friday morning

0:58:39 a belief it was Saturday morning Saturday morning

0:58:42 We heard sirens going by, and I live in a residential neighborhood, so we don't usually hear that, and then we heard fire trucks as well.

0:58:51 And we looked out our window, and the house was fully engulfed in flames, and the gentleman inside was injured, and our thoughts and prayers go out to he and his family.

0:59:02 As well as this time during Thanksgiving, that his house, from what I can see, I drove by not long ago, was pretty well destroyed.

0:59:11 But it really did remind me of what a great city that we do have here in our public safety,

0:59:19 our place we're on scene immediately, our fire department was there right afterwards, I saw

0:59:25 ambulances on the way, and we really do live in a good city with a lot of really good employees

0:59:31 working for the city, so really thankful for that.

0:59:35 Kristoff.

0:59:36 When I update the Council that we have an intergovernmental

0:59:41 cooperation agreement between the county of the city for

0:59:44 Johnson Field and process of being refined and it'll come to

0:59:49 the Council sometime after the board, the city and the county,

0:59:54 the city staff refine it.

0:59:56 But I kind of just look at as an updating of extremely informal

1:00:03 agreement that the city and the county have had for decades of how to operate.

1:00:06 And this just codifies it a little bit more, and it'll provide a little clear

1:00:11 operation limits and boundaries and expectations.

1:00:15 Chris, is that in Hawkins?

1:00:18 I'm going to back up to the parade, just so the other council members are aware.

1:00:21 This year for the parade route, they're collecting unwrapped toys for the toys for

1:00:25 Tots donation.

1:00:26 So being a part of the parade, we can still bring an unwrapped gift and donate

1:00:30 to that they'll be collecting along the parade route

1:00:33 as we drive down.

1:00:35 Thank you Suzanne, anything further?

1:00:37 All right, I believe that we should have time

1:00:39 to go into executive session before we do that.

1:00:42 Just let members of the audience,

1:00:43 including our Boy Scouts know,

1:00:45 we're going to be going into executive session

1:00:47 if it's voted on by the council.

1:00:50 We're only gonna be in there five or 10 minutes

1:00:52 so I don't want you to miss a thing.

1:00:55 We're gonna be back out for a couple of public hearings.

1:00:57 Don't hesitate to stay, not telling you to have to.

1:01:00 you have the scout leader there,

1:01:02 he can probably guide you through that process.

1:01:04 But I didn't want you to think that we were leaving

1:01:06 and not coming back out and reconvening.

1:01:08 So at that, this time I'd like to talk about

1:01:12 the next item on the agenda, which is 67, 23, 45,

1:01:17 one aid to consider hiring a public officer, employee,

1:01:21 staff member or individual agent,

1:01:23 wherein the respective qualities of individuals

1:01:26 are to be evaluated in order to fill a particular vacancy

1:01:30 or need unless a vacancy in an elected office is being filled.

1:01:35 Great glancing.

1:01:35 So moved.

1:01:38 Second.

1:01:38 Have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanning, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins

1:01:42 to move into executive session, as stated.

1:01:44 Anything further on that motion, Council?

1:01:48 Leyla, roll call.

1:01:50 Rebecca Mizzoica?

1:01:51 Yes.

1:01:51 C. Zann Hawkins?

1:01:53 Yes.

1:01:53 Jim Mun?

1:01:54 Yes.

1:01:54 Sean Berriger?

1:01:55 Yes.

1:01:56 Chris Chalkington?

1:01:56 Yes.

1:01:57 Greg Lanthin?

1:01:58 Yes.

1:01:58 Don Hall?

1:01:59 Yes.

1:02:00 Motion passes seven to zero.

1:02:02 We will be adjourning into executive session.

1:02:05 We'll be coming back out and reconvening

1:02:07 for the public hearings.

1:13:10 I'd like to reconvening the meeting

1:13:11 of the Twin Falls City Council December 1st, 2014.

1:13:15 It's about three minutes after six o'clock in the evening.

1:13:21 We are now moving towards our public hearings.

1:13:23 We have two of those.

1:13:24 The first one is a request to allow additional building height

1:13:28 for new silos on property located

1:13:30 at 236 Washington Street South,

1:13:33 and we have Steve Mon from Columbia.

1:13:37 Well, Steve be presenting first,

1:13:39 and then followed up by a staff report, correct?

1:13:44 Mr. Mon, welcome.

1:13:46 Good evening, thank you.

1:13:49 Columbia Foods are installing some process expansions

1:13:54 enhancements that will enhance our operational capabilities

1:13:58 at our Twin Falls facility.

1:14:00 This will require some additional building and about eight new silos.

1:14:06 Three of those silos and all of the silos will hold obviously different parts of dairy processing,

1:14:12 milk or water or what have you.

1:14:14 All of the three of those silos are exceed the 50 foot height restriction from the building

1:14:21 code.

1:14:22 We seek a variance for that.

1:14:25 Those will be about 70 feet, 71 feet in height from grade.

1:14:30 the same height, in fact, they're the same size of two of our existing silos that are

1:14:34 on the north side. If you're familiar with the facility, one of those has our logo painted

1:14:39 on the side on the north end. So these silos will be that same size. You can see the two

1:14:46 on the north end there. What may be difficult to see is there's a little red dot right

1:14:51 above that one where the one of the silos will go a milk silo.

1:14:55 Mitch or Jonathan, could you give him the pointer so he can show us?

1:14:59 Want us to go right here?

1:15:05 And then what's not shown is down here is going to be new building space,

1:15:09 stand alone building in right in here, and two of these cybers

1:15:15 will be here. There will be some others here that are smaller below the 50 foot limit.

1:15:19 So it will be kind of a medieval cybers

1:15:23 farm if you will right here. Did we expect no

1:15:34 of impact to our neighbors. This is more than 300 feet back from the road. Here, they will

1:15:42 be stainless steel resistant to Russian corrosion, as I mentioned, essentially the same size

1:15:49 as we have now. The two on the south end here are actually going to hold water that we're

1:15:56 going to start reclaiming from our operation and will actually be considered environmentally

1:16:02 friendly, if you will, we'll keep our footprint neutral as this

1:16:06 expansion goes on with regard to water use. Any questions?

1:16:12 Do we have any questions, Chris, I understand that the proposed

1:16:16 silos would be the same height as those on the the north end. They

1:16:21 are 71 feet or so. Yeah. Okay. So there's another one standing

1:16:27 up in front here. Okay. We have any other questions, Mr.

1:16:33 not at this time. We might call you back after the city report.

1:16:37 Thank you for your time.

1:16:38 Thank you, sir.

1:16:40 Jonathan Spendlove.

1:16:45 Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council on the history.

1:16:47 I'll be brief. Currently, M2 zoning.

1:16:50 I believe it's been M2 since the city implemented those types of zoning districts back in the 80s.

1:16:57 This is actually the first time that you were seeing this new height extension

1:17:03 under the new zoning code that we changed recently.

1:17:05 requires a public hearing with the planning and zoning,

1:17:07 and then it comes for public hearing as well.

1:17:10 That was changed recently for two public hearings,

1:17:12 recommendation from the planning and zoning commission.

1:17:15 That was done and completed on November 25th,

1:17:19 and we did this pretty close in succession

1:17:21 because of the project the Clamby is,

1:17:23 it's an ambitious project they wanna get done

1:17:25 and accomplish quick.

1:17:28 Code sections we use now, it's 10, 4, 10.

1:17:32 That's the no building shall exceed 50 feet

1:17:34 height except as provided in 1073 and that's when we change to include the additional height

1:17:41 goes through the public carrying process of zoning map amendment which is the two public

1:17:45 carrying. So those are two code sections we're working with. Since the project is located

1:17:49 in the M2 zoning district, the applicant had to apply for additional building height following

1:17:54 the process outlined in 1014 and the possible impacts. Staff does not foresee a significant

1:18:00 impact on adjoining property owners for this request to the item. The locations of

1:18:04 the proposed silos are considerably sent back from the current roadway and from

1:18:08 any nearby residential properties. The facility currently utilizes silos of

1:18:11 similar size and height for their operation and staff does not expect these

1:18:15 proposed silos to cause an unreasonable visual impact to the area. So in conclusion,

1:18:21 as I previously noted the Planning Commission held the public hearing, one

1:18:25 person spoke in opposition of the request upon conclusion of the public

1:18:28 and with further deliberation, they recommended approval of the request as presented for a maximum of three silos subject to the following conditions.

1:18:36 I won't read all of them, but I will say that number three was added by the commission.

1:18:41 And that was subject to any structure used to enhance the safety of the silos,

1:18:46 maybe added provided they do not exceed 80 feet.

1:18:49 That came about by one of the commissioners saying the silos were very specific at 79 or

1:18:57 70 feet, maybe hosha decides they need to have a light up top or a lighter extension or something

1:19:03 that will exceed that 70 feet.

1:19:05 So they said any of those types of extensions for safety measures should be able to happen

1:19:10 without having to come back through the process.

1:19:13 That's why condition number three was added.

1:19:18 include it to be a concur with the commission's recommendation and that is all we have.

1:19:23 Johnson, I'm looking and maybe I'm just not seeing it right. I see two conditions on the

1:19:32 staff. It was changed because of the timing of this. I'm going to put it up here. Okay.

1:19:37 The commission added it. We had your packets out before the night before because of Thanksgiving.

1:19:43 So I'm going to put it up here. Could you just support clarification? Yes, I believe the packets

1:19:55 We're done Tuesday afternoon, we had the meeting Tuesday night, so we had to add it on Wednesday.

1:19:59 Very good.

1:20:00 Do I have any questions for Jonathan?

1:20:05 I have one question for you, Mr. Mon.

1:20:07 Do you have to come back just out of curiosity?

1:20:10 This looks obviously to be an expansion of your existing facility here.

1:20:15 Any additional jobs?

1:20:17 My comfort.

1:20:20 We anticipate about eight.

1:20:23 Excellent.

1:20:24 Excellent.

1:20:25 I should mention that we don't anticipate any more,

1:20:28 when I'm processing more milk or making more change,

1:20:32 cheese is an enhancement if you will,

1:20:35 additional processing equipment on the way processes.

1:20:39 Okay, utilizing the same resources coming in,

1:20:43 but just using them more efficiently.

1:20:45 Yes. Okay.

1:20:46 That makes sense. Thank you, sir.

1:20:47 So it actually potentially is less

1:20:49 compared to our wastewater loading.

1:20:52 So new equipment will take more,

1:20:55 but we're going to use the water that's in the milk.

1:20:58 We recycle it.

1:20:59 That's just a clean.

1:21:02 Very good.

1:21:03 Thank you, Ms. Ma.

1:21:05 If we don't have, oh, John Berger.

1:21:06 I just have a question for Jonathan.

1:21:07 Did you mention there was one person who spoke against the request

1:21:10 of the planning commission since we don't have the minutes?

1:21:12 Could you tell us what that person had to say?

1:21:15 The person who spoke against it is the person that lives immediately

1:21:19 south here, speaking against it was that because the minutes haven't

1:21:29 been approved or anything by give you a general sentiment.

1:21:32 We're back up where you there so you could be.

1:21:37 I was not.

1:21:38 Chris said to give a try.

1:21:39 His basic sentiment was Glamby as a big company and so they'll probably be approved.

1:21:44 He believes that a couple of silos were already put up and that big companies in town bring

1:21:51 jobs and so they have a, they're going to be allowed to do it anyway.

1:21:57 That's pretty much it.

1:21:58 That's the best I can do.

1:22:01 Thank you.

1:22:02 Thank you, Jonathan.

1:22:03 All right.

1:22:04 I see no further likes.

1:22:05 this time I'll go ahead and open up the public testimony portion of the

1:22:08 seedlings hearing for anyone that would like to come forward and testify

1:22:11 regarding this item. I see no one coming forward so I'm going to close the public

1:22:18 testimony portion and turn it back to council for any additional questions

1:22:23 and or a motion. Please don't jump out at the same time.

1:22:33 Well I will go ahead and make a motion that we allow the building height on the

1:22:39 silos on the property located at 236 Washington Street South for Glenby up with the three with the three conditions

1:22:50 And we have a second by Chris talking yes

1:22:53 Motion on four by Suzanne Hawkins seconded by Chris talking to anything further on that motion council

1:23:04 Suzanne Hawkins yes Jim on yes

1:23:08 Yes, yes

1:23:10 Great. Well, and team. Yes, Don Hall. Yes, Rebecca Mills, I guess. Yes. Motion passes.

1:23:16 Seven to zero. Thank you, gentlemen. Okay. Moving on to the next item on the agenda.

1:23:22 The public hearing is a request for a zoning title amendment to delete Title 10,

1:23:27 Chapter 6, Section 1 Plan Unit Development Sub-District and replace with

1:23:33 new Section Title 10, Chapter 6, Section 1. Zoning Development Agreement to add a

1:23:38 definition of zoning development agreement to Title 10, Chapter 2, definitions, and to

1:23:44 amend Title 10, Chapter 2, definitions of plan unit development.

1:23:48 Again, we have Jonathan Spentlow.

1:23:50 Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council.

1:23:53 This is a zoning title limit long in the making, about a year or so, a year and a half.

1:23:59 This will entirely remove Title 10, Chapter 6, which is the plan unit development or PUDs.

1:24:05 Replace it with a new section.

1:24:08 number titled ZDA. The reason for the name change was we needed to conform or follow what

1:24:15 the state statute said. What we were doing as PUDs have the same name in the state statute

1:24:20 we weren't actually doing what the state statute said so we needed to change the name a little

1:24:24 bit. Along with that, the other changes most notably, the change will be a clear requirement

1:24:32 for applicants in regard to the conceptual development plans and documents needed. Number

1:24:36 Number two, stated criteria for conformance to the conceptual development plan, and three

1:24:41 a clear path of procedure for the ZDA process.

1:24:44 I've outlined those in your reports as one, two, three to follow them.

1:24:47 I'm not going to read all of them, but basically what this will do is make the whole process

1:24:53 a little bit more clear to the applicants, more clear to the commission and to the council

1:24:57 as you see them, and more clear to the staff as far as the changes that people want to make

1:25:02 to their development plans after they've been adopted.

1:25:08 Another big change is the documents will be signed prior

1:25:12 to the council actually passing the ordinance

1:25:15 or passing the zoning.

1:25:18 Right now there are times where the council

1:25:21 will approve the zoning or approve the PUD

1:25:23 but the documents aren't signed.

1:25:24 It's a loophole the developers have.

1:25:27 We're gonna close that loophole by saying

1:25:28 they have to sign it prior to any ordinance being passed.

1:25:32 So once the council makes the final decision

1:25:34 on any now ZDA agreement,

1:25:37 as soon as you pass it, it is then the law, it's the zone.

1:25:42 Soon as it's published, so that's a big change.

1:25:45 The rest of these, you can go through them.

1:25:48 Most of the packet is actually sections

1:25:51 that refer to PUD,

1:25:53 that we have to change to ZDA.

1:25:55 It's probably seven or eight pages

1:25:56 that just list different code sections

1:25:58 that we have to change the name.

1:25:59 The book of it is really only three pages.

1:26:02 talks about the purpose and the standards and the conceptual development plan is a lot more

1:26:07 clear on what we require, close to residential and non-residential. A lot of the changes were

1:26:15 made and implemented by the Planning and Zoning Commission, they wanted to see more information

1:26:20 up front than we have been seeing in the past, particularly when it comes to multi-use transportation

1:26:26 access and pathways, the density, the building height. The difference will be that developers

1:26:31 now have to say the main differences between their ZDA and what the zoning currently is

1:26:36 on the property.

1:26:37 So it will be a lot more clear to follow what they really want to do as well as hold them

1:26:42 accountable to any changes they want to make after it's been approved.

1:26:48 So conclusion here.

1:26:52 On October 28th the Planning and Zoning Commission unanimously recommended approval of the amendment

1:26:56 as presented.

1:26:58 This change could affect properties within the area of impact and staff concurs with the

1:27:01 commission's recommendation.

1:27:02 is stand for questions.

1:27:04 Yeah, we have a question for Chris, but just real quick,

1:27:06 is this an item that would need to go to third and final

1:27:09 changing, because it's changing in ordinance?

1:27:12 Okay, very good.

1:27:13 Chris Donington.

1:27:14 So Jonathan, if this is approved,

1:27:17 I'd like to know the impact requiring the applicant

1:27:21 to sign the PUD at the time of, I don't know,

1:27:25 acceptance rather than sometime in the future.

1:27:28 I recall, because I voted against the PUD

1:27:32 that had a change in density, that there had been some,

1:27:36 I don't know, some wiggle room or whatever.

1:27:39 Would this prevent that for consideration

1:27:42 or would the applicant still be able to change

1:27:45 the terms of a PUD even after signing?

1:27:49 I don't believe they'd be able to change

1:27:51 specifically the density after they've signed it.

1:27:53 However, I believe the process would be

1:27:56 if there's a public hearing and they come up here

1:27:59 and you guys say I want to change the density,

1:28:00 you put a maximum density and they don't

1:28:02 agree with that, they can not proceed further until they sign the changes that you guys implemented.

1:28:08 If they don't agree with the changes, the zoning stays the same as it is, the PUD does

1:28:14 not happen, it does not become an ordinance signed by you, it does not change the zoning

1:28:19 at all.

1:28:20 So from the builder's point of view, it's all cut and dry, black and white, no negotiation.

1:28:31 I'm trying to look at from how they look at it.

1:28:35 Did we have anybody testify or I guess we have some opportunity of people who are here at

1:28:40 the public hearing?

1:28:41 I'd just like to know what the downside is from the developers by us tightening this

1:28:47 structure.

1:28:48 The impacts I see is going to require a lot more work from them up front to decide what

1:28:53 they want to do with property prior to coming to the public hearing.

1:28:57 need a more solid plan with more more solid like density numbers. The development plan

1:29:03 calls out certain things that need to be part of the plan that currently they're not actually

1:29:07 putting in. Okay, we will require more work up front for them. Okay, the benefits I believe

1:29:14 to the people that are going to be affected by these EDA's, that way that person. Okay,

1:29:20 thank you.

1:29:21 clear. You reckon, Melissa? Sir?

1:29:24 Thank you, Mayor. And maybe to help

1:29:26 answer Chris's question, you know, I

1:29:29 think that wouldn't wouldn't have been

1:29:31 a possibility after after this is passed

1:29:34 because they do have A through H. If

1:29:37 those changes are made after approval,

1:29:40 it just clarifies for staff and the

1:29:44 applicant what's allowed and what's not

1:29:45 allowed and if there is B, for instance,

1:29:48 is an increase in density and if there

1:29:51 is a change made to the plan that is an increase in density that causes the process to start

1:29:58 over again and for it to go back through public hearing.

1:30:01 And that's a good question is, you know, what's the downside and the Planning and Zoning Commission

1:30:06 has been working on this with the staff for several months and I really think they have

1:30:11 done an excellent job in vetting the process.

1:30:15 Not the process we never heard any negative comments from developers or applicants.

1:30:22 And time and time again, the commission said, you know, really this is positive for both

1:30:27 the community and the applicants because it just makes the process more clear.

1:30:32 The developer knows what's being expected and the community knows what's coming.

1:30:37 There won't be any surprises.

1:30:39 You know, I'm reminded of a story that Katie Breckenridge came to us about, you know,

1:30:45 she said when the parking lot that was approved near her property for what is the old Del

1:30:51 parking lot, it had, you know, this berm and these trees and it looked really great and

1:30:56 so it was approved and as she pointed over to the parking lot, you saw that none of those

1:31:02 landscaping improvements were made and so I think it seems like that, that this will

1:31:07 really improve the process. And like Jonathan said, the loophole in the system where the council

1:31:14 can change the zone, but then sometimes we've had an applicant refuse to sign. And what does

1:31:19 that really mean? Does it mean the zone exists or doesn't exist? Really these changes clarify

1:31:26 the process I think for everyone and let people know what's coming up front so that they do

1:31:31 have due process and the ability to comment on it before it happens. So yeah, I really

1:31:37 tried to look for maybe a downside or something negative, but with all the work that's been

1:31:43 put into it and as Jonathan said over the past year, really, I think that the improvements

1:31:49 are pretty positive.

1:31:50 Thank you Rebecca, Sean Bearer.

1:31:53 Jonathan, does the density component only deal with those that will have a residential component

1:31:58 in them. So maybe the better question is how is density defined? Typically it's a residential

1:32:05 deal as far as units or units per acre. Typically that's what it is. If you're going for apartments

1:32:12 that would definitely come under the density. They would have to save how many units they

1:32:16 want to have. We're going to have as a base or a maximum. Then if they want to change

1:32:22 those later they would have to come back through the process. If you're thinking of like a commercial

1:32:26 just stores, it really isn't a density requirement or density.

1:32:31 Those are regulated typically by the height,

1:32:34 the lock coverage, requirement for parking and landscaping.

1:32:39 Thank you.

1:32:42 Hey, can I have a comment?

1:32:43 Sorry, can I pipe in for a second?

1:32:45 Oh, I'm sorry.

1:32:45 And it's provided another further answer

1:32:48 just to Councilman Berger's question.

1:32:52 Density is what John says, more talking about residential,

1:32:55 but if you look on that same list

1:32:56 at the bottom of page two.

1:32:58 We also talk about an increase in building height

1:33:00 and increase in building coverage of the site.

1:33:03 And those would be more about the non-residential development.

1:33:06 So you're going to see in a plan,

1:33:08 you'll see kind of a layout and a size of buildings

1:33:13 and that generally layout needs to stay the same.

1:33:17 So an increase to the building coverage in a non-residential

1:33:21 setting is a very similar kind of a thing

1:33:23 to an increase in density and a residential

1:33:26 And so I think that's covered as well.

1:33:29 And D, in that list, A through.

1:33:34 And then I'm going to go back to questions if I can.

1:33:39 So I'm trying to remember who asked it now.

1:33:45 I think Chris, you asked what might the downside be the developers?

1:33:49 And I see this really eliminating flexibility

1:33:54 and firming up the plans up front.

1:33:57 If I were a developer, I would want to maintain

1:33:59 as much flexibility as I could,

1:34:00 and I can see that being a potential downside.

1:34:03 However, I'll also say that that was the primary goal,

1:34:06 at least for the Planning and Zoning Commission

1:34:08 going into this was to eliminate flexibility.

1:34:11 So that the plan that was sold to the community

1:34:15 is the plan that is developed.

1:34:17 And so that I see as a downside,

1:34:20 but I also see that as being the goal of the commission

1:34:23 in moving forward with this.

1:34:26 And then one more thought.

1:34:28 This code amendment was actually prepared,

1:34:31 actually two more thoughts, I'm sorry.

1:34:33 This code amendment was prepared

1:34:34 when we were working as a ZOAC committee.

1:34:36 A lot of it was prepared when we were working

1:34:37 as a ZOAC committee.

1:34:39 And at one point, we had the ZOAC group

1:34:43 had this done enough that we presented this

1:34:46 at two different public open houses.

1:34:49 And we didn't have a great attendance

1:34:51 at those open houses, but we did have

1:34:53 a couple of developer types up to those open houses,

1:34:55 and they made a couple of suggestions to this one,

1:34:58 and we implemented those suggestions,

1:34:59 and but generally it was pretty well accepted.

1:35:02 The one thing I'll add is that since that time,

1:35:06 H on that list of A through H was added by the commission,

1:35:12 I don't know that that necessarily would cause

1:35:15 those developers to change their comments

1:35:17 at that open house that we held.

1:35:19 It's probably been eight, nine months ago now.

1:35:23 And then finally, Don, you asked the question about does this need to be on third and final tonight?

1:35:28 And not tonight. We don't have the ordinance in front of you tonight for adoption.

1:35:32 We just have the plan. When the ordinance does come back, it will.

1:35:36 If you want to adopt it that same night, we'll need to be on third and final and all that.

1:35:40 But tonight we haven't provided you with the ordinance for adoption. Just the language.

1:35:46 Thank you for that clarification. Anything further for Jonathan?

1:35:51 Sorry, I'm sorry.

1:35:52 Your life wasn't on.

1:35:53 Sorry, I apologize.

1:35:56 So I'm not opposed to what you're bringing it all, but Rebecca's point about the parking lot without the landscaping just made me think.

1:36:05 They agreed to do it and didn't, and we really have no way to enforce that.

1:36:09 And even though they're signing at the beginning in that same predicament,

1:36:13 if the parking lot was done under the ZDA instead,

1:36:19 what enforcement do we have to go back and make them do it?

1:36:21 I mean, it's a parking lot,

1:36:22 it's not like you're gonna close it down on them,

1:36:24 or I mean, what can we do

1:36:27 if they have agreed to put in so many trees

1:36:30 and the berms and they just don't do it?

1:36:32 So I can't speak about that particular instance.

1:36:36 Under this, then typically those parking lots

1:36:39 would all be done at the time building permit,

1:36:41 in the finalization.

1:36:42 If the parking lot is associated with the building, typically the building is not given

1:36:47 a certificate of occupancy until those improvements are accomplished and completed.

1:36:51 I'm not sure what happened at that one.

1:36:55 I can't speak for that one, but that's how it's done.

1:36:57 Any building would have to comply with whatever ZDA or it's going to be applied to.

1:37:03 They have to follow those rules.

1:37:05 But the changes we're making really don't affect.

1:37:08 It doesn't change how it is now anyway.

1:37:11 It's the same thing.

1:37:12 still would fall back the same way.

1:37:14 I think that was urban renewal, wasn't it?

1:37:16 I don't know.

1:37:17 Okay, thank you.

1:37:20 Greg Lanning.

1:37:22 Fritz, this may be a question for you.

1:37:23 Along the same line, what is our process for,

1:37:28 as I think of another one, and I won't name the exact

1:37:33 business that moved into a home, and at least in my mind,

1:37:37 when we got done, we were going to have a berm.

1:37:39 So it kind of followed the same general landscaping

1:37:43 that was going along the west side of Washington Street,

1:37:46 that's the different places, and the borough never occurred,

1:37:48 and yet that business is in operation

1:37:51 and has been for some time.

1:37:53 And so what process do we have for enforcement of some of it?

1:37:57 I'm not remembering what that was,

1:37:58 so did they require a special use permit or anything?

1:38:01 Yeah, they changed the house into a business,

1:38:05 and they changed the,

1:38:07 we've proved some additional,

1:38:09 Williams-Coy practice across from CSI.

1:38:14 Yeah, we assumed anyway, and maybe I heard it wrong.

1:38:18 So the way we deal with those is we send them notice that we're going to planning its

1:38:23 own commission is going to do a revocation of the special use after we wrote the special

1:38:28 use of that goes through they're operating illegally.

1:38:31 So the next thing we do is go we take them to court then because they're operating illegally.

1:38:37 All right.

1:38:38 And will this and this is possibly a question for you or them.

1:38:42 Those are situations that were that were back up brought up that the other end of Washington Street

1:38:48 The northern end of Washington Street on the east side the sidewalk goes to nowhere

1:38:52 It just ends in front of all those condos there because either our development agreement

1:38:58 Wasn't what it needed to be or the people we didn't make a bond or whatever that but that those kind of things

1:39:04 Is this the kind of stuff that will help that do no longer occur? That's what you decide to I hold

1:39:09 Mitch

1:39:11 I honestly don't know why the sidewalk never got built. It should have been built and nothing about the rules that I see in place then or now

1:39:20 Even after this changes would would suggest to me that there's any reason why that sidewalk didn't get built now

1:39:26 We're talking behind the town homes there on the on the east side of Washington north of the storage

1:39:31 You know what you're talking right right and the curb and sidewalk never got built never got built and it should have honestly

1:39:37 I can't I don't understand why that wasn't required at the time and those were built

1:39:41 I'm sure there's no reason for it, but as you had further closer, further north, closer

1:39:47 to the canning crest, there is another vacant lot at the corner and that hasn't developed

1:39:54 yet.

1:39:55 That's the reason why it doesn't continue all the way to the corner, but there is a piece

1:39:59 there that has been developed and should have been built with the sidewalk and a curb and

1:40:04 a gutter and a widening of the street to the sidewalk curb and gutter that never happened

1:40:08 and I just honestly honestly wanted to be because the new hotel and some of those other

1:40:14 things along there maybe didn't have a spirit sidewalk yet so maybe it was a deferral type

1:40:18 of thing until there was contiguous that's just that the the developer didn't have to

1:40:23 vote for the long run.

1:40:24 Perhaps there could be a deferral.

1:40:25 Why are you looking at that?

1:40:27 Make that happen down when things come due later.

1:40:31 I'm just just hoping all these things help help us to alleviate these problems in the future

1:40:36 because I see this city having to put that in someday.

1:40:41 That section of ground there.

1:40:43 All right, thank you.

1:40:45 Sorry.

1:40:45 Anything further from council before we open up the public testimony

1:40:49 portion of this hearing?

1:40:52 At this time, we're opening up public testimony portion of the hearing.

1:40:55 Is there anyone wishing to come forward and testify?

1:41:01 I see no one coming forward.

1:41:02 So we're closing the public testimony portion of the hearing,

1:41:05 turn it back over to council for any additional questions and or motions.

1:41:12 Chris talking.

1:41:12 So I'm assuming lacking an ordinance

1:41:14 which does has this as the first hearing tonight.

1:41:17 So we would just ask for the council

1:41:20 to give us some direction to go prepare an ordinance

1:41:22 that looks like this.

1:41:24 It looks like this.

1:41:25 Good, one second.

1:41:28 We have a motion on the floor by Chris Dodgton,

1:41:30 seconded by Greg Lanting to instruct the staff

1:41:33 to go forward and prepare a ordinance related

1:41:37 to what was presented to us this evening.

1:41:40 Anything further on that motion council?

1:41:44 the island roll call vote, please.

1:41:47 Yes.

1:41:48 Sean Berger.

1:41:49 Yes.

1:41:50 Chris Daukington.

1:41:50 Yes.

1:41:51 Greg Lanting.

1:41:52 Yes.

1:41:52 Don Hall.

1:41:53 Yes.

1:41:53 Rebecca Mills-Sneikert.

1:41:55 Yes.

1:41:55 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:41:56 Yes.

1:41:57 Motion passes 7-0.

1:42:00 That's the last item on our agenda this evening.

1:42:02 Is there anything for Councilor Stapp before we adjourn?

1:42:06 I see nothing, so we are now adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, December 1, 2014. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:42:37.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    b5ac4df9c1031c71f8e5805776756a2d9dfb4dd36b1e421cea00ea6439fee0cb
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a ff6bf5737f30c3680ec7b2b6220c3ebae14145b05ea5be21cd9c1f888e3da6f5
    part02.m4a cea3eab2511e9716f7936c914565fc5934e963f73013ad3bfaf025c14e1c2500
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    e70daf74e3bd0d77c433a266110f6c96c774effd0d391175c6ff6dfc82277d02

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file