City Council meeting
Monday, April 13, 2015
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Minutes on file
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:00:54 I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council order. It's April 13th 2015 and as always our first item
0:01:01 I our agenda is to do the Pledge of Allegiance, so please rise. I
0:01:04 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:01:24 Welcome everyone to the council meeting this evening.
0:01:27 We do have a quorum of the city council.
0:01:29 There's five members here.
0:01:30 We have two members there, had prior engagements, we're not able to make it this evening.
0:01:36 Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to our agenda this evening?
0:01:40 and all amendments to this evening.
0:01:41 Thank you, sir.
0:01:42 We do have a couple of proclamations and I have the privilege of reading this first one
0:01:46 on Saturday at volunteer event at the senior center and Jeanette, thank you for allowing
0:01:54 me to be there and part of that.
0:01:56 And so I will be reading the first proclamation.
0:01:59 Open your heart, do your part, volunteer, share and care.
0:02:04 Through countless acts of kindness, generosity and service, residents of Twin Falls recognize
0:02:09 that we are all bound together, that we move this community forward by giving of ourselves
0:02:15 to others and caring for those around us.
0:02:18 Every day the citizens of Twin Falls carry forward the tradition of service embedded in
0:02:23 our character as a people.
0:02:26 As we celebrate National Volunteer Week, we embrace our shared responsibility to one another
0:02:32 and recommit to the task of building a better community.
0:02:37 Whereas the City of Twin Falls accomplishes so much more for their citizens because of
0:02:42 the large number of volunteers who truly care about their neighbors and their city and whereas
0:02:49 volunteers are one of our city's greatest assets in that they are dedicated to helping others
0:02:54 and unselfishly give their personal time to make a difference.
0:02:59 Whereas individuals and our community is at the center of social change discovering their
0:03:06 power to make a difference, and whereas during this week all over the nation, service projects
0:03:12 will be performed and volunteers recognize for their commitment to service, and whereas
0:03:17 the giving of oneself in service to another empowers the giver and the recipient, and whereas
0:03:24 the health and well being of our seniors is in the interest of all and further adds to
0:03:29 the health and well-being of the community, and whereas volunteers are a vital to our
0:03:36 future as a caring and productive citizen city, and now therefore, I, Don Hall, Mayor
0:03:43 City of Twin Falls, proclaim the week of April 12th through the 18th, 2015 as National
0:03:48 Volunteer Week in Twin Falls, Idaho, and urge my fellow citizens to volunteer in their respective
0:03:56 communities by volunteering and recognizing those who serve, we can come together to make
0:04:01 a difference.
0:04:02 And at this time I'd ask Janette to come forward.
0:04:18 We appreciate the city recognizing how important volunteers are in the community without them.
0:04:24 The senior center would have a very little possibility of surviving.
0:04:28 We have almost a hundred that work on a part-time basis at the center and without their diligence
0:04:33 and daily commitments to the cause.
0:04:36 would be very hard for us to handle the load that we do in providing meals for the community.
0:04:41 But also the fact that there's so many other organizations that rely heartily on volunteerism
0:04:46 as well.
0:04:47 And we're going to highlight some of those.
0:04:49 We are having a volunteerism fair with about 14 different agencies on Friday between 2 and
0:04:55 3 o'clock at the senior center so people can come and look and take a choice of what they
0:05:00 might be able to do.
0:05:01 And so we've asked some of them to come to the center so they can have a choice and explore
0:05:06 the different options that are available.
0:05:08 We also are looking very desperately for home meal delivery drivers is the time of the year
0:05:12 when everybody decides to take a vacation or be offered a little bit.
0:05:16 So we have a real burden right now and I feel that if I pray about it and ask about it,
0:05:22 it will finally get filled.
0:05:24 Also one of our gentlemen that used to do our home meal delivery and helped in the kitchen
0:05:28 a little bit.
0:05:30 He had a major heart attack and had bypasses last week, and he's unable to, and that's left
0:05:36 a very old boy, because he was our person that always went back out after the Mills were delivered
0:05:41 if there was somebody that needed to have a late delivery, or we missed the first time
0:05:45 around, he was that person to pick that load up.
0:05:47 So like I said, if there's somebody out there, we'd appreciate it, but we appreciated Mayor
0:05:51 Hall coming on Saturday and recognizing all the volunteers.
0:05:55 Everybody said it was an excellent banquet, and everybody sure enjoyed it.
0:05:59 They fed us extremely well as well, didn't they?
0:06:03 We do that.
0:06:04 I have an excellent chef and he does a great job and we're always trying to figure out ways
0:06:10 to come up with more money and so our fundraiser will be on April 25th.
0:06:14 It is a local celebrity roast with Danny Morona.
0:06:17 We're roasting him and having a dinner with our chef is preparing.
0:06:21 It should be a night of fun.
0:06:22 So if anybody would like to have tickets, they can just call the center.
0:06:25 Excellent.
0:06:26 Our oldest volunteer that day was 94, is that correct?
0:06:29 That's correct.
0:06:30 Yeah, how impressive.
0:06:32 Yeah, and we still have a driver who's still delivering on the home deliver meal size, and
0:06:36 he's 90.
0:06:37 Wow.
0:06:38 And still driving.
0:06:39 So he does an excellent job and has, and like his wife says, if he's not going to the
0:06:44 center, he really misses it a lot.
0:06:46 I mean, he demands that he shows up every day and he has for years.
0:06:50 But yes, and the volunteer that's 94, Ashley, is legally blind, but she still sows and
0:06:55 quilt room and she pieces patches of fabric together and they make beautiful quilts out of them.
0:07:02 Thank you, Janette. Thank you. Appreciate it. Next proclamation we get to do today is telecommunication.
0:07:09 Telecommunicators week, April 12th through the 18th 2015 and after I read this I'd like to ask
0:07:15 Lieutenant Stodz to come forward and say a few words and I'll present this to him. Whereas
0:07:20 As emergencies can occur at any time that require police or fire services, and whereas when an
0:07:26 emergency occurs, the prompt response of police officers and firefighters is critical to the
0:07:32 protection of life and preservation of property, and whereas the safety of our police officers
0:07:38 and firefighters is dependent upon the quality and accuracy of information obtained from citizens
0:07:44 who telephone the City Communication Center, and whereas public safety, telecommunicators,
0:07:51 dispatchers are the first and most critical contact our citizens have with an emergency
0:07:57 service, and whereas public safety telecommunicators, dispatchers are the single vital link for
0:08:04 our police officers and firefighters by monitoring their activities by radio, providing them information
0:08:11 and ensuring their safety, and whereas public safety telecommunicators, dispatchers, of the
0:08:17 City of Twin Falls have contributed substantially to the apprehension of criminals, suppression
0:08:23 of fires, and treatment of the injured, and whereas each telecommunicator, dispatcher, has
0:08:30 exhibited compassion, understanding, and professionalism in the performance of their job in the past
0:08:37 year.
0:08:38 where I don hall mayor of the city of Twin Falls do proclaim.
0:08:41 Telecommunicators week in Twin Falls, Idaho, and urge all citizens of the city of Twin Falls to join in this observation.
0:08:49 Lieutenant Stots.
0:09:04 Thank you Mr. Mayor and Council members for taking the time to recognize such a dedicated group of professionals.
0:09:10 Often the public safety telecommunications dispatchers overlooked and undervalued.
0:09:15 They are truly the silent heroes of public safety.
0:09:18 Last week the police and command staff spoke to a group of student leadership members from
0:09:24 our Magic Valley and when it was my turn to talk about my division that oversee I asked
0:09:30 them what their expectation was if they called 911 and they said simply that we expect help.
0:09:38 That is exactly what your men and women do every day in the city communication center
0:09:42 is help others.
0:09:45 The public safety dispatchers are truly the first responders.
0:09:48 This profession is extremely challenging, it's stressful, yet rewarding, and it requires
0:09:53 a tremendous amount of patients, multitasking abilities, and technical knowledge.
0:09:59 And just to give you some statistics, a lot of people like statistics, the City Communication
0:10:06 Center fields approximately 150,000 calls for service, I'm sorry, not calls for service,
0:10:12 ongoing and outgoing calls every year, which results in about 50,000 calls for
0:10:18 service that have to be handled at some level or another by a city employee, 20,
0:10:23 911 calls per year and equates to about 400 calls per day that our
0:10:33 dispatchers are handling. And that is aside from all the radio traffic that they
0:10:40 have to listen to, respond to, know where their officers and firefighters are at all times.
0:10:47 And that number is kind of astounding as well.
0:10:52 They handle about 80 radio transmissions per hour.
0:10:58 And if you do that math, that's close to 60,000 a month.
0:11:04 So every time that a firefighter or police officer presses the button on the radio and
0:11:10 dispatch response they're doing that over 80 times an hour.
0:11:14 So a tremendous amount of work.
0:11:15 So thank you again.
0:11:17 We appreciate you recognizing our dispatchers
0:11:21 and the fine job that they do.
0:11:22 Thank you.
0:11:23 Thank you, Lieutenant.
0:11:24 And I spent a little bit of time in working as a police
0:11:28 officer, and I always said I don't
0:11:31 think I could do the job of a dispatcher that's tough.
0:11:35 And sometimes it's thankless.
0:11:36 So thank you for bringing that to our attention.
0:11:38 Oh, he got away from me.
0:11:41 Suzanne.
0:11:42 Sorry.
0:11:43 I'm going to put you back on the spot.
0:11:45 Was there a barbecue or is there going to be a barbecue lunch?
0:11:48 I look forward to that every year.
0:11:50 Well, I'm beginning to wonder.
0:11:53 Yes, thank you for reminding me.
0:11:55 Our barbecue will be this Thursday at noon and will be at the garage at the police department.
0:12:01 So thank you for reminding me.
0:12:03 Thank you.
0:12:04 If we could give both of these groups a hand, thank you very much.
0:12:13 Next item on the agenda is general public input.
0:12:16 If there's anyone here from the general public that would like to address the City Council,
0:12:19 now is your opportunity.
0:12:22 Okay, we were moving.
0:12:25 My mic is on.
0:12:26 Am I not getting picked up?
0:12:27 Maybe I'm too far away.
0:12:29 Okay.
0:12:30 Next item on the agenda is the consent calendar.
0:12:33 I will turn that over to Council for their direction.
0:12:35 We have motion on the floor by Jim Munn, seconded by Rebecca Milsoyka to approve the
0:12:46 consent calendar as published anything further on that motion council.
0:12:51 Yeah, I think we have a roll call vote, please.
0:12:53 Susan Hawkins?
0:12:54 Yes.
0:12:55 Jim Munn?
0:12:55 Yes.
0:12:56 Sean Berriger?
0:12:57 Yes.
0:12:59 Don Hall?
0:12:59 Yes.
0:13:00 Rebecca Milsoicam?
0:13:01 Yes.
0:13:02 Motion passes 5-0.
0:13:04 Thank you, Council.
0:13:05 Moving now under items for consideration, first item is consideration of request to
0:13:10 authorize the mayor to sign a cooperative agreement with ITD for Americans with
0:13:15 Disability Act, ADA, Curb Grant Program Award,
0:13:20 and to adopt a resolution confirming the commitment.
0:13:23 The resolution, if you choose to adopt this evening,
0:13:27 will be number 1945.
0:13:30 So I will now ask Mandy Constant to come forward,
0:13:33 our grant administrator.
0:13:36 Welcome.
0:13:37 Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of council.
0:13:39 I will be brief this evening.
0:13:41 I just wanted to bring before you this resolution
0:13:44 and the cooperative agreement.
0:13:47 So the ADA for a little background,
0:13:48 the ADA Curbrand Program is a state administered program
0:13:51 that provides for funding for projects
0:13:53 to address pedestrian curb ramps,
0:13:55 but they are limited to our state highway system.
0:13:58 So there have been questions asked of city staff
0:14:01 in the past, why did you choose that particular location?
0:14:04 In order to receive this particular pot of money,
0:14:06 we have to keep the locations have to be located
0:14:10 on one of our state highways.
0:14:11 The goal of the program is to provide a safe
0:14:13 easily accessible facilities for pedestrians with disabilities while allowing local jurisdictions
0:14:19 the flexibility of choosing which of the locations they would like to use the funds for.
0:14:26 The process is under which we make the selection of the locations of the ramps is by utilizing
0:14:34 a ADA transition plan that was put together by one of our engineers, Josh Baird.
0:14:39 We choose based on the priorities that have been assigned by ITD,
0:14:45 location to government offices and facilities and other places of public accommodation,
0:14:49 as well as the ability to considerably improve the local ADA accessible networks.
0:14:53 So we try when we can to create essentially to create routes that could be more easily
0:15:00 allow for those with disabilities to more easily access some of these locations.
0:15:06 The city applied for these particular funds in April 2011 to construct 11 ramps on the state highway system.
0:15:13 Also part of the application process is to get letters of support from property owners that are adjacent to these curbs.
0:15:21 We've never, to my knowledge, this is the second time that we've done this.
0:15:26 No one's ever said no.
0:15:28 We've had a few times, we've had a hard time getting ahold of people because a lot of times they're rental properties and it's hard to come track down the owners.
0:15:34 But everyone's always very happy that we are there to make improvements to their property,
0:15:38 the property's adjacent.
0:15:40 They always ask us to go a little bit further and work on the sidewalks.
0:15:43 Unfortunately, we can't do that.
0:15:46 So the city was notified in July of 2014 that we were awarded the $60,000 grant,
0:15:51 which is the maximum amount to be awarded through this grant program.
0:15:55 And we were able with that first award in July of 2014 to actually construct 14 wraps.
0:16:03 And that was because some of the ramps were a little bit more
0:16:07 straightforward than we thought.
0:16:08 And we were able to do a few more with the funding per approval
0:16:12 by I.T.D.
0:16:13 And so then this particular award is also to do 11 ramps.
0:16:17 But there is, again, the possibility
0:16:19 that we might be able to do a few more if the construction
0:16:23 costs are a little bit less.
0:16:24 And then additionally, Josh and I are also
0:16:26 working on an application for the 2015 cycle for another $60,000.
0:16:33 So, as long as the state's willing to help us in this endeavor, we'll continue to apply for the funds.
0:16:38 The funds are only to be used for construction, and they will be available in July 2015.
0:16:45 So, about the time we get finished with one grant, then we'll be able to go into the next one.
0:16:50 And in your packet is all of the locations of the ramps that we've selected and the work that will be done.
0:16:57 Is there any way you could put it up on the overhead so the folks in the audience can see?
0:17:03 Absolutely. Do you want the map or the actual individual?
0:17:11 Excuse me, as you can see, they're along Highway 93,
0:17:22 primarily, and then also Highway 30.
0:17:26 Now, remind me, do I need to read aloud the resolution,
0:17:36 or how does this? No, you don't have to read it.
0:17:39 Hopefully we've all read it and we're ready to
0:17:42 take some action. Sean Berger. Mayor, I would have
0:17:46 move to approve resolution 1945.
0:17:50 Second.
0:17:51 Motion on 4 by Sean Verver, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve resolution 1945, authorize
0:17:59 the mayor to sign it.
0:18:00 I have a question.
0:18:02 How many have we looked at the totality of how many ramps we really need, probably
0:18:07 hundreds?
0:18:08 Well, I brought my worker.
0:18:13 It is quite daunting.
0:18:14 And what's in the, we've, a lot of them are, what's in the EDA transition plan, are located
0:18:21 on the state highways, so.
0:18:22 I didn't bring the plan, I should hold the plan.
0:18:30 A lot.
0:18:31 It's in the, I think it's like 6,400 is, what's coming to mind?
0:18:35 6,400.
0:18:36 It's a ton of wraps.
0:18:38 Well, I want to say it was 1,600 intersections.
0:18:40 We assumed only 4 per.
0:18:43 So.
0:18:44 I'm sorry I asked.
0:18:45 It's a lot.
0:18:46 Thank you.
0:18:47 Anything further on the motion council?
0:18:50 The aye will roll call vote.
0:18:52 Jim Munn.
0:18:53 Yes.
0:18:54 Sean Bericher.
0:18:55 Yes.
0:18:56 Don Hahn.
0:18:57 Yes.
0:18:58 Rebecca Milsoyka.
0:18:59 Yes.
0:19:00 Suzanne Hahnkins.
0:19:01 Yes.
0:19:02 Motion passes five to zero.
0:19:03 Thank you.
0:19:04 Good job.
0:19:05 Exciting on the agenda is consideration of a request to re-adopt ordinance 3090 to vacate undeveloped property within a portion of northern passage subdivision number three and number four.
0:19:16 and number four on property located at the northeast corner of Federation Road,
0:19:22 extended, and Grandview Drive North for Northern Passage, Inc.
0:19:27 And we have Renee Caraway Johnson with us.
0:19:30 Welcome Renee.
0:19:31 Good afternoon, Mayor Hall City Council.
0:19:33 I am here this afternoon to ask for your consideration as you just said to
0:19:38 re-adopt Ordinance 3090.
0:19:41 On February 23rd of this year, the Council did adopt this ordinance,
0:19:45 which did allow for vacation of the 13 acres
0:19:48 at the northeast corner of Grandview Drive North
0:19:51 and Federation Road.
0:19:53 That is the future location of the Rock Creek Elementary School.
0:19:59 Unfortunately, after that ordinance was adopted,
0:20:04 it did not get published.
0:20:07 Idaho State Statute 50, Chapter 9, Section 901 states
0:20:12 that within one month after an ordinance is passed,
0:20:14 it shall be published.
0:20:16 Once the ordinance is published, it may take effect.
0:20:20 Due to technical timelines,
0:20:22 the ordinance was not published within the one month window.
0:20:26 The applicant informed me that they are now ready to proceed
0:20:29 and they are asking for the council to re-adopt this ordinance
0:20:32 as it was approved in February.
0:20:36 So the staff recommends that the council re-adopt
0:20:39 unless you have some questions, I believe Mr. Vosser's here.
0:20:42 If you had some questions for him.
0:20:44 Council, any questions, how about directions, Suzanne Hollis?
0:20:50 I move that we re-adopt Ordinance 3090 as presented.
0:20:54 Oh, we have to do third and final again?
0:20:59 If you want to ask tonight.
0:21:01 Yeah.
0:21:02 Well, I thought because we were re-adumpled.
0:21:03 Well, I didn't know either, so good question.
0:21:05 Okay.
0:21:06 Thank you for the clarification.
0:21:07 The council just said yes, you do, so.
0:21:08 Okay.
0:21:09 So then I would make a motion that we suspend the rules and put Ordinance 3090 on third and
0:21:15 final by title only.
0:21:16 I'll second that.
0:21:17 We have a motion on the floor by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Rebecca Melsoica as stated.
0:21:22 Anything further on that motion council?
0:21:24 The add or roll call vote please.
0:21:29 Sean Berriger?
0:21:30 Yes.
0:21:31 Don Hall?
0:21:32 Yes.
0:21:33 Rep back in Melsoica?
0:21:34 Yes.
0:21:35 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:21:36 Yes.
0:21:40 Oh, I'll just take a pass.
0:21:42 Yeah.
0:21:43 You said yes.
0:21:46 Motion passes 5-0.
0:21:47 Could you read the title?
0:21:49 In ordinance of the mayor and the city council of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho,
0:21:54 vacating the real property described below and providing for
0:21:57 investing a title to the property so vacating.
0:22:01 Stanford Motion Council, Sean Berger.
0:22:05 I would move approval of ordinance 3090.
0:22:07 Motion on four by Sean Berger, seconded by Jim Mein to approve ordinance 3090.
0:22:15 Anything further on that motion council?
0:22:18 Leanna Rokomvo please.
0:22:19 Don Hall?
0:22:20 Yes.
0:22:21 Rebecca Milsoica?
0:22:22 Yes.
0:22:23 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:22:24 Yes.
0:22:25 Jim Mun?
0:22:25 Yes.
0:22:26 Sean Berger?
0:22:27 Yes.
0:22:28 Motion passes 5-0.
0:22:29 Thank you Renee.
0:22:30 Thank you very much.
0:22:31 Have a good rest of your evening.
0:22:33 Moving on to the next item on the agenda.
0:22:35 Consideration, every request to adopt a resolution declaring
0:22:39 a sole source supplier for the purchase of law enforcement
0:22:43 computer software to aid in dispatching, map, update,
0:22:48 mobile computing, evidence and record management.
0:22:52 We have Captain Anthony Barnhart with us
0:22:55 and for the Council's application number 1946
0:23:00 if we choose to pass this.
0:23:02 Captain, welcome.
0:23:03 Good evening, Mr. Mayor and members of the Council.
0:23:06 I am here this evening to ask you to adopt
0:23:08 a sole source resolution so that the Police Department
0:23:11 may purchase software upgrade from
0:23:13 Executive Information Services
0:23:15 so that we can upgrade our current public safety system software.
0:23:20 I believe that this upgrade will improve management of our computer aided dispatching,
0:23:27 our mapping, our records, and our records management along with our property and evidence management.
0:23:33 Tonight I'd like to share with you a history of our current software,
0:23:37 talk about what the upgrade has to offer, and also break down the funding for you.
0:23:44 The executive information services is the sole provider of public safety information software
0:23:49 that we currently use.
0:23:50 We first purchased this software in 2000 and it was fully implemented in 2001.
0:23:57 There are three main components to the software.
0:24:00 The first one is the computer assisted dispatching which obviously our dispatchers use.
0:24:05 The second component is a records management system which is used by everyone in the organization
0:24:10 but primarily by our records personnel and the records bureau.
0:24:14 The third piece is the mobile data computing which is software used in our computers that
0:24:20 are in the control vehicles and our police officers use that.
0:24:23 There's some subcategories to the records management system that is the property evidence
0:24:28 management software.
0:24:30 We currently use a different software program however if we are able to move forward with
0:24:34 this upgrade we will use EIS's software.
0:24:39 And then underneath that there is a mapping component that is underneath the computer assisted
0:24:44 dispatching or piece that is primarily used with our mobile computers in the car
0:24:51 in the cars and they'll show the locations of the police officers throughout the
0:24:55 city. The software is manufactured and distributed by EIS solely. No other company
0:25:02 is capable of providing the installation, conviguration, training and support
0:25:08 services on an EIS project. For several years now we've been told by EIS that
0:25:13 they are no longer going to be able to service this product. The last update was in 2008 and I would
0:25:20 kind of compare this to Microsoft when they recently just recently came out and said that they would no
0:25:25 longer serve as Windows XP. With the EIS providing us the upgrade solution we'll be able to move forward
0:25:35 and streamline workflow and become more efficient. There are many benefits to this upgrade to our current
0:25:42 service as opposed to purchasing an entirely new system. The upgrade will
0:25:47 extend the life of our system with minimal disruption to operations. The
0:25:51 upgrade can be embedded for a fraction of the cost and risk when compared to
0:25:55 purchasing an entirely new system. We did explore some options with entirely new
0:26:00 systems. They range or varied in price between $240,000 and a half a million
0:26:07 There's also a risk involved if you take a look at going with a completely new product
0:26:13 with the data exchange from our current system over to a new product, not to mention that
0:26:18 there would be a large learning curve for our employees to learn an entirely new system.
0:26:25 The EIS upgrade provides a host of advanced functionality and new features that improve
0:26:30 productivity, security, and safety for the department.
0:26:34 The upgrade will also provide new ways to interact with each other within the department
0:26:38 and with other agencies in the area, all while maintaining the criminal justice information
0:26:44 services requirements.
0:26:45 Let me just go over a few of the upgraded highlights, specifically related to computer
0:26:51 assisted dispatching.
0:26:53 Dispatchers will now be able to receive photographs when they make a driver's license inquiry.
0:27:00 This upgrade supports high resolution wide aspect monitors, making it easier for dispatches
0:27:05 to view and manipulate their working environment, it makes it easier for event sharing specifically
0:27:10 with Circon, we'll be able to transfer service calls via the computer and mapping will be
0:27:17 a lot more accurate. The dispatchers will know exactly where the police officers are at in
0:27:22 the city. Related to the mobile data computing, this also supports DMV photographs, regional
0:27:32 messaging with other agencies, and it enhances the criminal justice information services compliant
0:27:40 encryption for officers.
0:27:43 Related to the records management system, this will improve workflow, it will be workflow-driven
0:27:50 through management, assignment, and also citizen notification.
0:27:55 Productivity enhancements like type-ahead data fields, limited exposure to fields not
0:27:59 required locally and morphing controls that dynamically change as data is entered.
0:28:06 Also property and evidence management will be streamlined with auditing and inventories.
0:28:12 Digital signature for property release to citizens and officers will now be available
0:28:17 as well.
0:28:19 These are just a few of the highlights.
0:28:21 We have a real opportunity to improve workflow and make it a lot more efficient where only
0:28:28 one person is touching the information going into records.
0:28:33 One element that they're going to provide to us is infield reporting, so the officers
0:28:37 will no longer be filling out a piece of paper and then turning it into records and having
0:28:41 them input the data.
0:28:42 The officers will now input that data.
0:28:44 It will still be checked by our records bureau, but they will be doing that initial report
0:28:49 over the computer.
0:28:53 We plan on funding a major portion of this project with two grants we received from the
0:28:58 Idaho Communication Commission. Both grants are called the dedicated enhanced emergency
0:29:04 communication grant. The first grant was awarded in fiscal year 2014 for the amount of $42,070.
0:29:11 It was awarded for an upgrade to the computer assisted dispatching software. The second grant
0:29:17 was awarded in fiscal year 2015 in the amount of $28,765 and it specifically relates to
0:29:23 the mapping in the MDCs.
0:29:31 And along with that upgrading of the software, there is some hardware upgrades that we need
0:29:36 to do that is not covered by the grants.
0:29:40 We did work with our Information Services Department to identify these needs, and specifically we
0:29:45 identified them with the property and evidence module.
0:29:48 We will need $5,210 to purchase some different items such as scanners, barcode printers, a
0:29:54 tablet and a check-in desktop to ensure that the upgraded software works to its full potential.
0:30:01 We're proposing that a budget amendment is made in our restitution line to make this purchase.
0:30:08 And in closing, I would just ask that the Council adopt this sole-source resolution so
0:30:12 that we may proceed with the upgrade with the public safety information system software.
0:30:18 And with that, I would stand for any questions.
0:30:20 Yeah after as far as the the two grants that we received one was in 14 one was in 15
0:30:26 Have we just been holding that money waiting to make this decision? Yeah?
0:30:31 I think that we had about two years stand that might okay, and secondarily the
0:30:37 52 10
0:30:38 52 $110 for that purchase the hardware. You're looking at and doing a budget amendment that will be coming later to us
0:30:46 That's not part of this evening's right discussion
0:30:48 What you are doing is you're authorizing the expenditure of $5,210 out of restitution which is currently all restitution dollars we get we place into a cash reserve position if they're not mobilized.
0:31:00 We will account for that during the budget amendment which is typically done the last week in September.
0:31:08 Okay. Do we have any further questions? We're back in Milsoyka.
0:31:12 Thank you, Mayor. Thank you, Captain Barnhart for your report.
0:31:16 Thanks for addressing a little bit kind of the highlights of the new software.
0:31:19 I just want to make sure that you guys took time and you looked at all of the other software
0:31:24 that's available out there and you felt like this would make, like you mentioned, the data
0:31:31 input a one-time data entry and you feel like this system will be the most efficient
0:31:37 and the most cost-effective upgrade for where you want to be technologically, you know,
0:31:43 now and into the next couple of years.
0:31:46 Sure, I feel really comfortable in saying that we did do our due diligence in that way.
0:31:50 We actually, for the past two years, one and a half years, we've been having these different
0:31:56 companies, these different vendors come in and put on demonstrations for us with their
0:32:00 software, including the EIS to come in and do a demo as well.
0:32:06 And I feel really comfortable with this upgrade.
0:32:09 Great.
0:32:10 Thank you.
0:32:11 I appreciate that.
0:32:12 So I just wanted to make sure the two grants are exactly what you need for the software purchase itself
0:32:17 And so the only addition is that 5200 roughly for the hardware. Yes
0:32:23 Just wanted to clarify things
0:32:25 So we're potentially going to approve the resolution and then we need to say something regarding the 52 10 as well
0:32:33 No, no if you approve the resolution, it'll be assumed that we're gonna be able to move forward with the budget amendment
0:32:39 Very good. All right. I see no further lights for questions. Stamp for a motion. Suzanne Hawkins. I move approval of resolution 1946.
0:32:48 Second. Motion on floor by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Rebecca Milsoyka. As stated. Anything further on that motion, Council?
0:32:59 The aye. The roll call vote, please. Rebecca Milsoyka. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Jim Mann. Yes. Sean Berger. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Motion passes 5-0.
0:33:10 5-0. Captain, thank you for your presentation. Next item on the agenda is
0:33:15 consideration of request to accept a section of property from JCO, Inc. and
0:33:20 authorize the mayor to sign the agreement for donation of real property and we
0:33:25 have Jason Brown. Welcome, Jason. Mr. Mayor Council members, thank you very much.
0:33:29 So the consideration is to accept the donation from JCO, Inc. for the
0:33:38 upgrade of a lift station that project we have out there at the J-Co site and
0:33:43 actually have a map just to kind of a high-level map and then I'll I'll zoom in
0:33:48 just a little bit so we can see what that looks like. So this is the location we
0:33:57 have the the cliff bar site and then Hankins, Hankins Road, you have a pointer.
0:34:04 We're high tech around here, just right here. Here is Hankins Road right here and
0:34:09 so the current lift station sits pretty much on the corner of Eldridge and
0:34:13 and Hank and so we'll zoom in just a little bit and this was this was a drawing presented by
0:34:24 Rita's L engineering who was the design engineer on the project and so under where the current lift
0:34:31 station sits we're inside of a partially inside of a utility easement and as through this process
0:34:38 of expanding the lift station to serve as Cliffbar we realized that a portion of the current lift
0:34:44 station and the future lift station is outside of this easement and so we needed to take care
0:34:50 of that in order to satisfy the requirements of the community block grant which will be
0:34:55 constructing the money that will be constructing this lift station.
0:34:59 So in working with JECO and talking with them and laying out some of the options the options
0:35:06 could have been having the city purchase that as part of that or the other was a donation
0:35:12 And through that process, they felt like the donation.
0:35:16 It's really a small section of property.
0:35:19 And so the information presented was for that donation.
0:35:25 And it requires the mayor's signature to accept that donation.
0:35:28 Very good.
0:35:29 Do we have any questions?
0:35:31 Mr. Brown, do we have some direction?
0:35:40 There's not a resolution, is it just an accepted donation, right?
0:35:43 They just, Rebecca Mills, so I got it.
0:35:47 Thank you, Mayor.
0:35:48 We all move that we accept the donation from Jacob, Inc.
0:35:51 and authorize the mayor to sign the agreement for donation of real property as presented.
0:35:56 Second.
0:35:57 Motion on floor by Rebecca Mills-Suega, seconded by Sean Berger as stated.
0:36:01 Council have any further on that motion?
0:36:05 Be added.
0:36:06 Roll call please.
0:36:07 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:36:08 Yes.
0:36:09 Jim Mon.
0:36:10 Yes.
0:36:11 Sean Berger.
0:36:12 Yes.
0:36:13 Don Hall.
0:36:14 Yes.
0:36:15 Rebecca Mills-Suega.
0:36:16 Yes.
0:36:17 Motion passes by zero.
0:36:18 Consideration of request to reject all bids for the JCO lift station improvement project, and we have Jason Brown
0:36:25 Thank you, mr. Mayor council members
0:36:28 So in in conjunction with with the cliff bar project
0:36:32 We we redesigned and expanded the current JCO lift station and went out to bid
0:36:39 Just recently and we did receive one bid, but it happened to be double what?
0:36:44 what was anticipated and it actually would it takes up all of our community
0:36:49 block grant money and through talking with with the engineer and looking at
0:36:54 some opportunities we felt like it would be best to reject this bid and then seek
0:37:00 the opportunity to go out and negotiate with some other contractors and see if
0:37:04 we can bring that price down. I agree that's a good idea. Any questions from
0:37:13 Council direction from Council Suzanne Hawkins I move that we reject all
0:37:19 bits for the jay kolive station and negotiate on the open market is that
0:37:25 what you want to do yes we have a motion on the floor by Suzanne Hawkins
0:37:31 submitted by Rebecca Melsoika anything further on the motion council Jason
0:37:39 you got away with an easy easy ones tonight
0:37:44 Jim Mann?
0:37:45 Yes.
0:37:46 Sean Berger?
0:37:47 Yes.
0:37:48 Don Hall?
0:37:49 Yes.
0:37:50 Rebecca Masueka?
0:37:51 Yes.
0:37:52 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:37:53 Yes.
0:37:54 Motion passes 5-0.
0:37:55 Thank you for your presentation.
0:37:56 Thank you very much.
0:37:57 Next item on the agenda is consideration of a request to award a contract between the
0:38:02 City of Twin Falls and Hummel Art Contact for design and construction, management, services,
0:38:09 for the development of the public safety complex and the new city hall and we have our city manager Travis Roth,
0:38:16 why they're welcome Travis.
0:38:17 Thank you sir.
0:38:18 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, good evening.
0:38:20 Tonight is maybe the second hurdle of a 300 hurdle race.
0:38:26 The first hurdle that we had was to really kind of go forward and engage the members of
0:38:31 our community to talk about should we invest city resources in moving forward in a series
0:38:36 of new facilities.
0:38:38 And they came back with a response that said, yes, we believe that it is time and it is also
0:38:44 prudent for us to utilize cash reserves to assist with that project.
0:38:49 The second hurdle was to go through a process as required by Idaho Code to select a architect
0:38:56 that will really assist us through this process.
0:38:59 We went through an RFQ process as outlined in the Idaho Code and from that process we
0:39:05 received six individual packets from there. We had a selection committee that
0:39:10 elected to interview three and through that process we were able to prioritize
0:39:15 the list of individuals with humble architects being on top of that list. We
0:39:21 brought that list back to the City Council and we said we'd like to begin
0:39:24 primary negotiations with humble and see if we could find a scope and a
0:39:29 contract that meets our approval and also something that we believe that could
0:39:35 be supported by the City Council.
0:39:38 So we are back this evening to share with you the agreement that has been struck from
0:39:44 a tentative place, but does require your approval for us to be able to move forward.
0:39:50 Tonight joining us with Hummel is both Clint Seavers and Scott Strubar.
0:39:53 They're going to talk about a piece of this project and really talk about that process.
0:39:58 What I want to do is highlight a couple of things that we talked about and discussed in our negotiations
0:40:04 is what I believe to be maybe a really good way for us to structure this project to be able
0:40:10 to move forward.
0:40:11 That project, that process is called the construction manager general contractor phase and that
0:40:16 is included into this agreement.
0:40:19 It's a concept that allows us to go through a request for qualifications process to hire
0:40:26 the construction manager to be on board at the beginning of the design phase so that they
0:40:31 They will be able to help us and walk through the project, which then, at the end, we get
0:40:37 that construction, not only the design expertise, but the physical construction expertise working
0:40:42 collaboratively as one big team.
0:40:45 Clint's going to talk about many of the advantages, but probably one of the biggest things that
0:40:49 I see is through this process, we still follow all the state procurement processes.
0:40:53 So all of those HVAC requirements and the electrical requirements and all of the others
0:40:59 that need to be bid, will be bid, but it does set a maximum guaranteed price for the city
0:41:06 and the risk is really with the general construction and general contractor for the project.
0:41:16 We think that that is an important piece because what we're doing is fairly unique.
0:41:22 We're going to take structures and we're going to repurpose them and add new life and when
0:41:29 If we're going through that process, it's going to be maybe at times a little bit more
0:41:32 complex than a straight build from the ground up.
0:41:36 Again, Clint is going to spend some time talking and sharing with you about that process.
0:41:42 There's two things.
0:41:43 Number one, I guess, like to leave you with on that.
0:41:47 At any point in time, should we elect to stop that process?
0:41:50 And we want to go back to the more tried and trued bid process, we're able to do that.
0:41:56 The second is we've had conversations with our legal counsel and it is an approved process
0:42:01 and it's one that is being used, it's being used locally by the Twin Falls School District
0:42:06 as they're going forward and constructing their projects.
0:42:09 You'll notice inside the packet that we're prepared for you is a preliminary, and I want
0:42:16 to stress preliminary, but budget estimate on the project.
0:42:20 And at this point we still believe that the project with the appropriate contingencies is
0:42:24 going to be approximately $7 million. If you look at the fees at $6,811,948.67. And what
0:42:34 we've done to help determine the architectural costs is we took it by percentage and taking
0:42:39 a percentage of work is very, very common. You'll notice the percentage of work here is
0:42:43 at 8% for the public safety complexes and 9% for the banner facilities for a total cost
0:42:51 $493,000 in $1 for the architectural services, and that is the architectural services that
0:42:58 goes from the very, very beginning through our assistance with the construction management
0:43:05 bidding and gives us a project at the end that is ready for us to go into.
0:43:13 With that, I'm happy to answer any questions that you may have about the agreement right
0:43:17 now.
0:43:18 the entire agreement has been reviewed by legal counsel.
0:43:22 It is a standard AIA contract that is before you this evening, and that AIA contract was
0:43:27 spelled out as the process that we would use when we went through our bidding RFQ process.
0:43:34 Do we have any questions for Travis?
0:43:38 Rebecca Milsocka.
0:43:40 Thank you, Mayor.
0:43:41 Thank you, Travis.
0:43:45 Maybe just to clarify, I think I understand the difference between this construction manager
0:43:49 your difference versus the traditional way.
0:43:52 But you said that we still follow all of the state bidding
0:43:56 requirements.
0:43:56 So what is the main difference?
0:43:59 Is it that the contracts don't come to the council
0:44:02 for approval.
0:44:03 They go through this construction manager.
0:44:07 What's the main difference?
0:44:08 So I think those are great questions.
0:44:10 And what I'm going to do, Clint has prepared a presentation
0:44:12 to really walk through what is this process.
0:44:15 Because it's really a process that's
0:44:18 one that we as an organization have never gone through, but Hummel has, and many local
0:44:23 entities around us have, so we thought that we'd have Hummel take a few minutes this evening
0:44:27 and talk about that process.
0:44:29 So I'll have to remember the question or answer it now as part of the process.
0:44:34 Great.
0:44:36 And it may be answered by his presentation, because I think it's just a general, I want
0:44:40 to make sure I really understand the differences and the advantages for one method as opposed
0:44:46 to the other.
0:44:47 Absolutely.
0:44:48 I think, why don't we go with Clint's, and then we might have other questions.
0:44:52 I'm sure we'll have other questions for you, Travis.
0:44:54 So welcome, Clint.
0:44:56 Thanks, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council.
0:45:00 First of all, we're excited about this process and about these projects.
0:45:05 Scott and I are both are from the Twin Falls area,
0:45:08 so it's really exciting for us to come back and give back,
0:45:10 be a part of this exciting time in the community.
0:45:15 We realize that the scope of services that are in front of you, the contracts, you've probably had an opportunity to read through those.
0:45:23 It's something that we deal with every day, and so we wanted to just give you an opportunity to listen to us, communicate those basic services.
0:45:32 We'll show you some slides. I won't be too exhausted with it, but hopefully it gives you a little bit more education on the contract itself.
0:45:40 the process that is in the contract, and then we'll look at that CMGC process, that delivery method as well.
0:45:48 So, first of all, I wanted to tie everything along the schedule.
0:45:53 So the basic process that's in the contract revolves around the phases of design and construction,
0:46:00 and you'll see those phases here.
0:46:02 starts with visioning and a program phase up front and that's really where we understand
0:46:09 your needs and wants spatially adjacencies in the building and we meet with program groups,
0:46:17 small program groups to understand that and we'll actually write a program for you.
0:46:22 You'll see the symbols in the legend and the solid triangles of staff,
0:46:28 That's just indicative of your city staff meeting with us to move the project forward.
0:46:35 You'll also see the empty triangle.
0:46:38 That is an effort to really milestone some community involvement.
0:46:43 None of these are necessarily, I guess, hard when it comes to the schedule.
0:46:49 We can add or take away, you know, this thing is really fluid.
0:46:53 The schedule as we move along.
0:46:55 The idea is to develop some really good framework up front and give us a path.
0:47:00 And so, as I move through, I'll come back to the schedule,
0:47:03 but the vision part of the project is really to help us understand your vision.
0:47:09 When I say your, I mean the communities as well as the council staff,
0:47:13 because we're the Twin Falls City staff.
0:47:16 You'll have different vantage points and different views,
0:47:19 so it's really to understand the big picture vision.
0:47:22 And we'll visit some facilities from a public safety standpoint from the City Hall standpoint
0:47:29 And we'll start to work with the Main Street redevelopment team to start to understand that bigger picture
0:47:37 Just a slide here to show you community involvement
0:47:40 What we would intend to do is after we see some of those facilities
0:47:44 We come back and maybe pin up in the banner facility itself
0:47:48 What we've seen what we like what we don't like and we'd allow the public to come in and
0:47:52 and make comments on that for the design.
0:47:57 So it really sets up a big picture priority
0:48:00 and goal for the project.
0:48:03 In the meantime, and this is a work in progress,
0:48:05 but I worked with Mitch and Travis and Brian to date
0:48:10 to start to establish a project team.
0:48:13 It's really key to be organized
0:48:15 and communicate effectively with this.
0:48:17 So as we move along, this will be the start of that team.
0:48:22 Travis and I will frequently talk and then Brian and Mitch have both offered to lead the program teams for the City Hall side and the public safety side.
0:48:32 So you would see a select committee underneath each of those sides to work with us during the program and then into the design as well.
0:48:41 And so I just wanted to add this slide for programming.
0:48:46 This will be one of the upfront phases.
0:48:48 process happens in the next few months and it'll happen over a series of meetings and what we'll deliver to you is not only a
0:48:56 description a document and writing describing each room in the facility sizes
0:49:02 anything from mechanical electrical systems lighting
0:49:06 Finishes all that kind of stuff and then we'll also graphically show you floor plans
0:49:12 They don't necessarily need to be
0:49:14 perfect as far as floor plans go. What they'll describe is the adjacencies of
0:49:19 spaces next to each other and relationship within the building. Obviously
0:49:24 when we get to like the banner building for example we've got an existing
0:49:28 structure that we'll work with so we'll use these adjacency plans and mold them
0:49:33 into that building and that design. And so that's really the upfront vision and
0:49:40 programming phase in the contract. You'll see the asterisk here, which represents cost
0:49:46 estimates. One thing that we really like to practice is a check-and-balance type system
0:49:51 where after each phase we do a cost check. Obviously early on the information is more vague.
0:49:59 As we get farther down the road it's more detailed. So you would see the same thing with
0:50:03 the cost estimates. And then the city, both staff and yourselves can make educated decisions
0:50:09 as we move along.
0:50:12 One thing that I don't have on here are council updates,
0:50:16 and that was something that we felt
0:50:18 we would communicate with you and come to terms
0:50:21 with how often is best, certainly at the end of each phase
0:50:25 seems appropriate and possibly more.
0:50:30 So the next few phases are schematic design,
0:50:32 which is the blue one here in the middle,
0:50:34 design development, and then into construction documents.
0:50:38 we would carry the same meeting type schedule
0:50:41 through the schematic design phase,
0:50:44 a few staff meetings, for sure,
0:50:46 and then also some community involvement.
0:50:48 So we could bring back the designs
0:50:50 that we've started to work on and get the public's input.
0:50:55 What that starts to look at,
0:50:57 and you'll be able to relate to this,
0:50:58 is the elementary schools,
0:51:01 what we did with the school district,
0:51:02 we did a similar process there,
0:51:03 where we had some conceptual renderings, different ideas,
0:51:08 And then we allowed the public to weigh in on different ideas
0:51:11 and vote, and that way we could move forward
0:51:13 with being educated from the public's perspective.
0:51:18 And so you'll see something like this.
0:51:20 You could see where we print off big sheets
0:51:25 or come down with our models.
0:51:28 We do a lot of digital modeling now,
0:51:29 so we could bring down digital models and work
0:51:32 while we're here for a day or two,
0:51:34 allow the community to come in, weigh in,
0:51:36 discuss the projects with us,
0:51:38 and that way we can learn from them and educate the public on projects as well.
0:51:43 You know, this is a phase where you start to get a little more definition, you start
0:51:48 to develop that floor plan, you start to get some elevations and some concepts of material
0:51:54 and that kind of stuff.
0:51:55 So a little more definition with how the design comes together.
0:51:59 And then also another update of that cost estimate.
0:52:03 And so we'll really be able to look at what's costing more than we think, what's costing
0:52:07 less and make sure we stay on your budget most importantly. Design development you'll
0:52:16 see as we get farther along in the process the triangles tend to fade away a
0:52:21 little bit that simply means that that we're we've learned the information from
0:52:27 you from city staff and from the community and we've taken that into more
0:52:32 concrete design and what we'll do is we'll start to create more definitive
0:52:38 models, more definitive renderings, more real-time realistic type images, and then further that
0:52:46 cost estimate and be able to move into a construction document phase.
0:52:52 And so this is where we start to break the project up a little bit.
0:52:57 We see being able to run programming designed for both the public safety campus and the
0:53:02 City Hall parallel. Once we get to a construction document standpoint, we feel we can break the
0:53:11 public safety away and possibly start to create bidding packages earlier. The City Hall, the
0:53:19 banner building itself, is just simply bigger in size. It's a more complex project, so it'll
0:53:24 take longer to get the construction documents ready. And so we'd like to take advantage of
0:53:29 schedule so we can complete some construction documents earlier on the
0:53:34 public safety side and start to bid that work if that's the way the city would
0:53:40 like to proceed. You'll see an agency review section here in the middle of that
0:53:47 phase and that's an owner review so that would be your city staff's review that
0:53:53 would be another update to yourselves that is also where we would go through
0:53:57 final plan review with the CD. It's a code check, energy checks, those types of things,
0:54:04 and getting final approval for permits and construction. You'll start to see fewer pretty
0:54:11 pictures at that point, and more very complex floor plans with detailed information on them.
0:54:17 So that's an idea of what that would look like. And then as we get into construction,
0:54:25 know it's a phased project. We don't really know what the phases are going to be at this
0:54:30 point. We have a budget that we've set. I was a part of that last fall. It's still consistent.
0:54:39 So now I think as we work through that program process and that design process, we start
0:54:43 to develop priorities. We start to develop plans for how we execute the work. Brian and
0:54:50 and I have also started to brainstorm kind of how the police department, how that work
0:54:58 gets executed and how those guys can still do their job and do a quality job, but also
0:55:03 be able to move around so we can complete that work.
0:55:06 So we're starting to get into some of that pre-planning that will help us dictate what
0:55:11 those phases are.
0:55:13 The CMGC delivery method is something that we're familiar with.
0:55:19 It's about a year or so old.
0:55:25 It's a little bit different to answer your partially answer your question.
0:55:32 It's a delivery method that's kind of a combination of previous delivery methods.
0:55:39 In the past there's been just a general bid delivery method where a design bid build,
0:55:44 An architect would design a building, a public entity would bid that and select based on
0:55:49 that low bid, contract price and move forward.
0:55:54 There's also the construction management delivery method where a public entity could
0:55:59 select based on quality a construction manager.
0:56:03 That manager would interact with the owner and the architect throughout the process, but
0:56:09 would not have any risk in that project.
0:56:14 They would have a contract with the owner.
0:56:17 All the contracts for different materials, electrical, mechanical, all those subcontracts
0:56:22 would retain with the owner.
0:56:24 So contractually the owner still bears that risk with those subcontractors.
0:56:30 There is some value to that CM delivery method.
0:56:35 They would not be able to perform, that's another difference.
0:56:39 The CM would be able to make recommendations on the work, but actually could not perform
0:56:43 work in a CMGC delivery method. The CEM would act as a CEM and work with us to
0:56:51 estimate the design and to give advice as we work through the early stages. They
0:56:56 would also be responsible to bid the work and they would hold those contracts
0:57:01 with the subcontractors. So you as an owner as the city would hold two contracts, you
0:57:06 would hold one with the architect, you'd hold one with the general contractor. If
0:57:11 you bid and pursue that guaranteed maximum price with them. So in our experience it's a
0:57:20 significant advantage just because you're in a way offloading some of that burden on to
0:57:27 the contractor that knows the business and can manage that risk. You as an owner may or
0:57:32 may not be able to manage that risk as well as a contractor would. So that I hope answers
0:57:39 your question a little bit. Some of the other points I just wanted to make are that it, some
0:57:50 of the benefits, you get the CM services still, the upfront estimating, you get that guaranteed
0:57:57 maximum price and that's one way to know that you're not going to go over budget. There's
0:58:03 contingencies built into that. There's fees built into that. So at the end of the day after
0:58:08 you bid that work, you lock in a GMP, which we call GMP,
0:58:13 guaranteed maximum price, with that contractor.
0:58:16 And you're good to go for the rest of the project.
0:58:20 Clann I was going to recommend that, you know,
0:58:23 the acronyms and the, maybe you spell those out,
0:58:26 because there's folks at home that, okay.
0:58:29 Sure, sure.
0:58:29 L-O-M-N-O-P's don't mean anything to that.
0:58:31 So, and I think Rebecca has a question.
0:58:34 Oh, just a follow-up.
0:58:36 Couldn't you also do the guaranteed maximum price if you were going with a traditional bidding
0:58:42 and you would say doing an RFQ or you wanted to do something based on qualifications?
0:58:49 Couldn't you negotiate a maximum price or is that something that only comes with the CMGC?
0:58:55 Yeah, since my knowledge is the only delivery method that would allow you to walk a guaranteed
0:59:00 maximum price would be this method.
0:59:04 And why is that?
0:59:05 I was going to let Travis weigh in if that's alright with you, go ahead.
0:59:09 So the Idaho Code requires us, it has a series of procurement layers and triggers that as
0:59:15 it crests over certain dollar amounts, there's a formal bid process that we would have to
0:59:22 go forward with.
0:59:23 The formal bid process in accordance with Idaho Code is you take the lowest responsive
0:59:27 bid.
0:59:28 And those are the bids that, for example, the lift station that was brought to you this evening
0:59:34 was an example of that process where the bids were outside of the range that we thought that
0:59:40 we could get on the open market and so we came forward this evening and asked for you to reject
0:59:45 those. This process really allows us, they go through that same competitive process but
0:59:54 it's a negotiated process with, we get to see the bids with the general and then we also
1:00:02 have the opportunity to negotiate that price for the project, not only knowing the bids,
1:00:08 but also understanding what the profit and the overhead that's going to be assessed to
1:00:13 us is as opposed to opening it up and then looking at lump sum costs.
1:00:21 Yeah, I think it's important to note too that by proceeding with this as a fourth and hour
1:00:28 contract, that doesn't, you still have the option to change.
1:00:32 So the nice thing about the CMGC delivery method is you're using both a CM and a general
1:00:38 contractor delivery method, kind of the pros of both.
1:00:42 You could select, you could approve this method and you could select a CM all the way through
1:00:48 if you decide that meets your needs the best.
1:00:51 You don't have to proceed through that general contract method if you don't want to.
1:00:56 So it kind of leaves you the most option as you move forward.
1:01:02 you would be using a qualifications based process all the time as opposed to
1:01:08 having to use lowest bid in some cases I guess I'm still confused at what the
1:01:14 difference is yeah I can I can add a little you're saying we'll get we'll be
1:01:19 able to choose the the most qualified contractor as opposed to following the
1:01:26 state code and and sometimes you have to choose the lowest response is bitter so
1:01:31 So it is an adopted state code, this CMGC delivery method.
1:01:38 What you're doing with this is you're selecting that CMGC based on quality, just like you would
1:01:45 in Architect.
1:01:47 That CMGC is still obligated to bid the work for you and open the bids in the presence
1:01:55 of the owner, competitively bid that work.
1:02:00 And so, the city or the owner of that project could dictate how many bids they would like
1:02:07 for each package.
1:02:08 For example, with the school district, we negotiated with CMGC and said, we'd like to
1:02:14 make sure every bid package is competitive.
1:02:16 We want minimum of three bids per bid package, and then you're going to take the lowest bidder
1:02:23 on each package.
1:02:24 So we had a ballpark of 26 bid packages where we had some that were advertised, I think,
1:02:33 with up to six or eight local contractors.
1:02:35 We ended up with only two or three bidding.
1:02:37 We also had some that we had four or five, six bids on.
1:02:41 So the idea is really to encourage that CMGC to advertise for those bidders locally and
1:02:52 farther out.
1:02:53 We tend to get better pricing locally and I think that would be the goal here also to
1:02:58 encourage those local contractors to do the work.
1:03:02 You're still getting that low-bid subcontractors based on that process.
1:03:09 You say this is a relatively new process, it was just, I'm assuming it went through
1:03:17 the legislature to say that we can do this.
1:03:19 It must have been used in some other states or something and we grabbed a hold of it and
1:03:23 I'd hope.
1:03:24 It's a little bit different and I'm not from a legal standpoint up to date on all of the
1:03:31 details.
1:03:32 I know it has been used in Oregon, it has been used in Washington and other surrounding
1:03:36 states and it really has been an evolution of that construction manager process into a
1:03:44 process where they can perform some of the work themselves.
1:03:48 When I say that, they have to prove that they customarily do that work, so if a CM, if you
1:03:56 selected a CMGC based on quality, they wanted to bid, say the concrete work themselves, they
1:04:03 would have to prove that they consistently do that work in the community and relevant projects
1:04:10 of that size in order to bid it themselves.
1:04:13 Now they would still have to competitively bid that against other subcontractors.
1:04:17 who do they prove that to the owner?
1:04:20 Yes, okay.
1:04:21 The owner and the architect.
1:04:22 Okay.
1:04:23 We serve as your initial decision maker for the contract,
1:04:26 and so we would assist you through that.
1:04:28 Excellent.
1:04:29 Suzanne Hopkins has a question.
1:04:30 Not a question, just to go on the record.
1:04:32 Last year when this process was going through the state
1:04:34 legislature, the AIC board officially took a stance
1:04:38 in support of it and helped work through some of the issues
1:04:43 as they were coming up.
1:04:44 And so from our position on a board for the state,
1:04:46 we felt this was a very good process to bring on.
1:04:49 Thank you, Suzanne.
1:04:52 So I just wanted to add a little bit of information to you.
1:04:55 There's an anticipated project process,
1:04:58 and this is information I'm pulling from a presentation that
1:05:01 was done by the AGC Association of General Contractors,
1:05:05 and has had state input as well.
1:05:09 And so I just wanted you to see some of this information
1:05:13 on how the process was intended to be.
1:05:17 It's a public entity issuing a request for qualifications
1:05:21 as we've discussed similar to the architect's selection
1:05:23 process.
1:05:25 The RFQ requests qualifications for the general contractor
1:05:29 as well as a CEM.
1:05:30 So you can select that contractor based on qualifications
1:05:34 and then make your decision on which method
1:05:36 you'd like to pursue.
1:05:42 The owner can enter into a negotiate
1:05:44 into a fixed price or a guaranteed max.
1:05:48 Something we've talked about a little bit.
1:05:50 And then here are some bullets for benefits.
1:05:53 It really does allow you guys to reap the benefits from working, having your contractor
1:05:59 work with the architect up front and be able to have a risk in what he's doing.
1:06:04 So just a little summary of what that says.
1:06:09 But I'm happy to stand for any further questions on the CMGC method as well as our contract.
1:06:18 Is Scott going to make?
1:06:19 Yeah, I think it's ready.
1:06:20 Okay.
1:06:21 I didn't want to leave you out.
1:06:22 Okay.
1:06:23 Very good. I don't see any further lights. There might be so we'll turn back over to Travis
1:06:30 so that's really the
1:06:32 The process that's outlined the contract is before you for your consideration this evening and
1:06:40 After this step then we will continue to
1:06:43 You know build those teams and then build those processes that were outlined in the schedule by click I
1:06:48 I just wanted to go on record and say this process makes sense to me.
1:06:56 The only hesitation I have this evening about going forward is that we have two council
1:07:00 members that are not here.
1:07:02 I don't know if that's enough for us to not go forward with it, but that's the only hesitancy
1:07:06 that I have for it.
1:07:08 Rebecca Milsoica.
1:07:09 Thank you, Mayor.
1:07:12 Just a clarification question because it talks about the total square footage of the building
1:07:19 that was purchased as being 42,500 to 50,000 square feet, and in the cost estimate in the
1:07:29 budget, it talks about the general tenant improvements, which I assume to mean kind of the indoor
1:07:37 usable space, the meeting and office space, at the end of this project will be about 29,500.
1:07:44 just wondered that additional space, when is it anticipated to be finished and maybe
1:07:55 what's an approximate cost for full build out? As we talk about this space lasting for
1:08:03 50 years, I was just wondering what kind of that looks like as far as we're only finishing
1:08:10 a little bit less than 30,000 when we might need to finish some more and how much that
1:08:19 might cost.
1:08:20 That's a really good question.
1:08:21 So in terms of cost, I think it's going to be really largely driven by the time frame.
1:08:25 And I'm going to say that the time frame is several years out.
1:08:30 Right now, the building is going to be largely tended and proved, if you will, as we need
1:08:40 the additional space. At this point in time, we believe that it's probably prudent based
1:08:46 upon our current knowledge of the cost to do only the rough-in plumbing costs associated
1:08:51 with the basement and leave the entire basement floor at this point in time unfinished. And
1:08:58 we're looking at that approach for several reasons. Number one, we don't believe that
1:09:02 we are going to need that space for several years. And when I say several years, I'm going
1:09:06 look at Mitch, we estimated that we would add about two employees a year on the average
1:09:14 to the staff that would go into that building and that's following about 14 years of historical
1:09:21 trends in terms of what that looks like.
1:09:25 In the reports that we shared, trying to be very conservative in our approach, we said
1:09:29 that the average employee would use about 200 square feet of office space.
1:09:35 In all reality, the actual office space is anywhere between 80 and 120.
1:09:41 To put 120 in perspective, that's roughly about the size of my office now.
1:09:46 And so, they are, when you think it's 10 by 12, that's a pretty good office space, especially
1:09:52 when we start thinking about creating more open places.
1:09:55 The open places allow us to also maybe maximize space in a bit of a different manner.
1:10:01 So that's going to be part of that.
1:10:03 If I had to crystal ball, I'm going to ask Clint to kind of help me out.
1:10:08 We believe that we would use the first floor.
1:10:11 We would expand the mezzanine, which gives us that additional square footage for office
1:10:16 space and we would make and create improvements on the third floor.
1:10:20 I think that's how Clint is coming up with his roughly 29,000 square feet.
1:10:25 The basement would be unoccupied space for the time,
1:10:31 and we would not make that improvement.
1:10:35 Based upon that, we estimated that the building
1:10:37 would last about 53 years.
1:10:41 And in lasting 53 years, we believe that there,
1:10:44 I think we said that there's at least 18 years
1:10:46 based upon historical growth trends, is that about right?
1:10:53 Yeah, so we'd be adding 36 more people
1:10:55 to our organization who would go into that facility
1:10:59 before we would have to make any attendant improvements.
1:11:03 And again, based upon this historical calculations,
1:11:06 it's about just shy of that 20-year benchmark.
1:11:10 The other thing that we also spent time talking with the
1:11:12 committee about is workflows change, work processes change.
1:11:17 And if we think about how we work as an organization 20
1:11:20 years ago, it is probably remarkably different than how
1:11:23 we work today.
1:11:26 And as we're continuing to use more technology, we're creating
1:11:29 a series of mobile offices. It may be the case that that building lasts longer. It may not
1:11:36 be the case that you have to come into City Hall to do different types of things that we
1:11:41 have a series of moving and rolling offices if you think about just police service and the
1:11:46 use of MDCs over the course of the last decade into our organization and compare that to how
1:11:51 while policing was done, say 15, 20 years ago, it's really aided in the expansion of
1:12:00 being more efficient, but also the space that we can grow.
1:12:02 I'll just add to that.
1:12:03 I saw Sean Stanley today sitting at a corner with his little iPad thingy doing something
1:12:10 because there were some kind of water issues.
1:12:12 So he was able to go out in the field and take care of something that I think probably
1:12:16 five, ten years ago, traditionally, he'd have to come back to an office for.
1:12:21 So you're exactly right.
1:12:22 So even with that, we're going to be bringing a city works presentation back to the city council
1:12:27 to really share and I'll give you a sneak preview.
1:12:30 Cody who oversees a lot of the water functions in the past would have to go in and he would
1:12:36 get a series of handwritten notes or different work orders in terms of what it would be and
1:12:40 he would have to make frequent trips back into the office to be able to get those ons
1:12:44 and offs and different call ins.
1:12:47 Now everything's done through city works.
1:12:50 gets that information electronically and they continue to move forward so they
1:12:54 can prioritize their work when they're in a particular area of the community. They
1:12:58 can function and get all of the work orders out of the way while they're there.
1:13:02 Now some may come in but that allows us to be able to roll and be much more
1:13:06 efficient and effective with our time and that's just how technology I think is
1:13:09 probably going to add even more life into this facility. So to the second part
1:13:15 of my question you're saying the third floor would be completely finished or is
1:13:19 Is there some unfinished space on the third floor?
1:13:22 Is that what you're saying?
1:13:24 Completely finished.
1:13:25 Completely finished.
1:13:26 Everything but the basement at this point in time.
1:13:28 Okay, and then so.
1:13:31 What we do is we make all the rough and improvement.
1:13:33 So we know that there's some elevators.
1:13:36 I think in these schematics,
1:13:38 we talked about possibly two elevators in the facility.
1:13:41 Obviously the elevators would be able to go
1:13:43 clear to the basement.
1:13:44 They would be completed to serve in that area.
1:13:46 There would be restrooms that you would have the rough
1:13:48 plumbing put into place
1:13:49 because it would make more sense from getting that all done.
1:13:52 But in terms of roughing out the improvement
1:13:55 that's about all the further we would go.
1:13:58 Clint?
1:13:58 Yeah, I think I would just add to that,
1:14:01 talking about how the distribution is in the building.
1:14:05 The intent was for the first through the third floors
1:14:07 to be fully finished.
1:14:10 That first floor was really valuable square footage,
1:14:12 especially for departments that are involved
1:14:16 with the public on a daily basis.
1:14:18 And so we would see that filling up right away.
1:14:20 The second third floors would have room to grow in them.
1:14:24 So you don't have to go right to the basement, I guess,
1:14:28 as you start to grow.
1:14:29 You're going to have room in that second third floor.
1:14:32 I'd also add that that basement can easily be heated and cooled.
1:14:38 And really, it's just gelled out space.
1:14:40 So you could do it.
1:14:41 You could populate that space with systems furniture.
1:14:44 or there's a lot of ways that you could cost effectively finish that.
1:14:48 Sure, and I'm sure the space needs program will give us a better sense of where you're going there.
1:14:56 So I understand technology.
1:14:58 What I'm trying to get a sense of is the total cost of the city hall at full build out.
1:15:04 I mean, right now we're looking at four and a half million for the space that we're going to be completing,
1:15:10 just curious in the future that the cost if you were to build out that entire space?
1:15:15 Yeah, so you could obviously use, I think the worst thing that we could do is to take
1:15:22 that same square footage per square foot and say this is what it's going to be if we
1:15:28 don't believe that we're going to start any improvements for a period of 20 years with
1:15:34 price escalations that are more likely to occur in that period of time.
1:15:39 I think that it would be, I couldn't even project the value of money.
1:15:46 More, I mean, the safest thing I could say is it'll cost more per square foot and
1:15:50 20 years from now than what it costs now and that's probably safe.
1:15:55 That's about safe.
1:15:56 That's about as safe as I can do.
1:16:00 So just okay, you know, fine.
1:16:03 There's just, I think one good way to answer your question to is, and
1:16:09 we're taking this approach a little bit with the public safety project.
1:16:12 We want to think about the public safety campus as a big picture and let you select what you
1:16:20 want to pay for now and what you want to pay for in the future.
1:16:23 So we can very well master plan the campus and say it's $5 million worth of work but you
1:16:28 only want to spend two now.
1:16:30 You at least know, hey we're almost halfway there or it's about the same amount to do that
1:16:36 next phase.
1:16:37 We can do the same thing with the banner building.
1:16:39 We can master plan the entire building.
1:16:42 you a budget for the entire building, but maybe you say no, let's do three quarters of it,
1:16:47 but you at least know what the rest of it is, the balance of that word.
1:16:52 Sure.
1:16:53 My only other comment, I appreciate you talking about the public input portion.
1:16:59 I think what's important, besides your community meetings, I feel like it's important to have
1:17:08 a way to engage citizens and involve them online for people who can't make it to an in-person
1:17:14 meeting.
1:17:16 And you know, as you show your options, you know, have some sort of ability for citizens
1:17:23 to give input, either, you know, multiple choice questions or also a section for comments,
1:17:29 because as you've addressed the personnel needs, the office space, there were a lot of
1:17:35 people on the committee for the City Hall that talked about community needs and what they
1:17:40 wanted to see.
1:17:41 I mean, this is their building and what use is they want to be able to have in this building.
1:17:47 And so I just hope that we will also engage people in a more, maybe modern and more accessible
1:17:54 way to them as we go.
1:17:57 I'm just going to make one more comment and I think Jim's going to make a motion.
1:18:04 I know that there was a lot of conversation about the police department in the day that
1:18:07 when they built that and they wished that they would have put a basement in the, and unfinished
1:18:13 basement in the police department because we could really utilize that space for many,
1:18:19 many items, whether that's dispatch or whatever.
1:18:23 So it's pretty cheap space to have for the future.
1:18:28 And I think this is exactly the right way that we should go.
1:18:31 building that will meet our needs for several years into the future and we don't have to
1:18:37 finish the basis because we don't even know what we'll need then.
1:18:40 Okay, so that it gives us so much flexibility and options.
1:18:44 With that, Jim Munn.
1:18:45 Thank you, Mayor.
1:18:46 I reviewed the contract and I believe it's just spot on.
1:18:54 And with that, I would move that we approve and award the contract between the city and
1:18:58 and humble architects for the design and construction management services for both the public safety building and City Hall.
1:19:05 Second.
1:19:06 Motion on the floor by Jim Munn, seconded by Sean Berriger, as stated.
1:19:11 Anything further counsel?
1:19:13 Lee Island, roll call vote please.
1:19:15 Sean Berriger?
1:19:16 Yes.
1:19:17 Don Hall?
1:19:17 Yes.
1:19:18 Rebecca Milsenka?
1:19:19 Yes.
1:19:20 Suzanne Hawkins?
1:19:21 Yes.
1:19:22 Jim Munn?
1:19:22 Yes.
1:19:23 Motion passes 5-0.
1:19:26 The next item on the agenda is public input and or items from city manager, city council.
1:19:32 So we'll start with the public first.
1:19:33 Is there anyone here from the public that would like to address the council?
1:19:39 I see lady in the audience looking around behind her, so that I'm assuming she does not want to come forward.
1:19:44 So with that, we'll go to the city manager, anything from the city manager.
1:19:48 Just just two quick items, number one.
1:19:50 And remember that tomorrow is the state of the city conversation.
1:19:54 The conversation, I believe Lynch is going to be served at noon and that the brief presentation
1:20:03 as well as opportunity for question and answer will begin roughly 1230 and I don't know if
1:20:09 the event is sold out Sean or not.
1:20:15 People are welcome to come but lunch is capped.
1:20:19 That's what I was yep so.
1:20:20 You're welcome to attend but they won't get fed.
1:20:26 So, again, we would encourage individuals to come and as like I said, they'll be considerable
1:20:31 opportunity for questions and so we hope that we'll have those and Don has agreed to answer
1:20:39 all the hard ones tomorrow.
1:20:41 Yes.
1:20:42 Second.
1:20:43 Well, but I will answer them.
1:20:45 Second, I will be out of town on Friday and so Mitch Humble will be acting at DCM and
1:20:55 should I not survive? He's not acting DCM. He is a DCM. He's acting DCM. Don't say he's
1:21:02 acting DCM. DCM is going to be a CM. Should I survive? I'll be back on Monday. Should I
1:21:09 not? There's two capable hands to move forward. That's why we did this. From the council perspective,
1:21:17 just take care of yourself and your and your lovely wife. But have fun and I hope it's a
1:21:21 great event for you. Suzanne Hawkins. Thank you. For people who have been to our council
1:21:28 chambers and out to our airport, you probably know that we display local artists' work on
1:21:34 our walls here and at our airport. And last year we had artwork displayed from one of our
1:21:40 local citizens, his name is Rick Otto, and it's with sadness I tell you that Rick passed away
1:21:45 this last week. But I was just hoping you guys would join me in a moment of silence for Rick
1:21:49 in his family because he was a big part of this community and he was very involved in
1:21:53 the art councils and lots of other jobs around town so I was just hoping we could have a moment
1:21:59 of silence. Thank you.
1:22:07 Thank you Suzanne. I wanted anything else from council Rebecca
1:22:13 Milsoyka. Perhaps Mayor you are going to talk about this but I'm just going to share about
1:22:18 the URE meeting today. Go right ahead. Did you want to know? No, I'm okay. That's perfect.
1:22:24 Mary and I attended the Urban Renewal Agencies Board Meeting today and they were having a
1:22:29 good conversation about whether to go forward with a certain style of parking, back in angle
1:22:34 parking and you know I've been approached by some merchants is very against it but the
1:22:41 consensus on this committee that they've constructed, I think they call it a pack?
1:22:49 Yeah.
1:22:50 Public action committee or something?
1:22:52 Yeah, and we both weren't sure who's on that committee, or maybe how they were chosen, but the committee is very for it.
1:23:00 And so I thought it might be good from a council perspective to engage the public now before the URE makes this choice.
1:23:10 Just so that we make sure they're talking about it's important to engage the public and
1:23:16 get their sense of resistance or their sense of acceptance from the back in angle parking
1:23:22 because once they choose it, they will build it to a certain design and you really can't
1:23:30 go back.
1:23:32 So in order to engage the public and to prevent any sort of backlash or misunderstanding and
1:23:39 kind of start educating, I thought it might be good for us to have a conversation and
1:23:44 and just also reach out to our media partners to see if the newspaper or the TV stations
1:23:50 want to kind of spread the word and see how it falls on public years so that we don't get
1:23:59 too far down the wrong road there.
1:24:01 But I think they were having a good conversation about the pros and cons and I personally don't
1:24:06 have any concerns about back-and-angle parking but I think it would be a really good idea
1:24:12 and engage the public just a little bit.
1:24:14 I would just add to that that I think it's incumbent upon us
1:24:21 to become more educated about that and how it looks
1:24:25 on Main Street and the space needs and all those other things
1:24:29 so that when we do engage the community and they do talk
1:24:32 to us we can give them what it really looks like
1:24:35 and the safety aspects of it and how it's going to work
1:24:38 with the pedestrian piece, the bicyclists pull in straight angle parking is really not
1:24:46 very conducive to bicyclists and what we're trying to accomplish with our main street.
1:24:51 So I think it's incumbent upon us again to become really educated so that we can share
1:24:55 that with the citizens because that's what happened with this PAC group.
1:24:59 I think probably majority of them were really uneasy about this whole back in parking until
1:25:05 they were able to become educated and understand it a little bit more.
1:25:08 A gentleman that spoke after this item today actually stood up and he made a lot of sense.
1:25:15 He says, ladies and gentlemen, we already have back-end parking.
1:25:19 It's called parallel parking.
1:25:20 We all do that.
1:25:21 Well, some of us do it better than others, but so there's already back-end parking.
1:25:25 So it's really not a new concept other than it just being at an angle.
1:25:29 So I think it's incumbent upon us to do that.
1:25:32 With that, Suzanne Hopkins.
1:25:34 I might have just been at the wrong place at the wrong time but I was in Seattle last week
1:25:38 and stood and watched back in parking for a while and I can tell you it was horrible.
1:25:43 The people were pulling in and out four and five times trying to get in and traffic was
1:25:46 lining up and I was amazed at how smooth it was working in downtown Seattle.
1:25:53 Just so you know.
1:25:54 Okay.
1:25:55 Sean Berger.
1:25:56 So there was some discussion when Mandy was here last time about doing a demonstration project.
1:26:02 So I'm all four engage in the public, but I think if we say, hey, would you like it if
1:26:06 we changed everything on Main Street, the answer is going to be no.
1:26:11 Whether it's the best thing since sliced bread or not, I think if we ask the question, do you
1:26:14 want us to change things?
1:26:15 People are going to say no.
1:26:16 If we can do an event that actually lets people try it, or educates or does those things, because
1:26:23 again, I just-
1:26:24 Right, obviously we wouldn't choose a horrible approach to engage the public, but yeah, I-
1:26:28 Right, but I think if the general question is we're thinking about changing all these things,
1:26:32 What do you think?
1:26:33 Yeah.
1:26:34 No, I'm not suggesting that.
1:26:35 Right.
1:26:36 So I would support doing something, and if we need to do it sooner than later, so that
1:26:41 this decision can be made, I think that needs to get put together.
1:26:44 Exactly.
1:26:45 To actually have an event, bring people down, let them see it.
1:26:49 Great suggestion.
1:26:50 I think that's a great way to do that.
1:26:51 So we'll share that with Melinda and City leadership and see what we can come up with.
1:26:57 And just to answer yours, I've seen just the opposite in Salt Lake back in parking moved
1:27:02 really smoothly.
1:27:03 So I guess it's how it's designed and yeah, maybe it's the hills or the water there.
1:27:09 I don't know.
1:27:12 Last anything else from Council.
1:27:13 I was just going to briefly mention this and I feel bad.
1:27:16 I should have mentioned it last week, but several of us were able to go to the Harrison
1:27:21 leadership event that they had.
1:27:24 Harrison Elementary and it was incredible.
1:27:27 that school, I mean we need to take our hat off to our public schools. Sometimes
1:27:32 they get the bad route, but they are really being innovative. They're utilizing
1:27:36 this Stephen Covey 7 habits and permeating that through the school and
1:27:42 the kids are now going home and saying, Mom, dad is that a win-win or some of the
1:27:47 other philosophies and it's dramatically reduced their discipline
1:27:52 issues and homework is starting to get done at a higher rate and again I just
1:28:00 wanted to just say something about that because I failed to do it last week but
1:28:04 Harrison Elementary, good job, Twin Falls School District, good job. So with that
1:28:09 anything else council? We are adjourned.
Download
- Transcript (text) 88 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 116 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 156 KB
- Audio (M4A) 20.9 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, April 13, 2015. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:28:28.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
66ed37fcccb569f6617f07ba6b8d3c2ea9116a81ea01fa660a5926d63edac909 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 0f001e56fa63649826153f20a11f44491505a33a2e3b67e8e2afd71e934b250b - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
c4e2f6fb159de0defd26c54c4b8afdaad01276cd86aee2c9f31e0afad7364570
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file