OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, June 22, 2015

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Minutes on file

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:03:51 I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order.

0:03:53 It is June 22nd, 2015.

0:03:56 For those of you wishing to join us,

0:03:57 please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:04:00 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:04:16 I'd like to welcome everyone to our City Council meeting.

0:04:20 We do have a quorum of the City Council.

0:04:22 We have five members here, a couple of members.

0:04:24 We're not able to make it this evening.

0:04:26 Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments

0:04:28 to the agenda that's been posted?

0:04:30 We do not.

0:04:31 Thank you, sir.

0:04:32 We have no proclamations.

0:04:33 And so the first item on our agenda, as always,

0:04:37 is to ask anyone from the public

0:04:39 that would like to address the council

0:04:40 on something that's not on the agenda.

0:04:43 This is your time to come forward and visit with council.

0:04:50 He's not a voice scout, is he?

0:04:51 Okay, very good.

0:04:52 All right, I see no one coming forward.

0:04:55 So the next item is the consent calendar.

0:04:57 I'll turn that over to council for their direction.

0:05:02 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:05:03 I move approval of the consent calendar as printed.

0:05:07 Second.

0:05:08 Motion on the floor by Suzanne Hawkins.

0:05:10 Seconded by Sean Berriger to approve the consent calendar

0:05:13 as opposed to anything further on that motion council.

0:05:17 Leela, roll call vote please.

0:05:19 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:05:20 Yes, Jim Mun.

0:05:21 Yes.

0:05:22 Sean Berriger.

0:05:23 Yes.

0:05:23 Chris Hockens.

0:05:24 Yes.

0:05:24 Great glancing.

0:05:26 He's gone.

0:05:28 Don Hall.

0:05:29 Yes.

0:05:30 Motion passes 5-0.

0:05:31 Thank you.

0:05:32 Now moving to items for consideration.

0:05:34 The first item is consideration request to approve the Rock Canyon Summer Concert Series 2015

0:05:41 to be held at 245th Avenue South and we have Staff Sergeant Dennis Pullen from the Police

0:05:49 Department.

0:05:50 Welcome, Dennis.

0:05:51 Thank you, Mayor Hall and City Council.

0:05:54 One months ago, I was approached by Mark from Kirk Gallegos to speak about a location to

0:06:02 start holding a series of concerts during the summertime months.

0:06:07 That location is at 245th Avenue South, just off of Minidoka and Idaho.

0:06:12 If you're not familiar with that area, right now it's a gravel lot just to the east of the

0:06:21 complex building, I guess, of where Red's Trading Post is.

0:06:23 I don't know what the proper name for that building is.

0:06:26 The old Woody's.

0:06:27 Yeah, where the old Woody's was at.

0:06:31 So when they approached me, we went down and looked at that,

0:06:34 and they kind of gave me their idea of what they wanted to do.

0:06:37 We've been in communication since probably late last fall.

0:06:40 I'm guessing it's when it was.

0:06:42 Working closely with them, what they're proposing to do.

0:06:48 I don't want us to get ahead with the special event process,

0:06:53 nor do they want to get ahead of it.

0:06:55 They have to put some work into this area.

0:06:59 One of the issues is they're gonna be leasing that property,

0:07:01 but they wanna clean up the area, landscape that area.

0:07:05 I believe you received a copy of the landscape

0:07:08 and plan that they had,

0:07:09 but we're gonna go through this process first

0:07:11 before they start basically putting the money

0:07:15 into this project.

0:07:16 What their proposal is, they currently work for a company

0:07:19 that puts on concerts in the Salt Lake area

0:07:24 area as well as the Boise area, they're looking for a place to, if I'm correct, they may correct

0:07:30 me later. When they're traveling back and forth with these bands, bigger name bands,

0:07:36 they'll stop off in Twin Falls for the weekend and provide entertainment. Their idea is once

0:07:44 they landscape this is to fence that area in. Initially, they're expecting upwards of

0:07:51 2,000 to 2,500 people however we all know we don't know what that exact number is until they get these going

0:07:58 They have a set up to where they will have a beer garden inside

0:08:04 Inside their fenced area this year to my understanding it will be temporary fencing

0:08:09 They talked with planning and zoning on this till they see how it's going and then maybe build on further in the future

0:08:16 The original dates of them. I'm getting ahead of myself

0:08:21 So the parking is a concern.

0:08:24 I've talked to them extensively about parking.

0:08:27 It is city parking across the street on Minnadoka Avenue.

0:08:31 There are next to the railroad tracks.

0:08:33 I don't recall how long ago it's been

0:08:35 since the city's paved that made a parking lot.

0:08:39 They're planning on utilizing that

0:08:40 as well as legal street parking and parking lots.

0:08:45 They're on the second avenue south area.

0:08:47 There are several city parking lots there.

0:08:49 These concerts, the way they haven't scheduled at this time,

0:08:52 would be held on a Saturday and again on a Sunday.

0:08:54 After speaking with them about clean up plans,

0:08:59 they've advised that they'll have their own personnel

0:09:03 walking the parking lots to assure everything's okay there,

0:09:06 as well as when the events are over,

0:09:08 they will police those areas of garbage and trash.

0:09:11 We spoke of porta-potties.

0:09:14 When they first start out, they're gonna start out

0:09:16 with a large number of those until again,

0:09:19 they see kind of what they need to have.

0:09:25 One of the concerns we have is pedestrians walking across the street have been advised

0:09:32 by them that they will have people assisting with that, with their own personnel.

0:09:37 We will require law enforcement security at these events.

0:09:42 Police Department recommends they have four police officers attend each one of these events

0:09:47 starting at the time, they start and they'll go until one hour after these events are over with.

0:09:53 We've always done that in the past and hour after the beer gardens close

0:09:57 and after the events over to make sure people disperse and everything is okay.

0:10:01 For each event, if they go for seven hours, they start at three in the afternoon and conclude at nine p.m. in the evening.

0:10:09 We talked extensively about when they were going to stop that.

0:10:13 I'm resorting to past experiences with other businesses that have held concerts in those

0:10:18 areas or in their parking lots and we do receive a lot of noise complaints from the south side

0:10:24 of the Brock Creek Canyon there that is a residential area, but that's when it was decided that they

0:10:29 would conclude these by 9 p.m. hoping to avoid a lot of that.

0:10:33 We've also indicated that the cost for the security would be $1,232 per event towards

0:10:41 for the police security, they would be required to pay

0:10:44 that as other events within 60 days,

0:10:47 as our city ordinance states,

0:10:49 the conclusion of each event.

0:10:52 If this is a success and continues,

0:10:56 depending on the types of calls for service we have,

0:10:58 we can work with them as well as as far as reducing security

0:11:01 costs by using other agencies,

0:11:04 or to determine if we need to increase

0:11:06 or decrease our security or keep it about the same.

0:11:08 That a lot of that will depend on the type of turnouts

0:11:11 the numbers of people that we get. We do have one note I received from them today

0:11:18 where we're getting so close to their first scheduled date of July 11th and

0:11:24 12th they're not going to be able to get this up and going by then. So if

0:11:28 this is approved by you they have asked it to cancel the advance on July 11th

0:11:33 and 12th and swap that out with a weekend in October of October 2nd

0:11:38 and third to replace that one.

0:11:41 So we'd have a total of eight events over four weekends.

0:11:47 One of the concerns that we've had,

0:11:49 and they've been working with us closely on this,

0:11:52 all this relevant city staff members have met on this.

0:11:57 There was some concern with the parking

0:11:59 we've gotten through all of that.

0:12:01 Better concerns from the building department,

0:12:02 the fire department regarding their stage that they use.

0:12:06 It's a semi-trader, and they can probably

0:12:09 provide more information they are here.

0:12:11 They got the specs to us this morning due to my

0:12:15 lack of technology skills.

0:12:17 I finally got it this afternoon with the fire department

0:12:20 has looked out over and they're comfortable with it.

0:12:22 However, Jared from the building department is out of town

0:12:25 this week kind of based on the information I got.

0:12:28 I think he's probably going to be okay with that,

0:12:30 but he just wanted to look to make sure that this was

0:12:32 a stable platform and not going to cause any other issues.

0:12:37 One thing that we talked about, with this many people,

0:12:42 I don't know how we would get an accurate number,

0:12:44 there's several different ways we can try to figure out

0:12:45 how many people arrive in a car to determine

0:12:47 how many cars we're gonna have in the area.

0:12:50 But it's gonna, I'm sure eventually,

0:12:54 a lot of the parking spaces are gonna be taking.

0:12:57 Granted, a lot of this will be when a lot of the businesses

0:12:59 are closed, I did advise them they needed to speak

0:13:01 with business owners in the immediate area

0:13:06 to make sure that they were aware of what was going on.

0:13:08 I did speak with them briefly and they are currently working

0:13:11 on that at this time when I figured you probably would have

0:13:13 some questions for them.

0:13:15 So at this point, we as a police department,

0:13:17 we have not signed off on this yet until I won't sign off

0:13:21 on these until everybody else has signed off.

0:13:23 So I'm at this point I'm waiting for Jared to get back.

0:13:27 I don't foresee any issues if he approves this and will sign

0:13:30 up on it so they can move forward if approved

0:13:34 to start preparing the area for the concert series.

0:13:37 I think I covered it all.

0:13:42 I know there's going to be several questions.

0:13:44 I know I have some concerns and some questions.

0:13:47 So, Mr., do you think the legos or go get, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

0:13:51 Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

0:13:53 You might want to make your way up kind of close because I think maybe some

0:13:56 of the questions will come to you, sir.

0:13:58 And I'm maybe even to Staff Sergeant Poland.

0:14:01 Now, I've got a few lights on and we'll see if my questions get asked.

0:14:06 Chris talking.

0:14:07 This is actually to the sergeant, actually, if they approach anywhere near their anticipated

0:14:15 2000, there is going to be some littering, some noise.

0:14:21 I'd like to have a little clarification on your statement that the success of the previous

0:14:28 This concert may depend, determine if we allow it in the future, and that is from the lack

0:14:34 of complaints, no additional place response or other issues.

0:14:38 We're not going to have that type of a threshold, I hope, where if we find a paper down, it's

0:14:43 going to be a reason to get them on it.

0:14:46 No, and we don't do that.

0:14:48 We haven't done that in the past.

0:14:49 Again, after we have the first one, we're going to have more of an idea.

0:14:53 If we find garbage, we're going to let them know, you know, this is a problem area.

0:14:57 You need to police that at the next one.

0:14:59 If that continues, the third or fourth concert or not,

0:15:03 abiding by our wishes to keep the city cleaned up,

0:15:06 or even the noise complaints, we will work with them.

0:15:11 However, if it continues and they're not doing anything

0:15:13 to resolve it, then we're going to probably

0:15:14 make a recommendation to terminate the.

0:15:16 It's a large agriculture lines of communication,

0:15:18 starting with you guys to the cop shop and back and forth,

0:15:21 making it a good event that the community feels

0:15:24 that was worthwhile doing.

0:15:26 I know the place will work with you.

0:15:29 Thank you, Chris, Suzanne Hawkins.

0:15:31 Thank you.

0:15:32 Yes.

0:15:34 I'm sorry if I missed it in your presentation,

0:15:36 but who owns this property?

0:15:40 Dave Woodhead, from what I understand.

0:15:41 OK, and so they're willing to invest their money

0:15:44 to landscape somebody else's property and.

0:15:48 That's what I've been told.

0:15:50 Without really owning anything.

0:15:52 Yeah, yeah.

0:15:53 Do you want to explain kind of?

0:15:55 When you come to the mike, folks at home are watching,

0:15:58 so state your name if you wouldn't mind, sir.

0:16:00 Yeah, my name is Alan Moss.

0:16:01 And to answer that question, we have an option

0:16:04 to purchase that land.

0:16:05 So depending on everything works out,

0:16:07 well, then we plan on purchasing that property at some point.

0:16:11 So the landscaping you're putting in, though,

0:16:12 is permanent, correct?

0:16:14 Yeah, it'll be sawed, and some trees, and some berms there

0:16:17 to make some elevated areas, correct.

0:16:20 Could speak more to the landscaping details, if you'd like.

0:16:24 I've seen your plan here, I was just, it's very generous to put in that type of landscaping

0:16:31 before you know what to expect.

0:16:34 And he's a landscaper by trade, so that helps a little bit.

0:16:38 Got it. Thank you.

0:16:39 Sean Bearer.

0:16:41 So my question is related to parking and staff's argin, you may be able to answer this.

0:16:46 So the lots that are on 4th Avenue South are those urban renewal lots and not city lots.

0:16:54 lots. So the one behind St. Luke's and so would that parking be available on

0:17:01 Saturday and Sunday to this event? Melinda's peaking around there. So she's

0:17:05 shaking her head in the infra because that would that would seem to me to be

0:17:08 a little more convenient public parking than utilizing the city lots over on

0:17:15 2nd Avenue and and perhaps not to have to deal with as much crossing traffic.

0:17:21 If I'm not sure we do own those parking lots, is that the Urban Renewal Agency, I believe,

0:17:29 owns those.

0:17:30 If they were given permission to use that, I would say, yeah, that would be a good idea.

0:17:35 Travis, you want to weigh in?

0:17:36 Yeah, they are already designated as public parking lots, and so that permission does not need to be granted.

0:17:41 Yeah, so I would encourage use of those lots as well.

0:17:45 Okay.

0:17:46 First, it puts people closer to the venue and they're not having to cross with 30 to get over there.

0:17:52 Sure. I can show if they're not familiar with that. I can show them where those are at.

0:17:55 Yeah, I have several questions. Probably to you, Mr. Agos.

0:18:01 Have you contacted any of the neighbors?

0:18:05 My brother has. He has talked with Wells Fargo and some of the surrounding areas recently.

0:18:13 So we have been in contact with them and will continue to get in contact with the ones that

0:18:18 were probably going to affect the most in the nearest area there.

0:18:22 The people across the canyon, we haven't checked with them per se, which is obviously residential,

0:18:30 so.

0:18:31 Well, my concern is this.

0:18:33 You've got several neighbors that run businesses.

0:18:38 parking is a premium in their general area. Certainly there's some cross and the

0:18:43 parking that Mr. Berger just talked about as well as is fairly flexible. But

0:18:49 they're running their businesses. You've got at least one event center down there

0:18:53 or two. Actually there are two right in that general area that utilize some of

0:18:58 this parking as well. And I just didn't know if you had contacted them to tell

0:19:01 them there's the influx potential influx of 2,500 people where there will be no

0:19:07 parking for their events during that time are you talking about like the radio

0:19:13 rendezvous no no there's there's a different stone house and what's one

0:19:17 brick three three yeah and three there's three yeah there's three events and

0:19:23 are sent essentially in that oh it's surrounding area yes yes I know which

0:19:28 ones you're talking about yeah we can certainly get down there and talk with

0:19:31 them as well and make sure that you know our calendars don't conflict too much and

0:19:35 if there is something that does come up,

0:19:38 then we'll certainly work on a plan to keep them

0:19:40 to where they have parking for their customers

0:19:46 and whoever they end up needing parking space for.

0:19:50 Yeah, I just think I want your event to be successful.

0:19:54 And one of the worst ways to start off

0:19:57 is make your neighbors mad at you.

0:19:59 Absolutely.

0:20:00 We understand that completely.

0:20:01 And so I really encourage you to do that.

0:20:05 Also, menidoka, I have some concerns, especially after a concert where maybe alcohol has been

0:20:14 consumed, crossing menidoka at night.

0:20:18 Menidoka is a truck route, and I'd really like to see more specific plans of how you're

0:20:25 going to get people across that road safely to that parking lot.

0:20:30 Does that kind of make sense to you?

0:20:32 Absolutely, yeah, we want public safety to be number one, of course.

0:20:36 We are going to also staff our event with security as well, so that should be part of

0:20:44 our plan.

0:20:45 We actually had that in the original plan to have somebody as a crossing guard there to

0:20:48 make sure people can cross either way and continue until everybody is cleared out from

0:20:55 the venue.

0:20:56 And I don't know, Staff Sergeant, I don't know if that's something that the police department

0:21:01 can help with.

0:21:02 I know I've been to a lot of concerts and when concerts are let out, there's a huge influx of vehicles trying to leave and generally the police are there to help with that.

0:21:15 Do we have plans for that?

0:21:17 We would have to utilize the people we have there for security, otherwise we're taking our officers off the street there in the call rotation.

0:21:23 And being on a weekend, especially Saturday evening, I would not feel comfortable at all counting on our patrol officers to be able to assist.

0:21:30 You know, we could certainly work with them on that.

0:21:33 However, we've got to keep in mind if we have some other issues going on,

0:21:37 we're not going to be able to go over and deal with traffic issues.

0:21:40 I guess some of this is experimental to see how it goes.

0:21:45 The other concern that I do have is really the cleanup.

0:21:49 I know that you've addressed that. You've talked about that.

0:21:51 But cleanup isn't just close.

0:21:54 People, as they go out to their cars, they litter.

0:21:57 We've done numerous, numerous events like this, you know, we've provided production for

0:22:04 a lot of these.

0:22:05 As a matter of fact, I just got back from a big festival in Wyoming where we have Toby

0:22:08 Keith, you know, it's just a mess for sure.

0:22:13 And it goes quite a ways and we understand that part.

0:22:16 We are working with local people here in town, too.

0:22:19 We're going to staff local people here locally and hire them so we can have somebody do a sweep

0:22:27 and we'll actually get with Dennis and figure out what our scope is of the whole thing and

0:22:35 make sure that we cover this every time and it should probably take us between two and

0:22:40 three days I would think to make sure we get a clean sweep of everything and make sure

0:22:45 that everybody's happy and make sure that we don't miss anything and hopefully as we

0:22:51 go along too and we make contact with our neighbors around there that they can certainly

0:22:56 get a hold of us and make sure that you know if they have any issues we'll get

0:23:00 somebody on it and get over there and get it taken care of. Staff Sergeant the

0:23:06 question I have for you this hasn't been truly approved to come to us yet

0:23:10 because you haven't signed off so for me personally to feel good about this I

0:23:15 think I just need a little more information that they've contacted the

0:23:19 neighbors and there's some sort of a plan in place what's what's the process

0:23:25 from here, Dennis.

0:23:28 What all we're waiting on is for Jared to get back.

0:23:30 Like I said, once he looks at this, he was one of them that was concerned about the platform

0:23:36 stage, which is a semi-trader, more or less, but once he looked at the fire department, went

0:23:42 over and looked at it, looked at it before, and then again looked at the specs on that

0:23:47 today, and he approved that.

0:23:51 I don't see any issues once he approves that.

0:23:54 Once we make sure that they continue notifying everybody,

0:23:57 then we're good to sign off on it at this point.

0:24:01 Okay.

0:24:02 Jim, Mike.

0:24:03 Thank you.

0:24:04 My question is for City Attorney.

0:24:09 Is this Fritz here?

0:24:10 I see him, there he is, he has indeed.

0:24:13 One of the, here's how things usually work.

0:24:16 I remember that we would have nightclubs open

0:24:18 and other things open, concert areas down somewhere,

0:24:22 and we'd have problems, and it would just take forever,

0:24:25 or it could take forever to resolve the matter,

0:24:28 because there was really no teeth in a contract,

0:24:32 or some sort of provision that makes it very, very easy

0:24:36 for us to shut this down, if, I'm not not saying

0:24:40 these guys are not gonna do that,

0:24:41 I have every hope in the world that they will abide

0:24:44 by the rules, but put something in writing that says,

0:24:48 we will do this if this happens, you know.

0:24:53 And I just, not just the special events,

0:24:55 but something that we, I don't know, a contract or?

0:24:58 Yeah, so, and I was thinking about that

0:25:01 as you were talking about it.

0:25:02 The problems we had before is people

0:25:03 would get special use permits to allow that use.

0:25:08 And so we would have to revoke the special use.

0:25:11 So that would require their rights to come to hearing stuff.

0:25:14 This is not like that at all.

0:25:16 it may be that you want to just grant one of these to start with so they have

0:25:21 no expectation other than one event

0:25:24 and then everything works great they can come back and say okay we're gonna

0:25:28 want to do seven more just like this

0:25:31 so that that's an alternative

0:25:34 honestly this is experimental you don't know how it's gonna go and probably you

0:25:39 do want to see how the first one absolutely

0:25:41 this one goes you know just have been a cop for thirty years i know how this works

0:25:45 And so, I would only permit this to, I think that's really good.

0:25:50 Because I've been in that uniform when, oh yeah, we're going to make it better next time.

0:25:55 Oh yeah, we're going to make it better next time.

0:25:57 And it never gets better.

0:25:58 It gets worse.

0:25:58 And then we get cops hurt and the whole, you've seen it.

0:26:00 I mean, you and I both seen this.

0:26:02 So I would, I would sign off on this for one time.

0:26:06 See how it goes and then bring it back.

0:26:09 I'm a student of body language, and when we talked about one time, that was difficult

0:26:16 for you.

0:26:17 Well, yeah.

0:26:18 To put that kind of money into it, to make it the kind of venue we need to, the landscaping

0:26:22 and everything, that'd be kind of tough.

0:26:25 You know, that's just understandable.

0:26:28 I mean, I see your side of it as well, but we're looking at longevity ourselves.

0:26:34 We don't want to mess this up on our part either.

0:26:37 So I mean if we're going to buy the property and put all that money into it, we certainly

0:26:41 want to get some sort of return obviously.

0:26:44 And I know it's a building process to make these successful as I say I've been doing this

0:26:50 for 25 years and in the audio realm of it.

0:26:55 So I'm from one end to the other and we certainly would like to, you know, we want to make it

0:27:01 the best.

0:27:02 Obviously it can be simply for us because my brother and I, we grew up down the road

0:27:08 30 miles.

0:27:09 So we've done this as a matter of fact, they did the Great White concert down at the Burleigh

0:27:15 Regatta a few, I guess it's been about eight years now.

0:27:20 And it just seems like it's a good idea in this area where Salt Lake and Boise are pretty

0:27:26 saturated with that.

0:27:29 business looks like, you know, a really good idea.

0:27:32 You know, I agree with everything you've just said.

0:27:34 The only challenge that I personally have,

0:27:36 and I spent 12 years in that uniform, too,

0:27:39 is the location.

0:27:41 Because there's not a lot of parking right next to it.

0:27:45 You're sharing parking with a bunch of other businesses.

0:27:48 I want to see you being successful.

0:27:50 I believe in business.

0:27:53 But I also want to be assured that we're not stuck in something

0:27:58 and something that's going to take us a long time to get out of if it's not safe, if it's not working well.

0:28:03 I understand your point of you're investing a lot, but I think I'm kind of in the same area that Jim is

0:28:10 regarding, you know, relationships are about trust and trust is built.

0:28:16 If you have a good concert series and it's safe and you clean up and things are good, then we'll go to the next and on and on.

0:28:23 I think the last thing we would expect the people before us investing the money they are

0:28:30 investing to purposely shoot themselves on the foot by negligence.

0:28:35 For God's sakes, why not just put in this that will allow that subject to a review after

0:28:41 the first one or two, but make it preemptive on our side as long as I'm not stating that

0:28:48 correctly, a law would continue unless there has been a demonstrated failure.

0:28:53 Again, they have all the risk on their side right now.

0:28:59 Let's see what they can do for the community.

0:29:01 Yeah, I don't think you're getting an argument from us, Chris.

0:29:04 I think we're just trying to get there.

0:29:06 Sean Bearer.

0:29:07 I would agree with Chris's comments that so in the staff report, it talks about the on-duty

0:29:13 patrol supervisor being authorized to terminate the event if there are issues, whether that's

0:29:18 who has complaints or fights or people getting run over on Minidoka or whatever.

0:29:24 So to me, I think I feel like we're addressing the things that both Jim and Don have expressed as concern.

0:29:33 I would be comfortable approving the series knowing that if the first one has challenges,

0:29:41 the likelihood of you continuing is going to be minimal.

0:29:45 But it gives you that incentive certainly to make sure it works with those in the future.

0:29:53 And I don't see that being any different than saying, let's try one and review it.

0:29:59 Because that's going to happen anyway, whether it's one approved or all eight.

0:30:04 Jim, Jim, I'm on.

0:30:05 Oh, thank you.

0:30:06 Yeah, I understand exactly what Sean's saying there.

0:30:09 That if during the first concert, things go south and the police shut it down.

0:30:14 they should have done, but that doesn't stop the next one from happening.

0:30:17 Well, it doesn't say that in this.

0:30:21 We would have to have some provision or agreement with them that that happens because I'm really,

0:30:32 I want to trust, but I want to trust and verify, and that means we'll approve one and then come

0:30:37 on back.

0:30:38 That's where that is.

0:30:39 some language that we have.

0:30:40 Yeah, so I think the problem is is that if we look at it two different extremes, one

0:30:46 stands by itself and then come back to us versus, yeah, you got eight of them and we're going

0:30:52 to have to drag you back here somehow if we don't like the way this is going and maybe

0:30:56 the answer is they'll have to come back to the council after each one along with Sergeant

0:31:03 pull in or whoever else and give you a report, how it's gone.

0:31:07 So on the spot, you can say, now we're not doing this anymore.

0:31:12 Otherwise, you're stuck with eight, they've got, you know,

0:31:15 if they do one and it's a disaster, they still have seven more.

0:31:19 And so then you're going to have to figure out how are we

0:31:21 going to shut this down.

0:31:24 That's what I'm struggling with is like, and I think

0:31:28 that's what Jim's problem is, is it looks more like a special

0:31:31 use permit that we have to go through some procedure that

0:31:35 it takes time to get it stopped.

0:31:37 And so, you know, maybe you want to have a review

0:31:40 after each one until you decide this is going great.

0:31:44 We don't need to do this anymore.

0:31:47 Yeah, go ahead, Chuck.

0:31:49 And I'm not beating you guys up.

0:31:50 I've just done this for so long and seen it go south

0:31:53 too many times that I'm going to have to have some assurance

0:31:55 of before I vote yes.

0:31:56 And I think this might be a very good compromise.

0:32:00 Mr. Monster, did you want to add something?

0:32:02 Yes, if I may.

0:32:04 There are two issues that make that just a little bit

0:32:06 difficult.

0:32:07 The first is that the artists tend

0:32:08 to be booked out quite a ways in advance.

0:32:11 And so if we only have a few weeks or a month

0:32:14 between each event, it's going to be difficult to book

0:32:16 the artists to get all that approved,

0:32:18 and then get advertising approved by the artist's management.

0:32:21 And then in turn, let the public into impulse

0:32:23 know that this event's happening.

0:32:25 So that's the first one.

0:32:26 The second one, and I've seen this done before in Salt Lake,

0:32:30 and I don't know if you have the ability to do this or not,

0:32:32 is a conditional permit, so you approve it,

0:32:36 but conditional, you put it language in there

0:32:38 where it's conditional upon the event going successfully.

0:32:41 So if police, for instance, shuts the first one down,

0:32:44 then we violated the conditional portion of your approval

0:32:48 and don't have those granted in the future.

0:32:50 So that would at least give us a little bit of a leeway

0:32:53 to do that, and I'm sure you would speak to that.

0:32:56 So on both sides here, we're gambling a little bit,

0:33:01 So I understand what he's saying that he's got a book in advance, absolutely.

0:33:06 So if they know that this is going to be great, there aren't going to be any problems,

0:33:12 they can book away because they know you're not going to shut them down.

0:33:18 Because everything is going to go great.

0:33:19 On the other hand, if they book ahead and the first one is a disaster and

0:33:24 they've booked seven more acts and you shut them down, well, how are you going to deal

0:33:31 with that. So they've got the same problem either way. So it just seems like to me they

0:33:37 ought to just go, if they know they're going to do a great job, they should just go ahead

0:33:41 and book their acts and it's going to go great and it's not going to be a problem. They're

0:33:45 going to come back and report and Dennis is going to say everything went great. But if

0:33:50 they think there's a chance they're going to get shut down after the first one or the

0:33:54 second one, they've booked ahead and they've got a problem.

0:33:59 Chris talking to how about some bonding the council thinkers any value in that haven't posted bond

0:34:05 Yeah, I'm not sure what that means in this context. Chris. Could you explain it litter clean up damage?

0:34:14 Broken windows, I mean anything material that may be directly related to the to the concert's performance and

0:34:24 Duration I would guess you've posted performance bonds before

0:34:28 Yes, I've done surety bonds before where, you know, basically that money's put up by us to get surety bond and then if there are damages or issues with payments or anything, then whoever the person that bond is issued for has the right to recoup funds from the bond agency if we default on some obligation or cost some damages if they're broken windows or something like that.

0:34:53 Because if I hear most of the problems Jim's had in his professional, it's been a career.

0:34:58 It's been related to not crud control during the time, but something after related to mopping

0:35:06 up or cleaning up Jim.

0:35:07 Oh, no.

0:35:08 Well, I've seen things happen where in boxing matches down in a big venue, it was a disaster.

0:35:17 I mean, I've seen a lot of bad stuff.

0:35:19 I don't think it bonds the solution here to you.

0:35:20 I mean, I really don't, I'm looking at Fritz and he's shaking his affirmative.

0:35:25 I really, I think Fritz explained it very well.

0:35:29 They want to have seven or eight events that are going to be problem-free.

0:35:35 This is a business risk.

0:35:36 This is business, guys.

0:35:37 So you're going to have to take the risk.

0:35:42 And I'll approve this, you know, in my opinion, if there's going to be a risk involved.

0:35:48 And I believe they have to come back after every event with a report from the police about property damage,

0:35:54 disorderly conduct, assaults on police officers every single week.

0:36:00 And that's the risk.

0:36:04 Sean Berger.

0:36:05 I don't think the bond is a solution.

0:36:11 Truthfully, I see the biggest risk factor here being complaints of noise.

0:36:17 I'm less concerned about destruction of property

0:36:20 and trash to a certain extent,

0:36:23 but I think it's really gonna be the one person

0:36:25 who doesn't want to listen to the concert at 6.30 in the evening

0:36:28 while they're sitting in their backyard

0:36:30 and you're blaring away.

0:36:33 If I may, we've got it down to a pretty good science now

0:36:38 that sound systems are not like they used to be

0:36:41 in the good old days where you just do a shotgun blast out there

0:36:45 and hope everybody hears it okay now.

0:36:48 We now have technology to exactly point each speaker exactly where we need to.

0:36:55 So we're inside our venue and the reason that we're of our landscape design is to design any

0:37:02 other noises to go up into the air and trees to kill it.

0:37:06 And we're getting pretty good at it to where we can stop it.

0:37:10 I do Sandy Amphitheater in Utah.

0:37:14 We have neighbors right over the hill.

0:37:16 And the first year I was in there using their equipment

0:37:21 more or less.

0:37:23 We had three or four complaints a year.

0:37:25 Since I've taken it over, not one.

0:37:29 So it's kind of getting down to pretty good science.

0:37:33 And I feel really comfortable with that as well.

0:37:36 So hopefully we can keep that under control as well.

0:37:39 And we've taken that into consideration as well.

0:37:43 One of the challenges with that, there aren't any trees

0:37:45 between you and South Park.

0:37:47 Right.

0:37:48 It's pretty flat.

0:37:49 But we are going to plant some as well.

0:37:51 So deflection of audio is trying to help it.

0:37:55 But like I say, aiming the speakers

0:37:57 at the back of our venue, at the highest point

0:38:00 and getting the rest of the people is what I specialize in.

0:38:06 So Chris talking to you.

0:38:07 Well, can we do it this way since the events are grouped back

0:38:12 back, four different back-to-back events over that time period. So for instance, did

0:38:18 you say the July 11th 12th is canceled now? So the first one would be July 2526. Is it

0:38:26 possible after the night, nine o'clock closed down for them to clean up and get the word,

0:38:33 or get us get the word I guess from the sergeant that they've satisfied the expectations and

0:38:39 that can proceed some 20 hours later.

0:38:43 It looks like it's gonna be awfully tight

0:38:45 where you have back-to-back events.

0:38:47 Well, it could be a possibility that we may not,

0:38:50 we're just kind of giving ourselves

0:38:52 a little bit of proper time in there

0:38:54 just in case of routing dates and time.

0:38:57 So there could be a possibility

0:38:59 that we may not have the second day.

0:39:02 We may only do the one Saturday.

0:39:05 And the quality events we're talking about is, you know.

0:39:08 that that's what you're asking us to approve so we have to go on what you've

0:39:11 told us that they could be for back-to-back events to back-to-back on a weekend

0:39:19 yes potentially that's the the highest level yes I can't imagine you get in a

0:39:25 Toby Keith for two days in a row and Twin Falls I'd hope so maybe if someone

0:39:34 would like to float a motion.

0:39:38 Council.

0:39:41 John Barriefer.

0:39:44 Mary would move to approve the request of Rock Canyon events, LLC, for these special

0:39:53 events to be held on July 25, 26, August 15, 16, September 19, 20, and October 2nd and

0:40:04 Third, as presented, subject to the approval of the building

0:40:13 department, signing off on the special event application,

0:40:17 and that there will be a report back to the council

0:40:22 following the first event, first events,

0:40:25 potentially, of that pair to assure there were no issues.

0:40:36 second.

0:40:37 Yeah, motion on floor by Sean Berger, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.

0:40:41 In your motion, Sean, is there the potential if there are grave concerns to the council

0:40:47 that they will cancel the rest?

0:40:50 Or have that option?

0:40:51 Yeah, so if, well, that would maybe be a question for Fritz.

0:40:54 So if it comes back to us on the 27th or whatever the next council meeting is after that, would

0:40:59 we have the authority at that point to say this was terrible?

0:41:03 It's revoked?

0:41:04 I think that's the option that you want to be able to have so that you don't get tied

0:41:08 up into some argument about, I mean, you should just have the ride and you shouldn't have to

0:41:14 get into an argument with them whether they say it was great, there were no problems

0:41:18 and yet your police department is reporting a lot of problems to you, it's solely in your

0:41:22 discretion.

0:41:23 So should I put that in the motion?

0:41:24 Sure.

0:41:25 I would include that in the motion.

0:41:26 So are you striking the no problems because that's going to make it a guess no for them?

0:41:34 So let's say that it will come back to the Council for a report and our review of potentially

0:41:43 revoking the balance of the events based upon reported issues.

0:41:48 Second, good with that?

0:41:50 Did you get that motion?

0:41:52 Yeah, because I'm not going to try to repeat it.

0:41:55 Gentlemen, do you understand what the motion is?

0:41:59 You're able to live with that.

0:42:01 Okay, very good, sir.

0:42:03 John Berger.

0:42:04 I think we have a responsibility, too, that it's not going to be, well, there was an empty

0:42:11 beer can on the side of the street, therefore the other three events are yanked.

0:42:15 I think it has to be significant concerns and no effort to mitigate them.

0:42:22 That's the position I feel I would be in to say these are not going to go forward.

0:42:26 So certainly every effort on your part to make sure those things don't happen or understanding

0:42:31 if there are issues having a plan to address those and working closely with the police department and other departments.

0:42:39 Jim, I want to set their mind at ease also. I mean, I'm not going to be shutting them down over the, it's going to be a significant breach of the piece here before I would vote not to have the second one.

0:42:54 I mean, I'm not there, but I want to make sure that it's done properly.

0:43:00 Anything further on the motion council

0:43:03 The other roll call vote, please

0:43:06 Jim Munn yes, Sean Berger. Yes, Chris talking ten. Yes, Don Hall. Yes, Suzanne Hawkins. Yes

0:43:13 Motion passes five to zero gentlemen. I just want to assure you where we believe in what you're doing

0:43:19 We want it to be successful

0:43:20 But as stated we have an obligation to our community for the safety of our community for their property safety

0:43:26 and others and quality of life, frankly, as well, so.

0:43:31 Absolutely, and we will work diligently

0:43:34 with the police department and whoever else we need to,

0:43:39 absolutely.

0:43:40 Thank you, thank you.

0:43:41 And we won't judge you on the quality of your bands,

0:43:44 that's your business.

0:43:45 Well, we're gonna try to bring something for everyone.

0:43:49 Just, you know, Van Halen, Erasmith might be nice.

0:43:52 Suzanne Hopkins.

0:43:53 I just wanted to say thank you for giving our community

0:43:55 I know this is something that we have been asked for by our citizens, and I wish you the best, and I hope this turns out to be really great because I know it's something that this community has been looking forward to.

0:44:06 Thank you.

0:44:07 Good luck, gentlemen. Thank you.

0:44:08 Thank you so much.

0:44:09 Moving on to the next item.

0:44:11 Consideration of request.

0:44:13 And thank you, Dennis. I didn't say thank you to you.

0:44:15 Thank you, sir.

0:44:16 Consideration of request to approve a memorandum of understanding termination agreement between the city of Twin Falls, college of southern Idaho.

0:44:24 of Southern Idaho and the College of Southern Idaho Foundation concerning trail development.

0:44:30 Dennis Boyer will be making the presentation.

0:44:32 It looks like Mitch Humble might be making the presentation.

0:44:35 Before we do that, I do want to state that I had a conference with Fritz Wonder left

0:44:40 today because there's at least two or three of us on the council that have ties with CSI.

0:44:47 And I don't believe that any of us have any direct ties with CSI Foundation.

0:44:52 So we discussed it and so there shouldn't be a conflict of interest for us.

0:44:59 Just wanted to state that.

0:45:00 Jim Munn.

0:45:01 Well yeah, and I want to go on record just so it's out there.

0:45:05 I am under contract with the colleges Southern Idaho as a faculty member until August 1st.

0:45:13 Or July 1, I can't remember what it's August 1st.

0:45:17 Yeah, they were wrong on that.

0:45:19 So I no longer work there, but I'm just being under contract.

0:45:23 Am I okay on this?

0:45:25 I am good.

0:45:26 Okay, thank you.

0:45:27 Yeah, we will walk through that.

0:45:28 Yeah, so I'm not Dennis, you guys probably know that.

0:45:32 Dennis has a visitor with him today,

0:45:34 and I want not a visitor, it's probably not a fair statement.

0:45:37 We have a new employee that started with us today.

0:45:40 This young lady that sat beside Dennis

0:45:42 just stand up, Wendy Davis, and I thought I'd introduce her

0:45:45 since she's gonna be presenting the next four items.

0:45:48 trial by fire windy I like it maybe not Dennis will probably still do it but I

0:45:56 just wanted you to counsel the recognize that Wendy's on board now and

0:46:00 day one she's ready to hit the ground running so to take Dennis's large shoes

0:46:06 to fill when he leaves so anyway there you go thank you Mitch and welcome aboard

0:46:11 Wendy pleasure to have you here Dennis Boyer

0:46:17 Is this your last council meeting? Yes it is. As a city employee, who knows if I come back and harass you guys.

0:46:24 What can I say to me? What can I say tonight to make you cry? Anything? Nothing.

0:46:29 Just look at you wrong. Thank you Dennis. Welcome.

0:46:34 Okay. Thank you mayor and council's a pleasure to be here tonight.

0:46:50 Maybe a little extra pleasure for me tonight.

0:46:53 Since this is my last one is a city employee anyway. I had to throw that in there.

0:46:58 This first item here is we're looking at to terminate. We have a couple of MOUs.

0:47:04 One MOU is just with the foundation themselves and another MOU that the city, the college and the foundation sign.

0:47:12 So this first one is the one that we signed back in 2003 with the foundation themselves.

0:47:19 is we're looking at our trail system,

0:47:22 and how can we connect sound up really the college up

0:47:25 to our trail system that goes underneath the pole line.

0:47:28 So we had agreement with the foundation at that time

0:47:31 to put a trail, and this idea was completely

0:47:36 on foundation property, on the east side of the ponds there,

0:47:40 coming up here, then going up in between Lazy J

0:47:42 and Fawnbrook Apartments there, coming up here,

0:47:45 hit the sidewalk, and then eventually going underneath the tunnel.

0:47:48 So that was signed back in 2003,

0:47:50 because I think by the memorized, we applied for a grant.

0:47:52 This was the whole purpose of this memorandum of understanding.

0:47:56 We did not get the grant, so we started working on some more,

0:47:59 and then our next idea was to work on,

0:48:08 it's real similar, the trail system was,

0:48:10 except for when we started at North College,

0:48:12 we were on the West Side of the prime Cooley,

0:48:15 which the West Side is owned by the College of Southern Idaho.

0:48:18 So we had to have an agreement with the College of Southern

0:48:20 Idaho and the foundation because the trail was going to be a little bit on the west side,

0:48:24 then we're going to go cross the Cooley and back on the foundation and straight up there

0:48:28 and get to the pole line again.

0:48:30 So that was the agreement that was signed in 2004.

0:48:34 And you know, we applied for a grant, never did receive a grant.

0:48:37 So this never came into fruition of a trail system anyway.

0:48:41 But in the meantime that between the college, the foundation themselves and a private developer

0:48:48 that we are now looking at, you know, the idea of ultimate goal is have the trail system

0:48:53 on the west side of the Cooley, and eventually when Lazy J develops, this half the trail continue

0:48:58 on through Lazy J, or the former Lazy J, I guess, connect with the tunnel underneath

0:49:02 the pole line. But we, as we know, Lazy J is not any time developing soon, so we have now

0:49:08 looked at is, um, build the trail on the west side of the Cooley all the way up here until

0:49:16 So you hit the southern part of Lazyjay, and we have kind of worked it out with private

0:49:22 developers.

0:49:23 Take the trail, kind of on the south side of Lazyjay here, then eventually head straight

0:49:28 north on the west side of Lazyjay.

0:49:31 So that's the, and you might say that's just our temporary trail, because we know someday

0:49:35 Lazyjay will develop and will punch the trail just along the Cooley there.

0:49:40 So tonight the termination agreement is really terminate those two MOUs, that one sign in

0:49:45 2003 and 2004, so we ensure the foundation that we are not looking ever to build a trail

0:49:52 through the foundation property.

0:49:54 So that's why this termination, I've got to remember the memorandum of understanding termination

0:49:59 agreement is for you, is in front of you tonight, staff recommends that the council authorize

0:50:05 the mayor to sign this agreement.

0:50:07 It has not gone to the foundation board or the college board themselves to review, but

0:50:13 they know that it's in effect anyway because they all parties kind of agreed to this idea

0:50:18 of where this trail will eventually go.

0:50:22 So that's my presentation for tonight on this part on the first item.

0:50:26 Yes.

0:50:27 We have a couple questions Suzanne Haughness.

0:50:29 Thank you.

0:50:30 So with the Chaney Drive road project going on, how would that affect this trail?

0:50:35 Are we going to be crossing the middle of that new street somewhere or?

0:50:39 A little bit, but okay.

0:50:45 Let me jump if I'm wrong here Jackie.

0:50:47 Okay on the road or Travis can tell me.

0:50:50 You know, North College,

0:50:52 well then it'll turn into a chain,

0:50:53 it'll kind of swing up this way.

0:50:55 North College will kind of swing up here,

0:50:56 and we're gonna have like a T intersection

0:50:58 with the stoplight there,

0:50:59 and our Y intersection.

0:51:01 So we'll be to the east of that?

0:51:04 Yeah, we'll cross kind of the intersection, the trail well,

0:51:07 but then the trail will be in between

0:51:10 the new chain drive and the Cooley.

0:51:11 Okay.

0:51:12 will be on like the east side and the north side of the road itself.

0:51:16 Great. Thank you. Travis?

0:51:18 You know, I just wanted to add maybe a couple of things to Dennis's report. So this was brought to our attention

0:51:24 by Katie Breckenridge, and we really think Katie for bringing this to our attention.

0:51:30 What we've learned through our process is that all of the

0:51:34 prior agreements were really constructed in error, and they were constructed in conflict with

0:51:40 the dedication of the land.

0:51:43 We had many great conversations with the college president,

0:51:46 Dr. Jeff Fox.

0:51:47 We've also had presidents with the foundation director.

0:51:50 And in that, we were able to come to a place

0:51:54 that we really believe that the solution

0:51:56 that Dennis presented accomplishes the public objective

0:52:00 of really creating a complete trail system.

0:52:03 But it honors the Breckenridge gift of the property

0:52:05 and the manner in which it was intended.

0:52:08 And so it also keeps that property intact as well,

0:52:11 which is also a community value and benefit.

0:52:14 Thank you, Travis.

0:52:15 Kristin?

0:52:16 Well, I'm ready to make a motion,

0:52:17 but before then I think we should hear from Katie Preckenridge.

0:52:23 I know you came here on this.

0:52:25 Katie?

0:52:26 We certainly don't have to come up here, madam,

0:52:28 but you certainly can if you'd like.

0:52:37 First of all, Katie, welcome.

0:52:49 One of the last things my father said to my dad said to me

0:52:54 before he died was Katie, protect the farm.

0:52:59 And I totally understand why the community would want a bike

0:53:03 path through that beautiful piece of property.

0:53:07 But from the farmer perspective, you can never farm with a

0:53:12 bike path.

0:53:13 And that was not one of the ideas that he had in mind.

0:53:17 And so I am very, very grateful to the people that stepped to

0:53:23 this when it was brought to your attention.

0:53:26 The bike path does not belong on the Breckenridge Endowment

0:53:30 Farm.

0:53:32 It was the only thing that my dad wanted

0:53:34 was that piece of property to remain

0:53:37 a farm in the heart of Twin Falls.

0:53:41 And my heart sings loud if you pass this.

0:53:47 And I thank you very, very much for what you've done.

0:53:51 And I'm not very good at this because it

0:53:53 is such a huge emotional issue for me, huge.

0:54:02 Thank you, Katie.

0:54:03 Thank you, Chris, for reminding us to ask Katie,

0:54:06 come up and you have the floor.

0:54:08 Well, I would just move to approve the memorandum

0:54:11 of understanding termination agreement

0:54:14 between the City of Twin Falls and CSI

0:54:16 and CSI's foundation concerning the trail development

0:54:19 of CSI's property and CSI's foundation property.

0:54:25 and instruct the mayor of the sign and instruct the mayor of the authorized

0:54:31 signing thank you Chris second we have a motion on what by Chris talking in

0:54:37 seconded by Sean Barrigger anything further on that motion council again

0:54:44 thank you Katie for your patience the island roll call vote Sean Barrigger yes

0:54:52 Chris talking to yes Don Hall yes Suzanne Hawkins yes Jim mine yes motion passes

0:54:59 five to zero. We could tell who that was from. Chris talking. Well I'd just like to

0:55:07 say that Katie was not shy and reminding me I was involved in the error of getting

0:55:13 that going to begin with so thank you for allowing me to make the motion to allow

0:55:17 me to sleep with a clear conscience tonight.

0:55:20 Next item on the agenda presentation from Steve Meyer-Hofer on the contract

0:55:25 involving the leasing of the Twin Falls Golf Club and Dennis, are you gonna

0:55:31 start or we're gonna have Steve come up?

0:55:35 He didn't volunteer. I was asked to give an overview of our current state at the golf course as of this spring and it's going to be kind of broad.

0:55:51 So, questions that you had I don't cover, they'll free to ask when we're done.

0:55:56 First off, this is my fourth year at the golf course.

0:56:00 I was hired in June of 2011, so it's my four year anniversary, so it's been nice to be here.

0:56:04 I've enjoyed it very much, so thank you guys for that.

0:56:08 I want to talk first about the golf course in general and where we're at and how it's going.

0:56:13 Dario Marcus is our superintendent, he's been a lot longer than I have, and he's done a wonderful

0:56:18 job in my eyes.

0:56:22 We do each year kind of look at some things that we kind of work on and improve at the

0:56:26 golf course and some examples are this year.

0:56:31 Number one, our tree trimming, every spring we do some trimming of our trees and we're a

0:56:38 little bit behind I felt because every windstorm we have those little elm trees just drop tons

0:56:43 of lit twigs, leaf branches.

0:56:46 So the areas that have been very bad in that aspect we cut way back which has helped out

0:56:52 a lot that the spring as far as wind blowing that maintenance as far as that goes, so that's

0:56:55 been one project we've improved on greatly. Since I've been there, probably the biggest

0:57:00 complaint on the golf course itself has been the sand traps. So over the last couple years

0:57:06 we spent a lot of time with new sand, working the sand, working around the sand traps, and

0:57:11 for the first time since I've been there, they are much better, they've improved 100%.

0:57:16 So that's been very good for the golf course itself, and probably the other area on the

0:57:21 golf course itself, the one I just mentioned is that,

0:57:24 usually we play a golf course, they ask you,

0:57:26 how are the greens, how are the greens in this area?

0:57:29 How do they roll?

0:57:29 And I would say that our greens,

0:57:31 that's what it's called, are probably the nicest

0:57:34 in the Magic Valley.

0:57:35 So the golf course itself is based on improvements.

0:57:38 We have our ears open for problems that we kind of work on,

0:57:41 but we're heading right direction, I feel.

0:57:44 So that's been good.

0:57:46 The next step I want to mention is our clubhouse,

0:57:50 which the sheets that Dennis handed out,

0:57:52 there's some information of what we've done

0:57:56 to the clubhouse over the last couple years

0:57:57 to make improvements.

0:57:59 When I came there, there was a lot of things

0:58:01 that hadn't been done over the years

0:58:02 or kind of behind, as far as just making the stuff,

0:58:05 cleaning some stuff up.

0:58:08 It looks much nicer, we found a lot of compliments

0:58:11 on our improvements we've made,

0:58:14 but I think probably the biggest improvement

0:58:15 is the deck we've added to the east side of the clubhouse.

0:58:18 That's been a major hit, it holds about 20 people

0:58:20 And it's a nice spot to watch people come in off the golf course.

0:58:24 And that was open last spring.

0:58:27 And that's been a big hit with the golfers.

0:58:29 So thank you for letting us do that.

0:58:33 As far as the golf itself, that's where we're here for it.

0:58:38 More golfers enjoy themselves.

0:58:40 We are right in kind of the midst of our busy seasons right now.

0:58:43 We have our mise-liques going on, our women's league going on.

0:58:46 We have a couple's night on Friday nights.

0:58:48 We have juniors June, July, August.

0:58:51 So we're right now cutting the meat of our season.

0:58:54 It's going very well.

0:58:55 It's been good.

0:58:57 Upcoming events that I want to make note of,

0:59:00 our capital improvement scramble, which

0:59:03 is the Prince of Muni, is July 25th, I believe,

0:59:08 on a Saturday.

0:59:10 And what that is, it's an event to raise the money

0:59:13 for the golf course itself.

0:59:14 So all the money coming in goes straight back

0:59:15 to the golf course, whether it's the new T-box,

0:59:18 or a new sand trap, or a cart path.

0:59:20 All that money comes straight back, goes right back to the golf course.

0:59:23 And over the last four years I've been that we've raised about $39,000 when Rev.

0:59:29 the golf course.

0:59:30 So, any of you who want to play that event on the 25th gives the call out there, we'd

0:59:34 love to have you, but it's been a very good event for us.

0:59:38 So, another thing we have coming up, we have Library Scramble in September, which has been

0:59:45 a long ongoing event out there.

0:59:47 We have our flag like an eagle up this fall also.

0:59:52 We have our magic valley amateur.

0:59:53 We've just been a long rain event at the golf course also.

0:59:55 So we have a lot of things lined up.

0:59:57 We're staying busy.

0:59:59 But it's been a very good spring so far.

1:00:02 So it's hopefully a nice summer and fall as well.

1:00:09 One concern that I do have that I just mentioned

1:00:11 that currently our equipment is getting into a state

1:00:17 where we might need some updates fairly quickly.

1:00:20 And I just have a recommendation that I would hope

1:00:23 we don't wait, whereas too long we have to do

1:00:26 a lot of things at once.

1:00:27 It's nice to be on a schedule that may be out of

1:00:30 pizza equipment every year, every two years, three years.

1:00:32 So we're gonna have a cycle.

1:00:33 Rather than waiting, you know, eight, 10 years also,

1:00:35 we need to buy a lot of equipment for the golf course.

1:00:38 So that's one that I've concerned that my superintendent

1:00:41 has, and I want to reiterate that on my part also.

1:00:45 So as far as the numbers at the golf course

1:00:48 I've been doing, that sort of thing.

1:00:51 I'm glad to answer any questions you may have about my lease,

1:00:53 about financially, how we're doing.

1:00:56 But it has been a good year.

1:00:57 We've progressed most years in at least some areas I feel.

1:01:02 And I know the last three years,

1:01:07 there's been no money coming my way from the city,

1:01:09 which has been kind of nice, but I've been

1:01:10 going a little bit your way, which is where we're hoping

1:01:12 that this all started, so it's been good.

1:01:15 Excellent, Travis, did you want to add?

1:01:17 You know, first, just a really big credit to Steve

1:01:19 and Travis out at the golf club

1:01:22 and everything that they're doing.

1:01:24 Maybe to answer the question, in terms of the equipment piece

1:01:27 that Steve had talked about, we agree with him.

1:01:30 I think it's important to recognize that even though this

1:01:32 is a city leased asset or contract,

1:01:35 this remains a city asset.

1:01:37 And it's important for us to maintain it as it is a city asset.

1:01:41 So we, in our upcoming budget, we have programmed

1:01:44 funding to fix some of the bridges out there, as well as acquire a mower in this upcoming

1:01:51 budget.

1:01:52 And then in subsequent years of the five-year plan, we also have followed that suggestion

1:01:57 of acquiring additional pieces of equipment to help maintain the asset.

1:02:02 And the city's interest in that is because of our agreement, there are certain profit

1:02:07 thresholds that have to be met.

1:02:09 And if Steve and his team are able to do their part to meet those profit thresholds,

1:02:14 And that's the revenue guarantee clause in our agreement never gets invoked.

1:02:20 And so what we're doing is we're being very proactive on the front end to ensure

1:02:23 that the golf course playability, ensure that it remains to be a public asset,

1:02:27 is up at that first and foremost place.

1:02:31 But aside from that, then just really a credit to Steve.

1:02:34 I have a couple little guys that like to go out and play golf.

1:02:38 And they participate in Steve and Travis's youth golf program.

1:02:43 And I will tell you, there were 19 kids that every single one of them at their last session

1:02:49 left with smile on their faces.

1:02:51 And if that is a testament to the level of service, that if you can please six and seven

1:02:56 year olds and keep their attention for an hour at golf, then you're probably doing something

1:03:00 right.

1:03:01 So, you know, just really big hats off to Steve, and if Lori was here, Lori raised our CFO would

1:03:07 say that the financial reporting that Steve shares with us is never in doubt.

1:03:13 It is always very accurate, it's always very detailed,

1:03:16 and he provides a wealth of information

1:03:19 that allows us to really follow the information very thoroughly

1:03:23 and very effortlessly.

1:03:26 Thank you for having us.

1:03:28 Do we have any questions for Steve, Council?

1:03:31 Good job.

1:03:31 Thanks.

1:03:33 Just want to say thank you.

1:03:35 You know, I hear nothing but compliments.

1:03:36 I appreciate that.

1:03:37 Out at the golf course.

1:03:39 You know, you might, I don't know if you know great planning.

1:03:41 Yeah, that's fine.

1:03:42 That's what I'm going to do.

1:03:43 Go ahead.

1:03:44 I think this is the first report that he has since I've been on council about the golf course.

1:03:51 He was coming so he got the heck out of you.

1:03:53 That's the reason we're getting out before 9 o'clock.

1:03:57 That's exactly right.

1:03:58 But really Steve, thank you.

1:04:00 And for the professionalism that you and Travis have out there.

1:04:04 It's a friendly environment and a well-run environment.

1:04:07 It's one of our main goals where there's make it more more open everybody to come enjoy yourself to fill it home

1:04:14 And I think it's been a good thing though. So there is a check that you give to the city

1:04:19 And I'm assuming you gave that to Travis and then he gave it to the right person Lori

1:04:25 Well, so actually I think you gave it to Dennis and they completely bypassed me and gave it to Lori

1:04:29 You know, I'm gonna go straight to Lori

1:04:31 Well, in Mr. Mayor, you bring up a really good point.

1:04:35 What we do with those funds is then we return and put that back in the investment into the

1:04:39 course.

1:04:40 So those are those are golf funds and what we'd like to do is we'd like to take those

1:04:44 funds and we'd like to continue to invest in our asset.

1:04:48 You know, at the end of the day, we want to involve golf club to be the most playable,

1:04:53 most accessible golf course in the Magic Valley.

1:04:57 Thank you, Travis.

1:04:58 And thank you, Steve.

1:04:59 I just have one question in the numbers, Steve, it looks like the rounds played the last couple of years been pretty much the same.

1:05:07 I don't even know what days you're open. How many rounds of golf per day does that average do you recall?

1:05:13 You know per day, I don't know tell you the truth. I wrote that down, Chris, but it's about 28,000 a year.

1:05:19 And depends on this spring, we are way up. We had a nice spring this year, you know, January, February, March was nice.

1:05:25 I think a lot of the hot stretch will be quite so it fluctuates yearly.

1:05:29 The last three years we're about 28,000 rounds a year is where we've been kind of hovering.

1:05:34 So, and you know, my main goal when I first got there was to get more people in the door.

1:05:38 So, you know, so it improves our concessions, it improves everything.

1:05:41 And I would say that we lost the people that have come back.

1:05:45 It's been nice.

1:05:47 And growing around from here, it's hard to get higher than we are, but we'll keep working on it.

1:05:56 Thank you, Steve.

1:05:56 Appreciate it.

1:05:58 Moving to the next item, consideration of a request

1:06:00 to name two sections of the Snake River Canyon Trail System.

1:06:05 Dennis Boyer.

1:06:10 Thank you, Mayor and Council.

1:06:12 Tonight, I'm asking the Council to look at a name,

1:06:15 a couple of sections of our Canyon Trail and memory, sorry,

1:06:19 in honor of two long-time city employees.

1:06:22 Don't tell Gary or Lamar that way.

1:06:24 Yeah, don't say memory yet.

1:06:25 I know, bad choice of work.

1:06:28 But, you know, to give you a little background, you know,

1:06:30 in 2012, you know, the council approved a naming policy

1:06:33 for something exactly like this here.

1:06:34 You know, could we get name buildings or parks

1:06:36 or sections of the trail?

1:06:38 You know, there's kind of key points to the policy

1:06:40 where, you know, there's four criteria as to kind of name

1:06:44 or rename the facility.

1:06:45 You know, we talked about the geographical area,

1:06:47 the neighborhood area, you know,

1:06:49 or kind of look at a historic cultural significance

1:06:52 or even look at, you know, historic figure

1:06:55 or individual that has contributed to the community.

1:06:59 And it specifically talks about in our naming policy

1:07:03 as a city employee, you know, yet the employee

1:07:05 has to be at least retired for six months

1:07:09 before you consider that.

1:07:10 And both of these gentlemen have been retired

1:07:12 a little bit longer than six months anyway.

1:07:13 But staff proposed to the Parks and Recreation Commission

1:07:17 to rename, I'll give you quickly.

1:07:21 Kind of see this, I don't know if you call it purple

1:07:23 to whatever color this officially is.

1:07:25 This section here, right now, it's commonly referred

1:07:28 to as the Washington Street and North Prine Cooley Trail system.

1:07:32 Just because in the Washington Street, right there as

1:07:35 where it starts, there's a Prine Cooley runs along there.

1:07:37 So a real original name that came up with there.

1:07:41 So this is a section I am asking the council to look at,

1:07:46 name in this as Lamar Orden section.

1:07:49 And then we have the Prine Bridge East Trail and the Prine Bridge West Trail.

1:07:56 Both of them, one was built, I think, in 2001 and 2002.

1:08:00 And I'm asking the council to get to rename these sections as a Gear Young Trail there.

1:08:06 Kind of some of you, Chris especially knows the two gentlemen that we're talking about,

1:08:12 been on the city employees for a long time, like Lamar was hired originally back in 1974.

1:08:17 He was our planning and zoning director for over 25 years

1:08:20 and retired, you know, it was 10 years ago.

1:08:23 You know, one of his passions were trails like that.

1:08:26 And I'd like to tell the story,

1:08:28 because I remember when our first trail

1:08:30 to Washington Street, Brian Cooley's section,

1:08:32 that overlook over there by Canyon Crest,

1:08:35 the grading there wasn't put on there yet.

1:08:38 We just had those high beams out there.

1:08:40 And Gary, young and I, that's before we had,

1:08:42 we had did have railings, I think.

1:08:44 Here and I, young, young could walk on the high beams

1:08:47 and walk out there even though you got straight drop off there.

1:08:51 Lamar even though his passion was trails,

1:08:53 he could not get close to that edge area.

1:08:55 I know some people have that fear too,

1:08:57 but he was a smart one.

1:08:58 He was a smart one, yeah.

1:09:00 Thanks, and don't.

1:09:01 But without his passion for trails and its guidance

1:09:08 and pushing through the changes in our city code,

1:09:10 we would have our trail system where we had,

1:09:12 and he was intermenstrual, involved in really every trail

1:09:16 until he retired, you know, because I named him off, you know,

1:09:19 the Breckenridge Estates, that very first trail that went

1:09:21 through the Breckenridge Estates, you know, the one we're asking

1:09:24 to name this section off, both of them on both sides

1:09:26 of the Prine Bridge, the Centennial Trail was involved with that,

1:09:30 you know, and through that little section

1:09:31 with Katie Breckenridge's property on the south side

1:09:33 of her property and the section where we worked it out from least

1:09:37 that house on the, you know, this section here,

1:09:40 we kind of call this the blast section, because that kind

1:09:42 of connected this trail down, at least the pole line anyway,

1:09:46 You know, and he was, besides that, you know, our rock creek property that the city owns,

1:09:51 currently kind of by my office that goes down to close to the old daydream ranch below the

1:09:56 rock creek condos.

1:09:58 You know, he got the city to buy that property back in the 70s sometime.

1:10:03 That's all I remember.

1:10:05 So, so staff kind of recommend to name this section, Lamar Orden section.

1:10:10 And Gary Young was our city engineer for about 30 years himself.

1:10:14 He retired in 2005 also, Gary really worked a lot behind the scenes, working with developers

1:10:20 and helped design our trail system like that, and he was out there, I remember the Centennial

1:10:25 Trail, we walk in along that where we're going to get the trail, how do we go up this side,

1:10:30 when we go down there, so he was working with the Centennial Commission at that time and staff

1:10:35 about how we're, and I know he probably another story about this section here, walking this

1:10:40 section before any of this was built before any is out there. Of course, we hit one of

1:10:45 those sudden rain, sleet, hail. That's what that day, hail storms. And there's myself,

1:10:52 Lamar, Ordon, Gary, Young. I don't think Mr. Courtney was here, but also our former

1:10:58 airport manager, the Allen was his last name. Also in that hail head out there, we're trying

1:11:04 to scramble. We hit underneath Russian olive trees to get out of the hail. And usually

1:11:09 I don't go close to a Russian olive trees because they have those long pointy things out there that stabs you

1:11:13 But that was better than the hail that was coming down that day because was a beautiful day five minutes later

1:11:18 Just held on this but I remember that day before that trail was built

1:11:22 So this was back that trail was built in 1998, but we were out there like a 97 that time

1:11:27 Walking to see where that trail system should be at so

1:11:31 Staff is kind of

1:11:33 Asking to city council would consider to name these two sections here as a gear young section because really

1:11:39 you know, without those two gentlemen,

1:11:41 our trail system would not be where it's at today.

1:11:43 Because it's really was a, you know,

1:11:46 I get a lot of credit for this, but it's not me.

1:11:48 It's the whole city staff, the whole community,

1:11:52 but really, especially without these two gentlemen,

1:11:54 our trail system would not be where it's at today.

1:11:57 So staff recommends that, you know,

1:11:59 council will approve the renaming of this section

1:12:02 as the Lamar Ordinance section,

1:12:03 and renaming these two sections as the Gary Young section.

1:12:07 So I'll stand down for questions.

1:12:09 Any questions for Dennis or direction?

1:12:12 Just to remind Dennis, that actually started

1:12:15 in Rock Creek Canyon with Lamar acquiring the property.

1:12:19 Yeah, so that was about 78, I think.

1:12:22 78, okay.

1:12:22 Around there, yeah.

1:12:25 That was before my time with the city, okay.

1:12:28 Yeah, barely.

1:12:28 Yeah, barely, I know.

1:12:29 I know.

1:12:31 Sean Berringer.

1:12:32 I would move approval of the request

1:12:35 name the two sections of the Snake River Canyon Room and Trail System as presented.

1:12:39 Second.

1:12:41 Motion on 4 by Sean Berger, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.

1:12:46 I just want to add that you're absolutely right.

1:12:49 Those two gentlemen, I had the opportunity to work with both of them, I've worked for the

1:12:53 city, and their passion about this community is overwhelming, really.

1:13:00 My favorite story about Gary Young is one day I walked into his office and made the mistake

1:13:04 of saying what's that? About two hours later, I was able to find the leave. That's how engineers

1:13:10 work. They want to tell you about everything, but they definitely had passion for this community.

1:13:16 Anything further on the motion council? Yeah, the roll call vote, please.

1:13:20 Chris Talkington? Yes. Don Hall? Yes. Suzanne Hawkins? Yes. Jim Munn? Yes. Sean Barriper? Yes.

1:13:27 Motion passes 5-0. Last Dennis Boyer item. Yes. Presentation of an update on an alternate

1:13:36 type of fencing along the Snake River Canyon Rim Trail system. My boss told me to make it a good one.

1:13:42 I should have counted all the presentations I made to the council. I could say this is my last one out

1:13:47 of 148. I don't know how many I presented but it could be that many. But really if you don't do good job

1:13:52 what can we do? Okay several weeks ago I came in front of this council we looked at alternate

1:14:03 and looked at our Kenyan Rim trails,

1:14:07 because I think Chris Talkington brought about

1:14:09 maybe some sections of our trail system

1:14:11 that maybe we need some additional fencing.

1:14:14 So myself and Gretchen Skye went on,

1:14:16 walked the trail system,

1:14:18 and then we came up with, if I remember correctly,

1:14:20 about a little bit over 300 feet of additional fencing,

1:14:23 we thought.

1:14:24 But I kind of told you, some of the problems

1:14:27 we would have with the fencing we have out there

1:14:29 with that wooden post,

1:14:30 even though they get pressure treated after 15,

1:14:32 maybe up to 20 years, the post eventually brought off.

1:14:36 I had in front of you kind of a one idea

1:14:39 where we could do some metal post with the key with fencing.

1:14:42 That time I know the council basically thought

1:14:44 that fencing was ugly, might say okay, but it's bluntly.

1:14:48 And he asked me to come back with maybe

1:14:49 with alternative type of fencing.

1:14:52 Since that time, like a draw, I just had a gentleman

1:14:59 come into my office and say,

1:15:01 he showed me a patronized iPhone,

1:15:02 he says, what do you think about this type of fencing?

1:15:04 I went, wow, that looks pretty nice.

1:15:06 This is located, I drove out there on the west side of Rock Creek itself on 2700 East.

1:15:13 I took pole line and took a ride and took north and went about two miles almost all the way to the rim.

1:15:21 Okay, so this is a metal post right here and these are wooden dowels and on the post he welded some little slats you might say or something.

1:15:31 are close up here and he just you know cut the dowel and it kind of a slice of

1:15:36 there and it bolts bolts it through. This fence here is not needed for a longer

1:15:41 trail system but this fence he said the property owner wanted to keep

1:15:45 remember keep dogs in or dogs out along the other. So that's why this metal no

1:15:50 climb fence as I call it is there. So this is a metal post and he said that I

1:15:55 found out the Snick River fence out of Window Idaho made this and you can make

1:16:01 this is currently a three-rail fencing and you can make it a four-rail fencing and

1:16:06 the four-rail fencing would kind of tie into the existing type of fence we have

1:16:09 right now along the canyon rim and the cost of this is you know the three

1:16:16 rail fences approximately 16 bucks a linear foot and four rail fences about

1:16:20 18 dollars a linear foot currently when I do those other all wooden posts you know

1:16:25 they're roughly between 18 to 20 dollars a linear foot so the price is real

1:16:29 as I mentioned we have a box in about 300 feet of sections, we thought we could add additional

1:16:39 fencing.

1:16:40 The main one was right behind the new Canyon Park West, just west of the visitor center.

1:16:45 And I did, if you read my staff report, you know, I was talking to Tina Looper, she's a

1:16:49 project administrator for Nielsen and Company, you know, she wanted me to make sure the Council

1:16:55 people knew that, that if we do additional fencing there, which we're proposed, they would

1:17:01 like to keep the same type of fencing we currently have now. Even though, you know, they said

1:17:06 they like this type of fencing, but they really want to be consistent with the fencing behind

1:17:11 their development is the same along their section anyway. So that would be from the

1:17:16 prime bridge all the way to Canyon Springs Road. We do have existing fence out right

1:17:21 right now and we're looking to add another 250 feet if I remember correctly out there.

1:17:28 So this fencing, you know, it's a kind of a Mont-Paul operation.

1:17:31 We can get it done.

1:17:33 So I want to know if the council was, you know, kind of think this is appropriate type

1:17:37 of alternate fencing.

1:17:38 If you don't think it's appropriate, we still can go back to the original fencing and we

1:17:42 just know that eventually 15, 20 years we're going to have to start replacing posts along

1:17:46 the way.

1:17:48 So I think that's what's the downside.

1:17:53 Give us a downside if you can think of this fencing.

1:17:57 I don't really, our staff really likes this. I know Mitch Travis likes that.

1:18:02 And one of my park guys that's really particular about fencing and stuff, he likes it.

1:18:08 So Mikey likes it, you might say. I look at the post and the post almost look wooden from a distance.

1:18:14 And if it's going to last longer, I mean, I'm kind of in there.

1:18:18 We hopefully, and it's similar cost,

1:18:21 similar cost, hopefully these metal posts

1:18:23 will never have to worry about rotten them off.

1:18:25 Well, at least we're around.

1:18:27 Yes, that's true.

1:18:28 So we really don't see a downside.

1:18:31 So let me ask this question.

1:18:33 So if we switch to this in the future,

1:18:36 as existing posts fail, would they

1:18:40 be replaced with the metal post?

1:18:42 Yes, we would go with that.

1:18:43 Because I would say that the downside of it

1:18:45 is it doesn't match.

1:18:47 So if you're, if you're, I mean, it's similar, but it's not identical.

1:18:52 And so if you're going down the trail and all of a sudden everything's wooden,

1:18:55 then now you've got a 40 foot section that's steel posts and rails and then it

1:19:00 switches back to the wooden.

1:19:02 So I, I, I'm supportive of it for the long term of, of cutting down on

1:19:07 maintenance, but it doesn't match.

1:19:13 I guess I'll add to that that we already have non matching.

1:19:16 If you get down to Canyon Crest, they're fencing is different.

1:19:20 And I walk the trail a lot, and I got to be honest with you, I don't.

1:19:25 I'm looking at the canyon.

1:19:27 Okay.

1:19:28 To me, I want it to look nice, but this is about safety.

1:19:33 And longevity is an important aspect of what we do.

1:19:37 We need things to last.

1:19:38 So you're looking for a thumbs up on us or a thumbing?

1:19:45 I don't think it requires action necessarily.

1:19:48 The one question is, what about the consistency around Canyon Park West?

1:19:57 Does council have any issues with trying to stay consistent around that for that particular

1:20:02 development?

1:20:03 I don't have a problem with staying consistent, but I would like to know what it would cost

1:20:07 to slowly replace that to this as we're going, I hate to put the money into the old type

1:20:13 of fencing if those other poles are going to start rotting in five years and we're going

1:20:17 going to be replacing them with this anyway.

1:20:19 So where's the breaking point on that?

1:20:22 I would have to go out there and kind of measure

1:20:24 what existing fence we have on from the prime bridge west.

1:20:29 Because I think part of it, there's

1:20:31 a couple of new sections that were just put up.

1:20:33 I think, Sean, you may have to help me just

1:20:35 in the past year or a couple of years.

1:20:37 So the new section was put up.

1:20:38 It's actually a new section that was put in

1:20:40 the last couple of months right there at the end of the.

1:20:44 But that rail fence doesn't go all the way to the bridge

1:20:46 because it has the lava rock wall to about where the visitor center is actually.

1:20:54 I would just be curious if we're making a change.

1:20:56 I'm not sure that we want to put in the old style knowing that we're going to be changing

1:21:01 the existing to the new style.

1:21:05 Does that make sense to understand what I'm on that part?

1:21:11 You know, I think maybe I'd like to kind of measure what we have out there now.

1:21:16 I think we'll try to figure out when it was built because there's still some of the original

1:21:18 I was, I think this section, the formerly prime bridge west, part of your young section.

1:21:25 Yeah.

1:21:26 Section.

1:21:27 Some of that, I can remember that was in 2001 or 2002, that was built.

1:21:31 So some of that would, you know, soon, there'll probably be, some of it can be riding, the base

1:21:36 is going to be riding off.

1:21:38 So there's some sections that we're probably going to be replacing here soon, but like mentioning,

1:21:42 you know, there's just a new section that was just put in earlier this, you know, this year.

1:21:47 section of probably put a year or two ago and that's going to be years before that

1:21:52 we would have to look at replacing that. But you know there might be section where

1:21:57 we could yank them out and save the wood and use it for somewhere else that

1:22:01 fencing if we want to look at that replace that. Travis? So I think that

1:22:06 Dennis brings up a really good point. There's going to be sections of trail

1:22:09 that were established about the same time and so we wouldn't be necessarily

1:22:12 replacing individual posts. A lot of the time we may be looking at full

1:22:17 sections that were, you know, as every budget goes forward, this might be a strategy where

1:22:22 we look at replacement of fencing along the Canyon Rim Trail in certain key areas where

1:22:27 the fence is beginning to, or the post beginning to, beginning to fail, we can look at replacing

1:22:33 those sections based upon some level of age or expected life, life of the post.

1:22:40 Do you think that Ms. Cooper would be willing to work with us a little bit if we're moving

1:22:46 to the new side and knowing that there might be a little bit that's mismatched for a short

1:22:51 period of time.

1:22:52 We're working in that direction.

1:22:54 Can we have that conversation to you?

1:22:56 Definitely could, yes.

1:22:57 Okay.

1:22:58 Thank you.

1:22:59 I think, Dennis, you have support for moving this direction, anything further from Council.

1:23:06 Ladies and gentlemen, is this your last?

1:23:08 Yes.

1:23:09 Good.

1:23:10 And I, before you start off, please, Mayor, last couple of meetings I've been to with,

1:23:15 I say this is my last meeting we do we've been doing a little celebration

1:23:18 but we won't do that part Travis okay sorry that's something else I don't want

1:23:23 to know okay but I have just a little popper to show okay that's it okay now

1:23:30 well I I just want to say it's it's absolutely been a privilege I had the

1:23:36 opportunity couple of us had the opportunity actually work with you not

1:23:39 in this capacity but other capacities I know that we're gonna have some other

1:23:44 events. Wednesday we're going to have a retirement party and then I think you're

1:23:48 going to have a couple others. Only one part I know. At least one other. But I

1:23:54 would just ask the audience and council if we could just stand and give

1:24:00 Dennis some applause.

1:24:02 Now you're supposed to ride away in the sunset on your bike. I will be doing that

1:24:17 Friday. I have to tell you honestly I don't think I'll work a full day Friday.

1:24:21 No, okay, just no, I believe in early Wendy don't count on much from me much Friday

1:24:28 Well again Dennis, thank you for your your leadership and your friendship

1:24:39 Next item on the agenda is

1:24:44 consideration to request to reject a

1:24:46 a bid for the 2015 3rd Avenue West Improvement Project.

1:24:52 John Keaton.

1:24:53 Welcome, sir.

1:24:54 Thank you, Mayor and Council.

1:24:56 This past winter, EHM helped, or did design,

1:25:02 our zone maintenance project this season for 3rd Avenue West.

1:25:05 And Tim Busser is here in the audience as well.

1:25:07 So if we have questions for him, he can answer them.

1:25:12 This year, we planned on a project

1:25:14 that included stormwater, sewer, and surface repair

1:25:18 on Third Avenue West, which is west of Washington,

1:25:21 south of Addison, and lines right up with our BMX Park.

1:25:25 So it gives you an idea of where we're at.

1:25:28 In May, we put the project out to bid,

1:25:33 and at the end of May, we received one responsive bid

1:25:38 from Idaho Sand in gravel.

1:25:41 The engineers estimate was 520,000, approximately 520,000,

1:25:55 and the actual bid came in at 850,000.

1:26:09 It's my feeling it's just a sign of the time right now.

1:26:14 It's a tough bidding environment.

1:26:15 And my recommendation is that we reject this bid.

1:26:20 Thank you, John.

1:26:21 Chris, talk.

1:26:22 John, just looking through the particulars of labor

1:26:26 material that bulged out the most or everything. One of the biggest things that

1:26:34 caught our eye was the excavation and grading. If you'd introduce yourself sir, come on up.

1:26:44 Good evening Tim Bosser with the HM Engineers. It is definitely out of line as

1:26:53 far as some of the numbers and I want to emphasize I don't think anybody's

1:27:00 trying to gouge anybody. It's one of those things that Pido Sand was the only

1:27:06 responsive bidder and they are very busy with a lot of projects and I think for

1:27:12 the most part a large part of this was to cover over time because if they're

1:27:17 gonna bid it and get it they're gonna have to pay people to stay late so but

1:27:22 it is outside of the anticipated prices that we thought were reasonable and I

1:27:29 I don't believe John has it in his budget.

1:27:32 Thanks, Tim.

1:27:33 I hope we recommend her reject the bid.

1:27:38 Motion on the floor.

1:27:39 Second.

1:27:40 By Chris talking at seconded, Vice-President Hawkins

1:27:43 to reject the bid for the 2015 Third Avenue

1:27:46 West Improvement Project, anything further

1:27:49 on that motion council?

1:27:51 Lee, I.

1:27:53 I'm sorry.

1:27:54 I'm sorry, I didn't see the light.

1:27:56 Thank you, John.

1:27:57 So what's the plan from here, then,

1:27:59 If this is rejected, where do we go, what's the future hold for us?

1:28:04 We have a few options.

1:28:05 What we'd like to do is go back to the contractor and see if we can negotiate.

1:28:10 And we do have an opportunity in the code to go back and

1:28:13 just see if we can find a better price on the market.

1:28:17 We can't even get close, you don't have to explore other options.

1:28:20 So that'll be our first choice.

1:28:22 Okay, thank you.

1:28:23 Yeah.

1:28:25 Anything further council?

1:28:27 We'll actually look at the light to this thing.

1:28:29 the aye of the roll call vote. Don Hall? Yes. Suzanne Hawkins? Yes. Jim

1:29:35 I'd like to reconvene the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council, it is June 22nd, and about 1833 hours, so 633 in the afternoon.

1:29:46 Next item on the agenda is consideration of a request to enter into a contract with Phil Cushlan, Cushlan and Associates,

1:29:56 for the Canyon Springs Pedestrian Enhancement Project Community Involvement Plan, for the

1:30:03 amount of $48,585, and we have Troy Vitek. Welcome Troy.

1:30:09 Evening Council Members, Troy Vitek, Insisticity Engineer, and I'm before you tonight to make

1:30:15 a recommendation to enter in a contract with Phil Christian, that's previously stated.

1:30:23 Bill has put together an estimate of what we believe to be the scope of work necessary

1:30:27 to delve into this highly public topic.

1:30:30 His scope includes the breakdowns for items such as project planning, pre-design, design

1:30:37 construction, and post-construction.

1:30:41 The estimate before you places a dollar value associated with those items will be dependent

1:30:46 upon the total number of meetings associated with those items.

1:30:49 So if it's a larger public process, there probably will be more meetings that may change

1:30:55 slightly.

1:30:56 So this really is an estimate, but we feel it's a good estimate.

1:31:01 When this item was first discussed in our group, there were four people with four completely

1:31:04 different opinions.

1:31:06 Then when this was brought for the first time before council discussions, we soon found

1:31:10 that there were some passionate people that would like to be heard and considered.

1:31:17 At that time, we was determined that we should approach the council about the possibility of

1:31:20 hiring a third party consultant, and I recommended Phil Christian, and I've been in discussions

1:31:25 with him.

1:31:26 I contact Phil because he's an experienced negotiator, and he's capable of what I would

1:31:32 say teasing the values out of the citizens that want to participate in this.

1:31:37 So he can really set the tone and the charter for what we want to do here as part of this

1:31:44 project.

1:31:46 He can build consensus even on the toughest of topics and the variability of outcomes.

1:31:52 And I believe that this project will be critical asset to the future of the City Trail system

1:31:59 with an estimate currently valued at over $6 million that was previously mentioned.

1:32:04 And we want to make sure that the citizens are supportive of whatever decision we made.

1:32:11 So I have filled in my audience tonight if you'd like to ask any questions.

1:32:16 that I would recommend that we award a contract with them

1:32:18 when we begin the pre-design process.

1:32:22 Thank you, Troy.

1:32:23 Chris, talking.

1:32:24 Well, I would like to have Phil come up

1:32:26 and kind of hold the council's hand

1:32:29 on what sort of the scope of the project

1:32:34 is going to have some intense public input and pressures.

1:32:39 Hope you will use the city's video streaming

1:32:44 whenever possible for meetings.

1:32:46 Electronic means whatever possible,

1:32:48 but how are you really going to advise the council

1:32:52 along the way instead of just presenting

1:32:54 a final package to this bill?

1:32:56 If I might welcome Mr. Kushner to the city council.

1:32:59 We're on our council members, again, my name is Phil Kushner.

1:33:04 Again, as Troy indicated, he did contact me

1:33:07 and so we've got this little project out here

1:33:09 that nobody seems to care about.

1:33:11 And we might want to have somebody drum up

1:33:14 some interest in it.

1:33:16 And so what you saw in your packet

1:33:19 is basically my thinking of what I

1:33:22 perceive to be an extremely critical, highly

1:33:25 visible project with a variety of stakeholders and probably one

1:33:30 that everybody's going to have an opinion about.

1:33:33 And so I think what we've laid out

1:33:36 in several iterations with the engineering staff

1:33:41 is maybe more aggressive than you've had in the past.

1:33:46 I've listened to your previous conversation about this,

1:33:49 and I think one of the things that you'll see there

1:33:52 is the development of a charter for this advisory group

1:33:58 that we're talking about, so that this group, the city council,

1:34:02 can kind of put some sideboards around where the conversation goes.

1:34:06 So rather than just turn on this bigoted public opinion,

1:34:09 is let it run.

1:34:10 I think it's important that you kind of go through the process

1:34:13 of determining for yourselves just kind of what

1:34:17 you want to see this project be and then

1:34:19 garner public participation, at least in the realm

1:34:23 of the possibilities that you see our legitimate.

1:34:29 Again, as has been presented in that scope,

1:34:32 we're coming back to you a lot.

1:34:34 we've suggesting that while there's a design process going out here that we come back and

1:34:41 give the council an opportunity to steer us one way or the other, we've looked at a variety

1:34:48 of ways of media outreach both in terms of your own systems here but possibly also maybe

1:34:58 some purchased media with newspaper in terms of display ads during the construction period

1:35:04 Also, maybe they're working with the television station to get some kind of features focusing

1:35:10 on the people working on the project.

1:35:12 Try to create some broad ownership of the community in the outcome that you're going

1:35:18 to generate.

1:35:19 Talking to Troy, it looks like this is like a two-year endeavor here, probably if we're

1:35:26 lucky.

1:35:27 This is going to take some time.

1:35:30 But I think this is a major piece of work, one that is going to be highly visible and difficult

1:35:38 to build.

1:35:39 You know, this is not elbow room from Daniel Boone, this is a real tight spot.

1:35:46 And so there's going to be inconvenience.

1:35:48 And so trying to get as much understanding of the ultimate outcome, being upfront about

1:35:55 the struggles that you're going to have in building this in this difficult spot.

1:36:00 I think it's going to maybe keep some people from this podium in a less favorable conversation

1:36:07 with you if we can keep them on board ahead of time.

1:36:09 So that was our goal.

1:36:12 I think probably going to need to be flexible in terms of we're going to learn things as

1:36:17 we go along.

1:36:18 But again, this is a project that we're going to need your ongoing participation and support

1:36:26 on.

1:36:27 So looking forward to moving ahead with this, if you're willing to approve this, and we'll

1:36:35 get rolling as soon as we can, in terms of the schedule of the project.

1:36:39 I'm happy to answer any questions that you might have.

1:36:42 Do I have any questions for either Phil or Troy or our city manager?

1:36:48 Sean Berger.

1:36:49 Phil, what kind of a timeline do you think this is to shepherd the, to herd the cats?

1:36:57 Well, I think, again, early on there's going to be quite a bit of work just in terms of generating this advisory group and empowering it in a manner that is consistent with your perspective.

1:37:13 That's going to be fairly aggressive work.

1:37:18 One of the things that Troy wanted to add was helping them

1:37:23 modify their scope of work for the engineering work.

1:37:29 Because one of the things we talked about was ultimately when

1:37:32 you get to construction, the contract

1:37:36 needs to have somebody who is lived with this project and

1:37:40 with all of the stakeholders.

1:37:42 They've got in their cell phone number.

1:37:45 They're out there every day working with the problems

1:37:48 that are going to arise.

1:37:49 So we're wanting to make sure that whoever bids this project

1:37:52 understands the critical component that that is going to be.

1:37:57 I see there's going to be quite a bit of work early on,

1:38:00 probably as some of the engineering work is kind of defined.

1:38:05 And then you'll probably slack off

1:38:09 through the latter part of the construction period,

1:38:12 but I think we're gonna have quite a bit of time

1:38:15 with each other in a short time.

1:38:18 That answer your question adequately, sir.

1:38:21 I don't know in terms of specifics.

1:38:24 Thank you.

1:38:26 Any other questions, Council?

1:38:30 Do we have any directions?

1:38:31 Suzanne, pockets.

1:38:32 Yes, I would move that we enter into a contract

1:38:36 with Phil Cushlan for the amount of $48,585

1:38:41 for the Canyon Spring Road Pedestrian Enhancement Project

1:38:45 Community Involvement Plan.

1:38:49 Very nice.

1:38:51 Second, then.

1:38:52 We have a motion on the floor by Suzanne Hawkins,

1:38:53 seconded by Chris Talkington, as stated.

1:38:57 I just want to go on record that I

1:38:59 tend to be somewhat hesitant to have consultants and the like

1:39:07 come in, because I've seen too many times with some

1:39:12 organizations where they have them come in and then the plan gets put up on a shelf and never

1:39:17 utilized. But my experience with Cushland and Associates, especially going through our strategic

1:39:23 planning, I've been on council for nine years now and we've had a series of strategic plans since

1:39:30 I've been involved with the city. And by far the most comprehensive and workable plan that we've had

1:39:39 and had the most community involvement in, in my opinion,

1:39:44 was the one that was helped and led by Cushman Associates.

1:39:47 So is that trust factor that I have that makes me feel good

1:39:53 about this contract bill?

1:39:56 Anything further, Council?

1:39:59 You have a roll call vote?

1:40:01 Susan Hawkins?

1:40:02 Yes.

1:40:02 Jim Munn?

1:40:03 Yes.

1:40:04 Sean Berger?

1:40:04 Yes.

1:40:05 Chris Tockington?

1:40:06 Yes.

1:40:06 Don Hall?

1:40:07 Yes.

1:40:08 Motion passes.

1:40:09 5-0.

1:40:10 Thank you, Phil.

1:40:11 Thank you, Troy.

1:40:13 Next item on the agenda is consideration of a request

1:40:16 to reject all bids for the Bio-Tower-Oder control procurement

1:40:22 package.

1:40:23 Troy, you did that.

1:40:25 Who did that?

1:40:26 Evening Council.

1:40:29 Tonight I'm bringing, well, I'll start it back at the beginning.

1:40:34 Several weeks ago, I was going to bring forward a recommendation

1:40:37 to award this bid to ECS Environmental Solutions Company

1:40:50 in the amount of $99,000.

1:40:52 At that time, we received a protest letter.

1:40:57 We sent out on the letter of intent

1:40:59 to award to these people,

1:41:00 and Bio-Air sent us a letter of protest.

1:41:02 And before we get going too far,

1:41:05 before I ask you guys to recommend it,

1:41:07 we step back and we want to say,

1:41:09 well, what's the protest about?

1:41:11 So we had, you see, it's too impaled,

1:41:13 look at the information on all three bidders.

1:41:17 So ECS felt to cement three things,

1:41:21 but the bid documents have it and says,

1:41:24 for minor things that doesn't affect schedule or price,

1:41:27 you can actually negotiate those afterwards.

1:41:30 So they weren't a big deal, but the BioWare brought up

1:41:33 one concern of theirs is one of the documents,

1:41:37 one portion of the contract says,

1:41:38 you have to list your previous experience

1:41:40 show that you're capable of doing this. And they listed several projects. And I

1:41:47 aware says no those aren't theirs. So when we got into the to the nitty-gritty of

1:41:52 it, ECS was co-owned by a parent company and they broke off and somebody else

1:42:00 bought them. So they listed kind of co-joint, constructed type stuff but it

1:42:07 wasn't theirs specifically. CH2PIL feels that they have the knowledge necessary to do this

1:42:15 kind of work. You can go through it, but when you get into protests, it can drag out to

1:42:21 a very, very long process. So you go to BioWare, the very next bidder of 149,000, and they

1:42:28 had several things, but they listed many things on their bidding documents and took exceptions

1:42:35 to them.

1:42:36 Only time you take exceptions to a bid, essentially you're not bidding apples and apples, so you

1:42:40 have to look at those very specifically and say you aren't those reasonable.

1:42:44 The third one, or zero, they just submit the full bid for them.

1:42:48 They just gave us a packet of essentially, like, here's an example of what we put in,

1:42:53 but there was no sign agreement, no bid bond, nothing like that.

1:42:56 So they're completely out.

1:42:58 So what we do, we would come to you tonight.

1:43:00 we'd like to reject all bids at this time.

1:43:05 With the intent, I believe, to go and re-bid it here

1:43:08 shortly in the next little while,

1:43:10 so we can start the project over,

1:43:12 and we will take these considerations into the bid

1:43:14 documents so that they're reflected so that all three

1:43:20 of these people will meet those requirements

1:43:22 and will incorporate what we believe

1:43:25 is acceptable language in the new contract as well,

1:43:29 so everybody should be eligible to be awarded in the future.

1:43:33 But this is the first step.

1:43:34 We have to reject the bids before we can set them

1:43:36 out for a re-bit.

1:43:38 Thank you, Troy.

1:43:39 Do we have any questions for Troy?

1:43:42 What's this do for our timeline?

1:43:43 It does push it back.

1:43:45 Right now, I don't believe there's any odors down there.

1:43:48 More than has always been down there.

1:43:50 I know it stinks, but I don't think

1:43:52 there's anything extraordinary as the temperatures get

1:43:55 up this weekend.

1:43:55 I don't know what that's going to do,

1:43:57 but it does push it back so on once.

1:44:00 move to reject all business associated with bidding of the order of

1:44:03 reduction in a located to Kenya spring for the engineers suggestion second motion

1:44:10 on floor by Chris talking to second by Sean Barreger

1:44:15 all bit says stated anything further on those mode on that motion council Lee

1:44:20 Island roll call vote please Jim Munn yes Sean Barreger yes Chris talking yes

1:44:27 Don Hall yes Suzanne Hoffman yes motion passes 50. Thank you try next item on

1:44:34 the agenda is consideration of the request to adopt an ordinance for zoning

1:44:39 title amendment amending title 10 chapter 12 section 2.5 b regarding the

1:44:46 timing for required improvements for conveyance plan proposed ordinance will

1:44:51 be 3098. We have Renee, Caraway Johnson. Welcome Renee.

1:44:56 Good evening, Mayor Hall Council. I'm here this evening to finish up a code amendment process.

1:45:03 In order to change the code, it requires a public hearing before the Planning and Zoning

1:45:07 Commission. That occurred April 27th. God bless you.

1:45:12 That occurred April 27th. The Commission did hold a public hearing on this request. There

1:45:17 There was actually no public comment.

1:45:21 Commission had deliberations where they stated they had some concerns regarding just leaving

1:45:27 a carte blanc change but they went ahead and they did recommend approval of this.

1:45:35 All members voted to go forward.

1:45:38 The second part of this request is a public hearing before the city council for a code

1:45:42 amendment.

1:45:43 Council heard this request on May 26th.

1:45:46 You did hold the public hearing.

1:45:47 There was one person that spoke had some questions on some parks and move requirements.

1:45:53 There wasn't an issue with that.

1:45:55 You ultimately did recommend approval of this document.

1:46:00 So upon conclusion, as per your request, staff is prepared an ordinance that's in your packet

1:46:07 and we're asking for adoption so that this code can be changed.

1:46:10 Thank you, Renee.

1:46:11 And as always an ordinance means second and final suspension,

1:46:17 third and final thank you and suspension of the rules.

1:46:19 Council, any questions?

1:46:23 Direction from council?

1:46:28 Your turn.

1:46:28 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:46:30 Okay.

1:46:31 I saw your hand of the way.

1:46:32 Well, I was waiting to make sure nobody else wanted it.

1:46:35 So, okay, so I would like to move that.

1:46:38 We, do I suspend the rules first?

1:46:40 Suspend the rules and put ordinance 3098 on third and final.

1:46:46 heard and final by title only do I need to read more about the

1:46:50 amendment is that good that's good okay motion on the floor by

1:46:57 Suzanne Hawkins seconded by Sean Barrett anything further on that

1:47:02 motion council the island will call

1:47:06 please Sean Burger yes yes yes yes yes Jim

1:47:12 yes motion passes five zero the island ordinance of the city

1:47:17 Council of the City of 2012 Idaho,

1:47:19 embedding 24 City Code Section 10, 12, 2.5B

1:47:24 by permitting the City Council to require construction

1:47:26 of streets and utilities before development

1:47:29 of conveyance plans.

1:47:31 Stand for a motion council.

1:47:33 Move passage of 3098.

1:47:35 Second.

1:47:36 Motion on floor by Chris Tockman,

1:47:38 seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.

1:47:42 Anything further on that motion council?

1:47:45 The aye, the roll call vote please.

1:47:47 Chris Tockington.

1:47:47 Yes.

1:47:48 Yes.

1:47:49 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:47:50 Yes.

1:47:51 Jim Munn.

1:47:52 Yes.

1:47:53 John Berriger.

1:47:54 Yes.

1:47:56 Motion passes 5-0.

1:47:57 Next item on the agenda.

1:47:59 Discussion on the creation of a comprehensive plan update technical advisory committee.

1:48:04 We have Renee Keraway-Johnson again.

1:48:06 Welcome.

1:48:07 Thanks.

1:48:08 Thank you.

1:48:09 I'm actually here today for two reasons on this request.

1:48:11 A one is to ask the Council's direction on the creation and assembly of the advisory committee

1:48:17 with a comp plan update.

1:48:19 And the second is just to give you a brief update on where we're at in that beginning process.

1:48:24 I'll start with a little bit of history.

1:48:27 About a month ago, the Council approved a contract with Logan Simpson Design to prepare a comprehensive

1:48:33 plan update for the city.

1:48:35 We have been working with them towards organizing a kickoff on this project.

1:48:40 Stevenson recommended in their scope of services that the city create a technical advisory committee

1:48:47 consisting of city staff and also an advisory committee made up of residents and representatives from city council

1:48:54 Planning and planning and zoning to help guide and direct the comp plan through this

1:48:59 anticipating about a year process

1:49:02 Logan Simpson also recommends that the advisory committee group be no larger than 15

1:49:07 They suggest the committee be made up of representatives from stakeholder groups throughout the community such as the Twin Falls school district, CSI, the county, St. Luke's.

1:49:17 Staff has discussed the role of the advisory committee with the mayor and the chairman of the Planning and Zoning Commission and have determined those should be representation on this committee.

1:49:29 Mayor Hall, has asked that Councilman Lanting

1:49:35 and Councilwoman Mills-Soyka be part of the advisory committee

1:49:38 and Planning and Zoning Chairman Frank

1:49:41 has asked commissioners Munoz and Higley

1:49:45 to also be a part of the advisory committee.

1:49:48 Every advisory committee meeting will be notified

1:49:51 as an open meeting so that the public

1:49:54 as well as people serving on other city boards

1:49:57 and commissions will be notified and encouraged

1:49:59 to come and participate in this process.

1:50:02 Staff also believes that the member

1:50:04 of the Consultant Selection Committee,

1:50:07 which was the group who reviewed and made the recommendation

1:50:10 of which the RFQ applicants were to be interviewed,

1:50:13 should also be part of the advisory committee.

1:50:16 They have already provided valuable input

1:50:18 from the beginning of the process,

1:50:20 and from what we are understanding,

1:50:23 they are encouraged and would like to get

1:50:27 participate in this process.

1:50:30 Those members who served on that committee were Kevin Dane Bradwheels and Kevin Mailer

1:50:36 with these seven, which is those three and then the four P&Z and City Council potential committee members staff recommends the following advisory committee membership

1:50:46 And I do have just always jumping in

1:50:56 You can see this group consists of the two council people, the two planning and zoning

1:51:05 commissioners, the three off of the selection committee. I will tell you I've had communication

1:51:11 with the Twin Falls County Commissioners as well as the city of Kimberly. They have both

1:51:17 made a recommendation to me for people to be placed on this committee. The other folks

1:51:23 were kind of sending out some messages and see where we might end up. Do you have any comments

1:51:32 on the list? Anybody have any questions or comments on the list? I just, no, go ahead.

1:51:40 I just think it kind of makes sense. I like the broad perspective, especially when we start

1:51:45 talking about the county city of Kimberly and a lot of the stakeholders on this list.

1:51:54 Actually, the city of Kimberly and the county were both two stakeholders that I had contacted

1:52:01 right away and without any hesitation they both had volunteered somebody to serve.

1:52:08 I'm necessarily volunteering but somebody got volunteered.

1:52:11 I'm very encouraged and exciting about the opportunity to take a look at our community

1:52:16 again and be a participant.

1:52:21 So I'm kind of at that point, I don't know if you want to provide direction on how to

1:52:25 proceed with the selection of this group.

1:52:28 If you want staff to go ahead and contact some folks, come up with the list and then come

1:52:34 back to you with that list for final confirmation or just have us proceed.

1:52:40 Well I think Travis has some comments and I know Chris does but yeah let's start with

1:52:45 that.

1:52:46 So I think it's also important to recognize that Ryan Higley, who is recommended for planning

1:52:49 and zoning also represents the area of impact and so that it could be the case that he could

1:52:55 serve as the representative for the county.

1:52:58 That may not be the person that the county commissioners have selected to move forward,

1:53:03 but if you want to keep and limit it to 15 people, that may create for greater diversity

1:53:08 and greater opportunity for more people to participate.

1:53:10 As you can see, the line item 15 is that we have St. Luke's, Idaho Power, Business

1:53:17 plus seat open. We're trying to find someone or multiple

1:53:21 someone's maybe from those hats. You'll also notice that we have an area of impact at area

1:53:26 number 14. And having county representation is really important to the process. But I would

1:53:31 also say that those other groups also add value to that process. So I think it's important

1:53:36 that when we look at represent, represent is from very specific groups that we want to try

1:53:41 to spread that out as much as possible.

1:53:45 Chris Docking?

1:53:46 I guess I'll just follow on Travis's comments

1:53:50 because I'm concerned this is almost an unmanageable size

1:53:54 of a group.

1:53:55 Public administration, I think the optimal size of a group

1:53:58 is somewhere around 9 to 12 maximum, and that's felt as up.

1:54:03 Here I see, especially with line 15,

1:54:05 we could end up with 20 people.

1:54:08 And I'm just saying that we can consolidate

1:54:11 some of those in, into one from several of the categories on here, I would be supportive

1:54:18 of a little smaller group.

1:54:21 I'd like to respond to that comment.

1:54:24 Logan Simpson didn't indicate that they wanted 15, they just said no more than, so I think

1:54:30 it leaves us with an opportunity to clearly have less than, and we agree with you.

1:54:36 Okay.

1:54:37 Yeah, I think that I think we might be able to find some folks that can wear multiple hats

1:54:44 here that could condense it down to the 10 or 12. Is that what you're thinking, Chris?

1:54:48 9 to 12 would be awesome, I think.

1:54:51 Okay. So maybe we'll leave that into your hands, but I think I would like it to come

1:54:54 back to council with the names attached to him because it is a commission committee of

1:55:02 the council and we'll approve that and then move forward. Travis, you

1:55:07 crowned at that. You did it. Oh, okay. You were just frowning.

1:55:13 So, um, what's that? It's smiling inside. Okay. Um, yeah. Okay.

1:55:22 As far as direction, just a little update, we've been working really closely with

1:55:26 Logan Simpson and we are expecting to have our first kickoff group meeting in

1:55:32 partnership with the City Hall kickoff as well as downtown revitalization a little bit of

1:55:40 that on the second Twin Falls tonight group meeting on July 8th so we're really looking

1:55:48 forward to that.

1:55:50 On that note we would like to bring that list back to you either June 29th or July 6th so

1:55:56 that we have that committee started.

1:55:58 and since the group will be here the eighth, the ninth,

1:56:01 and the tenth, they'll be doing some

1:56:03 inter-stakeholder interviews on the ninth

1:56:06 and partly on the tenth.

1:56:08 And so they're also gonna present

1:56:10 to the Planning and Zoning Commission on the eighth,

1:56:12 so they are off and running.

1:56:15 So I'm gonna get to Travis in just a moment.

1:56:18 But nothing precludes from other folks

1:56:22 not being able to come to the meeting and have input.

1:56:26 We're just trying to have a manageable group to guide through this process and these will

1:56:32 all be publicized and be public meetings noticed every time.

1:56:38 Perfect.

1:56:39 So this is an example of how we live in an ever changing environment.

1:56:45 The meeting that Renee just talked about for you on July 8th that we had a conversation

1:56:50 this morning was moved to July 15th and we will be spreading and providing more details

1:56:57 as that goes forward.

1:56:59 So it's actually part of my report a concept that we have later, but we will not be able

1:57:06 to do it on July 8th and we're looking to reschedule for July 15th and you will see what that means

1:57:13 in a minute.

1:57:14 And we were going to do that in the building or in the banner building, because I put that

1:57:21 on my calendar already, so I have to change that.

1:57:23 I still, those folks, Logan Simpson, are planning on coming, they already have their flight, so

1:57:28 we'll do do, we're going to do our kickoff on July 8th, so please come, we'll keep you

1:57:35 posted.

1:57:36 Very good, very good.

1:57:39 Direction given, thank you.

1:57:41 I feel good.

1:57:42 Thank you, Renee.

1:57:43 your name. Next item on the agenda is public input and or items from City Manager City Council. So first we will open it up to the public. If there's anything that you would like to engage your Council with briefly. This is time to do it. Not anything that's on the agenda. We have a couple of

1:58:02 hearing is still coming out.

1:58:04 So anybody from the public like to engage the council?

1:58:08 I see no one coming for it.

1:58:10 We'll move it over to the city manager.

1:58:12 Mr. Mayor, members of the council just two quick items.

1:58:15 The first is one has already been mentioned,

1:58:17 but again, a reminder of Dennis Boyer's retirement

1:58:21 celebration that will be at three o'clock

1:58:23 this Wednesday in city park.

1:58:26 We will be doing a ceremony as well as a little cake

1:58:30 and punch and really time to celebrate Dennis's 34-year career with the City of Twin Falls.

1:58:36 The second item is what was just briefly mentioned is we are looking at having what we're calling

1:58:43 a city fair in which we have lots of different issues going on in the city right now. Many

1:58:50 of them that are going to either need or have some public component. And so we thought that

1:58:56 we would use the summer concert series on July 15th to really host an open house at the

1:59:03 Banner Building.

1:59:04 With the focus being not only the comp plan, but we're also going to be talking about in

1:59:09 the primary conversation is the very first community conversation regarding the appearance

1:59:15 of the city hall facility as well as additional conversations with OTAC and the urban renewal

1:59:22 agency about the design of the downtown project.

1:59:27 In addition, there's some other great things going on in the city that we're trying to

1:59:30 really get the word out where we're going to have a series of informational session,

1:59:35 or booths, if you will, with information available about water conservation and the importance

1:59:40 of recycling and our sustainability message that we're moving forward, our new Sherrow

1:59:44 program.

1:59:45 And so it's really going to be this opportunity in an open house that will start in the mid-afternoon,

1:59:52 And it will run through the summer concert, so as individuals are going to the concert,

1:59:57 they'll also have the opportunity to come into the banner building, have some refreshments,

2:00:01 and also grab some additional city information.

2:00:04 So again, we'll continue to share more about that as we develop that.

2:00:07 But right now, it's tentatively scheduled for July 15th.

2:00:11 Thank you, Travis.

2:00:12 Can I?

2:00:13 Can I?

2:00:14 Oh, I have a question for Travis on that.

2:00:16 Sure.

2:00:17 May I?

2:00:18 You may?

2:00:19 Thank you.

2:00:20 possibility if the youth council is available to have a space in that where they can promote

2:00:25 what they are doing right now.

2:00:28 They have a video with a little TV and some flyers to promote new membership for their

2:00:34 group.

2:00:35 Yeah, I don't see this problem.

2:00:36 Thank you.

2:00:37 Sorry, Susan, I thought you were just putting your light on to speak.

2:00:41 All right, thank you, Travis.

2:00:44 Anything from our city council?

2:00:50 I wanted to state, you mentioned the water conservation program that we were doing.

2:00:55 I was in the movies yesterday, I'm going to a movie forever, and there was Mandy Thompson

2:01:00 up on the big screen talking about water conservation.

2:01:03 I've seen that commercial numerous times.

2:01:05 I think it's been very effective.

2:01:07 So kudos to her and someone else that's probably in the audience somewhere that's trashed together.

2:01:15 Did Josh Lee.

2:01:16 So anyway, really highly public, so appreciate that.

2:01:20 All right, moving on now to the public hearing portion.

2:01:22 If you're here for the public hearing, we have two of them.

2:01:26 We start off with the applicant generally,

2:01:29 followed by staff report, these questions and answers

2:01:33 for the council, and then we will turn it over

2:01:35 and open it up to the public,

2:01:37 and give you a couple of minutes each

2:01:38 to come up and testify if you wish.

2:01:41 So the first item under public hearing is consideration

2:01:44 of a request for a zoning district change

2:01:47 and zoning map amendment from R4 to C1 for 2.4 acres located at 1629 Locust Street North

2:01:57 for Christie J Williams. And I believe we have Adam Hess is going to be making the presentation.

2:02:07 So Adam, you have up to 15 minutes, sir. The floor is yours.

2:02:11 Welcome.

2:02:12 Thank you, City Council. We're here tonight. The Williams family is asking for your approval

2:02:17 to rezone their property at 1629 Locust Street North from currently zoned to R4 and like

2:02:24 get it zoned to C1. Properties approximately two acres, just over two acres and currently

2:02:31 surrounded on all four sides by other properties zoned C1. The rezone meets all the city's

2:02:38 compro- meets the city's comprehensive plan. We don't have a sale currently on it but we

2:02:45 do have a list of for sale and we'd like to bring it to the council now for approval

2:02:48 So when we get a sale done, that's already taken care of.

2:02:52 We have the Williams family here.

2:02:53 If you have any questions for us, that's really it though.

2:02:59 Very good.

2:02:59 Do we have any questions for Mr. Hass before we turn it over

2:03:02 to his staff report by Jonathan Spandlove?

2:03:06 No questions this time, but you might stand by.

2:03:08 Mr. Spandlove, welcome.

2:03:10 Thank you, Mayor.

2:03:11 All members of the council.

2:03:14 So pretty much summarize what it is.

2:03:17 It's a remaining piece.

2:03:19 It's centered around a bunch of C1 properties right off of Pole Line and Locust.

2:03:24 Home Depot is to the east.

2:03:28 Harbor freights to the north with Deseret Book.

2:03:30 The west has some storage units and those are all taken all done years ago.

2:03:36 So this is the old basically house that's been there for quite a while.

2:03:40 Just to let things develop around it.

2:03:43 The 2009 Comprehensive Plan and Future Land Use Map designate this area as a commercial

2:03:50 retail, how is that one in red?

2:03:57 So on May 27th, the Planning and Zoning Commission held the public hearing.

2:04:02 There was one public comment, there's a question where this is located by a resident nearby.

2:04:09 Besides that, there's no other concerns.

2:04:11 Upon conclusion of the public portion of that hearing, the Commission held deliberations and

2:04:15 concluded that the request is in conformance with the comprehensive plan and the extent

2:04:19 to nature of changing the zoning of this property to see one would allow development that would

2:04:23 to be compatible with and not detract from the surrounding property, not the surrounding

2:04:26 area. Commissioner Tatum made a motion and commissioner Boyd seconded that motion. All members voted

2:04:32 in favor and then conclusion staff concurs with the commission's recommendation and recommends

2:04:37 the request be granted as presented.

2:04:40 Thank you Jonathan. Any questions for either Jonathan or Mr. Hess? I see no questions. So

2:04:48 at this time I'm going to open up public testimony for this item. Is there anyone from

2:04:53 in the public that would like to address the council

2:04:56 on this item.

2:04:59 We are closing the public hearing portion of this request

2:05:03 or this item and turn it over council for their questions

2:05:06 and or direction.

2:05:07 Chris, talk.

2:05:08 I would move to approve the zoning district change

2:05:11 and zoning map amendment from R4 to C1

2:05:14 for the 2.4 plus or minus acres at 1629 Locust Street North.

2:05:20 I will second that.

2:05:21 Motion on four by Chris talking to and seconded

2:05:23 by Jim Munn as stated.

2:05:25 Anything further on that motion council?

2:05:28 Leyla Roll call vote please.

2:05:30 Chris Talkington?

2:05:31 Yes.

2:05:33 Don Hall?

2:05:34 Yes.

2:05:34 Suzanne Hawkins?

2:05:35 Yes.

2:05:36 Jim Munn?

2:05:37 Yes.

2:05:38 Sean Berger?

2:05:39 Yes.

2:05:40 Motion passes five to zero.

2:05:41 Driven by that place numerous times

2:05:43 and wondered what was going to happen eventually.

2:05:45 So, very welcome.

2:05:49 Ladies have a good evening.

2:05:51 Next item on the agenda is consideration request

2:05:54 for the annexation of 53.38 plus or minus,

2:05:58 acres located at the southeast corner of 2700 East,

2:06:03 also known as Sunway Drive North and North College Road West,

2:06:08 extended for the Twin Falls School District.

2:06:11 We have Mr. Brad Wills coming forward, and welcome Brad.

2:06:17 Good evening, Mayor and Council.

2:06:35 So what's before you tonight,

2:06:37 earlier we had come with a conveyance plaid,

2:06:40 where we had a larger portion here,

2:06:43 that we split off into two lots,

2:06:48 so the school district could sell the south lot.

2:06:52 The plan here is to annex this land,

2:06:56 at this point, rather than deal with the county on it

2:07:00 and the city we decided the first thing we wanted to do

2:07:03 was to annex it into the city,

2:07:06 and then we will come back to you

2:07:08 with a preliminary final plat,

2:07:11 Again, sub-dividing this land into a future school's parcel

2:07:16 and then create the Sunway parcels

2:07:20 that we're going to, as a school district,

2:07:23 transfer ownership to the Twin Falls city

2:07:26 as we agreed to in past agreements.

2:07:29 So that's basically what we're doing right now.

2:07:32 The city limit is right here and right here.

2:07:35 So we're just expanding that

2:07:37 with our nice, slow, controllable growth.

2:07:41 Thank you. If there's any questions, are there any questions for Mr.

2:07:45 Wells? We don't often give petitions for annexation. This is a new one. I think this

2:07:51 year. I see no questions, Mr. Wells, but either maybe one in the future. Jonathan

2:07:59 Spindler. Welcome back. Thank you, Mayor Humman and members of the Council. Brad's

2:08:05 right in the conveying splat came in March and the commission, the County

2:08:09 commissioners approve that on March 19th about 10 days after council prove that

2:08:14 conveyance plats. So in the future Brad's trying to avoid going to both to get

2:08:18 approval for any future plats. So the purpose of this, spring all of this into

2:08:22 city limits. Let me check the thing up I get another map up. So future land use map

2:08:31 shows this shows the soccer fields as open space designation and some medium

2:08:36 density designations. The current zoning map shows it kind of split up into multiple

2:08:46 SUI and R1. We can't have SUI or it's not appropriate to have SUI zones within city limits. It's

2:08:53 a between county and develop properties. So the recommendation we showed and provided to the

2:09:00 Commission was to have all of the property being annexed BR1 variable. Very similar to what's

2:09:06 already there, hardly different from what's currently zoned.

2:09:10 So that was kind of a negotiation between the two parties to fill on that part.

2:09:19 Since the school district acquired the property, its intended use was for potential expansion

2:09:23 of the school district's facilities, including but not limited to a new school site.

2:09:27 School district and the city of an agreement to transfer this ownership in the near future.

2:09:31 HARS would be the suddenly soccer fields themselves.

2:09:34 The school district would retain the Southeastern acreage

2:09:39 for a possible future school.

2:09:41 Staff recommended the R1 be appropriate for the entire site.

2:09:46 On May 27th, the commission held a public hearing

2:09:48 on this request.

2:09:49 Two people spoke at the public hearing.

2:09:50 The concerns were about additional traffic upon development

2:09:53 and the development time for North College Road.

2:09:56 Upon conclusion of the public hearing,

2:09:57 the commission held deliberations without concerns.

2:10:00 Commissioner Gray made a motion to recommend the R1

2:10:03 Variable Zoning District for the entire acreage.

2:10:08 As presented, Commissioner Reed seconded the motion

2:10:11 in all members present, voted in favor of the motion.

2:10:15 Staff concurs with the commission's recommendation,

2:10:17 and recommends request be granted as presented.

2:10:20 That is all.

2:10:21 Do we have any questions for either Jonathan or Brad?

2:10:25 Chris, talk.

2:10:25 Jonathan then, we're just acting on annexation tonight.

2:10:30 It's not a zoning designation.

2:10:32 It's both.

2:10:33 The R1 is part of the annexation.

2:10:35 Okay.

2:10:36 Any other questions from council?

2:10:39 I see no further questions.

2:10:42 So at this time I'm going to open up the testimony part of the hearing and ask that anyone that

2:10:47 wishes to testify come forward now.

2:10:50 I see no one coming forward.

2:10:53 So we are closing the public testimony portion of this hearing.

2:10:56 Turn it over to council for either questions and or direction.

2:11:04 Sean Verrier.

2:11:05 I would move to approve the annexation request for the 53 plus or minus acre

2:11:13 site with an R1 variable zoning designation. Second.

2:11:19 What's on the floor by Sean Berger said seconded by Suzanne Hawkins as stated.

2:11:25 Anything further out of that motion council?

2:11:28 The aye will call vote please. Don Hall? Yes.

2:11:31 Susan Hawkins. Yes. Jim. Yes. Sean Berger. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes. Five zero. Thank

2:11:40 you, Mr. Wells. Thank you, Mr. Spendlove. And ladies and gentlemen, we are adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, June 22, 2015. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:12:22.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    9420aa07112bb3e6ec4aab54e43d97b117eab3d9b642cfc7669a84d1d6d24a9d
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 60799bcb199c353ebda05d354e3b722be51e0456cdd46b692b064b440a6ce7e9
    part02.m4a 2d07c01dd17a931b0ce11caf7ede92a79179023fb4f8e533f4bbbf56fe22bc80
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    b3cba7025083d8f145dc1f5ced7510f19ada4552015661613f0e8cffe6451ae6

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file