City Council meeting
Monday, November 9, 2015
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Minutes on file
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:00:00 November 9th, 2015, and we have a couple Boy Scouts in the audience that are just
0:00:07 excited about coming up and leading us in the Pledge of Allegiance. So if the two of
0:00:11 you would come forward and for the rest of us if you would like to join us please
0:00:16 rise.
0:00:33 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:00:43 All right, gentlemen, if you would go behind the podium there, pull the microphone down, and you drew the...
0:00:51 He hasn't started unless you wanted to do all the rest of it, and are you pulling it down for him?
0:00:56 Okay, my name is Raleigh Britain and I'm in two two hundred two hundred seventy and
0:01:06 We're working we came here for the communications mayor badge and we meet in the LDS church on park
0:01:12 Excellent you remembered all of them
0:01:21 That's a future mayor right there
0:01:25 I do want to confirm that we have a quorum of the city council all seven members are here this evening
0:01:34 Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to our agenda, sir?
0:01:38 We do not.
0:01:39 Thank you.
0:01:40 We have no proclamations this evening, so we will start off as we always do with any public
0:01:46 input.
0:01:47 Is there anyone here that would like to address the council on something that is not on the
0:01:51 agenda this evening?
0:01:54 I see no one coming forward, so I will move to the next item which is number one for consent
0:01:59 calendar and turn that over to council for their direction.
0:02:02 I move approval of the consent calendar motion on floor by Suzanne Hawkins
0:02:09 seconded by Chris talking to him to approve the consent calendar as posted
0:02:14 anything further on that motion council Sharon roll call vote please Suzanne
0:02:20 Hawkins yes Jim Mann yes Sean Baraker yes Chris talking
0:02:25 yes Greg Lanting yes Don Hall yes Rebecca Mills so I can yes motion passes
0:02:32 7-0 moving under items for consideration.
0:02:36 The first item being presentation of peace officer standards
0:02:39 and training council certificates
0:02:41 to the following individuals.
0:02:43 Officer Eric Strassner, Sergeant Justin Diamond,
0:02:47 and Sergeant Kevin Loosely.
0:02:48 And we have Lieutenant John Wilson with us this evening.
0:02:51 Welcome, Lieutenant.
0:02:53 Thank you, Mayor Hall, council members.
0:02:55 As usual, it's an honor to be here
0:02:57 to help present these post certificates
0:03:01 to some of our officers.
0:03:03 And if I could have Officer Strassner, Sergeant Diamond,
0:03:06 and Sergeant Loosely please stand up
0:03:08 and move to the front of the room.
0:03:14 On March 3rd, 2015, Officer Eric Strassner
0:03:17 was awarded his post basic certification.
0:03:20 Officer Strassner attended and graduated
0:03:22 from the 10 week post patrol academy in 2014.
0:03:26 Officer Strassner successfully completed
0:03:29 the Twin Falls Police Department's field training program
0:03:32 and is served as a police officer
0:03:34 in the state of Idaho as required to receive this certification.
0:03:39 On May 26, 2015 and July 20 of 2015, sergeants diamond and loosely respectively were awarded
0:03:49 their post supervisor certification.
0:03:53 To receive this certification, sergeants diamond and loosely were each required to hold a higher
0:03:58 level post certification, complete 100 hours of post approved supervised retraining within
0:04:05 the specified time frame and be a first line supervisor for a minimum of one year.
0:04:11 The personal commitment of these officers to better themselves through training has helped
0:04:15 the Twin Falls Police Department in achieving its goal of being the best police department
0:04:20 in the state of Idaho.
0:04:22 Congratulations, gentlemen, and Mayor Hall will present the certificates.
0:04:30 Well, gentlemen, thank you for your dedication to your department and for achieving these
0:05:42 certifications.
0:05:43 Much appreciated.
0:05:46 Moving to the next item on the agenda is consideration of a request to approve using contingency funds
0:05:52 to repair roof damage at the senior center.
0:05:55 We have our CFO, Lori Race, welcome Lori.
0:05:58 Good evening mayor and city council.
0:06:01 The first part of last week, Gretchen Scott received a phone call from Jeanette Rowe at
0:06:06 the senior center.
0:06:07 She was having some substantial leaks there.
0:06:11 And currently the senior center is undergoing some improvements to their HVAC system.
0:06:18 So they needed their roof repair.
0:06:21 They're doing these upgrades to the HVAC system.
0:06:25 So it kind of seemed like we had two independent projects.
0:06:29 So I asked Jared Boardy, our building official for his input.
0:06:32 I didn't want to spend money where we're going to have to tear out and redo.
0:06:38 Jared assessed the situation and worked with both Lewis Riffing and Terry's heating and
0:06:43 air conditioning to coordinate their efforts and Jared's quote to me was, I confirmed with
0:06:49 Steve from Terry's heating and air conditioning that they're going to use curb adapters and
0:06:54 will not be replacing or moving the current curves.
0:07:00 This means we can have Lewis Riffing proceed with the roof repairs and prevent further water
0:07:05 damage.
0:07:07 So tonight, I would just ask that you approve the use of $4,500, a budgeted contingency dollars
0:07:15 to cover the cost of this repair, and I'd be happy to answer any questions you might have.
0:07:20 Thank you, Lori.
0:07:21 Chris, talking.
0:07:22 Yeah, $4,500 doesn't go far when you're doing roofs, so a partial repair is not a replacement.
0:07:27 It's not a replacement, Chris.
0:07:29 In fact, this bid was from March of 2015, and it was for some wind damage that occurred
0:07:36 at the time and I called them up to make sure that the bid was still good and they assured
0:07:40 me it was.
0:07:41 Well, my experience with roof repair which is minimal but I've walked on enough roof so
0:07:47 I repaired on wherever you repair, you walk and you've caused damage so it saves some
0:07:52 more contingency money because I think once it starts going there's going to be further
0:07:57 repairs required.
0:07:58 I certainly would support it though because in addition to the high vac system they put
0:08:04 money and for new carpeting and another amenities that we have to protect. So I
0:08:10 would if nobody else has a question that's a motion to authorize 4500 for the
0:08:16 senior citizen roof repair. So whomever it is. It just Lewis riffing. Right.
0:08:26 We have a motion on the floor by Chris talking to the seconded by Sean
0:08:30 on Barredger.
0:08:32 Travis, maybe you could explain for folks at home
0:08:35 why we are involved in this building.
0:08:38 It's the senior center, but maybe give a history
0:08:41 of why the senior center is where it is
0:08:43 and why we have some sort of responsibility on this building.
0:08:46 Certainly.
0:08:47 So the citizens of the city of Twin Falls
0:08:50 approved a levy override in which they voted
0:08:52 to increase their property taxes through a special assessment
0:08:56 for a two year period, which allowed us
0:08:58 to acquire the building, and then to be able to make the necessary improvements inside, as such, it's a city asset.
0:09:05 So it's an asset that is owned by the city, and we, through a lease agreement, a long-term lease,
0:09:11 lease that to the senior citizen organization for $1.
0:09:17 And so since it is a public asset, it's important for us to maintain that asset in the event that the senior citizen goes
0:09:24 to a different location or choose to do something different that the asset is
0:09:28 available and could be remarketed if needed at some point in time however we
0:09:33 don't anticipate that ever occurring because the purpose again of the lovely
0:09:37 override was for the re-establishment of the senior citizen center. Not unlike the
0:09:42 golf course building as well. Yeah the golf course building the city pool and all
0:09:49 other assets that we have. Thank you Travis. Do we have anything further on motion
0:09:54 Council. Sharon Rokow, please. Jim Mann. Yes. John Barrigar. Yes.
0:10:07 Yes. Chris Tocquenten. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Said that with a question.
0:10:17 Behind it, Tom. Rebecca Milsoyka. Yes. And Suzanne Hocken. Yes. Motion passes 7-0. Moving
0:10:29 to the next item as a presentation of an update on the City Hall and Public Safety Complex.
0:10:35 We have a...
0:10:36 Clent...
0:10:37 Well, and...
0:10:38 Trapped the clock.
0:10:39 Pay for the council technical issues, so we'll get started as soon as possible.
0:12:51 We're going back kind of old school.
0:13:21 Not completely, yes.
0:13:24 Yeah, that's the word.
0:13:27 Welcome, sir.
0:13:28 Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the council.
0:13:32 As you know, as you know, we've been working on your new City Hall and Public Safety Project
0:13:42 now for quite a few months.
0:13:45 We saw you last earlier in the summer and the spring for programming meetings and those
0:13:52 were more specific to the Council chambers themselves and to get your general input on
0:13:57 the project and to update you on phases and schedule.
0:14:02 Tonight we're here to update you again on the design, the process, and where we are in that process, the schedule, and then we'll talk about budget a little bit too.
0:14:14 So, in the big picture, as far as process goes and where we are in this process, we have, as far as your design schedule goes, really programming from programming at the beginning to construction documents at the end,
0:14:32 at the end and that's where we're actively involved prior to construction.
0:14:36 We're somewhere in the middle right now just to give you a big picture idea of where we are
0:14:42 in that schedule.
0:14:43 And we'll talk about that a little bit more and we'll have Star come up and add there and
0:14:49 put it as well.
0:14:50 But the way I wanted to go through this tonight was just to give you an update on design, show
0:14:55 you what the last several months is doing graphically and give you an idea of what it's looking like
0:15:03 your buildings. So after that, I'll go through that. I'm free to interrupt to me
0:15:09 any questions you have along the way. And then secondly, we'll talk a little bit
0:15:14 more about schedule and some more detail with the schedule. And then lastly,
0:15:18 budget. So my hope is to just build the information through this presentation
0:15:23 and educate you on what we've been doing, which will help you give us more
0:15:29 and better questions, I guess, at the end. And certainly when we get into
0:15:32 budget as I know that's a concern. We can have some good conversation about that.
0:15:38 So, this slide I wanted to show really what this slide is, it's a summary of where we are
0:15:45 to date. So if you look at the bar in the very center, April on the left, October on the
0:15:51 right, this is just a simple timeline of the last several months. We started in April with
0:15:56 a program process and what we started to do was meet with staff and users of these facilities
0:16:05 on a biweekly basis where we could meet, examine their needs both quantity-wise, like office
0:16:12 quantities and in detail.
0:16:14 So by summer we were talking about a number of casework in offices, power and mechanical
0:16:20 systems and all those kinds of details.
0:16:25 So now we do have a program document, there's actually two books, one for the public safety
0:16:30 building, one for buildings and then one for new city hall, those really serve as the foundation
0:16:35 for what we design into your buildings and it tells us what your needs are.
0:16:42 So if you'll remember last fall we did facility planning and we had some conversations about
0:16:49 the ban of facility big enough is we should we build a new building and we talked about
0:16:55 programming and we didn't have a program so we didn't know exactly what those needs would
0:17:00 be. That's what we did in this term so we've really got a good idea now of what those needs
0:17:06 are and we'll give you some more information on that in a little bit. So the program kind
0:17:14 kind of overlapped with some city fair opportunities and for us it was an opportunity to engage
0:17:21 with the public and really learn from them what's important and what their priorities are.
0:17:26 So you'll see we identified on the timeline July, August, and October we had a public open
0:17:35 house.
0:17:36 So what these graphics are if you look at the top two and say what's your vision at the
0:17:42 top?
0:17:44 We really wanted to engage the public and just see what's important to them.
0:17:48 So we put words up like energy efficiency, history, tradition, things like that, and people
0:17:54 could actually put stickers on what they liked.
0:17:57 We also did that with images, so we had some architecture, interior, exterior, just to see
0:18:02 what people liked.
0:18:03 And so it was really interesting and fun to learn what people liked in the community.
0:18:08 I've got the most popular ones in a later slide, so I'll show those.
0:18:13 But then of course, towards the end of the timeline, we took what we heard in those open
0:18:21 house city fairs, we took the program document that we had built along with you and we started
0:18:27 to implement that into floor plan form and started in the banners, actually all three
0:18:35 buildings, taking that existing envelope of that building and trying to fit in those program
0:18:40 pieces. So you'll see some of that in the floor plans to follow. So since it's in
0:18:48 your packet in this order I thought I would start with the new city hall, the
0:18:58 banner building, since it's in that or in your packet. And what I wanted to do with
0:19:04 these slides is just kind of tell the story of the process we went through. So
0:19:07 of course the first one is just the image of the banner building. This is as it is
0:19:11 now. If you'll remember last fall, we did some concept studies where we just looked at what
0:19:21 was valuable in that facility. We validated that the size of buildings was big enough, which
0:19:27 it still is. I think we'll still have plenty of room for growth. And then we just looked
0:19:34 at what's valuable, what do we take away, and then how do we build that back. So that's
0:19:37 what the next few slides will show you.
0:19:40 The structure of the building, concrete break,
0:19:44 the floor systems, the structure in the roof system,
0:19:46 those types of things we're going to preserve finishes,
0:19:49 all those types of things will go away.
0:19:54 And so I wanted to illustrate, as we did the program,
0:20:00 there was a conversation about the council chambers moving
0:20:03 from this location to City Hall.
0:20:05 It seemed pretty favorable.
0:20:07 I think both when we spoke with yourselves
0:20:09 as well as the public and the city fairs as well.
0:20:13 So we started, you'll see these blocks
0:20:15 and how we fit them into that existing envelope.
0:20:20 The city council chambers ended up on kind of a bi-level location
0:20:27 in that corner where it is a two-story space
0:20:30 both in the basement and the first level.
0:20:33 We did look at the option of having it
0:20:34 on the third floor as well.
0:20:36 We heard from the public mostly that they prefer
0:20:39 to have it on the first floor if it's in City Hall.
0:20:41 So that's why it landed where it did.
0:20:48 For the next slide, this is a little bit
0:20:50 could I interrupt you real quick?
0:20:51 Rebecca, may I second?
0:20:52 Thank you, Mayor.
0:20:53 Just a quick question on that new council chambers.
0:20:56 What is the square footage and what is it compared
0:20:59 to the square footage here?
0:21:00 This I believe we upped the capacity of council chambers
0:21:06 to about 120 seats.
0:21:08 If I remember right, this one's 90, is it?
0:21:17 130 with the overflow says a hundred and thirty back there
0:21:28 100 130 is for both rooms with the overflow. Yep. Right. So I think the occupancy is different than seats
0:21:37 I think we were talking actual seats and it was 90 ish and the occupancy would have been 130 total
0:21:44 What we heard during programming was that this needs to seat about a hundred and twenty and then also have room for overflow on those
0:21:52 those high-capacity nights.
0:21:54 So I'll show you a section here in a little bit
0:21:57 where we designed the rear end of the council chambers
0:22:00 for odor flow capacity.
0:22:02 And then there's actually a multi-use space behind it
0:22:05 that could have AV components so that people could sit
0:22:11 in that overflow room and then visualize what's going on
0:22:15 in the council chambers.
0:22:16 That conserved, so it doesn't sit vacant all the time,
0:22:19 it can serve as a training room for staff.
0:22:22 whereas meeting space as well.
0:22:24 Thank you.
0:22:25 Does that answer your question?
0:22:26 The square footage, I think, is about 3,500 square feet.
0:22:29 It's just a little bit bigger than this one.
0:22:33 And this here is how much space, square footage?
0:22:37 Um, 3,000.
0:22:42 I want to say this one's a little over with the overflow,
0:22:47 and then this one's 35, up to 4,000.
0:22:50 Okay, slightly larger.
0:22:52 And so the, also on the first floor, the overflow training room is the blue box in the back.
0:23:02 So there was a strong desire to have that multi-use space adjacent to council chambers
0:23:08 for overflow capability.
0:23:10 And then utility billing makes up the rest of the first floor from a program standpoint.
0:23:16 And that was simply due to that department being the most active as far as the public
0:23:22 goes.
0:23:23 And that would have access from the alley the back parking lot would it it could it certainly has the opportunity to we did not hear that in
0:23:32 Programming that that you know that we've had the conversations about the drive-up window and that sort of thing
0:23:40 It wasn't evident to us that we needed direct access to the alley from utility
0:23:45 I think a base short-shited for us not to do that taking advantage of that whole perk and out there
0:23:52 to have another entrance. Is that what you're saying? Well, there's already an entrance, sir.
0:23:57 That entrance that's there would be maintained. So that that's the staff entrance is the way it's
0:24:04 intended right now would be not public. So this is the second floor. As you can see the foxes in the
0:24:19 diagram start to stack up. So one of the things that moving the council chambers to the basement
0:24:25 first floor space was it allowed us to open the second floor up for all of your building
0:24:33 engineering, planning and zoning departments.
0:24:35 So as we worked through this program, it was a real challenge just spatially to get everyone
0:24:40 to fit in one place.
0:24:43 They were pretty adamant that they needed to be together just from a workflow standpoint.
0:24:48 So that was one of our main focuses was to look at building P&Z engineering and really
0:24:53 find them at home where they can work together consistently without having to go up and down
0:24:58 stairs all the time.
0:24:59 Also the public can go to one location for a front desk.
0:25:03 So that was pretty important for us as we went through this.
0:25:07 And then floor plan we'll see in a minute that whole second floor then becomes engineering
0:25:13 building and planning and zoning.
0:25:16 So as this, the diagrams start to build, the center of the building really is for stairs,
0:25:25 restrooms.
0:25:26 We try to keep all of that as efficient as possible, both for wayfinding for the public
0:25:31 and simply for costs.
0:25:32 If you can tend to stack those types of things together, it's really efficient.
0:25:38 So keep that in mind.
0:25:42 So then the third floor, HR Finance Administration, Economic Development, we have IS and then
0:25:52 we have staff lounge that needed to fit in somewhere.
0:25:56 It was obviously lower on the priority list as far as location, but it seemed to fit the
0:26:01 best up here.
0:26:03 So you'll see administration kind of on the corner on the third floor, but there's a really
0:26:10 a really nice circulation path between HR and finance, administration, it all works kind
0:26:15 of as one big office suite.
0:26:18 What we heard during programming was that those folks often work together in Southern
0:26:23 Constantly, moving back and forth between each other.
0:26:28 So you can see in three dimensions here, the way these blocks, these departments and square
0:26:33 footer just started to stack.
0:26:35 So we were looking at what needs to be on the first floor, what needs to be away from
0:26:39 public what needs to be directly accessible, and that really drove how these fit into that
0:26:45 existing home.
0:26:50 So then what we did is we took that exercise and what we had built with the program, and
0:26:55 we started talking to the public yourselves with the open house events, and learning what
0:27:02 people liked, and talking about downtown Twin Falls and historic nature, and red brick, and
0:27:09 those sorts of things. You can see on the left the two slides that we have or the exterior
0:27:13 slides that were most popular. We probably showed 8 or 10 photos and got input. People
0:27:20 seem to really like the brick and the predictability of the City Hall and Vancouver. It's effective,
0:27:26 it's symmetrical, but then it's got a nice lobby component to it. It's transparent. Hillsborough
0:27:33 was another one. It had a nice plaza. It's very similar to how the downtown commons could
0:27:38 to work with City Hall and Twin Falls.
0:27:40 So there was some positives that came out of that.
0:27:44 I personally like the interior photos that people like.
0:27:48 It's funny that the banner facility
0:27:51 has concrete posts and beams and red brick on the alley
0:27:55 and the other adjacent walls.
0:27:58 So I think there's a real opportunity
0:28:00 to preserve some of that, use it as a character
0:28:03 in your City Hall.
0:28:04 So we're starting to do that with star corporation
0:28:07 exposed some of that concrete, that brick, see what's in good condition that we can expose.
0:28:14 So it seemed to be really consistent with what people liked.
0:28:17 So we took that, those observations and those comments, and we started to think about, okay,
0:28:27 what is the exterior of this building need to look like, and how does the program translate
0:28:32 out from the inside to the outside.
0:28:35 So just to go back and look at what the banner is today,
0:28:38 it's got metal skin on it, this wall.
0:28:41 adjacent to the alley is brick.
0:28:43 Now it's just painted over, but we're
0:28:46 going to attempt to expose some of that.
0:28:48 Let me go to the next one.
0:28:52 And then just the inside shot showing a two-story space.
0:28:55 As many of you know, the columns are all concrete
0:28:59 behind that plaster and that kind of thing.
0:29:01 So that's what we're starting to work towards exposing.
0:29:07 And so we took the diagram, it took the program as it fit within that envelope, and we took
0:29:13 those elements from what we saw in the photographs and we started to apply that to the structure
0:29:19 that is the banner after demolition.
0:29:22 And so you'll see in this next few sheets, you know, we started to add these brick masonry
0:29:27 components with windows, pretty symmetrical, pretty predictable.
0:29:32 This is really where the office space is.
0:29:35 If you remember, first floor is utility building, second floor planning and zoning, building engineering, third floor is economic development and staff lounge on this side.
0:29:49 And then the next side would be very similar material, glass, first floor, council chambers.
0:29:59 So one thing we heard talking to you guys about the council chambers was just the opportunity to get some daylight into that space.
0:30:07 We've added some upper windows on this first floor and what these three windows do is they're
0:30:11 kind of trans and windows are high windows that you can't look into from the street level
0:30:17 but they allow daylight into that council chambers.
0:30:20 So I'll show you there's a little better graphic here coming upwards that's easy to
0:30:24 see.
0:30:25 The second and third floor then again are our offices as well and so what's left over is
0:30:33 the lobby space, and intentionally it's on the corner of Maine,
0:30:38 and Hanson, it's the most approachable, I guess,
0:30:42 from parking, it's approachable from Commons,
0:30:44 and it's kind of the front door, if you will, naturally.
0:30:49 So we've identified this two-story space on the corner
0:30:52 as a place for more transparency, more glass, signage,
0:30:58 wayfinding, telling people this is where you come into the building.
0:31:02 And then on third floor, there's a large conference space
0:31:06 up on the third floor, and then we're on the space here.
0:31:13 And so these, we've added vestibules per the energy code.
0:31:17 We start to do some things.
0:31:19 It's a little glass and vestibules for spaces
0:31:21 that are over 3,000 square feet inside.
0:31:24 So that's kind of as an airlock.
0:31:27 We'll insert these vestibules where we have entries
0:31:30 into the building.
0:31:31 Those won't exactly look like that,
0:31:34 but this in concept is to illustrate
0:31:37 that's where you would enter the building.
0:31:38 For folks at home, what is the best?
0:31:41 The best field is just a space that allows,
0:31:45 it's kind of an air lock, so you open the first set of doors
0:31:48 and then you don't get a gush of wind into the space.
0:31:51 That second group of doors are blocking in that air flow,
0:31:53 so. Thank you.
0:31:58 And then we're starting to look at,
0:32:00 and this is just an idea, I mean concept right now,
0:32:04 but we're starting to look at with that added glass on the corner for the lobby in the office space above.
0:32:10 It's kind of a northwest and southwest facing glass, so it's got good exposure to it, something that we need to treat in some way,
0:32:20 or it'll get a lot of heat gain in that lobby.
0:32:23 So we want to make sure it's a comfortable space, we've got to look at that glass and either tent it or do some sort of shading device on this corner
0:32:32 to help mitigate that exposure.
0:32:37 The other thing I like about this corner,
0:32:41 it's kind of feeling right when we come in
0:32:45 and do a lot of the demolition with the banners
0:32:47 in between columns, there's a concrete block
0:32:51 that will remove and that block is right now structural.
0:32:54 So what we'd like to do is come back in,
0:32:56 lighten the building up at the windows
0:32:58 but add some steel reinforcing for seismic reasons.
0:33:02 that's another opportunity where we can do some of that and brace back the building.
0:33:11 So then some of these other images are just different views.
0:33:16 We've been working hand-in-hand with OTAC and Urban Renewal Agency on the Commons and the
0:33:23 Main Street design that's going on.
0:33:26 We really want to make sure that this is a collaborative project so that we're using
0:33:33 what they're doing to our benefit and vice versa.
0:33:36 And if there's things we can do to help each other out
0:33:38 and make this all read consistently,
0:33:40 we certainly do that.
0:33:41 So we're starting to overlay paving patterns,
0:33:46 things of that nature and look at how it would it means
0:33:48 for the corner of City Hall.
0:33:52 So this you can see the commons in concept.
0:33:55 These are, this is just something we had inserted
0:33:59 as we've been having conversations with them.
0:34:01 But it's a work in progress.
0:34:03 wanted to study the angles, the true North-South angles in Twin Falls and how
0:34:09 that could apply to the Commons and then how the Commons can actually apply in
0:34:13 and link to the lobby of City Hall. So we have a graphic. Can we go back to that
0:34:23 just real quick? I have a real quick question. Yes. So the scale here, obviously
0:34:28 your architectural company, is correct. That's a pretty good chunk. Big space over
0:34:34 there were the Roger Simmons, you remember the comments there. Yes, that's impressive.
0:34:39 It's very similar to the footprint of the banner building. Excellent. Yeah, just across the street.
0:34:44 Thank you. So this is an opportunity we took and this is an idea that we'd like to
0:34:53 to pursue further, but one comment we heard from your staff, Travis, Mitch, and Brian was that
0:35:02 you know this is a city hall building. This could be a public building that you can fit anywhere
0:35:07 in any community around the country, right?
0:35:09 But that's not what we want.
0:35:11 We want a facility that can be grounded in Twin Falls
0:35:14 and it can be an example for the community.
0:35:16 It can tell the history.
0:35:17 It can educate the public.
0:35:19 But it needs to be our building, not just any building.
0:35:22 So after hearing that, you know, it really needs sense
0:35:25 and we started to go back and do our research
0:35:28 and think about the Bisbee photos and the timeline
0:35:31 of Twin Falls and those types of things.
0:35:33 And we just came up with this one concept, you know,
0:35:36 as it along the lobby to just do some digital graphics along that class.
0:35:41 It's a pretty cost-effective way to tell a story, educate the public, and when the city
0:35:46 halls closed after five or, you know, whenever people that walk by bystanders can still learn
0:35:53 and still see buildings.
0:35:54 So, certainly not the only thing we want to do, but this starts to do that, I think.
0:36:02 I like that.
0:36:03 And so this view, I wanted to show simply because the context and the different perspectives
0:36:16 definitely need different treatment, this brick wall on the alley side.
0:36:21 We're trying to look at that so that we can preserve it, remove the paint, you know,
0:36:26 but we're not convinced that we're going to get the great result.
0:36:29 So one of the things we're looking at is do we just cover that up with a different kind of brick?
0:36:34 one day, you know, if this is more exposed, what does it look like and how does the public see that?
0:36:43 So we want to really be able to tie the new facade on Hanson Street to what happens around the corner.
0:36:50 So I don't know that we have that solution yet, but we're starting to work through those ideas.
0:36:55 Rebecca, we'll show you.
0:36:56 Thank you, Mayor. Another question on the windows, the large open windows on the main floor are pretty inviting and open
0:37:04 to the public but I think it's the smaller windows like we see in the alley that are
0:37:10 on the main street side where council chambers will be is there any thought to
0:37:15 making that side more open and inviting it just might look closed off especially
0:37:20 sitting next to the other storefronts that are open and have the windows sure can
0:37:28 we go to, yeah, I mean, there's certainly, I understand exactly what you're saying is you're
0:37:50 gonna find with this concept anyway that there's a long main street, there's about, you know,
0:37:57 six feet or so of wall that's just solid masonry and then there's a window of, that's what this
0:38:03 section starts to illustrate is this upper window. We really just did that because we thought
0:38:08 there would be a security concern with peering into the council chambers. But you'll notice
0:38:14 also that this volume is pretty significant. There's probably 15 feet there in height so
0:38:21 you'll have more than you have now. So we really need to think about that and that's
0:38:26 a good point because you could lower this sill a little bit. I would just have the concern
0:38:32 and security issue. Does that answer your question?
0:38:39 It does, thank you. And I see those stairs there. Is there going to be anything that is
0:38:44 is ADA acceptable for someone going down to the front to testify or how will that work?
0:38:53 The floor plans, let's go to actually the floor plan.
0:39:15 Start on the first floor just because that's an easy way to see how you're entering a building
0:39:20 and then you're active the building from there.
0:39:22 So Hanson Street's on your lower side here, Main Street on the right.
0:39:27 two entrances right now off the main street in the corner of Hanson and Maine. So this
0:39:34 is your lobby. It ends up being kind of an L-shaped space and we really wanted to use
0:39:40 this space as a wayfinding space and education space and then for somebody that's coming in
0:39:48 to be able to walk into that lobby and if they're going to utility building, if they're
0:39:52 going to planning and zoning or the council chambers, they're going to know exactly where
0:39:57 going right when they walk in. So that's really what this lobby establishes, utility
0:40:02 buildings here on your left. And the other thing that we've done with this core that I
0:40:07 mentioned was we set up the circulation such that the public stair and elevator is right
0:40:12 off the lobby and also the public restrooms are right off the lobby. So you'll see those
0:40:18 stack all the way up so it's pretty easy once you're in the building to know where those
0:40:22 stairs are where the elevator is where the restaurants are on every floor.
0:40:27 This elevator to answer your question on the ADA accessibility is from the basement all
0:40:33 the way up to the third floor.
0:40:35 So this would be your access into the council chambers, you'd actually come into this elevator,
0:40:40 it dropped you down to the basement, and then you could walk around and there would be a
0:40:45 ADAC at the front, so like in this area by the presentation.
0:40:50 Okay.
0:40:51 Thank you.
0:40:54 So, just to expand on that, as you come out of an elevator and you'd have circulation, keep
0:40:59 in mind this is still at a design development stage, so we've got to work out some bugs,
0:41:04 you know, in the plan and clean things up, but as it stacks up, you access the council chambers
0:41:11 out of the elevator through here and then there'd be ADAC at the front of the council
0:41:17 chambers. So since we're here, all this. Man, I actually
0:41:24 question going back just a little bit, just on the
0:41:25 brick, the existing brick. Are you going to try to like so to
0:41:29 blast that first, see what it looks like and then make
0:41:32 decisions from there? Is that the intent? Yeah, that's the
0:41:34 intent. There's two or three methods that we are hearing
0:41:37 about and stars done a little bit more. So we're going to do
0:41:41 some tests. We've started to do some of that already. The
0:41:44 plaster that's actually on the inside of those brick walls is
0:41:47 pretty well adhered. So we're finding that it's pulling some of that mortar and brick face away as we do that. So we'll just have to try it and see.
0:41:59 But that's the intent. Thank you. Yeah, if you see, you know, like the sandwich company or the slice, those types of exposed brick finishes, you can tell they've done something like that to bring them back out. That's the look.
0:42:14 So the council chambers, and we've got some three-dimensional views in that section that I just brought up,
0:42:20 seats about 120.
0:42:24 Actually, when we did the program, we programmed the council chambers in two options, one for a flat floor option,
0:42:31 which is similar to what you have right now.
0:42:33 The other option, which we heard a lot of good feedback on, was to slightly slow the floor and tear the seating.
0:42:41 So it's not drastic. You've only got about six inch risers the way we're looking at it four to six inch risers
0:42:48 And I think there's six steps so it only goes up to three feet
0:42:53 We didn't want to get the crowd to
0:42:55 Hi, I guess in the space so we kept that pretty gradual, but it still seats a hundred and twenty
0:43:02 There's opportunity for staff on both sides of the dias and then
0:43:08 Then once we get into a little more detail, it starts to develop the AV, and how it works
0:43:15 around this layout, if this is the way you continue to want to proceed.
0:43:21 The overflow, there's overflow opportunity actually outside of the chambers.
0:43:26 If you go back to the first floor, Mitch, see you would enter the lobby, and straight
0:43:33 ahead off of Hanson Street would be some steps that you would walk down to an overflow
0:43:39 area outside council chambers. So this would really serve as kind of a gathering space before
0:43:45 after during meetings for those that may not want to be in the meeting but sit outside
0:43:50 or certainly if the council chambers is full you get a certain amount of people outside
0:43:58 here in this overflow area. So it drops down about five feet or so from the main floor
0:44:03 to that platform and then you go in with the council chambers.
0:44:06 that are collapsing between those so you can see what's going on and see when it
0:44:10 looked like it'd be a appropriate time to come in. Right. Yeah, we've talked
0:44:14 about having an agenda table outside, you know, it goes to sign and cheat, that type
0:44:18 of thing happening on that overflow space. The other overflow space that I
0:44:23 spoke of is this here and you'll see it's got a partition wall in it. There's
0:44:29 really, we heard during programming the need for training space, large meeting
0:44:34 space overflow for council chambers. The more we talked about it, the more it felt like.
0:44:40 You know, we just really need a big room that we can schedule for anybody or it can be used
0:44:45 for council chambers overflow. So that really drove why this is located, where it is, and
0:44:52 its size. This actually has glass as well along this side of the room so you could be
0:45:00 in there, you could have video of presentation and audio, and actually also
0:45:04 still be able to see down into what's going on in Council Chamber. So, just
0:45:09 something to think about. The second floor plan, as you'll notice right off the bat,
0:45:18 there's some areas that are grayed out, and those are intended for growth. And so
0:45:24 the way we approached the programming was that we knew this needed to be a 30 to 50
0:45:29 year solution building for the city. But we also knew that you're going to grow
0:45:34 grow in the foreseeable future up to 20 years and so what we didn't want to have is a project
0:45:39 that you have to remodel in five years because they're growing again. These grey spaces actually
0:45:46 take into account future growth down the road. We were planning to grow, planning growth within
0:45:53 about the next 20 years in this current plan. So these grey spaces are in addition. When we
0:46:03 you when we get into more detailed budgeting and start to look at the real
0:46:07 numbers as targets more involved we'll start to look at what is it cost to
0:46:12 shell this space out versus finish it now and those types of things because we
0:46:18 really want to give you options as we go into the budget part of this so you can
0:46:24 choose. So you'll see on the second floor for example engineering planning and
0:46:30 zoning and building. I'm not that they're going to be designated in those actual areas.
0:46:35 This plan, the way it functions, and it's going to change a little bit, but it's really meant
0:46:43 for them to collaborate and all work together. Sometimes there's teams where they've got planning
0:46:48 and zoning engineering building, all the team, and they want to sit together or something
0:46:51 like that. So we're designing around that opportunity. You see the consistent lobby, circulation,
0:46:58 restrooms, those types of things. So, public space is all kept here in the center and then
0:47:04 they're greeted with some sort of kiosk and front desk. And then, of course, can move back
0:47:11 into any of the workspace if they're right back there. Intermixed within staff, office
0:47:19 area, we've got storage and plan, layout space. So, we'll get into what that looks like in
0:47:26 the next coming months, the details of the case work, how much storage files, plans, those
0:47:32 types of things as we get into it. I really wanted to take opportunity of the glass, if
0:47:37 you remember looking at the concept, elevations and the model that I showed, there's glass
0:47:43 along this main street side, glass along the Hanson side here. That's where those windows
0:47:50 So I'm just sort of the open seating as the officers.
0:47:54 And then of course along the alley, just brick wall,
0:47:56 we'd like to take the opportunity to use the windows
0:47:59 that are there, put in new windows and those openings,
0:48:02 but also maybe punch some new windows in that brick wall.
0:48:07 If we do intend to shell some of this space
0:48:11 on the second third floor,
0:48:14 there's opportunity third floor as well.
0:48:18 If we're looking at right now,
0:48:19 possibility of aligning some shell space
0:48:22 against that back wall so that you would finish out, you know, 80% of that floor and then 20
0:48:28 years from now you can finish up the rest of it and gain that office space. We'll continue
0:48:34 to pursue that. Third floor. We want to know where the City Management's office is. It's
0:48:46 this little room in the back. Closet. That's funny you say that because I was talking to
0:48:58 Josh Palmer about storing his camera equipment. I thought Travis's office was a good spot.
0:49:05 The lobby seems space. So as the public or anyone coming to HR administration, economic
0:49:15 development in those offices, you come out of the stairs out of the elevator into a central
0:49:21 lobby space, entries to HR administration and economic development would all be off that
0:49:29 lobby space. This rear stair that we have on the, I guess, kind of the south side of the
0:49:35 building would be more of a staff stair for, you know, people moving between departments.
0:49:41 But you'll see the administration happens here, entrance to administration city manager's office,
0:49:50 and there's really not just one designated office suite. Really the finance HR and city
0:49:58 city manager's office all kind of blend together throughout this site of the building.
0:50:06 IS ended up locating on the third floor.
0:50:11 This was one that didn't really have a priority as far as which floor it needed to be on and
0:50:19 it certainly felt like the room that they needed.
0:50:22 We could afford it most on the third floor.
0:50:25 So they're in this corner and then the balance of this is staff lounge.
0:50:29 this is about double what we perceived in the program for staff lounge. So if you
0:50:34 look at these gray spaces that are future growth and then you take about half of
0:50:39 that staff lounge space, there's a pretty good amount of square footage there that
0:50:42 we could shell out for future growth as well. So you can see the second floor, the
0:50:47 third floor, those both have pretty good opportunity for for growth down the
0:50:52 road and then we didn't spend much time on it but the basement there's also
0:50:57 also about 8,000 feet, 7,000 feet in the basement that becomes all growth space.
0:51:06 Oh, that's right.
0:51:12 I wanted to mention that on the first floor.
0:51:14 So as we work through programming, after programming, actually, we had some conversations
0:51:18 about Parks and Rec.
0:51:20 And it never been really a part of the conversation in the past, but the thought was, let's look
0:51:25 at it and see if it makes sense.
0:51:27 The steering committee who is built of your city leadership, we've been meeting with on
0:51:33 a monthly basis, ultimately decided that we don't know if this is the right time to have
0:51:39 Parks and Rec and City Hall, so we pulled it back out, but this is, we did a layout for
0:51:45 Parks and Rec in this space, and we just left it out and showed space now, so that could
0:51:50 be an opportunity for another department, or gross down the road, or maybe Parks and Rec
0:51:56 coming to a later date, so you can see as we flip through these plants, there's quite
0:52:04 a bit of space for growth and expansion in the future.
0:52:16 So we did a few of these diagrams and it really, I guess, communicates location of departments
0:52:25 throughout the building and you can see the shelled space in the basement, the council
0:52:30 chambers obviously, overflow training, building and engineering on the second floor, and then
0:52:36 the third floor, and then if you want, can you zoom in on the council chambers?
0:52:42 So, what we're looking for Main Street or Hanson?
0:52:48 You're looking for Hanson Street.
0:52:49 Hanson Street, yeah.
0:52:50 So this by-stacks the council chambers from the Hanson side, so this would be Main Street's
0:52:56 sidewalk over here.
0:52:57 As Rebecca mentioned, those upper windows would be above the sidewalk on the storefront side.
0:53:04 So the dias actually would be against the back wall similar to how it is now.
0:53:09 So let me stop here. So I get it now about security.
0:53:13 Yeah. Yeah. That was our concern. Just opening this up.
0:53:17 Because the other views made it to me look like it was a little different configuration, but now I get it.
0:53:26 And there's other ways we can do it.
0:53:28 I mean, there's a lot of ways to treat glass,
0:53:30 so maybe it's something where you do that glass.
0:53:33 You can drop it down lower, but then there's a way to flip
0:53:36 through it and re-blind it, or control the visibility
0:53:40 and the light so we can do that too.
0:53:42 Wow.
0:53:46 So as you can see, the volume is really nice in there.
0:53:50 This is the lower level.
0:53:51 This would be the basement level, and then it tears up a few feet.
0:53:54 This is the back wall, which would be mostly transparent
0:53:57 and glass.
0:53:58 And this is the platform for overflow.
0:54:02 The big overflow room sits up in here,
0:54:04 so the transparent wall I spoke of is right here.
0:54:09 So you can actually see out of it, this railing,
0:54:11 or be in this room and see through into the council chambers.
0:54:15 And again, how does the Handicap access,
0:54:17 the speaker dies there?
0:54:19 They come around on the far side, I guess.
0:54:21 And this would be an ADA accessible presentation podium.
0:54:26 So we'd like, we're studying a combo type podium where it could all be at a lower level,
0:54:31 the CDA accessible, and then maybe there's two stations to it instead of just-
0:54:36 But how do they get down to that level?
0:54:38 Is there a ramp on the-
0:54:40 The elevator in the center here.
0:54:43 So on the first floor, the elevator's right off the lobby.
0:54:46 You would take that elevator straight down one floor.
0:54:50 Show me how they get into City Council, right there.
0:54:52 Yep, you did it through that side door.
0:54:54 to be similar to one of these doors here, and then ADA seating would be in this
0:55:00 front room. And again behind his main on this side is...
0:55:07 Main is on the right, correct. And this is Hanson here. Okay. That makes sense.
0:55:13 Yeah, it's a little pervert too. Yeah, I was turning it on. So yeah, it gets a little confusing.
0:55:20 So Mitch, I think you can go to the perspectives now. So these are just a
0:55:27 couple of concept renderings that we've done to help visualize what the chambers
0:55:32 would look like. We're going to work on some more for the lobby as well but you
0:55:38 can see the upper windows if you looked at changing those sill height for those
0:55:43 windows obviously those would come down. I think you've got the volume to do
0:55:47 that it's just a matter of studying the AB studying all of that together.
0:55:53 Well, I think I'd be concerned, too, because the focus is to the front and the sun was coming in there.
0:55:59 It'd be difficult for the folks in that.
0:56:02 We'll certainly control this either way.
0:56:04 Yeah, it's easier to control.
0:56:06 And you'll possibly have an AV screen of some kind like you have here that would be behind you.
0:56:15 If you remember, we had the conversation about that presentation being off to the side versus behind.
0:56:20 In this concept, in the way we programmed it, you would have
0:56:24 AB presentation screen behind you, a large one,
0:56:28 but you'd also have these LED screens that hang from the ceiling.
0:56:32 So the public in the back would actually still be able to see it here.
0:56:36 And yourselves, you'd be able to look straight out at this screen
0:56:40 instead of having to look at the side. And folks in the overflow would have that same
0:56:45 Right capabilities.
0:56:47 Audio and video.
0:56:50 So what we've done as far as finish goes
0:56:52 is just a simple carpet and exposed concrete columns.
0:56:57 We're aware that the acoustics are very important
0:56:59 in the council chambers.
0:57:00 So it's just a concept of looking at acoustic panels
0:57:04 and ceiling treatments as well.
0:57:08 And then reusing some of the artwork you've got.
0:57:11 As we get into this in more detail,
0:57:12 we want to look at those opportunities
0:57:15 and see how to implement those.
0:57:20 So that was the view from the back.
0:57:23 This would actually be the view from the dais
0:57:26 and the staff seats along this side.
0:57:29 So you can see the steps, of course,
0:57:32 in the seating in the back wall.
0:57:33 This would be the entry.
0:57:36 We're going to get into some more detail
0:57:38 with how the seating is and the AB is for yourselves
0:57:44 and just the controllability of the meetings
0:57:46 that talked out works that will be integrated
0:57:49 into this for a bit.
0:57:56 Any other questions on design as far as the
0:57:59 the city hall goes?
0:58:00 Any questions from council?
0:58:02 Chris talking.
0:58:02 Well, Clint, I'd like to congratulate you so far.
0:58:04 It looks harmonious at the downtown.
0:58:07 You had to add it, Abe, in ways I think
0:58:09 they're going to be pretty favorably received.
0:58:13 I'd like to take a step further if I might though,
0:58:15 talk a little bit about the infrastructure
0:58:17 as far as communications.
0:58:19 talk about it before, but it's my daily work and that it's
0:58:24 something I won't let loose of and if you hear me and it makes
0:58:28 sense, then I think it'll be net some gain. I'm most concerned
0:58:34 that rather than building the structure and then coming in
0:58:39 post construction, trying to push through communications that
0:58:44 we haven't planned from the beginning is going to be counter
0:58:47 productive and frankly, money foolish, it's bad.
0:58:51 So I'd really like you to have the hit list of the things that I think that you're probably
0:58:56 already aware of, and that's to anticipate some of the communication services that we don't
0:59:04 even know the technology or what it is today, that we know that probably between fiber and
0:59:12 wireless is going to be some combination.
0:59:15 I would hope that the building has plenty of capacity for growth of any fiber bundling you
0:59:21 bring in, that you adequately prepare for Wi-Fi to serve all communications devices including
0:59:31 Wi-Fi booster stations strategically planted so there are no dead spots.
0:59:37 Also like to make sure it looks like you have the server room where there's adequate air
0:59:42 conditioning but you know electronics don't do well under heat so they've got to have maximum
0:59:47 cold over plan your air conditioning for today's needs. Very important to me is to have an equalized
0:59:54 sound system here. This is totally inadequate we have now. We have some counsel among myself
1:00:00 and staff and others who are mumblers. It is not well received at home and are streaming
1:00:06 and we have to have an equalized system where people don't have to be
1:00:10 communications pros to know what to do with the mic, but something that will be
1:00:16 readily accessible and usable. And probably some roof design for dishes, they
1:00:26 have not outlived purpose yet, and they're pretty small now for the high-freak
1:00:30 ones, but I think we'll probably be using the satellite communication for
1:00:36 foreseeable future and plan for adequate sound happening in the main
1:00:42 council chambers. Is any of that sound foreign or I probably miss some things
1:00:47 you're thinking? It's certainly important. You know it's no different than many other
1:00:53 project type two. It's we face this challenge with a lot of buildings. The
1:00:58 technology grows so fast how do you stay ahead of it and design for it in the
1:01:02 future. So we certainly designed an adequate conduit so that if you need to pull something
1:01:09 later, you can do that kind of thing without having to tear up the construction.
1:01:13 You get to roll your scissor, conduit, or make multiple conduits, right. So we've had some
1:01:17 conversations with your IS group and there's actually a committee, kind of a sub-committee
1:01:22 that's an A, B, I, T sub-committee that's going to work through those. I know this DAB
1:01:30 the industry in this room itself is going to be something we need to work on.
1:01:33 I'm pretty sure I know you're a step ahead, thank you.
1:01:36 Sure.
1:01:37 Rebecca Milsocko.
1:01:38 Thank you Mayor.
1:01:39 I appreciate how you mentioned Parks and Rec and that there is some open space available.
1:01:44 I think that one of the concepts that citizens like is having a one location to do all their
1:01:50 city business.
1:01:51 And so I think the concept of being able to come and register your kids for the Parks
1:01:55 and Rec activities that they need to while you pay your water bill or you know get
1:02:00 whatever permits you need. I really like that concept and so even if staff doesn't want
1:02:05 to put the entire department there, I think at least having an opportunity for citizens
1:02:10 to do their business there and be able to sign up and pay for classes and that sort of
1:02:15 a thing I think would be wise to incorporate now so that we are achieving that goal of being
1:02:23 in one location and that was a main goal of relocating City Hall.
1:02:31 Council have any other questions great landing looks great when we start
1:02:40 We know the city manager's offices
1:02:46 So if no other questions, let's move on to public safety
1:02:50 And we'll do kind of the same thing. I had electronically a couple of
1:02:56 Images that showed how we implemented the program and see the plan
1:03:00 but I don't know that it's critical if you have any questions certainly ask me if
1:03:05 there's any in detail and we can review the plans. So this is a look at your
1:03:12 campus we took the same approach the programming happened at the same time
1:03:17 as New City Hall we formed a subcommittee steering committee and then committee
1:03:23 user committee for the program of public safety. This is really divided into
1:03:29 police administration in what is the existing city hall and then the police
1:03:35 station would just be renovated for operations. So that will acclimate you to
1:03:41 the campus. I'd want you to just note a few things that the program told us. So
1:03:48 when we first started looking at this last fall, the thought came to me and
1:03:54 Travis and I had discussions about what would it take to renovate these
1:03:58 buildings, clean them up, refurbishment, heating and air roofs, those types of things to make
1:04:04 them use of their buildings again for the next 30 to 50 years. What does that mean? That was
1:04:12 prior to the program and so we started working through this program and the actual needs and
1:04:17 how operations work, how the administrative folks work, and how much space they need. We
1:04:23 started to identify a couple of things that we didn't have room for. And so if you'll
1:04:28 notice on the back, there's a little addition that we've done on the back side of existing
1:04:33 City Hall. This was an interview room type of addition. I lost Brian to give a little more
1:04:41 detail if you have questions on that. This would be off the secure park and also no public
1:04:48 access to the rear room building. The other thing I bring to your attention on this building
1:04:53 is the front entry. After looking at further life safety code and ADA accessibility with
1:05:00 that building, as many of you know, there's the existing platform that's in the lobby.
1:05:05 I mean, I don't think that would work if we chose to totally renovate this building.
1:05:11 So this would actually include the implementation of an elevator at the front of the building
1:05:15 along with a new lobby space. So keep that in mind. I'll show you a few more images.
1:05:20 And that would service all three floors.
1:05:23 Correct.
1:05:24 It would be a three stop elevator that would service the lower, the middle of the upper
1:05:27 floor.
1:05:30 So the police station, then again, as we worked through the program with the crime lab, it
1:05:38 really came to be that they needed, I guess, an additional garage type of space.
1:05:44 What was there now that was supposed to be the garage is used for something else and they
1:05:48 just don't have room for it.
1:05:50 So it was apparent to us that they needed an additional garage space for that crane-wet
1:05:55 van.
1:05:56 And that's what you'll see at the back here.
1:05:59 So a few things that this is a concept rendering of the front view of the existing city hall
1:06:12 building.
1:06:13 So this is from 2nd Street looking at the building.
1:06:16 The main entry would stay in the same location.
1:06:19 However, we would implement a little bit of glass and some new material there to really
1:06:25 kind of dress up the lobby.
1:06:26 This would serve as the public entry
1:06:29 for the police department.
1:06:30 So if you think about the entry,
1:06:34 that's off the first street,
1:06:37 that would go in the window.
1:06:39 So all the public would have to train
1:06:42 to go to the second street site.
1:06:46 The vertical element on the left-hand side of the entry
1:06:48 that you see is that elevator that I spoke of.
1:06:51 So that gets you your ADA accessibility.
1:06:54 Couple of other things we used,
1:06:56 opportunity to try and tie in a way we want to try and tie some of the city
1:07:01 architecture together and so you'll notice this has a metal screen on it, some
1:07:07 glass and a metal screen type material. We don't really know what that is but the
1:07:11 intent is for that to be similar to new City Hall. It also gives us an
1:07:17 opportunity to sign this building so we can have a Twin Falls City logo, we're
1:07:22 in a police department up there, and it's very identifiable.
1:07:25 So some of the things we're starting to think about
1:07:29 and solve several, so it gets several solutions at one time.
1:07:35 So this would be the rear elevation of the building.
1:07:40 This is the addition that I spoke of with the interview rooms.
1:07:43 There's a conference room and then some interview space
1:07:47 back in this site.
1:07:49 And when I believe, if I'm not mistaken,
1:07:52 Introducing code enforcement to this building is part of the reason of this expansion, correct?
1:08:01 The operation is building.
1:08:05 And so concept, we've got a metal panel, very simple type metal panel.
1:08:11 You'll see a couple slides, a little more clearer idea of what that metal panel could be, but
1:08:16 just something that can accent the existing brick and stuck over it's there and be cost effective solution.
1:08:23 So this is actually a metal panel, like a gray metal panel
1:08:27 vertical, and this would be like a cement or type material
1:08:31 in glass to identify the entries.
1:08:34 Thank you, could I ask a question?
1:08:35 Brian, I have a question for you.
1:08:37 Now, this might be addressed in the process here,
1:08:40 but if it's not, I'm afraid I'll forget to ask you.
1:08:45 Is it necessary or have we thought about having
1:08:47 any kind of a holding, I don't want to say sell,
1:08:51 but some sort of holding facility for folks
1:08:54 that you have in custody, and is there some secure thought
1:09:00 towards that?
1:09:01 Well, it's actually a great question.
1:09:02 And we have looked at it.
1:09:03 One of the problems in having a holding facility is there's
1:09:08 a whole list of things that we'd have to come in compliance
1:09:10 with that we do not currently have a holding facility
1:09:14 because of that.
1:09:15 And I think we probably were best served by allowing the
1:09:19 chair of Carter and his team to handle our holding.
1:09:21 Our holding is his horse.
1:09:24 That makes sense to me.
1:09:24 I just didn't know if there was any thought towards that.
1:09:27 Yeah, we thought about it, and then we looked at what we
1:09:29 would have to actually do to build that in there.
1:09:32 And in addition to losing space, which is pretty critical,
1:09:36 a whole list of things that we'd have to comply with.
1:09:38 OK.
1:09:39 Thank you.
1:09:40 Sorry to take us off that way.
1:09:43 No worries.
1:09:44 Good question.
1:09:47 So let's go to Operations Building.
1:09:56 So this is a perspective looking from the parking lot side.
1:10:02 You can see the fence in concept.
1:10:05 We've fence the parking lot off.
1:10:06 This is where the existing parking, police parking is now.
1:10:10 So right now, this is a pretty basic brick building.
1:10:15 It was built to be secure as a police department.
1:10:20 So there wasn't a lot of daylight on this side.
1:10:23 The architecture, the metal panels that I spoke of.
1:10:26 This is, I'm just accenting the corners of the building
1:10:29 and the entries on this side.
1:10:32 I'm tying them in with the police administration building
1:10:34 on the second street side.
1:10:36 And then we're looking at penetrating that brick wall
1:10:40 and actually adding some windows.
1:10:42 So if you look at the plan, I'll actually
1:10:44 have Tom Nyeworth, who did the programming
1:10:47 for the police department with your staff.
1:10:50 Come up and tell you a little bit about the plans,
1:10:53 But dispatch is on this corner.
1:10:57 One of the things we heard from them during programming
1:10:59 is that they sit in that room hours and hours at a time.
1:11:02 They rarely get to see daylight or see what's going on outside.
1:11:05 So it was nice to give them an opportunity on that corner,
1:11:09 give them some natural light into their workspace.
1:11:14 Also an opportunity for signage on this site.
1:11:17 We didn't want to identify this too much,
1:11:20 just because we didn't want the public thinking
1:11:22 they could go there today.
1:11:24 It's an opportunity for logo or something of that nature.
1:11:28 And then as I mentioned, the site of the building
1:11:30 would then be closed off and repurposed.
1:11:34 Would there still be an exit there?
1:11:37 No, that would go away completely.
1:11:40 Yeah, I think it would be a window instead of a door.
1:11:42 OK.
1:11:45 So this is the parking lot site.
1:11:47 Again, you can see the metal panel.
1:11:48 It just turns the corner in the alleyway.
1:11:53 This was kind of in addition to what we previously
1:11:56 thought about doing to this building.
1:11:57 But as we thought more and more about what's going into it
1:12:00 and how we worked through the program with the staff,
1:12:04 those conversations really drove this design.
1:12:08 So I think it really ties the campus together.
1:12:11 We've even thought about future phases.
1:12:13 We could do something similar with the fire.
1:12:16 So all three buildings can tie together.
1:12:18 So keep that in mind.
1:12:33 So this is your floor plan of the existing city hall.
1:12:41 step up and explain these. Welcome, Tom. Thank you, Council. Just briefly, this is the
1:12:53 Ford plan of the existing city hall building. And as I mentioned, we want this to be the
1:13:01 main or the only really public access to the police department. So we've done some things
1:13:08 to emphasize that this is an entryway, basically of your entry and then we created a public
1:13:14 lobby area here that's adjacent to the records groups and the CSOs. This public
1:13:23 area has a couple of new restrooms and this area is basically secured so that
1:13:30 no one can really go beyond that without an escort.
1:13:35 Accessible from that, that side we have a soft interview room here after the CSOs,
1:13:41 We also have a fingerprinting room that's accessible from the lobby side and also from the CSO businesses.
1:13:49 We have, of course, secured glass and counters.
1:13:54 If I could stop you, Tom. Just put folks at home, CSO, community service officers, CID, criminal investigation division.
1:14:03 Perfect, thank you.
1:14:05 So, on this level, basically took the bulk of that space, now becomes a records department.
1:14:12 So, we have a large open office area, some private offices, file storage, work room, small
1:14:19 break room, and then the NCIC room and transcription room.
1:14:24 So, that department then is all concentrated on this side of a central corridor.
1:14:32 That's the corridor that exists now that serves the old council chambers, so we're kind of retaining that.
1:14:39 This is the addition we talked a little bit about, and this basically is kind of a separate, there should be a doorway shown through there, and it doesn't really show up on here, but that would be a secure door, and this would kind of function independently.
1:14:56 So with an access from the outside, we'd have the interview rooms, a polygraph room,
1:15:03 and a media room, and a small restroom in this area.
1:15:06 So that's accessible from the secure lot, from the outside, and could be accessible by
1:15:13 department personnel into the rest of the building.
1:15:16 But if someone were un-exported, for some reason, they wouldn't be able to get into the
1:15:21 rest of the building from that portion.
1:15:23 that portion.
1:15:30 It doesn't actually show up on here, but this has become an elevator lobby.
1:15:34 Tom, would you mind talking right into the box?
1:15:36 Oh, I'm sorry.
1:15:38 Yeah, this would be kind of an elevator lobby that's accessible from the hallway out here,
1:15:44 and the actual elevator would happen in that little one-story edition that's outside of
1:15:52 the main footprint ability.
1:15:55 stairways while we're on here. The stairway to the upper level would be unchanged. The
1:16:01 stairway to the lower level would reconfigure that. So that planter, part of the planter
1:16:06 and the stairs would actually be removed so that we open that hallway. This is the lower
1:16:18 level of the old city hall. We'd have the stairways going down. We've converted this
1:16:24 to kind of an open office space, so this is all workstations for CID. This would be your
1:16:31 elevator access. We have a stop at the main level and you could go down or up to either
1:16:39 the other two levels. The back part of it is narcotics and mechanical and some additional
1:16:45 private offices for the investigators. And then the upper floor, again, access is the same
1:16:56 with the existing stairway, the elevator would come up to this level as well.
1:17:01 We'd have a small connector here and then the existing hallway,
1:17:05 most of the walls on that hallway would go away.
1:17:09 It's a post-and-beam system, so we're able to open a lot of that up and create some glass,
1:17:16 nice glass entries into these private offices and conference rooms.
1:17:21 So this then becomes, I believe that's a copy room.
1:17:26 a group of offices for administrative folks,
1:17:31 chief's office, his assistant, the file room.
1:17:34 We've got a small conference room,
1:17:38 and then a larger conference room that opens up
1:17:41 into a break room.
1:17:44 So that space can be used as a combined space as well.
1:17:50 That's really about it on the administrative building.
1:17:55 Anybody has any questions?
1:17:56 We have any questions for Tom.
1:18:00 Chris, talking to me.
1:18:01 We already have it to a certain extent on the approaches,
1:18:04 but vehicle barriers on the existing cop shop
1:18:09 and the new one are going to add preventative drive-through.
1:18:14 We have talked about that, and I think
1:18:18 I don't know whether a decision was made to keep
1:18:19 the existing ones and reuse those,
1:18:21 or I'm not sure exactly where we're at on that right now.
1:18:26 But that has been discussed, I know.
1:18:28 But that would be around any sort of entrance
1:18:31 as whether they're secure or not.
1:18:34 OK.
1:18:38 Move forward.
1:18:41 And then this is the proposed renovation
1:18:45 of the existing police department building.
1:18:49 The parking area is here on the left side.
1:18:53 This would be the alley.
1:18:55 I believe it's Jerome Street and Third Avenue here.
1:18:59 This is the existing entry, and you can see we've filled that
1:19:03 in so that no longer appears as an entry to the public.
1:19:07 We want everybody to come to the entrance and the lobby space
1:19:12 on the second avenue side so that they only have one point
1:19:17 of access to cover.
1:19:18 So this then becomes an operations building.
1:19:23 And what we did here is most of this will be, most of what's there
1:19:28 out goes away. We have an opportunity to kind of rework circulation and group the functions
1:19:38 together so that they work a little more efficiently. So that's kind of what we've tried to do here.
1:19:43 This is your existing door now after the parking lot side and we've basically grouped the patrol
1:19:53 functions in this quadrant of the plan. We've got kind of a T-shaped circulation path now
1:20:03 with the circulation space in the middle. It's kind of a round space that could have some
1:20:08 department history displays and kind of an informal meeting place for people.
1:20:13 It's a pedestrian roundabout. Yeah. Well actually, yeah.
1:20:18 I don't know if it will be regulated or not, but it will kind of serve that function.
1:20:28 We relocated, I think Clint mentioned dispatch is all in this corner now with their breakroom
1:20:34 supervisor's office.
1:20:37 We were able to get some high windows for them so that they get natural light, but they're
1:20:42 not really visible to people from the outside.
1:20:46 Again, patrol is down here, it was real important for patrol to have real quick access to their equipment and to be able to get out to the parking lot.
1:20:57 So we retained that existing exterior door out of the patrol officer's room.
1:21:03 We've got all their equipment storage and everything in this area so they can grab their gear and go pretty rapidly.
1:21:10 The bottom part is SWAT, the SWAT room and the armory.
1:21:14 They also have their own exterior door to the alley,
1:21:19 so they can load out of there pretty rapidly.
1:21:23 This part of it is code enforcement.
1:21:26 It takes over the old lobby area.
1:21:29 We consolidated all of the evidence functions.
1:21:32 The lab relocates from this corner of the building,
1:21:36 over here closer to all the other evidence functions.
1:21:39 So we have a new lab, office area, packaging area,
1:21:43 and evidence storage out here with some high density storage.
1:21:48 This is the little garage that we talked about as an addition.
1:21:54 And basically that gives evidence an enclosed space
1:21:59 for handling vehicles and that sort of thing.
1:22:04 We have another little portion over here.
1:22:07 This now all becomes basically evidence,
1:22:11 and most of it is part of the secure evidence piece of that.
1:22:16 We have some functions here that people require access
1:22:22 to that we, of course, don't want going
1:22:24 through the secure evidence portion of it,
1:22:26 so this would be the communications equipment.
1:22:30 I think it was AT&T, it has some equipment in this corner,
1:22:36 car seats, the car seat program.
1:22:38 So things that other people need access to,
1:22:41 we created another entrance off of Jerome,
1:22:45 provide access for those things
1:22:47 without having to cross through evidence.
1:22:50 And then this center portion of it here
1:22:55 is a kind of a central break room for everyone
1:22:58 in the building, and kind of a meeting space,
1:23:01 training room, multi-purpose room,
1:23:04 which also opens up into the break room.
1:23:07 And then the bottom part of it here, real short on locker room space now, and so we've
1:23:16 created new restrooms, new shower rooms, new men's locker, and women's locker spaces for
1:23:24 the department.
1:23:25 And then we also have an exit now out to the alley and another primary exit out to the
1:23:32 secure parking.
1:23:33 With all the access now, with the secure parking lot, this would all be gated.
1:23:41 So any of this area out in here would be secure at this point or within the secure parking enclosure.
1:23:49 So we also created some new window openings into the patrol briefing area, into code enforcement,
1:23:57 retaining that existing opening, and trying to get a little more light into the interior
1:24:01 of the building.
1:24:02 We discussed possibly doing a skylight over the central area.
1:24:07 It brings more natural light in.
1:24:09 So briefly, that's the new layout of the existing building.
1:24:14 Anybody has any questions?
1:24:15 Great landing.
1:24:16 Well, sir.
1:24:17 Just one thought, and then one of the discussion occurred previously or not,
1:24:22 but since we were putting the secure parking in that the alley seems to be kind of running out of reason to be there.
1:24:30 And so is there any thought of just bridging the two across to the fire and across to the
1:24:37 police?
1:24:38 We have talked about that and in fact we did look at one concept of putting a cover over
1:24:47 a portion of the alley between the operations building and the fire building to provide covered
1:24:56 access for people going back and forth between the two buildings and also to create a cover drop-off space and the consensus was that the
1:25:06 the budget could be better utilized elsewhere as far as as far as the covered space. Now we also looked at at
1:25:13 you know that alley as far as being able to build across the top of it. It is a there are various utilities out there so there's
1:25:24 some easements and some things that would have to be relocated before we could do that that
1:25:28 are fairly expensive. I don't think that would preclude doing it possibly down the road if
1:25:36 that became something that was feasible to do. That's kind of where we left it now. Thank
1:25:42 you, Tom. Chris, talking to you already pointed out where the locker rooms are and do they
1:25:48 provide adequate separation for the genders?
1:25:51 Yes, this is the, basically what we have is
1:25:55 off of this main corridor.
1:25:58 We have an entrance on the men's side
1:26:00 and an entrance on the women's side.
1:26:03 We have a little, kind of a hallway here on both sides
1:26:07 that gives access to the locker room
1:26:10 and also to the restroom.
1:26:12 So, and it kind of mirrors from one side to the other.
1:26:17 And then from the restroom, we have access into the shower
1:26:22 rooms and into the locker space again from that.
1:26:25 I think we ended up with, I don't recall the exact number on there.
1:26:32 I think we were shooting for around 100 or so
1:26:35 lockers on the men's side and 20, some on the women's side,
1:26:40 were the numbers that we were shooting for.
1:26:41 And in order to accomplish that, we had to steal a little space out
1:26:46 of the old salad board to get enough capacity on the men's side.
1:26:49 And then these two spaces, this is the IT equipment here,
1:26:55 so that's an existing space and the mechanical room.
1:27:00 I like the room, this here, and also in the existing space.
1:27:05 Sean Berger?
1:27:07 So in the city hall space,
1:27:10 we have some sort of shelled space
1:27:12 with the gray spaces for a future though.
1:27:15 This looks to me like it pretty much meets current needs
1:27:19 and with maybe a little growing space in it.
1:27:22 But the intent be that at some point when you grow
1:27:26 it's to build on this campus separately.
1:27:29 There's not a lot of spare room.
1:27:32 Yeah, you have, and that kind of points
1:27:35 to what we had to do, the two small additions
1:27:38 in order because we have some organizational challenges
1:27:43 as far as making sure that the people
1:27:45 who work closely together are in the same building.
1:27:48 And so that kind of drove how we separated out functions
1:27:51 between the existing police station and the old city hall.
1:27:57 And that we tried to build as much excess capacity
1:28:03 into this as we could in the locker rooms.
1:28:06 We have some additional growth in the briefing room.
1:28:13 I think we have a little bit of, I think
1:28:15 We have four or five dispatch stations down.
1:28:21 We have the room to have an additional one.
1:28:25 So we tried to use some strategies,
1:28:28 the high density storage to make the most
1:28:30 of the storage area and evidence that you do have
1:28:33 to maximize the usage of that.
1:28:36 But yeah, we don't, I don't think we have as much space
1:28:41 in this for growth as we have in the city hall building.
1:28:45 It's just, we just don't have the square footage for it.
1:28:48 But we do have some access to pasty for growth in here.
1:28:52 I guess my question would be, do we have a rough time frame on it?
1:28:56 Can I interrupt you just real quick?
1:28:57 Gentlemen, thank you for coming this evening.
1:28:59 You lucked out.
1:29:00 Generally, I ask you to come up and introduce yourself
1:29:02 right in the middle of the process.
1:29:04 So, progress.
1:29:05 Thank you.
1:29:07 I'm sorry.
1:29:08 So my question would be, do we have maybe a rough window
1:29:11 of how long we think this space would meet
1:29:14 our current growth patterns.
1:29:16 Travis Rothwiler.
1:29:18 So if you take a look at the locker rooms,
1:29:21 maybe in particular, so right now,
1:29:24 I was talking to Brian just now,
1:29:25 and he thinks that we have somewhere
1:29:26 between 66 and 68 male sworn officers.
1:29:33 And if there's accommodations in those locker rooms for 100,
1:29:37 it illustrates that there's some additional growing room
1:29:39 for the on-street officer account for both male
1:29:44 and also for female.
1:29:46 When you start looking at additional office space,
1:29:48 one of the things that they're doing
1:29:50 is they're building an overall master plan.
1:29:52 That allows for the existing city hall
1:29:54 to be connected to the fire station,
1:29:56 and the fire station to be connected
1:29:58 to the existing police station,
1:30:00 which is going to also create additional room
1:30:03 and opportunities for growth,
1:30:05 for more administrative functions
1:30:08 if those office spaces are needed.
1:30:10 Inside the current fire station one,
1:30:12 we're going to be pulling out the entire IS team.
1:30:15 So inside of that facility, there's also
1:30:18 a significant opportunity for additional growth
1:30:20 in the additional room, whether that be for a truck company
1:30:23 or for the blending of more police and fire services.
1:30:27 Thank you.
1:30:29 I have several questions.
1:30:31 So you just said 68 male, how many female officers
1:30:34 do we have now, Brian?
1:30:40 Four.
1:30:41 The current trends in the United States
1:30:43 is about 20% female officers.
1:30:45 I know that we're not there yet,
1:30:47 But I think that's going to happen with us.
1:30:49 So I think the growth, we're prepared for that,
1:30:54 at least in the locker rooms.
1:30:55 I'm assuming the rest of the flow will work.
1:30:58 What are we gonna use this space for?
1:31:00 That's pretty twisted.
1:31:06 So if I could dream,
1:31:10 well certainly not big enough for a baseball field, right?
1:31:12 Okay, thank you.
1:31:14 But one of the things that we've talked about
1:31:16 is the employee wellness is an important critical function
1:31:20 moving forward.
1:31:22 And we thought that this might be a good central location
1:31:25 to be converted into an employee fitness facility,
1:31:33 that we've moved that out of the existing fire station
1:31:36 because that's going to be a secured lot.
1:31:38 And that we would turn access for city hall,
1:31:41 access for police and fire
1:31:44 to be able to utilize that facility.
1:31:47 There's absolutely no funding or plan.
1:31:50 In the meantime, what we'd use it as a subsequent meeting space, meeting opportunity, should spaces be filled or there be a schedule in conflicts this would serve as an additional meeting space for us or also for the community.
1:32:09 which would free up a little bit of space and I know they existing work out
1:32:13 room and fire departments not that large but it would free up a little bit of space there.
1:32:17 I have a question for Fritz.
1:32:21 We're talking about and I'm in full support of fencing
1:32:28 the parking lot making it a secure parking lot for our law enforcement.
1:32:32 How does that work with others that are utilizing that parking lot right now
1:32:37 on a legal basis?
1:32:41 talking about the church I am church has no right to use that they use it now
1:32:46 because we use it as a public parking but you could reserve all those spaces and
1:32:50 they wouldn't be able to use it so you don't have an issue so they're
1:32:54 nothing in that they have no claim to any of those parking that answers my
1:33:00 question lastly what are we thinking about with the freed up space for the
1:33:09 fire department on some day when we get a female fire person that's going to
1:33:15 change our world and fire we're going to have to have facilities, restroom
1:33:20 facilities, sleeping quarters, all of those. How does that work with this plan?
1:33:26 So all of our facilities are inadequate. What we do if we hired a female
1:33:33 firefighter right now is that we would have like a door hanger that's
1:33:37 that are occupied by a particular gender.
1:33:45 When we do hire that first female firefighter
1:33:48 and it's a matter of when, not absolutely.
1:33:51 All of our spaces that we have have to be
1:33:56 for both genders.
1:33:58 You can't just say this is the only fire station
1:34:01 that we have so you can only work out of here.
1:34:04 It's an issue that we'll need to address
1:34:06 in all of our facilities.
1:34:07 The short-term solution, again, is to have, you know,
1:34:10 an occupied sign that would be used for both
1:34:14 and then moving forward.
1:34:17 We obviously probably need to look at all
1:34:19 of the existing fire stations to make sure
1:34:21 that reasonable accommodations could be made
1:34:24 for both genders.
1:34:26 Thank you.
1:34:29 All right.
1:34:31 So I think that includes really the design update as far
1:34:36 as the public safety campus and the new city hall as well.
1:34:40 Are there any questions, additional concerns, comments?
1:34:44 Any questions from Council?
1:34:45 Kristoff?
1:34:46 Yeah, what's the next stage on the development moving
1:34:49 into construction?
1:34:50 Final design?
1:34:52 That's the perfect segue in the schedule.
1:34:55 So as far as schedule goes, like I mentioned,
1:34:57 we're kind of in that middle part of the schedule
1:35:01 where we're developing a design.
1:35:02 We certainly want to hear from you.
1:35:05 I know we didn't ask for approval or anything tonight,
1:35:07 but we certainly want to hear your comments
1:35:09 and your initial reaction to both the floor plans,
1:35:12 the design intent conceptually,
1:35:15 and from an exterior perspective,
1:35:18 what you think of materials, glass,
1:35:20 those types of things,
1:35:21 and how the public uses the facilities.
1:35:25 And then we'll continue to develop these designs
1:35:27 into more detail.
1:35:29 We'll also get into more detail with the budget.
1:35:32 We know that's a concern, so we'll get in,
1:35:36 we'll start to work in detail
1:35:38 what those numbers are going to come out to be.
1:35:42 So for schedule-wise, specific to New City Hall,
1:35:46 we're on track for next spring bidding,
1:35:49 and we would complete our construction documents
1:35:52 the first part of next year, and then bid the project.
1:35:55 The goal now is to finish by the summer of 17,
1:36:00 and we've kind of overlaid that schedule
1:36:02 with downtown Commons and the Main Street Project as well.
1:36:06 So we're coordinating that effort to hopefully open that downtown commons and new city hall
1:36:11 at the same time.
1:36:13 So that's really the forecast for new city hall.
1:36:17 The public safety campus can follow a shorter timeline.
1:36:22 Right now our design in favor and meets your budget concerns could move quicker possibly
1:36:29 bid a little bit sooner.
1:36:31 The challenge with that phase of the project is, of course, the two buildings, and they're
1:36:38 both occupied.
1:36:39 And so that's one thing that we really started to study, is what do we do first?
1:36:44 Where do people go?
1:36:46 You know, the natural reaction I had when we got the project and started thinking about
1:36:52 it was, okay, let's do new city hall, then we can vacate old city hall and start doing
1:36:57 that work.
1:36:58 The thing about that is it delays the public safety schedule, you know, 18 months to 2 years.
1:37:04 From what I've heard, nobody wants to do that.
1:37:07 So I think it's a good idea to put public safety first.
1:37:11 I think we can phase it in such a way that we do the existing city hall building first.
1:37:17 Of course that means those occupants either move to another leased space or a temporary
1:37:24 trailer type mobile location or something like that.
1:37:28 But certainly we could occupy and construct that phase
1:37:32 of public safety, then allow administration to move
1:37:36 into it freeing up space in the operations building
1:37:39 to the emery model that.
1:37:41 So that's really our focus right now is starting to work
1:37:43 out those details, understand what those costs
1:37:47 associated would be.
1:37:49 For example, I had one scenario electronically,
1:37:53 but I think I could explain it,
1:37:55 that the police operations building itself, as you know,
1:37:58 you can't take down dispatch and some of the emergency services
1:38:02 and communication for any length of time.
1:38:04 So how do you work around that remodel their facility
1:38:08 that allowed them to do their day-to-day work?
1:38:11 And one of the solutions was to phase our way
1:38:15 through that building.
1:38:16 We could actually phase three or four mini phases
1:38:20 through that building.
1:38:21 It would drag out construction time
1:38:23 be a little more costly. We've actually been working with Brian and his folks to try to
1:38:29 vacate that building completely and move communications just outside in a secure portable
1:38:36 type area where we could then go in and do the public safety campus in two phases. So
1:38:42 we would do the existing city hall as about a five month project and then the operations
1:38:47 building is like a five-seven-month project. So really shave off five months of time, probably,
1:38:57 if we conversely tried to phase our way through that operations building. So it's certainly weighing
1:39:02 the pros and cons of it. We're working through the details of that now, but it's starting to feel
1:39:08 to us like that would be the most effective way to do the phasing, both from a public service standpoint
1:39:15 and from the cost standpoint.
1:39:19 So that's kind of a summary of schedule
1:39:22 and where we're at, the public safety side,
1:39:24 I mentioned five months and seven months.
1:39:26 So the intent with that would be to open
1:39:29 by the summer of 17 as well.
1:39:33 Chris, you should probably still want.
1:39:35 Yeah, I had one follow up to this question.
1:39:40 I'm most apprehensive about us getting
1:39:42 heft between the eyes with construction surprises.
1:39:46 and I can only allude to what we faced at the airport
1:39:50 with the terminal remodeling,
1:39:53 where we had to go back to the feds
1:39:55 and actually ask for additional fundings
1:39:58 but over two years, because apparently that terminal
1:40:02 was being bedded, something like one and a half,
1:40:06 time and a half over time, has regular construction costs.
1:40:10 So I'm asking both the gentlemen, I guess.
1:40:13 Are there any longer term economies of scale
1:40:16 that we might gain by purchasing girders, things brick,
1:40:23 the hard assets that we know we're going to need anyway,
1:40:26 and in effect stock buy all of them,
1:40:29 if there's any economic advantage to that,
1:40:31 or if there are any other tricks of your trade
1:40:34 to avoid getting hit between the eyes.
1:40:38 There's too much construction going on
1:40:40 for us not to have surprises.
1:40:41 That's a great question.
1:40:43 Yeah, I think we have had some conversation
1:40:45 let Michael address this because that does play into the phasing and if we can get solid
1:40:51 contractors up front and bid all of the work at once, we can get the same contractors for
1:40:57 multiple pieces of the scope and then be more efficient with costs rather than bidding every
1:41:03 phase and getting different folks each time.
1:41:06 So I want to let Michael speak a little bit to that because he's known.
1:41:12 Michael Arrington from Start Corporation, welcome, sir.
1:41:17 Thank you, Mr. Mayor, counsel.
1:41:20 Appreciate the concern.
1:41:22 It's very real.
1:41:23 And as Clint mentioned, one of the strategies
1:41:25 would be to take two relatively small projects
1:41:30 with the remodel of the current city hall
1:41:33 and the remodel of the police station,
1:41:36 package those together in such a way to make them
1:41:38 one little bit larger project and make it more attractive
1:41:42 to a variety of different contractors.
1:41:45 Another thing that we'll want to do there
1:41:47 is to pay attention to the packages that we write
1:41:51 when we go out for bidding.
1:41:52 For instance, it would be most convenient for us
1:41:56 to take all the flooring in the job
1:42:00 and package it into one package.
1:42:02 It makes it less people to manage and can make it a little bit
1:42:06 easier.
1:42:07 But that's not always the best thing
1:42:09 to do in the marketplace.
1:42:11 On some of the projects that we're administering right now,
1:42:13 we have written five flooring contracts
1:42:17 to allow for more contractors to compete for the work.
1:42:21 The example is the wood floor in a school,
1:42:24 and then the ceramic tile,
1:42:26 and then some of the specialty coatings you put on them,
1:42:29 and then perhaps carpet,
1:42:31 where you could package those all together,
1:42:33 but it makes it to where just a few could compete for that work,
1:42:36 and so we find by breaking that apart,
1:42:38 more can compete for it,
1:42:40 and we can try to maximize competition there.
1:42:43 We will be watching for things like you mentioned
1:42:46 that we could potentially, early purchases
1:42:50 that may need to be made.
1:42:52 None have been identified yet, but that is something that's
1:42:56 out there on the radar of things that we need to watch for.
1:42:58 It'll be important to also to survey the market
1:43:02 for when the correct bidding date is.
1:43:06 In just a few years ago, you could pick about
1:43:08 whatever date you wanted. And when you advertised for bids, you just had to go out and whisper
1:43:14 out the front door, and people came from everywhere to bid it. And that's not the case anymore.
1:43:21 That's a reality right now that there is a lot of construction. Don't know that it's
1:43:26 too much, but there's a lot. And so it will be important for us on our side to be out
1:43:35 to advertise this project to make it attractive to people and to bid it in such a time that
1:43:40 we're not directly competing with other projects that are out there on the street. So the contractors
1:43:47 wouldn't have to necessarily take a look at our project and choose between bidding ours
1:43:51 and another to try to work together. And we've found as we develop relationships in the industry
1:43:56 with other contractors and other design professionals, that's best for their project too. And so we'll
1:44:02 work together on that and as a team, as well as a team in the industry, try to make that
1:44:09 the best for this project.
1:44:12 Thank you.
1:44:14 Travis, did you have some comments?
1:44:18 Well, Michael's not going to want to hear this.
1:44:21 But one of the beauties of the CMGC process is there's going to be a guaranteed maximum
1:44:26 that we negotiate on the project.
1:44:28 And so part of that risk factor and the reason we went through this process is that they're
1:44:32 going to do their due diligence, we're going to work collaboratively and then we'll bring
1:44:36 a subsequent agreement back to the council that has a guaranteed maximum on the project
1:44:41 where we've spelled out everything that we want that project to do, what we want to look
1:44:45 like and then we will negotiate a guaranteed maximum, we will present that to the council
1:44:52 and then it'll be incumbent upon star to bring in the bids at those guaranteed maximums.
1:45:00 And, you know, it really is a partnership, but one of the beauties of this process is, Star
1:45:07 is on board now, and they are talking with Hummel about the constructability of the project.
1:45:14 And what's happening is a lot of the unknowns are getting resolved on the front end.
1:45:20 And so, Michael has a lot of good understanding and will continue to have more understanding
1:45:25 of what this project is, what the needs are, what the desires are.
1:45:29 so that when he puts forward his guaranteed maximum,
1:45:33 it's not like a sealed bid process
1:45:35 where people are reviewing plans and specs on their own,
1:45:38 but Michael's been involved intimately in that project
1:45:41 as we go out to bid and can bid some of the work themselves.
1:45:45 It's also secure the bid from firms that we believe
1:45:48 will be able to do the work that we have set forward.
1:45:53 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:45:54 Thank you.
1:45:56 You hit on my question, but I'm gonna go ahead
1:45:58 and ask anyway because there's been a lot
1:46:00 of conversation going since I buzzed in. So the addition to the current city halls kind
1:46:07 of new, you know, I don't think it's anything we were anticipating doing. So in that in light
1:46:12 with the budget we set forth, are we giving up something else? Are we making a trade off
1:46:17 for that? Or is the budget number increasing by that much? Or how do you see that played
1:46:22 into where we started?
1:46:24 we started? That's a great question and really what where I wanted the conversation
1:46:29 to go as we get into this budget update. I think not only with public safety but
1:46:37 with new city hall as well after doing the program process and understanding
1:46:41 really what the need is from the users city staff and the public what we've heard
1:46:48 is a little bit more than what was anticipated from my standpoint, at least a year ago.
1:46:56 And that's not uncommon, I'm trying to talk about a project before you know what goes into
1:47:02 it, knowing what the need is.
1:47:03 This is difficult after doing that program, after understanding what those needs are.
1:47:10 You can better put numbers to those.
1:47:12 You can better understand what that actually scopes going to be.
1:47:17 I can tell you that at the public safety campus, the elevator, the addition of that from a life
1:47:24 safety and ADA standpoint was in addition to what we talked about or knew about last year.
1:47:33 Also the additions, the garage and the addition of the back of the existing city hall were
1:47:38 as well.
1:47:39 So there's some challenges there.
1:47:40 I foresee, you know, we're not there yet as far as the budget goes.
1:47:45 We don't have exact numbers.
1:47:47 Michael and Jason, they've been on board for all over a month or something like that,
1:47:52 working with us through design.
1:47:53 And we're making some really good headway.
1:47:57 In the next coming time, we'd like to bring those detailed numbers to you.
1:48:02 But I foresee there being a little bit of growth and scope from what was talked about previously.
1:48:08 So a good example for New City Hall.
1:48:11 For example, last year, I think.
1:48:14 When we studied the facility, we talked about about 29,000, 29,000, and as far as square footage
1:48:21 goes, and when looking at that we looked at the existing buildings, who occupied those buildings
1:48:27 and what square footage did they have, and then we added the council chambers and then we grossed
1:48:33 that number up a little bit to accommodate egress restrooms, those types of things, to get to
1:48:40 that number. The program process told us that what you need now for the new City Hall plus
1:48:48 your gross, plus some growth area for about the next 20 years, that's up to about 35,000
1:48:56 people. So we'll come back and show you numbers that show this is what we saw then, this is
1:49:02 what we're hearing now. And what we want to do ultimately is let you guys make the decision.
1:49:09 So we want to come in with a baseline budget.
1:49:11 This is the base.
1:49:13 Okay, now here we heard 6,000 square feet more
1:49:16 in school we needed at the banner.
1:49:18 And it's gonna cost this much money.
1:49:20 So we want to give you the opportunity
1:49:22 to make the educated decisions.
1:49:25 We're certainly on track with the budget,
1:49:27 the baseline budget.
1:49:29 But I do see some additional needs driving costs up.
1:49:36 We have anything further, Council.
1:49:39 I just want to say a great presentation.
1:49:41 Thank you for a lot of information and clarifications.
1:49:46 I was gonna make a joke about the elevator,
1:49:48 elevating the costs, but you took that away from me.
1:49:52 Tom, thank you, Michael and Clint.
1:49:54 Thank all three of you for your presentation.
1:49:59 Council, I have a question for you.
1:50:00 I'm ready to forge ahead,
1:50:01 but is there anybody that needs to take break
1:50:03 before we do the last two items?
1:50:06 All right, next item is consideration of a request
1:50:09 to approve a memorandum of understanding
1:50:12 Between the city of Twin Falls and the urban renewal agency, we have our city manager, Trev Strathorn.
1:50:17 Well, Mr. Mayor, members of the council, before you is a very simple memorandum of understanding.
1:50:22 In this memorandum of understanding, it allows for the coordination of the demolition of the aspects,
1:50:29 not only for the banner building, but also to achieve greater economies of scale if they're available for the Rogerson building, as well as the existing fountain area.
1:50:38 In the current contract that we have with STAR, it allows us to not only look at that building but also areas of influence, that's what I call it, or areas that could be impacted by that.
1:50:48 What we would like to do is enter into this agreement with the agency so that we bid this as one overall package to have one coordinated effort,
1:50:58 but we would have a scope A and a scope B so that we could fully separate those costs.
1:51:03 Those costs that would be of the agencies would be completely remitted back to the city and so there is really no
1:51:12 Each each entity is going to cover their own respective piece of the project, but it just allows for greater coordination of work
1:51:21 Really this came from a conversation by the old tech, but also with star in making sure that there was a
1:51:27 Coordinated effort in a very very confined space. We felt that this was the best way to do that
1:51:32 The agreement that you have was drafted by our city attorney, and so it probably obviously
1:51:39 meets legal review.
1:51:41 And then the second is it was approved by the Urban Renewal Agency earlier today, being
1:51:45 entered into that agreement.
1:51:46 So for the agreement to become effective, we would just need a motion and then have the
1:51:52 authorization for the mayor to execute it.
1:51:54 I just wanted a clarification.
1:51:56 our copy star is misspelled on the actual copy that is to be signed is spelled
1:52:03 correctly you have two Rs. Okay try and take care of me Michael. Greg
1:52:07 Lanning. We're all I move that we approve the memoround of understanding between
1:52:12 the city to enforce the urban renewal agency and authorize the mayor to sign
1:52:17 such a set agreement. Second. I have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanning
1:52:22 seconded by Sean Barrieger as stated. Anything further on that motion council?
1:52:26 Sharon, roll call vote please.
1:52:29 Sean Barrieger. Yes.
1:52:31 Chris Tockingpin. Yes.
1:52:33 Greg Lanting. Yes.
1:52:34 Don Hall. Yes.
1:52:36 Rebecca Mills-Soyka. Yes.
1:52:38 Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Jim Mann.
1:52:41 Yes. Motion passes 7-0.
1:52:44 We will now move to public input.
1:52:46 Is there anyone here from the public that would like to address the council?
1:52:49 Thank you. I'm hungry.
1:52:53 Any other items from our city manager?
1:52:56 Just one briefly, Mr. Mayor, members of the council,
1:52:59 and also for the community,
1:53:00 we will be closed on Wednesday
1:53:01 and observation Veterans Day.
1:53:04 Thank you very much.
1:53:05 And I was going to mention that as well.
1:53:07 Tomorrow actually is the Marine Corps birthday.
1:53:10 So happy birthday, Marines.
1:53:13 And then Wednesday is Veterans Day.
1:53:16 Please get out to all the fitting celebrations
1:53:21 for both these events.
1:53:21 City park.
1:53:22 City Park. What time Chris? 11. 11 o'clock City Park on
1:53:26 Wednesday. 11th hour. Thank you, Chris. Any great line?
1:53:33 I'd like to I'll make this very brief. This was a weakness of the
1:53:36 hour here. But I was represented the AIC and I guess also the
1:53:42 City of Twin Falls. Oh, yeah, I see Pete O'Pills back at the
1:53:46 National League of Cities Convention in Nashville.
1:53:53 Nashville, pretty fun place to go, I've been there.
1:53:57 But one of the things I would like to bring back,
1:53:59 and there are certainly other things that I would,
1:54:01 the workshops and things I went to, were excellent.
1:54:08 We did have a speech by Vice President Joe Biden,
1:54:13 at one of our general sessions,
1:54:15 And by the way, he was a former city councilman,
1:54:18 so we were to start about two years on a city council
1:54:22 and then run for senate in one.
1:54:23 So a little quick transition there, US senate.
1:54:26 What is this one for Greg?
1:54:27 Yeah, I have it.
1:54:29 The thing, but anyway, one of the things he talked about
1:54:31 was the fact that I'm not sure if you remember
1:54:34 the exact organization that has surveyed the companies
1:54:37 that have moved to China.
1:54:39 And one of their plans for the future and things in the
1:54:43 The startling statistic was 54% are looking to move back to the United States, because of the energy and other climate that has made it look for the coming.
1:54:54 That their trickle of them coming back now could soon become a flood of companies back coming back to China.
1:55:03 But he talked about the things that cities need to do to facilitate that flood.
1:55:09 And the two things I think we have been looking at and are in the head of the curb are certainly thinking about it was one we was the upgrade to
1:55:19 infrastructure the companies all said before we can come back we need these things upgraded so we can and we have used urban and
1:55:26 are able to do this but we made little ago things upgrades to infrastructure including streets water wastewater fiber
1:55:34 Rock Creek's power, broadband, all the things that they need to be able to come back to the United States,
1:55:39 things that they're getting there that they weren't getting here.
1:55:42 And then the other was one we have highlighted is work first training.
1:55:47 And the fact that they need a train and skilled workforce to be able to bring their company back to the United States
1:55:54 to utilize that and of course, Vice President Biden, who was highlighting some of the administration's programs,
1:56:01 was talking about their initiative to provide for free public education through the community
1:56:10 college level. And that doesn't necessarily mean academic, but that would mean that you
1:56:14 would welding HVAC, wind power, all the different things that we offer here at CSI amongst a
1:56:23 bunch of missed, I'm sure. Law enforcement. Thank you. But those are one of the things
1:56:29 talked about but I thought it's interesting though it's the exact things that we feel like
1:56:33 we've been working on here in Twin Falls is exactly what you could have given that
1:56:37 speech. Do they? Instead of Biden? Yeah well we're doing that. But again it was an interesting
1:56:45 conference and again the city of Twin Falls did not pay for me to go to the
1:56:50 Association by the city's pay for me to go. So who was it again to pay? Association by the city's
1:56:55 Then why don't you think I was back there on the city die?
1:56:58 So thank you Greg, that's a good report.
1:57:00 Anything else from council?
1:57:03 We are adjourned.
1:57:09 And you got to see Justin Bieber, no, it wasn't Justin Bieber.
1:57:13 It wasn't Justin Bieber.
Download
- Transcript (text) 109 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 143 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 193 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.2 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 6.4 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, November 9, 2015. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:57:19.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
364a5560683b1f929e889943a6fcc8c90a3caedae5087cc2220c028b5b8bde15 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a e3b141e245da34a3fe305c57fd0ae57ade9bd15a89333f8830eff52f0eafddc0
part02.m4a a41aa7e1314b08d73d05e56f59b1a6b8397fcdd45fa293593ff0a678016ae8bf - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
9239175d977e738c12dbf378f06b18ea414d981716b24299e0ad77227a8d6299
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file