City Council meeting
Monday, December 7, 2015
Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:00:00 Order, it's Monday, December 7, 2015.
0:00:03 And you know, we usually start off our meetings with the Pledge of Allegiance, but we put that off.
0:00:08 But I'm going to do it anyway, right at the beginning of this meeting.
0:00:11 So those of you wishing to join us, please rise.
0:00:13 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:00:29 We do have a quorum of the City Council, thank you all for being here this evening, Jim Mundt.
0:00:35 I'm not sure if it's going to be able to make it, he was on a conference call, and so we'll see if he's able to make it later.
0:00:41 We are meeting early at 3.30 for the purposes of spending some time with our local legislators,
0:00:47 and I want to be the first to welcome them and thank them for being here.
0:00:50 So at this time we're going to go ahead and just move down to the, I was going to say the pit, but that's not right.
0:01:00 right, the round table, the square tables.
0:01:03 Absolutely.
0:01:37 Yeah.
0:01:57 The microphones may work.
0:02:01 Mine's working, and so it's going to be, I'm going to be here talking a little bit.
0:02:09 We are streaming now.
0:02:10 So first, thank you for joining us today.
0:02:24 We have had this opportunity in the past.
0:02:27 It's really a good opportunity for us to kind of connect with the members of our local delegation,
0:02:32 and kind of share some of the issues
0:02:34 that we see coming up in this legislative session.
0:02:38 But before that, we want to spend a little bit of time
0:02:41 maybe catching you up with where the City of Twin Falls
0:02:44 is today and the path that we've been on
0:02:47 over the course of the last year.
0:02:51 We are streaming this meeting right now
0:02:54 and what we're going to do is as,
0:02:57 I would encourage it to be interactive.
0:02:59 And as you ask questions of either me
0:03:01 or any of the other presenters that will be before you.
0:03:05 We will repeat the question so that the members who will
0:03:10 either watching this now live or who may look at it later
0:03:14 will have the opportunity to understand the question
0:03:16 that was asked and the response that was provided.
0:03:19 We also have an agenda before you that's covering
0:03:22 some of the major topics you'll see today.
0:03:24 We want to talk about urban renewal legislation.
0:03:26 Melinda's going to cover that.
0:03:28 Brian Pike, our Deputy City Manager, along with Captain Anthony Barnhart, will be having
0:03:33 a conversation with you about body cameras.
0:03:35 It's an important topic for us.
0:03:38 We also want to spend some time talking about primacy and waste stormwater fees.
0:03:44 Jackie Fields is going to cover those projects.
0:03:47 We also have a couple of members of our Council who have the privilege of serving on the AIC
0:03:53 Board, as well as other members of the Council who have been actively involved in legislative
0:03:58 issues until we want to give them an opportunity to share.
0:04:01 And then at the end, we'd really like to kind of get your
0:04:04 perspective on what you might be seeing and things that we might
0:04:07 need to be aware of and things that we need to kind of keep moving
0:04:13 forward. So again, I hope that the next hour and a half or
0:04:16 thereabouts is a really nice, interactive conversation.
0:04:18 With that, I'm going to kind of start our presentation after I
0:04:21 turn it over to the mayor. My name is Travis Rothweiler. I'm
0:04:29 the city manager. So one of the things that we really like to
0:04:39 emphasize is everything that the City of Twin Falls does is based upon a strategic plan.
0:04:45 That strategic plan was created in concert with our citizens and it carries eight primary
0:04:51 objectives.
0:04:52 Those eight objectives are issued up there and you'll notice that it requires partnerships
0:04:57 for us to realize our vision.
0:05:01 The local delegation is part of that partnership.
0:05:03 We really need you and the partnerships to be able to continue to do the things that we
0:05:08 want to do and we are going to continue to hopefully build relationships and continue
0:05:14 to build opportunities that we can take advantage of other opportunities in the future.
0:05:18 This year we are also going to be going forward and updating our strategic plan.
0:05:23 The City Council authorized funding in this year's budget to update our strategic plan
0:05:29 as well as our citizen survey and so we will start a citizen survey.
0:05:32 use those results to begin redefining and taking a look at the goals that are articulated
0:05:40 in our strategic plan.
0:05:41 Our strategic plan is online and it really covers the time frame over the course of between
0:05:47 today and the year 2030 and then it's broke out into five-year increments and we fund
0:05:52 those immediate five-year plans today.
0:05:57 One of the things that we like to share is how we're being good stewards of our resources
0:06:04 and honoring our fiduciary responsibility locally.
0:06:08 What we've illustrated here is kind of a spread chart and if you've gone to our budgeting processes
0:06:15 this becomes very, very familiar and it's updated with the final numbers that we received from
0:06:21 the county.
0:06:22 And so our tax rate for this upcoming year decreased another $0.6 per $1,000 of taxable
0:06:27 value went from $7.66 to $7.60.
0:06:33 Everything that we talk about in those charts and graphs really represents the average home
0:06:37 inside the City of Twin Falls.
0:06:38 And that average median value house is $144,000.
0:06:43 And as a result, that individual, that family will enjoy a $5.46 decrease in their property
0:06:50 taxes that are assessed by the city. In addition to that we were able to hold the water and the sewer fees flat and we found the opportunity to reduce the sanitation fee by 66 cents. And so the monthly savings to our residents is $1.11 per month for an annualized savings of $13.32 this at a time in which the cost of doing business for us grew about 1.25%.
0:07:19 What we like to do is we like to illustrate the net taxable value of the city by comparison to the prior year
0:07:29 again for the budget that was
0:07:32 adopted in 2016 the total taxable value grew to two point three one three billion dollars
0:07:39 Up from two point two six four
0:07:42 That increase allowed us to help decrease the total tax rate
0:07:46 And so we were able to take a look at our local spending and we held that in check.
0:07:51 We did not take the full 3% that is authorized by statute.
0:07:55 We took one and a half percent plus the growth formula.
0:07:59 Our foregone balance now has grown to excess of $2 million.
0:08:03 It is one of the largest foregone balances in the state and certainly one of the largest
0:08:08 in our area.
0:08:09 A foregone balance in excess of $2 million represents about a 12 and a half percent property
0:08:15 tax savings to our residents. The value of that foregone and the opportunity that exists
0:08:23 is I think very important for us as an organization. We do not take 3% because we recognize that
0:08:31 at some point in time if there was a true need and the Council saw that need, that opportunity
0:08:38 to collect those resources are there. Without that ability, organizations may be more inclined
0:08:45 to take that 3% on an annual basis.
0:08:48 We believe in being good stewards
0:08:49 and taking only what's available,
0:08:51 but we also need to have access to resources
0:08:53 should those critical needs and junctures rise.
0:08:57 And so we would ask that in that foregone formula,
0:09:00 that that be something that be preserved
0:09:02 in this legislative session
0:09:04 and not be something that is taken away
0:09:07 from local government entities
0:09:09 and all local government institutions for that matter.
0:09:15 One of the things that has really continued
0:09:17 to drive our local economy is the issuance of building permits.
0:09:22 And you'll notice that in this report,
0:09:24 the city had a 21.7% increase in the total number
0:09:28 of single family permits that issued this year
0:09:32 in comparison to the prior year.
0:09:34 And this is the fourth year that we've seen an increase
0:09:38 in the issuance of single family permits.
0:09:41 In 2011, we issued a low of 98 permits.
0:09:44 And you can see that that is growing up
0:09:45 to the 230 permits that we issued just last year.
0:09:50 We continue to expect to see that number remain pretty close
0:09:54 to that 200 to 230 mark in the upcoming years.
0:10:00 Representative Clow was on the council at a time
0:10:03 in which the city was doing 650 building permits in 2006
0:10:08 and 2007.
0:10:09 We don't anticipate those days coming back,
0:10:13 But we really do believe that the level of growth
0:10:16 that we're having right now is allowing us
0:10:18 to reasonably meet those needs.
0:10:21 We're also making some investments in our infrastructure
0:10:24 that I'll talk about a little later.
0:10:26 That will allow us to open up additional lands.
0:10:28 That will allow us to create additional
0:10:30 single family residents.
0:10:32 New commercial was also a huge driving factor for us.
0:10:35 You can see that it grew by 63.9%.
0:10:39 That commercial factor is really good for not only expansion of the tax base, but also
0:10:46 for the creation of job and job opportunities, redevelopment of downtown, creating additional
0:10:52 retail opportunities within our community.
0:10:55 We don't by matter of economic development practices go after an attract retail, but retail
0:11:00 does provide an important segment to our community as it continues to create a more well-rounded
0:11:06 local economy.
0:11:08 And then the City of Twin Falls is one of the few cities and the only city in our area that
0:11:12 also issues mechanical, electrical, and building permits and that data is reflected up there.
0:11:18 We do that inside the city boundaries, inside the area of impact that is now a service that
0:11:23 is offered by the state, the state through the county is elected to take that back over.
0:11:32 The total values you can see there, the total value of all the permits issued grew by 88.7%.
0:11:39 the total value of all permits inside the City of Twin Falls
0:11:42 exceeded $162 million.
0:11:45 It's a bit of a skewed number because it also
0:11:48 includes the new school.
0:11:50 So not all the $162 million is going to go to increased
0:11:55 taxable value.
0:11:56 But what it does is it represents growth
0:11:58 inside of our community.
0:12:00 It also includes the Cliff Bar Project moving forward.
0:12:13 This is an area that I think that probably
0:12:16 deserves a little bit of attention in our focus.
0:12:18 And while we have a really strong and robust local economy,
0:12:22 one of the things that we need to continue to be mindful of
0:12:26 is talent attraction.
0:12:29 Talent attraction is something that every community that
0:12:34 has seen good, strong growth is now
0:12:37 beginning to try to find a way to move forward.
0:12:41 It's a conversation that in Twin Falls,
0:12:42 we first started having in 2006 and 2007, and even in 2000, I believe we had that conversation
0:12:50 for the first time.
0:12:51 And as the economy continues to move and heat up, you can illustrate where we're at based
0:12:57 upon the October numbers.
0:12:58 And you can see that the city of Twin Falls is unemployment rate is 3.4% and the micropolicinarias
0:13:04 is 3.4%.
0:13:07 This percentage is don't tell the whole story.
0:13:09 And what is illustrated in there is 3.3% is represented by 794 people inside the city
0:13:18 of Flint Falls that are unemployed, 794 people.
0:13:24 And last time I heard the Idaho Department of Labor had in excess of 1200 job openings.
0:13:31 The unemployment rate that you see here is pre-Cliff Bar moving forward with their significant
0:13:37 recruitment.
0:13:38 They're going to continue to make those hires and move forward with their first wave of production.
0:13:46 We believe that in the end, they'll employ somewhere between 200 and 250 employees that
0:13:52 are not included in this number.
0:13:55 In the entire micropolitan area, there are 1,745 people that are unemployed.
0:14:04 Economists will tell you, depending upon which one you listen to, that full employment occurs
0:14:08 at four or five percent.
0:14:10 It either case, both the state of Idaho and the city of Twin Falls and our micropolitan
0:14:16 area are now considered to be at full employment.
0:14:19 And so as we continue to look at talent attraction, this is an issue that not only impacts the
0:14:24 of Twin Falls, but it's also going to be an issue that's going to impact the state.
0:14:29 Having the ability to bring talent into our community to assure companies like Jibani,
0:14:34 like Columbia, like Cliffbar, that we have the labor force ready to go to work for them
0:14:41 is going to be important as we continue to try to grow our local economy.
0:14:48 If there are any efforts that we can assist or partner with the state on in terms of talent
0:14:53 and talent attraction, we'd certainly want to come to the table on those.
0:15:00 And again, we've talked a little bit about our economic successes, but we like to always
0:15:04 share that.
0:15:05 Those three companies right there represent $650 million of total value and over 5,000 direct
0:15:17 and indirect job opportunities.
0:15:20 We continue to realize the benefits of those companies in our community, whether that be
0:15:25 be the downtown improvement projects, whether it be continued requests for information about
0:15:32 our local economy.
0:15:34 We are still continuing to move forward in the areas of economic development.
0:15:37 We don't believe that you can just turn off the switch and stop.
0:15:40 We believe that momentum is too hard to restart and recapture, and so we want to be measured
0:15:46 in our approach of economic development, recognizing that we have a talent issue, but
0:15:51 We also need to make sure that we're continuing to grow our local economy so that we don't
0:15:56 revert back to days of just turning that over to the Urban Renewal Agency.
0:16:03 Part of that is investing in our infrastructure and our wastewater treatment plant is soon to
0:16:10 be completely finished.
0:16:12 It is going to be under budget and it is right on schedule.
0:16:15 So knock on wood, that's a great place to be, right?
0:16:20 It's going to give us some opportunities to continue to move forward with other collection
0:16:25 line improvements and other strategies to enhance our infrastructure.
0:16:30 One of the things that we really like to talk about is since 2007, Jackie Fields and
0:16:36 the engineering team have overseen over $150 million of public improvements inside the city
0:16:43 of Twin Falls.
0:16:45 That includes arsenic, that includes wastewater treatment, but that also includes the Will's
0:16:48 Booster Station which is a project that the council has authorized the use of cash reserves
0:16:54 to open up additional lands in the south of our community for talent-based housing.
0:17:00 It's going to open up approximately 1,700 additional building lots for families and we
0:17:06 hope that that's going to be one of those key ingredients just as education, just as health
0:17:11 care, affordable housing or part of those pillars that will help us hopefully be an attraction
0:17:17 for young families choosing Twin Falls that can be added to our labor force.
0:17:22 It also includes improvements out at our airport.
0:17:27 This is a really, really big time inside the City of Twin Falls and the level and investment
0:17:31 that we're making in our community.
0:17:34 Probably rivals what anybody else is doing inside the state of Idaho, you know, from wastewater
0:17:39 treatment to water to roads to maintenance, I mean, it's really an exciting time and we're
0:17:44 going to kind of talk about downtown and City Hall in just a minute. So Mitch told me I had to go this way.
0:17:54 But part of that infrastructure also is a strong education system. Now I'm part of the city strategic
0:18:00 plan, talks about a learning community and we're really, when you take a look at that critical
0:18:06 infrastructure piece, the investment that is going on by our schools is part of that.
0:18:11 It's not done by the city, but it's done as part of our community and celebrating the accomplishments
0:18:17 of the Twin Falls School District.
0:18:18 I know that you spent time with Dr. Dobbs and they kind of really showcased what they did.
0:18:23 We recognized them as a real valued partner and for a community that they have allocated
0:18:29 over $125 million in capital improvements to their public education system causes us to
0:18:36 also be the envy of a local area.
0:18:41 One of the things that we're doing and we're partnering with the Urban Rural Agency on a
0:18:45 project is to really kind of reinvent our downtown and continue that creation of cool spaces.
0:18:52 The downtown is that heart of our community.
0:18:55 It is that place downtown separate and make places different.
0:19:00 They provide that unique culture of a community.
0:19:03 The Urban Renewal Agency is using tax increment financing to restore Main Street, to go forward
0:19:09 and enhance the infrastructure in that area to allow
0:19:13 for additional growth and development.
0:19:15 Over the course of the last few years,
0:19:18 we've seen 30 new businesses locate
0:19:21 in the larger downtown core area.
0:19:23 And we believe this project is going to enable us
0:19:25 to continue to see additional growth, additional development
0:19:30 and help create those places that continue to be an attraction
0:19:33 for young and other members of our community
0:19:36 to come into Twin Falls.
0:19:38 Part of that is going to be a city hall complex
0:19:42 that we're really excited about.
0:19:44 This kind of shows a bird's eye view.
0:19:47 If you are standing on top of the Idaho Youth Ranch Building,
0:19:51 you can see off to the, what would be your left,
0:19:55 there's a plaza.
0:19:56 That's where the Rogerson Hotel currently stands
0:19:58 that will come down.
0:19:59 It will be forming into a community plaza.
0:20:02 And then we're going to repurpose an old department
0:20:06 store and furniture store and turning it
0:20:07 into a modern city hall and municipal complex.
0:20:12 We believe that this is going to be a catalyst
0:20:14 for growth and opportunity, and we're also using
0:20:16 cash reserves to help advance this project.
0:20:20 We've been able to be frugal with our resources,
0:20:22 and we're going to apply that by reinvesting in our spaces.
0:20:26 This is also going to allow us to invest
0:20:28 into public safety facilities, which the current city hall
0:20:33 and the current police station will be, again,
0:20:36 also repurposed and retrofitted to serve as a command center and an operation center for
0:20:42 our growing police department. What's interesting about our police department, and there's lots
0:20:46 of different data that we're starting to review, but inside the City of Twin Falls, slightly
0:20:52 less than half of all the individuals who are cited and individuals who receive misdemeanors
0:20:57 by the Twin Falls Police Department have addresses outside of the City of Twin Falls as corporate
0:21:02 and so as we continue to grow and we continue to expand and we continue to be that urban
0:21:09 center for a population in excess of 250,000 people, we would really like, I would really
0:21:17 like the opportunity to at least ask, at least ask our citizens to see if they're supportive
0:21:24 of a local option sales tax. Right now we are not able to even ask that question and
0:21:30 And I don't know if they would say yes, and I don't know if they would say no.
0:21:34 But I don't know if it's fair to the citizens of Twin Falls to have to pay for the level
0:21:40 of services to support a community in excess of a daytime population, in excess of 75,000
0:21:45 people on a tax base that's supported by 46,000.
0:21:51 And so we would just, if the opportunity arose, and there was an opportunity for us to
0:21:57 ask our citizens if it's something that they supported, that might be something that, at
0:22:03 least I would appreciate, I don't know what the council stance is on that, but I think that
0:22:07 at least being able to ask would help maybe take those revenues and help offset other types
0:22:14 of things that we're trying to do in our community.
0:22:17 Whether that be through Senate or Windows proposal in the expansion of infrastructure, I think
0:22:23 that that would be also something that would be welcome and received.
0:22:29 So just some final thoughts before we turn it over to some questions and then move it over
0:22:33 to other individuals on our list.
0:22:36 What we're seeing is the continuation of a really vibrant economy and we're excited about
0:22:42 that.
0:22:43 The vibrancy is in part because of our partnership with the Urban Renewal Agency and their ability
0:22:49 to utilize taxing from and financing to support really large industrial businesses moving forward.
0:22:56 We're going to continue to invest in our infrastructure as a city, and we do that in partnership with
0:23:00 the agency, but we believe having good infrastructure, sound infrastructure is going to allow us to
0:23:05 continue to attract additional business opportunities.
0:23:10 And then last, I really appreciate the relationship that we have with each of you.
0:23:14 I know that we can call you not only and have you come on Pearl Harbor Day, but we can also
0:23:23 engage in a conversation with you throughout the legislative session and I know that what
0:23:28 I appreciate about the relationship is the phone works both ways, that you are often engaging
0:23:33 with us also about questions that you have about legislation that is upcoming and so we
0:23:39 really appreciate that.
0:23:40 I appreciate that relationship.
0:23:41 I know that the relationship that we possess is not the same that other members may possess
0:23:48 with their local delegation and I just am very appreciative of that. So if that
0:23:54 stands for any questions that you might have on my presentation, if not, I will
0:23:59 turn it over to Melinda Anderson to talk about economic development and urban
0:24:03 renewal legislation in particular. Yes sir. No, most of that is inside the city's
0:24:25 corporate boundaries. So in the actual number three of them are going to be
0:24:43 schools. When you take a look at the value piece where you see that it is
0:24:50 growing by 149 percent, the values are going to largely be driven not only by
0:24:56 the three new schools and Cliff Bar which are either one tax exempt by being a
0:25:02 local government entity or two those tax resources are going to cover the
0:25:08 initial infrastructure investment that is being paid for by Cliff Bar right now, but
0:25:15 it's also the commercial development that has occurred along the rim and also
0:25:18 commercial development that we're seeing and repurposing the properties throughout
0:25:22 our entire community. Yes sir. It's going to be like carports, decks, you know,
0:25:39 anything that's over about a hundred and twenty square feet I believe requires a
0:25:43 building permit so it's going to be those that are going to be attached to a
0:25:49 residential property but not an actual dwelling itself. Same with then the
0:25:54 miscellaneous commercial is going to kind of fall into that same same general
0:25:58 category. Yes sir. At schedule. Yep. CMGC. So I got to get to the habit of
0:26:19 answering. So the question was in term the wastewater treatment plant is coming
0:26:24 under budget representative Clow asked what method did we use and whether we
0:26:29 use the new CMGC process. We did not on the wastewater treatment plant, we used the more
0:26:37 sealed-bit approach to the traditional approach. We are using the CMGC approach on the City
0:26:44 Hall project as well as the public safety building. We have gone through the RFQ process
0:26:53 for both the selection of the architect as well as the selection of the general contractor,
0:26:58 Hummel Architects is the architect of record and star corporation will be serving as our general
0:27:03 contractor on the project.
0:27:18 We will keep you informed of what that looks like, absolutely.
0:27:33 Two years.
0:27:34 So, the question was asked is whether or not the CMGC process was available for the city
0:27:39 to consider at the time of the waste of our treatment plant and we don't believe that it
0:27:42 was and if it was, it was very much in its infancy and we had already selected the path
0:27:47 have to move forward on the traditional bidding process.
0:27:54 Thank you for your questions.
0:27:55 With that, I'm going to turn it over to.
0:27:57 Good afternoon, everyone.
0:28:40 Thank you as Travis said for coming today as you do every year.
0:28:43 It's really nice to be able to have this conversation with you all to have this.
0:28:51 So Travis, we got this up, so as usual work, we don't work through our technical problems
0:29:04 or my lack of ability to figure out how to make this thing work.
0:29:10 These here, so our experts here, while we're getting that up,
0:29:19 I just also want to echo what Travis said about.
0:29:22 We thank our local delegation for your support of urban renewal.
0:29:27 And over the past, I've been, so this would have been my 10th
0:29:32 legislative season coming up in 2016.
0:29:35 And every single legislative season,
0:29:37 And I've spent a good part of it in Boise, helping legislators understand the impact of
0:29:42 urban renewal and what potential decisions that you make can affect urban renewal.
0:29:46 And that's our economic development and placemaking activities.
0:29:50 So I just want to thank you all very much for your support in that.
0:29:54 And also with the council, while the Urban Renewal Board is a separate,
0:30:00 urban renewal agency is separate agency from the city and the board is all private.
0:30:06 We have a really strong partnership with the Council on all of our projects and the City
0:30:12 Council and their Renewal Agency Board have really worked hand-in-hand on all of the projects
0:30:16 moving forward.
0:30:17 So it's really worked, our model has really worked well for us.
0:30:20 It doesn't say, it's the same model that every community in the State of Idaho should
0:30:24 use but it has really worked here in Twin Falls.
0:30:28 So this particular presentation was made by Ryan Armbuster last Friday at the AIC legislative
0:30:36 session.
0:30:37 And I'm just basically going to go through this with you for a few minutes and talk about
0:30:42 what Brian, Ryan did.
0:30:44 As with, as what Ryan has done with a lot of, Ryan, I'm sure you all know, but he's one
0:30:48 of the foremost urban renewal attorneys in the state of Idaho.
0:30:52 And he makes lots of presentations in front of all kinds of groups all year round, including
0:30:57 legislators.
0:30:59 So Ryan does a lot of discussing what historically has been going on with urban renewal legislation
0:31:07 And then what maybe also he goes into what will be going forward in the future.
0:31:12 So 2010, not much happened.
0:31:16 There was a big bill that was presented, but it didn't get anywhere.
0:31:20 It didn't get a hearing.
0:31:21 It just wasn't ready, and so we moved on to 2011.
0:31:26 Where a lot of that legislation from the year before became House Bill 95,
0:31:32 where there were great many changes made, and
0:31:34 I really wish I would have brought my glasses.
0:31:38 I've gotten to the point where I now have to wear them almost
0:31:42 all the time, unfortunately.
0:31:45 There was just a lot of information regarding how
0:31:48 to fill vacancies, how to remove urban renewal board
0:31:53 commissioners, how the chair vice-chair is elected each year
0:31:59 by the urban renewal board, the fact
0:32:02 that we needed to provide an annual report
0:32:04 to the local governing body,
0:32:07 which for us is the city of Twin Falls.
0:32:09 And then extended the period of time from 30 to 60 days
0:32:16 once planning and zoning has approved a new TIFF plan
0:32:19 or an amendment to a TIFF plan
0:32:21 so that people have more opportunity to comment on it.
0:32:25 So those are the big ideas from the 2011 legislative session,
0:32:30 legislative session, along with forest land being excluded from deteriorating areas.
0:32:37 Oh, and also the big, really big thing that affected us was how plans can be amended.
0:32:45 For instance, geographically, we couldn't do any more shoestringing.
0:32:48 The plan, the new geographic area being added had to be actually adjacent to it.
0:32:53 You couldn't expand the urban renewal district by any more than 10 percent, and that was
0:32:59 a one-time deal only.
0:33:00 So as you recall, we did that here in Twin Falls back in 2012.
0:33:05 We expanded our downtown Fort Ash 1 TIFF district by 10% so
0:33:10 that we could work on the main avenue project.
0:33:13 So that's how we were getting started with that.
0:33:18 Let's see, lifespan of the newly created district was reduced from 24 years to 20,
0:33:24 which does impact a lot of projects.
0:33:27 projects either have to be reduced in scale or don't get happen because they can't generate
0:33:33 enough $5 through property taxes for a long enough period of time to be able to pay for
0:33:39 that project. So it has had an effect on urban renewal.
0:33:46 So there wasn't a lot that happened in 2012 to 2014. 2013, as you know, you've all passed
0:33:57 a property tax, personal property tax exemption, which does also impact the urban renewal agencies
0:34:02 along with all the other public taxing agencies around the state.
0:34:09 So 2015, last year, at the beginning of the year, or excuse me, fall of 2015, in October,
0:34:15 specifically a group of legislators and other folks, including myself, drove down to Salt Lake
0:34:22 for a couple of days to see how Utah uses it.
0:34:25 because you've all have heard, they use it really differently from the state of Idaho.
0:34:30 They use it up there, much more expansive in the use and the kinds of projects that they will use it.
0:34:36 They use sales tax as well as income tax as part of TIF dollars, not just constructed to property taxes.
0:34:45 So what we learned was there were really a lot of differences between the two states and how we use TIF dollars.
0:34:53 So as you know, Speaker Bedke created the interim committee
0:34:58 to work through last spring sessions from January
0:35:02 through April, I believe.
0:35:03 So once a week, a group of folks got together,
0:35:07 legislators along with people like myself got together
0:35:11 and talked about what kind of changes
0:35:13 can should be we be making to urban renewal.
0:35:17 An early original attempt was to try to modernize
0:35:21 urban renewal statutes.
0:35:23 Instead of trying to make economic development into urban renewal, we wanted to separate
0:35:30 them so that they both had their own chapters.
0:35:33 They do right now, but to make it even clearer than what it is right now.
0:35:38 By the end of the six weeks or so that we all met, there wasn't a lot of consensus on
0:35:43 what any legislative changes should be.
0:35:46 At that point, you all approved HCR-17 to create the Summertime Interim Committee to meet which
0:35:54 Representative Clow is a part of as well.
0:35:57 I believe you started meeting in August of this year, Lance, and then I think you will
0:36:03 have your next meeting, your last meeting this next Monday, and you've been meeting once
0:36:08 a month since then, I understand, thanks.
0:36:17 So this is just the people who sit on that committee, it's five senators and five representatives.
0:36:24 I mentioned Representative Clow being representing our area that's on it.
0:36:32 So these are just the next couple slides are just talking about what the interim committee
0:36:37 discussed during those sessions that have been going on since August.
0:36:42 as usual, I mean, reviewing of history, reviewing of statutes, talk about best practices, about
0:36:50 how various communities use urban renewal, what people feel like we do correctly or not,
0:36:57 accountability.
0:37:02 A lot of testimony from a lot of different folks, both really wanting to look at modernizing
0:37:09 but a lot of people wanting to really focus on reform.
0:37:12 So again, I've either listened to or attended most of the sessions
0:37:17 of these committee meetings.
0:37:19 And I think at the last session in November is really when
0:37:24 legislators like Representative Klaus
0:37:26 are to bring for potential legislation to consider for this committee
0:37:31 to consider to move forward on.
0:37:35 And Representative Klaus may want to take some time after I'm finished
0:37:38 talking about what his perspective is on this.
0:37:42 So there's a lot of discussion around board makeup
0:37:48 and how they get either get appointed or elected,
0:37:52 how we pay for public buildings.
0:37:54 We want to use TIFF.
0:37:55 That was a big thing that came out of last legislative session
0:37:59 was we want to use TIFF for use in public buildings.
0:38:02 And if we do, what kind of public buildings?
0:38:04 Or no TIFF for public buildings.
0:38:07 We wanted to again consolidate the blight and community development, but separate those two
0:38:12 from pure economic development projects.
0:38:15 Talk about accountability, make sure agencies are transparent and accountable to citizens within
0:38:21 the state.
0:38:23 How we control our finances, central repository is part of that transparency issue, enforcement,
0:38:29 who should be enforcing any statutes that are on there.
0:38:32 How does that happen?
0:38:34 And then how we can we modify plans.
0:38:38 So some of the things that were discussed were election of board members.
0:38:42 One of the ideas that came up was to provide an option by community.
0:38:46 Do you want to elect your local urban renewal commissioners or do you want to have city council
0:38:51 or that local governing body appoint them?
0:38:55 How many terms should they have?
0:38:57 We talked about an option to establish a limit on terms like we do here in Twin Falls.
0:39:01 As you probably know, we have a limit of two terms of three years each for board members
0:39:07 on our Urban Renewal Agency Board.
0:39:13 Provide some, you know, talk about how we may change the base values of revenue allocation
0:39:21 areas.
0:39:23 So also public buildings, we're still talking about those public buildings, what can be funded
0:39:29 by Urban Renewal, limitations, maybe there's a percentage of how much either the buildings
0:39:36 worth or how much TIFF could be put in, could affect how much the urban renewal agency may
0:39:40 get involved in that.
0:39:43 Maybe there should be an election to vote on the project at all.
0:39:49 Plan specifics, one of the things is to provide an annual progress report on the state of projects
0:39:57 of that urban renewal house.
0:39:59 We here typically have an annual meeting within the urban renewal board meeting and we also
0:40:04 have an annual audit that takes place that we also present.
0:40:08 We can definitely present that to City Council as well.
0:40:12 That's not an issue for us.
0:40:13 And so there's just wanting to, you know, some of this transparency, I want to make sure people
0:40:17 understand what urban renewal agencies are doing around the state.
0:40:23 So modifying, there's been some discussion about resetting the base assessment role, especially
0:40:29 if you amend the plan, so which can be challenging for urban renewal agencies if we did.
0:40:34 So if we invented a plan and it got reset to the nuke, value of that new base year could
0:40:40 affect our ability to repay bonds off if we're losing some of the money that we had been using
0:40:46 to pay off those bonds.
0:40:51 Shell, your annual plan shall describe what kind of changes.
0:40:56 So over 20 years, sometimes things can change because the market changes and things that you
0:41:01 were planning to at the beginning of the plan may change seven or eight years down the road
0:41:05 if the market changes and it's really challenging at the beginning of a plan to say this is everything
0:41:11 we're going to do for 20 years and it will never change. That would be challenging for
0:41:16 anybody to be able to accomplish. So again, more transparency, a separate website or link
0:41:25 within the city. So we link urban renewal, our urban renewal within our city's website. So
0:41:30 it's already there. We already reposit our agency records everywhere. The other one is
0:41:36 to have urban renewal agencies not do any lobbying, but have them do their lobbying
0:41:43 through the city only through, say, AIC instead of RAI, which is the statewide urban renewal
0:41:55 association.
0:41:56 I think RAI was formed back in 2010.
0:41:58 I was one of the founding members, was because AIC was not able to effectively lobby for urban
0:42:06 renewal agencies.
0:42:07 that there were so many other issues that were going on
0:42:09 at the same time.
0:42:10 And so one of the recommendations from EIC
0:42:12 was to perhaps form, if everyone in the agency
0:42:17 should form their own statewide organization.
0:42:19 And it, or REI is not just lobbying.
0:42:22 It's all about really education of both the public
0:42:26 and how we put projects for working on,
0:42:30 how we go about doing our projects,
0:42:32 but also to educate our members of best practices
0:42:35 because we know that that's a concern as well,
0:42:38 making sure we're all doing it the way it should be done.
0:42:42 So there's some other modernizations
0:42:43 of oversight and penalties.
0:42:47 So I think what you probably hear from folks like myself is,
0:42:53 if there are gonna be public limitations,
0:42:54 let's really talk about how TIFF can play a part
0:42:59 or if it doesn't play a part,
0:43:00 and which public buildings are we talking about?
0:43:02 Perhaps for some, a city hall doesn't need
0:43:05 to be paid for through TIFF,
0:43:06 but maybe a fire station does,
0:43:09 because it certainly could be affected
0:43:11 by an urban renewal project.
0:43:15 Penalties, you know, everyone,
0:43:18 if we're not paying attention to what we should be doing,
0:43:21 they're sure we should be penalties,
0:43:22 and I think everybody understands that.
0:43:24 I think for the most part we all agree with that.
0:43:28 Clarify the amendment process.
0:43:29 I mean, we've talked about it a lot.
0:43:31 We probably do need to clarify it.
0:43:35 One of the things that we've been talking about a lot,
0:43:37 I mentioned earlier was trying to modernize. Really the big deal is separating economic
0:43:42 development projects from traditional urban renewal or community development projects.
0:43:47 I think that would be one of the biggest things that we could do in the state to really help
0:43:51 communities in Idaho is to be really clear about how we're using it. Again, all of we
0:43:59 talked about most of these already. And as I said, the next, and I think the last meeting
0:44:05 is this coming Monday, December 14th for this interim committee that was appointed by Speaker
0:44:09 Bed-Key.
0:44:10 I just, again, I want to thank you all for your support over the years.
0:44:15 Really, our local delegation has been very supportive of urban renewal statutes through
0:44:20 in Idaho, within the legislature, and I just want to thank you.
0:44:24 And if you have any questions, I'd certainly be glad to try to answer them.
0:44:45 Thank you, Representative Kauffman.
0:44:47 That's very kind.
0:44:48 Lance, did you have anything you want to talk about?
0:44:51 I do this.
0:45:22 One of the things I found interesting from your report, and I guess this came from RAI.
0:45:27 It came from Ryan Arbusto.
0:45:30 About, well, one was it, November 4th there about site was working with a legislator from
0:45:37 Northern Idaho, Senator Susa, who's in a hotbed area that has some real problems with
0:45:43 urban renewal. And I made the choice to kind of team up with her to come up with, well,
0:45:50 what are the problems in your area? And knowing what the strengths are down here. And there
0:45:55 is a common thread to things. One is, it seems like everybody around the state looks at Twin
0:46:02 Falls and say, what you guys are doing, you're doing right. And some of the things that we
0:46:07 do, I thought were state law, but we've just made individual decisions down here. For
0:46:13 For example, everything from term limits on a board, and I've heard, so when we came
0:46:21 up with a list, but it looks like you just kind of went down the list, and the first reaction
0:46:25 was, oh my God, I've gone to the dark side.
0:46:29 The clouds gone to the dark side on this, but it seems to me that people are starting to
0:46:33 realize what this list was attempting to do, and that was to one, put all of the issues
0:46:41 on the table so that we didn't each meeting come out and find a new issue to deal with.
0:46:46 So the idea was one of the things that we can find some common areas and we can look
0:46:51 at.
0:46:52 And I think that's what the whole purpose of that November 4th memo was that Senator
0:47:00 Susan and I put out.
0:47:03 And it really has gotten discussion to focus in on certain things.
0:47:07 And I want to point out a couple of examples is that some of the complaints that we heard
0:47:12 in meetings was that people get appointed to urban renewal boards around the state and they
0:47:17 never seem to go away.
0:47:19 They're on there forever.
0:47:22 And I said, well, my first reaction is, how can that be, isn't there a law that they can
0:47:27 only go to terms?
0:47:29 And then I, you know, I don't know if I called Fritz or not, but you got redirected to the
0:47:33 city code and we have it in city code, then it's two limits. You can technically do a part
0:47:38 of a third if you're appointed for a partial term. And so I'm reporting this stuff and then
0:47:43 all of a sudden people say, that's the way we should be doing it. You know, that's the way
0:47:45 we should be doing it. And then there was the questions like elections. And I said, well,
0:47:53 and also appointing city council members. It's interesting because a few years ago there was
0:47:57 a big Supreme Court case that they didn't want any elected official city council on urban
0:48:04 renewal boards. But then the Supreme Court upheld that position that you could. Now it
0:48:08 seems like a lot of people that were opposing that now they think they should all be elected
0:48:15 because they would rather have elected officials making urban renewal decisions. So you'll find
0:48:20 in a lot of these recommendations is that we're trying to say, all right, if the local
0:48:24 sponsoring community in the city and there's a few counties want to have an urban renewal
0:48:28 that agency and they want to elect their members from a public election they can write their
0:48:34 ordinance to do it that way if that's what they wish. It doesn't mean that the city's
0:48:38 one falls has to but they could do that and if you want to have term limits they could
0:48:44 do that if they wish and so most of these things when I looked down had very minimal impact
0:48:49 on what I thought the city has been doing.
0:48:54 One of the things that I think everyone needs to understand, and I didn't know this until
0:48:57 I got in the legislature and started working with different cities in more detail, is how
0:49:02 naive I was about the way other communities handle urban renewal.
0:49:08 But some of the other communities aren't using urban renewal for industrial development as
0:49:12 as much as they are truly to try and grow their city
0:49:16 and deal with the urban areas.
0:49:19 And in three major cities in the state,
0:49:26 virtually their urban renewal area,
0:49:29 and you think about ours, we have an urban renewal area,
0:49:31 it goes out into the presidential streets
0:49:33 and all of this area.
0:49:35 They are not in revenue allocation areas.
0:49:38 And in other cities, a hundred percent of the land
0:49:41 inside those urban renewal areas are revenue allocation areas.
0:49:46 And so people are saying, well, wait a minute, you've got all this land, all these homes,
0:49:50 and all the incremental taxes is going to urban renewal, none of it end for like 20 years or
0:49:57 originally 24, yet we don't have the money to service with police and fire all these areas.
0:50:06 So think about it until it falls.
0:50:07 If we had every home in the presidential streets and everything, all of the incremental taxes
0:50:12 from the day that those areas were formed, if all that tax was not going to the city or
0:50:18 the county or the highway district.
0:50:20 So we've tried to deal with that and recognize that there are some differences around the
0:50:26 state the way these things have been done.
0:50:28 But a lot of it has been philosophical.
0:50:31 I'm not sure it's interesting. There are things in the laws
0:50:36 that
0:50:37 There's two sections of code two chapters and they have different definitions
0:50:42 Some of them have a definition one chapter not the other. We're trying to look at those definitions
0:50:47 There are terms used in there
0:50:50 that
0:50:51 Do not you can't find a definition for and so we're trying to look at that
0:50:56 Some people want to have the term blight defined. I think Webster's did a pretty good job
0:51:01 But there's a, we have a definition called deteriorated area and
0:51:05 deteriorating areas.
0:51:08 And so those pretty much cover it.
0:51:10 So we may be addressing some of that.
0:51:13 But next week should be, hopefully we'll be narrowing down what we're going to focus on.
0:51:20 I do not believe we're going to come up with two separate bills this year,
0:51:24 one for economic development, one for urban renewal.
0:51:28 And my recommendation actually is let's fix the big problems
0:51:31 and try and smooth all that out,
0:51:33 if we can get some commonality to that issue,
0:51:36 then when we want to separate,
0:51:37 we're not have to deal with all those other issues
0:51:39 at the same time, so that's what I would add.
0:51:47 Thank you, Representative Plough.
0:51:49 We're very much for that.
0:51:50 Is there anyone else that might have any questions
0:51:52 or comments, Rebecca?
0:52:04 So, Councilwoman Rebecca Mills,
0:52:10 so I could ask about if the erudurinolacency
0:52:12 has adopted the city's transparency resolution.
0:52:14 It did, it did, yes, about a month or so after the council adopted the transparency resolution,
0:52:22 the urban renewal agency did as well.
0:52:29 Anything else?
0:52:30 Well, thank you all very much for paying for your patience with me.
0:52:36 So Brian Pike's going to come up and chat.
0:52:45 Good afternoon.
0:52:46 Travis talked to me this afternoon and asked if I'd be willing to share a little bit about
0:52:50 what's happening across the state with you in regards to body worn cameras and what's
0:52:55 happening here in Twin Falls. I don't have a PowerPoint for you and my eyes are
0:53:00 failing and I'm going to try to read my notes here. So if I get lost I've got
0:53:06 Captain Anthony Barnhart to help me. Anthony has really spearheaded this
0:53:10 project for our department as we move forward and there's a couple things I
0:53:13 think that's really important for you to understand. I would like to go back a
0:53:16 little bit in history and kind of tell you how we arrived at this point and I can
0:53:21 only speak for the Twin Falls Police Department. But before I do I want to I
0:53:25 I want to talk a little bit about how we didn't arrive here.
0:53:28 And if you've been, like anyone else in our community,
0:53:32 you've probably watched a lot of national news,
0:53:36 and you've probably seen some things that troubled you
0:53:39 and concerns you along with probably
0:53:42 every law enforcement professional in the state.
0:53:45 The good news is that's not why the Twin Falls Police
0:53:48 Department is moving to body cameras.
0:53:50 It's not why we believe in them.
0:53:52 Our men and women are committed to providing
0:53:54 professional and dedicated service to our community, and I think they have a long track
0:53:59 record of doing just that.
0:54:01 But I think that this is kind of a historic moment in law enforcement as we watch technology
0:54:07 move forward and bring to license things that are happening.
0:54:10 And it reminds me years ago when, and I think that Mayor Hall will remember this, years
0:54:16 ago as a young officer in going around to different squads, we had the privilege of talking
0:54:21 them about a little fad that they believe was called community policing.
0:54:26 And we would talk about Sir Robert Peele who formed in the late 1800s the London Metropolitan
0:54:32 Police Act which created the London Metropolitan Police and he had a series of principles and
0:54:37 those principles are as true today as they were back in the 1800s.
0:54:42 And one of those principles that he talked about is that the police are the people and
0:54:47 the people are the police.
0:54:49 And I think nationally as we look and we see some of these troubled communities, what we
0:54:53 see is a disconnect between that sense of community in law enforcement and what's really
0:54:58 happening.
0:54:59 So the good news is that's not why we're here talking about body cameras in Twin Falls.
0:55:04 And I hope that we're never here talking about those issues.
0:55:08 So I'm going to go back in Twin Falls history and talk a little bit about when we started
0:55:12 using video camera.
0:55:13 Do you remember VHS?
0:55:15 Yeah.
0:55:16 What a great technology.
0:55:18 And I should have, if I was thinking about this, I would have brought a prop and I would
0:55:23 show you some of the early cameras that we were packing around.
0:55:29 Thank goodness there was a thing called the, I think it was the micro cassette or anyway.
0:55:34 We had been playing around as an agency with video for a long time.
0:55:38 I remember it was a technology that we believed in that we thought we should use.
0:55:43 We went down to milk quality as we purchased a whole bunch of micro video players.
0:55:49 We Velcroed them on to the dashes of our patrol cars.
0:55:54 When you made a corner, it would all tumble down and do the passenger seat.
0:55:58 But I shared that because this isn't a new technology for us.
0:56:02 This is something that as an agency we've been struggling with.
0:56:04 We have recognized the value of capturing video or any type of evidence for a long time.
0:56:11 And so it really started that, you know, as an agency for the last 10 plus years, we've
0:56:16 used digital audio recordings.
0:56:18 We require our police officers when they have a law enforcement contact with the community
0:56:22 to record that contact, and it's been an expectation for a long time, and it's not something that
0:56:28 our officers went into kicking and screaming.
0:56:29 As a matter of fact, they embraced that technology, and they look forward to the video technology,
0:56:35 something that they want to have.
0:56:38 So I think that you've got just a number of issues out there as we move forward, and I'm
0:56:43 not for sure what may come forward that Idaho chiefs of police and Idaho sheriffs are meeting
0:56:50 as we speak.
0:56:51 Well, it's 4.30, so I don't know if they're still meeting, but I'd like to give them credit
0:56:55 for that.
0:56:56 But they are meeting and they're talking about this issue.
0:56:59 So I don't know what will come forward, but I thought maybe from our perspective I would
0:57:03 share just a little bit of just in case something comes forward.
0:57:06 But I know that AIC, along with the sheriffs and the police and the prosecutor's association
0:57:12 are working on presenting a bill.
0:57:15 I don't know if I don't think that you'll see it this year.
0:57:18 You'll probably see it next year.
0:57:19 But you never know.
0:57:20 There's a lot of issues taking place.
0:57:22 The issue in Adams County could create some urgency with this.
0:57:25 And so I thought it was important to talk a little bit about it.
0:57:28 The reason, you know, we started, and Anthony reminded me of this, we really started looking
0:57:33 at video seriously about five years ago.
0:57:35 And one of the drawbacks that we had with video is, like I said, when we talk about VH, I should
0:57:40 talk about the big recorder, I talked about the micro cassette, it was mounted to the dash,
0:57:46 and the disconnect for us has always been, if we were the state police and most of our
0:57:50 contacts occurred in front of a car in a traffic stop, that video would be really useful.
0:57:56 But as an urban department, most of our contacts occur inside buildings.
0:58:01 And so what we saw early on in our video is that the officers would record their response
0:58:06 to the call and then we would look at video of a car that's parked in the street, a tree
0:58:12 that they parked by and then there would be garbled audio and then once they were inside
0:58:16 there would be nothing but what the camera was showing.
0:58:20 So that wasn't really satisfactory and that led us back into the digital audio recording
0:58:24 because we thought okay at least it may not be audio but it's a form of a recording that
0:58:29 And our officers, our men and women, could have with them anywhere they're at.
0:58:33 So if they're in the basement of a building, they'd be able to capture what was happening
0:58:38 and share it with not only the prosecutor but also the community.
0:58:41 And it was also accountability piece, right?
0:58:44 Because if you know that you're being recorded, I mean, just think about it.
0:58:48 I mean, if you're being recorded, you act differently.
0:58:51 It took me a little while because I didn't, as an officer, I didn't have that technology,
0:58:55 but you figured it out really fast.
0:58:58 The reason that we haven't progressed quite as rapidly as we'd like to is because of the
0:59:02 challenges of technology.
0:59:05 So what I mean by that is it's not really the camera.
0:59:09 I mean, you know, you can get a camera anymore that's just tiny, microscopic.
0:59:14 The real challenge is at the back end of that technology, you know, to make sure that we
0:59:19 have the back end in the department that supports the capturing of that evidence, the capturing
0:59:23 of that video that allows for the redaction of it, the storage of it, and all those things
0:59:28 that it takes a little time to think through and to process.
0:59:34 The other thing is that we were hoping, and maybe as we move forward, this is something
0:59:38 that will come forward, is maybe clear standards on what this may look like, so that it's not
0:59:44 just agency by agency, it's not kind of a hodgepodge of policies throughout the state.
0:59:50 Maybe the state can provide some guidance and maybe not the specifics but maybe the umbrella
0:59:55 so to speak of an idea saying that if we recognize the value of this technology and we would recommend
1:00:03 the following things, a policy that covers the storage, the retention, the redaction, things
1:00:11 like that.
1:00:12 But those are some of the things that we've struggled with and I think that we support as
1:00:16 an agency a clear statewide direction.
1:00:20 The other concerns that we have moving forward would be public records, and although we believe
1:00:24 that our public records law is adequate, I also recognize the fact that when that law
1:00:29 was written, it didn't envision the technology that we're talking about.
1:00:33 And so, I'm mindful of that.
1:00:35 When you think about suicides, you think about death investigations and violent sexual crimes,
1:00:43 what will be available to the public, and what shouldn't be available to the public?
1:00:49 And although we want to be as transparent as possible,
1:00:52 we believe that privacy is an important part of that,
1:00:57 especially in relationship to some of these issues.
1:01:01 I just had this conversation with Matt Christensen
1:01:04 from the Times News about having this conversation,
1:01:06 and what is the expectation as we move forward
1:01:09 on what will be available?
1:01:11 And I think it's something we need to work through.
1:01:14 I think the same thing is true with record retention.
1:01:16 I think that we have current laws
1:01:18 that probably are adequate and cover what needs to be covered,
1:01:21 but that could change, right?
1:01:23 What's realistic on how long do we retain this video?
1:01:28 Do we hold it forever?
1:01:29 I think if we talk to the prosecutors association,
1:01:32 they would recommend that we hold on to everything
1:01:35 that we capture.
1:01:36 Is that realistic?
1:01:38 So I share all these things with you
1:01:39 because I'm not for sure what will come forward
1:01:42 in this legislative session.
1:01:44 I think that obviously it's a concern,
1:01:47 And it's something that we want to address.
1:01:49 I think both the sheriffs and police association
1:01:52 along with the prosecuting attorneys association,
1:01:54 they want to address this issue.
1:01:55 I think we need to address this issue.
1:01:57 I'm just not for sure what could come forward.
1:02:00 And so I share some of those concerns with you
1:02:02 because I think it's important to have that
1:02:04 in the back of your mind if you are presented with something.
1:02:07 And then I guess my challenge would be,
1:02:09 this is really something that I think probably
1:02:13 all groups, including our media partners,
1:02:15 to sit down at the table and come up with maybe a clear understanding of what this really
1:02:19 looks like in the future.
1:02:22 Video is so powerful and I, you know, it's easy to say, well, I think we should record
1:02:26 everything until the police are in your house recording you and your belongings and things
1:02:32 like that.
1:02:33 I'm not opposed to that, but I share that with you because our men and women see all
1:02:38 kinds of things and for the most part we deal with really good people.
1:02:44 of the times our interactions with our community, we're just dealing with really good people
1:02:48 that have made a series of decisions and choices. That's really what it comes down to. They're
1:02:53 not criminals in a sense. They've just made some really bad decisions leading up to a
1:02:58 certain moment that they probably don't necessarily want to capture it on video and uploaded
1:03:03 to YouTube for everyone to watch. But maybe that's the reality of where we're at today because
1:03:08 video is so powerful. But I think moving forward, I only share that with you because I think
1:03:13 we need to be mindful of what, of the potential of video and what, you know, these moments
1:03:21 that we capture that really are private and have that, have the potential of exposing
1:03:28 some things that I don't think is the intent of video.
1:03:31 So, are there any questions about body worn cameras and this technology?
1:03:37 And I'm not aware of, I'm not aware of any legislation coming forward currently.
1:03:43 I know there's talk about maybe bringing something forward next year after these parties sit
1:03:48 down and really, I think what we're trying to do, and if I'm not mistaken, I think what
1:03:53 we're trying to do as a group is have a nice, comprehensive package, well thought out package
1:03:59 that addresses these issues before we move forward with it.
1:04:17 that seems to be where the kids act,
1:04:20 which is the first time the officers act.
1:04:25 I think that's-
1:04:26 Well, thanks body, body, body, camera,
1:04:29 like you, does that help your force to defend themselves
1:04:34 in a criminal case as much as the-
1:04:40 Yeah, absolutely.
1:04:41 It does, and what we've seen with our digital audio
1:04:44 is that when complaints are made,
1:04:48 the high percentage of these complaints
1:04:50 are when they're adjudicated or to the favor of the officers.
1:04:53 It's amazing how fast the conversation changes
1:04:56 when people know that the contact was recorded.
1:05:01 However, there are times when, you know,
1:05:02 what we do discover is that, you know,
1:05:05 they're what we call if the action isn't so egregious
1:05:08 on the officers part, they're times when
1:05:10 we've, they're great teachable moments.
1:05:13 When you say there's things that you could probably do
1:05:16 in this contact that could maybe change the course
1:05:19 of it a little bit.
1:05:20 But I agree.
1:05:21 And that's really why the men and women of our department embrace the technology.
1:05:24 They look forward to it.
1:05:26 They want us to implement it.
1:05:28 What we want to do is we just want to do it in a manner that's not wasteful of the taxpayers'
1:05:32 resources so that we don't.
1:05:34 We've watched a couple agencies jump in early, run into all kinds of problems in the back end
1:05:40 and then just have to shut down the programs and they're basically restarting them.
1:05:43 We don't want to be in that situation.
1:05:46 So we're trying to be mindful as we move forward.
1:05:52 Okay, once again, I appreciate the time.
1:05:54 Thank you.
1:06:13 Much, Laura, Mike, for me.
1:06:16 So it's good to see you all again.
1:06:19 And tonight I wanted to talk to you a little bit about the IPDS program.
1:06:24 So the state is moving towards primacy and we are absolutely supportive of that and have
1:06:33 participated heavily in all kinds of attributes to that program.
1:06:38 We're currently getting ready to enter a permitting cycle for our wastewater treatment plant, so
1:06:43 primacy doesn't directly help us on that.
1:06:46 We still think it's important in the long haul, and as we grow, soon we'll be an MS4,
1:06:54 so we'll have stormwater rules, and we would really appreciate the opportunity to work with
1:06:58 with DEQ as the prime entity as we develop what we hope will be reasonable and achievable
1:07:07 ways to manage stormwater through our community.
1:07:12 So yes, oh, I'm sorry.
1:07:19 So our permit is a national pollutant elimination discharge permit and it's administered by the
1:07:30 Environmental Protection Agency.
1:07:32 So that's an NPS permit administered by EPA.
1:07:38 What we would like to do is have an Idaho version of that permit administered by the Idaho
1:07:44 Department of Environmental Quality.
1:07:47 We feel like a local presence and someone who can, you know, we can go down to the DEQ
1:07:53 office and say, come with me.
1:07:55 I want to drag you through my community and have you experience how well we're doing and
1:08:01 actually see this situation for yourself, there's a definite advantage to doing that.
1:08:08 So let's see, as far as our communications in the development of the Idaho pollutant discharge
1:08:18 elimination system program, we have been talking to the DEQ about a few things, a couple of
1:08:26 things in particular.
1:08:27 One of them has to do with fees and how they're actually both of them have to do with fees.
1:08:33 So, there is a unit of measure for how much a particular family would discharge into the
1:08:45 wastewater system.
1:08:47 And that's called an EDU.
1:08:50 And EDUs are going to be applied to the City of Twin based on whatever the Census Bureau
1:08:56 thinks our population may be in the current year.
1:09:00 We have lobbied the DEQ heavily, vigorously, and a little bit more than conscientiously
1:09:08 to allow us to use our water tap numbers.
1:09:12 We have excellent figures on water taps, we're not like the little communities where
1:09:16 everybody's a flat rate, and the reason that we're doing that is that we're one of the
1:09:20 few communities in the state that is in that magic spot where stormwater permitting is imminent
1:09:29 And we don't want to use unofficial population data to drive us any closer to unfunded and
1:09:37 unfunded mandate and storm water management than we have to be.
1:09:43 So that's one of our issues.
1:09:44 We were lobbying to be able to use our number of water taps and any support that any of you
1:09:52 would give us on that matter would be greatly appreciated.
1:09:55 The other piece of conversation that we're having regularly with the DEQ is that we're
1:10:00 asking that the fees are equitably distributed among all of the people that are going to benefit
1:10:05 from the service.
1:10:08 To us, it appears that the municipalities are paying a little bit more than their fair share
1:10:14 of the cost.
1:10:17 So for instance, everyone's going to have to apply for a permit.
1:10:22 So everyone should pay an application fee that should be related to that amount of work.
1:10:27 Everyone is going to be inspected at some point in time.
1:10:30 Municipalities get inspected more and so do industries and that all makes sense that municipalities
1:10:38 would pay a heavier share of that cost because we use the service more.
1:10:42 But other entities like fisheries and so on will also be inspected at some point in time.
1:10:50 So we've made those comments, we'll continue to make those comments and when and if you
1:10:55 You have an opportunity to view what happens with the fee structure that's being proposed.
1:11:01 We would appreciate support on an equitable distribution of the low.
1:11:06 So right now, these fees will come to our citizens through their sewer rates.
1:11:17 And everything we can do to keep the total taxation structure for our community down
1:11:22 as much as possible is appreciated.
1:11:29 It's not really on the schedule, but I want to talk to you a little bit about stormwater.
1:11:33 So soon, as I said, the City of Twin will be large enough to be an MS4, so we'll end up,
1:11:39 and I don't know what that stands for, but it has to do with how we're going to be managed
1:11:44 for stormwater.
1:11:45 We're going to need to pull a permit like the bigger towns of Boise and Cord Lane and so
1:11:49 on.
1:11:52 And the statewide, everyone, are all of these larger communities are having some trouble
1:11:59 dealing with how they're going to pay for this, we don't, we is me. I don't want to spend pavement
1:12:08 dollars on storm drains unless I absolutely have to. So, you know, Fritz helped me look
1:12:15 through the statute and utilities are, you know, water and sewer, but not clearly stormwater.
1:12:21 So if we end up in a spot where we have an opportunity to talk about adding a stormwater
1:12:26 utility to the definition of utilities, that would be awesome.
1:12:30 And it's clearly visible to everyone, you and the citizens, what that money's going for.
1:12:36 This is to deal with sediment.
1:12:39 This is not an abuse of pavement dollars, you know, of railway dollars.
1:12:43 This is not an abuse of wastewater dollars, you know.
1:12:47 It's hard for people to understand why storm drains that are not linked to your sewer system
1:12:53 show up on your sewer bill.
1:12:55 So, anyhow, that's my personal lobby and probably will be a group lobby as time goes on, but we
1:13:02 just changed the rules to provide us an opportunity to have a vote to address what currently is
1:13:07 an unfunded mandate because it's not funded.
1:13:10 And it's going to be terrible and really inclusive.
1:13:14 So there will be a lot of us that are wishing that we could deal with it.
1:13:18 So when we become a stormwater town, having a permit, ITD will participate with us, the
1:13:25 highway district will participate with us all kinds of different entities will
1:13:28 participate with us. So it will not cleanly fit into our current budgeting
1:13:34 standard. So let's see. Does anyone have any questions about those things or any
1:13:41 other thing you want to ask me about? I'm here now.
1:13:48 in the legislation is the way it's not,
1:13:53 the way it's like to do the best
1:13:56 and I'd like to say, can I'm ready to turn these
1:14:01 and make the right legislation and make the work
1:14:03 to serve?
1:14:12 So the question is, has the city approached AIC
1:14:15 to begin the process of developing the legislation?
1:14:18 And to the best of my knowledge, the city of Twin hasn't,
1:14:22 but it's on the target list.
1:14:25 And the sooner I can inform you about it,
1:14:30 the better off will all be as we progress through it.
1:14:33 So I do understand that AIC is looking into some options
1:14:36 for how to address storm water.
1:14:38 I don't know that they're actually looking
1:14:40 into the legislative change at this time,
1:14:42 but it'll be incoming.
1:14:50 So at the conclusion of this legislative session,
1:14:53 AIC has the intent of creating an interim committee
1:14:57 that we can then work to build draft legislation
1:15:01 or draft concepts that can be turned into legislation
1:15:04 and ask members of the legislature to carry
1:15:08 and hopefully we can see those enacted into law.
1:15:16 Anyone else?
1:15:20 That's it for me.
1:15:22 So there's the next item on the list is Travis's item
1:15:27 for city council thoughts and ideas
1:15:32 and local delegation thoughts and ideas.
1:15:39 So Travis, if I can give the bender just real quickly
1:15:44 and if Suzanne wants to add something to it.
1:15:47 The AIC had a legislative board meeting
1:15:50 and a legislative group meeting as well late last week.
1:15:54 And the board decided at this point
1:15:56 we're supporting three pieces of legislation
1:15:59 who may support more later as they come along
1:16:01 with these three or the three
1:16:03 where the AIC board is supporting at this point.
1:16:06 The first one is that we would like to join the counties
1:16:09 and the highway districts on being able
1:16:11 to retain permanent records in a digital format.
1:16:16 There's highway districts in the counties
1:16:17 have already got that opportunity.
1:16:19 We would like to be able to,
1:16:20 the cities would like to be able to do the same thing.
1:16:22 And then some ventilation of what we need
1:16:24 to keep in hard form.
1:16:26 Right now we have to keep everything in paper copy form.
1:16:28 In this world, that's not really very realistic.
1:16:31 And I think that one is a fairly easy one.
1:16:35 And if you have questions on it, I'll go forward.
1:16:38 The second one is the city of Boise brought this one forward.
1:16:41 They would like to amend the alcoholic beverage catering permit to allow for catering for festivals,
1:16:48 and they have a destination of what a festival is.
1:16:52 In the current law right now, it allows for catering permit.
1:16:55 In other words, bar bar and Twin Falls say the cove,
1:16:59 to us the golf course, we're having an event.
1:17:02 Before we had to liquor license out there, we would lease that for three days.
1:17:06 There's a fee involved, and they would have a three day event.
1:17:10 while it allows for a three day event.
1:17:13 They have come up with a problem
1:17:14 and a court of lane has a similar one
1:17:15 where they actually have a longer event called tree fort
1:17:19 and they have now had to,
1:17:20 they have a liquor license for three days
1:17:23 on a catering basis and they shut down for a day
1:17:26 and then they have a number of three more days
1:17:27 than they shut down for a day and then they have two days.
1:17:30 So they would just like to extend that to nine days.
1:17:32 Not the reason for the number of nine days
1:17:34 is two weekends, you get a weekend five day a week
1:17:38 And then a weekend, so that's the reason for that.
1:17:40 And it just extends that and they have made it very specific
1:17:44 on the festival and the definition of the festival
1:17:48 so you can't disuse this as the way to open up
1:17:52 a second bar using your own liquor license.
1:17:56 And so that's the purpose of that one.
1:17:58 And again, alcohol license holders
1:18:02 around the state are already in support of it.
1:18:05 And the state police act of all beverage control
1:18:07 decided to remain neutral. They're not against it, but they're not for it. And then
1:18:12 the third one is to amending the, oh, this one's about my city of Idaho Falls, but also by the power
1:18:22 cities organization. There's a right now under public records request, someone could actually request
1:18:31 request the plans for Idaho Falls as power plant, or dams, because they're a city entity.
1:18:40 Idaho powers are protected, but the city of Idaho Falls is not.
1:18:44 And it comes to the same thing with this, our mind on terrorists right now that we really
1:18:49 don't want the wrong people to have that information if it really shouldn't be something
1:18:53 they would have.
1:18:54 So they're asking for an exemption from the public records law, from the disclosure of
1:18:59 any public record that contains sensitive information regarding critical infrastructure.
1:19:04 They're not trying to get around public records completely. They're just trying to get around
1:19:09 not having to turn their blueprints over for their facilities. And we have the same thing here,
1:19:14 our water system. We would really not like to have to have over our water system blueprints
1:19:23 to somebody we don't think probably should have them.
1:19:26 I could utilize them to commit a terrorist act or whatever the case may be.
1:19:30 Susan, do you have anything to add?
1:19:33 Those are the three that were supported this time.
1:19:35 If you have any questions, that's green, but probably an excellent resource for you, the
1:19:40 AIC director or an executive director.
1:19:43 I'd like to...
1:19:46 Hot?
1:19:47 Not hot.
1:19:48 Is that okay?
1:19:49 I think a lot of increasing evidence of conflict between urban and rural,
1:19:57 water users in this state. And I'd like to take a minute or two to show you, demonstrate
1:20:04 to you, the Twin Falls City is actually a pretty good steward of water consumption usage. Since
1:20:11 about 19, well, about eight years ago, when we got service with water conservation, we
1:20:19 changed ordinances to mandate new subdivisions coming in under a pressure-derived irrigation
1:20:26 system using surface water, in other words canal water. In that, approximately eight to
1:20:31 nine years, we've gone from a peak consumption day in August of 26 million gallons down to
1:20:38 about 19 million. And that represents almost a fourth, 24 or 23 percent decrease in water
1:20:48 usage switching primarily from groundwater to surface usage. And this comes even as a
1:20:55 the town that our town has probably grown by 10,000 people.
1:21:00 We're down serious about what our conservation in Twin Falls
1:21:03 because we do live in a desert as we're reminded of occasionally.
1:21:07 And I think we'll be taking increasing measures
1:21:10 toward conservation, including rewriting some ordinances
1:21:14 to encourage zero escaping.
1:21:17 But we are, I think, pretty good stewards of water
1:21:20 in our city here.
1:22:01 Well, and Fritz is here too, and so he's really been walking hand in hand with us in this entire water conversation.
1:22:08 There are a whole series of conversations that are going on right now, and one of the important things, I think,
1:22:14 that in fact, could impact the City of Twin Falls is whether or not the conjunctive management practices rule 50,
1:22:21 I think, as it often is referred to, remains intact.
1:22:25 So as long as that remains intact, the City of Twin Falls is outside of that call area of the Eastern Snake Plain Aquifer.
1:22:35 There are about 65 cities, I believe, I think is the number that are included and that could be impacted by that call,
1:22:45 or a series of calls that are moving forward.
1:22:49 But when it comes to recharge, we've had conversations internally and with members of
1:22:55 our team about doing intentional recharge that would help benefit the Blue Lakes Reach
1:23:01 in particular in other areas where you might define as more of a ground zero with calls
1:23:07 and where the potential for future calls may be.
1:23:12 We haven't gotten to the place that we could really build those partnerships with our partners
1:23:17 on the north side because really it's going to be working collaboratively with the folks
1:23:23 on the north side to ensure that that rechargeable blue lakes does happen.
1:23:28 They've been, as you've been following, very involved in their own water conversations
1:23:33 about how to make sure that they can continue to move forward and pump.
1:23:39 I believe that you're going to see some legislation moving forward that's going to
1:23:48 require or there may be at least some movement afoot to require IDWR's rule making processes
1:23:59 to be much more transparent and much more open than what they currently are right now.
1:24:06 Our understanding is when they make a rule, that rule then can be placed into some file
1:24:12 and can be pulled out and then thrust upon other entities without much comment and they
1:24:20 follow those rules as a matter of trying to be consistent.
1:24:23 I don't know if Greg has something to do.
1:24:26 Well and to your question Lance the AIC is currently forming a joint powers group with
1:24:33 those 45 cities and possibly other cities we may decide to join as well to bring in as
1:24:40 a group of like water attorneys and water experts and things to help them. The cities
1:24:47 with the term sheet as it's being referred to, it's not in the paper lately, where the
1:24:53 two groups have agreed, the city's kind of got left out of that whole process. They weren't
1:24:59 involved in it. And so this, the ASC is bringing this group together in an attempt to get back
1:25:05 into the situation. What is going to be expected of those four? I think it's actually 45 cities,
1:25:09 but it may be 65 cities.
1:25:11 What's going to be expected of them?
1:25:13 Are they going to be expected to reduce by 13%?
1:25:16 Just like the water, the irrigators are.
1:25:20 And how do you do that?
1:25:21 I mean, most cities have already embraced
1:25:23 some sort of conservation.
1:25:25 And then how do you attract industries
1:25:29 when you're in a situation where you need to reduce
1:25:31 by 13% that's going to really hamper those cities?
1:25:34 And then also, or is it just going to be recharged?
1:25:38 which Travis has talked about,
1:25:40 we're in internal conversations of how we may be able
1:25:43 to help our neighbors to the north with that.
1:25:46 Most people don't realize the city of Twin Falls
1:25:48 is the largest water share holder in the Twin Falls track.
1:25:53 And of course the Twin Falls track
1:25:54 is the most senior of the irrigation districts.
1:25:57 So we're involved in that situation as is the AC.
1:26:26 Surface water coalition.
1:26:28 Yeah, and I think that it was shared by Councilman talking to that our peak day has decreased significantly
1:27:00 at the same time in which our population is known by almost 28%.
1:27:06 And so we're looking at per capita reductions of water use by almost like 46% inside the city
1:27:13 of Twin Falls.
1:27:26 So what can we expect?
1:27:31 Good things.
1:27:32 session. There is a lot of activity going on to look at the tax code. Perhaps we will
1:27:55 address Medicaid, but I think it will be mostly a budget session. They're talking about being
1:28:06 done this 17th of March. I will not be packing. However, I may be gathering and getting a
1:28:16 out a little bit earlier. The income looks good right now. We're up. All measures are
1:28:26 up. And we have some issues on the table that will be addressed, probably not completely.
1:28:34 You know, there's always about 800 and some odd bills drafted and about 347 become law.
1:28:42 And some of them are like diaper awareness week, so there may be a time that will be important
1:28:54 to you.
1:29:01 Somebody will have another license plate and there will always be guns and wolves and
1:29:08 sage-grouse and water.
1:29:12 water is a big issue and you are correct.
1:29:16 Yeah, Mrs. Otter is assuming that we'll take care of the little girl scout so they don't
1:29:23 have to ask for sales tax and I would say to you it's a cookie.
1:29:30 And thank you, I didn't mean to be the spokesman but I always love it when that happens.
1:29:41 I second what Maxine just said, some issues that are coming which have to do with Food Safety
1:29:49 Modernization Act that could affect all of us more than we know at this point I think
1:29:55 those rules are being written now. Working on some veterans issues, some young farmer legislation
1:30:06 possibly, and solar power taxation, how should it be taxed out? I would invite you all to
1:30:15 stay tuned on that issue because if their property tax is on property or if it's on production,
1:30:30 that can affect locals a great deal. There we go. Sit on. So I would invite you to stay
1:30:43 on the solar power issue. There's a project going in up at CUNA, 550 acres, enough to
1:30:54 run about 10,000 houses. So Idaho Power has to adjust that. The Sun doesn't shine at night,
1:31:04 so somebody has to keep that balance. So right now Idaho is in a surplus of power. So we
1:31:13 We don't really need the power, so should we incentivize it with tax policy?
1:31:18 I would like your input on that.
1:31:26 As you all know, there are about 78,000 people that fall into a gap for Medicare, Medicaid.
1:31:33 And the Director of Health and Welfare has come up with a plan.
1:31:38 I think he plans on using tobacco tax money to cover most of those people, that group of
1:31:46 people who right now fall in the gap and are not covered by any insurance.
1:31:52 So that will definitely be, I think something we'll take a look at and we'll come forward
1:31:57 and whether or not it gains traction or not I don't know, but it'll definitely come forward
1:32:02 this year.
1:32:03 There are going to be a lot of issues that come forward.
1:32:07 I don't know how many of them will gain traction, but at so far there are a lot of people with
1:32:14 a lot of ideas coming down the road.
1:32:17 So we'll just have to take a look at them, Bert.
1:32:30 We'll try it here.
1:32:31 I just want to thank the council.
1:32:36 These kind of discussions are very...
1:32:55 So I appreciate the effort that you put into it.
1:33:01 Gives us a chance to find out what your issues are.
1:33:04 And once we get up to Boise, things start happening pretty fast.
1:33:09 And if we can have some awareness of what the issues are before we get there, we get recall,
1:33:17 and it's easier to make an informed decision on some of these issues.
1:33:24 The one issue that I will share with you, something we'll be faced with, and that is the real ID,
1:33:36 Real quick review, Real ID was passed in the Patriot Act in 2005 and 2008.
1:33:44 The state passed legislation that prohibited I.T.D. from working on implementation of it.
1:33:56 Some of the concerns at that time were state rights and federal overreach, just a pushback
1:34:04 to federal and reach sovereignty and the cost that time it was estimated $20 million cost.
1:34:14 So the bill passed unanimously in both houses, so it was a pretty strong statement.
1:34:21 We all felt good about it at the time because really we reflected the state's sentiment, I
1:34:27 think, at that time, but since then there's been a series of deadlines that are just starting
1:34:34 to take place to occur. One of them kicked in last fall, and that was entry into the
1:34:42 INL. You couldn't use a driver's license to get in to the INL. And there's another
1:34:50 series as we went forward at some point we wouldn't be able to use a driver's license
1:34:55 to get on commercial air flights. So that starts affecting a lot more people. So the
1:35:04 The action we took last year was to request an extension that was an option that was available.
1:35:11 We did that, we got the extension that was due to October of this past year, or just recent
1:35:19 coverage.
1:35:22 But we're also notified that that puts us in a position of having to do something.
1:35:34 So it will be addressed most likely some form of repeal and replace, we would just like to
1:35:41 to be able to get a vision from something else.
1:35:53 Homeland Security's rules, and the main thing that we're faced with,
1:36:01 we do have to do something in AM October with that.
1:37:14 a jam that is to feel we really
1:37:25 shot the men's job, we accomplished all
1:37:28 using a Friday morning for you.
1:37:36 It was a legislation during the time of translation.
1:37:40 We very much appreciate it.
1:37:41 And I feel like we could call everyone of you
1:37:44 on fall anytime and ask questions about issues
1:37:49 that come up during the session.
1:37:50 That's also a very eager take on all of it.
1:37:55 And likewise, if you have issues that come up
1:37:58 If you don't think we're investing, we appreciate all of you.
1:38:01 After that, it's really probably one of the better ones
1:38:04 that we do at some stage.
1:38:06 And that's Valley, legislators, and the city.
1:38:10 Thank you all for what you do,
1:38:12 and we appreciate it, and we all know we should.
1:38:28 Just, I just wanted to take the time as representative counsel
1:38:44 to thank all of you for your time that you spend with us
1:38:47 throughout the session, and the off times as well.
1:38:50 We have a conversation with you folks.
1:38:53 And thank you for spending the time this evening
1:38:56 and coming out.
1:38:57 And for the folks that are in the audience,
1:39:00 we're running just a little bit late
1:39:01 for the beginning of our session this evening.
1:39:03 So again, thank you all for coming.
1:39:06 And at this point, I think we're gonna take
1:39:07 about a five minute break for council to have that,
1:39:10 and we'll get started about 5.15.
1:39:12 Thank you folks.
1:39:13 And no one's listening.
1:39:28 Yeah.
1:39:29 Nobody cares.
1:39:30 We are in need there.
1:39:33 Different day, same issue.
1:39:36 Again, we are reconvening the City of Twin Falls City Council
1:39:41 meeting.
1:39:41 That's December 7, 2015.
1:39:43 I know we've already done this, but with reconvening,
1:39:47 I think it'd be appropriate to do again
1:39:49 is the Pledge of Allegiance.
1:39:51 And we have a couple government dual credit students
1:39:55 that would like to lead us in this process
1:39:57 and then introduce themselves.
1:39:58 So if those of you wishing to join us, please rise.
1:40:01 I pledge the allegiance to the flag on the United States of America and to the Republic
1:40:13 for which it stands, one nation that we are not in individual with liberty and justice for
1:40:19 all.
1:40:21 Thank you, gentlemen.
1:40:22 If you wouldn't mind pulling the mic up and introduce yourself, tell us what you're doing
1:40:25 here tonight.
1:40:26 Hello, my name is Ryan Walters, and I go to Twin Falls High School.
1:40:29 I'm a senior and for a dual credit government course, it dictates that we have to do that
1:40:34 attend that we get to attend a city council meeting and so I'm going to be
1:40:40 taking notes along with my friend here to write an essay on the proceedings here.
1:40:44 Thank you. And I'm Gunnar Gentry, I'm Twin Falls High School, I'm also a senior there. I'm basically doing the exact same thing as
1:40:52 same students and everything. Well I just wanted to tell both of you welcome, if you have any
1:40:57 questions please let us know and you have to do this I understand it's not
1:41:01 Thank you for coming this evening.
1:41:06 Moving on to the next item is Mr. Rothweiler.
1:41:10 Do we have any amendments to our agenda this evening?
1:41:13 Mr. Mayor, members of council staff would ask that the council consider going into an executive session,
1:41:17 although it is not posted, we'd ask that the could be added under
1:41:25 74-206-1F, as in Frank, to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency to discuss
1:41:36 the legal ramifications of and legal options for pending litigation, where controversy
1:41:45 is not yet to be litigated but imminently likely to be litigated.
1:41:50 The mere presence of legal counsel at the executive session does not satisfy this requirement.
1:41:56 The reason that we're asking the council to consider this that was not posted on the result
1:41:59 of issues that have developed since the publishing of the agenda earlier today and we'd like
1:42:04 to get the council up to speed on some issues.
1:42:06 Thank you, Travis.
1:42:07 Do you have any direction from council?
1:42:10 Chris talking.
1:42:11 I'd move to add that item present to 740261.
1:42:14 Second.
1:42:15 Motion on the floor by Chris talking and seconded by Sean Berger to add the executive session anything on that motion council
1:42:23 Sharon roll call vote, please
1:42:25 Suzanne Hawkins. Yes
1:42:27 Sean Berger. Yes, Chris Hockington. Yes Greg Lanting. Yes Don Hall. Yes, Rebecca Mills, so I guess yes
1:42:36 Motion passes six to zero. Do we have some boy scouts that just came in the audience?
1:42:40 That's okay. Would you mind coming forward? The young man, the young man.
1:42:46 Why don't we give it just a second? When you're all seated, we'll have them come.
1:42:53 We believe strongly in them earning those merit badges here, okay?
1:43:00 Very good. Thank you, sir. Well, we're a little bit late too, so you're just fine.
1:43:05 So thank you.
1:43:08 So we have motion on floor.
1:43:09 That was seconded as well as voted on and passed.
1:43:13 We are now moving to proclamations, which we have none.
1:43:17 And we will move now to any general public input.
1:43:21 Is there anyone here from the public
1:43:23 that would like to address the council this evening?
1:43:28 I see no one coming forward.
1:43:29 So I'll move down to the consent calendar
1:43:32 and ask council for the direction, Greg Lanning.
1:43:34 I move that we approve the consent calendar as published.
1:43:38 Second.
1:43:39 Motion on the floor by Greg Lanting,
1:43:40 seconded by Suzanne Hawkins,
1:43:42 to approve the consent calendar as published.
1:43:45 Anything further on that motion council?
1:43:49 Sharon, roll call vote please.
1:43:55 Shawn Baraker.
1:43:56 Yes.
1:43:57 Chris Hockington.
1:43:58 Yes.
1:43:58 Greg Lanting.
1:43:59 Yes.
1:44:00 Don Hall.
1:44:01 Yes.
1:44:02 Rebecca Mills-Soyka.
1:44:03 Yes.
1:44:03 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:44:04 Yes.
1:44:06 Motion passes, six to zero.
1:44:09 We now will move to ask our young boy scouts
1:44:13 to come forward if they wouldn't mind.
1:44:16 And are you all with the same troop?
1:44:18 Well, Pac said you were a re-close group.
1:44:20 Excellent.
1:44:21 So if you could pull the mic down in the first person,
1:44:24 if you could go to the mic, introduce yourself,
1:44:28 tell us what Pac you're with again, and where you meet,
1:44:31 and what you're working on this evening.
1:44:35 I don't know what to work on.
1:44:38 It's not the world.
1:44:40 We just have to show up to a county meeting or a city meeting
1:44:43 to fulfill their requirements for their government.
1:44:46 Okay, very good.
1:44:52 Hi, I'm Elijah and we are from Twin Falls.
1:44:57 And we're packed Sunday.
1:45:01 We meet at the church.
1:45:03 Church on Park Avenue.
1:45:04 On Park Avenue.
1:45:06 Thank you, Elijah.
1:45:09 I'm Mason Andrews.
1:45:11 That's all you have to say, Mason.
1:45:13 You lucked out.
1:45:15 I'm Bronson Larson.
1:45:16 Bronson.
1:45:17 Thank you, gentlemen, for coming this evening.
1:45:19 Thank you.
1:45:23 Next item on the agenda, we're moving down
1:45:25 to items for consideration.
1:45:27 Tonight is the night for introductions.
1:45:30 We got to do an introduction last week
1:45:32 of our new chief of police starting next month,
1:45:34 and now we get to do several others.
1:45:36 So the first one is introduction of a newly promoted
1:45:39 budget coordinator, Shane Carpenter, and account specialist,
1:45:43 Janie Higgins, and it's done by our CFO, Lori Race.
1:45:48 Welcome, Lori.
1:45:49 Good evening, Mayor and City Council.
1:45:51 So tonight I have the pleasure of sharing
1:45:53 two recent promotions with you.
1:45:56 The first is Shane Carpenter.
1:45:59 He served in the United States Marines,
1:46:01 and he earned his associate degree in business in 1995.
1:46:07 He worked as controller for Panal Energy
1:46:10 located in Arizona for two years before moving to Idaho.
1:46:15 He then worked as controller for JD Haskell for two years
1:46:18 before making the change to a licensed contractor,
1:46:21 performing residential remodeling.
1:46:24 Shane joined our team in January of 2012
1:46:28 as an account specialist.
1:46:31 And Shane's primary responsibility,
1:46:34 they were to reconcile our 11 bank accounts
1:46:37 and maintain our general ledger.
1:46:41 And I just want you to know, this is no easy task.
1:46:44 He immediately prepared a flow chart
1:46:46 to understand how the different pieces of this task worked.
1:46:50 And he came up with a master plan
1:46:51 to fundamentally change the process of reconciling cash
1:46:56 and immediately begin implementing positive changes
1:46:59 to that process.
1:47:01 Shane is married to Michelle and has a daughter named Lindsey,
1:47:04 who's a nurse.
1:47:06 Shane likes hunting, fishing, camping, traveling,
1:47:10 and most importantly, crafting beer.
1:47:13 Shane has set a high bar and we're expecting great things from him as he steps into the role of budget coordinator.
1:47:20 Now, I will share with you that while we've been looking for his replacement, he has continued to do the critical aspects of both of those positions.
1:47:29 He's continued to keep our cash account reconciled, which is very important for our internal controls,
1:47:35 goals, and he took the initiative to get our 2016 budget shipped off to GFOA, so we appreciate
1:47:45 his hard work very much. So please join me in congratulating Shane Carpenter on his promotion
1:47:51 to the position of Budget Coordinator.
1:47:53 There will be a speech next, Shane.
1:48:01 I understand he has a presentation.
1:48:03 Well, I'll get with Jim. We need to get Jim here for that.
1:48:10 The next one is Janie Higgins, and she has been with the city for only eight short months
1:48:15 as a utility services representative.
1:48:18 She's very qualified to fill the vacancy created by Shane's promotion.
1:48:23 Janie worked as a sales coordinator, providing customer service and bookkeeping services for
1:48:28 Idaho Trout Company in Buell for over 17 years.
1:48:32 She then worked for Renaldi Construction, providing customer service, bookkeeping services,
1:48:38 administrative assistance before joining our team in March of 2015.
1:48:44 Janie was hired as a utility services representative to fill a vacancy created by the retirement
1:48:50 of a 35-year city veteran.
1:48:54 She has lived in the Magic Valley all of her life and she and her husband of 10 years love
1:48:59 living in Twin Falls.
1:49:01 Janie likes cooking and reading.
1:49:04 When I will share with you, she is very quiet but very quick to jump in and help when needed.
1:49:11 During the eight months that Janie has been with us, she's been a quick study, easily learning
1:49:16 our software and how to work with our customers and their varied problems and concerns.
1:49:22 She's highly capable and an integrated member of our team.
1:49:26 Janie is very willing to learn and help in any situation.
1:49:31 Janie, like Shane, has set a high bar, and we are confident in her as our choice for the
1:49:36 next account specialist.
1:49:39 So please join me in congratulating Janie Higgins on her promotion to the position of account
1:49:43 specialist.
1:49:44 Thank you, Laurie, and congratulations to both of you.
1:49:54 We know that we're in good hands, so thank you very much.
1:49:58 Oh, thank you.
1:49:59 Great, glad to.
1:50:00 Yes, I just want to make sure I think most of our council knows this, but Shane is also
1:50:05 involved in the community in other ways. He's the, he and his wife are the driving force
1:50:09 between the Magic Valley Beer Fester, Twin Falls Beer Fester, whatever the title of it is, that
1:50:14 for the Blue Lakes Rotary and then that allows the Rotary to have funds to do things for our community.
1:50:20 And we appreciate when our employees are out there doing good in the community.
1:50:25 Thank you. Thank you for sharing that. Did either one of you want to come up and speak?
1:50:30 Okay. You don't have to. Okay. I want to give you that opportunity though. Thank you both and thank you, Lori, for your presentation.
1:50:37 Next item on the agenda is an introduction to newly promoted wastewater collection supervisor, Doug Denzales.
1:50:43 And we have John Keaton. Welcome, John.
1:50:48 All right. Thank you, Mayor and Council.
1:50:52 Tonight, I'm going to introduce Doug Denzales and he has recently been promoted to wastewater collection supervisor.
1:51:00 Originally, he's from Gooding Idaho, and he previously worked for the city there for
1:51:04 18 years in the Public Works Department.
1:51:07 During this time, he gained a great yield knowledge and experience working with several different
1:51:11 disciplines, including streets, water, sewer, wastewater treatment, sanitation, and storm water.
1:51:18 Doug wanted to move into falls in order to be closer to family, and accepted a position
1:51:22 with the city in 2007.
1:51:25 Since then, Doug has been a dedicated member of Public Works, and I'm very excited to
1:51:29 to be placing him in a position of greater responsibility.
1:51:32 His public works experiences both diverse and well-seasoned.
1:51:36 He'll add a great deal to our team.
1:51:38 Doug also has a few interesting hobbies, including music.
1:51:42 In fact, he's the lead singer in the local band, Dirty Johnny.
1:51:46 His band has had the honor for opening for Leonard Skinner,
1:51:49 count 77, Grant Funk, and recently opened for the Cliff Bar
1:51:53 corporate band at the Twin Falls Beer Festival.
1:51:57 So I just wanted to say to Doug, you know,
1:52:00 the in public works, the supervisor position is probably
1:52:05 the backbone of public works.
1:52:06 You have to be able to take design knowledge
1:52:10 and make it practical.
1:52:11 You have to be able to take from the office
1:52:14 and put it in the field.
1:52:16 You have to be able to lead your team.
1:52:17 You have to be able to understand engineering drawings.
1:52:19 And it's a very critical role.
1:52:22 And I'm really excited because Doug's vast background,
1:52:25 he's got good people skills.
1:52:27 and he's a natural leader.
1:52:28 So I'm very pleased to have him aboard.
1:52:30 Congratulations.
1:52:32 Go ahead.
1:52:33 Go ahead.
1:52:38 And he's got an awesome goatee, OK?
1:52:41 Let's give him credit for that.
1:52:43 Nice job.
1:52:45 Next item on the agenda is introduction
1:52:47 of new airport of the new airport supervisor, Matt Barnes.
1:52:52 And we have Bill Carberry to do that.
1:52:54 Thank you, Mayor.
1:52:54 Good evening, Council.
1:52:56 All the reasons I come to before you,
1:52:58 this is about the most fun to introduce Matt here tonight.
1:53:01 Ed Lang is going to be retiring in a couple of weeks.
1:53:06 I just couldn't introduce Matt
1:53:07 without saying a couple of things about Ed.
1:53:10 It's worked for the city for a long, long time
1:53:12 through the street department.
1:53:13 He's been out at the airport about as long
1:53:16 as I have, I think, almost 15 years now.
1:53:18 So he's just done a bang-up job
1:53:20 and I invite you to come out to his retirement party
1:53:22 on the 15th when he does retire.
1:53:25 With that, I'd like to introduce Matt Barnes.
1:53:28 Matt was born and raised in Twin Falls, the son of Jack and Robin, who are in the back
1:53:34 and Matt may introduce the rest of his family shortly.
1:53:37 He graduated Twin Falls High School in 2001, went on to obtain an AA degree in liberal arts
1:53:43 from CSI in 2004.
1:53:46 He was first hired to work at the airport in 2005 as a part-time airport operator, moved
1:53:51 to full-time in 2006, promoted to a senior airport operator in 2010.
1:53:58 That always took advantage of formal training opportunities to include airport safety and
1:54:03 operations specialist school, airfield pavement marking and signage, airport wildlife hazard
1:54:09 mitigation and a member of the bird strike committee in the United States.
1:54:15 He's progressively taken on more and more areas of responsibility at the airport to include
1:54:19 developing some of our training curriculums, long term planning as a member of the city.
1:54:24 He's acted as a liaison with the many regulatory agencies that we have that look over our operational
1:54:29 components.
1:54:30 He's coordinated emergency drills and safety awareness programs, so he's really stepped
1:54:34 up over the years.
1:54:35 I'm really proud of what he's been doing.
1:54:38 As a new role, as a supervisor, he gets to do a lot.
1:54:42 He gets to oversee the maintenance of the facility out there.
1:54:44 He oversees our operations day-to-day.
1:54:47 He handles the staff who works shifts and tries to cover the airport in the manner that
1:54:52 we need to.
1:54:54 So please help me make welcome Matt Barnes is our new airport operations.
1:54:58 Matt, would you like to come to the microphone and introduce your family?
1:55:07 Because I think we know a couple of them.
1:55:09 Yeah, some of them.
1:55:11 One of them just recently left the city organization.
1:55:15 My father Jack is back there.
1:55:18 Next to him, my mom Robin.
1:55:20 My wife, Nisha, my two kids, Cohen and Evelyn.
1:55:24 And then a surprise for me, my brother Craig is here.
1:55:27 I would like to just real quick Travis remember the group that you had come and make presentation
1:55:38 to us and Matt was part of that what was that again remind me because that was the long-term
1:55:43 planning I will tell you Matt from the time that you made were part of that presentation
1:55:49 I didn't know you before and and that was such a powerful presentation to us we learned
1:55:53 so much. And it was obvious to me that you were a leader through that process. So this
1:55:59 it's been confirmed tonight that you are. So excellent. Chris talking to you.
1:56:03 Well, on behalf of the airport board on a matter, we have complete confidence in
1:56:08 you. You do have a problem of needing to monitor bill to keep him on track. But we
1:56:14 know you're up to it. There's so much going on in the airport this next couple
1:56:18 years we need your expertise and we know you guys will make a good team together. So
1:56:22 Congrats. Thanks, Chris. Greg Lanny. Well, I was wondering if we had other families.
1:56:27 Doug didn't get a chance to introduce his wife. Oh, Doug, come on up. I have my wife with me this
1:56:39 evening. Yeah, Kelly Gonzalez. No introductions? We didn't want to leave you out. All right, we have
1:56:52 another agenda item, but what I've always found is once these things are done, maybe folks would
1:56:58 would like to leave. You don't have to. You can certainly stay, but we'll give you just
1:57:02 that opportunity to do that because you're here for an agenda item. And thank you. The
1:57:11 high school students have to stay because they have to earn that. Dual credit by listening
1:57:17 to us for a gentleman. Alright, that's always fun. Next item on the agenda is a consideration
1:57:32 of a request to adopt an ordinance vacating a portion of utility easement with the Eldridge
1:57:37 commercial subdivision located north on of the intersection of Eldridge Avenue and Madron
1:57:44 Street and we actually have a Mitch Humble making this presentation welcome Mitch.
1:57:48 This meeting just keeps getting better.
1:57:51 Well, no, we got all those fun introductions now we get to adopt an ordinance.
1:58:00 Well, these are pretty easy to do, you guys know what you're doing here.
1:58:03 So I'll just tell you that back on October 5th we had a hearing, we approved this vacation
1:58:07 request and we've gone and prepared the ordinance and we come along with that approval, I guess.
1:58:18 And we're waiting on the property owners for some time to get the legal description turned
1:58:23 out.
1:58:24 That's why it's now December and that's over back on October 5th.
1:58:27 But anyway, it's ready to go now.
1:58:28 And it needs to be adopted tonight.
1:58:31 If you choose to adopt it tonight,
1:58:33 we'll do the third and final waiver of the rules
1:58:36 and all that kind of stuff.
1:58:37 So, all we can do is first reading.
1:58:41 If that's where you want to go.
1:58:43 But anyway, there you go.
1:58:44 If you have any questions, I can try to answer them for you.
1:58:46 This is pretty easy.
1:58:47 Thank you.
1:58:48 What would the ordinance number be?
1:58:51 Ordinance number 3109.
1:58:54 3109.
1:58:55 Thank you.
1:58:56 Council have any questions and or direction, please. Greg Lanning.
1:59:00 Mayor Hall, I move that we suspend the rules and place ordinance 3109 on
1:59:05 third and final by title only. Second motion on floor by Greg Lanning
1:59:10 seconded by Suzanne Hawkins as stated. You being further on that motion,
1:59:14 Council. Sharon, roll call vote, please.
1:59:22 Chris Hockington. Yes. Greg Lanthine. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Rebecca,
1:59:28 Yes.
1:59:29 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:59:30 Yes.
1:59:31 And Sean Barrieger.
1:59:32 Yes.
1:59:33 Motion passes 6-0.
1:59:34 If you could read the ordinance of the title, please.
1:59:42 Ordinance number 3109.
1:59:44 And ordinance of the mayor and the city council of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho, vacating
1:59:49 the real property just right below and providing for vesting of title to the property so vacated.
1:59:58 Chris talking to.
1:59:59 Move pass to it to 3109.
2:00:01 Second.
2:00:02 Motion on the floor by Chris talking down seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to passage up 3109
2:00:09 Anything further on that motion council?
2:00:12 Sharon roll go vote again, please
2:00:14 Greg Lanthine. Yes, Don Hall Rebecca Mills, soica. Yes Suzanne Hawkins. Yes
2:00:22 Sean Barrieger. Yes, Chris talking. Yes motion passes six to zero
2:00:28 Next item on the agenda is public input and or items from City Manager City Council
2:00:32 So we'll start with the public again if there's anyone here from the public that would like to address the council now
2:00:37 It's your opportunity
2:00:39 Just real quick are the two young ladies with you two gentlemen. Are they here for the same reasons?
2:00:53 Wait
2:00:57 If you could just introduce yourself and tell us again what you're doing here, we want to make sure you earn this
2:01:02 Okay, my name is Tanner Thompson and I'm here tonight because I wanted to see what this is like and also because I'm doing an assignment that requires it.
2:01:11 I go to Twin Falls High School, I'm a senior and the classes dual credit American government.
2:01:17 Thank you, thank you.
2:01:18 I'm Holly Thompson and I go to Twin Falls High School and I'm a sophomore and I'm doing this because it's an assignment in dual credit government.
2:01:29 and you just want to. Very good thank you ladies for sharing and I see budding
2:01:39 politicians in the audience. So excellent job. Is there anyone else from the public?
2:01:44 City Manager, Mr. Roth rather do you have anything further? City Council, Chris
2:01:50 talking. The latest managers report Travis Raisin issue that there's nothing
2:01:55 confidential, a little bit puzzled about the new well that we budgeted for funding and
2:02:03 punching out and it looks like it's going backwards because as I recall all the well
2:02:11 water is rather high in arsenic and why we would want to get even a relatively small
2:02:18 gallon each well when we already have through the arsenic piping enough pressure pretty much
2:02:24 history of the town, why would we want to get an arsenic laden new well?
2:02:30 So one of the things that we're finding is that the arsenic in the various areas is continuing
2:02:34 to go downward.
2:02:35 And so that's an improvement.
2:02:37 The other side is we've had a water right that has been under protest for several years.
2:02:47 It's about 19 CFS of water and it is currently under protest by the College of Southern Idaho
2:02:53 as a result of the direct impact that it could have on the fish farm.
2:02:57 And so what we're trying to do is take advantage of the 19 CFS water
2:03:01 that we already have in the form of a right and find another location that we can pump it out.
2:03:06 And the arsenic is not a major consideration.
2:03:09 At this point, I think we don't believe so, but also with the blending systems that we have out at Harrison,
2:03:15 we're able to make those arsenic ratios.
2:03:18 So even though we have quite a bit of fun legally usable water from the aquifer on the
2:03:27 north side, we're doing this in part to protect or replace the challenged water, right?
2:03:34 Yes.
2:03:35 Yes.
2:03:36 Thank you.
2:03:37 Thank you, Chris.
2:03:38 Great learning.
2:03:39 Well, I would like to add that when I read that I thought about it for a while and I kind
2:03:42 of thought of another advantage to having an additional well out there and making sure
2:03:48 we have that much water out there is the fact that if we have a situation that occurred
2:03:53 like two years ago when we were, we could no longer pump water out of our wells south
2:03:58 because of power outage, we had to, we relied on those wells at that time to help us to
2:04:05 get through that experience and so I think we need to make sure we have our full water
2:04:10 pumping ability on our south wells just in case that type to happen give us a
2:04:15 little bit of leeway as well so that's one of the things I thought of I don't
2:04:19 know that's what he's more doing it but that's what I thought of as being a
2:04:22 possibility thank you great anything further from council and maybe Travis you
2:04:28 could help me with this but next next week is our final meeting of the month or
2:04:33 two weeks so we have two more meetings we have a meeting on the 14th and the
2:04:38 21st which which of those meetings are we going to be discussing the selection of the mayor process next week next week
2:04:45 We are discussing the selection of the mayor process. We are also holding a public hearing on
2:04:51 The ordinance that has been proposed to modify the current alcohol
2:04:56 States of sales and possible the times of sales
2:04:59 I kind of want to just remind council that because obviously we want to have a discussion about that and and the direction and
2:05:06 and just give you that quick reminder.
2:05:10 Is there anything else from Council?
2:05:12 All right, moving to the next item that we added
2:05:15 is an executive session potentially,
2:05:17 and that is Executive Session 74-206,
2:05:23 was it one half?
2:05:24 One half.
2:05:25 To communicate with legal counsel for the public agency
2:05:28 to discuss the legal ramifications of
2:05:31 and legal options for pending litigation
2:05:34 are controversies not yet being litigated,
2:05:36 but eminently likely to be litigated.
2:05:39 The mere presence of legal counsel
2:05:41 at an executive session does not satisfy this requirement.
2:05:44 Turn it over, Council for their direction, Sean Barrier.
2:05:47 So moved?
2:05:48 So yeah.
2:05:49 Motion on four by Sean Barrier,
2:05:50 seconded by Greg Lanting to move into executive session
2:05:53 as stated and then further on that motion council.
2:05:56 And our council elect are invited as well.
2:05:59 And assuming.
2:06:01 Yeah, as always, I'm sorry I didn't say that,
2:06:03 But yeah, we've made that kind of a historic direction.
2:06:08 Anything further council?
2:06:10 Sharon, roll call vote, please.
2:06:12 Don Hall?
2:06:12 Yes.
2:06:13 Rebecca Mills-Soyka?
2:06:15 Yes.
2:06:16 Suzanne Hawkins?
2:06:17 Yes.
2:06:18 Jima, or Sean Berriger?
2:06:20 Yes.
2:06:21 Chris Hawking?
2:06:21 Yes.
2:06:22 Greg Lanting.
2:06:23 Yes, motion passes six to zero.
2:06:25 Ladies and gentlemen, we will not be coming back out
2:06:27 after the council meeting this evening and reconvening.
2:06:30 So that is it.
2:06:33 Yeah.
Download
- Transcript (text) 116 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 153 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 206 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.2 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 8.7 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, December 7, 2015. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:06:48.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
09e52109353025e12f5fd8ef32c299d6da5cce884cd81f6c6e65465eef8f56d5 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 8dd50373ce418c1ecb22957bb4e58117efaa9e1b824494a15d3312c1ee62766b
part02.m4a 8a6ca79403448eb0a6d7e310000b1b8e0fe0b6cda729f95bf9a69ee7bbc314d3 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
660a85c3c346b6aee6e736c09d05b7cd92d69c90528f66a595dd6f4e453550f2
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file