OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, March 21, 2016

Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:09:01 I'd like to call to order the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council for Monday, March 21st.

0:09:07 At the start-off, we will have the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:09:10 Those of you who wish to join us, please rise.

0:09:12 Our Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:09:28 We do have a quorum this evening. All seven members of the council are here.

0:09:37 Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to the agenda?

0:09:43 Mr. Mayor, members of the council staff would ask the council ad for its consideration.

0:09:49 An additional executive session to the item already listed,

0:09:53 and that would be under 742061F to communicate with legal council

0:09:59 the public agency to discuss legal ramifications of and legal options for pending litigation.

0:10:08 Chris Stockington.

0:10:09 I move to add the close meeting at percent of 742.061f.

0:10:14 Second.

0:10:16 I have a motion by Chris Stockington, seconded by Nikki Boyd to amend the agenda to include

0:10:21 that item.

0:10:22 Any discussion?

0:10:25 Seeing none, the aye la roll call vote please.

0:10:27 Suzanne Hawkins?

0:10:28 Yes.

0:10:29 Nikki Boyd?

0:10:30 Yes.

0:10:31 Sean Berriger?

0:10:32 Yes.

0:10:33 Greg Lanting yes Don Hall yes Ruth Pierce yes motion passes seven two zero

0:10:42 We have no proclamations this evening the next item on the agenda is general public input

0:10:46 Is there anyone here from the public who would like to?

0:10:49 Bring any issues before the council on an item that is not on this evening's agenda

0:10:56 Seeing no one we will move to the consent calendar

0:11:02 Suzanne Hawkins and move approval of the consent calendar second

0:11:06 Motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the consent calendar.

0:11:12 Any discussion?

0:11:15 Seeing none, the aye, the roll call vote please.

0:11:17 Nicky Boyd.

0:11:18 Yes, Sean Berriger.

0:11:19 Yes.

0:11:20 Chris Talkington.

0:11:21 Yes.

0:11:22 Greg Lanting.

0:11:23 Yes.

0:11:24 Don Hall.

0:11:25 Yes.

0:11:26 Yes.

0:11:27 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:11:28 Yes.

0:11:29 Motion passes 7-0.

0:11:31 Under the items for consideration, the first item is a presentation of Peace Officer Standards

0:11:36 and training council certificates to the following individuals. Officer Matthew Guzman,

0:11:41 Officer Tyler Smotherman, Officer Kyle Scousa, Officer Ben Hammer, Staff Sergeant Chuck Garner,

0:11:49 and formal ceremony promoting Officer Justin Hendrickson to the position of Sergeant. We have

0:11:55 our Police Chief Craig Kingsbury. Welcome. Thank you Mayor, Council. This is a great evening for

0:12:03 the men and women of the Twin Falls Police Department and our community.

0:12:08 As you know, I'm in my third month as the chief and I can tell you that I am very impressed

0:12:13 with the professionalism of the men and women that we have working in all aspects of the Twin

0:12:18 Falls Police Department.

0:12:19 I couldn't have asked to inherit a better agency, so I thank you for that.

0:12:24 Tonight is going to be a great honor for me as well as our staff.

0:12:29 I'd like to call up for the first part,

0:12:32 Lieutenant Wilson and Lieutenant Lewis.

0:12:45 Good evening, mayor and council members.

0:12:51 Terry and I are gonna sort of split this up

0:12:53 and to begin with, I guess,

0:12:58 council member Hollis, the representative

0:13:01 to the police department from the city council,

0:13:03 would you like to hand these certificates out

0:13:07 after I explain what's going on.

0:13:10 Well, actually, Lieutenant, I would love to do it.

0:13:12 It would be an absolute honor, but we

0:13:14 don't have representatives to the departments anymore.

0:13:17 The mayor will be doing that.

0:13:18 Well, mayor?

0:13:20 So you're putting me to work, because we're serious.

0:13:23 But if he does not want to, I'm down there.

0:13:26 More than half.

0:13:27 Well, somebody will do it on there.

0:13:31 At this point, I just want to read.

0:13:32 If I can get Officer Tyler Smotherman and Officer Matthew Guzman to come to the front

0:13:43 please.

0:13:55 Officer Tyler Smotherman was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on December 8, 2014

0:14:00 as a full-time police officer.

0:14:02 Tyler was born in Ventura County, California.

0:14:05 He and his family moved to Coeur d'Alene, Idaho in May of 2003.

0:14:10 He attended and graduated from Coeur d'Alene High School.

0:14:13 He went on to further his education at the University of Idaho and graduated with a bachelor

0:14:18 of arts degree in political science and international studies with minors in Spanish and military

0:14:25 science.

0:14:27 During college, Tyler became nationally certified as an EMT.

0:14:32 He also is commissioned as a U.S. Army officer through the Army Reserve Officers Training

0:14:37 Corps program. In 2014, Tyler graduated from the 18-week U.S. Army Military Basic Police

0:14:46 Officer Leader Course. He has served as a military police platoon leader in the Idaho

0:14:51 Army National Guard and was recently promoted to First Lieutenant. Tyler completed the College

0:14:57 of Southern Idaho Law Enforcement Program in May of 2015. He successfully completed the

0:15:04 Twin Falls Police Department's Field Training Program in October of 2015. Tyler has been

0:15:11 married to his wife, Rachel, since 2012. They enjoy politics, target shooting, the outdoors,

0:15:18 and spending time with their new German Shepherd. It is with great pleasure that we present Tyler

0:15:23 with the basic certification from the State of Idaho Peace Officers Standards and Training

0:15:28 Council. Officer Matthew Guzman was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on December

0:15:53 8, 2014 as a full-time police officer. Matt was born in Madera, California. After graduating

0:16:00 high school, he joined the United States Navy and served as an aviation ordinance man on

0:16:07 board the USS John C. Stennis aircraft carrier for four years. He completed two Westpac deployments

0:16:14 during the duration of his service and separated in 2010.

0:16:19 Matt then pursued his education at the University of Colorado

0:16:22 in Colorado Springs and attained a bachelor of arts degree

0:16:26 in criminal justice.

0:16:28 Matt completed the College of Southern Idaho Law Enforcement

0:16:31 Program in May of 2015.

0:16:34 He successfully completed the Twin Falls Police Department

0:16:37 Field Training and Evaluation Program in September of 2015.

0:16:42 It is with great pleasure that we present Matt with the basic certification from the state

0:16:47 of Idaho Peace Officers Standards and Training Council.

0:16:50 Officers Kyle Scooza and Ben Hammer come forward please.

0:17:25 Kyle Scooza was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on August 11, 2014 as a full-time

0:17:31 police officer.

0:17:32 Kyle was born and raised in Twin Falls and graduated from the Twin Falls High School in 2005.

0:17:38 Kyle attended the College of Southern Idaho Law Enforcement Program and graduated

0:17:42 in July of 2011. Prior to his employment with our agency,

0:17:47 Kyle worked for the City of Bellevue, Idaho as a deputy

0:17:51 marshal from December 2011 to August 2014.

0:17:56 Kyle received his post basic certification in July of 2012.

0:18:01 He and his wife, Christina Dawson-Scousa,

0:18:04 have been married for six years. Kyle loves to play all types of sports and loves

0:18:09 to snowboard. It's with great pleasure that we present Kyle with his intermediate certification

0:18:14 from the state of Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training Council. Ben Hammer was hired by

0:18:35 the Twin Falls Police Department on September 26, 2011 as a full-time police officer. Ben

0:18:42 graduated from Meridian High School. He attended the law enforcement program at the College

0:18:46 of Southern Idaho and obtained a technical certificate and an associate of applied science

0:18:52 degree in law enforcement in December of 2010. Ben continued his education at CSI and obtained

0:18:59 an associate of arts degree in criminal justice in December of 2011. In his pursuit of a law

0:19:05 enforcement career, Ben served as a reserve officer at the Rupert Police Department from

0:19:11 February 2010 to June of 2011. Prior to his employment with our department, Ben worked

0:19:19 to the sportsman's warehouse in C3 here in Twin Falls.

0:19:24 Ben successfully completed the Twin Falls Police Department's

0:19:27 field training program and achieved

0:19:29 ride-alone status in February of 2012.

0:19:32 Ben was awarded his post basic certification on July 11, 2012.

0:19:38 It's with great pleasure that we present Officer Hammer

0:19:41 with the intermediate certificate

0:19:42 from the state of Idaho Peace Officer Standards

0:19:45 and Training Council.

0:20:09 And if Staff Sergeant Chuck Garner will step forward, please.

0:20:19 Staff Sergeant Chuck Garner was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on June 2nd of 1997 as a full time police officer.

0:20:27 During his career with the police department, he has served as a patrol officer, an narcotics detective,

0:20:33 a field training officer, and a member of the SWAT team.

0:20:37 He was promoted to the position of Sergeant in the Patrol Division in May of 2006.

0:20:42 In June of 2011, Chuck was promoted to Staff Sergeant and has served in that capacity in

0:20:49 the Patrol Division and the Administrative Services Division. Chuck now supervises the

0:20:54 Criminal Investigation Division. Chuck graduated from Post Academy as a self-sponsored student

0:21:00 in March of 1997. He served in the United States Army for five years prior to attending

0:21:06 the Academy. Chuck has been awarded the basic, intermediate, and supervised recertifications

0:21:12 from the Peace Officer Standards and Training Council. Chuck and his wife Sarah have been

0:21:17 married for 24 and a half years and have three children. It is a great pleasure that we present

0:21:23 Chuck with the advanced certification from the State of Idaho Peace Officer Standards and

0:21:28 Training Council.

0:21:53 As I mentioned at the start, this is just an example, you know, just a little bit of a piece

0:22:00 of the fine men and women that serve the Twin Falls Police Department and as I know

0:22:05 Councilman Hall was counting four out of those five gentlemen I'll graduate so

0:22:10 the college is something I know. Go Eagles. I kept hearing that my year after each

0:22:15 one of you passed. I saw that sir. Now first of all I just want to mention when

0:22:22 we talk about post certificates and certifications in Idaho police officers

0:22:29 When they start their career, they have one year to obtain the basic post-certificate.

0:22:34 So, when you saw Officer Guzman and Smotherland receiving their basic post-certificate,

0:22:39 that is that you have to achieve that by state law, by ADAPPA rules within the first year.

0:22:45 Really, by ADAPPA rules, that's the only certificate that an officer must obtain.

0:22:51 But what you saw tonight was you saw three officers getting other steps,

0:22:57 other steps, including two receiving the next step of the intermediate certificate.

0:23:02 The step after that would be an advanced certificate.

0:23:05 And what you saw, that's what you saw Staff Sergeant Gardner getting was his advanced certificate.

0:23:10 And I think it also was pointed out that Staff Sergeant Gardner also has his supervised

0:23:15 certificate.

0:23:16 So, again, just a high level of education and training hours that it takes to achieve those

0:23:20 certificates, and I think that's just a tribute to the dedication of the men and women of the

0:23:26 TFPD.

0:23:27 Speaking of that, this is really quite an honor, as a chief, I'm about to do my first promotion

0:23:34 to the rank of Sergeant.

0:23:36 Sergeant in the Twin Falls Police Department is the first level of supervision.

0:23:43 It's really where the rubber meets the road when it comes to guiding the activities that

0:23:48 occur day in and day out with the men and women that serve and protect this fine city.

0:23:53 The promotion to sergeant is not to be taken lightly.

0:23:57 There is a lot of responsibility that go with the rank of sergeant.

0:24:02 And we went through a very, so we say hard fought a promotional process, a very thorough

0:24:10 process of which we had nine members of TFPD that applied for this position of sergeant.

0:24:18 They went through a round of interviews and had to give a presentation to a group of outside professionals as well as a presentation interviews to the command staff and a supervisor review.

0:24:32 So the person who I'm about to promote finished number one in that process and it is with with great honor

0:24:39 I'm about to do this so if I could call Sergeant Justin Hendrickson and his wife

0:24:45 Catch up to the front of the room, please

0:25:04 I

0:25:08 Mayor, members of the Twin Falls City Council,

0:25:11 Justin Henderson was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on January 2, 2003,

0:25:16 as a full-time police officer.

0:25:18 He was born right here in Twin Falls.

0:25:20 He graduated from Kimberly High School and attended the College of Southern Idaho.

0:25:24 Prior to his employment with the Twin Falls Police Department,

0:25:27 Justin worked as a transportation technician with the Idaho Transportation Department.

0:25:31 During his employment with TFPD, Justin had served as a patrol officer,

0:25:36 Narcotics Detective, a member of our SWAT team, a traffic officer, and a field trading officer.

0:25:43 Justin and his wife, Keesha, have one child.

0:25:46 Justin was awarded his basic certificate from Peace Officer Standards and Training on December 29th, 2003.

0:25:53 His intermediate certificate on February 7th, 2009,

0:25:57 and his advanced certificate on February 24th, 2014.

0:26:02 As mentioned earlier, after a very competitive process,

0:26:05 Justin has been selected for the position of Sergeant.

0:26:09 He will be assuming his supervisory duties

0:26:11 as a patrol team Sergeant, effective immediately.

0:26:14 Otherwise, he took tonight off to celebrate with family.

0:26:20 Justin, before we go any further,

0:26:22 would you like to take a moment to introduce

0:26:23 family and friends that you have here with you today?

0:26:26 What about him?

0:26:38 Thank you, Sergeant.

0:26:40 As I think you can also tell by looking behind me,

0:26:44 As you're going to say, the Twin Falls Police Department is also one big family.

0:26:48 This truly is a family affair when we have the opportunity to promote people to these ranks.

0:26:54 So without further ado.

0:28:35 Chief, could you explain what's going on right now to the audience, possibly, and to me for that matter?

0:28:42 Mayor Councilman Lansing and members of the audience, yes, what is happening right now is every member of the Twin Falls PD Supervisory Group

0:28:51 is handing Sergeant Hendrickson his Sergeant Chevron's,

0:28:55 which will be sewn onto the sleeve of his uniform shirts.

0:28:59 So he has a lot of sewing to do.

0:29:01 I'm up here, Sergeant.

0:29:04 We want to shake your hand.

0:29:18 Thank you very much.

0:29:20 Thank you, Chief.

0:29:28 Don Hall has a comment.

0:29:29 I just have a real quick comment.

0:29:31 First of all, I'm very, very proud of everyone

0:29:32 that was here.

0:29:33 Four out of the five were CSI, Go Eagles, as I said.

0:29:37 And just I'm very proud of your new position

0:29:40 And it's honestly, I was there.

0:29:42 Sergeant's a tough position, but very rewarding.

0:29:45 But I just have to say, I am most impressed

0:29:47 with Staff Sergeant Gardner to be able to pull off

0:29:50 a purple pocket hanky in his suit tonight.

0:29:55 Awesome, Chuck, good job.

0:29:58 Well, once again, congratulations to all of our officers

0:30:02 this evening and thank you for the service

0:30:04 that the Twin Falls Police Department provides

0:30:06 to our community.

0:30:07 Now, I'm sure that everyone was thinking

0:30:09 all these folks showed up to hear the audit, which is the next item on the agenda, but I

0:30:13 suspect we'll go ahead and give it just a couple of minutes for the room to clear out a little

0:30:16 bit. Thank you all for being here.

0:30:22 Oh, don't be. Don't be letting it continue. I started a little late. I didn't start until

0:30:29 I tried to. But you added the little light too.

0:30:33 You have one now? Yeah. I'll never stop for one time. Well, this time you probably should

0:30:47 We have to wait for the room to clear up to the audit.

0:30:51 That's what we're looking for.

0:30:55 It's years.

0:31:00 Yeah, it's not.

0:31:13 Alright, so we will go ahead and move to our next item on the agenda, which is a presentation

0:31:18 of the City of Twin Falls 2015 Audited Financial Statements.

0:31:23 We have Lori Race, our Chief Financial Officer, and Scott Hunsaker

0:31:28 with Mulkey Hunsaker and company who performed the audit.

0:31:31 Welcome, Lori.

0:31:32 Thank you.

0:31:33 Good evening mayor and city council. Idaho codes 67-45-0-B states the governing body of

0:31:42 a local governmental entity whose annual expenditures from all sources exceed $250,000 shall cause

0:31:51 a full and complete audit of its financial statements to be made each fiscal year.

0:31:57 Well we've complied with that code and feel it's very important to have a formal presentation

0:32:01 of the audit findings made to you, the governing board of the City of Twin Falls.

0:32:07 We do this because we believe it adds another layer of transparency to city finances and

0:32:12 government.

0:32:13 We believe the audit presentation adds validity and credibility to what we're doing, and it

0:32:19 provides an independent review and appraisal of how we're handling taxpayer dollars.

0:32:24 You're receiving an unbiased expert review.

0:32:28 So the finance team, headed by Brent Hyatt, put an audit plan together.

0:32:32 Susan Klein began her field work in late December, and she was completed by February 19th, which

0:32:38 is the date of the financial statements.

0:32:41 Scott Hunsaker, with Mulkey and Sae Green Company, is here this evening to present the audit findings

0:32:47 and audit opinion for the City of Twin Falls 2015 financial statements.

0:32:52 You should have received an electronic copy of the statements in your agenda packet, and

0:32:56 We wanted to make sure you have those in your hands before Scott's presentation so that you would have time to

0:33:02 Have any questions ready to ask

0:33:06 All right

0:33:08 So

0:33:10 Scott's here and ready to go with that. I'll turn it over to him. Thank you. Thank you, Laurie

0:33:18 Welcome Scott. Thank you. It's good to be with you this evening

0:33:24 I'll let down after all the pictures

0:33:31 But as Lori just mentioned, we're here to report on the audit and how things went and any findings we have.

0:33:39 Again, it's not our intent to go through the details of all the numbers.

0:33:45 It continues to grow now. I think it's about 120 page document.

0:33:49 So we won't get into too many details, but talk about a few changes that have happened

0:33:54 and the standards that were required to report and maybe hit some highlights for you

0:34:00 kind of describe the document that you've received.

0:34:03 I know there's a couple new council members and so we'll kind of describe our role in these

0:34:09 financial statements.

0:34:11 What you've actually received is a comprehensive annual financial report or CAFRA, which is somewhat

0:34:19 unusual for this area of Idaho.

0:34:22 Most entities do not produce this document.

0:34:27 the time it's just the basic financial statement that is produced. The city has gone the extra

0:34:33 mile and taken another step to produce a more detailed document with the management's discussion

0:34:39 analysis and statistical data at the end as well. Our part of this is a portion of it, not

0:34:46 all of it. And so I applaud the city for going that extra step in producing a caffer, which

0:34:54 which is, like I said, unusual, which you'll notice, there is a distinguished budget presentation,

0:35:02 which is because the CAF has been submitted to the GFOA and reviewed a very detailed review,

0:35:11 which is significant that they've received that award.

0:35:15 Our section actually starts on page one.

0:35:18 There's quite a section before, but page one is our audit report, and this is the most important

0:35:27 part.

0:35:29 And down in the opinion section of that page one, we say it's in our opinion the financial

0:35:36 statements referred to above present fairly in all material respects to the financial position

0:35:41 of the government activities, business type activities in the aggregate, discreetly presented

0:35:45 component units of each major fund and aggregate remaining fund information for the city of Twin Falls.

0:35:51 So that's an unqualified opinion.

0:35:54 The next page there is one paragraph that says we've made some changes and we get into those

0:35:59 changes a little bit in detail in just a moment.

0:36:02 Scott Donhall has a question.

0:36:04 I was just curious, do we have any way to put that on the overhead for folks in the audience?

0:36:09 I'm not sure we can.

0:36:11 So that's just, if you want to show page one, if it's not appropriate, don't, I just, you know,

0:36:25 I sometimes being in the audience, they'd like to see it.

0:36:27 There's probably some notes on it and things like that.

0:36:29 Okay. Public information.

0:36:31 So the opinions paragraph is what I just read for you right there.

0:36:38 And that's the unqualified opinion.

0:36:41 On page two, there's a paragraph that's saying, you know, there's some statistical information

0:36:49 down there at the second to the last paragraph, statistical information in the

0:36:53 NDNA and things like that aren't audited. They're actually produced by the city staff

0:36:57 and on to our documents. And there's some

0:37:01 adjustments that get made because of this Percy change that we'll talk about.

0:37:05 The next section is the Management's Discussion Analysis

0:37:09 and like I've told you in the last couple years, that's

0:37:13 a snapshot and that's written by the city and

0:37:17 in plain English, not accounting, jargon,

0:37:21 just kind of giving you a brief overview of where you've been,

0:37:25 what the changes in your net assets have been,

0:37:27 how things have gone this last year,

0:37:30 and then somewhat of the projections going forward.

0:37:33 So that's where I would focus if I was sitting

0:37:36 in your seats.

0:37:38 There's some condensed financial statements

0:37:40 for you to look at on page three of the MD&A.

0:37:45 I don't know if you want to show them or not.

0:37:47 And the next page, Laura, I think, page five on your copy.

0:38:01 We've changed page numbers, I think.

0:38:03 So this is your condensed financial statements.

0:38:07 And essentially, it's a balance sheet showing your assets

0:38:12 and liabilities, your assets far exceed your liabilities,

0:38:15 very stable financial position.

0:38:19 Often we like to look at current assets compared to liabilities, or your ability to fund your obligations for the next year.

0:38:29 You have cash investments that are exceeding a year's worth of expenses or expenditures, which is good.

0:38:35 You're very secure that way.

0:38:38 These statements show two different types of statements, government-wide, and then fund statements.

0:38:44 These are showing government-wide, which show all your infrastructure and

0:38:47 all the assets that the city has, as well as all the obligations dead and all that.

0:38:53 So it's a very secure and then stable financial statement and balance sheet.

0:38:59 There's some graphs there for sources of funding and then more detail in the NDNA is that you can review.

0:39:08 That's going to get to the government wide balance sheet, and the statement of net positions,

0:39:13 which is 14 and 15 on my copy, I think it's a little bit different.

0:39:19 Now, what I want to talk a little bit about tonight was this change with the Percy obligations.

0:39:26 Your government entity, obviously, and you're required to comply with GASB, Government Accounting

0:39:33 Standards Board, they came out with two pronouncements a few years ago, and this is the first year

0:39:38 that they became in effect at 68 and 71 of the numbers

0:39:43 of those two statements.

0:39:45 What it's requiring is that any unfunded liability

0:39:49 of the city for its pension obligations needs

0:39:53 to be put on the balance sheet.

0:39:55 So Percy has spent years, and I don't know how much money,

0:40:02 funding an actuarial study, and significant time and effort to calculate this unfunded liability

0:40:13 for the whole Percy, 130-some-thousand employees, and billions of dollars.

0:40:20 And so what they do is they calculate what the obligation would be for everybody that

0:40:26 could retire at that time, because it's a defined benefit plan, so they can calculate

0:40:31 that, then they do a present value calculation to today's dollar dollars and say that's the

0:40:38 liability that Percy has for future retirees. Then they say well the City of Twin Falls

0:40:46 is obligated for a portion of that and then they take that ratio and say here's the number

0:40:52 that needs to be on your balance sheet. That's now on your balance sheet and it's on the

0:40:58 next page, Lori.

0:40:59 Seven, million, one.

0:41:01 Yeah.

0:41:01 So that gets put onto your balance sheet this year.

0:41:05 It comes as a prior period adjustment

0:41:07 because this is the first year it's gone.

0:41:09 Come on.

0:41:11 It does affect your net assets because it's a liability being

0:41:15 put just directly on your balance sheet.

0:41:18 The problem with this calculation is

0:41:23 that it doesn't take in to consider,

0:41:24 I mean, unfunded liability sounds terrible.

0:41:28 But it doesn't take into consideration the years

0:41:31 that these employees are going to contribute to the plan.

0:41:35 And so with that number of these contributions

0:41:40 for future years, that liability will be funded.

0:41:44 And so it's kind of an extreme and a very conservative approach

0:41:50 to put the full unfunded liability on your balance sheet.

0:41:53 but that's the way the standard board decided it needed to be done.

0:41:57 So it's a much to do about nothing situation really to be honest

0:42:02 because of those liabilities will be funded over time

0:42:05 as employees continue to work and fund their retirement.

0:42:09 That should go down to zero.

0:42:11 It will always be there and it will be adjusted every year going forward.

0:42:15 Percy will continue to provide us with those adjustments up and down.

0:42:19 Whatever your share of that obligation is.

0:42:22 But it added a significant amount of pages to your document, really,

0:42:29 to be honest, of notes and disclosures as to how these assumptions were made.

0:42:33 But in the end, it doesn't really affect you too much other

0:42:37 than produce the amount of net assets you show on your balance sheet.

0:42:41 How we have a couple of comments or questions.

0:42:43 Chris Dockington.

0:42:44 Yeah, and reading through this, and that was fascinating reading.

0:42:47 I have to tell you, the Percy's new declaration

0:42:52 has unfunded liability, cut my attention in the 7.1 million of unfunded balance against

0:43:01 the fireman's million, 950 over funded shows a net balance of about just over 5 million

0:43:09 unfunded. My question is, since it's going to be on the books here after, up and down,

0:43:16 depending what the liabilities are. How does this impact or does the unfunded liability

0:43:24 impact the city's credit rating? Well, that's part of the question. Well, I don't know

0:43:32 exactly. I guess it's the simple answer because I'm not sure how they're going to apply this.

0:43:38 My thoughts would be it wouldn't affect it at all because they would probably back that

0:43:42 off because every government agency is going to have this put on their balance sheet and

0:43:47 really the net effect is, it wouldn't matter really because it's going to get funded.

0:43:53 Now it does affect your net assets and so they could look at that but I would think most

0:43:59 criterating agencies would understand to know and be very familiar with this new liability.

0:44:05 But within the state if all municipalities for instance that are on Percy are treated the

0:44:12 the same, I can see what you're saying so far as you raised the standard for everyone

0:44:18 and so there shouldn't be a difference, comparative, though, to other states that may not have

0:44:23 this requirement or is it a national standard?

0:44:26 So there should be no net change for comparison of all Percy or similar state-funded to find

0:44:34 benefit plans.

0:44:35 Yeah, it's across the nation.

0:44:37 Every government entity that has a pension plan would have to comply with this.

0:44:41 So if they're comparing you with another city it should be apples to apples. Okay. Thanks. That's all Greg Lanting

0:44:49 Just to drill down this gas be required live just a little bit in my mind. Is this because some of the other

0:44:56 Defined retirement programs are so grossly underfunded across the country is reason this requirement came

0:45:02 Into being and plus a lot of other cities have their own

0:45:05 retirement plan, we're part of the state plan here, but in ours plan it's all about a hundred

0:45:11 percent funded, it's certainly closer. And the part that I have a little trouble with

0:45:16 or stand is you can't even retire under per se with the exception of disability until 855.

0:45:23 So how do you say that's unfunded when people can't even access it, even if they wanted to?

0:45:32 There are some significant assumptions that have been made to come to this number.

0:45:38 And that's just the way it is.

0:45:39 And these actuaries have done that.

0:45:42 We have to assume that their assumptions are valid and good, but Percy, who's audited, that's

0:45:52 what they've done and spend a lot of money on to get it done and hopefully accurately.

0:45:59 But from what I understand, Percy is a very secure retirement system compared to many.

0:46:06 To your point about it being an overreaction, I think it is, and in the MD&A there's a bullet

0:46:11 point about that saying this is really kind of a reaction to some other plans that struggled

0:46:17 that were, had a significant unfunded liability and weren't able to meet those obligations.

0:46:22 So it is a reaction to what's happened.

0:46:26 Other, please.

0:46:27 Travis, did you want to add to that?

0:46:28 Yeah, I think this got just hit at the many of the communities that this was probably geared

0:46:34 at have one of their own independently funded plans that as a result of the recession and

0:46:41 other activities, you notice that their liabilities went significantly up and some cities that

0:46:47 come to mind immediately are the city of Stockton, California.

0:46:52 And because what gets me is it's a national board and it basically reviews and makes recommendations

0:46:58 on what should be included in a complete audit, we are forced to comply with those general

0:47:04 standards as we move forward.

0:47:07 Even though it may not be an apples-to-apples comparison as what you see here, we are required

0:47:13 to insert that.

0:47:15 Where that number becomes more concerning is if the City of Twin Falls is not a member

0:47:19 of Percy, but actually may have its own operated independent retirement benefit and program.

0:47:28 And then on the backside of that, you have to be able to demonstrate that you have the

0:47:31 ability to pay and meet those extreme circumstances, unlike where this is more connected to Percy

0:47:38 and you have those years that Scott is talking about.

0:47:42 Thank you.

0:47:43 Yeah, I think there's significant security in being part of the Percy Plan because of

0:47:48 this, this unfunded liability, certainly.

0:47:51 So that's a significant change this year,

0:47:54 compared to last year.

0:47:56 And you'll see it kind of throughout the financial statements

0:48:00 as a prior pretty adjustment on the income statements

0:48:02 and those types of financial statements.

0:48:08 Like I said, you can go through the detail

0:48:10 and Lori does a good job of presenting the detail

0:48:13 regularly to you.

0:48:15 In the back, there are budget to actual,

0:48:18 which from management's perspective is kind of interesting to see how you've done budget to actual.

0:48:24 And then in the very back, there's a most statistical analysis.

0:48:28 But in front of that is our opinion as to the internal controls of the entity,

0:48:34 which is important for you as a governing body to know that we've tested.

0:48:39 We select a sample of transactions and we trace that through the internal control structure that's been established by the city and

0:48:46 make sure that the processes are followed and complied with, that's the letter, and we didn't

0:48:54 do note any exceptions.

0:48:56 As a year or more ago, we talked about that.

0:48:59 If there were to be exceptions noted during our internal controls testing, we would bring

0:49:04 them to your attention and let you know what our findings were at this time we didn't find

0:49:10 anything.

0:49:11 So, kind of heavy on the Percy side this time, but that's okay in my opinion because it's kind

0:49:18 of an interesting change.

0:49:20 But it really went very well, Lori and her staff do a great job, Brent helps us get things

0:49:24 scheduled and get things to us in an orderly manner so that we can audit and get things done.

0:49:29 So, I appreciate them very much, I appreciate the opportunity to present this to you tonight.

0:49:34 Chris Tockington.

0:49:35 A couple more questions on long-term debt, incidentally, Council, it's on page 47 of our

0:49:43 iPad if you're interested under long-term debt.

0:49:48 It's talking about the long-term debt incurred by unused vacation and other absence and this

0:49:57 This may be more a question for a city manager.

0:50:00 But the more unused vacation and work hours out in employee, the more that long-term debt

0:50:10 goes up and it's about a million eight this year by your calculation.

0:50:15 Could you Travis go over what our policy of how much vacation time an employee may acquire

0:50:25 and posing the devil's advocate question, why should we not require employees to take more

0:50:32 of the vacation on an ongoing basis, since there's a very real value to that for regenerating

0:50:38 employees' enthusiasm as opposed to not doing what they intended with the vacation?

0:50:47 So I don't think that you'll find anyone in disagreement that if they have vacation

0:50:51 hours on the books, they would love to be able to take those vacation hours as those times

0:50:56 come up. Speaking from someone of experience, I think the best slate of intentions sometimes

0:51:03 get hijacked by need and projects that come about and sometimes that our attentions are

0:51:10 needed to be here even though you might have had vacation plans. Sometimes staffing issues

0:51:18 are going to play a role into whether or not an individual can take those

0:51:24 times off that they may have scheduled. The city's policy is that every employee

0:51:29 inside the city of Twin Falls who is eligible can carry up to 160 hours of

0:51:37 vacation time on the books. After 160 hours they have to and their

0:51:45 their anniversary date approaches, they have to make special arrangements to be able to

0:51:49 use that time within a defined period of time or they lose that time.

0:51:54 And that time can be trans, can go into build sick leave time or it can be, I guess it go

0:52:01 into sick leave time.

0:52:04 One exempt employees can earn comp time up to 60 hours in the non-police and fire areas.

0:52:16 And so we offer comp time.

0:52:18 After comp time, we begin to pay overtime in the public works functions, for example.

0:52:24 In the police and fire functions, we pay overtime upon those dollars being earned.

0:52:33 You'll see in the business type, that business type is illustrated by the sewer fund, the water fund,

0:52:39 the enterprise funds that we carry inside the city, the governmental type are going to be all the tax-supported funds.

0:52:44 It makes sense that the government fund is going to be larger because that's where you're going to see the bulk of our employees

0:52:52 associated with our organization are going to be in that area.

0:52:58 I think this is kind of like Gadsby was at 68, I think, on Percy, because what this says

0:53:05 is that if every employee inside the City of Twin Falls were needed to be cashed out that

0:53:10 vacation time today, this is what that liability would be.

0:53:15 And so even though it's reported and it's disclosed, it's not something that is immediately cashed

0:53:21 out.

0:53:22 concerns and Laurie and I've talked about this is as we continue to migrate through

0:53:28 our areas with compensation that value is attached to a hour and a wage and as

0:53:39 we kind of increase those wages we can expect that liability to increase if

0:53:44 we don't take some sort of other action and I think that one of the things that

0:53:51 What you'll find is that our liability in terms of vacation, leave, comp, and sick leave

0:53:57 is probably very in line with an organization our size.

0:54:03 Similar to our Percy, liability is going to be probably similar in line to an organization

0:54:08 our size as well as with our tenure.

0:54:10 If we were looking at a larger organization that had more employees, you would see that

0:54:16 those would significantly increase.

0:54:19 Thank you. Any other questions for Scott? I don't see any more questions. Thank you very

0:54:30 much for your presentation. The next item on the agenda is consideration of a request to

0:54:41 award a contract to CH2M in the amount of $817,776 for the Twin Falls Wastewater Treatment

0:54:50 Plant Headworks Improvement Project and we have Assistant City Engineer, Troy Vitek.

0:54:55 Welcome, Troy.

0:54:56 Thank you, council members.

0:54:58 Tonight, I'm coming before you.

0:55:00 Well, recently I brought before you an award for the wastewater treatment plant, headworks

0:55:05 construction for RSCI, who was under the engineer's estimate, and we awarded to them.

0:55:12 This contract before you today has kind of been two parts.

0:55:15 The first part is for 664,986, and that is construction management and services to construction.

0:55:24 So they essentially are on site, they watch the contractor perform the work, make sure

0:55:29 we are getting the project that we bid and awarded to them.

0:55:34 It's continued work, they keep track of like change orders and request for information

0:55:41 and makes the work progress smoothly and we know the product we get in the end.

0:55:47 The other portion of this request tonight is for $152,790.

0:55:52 This is for the SCADA programming.

0:55:54 So this, to me, is more of an engineering issue.

0:55:56 We would have designed it with the headworks, but we weren't entirely sure we could afford

0:56:01 headworks at the time, so we went out and bid it, and if it came in high, we were just

0:56:06 going to shelve it until we can afford it in the future.

0:56:10 That's why we didn't design the program because, as you know, computers change, programs change

0:56:14 fast, so we held off on doing the rest completing this engineering until we were ready to bid

0:56:20 it.

0:56:21 This is why this contract adds up to $817,776, and I just request approval of this.

0:56:29 This is budgeted. We had a savings on the original bid.

0:56:34 This seized to mail is currently working force down there, and representing us.

0:56:39 This is really an extension of that contract.

0:56:42 What was the savings on that bid?

0:56:44 So the total bid originally was $5.8 million,

0:56:49 and we have allocated roughly $5.6 million

0:56:53 towards the Headworks Project,

0:56:55 saving a little bit for other projects in the future.

0:57:00 Thank you, Troy.

0:57:01 Sure.

0:57:02 Any other questions for Troy?

0:57:06 Entertain a motion.

0:57:08 Great landing.

0:57:09 There, I move that we approve the request award to H2M

0:57:14 and the amount of $817,76, when we start over.

0:57:20 817,776 dollars for the wastewater treatment plant

0:57:26 headworks improvement project.

0:57:28 Second.

0:57:30 A motion by Greg Lansing, seconded by Don Hall

0:57:32 to award the contract, Chris Talkington.

0:57:37 Well, when I ran last time, I ran on wanting to make sure

0:57:40 that we're on schedule and on budget for this project.

0:57:43 It's fair to say that the umbrella, the overview of the wastewater plant is that we have not

0:57:49 exceeded budget nor extended past our intended deadlines.

0:57:55 For the original phase, that is correct.

0:57:56 For the original?

0:57:57 Yes.

0:57:58 We haven't started this phase.

0:57:59 So, let's see, as we start up, we're anticipating we've been just as fast as we did originally.

0:58:05 Try this route by the way.

0:58:07 We were able to add the Head Works Project in as a result of savings realized on the other

0:58:13 phase. This was contemplated in the event that we found ourselves in this position when

0:58:18 we wrote the bond resolute or bond ordinance and this is being able to take advantage of

0:58:24 the savings that we realized on that project.

0:58:27 To ponder, have that stated public like.

0:58:32 Thank you. Any other discussion from the council? Seeing none, the aisles roll call vote please.

0:58:38 Sean Bericker, yes.

0:58:40 Yes.

0:58:41 Great glanting.

0:58:42 Yes.

0:58:43 Don Hall.

0:58:44 Yes.

0:58:45 Yes.

0:58:46 Yes.

0:58:47 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:58:48 Yes.

0:58:49 Nikki Boyd.

0:58:50 Yes.

0:58:52 Passes 7-0.

0:58:53 Next on the agenda we have consideration of a request to accept and approve the guaranteed

0:58:57 maximum price on the partial demolition of the banner building site and complete demolition of

0:59:02 the Raderson Hotel and existing city downtown fountain.

0:59:05 We have city manager Travis Rothweiler.

0:59:08 Mr. Mayor, members of the council also with me tonight is Michael Errington with Star Corporation

0:59:14 Star Corporation serving as our construction manager and

0:59:19 General Contractor associated with this project

0:59:22 And we went through a very competitive process to select them and since their selection

0:59:27 They've been working hand-in-hand not only with the city, but also with humble architects as we advance

0:59:33 into this exciting phase in the city, which not only includes the reconstruction of the

0:59:40 banner facility and transforming that into a modern city hall, but taking advantage of

0:59:45 the current properties that we own, and then transforming them into a fully functioning

0:59:50 public safety camp.

0:59:53 Tonight before you is the very first of many steps that you will see as we kind of go through

0:59:59 this process.

1:00:03 R has presented a guaranteed maximum price referred to as a GMP for your review and approval,

1:00:12 and you'll notice that there are a series of different proposals in this document for

1:00:17 your review and consideration.

1:00:21 The total of the projects is $758,662, but what's important is they are broke into two

1:00:36 responsible parties.

1:00:39 The first would be approximately $200,000, $200,813 for the banner piece and the balance

1:00:49 of that is associated with the Rogerson piece and the Falcon piece.

1:00:54 Some time ago, the city and the urban rule agency entered into a memorandum of understanding

1:00:59 in which the agency asked the city through STAR to serve as the general contractor over

1:01:08 the downtown commons in the removal of Falcon because of how tight that construction area

1:01:14 is going to be.

1:01:15 And so we went forward and we had STAR bid those pieces on their behalf.

1:01:21 The Urban Renewal Agency will be responsible for all the true costs associated with their

1:01:26 project.

1:01:27 Their guaranteed maximum will be presented to them at their board meeting on Wednesday

1:01:33 of this week.

1:01:36 The guaranteed maximum is what STAR is estimating that maximum price for this project will be.

1:01:44 And you'll notice that it has a cost for the demolition.

1:01:48 It also has a series of costs associated with the individual pieces of the project.

1:01:55 There are what I would define as those general conditions or look at them as those fixed costs,

1:02:00 which is going to be the project managers and the superintendent, which falls in line with

1:02:05 our scope.

1:02:06 You'll also notice that there are some allowances and some contingencies.

1:02:11 We've also, as you'll recall, pre-negotiated the profit with STAR.

1:02:16 And so in the event that the contingencies are not realized and in the event that the allowances

1:02:23 do not cost what are presented here, we will retain those savings.

1:02:28 And STAR is only receiving the profit on the cost of the demolition work.

1:02:36 So what's beautiful thing for us about the maximum guaranteed, which doesn't necessarily

1:02:42 make Michael happy, is that even if the contingencies are elevated above, and we believe that they

1:02:50 could have recently been anticipated, there is no additional cost to the city or to the

1:02:57 agency.

1:03:00 So one easy way to look at it is if there is savings on the $200,813 project for the demolition

1:03:12 of the banner, so say it takes less time than what's anticipated for those costs, we will

1:03:18 enjoy those savings.

1:03:21 If for some very unfortunate reason, Michael's number isn't quite right, it's a pretty bad

1:03:29 a day for Michael, but in fairness, Michael and his team have spent a lot of time on this

1:03:40 project. There should be very, very few on, no, and in fact we should probably anticipate

1:03:45 that this project is going to come in very, very close to this number with the amount of

1:03:50 time that we've spent studying this project as well as the Banner, as well as the Rogers

1:03:55 building and that's the advantage is that there are limiting surprises is why we

1:04:02 go through the CMGC process. So tonight we would ask for you to award the guaranteed

1:04:08 maximum price as presented for all three phases contingent upon the urban

1:04:14 renewal agency accepting the GFP for their two pieces of the project. Thank you Travis

1:04:22 Chris talking. Could you kind of reacquaint us with what the project of this size and

1:04:27 Star is certainly a known entity in our town but what the bonding or the

1:04:32 insurance protection is for the city or the people that might be interested in

1:04:37 a falling crack or something of that nature.

1:04:44 Mr. Mayor, how's the long time ago?

1:04:52 Mr. Mayor, there's a couple of different protections for the City of Twin Falls and to the neighboring

1:05:00 businesses down there, really.

1:05:02 First of all, we'll provide a payment performance bond that is payable to the City of Twin Falls.

1:05:09 We provide that that takes care of in the event that we get in the situation where you

1:05:17 pay us and we fail to pay somebody else that's working on the job.

1:05:21 You don't have to pay your bills twice then essentially.

1:05:24 So that protection is offered to you.

1:05:26 There's also, that's the payment side of the bonding,

1:05:28 then there's a performance side.

1:05:30 That's in the event that we can't complete the work for,

1:05:33 or won't for whatever reason.

1:05:35 There's a protection of the city to be able to go in

1:05:37 and do that.

1:05:39 There's also general liability requirements

1:05:41 that are specifically laid out into the contract

1:05:44 where we will name you the city of Twin Falls

1:05:48 as an additional insured under our general liability insurance.

1:05:51 We also, because of the nature of this particular phase of the project, we also have some very

1:05:58 specific language and armpit packages that have the demolition of subcontractors name

1:06:03 ourselves and the City of Twin Falls as additional insurance.

1:06:10 Thank you, Mr. Herring.

1:06:11 Thank you.

1:06:12 Susanne Hawkins.

1:06:13 Thank you.

1:06:14 This question is for Travis.

1:06:15 Thanks, Michael.

1:06:16 So, just playing devil's advocate.

1:06:19 What happens to our portion of this if the URA for some reason decides to say no to their

1:06:24 portion of it?

1:06:25 We still move forward with ours.

1:06:27 So we're okay in the whole thing but really okay in our part.

1:06:31 So I'm asking is that because we have the memorandum of understanding is that you approve

1:06:36 ours and then there's contingent upon their review earlier this week.

1:06:41 If they simply fail to move forward then we want to move forward with those two pieces

1:06:46 of the work.

1:06:48 Thank you.

1:06:50 Any other questions for Travis or Michael?

1:06:53 Seeing none, I would entertain a motion.

1:06:58 Greg Lanting.

1:06:59 Yeah.

1:07:00 Slow down here.

1:07:01 I, uh, mare, I would move that we accept and approve the guaranteed maximum price on

1:07:07 the partial demolition for the banner building site and complete demolition of the demolition

1:07:13 of the Rogers Hotel and the Zistine City Downtown Fountain pending approval by the Urban Rural

1:07:19 leads and see for those last two portions.

1:07:22 Second.

1:07:24 The motion by Greg Lansing, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins

1:07:29 to approve the request.

1:07:31 Any discussion from the council?

1:07:34 You didn't name the party though, didn't you?

1:07:37 No, I didn't.

1:07:38 Which I'm not so sorry, as Rick, as presented.

1:07:41 As presented, that's what I'll add.

1:07:43 If my seconds are right with that.

1:07:48 So it says there's not a party that was just

1:07:51 Successful bidders, okay?

1:07:54 Seeing no further discussion. We are the roll call vote, please

1:07:57 Chris talking to yes great glanting

1:07:59 Yes, don Hall yes booth pierce. Yes, Suzanne Hawkins. Yes, Nicky Boyd. Yes, Sean Berrigger

1:08:07 Yes, motion passes seven two zero don Hall Travis. Would you mind just giving us a brief?

1:08:15 timetable you and I had this discussion

1:08:17 late last week because I had a

1:08:19 business on Main Street asked about that because they're very sensitive to their retail obligations there.

1:08:26 Maybe give us just a real brief, when's the demo happening, what's happening on Main Street and all those things.

1:08:33 Great question.

1:08:36 So on April 12th, and I think Sean is going to talk about this later this evening during the council report,

1:08:45 We are planning to have the state of the city.

1:08:49 On the 13th, we will turn possession of all three facilities over to Star Corporation on

1:08:56 and they will begin their processes.

1:08:58 You'll notice that in the GMPs, it contemplated up to a three month period of time for all

1:09:09 of that area and it will include the banner, it will include the fountain as well as the

1:09:16 Rogers in Peace. Those are the projects that we will begin construction and people will

1:09:22 begin to see immediately at the entire time with maybe some demolition on the

1:09:28 fountain. Main Street will remain passable until we begin the construction

1:09:34 associated with the urban and old downtown Renaissance piece and that

1:09:38 construction piece will not begin until February right now the anticipated is

1:09:42 February of 2017, and we will begin on the blocks generally west of Shoshone, and then

1:09:51 coming back and completing the other works, the other three blocks, and you can

1:09:57 anticipate those occurring in middle to late spring of 2017 and concluding

1:10:05 sometime by early summer. We are continuing to

1:10:12 to refine the schedule of the Urban Renewal Agency

1:10:14 is looking at hiring a project manager

1:10:16 at their next meeting and hiring the project manager.

1:10:20 They will be able to pinpoint the exact time right now.

1:10:23 It's estimated that each block moving forward,

1:10:26 as currently designed, will take about six weeks,

1:10:28 four to six weeks for completion.

1:10:33 Thank you, Travis.

1:10:34 Greg Land.

1:10:35 Just for the public's knowledge,

1:10:37 I know there's been some concern about the,

1:10:40 the Wednesday night concerts downtown,

1:10:42 and they are looking for an alternate location

1:10:45 for at least this summer,

1:10:47 and maybe the following summer.

1:10:48 I haven't heard that before, that is.

1:10:49 I'm assuming that has moved to the Northwest Street,

1:10:51 but we've been working with them on that project.

1:10:55 We spent some time with Tony and Robin,

1:11:01 and really trying to investigate really good possibilities.

1:11:05 We've shared that we're happy to be a partner in.

1:11:07 And with them, we know they've had conversations

1:11:09 with the fire department in terms of what areas of streets

1:11:12 that they can look at.

1:11:14 They've also been in conversations

1:11:15 with the Idaho Power Company in terms of bringing power

1:11:18 to ensure that there was a proper

1:11:20 and through electricity in those areas

1:11:22 to be able to support the bands

1:11:25 and the different venting going on.

1:11:30 We believe, and I will confirm this,

1:11:33 but I believe that in this first year,

1:11:36 I think that they're just talking about turning

1:11:39 and utilizing Main Street since Main Street

1:11:41 is still going to continue to be un-destructed,

1:11:44 but maybe push down just a little bit.

1:11:47 Don't know.

1:11:48 Again, just on the demo side of the three areas,

1:11:53 starts April 13th, when will it be completed?

1:11:58 It's about three months.

1:11:59 Three months, okay, very good, thank you.

1:12:04 All right, next item on the agenda.

1:12:10 City Council input on priorities to be incorporated

1:12:12 into the long-term planning committee's recommendation

1:12:15 and we have Lori race again.

1:12:17 Welcome, Lori.

1:12:22 Thank you.

1:12:26 So as most of you are aware,

1:12:29 the long-term planning committee is a group of employees

1:12:32 across our organization.

1:12:34 And this team consists of 17 employees.

1:12:38 We meet twice a week and we discuss the needs of the city

1:12:42 and help shape a plan that moves forward

1:12:47 our strategic plan. So we're tasked with preparing and refining a five-year spending plan for the City of Twin Falls.

1:12:55 We approach this by the focus areas in the strategic plan and with all members as a whole weighing in on personnel and equipment needs deemed necessary for the city to achieve the goals and objectives for each identified area.

1:13:11 Knowing that our revenues are limited and that list of needs is not, this planning tool allows us to look at a bigger picture and make our recommendations to Travis as he begins preparing the budget for fiscal year 2017 and beyond.

1:13:27 Last week, Travis shared his priorities with you for the upcoming budget.

1:13:32 Tonight, the long-term planning committee is asking you to weigh in and share your priorities.

1:13:38 We want to take those items to the committee and ensure we've included them and our recommendations

1:13:43 to travest.

1:13:45 So if you have any questions about the process, I'm very happy to answer those and if not, we're

1:13:50 ready to hear what your priorities are.

1:13:57 Council.

1:14:01 So Laurie, maybe a question.

1:14:03 So in looking through this strategic plan and the matrix that we have lined out, this is probably

1:14:10 going to be your best guesstimate.

1:14:13 So of the items that we have listed as priority one issues, how many of those do you think

1:14:19 we're actually addressing currently?

1:14:22 So Sean, so you're talking about the number one listed in the strategic plan.

1:14:36 So I think we've done a really good job of starting to address those things.

1:14:41 I know that when we were working on the strategic plan that was a concern that we seemed to

1:14:45 to have an awful lot of priority one issues

1:14:49 that we're gonna jump right into.

1:14:51 But as I glanced through two, I feel like

1:14:54 we've at least touched most of them.

1:14:56 We have.

1:14:58 And that number one priority really gives us

1:15:00 a five year window to get those things done.

1:15:03 And the beauty of this strategic plan

1:15:06 is that it's our roadmap.

1:15:08 We're all on the same page and we're all moving forward

1:15:10 and helping to achieve all those goals

1:15:13 and objectives that have been identified, so.

1:15:19 Chris Stockins, with Brother of General's statement,

1:15:21 and it doesn't fit in any tight category,

1:15:25 but I think that the city and its staff

1:15:27 have to emphasize technology over labor, working smart,

1:15:33 and the cross training and working and helping

1:15:37 and assistance that we're seeing with departments now,

1:15:42 doing away with killing trees as much as possible,

1:15:45 going to the iPads using the technology for wireless communication, upgrading our staff's

1:15:52 capabilities, rewarding them commensurately to help on longevity.

1:15:57 But we cannot afford to be a technology avoidance community and I expect our staff to be leading

1:16:06 examples of that for other businesses and governments.

1:16:12 Nikki Boyd.

1:16:13 So, as I just call myself a newbie, I'm just clarifying, so in the green line, those are

1:16:19 our goals, those are our focus areas, so the focus areas, Nick, you're like healthy community,

1:16:26 there's eight of them.

1:16:27 Correct.

1:16:28 Okay.

1:16:29 So, those are the goals in the green lines and then it goes down to an initiative and

1:16:36 then that committee has broken it down to the objectives on how we're going to accomplish

1:16:42 the initiative.

1:16:43 So in those objectives were created when the plan was created?

1:16:47 Right.

1:16:48 Yeah.

1:16:49 And so we just take it focus area by focus area.

1:16:51 Right.

1:16:52 Okay.

1:16:53 So so far I'm tracking 100 percent.

1:16:55 The next question is it shows a time frame and it has the one twos and threes.

1:17:02 Is there a checklist where as this is accomplished it's checked off or what's the rest of the

1:17:09 story?

1:17:10 I do know that there was an update to that and I believe it's time to update it again.

1:17:15 But we're also planning on going through a review of the strategic plan.

1:17:19 Because while it says it's comprehensive for through 2030, things are changing.

1:17:26 So long time from now.

1:17:27 Yeah.

1:17:28 So I know we'll be updating that.

1:17:30 Okay.

1:17:31 Thank you very much.

1:17:33 Don Hall.

1:17:34 You know, Lori, just looking through here obviously that's number one that comes up and

1:17:39 This was brought up last week by our city managers.

1:17:42 The goal that says treat our employees fairly, and it talks about the benefit packages and

1:17:49 the compensation packages, make sure that we're staying on board and maintaining our market

1:17:56 ability to bring in that staff, because everything else that we do, as well illustrated last

1:18:02 week, really depends on our employees and the quality of employees that we have.

1:18:09 So that would be kind of an overarching thing that I would like to just bring up.

1:18:16 And then I'm going to get on my horse again and talk about mobility and sidewalks.

1:18:21 It's in our strategic plan as well, not only transportation.

1:18:27 Well, Mike was not on.

1:18:31 Sorry, I'm not going to start over.

1:18:33 I wouldn't torture everyone with that.

1:18:36 But that to me is, the trail system, all those dynamics are very, very important.

1:18:43 And some of the things that we can do in relations to making our community more

1:18:50 appealing to bring in staff and employees.

1:18:54 But sidewalks to me are the things that help folks,

1:18:59 that that's their only way around.

1:19:02 The only way that they can get from point A to point B is because they walk or

1:19:05 whether they're in a wheelchair or they're on a bike or whatever.

1:19:09 That is so important.

1:19:11 So I would just re-emphasize that that should be a goal of the city.

1:19:18 So thank you.

1:19:19 Great Lansing.

1:19:22 Well, someone along the same line, Vayne is talking about.

1:19:26 One of my major goals would be is under a more broad setting of customer service.

1:19:32 service. And of course, the huge portion of customer services is our employees. And

1:19:38 it's been a lot of years as a supervisor. And I know that happy employees are much more

1:19:44 productive than unhappy employees. There's just no comparison. And so, I will read the

1:19:51 same thing as Dom was talking about that, I believe that's the compensation of our employees

1:19:56 needs to be fair. We need to match our comp-competition so we can keep the best employees here.

1:20:02 I'll put my next one on another, almost another broad title of livability, and we're

1:20:10 talking about the city of Twin Falls' livability, and well that may include Don Sidewalks, I'm

1:20:16 not as passionate about the Sidewalks as Don is, but I know it's important.

1:20:21 I made a special purpose to drive down third the other day, the one that John Keaton talked

1:20:27 about last week and we made that effort that since it was in the zone to be worked on we

1:20:33 took care of sewer, we took care of curbs, we took care of sidewalk on one side, that seems

1:20:38 to make a lot of sense to me to target those areas where we can get the most bang for our

1:20:44 buck. We're not going to put a new street and then three years later I've put a new

1:20:48 sewer line or a new water line. Let's see Rob back there. No, that makes any sense to me.

1:20:53 So, streets are very important to me along with the amenities around them, but I still feel

1:21:01 like anything we can do to extend our trail system within reason, of course, is important,

1:21:08 goes to the livability.

1:21:10 And the quality of streets within our city outside of those areas where we target something,

1:21:16 the repair of and those particular things are very important to me.

1:21:22 I mean, this one goes to the problems we may have had just recently with our water supply

1:21:29 and him and a men would have said in the past.

1:21:34 And I've said in the past the people, when they turn their water on and they want to have

1:21:41 water there and they flush the toilet that they want that water to go away.

1:21:44 They want that to go away.

1:21:45 They don't want to how.

1:21:46 They just want it to be that way.

1:21:48 I'm going to say when they turn that water tap on, they want that water to be clean and

1:21:53 safe.

1:21:54 And so that stretches out to a few things of what water lines

1:22:01 when they need to be placed, as well as, and Don,

1:22:04 I can't believe you didn't mention this one.

1:22:05 Capacity.

1:22:06 Capacity and storage, which is another item

1:22:10 that I think we need to make sure we're aware of our needs.

1:22:15 I think John scared us just a little bit here two weeks ago,

1:22:18 but it was a three weeks ago about the different zones

1:22:23 And some zones are overtaxed, and others are in good shape, because in my mind, I thought lawfully, but storage one place is good everywhere.

1:22:30 Well, that's true to an extent, but not completely true.

1:22:32 So those are would be my emphasis, my personal emphasis for this budget.

1:22:40 Thank you, Suzanne Hawkins.

1:22:42 Thank you.

1:22:43 I feel kind of greedy this year.

1:22:45 We have so much going on with the downtown project and the new city hall and the safety complex.

1:22:51 And we know the issues with the water and the streets.

1:22:54 And I want to make sure that our employees are treated fair and that compensation does

1:22:57 rise to the top.

1:22:59 But if I could have anything off of my wish list this year, it would be that recreation

1:23:03 center that we so desperately need.

1:23:06 I think the trails are great, but in the wintertime they're not always accessible.

1:23:10 And if we had an indoor facility that could be utilized, there's so many different age groups

1:23:15 and groups in the community that would benefit from that particular facility.

1:23:20 I'm going to be short and sweet, but that's what rises to the top of my list.

1:23:25 Thank you, Ruth Pierce.

1:23:27 Well, I wanted to mention that probably the number one topic that was brought up at the

1:23:32 senior centers was transportation.

1:23:37 They're having a hard time with what's going on with, I can't think of the name of the program

1:23:42 at the college, Link, yes, and being able to get to places if they don't drive.

1:23:50 And I know that we're hitting the 50,000 mark, and so we're going to have to be investigating

1:23:56 that.

1:23:57 But somehow these seniors aren't getting serviced.

1:24:05 Chris, talk.

1:24:06 As a follow up to my technology comments, under former IT guru, Nick Turner?

1:24:14 Yeah.

1:24:15 We started the program a long time ago on the GPSing of all of our water sewer utility

1:24:24 lines.

1:24:25 I'd like to have an update on that periodically and hope that that will remain a priority

1:24:30 because long term that's going to be an incredible labor saver as well as the material saver.

1:24:39 And I would hope that we would have a goal within some reasonable period of time to have

1:24:46 the citywide system all digitized.

1:24:51 You know about how far we are along on that citywide now, anybody?

1:25:01 I know when new subdivisions come on, they're automatically digitized, I'm pretty sure, but

1:25:06 It's the old town side and old infrastructure, I don't think has received much attention.

1:25:13 Let us kind of put together a presentation or report and we'll be able to show where we're at with that.

1:25:19 Thank you.

1:25:20 Don, how?

1:25:24 I just want to make a quick comment about the water.

1:25:28 I would feel very greedy if I said something about capacity again because I know we've made some significant infrastructure.

1:25:37 investments because of our business partners.

1:25:41 Frankly, we wouldn't have been able to do it without our industry coming into town.

1:25:45 I still think that should be a priority for the future and water lines and all that.

1:25:50 Transportation as far as streets, I think that we've made some great strides in that respect as well.

1:25:56 And putting our roadways on a rotational maintenance plan.

1:26:02 Certainly there probably needs to be more money invested in that area as well.

1:26:07 And that's why I didn't go down those roads, I just wanted to clarify.

1:26:11 I would add just a couple of comments that echo some of what's been said here.

1:26:15 So I find it interesting that when you look under our different focus areas, all but

1:26:21 one item under the internal organization has a priority one on it.

1:26:26 So I think that says that we've already made a commitment when we did the strategic

1:26:31 plan that our employees and our internal support is the most critical issue that we

1:26:38 need to be addressing. And it's not only about compensation, that's certainly one of the initiatives,

1:26:43 but it talks about training, it talks about incentive programs, it talks about mentoring

1:26:50 and cross-training, which is actually the only number two priority in there. And I'm sure

1:26:55 that many of these things are happening internally, but I would just echo that I think a focus

1:26:59 on ensuring that we are bringing in the top talent to our city and making sure that they

1:27:09 stick around to continue to provide those talents to our citizens is important.

1:27:13 Obviously we've had a lot of really capital intensive things that have rolled our way over

1:27:18 the last year or so in particular and when we talk about things like sidewalks and the

1:27:24 water improvements and those types of things, those are giant issues.

1:27:29 I would certainly support the continued planning for those efforts.

1:27:34 So we have sort of this master water plan now, let's chop it up into the pieces that we

1:27:38 think we need to start doing over the next five years.

1:27:42 Transportation, we have a master transportation planning process that's going to be underway

1:27:46 soon, so making sure that we're focused on that.

1:27:50 And to Suzanne's point about the recreation center, I know we had an effort with the Parks

1:27:55 and Recreation master planning this last year that probably still needs a little bit

1:27:59 attention and focusing on what did that plan tell us and what are we actually

1:28:04 going to go do because they think all of us have our gut check of what we think

1:28:09 people want. I mean the trails are a very visible thing that have visible gaps and

1:28:15 it's easy to say let's finish those gaps but we need to start thinking about down

1:28:20 the road and things like recreation centers and perhaps new regional parks

1:28:25 and those types of things.

1:28:26 So I would say those very capital intensive projects obviously aren't all going to be able

1:28:35 to be done in the next year, but we need to make sure that we're planning appropriately

1:28:38 for those so that it's not, oh geez, we haven't done anything with this for 15 years and now

1:28:43 it's going to cost us $90 million to do it, so there's my two cents.

1:28:54 Anyone else have any additional input for the Long Range Planning Committee?

1:29:00 Chris Stockton.

1:29:01 to give a kudos to the city staff for making this probably an exemplary plan around the state.

1:29:09 I would measure up what we're doing here with any place that I'm aware of in the northwest.

1:29:14 And it's because of you, we're going to succeed and we really appreciate the feet on the ground,

1:29:21 knowing what's realistic and what's needed.

1:29:24 And so we make a good team, but you guys are leading, we're following.

1:29:28 Just remember that.

1:29:33 to you and the rest of the team feel like you've got some good input from the

1:29:37 council this evening. I think we certainly have some information that we can take

1:29:41 back and incorporate. Great. Well next week could have a

1:29:47 pretty old. Thank you very much. Thank you. The next item on the agenda is

1:29:55 another opportunity for general public input. If there's anyone here from the

1:29:59 public who would like to address the council on any issues that we did not

1:30:03 address on the agenda this evening seeing no one items from the City Manager Mr.

1:30:12 Rothweiler. Mr. Mayor members the council I spoke just briefly about the state of the

1:30:19 city that was going to be the largest piece that I had also just begin to share

1:30:26 with the council and also with the community. March 30th is the day in which

1:30:31 we are going to take six hours of our time and move forward and have an internal business

1:30:37 meeting with the city staff and the city team to begin that construction, that building of

1:30:42 one city.

1:30:43 So just wanted to share, we're starting to have that communication not only with the council

1:30:47 but also with the community that from the hours of like 8.30 to 3.30 we're going to be

1:30:54 still offering all of the critical public safety support but we're going to be locking

1:31:00 ourselves away at a remote facility and really engaging on how to advance one city inside

1:31:07 our organization.

1:31:08 So, we're starting to plant that conversation in the end.

1:31:12 So, I'll follow up on the state of the city, so the state of the city is the annual partnership

1:31:18 event that the city has with the Chamber of Commerce, so this is our monthly Twin Falls

1:31:23 Today luncheon.

1:31:24 So, that will be on April 12th, I've worked with Travis and we're actually going to hold

1:31:28 that in the banner building the day before the demolition begins. So we'll be set up in there

1:31:35 and the chamber is working with all of the downtown restaurants and various food vendors

1:31:42 to help provide all of the food for the luncheon so we can kind of spread the

1:31:46 wealth around down there and help support those businesses. And then we'll be, what did you call

1:31:52 it? The Golden Sledgehammer will be, so we're good at ribbon cuttings at the chamber but apparently

1:31:57 Travis once at Golden Sledgehammer so we can start tearing things up at the end of

1:32:01 that because the demolition will begin that next day so it'll be a good

1:32:04 opportunity to to celebrate that and it's always a well-attended event we look

1:32:08 forward to the the partnership to share in detail what's happening downtown so

1:32:15 stay tuned for more information anyone else from the council have reports

1:32:20 Don Hall I don't have a report just real quick Tammy I just want to mention to you

1:32:24 my iPad is really starting to suffer it's it's been plugged in for about eight

1:32:29 hours now and it's only at 60 percent and I've talked to a couple other council

1:32:33 members that are seeing similar things with their so it must be that time I guess

1:32:39 for the battery. Susan Hockett. I had something else to say but I'll piggyback on

1:32:45 that maybe it's time to go away from iPads into something windows based since

1:32:50 I have your attention so it would be so much better. Okay so I just wanted to ask

1:32:59 the council. We're coming up on I know it's not until June for the annual conference for

1:33:03 the Association of Idaho City but it's time for our youth council to start filling out

1:33:07 applications to going to the youth delegate portion of that and in years past the city

1:33:13 has paid half of the registration fee and the students have paid the other half and before

1:33:18 I make promises to our youth that I can't keep are we still on board with that again this

1:33:22 year. How many years? I don't know. Last year we had three I would assume three to

1:33:29 five again. What's the potential? I mean you have a new group. We had 14 last week

1:33:34 but the potential is not close to 14 going. Okay. I would estimate three to

1:33:39 five honestly. And how much of the registration fees? I believe it's close to

1:33:45 $300 a student. So about half each? I would be supportive of that. Those are

1:33:50 items that we that's we have that in the budget correct. I just wanted to make

1:33:55 sure because I wasn't well I've got a cap on the number of participants just

1:34:00 so we have an idea when I get ahead can't I will bring that back no I'm

1:34:07 suggesting we put a cap on the phone if they're 14 to want to go I'm not

1:34:11 familiar with wanting to have 14 be able to go some three to five something like

1:34:16 That sounds very reasonable.

1:34:18 I guess I disagree.

1:34:20 Look at some of the other youth councils over there.

1:34:23 They pay 100% and they have like 20 kids there.

1:34:26 And they just have made a commitment to that portion of their thing.

1:34:30 So, to me, the cap should be 10 or something like that.

1:34:34 It is in our strategic plan to further the education of the youth and city government issues.

1:34:39 So, it is one of our initiatives.

1:34:42 So how about maybe for next week we find out exactly what the cost is and then we can look at it and say

1:34:51 Set a dollar amount and if that needs to get spread over

1:34:55 15 kids at a smaller amount then we could do it that way or it could be a couple of kids

1:34:59 We get a middle-larger

1:35:01 Okay, I think it's difficult to make a cap when we don't know the exact details. Thank you

1:35:06 great night

1:35:08 well a couple of items number one I I did a little

1:35:12 research to Fritz on we've had an unwritten policy on council that we are not

1:35:20 included in the health care of the city and I'm not proposing that we be that we

1:35:27 have a paid but I would like to have the option for council members to become

1:35:32 part of the health care and pay for it themselves so in other words it would not

1:35:38 not be in the additional potential,

1:35:41 it should not be any additional cost to the city.

1:35:44 I know I'm talking to other councils around the state,

1:35:49 like Rupert and Burley and several of those,

1:35:52 they actually provide the insurance for the council members.

1:35:55 I'm not asking for that because that would be something

1:35:57 that would be an increase in compensation

1:35:59 and wouldn't it be done,

1:36:01 probably not until the election of 2017

1:36:04 to be within a certain range as the state requires.

1:36:07 But I am asking us if there's any interest among council members to possibly be part of

1:36:13 the city's insurance program and then if there is, I would ask that that would allow the

1:36:18 Susan and Gretchen to take contact the underwriters, select health and the underwriters to see if

1:36:25 that would actually increase the city's obligation due to our ages, I guess, for the one of

1:36:32 a better term. And so I've just seen if there is any interest to pursue, to

1:36:39 find out whether it would cost any additional, or would change the rates for

1:36:44 the city. I don't want to change the rates for the city. I think we're probably

1:36:47 small enough an influential group of those who would actually be interested. I doubt

1:36:52 it would change it. But if anybody has interest, I'd like to know because if

1:36:57 No one has interest.

1:36:58 I'm not going to put the staff through, even ask the question.

1:37:05 I would be interested, but.

1:37:07 OK.

1:37:08 OK.

1:37:09 Chris.

1:37:13 In different dimensions.

1:37:14 I wouldn't utilize it, but I'll have a problem looking at it

1:37:18 to see if it has any.

1:37:19 My light was on for this.

1:37:20 From what I understand, part of the reason

1:37:23 that we went away from doing this in the past

1:37:25 is because it could create an issue with people wanting

1:37:30 to stay or come on counsel just for the health insurance.

1:37:35 And I'm totally opposed to that.

1:37:37 This is a service up here.

1:37:40 Our compensation helps that we get paid.

1:37:43 But certainly, I think I figured it out one time.

1:37:45 I think I, especially as mayor, I made a dollar an hour,

1:37:49 I think, so I was breaking all funds and labor laws, I think.

1:37:53 And that's really what it should be in public service.

1:37:56 And so I would be very cautious about moving down

1:38:00 the road of allowing elected officials to be part of an insurance program that your staff

1:38:06 members have just for the matter of fact that some people might either come on council or

1:38:11 stay on council past their prime that's a good way to put it just because of the health insurance

1:38:20 issue.

1:38:21 That's why I was not proposing that they'd be paid because I think that's where the issue

1:38:27 came from previously when they went away from it.

1:38:29 The council's insurance was actually being

1:38:33 paid for by the city, not by their end of the city.

1:38:36 But it's still the same issue, Greg,

1:38:37 because it would still be cheaper to go on a group

1:38:40 or eight than it would.

1:38:41 What we're seeing out there with, believe me,

1:38:44 I've talked to folks there on their own insurance

1:38:46 and it is affordable care act really isn't that affordable.

1:38:51 So Suzanne Hawkins.

1:38:53 Could we maybe find out what other cities in the area

1:38:56 are doing and go from there?

1:38:57 I know Rupert and Burley provide it and pay for it in those two cities, but I don't know about the others.

1:39:04 Five hundred pays for it, I'm pretty certain, but that's all I know, but I have done a survey of that.

1:39:08 I could do a survey and bring it back next week to see what was comparable as far as communities.

1:39:13 Yeah, with the whole thinking.

1:39:15 I don't think Ruth has spoken on this yet.

1:39:18 So I've got really mixed emotions.

1:39:20 Obviously, I'm in the elder group now, and so it could be more expensive than,

1:39:27 I mean, my insurance right now is ridiculous, absolutely ridiculous.

1:39:32 And I'm not sure how that edits select out,

1:39:35 so I'm not sure if it's even going to change things for me.

1:39:39 But I mean, I would be kind of interested to know what it might

1:39:44 do to the plan without having everybody go to a lot of work.

1:39:50 But you know, and the other thing is, do we have a 125?

1:39:54 So we could do it 125, you know, off of gross.

1:40:00 I mean, that's an option, but.

1:40:03 Well, I think select health would actually be doing the work

1:40:07 because they would be contacting their underwriters

1:40:09 and things that our staff.

1:40:10 But I think, what I would do, I'll come back with

1:40:14 one of the communities near our size are doing.

1:40:17 And then I think I will ask them, at least ask the question

1:40:22 of whether, because I'm not in favor of it

1:40:24 if it's going to change the rate we pay for our employees.

1:40:28 I don't think that makes any sense.

1:40:30 And so, and Gretchen doesn't think that we'll,

1:40:33 but I would like to find out for sure.

1:40:35 So, okay, so I will bring back additional information.

1:40:41 Thank you.

1:40:42 And Travis, did we want to, I'm sorry,

1:40:44 I got one more.

1:40:45 Yes, I knew you did.

1:40:46 Did you want to speak to the Urban Renewable

1:40:49 that will probably be introduced tomorrow

1:40:51 and whether or not we want to support

1:40:53 or only if you wanted to.

1:40:55 I would like you for you to.

1:40:56 I think it's very important to our urban and rural agency.

1:41:01 So as you're aware, the legislature

1:41:06 created an interim committee to investigate

1:41:10 what they believe to be possible fixes

1:41:13 to urban and rural law and legislation.

1:41:16 And the idea was to have a bill come forward this session that

1:41:22 fixed what others believed to be were problems associated with the urban renewal bill.

1:41:28 Representative Lance Clout was a member of that interim committee and he served and he

1:41:34 was in close contact with several of us throughout that entire process.

1:41:39 They created a bill and that bill then subsequently, some of the more substantive pieces of that

1:41:48 The interim committee bill changed as a part of the legislative process.

1:41:54 It's being very nice.

1:42:01 The what is important is a bill needs to pass.

1:42:10 During the interim committee's work, it was determined by an attorney general opinion that

1:42:18 There is an inherent conflict in our state code

1:42:22 as to what happens with an urban renewal plan

1:42:25 if it is amended.

1:42:28 One section of the code would lead you to believe

1:42:32 that nothing happens.

1:42:34 Another section of the code talks about a reset.

1:42:37 And since there is a conflict,

1:42:41 Fritz can correct me if I'm wrong,

1:42:43 but with conflict and code usually

1:42:45 is a sheer sign of litigation.

1:42:47 And that is one of the conversations that we talked about earlier today.

1:42:52 And I know that there was an association of Idaho City's conference, phone conference.

1:42:58 Exactly community conference.

1:43:00 And in part of that conversation, I think it's important to recognize that there is great

1:43:07 fear, I think, by many entities, the association of Idaho City's redevelopment group,

1:43:14 possibly even the chamber, that without a fix,

1:43:19 there will be some form of litigation to occur.

1:43:23 That litigation would cause that inconsistency in state code

1:43:29 to go through the court system.

1:43:33 And there is a belief that there would

1:43:36 be little sympathy from any member of the legislature

1:43:40 in trying to fix a issue that is addressed at the courts.

1:43:45 There have been conversations to determine, is that a reality?

1:43:49 And I think that most who have had in the conversation believe

1:43:53 that without a legislative fix, we will see some sort of action taken

1:43:58 to define what that looks like.

1:44:02 I will tell you that House Bill 606, as amended, is a terrible bill.

1:44:09 I mean, it is probably, it is difficult because it does not recognize or at least fails to recognize that urban renewal is really one of the only real tools that local governments have to advance economic development efforts.

1:44:30 It is one of the few tools that we have to help offset the cost of public infrastructure improvements to allow an entity to choose a location and come here.

1:44:40 It is the reason why we were successful with Chibani and Cliffbar and Glenpia.

1:44:48 But the fear of litigation and having an automatic reset is greater than what the problems are presented in House Bill 606 amended in my opinion.

1:45:03 after the amendments that occurred on Friday.

1:45:08 So there is an amendment that was attached,

1:45:11 and one of those amendments basically says

1:45:15 that all plans that have or are created

1:45:18 prior to July 1st of 2016 are grandfathered.

1:45:24 And so if they amend and they change and they move forward,

1:45:28 it does not change how we currently

1:45:31 would operate in those areas.

1:45:34 And as you move forward, House Bill 606

1:45:38 would amend the playing field on how we have to work

1:45:42 and operate as we create urban renewal districts.

1:45:45 Going forward, going forward.

1:45:47 And I will tell you that how we work

1:45:50 and how we operate is all very, very different

1:45:54 than the rest of the state.

1:45:57 And sometimes when you're held up as that poster child,

1:46:01 if you will, sometimes there are laws

1:46:04 that are created to reflect how we operate,

1:46:07 which may not necessarily be consistent

1:46:09 with how other people have operated.

1:46:12 Fritz and I spent a Saturday with Representative Clow

1:46:15 going through the bill,

1:46:16 and as we studied the bill, compared it to current code,

1:46:20 we did not see any significant challenges

1:46:24 to how we operate today.

1:46:28 So we struggle with the position that we're in.

1:46:36 We believe that if there was a court case and there was a need for movements forward and

1:46:43 plan amendments to support Chibani expansion, to support the anticipated Cliff Bar expansion

1:46:51 or to support other projects, those could come into jeopardy.

1:46:57 And we think that that is a really bad position for us to be in, even if it is the differing

1:47:04 opinion of the Association of Idaho Cities, the Redevelopment Institute of Idaho, or Association

1:47:10 of Idaho.

1:47:14 In all reality, I think that the law and the bill that we're seeing is a response to how

1:47:21 others wish that the urban renewal law would be used in the state, as opposed to maybe how

1:47:26 some are currently using that tool.

1:47:31 Greg Lansing.

1:47:32 Well, the action that the AIC executive committee took this morning, this afternoon, at a meeting,

1:47:38 and I had Travis set in with me so that he would be well informed of what was going on.

1:47:46 They basically have taken this stuff.

1:47:48 We were a voice of one that we just go forth with 606 and see what happens, and if we can

1:47:54 get it through, we're better off because of the reset plan and grandfathering.

1:47:59 There were others who were just want to kill the bill.

1:48:02 They don't want it because it makes them change what they're doing dramatically, they don't

1:48:06 want the bill.

1:48:07 There are others more in the middle that were willing to look at an amendment that I didn't

1:48:13 write it down exactly, but it would make it a little more business friendly for plan amendments

1:48:19 around the state.

1:48:21 We would probably utilize it if it's put in, but it's not necessarily something we would

1:48:26 have to do.

1:48:27 That's where the consensus ended up being is that they were going to, they have several

1:48:32 friends including Senator Sitaway in the Senate who is the Chairman of the local government

1:48:39 or whatever, the german committee anyway.

1:48:42 That they feel that it will pass the house.

1:48:44 They will try to amend it in the Senate to add this narrow definition.

1:48:49 I know some of the others wanted a broad definition and they came back with a more narrow definition

1:48:53 to help, and then their hope is that that would again,

1:48:58 would still pass muster in the house and would be passed,

1:49:02 the Senate amendments.

1:49:05 There were some thoughts, especially John Evans,

1:49:07 the mayor of Garden City, that Speaker Betkey

1:49:11 wants something to pass.

1:49:12 And so even with the amendments, they

1:49:16 feel that they can get the house to pass it.

1:49:19 That's giving me a little bit of a flutter, that that's the case.

1:49:22 that I really don't have a lot of support term use.

1:49:26 The health beats to a different drummer than I do.

1:49:29 It was put it that way as far as what they would kill it or not.

1:49:32 So we are initially in favor of 606, as it is,

1:49:37 if certainly we'll be in favor of 606 as amended,

1:49:40 if it is amended in the Senate,

1:49:42 is that would be the feeling I would have myself personally,

1:49:45 and the AIC is going forth with amendments,

1:49:48 and then we'll try to get it through both houses.

1:49:51 Additional amendments.

1:49:52 The amendments are already there.

1:49:53 Travis, do you want to finish?

1:49:54 I think that a bill needs to pass to eliminate the conflict so

1:50:02 that we have safe harbor, if you will, continuing to move forward with the projects that we have planned.

1:50:09 If there are amendments that even allow the tool to be even more viable in the future,

1:50:14 to promote economic development and to involve across the state, I think that those should be something that we should easily support.

1:50:22 and get behind. It's unfortunate that this is a critical last-minute issue. The timetable

1:50:34 that we were shared earlier today is that they hope that this bill may be considered tomorrow

1:50:42 in the House. The Senate has every intention of adjourning

1:50:48 signing die prior to good Friday. So there's not much time. Not a lot of time. And I really

1:51:01 do believe that action needs to be taken on a bill or it will be, as Fritz likes to share

1:51:12 with us, you never know what's going to happen in the courts.

1:51:15 Well, it just ties it up, too, it potentially ties up projects.

1:51:22 So I'll finish by that, anybody else can speak.

1:51:28 We would hope that we can get a lot of support from not only our council, but our community

1:51:36 knows this is important, that if it does go back to the house, we contact our, not only

1:51:41 They are two legislators but also the two legislators in the district that surrounds

1:51:46 us to help pass that, pass it with the amendments as presented because I think we need it because

1:51:55 I'm pretty sure.

1:51:56 My worry is that the threat of conflict is probably going to keep the bond councils from

1:52:06 feeling very good about saying, yeah, issue bonds, because they don't want to tie that

1:52:14 litigation.

1:52:15 Chris talking to you.

1:52:17 Well, as you've explained at Greg, and I think I understand what you're saying in Travis,

1:52:22 it sounds like HB 606 is kind of the lesser of any evils we've had for a while.

1:52:29 The danger is once it comes out for amendment, we have no control, what's going to happen

1:52:33 on the south side or if they send it back to the house.

1:52:37 And there are downright opponents to urban renewal here local,

1:52:42 but never voiced one Iota of support for what Twin Falls City

1:52:46 has accomplished in the prosperity that's brought to our community.

1:52:51 So if you're asking do we support HB 606 and it's print out

1:52:57 our presentation form, I guess what you're saying is your advice

1:53:00 as yes.

1:53:01 Yes, and then in the meeting, if it is amended in the Senate, we still need to support it.

1:53:07 Well, I bet your copy comes out there will not be one amendment, there will be multiple amendments.

1:53:12 And they'll all be derogatory to our liability.

1:53:16 So Travis, would it be helpful to have some formal action from the council tonight regarding a position on this bill?

1:53:26 You know, I don't know if there's a formal action other than, maybe I'll say it this way,

1:53:31 And my intent right now is to go out as I understand it and support House Bill 606 as amended as amended in the House with the amendments that were placed onto it on Friday to review the amendments.

1:53:45 I have this really bad sinking feeling after the AIC phone conference that I will have a kind of like a labor bag, if you will, packed ready to drive up and

1:53:58 spend a night or two in Boise to make sure that the only economic development tool that

1:54:04 we have is preserved. I've avoided going up, but it appears that in the 11th hour I might

1:54:14 get sucked in.

1:54:19 Thank you. Anything else from the council?

1:54:26 If not.

1:54:27 Hold your breath and pack your back trash.

1:54:30 Next item on the agenda is consideration

1:54:33 of an adjournment to executive session under section 742061C

1:54:39 to acquire an interest in real property, which is not owned

1:54:41 by a public agency, and 742061F, which is something else.

1:54:50 Legal counsel.

1:54:51 To communicate with legal counsel.

1:54:53 Council for the public agency to discuss legal ramifications of and legal

1:54:59 options for pending litigation or controversies not yet litigated but

1:55:02 imminently likely to be litigated. Don Hall. So moved. Second. Motion by Don

1:55:11 Hall, seconded by Ruth Pierce to adjourn into executive session. Under those two

1:55:16 sections. Any discussion? Seeing none. Leyla roll call vote please.

1:55:23 Craig Lanting, Don Hall, Ruth Pierce, Susan Hawkins, Nicki Boyd, Sean Bergever, Chris

1:55:32 Yes, motion passes seven to zero.

1:55:36 We will adjourn.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, March 21, 2016. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:55:44.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    91a2c703e4eb848674c6a3ec68f5f4dce6bae18bfd61c8e970cfab340b17b0d0
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 7607a2d341f166a11caeaa4f9e14f9b0bb2e324560a8445cd260980c94c25bad
    part02.m4a ab2920756a982e62505cc47e49ee96ce13aedbc8a51793420a7d1029418c5384
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    ff87c0d40cec9557d9068deb67911208223755ded577fefec3e2e0b1d5b67074

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file