OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, May 23, 2016

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Minutes on file

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:00:00 I would confirm we do have a quorum of the City Council.

0:00:27 All seven members are here this evening.

0:00:29 Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to the agenda?

0:00:33 Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, staff would ask for consideration of an item to be added

0:00:37 to the consent calendar.

0:00:39 It is the approval of a beer and wine license for KB,

0:00:44 also known as Ketchum Burrito,

0:00:46 soon to be operating at 117 Main Avenue East.

0:00:53 Great landing.

0:00:54 Mayor, I move that we add the beer and wine license

0:00:57 for KB's to the consent calendar.

0:01:00 I would second that.

0:01:02 The motion by great landing seconded by it appears

0:01:04 to add the approval of a beer and wine license

0:01:08 for KB's to the consent calendar.

0:01:10 Is there any discussion?

0:01:13 Seeing none, should I roll call vote please?

0:01:15 Suzanne Hawkins?

0:01:16 Yes.

0:01:17 Licky Boyd?

0:01:18 Yes.

0:01:18 Sean Berricker?

0:01:20 Yes.

0:01:21 Chris Hocking?

0:01:22 Yes.

0:01:22 Greg Lanti?

0:01:23 Yes.

0:01:24 Don Hall?

0:01:24 Yes.

0:01:25 Ruth Pierce?

0:01:25 Yes.

0:01:27 Motion passes 7 to 0.

0:01:31 We do have a proclamation on tonight's agenda as well,

0:01:33 but I'm going to shift that down in the agenda as we await

0:01:37 our fire chiefs arrival.

0:01:39 So we move to general public input if there is anyone here from the public

0:01:43 who wishes to address the council on an item not on tonight's agenda.

0:01:47 You're welcome to come forward and do so now.

0:01:52 Seeing no one charging the stage, we will move on to the consent calendar.

0:01:58 Council wishes.

0:01:59 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:02:00 Move approval of the consent calendar as amended.

0:02:03 I'll second that.

0:02:05 Motion by Suzanne Hawkins seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the consent calendar

0:02:09 As amended, is there any discussion?

0:02:12 Seeing none, sharing roll call vote please.

0:02:15 Nikki Boyd, yes.

0:02:16 Sean Berriger, yes.

0:02:18 Chris Talkington, Greg Lanthine, yes.

0:02:21 Don Hall, yes.

0:02:24 Ruth Pierce, yes.

0:02:25 Suzanne Hoppen, yes.

0:02:27 Motion passes, seven to zero.

0:02:33 The first item under items for consideration

0:02:36 is consideration of a request to approve the Special Olympics

0:02:39 2016 Summer Games, sponsored by Special Olympics in Idaho.

0:02:44 The event is scheduled to be held on Friday and Saturday, June 10th and 11th, and we have

0:02:48 Ron Festus with us.

0:02:49 Welcome, sir.

0:02:50 Thank you, Mr. Mayor, Member of Council.

0:02:51 I bring before you to the consideration of a request to approve the Special Olympics 2016

0:02:58 Summer Games, sponsored by the Special Olympics in Idaho.

0:03:02 The Games will take place at several venues in Twin Falls on Friday and Saturday, June

0:03:07 10th and 11th.

0:03:09 This will be the first year of the event with one or two to follow.

0:03:15 On Friday, June 10, 2016, starting at 10 AM, the Special Olympics Torch Run will commence

0:03:21 from Idaho Joe's parking lot located at 598 Blue Lakes Boulevard North.

0:03:27 Runners will proceed north on Blue Lakes Boulevard North in the outer lane.

0:03:32 Twin Falls Police Motor Officers will guide the runners and a Twin Falls Police Cruiser

0:03:36 will trail the group.

0:03:39 The Twin Falls Police Service van will also trail the runners to provide assistance to runners

0:03:43 that should fall behind.

0:03:46 Runners will stay on Blue Lakes Boulevard North until they reach Bridgeview Boulevard while

0:03:51 they will head in towards the visitor center.

0:03:55 And once there the run will terminate.

0:03:57 A small dedication will take place and it is expected to last until about 11 a.m.

0:04:05 Opening ceremonies for the games will take place on Friday evening at 7 p.m. at the Canyon

0:04:11 Ridge High School football stadium. Opening ceremonies are anticipated to last until about

0:04:18 9 p.m. On Saturday morning the games will begin at 9 a.m. Track and field events will

0:04:25 occur at the Canyon Ridge High School. Stadium and Aquatics events will occur at the Twin

0:04:30 Falls City Pool. A bicycle event will take place on city streets just north of Canyon

0:04:36 Ridge High School. The games are expected to conclude at 5 p.m. followed by closing ceremonies

0:04:45 in a barbecue until 9 p.m.

0:04:49 Event organizers predict there will be 800 athletes, 300 volunteers and roughly 2,500

0:04:56 spectators throughout the event.

0:04:59 There may be some minimal non-budgeted overtime costs incurred by the police department during

0:05:04 this event.

0:05:07 The special event application has been approved by several relevant city staff members in the

0:05:12 Twin Falls Police Department staff.

0:05:14 It is recommended that this request be approved by the City Council as presented

0:05:19 Kevin and Laura Stewart are here and they will answer any questions if you might have

0:05:27 Just my day as good. It's just coming out of overtime budgets for city staffing or is there any

0:05:35 participation by the

0:05:37 Chartering Agency to help us on any of this not to my knowledge, okay

0:05:41 Susan Hawkins.

0:05:44 Thank you.

0:05:44 I'd just like to make sure that everyone knows we have one

0:05:47 of our athletes with us tonight, Connor Stewart's here.

0:05:50 And he will be participating in the games.

0:05:52 Thanks, my welcome.

0:05:59 It wasn't expected.

0:06:01 I know.

0:06:03 So Laura, if you and Kevin could introduce yourselves,

0:06:06 please, sir.

0:06:06 Hi, everyone.

0:06:07 My name is Laura Stewart.

0:06:08 And I am the games management team director

0:06:12 for the Special Olympics Idaho Summer State Games,

0:06:14 coming to Twin Falls this summer.

0:06:17 I am Kevin Stewart.

0:06:18 I'm exactly the same thing she is, the counterpart.

0:06:22 So are there any questions for Kevin or Laura

0:06:25 related to the request?

0:06:28 We wish you good weather.

0:06:29 Thank you very much.

0:06:30 We're very excited about that part.

0:06:32 Ruth Pierce?

0:06:33 I would like to make a motion to approve the request

0:06:40 for the Special Olympics to be held on the June 10th and 11th.

0:06:47 I'll second that motion.

0:06:49 The motion by repair seconded by Suzanne Hopkins

0:06:52 to approve the special event request.

0:06:55 Any further discussion from council?

0:06:59 Suzanne Hopkins.

0:07:00 Thank you.

0:07:01 I'd just like to say a special thank you to Kevin and Laura

0:07:03 for all the time they've put in

0:07:05 and what a great event for our community

0:07:07 and the fact that you stepped up the way you have.

0:07:09 I've been so impressed.

0:07:10 It's been fun to get to know you and work with you

0:07:12 and you guys are doing a great job.

0:07:14 Thank you, Suzanne.

0:07:15 And after we vote, we'll give you a chance

0:07:17 to say a few words.

0:07:18 So any other discussion?

0:07:20 Chair and roll call vote, please.

0:07:22 Sean Berriger.

0:07:23 Yes.

0:07:24 Chris Tocking do.

0:07:25 Greg Lanting.

0:07:26 Yes.

0:07:27 Don Hall.

0:07:28 Yes.

0:07:29 Ruth Parrish.

0:07:30 Yes.

0:07:31 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:07:32 Yes.

0:07:33 Nikki Boyd.

0:07:34 Yes.

0:07:35 Motion passes 7 to 0.

0:07:36 So tell us how the community can become involved in this great event that we have coming up.

0:07:40 Thank you, Mayor.

0:07:41 The grade that you can get involved with this event, Suzanne Hawkins is actually our volunteer

0:07:46 director.

0:07:47 if anyone in this room would like to volunteer,

0:07:49 she'd be happy to take your name and phone number.

0:07:52 But really, I would say at this point,

0:07:54 the most important thing that we can have the city

0:07:57 of Twin Falls and the surrounding community of Magic Valley

0:08:00 is to come and share it on these athletes.

0:08:02 On Friday night, they do a parade of athletes

0:08:04 from about seven to eight, 30 that night at Canyon Ridge.

0:08:07 They would love the whole community to come out

0:08:09 and support them.

0:08:10 And then on Saturday from about nine to five,

0:08:13 come and share these athletes on either

0:08:15 at the Y City Pool or Canyon Ridge,

0:08:17 they will just be thrilled to have this city

0:08:20 and this community engage in an opportunity

0:08:23 for them to really kind of be seen,

0:08:28 be admired, be cheered on, and really to matter.

0:08:32 That's really what it's all about.

0:08:33 Special Olympics is engaging and including

0:08:36 the disability community, and it's really important

0:08:38 that we support this as a community,

0:08:40 because it's a lot of fun.

0:08:42 You won't be sorry, that would be great.

0:08:43 So thank you.

0:08:44 Thank you, Laura.

0:08:45 Thank you, Kevin.

0:08:46 And thank you, Ron.

0:08:56 So next, we do have a proclamation this evening, in the office of the Mayor's City of Twin Falls,

0:09:03 in memory of firefighter Ryan Franklin.

0:09:06 On Wednesday, May 18, 2016, the City of Twin Falls lost an invaluable member of its team

0:09:11 when firefighter Ryan Franklin was struck and killed by a vehicle.

0:09:15 He was 34 years old and is survived by his loving wife and four children.

0:09:19 Franklin was a firefighter with the Twin Falls Fire Department for almost three years, where

0:09:23 he served honorably alongside his brother firefighters.

0:09:27 He was humorous and light-hearted, with everyone who knew him, but he was also brave and professional

0:09:32 when called to duty.

0:09:34 His selfless service to community will not be forgotten, and neither will the sacrifices

0:09:38 his family made when he was called to put the safety and concerns of others before his own.

0:09:43 Franklin was passionate about cycling.

0:09:46 enjoyed both competing on the course as well as relaxing rise with friends and

0:09:50 family. He died doing what he loved. His death shocked his family, his brother

0:09:55 firefighters, and our community. As mayor of the city of Twin Falls and with the

0:10:01 consent of the governor's office, we requested that flags be flown at half

0:10:04 staff last week in memory of firefighter Ryan Franklin. In addition, an account has

0:10:09 been established to assist his wife and four children. As a community, we mourn

0:10:14 together, and I would encourage us all to work together to support the Franklin

0:10:19 family. I would now ask for a moment of silence to honor the memory of Firefighter

0:10:24 Ryan Franklin. Thank you and I'd like to present this proclamation to Fire Chief

0:10:44 Ron Clark. Do you expect me to say anything? Always. I'm not sure what to say or to add

0:11:26 to what hasn't been said. He was a really good guy, a good citizen, a good

0:11:40 firefighter, a good husband, a good father. He's going to be sorely missed. We're trying

0:11:50 to have the department get through it, as well as the city and all of the family and

0:11:57 friends and all that. So, no one says it's terrible tragedy.

0:12:06 Chief, thank you. I know that I already missed our thoughts and our hearts are with you and

0:12:12 our city family and certainly with his family as well. I do encourage the community to get

0:12:18 continue to offer support of where it's needed.

0:12:22 I think the battle point this last week has been overwhelming.

0:12:28 Yeah, it's been a rough week for everyone, so this won't.

0:12:31 We won't hang.

0:12:32 Proudly if that's the right word in the station.

0:12:35 Thank you, Chief.

0:12:37 Travis.

0:12:39 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, just a couple of quick things.

0:12:44 Tomorrow evening, there's going to be an opportunity to ride for Ryan.

0:12:53 It is a ride around our community in which all individuals are encouraged to participate.

0:13:03 It's about a 12 mile loop.

0:13:05 There will be an escort of a fire truck as well as a police escort to assist through the community.

0:13:14 And the total ride is about eight miles until we're asking that anyone who wants to participate in that ride to show up at Lighthouse at 630.

0:13:24 The second item is the funeral services will be held at 3 o'clock at the Reformed Church on this Saturday.

0:13:31 And we've made arrangements to ensure that all members of our City Firefighter team will be able to attend as we'll have mutual aid covering the stations.

0:13:49 Ruth?

0:13:50 Travis, I have a question. So for those of us who are not avid bike riders, how may we participate come to the potluck?

0:13:59 There's a great potluck afterwards.

0:14:01 And see you off?

0:14:03 Absolutely.

0:14:04 Okay.

0:14:05 We can do that.

0:14:06 Thank you.

0:14:07 Well, once again, our thoughts and our hearts are with the firefighters here in Twin Falls

0:14:15 and certainly Lefurian's family.

0:14:18 And I would encourage the community to continue to support all those in need with this terrible tragedy.

0:14:27 With that, we will move to the next item on the agenda, which is consideration of a request to provide a mid-year salary

0:14:33 table adjustment of 4% effective May 29, 2016, and we have our city manager, Travis Rothwein.

0:14:40 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, thank you for the opportunity to present a proposal

0:15:20 to adjust salaries for the employees of the City of Twin Falls mid-year.

0:15:28 One of the first things that we started having a conversation about during this upcoming budget

0:15:34 was the need to really focus on our employees inside of our organization.

0:15:39 The organization that we have is really based upon the talents of the men and women that

0:15:45 work for the City of Twin Falls.

0:15:49 And as we kind of look at the goals and objectives of the City, you'll notice that in a sense, everything

0:15:54 does kind of flow through the internal organization of our strategic plan.

0:16:00 that in order for us to be secure, in order for us to be accessible, to be healthy, to

0:16:05 be safe, to be prosperous, there is a dedicated public servant connected to the city of Twin

0:16:11 Falls executing and seeing that process happen.

0:16:16 When I came to the Council in March and talking about priorities, we really began to investigate

0:16:22 where our salary stood in comparison to our competition.

0:16:27 And it is important for us to ensure that our salary remains market competitive.

0:16:36 In fact, it is talked about in our strategic plan where we talk about where the city will

0:16:42 carry out its mission on question integrity with the highest of ethical standards, that

0:16:48 we have shared obligations to create livabilities and opportunities, and that we're transparent

0:16:53 in our decision-making process.

0:16:57 We want to make sure that we work in close partnership with all of our entities.

0:17:03 We also want to make sure that we carry a high degree of competency expertise and that the

0:17:09 City of Twin Falls is a lean and properly compensated organization.

0:17:16 The City of Twin Falls has a total of 288 employees positions that are allocated.

0:17:23 When you take a look at the full time equivalents that we have inside of the City of Twin Falls,

0:17:28 We are much smaller in size and in scope than what any other department of a like size may be.

0:17:38 In fact, many of those same cities who offer a full collection of services inside of the city are often several hundred employees larger than we are.

0:17:49 If you take a look at many cities, one of the things that we pride ourselves on

0:17:54 the number of employees that we have working for us.

0:17:58 And when you look at the City of Twin Falls,

0:18:00 it's important to recognize that we are 288 allocations

0:18:05 serving a population greater than our census population.

0:18:10 For every single day, we serve the incoming population

0:18:14 that comes to the City of Twin Falls for education,

0:18:17 that comes here for medical to participate

0:18:20 and recreational opportunities for commerce for retail for jobs.

0:18:25 All of the visitors that come to our community

0:18:28 receive the exact same level of service,

0:18:30 and they expect that exact same level of service

0:18:33 to be provided as we would for all of our citizens.

0:18:38 And the council recognized that when they created the goal,

0:18:41 and that was to provide a highly effective professional

0:18:43 quality services to our citizens, residents, and businesses.

0:18:47 And we recognize that initiative, 1.1A,

0:18:51 was to attract and to retain the quality folks

0:18:54 of the men and women of the city of Twin Falls.

0:18:59 We also believe that there was an important piece

0:19:01 of treating our folks fairly.

0:19:03 And in treating our folks fairly,

0:19:04 we recognize that we had to have

0:19:07 a market-based compensation program

0:19:12 that looked at all benefits, complete benefits.

0:19:16 It's not just salary, but it's also to make sure that our other benefits are full compensation,

0:19:22 which involves health care, is also included inside of that mix.

0:19:27 And I think that the organization as a whole has been committed.

0:19:33 Since 2009, we have moved, excuse me, since 2013, we have moved the table 11 and a half percent.

0:19:41 We've made up considerable ground, but unfortunately, there is a time behind those years, a time

0:19:49 that we are still working to catch up.

0:19:53 For there was a time inside the City of Twin Falls where we didn't move our salary table,

0:19:57 and we hadn't moved it for about nine years.

0:20:00 And many of those reasons are very valid and just for those times, but the unfortunate

0:20:06 place that we find ourselves in is our competition moved their tables.

0:20:13 And our competition continued to create much more market-based compensation levels, and

0:20:20 they began to drive the market.

0:20:24 In addition to that, we've been able to provide about an average of a 3% compensation adjustment

0:20:29 as related to performance over the course of those same years.

0:20:35 And one of the things that we have found is that having a good compensation program really

0:20:41 helps us accomplish those six major objectives.

0:20:45 You know, there is something about job satisfaction when an employee feels valued, and there's

0:20:50 motivation, there's low absenteeism, low turnover.

0:20:55 The opportunity for us to be appropriately lean.

0:20:59 If we can continue to attract and bring in the best and the brightest into our organization,

0:21:04 We can continue to work at levels that often are much smaller than other areas and offering

0:21:11 similar services in like areas.

0:21:14 And we can continue the promotion of one city.

0:21:18 For one city allows us to become truly innovative, it allows us to become connected, it allows

0:21:23 us to work more collaboratively.

0:21:26 But if we're going through a revolving door process of employees, then it is hard for us

0:21:32 to build those connections, to create continuity, and allow us to continue to move forward.

0:21:38 I shared with the Council some information, and it has changed slightly.

0:21:46 But as you'll recall, I shared with the Council since January of 2012, the city at that point

0:21:53 in time had lost a total of 119 employees.

0:21:59 We've made 119 recruitments in that period of time.

0:22:03 And of the 119 people that we brought into our organization, we retained 94th.

0:22:11 So even in that four-year period of time, we are seeing individuals develop skills and abilities

0:22:17 and move to other locations.

0:22:19 Now admittedly, some of those individuals are retiring, which makes making a compensation

0:22:26 mid-year adjustment all that more important because we're competing for talent to bring

0:22:33 into our organization as skilled veterans leave us.

0:22:37 And we want to replace that talent into our organization with like talent, with like abilities,

0:22:43 that we are more than capable of training talent from the ground up.

0:22:48 But for us to continue to grow, we also want to attract quality talent, experience talent

0:22:53 into our organization.

0:22:54 And the only way that we can do that is through a compensation model.

0:23:00 So as I shared with you earlier this year in March, we reflected that a 3.5% adjustment

0:23:08 was something that was needed to be made now.

0:23:14 And I shared with the Council that we would continue to find ways and develop strategies

0:23:18 to make a mid-year adjustment at that time.

0:23:21 We also shared that we put money into the budget to go through a re-evaluation of our salary

0:23:26 table.

0:23:27 Those first two bullets are now before you.

0:23:30 The first bullet this evening in terms of a mid-year adjustment, and the second is we made

0:23:34 arrangements to start a complete review of our salary survey.

0:23:40 The other places in which we'll investigate our salaries will occur during the course of

0:23:47 our development of the fiscal year 2017 budget.

0:23:51 We will continue to evaluate what we need to do to make sure that we are market competitive

0:23:56 in all of our positions, and we will also need to probably recognize that some of those

0:24:01 grounds that we need to make up will probably require us to take some time.

0:24:08 Because one of the things, as you'll recall, that I shared is that the cost of living index

0:24:13 for the city of Twin Falls is very, very comparable to that of the Treasure Battle, but

0:24:19 yet our wage scale, where they are paying their employees for life positions, is significantly

0:24:25 larger than where we are paying our folks.

0:24:28 In fact, as of late, we've lost individuals to positions

0:24:32 within the Treasure Valley, in which they were earning upwards

0:24:36 of $10 more per hour for a similar in life position.

0:24:41 And in order for us to be able to truly compete

0:24:45 for that type of talent in all across of our public sector,

0:24:49 we need to build a model that is sustainable.

0:24:53 It is not something that is going

0:24:54 to occur overnight.

0:24:56 In fact, many organizations who have built solid strong salary

0:25:01 plans have done that over a period of time.

0:25:05 We will begin to present what that plan looks like as we

0:25:08 develop the 2017 budget and present that to you later this year.

0:25:16 I wanted to illustrate what this looks like in the move

0:25:19 that we're talking about.

0:25:20 And I apologize.

0:25:21 This is small, so I gave you a handout one for your own.

0:25:26 But what this illustrates is a side-by-side comparison of the hourly wage rate for our employees in the blue is the current table.

0:25:37 This year, as you will recall, we removed that table one half of 1%.

0:25:43 Under the green heading, it illustrates what the compensation adjustments will be with a 4% move.

0:25:51 Should that be accepted by the members of the city council?

0:25:55 The one thing I do want to share is that when you look at moving a table, it does not mean

0:26:02 that every single employee in our organization receives an increase in their compensation.

0:26:09 In fact, of the 288 employees that we have in our organization, we have 276 of those positions

0:26:17 currently filled. Of the 276, there will be 167 that would receive a compensation increase

0:26:26 associated with a 4% table move. The range of the move is from 0%, some employees as a

0:26:35 result of this move will not see an adjustment at this point in time. Others may see the

0:26:41 full 4%. The average across the organization is 2.4%, four of those employees who are

0:26:47 are receiving that compensation and that equates to about 55 cents per hour. That's

0:26:53 what we're talking about. About 55 cents per hour on the average across the organization

0:27:00 for the 167 employees who would see an adjustment here. The reason we're moving and shifting the

0:27:10 table is because it is the place that we start because the table first needs to be solid.

0:27:17 needs to be based upon market and market competition.

0:27:22 After we will continue to find ways to increase the salaries based upon performance, if warranted

0:27:27 as we continue to move through this fiscal year.

0:27:32 So the proposal before you this evening is to adjust the salary table.

0:27:39 We have been able to find the funds internally.

0:27:41 There is not an increase associated with property taxes or user fees associated with

0:27:48 We've been able to look within and find the means within our current operating budgets.

0:27:53 We believe that the funding that we have allocated is sustainable and it is available for us, not only in this year, but in the ongoing years.

0:28:06 Because compensation is a fixed cost that continues to grow with our organization.

0:28:10 It is not like a capital cost.

0:28:13 We are not using cash reserves associated with this.

0:28:15 are using monies that we have identified into the budget as a result of savings.

0:28:25 Could you explain that a little bit more?

0:28:27 I don't think that people listening or viewing might see how outside of one year reserves may

0:28:34 take care of this cost, but it's a compounded cost every year and for us to be able to do

0:28:40 it without impacting property taxes.

0:28:44 might be something people don't understand and I'm not sure I do.

0:28:49 So over the course of every year we take a look at how much money it takes to operate

0:28:55 our government.

0:28:57 And there have been areas that over a period of time we have looked at in terms of fixed

0:29:02 costs in the areas of operation.

0:29:04 There are two areas that we have pinpointed associated this year.

0:29:08 The first area is in the area of health insurance increases.

0:29:12 significantly over appropriated dollars this year.

0:29:15 Now health insurance is a moving target and everyone is concerned about health insurance

0:29:20 moving out.

0:29:22 We've also been able to identify the cost of fuel.

0:29:25 In fact, we had significantly retained, well, we had retained significant prices per gallon

0:29:32 based upon rates that we were seeing during the recessionary era.

0:29:38 We've been able to reduce what we think that those are going to be, in some cases, almost

0:29:43 by a dollar per gallon, and our rate of fuel cost and consumption is significantly less

0:29:52 than what individuals would pay at the pump.

0:29:55 And so we've been able to identify fuel savings and other savings.

0:30:00 Over the course of the last fiscal year, fiscal year 2015, the City of Twin Falls placed 2.2

0:30:08 million dollars into its cash reserves from its general fund.

0:30:13 $1.2 million was from salary savings, vacant positions, positions that we hope to fill.

0:30:21 And we're not using that funding because we believe that one time will be fully staffed and

0:30:26 that those funds will be needed to move our organization forward.

0:30:30 There was $600,000, slightly more than $600,000 of O&M savings.

0:30:36 we were able to realize across just the general fund.

0:30:41 And we have been able to notice trends over a period of time,

0:30:45 and that's why when we take a look at those costs,

0:30:48 we wanted to make sure that we could fully move them forward.

0:30:52 Lori race, the city CFO is here,

0:30:54 and she can also talk about those funds

0:30:57 that we found available.

0:30:58 The difference is an additional $400,000

0:31:02 of revenue that was unanticipated that came into the system,

0:31:05 whether that be through additional state sales tax money, investment income,

0:31:11 monies that came into the system that were not anticipated.

0:31:15 And the 2.2 million again reflects only funds from the general fund.

0:31:20 It does not talk about reserves that were captured in the street fund,

0:31:24 the water fund, sewer fund, airport fund, and the other funds that we have.

0:31:31 The reason we wanted to make sure that we could absorb this is because we never want to start the next year out.

0:31:36 in the whole. We want to make sure that we're able to fund all of the liabilities that we

0:31:42 have on the books moving forward. So it was important for us to spend some time truly investigating

0:31:48 where we stood to be able to identify those resources and to move those forward for this

0:31:53 upcoming year. So for us to be the employer of choice, it is important for us that we,

0:32:05 number one lead and have the market when it comes to compensation of public

0:32:12 employees in the Magic Valley. If we have to continue to fight for talent the

0:32:20 way in which we've been fighting for talent and losing talent in the Magic

0:32:24 Valley then we're still considerably less than what we're finding ourselves in

0:32:29 the treasure valley.

0:32:32 And so it's not only a retention issue, but it's also an attraction issue.

0:32:38 We want to make sure that as those vacancies occur and when they occur, that we are going

0:32:43 to be able to bring in the best talent into our organization.

0:32:46 Now, we do not believe that compensation and fixing the compensation is the magical elixir.

0:32:52 And we will still tell you that we will have employee turnover.

0:32:55 In fact, we will also probably tell you that we believe that certain levels of employee turnover

0:33:00 are probably appropriate because that helps us grow.

0:33:03 It brings in fresh ideas.

0:33:05 New perspectives helps us continue to advance as an organization.

0:33:10 But I think that we would also tell you losing 119 people.

0:33:14 More than a third of our workforce in a four and a half year period will not allow us to

0:33:19 become innovative.

0:33:20 It will not allow us to capture the ideals that are embodied in one city and it will not

0:33:24 allow us to continue to advance as an organization.

0:33:31 We also need to recognize that we've been incredibly successful in the areas of economic development,

0:33:37 that we as an organization have played a part in the vibrancy that is Twin Falls, through

0:33:43 our recruitment, through our Renaissance projects, and through our efforts.

0:33:48 Council and our teams have built and started work to create a much more vibrant

0:33:54 Twin Falls. We are starting to find ourselves like others a victim of our own

0:34:00 success. We are fighting and competing for talent against those individuals, not

0:34:05 only on retention but certainly on attraction, bringing people into our

0:34:10 organization. And while we may not be able to compete completely with all of our

0:34:16 private sector folks and all of the other public sector folks. We want to

0:34:20 lessen the gap of where we stand today and that's why the 4% table moved us

0:34:25 before you. And again I talked about the need for one city where it requires us

0:34:31 to move forward as an organization. With that, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, I'd

0:34:38 be happy to stand for any questions. Any questions for Travis? Chris talking.

0:34:48 Not a question so much as a comment.

0:34:52 It's not easy to consider a mid-year adjustment like this, but I think the fact that things

0:35:01 are catching up with us, we are amongst the lowest wage scale areas in Idaho.

0:35:07 Idaho is the Mississippi of the North and has one of the lowest wage scales for whole

0:35:15 personnel.

0:35:17 the fact that you've demonstrated that we've had 41% turnover since 2012, which averages

0:35:24 about 10% of a year. Many of those in our direct public safety departments should be unsettling

0:35:33 to anybody. I don't know how the importance of our work can be looked at as being under

0:35:39 percent of fishing or as efficient as it could or should be with that kind of

0:35:44 a turnover. I'm most impressed that we can do it without impacting the property tax

0:35:53 rate and that happens because we're in a growth mode right now and let's hope

0:35:56 that that continues for a while. But I think it's justified and I'm thinking

0:36:02 it's something that we didn't do it for too long and now we're kind of trying

0:36:06 to catch up and we've got a state competitive, I guess those 12 positions that are not filled,

0:36:13 are they still on the active role, and are they in police fire, what areas?

0:36:20 They're across the organization, but most of the areas that we're looking to fill are in

0:36:26 the areas of police.

0:36:28 Certainly there are some in fire.

0:36:31 We have, we're in the process of looking at an economic development director position that

0:36:36 is vacant. We're looking at a communications dispatch place that is vacant. But really,

0:36:43 it is, it is positions across our organization and they are largely frontline and critical

0:36:51 positions for us to help advance and move our economy.

0:36:56 Thank you. Ruth, Chris?

0:36:58 I would concur with Chris. I know that we have a need to increase our salaries, especially

0:37:05 in the public safety sector, this recent shooting is, you know,

0:37:13 above everybody's minds and I know it's important to have experienced officers helping

0:37:21 to investigate and I do as well concur that I'm glad to see that we are able to bring it

0:37:30 out of the normal operating budget as opposed to an additional assessment.

0:37:34 that I think we need our employees are passionate

0:37:38 about what they do and it's important to retain them.

0:37:43 Greg Lanting.

0:37:44 Thank you, Mayor.

0:37:46 I too concur with the decision for the mid-year adjustment.

0:37:51 As I'm sitting here looking at the logo of City of Twin Falls

0:37:56 is people serving people.

0:37:57 We don't have the proper people in place

0:38:00 to serve those people than we're falling down on our job.

0:38:04 We should have the best of the Magic Valley, not the medium order,

0:38:10 certainly towards the bottom of the scaler.

0:38:13 A lot of the money that we're talking about that we've came up with is truly back to our staff.

0:38:20 The fact that the staff all the way through the organization that there's not a use

0:38:24 that or lose it mentality in the city to involve.

0:38:27 And that's the reason some of this money gets swept into the, at the end of the year.

0:38:31 If they didn't need it, they don't spend it.

0:38:34 And they get swept into reserves and other places,

0:38:37 in this particular case, we can use it here.

0:38:39 And I think that's important for people to understand

0:38:42 because I think a lot of people think that

0:38:44 almost all government operates on that philosophy.

0:38:47 If they don't use it, they lose it.

0:38:48 So they go in and spend it, even if they might not need it.

0:38:51 I don't see that culture in Twin Falls,

0:38:53 and I really appreciate that.

0:38:55 And also, we talked about police and fire,

0:38:57 but the one I want to, and obviously important

0:39:00 and right at the top, but many of our other parts

0:39:04 of our organization require very advanced certifications

0:39:08 that are very valuable to the private sector.

0:39:10 And if we don't pay our folks that have those certifications

0:39:15 what they deserve, then they're always

0:39:20 trying to poach them from us.

0:39:22 And that's the term I use there.

0:39:24 We've trained them, we spent the money

0:39:26 to get them to that certification,

0:39:28 And then somebody else can take them and get that expertise

0:39:32 without having to pay for it.

0:39:34 So everybody we train to lose really is just a waste of our

0:39:39 waste of money to try it.

0:39:41 So we need to have them in a salary that they're going to

0:39:44 want to stay.

0:39:45 And that goes from not only police and fire, but to

0:39:49 building department and the water and sewer departments

0:39:52 and streets and everything else you talk about.

0:39:56 If we're training them, what's our best efforts to keep them?

0:40:01 I don't know.

0:40:03 I think it's important to weigh in.

0:40:05 This is a really important decision that we're embarking on

0:40:08 to do a mid-year adjustment in salaries is a big deal.

0:40:14 And I wouldn't be supportive of this

0:40:18 if we didn't have the evidence to do it.

0:40:21 And if you've laid out the evidence well,

0:40:23 I know that we did get some evidence a little bit late

0:40:27 in the process too, because we probably could have done this

0:40:30 at the budget time, the beginning of the budget time,

0:40:32 but some of the information came in a little bit later.

0:40:36 I'm just going to piggyback on what's already been said.

0:40:40 Some of the skills that we need in our city staff are incredibly

0:40:44 technical.

0:40:45 If you look at, just for example, I know we recently lost one

0:40:50 of our polygraphers, a polygraph operator,

0:40:53 And that costs anywhere from $10,000 to $15,000 just to become a

0:40:59 polygrapher.

0:41:00 And these are highly competitive positions and highly technical

0:41:05 positions that we need to learn how to retain these folks,

0:41:12 because that's $15,000.

0:41:16 Some other organization is thanking the City of Twin Falls

0:41:19 for this very moment.

0:41:21 much less, or much even more, the experience of this detective that left us and losing that

0:41:29 person to be able to investigate crimes and to seek justice for our citizens.

0:41:36 But it's not just the police, it's the great exit, it's every aspect of our city.

0:41:40 I don't know if we have a position in the city anymore that's not technical, from everything

0:41:46 that we do, GIS and firefighting and water and streets, all of these positions take a

0:41:55 high level of technical skills anymore.

0:42:00 And we have to invest in our folks to be able to serve our citizens correctly.

0:42:05 And we are a lean organization.

0:42:08 Absolutely.

0:42:09 We always have been.

0:42:10 I've been involved in this organization for about 30 years now.

0:42:13 And we've always been lean, and we're always proud of that.

0:42:17 But we need to retain these individuals, but recruiting, you call it a traction.

0:42:22 Recruit and retain are incredibly important for us to be able to serve our citizens.

0:42:28 So I will be in support of this mid-year adjustment because we got to quit bleeding.

0:42:37 We're bleeding right now.

0:42:38 I think the public needs to be made aware that the city manager's position is not included

0:42:48 in this consideration.

0:42:50 That position will be taken up separately by the city council and we'll see how good

0:42:56 of a dance he can put on.

0:43:02 Any other comments or questions from the council?

0:43:05 I'll try as thanks to you and the HR team and the finance team for the work I know you

0:43:12 all did in going through this and again I support of our employees is probably one

0:43:19 of the most critical things we need to do because the stuff that city government

0:43:22 does doesn't happen without people making it happen. Suzanne Hopkins. I'm

0:43:27 ready to make the motion if you're ready. I would make the motion that we approve

0:43:33 the request to move the city's salary table for present after all of the

0:43:38 the information we've received.

0:43:40 Second.

0:43:41 Do we want to put a date on it?

0:43:44 Did you want a date on it?

0:43:46 It should be effective June for the first payroll in June.

0:43:52 I believe it's May 29th or June 1st, 20th.

0:43:55 So noted.

0:43:57 May 29th, I saw Susan check her head at that.

0:44:00 Motion by Susan.

0:44:01 How can second by Nikki Boyd to approve the mid-year salary

0:44:05 table adjustment as presented?

0:44:08 I was talking to trials should the motion include the 4% I think the weight of average is 2.6

0:44:15 So what we're going to we move the table 4% okay, but not everybody is

0:44:21 Yes, so the point you yeah individual employees do not move is the table moves

0:44:26 It's the table moves and then it triggers appropriate movement of employees

0:44:30 Greg Lanting?

0:44:32 Since Chris brought up the fact that the city of Mayors

0:44:35 not include the city councils not included in this either.

0:44:38 We haven't already ever been.

0:44:41 Dang.

0:44:43 So people ought to have a full understanding.

0:44:46 All this closer.

0:44:48 Any further discussion from the council?

0:44:51 Seeing none, Sharon will call a vote please.

0:44:55 Chris Harkington?

0:44:56 Yes.

0:44:57 Greg Lanting?

0:44:58 Yes.

0:44:59 Don Hall?

0:45:00 Piers yes, Suzanne Hawkins yes, Nikki Boyd yes, Sean Baraker. Yes

0:45:07 Motion passes 7 to 0. Thank you

0:45:11 Thank you Travis

0:45:15 Next is another opportunity for public input if there is anyone here from the public who wishes to address the council

0:45:20 Now is your chance to come forward and do that?

0:45:26 Seeing no one items from the city manager mr. Rothweiler

0:45:29 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, nothing more than what I shared, but maybe just a couple of quick reminders for individuals who might be tuning in late.

0:45:38 There's an opportunity to write for Ryan tomorrow at 6.30 PM.

0:45:44 Staging will begin.

0:45:46 It will be a very easy tour through the community.

0:45:52 roughly about eight miles, there will be a potluck after, and we would, you know,

0:46:00 certainly it is sponsored by the Magic Valley Chain Gang, a group that Ryan was

0:46:06 certainly an active member in.

0:46:09 The second to our services for Ryan are going to be this Saturday at 3 o'clock

0:46:16 at the Reformed Church and really credit to Chief Clark and to members of the Fire Department

0:46:27 family who are not only grieving but working with Ryan's wife, Amy, as they really put

0:46:37 together a proper and fitting memorial for Ryan.

0:46:43 Thank you, Travis.

0:46:47 Don Hall.

0:46:48 I just wanted to mention that the chief and I were talking about this this this morning how I thought the memorial service the

0:46:56 Police Memorial Service this weekend was

0:47:00 Just a quality event and we were very blessed because it rained before

0:47:07 The Sun came out and it rained right after so it was it was it was we were very blessed to be able to pull that off

0:47:14 I'd like to report to the Council on the public on our quarterly impact fee committee meeting.

0:47:24 We held this last week.

0:47:26 As you're aware, it's been approved or upheld by courts for municipalities to address new

0:47:34 growth in the areas of police, fire, streets and parks and that new growth can be assessed

0:47:40 a surcharge to help pay for that.

0:47:45 The members of the committee, backed by the knowledge of the city staff, decided for the

0:47:51 second year in a row there will not be any increases on new growth into Twin Falls, which

0:47:58 I think is a little bit of a pleasant surprise.

0:48:01 Just might give you a little update that some of the collected money, which I mentioned need

0:48:06 a little help, it's like a million plus now, as in a million three, that is in a cruel.

0:48:12 Yeah.

0:48:13 And a certain portion of that will be used for the police department improvements.

0:48:18 It might have been 9-1-1 or fired as batch.

0:48:21 I can't remember.

0:48:22 Perhaps you could share that with the council.

0:48:24 So there's about $127,000 from the fired department impact fees that's going to go to the communication center improvements.

0:48:33 For the growth to that portion, we're adding,

0:48:38 I think we're gonna create a six person communication center.

0:48:43 We currently have a three person center.

0:48:44 So we're basically doubling the size of it

0:48:47 and that growth is gonna be paid for with this fire impact fees.

0:48:51 And the remaining, I wanna say about $800,000

0:48:54 from the police department impact fees,

0:48:57 we'll be going into the remodel of the current city hall

0:49:01 turning it into a police admin building.

0:49:04 Thank you.

0:49:06 Yeah, and the $127,000 from the fire department

0:49:09 is in the bank, collected right now,

0:49:11 and most of that $800 is also in the bank right now,

0:49:14 and we'll be collecting more over the next couple years

0:49:16 to make up that full $800,000.

0:49:20 Thank you, Mr. Greg Lanting.

0:49:21 I also would like to report that there's

0:49:23 going to be a combined meeting of the Twin Falls City Planning

0:49:27 and Zoning Commission, as well as the Comp Plan Committee,

0:49:31 I guess it's a call that will be here in this room at noon on Wednesday to continue work on a new comprehensive plan.

0:49:40 It's open to the public.

0:49:43 Suzanne, go ahead.

0:49:45 I believe Saturday is also the grand opening of the splash pad. Did anybody have that?

0:49:50 One o'clock.

0:49:51 One o'clock at First Federal Park and the communities invited to come celebrate.

0:49:56 And I would add too, so earlier on the consent calendar, we did approve these special event requests for western days.

0:50:04 So that is coming up on Friday, June 3rd, Saturday, June 4th, and Sunday, June 5th.

0:50:10 So I would encourage folks to check out the schedule for that and get involved.

0:50:14 And I will get an email after the council about our opportunity to participate in the parade.

0:50:20 If you can and if you can't, that's fine, too.

0:50:22 Anything else from any members of the council?

0:50:27 I do want to take just one quick second to embarrass Sharon and congratulate her.

0:50:32 later she was informing us before the meeting that today marks her 40th

0:50:37 anniversary with the City of Twin Falls. So Sharon thank you for all of your

0:50:47 service to the community and here's to 40 more.

0:50:55 That the meeting is adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, May 23, 2016. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:51:17.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    1b431688b19b1f1e1a1729bc3f701c2312d37f29b0d871a4c66297c17d005f1f
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a a6691df9235cb913af5682abd80a47acc37e5cc0c715c7342594618bf29c6faf
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    a8850093e96b5b2cbdab5682bec95dc66692977b89df1460215a8d3b8547b2b0

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file