City Council meeting
Monday, June 20, 2016
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Minutes on fileExecutive session: f
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:00:00 Those who would like to stand and say the Pledge of Allegiance with us, please rise.
0:00:30 Do we have any way to get the feedback under control? Please bear with us. We're trying to get the sound worked out here.
0:00:48 This is too hot the Mike. Thank you, Tammy
0:01:00 Guess I should have explained myself
0:01:14 Okay, we're gonna see how this goes
0:01:17 First of all I would like to confirm that we do have a quorum of the council here tonight
0:01:22 We have six out of the seven members our mayor was
0:01:25 available to attend tonight
0:01:28 So with that we are going to move on Travis. Are there any?
0:01:34 Considerates of amendments to the agenda tonight
0:01:36 Yeah, Madam Vice Mayor, members of the Council tonight, we would ask for two considerations.
0:01:43 The first is we would ask that item number three be postponed until next week.
0:01:50 We want to give ample opportunity for the first item in which we would like to ask the
0:01:59 the Council's indulgence to have a statement regarding the incident that occurred at the
0:02:06 Fonbrook Apartments to be delivered by Chief Kingsbury following that we would suggest opening
0:02:13 up for public comment and then moving into the balance of the meeting as described on
0:02:20 the published agenda.
0:02:22 So noted, do we need to take a vote on that or can we just make that move?
0:02:25 Okay.
0:02:26 Thank you very much.
0:02:35 I'm going to have our City Attorney Fritz Wonder look reply.
0:02:39 You're not permitted to add any new item to your agenda without 24 hour notice.
0:02:45 The request here is not to add any new item so you're permitted to do this.
0:02:50 The gentleman is incorrect.
0:02:52 Thank you very much.
0:02:54 At this point I just want to remind everyone that in our form of government and in our personal
0:02:58 rules here, when you address the council we do ask that it is at the microphone because
0:03:03 we are live recorded and live streaming, and people at home cannot hear if you're talking
0:03:07 from the audience.
0:03:09 So if you can wait until it's your turn to come to the microphone and address us, we're
0:03:13 going to try to get through everybody in the best order we can tonight and give everybody
0:03:18 a fair chance to be heard.
0:03:20 But bear with us and let's make sure that you are at the microphone when you speak.
0:03:24 And I'd really appreciate that help tonight.
0:03:27 So at this time, I'm going to turn it over to our chief of police, Craig Kingsbury, and
0:03:32 ask him to please address not only the council but the citizens of our community.
0:03:36 Welcome Chief.
0:03:38 Thank you Vice Mayor, members of the council, and members of the community who are in attendance
0:03:43 tonight, as well as those that are listening as we're live streaming, there's way too many
0:03:49 other mics on our mics so it keeps falling down.
0:03:56 Can we hear me now?
0:03:58 Yes.
0:03:59 Okay, and it keeps falling.
0:04:00 I'll just hold it here.
0:04:02 Okay.
0:04:04 Council members of the community citizens of Twin Falls and even citizens of Idaho
0:04:10 and the United States. In December I stood in this very room and raised my right
0:04:17 hand and took an oath of office to become the chief of police for this city.
0:04:21 That's something that I have done three other times in my career. Taking an oath
0:04:27 to be a deputy sheriff, taking an oath to be a police officer, then taking an
0:04:31 oath to be a chief of police of another city and now here in Twin Falls. I take that oath
0:04:38 very, I take it to heart. Part of that oath is that I will do everything that I can within
0:04:45 the rule of law, within the United States Constitution, the Constitution of the State of Idaho, to
0:04:51 make sure that what we do at Twin Falls Police Department is to reach our mission and protect
0:04:58 and serve, and protect and serve everyone. So I want to talk a little bit, it's really hard
0:05:03 to talk and hold this foot. Sorry. I'm going to talk a little bit about the incident that
0:05:07 occurred on June 2nd in our city. As Mr. Rothweiler noted on June 2nd, there was a report of a
0:05:19 Ludenless Civvies conduct that occurred at the FOMB Brook Apartments. That case, the phone
0:05:29 call came into the Twin Falls Police Department's Communication Center and the
0:05:36 original call was for something a lot less serious than a sexual assault or
0:05:42 gluten-sleeves conduct. However, when people called in several minutes later
0:05:48 and requested medical aid officers and subsequently detectives were soon
0:05:53 dispatched. It's important on cases like this and these types of investigations
0:06:02 that all of us, needs in chief, members of council,
0:06:07 and members of the community, understand that the number one priority is the victim.
0:06:12 We can't forget this.
0:06:13 We have a young girl who has been victimized and part of my oath to serve those victims,
0:06:23 to make sure that it's done with the proper protocol and to make sure that we don't
0:06:30 re-victimize the victim.
0:06:34 I think where we're at in the 21st century, not only in law enforcement, but just in the
0:06:39 United States, we have a lot better understanding of how to deal with victims of sexual assault
0:06:47 than we did even 26 years ago when I first got into this profession.
0:06:51 We've come a long ways and we do a really good job with how we deal with victims of
0:06:56 these types of heinous crimes.
0:07:01 The individuals responsible for this crime, for this incident, two of them have been arrested
0:07:09 and taken to the juvenile detention center.
0:07:11 That happened on Friday.
0:07:13 Need to understand that these types of cases take a long time and just in a little bit, I'm
0:07:24 going to talk about how we investigate these types of cases.
0:07:27 But I think the community, city council, everybody has a right to know that the two offenders
0:07:33 are in fact currently incarcerated in the juvenile detention center here at Snake River
0:07:39 Juvenile Detention.
0:07:40 I think we're all aware that the handling judge has sealed this case.
0:07:47 Because of that, and because of state laws that deal with juvenile offenders, I is the
0:07:52 chief or any law enforcement official really cannot comment any further in regards to that
0:07:59 particular incident.
0:08:01 What I would like to do is to first talk about some of the things that didn't happen.
0:08:08 Because there's a lot of misinformation on social media.
0:08:12 A lot of stuff that quite frankly, I don't know if they made it up or what, but it's just
0:08:16 not true.
0:08:17 And I'd like to address a few of those issues.
0:08:25 First of all, the first issue is that, I can do it, thank you Mitch, yeah I'm fine.
0:08:30 The first issue is that this was a rape committed by three Syrian refugees.
0:08:39 That's not true.
0:08:41 As Mr. Loebz was quoted in local media today, the juvenile suspects are not from Syria.
0:08:49 In fact, they are from the countries of Sudan and Iraq.
0:08:53 We understand that they have been in the United States for less than two years.
0:09:00 I am not certain as to their refugee status, but they have been here for less than two years, and they are from those two countries.
0:09:07 They also was reported that a knife was used.
0:09:09 There's no evidence to report this.
0:09:12 No evidence that a knife was used.
0:09:15 Then it took the Twin Falls Police Department over two hours to respond.
0:09:19 Quite simply, that just is not true.
0:09:22 The Twin Falls Police Department, the Magic Valley paramedics, and even the Twin Falls County Sheriff's Office responded in due time.
0:09:30 The detectives were on scene in short order of time.
0:09:34 This was an investigation that was taken very seriously, right after it was reported
0:09:40 that this was a sexual assault investigation.
0:09:44 The investigation took quite a bit of time, and I'll go into maybe some reasons of why
0:09:49 that happened, and when that investigation was complete, the full investigation was turned
0:09:54 over to our Twin Falls County prosecuting attorney Grant Loeb's in his office.
0:10:01 There's some stuff on social media that the suspect or subject's father or father's were
0:10:08 high-fiving and congratulating the boys on this incident.
0:10:13 We have no evidence at all that that occurred.
0:10:18 We've been asked that the Twin Falls City Council cover up this incident and the answer
0:10:22 to that adamantly is no.
0:10:24 The Twin Falls City Council, no member of Twin Falls government has tried to do anything
0:10:30 to cover up this incident.
0:10:33 As the City Council done nothing to address this crime, to that I say, it's not City Council's job to investigate or address criminal matters.
0:10:43 As you know, Vice Mayor, members of the Council, your role is governance, and you do a good job with that.
0:10:49 You provide the Police Department and me as the Chief with the mission and the direction and the resources to carry that out.
0:10:59 The men and women of the Twin Falls Police Department do a pretty darn good job of doing
0:11:03 that.
0:11:04 I'm not saying we're perfect.
0:11:06 We do learn from our mistakes, but we do a good job of carrying out the mission of the
0:11:11 City of Twin Falls and the City of the Twin Falls Police Department.
0:11:17 There also was a question that's been asked on social media and it was asked last week
0:11:22 in open forum in regards to the mosque here in town and the building permit timeline.
0:11:29 Obviously, the building department is not a department that I work in, but I have some friends that I reached out to.
0:11:36 The building permit for the mosque was submitted on January 27th, and subsequently issued on April 17th, obviously not 24 hours.
0:11:47 I would also say that there was a plumbing permit that was issued on May 15th for this building.
0:11:53 That's the same day that it was applied for, but that is common practice in the City of
0:11:59 Twin Falls for plumbing permits to be issued the same day that somebody comes in and asks
0:12:04 for it.
0:12:06 So those are a few of the items of misinformation that I wanted to address, things that just
0:12:13 quite frankly were not true.
0:12:14 Now I'd like to talk a little bit about sex abuse investigations and how we in law enforcement
0:12:23 conduct these investigations, and the many partners that we have when we conduct these
0:12:28 investigations.
0:12:30 Because the Twin Falls Police Department does not take these investigations lightly, and
0:12:36 we do not conduct them by ourselves.
0:12:41 When a call of a sexual abuse of a child comes in through the dispatch center, first and
0:12:48 foremost, our number one goal is a safety of that child, or for that matter any victim
0:12:54 of sexual abuse or any crime against persons.
0:12:57 We want to make sure that the medical needs are being met and we want to make sure that
0:13:02 they are safe from the perpetrator or perpetrators.
0:13:06 Are they away from the suspects?
0:13:12 Obviously if they're not, police are dispatched, what I would call in a code three response.
0:13:19 We come in with lights and sirens and get there to try to stop the acting progress if
0:13:23 that's what we have to do.
0:13:26 More often than not, when we are, when Ludenlessivious Conduct is reported to law enforcement,
0:13:32 it is reported after the fact.
0:13:35 It is reported when that incident is actually no longer happening, and the victim most of
0:13:41 the time is in a safe place.
0:13:45 Therefore, our first after that is to get the medical aid to the victim, and dispatch
0:13:51 patrol officers and or investigators to make sure that all evidence is
0:13:56 collected and that statements that statements are are taken. Now I will tell
0:14:02 you there is a matter of of practice patrol officers nor detectives will
0:14:10 interview young children when it comes to these types of cases because we know
0:14:16 from the years that we've been doing this, that the questions and the question
0:14:24 formulation in interviewing young child victims is so important and we don't
0:14:31 want to do anything that's going to a re-victimize. Now, we don't want this
0:14:35 child to have to tell that story more than once if we can help it. And we also
0:14:42 don't want to do anything that's going to jeopardize the prosecution if an
0:14:47 officer or detective were to improperly formulate questions.
0:14:53 So here in Twin Falls and in the Magic Valley, we're very lucky, we have some great partners.
0:14:58 One of those partners is CARES.
0:15:00 CARES stands for children at risk evaluation services.
0:15:04 CARES works in conjunction as a part of St. Luke's Regional Medical Center here in Twin Falls.
0:15:12 CARES is an organization that each and every day saves lives.
0:15:18 There is a partner that we in law enforcement, not just with Twin Falls PD but also the Sheriff's Office and other partners,
0:15:26 rely on so often for these types of investigations.
0:15:34 We have a protocol within Twin Falls County.
0:15:38 That protocol is signed by Grant Loebz, our prosecutor by Sheriff Carter.
0:15:45 It was actually signed by the former chief of the Twin Falls Police Department, but I'll be signing out as well and we follow it.
0:15:50 as well as other law enforcement heads that dictate how we will handle crimes against children.
0:15:58 So that we as departments whether here in Twin Falls or in the city of Biel or any of
0:16:03 our law enforcement partners in the county, we all do this the same way.
0:16:09 There is a method to how we do this.
0:16:12 And I can't stress enough that the number one reason that we do this and handle this way
0:16:16 to make sure that we are not re-victimizing the victim and that we are guarding the best
0:16:22 evidence possible.
0:16:26 Now CARES interviewers are trained to provide questions that are developmentally appropriate
0:16:32 for that child.
0:16:35 They want to make sure that the child can comprehend the question, comprehend the questions and
0:16:39 answer them in a safe, neutral facility.
0:16:43 In other words, they are not interviewed at the Twin Falls Police Department or the Twin
0:16:46 Falls Sheriff's Office. They're interviewed in a safe environment. TFPD and CARES also
0:16:58 works with our many partners to make sure that the family of those involved and the child
0:17:08 victim themselves can get the proper counseling services that they need to get through this.
0:17:15 I stand up here as a Chief of Police, but I think it's also important to note I'm a father
0:17:20 of three and a grandfather of three. You know, I'm a kid that grew up in Idaho. I grew up
0:17:28 in Lewiston and I've been down here in the southern part for the last couple, two and
0:17:32 a half decades. But when push comes to shove, we all have our histories and we all have our
0:17:38 belief systems. And I think that one of the things that we do a really good job with in
0:17:44 law enforcement and here in Twin Falls County is our utilization of CARES, our other partners
0:17:50 such as the Department of Health and Welfare Child Protective Services that get involved in
0:17:55 these investigations, working with the Victim Witness Coordinator for the Twin Falls County
0:18:00 Sheriff's Office as well as the Twin Falls County Prosecuting Attorneys Office.
0:18:04 We do all these things so we can envelope around the victim and so we can make sure that victim
0:18:13 is covered with the services that they need.
0:18:18 These cases are investigated very carefully and again not quickly.
0:18:24 Many times these cases come down to physical evidence that takes time to collect.
0:18:30 Needs to be sometimes sent off to various labs, especially through that of state police at the
0:18:36 lab and Meridian as an example.
0:18:39 Oftentimes these cases in today's society also involve some sort of computer or mobile device,
0:18:47 and we utilize, you know, we utilize our prosecutor friends to get warrants, to obtain those devices
0:18:54 and then to search those devices for evidence that supports.
0:19:00 And then most importantly, the statements of the victim as well as any other witnesses.
0:19:07 I would also say that with CARES, they are a great resource when we have young offenders
0:19:31 because in my 26 years of policing of which several were spent investigating these types
0:19:39 of crimes, live in the serious crimes. Often times when the offenders are young, you have
0:19:47 to ask yourself, what did they learn this? Were they in fact victims themselves? And
0:19:53 so the folks at CARES are great partners at CARES. We utilize them for those interviews
0:19:58 as well because they are again properly trained and forensic interviews and they can interview
0:20:04 those people, those youngsters, and make a determination as to whether or not these children are displaying
0:20:14 inappropriate sexual behavior and why are these children are acting out.
0:20:19 Again, like I said, young children don't usually act out this way.
0:20:24 Unfortunately, sometimes they were victims themselves.
0:20:27 Our maybe learned it from an older sibling or neighbor or something along those lines.
0:20:32 So we have to try to find those things out in investigations such as these.
0:20:39 So in closing, I just want to make sure that you, as a city council,
0:20:46 I want to make sure that our community, and not just Twin Falls City, but this community,
0:20:53 the Magic Valley community, and our state understands that law enforcement
0:20:59 takes these types of allegations very seriously.
0:21:03 However, we can't act on them within an hour.
0:21:10 It's not like a crime show, it's not like TV.
0:21:13 Unfortunately, we don't respond and solve everything within an hour.
0:21:17 To try to do that would not be fair to the victims involved in cases such as these.
0:21:23 We need to take our time.
0:21:25 And the incident that we're here to discuss tonight, again, I will tell you that the investigators took their time appropriately.
0:21:36 They worked with CARES to make sure that right interviews and everything was done right.
0:21:42 And then this case was submitted and reviewed by our partners at the prosecutor's office just like any of these cases.
0:21:49 And so that's why we're here tonight.
0:21:53 I know that the community and even the national community is asking a lot of questions.
0:22:02 I hope I've cleared up a lot of the mistruths, a lot of the information that is out there in social media that just isn't true.
0:22:10 I mentioned the beginning that I took an oath right here in this room, and I took that oath and pledged to use a council into this community that I would do my best as a chief to protect and serve everyone.
0:22:25 I don't care who they are.
0:22:29 I don't care what color they are.
0:22:31 I don't care how much money they have or don't have, and I don't care where they're from.
0:22:36 If they're within the jurisdictional boundaries of the City of Twin Falls, it's my job to
0:22:41 make sure that they're protected.
0:22:44 And if people violate the law, the same thing goes, I don't care where they're from, it's
0:22:49 my job to make sure that we investigate these cases properly and that these cases are presented
0:22:56 to our partners at the prosecutor's office in a fair and just manner, and then that part
0:23:03 of the criminal justice system we'll take over.
0:23:06 Thank you very much.
0:23:09 Thank you very much, Chief.
0:23:10 I appreciate your time tonight.
0:23:13 At this point, I'm going to go ahead and go through the agenda
0:23:17 as it is.
0:23:18 And so the next thing is we have no proclamations tonight.
0:23:21 And the first thing we like to do at our meetings
0:23:24 once the formalities are over here
0:23:25 is to open up the forum to public comment.
0:23:29 And before I do that, I just want
0:23:30 to remind you that we do have a full house tonight.
0:23:34 Please be considered of the amount of time you take.
0:23:36 I'm not going to time you.
0:23:37 I'm not going to cut anybody off.
0:23:38 I'm just going to ask everybody to please be reasonable.
0:23:42 And we're here to listen to whatever it is you would like to have to say tonight.
0:23:47 I'm asking for Noah Plause during any of the speeches tonight, please.
0:23:53 And with that, I believe there was a sign of sheet in the back.
0:23:57 Is there someone who can grab that?
0:24:01 When you come up to the microphone, would you please introduce yourself
0:24:05 by your name and what city you're from.
0:24:07 We don't need physical addresses,
0:24:08 but we would like to know what city you are
0:24:10 representing tonight.
0:24:23 Okay, the first one on our list tonight is Gary Garnand.
0:24:26 Gary, did you want to speak on this?
0:24:29 Are you here for another issue on the agenda?
0:24:33 Thank you.
0:24:35 Council, I'm Gary Garnand from Twin Falls.
0:24:38 I'm here to ask for confirmation
0:24:41 for a three-year term on over there.
0:24:45 All right, we have you coming up
0:24:46 under our items for consideration then.
0:24:48 we'll get to you just a minute. Sorry. Susie Kepersk. Sorry. If you could hold the microphone
0:25:07 up for us, that would be great. Ah, there we go. Thank you and welcome. My name is Susie
0:25:15 and I am here, Vice Mayor and Council, I just wanted to speak and share my support for the
0:25:24 way the situation has been handled for the forthcoming nature of the place and the honest
0:25:34 accounting and statement that was shared this evening and the attempt to refute misinformation
0:25:43 that I believe is meant purely to stir up bigotry and hatred.
0:25:49 And I don't think that's indicative of what we are as Idahoans
0:25:53 or of what we are as Americans.
0:25:56 And I just, I thought I didn't know I'd be first.
0:26:00 I don't have a lot to say.
0:26:01 I just wanted to share my support and my hope and my belief
0:26:05 that we can all grow together as to involves natives as Idahoans
0:26:12 and as Americans to embrace the diversity that we have
0:26:16 and to appreciate the diversity that we have
0:26:19 and to be better citizens and better neighbors
0:26:23 and try to truly listen to each other.
0:26:27 That's it.
0:26:28 Thank you very much.
0:26:31 Terence Edwards.
0:26:38 Thank you.
0:26:39 Terence Edwards, I live in Jerome.
0:26:41 I have property in Twin Falls and I'm concerned
0:26:45 about the reporting that was made, as was pointed out,
0:26:49 there's all kinds of things flying around the community
0:26:52 and on the intranet about the refugee situation
0:26:57 and about the Muslim influence here in Twin.
0:27:03 I don't believe anybody said anything
0:27:05 about Syrian refugees here last week.
0:27:09 What they said was a Muslim influence,
0:27:12 and that's been twisted and misreported
0:27:15 by our local media, and also on the internet, they're talking about Syrian refugees.
0:27:21 We're talking about the Muslim influence.
0:27:24 The Muslim influence is not just a religion, it's a theocracy, it's a religion that is overridden
0:27:34 by their government structure, and everybody's heard about Sharia law.
0:27:39 I'm glad that the Chief of Police pointed out the fact that he took an oath, as I did,
0:27:44 to defend the Constitution of the United States,
0:27:47 you took a note to defend the Constitution of the United
0:27:50 States as well as the state of Idaho,
0:27:52 to serve and protect the people equally.
0:27:55 But I'm afraid that a lot of you don't know what's
0:27:58 in that Constitution.
0:27:59 And I'd like to give you a copy of the old that you took on.
0:28:03 And also I have one for each of you,
0:28:06 both that maybe I'll read this, because it's informative.
0:28:09 I know a lot of people have taken a note,
0:28:12 and they haven't been able to understand
0:28:14 why people are so upset if you read the oath.
0:28:17 Thanks, I'll take a look at the other dozen I have.
0:28:20 Well, good.
0:28:21 OK.
0:28:21 And have read them.
0:28:26 The concern is that we are concerned,
0:28:29 and it took a meeting of last week
0:28:31 to get things kind of on the front burner.
0:28:34 And they're on the front burner.
0:28:36 And now accusations on both sides are flying back and forth.
0:28:40 I think the problem is is that if you
0:28:42 were out ahead of the issue two and a half years ago,
0:28:46 three years ago, a year and a half ago, we wouldn't be here today.
0:28:50 And coexistence doesn't exist in our country.
0:28:54 If you don't know that, you're just looking at the wrong newspapers because we don't coexist
0:29:00 here.
0:29:01 Our president has separated the minority, separated religion, separated communities,
0:29:08 separated everything.
0:29:09 He has done nothing to bring anybody together.
0:29:12 this pathetic and that's what we're you guys look to your leadership your
0:29:17 leadership looks to the president the president is misusing his office and
0:29:21 you're following in suit so I don't have much to say about that anymore but you
0:29:27 guys know where you're going with this thank you for coming tonight Charles
0:29:33 Welch thank you I sorry Mr. Berger wasn't here tonight I just wanted to clear up
0:29:45 something from your last meeting last week where someone addressed that, you know, tax
0:29:52 dollars are going to the refugee program and he was pretty adamant that it's a federal program
0:30:00 and no one's taxes, you know, go to pay for it throughout here but I wanted to remind
0:30:07 that federal taxes do come from us.
0:30:11 So he was quite wrong on stating that, and also I'd like to say, to CSI gets funding for
0:30:21 the refugee program, proportionally from our property taxes, us, and I believe up as a
0:30:30 Bonner County for Coeur d'Alene for their college, where the only two counties in the
0:30:33 state that get that tax imposed on us for the college.
0:30:38 So therefore again, there's more tax dollars that people aren't addressing that are going
0:30:44 to the refugee program and as well they also, I know folks who have worked with the refugee
0:30:48 program, they get chipped, they get Medicaid, they get food stamps and those were state
0:30:53 tax dollars and you know people need to address that and you know for the people who are unsupportive
0:31:00 of the program you know.
0:31:03 So I just wanted to clear that record up.
0:31:04 Thank you.
0:31:05 Thank you very much.
0:31:09 If you could try to get a little closer to the microphone when you speak, we have people
0:31:12 in the audience who are having a difficult time hearing what's being said tonight.
0:31:16 The next one is a signature and, okay, there you go.
0:31:20 I thought somebody would recognize it.
0:31:27 Sorry.
0:31:28 Couldn't even guess.
0:31:29 I know.
0:31:30 You should see my son on the line.
0:31:32 Welcome.
0:31:33 Thank you.
0:31:34 Thank you.
0:31:35 My name is Danny.
0:31:36 I'm glad.
0:31:37 I'm glad to have met this gentleman, he sounds like a very sincere gentleman and we need somebody
0:31:42 like that in our town.
0:31:44 He said he doesn't know for sure that the father high-fived the young boy that was in
0:31:52 charge of this.
0:31:56 I went over to their house today and most likely in hiding and they should be.
0:32:01 They should be scared.
0:32:03 I bought presents for the little girl.
0:32:05 I can give him later.
0:32:07 We need to speak to the grandmother that took the camera away from the young man and gave
0:32:12 it to the police department to find out if he really had a knife, if he really high-fived,
0:32:18 because I do know that the media hides a lot of stuff from us. I've experienced that well
0:32:24 too much, but I'm a red old-blooded American. This is my country, dammit, and bringing in
0:32:31 these people from other countries, if they don't abide by our rules, they need to get
0:32:36 to help back to their country, a lot of them went to Canada to get away from the draft.
0:32:44 So I want them to see my face because they're going to meet me someday if they try to mess
0:32:50 with my country.
0:32:53 And you're going to be standing by because I may need to call you, I don't allow people
0:33:00 to terrorize my family or myself, my little animals or my country, and the gentleman's right,
0:33:10 Obama has separated us. It's time to take our country back. It's time to do something
0:33:16 about it. Let's stop feeling sorry for all these people in sitting around saying, oh yeah,
0:33:23 this is bad. This is terrible. Let's really do something. Let's stand as Americans and
0:33:28 We take our country back.
0:33:30 Thank you.
0:33:31 Thank you for coming tonight.
0:33:34 Vicki Davis.
0:33:35 Hi.
0:33:47 I'm Vicki Davis.
0:33:48 I live in Twin Falls, Idaho, sometime just over a year ago, when we first started protesting
0:33:55 the refugee program over at CSI, I gave a presentation over there.
0:34:01 And I said, the nation of Islam, it's a self-contained nation.
0:34:07 They are a nation without geographic territory.
0:34:11 They bring their political system, they bring their religion with them wherever they go.
0:34:17 The nation of Islam has declared global jihad on us.
0:34:24 And Obama, this administration, is bringing them in as fast as he possibly can.
0:34:32 Now, why do you think he's doing that?
0:34:34 Do you think it's out of the goodness of his heart?
0:34:39 isn't. There is a war on the American people and you people are allowing the
0:34:47 importation of these people, these people who have declared war on us, you're
0:34:53 bringing them in. And this little girl who was attacked, she's just one one
0:35:01 episode. There have been other episodes and you know it and I know it. We all know
0:35:06 it. And it's not just in this town, it's in other towns. And the things that are
0:35:16 happening is they continue to happen in this town. They're on your head, your head,
0:35:22 your head, your head, yours, yours. This has got to stop. They are not compatible
0:35:29 with our culture. They hate us. They don't want to be Americans. They don't want to
0:35:36 a semalite. What do you need to see? What more proof do you need?
0:35:41 Thank you, Vicki. That is everyone I have signed up on the sign-in sheet to speak. If there's
0:35:49 anybody else at this time who would like to come up, we'll just ask you to come up one
0:35:52 at a time and please introduce yourself in what city you're from.
0:35:56 My name is Savannah Henderson and I am from Twin Falls. What bothers me about this case
0:36:08 is through media, I don't know if this is true or false, but it says that there was a restraining
0:36:13 order pressed against the two families, but it never went through.
0:36:16 And I just wanted to know why wasn't that pressed, because as a police officer,
0:36:21 you were supposed to be protecting us.
0:36:24 So that's what I have heard from you.
0:36:26 Am I correct?
0:36:27 I thank you for your question, but we cannot make any comments on the case because
0:36:31 it has been closed by the judge in charge of it at this time.
0:36:34 So the information that we've put forth is all that we can say at this time.
0:36:39 And as the case proceeds through, that would be up to the judge to release what he wants.
0:36:44 So it's hard for us to say here, say what has and hasn't happened.
0:36:48 But if you have anything you want to comment on, feel free to comment.
0:36:50 I do have another comment.
0:36:53 Based on our second amendment rights and our constitution, we are free to do our own state of religion.
0:37:01 I was wondering myself, as a high school student, I have many refugees in my school at Canyon Ridge.
0:37:07 And I'm not allowed to express my religion because it offends them and I was wondering why I should stop going by my second amendment.
0:37:17 So they're happy and they don't even respect my religion.
0:37:23 I can't speak to the school district and their policies, they are their own entity.
0:37:28 I have grandchildren that locally go to school and they have never been stopped from praying over their lunches or
0:37:34 carry in their Bibles to school or whatever their personal preferences are, so I'm not
0:37:40 sure, you know, whoever has told you that, you would probably need to seek assistance from
0:37:47 the school district or whatever legal counsel you need, but that is, again, is something
0:37:52 that is not under the umbrella of your city council.
0:37:55 I'm sorry.
0:37:56 Okay.
0:37:57 That is all I have to say.
0:37:58 The city manager would like to go ahead and weigh in.
0:38:00 So what we'll do is we'll capture the questions and try to be in a response or to respond to
0:38:09 the ones that we can.
0:38:12 I don't know what questions we are going to be able to answer, what questions we won't
0:38:16 be able to answer, but I'd certainly like the opportunity to ask to see if there are
0:38:21 certain questions that are generated this evening that we might be able to continue
0:38:25 to answer as part of the community dialogue.
0:38:28 But at this point in time, I don't know what those are.
0:38:30 So we'll make a note of the questions, and we'll look into the restraining order question
0:38:37 that has been asked, and we will certainly provide that information moving forward.
0:38:45 I'm going to just real quick, for the people that are asking the questions since we're
0:38:49 just getting names and cities tonight, what is the best way for them to follow up to get
0:38:53 those responses?
0:38:58 If they want to give us the best form of communication, maybe on a back sign up sheet, maybe a FETs, by email,
0:39:06 that might be the best way for us to be able to answer that.
0:39:11 There also might be individuals who are generally interested in the responses, and so we could work with our media partners.
0:39:17 We could also post that on our social media sites.
0:39:20 We could do a whole series of different releases, but for direct contact we would ask that individuals
0:39:27 leave their preferred method of contact with us and maybe Sharon, I don't know if she has
0:39:34 a notebook or something, but maybe guests could go over there and just write their name
0:39:38 and email or phone number or preferred method.
0:39:41 So would you like them to go that way and then back out? Is that what you're saying? Go to
0:39:45 Sharon and over or is she too busy?
0:39:48 We'll make it work.
0:39:49 Okay, so if you want answers to questions tonight, if you'll just come over to the desk
0:39:54 On this side of the council chamber and leave your name and email address, you will be
0:39:58 replied to.
0:39:59 How's that?
0:40:00 Thank you for coming tonight.
0:40:02 Nicky Boyd?
0:40:03 I have a question for the young lady signing the paper over there.
0:40:07 May I ask her a question?
0:40:08 Yes, you may.
0:40:11 What was her name?
0:40:12 We shouldn't sign the inside of them.
0:40:14 Savannah.
0:40:15 Savannah, thank you.
0:40:17 I'm interested to know who told you that you could not follow your faith or who brought
0:40:23 up the Second Amendment at school.
0:40:26 Second Amendment, it's been going on since my freshman year.
0:40:29 I am now a senior at high school and every time, like we pray in the lunchroom, we are not allowed to do that because it
0:40:36 spends certain refugees and we are taken to the principal's office due to it.
0:40:40 I have witnessed this firsthand and it happens to a lot other people, not just me.
0:40:46 You're physically stopped?
0:40:47 Yes, I am physically stopped by other students, not by other students, by other, they make reports to our
0:40:54 principals, whoever's in charge, and we are then taken and prosecuted out of the area into
0:41:00 the principal's office where we're said that we cannot discuss that ground because it affects
0:41:05 certain people.
0:41:06 Thank you.
0:41:08 Travis?
0:41:09 So, I think all issues are important that need to be discussed this evening.
0:41:17 I think it's important to recognize that in Idaho City Councils do not have jurisdiction
0:41:25 oversight of schools, school activities, school boards.
0:41:29 I would encourage Ms. Henderson to work with Dr. Dobbs and members of the school district
0:41:40 administration through those issues in which that group might be able to better address
0:41:48 her concerns.
0:41:52 Our role is not with schools and school districts.
0:41:56 So just for the audience and trying to provide maybe an avenue in which that concern can be addressed and vetted.
0:42:06 Thank you, Greg Lanting.
0:42:08 I'm sorry, the old Gogmert teacher is coming out of me.
0:42:11 It's the first amendment, folks.
0:42:15 Thank you, Greg.
0:42:18 Anyone else like to address this?
0:42:25 Julie Roth, Twin Falls County.
0:42:29 The first thing I'd like to address is Chris Chalkington.
0:42:34 You sit in an honorable seat.
0:42:36 The City Council is an honorable position, all of you.
0:42:40 Have achieved that because your community has put their trust in you and voted for you.
0:42:47 Last Monday you implied I'm with the white supremacist group.
0:42:51 That was entirely dishonorable of your seat.
0:42:56 unacceptable, unacceptable to me, and unacceptable to the people that you assumed I was here with.
0:43:03 I would like to address that as being inappropriate of your honorable position.
0:43:10 It is a gross insult to have the community, and it's not comfortable to do this.
0:43:15 Surely you must know that.
0:43:17 It's not comfortable for the community to have to address serious issues.
0:43:21 You actually ask for public input if I'm not mistaken.
0:43:25 You have a spot listed on your form.
0:43:29 So when the public actually has the guts to come here and address really, really difficult
0:43:34 things, they shouldn't be afraid of being considered part of a white supremacist group.
0:43:42 That's your personal opinion, but you've never even had a conversation with me.
0:43:46 So I'm drawing that into the public forum.
0:43:49 I want that on record.
0:43:50 That I was appended by that.
0:43:52 I think that was very, very disrespectful.
0:43:54 In addition to which, once everyone was seated, you did also make a statement that you're glad
0:43:59 that we weren't around when your family were refugees to the United States.
0:44:03 That was insulting.
0:44:04 Do my relatives hurt their home?
0:44:07 Yeah, of your predecessors, you were glad that whatever group you saw us as, you were glad
0:44:13 we were not around when they were coming here.
0:44:15 My lineage is Irish, too.
0:44:18 So we probably would have had ancestors hanging out, dancing to the same tunes, would have been
0:44:22 okay.
0:44:25 I talk to refugees. I don't know if a lot of you have them as friends. I do. I ask them
0:44:30 this curious little question. What crisis did you escape? Do you know what they say to me?
0:44:39 Nothing? I didn't escape a crisis. So you're being sold a bill of goods. Yes, there are
0:44:48 legitimate crisis that some people have experienced, but by and large, you're being sold a bill
0:44:55 of goods, that if you're not actually talking to these people and befriending them, you cannot
0:45:00 possibly know that. Are you out walking around talking to these people and asking them? I
0:45:06 know that there are a couple of celebrity refugees in this community and I'm not talking
0:45:10 about them. I'm talking about the average refugee. I want to address the inaccuracy of
0:45:21 social media. Everyone is very quick to point out that people had some facts wrong. I don't
0:45:27 think anybody's going to debate that, but I'll tell you what, liberals have their facts
0:45:31 wrong too. The media swung very left on this as well, claiming that everything was inaccurate
0:45:39 and we were liars and we had no facts, that it never happened. And that needs to be addressed
0:45:46 if you want to be a fair counsel. You cannot look at it from the position of a leftist and
0:45:51 assume that you have judged correctly. You're not representing the community if you do that.
0:45:57 you have more than one view in this town. And inaccuracy comes frequently from the people
0:46:04 standing here with the cameras in their hands, which is one of the things that the officer
0:46:09 addressed about the, the permit in a day, that was publicized in, during fall's local newspaper.
0:46:19 You know how you could have solved that? Called them up and said that was an inaccurate statement
0:46:25 and you need to do a correction.
0:46:28 They have also maligned the police officers.
0:46:31 I don't know if it's accurate or not,
0:46:32 but when we had Sharam Hadian in town,
0:46:35 we were informed through the Times News
0:46:38 that those officers were refugee officers
0:46:41 who later went and complained to the Times News
0:46:44 that they were made miserable by being at that event.
0:46:47 Is it true?
0:46:50 God only knows, but what do you want the public to believe?
0:46:54 Again, I don't take the paper,
0:46:55 So if somebody taps you and says, hey, look, what's in the paper,
0:46:58 and you find out it's inaccurate, it's best for the community
0:47:01 if you address it and ask the Times News to make a correction.
0:47:06 That might help.
0:47:07 I know that several of you have actually told me the Times News
0:47:10 maligns you as well.
0:47:13 If we could actually ask the Times News
0:47:15 to get their facts straight and stop insulting the community
0:47:18 when they stand up in a microphone,
0:47:20 that would go a long way to build unity here.
0:47:23 I have been called so many names, it's ridiculous,
0:47:26 thanks to the Times News.
0:47:28 And so have many other grandmas and grandpas
0:47:33 who stand up and say, I'm uncomfortable with what
0:47:35 your decisions are.
0:47:37 I think you should do this or not do this.
0:47:40 And none of us in this community deserve
0:47:42 to be associated with white supremacists
0:47:46 or insulted in the local newspaper.
0:47:50 That's appalling.
0:47:51 Why do we have a community that thinks that that's OK?
0:47:55 And that could change in a moment if you took it seriously,
0:47:59 in a moment, and said, no more of this.
0:48:02 If you print an insult, you'll be printing a correction.
0:48:05 Now, very well, if somebody quotes a white supremacist
0:48:08 statement, by all means, quote the person accurately
0:48:12 and name their name.
0:48:13 But otherwise, don't carelessly associate your community
0:48:16 with such a despicable group of people.
0:48:23 Thank you for your time.
0:48:25 Thank you, Julie.
0:48:28 Chris Talkington.
0:48:29 And I will not respond to the lady's freedom of speech that she is so eloquently expressed
0:48:33 here.
0:48:35 The meeting that we talked about was sometime in February.
0:48:39 There was language used by a number of people, anti-refugee, anti-immigrant, and one person
0:48:48 characterized the reason for their meeting at that time was for preservation of the white
0:48:53 race.
0:48:54 I stand by the words that were made on that statement and that date.
0:48:58 people that might have been here heard it those of you who didn't hear it and we're not
0:49:03 here don't start a new room or mill going but I think we can agree on one thing there
0:49:09 should be more actual factual representation of what is said rather than third and fourth
0:49:15 parties that's where you get misinformation going is there anyone else would like to address
0:49:23 the council tonight Jesse's troop I live in Twin Falls many of you know me from my service
0:49:32 on the Twin Falls City Youth Council.
0:49:35 I've worked for five years to make Twin Falls a better place, not because it's a super fun
0:49:39 job or because I get a lot of accolades, but because I care about my community and the people
0:49:43 that live in it.
0:49:45 So when I listen to the recording of the council meeting last week, I was shocked by your treatment
0:49:53 of members of this community who came to share their concerns and information.
0:49:57 I don't know why you feel it was appropriate to treat these citizens like their concerns
0:50:02 were of little or no significance, even treating the 25 minutes of time like it was a burden.
0:50:09 You took away their individuality and grouped them together, and from my perspective, you
0:50:13 treated them like they were enemies.
0:50:17 I'm sure a lot of frustrated people, full of emotions, have come to speak at the City
0:50:21 Council.
0:50:24 But as representatives of the City, you are expected to speak with these people with decorum
0:50:30 and calm, even showing compassion and fairness, not sarcasm and rude insinuations.
0:50:36 No matter what your personal view is, that's all I had to say.
0:50:40 Thank you, Jesse.
0:50:41 Go ahead.
0:50:45 I see you waiting.
0:50:46 Thank you.
0:50:47 Hi, my name is Lisa Copeland and I live here in Twin Pills.
0:50:50 I just have a couple things I want to say and I'm actually very shy, so this is hard for
0:50:54 me.
0:50:55 First, I just wanted to know why it took two weeks to arrest the kids.
0:51:02 We cannot answer your questions, but they will record them over there.
0:51:05 Perfect.
0:51:06 I would like to address.
0:51:08 The second thing is that people are concerned about there being misinformation out there.
0:51:13 There needs to be transparency between our government, our police departments, and the
0:51:19 public needs to be informed.
0:51:22 Things like this that add a hand, it's based on truth in the beginning and it expands because
0:51:28 nobody tells us anything.
0:51:33 That's a concern.
0:51:34 That's a concern for every parent out there.
0:51:35 This should never have been kept secret.
0:51:39 And that's all I have.
0:51:40 Thank you.
0:51:41 Thank you for coming tonight.
0:51:42 Is there anyone else who would like to address the council?
0:51:45 Actually, I had a question for him.
0:51:48 Okay.
0:51:49 If you address it towards the council, we'll record it and then the answers will be given
0:51:51 back to you.
0:51:52 If you could just tell us your name and what city you live in.
0:51:55 My name is Sarah Comer.
0:51:56 I live here.
0:51:57 Well, I live in Filer.
0:51:58 Okay.
0:51:59 Thank you.
0:52:00 And I was wondering why he thought it was okay to phrase it that those boys were simply acting
0:52:04 out. That is a very bad way to phrase that. He did say that in his speech. He said that
0:52:11 in his speech. He said that they were acting out. Okay. That is not acting out. That is
0:52:15 violence. That is wrong. Thank you. Is there anyone else? Hi. Hi there. My name is Davis
0:52:27 Odell. I am a 12-year-old student. Many people are actually becoming very familiar
0:52:33 with my name. There's a lot of things. You pull it up. There you go. You'll have to hold it.
0:52:42 Yeah, sorry. So a lot of concerns have been addressed. However, the reason this whole thing
0:52:50 started was one bad news article. We stated that there was an alleged rate and it was sealed,
0:52:59 no details. My kids go to these schools. What happens to these kids is more important than
0:53:06 you guys know. If they are punished with counseling, they're still going to be in our schools. If
0:53:15 it's simple as house arrest, they're going to be in our schools. They haven't been able
0:53:21 to assimilate with our culture. That's fine. Send them to jail for 60 days and they're going
0:53:27 to come out rehabilitated? I'm sorry, they're not. We need to know what's going on with this
0:53:33 case. We don't need their names. That's not what we're asking for. We are asking for transparency
0:53:40 and whether we need to know, because quite frankly, if you don't tell us what their punishment
0:53:47 is, we're going to have a town full of fear. Our schools are going to shut down. That's not
0:53:54 what we want. We're not racist. We're not bigots. We want what's right for our kids. So I hope
0:54:01 you can all respect that. I didn't start this to be a racist or, you know, granted, Muslim
0:54:08 isn't a race. It's a religion. But we need to understand what the implications are of
0:54:14 this. It's going to continue. Whether it's by kids or somebody else. We need to know.
0:54:22 Thank you for your concern. I just want to remind you that the case was sealed from a judicial
0:54:26 branch and not from us, and we're under the same court orders as any other citizen.
0:54:32 We are allowed to know what you're allowed to know, and as a counsel, we're not above
0:54:38 the law either. We cannot step above when a judge seals a case. Travis?
0:54:44 So Chief King's very is going to kind of talk about the process and where maybe just to
0:54:50 can again clarify where we're at in that judicial process and to share what
0:54:56 possible next steps would look like. Thank you. I understand that. It is not
0:55:05 necessarily that we want every detail as to what happened to this child. I understand.
0:55:09 You know, I understand the police force. I actually was a post-student. I understand
0:55:16 process but you know don't allow the media to post something that's going to
0:55:23 cause so much problems without giving the rest of the information. I understand
0:55:29 your concerns. Thank you for sharing with us tonight. At this time we're gonna let
0:55:32 Chief Kingsbury come back up. Vice mayor council and again members of the
0:55:40 community want to address two issues number one on the procedurally what
0:55:45 happens in a case like this. So as I mentioned earlier, the juvenile suspects are currently
0:55:52 in custody at the juvenile detention center. They will then have a day in court, in juvenile
0:55:59 court, it's not like adult court, I'm sorry I'm trying to look back here, but-
0:56:04 If you want to pull the microphone around and address, I think that's perfectly appropriate.
0:56:10 It's okay.
0:56:11 That's okay, get what you can get.
0:56:14 So, for everybody, when a juvenile case, such as these, the juvenile defendants, they don't
0:56:22 have a trial by jury, like what those of us that are adults, like we would get.
0:56:29 They'll go before a judge, and in essence, it is a juvenile court version of a court trial.
0:56:38 The juvenile process is very different than the adult process.
0:56:43 So as to being able, I'm trying to look where the lady was, it was just speaking.
0:56:51 Okay, so to address your concerns, I told you to understand that.
0:56:57 Like I said earlier, I'm a parent and a grandparent as well, right?
0:57:02 But unfortunately, by law, there are a lot of things that we can't, as a police officer,
0:57:09 Police Department that we can't share with the community as to the disposition of juvenile
0:57:15 cases.
0:57:17 Sometimes certain juvenile cases get waived up into adult court and that's a discussion
0:57:25 that the prosecutor's office has with the judge and that's how that decision is made.
0:57:33 In our system of government, the police work, once we turn the case over and we turn it over
0:57:41 to the prosecutor, and as we said in this case the offenders are put into the detention center,
0:57:49 other than continuing to investigate if other allegations come up, the police department is
0:57:53 really out of it, as is, as I said earlier, the city council.
0:57:58 So that becomes a question that we might take up with our prosecutor if you have questions
0:58:04 as to the status and he will know whether or not he can release that information.
0:58:09 I understand your need for protection.
0:58:12 Oftentimes if these type of offenders, and I'm not talking about in this case because I
0:58:16 don't know how this is going to, what the end result is, right, but oftentimes in these types
0:58:20 of cases, juveniles that are released into the community are put on severe probation, our
0:58:27 Our school resource officers who work in the schools know who they are, and we're able to monitor them that way and work with juvenile probation.
0:58:37 I also wanted to address the young lady that said I said that they were acting out.
0:58:44 That, oh, there you are, thank you.
0:58:46 I would know a way, and if I said that, I'm just going to apologize this whole community, because I wouldn't say that.
0:58:53 I think what I meant.
0:58:54 talking about how cares, especially trained interviewers, that they interview sometimes
0:59:02 young offenders to make a determination as to why they do that.
0:59:07 Is there a reason?
0:59:08 Were they victims themselves?
0:59:10 Were they taught that by somebody else?
0:59:12 And what is that?
0:59:14 Why were they sexually inappropriate or whatever?
0:59:17 So that's part of the process.
0:59:19 So if I said that they were just, I really, from my heart, apologize.
0:59:23 I've worked way too many crimes like that, and I would never characterize Luden-Sivius
0:59:28 Conductor of the crime of rape as acting out.
0:59:31 It is a violent, heinous crime that I have for the last 26 years been involved in investigating
0:59:36 and bringing people to justice for.
0:59:38 So thank you for pointing that out to me, and I apologize to you in this community if
0:59:43 that's what I said.
0:59:44 So thank you.
0:59:45 I'm sorry, ma'am.
0:59:47 I can't have you speak from the…
0:59:49 Chief Senator.
0:59:50 from there. You've already had your
0:59:56 excuse me, ma'am, you have to follow
1:00:01 our form of government here and it's my turn to speak right now. Give me just a minute.
1:00:04 I'm going to allow you to ask your question, but you have to understand that we allow you one turn when you come to our city council meetings.
1:00:11 There's a lot of people here to talk, so if you will nicely, okay, if you nicely ask your question, it'll be recorded and then leave your name and email address here and they will respond to you.
1:00:20 respond to you.
1:00:21 You might know this better than I.
1:00:24 They are going to go before a judge.
1:00:27 These are people from other countries.
1:00:29 Are they going to be treated like Americans and punished?
1:00:32 Are we going to cow down like a lot of us do here in America because we're supposed
1:00:37 to be scared, which we're not?
1:00:40 Are they going to be treated as Americans here in America?
1:00:44 Are we going to say they're not Americans, you know?
1:00:50 do you know how this is going to play out?
1:00:56 Thank you for the question, ma'am.
1:00:58 Again, I don't like this trying to turn around.
1:01:00 To answer your question, first of all, no.
1:01:02 I don't know how this is going to end up.
1:01:04 But I will tell you, this is We Are In America.
1:01:06 This is the American judicial system.
1:01:08 That's the system that these offenders were put into.
1:01:15 Thank you, Chief.
1:01:16 Is there anybody else who has not spoke yet who would like to?
1:01:21 First off, I'm really nervous, so I'm sorry.
1:01:23 We'll take it easy on you.
1:01:24 OK.
1:01:24 My name is Kari Colver, and I'm a Twin Falls County resident.
1:01:27 My concern is that I, after watching last the 13th council meeting, I think you guys are
1:01:35 kind of confused on who you represent, to be completely honest.
1:01:39 I was offended by that, and I wasn't even here.
1:01:41 For those people that were, secondly, today is the 20th.
1:01:47 What we were discussing took place on the second.
1:01:49 If the community would have been addressed, all these rumors, all the anger, all the hatred,
1:01:56 never would have got this out of hand.
1:01:58 I'm not saying there wouldn't have been people, but it would have been handled better.
1:02:02 There is no reason why the community should have went 18 days without knowing something.
1:02:06 I have a little boy who's about to turn four and a little girl who is two and I am terrified.
1:02:12 I've been deployed to Iraq, and this is something that would happen there, and it makes me heartbroken
1:02:18 for that little girl and it makes me sad that nobody in the community knew to embrace
1:02:22 that family and to pray for that family and to help that family any way that we knew how
1:02:27 raising money, showing them protection, showing them love, showing them that they weren't alone
1:02:31 because they are not alone at all.
1:02:34 And I feel like they really think they are and that's sad.
1:02:37 And I just want all of you to remember me, to remember everybody that is here.
1:02:43 I can leave this place today with respect for you guys.
1:02:46 On voting time, if this doesn't change and we are not represented as a community, I will
1:02:52 not vote for any of you.
1:02:54 None of you.
1:02:55 And I'm sorry for that family.
1:02:58 And I want to say thank you to the Twin Falls PD as well.
1:03:00 I'm not one of those that's hanging on them.
1:03:02 And I want to know, and this is a question, who holds district attorney lokes accountable?
1:03:08 Nobody?
1:03:09 There's nobody?
1:03:10 That's his boss?
1:03:11 Ma'am, I'm sorry.
1:03:12 I don't know who answered that for you.
1:03:13 is an elected official, so it would be the citizens and the people that voted for him that would hold him accountable.
1:03:20 There's nobody above him though, is that who?
1:03:24 I have, I don't know.
1:03:26 Well then, can somebody get me an answer for that when they get a chance and I will write down my information?
1:03:31 So, in Idaho, we have a county prosecutor system.
1:03:35 Each of the individual counties, prosecutors are their own individual elected head.
1:03:42 They don't play a subordinate role to another group of or body.
1:03:51 And so, prosecutor Loeb's, his direct boss, if you will, would be the citizens and
1:04:01 the voters of Twin Falls County.
1:04:04 Okay, that's perfect.
1:04:05 So citizens in Twin Falls County, please know that you are his boss.
1:04:10 Please know if this is not handled.
1:04:12 We can handle it, and we are his boss.
1:04:15 He works for us.
1:04:17 And again, to the Twin Falls PD, thank you to you guys.
1:04:21 Thank you if you can do your jobs and represent us.
1:04:24 We would greatly appreciate it.
1:04:27 I am a Christian and I don't try to hate anybody,
1:04:29 but this is really scary,
1:04:31 and this is really sad for our community.
1:04:33 I am sincere about that,
1:04:35 but thank you guys for hearing me out.
1:04:38 Thank you for coming and I just want to let you know on behalf of the City Council that
1:04:43 we learn as we progress to there isn't like a class you take to be prepared for this job
1:04:49 and this is a new situation for each and every one of us that we have to work through and from
1:04:55 our perspective we could have probably done things differently and we now know in the future and
1:05:01 I know that doesn't fix the miscommunication that's been out there but please know that
1:05:06 We are aware we understand that our citizens are looking to us for that information and we are
1:05:13 working on becoming better at what we do all the time to.
1:05:16 I think that is all the community can ask is live and learn and represent us please.
1:05:22 Okay and Greg Lanting. Well again my old government teacher coming out I want to make
1:05:26 sure you're aware that if you live in Twin Falls County we don't actually represent you
1:05:30 and you don't vote on us. Okay we represent the city of Twin Falls and the citizens
1:05:36 of the city of Twin Falls and that's who votes on us.
1:05:39 So just my government teacher coming out, I'm sorry.
1:05:41 No, that's why I said the city of Twin Falls.
1:05:43 So we do vote on you.
1:05:43 Yes, you do.
1:05:44 Oh, I thought you said you were a Twin Falls scam.
1:05:46 Oh, yes, my citizen is an officer.
1:05:48 OK, I apologize.
1:05:49 I'll wear my right.
1:05:50 Thank you.
1:05:51 I thought you said you were out in the county.
1:05:52 No, I paid attention in school.
1:05:54 Thank you.
1:05:55 Thank you.
1:05:58 Welcome.
1:05:59 My name is Jeanette, and I do live in Twin Falls.
1:06:02 Jeanette, could I get your last name, please?
1:06:04 Sorry, yours.
1:06:05 Thank you.
1:06:06 There's just a couple of things I want to say, and I'm also a little bit nervous, so be
1:06:11 nice.
1:06:12 We will.
1:06:13 So I've checked into Grant Loeb and how we can, we need to get, sorry, about 7,600 signatures
1:06:24 to recall Grant Loeb.
1:06:27 I checked into that today.
1:06:30 And I just want to make a comment that the things that I've been reading, it seems
1:06:36 to me that he focuses a lot on the fact that these kids are not Syrian. I don't care what
1:06:47 these kids are. And I don't think anybody else cares. And it would be just as bad if
1:06:54 they were American kids. So who cares really what nationality that they are. They just
1:07:03 need be held accountable and we should have known about this way before the information
1:07:10 got out.
1:07:12 And if anybody would like to pursue the recall of grant load, I'll help you out.
1:07:20 Thank you.
1:07:21 Thank you for coming.
1:07:23 Greg Lanting.
1:07:24 Again, my government teams are coming out.
1:07:27 We need 7,600 signatures to get it on a ballot that the 7,600 would not actually recall him.
1:07:35 Then he would go and everyone in the county would have a chance to vote.
1:07:39 Okay, just want to make sure you're interested.
1:07:42 But thank you.
1:07:43 I didn't understand that but it's a start.
1:07:47 Thank you very much.
1:07:49 Is there anyone else in the community that would like to address the council tonight?
1:07:56 Last chance.
1:07:57 If you want to speak, just come forward.
1:08:02 Please tell us your name and what city you live in.
1:08:08 My name's Eric Odell, Twin Falls.
1:08:11 I really hadn't intended on speaking,
1:08:13 but I saw so much that just didn't get said at all.
1:08:18 I mean, first, our law enforcement officers,
1:08:21 they protect everybody 24-7.
1:08:23 Every time they put that badge on,
1:08:25 they're risking their lives for us.
1:08:28 So that can't be forgotten, right?
1:08:30 Everybody has so much that they can do.
1:08:33 Now, with this issue with the immigrants,
1:08:38 everybody's targeting all of the immigrants,
1:08:40 not all of the immigrants are bad.
1:08:43 I worked at Shobani for a while.
1:08:46 I was made lead over one of the shifts,
1:08:48 and I had almost 150 Muslims under me.
1:08:52 The majority of them were beautiful people,
1:08:54 they were awesome, they were just so caring and loving,
1:08:56 and I did meet some of them that were just pure evil.
1:09:00 not all. Some of them were just absolutely amazing and scared and just grateful to be
1:09:07 here. Not all. I had some that I didn't even threaten to cut my head off. Just some of
1:09:15 them were scared. Those are the ones that don't need to be here. The ones that want to
1:09:20 assimilate, want to be part of us. Part of Twin Falls are the ones that deserve to be
1:09:25 here. Not the ones that ruin it for the rest of them that actually deserve it. We need
1:09:30 something better to vet, something better, not let the federal government do it for us,
1:09:38 but where we can do it ourselves, pick the ones who deserve a second chance, who deserve
1:09:45 to be away from this.
1:09:49 And as the issue of the schools, Mike, I don't care who they are, we had a recent incident
1:09:56 of Americans that did this to an immigrant.
1:10:02 My kids are going to school with any of these.
1:10:06 They, a resource officer can't keep track
1:10:09 of all these people, they don't know what's going on.
1:10:12 We can't have something in place
1:10:16 to be more prepared when it does happen.
1:10:19 We have to prevent from happening.
1:10:23 We cannot allow this, well we've done all this
1:10:25 to, you know, so when something does happen, we're ready to act.
1:10:29 Why not prevent?
1:10:33 Thanks.
1:10:34 Thank you.
1:10:40 This will be the last call for anybody from the community
1:10:42 who would like to speak.
1:10:53 Welcome.
1:10:55 My name is Linda Rasmussen.
1:10:56 I live in Twin Falls.
1:10:57 And I'm just wondering why there were only two of these people
1:11:02 taken in to custody if they were more involved.
1:11:07 We can add that to the question if you want
1:11:08 leave your name and email over here, we can work on getting responses to those questions.
1:11:16 Is there anyone else?
1:11:17 Okay, at this time I'm going to close the public comment portion of this meeting and
1:11:25 we are going to move on to our agenda for our consent calendar and I would be willing
1:11:30 to take Council's wishes on that.
1:11:33 I move approval of the consent calendar as printed second we're going to hang on here
1:11:44 before we take a roll call vote on this if anybody wants to leave you're welcome to do
1:11:49 so if you want to stay we invite you to stay for the rest of our meeting we are going to
1:11:53 talk about our budget tonight there we go.
1:12:38 Okay, we have a motion on the floor to
1:13:49 To accept the consent calendar as presented by Greg Lanting and seconded by Don Hall.
1:13:55 And if there's no other discussion on that, Sharon roll call vote please.
1:14:00 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:14:02 Yes.
1:14:03 Nikki Boyd.
1:14:04 Yes.
1:14:05 Chris Hockington.
1:14:07 Yes.
1:14:07 Greg Lanting.
1:14:09 Don Hall.
1:14:10 Right there.
1:14:11 Yes.
1:14:12 Motion passes six to zero.
1:14:16 Okay, on to items for consideration.
1:14:18 The first thing is finally Gary Garnand.
1:14:21 We are going to consider the request to confirm the reappointment of Gary Garnand to the Twin
1:14:27 Falls Urban Renewal Agency Board.
1:14:30 And I think Gary, before we have you, we're going to let Mitch make his presentation first.
1:14:38 Well, it doesn't have all the weight.
1:14:50 It's not going to be playing the part of the mayor.
1:14:54 It's the mayor's appointment, or reappointment, to the Urban Renewal Agency.
1:15:00 I talked last week before he left and so I'm just gonna give his presentation for him.
1:15:05 Gary's only served a one-year term on the on the agency this time.
1:15:11 I think he was on there before for a good six years or so, but he served on a partial term
1:15:16 that was left with one of the former board members resigned and moved out of the community.
1:15:21 And so he's eligible for two full terms at this point and is requesting to be reappointed
1:15:27 to one of those, the mayor and the liaison hall,
1:15:31 and the chairman of the committee
1:15:33 was just in Brazil in those three kind of chatted
1:15:35 and feel like it would be appropriate
1:15:37 to reappoint carry to a three-year term
1:15:40 that would start on July 1st
1:15:42 and go through June 30th of 2019.
1:15:46 So with that, I'm just gonna pitch that out there
1:15:49 and we need a motion and vote of the council
1:15:51 to confirm the mayor's appointment.
1:15:53 Thank you, Mitch, Don Hall.
1:15:55 I would just concur with what Mitch just said.
1:15:58 Gary is an active, involved, and knowledgeable board member.
1:16:05 It has returned back to us, and it's very nice for him
1:16:08 to be back on this board.
1:16:10 And I, again, concur with this decision.
1:16:13 I'm ready to make the motion unless someone else
1:16:15 has a message.
1:16:17 Is that OK with you, Chris, if he makes the motion?
1:16:19 I thought that was a motion.
1:16:21 So moved.
1:16:23 I would make the motion that we reappoint Gary Garnan
1:16:27 to the Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency
1:16:30 for another three-year term starting July 1st
1:16:33 and potentially ending in June of 2019.
1:16:38 Second.
1:16:41 Chris Talkington?
1:16:42 Well, I won't second all third at then.
1:16:45 Gary and I worked together on setting up a bank
1:16:47 in downtown Twin Falls and we put personal money
1:16:50 into rebuilding Shoshone and Main Street.
1:16:54 I think he's shown by his action that he has the best interest of the downtown area and
1:17:00 as a result of that certainly the urban renewal project so with just some amount of hesitation
1:17:05 all thirded.
1:17:06 Okay.
1:17:07 I'm sorry Greg, before I call on you I just want to go back and make sure that we know
1:17:11 that there is a motion on the floor by Don Hall and seconded by Ruth Pierce and now thirded
1:17:15 by Chris and thirded and now you're up Greg.
1:17:19 Well, I would like to concur in your area work closely with him on both of those my time as mayor and also
1:17:27 I was liaison to the urban billboard and he certainly brings knowledge
1:17:31 I remember specific questions of being able to
1:17:36 Directed to him during the Chibani or the clay. Yes, it's actually the cliff bar a recruitment
1:17:42 He had information about trucking that the rest of us playing this plane didn't have until paying a plus five
1:17:48 except through that the whole part of the meeting,
1:17:51 the graciously waiting for us to confirm him,
1:17:53 so I will definitely be voting for confirm.
1:17:56 Thank you.
1:17:58 Sharon Roll, call vote.
1:18:00 Nicky Boyd, yes.
1:18:02 Chris Tockington, Greg Lanting, Don Hall,
1:18:06 Ruth Pierce, Suzanne Hawkins.
1:18:09 Yes.
1:18:09 Gary, now it's your turn to address the council.
1:18:12 Welcome and congratulations.
1:18:14 Thank you very much.
1:18:16 I'm a little flattered by the accolades, I'm not sure I deserve them, but thank you very much for all of them, even you, Mitch.
1:18:24 I just want to thank you for giving me the opportunity to give back a little bit to a community that's been pretty good to me.
1:18:33 And I admire each of you for taking the steps you have taken to serve our community, and in my small way I appreciate being given this opportunity.
1:18:45 Thank you.
1:18:46 Thank you so much for your service.
1:18:53 Okay, I'm just gonna pull the council real quick.
1:18:55 The next item on our agenda is a presentation
1:18:58 from Sean Stanley on Code Enforcement Practices and Policies,
1:19:01 and this can take 15-ish minutes,
1:19:03 and I don't know if you need a break before we move on,
1:19:05 or is everybody good to go?
1:19:08 Sean Stanley.
1:19:13 Thank you, Vice Mayor and Council.
1:19:17 The reason this is on the agenda tonight,
1:19:18 I just kinda wanted to update the council on our practices
1:19:21 and policies where we're out in the field,
1:19:24 ensuring the quality of life for our citizens and the people that visit Twin Falls.
1:19:31 Code enforcement is derived to three employees, Woody Colan and Carolyn Palmer and myself.
1:19:39 Carolyn Palmer is here from about March 1st till Thanksgiving.
1:19:45 So she's here for the busy, busy time in Code enforcement.
1:19:49 We have split up the city into three zones.
1:19:54 Each one of us have a zone, although here lately we've been in each other's zones all
1:20:00 the time.
1:20:04 Code enforcement is more about ensuring the quality of life per citizens.
1:20:09 And quality of life issues has a very broad range, whether it's a parking dog at 2pm in
1:20:17 the afternoon that's keeping you awake, whether it's a site obstruction that is on the route
1:20:26 you take to and from work every day, whether it's a sidewalk obstruction, and I've put together
1:20:31 a little presentation here. I know a couple of you have seen this, a new council orientation,
1:20:36 but I made another copy anyway. There's a numbers on here from fiscal year 2015, so I do have
1:20:44 of updated numbers from October 1, 2015 till this morning.
1:20:50 So I'll go ahead.
1:20:51 Thank you.
1:20:57 Always so prepared.
1:21:00 Always so prepared.
1:21:13 So the enforcement categories that we enforce are up here.
1:21:18 Title 3, we help Sharon enforce our mobile food vendors
1:21:23 on some business regulations.
1:21:25 Title 4, we do assist the building department
1:21:28 with abandoned buildings, unsafe buildings.
1:21:34 If you remember one on Addison Avenue East
1:21:36 across from Pizza Hut that is no longer there,
1:21:40 we were very excited to see that disappear.
1:21:44 Title six public safety,
1:21:46 that is mostly city code 652,
1:21:50 which includes furniture and driveways,
1:21:54 non-operating vehicles, dismantle vehicles,
1:21:57 things of that nature.
1:21:59 Title seven is our weeds, grass, rubbish, water conservation.
1:22:05 It's also in that title.
1:22:07 Public ways and property.
1:22:10 Title eight, that is right-of-way trees, vegetation,
1:22:15 encroachment, things of that nature.
1:22:18 Traffic regulations, that's our abandoned vehicles, which also
1:22:22 includes downtown parking enforcement.
1:22:25 And then we also assist zoning with Title 10,
1:22:29 which is all zoning stuff, and that also includes
1:22:31 the area of impact at this time.
1:22:36 Most common inspections, I would say this time of year,
1:22:40 is probably weeds and water conservation,
1:22:44 although we're fairly busy with every one
1:22:47 of those violations up there.
1:22:52 So I just wanna walk through some of our most important ones,
1:22:57 fiscal year 2015, sidewalk constructions,
1:23:02 You can see in the pictures there.
1:23:03 I don't believe people actually know they're doing this,
1:23:06 but they do.
1:23:07 And we do get complaints on this on a daily basis.
1:23:11 We don't go out looking for these things.
1:23:13 These are complaint type basis.
1:23:16 122 in 2015, so far this year since October 1, we've had 35.
1:23:25 Animal permits required.
1:23:28 Everybody who chooses to have an animal,
1:23:32 except for dogs and cats in Twin Falls,
1:23:34 They have to obtain an animal permit.
1:23:37 We had 16 last year that did not know that.
1:23:40 We currently have had 21 since October,
1:23:46 and we also managed 49 animal permits at this time.
1:23:49 So we do issue the permits, make sure
1:23:52 where they're keeping this efficient.
1:23:57 City code 652, this is a tough one.
1:24:02 It takes quite a long time to get these resolved,
1:24:05 but we do get them resolved.
1:24:07 We give people anywhere from, in these cases here,
1:24:12 30 days to get them resolved.
1:24:14 We don't expect that to happen overnight.
1:24:17 And we do get a lot of help from our city youth council.
1:24:22 The third picture from the right,
1:24:24 our city youth council cleaned that up.
1:24:29 And we've got some Boy Scout groups that also pitch in.
1:24:32 And if we have to, we will roll up our sleeves
1:24:35 and help as well.
1:24:37 Currently, since October, we have 353
1:24:40 of those? How about that third picture? Is that actually Twin Falls? What's that? The third
1:24:48 picture is from Twin Falls City. Yes, sir. Yes. This one has come up in the last couple
1:24:59 years. We don't go out looking for these. In fact, I talked to you, talked to Woody in
1:25:04 Carolina today. We don't know what day is our garbage day. So we can't, we don't go around
1:25:10 looking for these, but people call in and complain about this all the time. We have citizens
1:25:15 that do not like to drive down their road and look at garbage cans.
1:25:20 So we had 198 complaints of this last year.
1:25:25 We're up to 33 this year since October.
1:25:33 The next one, this is a busy time of year for this.
1:25:38 Last year, 2,551 cases this year were up to 1,588.
1:25:48 And I would say about a 90% success rate.
1:25:50 We do give people the opportunity to take care of this voluntarily.
1:25:57 Sometimes they don't.
1:25:59 Our code has some teeth in it to help us out with that.
1:26:06 This doesn't happen very often, but we do have a lot of fire hydrants that get covered
1:26:11 up.
1:26:12 The adjoining property owners are responsible to keep a three foot clearance around those.
1:26:16 This also includes water meters.
1:26:18 We get a lot of people that like to park on water meters and our meter readers can't
1:26:23 So we are out all the time, there might be people of that.
1:26:27 We've had 15 of those this year. Water conservation, we don't have to go out very far to find this.
1:26:39 And 491 last year, we're up to 207 this year.
1:26:46 It's most of the time people are just not aware that they're watering on the wrong day or the wrong time.
1:26:57 Can I ask a question on that one?
1:26:59 Yes.
1:27:00 Is there a way to remind citizens from the city public service notice or something of what our
1:27:10 watering rules are because I know we've seen that come up recently in our emails as well.
1:27:14 Maybe it's just time for a general reminder.
1:27:17 I believe Bill and Josh have talked about it.
1:27:20 I know it's coming.
1:27:22 Also on the notices that we leave, we also print off their schedule for that particular address.
1:27:28 whether it's city water, potable water, or pressurized irrigation, they both have different
1:27:34 rules.
1:27:35 Right.
1:27:36 We also may print that out when we do stop and talk to them.
1:27:39 Thank you.
1:27:42 Great glanting.
1:27:43 John, I have taken this upon myself on many occasions.
1:27:47 I'm not sure how we do this, but there are areas in town where people are new that moved
1:27:53 into a house that's under pressure and irrigation.
1:27:56 And I think that if they water their lawn, they're going to end up having an additional bill, and they don't understand that they're already paying for that pressure adjudication.
1:28:06 Even if they use it, or don't use it, they made the same amount of money.
1:28:10 So, you know, in my girlfriend's neighborhood, I've talked to individuals about that, and they're always amazed.
1:28:17 I don't know if there's no way we can get that information out as well.
1:28:20 Well, if you're under pressure of irrigation,
1:28:22 there's no reason not to water your water.
1:28:26 If you're watering your lawn to save money,
1:28:27 it's not saving you any much.
1:28:29 Now, city water, yes, I'm sure it's standing there,
1:28:32 but if there's any way we can get that word out.
1:28:36 And we can try to include the same time.
1:28:38 Whatever it's, whether you go to weed,
1:28:40 because they just don't want to try to,
1:28:42 they're afraid of water, I'm not sure how to command my land.
1:28:46 I'm not suggesting I have a solution,
1:28:48 I'm just saying that I see that issue.
1:28:50 people move into new areas that they came from potable water and they moved
1:28:55 pressure in their dish water and they're afraid to use the permit water because they're afraid it's not the money in their water.
1:29:02 Sure. Yeah. We can include that in the same PSA.
1:29:08 Vegetation encroachment. Last year we had 86 cases. This year we took on a new
1:29:14 endeavor and we decided to help our street department and our engineering
1:29:18 Department, they are chip ceiling zone four this year, which I hope I get this right, is
1:29:24 from Addison to Falls and from Washington, North to Lulex.
1:29:32 So we went out in March and we have notified to this date, 165 people, that to ensure that
1:29:40 we can get our equipment through the streets, the trees need to be up 13 feet over the street,
1:29:46 And then seven foot over sidewalks to allow access to our sidewalks.
1:29:51 It's worked fairly well.
1:29:53 I think we have about 15 left that have not got it done, but they're working on it.
1:30:02 City code 968, this is our abandoned vehicles.
1:30:06 425 last year, we're 206 so far this year, not only abandoned vehicles,
1:30:13 but semi-parking and residential zones, things of that nature.
1:30:19 We do help out our police department when we're out there and we will tag a vehicle.
1:30:24 We will even notice on the door if we can find out who it belongs to and make them aware
1:30:29 that they need to move them.
1:30:35 Great, glanting.
1:30:36 First one of the few calls I've ever received at like 2 a.m.
1:30:39 in the morning and said it was a council member or somebody who I knew calling because the
1:30:44 police parked their truck outside their house and the reefer was running and it was right
1:30:47 outside their bedroom window so you can see a candy and it just went out of now.
1:30:51 and currently our city code allows that on private property I guess it would turn in
1:30:58 more to more of a noise disturbance but they are code on the street yeah
1:31:04 they do need to part the listening industrial zone obstruction division
1:31:16 at intersection howies and driveways we had 61 last year we're up to 21 this
1:31:21 year. These are mostly a complaint type basis and we get them all the time.
1:31:27 People travel the same route to and from work every day and they'll notify us.
1:31:33 Shawn, I've had people tell me that they don't want to complain. They don't want to feel like
1:31:39 they're being the neighborhood police, I guess. Is there a way to reassure people that this
1:31:47 is what you do and you do want to know and that it is helping the city by them,
1:31:51 Notifying you and that they're not going to be looked upon poorly for
1:31:55 Turning in these yeah, you know, we're not in the creating neighborhood disputes
1:32:00 So that information goes nowhere if they ask us if we've had a complaint. We'll see yes
1:32:05 We've had a complaint, but we don't give that information out and most the time
1:32:10 The anonymous ones that that's just what they are anonymous. Thank you. Yeah, so we do four smoke a lot of properties a
1:32:19 A lot of foreclosed homes, a lot of bank owned homes, a lot of vacant lots.
1:32:24 We were 151 last year, we're up to 48 this year since October 1.
1:32:30 This is only after we've done everything we can do to try to get it resolved.
1:32:36 And we have no other choice but the hire contractor and get it done.
1:32:40 And then the city gets their money back as we assess the property taxes in August.
1:32:45 So it does take us a couple years, but we do get it back.
1:32:48 So Title 10 is zoning and we do assist them in the City of Twin Falls and the area of impact at this time.
1:33:00 We do get called quite often about storage sheds too close to property lines.
1:33:07 And so we had seven this year, we're up to six this year, it's a spring type bill where everybody gets new shed and they just don't know where they're supposed to put them.
1:33:16 They're not supposed to be in the front yard, they're supposed to be the site of the house or the back and three foot down property lines.
1:33:22 Sean, do you ever get queries by people who have
1:33:28 restricted home covenants that have been violated,
1:33:32 but they're less restricted than the city ordinance.
1:33:35 They want you to step in and...
1:33:37 Yeah, we do get a lot of those phone calls.
1:33:39 And what is your response in that case?
1:33:41 Yeah, we just don't enforce homeowners associations or
1:33:45 covenances.
1:33:46 We just don't know that they need to get their own council or whatever they...
1:33:50 Yeah.
1:33:51 Okay.
1:33:52 Yeah, we just answer that by and if it's a city code,
1:33:55 we'll gladly come out and take a look.
1:34:01 10, 7, 16, people occupying RVs on residential lots.
1:34:07 31 last year, we're up to eight this year.
1:34:12 Once again, it's not the people that come in
1:34:14 and spend a weekend with their family.
1:34:18 It's people that are definitely occupying the properties
1:34:22 and they're hooked up to water.
1:34:24 They're hooked up to electrical services and we've had quite a few that have chosen to put their sewer where it shouldn't be, so that's the reason we have that code.
1:34:41 Signs, I know you all know about signs in the City of Twin Falls.
1:34:45 Signs are not permitted in the right-of-way except if it's an open house sign and they have to leave clearance on the sidewalk.
1:34:56 We get a lot of these, especially yard sale time, see by the next one.
1:35:01 We get a lot of people that want to get the most they can after their advertisement and put them out on the road.
1:35:07 We choose to just pick them up, get them out of the way, make it safe.
1:35:13 And if they want them back, they can come and get them, but they don't.
1:35:17 You don't, you don't have many.
1:35:20 Surprise, surprise.
1:35:25 And then we do get a lot of calls for people operating businesses in residential zones.
1:35:30 That one on the left is the same one.
1:35:32 That was a heating and air conditioning business.
1:35:39 The one on the right was a recycling business that was in the area of impact, but it wasn't a residential property.
1:35:46 I don't have a number on how many of those we get.
1:35:48 I'd say maybe a dozen a year.
1:35:51 So yeah, just wanted to bring you up to speed with what we've been doing with our time.
1:35:57 If there's any more questions, I'd be glad to answer any questions.
1:36:02 Chris talking to you back on the noxis weeds or weeds that need cut.
1:36:07 I think it's legitimate to start getting concerned when we have weeds
1:36:11 that are already going to see going to occupied areas.
1:36:16 Is there a certain time that you've or do you do it by the weed type of sand?
1:36:21 This has got to be cut.
1:36:23 I know it varies from year.
1:36:25 You could have an early bloom and a late bloom, but I think that one
1:36:28 of our goals could be to try to minimize the contamination factor for spreading seed.
1:36:33 Yeah, typically the sprayers that we hire to spray our city properties, they like to spray
1:36:41 them on Memorial Day, the 4th of July, and Labor Day.
1:36:46 Now I know there's a lot of weeds out there that have already went to bloom, come Memorial
1:36:49 Day.
1:36:51 Most of the time it's not the noxious weeds, it's the kosha, all the weeds that are not
1:36:57 on the noxious weed list.
1:37:00 You know, we have one that's started to germinate right now
1:37:02 called puncture vine.
1:37:04 Go ahead.
1:37:05 I know everybody knows about that.
1:37:06 It's kind of get rid of it.
1:37:10 So there's a difference between obnoxious and obnoxious weed.
1:37:14 Correct.
1:37:15 Sometimes the same.
1:37:17 Don Hall.
1:37:19 This is probably just more of a comment.
1:37:21 I know that we received several members of the council
1:37:24 receive e-mail regarding water conservation and the time of day and all those kind of
1:37:29 dynamics.
1:37:30 And I'd just like to maybe just make a comment.
1:37:33 I'd like to revisit the actual ordinance about that.
1:37:37 And the science behind it, this gentleman had charts and pie graphs and tell them when
1:37:41 the best time to water and the worst time to water and all those dynamics.
1:37:46 So I'd probably just say it more as a matter of fact to spur some conversation later on.
1:37:51 would you open the door with your page on water conservation?
1:37:54 So thank you.
1:37:56 Travis?
1:37:57 So we have taken the information,
1:37:59 and we've forwarded on to the members of our water team,
1:38:01 and they've started to go through the gentleman's information
1:38:07 that he provided.
1:38:08 We're also comparing that to information
1:38:10 that we have from our sources.
1:38:12 And we intend to provide a response
1:38:17 so that the council is aware of what that is.
1:38:20 we can do that by email so that you can respond to the individual directly or we can also do
1:38:24 that through a process of, you know, formal city council, you know, presentation and action.
1:38:35 I'd kind of like to see it come in front of the city council. I'd like to see the signs
1:38:39 behind the hours and all those dynamics to, I'm a big advocate to look at processes and
1:38:45 procedures of any government organization to ensure that we're staying on top of what's
1:38:51 current and if there's better hours to water than what we say you can water as
1:38:56 far as evaporation and water conservation then I think it'd be nice to know that.
1:39:00 Yeah. Thank you Sean I do not see any other lights on at this time. Thank you.
1:39:07 Thank you for the information. Oh one more. I guess no I want to compliment you've got
1:39:12 you've got the damn toughest job in Twin Falls especially this time of year my
1:39:16 hats off to you. Thank you. Thank you. Next item on our agenda is a present
1:39:23 Presentation regarding the city's progress on our 2017 budget preparation
1:39:29 So if the council wants to take like a five-minute recess while I kind of look up the technology that would be
1:39:36 Five minute break we're recessed
1:39:41 Council and at this time we are going to have our city manager Travis Rothweiler
1:39:47 Give us an update on the 2017 budget preparation
1:39:51 Man and vice mayor members of the city council
1:39:53 Tonight is the fourth, believe it or not, it is already the fourth conversation that we've
1:40:01 had about the fiscal year budget.
1:40:04 We had a conversation presented to us that kicked it all off with the long term committee
1:40:12 that kind of came forward.
1:40:15 After I shared the city manager's recommendation, the council has given the opportunity to provide
1:40:20 their thoughts and reactions to what was presented by the long-term planning committee.
1:40:25 And then tonight is just one last check-in.
1:40:28 Our final check-in before we go back and we begin those processes of publishing the budget.
1:40:33 But before we do, before we put that ink to paper, we want to check in with the council,
1:40:37 we want to make sure that we've covered all of those priorities that you thought were important
1:40:42 and to be able to make sure that what we're doing is well understood and has general support.
1:40:50 Now, that doesn't mean that you don't reserve the right to debate and discuss and to bet
1:40:56 as we continue to move through that entire process and we'll talk about what that schedule looks
1:41:00 like as we kind of move forward through this tonight.
1:41:06 The information that we have is going to be very general.
1:41:13 So what's important right now is that at this point in time, we are still working through
1:41:18 to understand what the city's new construction number is going to be.
1:41:23 That number will be provided to us by the county assessor and after that the county will provide
1:41:28 to us the total taxable value.
1:41:30 So at this point in time, we also can't be in a position to even guess about what the
1:41:35 tax rate might be inside the City of Twin Falls.
1:41:38 And as I have shared with you, many times in the past, we're not really good at predicting
1:41:45 that because of how that total taxable number seems to change and ebb and flow as we go through
1:41:51 our process.
1:41:52 So tonight what we want to do is we want to talk about the priorities, we want to talk
1:41:56 about what we view right now the current level of expenditure will be and we have some
1:42:03 general idea of impact potentially on rates when it comes to those utility rates but not
1:42:09 at this point on property taxes but we will talk generally about that.
1:42:15 Everything that we do inside the city of Twin Falls is based upon the strategic plan and we
1:42:20 took some liberties earlier this year to kind of really reflect that everything inside of
1:42:25 our organization, everything that we do, all the services that we provide are driven and
1:42:31 delivered by the employees of the City of Twin Falls.
1:42:36 At this point in time, all of those services require a human connection to be able to deliver
1:42:43 that all the way to the end of our customers.
1:42:46 We really believe that this year, as we have shared with you many other times, this year
1:42:51 we need to really spend concentrated time on our internal organization, recognizing that
1:42:57 that is going to help us accomplish the other seven vision areas of our strategic plan.
1:43:04 All of those equal a full collection of the vision that we hope to accomplish by the year
1:43:09 2030, and as we complete this year's budgeting process, we will then begin to roll into an
1:43:16 update of the City Strategic Plan. So we will begin that process this fall and then we'll
1:43:22 use that and other data to help us create the long-term planning goals, groups, goals and
1:43:30 visions as we look forward actually to use that to create and offset the fiscal year 2018
1:43:35 budget. So generally at Budget Overview, what are we looking at when we're moving forward?
1:43:43 We want to make sure that our budget is implementing our strategic plan and then all of the other
1:43:48 corresponding plans that we have attached to it.
1:43:51 It's going to be our water plan, our facility plan, our parks and recreation master plan,
1:43:56 our comprehensive plan which is nearing that completion of that update and then also that
1:44:01 transportation plan that we will begin later this year.
1:44:06 We want to set a budget that is very cognizant of the environment in which we're operating.
1:44:13 We want to be sensitive to tax rates and tax adjustments.
1:44:17 We want to be sensitive to utility rates not only in this fiscal year but also what is
1:44:23 it going to be in upcoming years because we want to make sure that we are setting a sustainable
1:44:27 course of action moving forward.
1:44:30 We want to make sure that we are focusing this year on employee compensation, development,
1:44:35 training. One of the things that we have found is that at 3.1% unemployment, we are having
1:44:43 a difficult time finding the number of people and qualified applicants to come and apply
1:44:52 for jobs in our organization and while compensation is not all things, we do believe that it is
1:45:00 is part of the equation that we need to continue to look at.
1:45:04 Additionally, what's also important is, I think,
1:45:06 is we've talked about there's a demographics issue where
1:45:10 the size of the Generation X group is about 50% less
1:45:17 than the millennials and the baby boomers on the book end.
1:45:20 Both the baby boomers and the millennials
1:45:22 have roughly 75 million people associated
1:45:26 with that generation while Generation X is somewhere around $49 million, $49 million.
1:45:35 There is fewer people entering into specialized areas into the workforce, especially when we
1:45:41 look at the areas of law enforcement and certifications.
1:45:46 It is really becoming a simple economics question about supply and demand.
1:45:53 In order to be able to continue to attract, retain, and recruit, we have to make sure that
1:45:58 our compensation system competes with those who are routinely taking individuals from
1:46:03 our organization.
1:46:05 We also need to make sure that we're keeping up with our infrastructure.
1:46:08 This Council and past Councils has worked really hard over the course of the last several
1:46:13 years investing more money into our systems, into our facilities, into our roadways, into
1:46:19 our water and sewer systems.
1:46:22 We plan on continuing to do that as you will see that we are maintaining funding in those
1:46:27 areas and in some cases even increasing funding to address some of the Council priorities moving
1:46:32 forward.
1:46:33 Then we also wanted to make sure that we're providing the types, the level and the levels
1:46:38 of services that are wanted and desired and anticipated by our citizens and reusing the
1:46:44 National Citizen Survey to help guide some of that.
1:46:47 We had earlier hope to make that as a part of a presentation this evening to kind of have
1:46:52 them go hand in glove, but in light of the length of the meeting and we thank the council
1:46:58 for allowing us to defer that until next week.
1:47:01 But that will be an integral part of how we continue to move forward.
1:47:05 The citizen's sentiment when it comes to service delivery does have a direct connection to
1:47:12 the budget and we want to make sure that the council and the community have a full understanding
1:47:17 of how our citizens feel we operate and then also try to find strategies to address those
1:47:22 areas where we may fall a bit short to their expectations.
1:47:33 So just really quickly, this was the tax rate that we had over the course of the last year.
1:47:41 It may look slightly different, but again, this is because when we went through the urban
1:47:45 renewal issue, there was the monies that were assessed and provided to the value that
1:47:53 was not provided to the urban renewal agency, but it was provided to all the different
1:47:57 texting entities by a mathematical error from the assessor's office.
1:48:01 This is what that corrected sheet does look like, and you'll see that it was a 47 cent
1:48:07 increase.
1:48:08 Notice that the service areas where we focus on that average customer, again, an average
1:48:15 customer for us follows into that 18,000 gallons of water consumption.
1:48:22 They go to the maximum cap of sewer and they have curbside sanitation and recycling.
1:48:28 We will define that as our average customer, also an individual who is residing in a house
1:48:33 that meets the median value as according to the U.S. Census, in this place it was $144,000
1:48:42 last year. So this is kind of what we know right now. The total taxable value, which
1:48:49 is going to be the denominator. Sorry, he has a question on the next slide. Go ahead.
1:48:58 No, one more. Go one more. Okay. The total taxable value, remember, is the
1:49:07 It is the number that we need to help calculate that tax rate and at this point in time, that is not known.
1:49:14 But, however, as we kind of go through this process, we do know that we are going to be looking for 3% more revenue plus the value of the new construction.
1:49:24 And this also reflects what we are looking at the non-tax supported funds.
1:49:28 Those are going to be those enterprise type funds, the utility funds, and all of those funds that operate like an independent small business,
1:49:36 where they collect their funds and their fees, impact funds would be another example,
1:49:40 where they take those funds and they apply that specifically for them.
1:49:44 We're looking at total tax collections this year to be roughly $18,757,000.
1:49:51 That $860,000 represents 3%, and what we're estimating to be the new construction number right now,
1:49:58 which is about $40 million, and once we have the taxable value number
1:50:04 at the top, then we will be able to share with the council what we believe the anticipated
1:50:09 tax rate is going to be.
1:50:11 As we've always shared, the tax rate is not an indicator of tax load because it needs to
1:50:17 be multiplied against the property assessed value.
1:50:21 One of the things that we're noticing is that when the state legislature this year changed
1:50:28 the indexing to more of a flat rate on the homeowner's exemption, they moved it to a flat $100,000, and so that is going to have some implications on individuals in our city as we begin to look at their individual tax rates.
1:50:47 Just as we have in the past, we will put up the property tax calculator so that individuals, once we know that information, they will be able to go online and they'll be able to compute what those property taxes are.
1:50:57 Everything that we talk is the city's portion.
1:50:59 We have no control over the school district, the county,
1:51:02 or any of the other taxing entities.
1:51:04 So again, when we focus on our tax rate,
1:51:06 we focus only on that piece that is the city of Twin Falls.
1:51:10 Great planting.
1:51:14 I will be sure to say that I'm only getting
1:51:16 what they perceived as their increase in our tax load on it.
1:51:21 Some of it would have had to have been last year's tax load
1:51:23 because they were,
1:51:24 had one citizen that was complaining to me that they're,
1:51:26 and again, we only have a small portion of it.
1:51:28 And I also know that they took a huge increase in their
1:51:32 evaluation that was there 50 year and they went up by like
1:51:35 20 some percent or something on their house value.
1:51:40 That they're claiming their income to their property
1:51:43 taxes went up by $100 a month.
1:51:46 Now, whether that was included, their insurance went up as
1:51:49 well, you know, all the things that are in that, that
1:51:53 what do you call the party your escrow account, your
1:51:57 best of your account, but if some homes are being
1:52:02 able to be raised by as much as 20 to 25%,
1:52:05 I'm wondering what that new number might look like.
1:52:08 Because it didn't seem like it went up like we thought it
1:52:10 would last year.
1:52:11 Right.
1:52:12 And so what we're, and that's why we can't project the tax
1:52:16 rate.
1:52:16 We have no idea of understanding what that tax rate is until we
1:52:20 get the total taxable value of the city.
1:52:23 What you'll see right here is based upon the tax rate,
1:52:25 You'll notice that the average person inside the city of Twin Falls,
1:52:29 their total property tax and utility bill went up 47 cents.
1:52:34 Per month, right?
1:52:35 Per month.
1:52:38 Thank you.
1:52:39 Yeah.
1:52:39 So is the $100 a month possible?
1:52:44 Sure it is.
1:52:44 But it may have more to do with how the new assessment came in,
1:52:51 as opposed to the tax rate that was applied to those properties.
1:52:58 that went to the home show this weekend went to multiple houses talking to multiple builders.
1:53:05 I really tried to talk to the builders about what they were seeing and they said that their
1:53:10 costs are up like 20-25 percent of their, they can't, like a 1300 square house, they can't
1:53:17 build it for less than 165,000 now and things along that line. So they're seeing the value
1:53:24 going up in just the one of house costs.
1:53:26 So you would assume that the assessor
1:53:29 will catch up with that as well at some point.
1:53:31 Yeah, one of the things that's important to remember
1:53:32 is the assessed value and the sale value only
1:53:39 have a state lock connection that they have to be generally
1:53:43 within, I think it's 90% and 105% of the average selling
1:53:48 market for within that area.
1:53:52 Often times what you'll find is the assessed value is slightly less than what the sale value may be.
1:54:02 And it is on a five year rotation.
1:54:05 So every five years one of the things that you will find is that the assessor I believe by Idaho code does have to go out.
1:54:12 And they do have to go through a reassessment to ensure that your property is within those parameters.
1:54:18 And there's an appeals process that the county commissioners get to.
1:54:21 There is an appeal process.
1:54:29 So we will continue to highlight and illustrate this as we continue to move forward through
1:54:36 the process.
1:54:38 So I'm going to break this into three general segments.
1:54:43 We're going to break this into personnel.
1:54:45 We're going to break this into operations.
1:54:48 And then I'm also going to spend a little bit of time talking about capital projects that
1:54:51 we hope to move forward.
1:54:54 And you'll notice that I say provide up to, because everything right now is still in that
1:55:00 state of wanting to make sure that this budget does not tap into the foregone balance, that
1:55:06 it does not touch that, that reserves that, and locks that away.
1:55:09 So the budget that I am presenting will be based upon no more than the statutory allowed adjustments
1:55:17 that are afforded to you by the code.
1:55:23 So we're looking at up to a 5% adjustment
1:55:25 for all city employees who meet performance standards
1:55:29 and performance expectations.
1:55:31 We also wanna make sure that we continue to move that table.
1:55:36 And we wanna make sure that we're moving it
1:55:38 in a manner that allows for us to remain competitive.
1:55:43 And then we also have that compression ratio
1:55:45 to ensure that individuals are hitting those target points
1:55:49 within the 10 years that we believe that they should.
1:55:52 So for example, a person who is with us for five years,
1:55:55 we believe should be at market
1:55:57 because that is the standard definition of market
1:55:59 in the areas of compensation.
1:56:01 When we look at compensation, we look at full compensation.
1:56:04 So it's not only the rate of salary,
1:56:06 but it's also the component of benefits.
1:56:08 And we're looking at maintaining our current health insurance
1:56:11 benefits that are provided to our employees.
1:56:14 We received our renewal.
1:56:16 Our renewal this year is at 15%,
1:56:19 and we believe that that is something
1:56:21 that we can hold and adjust into this budget moving forward.
1:56:27 And then we're also going to continue
1:56:28 to evaluate positions on that case-by-case basis
1:56:31 to make sure that they're in place of a market position.
1:56:35 We want to make sure that all positions,
1:56:37 even though that they're classified
1:56:38 into a kinds and levels chart or a matrix or salary matrix,
1:56:42 We want to make sure that they fit and that they accurately represent the marketplace for
1:56:48 those positions.
1:56:50 As we shared earlier when we came forward to move the table with the mid-year adjustment,
1:56:55 that we're going to start that process and we've started that process having conversations
1:57:00 of looking at our current salary table and making sure that the positions are slotted
1:57:04 in those places appropriately, we hope that that will be part of this process as well.
1:57:13 For operation and maintenance, this is one of the areas that we really challenge members
1:57:19 of our team to take a look at their actual expenditures.
1:57:23 And so in operation and maintenance, you'll notice that there are reductions in every single
1:57:29 one of those budgets.
1:57:31 This is capital, right?
1:57:32 We didn't do an operation and maintenance budget.
1:57:34 So O&M is usually pretty boring.
1:57:37 It usually covers fuel, heats, lights, electricity, training.
1:57:41 We challenged each member of our team to take a look at their individual ONM budgets and each
1:57:46 of them rose to that challenge to make changes in reductions.
1:57:51 We're going to continue to look at that as we move forward.
1:57:54 We want to make sure that the costs that we say are for us to operate truly reflect the
1:58:00 cost of operations and we're going to continue to find opportunities I think in investigating
1:58:08 those dollars and those allocations and moving forward.
1:58:11 By reallocating dollars that make sense from operational line items that might be over-inflated,
1:58:17 we can move them into capital projects in compensation without negatively impacting the
1:58:25 tax values or the rates that we need to assess.
1:58:30 When we take a look at the total capital projects, these are what we're going to be
1:58:35 funding by a combination of incoming cash, also with impact fees or cash reserves, and
1:58:43 we'll kind of talk about what those each look like.
1:58:46 So the FFE is furniture, fixtures, and equipment.
1:58:49 That's going to be all of the things that don't come with the property.
1:58:56 And that's for not only City Hall, but it's also the public safety buildings.
1:58:59 It's going to be screens and cameras and chairs and desks and all of those things because we're
1:59:06 going to a different type of system where they have actual office systems.
1:59:10 We need to move and acquire some of that stuff.
1:59:13 We also have a plan to move desks that are currently being used throughout our entire
1:59:17 organization.
1:59:20 One of the great celebrations we had earlier this year was the signing of the trail for
1:59:25 for this, for the, to go across the store property.
1:59:29 So we've allocated again this year the $800,000
1:59:32 for that trail, recognizing that that will be,
1:59:35 more than likely, we're really hoping
1:59:37 that MAFTEC can execute their piece,
1:59:39 so that we can be in a position financially
1:59:42 to move forward in the upcoming fiscal year.
1:59:45 We're gonna be looking at replacing that bubble
1:59:48 and making other corresponding improvements.
1:59:50 And so we, you know, that bubble is beginning to live,
1:59:54 It's out useful life and next week,
1:59:56 Wendy is going to be coming to talk about making improvements
2:00:00 to the bubble and other aspects of the pool
2:00:05 to help move forward.
2:00:06 We're looking at digitizing our permits.
2:00:09 And then you'll see a whole series
2:00:11 of different transportation improvements
2:00:13 where some reconstruction jobs on Eastland South,
2:00:17 Eastland and Julie Lane, defaults zone 5 maintenance
2:00:22 is where we do the chip and the seal and the overlay and the fog.
2:00:26 And so we want to continue to fund that.
2:00:29 That rotation allows us to hit each one of those zones
2:00:32 and then eight-year increment.
2:00:35 Fiscal year 17 will be the fifth year that we follow zone maintenance.
2:00:38 We have a sidewalk management program of $50,000,
2:00:41 which we think is a good first step.
2:00:44 We want to continue to find money to investigate
2:00:47 and provide additional funding moving forward.
2:00:49 We've also applied for a series of grants with ITD
2:00:52 to assist with other types of side drug replacements.
2:00:58 Don, how has question for you?
2:01:00 So Travis, that interests me.
2:01:01 So that's kind of a match and what's your vision
2:01:04 about that again?
2:01:05 Do we have a philosophy, a construction of how we would
2:01:11 engage the community regarding that?
2:01:12 Yeah, we're still working through that process.
2:01:15 What we wanted to do was to make sure
2:01:16 that we had the allocation in place.
2:01:19 That would give us the opportunity to have funding to build a program around that.
2:01:24 We started with $50,000 to see if there's a lot of money.
2:01:28 You'll remember that John Caten came and made his presentation.
2:01:31 We want to have a more solidified plan that we will develop, that we will then use more of an application process to help move in that forward.
2:01:45 And Mitch is sharing with me that John will be in a position to present that when we
2:01:52 to present the accessible community piece of the budget.
2:01:56 I just think that's positive.
2:01:57 It's something to get us started.
2:02:00 And what I'm hoping is that we find that the $50,000
2:02:05 is not enough money, because that means
2:02:08 that there's a lot more interest in the program
2:02:12 in creating more sidewalks and more accessible opportunities
2:02:16 within our community.
2:02:18 Water meter replacement, we want to continue
2:02:20 to make sure that we're doing that for $300,000.
2:02:24 The taxiway reconstruction and the R vehicle
2:02:26 are going to be, again, federal funded support projects
2:02:30 out of the airport.
2:02:31 Those are large dollars coming in from the federal government,
2:02:34 but we want to make sure that those are allocated
2:02:38 and moving forward.
2:02:40 If for some reason, we were not able to receive
2:02:42 the discretionary funding or we were not able to receive
2:02:45 the entitlement funding that those projects
2:02:48 would just be suspended.
2:02:49 in our conversations with Bill and his conversations with the FAA, we're very
2:02:55 comfortable in putting these allocations forward this year. So we want to talk
2:03:01 about the impact. So the utilizing the statutory increase generates 861
2:03:06 thousand dollars of new property tax revenue. That does not touch any portion
2:03:12 of the foregone balance. The city's foregone balance will remain intact at
2:03:16 $2,150,000 and then we're looking at a potential maximum rate increase.
2:03:22 So right now we're still kind of working through those numbers but the most we're looking right
2:03:27 now is a 3% increase in water, a 3% increase in sewer and we know that it's about a 1.5%
2:03:34 increase in sanitation.
2:03:35 The total aggregate of those is about a 2.2% increase which is about $24 a year for the
2:03:46 utilities that are provided by the city.
2:03:50 Again, we're starting high and we're talking about what those potentials could be.
2:03:57 We have every indication to believe that we'll continue to work, investigate revenue trends,
2:04:02 investigate expenditures and to continue to find ways to bring those rates down even further.
2:04:14 So this is the process.
2:04:16 On Wednesday, July 6th, we will present, we will provide to you electronic and hard copy
2:04:21 of the budget and then starting on the July 11th, we will move forward with an overview
2:04:25 of the budget.
2:04:26 We'll each, each, each individual of the focus areas with the budget ultimately being
2:04:32 set to be adopted on August 28th of this year.
2:04:38 That will give us time to certify everything to the county and to finalize the budget and
2:04:44 and to be able to move forward in terms of the statutory deadlines that are
2:04:48 required by code is outlined below. Travis, I'm just curious why we are on
2:04:54 Wednesday July 6th instead of Tuesday the 5th. So we're not meeting on Tuesday the
2:05:01 5th. Okay. And we as a staff wanted to give ourselves an extra day. Okay. We'll
2:05:07 holiday to be able to make sure that we met that commitment to get the
2:05:11 budget up to you. So that will be coming to us not presented in a meeting.
2:05:14 Yeah, so the first time that we're presenting the budget overview will be on
2:05:18 the 11th. Perfect. Thank you. So there is no meeting on the 5th. There is our
2:05:22 understanding is we might not have a quorum and so we were moving the direction
2:05:29 of not having the meeting. Thank you. Chris Talkington? This of course deals not
2:05:37 only with the upcoming budget travels but a little longer range planning. A couple months
2:05:43 ago, we were informed by attempts by the State Water Master to question our decreased total
2:05:57 water consumption from our water rights in such a frame of mind that it would be, if you
2:06:03 don't use it, you have a potential bloosing it.
2:06:07 Is there anything you can speak publicly on that
2:06:09 that may impact our near and short term budget on water?
2:06:14 That's a great question.
2:06:15 And so what this was going to be was a comprehensive change
2:06:18 on how the state has approached local government units
2:06:22 and their ability to stockpile water
2:06:24 rates for anticipation of future use.
2:06:28 At this point in time, there has not
2:06:30 been any formalized change to the law that allows cities
2:06:35 the opportunity to acquire water rights
2:06:41 for anticipated future use. Right now
2:06:44 all water right users and I'm going to look to for it to make sure I get this right
2:06:48 all water right users with the exception municipalities have to go through a
2:06:51 window
2:06:52 proving up that the water that they use has been applied to beneficial use and I
2:06:56 think that's a five year window
2:06:58 they have to go through that allocation. Cities in Idaho are exempt from that. There was
2:07:03 a conversation that cities would be brought under that same umbrella and so far that
2:07:08 has not happened and that conversation has kind of passed and it has not been rekindled.
2:07:15 It is not happening to date as I mean as being dropped as a potential threat.
2:07:22 At this point so anything can come back up but our understanding right now is that that
2:07:27 issue will not. There's always the potential for issues to resurface, but in the conversations
2:07:34 that we've had, we don't believe that is in our more short to mid-range window of concern.
2:07:43 That's good news. So my question is, did we grossly miss, I mean, it's quick, it's a
2:07:54 quick hit, but did we say anything that causes concern before we go to publish? Is there
2:08:00 more information that we can provide. Granted, there is going to be more vetting of this budget
2:08:06 than in the future and certainly every opportunity for the citizens to engage in every single piece
2:08:15 and part and presentation as we move forward.
2:08:18 I think there's a reflective direction we indicate we want to go.
2:08:23 Any other comments from the Council? At this time then I'd like to open it up to the public
2:08:28 If there's anybody who has any questions on the budget process that we've just discussed tonight,
2:08:33 now's your chance to bring them before us or the budget period.
2:08:41 Looks like we're good.
2:08:44 Sorry, quick.
2:08:45 Quick seat.
2:08:51 Thank you very much, Travis.
2:08:55 With that, then I'm going to give one more opportunity if there's anybody in the public who has anything
2:09:00 like to talk to the council about that was not on tonight's agenda. You can go forward. If you
2:09:09 just tell us your name and what city you live in, that would be great. Hi, I'm Winnie Christensen.
2:09:18 I read Blooded American. I have a question. I don't live in a neighborhood where there's an
2:09:27 association, but I'd love to put a speed bump. How do I go about that? Good question. We have a
2:09:35 Traffic Safety Commission that takes up those issues and Mitch Humboldt, right here next
2:09:42 to you, is the gentleman you want to speak to and he will help you with that.
2:09:47 We have a date.
2:09:56 Is there anyone else who would like to address the council tonight?
2:10:04 I'll let you introduce yourself, Leah.
2:10:06 My name is Leah Papayan and I live in Twin Falls.
2:10:12 I want to thank the council for allowing conversation in regards to emotional issues and incidents.
2:10:25 But at the same time, I appreciate you calling it what it is when it is in front of you and
2:10:40 if it is bigotry or racism or if it's fueling that,
2:10:44 I appreciate you taking a stand and shutting it down,
2:10:50 because it trickles outside of a newspaper,
2:10:53 it trickles outside of this room,
2:10:55 and it affects innocent people's lives
2:10:58 in their work environments, in their place of business,
2:11:01 it affects their children on playgrounds,
2:11:05 and there's crimes in this community,
2:11:09 every single day. If I open up that newspaper, sadly, there are crimes against children and
2:11:16 predators and pornography and it saturates our paper. But when it happens to be convenient
2:11:23 and when it happens to be a minority, a immigrant or refugee, whatever, that is an opportunity
2:11:35 for a broad brush to circle a whole population
2:11:40 of decent, hard-working, contributing Americans or Americans
2:11:46 to be, that fire is fed, and that fire can take off,
2:11:52 and it affects people's lives.
2:11:54 It hurts people.
2:11:56 I'm here also to speak in support and also with empathy
2:12:06 to the parents that are affected, I'm a parent,
2:12:11 but I'm also here to speak for all the innocent refugees
2:12:16 and immigrants and minorities that are profiled automatically
2:12:22 in our community and are victimized,
2:12:26 whether it's with road rage or words on social media
2:12:31 or screaming things at them as they're walking across the street
2:12:34 with their child, that's also making victims out of people.
2:12:41 And I think our community definitely is better than that.
2:12:44 This room always fills up with the nose more than the yeses
2:12:47 because that's just how it goes and informs like this.
2:12:52 But I want to acknowledge your positions and how you balance
2:13:01 the emotions that come before you here.
2:13:03 And the emails and all the things that you probably hear that aren't voiced here.
2:13:08 And to encourage you to remember that there are a lot of innocent people in this community
2:13:14 that are vulnerable because of their status,
2:13:17 and they're vulnerable because of how they're portrayed.
2:13:20 Nobody should be profiled legally or in just someone's actions towards them.
2:13:30 And we shouldn't encourage that kind of energy in our community because all that does is further
2:13:39 persecute people that have arrived here to escape persecution.
2:13:46 It further victimizes, like the chief said, the victims and refugees are victims.
2:13:51 I'm not sure what refugees Julie's been talking to, but as a refugee, none of us come here because
2:14:00 we win a cruise, especially not to Twin Falls, Idaho.
2:14:04 There are crises and there are horrible,
2:14:07 traumatic instances and circumstances that bring us,
2:14:11 uproot us out of our homes and bring us
2:14:13 vulnerable into a community where we have to assimilate
2:14:17 and adjust.
2:14:19 And I think Twin Falls has done a very good job
2:14:22 at supporting that, not just in the recent difficult years,
2:14:27 but for many years because the results of that I see every day,
2:14:31 not just in my own circle, but with many success stories
2:14:35 that are then Twin Falls' success stories.
2:14:38 So thank you.
2:14:40 And I know that there's a lot that's in the community
2:14:45 that is emotional right now, but I would encourage our community
2:14:50 to not victimize also all immigrants and refugees,
2:14:56 whether or not they're from the countries of where these little boys are from or categorize
2:15:02 everyone with a broad brush and let their emotions cause actions towards people that
2:15:11 are also unfair.
2:15:14 If someone commits a crime, they commit a crime, not because of the color and not because
2:15:20 of their religion.
2:15:22 Their religion isn't what's committing the crime.
2:15:24 The color, their skin is not what's committing a crime and definitely not a status on their
2:15:29 citizenship is what's responsible for that crime.
2:15:33 The crime is what is the criminal element and I trust, I'm not sure if the rest of the
2:15:39 speakers that spoke that are defending this great nation, trust the actual infrastructures
2:15:45 of this great nation, but I trust our legal system and I trust our governments and I trust
2:15:51 that these crimes can be addressed in a way
2:15:55 where we don't need mob rule and social media
2:15:59 to create a verdict and judgment before the process works
2:16:05 it's way through, so thank you.
2:16:07 Thank you for coming tonight, Leah.
2:16:09 Sorry, thank you.
2:16:13 With that, the next thing on our agenda.
2:16:15 Oh, I'm sorry.
2:16:16 Council comments, any advisory reports,
2:16:20 anything from city staff?
2:16:22 is talking to you just a short update on the North Five Points art project we hold a meeting
2:16:29 today with a quorum thank goodness and toward North Five Points I hope to say that this time
2:16:37 next month we will have an artist rendering with specific measurements and meets and bounds
2:16:44 and lighting and other signings that in trim trees that will be enough visual with cost of
2:16:53 tasks that the council can make the next decision whether they want to support the go ahead on
2:16:58 the project.
2:16:59 Don, I think it's fair to say that we've got a design and Greg that's going to be very unique
2:17:05 in the Magic Valley that we're finalizing or conceptualizing on with a well-known artist.
2:17:12 So although our goal is to have it down if the council concurs by sometime in September,
2:17:18 it may slop over a little bit into the next fiscal year if necessary.
2:17:24 Thank you, Chris.
2:17:25 Travis?
2:17:26 So just a quick update, Chaney Drive is now open.
2:17:34 It's a new type of intersection and we would just encourage individuals to, you know, as
2:17:44 they drive be aware. We've had one accident already, so we would just continue to add.
2:17:59 It wasn't open very long, but we would just ask citizens to really pay attention as they're
2:18:09 kind of driving and have a sense of awareness not only for how they're driving, but also
2:18:14 So how this might be a new driving experience for others.
2:18:20 Just always remember to stay on the right-hand side of the road.
2:18:25 Thank you, Travis.
2:18:27 Okay, the next thing on our agenda is adjournment into Executive Session 74206F,
2:18:36 to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency,
2:18:39 to discuss the legal ramifications of,
2:18:42 and legal options of pending litigation or controversies not yet being litigated, but
2:18:48 imminently likely to be litigated.
2:18:50 The mere presence of legal counsel at an executive session does not satisfy this requirement, Don
2:18:57 Hall.
2:18:58 So moved.
2:18:59 Second.
2:19:00 We have a motion on the floor by Don Hall, seconded by, I'm going to give it to Nicky
2:19:05 Boyd because we thought one tonight, and to adjourn into executive session and with that
2:19:12 Sharon Roll Call vote.
2:19:15 Chris Hockington.
2:19:17 Greg Lanting.
2:19:18 Yes.
2:19:19 Don Hall.
2:19:20 Yes.
2:19:21 Rick Pierce.
2:19:22 Yes.
2:19:23 Suzanne Hocking.
2:19:24 Yes.
2:19:25 Nicky Boy.
2:19:26 Yes.
2:19:27 With that, I'd like to make sure that everyone in the audience knows that we will not be reconvening
2:19:30 this meeting tonight and no decisions will be made in executive session.
2:19:33 Thank you for attending and the meeting adjourned.
Download
- Transcript (text) 128 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 169 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 227 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.2 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 11.7 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, June 20, 2016. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:19:44.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
b1de71e95187a2802da578ea712ae61d3845635d56a67b40bdd8312a069aca3c - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 0793158b9d632909538d5c2c375072e813d402967c591a3ac51a39ae25f359a7
part02.m4a d3f915b7713e915ed970554f7f79c0ca5b440f919c12b4f977a44bd7e5850da9 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
c84624df32211b5608d925285cb4d34d41ffdb8dcf11e7df84b88645046d6723
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file