OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, September 12, 2016

Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Part 3 (from 3:00:00)

Transcript

0:25:06 I'd like to call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday, September 12th, 2016.

0:25:13 Before we do the Pledge of Allegiance, I'd like to ask everyone to please join me in a moment of silence to recognize the 15th anniversary of the September 11th terrorist attacks yesterday.

0:25:23 And now for those of you wishing to join us, please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:25:35 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for

0:25:46 which it stands, one nation under God, universal with liberty and justice for all.

0:25:52 I will confirm we do have a quorum of the Council here.

0:26:00 All seven members are here this evening.

0:26:02 Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to the agenda?

0:26:05 Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, there are no amendments this evening.

0:26:08 Thank you.

0:26:09 Next on the agenda, we have general public input.

0:26:13 And to begin that, I'd like to invite up Billy Bello,

0:26:15 who is the new president of our Twin Falls Youth Council,

0:26:21 and to also bring up his executive team,

0:26:25 introduce themselves.

0:26:30 Welcome.

0:26:32 So I'm Billy.

0:26:32 You can just pull that out.

0:26:35 So I'm Billy Bello.

0:26:36 I'm the president of the Twin Falls City Youth Council.

0:26:41 I'm Carlos Munoz, and I'm the vice president

0:26:43 of the City Youth Council.

0:26:47 I'm Eleanor Pruitt, and I am Secretary of Youth Student

0:26:50 Council?

0:26:51 Youth Council?

0:26:52 I am Ben Walland and I'm the Treasurer of the Twin Falls City Youth Council.

0:26:59 Excellent.

0:27:00 Great.

0:27:01 Well, welcome to all of you and thank you for your service to our community and serving

0:27:04 on that committee.

0:27:05 It sounds like we have a great group of students.

0:27:07 I know Vice Mayor Susanne Hawkins is involved with your group and we're very excited for

0:27:13 another exciting year of the work that you all are going to do.

0:27:17 Thank you guys for coming tonight.

0:27:21 Have a good evening.

0:27:25 So general public input, this is an opportunity for folks to address the council on issues

0:27:29 that are not on this evening's agenda, and I don't know if anybody could even make it

0:27:33 up to the sign-up sheet with the crowd we have in here tonight.

0:27:36 So if there's anyone who wishes to address the City Council on the item that's on the

0:27:42 agenda, please come forward.

0:27:43 Mr. Smith.

0:27:59 Paul, I would ask that you please keep your comments limited to three minutes.

0:28:03 I plan on three minutes.

0:28:05 I appreciate it.

0:28:06 Please don't ask yourself.

0:28:07 And if you please introduce yourself for the record.

0:28:11 Okay, I'm Paul Smith. I'm a resident actually at the county, but do own property in the city.

0:28:17 We're here about this statue over here.

0:28:20 And this is John Hayes, a statue to John Hayes.

0:28:23 And if you look, there was a book written about eight years ago for about the canal company.

0:28:29 And in that, the author of the book found a picture in the Hayes family.

0:28:35 And this is the first day of Twin Falls.

0:28:38 This is Shoshone in Main Street, that's Sagebrush and Rocks and all those things.

0:28:43 And the company that was the developing Twin Falls Canal Development Company went to some

0:28:48 effort to hire an engineer, surveyor.

0:28:50 His name was John Hayes.

0:28:52 He became a big part of our life in Twin Falls.

0:28:56 He was our first city engineer.

0:28:58 He stayed here the rest, well, he went away to some mines in Colorado for 14 years, then

0:29:04 came back.

0:29:05 He married Hanson, where Hanson is named of, he married the daughter, and things, but our

0:29:12 desire is somewhere along the line in the next year to put a statue that is one and

0:29:18 a quarter times life size on the corner, Shoshone and Maine, on one of the corners, and we being

0:29:26 Dave Lemure, the artist, took that picture and came up with a full statue, and it was

0:29:33 This is poured in Joseph, Oregon.

0:29:36 It will be donated to the public library when we're done with showing it, so to speak, and

0:29:41 using it.

0:29:42 So it'll have a life of its own.

0:29:45 The two foundations have paid for the whole thing, and we're not asking for money.

0:29:50 That's what I guess I wanted to tell you this time.

0:29:53 But we are going to need your help.

0:29:55 It's probably going to have to go on the city right away in some form if we can pull off the

0:30:01 big one and the other we are talking to other foundations. But Dave Lemire took that

0:30:07 picture and I think he made a very interesting thing and twirls around so after your meeting

0:30:12 you might want to take a look at it. It's about 70 pounds that little one. So God knows

0:30:17 how big it is going to be. We just wanted you to know what was going on and kind of give

0:30:24 you an idea of what it's going to look like. I hope so. Thank you for the time. Thank you.

0:30:28 Well, Chris talking just might mention that in a tandem with our new art project in the north five points park is really going to demonstrate bringing twin falls out the sagebrush and the pioneer spirit that this demonstrates.

0:30:45 As there anyone else who wishes to address the Council for our general public input, seeing no one we will move on with our robust agenda here.

0:30:59 So the first item for consideration is the consent calendar.

0:31:02 Don Hall moved to approval.

0:31:04 Second.

0:31:06 Motion by Don Hall, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the consent calendar.

0:31:10 Is there any discussion?

0:31:14 Seeing none, Chair, and roll call vote, please.

0:31:16 Suzanne Hawkins?

0:31:17 Yes.

0:31:18 Nikki Boyd?

0:31:19 Yes.

0:31:20 Sean Bericher?

0:31:21 Yes.

0:31:21 Chris Tockingfield?

0:31:22 Yes.

0:31:23 Greg Plantin?

0:31:24 Yes.

0:31:24 Don Hall?

0:31:25 Yes.

0:31:25 Ruth Pierce?

0:31:26 Yes.

0:31:27 Motion passes, 7-0.

0:31:30 And items for consideration.

0:31:31 The first item is a formal ceremony promoting Officer Lou Coronado to the position of Sergeant

0:31:36 and Sergeant Brent Wright to the position of Staff Sergeant,

0:31:39 and we have our Chief of Police, Craig Kingsbury.

0:31:42 Welcome, Chief.

0:31:47 Thank you, Mayor and Council.

0:31:49 It's always an honor to be before you for moments like this.

0:31:53 In the policing profession, there's

0:31:57 a couple great days in the life of a police employee.

0:32:02 The first day getting sworn in is obviously a pretty big day.

0:32:05 But as the career progresses being promoted and taking the next step into the supervision

0:32:12 and management of the agency also are great days.

0:32:17 And this evening we're going to honor two very dedicated, very professional young men

0:32:24 who have been police officers for the City of Twin Falls for quite some time and through

0:32:29 a very robust and competitive promotional process have been selected to be promoted

0:32:35 to the ranks, as you mentioned, Mayor.

0:32:38 So what I'd like to do is have, I guess I'll call him,

0:32:43 Sergeant Lou Coronado come forward.

0:32:47 Now, I'm going to go over Lou's bio as he's coming up here.

0:32:51 Lou was hired by Twin Falls PD full time on June 19th of 2000.

0:32:56 And as I read this earlier today, I remembered that was

0:32:59 actually the day that I got married to my wife, Lou.

0:33:01 So see, we've got an anniversary in common.

0:33:05 He attended Walla Walla Community College in Washington,

0:33:08 and then graduated from the College of Southern Idaho Law Enforcement Program in 1996.

0:33:13 Prior to coming to the Twin Falls Police Department, he was a deputy sheriff

0:33:16 from the Twin Falls County Sheriff's Office for three and a half years,

0:33:19 where he also held a position of a field training officer.

0:33:22 Lou served as a patrol officer here for three years prior to being assigned

0:33:26 to the Strategic Traffic Accident Reduction Team or STAR.

0:33:30 He's had the pleasure of writing.

0:33:32 Now this is probably one of the best jobs in policing, sorry,

0:33:35 if you'll agree with me here.

0:33:36 The pleasure of writing a Harley-Davidson motorcycle,

0:33:39 a BMW motorcycle, and a Honda motorcycle

0:33:41 for the past 13 years.

0:33:43 So I'm guessing making the decision

0:33:45 to promote the Sergeant was a little difficult.

0:33:48 Might have to give up the motorcycles.

0:33:52 Sergeant Cornal has also been a member

0:33:53 of the Special Weapons and Tactics,

0:33:55 our SWAT team for the past 13 years,

0:33:57 and he has been a team leader on that team

0:34:00 for the last three years.

0:34:02 Lew also has served up until very recently as a field training officer and field training

0:34:07 officers.

0:34:08 That's really the first supervisory position in the police department is a mentor and training

0:34:13 the brand new hires that come aboard.

0:34:16 Lew was awarded his basic certificate from Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training in

0:34:20 1997.

0:34:21 His intermediate certificate in January of 2001.

0:34:25 His advanced certificate in August of 2008 and his master's certificate in December of 2011.

0:34:32 Lew and his wife, Barbara, have two wonderful sons, Christopher, age 21, and Braden, age

0:34:37 17.

0:34:38 As I mentioned, after a very competitive promotional process, Lew has been selected by the administrative

0:34:45 staff and myself to serve as a position of sergeant.

0:34:48 He actually started this last week with the new paper, so Lew's into this a week in a

0:34:55 day.

0:34:56 So before we get started, as I've said every time I come up here, in policing, we are a

0:35:03 family at the TFPD, but we also have our extended family and our family members, and for a person

0:35:10 to be successful in this career, he or she needs to have the support of their family and their

0:35:20 children, and I think that all of us can attest to that how important that is.

0:35:26 I know Lou has a plethora of folks here in the audience, some of whom already mentioned,

0:35:31 but Sergeant Coronado, now is the hard test, would you like to introduce who we have in

0:35:35 the audience here?

0:36:02 Well, welcome to the Coronado family, and this is a great, great day.

0:36:07 Now, Lou has promised I also have a brand new in the bag, Sergeant Badge, to present to

0:36:14 you.

0:37:03 Sergeant until just stand up there for a moment. Now I would like to call up Staff Sergeant Brent

0:37:09 Wright. So Staff Sergeant Wright began his law enforcement career in December of 1997 as

0:37:26 a detention officer with the Minacasha Criminal Justice Center. He then went on to work as

0:37:30 a police officer for the city of Kimberly from August of 98 until April of 2002. On April 15th

0:37:37 of 2002 Brent was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department to serve as a full time police

0:37:42 officer. He also attended the College of Southern Idaho, where he majored in law

0:37:46 enforcement and received a certificate of completion in July of 1998. During his

0:37:53 career with the Twin Falls PD, Brent has served as a member of the STAR team, also

0:37:59 getting to ride motorcycles for a living. It's one thing I never did, maybe we can

0:38:04 make a cheap position on a bike. Brent has been a field training officer, also a

0:38:10 a member of our special weapons and tactics team,

0:38:14 and narcotics detective.

0:38:17 He's currently a team leader on our SWAT team.

0:38:19 He's an instructor in almost every law enforcement

0:38:23 discipline that there is from firearms to auto theft,

0:38:28 traffic code, speed measurements,

0:38:31 and I think as Councilman Halkin and Testu,

0:38:34 Staff Sergeant Wright can teach pretty much anything

0:38:36 that the post has out there to teach,

0:38:39 and he does it very well.

0:38:41 Brent was promoted to sergeant on June 26th of 2011,

0:38:45 and that capacity he served as a supervisor

0:38:47 in the patrol division, the juvenile crime unit,

0:38:50 as well as the criminal investigations division.

0:38:53 He was awarded his basic certification in June of 1999,

0:38:56 his intermediate certification in May of 2004,

0:39:00 his advanced certification in October of 2007,

0:39:03 supervisory certificate in June of 2012,

0:39:06 all by the Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training Council.

0:39:10 As mentioned earlier, after a very competitive promotional process for the position of Staff

0:39:15 Sergeant, which became available with the retirement of Staff Sergeant Lew and here a

0:39:20 few weeks ago, Brent was selected by myself and the administrative staff to take on this

0:39:26 new position as Staff Sergeant.

0:39:30 Now Brent's here with his girlfriend Lisa, right?

0:39:33 And I know that Brandt, your daughter is away attending college and obviously couldn't make

0:39:38 the trek down here.

0:39:41 That's probably good advice, Staff Sergeant, good advice.

0:40:27 And then following, hey, well, stay up there, gentlemen, okay, oh, I thought you were walking

0:40:31 away, I was watching you.

0:40:32 And following one of the, what I think is one of the coolest traditions that we have at

0:40:36 the Twin Falls Police Department, the members of the Supervisors Corps will now come up and

0:40:41 present the Chevron's to Sergeant Cornado and then Staff Sergeant Wright.

0:40:48 So, Sergeant, Staff Sergeant, thank you very much.

0:41:48 I'm very proud of you.

0:41:49 And I would ask some of the members of the PD to stick around.

0:42:01 I know we have a similar process for our brother from the Fire Department than a special event

0:42:06 after that.

0:42:07 So.

0:42:08 Thank you, Chief.

0:42:10 Next on the agenda we have a presentation to recognize the achievements of Jesse Killinger,

0:42:14 who has completed his firefighter level 1 certification, Dallas Williamson and Zachary Fleming for their

0:42:20 successful completion of this year's Twin Falls Drivers Academy and we have, you're not the

0:42:25 battalion chiefs. It says battalion chiefs. Right, I'm one of the three.

0:42:30 So good evening Mr. Mayor and Council. So it's my job on behalf of the administration tonight,

0:42:36 the fire department administration, to thank you for helping us to recognize some of our,

0:42:42 some of the achievements of some of our guys. So with that I'm going to turn it over to the

0:42:44 battalion chief Cunningham. Good evening mayor and council. My name is Brian Cunningham.

0:42:56 and I would again like to thank you for taking the time to recognize Jesse

0:43:00 Killinger on his achievement of firefighter one. Jesse, if you could step up

0:43:05 here please. I'd like to take this opportunity to tell you a little bit

0:43:09 about Jesse. Jesse was born in Portland, Oregon, but grew up in the Twin Falls and

0:43:14 Filer area. Jesse graduated high school in 2006 and joined the Army in 2008. Jesse

0:43:20 was stationed in Fort Drum, New York and served two tours in Afghanistan. When

0:43:26 As contracted with the Army was complete, he joined the National Guard and is currently

0:43:31 still serving with them.

0:43:33 Jesse married his wife in 2014 and they're expecting their first child in November.

0:43:39 Jesse joined our department on September 2015 and recently completed his firefighter one.

0:43:46 Firefighter one consists of several classes that include the incident command system, hazardous

0:43:52 materials, operation, extrication, or awareness, hazardous material awareness,

0:43:58 extrication awareness, and CPR. The candidate must also complete 21 chapters in

0:44:04 the Essentials of Firefighting Manual. This includes required reading, bookwork,

0:44:10 quizzes, and final chapter tests. There are many chapters that require hands-on

0:44:17 skills of base test as well. Once all the coursework is complete, there is a final

0:44:23 written and practical exam in which the candidate must achieve 80% or greater.

0:44:29 Jesse has performed exceptionally well and has demonstrated that he has the skills and

0:44:34 abilities to receive as firefighter one.

0:44:38 Fire administration would like to thank all of those in the department that helped Jesse

0:44:41 along the way, including the training office that issues the grades or issues all the tests

0:44:48 and grades them.

0:44:50 and they also set up all the outside classes as well.

0:44:53 So Jesse, not only performed well in that,

0:44:58 he's a great fit for our department,

0:45:00 and we're proud of him.

0:45:02 So at this time I've asked the mayor,

0:45:04 if he'd come down, we present his certificate

0:45:06 and his new helmet shield.

0:45:46 At this time, Jesse, we'll go ahead and have you sit down.

0:45:49 I'm gonna turn it over to the town chief Brooks.

0:45:59 Thanks, Brian.

0:46:01 Good evening, mayor and council.

0:46:02 My name is Mitchell Brooks.

0:46:04 We're here to acknowledge a couple firefighters

0:46:07 that just recently completed the Driver's Academy.

0:46:09 So I would like to invite Mr. Zach Fleming

0:46:13 and Dallas Williamson up to the front, please.

0:46:24 So just for clarification, Zach's the small one.

0:46:27 That's not that bad.

0:46:34 So I'll start with Zach.

0:46:35 Zach graduated from Jerome High School in 2004

0:46:38 and the University of Idaho in 2008.

0:46:41 He began his career as a wild land firefighter

0:46:43 in Ketchum and was hired by our department in 2013.

0:46:48 He's very motivated and has accomplished great things in the short time he's been here.

0:46:55 Dallas graduated from Filer High School in the walk after in 1998 and joined the Marine

0:47:03 Corps that same year.

0:47:05 After completing his military career, Dallas worked in Iraq and Afghanistan for three years.

0:47:11 He then joined our water department and then he was hired by the fire department in 2012.

0:47:21 Dallas brings a lot of strength to the department which includes his physical strength.

0:47:26 I know Dallas' wife is in the crowd, Jamie, if you'd like to introduce her, please.

0:47:42 So both these gentlemen have recently completed this year's Drivers Academy and are now qualified

0:47:46 to drive and operate all Fire Department apparatus.

0:47:50 So driving a fire truck comes with a lot of responsibility.

0:47:53 These two have demonstrated to us that they have the skills and abilities to handle it.

0:47:58 The Drivers Academy started in June and ended in August.

0:48:02 was broken down into segments covering things like defensive driving, pump theory, which

0:48:06 is one of my favorites, ladder truck, aerial operations, operating the RF truck located

0:48:12 out at the airport, and equipment maintenance. Both guys had to log several hours of drive

0:48:18 time during the day and night. So on behalf of the fire department administration, I would

0:48:24 like to thank the drivers academy instructors, Tristan Jones and Fred McDonald, the two of

0:48:37 work well together and made it a success. We would also like to thank the training office

0:48:42 and engine companies who worked with these two gentlemen over the course of the academy.

0:48:47 The three of us on the command staff know what it takes to make it through this program and

0:48:51 have a lot of respect for what these two have accomplished. So Mr. Mayor, if you go over

0:48:56 and present their certificates please. Congratulations gentlemen on your promotions. Thank you for

0:49:33 your dedication to the community and your service to all of us. And Chief, did you want to come

0:49:39 back up for our special surprise before everyone skid adults.

0:49:50 Thank you mayor and council for inviting me up for I guess item 2.1 if you will on the

0:49:56 agenda. I think a lot of people here of course the members of council I think a lot of the

0:50:03 folks in the audience and probably a lot who are viewing from the comfort of their home

0:50:08 are aware that the City of Twin Falls is a wonderful city in many ways, but in one regards

0:50:14 and it's the way that we honor and support our veterans of our military service.

0:50:19 I know we have several veterans in the room with us tonight and on council and we recently

0:50:25 became a Purple Heart City and if you've been following TFPD on Facebook or a great follow

0:50:31 on Facebook and Twitter, you are aware that the PD has been taking part in the 22 and 22

0:50:39 challenge, which is 22 push-ups in 22 days to raise awareness for post-traumatic stress

0:50:47 disorder. Unfortunately, we know that throughout this country, on average, every day, approximately

0:50:55 22 of our veterans take their own lives because of PTSD. And this challenge is something

0:51:02 that's been going on in social media, just to raise awareness.

0:51:05 Today, March day 21, for those of us at the PD,

0:51:10 the push-ups are getting a little bit easier.

0:51:12 I'll tell you that a little tough at first.

0:51:13 Especially days two and three, that's when I was a source.

0:51:16 I don't know about the other members out there.

0:51:18 But a while back, Mayor, you joined us out at the Visitor Center.

0:51:24 We knocked out some push-ups.

0:51:26 And you challenged, you did challenge their-

0:51:30 I kind of challenged.

0:51:32 So you challenged Mayor Peter and the City of Boise and their council.

0:51:38 I don't know if they've done that, but I'm happy to say that Chief Bones of Boise PD and

0:51:43 some of his officers joined me Saturday as we were tailgating for the Boise State Washington State football game.

0:51:50 And I did knock out 22 push-ups with Chief Bones and BPD.

0:51:54 So some representatives of the City of Boise did accept the challenge.

0:51:57 But yes, you may be kind of challenged some of your fellow members on council in regards to this.

0:52:04 And so I am here to, shall we say, put you on the spot.

0:52:08 But one thing that I have learned as a chief of police is you never totally surprise the elected officials.

0:52:15 So I know in speaking with you that we have five of you that are going to help us do push-ups and

0:52:21 a couple that are going to help us count the set push-ups.

0:52:24 to partake in the whole event.

0:52:27 I also am going to throw the challenge out to members of the audience.

0:52:31 We have, like I said, our brother from the fire department out here.

0:52:34 We have several members of both our police and fire families and of course our city manager

0:52:41 and the two deputy city managers and just anybody else who is out here.

0:52:45 So let me ask you first, how many veterans are out here?

0:52:58 So are we ready to knock out some push-ups, Mayor?

0:53:01 Councilor?

0:53:02 down here I suppose. I saw it. Go ahead and get up fire guys. So the way this is gonna

0:53:31 work is Councilperson Boyd is going to say down and Councilperson Pierce will

0:53:38 count so we have 42 so you and the audience aren't doing them you can help

0:53:42 us by counting

0:53:57 we're looking ready are we ready down one two why what seven eight nine

0:54:12 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, you guys did more like 30 so I was

0:54:40 trying to follow you too.

0:54:42 That was awesome. I got a fun picture.

0:55:00 I'll send you a picture.

0:55:05 But he got him too.

0:55:06 Excellent.

0:55:07 That was even cool.

0:55:09 Chief, thank you and thank you to all of your team that's been part of this challenge

0:55:14 and you have been making the rounds on Facebook.

0:55:16 I've seen it all over the place.

0:55:18 We've been doing what we can, man. I don't know what we're going to do after tomorrow.

0:55:21 I'm about to find another challenge.

0:55:23 How about not push-ups?

0:55:24 Yeah, I think we go for the 55 push-ups next year.

0:55:30 Thank you so much. I hope that went over streaming media.

0:55:40 So we'll hold off here for just a second as the room clears from some of our audience.

0:55:48 Are there anybody that we all get your breath?

0:55:53 Now we're down to normal numbers.

0:56:05 I just got a full shot tonight.

0:56:26 All right.

0:56:27 Next on the agenda, we have a request to purchase 40 Dell OptiPlex 7040 SFF computers for a total cost of $34,290.40.

0:56:38 Kathy Marcus.

0:56:41 Welcome, Kathy.

0:56:42 Good evening, Mayor and Council.

0:56:45 I also have Mike Freeman with me.

0:56:47 Mike Freeman is our Dell account rep,

0:56:49 and he came for moral support,

0:56:50 and also to answer any questions that you might have,

0:56:53 because he was here when the devices

0:56:56 that we are replacing were purchased.

0:56:58 So he has some history that I might not have available.

0:57:01 I wanted to start off by giving you an example

0:57:04 of one of the many tech support calls

0:57:07 that we got regarding the WISE boxes.

0:57:10 This one came in within, I am done,

0:57:13 all-in-upper case and exclamation points.

0:57:17 It says, I am so done with this computer.

0:57:19 It is slow.

0:57:20 It freezes up.

0:57:22 It makes me not happy to be here.

0:57:24 I want my happy back.

0:57:25 And then it was followed by 40 to 50 exclamation points.

0:57:29 We were able to get this particular individual at a computer

0:57:32 because we had extras available.

0:57:35 But at this point, we don't have any extras available.

0:57:37 And we have a lot of people who are extremely unhappy

0:57:40 with the WISE computers, which are BDI boxes

0:57:43 that they currently have.

0:57:45 So I wanted to give you a little background

0:57:46 on how we got to where we are.

0:57:49 In 2014, 15 fiscal year, we had the IS department budgeted

0:57:54 to purchase 90 Dell WISE boxes.

0:57:57 These are BDI boxes, so their virtual desktop infrastructure

0:58:02 is what they are.

0:58:03 The idea behind them is that all the processing

0:58:05 would take place at the server,

0:58:07 and the boxes are just kind of a display,

0:58:09 kind of going back to the olden days where it was just a box, it didn't really do anything.

0:58:15 The response, this was supposed to eliminate the amount of time that the tech support was

0:58:20 spending on keeping the computers up to date. It wasn't to save money because they, with

0:58:25 the cost of licensing and everything, they ended up costing about the same as a regular

0:58:29 box. So they tested it with about 10 computers. It worked great. The 10 people that were

0:58:38 in the test environment didn't have any problems with it

0:58:40 and they thought it was wonderful.

0:58:42 So then they went out and added 50 more computers.

0:58:46 And at that point is when people began complaining,

0:58:50 the response times were terrible.

0:58:52 So as an IIS staff, we went out and thought,

0:58:55 how can we fix this?

0:58:56 So we bought some software, which is called Pernix,

0:58:59 and this software is supposed to,

0:59:01 it is said to increase virtual desktop performance

0:59:06 with a cost-effective scale growth.

0:59:08 And so it was supposed to make the desktops work a little faster.

0:59:12 It didn't improve the response time, so we quit using that

0:59:17 after it proved not to be helpful.

0:59:19 We also purchased some video cards,

0:59:21 which were supposed to enhance the speed.

0:59:23 And we upgraded our blades, but all these enhancements

0:59:26 didn't make a difference to the actual end result.

0:59:29 And so our users were just getting more and more frustrated.

0:59:32 Some of these users have been using these VDI boxes

0:59:35 for over a year and I ran some members on the support calls

0:59:39 just to see where they were going in.

0:59:41 We have about 70% more support calls

0:59:44 from those people with VDI boxes.

0:59:46 So not only are they slow when troublesome,

0:59:48 they're causing them to have to call us

0:59:50 and try and get support.

0:59:53 We swapped out 20 of the VDI use boxes already

0:59:57 with regular Dell computers.

1:00:01 Most of those were because of video problems

1:00:04 the VDI boxes didn't work very well with video at all,

1:00:08 because the video would have to process locally,

1:00:10 go to the server, and then come back

1:00:12 instead of just processing it on the machine directly.

1:00:15 So anyone who needed video automatically got a desktop

1:00:19 that we had available.

1:00:20 So at this point, we're out of extra desktops.

1:00:23 We don't have anything else to give.

1:00:26 And we still have 40 users, and probably about

1:00:30 half of those are happy with their VDI boxes.

1:00:33 They're low-end users.

1:00:34 they don't do much processing.

1:00:36 But the cost to maintain the software and infrastructure

1:00:39 and push out those VBIs just isn't worth keeping

1:00:42 for keeping 20 people happy,

1:00:45 because they will be just as happy with a desktop.

1:00:47 So it's not a thing that we would really want to do,

1:00:53 but I'm before you asking to be able to purchase computers

1:00:56 to replace these VBIs.

1:00:58 It's costing a lot of time on both sides,

1:01:00 the user side and the support side.

1:01:06 Before Dell came and volunteered to come to a meeting with me,

1:01:10 I ran the number on what the replacement costs would be just

1:01:13 in the time getting our existing licensing fees.

1:01:19 And software that we knew that we had to purchase in the next year

1:01:23 if we were going to keep the EDIs.

1:01:25 And it came out to be about three and a half years

1:01:27 that it would take to pay that off.

1:01:29 But since that time, Dell has come and they actually have

1:01:33 volunteered to lower some of their prices for us,

1:01:38 so that we'll get that amount back through discounts,

1:01:42 enhanced discounts on top of what we'd already get.

1:01:45 On top of that, they've given us a server.

1:01:47 I had thought from the information I was provided,

1:01:50 it was estimated at $64,000, but we have an invoice now,

1:01:54 and it would have been $33,746 for the server

1:01:58 that they provided to us.

1:01:59 And they gave that to us absolutely free

1:02:01 to try and increase the speeds of these VDI boxes.

1:02:05 But unfortunately, that didn't work.

1:02:06 So they're letting us keep the server.

1:02:08 And on top of that, they're willing to sell us

1:02:11 a second sister server for $12,000.

1:02:14 So that's another $21,746 that they're discounting us

1:02:22 so that we can have a server and a sister server

1:02:25 for redundancy.

1:02:28 For the existing VDI boxes that we have,

1:02:31 I contacted all kinds of people

1:02:33 trying to find someone who would be willing to buy them.

1:02:35 And I found,

1:02:37 for family health services said that they would be interested

1:02:40 in purchasing them for $50 a piece.

1:02:43 And we have 90 of them, approximately 90 of them.

1:02:46 So that would be income that we would get

1:02:49 from the sale of those existing VDI boxes.

1:02:52 Dell also has a buyback program.

1:02:54 So before we sell these to family health services,

1:02:58 We're just going to verify that the amount that we're getting is more than what Del would

1:03:02 have given us for the buyback program.

1:03:05 There was one other thing that I neglected was that the $34,950 is going to be the total

1:03:13 cost that we need to replace these 40 pieces of equipment and the DVI display adapter.

1:03:19 I thought we had enough of those around that we wouldn't have to buy those but we are going

1:03:24 to need to purchase those DVI display adapters.

1:03:27 So the 34, 950 is the total cost that we would need to replace these 40 devices.

1:03:34 And I have, Mike, did you want to add anything or did I cover everything?

1:03:38 So Mike's here if you have any questions.

1:03:41 And so Mike.

1:03:42 So.

1:03:45 She's here in Hawkins.

1:03:46 Thank you.

1:03:47 So my first question, the video cards we bought for the boxes that we're getting rid of,

1:03:52 are they not usable to come out and be moved to the new computers instead of buying video

1:03:56 cards for all the new computers as well?

1:03:58 a video card that we bought was actually for the server side, so it was a card that goes

1:04:02 on the server to enhance the device.

1:04:04 Okay.

1:04:05 I thought you put some in some of the boxes, you said?

1:04:07 No.

1:04:08 Just inside of the server.

1:04:09 Okay.

1:04:10 It's a video card for the server.

1:04:11 And is it not possible to configure these computers with video cards that have the DVI

1:04:15 output, so we don't have to purchase the adapter instead of the DisplayPort?

1:04:24 Hm.

1:04:25 I thought you, is it just, what type of video slot is in that computer, because you should

1:04:32 to be able to get a car split.

1:04:34 Probably be helpful if you went to the mic.

1:04:44 Because people, my voice is bad.

1:04:46 Sorry, Boise State came by the way.

1:04:48 So the units that you purchased, so the concept was that from the server is where all the real thinking

1:04:57 and the construct happens, right?

1:04:59 So that's where the power in the car needs to be at the server.

1:05:02 When this initially was designed by the city folks and ourselves, we attempted to keep our

1:05:09 cost as low as we possibly could and utilize an older server that you have on staff.

1:05:15 So that was already depreciated and still functional, but the two did not make well older

1:05:21 technology in the new or tech industry that we didn't go into.

1:05:23 I guess what I'm looking at is on this bid for the 40 computers that we're looking at purchasing.

1:05:27 There are video cards included.

1:05:30 Why are we buying video cards with display, the display output where we need to buy the

1:05:35 DVI adapters instead of just putting video cards in them with DVI output.

1:05:39 Two different animals. So the VDI machines are almost what they call a dumb terminal.

1:05:43 Right, but I'm not looking at those at all. So we have a bid for 40 new computers that

1:05:50 include the Radeon video cards, but they come with the display output, the display port

1:05:56 output, and so now we're having to buy adapters to convert that to DVI. Why can't we put video

1:06:01 cards in these 40 machines that have the DVI output already, so we're not

1:06:06 buying all the adapters.

1:06:07 The processing power doesn't exist. So in other words, the new machines that she

1:06:11 wants, those are standalone machines. So all the processing power is at the end instead

1:06:17 of at the server layer. Okay. Does that make sense? Yes. Thank you.

1:06:22 Not compatible.

1:06:27 And this isn't, I'm thinking probably what you're asking is a lot of the desk

1:06:32 have dual monitors and that adapter helps give both monitors display that second.

1:06:39 We just normally sit ends up with HDMI and DBI so that you don't have to have the display

1:06:44 port with the adapter to save the extra cost and we are doing them with i7 processors and

1:06:49 very similar configurations so just curious.

1:06:55 Be glad to compare what you currently have against this just to show you the difference

1:06:59 if you'd like to see it.

1:07:01 That's fine thank you.

1:07:02 Well, Kathy, this is before you came on board, but it sure looks like the city either in an

1:07:10 incomplete or wrong speck on our needs or it was not understood by the vendor of what the

1:07:18 operation needed to include.

1:07:21 I'm not in the habit of rewarding our failure by giving another bid was going to be different.

1:07:28 this over buying a new package say from Hill of Packard where you're

1:07:32 expecting the thing. It looks like Dell tried to make accommodations and

1:07:37 corrections was unequal to the task on this but where did we do a wrong

1:07:43 spec to begin with and what kind of guarantee do we have on the new package

1:07:48 is going to work. The new package is the same desktops that we use throughout the

1:07:53 We have like 264 of these in existence for existing users, and we use the Dell case with it to push out our software.

1:08:04 So we have the infrastructure in place already for these devices.

1:08:08 You say Dell has the architecture that we can't change midstream with a non-compatible sourcing like HP.

1:08:19 Does the case work with HP?

1:08:21 Yes.

1:08:22 case will work with HP and did we do the wrong spacking? Where does our fault lie?

1:08:26 Again I pointed out that when we originally designed and when we all sit down and

1:08:32 design the piece we were trying to keep your capital costs as low as possible for

1:08:36 the proof of concept and we were using over HP servers that you had in your

1:08:41 facilities. What had happened was the servers just couldn't perform they just

1:08:47 simply could not drive that new architecture.

1:08:49 I don't know.

1:08:54 Kathy, did you say it was $34,950?

1:08:57 Yes.

1:08:59 Yes.

1:09:02 There's a little different thing on here, right?

1:09:04 Well, let's see.

1:09:05 Look at the...

1:09:06 It's on...

1:09:07 I don't know what page it was exactly, but it's the quote number 101, 5111, 460, 561.1.

1:09:16 Go ahead.

1:09:17 No.

1:09:18 I just have one other question.

1:09:21 So I understand we got the original server value.33 something.

1:09:27 Right.

1:09:28 Now the second server we're purchasing at 21.

1:09:32 They have offered to sell us the second server for $12,000.

1:09:37 We don't have that money in this budget year.

1:09:40 So if we do decide to purchase that second server,

1:09:43 it would come from next year's server funds, which would be after October 1st.

1:09:47 So you're not asking for that in addition.

1:09:50 Thank you.

1:09:51 Thank you.

1:09:53 Any questions?

1:09:54 I do.

1:09:55 One of the pieces that may help is that the server that we gifted to the city will carry

1:10:02 you for the next ten years for your needs, or even longer.

1:10:07 It's very, very powerful machine.

1:10:09 Is that in running?

1:10:11 I don't know anything in computer world in the last ten years.

1:10:16 I'll send you the specs of making you understand it.

1:10:18 You never make me understand it.

1:10:21 It's staggering for one.

1:10:23 Thank you, Nicky Boyd.

1:10:25 My question is, the family health services

1:10:29 that may be interested in purchasing,

1:10:32 do they understand what they're actually purchasing?

1:10:35 Is this a system that they know that they can use?

1:10:40 I have told them if they wanted to,

1:10:42 they could use one of them first to make sure it works for them.

1:10:46 And we explained that is the wise box

1:10:49 and gave them the model number and the serial numbers

1:10:51 and gave them a link to the Dell site.

1:10:54 He believes he'll be able to use them,

1:10:57 but I want to make sure that he can before we actually

1:10:59 set them to them, because otherwise we'll sell them back

1:11:01 to Dell.

1:11:02 Thank you.

1:11:02 That's my recommendation.

1:11:04 And if it's not a good fit for them, let's not do that.

1:11:08 Not sell that to them.

1:11:11 Yes.

1:11:13 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:11:14 Sorry, just a housekeeping note.

1:11:15 I noticed that the shipping contact is still

1:11:17 Eli on the contract and I think that needs to be addressed.

1:11:23 I noticed that also.

1:11:24 Thank you.

1:11:26 Chris talking to me.

1:11:27 Yeah, one other follow up.

1:11:29 Do I understand we have a total population of approximately 260 citywide 240 and they all

1:11:38 operate through one server.

1:11:40 Am I in?

1:11:41 No, we have several servers.

1:11:43 Okay.

1:11:44 those 264 operate through one software product called Delcase and that software

1:11:51 product allows us to push out whatever MSI is or software that we want to push

1:11:55 out to those machines. So that way we don't have to go touch each machine.

1:12:00 But we have an adequate number of servers. I'm thinking that we have about 80

1:12:06 servers and there's a difference between software and hardware servers. Those are

1:12:11 about 80 software servers, hardware servers, we use blades and so I don't know how many

1:12:18 physical boxes we actually have, I don't think we have one.

1:12:23 Most of it's virtualized, so we created virtualization for you to drive additional hardware, additional

1:12:31 hardware, additional compute power.

1:12:35 So we don't have a lot of boxes sitting at like the old traditional servers in the back room,

1:12:40 We have blades which are hard disk arrays,

1:12:43 and then we do virtual servers on those hard disks arrays.

1:12:47 These two, this one server that they gave us

1:12:49 is an actual physical server that came in one item,

1:12:54 and it has, what was it, 64 processors?

1:12:57 Around 64 processors, it's like a super machine,

1:13:00 and we are analyzing to see what will work best for it.

1:13:06 One of the big problems with a machine of this grade

1:13:08 in this caliber that they gave us,

1:13:10 is the Microsoft licensing is outrageously expensive for it.

1:13:14 So we have to make sure that whatever we put on it,

1:13:17 the licensing fees aren't gonna kill us,

1:13:19 because a lot of times Microsoft charges per processor

1:13:21 or per poor, so we wanna make sure that whatever we do

1:13:25 with it isn't gonna break us licensing-wise.

1:13:30 Done, huh?

1:13:31 So I've been trying to make a motion,

1:13:33 but I wanna make sure that I say it right.

1:13:35 This is going to be coming out of the contingency

1:13:37 in the Capital Improvement Funds.

1:13:39 for the total amount of $34,950.

1:13:43 Okay.

1:13:44 And both Lori and Travis have reviewed that.

1:13:48 So I would make the motion that we approve

1:13:50 the purchase of $40 Dell OptiPlex, $740 SFF computers,

1:13:56 along with a Dell adapter display port to DVI single link

1:14:02 in a total amount of $34,950

1:14:06 that would come out of the contingency

1:14:09 in the capital improvement fund.

1:14:12 Ruth Pierce.

1:14:13 I'll second that.

1:14:15 Motion by Don Hall, seconded by Ruth Pierce

1:14:17 to approve the purchase as requested.

1:14:20 Greg Lanting.

1:14:23 That's the last time I was able to keep up

1:14:25 with what was going on.

1:14:26 There was 446s or something in the name of the computer.

1:14:30 So I'm going to trust our tech people.

1:14:32 That's Regent Hire.

1:14:33 I won't be voting yes.

1:14:37 Any other discussion for the council?

1:14:40 Seeing none, Sharon, Rolf, although, please.

1:14:46 Nikki Boyd.

1:14:47 Yes.

1:14:48 Sean Bericke.

1:14:49 Yes.

1:14:50 Chris talking.

1:14:52 No.

1:14:53 Greg Lanting.

1:14:54 Yes.

1:14:55 Don Hall.

1:14:56 Yes.

1:14:57 Ruth Pears.

1:14:58 Yes.

1:14:59 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:15:00 Yes.

1:15:01 Motion passes 6-2-1.

1:15:02 Thank you very much and thank you for Mike for being here to support.

1:15:05 Thank you.

1:15:06 Next on the agenda is a request to award the 2016 Zone Maintenance Sewer Improvement

1:15:13 project to Idaho materials and construction and the amount of two hundred eighty eight thousand three hundred ninety five dollars

1:15:20 We have our public works director John Kate

1:15:22 Welcome John. Thank you mayor. Good evening

1:15:25 I'm here tonight to tell you a little bit about this project and then as council to consider awarding

1:15:31 this contract

1:15:36 We've got some up here John of the new lease bodies

1:16:01 So this sewer project is to orient you where we're at, here's five points, here's City

1:16:12 Park.

1:16:13 So this is Blue Lakes and of course Addison up here.

1:16:16 And the sewer line that we have designed to be replaced runs in this alley, we call it

1:16:22 the clinic line because it's behind the old clinic on the corner of Shoshone and Seventh.

1:16:29 The sewer line from blue lakes all the way to Addison is is old it's sags

1:16:35 There's a lot of there's a lot of large kitchens there that you know

1:16:39 There's grease and all sorts of things and because of the because of the age of the sewer it needs to be replaced

1:16:47 So we we designed an EHM designed the whole project

1:16:51 We intended to and we did bid half the project because of the

1:16:55 because of the expected cost to replace it.

1:17:00 We knew we were going to have to phase it into two pieces.

1:17:03 So we bid this north portion from Addison to Shoshone, and we bid that in August, and

1:17:12 the bids came in as are described in the agenda item.

1:17:18 The Idaho materials construction was 288,395, extreme excavation, 388, 9th river, 430,000.

1:17:29 And as you can see, the engineer's estimate was 415,000, which is right in between the

1:17:34 two, the two upper.

1:17:38 The little bid is a good bid from a reputable company.

1:17:43 And at this time, I'd like to ask Council to award this contract to Idaho materials.

1:17:51 Christogans.

1:17:52 Move to award the 2016 Zone Maintenance Sewer Improvement Project to Idaho Materials Instruction

1:17:57 for $288,395.

1:18:00 Second.

1:18:01 Motion by Christogans and second by Nikki Boyd to approve the request.

1:18:07 I do have a question, John.

1:18:08 What would be the timeline for the construction on this?

1:18:11 Okay, good.

1:18:12 I want to make a comment on that as well.

1:18:15 we would probably, we were allowed, this is in an alley,

1:18:19 and so it won't really affect traffic that belly,

1:18:22 and I don't know what you're thinking about downtown

1:18:24 the time we have downtown and everything,

1:18:26 but most of this work is in the alley,

1:18:28 so we can accommodate the local traffic.

1:18:32 Because there's not a lot of pavement,

1:18:34 we can do some of the work in the winter,

1:18:36 so we're allowing the contractor a long window

1:18:39 to get the work done, I believe until May 15th,

1:18:44 So I'd also like to mention that because the price is so good,

1:18:49 we're gonna be talking to the contractor

1:18:51 to see if they would change or end the other half of the project.

1:18:56 I have to talk to Lori to see about some finance and money,

1:19:01 but it's a really good price, so we can find money.

1:19:03 We'll do that.

1:19:05 Thank you, Greg Lanting.

1:19:06 John, I've asked you this question,

1:19:07 and I'm sure about this same company before,

1:19:09 but whenever the low bids, 25% or more,

1:19:13 less than the other beds that tends to make us a little nervous, at least this me, about

1:19:19 the quality of work. We worked with Idaho materials previously, I'm sure, and each and

1:19:27 people would like to persuade my fears and go for it.

1:19:31 Tim lost with EHM engineers. I had the same reservations as yourself. I talked with John,

1:19:38 agreed that it would be best to contact auto materials,

1:19:42 especially on a couple of the unit prices,

1:19:46 just for verification that they hadn't made it

1:19:48 mathematical or some kind of obvious error

1:19:53 that they left something out.

1:19:56 Their statement to me was that this time,

1:19:59 they're busy like everyone else,

1:20:02 but their underground crews really needed the work.

1:20:05 They wanted to keep them busy through the fall.

1:20:08 That was why the aggressive schedules put in the aggressive a little bit.

1:20:12 Okay. Thank you, Jim. Good point, Greg.

1:20:15 Any other questions for John? Seeing none, we do have a motion to approve the request as presented.

1:20:25 Sharon, roll call vote, please.

1:20:27 John, Greg, yes.

1:20:30 Chris Hockington, Greg Lanting, yes.

1:20:33 Don Hall, Ruth Pierce, yes.

1:20:35 Suzanne Hawkins, yes.

1:20:37 Nikki Boyd, yes.

1:20:39 Motion passes seven to zero. Thank you John

1:20:43 Thank you

1:20:46 Next on the agenda is a request to award the 2016 South Hills packaged irrigation pump station

1:20:54 Procurement contract to hd Fowler of Twin Falls in the amount of

1:21:01 $129,900 and we have the placement. Welcome Lee

1:21:05 Good evening mayor council. That's the the short version of the name of the project

1:21:12 Yeah, this is on the south side of town, just to give you a little bit of background.

1:21:19 The new South Hill school is located right here.

1:21:22 This is Harris Street, this is 3600 North, Washington Street is over here.

1:21:27 The new pressurized irrigation station will be located right there at that location.

1:21:32 So we're going to be building a wet well out there and this project is the procurement of

1:21:39 the skid. It's the pump skid. It's a packaged unit. It comes in basically a turn key type

1:21:45 of vitamin you hook up your electricity to it and water. And that station will be able

1:21:51 to provide pressurized irrigation to several subdivisions out there currently. We have this

1:21:56 subdivision here and over and here that are all on potable water. Those were all constructed

1:22:02 at one time with the after 2000, which required the pressurized irrigation piping. But since

1:22:08 we didn't have a station out in this area that could provide the water to it. We've

1:22:12 been providing it with potable water. So with this new specialized irrigation

1:22:16 station, we'll be able to pull them off of potable water, free it up for culinary

1:22:20 uses rather than landscape watering. And we'll be able to also probably take you

1:22:28 on another two times that area with the station. We open bids and the

1:22:39 The low bidder was HD valor of Twin Falls and the amount of $129,900 and we expect the work to be done in the spring.

1:22:51 And staff recommends that we're all living the procurement contract HD.

1:22:56 Thank you, Boyd.

1:22:59 I'm ready to make a motion if.

1:23:01 Great to see you.

1:23:02 I'm curious.

1:23:03 You said a couple of subdivisions are on using potable water now for about how many homes are we talking about?

1:23:09 from about how many gallons the guests work save.

1:23:12 I'm kind of curious about how we can conserve.

1:23:14 Our station itself is right now it's capable,

1:23:18 it'll be capable of 900 gallons per minute

1:23:20 and with two additional pumps it'll be able

1:23:23 to supply 1800 gallons per minute.

1:23:25 Give a little bit of an idea.

1:23:27 1800 or 900 gallons per minute will handle somewhere

1:23:34 between 133 acres and 160 acres of development.

1:23:39 And so we should be able to, and then when we have the additional two pumps in the future, it could be

1:23:45 you know over 200, 250 acres. It's really about the canal company being able to supply the water to the station.

1:23:52 But as it sits right now, it'll be able to do out of the box 900 gallons per minute, which is about 133 acres.

1:24:00 Oh, that's worth bragging about. That's really good news.

1:24:02 So it's basically a quarter mile by quarter mile square.

1:24:06 I just want to make sure I'm clear so we an accepting a bit of 129 the total

1:24:18 budget is 205 is there another phase included in that two oh five actually

1:24:23 construct the wet well okay on top of that's that's the part that the canal

1:24:29 water is delivered into and then we suck the water out of the pump station so of

1:24:33 With that original 205, how much if it was allocated for the procurement itself?

1:24:40 Well, we had estimated that it would be about 140,000 and the actual structure itself would

1:24:46 be around 60,000.

1:24:47 Okay.

1:24:48 Thank you.

1:24:49 These houses were already on, at least, excuse me, these houses were already on potable

1:24:56 waters.

1:24:57 This is some of the ones that we made the realization that they had already paid more

1:25:01 We're actually charging them the PI price for their water rather than they're actually

1:25:06 U-seeds at this time.

1:25:07 Yeah, they're not individually metered.

1:25:09 Okay.

1:25:10 Thank you.

1:25:11 Yeah, they're on the PI pricing.

1:25:13 Right.

1:25:14 Thank you.

1:25:16 Nicky boy.

1:25:17 Right.

1:25:18 I moved to award the 2016 South Hills Packaged Irrigation Pump Station Procurement Contract

1:25:25 to HD Fowler of Twin Falls, Idaho in the amount of $129.9.

1:25:32 Thank you.

1:25:33 Motion by Nikki Boyd, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the request as presented.

1:25:39 Is there any discussion with the council?

1:25:43 Seeing none, share and roll a call vote please.

1:25:46 Chris Hockington?

1:25:47 Yes.

1:25:48 Greg Lanting?

1:25:49 Yes.

1:25:50 Don Hall?

1:25:51 Yes.

1:25:52 Ruth Pierce?

1:25:53 Yes.

1:25:54 Suzanne Hawkins?

1:25:55 Yes.

1:25:56 Nikki Boyd?

1:25:57 Yes.

1:25:58 Sean Berker?

1:25:59 Yes.

1:26:05 Motion passes 7-0.

1:26:06 Thank you very much.

1:26:07 the city manager or city council is there anyone else from the public who

1:26:11 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:26:20 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:26:26 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:26:32 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:26:35 talking to them opposed it and I'm disappointed that the rest of you supported spending another

1:26:41 thirty five thousand dollars with the vendor who for two years has not been able to deliver

1:26:47 what we purchased and is not able to provide compatible equipment at this point. I'd ask

1:26:55 the council to reconsider that vote and to put this out to bid give other vendors a chance

1:27:04 to come up with compatibility issues and to come up with equipment that we know will

1:27:13 do the job instead of rewarding a company that for two years has not been able to make

1:27:18 what they sold its work. Thank you.

1:27:21 Thank you, Mr. Moore. Anyone else from the public who wishes to address the Council? Seeing

1:27:30 then? Don Hall.

1:27:32 I would just like to let the Council know we had a very interesting meeting today at the

1:27:37 urban and rural agency and a lot of good decisions, a lot of good information came our way.

1:27:42 I had to get out a lot of there a little bit early because I had a conflicting meeting.

1:27:46 So I just asked Travis if he could just maybe brief counsel of what took place today.

1:27:55 So I think that there were a series of really good decisions that were made by the council

1:28:02 that really advanced several of the projects that the agency has been working on for quite

1:28:07 a while.

1:28:09 One of the decisions today was to have the board consider a CMGC for the five block downtown

1:28:14 project.

1:28:15 They went through a process in which there were six individuals that had expressed a level

1:28:22 of interest.

1:28:23 I believe that there were five that ended up submitting proposals and there was a short

1:28:28 list made of two firms.

1:28:30 I have the opportunity of being one of six individuals serving on the interview panel

1:28:36 all four of the two firms that were shortlisted.

1:28:39 One was McElvane Construction, the other was Guho Construction.

1:28:43 Paul Johnson was CH2M Hill, who was the agency's owner representative

1:28:46 on the project, really went through a good job in detailing the process that was used.

1:28:51 And at the end of the day, I think that Paul said it best.

1:28:54 Both firms were incredibly competent, incredibly skilled in doing that work.

1:29:00 It really came down to who we felt was going to be the best connection and

1:29:04 best fit for the merchants in the downtown core who really seem to understand the value

1:29:10 and the importance of starting off with that relationship on an early footing.

1:29:15 And so they selected Guho construction out of Boise.

1:29:19 Guho is a firm that has done Broad Street recently.

1:29:23 They've done 8th and Maine recently and they're also working on that center, Boise, center

1:29:29 on the Grove terminal project as well.

1:29:32 So they're very, very skilled at streetscape, they're very skilled at urban projects and

1:29:37 working with existing customers.

1:29:39 And, for me, Guho was the company that I had selected.

1:29:42 I was one of the four who had selected them.

1:29:46 Two others had selected McElvane, and again, it was because of their experience and their,

1:29:52 I think, their ability to connect with the project.

1:29:55 The second was, this was Phil Cushland's last official meeting as the interim director,

1:30:01 And I think that as it was expressed by the members of the board, and I would certainly

1:30:04 echo that, that Phil really did an outstanding job getting us to the place that we are today.

1:30:11 Nate Murray now will be responsible for moving those meetings forward, and we also have a

1:30:17 special agreement with Phil so that Phil can be kind of Nate's wingman, if you will, as

1:30:22 we had kind of contemplated, as Nate continues to get up to speed, learn the intricacies and

1:30:28 the issues. It's a good opportunity to be able to have Phil have an on-call contract, so that's

1:30:34 already pre-negotiated for what that looks like. We expect Nate to be carrying on most of that

1:30:39 work and moving that forward, but he'll also be utilizing Nate as he kind of moves forward.

1:30:46 Similarly, the agency also entered into a agreement, as I understand it, that would also

1:30:52 allow them to have expertise in addition to what they receive from Fritz, but also with

1:30:57 Elam and Burke out of Boise.

1:30:58 And so where Fritz, I look at his kind of being like your general doctor,

1:31:03 Elam and Burke, is kind of like that person you go to if you need a surgery.

1:31:07 And so as I was talking with Dan Bursey at the end, you know,

1:31:10 they have every intent of utilizing both areas to the maximum of their ability,

1:31:14 moving forward, maintaining that continuity.

1:31:16 We had an update on the downtown project and we're going to be making sure

1:31:20 that they come and make that same presentation to you in October.

1:31:24 But right now, just to kind of give you an update, it is an agency review.

1:31:28 I believe that they're at about 90 percent design review.

1:31:33 Once they are at 100 percent review, then they go out to bid, and then we'll start that process.

1:31:38 We've been holding the plans back so that the CMGC could get on board.

1:31:43 They could review those for any potential changes and issues that they kind of want to move forward with.

1:31:49 And also to get some suggestions on three basements.

1:31:52 We've talked about how we have those three basements that kind of encroach into the public,

1:31:57 right?

1:31:58 So we've been using Brits and his guidance and we believe that two of the three basements

1:32:02 based upon the analysis and the in-depth structural research that has been done are totally fine

1:32:08 and there's no recommendation to do anything to make those changes.

1:32:11 And those are the two Wells Fargo and the current city hall location.

1:32:18 Those are structurally reinforced.

1:32:21 The other one that they're kind of looking at is the old Crowley's in front of moose,

1:32:25 and also moose scale.

1:32:26 That is one that is still, they want to do a little bit more examinations and a little

1:32:32 bit more looking in terms of the best solution.

1:32:35 The cost to either stabilize the cap that's on top or to remove the cap and then to move

1:32:41 forward and fill in that basement, they range from between 60 and $120,000 in the agency

1:32:48 right now is talking about how to fund that, some sort of cost sharing mechanism with the

1:32:54 individual property owner.

1:32:58 The alleyway?

1:32:59 The bids coming in on the house.

1:33:01 Yeah, so the alleyway work, and I think that it was shared, was that there was some dry utilities

1:33:07 and the dry utilities are going to be the gas and the electrical, and I think John left,

1:33:16 I think maybe left.

1:33:21 So, okay, it was a dry utility.

1:33:24 My understanding is that there are very few firms in the state of Idaho who have the ability

1:33:30 to install dry utilities as for both Idaho power and intermelon gas.

1:33:38 And so because of that workload, and because of other restrictions that were placed upon

1:33:44 the job, the bids came in significantly, several factors higher than what was originally anticipated.

1:33:50 And because the removal of those and the replacement of those lines or the responsibility of the

1:33:57 individual utility companies, the solution was to reject those bids.

1:34:02 And so they're out re-tweaking the agreement, having conversations with those firms to find

1:34:08 a way to get bids that are much more in line with the engineering estimate.

1:34:15 And the problem was, is there was only one bidder.

1:34:18 the one bidder submitted that one bid and it was significantly higher than what was anticipated,

1:34:23 so they're still looking at that two-block project. Part of the issues are how do you

1:34:28 lengthen that window so that they have more flexibility in moving forward, and so Ivan

1:34:34 McCracken with JUB is in constant contact with those individuals and trying to find a solution

1:34:39 to that now.

1:34:42 factors means four times the engineers guess.

1:34:46 So that's four times, yep, early significant.

1:34:50 So council, that's my report with the URA.

1:34:53 Excellent.

1:34:54 I have a standard report, John.

1:34:56 Thank you, Travis.

1:34:57 Thank you, Travis.

1:34:59 Anything else from members of the council?

1:35:03 Anything else from you, Travis?

1:35:07 So the downtown project is just one of the many projects that we have going on right

1:35:11 now.

1:35:12 Next week, just a quick reminder for the council, we're going to be meeting at three

1:35:15 We ask that you come here, we'll enter into session, and then we'll be carevounding out

1:35:21 to the airport to take a tour of the current airport construction, kind of get that walk

1:35:27 through and move forward.

1:35:29 The following week we'll be having an update on the City Hall project as well as opening

1:35:34 and asking the council to improve guaranteed maximum price on the public safety complex,

1:35:41 that second piece.

1:35:42 We opened bids for the public safety building, those remaining portions that we didn't secure

1:35:46 bids for.

1:35:49 This Thursday we've had conversations with Michael Errington and he is a lot more excited

1:35:55 about this opening than he was the last time there's a lot more response and I know that

1:36:01 there's a lot more response because of the work that Michael and his team are doing and

1:36:07 they are spending a lot of time in a very busy construction season getting the right

1:36:11 bidders on the job. We're still very confident in the numbers and we'll know

1:36:17 more after we open up the bids and have a chance to review them. Also there's been

1:36:23 some question about, okay, so you moved really really fast on City Hall. Why aren't

1:36:27 you now moving for construction? And it's important to just to kind of walk

1:36:32 back just a second. We wanted to take a look at the City Hall and get it to a

1:36:36 a place of demolition so we could continue that last bit of structural analysis.

1:36:42 Completing that structural analysis and now we have 90% plans to the city for our review.

1:36:48 Those 90% plans should be reviewed by the, I think it's the end of next week.

1:36:54 And then any comments and corrections will be made.

1:36:56 We'll transform those into bidable documents and we anticipate bidding the city hall piece

1:37:02 in October, early October.

1:37:06 the biz in early October. We'll start that bid process in September.

1:37:09 Thank you, Travis. Seeing no other items from anybody up here, we will move to our public

1:37:19 hearings. Excuse me. So our first public hearing is a request for amendment to latitude

1:37:25 42 PUD numbered 272 to modify development requirements for Cheney Drive West, a collector

1:37:32 between Fieldstone Drive and Creek Sideway. And we will have our presentation from Gerald

1:37:39 Martin's not from Gerald Martin's from Gary Sledy welcome mr. Sledy good

1:37:45 evening mayor members of the council my name is Gary Sledy Gerald Martin's was

1:37:51 called out of town unexpectedly today so you're stuck with Todd Blass and me as

1:37:58 the owners representatives of the latitude PUD we are before the council

1:38:04 tonight on a QD amendment that would allow the width of

1:38:14 Chini Drive line on the south boundary of latitude 42 to be 39 feet wide in terms of

1:38:25 the paved width with a 50 foot right of way.

1:38:30 The construction that this would allow would be consistent with the agreement that was reached

1:38:38 between and among the developers lying to the east and south of latitude 42 as well as the

1:38:48 city of Twin Falls.

1:38:51 What this allowed basically was the construction.

1:38:57 The whole idea was it was going to be impossible to get Chien Drive extended to the west because

1:39:02 the trailer park was in the way.

1:39:07 The only way that it came together was for the various parties who were the developers

1:39:14 and the city to reach an agreement as to how construction would be accomplished lying west

1:39:21 of Grandview.

1:39:23 you have the Reformed Church just for ease of location. The city has previously

1:39:30 approved the construction plans for the length of the roadway, lying to the west

1:39:38 of Grandview Drive, and if you've been out there and as the pictures in the

1:39:43 staff report depict, the curb and gutter has been constructed consistent with the

1:39:49 approved construction plans. The south boundary or this south right away line has been firmly

1:40:00 established by the city in the context of the approvals of all the various PUDs that

1:40:10 lie a budding Chini Drive West, lot one of latitude 42 in this location has been approved

1:40:21 by the city and it established the north boundary of the Chini Drive right of way.

1:40:32 So I think what we're asking for is approval of the amendment of the PUD so that it would

1:40:40 be consistent with the construction techniques that have been approved by the city all the

1:40:47 way from Grandview Drive lying to the west.

1:40:51 I know that it specifies it's a collector width, but I think it's pretty evident to see

1:40:57 that the scope of development on these properties accessing the street to the south are pretty

1:41:06 evident as well as the development of the subdivisions that have already been approved

1:41:14 on the south side of Keeney.

1:41:16 So as I indicated, luckily we're here tonight with the unanimous recommendation of approval

1:41:24 by your planning and zoning commission.

1:41:27 We also have Dave Teane of EHM engineers here tonight in case you have any questions from

1:41:35 an engineering perspective, I would also state that not only is the curb and

1:41:42 gutter installed on this particular portion of the latitude property consistent

1:41:49 with the city's approved plans, but also the water and sewer lines are already in

1:41:55 place if only to add further emphasis as to why this amendment should be considered

1:42:02 as an approval by the city council.

1:42:06 If you have any questions, I'm happy to respond.

1:42:08 I think the staff report certainly has detailed

1:42:12 all facets of the application.

1:42:15 Thank you, Mr. Sledany.

1:42:16 Questions for Gary?

1:42:17 Chris?

1:42:18 No, I don't.

1:42:19 Gary, I just want to make sure you're aware

1:42:20 of the recommendations that are going to be attached to this.

1:42:25 Oh, Chris, thank you.

1:42:27 Yes, the condition relative to this approval only

1:42:33 extends to this location.

1:42:36 So there is a gap that in the event,

1:42:40 there is a required need for a deceleration or turn lane

1:42:44 off to the north that is still available for the city.

1:42:50 And the other conditions as suggest

1:42:53 by the Planning and Zoning Commission.

1:42:56 Thank you.

1:42:57 Thank you.

1:43:00 We will now have our staff report from Jonathan Spendlove.

1:43:04 Thank you Mayor and Council members.

1:43:07 the brief history on the property for the council and anybody listening on the

1:43:10 audience history is in 2005 the City Council approved annexation for this area

1:43:17 and some other areas out there there's no change to the zoning designation of R2

1:43:22 2009 four years later they rezoned it from R2 to C1 there's a declaration of

1:43:28 deed restriction recorded 2009 stating some conditions as far as the width of the

1:43:32 roadway as well.

1:43:34 January 2011, the Council approved a request to rezone the property from C1 to a PUD, that

1:43:40 PUD would encompass their property only for a lot of 242.

1:43:45 With that, there were a couple of conditions.

1:43:47 I won't read all of them, but the one that's pertinent to tonight is number two, subject

1:43:51 to arterial and collector streets adjacent, and within the property being dedicated to

1:43:55 the city of Tofuen Falls and to be rebuilt or built to current city standards upon development

1:43:59 of the property.

1:44:00 Then in February of this year 2016 the Commission planning his only commission approved the preliminary

1:44:06 Platt consisting of 18 commercial law subject to conditions and then in March the City Council

1:44:12 approved the PUD agreement that had those conditions originally from 2011.

1:44:18 Then there was a single lot Platt approved in March and that was for this corner.

1:44:23 It was a single lot commercial Platt for one large user that was recorded at that time and

1:44:29 in July preliminary presentation to the PUNNING

1:44:33 and Commissioning Requesting the Amendment

1:44:35 to the Agreement that had been approved in 2011

1:44:38 and signed 2016.

1:44:41 So it's kind of a abbreviated history of what's going on here.

1:44:45 Mr. Schledia definitely summarized everything encompassing

1:44:49 and everything in the report.

1:44:51 I'm not going to talk about all of it, but basically we're asking

1:44:54 for this section to be smaller

1:44:57 More than the required code section requires a 50 foot right of way they're asking for

1:45:02 smaller section.

1:45:04 The master transportation planning current city code set forth requirements for certain

1:45:08 roadways throughout the city in order to maintain and encourage adequate traffic flow

1:45:11 and access to various parts of the city.

1:45:15 Within this plan a concerted effort is made to anticipate growth and demand as part of

1:45:18 this anticipation and part of city code 10, 12, 3-3 certain roadways are designated to

1:45:23 and collectors, Chaney was identified as such a roadway given a designation of

1:45:28 collector. These roadways are planned to be wider in order to facilitate the

1:45:31 movement of goods, services, and people as a city and traffic demand develops.

1:45:35 In that city code, right-of-way requirements collectors are identified as

1:45:39 having 64-foot right-of-way width. This width typically includes curb

1:45:42 bedder and sidewalk. The total pavement width ends up being about 48 feet. The

1:45:47 applicant is proposing to allow this section of Chaney drive to be 50 feet

1:45:50 50 foot wide with a total pavement with the 39 feet.

1:45:55 The difference of nine feet basically is to travel.

1:45:59 Per City Code 10.11.5, it's another code requirement

1:46:01 that does apply adequate access for buildings

1:46:04 to be constructed, not to be constructed

1:46:09 unless adequate access to a 50 foot wide minimum standard

1:46:11 all whether public traffic way is provided.

1:46:13 They are complying with that code section

1:46:15 so there's no asking for variation from that.

1:46:18 the impacts staff is tasked with planning for the orderly and adequate growth of public

1:46:23 infrastructure to accommodate the development of properties.

1:46:26 It would be negligent for city staff to ignore the possibility that the proposed 50-foot right

1:46:30 of way with maybe inadequate in the far future.

1:46:33 Staff does not have the luxury of ignoring future growth of possibilities which could

1:46:37 happen 20 years from now, which is what our complaint is, a 20-year planning window.

1:46:42 However, the projects declared as of today will not constitute a need for a larger

1:46:45 right-of-way width than it is not anticipated the projects in the near future will constitute

1:46:50 a need for a larger right-of-way.

1:46:53 As such, staff supports the right-of-way dedication of 50 feet, 25 feet per side, for the currently

1:46:58 proposed and approved projects along Chaney Drive West.

1:47:01 The support only extends from Fieldstream Way to the beginning of the intersection of

1:47:06 Creek-side Way, which is Fieldstream's this road, so we'd start that intersection and stop

1:47:11 just short as Mr. Study was explaining.

1:47:14 It does not include that intersection in case of a right-turn line or desalvation line.

1:47:20 As a condition of support with the future in mind staff requests, a condition be added, which

1:47:24 would allow City Code 1010-5 to remain enforced with a PUD.

1:47:28 I won't read all of it, basically what it states is if there's a building permit that comes

1:47:31 in for property over here where we have allowed this smaller section and it drives traffic

1:47:37 demand to a point where there's a safety issue on the roadway, we would be allowed, we're

1:47:42 committed through this code section to require a drop lane in order to access that property.

1:47:46 So if some larger traffic impact comes in, we'd like to keep that in force so we could

1:47:53 basically enforce it on the building permit.

1:47:54 It's not the most ideal, but it's something that we could possibly do when that building

1:47:58 comes in, but only if it comes in.

1:48:02 On August 9th, the Planning and Zoning Commission held a public hearing.

1:48:05 At the conclusion of the application, presentation and staff presentation that commissioned open

1:48:10 of the public hearing.

1:48:11 One person spoke against the reduced width

1:48:12 of Change Drive West.

1:48:14 Pong conclusion of deliberations,

1:48:16 Commissioner Tatum made a motion to recommend approval

1:48:18 of the request as presented with staff recommendations.

1:48:21 Commissioner Wood second the motion.

1:48:22 All members present voted in favor of the motion.

1:48:25 And the recommended approval for city council

1:48:28 is the following conditions subject to the 50 foot

1:48:31 right away with only being applied

1:48:33 for that section of Chaney Drive from Field Streamway

1:48:36 to Creekside Way, not including any part

1:48:37 the intersection of Chaney Creek side and number two subject to City Code 1015

1:48:42 still being enforced on that smaller section of Chaney Drive as Chaney Drive

1:48:46 as described above that concludes the staff report. Thank you Jonathan. Great

1:48:52 landing. Jonathan was there ever during the deliberations by the planning zone

1:48:58 in or even in staff discussions was there a consideration of the restriction on

1:49:05 parking on street parking? On street parking will not be permitted at all

1:49:09 I want you to call on Chaney Drive with the smaller room.

1:49:11 Okay, that's what I was wondering.

1:49:12 Thank you.

1:49:13 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:49:14 Just didn't see it in here.

1:49:15 Thank you.

1:49:16 Jonathan, so what is the width of Chaney Drive between Grand View and Fieldstream Way?

1:49:21 Is it the same?

1:49:22 So we're just lining it up straight across, basically.

1:49:27 The same length across the building.

1:49:29 And we really don't have any idea what else is going to be going out there at this time.

1:49:34 We have two building permits for the area.

1:49:36 So we know these are apartments, I want to say 60 units, then there is a senior facility

1:49:44 here that's being constructed now.

1:49:46 I don't remember the number of beds, I think it's between 60 and 80, I'm not sure.

1:49:51 I know they have individual cottages going out there as well.

1:49:55 Future projects we don't have a building permit for, but that's part of their plan was

1:49:58 to do some type of single family, or a single family type condos or something.

1:50:03 And this project here is an assisted or it's a rehab facility, I believe it's a 60-year-so-bed

1:50:10 as well.

1:50:12 I know we just put the bike lanes on North College, but I'm thinking with the school and

1:50:18 the park out there and stuff, going that narrow worries me about adding bike lanes and other

1:50:24 amenities that we've been trying to add to the city.

1:50:27 Any of that addressed it, the planning and zoning now?

1:50:30 They didn't speak about it, but with this small of a width,

1:50:34 and if there's pictures in there, you can kind of see,

1:50:36 there's really not a lot of room.

1:50:37 It's going to act, what I've been told it's going to act

1:50:40 similar to what Fillmore is around the post office.

1:50:42 So we're kind of tying our hands a little bit.

1:50:45 A little bit.

1:50:45 OK, thank you.

1:50:49 Travis?

1:50:51 So in response to the bike lane question,

1:50:55 the other tool that we've used in areas that

1:50:57 have been narrow roads as we use a sharero.

1:51:00 And so you'll see those in many other locations.

1:51:03 And personally, as a cyclist, I prefer the Shiro,

1:51:08 simply because it doesn't create an illusion of safety,

1:51:11 kind of like a crossblock, just because I'm in a bike lane,

1:51:15 doesn't necessarily mean that I'm safe.

1:51:17 And so I kind of like to ride more in the road where I can,

1:51:22 so that I'm be noticed.

1:51:29 Donald.

1:51:30 So Travis, I'll ask that question of view,

1:51:33 because I think that that is a good subject.

1:51:35 I'm glad that Suzanne asked the question.

1:51:40 The kind of development that's going out there

1:51:42 is it conducive to Sheryl's?

1:51:44 Because certainly there's certain roads

1:51:46 that Sheryl's blue legs being one of them,

1:51:48 probably wouldn't work very well.

1:51:50 What do we anticipate the traffic load

1:51:53 and types of traffic being out there

1:51:55 and what a Sheryl work?

1:51:56 So it all depends.

1:51:58 So what I'm hearing is you're seeing some level

1:52:00 of residential with the apartments

1:52:03 And then you're also going to have assisted living facilities.

1:52:06 I don't know if the assisted living facilities have vehicles or they're going to be more visitors that are going to be there.

1:52:12 If they're going to be more residents and I'm going to hear the term rehab facilities.

1:52:16 It doesn't sound like permanent dwellings either.

1:52:19 And so I couldn't tell you exactly what that traffic count is.

1:52:22 But from my perspective, you utilize a share when you know that the traffic

1:52:28 patterns are going to be not as dense as what you might have on other arterials and collectors.

1:52:35 And you'll see those in the positions that we have them now.

1:52:37 I think that we have Sherro's on Hanson Street are a couple of examples of where we'll have those in the bike in that niche made a really good point.

1:52:49 At this point in time, we haven't identified this as an area in which we would place a bike path right now or a Sherro.

1:52:56 So we would go through that process just like we did on the phase one and the phase two to determine the appropriate locations

1:53:02 Thank you

1:53:05 Greg lint

1:53:08 Jonathan I'm back so just running through this in my mind on the way. Yeah a normal collector before to eat

1:53:15 Correct. So the staff reports that's right. Yeah, well, I read here

1:53:20 I don't have all the specs in my head

1:53:21 40 feet typically if you're allowing parking on both sides of a collector which most of them have

1:53:28 That takes away 16 feet

1:53:32 Approximately eight feet on each side. I get a non-permitcer. So that would that actually use you a

1:53:38 an area of

1:53:40 32 feet for traffic 16 feet in each direction if you have

1:53:46 This one's going to be 39 without parking correct

1:53:49 then you're actually 7 feet wider of traffic area, then you went on a normal

1:53:57 collector with parking on both sides. Am I my math wrong Mitch? So if we were to

1:54:02 have a full width collector with four lanes we wouldn't put, there would be no

1:54:06 parking on that one either. Okay. So like North College is a pretty good

1:54:11 example of a collector's tree right now. It is that width right now. There's a

1:54:14 parking on one side there's bike lanes and and just two lanes. At some point if

1:54:21 traffic demands it we might switch it over to like the what you see on falls

1:54:25 west of Washington where it's three lanes basically they were center turn

1:54:31 lane and again there's no parking that really on one side of that happens there

1:54:36 either so you know this is going to be basically a residential kind of a road

1:54:43 It's going to have two lanes either direction.

1:54:45 There won't be any parking on it.

1:54:47 If at some time you could maybe squeeze in a middle turn lane

1:54:50 in there if it's necessary, the provision

1:54:55 that allows for the right turn lanes into the development

1:54:58 is a pretty good one.

1:55:00 Should those developments demand that?

1:55:04 But this is just in keeping with, like Gary said,

1:55:07 in his presentation and keeping with what we've already

1:55:09 started to kind of work through that really wacky kind

1:55:12 the scenario to get around the trailer park, just takes it out to the logical term that's

1:55:19 there at Creek site.

1:55:22 Which eventually with this development will connect to pole line and that will give another

1:55:27 outlet for this whole quarter mile will be Creek site to pole line which we haven't talked

1:55:32 about at all but that's a big deal out there too.

1:55:36 Creek site to pole line.

1:55:37 And the cuts already there on pole line for the site.

1:55:39 In fact, you can see it on the aerial photo right here.

1:55:42 It's already built for a little bit.

1:55:44 Yep.

1:55:46 Nicki Boyd?

1:55:47 This was interesting to read the reports.

1:55:50 My friends at Planning and Zoning, some of them struggled.

1:55:53 They had some good questions and some good comments that I really took to heart.

1:56:02 I also look at the amount of negotiation and discussion that everybody involved has had

1:56:12 to try to make everybody happy in this.

1:56:16 And I was really struggling with, could I vote for this?

1:56:20 But I think what's kind of got my attention now is it's a good compromise.

1:56:27 It's going to last hopefully 20 years, but with the turn lane being saved in there, does

1:56:39 the city, does engineering, do you feel confident enough where that will be?

1:56:45 It's just one little stretcher road because we've gone through some funny roads here where

1:56:51 people didn't even know where to turn in and once they got into the business they didn't

1:56:54 know how to get out and but then over time it all worked itself out. Is this kind of a

1:56:59 big black hole we're falling in? I think that I'll speak for planning and zoning

1:57:04 as I'm an engineer in any way shape or form. I would say that there's been a lot of discussion.

1:57:11 This is a compromise that they come up with. When I say they, engineering was involved,

1:57:15 planning and zoning is all, sitting in Andrews office was involved and the applicants were involved.

1:57:20 And I did notice that after all the conversation, they did unanimously vote in favor of this.

1:57:26 So I appreciate all the hard work that's gone into this.

1:57:30 Thank you.

1:57:33 Any more questions for staff?

1:57:38 Seeing none, we will open the public hearing for public input on this proposal.

1:57:45 Does anyone wishing to speak on this one please come forward.

1:57:49 Mr. Capillaras, welcome.

1:57:56 Mayor and Council. I'm John Capillares, 1-2-3-1 Sunburst. I attended that meeting that hearing

1:58:02 last month and in my capacity as the Xavier Charter School Board Chair. I represented the

1:58:09 school's interests and the ideal of public safety in general. At that meeting, we met

1:58:17 a great conundrum and the three parties involved were the commissioners who felt powerless,

1:58:23 owners who felt stabbed in the back and the engineering department, which was

1:58:27 in feeble of enforcing city code. The question was, should there be three

1:58:32 lanes or four lanes and why? The argument was between expediency and the

1:58:39 ideal form, between what is and what ought to be. These are fundamental and

1:58:46 foundational questions that all community members should be asking

1:58:50 themselves, especially public officials.

1:58:53 City code is in place for the common good.

1:58:56 White or streets allow for easier flow of high-volume traffic,

1:59:00 which may not be there yet, but will be as soon as the creek

1:59:04 sideways opens to the pole line.

1:59:08 And it will be, especially because of the way we altered

1:59:10 our pickup and drop-off procedures.

1:59:15 However, there is a larger agreement in place among many

1:59:19 different parties, including the city involving Chaney Drive.

1:59:24 With all these moving parts, separate from the code,

1:59:27 the city approved the south side DUDs

1:59:29 and gave them more land overlooking the agreement

1:59:32 and eventually the code.

1:59:33 Continuing this fashion, would it provided a two-lane street?

1:59:38 But someone finally caught it.

1:59:40 And to the credit of the north side owners,

1:59:42 they came up with a compromise, which allowed for three lanes.

1:59:46 and also that right turn lane on the creek side way.

1:59:53 The city staff recommended four lanes,

1:59:55 which is the right thing to do by code,

1:59:58 but it was undoable, let's be honest.

2:00:01 The commission voted yes,

2:00:03 but some of those votes were reluctant,

2:00:06 and they said so.

2:00:08 You can look at the video and see

2:00:11 how they struggled to vote yes.

2:00:14 So everyone involved was in a difficult position,

2:00:17 And the lesson we must take away is the importance of oversight

2:00:20 and planning and so we may, in the future, more often

2:00:25 than not choose the common good over private financial

2:00:29 benefit.

2:00:33 Thank you, John.

2:00:35 Is there anyone else wishing to speak on this issue?

2:00:42 Seeing no one, we will close the public comment portion

2:00:46 of the hearing.

2:00:49 And Mr. Sleddy, did you want to respond

2:00:51 to any comments there, you don't have to.

2:00:56 Well, okay, if I don't have to,

2:00:58 I probably better sit down.

2:01:00 But I just wanna say, I don't feel as one of the owners

2:01:07 of latitude that we were stabbed in the back.

2:01:10 We knowingly and willfully participated in an agreement

2:01:18 with this city and with all of our adjacent owners

2:01:22 to get something done that would never otherwise have gotten done.

2:01:28 And I think if you read Mr. Wonderlich's comment at the bottom of page 68 of your record

2:01:38 or your staff report, you get a good feel as to why this PUD amendment is susceptible

2:01:47 of approval.

2:01:48 So when you talk about what is or what ought to be, you know, what ought to be maybe have

2:01:57 been something different all the way through that stretch, but what is is a product of a

2:02:04 willingness of owners to come together with this city for what we think is the good of

2:02:12 the order.

2:02:13 Thanks.

2:02:14 Thank you, Mr. Sledding.

2:02:19 We will turn it over now to the Council for

2:02:22 deliberation and direction.

2:02:26 Ordinance?

2:02:27 Is this an ordinance?

2:02:29 No.

2:02:31 This is a modification to the PUD.

2:02:34 Chris Stockington.

2:02:36 Well, I'll throw out the move approval request to amend

2:02:41 the latitude 42 PUD agreement 272 to modify development requirements

2:02:47 for Chaney Drive West, a collector between the Fieldstone Drive and Creek

2:02:52 side subject to P&C's attached recommendations.

2:02:57 So, motion by Chris Stockington, seconded by Greg Lansing to approve the amendment to

2:03:04 the PUD with the conditions recommended by the Planning and Zoning Commission.

2:03:10 Is there any discussion from the Council?

2:03:15 Don Hall.

2:03:16 I'm just going to say I struggle with this a little bit,

2:03:19 because really the call that we have anymore

2:03:23 is to look long-term on these projects.

2:03:27 And to develop a community that is ready for different uses,

2:03:33 we have a significant amount of folks in our community now

2:03:37 that their transportation needs are different than they

2:03:41 were 20 years ago.

2:03:43 And so with that in mind, we always

2:03:45 have to make our decisions looking to the future.

2:03:50 This is no longer just a farm to market community, although it still is, because agriculture is

2:03:57 still our bread and butter here, but this is a small city that we have now, and they have

2:04:04 different needs, and folks are more mobile with different types of mobility, bikes and

2:04:13 walking and skateboards and who knows what's going to be in the future and so we need to

2:04:21 keep that in mind.

2:04:23 With that being said, I think that from everything that I can see and read and look at this and

2:04:29 with the P&Z Commission went through, this is probably the best compromise they could

2:04:36 come up with.

2:04:38 And I will be voting in favor, but it's not easy.

2:04:44 Thank you. I'm struggling with this one as well. It's hard to change that road width down.

2:04:54 I understand the complication where it started over at Grandview and why we had to make that

2:05:00 road narrow there to get around the trailer park. And even if we require this portion of

2:05:07 the road to stay at the collector's width, it's still going to bottle deck right there.

2:05:11 There's nothing we can do about that.

2:05:13 I wish there was a better solution.

2:05:15 We don't live in a perfect world, but I don't see any other way around it in this situation.

2:05:22 I would ask if there's any way the developers could leave that area between the roadway and

2:05:28 the sidewalk where there's a little buffer because of the more narrow road so that if

2:05:32 there are people out walking on the sidewalks, they're not right on the edge of the road.

2:05:37 I think that would be an extra nice compromise to give it just that little bit of space for

2:05:42 safety, but that would be the one thing that if there's any way possible, I would see as

2:05:49 a better compromise.

2:05:51 I will support it because I don't think we have another option, but it is a tough one.

2:05:56 Other comments from the Council?

2:06:02 I would just make a general comment, you know, again, as I look at how this area is developing

2:06:07 out here, to be honest, I think a slightly narrower roadway

2:06:12 actually provides additional safety

2:06:15 because it's traffic calming,

2:06:16 because you don't have two lanes of traffic

2:06:19 trying to speed both directions.

2:06:21 I think even though some of this is commercial development

2:06:24 with assisted living and those types of things,

2:06:26 they're very residential in nature.

2:06:29 And I think trying to create a wide roadway,

2:06:34 like you would see in a commercial area,

2:06:38 But by not doing that, I think it keeps more of the residential feel.

2:06:41 And I like the conditions that allow that if there is significant commercial development,

2:06:48 the requirements for deceleration lanes and turn lanes and all of that accommodates that traffic flow.

2:06:54 So I'm supportive of the notion, again, I think this is one of those areas where

2:07:00 we're doing our best to get through the area to at least have the connection.

2:07:05 And I think it's a reasonable compromise for all involved.

2:07:09 It's also difficult to look 20 years out

2:07:11 and try to think about this roadway when it's going

2:07:14 to be in a grid system that's connecting to much more,

2:07:18 much larger thoroughfares.

2:07:20 Not everybody's going to be trying to snake around

2:07:22 Cheney Drive to make it east and west over in that area

2:07:27 when you have connections to Pull Line and North College

2:07:31 going through.

2:07:32 So, those are my comments.

2:07:35 Any further discussion?

2:07:37 Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote, please.

2:07:41 Greg Lanthi?

2:07:42 Yes.

2:07:43 Don Hall?

2:07:44 Yes.

2:07:44 Ruth Pierce?

2:07:45 Yes.

2:07:46 Suzanne Hawkins?

2:07:47 Yes.

2:07:48 Nikki Boyd?

2:07:49 Yes.

2:07:50 Sean Bericher?

2:07:51 Yes.

2:07:52 Chris Tocking?

2:07:53 Yes.

2:07:55 Motion passes, 7 to 0.

2:08:00 Next on the agenda is a request for an annexation

2:08:03 with a zoning district change and zoning map amendment

2:08:07 from SUI area of impact to R2, R6, and C1,

2:08:14 Canyon Rim Overlay Zoning Development Agreement

2:08:18 for approximately 28.84 plus or minus acres located

2:08:21 on the north side of the 1800 and 1900 blocks

2:08:24 of Pole Line Road East, Dave Tebow.

2:08:29 So, yes.

2:08:30 Mr. Mayor and Mayor of the Council,

2:08:31 just for a point of reference,

2:08:32 We anticipate that this public hearing will take some time, it is one of those, just, there's

2:08:40 a lot of information behind it, and so in the event that you might want to take a quick break,

2:08:47 we want to extend that opportunity now.

2:08:49 We anticipate if it goes as long as the planning and zoning, this could be about a 30 to 45 minute

2:08:55 conversation.

2:08:56 conversation. All right well we have we'll take about a five-minute break then and

2:09:02 then we'll get rolling with it. Thank you for the heads up. For the lengthy name of

2:09:15 what I listed out there requesting an annexation with a zoning district change

2:09:20 and zoning map amendment and we have Dave Tebow who will be beginning from

2:09:26 HM engineers. Welcome Dave. Good evening Mr. Mayor and members of the City Council.

2:09:30 I'm Dave Tebow, EHM engineers at 621 North College for the record here in Twin Falls,

2:09:37 and I'm representing John and Bonnie Lithamis who are in the audience this evening with us,

2:09:43 and their organization, Notch Mute Farms, LLC, as they intend to develop their property

2:09:49 here that we have on the map in front of us, if you'll follow with me around this particular

2:09:55 property as located out here north of Poline Road and in the middle of it here

2:10:00 is the YMCA facility and some property that we do not have ownership of at the

2:10:04 current time. The request before you this evening is that we annex this property

2:10:09 into the city limits of Twin Falls and that we apply a zoning designation to it

2:10:13 because we lie within the Canyon Room overlay zone which is depicted by this

2:10:18 light blue line here. A zoning designation agreement is required by code now and

2:10:24 And so we've prepared a ZDA agreement and request that we have this property zone in a couple different tiers

2:10:30 The first here or area would be area one

2:10:38 Area one as depicted on the master plan here

2:10:42 Let me have up on the monitor now

2:10:45 It's it's this number one here and out here on pole line and

2:10:50 Identified in blue and there's also these two lots right here will be also

2:10:55 area one and

2:10:57 meet the requirements of the

2:10:59 Memorandum of understanding for that area that area is intended to be similar to the C1 zone

2:11:04 commercial highway district and we anticipate retail uses and commercial type uses in that in that area of

2:11:12 It's designated as a one there. So that's the first area

2:11:16 As a buffer against Pull line road the major arterial and has the high high traffic counts and exposure for commercial businesses

2:11:24 Area 2 is tucked in here behind Bridgeview Boulevard,

2:11:28 just Street, or Bridgeview Care Center, excuse me,

2:11:31 straight east of their care center facility.

2:11:33 And area 2 is intended to be residential townhomes,

2:11:37 condominiums, similar to an R6 type density.

2:11:41 That would allow some nursing home type uses as well.

2:11:45 Inside that area, this is a public road

2:11:49 that approaches from Poline coming off northerly.

2:11:53 And the public portion of that road would terminate at this approximate intersection.

2:11:57 That road would form the eastern boundary of that area, too, and the property boundary would be the western boundary of that area, too.

2:12:04 Area three, we've identified in this mixed-use development a single family residential lots.

2:12:11 It is serviced by a private road coming off of the intersection that I just spoke about.

2:12:15 We anticipate that we would like to have that be a private road with the potential to gate it,

2:12:21 Obviously providing access for emergency vehicles, but to give it that gated and private feel.

2:12:28 Those lots are larger lots and intended for single family use that would blend back to

2:12:34 some of our neighboring uses that are proposed in PUDs that are currently in existence.

2:12:41 Area 4 is the Canyon Rim Frontage.

2:12:44 It's intended to include hospitality, perhaps some office, perhaps some restaurant.

2:12:52 You can see we have some type of hospitality use identified in our hopeful that that is

2:12:57 the ultimate user of this property.

2:12:59 This property is closest to the canyon rim.

2:13:02 We expect there to be C1 type uses there within the limitations of the canyon rim overlay.

2:13:10 And we have prepared a memorandum of understanding for each of these areas and I'd like to talk

2:13:16 about some of the some of the critical items there.

2:13:20 And in this area four, because we are contemplating marketing this for a hotel site, we'd like

2:13:26 the opportunity to have a special use process allowed in the event that we find a hotel

2:13:33 user that would like to exceed the 35 foot maximum building height that's stipulated in

2:13:39 the Canyon Room overlay.

2:13:41 And if they meet the criteria that is currently codified in other areas within the Canyon

2:13:46 and removerlay zone of having a convention center capable of housing 500 or more occupants

2:13:51 that their height variance would be allowed up to 50 feet of height.

2:13:56 So in your review of the memorandum of understanding for area four, you will find that there's

2:14:01 a provision that would allow a potential user to go back before the Planning and Zoning

2:14:07 Commission present their project and their specific use with specific design standards

2:14:14 and allow for additional height of a facility.

2:14:22 We also have included in each of these areas

2:14:26 connection to the Canyon Rim Trail system

2:14:28 that's currently exist.

2:14:32 Schematically we depict that over here,

2:14:34 making connection and over here making connection.

2:14:38 Obviously as we design this,

2:14:40 we're hopeful that we'll have routing

2:14:41 through our development as the nature

2:14:43 of this overall development is intended to be mixed use.

2:14:48 And we have a provision in there

2:14:50 that those locations can be determined with the engineering

2:14:53 and design teams along with city staff

2:14:56 so that they can be made at the appropriate locations.

2:15:00 I did allow for an additional use in both areas 2 and area 4

2:15:05 for sanitary sewer lift stations and pressurized irrigation

2:15:08 pump stations.

2:15:11 We've been evaluating the availability of sanitary sewer

2:15:13 service and would like to service this out.

2:15:16 We believe that a sanitary sewer lift station will probably

2:15:19 be required to service not only the property that we're talking about this evening, but

2:15:24 the Pillar Falls planned unit development property that's located east of our property.

2:15:29 We've had several meetings with both of the ownerships of these two properties and developments,

2:15:35 including meetings with Mr. David Sparks, who owns some critical ground between the developments,

2:15:42 have begun discussions about easement acquisition and installing a line for both pressurized irrigation

2:15:50 and sanitary sewer so that they can be run from a common system and open up a larger area

2:15:56 for development. So those are some of the differences that we were asking for inside of

2:16:00 this ZDA. Those are some concessions we're asking the city to make as they as we place

2:16:04 the zoning designation on this but I believe they're going to be important for the ultimate

2:16:08 success of this project. I'm excited to work on this one. It's a neat one. It's going to be an

2:16:14 interesting project as it develops out. And I think that the right people are involved with it.

2:16:20 So this is the first step. Obviously, in getting this developed, we haven't begun really any serious

2:16:25 engineering design that we can show you, but I'm happy to stand for any questions as we have

2:16:30 preliminarily begun to evaluate this property and get it off the ground.

2:16:34 Thank you, Dave, Greg Lanting.

2:16:38 Staff might have been helping on this as well, or ask for this as well.

2:16:45 I was understanding that if gravity was available, no matter how expensive it was,

2:16:52 we would not allow or maintain a list station.

2:16:56 Does that mean that you're planning to, if that is true,

2:16:59 is there some consideration between you and the other properties

2:17:03 that you would actually maintain this through a list station?

2:17:06 So right now we're thinking about a commercial business owners district, an association that

2:17:12 would own and operate that.

2:17:16 We don't believe that this property can gravity sewer out at this point in time.

2:17:23 There's a manhole that exists between Bridgeview Care Center and Sportsman's warehouse, and

2:17:29 that manhole will not allow for the property to sewer out all the way from the pillar falls

2:17:35 development, Mr. Lening.

2:17:37 of the Iowa was understanding that even if you had to sewer it out by going down into the canyon somehow,

2:17:45 that was the way our code was written. You're not under that same understanding?

2:17:51 If that's the case, the cost to take it clear down to the canyon would then encourage us to seek a commercial business

2:17:58 owners or property owners association that would own and operate that lift station.

2:18:03 All right, thank you.

2:18:05 Donal.

2:18:07 Has there been much thought really about traffic patterns?

2:18:11 Obviously, this is just preliminary, I understand that.

2:18:14 But traffic patterns and loads on some of those roadways,

2:18:19 bridge you, for example, certain parts of the day

2:18:22 is miserable to get around.

2:18:25 And this is going to be, in some areas, fairly high density

2:18:30 potentially.

2:18:32 Has there been thoughts?

2:18:33 Yes, there has.

2:18:34 We've actually approached the neighbors here about getting right away acquisition from them.

2:18:40 The initial meetings several months ago were not successful in negotiating that right away.

2:18:46 Obviously, the widening of Poline Road is going to be required on this side,

2:18:49 and there's an embankment operation and fill operation that they required as part of that.

2:18:53 We're prepared to do that.

2:18:56 It's hard to crystal ball the users and place traffic demands and loads.

2:19:01 However, we can take a stab at it,

2:19:03 and that'll be part of our design process to evaluate that.

2:19:07 You'll notice that I do show our interior parking

2:19:12 and drive aisle extending all the way to the property line

2:19:16 with the hope that a connection could be made

2:19:19 or would be possible with the neighboring property

2:19:21 and perhaps clean up a situation right now

2:19:23 that can sometimes be confusing for motorists

2:19:26 as a venture in and out of establishments

2:19:29 that are currently in existence.

2:19:31 We provide connectivity on both our west boundary and our east boundary for neighboring developments

2:19:36 to loop through.

2:19:39 We have a loop road here.

2:19:42 Now this I'm telling you is indicated to be private and hopefully gated, but that will

2:19:48 be part of the engineering process that we engage in.

2:19:51 I think the critical item would be Pull Line Road and the need for a deceleration and right

2:19:56 hand turn lane.

2:19:57 The left hand turn lighting and width exists out there.

2:20:01 we would be improving the north side there,

2:20:03 scheduled to be in another meeting tomorrow

2:20:05 with the new directorship that that ownership here.

2:20:08 And hopefully we can get this figured out.

2:20:12 Thank you.

2:20:13 Chris talking.

2:20:14 I'm a little concerned about the access

2:20:17 for public safety vehicles.

2:20:20 Your main, your only public road comes off

2:20:23 of just west of the Y then,

2:20:26 and it will travel north on a public road

2:20:29 to the intersection and it, fire will have to do a hard right

2:20:35 to access those single family units there.

2:20:39 It's not gated though, it's just private.

2:20:42 We anticipate that it could be gated,

2:20:45 Councilman Dockington, right?

2:20:46 We don't have this come out very often

2:20:49 but how does an emergency vehicle get through a lock gate?

2:20:52 And they'll have an access code

2:20:54 or it'll be a locked gate that is actually open

2:20:57 similar to what like Breckenridge is

2:20:59 some of the time and other private roads around the community are.

2:21:03 Thank you.

2:21:04 Greg Lanting.

2:21:05 This is a question you may not know the answer.

2:21:09 Mr. Sparks is the ownership down near the Canyon, correct?

2:21:13 Yeah, his residence is approximately in this area, yes.

2:21:16 Does he have, do you have control of or is he the same ownership of the house that's

2:21:22 clear up on, uh, Hawaii?

2:21:25 I'm blind.

2:21:26 No, they're separate ownerships as I understand it.

2:21:28 Okay, and have you been in contact with them?

2:21:31 I have not.

2:21:32 Okay.

2:21:33 My clients, the lithomies, have been in contact with both of these folks.

2:21:37 Okay.

2:21:38 And are working on securing some options on both of those pieces of properties.

2:21:44 And then for the property nearest, the canyon, I noticed in here that it talks about if you

2:21:49 want additional height, it has to be at least 100 feet from a canyon ramp.

2:21:53 Is this scheduled plan to be of 100 feet from a canyon ramp or do you know?

2:21:58 that at this point of the property we're about 65 feet from the canyon rim to

2:22:06 the property line I think that right in here right in here we're about 125 feet

2:22:14 from the canyon rim to the property line and right in here we're about a hundred

2:22:18 feet from the canyon room to the property okay so it's only it's only for

2:22:24 buildings have to be a hundred feet right not just actual property building

2:22:27 are being inside our property with the setback off the property.

2:22:31 So is there an office?

2:22:36 I'm not really sure if this is for your staff,

2:22:39 but see if I can explain this.

2:22:42 You guys have the property on both sides of the Y.

2:22:45 But when it this trigger needing pole line widened out

2:22:48 with sidewalks and things that aren't there now,

2:22:50 and how do you do that with the hole in the middle

2:22:52 of the property?

2:22:53 We're only to able to develop the property in which we own,

2:22:56 unless we can come to an agreement with the adjacent property

2:22:59 But you would say eight months ago that agreement was not received with any

2:23:04 welcome with the YMCA directorship at that time and we're hopeful that tomorrow

2:23:10 we'll get a different reception. But you would still be required to do pull on

2:23:15 on both sides of that then and on the frontage. Our anticipation is that we

2:23:22 would improve our roadway frontage here and our roadway frontage here for which

2:23:28 we have ownership. Thank you. Any other questions for Dave at this time? Do not

2:23:38 see any so we will turn it over to Jonathan and spend love for the staff

2:23:41 report. I think Mr. Mayor members of the council there's a lot of material on this

2:23:52 one. So I'll try to be as brief as I can but also hold on. Bearing in mind

2:23:59 those that are listening around the audience if not seen this before the

2:24:03 history the property we basically have a property outside of city limits. The

2:24:07 Zones came into place back in the day or during the area impact agreement.

2:24:13 What we have is SUI's own property, they're asking to be re-zoned and annexed at the same

2:24:18 time.

2:24:19 So when we took that to the funding and zoning commission, they only look at what an appropriate

2:24:22 zoning district would be for annexation.

2:24:25 They don't debate on whether it should be annexed, that's what comes to this body for.

2:24:30 They talked about the ZDA, which is what the applicant proposed.

2:24:33 ZDA is a new process.

2:24:35 This is like the first real big one that we've had with that comes these areas that they

2:24:43 designate on the map will show and days talked about these areas area one two three and four

2:24:49 being actually zoned what we have in our code.

2:24:53 So areas one will be zoned C one and then the memory and of understanding is those things

2:24:59 they want to vary from our base code.

2:25:01 So it's different from a PUD where they listed all the uses they wanted to use.

2:25:05 We did it the other way.

2:25:06 It's C1.

2:25:07 If they don't want the use, they identify.

2:25:11 They want it taken out or added.

2:25:13 So that's what those MOUs are supposed to be listing.

2:25:16 So they did that for areas one, two, three, and four.

2:25:20 And they're kind of long.

2:25:21 I've got them all in the packets here.

2:25:22 If we go through each one, we can.

2:25:25 That's just kind of been brief over here for us now.

2:25:27 So for the new city code 10.6, they're

2:25:31 supposed to address a number of items.

2:25:35 I'm not going to list every single one.

2:25:36 Land use, topography, size, type, and location

2:25:39 of buildings and sites.

2:25:41 They did all of those through either this master plan.

2:25:45 I mean, subsequent pages showing examples

2:25:47 of what the building types are going to use

2:25:49 and the written documents of those end we use.

2:25:52 Those collectively identify what they're going to be doing

2:25:56 for the land use of the property,

2:25:58 size, type, and locations of buildings and sites.

2:26:01 And the proposed ingress and egress

2:26:03 is something they have to identify physical features

2:26:05 in existing streets.

2:26:06 All of those things have been identified on the master plan.

2:26:09 They showed where they're going to access the property.

2:26:11 So the physical features would be the canyon,

2:26:14 any type of a ditch or cooing, and they

2:26:16 identified the location of that.

2:26:18 And the existing streets we currently have pole line.

2:26:21 Stromwater, alleys, and easements, future public facilities,

2:26:25 they're not requesting any change

2:26:27 from our current base zoning code, and things

2:26:29 that we enforce through the planning process already.

2:26:32 So I'm not going to address those.

2:26:34 Multi-use transportation access and density.

2:26:36 They showed access on the trails.

2:26:39 We've also put in some language, talking about where the

2:26:44 access will be, that'll be taken care of in the planning

2:26:46 process with the input from the parks director for the most

2:26:49 appropriate location for the scenic overlooks, things like

2:26:53 that.

2:26:53 So that's something we've identified as a condition

2:26:55 that's located in the MOUs.

2:26:58 The density they talk about, when you inherently have a

2:27:02 Zoning of R6 that comes a certain lot size and a density that comes with that

2:27:06 They're not asking to go any more than what's currently permitted in that zone

2:27:10 The same goes for the residential of R2 and then see one zone as well. They're not increasing the density

2:27:17 per our current code

2:27:20 Parking landscaping and screening they're not asking for any changes from our current code for those things

2:27:25 They're scheduled they identified as five-year

2:27:27 where maximum five-year time limit between final flat phases,

2:27:32 a lesson extension is granted by the city council,

2:27:35 preliminary lot of arrangements.

2:27:37 Those are a little bit more tricky.

2:27:39 The plan shows these lots, but all property will undergo

2:27:43 preliminary and final planning.

2:27:44 May adjust these arrangements per city code 1061.6.

2:27:49 That's a code section.

2:28:00 There are about seven or eight items.

2:28:04 When a ZDA comes through, and we identify certain things,

2:28:08 The applicant has the option to change some items, but not change others.

2:28:14 These items are things that if they change, they have to come back through this process again,

2:28:18 go through public hearing with the Planning and Zoning Commission and the City Council.

2:28:22 The changes are permitted uses of increase in density, increase in building height, increase

2:28:27 in building coverage of the site, reduction in the off-street parking ratio, reducing

2:28:31 the building setbacks provided at their boundary of the site, reduction of any open space plans,

2:28:37 alteration of overall design theme, primary architecture elements, or building materials.

2:28:42 So if they change things other than those, it would just be a staff type of approval.

2:28:46 We'd say yes, that does not alter these items.

2:28:50 We can move forward with the building plan.

2:28:52 If they change any of those items, they would go back through that process.

2:28:56 So it's a little bit of a lot of arrangements are not really identified here, so we could

2:29:02 move the lot of arrangements.

2:29:03 The roadway could move a little bit to the left or right.

2:29:07 Those are the elements we'd be looking for not changing.

2:29:10 Parks and open space we kind of talked about.

2:29:13 They're not changing the dedication process

2:29:15 or the parks and the loop process

2:29:17 that will go just as normal as you've seen before

2:29:20 with our current planning process.

2:29:22 The other standard is something we do need

2:29:24 to spend some time on the hours operation.

2:29:27 They've requested no limits for areas one and four.

2:29:31 That would be the areas zoned commercially.

2:29:34 Areas two and three will be limited to seven and a 10 pm.

2:29:37 Those are residential zones anyway, and there's some uses that could possibly be there that would have service or light retail, but it's very unlikely.

2:29:48 The extra height is something that I want to spend some time on.

2:29:50 The requesting to change the Canyon Rim overlay zone.

2:29:54 The blue line is the approximate location of the Canyon Rim overlay that extends 750 feet from the rim into the property.

2:30:01 Anything within that has a separate development criteria.

2:30:04 They're asking to change the mechanism by which they can have extra height.

2:30:10 Currently, the can room overlay does not allow for extra height in this area.

2:30:15 It's just not permitted.

2:30:17 The only provision is for the west side of Blue Lakes to have a convention center as identified in the city code.

2:30:25 It talks about looking down past my report.

2:30:32 for hotel convention centers defined as a full service hotel

2:30:35 with the convention center designed

2:30:36 to accommodate a minimum 500 convention attendees.

2:30:39 So what they're asking for is a change

2:30:41 from the canerim overlay to permit them

2:30:44 to go through a special use permit process,

2:30:46 which is a public hearing with the planning and zoning commission

2:30:49 to permit an additional height above 35 feet.

2:30:52 Completely departing from the canerim overlay zone.

2:30:55 Through the ZDA process, they can ask for it.

2:30:58 Jonathan, Chris, talking to that question.

2:31:00 Speaking of that, the variance for height above 35 feet,

2:31:05 I think we have a few cases in Twin Falls

2:31:08 where they're allowed to go 50.

2:31:10 And then they punch an antenna on top of that

2:31:13 or a flagpole.

2:31:14 What is the code allow?

2:31:15 It seems like we're getting fudge factors.

2:31:18 I think there's an elevator shaft on one of them

2:31:20 that exceeds whatever the approved variance was.

2:31:25 So what's the ultimate?

2:31:27 So the height is measured from nearest curb, or in this case,

2:31:32 it'd be building elevation where it's built to the top of the roof.

2:31:36 That would be the height.

2:31:38 However, our definition of height does exclude architectural features.

2:31:44 Does it include?

2:31:45 Yes, architecture features can go higher.

2:31:49 It is allowed.

2:31:49 Yes.

2:31:50 So if you want to put a lit 50 foot extension,

2:31:57 subtle advertising could be done.

2:32:00 Possibly.

2:32:01 And that's where it...

2:32:02 It couldn't be outright prevented though.

2:32:07 Advertising, and that's where I'm...

2:32:09 If I go advertising, I'm going to be a sign permit.

2:32:11 So I guess that's a...

2:32:12 I'm just saying sign permit would come into play

2:32:14 with the current...

2:32:15 The current way we say is a fudge fabric,

2:32:16 you can get above 50.

2:32:17 Yeah, there's some areas where you could get above 50,

2:32:20 and the one that comes into mind is an architectural feature

2:32:22 of like a...

2:32:28 Yeah, parable wall.

2:32:29 Parable wall on like the Fairfield.

2:32:31 That was above...

2:32:33 at the time, it was above 35 feet.

2:32:36 So it was just a wall that went above.

2:32:38 There's no actual habitation above the 35 feet,

2:32:42 it was just part of the face of the building.

2:32:45 Just throwing this out to the council,

2:32:47 I think with that Kenyonram overlay,

2:32:50 putting buildings with a 50 foot top on it

2:32:54 and allow unknown heights above that

2:32:57 that may or may not be led.

2:32:59 I think that's gonna be almost a complete capitulation

2:33:04 to our intent to keep that line of sight

2:33:07 somewhat lumbed it along the canyon.

2:33:12 Just my thought.

2:33:13 Great, Lanting.

2:33:14 As Jonathan, don't we also have another building

2:33:17 that was approved to be higher than 35 feet,

2:33:20 but she ended up choosing not to elevation 46 building.

2:33:25 And where we allowed that is because they put in

2:33:27 community gathering site next to the buildings in that

2:33:32 permit so yeah they actually had two buildings approved to go taller than that

2:33:38 height in addition to that the Nielsen property there by the bridge also at

2:33:46 one point had approval for like a 10-story hotel or something like that

2:33:50 never actually came about so we've had three different buildings approved on

2:33:55 on the west side of Blue Lakes,

2:33:57 and only one of those has actually come to fruition.

2:34:00 But again, on the west side of Blue Lakes,

2:34:02 the code actually allows for those processes in place,

2:34:06 and the east side of Blue Lakes,

2:34:08 the code does not allow for those processes.

2:34:10 That's clarification, thank you.

2:34:16 What's the extra height?

2:34:18 The architectural standards,

2:34:19 they provide examples of the materials

2:34:21 they'll be using,

2:34:23 types of things of the rocks,

2:34:24 stucco examples of the types of buildings

2:34:27 be having for commercial offices. That's all in the packet. As far as the impacts, that's

2:34:32 what I'm going to move towards. The impact of this, it's difficult to gauge the impact.

2:34:37 This is a project that will take years to be built. Won't be immediately felt like community

2:34:44 because it's so large. Since the timeframe is over multiple years, it's difficult to discern

2:34:49 those impacts, especially occurring at this time one project or to an overall growth of

2:34:54 community, it's hard to tell if it's going to be this or just to involve the growing on

2:34:59 its own.

2:35:00 In any case, staff has attempted to address the most common and impactful items this project

2:35:04 may produce.

2:35:05 I'm going to focus on three land use, the canyon rim, and the last one will be the traffic

2:35:11 slash access.

2:35:13 The land use shows a mixed use type of development complete with commercial zones, two types of

2:35:17 residential.

2:35:19 Zoning along Pull Line and Snake River Canyon are proposed to see one similar to what you

2:35:23 see along the pull line on the west side of Blue Lakes with the Kenyon Park West.

2:35:30 However, the CRO, Kenyon River only has different land uses and development requirements than the

2:35:36 C1, and they are going to be adhering to those land uses as they're listed in the C1 and CRO.

2:35:43 We go with the most restrictive one, so whatever's listed in the CRO that we'll go with for those

2:35:47 areas that are affected by it.

2:35:49 Two residential areas are R6, R2, and no deviations from city code.

2:35:54 The end product could be a number of mixed housing types, single family duplex, apartments, et cetera.

2:35:59 As are permitted in the R6, R2, and the cane room overlay, those are out right permitted in our code currently.

2:36:06 Zoning districts are end up, the end product could be a standard residential subdivision, it just depends on what the developer brings forth in the planning process.

2:36:13 These areas will be developed per standard set forth in our current code and as approved

2:36:18 through the ZDA process.

2:36:20 With the mixed-use development pattern being a relatively new concept between falls, it's

2:36:23 difficult to identify potential impacts associated with the land use.

2:36:27 In theory, mixed-use developments provide an area where residents can live, work, and plan

2:36:31 the same vicinity without requiring them to travel long distances for necessities.

2:36:35 Although we do not have an actual business name or building plans, these areas will be developed

2:36:39 as permitted in current city code.

2:36:41 impacts of this type of land use would generally be a positive one. In our

2:36:45 profession we think of mixed use as positive type developments. Council should

2:36:50 review the proposed zoning designations and propose mitigating conditions to

2:36:53 possible impacts if it deems necessary. On the canyon rim, we've kind of talked

2:36:58 about this when we jump to the building height. The most the biggest impact is a

2:37:02 visual one. Something the council needs to discuss and think about. Staff outlined

2:37:09 And the code, can you remotely, does not permit additional building heights through the ZDA

2:37:14 process, they're asking just to reiterate this one more time.

2:37:17 They're asking to go through a special use permit process which is different from the process

2:37:21 outlined in code to allow for additional building height.

2:37:24 That would be a public hearing with the Planning and Zoning Commission appealable to the Planning

2:37:28 and Zoning, appealable to the City Council for any of those things.

2:37:32 When you go through a special use permit process, as they're asking for, they would develop site

2:37:37 plan specific and building elevations specific to their plan prior to actually

2:37:42 going to the public hearing. So those are two things that we would actually get

2:37:45 prior to that special use permit they're asking for. Jonathan the current code

2:37:50 that does allow for that request on the west side of Blue Lakes what is that

2:37:55 process is that the it's a different special commission yes it's a citizens

2:38:00 design review committee appointed by the mayor making recommendations to the

2:38:03 planning and zoning commission for any building higher than 35 feet. That's what

2:38:09 the code list says the current process what happens on the west side. And that

2:38:12 process hasn't been used since the Nielsen property request I believe. Was

2:38:21 that used for the elevation building as well? Okay. But that was 2007 or 8 is the

2:38:32 last time that that happened.

2:38:37 Done all.

2:38:38 So is there so some mechanism in place for type of material,

2:38:46 color, all those things, would that

2:38:48 be going through the process as well?

2:38:52 We would require them, especially along the CRO.

2:38:55 We'd require them to adhere to what they provided in the packet,

2:38:58 which was the guts of examples of building materials,

2:39:01 which I think is the last two pages.

2:39:11 these types of examples and materials,

2:39:15 and plan A, the colors correspond.

2:39:22 So this commercial retail corresponds

2:39:24 with the color near the building.

2:39:26 And that's what we'd be adhering to,

2:39:28 is these types of materials outlined to be used

2:39:33 on those types of buildings.

2:39:36 No purple buildings.

2:39:38 It's not shown on there.

2:39:39 Nope.

2:39:41 Nicky Boyd.

2:39:46 So what we're being asked tonight,

2:39:50 there's many, many things in here.

2:39:52 One is it being annexed into the city,

2:39:58 where they're giving us a lot of this kind of information

2:40:02 in the ZDA process, once it's outright allowed,

2:40:08 this information is all we get,

2:40:11 and it doesn't come back through a hearing process

2:40:15 of a final approval.

2:40:16 if break down what we have to decide tonight,

2:40:20 annexation, height.

2:40:26 You are at your request is annexation

2:40:30 with this specific zoning designation.

2:40:34 And what makes us so complicated is we're basically

2:40:36 creating in a way its own zoning district

2:40:40 because we are placing limitations on the land uses,

2:40:43 placing limitations on access,

2:40:46 those types of things that they've shown.

2:40:49 The other limitations is the types of materials they're using,

2:40:53 or creating its own zoning district or agreement

2:40:55 that they will develop the property as shown

2:40:57 within this document, or as they can modify

2:41:00 per the code if they don't change those other aid items.

2:41:04 So what you would see is if this were approved,

2:41:08 they would come back with plats for these areas

2:41:11 showing at that point lots.

2:41:13 It's a final, instead of, it's a very nice diagram, I think it's beautiful.

2:41:19 But that's not, that's an artist's illustration, but they come back with plats.

2:41:24 But once we put this through tonight, then we're actually locking down.

2:41:30 Now the clients who are doing this own the property, but they're just getting this ready

2:41:36 for other people who want to build in these different phases to come and do that.

2:41:42 We'd get a plaque for this area by the say it's this one right for it however many lots

2:41:47 Right, they decide through the planning process that doesn't change from what we currently have right they go through that whole network

2:41:53 The whole thing of going through engineering and water sewer how that works

2:41:57 At that point it would be coming to you to review the plaque

2:42:01 We'd review the plan according to what this document says if there's any changes that I need to put this document

2:42:07 It's not it can be approved if we got a building permit for something

2:42:12 or land use, we go back through this document to see what is going to be required for those land

2:42:18 uses. Is it permitted? Does it require special use permit? Those things all following our current

2:42:23 code. You would see a building down here that could be built according to a few different steps.

2:42:33 What our current C1 zoning code states or if this document limits those uses and or the size or

2:42:41 the type of construction, we would go off of the most restrictive.

2:42:47 And the beauty of the ZDA is you can, once you get what's out right allowed the right

2:42:54 word or once, what's permitted, then that streamline, the process makes it streamline

2:43:01 because this is going to take several years and that way every time something happens,

2:43:07 and they're not coming back getting a whole new permission to do whatever.

2:43:10 It's all in the ZDA.

2:43:12 The beauty of it is all in the ZDA and since we reference our zoning code,

2:43:17 the decision rests with the City Council for the finality of what can happen there.

2:43:22 We go with if we change our code, usually we don't go more restrictive,

2:43:26 usually we point out certain things or make things better defined.

2:43:31 The City Council has a decision on what our code states.

2:43:34 So since this points to our code city councils the final decision-maker on what the zoning and what's permitted in these land uses now typically

2:43:42 We have to be careful with what we take away

2:43:45 And we would be identifying those with you prior to doing that with our code, but

2:43:49 Typically our codes be pretty stable and we don't anticipate changing drastically

2:43:53 But it's something that's already out there that the developers know what the C1 zoning cuts states

2:43:58 We're not creating its own document that we see with all the PUDs, we have that they can

2:44:04 choose different land uses.

2:44:07 So I just wanted to make sure I understood the ZDA and how it was going to work and what

2:44:13 we were actually approving tonight.

2:44:16 Thank you very much.

2:44:19 Suzanne, I'm going to go back to the hike a little bit.

2:44:24 So the applicant has asked for the right to have a building height adjustment by special

2:44:31 use permit.

2:44:32 Could we attach to that that it has to go through a citizen committee like the west side?

2:44:38 Are we allowed to establish ground rules like that in addition to what they're asking for?

2:44:43 You certainly have the right to place any conditions to change any DMOUs you wish.

2:44:47 Do you know why there was a distinction between west side of blue lakes and east side of blue

2:44:53 on that Canyon Room overlay and citizen committee versus special use and so

2:45:00 this is the this is the building height exception and this is the code right out

2:45:05 of the code. In fact about building height beyond owner feet in the kingdom maybe

2:45:09 allowed for hotel convention through the DDA process within 1000 feet of state

2:45:14 administered highways serving as gateway arterials and as defined in section 10

2:45:19 and 72, which is the gear materials.

2:45:21 And then it defines the term hotel convention center

2:45:25 shall be defined as really what was happening

2:45:28 is they're saying if it's not within 1,000 feet

2:45:30 of the state administered highway, you can't ask for it.

2:45:33 So is this within the thousand feet?

2:45:35 It's not.

2:45:36 But there's a second area of the code

2:45:40 which was used for elevations building

2:45:42 that addresses community and artistic cultural facilities.

2:45:48 facilities. And it's also specifically between Washington and Blue Lakes. That's the west side one.

2:45:55 This one's with thousand feet from Blue Lakes essentially. But we could put the caveat on there

2:46:02 that yes, especially use permit, but also with the Citizens Advisory Committee on that. So we could

2:46:09 hear back from the citizens on there. Thank you. Any more questions? There are no more questions

2:46:20 at this time, John.

2:46:23 Positive to the Canyon Rim is an increase in the access points to the trail.

2:46:29 Adding a little bit more parking in areas for people that are living in this location

2:46:33 and attending, going to the commercial areas that will be connected to the room up there.

2:46:38 Basically, we see more traffic on the room, possibly more activities depending on how any

2:46:45 parked dedication goes.

2:46:46 It could be an addition of a nice park or something like that through the Parks and Rec

2:46:52 dedication process with the planning.

2:46:55 So that's a positive to the rim by expanding public access to it.

2:47:00 It should be noted as far as city code.

2:47:03 City code does not address aesthetics.

2:47:06 City code does not talk about the types of materials you use.

2:47:09 ZDA requires the applicants to propose those.

2:47:12 So, staff does not have any comments on aesthetics, which is not the city code.

2:47:19 Council should review the proposed master development plan and proposed zoning designations and any

2:47:23 mitigating conditions to any possible impacts that may be deemed necessary.

2:47:27 The last item is a traffic with the access impact due to the location of the project along

2:47:32 Pull Line and the proximity of Blue Lakes Boulevard North.

2:47:38 This project will have an impact on the local road network.

2:47:42 the natural barrier of the Snake River Canyon access to the Overall Street Network is limited

2:47:46 to Poline Road only. It's the only way in and out of this development as they're proposing

2:47:50 it today. It does not show access to Bridge River Boulevard or any other local roadway.

2:47:56 This will funnel all traffic to Poline Road to the south. The developers stated they would

2:48:01 like more, but this certain thing we have today only shows access to Poline Road.

2:48:07 With Poline being an overloaded arterial and its current underdeveloped state, the increased

2:48:10 traffic and access to this particular stretch will create a significant impact.

2:48:15 As previously stated, this project is anticipated to be constructed over multiple years, so the

2:48:20 full impact will not manifest immediately.

2:48:22 However, it would be careless for staff to ignore the issues of the future while discussing

2:48:26 the currently proposed projects.

2:48:28 A widening of the roadway and potential drop lanes to service this project may be needed

2:48:32 in order to mitigate the increase of traffic on an already congested roadway.

2:48:38 In conclusion, during the August 9th meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission, a favorable

2:48:41 recommendation was forwarded to the City Council by about of eight in favor and zero

2:48:45 opposed with the following conditions. Number one subject is site

2:48:49 condiments as required by building engineering fire and zoning officials to

2:48:52 ensure compliance with applicable city code requirements and standards. Two

2:48:56 subject to pull on road widening and possible drop lanes being designed and

2:48:59 constructed per city engineer approval. Number three subject to length of public

2:49:04 roadway designated on conceptual development plan to be determined by

2:49:07 city engineer. That one's specifically talking about this public road internally and where

2:49:13 the public maintenance stops or starts to be left up to the city. That is all.

2:49:24 That's enough. Any other questions for Jonathan at this time?

2:49:36 If not, we will open the public hearing portion of the agenda and allow members of the public

2:49:43 to come up and address this issue with the council. Is there anyone wishing to address

2:49:47 the council. Seeing no one, we will close the public input portion of the agenda.

2:49:57 And Dave, do you have any additional items you would like to present to us?

2:50:01 Just a comment. My client's property isn't within a thousand feet of the state administered highways.

2:50:09 I'm not between Blue Lakes and Washington. I need a mechanism to market this property

2:50:14 to the users that we believe will be interested. We believe because of the

2:50:19 the valuation of the property, that the additional density that a third story would

2:50:24 afford or a multiple story would afford will require additional height. And therefore, I'm

2:50:29 asking for a mechanism to do that. I am sensitive to the proximity of the Canyon Rim, and I

2:50:35 was told that that's going to be a major hurdle. And at both the preliminary P&Z hearing,

2:50:41 the regular P&Z hearing, and now this hearing, the only person to show up is Mr. David Sparks

2:50:46 from the community over here, despite notifying everyone

2:50:52 and publishing according to state rules.

2:50:54 And so while I am sensitive to that,

2:50:56 I would hope that the council would make consideration

2:51:00 and give some weight to the lack of participation or concern

2:51:04 for our development.

2:51:06 Thank you.

2:51:08 Thank you, Dave.

2:51:10 Greg Lanting.

2:51:12 Well, I think this is interesting one.

2:51:15 You cut in right after Mr. David Meat passed away,

2:51:19 because I guarantee he would have been here.

2:51:21 Yeah, but a lot of moving parts to this,

2:51:27 and I'm trying to make sure I have it around my head.

2:51:28 What's amazing is like last Monday night,

2:51:31 I walked this stretch and thought,

2:51:34 was I was going to my mistress' parks' property

2:51:37 and waved to him, and I said,

2:51:39 yeah, I wonder when this part's gonna develop,

2:51:41 and then we get the packet and I'm fighting it.

2:51:43 I'm like, okay, that was pretty quick.

2:51:47 I am generally in favor, obviously,

2:51:49 of annexing the property with some restrictions

2:51:53 on the heights that we get to take a look at it,

2:51:56 to be honest with you.

2:51:57 Well, even with the special use permit,

2:51:59 we can still take a look at it,

2:52:01 because we can appeal special use permit with P and Z

2:52:05 as we can appeal that on our own.

2:52:07 Individual council members may advance

2:52:10 a special use permit to the council for consideration.

2:52:14 So I'm not worried about us getting the chance

2:52:16 to look at it.

2:52:17 I guess I'm in agreement.

2:52:23 I just, if we get the proper wording in

2:52:25 that so that everyone is protected,

2:52:27 and if there is additional height is contemplated.

2:52:36 We have the mechanism to do so,

2:52:39 but with having a chance for us as the representative,

2:52:43 like to represent the city citizens

2:52:46 to be able to weigh in on it.

2:52:56 That you're gonna make them all go through.

2:52:57 I'll weigh in on that as well.

2:52:59 I think to Dave's point, there needs to be a mechanism to provide some opportunity to look

2:53:07 at that because again, I think when you look at our community and you compare it to other

2:53:13 communities with a beautiful natural scenic amenity, they tend to have hotels and convention centers

2:53:20 on them.

2:53:21 Look at the Cortilane Resort in Cortilane.

2:53:27 Our Canyon is Lake Cortilane with no water in it.

2:53:31 I do believe that we need to have a mechanism.

2:53:35 I am not convinced that just having a go directly to the Planning and Zoning Commission is the

2:53:40 appropriate review mechanism.

2:53:43 So I would be supportive of language that uses the same the Citizens Committee without all

2:53:53 the other restrictions around it to have that proposal come through and go forward.

2:53:59 But again, the general concept of this mixed-use development, I think, is spot-on for this area

2:54:07 of town.

2:54:08 I think the last thing you want is two or three big boxes plotted there.

2:54:14 You don't want it to be a big giant gated community that nobody else can access.

2:54:18 needs to be mixed use to provide really some lifestyle amenities that you know as

2:54:26 Jonathan pointed out we just haven't been able to pull the trigger on yet in

2:54:30 this community and I think it really makes a lot of sense but I think for the

2:54:35 marketability of the property and certainly the value to owners we do need

2:54:38 to have a reasonable mechanism for them to be able to fall back on to look at

2:54:43 opportunities for the Canium Room development.

2:54:46 Mr. Do you have a comment?

2:54:49 So to that, to that same point, I was going to make a suggestion

2:54:53 to where our code actually contains two different processes

2:54:57 to request additional height.

2:54:59 There's the two that we've talked about tonight

2:55:02 that are codified in the Canium Room overlay.

2:55:06 And I believe, I wasn't here at the time,

2:55:09 but I believe that they were written the way that they were

2:55:12 Because the people who proposed the amendments had a very specific outcome they were looking

2:55:19 for and it did not include something over here.

2:55:22 And I mean when it says within a thousand feet of blue lakes somebody made a code request

2:55:26 to change because their property was within a thousand feet of blue lakes.

2:55:29 Or because their property was between Washington and blue lakes.

2:55:34 And somebody on the other side wasn't making a request and so it didn't get written

2:55:40 that way otherwise why, right?

2:55:42 So, anyway, so there's that process that's in there.

2:55:45 What that process says is go to a design review committee,

2:55:50 get an input from them, and then their input will go

2:55:53 into this process that we're having now, the ZDA

2:55:58 or at the time of the PUD process.

2:56:00 And that is a recommendation from the design review committee

2:56:03 to the Planning and Zoning Commission who then makes a

2:56:05 recommendation to the City Council.

2:56:07 And that is the process that's defined there.

2:56:11 Apart from that in the C1 zone just not not counting the candor

2:56:16 over there, but as in the C1 zone, we also have another process

2:56:18 to get additional height and that is a series of public hearings.

2:56:22 It goes to a public hearing and planning and zoning commission.

2:56:24 They make a recommendation and they come into a public hearing

2:56:27 here at the City Council and that was a change

2:56:30 that we did recently a year and a half, two years ago

2:56:33 to that whole additional height process.

2:56:35 Now that doesn't typically apply to the candor overlay,

2:56:39 but it could with if we were to say so in the in the body of this ZDA we could say go get additional height through the C1 additional height process and we could have a series of public hearings we can invite the public to come attend when we have a use when we have a hotel and when we can see the picture of it and that might be another appropriate option.

2:57:05 I don't see the person that would recommend creating yet another opportunity or another

2:57:11 process to go through like what's being proposed here.

2:57:14 I would rather pick one of the two that we already have in code and just use it.

2:57:20 I see going back through the ZDA process to be maybe a little bit cumbersome where we've

2:57:27 already done two of those hearings now without that.

2:57:31 to start over again would be, I don't know that I would be really supportive of that.

2:57:36 So I guess if it was up to me I would say let's just pick the C1, the process that we have

2:57:41 in code for additional height and the C1 and apply it to this property even in the Canyon

2:57:46 overlay if that's where the council is leaning toward going and that might be an appropriate

2:57:51 revision to make tonight.

2:57:52 It still gets you a public hearing, it still gets your public involvement, it still adds

2:57:58 the fact that the council then is the deciding authority not to planning and

2:58:01 zoning commission. Thank you Mitch. Nick, your boy. I think that's a really good idea.

2:58:09 That's what I was thinking about is not having this another separate advisory

2:58:15 whatever. I thought that was we have things in place for that. I think this is

2:58:20 spectacular and as much as we through tourism and everything we have all this

2:58:30 wonderful, fly fishing and kayaking and all the things you can do. There are lots of people

2:58:35 who live here that just don't do those things, but they would do this. They would use this

2:58:44 and the idea of having some kind of a convention center where we could have with all the hotel

2:58:51 rooms we have and then with that being there, what a great place for I can think of so

2:58:56 organizations that take their business out of town that could now keep it in

2:59:02 Twin Falls. We have a great place to come. It would be a great marketing tool.

2:59:07 Plus it would benefit everybody who lives here. I just think the time is so

2:59:12 come for this. So come for this. I very much in favor.

2:59:19 Thank you, Nicky. Great landing. I was going to make a motion to Don's like Kim

2:59:23 also maybe he's. I just have a comment real quick. I like this. I had the

2:59:28 Heights never bothered me along the canyon.

2:59:30 I've always been a proponent of that

2:59:33 if it's done tastefully in the right way.

2:59:38 The only concern that I have,

2:59:40 and I hope that we mitigate this,

2:59:43 is just the traffic volume in and out of a complex like this

2:59:48 because we have examples in other parts of the town

2:59:52 that it's really restrictive for folks.

2:59:59 And it's border lines on dangerous at times.

3:00:03 And I just hope that this is well thought out,

3:00:06 the traffic patterns and how many people are coming in out

3:00:09 of this complex.

3:00:12 But other than that, I mean, I think this is great use.

3:00:16 And I think I have to agree with Sean.

3:00:20 The last thing I'd really like to see here

3:00:22 is a bunch of big boxes.

3:00:23 We have enough of those already.

3:00:25 This is a quality development.

3:00:30 Greg Lant.

3:00:31 I would move that we approve the annexation and zoning district.

3:00:36 District change and zoning map amendment from SUI area of impact, that AOC was really small.

3:00:44 To R2R61 CRO ZDA or 28.84 plus for my executor's located on our side of the 1800 and 1900 blocks

3:00:54 of Poland and Rhode East and I would also add that to change the portion of the ZDA, it's

3:01:02 about how they can ask for additional height to,

3:01:07 they just follow the existing C1 code for additional height.

3:01:16 Did I cover that well enough, Mitch or not?

3:01:19 Okay, so that's probably,

3:01:22 that would be what I would recommend, exactly that,

3:01:23 just use the C1 language.

3:01:25 Now, I probably should tell you that what they're proposing

3:01:28 says the stuff about the convention center

3:01:31 and all that kind of thing.

3:01:32 If you would mirror the C1 language, you may not necessarily see a convention center, but

3:01:36 you will see the actual proposal of whatever they're going to do, whatever that happens

3:01:42 to be.

3:01:43 So if you remove what they've asked for, and you put in that, this idea of a convention

3:01:48 center, so every 500 people would probably go away with that, unless that's what happens

3:01:53 to be proposed when they come ask for it.

3:01:55 So yeah, I think your language is just exactly what I recommend.

3:01:59 I don't understand that.

3:02:02 So what Mitch is saying is that their current CDA says if it's a hotel or convention center,

3:02:10 they would be permitted to ask for additional height.

3:02:13 What Greg proposed is if you just want additional height, whether it's a hotel or convention

3:02:17 center or not, it would come through the C1.

3:02:20 So the question is whether we want it tied to a hotel or can you send it out?

3:02:25 Can I change my motion since there hasn't been a second?

3:02:28 I'm just going to change number two, C to, but after the Hotel Consension Center shall

3:02:37 be bended a height beyond 35 feet following the current C1 additional language and that

3:02:46 leaves the convention center and except really would like to see a convention center.

3:02:50 I'll second that motion.

3:02:53 So motion by Greg Lanting, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins

3:02:56 to approve the annexation and zoning district change

3:03:01 and zoning map amendment with the change

3:03:07 to the building height condition by Greg Lanting,

3:03:11 seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.

3:03:12 My question are the conditions

3:03:14 at the Planning and Zoning Commission.

3:03:16 I don't know if you can hear that.

3:03:17 I'm feeling right as well.

3:03:18 Yeah, can I add those as well?

3:03:20 Yes.

3:03:21 Yes.

3:03:22 Yes.

3:03:22 Okay.

3:03:24 So including the recommendations of the planning

3:03:26 and zoning commission and with the change

3:03:28 to the additional building height request process,

3:03:32 motion and a second.

3:03:33 Any further discussion from the council?

3:03:38 Seeing none, Sharon Ralco, please.

3:03:40 Don Hall.

3:03:42 Yes.

3:03:42 Ruth Pierce.

3:03:43 Yes.

3:03:44 Suzanne Hopkins.

3:03:45 Yes.

3:03:46 Nikki Boyd.

3:03:47 Yes.

3:03:48 Sean Bericher.

3:03:49 Yes.

3:03:50 Chris Tockington.

3:03:51 Yes.

3:03:52 Reg Lanting.

3:03:53 Yes.

3:03:54 Motion passes 7-2-0.

3:03:59 their banjo for their business

3:04:01 meeting is adjourned

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, September 12, 2016. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 03:04:09.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    b87cf86fd686064ca897095307041ecb66c2808874c8789a960decc331c8f1e5
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min, with 1 passage muted for privacy. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a ce9c5a12742b8081580b0cff1ccc773028a303bbc2c0ec6256ee58cc5b712d6a
    part02.m4a 7e06ecd52d4fc759cf29b4c2e5a7bc49773e80bc77d576c2f444e4bca5a2fa04
    part03.m4a d107ee87bd57263e9043d57d407fdb272d3e2089093465905c95bd2911f8c09e
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 4 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    8196621094421de2e63235071ffe0936d15d20af1fd18c407233ecd04d2f3226

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file