City Council meeting
Monday, November 7, 2016
Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:11:29 I'd like to call to order the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council for Monday, November 7th.
0:11:34 At the start off, we have several Boy Scouts here who I've asked if they would come forward
0:11:39 and please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance.
0:11:41 For those of you who wish to join us, please rise.
0:11:43 Boy, as you can come on down in the front here, it's to the flag of the United States
0:12:07 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:12:19 And then if you would all just stick around
0:12:21 up here and head up to the podium there
0:12:23 and give us your name and tell us which troop you're with
0:12:26 and what you're working on, that would be fantastic.
0:12:30 My name is Ben Wallace and I'm with the Troop 60.
0:12:37 Working on my citizens yet.
0:12:39 All right.
0:12:41 My name is Harris Burge.
0:12:43 I'm in the Troop 60 and I'm working on my citizenship.
0:12:47 Citizenship.
0:12:50 My name is Morgan Clayborn and I'm with Troop 60
0:12:53 and I'm working on my citizenship.
0:12:59 My name is Bryant Harding.
0:13:00 I am with Troop 60 as well,
0:13:02 and I am working on my citizenship
0:13:04 in the world and nation merit badges.
0:13:09 Excellent.
0:13:11 In the two that's not candy,
0:13:12 you get punished and have to come forward as well.
0:13:15 Please just tell us your name
0:13:18 and what you're working on this evening.
0:13:22 Tell me your name and what you're working on this evening.
0:13:25 My name is Adam Wallace,
0:13:27 and I'm working on my citizenship
0:13:29 the community. Excellent. I'm Jeremy Wallace and I'm working on citizenship in the community.
0:13:39 Great. Thank you. Wally Wallace, I'm working on patience. Outstanding. Well, thank you
0:13:51 boys. Hopefully this will be an enjoyable evening for you. So we do have a quorum of
0:13:58 The council, all seven members are here this evening.
0:14:01 Mr. Rothweiler, are there any amendments to the agenda this evening?
0:14:04 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, there are no amendments this evening.
0:14:07 Thank you.
0:14:08 Next on the agenda we have a proclamation for the People's Christmas Tree.
0:14:13 Whereas the custom of placing the People's Christmas Tree on the West Front lawn of the United
0:14:17 States Capitol in Washington, D.C. dates back to 1964.
0:14:22 And since 1970, the People's Christmas Tree has come from a national forest.
0:14:26 Whereas Idaho has been given the unique honor to provide the U.S. Capital Christmas Tree
0:14:30 in 2016 harvested from the Payette National Forest.
0:14:34 And whereas the 2016 Tree from Idaho and this project provide an excellent opportunity
0:14:39 to highlight Idaho and the public lands and natural resources located here.
0:14:45 And whereas in addition to providing the U.S. Capital Christmas Tree, 60 to 70 smaller companion
0:14:50 trees will be provided for federal government offices, the U.S. Supreme Court and the National
0:14:55 Arboretum, and whereas Idaho's school children are involved in helping to make approximately
0:15:00 8,000 handcrafted ornaments to decorate the U.S. capital Christmas tree, and whereas community
0:15:06 celebrations will showcase the tree on its journey to Washington, D.C., including an event
0:15:11 in Twin Falls on Monday, November 14, 2016, at the Twin Falls City Park.
0:15:16 Now therefore, I, Sean Berriger, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, urge our citizens to participate
0:15:21 in the activities surrounding the 2016 U.S. Capitol Christmas tree, including the community
0:15:26 celebrations and ornament making, and to thank the organizers and sponsors who have made these
0:15:30 activities possible. And I've signed that and I'm going to hang on to it and I will give
0:15:35 that to our friends at the Forest Service next Monday at our celebration. So I would encourage
0:15:40 folks to make plans to attend that event. We will be starting our City Council meeting
0:15:45 early next Monday. We're going to start at four o'clock so that we will be finished by
0:15:50 by six to be over to the park will have musical entertainment from the choirs at both Canyon
0:15:56 Ridge and Twin Falls High School and a saxophone quartet from the municipal band. The Forest
0:16:01 Service will be there handing out passes, every kid in a park passes, so any fourth grader
0:16:07 who attends with their family gets a pass for access to all national parks for free next
0:16:14 year, quite a bargain. And we are asking as well that folks who want to attend to please
0:16:19 bring a non-perishable food item, the police department, and the Twin Falls Chamber Ambassadors
0:16:25 will be collecting those food donations and donating them to local food banks this holiday
0:16:33 season, and we'll have a big potato and chili feed for folks who bring those donations.
0:16:38 So, there's my spiel on that.
0:16:40 Next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input.
0:16:46 If there's anyone here from the public who wishes to address the Council on an item that
0:16:50 that is not on this evening's agenda.
0:16:52 You're welcome to come forward and do so.
0:16:58 Seeing no one, we will move on with our agenda.
0:17:02 The first item for consideration is the consent calendar.
0:17:05 Nikki Boyd.
0:17:12 Second.
0:17:14 Motion by Nikki Boyd, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins
0:17:17 to approve the consent calendar.
0:17:20 Is there any discussion?
0:17:23 Seeing none, Sharon, we'll call vote please.
0:17:25 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:17:26 Yes.
0:17:27 Nikki Boyd.
0:17:28 Yes.
0:17:29 Mr. President, Mr. President, Mr. President, Mr. President, Mr. President, Mr. President,
0:17:36 Mr. President, Mr. President, Mr. President, Mr. President, Mr. President, Mr. President,
0:17:43 Mr. President, Mr. President, Mr. President, Mr. President, Mr. President, Mr. President,
0:17:49 Mr. President, Mr. President, Mr. President, Mr. President, Mr. President, Mr. President,
0:17:54 Mr. President, Mr. President, Mr. President, Mr. President, Mr. President, Mr. President,
0:17:59 three dollars and we have our city engineer Jackie Fields. Welcome, Jackie.
0:18:04 This evening's presentation is going to be done by a small group of us.
0:18:08 So I'll start and then Brad Willes will
0:18:12 participate in the discussion and then I'll revert back to the staff
0:18:16 and some form for more discussion on the budget.
0:18:22 Okay, so the background
0:18:26 on this item is that developers are required to make
0:18:30 provision for the logical extension of public utilities.
0:18:34 And when this usually occurs during plating
0:18:36 and the execution of our development agreements,
0:18:40 in the last decade, it has become apparent
0:18:43 that in order to continue development
0:18:45 on the south side of town,
0:18:47 some significant improvements would be required
0:18:50 at staggering costs to the existing water
0:18:54 and wastewater infrastructure.
0:18:57 Because these improvements had far exceeded their design life
0:19:02 in their actual life expectancy.
0:19:05 The city designed and constructed about $6 million
0:19:08 in improvements, or we're doing that now,
0:19:10 $6 million of improvements to the sewer trunk lines
0:19:14 in Rock Creek and the Grandview sewer,
0:19:16 as well as another $6 million on Rock Creek lift station
0:19:20 and the Will's Booster station that pumps,
0:19:22 pressurizes the water from our wells.
0:19:28 Will's Booster and Rock Creek lift station
0:19:30 make provision for expansion in the future.
0:19:35 So, and then the community voted for sewer line projects
0:19:42 to address Rock Creek sewer.
0:19:43 Those are really large diameter lines.
0:19:45 They're difficult to place, and they serve
0:19:49 a huge group of people.
0:19:54 While staff does not always need to make significant
0:19:59 provision for the future. We are required to make some provision for the future in our
0:20:05 design to satisfy DEQ and more importantly we need to address why this is the right thing
0:20:13 to do in the long haul. So we try to do a design that's actually going to work for the
0:20:17 whole design life facility so that people can tie on to it and we can all benefit from
0:20:24 We think that's the best way to address the life cycle cost and the actual community need
0:20:30 the bang for the buck as it were.
0:20:38 I started waving my hands and lost my place.
0:20:41 Okay, so we have done that.
0:20:46 And there is the ability to add pumps and the controls at both the rock creek lift station
0:20:51 and the will's water pumping station in the future when it's needed.
0:20:54 There's a little bit of capacity now, but you know, it'll be easier to handle all of our
0:21:00 growth as we progress because we've dealt with major issues like routing wet wells and
0:21:06 insufficiently sized wet wells for the new demand.
0:21:09 And those stations were both really old, so they were appropriately designed for the time,
0:21:12 but the times have changed and there was, we needed to address that.
0:21:20 Let's see.
0:21:24 When we plats, the developers have the ability to recoup some of their costs for building
0:21:33 in this logical progression of infrastructure.
0:21:37 And that cost really is a cost to late comers.
0:21:42 So if you're the developer that develops last,
0:21:46 there is no one who comes lately to add on.
0:21:50 So this project, that'll become important later.
0:21:57 I'll readress it later.
0:21:58 So this is our project proposal right now.
0:22:06 So we're looking at Highway 74, the two little round circles are the city's water tanks, Washington
0:22:12 Street South is right here next to the blue.
0:22:17 This is the request that the city consider constructing this line.
0:22:23 The developers remain responsible and willing to construct this line at least out to Harrison
0:22:29 and then to extend it as time goes on, you know, in that direction.
0:22:34 There's possibility with the tea that gets placed here to, at some point in time in the
0:22:40 future, extend the water line in this direction to provide a spine for that portion of the
0:22:44 community.
0:22:53 Okay, so once again, there are water tanks and that little piece right there is the proposed
0:23:04 city project and here is the proposed developers project.
0:23:08 These little shaded blobs are the individuals that are participating in the construction
0:23:17 of this line at this time.
0:23:19 And then these other hatched marks are potential contributors in the future.
0:23:26 So if you look at the picture together, just about everyone who has not already constructed
0:23:34 in the area between Orchard, Blue Lakes, 3,600 North,
0:23:39 and Washington Street South will be participating
0:23:42 or could participate in this future or in this project.
0:23:46 In addition, there's space over here where there may be a
0:23:51 possibility to consider that later, you know,
0:23:55 as we continue to grow.
0:24:06 Sadly, and I've decided I'm going to become more paper
0:24:08 efficient and I didn't turn the page over.
0:24:11 This was duplex copied, so except number two is now last.
0:24:15 And these are the service areas for the ability to serve
0:24:18 out of a spine that goes this way.
0:24:20 So you can hardly see it here, but right there,
0:24:23 where the red dot is, is the proposed city line.
0:24:28 Here's the developer's line, that's the project.
0:24:30 And here is the service area that will, at some point,
0:24:34 benefit from the construction of this line, right here.
0:24:38 So everybody wins, there is, I did not ask the person who helped me generate these graphics
0:24:46 to place in all of the pressure or dizzying valves that run along the north side.
0:24:50 So there's a little tiny bit of area up here out of the U-line and right along the edge
0:24:55 that will not be included as a beneficiary in here because they fall into a different
0:24:59 pressure zone and they're served differently, okay?
0:25:12 So I think this would be a good point in time for me to step aside and have Brad
0:25:16 I will speak a little bit and we'll come back to talk about that.
0:25:21 Thank you, Jackie.
0:25:27 Welcome, Brad.
0:25:29 Mayor and City Council people.
0:25:33 I'm taking off my CDU hat, so I am not representing CDU tonight.
0:25:39 And also, I don't own any land in this area that we're discussing.
0:25:46 But I've been involved from the start.
0:25:48 So what I thought might be helpful is just a little quick history.
0:25:58 So, in 2003 when I came back to the Magic Valley, was right when we had been building
0:26:09 the same number of homes every year, about 175.
0:26:13 And so in 2004, 2005, 2006 was when we saw the incredible numbers, and we were panicking
0:26:21 because we didn't have enough land south of town, and that was where we were building
0:26:26 or more affordable houses or workforce housing, we'd call it.
0:26:32 So in the fall of 2007, we met as a group of developers in the same way that we've met
0:26:37 on numerous issues.
0:26:41 And at that time, several of the developers had to pay about $200,000.0 power to bring
0:26:47 in a grid of power into this area, and they end up splitting all the costs.
0:26:52 point all the way up to Golden Eagle. In 2008, we were looking at Gary Burke and
0:27:02 had done an estimate of about a little over eight million dollars it was the
0:27:06 infrastructure bill that we were looking at and we gathered up everything on this
0:27:11 on the east is called the southeast basin everything east of Washington. We
0:27:20 We were looking at 8.3 million split among about 1600 lots, or it was going to be about
0:27:26 $5,000 per lot, and that included the lift station in Rock Creek.
0:27:32 The lines that were not big enough for the sewer collection and also the wheels booster
0:27:38 station and a couple other things.
0:27:41 So at that point, the market had not changed, so we were still moving forward figuring out
0:27:46 how could we do that.
0:27:47 in the LID, then we looked at a CID, which is a community
0:27:51 infrastructure district, which is like Harris Ranch
0:27:54 in the Boise area.
0:27:56 Again, they had large infrastructures to try to spread.
0:27:59 And the problem is one developer just cannot do
0:28:03 that project by himself.
0:28:05 It has to be a group effort.
0:28:09 So in 2010, you got, you guys, the city council used judicial
0:28:15 confirmation to upgrade your rock creek
0:28:20 lift station over by Addison.
0:28:25 2012 was the last meeting that we had looking at the CID,
0:28:29 and then we just kind of decided that we couldn't do it.
0:28:33 So we want to first say that we really appreciate
0:28:39 all the city has done at this point.
0:28:40 You have really done an incredible job as far
0:28:45 as taking care of the lift station,
0:28:46 taking care of the Will's booster station.
0:28:49 By no means do we feel like you guys have not tried your
0:28:53 hardest.
0:28:54 We did the collection, sewer bonds, where we can get the
0:28:57 million dollars fixed in Rock Creek.
0:29:00 So everything has been in place, but we still have one more
0:29:05 piece of the puzzle to solve.
0:29:07 And this is the water line to open up that whole area.
0:29:12 When I came before you for the new middle school, that was
0:29:16 pretty much the last permission that we had to go forward without some major thing happening.
0:29:25 Schools spent $30 million on South Hills Middle School. We feel like that will be the start
0:29:32 of the growth again in that area. And right now we have some lots in Golden Eagle, which
0:29:38 is the subdivision to the west and to the north of the school site. But that's about all that's
0:29:44 out there. If we could get this puzzles piece solved this winter then we feel we
0:29:55 have three different developments that are ready to go forward so so we looked at
0:30:04 doing our the whole portion here and it was it's quite costly and so we we came
0:30:12 back we as the the several developers here came to the city and asked if you
0:30:18 would participate in the first section to get it up to $3,600, and then we would
0:30:26 take the million dollars and spread it among all the developments. There's about
0:30:31 a thousand lots there. If you figure we're doing 225 homes a year right now, single
0:30:38 family. It used to be we did about 40% of our homes south of Rock Creek. That
0:30:45 markets change a little bit, but even if we do, you know, 25% of our future homes in there,
0:30:51 that's still 50 homes a year that we could be developing to help the workforce people that
0:30:57 are coming in. So I think that is, I mean, the staff did an incredible job going through
0:31:06 describing what we're proposing and I think that is the end of my presentation. Do you
0:31:15 guys have questions. Chris talking to me. Brandon, reacquaint us with South Hills Middle School. It
0:31:23 was able to utilize the existing water pressure structure infrastructure, meaning the needs without
0:31:31 impacting existing housing. But it pretty well kind of depleted any available reserves or capacity. Is
0:31:39 Is that a proper way of stating it?
0:31:42 So when it was determined that the water system, the
0:31:49 zoning that they have there was at capacity, no more approvals were done after that point.
0:31:57 The subdivision right here was calistoga springs.
0:32:03 They had 66 wheel-served, still available.
0:32:07 So when we did the school, we purchased 66 will serves from that subdivision to give
0:32:16 us the capacity to do that school.
0:32:19 So that's where we came up to it.
0:32:22 You've done a lot of water studies in the last five years.
0:32:27 What helps the school a little bit is that they are, in a sense, a little bit downhill,
0:32:33 But when you start developing in this area, and more on the lawn that way, that's where
0:32:39 we run into the problem.
0:32:41 Downstream they have pressure reducing valves because of the gravity thing.
0:32:47 So that's how we got the middle school.
0:32:49 But when we did that, it was very tight.
0:32:52 It was a little bit of a worry, but I believe it's turned out to be okay.
0:32:59 But then much of any other developments going to occur just by trading the well serves
0:33:05 No amongst the various people those were the last
0:33:08 Will serves that they were okay, there are
0:33:13 We only needed 40 of them and we ended up
0:33:17 Selling them back to the developer so there are 26 will serve sitting out there that are not built at this point
0:33:25 Ruth there's Brad how when you say three different developments ready to hit the ground?
0:33:31 How many homes are we talking about in that those three potentially?
0:33:36 Typically, a developer normally does maybe 25-30 lots at a time.
0:33:43 There's an economy in scale.
0:33:45 Sure.
0:33:46 But yet, there's the turnover or the takedown.
0:33:51 And if you really only want to get about enough for a year or so.
0:33:56 So, there are subdivisions, Calistoga Springs, that has a final plaid recorded, South Estates,
0:34:07 which is around the LDS Church there, has infrastructure that's in place and they have
0:34:14 an improved final plaid.
0:34:18 Beno's Point has an approved final plaid and lots available.
0:34:24 And then we have a project here that's called Valencia Park, and that is that for the townhouse
0:34:34 project that you may have seen, and probably that one is the most ready to go.
0:34:39 I think if that one, if we were able to do that, and that one's probably the one that's
0:34:44 going to start right away, and that would be some multifamily housing, which we are
0:34:48 doing none of what we really need to be doing there.
0:34:51 So, thank you very much.
0:34:54 Any other questions for Brad while he's still there Nicky boy. I just thought of when Brad the the builder for that
0:35:02 Valencia park is that that's an out-of-state or out-of-town individual correct? Yeah, that I believe
0:35:09 Dennis is from Wyoming
0:35:11 Yes, okay, that is correct. And so is he one of the people that would be going in on this? Yes
0:35:18 He's one of the partners with the group. Yeah, thank you
0:35:22 Any other questions for Brad? Thank you Mr. Will. Thank you. Okay so the city's
0:35:37 being asked to participate in about 660 feet of 24 inch waterline and as I said
0:35:45 before that could be the backbone for the western part of the south side of town
0:35:49 as well as the eastern side and that cost is estimated at about six hundred
0:35:55 the development community for what is shown in red only, not the rest of the work that they
0:36:04 still have to do, is estimated at about a million dollars, I believe, by the estimate that they
0:36:09 gave me.
0:36:10 And that water mine is about 1,580 feet.
0:36:15 So the reason they're fairly spending jobs is that the rock is quite high in that neighborhood
0:36:20 And we have some measurable other water lines
0:36:26 to try to get around while we're making our way past
0:36:31 our existing well site over to about Valencia Park.
0:36:34 And I think we spilled Valencia wrong, unbelievable.
0:36:37 Okay, that has to be my challenge here.
0:36:41 Okay, so currently we have about $300,000
0:36:46 in waterfront reserves that could be made available
0:36:50 for this project and there's two possibilities
0:36:53 for securing the remaining funds on the city's part.
0:36:59 One of them comes from bond covenants
0:37:01 in order to meet the requirements of our,
0:37:04 well, kind of, in order to meet the requirements
0:37:07 of our arsenic bond covenants,
0:37:09 we're required to collect 125% of the cost
0:37:12 that it takes to operate the water system.
0:37:14 And what we've done with this other 25%
0:37:18 that we have put it into a reserve account for early payoff of the bonds.
0:37:25 So a potential opportunity is for that little payoff reserve account to supplement existing
0:37:34 reserves with a loan that could either be paid with when reserves become available after
0:37:40 the audit in January or could be paid back by providing an offset in operating or capital
0:37:49 funds in the future.
0:37:52 Second possibility is to supplement the water fund with the loan from the capital improvement
0:37:57 fund which is technically a separate category with the same type of payback opportunity.
0:38:04 The capital improvement fund does have sufficient reserve to enable this as a temporary measure
0:38:09 if you chose that.
0:38:19 This time I'll attempt to answer any questions that you have
0:38:22 if you have them of staff or someone else
0:38:26 to try to answer that.
0:38:28 Otherwise, staff is going to recommend
0:38:30 that funding is provided to this project.
0:38:40 And it's going to request that the council approve
0:38:43 amending the budget to include the design and construction
0:38:45 of a 24-inch line from Will's Wooster Station
0:38:47 to the intersection of 3600 North on Washington Street.
0:38:50 So at a cost of $592,403.
0:38:56 And then staff is also recommending the council approve a request to fund this project by utilizing water fund reserves and borrowing the remainder from arsenic bond.
0:39:08 Greg Lanting.
0:39:11 The arsenic bond funds we would, the reserve that we built there with the thought process of paying off early. What is the interest on that bond do we know?
0:39:24 You know, I don't know what the interest is on that bond.
0:39:28 I do know that the term, it's through the Idaho Bond Bank and it was sold at a time prior
0:39:34 to the interest rates falling down.
0:39:38 Staff is currently investigating an opportunity to refinance that in which we believe that we'll
0:39:43 save over $400,000 in the remaining balance associated with that, but I can't tell you
0:39:48 what the interest rate is.
0:39:49 But we are investigating that part.
0:39:51 And it is higher than what we're anticipating in the market.
0:39:54 And I think Lori is going to be making a presentation to you
0:39:57 either next week or on the 28th to have a conversation about that.
0:40:03 OK.
0:40:04 Second question, Jackie, is if we take it out of the capital,
0:40:08 we're basically loaning out of the capital fund
0:40:12 to the water fund and then the water fund would repay us.
0:40:16 Repay the capital fund out to us.
0:40:18 Repay the capital fund.
0:40:19 is that with the way I understand it?
0:40:21 You're not recommending that, but that's what that one would be.
0:40:24 That's accurate.
0:40:27 Travis.
0:40:28 So what we're looking at doing is
0:40:32 we're looking at the council to give authorization
0:40:34 to first move forward with the project.
0:40:37 The second step is right now pre-audit.
0:40:41 So we are looking at cash reserves
0:40:43 that we have not committed based upon the 2015 fiscal year
0:40:48 audit in the neighborhood of about $300,000.
0:40:52 We will go through and close out the books and we will come out with a final number at
0:40:56 the conclusion of the fiscal year 2016 audit which just ended in October.
0:41:01 And we do know that we are going to be putting money back into cash reserves and it could be
0:41:06 enough to cover this entire balance of this project moving forward.
0:41:10 And in which case, there is really technically no loan from any of those funds.
0:41:16 But what we're doing is we're trying to create a series of pathways to be able to one move
0:41:20 forward with the project, because this is the window of opportunity for the development
0:41:24 community.
0:41:26 There is considerable work and design work that they have to do.
0:41:29 After they get the city's commitment, the development community is going to work collaboratively
0:41:34 to shore up the resources that they need to be able to do their portion, and then the
0:41:38 idea is to try to hit the ground running in the spring by being able to move forward.
0:41:43 So what we're looking for from the council is first the authorization to proceed and then
0:41:50 a little flexibility in determining what the way to fund it would be, recognizing that
0:41:57 there are those three options.
0:41:59 Again, revenues coming in from the fiscal year budget that haven't necessarily gone into reserves
0:42:05 a loan from the capital fund that would be paid back by the water fund or a loan from
0:42:13 the additional funds that we've captured to settle the arsenic debt early and to repay
0:42:19 that back as well.
0:42:21 In all of those cases we believe that there would be that repayment would occur if it
0:42:28 was even needed at the conclusion of the current fiscal year by the way in which we've been
0:42:32 able to cover or to bring in revenues and be very cautious on our expenditures.
0:42:39 Thank you. Chris talking to.
0:42:43 Well, I think this water line built out is absolutely essential for the healthy growth of the part of the town.
0:42:50 There's a logical growth corridor for especially first-time homeowners coming in.
0:42:56 I'm not sure we're all aware that when we have the will serves, we think of that in
0:43:02 the water potable capacity, but that also includes the fire lines to pressurize the hydrants,
0:43:11 correct on the will serves.
0:43:12 So without additional water pressure and capacity there, we're impacting not only insurance
0:43:18 rates, but just the ability to have any more growth out there.
0:43:23 I'm ready to make a motion on them, but I see their other lights, so I'll defer.
0:43:27 Not how?
0:43:28 Well, I have a question, my favorite question about storage, but first thing I want to say is that we talk about talent attraction all the time that we need to bring more people here.
0:43:41 Talent attraction is getting employees.
0:43:44 And this obviously is a corridor or an area for
0:43:48 workforce housing, entry level homes so that we can get those employees here.
0:43:54 Cuz we have fine companies and businesses that are looking for employees.
0:43:59 We have the luxury of having a very low unemployment, right?
0:44:03 But you need to have a place for those folks to live.
0:44:07 The multi-family ready to roll that Brad talked about is very appealing to me cuz
0:44:12 know I hear that time and time again that we need more multifamily units for
0:44:17 our for for these folks so so my my question really is so I'm supportive of
0:44:23 this but when do we need more storage out there with potential growth we need more
0:44:33 storage out there after we address more storage near Harrison station so currently
0:44:39 This is a pretty decent storage facility, but our primary focus should remain around Harrison.
0:44:47 And then potentially with the growth patterns with this area growing, this might be next.
0:44:55 I'm just asking you to do that.
0:44:57 I always like to talk about storage.
0:44:59 We need storage.
0:45:00 No, we appreciate support of storage.
0:45:02 It's awesome for flexibility and when you have things like power outages and so on.
0:45:07 And I would have to go back and refer to our planning document to see which tank came next.
0:45:13 Okay.
0:45:14 Okay.
0:45:15 Honestly, don't remember which one is next.
0:45:16 I just like to always put it on the burner when we can.
0:45:20 That's awesome.
0:45:22 Chris talking.
0:45:23 I would move to amend the 2017 budget for the design and construction of the 24-inch water
0:45:28 line so described in the amount of $592,403.
0:45:34 The funding can be paid for by available water reserves.
0:45:38 the rest from our SNCC bond fund and all that to be reimbursed upon completion of the project.
0:45:45 Second.
0:45:46 Second.
0:45:49 Motion by Chris Toggington, seconded by Ruth Pierce.
0:45:51 Don't ask me to repeat it.
0:45:54 To approve the request as presented.
0:45:55 There we go.
0:46:01 Seeing none, Sharon, we'll call the vote please.
0:46:03 Nikki Boyd.
0:46:04 Yes.
0:46:05 Sean Beriker.
0:46:06 Yes.
0:46:07 Chris Toggington.
0:46:08 Greg Lanting.
0:46:09 Yes.
0:46:10 Don Hogg.
0:46:11 Yes.
0:46:12 Susan Hawkins. Yes. Motion passes 7 to 0. So Jackie we had another group of
0:46:22 Boy Scouts show up here and if you wouldn't mind I'd like to have them come
0:46:26 up and introduce themselves at the microphone tell us which troop they're
0:46:30 with and what they're working on. You guys can blame Trent for having to show
0:46:34 up 15 minutes late. So we'll start off with you if you just come up to the podium
0:46:40 and give me your name and I'm Sam Robinson and I'm from troop 59 and we are
0:46:47 doing citizenship in the community and communications awesome and if you're
0:46:53 all working on that same thing you can just get up and give me your name I'll
0:46:57 make it easy for you I am always all this welcome
0:47:02 Kevin Lewis welcome Brad McQueen Jerry Jew welcome
0:47:25 Jaden Stimson, Jed Woodworth, I'm Zach Hawkins
0:47:48 Excellent welcome so thanks for being here and hopefully this will be a fruitful
0:47:54 use of your time to learn a little bit about citizenship and the community and
0:47:58 communications. Moving on with our agenda second item and items for
0:48:04 considerations a request to adopt a resolution to modify the definition of
0:48:07 developer for the purposes of reimbursing infrastructure development, Jackie Fields.
0:48:12 Okay, so as I said in our previous item, developers are required to make provision for the logical
0:48:18 extension of public utilities.
0:48:20 So that means that you can't stick a four-inch water line through your neighborhood and then
0:48:24 the next developer comes through and they have to tear out your four-inch water line
0:48:28 and put in a six or an eight or however it goes along the progression.
0:48:33 So currently we have a resolution in place, it's number 18-16, and it is the mechanism
0:48:38 by which a private developer is enabled to gain reimbursement from people who come later
0:48:46 and benefit from the larger pipe sizes or the larger sewer line sizes.
0:48:54 So there was a tremendous amount of work done on this resolution, and the group that did
0:49:00 the work, spend a lot of time trying to think about all the consequences and who should be
0:49:05 included and not included.
0:49:07 And we found through experience, as usual, that our definition for initial developer was
0:49:13 quite good, but it did not address everyone.
0:49:19 We have some governmental agencies that do not normally do public works improvements as
0:49:24 as their normal course of business that were required
0:49:28 to make provision for the future
0:49:31 and will not be able to seek reimbursement for those costs
0:49:38 unless we modify this resolution.
0:49:40 And so a near to heart, easy to see example
0:49:45 is that the Twin Falls School District has built schools.
0:49:49 They have done their infrastructure improvements
0:49:51 or are doing their infrastructure improvements
0:49:53 very responsibly.
0:49:55 and they are not in the business of building public works
0:49:58 in the business of education.
0:50:00 So the request this evening is to modify the definition
0:50:04 to enable entities such as those,
0:50:07 not the city or the urban renewal agency
0:50:10 or someone who normally builds public infrastructure
0:50:14 to be able to qualify for reimbursement.
0:50:19 So the staff recommends that the council
0:50:22 approve the resolution that is in your packet,
0:50:25 to modify the definition for a developer,
0:50:27 for the initial developer,
0:50:29 for the purposes of reimbursing an infrastructure development.
0:50:34 Thank you, Sharon.
0:50:35 What is the resolution number?
0:50:40 2016-5.
0:50:45 So Jackie, let me ask the question.
0:50:47 Is the school district currently in the situation
0:50:50 of not being able to be reimbursed
0:50:52 for improvements they may have made
0:50:53 with the two elementary schools?
0:50:57 They're in this place where they will qualify.
0:50:58 They can qualify.
0:51:00 Thank you.
0:51:01 Great landing.
0:51:02 move approval of resolution 2016-5 second motion by Greg
0:51:08 Lanting seconded by Don Hall to approve resolution 2016-5
0:51:13 discussion.
0:51:15 Chair and roll the vote please.
0:51:18 Sean Baraker.
0:51:20 Yes.
0:51:21 Chris Hockington.
0:51:22 Yes.
0:51:23 Greg Lanting.
0:51:24 Yes.
0:51:25 Don Hall.
0:51:26 Yes.
0:51:27 Ruth Hairs.
0:51:28 Yes.
0:51:29 Suzanne Hocking.
0:51:30 Yes.
0:51:31 Nikki Boy.
0:51:32 Yes.
0:51:33 Motion passes 7-0.
0:51:35 Next is a request to purchase a new color HP DesignJet T-1300 scanner printer
0:51:41 copy and warranty. Once again, Jackie Fields.
0:51:45 Okay, so it had been our department's plan to try to systematically replace our equipment.
0:51:53 And so we had begun, because we were starting to have
0:51:59 points in time where our scanner is not available to us, is where it's broken down on its needs service.
0:52:04 We were getting ready to plan to put this in our long-term planning process and budget for it.
0:52:09 But our problems are increasing exponentially.
0:52:13 And they are exacerbated by a change of conditions that we did not know about until September.
0:52:18 We received a 30-day notice from our maintenance folks that said that the machine is no longer supported,
0:52:25 hardware or software, so by the initial vendor.
0:52:29 vendor and so we have a definite and immediate problem and sadly or beautifully this machine
0:52:36 is heavily used by all the departments in the hands and building in particular the building
0:52:41 department but certainly everyone values that piece of equipment.
0:52:46 So the IS department really worked with our group with our entire building to figure out
0:52:53 what kind of performance standards we really needed and then selected a piece of equipment
0:52:58 that they believe would satisfy the types of things
0:53:01 that we need to be able to do on a regular basis.
0:53:05 And they have secured bits and have
0:53:09 recommended that we purchase a design jet T-1300 scanner.
0:53:13 They believe that'll satisfy our needs now
0:53:16 and shortly in the future here for the life of their company.
0:53:20 The cost is about $15,500.
0:53:23 Normally that would be a capital request item
0:53:25 that we would have put in through the long-term planning
0:53:27 process but our problem is now. The highest department specifically, Kathy Marcus, suggested
0:53:35 that they could cover the warranty, the three-year warranty period for service on the equipment
0:53:42 at a cost of $2350. So we are recommending, oh we can, we have money in the engineering
0:53:56 budget, sorry folks, I forgot the most important part, how we found this. So we do have, we're
0:54:01 just not going to wish that it happened. We are going to choose to defer some of our professional
0:54:08 services contracts to do investigation on the payments and things like that so that we can
0:54:12 purchase this piece of equipment. And the ISD department has budget and they're operating
0:54:18 to address that cost. So staff recommends that the council authorize the purchase of an
0:54:23 H. P. Design jet.
0:54:25 T. 1,300 scanner and it's three or more.
0:54:28 Do you have any questions?
0:54:30 Chris talking.
0:54:31 And I'm assuming that this is a non-competitive bed
0:54:35 because of either the technical nature of the scanner
0:54:38 or pull it to a certain price threshold.
0:54:41 The price threshold is low, but they did seek more than one
0:54:46 bid.
0:54:48 They still sought pre-bids.
0:54:50 That's it.
0:54:50 OK.
0:54:53 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:54:54 I'm ready to make a motion if everybody else is ready.
0:54:57 I think you're good.
0:54:58 Okay. I would move that we approve the request to purchase the new HP DesignJet T1300 scanner
0:55:05 printer copier and the extended warranty paid for from the two funding mechanisms that was
0:55:12 presented to us tonight.
0:55:15 Second.
0:55:18 Motion by Suzanne, how can I second it by Ruth Pierce to approve the purchase as presented?
0:55:22 Is there any discussion?
0:55:25 Sharon, I'll call vote please.
0:55:27 Chris Tockington, Greg Lanting, Don Hall, Ruth Pierce, Suzanne Hawkins, Nicki Boyd, Don
0:55:37 Berricher.
0:55:38 Yes.
0:55:39 Motion passes 7-0.
0:55:40 Thank you.
0:55:41 Thank you, Jackie.
0:55:44 Next is a request to adopt an ordinance for the vacation of approximately 2,500 at square
0:55:49 feet of right of way along the 100 block of Hanson Street.
0:55:52 I in care of the City of Twin Falls, and we have Renee Caraway Johnson.
0:55:56 Welcome, Renee.
0:55:57 Yes, thank you.
0:55:59 Good afternoon.
0:56:00 Now you're in Council.
0:56:02 Tonight I'm here for actually two ordinances,
0:56:04 if you look at your agenda.
0:56:06 This first one came to you back in May.
0:56:10 It was a request to vacate a portion
0:56:12 of Hanson Street sidewalk to allow the improvements
0:56:17 on our new city hall building.
0:56:19 So it did go through the standard public process.
0:56:22 On May 10th, the Planning and Zoning Commission
0:56:25 did hold a public hearing.
0:56:27 The public hearing was opened and closed with no public input on this request.
0:56:31 Upon conclusion of the public hearing and a discussion from the commission, Commissioner
0:56:37 Tatum did make a motion to recommend approval of this vacation as presented subject to a
0:56:42 reduction of the area shown on the site plan, subject to retention of a pedestrian easement
0:56:48 along Hanson Street East and subject to a technically correct legal description being provided prior
0:56:55 to the City Council of Public Hearing.
0:56:58 Commissioner Reed seconded the motion,
0:57:00 and all members on the commission voted in favor of the motion,
0:57:03 so it came to you with all the recommendations.
0:57:06 On June 6th, this request did come to you at a public hearing.
0:57:11 The public hearing was opened and closed
0:57:13 with no public comment.
0:57:15 Upon conclusion, the council did make a motion to approve.
0:57:19 The request to vacate approximately 2,500 square feet
0:57:23 of right away along the 100 block of Hudson Street East,
0:57:27 subject to the two conditions of the commission recommended.
0:57:31 Motion was seconded by Councilman Hall,
0:57:34 and it was approved by a vote of five to zero.
0:57:37 So upon conclusion this evening for this ordinance,
0:57:40 as directed by this body,
0:57:42 staff has prepared an ordinance for your consideration,
0:57:45 and staff does recommend that the council adopt the ordinance
0:57:48 by a third and final motion
0:57:50 so that it can be published and codified.
0:57:53 Thank you.
0:57:54 Thank you, Renee.
0:57:55 Sharing what is the ordinance number?
0:57:57 Ordinance 2016-15.
0:58:03 Chris talking to.
0:58:04 Move to place ordinance 2016-15
0:58:08 on third and final by Tom only.
0:58:10 Under suspension of the rules.
0:58:13 Second.
0:58:15 The motion by Chris talking to the second
0:58:17 and vice Suzanne Hawkins to place the ordinance
0:58:19 on third and final reading by title only
0:58:21 under suspension of the rules.
0:58:22 Is there any discussion?
0:58:25 Sharon, we'll call vote, please.
0:58:31 Greg Lanting.
0:58:32 Yes.
0:58:33 Don Hall.
0:58:34 Yes.
0:58:34 Ruth Pierce.
0:58:35 Yes.
0:58:35 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:58:36 Yes.
0:58:37 Nikki Boyd.
0:58:38 Yes.
0:58:39 Sean Berrigger.
0:58:39 Yes.
0:58:40 Chris Talking.
0:58:41 Yes.
0:58:42 Motion passes, 7-0.
0:58:44 Sharon, would you read the title, please?
0:58:46 Ordinance, number 2016-15.
0:58:49 And Ordinance of the Mayor and the City Council
0:58:52 of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho,
0:58:55 vacating the real property described below
0:58:58 and providing for a besting of title
0:59:01 to the property so vacated.
0:59:04 Thank you, Don Hall.
0:59:05 Move approval of ordinance 2016-15.
0:59:08 Second.
0:59:10 Motion by Don Hall, seconded by Nikki Boyd
0:59:12 to approve ordinance 2016-15.
0:59:15 Is there any discussion?
0:59:18 Share them, they'll call vote please.
0:59:20 Don Hall.
0:59:21 Yes.
0:59:22 Ruth Pierce.
0:59:22 Yes.
0:59:23 Suzanne Hopkins.
0:59:24 Yes.
0:59:25 Nikki Boyd.
0:59:26 Yes.
0:59:27 John Berriger.
0:59:27 Yes.
0:59:28 Chris Talkington.
0:59:29 Yes.
0:59:30 Motion passes, seven to zero.
0:59:34 Next we have a request to adopt an ordinance
0:59:36 for a zoning district change and zoning map amendment
0:59:39 for nine plus or minus acres,
0:59:41 from R4 to R4 ZBA to develop a plan four plucks,
0:59:47 town home development on property located at 2916 East,
0:59:51 3600 North in Carabex, Harding,
0:59:53 Resell Engineering, Inc. on behalf of Dennis Horne.
0:59:58 Renee Caraway, Johnson.
1:00:00 Thank you.
1:00:01 I'm back.
1:00:02 I'm back.
1:00:03 Just a little history on this project.
1:00:07 This is actually a pretty exciting development that we had come through for us.
1:00:12 It was part of the first presentation this evening, and it is also the first ZDA process
1:00:19 that we have gone through with you.
1:00:21 So just a little history, which has shown you put up the area map, that's 3,600 on the
1:00:28 south.
1:00:29 The middle school was up to the right.
1:00:32 So on April 12th, the commission held a preliminary presentation
1:00:37 on the request.
1:00:38 There were questions and comments from the commission
1:00:41 as well as neighbors.
1:00:42 There was quite well attended.
1:00:44 On April 26th, the public hearing was held for this request.
1:00:49 Upon conclusion of the applicant's presentation
1:00:51 and staff's presentation, public comment
1:00:54 and commission deliberations, the request is presented
1:00:58 was recommended for denial by a load of two, four, and six
1:01:01 against.
1:01:03 Then was considerable concern with the density
1:01:05 and how the project was laid out.
1:01:08 There was a hold on the project technically.
1:01:11 It wasn't scheduled to come before you with that denial.
1:01:15 On May 31, the developer did meet with the surrounding neighbors
1:01:19 to discuss the concerns and possible changes
1:01:22 to the master development plan to help
1:01:25 with their conflict with this development being built.
1:01:29 On June 28th, the Commission held another public hearing
1:01:32 for this request.
1:01:34 The developer presented a revised development plan
1:01:36 with modifications to the Planning and Zoning Commission.
1:01:40 Upon conclusion of the African's presentation,
1:01:43 of staff's presentation, public comment
1:01:45 and commission deliberations,
1:01:47 the Commission unanimously recommended approval
1:01:49 of the request as presented and subject to five conditions.
1:01:54 On July 25th, the council held a public hearing on the request.
1:01:58 The public hearing was opened and closed with no public comment.
1:02:02 So the neighbors were definitely appeased
1:02:05 with the changes that were made.
1:02:09 The council recommended adoption as presented,
1:02:12 subject to the following conditions.
1:02:15 Number one was subject to psych fund amendments
1:02:17 as determined by building engineering fire
1:02:19 and zoning officials to comply
1:02:21 with applicable city codes and standards.
1:02:25 Number two is subject to the entirety of Valencia Street being constructed in the first phase.
1:02:31 If construction begins on the north end Valencia can shall connect to 3600 north Valencia connector
1:02:38 width to be determined by the city engineer at that time.
1:02:42 If construction starts on the south end either full construction of Valencia Street is required
1:02:48 or they can bond for future phases with a completion deadline by the year 2022.
1:02:55 Excuse me. Number three is subject to the parameter fence being installed prior to
1:03:01 issuance of the building permit for each phase of the project. Number four is
1:03:05 subject to a final plan being recorded prior to any development. Number five is subject to
1:03:10 conformance to the zoning development agreement and the Valencia Park Master
1:03:14 development plan has approved and number six was subject to an on-site or hired
1:03:19 property manager. That motion was seconded by Councilman Lanting and the
1:03:25 roll call vote showed it was five to zero in favor of this request. However on
1:03:33 August 9th the developer made again some changes to the project. It was
1:03:40 determined to bring this back to the planning and zoning commission for their
1:03:43 review to determine if, in fact, those changes would require to come back through the public
1:03:50 hearing process. So that meeting was held, the commission reviewed the changes, those changes
1:03:58 included adding a single-card garage to each unit except the northeast building as shown
1:04:04 on this plan, correct?
1:04:08 No, this.
1:04:11 That's not the new one, this is.
1:04:14 I'd like to show you that.
1:04:24 The right one is in our packet.
1:04:25 Yeah, I think so.
1:04:27 It's got the, it's moved the building.
1:04:29 There we go.
1:04:32 That's it.
1:04:33 Right.
1:04:34 Right.
1:04:35 Right.
1:04:36 Okay.
1:04:38 So, some of the other changes included garages for each of the buildings, except that Northeast
1:04:43 building, making a few of the buildings a little bit larger, moving the buildings to allow for
1:04:51 larger backyards and side yards, and moving the park area to the northeast lot. That park
1:04:56 is part of this development and will be maintained by that property and that was also part of
1:05:01 that agreement. At that meeting, there was no public input and the neighbors were informed
1:05:07 that there was going to be a discussion on this, and again that to me is a very positive
1:05:13 sign. So upon conclusion of that meeting, Commissioner Gray did make a motion to find
1:05:19 that those proposed changes as presented were in substantial conformance with the Approved
1:05:23 Valencia Park ZDA Master Plan and no additional public hearing was required. Commission
1:05:29 and the motion was passed by a vote of 5, 4, and 3, against.
1:05:36 As directed by this body back in July, the staff has prepared an ordinance
1:05:42 and would ask for your consideration to adopt by third and final reading this evening.
1:05:48 Chris Stockington.
1:05:50 Renee, I'm curious the three dissenting votes.
1:05:53 Could you summarize what their objections were?
1:05:56 I think they were still concerned with the density of the project, the way it was laid
1:06:02 out.
1:06:03 I don't believe that there was a comfort level with the project in general.
1:06:09 Thank you.
1:06:10 Nicky Boyd.
1:06:11 This is our very first ZDA that went all the way through.
1:06:15 Could you remind everybody what ZDA stands for?
1:06:18 It stands for Zoning Development Agreement and in the past the PUND process would take
1:06:24 us through the same rezoning type, and there would be a full development agreement that
1:06:29 would be adopted at the end of a final flat. That document was generally anywhere from 20
1:06:35 to 40 pages. This process is quite a bit condensed. There's a memorandum agreement that is attached
1:06:43 to the very beginning process of this rezoning process, and it is attached to the ordinance.
1:06:49 The developers agreement upon development will be handled through the engineering department
1:06:54 through standard development processes.
1:06:57 So it's a little bit quicker process, more complete.
1:07:00 The only thing that the developer identifies is are the things that are different from
1:07:05 code.
1:07:08 So thank you.
1:07:09 Yes.
1:07:10 You're welcome.
1:07:11 Thank you, Renee.
1:07:12 I don't see any more questions.
1:07:17 Oh, Sharon, what's the ordinance number?
1:07:20 I'm going to guess it's 2015.
1:07:22 2016-16 16 yes, I did have one more follow-up and Nick's question on the ZDA what what is the downside?
1:07:35 If all this convoluted decision making and things that I don't quite understand they're full
1:07:42 Extend what's the worst that might develop out of this sort of lawsuits
1:07:49 Yeah
1:07:55 What we're asking of the developer is to just identify what they would like to have done besides what's allowed in the code.
1:08:04 For example, this guy, this development said, I will put in single car garages. That's not a requirement.
1:08:12 So this is an addition to, but it's clearly codified. And so through this next six years of development, that will be something that he will, it's part of his agreement with the city.
1:08:22 To develop this, I'm going to put in a garage.
1:08:25 He's got islands in the center of Valencia.
1:08:28 That's also not a standard city approved item.
1:08:32 He has committed to that.
1:08:34 The park is his commitment through this development.
1:08:37 So there's nothing else that is identified.
1:08:42 No other agreements attached to the ordinance.
1:08:45 So all the developers' expectations are clearly laid out.
1:08:50 Absolutely.
1:08:52 And okay.
1:08:53 Thank you.
1:08:58 Great landing.
1:09:00 Bear, I've removed that we suspend the rules
1:09:02 in place ordinance 2016 day 16 on third and final
1:09:06 by title rule.
1:09:09 Second.
1:09:10 The motion by great landing seconded by Ruth Pierce
1:09:13 to place ordinance 2016 dash 16 on third and final reading
1:09:17 by title and win under suspension of the rules.
1:09:19 Any discussion?
1:09:20 I've included the conditions as there's still.
1:09:23 We're just suspending the rules now
1:09:24 to place it on third reading and then we'll approve
1:09:26 ordinance. Sharon roll call vote, please.
1:09:32 Ruth Pierce. Yes.
1:09:33 Suzanne Hawkins. Yes.
1:09:35 Nikki Boyd. Yes.
1:09:36 Sean Bericher. Yes.
1:09:38 Chris Tockeington. Yes.
1:09:40 Greg Lanthine. Yes.
1:09:41 Don Hall. Yes.
1:09:42 Motion passes 7-0.
1:09:45 Sharon, would you read the title, please?
1:09:47 Ordinance number 2016-16.
1:09:56 And ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho.
1:10:00 We zoning real property below described, providing the zoning classification therefore and ordering the necessary amendments to the area of impact and zoning district map.
1:10:14 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:10:15 Thank you. First of all, I'm very excited with this project.
1:10:17 I'm anxious to see how it all comes together in the end.
1:10:21 And with that, I would move approval of ordinance 2016-16.
1:10:27 Second.
1:10:29 by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Don Hall to approve Ordinance 2016-16, Greg Lanting.
1:10:36 I don't have the same question as Chris, does that ordinance already include the, so we don't have to add the verdict there?
1:10:42 Okay.
1:10:43 You exhibit B that is in your packet attached to the ordinance? Yes, sir.
1:10:47 Thank you.
1:10:49 Thank you, Renee.
1:10:50 Let's find any further discussion?
1:10:55 Sharon, we'll call vote, please.
1:10:56 Suzanne Hawkins?
1:10:58 Yes.
1:10:59 Nikki Boyd?
1:11:00 Yes.
1:11:00 Sean Barriker?
1:11:01 Yes.
1:11:02 Chris Tockington, Greg Lanting, Don Hall, Richard.
1:11:07 Yes, motion passes, seven to zero.
1:11:10 Thank you very much.
1:11:11 Thank you very much.
1:11:16 Next on the agenda is another opportunity
1:11:18 for public input if there's anybody here wishing
1:11:21 to address the council on an item that was not addressed
1:11:23 on the agenda this evening.
1:11:25 We also do have a public hearing that we'll get to momentarily.
1:11:29 Is anyone wishing to address the council as your chance?
1:11:35 Welcome if you'd please state your name and address for the record.
1:11:39 My name is Heather Strump and I live in Twin Falls County.
1:11:42 And I brought some sample ballots with me tonight and I put them on the back table.
1:11:47 And I'd like to offer anyone who wants to pick one up.
1:11:50 There are several different legislative districts represented there, District 23, 24, and 25.
1:11:57 And please note that District 25 is divided
1:12:03 by different things that will be voted on on the back
1:12:06 once the filer, water issue.
1:12:09 And so just make sure that you get the right one
1:12:11 if you're district 25.
1:12:13 And that's for Sea of With People Magic Valley.
1:12:15 Thank you.
1:12:16 Thank you Heather, I appreciate it.
1:12:18 Good reminder for everyone that tomorrow is election day.
1:12:20 So go exercise your constitutional right
1:12:23 from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m.
1:12:25 if you didn't already go voter.
1:12:27 I already voted.
1:12:28 Like I'm pretty sure a lot of folks did.
1:12:32 Mr. Rothwell, any items from the city manager?
1:12:38 Well, in addition to election day,
1:12:39 we'll be closed on Friday in observation of the Veterans Day.
1:12:42 Thank you to all the veterans who have served our country
1:12:46 to provide the basic freedoms that we all enjoy
1:12:50 every single day.
1:12:53 Again, for those who might be tuning in late,
1:12:55 we'll be starting the council meeting early
1:12:57 as shared by the mayor at four o'clock,
1:13:01 so that we can be at City Park by 545,
1:13:06 anticipation of the festivities
1:13:09 associated with the National Christmas tree.
1:13:13 Thank you, Travis.
1:13:14 Any items from members of the city council?
1:13:17 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:13:18 Thank you.
1:13:19 I just wanted to share a little bit Saturday,
1:13:21 our library held a celebration for the heroes tree
1:13:25 in observation of veterans this month.
1:13:28 And the tree will be set up at the library all month.
1:13:30 Anyone's welcome to stop it and look.
1:13:32 They also have ornaments set up there
1:13:35 that you can create while you're there
1:13:38 for your family members who are veterans,
1:13:41 currently serving or past.
1:13:44 Chris Talkington this week was one of our speakers
1:13:46 Saturday at the event as well as Sheriff Carter.
1:13:49 And it was a really nice reminder of the sacrifices
1:13:52 that people have made so that we can have our freedoms
1:13:56 so we can go vote tomorrow.
1:13:58 But I just like to encourage everybody to swing by the library
1:14:01 and take a look at the veterans tree, the hero's tree.
1:14:04 And if you have a veteran in your family, please,
1:14:06 you can take an ornament or make one there.
1:14:10 Thank you, Suzanne.
1:14:11 Anyone else from the council?
1:14:16 All right, so the next item on the agenda
1:14:18 is actually not scheduled as a public hearing,
1:14:20 but we will allow for some public input on it.
1:14:23 This is a continuation of a discussion we had last week.
1:14:26 A request to adopt a resolution for the 2016
1:14:29 Twin Falls comprehensive plan.
1:14:30 grow with us as the city's comprehensive plan.
1:14:33 Renee Caraway-Johnson is here, as well as Jonathan Spendlove,
1:14:39 I believe, hiding out the back there.
1:14:41 So Renee will make just a brief presentation
1:14:48 on the information in the resolution,
1:14:50 which is what is before us this evening.
1:14:52 But again, we did have a presentation last week
1:14:54 if there are further questions about the details
1:14:57 of the comprehensive plan, they can answer those.
1:14:59 And then we'll see what action the Council wishes
1:15:02 to take.
1:15:03 Just a summary for this request for adoption of the resolution.
1:15:08 On September 27th, the Planning and Zoning Commission did hold a public hearing on this request, making
1:15:14 more of Logan Simpson design was present to address questions or concerns regarding the draft
1:15:20 plan.
1:15:21 There were two people who spoke at that public hearing regarding this updated comprehensive
1:15:26 plan.
1:15:27 One person inquired about having more pathways and residential options for the growing senior
1:15:31 population and the other person was very supportive of the plan encouraging mixed
1:15:36 neighborhood uses throughout town. On conclusion of that public hearing and
1:15:41 discussion the commission unanimously voted to recommend adoption of the 2016
1:15:46 Print Falls comprehensive plan grow with us as presented and including there
1:15:51 being no amendments to the plan for one year after adoption. On October 24th the
1:15:57 Council had the first public hearing on this item.
1:16:02 There was no public input.
1:16:05 Maybe there was one person.
1:16:09 And the Council ultimately voted to bring it back on the 7th
1:16:12 and have no public hearing.
1:16:14 We do have the seating.
1:16:16 And I think there was some questions from Council for some
1:16:19 hawkins on some comparisons of our current zoning map versus
1:16:24 what the comprehensive plan looks like and what is the
1:16:26 the difference of the two.
1:16:28 Megan, like I said, submitted some summaries on that,
1:16:32 and Jonathan will go through those with you.
1:16:35 But ultimately, we are asking for your adoption
1:16:38 of this resolution this evening.
1:16:41 Staff would love to start working on some of these changes
1:16:43 and going forward with the growth of our city.
1:16:46 So are you behind me?
1:16:51 Thank you, Renee.
1:16:58 So we had Megan more put together,
1:17:00 basically at the end of slides, four or five slides,
1:17:03 kind of explaining the difference
1:17:04 between our existing future land use map,
1:17:07 the one we currently have adopted,
1:17:09 the one we're proposing on the existing categories,
1:17:12 we currently have adopted and the ones we're proposing.
1:17:14 And then the difference between the zoning map
1:17:16 and then the new future land use map we're proposing
1:17:19 is laws the existing categories and the new ones
1:17:22 and how those in early relate and how they work.
1:17:25 So on the left hand side,
1:17:27 you have our existing future land use map.
1:17:29 when we've adopted currently in force, and when we bring to you a rezone of a property,
1:17:35 this is the map we are referring to when we talk about that future land use category.
1:17:41 In general, and the colors are washed out as you know with all these presentations, the
1:17:45 red, along the pole lines, along the blue lakes, Kimberly Road, and Addison, those are all commercial,
1:17:51 what we call it, commercial slash retail.
1:17:54 There's a gray that's come on the outskirts, that's called urban village slash urban fill.
1:18:02 And then the majority within town is a medium density.
1:18:08 That's what it's called on that map.
1:18:09 And the exterior has some rural residential out here.
1:18:13 And there's actually a green that's mainly over here, some down here on these outskirts
1:18:19 for agriculture.
1:18:20 Then the outlier also is the airport down here, which is a different color of gray, but
1:18:26 when you get it up there, it's all kind of one grayish.
1:18:30 So that's the existing what we have now.
1:18:31 If you saw a reason tonight, we would refer to that map.
1:18:35 What we're going to is this proposed future land use map.
1:18:39 And the next slide will show you the categories condensed down.
1:18:42 But what we've done is condensed them down pretty much removed two or three, maybe four
1:18:47 categories.
1:18:49 one for downtown. It's a higher density downtown, basically the town site a little
1:18:54 bit west of Washington. The red is continuing along Kimberly Road and
1:18:59 Pull Line. That continues as a commercial. There's a purple up here along Pull Line
1:19:04 at Blue Lakes as well as some over here on Kimberly Road and at some of these
1:19:08 larger intersections up here in Washington and Orchard I think is what it
1:19:14 is. Those are mixed use and there's some definitions as what we're talking
1:19:19 about mixed use as we get into the comprehensive plan.
1:19:22 The pink is what we are putting as neighborhood commercial.
1:19:27 It takes the place with like a residential business.
1:19:30 The idea behind that is along Addison,
1:19:33 you have residential homes that are being converted
1:19:35 to commercial type uses, as well as along Filer and Washington.
1:19:40 And at these other nodes or intersections of major streets,
1:19:45 the opportunity for commercial at the intersections.
1:19:49 Basically, places where housing is no longer desirable due to the volume of traffic and noise
1:19:56 and the ambient noise of those intersections.
1:19:59 You can see falls and Eastland is a busy intersection.
1:20:05 You get out hankins as well as down here, blue lakes and I believe that's where it's
1:20:11 hard to see.
1:20:12 areas where housing is less desirable due to those effects of traffic and other things.
1:20:21 So the rest of it orange would be what we're just calling town neighborhood and then the
1:20:29 exterior is yellow, rural, residential and green is agriculture with again the outlier
1:20:36 of the airport down here. Fewer categories.
1:20:40 Jonathan, before you leave out, it's specific to the area along 3,700 that we have also received
1:20:48 some comments about where industrial or employment area development may occur next to rural residential.
1:20:59 Can you tell me what the difference is between those two in that specific area?
1:21:08 area here on the existing one is identified as industrial, it's supposed to be a purple,
1:21:13 but you're north over here, that same area is has not changed virtually, it is an out
1:21:20 blue right for industrial flex employment. Those areas did not change to move that line
1:21:29 along this area over here. South of 3700, it's the same on both maps. Yeah, it's agricultural,
1:21:37 It's basically this corner here, it has remained as agriculture, and that's what you kind of see right there as an agricultural.
1:21:44 Future land use.
1:21:45 Okay. Thank you.
1:21:46 Okay. Chris, talking.
1:21:47 You were talking about the desire for commercial along Addison East, and if you go out to Addison East and Eastland,
1:21:55 there's the corner where a gas station is to the east, and there is a bank on the northwest corner.
1:22:02 We still have the overlay though, do we not for a residential professional, as opposed
1:22:10 to an outright commercial in that area and others, I guess the only question is the overlays
1:22:16 are still intact.
1:22:18 Yeah, so the basic understanding of this map is what people want to change their zoning
1:22:24 to in the future.
1:22:25 And the overlays you're referring to are what the actual entitlement is right now.
1:22:30 We are not changing entitlements on people's properties with this map.
1:22:34 Thank you.
1:22:37 Any further questions?
1:22:40 So here's the categories as they break down.
1:22:43 The existing map we have and use, and this is what we've changed it to and how they kind
1:22:50 of relate to each other.
1:22:52 The existing map has residential business, we're going to call it a neighborhood commercial.
1:22:56 Commercial retail can be mixed use commercial as you go down this list.
1:23:01 combined and some are going to show up in different places. So commercial over here
1:23:05 is going to show up in a couple spots. That's kind of the contrast that I believe
1:23:11 it was Suzanne that was looking for. That list, this is for the future
1:23:15 categories, not the current zoning on properties. Any more questions on this list?
1:23:22 We'll go to the next. I think you're good.
1:23:31 So as this relates to what people's property is zoned and what we're talking
1:23:38 about zoning we're talking about, the use that is outright permitted on their property,
1:23:41 what they can use it for.
1:23:43 The map on the left is what the current zoning map is showing.
1:23:47 That is not changing.
1:23:49 People request to change the zoning map, and that decision comes to this body unless it's
1:23:54 in the area of impact.
1:23:55 It still comes to you, but the final decision goes to the county.
1:23:59 For anything within city limits, this body is the final decision maker for the zoning
1:24:03 of properties.
1:24:04 So Valencia Park that came in with the coordinates, they came through and changed the zoning on this property down in this area.
1:24:13 It will have the ZDA moniker behind it and that is a zoning district, so it's a zoning change.
1:24:19 It changes the essential permitted uses on those properties.
1:24:23 So that's the map on the left.
1:24:25 This map on the right is a guiding document for the Planning and Zoning Commission to make a recommendation to you and for you to use
1:24:34 when you're making those decisions on what to reason property to.
1:24:38 People bring in an application just like Valencia did.
1:24:42 They go through the Planning and Zoning Commission.
1:24:44 The Commission looks at this map.
1:24:46 They say, OK, does it meet the intent of this map as well
1:24:50 as the comprehensive plan as it's written?
1:24:52 So the other information that the comprehensive plan dictates
1:24:56 should we have things next, what should be your next residential?
1:24:59 Should we have sidewalks connecting to commercial?
1:25:02 It kind of gets to the details of what these zones or these areas on the Future Land Use
1:25:07 Map should be and what we should look for when you have a project.
1:25:11 So that's what that document has.
1:25:14 The map is the main thing as far as what people can ask for and then the rest of that document
1:25:18 speaks to the specifics of what we should look for in those projects.
1:25:24 So if you get a project like Blaine's here down here, that Future Land Use Map will say
1:25:29 a town neighborhood, but should we just accept any zoning designation?
1:25:36 We wanted to have a little bit more flexibility.
1:25:38 So we have town neighborhood that encompasses potentially anything from R1, R2, R4, R6.
1:25:45 And then the decision comes when they go to planning and zoning.
1:25:49 They look at the specifics of that site and what they should look for as far as what's
1:25:53 around it.
1:25:54 Is it appropriate for that area?
1:25:56 And then it comes to this body, and you make the decision, is it appropriate for that area,
1:26:01 or should we look for other things to mitigate or help augment that project to make it fit
1:26:05 into that spot?
1:26:08 So the map basically becomes more flexible for developers as well as the city and the
1:26:12 city council to make those decisions.
1:26:15 So this is where our zoning categories fit and what we are proposing to have as our future
1:26:24 land use categories.
1:26:26 So if you came in, the future land use map says it's rural residential, and they ask for
1:26:31 SUI or R1, that could be possible.
1:26:36 The decisions come from you after recommendation from the Planning and Zoning Commission.
1:26:40 They look at the specifics, doesn't meet this future land use.
1:26:44 It does or it doesn't.
1:26:45 That's what we'd be looking for when you make those decisions.
1:26:50 That's how they would fit.
1:26:51 Any questions on the categories?
1:26:57 It's been a long existing barrier to put commercial and residential adjacent.
1:27:06 I'm assuming in the large overview that is still holding.
1:27:10 We discourage it or outright prohibit it.
1:27:15 I think if you're looking for a hard road.
1:27:16 Unless the commercial is encroached upon by the residential.
1:27:20 If commercial is there first.
1:27:23 So if you go to, when we're looking at this proposed map,
1:27:30 we are proposing for some neighborhood commercial
1:27:33 to be near residential.
1:27:36 What that looks like is within the document
1:27:39 of what we should be looking for as a specifics.
1:27:42 May not be 24 hour letting gas stations in other words.
1:27:45 It may or may not depending on the specifics, yes.
1:27:48 And that would be a decision that comes here
1:27:52 or per the zoning that's permitted in those districts.
1:27:56 With this map comes a lot of changes to our zoning codes.
1:28:01 And using codes we haven't used before.
1:28:04 We have a commercial mixed use district
1:28:06 and we have a residential mixed use district
1:28:08 that have never been utilized.
1:28:10 We have a residential business that we've modified
1:28:12 to be useful and there's a couple properties
1:28:14 that have gone that direction.
1:28:16 Those codes probably be more heavily used
1:28:19 and we need to modify change them
1:28:21 so it matches what we're looking for in this comprehensive plan.
1:28:28 Thank you, Jonathan.
1:28:29 Great landing.
1:28:30 Jonathan, this is kind of a out of the box question
1:28:34 but a little bit, but well, maybe not.
1:28:36 If you could say that one, our area of impact ends where?
1:28:43 Up to the east.
1:28:44 The boundaries here, and this is the area of impact.
1:28:48 It's the extent.
1:28:50 There's no like roadway here, but it then
1:28:53 It comes up to 38.
1:28:55 37, 38.
1:28:56 OK.
1:28:57 And so there, it has impact.
1:28:59 On the opposite side of, what is that?
1:29:01 3,700?
1:29:03 Over here.
1:29:03 Or 36, and 3,700.
1:29:05 That's camera, at least correct.
1:29:07 That's correct.
1:29:07 And there's stops at that line here.
1:29:10 Do they have that listed as ag or residential,
1:29:13 or do we know?
1:29:15 I don't know off the top of my head.
1:29:16 OK, I actually have them to have there.
1:29:18 Thank you, it's mad right here.
1:29:19 Hold on.
1:29:20 I will tell you, we had Nancy Duncan.
1:29:35 on our advisory committee, she's a Kimberly Councilwoman.
1:29:38 So she was very well.
1:29:40 I just didn't remember what.
1:29:41 I think I asked this question on one of the meetings,
1:29:43 too, I forgot what the answer was.
1:29:44 So starting at Kimberly Road, so a long Kimberly Road
1:29:48 is commercial gateway.
1:29:50 And then south of that is light industry.
1:29:55 And then our three generals, and there's a residential,
1:30:01 and then a commercial interior along 3,700 north and then residential.
1:30:09 That's already zoned.
1:30:11 So that was the question we had a letter that talked about that they were registered
1:30:14 across from Cliffbar and I knew that it had to be in curor lease on one quite
1:30:20 sure why we got the letter and yet it looks like they already have it zoned as
1:30:25 somewhat of an industrial zone.
1:30:28 And I think our existing zoning as well as the proposed future land use map supports that also
1:30:41 Right and then of course the next question I may would be or Jonathan would be to the west down Addison
1:30:51 That blue area is so a pass oh just over right there. That's so that's industrial correct
1:30:59 for future future would be industrial and that's the area where we impact is that
1:31:04 filers that this county on the outside of this county okay thank you any further
1:31:15 questions for Jonathan or may so is that you may Jonathan both of you guys
1:31:27 did excellent job but this little demonstration here and understanding
1:31:32 zoning for everybody and then the proposed land use. That was very good. Thank you.
1:31:38 Thank you. It was exactly what I was looking for. You hit it spot-on. So we will
1:31:44 give an opportunity for any members of the public who are here this evening who
1:31:48 would wish to share any information about the comprehensive plan before we
1:31:54 potentially take action. Yes, Mitch? So we've got two letters that I'm gonna
1:31:58 I'm trying to throw up on the screen here during this part of it, too.
1:32:03 Okay.
1:32:04 So are there any members of the public who wish to come up and address us?
1:32:11 Not seeing anyone?
1:32:24 These all should have been forwarded to the council as well.
1:32:26 Right, so we did receive these.
1:32:27 We received this one soon, right?
1:32:29 So I'll just quickly summarize this one from Jack Leakey, commenting about he lives across from the Cliff Bar facility.
1:32:41 3289 East 3700 North and does not want to see a change on the map to change the
1:32:49 Ag Zoning that is in that neighborhood to commercial. And as we addressed that
1:32:54 area currently is already an industrial and employment center type land use and
1:33:01 would continue in that way. Concerned about water usage as well, but some
1:33:09 Kimberly to boot. Kim Oasis area. And then I come coming from Gerald Lazardo, 3311 Aspen
1:33:23 Ridge Circle in disagreement for a zoning change along 3300, not wanting to see high density
1:33:30 there, one of that to remain rural residential. So I'm going to guess that that is discussing
1:33:38 the mixed use north of Kimberly Road along 3,300.
1:33:47 Our current complaint shows that it's commercial
1:33:50 and right now it's actually a softer zoning proposal
1:33:55 for someone to come in and develop.
1:33:57 To be a mixed use.
1:33:59 Thank you.
1:34:02 So seeing no other comments from the public this evening
1:34:07 and having addressed those,
1:34:08 we'll turn it over to the council because talking to
1:34:10 resolution number? 2016-6.
1:34:22 Who passes the resolution 2016-6?
1:34:26 Second.
1:34:28 Motion by Chris Togginton, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve resolution 2016-6 which
1:34:35 would adopt the comprehensive plan as it has been presented.
1:34:40 Is there any discussion from the Council?
1:34:44 I just want to take a moment, Renee, to thank you and Jonathan and the Citizens Committee
1:34:49 that assisted with going through this very lengthy, very public, very engaged process.
1:34:56 I think of all of the various plans that I've seen developed at the city, and my tenure here
1:35:02 this probably had the greatest participation of the public and very unique ways of tapping
1:35:07 into diverse communities around Twin Falls, and I think it's been very positive.
1:35:13 So kudos to you, both, and your teams, and everyone for participating in that.
1:35:19 I think I'll just echo what you said, Sean, I appreciate all the work, but I also appreciate what Nikki just said and Suzanne's questions because I think the comparison was really useful to me and I hope it was for other folks really, you know, fills in the gaps in your mind exactly
1:35:38 with this comprehensive plan is doing.
1:35:41 We're going to keep that posted on our website along with a
1:35:44 comp plan map.
1:35:45 I think that will also help with some questions.
1:35:47 I think that's very helpful.
1:35:49 A lot of folks are very visual.
1:35:50 Myself include has to have colors and graphs.
1:35:53 And, you know, yeah.
1:35:55 So thank you.
1:35:57 Great land.
1:35:58 I don't like that what they said and thank Renee and her
1:36:00 staff and Jonathan and everyone with those departments
1:36:05 that helped us through this.
1:36:07 I guess this is my third comp plan that I've been
1:36:10 involved with the first one was back in like 1983,
1:36:15 if I'm lying to when I was not planning a zoning.
1:36:17 And this one I think was organized the best
1:36:21 as far as leading this to understand
1:36:25 where we needed to go or what we wanted to do.
1:36:27 And I appreciate that guidance.
1:36:29 Thank you.
1:36:31 I would be remiss by the way,
1:36:32 if I did not thank the Planning and Zoning Commission
1:36:34 as well.
1:36:35 I did not do that.
1:36:36 I'm very proud of that.
1:36:36 We definitely have driven this process.
1:36:40 and the 1200 people that gave in.
1:36:42 Absolutely.
1:36:43 They definitely do the heavy lifting on this.
1:36:46 So thank you.
1:36:47 All right, with that,
1:36:48 we have a motion to approve resolution 2016 dash six.
1:36:52 Share in roll call vote, please.
1:36:53 Nicky Boyd.
1:36:54 Yes.
1:36:55 Sean Beriker.
1:36:56 Yes.
1:36:57 Chris Tockington.
1:36:58 Yes.
1:36:59 Greg Lanting.
1:37:00 Yes.
1:37:01 Don Hall.
1:37:02 Yes.
1:37:03 Ruth Pierce.
1:37:04 Yes.
1:37:04 Suzanne Hopkins.
1:37:05 Yes.
1:37:06 Motion passes seven to zero.
1:37:08 There you go.
1:37:10 to see if it leaves the silo really.
1:37:11 I start working on the upgrade on the update.
1:37:15 Get to work.
1:37:15 Now the work begins, right?
1:37:18 We do have a public hearing schedule for this evening.
1:37:21 This is a request for a vacation of a 15 by 185.13 foot,
1:37:28 2,777 square foot utility irrigation and drainage easement
1:37:32 on Lot 10 of the Wild Rose estate subdivision number one
1:37:36 on property located at 4042 North,
1:37:39 3320 East in the area of impact and care of Jennifer and Ken Ashley, Suzanne Hawkins.
1:37:46 Thank you, Mayor.
1:37:47 On the advice of our city attorney for its wonder look, I am going to recuse myself on
1:37:52 this item.
1:37:54 The applicants are customers of mine.
1:37:57 Thank you, Suzanne.
1:38:00 So with that, we will turn it over to the applicants to come forward and please present
1:38:10 your information.
1:38:11 If you please state your name and address for the record, please.
1:38:15 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:38:16 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:38:20 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:38:38 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:38:41 That easement right here, the question I've had to be vacated.
1:38:55 Oh, I'm requesting it to build a shop.
1:38:58 So I'm the backside of the property.
1:39:02 You have 10 minutes.
1:39:04 I don't know how you're going.
1:39:05 I don't know how to get a second.
1:39:07 That's quite all right.
1:39:08 All right.
1:39:10 So we'll call that good.
1:39:12 We'll turn it over to staff to give the staff report.
1:39:14 And if we have any questions, you might want to stick around nearby up front here.
1:39:18 So the history of this easement was dedicated with the plat in 2003.
1:39:25 House was constructed in 2006.
1:39:27 And then 2015, they purchased the property.
1:39:30 When they purchased it, there was a bit of a change with this property to the east.
1:39:35 It was going to be a buildable lot.
1:39:37 what happened was the homeowners in the area constructed an irrigation pond and have their
1:39:44 own pressurized irrigation system. So when they did that, this lot became unbuildable for
1:39:49 a house. What they did was convey part of the property to this lot. So what they ended up
1:39:56 purchasing was actually over to this point and down and over. So the original platted easement,
1:40:03 which does not go away without going through this process
1:40:06 remained here, even though they owned all of this area.
1:40:11 So they've come in, want to build a shop in this area.
1:40:15 You can't build a shop on an easement.
1:40:17 And so they're going through the process
1:40:18 to vacate the easement.
1:40:20 Originally, there was some back and forth communication
1:40:24 with us in the Twin Falls Highway District
1:40:25 worrying about drainage and other easements.
1:40:29 That kind of came up during the planning and zoning.
1:40:32 I've been carrying you if you read the minutes for that meeting since then, basically, on the second.
1:40:36 This last week, the Twin Falls Highway District sent a new letter, which is in your packet.
1:40:41 It's the new one to be updated on the second.
1:40:43 They are not pursuing any other new easement to be recorded on the east side, and no other
1:40:49 utility companies, including the canal company, nobody sees fit to keep the utilities in the
1:40:54 area.
1:40:55 So they are just completely vacating that easement, not rededicating a new one.
1:41:00 And as a conclusion, should the City Council recommend approval of the request to the County
1:41:05 Commissioner's staff recommends no additional conditions?
1:41:09 Your recommendation gets forwarded to the City County Commissioners since this is an area
1:41:14 of impact and they have final rules to count those matters.
1:41:17 That's all.
1:41:18 All right.
1:41:19 Thank you, Jonathan.
1:41:20 Any questions for Jonathan?
1:41:21 Seeing none, we'll open it up for the public hearing.
1:41:29 Is there anyone who wishes to address the Council on this issue?
1:41:36 No one we will close the public hearing and turn it over to council for Nicky Boyd.
1:41:48 Ready to entertain a motion?
1:41:50 You gotcha.
1:41:51 Okay.
1:41:52 I move that we grant the request for a vacation of a 15 by 18.
1:41:57 I guess I read it all right.
1:42:00 A lot of numbers.
1:42:02 185.13 feet, 2,777 square feet, utility, irrigation and drainage easement on Lot 10 of
1:42:13 Wild Rosa State's subdivision, Number 1, on property located at 4042 North, 3320 East,
1:42:21 in the area of impact, Carab, Jennifer and Ken, Ashley application, Number 2815.
1:42:27 Greg Linton.
1:42:30 I would second that if we include that this is our recommendation to the county commissioners
1:42:37 Do you want to read that again Nick?
1:42:42 We have a motion by Nikki Boyd seconded by Greg Lanting to forward a recommendation to the Twin Falls county commissioners to approve the vacation as stated
1:42:52 with
1:42:53 No need for an additional easement. It's their need further discussion
1:42:58 Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote, please.
1:43:06 Shawn Beriker.
1:43:07 Yes.
1:43:08 Chris Tockington.
1:43:09 Yes.
1:43:10 Greg Lanting.
1:43:10 Yes.
1:43:11 Don Hall.
1:43:12 Yes.
1:43:12 Ruth Pierce.
1:43:13 Yes.
1:43:14 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:43:16 She's abstaining.
1:43:17 She's abstaining.
1:43:19 Nikki Boyd.
1:43:20 Yes.
1:43:21 Motion passes 6 to 0 with one abstention.
1:43:27 I have a quick question.
1:43:28 Greg Lanting, Chris.
1:43:30 I've been on council almost 12 years down.
1:43:32 We've never had the county say no on anything.
1:43:34 We recommend what happens if they do say no.
1:43:40 It's their decision.
1:43:41 Okay, so we're basically planning zoning
1:43:44 on the area of impact issues.
1:43:45 Okay, thank you.
1:43:49 Sound like there's some more.
1:43:51 Yeah, I probably should have said that.
1:43:53 That's pretty cool.
1:43:54 The next item on the agenda is a adjournment
1:43:57 and an executive session under Idaho Code 74206-C
1:44:02 to acquire an interest in real property,
1:44:04 which is not owned by a public agency, Council wishes.
1:44:09 Suzanne Hopkins.
1:44:10 I move approval of everything you just read.
1:44:14 Second.
1:44:16 Motion by Suzanne Hawkins is seconded by Greg Lanting
1:44:18 to adjourn into executive session as stated.
1:44:22 Sharon, roll call vote please.
1:44:24 I'm Chris Talkington.
1:44:25 Yes.
1:44:26 Greg Lanting.
1:44:26 Yes.
1:44:27 Don Hall.
1:44:28 Yes.
1:44:28 Ruth Pitts.
1:44:31 Yes.
1:44:33 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:44:34 Yes.
1:44:34 Nicky Boyd.
1:44:35 Yes.
1:44:36 Sean Baraker.
1:44:37 Yes.
1:44:38 Motion passes 7-0.
1:44:39 just a reminder we will not be making any decisions in executive session nor will
1:44:43 we be coming back out following that to make any decisions. Greg Lanting. I just
1:44:49 want to come into the Scouts as one of the first groups and both of them stayed
1:44:53 for the whole thing. We appreciate that. It's not always this
1:44:57 dry. I realize this since I taught middle school social studies for a while in my
1:45:06 I realize this probably seemed a little like a
1:45:10 They and their wolf stage class not mine not any of mine, but some sort of
1:45:21 Say as I'm sitting over there for a half an hour signing paperwork after all the things we just approved tonight
1:45:26 We'll see how dry it was
1:45:29 All right with that the meeting is adjourned
Download
- Transcript (text) 88 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 120 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 166 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.2 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 3.6 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, November 7, 2016. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:45:42.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
d6365db0a2418b051ccb3f41a1929b4821e821711eb9cc5a0167dfff51f5e9e6 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min, with 1 passage muted for privacy. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 9a97053372ab4b6b9c9a547823186846531eca882516623de935aa2e90afd2bd
part02.m4a 4c0041615aa36eaf4f91b17aa7dd218021ebfb981614e6823fa0145ce430fd2c - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 4 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
7f25084da6d5d5b834396696a23f3a37c7830f9b1f9ad305e638466328cf995b
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file