City Council meeting
Monday, November 28, 2016
Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:09:46 I'd like to call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday, November 28th.
0:09:54 We do have some Boy Scouts here this evening, so I would invite them to come forward to please
0:09:58 lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance.
0:09:59 And those of you wishing to join us, please rise.
0:10:02 Right down here.
0:10:13 It's perfect.
0:10:14 Unless you're going to run for a second.
0:10:18 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:10:35 If you guys just want to step up to the podium right there, right over here, if you would
0:10:42 introduce yourself and let us know which troop you're with and what you are working on this
0:10:47 evening.
0:10:48 I'm Benson Hatch and I'm from Chuke 104.
0:10:52 I'm working on the citizenship in the community, the Mayor badge.
0:10:58 Awesome.
0:10:59 Thank you.
0:11:02 I'm Curtis Christensen and I'm from Chuke 104 as well and I'm working on the citizenship
0:11:08 in the community Mayor badge too.
0:11:10 Great.
0:11:11 Well thank you both for joining us this evening.
0:11:18 We do have a quorum of the council here this evening.
0:11:20 All seven members are here.
0:11:21 Mr. Rothweiler.
0:11:22 Do we have any amendments to the agenda this evening?
0:11:25 Mr. Mayor and members of council, there are no amendments.
0:11:27 Thank you.
0:11:28 We have no proclamations this evening either.
0:11:31 So next on the agenda is general public input.
0:11:33 If there is anyone here from the public
0:11:35 who would like to address the council on an issue,
0:11:37 not on tonight's agenda,
0:11:38 now is your opportunity to come forward.
0:11:43 Seeing none, we will move on to the consent calendar.
0:11:46 Council wishes, Suzanne Hawkins.
0:11:48 Mayor, make motion that we pull the council minutes
0:11:52 off of it since some of us weren't here last week to vote on that issue
0:11:57 is that okay
0:12:04 so we'll remove that
0:12:05 but i want to stay from that part of the panel's right so we'll vote on the
0:12:09 two items separately
0:12:12 so that council wishes on approval of the accounts payable
0:12:18 motion by great lanting seconded by don hall to
0:12:21 approve the accounts payable as presented in the discussion
0:12:26 seeing none sure we'll call the police
0:12:30 Ms. Anne Hawkins.
0:12:31 Yes.
0:12:32 Nicky Boyd.
0:12:33 Yes.
0:12:34 Sean Beriker.
0:12:35 Yes.
0:12:36 Chris Hockington.
0:12:37 Yes.
0:12:38 Greg Lanting.
0:12:39 Yes.
0:12:40 Don Hall.
0:12:41 Yes.
0:12:42 Ruth Pierce.
0:12:43 Yes.
0:12:44 Motion passes.
0:12:45 Seven to zero.
0:12:46 And council wishes on the minutes of the November 21 meeting.
0:12:49 Move approval.
0:12:50 Seven.
0:12:51 Motion by Greg Lanting.
0:12:54 Second by Nicky Boyd to approve the council minutes for November 21 as presented.
0:13:00 discussion. Seeing none, Sharon Roll call vote please.
0:13:04 Nicky Boyd?
0:13:05 Yes.
0:13:06 Sean Beriker?
0:13:07 Yes.
0:13:08 Chris Tockington?
0:13:09 Epstein.
0:13:12 Greg Lanting?
0:13:13 Yes.
0:13:14 Don Hall?
0:13:15 Yes.
0:13:16 Ruth Pierce?
0:13:17 Yes.
0:13:19 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:13:20 Epstein?
0:13:21 Motion passes 5-2-0 with two abstentions.
0:13:28 Next item for consideration.
0:13:30 The first is a presentation regarding the Mayor's School
0:13:33 Walking Challenge, and we have Kendra Whit Doyle and Courtney Frost with the Blue Cross
0:13:39 of Idaho Foundation for Health.
0:13:41 Welcome.
0:13:42 Thank you.
0:13:43 Thank you, Mayor and City Council.
0:13:44 I'm here today on behalf of the Mayor's School Walking Challenge, which is a challenge
0:13:48 for mayors in their local elementary schools in southwest Idaho to a Walking Challenge.
0:13:53 And this is in partnership with the Blue Cross of Idaho Foundation, St. Luke's and the Idaho
0:13:57 Dairy Council.
0:13:58 And we're here today to award Mayor Beriger
0:14:01 for walking at least 10,000 steps.
0:14:05 Every day.
0:14:06 Yeah.
0:14:07 Yes.
0:14:07 Yes.
0:14:08 Actually.
0:14:09 That just in total.
0:14:11 Yeah, it's the average 12,421 steps per day,
0:14:17 which is no small feat.
0:14:19 So he needs a round of applause for doing that.
0:14:21 Thank you.
0:14:26 Not only that, but he was passionate,
0:14:28 excited and enthusiastic about the challenge.
0:14:31 He walked 11 times with local elementary schools
0:14:34 here in Twin Falls, and actually four schools
0:14:37 in the community here won $1,750 in the challenge as well.
0:14:43 This was a manual Lutheran, sawtooth elementary,
0:14:45 Harrison, and morning sight elementary,
0:14:47 all one funds as well during this challenge.
0:14:50 You were also the first mayor to really engage social media,
0:14:54 which was fun and exciting to see his updates
0:14:57 and his selfies with the children and also the videos.
0:14:59 There were some very historical videos that I know myself and the community really loved.
0:15:05 And we also know you use the Mayor School Walking Challenge as a platform to engage your community
0:15:09 to get active and also support the local trails.
0:15:13 So we're here today to give you $1,000 towards your community.
0:15:17 On behalf of our partners Idaho Dairy Council and St. Luke's, I'd like to invite them up
0:15:20 right now, Tom and Jody and Bill and April and Courtney to present the check to you.
0:15:25 Thank you.
0:15:26 Well, thank you all so much for the opportunity to participate, so Mayor Hall did this last
0:16:33 year and walked a lot more steps than I did.
0:16:36 Worked his tail off.
0:16:38 I knew that I was going to not be able to exceed those expectations, so I finished solidly
0:16:44 in the middle of the pack amongst the mayors.
0:16:47 But I really had a great time.
0:16:48 I actually think spending the time with the school kids was the most rewarding part of it.
0:16:56 It was during the election season, leading up to the presidential election.
0:16:59 So it was a lot of fun every day, walking with them, getting asked who I was going to vote
0:17:04 for for president, and then hearing their opinions on who they would like to vote for for president.
0:17:09 So we had a good time with all of that.
0:17:11 So I appreciate the contribution.
0:17:13 This money will go to this city, to the Parks and Rec Department, and I'm hoping we can
0:17:18 dedicate that to our trail system.
0:17:22 As Kendra mentioned, I use this as an opportunity to encourage people to contribute to our local
0:17:27 trail system.
0:17:29 And so with contributions from my parents, Mike and Jody Tremblay, Ken Lisa Brennan, Jeff
0:17:37 Jeff and Michelle Martin and a top off check from my wife and I will be contributing $1,000
0:17:45 to MavTech toward their efforts to raise matching funds for the new section of trails.
0:17:51 So I'd like to invite Jamie Teague to come up, say a few words on behalf of MavTech and
0:17:56 then I'll give you your checks.
0:17:58 Thank you so much.
0:18:04 We are very honored for you to, I guess, have us be a huge participant in what you did.
0:18:11 Your efforts go a huge and a long way, thanks Sean, we appreciate it so much.
0:18:17 Today we have made huge strides towards where we're at and thank you for your support City
0:18:24 Council members for helping us get to where we are at today.
0:18:28 We are just a little under now needing, it's approximately $199,000 left out of the 600.
0:18:36 So this includes the thousands.
0:18:39 So thank you so much.
0:18:40 We really appreciate it.
0:18:42 We're really grateful for it.
0:19:04 So I've already made a note on my calendar for next July
0:19:07 to start getting in shape to walk a few more steps next October,
0:19:10 but I look forward to doing it again.
0:19:12 And thanks again to St. Luke's,
0:19:14 to the Blue Cross Foundation,
0:19:16 and to the I know Dairy Council for your efforts
0:19:19 in helping make this a whole lot of fun,
0:19:21 and to MavTech for continuing your efforts in the communities.
0:19:24 Thanks to everyone.
0:19:27 Next, on the agenda, we have a presentation of a Peace Officer Standards and Training Executive
0:19:33 Certificate, the highest certificate awarded to Peace Officers in the State of Idaho, to
0:19:37 Chief Craig Kingsbury of the Twin Falls Police Department.
0:19:40 We have Victor McRaw, Division Administrator, Peace Officer Standards and Training.
0:19:45 We have Travis Rothwell, our Senator.
0:19:47 It's actually my pleasure to introduce to you, Victor McRaw.
0:19:51 Thank you, Travis.
0:20:04 Welcome.
0:20:05 Good evening.
0:20:06 Thanks for inviting me here. This award is really for the Chief, so I'd like to bring the Chief up,
0:20:11 and no disrespect to you, but I'd like to move up here and address the audience.
0:20:17 That would be perfect, the microphone will just pull over the top there.
0:20:25 And I told the Chief, I hope he has wall space.
0:20:30 This is a huge certificate. I'll read it really quickly and I'll say a few words about it.
0:20:35 State of Idaho, Peace Officer, Standards and Training, Re-enforcing professionalism, training,
0:20:40 education and dedication of service to the community and the State of Idaho awards the executive
0:20:46 certificate to Craig Kingsburg. This certificate is not something that we give out, even though
0:20:54 I'm going to give it out. This is something that's earned and not every chief and not every
0:21:00 sheriff has one of these, nor will they, in the State of Idaho. It is a definite milestone
0:21:08 and professionalism in a career.
0:21:10 In this case, a career that started in 1989,
0:21:12 I understand it, as a reserve officer in Lewis Day.
0:21:16 And I just heard from your mom, that's where you grew up.
0:21:18 And that's something I never got to do.
0:21:21 I grew up in Washington State,
0:21:22 I became a peace officer about three years before you.
0:21:26 So we've seen some of the same things, but in 86,
0:21:29 in Arizona, so I never got to serve my community
0:21:31 that I grew up in, so in the U-Vat.
0:21:34 I also in the Tampa.
0:21:36 And I also envy all of you for stealing him away from our Boise,
0:21:40 Napa area here to your city.
0:21:45 But this certificate is for continuing training.
0:21:49 One of the failings of law enforcement nationwide that you
0:21:52 see when you turn on the news when agencies have not done right
0:21:56 by their communities.
0:21:57 And then that one event seems to blow up into something bigger
0:22:00 than it should have been is usually
0:22:02 because that agency is stagnant, which usually
0:22:06 means that the officers have not been getting trained,
0:22:09 they've not been keeping up with what's going on,
0:22:11 they've not been keeping up with the community,
0:22:13 and that usually is a result or a reflection of poor leadership.
0:22:19 So this is the exact opposite.
0:22:21 This is the leader of your police agency going out
0:22:24 and getting more training than just about anybody else.
0:22:28 This is the only one of these I'm issuing in the last six
0:22:32 months, I think.
0:22:35 So that's huge, and hopefully setting an example
0:22:37 for the officers that are on the back
0:22:39 to stay up on their training.
0:22:41 I came on an 80s, I came on an 89, it's a different world.
0:22:46 It definitely is.
0:22:47 And as I understand it, you walking the footsteps
0:22:51 of your father, my father was an MP,
0:22:55 that's about as close as we got to being police.
0:22:59 I can't say that I want either of my sons
0:23:02 or my daughter to be a police owner.
0:23:04 I can't.
0:23:06 I wish that I could because I love my career.
0:23:09 But I think we've got to a place where this type of
0:23:12 professionalism is so important and so needed to turn that
0:23:17 around.
0:23:19 The Chief is just a fine example of that.
0:23:21 And I appreciate him.
0:23:22 And I hope that you do too.
0:23:57 And Council, community members, members of the Twin
0:24:01 Falls Police Department, I just want to thank you for the
0:24:04 support that you've given me.
0:24:05 I'm about five weeks from my one-year anniversary here at
0:24:09 TFPD. As Director McGraw said, I started my career in 1989 in
0:24:15 the town of Lewiston as a reserve officer. That time my dad was a sergeant with LPD, and it
0:24:21 was actually really cool to be able to work with him and ride with him on patrol as a uniform
0:24:27 reserve officer. And then I moved over to the sheriff's office there, Nesperce County, and
0:24:32 worked there for 20 years, just under two years. And now Director, I did lead the area
0:24:39 where I grew up in, because I did get a little tired of booking into jail some of my classmates.
0:24:44 So I was fortunate enough to get a job in NAMPA where I worked for 24 years before coming here.
0:24:52 I have had great support from the city here at Twin Falls, but I also want to thank my mom who's in the back.
0:24:58 My father passed away four years ago next month, but I want to thank my mom Gretchen for all the support that she's given me and my two brothers.
0:25:07 One brother who also is a police officer.
0:25:09 He's a sergeant with the Uselton County Washington Sheriff's Office.
0:25:13 And my youngest brother, we say that he's one of the smarter ones.
0:25:16 He's a pharmaceutical representative.
0:25:18 So he's living a good life.
0:25:21 But selling legal stuff in case he doesn't work in Washington state.
0:25:28 You also want to thank the men and women of TFPD for their support in my year
0:25:32 that I've been here.
0:25:33 It has been a wonderful coming to this agency.
0:25:36 I'm really proud to be a member of the team with all the men and women of the Twin Falls Police Department.
0:25:42 We have Sheriff Carter here.
0:25:43 The Twin Falls Sheriff's Office is an excellent partner.
0:25:46 And Sheriff, I appreciate the support that you've given me personally through the last 11 plus months that I've been here.
0:25:52 It's been wonderful.
0:25:54 And of course, our city managers, Travis Rothweiler and the deputy city managers, Brian and Mitch.
0:25:59 And all the support that they've given me and our city team.
0:26:02 So this is really an accumulation of a lot of years, but as a director said, also a lot of training.
0:26:08 We are in an equivalent point in law enforcement, or unfortunately we see things happen across our country
0:26:14 that are the result of lack of training.
0:26:16 And I think sometimes that lack of training comes because of lack of support from mayors and councils and city administrators.
0:26:24 We're fortunate here in Twin Falls, we don't have that, and knock on wood.
0:26:29 We do a nice job when we have those critical situations that arise
0:26:35 because we have well-trained men and women to answer,
0:26:37 not only the 911 calls, but to send out to the scene.
0:26:40 So thanks everybody and there we go.
0:26:43 Congratulations Chief and thank you for your professionalism,
0:26:56 your dedication to your position
0:26:58 and to the men and women of the Twin Falls Police Department.
0:27:04 Next on the agenda is a presentation
0:27:06 from Vera C. O'Leary Middle School students
0:27:09 on a city ordinance for animal abuse
0:27:10 and corresponding fines, and Councilman Talkington will introduce our guests this evening.
0:27:16 Thank you.
0:27:17 About a month and a half ago, I was contacted by students at the Vera Middle School, and
0:27:26 they exemplified immediately what many of us in the Council have been talking about,
0:27:30 the local government works.
0:27:33 These aren't even voters' friends, but they're involved in our community, and they're tackling
0:27:39 a controversial and a never settled issue entirely that dealing with animal cruelty in
0:27:46 the city limits.
0:27:48 What finds there are, what might be done to improve the situation so far as the animals,
0:27:55 not only dogs, not only cats, but animals, under the main frame of public safety as well
0:28:02 as being animal lovers.
0:28:05 So at this time, and by the way, their data collection,
0:28:10 I tried to show them some data, and they
0:28:12 knew more than I did on what the stats were in the Twin
0:28:15 Falls City enforcement.
0:28:18 So at this time, I'd like to turn the microphone over
0:28:21 to Kathy and Eric Price, who will kind of lead us
0:28:27 on some questions and answers and information.
0:28:29 Eric might want to introduce her.
0:28:34 Good evening City Council members of City Council. My name is Eric Price and we are part of the
0:28:41 Tesla Volts Robotics team from my Larry Middle School. We are part of the first Lego League
0:28:46 international organization. The core values of this organization are discovery, integration,
0:28:53 inclusion and cooperation. The theme this year is helping our animal allies and we are asked
0:29:00 to find ways that we can help our animal friends.
0:29:02 Thank you.
0:29:03 Our team chose to focus on animal cruelty in the city of Twin Falls.
0:29:07 We interviewed a veterinarian, animal control officers, and did a public record search to
0:29:13 research our topic.
0:29:15 We also talked with your own member, Chris Talkington, and to find out about the current
0:29:20 situation and what we could do about it.
0:29:22 For our investigation, we found out that the number of calls to animal control in 2015 was 3,231.
0:29:30 And in this year, through October, there have already been 2,900 calls.
0:29:35 The number of convictions has also increased.
0:29:37 As the population of Twin Falls continues to rise, we feel that the number of animal cruelty cases will only increase as well.
0:29:44 The current city ordinance has a penalty of $100, no matter how many times you get caught.
0:29:50 We feel that $100 is not enough to stop people from abusing animals.
0:29:54 We would like city council to consider increasing the penalties for
0:29:58 repeat offenders to what the city of Ketchum did recently.
0:30:01 We have provided for you on the day issue we gave you the scientific wording from the city ordinances.
0:30:07 Summarizing, they say that first, any person convicted of a first violation for
0:30:12 each offense shall be punished by a jail sentence if not more than six months or
0:30:16 find of not less than $100, more than $5,000, or by both find and imprisonment.
0:30:25 Any person convicted by a second violation within 10 years of the first conviction shall
0:30:30 be punished for each offense by a jail sentence, if not more, than nine months, or a find of
0:30:35 not less than $200, nor more than $7,000, or by both find and imprisonment.
0:30:42 any person convicted of a third or sub-stickland violation within 15 years of the first conviction shall be punished for each offense by
0:30:50 jail sentence if not more than 12 months or fine of not less than $500 nor more than $9,000 or by both fine and imprisonment.
0:31:00 Changes to catch on city ordinances are new enough that we can't see what effects they have had in their city, but we feel that being proactive in protecting the
0:31:09 animals in the city of Twin Falls is important. We have collected 150 signatures from our friends
0:31:16 at school and from around the community. We also agree that this change should happen. In
0:31:21 addition to this request, we have created stickers like the ones we attached to your information
0:31:25 sheet that we will be passing out in the community and have run a successful pet food drive at
0:31:31 our school to support the pet food pantry at the animal shelter. We have started doing our
0:31:36 our part to support and protect the animals in our community.
0:31:40 Will you please help us by changing the city ordinances?
0:31:43 Thank you for your consideration of this request.
0:31:48 Thank you very much, Eric.
0:31:49 Are there any questions for Mr. Price or his colleagues?
0:31:53 Nicky Boyd.
0:31:55 It's not a question, but thank you for such a wonderful presentation.
0:31:59 You did an excellent job.
0:32:01 Thank you.
0:32:03 Don Hall.
0:32:04 You know, I'd agree with Councilwoman Boyd
0:32:08 that you did a fantastic job, and this is great information.
0:32:11 You've done a lot of great research,
0:32:13 and I really appreciate that.
0:32:15 I'm personally not ready to make any move tonight,
0:32:19 because this is the first I've seen it.
0:32:21 I always like to have at least a week or so to look at it.
0:32:25 It seems reasonable to me.
0:32:27 It seems like the right thing to do,
0:32:29 but just I just want you to know
0:32:31 that I just have some hesitancy,
0:32:33 because any time that we're gonna make a change
0:32:35 in any kind of ordinance,
0:32:36 We would have to bring it back anyway, Fritz.
0:32:41 Yeah, yeah.
0:32:43 I'd like to mull it over a little bit more,
0:32:45 talk some community members.
0:32:47 Again, from just face value,
0:32:50 it looks very reasonable, well researched,
0:32:52 and I appreciate what you've done.
0:32:56 Chris talking to me.
0:32:57 I did explain to the group that there may be
0:32:59 some input from the A City attorney,
0:33:02 so far as fines and penalties regarding misdemeanors.
0:33:07 of the
0:33:10 members.
0:33:11 It's anything you can add to what these city council
0:33:15 wanted tomorrow have already researched on?
0:33:22 The reason the penalty right now is $100 is because the
0:33:26 offense is an infraction and $100 is the maximum
0:33:30 buying that this state allows us to impose by infraction.
0:33:34 We'll want to take a look.
0:33:37 You'll have to decide if you want to change that to a
0:33:40 do it affects us as prosecutors because suddenly instead of a court trial then we're looking
0:33:46 at a jury trial and I will tell you from past experience everyone that has a vicious dog
0:33:52 or a barking dog wants a jury trial and it's a lot of time by the judicial system in those
0:34:02 cases.
0:34:03 So that's why we and the county changed those two interactions.
0:34:11 Thank you. I was just going to ask about the cost because I know it is the county that would have to provide the legal defense for the person we're making those accusations against. Is that correct?
0:34:28 Ordinarily, it's the public defender's office that represents the and so you're right. Thank you.
0:34:38 And then I just have a question.
0:34:39 Can we meet all of the young men up there?
0:34:42 I would be curious to hear who we have here.
0:34:46 Gentlemen, would you mind introducing yourselves to us?
0:34:49 My name is Kayla Bowness.
0:34:56 I'm Katie Brusik.
0:35:01 I'm Cole Kelly.
0:35:06 And I'm Ethan Pustich.
0:35:09 Thank you.
0:35:21 Thank you again, gentlemen, for your presentation.
0:35:24 Chris Talking.
0:35:25 I would suggest that we ask the city manager
0:35:27 to do a little research to see with Princess Guidance,
0:35:32 perhaps what some other communities
0:35:34 in the Northwest are doing so far as animal cruelty,
0:35:38 so far as maybe some innovative or new ideas
0:35:42 on trying to get better control on it,
0:35:47 including publicity.
0:35:49 I did inform the group when they were getting together
0:35:53 that city government works on four out of seven,
0:35:57 if it's legal to consider, but we often have to do our own research to say, are we following
0:36:03 best practices? There may be some place in a community in Idaho or elsewhere who has had
0:36:09 another group of students such as yourself who's helped city councils realize that we
0:36:14 need to do more than what we have. So I think we need to do a little more of studying, but
0:36:19 we want to encourage you to keep the pressure on us. And it's really impressive to have half
0:36:26 of the school there is sign of petition.
0:36:29 Just don't have them call us late at night at home.
0:36:31 Great, Lansing.
0:36:34 French have a question for you.
0:36:37 It's your reference to your infraction.
0:36:41 So if I'm just using this as an example.
0:36:44 So the first one could remain a refraction,
0:36:47 but to bring you the rest of it, they
0:36:50 would have to become misdemeanors two and three.
0:36:52 Yeah, in order to increase the fine of $100.
0:36:55 I'm saying the first could stay in the fraction, but the others would have to be a misdemeanor, okay.
0:37:00 Thank you, boy.
0:37:01 I have a question for the boys.
0:37:03 You said that you collected pet food at your school.
0:37:07 Can anybody drop off cat and dog food or what kind of pet food do you collect and can it be dropped off there at any time?
0:37:15 You can take the food up to the animal shelter and they'll take it for their pet food.
0:37:23 Okay, but you've collected at school and then you take it to the animal shelter also at school
0:37:27 Yeah, we collected for about two or three weeks and
0:37:31 A lot of them got a lot of food. It was really great. Thank you
0:37:36 Susan I can't pass up the opportunity. Are you gentlemen seventh grade eighth grade?
0:37:42 So once your eighth grade and older we have a city youth council
0:37:54 That we love to have young citizens come help us advise and make decisions and give us input
0:38:02 on what your age group would like to see in our city.
0:38:06 And I meet with that youth group.
0:38:08 We meet the second Monday of every month at the city hall office and I'd like to extend
0:38:13 an invitation to all of you.
0:38:15 If you'd like to come join us for a meeting and see what we do and how we do it, that would
0:38:19 be great.
0:38:20 There's a lot of good opportunity for you to learn more about local government but it also
0:38:24 is a great thing on your college resume someday and so you can help us and we can help you
0:38:30 and if you're interested get a hold of me and I'll give you all the information.
0:38:38 Once again thank you for your presentation I'll give these signatures on the petition to
0:38:43 our city clerk to include in the record for tonight and Travis you have some direction
0:38:50 there to perhaps bring back some information from other communities.
0:38:54 Yeah, Brian Pike will be working with Sean Stanley and members of our animal control and
0:39:00 we'll be making a presentation back to the Council on the third of January.
0:39:04 Thank you very much.
0:39:08 The next item on the agenda is a request to approve the design guidelines for the Twin
0:39:11 Falls Downtown Historic District and Twin Falls City Park Historic District as a reference
0:39:16 document and recommendation from City Council to amend the City Code to codify the design
0:39:21 guidelines.
0:39:22 We have Kelly Weeks and Nancy Taylor.
0:39:27 Welcome Kelly.
0:39:30 Hi.
0:39:31 I'm Aaron Castle.
0:39:32 This is Kelly Weeks, Planner 1.
0:39:39 Staff support for the Historic Preservation Commission.
0:39:41 HPC is a web to call it.
0:39:46 About two years ago we went and got a CLG grant which is a government local certified
0:39:55 local government grant and started putting together design guidelines for the historic
0:40:04 downtown district and the city park historic district.
0:40:14 We asked for an extension in 2014 of those grant funds.
0:40:20 That year we also worked on the Lincoln street lights and it got those done.
0:40:26 And then we asked for an extension for part of the money and got another grant in 2015
0:40:33 and finished up the guidelines for these two districts.
0:40:39 In 2015, the HPC voted to have us come before the council and ask you to approve the guidelines
0:40:49 as a reference document and also ask you to give us a recommendation to take it for codification
0:40:57 in the city code.
0:41:01 Before we did that, we wanted to take it to the public, the downtown districts and the
0:41:06 Park District property owners especially and see what their feelings were about these guidelines.
0:41:13 So we took it to three city fairs and we also had an open house.
0:41:19 And at the city fairs we got several comments.
0:41:25 Most of them were in favor of preserving the old buildings, keeping the historic characters.
0:41:34 They wanted us to make the guidelines flexible.
0:41:38 Keep the guidelines strictly historic, make them super easy to understand, make the process
0:41:46 easy and quick, allow an appeal to the elected body.
0:41:55 They suggested we have the city have one point of contact representing the city departments,
0:42:00 which the building department has already done that.
0:42:09 There was several other comments about streetscapes and keeping downtown vibrant, creating and
0:42:17 allowing housing on second floors, allowing for plaza entrances, don't allow plastic
0:42:25 awnings or façade treatments, and they wanted us to do a lot of education, which we tried
0:42:33 to do. We haven't got a whole lot of responses on our, especially our open house. We did get
0:42:40 several people there, and they were property owners of downtown businesses. The comments
0:42:48 that we got at our open house.
0:42:49 Everybody was in favor of the guidelines.
0:42:56 We put together a slideshow for the open house
0:43:00 before and after pictures.
0:43:04 I brought a few of them so you could see
0:43:08 the guidelines would kept flexible.
0:43:09 They're a lot like the historic downtown.
0:43:12 There's like three choices in each one, the shawls,
0:43:16 not chow, but the most preferenced,
0:43:19 if you're gonna do a remodel,
0:43:21 this is what you really should do
0:43:23 to keep the integrity of the building.
0:43:26 If you can't do this, then this is our next preference.
0:43:29 If you can't do this, then maybe this.
0:43:32 And if it's just not possible, then I've not seen the HPC
0:43:37 say you definitely can't do that.
0:43:41 We're pretty flexible.
0:43:49 At least the Strickland, our administrative assistant,
0:43:51 did a lot of research and found the OSP photos
0:43:55 of the different buildings downtown and in the city park district and then we went through
0:44:02 and found some more current ones of what they look like now.
0:44:08 This happens to be the key bank and old Duncan's on the corner, main street in Shoshone, that's
0:44:18 another picture of the key bank, city hall now, that's Duncan's.
0:44:29 There's an early on to a boy here, old doctor, remember the direct story.
0:44:32 I do.
0:44:33 Thanks a lot.
0:44:34 I remember it too.
0:44:38 Rosie's, that was really an interesting picture.
0:44:45 This is the um.
0:44:52 Ballroom.
0:44:54 Ballroom, yeah.
0:44:55 The name just went away.
0:44:57 For us old folks, the office building.
0:45:00 Yeah.
0:45:01 The van shell.
0:45:04 The pry and building.
0:45:10 Black or furniture.
0:45:17 Was car dealership.
0:45:19 Well, it was before me.
0:45:22 Yeah.
0:45:22 And my brother.
0:45:25 This is Idaho Department store, which is now the youth center,
0:45:28 or the youth ranch, and the reform church, which isn't there now.
0:45:36 It's now the library.
0:45:41 You're on just the hotel, of course, which isn't there.
0:45:45 And he'd have taken a right-hand picture.
0:45:49 Twin Falls High School, which isn't there now, it's the jail.
0:45:57 We're doing Larry's students going.
0:45:59 It was a learning for a while, too.
0:46:00 But right now, we're asking for two, this is a twofold request.
0:46:10 We're asking you to approve the guidelines as a written, as a reference document.
0:46:15 So if anybody in the downtown district and the city park district would like to remodel
0:46:20 the outside of their building, they have a reference document to go to.
0:46:25 And we're also asking you to recommend that we take these, go through the process to codify
0:46:35 this document in the city code so that the property owners would have to come through for a certificate
0:46:43 of appropriateness for any remodeling that they do to the outside of the buildings.
0:46:48 So we can preserve the integrity.
0:46:51 Kelly, can you clarify for me the old town district currently is codified correct?
0:46:57 The warehouse district.
0:46:58 The warehouse district, right?
0:47:00 Yes.
0:47:03 Thank you.
0:47:04 Don Hall.
0:47:06 I trust, and I've read through the guidelines, and I trust the HBC right now, the Start Preservation Committee,
0:47:14 but one of the concerns or one of the things that were brought out by your open houses and the thing that I share as well
0:47:21 is to ensure that we're flexible with these businesses and these homes.
0:47:26 Because sometimes government has a habit of becoming overreaching at times.
0:47:33 How do we ensure, is there some language in here?
0:47:36 How do we ensure in the future that we will stay flexible with folks and try to work through?
0:47:43 There's language in here that if the Historic Preservation Commission says that you have to
0:47:49 do it a certain way and the person doesn't agree with that, they can appeal to planning and zoning
0:47:55 and then to the council, there's an appeal process.
0:47:59 So you think that that will help us continue that flexibility?
0:48:03 because that was my second question about the actual appeal process for folks in the audience,
0:48:09 that it will go through P&Z first, if they don't have satisfaction there, it can come to the full council.
0:48:14 Okay, I think that builds in the flexibility and the intent here.
0:48:19 And what I've seen with the warehouse district, because I've been a council member of the HPC a couple times,
0:48:27 is that there is tremendous flexibility in trying to work with folks.
0:48:31 And lastly, I just want to say that I am supportive of these guidelines.
0:48:36 I think it hit me the strongest when Judge Smith, Paul Smith, said one time in a meeting that he currently owns the canal building, the old canal building.
0:48:46 And he says right now I can go and draw by demolition request and go chair that down.
0:48:53 There's nothing preventing me from doing that.
0:48:56 And I thought, what a travesty that would be.
0:48:59 He was just, he was not going to do it.
0:49:01 It was just illustrating that that's what could take place with these historic buildings.
0:49:06 And that would be an absolute travesty, so I think this is the right direction.
0:49:10 But again, I just want to ensure that we have that flexibility.
0:49:16 Chris, talk.
0:49:17 Kelly, good job on presentation of this.
0:49:20 The two questions kind of related I get from people are if you
0:49:26 have a structure in the downtown historic or the city park historic district and
0:49:31 not contemplating any remodeling changing, there is no impact, financial impact to you.
0:49:39 You can retain a structure in its current condition if it's a continuing use.
0:49:46 That's true.
0:49:47 And the second, and that's what I more or less verified, but I want to make sure it's
0:49:51 on the public record, and for those people who, or business owners who are contemplating
0:49:57 changes. The past history where we've implemented this, the costs have not neither been prohibited
0:50:09 or unreasonable nor the design standards unpopular. I'm kind of putting words in your mouth, but
0:50:16 I mean it's not force feeding, but instead of a plastic awning we're encouraging to use
0:50:22 available material on the building and sometimes could be cheaper, but isn't necessarily going
0:50:29 to impose new costs to them.
0:50:31 That's true.
0:50:32 Am I oversimplifying that?
0:50:34 I don't think so.
0:50:35 I think that's true.
0:50:38 Great.
0:50:39 Thank you.
0:50:40 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:50:41 Thank you.
0:50:42 Good job, Kelly.
0:50:43 I really enjoyed reading through all the material and refreshing myself on it.
0:50:47 In order to codify, do you know what the cost is and does that come out of the city's general
0:50:52 budget or does that come out of the HPC budget?
0:50:57 It would come out of, right now the HPC budget is kind of the planning and zoning budget.
0:51:02 Okay.
0:51:03 It's a combination.
0:51:06 We're going to try and get another grant that will help with that cost.
0:51:13 The cost would be mostly the planning and the public hearing cost and the publications
0:51:20 and the mailings that we would have to do.
0:51:23 We would have to have two public hearings, one before planning a zoning, and one before
0:51:28 the city council.
0:51:29 And you don't have an estimate with those costs, Dara?
0:51:33 I don't have to have a city council.
0:51:36 So the costs are largely going to be staff time.
0:51:38 Okay.
0:51:39 And so they're going to be, I mean, you're going to have some nominal costs when it comes
0:51:43 to publishing, like Kelly's talking about, publishing notices for public hearing.
0:51:48 If it's a big ordinance, we would encourage the council to adopt a summary of that to lessen
0:51:54 that cost as well. So when you're looking at the actual cost of turning that into city
0:51:58 code, it's going to be more staff time driven and legal time driven as opposed to any hard
0:52:06 costs that would be associated with the project. So we don't have to pay sterling to do that.
0:52:10 We can just do it in-house or- We pay sterling a normal routine maintenance agreement on
0:52:16 annual basis as I understand it. Thank you. Any other comments or questions for Kelly?
0:52:25 So, I've in the past been on the commission and I currently serve as the liaison, the council
0:52:35 liaison.
0:52:36 And I just want to know that we, when I was on the commission and even since then, there
0:52:41 have been issues that are maybe a little controversial that don't quite look right or maybe some
0:52:49 steps haven't been taken.
0:52:50 And I've found that the city staff and the commission has been over backwards to not
0:52:57 make it ridiculous for somebody who needs to make a correction.
0:53:01 And so I would like to make a motion if you're ready for that.
0:53:05 I was going to give Nancy- Oh, I'm going to speak to us first, if you wouldn't mind.
0:53:10 I'm done.
0:53:11 In case she had any comments she wanted to give us.
0:53:14 She is on the agenda.
0:53:15 If you don't have anything you want to say Nancy, we can sit in the room.
0:53:21 Mayor, Council, this step is vital to our preserving our historic heritage in this city and it becomes
0:53:31 even more important as downtown redevelopment kicks into gear and we have several historic
0:53:40 or we call them contributing buildings downtown and not so much the city park, that's, we'll
0:53:47 deal with those, but downtown is becoming critical that we keep our eye on what is happening down
0:53:53 there. To address Councilperson Hall, Councilman Hall, this is not a police state. We are certainly
0:54:06 not going to do it, but we're going to keep our eye out. And what what astounds me is when
0:54:16 When things happen like the Rogerson coming down, for instance, oh, Travis, I'd like to
0:54:22 know if you could dig up the basement.
0:54:23 I think I left my cell phone down there.
0:54:30 There's always a funeral.
0:54:32 People are outraged.
0:54:33 How could you do this?
0:54:34 What happened?
0:54:35 Why didn't you save it?
0:54:38 This step becomes critical in our addressing those issues before they happen.
0:54:43 We're proud of our downtown.
0:54:45 We're proud of our city park.
0:54:46 We're proud of our warehouse district and the historic value that it has, and we want to continue that.
0:54:56 Like I said, we're not married to anything, however, we will be watching.
0:55:02 And we want to keep the integrity of our fabulous city.
0:55:06 Historic preservation is good business, and we want to keep that going.
0:55:13 Thank you.
0:55:14 Thank you, Nancy.
0:55:16 Appreciate your comments.
0:55:17 I just make the observations I read through these, while it is a lengthy document and can
0:55:23 feel intimidating if you were thinking about doing development downtown.
0:55:27 When you actually read it, what it's doing is laying out the, if you wanted to maintain
0:55:33 the most integrity of this building that you possibly could, here's how you could do it,
0:55:37 or as you said Kelly, this would be an acceptable option to, or we can do this, or tell us what
0:55:45 you want to do and let's figure out how to get there and I think by having these adopted
0:55:50 as a guideline for developers but also having them codified as a guideline for staff makes
0:55:59 historic preservation an important part of city staff's job to and planning and zoning
0:56:04 and the council as we look at instead of just saying these are the rules and let's apply
0:56:09 the rules how are we applying the rules and how are we trying to get to that end goal so
0:56:14 I certainly would be supportive of that motion and Ruth, if you have a motion, I would certainly
0:56:20 turn it over to you.
0:56:22 I do.
0:56:23 So I would make a motion that we approve the guidelines for the downtown historical district
0:56:28 and the city park historical district and ask staff and the HPC to have those guidelines
0:56:38 codified.
0:56:39 Second.
0:56:41 Motion by Ruth Pierce, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the design guidelines as a reference document and also to codify those guidelines.
0:56:50 Any discussion? Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote, please.
0:56:55 Sean Baraker.
0:56:56 Yes.
0:56:56 Chris Hockington.
0:56:57 Yes.
0:56:58 Greg Lanting.
0:56:59 Yes.
0:56:59 Don Hall.
0:57:00 Yes.
0:57:01 Ruth Pierce.
0:57:01 Yes.
0:57:02 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:57:03 Yes.
0:57:03 Nicki Boyd.
0:57:04 Yes.
0:57:05 Motion passes.
0:57:06 It's seven to zero.
0:57:07 Thank you.
0:57:08 How do you use your work, Don?
0:57:11 And next is a request to review and approve contract terms for PSI 10-year period beginning
0:57:21 October 1, 2016 with terms to become effective on that date.
0:57:25 And we have Bill Baxter, there you are, Bill, I couldn't see you, you were hiding behind
0:57:31 that microphone.
0:57:32 I was getting pretty strong.
0:57:33 Well, that would work.
0:57:35 I'm sorry, I got a little joke.
0:57:36 You stay outside.
0:57:37 This is the guy you're talking.
0:57:38 You'll look like a zipper.
0:57:39 You'll look like that, too, right?
0:57:41 I have.
0:57:42 Well, good evening, Merritt City Council.
0:57:45 I was tempted to say, I'm back.
0:57:48 And I hope that the information provided me a packet.
0:57:51 You find helpful.
0:57:53 We certainly appreciate the guidance you've offered over the last five or so meetings that we've had to try to pin this down.
0:57:59 And before you, you have a presentation hopefully for the 10-year contract with PSI.
0:58:07 I have a few comments.
0:58:09 I've promised several of you not to be one of them that you've heard a lot of this before.
0:58:13 The 10-year term, the big question, it provides incentive for PSI to continue their investments in the community.
0:58:22 It is also time sufficient to develop the smaller cart user options, which we have heard
0:58:28 extremely clearly, is a driving force, not only behind cost issues with the landfill, but
0:58:35 also being better environmental stewards of the community and improving our recycling.
0:58:42 It gives us time to improve acceptance and use of recycling.
0:58:46 I don't think a day goes by when I don't hear the ladies at the counter explaining again
0:58:51 The orange lid is recycling.
0:58:53 You can't put your garbage in there.
0:58:55 That's why PSI didn't collect it.
0:58:59 And PSI is at least as anxious as we are.
0:59:03 I have, I think, four of the staff back here, the local CFO,
0:59:10 the local regional manager, the sales manager,
0:59:13 and the route supervisor.
0:59:15 So we can answer pretty much any questions you have
0:59:17 all to step aside.
0:59:20 Cart sizes, we would currently work with a 35-gallon and 95-gallon customers, every
0:59:28 cart size under this new contract gets a recycling bin.
0:59:32 The one thing that would stay the same with the smaller cart size both now and as we move
0:59:37 forward into entertaining 65-gallon cart size options would be that that is the only garbage
0:59:43 collection you would receive.
0:59:46 than three times a year, spring, fall, and the week after Christmas, PSI will allow additional
0:59:54 garbage to be set next to any cart size service.
0:59:57 So those are the heavy times, those are the times when you just can't use that small cart.
1:00:02 And in order to keep our code enforcement team from being overwhelmed and also to keep the
1:00:07 community in the condition we want, that is a necessity.
1:00:14 We are entertaining in this contract method of handling contaminated recycle part of the
1:00:22 educational process.
1:00:24 Two warnings, then there would be a five dollar fine and the cart would be removed.
1:00:30 It would allow us then to have perhaps a more clear conversation with the resident and hopefully
1:00:36 restore the recycle cart.
1:00:38 But again, it gets into PSI's time and management, our code enforcement team's time and management
1:00:45 to go out there.
1:00:46 So we needed some teeth in that piece.
1:00:51 Let's see.
1:00:52 We will continue large and bulky item collection as defined in the contract terms, spring fall
1:00:59 and Christmas extra bag can allowance, the revenue cost-sharing provision.
1:01:05 Currently, the way the recycling revenues and costs of management transportation and storage work out,
1:01:13 PSI is paying approximately $1 a month for that.
1:01:19 In this contract, beginning with the year ending December of 17, we would begin to discuss
1:01:26 and arrange methods of perhaps sharing that cost with PSI.
1:01:31 would be a discussion item that would take place annually with city management and staff.
1:01:37 But that is in there so that they know that should the marketplace continue as it is, we
1:01:44 would be willing to discuss a sharing opportunity in that cost to keep the program working.
1:01:52 Educational materials and presentations would continue.
1:01:56 Again, the contract with PSI supports three of the strategic plan areas, healthy community,
1:02:04 environmental community, and a responsible community.
1:02:08 That's the education piece that comes in.
1:02:10 And the 10-year timeframe, this has been obviously a focus of a lot of conversation on any number
1:02:16 of contracts I know that Council has dealt with here recently.
1:02:21 PSI's investment in any changes, cart size, recycling available to all people, or in demands
1:02:33 capital investment on their part.
1:02:36 If the recycling becomes more successful, it may require more staff, more trucks, or just
1:02:43 any number of things that in going forward and trying to develop and make this program
1:02:48 more effective and provide the kind of service the city has come to expect.
1:02:53 Their capital investment in car sizes and things is going to require some kind of a commitment
1:03:01 on our part because the five-year term rolls around and disappears real quickly.
1:03:06 The ten-year gives us a better chance to get a handle on the assignments.
1:03:10 And with that, I've warned PSI staff that we would all stand for questions.
1:03:16 Thank you, Bill.
1:03:19 Chris Stockington.
1:03:20 I think PSI has been a most positive influence in our community and both with this new contract
1:03:27 continue leading us to more of a truly recycling community.
1:03:33 I have had some problems with the tenure because we are locking in an area that I think the
1:03:43 Council is overlooking as a legitimate concern, and that's a single can, small can rate.
1:03:51 The retirement demographics in our committee are some of the fastest growing, including
1:03:57 single individuals, and those in fixed income that simply don't put out enough trash to even
1:04:04 fill up a portion of one of the smaller cans.
1:04:07 We have to address it at some time, and if we don't now, the Council decided not to before
1:04:12 locking this up for 10 years without the flexibility to seek new 110 users seems
1:04:22 to be the only loose bearing in this whole contract. I was floated down before in the
1:04:29 thing. I'll vote for it but I will be a constant baggage of garbage. I was going
1:04:36 to try to get this changed somehow to make more sense toward as little garbage curve size
1:04:44 as possible and as much recycled as possible.
1:04:48 Thank you.
1:04:49 So Bill, can I follow up on that?
1:04:51 So on the first page of the contract, it talks about this pilot program to develop a strategy
1:04:57 and method for expanding smaller card sizes.
1:05:00 That is the single-can concept that there would be a development of a strategy.
1:05:06 and correlating prices, I assume, would come back to the council to say, this is the proposal.
1:05:15 That is correct. The pilot program has been considered and would have to be strategized a little bit.
1:05:24 PSI know has been working on this. They're doing their cart on it right now.
1:05:29 But the idea being, because the message from council has been very clear,
1:05:34 We need to figure out how we would approach allowing people to choose a smaller cart size,
1:05:42 not limited by income level or age group, so that it would be a broadly available option.
1:05:51 The biggest issue we run into is the cost of the cart is a minimal piece of the proposal
1:06:00 of the service.
1:06:02 The big cost is the truck, the driver, unloading at the landfill, the transfer station, and
1:06:10 that puts us in the position of if we have a certain size increase in the percentage of
1:06:17 the population using the smaller carts, we still have the fixed cost of the service annually
1:06:22 to pay.
1:06:24 It does not mean the door is closed on options, but anything that would keep the smaller cart
1:06:31 size lower for any group of the population, we would have to come up with some way to
1:06:38 price the other service to continue to get us to paying the fixed costs for the month.
1:06:44 Well, the 10-year contractors were actually no incentive to look for those.
1:06:49 Oh, I think the incentive is there.
1:06:51 We want to increase the recycle.
1:06:52 And we want to provide a service that the population really wants and needs.
1:06:58 We certainly don't want to keep hauling all kinds of extra garbage to the landfill.
1:07:03 And the incentive that is there, I think, is to provide the better service so that the
1:07:13 population, this community, is happy with the service being delivered.
1:07:18 The pricing becomes an issue, but I don't know that that door is closed.
1:07:23 We just would have to figure out how to pay the cost.
1:07:26 If we all went to 35 gallon carts right now, we still have roughly $144,000 to pay for.
1:07:36 And that isn't because of the weight of the garbage, it's because mostly of the time it
1:07:40 takes to drive the routes and pick it up.
1:07:43 But I don't believe that I have heard nothing in PSI's approach to this that says we can't
1:07:51 to talk about different options for pricing the service.
1:07:54 It just is we can't get a smaller cart
1:07:57 and lower the overall cost of service.
1:08:02 So, and I know we have a couple of other lights
1:08:03 but I'm still on this topic here.
1:08:05 So.
1:08:07 And I can.
1:08:08 So, yeah, and so I appreciate the willingness
1:08:13 to develop a pilot program.
1:08:15 The thing that I hesitate with,
1:08:17 and it's a bit to Councilman Talkington's comment,
1:08:20 in a 10 year contract with no date
1:08:22 by which you're going to have a pilot program developed
1:08:25 for consideration, is that at year 9.8,
1:08:31 you decide that you might have a pilot program.
1:08:33 So I throw it out as a could or should there be
1:08:38 some date in the next six months, nine months,
1:08:43 four months, I don't know how long it takes
1:08:45 to develop a concept to bring back to the council.
1:08:48 Again, understanding that there's a lot of noodling
1:08:52 I think you can answer that question outside of the contract so we have a contract the contract
1:09:04 is going to say these are the duties that we accept to be performed at that same point
1:09:08 in time you can instruct staff that you want to have a pilot program and the result of that
1:09:13 program presented to you and I would turn to Jeff and the other members of the PSI team
1:09:18 on what is the proper length of that duration.
1:09:21 I think that would be outside of city staff scope
1:09:24 and understanding to set a timeframe
1:09:26 without understanding the broader implications of the process
1:09:30 that they need to go through to set that up.
1:09:35 I would also, Jeff, right here.
1:09:39 I'm right behind you, sir. Welcome, Jeff.
1:09:42 Good evening, Mr. Mayor and members of the Council,
1:09:44 Jeff, for sure, PSI and environmental services.
1:09:47 And yeah, I mean to answer that question it's even the contract regardless of it's five
1:09:52 years or ten years does not stop us from doing different projects or altering the way to be
1:09:58 serviced at the community right now.
1:10:00 So those things can always be played out as it goes along at any time.
1:10:04 So I agree there should be a timeline on when that pilot program should go in place.
1:10:09 Maybe we should say nine months from now we should have something in front of you and
1:10:14 at least rolling that out within the first twelve months.
1:10:16 So just to see how it plays out, and then we can go from there and see how the program
1:10:21 would work and benefit the community and the low volume users.
1:10:24 That's really what we're trying to accomplish here is to help those folks.
1:10:30 I like nine months.
1:10:31 That's a nice round to it.
1:10:34 Thank you, Chair.
1:10:35 A nice commitment to it.
1:10:38 Great landing.
1:10:40 Well then, actually, maybe if you're here to reach this.
1:10:44 I've had people ask about what is the process, let's say they're taking over a piece of property
1:10:52 that needs to clean out or they have a state type situation occurring and they need more
1:11:01 and they don't want to pile up back after bag after baging the curb.
1:11:05 What is the cost for a, let's say a small dumpster to be brought in and how does that work?
1:11:11 You pay by the month, you pay by the time it's dumped, how does that work?
1:11:14 Actually the way that the contract is currently written, it actually allows for
1:11:19 some of those hardship cases where we can come in, work with the city staff and
1:11:23 just clean up that entire area. We'd either bring in a roll-off truck or a
1:11:27 reload truck and clean up that material at that time. So there is so many of those
1:11:32 loud and then there's also other hardship or not necessarily hardship cases, but
1:11:36 cases where people would have very large volumes and we would make the city staff clean that up too for a normal fee.
1:11:43 Okay, thank you.
1:11:45 Ruth Beifs.
1:11:47 So being the newbie here and learning contracts and all that related to the city, I think the two questions that have come to me are the tenure
1:11:57 versus five and I think you explained it from a capital standpoint in helping keep the cost down for this city citizens.
1:12:05 citizens, and then secondly is this smaller container because there are a lot of elderly
1:12:14 people that really don't even need to take their garbage out every week. And so I might
1:12:20 be one of those included too. But so it would be worthwhile to have some other avenues. And
1:12:27 then I think the education on the recycling, I got to thinking it might be a really good school
1:12:35 project to come up with these signs that you can hang around town that would show what
1:12:42 you couldn't do.
1:12:43 And actually a lot of elementary schools we feel like those younger folks in our population
1:12:53 take that message home better than anybody else could or better than the flyer we've
1:12:57 done some flyers at some of our functions like truck and trade and we participated in
1:13:02 and stuff like that, we're also going to be involved
1:13:05 in the great alliance this weekend,
1:13:07 and we'll also hand out some flyers.
1:13:08 We do try to get that message out,
1:13:10 but I don't think anything works better
1:13:11 than your own children coming home.
1:13:14 Oh, it nagging me.
1:13:16 Okay, thank you.
1:13:18 Thank you, Jeff.
1:13:26 Council wishes, I would say that the motion we're looking
1:13:30 for is to approve the contract to authorize
1:13:32 the mayor sign it.
1:13:34 So moved.
1:13:37 Second.
1:13:39 Motion by a great landing second
1:13:40 by Nikki Boyd to approve the contract as presented
1:13:44 and authorize the mayor to sign it.
1:13:46 Chris Stockington.
1:13:47 I would like to make an amendment that the DSI report back
1:13:51 to the council no later than nine months from now
1:13:54 on options to explore the, what do we want to call
1:13:58 reduced usage minimum usage.
1:14:01 Sit in the Senate can usage.
1:14:03 Low volume usage for.
1:14:05 This is not an obligation except to see what you think
1:14:08 There's some ideas for us to pursue.
1:14:11 The maker of the motion will accept that amendment
1:14:13 without it having to be separated the second will.
1:14:15 Yes, I will.
1:14:16 Let's make it part of the general motion.
1:14:19 OK.
1:14:21 Keeps it coming, I said that.
1:14:23 It'll work.
1:14:25 So I'm going to say that would be by August 31, 2016.
1:14:29 That being?
1:14:30 That's a few days.
1:14:32 Give them two days.
1:14:35 OK.
1:14:36 All right, any further discussion on the motion?
1:14:40 Seeing none. Chair and roll call vote please.
1:14:44 Chris Hockington.
1:14:45 Yes.
1:14:46 Greg Lanting.
1:14:47 Yes.
1:14:47 Don Hall.
1:14:48 Yes.
1:14:49 Ruth Pierce.
1:14:50 Yes.
1:14:51 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:14:52 Yes.
1:14:53 Nicky Boyd.
1:14:54 Yes.
1:14:55 Sean Beriker.
1:14:56 Yes.
1:14:58 Motion passes.
1:14:59 70.
1:15:00 0.
1:15:01 Jeff, thanks to you and your team for your patience and working through all of this and
1:15:02 bill to you and your team as well.
1:15:04 Thank you very much.
1:15:10 And next on the agenda is a request to authorize city staff to move forward with refunding
1:15:15 the 2009 bond issuance, and we have our Chief Financial Officer, Lori Race.
1:15:19 Welcome, Lori.
1:15:20 Hey, good evening.
1:15:22 So tonight, I'm asking for your authorization to allow the city to move forward with refunding
1:15:28 our 2009 bond issuance in the Water Fund, and this includes authorizing a $500 application
1:15:36 fee to the Idaho Bond Bank.
1:15:39 So the city issued $10,255,000 worth of debt through the Idaho bond bank to purchase pristine
1:15:47 springs water rights back in mid 2009.
1:15:51 These bonds were for a 15-year period and they were scheduled to be paid off September 15th,
1:15:57 2024.
1:15:58 However, based on current interest rates, we could be looking at a net savings of approximately
1:16:05 $300,000.
1:16:08 And while this is down from the original estimate of about 400,000, we could still realize the
1:16:15 net savings by doing this refunding now.
1:16:19 The idea would be to team up with several other entities that are looking at issuing debt through
1:16:23 the bond bank.
1:16:25 And the city and the rate payers would benefit from lower interest rates than the shared cost
1:16:29 of issuance.
1:16:31 We would not be extending the term of this debt.
1:16:35 And also, if rate changes to the point that it doesn't make financial sense to proceed,
1:16:41 then we'll stop the process.
1:16:43 Tonight, Christian Anderson and Jonathan Ward, with Science Bank, are here to present information
1:16:48 on this potential refunding.
1:16:50 So I'll turn the rest of the time over to them and then be available to answer questions.
1:16:55 Christian?
1:16:56 Thank you, Laurie.
1:16:59 Welcome, Christian.
1:17:00 Thank you.
1:17:01 Anderson from Zion's public finance and actually brought some paper copies here in case you wanted to take any notes on them.
1:17:10 Thank you.
1:17:16 Alright, just for any members of the council who don't know, Zion's has for the last few years acted as the city's municipal advisor.
1:17:29 We've worked with you on the last few bond issues in that role.
1:17:32 We've made a fiduciary duty to the city.
1:17:35 you're actually on your side of the table in any financial debt transaction that you enter into.
1:17:40 So we're specific to debt and bonds.
1:17:43 You have Michael Tippett's up there, he's typically with me, working with me here in Idaho, both of us in Boise.
1:17:51 But I do have a stand in tonight, my colleague Jonathan Ward.
1:17:56 So just to give you some background on what you have outstanding for your water system,
1:18:00 There are three outstanding bonds that first, as Lori described, the 2009,
1:18:05 a little over 6 million outstanding, just a little less than that, that's callable.
1:18:11 The amount that is callable is 5.395 million.
1:18:16 Final maturity in 2024, we're not planning to extend that in any way.
1:18:20 And that can be refinanced for savings.
1:18:22 You also have your 2010 water revenue bond, 12.4 million outstanding.
1:18:28 Final maturity in 2025.
1:18:30 And this is what's called a Build America Bond.
1:18:32 So this is a unique bond where you actually
1:18:35 issued bonds at taxable interest rates.
1:18:38 But you receive a federal subsidy each year,
1:18:42 equal to 35% of your interest expense.
1:18:45 Now, given some of the cuts at the federal level,
1:18:48 the sequester, you will receive a little bit less than that 35%.
1:18:52 You are still receiving a subsidy on that.
1:18:54 And these are not something that you most likely would not
1:18:58 be looking to refinance these until the actual call date, which is in 2020, if at all, as
1:19:05 it would require you to give up the subsidy.
1:19:07 The last is the 2012 Water Revenue Refunding Bond.
1:19:11 So this was a refunding of a different bond, 1.935 million outstanding, final maturity in
1:19:18 2022.
1:19:19 These cannot be refinanced, I believe, until the call date, which is 2022.
1:19:24 So they will likely stay until maturity.
1:19:28 So this is an analysis of the city's water system coverage, and I'll tell you the reason,
1:19:36 show you what you have here and then why I've included it.
1:19:38 So what this does is simply take the revenues of the system, the operating revenues, deduct
1:19:42 the operating expenses.
1:19:44 So supplies, payroll, utilities, things like that.
1:19:49 Add back into appreciation is that's not a cash expense, and you get a net revenue available
1:19:54 for debt service.
1:19:55 money is available after we've paid all the bills, paid all the employees, how much cash
1:20:00 is left over to pay our bond payments.
1:20:04 Dividing that by the amount of your annual bond payments gives you a coverage ratio.
1:20:08 So for 2013 you can see 1.83.
1:20:11 That means with the revenue you were bringing in, less the expenses that were applicable,
1:20:17 you could have made your debt payments 1.83 times.
1:20:21 So the minimum standard here is 1.25.
1:20:24 The reason I show this is that the Bond Bank, if you are showing coverage in excess of 1.5,
1:20:30 they waive the requirement for a reserve fund.
1:20:33 They did that for you in 2009, and they should do that again here, which helps to save you some money.
1:20:39 And for the Bond Bank's purposes, I've actually excluded your bill to America Bond subsidy here to be more conservative.
1:20:46 If in the unlikely event that for some reason the subsidy was taken away altogether, you still have a strong coverage situation.
1:20:54 above the one point, one and a quarter.
1:20:56 This is assuming no subsidy at all.
1:20:59 So in reality, your coverage is even higher
1:21:01 because of those federal subsidies.
1:21:04 So this is a chart just showing that water debt combined.
1:21:08 The purple at the bottom is the 2010.
1:21:11 The blue is the 2012.
1:21:13 And then the red is what we're projecting
1:21:15 to be the new 2017, replacing the 2009.
1:21:20 Then the white space at the top, you can see the dark outline
1:21:24 is your current payment combined, all of them together,
1:21:27 the white space is the savings.
1:21:29 So relative to the overall picture here,
1:21:32 it's not a huge number, but that does that up
1:21:34 to a good contribution to other expenses that you have
1:21:39 to save that 300,000.
1:21:45 So in summary, moderate savings, we hope for more.
1:21:50 Unfortunately, we've just seen the world turn upside down
1:21:53 a bit in the last few weeks.
1:21:55 and we're in a very different interest rate environment.
1:21:57 I'll show you that specifically on the next slide.
1:22:00 But in present value terms,
1:22:02 taking that annual savings and discounting it back
1:22:05 to today's dollars, it's worth about 300,000.
1:22:09 The actual cash flow savings, 321, not discounting that back,
1:22:15 works out to about 40,000 per year.
1:22:17 As an extra option, the city could increase savings
1:22:20 a little bit by simply maintaining your existing payment.
1:22:24 So we lower the rate, but you pay the same amount,
1:22:27 you just pay it off more quickly.
1:22:29 That adds about 30,000.
1:22:31 There's not enough room there to cut a year off,
1:22:33 but it does take that final payment down by about half.
1:22:37 So that's an option to the council.
1:22:38 The council doesn't need to choose that right now.
1:22:41 We can figure that out later.
1:22:46 And that's the maturity of when?
1:22:48 The same as now 2024.
1:22:50 Okay.
1:22:53 So as far as the steps tonight,
1:22:55 We're asking the council to give direction to proceed and authorize the $500 fee to the bond bank.
1:23:00 Zion's has already prepared an application for this.
1:23:03 It's due later this week.
1:23:06 So we'll submit that to the Idaho bond bank.
1:23:08 The bond bank board will meet in mid-December to approve applications.
1:23:12 We would expect to just have Lori on the phone for that, don't anticipate any issues in getting that through.
1:23:19 We are actually refinancing an existing bond bank loan, so
1:23:23 They shouldn't have any concerns with how much twin false debt they have on their books,
1:23:28 which you happen to have the most, by the way.
1:23:31 So if you were coming with new debt, we probably want to bring a few people.
1:23:34 But in this case, they shouldn't have a problem with it.
1:23:38 In January and February, we'd be working through the process of preparing those bonds.
1:23:42 So as Lori mentioned, if the market turns further, I don't anticipate that happening.
1:23:47 But if something unexpected happens, another Brexit, a Greg's it, or a Brexit, the changes
1:23:54 things perhaps, the moves rates up, Brexit went down, so it wouldn't be so bad, I guess.
1:24:00 But if something happened that moved rates up substantially, the city can walk away.
1:24:05 But during that time, January and February, we worked with the city bond council, with the
1:24:09 bond bank city staff to prepare all the necessary loan agreements, offering documents, and so
1:24:16 on.
1:24:17 to sell bonds about mid-February and close at the end of that month or early March.
1:24:21 Chris, Chris, talk about that.
1:24:24 I understand the Fed's looking at potential here.
1:24:29 The odds are now rate increases at December 18th, but you kind of downplay does not like
1:24:36 me to happen, but he isn't Zions pretty much forecasting with other financials that there
1:24:42 will be that rate high.
1:24:43 Mayor Council, the savings projections that are in here are based on the prevailing rate
1:24:48 forecasts for second quarter, actually, of 2017, so we've baked a little bit of cushion
1:24:54 in there already, and that's already baking in an assumption of the Fed moving.
1:25:00 That doesn't always translate to higher rates when the Fed made its move.
1:25:05 Last, rates went down from there.
1:25:07 It's tied to a lot of other economic factors.
1:25:11 the market is fully nearly 100% expecting that to happen.
1:25:16 So it's already.
1:25:18 The long term rates are heading the other way, though.
1:25:21 Heading up.
1:25:22 Yeah.
1:25:23 Yeah, and I'll show you that here.
1:25:24 Your banks can't afford not to have more rate increases.
1:25:27 I mean, that's how you make your money.
1:25:29 There may be short term gyrations,
1:25:31 the long term there's going to be a change
1:25:34 from the current environment.
1:25:36 Yeah, rates are changing.
1:25:37 And, unfortunately, in this case, just to clarify,
1:25:40 the bank, science doesn't buy your bonds.
1:25:43 We act as your representative in providing you access
1:25:46 to the bond market.
1:25:48 So the bond bank bundles together.
1:25:50 We're looking at now nine or 10 different participants
1:25:53 who have different loans for different purposes.
1:25:56 Bundle those together and sell bonds to the open market
1:26:00 under the name of the Idaho Bond Bank Authority
1:26:02 and then make a loan to the city for your piece of that.
1:26:05 And so these would be sold in the open market.
1:26:09 This is what's called the Bonfire Index.
1:26:11 Think of this as kind of like the Dow Jones of the bond market.
1:26:14 Give you a snapshot view of where they've been.
1:26:17 Go back pretty far here.
1:26:18 You can be thankful we don't have the interest rates of the 80s,
1:26:21 if you're borrowing.
1:26:22 I guess great if you're saving.
1:26:24 But we're back to 1988 on the left.
1:26:27 And on the far right, you can see where we are.
1:26:29 So historically speaking, we're still at low interest rates.
1:26:34 not quite as low as a month and a half ago.
1:26:36 You see the bottom there.
1:26:38 We have seen quite a spike in the last few weeks,
1:26:40 but we are basing this on the savings estimates
1:26:43 on projections for further out.
1:26:45 So if we could do this today, the savings would be higher,
1:26:49 but the process requires weeks.
1:26:52 So getting through this process,
1:26:54 we're forecasting out till spring.
1:26:58 Don Hall?
1:26:59 If there are no further questions, I'm ready for a motion.
1:27:02 Did you have anything further for us, Christian?
1:27:04 I don't.
1:27:05 All right.
1:27:06 Thank you.
1:27:07 So help me out.
1:27:08 Make sure that I say this right.
1:27:09 I move that we proceed with the refunding of the two thousand non bond issuance and authorize
1:27:13 the five hundred dollar fee to the bond bank.
1:27:16 Is that close?
1:27:18 Second.
1:27:19 I feel good.
1:27:20 Motion by Don Hall seconded by Ruth Pierce.
1:27:22 Is there any discussion from Council?
1:27:25 Seeing none.
1:27:27 Chair and roll call vote please.
1:27:34 I'm Greg Lanting.
1:27:35 Yes.
1:27:36 Don Hall.
1:27:37 Yes.
1:27:38 Ruth Pierce.
1:27:39 Suzanne Hawkins, Nikki Boyd, Sean Bericher, Chris Talking.
1:27:45 Yes.
1:27:47 I think it passes seven to zero.
1:27:50 John, did you have a further comment?
1:27:51 Yeah, I did.
1:27:51 I just want to say we really appreciate our relationship with Zion.
1:27:55 I really appreciate city staff and their innovative and forward looking processes that they put
1:28:03 in place on our finances that you've done this couple times that I've since I've been up here
1:28:09 where we've been able to go back and save our taxpayer money.
1:28:12 So, thank you very much.
1:28:13 We'll be back in January with an actual resolution with a podcast.
1:28:19 Thank you.
1:28:20 Great planting.
1:28:21 Well, I would kind of like to echo Don's comment.
1:28:23 So they were science bank was instrumentally in helping us to get the sewer or the wastewater
1:28:32 treatment plant bond and the questions.
1:28:35 They had somebody here at every meeting of the group that
1:28:40 meant to try to help decide what direction it would be.
1:28:44 And without their expert explanations of things,
1:28:48 the group might not have decided to do that direction.
1:28:50 They probably still would have.
1:28:51 But it certainly helped, especially
1:28:55 to figure out that no, they aren't buying the bonds.
1:28:58 They're just helping us to sell them.
1:29:00 I think that people could lead them through the process,
1:29:03 especially where that one where we bundled
1:29:05 some existing ones and utilize that lower interest rates.
1:29:08 So they've been a great part.
1:29:10 Thank you.
1:29:11 Thank you.
1:29:12 Thank you.
1:29:15 I can do that.
1:29:16 I'm going to go ahead and move to the next agenda item,
1:29:18 and then I'll sign these.
1:29:19 So next on the agenda, we have a consideration of a request
1:29:22 by Star Corporation to present a proposed guaranteed
1:29:24 maximum price GMP for the City Hall Project, Mitch Humbler.
1:29:29 We won't get back to those events.
1:29:33 All right, thanks.
1:29:35 So we've done this a few times with our GMP awards,
1:29:38 So this should be old hat by now, right?
1:29:41 A few weeks ago, we opened our open bids
1:29:44 for the City Hall project.
1:29:46 I know that it's been sitting there
1:29:48 without a whole lot going on for some months.
1:29:50 Now we've been getting some questions about
1:29:53 what's happening with progress.
1:29:54 And well, tonight we're going to make some progress.
1:29:58 So we're going to ask you to approve the GMP and happily.
1:30:05 I'm able to stand here and say we've
1:30:07 come in under budget.
1:30:10 So the GMP that were, we had 23 bid packages
1:30:15 that we were looking for bonds for.
1:30:17 And one of those we didn't get a bid for.
1:30:21 And so keep saying bonds, hold the last conversation.
1:30:25 I said like three times.
1:30:27 One of them we didn't get a bid for.
1:30:29 And that's for the sun shading on the outside of the windows.
1:30:32 If you all remember the corner of the building
1:30:33 has these windows, and we've got these vertical sunshades.
1:30:35 And we didn't quite get a bid for that.
1:30:38 So we're going to go back and try and figure that one out.
1:30:40 So this GMP is minus that one area.
1:30:45 But the total cost, hoping that maybe one of you guys
1:30:53 can read that because I can't.
1:30:55 But I've got mind handy right here.
1:30:56 So the total GMP cost on this is $5,733,566.
1:31:04 That number at the bottom of the page.
1:31:06 Now that also includes the demolition amount
1:31:10 of $261,000 and that amount has already been awarded and spent.
1:31:15 So this balance is $5,472,000, 531.
1:31:19 And that's the amount that we're looking for you to award tonight.
1:31:25 I can tell you that these bid process was all done above,
1:31:29 you know, in good importance with the law.
1:31:31 We got all kinds of public bidding.
1:31:33 In some cases, we went back out because we were quite comfortable
1:31:37 with the numbers we got and we got a few, you know, we re-bid a couple of these bid packages,
1:31:41 but in the end we're down there at the $5 million for $170,000 and we just ask for your approval
1:31:49 tonight of that number. And I can answer questions if you want. Travis has got some
1:31:54 knowledge, you can answer some questions. We also got our team back here with Hummel and
1:31:57 Starorp and those guys can answer some of your questions too if you have any.
1:32:02 Thank you, Mitch. Don't help. Mitch, you said that we were under budget. We see where we're
1:32:06 about what were we going to be and how much under budget are we and how much of
1:32:13 the sunshade will will eat up that under budget piece and I still want to build
1:32:25 that second story well that's a different discussion okay so from the
1:32:34 numbers that we presented in September the number that we're presenting to you
1:32:37 today is $40,000 under the budget that we presented at that time.
1:32:43 The sunshades, there's all manner of ways to protect the building against the sun there.
1:32:50 At one time, there had been sunshades that contemplated that were pushing $100,000.
1:32:55 There's also strategies that will shade the building for less than that.
1:33:00 This is one item, that's one of the reasons why you've seen us before when we didn't get
1:33:04 we go back out and we push for a rebid.
1:33:07 The reason that we didn't do that on this specific item
1:33:10 is because there's been a pause of exactly the strategy to take
1:33:15 with how the building will look from the outside with these sunshades.
1:33:18 And so with that revisiting that strategy, we paused on that.
1:33:21 We didn't go push for a rebid on that.
1:33:25 It didn't even push really hard during the bidding process for bids
1:33:29 on that package specifically because we were reconsidering
1:33:33 reconsidering how we would go about that. So this this is 40,000 under and now we know exactly what
1:33:41 the sunship budget needs to be out of. So we never mind. Thank you Michael. Any other questions for
1:33:54 Michael or Mitch or Clantor anyone? Greg Lanting. I'd like whoever said that that's one of the
1:34:04 the first of the questions they've been getting most of.
1:34:06 I can't walk downtown with it yet, that question.
1:34:09 So when we're going to get started,
1:34:11 I'd travel so I'd be glad when we have workmen in there
1:34:15 and put a big this screen over the whole thing.
1:34:17 So everybody stays warm and get going.
1:34:21 We'll try not to spend your cold weather dollars
1:34:24 by keeping the workmen warm.
1:34:25 We encourage them to move to keep on them,
1:34:28 but we're anxious to get going as well.
1:34:31 And yeah, my standard response on that,
1:34:32 when someone sees a bear lot or an empty building is,
1:34:35 When are you going to start?
1:34:36 There's a lot of work happening.
1:34:38 You just can't see it right now.
1:34:39 But we're about to move to that exciting phase
1:34:42 when people can see it.
1:34:43 And it's wonderful that you're getting
1:34:45 so many questions because people are excited
1:34:47 and we aren't too.
1:34:49 Chris talking to me.
1:34:50 I think you've been indicated that all your subcomponents
1:34:53 have already been completely bid on
1:34:55 or you're still in transition on a couple of them.
1:34:59 No, we've received bids on.
1:35:01 OK, so these are pretty firm.
1:35:02 That's correct.
1:35:03 And is this 40,000 savings reflecting commodity prices going
1:35:09 our way that we didn't expect or a sharp pencil or what?
1:35:15 I can only use the reference of FedEx out of the airport.
1:35:18 They had a significant decrease in their big eye
1:35:21 beaming that really put them on the positive side
1:35:25 of the ledger.
1:35:26 And I don't know how much metal we're using here,
1:35:28 but I would hope we'd have all commodities moving our way
1:35:33 still.
1:35:34 Well, I would hope for that as well.
1:35:37 I think the bidding climate, I think we saw some of the
1:35:40 strategies you were called to cool off on when our bid date
1:35:44 was going to be on this and to back it off a little end of
1:35:46 the fall, that was intentional to get out of that hectic
1:35:51 summer climate that we experienced.
1:35:53 I've been back to you a number of times, but under,
1:35:56 we did advise you bid or award this portion, and we
1:35:59 rebid that, and so there was a strategy here to kick that out,
1:36:01 and I think that that's what helped us stay on.
1:36:04 But we're not at risk anyway, for instance, the electrical system that has all the labor component
1:36:11 built in and the better is a risk on that.
1:36:14 That's correct. As soon as you prove this, we'll execute a contract and we will be at risk at that point.
1:36:21 We'll execute those contracts with the subcontractors and spread that around a little bit.
1:36:27 And you don't need to worry about escalation of copper anymore.
1:36:31 So if the long as they're not using aluminum wire.
1:36:35 No copper.
1:36:37 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:36:39 Are you ready for a motion?
1:36:40 I am ready for a motion.
1:36:42 All right.
1:36:43 I would like to move that we accept the maximum guaranteed price for the City Hall project to
1:36:49 be five million seven hundred thirty three thousand five hundred sixty six including the demolition
1:36:56 work that has already been done.
1:37:01 second that motion by Suzanne Hawkins seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the
1:37:08 presented guaranteed maximum price for the City Hall project is there any
1:37:13 discussion seeing none Sharon we'll call both please Don Hall yes Ruth Pierce yes
1:37:24 Suzanne Hawkins yes Nikki Boyd yes Sean Beriker yes Chris Hockington yes
1:37:31 Reg Lanting yes passes 7 to 0 Don Hall this little bit nostalgic for me because
1:37:39 I am the one that signed the check for buying the building because I was the
1:37:42 mayor of the time and then this is probably the last big ticket vote that I
1:37:47 will be able to make sitting up on this dias and I'm excited I'm sure you want to
1:37:52 come back and design the sun shades I might come back and do that won't be over
1:37:57 $40,000.
1:37:58 No.
1:37:59 Try this around while it.
1:38:02 So what's important is, and I just verified this with Clint, is that when you look at the
1:38:07 $40,000 under budget, it also includes the $169,000 that we have earmarked for contingency.
1:38:15 So when you look at the contingency that is in that maximum guaranteed price, there
1:38:20 is enough, you know, we're still projecting that to be not only the $40,000 under budget,
1:38:26 but also it gives us $160,000 of room for those unexpected things in addition to shade
1:38:35 subject.
1:38:36 Thank you, Michael.
1:38:48 Next on the agenda is City Council discussion of the applicant seeking appointment for the
1:38:52 Twin Falls City Council seat.
1:38:56 So a couple of weeks ago we had the opportunity to hear from 14 applicants who have expressed
1:39:02 interest in the upcoming vacancy on the City Council,
1:39:06 that I will appoint and then have the concurrence
1:39:09 of the Council.
1:39:10 So last week we had a fair number of Council members
1:39:13 who weren't with us, so we thought we'd wait
1:39:15 till this week when we were all here.
1:39:17 And I would look forward to hearing input from you all
1:39:22 on your perspectives on those,
1:39:26 this input for me as I hopefully will be able
1:39:29 to bring back a recommendation next week for consideration.
1:39:34 Greg Lanting.
1:39:35 I had a question, Mayor, were you expecting us
1:39:38 to list the type of things that we're looking for?
1:39:41 Or are you actually wanting us to be brave enough
1:39:44 to say people's names?
1:39:45 Well, you know, this is a little bit of a new adventure
1:39:49 for all of us doing this in an open council meeting.
1:39:53 So I would, whatever you feel, input would be helpful
1:39:56 in helping me make that decision.
1:39:59 Chris Stockington.
1:40:00 question for Fritz, given our transparency, I know none of us want to violate the premise
1:40:10 of making decisions behind executive doors. But if there is information on any of the
1:40:17 candidates that may be not necessary for the public to know, could even be construed as
1:40:27 harmful or threatening or
1:40:29 Surprising is there no way that we can justify an executive session
1:40:35 As long as the decision does not meet in the meeting. I don't think there's any way to do that because you will be deliberating
1:40:44 Including receiving information on a vote that you'll have to take in a public session
1:40:50 so
1:40:52 public
1:40:53 meetings law that is deliberation and unless there's an
1:40:57 a specific exception for executive session. It has to be in an open session.
1:41:01 Okay. I am not surprised I should answer, but thank you. Christian, do you have something
1:41:09 further? Great landing. I'll jump in first. What the? Sorry, I didn't mean that. We
1:41:18 you're bored. I'm not going to start skating. I when I wrote I I ranked the candidates and I
1:41:28 did pluses, minuses as we were listening to them. Of course, some of them already knew and some of
1:41:35 them I didn't know. I tried to take that already knew part out a little bit. It's impossible to
1:41:41 do that. But I tried and I did pluses and minuses on my sheet. And then I after I got done with
1:41:48 my pluses and minuses, I ranked them.
1:41:51 I ranked them one through 14.
1:41:53 Got a little tough down there, mid to lower.
1:41:56 It truly doesn't mean there's a lot of good candidates
1:41:58 there really was.
1:42:01 But in my own mind, the criteria I used,
1:42:04 I think is still the same criteria
1:42:07 that I would use if I was voting for a city council member.
1:42:11 If I'm others, if there's three candidates running for a seat,
1:42:16 whatever, whichever seat it is, my seat, let's say, seat five.
1:42:20 And how would I vote?
1:42:23 What things would I look at to vote for them and to choose them?
1:42:29 And then I tried to bring that back
1:42:33 and what I would utilize for an appointment,
1:42:37 or a recommendation to the mayor for an appointment.
1:42:42 And this excludes a few people, but it's my own personal thought.
1:42:47 on what I will look at when I'm voting for somebody.
1:42:51 One would be the length of time in the community has some effect to me,
1:42:58 because that makes them more of a known commodity to me.
1:43:02 And so I put an arbitrary time of five years here, and it might be ten years,
1:43:07 I don't know, but I put five years here that if they've been to community five years,
1:43:11 then I think they've had an opportunity to learn about our community,
1:43:16 We have the flavor of our community, and that would be a representative of our community.
1:43:24 I also put some, and these aren't in any particular order, I just have a item down here two minutes
1:43:29 ago.
1:43:30 I had a nice big list, I had a list ready for the last week, and I couldn't find it to bring
1:43:33 any answer.
1:43:34 This is a shorter list than I did in the last couple of minutes.
1:43:38 My next one was people who have ran previously, that makes an effect for me, especially on
1:43:44 appointment. I guarantee you that putting your name out there on a ballot and have a
1:43:50 chance to lose is big because all of us who have done that and we've all done that up
1:43:56 here, nobody wants to lose and so you put your name on a ballot and let people vote on
1:44:01 you and see whether you're going to win. I've been lucky enough and I would like to think
1:44:08 worked hard enough and represented the people to be elected three times.
1:44:15 And I think that's important.
1:44:16 I put my name out there to run, and so I think that's an important thing.
1:44:21 Just as important, obviously, is active in the community.
1:44:25 And that can be anything from service organizations to church to whatever it may be that makes
1:44:31 you a member of this community and makes you people know who you are and you are helping
1:44:38 people and to make Twin Falls a great place and I think that's what those
1:44:42 organizations do. I think that's what churches do. I think all of those things
1:44:45 are important. I also think it's as we've seen people here tonight that have served
1:44:50 this active in our city commissions and boards. I think that's an important
1:44:55 thing and there were a lot of people on that list that were that were active in
1:45:00 those those situations of I think in the main two which Urban Renewal and Planning
1:45:06 zoning, but there's certainly others. Nancy was here for her, the story
1:45:12 preservation, which I think is another important one, partial rec is an important
1:45:16 one. Airport boards an important one. All those, all those are making Twin Falls a
1:45:24 great place and helping provide information to us so we can make a
1:45:27 better decision on things that have my very seldom vote against what one of
1:45:31 those commissions or boards put forth because they probably have more time to
1:45:35 to actually get in the weeds and see what particular issue was.
1:45:40 That doesn't mean we haven't turned over position things
1:45:43 that by these don't eat said.
1:45:45 But it's probably very often, man.
1:45:48 And I don't know if this last one is kind of nebulous,
1:45:53 but do I think I could work with it, okay?
1:45:56 And that's important.
1:45:57 It really is.
1:45:58 I mean, I've been on here just right almost 11 years,
1:46:02 and that's important.
1:46:04 It truly is to have people on the board on the City Council that you feel that you can
1:46:12 move forward with and make it work.
1:46:16 And there's probably other things that I considered in my mind that night.
1:46:20 That's the ones that came forth to me.
1:46:22 And Mayor, I would like you to see that I would hope that you would consider those particular
1:46:28 things in your choice.
1:46:29 Thank you.
1:46:31 Great.
1:46:32 Chris taught you too.
1:46:33 So when I handed out the sheet a couple weeks ago that I think most of you used, I used her
1:46:38 past experience of trying to write down some very specific guidelines.
1:46:45 There's not a lot of room there, but I figured this is a way.
1:46:49 I've suggested in times past reading everybody on various skills, one to ten, and some people
1:46:54 like that, some didn't, but trying to quantify and simplify the assets of this qualified group
1:47:02 of people that have applied and are very pleasantly surprised with the broad spectrum
1:47:09 of people that can help us fulfill our mission.
1:47:13 There are four criteria, however, that I used in coming to grips with how to narrow the
1:47:20 field a little bit and how difficult it is down to about the top four.
1:47:25 I like to have people that have had experience with city issues.
1:47:30 I personally don't care if they've been here a year or 20 years, some people get in right
1:47:35 away and do things because that's their nature and they like municipal government.
1:47:41 But if you have had experienced everything in your workplace working with others, comp
1:47:48 plan zoning, that sort of a thing, I think it gives you a little better, broader perspective
1:47:55 on some of the issues that our business here at City Government involves.
1:48:01 I like to have people that are publicly involved, whether it's through recreation or their church
1:48:08 or school programs.
1:48:11 We can't have people up here that don't have an idea of what the questions are let alone
1:48:16 the answers.
1:48:18 I personally value independent thinkers, people that are not afraid to occasionally be in
1:48:24 the minority vote, especially when they say there might be something that they can offer
1:48:30 to the group discussion that hasn't been brought up.
1:48:34 And I do like to look at what I know of the follow-through on commitments people made
1:48:40 in previous activities where I may have had personal experience with them in civic, municipal,
1:48:47 or military, or some sort of trade group.
1:48:51 So those are the four criteria that I used to get my finalist.
1:48:58 Thank you, Chris.
1:49:02 Nicky, boy.
1:49:03 Well, I did a similar thing to Greg, and I really appreciate the way that you articulated
1:49:10 that.
1:49:11 And I think that that's very good format to follow.
1:49:15 That's what I used to come up with my top three.
1:49:19 And I think that our mayor is very well qualified to make this appointment, it is his appointment, and-
1:49:28 With our concurrence.
1:49:29 With our concurrence, but I think that I have confidence that using the guidelines that we're talking about is what we're all thinking.
1:49:38 And I think that's good.
1:49:42 Thank you, Nikki.
1:49:43 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:49:44 Thank you.
1:49:45 I agree with what has been said here tonight.
1:49:48 I know after the meeting I've gone back and watched the video from two weeks ago, half a dozen times to just make sure that I wasn't missing something or picking up on little hints.
1:49:59 For me, the number one thing I looked at is somebody I can work with for the next year, and somebody that I hope would continue to want to serve because it truly does take you a year to figure out this job.
1:50:14 And there's a lot of work that goes into it.
1:50:17 City staff invests so much of their time into your training that to come into it and think
1:50:23 after a year that it's probably something you're not interested in is not fair not only
1:50:28 to the council but to the city staff as well knowing that you still have to run a campaign
1:50:34 and be willing to go through that.
1:50:36 So along with Greg I looked at a lot of the things he looked at but my number one concern
1:50:40 was who can I work with in the next year to continue the good things we have going on in our city?
1:50:47 Thank you, Susan. Anyone else?
1:50:54 I don't know if you're expecting everybody to talk.
1:50:57 I don't have much to add. I somewhat did the same thing.
1:51:01 I didn't watch it six times. I watched it two, so...
1:51:05 I'm paranoid.
1:51:07 But excellent excellent people, and I repeat what I said two weeks ago.
1:51:13 Only one person can get picked and there's plenty to do out there, so
1:51:18 Don't be discouraged because you didn't make it this go around. There's a lot of other things you can do, so
1:51:27 Well the only comment I would make is that again, I appreciate everyone's input
1:51:37 I mean, it's not like I've been sitting around waiting for your input. I've certainly been giving thought to this as well
1:51:41 but the past couple of weeks and
1:51:44 You know, I think Greg sort of nailed it
1:51:46 I looked at it as if I were making this decision based upon these 14 people running for the
1:51:51 seat, who would I consider voting for?
1:51:54 So that's kind of how I'm looking at that service, because it is a service position, Dunhill.
1:52:04 Why I chose to be last because this is obviously this community is important to me.
1:52:09 I've spent a lot of time working with it in different capacities.
1:52:14 And the seat's important to me because it is mine right now for a little bit longer.
1:52:20 I'm actually going to state a name and I'm not going to state a bunch of names, I'm going
1:52:24 to state a name, my number one pick.
1:52:27 I will tell you first of all what an impressive group of people.
1:52:34 It was really heartwarming to me to be able to get to know some of you.
1:52:39 I didn't know. Some of your sons or your relatives I knew, but I saw a tremendous background in
1:52:47 not only business but in military with some of you have been involved in business and labor
1:52:54 unions. That was very impressive to me. We had a gentleman that I've known for years and I would
1:53:01 have a pretty good sense of how he would vote on things and he only wanted to serve my term.
1:53:09 and then open it up for someone else.
1:53:10 And I thought that actually was appealing to me
1:53:13 because I think there is some value
1:53:16 to going through the vetting process.
1:53:18 Well, I think there's a tremendous amount of value
1:53:21 going through the vetting process
1:53:22 of actually running a campaign
1:53:24 and having the citizens either vote for your vote
1:53:27 for an opponent.
1:53:28 So we also have others that have served this community
1:53:32 and the URA or the airport board, you know, Jim O'Donnell,
1:53:36 I don't know what you haven't done for our city and our community and our nation for that fact.
1:53:44 But, you know, you have to kind of go down and make, I'm going to make a recommendation of one person to the, to the mayor.
1:53:54 And then it's his choice.
1:53:55 And then of course it's the choice of the council to rather confirm that or send him back to bring another name.
1:54:03 And that name is Superman, Christopher Reed.
1:54:07 I feel very, very comfortable, and that's a joke.
1:54:10 His name isn't really spelled the same way.
1:54:14 But I've known Christopher for years.
1:54:17 He's been incredibly involved in this community.
1:54:20 He shares a lot of the same morals and views that I have
1:54:30 as far as economic development, economic development,
1:54:34 not just for the sake of economic development,
1:54:36 but for the benefit of our citizenry.
1:54:39 And I think that he would be someone
1:54:42 that all of you could work with
1:54:44 and be an asset to this council.
1:54:51 Thank you, Don.
1:54:53 Thanks to everyone for your input.
1:54:55 Again, this was a slightly different process this time
1:54:59 as we went through the letters of interest
1:55:02 and having the opportunity to hear
1:55:05 from all of the applicants, I guess, for lack of a better term,
1:55:11 and then having this opportunity for some input,
1:55:14 so I appreciate that.
1:55:15 So my intent will be to bring a recommendation forward
1:55:19 for the council meeting next week,
1:55:22 and I certainly value the input you all gave tonight.
1:55:27 I think we're all on the same page
1:55:28 on the type of person that we're looking for,
1:55:31 and I'll take those criteria and stack them up
1:55:36 as I would apply them and see where we go next week.
1:55:40 So again, thank you all.
1:55:45 Next on the agenda is another opportunity for public input.
1:55:48 If there's anybody here from the public wishing
1:55:50 to address the council on any issues,
1:55:51 now is your chance to come forward.
1:55:56 Seeing no one, Travis, anything from the city manager.
1:56:02 City council, Greg Lansing.
1:56:05 Friday's the parade, and then I'm assuming
1:56:07 that we're riding a fire truck
1:56:09 and doing all those wonderful things.
1:56:12 So there was an email out from the island today that yep that's okay that yes we
1:56:18 will be participating in the holiday light parade Friday night if you are
1:56:23 interested in getting on the fire truck at the fire station that is at 515
1:56:27 grade starts at 6. On that I didn't hear back it is okay for the youth
1:56:34 council to join us. I think it would be awesome for the youth council to join us.
1:56:36 Well that question is as safe for that many people to be on the fire truck.
1:56:40 Are we doing okay with all of us here? Who's plus bunch of kids? We'll have we'll have four or five kids
1:56:47 Like I said all was he so I'm sure that the firefighters will let us know when we death when we have too many people
1:56:54 I'm planning to walk the route anyway, so I'm not writing on the truck
1:57:00 It's for the weeks. I think we'll be in the gym five
1:57:12 I recommend the cab
1:57:17 I just wanted to mention that Susanne and I had the privilege of going to the Citizens
1:57:29 Police Academy graduation on Thursday, 25 citizens from our community participated, some
1:57:37 were city staff, some were people I'd never heard of and it sounded like they had a lot
1:57:43 a lot of fun. And so I just wanted to thank the department and all the officers that
1:57:49 instructed Craig that was awesome and I believe I don't remember the date but
1:57:54 they're going to be announcing another one soon. Perfect. So I encourage anybody
1:58:02 who hasn't ever participated in that to potentially sign up. It's about a three
1:58:08 month program so it might be kind of fun.
1:58:12 Sounds good.
1:58:14 Anything else from the council?
1:58:17 Amen.
1:58:20 That's it.
1:58:21 Means adjourned.
Download
- Transcript (text) 102 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 137 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 189 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.2 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 6.7 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, November 28, 2016. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:58:31.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
a419dfe3d050c93b958adb5a45ecb71cef491b59f4e4cc25751f6bf506b29d7b - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 529c780a9b85b375ebfcd7d8a0830d077fefb0e14f7e32bb7940ab6855fe8ef2
part02.m4a c330948c31c31a2d2f963bf338bc7e40d36ad201f8a7918c16095e285aa8c252 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
879e61cb884a072d8544b6572f09231f8d9b91dc1d6aafcf677339d40e8c75eb
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file