OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, December 12, 2016

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Minutes on fileExecutive session: a,e

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:29:59)

Transcript

0:16:31 It's still hot.

0:16:32 You may not have our potted up on that.

0:16:34 Okay.

0:16:37 So are we ready now then?

0:16:48 Good evening.

0:16:49 I'd like to call the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday, December 12th to order.

0:16:54 We are going to start tonight with the Pledge of Allegiance and we have some Boy Scouts in

0:16:57 the audience tonight who have agreed to come up and lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:17:01 So if everybody wishing to participate, would please rise?

0:17:20 Please join me in the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:17:22 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:17:35 Thank you guys.

0:17:38 Thank you gentlemen, if you want to stay right there for just a moment, I'm going to have you introduce yourselves and tell us what troop you're with and what badge you're working on and if there's anything else we should know about Boy Scouts tonight, tell us what we need to know.

0:17:52 So, this is my troop and we're part of troop 79, we're all 12 and you're 13.

0:18:03 We're working on the citizenship in the community merit batch and one of the requirements to

0:18:10 attend a city council meeting.

0:18:12 So, yeah.

0:18:14 There we are.

0:18:15 Thank you.

0:18:16 If you just want to tell us your name, then you can have a seat.

0:18:18 I'm Josh.

0:18:19 I'm Hunter.

0:18:20 Isaac.

0:18:22 Michael Hanson.

0:18:25 Michael Hanson.

0:18:26 Thank you, gentlemen, for coming.

0:18:29 We appreciate your help tonight.

0:18:34 With that, I would like to say we do have a quorum in attendance tonight.

0:18:39 There are six, seven of the council members here.

0:18:43 And at that, are there any amendments to the agenda tonight?

0:18:47 Madam Vice Mayor, members of the City Council staff would ask that item number four under

0:18:52 the consent calendar request to approve a request by Mr. Taylor for a payment in LUE.

0:18:59 Be removed from this agenda and we'll include it on the next agenda. Staff inadvertently

0:19:03 place the wrong information in the staff packet and so we'd like to have that removed this

0:19:10 evening and we'll put the appropriate information in next week's council packet.

0:19:14 Thank you. Do we need a motion or can we just remove it? Okay. So number four has been pulled

0:19:22 from the consent calendar.

0:19:24 We have no proclamations tonight.

0:19:26 At this time, we'd like to give anyone in the audience

0:19:28 a chance to address the council.

0:19:30 If there's anything you'd like to speak to us about

0:19:32 that is not on tonight's agenda.

0:19:37 Seeing no one, we will move on to the consent calendar.

0:19:42 Don Hall.

0:19:43 Acting Mayor Hawkins.

0:19:45 I would move that we approve the consent calendar

0:19:50 with the exception of item number four.

0:19:53 second that. Thank you. We have a motion by Don Hall, seconded by Ruth Pierce to accept

0:20:00 the consent calendar. Sharon, can we have a roll call vote please? Suzanne Hawkins. Yes.

0:20:07 Nikki Boyd. Yes. Chris Tocquinton. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Right there. Yes.

0:20:15 Motion passes six to zero. First item for consideration tonight is a presentation by Region 4 Development

0:20:22 for Development Association on Community

0:20:25 and Development Programs,

0:20:26 and we have Carleen Herring tonight.

0:20:29 Thank you, Carleen.

0:20:30 Thank you for the invitation members of the council.

0:20:34 My name is Carleen Herring,

0:20:35 I work for a Region 4 Development Association

0:20:37 here in Twin Falls.

0:20:39 We're a private nonprofit organization

0:20:41 established back in the early 70s

0:20:44 to provide professional staff support

0:20:46 to the smaller communities in the region.

0:20:48 At that time, Twin Falls was actually one

0:20:50 of those smaller communities.

0:20:52 Our organization has a board of directors

0:20:54 made up of local elected officials,

0:20:56 members of the different industry sectors,

0:20:59 higher education, departmental labor,

0:21:02 minority businesses, minority organizations,

0:21:06 agriculture, trying to take a cross-section

0:21:08 of the major influences on the economy in the region.

0:21:15 Our operation is set up in two separate pieces.

0:21:18 We've got a community development side,

0:21:19 which I will speak with you about this evening,

0:21:22 as well as a small business lending side.

0:21:25 That small business side actually can do commercial business deals

0:21:29 up to about $5 million.

0:21:31 We've got several different programs

0:21:33 that we provide to community members in regards to that.

0:21:37 From working capital to fixed asset financing,

0:21:40 subordinated lending.

0:21:42 So there's a side of the shop

0:21:43 that you don't usually hear from me talking about,

0:21:46 but I thought I'd give you a little bit broader overview

0:21:47 this evening before I get into the community development

0:21:50 side of things.

0:21:52 Primarily because that economic development piece often

0:21:55 ties into some of the infrastructure development

0:21:58 that our organization works on, on behalf of communities

0:22:01 like yourselves.

0:22:04 Ask me this evening to come and talk

0:22:05 a little bit about community and economic development programs,

0:22:08 funding sources that are available in the state

0:22:10 to assist with public infrastructure improvements.

0:22:14 The city's been really successful in using some

0:22:17 of those state and federal programs that are available

0:22:20 for building sewer, streets, water, bridges,

0:22:25 other infrastructure that both the community members need

0:22:28 as well as incoming economic development interests,

0:22:31 businesses that are recruited to the area

0:22:33 or wanting to expand existing businesses

0:22:36 in the community that want to grow larger.

0:22:40 Couple of the different programs that we've used

0:22:42 in the past have been the Idaho Community Development

0:22:45 Block Grant, which is funded by the US Department

0:22:48 housing and urban development, as a chunk of dollars given to the state of Idaho,

0:22:52 those funds are only eligible to cities and counties. So if you're not a city or

0:22:57 county, if you're a fire district or a water sewer district, you cannot directly

0:23:01 apply for those funds. You have to come through the City Council. There's two

0:23:05 separate categories that we've mostly used in this community. I just like back

0:23:09 that up. There's actually been three categories under that block grant program

0:23:12 that we've used successfully in the community. One has to do with senior

0:23:17 centers and community centers.

0:23:21 Those funds are a special set aside category and the other two have to do with your basic

0:23:26 infrastructure, things like curb gutters, sidewalks.

0:23:30 We've used those in a couple of neighborhoods in the community and I don't see any faces

0:23:34 on this council who are here at that time.

0:23:37 And the other program that we've used successfully has to do with the economic development.

0:23:41 We've used that for a number of businesses, from JCO to I guess their Dart Industries

0:23:46 now when they were clear shield when they got here transferred to solo cup and now dart

0:23:52 industries.

0:23:53 But the catch to remember there is that it's a competitive process regardless of which application

0:23:58 program you tap into of those three funding sources.

0:24:03 It has to be public infrastructure.

0:24:06 Those dollars cannot be used for cutting a check directly to the senior center or cutting

0:24:12 a check directly to a business.

0:24:13 It has to be for public infrastructure.

0:24:17 So on the community side, we talk economic development and community, on the community

0:24:22 side has to be public infrastructure, it has to solve a health and safety issue, something

0:24:28 that's been identified whether that's the DEQ, the Department of Environmental Quality

0:24:34 or perhaps the EPA, the Environmental Protection Agency has said you have a problem and it needs

0:24:39 to be resolved.

0:24:40 So we have to solve a health and safety issue.

0:24:42 And the second thing we have to do is serve a low to moderate income population.

0:24:47 And what that means is that the folks who benefit from that infrastructure development

0:24:55 have to make less than 80% of county household median income.

0:25:00 And right now that's sitting at about 43.7 for a family of four and about 30,650 for a single individual.

0:25:10 And there's a threshold whether you go by the Census data, the Census track, this particular

0:25:15 bill that we would have has a low to moderate income population, or that we do an actual

0:25:20 income survey where we anonymously ask folks, please fill out the following form, and then

0:25:25 we do some tabulations to determine that eligible population to benefit.

0:25:31 The second side is that economic development side.

0:25:35 And remember the funds come from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development who has that

0:25:40 low-modered income benefit requirement? Well, on the job creation side, that requirement

0:25:46 does not go away. So again, you still have to produce a project that fits a community

0:25:53 need, only public infrastructure, sewer, water, streets, regulated utilities. We've done some

0:25:59 railroad sightings or some natural gas lines. Idaho Power, again, regulated utilities.

0:26:06 They have the same kind of features as a public infrastructure system, your municipal systems.

0:26:13 Because it's a competitive process, the employers that were assisting with the development of

0:26:17 that infrastructure has to also meet that low to moderate income benefit.

0:26:25 They have to provide wages that are above that county household meeting.

0:26:29 They have to be what's already existing in the economy.

0:26:33 They also have to provide jobs that have a comprehensive benefit package because the purpose of the

0:26:38 program is to lift all boats. So by having benefits that health insurance,

0:26:43 retirement, paid vacation, sick leave, the information that we collect in order to

0:26:51 prove that we have met that threshold is the company is signing what's called a

0:26:57 grant assistance agreement where they are committing to a certain number of jobs.

0:27:02 And those jobs have to have those wages that are spelled out specifically at what

0:27:09 all kinds of positions they're hiring for.

0:27:12 Has to have spelled out how those benefit packages

0:27:14 actually are going to be spread out

0:27:17 amongst their employees.

0:27:20 Several times we have provided,

0:27:22 Region 4 Development has provided

0:27:24 the administrative oversight for the different programs

0:27:27 that we've used in the City of Twin Falls.

0:27:29 Again, it takes a removed one from the city staff.

0:27:33 We have the expertise in it.

0:27:35 That documentation includes doing an income survey

0:27:39 of all of the applicants for any given business project.

0:27:47 Many of you may remember back when Dell was recruited.

0:27:50 I think our staff went through 3,000 pieces of paper

0:27:56 with the income survey on it to document the hiring pool

0:28:00 that Dell had for their positions.

0:28:03 Once those positions were filled,

0:28:05 we had those employees fill out yet another one

0:28:07 to make sure that we cross-referenced,

0:28:10 There wasn't, I think, you know, honky going on.

0:28:13 We cross-referenced those 3,000 against the 700 and some

0:28:16 odd that they actually hired.

0:28:20 As with any federal program, their strings attached.

0:28:23 And again, our organization tries to mitigate those demands

0:28:28 on city staff, but environmental assessments are required.

0:28:31 If we're going to be spending federal dollars,

0:28:33 which these are, on public improvements,

0:28:36 we also do public hearings and get input

0:28:38 on the applications prior to going in,

0:28:40 And at about a 50% point during the progress of construction,

0:28:44 there's some civil rights progress that we're monitoring.

0:28:47 There are housing, ADA accessibility, and some other programs.

0:28:52 Our organization also works in other community development

0:28:55 programs.

0:28:56 There have been several instances where

0:28:58 we've identified potential funding sources for other things

0:29:04 that I see in the city's strategic plan, or Travis's wish list.

0:29:08 And whether that's things from, well, the truth.

0:29:13 Things like smart growth.

0:29:15 If there's some technical assistance

0:29:17 that smart growth can provide,

0:29:18 I've tried to put city staff in touch

0:29:20 with those organizations.

0:29:22 EPA Brownfield, the Economic Development Administration,

0:29:26 has some funding that comes along

0:29:27 from time to time to partner with,

0:29:30 Block Grant, Urban Renewal,

0:29:32 cuddling together whatever city funds we have available

0:29:35 to do public infrastructure projects.

0:29:39 That's basically the overview of the kinds of different

0:29:42 things that we do providing community development as well as economic development programs and

0:29:47 trying to bridge that gap between what your staff is already working on and the other resources

0:29:53 we come into contact with our organization.

0:29:59 Thank you very much.

0:30:00 We've got lights coming on all over the place.

0:30:02 Okay, I'm going to start with Ruth Pierce.

0:30:05 Ms. Mayimale.

0:30:06 Carly, you and I just need to tell you how proud I am of what you do for our community

0:30:12 what you do for our region and you might want to take a minute and address the

0:30:17 manufacturing designation just to repeat that again but you have done so much for

0:30:23 us so thank you very much designation is a label that only 24 communities nationwide

0:30:34 currently have eight counties of South Central Idaho is actually the smallest of

0:30:40 those 24 were the only one without an urban center. Our manufacturing designation highlights

0:30:46 the impacts to the national economy, not just the Idaho economy or our regional economy,

0:30:52 but our impact on the national economy of our food processing, production and science

0:30:57 sector. We're pretty excited about that. We're finally starting to get some traction with

0:31:02 funding opportunities. We've had it since July of last year and we're now finally getting

0:31:09 the point where we have several different initiatives that are moving forward, including

0:31:13 some things in workforce, career awareness, and transportation, working very closely with

0:31:19 the folks at Watco on that Translow facility down in Bully.

0:31:23 So thank you, ma'am, for asking.

0:31:25 It is, we are one of 24 nationally with a pretty big spotlight directing investment and opportunities

0:31:33 to our region.

0:31:34 Thank you.

0:31:36 Chris Talkington.

0:31:37 Hi.

0:31:38 Carling, yeah, we go way back to Dallas to that we couldn't kept them, I guess that's part of the winds and

0:31:44 Progressions

0:31:45 You work with Mandy Roberts probably fairly closely don't you within the city staff?

0:31:52 Yes, okay

0:31:54 We've been trying to get gas and as long

0:31:58 Extended from approximately the water tank on the south Washington out to the airport

0:32:03 She's not been able to have much luck with that and I wonder if even she might look at

0:32:08 again.

0:32:09 I can't tell you that it might result in dramatically more employment immediately that

0:32:15 I think that the opportunity to extend gas to an area that's now served by propane large

0:32:22 hanger areas would potentially longer term be a potential for turning that underdeveloped

0:32:32 airport area into a major manufacturing, light manufacturing business.

0:32:39 And the Intermountain Gas says that the cost or the valuation of natural gas right now,

0:32:47 they just can't extend a line for probably two and a half miles without subsidies on

0:32:53 somebody's part.

0:32:55 Just wondered if you might, you and Mandy get together sometime and lift up a few rugs

0:33:01 and see if there might not be some way we can pull the impossible.

0:33:04 I sure appreciate you looking into it.

0:33:06 That one is still on my shopping list of things that the communities need, so no, I have not

0:33:14 misplaced it.

0:33:15 I did speak with some folks at Intermountain Gas about that probably I say about five months

0:33:21 ago taking a look at some of the other opportunities as well as trying to figure out whether there's

0:33:26 There's the ability to generate our own natural gas and try to offset what their cost would

0:33:34 be.

0:33:35 I guess we're talking a little bit more than a million bucks a mile for that extension.

0:33:40 So yes, sir.

0:33:41 Yes, sir.

0:33:42 Certainly with the new school going in there and the potential for housing development,

0:33:46 I think that longer term this would be seed money that they could look for a good return

0:33:52 on investment.

0:33:53 But thank you.

0:33:57 You know, Carlin, both Greg and I have had the privilege of being in leadership positions,

0:34:02 the mayor positions during some of these great economic times, the economic development times,

0:34:07 and we've traveled to Boise with you to make some of those presentations.

0:34:11 And I've always just been so appreciative of the work that you and your staff do to help us.

0:34:17 But really what I'd like to ask Travis is if he could give us a staff perspective of some of the work that they do

0:34:25 that they do and really assist us

0:34:29 because it'd be difficult without them.

0:34:33 Yes, I think difficult is an understatement.

0:34:36 I think that when we look at Carleen

0:34:38 and we look at Region 4, they are a part of our team.

0:34:44 And I know that they're a part of lots of teams,

0:34:46 but really when we're at that stage,

0:34:48 when we're having a conversation with the Idaho Department

0:34:50 of Commerce or the Idaho Department of Labor,

0:34:52 they're really wearing our uniform

0:34:55 and advocating as though they were working with us

0:34:58 on behalf of the community.

0:35:00 And I've also had the opportunity to observe Carleen

0:35:03 and work with Carleen when I was with another community

0:35:06 and do that exact same thing at the federal level.

0:35:10 So I'll give you an example of one of the things

0:35:12 that Carleen and her team, what they do.

0:35:17 So Carleen spent just a minute talking about

0:35:21 the number of applications that they receive

0:35:23 And I think that when she shared, when they went through Dell,

0:35:27 they had 3,000 different wage surveys moving forward.

0:35:32 We know that that number is really close, if not even larger,

0:35:36 when you start talking about Chivani jobs, it was like 5,000.

0:35:40 And you look at Cliff Bar and those jobs moving forward.

0:35:45 Every single one of those applications and those hires

0:35:49 have to be validated for to meet the LMI criteria.

0:35:53 And really, Carleen and her team are working closely,

0:35:58 not only with the Department of Labor,

0:36:00 but also with the Department of Commerce,

0:36:02 to ensure that that's happening.

0:36:03 And the amount of time and staff hours that they spend,

0:36:07 which would completely overwhelm our operational capacities

0:36:12 inside of the city.

0:36:13 The other side is they bring talents and expertise

0:36:17 that they loan to us for every single project,

0:36:20 and it's not ones that we have to work on in-house,

0:36:23 And I know that Mandy uses Carlin in Region 4

0:36:29 as almost in a mentorship role, being able to reach out,

0:36:34 tap their expertise, talk about different things,

0:36:37 and put us in contact with other of our partners.

0:36:42 And so we couldn't do, and we wouldn't

0:36:44 be successful on Jibani, on Cliff Bar, on Glendia expansion

0:36:53 without their assistance and they don't know if that's always celebrated as part of our community

0:37:01 but they are an integral part of our team.

0:37:03 Thank you.

0:37:04 I just really want to emphasize invaluable.

0:37:06 Thank you.

0:37:07 Thank you.

0:37:08 Great landing.

0:37:09 Well, Carlene, I want to thank you.

0:37:12 Like Don talked about, you witnessed me on a trip up to Boise to give me exactly what I

0:37:19 I need to say it when I need to say it and it was supposedly that we were guaranteed that

0:37:27 we were going to get this but it didn't feel like it when you're set in front of that committee

0:37:30 and we were the third year in a row asking for basically half of the money or more that

0:37:35 they had available.

0:37:37 And so I thank you very much for showing me the ropes and letting me, I was having to

0:37:44 speak but I guarantee I was saying your words so I appreciate that.

0:37:48 Thank you.

0:37:49 Thank you.

0:37:50 Carlin, thank you so much for coming tonight.

0:37:52 I know you and I have had a chance to talk on a few occasions about how some of these funds

0:37:56 work and how they get to our community.

0:37:58 And I appreciate you always taking time for me as well.

0:38:02 Besides the staff and everything else you do, you make each one of us feel like we're the

0:38:05 only person you have to deal with and you have a real gift in doing that.

0:38:10 And I appreciate it.

0:38:11 Thank you, ma'am.

0:38:12 Thank you so much for coming tonight.

0:38:13 Thank you all.

0:38:14 Appreciate the opportunity.

0:38:15 Okay.

0:38:20 Next item on our agenda is a request to adopt the Twin Falls Park and Recreation Master Plan.

0:38:31 And we have Wendy Davis and I'm assuming Lori's working there to get that up and running for

0:38:35 us.

0:38:39 Welcome, Wendy.

0:38:40 Good evening.

0:38:41 Mary and Council.

0:38:42 This evening we were here in October and gave an overview of the process and talked a little

0:38:48 bit about the mapping and the GIS data system that comes with this master plan and tonight

0:38:54 we're here I have Greg Graves which you JUB is going to present a little more specifically

0:39:01 the recommendations outlined in the master plan. We're going to talk a little bit about

0:39:05 the application of those recommendations and how we can move that forward and the tool as

0:39:11 it can be useful to parks and recreation into the city and to the council for planning is

0:39:16 So I'm going to step aside and let Greg talk about the plan and the recommendations and

0:39:21 then I'll kind of wrap it up with some of that application.

0:39:24 Perfect, thank you.

0:39:27 Welcome back, Greg.

0:39:28 Thank you.

0:40:11 Thanks for letting me come back and address in more detail some of the things.

0:40:16 We didn't get to last time.

0:40:18 Last time you saw all of our pictures, the maps that we prepared in this process.

0:40:26 You remember seeing all of these slides.

0:40:46 We started out with the existing parks.

0:40:48 Again, this is just inventory and data that all went into the GIS program that we developed.

0:40:54 Also, put in the trails in there, looked at areas of service for all of these different neighborhood parks,

0:41:01 for community parks, what they look like together, how they looked at all of the areas that are not served.

0:41:10 by the parks and looked at what's online,

0:41:18 what plan to be developed and add those together

0:41:22 so that you can see all of the resources

0:41:26 that are available, that City owns

0:41:30 and currently is able to provide recreational amenities

0:41:33 to its own citizens.

0:41:35 We looked at where potential growth is gonna make sense

0:41:38 that it will be on the periphery of the city.

0:41:41 That's where the open space is.

0:41:45 We see where the service areas of existing facilities are.

0:41:51 And then in order to meet the growth,

0:41:55 we have areas that we need to provide new amenities for.

0:42:01 Again, all of this is more or less a kind of mapping exercise.

0:42:07 It appears as though we're just kind of plugging holes in here

0:42:12 with parks and that sort of thing.

0:42:15 It's a little bit more than that.

0:42:17 And so that's where I wanted to spend a little bit of time

0:42:20 and kind of explain in a little bit more detail

0:42:25 how we arrived at all of this.

0:42:28 One of the things that I wanted to emphasize

0:42:31 and make sure that we have a clear idea about

0:42:33 is what level of service is and how that was calculated.

0:42:42 We looked at the neighborhood, how many acres, level of service is a number which represents

0:42:49 how many acres per thousand population of park space that a particular city has.

0:42:59 It's different for every city and that's fine.

0:43:05 To calculate that number we look at the number of acres of neighborhood parks plus the number

0:43:12 of Acre of community parks, combine those, and then divide that by the population, and

0:43:23 adjust that per 10,000 figure, and that's where the 3.42 number comes from.

0:43:29 That's the existing level of service in terms of neighborhood and community parks.

0:43:35 Now, the reason we look at specifically neighborhood community parks is because those are, it's

0:43:45 kind of an industry standard that cities look at that rather than their total open space.

0:43:55 Parks are fairly easy to identify and understand what the recreational value is and what we're

0:44:01 getting.

0:44:02 When we're looking at open space, it gets a lot more subjective.

0:44:06 is hard to compare. Having a hillside where people can go walk doesn't have the same recreational

0:44:13 value as say a park that has playgrounds and sports fields and that sort of thing. So the

0:44:20 standard is to look at the neighborhood and community parks. Now this 3.42 number is on

0:44:37 The lower range of what we often see,

0:44:39 sometimes usually the range is from four to six.

0:44:45 But being hung up on this 3.42 number

0:44:48 is not a particularly important thing to worry about.

0:44:53 One of the things that we either remind ourselves

0:44:56 is that every city is unique,

0:44:58 every city has resources that are specific to them.

0:45:04 specific to them. While the city has neighborhoods and community parks, you also have the benefit

0:45:13 of having very close by several regional parks, as well as county-owned parks. And those provide

0:45:22 a tremendous amount of recreational value for the city. They're probably the most visited of all of

0:45:29 all of your parks. In fact, four of those were in the top six most visited and most used

0:45:41 parks. But again, the regional parks, the county parks are not facilities that you own, that

0:45:50 you control and that you can direct the programming in. It doesn't mean that they don't provide

0:45:56 value is just that you don't control or own those.

0:45:59 And that's why those kinds of recreational minis aren't

0:46:04 included in this level of service number.

0:46:07 Realizing that then, having a little bit lower number

0:46:10 than what might be average may not matter at all,

0:46:15 because of the benefit that you're gaining

0:46:17 from these other parks.

0:46:19 And I think that's something we wanted to emphasize.

0:46:22 I'm going to interrupt you real quick.

0:46:23 We have a couple of lights coming on here.

0:46:24 Don Hall.

0:46:25 So tell me, give me an example of a regional park then.

0:46:30 In this case, social and false.

0:46:33 That's a large park.

0:46:38 That again, most places don't.

0:46:42 So I just wanna clarify that we do own that

0:46:44 and we do direct the recreation down there just.

0:46:49 Cause that's why I was curious what you're,

0:46:51 I know that the county parks we don't,

0:46:54 There's several that are really good quality county parks, Rock Creek and Centennial.

0:46:59 But then when you said regional, I'm thinking of other falls and probably the Shoshone,

0:47:04 both of which we do own just for clarification.

0:47:07 Right.

0:47:10 Chris Talkington.

0:47:11 And I just wanted to clarify if I understand this 3.42 ratio would not include

0:47:17 our world famous walking trail along the canyon.

0:47:21 It does not.

0:47:23 even though it's an incredible recreation opportunity,

0:47:26 it's still a trail, and it kind of falls out of the lexicon.

0:47:29 That's correct.

0:47:30 Can we change that?

0:47:31 I think we should have that.

0:47:33 I mean, I'm staying that for a seciously, but how many?

0:47:37 Acre-Johnna on a trail like that.

0:47:41 Again, it's a valuable amenity that you have that contributes

0:47:45 greatly to the city.

0:47:48 But it's because of the limited acreage

0:47:49 that it represents, then, with the type of recreation.

0:47:52 Normally a trail is hard to sign an acreage to a trail because it's a linear path.

0:47:59 It doesn't mean it doesn't have value.

0:48:01 It just means it's not a neighborhood or community park.

0:48:05 Thank you.

0:48:07 That's all the lights for right now.

0:48:08 Okay, great.

0:48:09 Again, this level of service is kind of important to keep in mind moving forward because this

0:48:24 This is what your city's recreational standard is.

0:48:29 It used to be that there would be a national standard set up and everybody tried to have

0:48:35 so many this per thousand and so many of that.

0:48:39 We've gone away from that and each city now is encouraged to set up their own standard

0:48:44 based on what their own citizens want to use, what they want to do, what kind of amenities

0:48:50 they want to have.

0:48:57 So, in this case, that's what we've done.

0:49:01 We've looked at this based on this particular city.

0:49:09 This, because this is a standard,

0:49:12 it will be something that will guide us in the future

0:49:16 in knowing how much more, as growth occurs,

0:49:20 how much more recreational park space we're going to need

0:49:25 in order to accommodate growth.

0:49:28 I'll talk a little bit more about that in a second.

0:49:34 Any other questions at this point

0:49:36 with regard to the level of service?

0:49:38 I think you're good to go.

0:49:39 Okay, great.

0:49:40 Let me touch for just a moment on the citizen survey

0:49:44 that we had in this.

0:49:47 We spent quite a bit of time putting this survey together,

0:49:53 trying to make it thorough,

0:49:54 cover a lot of different things from preferences

0:50:01 businesses and values to programs, trying to get a feel for what it was that the citizens

0:50:09 were concerned about and what they liked, what they didn't like, those kinds of things.

0:50:15 Now, this was in a perfect survey.

0:50:18 There were a couple of strengths and weaknesses with it.

0:50:21 Let me touch on the weaknesses first.

0:50:24 It wasn't truly a random survey.

0:50:27 be truly random, we would have to spend a lot more budget than we had in order to identify

0:50:34 again randomly various households throughout the city and then make sure that we get a response

0:50:40 back from all of those. That's one of the things that makes it truly random. This was

0:50:48 advertised in the paper through the news media, on TV, the rec center, or the recreation

0:50:59 department, touch base with numerous stakeholders,

0:51:05 trying to get the word out.

0:51:06 The survey was available online, as well as paper copies,

0:51:11 if someone wanted to use that.

0:51:14 But when you have a survey that's administered in that fashion,

0:51:17 it becomes somewhat self-selecting for those that respond.

0:51:23 It's general to people who have a specific interest

0:51:26 in recreation in general or a specific amenity that they want to talk about or a program

0:51:36 that they want to advance.

0:51:42 Example was the disc golf.

0:51:46 This is not something that we even mentioned in the survey as a choice or anything.

0:51:50 We've got a lot of response about that.

0:51:52 There's obviously a group that wanted to be heard with regard to that and they were

0:51:59 and it showed up in the survey.

0:52:03 However, the survey also has the ability to miss certain segments and we've kind of seen

0:52:10 that with the pickleball group.

0:52:14 For some reason, they didn't respond to the survey and their voices weren't heard and

0:52:18 And yet that's a group that is being responded to, that has a need, or has an interest in

0:52:27 being accommodated.

0:52:30 So that was something that the survey didn't pick up.

0:52:35 And that, again, that can happen when you have a survey that's administered like this.

0:52:41 It doesn't mean that the survey is bad.

0:52:45 It just means that it has a potential for missing certain niches in the population, and

0:52:52 that happens.

0:52:53 It's not unusual.

0:52:58 It is, it may not be perfectly representative of the city as a whole, but it is very representative

0:53:05 of those who took the survey.

0:53:08 So the way to improve this in the future is to get more people to take it.

0:53:15 I'm not sure I can solve that problem at this point, but that's how we deal with that problem.

0:53:28 It could have easily been the other way where Pickleball, if the Pickleball group had responded

0:53:33 to this and not the disc golf, then you would have seen a completely different outcome with

0:53:39 regard to that particular amenity.

0:53:46 The strengths again of the survey, I think, are that it was pretty thorough.

0:53:51 that cover a lot of different areas.

0:53:56 It's also serves as kind of a starting point or a benchmark for where we can begin as we

0:54:07 look at attitudes, desires, values with regard to recreation.

0:54:15 And it's something that the next time it comes around, next time the surveys administered,

0:54:20 you've got something to compare to.

0:54:24 It should be noted again that this master plan is not an absolute, it has to be this way sort

0:54:31 of a document.

0:54:32 It is a guide, it gives us a starting point, but it is a guide and there is all kinds of

0:54:40 opportunity to be flexible in responding to the various needs that the citizens may have

0:54:48 in terms of programs or new amenities or that sort of thing.

0:54:54 Because a survey didn't happen to catch a certain thing,

0:54:56 doesn't mean it isn't valuable, and it isn't something

0:55:00 that shouldn't be given a further look at.

0:55:06 One of the other strengths of this is the GIS component

0:55:09 of this whole effort.

0:55:12 All of your existing facilities have been inventoryed

0:55:15 and entered into that program, and that program is something

0:55:18 that you added to and updated continually,

0:55:21 so that you've always got this accurate live database

0:55:25 that you can use in any further recreation development.

0:55:33 Again, the survey may not be perfect,

0:55:35 but it certainly is a good starting point.

0:55:37 And while a couple of things,

0:55:41 it may have missed some things,

0:55:42 it doesn't invalidate other information

0:55:46 that it did provide.

0:55:49 Some of that has to do with things that people like in parks,

0:55:53 shade, walking opportunities, more trails, nature, picnic tables.

0:56:04 These seem obvious, but these are also things that people said there's not enough of, generally

0:56:12 speaking, in our parks.

0:56:14 So those kind of design guidelines that are in here, as part of the recommendations, are

0:56:20 pretty valid regardless of what amenities we may or may not have highlighted. More specifically,

0:56:34 now I'd kind of like to focus on the recommendations that we have in here. One thing I want to emphasize

0:56:52 again is that in order to make some of these recommendations, we're looking at build out.

0:57:02 That means when the city is within its annexation boundaries, when it's fully developed, what

0:57:10 will be the needs at that point?

0:57:14 We haven't identified, say, a 10 or a 20-year time period, what will be needed then, because

0:57:21 We have no idea how fast growth will occur, nor do we know where it will occur.

0:57:27 So we look at build out to see long run what are the kinds of things that we need.

0:57:36 In order to do that, we're looking at population projections and then taking this level of service

0:57:43 and doing the math with those two to determine at some future point when this is build out

0:57:50 How much, how many acres are we going to need?

0:57:53 How many do we already have?

0:57:55 How much more are we going to have?

0:57:58 In the report, on page 31 there, we

0:58:04 looked at two different population numbers,

0:58:06 a lower range and a higher range, and gave you

0:58:09 the projection of how many more acres might be needed.

0:58:13 And based on how many acres are needed,

0:58:17 that can be translated into how many more parks,

0:58:22 How many more neighborhood parks, how many community parks

0:58:25 would we need in order to provide that?

0:58:29 And this, that's kind of what this final master plan map

0:58:33 that you see indicates is that that's about

0:58:37 what we're gonna need when everything is built out.

0:58:42 That's not within the next three years,

0:58:43 not in the next five, but it built out.

0:58:54 I have a couple of lights on to give it to you.

0:58:56 Greg Lanthine?

0:58:57 Yes, to do your projection maps and need maps that include the county parks.

0:59:04 Did you not?

0:59:05 I'm thinking of a couple of areas where you have places that are going to be proposed that already have a, well, at least one of them already kind of have a county park right in that very close general area that may be put those back on the burner a little bit to fulfill other areas first.

0:59:23 Exactly. That may be exactly the case.

0:59:26 Again, these circles are the dotted lines or the areas that particular park may service.

0:59:35 The dots represent what may be the center of that park.

0:59:41 Now, that can be adjusted or moved around and probably should be.

0:59:45 This is just general locations.

0:59:49 Each time the city looks to develop a park,

0:59:53 You're looking in advance at what lands available, what development is going on, is that development, providing space that will accommodate what we need, that sort of thing.

1:00:04 Is the programming going to be the same in the new neighborhood or the community park, as say the county park?

1:00:12 Well, they may be close to each other, but provide different needs.

1:00:17 It depends on what develops around that particular place.

1:00:22 Again, these are proposed generalized locations, and they can be adjusted depending upon what

1:00:31 opportunities present themselves, what if the city has property in that vicinity that they

1:00:39 could use, if somebody is in a position to kind of partner with the city in developing

1:00:49 something like that. Those are all things to look at and this just becomes a guide to

1:00:56 where you might be looking. It also depends on where that growth occurs. If the growth is

1:01:02 occurring in the south part of the city then we certainly don't want to focus on getting

1:01:07 something in the north or the east, focus where you're short, where the growth is and

1:01:13 where you need to provide future amenities.

1:01:17 Okay, Ruth Pierce?

1:01:19 Okay, so I just want to step back to the survey for a minute.

1:01:23 Sure.

1:01:24 And this is probably a question for Travis,

1:01:27 and it's moot at this point, but for future.

1:01:30 What does it cost us to do the city survey?

1:01:34 It just, give me a ballpark.

1:01:39 So the citizen survey that we do ranges

1:01:43 with the different geographical tabs, anywhere between $12,000 and $15,000.

1:01:49 Okay, and how many citizens do we survey?

1:01:54 Enough to be statistically valid.

1:01:56 Okay.

1:01:58 So we're, yeah, so we will send out about 1,200 surveys,

1:02:02 and we'll get probably somewhere slightly less than 500 responses back.

1:02:09 Okay.

1:02:12 Okay, that's what I need to know.

1:02:15 this particular survey got back just a little bit less than 500.

1:02:22 At this point, I want to quickly mention trails.

1:02:24 We didn't focus a lot on trails in our study.

1:02:31 The city was going through an evaluation of their existing

1:02:35 trail system, and we were encouraged to kind of look at that

1:02:44 and not spend time trying to redo that effort,

1:02:48 focus more on the parks. So we did not spend a lot of time when it comes to the trails and

1:02:55 evaluating different places that they should be. We did focus however on recommending trails

1:03:02 that would help link some of these future parks together so that you would have a network

1:03:07 of trails that lead somewhere from one recreation site to another.

1:03:23 With some of the recommendations, talk about things that need to be done overall in the

1:03:32 park system.

1:03:33 We mentioned some of those already providing more shade.

1:03:39 That sounds like a pretty simple thing, yet it's something that we need to take a look

1:03:48 at.

1:03:49 The best time to plant a tree for shade was 30 years ago.

1:03:53 So that's something that I think is a good recommendation.

1:03:59 One that you can start doing, relatively easy to do.

1:04:02 It's easier to take down a tree if you've got too many

1:04:06 than it is to try and get one up and get shade

1:04:09 when you need to shade now.

1:04:12 More walking paths and trails is important.

1:04:17 Particularly, as you develop parks,

1:04:19 having a perimeter trail, a lot of people

1:04:22 in the neighborhood like to come and walk and exercise.

1:04:24 And those are, that's a great way to accommodate that

1:04:28 in various neighborhoods.

1:04:33 Also, the fact that one of the biggest brights

1:04:36 that people have is when it comes to restrooms,

1:04:42 they like them clean and neat.

1:04:46 And so again, a recommendation that they'd be

1:04:49 in good condition and kept clean,

1:04:51 That seems to influence a lot of people

1:04:56 to whether or not they're going to go and visit a particular park,

1:04:59 is how nice the restrooms are.

1:05:11 Touch one more thing with regard to programming,

1:05:16 a couple of highlights there.

1:05:18 The city has done an extremely good job in the events

1:05:21 that it sponsors for its citizens.

1:05:24 And those were the most enjoyed by your citizens.

1:05:29 of all of the amenities, concerts in the park, movies,

1:05:36 cabin fever day, arbor day, those were the top,

1:05:40 and people liked that.

1:05:41 So kudos to the city for doing that and encouragement

1:05:44 to consider looking at other opportunities there.

1:05:50 People here really like nature-related type activities

1:05:54 and spaces.

1:05:56 That's important.

1:06:01 Also, because of the weather through the winter,

1:06:06 there was a strong indication that we need some place

1:06:11 to play basketball.

1:06:12 We need some place to walk and to run indoors.

1:06:16 We need classroom space for different programs.

1:06:21 So again, our recommendation is to look at providing

1:06:25 some kind of a silly that would accommodate that.

1:06:28 You can call it whatever you want to call it,

1:06:30 but most people call it a recreation center.

1:06:33 Again, one that would provide those kinds of facilities

1:06:39 for indoor activity.

1:06:41 Final thing I think is a reminder that, again,

1:06:51 this master plan and the related survey is kind

1:06:56 of a snapshot in time in order to really be valuable going

1:07:02 forward, it will need to be updated from time to time, periodically. It's up to the city how often that happens, but it does need to be updated.

1:07:12 As new, new trans arise, new demands present themselves, you want the ability to respond to those. Again, this master plan allows you that flexibility to respond and to change as needed.

1:07:29 but you do need to update from time to time.

1:07:37 We have another question from Chris Talkington.

1:07:40 I'd like to go back to the question that Don posed

1:07:42 about the parks that aren't necessarily included

1:07:45 in the 3.42 ratio, and that's in particular, Auger Falls.

1:07:51 I was on the council when we spent a substantial amount

1:07:54 of money taking a chance on a very unique park

1:07:58 that is a low impact usage without a lot of infrastructure,

1:08:03 but that's not included in this park system.

1:08:08 If I understand that?

1:08:09 It's not included in the level of service.

1:08:11 And why couldn't or wouldn't it be?

1:08:14 I guess I didn't quite understand that.

1:08:16 We have one to respond to that.

1:08:21 So when I was talking about the application of this,

1:08:22 I was gonna go into this a little bit,

1:08:24 but it's my understanding that originally,

1:08:26 there was a decision made specifically

1:08:28 and intentionally to leave those parks out

1:08:31 and to deal more specifically with regional,

1:08:33 not regional, excuse me, community and neighborhood parks.

1:08:36 And so that information was left completely out

1:08:38 of this plan from the beginning.

1:08:40 Now, in our most recent conversation,

1:08:44 it was bothering Greg a little bit, it kind of bothered me.

1:08:46 And so we decided to go back and put some language

1:08:49 in that as specifically addresses those regional parks

1:08:52 and the value they bring to the community.

1:08:54 But really all we're talking about,

1:08:56 when we're talking about build out and the level of service

1:09:00 is what do we need to do as far as community and neighborhood

1:09:04 parks as we move forward?

1:09:05 And then using the language to recognize the fact

1:09:08 that our area is unique, and we have some really

1:09:12 substantial regional parks and facilities that

1:09:15 are both county and city owned that

1:09:19 provide a great level of service, which

1:09:22 allows us to get away with that lower number.

1:09:25 So when we talk more about the 3.42 acres,

1:09:27 that would probably not be as acceptable

1:09:30 if we didn't have those other parks to consider.

1:09:33 And so while back when they set this up,

1:09:37 they told them to leave it out.

1:09:39 Greg and I talked about it,

1:09:40 and we put some language back into the plan

1:09:42 that specifically addresses the value

1:09:46 and the contribution of those parks to this area.

1:09:51 Does that kind of answer that question?

1:09:54 I don't agree, but I understand.

1:09:56 I don't know, honestly, I wasn't here either.

1:09:58 So I don't know what the thinking was.

1:10:00 Yeah.

1:10:01 I just know that that's what happened.

1:10:02 Thank you.

1:10:03 Don't call.

1:10:04 You know, I'm just going to piggyback on that.

1:10:06 Again, it really bothers me because those are hundreds of acres down there

1:10:11 that was specifically, we made effort.

1:10:15 And when I say we, the city, the citizens, the councils at the time

1:10:20 made an effort to ensure that those parts were available

1:10:23 to our citizens and it blows me away a little bit that they weren't involved and I don't remember

1:10:29 who made the decision not to put them into the study but I think that's frankly that's a mistake

1:10:36 because you know these scales always bother me anyway because we're very competitive as human beings

1:10:45 And we want to, you know, if five is the five stars, we want to be five stars.

1:10:50 And we have invested heavily for our citizens in those parks.

1:10:57 And as a user, they are world class.

1:11:01 This trail system is world class.

1:11:05 And I think we, I appreciate you putting the language in there, but

1:11:09 that almost does a disservice to me even thinking about just putting language in there.

1:11:14 We can change those numbers.

1:11:16 If you want to add that, that's no problem.

1:11:17 That'll serve your 3.2 or 3.42 into a higher number.

1:11:24 It won't change how well the neighborhood

1:11:28 and community parks are serving your community.

1:11:31 It will change your level of service number.

1:11:34 If that's a concern, that can be done.

1:11:39 Well, I'm just going to say it is to me personally.

1:11:41 I don't, I can't speak for the council.

1:11:45 We're gonna let Mitch weigh in real quick.

1:11:46 So I might just pipe in here a little bit.

1:11:49 I know that when we started this plan,

1:11:50 Dennis was on board with us.

1:11:52 And Dennis and I talked a little bit about

1:11:55 his goals for this plan.

1:11:57 What he was really looking for, I think,

1:11:59 was something that'll help guide future decisions

1:12:02 on neighborhood and community parks.

1:12:07 And this map particularly really does that really well.

1:12:12 for the city. And this map I think was one of Dennis's primary goals in this plan would

1:12:18 produce something like this tool so that when he has developments that are coming in, do we

1:12:24 ask for park dedication, for a neighborhood park, or do we ask for fees? And was it in

1:12:29 the right location? And how many more neighborhood parks do we really need? And those were really

1:12:34 the kinds of questions that Dennis was really struggling with that prompted him to want to

1:12:40 to go do this plan in the first place.

1:12:42 And the fact that we have agra falls and shoshone falls

1:12:45 and Centennial Park are fantastic and they're there,

1:12:49 but they don't like was just said,

1:12:52 they don't really change our future need

1:12:55 for community and regional park.

1:12:57 And what I'm hearing the presentation tonight is,

1:13:00 is yeah, it says we have 3.4 or whatever,

1:13:03 whatever that I can tell, 4.314.

1:13:06 But let's not focus on that so much

1:13:07 because we have some really unique circumstances

1:13:11 about our community that we need to recognize.

1:13:13 And yes, we have these world-class, fantastic parks.

1:13:16 We're not ever going to recreate Shoshone Falls Park,

1:13:20 but we do need future neighborhood parks

1:13:22 in future neighborhoods.

1:13:23 And we do need future community parks

1:13:25 to serve our growing area.

1:13:28 And this plan, that was one of his primary goals,

1:13:31 and that's why I think the direction kind of came out

1:13:33 the way it did back in the beginning,

1:13:35 is that was really one of the ultimate goals of having this plan.

1:13:40 And I think it does that pretty well.

1:13:43 I also agree that I felt like maybe we're downplaying what we already have.

1:13:50 But myself, I've kind of got past that because this is helping us guide our future

1:13:57 more than look at what we have.

1:14:00 And I think that's probably a good goal for us is to,

1:14:04 How is this going to help us moving forward?

1:14:08 And this particular map here, I think,

1:14:10 does a pretty good job of that.

1:14:12 It tells us where we need to be focused on.

1:14:14 And I think if Dennis were sitting here,

1:14:16 he would tell you this is what he was looking for.

1:14:18 And this is what he needs in order

1:14:21 to make this thing a success.

1:14:24 And trying to speak for him a little bit here,

1:14:27 I know, but that's going to take heart.

1:14:30 So this is really more of an internal document anyway.

1:14:32 It's not something that's going to be out shared.

1:14:34 This is going to be something that Wendy will use when she's working with development folks.

1:14:42 This is going to be something that Wendy's going to use for long-term planning.

1:14:45 But it's not going to be hidden away on a shelf or anything like that.

1:14:49 So it certainly is a public document.

1:14:51 But yeah, it's going to be something that helps us do the job that we need to be doing.

1:14:57 I can't agree with this regard more than it's not going to be a public document.

1:15:01 a company like Cliffbar will look at that data and it may make the difference

1:15:06 before between them coming to Twin Falls and not. And that map shows auger falls

1:15:11 in green right now on why it's not included in our 3.42 ratio. It's mind-boggling.

1:15:19 Great. Well I guess I'm gonna go with Mitch a little bit on this. To me the

1:15:25 other is just a number that I really can't compare to anything else and I

1:15:30 think about Auger Falls and I think let's think about the first federal and

1:15:35 the Sunway Soccer Fields. That park sees more people on a Saturday during

1:15:40 soccer season than Auger Falls will all year long and so I don't know if they

1:15:47 can be compared to the same to me. I mean if you're out there on a Saturday

1:15:51 morning to the Sunway Soccer Complex that parking lot is full all day long and

1:15:55 it's a transfer of cars. People come in their kids play for an hour and they

1:15:58 leaving another thousand kids show up and they play for an hour and another thousand

1:16:03 kids show up in their families. And so you really can't compare some of the

1:16:07 copper, the soccer complex and the new federal, first federal park there with

1:16:13 Auger Falls, which is a more individualized group. It's hikers, it's bikers, and they

1:16:19 certainly have their, it has its niche and it has its place in our deal. But to me,

1:16:23 the other is just a number. This is more when I was, since we're already

1:16:26 Where should we put our neighborhood parks?

1:16:29 We have those other parks, and sure,

1:16:31 if you'll have to throw the number in it,

1:16:32 or not throw the number, I really don't care.

1:16:34 But this is what we needed, not some number that I can look at

1:16:40 unless I have somebody else's exact number to compare to.

1:16:43 And we're still gonna be blown away by places like Meridian

1:16:46 that I put in 300 acre parks like crazy, yeah, maybe not.

1:16:50 But it seems like they've put in some really big parks of late.

1:16:54 And, but I guess you can present their populations

1:16:56 80,000 Tuesday, get a look at that way.

1:16:58 To me it's just a number, this is what I was,

1:17:01 whenever Dennis first proposed it,

1:17:03 that's what I was hoping we would get.

1:17:05 Where to put the parks in the city to serve the citizens?

1:17:09 And the other number, don't put them in,

1:17:11 they didn't really matter to me,

1:17:13 it's just a number.

1:17:15 This is something we can use to plan our growth.

1:17:19 In adding those other parks in, I can see why you want to do that, that gives you as much

1:17:27 health you're looking number.

1:17:31 Again, it doesn't change where we need neighborhood and community parks, however, if that number

1:17:39 goes up and then you rely on that number to decide how much more you need in the future,

1:17:46 going to need it's going to show less than what this will show. Don. I don't think it's

1:17:52 mutually exclusive to the number versus the the the need. I think that we're

1:18:00 rational human beings and that we can look at the need. Your map will show

1:18:04 that whatever the number says that we need a neighborhood park here and

1:18:09 neighborhood park here. But I just think we're underselling what we truly have in

1:18:14 our community. These are, I'm going to say it again, world-class parks. There are places

1:18:21 that would dream to have agar falls or shoshone falls. And I will compare shoshone falls population

1:18:28 going down there every week too, especially when the falls are running. I know you've stayed

1:18:32 away from shoshone falls. So I don't think we're arguing here. I just, I personally think

1:18:38 that that number should reflect the other parks. And we will still have a focus on knowing

1:18:44 that we need regional and neighborhood, not regional, neighborhood parks.

1:18:48 Travis?

1:18:49 Okay.

1:18:52 So when I look at our park system, and you'll see that maybe this is an opportunity for staff

1:18:57 to either slightly disagree.

1:19:01 When I look at our park system, I don't think of just green grass manicured parks as being

1:19:09 the only place of value.

1:19:13 Because when I think about what agra falls brings to members of our community, you can't

1:19:19 get that on green grass man if you're manicured parks.

1:19:24 And when I think of what Shoshone Falls brings and Durkys Lake Springs, that's not going

1:19:30 to be at the same place that Sunway Soccer Field is or an ADA all accessible park or splash

1:19:37 pad.

1:19:39 It's the same holds true that what you want to achieve from a recreational output is probably best achieved at Sunway.

1:19:46 That may not be able to be achieved down at Augra Falls.

1:19:49 And so I think that when you look at the totality of the city's park lands and park systems,

1:19:58 I think that by just focusing on 3.42 acres, I think that's the right number, right?

1:20:04 is a disservice to the overall park system that we have.

1:20:11 But 3.42 acres is relevant if you're going to look at

1:20:16 neighborhood parks as its only number.

1:20:20 And so I think there really needs to be maybe two numbers that are presented here.

1:20:25 One number that represents all of the total open space recreational acres

1:20:32 that are available to our members of our community.

1:20:37 And then another subset that talks about

1:20:42 that are more reserved for neighborhoods,

1:20:46 neighborhood park systems, and those type of things.

1:20:50 Because if the goal is to establish more neighborhood parks,

1:20:56 that's one output.

1:20:58 If the goal is to establish more open space,

1:21:01 say the opportunity to expand, Augur Falls came to us, and we chose to go down that option

1:21:10 and move down that path, and you invested hundreds of thousands of dollars in that acquisition,

1:21:17 it wouldn't move the 3.42 needle, but it would greatly expand recreational opportunities

1:21:25 or could expand recreational opportunities inside of our community.

1:21:28 So I do agree with Mitch and the fact that the 3.42 is probably slightly misleading and

1:21:37 not something that we should focus on in its totality.

1:21:41 But I think that we need to also give, the plan needs to give credit for all of the other

1:21:47 acreages that are not included in the 3.42 number.

1:21:52 I'm going to go just real quick way in along with what Travis was just saying.

1:21:56 And I think it's important that the public also realizes how much responsibility our parks and

1:22:01 rec department has and how much land they do have to oversee and take care of.

1:22:06 And by leaving that out, I think you're doing a disservice to the parks and rec department itself and the responsibility that they have.

1:22:14 So I feel like I could live with having both figures in there, but I do think it needs to be recognized more clearly as to how much they are responsible for

1:22:25 a total amount of property.

1:22:29 And that's something we can easily do.

1:22:32 These parks you're talking about have been designated by your city as regional parks.

1:22:39 Because they're regional, that's why they're not counted.

1:22:41 If you want a complete number that includes regional, that's easy to add into this very

1:22:49 easily.

1:22:50 I'm going to interrupt you one more time here, Don.

1:22:52 I would just add too.

1:22:53 I hate to be the ones keep bringing this up up, but the trail system, I think you say it's eight feet wide and it's 42 miles long, whatever it is, and add that.

1:23:03 I think the trail system converted to acres.

1:23:07 Yeah, I think that's easily enough done because we know how long the trail is.

1:23:13 We know on average it's so wide and I think we need to have credit for that too.

1:23:17 I mean, Suzanne brings a really good point up about the guess who has to take care of that trail system, the city, the city, employees, those folks, and that's another amenity that we have that other communities would dream of having.

1:23:30 So I think that needs to be added as well.

1:23:32 There's no lights, so if you want to finish, now's your chance.

1:23:38 I'm done.

1:23:39 Okay.

1:23:40 I'm done.

1:23:41 I'm done.

1:23:42 I'm done.

1:23:43 Didn't mean to scare you away.

1:23:45 Wendy, I think you're batting clean up.

1:23:48 please come back you know I I'm not sure exactly that I you know we we manage

1:24:00 1,478 acres of parkland and open space that does include airport property and

1:24:09 then we have 20,050 linear feet of Snake River Canyon Trail and that is as of

1:24:14 January of 2015 and so we've added some acreage to that and some linear feet to

1:24:19 that, but that's approximately where we sit. You know, one of the things that I was thinking

1:24:23 is everybody was talking about the ratio and the level of service. If you calculate these

1:24:29 regional parks into that, we set a level of service that may be harder to maintain as we

1:24:33 move forward to say that if we're going to call out our level of service and let's say

1:24:38 that we have these acreages in and we come up with a level of service that is more like

1:24:43 eight acres per thousand or something, and then trying to maintain that moving forward,

1:24:55 that might not be as reasonable an expectation as to try to maintain 3.42.

1:25:02 If we look at a total build out, we're looking at 70 to 140 acres of acquired park land at

1:25:10 that 3.42 and if we take that level up,

1:25:13 we may be setting ourselves up for potential failure,

1:25:17 trying to keep at that level if we use that in our calculations.

1:25:21 So that's just something to think about.

1:25:24 I think that a couple of things that I wanted to talk about,

1:25:26 just to kind of finish up, is obviously I inherited this.

1:25:31 I think that they finished the final draft in June,

1:25:35 and I showed up in July.

1:25:37 And so for me to kind of take this and embrace it and move forward, it's taken a little bit of time.

1:25:42 And I've gotten to a point now where I'm pretty comfortable with this document.

1:25:45 And we've had a few changes made to kind of accommodate some of my concerns and some of the things that I see.

1:25:53 But when you get back to what it is intended to do, I feel like this document does what we needed to do.

1:25:58 We've changed the language in a couple of areas.

1:26:00 We've added some information, we added another map to include school district properties.

1:26:05 in my mind, I feel like when we talk about service areas, you can see what looks like an

1:26:11 area of nothing, but then when you realize that there's a school playground right there,

1:26:16 it makes sense.

1:26:17 It makes sense that there's nothing there.

1:26:19 And so we added a few things like that to kind of accommodate that.

1:26:22 I think that identifying future park locations like it does, I think the GIS tool and the

1:26:33 ability for us to add those layers and take those layers away when we're evaluating as

1:26:37 we move forward.

1:26:38 I think it's going to give us what we need to talk to the development community as we move

1:26:42 forward and identify these areas and get some of that development out of them when we can.

1:26:48 I think that identifying the preferred amenities and using those as we move forward when we're

1:26:53 talking about parts development, adding amenities to parks, it gives us a clear direction in

1:26:59 the kinds of things that are important when we see that walking and exercise and trails

1:27:03 and shade and natural features are important to this community, we can take that into account

1:27:08 as we move forward in our planning. I think that it gives us a good basis to set goals

1:27:16 when we talk about capital improvements, when we talk about planning and budgeting and looking

1:27:22 at five and ten years down the road where we need to be. This plan specifically lines out

1:27:27 each park that exists and the kinds of improvements that are recommended to get it to the standards

1:27:33 that we set forth and the information we got out of the survey.

1:27:38 So I can take this if I wanted to and just go through park by park and it identifies improvements

1:27:45 that it recommends specifically to each individual park as it exists and then as well as talking

1:27:52 about future development.

1:27:54 So I think it gives us the stuff, it gives me the things that I think we need to move forward.

1:28:00 It gives me the tools to back up some of the recommendations that we can make.

1:28:04 We can tie things to this master plan that also would tie to the strategic plan.

1:28:10 As we move forward in budgeting with the city, I think that the recommendations are solid for the most part.

1:28:18 It gives us the flexibility to respond to changes.

1:28:21 gives us the flexibility to listen to the community

1:28:24 and see what the needs are.

1:28:27 And it kind of weighs out some of the personnel needs too.

1:28:33 If we start looking at acreages and looking at improving,

1:28:36 and we start to talk about where we need to be,

1:28:38 we can respond in staffing as well.

1:28:43 You know, when I look at what our current staff

1:28:46 is trying to maintain when we're talking about trails,

1:28:49 and we're talking about city properties,

1:28:50 and we're talking about parks and we're talking about

1:28:53 agar falls and and dirkies like in those kinds of things,

1:28:56 where do we need to be as we start to move forward

1:29:00 so that we don't look around when anything,

1:29:01 oh my God, we need to hire five people.

1:29:03 So, you know, trying to plan ahead,

1:29:05 it allows for that as well.

1:29:07 So I am at this point very comfortable with the document.

1:29:10 If you do see some things that you'd like to see

1:29:12 as change or add, I think we could still make

1:29:14 a couple of tweaks to it, but for the most part,

1:29:16 I think it does what we needed to do.

1:29:19 And I would support adopting it.

1:29:20 Okay, Don Hall.

1:29:22 So Wendy, would it be too much trouble

1:29:25 to try to get those two numbers?

1:29:26 The reason, I think Chris brought up a really good point too.

1:29:29 A lot of these businesses and companies

1:29:30 that are scouting your area,

1:29:32 you don't even know they're scouting yet.

1:29:34 And so they pour over our documents,

1:29:36 they come in and they interview people.

1:29:38 And they might just, I mean, if they see one community

1:29:41 that says they have this level of service

1:29:43 and this community that has this level of service,

1:29:45 that might be just enough for them

1:29:46 not to look at our community.

1:29:48 So I think that we need to give a true picture.

1:29:50 And this document is a public document.

1:29:53 It's not going to be tucked away on a shelf.

1:29:55 I'm assuming it's going to be on the web,

1:29:57 on our website, and advertised it as there.

1:30:01 So is it that big of a deal to make those two calculations?

1:30:03 I looked to our patients and scared Greg away.

1:30:05 All you did was went to that chair, right?

1:30:07 Kind of ran away.

1:30:08 So I'm going to do this.

1:30:09 So that would be a hard calculation to make it happen.

1:30:12 Is the council supportive of doing that?

1:30:14 I just looked at it.

1:30:15 I said, OK.

1:30:16 but not rolling it into that 3.42 figure, but as a side bar.

1:30:20 Yeah.

1:30:21 So we could talk about total level of service,

1:30:23 including the regional parks, and then we

1:30:25 could talk about projected level of service,

1:30:29 as far as neighborhood and communities.

1:30:31 Would that kind of do what we're talking about?

1:30:32 Can you live with that?

1:30:34 I think so.

1:30:35 And I think you bring a valid point

1:30:37 that you can't ignore those things,

1:30:39 and we cannot ignore those amenities and those features.

1:30:42 But to think that we could maintain it forever, sustain it,

1:30:45 moving forward might be difficult.

1:30:47 But if you want to look at it as far as what we're providing

1:30:51 and serving, I think that that's a very reasonable number

1:30:54 to include.

1:30:54 Let's brag on our community because it's a great community.

1:30:57 Thank you, boy.

1:30:58 An amazing park system.

1:30:59 We do.

1:31:00 And park director, too, incredible.

1:31:02 Yes, it does talk about that.

1:31:04 Go, Nicky, go.

1:31:05 Well, that's what I wanted to say is I

1:31:08 have the privilege of serving as a liaison to Parks and Rec.

1:31:10 And Wendy does have a fabulous team.

1:31:13 She is a fabulous leader.

1:31:15 And we need to adopt this so that we can actually get to work.

1:31:20 They need to take this direction, and they're going to have meetings all through, you know,

1:31:26 they're not skipping because it's winter or anything like that.

1:31:29 She has her commission geared up.

1:31:32 She's taken them and looked at parks, field trips, field trips to parks.

1:31:37 So if you haven't been there for a while, they went there.

1:31:40 They looked at it, and they can talk about what's needed.

1:31:44 and they can look at these recommendations.

1:31:47 And this is to be used as a tool.

1:31:49 This doesn't say that at this park,

1:31:51 we have to do these three things

1:31:53 and we can only do these three things.

1:31:55 This is our starting point.

1:31:57 This is a tool.

1:31:58 And I would really like to see

1:32:00 when to get this tool so she can start using it.

1:32:04 And if everybody's in agreement,

1:32:07 I'd like to make a motion.

1:32:08 Please do.

1:32:10 I move that we adopt the Twin Falls Parks and Recreation.

1:32:14 master plan as as presented in this draft it does have the year 2015 on it do

1:32:20 you need that in the motion we've got it updated okay you thought I could read

1:32:29 that from here really did you have anything else you like okay is there a

1:32:41 second I will second that motion as long as the caveat with what we discussed

1:32:45 is also placed within that motion is there any other discussion Sharon roll

1:32:55 call vote please Nicky Boyd yes Chris Tockington yes Greg Lanting yes Don Hall

1:33:06 yes Ruth Pierce yes Suzanne Hopkins yes motion passes 6 to 0 and Sharon I'm

1:33:12 sorry I did not repeat that motion are you okay okay I've never seen so much

1:33:19 It's controversial for parks and

1:33:22 It's all for the good

1:33:24 Good job. Thank you. Thank you very much

1:33:27 We appreciate your time tonight

1:33:31 Okay

1:33:32 Next on the agenda. We have a request to approve it can

1:33:36 to approve the construction of a regional grandview PI station in lua funding the

1:33:42 the P.I. Master Plan as approved in the fiscal year 17 budget and we have John

1:33:49 Caten. Thank you, Mayor. Good evening, Council. Okay, so sure. So we'd like to

1:34:02 construct the P.I. station now rather than later and I want to give you a

1:34:05 little bit of background on what we have going. So this year in this fiscal

1:34:10 year budget we have approved the P.I. Master Plan for $250,000. It's an

1:34:17 important thing for us to do. We need to do it. And so if we don't do it this year, we're

1:34:26 going to ask for it in one-term plan through this process that we're going through. So

1:34:31 you'll see it again in the near future. But the reason why we'd like to forgo that is because

1:34:37 we've been recently approached by developers and we never know the timing of development,

1:34:41 you know, as you know. And the city has an opportunity here that I just wanted to share

1:34:47 with you. So, right now, let me orient you to the map. This is Grandview and this is

1:34:54 Pullline. This is Settler's Bridge Subdivision. This is hometown subdivision, northern passage,

1:35:03 and this is Grandview. All three have been plattered. This Grandview is the only one of the three

1:35:11 that has the requirement to participate in the construction of a PI station. The other two

1:35:18 The other two came in, they've been grandfather Dan,

1:35:22 that it was before the requirement was made.

1:35:25 So, this developer here is required, the OPI station,

1:35:32 and they're going to go.

1:35:34 And we have all this acreage and parts of the Settlers Ridge.

1:35:38 As you know, we have a Settlers Ridge PI station over here,

1:35:42 and it provides irrigation to this subdivision.

1:35:45 It's getting built out.

1:35:46 We also have the school here in this area and

1:35:50 Point that out for reference to the school, please

1:35:53 schools, right? Okay here. Thank you and

1:35:59 See the proposed the proposal right now is to put the PI station right here and

1:36:06 The opportunity here would be so every subdivision

1:36:11 Would need to build a PI station

1:36:13 And ideally, we don't want to be taking care of 20 or 30 more

1:36:19 P.I. station scattered throughout.

1:36:21 So we have an opportunity to build a regional station here.

1:36:24 The city is on the hook to construct a station for these

1:36:28 plats that were platted prior.

1:36:31 And then this developer is on the hook to participate.

1:36:34 And this person could develop on their own, but we'd rather

1:36:38 they go into our regional station.

1:36:41 In order to do that, we have an estimate for the improvements of $250,000, which is the exact

1:36:50 amount that we had in for our P.I. master plan.

1:36:52 So the thought was to go ahead, that's the total cost that doesn't include any pro-rata

1:36:58 share of the participating developer.

1:37:03 But they would, they'd pay their fair share.

1:37:05 The station built out is about this best to talk in acreage.

1:37:09 So again, these are 40 acres subdivisions here.

1:37:14 And this station would be designed at 260 acres.

1:37:21 So that's like 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6.

1:37:25 Basically all the blue.

1:37:27 Now I just want to point out, we're not saying that we're

1:37:29 going to serve the blue, we can serve 267 acres.

1:37:34 And the reason I'm saying that is with our PI stations,

1:37:37 We have a limited amount of supply and shares that come into the station.

1:37:41 And basically, it's first come, first serve, meaning if you live in this area and your shares

1:37:48 can transfer to the station and you want in, we'll let you buy in rather than build your

1:37:53 own station.

1:37:54 So we look up over here to the west side of Grandview, it's way more accurate than this

1:38:00 station will handle.

1:38:02 But in our PI Master Plan, we'll think about how we're going to do this and an opportunity

1:38:07 would be to build to maybe duplicate this station.

1:38:11 So it's kind of nice to build in phases.

1:38:15 And that's what we probably do here.

1:38:18 So at this time, I'd like to stand for any questions

1:38:23 and propose that we go ahead and move forward

1:38:25 with the construction of this PI station now.

1:38:28 We do have lights.

1:38:29 OK.

1:38:30 Greg.

1:38:31 John, show me the two areas that don't have to participate again.

1:38:36 This 40 acres hometown, and this is northern passage,

1:38:41 those two, they platted prior to the PI station requirements.

1:38:46 They have PI pipe in, and there's a vision,

1:38:51 just not the station.

1:38:52 Oh, I said, okay, okay, now I'm kind of catching up here

1:38:55 a little bit because we did change the rules

1:38:57 from they putting it in, from us putting it into them,

1:39:03 putting it in, it just makes me wonder,

1:39:06 The hometown's building out and everything up there.

1:39:08 That's a subdivision that's around the school.

1:39:10 Yeah, it seems like there's been setting

1:39:12 there for a long time, but we need to start putting in

1:39:15 the things that we add a new rule.

1:39:16 And you don't build out for two years after that rule,

1:39:19 that rule takes effect to you as well.

1:39:21 I mean, I'm trying to figure out.

1:39:24 It just seems like the brand new subdivision,

1:39:26 people have just came up with the idea to put in

1:39:29 and they put it in, they're stuck for

1:39:30 paying for the PI station, but somebody

1:39:33 has been sitting on the property for 10 years, at least here,

1:39:38 and they're not have to participate in the same levels.

1:39:41 It's like an unleveled playing field to me.

1:39:43 At some point, it can be unfair for both parties,

1:39:46 because if we change the rules after we agree,

1:39:48 and it's a real short period of time,

1:39:50 and it's not very fair, but you're right.

1:39:51 If you sit on it forever, you shouldn't sit on short.

1:39:53 10 years, and you don't build.

1:39:55 I mean, it just seems like there's something

1:39:58 where we can work that into the way our subdivision

1:40:01 agreements or something.

1:40:02 Thank you, I'm just being carpeted and I don't get so sorry.

1:40:06 Chris.

1:40:07 John, are we budgeted for this regional PI this year in the budget?

1:40:12 No, just to be clear, we are not budgeted for this PI station construction.

1:40:16 We're budgeted for the PI master plan.

1:40:18 And so what I'd like to propose is we defer writing the master plan so

1:40:24 that we can construct this.

1:40:25 I understand.

1:40:25 Thank you.

1:40:27 Any other questions for John?

1:40:31 Seeing none, great.

1:40:33 I move that we approve the construction of the regional Grandview PI station now in

1:40:37 lieu of funding the PI master plan as approved in the

1:40:41 2000, or fiscal year 2017 budget.

1:40:45 Second.

1:40:47 We have a motion on the floor by Greg, seconded by Chris.

1:40:50 Is there any more discussion?

1:40:54 Sharon Roll call vote please.

1:41:00 Chris Tockington.

1:41:01 Yes.

1:41:02 Greg Lanting.

1:41:03 Yes.

1:41:03 Don Hall.

1:41:05 Yes.

1:41:05 Ruth Pears.

1:41:05 Yes.

1:41:06 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:41:07 Yes.

1:41:08 Nikki Boyd.

1:41:09 Yes. Motion passes six to zero.

1:41:12 Thank you, John.

1:41:14 Thank you. Appreciate you looking out for us.

1:41:17 Thanks. At this time,

1:41:21 we are going to take public input from the City Manager or City Council.

1:41:26 Is there anything for anyone tonight?

1:41:28 Chris. I have two points.

1:41:32 I've had contact in the last couple of days about the Chobani pretreatment plant,

1:41:38 Travis, the motor control abatement plan apparently is either out of tolerance, out of whack,

1:41:46 not working or something, but there was some people gasping for air in their terms.

1:41:51 So if you look into that.

1:41:53 Now the other thing just to reiterate that today's urban renewal meeting,

1:41:58 the scheduling for the bidding for the downtown project is going to commence the first couple of weeks of January.

1:42:05 The beds maximum cost bidding will be released in February and construction is

1:42:14 Anticipated to begin in March

1:42:17 Thank you Chris. I'd just like to remind council that we are starting at 3 30 next Monday

1:42:22 So everybody has that on their calendar to be here on time

1:42:29 Pardon me legislative

1:42:33 Okay

1:42:35 All righty, so it is after six o'clock we've done well and we are going to move on to a public hearing tonight

1:42:43 We have a request for a zoning district change and zoning map

1:42:47 Amendment from our four to see one for the undeveloped property on Filer Avenue West and

1:42:53 Located West of 515 Washington Street, North and it looks like Jonathan's spin love is going to present tonight

1:43:01 Hi Jonathan

1:43:04 The applicant is going to be represented by Dave Tebow.

1:43:07 He'll do his presentation first.

1:43:09 Okay, perfect, thank you.

1:43:13 Welcome, Dave.

1:43:15 Good evening, Mayor, members of the council.

1:43:17 My name is David Tebow, the EHM engineers at 621,

1:43:20 North College Road here in Twin Falls.

1:43:22 And I'm representing Dan Willy and Troy Willy tonight

1:43:26 who are the operators of the Oasis Stop

1:43:28 and Goes gas stations that we have in the city.

1:43:32 We're talking this evening about their filer,

1:43:35 Avenue in Washington's North property,

1:43:40 which is located right here.

1:43:43 And they are operating this facility

1:43:47 on behalf of Jackson Oil,

1:43:49 and they own the property to the West.

1:43:51 And that's a vacant lot that's currently zoned our four.

1:43:55 They've recently cleared up the weeds,

1:43:58 placed some gravel,

1:43:59 used some of the gravel that was salvaged

1:44:00 from their Hankins project that's newly opened

1:44:03 and available for use and leveled out the site

1:44:08 and as such they received notice that if they were going

1:44:11 to develop a parking area on this property

1:44:13 they needed to get it zoned and receive a special use permit.

1:44:16 So we began the process and started creating exhibits

1:44:20 and made an application to do so

1:44:22 and we've gone through the Planning and Zoning Commission

1:44:24 and received a positive recommendation

1:44:26 to have this property rezoned from R4 to the C1 zone.

1:44:30 In order to allow this particular facility to experience some improvements

1:44:36 the owners I believe intend to

1:44:39 develop a parking area

1:44:41 We'll have some associated stormwater retention and whatnot and there was a list of

1:44:46 Conditions that the Planning and Zoning Commission

1:44:49 recommended that we have placed on on the

1:44:53 Rezone and the special use permit and we've reviewed those conditions

1:44:56 I believe there's nine of them and and we don't have any real objections to any of them

1:45:00 We received some input from the neighbors to the west about some noise and the potential

1:45:05 for some camera surveillance cameras and security and that's acceptable and then also

1:45:12 there's a buffer requirement of about seven feet for landscaping so that we're not bumping

1:45:18 into the fence with the nose of our vehicles or the rear end of our vehicle.

1:45:23 All of these conditions have been given to the willies and we're here to just request

1:45:28 that you rezone it and we're

1:45:30 amenable to the conditions that were placed on it.

1:45:35 Thank you. We have a question from Chris.

1:45:37 Yeah. Right across the street on

1:45:39 Filer is another R4. What is that a residence

1:45:43 or what's the occupant there? Do you recall?

1:45:46 Are you talking about right here?

1:45:48 Right there. Yeah. I believe that is a residence.

1:45:51 And have they been contacted?

1:45:54 I believe so. I believe that.

1:45:56 where they had the opportunity at PNC, sir.

1:45:58 That is correct, yeah.

1:45:59 I believe they were notified.

1:46:01 Thank you.

1:46:02 Of the public hearings.

1:46:03 And the sign was posted.

1:46:04 I think there's better detail.

1:46:13 You can see the improvements that were made with the gravel

1:46:16 and that the vegetation was cleaned up,

1:46:18 and the weeds were cleaned up.

1:46:20 And right here, I'm sure that property was notified.

1:46:22 There is a sign advertising the public hearing

1:46:25 sitting right in this location.

1:46:27 And has been there since we were scheduled

1:46:29 for the planning and zoning.

1:46:31 Thank you.

1:46:32 I stand for any other questions that Councilman had to say don't go too far away.

1:46:38 Okay, Jonathan.

1:46:41 Thank you.

1:46:42 So the history of it, um, pertinent history, part of the subdivision back in 1938 over the years, um,

1:46:49 they've rezoned a bunch of properties with that zoning map.

1:46:56 Most everything along Washington now has been rezoned to see one.

1:47:00 That was due to back in the, basically 1993 is when it kind of started with that

1:47:04 original comprehensive plan designated some of this as office after that in 2009 they

1:47:09 redesignated it as like a commercial type corridor. Some of this when I say back in the

1:47:16 day at some point we actually had a C1, C2 and C3 zoning districts. We departed from the

1:47:24 C2 and C3 which were less intensive than we just went with the C1 which is the highway

1:47:28 commercial. At some point some of these were zones C2 and C3 when we got rid of those districts

1:47:34 and no longer had them in our code, they were reverted to C1.

1:47:37 So that's kind of how we get this commercial along Washington,

1:47:41 even the Washington's not a highway,

1:47:43 because that's what C1 is commercial highway.

1:47:45 So over the years, they've rezoned most of those along the corridor.

1:47:50 The gas station on the corner originally constructed in 1985

1:47:54 as a circle-k food store, and then in 1999,

1:47:57 converted to the Oasis convenience store.

1:48:00 So, as we're looking at a rezone of the property,

1:48:08 this is the future land use map

1:48:10 that is located in the comprehensive plan,

1:48:13 not the new one that we just adopted.

1:48:16 This application came in before.

1:48:18 That was adopted, so we're under the old one,

1:48:20 just for a few applications.

1:48:22 Designates this whole corridor as like a retail

1:48:26 or residential business type of application.

1:48:29 We've used that for multiple rezones along Washington

1:48:32 has appropriate for the C1 zoning designation.

1:48:37 Many of the properties have also been converted to offices

1:48:42 or other businesses recently across the street.

1:48:45 There's a new one over here that was recently built.

1:48:48 The public's down here.

1:48:50 Those are recent developments in the last few years.

1:48:54 As we're reviewing this request for a rezone,

1:48:57 for the zoning use of change in zoning map amendment,

1:48:59 the council has two main tasks.

1:49:01 Number one is to determine whether the request

1:49:03 in conformance with the comprehensive plan and the future land use map.

1:49:07 And number two is to evaluate the request to determine the extent and nature of the amendment

1:49:12 requested.

1:49:13 The comprehensive plan indicates this corridor as appropriate for residential business type

1:49:17 uses or commercial uses.

1:49:19 On November 8th, 2016, a public hearing was conducted with the Planning and Zoning Commission.

1:49:24 After the public hearing, all commissioners present made a positive recommendation for the zoning

1:49:29 change.

1:49:30 So everyone there voted for it.

1:49:33 The conclusion that Council's asked to make a decision on this request, Council's decision

1:49:37 may be to deny the request, approve the request as presented or request additional information

1:49:41 be provided.

1:49:43 Dave did mention at that same meeting we had a special use permit request separate from

1:49:48 the rezone.

1:49:49 They're somewhat connected.

1:49:51 There were nine conditions.

1:49:52 One of the conditions was they approved the special use permit to expand that parking lot

1:49:57 only if the rezone was approved.

1:49:59 So he's referencing some things, not necessarily part of the rezone, but they did him at the

1:50:03 same time.

1:50:04 If you want to see those conditions, I have them ready if you'd like to see them.

1:50:09 And any other questions?

1:50:11 Thank you.

1:50:12 I believe those conditions were attached to our packet, so we should have all had a chance

1:50:15 to review them.

1:50:16 Are there any questions for Jonathan from Council?

1:50:21 I think we're good.

1:50:22 We'll go ahead then and open up the public hearing portion of this request.

1:50:26 It doesn't need a tap, does it?

1:50:28 I don't know.

1:50:29 There we go.

1:50:30 need a tap will open it and see no one coming forward. We will close the public hearing.

1:50:39 And I will turn it over to Council. Great.

1:50:45 I came here. I was going to get there. So thanks for the help. I move that we have proved

1:50:56 the request of a zoning district change and zoning map amendment from R4 to C1 for the

1:51:01 develop property on file or everything west located west of 515 Washington Street North.

1:51:08 Second.

1:51:09 Second.

1:51:11 The conditions are for the special.

1:51:13 The conditions are for the special views.

1:51:14 The conditions are for the special views.

1:51:15 They're not on this.

1:51:16 I can't put special.

1:51:17 Okay, and I have Nikki for the second on that motion.

1:51:20 So we have a motion by Greg, seconded by Nikki to approve the zoning district change

1:51:26 and map amendment from R4 to C1.

1:51:29 Is there any discussion from the council?

1:51:32 I have two lights on.

1:51:35 Sharon roll call vote please.

1:51:40 Chris Hockington?

1:51:41 Yes.

1:51:42 Reglanting?

1:51:43 Yes.

1:51:44 Don Hall?

1:51:45 Yes.

1:51:45 Ruth Pierce?

1:51:46 Yes.

1:51:47 Suzanne Hawkins?

1:51:48 Yes.

1:51:48 Nikki Boyd?

1:51:49 Yes.

1:51:50 Motion passes six to zero.

1:51:52 Thank you very much, Dave.

1:51:54 Have a good evening.

1:51:58 So I neglected to ask if there was anybody in the public

1:52:02 earlier who had any comments.

1:52:03 But I'm thinking we're probably good to move on and we have requests to adjourn into executive session tonight under Idaho Code 74-206-1A to consider hiring a public officer,

1:52:19 employee, staff member or individual agent wherein the respective qualities of the individual are to be evaluated in order to fill a particular vacancy or need.

1:52:29 This paragraph does not apply to filling a vacancy in an elective office or deliberations

1:52:34 about staffing needs in general.

1:52:37 Don Hall.

1:52:38 Point of clarification.

1:52:39 You did ask for public input.

1:52:41 Oh, okay.

1:52:42 Thank you.

1:52:43 And secondarily, I move that motion, please.

1:52:47 I'll second that.

1:52:52 Okay.

1:52:54 We have a motion by Don, seconded by Ruth, to go into executive session under the aforementioned

1:53:02 reason. We'll call vote, please, Sharon, Greg Lanting, Don Hall, Ruth Pierce, Suzanne Hawkins,

1:53:12 Nikki Boyd, Chris Tockington, motion passes six to zero. And just to let the public know,

1:53:19 we will not be making any final decisions in executive session. And we will not be coming

1:53:24 back out to conduct a new or business tonight. Thank you for attending.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, December 12, 2016. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:53:38.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    34cfe7cfc2821b4cff85a3076408ec4927cc3fed72bcfba89b068e1e5b1335ea
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 6b195379203f1eebb015b98f3e7f8528c96ebb8a2f2e18d1809a7e4a8f15c709
    part02.m4a 74534aabdf6915f68a9492519a9d3d3ee0e8de7d05da13f18a030b936417a41e
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    a24ab40952d821756dd892d3b9510fbc80afa39aa54c539c348c75ed4b7a747f

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file