OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Tuesday, January 17, 2017

Special meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Minutes on file

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:08:42 We good chair. I'd like to call to order the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council for Tuesday January 17th

0:08:50 The first order of business for those of you wishing to join us please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance

0:08:54 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:09:11 I would confirm we do have a quorum of the council, so five of the six current members of the city council are here.

0:09:23 Councilman Lansing is absent this evening.

0:09:25 Mr. Rothweller, do we have any amendments to the agenda?

0:09:28 Mr. Mayor and members of the council, there are no amendments.

0:09:30 Excellent. So we are going to have now the swearing-in ceremony for Christopher Reed

0:09:37 for our new city councilman. So Chris if you want to come forward photo

0:09:56 of the United States and the Constitution of the State of Idaho, and that I will faithfully

0:10:19 discharge, that I will faithfully discharge the duties of council persons with you, the

0:10:24 of the City of Twin Falls according to the best of my ability.

0:10:43 I think it's...

0:10:47 And I need to read you the best of my ability.

0:11:04 Easy parts over now, Reid.

0:11:07 So welcome, Christopher. Would you like to say a few words?

0:11:17 I'm sure I'll have a few words later on.

0:11:20 Alright, great.

0:11:23 So next on the agenda. Oh, welcome.

0:11:26 Welcome, Councilman Lansing.

0:11:29 Next on the agenda of proclamations of which we have none. So now is general public input

0:11:34 This is an opportunity for anyone from the public wishing to address the council on an issue not on this evening's agenda

0:11:40 Now is your chance to come forward and speak and seeing no one we will move on with the agenda

0:11:48 The first item for consideration is the consent calendar

0:11:53 Council wishes Suzanne

0:11:54 Move approval of the consent calendar

0:11:56 Motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Nikki Boyd to approve the consent calendar.

0:12:04 Is there any discussion?

0:12:06 Seeing none, chair and roll call vote please.

0:12:09 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:12:11 Yes.

0:12:11 Nikki Boyd.

0:12:12 Yes.

0:12:13 Sean Beriker.

0:12:14 Yes.

0:12:14 Chris Hockington.

0:12:15 Yes.

0:12:16 Greg Lanting.

0:12:18 Christopher Reed.

0:12:19 Yes.

0:12:20 Ruth Pierce.

0:12:21 Yes.

0:12:21 Motion passes 7-0.

0:12:24 Under items for consideration, the first is a presentation of a service plaque to Don

0:12:28 Hall in recognition of his service on the Twin Falls City Council.

0:12:32 So we've asked former councilman Hall and now commissioner

0:12:35 Hall to come join us this evening.

0:12:37 I'm going to go ahead and read this certificate.

0:12:39 And then Don, you can come forward and say a few words

0:12:42 and accept it.

0:12:44 We, the mayor and city council of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho,

0:12:47 do hereby award this certificate to Don Hall in recognition

0:12:51 of his 11 years of service to this great city and its residents

0:12:55 as a member of the city council.

0:12:57 We do express our sincere gratitude and honor him

0:13:00 for his demonstrated civic pride and duty,

0:13:02 reminiscent of that of the ancient Athenians.

0:13:06 And on this certificate, as with most of the certificates

0:13:09 that we give out to those who serve our community,

0:13:12 is the Athenian oath.

0:13:13 And I'm gonna take a moment to read through this,

0:13:15 and although it says city quite often in it,

0:13:18 I'm sure that those same principles

0:13:20 will convey to the county as well.

0:13:23 The Athenian oath, we will never bring disgrace

0:13:26 this our city by any act of dishonesty or cowardice, nor ever desert our suffering comrades in the

0:13:33 ranks. We will fight for the ideals and sacred things of the city, both alone and with many.

0:13:39 We will revere and obey this city's laws and do our best to incite to a like respect and reverence

0:13:46 those who are prone to annul or set them at naught. We will strive unceasingly to

0:13:53 quicken the public sense of public duty, that this in all these ways, we will transmit this city

0:14:00 not only, not less, but greater, better and more beautiful than it was transmitted to us.

0:15:07 I just wanted to say a couple of things. I'll keep it brief. My journey with the city actually

0:15:13 began in 1980, October 10, actually, in 1988, when I took an office, a police officer for this fine

0:15:20 city and I was outside of the city employment or service for about six years but even during

0:15:28 that time when I was working for the Boys and Girls Club before I became a council member

0:15:33 I was on committees and the like for the city and I don't see any change in my future either.

0:15:38 I believe in our community, I believe in the city and I charge all of you to take really

0:15:44 really good care of the city.

0:15:46 I am extremely pleased that we have council member Reid in his position.

0:15:52 I know that he's going to serve this community extremely well and I just really wanted to say

0:15:57 thank you to the staff.

0:15:59 It's been a pleasure and an honor and to my fellow council members.

0:16:04 Thank you.

0:16:05 Thank you, John.

0:16:10 So, hey, John, before you sneak out, we have a couple of lights on up here, which you'll

0:16:15 know what that means.

0:16:18 So I promised Don I wouldn't cry if he wouldn't cry so I'm not gonna cry but Don and I've been friends for years and years and he

0:16:27 Was instrumental in me being on the council the only negative thing about sitting next to him is

0:16:33 That he would flip on my light when he thought I should talk and I will not miss that but everything else on me

0:16:40 Yes, thank you so much, Don. Thank you. It's great Lansing. Well Don you and I came on same time

0:16:45 time we knew each other before. We came friends I think during the orientation and we found

0:16:52 that we had strengths and we had gaps and we had to overlap. We didn't have the same strengths

0:16:58 and we didn't have the same gaps and we had a whole lot of gaps. But we both had and certainly

0:17:06 been an honor to serve with you and have a little magic value memories that I think will

0:17:13 give you a few ganyones as well. Suzanne Hawkins.

0:17:19 Thank you, darling. Thank you so much for being a friend in the mid-term. When I was new in this position and wasn't sure how to address things, you were always there to help me boost my confidence and help me grow and who I am in the position I serve in.

0:17:35 Thank you for asking me to be your vice mayor last time. It was really nice working with you and I'm anxious to spend more time with you and Jim and do fun things now that were no longer going to be looking out for you.

0:17:47 you know, for all those, how many of us are together?

0:17:50 Well, Don, just a couple of final thoughts for me.

0:17:56 So I read the plaque, so that made my speech easy.

0:18:00 But on a personal note, in addition to your service, I appreciate the leadership that you

0:18:05 gave to this council, both as the mayor and not as the mayor, just as a fellow council

0:18:10 member.

0:18:11 I think you challenge staff, you challenge the rest of us to do a better job in how we

0:18:17 we do our jobs and I trust that you're going to take that same conviction and

0:18:21 dedication to the county as well.

0:18:25 So I look forward to your service there.

0:18:27 I look forward to great opportunities to strengthen partnerships and

0:18:31 continue to serve the community.

0:18:32 So thank you, Don.

0:18:33 Thank you for the kind words and you almost had me.

0:18:36 And so thank you for quick.

0:18:38 And I think I'd just like to echo that we are going to work together.

0:18:44 County and the city are serving the same people and we need to work together and

0:18:48 I look forward to doing that with all of you. Thank you. Thank you Don. I only

0:18:53 want to say one thing Don it's okay you can sit down. I think we need to give

0:18:58 a special round of applause to your beautiful bride she first standing by

0:19:02 you throughout all these years so thank you Jen. So I think Don is that through

0:19:13 enough of these council meetings to know that he is not planning to sit back down

0:19:16 He's going to sneak right out the back door because his item is done on the agenda.

0:19:21 Thank you, Don.

0:19:25 Next on the agenda is a request to confirm the appointment of Gretchen G. Scott as the new human resources director, effective January 23rd, 2017.

0:19:34 We have our city manager, Travis Rothweiler. Welcome, Travis.

0:19:37 Mr. Mayor, members of council, before I begin, I think it's also important to recognize another individual with our organization who is to

0:19:48 at their last council member, at their last meeting as a member of the city staff, and that is Susan Harris.

0:19:55 Susan has worked for our organization for over 30 years.

0:20:08 She has really built a leadership legacy, has implemented great programs, has brought new practices,

0:20:17 and always helped make sure that we were following rules, laws, regulations,

0:20:23 in striving to be a better organization.

0:20:26 We're gonna have the opportunity to spend time

0:20:29 celebrating Susan's retirement this Thursday,

0:20:32 but it would be completely remissed

0:20:34 if we didn't congratulate her for her role

0:20:36 and her responsibility with the city for that 30 years.

0:21:00 Mr. Mayor, members of the council.

0:21:03 With Susan's departure, there is a vacancy that has

0:21:08 or was created with her announcement

0:21:10 on the city's executive leadership team.

0:21:15 As a member of the city's executive leadership team,

0:21:17 those are positions that are appointed by the city manager,

0:21:23 but they need that confirmation by the city council.

0:21:27 So I wanna take a few moments to talk about

0:21:29 how the process came to be that causes me

0:21:33 to recommend Gretchen G. Scott

0:21:35 to the position of human resource director

0:21:37 for the city of Twin Falls.

0:21:40 Upon the announcement that Susan provided

0:21:44 for retirement, we began a national search to find our next human resource director.

0:21:50 And in performing that search, we received 19 applications from across the country in various

0:21:55 walks of life.

0:21:57 We went forward with the process and what we typically do is we will then ask members of

0:22:03 the council, we will ask members of the city's executive leadership team, and then partners

0:22:07 that we routinely work with to serve on one or two panels.

0:22:12 The very first process that we go forward with is a Skype interview in which we want to spend

0:22:16 some time after we review the initial applications and make that initial cut to see which of those

0:22:22 candidates would be finalist in our organization.

0:22:26 After we went through a series of Skype interviews, it was incredibly apparent to all the members

0:22:32 of the committee who had the opportunity to help with the selection process that there was

0:22:37 There's one candidate that's good out and above all of the other candidates that have applied.

0:22:42 And Gretchen was competing against a very, very qualified field with amazing credentials.

0:22:49 But what Gretchen brings to our organization is not only consistency and knowledge, but

0:22:55 it's an expertise and it's a passion for where we're going to go.

0:22:59 She has all of the certifications.

0:23:01 She has earned a Master's in Science from California State University.

0:23:05 She has a bachelor's degree from the University of Nevada, Reno.

0:23:09 She has many HR designations and certifications.

0:23:14 She is a certified professional from the Society of Human Resource Managers.

0:23:19 She's a professional in human resources from the Human Resource Certification Institute.

0:23:26 And she is a certified practitioner in Myersburgs.

0:23:31 All of those things were amazing credentials that really set her apart, but I think that

0:23:37 there was one thing that really pushed us over the edge.

0:23:41 That is her commitment to the City of Twin Falls.

0:23:44 Gretchen has been a committed member of our team since she first joined our organization

0:23:50 and served as our aquatics director in December of 1999.

0:23:56 Before the course of her career, she has gone from the pool.

0:24:03 She worked with Tom Courtney as one of his assistants.

0:24:08 She has worked in HR and now she is completely ready to serve in this next venture and that

0:24:16 is as the City's Human Resource Director.

0:24:19 Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, it is my pleasure to submit the name of Gretchen G. Scott

0:24:25 for your consideration to the position of human resource director,

0:24:30 and I will stand for any questions.

0:24:32 Thank you, Travis.

0:24:33 Chris Toganton.

0:24:34 No questions, all right, make a motion.

0:24:36 There's going to be a tight job getting a majority

0:24:39 on those counts.

0:24:42 I would so move that we approve the name of Gretchen Scott

0:24:45 as HR.

0:24:46 Second.

0:24:48 Motion by Chris Toganton, seconded by Ruth Pierce,

0:24:50 to confirm the appointment of Gretchen G. Scott

0:24:54 as the new Human Resource Director,

0:24:55 effective January 23rd, 2017.

0:24:57 Is there any discussion?

0:25:01 Seeing none, Sharon,

0:25:02 we'll call vote please.

0:25:03 Nikki Boyd?

0:25:04 Yes.

0:25:05 Sean Bericher?

0:25:06 Yes.

0:25:07 Chris Hocking?

0:25:07 Yes.

0:25:08 Greg Lanting?

0:25:09 Yes.

0:25:10 Christopher Reed?

0:25:11 Yes.

0:25:12 Ruth Pierce?

0:25:12 Yes.

0:25:13 Suzanne Hawkins?

0:25:14 Yes.

0:25:15 Motion passes, seven to zero.

0:25:17 Welcome, Gretchen Great Scott.

0:25:19 Thank you very much.

0:25:33 I'm extraordinarily excited to be selected for the position.

0:25:37 I'm honored that you've entrusted me with the responsibility of caring for our employees

0:25:42 and for how we operate and organize within the city.

0:25:47 I think it is a tremendous honor and I really look forward to serving and helping our employees

0:25:54 reach their goals and our organization to continue to move forward.

0:25:58 I just have a couple of things.

0:26:00 I also want to sincerely and truly thank Susan.

0:26:06 She has been a wonderful mentor.

0:26:08 She has provided me challenges, growth, the opportunity to shine, to take the lead on things

0:26:15 and has done that with a consistent and compelling drive to do what's best for the organization

0:26:24 of our departments, really keeping them in mind, and I think that is absolutely critical

0:26:28 to our organization's success, and I really thank her very much.

0:26:34 If it's okay, I would like to acknowledge my family and friends that have come tonight.

0:26:40 Tonight I have my husband and my children, Earl Scott, and my daughter Evelyn, my son

0:26:46 Nathan, and my daughter Catherine.

0:26:55 I have my parents Linda and Chuck Bro and Lauren and Kay Gillespie.

0:27:06 I have my brother and his wife, Tony and Susie Collins, and then I have some wonderful friends,

0:27:16 some dear friends of ours, Jerry and Susie Wilson, some of my friends on my co-workers

0:27:21 that I work with.

0:27:24 And then of course, many of the partners that I work with in our public safety and our

0:27:34 departments. Thank you very much. I really appreciate the opportunity.

0:27:39 Thank you. Congratulations.

0:27:48 Next is another opportunity for public input. If there's anyone here from the

0:27:53 public who wishes to address the council, now's your chance to come on

0:27:57 forward. Seeing no one. Travis, any items from the City Manager? Any items from the

0:28:06 City Council? Might be a record. 21 minutes.

0:28:11 Meeting is current.

0:28:14 That long day.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Tuesday, January 17, 2017. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:28:21.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    f3919e0e1d79c20761945ebc6d5c0a11023d3d2aad2f7695faaa4ccf6e431ff5
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 5401d4ce76859ce955941a7e8b2f1b8c480aaa850ca7384687ac04569b962fc0
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    3cd38a764695692ef63cc6ac9ed0c2a30a2e4e0bc0914be99137e18a5fd53cfc

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file