OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, January 23, 2017

Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:16:31 Okay. I'd like to call the City Twin Falls City Council meeting for January 23, 2017 to order.

0:16:42 If anybody in the audience would like to join us in the Pledge of Allegiance, please rise now.

0:16:50 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:17:08 Thank you and welcome to everybody tonight.

0:17:13 The first thing on our agenda tonight is to confirm that we do have a quorum of the City Council.

0:17:17 We have six of the seven members in present tonight.

0:17:22 And next from our city managers, do we have any amendments to the agenda tonight?

0:17:27 Madam Vice Mayor, there are no amendments this evening.

0:17:30 Thank you very much.

0:17:32 At this time, we'd like to open up our meeting for public comment.

0:17:35 If there's anybody in the audience who would like to address the City Council on any issue

0:17:40 that is not on our agenda for tonight.

0:17:43 is your opportunity. Seeing no one, we're going to move forward and we have Chris

0:17:50 talkington. Madam chair, I don't believe in coincidences. So I find it highly unusual

0:17:56 that our new council person, his first full meeting shows up amidst a winter storm

0:18:02 that will go down in the history books as one that I think is deserving to

0:18:06 rename him a character at a little Wagner as a guy that walked around with a

0:18:10 numbrella and inside the umbrella that he held over his head it was always

0:18:14 was raining and that guy's name was Joe Pefidlsteck.

0:18:17 So I decree you'd Joe Pefidlsteck with this snow.

0:18:23 Any rebuttal?

0:18:24 Well, if we're making up names for each other,

0:18:27 give me a week, at least.

0:18:29 I'll have one for you, Chris.

0:18:30 Thank you.

0:18:32 Thank you.

0:18:34 OK.

0:18:35 We're going to move on to the consent calendar.

0:18:37 Tonight we have eight items on the consent calendar.

0:18:40 And if there are no discussions from any of the council

0:18:42 I would stand for a motion.

0:18:44 Nikki Boyd.

0:18:47 Vice Mayor, I move that we accept the consent calendar.

0:18:53 Second.

0:18:56 We have a motion from Nikki Boyd seconded by Ruth Pierce to accept the consent calendar.

0:19:01 Is there any other council discussion?

0:19:03 Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote please.

0:19:06 This is Ann Hawkins.

0:19:08 Yes.

0:19:09 Nikki Boyd.

0:19:10 Yes.

0:19:11 Chris Hockington.

0:19:12 Yes.

0:19:13 Greg Lanting.

0:19:14 Yes.

0:19:15 Christopher Reed.

0:19:16 Yes.

0:19:17 Motion passes six to zero.

0:19:21 Moving on to items for consideration,

0:19:24 the first item on our agenda tonight

0:19:26 is a request to approve the purchase of real property

0:19:29 from St. Edward's, the Confessor Catholic Church,

0:19:33 for 2.973 acres located within lots three

0:19:37 and five of the Peters subdivision.

0:19:40 And we have John Caton.

0:19:41 Thank you, Acting Mayor and Council.

0:19:44 I wanted to give a little background on this project before I jump right into it.

0:19:50 First of all, Mike St. Marie is here and he is the parish priest for St. Edwards.

0:19:56 And he was my direct point contact for this whole deal.

0:20:01 But before we get into that, this is, and I know, Councilman Reed, you haven't been

0:20:07 with us for very long, this is our water facility plan.

0:20:10 It took us over a year to develop, and we implemented it last year, and this is basically

0:20:16 our master plan for a water system.

0:20:18 If you want to know something about our water system, it's in here.

0:20:22 It's also our playbook.

0:20:24 So there's a lot of things in here.

0:20:27 What if a new industry comes down, or what if the growth looks like this?

0:20:31 It's kind of a what if scenario.

0:20:33 And in this, depending on the scenarios, I thought that was mine.

0:20:41 Depending on the scenarios, it gives viable options and also the costs.

0:20:47 And it's actually kind of scary to look at the costs.

0:20:51 I'm going to show you a page out of that.

0:21:05 Without going through all the details, there's several options.

0:21:09 We've selected option one, and then zero to five years, there's potentially, depending

0:21:14 on certain scenarios and things that could happen, we would need to come up with $15 million

0:21:19 improvements depending on how things happen. In five to ten years you're talking $44 million.

0:21:25 And so obviously we don't have the money to do that. We'd have to come up with an instrument

0:21:32 to fund these things or come up with ways that we don't need to spend money on some of these

0:21:40 things. And that's where we started talking about our existing water system and Harrison

0:21:47 tank, our Harrison Water Reservoir is located at the intersection of Falls in Harrison.

0:21:58 And you can see it's the white circle there on the west side of Harrison.

0:22:03 It's a five million gallon reservoir.

0:22:05 In the summer, our water use goes from about seven million gallons a day up to almost 27

0:22:13 million gallons in a day.

0:22:15 And we'll empty that reservoir five times in a single day in the irrigation season.

0:22:20 So as the city continues to grow, it's also the heart of our system.

0:22:25 It feeds our largest pressure zones.

0:22:28 It affects the most customers in the city, both in drinking water and fire protection.

0:22:35 It is probably, it is one of our most critical locations and clearly our most critical reservoir.

0:22:42 And it's that capacity.

0:22:43 So we need to build another tank.

0:22:47 And the problem was, there's no more room on that site to build another tank.

0:22:52 And we certainly can't take it offline to build a bigger one.

0:22:56 So this facility plan investigated options to build another tank.

0:23:02 And we were eyeballing that red square across the street for a long time without knowing whether

0:23:08 we'd have a willing partner or sales at all, we had to investigate other options.

0:23:14 If we couldn't build a tank in this location,

0:23:19 we'd have to build a large diameter pipe to this offsite tank.

0:23:27 And the nearest location we were looking at

0:23:29 was about a mile away.

0:23:30 So a mile of pipe, you'd have to have another booster station

0:23:33 in that location, just so you can add another reservoir.

0:23:38 And those costs were estimated to be about $9 million,

0:23:42 just to, and that doesn't include the water tank, that's just the pump station and piping.

0:23:50 So we looked across the street and we recognized that's a lot less pipe and it does not require

0:23:55 another booster station because you know we have two booster stations there so it was an

0:23:59 ideal piece Ross. In fact, I went to see, oh my God, I reminded me that it was last March

0:24:06 when I went to see him and basically I knew all I had to do was to appeal to his, to the

0:24:13 greater good in the greater need of the community.

0:24:16 And so I explained to him what we were up against,

0:24:18 and the fact that, you know, in a bad fire,

0:24:22 there's certain part, depending on the demand situation,

0:24:25 we don't quite meet fire flow in certain situations,

0:24:28 and definitely not as we go farther into the future.

0:24:31 So it was a real, could become, in the near future,

0:24:34 a life safety issue, if we couldn't develop

0:24:37 something on this site.

0:24:38 And I remember, I sat down with him,

0:24:40 and he immediately, he's a builder's son,

0:24:42 And he understands this kind of stuff.

0:24:45 And he immediately started asking me very pertinent questions,

0:24:50 like, are you only going to build $5 million?

0:24:53 Why wouldn't you build more?

0:24:54 And which piece of the property would work for you?

0:24:57 And he was extremely cooperative.

0:24:59 And I said, you know, beggars can't be choosers,

0:25:01 but I take that piece.

0:25:03 And he had to think about whether or not

0:25:06 that would conflict with the future use of that piece

0:25:09 of property.

0:25:09 And fortunately, he was able to get it to work with his property.

0:25:15 Obviously, he has a board and a council can answer to, and from day one, it was very clear

0:25:23 to me that he was a willing partner and understood that he wanted to be part of the solution and

0:25:29 be a neighbor.

0:25:30 So, for that, I was very grateful, thank you very much.

0:25:33 And he's here if you guys have any questions, a little bit about the property.

0:25:38 It's 2.9, 7, 3 acres or something like that, and Travis asked me a while ago, I said, why

0:25:44 didn't you just round up to three?

0:25:47 I think it's a fair question, so I thought I'd explain.

0:25:50 The dimensions of that square are round and even numbers.

0:25:55 So when you go out there to measure and stuff, it's nice even numbers.

0:25:59 And so when you take the area of it, that's why it's a funny acreage.

0:26:04 But the dimensions work for us, and it works for the church.

0:26:07 We can fit 10 million gallon tank there and it's something that we're going to have to

0:26:12 talk about how we would fund it and that's going to be part of our long-term plan.

0:26:15 I think I don't really have much else to add unless you have any questions.

0:26:26 Chris Stockington.

0:26:27 A couple of points, John.

0:26:29 Number one, or a peak summer usage.

0:26:31 You said seven goes up to as high as 27 million gallons a day.

0:26:35 I thought through our alternative water system that we've been able to reduce that to around

0:26:41 20 million gallons a day or is this new growth that we have since incorporated or did I

0:26:47 misconstrue the amount of water conservation we have?

0:26:50 I'm actually probably a little bit high. It's probably closer to 25 to 26 million gallons.

0:26:55 And we were over 30 million gallons and we've reduced it 20% to about 25 to 26 million gallons.

0:27:03 My second question, we all have known we've needed more water storage both for a growing

0:27:09 community and also for cases anything that happens with pumping system that we

0:27:15 have at least a day's water until we get to the emergency at hand. I want to make

0:27:21 sure though I think it's really important that if I understand the

0:27:26 economics you're saying that to build elsewhere might require another pump

0:27:32 station up to nine million dollars in cost and so for this 900,000 one-tenth of

0:27:39 that we're avoiding that cost.

0:27:42 That's exactly right for every dollar we spend here

0:27:44 we're avoiding 10.

0:27:46 Well that's very good planning and it couldn't have happened

0:27:49 without the Catholic diocese so we're highly appreciative.

0:27:54 John if you just take a moment in addition to this being

0:27:58 the life blood of our system maybe you could explain

0:28:00 briefly for those listening at home and in the audience

0:28:03 who don't understand about our blending

0:28:05 and why this station is incredibly important

0:28:09 to how we get clean drinking water to everyone?

0:28:12 Yes.

0:28:13 So I want to call you mayor.

0:28:16 I want to call you Vice Mayor.

0:28:19 I answered a lot of different names.

0:28:21 This is referring to our arsenic compliance project

0:28:25 that we built in 2007.

0:28:27 And we had an end date from the EPA to meet the rule.

0:28:30 And in order to meet that rule, the water supply from our South

0:28:36 wells had a high level of arsenic concentration, and what we were going to do is take water

0:28:41 from the blue lakes on the other side of the river and bring it across to the south side

0:28:47 here and blend it with that arsenic water. So we have this Harrison Reservoir here, and

0:28:56 This is the new booster station, specifically used to send water, blue-eggs water, out south

0:29:07 for blending purposes.

0:29:09 So did I answer your question, is that good?

0:29:14 Thank you.

0:29:15 This is basically, like I said, this is the heart of our system and so it makes a lot

0:29:20 of sense to park another reservoir right here because we have all the other infrastructure

0:29:24 hence the cost avoidance.

0:29:26 Thank you.

0:29:27 Are there any other questions for John or for the father that's here tonight?

0:29:34 Seeing none.

0:29:35 Chris Tockington.

0:29:36 I would move we authorize purchase of the real property of 2.973 acres, lots three and

0:29:41 five of Peter's subdivision from St. Edward's Professor Catholic Church for the 900,000.

0:29:47 All right.

0:29:49 Second.

0:29:52 We have a motion from Chris Tockington, seconded by Nikki Boyd.

0:29:55 Is there any other comments or comments?

0:29:57 Oh, and they were reserve funds.

0:30:00 Oh, so the contract, the contract allows us to close on or before October 6th.

0:30:07 And so I'm going to be working with Travis and Lori.

0:30:10 We're going to budget for it in the next fiscal year.

0:30:13 Thank you.

0:30:14 Nikki, did you have anything else?

0:30:17 I'd like to just reiterate what Chris said about having a great partner in the Catholic Church

0:30:23 and how wonderful it is that we have community partners who are willing to step up and help us

0:30:27 when we come across issues like this.

0:30:29 Thank you.

0:30:31 Sharon, we'll call vote.

0:30:34 Nicky, boy.

0:30:35 Yes.

0:30:36 Chris, talking to.

0:30:37 Yes.

0:30:38 Greg, landing.

0:30:39 Yes.

0:30:39 Christopher Reed.

0:30:40 Yes.

0:30:41 With peers.

0:30:42 Yes.

0:30:42 Suzanne Hopkins.

0:30:44 Yes.

0:30:44 Motion passes six to zero.

0:30:47 Thank you, John.

0:30:47 Thank you very much.

0:30:56 Next on our agenda is a request to adopt an ordinance

0:31:00 to vacate a portion of a sewer easement and utility easement

0:31:05 located within lot one block one of St. Luke's subdivision.

0:31:10 The property is located at 801 Pole Line Road West.

0:31:14 And it looks like we have Jonathan Spinlove.

0:31:18 At least you don't look like Renee to me.

0:31:20 Yes, and I am Renee.

0:31:22 Renee put the weather.

0:31:23 I had to be here for the public hearing anyway.

0:31:25 So I don't really have to do this on top of half.

0:31:29 December 13th, this should be familiar to everybody

0:31:31 on the council.

0:31:32 December 13th, the planning and zoning commission

0:31:34 and a public hearing to vacate.

0:31:36 There's two easements.

0:31:38 One is more of a paper easements, the sewer line.

0:31:41 Easement that there's no sewer in the ground

0:31:43 is just one of those things that was put on the plat.

0:31:46 Originally, and then the blue is the location

0:31:49 or approximate location of a water line

0:31:51 that's currently there.

0:31:52 St. Luke's is going to build a medical office building.

0:31:55 Part of the building was going to cover that water line,

0:31:59 and they are asking to vacate that.

0:32:01 The council heard this on January 9th.

0:32:05 Both of those meetings all members present voted in favor of that motion and the public hearing was opened and no public comment

0:32:11 and there were three conditions for St. Luke's and their representatives to meet they have met all three of those and

0:32:18 Has directed by the council staff is prepared an ordinance for your consideration and staff recommends the city council adopt the ordinance

0:32:25 Suspending the rules and by a third and final motion so it can be published and codified hopefully this week

0:32:30 Thank you. Are there any questions for Jonathan?

0:32:32 Sharon do we have an ordinance number ordinance 2017-3. Thank you very much. I

0:32:44 stand for a motion from the council if there's no discussion. Greg Lanting

0:32:48 27-3. I move that we place an ordinance 2017-3. I'm third and final by title only

0:32:58 you know we'll do that by suspending the rules. Second we have a motion from

0:33:04 I'm Greg Lanthine, seconded by Ruth Pierce,

0:33:06 to put the ordinance on third and final by title only.

0:33:11 Is there any questions from the council?

0:33:14 Sharon Roll call vote.

0:33:17 Chris Hockington.

0:33:18 Yes.

0:33:19 Greg Lanthine.

0:33:20 Yes.

0:33:21 Christopher Reed.

0:33:22 Yes.

0:33:22 Ruth Pierce.

0:33:23 Yes.

0:33:24 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:33:25 Yes.

0:33:25 Nikki Boyd.

0:33:26 Yes.

0:33:27 Motion passes six to zero.

0:33:30 Sharon, could you please read the title?

0:33:33 Ordinance number 2017-3 and ordinance of the mayor and the city council of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho

0:33:41 Vacating the sewer easement and the utility easement

0:33:45 Describedable below and providing for vesting of title to the property. So vacate it. Thank you

0:33:54 Chris talking to move passage of 201 7-3

0:33:59 second

0:34:00 We have a motion from Chris talking to

0:34:03 seconded by Christopher Reed

0:34:06 I can't even go now to record the ordinance 2017-3.

0:34:17 Sharon, we'll call vote, please.

0:34:20 Chris Hockington.

0:34:21 Yes.

0:34:22 Greg Lanting.

0:34:23 Yes.

0:34:24 Christopher Reeve.

0:34:25 Ruth Pierce.

0:34:26 Yes.

0:34:27 Suzanne Hockand.

0:34:28 Yes.

0:34:29 Nikki Boyd.

0:34:30 Yes.

0:34:31 Motion passes 6-0.

0:34:32 Okay.

0:34:35 Item number three tonight is a request to approve and adopt two ordinances.

0:34:42 One is a master bond ordinance, and the second one is a supplemental ordinance.

0:34:48 And we have Lori race, and I believe we have Nick Miller on the phone to help get through this issue.

0:34:57 But before you start, Chris Reed.

0:35:00 I need, after a council with Fritz, I need to remove myself from this item, so I'll take

0:35:08 a seat with the audience.

0:35:10 And we're going to assume that's a conflict with work.

0:35:13 Correct.

0:35:14 Okay.

0:35:23 Okay.

0:35:25 Thank you.

0:35:27 Nick, are you available?

0:35:47 Yes, this is Nick Miller.

0:35:49 I'm on the phone.

0:35:50 Welcome to the meeting and the floor is yours.

0:35:53 Okay, thank you so much and thank you for letting me attend by phone in light of the weather conditions today, but I'm grateful to you for proceeding with your meeting on this.

0:36:04 The Bond Bank meets tomorrow, and they like to have the underlying borrowers in their group.

0:36:11 like seven or nine, other cities and districts involved in this joint bond issue and so staying

0:36:21 on schedule and I was a good thing and I appreciate your willingness to go forward. I hope everybody

0:36:26 can get home safely. I think the place to start and Lori can jump in if you'd like but

0:36:32 as you can see and vice mayor read we have two ordinances and in your agenda right up

0:36:40 for staff write-up. We worked with Lori to describe the two ordinances, and so I think

0:36:47 what I'd like to do is just to have your follow along the staff write-up, the agenda

0:36:53 request, and then I want to call your attention to one of the pages of the

0:37:00 supplemental ordinance, which I think Lori has pulled out as a separate handout for you

0:37:06 so you don't have to scroll through on your iPads,

0:37:09 the large set of documents in the prepack

0:37:14 or the board packet.

0:37:16 And then there's a one page handout with my two pages

0:37:22 that is the summary from Zion's, you know,

0:37:26 who's serving as the city's financial advisor

0:37:29 for the bond issue.

0:37:31 So I'll try to move through this quickly,

0:37:34 a bit of certainly open to any and all questions that interrupt me or we can cover questions

0:37:41 at the end.

0:37:42 So, as you can see there under the background, we, and we act as a bond council, I think when

0:37:51 the city did the RFP for bond council, we submitted a proposal that showed our experience

0:37:57 of having served in Idaho as a bond council for now over 30 years since 1985, and we've

0:38:04 represented quite a few, you know, cities as well as school districts and gun bond issues

0:38:11 all over the state.

0:38:12 And when we worked with the cities on their revenue systems, what we'd like to put in place

0:38:19 is a so-called master ordinance because that way you have one set of rules in one place to

0:38:24 govern all the bonds that are going to be issued under that system.

0:38:27 And so it clearly provides that which bonds are on a parity, which is mostly the case,

0:38:33 when bonds are not on a parody.

0:38:35 But it gives you essentially one stop shopping

0:38:38 when I met with Laurie and we collected the transcripts

0:38:42 of the CDs that contained the bond documents

0:38:44 from all the prior bond issues.

0:38:45 I said, you know, it would be nice if we had one master

0:38:48 ordinance that had all the rules and regs for all the bonds

0:38:51 and then each separate bond issue with its own interest rate

0:38:55 and some repayment terms can be layered in on top of that.

0:38:59 So that's what we're suggesting that the city move

0:39:02 to is a so-called master ordinance system.

0:39:04 So your first ordinance, the floor is new,

0:39:09 fill the number in, we have the number of blank right now,

0:39:12 sets up this master system.

0:39:16 Then secondly, moving on to the next one,

0:39:17 the second ordinance, the supplemental ordinance,

0:39:20 is specific to these 2017 bonds, which the only purpose

0:39:25 of the 2017 bonds is to refinance the 2009 bonds.

0:39:30 And we'll get, obviously refinancing at a savings,

0:39:32 and we'll get into the savings in a minute.

0:39:36 You know, it's a parody pledge.

0:39:38 It's the 2017 bonds, or as they do,

0:39:43 we're playing vanilla, but they are on a parody

0:39:46 with all other bonds of the water system.

0:39:50 And the supplemental ordinance, you know,

0:39:52 provides for the city to authorize those bonds to be issued.

0:39:56 So, that's the, in an nutshell, the purpose of the two ordinances, and I was on the phone

0:40:04 a minute ago, and I heard you go through the suspension of rules to suspend the reading

0:40:09 and on the previous ordinance that you just adopted, and obviously we would need to do

0:40:15 the same thing for these two.

0:40:17 I'm comfortable if you have one suspension, but if you want to do it twice for each of

0:40:22 the ordinances, that's obviously fine, too.

0:40:26 And then, obviously, you can record the votes.

0:40:28 And then, I understand that Chris stepped out

0:40:31 because he's a science employee.

0:40:32 And as I mentioned, the city's contracted

0:40:35 with at least a division of science

0:40:38 as the financial advisor.

0:40:42 So that's, I would say, the background of the two ordinances.

0:40:46 If you look briefly at your handout,

0:40:48 this, I think, just to really focus on,

0:40:50 What are you actually doing this evening and what exactly does this approval authorize?

0:40:58 I've included pages 6 and 7 of the supplemental ordinance, so that's the ordinance that authorizes

0:41:06 these 2017 bonds.

0:41:08 And if you look at the starting at the bottom of page 6, there's a section 207 entitled

0:41:13 sale of the bond delegation authority and there's a reference there to section 57235 of the Idaho

0:41:21 Code which is a law we helped pass a couple of years ago to allow for governing body a city

0:41:30 council or a school board to delegate to either it's uh it could be an officer or it could be one

0:41:37 of the trustees or one of the members uh delegate to somebody within the officers of the district

0:41:45 or the city to go ahead and approve the actual final pricing for the bonds.

0:41:52 So if you flip over the page, you're delegated at an interest,

0:42:15 establish what the interest rates are.

0:42:18 Now right now the bond bank isn't planning to go into the market until about March 1st.

0:42:23 I think if they get this approval and everybody else lined up,

0:42:26 there's maybe it will go sooner than that, but that's sort of the target date

0:42:30 of when the bonds would actually be priced in the market.

0:42:33 market, and that's when the interest rates become fixed.

0:42:37 So we don't know the interest rates.

0:42:39 We're giving Lori and the mayor authority to go ahead and sell the bonds or to agree to

0:42:45 sell the bonds on March 1st, or I'm actually hoping slightly earlier.

0:42:51 But then there's the proviso that the rates have to be such that the city will save money

0:42:57 on the 2009 bonds.

0:43:00 And then we've created a conventional test in the industry of how do you measure what

0:43:08 the savings are that you should jump on versus wait and see if the market gets better later.

0:43:17 And the number that we are here is the savings, the present value of the savings, the dollar

0:43:25 amount of the savings, the present value that, because you're going to save some money every

0:43:30 year over the next eight years until the bonds are paid off.

0:43:37 You present value that and that value number has to exceed 3% of the bonds being refunded.

0:43:50 As I say, it's somewhat of a convention in the industry that's a benchmark for how much is good savings.

0:43:57 If we said if you had a $100 million bond issue but are only saving $300,000, it's not very much on a present value basis.

0:44:05 but if you had a million dollars, well, that's a pretty good savings.

0:44:10 So that's why you use a present value number and is treated as a percent, and compare that

0:44:18 to as a percentage to the bonds that are being re-financed.

0:44:22 So bottom line is we're delegating to the staff, to Mayor and Lori to decide on the data

0:44:29 the pricing, do we, are we able to achieve this 3% savings?

0:44:34 When they will, in so doing, they'll also have to establish some of the other things about

0:44:39 the bonds.

0:44:40 How many bonds need to be sold to refinance the old bonds, when the new bond should be paid,

0:44:48 the final maturity if possible that we could shorten the maturity, and the price of the

0:44:55 bonds, that is how much the underwriters paid to sell the bonds, and the date on which they

0:45:00 can be redeemed, which is probably not going to be subject to redemption because there's

0:45:04 less than 10 years left.

0:45:07 So again, maybe a little more long-winded explanation than you wanted, but I do want you

0:45:12 to focus on the fact that this is what you're approving is a delegation so that Celibon's

0:45:21 Sire de March 1st is in that graded day and we decide to move it back a bit.

0:45:27 We don't need to come back to the council and we don't need to coordinate the sale date

0:45:32 to coincide with the city council date.

0:45:35 So we've used this delegation concept, say universally, since it was adopted, or since

0:45:42 the legislature authorized it, especially in the case of refinancing where you are frankly

0:45:47 playing the market.

0:45:48 I mean, Zion's and Christian, they're going to watch the market every day and say, this

0:45:52 is a good day to price the bonds or not.

0:45:55 If it is, then we go and price the bonds, and the mayor and Lori can approve it.

0:46:01 So that takes me to the last page, which is the reason that Zion's is recommending the

0:46:06 savings target. I think when Christian was last there, he was showing savings, you

0:46:15 know, more about his real numbers here. I mean, it's about a $300,000 savings, about

0:46:22 $40,000 a year. But in that, over a 5% present value savings. And that, he'll

0:46:33 we think the savings would be if we priced the bonds even right now, right

0:46:37 today. I mean, rates obviously are volatile after the election. They've come

0:46:40 back down since they spiked, so they are well within range of being able to execute on this

0:46:50 refinancing and save the city to create this savings in the water fund.

0:46:58 But the reason to use 3% is I think is spelled out in that one-page recommendation page, which

0:47:03 is we could get into a situation where rates are going up and we don't expect them to get

0:47:08 better. You know, that is, you know, rates are going to rise and they're just, you know,

0:47:13 maybe the, who knows what all the factors would be. But if so, 3% is still a good savings. And

0:47:19 if we'd never get, you know, if we don't take advantage of it, we'll never save anything.

0:47:24 So 3% is really a floor. You know, as Christian says, it's possible that we think that rates

0:47:34 could go up, but it's still volatile. We've had this for the last, you know, two months

0:47:39 or two and a half months of, you know, rates going up and then dropping back down.

0:47:44 And it went up last week or down today.

0:47:47 So if we were not able to get 3% or if we were just say barely above 3 or maybe even 3-4,

0:47:55 we might not sell the bonds because you're still relying on, or Lori and the mayor are

0:48:01 going to be relying on Christian to say, you could get 3% but let's wait because we can probably

0:48:07 get closer to five for what we've been, percentage less than we think the city should

0:48:16 get today, but it still should capture, we can't get back to you to get further authority

0:48:26 and the market is running away.

0:48:30 So I think that's, and we've seen this, and this is typically the savings threshold that

0:48:35 we use as the floor in a resolution where we ask the council to adopt and delegate further

0:48:42 authority. So I think I took about 15 minutes or a little less, so I hope that's understandable,

0:48:54 but why don't I stop there? If you or any council members have questions, let's see

0:48:59 if I can answer them.

0:49:01 Thank you very much, Nick. We do have a question from Chris Talkington.

0:49:05 Probably more than one question, but I want to understand then that we're talking about

0:49:10 just over a 10 million bonding over seven or eight years and because rates are

0:49:17 increasing we're anticipating being able to refi and save 300,000 or so although it

0:49:26 could be more or less. Am I entirely off-base of the assessment? No, that's a

0:49:33 good summary. That's the numbers that I'm seeing here. And certainly over the

0:49:38 seven or eight years of the way the anticipated Federal Reserve is indicating

0:49:43 rates are going to go up considerably, I think, rather than a little bit. We're

0:49:50 been historically at low levels, but you're saying capture this now because it's

0:49:58 more certain than in the future? Well, I can't say, I mean, I don't know

0:50:04 Nobody has the proverbial crystal ball.

0:50:09 I would say it's a conventional approach to say, if I can say 3% present value or greater,

0:50:17 I should balance the risks.

0:50:20 I might say more or later if rates go down, sort of the burden of hand theory.

0:50:27 We have a good refunding, so let's not miss it.

0:50:30 Yeah, and 300,000 present value just opposed to seven or eight years now, that's a good

0:50:36 burden of hand.

0:50:37 No, that's right.

0:50:38 Right.

0:50:39 I mean, if I don't know if Christian provided you a sensitivity analysis previously, sometimes

0:50:46 he does say, well, you know, how much rates would have to go up to lose the 3 percent.

0:51:00 You might not lose the 3 percent, but you may get a 5 percent PV range that's still

0:51:08 a pretty significant savings.

0:51:12 Thank you.

0:51:13 I don't see any other lights on for questions, so I will turn the matter over to the council.

0:51:18 Greg Lanthine.

0:51:22 I need to do them separately.

0:51:26 I know that we suspend the rules in place ordinance 2017-4.

0:51:30 Yes. Yes.

0:51:33 Third and final by title.

0:51:35 Do we have a second?

0:51:40 I'll second that.

0:51:44 We have a motion from Greg Lanthine seconded by Ruth Pierce to suspend the rules and put ordinance 2017-4 on third and final by title only.

0:51:55 We're doing them separately, completely separate, of two issues, two issues, fabulous.

0:52:02 Sharon, we'll call vote.

0:52:04 Greg Lanting.

0:52:05 Yes.

0:52:06 Ruth Pierce.

0:52:07 Yes.

0:52:08 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:52:09 Yes.

0:52:10 Nikki Boyd.

0:52:11 Yes.

0:52:12 Chris Tocquentine.

0:52:13 Motion passes.

0:52:14 Six to zero.

0:52:15 Sharon, can you read the title, please?

0:52:18 Bond ordinance.

0:52:19 Excuse me.

0:52:20 That's five to zero.

0:52:21 Chris recused himself.

0:52:23 I apologize.

0:52:24 a bond ordinance number 2017-4 water system.

0:52:30 And ordinance of the city of Twin Falls, Twin Falls County, Idaho,

0:52:35 authorizing the issuance and sale of water revenue bonds from time to time to

0:52:41 provide funds necessary to finance or refinance improvements to the city's municipal domestic water supply and distribution system.

0:52:53 fixing the form, covenants in certain terms of the bond to be issued, providing for the registration and often

0:53:02 authentication of bonds, pledging revenues for payment of debt service on bonds issued here under,

0:53:15 providing for certain federal tax covenants with respect to the bonds,

0:53:21 and providing for other matters properly relating there too.

0:53:27 Thank you, Sharon.

0:53:28 Ruth Pierce.

0:53:29 I move that we accept the ordinance number 2017-4.

0:53:35 Second.

0:53:36 We'll go motion by Ruth, seconded by Chris Talkington, to accept the ordinance 2017-4.

0:53:48 Did you have a question on that, Ruth?

0:53:51 No.

0:53:53 Sharon, roll call vote.

0:53:54 Ruth Pears? Yes. Suzanne Hawkins? Yes. Nikki Boyd? Yes. Chris

0:53:59 Hawkins? Yes. Greg Lanthine? Yes. Motion passes five to zero. On the second

0:54:06 issue, Greg Lanthine. I move that we suspend the rules in place

0:54:09 order the 2017 days five on third and final by title only and hopefully

0:54:14 it's a shorter title than the last. Second, we have a motion from

0:54:20 Greg Lansing, seconded by Nicky Boyd to place ordinance 2017-5 on third and final by title

0:54:28 only.

0:54:30 See you in the lights on.

0:54:32 Sharon will call vote.

0:54:33 Ruth Pierce.

0:54:34 Yes.

0:54:35 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:54:36 Yes.

0:54:37 Nicky Boyd.

0:54:38 Yes.

0:54:39 Chris Hockington.

0:54:40 Yes.

0:54:41 Greg Lanting.

0:54:42 Yes.

0:54:43 Motion passes five to zero.

0:54:44 Sharon, can you read the title, please?

0:54:46 Ordinance 2017-5.

0:54:51 A supplemental ordinance number 2017-5, a supplemental ordinance of the City of Twin Falls, Twin Falls,

0:54:57 County, Idaho authorizing the issuance of its water revenue refunding bond,

0:55:05 Series 2017, to provide funds necessary to refinance improvements to the city's municipal,

0:55:12 domestic water supply and distribution system,

0:55:17 Allocating authority to approve the terms and provisions of the negotiated sale of the bonds pursuant to a loan agreement with the Idaho Bond Bank Authority and providing for other matters properly related there too.

0:55:34 Thank you, Sharon.

0:55:36 Chris talking to.

0:55:37 Move the passage of 201.7-5.

0:55:40 Second.

0:55:41 We have a motion from Chris Tockington, seconded by Ruth Pierce, to pass Ordinance 2017-5, and I see no lights, so Sharon, roll call vote please.

0:55:53 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:55:54 Yes.

0:55:55 Nikki Boyd.

0:55:56 Yes.

0:55:56 Chris Tockington.

0:55:57 Yes.

0:55:58 Greg Lanting.

0:55:59 Yes.

0:56:00 Ruth Pierce.

0:56:00 Yes.

0:56:01 Motion passes 5-0.

0:56:04 That time we'll invite Christopher Reed to come back up and join us.

0:56:17 Item number four on our agenda tonight is-

0:56:19 Thank you again.

0:56:20 Thank you Nick.

0:56:21 I'm sorry.

0:56:22 We will be in touch and obviously keep the city updated on the progress for the actual

0:56:27 sale of the bond.

0:56:29 Thank you very much.

0:56:30 Can we expect that $300,000 check within the week?

0:56:33 That'd be nice, but I'm trying to figure out why we're waiting till March 1st to sell

0:56:41 the bonds because the bond bank meets tomorrow and we should be ready to go fairly quickly

0:56:45 here.

0:56:46 But the process is just to detain you one more second here.

0:56:51 Once they have all the approvals from the underlying borrowers,

0:56:55 the bond bank will then authorize the publication of a so-called official statement,

0:56:59 which gives the description of all the borrowers,

0:57:04 and it's a disclosure document that goes to the market.

0:57:07 And they let that germinate in the market for a week or two,

0:57:13 so while they assess interest in the bonds and they call people at a time,

0:57:17 bond. So there's a little period of time here that's the sales effort. We won't

0:57:25 actually, you know, you won't really get a check, you'll just have savings

0:57:28 starting with the next payment on the bond. But we would know what those

0:57:34 savings are, I would say, you know, no later than March 1st when we go to the

0:57:40 market. We have one more question for you, Nick. That was just my poor sense of

0:57:45 humor I understand that. I can see it smiling over the phone and I think a

0:57:50 relevant question is I'm not sure if it's pertinent as type of bonding what what

0:57:55 is the bonding for city at Twin Falls or do we follow on to the Idaho bond

0:58:01 rating system or how does that work? Well that's the virtue of the bond bank is

0:58:05 that the bond bank has the authority to pledge the state sales tax to guarantee

0:58:11 it's bonds. And so, if we say bond through the bond bank, it's a misnomer, it's not a bank,

0:58:19 they don't have money, but they are an access point to the marketplace. And that means that

0:58:25 their bonds carry the rating of the state of Idaho. So that translates into a lower rate

0:58:31 than the city of Tinfoen Falls, you know, you're a very good credit, both for G.O. and

0:58:35 for revenue debt, but you might be a single-aid credit

0:58:39 and the bond bank is a double-A.

0:58:41 So they charge, obviously, for fees to get these details assembled

0:58:47 because we're doing nine at once.

0:58:51 And then those lower interest rates translate to the city's

0:58:55 the rate that we pay the bond banks,

0:58:57 the bond bank can pay its bond.

0:58:59 The trade-off is that the state statute that

0:59:05 The bond bank also authorizes the bond bank.

0:59:08 If we didn't, if we the city didn't pay on our bond when we were supposed to,

0:59:14 the bond bank had to actually pay the bondholders from the state,

0:59:18 go to the state controller and get a warrant issued to pay the bondholders

0:59:24 because the city didn't, then this is the bond bank to intercept any state revenue sharing funds

0:59:32 that the city is eligible for.

0:59:35 but nobody's ever not paying the bond bank.

0:59:47 Everybody benefits being at the bond bank

0:59:53 because of the pledge of the state sales.

0:59:56 The bond bank ultimately would reclaim money

1:00:00 if it ever had to perform from you and from the city

1:00:04 in some way.

1:00:06 Thank you.

1:00:09 Thank you very much, Nick.

1:00:11 My pleasure, I will talk soon.

1:00:16 So moving on to item number four.

1:00:17 Now we have a presentation on the finances of the city

1:00:21 for the first quarter of fiscal year 2016-2017.

1:00:25 We have Lori, ready to go.

1:00:27 All right.

1:00:28 So good evening.

1:00:29 Tonight we're going to review the city's finances for the first quarter, 2017.

1:00:34 October, November, December, three months, it's 25% of our fiscal year.

1:00:40 That's going to be our benchmark.

1:00:43 I'd like to start with the tax-supported funds, and we'll focus the discussion on the four major revenue sources in those tax-supported funds.

1:00:51 And then we'll look at the four expenditure categories.

1:00:55 does it all compare budget to actual? Then we'll look at the three enterprise funds, water,

1:01:01 wastewater and sanitation. And in those funds, we're going to focus on user fees and also

1:01:07 look at the for expenditure categories and how they look compared to our 25% benchmark.

1:01:17 So Chris Reed, this is kind of for you. In the tax-supported funds, we have nine funds

1:01:23 And they receive a majority of their operating money from taxes.

1:01:27 And they are general fund, street, street light,

1:01:33 library, airport, capital improvement, and then pool insurance and fireworks,

1:01:39 while they're all separate, they're all pretty small.

1:01:45 And the total revenue budget for the tax-supported funds is $36.8 million.

1:01:52 The largest contributing revenue sources are property taxes,

1:01:58 which represent 52% of the total.

1:02:01 Franchise fees of 5% state shared revenues at 10,

1:02:06 highway monies at 8, and our inner fund transfers at 8.

1:02:11 The total of these revenues is almost $31 million,

1:02:15 and they make up 85% of the total revenue picture

1:02:18 in our cap supported funds.

1:02:24 So we're gonna start with property taxes.

1:02:27 Property taxes contribute the largest amount.

1:02:32 The $19.3 million we expect to receive is over half.

1:02:37 Now this graph shows the total amount of property taxes

1:02:40 budgeted and then received for the first quarter

1:02:43 of each of these four fiscal years.

1:02:46 And if you think about property taxes,

1:02:49 the ones that we receive in October, November, and December,

1:02:53 there are delinquents and there are penalties and interest

1:02:57 because we don't receive our first large property tax

1:03:01 installment until January.

1:03:04 So typically at this time, we've received it,

1:03:06 and I can tell you about it.

1:03:08 But we haven't received it yet, because I'm

1:03:09 a little early this year.

1:03:11 But I called Deb Kaufman just to ask.

1:03:13 She keeps lots of statistics.

1:03:15 And just to ask her, what are you seeing in terms of collections?

1:03:19 And Deb shared that, so collections are down just

1:03:23 a little bit this year, but certainly nothing alarming.

1:03:26 she said they're just down a little bit from the previous two years.

1:03:30 And I don't know if you remember, but last year was record year.

1:03:34 Delinquent properties are running about the same.

1:03:37 I always think of these collections as kind of an indicator of our local economy,

1:03:42 and it still seems pretty positive.

1:03:45 And one thing to remember about property taxes is we're not going to ever receive

1:03:48 anymore, it's just a matter of when.

1:03:51 Did that answer the question you left for me, Chris?

1:03:54 Yes, it does.

1:04:01 The franchise fees are 5% of the total and they are coming in a tick above where they were last year at 24% of budget.

1:04:09 We received these revenues from natural gas, cable companies, power, and they're basically a rent that these utility companies paid to the city to use the right of way for their lines and poles and pipes and that kind of thing.

1:04:26 State shared revenue comes in quarterly and they're really spot on with the prior three

1:04:32 year average at 27% of budget.

1:04:35 The information from the state of Idaho Division of Financial Management is that, and it's their

1:04:41 words, predicted and actual collections are up 7% over last year.

1:04:47 That kind of tells me that I got the budget pretty decent on this one.

1:04:52 Highway user revenues up from the prior three year average.

1:04:56 We're sitting at 21% of budget, and the prior three-year average is about 18%.

1:05:03 This budget was increased a little over 2% for fiscal year 2017, and the prior year we

1:05:10 jumped at 35% based on the legislative action to increase fuels tax and vehicle registration

1:05:16 fees.

1:05:17 Because we're up a little bit on this budget, tells me maybe I should have put a little bit

1:05:21 more money into this budget.

1:05:23 oops and these funds are dedicated to the street fund. That's the tax-supported

1:05:33 fund they stay in. So that's really a look at the major revenues of our tax-supported funds.

1:05:39 We receive 15 percent of our budget through December and that's above where

1:05:44 we typically are at this time. When you look at the expenditure category in these

1:05:52 nine tax-supported funds, the capital expenditures seem higher than normal for

1:05:58 this time of year and that in and of itself is really a big concern for me

1:06:02 because you know you think of capital expenditures at one time they're made we're not going to do it

1:06:08 at the same pace throughout the year. But the reason this is higher is due to the progress

1:06:13 on our police station and the city hall project. These approved projects are being paid for with

1:06:19 capital fund reserves and they're spread over multiple years so we will include these expenditures

1:06:26 in the year-end budget amendment.

1:06:27 Actual personnel costs include, so we talk about our benchmark 25 percent,

1:06:39 but the actual expenditures are 27 out of 26 paid periods,

1:06:45 so the benchmark for personnel is really 27 percent.

1:06:50 This would indicate that this expenditure should be at almost 27 percent

1:06:54 of budget this year, and we're actually at 25.7 percent.

1:06:59 So you can see we're below, and since we rarely have 100% of our positions filled,

1:07:04 this is what I'd expect to see.

1:07:07 M&O and transfers are all at or below the 25% benchmark, and overall,

1:07:13 the tax-supported funds are at 24% a quarter of the way through the fiscal year.

1:07:18 This includes the capital expenditures that will be included in the year end budget amendment.

1:07:25 So in wrapping up the tax-supported funds, the major revenue sources are looking solid

1:07:30 for that first quarter and I have no concerns on the expenditure side when I compare actuals

1:07:36 to budget. We've been sweeping our excess general fund reserves to the capital improvement

1:07:43 fund and those reserves in the capital improvement fund are strong at over $8.4 million after

1:07:50 earmarking $8.5 million for the police department and city hall projects.

1:07:57 So I'd like to finish this discussion with a look at the report that's included in your

1:08:00 packet or up here on the screen.

1:08:03 And when I looked at that, the questions that I had were, why are the court revenues falling

1:08:09 behind?

1:08:11 And there are so many variables to this that it's really not easy to define.

1:08:16 According to Christina Glasscock, the variables include acquittals, dismissals by the court,

1:08:22 dismissals by the prosecutor, whether they're paid, whether they're not paid, for infractions,

1:08:28 the dependent, defendant, please guilty or found guilty, the penalty is fixed.

1:08:34 For misdemeanors that pled or were found guilty, the judge determines the fine.

1:08:40 One of the things that Kristina said is that our actual citations are dropping off, so,

1:08:47 and I'm not suggesting this is a big revenue maker, get out there and that's more to get

1:08:51 said.

1:08:52 I just like to know why the changes are occurring.

1:08:55 The next question I have is, why is grant revenue received so much higher than what we

1:09:00 budgeted?

1:09:01 Well, we budgeted $60,000 for ADA money, and we haven't received a dime of that yet.

1:09:08 We have, however, received $26,000 for prior year COPS funding, $46,000 in E911 grants,

1:09:18 50,000 for a community development block grant, and 27,000 for a transit development plan.

1:09:28 And the last question, why are transfers at anything other than 25%, and this one's really

1:09:34 easy.

1:09:36 We budgeted some additional dollars to cover operating costs at the pool, but that need

1:09:42 did not materialize, so we're not making that transfer, and if we were, it'd be spot

1:09:46 on at 25%.

1:09:49 So overall, our tax-supported fund revenues are at 15% for this time of year, and that

1:09:57 exceeds the prior three years, and our expenditures are all at or below the 25% benchmark.

1:10:05 So before we move on to water, does anyone have any questions?

1:10:10 We do have some lights.

1:10:12 Ruth Pierce.

1:10:13 So, Lori on the grant revenue because it wasn't budgeted.

1:10:18 Are the expenditures for those particular things that grants were received for going to be up

1:10:25 as well?

1:10:26 So, it's a wash.

1:10:27 So, and those are things because we can't spend without counsel authority.

1:10:33 So those types of things will be included in the budget amendment.

1:10:36 Okay, thank you.

1:10:37 Thank you.

1:10:38 Chris Talkington.

1:10:39 If I understood your explanation a few months ago about our reserves, we've set or dedicated

1:10:45 about eight and a half million for a city hall and the police complex, the safety complex.

1:10:52 Net of that, we still have over eight million, eight point four in reserves.

1:10:56 Right.

1:10:57 And Chris, that's as of the end of our last audit.

1:11:01 And then I update those reserves after the audit's complete.

1:11:05 This is a philosophical question that put as much the city manager as you, Lori.

1:11:11 I've had a few people comment that we always seem to have plenty of reserves for these projects.

1:11:17 But how do we justify continuing to raise property taxes even if the nominal amount we have?

1:11:24 I think we need to have a little public rationale.

1:11:28 So I think that's a phenomenal question and that's something that we wrestle with at the staff level on an annual basis.

1:11:35 One of the things that we want to do is we want to make sure that the property taxes that we are assessing or the user fees that we're assessing

1:11:42 are going to be appropriate for the revenues that we bring in.

1:11:46 And you'll know that every year we don't necessarily budget to save anything.

1:11:50 We budget the actual expenditures as well as the revenues that are coming in.

1:11:55 We present to you a balanced budget.

1:11:58 What occurs over the course of the fiscal year is not necessarily in accordance to the plan.

1:12:03 And if you were to take a look at the property tax, or the general fund budget, for example,

1:12:09 you'll notice that, say, of the $1.8 million that we will not spend in the course of a year,

1:12:16 maybe $1.2 million to $1.3 million is a result of vacancies and positions that we had over

1:12:21 the course of that year.

1:12:23 Now we have no way of knowing which positions are going to end up being vacant or for the

1:12:27 length of time that they're going to be vacant.

1:12:29 But it wouldn't be prudent for us not to budget that full expense without the understanding and hopes that those employees would be with us for that duration.

1:12:38 Another second piece would be like Lori was sharing when it comes to revenues coming into the system.

1:12:45 We do our absolute very best, but we tend to take a conservative approach on terms of outside revenues that may be coming in.

1:12:54 Some of those areas are going to be franchise fees, they're going to be building permit revenues,

1:12:58 they're going to be other things that may be largely driven by the economy.

1:13:03 Like so on the franchise fees, the way it's called out with Intermountain Gas is that we're

1:13:07 going to get 3% of the revenues that they collect.

1:13:11 Now when we're going through this process, we would have never predicted this type of

1:13:14 winter.

1:13:16 And most of us who recently received our Intermountain Gas Bill probably were a bit shot because

1:13:24 of the cold temperatures that we've been experiencing and so when that goes up, when

1:13:30 their billables go up, we also see an uptick in the revenues that we have.

1:13:35 Same with as Lori was sharing with the state sales tax numbers kind of moving forward,

1:13:39 so that will be another piece.

1:13:42 Then the third piece is going to be operation and maintenance line items.

1:13:46 We tend to budget conservatively when it looks at fuel costs.

1:13:50 Over the course of the last several years, fuel, automobile fuel in particular, has been

1:13:56 fairly volatile.

1:13:57 And the last thing we want to do is not have enough resources inside of those line items.

1:14:02 And so I think it's, when you take a look at that, you say, how do you always have all

1:14:08 these cash reserves?

1:14:09 And I think the reason is because, again, salary savings, vacancies, conservative approach

1:14:15 on estimating the revenues that are coming into the system and then also on some of those

1:14:19 expenditures. If we were able to be fully staffed throughout the organization you

1:14:26 would eliminate nearly 60% of the monies that we place in the cash reserves on an

1:14:30 annual basis. And the goal should be to be fully staffed. And that's that's

1:14:37 ultimately our goal moving forward. Thank you. Thank you. Great landing. I'd like to

1:14:43 comment on that as well, Travis, I think that's a kudos to your staff. I was here

1:14:50 when we went through the Great Recession, I guess they call it now, in

1:14:55 eight, nine, and those time spans. And we were one of the few organizations

1:14:59 didn't have to make massive cuts because of those exact things. You guys are

1:15:03 conservative on the amount of revenue that's going to come in. You cover all

1:15:07 the bases to make sure if the fuel does go up or those different things that

1:15:12 We're there and we were the only reason we could weather that storm like we did was the fact that we had some reserves and

1:15:20 Some people that are taking we're taking care of the money to make sure that

1:15:25 The numbers were gonna match and they did match or at least if they didn't match we had some money to cover them with mother places

1:15:31 So thank you for the keeping us in the black. I guess so to speak

1:15:38 Chris I'd just like to add that

1:15:42 It is certainly not my intention to underestimate on revenues because you try to get as close as you can

1:15:51 Because if I continually underestimate on those it equates to lost opportunities in other areas, so

1:16:01 Your experience is proven that to be correct. Thank you

1:16:07 So now we move to the Water Fund and this graph shows the actual user fee revenues received

1:16:15 for the first quarter of fiscal year 2014 through 2017.

1:16:22 So we had a 2% rate increase in 2015 and we saw about a 2.6% increase in revenues.

1:16:33 We had no rate adjustment in 2016 and just budgeted a modest 1% increase for growth.

1:16:41 But the 2016 percentage received was almost 11% higher than the previous year.

1:16:49 So why?

1:16:50 So we look at individual month revenue and consumption.

1:16:55 We compare temperatures and precipitation for the same timeframe.

1:17:00 And what we discovered was increased consumption in the month of October 2015.

1:17:07 Temperatures were much warmer then compared to 14, and the highs were in the low 80s,

1:17:13 and we even reached a record-breaking 92 degrees on October 10th.

1:17:17 I really find that whole thing part to believe in a mansion right now.

1:17:21 While the priest was higher in October then, we also find that it's often the time if you've

1:17:27 You've got your irrigation system on a timer.

1:17:30 You don't go out necessarily change that because we've had rainfall.

1:17:34 So that was about what we had concluded about the increased revenue.

1:17:39 And in looking back at the past years of revenue history, we are typically about 21 to 22 percent

1:17:46 of total revenue this time of year.

1:17:49 And we currently stand at almost 22 percent.

1:17:57 costs in the water fund are below our 27% mark. And M&O expenditures are well below budget

1:18:04 and the benchmark. Capital projects are showing they're almost 100% spent, but that's due to

1:18:12 the carryover of the Will's Booster Station project. And if you remove those expenditures,

1:18:17 then that cap budget is about 14% year to date. We've only made a small expenditure

1:18:24 in debt, and that's for the Idaho Bond Bank application that we have coming up.

1:18:29 We also have an interest payment due in March and interest in principal payments due in September

1:18:34 of each year.

1:18:35 So you'll be seeing that first interest payment come through in the February payables.

1:18:41 Transfers are as expected at 25 percent, and overall, we're 24 and a half percent spent

1:18:47 quarter of the way through the fiscal year before adjusting that Will's booster station

1:18:51 carryover project.

1:18:53 If you reduce those total expenditures by that, we're only at about 14% of that budget.

1:19:05 So we move to wastewater.

1:19:08 And this graph shows the total residential, industrial, and municipal user fees budget,

1:19:14 and the amounts of fees received to date.

1:19:17 For 2017, we are on track at a tick over 26%.

1:19:23 So I really follow those industrials and the municipal revenues.

1:19:28 I track them closely, year over year, month to month,

1:19:33 and I provide monthly updates to Travis

1:19:35 so that we can be prepared for any unexpected shifts

1:19:38 in that revenue.

1:19:40 So for instance, last year, one of our major industrial

1:19:42 customers reduced productions for the month of December

1:19:45 and January, and another customer

1:19:48 implemented some water reuse measures,

1:19:50 and that reduced their wastewater flows and in turn our revenue.

1:19:53 So we just want to make sure that we're aware

1:19:56 if we need to take any steps to reduce some of our projects so that we stay within budget

1:20:01 and always mindful that we're not violating our bond covenant requirement of 125% debt ratio

1:20:08 coverage.

1:20:16 On the expenditure side, personnel costs and M&O are well below the benchmark.

1:20:23 Capital is showing its over budget, but the majority of these expenditures are for the

1:20:28 wastewater treatment plant expansion project.

1:20:30 Again, they'll be included in that budget amendment.

1:20:34 This project is nearing completion, and according to Troy VTech, that will be around April 24th,

1:20:40 2017.

1:20:43 Nothing has been expended for debt, and just like in the Water Fund, we'll have interest

1:20:47 payments due in March and September, and principal payment due in September as well.

1:20:54 All in all, this fund is showing its 37% spent to date after I adjust out a million and a

1:21:00 half of expansion project costs. This fund is closer to 21% a quarter of the way through

1:21:05 the fiscal year. Finally, we get to sanitation. When you look at the revenues in excluding

1:21:16 a small portion of interest income, you can see that the amount received here to date is

1:21:21 almost 25% for all three of these years. This fund is right where it needs to be. Expenditures

1:21:32 and sanitation fund need just a little explanation.

1:21:36 So, MNO looks like we're under the benchmark,

1:21:39 but that's only because PSI and the Twin Falls Solid Waste,

1:21:44 they built after the FAFT,

1:21:45 so that's just two months worth of expenditures.

1:21:48 When you make that adjustment,

1:21:49 this category is about 24.6% spent to date.

1:21:54 There is no capital, and there is no debt in this fund.

1:21:58 Transfers are on target,

1:22:00 And overall, after adjusting M&O expenditures

1:22:03 to include those three payments instead of two,

1:22:05 this budget is 24.7% spent a quarter of the way

1:22:09 through the fiscal year.

1:22:14 So that's a look at the revenues and expenditures

1:22:18 for our three major enterprise funds.

1:22:21 Revenues are coming in as expected,

1:22:23 and expenditures are below the benchmark

1:22:25 for both water and wastewater funds,

1:22:27 and sanitation is right where it needs to be.

1:22:30 And with that, I'd be happy to answer any questions.

1:22:33 Chris talking to back on the the sanitation.

1:22:39 The big question is our recycling program now.

1:22:44 The more we recycle the less we pay in tipping fees out south of town.

1:22:49 Correct. Right. It's not reflected.

1:22:55 What we pay except that the tipping fees are I guess we do a landfill.

1:23:00 payment as well, but it still bothers me that we have not

1:23:06 paralyzed any savings that I can see except through reduced

1:23:11 overall budgeting through years because of our fairly successful

1:23:16 recycling program.

1:23:22 Chris, would it help if I could provide some tonnage information to

1:23:28 you on what's not going to the landfill?

1:23:31 Yes, it's not reflected by any reimbursement, reduced rates from the county, a solid waste

1:23:41 district from what I interpret and have interpreted and anything you can do to help get some sense

1:23:49 of my head, I'd appreciate it. Travis?

1:23:52 Yes, I think that the Councilman Tockington is absolutely right and when you look at that,

1:23:58 What we've done is we've had cost avoidance, while there not necessarily has been a savings

1:24:05 in the unit price of the ton that's been moving forward, we've paid less units as a result

1:24:13 of our recycling efforts.

1:24:16 One of the things to keep in mind is that the City of Twin Falls is a smaller, maybe a

1:24:24 a large user, but we're a small piece of the overall eight county system.

1:24:30 And as we've had conversations with members of the Southern Idaho Solid Waste District,

1:24:35 they share with us that there are significant fixed costs associated with their system.

1:24:40 And we will continue to have those conversations.

1:24:42 We believe that there should be at least some level of credit in the area of recycling.

1:24:48 And then when you look at recycling and diversion, we also believe that through

1:24:53 continued education, the city could do more in those areas.

1:24:58 One of the things that we found when you take a look at recycling reports is almost like

1:25:04 a flat lining of recycling.

1:25:08 Even though you've seen growth, we've never really seen a significant uptick in the diversion,

1:25:15 and so that's probably something incumbent upon the staff to continue to work with PSI

1:25:20 to share the importance of diversion and encourage recycling throughout our community.

1:25:26 Chris has another comment, but before we move on real quick, with the two new county commissioners,

1:25:31 do we know which county commissioner has been assigned to take on this southern Idaho solid

1:25:36 waste contract because it was George Eury before?

1:25:40 We can find out.

1:25:41 Maybe just as a side note, we can find out where each of them have been assigned in different

1:25:46 places so we know who to contact when we have questions to since all of their

1:25:50 roles have changed it might just give us a better communication piece thank you

1:25:55 sorry Chris yeah I guess what bothers me and Chris this might be new to you it may

1:26:01 not in fact Ruth and Nicky but the solid waste district is seven counties as

1:26:06 meant there is an eight it's either the seven or eight and it's largely a

1:26:11 a consortium of the counties that and the more rural counties have a vote

1:26:19 disproportionate to like Twin Falls County for setting rates. Yes, they have

1:26:24 all these fixed costs. They have personnel running cats out bearing garbage all the

1:26:29 time. What bothers me is we have never been able to realize any savings through

1:26:36 are recycling while south central solid waste in their mission statement acknowledges that

1:26:42 they're encouraging and rewarding conservation. So if nothing else, if they don't do anything

1:26:48 else, I would like to see them modify their dog on mission statement, because they're

1:26:52 not rewarding the recyclers that turn falls. Other than that, I have no opinion on recycling.

1:27:02 Thank you, Chris.

1:27:03 Nicky Boyd.

1:27:04 I also don't have an opinion on recycling, but there is more to it.

1:27:13 I think the money will come.

1:27:16 And I think it's taking longer than we want, but the education has been good and it's continuing.

1:27:23 And I think as our kids are growing up and our grandkids are growing up and they understand,

1:27:28 they just automatically sort.

1:27:30 They don't just throw things out.

1:27:31 know what goes and what been and why and I think as we continue to do that we do it

1:27:39 because it's the right thing to do and some of us feel good when we continue to

1:27:44 recycle and it's good so it's not making me money but I feel good and that's

1:27:51 worth something. Thank you Nikki. Any other questions or comments for Lori tonight?

1:27:59 Thank you very much. Excellent as always. We have one more item on our calendar

1:28:10 before we move on to our public hearing. So if you are here for the public hearing

1:28:14 sit tight for a few more minutes. We're getting close. So at this time we're

1:28:21 going to move on to a request to adopt a resolution and authorize the mayor to

1:28:26 sign a state local agreement for project development of Washington Street North

1:28:32 and Falls Avenue and we have Jackie Fields.

1:28:36 Good evening.

1:28:39 In October, I came to the council and I asked for permission and support to make three applications

1:28:50 for the local Highway Safety Improvement Program.

1:28:53 One was two, and these projects address safety problems, but they also are going to address

1:29:02 some necessary signal updates, our equipment's obsolete,

1:29:06 and we have found a way to achieve two goals

1:29:10 at the same time.

1:29:11 So this week, I am here to ask you to consider entering

1:29:17 and to authorize the mayor to enter into an agreement

1:29:26 with the State of Idaho to fund the decision.

1:29:32 design for the project that is on Washington Street North.

1:29:36 So those signals, I'll remind you, just briefly here.

1:29:58 There's four locations.

1:29:59 These are all relatively new signals.

1:30:02 And they use the latest technology at the time.

1:30:06 But the controllers were not new technology.

1:30:08 And that's really the part that's really obsolete.

1:30:13 So we're going to fix that, as well as addressing

1:30:16 and safety considerations at those locations.

1:30:19 So next week, so this evening I just received an application

1:30:23 or an award, the award for one of the other projects

1:30:27 which was on Shoshone Street.

1:30:29 That's a joint project with the State of Idaho

1:30:31 to address signals between the Sixth Amendment

1:30:34 and Doka intersection all the way back

1:30:36 to your Addison on Shoshone.

1:30:40 So I'll be back next week with a similar request.

1:30:43 So tonight, the request is to adopt the resolution

1:30:47 and authorize the mayor to sign the state

1:30:49 and local agreement for project development

1:30:51 of Washington Street North and Falls Avenue.

1:30:54 The key number is 20291 with a payment of $1,000

1:30:59 as part of the local match for the project.

1:31:02 Thank you.

1:31:02 I have two quick questions, Jackie.

1:31:05 I noticed on the corner of Poline and Washington,

1:31:08 They've added a signal head on the east-west boundaries on the front side of that big.

1:31:17 I understand what you're saying.

1:31:18 Is that, I'm assuming the state did that and we did not and what can you explain that to

1:31:24 me?

1:31:25 The state did that and we did not.

1:31:28 It is a recognition of people's behavior and trying to provide some additional safety

1:31:38 safety there. So the design speed for the road is significantly different than the

1:31:45 posted speed of the road. And when you're in a position where you're actually driving the

1:31:50 road as fast as you feel safe and exceeding the speed limit, it is very difficult when

1:31:56 you come over the Pron Cooley and the Westbound movement to see the signal heads. So if you

1:32:01 want to see them well in advance, having the signal head on the front side of that structure

1:32:07 is very helpful and then it was placed on the other sides of the bridge structure, just

1:32:16 as an additional safety component.

1:32:19 Thank you.

1:32:20 And my second question real quick is the corner of Falls Avenue and Washington.

1:32:26 If you're northbound and you're trying to turn west on Falls Avenue and you're in

1:32:30 that turn lane, you are blind to traffic, oncoming traffic towards you.

1:32:35 And before there was a blinking light there, so if you felt that it was clear you could

1:32:40 turn, and I've noticed the blinking light's gone now and that left hand turn signal stays

1:32:46 red.

1:32:47 Was that, was there complaints about that, or did we know about, did we change that, did

1:32:51 the state change that, or do you have any history on that one?

1:32:54 So that is a-

1:32:55 Curious Minds.

1:32:56 That's a city, that's good.

1:32:57 Okay.

1:32:58 So that's a city controlled signal, and so the state had nothing to do with how that was

1:33:04 modified. When the project was complete, it became clear that there was some misjudgment

1:33:15 at that location. And there was a local citizen that wrote regularity and patiently and asked

1:33:22 us to consider changes. So we, we as Mike Sullivan, tweet the signal, you know, made a

1:33:30 few changes here, made a few changes there. We looked at some geometry changes on the

1:33:34 maybe we could re-stripe it a little bit different,

1:33:36 provide some refuge, and at the end of the day,

1:33:39 Mike took the opportunity to,

1:33:44 away from people to reduce the potential there.

1:33:49 That was a good choice.

1:33:51 Thanks.

1:33:51 So, thank you.

1:33:52 Okay.

1:33:53 We always hesitate to do that because it reduces capacity

1:33:56 and it's kind of the bummer if you don't have a problem.

1:33:58 If you're the person who doesn't perceive

1:34:01 there to be a problem, but if you're on the receiving end

1:34:04 and you're t-boning somebody who made the mistake,

1:34:07 that's kind of a bummer as well.

1:34:09 That is correct.

1:34:10 OK, thank you.

1:34:11 And Nicky Boyd has a question for you.

1:34:15 To follow up on her first question,

1:34:17 are those the three signals that have a yellow frame around them?

1:34:21 Is that what I'm seeing at Polline?

1:34:23 Where am I seeing the yellow frames?

1:34:25 So the yellow frames are showing up

1:34:27 on all kinds of signal heads all over town.

1:34:29 And that's a little bit different than what Suzanne was

1:34:32 talking about.

1:34:33 So that tubular bridge structure that's at Washington

1:34:36 and Vermont only have the signal heads

1:34:40 on the far sides of the structure.

1:34:44 So the state put one signal head on the near side,

1:34:47 so you can kind of see what's going on in advance.

1:34:49 Normally, that tube blocks your view line until it just

1:34:57 doesn't give you as much lead time to stop when

1:34:59 that road slippery.

1:35:00 So the yellow things that are showing up

1:35:02 are retroreflective back plates.

1:35:05 And that is seen as an additional safety measure

1:35:08 for reduced visibility conditions and so on.

1:35:11 So these projects, these state local projects

1:35:15 that we're going to be doing,

1:35:16 we'll also put them on our city-only signalized

1:35:20 intersections, the ones on Washington

1:35:22 and also the ones on Shoshil.

1:35:26 Okay, thank you very much.

1:35:28 I see no other lights, so at this time

1:35:30 I would stand for a motion.

1:35:33 I'm sorry, Sharon, do we have a resolution number?

1:35:36 Resolution number 2017-2.

1:35:39 Thank you.

1:35:40 Chris talkington.

1:35:41 Mitch, I do have a question.

1:35:43 How much money do we have in our street fund for, you know, our new growth?

1:35:50 Can you remember what we call that now?

1:35:53 The city police streets and parks that we have.

1:35:58 We have some amounts out of the side beyond this 154,000.

1:36:03 4000 is that in our

1:36:05 No, we have I think we have a pretty good amount our impact female right now

1:36:10 I can't remember the exact number right off my head, but it's easily enough to put in a traffic signal

1:36:15 But also these monies were looking to spend here are not impact fee money

1:36:19 So the we're not matching this with impact female

1:36:22 And that'll still continue to grow but we do we do have a healthy amount in the street fund right now, okay?

1:36:27 So the signals that are qualified for use of impact fees are new signals caused by

1:36:33 So, if you have an existing situation that does not need a longer mass-darm because you're

1:36:40 adding a lane for future development, then it is not acceptable to use the impact piece

1:36:45 for that purpose.

1:36:46 So, these are currently funded, we've placed money in the streets budget to try to address

1:36:52 controller upgrades, and we're using that portion of the streets budget to fund these projects.

1:36:59 So, it's actually being used a little bit differently than we intended to, but for the same purpose.

1:37:06 Thank you.

1:37:09 Nicky Boyd.

1:37:10 Are you ready for a motion?

1:37:12 We are.

1:37:13 I move that we adopt resolution 2017-2 and to authorize the mayor to sign a state and local agreement for project development of Washington Street North and Falls Avenue.

1:37:26 Key number 20291 with a payment of $1,000 as part of the local match for the project.

1:37:33 Second that.

1:37:38 We have a motion by Nikki Boyd, seconded by Ruth Pierce to adopt the resolution 2017-2.

1:37:46 Authorize the mayor to sign the agreement and send in a $1,000 match for the project

1:37:52 on key number 20291.

1:37:54 Is there any other discussion by the council?

1:38:00 and roll call vote.

1:38:01 Nikki Boyd.

1:38:02 Yes.

1:38:03 Chris Hockington.

1:38:04 Yes.

1:38:05 Greg Lanting.

1:38:05 Yes.

1:38:06 Christopher Reed.

1:38:07 Yes.

1:38:08 Ruth Pierce.

1:38:08 Yes.

1:38:09 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:38:10 Yes.

1:38:11 Motion passes 6 to 0.

1:38:14 Thank you.

1:38:14 Thank you very much, Jackie.

1:38:17 Before we move on to our public hearing,

1:38:19 at this time we'd like to give one last chance

1:38:22 if there's a committee in the public who

1:38:24 would like to address the council tonight.

1:38:29 See no one.

1:38:30 We will go on to information from the city managers.

1:38:35 Madam Vice Mayor, members of the city council,

1:38:36 just wanted to put an item on your radar.

1:38:42 At the February 6th City Council meeting,

1:38:43 we're going to be asking you to come in a little early,

1:38:48 if you can, at 3.30.

1:38:50 We would like to take a tour of the City Hall project.

1:38:55 Hopefully, you'll have a little bit better weather than today.

1:38:59 And then we'll also be taking a tour of the admin building

1:39:03 as that project's getting closer to occupancy and completion

1:39:07 which we anticipate to be in the middle of March.

1:39:11 At that meeting, we'll also be providing an update.

1:39:14 But we wanted you to have the opportunity to take a tour

1:39:16 of the facility on the same evening that we have the updates

1:39:19 and so we'll be moving forward with that.

1:39:20 So again, February 6th at 3.30, we'll meet here

1:39:25 and then we'll move forward.

1:39:26 next week we will have a regular scheduled city council meeting but we just want to put

1:39:31 this just a couple of weeks out so you can get that on your calendar.

1:39:35 Thank you. Anything from city council? Great land team.

1:39:41 I've just received an alert that they're now predicting up to 10 inches of snow overnight.

1:39:46 Yay. Happy days. Go ahead Travis.

1:39:51 So our team has been out really working tirelessly again today and wanted to kind of give you

1:40:01 a status report of where they're at.

1:40:04 One of the things that Dean does a really good job of is making sure that his team are

1:40:10 well prepared to be able to have the energy in the stamina to continue to be working through

1:40:15 the hours of the night.

1:40:17 So what they've done is they sent a crew home that are on call and could come back, but

1:40:22 they're at home until about 8 o'clock this evening, in which at that point we're going

1:40:26 to be rolling back around to around the clock, moving up snow, and we will continue to do

1:40:33 that until the primary roads and the secondary roads move forward.

1:40:38 I think it's really important to keep this amount of snow in perspective, and we certainly

1:40:43 can sympathize with the frustration.

1:40:46 I think that we're all frustrated with the amount of snow that we've received.

1:40:51 But when you receive 10 inches of snow in an arid desert that's used to receiving maybe

1:40:57 a quarter of that and a skiff here and there on top of the 16 inches that we had received

1:41:04 over the course of the last few weeks, our crews I think have done a pretty good job in

1:41:10 moving the snow, we would ask our citizens for a couple of

1:41:14 favors. Number one, continue to be mindful of the road conditions

1:41:19 and continue to exercise discretion as you're traveling. We

1:41:23 would ask that our citizens continue to give themselves a

1:41:26 little bit more time to get from point A and to point B. And

1:41:32 then also to maybe be a little bit more, you know, a little

1:41:35 tolerant of all of those who may be a little less familiar or comfortable in driving in

1:41:42 some of these conditions. And then that always good will if you see somebody that's stuck

1:41:47 or someone that's stranded, lend that helping Twin Falls hand and help them out. Spring

1:41:53 will come, maybe not soon enough, but I think the beauty of this is to maybe look at the

1:42:00 blessing that it is being provided and that is the condition of our water reservoirs

1:42:04 in our snowpack and the ability to take that water and apply it to an effective use to help

1:42:10 drive our local economy in the spring. At that point in time we'll certainly be looking

1:42:14 at all this moisture as a blessing. Thank you, Travis. Great glanting.

1:42:18 I'd like to comment on I think our crews again, our crews have done an excellent job

1:42:22 before. Have lots of relatives or acquaintances live in Aida County and are dealing with Aida

1:42:29 County Highway District and they're not happy in any way shape or form with the performance

1:42:33 of that, Highway District, people who don't know, don't do it, we have our local, we have

1:42:40 our own street departments, the Boise, CUNM, Meridian, Eagle, those towns do not have their

1:42:47 own, they don't have their own city crews, the Ada County Highway District provides that

1:42:51 for them. It's a good deal in some ways, but in this particular case not because most

1:42:56 of them have yet to see any plow go down their residential streets and they have had

1:43:03 a considerable more storm than we've had and so they're very upset that they're also

1:43:09 talking about trying to figure out ways that the cities can help augment and make that happen

1:43:15 so that they can have it. But we are I think our crew has responded better than we ever

1:43:21 have to be gone on to because we have had this kind of storm a little over a long time so

1:43:25 maybe we forget but I think they've responded as well as I can ever remember in my sixty-some

1:43:32 years of living in and around when falls. So I appreciate them and they've been doing a great job. I talked to a few of them on occasion and they're getting tired of it as well. I don't think anybody

1:43:47 wants it to quit stung quicker than that. So thank you to them. I appreciate all that they've been doing.

1:43:53 doing. Thank you, Greg. Chris

1:43:55 Stockington. And two times in the last

1:43:57 two weeks I have received direct and

1:43:59 indirect comments from

1:44:01 citizenry. So those people

1:44:03 watching listening in tonight

1:44:05 I'd like to dispel the rumor that

1:44:07 City of Twin Falls has sold all

1:44:09 its snowplows and blades.

1:44:11 Best of my knowledge we don't have

1:44:13 more but we certainly don't have less

1:44:15 and or fewer. And it's

1:44:17 important for people to keep in

1:44:19 mind that we do live in a desert

1:44:21 And if we were to double the size of our snowpliles in one year, you can be sure the next year we'd have not a lick of snow.

1:44:30 We're trying our best, and I think we're doing better than average, as Greg alluded to.

1:44:36 Thank you.

1:44:37 I do have a message for the council from Lee Eilah.

1:44:40 She asked me to remind everyone that next Monday night at four, we will be taking the new City Council picture.

1:44:47 Please wear something dark.

1:44:49 So, there you go.

1:44:53 Okay.

1:44:54 Are you guys good to keep going?

1:44:56 Yes.

1:44:57 Okay.

1:44:58 We are going to move on to our public hearing.

1:45:02 And tonight, our public hearing is a request for a zoning district change and zoning map

1:45:07 amendment from R1 to C1 for 1 plus or minus acres to allow the expansion of an existing

1:45:15 self-storage facility on property located at 2716 Addison Avenue East.

1:45:22 Forest LeBaron is the applicant and we have Jonathan Spindlove for the City Step.

1:45:27 Forest knew he was going to be gone and I'm guessing he said his replacement would be here

1:45:31 but they may have been not sure whether I don't know but I'll do my best to present this.

1:45:38 I won't be able to answer any questions as far as the project goes but luckily for us

1:45:42 it's only a zoning map in memory we're talking about, not really this project.

1:45:46 Thank you, Jonathan.

1:45:47 History on the property in the area zoning, just shown on here,

1:45:57 the sign at least as far back as that ordinance,

1:46:00 this is the 2012, this is the number, but it's really in 1980s,

1:46:04 zoned the corridor along Addison approximately 600 feet south of Addison Avenue.

1:46:09 And so that's where this line of C1 equates to.

1:46:13 because it kind of goes along Addison for quite a ways.

1:46:17 The first business, and this is the property

1:46:20 outlined here in red, the first business came up

1:46:23 in the Pope directories in 1988 as a residence.

1:46:26 Since then, there was an accountant's office.

1:46:29 Somebody had a new home office there,

1:46:31 forced, purchased that property, and turned it

1:46:35 into a self-storage unit.

1:46:36 You can kind of see those units there, a bit better here.

1:46:44 He did that approximately two years ago.

1:46:46 This request is to rezone the south property that was outside

1:46:50 of the original 600 feet of C1 and is shown as R2

1:46:55 on the zoning map.

1:46:58 This request came in before our future land use change

1:47:02 from this recent change that we're going

1:47:03 off of the original future land use map.

1:47:07 I was going to have that prepared on this.

1:47:19 It's actually this area right over here.

1:47:22 And as that comes in, you can see the Cooley.

1:47:24 And all of this pink area is denoted as commercial slash retail.

1:47:29 So the land we're talking about turning to C1

1:47:32 on the future land use map shows as commercial.

1:47:35 Therefore, under staff believes this is compliant

1:47:38 with the future land use map that's applicable

1:47:40 for this application.

1:47:43 On December 13th, the PUNNING and ZONI Commission conducted

1:47:47 public hearing on the request.

1:47:48 After the public hearing, the commission unanimously passed

1:47:51 a positive recommendation to the City Council to rezone this property. The Council is asked

1:47:56 to make a decision on this request in order to make a decision in the positive the Council

1:48:00 must determine the number one the request is in conformance with the country and its

1:48:04 plan and to the extent and nature of changing the zoning of this property to commercial highway

1:48:09 or C1 would be compatible with and not detract from surrounding area. The City Council finds

1:48:14 that numbers 1-2 above have been met staff recommends the City Council approve this request

1:48:18 that's presented.

1:48:19 Should be noted, Forest is, I've got another map here,

1:48:29 blown up area of the portion to the south.

1:48:31 It has kind of his plan on what he wants to do.

1:48:34 He's actually reserving a strip of land down here

1:48:37 the furthest south closest to the Cooley,

1:48:39 and that will be remained as our two.

1:48:41 They're not changing the zoning on that.

1:48:42 That's what abuts the residential to the south.

1:48:45 I believe it's approximately 30, 35 feet.

1:48:49 Part of it is there's a, the canal easement.

1:48:52 He can't do anything with the property anyway,

1:48:54 because it won't let him build that close to the Cooley.

1:48:57 So they need access to that.

1:48:59 And the other part was so that people to the south

1:49:01 know that he can't use it for any commercial activity

1:49:03 for that area.

1:49:05 He's going to be just an R2 residential.

1:49:07 In effect, it will be remaining.

1:49:10 Somebody said they have some berry bushes back there,

1:49:13 that the farmer to the east is going

1:49:15 to keep using and farming.

1:49:16 So that's what's going to remain there, just as a site

1:49:20 note.

1:49:21 Closer report.

1:49:22 Thank you, great, great.

1:49:23 Thank you.

1:49:24 Great.

1:49:25 You have the approximate acreage of the part that we're rezoning.

1:49:29 It's about an acre.

1:49:30 About an acre.

1:49:31 And is it being farmed currently?

1:49:34 It is.

1:49:35 Does it connect to the other field or it connects to the other field?

1:49:41 There's an access down here.

1:49:42 I believe there's a ditch or something that runs along here.

1:49:46 So do you know whether they're irrigating east to west or north to south or do you know?

1:49:51 North to South with potentially maybe some subtype of irrigation equipment that comes from the ditch and this farmer accesses down here

1:49:59 There's gonna be like a cold work or something over it on this bottom part, and that's where he's reserving

1:50:04 So those those two pieces of property or are because of the ditch or have to be farmed separately

1:50:11 The same person's farming them, but yeah, I think they have separate

1:50:15 Okay, so pet fox being an old farm boy farming an acres of paint

1:50:18 I mean, if you get that many point rows and, yeah.

1:50:24 Nikki Boyd.

1:50:25 Jonathan, help refresh my memory.

1:50:29 That burned back there.

1:50:34 Don't, yeah, don't one of those neighbors,

1:50:38 or two of those neighbors, have, Christopher,

1:50:43 do you remember on planning and zoning?

1:50:45 Did they have a discrepancy or concern back there?

1:50:54 We had, very good question, Chris may have gone,

1:50:58 there was some correspondence with the neighbor down here

1:51:02 regarding the rezone.

1:51:04 We contacted, we were contacted by the attorney,

1:51:09 forced, I don't remember which property was,

1:51:10 he didn't actually tell me which property

1:51:12 he said, one of these neighbors.

1:51:14 In talking with the attorney, with this being a rezone

1:51:18 of the property, the zoning being supported

1:51:21 by the comprehensive plan satisfied his request.

1:51:25 Forest plan to expand his business

1:51:28 has to come back for special use permit

1:51:31 in order to actually develop this area

1:51:33 for what he wants to do.

1:51:35 So the correspondence we had was the zoning actions,

1:51:39 a yes or no, there's no conditions you put really

1:51:42 on a zoning action per se for a rezone,

1:51:45 but the special use permit is really where the concerns

1:51:48 of the neighborhood come to light

1:51:49 and anything he was looking for would be taken care of at that point.

1:51:53 Okay, and that 35 feet where we have, what do we have there?

1:51:59 It's really just going to be left as R2 with farm their bushes or berries.

1:52:05 That's kind of the idea of what's there.

1:52:08 What ends up being there is a canal he's been for maintaining the canal.

1:52:12 You can't build anything on it.

1:52:15 But it just seems 35 feet for some bushes or like weeds or.

1:52:23 So that 35 feet is on forest side.

1:52:29 So when he gets his special use permit,

1:52:33 that's when those neighbors are going to have a say again.

1:52:36 Yes, there'll be a public hearing for his special use permit

1:52:39 to do any type of use.

1:52:41 Any of the use of forest is currently saying

1:52:43 he wants to get attached conditions at that time.

1:52:46 Right.

1:52:47 That's the conditions for any type of mitigating factors for neighbors that take place.

1:52:51 Okay.

1:52:52 Thank you very much.

1:52:53 Chris talking to you.

1:52:54 Yeah.

1:52:55 And this is a point of some sensitivity.

1:52:56 Anytime you mix C1 and R2, it's philosophically not a good mix, but there are extenuating circumstances

1:53:06 on at least the 35 foot area.

1:53:09 However, to the west, that whole area is marked or too straight across from there, as I recall.

1:53:16 Is that correct, Jonathan?

1:53:17 This area.

1:53:18 The bare ground.

1:53:19 No, the other way.

1:53:20 Yeah, so this is the property we're talking about here.

1:53:25 Right.

1:53:26 And then directly to the west, wouldn't it be?

1:53:28 Yeah, this little bit is R2.

1:53:30 Well, the east, yeah.

1:53:31 The east here is R2.

1:53:32 Yeah, right there.

1:53:33 That's not being re-zoned right now.

1:53:35 So we bring this in as C1, they go for the application, we can attach conditions, but

1:53:45 we're still going to have a C1 with grandfathering in over the existing R2 on both sides actually.

1:53:54 Yeah, you have the R2 here and here, now from a development standpoint, there is virtually

1:54:01 no way anybody is going to get to this property except from Asen.

1:54:07 It's going to be, in our estimation, these are going to be turning into, either it's going

1:54:12 to be farmed for a while or someone's going to actually rezone this property to something

1:54:16 else in the future time.

1:54:19 They won't really have access to it.

1:54:21 We may make that assumption, but without some mitigation at the time of this special application,

1:54:29 We are still putting that R2 property at a disadvantage.

1:54:34 Even though the C1 will have grandfathering preference on the thing, it's still a bad

1:54:40 mix putting C1 next to R2 without some buffering or dealing with lighting or fencing or something

1:54:48 of that nature.

1:54:49 Yeah, and when Mitch is in my ear a little bit, whenever you have those next to each other,

1:54:56 We require the commercial property to screen from the residential.

1:55:00 That's all.

1:55:01 And just kind of making that as a public statement or an affirmation, yep.

1:55:04 Okay.

1:55:05 I'm not sure if it's Joe, Don or Chris Perried, but we've got Don's light.

1:55:10 We've got Joe on the side and Chris over here.

1:55:13 Well, just to kind of answer Nikki.

1:55:17 So when it first came through for the special use permit for currently what it's using in

1:55:21 the C1 zone, it came through.

1:55:25 And I remember that, and there's a lot of the same discussion.

1:55:28 The public hearing that we had planning and zoning, we had quite a few neighbors that were

1:55:32 concerned.

1:55:33 But this one specifically for just the C1 zone, at which point in time when we did have public

1:55:39 input, it was, we'll come back and discuss what use is going on in that C1 zone.

1:55:47 And also you mentioned the future land use and what's going out there.

1:55:54 And clearly, that's Addison Avenue, and there is commercial along there, and we can't just

1:56:01 have these little bitty triangles of weeds and whatever.

1:56:08 So clearly, that is the future progression of things which I'm fine with.

1:56:13 I was just being sensitive to the original situation there, but I do think that that's

1:56:21 all going to go see one and it will be fine.

1:56:24 And Fritz is reminding me that instead of a public hearing, she does, for these years.

1:56:28 There he goes.

1:56:29 Okay, so at this time we will open up the public hearing and we have Trevor Poli signed up

1:56:43 to testify.

1:56:45 If you don't mind just stating your name and where you live for the record when you start

1:56:49 and then have at it.

1:56:51 My name is Trevor Poli.

1:56:54 I live here in Twin Falls for them to give you my address.

1:56:58 No, that's fine.

1:56:59 This is not to the matter of regards that was just talked about, but actually another thing that is going on.

1:57:08 So I am the administrator of dialysis clinic here in town.

1:57:15 The debut dialysis of five, eight, two point road.

1:57:19 Talking about some of the zoning and planning.

1:57:22 So is this in regards to the property we're discussing now?

1:57:31 The public hearing is only on this property right now.

1:57:34 If you want a chance to talk to us at the end of the public hearing, we'll stay for a few minutes and we'll let you address us then.

1:57:39 Okay, thank you.

1:57:40 You're welcome.

1:57:41 Just have a seat.

1:57:42 We'll get right back to you.

1:57:45 So is there anyone here to address the issue of the property we're talking about zoning now?

1:57:50 So we'll close the public hearing and now we will turn it over.

1:57:55 There's no rebuttals since we don't have an applicant.

1:57:58 I don't have an applicant or anybody that's speaking for itself.

1:58:01 So, we will turn it over to the Council for Council wishes.

1:58:08 I'm off.

1:58:09 Chris Stockington.

1:58:10 I would move we approve a zoning district change and zoning map amendment from R1 to C1 for

1:58:17 the 1 plus or minus acres for expansion of existing cell storage facility at 2716 Addison

1:58:25 Avenue east.

1:58:26 Second.

1:58:28 We have a motion from Chris Stockington seconded by Nikki Boyd to approve the request

1:58:34 for the zoning district and zoning map change in a moment.

1:58:38 Is there any discussion from the council?

1:58:41 Sharon roll call vote, please.

1:58:43 Chris Hockington.

1:58:43 Yes.

1:58:44 Rick Lansing.

1:58:45 Yes.

1:58:46 Christopher Reed.

1:58:47 Yes.

1:58:48 Ruth Pierce.

1:58:48 Yes.

1:58:49 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:58:50 Yes.

1:58:51 Nikki Boyd.

1:58:52 Yes.

1:58:53 Motion passes six to zero.

1:58:55 That concludes this public hearing, but we're going to go ahead and let Trevor come on up

1:58:59 now and address us on what you have going on tonight.

1:59:03 First time it's doing this.

1:59:07 It's fine, welcome.

1:59:09 So, concern, and I know that this has been brought up

1:59:13 in the past when it was first coming out with,

1:59:15 this is a considering with a degree dial,

1:59:18 this is in Dutch Brothers, that is in the front parking lot.

1:59:21 I know it's been discussed for quite a few times,

1:59:25 but the concern is through the amount of traffic

1:59:31 that is going through that area, grateful that they're

1:59:36 obviously doing very well with their business, but it also is a very it's a

1:59:40 concern for the patients and for our healthcare facility there. There are times

1:59:45 that we're not able to get anyone through. That would also mean emergency vehicles as

1:59:50 well. So the response time for patients that

1:59:53 is on dialysis, which dialysis is obviously a life-sustaining treatment.

1:59:57 Something for them to be able to get immediate care is not able to be done

2:00:01 because we're not able to get cars past that line that is lined up and it could

2:00:06 be almost lined up into polling.

2:00:08 And so there needs to be some sort of actually taken

2:00:12 so that we're able to safely get our patients

2:00:16 in and out of dialysis, and also the response time

2:00:20 for emergency vehicles to be able to get to those

2:00:23 to our facility as well.

2:00:25 Okay, stay right there for a second, Greg Lanting.

2:00:27 Well, I was just gonna ask Mitch or Jonathan,

2:00:30 that obviously has to be a special,

2:00:33 being used permit for that facility, can we revisit that,

2:00:37 especially is permit to see if we can add additional conditions

2:00:40 so that they have to allow that entry way to remain open?

2:00:45 Or is that the way path we should take?

2:00:47 Or do you have a better suggestion?

2:00:50 That's exactly right.

2:00:52 There's an SUP for the drive-through portion of the business.

2:00:56 And since it's an SUP, there's potential

2:01:00 for an opportunity to, I don't know how to say it,

2:01:05 like work with them to encourage some solutions.

2:01:10 I'm not quite sure what the solutions might be,

2:01:12 but we can certainly try and we have worked with,

2:01:17 I think Renee and her staff have talked to those guys before

2:01:20 and you know, so we'll see what we can do.

2:01:24 They quite often have an employee out there

2:01:27 collecting orders prior to the people going through there,

2:01:32 and it looks like to me that the solution might be,

2:01:35 is that they need to stand,

2:01:36 that person needs to stand on the west side of that entrance

2:01:40 and stop traffic there and take the road over there,

2:01:43 and just allow traffic to go across that way,

2:01:45 that opening could remain open at all times,

2:01:48 they can take the initiative,

2:01:50 because that way they often have somebody out there anyway,

2:01:52 so they could have them be the kind of the road guard,

2:01:56 So to speak, there's an old term at the age there, didn't I?

2:02:00 I know at Christmas time though, it was actually lined up on pole line.

2:02:03 You couldn't even get in, traffic was blocked on pole line from people trying to get in there,

2:02:08 so the problem is greater than that. And there does need to be a solution.

2:02:12 Can I actually have a picture of what I can show you?

2:02:14 I'm sure that you probably would.

2:02:16 Yeah, we haven't seen the pole line thing, but I've seen the line drift stress all the way around, almost two pole lines.

2:02:21 too poor.

2:02:22 Trevor, make sure you leave your contact information with Mitch so you guys can work

2:02:27 together through that.

2:02:28 I've tried to work with those brothers with this and we've had any conversations I actually

2:02:32 had them in this week as well.

2:02:34 They're still just, it's quite a concern.

2:02:38 So when are they opening a new location so they would take some of the pressure off?

2:02:42 I talked about that as well.

2:02:44 I don't know.

2:02:45 I understand.

2:02:46 And I do understand your concern.

2:02:47 Yes.

2:02:48 Thank you for bringing it to us.

2:02:50 We need to be given the full scope of properties and agreements in grassy grass.

2:02:58 I don't understand it enough.

2:03:00 I recognize the problem there.

2:03:03 Thank you for coming and making us aware.

2:03:05 Thank you, Lisa.

2:03:06 Nikki Boyd.

2:03:07 I did have one, one just general thought is that is really congested.

2:03:12 I've watched it there.

2:03:13 I watched it when it first went in.

2:03:15 And is there room?

2:03:18 Can we do anything, Mitch?

2:03:21 Can we make a divita dialysis lane that's,

2:03:27 you know how like at the post office,

2:03:29 you can go this way or you can go this way,

2:03:31 but you can't be in both.

2:03:33 Is there any room to do anything over there to help out?

2:03:37 Private property.

2:03:38 Well.

2:03:39 So there's room left to the west of there

2:03:44 that's yet to develop

2:03:46 and maybe there's some potential solutions.

2:03:48 But yeah, I mean, it is a private property issue

2:03:51 but again, we'll get in there and see what we can do.

2:03:57 Because it's a special use permit,

2:03:59 it does give us a little bit of an end.

2:04:02 And fabulous, fabulous, thank you.

2:04:06 Seeing nothing else, we are adjourned.

2:04:13 Assured, got away from me.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, January 23, 2017. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:04:20.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    5a309ad3d81c6e20c37515dd54a3c7ec429e35399f7a897bda20423e1a398978
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 55dff69532a8fc0b49d1e69c80ef7bd386088f57ddeee190f8b449c33b49cb8d
    part02.m4a 4ebe6ed39ab420c7e0a7438eb928134a353ba30ce2bb1cc53cac88637755cefe
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    e185ed6eda67244149350c6c40ca3f167d9c0e207aadc1c4e5a654f9953782cb

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file