City Council meeting
Monday, May 22, 2017
Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:00:00 First, I, so call the me to order.
0:00:03 We do have a quorum of the council here.
0:00:05 Six of the seven members are present this evening.
0:00:08 Councilwoman Pierce is absent this evening.
0:00:11 Next item of the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.
0:00:13 Those of you wishing to join us, please rise.
0:00:19 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:00:31 for all.
0:00:36 Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to the agenda this evening?
0:00:41 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, we do have one amendment to the agenda.
0:00:46 It is on the consent calendar and it is for a beer and wine license for the burnt lemon.
0:00:54 We submitted that to the council for their review earlier this afternoon when the application
0:00:59 came in.
0:01:02 Greg Lanting.
0:01:03 I'm here.
0:01:04 I move that we place the talk in the motion by Greg Lanting, seconded by Chris Tockington
0:01:14 to add the Beer and Wine License approval for Burt Lemon Grill to the consent calendar.
0:01:20 Is there any discussion?
0:01:22 Chair in roll call vote please.
0:01:28 John Berriger.
0:01:29 Yes.
0:01:31 Nicky Boyd.
0:01:32 Yes.
0:01:33 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:01:34 Yes.
0:01:35 Greg Lanting.
0:01:36 Yes.
0:01:37 Christopher Reed.
0:01:38 Yes.
0:01:39 Chris Tockington.
0:01:40 Yes. Motion passes 6-2-0. No other amendments, Travis? We have no proclamations this evening,
0:01:51 so the next item on the agenda is general public input. This is an opportunity for the
0:01:55 general public to address the council on issues that are not on this evening's agenda. Is there
0:01:59 anyone wishing to address the council? Seeing no one, we will move to the consent calendar.
0:02:08 Council wishes. Suzanne Hawkes. I move approval of the consent calendar as printed. Second.
0:02:18 by Suzanne Hawkins second by Christopher Reed to approve the consent calendar I
0:02:22 will say as amended. Thank you. Any discussion? Sharon I'll call a vote please.
0:02:29 Yes Suzanne Hawkins yes Greg Lanting yes Christopher Reed yes Chris
0:02:41 Hockington yes Sean Verger yes motion passes six to zero so if you were here
0:02:48 for the Magic Valley Pride Festival event, the Western Days Special Event and Parade
0:02:54 application, or the YMCA Youth Triathlon, all of your events were just approved.
0:03:00 Welcome to Stick Around for all the fun.
0:03:02 We also are done on the agenda.
0:03:07 Next under items of consideration, the first is a request to amend City Code 6-4-14 by the
0:03:14 The addition of a new subsection 6-4-14 subsection M, prohibiting the confinement of animals in
0:03:23 unattended motor vehicles, and we have Sean Stanley, our code enforcement coordinator.
0:03:28 Welcome, Sean.
0:03:29 Thank you, Mayor and City Council.
0:03:32 So confinement of animals in unattended vehicles, we've seen an influx of calls coming into dispatch
0:03:40 through code enforcement.
0:03:44 So in 2014, we had one call.
0:03:47 2015, we had five.
0:03:49 And in 2016, we had 16.
0:03:52 And already this year, we've had seven.
0:03:56 Currently in our city code, we do have a cruelty to animals.
0:04:03 Section K in the agenda.
0:04:07 6-4-14-K.
0:04:10 Although rarely is the situation severe enough
0:04:13 to write that citation.
0:04:15 our animal control officers struggle with that.
0:04:19 We did a little research with different cities
0:04:22 in the state of Idaho and found a few that we liked.
0:04:26 And with the help of Fritz came up
0:04:28 with the addendum on there with Em.
0:04:33 And this one not only helped us educate our citizens
0:04:37 on the dangers of leaving animals in the band of vehicles,
0:04:42 but it also gives us a little bit better avenue to enforce it.
0:04:50 The infraction penalty for all these items
0:04:53 is $100 in the city code.
0:04:57 And in an emergency, this also gives a police officer,
0:05:02 a code enforcement officer, or an animal control officer
0:05:05 the right to go and get that animal out of the vehicle.
0:05:10 After exhausting all other avenues of training to locate the owner of that vehicle.
0:05:18 Most of these calls are in parking lots.
0:05:22 We see a lot on streets and we also see a lot on private property.
0:05:25 Colton Forceman gets a lot of those phone calls for private property situations.
0:05:34 We think it's a really good idea and it just helps us out in the field.
0:05:36 It's a great tool not only to educate but to enforce.
0:05:42 So I'd answer any questions if there is any.
0:05:45 You just talked.
0:05:47 Sean, I was wondering if a person observing animal
0:05:51 offering in a state of discomfort
0:05:54 or what you think is an endangerment to the animal
0:05:58 and the vehicles on the city of property,
0:06:00 if a person were to break a window to rescue that animal,
0:06:04 currently charges be filed by the vehicle owner,
0:06:09 or what's the consequence?
0:06:11 I'll let for his answer that is.
0:06:13 Yeah, I'll let for his answer.
0:06:17 Charge is filed against the code enforcement officer.
0:06:20 Is that what you're asking?
0:06:21 No, you're saying an individual is just a citizen.
0:06:24 What's the consequence of that?
0:06:26 Oh, if a citizen rescued, it's not,
0:06:29 there wouldn't be any criminal charges.
0:06:30 Obviously, there's no malicious injury to property.
0:06:33 There's an intent to rescue an animal.
0:06:35 So it's not the intent to destroy someone's property.
0:06:39 It's intent to rescue an animal.
0:06:40 So not no criminal charges.
0:06:44 It's not even a misdemeanor or a destruction of property or a.
0:06:48 So that has an L an intent element and so it's the intent to harm the property owner and here
0:06:55 the intent would be to rescue the animal so we would never we would never prosecute for
0:07:01 something like that.
0:07:03 Thank you.
0:07:04 The reason I brought it up Council as I was attending the law enforcement Memorial City
0:07:09 part the other day and there were two dogs confined in a vehicle adjacent to the city
0:07:15 park property. They were not in that state of endangerment but they were highly discomforting
0:07:23 in the heat of the mid day.
0:07:26 In those cases we will ensure and exhaust every avenue before we ever break a window of going
0:07:32 and rescue that animal.
0:07:35 Nicky Boy.
0:07:36 Sean, I have a couple of questions. At the very beginning, under the code 6-4-14, it says,
0:07:42 it is unlawful. That, and then everything listed below, comes with a $100 fine. Is that what
0:07:51 the $100 is attached to as all those items? Yes, it's an infraction penalty of $100. Okay, and
0:07:57 And then I read that allowing a dog to run free was a misdemeanor.
0:08:04 Is that true?
0:08:05 That's correct.
0:08:06 No.
0:08:07 Where did I read misdemeanor?
0:08:10 It was on this paper.
0:08:12 Geez.
0:08:15 For an animal running at large.
0:08:20 Yeah, so that's like out of date because we have all of our violations within this chapter.
0:08:30 Our infractions and punishable by $100 fine.
0:08:34 Okay, so if we see the new M specifically talks about code enforcement, so if I see a
0:08:45 dog or an animal in a car, I need to call, I call dispatch.
0:08:50 Correct.
0:08:51 Okay, so citizens are, this is not giving citizens the proper protocol is to call.
0:09:00 Right.
0:09:01 And they will get somebody out there.
0:09:04 I referably our animal control officers.
0:09:06 That's their expertise.
0:09:07 Okay.
0:09:08 Okay.
0:09:09 All right.
0:09:10 Thank you.
0:09:11 Susan Hawkins.
0:09:12 Thank you.
0:09:13 So, Shawn, I will be supporting this, but I just want to go on the record saying it frustrates
0:09:18 me to no end, that we have to legislate common sense.
0:09:22 I hate being put in the position where we have to go to this step.
0:09:27 To me, it seems like pet owners in those responsibilities should have enough knowledge to not leave
0:09:34 their animals in a vehicle and I know it happens and I know it's wrong but I
0:09:39 just don't like it when government has to put common sense into our rules.
0:09:46 So one note I have since English seems to be what we do in correcting grammar I
0:09:54 think we're actually missing a word in here in the at the tail end of it it says
0:10:00 or under such other circumstances as good reasonably expected to cause suffering I
0:10:06 I think the word be needs to be in there and not being an amazing English person.
0:10:12 I'm not sure if that goes before the adverb or after the adverb.
0:10:16 So I don't know if it should say as could be reasonably expected or as could reasonably be expected.
0:10:22 But the word be needs to be in there.
0:10:24 Oh, that's pretty impressive.
0:10:31 That was my only observation.
0:10:34 It wasn't my only observation.
0:10:35 It's the one I'm pointing out.
0:10:39 Is there any further questions or comments for Sean?
0:10:44 No, it's, do we have an ordinance number, Sharon?
0:10:49 It's a resolution and it's resolution 2017-10.
0:10:54 It's actually an ordinance.
0:10:56 It shows an ordinance.
0:11:34 Okay, it's ordinance 2017-14.
0:11:40 Great planting.
0:11:42 Mayor, I move that we place ordinance 2017-14
0:11:46 on third and final by title only by suspension of the rules.
0:11:51 Second.
0:11:54 Motion by Great Lanting.
0:11:55 Second by Suzanne Hawkins to place ordinance 2017-14
0:12:00 on third and final reading by title only under suspension
0:12:03 of the rules.
0:12:04 Chris, Dr. Chris.
0:12:05 I guess I'd support the third and final, but I think this is one
0:12:08 time where a little public input would either help us to affirm
0:12:13 that this is clearly owner neglect and deserves tightening
0:12:18 up or there may be some extenuating circumstances we're possibly not even aware of.
0:12:23 I'm not smart enough to figure out what those extenuating circumstances are, but something
0:12:29 like this, it seems so obvious we could be overlooking a little relevant public input.
0:12:36 Nonetheless, I'm much more in favor of getting it passed than waiting too many weeks.
0:12:43 Any other discussion?
0:12:47 Sharon Roll, call the vote, please.
0:12:55 Suzanne Hawkins, yes.
0:12:57 Greg Lanting, yes.
0:12:59 Christopher Reed, yes.
0:13:02 Chris Tockington, yes.
0:13:04 Sean Berriger, yes.
0:13:06 Nikki Boyd, yes.
0:13:08 Motion passes six to zero.
0:13:10 Sharon, would you read the title, please?
0:13:19 Ordinance number 2017-14.
0:13:22 An ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls,
0:13:25 Idaho, amending Twin Falls City Code 6-4-14
0:13:31 by the addition of a new subsection M,
0:13:34 prohibiting certain confinement of animals in vehicles,
0:13:39 be ordained by the Mayor and the Council
0:13:42 of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho.
0:13:45 Thank you.
0:13:46 Council wishes.
0:13:48 Suzanne Hawke.
0:13:49 They move approval of Ordinance 2017-14.
0:13:54 Second.
0:13:56 Motion by Suzanne Hawke and seconded by Nikki Boyd
0:13:58 to approve Ordinance 2017-14.
0:14:01 Is there any discussion?
0:14:04 Seeing none, Chair and roll call vote, please.
0:14:06 Greg Lanting yes Christopher Reed. Yes, Chris Tockington. Yes
0:14:14 Sean Berriger. Yes
0:14:17 Nikki Boyd. Yes
0:14:19 Suzanne Hawkins. Yes
0:14:21 Motion passes six to zero. Thank you Sean
0:14:27 Next is a request to approve a petition for right-of-way dedication at the East corner of
0:14:33 Shoshone and 4th Avenue East and we have our city engineer Jackie Fields. Welcome Jackie
0:15:04 This petition is being made somewhat in conjunction with our local highway safety improvement project
0:15:10 to put ADA ramps in many places, but this place in particular is at City Park on the corner
0:15:18 of 4th and Shashan.
0:15:23 So there is an existing ADA ramp in place at that corner, and sadly that ADA ramp does not
0:15:30 exist on public right away, but it exists on City Park property.
0:15:35 I need to have that ADA ramp exist as part of the public right away and so I discussed
0:15:44 with the administrator and with Parks and Rec whether or not it would be appropriate to
0:15:52 dedicate 113 or so square feet of land to the public right away so we can continue with
0:15:59 the project and improvement of ramps in this area.
0:16:02 So, the approval process is outlined in the document, it's pretty straightforward, a petition
0:16:10 is made, this is a petition.
0:16:12 We've got a legal description that this exhibit has been, the errors on the exhibit have been
0:16:19 addressed in the description, which is always, you know, informative for the general public.
0:16:33 Just in case you're truly curious, because I know you're just dying to know, but properly
0:16:36 learned.
0:16:42 So you can't actually see the road on there, that's not the purpose of the document for
0:16:45 for a record survey, but we just nick the edge of the park.
0:16:51 Staff recommendation this evening is to approve the petition
0:16:54 for dedication of approximately 113.
0:16:57 This is not one of my shining agenda items,
0:17:00 if you noticed, it should be 113 square feet
0:17:03 of city property to the public right away.
0:17:05 So I have three spelling errors and only two paragraphs.
0:17:08 I didn't catch one of them.
0:17:10 So I'm out.
0:17:12 Wow.
0:17:14 Thank you, Jackie.
0:17:15 I understand where the Parks Department was basically giving the street department the
0:17:25 right way.
0:17:26 Is that correct or am I?
0:17:29 They are supporting the dedication of the Park City property to the public right away.
0:17:37 And then why does that say 8th Avenue down there?
0:17:40 That's one of the errors that was corrected is actually is 4th Avenue East and it was
0:17:45 It was fixed for the purposes of recording.
0:17:47 All right.
0:17:48 That's just worth worrying about.
0:17:50 I thought I was some new numbering from old way back
0:17:53 that I didn't know about.
0:17:54 So started counting from some police different deal.
0:17:56 I don't know where that came from.
0:17:58 It's not a number that has any meaning for me.
0:18:01 So it was released.
0:18:04 Any other questions for Jackie?
0:18:07 Chris Stockett.
0:18:07 Except approval of the petition for right away
0:18:10 by the occasion of the east corner
0:18:11 should have shown on 4th they have now
0:18:13 ace per the description.
0:18:17 Second.
0:18:18 Oh, sorry.
0:18:19 Motion by Chris Stockington, seconded by Christopher Reed
0:18:22 to approve the petition for right-of-weight dedication
0:18:26 at the East corner of Shoshone and 4th Avenue East.
0:18:29 Is there any discussion?
0:18:31 Seeing none, Sharon roll call, please.
0:18:35 Christopher Reed.
0:18:36 Yes.
0:18:37 Chris Stockington.
0:18:38 Yes.
0:18:40 Sean Berriger.
0:18:41 Yes.
0:18:43 Nikki Boyd.
0:18:44 Yes.
0:18:45 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:18:46 Yes.
0:18:47 Greg Lanting.
0:18:48 Yes.
0:18:50 passes six to zero. Thank you, Jackie. Next is a request to adopt a resolution declaring the city's intent
0:18:58 to dispose of real property and setting a date for a public hearing. We have Deputy City Manager Mitch Humble.
0:19:06 Welcome, Mitch.
0:19:11 A couple weeks ago, we brought you a resolution to
0:19:14 dispose of some city property because it works good for our trail. Well, in the last couple of weeks, we've made a couple of more
0:19:21 progress on a couple of more potential exchanges that we wanted to
0:19:25 initiate those public hearings as well. And so I'll direct your attention to the
0:19:30 trail exhibit that's up here on the screen. And so the two that we talked
0:19:35 about a couple weeks ago were right up here and then right over here. The one I
0:19:40 wanted to start tonight, the first one I want to start tonight is in this. It's
0:19:44 actually a shade of blue but it's hard to see but it's shade of blue right here.
0:19:48 And so, the property that we currently own, that we worked with MavTech and then Gary
0:19:55 Store to acquire, follows this black line, that's the trail line, and it comes to this
0:20:00 point and it goes straight across, and then it goes up or south down that property line,
0:20:04 so it's this kind of L-shaped property.
0:20:07 And if we take that and trade it, Gary Store is still currently the rest of the property
0:20:14 on our so we're kind of having these conversations right now.
0:20:16 If we trade that for a line that takes that corner and goes kind of diagonal, it again
0:20:22 smooths out our trail less hard, 90 degree turns, makes it a little bit easier to navigate.
0:20:27 And also in this case, it eliminates about, I want to say 300 ish feet of trail construction
0:20:33 cost.
0:20:34 And so that's the first of the two that are included on the attachment.
0:20:38 Let me show you the other one.
0:20:42 I have to make sure sideways.
0:20:54 So this is the extreme west end of that trail.
0:20:59 So that trail on the air photo would come in right down
0:21:01 this property line and get us to about this point.
0:21:07 And on this picture, we're getting ourselves to about
0:21:17 this point with this trail job that we're about to start
0:21:22 construction on here in the next couple of weeks.
0:21:24 If you see right over here at the edge of the picture, this
0:21:29 This is our existing trail, and it just sort of tees into the curve right here on Poline
0:21:36 before it turns into Eastland.
0:21:37 And that's where the trail stops right now.
0:21:40 We want to make a connection from this point over here, across the road, and then it will
0:21:45 work around the bend to make that connection.
0:21:48 Okay, so some of that is happening in right-of-way, but a piece of that right up here is happening
0:21:53 on property that is privately owned by Rick Eastler.
0:21:57 and I have had several conversations.
0:22:00 We've come to an agreement where we would exchange,
0:22:03 it ends up being about 3,000 square feet right here.
0:22:07 For this property, which is about 6,000 square feet,
0:22:11 on the canyon rim that we own and have owned for some time
0:22:15 with the intent of maybe you put a small little parking lot
0:22:18 for a trail there.
0:22:20 That is not needed anymore because right here,
0:22:23 we have three acres of trail head and trail.
0:22:26 So the idea being, let's trade this for this.
0:22:31 We'll make this last little connection here with that trade.
0:22:34 And we'll go through what we need to do
0:22:38 as we need to adopt the resolution middle.
0:22:40 Declare our intent to do so.
0:22:41 We'll have a public hearing.
0:22:42 Public hearing we'll talk about whether we should do that
0:22:44 or not.
0:22:45 And if we do, then we'll move forward.
0:22:48 We'll amend our change order on our construction plans.
0:22:52 And we'll go ahead and make this last little connection.
0:22:54 be ashamed to build 7800 feet of trail and stop 180 feet short of making that
0:23:01 kind of final connection I think. And so these two properties are included in the
0:23:06 attached resolution. If you approve it tonight we're gonna have a hearing in
0:23:10 about three weeks from now. It's actually to actually discuss the trades and then
0:23:16 you can have the opportunity to act on those trades. So I've got any questions
0:23:20 I'm happy to answer those for you if I can.
0:23:23 Greg Lanting.
0:23:24 It seems like I've been on, I'm not sure that exact piece property, but I've certainly
0:23:30 been on this one before.
0:23:31 Yeah.
0:23:32 And as I recall, those are big fissures that are going across that piece property.
0:23:36 Yeah, you can see them.
0:23:37 Yeah, there's some good cracks in the rock.
0:23:39 I mean, good size cracks.
0:23:40 Yeah.
0:23:41 The beans that, you know, maybe 10,000 years or maybe next week, that's going to fall into
0:23:45 the canyon.
0:23:46 Potentially.
0:23:47 Okay.
0:23:48 And can we have a, I can't imagine any other value to that property?
0:23:55 There's very little value to that property, I would say.
0:23:57 It's good build on it, obviously.
0:24:00 It's unbuildable.
0:24:01 So I believe that this property was initially included with this property.
0:24:07 It's one, it was one parcel years and years ago before that home was built.
0:24:12 And when that home was built, I want to say in something like 74ish, a while ago, the home
0:24:18 was just built in right of way, that was highway district right away.
0:24:24 You can see if you follow the alignment of Eastland straight on up, it would have gone
0:24:28 right through that home.
0:24:30 And because that happened, the highway district and the property owner at the time worked out
0:24:37 a little swap so that the highway district was kept whole.
0:24:42 They gave the property to the homeowner and they took this 50 foot strip over here.
0:24:47 It is only a 50 foot strip.
0:24:49 It was intended to be a right of way over the edge of the canyon for some reason or other.
0:24:57 You know, again, property for property.
0:25:02 There really is very little value to it, but what I will say is that when that home got
0:25:06 built at the same time there's a portion of the well, I believe the well is like just
0:25:10 barely on that property, the well that serves that home.
0:25:12 So it has some real value for that home order, which is not the same homeowner that built
0:25:20 it in the wrong place in the first place, just so we're all clear.
0:25:22 This is way down the line a few homeowners later, but yeah, there's very real value in
0:25:27 having that property as attached to this home for that homeowner, but for the public, I don't
0:25:33 see a whole lot of value if you're not going to park, you know, it's 50 feet wide, so you
0:25:39 could park one row of parking in there kind of 90 degree parallel to that road
0:25:46 and maybe you get six or seven cars in there. But again we've acquired with this
0:25:52 deal that MAFTEC helped us work out. This deal gives us a three acre park right
0:25:57 here right at the entry of that trail and that in my mind is the more logical
0:26:01 place for parking for a trailhead and so this becomes even less valid to us.
0:26:07 Any other questions for Mitch?
0:26:12 Yes, both of those parcels are in this.
0:26:17 One resolution is going to take care of both
0:26:21 parcels, both in intentions to exchange property, so
0:26:25 resolution number sharing. 2017-10.
0:26:31 Consolutions. Chris Stockton.
0:26:37 We have passage of resolution 2017-10.
0:26:42 Chris Stockington, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins,
0:26:44 to approve resolution 2017-10.
0:26:48 Is there any discussion?
0:26:51 Share in roll call vote, please.
0:26:54 Chris Stockington.
0:26:55 Yes.
0:26:56 Sean Beriker.
0:26:57 Yes.
0:26:58 Nicky Boyd.
0:26:59 Yes.
0:26:59 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:27:01 Yes.
0:27:02 Greg Lanting.
0:27:03 Yes.
0:27:04 Christopher Reed.
0:27:04 Yes.
0:27:06 Motion passes, it's six to zero.
0:27:13 Next is another opportunity for general public input.
0:27:16 Is there anyone here from the public who wishes
0:27:17 to address the council on any issue this evening.
0:27:23 Seeing no one, advisory board reports,
0:27:26 anything from the council on any of the commissions
0:27:29 or such Suzanne Hawkins.
0:27:31 Just a couple quick updates.
0:27:33 First of all, I'd like to thank our police department
0:27:36 for inviting us to their awards banquet Friday night.
0:27:39 Was a wonderful dinner and you always learned so much
0:27:41 about what's happening in our police department
0:27:43 by attending those, so thank you for that.
0:27:46 And secondly, I wanted to say that Saturday was the Magic Valley Law Enforcement Memorial
0:27:53 Service at City Park, which was also another great event.
0:27:56 But I wanted to make sure we gave a special thank you to Lighthouse Christian Church for
0:28:00 hosting the free lunch afterwards for everybody who attended.
0:28:04 It was a fun day to be out at the park and have that celebration in our city with all
0:28:10 of our surrounding cities coming over to join in that with us.
0:28:14 And lastly, from the Youth Council, on Saturday they held their big campaign event this year,
0:28:21 which they called Hula Hoop for Health.
0:28:23 And they held a Hula Hoop contest at the Visitor Center.
0:28:27 They gave out flyers to fourth and fifth graders at all the elementary schools.
0:28:31 But we ended up having adults and kids and all kinds of people jump in.
0:28:36 We had plenty of Hula Hoops, and we Hula Hooped for two hours and provided all the participants
0:28:41 with bananas and water and gift certificates to healthy places around town and St. Luke's
0:28:47 also donated sunscreen and lip balm to all the participants. So the youth council did a great
0:28:53 job pulling that off. We had a lot of fun and maybe next year we'll try again.
0:28:57 Very nice. Thank you, Suzanne. Great landing.
0:29:01 I think somebody came across my email today that the county is having an open house this Thursday.
0:29:07 You totally stole what I was going to say.
0:29:09 I'll back from here. Go ahead.
0:29:11 They're going to have an open house from four to five and then we'll morph into the business after hours,
0:29:16 the chamber business after hours and give them a chance to show off what they've done with that billy
0:29:23 and people haven't had a chance to see it
0:29:24 the old hospital, at least the doctor's offices portion,
0:29:29 and maybe they'll even tell us what's going on
0:29:32 and the rest of it, which is I really don't know.
0:29:33 So, this one didn't think about it,
0:29:35 you would probably want to bring me on that.
0:29:37 Quite alright, it's quite alright.
0:29:40 Anything else from the council?
0:29:41 Chris talking to.
0:29:42 Since the city passed a good neighbor resolution
0:29:46 several weeks ago, things have been moving pretty fast.
0:29:49 If you recall the neighborly resolution passed
0:29:53 after quite a bit of public comment about the CSI's refugee program, about juvenile crimes,
0:30:02 the claims of conspiracy and Sharia law. Things have moved really to the point that I think
0:30:10 it involves the council's leadership in passing the neighborly resolution. For one thing,
0:30:19 There have been a lot of public cross currents within the community of what can we do to
0:30:26 show our openness to people moving into the community despite the earlier comments of this body
0:30:33 that we need to terminate or limit the refugee program to preserve the white race.
0:30:40 I'd like to say that even as we speak tonight, there is a community event
0:30:45 involving up to about 50 people and I think about nine denominations and
0:30:51 religions within Twin Falls
0:30:54 its attempt to
0:30:56 communicate better
0:30:58 at cross currents of different denominations to expand the
0:31:02 the meaning of what it is to be in Twin Falls a town of opportunity and open hands and I
0:31:08 Just think it's commendable that the city took this leadership position
0:31:12 which was following quite interesting on the opinion page of MagicValley.com about Alex Jones
0:31:21 eating crow, being forced to retract allegations against Chavani, one of our major new employers
0:31:29 in Twin Falls. Things are moving in the right direction. I applaud that.
0:31:34 Thank you, Chris. Anything from the city manager's office?
0:31:40 Just to note that Monday is Memorial Day and as a result, city offices will be closed.
0:31:47 That will move our meeting to Tuesday and so we'll be meeting at Tuesday at five o'clock.
0:31:53 We do have a couple of public hearings that are scheduled for six o'clock and so right
0:31:59 now we're looking at the agenda so we're just going to put new on alert that we may
0:32:04 have a later start because of the stuff that we have but we're going to look through that.
0:32:09 right now plan on five and but should we choose to move that we will move that to
0:32:16 five thirty to accommodate public hearings that we do have at six o'clock
0:32:21 that deal with land use and had to be published in advance thank Travis so
0:32:27 these public hearings were noticed for six p.m. correct this public hearing all
0:32:31 right so that completes the regular agenda except for the public hearing which
0:32:35 is scheduled for six so we will recess for 25 minutes and we'll come back at six
0:32:40 All right, we will reconvene the City Council meeting for Monday, May 22nd for our public
0:58:21 hearings.
0:58:22 But first, Councilman Regan has something to share.
0:58:25 I just wanted to congratulate the high school seniors this week as graduation for them.
0:58:30 I know Canyon Ridge is having theirs at seven o'clock tonight.
0:58:33 I don't know when Twin Falls is having theirs tomorrow night.
0:58:37 So we just wanted to congratulate them on all their hard work and then success in the future.
0:58:43 Thank you.
0:58:44 Here here.
0:58:45 All right.
0:58:46 Next on the agenda is a public hearing.
0:58:47 A request to approve and exchange a real property near the Snake River Canyon for use as an extension
0:58:52 to the Canyon Rim Trail.
0:58:53 We have our deputy city manager, Mitch Humble.
0:58:56 I'm going to share to you what I have this great picture that you guys might have seen
0:59:03 somewhere before.
0:59:04 So, a few weeks ago, we adopted a resolution declaring our intent to dispose of city owned
0:59:21 property and setting a public hearing date for that conversation that's tonight.
0:59:25 Up here on the map, just to get our bearing straight again, the heavy dark line that runs
0:59:32 from over here, this is Eastland and Pole Line, heavy dark line that kind of runs all
0:59:37 the way through this property up to the Jeff site right over here, is our proposed trail
0:59:41 alignment for the Canyon Room Trail Extension.
0:59:43 about, I don't know, close to 8,000 feet of trail, with all kinds of jobs and turns and
0:59:52 ins and outs. One of the things that continued to happen after we acquired the property was
1:00:00 we continued to work with the property owner, Gary Stor, and Gary Stor continued to work
1:00:05 with some of the adjacent property owners to try and make this a little bit better for adjacent
1:00:09 property owners, and also as it works out a little bit better for the city. And the two
1:00:14 that we want to talk about tonight. There's two pieces and they're both
1:00:18 labeled here as Addendum 1. Addendum 1 meaning that's the first kind of
1:00:21 change to our plan and they're both in that same addendum 1. So let's start down
1:00:26 here at the south end of the trail right here. There's a homeowner that is right
1:00:31 in this area and they have come to terms with Gary's store to acquire this. What
1:00:38 is that? That's not a parallelogram. What is that? That's like a weird geographic
1:00:43 Trapezoid. Trapezoid. That's what I was looking for.
1:00:47 I'm about to have trapezoid.
1:00:51 I like getting out there with your English in math today.
1:00:55 It was a long time ago when I was in geometry.
1:00:59 So I'm going to buy this property here. And one of the deals
1:01:03 contingencies of that print land purchase is that we go ahead and go through this
1:01:07 land exchange. And so what we currently own is this kind of
1:01:11 dark line right in here, and the proposal would be to trade that for this line right here.
1:01:17 Same width, we're going to build the same width of the trail right through there, but
1:01:20 that one cuts down.
1:01:21 These two together cut down nearly a thousand square feet of trail construction costs from
1:01:25 the city.
1:01:27 They also really kind of make that trail much more usable trail without so many hard 90
1:01:34 or greater degree turns.
1:01:35 There's eight of them that we're limiting with these two trades, and so this one does that.
1:01:40 What it also does is it pulls this trail a little bit further away from the existing home
1:01:44 right there.
1:01:45 And then up around the corner here, we're doing the same thing, except for up in here,
1:01:49 I want to say there's three different homeowners that have come to terms with Mr. Store, and
1:01:54 they're going to split this other trapezoid property three ways, eventually, and that'll
1:02:02 get divided there.
1:02:04 And so this is where we see a big chunk of our savings here.
1:02:06 We're going to take the new alignment and just kind of diagonal across that property and
1:02:09 trade all of this. Again, the two combined save us nearly 1,000 square feet of trail.
1:02:16 Check out 8, 90 degree or greater turns. Make it a little bit easier to use, a little bit
1:02:21 easier to construct, and a little bit cheaper to construct.
1:02:24 We just say that again, how much are we saving on the second portion?
1:02:28 So the two combine are about 1,000 feet. I can't remember how it breaks down between
1:02:33 the one and the other. I know up here you have a greater portion of that 1,000. This one
1:02:37 is something like 700 feet, this one's like 300 feet.
1:02:40 Also combined total is about 1,000 feet,
1:02:44 linear feet of trail.
1:02:48 Again, significant savings in construction costs
1:02:51 and ease of constructability.
1:02:53 Actually, that's a big deal.
1:02:54 I didn't really talk about too much
1:02:56 when we did the resolution, but the constructability
1:02:59 is a big deal here.
1:03:00 When you have a 90-degree turn and you only
1:03:02 have the short distance to work in,
1:03:05 It makes it a lot more difficult to construct and have these hard, negative returns.
1:03:11 And so that's going to be the proposal tonight.
1:03:15 So we do need to have a public hearing.
1:03:17 So from a process standpoint, we need to give public an opportunity to come and tell you
1:03:21 what they feel about us getting a public property.
1:03:25 At the end of that, we would ask for the Council to approve and we recommend approval of their
1:03:29 request to proceed with the land exchange and that will come up. We'll deal with all the details of that.
1:03:35 The title fact and we'll just take care of that. This is the action tonight. It's
1:03:45 required a simple majority vote of the council if we decide to proceed. So with that,
1:03:50 I can answer your questions if you have any. If not, we can open a public hearing and I know we
1:03:55 at least have one person signed up on that to talk.
1:03:58 Any questions, Chris talking to?
1:04:00 And roughly 1,000 square feet of trail construction.
1:04:04 What are we figuring the construction costs
1:04:06 for square foot roughly?
1:04:08 It's linear.
1:04:15 So the construction cost on that is about $90 a foot.
1:04:18 That's including the fence and the trail.
1:04:20 Sure.
1:04:21 OK.
1:04:22 Thank you.
1:04:24 Any other questions for Mitch?
1:04:27 If not, we will turn to the public
1:04:30 and give the public an opportunity
1:04:31 for the public input portion of the hearing.
1:04:34 I have, is it David, is it good or good?
1:04:37 Yeah.
1:04:38 Yeah.
1:04:39 And that's an A, penmanship.
1:04:41 Okay.
1:04:42 Another academic topic we can discuss and see.
1:04:48 I apologize for that.
1:04:49 No, don't worry about that.
1:04:50 Mr. Gadd.
1:04:51 Thank you.
1:04:52 I am here on behalf of the property owners, Lincoln and Shelley Tubbs, who own this property
1:04:58 right here.
1:04:59 I will understand, excuse me, not Shelley, Heather Tubbs, I understand that Mrs. Tubbs
1:05:05 came to a prior meeting and expressed some of her concerns about the proximity of the
1:05:10 trail and their home. I was pleased to hear that Mitch, as well as Gerald and Gary Store,
1:05:18 have been working together to find some creative solutions to that problem. They are the proposed
1:05:23 buyers of this southern lot right there, and their intention in buying that is to develop
1:05:31 essentially a win-win scenario for both them and the city.
1:05:34 It's their intention to submit a request to the city for reimbursement to the cost to
1:05:40 construct a fence, which I understand she spoke to the council about before, essentially
1:05:45 along this line starting at that southwest corner and going to the new southeast corner.
1:05:53 My understanding is that the cost of that as well as the removal of four trees along
1:05:57 that route will still be less than the amount that the city is saving and so the city gets
1:06:04 a better trail as Mitch explained with the without the hard corners on there. The tubs
1:06:12 get more privacy hopefully get the reimbursement for the cost of the fence so that they can
1:06:19 have that increased privacy along that line. Again our intention is to submit that request
1:06:24 here shortly for the council's review and approval, but we at this point are in favor of this and
1:06:30 would support the council's approval of it. Any questions?
1:06:39 Nikki Boyd.
1:06:40 I do have a question. In the CC&Rs out there, are fences allowed? Do people have any part
1:06:50 of their property or their property lines with six foot fences on them?
1:06:54 I'm not aware of any CC and RS that would restrict the construction of the six-foot fence along that property line in addition one item that I know that Mitch is aware of is that their current parcel is county.
1:07:08 That's a county parcel whereas the new parcel will be is currently annexed with the city and so at least upon the exchange the swap.
1:07:18 there will be two separate parcels, one that is city, well,
1:07:22 annexing the city and one that's still part of the county.
1:07:27 So any CCNRs I would imagine would not encompass the entire span, but
1:07:32 I'm not aware of any restrictions that would prevent the offense being.
1:07:36 I'm just thinking I understand why they want offense, but is that compliant with
1:07:40 the rest of the neighborhood and what they understand to be?
1:07:43 My understanding at this point is it is.
1:07:45 Okay, thank you.
1:07:48 All right, thank you, Mr. Gaddon.
1:07:49 Thank you.
1:07:53 Is there anyone else who wishes to address this issue?
1:07:58 Seeing no one, we will close the public input portion
1:08:00 of the hearing and turn it back over to council
1:08:03 for any discussion.
1:08:05 Greg Lanting.
1:08:06 Mitch, I don't know what Mike was,
1:08:10 and my laptop wasn't working earlier.
1:08:13 The other side of their property,
1:08:14 is that what we just worked on earlier today?
1:08:17 Right, that's the other piece.
1:08:19 So there's a triangle property right over here
1:08:23 that is being proposed to be purchased by a third buyer
1:08:28 from these two that would then acquire that property,
1:08:31 then pushing, if that goes through in a few weeks,
1:08:34 then it would push that this fence
1:08:37 or this trail alignment would push out to here,
1:08:40 again, taking really care of both sides of the tubs, right?
1:08:43 Thank you.
1:08:47 Christopher Beatt.
1:08:49 I think this is wonderful as somebody
1:08:51 that will be using this trail,
1:08:52 I think for runners bikers, smoothing out this trail
1:08:56 is really beneficial.
1:08:58 Those sharp turns are very difficult if you're wanting to use it.
1:09:01 So I think this is really nice and I'm in favor of it.
1:09:06 Chris Stockton.
1:09:07 Well, with that universal applause,
1:09:08 I would move to approve the exchange of real property
1:09:11 near the Snake River Canyon.
1:09:13 For use as the extension of Canyon Rim Trail,
1:09:15 the property is so described.
1:09:18 Second.
1:09:20 Motion by Chris Stockton, then seconded by Chris Reed
1:09:22 to approve the property exchanges
1:09:26 near the Snake River Canyon as presented.
1:09:29 Is there any further discussion?
1:09:33 Share and roll call vote please.
1:09:35 Chris Tockington.
1:09:36 Yes.
1:09:37 Sean Beriker.
1:09:38 Yes.
1:09:39 Nicky Boyd.
1:09:40 Yes.
1:09:41 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:09:42 Yes.
1:09:43 Greg Lanting.
1:09:44 Yes.
1:09:44 Christopher Reed.
1:09:45 Yes.
1:09:47 Motion passes six to zero.
1:09:50 That about all the loose ends, Mitch,
1:09:53 on the trail for that section.
1:09:56 So I think in a few weeks when we deal with that public hearing, that'll, I'm going to stop messing with it.
1:10:03 Yeah.
1:10:07 Alright, with that, the meeting is adjourned.
1:10:12 Cool.
1:10:14 When, when, when.
Download
- Transcript (text) 42 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 57 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 78 KB
- Audio (M4A) 16.6 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, May 22, 2017. The recording started at 16:58 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:10:28.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
e6f9170e4ed76b617711fae3177c867ac8ddcbf847639277084b9f0f38a5d111 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 2157fe843b470bf8b20901e3b7178e779e03b15f504b9e3f5d58f2bb68739837 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
3ec0213a7074b92b4388f41ff30d3f6ff1ecb3789cf8cae8b3cd66bd38a47156
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file