OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, September 25, 2017

Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:00:00 building that we're going into, the use of all walk through,

0:00:04 you've seen that it's quite a bit larger,

0:00:06 there's more space in there,

0:00:07 we're actually setting up six different workstations

0:00:10 in that space, we currently have three.

0:00:14 So this is doubling the capacity,

0:00:16 at least the space capacity for this batch.

0:00:20 We would like to get some of the equipment

0:00:23 that we didn't necessarily have budgeted just yet,

0:00:25 equipment and licenses to get those workstations

0:00:29 actually set up and running it not just at the space for it. And that's what the

0:00:33 $38,815 of sports for radio licenses and dispatching equipment for those new

0:00:39 workstations that we're putting in there. In addition to that, you've seen in there

0:00:43 and it's got those hard block walls and they're a little bit concerned about

0:00:46 noise echoing and they'd like to get some wall hangings in there to sort of

0:00:52 dead in the sand, and that's a $3,000 expense.

0:00:58 These last two are kind of going to talk about them

0:00:59 a little bit together.

0:01:00 There's two parks related to expenses in here.

0:01:03 The first one is a parking treatment

0:01:05 at the Preserve Trail.

0:01:07 And the Preserve Trail is the trail that we just completed,

0:01:12 I guess.

0:01:13 I'm not really completely substantially complete.

0:01:15 We'll call it that.

0:01:17 It is open to the public now.

0:01:18 If you have any chance to go walk it,

0:01:19 it's fantastic.

0:01:20 Go walk it a new 8,000 feet of trail of our Candy River

0:01:23 trail system. It opens substantially completely to the public on the 15th. We've noticed since

0:01:31 it's been open there's been a little bit of parking, I guess, activity that's a little bit

0:01:36 concerning for us. We knew going into that project that we didn't have enough in the budget,

0:01:41 we had an 800,000 other budget. We knew we didn't have enough to put in the parking lot

0:01:45 that either ended that project. And the project didn't have enough to do it. So we didn't really

0:01:52 budget that. The idea would be that we know we have the three acres at the corner of East

0:01:56 Little Collein. Maybe come back this coming fiscal year, we'll do a plan for that park.

0:02:03 How's it going to look? Part of that obviously will include some parking. It's in a great

0:02:07 location to be in the trailhead for that new trail section. We haven't had a chance to

0:02:12 do that plan yet. And we haven't had a budget to develop that park yet. And so our thought

0:02:18 was that during the construction of this trail, they would use that as a staging area, which

0:02:21 that would compact, dirt really nice and tight,

0:02:24 and maybe there'd be some leftover gravel from the project

0:02:27 that they could just sort of spread around.

0:02:29 And temporarily people could maybe use it for a parking lot

0:02:32 until we went through this process and built a parking lot,

0:02:38 appropriate parking lot with asphalt.

0:02:40 It turns out we didn't have it drop the gravel left.

0:02:43 In fact, we ended up ordering a whole bunch more gravel

0:02:46 than we ever thought we were going to need,

0:02:48 and that's some of the reasons for why that project

0:02:50 that project was as costly as it was.

0:02:53 But the trails didn't need a compliant

0:02:55 and we needed to bring some extra fill in places

0:02:57 to kind of keep it that way.

0:02:58 We ended up using all the gravel.

0:02:59 There's nothing left over at the beginning

0:03:01 of this trail section.

0:03:03 And so we've also noticed that since it's been open,

0:03:05 we've had people parking along the street

0:03:07 and not moving up there on top of it.

0:03:09 I think there's an uncomfortableness,

0:03:11 it's how we're people driving across the trail

0:03:15 to get to this property.

0:03:16 And so we haven't seen anybody doing that.

0:03:18 Instead, they're parking on the street.

0:03:20 streets kind of narrow is a public street, right? So there's generally the right to park

0:03:24 there, but it gets really narrow and the residents in there are kind of worried a little bit about

0:03:29 it. And likewise we should, I concern. So the idea would be with this $40,000 and potentially

0:03:36 the next project's $50,000 for a total of 90 to kind of go in there and potentially address

0:03:45 this parking issue at that location.

0:03:50 Put some gravel down if we have the other 50 towards it.

0:03:54 This is the priority of the two.

0:03:56 The other trail section is probably a secondary.

0:04:00 There's savings, we can go back to that one.

0:04:01 But we'd like to address this parking issue first.

0:04:05 I think if we have the $90,000, we might be able to do that.

0:04:08 But let's plan it a little bit, because we haven't got a plan yet.

0:04:12 Let's put the gravel down, and then probably in the spring,

0:04:16 It's an asphalt down on top of it.

0:04:18 Now, the reason why we want to talk to you about that is we

0:04:19 don't allow gravel parking lots.

0:04:21 It's not compliant with our code.

0:04:24 And so that's really the crux of the issue, is if we

0:04:30 wouldn't allow somebody else to put the gravel parking lot for

0:04:32 their use, why should we do it for ours?

0:04:34 And we should really lead the way on that.

0:04:37 That's why I think we need more than the 40,000.

0:04:39 I don't think 40 gets us gravel and paving now.

0:04:43 I also don't think that we can get it paved before our

0:04:46 asphalt plants close this year.

0:04:49 I think we could get some gravel down and compacted

0:04:51 and designed, maybe, before that.

0:04:55 But it might be that we go through the winter

0:04:57 with the gravel down and pave it as soon as we spring.

0:05:03 Sorry, there's some stuff there.

0:05:04 We also don't have a bid yet, so I don't know that 90,000

0:05:08 will cover it.

0:05:08 I don't know, 40,000 cover it.

0:05:10 So that's a little bit of a flexible spending money, I guess.

0:05:16 We'd like to go in with your approval, do kind of a temporary

0:05:20 gravel through the season until the asphalt starts being delivered

0:05:23 again this spring, and then maybe finish that parking lot out.

0:05:28 I'm thinking we need 12 or 15 parking spaces.

0:05:31 It's not a huge parking lot.

0:05:32 But there does need to be some off-street parking, I think,

0:05:36 to avoid kind of clogging up the entry to that neighborhood.

0:05:41 And then the second piece of that, the $50,000

0:05:44 for the Rock Creek Trail extension,

0:05:45 you're all aware of our sewer line project that's

0:05:47 going under our rock creek trail right now.

0:05:51 They're about ready to start paving.

0:05:53 The sewer line is being put in and we're getting close

0:05:57 to repaving the trail on top of that new sewer line

0:06:00 that we put in.

0:06:01 So we've had a sewer line under our trail for years.

0:06:04 We had to repair a new sewer line in there.

0:06:08 In doing so, we tore out the trail.

0:06:10 It used to be there.

0:06:11 Put the sewer line out and we put the new trail down

0:06:13 on top of it.

0:06:14 That's all part of this sewer project

0:06:16 and being paid for with the sewer project.

0:06:18 But if you're familiar with the location

0:06:20 at the bottom, right below the park's office,

0:06:25 there's like a hard switchback

0:06:27 where you start the trail heading kind of northwest.

0:06:31 There's a gravel trail that goes back to the east

0:06:35 that's not been paved.

0:06:36 It has traditionally, historically it's not paved.

0:06:39 But the sewer line is going in there as well.

0:06:40 And we have a contract with this contractor

0:06:42 who's doing the work.

0:06:43 We could do an adder to their materials

0:06:47 to bring in a little bit more asphalt and pave

0:06:50 as far to the east as we have property to pave

0:06:53 which just extend our rocker trail

0:07:01 a little bit to the east where it currently stops.

0:07:04 Now today you can walk on it, it's gravel, it's not paved

0:07:08 and you can get kind of back there to the end,

0:07:11 but it's not paved.

0:07:12 And so this really is just, we have an opportunity

0:07:16 that we wouldn't otherwise have had.

0:07:18 And so for like a materials addition to a contract,

0:07:21 we can get this done.

0:07:24 The issue really just becomes,

0:07:26 do we jump on this opportunity now?

0:07:28 And if so, then it costs us about $50,000.

0:07:34 Again, we believe that the total of the two,

0:07:38 the 90,000 between the two should be first pointed

0:07:42 at the parking situation at the Preserve Trail,

0:07:45 thinking that's a higher priority than an extension of 800 feet or so to the rock

0:07:52 creek trail. It doesn't really go anywhere. When you get down to the end you just

0:07:56 kind of turn around and go back and you can walk it today. Eventually we're

0:08:01 going to pave it, but we need another, we need to acquire some property to get it

0:08:06 all the way over to like blue legs and it's not, it's like a choir group, choir

0:08:11 property from one or two people. We can make that last

0:08:14 bullet connection, but we don't have it. And so this would

0:08:16 just simply be, if we could do this now, we can avoid some

0:08:21 mobilization costs and stuff like that in the future. And so

0:08:26 there's that. That's my list. So we have a couple of lights

0:08:31 here. So Greg Lanting. Well, first on the on the savings, I've

0:08:36 always been impressed with my Taiwan Council that the city

0:08:39 departments maybe is a feeling they have they have trusted just because they don't

0:08:44 use something the one year that doesn't mean they won't get what they budget for

0:08:48 the next year and so they will if they can save money they save money and they

0:08:51 turn it back I mean I've always impressed and that's where this money came from

0:08:54 is obviously if each department said well I gotta spend every dime then this

0:08:58 money would exist and so I appreciate that the second one it would be on the

0:09:03 preserved trailhead somehow figured out across the trail in part I went by

0:09:08 there yesterday and there was cars parked out in where it would be the parking

0:09:12 parking area and also again from my knocking door to door this is where you

0:09:18 get the chance to get people's concerns somebody is concerned and I don't know

0:09:23 whether we've accepted the fence yet or not but the they had concerns that they

0:09:27 had not some of the some of the stays across have not been welded all the way

0:09:31 around and so they're breaking loose and so that's something we might want to take a

0:09:34 look at before we take full acceptance and what were we expecting in other words, were

0:09:41 we expecting more of a all the way around well or just a portion of each prod and so that's

0:09:48 something we need to consider before we accept.

0:09:50 All right.

0:09:51 Thanks, submission.

0:09:52 So, I'll tell you, to that concern, I mentioned a minute ago the trail was substantially complete.

0:09:58 It's a contracture.

0:09:59 It's substantially complete.

0:10:00 We can open it up to the public and it's generally usable and safe.

0:10:05 not finished and the fence is the thing that's not finished. Those crossbars, that fence is a really

0:10:12 stout fence when the crossbars are all welded in place and in an effort to get it substantially

0:10:20 complete by the 15th. So we could open it to public. Some of those were attacked in place and they

0:10:25 got to come back and finish them up. Most of them were finished all the way around, well there are

0:10:30 several that are just tacked in place that need to be finished. Also the fence

0:10:34 caps on the post. There's some of those that are just kind of tacked in place

0:10:37 that they need to come back and finish. So we have not finally accepted the

0:10:41 project and the fencing is the reason why. Also at the bottom you notice at the

0:10:45 beginning of the trail by east and there's that mesh, that wide mesh that goes along the bottom

0:10:49 18 inches or so. That's only installed for four other feet and that's got to go the

0:10:56 whole length of it. Okay let's keep the dogs away from the cows right?

0:10:59 always wait for the couch. And so the fence is the thing that's not yet finished. There's

0:11:03 a couple of ballerds that we need to put in place and some signage, you know, stay on

0:11:08 the trail, don't bother your neighbors, that kind of stuff. So we'll do all of that. And

0:11:12 so we have not finished the trail project. The trail is done and walkable. They still

0:11:19 need to finish the fence or absolutely aware of it.

0:11:22 Thanks, Mitch. Great talking to you.

0:11:24 Yeah, I think the city under expenditure of the general fund is something we're almost

0:11:32 expected to do, and it shows the conscientiousness of the city workforce.

0:11:37 So I'm sure we're all in congratulations for that.

0:11:41 And most of the requests you have here seem to make quite a bit of sense.

0:11:46 I have some concern on the performance of measuring professional services that apparently did

0:11:53 not receive a high enough vote to get it on this next year's budget and we want to do

0:12:00 it now.

0:12:01 But my experience with performance measuring systems are a dime a dozen and they're done

0:12:07 by out of work HR people and they don't have a good track record or a known one.

0:12:13 So to be quite objective on this, have we evaluated the performance measuring systems track record

0:12:21 in other cities is something that is hard information coming out of a bunch of agity

0:12:27 of adverbs that say well everybody's trying real hard.

0:12:31 I'm just a little bit uncertain that I can support this right now, much unless I got a

0:12:36 clearer approval check that yeah, it's going to have a measurable impact on our performance.

0:12:46 Some years ago, I want to say five-ish years ago, the city participated in a program offered

0:12:54 by ICMA.

0:12:55 ICMA is the International City Management Association.

0:12:58 They have a product that they sell that is a performance measure product.

0:13:04 And if you look at that product and we did, the intent would be buy into this program much

0:13:11 It's like the National Citizen Survey, they give you this product and you implement it across

0:13:17 your departments and it's a performance measurement system.

0:13:20 It's very, it's numbers based, it's not objective, it's the building department reviewed and approved

0:13:26 X number of permits in the fiscal year and the public works department review or improved

0:13:33 X miles of road and it's very measurable, the problem that we had, and we did it for,

0:13:39 I want to say two years in a row,

0:13:42 we had a real difficult time implementing it

0:13:45 in a way that worked for us because different cities

0:13:48 measured things just differently.

0:13:50 And this was kind of a can to product,

0:13:52 and we found that we didn't really fit well in the can.

0:13:55 And so we abandoned it pretty quickly,

0:13:58 like I said, after the second year.

0:13:59 It also wasn't complete for us.

0:14:02 So we have one of the things I can remember clearly

0:14:05 was there was no real good measurement

0:14:07 for economic development, where economic development department was, we were moving

0:14:12 down this path of performance measurement and Melinda at the time was looking at that going,

0:14:17 how do I measure, what do I measure, because they weren't included in my can.

0:14:23 And so it was an attempt, it was a good attempt in some ways and then it kept it very, you know,

0:14:28 numbers based measurable, but it also wasn't real good because it didn't necessarily work

0:14:33 for everything we were doing.

0:14:34 was asking for data that we didn't necessarily collect.

0:14:38 So we abandoned it.

0:14:40 The idea would be to bring somebody in,

0:14:43 kind of help us create a program that takes the good things

0:14:47 from that, that helps us as a department,

0:14:50 various departments around the city,

0:14:51 to find what's important for us to measure.

0:14:55 And then how do we measure it?

0:14:56 And is that the right thing to measure?

0:14:58 Should we be measuring something else,

0:14:59 and kind of walk us through that process so that in the end,

0:15:03 We could have a product that we'll use, right,

0:15:07 that the departments will buy into.

0:15:10 That was another real struggle for us,

0:15:14 handing the departments something to say, use this,

0:15:16 and then like, oh, that doesn't work for us.

0:15:18 We don't do x, y, z, and so have a creation of our own process

0:15:23 that the departments can buy into that they helped create

0:15:27 with this consultant out there, things that

0:15:32 that are measurable and important for us to measure, that aren't substantive, but rather, you know.

0:15:38 Right, so their cities have on request of this very type of a model?

0:15:43 Well, in the ICMA product was adopted by a ton of cities.

0:15:46 That was one of the benefits that they gave us the ability to compare with just a bunch of cities.

0:15:52 In those areas that we actually measured and compared it,

0:15:56 I said it didn't work out well for us, so we kind of wanted to do this other thing.

0:16:03 Now, Travis, we put this budget request out of our office.

0:16:10 I think in balancing the budget, Travis decided to kind of take one for the team, lots of

0:16:16 every department stuff they had to give up, and I think that was the city manager's give

0:16:21 up.

0:16:22 Not that there wasn't, not that there was a lack of confidence we could accomplish it,

0:16:28 other things were more important for the money at the time.

0:16:31 And so I think if we, I think Travis has an expectation

0:16:37 of the organization that we're going to do this.

0:16:40 And if we don't get funding for it,

0:16:41 we're going to attempt to do it anyway ourselves.

0:16:44 It would just be a lot easier, I think,

0:16:45 to get done if we had a little help

0:16:47 from somebody who may have done some before.

0:16:49 And so that's why we're going to put it back in.

0:16:54 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:16:56 Thank you.

0:16:56 Well, not to beat a dead horse,

0:16:58 but I was going the same direction as Chris.

0:17:01 So, are we measuring against other cities?

0:17:03 Are we measuring against ourselves?

0:17:06 I, to me, that seems like a lot of money where we already do the citizen survey and we do other things.

0:17:12 And we have a lot of things in position to make sure that we're offering a quality service to our citizens.

0:17:19 And so, I'm not following why we would want to spend $50,000 when we have a whole list of other items.

0:17:28 So what's the point to measure against other cities to?

0:17:31 The idea would be to set us, I guess,

0:17:35 a performance expectation of our own,

0:17:38 not to compare to other cities.

0:17:40 So we had that when we were trying to go with the ICA product.

0:17:43 And like I said, struggled with it.

0:17:46 But this idea moving forward would not

0:17:51 be to compare ourselves with others,

0:17:52 because obviously we'd create our own system that would be ours

0:17:56 and not necessarily directly comparable to others.

0:18:01 But rather, here's what we expect of ourselves.

0:18:04 Here's what the community expects of us,

0:18:07 and are we meeting that expectation?

0:18:10 So only for our own measurement of our own products

0:18:13 that we feel are important for this community.

0:18:16 And year to year are we doing also

0:18:22 to tie that to strategic planning efforts.

0:18:24 Are we doing what the community expects us to do?

0:18:28 It's really just about managing our own work.

0:18:31 It just seems to me that we know that,

0:18:34 and I don't understand why we pay somebody

0:18:36 from the outside to come in and help us create it.

0:18:39 I understand everybody's busy and has full workloads,

0:18:42 but we know what we need.

0:18:43 Somebody outside the organization doesn't.

0:18:46 So I have a really hard time with that one.

0:18:49 And just to be honest, I have in the past voted

0:18:52 against other citizens who've asked for extensions

0:18:56 to have gravel pavement, and I could not support the city going that direction if we're not

0:19:03 paving, so I just would, I would feel very hypocritical.

0:19:11 So I'd like to chime in and just briefly on the performance measurement piece, so the

0:19:17 past conversations I recall as we've gone through the strategic planning process, as

0:19:21 once we've gone through the strategic planning process and we've laid out what our goals

0:19:25 and strategies and objectives are, the question has always been, how do we know when we accomplished

0:19:31 it, unless it's, yes, you did that or no, you didn't do that.

0:19:36 And a lot of those have this sort of spectrum of how you've accomplished it.

0:19:41 And I've always looked at the performance measurement, again, developed by some professional

0:19:46 that knows how to lay that measurement over the top, being the tool that we would use to

0:19:53 not only our internal performance, but I think, again,

0:19:56 meeting the objectives laid out by the community input

0:20:00 and the citizens' expectations, different

0:20:03 than how did your police department perform last year,

0:20:07 which is the citizen survey component.

0:20:09 And more, did you accomplish X, Y, and Z

0:20:12 that you laid out to do?

0:20:14 And if not, how do you get there?

0:20:16 So I can see it being a valuable tool.

0:20:19 You're not going to go contract a consultant by Friday.

0:20:24 So, and any contract that is developed is going to come back to the Council for approval anyway.

0:20:32 So, I would not have a problem supporting that funding be available should a reasonable project,

0:20:42 a reasonable proposal come back that has, that meets the expectations of the Council and the staff.

0:20:49 So, on that issue I would say I could be supportive of an understanding.

0:20:54 it's not going to be implemented by September 30.

0:20:59 Absolutely accurate.

0:21:00 This is one on this list where we wouldn't encumber the funds, but in the week it wouldn't

0:21:05 happen.

0:21:06 So this would be essentially Council's authorization to use next year's reserves.

0:21:11 Right.

0:21:12 And then on the parking lot issue, so I too drive around that curve many times a day since

0:21:20 It's on my way to work from home and vice versa.

0:21:23 And currently, people are parking on the dirt and weeds.

0:21:27 So I would support getting some sort of surface treatment

0:21:31 down that helps to keep it from becoming a mud

0:21:34 fest in the next month when it might actually rain,

0:21:37 and certainly when it starts to snow.

0:21:40 In anticipation that there will be a more permanent solution,

0:21:43 but to your point, we're not going

0:21:45 to get asphalt down before the plants close anyway.

0:21:49 And the reality is we can't stop people from parking out there

0:21:53 because right now they're finding every nook and cranny

0:21:55 to park it.

0:21:55 They're parking in the next to the T where the road comes in.

0:22:00 They're parking on the road.

0:22:01 And now they're parking in the weeds.

0:22:04 So personally, I think compacted gravel is better

0:22:09 than what it is now, understanding

0:22:11 that it's probably not feasible to get asphalt down this wall.

0:22:16 So again, those are my two cents.

0:22:18 Both of those points, Sean, yours and Suzanne, I agree.

0:22:22 I don't think we ought to just put a gravel.

0:22:24 I think it needs to be followed up with asphalt later,

0:22:27 because we have that expectation on everybody else.

0:22:30 We should do better ourselves.

0:22:33 It won't happen before the winter.

0:22:35 We just can't.

0:22:35 And even if we had the money now in an asphalt company

0:22:39 mobilized by the end of paving this year anyway,

0:22:42 because they're all going through the season anyway.

0:22:46 but I'd probably get some gravel delivered,

0:22:49 and we could probably get that down,

0:22:50 and then in the spring we could probably

0:22:52 get somebody out there, and if we had the full 90

0:22:54 instead of just the 40, I think that the rest of that

0:22:58 could very likely put some asphalt down on top

0:23:02 of the gravel that we were gonna put down now.

0:23:04 Understanding that we would need the council to say,

0:23:08 yep, temporary gravel is okay because that's the base

0:23:12 for your future asphalt.

0:23:13 It's got to be there anyway when you pour asphalt down on top of it so

0:23:18 If this were to be approved I would probably not do the trail extension for on break

0:23:24 And I would hold that money for the spring

0:23:27 We all talked about it in the room and we felt the same way that we need to pay this

0:23:34 You know Sean and Stanley

0:23:38 And he's like how can I go out there and tell people they need to pay their parking lots when ours isn't

0:23:42 So there's a whole Christmas tree up here, so let's stick to the parking line, Suzanne.

0:23:51 So I understand what you're saying, and I can live with that, and real quick, on the trail

0:23:59 extension, as long as that isn't happening, I understand the mobilization piece of that.

0:24:05 But if we have other property to buy, we're going to have to mobilize again, anything else.

0:24:12 piece of that, but if we have other property to buy, we're going to have to mobilize again

0:24:16 anyway. So if we take the Rock Creek off, I would compromise on the other.

0:24:24 Any of the other three of you have comments on the parking lot?

0:24:27 I do.

0:24:28 Yes.

0:24:29 So Greg Lantic.

0:24:30 I guess all of the rest of you.

0:24:31 The point I would make on the parking lot is we, well, I don't know how much we do it

0:24:35 on council, but we often do it on planning zoning where you were allowed to tell the next,

0:24:40 a certain date in the next contractions season June 1st, July 1st, whatever it was in order

0:24:45 to get the asphalt down it, but you can utilize it now in a way that you have not tracked about

0:24:52 out on the road just shot right. If we go into the winter without anything on there,

0:24:59 the storm water retention rules are going to be, well we aren't quite under them yet,

0:25:05 we're certainly going to be breaking, we're bringing dirt out on the big roads.

0:25:10 Thank you, Boyd.

0:25:13 One of my concerns is when I heard that people were driving, they were not really wanting to

0:25:18 drive over the trail to park, but now they're doing that.

0:25:24 You cannot drive over edges of things.

0:25:27 It completely crumbles that, and we're going to have cost and repair.

0:25:32 But I think some kind of signs out there that tell people where to park with winter coming

0:25:38 up and there's speculation out there that it's going to be at least as bad as last year,

0:25:42 if not worse. Between the community of people, the neighbors that live there and the amount

0:25:48 of traffic that travels on pole line, we have to do something to protect the citizens and

0:25:57 that asset that we have there. And so if we're going to spend the money to go in and do the

0:26:04 proper compaction and the rock that we use is the same rock that's the layer under the asphalt

0:26:13 and we can use all of that. I would be in favor of doing that in the asphalting in the spring.

0:26:21 Ruth Pierce.

0:26:24 So Mitch, remember the Gould parking lot and we did something temporary for that. Was it gravel

0:26:32 or was it a step further? Because I remember we did something early on and then we had to finish

0:26:39 it up the spring. Yeah, it's still in its temporary. It's not a school day. It does. It's a carriage up.

0:26:49 Well, so what we did there initially was just a gravel treatment and then that was a very, very

0:26:57 short time. And then a few months later I want to say we came back in with a like a double chip oil

0:27:04 seal which is very similar to the parking lot that we have at Sunway Soccer Complex and

0:27:10 at...

0:27:11 Lower half of the golf course.

0:27:14 Golf course right now.

0:27:15 That's what I was thinking of the ball fields that we have south, south park, Oregon Trail

0:27:20 Youth Complex.

0:27:22 And so we have the, it's basically kind of like a oil double chip that acts like an

0:27:27 asphalt and we've kind of approved that in a few different situations as a paved lot.

0:27:34 Ultimately, that will be kind of redone full on asphalt pavement with its appropriate landscaping

0:27:43 and things like that, too.

0:27:44 So could we do that in this parking lot or?

0:27:48 But I'm proposing is just a full on paved job, not that, but just a regular.

0:27:53 But not till next spring.

0:27:55 Yeah, in phases we'll get it kind of put in place and then by next summer hopefully we

0:28:01 would have a regular old parking lot.

0:28:04 I don't have to address drainage too, which is something I really talk about, but once you put asphalt down it tends to run water off and we got to put that somewhere.

0:28:11 Chris Reed.

0:28:12 So with the parking lot, I think we actually have more of a responsibility to do that if we have people on dirt, which is going to turn into mud, and we're going to have people stuck out there.

0:28:23 So, I would say we would really get rid of the Rock Creek Trail extension.

0:28:31 That's a trail that's going to end, you know, really go nowhere, putting money into something

0:28:37 that I don't know how many people are going to go down.

0:28:40 I enjoy that trail.

0:28:42 I'm not going to run down something that just dead ends.

0:28:44 I'm going to have to turn around and run back.

0:28:46 So I would propose that we would move the 50 and just put all of it on the parking lot

0:28:52 90 and make sure that it's done properly and I think that we have to do something right now people are parking there

0:28:59 We're gonna get snow. It's gonna melt

0:29:01 It's gonna turn into mud. We're gonna have people out there, and so that would be my recommendation

0:29:24 So do you need a

0:29:31 So, can I, yeah, I think so.

0:29:34 I think emotional would be good because I heard a little uncertainty on the first one.

0:29:38 It'd be nice to have a clear direction on the performance measurement because there's

0:29:41 some more and some against.

0:29:43 And then it seems like, strike the last one and put 90 toward the parking lot seems to

0:29:48 be a consensus at least, apart from that.

0:29:52 Right.

0:29:53 Yeah.

0:29:54 Okay.

0:29:55 So, Chris, talk.

0:29:56 Well, I'm just going to throw out a motion to start that it seems like we're in total agreement

0:30:00 on the items 2, 3, 4, 5 enrolling that 50 into the 40 or 40 into the 50 for a 90.

0:30:09 So I would move to approve those and then leave up first one there for a number of rules.

0:30:16 Second.

0:30:17 Motion by Chris Tockington, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the projects as presented

0:30:25 with the exception of the performance measurement professional services and the Rock Creek Trail

0:30:31 extension but to combine those funds into the reserve trail head parking

0:30:35 treatment. Yeah Greg Lanting. Well I was gonna make it make a motion for

0:30:39 amendment but I decided maybe it'd be better if we just vote on that one.

0:30:43 Completely separate makes it cleaner and then only may vote against the main motion

0:30:46 because the amendment passed. Yeah. So is there any discussion on the amendment

0:30:52 that's on the floor? Sharon will call it please. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Greg

0:31:04 Glanting, Ruth Pierce, Christopher Reed, Chris Talkington, John Bericher, Nicki Boyd.

0:31:12 Yes.

0:31:13 The question passes 7 to 0.

0:31:17 So Mitch, a question for you.

0:31:19 If that $50,000 for the performance measurement professional services just rolls to reserves,

0:31:29 what's the process, should a proposal come back to the Council after this sort of new

0:31:33 to here to tap into those slides.

0:31:36 So in the absence of some approval to move forward

0:31:40 with that tonight, we would have this conversation.

0:31:42 Can we come back and can we take $50,000 out of reserves?

0:31:48 Actually, at that point, you might have a more firm number

0:31:50 because we might actually have a contract with somebody

0:31:52 that could say $48,736 or whatever the actual number was.

0:31:57 Can we take that much money out of reserves

0:31:59 and authorize this contract to proceed?

0:32:02 And then with the council's approval,

0:32:05 we would enter into that contract.

0:32:07 And then at the end of the year, next September,

0:32:10 we do a bunch of the amendment to take care of it.

0:32:12 Yeah.

0:32:14 Chris talking to you.

0:32:15 Yeah, that being said, I would say that I would move,

0:32:17 rather than we withhold the 50,000 expenditure

0:32:21 at this time on the performance measuring system,

0:32:24 just roll it forward into reserves with the risk of the money.

0:32:27 I'll second that.

0:32:30 Motion by Chris talking to the second by Ruth Pierce

0:32:32 to withhold those funds and have a proposal come back in the new fiscal year.

0:32:41 Chris Reed.

0:32:43 Jumped over Greg on that and we have to go into order.

0:32:46 I just wanted to make sure, no matter what, whether we approve the 50,000 now or later,

0:32:51 you're going to have to come back with somebody.

0:32:54 With a contract that says, hey, ABC Company is going to come and do this, we like what they do.

0:33:01 Yeah, either way, I do what this money would be to hire a contract, to enter into a contract,

0:33:06 and that contract would have to be approved by the council.

0:33:09 So it's not stopping the process.

0:33:12 It's just you would have to come back at that point in time.

0:33:14 Okay.

0:33:15 Thank you.

0:33:16 Great.

0:33:17 Thank you.

0:33:18 I think I'd like to be on record.

0:33:19 I'd like to at least look to see what they can give us.

0:33:21 You know, if we put a proposal out that somebody, then we could make a decision on whether

0:33:27 under that 50,000 was better.

0:33:29 Setting her blind, and kind of like Chris,

0:33:32 I was moving this down into like performance model

0:33:36 for mayor pay and everything else.

0:33:37 It wasn't, but every time every place I've ever worked

0:33:40 that they went to an efficiency expert,

0:33:43 it was just like, oh no.

0:33:44 So I want to make sure it's not that type

0:33:47 of a situation before I would be willing to vote yes on it.

0:33:50 So I will be voting yes on his motion,

0:33:52 but I would still like to see what they might be able

0:33:54 to do for us.

0:33:55 So, to answer your question, Councilman Reed, I guess I would back up a little bit.

0:34:00 If the Council tonight were to say we're not interested, we wouldn't even do the next step.

0:34:04 We just back off and talk.

0:34:05 But I'm not hearing that.

0:34:06 I'm hearing let's work through this a little bit more closely and then come back again.

0:34:11 The devil's in the details.

0:34:13 Again, I think as we've had this conversation through the strategic planning process for

0:34:18 the last five years, we've always talked about how are we going to know if we're successful?

0:34:23 How are we going to measure that?

0:34:24 And I think that's an important factor, as opposed to, well, it felt good that we did

0:34:30 some things.

0:34:31 I think we need to be finding a way to do that, and it sounds like a system that we were looking

0:34:38 at previously wasn't quite the mechanism, so I would hope that we could go out and look

0:34:43 for something that could help us be successful at, particularly now that we're coming through

0:34:48 with the update to the plan and really laying out some new goals and addressing how we've

0:34:53 done in the past I think it would be timely to have that discussion. Any other

0:34:58 discussion on the motion? Sharon Roll call vote please. Greg Lanting yes

0:35:08 repairs yes Christopher Reed yes Chris Tockington yes Sean Berriger yes Nicky Boyd

0:35:19 yes Suzanne Hoffman yes motion passes seven to zero so I would note that we do

0:35:27 have a public hearing that was scheduled to begin no sooner than 6 p.m. to do our

0:35:33 end-of-the-year budget amendment. We have a couple more items still on the

0:35:37 agenda so we're going to keep cruising along with those and then we will get to

0:35:40 that public hearing. Next in the agenda is a request to modify the speed zone on

0:35:46 Orchard Drive between Washington Street South and Blue Lakes Boulevard South. We

0:35:50 have Jackie Fields, our city engineer. Welcome Jackie. So this evening I intended to

0:35:57 come and request modification to the speed zone, not

0:36:00 larger, between Washington and the street south, and

0:36:03 Blue Lakes, Boulevard south.

0:36:05 That is a split jurisdiction roadway between the

0:36:07 Highway District and the city.

0:36:10 Last week, I went and visited with the

0:36:12 Commissioners for the Highway District, and they had

0:36:15 expressed an interest to get some additional input on

0:36:19 their part and do a field trip, and they wanted to

0:36:23 reconvene at their first meeting in October, do their

0:36:28 and presumably as to whether or not they were in full support for speed reduction in that area as well.

0:36:39 So this evening I would like to postpone your decision

0:36:47 after they have had an opportunity to gain input on their own.

0:36:51 The real challenge with the speed zone is that the Highway District's jurisdiction ends right at the intersection of Harrison Street South

0:37:03 And that makes a reasonable, more inclusive process

0:37:14 than just having us sign our own section in a vacuum.

0:37:20 The desire to look at a speed zone on archer drive

0:37:24 is part of an ongoing process that we started before the school.

0:37:30 I actually started and are going to continue, probably,

0:37:35 the better part of a year to address what really happens.

0:37:42 You know, we look at our situation with kids coming to a new school and we make an estimate

0:37:48 on how we think behaviors are going to occur and we start working on truing those up.

0:37:55 We're a situation that aligns with our pedestrian and bicycle behavior as well as our parental driver behaviors.

0:38:06 several ongoing steps that we'll be making in the entire vicinity of the school.

0:38:15 Now, I want to just throw out there. Orchard is a long way away from the middle school.

0:38:23 It's over half a mile. But it is being impacted potentially by the school behavior.

0:38:31 So we're not ignoring that. The staff recommendation is to postpone the decision until after the

0:38:42 the highway district is meant, and I can more inform recommendation.

0:38:50 Do you know when their meeting is scheduled in October?

0:38:52 It's the first Wednesday. So my hope and goal is to attend the meeting, have a happy outcome.

0:39:00 It causes me to have to no more investigation, dash off the agenda item, which is due on Wednesday,

0:39:05 so that it can be come to you on the night.

0:39:08 Thank you.

0:39:09 If it's not a happy outcome, I'll be back on the 16th.

0:39:12 Okay. Thank you. Greg Lanting.

0:39:15 Well, Jackie, I certainly don't want to disagree, and I don't want to step on the toes of the highway district because they've been a good partner with us, but to me, because I've been through that intersection of months, the dangerous direction is our direction to the west, you know, make sure I'm saying this correctly, the direction from Orchard West is ours.

0:39:36 And Orchard East is the Highway Districts.

0:39:39 I mean from Harrison.

0:39:41 From Harrison's, excuse me.

0:39:43 Yeah, thank you.

0:39:44 From Harrison East, there last is ours.

0:39:47 And from Harrison East is the Highway Districts.

0:39:52 So, sadly that's not quite true.

0:39:54 The city has jurisdiction from Washington Street south to about Villavas to Park.

0:40:00 And then the Highway District has jurisdiction from Villavas to Park to Harrison Street south.

0:40:05 And then as we progressed in an easterly direction,

0:40:08 we have jurisdiction from Harrison Street South

0:40:11 to about Gregory Wade,

0:40:13 and then the Highway District has jurisdiction

0:40:15 from there, all the way out.

0:40:20 So it's on this map.

0:40:21 There's another city piece out there.

0:40:23 A map that's in the packet.

0:40:25 The gray part is the highway district.

0:40:27 Let me just open it home.

0:40:28 Let me see if I can get it open here, my fault.

0:40:32 We're the white parts, so we've got this little section

0:40:35 and the way out here by Washington.

0:40:39 I was considering, you know, because in my mind, we had the west part, they had the east

0:40:52 part and we had the west part.

0:40:55 My concern is I believe the most dangerous direction is those vehicles traveling east

0:41:02 on Orchard because you come over that hill and they can't see the intersection until they're

0:41:07 over the hill.

0:41:09 I believe it's a safety issue, I truly do, I mean I believe we got lucky with the one

0:41:15 accident that we had, that we didn't have a fatality, and I would like this to see at

0:41:21 least if we can, we have some way to put a warning sign up there for those about traffic

0:41:27 kidding, if we can't change the speed of them tonight, can we put some sort of warning as

0:41:32 a student's crossing or anything to slow the traffic down so we don't, if I went, we have

0:41:38 I'm a fatality and I didn't make a motion tonight, I'm never going to live with it, okay, I'm not.

0:41:43 And so that's my concern. The traffic heading east on orchard needs to be slower.

0:41:50 And what we can do as quickly as we can do is what I would like to do.

0:41:59 Nicky Boyd?

0:42:00 So my question is, has something transpired?

0:42:04 So we go back to the summer when the traffic safety commission did a field trip and we went out there and we looked at all this stuff.

0:42:13 We made recommendations. You've presented and been before council before. The highway

0:42:19 district was in attendance at that. And all along, everybody has been in agreement. And

0:42:27 there's certain things we can't do anything about, like the farm ground on Harrison going

0:42:33 north. I mean, you can't put sidewalks out there. And the people who live out there came

0:42:39 and they said what they wanted.

0:42:41 And everybody agreed that that speed limit

0:42:45 and some well marked crosswalks would be great.

0:42:51 And now it's the end of September, we've had an accident,

0:42:56 and really I don't see that anything's been done,

0:42:59 and I'm feeling immense, I don't live out there,

0:43:02 but I'm feeling a lot of pain for the people

0:43:04 who do live out there, that they've asked

0:43:07 for these things to be done, and they've gotten

0:43:09 all this positive feedback, but nothing actually happened that I can tell.

0:43:14 So the people that came and spoke to traffic safety were very interested in what was happening

0:43:18 on mile to the south on 3,600 and so their improvements are occurring out there.

0:43:27 So there was a pretty fair number of people, I don't remember exactly how many, but a

0:43:34 The short dozen came to the traffic safety commission in ways their concerns and they

0:43:39 were almost entirely associated with 3600.

0:43:47 And we're addressing those concerns.

0:43:48 So we had to order equipment, the equipment's coming in, we had to place requests, I to

0:43:58 power to install an luminaires, but it's easier to see the intersection of Harrison, and 3600

0:44:03 north.

0:44:04 and what the time changes and it starts when the kids are coming and going away and we're

0:44:10 doing that.

0:44:11 Okay.

0:44:12 So those things, so the people out there feel like they've been heard and we're making some

0:44:17 progress.

0:44:18 I understand.

0:44:19 So we want to do it right and it's a really big picture.

0:44:21 I think they do believe that they've been heard and they've also been encouraged to re-contact

0:44:27 me or the Traffic Safety Commission if they feel that they are seeing something that is

0:44:34 or they do not understand where the progress is.

0:44:38 If they're not seeing progress and they're wondering

0:44:39 if we've forgotten them or if something happened,

0:44:42 they have been encouraged to call me and ask.

0:44:45 Okay, and if I don't exactly have the schedule,

0:44:47 I'll go find out what it is.

0:44:49 So when I made that presentation, the City Council indicated

0:44:53 that you as a group or at least portions of you

0:44:57 would like to have us investigate what's going on in

0:45:00 with the intent of doing some sort of safety improvement there.

0:45:05 And we're working on that.

0:45:08 So safety improvements are usually a result of an unsafe condition.

0:45:13 And so some of what's happening on Harrison Street South is perceived with anxiety.

0:45:20 What is actually happening is that the people are sure in the road.

0:45:24 So I had an anecdote that came to me where there was a driver who was concerned

0:45:29 concern because she had to stop because there was a, she was in conflict with the school

0:45:34 bus and a vice-super writer. That is absolutely perfect and appropriate behavior on a normal

0:45:41 narrow country road. And that section of Harrison that she was on is a normal narrow

0:45:46 life road. So it's good that people have enough wherewithal and concern that they are

0:45:53 saying, hey, you know, we have to slow down. And, you know, I'm paying attention to these

0:45:58 gets and it comes to you in the form of I'm worried and that's good that's how

0:46:04 people are calm with traffic to your point on on orchard you said hey you

0:46:09 know I think that Greg you said you think that the more dangerous section of

0:46:13 road is the eastbound you know or more uncomfortable section of road and it is

0:46:18 because the visibility is encouraged con and it's a narrow section of roadway

0:46:21 and we actually see that in the traffic data yet so the speeds for eastbound

0:46:26 traffic are slower by five miles an hour than those coming west and because they perceive

0:46:33 that there's a problem.

0:46:35 That was my follow up question is I actually went through and looked at all of that data

0:46:39 and that's what I figured I was looking at.

0:46:45 Are you happy with the results of the data, the speeds on there, or is it sitting relatively?

0:46:52 I think that the data is accurate and that it's actually reflective of what's happening

0:46:56 And it's interesting to me that people will self-regulate.

0:46:59 The speed limit is supposed to sit at 50 in that section,

0:47:02 and people are not going 50, right?

0:47:05 Especially not between two and four.

0:47:07 85% of the people are not going 50,

0:47:11 which is kind of surprising, you know,

0:47:13 that there are most people hit the post-to-speed limit.

0:47:17 So I believe that the first step was to modify the speed zone

0:47:22 and to watch and see what happens here.

0:47:25 So the situation with the kid that got hit on a bicycle

0:47:28 is a little bit more complicated than simply getting

0:47:33 mowed over by some speeding driver on orchard.

0:47:36 Otherwise, his personal situation

0:47:40 would have been a lot different than it is.

0:47:43 And it wouldn't have just been, thank you, Jackie.

0:47:49 Chris Reed.

0:47:51 First I want to thank you for all the work

0:47:52 that you've put into this.

0:47:53 I know that you've really worked with the Highway District.

0:47:56 And so thank you for that.

0:47:57 My question is, why are we waiting for them first?

0:48:03 Why couldn't we change our section of the road?

0:48:06 And just go with that.

0:48:07 And then they do what they want to do.

0:48:10 Again, we have the section when you're turning off the

0:48:14 turning off blue lakes or Washington.

0:48:16 We have that section.

0:48:17 So that sign would be posted right there.

0:48:19 They'd see that first and hopefully carry that through on

0:48:23 the highway districts area.

0:48:24 So why wait for them and not just make the change ourselves?

0:48:29 Okay.

0:48:31 So it is always easier as a driver to comply with the law when I can look at the sign and

0:48:41 know what the speed is for a given run of payment.

0:48:45 In our particular case, I'll try to show you what's going on here.

0:48:51 Okay.

0:49:01 So Washington's at the bottom.

0:49:02 Oopsie.

0:49:11 Sadly, I can't see the screen over there and I can't see it here either, so I can kind

0:49:20 of see it here.

0:49:26 That sense.

0:49:27 Right where my pencil tip is, is within city limits.

0:49:30 That's a 35 mile an hour zone.

0:49:32 The 50 mile an hour speed zone is right here.

0:49:35 That sign currently exists.

0:49:40 Okay, there's a sign right there.

0:49:42 There's a sign right there that says 50.

0:49:44 Okay, so what we are, so then our opportunity here is to place a 35 mile an hour sign.

0:49:49 five mile an hour sign right here on this side of Orchard, which is really helpful if you are a kid who is coming off of Gregory and you decide you want to cross the street before you get to Harrison and then come down the ditch and come up that way.

0:50:12 And it's probably helpful that some of the drivers coming out of that south-to-states neighborhood.

0:50:17 And then right here, it goes back to 50.

0:50:26 And then it stays 50 until you get over to Paul's brand, and there's a 45-hour speech on there.

0:50:33 So, for the people who are coming from the west, they would be regulated at 35 miles an hour from right about Gregory,

0:50:45 kind of where my pencil is, it's a Harrison potential speed zone change.

0:50:52 I don't think that that accomplishes overall mission of lowering the speed limit in this

0:51:02 area that is looking and feeling like the inside of town, even though there are two parcels

0:51:10 that have not yet annexed.

0:51:11 I really think it's worth the wait.

0:51:21 We have a great relationship with the Iowa District.

0:51:24 I think it's important that they're able to address the concerns that they'll have, which

0:51:29 I would guess, and I don't know for a fact,

0:51:31 would come from the trucking community,

0:51:32 because there's an awful lot of people

0:51:34 that are coming through trying to get over

0:51:37 to the industries on the other side of town.

0:51:40 Now, there's a definite advantage to having the speed

0:51:43 have a reduction without having a stock sign.

0:51:47 It's really hard for those trucks to get going,

0:51:49 and they rent the pavement if they have to stop and start again.

0:51:52 So there may not be a lot of pushback

0:51:55 from the trekking industry for hitting the intersection of Washington Street South and

0:52:02 Orchard and then just proceeding at a very stately pace because it's going to be slow until

0:52:10 they get over on to the other side of Gregory Lane or perhaps even Lewis.

0:52:15 Great landing.

0:52:18 Well, I understand your explanation, Jack, you know, I certainly understand our relationship

0:52:27 with the highway district. I see an advantage, to be honest with you, when

0:52:34 Chris was talking about it, we go ahead and re-sign ours at this time and then

0:52:40 hope that the school district will or the school district will be the highway district will follow.

0:52:44 Because if I saw it, we had a 35 mile on our sign right there at the corner of

0:52:51 Orchard in Harrison for the traffic hitting east or 25 water would want to

0:52:55 make it, that would slow me down. I would see it and I would start to slow down because

0:53:02 I see a 35 mile an hour speed limit. I realize that it's a stop yet measure, but I don't know

0:53:12 what else to say other than we put the four way stop in on blue lakes, we put all these

0:53:17 big flashing signs. We have the capability of doing those kinds of things to make an area

0:53:24 safe and is it is it timely no but I have I'm here on the side of safety here

0:53:32 I like I said no no I could not imagine this between now and the highway district

0:53:37 gets us the meaning we have a fidelity or a fatality or a severe accident with

0:53:43 one of those children on that street I'm not gonna move it myself so I'm gonna

0:53:48 make a motion that we go ahead and resign our portion of Orchard Street to 35

0:53:54 miles an hour. Second. Motion by great landing second by Christopher Reed to

0:54:04 reduce the speed limit in the portions of Orchard Street that are in the Twin

0:54:10 Falls City jurisdiction to 35 miles per hour. Oh sorry I didn't hear the 35 I was

0:54:18 wondering what we were doing. 35. So 35 miles an hour is in no way shape or form

0:54:26 is represented by the 85th percentile or the speed state.

0:54:29 However, there is a section of state code

0:54:32 that indicates that the maximum speed limit

0:54:36 in a residential district can be 35 miles an hour.

0:54:42 And we meet that definition as a city

0:54:47 and a residential neighborhood.

0:54:50 So we can post to 35.

0:54:56 So Jackie, a question for you.

0:54:58 If this motion were not on the table tonight

0:55:00 and you had a conversation with the highway district, would your recommendation be,

0:55:05 if we had jurisdiction in this whole mile section, would your recommendation be 35 miles per hour

0:55:12 or would it be to follow the data for the 85th percentile?

0:55:16 My preference would be to follow the data for the 85th percentile.

0:55:20 My understanding is that that's not desirable and the recommendation

0:55:24 to go to a 35-mile-hour posting isn't acceptable.

0:55:27 I speak from the right-hand side.

0:55:33 Well, one of the things I would like to believe, I know that the 85 percentile shows one thing,

0:55:40 but I think the 85 percentile will move down if it's marked at 35.

0:55:45 People are going to drive. People do drive based on what the mileage is,

0:55:51 and people purposely drive less than the speed limit, and so I believe the 85th percentile

0:55:58 would change based on how we have it signed.

0:56:02 But I don't have any empirical data to back that up.

0:56:05 I won't be for student.

0:56:06 So the only comment I would say is,

0:56:17 I certainly appreciate your concerns, Greg,

0:56:21 that we need to err on the side of safety here.

0:56:26 I am hopeful that our continued collaborative approach

0:56:30 with other jurisdictions can come to a resolution

0:56:33 that helps to address all the concerns in this area

0:56:40 that is unfortunately experiencing some growing pains.

0:56:43 I mean, just looking at that map,

0:56:45 there's more non-urban development in that mile section

0:56:49 than there is urban development.

0:56:51 It happens to be an intersection

0:56:53 that's getting some new traffic that didn't exist a year ago.

0:56:59 So again, I hope we can have a good conversation

0:57:02 with the highway district and find a solution,

0:57:07 I suppose airing on the side of caution

0:57:09 for the next couple of weeks isn't going to hurt.

0:57:13 Chris Dockington.

0:57:14 Yeah, I think that's kind of what I was trying to put together

0:57:16 in my mind too, Sean.

0:57:19 I think if we put a 35 on there and then go back

0:57:24 and talk with the highway district and they're upset,

0:57:26 and something else comes out of their recommendation,

0:57:30 We have weakened our relations with another governmental jurisdiction.

0:57:36 And if we change that from a 35 that we'd temporarily put on their back to some other speed,

0:57:42 that's going to put them uncertain in people's minds that drive and traverse that area,

0:57:45 and that's going to decrease safety.

0:57:48 So those are the two downsides I see.

0:57:50 I don't want to damage the relations with a highway district.

0:57:55 However, it's damn difficult to argue

0:57:58 with the safety of a child.

0:58:01 I will henceforth go with the 35-mile-an-hour motion,

0:58:05 but with the hope that it is looked at as temporary,

0:58:08 and then until and unless we get other information

0:58:11 from the highway district.

0:58:13 It's fair.

0:58:16 Any other discussion?

0:58:19 Chair and roll call vote, please.

0:58:27 Ruth Pierce.

0:58:28 Yes.

0:58:29 Christopher Reed.

0:58:30 Yes.

0:58:31 Chris Taki.

0:58:32 Yes.

0:58:32 Sean Beriker, Nicky Boyd, Suzanne Hopkins, Greg Lanting.

0:58:38 Yes.

0:58:40 Motion passes.

0:58:41 Seven to zero.

0:58:42 Wasn't that simple?

0:58:43 Thank you, Jackie.

0:58:46 Next on the agenda is the approval and adoption of the collective bargaining agreement between

0:58:51 the City of Twin Falls and the Twin Falls Firefighters Local 1556.

0:58:56 And Gretchen Scott, our Human Resources Director.

0:59:00 Welcome Gretchen.

0:59:03 Hi, welcome. Good evening, Mayor and Council. It's good to see you this evening. So we have tonight for your consideration the updated collective bargaining agreement.

0:59:25 There are a few things that I had gone over in the staff report.

0:59:31 The general, I just want to briefly go through the changes as they are outlined and let you

0:59:42 ask questions if you have any of those specifics.

0:59:47 The union met last Thursday and voted adoption of the contract.

0:59:54 The executive board of the union is here today to help answer any questions that I cannot and

1:00:01 for the most part we're ready to go.

1:00:04 So this is a one-year contract that we are proposing tonight.

1:00:10 In general, the changes that I just wanted to review with you, Section 5 is the first one

1:00:17 that we talked about.

1:00:19 It is just clarification of language to include standard SOPs, standard operating procedures,

1:00:25 and guidelines that are included within department operations, but were not necessarily included

1:00:31 in the language of the contract.

1:00:32 They do oversee parts of functions, of operations, and what they do within the department, so they

1:00:37 thought it was good to reflect those within the contract itself as well.

1:00:43 In section seven, previously there was a limit on the number of association meetings, which

1:00:48 could be held at Fire Station 1.

1:00:50 Fire Station 1 here has a large training room, has the ability for them to meet.

1:00:56 It wasn't a, I don't know particularly what the concern as far as making sure it was only

1:01:05 a certain number of limited meetings, just in order to open it up and allow them to use the

1:01:09 facility for their business.

1:01:14 Schedule or section 11 is the schedule piece where we talk about them formally adopting

1:01:20 the schedule change from the 24-48 that they used to run to the 48-96 that they have been

1:01:26 running since approximately the first of this year.

1:01:33 It has been working well, the length of time off, the 96 hours off, the more time away allows

1:01:42 the better recovery for the intensity, the duration of the work that they are doing.

1:01:48 And with their recommendation to make that a permanent change, that's what we have gone ahead

1:01:54 and done.

1:01:56 The change of emergency call back pay from four hours of a minimum to two hours as the new minimum

1:02:02 used to be that when we had to call people back they got a four hour on their time card paid

1:02:08 and that was reduced to two.

1:02:10 The removal of working out of a classification and essentially a swap for the temporary assignment.

1:02:18 So organizationally we have a policy called working out of class.

1:02:22 So, if a supervisor or if a department leader is going to be away from work and not just

1:02:29 at the trainees, well, it could even be at the training, but significant distance and

1:02:32 not available for decision making, for running things through them, we used to do it called

1:02:38 working at a class A. In the fire department, it works a little bit differently just because

1:02:45 of the nature of how they do those things. So, instead, if the duration of that assignment

1:02:51 essentially is going to be, I think it's four weeks,

1:02:55 I don't know exactly what the language

1:02:58 for consecutive tours, yeah, so roughly four weeks.

1:03:02 That would be a temporary assignment.

1:03:03 We would actually be putting somebody into that role

1:03:06 above those responsibilities that would come with that.

1:03:10 It's much more of a formal way of recognizing that leader

1:03:14 and what we're asking them to do as opposed to just saying,

1:03:17 well, I'm gonna be gone for the next week and a half,

1:03:19 so you're working out of class.

1:03:26 On section 23, when we move firefighters, drivers,

1:03:34 captains from one shift to another,

1:03:37 it can impact how they have their vacation schedules out.

1:03:40 It impacts who had the holiday based on their rotation.

1:03:45 We have asked for a three-day minimum notice

1:03:48 in order to do that.

1:03:48 But it can also affect over time.

1:03:50 It can affect a lot of different things.

1:03:52 language essentially preserved the what had been in place for the person that's

1:04:00 kind of moving and the people that they're impacting as well. So it may cause

1:04:03 some additional overtime if we allow that, but it also if people have made plans if

1:04:08 they've done certain things it protects that vacation piece, it protects that holiday

1:04:12 piece with their families as well. Section 24 is to allow shift rates to occur between

1:04:22 employees who have a clearly qualifications and capacity to act with the right so

1:04:26 previously a driver had to sub for a driver firefighter had to sub for a

1:04:31 firefighter and that limited the pool of people who could then work for those

1:04:36 additional trade shifts for shift rates what that does is it allows that to open

1:04:40 up a little bit allow more flexibility of people to serve what they need to do

1:04:44 that, just opened that pool with a wider section 25, is the requirement to conduct a

1:04:55 promotional process for each position on a two-year interval to establish a ranked

1:04:59 list from which selections will be made. So in the fire department it's not unusual

1:05:04 that when the pool is expired of applicants for the position of firefighter

1:05:08 or if we've hired everybody or if it's been a certain period of time and we feel

1:05:12 like we need to refresh that list we go ahead and conduct a testing. Previously for

1:05:17 promoted positions, driver, captain, telling, well, not the time, too well, but we've only

1:05:23 done those on an as needed basis. And by doing it on a two year interval without

1:05:28 allows them to do is to get a little bit more frequent in participating in that

1:05:32 process. It allows them to hone those skills. It allows them to experience that,

1:05:36 which is a rigorous testing process. It requires a lot of preparation. It certainly

1:05:43 and puts them through a exercise of how they prepare,

1:05:47 how they think about their careers,

1:05:49 how they think about their futures,

1:05:50 and what they do in preparation for those tests.

1:05:54 Establishing a rank list just provides

1:05:55 that natural selection that we go through

1:05:58 when those are established.

1:05:59 And if something occurred, there was something sudden,

1:06:02 you wouldn't have to go through a process right then

1:06:04 that list would be in place.

1:06:10 Section 32 is added language, which essentially says

1:06:15 which essentially says that if the golf rate benefit that employees have at the Twin Falls

1:06:22 Golf Club goes away for all employees, goes away for those covered under the collecting

1:06:26 bargaining agreement as well. So it just kind of equalizes that out.

1:06:33 Appendix A is the update of all of the different changes to compensation and the definition

1:06:43 of physicians within each of the ranks of the department that were, we moved to in February

1:06:50 with the mid-year adoption and then again we wanted to clean up the language about who moved

1:06:55 where and put in place some of the goals that the local had in terms of how they made those

1:07:02 compensation adjustments.

1:07:04 So there were really specific things that they were trying to do in moving to that.

1:07:10 They wanted to make sure that essentially there was real parity between all of the different

1:07:16 positions as far as where they were relative to market.

1:07:20 They wanted to try to address as best they could, trying to gain towards market and as

1:07:27 close as steps as much as steps as they could as well.

1:07:32 It isn't equal across every individual within the department.

1:07:36 People get different increases, but it is fair.

1:07:39 They've treated everybody the same

1:07:41 They've recognized both

1:07:44 required or recognized how important certifications and the ability to contribute to operations in the department are and how they selected those positions as

1:07:52 Well as individual contributions that people can make so I think it strikes a good balance

1:07:58 Within their members in their department strikes a good balance towards operational goals that the city has and what we want to accomplish

1:08:05 make sure that people have levels to achieve to aim for as they continue to increase their

1:08:12 own education, work on their own certifications, and make progress across that salary table

1:08:17 and upwork through it.

1:08:21 Previously in the last agreement, we did not necessarily have the ability to adjust individual

1:08:27 salaries if we saw a real problem.

1:08:30 This adds language to allow us to do that.

1:08:33 organizationally when we have had something that doesn't look right, that we come to that

1:08:38 internal equity piece, we've just made minor adjustments to make sure that those things

1:08:42 balance out. Under the former contract, promotional percentages were set, we couldn't deviate from

1:08:48 those. So it put things into place that we couldn't really tinker with and this adds some

1:08:53 language that allows that in conjunction with the level.

1:09:01 One of the things that this agreement does is it strikes all certification pay that the

1:09:08 fire department has been paying because they're now required as part of positions.

1:09:13 So when you move forward in positions, you have to have those certifications.

1:09:18 That pay is considered part of the base salary.

1:09:21 But what was not on there before were some of the extra duties or other assignments that

1:09:25 the department does participate in that weren't recognized for.

1:09:29 And those are called out in the agreement, it talks about the assignment of people to the hazardous materials crew, the row technicians that do all of the high-angle rescue.

1:09:41 The training officer was a position that worked a little bit differently, but they have designated three specific positions for training officer.

1:09:50 So it just called out those responsibilities that they were cast with, that they often served on call and ready to respond to, but weren't compensated for in terms of what they did in that capacity.

1:10:01 And then finally, it was just the changing of the names for signing parties, so updated to reflect those as well.

1:10:12 So if there, we have any questions that you would like to ask, we're all ready to answer those for you.

1:10:19 You were pretty detailed.

1:10:24 You did an awesome job.

1:10:26 I read it all and I thought, who did I kind of get it, but now?

1:10:29 Yeah.

1:10:30 Now I get it.

1:10:31 I suspect the awesome job has involved an awful lot of people

1:10:34 for the past several weeks.

1:10:36 It has really been a team effort and I commend the board

1:10:40 and how much of them diligently they have worked on this.

1:10:43 They've spent just a ton of time off duty coming in,

1:10:47 meeting with me. We worked with Debbie City Manager Pike with Travis with Chief

1:10:52 Soul. We really worked hard to make sure that the language reflected the changes

1:10:56 that they were hoping to achieve and that moved them progressively forward.

1:11:01 Thank you, Chris. Well, I just want to make sure that the local 56 leadership

1:11:08 concurs with this description of was that accurate and is there anything that is

1:11:15 additional or less that we need to know about pertinent to these specific points.

1:11:20 Mayor and Council, though I, I, I did a great job explaining our changes. I probably couldn't

1:11:30 have done it any better. We actually over a big thank you for all the help she's given

1:11:37 us. If you want with this. There's any specific questions that you can try to answer if

1:11:43 It's a great job to sort of ending what we like to have.

1:11:52 Great, Lansing.

1:11:54 Uh, Captain Seigworth, I always pronounce this pronounce.

1:11:57 Is that right?

1:11:58 Yeah.

1:11:59 Sorry.

1:12:01 Um, I'd like you to be in the Lupo 1556, if not only for this negotiation period, but for

1:12:07 the entire time I'm on council, I mean, certainly we sometimes have different views on what needs

1:12:12 to be in the contract and I've always felt like I've never been down a dirty like

1:12:19 retching or ever doing it but I know that we've always been able to reach a

1:12:23 reach an amicable solution or resolution to the contract and we

1:12:31 certainly we certainly appreciate the firefighters and thank you to the local

1:12:38 for working with us, appreciate me.

1:12:41 Thank you for your guys' support.

1:12:43 There wasn't really any down and dirty.

1:12:45 There was a lot of work, but.

1:12:46 It's good.

1:12:48 No, it went really well.

1:12:49 Everybody got along good.

1:12:51 I guess one thing I would say, these weren't all

1:12:53 our changes.

1:12:53 Some of them came higher up in the city.

1:12:56 And the conglomeration.

1:12:58 Understand that.

1:12:59 Thank you.

1:13:01 Thank you.

1:13:01 Any other questions?

1:13:04 Seeing none, Council.

1:13:05 Come on, man.

1:13:08 I think Chris Reed lit up first there.

1:13:11 Oh, I was just gonna make a motion on something.

1:13:13 I think everybody else but it's too late in here.

1:13:17 So I move that we approve the collective bargaining agreement

1:13:22 between the City of Twin Falls and the Twin Falls Firefighters

1:13:26 Local 1556.

1:13:28 Second.

1:13:29 The motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins

1:13:31 to approve the collective bargaining agreement as presented.

1:13:36 Is there any further discussion?

1:13:39 Sharon Roll call vote please.

1:13:43 Christopher Reed.

1:13:44 Yes.

1:13:45 Chris Talkington.

1:13:46 Yes.

1:13:47 Suzanne Ershonberger.

1:13:49 Yes.

1:13:50 Nicky Boyd.

1:13:51 Yes.

1:13:52 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:13:53 Yes.

1:13:54 Greg Lanting.

1:13:55 Yes.

1:13:56 Ruth Pierce.

1:13:57 Yes.

1:13:58 Pass on 7-0.

1:13:59 Now that it's passed, did you guys bring the stickers to me?

1:14:03 Oh.

1:14:04 I never see you without stickers.

1:14:06 No, no, no, no.

1:14:07 Somebody's already done helped.

1:14:09 I'll talk a little bit.

1:14:10 Thank you, thank you very much.

1:14:17 We will definitely have them in two weeks for fire prevention.

1:14:21 I think there's a proclamation on the agenda.

1:14:23 So next on the agenda is opportunity for general public input again.

1:14:34 If anyone from the public wishes to address the Council on an issue that wasn't on the agenda this evening,

1:14:38 now has your chance to come forward. Come on up to the microphone there.

1:14:42 and I would just like to say thank you for lowering the speed limit and today I saw two school

1:14:50 buses out there which seem to really help so I hope they can do some sort of sign when there's a

1:14:58 crosswalk or something because it really seemed to help myself out there much for a while.

1:15:03 Thank you. Thank you. If you could please can you also say your name for the record?

1:15:07 Or Kenny I am a property owner. That's perfect. Thank you. Thank you.

1:15:11 Does anyone else who wishes to address the council?

1:15:15 All right.

1:15:19 I didn't set a time limit, but we do have a little bit more agenda to get to.

1:15:25 This is totally on point, so I'm not going to go off topic here.

1:15:28 I had a schedule under budget as our ideas for what you guys do and what you guys vote

1:15:33 on certain things.

1:15:34 There's never should be a plateau of our abilities to do great and better things with ourselves

1:15:39 and with our certain works within the community.

1:15:43 With new technology, our abilities perform at or above.

1:15:47 Performers expectations should be a lot easier,

1:15:50 especially if we have the tools to kind of help us maintain

1:15:53 those jobs that usually had to be done with our hands

1:15:57 versus the use of GPS signals and other technology.

1:16:04 I think that negotiations need to be put in place

1:16:07 if you're going to be getting contracts put together,

1:16:10 at least three to five contracts put together.

1:16:13 you guys have some weight to put it against Tomich's what what he's going

1:16:18 after is somebody to to to find key performance indicators so we know who

1:16:23 it is deserves these types of a miracle raises that's on the table. The HR team

1:16:31 had a great presentation. I think the expectation should be that of everybody,

1:16:36 you know, all ever clearing concise presentations that are clear and cut without jumping

1:16:42 slides without being too confused not to give them the guys the water works a

1:16:47 hard time but we can't make proper decisions if the information isn't

1:16:51 clear again when those GPS units are rated as $700 per unit trust me I've

1:16:59 looked them up and we can probably negotiate a better price at $350 per unit

1:17:04 at 10,000 units if we're gonna be doing a complete upgrade of the city so I would

1:17:08 I just keep in mind to keep your wallets close to your body while you're figuring out how to spend the extra money from previous budgets.

1:17:20 Thank you.

1:17:21 Thank you, Mr. Madison.

1:17:24 Chris, talk.

1:17:25 I just came back from two weeks in the Great Alaska now back and it was a glorious trip.

1:17:30 There was one thing that spoiled it.

1:17:33 One night late at night via satellite television.

1:17:36 The name of Twin Falls Idaho came up two times

1:17:40 within about 15 minutes.

1:17:42 First time you hear it,

1:17:43 you're not sure if Twin Falls Idaho,

1:17:44 they don't even know where Idaho is.

1:17:47 Nonetheless, the second time

1:17:48 the Twin Falls Idaho story came up.

1:17:51 I listened again with a special concern,

1:17:54 because it put Twin Falls Idaho on such a critical light

1:18:01 to the revelations of outside our country,

1:18:07 foreign meddling on elections and refugee matters.

1:18:11 It bothered me because it did show the bad side of Twin Falls, and it also bothered me

1:18:18 because it was in the front of the four years that I spent in the Cold War battling the

1:18:23 nemesis of Russia, upsetting peace.

1:18:29 I hope that this is behind Twin Falls now, but it brings back to memory.

1:18:36 many memories for many of us veterans and it also will be the only thing that many people

1:18:42 will ever know about Idaho is that mention of Twin Falls and the outside meddling by

1:18:50 foreign agents regarding elections and refugees.

1:18:55 Ruth Pierce?

1:18:57 So on a lighter note, thank you Chris.

1:19:00 I wanted to mention that next month is Breast Cancer Awareness Month.

1:19:05 Excuse me in the second Tuesday and Monday the second Monday of October

1:19:13 Mayor burger will be reading a proclamation declaring it a breast cancer awareness day tough enough to wear pink and

1:19:22 So I encourage all the citizens Monday for sure our fire department and our police department is are gonna wear them all week

1:19:30 And so anybody that wants to do that I think just remember it'll be a good day.

1:19:38 I mentioned anything from city staff. So we just had an approval of our

1:19:48 our collective bargaining group with the fire department and this week on

1:19:53 Wednesday one of our local fire department members is retiring 330 right

1:19:58 here in this room Captain Petreselli will be will be retirement celebration we'd

1:20:03 I'd like to invite the council to come down for that.

1:20:07 Thank you.

1:20:08 Anything else from the council?

1:20:09 If not, we will go ahead and move to our public hearing.

1:20:13 It is a request to amend the 2016-2017 budget, and we have Shane Carpenter, our budget coordinator.

1:20:21 If you want to bring our fire stickers up too, you can bring those up so quickly.

1:20:25 We're all waiting for Shane to get their eye on this.

1:20:27 I want to make sure that the council has their fire stickers, you know.

1:20:32 Yeah.

1:20:33 Thanks, sir.

1:20:34 Thank you.

1:20:35 Thank you.

1:20:36 Thank you.

1:20:41 Welcome, Shane.

1:20:42 Do you need to remain accountable?

1:20:46 This is kind of a formality that we go through every year to just bring our budget in line

1:20:51 with some of the expenditures that either someone in the city is coming forward and asking

1:20:56 you to spend the money, additional revenues, or some major projects like the waste of our

1:21:00 treatment plan, the city hall, things like that that were approved years ago, and then

1:21:04 these are just the expenses that we bring forward.

1:21:08 You should know about, but I'll just go over some of the highlight ones that you may not remember.

1:21:13 Like the $1.85 million, Mitch touched on a little bit, that we're taking into reserves this year.

1:21:20 We've got $5.60, I think is what he said, last year.

1:21:25 We're at $1.85 million just on the general fund.

1:21:28 The majority of that was from salaries in the police, mostly.

1:21:33 But there are little M&O, between prayers and the cost of fuel and things like that.

1:21:38 The $4.4 million, John Keaton was here asking to spend that money on the streets.

1:21:45 The City Hall Public Safety Complex is, that's what we spent so far this year.

1:21:51 It's about 3.9 on the City Hall, about 3.2 on the Public Safety Complex.

1:21:57 So that was something wrapped forward a couple years ago, but that's what we spent so far this year.

1:22:03 Community Grant Airport Fund, that's every year.

1:22:06 We don't budget the grant, but when we do get the money, then the bill usually comes forward and has to spend that money, too. They spend that money too. They spend that money too.

1:22:14 The booster station, Rob was here six or seven months ago and asked to spend that money.

1:22:19 That was coming out of reserves to the wastewater treatment plant, winding things down there.

1:22:26 About 3.3 million that we spent this year, total is about 33 million.

1:22:32 Troy tells me we're substantially

1:22:34 Troy D. Tech, our assistant city engineer,

1:22:36 tells me we're substantially complete on that,

1:22:39 and he hopes to have that completed

1:22:41 by the first quarter of next year.

1:22:43 I'll be some pain in things that need to be done,

1:22:45 but the major construction is already done.

1:22:49 Centennial, false trail repair,

1:22:52 I think Wendy came to you guys

1:22:55 about four months ago asking to fix that trail,

1:22:57 that's what that told me came in at that.

1:22:59 And then if I were to display,

1:23:00 we changed how we do that.

1:23:02 It used to be a citizen's group,

1:23:03 I think they did that now.

1:23:05 Two bodies part of the partner with us,

1:23:07 and that was their eight grand

1:23:08 that we didn't have the budget.

1:23:11 And that's about it.

1:23:13 Any questions?

1:23:16 Any questions for Shane?

1:23:19 So that's what I was just gonna check.

1:23:21 So.

1:23:25 Is there a new ordinance number for this one?

1:23:27 Sharon?

1:23:28 Yes, it would be ordinance 2017-4.

1:23:36 2017-24.

1:23:38 Yes.

1:23:39 Chris talking.

1:23:40 to play sordin is twenty seventeen dash twenty four on third and final by

1:23:44 puddle under suspension rules

1:23:49 was

1:23:50 also i forgot we have to have it

1:23:54 uh...

1:23:55 sorry about that

1:23:57 totally spaced out of the state

1:23:59 so if there

1:24:00 so we'll open the public hearing on the uh...

1:24:03 i mean

1:24:04 amendment to the budget

1:24:06 if there's anyone wishing to address the

1:24:08 Council on this issue and has your chance to come forward, please, seeing no one,

1:24:14 we will close the public input portion of the public hearing and we will turn it

1:24:18 over to Council for discussion.

1:24:20 For the motion by Chris Stockington seconded by Greg landing the place,

1:24:28 ordinance, 2017, 24 on third and final reading by title only under suspension of

1:24:33 the rules. Suzanne Hawkins. Oh, no, sorry. Okay.

1:24:36 I can't get the wrong button.

1:24:38 Is there any discussion?

1:24:40 Sharon will call vote please.

1:24:46 Chris Hockington.

1:24:47 Yes.

1:24:48 Sean Beriker.

1:24:49 Yes.

1:24:50 Nikki Boyd.

1:24:51 Yes.

1:24:52 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:24:53 Yes.

1:24:54 Greg Lanting.

1:24:55 Yes.

1:24:56 Ruth Pierce.

1:24:57 Yes.

1:24:58 Christopher Reed.

1:24:59 Yes.

1:25:00 Motion passes 7-0.

1:25:01 Sharon, would you read the title please?

1:25:06 Ordinance number 2017-24.

1:25:09 And Ordinance of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho amending Ordinance number 2016-24.

1:25:15 the appropriation ordinance for the fiscal year beginning October 1, 2016, and ending September

1:25:23 30, 2017, appropriating additional monies that are to be received by the City of Twin Falls

1:25:32 Idaho in the sum of $17,544,916 and providing an effective date be it ordained by the Mayor

1:25:45 and City Council of the City of Fund Falls, Idaho.

1:25:50 Council wishes Suzanne Hawkins.

1:25:54 I move approval of Ordinance 2017-24.

1:25:59 Second.

1:26:00 Motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Christopher Reed to approve Ordinance 2017-24.

1:26:05 Any discussion?

1:26:06 Roll call, but please share it.

1:26:12 Sean Berger?

1:26:13 Yes.

1:26:15 Nicky Boyd?

1:26:16 Yes.

1:26:17 Suzanne Hawkins?

1:26:18 Yes.

1:26:19 Greg Lanting?

1:26:20 Yes.

1:26:21 Ruth Pierce?

1:26:22 Yes.

1:26:23 Christopher Reed?

1:26:24 Yes.

1:26:25 Chris Talkin?

1:26:26 Yes.

1:26:27 Motion passes, it's 7-0.

1:26:29 Thank you, Shane.

1:26:30 Anything further from the council?

1:26:32 That meeting is adjourned.

1:26:37 That's fun.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, September 25, 2017. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:31:07.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    4b81e716e479afa2f80e5636b1dfadb9d48422c94ca4ab3095e012fa31238e16
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 047b420c26df73c391884df89f85509279857300ba8a5eeb0b150ba7c045f6b1
    part02.m4a ddee4791245aac6f6f0fc728969e22b676bc93ea1098950f591e96b0feeb71ca
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    abf7047dabaa5c496d47261a47b89855ddf91b7810271f9ba5e284beb3c1ef6c

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file