City Council meeting
Monday, February 5, 2018
Special meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: a
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:01:03 I would like to reconvene the Twin Falls City Council meeting from Monday, February 5th.
0:01:07 We did call the meeting to order at 4 o'clock and then took a recess over and take a tour
0:01:12 of our new communications center and our police operations building.
0:01:16 So thank you Tammy for that tour.
0:01:19 So we'll start with our regular agenda now and I would confirm we do have a quorum of
0:01:23 the council here.
0:01:24 Six of the seven members are here this evening.
0:01:26 Vice Mayor Boyd is absent this evening.
0:01:30 the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. For those of you wishing to join us, please rise.
0:01:57 Mr. Rothwell, do we have any amendments to our agenda this evening?
0:02:00 Mr. Mayor, it's the Council. There are no amendments.
0:02:03 Okay, we have no proclamations. So next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input.
0:02:09 If there's anybody wishing to address the council now is your opportunity to please come forward.
0:02:14 I do have is it is it Darwin Crossland? All right. Do you see it that you're signed up here?
0:02:20 So if you would please state your name and whether you're a property owner in the city of Twin Falls.
0:02:27 If you could please keep your comments in size. We would appreciate it.
0:02:36 you push the button on that, or it says push.
0:02:40 I'm in Crossland, and I'm the clinical director of ambitions of Idaho Twin Falls.
0:02:45 They're on 378 Falls Avenue, and I just wanted to let this know about our services for mental health and substance abuse.
0:02:56 We have a huge problem in Idaho.
0:02:58 Oh, by the way, I am a renter, but a resident, very shortly.
0:03:09 So we have a huge problem in Idaho of opiate abuse among elderly seniors.
0:03:14 We've actually, for the first time in history, had more seniors that have addiction to opioids
0:03:21 than we do have other class of people over 50, each problem we'd love to take care of
0:03:29 that problem and start to begin to look at that and issue, direct forward manner.
0:03:35 Thank you for your time.
0:03:36 Thank you for making us aware of your program.
0:03:41 Is there anyone else who wishes to address the council this evening?
0:03:47 Seeing no one, we will move on to the consent calendar.
0:03:51 Council wishes Greg Lant, a mayor of the week, approves a consent calendar as printed.
0:03:58 Ruth Pierce?
0:03:59 Second.
0:04:00 Motion by Greg Lanting, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the consent calendar as printed.
0:04:06 Is there any discussion?
0:04:09 Being none, Chair and roll call vote please.
0:04:15 Suzanne Hopkins. Yes.
0:04:17 Don Berger. Yes.
0:04:20 Chris Hopkins. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes.
0:04:24 Christopher Reed. Yes. Ruth Piers. Yes.
0:04:28 Motion passes 6-0. Next to her items of consideration.
0:04:32 The first is a presentation of an award to Tina Kelly with her
0:04:36 post-advanced communications specialist certificate.
0:04:40 We have Tammy Lotta, Communications Center Manager. Welcome Tammy.
0:04:46 Thank you for coming to the center tonight too.
0:04:52 Tonight I'm here to acknowledge Tina Kelly for getting her advanced certificate from post.
0:04:57 To receive that certificate, a telecommunications specialist has to have completed a post basic dispatch academy,
0:05:04 received a post level 3 certification, served as a dispatcher for 10 years or more,
0:05:09 and completed at least 500 hours of post certified training.
0:05:15 Tina was hired by the City of Twin Falls on 9-11, of 06.
0:05:20 She's also a communications training officer for our center,
0:05:23 which is the very important job of training our next first of the first responders.
0:05:30 Tina's been married to Casey Kelly for 24 years.
0:05:34 Casey is the Shoshone Idaho Fire Chief.
0:05:37 She and Casey were also EMS first responders for Hagerman, Idaho, for eight years.
0:05:42 Two children, Hayley and Devon, Hayley's working to go into the military and Devon is stationed
0:05:47 at Fort Campbell, Kentucky. During her time away from work, Tina also works with the American
0:05:54 Lung Association teaching teens against tobacco use in schools around the valley. She's taken
0:05:59 part in many fundraising programs, Relay for Life, Dairy Days Scholarship Program, the
0:06:05 Policeman's Ball, Food Drives for Lincoln County, Joan Easter Egg Hunt, or just a few.
0:06:10 She and her family are excellent examples of those who support their community and our country.
0:06:16 I'd like to present Tina with her post-advanced certificate and thank her for her hard work and dedication to the public safety employees and the citizens of Twin Falls.
0:06:25 I can also have Casey come up because as the Chief says often, it definitely takes a family to support shift work.
0:07:10 There's a new communication center made with your approval.
0:07:13 Next on the agenda is an update on odor complaints and issues on the northeast side of Twin Falls.
0:07:26 We have Jason Brown, environmental engineer. Welcome, Jason.
0:07:34 Mayor, council members, thanks for this opportunity. If you remember, on January 8th, we had
0:07:43 some complaints come in front of the council. And in that same meeting, I was asked to come back
0:07:49 I can give an update where we're roughly a month away from that meeting and to date I haven't received any
0:07:55 owner complaints that are associated with that facility to my knowledge. Most people know how to get
0:08:03 in touch with me now so I have a good feeling that we're moving in the right direction. And so I've had
0:08:10 an opportunity to sit down with Giovanni and talk with him on what has been done over the last month
0:08:16 to help resolve and continue to move forward on this, excuse me, and so one of the processes
0:08:26 was that they had done was call out the manufacturing of the manufacture of that piece of equipment,
0:08:32 have them do a service on that equipment, and then also take some samples of the media inside of that
0:08:39 piece of equipment that I'm referring to as the odor control unit that helps mitigate
0:08:46 from the treatment process that they have locally, and so, and a couple of other things that were
0:08:54 discovered before the vendor came out was the water system that is needed to spray water on the
0:09:02 media, water is required to help the media or the biological organisms grow inside of that media,
0:09:09 which the organisms help reduce the odor levels out of that. And so there was a
0:09:15 amount of function of the water system it was repaired and then as the vendor
0:09:21 came out he took some core samples of the media and in one of his observations
0:09:26 noted that there would the media hit the head was wet again more testing is being
0:09:32 done back in New York on that media that's where the vendors lab is and so
0:09:37 there's there's some more information to hopefully come out of that to show
0:09:41 viability of the organisms inside of that and so the other part to this was
0:09:49 also Jibani is investigating putting in a redundant water system and that helps
0:09:54 knock down some gases before it even gets into the biological filters of
0:10:00 cells and then also through some through some investigation they noticed
0:10:04 some some pipes in the supply side the air supply side of the system has some
0:10:10 and so they're in the process of getting those repaired permanently with some better, more suitable material for the environment that they're working under.
0:10:21 And so if all continues to go according to plan, we should be able to hopefully resolve this situation here shortly when it's all said and done.
0:10:35 And again, at the last council meeting,
0:10:38 odors can come and go.
0:10:39 They change properties, change things,
0:10:41 change what we'll continue proactive with this scenario.
0:10:45 And I've sat down and talked with Giovanni
0:10:47 and had conversations with them about this.
0:10:52 That is my update.
0:10:54 Any questions that I can answer?
0:10:56 Or any questions for Jason?
0:11:00 Who's in Hawkins?
0:11:01 Not a question, just a thank you for staying on top of it.
0:11:04 It means a lot to us, and I know the citizens appreciate it too.
0:11:07 Thank you.
0:11:08 Thank you.
0:11:10 Chris talking to would you, Jason, make an effort to contact the gentleman who was here
0:11:16 to let him know that progress?
0:11:18 Yes, I think it'd be helpful.
0:11:20 Thank you.
0:11:21 I will do it.
0:11:22 Good job.
0:11:23 Thank you.
0:11:24 Thank you, Jason.
0:11:28 Next on the agenda is a request to reallocate funds to cover expenses related to Twin Falls
0:11:34 We have Wendy Davis, our Parks and Recreation Director.
0:11:39 Hello, everyone, Council.
0:11:47 As you're probably aware, there's been some request put forward to make some adjustments
0:11:54 to the bathroom.
0:11:55 I was actually the men's locker room to just do an upgrade.
0:11:59 And in the process of trying to get a bid on that, it became apparent that we needed to make some adjustments
0:12:07 adjustments to that facility to make it ADA-compliant, and then it just kind of went from there.
0:12:14 It turns out that there's a little bit more that we need to do than just make a larger
0:12:19 stall.
0:12:20 So we need to do it on both sides, men's and women's, and then there's some counter height
0:12:24 adjustments and things that need to be done.
0:12:26 And so what I'd like to do this evening is get permission to reallocate the funds that
0:12:32 we had budgeted for the sprinkler system,
0:12:39 computer controller, and used some of those funds,
0:12:44 along with the $100,000 that I have for master plan improvements
0:12:51 to cover the expenses for the architect
0:12:56 and as much of the construction as we can do.
0:13:03 So, I'm happy to answer any questions. I think I put it on the report. I don't know how far you want me to go, so I'll just stop there.
0:13:11 Great landing.
0:13:13 Well, Castle, maybe time to apologize myself here on this.
0:13:20 I thought it is some of the other everyday players at the golf course.
0:13:27 The ladies' room had a little bit of an update in the past. The men's room is like the 25-year part,
0:13:35 and it was looking pretty tired and needed some updates and so we thought we were going
0:13:41 to tweet myself and New India and some others we may become up in like 10 grand to do these
0:13:47 updates and then ADA jumped in and it's a little like the pool, very similar to the pool issue
0:13:56 where we found we were in non-compliance with newer ADA rules and something that's gotten
0:14:03 much more expensive to complete, because you have to bring the whole building up to 88,
0:14:08 not just the restrooms. And it's one of those things where now we know about it, as Travis
0:14:15 says, we know about it, now we gotta fix it. We didn't know about it before, so we didn't
0:14:19 have to fix it, but now we do. And so that's where we're at on this, and I would hope to
0:14:26 have your support in helping Windu to reallocate some of these funds to get this taken care
0:14:34 of and it's not just the restrooms, there's some other things around the building that
0:14:38 need to be taken care of to make them ADA accessible, like she's been mentioned, countertops,
0:14:46 and some crashed corridors and a few things along the outline, maybe even the ramp.
0:14:52 We got an architect today and walked through and he kind of gave me an estimate of what
0:14:59 would take as far as the cost for him to do a plan for me and there's a couple
0:15:07 things we may be able to work around with some of those counters and things
0:15:10 but walk through it again and he's an ADA guy he knows a lot of the rules and
0:15:15 and we talked about a few of those specifics out there. The parking lot
0:15:19 could be a really simple fix or a really big problem kind of depending how much
0:15:25 we have to go with that. So...
0:15:28 Hey, thank you for your help on this Monday.
0:15:31 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:15:32 Perfect lead in. I was just going to ask if you have a rough idea
0:15:35 of what the architectural costs are going to be.
0:15:38 So I tried to pin him down, and I told him I would not hold him to it,
0:15:43 but he thinks about 10 would give me a site plan for the shop location,
0:15:51 which is the part that I thought I would have some savings on.
0:15:55 So he thinks about seven for that and about three to do the building.
0:15:59 The parking lot, he didn't really want to throw a number at that yet
0:16:03 because he doesn't really know what that's going to take.
0:16:07 But it sounds like we're probably under 20 for sure.
0:16:11 And then how are we going to come back around to readdress the sprinkler system
0:16:15 if we take the money from that now? So what I'd like to do
0:16:19 is do some more research and come up with that bigger plan.
0:16:25 I think the problem with the sprinkler system
0:16:27 is that computer upgrade is just a partial fix
0:16:31 to the whole problem.
0:16:32 And while it addresses some of Kathy's concerns
0:16:36 with an older computer, it's a Windows XP operating system,
0:16:40 and she has concerns about supporting that.
0:16:43 But if we take the time and do the whole upgrade
0:16:49 that would include the upgrade to the satellites,
0:16:51 which are the controllers that the computer talks to
0:16:53 that run the sprinklers.
0:16:56 I thought they were up in the sky too, but.
0:16:59 So the computer talks to the satellites
0:17:00 that run the sprinkler system,
0:17:03 and we need to work on that as well.
0:17:05 So it's probably a little bit bigger project
0:17:07 that we could phase in,
0:17:09 but I want to get a better number for that.
0:17:12 And I'm looking at a couple years down the road.
0:17:14 I have it on the long-term plan.
0:17:16 So that's going to come back around.
0:17:17 Kathy won't let me forget.
0:17:19 Okay, thank you.
0:17:21 Chris Stockington.
0:17:22 Wendy, I really appreciate your diligence
0:17:24 working with the architect on this,
0:17:25 but it scares me when I say $100,000 potential budget.
0:17:29 You will come back to us before any expenditures
0:17:32 with a line item laid out of all the respective costs, right?
0:17:36 Correct.
0:17:37 So the architect will put together the plan
0:17:40 and attach a construction estimate to it.
0:17:43 And then we can take it out to bid.
0:17:44 And I don't think if we're going to come anywhere close to 100,000, unless we have to do that parking lot and I don't know what that'll take.
0:17:54 Well, there's only one crazy go-up on those city council and he probably would go for twice that 100,000, but I'm not that tight.
0:18:03 Christopher Reed, there aren't any more comments. I'll make a motion.
0:18:09 Not see any more discussion.
0:18:11 All right, I would move that we would approve the reallocation of funds to cover expenses related to the Twin Falls called
0:18:18 Club 88 compliance
0:18:25 Motion by Chris Reed and seconded by Greg Lanting to approve the request to reallocate funds
0:18:32 There any further discussion?
0:18:37 Please
0:18:39 Burger yes, Chris Hockington. Yes, Greg Lanting. Yes, Christopher Reed. Yes, Ruth Piers
0:18:46 motion passes six to zero thank you my little say but nobody says voting so next
0:19:21 on the agenda is a request to waive the non-conforming building expansion permit
0:19:25 process for a residential home located at 451 fifth Avenue north we have Jonathan
0:19:30 spend love senior planner in our planning department welcome Jonathan thank you
0:19:34 my very good members of the council, if I could get a chair under a
0:19:37 Matthew to switch to the, as with most of my presentations, I have a lot of visual maps and things like that I'm going to show you.
0:19:49 This one's a pretty simple one up here, I got a request on January 17th from Mr. Morris to do a non-conforming building expansion.
0:19:59 His house there outlined in blue is within a five-yard, the five-foot side yard setback, which is the dotted line,
0:20:07 which makes the house a nonconforming building.
0:20:11 He wants to do an addition here in Orange.
0:20:13 It's on the back of the house.
0:20:14 It's not within the five, but a side yard is set back.
0:20:18 And typically, these council's wave
0:20:21 that requirement for that nonconforming building expansion,
0:20:24 the normal process is a public hearing
0:20:26 with the Planning and Soning Commission.
0:20:27 It takes about six weeks.
0:20:29 It's a simple motion-minute entry
0:20:31 and by the council to wave that,
0:20:33 if so, if so, if so, if you so,
0:20:35 that concludes that report.
0:20:39 Thank you, Jonathan, and solutions.
0:20:45 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:20:47 It looks pretty straightforward to me,
0:20:48 so I would like to make a motion
0:20:50 that we approve the request to waive
0:20:54 the nonconforming building expansion permit.
0:20:57 Second, motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Christopher
0:21:01 Reed to approve the waiver of nonconforming building
0:21:05 expansion permit process.
0:21:07 Is there any discussion?
0:21:11 General call vote please.
0:21:13 Sean Berricker.
0:21:14 Yes.
0:21:15 Chris Talkington.
0:21:16 Yes.
0:21:17 Greg Lanting.
0:21:18 Yes.
0:21:19 Christopher Reed.
0:21:20 Yes.
0:21:20 Ruth Pierce.
0:21:21 Yes.
0:21:22 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:21:23 Yes.
0:21:24 So she passes 6 to 0.
0:21:29 And again, our little save buttons are working on the screen.
0:21:33 I did this time.
0:21:34 Chris has did, but he's the only one who gets to vote.
0:21:37 Next on the agenda is a request to adopt an ordinance for annexation with a zoning district
0:21:53 change and zoning map amendment from SUI to R2, R6 and C1, ZDA to develop a multi-use plan
0:22:01 development for approximately 28.84 plus or minus acres located on the north side of the
0:22:07 1800 and 1900 blocks of Pole Line Road east.
0:22:11 I need to once again have channel from spring love
0:22:14 Yes, since I was doing the first one and the next two grenades said I should bring this one forward
0:22:19 We have an ordinance for adoption as described that we are here for the property shown up on the screen
0:22:26 This actually came before the council
0:22:28 More than a year ago. I think the report is 2017. We did realize it was actually 2016 so it was
0:22:36 August 9th 2016 and September 12th
0:22:39 2017, respective public hearings for the P&Z and then the council. There were some additional
0:22:45 conditions, there were four, one of them for side fund amendments. The next one was for
0:22:52 a Poland road widening and possible drop lanes. The next one was the length of the public roadway
0:22:59 was to be determined by the city engineer. This is the public roadway that will be coming
0:23:06 up. The determination of it was to be determined by the city engineer. Whether it was at
0:23:10 the intersection or 20 feet past the intersection was something they were going to come up with
0:23:14 or decide at the time of the plan. And the one that was put in by the council was the
0:23:22 building height. The council voted to follow the process outlined in City Code 1073 which
0:23:29 is what we have in C1 zone. They wanted to do additional height, come through for that
0:23:34 two public hearings. So that was something that was added by the council. The other
0:23:38 three were added by the P&Z and confirmed by the council. There was a vote of seven to zero and
0:23:46 as a result and directed by the council we have an ordinance within the packet to adopt that ordinance
0:23:53 who'd have to go for a third and final reading and upon adoption the ordinance may be published
0:23:59 and then the property can proceed with development, planning, etc. concludes the report. Thank you
0:24:05 Okay, Jonathan, I'm so wish is, oh, uh, Sharon, what's the ordinance ordinance number 2018
0:24:14 dash three?
0:24:15 Great.
0:24:18 Also the one that the, the, was there was some consideration of it and things like that.
0:24:29 What, what did they end up being able to do with the sewer?
0:24:32 What they've done, um, and as requested, they've done a, you know, it was like a regional, uh,
0:24:38 station that will serve real VISTA, will serve this
0:24:43 pitfalls plaza I think is what is called, will serve all of
0:24:46 those properties and maybe additional few to the east.
0:24:49 It's going to be a regional lift station that they share,
0:24:52 develop, and then since they're private entities, they
0:24:55 can't actually run it.
0:24:57 We're left, so I'm going to just go on a limb, but private
0:25:00 entities can't run sewer lift stations.
0:25:01 DQ, you want to prove them, it has to be a public agency,
0:25:04 so then we would have to take that lift station.
0:25:06 All right, thank you.
0:25:11 Yeah, there are questions for Jonathan, Chris talking to him.
0:25:17 Jonathan, I'm curious why that is a dedicated public street instead of being internal and
0:25:25 just private.
0:25:26 This rationale on that place.
0:25:29 On this one, it's a continuation of the amount of you were a different road name.
0:25:33 I believe this is an engineer felt like he was servicing so many people up to this point
0:25:39 that it needed to be a public road, public service after that point.
0:25:43 some of these places will be gated, it'll be an allow for people to get them.
0:25:48 That's kind of how they propose it, and I believe that's what was Jackie's concern.
0:25:51 But it does line up on Mountain View?
0:25:54 I don't know if it lines up on Mountain View, it's kind of a...
0:25:57 If you might not...
0:25:58 If I lines up on Madron, I might be Madron, I'm trying to remember which name it was.
0:26:02 I think it's McCrowna close to it.
0:26:05 It also continues, the plan is to continue it over and connect it into Pillar Falls.
0:26:10 Oz it this way, connect it to their road network.
0:26:20 Council wishes on Ordinance 2018-3, Suzanne Hawkins.
0:26:29 I move that we put Ordinance 2018-3 on third and final
0:26:36 by suspension of the rules.
0:26:38 I get it all.
0:26:39 I title only.
0:26:40 I title only, thank you.
0:26:42 Great landing.
0:26:43 That's what I was going to do all seconding.
0:26:45 Motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by
0:26:48 Reglanting to place Ordinance 2018-3 on 3rd and final reading by a title only under suspension of the rules. Is there any discussion?
0:26:56 Seeing none, Sharon will call vote please.
0:27:02 Chris Tockington?
0:27:08 Yes.
0:27:09 Reglanting?
0:27:10 Yes.
0:27:11 Christopher Reed?
0:27:12 Yes.
0:27:13 Ruth Pierce?
0:27:14 Yes.
0:27:15 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:27:16 Yes.
0:27:17 Don Baraker?
0:27:18 Yes.
0:27:20 Motion passes 6-0.
0:27:21 Sharon, would you read the title please?
0:27:27 Ordinance number 2018-3, an ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho,
0:27:35 annexing certain real property below described, providing the zoning classification, therefore,
0:27:42 and ordering the necessary area of impact in zoning district map amendment.
0:27:47 Thank you, Sharon.
0:27:48 Chris Toggington.
0:27:49 Good passage of ordinance 2018-3.
0:27:53 Motion by Chris Toggington, seconded by Greg Lanting to approve Ordinance 2018-3.
0:28:01 Is there any discussion?
0:28:02 Chair in the roll call vote please.
0:28:06 Ranting, Christopher Reed.
0:28:15 Yes.
0:28:16 With Pairs.
0:28:17 Yes.
0:28:18 Suzanne Harkins.
0:28:19 Yes.
0:28:20 John Beriker.
0:28:21 Yes.
0:28:22 Chris Toggington.
0:28:24 Yes.
0:28:25 Motion passes 6-0.
0:28:26 Thank you, Jonathan.
0:28:28 Next is an opportunity for our general public input.
0:28:31 There's, again, anyone who wishes to address the Council,
0:28:34 now it's your opportunity to come forward.
0:28:38 Seeing no one, do we have any advisory board reports
0:28:41 from members of the Council?
0:28:43 In none, Travis, city announcements
0:28:48 from the city manager's office.
0:28:50 No sir, but staff would suggest that because of the time
0:28:55 and the balance of time before we can go
0:28:57 into the public hearing staff believes
0:28:59 that we can complete the executive session
0:29:01 should the city council choose to move into
0:29:03 between now and that six o'clock posting.
0:29:07 Sounds good.
0:29:08 So yes, we do have two public hearings scheduled
0:29:11 to begin now earlier than 6 p.m.
0:29:14 So we do have an item on the agenda for adjournment.
0:29:17 Sorry, Greg, did you have something else you wanted to add?
0:29:19 Well, just real quickly, I received a notice
0:29:22 from my associate's of cities that there's a bill
0:29:25 that they have concerns with concerning the going
0:29:28 to rev it tax concerning the foregone amount
0:29:31 I want to take a look at that as you individually and then contact your legislators if you feel
0:29:38 it's necessary.
0:29:39 Thank you.
0:29:40 So we do have on the agenda an adjournment to Executive Session under Idaho Code 742061A
0:29:50 to consider hiring a public officer, employees, staff member or individual agent wherein the
0:29:55 respective qualities of individuals are to be evaluated to fill a particular vacancy or
0:29:59 or need, unless a vacancy in an elective office is being filled.
0:30:04 I would entertain a motion to Greg Lanting.
0:30:10 I would move that we move to the executive session under the items listed by the mayor.
0:30:16 The motion by Greg Lanting second by Ruth Pierce to adjourn into executive session as
0:30:22 stated as there in a discussion.
0:30:24 Turn roll call vote please.
0:30:27 Yes.
0:30:32 Because if a read with his, yes, is Ann Hawkins?
0:30:38 Yes.
0:30:39 Ann Baker?
0:30:40 Yes.
0:30:41 Yes.
0:30:42 Question passes six to zero.
0:30:43 So we will adjourn into an executive session when we not be making any decisions while in
0:30:49 the executive session.
0:30:51 We will return to continue the council meeting no earlier than 6 p.m. for the public hearing.
0:30:59 So with that, we will stand for adjourned.
0:57:54 We will reconvene the City Council meeting for Monday, February 5th with our two items
1:00:02 that we have for public hearings this evening.
1:00:05 The first is a request for a zoning district change and zoning map amendment for 1 plus
1:00:10 or minus acres from C1 to M2 for property located at 1211 Addison Avenue East within the area
1:00:17 of impact.
1:00:18 Addison and West are within the area of impact and we have John Lucas as the applicant.
1:00:25 Mr. Lucas, yes, come on forward, give us your presentation and then we'll have a staff report
1:00:34 and then we'll open it up for the public hearing.
1:00:36 All right, thank you.
1:00:37 Thank you.
1:00:40 Thank you, Mayor and members.
1:00:44 My name is John Lucas.
1:00:45 I own and operate John's UPU you save, President of Twin Falls.
1:00:52 I'm here this evening to request a changing of the front part of my business of the property
1:00:59 from C1 to M2.
1:01:04 This will make the entire property sown to M2 as it was back in the 90s, late 80s, early 90s
1:01:12 before the impact came in there.
1:01:16 I want to conduct a small use car lot on the concrete slab that's out in front of my existing parking lot in property.
1:01:29 Currently on the 1 plus anchors where I'm requesting the change is the building that I operate as an office for my U-Pul wrecking yard on that property.
1:01:45 I still need to finish the landscaping required in the areas for that zoning and then the impact to the area, pretty much around that area, to the west is a used car dealership that's there in a tow yard.
1:02:06 The east is a storage unit, and a cross which is north is Addison Collision and a couple
1:02:16 other commercial properties there, so I don't think there's any impact to the area.
1:02:25 Thank you for the time and I can answer any questions if you have any.
1:02:31 Thank you.
1:02:32 I don't see any questions right at the moment, so we'll have our staff report from Jonathan
1:02:36 And then if there are other questions, we'll go back to Jonathan Spethlove.
1:02:43 Thank you, Mayor Berger and members of the council.
1:02:46 The history of the property, at least since the 1960s.
1:02:50 We got some Herald imagery that this was a salvage yard.
1:02:53 Used vehicle sales yard, something of that sort.
1:02:57 It was likely rezoned in 1981 with the adoption of wardens 2012,
1:03:03 which gives us our zoning classifications that we have today.
1:03:06 back then we just went down Addison, we kind of said on the south side of Addison
1:03:12 we're going to zone everything within X number of feet to the C1 and the rest of
1:03:18 it was going to be manufacturing. So Addison's changed and that center line's
1:03:22 kind of shifted a little bit, so as far as the distance we're not 100% sure on, so
1:03:26 we basically are saying we're just going to reaffirm the zoning on the
1:03:28 entire property as M2 that kind of solves the problem with not knowing the exact
1:03:33 location of the C1 boundary. As far as the comprehensive plan, this corridor is
1:03:41 appropriate for industrial, flex or employment. That's on the future land use
1:03:46 map. That's this map right here. That's all blue. It's what the industrial or flex
1:03:52 section talks about. So any change that we do for rezoning is to comply with that
1:03:58 comprehensive plan. That plan shows that an industrial so M2 does fit for the
1:04:02 comprehensive plan. The applicant states his wishes for dealership, auto dealerships are permitted in this zone, but it has a change of use
1:04:11 who will need to comply with some landscaping for any business that's not what he's currently doing. Changes that land use he has to do so
1:04:19 in improvements. It's kind of a separate issue that we take care of in the building permit stage or at code enforcement stage. The
1:04:25 rezoned really just whether it complies with the comprehensive plan.
1:04:29 To make a positive recommendation,
1:04:30 the Planning and Zoning Commission determined that the request
1:04:33 is in conformance with the con plan,
1:04:35 and the extent and nature of changing the zoning of this property,
1:04:38 a loud development that would be compatible with not detract from the surrounding area.
1:04:42 On January 9th, the Planning and Zoning Commission voted 6-1 to
1:04:46 forward a positive recommendation of the zoning change as requested by the applicant.
1:04:50 Council's asked to make a recommendation to the County Commissioner says this is
1:04:54 in a area of impact, make a decision, we can change the code,
1:04:58 and then we can afford it to them for the ordinance
1:05:01 to be ratified by them as it's their final decision
1:05:03 in the area of impact.
1:05:05 So the council can deny the request, approve the request
1:05:09 as presented, or request additional information
1:05:11 to be provided.
1:05:13 That concludes the report.
1:05:15 Thank you, Jonathan.
1:05:16 Chris Dockington.
1:05:18 A little bit, I'm sure we're kind of Jonathan,
1:05:20 the current use of the northern six acres
1:05:23 of salvage art. I'm not sure if the applicant has continued to use that and I guess the bigger
1:05:28 question is that allowed under an m-line. So the m2 zone if he does the salvage beyond the current
1:05:34 boundary he would be on new property. He would have to come back through four special use permit.
1:05:41 Right now I'm kind of strolling where the mouse is. The line kind of starts here, goes across the
1:05:45 front of this building, it comes down. Anything south of that has been historically used as a salvage
1:05:51 We can we've determined that aerial, aerial imagery. If he uses the front area for salvage, you would need to come through for a special use permit.
1:05:59 The M2 zone requires a special use permit for salvage. If he chooses to do something that's permitted in the M2 zone, there would be no public hearing. He could just do it being the requirements of the code.
1:06:12 any other questions for Jonathan don't see him. Is Ann Hawkins?
1:06:24 Thanks. So help refresh my memory again. In the C1, so what he's wanting to, I understand, is with cars and stuff, which is permitted in the C1, but with a special use permit, and by changing to M2, then he can bypass that. Is that the goal here or?
1:06:45 So the selling of vehicles in the C1 zone does require a special use permit.
1:06:51 The selling of vehicles in the M2 zone does not require a special use permit, so you're
1:06:55 correct in that.
1:06:56 So if it's not re-zoned, he could still use the property for that, but he would have to
1:07:00 go through a different process to get there.
1:07:02 Right.
1:07:03 In a way.
1:07:04 There's also some other requirements in the C1 zone that you would have to do to accomplish
1:07:11 that.
1:07:12 to those requirements are lessened. The landscaping doesn't go away. One of
1:07:19 note is the requirement to pave certain areas. There's also some setback
1:07:25 differences. I think the high requirements are the same. Like breaking
1:07:29 them down to be a bit difficult up here when I say I'm fine, but there's some
1:07:34 development requirements that are lessened than him too because of its nature as
1:07:37 being industrial. Thank you. Any other questions for Jonathan? All right,
1:07:49 With that, we will open the public hearing to take public testimony on this request.
1:07:55 There's no one who wishes to speak on this issue.
1:07:58 Now is your opportunity to please come forward.
1:08:03 Seeing no one, we will close the public input portion of the public hearing.
1:08:07 And we will turn it over to you if you have any rebuttal to the vast number
1:08:13 of public comments we received there.
1:08:14 If you had to clarify anything, Mr. Lucas.
1:08:20 Just for.
1:08:23 You can see on the picture where their concrete is, they're on the northern west side of it.
1:08:36 That's where I want to place the cars, it's all concreteed.
1:08:40 The entrance is to the property, and there is some pavement that is in the parking lot,
1:08:49 but it's so deteriorated.
1:08:53 And at this time, eventually, I would like to pave it, but I just started like three
1:08:59 years ago, so it's financially, that's why I'm going this direction.
1:09:04 But eventually, absolutely, I'd like to pave it, but I'd like to get a little further
1:09:09 ahead with...
1:09:10 All right.
1:09:17 Thank you, sir.
1:09:20 So, council wishes.
1:09:22 Chris, talking to me.
1:09:23 I would move to approve the zoning district change and zoning map amendment for plus or
1:09:28 for minus one acre from C1 to M2 for the property located at 12 at Addison Avenue West than
1:09:35 the area of impact.
1:09:37 Second.
1:09:38 Motion by Chris Stockington seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the request as presented
1:09:47 and forward that to the county commissioners that need to be part of that motion.
1:09:52 There any further discussion on that?
1:09:56 Hearing roll call vote please.
1:10:00 Christopher Reed. Yes
1:10:02 Ruth Piers. Yes
1:10:04 Zann Hawkins. Yes
1:10:06 Don Berger. Yes
1:10:08 Chris Hockington. Yes
1:10:09 Greg Lanting. Yes
1:10:11 Motion passes 6-0. Thank you Mr. Lucas.
1:10:17 Next on the agenda is the request for a zoning district change and zoning map
1:10:21 amendment from C1 PUD to C1 ZDA for the Magic Valley Mall
1:10:27 approximately 58 plus or minus acres on property
1:10:30 Looking at a 1485 Pull Line Road East,
1:10:34 Brent White on behalf of the Magic Valley Mall.
1:10:36 Welcome, Mr. White.
1:10:38 Thank you.
1:10:43 I remember as a council, I'm excited to be here tonight.
1:10:47 Really am.
1:10:49 I think we're starting a new chapter.
1:10:50 It's our entire company's excited about it.
1:10:55 I've had the opportunity to be with the P&Z
1:10:57 for two public hearings.
1:10:58 And I've asked myself to what length I want to trouble you
1:11:03 with all details, because we received unanimous support
1:11:07 from the P&Z, and I've had no public opposition whatsoever
1:11:12 to what we're suggesting to do.
1:11:14 But I felt like you could jump right to the final details
1:11:20 and ask for a vote.
1:11:21 And I just don't think that's the right thing,
1:11:23 given who you are in a 58-acre project
1:11:26 at the gateway of our community.
1:11:28 And so I want to take a few minutes
1:11:30 and share with you coming up the course.
1:11:34 OK, I want to share with you some information
1:11:37 that I think really is important for the community
1:11:41 and the council to understand relative
1:11:43 to where we see things going forward with this property,
1:11:48 where I jump into some of those details
1:11:50 and bring them up on the screen in a minute.
1:11:54 I want to share with you a little bit
1:11:55 about the Woodbury Corporation,
1:11:57 and I'm pleased to have with me tonight
1:11:59 from Woodbury Corporation Heather Barrett,
1:12:01 his assistant general manager and Trevor White,
1:12:04 his assistant regional manager.
1:12:05 Woodbury Corporation is going to celebrate its 100th anniversary this year.
1:12:12 And I think this is an important thing.
1:12:16 This is a company that's seen a lot of change.
1:12:19 We're seeing a lot of change now, but it's a company that's used to seeing a lot of change.
1:12:23 Adaptation and survival and success is the lineage of the company.
1:12:29 So, a couple other things about it backwards.
1:12:34 Thank you, Jonathan. We properties that we own in Twin Falls, the team that we work with
1:12:44 has brought over a hundred stores to Twin Falls over the years. We employ about 1,000
1:12:50 and 1,500 people in those stores at any point in time. And as a tax generator, sales probably
1:12:59 in excess of $150 million generating sales tax, property tax, I could be wrong, but
1:13:05 But I think we're probably combined probably the greatest property taxpayer in the Magic
1:13:10 Valley.
1:13:11 And so it's significant, I think, to the community and significant for our company what
1:13:16 we're suggesting that we'd like to do tonight.
1:13:19 I'm going to step in now and talk to you specifically about the request for a ZDA or a zoning change
1:13:27 in a ZDA, and I think you'll see on the screen as I go from page to page when I talk to you
1:13:34 about the wise to begin with.
1:13:38 First of all, when I began visiting with the staff
1:13:40 about this several months ago,
1:13:43 I was immediately met with a lot of enthusiasm
1:13:45 from the staff for us to change our agreement.
1:13:47 This is our current agreement written in 1984,
1:13:52 for subsequently, I mean, I think six amendments,
1:13:55 and each time the poor staff gets a set of permits in,
1:13:58 or plans in for permit,
1:14:00 they've got to go through all of this stuff
1:14:02 try to make heads and tails and see what applies here and what it's just very very
1:14:06 difficult. And so staff was excited to see us make a change and very very helpful.
1:14:12 I want to emphasize that we haven't put anything in our request that they didn't
1:14:16 support. There was anything we thought well we'd maybe like that which was a
1:14:19 height modification outside of the boundaries of the C1, the code and they
1:14:24 said we'd prefer you didn't put that in so we took it out. So everything that's in
1:14:29 We've done, I think, with the support and blessing of the staff that these are good things to do.
1:14:36 So from that standpoint, that's a motivation to us.
1:14:40 Secondly, our second is, old point number two up here, is that we want to be able to change and adapt as a market requires.
1:14:49 Our company owns the University of Baltimore.
1:14:51 You tell some of you have been there, mixed use development that has been adapted over the years very, very successfully.
1:14:56 We've added recently office buildings and residences to that property.
1:15:01 If you've been to the village in Meridian, it takes on the same kind of character.
1:15:05 And this is a future and it's a successful future.
1:15:08 And so we want to create an area where people in our community
1:15:12 and not only shop and dine, but also work, play and live, should they choose to do that.
1:15:19 That's the road map going forward for us and what we're seeking to do.
1:15:24 Interestingly, in this item number three, I commend you and the P&Z in 2014 you adapted
1:15:32 a new code, included the ZDA, and it really created the entitlement framework for exactly
1:15:39 what we want to do.
1:15:41 So I'm going to switch to the next page if I can do this successfully.
1:15:46 And so I've provided here just a little bit of the code about what is the ZDA and why
1:15:50 should we have it, what developers are encouraged to do with the ZDA, why does the city want
1:15:55 to see some ZDA's, and it's interesting, as I read this the first time, I'm just highlighted
1:16:01 some of the language I think, a zoning development agreement is designed to accommodate appropriate
1:16:08 combinations of users. Are there down, provide flexibility and development standards, facilitate
1:16:14 creative land development concepts, foster and promote a variety of appropriate land use,
1:16:21 a creative approach, create flexibility in a variety, it's um, the code is exactly what
1:16:27 we need and uh, they said I think it's terrific that the council and that PNC had the foresight
1:16:34 to suggest the developers should do this. So we've tried to look directly to the, to that
1:16:39 code and say how can we do this and so I'm not going to the next page. Um, what we're
1:16:45 proposing is a mixed use development simply. Um, what you see before you is a depiction
1:16:51 of what it might be, and it would include retail, potentially office, residential, combinations
1:17:01 of those things.
1:17:03 One of the things that's important about this is exactly what it will be is subject to what
1:17:09 the market asks it to be, when the market asks it to be.
1:17:14 We do have residential property on our shopping centers at our locations, and we're very inclined
1:17:20 to do that, but we'll do it when the market says, and until then, we don't want to be
1:17:26 ahead of the market, we don't want to be behind the market, but we want to be with the market
1:17:30 in accordance with the interest of the market.
1:17:32 And so this is conceptual, but it's also controlled, and I'll come to that in a few more minutes
1:17:40 about what we'll control carefully so that we're within the vision of the Council and
1:17:45 the PNC and the code onto the next page.
1:17:54 But what might it look like?
1:17:57 These drawings depict what residential property
1:18:00 might look like.
1:18:02 It would not be your typical properties
1:18:04 that have yards.
1:18:05 Accents in is obvious for obvious reasons.
1:18:08 How many folks don't want those responsibilities?
1:18:11 They want to live in a facility that provides
1:18:13 a nice residence near those opportunities
1:18:17 to dine, to play, to work.
1:18:19 And so, residential would be a future component.
1:18:25 And then office and retail.
1:18:28 The office building you see in the upper left corner
1:18:30 is quite similar to an office building.
1:18:32 We did it, one of our major developments recently.
1:18:35 And it's been very successfully received.
1:18:38 That development, if you were to, we're there today,
1:18:41 and again, this is a university mall in Orem, Utah.
1:18:44 The mall itself looks like our mall.
1:18:48 The office building looks like someone
1:18:50 like this office building.
1:18:52 residents looks like what I just showed you and they collectively together take
1:18:55 on a character of older things newer things that both from a from a use
1:19:00 standpoint complement each other but from an architectural standpoint from a
1:19:03 space planning standpoint all of those things have to work together so that the
1:19:07 users of the office space residents in the residential all want to be a part
1:19:13 and that's how we will develop and so now I'd like to focus specifically on
1:19:23 the CDA that we have in mind in some of the specific language.
1:19:28 As I said before, we worked closely with the staff.
1:19:38 As I got involved in looking at this, I became very familiar with sections 10.4.8 of code
1:19:47 and 10.6.1.
1:19:48 I did count one day.
1:19:51 I think we had 16 pages, 19 sections, 60 provisions and hundreds of special details.
1:19:58 We've made an analysis of this and we said, let's work within the code, let's make sure we want to be compliant.
1:20:04 And if we want any exceptions, let's be sure what those are now and talk about this now.
1:20:08 And so my point being, I don't want to, or with all those details, I'd rather focus,
1:20:16 simply say, we intend to comply with every section of the code.
1:20:19 However, we would like exceptions to seven specific pieces of the code.
1:20:25 I'm going to go to those right now.
1:20:31 And again, the staff has been supportive of these particular items that you can see on your screen.
1:20:38 First of all, we'd like the opportunity and ability to build a parking structure if the need arises.
1:20:43 We don't have an intent right now, but we don't want to be under parked ever at any point in time.
1:20:49 So if there's a need, we would like that ability to do that within our ZDA.
1:20:54 Secondly, we'd like the ability to say to a potential tenant who may have need that you
1:21:01 can have a drive-through.
1:21:05 Of course, if they had a drive-through, it would have to meet all the requirements of
1:21:09 the code and it would have to go through the permitting process, but our request is that
1:21:12 it wouldn't have to go through a special use process.
1:21:15 A reasoning is that I don't know of any case where on any of our properties that we've made
1:21:20 there's a request that it has been denied, because in every case it's sensible, it's meeting
1:21:25 the terms of the code, and our sentiment was, why take your time and staff's time if ultimately
1:21:31 the conclusion is going to be, this is reasonable, let's do it. And the next item with regard
1:21:38 to alcohol on the premises, it was interesting in meeting with the P&Z. We presented these
1:21:46 items and some of the members kind of looked at it and said, son of a gun, these are unusual
1:21:51 things. And then they went back and discussed themselves, is this developer proposing to
1:21:56 do exactly what we ask them to do. Be creative, be responsive, be able to respond to the market
1:22:01 and its needs. I want to give you a specific example of why we're asking for this. Right
1:22:06 now we're concluding negotiations with a restaurant, one that's been very much in demand for decades.
1:22:13 We're finally very close. When they approached this about eight months ago, they said, will
1:22:19 we be able to have alcohol on the premises? And we said to them, we believe that's the
1:22:23 case. They said to us, we have 10 opens to buy, which in their language means. We have
1:22:30 10 restaurants we're budgeting this year. We would like to put one in Twin Falls, but unless
1:22:34 you can be really confident, we don't want to waste our time and our opportunities. They
1:22:39 put us in a position where we need to be responsive, else we lose that opportunity to other communities.
1:22:45 And so, we went out and women said, we think you're going to be able to do this because
1:22:48 in every case you, where we've gone through a special use permit in the past, those have
1:22:53 granted, but we'd like to be in a position where we don't have to go through that process.
1:22:57 We think it's reasonable the staff has supported us, and we think that we can do it responsibly.
1:23:03 When a member of the PNC said, what about residents that might not want to live near those uses?
1:23:11 And our feeling about was they won't. They will choose not to be on our property. Only those
1:23:17 who want to live where they can participate in those things will be on our property. We're
1:23:23 asking something of you here which is unusual but we think is sensible allows
1:23:28 us to be responsive as a sport of the staff. The next item and I've cited some
1:23:37 other information about that. I'm not going to take the time right now but
1:23:42 number two residential lot areas we would request that we can build them
1:23:46 without minimum size because again ours would be probably of the kind and type you
1:23:54 saw they're not going to be lots with yards. They're going to be buildings that have multiple
1:23:59 level within the high restrictions that are in the code. The next item is we've requested
1:24:07 that building setbacks which are proposed by us that they are 35 feet around our property,
1:24:16 which is what the code requires. We're asking for one exception and that is that location
1:24:21 on a property which some of you probably can envision.
1:24:25 Between the entrance at Sears on Pole Line and to the east,
1:24:30 it's sloped land.
1:24:34 Nice hole there.
1:24:36 I'm infamous for putting there.
1:24:38 And there is an area where to meet a 35-foot building set back.
1:24:46 It doesn't work for us.
1:24:47 The reason is very simple.
1:24:49 In order to meet the ADA and slope requirements on that land, we have to be able to build parking
1:24:56 lots at the right slope.
1:24:59 And in order to build those, if we come too far back behind our property line to begin
1:25:04 building them, you simply don't have enough property left to build adequate parking at
1:25:09 the proper angles or slopes to meet the ADA requirements.
1:25:13 So it's a particular section where you feel in order to develop successfully, we have to
1:25:19 have a modification to the setback.
1:25:20 So that would be 20 feet in that area.
1:25:23 Daphas looked at that and felt that that was appropriate
1:25:25 in that area.
1:25:28 The next item we're requesting is on our landscaping
1:25:32 that we'd be permitted rather than meeting a 30 foot minimum
1:25:37 of landscape that we meet a 30 foot average of landscape
1:25:41 around our entire property.
1:25:43 I want to emphasize that right now we have 47 feet
1:25:46 on pole line average, 61 on bridge view, and 62 on blue legs.
1:25:51 per staff analysis. There are cases, however, where it's almost impossible to do. There might be geographic features in the land. There might be structures such as water or canal company structures.
1:26:09 There may be traffic lights. There may be other signs where it's simply almost impossible to meet that app or that total setback of 30 feet.
1:26:20 But we are committing that we would meet an average of 30 feet everywhere that we built
1:26:25 on all the frontages.
1:26:28 We're requesting a slide modification of the parking code.
1:26:33 I'd like to explain this in the simplest terms that I can.
1:26:38 And that would be perhaps to encourage you to envision the harbor freight parking lot.
1:26:43 It's across the tree from the mall.
1:26:45 It's small.
1:26:46 It's a bit challenging.
1:26:47 and in that location, the requirement of that property owner is four stalls per
1:26:53 thousand square feet of space and that is being met in that location. We are
1:26:59 requesting an average of three and a half stalls. The reason we feel it's
1:27:04 appropriate is first for practical reasons. We've been to them all. On an
1:27:08 average day, we're probably using it most 60% of our parking with 7 to 800 empty
1:27:15 stalls on our busiest days and should be like, I have aerial photographs, we're not
1:27:21 even, we're only using about 90, 90, little over 90% of our parking was still
1:27:26 hundreds of available stalls on Black Friday. And so we think it's not
1:27:32 reasonable to have parking that's not producing value either for us or for the
1:27:37 community. So our request there is to modify the retail, have an exception of
1:27:44 retail codes that we're having three and a half stalls rather than four per
1:27:47 thousand. We do have 2,700 stalls that are shared and we think that will be made
1:27:53 all of the needs. There will be occasions where we build new parking. In fact, the
1:27:57 permit that will come before the building department very soon we will add
1:28:01 parking because in that situation we think it's necessary for that
1:28:05 particular restaurant user and we will do that anytime it is necessary but we
1:28:09 don't want to be bound to it when it's not. And the last two items, signage, we simply
1:28:19 want in the future to be required simply to meet the city's code. We're bound under
1:28:24 this agreement, by our own agreement, which is more respective than the city code. And
1:28:30 so we're subjecting ourselves entirely to the code with one exception. You may remember
1:28:35 as you enter the mall we have lag banners at the entranceways. Those are intended to
1:28:40 created a sense of the place they're non-specific to stores usually and we
1:28:45 would like to have continued to have the ability to have those otherwise we
1:28:48 want to be entirely subject to the code. The last item, there is a part of the
1:28:56 code that calls for a tenant to be to have to get a special use permit to
1:29:02 operate after 10 p.m. We would like to have an exception in that regard. I
1:29:07 I apologize, I wasn't aware of this until after the P&C meetings, and it's come to our attention that it is legally required that there's a special use permit.
1:29:18 Because we have dozens and dozens of stores over all the years who have operated outside of those hires without a special use permit,
1:29:26 we think it's reasonable, and our request would be that if our tenants can operate their customary standard hours without the requirement of a special use permit.
1:29:36 I've given you a lot of information. I hope it's been helpful. I should stand now for questions later on.
1:29:47 See if there are any questions.
1:29:51 I don't see any quite yet.
1:29:54 Brent, so we'll have Jonathan get the staff report and then we'll get back to you.
1:29:59 Chris, can I say P and Z by and large approved your request, but they're saying the subject to all future buildings
1:30:10 design with first-class architecture, materials and workmanship, what does first-class make,
1:30:17 in a sense, subjectly, what does that mean?
1:30:20 It's a term in our industry.
1:30:22 What it really means is we are bound by, within our leases and our agreements with our tenants,
1:30:28 that anything we will be comparable to what you would see across the nation and for those
1:30:34 tenants to want to be there.
1:30:36 So it means something to them, they understand that not only are we going to build it, but
1:30:41 if we build something that just doesn't fit in the environment there, they would have a
1:30:47 cause of action against us.
1:30:49 And so we are bound by this language.
1:30:52 It can be substituted with other kinds of language, but that's an industry term.
1:31:00 A helpful.
1:31:03 We would.
1:31:04 It'd be foolish.
1:31:06 And obviously over time, first class today is a different style than first class was 20
1:31:13 years ago.
1:31:14 But we will always be committed to building things that are appropriate for the times in
1:31:18 the place.
1:31:27 Hello Jonathan.
1:31:28 Members of the council.
1:31:30 I'm not sure I'm going to add more details in Brentland other than to go through and what
1:31:37 talks specifically about the exemptions he's talking about.
1:31:41 Maybe add a little bit, but not a whole lot.
1:31:44 The permitted uses, including the hours of operation, the hours of operation did not come
1:31:49 up during the public hearing with the planning and zoning commission.
1:31:52 Something that we just didn't discuss in our, in our aching with bread through the months,
1:31:57 but there are multiple stores that do stay open in multiple places that have special
1:32:04 experiments and some don't have them all along blue lakes.
1:32:06 That's just the reality that we live in.
1:32:09 There's not a, I don't have a good answer for why I didn't come up, but just didn't come
1:32:14 up.
1:32:15 So as far as the land uses drive-through
1:32:19 into recreation facilities, parking structure,
1:32:22 entertainment facilities, those are types of uses,
1:32:24 some of them are not in our current code,
1:32:26 some of them you just wanted to make sure that they could do
1:32:28 if they wanted to do them specifically the parking structure.
1:32:30 It's just not outlined, but since it's not,
1:32:33 we just identified it.
1:32:35 The one talking specifically about the yards and setbacks,
1:32:41 That area from Pull Line Road, Blue Lakes, and Blue Lakes Boulevard North, so I've got
1:32:49 a wrong way through there, 15 feet from property line along Bridgeview, and then they requested
1:32:56 that one small section, 20 feet.
1:32:58 The removal of the centerline setback is also part of that.
1:33:01 So we're removing centerline setback, which is not applicable for that area between Locust
1:33:07 and Bridgeview.
1:33:09 step back comes into play in other parts of town typically where we don't have a
1:33:13 lot of right-of-way width. In this location we've got 120 feet of right-of-way
1:33:17 width already but only developed about 75 feet of it. So we feel that we've got
1:33:24 enough right-of-way if we needed future lanes we have enough room for maybe one
1:33:27 or two lanes and at some point we need to talk about how big of a road do we
1:33:32 really want that that leaves room for about six or seven lanes do we need
1:33:37 anything bigger than that. That's what I said back of 80 or 90 feet. It ends up being
1:33:42 a freeway. So that's where Brent's point was. We kind of took that as a reasonable request,
1:33:50 given that there's a pad site that was previously approved, that pad site is right here. That's
1:33:55 what he's talking about with the slope and ADA accessibility. Since there's a public sidewalk
1:33:59 on pole line, they have to deliver people from that public sidewalk to the building. As
1:34:04 This building slopes too far down the further north you go.
1:34:09 That slope is almost too much if they can't build that, building a little bit closer to
1:34:14 the road because it's higher.
1:34:15 So they need to be in that.
1:34:16 It's just a little bit of a cushion area to be able to have that building be, but that
1:34:21 pad be usable.
1:34:23 The arterial landscaping, we did do that calculation at the average was, we basically took Bridge
1:34:32 few blue lakes took the length and that took multiple points along that length and came
1:34:38 up with an average depth. There is a provision that can't go less than 15 feet in any case.
1:34:44 And there's two different things you have to think about when they're building a building
1:34:49 they have a setback of 35 feet. So the building can't be into that landscaping anyway really.
1:34:55 But then they could put maybe some parking or something else in there if they needed
1:34:58 to get it or a sidewalk, things like that within that 30-foot, but they still
1:35:05 would then have to accommodate that next door to and have something that's bigger
1:35:08 in 30 feet in order to get the average. We feel we'll get a good arterial
1:35:15 landscaping in the area with that average, given that they've given so
1:35:19 much currently. And our whole point, whole goal of this was to permit additional
1:35:25 buildings and different areas along their property. Some of those buildings will be closer to the
1:35:30 road, some will be further. We didn't want to limit the location of those buildings necessarily
1:35:35 other than to meet the minimum code of the building setback, site triangles, and that minimum
1:35:41 landscaping pretty much what we ask everybody else in the C1 zone to do. The off-street parking takes
1:35:48 a minute to explain a little bit more detail on it. In Prince's analogy with the harbor freight,
1:35:54 which is across the street, it was spot on, and the addition is residential we are requiring
1:36:00 for two spaces, minimum, that's what our code requires, but we've also written in provision
1:36:05 that one of those spaces has to be dedicated, and one of them could be a shared use.
1:36:10 So, the example would be they could build a parking structure and dedicate one space within
1:36:15 that parking structure for residential homes, and then the other one could be elsewhere nearby
1:36:19 on the site, maybe outside that parking structure, but during the day would be used by shoppers,
1:36:26 people that go to the restaurants, even in the early evening hours. People don't always
1:36:30 come home right at five o'clock. It would be a shared use type of situation. We get more
1:36:37 buildings. They have less parking. We get a little bit more valuable property. They get
1:36:41 a little bit more valuable property. That was really our goal was to have a little bit more
1:36:45 buildings or productive hacks based on this property that we have currently.
1:36:50 Brendan explained the science very well, and no difference from that.
1:36:56 The last piece before I get to the comprehensive plan compliance,
1:37:00 the future buildings wrote on the master plan for the future buildings
1:37:06 since they're not on the actual master plan.
1:37:10 I'm going to scroll down to it so you can see it.
1:37:12 I'm sorry, I didn't have this one set up.
1:37:19 Their master development plan, typically these ZDA's are on vacant ground.
1:37:24 They're kind of creating their plan.
1:37:26 We have a mall already built, and they've identified the buildings and the pad sites
1:37:30 they have.
1:37:31 They wrote a provision on there that the buildings are depicted on a certain day and subject
1:37:36 to the ZDA future buildings could be anywhere that meet the code.
1:37:42 That allows them to build in any spot that makes sense for them for their future development
1:37:46 plan.
1:37:47 That's really crucial. It's the same thing we allow every other C1 property in this town.
1:37:52 It's not under a PUD. If you own a large, in this case 60 or so acres, you can place that building anywhere on the inside of that property
1:38:00 as long as you meet the road setback or the building setback.
1:38:04 That's really what we're getting at with this, is they could add buildings wherever that makes sense on there.
1:38:10 any real public hearing unless it needs one. They just need to meet that C1 zoning
1:38:15 code as we've written it as a city and approved through the council. The comprehensive plan
1:38:21 designates this area as appropriate for mixed use. Designation is to be targeted
1:38:27 at intersections of major arterials. This is at two or three anchored by
1:38:31 commercial civic or entertainment uses and allows high-intensity mixed uses and
1:38:35 compact pedestrian-oriented environments. Types of commercial uses
1:38:39 should be retail office, restaurant, hotel, and mixes of residential end uses. Staff has
1:38:44 determined this request applies to that 2016 comprehensive plan. On January 9th, 2018,
1:38:50 a planning and zoning commission held the public hearing. There's lengthy discussion
1:38:55 on the concept of conceptual plans, building elevations, and materials. That's where that
1:39:01 subject they added that condition, typically with ZDA's. Again, we're using buildings that
1:39:07 built yet. Here we have a lot of buildings that have been constructed and the mall
1:39:11 doesn't have like a a pallet of materials. Planning and zoning commission added this
1:39:18 condition subject to all future buildings being designed with first-class
1:39:21 architecture materials and workmanship, and are to be harmonious and appropriate in
1:39:25 appearance with the existing characteristics of the surrounding area. The mall
1:39:29 didn't have a bird came up with that first-class architecture as you described
1:39:33 during that discussion. The commission hooked on to that and said you should build it that way.
1:39:40 While it hasn't had any comment on that condition per se after the commission talked about it.
1:39:48 So in conclusion the council is asked to make a decision on the request. The council may approve
1:39:52 of this request as presented, approve this request subject to conditions, deny this request,
1:39:57 or seek additional information by tabling this request for a date of a later date.
1:40:00 We'll add if the council wishes to add that hours of operation it could be a needs to be
1:40:09 a condition if you wish to add it if it's approved as presented from the P&Z Commission it wouldn't
1:40:15 have that hours of operation in it.
1:40:17 That's something that if it's to be done you could add it as a condition saying we're going
1:40:21 to add it if you feel it's appropriate that concludes our report.
1:40:28 Thank you Jonathan any questions for Jonathan.
1:40:33 So, Jonathan, can you clarify for me what are the hours of operation allowed in the C1?
1:40:37 7 a.m. to 10 p.m.
1:40:39 And that is specifically actually to retail hours of operation.
1:40:45 It's a specific section or code.
1:40:48 If you're a service, something else other than retail, you can operate 24 hours.
1:40:52 But if you sell something, 7 to 10, Suzanne Hawkins.
1:41:03 When that got missed before, is that dealing with like the couple times a year that they do the midnight sidewalk sales leading up to the holidays?
1:41:09 is that what we're it could it could also be a restaurant that wants to operate
1:41:13 to eleven his restaurants for retail thank you just talking to just for
1:41:21 councils perspective do we have any other areas of ZDA of this magnitude or
1:41:29 they strip areas I mean a central mall do we have anything like this the
1:41:34 ordinances approved earlier with the real list is about the same size the
1:41:40 real VISTA ordinance that we looked at that that property is a pretty large
1:41:43 property similar to size a camera with the A, which is the exact exactly the same
1:41:47 that would be the one at point two vacant property it's nothing that's actually
1:41:56 built we're kind of retroactively CBA as we feel it's appropriate that way
1:42:02 the corner at east then and the pull line also on CBA it was the last PUD but they came
1:42:09 in or a PDB is really close to being a smosh.
1:42:11 It's a little bit like that.
1:42:12 Pretty much functions actually.
1:42:13 It is a little bit unique, yes.
1:42:23 Any other questions for Jonathan?
1:42:26 Seeing none, we will open it up for public testimony.
1:42:33 If there's anyone who wishes to speak on this issue,
1:42:36 now's your opportunity to come forward.
1:42:38 Seeing no one, we will close the public input portion
1:42:43 with public hearing, and Brent, is there anything else
1:42:46 that you wanted to add or clarify for us?
1:42:49 Okay, turn it over to the Council for discussion.
1:42:54 I think we know who it is.
1:43:05 The hours.
1:43:39 And the hours as well?
1:43:41 Yes.
1:43:44 I'll second if you put the hours on it.
1:43:46 Motion to make the hours.
1:43:53 That would be per the motion intent.
1:43:59 Motion to approve the zoning district change and zoning map amendment has presented with the condition placed by the planning and zoning commission.
1:44:09 And then what was the terminology to allow customary hours of operations?
1:44:22 You can make the condition that there are no hours of operation.
1:44:25 You can make it extended to a certain time period.
1:44:30 It really depends on what the commission would like.
1:44:33 And if the specific is retail hours, only that's the only thing that we have that restricts uses.
1:44:43 It's the selling of something.
1:44:45 a lot of other uses that we don't have restricted hours of operation.
1:44:51 That's what this in particular is only the selling of items.
1:44:57 Would the terminology of customary hours of operation be something that could be interpreted by staff?
1:45:05 It would specifically say extended hours of operation without a special use permit.
1:45:12 It is what he's asking for.
1:45:14 What Mitch said?
1:45:19 Yes, so let me say is there a discussion on that?
1:45:27 Chris talking to I've got my light on, but it's not working you have to hit f5
1:45:38 Great landing. Oh, I'm gonna be one favor of this. I'm actually a couple of thoughts on it
1:45:49 One the Jonathan talked about the shared parking name
1:45:53 One of my friends lived in Oklahoma City in a
1:45:56 my government rewards building that had been repurposed a little bit like maybe
1:46:01 they're trying to do the youth you have ranch building or the ID building as
1:46:05 apartments and they had that shared parking behind they had one floor that
1:46:10 they parked on of a parking structure and it was used by if you've ever been up
1:46:15 home city I was amazed how many I can see why that was selected by the people in
1:46:20 Wanda Bama a government building Oklahoma City is nothing but government
1:46:24 buildings for whatever reason downtown and they're used by the offices and then the
1:46:30 residents use it at night so I think that's probably a realistic thing. I think
1:46:35 it's interesting on the housing and some of the other things Brent that you
1:46:38 describe is exactly what we're trying to do downtown. If you think about it it's
1:46:43 like like we're the mall industry is copying what downtowns are trying to do
1:46:51 revitalize themselves in the same manner that thing is exactly what we would
1:46:56 explain the ZDA was explained to me when we first put it in our code was to make
1:47:03 it realistic and I think this fits even though the ball is already there we got
1:47:07 58 acres that are all around it's pretty much surrounded by C1 but the
1:47:12 exception of the assisted living on the east side and so I can't see that
1:47:19 anything they're planning to do there would be in with have concern from their
1:47:25 neighbors so I will be voted favor thank you for bringing something new to us.
1:47:30 Other comments I do would like to say I think some of the the creativity put
1:47:43 into this proposal to be accommodating to changes in market conditions and to
1:47:50 really focus on that placemaking to Greg's point. It's very similar to some of that activity
1:47:57 and energy that's been spent downtown. And there's no reason that that can't be another
1:48:03 place for those types of things. So I look forward to the future success of it. With that,
1:48:14 Aaron, we'll call vote please.
1:48:16 Yes, Piers. Yes. Hawkins. Yes. John Berger. Yes. Chris Harkington. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes.
1:48:30 Christopher Reed. Yes. Motion passes 6-0. And with that, that's everything on the agenda.
1:48:41 The meeting is adjourned.
Download
- Transcript (text) 73 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 95 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 127 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.3 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 4.5 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, February 5, 2018. The recording started at 16:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:48:58.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
650c52d3f416eba9c2307a2a570bd332a811c108eff7c9e2e522ab2f9f58eec5 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a bd4830e3f9a242e5fd27c609fc5b4a44477116c1144a493c02002f32aedf0cdb
part02.m4a dd1ef28b554920141640ec7ebbc9d5801cc685fde3c53faea9ad19fa62387154 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
7768a560d979385853506af3bd883f9877d52039533eb4198638ff6ef82ee850
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file