OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, February 26, 2018

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on file

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:00:12 Anytime.

0:00:23 Good evening.

0:00:24 I'd like to call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday, February 26th.

0:00:29 We have six of the seven council members this evening for a quorum.

0:00:34 Vice Mayor Nikki Boyd is not here this evening.

0:00:38 Next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:00:40 I see we have several scouts here this evening who have enthusiastically agreed to lead us

0:00:46 in the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:00:47 So gentlemen, if you would stand up and lead us, that would be great.

0:01:08 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:01:22 Before you all get too comfy if you would head up here to the podium and give me your

0:01:27 name and what you're working on this evening.

0:01:32 My name is Riley and I'm working on citizenship in the community.

0:01:38 Thank you.

0:01:42 Hi my name is Nick and I am the Badger I'm working on a citizenship in the community.

0:01:48 Fantastic.

0:01:50 My name is Ian and I'm working on citizenship in the community.

0:01:56 Thank you.

0:01:57 My name is Kent.

0:02:00 I'm working on citizenship in the community.

0:02:03 Thank you.

0:02:04 My name is Grant.

0:02:08 I'm working on citizenship in the community.

0:02:11 Welcome.

0:02:13 Thank you.

0:02:14 I see we have a few more scouts who are sneaking in who got off the hook and leading us in the pledge.

0:02:19 But before you find a seat, if you would come up to the podium here, give me your name.

0:02:24 Accent.

0:02:25 And you are with, which troop?

0:02:28 Uh, troop 67.

0:02:29 Okay, and what are you working on this evening?

0:02:31 Uh...

0:02:34 Just hanging out for fun at the City Council meeting.

0:02:36 Citizenship in the community.

0:02:38 Citizenship in the community.

0:02:40 Excellent, welcome.

0:02:41 Landed in troop 67.

0:02:46 Citizenship in the community.

0:02:49 Yes?

0:02:55 and trip 67 and citizenship in the community outstanding. Thank you all for being here this evening.

0:03:03 Mr. Rothwell amendments to the agenda this evening. Mr. Mayor, members of the Council there are no amendments.

0:03:13 Thank you. We have no proclamations. Next is an opportunity for general public input.

0:03:19 There's anyone here from the public who wishes to address the Council on an item that is not on the agenda this evening.

0:03:24 now is your opportunity to come forward. Seeing no one we will move to the consent calendar.

0:03:33 Council wishes. Christopher Reed. Mayor I move that we approve the consent calendar.

0:03:40 Chris Stockington. Second. We have a motion by Christopher Reed seconded by

0:03:47 Reid Pierce to approve the consent calendar. Is there any discussion?

0:03:52 Question.

0:03:53 Ms. Talkington, do you have a question?

0:03:56 Nope.

0:03:57 All right.

0:03:58 Sharon, I'll call vote please.

0:04:00 Is that Hawkins?

0:04:03 Yes.

0:04:04 John Bericke?

0:04:06 Yes.

0:04:07 Chris Harkington?

0:04:08 Yes.

0:04:09 Greg Lanting?

0:04:10 Yes.

0:04:11 Christopher Reed?

0:04:12 Yes.

0:04:13 Ruth Pierce?

0:04:14 Yes.

0:04:15 Motion passes 6-0.

0:04:16 So all of you who are here for special events, your special events, were all just approved.

0:04:20 You're welcome to stick around for the rest of the meeting, but I just want to let y'all know

0:04:25 We're on the consent agenda.

0:04:28 Next, under items of consideration,

0:04:30 the first is a request to fill four vacancies

0:04:32 on the Twin Falls Planning and Zoning Commission.

0:04:36 I'm gonna get to the right spot on my computer screen here.

0:04:52 A, did you wanna present this,

0:04:54 or do you want me to just sail through it?

0:04:56 I'm welcome, I'm happy to do so.

0:04:58 So, as of February 28th, we have four vacancies

0:05:03 on the City Planning and Zoning Commission.

0:05:06 The commission's comprised of nine members,

0:05:08 representing the area within the city, and then two from the area of impact.

0:05:13 Of the four vacancies, one vacancy that we have represents the area located within the area of impact,

0:05:19 so this person will be recommended by the mayor and appointed by the county commissioners.

0:05:24 The other three vacancies are for city representatives, two of which are full terms,

0:05:30 and one is a partial term to fill a separate vacancy from a resignation that we had.

0:05:37 We had 14 applications to fill these four vacancies, which first and foremost was incredible that

0:05:43 we had such great interest from the community, all outstanding candidates.

0:05:49 On February 7th, 14th, and 15th, a committee consisting of myself, Vice Mayor, Nikki Boyd,

0:05:57 Planning and Zoning Commission Chair, Tom Frank, Deputy City Manager, Mitch Humboldt,

0:06:01 and Zoning and Development Manager, Renee Caraway Johnson interviewed the applicants,

0:06:06 of those applicants one had withdrawn.

0:06:08 And upon conclusion of those interviews,

0:06:10 the selection committee would submit

0:06:12 the following recommendations

0:06:14 for the council's consideration.

0:06:17 Craig Kelly and Curtis Hanson,

0:06:20 to be appointed to serve a three-year term

0:06:22 on the commission with terms ending February 28th, 2021,

0:06:26 that Carolyn Bolton be appointed to serve the remainder

0:06:30 of Darren Hall's term, which would end February 28th of 2020,

0:06:34 and that Dave Detweiler, the area of impact representative,

0:06:38 be recommended to the county commissioners

0:06:41 to serve a three-year term with a term ending February 28, 2021.

0:06:46 All of these folks have completed background jacks

0:06:50 through our police department and we're good to go there.

0:06:53 So I would ask for the council's concurrence

0:06:57 on those appointments.

0:07:05 No one's popping up on my screen.

0:07:06 So, there you are, Greg Lanting.

0:07:10 Where I move that we approve, prove that Kennedy says listed.

0:07:20 Second.

0:07:22 Motion by Greg Lanting.

0:07:24 Second advice, Suzanne Hawkins, to approve those appointments

0:07:28 as presented.

0:07:29 Is there any further discussion?

0:07:33 Here in Roll Call vote, please.

0:07:40 Sean Pareker.

0:07:41 Yes.

0:07:42 Chris Hockington.

0:07:43 Yes.

0:07:44 Greg Lanting.

0:07:45 Yes.

0:07:46 Christopher Reed.

0:07:47 Yes.

0:07:47 Ruth Pierce, Suzanne Hawkins.

0:07:50 Yes.

0:07:51 Motion passes 6 to 0.

0:07:53 Those candidates are here tonight,

0:07:54 unless they want to come down and give a lengthy speech.

0:07:57 Thank you all for taking the time to be here,

0:07:59 and we look forward to your service

0:08:00 on the lighting and zoning commission.

0:08:06 Next on the agenda is a discussion with CH2M Jacobs

0:08:10 regarding their annual update.

0:08:12 And we have Jason Brown, Environmental Engineer

0:08:16 for the city, and Sean Moffa, the CH2M Jacobs.

0:08:20 Welcome, gentlemen, Mr. Mayor, council members,

0:08:23 appreciate the opportunity to come tonight.

0:08:26 This one I won't say too much as has been to customary.

0:08:31 For the last couple of years, we've invited CH2M

0:08:34 to come and talk about their contract

0:08:36 and any updates that they have.

0:08:38 And I'll, at this time, go ahead and turn that over

0:08:40 to Sean Moffin, let him talk.

0:08:44 Jason, welcome, Sean.

0:08:46 Thank you, Mr. Mayor, council members.

0:08:47 It's great to be here.

0:08:49 As Jason mentioned, this is something that we do every year as we come to the end of each

0:08:53 contract year to come and give kind of an accounting of where we were at the end of the year and

0:08:58 how things went.

0:09:00 And what I would like to preface this with really quick before we talk is this is a little

0:09:04 bit different than we've had in years past.

0:09:07 Usually I'm coming up here and sharing that we came in under budget and with the way that

0:09:12 the contracts read that we are going to be making rebates.

0:09:16 This is one year that we went over, so to kind of give some history to that, back when

0:09:21 there was a lot of the changes going on, we had a lot of the planned upgrades happening.

0:09:26 We had a lot of significant industrial growth that was taking place in Twin Falls.

0:09:31 As we sat down and worked with city staff on that, there were a lot of unknowns that we

0:09:35 had to come up with from an operational standpoint, especially when it came to working with

0:09:39 the bunch.

0:09:41 So one of the nice things that changed where our contract used to have it, that any amount

0:09:45 that we came in under under under our budget amount we rebated that 75% to the

0:09:51 city and we kept 25% and as we looked at that we've been working with the city

0:09:56 in Twin Falls now since 1985 as we sat down and talked about it's like you know

0:10:01 we've been here a long time we're starting to get a really good handle on

0:10:04 what the costs are but during that time as we saw those different changes one of

0:10:09 the things that we talked about was let's let's change that to be a hundred

0:10:14 percent rebatable and also to rebate the management fee that we would make on that amount that

0:10:20 we rebated.

0:10:21 So that's the way that's set up.

0:10:23 So in the short amount of time that I've been here just to kind of talk about it a little

0:10:28 bit.

0:10:29 I got back here in July of 2010, but if we look at the last seven years of just the rebates

0:10:35 that we've made as a company back to the city of Twin Falls of operating it, we're right

0:10:40 at and this includes this year's overage which which come we were fifty two thousand six eighty one

0:10:46 over and with the management fee that comes to six sixty three thousand two seventeen but if you add

0:10:54 that into the total amount that we've done over the past seven years we've rebated and that's that's

0:10:59 subtracting that off but we've rebated eight hundred ninety five thousand one zero thirty five

0:11:05 back to the city during that time.

0:11:07 You can look at it again,

0:11:09 sometimes it was unknowns as we started up

0:11:12 and we had a lot of equipment,

0:11:13 we've completed all the plant upgrades now.

0:11:16 So those things have been done.

0:11:19 As we started those up,

0:11:20 there was a lot of things that we didn't know

0:11:22 that were projected to be very in,

0:11:24 if energy efficient, but you had to wait and see.

0:11:26 So some of those things came about

0:11:28 because of those energy efficiencies,

0:11:30 but that's where we stand today.

0:11:32 So we apologize that this has taken so long

0:11:35 to be able to get in front of the council,

0:11:37 but as we've been discussing this with city staff,

0:11:39 we've been sitting down with them

0:11:41 so that we can open up everything,

0:11:43 show them what the overages came from,

0:11:45 and make sure that they understood it completely

0:11:48 before we came to the council.

0:11:50 What with you?

0:11:51 So I'm open for any questions that you might have.

0:11:54 Any questions for Sean?

0:11:58 I was talking to you about almost button pushing.

0:12:02 that the 895,000 is just incredible, it actually represents 75% rebate, so actually it's a significantly

0:12:11 higher figure of which your company kept 25%, but we in effect are operating 895,000 or

0:12:20 more under the budget.

0:12:25 And so if you look at that announcement we had during that time when it switched would

0:12:31 been in 2014 and so that's when that change happened. Some of that still on top of that

0:12:37 was a few of those years were at the 75% but from 2014 on would have been 100%

0:12:43 but still adding it all together that's the amount that was returned back to the city.

0:12:50 Is that how I can do it? Thank you. Sean, not that I'm Cheryl

0:12:55 understand but can you maybe help us understand why the over to the share and

0:13:00 some of the causes, what has changed?

0:13:02 Sure, so we looked at a few things

0:13:05 and that we had come up this last year.

0:13:08 One of them that we had was, we went over,

0:13:12 we have a repair budget that we tried to come up

0:13:15 with what we think the repairs are gonna happen

0:13:17 to have the treatment plan.

0:13:18 So that not only includes the wastewater treatment plan,

0:13:21 but that would also include all the lift stations

0:13:23 that we operate for the city around.

0:13:25 But we had a budget set at $70,000

0:13:28 we thought would cover that and we actually hit just over 100,000 solar, about 25,000 that

0:13:34 were over there. Some of those things, for example, we had a brand new pump room that

0:13:41 was just completed in the construction. There was an older pipe that was a waste from that

0:13:47 that broke. Some time after that construction was done, it happened months after the construction

0:13:52 was finished, but it just failed and it had been end since 2000. But that actually flooded

0:13:58 where we had to pull motors out, we had to dry those.

0:14:03 There was some costs that went to one per budget.

0:14:06 A few others we had, as you're well aware, we had the UASB that was treated

0:14:11 the waste coming from Conagra.

0:14:14 When we tried to budget for that at the beginning of the year,

0:14:17 we budgeted that that was going to be going away in December,

0:14:20 and that actually didn't go away, and we operated that until April.

0:14:23 So there was about $32,000 of extra costs that weren't budgeted for, counted for that facility money now.

0:14:32 We also had, and this was a mistake on my part, but as we were starting up the Cliff Bar facility, that's one of the things I missed was natural gas costs on the Cliff Bar facility, and that equated to about $5,000, so that added in.

0:14:49 One last item that we did have a lot of expense that went out to.

0:14:55 We're, every year we do what they call toxicity testing for the wastewater treatment plant.

0:15:00 And it determines how well it's running.

0:15:03 It's a test where they put fish and fleas and some other things in the wastewater that we send off.

0:15:09 And they check reproductive rates and how well they survive and stuff.

0:15:14 We've had a couple issues with that over the last couple years for some reason.

0:15:18 still trying to determine what is causing some of the failures, but the extended testing

0:15:24 that we had to do from EPA to try to identify what it was was an additional 18,000 testing

0:15:31 this year alone.

0:15:33 So for some reason we're passing those again, we don't know why, but those tests are trying

0:15:39 to eliminate certain contaminants or whatever you are very expensive tests, but those things

0:15:48 that would be a good of the whole person's form.

0:15:51 Thank you.

0:15:53 Any other questions for, thank you for the report.

0:16:00 Thanks for your partnership.

0:16:02 Appreciate that.

0:16:02 And if I can take just one more second, please do.

0:16:06 We have some changes going on down at the wastewater treatment

0:16:08 plant.

0:16:10 I've appreciated the opportunity to be the project manager down

0:16:14 there.

0:16:15 And as I said, I've been down there since July of 2010.

0:16:18 But I have an opportunity to still with CH,

0:16:22 but more in a regional role.

0:16:24 So as we went through the process to come up

0:16:26 with a new project manager to run it,

0:16:28 the decision was made and we also talked with city staff

0:16:32 was to move Jack Benion,

0:16:34 who was the assistant project manager

0:16:36 at the time and to the project manager.

0:16:39 I can tell you from experience,

0:16:41 Jack was the person that hired me 20 years ago

0:16:44 within the age.

0:16:45 I can tell you that you will not have another person

0:16:48 that will dedicate more time to that plan.

0:16:50 Jack has been down there since 1987. I don't think there's anybody else with as much knowledge

0:16:56 as he has in the ways of our treatment. It's fortunate that we have him in that role and

0:17:01 he'll be taking that. I'll still be available. I'm still in the Twin Falls. I'm still coming

0:17:05 in. Hopefully still getting to see everybody in the presentations, but that role's changed.

0:17:12 Well, Sean, congratulations on your new role, and Jack, thank you for your continued dedication.

0:17:23 We'll look forward to working with you in that role. And if you wanted to say something,

0:17:27 more than welcome to come down.

0:17:29 I knew that was going to be soon.

0:17:31 Alright, anything else?

0:17:33 Alright, great landing.

0:17:35 This is John Sisser.

0:17:37 Thanks for close to me.

0:17:39 You have the friends of Beauty and Turnver rolls around to see it go.

0:17:41 I need to call you back.

0:17:43 I'm surprised you asked that after you see how bad I go.

0:17:46 I'll just ask you to call me back.

0:17:48 Definitely. Thank you.

0:17:50 Great, thank you.

0:17:55 Next on the agenda is a request to reject all bids on the onsite sodium

0:17:59 I am hypochlorite generator project, Jason Brandt.

0:18:03 I hear council members appreciate this opportunity.

0:18:08 So again, the request, as was just read,

0:18:11 was to reject the bids for the on-site sodium hyperchlorite

0:18:16 generator.

0:18:16 This generator, it helps generate bleach

0:18:20 to put into the public water system or potable water system.

0:18:25 The request is coming because as we receive bids on this

0:18:29 and talked and realized that the way we wrote the specifications, we felt it was best to

0:18:36 come before the council, have the bids rejected, and then rewrite the specifications again.

0:18:43 There was some misunderstanding and some more exceptions than what we had anticipated, so

0:18:49 we feel rewriting the specification is in our best interest, but also allows us to solicit

0:18:56 some more vendors for this particular piece of equipment, and so that's why we wanted to

0:19:03 come before the council tonight to reject going, in a sense, to get a do-over, write the specifications

0:19:11 a little bit clearer, a little bit better, from my hand, and go out to bid again, so at some

0:19:18 later they will come do this all over again with the proposal.

0:19:23 Chris Stockington, the other questions or comments?

0:19:31 Motion by Chris Stockington, seconded by Christopher Reed to reject the bids on the onsite sodium

0:19:50 hypochloride generator project, is there any discussion?

0:19:53 Chair, I'll call vote please.

0:19:57 John Beriker?

0:20:05 Yes.

0:20:07 Chris Stockington?

0:20:08 Yes.

0:20:09 Thank you, Greg Lanthing, Christopher Reed, Ruth Pears, Zann Hawkins, thank you very much.

0:20:22 Next is a request to amend Title 2, Chapter 5, Traffic Safety Commission.

0:20:28 We have Jackie Fields, our city engineer.

0:20:31 Also, John Capillara's Traffic Safety Commission member on the agenda.

0:20:35 Welcome.

0:20:36 Thank you. This item is to ask you to consider having the Traffic Safety Commission work on

0:20:44 potential amendments to the section of code that have responsibilities. And so, um,

0:20:51 non-cappularis is a member of the Traffic Safety Commission. And this is John to talk to you about

0:20:58 why, uh, with that. Thank you, Jackie. And Council, I'm John Capularis.

0:21:07 All right, so I'm on the Traffic Safety Commission.

0:21:18 Since my appointment, I've been contemplating the law of the Traffic Safety Commission.

0:21:23 All right, so here's the accomplishments, include the back of the work we've done around the South Hills Millisville,

0:21:29 and the submission of the Traffic Safety Commission.

0:21:34 But I don't know if the Traffic Safety Commission is meeting its potential.

0:21:40 the question, what is the full potential of the Traffic Safety Commission? City College

0:21:46 states that the Traffic Safety Commission is supposed to recommend plans for extension,

0:21:51 construction, and development of public streets. That is not what we normally do. We usually

0:21:57 deal with street signage and markings, not where streets will go or how well they will

0:22:02 be. That is up to planning and zoning and the City Council. Perhaps the Traffic Safety Commission

0:22:09 could have a greater role in our community, but what that means is up to you, mayor and council.

0:22:14 What is planned to wow is that the city code does not match current practice.

0:22:19 The options fit in a spectrum between changing what we do to conform to code, to changing the code to reflect what we do.

0:22:30 You can choose one of these options, but I believe that as a version, we are similar in the middle.

0:22:36 In this matter cannot change, and we should not interchange.

0:22:40 This option of doing what the court says would have all straight issues, not just safety issues,

0:22:48 but all straight issues coming before the Traffic Safety Commission.

0:22:51 This would prove too cumbersome for the city.

0:22:54 This would create a bottleneck in the approval process for most large developments.

0:22:59 The Traffic Safety Commission would become another planning and zoning commission.

0:23:04 But, the original intent of the violence that was written in the 1950s,

0:23:10 was before the Plonin-Zining Commission was created.

0:23:13 The violence record, after a few decades, was revived in 2000 with little change.

0:23:20 Nor to the other extreme option, changing the code to reflect only what we currently do.

0:23:27 This would know the world is to achieve our potential.

0:23:29 Right now, Plonin-Zining, and occasionally the City Council brought South London's new street issues.

0:23:34 More often than not, the planning and zoning commission handle streets kind of has a secondary issue to the primary issue of a new set of division or development.

0:23:42 However many times people will bring straight safety concerns, straight to planning and zoning, and even to the city council first.

0:23:51 And I know this because I've done it before, I've done it for years ago.

0:23:56 I don't think I have a people note too.

0:23:59 People don't want much about the Traffic Safety Commission and what we do.

0:24:05 This is the status quo, and a current rule of view so decided.

0:24:09 In all the terror options, why the solution?

0:24:13 I believe.

0:24:14 I also don't believe that virtue lay between two extremes.

0:24:17 For example, the virtue of courage can be found between rationalness and cowardice.

0:24:23 This is not the goal of me.

0:24:25 However, a solution can be found between the two options.

0:24:29 We don't care about it, but from diverse sectors or community, that is more part of your needs,

0:24:37 exist, which the Traffic Safety Commission can meet better than anyone else.

0:24:42 One of the biggest needs that I heard about was connectivity.

0:24:46 From strikes to back panels, trails, design blocks, all forms of traffic

0:24:53 must interact peacefully and should lead somewhere.

0:24:58 When we turn shot up, we'll beg to get the Traffic Safety Commission.

0:25:03 The duty of reviewing plants will request vulnerable departments.

0:25:07 When they leave for problems before they are made a past in Asheville and cement,

0:25:12 they'll be set at the city and developed for some time and money.

0:25:16 This was requested most emphatically by Dokesonack.

0:25:21 The one duty for the Traffic Safety Commission does,

0:25:25 but a more than statute includes our advice available to the city engineer.

0:25:29 year, providing input on the transportation master plan, and a sample word for the public

0:25:38 on traffic safety issues. The studies are not installed too, they need to continue to

0:25:44 record plans and studies and coordinate with county, state, and federal agencies. This middle

0:25:50 high solution will require change, and we should not fear change. As the global income

0:25:56 as a religious, almost 2,000 years ago, does a miracle shrink from change, but the new order

0:26:03 to the nature of the universe can't start to take a hot bath unless the wood for the furnace

0:26:08 suffer change, cuts down a bay, fed, life holds suffered no change, and can any of the needs of life

0:26:17 be provided for a platform change, so too we must change the traffic safety commission

0:26:23 to make the naves of today out of our future.

0:26:27 So, in closing, I am a council.

0:26:29 I believe it must change the code and change what we do

0:26:32 to frame the golden mean in order to achieve the potential

0:26:35 of the traffic safety commission

0:26:37 and serve the common good of twin falls.

0:26:40 Thank you.

0:26:42 Thank you, John.

0:26:45 Comments or questions from the council?

0:26:56 I would really appreciate any input the council has

0:27:00 with regard to this process.

0:27:03 If you have anything in particular,

0:27:05 you would like the Traffic Safety Commission to look at or consider, with regard to changing

0:27:09 the duties and responsibilities, we would really appreciate that. The request tonight

0:27:15 is that as traffic, if it is an indication of whether or not the Council would like the

0:27:22 Traffic Safety Commission to go forward considering whether or not to recommend change to the

0:27:28 code to you.

0:27:37 Is that awkward?

0:27:40 I'm trying to find something to correlate this to, have we ever had a commission write

0:27:47 its own changes to what it should or should not be doing?

0:27:51 That just seems out of place to me.

0:27:53 Sam, I don't think they're asking to write it, they're asking for con amendments to present

0:28:02 to you.

0:28:03 You would make the changes if you accepted them or you may modify them.

0:28:07 They don't want to surprise you by coming in here with the changes to the code saying

0:28:12 What are you guys doing here?

0:28:13 They're really asking permission to suggest changes,

0:28:18 but you would have to make the change.

0:28:22 You know, planning zoning does that all always on.

0:28:28 Sounds good.

0:28:29 Thank you for explaining that.

0:28:35 Well, it's the newest to be member on planning and zoning.

0:28:39 Our traffic safety commission, I think,

0:28:42 it is certainly worth a close review

0:28:47 if only to match the title of traffic safety commission.

0:28:50 There are issues, I think, that we can update ourselves on, so I'd certainly in favor with the concept.

0:28:57 Great landing.

0:29:05 Have we served as liaison previously to the traffic safety mission? It did seem like we were a little narrow in scope at that point.

0:29:14 Sometimes meetings the monthly meeting maybe didn't seem necessary to be honest with you because there wasn't enough.

0:29:22 It was all typically only complaints that people would have with a school zone or a speed in an area.

0:29:29 Basically, all we were dealing with, and if it is correct that the actual code does not match even that,

0:29:37 what they were working on, I would be willing to look at every right to see whether there was areas we would like to have them expand into as well as codify what they're actually doing now.

0:29:49 And so, yeah, I'm good with them.

0:29:52 I take it and look at what they come back with.

0:29:58 So a question I would have, and maybe John or Jack, either one can answer this.

0:30:02 So has the commission itself had an extensive discussion of this as a group?

0:30:12 The commission has started to have conversations and then the decision was made to appear

0:30:19 and worry the council.

0:30:23 I would agree with Greg's comments. I think aligning what it is that Commission actually

0:30:28 is doing to the code or vice versa probably makes sense, but I think it's important to

0:30:34 have some conversation about where is the best use of that committee's time to actually provide

0:30:40 direction. So, John, you mentioned the Transportation Master Plan. There are certainly components

0:30:46 of the Transportation Master Plan that I could see the Traffic Safety Commission having some

0:30:52 per view over, but that process in and of itself already has its own separate advisory

0:30:58 board that's working on that as well as a technical advisory group.

0:31:03 So I don't want to make it so cumbersome that some of these projects that we work on now

0:31:10 are running it through so many different commissions we're never getting to resolution.

0:31:14 So I'm not saying that that should or shouldn't be in there, but maybe as a discussion of that

0:31:20 Commission and with staff for the identifying where is the greatest need for that input that we're not getting someplace else

0:31:29 So I guess my input would be yes

0:31:32 I'm all for having some review of them

0:31:36 But I think it's gonna take a little time having that discussion before we know what the answer is

0:31:42 Is that Hawkins I was ready to make a motion, but I see Chris is Chris talking to you

0:31:47 I just want one more comment. I think it'd be very wise for us not to invent the wheel.

0:31:54 Let's check and see what other traffic safety commissions do in our immediate area.

0:32:00 State or the Northwest.

0:32:02 So the request is to amend Title 2, Chapter 5.

0:32:12 But the motion I'm going to make is to give authority to the commission, the staff and the liaison to that commission to look at what it is that needs to be changed.

0:32:20 that needs to be changed and bring it back to the council.

0:32:23 And I think I'll leave my motion there.

0:32:27 Second.

0:32:29 Motion by Suzanne Hawkins.

0:32:31 Seconded by Greg Lanting because it's closer to me and has always traveled faster than yours.

0:32:36 Chris Reed.

0:32:38 To give the commission and staff and the council liaison to the traffic safety commission direction to draft some changes and bring that back to the council.

0:32:49 Is there any further discussion?

0:32:54 Roll call vote please.

0:33:04 Chris Stockington.

0:33:05 Yes.

0:33:06 Greg Lanting.

0:33:07 Yes.

0:33:08 Christopher Reed.

0:33:09 Yes.

0:33:10 Ruth Pierce.

0:33:11 Yes.

0:33:12 Is Ann Hawkins.

0:33:13 Yes.

0:33:14 Don Bericher.

0:33:15 Yes.

0:33:16 Motion passes 6-0.

0:33:17 Thank you.

0:33:19 I apologize that the request does not match the actual recommendation.

0:33:23 So, was that what should okay for you?

0:33:25 Is that what you did?

0:33:26 Yes.

0:33:27 Perfectly.

0:33:28 I apologize for not having consistency there.

0:33:30 Thank you.

0:33:31 Thanks Jackie, and thank you John. Next on the agenda is a request to purchase a new HP Design Jet T1530 with one set of ink cartridges and with warranty.

0:33:45 Jackie Fields.

0:33:46 We in the engineering department have a plotter that's a really great plotter. It works on all kinds of media. It holds the two most common role sizes that we use.

0:34:00 We use it regularly to do production sets of maps for other departments like the Fire Department and so on.

0:34:08 And we ran that plotter as long as we could.

0:34:14 And the vendor finally, our service people finally told us that they could no longer support replacement parts.

0:34:23 They're not available.

0:34:24 And so we thought, okay, we need to start planning for replacement of the plotter.

0:34:28 And had every intention of doing that and putting the plotter in long-term planning.

0:34:33 And then our plotter guide, a violent death in November when we moved, is not available for us anymore.

0:34:45 So the item is not budgeted.

0:34:50 But we do have a little bit of cuff sittings from one of our other capital, an item scanner or surface pros that we bought for the lab.

0:35:01 So the total cost of the plotter with a warranty, which we think is necessary and appropriate,

0:35:09 is $8,630 with ink cartridges.

0:35:15 The request comes to $9,050.

0:35:18 So we add ink cartridges for our old plotter.

0:35:22 Our new plotter may not necessarily use them.

0:35:24 The cartridges that come with the new plotters are just like the cartridges that come with the new printers for your home computers.

0:35:30 They last for about 30 seconds and then they're done and our cartridges are rather expensive, you know,

0:35:37 $70 a pop for six, six, um, heads on there. So, um, there's several hundred dollars. The total request or the total cost of the item is

0:35:47 $9,050, asking for use of reserves in, um, amount of $8,000. Actually, we're asking you to let us purchase the plotter.

0:36:01 Thank you, Jackie, and solutions.

0:36:07 Somebody just speak up them.

0:36:16 This is Greg Lanting.

0:36:17 So, Mayor, I moved that we allow the engineering department or another department to purchase

0:36:25 a new HP design jet.

0:36:28 He won 1530 with one set of 8 cartridges in warranty for an amount not to exceed $9,050.

0:36:35 I think it was the number one.

0:36:37 Second.

0:36:38 Motion by Greg Lanting, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the purchase as requested as their further discussion.

0:36:46 Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote, please.

0:36:51 Greg Lanting.

0:36:55 Yes.

0:36:56 Christopher Reed.

0:36:57 Yes.

0:36:58 Ruth Pierce.

0:36:59 Yes.

0:37:00 Zann Hawkins.

0:37:01 Yes.

0:37:02 John Berriger.

0:37:03 Yes.

0:37:04 Chris Talking.

0:37:05 Yes.

0:37:06 Motion passes 6-0.

0:37:07 Thank you.

0:37:11 Thank you, Jackie.

0:37:12 discussion on the PSI recycle program and processing cost sharing for January

0:37:18 through December 2018. We have Bill Baxter, utility services supervisor. Well good

0:37:24 evening Marin Council. Thank you for this opportunity. I kind of wish everything

0:37:30 hadn't gone quite so fast because this is not probably going to be that smooth

0:37:34 path everybody else has followed this evening. We are faced with an issue of

0:37:42 market demand and cost for the recycled product that has brought us into

0:37:51 discussion with PSI regarding the cost-sharing section of the contract we

0:37:56 signed with them last year. They have experienced costs in the current year

0:38:03 which is the year covered by that particular section of the contract, the first year covered

0:38:08 by that section of $106 per ton in January and $136 per ton in February. So Jeff is in

0:38:21 less than a year tonight to help support this conversation. I believe that where we are

0:38:27 is to consider options. And I have some ideas, but what I'm going to do is just let Jeff

0:38:35 come up here. We have some information on the pilot program just real briefly that you helped

0:38:41 us introduce so you'll see how that is succeeding. And we want to expand that now, but in the

0:38:48 meantime we have to begin this conversation about how do we handle the recycling issue

0:38:54 of cost and disposal that we are currently faced with, but with that I'll turn this over

0:39:01 to Jeff and up up one of our first display items on the pilot program.

0:39:08 Thank you, Bill.

0:39:09 Welcome.

0:39:10 Thank you.

0:39:11 Good evening, Mr. Mayor and members of the council.

0:39:13 Before we get started, I did want to share.

0:39:15 I didn't know how we had you guys come out and help us with the cycle of art and challenges

0:39:21 that we put together a few months ago and we did get our calendars back and I decided

0:39:25 to copy that if you don't mind.

0:39:34 Had a good timing for that, since now we're having a

0:39:36 discussion about the true cost of recycling.

0:39:41 Before we get started on that, we can kind of go over, as we

0:39:44 discussed earlier in 2017, we were going to be in a pilot

0:39:48 program to offer smaller container options for some of the

0:39:52 customers in a specific area town.

0:39:55 Where we selected that was basically from Addison to Falls

0:39:59 to the Eastland and with that we offered smaller sized containers and with that

0:40:03 obviously that couldn't wouldn't allow for any extra trash other for a few weeks a

0:40:09 year that would be spring cleanup fall cleanup and the week following Christmas

0:40:13 holiday and with that obviously there's a significantly lower rate for those

0:40:17 smaller container options that today in those areas we have 52 35 gallon

0:40:24 containers that have been placed out there in 65 or I mean 76 65 gallon

0:40:29 containers up here very same thing I'm looking at so with that pilot program

0:40:37 it's been pretty successful with the 126 or 128 rather customers that signed up

0:40:43 for that program we've only had one that have a hundred and twenty nine

0:40:47 obviously to originally we only had one customer that called in and no longer

0:40:51 I wanted to participate in that program and it was simple communication there.

0:40:56 They thought they could still save the money, plus have answers each week, so once they

0:41:01 were educated on how the program truly worked, they decided to go back to the regular 95-gallon

0:41:07 trash container there, but so far it's been a pretty good program, the people that are

0:41:12 using it.

0:41:13 A lot of people that are using it are really elderly, a lot of fixed incomes that are really

0:41:18 They're just using it one to save money and they just don't generate a lot of volume

0:41:22 on a trash bill, so we're truly welcome from them.

0:41:26 We just also want to talk about expanding that program to a new area of town.

0:41:31 And moving that to the new area would be North College Road,

0:41:36 all the way to the North City boundary and then from Blue Lakes Boulevard West to the West.

0:41:41 The reason we chose that is, one, they do have the

0:41:47 the meanest recycle volume in the town of anywhere that we pick up recycling and I think that would be a good area to offer that

0:41:55 pilot program to those folks as well.

0:41:59 This is something that's ongoing and if this pilot program works again in this second area maybe it's something we've spent

0:42:06 either across town or at least into other areas, it's been so far it has been a pretty good program.

0:42:12 Questions for Jeff on the...

0:42:23 So moving along, now we can kind of talk about recycling and

0:42:29 and where it's at and why it's where it's at.

0:42:32 There is another slide up on the screen showing where our costs are as everybody knows when we begin the recycle program in 2010.

0:42:40 There was rebates for bringing in a legal recycling at that time.

0:42:45 at the tune of about 30 dollars per ton profit. At that time we were sharing the profits with the

0:42:50 City of Twin Falls. Probably about a year or two later it started to go down to zero.

0:42:56 It's been getting nothing for the volume that we brought in to the last couple of years. It's been

0:43:01 coming as a debits. See starting out the year we started around 30 dollars a ton.

0:43:07 one of the ones like $2.25.

0:43:10 Got me just a little bit.

0:43:14 As you can see in January 2017, I started out at $35 a ton, and it has significantly grown

0:43:21 since then.

0:43:22 Like Bill mentioned earlier, February has expected to be $136 a ton, too.

0:43:27 I'm getting rid of that recycling volume.

0:43:30 And what it really comes down to is China over the past couple of decades has really bought

0:43:35 about 50% of the world, not just the US, but the world's recycling products and that would consist of your plastics, some of your metals, and your mixed paper.

0:43:47 Mixed paper is really what drives this more amazing, just because the contamination levels that they fund.

0:43:53 The problem with selling this to China is basically, as I said, we're sick of taking everybody's trash because that's what's coming in all this recycled material.

0:44:01 They receive this material then they have to separate out the trash

0:44:07 Basically they're telling the world we no longer want to

0:44:11 more waste disposal facility

0:44:13 You to clean up your volume

0:44:18 3% down to one and a half percent contamination and now beginning January 1st 2018

0:44:23 They said we're not going to accept anything over a point or half a percent of contamination obviously with the way that

0:44:30 recycling goes into the trucks, ends up at the recycling facility, as sorted through by

0:44:36 the time it gets to China. They feel like they still don't get enough of that contamination

0:44:41 out of that material to make it worthwhile for China to buy. So basically they've just

0:44:45 shut their doors. And there's some other Asian countries that are buying it now, but

0:44:51 they're buying it at a significant lower price than what China was. So that's kind of where

0:44:56 the market is gone and then it really begins and ends with contamination. If you send a

0:45:01 clean product versus the market, it's going to be profitable. We figure out a way to give

0:45:06 them that. They're going to be paying $136 a ton. The last figure out is not just a twin

0:45:12 false problem, it's a global problem. That's kind of where we're at with recycling.

0:45:20 Jeff, a question I have on that is $136 a ton. Who is that getting paid to? Is there

0:45:25 a midpoint between you and China?

0:45:28 Yes, there is a couple of them actually.

0:45:31 So all of our recycling in Twin Falls actually goes to Magic Valley Disposal which is owned

0:45:36 by Western recycling in Boise, obviously a lot of the Boise volume goes to that same

0:45:41 facility as well.

0:45:42 From there it's actually sorted, rebelled into certain items whether it be plastics, metals,

0:45:49 It's a

0:45:53 There's a belt and put on trucks and ship to the west coast to another recycle facility in some cases

0:45:58 That's broken down any further more

0:46:01 Contamination is pulled out of it and that's loaded on to ship containers and ship to China

0:46:10 That's pretty much all the money that we pay Western recycling and Boise is for our shipping from here

0:46:17 their facility pay for their sorters, obviously. At the end market, they're getting, basically,

0:46:25 they're being charged right now as the problem. Up until about four months ago, they're getting

0:46:30 about five dollars a ton. After all their efforts, they would get five dollars a ton.

0:46:34 So in that process, the contaminants that are withdrawn from the system at that time are

0:46:40 ending up in a landfill somewhere along the line, how much of the, once it's sorted and

0:46:47 and resorted up that tonnage, how much of that is actually getting recycled?

0:46:54 So if it actually, once it makes it to China, they'll actually sort through it.

0:46:58 Like I said, previous to January 1st, they'd accept one and a half percent contamination.

0:47:04 Right.

0:47:05 Basically one and a half percent would be contaminants, probably a little bit more than that, but a very

0:47:10 small amount of that was going into a landfill in China, so to speak, when the rest was being recycled.

0:47:15 So a good portion of that.

0:47:16 So of every ton that we're sending up to get re-clean, how much is that?

0:47:20 How much of that is getting thrown away between you and there?

0:47:23 Oh, we're on the contamination level and I'll be honest with you, there are certain parts of town where our trucks probably have 10 or 15 percent contamination.

0:47:31 That is not that uncommon.

0:47:33 So obviously if we're shipping 15 percent contamination or trash essentially to OIC, they're going through it and trying to get down to about a 5 or 6 percent.

0:47:43 they ship it over to Oregon and then they try to get it down to that one and a half percent.

0:47:48 Like I said with the current sorting procedures out and it ran through the process right now

0:47:53 it's just very, basically they said it's almost impossible to get to .5 percent.

0:47:58 Great landing.

0:48:00 Further into the market.

0:48:03 So if China's not taking it and we're paying the ship at the Boise and then basically paying for Boise

0:48:11 to poison the shipper from Boise to Portland and if China's not taking it,

0:48:16 what is the bulk of it going to end up in a landfill in Portland right now or

0:48:20 tell things change or? As of right now, I have not heard of anybody land filling it,

0:48:25 but there is a lot of places that have been asking, hey, we have surplus materials right

0:48:29 now and it's really not your your plastics or your metals stuff like that or really is that

0:48:35 mixed paper, where it consists of some cardboard, but it's really your uh newspaper

0:48:41 which is obviously used to get newspapers now, everybody just reads their smartphone

0:48:49 and there's not as much newspaper. That's also driven down the modern e-level as well

0:48:53 because that was very easy to turn into products. So anyway, it consists of your junk mail, your office paper,

0:49:01 your paper, all that kind of stuff mixed with cardboard, that's your mixed paper

0:49:06 and that's really what China is not receiving.

0:49:09 I know we don't have the ability to sort here, but we also have our latest urban renewal newsletter.

0:49:31 They were talking about Hamilton manufacturing, and Twin Falls is actually looking for more

0:49:38 materials a little like the mixed paper and the cardboard to expand their

0:49:43 business and have a trouble finding it. I'm trying to figure out a way in my mind

0:49:48 that our mixed paper and cardboard didn't end up at Hamilton instead of

0:49:53 a shipping it's a place because this one the the parts that are going into a landfill

0:49:57 landfill to me is a landfill I don't care if it's a portal on our fridge and

0:50:02 And, you know, how beautiful or whatever we classify that landfill to be, there's no sense of paying 130 dollars a ton to ship it to Portland and the M.

0:50:12 Because the articles that we were able to receive kind of left sounded like those companies were looking to put in landfills.

0:50:20 I really don't want to waste the fuel and the cost of our customers to chip it to Portland and then put it in landfill there.

0:50:28 I just did be the 35 hours of time to put it in our landfill, or get it to Hamilton or things.

0:50:34 So I'm hoping that your guys are going to have proposals that I'm going to say.

0:50:38 That's a good idea. The hell is that out here?

0:50:41 As of right now until the market turns there's really just a lot of options that are really kind of faced with this.

0:50:48 is it still the best thing to do for the environment absolutely that goes without

0:50:53 seeing. Eventually landfill space is gonna fill up. I mean we think we're living

0:50:57 Idaho and we have thousands and thousands of acres of BLM and we can create another

0:51:02 landfill but eventually the world is going to be overpopulated and they're

0:51:05 not going to be there. They do need to think about it that way but they're I

0:51:09 think everybody also needs to consider there is a cost right where that's just

0:51:13 I don't know if we've reached that point or not, this is when you pay $136 to eliminate

0:51:20 the or get rid of your recycling where a lot of it may be land-filled somewhere else.

0:51:25 That's a tough decision to make.

0:51:28 I don't disagree with you, it's going to get land-filled, probably better put it in our land-filled

0:51:32 in some of the else's.

0:51:34 But the issues are the market will get fixed.

0:51:38 either we're going to clean up our recycling and they're going to pay top

0:51:43 dollar for it again or we're going to create our own processing plants whether

0:51:49 it be in America or other countries that are going to pay top dollar for it. At the end of the day, if we don't clean up our product, that's never going to happen.

0:51:57 So it really starts and ends with contamination levels and what we're going to do about it.

0:52:02 And if we want to ride this out and see if the market improves over time, it very well may.

0:52:07 I know Boy City Boise has exactly the same recycling, the commingal that we have and I

0:52:23 talked on Channel 7 news here, that's when I first realized this was a problem, they were

0:52:27 facing the same issue, they made a decision what they're going to do with their

0:52:31 They basically last I heard, and they're having...

0:52:35 Council has not voted on as far as I will wear yet.

0:52:39 What they determined is we either need a significant price increase to pay for this,

0:52:43 or get rid of the mixed paper was another option, and nothing else just recycled the other materials,

0:52:49 or just scrapped the program until the market comes back.

0:52:52 I'm not faced with the same situation we are, but I do not believe as far as I know that they have made it sick.

0:52:58 And a couple other folks here, Suzanne Hawkins.

0:53:04 Thank you.

0:53:05 So I'm kind of started to answer where I was going with this.

0:53:10 Is it possible for us to temporarily go from streamline

0:53:14 to separating our recycled goods again

0:53:17 so that you're getting a cleaner product from the end user?

0:53:20 You can.

0:53:21 The problem is we have such small volume

0:53:24 that I did ask this question to Western recycling

0:53:26 because I agree it's there.

0:53:28 other alternatives, profit, or at least most of profit back to the material or the commodities

0:53:34 that were sent in.

0:53:35 And the problem that we run into is if you do break it down to two or three high value

0:53:40 commodities, it still ends up being shipped to Boise.

0:53:43 They're just going to throw it on their floor with all the material from Boise and

0:53:47 from the sort of line anyway, so they have as much money to really go down the road.

0:53:54 So that wasn't the answer I was looking for, because I agree with that.

0:53:58 So the next question would be then, is it possible temporarily to have a fee for those

0:54:10 who choose to recycle since the costs are up and it's going to cost more and those that

0:54:15 choose to not recycle at this time then can opt out of that fee and we can unfortunately

0:54:22 keep it here in our landfill instead of paying to ship it to other landfills?

0:54:26 That's a possible, I couldn't give you the number on that, but yeah, I think there's always options that

0:54:31 I've been studying recycling since the military and helped set up the recycling center in Pelcatelle.

0:55:08 that was 1970, and one thing that has never changed in recycling as a market is all over

0:55:14 the place, you know, better than we do. I would bet that the scouts right here, without

0:55:19 exception, have grown up learning from their parents in school about not littering about

0:55:24 recycling. It is so much within our country's DNA now that I would fight whatever, whatever

0:55:33 remains most of them legal to keep the recycling program going.

0:55:39 The data supplied in this report indicates since 2010 we have kept 29 million pounds of

0:55:48 material out of the landfill.

0:55:52 That is incredible, 14 and a half thousand tons.

0:55:56 I would guess if we come back a year from now the market is going to be in a different

0:56:00 situation, it could be worse, it could be better. I don't think as feasible as I

0:56:05 understand the economics for you to go down the block and there's one that

0:56:12 wants to recycle and six that don't do this terribly inefficient for your man

0:56:16 power, for your for your gas. So I would really suggest the council look at

0:56:22 this as an interim measure and accept the rec- accept the recommendation of an

0:56:27 an increase in our dipping fees or recycling fees of 62 cents a month which

0:56:33 amounts to $7.44 a year and review this again when you come back to us or

0:56:40 within here. So that'd be my recommendation. Stopping recycling, I just

0:56:48 since stopped breathing before I quit recycling. Mr. Mayor? Yes. Because the

0:56:55 the potential fee to offset that exceeds the 5% threshold,

0:57:00 there would be the required public hearing process

0:57:03 to be able to go forward to the council.

0:57:06 Well, they could instruct staff,

0:57:07 if that would be the majority will,

0:57:10 to start that process and complete the public hearing.

0:57:14 Also, notice as for the public hearing,

0:57:16 you would not be able to implement

0:57:17 that rate improvement or increase this evening.

0:57:22 So gentlemen, so everyone's lights are coming on here again.

0:57:25 I'm going to assume that you had some more presentation that we maybe jumped in the middle

0:57:29 of with questions.

0:57:30 I just wanted to make sure that we weren't sidetracking maybe getting to a point where

0:57:40 you had some recommendations, some options to look at before we get too far down telling

0:57:45 you what each of us individually wants to do.

0:57:48 Well I will say that yes we have some options that we had discussed and we could certainly

0:57:54 put out there but our primary interest tonight given the complexity of this

0:57:58 question and the impact it can have was to address the questions council may

0:58:03 have so we can proceed with questions and then we do have some options or we

0:58:08 can go the other direction. Well actually if they've got some options I'd like to hear the

0:58:13 question. Okay these are broad options with there's a lot of room in

0:58:20 between. The question about opt-in, opt-out is a good one. The question then would

0:58:26 become controlling the billing process and the rates for those individuals who

0:58:33 want to be included in the process. The pilot program showed us that you get

0:58:40 some people out there that fortunately not many who try the small can to save

0:58:44 money which is one thing we anticipated happening and then find out that no

0:58:49 extra bags were allowed and so then they go back to the other one with a

0:58:54 recycling issue we have cart concerns anyway and so it would just be

0:59:00 interesting to see people opt out and their neighbor opts in and so they're

0:59:04 running over there filling up the camp. There's all kinds of things we could

0:59:08 see. The spectrum is obviously continue as we are with the collection at each

0:59:16 residents and ended into the recycling process. Another option, and this is just

0:59:25 me brainstorming because we knew you'd need to see some things, one of them is to

0:59:31 go to the other end of the scale but continue using the recycle carts. One

0:59:38 thing that was real apparent in talking to Jeff, there's no place to store 14 or

0:59:43 15,000 recycle carts. They don't stack well as they are currently constructed. And so,

0:59:52 leave them with the resident, could be the answer. They've got them already, they'll just

0:59:56 leave them next to their house. They couldn't put garbage in them. So, then there becomes

1:00:02 the issue of the calls we get because the garbage wasn't emptied from their cart while

1:00:08 it was in the orange lid cart. If we held to the recycling methodology and you handle

1:00:19 the loads that we are currently experiencing, but you allow that recycle truck when the

1:00:26 market conditions dictate, to continue going to the transfer station and just dumping it

1:00:33 into the landfill. We try to hold the line on, this is how you need to fill that cart so

1:00:39 so that when the market turns, everybody still is participating, they're still doing

1:00:43 it that way, but we have stepped from $136 a ton to the $37.50 at our landfill. It does

1:00:51 not answer the question, you, Councilman, talking to him, just brought up. It would be

1:00:56 going in the landfill, but the cost factor would be addressed to some degree. We would

1:01:03 have about $70,000 of increased tipping fees with that using last year's

1:01:09 tonnage. In the middle, there's leave the carts with the people in

1:01:15 abandoned the process altogether, but what do you do with the extras? In

1:01:22 visiting with Travis briefly is like everybody's allowed five to eight bags

1:01:26 of additional garbage, so that was how they would handle any excess capacity

1:01:31 than their blue cards. Within that range there may be other options, but that is the spectrum

1:01:38 in my vision. Just so you don't end up with the driver having to get out of the truck to

1:01:44 keep you the recycle card even though it's all going to the landfill. We are certainly

1:01:49 open to suggestions, thoughts and questions.

1:01:54 Greg Lanting. Well, but I didn't hear the options. The 62 cents that Chris talked about.

1:02:00 Would that be a different race to take us into the year here so we can kind of see where we're at with things that things turn around?

1:02:09 That would be an improvement.

1:02:11 What that is is the rate calculated using last year's number of customers, $14,810,000 and the tonnage, $1,846,000.

1:02:29 And the cost factor, as average, I think she was using that $9,859, was $110,000 for last year's recycling, was the rounded cost number.

1:02:46 And I think that's where the 62 cent comes from under a cost chair with PSI.

1:02:53 And part of that is, I mean, I understand that PSI, we signed up on a tenure contract

1:03:01 with you folks in good faith, in your side, and if we just quit recycling, that's not

1:03:09 going to do you butt trucks, you butt cans, you butt everything that we understand as

1:03:15 our partner.

1:03:16 And I'll use that term because almost as far as vendors are a partner, we need to recognize

1:03:21 that your costs aren't going to go away or for your equipment so you purchase so.

1:03:26 And I'm willing to go with Chris's process to at least have the public hearing.

1:03:32 Maybe we'll have some additional information by then.

1:03:34 Maybe we'll know what Boise's doing by then.

1:03:37 But I draw the line a little different where Chris says,

1:03:42 I don't want to be shipping stuff to Portland just to be putting a landfill.

1:03:46 I mean that landfills landfill to me.

1:03:48 I'll say that again.

1:03:49 That doesn't make any sense to me.

1:03:53 And right now we've just finally...

1:03:57 I live in a condominium that had to recycling tell

1:04:01 about four months ago. One of the condos

1:04:05 decided to pay themselves to have the

1:04:09 carts down there. And I've been utilizing it, but also

1:04:13 I'm not sure which plastic I can use. My eyesides get bad. I can't read the number

1:04:17 on the bottom. And so I'm wondering if we need to, if we do make this, we do make

1:04:22 me need to make an adjustment on that. We just don't take plastic. That seems to be

1:04:26 one of the ones that's hard to get rid of at this point. And this is maybe if we

1:04:31 do do this, makes some adjustments. So we're making it easier for people not to

1:04:36 contaminate because I'm sure if I can't read the number on the bottom of that

1:04:40 bottom, I throw it in or I'm contaminated. And if it's not in that number range. And I

1:04:43 I don't even want to be contaminated so I'm not putting plastic in there right now just for that reason

1:04:48 So I'd be willing to go with the public hearing to see and maybe by if this is gonna take us two weeks to advertise that

1:04:55 I'm sure that maybe we could find out what some of our larger neighbors who do it the same way we do

1:05:02 What they're trying to do and maybe we can have a cooperative effort to

1:05:06 To help solve this issue

1:05:08 I do want to be a good partner as well, but I cannot justify the cost raise to our citizens

1:05:18 at this point in time.

1:05:21 We have published our rates and I think we owe that to our constituents to try to hold

1:05:26 the line.

1:05:27 Bill's idea about still collecting the recycling, but when the costs are too high, taking it

1:05:33 to the landfill would be more in line with something that I could support at this point

1:05:37 time. So just to kind of give you a feel for what I'm thinking as you're working

1:05:43 through this for the next couple weeks, I don't see how I could support price

1:05:47 increase to our citizens. I would just say and this is way above my head so I

1:05:56 know Travis will weigh in. But if we took the $79,000 from last year and the

1:06:04 number of customers that works out to about half of what the 62 cent cost share

1:06:09 would be if we are going to try to recoup those costs which is the nature of this

1:06:14 particular department in the city budget. We bill out rates that will cover PSI's

1:06:21 costs, other item of solid waste costs, and the administrative fees for managing

1:06:27 contracts process.

1:06:30 So Mr. Mayor, members of the council, Lori Race is obviously not able to be with us today and she's, we'd say hello to her because her and her husband Terry are watching us live from Utah.

1:06:52 And she and I have been kind of texting back and forth and what is important to a couple

1:06:57 of points is number one at $136 a ton.

1:07:01 The fee that is included in that budget estimate is not right.

1:07:07 In fact, it's low.

1:07:09 And one of the challenges that we would have on a 50-50 cost sharing is if you just take

1:07:16 a look at the recycling fees that are presented, it is incredibly volatile.

1:07:20 those fees are going up and down and for us to be able to understand what that 50-50 split

1:07:27 would be, we would have to aim on the high side. And that would be more than $0.66 and

1:07:34 the $7.44 that was included in that package. I think it's important to recognize that

1:07:40 even if you split that in half, which is one of the proposals that I heard that we would

1:07:46 cost to share the expense of recycling.

1:07:50 In some cases, that's four times the amount of money

1:07:56 that we're currently would spend to send that to the landfill.

1:08:00 And I think that that needs to be put into consideration.

1:08:04 But we look at the value of the recycling program,

1:08:07 and we look at the momentum that we've moved this community

1:08:10 forward in single stream recycling.

1:08:12 I also think it is important, and I would not

1:08:14 be filling my duties and responsibilities to share with you that that would be

1:08:18 costing you and our rate payers nearly two times what we would normally pay to

1:08:24 send that to and through the Southern Idaho Solid Waste System. We can prepare a

1:08:33 public hearing notice for a rate adjustment but I think what staff is

1:08:39 looking for first is what are the range of things that you would find palatable. If you were to say

1:08:49 an increase is not palatable, we would go back and carve an adjustment to the contract that

1:08:56 accommodated a rate was palatable. If there was a number or an increase that you would be more

1:09:02 comfortable with, we would then also go back and negotiate a contract that would fit within

1:09:09 those parameters as well. But I think it's one of the things that we wanted to do tonight was not

1:09:15 necessarily come with a series of planned options, but really to kind of gauge your thoughts in

1:09:21 terms of a direction moving forward, recognizing there are other steps, recognizing that time is

1:09:27 of the essence for PSA, because at $136 a ton, this is eating into their corporate profits,

1:09:36 And in addition to that, we also know that there are citizens who are probably

1:09:41 fairly passionate about this on one side or the other, and understanding how they

1:09:47 would like for us to serve as probably an important piece to that equation.

1:09:50 I think Travis could read a couple of, I guess, just some feedback on what the

1:09:59 actual options are, because I heard four in there, and I'll then opt out, talked

1:10:05 about all of the potential negatives to that, raise the fee, dump recycling material into

1:10:12 the landfill, and then, well, I guess that would be actually only three, because then

1:10:17 just abandoning recycling in general would be dumping it all into the landfill. I guess

1:10:23 there'd be two there potentially. Once costs go down, we can continue recycling, or China

1:10:28 opens up again, or we just get rid of it. Is that pretty much our options?

1:10:33 Yes, okay, I mean I would like to see what I know the 62 cents

1:10:41 I'd like to see what people a public hearing ultimately. I mean I know for myself

1:10:49 I've I think recycling is important. I think you pay for it in the long run

1:10:55 No matter what because we're gonna be filling up that that landfill faster

1:10:59 Having to pay for a new landfill, but I'd like to see what the public has to say on that personally

1:11:06 Instead of just saying, hey, it's a volatile market right now, we don't know what six months down the road looks like.

1:11:13 I'm concerned if we just say, hey, we're done with it right now.

1:11:17 Now, if it does flip, are we able to renegotiate or is this 62 cents?

1:11:23 Once we've negotiated it, it's done, it's set and it's gone for another two years,

1:11:27 or two, whatever.

1:11:29 If it does flip, are we able to say, hey, let's come back down?

1:11:32 down. So my understanding of the request is that this is not going to go directly to

1:11:42 PSI. This would actually go to offset cost. And so this is a fee that would be above and

1:11:50 beyond the normal contract. And I think it would be more reflective of the market. And

1:11:54 we would evaluate that on a periodic basis is I think the best I could share with you.

1:12:04 We do not need a public hearing to lower the rate.

1:12:07 Idaho Code requires a public hearing anytime you increase the rate greater than 5%.

1:12:14 Part of my concern is trying to understand this market.

1:12:19 I would hate to be coming to you every other week asking for a rate adjustment because what's

1:12:24 important about sanitation is it is an enterprise fund which is fancy government language for

1:12:30 saying that it has to operate like its own independent small business and it must cover

1:12:35 the revenues to be able to cover its costs and so we need to make sure that the revenue

1:12:41 streams are appropriate to cover the costs that are going outside of and to support that

1:12:48 department.

1:12:50 Thank you.

1:12:51 All right.

1:12:58 Thank you.

1:12:59 Is there a price point where it just becomes like I think we're already past it right now

1:13:04 But is there one if it should retreat back is there a price point where you can survive as a company and not be

1:13:12 subsidizing it to the point where it's no longer profitable due to a situation to unfals

1:13:17 I mean or recycling it when I'm trying to come up with a number that if we

1:13:22 Set yep, there's been the discussion and Bill is one of the possibilities is that when the mount is over a certain amount

1:13:29 It's not feasible and especially if we find it's going on la villain

1:13:33 that may be we continue to collect it just as we have we just take it to landfill because it's just economically what we have to do is there a dollar number in there $85 $70 you have a number in your mind?

1:13:48 Well, obviously in 2017 we accepted 100% of that burden with knowledge that yes, in this

1:13:56 tract you will sit out at me and negotiate by sharing what we do with the program from there.

1:14:03 So obviously at $110,000 a year that is way too much for us to continue to absorb that expense.

1:14:11 Is there a number that makes sense?

1:14:15 I don't know, I can't really tell you what that magic number is, but at 110, if we could have had cost sharing last year.

1:14:23 I mean that would have been fair for both parties. I really do, I think.

1:14:27 Then we're fine. That was much built into the...

1:14:31 I'm saying it was all built into the raid, but unfortunately that was.

1:14:35 of that was. So with cost sharing in 2017 I'd say that would be fine but at $136 a ton,

1:14:42 yeah I think we're on the upside down again. So even with cost sharing. So that number I guess

1:14:49 fat to throw it out there maybe it is $15 a ton per party. That's a real tough one.

1:14:56 Well that allows me to ask the same question to Travis or Bill possibly.

1:15:00 If what number is the city able to handle with our current rate without an increase of cost sharing, is it $100 or 10? Is it $60 or 10? Do we know that number?

1:15:17 So it's close to zero, because what's important

1:15:21 about the Enterprise Fund is prior to the budgeting process,

1:15:24 we know all of the inputs that are going

1:15:27 to cause expenditures moving forward.

1:15:31 We negotiated the contract with PSI.

1:15:34 We understand what that is.

1:15:36 Josh, with Southern Ed and Solid Waste shares with us,

1:15:40 what those tipping fees are going to be,

1:15:41 and we can generally program what those tons are going

1:15:44 to be, and really one of the things that's important

1:15:47 recognizes the sanitation fund is a dollar-in and dollar-out program. It is not one of those

1:15:53 things that has significant overhead costs. It doesn't have any significant future

1:15:58 anticipated capital needs. So we don't assess a rate or a fee that is designed to

1:16:05 capture additional resources above what we believe the billings are going to be for that year.

1:16:11 And so when we plug in that number at the beginning, we took the contract

1:16:17 And we plug that number in. We didn't say, oh, and if there's this opportunity or this cause or whatever that may be, that we would have additional resources to be able to support programs.

1:16:31 So any adjustment staff would recommend that we cover that and that you would increase that fee accordingly to be able to cover those costs.

1:16:41 I will say that there is a level of cash reserves in the bank right now, as a result of past

1:16:51 systems and past collections, I would strongly urge the Council not to rely on cash reserves

1:17:00 to cover ongoing operating expenses, that's not good financial management, and all that

1:17:07 does is delay what should be done in the beginning, and that would be to make sure that the department

1:17:13 and cover its costs.

1:17:14 But I could just throw the one up there again that's the whole thing.

1:17:18 How much we were, it's been costing to recycle over this last year.

1:17:24 Yeah, there we go.

1:17:28 The one thing I would throw out there just to remove any mystery about the 50-50 is I believe

1:17:34 that was the revenue share back when this was actually generating a profit.

1:17:40 And that's where the 50-50 kind of comes in, but the contract does say negotiate a cost

1:17:50 share.

1:17:51 Doesn't give a percentage or a number.

1:17:55 Jeff, a question for you.

1:17:56 So you don't operate in a silo here, what are other companies within your corporation

1:18:01 doing in communities that are facing the same challenge?

1:18:04 They're really kind of going down the same path that the art company actually does own

1:18:11 several recycling facilities in Washington and Oregon and like I said as of now nobody

1:18:16 is actually saying anything to the landfill but it is something that they're entertaining

1:18:21 at least with some of the the items out there at least until they figure out what the market

1:18:26 is going to be. Like I said nobody's done it as of what I read most recently within

1:18:32 the last week is all that product has been sold whether it be H.E.A. or a lot of other

1:18:38 countries that are buying this product right now, obviously at a significantly reduced price

1:18:43 of what China was paying, so it is all the product has been purchased at least for February's body.

1:18:49 Now they're very concerned with what they're going to do with March, where's that going to go?

1:18:53 Because obviously those smaller countries don't have the same needs that a large China does,

1:18:58 so they do fill up their breaking point on it. People are ordering this material,

1:19:04 more pain for this material than it's going to have to be landfills.

1:19:08 As of right now, all the material is being at least sent to a country, and that's the

1:19:12 contamination that's being recycled, but it's at significantly lower rates.

1:19:17 So that is a touching health subject right now, I mean, really nice.

1:19:23 Thank you, Suzanne Ockens.

1:19:25 In the Magic Valley, are there any other cities besides Twin Falls that is trying to

1:19:30 do the recycling program like this or are we just kind of on our own? I mean, do any

1:19:35 of our neighbors, are they working on this issue? I know we talked about Boise,

1:19:40 but closer to home. As of right now, no other communities have a recycling program

1:19:46 where everybody's dissipating or at least has the option to participate. There are,

1:19:52 we offer some recycling in the county where people can opt in, opt out. I suppose it's

1:19:58 It's a totally subscription based and we do have some people that as far as an actual city in the Magic Valley area

1:20:04 and no one falls to the only one.

1:20:06 So you have made Optin off out work in the county, but in the city it seems to be more difficult.

1:20:11 Well in the county obviously we don't offer it everywhere.

1:20:15 So we'll offer it in certain neighborhoods where obviously we're already very nearby and we can cover our costs that way.

1:20:22 But if not enough people sign up then obviously we stop observing those areas.

1:20:26 really just depends. Like I said, it's really a cost is reduced based on volume

1:20:32 once again. The more people you have, opt in obviously that drives that cost down, but if you have to, right, the 100% of the city had to win falls to pick up 10% of the customers, they carry out 100% of the expense per...

1:20:46 I'm not catching that much.

1:20:50 I'm catching this recycling.

1:20:52 Is it catching?

1:20:54 I'm not catching them actually, they have a recycle program up there, and it is subsidized by the trash rates.

1:21:00 They do have a, they do have a recycle program in, it's Haley, though.

1:21:06 It has a residential.

1:21:10 Thank you.

1:21:13 I was talking.

1:21:14 Bill, would you go back to that spreadsheet to cost revenue by a year?

1:21:19 I know just a real unusual calendar 2015.

1:21:24 We had a very large change from revenue to expanse, do you know what drove that?

1:21:32 We went from 69,000 benefit valuation to about 3,000 in 2015.

1:21:41 Yes, so as far as that spreadsheet, basically what it's trying to say there is the cost saved

1:21:47 is that it basically takes the tons of three cycle material and then just times that by

1:21:52 the landfill costs that is 68,693 and then obviously the revenue that was the

1:21:58 cost actually recycled so obviously we paid out of pocket $65,000 to

1:22:05 recycle it but we saved if it would have gotten the landfill cost 68,000 so you

1:22:10 still have that uptick of $29.5.

1:22:12 That's when the market the recycling markets and expense not a

1:22:21 I would agree with the comment that was made earlier in Travis. I think you actually made

1:22:40 it that there are likely strong feelings on both ends or throughout the spectrum on this

1:22:46 in the community and I do think I would have a difficult time tonight making a decision

1:22:51 about where we wanted to go, but also understanding that this is a rather urgent issue to come

1:23:00 to some conclusion about but think some opportunity to gather some public input would be helpful.

1:23:11 Whether that's in the context of a actual hearing for a potential fee increase or not,

1:23:15 I don't know, I think that's probably some discussion we need to have.

1:23:22 The trouble is if we don't have specifics to offer the public, we're going to have very little turnout.

1:23:27 People won't hold on to respond or react in last week.

1:23:30 At least, remind the scope of options that have been presented here.

1:23:35 I would like to just look again at those options and see what the real impact is on number wise,

1:23:41 because I think that people are looking at it and thinking, well, it's going to be 62% increase,

1:23:46 but what if we abandon it and what's the cost associated with that and have those numbers

1:23:50 So that, at least for myself, I can look at them and say, these are the numbers with everyone.

1:23:57 Every option.

1:23:58 I would like to see that.

1:23:59 Yeah, I would agree.

1:24:02 I mean, I think even if it's in a large context to be there, we're going to do away with curbside

1:24:09 recycling.

1:24:10 We're going to keep doing it and that's going to have some cost associated with it that we're,

1:24:14 I don't even know if there's in the middle.

1:24:17 I mean, I suppose maybe changes to the program, but again, understanding gets difficult to

1:24:23 to do the math here because even looking at this spreadsheet that's up now, it was a $110,000

1:24:28 cost to recycle last year. However, we saved almost $70,000 in tipping fees by not sending

1:24:35 that to the landfill. So, you know, it has a difficult concept to help people understand

1:24:43 but it goes to Councilman Tocquepin's point earlier, there's a value in recycling period.

1:24:50 if it's still a negative number, it's $70,000 less than what it is the cost of the program.

1:24:57 So I would like to have an opportunity again, even if it's just the broad spectrum to say,

1:25:03 you keep doing the program and there's going to be a cost to that, or we abandon it and

1:25:09 start throwing it in the landfill, and actually there's going to be a cost to that too, right,

1:25:14 because we don't have increased tipping fees budgeted next year.

1:25:19 Well, I thought I would like to think there is a possible middle ground that we pick a number

1:25:28 and we say if the cost of sending our recycle somewhere is above this level, then we allow

1:25:37 BSI to go ahead and collect it as if it's a recycle, but if the number is just too high

1:25:46 and it goes to landfill anywhere and when the number comes back they can start sending it.

1:25:51 I think there's possibly a number in there that would be allow us to roll with the current economy as things are working, the economy is recycling at me.

1:26:03 Is that something we can-

1:26:08 We're trying to put PSI out of business either way, so it goes too high and this will make them.

1:26:12 We keep making them recycle and then we're cost sharing with them and then we're just completely get rid of it and all of a sudden they've got all these caps of costs, they have no way to recover.

1:26:24 So I'm not sure either extreme is a fair to our partner.

1:26:28 I think it has to be fair to our partner.

1:26:30 It has to be somewhere in the middle, which may include a small increase, but give them

1:26:35 some options as they can follow the market and know what's occurring as it goes along.

1:26:42 And I will explain that spreadsheet a little bit further.

1:26:45 That 69,000 is the savings to the city, say if that material was to go to landfill.

1:26:51 We didn't say that.

1:26:52 It's not like we said.

1:26:53 And we just accepted the entire burden of the $110,000, so.

1:26:57 I agree that, I understand that there are real dollars on that shirt, and there are value dollars on that shirt, but what I'm saying is, if we were to have sent everything to the landfill instead of recycling it, you would not have had a $110,000 cost to recycling, but our customers would have had a $70,000 cost to dump it in the landfill.

1:27:20 I guess before we have asked for a public hearing, public meeting, can we get some more

1:27:30 information?

1:27:31 I mean, those numbers that you guys can provide to us to look at those different options so

1:27:35 we can decide, hey, this is what we're thinking of as a council and then-

1:27:39 That's just a landfill cost for that 29 million pounds that we didn't.

1:27:44 Exactly.

1:27:45 But that would be.

1:27:46 Exactly.

1:27:47 That's probably relevant in the formula.

1:27:49 And Travis, I appreciate that this is a little bit of a shot in the dark on what's the number

1:27:54 look like in the coming months at a minimum if it's the numbers that we know for February.

1:28:02 How can we wait that?

1:28:06 Yes.

1:28:07 We can put together some numbers for some of this.

1:28:11 I know that as this conversation kept being delayed,

1:28:18 The SI's concern was entering into January, February, and now are some 32 or so thousand

1:28:29 hours, maybe more.

1:28:31 And so that, again, has been said several times, that is their concern.

1:28:35 Our certainly is the impact of the citizens, and in producing more numbers for you, we

1:28:41 probably can better define what that breakpoint might be, somewhere between what it costs to

1:28:46 recycle it and what it cost to put it out in the landfill. Maybe our landfill fees is the break.

1:28:53 You've got to pay those either way, but then how do we make that decision as to when the loads go where?

1:29:01 We can we can do that. Thank you. What is that in a week? Two weeks. Yeah, I think that we can

1:29:20 be prepared with the numbers to kind of roll forward next week. What I'm trying to do is maybe

1:29:25 trying to think of a simultaneous process because we can always begin the

1:29:32 process of setting and announcing a public hearing to have a rate adjustment

1:29:38 and we could publish the highest possible rate which means that any point

1:29:47 below that even zero is what can be authorized by the city council. So we

1:29:55 could start that process. My hesitation is we would want individuals to come and share

1:30:07 their thoughts at a public hearing. And if they came either tonight or they came next week

1:30:13 or they came in a subsequent week, you know, what they have felt like they had the opportunity

1:30:18 and so to really engage in a constructive dialogue that was complete.

1:30:24 We offer options to be a lot more relevant than just asking them to speak yes or no without

1:30:32 understanding the spectrum.

1:30:37 So next week we could certainly put together the options.

1:30:40 We could come forward and then the subsequent week.

1:30:45 I think it may not be the subsequent week.

1:30:48 It would probably be the week of the 12th.

1:30:50 That right now would probably be the week of the next week, the next week, the week of the

1:30:54 19th would probably be the soonest that we could do a potential hearing.

1:31:00 And the council could always, depending upon what you heard next week, just elect to move

1:31:06 forward with the hearing, not move forward with the hearing, depending upon whether or

1:31:10 not a rate adjustment was needed, depending upon the options that you reviewed.

1:31:15 Could we throw this on our social media and our webpage and maybe a survey monthly or just

1:31:19 try to get ahead of it that way, and see what kind of comments we could possibly get back

1:31:24 on people's feelings on the recycling program?

1:31:29 We certainly could.

1:31:30 I've always found it to be much more advantageous for people to come, to send us emails, to do

1:31:37 those types of things.

1:31:39 The problem with Survey Monkey sometimes is you could have individuals that would go

1:31:44 out and troll that, that they would maybe over-represent the, they're, or over-amplified

1:31:54 their voice.

1:31:55 But we can, these are only try other means, but we would never want individuals to believe

1:32:01 that commenting on social media is a more, or better means than actually participating

1:32:08 here in government in that process.

1:32:10 Thank you.

1:32:11 So if we think we could get some analyzed options together to have an opportunity for

1:32:21 public input next week, then maybe simultaneously be thinking about if we were to go down a rate

1:32:30 change pathway, how does that maybe simultaneously happen, my comment would be to the public who's

1:32:38 watching this or listening to it or watching it on the news tonight or reading

1:32:41 into the paper, we want your input.

1:32:46 I would prefer you to just give me a call or send me an email.

1:32:49 I don't need to go fish around Facebook to try to find out what you think about recycling.

1:32:53 So I would encourage you to get in touch with us on the council and staff and to

1:32:58 participate in that opportunity next week.

1:33:01 I do think that it's a twofold question.

1:33:04 One, I think it's a philosophical question about what we're going to do as a community

1:33:08 when it comes to recycling, much to councilman talking to this point earlier. Secondly,

1:33:13 there is a cost factor to it, but I think we need to think about that in the cost now

1:33:18 or the cost later of actually not doing it. So, that would be my encouragement that people

1:33:26 be involved and share your comments.

1:33:29 Mr. Mayor, I do believe that individuals did come this evening for the opportunity to maybe

1:33:38 share their thoughts as well.

1:33:40 Okay, so I only have, so Josh Bartlemay, you're signed up on the sheet, did you want to speak?

1:33:47 Yep, and the one is Dave Doweller, that's on here and I don't think Dave wanted to speak

1:33:55 either, so if there are others who are here who would like to come up and share your two

1:34:01 sense with the limited information we have at the moment, you're more than welcome to do

1:34:05 so, otherwise we will have a chance for that next week, so did you want to come forward

1:34:10 If you would please state your name and whether you're a resident or property owner in the City of Twin Falls for the record.

1:34:17 My name is Wade Olred, I am a resident and a property owner.

1:34:22 One of the things that I would like to ask is we talked about Western waste and what they're able to take.

1:34:29 Where I work, we were able to move away from PSI and find another partner that not only paid us the rates that we were getting before,

1:34:38 but they give us just as good a service.

1:34:41 So I don't know if that one partner is the only one out there for PSI,

1:34:47 but the partner we deal with and are dealing with,

1:34:50 I talked to them today and they can take an additional 1200 tons a month.

1:34:53 So there's other partners that I would ask that we look at

1:34:57 and look to to help us with this. Not just the one and done

1:35:01 and it's $7 a year, $10 a year, $20 a year,

1:35:04 but maybe there's other and better partners out there

1:35:07 Or PSI to descend this information to

1:35:17 I was talking about the middleman

1:35:25 I'm just saying that there's other partners that maybe PSI can work with

1:35:30 Well certainly share that with him. I did notice in some of the news coverage from Boise for some of the streams

1:35:36 They've tried to find other other markets to get rid of that. So that's a good point. Thank you. Thank you

1:35:43 Yes

1:35:46 Right smell that president known as well

1:35:55 Just the things we heard what would the 5% increase be and would that be enough?

1:36:01 In the cost sharing offset it so you don't have to have a public hearing someone's thinking I

1:36:08 Personally if they if you say cut out plastics that was one option someone I kind of mentioned I stopped recycling

1:36:14 I'd just say forget it altogether, there's no point.

1:36:18 I also know that part of this is the issue.

1:36:21 It's not just trying to not buying it, it's what their government's forcing them to do.

1:36:25 And the day-to-day where I sell toilet paper and paper towels and all those,

1:36:29 we've had different issues that we've found out in the economy,

1:36:32 and they've shut them down, they're switching from electricity to natural gas

1:36:35 and a whole bunch of other factors and recycling that.

1:36:39 The other thing is, can we stop picking up

1:36:42 And those that want to voluntarily put it in bins,

1:36:45 put bins out where we can take our plastics

1:36:48 and take our papers and whatever else,

1:36:50 glass that needs to be recycled.

1:36:52 Those are a couple of other options we have.

1:36:56 Thank you.

1:36:59 Is there anyone else who would like to chime in on this one?

1:37:07 OK, anything else from the council?

1:37:13 Suzanne Hopkins.

1:37:14 Thank you.

1:37:15 So I got my annual leather from Paint Magic

1:37:19 that they're forming their teams.

1:37:21 And I really feel like the last four years I've been leading and taking charge,

1:37:26 but I'd really appreciate it if somebody else on the council might have some interest to step up.

1:37:31 I don't know that I have the time this summer to do it again,

1:37:34 but I hate to see the City of Twin Falls not participate in that organization.

1:37:40 So if anybody's interested, I can send you the contact information.

1:37:49 Thank you.

1:37:51 There's anything else from that?

1:37:52 Let me back out.

1:37:53 Is there anything else on the recycling issue from the council?

1:37:55 Be here if I know.

1:37:57 That's okay.

1:37:58 Staff, do you have enough direction on where you think we need to go there?

1:38:01 Just want to make sure we buttoned that one out.

1:38:03 So let me back up to another opportunity for general public input.

1:38:11 If there's anyone from the public who wishes to address the council on an item that wasn't on the agenda tonight.

1:38:16 And now it's your chance to come forward when any other reports from the council need none.

1:38:28 and then, Travis, the announcements, all right?

1:38:31 What that meeting is adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, February 26, 2018. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:38:47.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    0fc484e5c69650f3a6fef3649ff73cc25a480afdda4b91698fae79e21c415e55
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a a204cbe6850888c03378d45d59b551a57241d7765f9fb3c8e338e4affab69018
    part02.m4a 208cfc0f00f50581ea28e852098bea58673d1d3b8d3652519f7f1e1bfd0e67eb
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    c64197b564c61fed03149bee2499c2c6be329a11d7913a2336390ec06a508dad

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file