City Council meeting
Monday, April 30, 2018
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on file
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:00:00 City Council meeting for Monday, April 30th.
0:00:03 We're just a few minutes behind,
0:00:04 so that's about 10 after five,
0:00:06 as we had a little bit of a technical glitch
0:00:08 getting our agendas pulled up.
0:00:10 We do have a quorum of the council here.
0:00:12 All seven members are here this evening.
0:00:14 The next item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.
0:00:16 Those of you wishing to join us, please rise.
0:00:41 Amendments to our agenda this evening.
0:00:43 Mr. Mayor, it's the council that are in no amendments.
0:00:46 Thank you.
0:00:47 And next on the agenda are proclamations,
0:00:50 and we have two this evening.
0:00:52 but the first is for mental health month.
0:00:55 Whereas mental health is essential
0:00:57 to everyone's overall health and well-being,
0:01:00 and whereas all Americans experience times of difficulty
0:01:03 and stress in their lives,
0:01:05 and whereas prevention is an effective way
0:01:07 to reduce the burden of mental health conditions,
0:01:10 and whereas there is a strong research
0:01:12 that diet, exercise, sleep, and stress management
0:01:16 and help all Americans protect their health and well-being,
0:01:19 and whereas mental health conditions
0:01:21 real and prevalent in our nation. And whereas with effective treatment, those
0:01:25 individuals with mental health conditions can recover and lead full
0:01:28 productive lives. And whereas each business, school, government agency, healthcare
0:01:34 provider, organization, and citizen shares the burden of mental health
0:01:38 problems and has a responsibility to promote mental, mental wellness, and
0:01:43 support prevention efforts. Therefore, I, Sean Berriger, do hereby proclaim May 2018
0:01:48 as Mental Health Month in Twin Falls, Idaho.
0:01:52 As the mayor, I also call upon the citizens,
0:01:54 government agencies, public and private institutions,
0:01:57 businesses, and schools in Twin Falls
0:01:59 to recommit our community to increasing awareness
0:02:03 and understanding of mental websites our citizens
0:02:05 can take to protect their mental health
0:02:07 and the need for appropriate and accessible services
0:02:10 for all people with mental health conditions.
0:02:23 I would just really like to encourage everyone
0:02:25 to come to our events for the month of May.
0:02:27 We have a 5K race on May 5th.
0:02:31 We have a wellness banquet at the end of the month.
0:02:33 You can nominate someone that if you know of some of this
0:02:35 overcoming mental health challenges that we also have
0:02:42 Rudy's and some other places sponsoring events for us.
0:02:46 So I just encourage everyone to get out there.
0:02:50 Thank you.
0:02:51 Our next proclamation this evening is for Older Americans Month.
0:03:02 Whereas the City of Twin Falls includes countless
0:03:04 older Americans who enrich and strengthen our community.
0:03:08 And whereas the City of Twin Falls, in partnership with the Twin Falls Senior Center, is committed
0:03:12 to engaging and supporting older adults, their families, and caregivers, and whereas we acknowledge
0:03:18 the importance of taking part in activities that promote physical, mental, and emotional
0:03:23 well-being, no matter your age.
0:03:25 And whereas the City of Twin Falls in partnership with the Twin Falls Senior Center can enrich the
0:03:30 lives of individuals of every age by promoting home and community-based services that support
0:03:35 independent living, involving older adults in community planning, events and other activities,
0:03:41 and providing opportunities for older adults to work, volunteer, learn, lead and mentor.
0:03:47 Therefore, I, Sean Berriger, Mayor of Twin Falls, do hereby proclaim May 2018 to be Older Americans
0:03:53 Month. I urge every resident to take time during this month to recognize older adults and the
0:03:59 people who serve them as vital parts of our community. And to accept this this evening,
0:04:04 we have Jenette Rowe with the Twin Falls Senior Center.
0:04:06 Thank you so much for recognizing the older Americans.
0:04:28 We are really, really excited about the month of May
0:04:31 because May 12th will be the 40th anniversary
0:04:34 of the Twin Falls Senior Center.
0:04:36 So we have planned a lot of festive activities
0:04:39 and things to commemorate the month,
0:04:41 as well as celebrate on May 11th.
0:04:43 We will have a ribbon cutting with the Chamber of Commerce
0:04:46 at two o'clock in the afternoon.
0:04:48 We're serving refreshments and letting people know
0:04:51 about what the center's about so you come down and visit it then on May 12th is our annual
0:04:56 breakfast, his almost Saturday, so I'll have continuous celebration on that day, but we have
0:05:01 put a lot of activities and functions together. On May 2nd I will be going out to a mouthful
0:05:07 made of sugar, and they have donated 600 pounds worth of sugar to the center to help us, uh,
0:05:13 was it should go as just about three months? The numbers keep growing and the number of people
0:05:22 we serve as is growing every single month.
0:05:25 Friday was the biggest day we've ever had
0:05:28 at the senior center.
0:05:29 We sent 250 frozen meals out the door to homebound
0:05:33 with 200 jails and a heart plate at the senior center.
0:05:38 So a total of five-half is really tired,
0:05:43 but they've really done an excellent job
0:05:45 and we just want to continue serving the community
0:05:48 and doing all we can to make sure
0:05:49 that people have the nutrition and the voluntary efforts
0:05:53 and the community support and being able to socialize
0:05:56 enjoy their community. Thank you. Next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input.
0:06:09 I just want to review the public input procedure so individuals who wish to provide input regarding
0:06:15 matters relevant to the city will be recognized by the mayor. They can approach the podium and
0:06:21 state their name and whether they're a resident or property owner in the city of Twin Falls.
0:06:26 We are going to limit that to two minutes this evening. So if there's anyone who wishes to address
0:06:32 the council now sure opportunity to please come forward thank you mr. mayor i believe i've met
0:06:43 each of the council members previously but i will briefly state my name is david gadde i'm running
0:06:48 for district judge and i want to come and just speak with council for a few minutes tonight
0:06:53 let you know why i'm running i am a resident of twin falls my wife and i reside here with our
0:06:59 eight children i currently am an attorney with worst of its charlton stover i've been practicing
0:07:04 for about the last 11 or 12 years. My practice involves all manner of cases involving civil
0:07:11 litigation. Currently the Filer City prosecutor and of course do some transactional work as
0:07:16 well. But most of my work involves the types of cases, civil cases that the district court
0:07:23 would hear. As a nonpartisan candidate, I don't have much of a platform and I'm not able to
0:07:28 have much of a platform in the United States and the state of Idaho on cases fair and
0:07:41 partially obviously I would be committed to do that to the extent that I am able to
0:07:46 have a platform it's it's not addressed to the types of issues that might come
0:07:50 before the court but I can talk about case management things like that and I
0:07:55 will say that cases well the court system really at its core is a
0:08:01 dispute resolution process and it's are from perfect but it's the best that we
0:08:07 And it can do an excellent job for the parties that are unable to resolve their disputes otherwise.
0:08:13 One of my concerns as an attorney that's been the private practice for a decade plus
0:08:17 is I feel as though it's becoming less and less successful to the public.
0:08:22 Whether you've been charged with a felony and that brings you before the district court
0:08:27 or you've got the type of civil case that would bring you before the district court.
0:08:31 As a judge, I'd like to take measures to help make it less risky, less stressful,
0:08:37 stressful, less expensive, and help the process move along quicker. It's a
0:08:42 stressful enough process as it is, and I do believe that there are some things
0:08:46 that the district court can do to help make that a bit easier on the parties
0:08:52 and a bit easier on the process. So, have any questions I'm certainly
0:08:59 answering, excuse me, I'm certainly willing to answer those. Otherwise, I'd
0:09:03 certainly appreciate your vote coming 15th questions. Is there anyone else who
0:09:16 to address the council on any items of relevance to the city this evening. The next item on
0:09:27 the edge is the consent calendar and just to let council know here I don't have very
0:09:33 good access to seeing people requesting to speak here so I'll just be trying to pay
0:09:37 attention across here. Council wishes. I move we approve the consent calendar. Motion
0:09:48 by Ruth Pierce, seconded by Chris Tockenton to approve the consent calendar. Is there
0:09:53 Any discussion?
0:09:54 Nicky Boyd?
0:10:07 Yes.
0:10:08 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:10:09 Yes.
0:10:10 Red Lanting?
0:10:11 Yes.
0:10:12 Ruth Pierce?
0:10:13 Yes.
0:10:14 Christopher Reed?
0:10:15 Yes.
0:10:16 Russ Hockington?
0:10:17 Yes.
0:10:18 I should pass the 7-0.
0:10:19 So just to let anyone know who was here for a special event this evening, those were all
0:10:24 just approved on the consent calendar.
0:10:26 You're welcome to stick around for the rest of the meeting.
0:10:41 Next on the agenda, enter items of consideration.
0:10:44 First, it's a request from the Twin Falls Optimus Foundation
0:10:47 to waive building permit fees
0:10:49 associated with the Youth House Project.
0:10:52 And we have Hack Cenavons, Senior Building Inspector,
0:10:56 and Barry Noblek with the Twin Falls Optimus Foundation.
0:11:00 Did I get it right, Hack?
0:11:29 Piece of property from the Twin Falls County.
0:11:34 It's a 239th Avenue, North, for kids that age out
0:11:45 of foster care at 18.
0:11:47 What happens now, at that point, the Child Protection Act ends, and for the most part,
0:11:54 they don't have a place to go.
0:11:57 Statistics are pretty grim.
0:11:59 It happens to these kids.
0:12:01 They don't finish high school, and at their six of them, they're just down the street at
0:12:07 the Magic Valley High School, right?
0:12:12 So a lot of them are not even out of high school, and if it's not.
0:12:19 Most of them have college, there's only two percent that make it through college.
0:12:24 50% of our home is within and some of them end up in cursory.
0:12:33 So this home will provide, it's kind of a boot camp
0:12:37 to become, when we first talk to the county
0:12:41 about the property foundation.
0:12:45 And by the way, the Lori Ward, our vice president
0:12:48 is here with me.
0:12:50 So if you got questions for her, the idea
0:12:55 was that they wanted us to cause,
0:13:02 but also the operational piece of the home.
0:13:05 And so we didn't eat six months,
0:13:08 together in about the months.
0:13:10 Oh, Jim Franz, Jim Franz has three similar homes up in the Treasure Valley.
0:13:17 We really invented some great story.
0:13:22 I'm telling you the whole thing that started Jim Franz started when she was in high school.
0:13:30 I had a friend that aged out and she couldn't believe nothing for them.
0:13:36 And so Franz, so we also like that they're in the process now.
0:13:58 We have a house where was there in our groundbreaking.
0:14:08 He was able to tour the home, like to show a tiny bit.
0:14:14 So we've had volunteers in the home so far.
0:14:17 We're doing the demo work in preparation for the boys' floor
0:14:23 on the upper section.
0:14:25 Pulled some of the gabram, say, too.
0:14:38 You can also have some other things there.
0:14:47 And it's all housed within that 5,000 square foot
0:14:50 of that building.
0:14:51 If I mention the police's increments.
0:15:02 So we see this as our Optimus Club and as the community,
0:15:06 as a long-term investment in these kids.
0:15:10 It's really not an investment, a house or the property.
0:15:21 And so this is one of the way you can participate
0:15:23 is to give us a break on the estimated total value
0:15:32 for the piece associated with the project
0:15:35 or approximately $2,497, applicable.
0:15:40 The packers who are capacity fees
0:15:42 would still be assessed.
0:15:46 The council have any questions.
0:15:48 S is in, it'll be about 16.
0:16:03 It's two words.
0:16:04 Absolutely.
0:16:07 Jim France is actually J. E. M. So if it's not where you give things, meeting certain standards,
0:16:23 so it's kind of like an apprenticeship. They have certain requirements in the home, mentors,
0:16:42 and it's mainly done volunteers. The resident person will be the girls one for the mixed.
0:17:09 They are in separate floors and they don't be activities of the precise age growth category.
0:17:48 This is one of the amazing things I should mention.
0:18:19 It's the Twin Falls Optimus Club and Foundation has started this, but now we have community support from everywhere.
0:18:26 All three rotary clubs are helping out lots of foundations and we have volunteers, groups, realtors, churches.
0:18:42 It's amazing what's happening, but on the surface side we've spent just as much time developing the construction part of this home as we have
0:18:51 what we call youth services, the extensive meetings with health and welfare, and the
0:18:58 college and all these other stakeholders that can provide things for these kids.
0:19:03 They are all willing to produce that they just kind of disappear.
0:19:22 And so now that they're aggregated in the spot where it's male and female, but in the
0:19:37 same area of this home, the upstairs is completely isolated.
0:19:41 They did not catch in their own bedrooms, and even see each other as maybe in the classroom setting.
0:19:52 This project, I want to say to you, and certainly the Optimus team, and as you mentioned, this really is growing into quite a community project, not a club project.
0:20:45 It's a pretty amazing sense of community as everyone has come together to put this together, because you say to invest in these kids out of the facility.
0:20:55 So, thank you for that sharing, I'll call them.
0:21:04 Nicky Boy.
0:21:05 Yes.
0:21:06 Yes, Greg Lanting with Piers, Christopher Reed, Chris Hockington, John Barrieger.
0:21:13 Yes, motion passes 7-0. Thank you. We look forward to having you with the agenda.
0:21:24 Next on the agenda is a request to approve an agreement for engineering services with JUB engineers for the 2018-2019 FAA airticks.
0:21:32 We have Bill Kerber, our board manager.
0:21:34 Good evening, Mayor. Good evening, Council.
0:21:36 I'd just like to bring out our heads for us.
0:21:53 Yes, good evening package of projects we put together here with GUB engineers are selected
0:22:02 airport consultant in the FAA group consists of taxi lane designing construction to your contract
0:22:10 that we're looking at three pieces of snow removal equipment to keep our fleet where we
0:22:15 need to be in these challenging times that we have with these winners and also a pavement
0:22:21 management plan update which is sort of a survey and a report card or a pavement
0:22:25 condition so we can continue to plan good work out there. So I'd like to just
0:22:31 show you on this other overhead the taxi lane we're looking to construct. If you
0:22:40 can see my prompt here this is a product of the concept that came out with the
0:22:45 airport board and the council approved for future growth in the northeast
0:22:50 development in the airport, this is the canal up here in the road again, the new
0:22:55 FedEx facility is right in here, and you need to expand this way, and this is years of growth ahead of us, but we're looking to do this
0:23:05 here is work with GUB to design a phase one which would be this taxi lane right here, and that would enable us to do more
0:23:13 and developable areas for hangers, which are scarce with the development of the FedEx project.
0:23:20 Some of that works, the larger ones in this area.
0:23:30 So with this taxi-ling project, with the associated utility planning that we're doing,
0:23:35 we're looking to expand our subdivision, if you will.
0:23:39 Also, in future phase, the next phase logically would be a connection to the taxiways.
0:23:45 would improve circulation back here as well as expanded hanger and construction capability.
0:23:52 I went to this first phase and we can get going next year after that's done.
0:23:58 So design would be this year and construction next and the store removal equipment we have
0:24:06 some acquisitions this year we're looking for a three axle, high speed, high capacity
0:24:12 plow setup with the dump bed here.
0:24:14 It's a large dump truck with a plow mount.
0:24:16 We do have a plow that we also utilize with a broom.
0:24:20 We cross utilize it.
0:24:21 We tend to use generally the broom,
0:24:23 so the plow will go on to this truck.
0:24:25 We're looking for a smaller, dually,
0:24:27 sort of a large pickup, if you will,
0:24:30 where we can put a 12-inch snow plow.
0:24:33 And we're more and more.
0:24:35 We're starting to use some de-icing chemicals
0:24:37 to keep an hour of snow and ice control plant.
0:24:39 So with this piece, we'll be able to get out,
0:24:42 the terminal building around airplanes, a very renewable lighter truck, and we'll be
0:24:47 able to use those chemicals as we need them, and an acquisition next year for a snowroom,
0:24:52 which has been really the greatest thing since sliced bread when it comes to keeping your
0:24:57 runways bare and wet and hacking action, which is more in demand for partners in the FAA compliance division.
0:25:05 So this is the host of work, and what we're required to do when we have an engineering
0:25:13 engineering contract that's estimated in excess of $100,000 for the work is to do an independent
0:25:21 fee estimate and it's something FAA requires airports to do is to get a very small contract.
0:25:28 I think it's $2,500 with someone that's an engineer in the industry, TEO engineers is
0:25:34 a reputable firm and a Boise, I work with their engineering division.
0:25:38 You can see on the left the different tasks, that's all the scope of work for the design
0:25:42 services, the PIDN Construction Services, and a quick glance table. There's much more
0:25:48 detail to this, but what you can see here is the JUB green TO engineers estimate based
0:25:55 on the same scope of work on the right, and you can see the costs are very close. They're
0:26:00 within about 8% of hearing about 10% of each other. The FAA finds that as a fairly reasonable
0:26:06 comparison. I think total cost was just about $35,000 higher. So looking at this I
0:26:13 thought it was a good comparison. I think JUB fees are reasonable. I just got
0:26:20 concurrence from the F.A. this morning. They feel the same way. So in conclusion
0:26:27 there I would just recommend City Council approved the agreement for
0:26:32 engineering services was JUB for the contract amount of $391,359.96 intention
0:26:41 of quantity review we're still looking for production that contract for Fritz to
0:26:44 look at that in FAA if we have to answer any questions you might have. Chris
0:26:50 talking to you take a minute. Yes thank you Chris. The matchport federal
0:27:02 grant is at a level of 93.75% so we have about a six and a quarter percent
0:27:08 local contribution, which we have an airport construction fund separate from
0:27:12 our airport operating and maintenance fund and we use our passenger facility
0:27:17 charges. The airline collects what else in 25 cents per passenger. We're able to
0:27:21 use those fees to offset that local match so the user fees based on our
0:27:27 airline passengers is used to help with these improvements.
0:27:30 Yes.
0:27:34 Come as your question.
0:27:59 Seconded by Ris presented.
0:28:03 19.
0:28:20 Yes.
0:28:21 Ruth Pierce.
0:28:22 Yes.
0:28:23 Christopher Reed.
0:28:24 Yes.
0:28:25 Chris Stockington.
0:28:26 Yes.
0:28:27 Don Bericher.
0:28:28 Nicky Boyd.
0:28:29 Yes.
0:28:31 passes 7-0.
0:28:32 Next on the agenda's request to utilize airport fund reserves to replace a recently failed emergency
0:28:40 generator.
0:28:42 Yes, we had misfortune out there at the airport back in the wake of the 9-11 tragedy.
0:28:49 Some dollars became available to help support your security system, things of that nature.
0:28:54 We did a fencing project with its help with security as well as wildlife control.
0:29:00 And the other thing was installation of an emergency generator, which was super.
0:29:04 Security systems in our building are air-filled lighting.
0:29:10 So we had that peace of mind that if something went down, we had that generator.
0:29:14 So, it's been 15 years when we had a catastrophic failure in the very early part of April.
0:29:19 I've been working with John Leisure, the city electrician, and working closely with the DFA,
0:29:24 we have about some options for replacement.
0:29:27 So, I've been able to sort of clear the way with the DFA to have a emergency generator funded,
0:29:34 reimburse to us.
0:29:35 So, I'm here tonight to talk about a cash flow situation where we could use airport fund reserves
0:29:41 to go out with an informal bidding process.
0:29:44 The best estimates I've gone from our electrician
0:29:46 is a replacement would be in the range of $75,000 to $100,000.
0:29:50 So we would have the ability to use the informal bidding
0:29:53 process and look for three bidders
0:29:54 to respond fairly quickly.
0:29:57 Right now, we're in the first month of an $8,500 per month
0:30:01 generator rental, the city IT electrical department
0:30:05 does not have one available for city facilities,
0:30:08 that size.
0:30:09 So it's still not determined how much longer we would rent that.
0:30:13 I don't know if it would be cost-effective for us to do that.
0:30:16 We may have to kind of expose ourselves in two or three months.
0:30:18 It may take to replace it.
0:30:20 So that's yet to be determined whether we'll continue that or not.
0:30:24 But the real request here is just that utilization of the reserves for cash
0:30:28 tokens to request to utilize the airport fund reserves to replace the recently
0:30:54 failed emergency generators in the discussion.
0:30:56 Thank you, Council.
0:31:04 Next on the agenda is a presentation on the Southern Idaho Water Quality Coalition, we
0:31:09 have Jason Browner, environmental engineer.
0:31:12 Welcome, Jason.
0:31:13 Thank you, Mr. Mayor, Council members.
0:31:17 Appreciate this opportunity to come and talk about a new project.
0:31:23 Coalition, we have Jason Brown our environmental engineer. Welcome Jason. Thank you, Mr. Mayor,
0:31:29 Council members. Appreciate this opportunity to come and talk about a group of people that have
0:31:37 gotten together and tried to look at a broader picture of water quality issues here in Southern
0:31:42 Idaho. If you remember about 18 months to 24 months ago, we talked and discussed about our
0:31:49 We spotted treatment plant in PDS permit or the permit that governs our water treatment
0:31:54 plant and our renewal of that process and through that process it was apparent that
0:32:00 the Idaho Department of Vice document that helps with water quality issues here in Southern
0:32:11 Idaho and so I've been participating in that group.
0:32:15 We call it the Watershed Advisory Group.
0:32:18 It's a hard to state law that local water users discharge the surface water and get
0:32:25 together and talk about water.
0:32:28 And through that process we see some limitations.
0:32:31 There are some regulatory limitations and there's also implementation of those regulations.
0:32:37 And so a group of people got together and started talking about forming a coalition.
0:32:44 And this coalition is a little bit different because it pulls in a broader base of industry
0:32:49 agriculture, people that declocation the cities discharge the surface waters, the
0:32:58 aquaculture facility, the Twin Falls Canal Company, and getting together
0:33:02 discussing long-term projects or benefits that we can do to help the
0:33:09 implementation of EMDL or that the state puts together. And really that's the focus
0:33:16 of this coalition is to look for projects and help focus on projects that
0:33:21 that would be farther reaching than what we are capable of doing inside of the
0:33:27 community itself.
0:33:29 And so, really tonight I just wanted to let the council know that if they start
0:33:33 hearing about this coalition forming, I participated in, I think, a long-term
0:33:42 benefit for the city and other municipalities around the area,
0:33:46 but also allows us to work with the agriculture industry, with the dairy industry,
0:33:50 with other industries around that really all of our economy depends on in this area and water is becoming increasingly a valuable resource for us and wanting to look for projects in areas the city is actually over the course of time and a very good job and staying on the forefront of issues like this we have ponds that we remove sediment from irrigation returns and that's in conjunction with the canal company.
0:34:22 So we've tried to be proactive in this area, but I think this helps us take another step in working with more people and have a larger voice at some point, come back and maybe want to show our support to going talking to state legislatures and also potentially federal legislatures of maybe finding money to help support some projects here in Southern Idaho.
0:34:47 So if you hear a conversation about this in, and I just wanted to have you here for me first.
0:35:01 We're going to continue to sit on this and be a part of the city engaged in any questions.
0:35:13 Good job Jason.
0:35:17 I've heard from some people saying that the state's eyes are upon.
0:36:39 And that's part of the hope of this coalition is to be able to go after projects and see and work with groups of people
0:36:47 of people that may not necessarily come to the table or be required to come to the table
0:36:52 through some other process, through the TMDL process.
0:36:55 And that's really what we're hoping is to engage people and also engage with them on what they've
0:37:03 been doing, what is it that you've been doing to help protect some of the water quality.
0:37:08 This is what the City of Twin Falls is historically done.
0:37:11 And to some of that credit, I've learned quite a bit from what some of the other industries
0:37:17 have been doing, particularly the dairy industry, trying to be a little bit more proactive in
0:37:23 controlling some of their water quality.
0:37:27 But we understand that Rock Creek has a huge impact on our city from the environmental aspect.
0:37:37 And that was really one of the early projects that we talked about is what could we do to
0:37:42 help clean up Rock Creek.
0:37:45 If you look it back at some historical documents, there's been a project called the Rock Creek
0:37:50 project back in the early late 80s, early 90s of where they went and did some assessments,
0:37:57 but maybe using and recolivating that project to help sponsor other projects often.
0:38:03 But it definitely is going to require us to go at some point and talk to the state legislatures
0:38:09 and also the federal because these projects are going to be quite big to look at some and
0:38:16 no one entity or industry in southern Idaho looking for opportunities, having a larger
0:38:26 voice and that's really what I think the coalition is helping and intrigue is an issue and we've
0:38:35 some of those issues here at this specifically at the city of Du Fols. Jason, thanks for your
0:38:51 leadership role in this and helping to elaborate and help resolve our own issues before someone
0:38:57 comes and resolves them for us. Thank you. And next on the agenda we have another opportunity
0:39:05 for general public input. If there's anyone here who wishes to address the council on
0:39:08 items not on the agenda this evening, now's your opportunity.
0:39:17 Council, Ms. Anoggins. Not really an advisory board report but just a shout out to the community.
0:39:24 Thursday is National Day of Prayer for our country and at the Twin Falls City
0:39:30 Park we will be hosting a gathering where you can come and pray and sing and
0:39:34 worship however you feel as a group and as a nation. So this last week at the
0:39:59 Police Department will work and just to list the individuals, the officers who
0:40:07 received awards or maybe just on the top of your head. Yeah maybe not all because
0:40:13 there were several which was very impressive for all the great work that
0:40:16 our officers do, we may be just the officer of the year.
0:40:22 Thank you, Counsel Wittering, Mayor Counsel.
0:40:25 Yes, we had our awards backlit on last Thursday.
0:40:28 It was a wonderful event.
0:40:29 The officer of the year is really an employee of the Supervisors Coalition.
0:40:38 So that is all of the sergeants and our civilian supervisor, which is Candy.
0:40:47 So they did select on Apple Y as our officer of the Azar Civilian employee.
0:41:01 We also organized several of our officers and employees with letters of commendations for
0:41:07 some of the great works that they did throughout the year.
0:41:10 There's life-saving members, Sheriff Carter, his crew.
0:41:57 I'm missing a thing from this man, members of the council, and also members who might
0:42:02 be tuning to the next week when we started 4 o'clock conversation.
0:42:09 Emitters said authorized the use of city funds and process of allocating those resources.
0:42:48 Seeing no other items on this portion of the agenda, the next item is a public hearing
0:42:53 and that is scheduled to begin no earlier than 6 p.m. and we're seven minutes shy of that right now, so we will stand in recess until 6 p.m.
0:43:04 And then before we convene the council meeting, it is after 6, 6, 0, 3.
0:43:25 Next on the agenda we have a public hearing. It's a request to approve the Enforcement Response Plan or ERP,
0:43:32 and industrial user surcharge program to adopt the enforcement response plan
0:43:38 and industrial user surcharge program resolution and we have Jason Brandner
0:43:43 environmental your title changed between item 70 and 90s.
0:43:49 That's okay it's like I think everybody knows who they're talking about so that's fine.
0:43:56 I appreciate this opportunity to come and this has been a process it's been going on
0:44:03 for about 18 months if looking back at the documentation almost the year to the
0:44:08 date I was here to talk about what our enforcement response plan was and a new
0:44:13 program called the surcharge program that we wanted to start implementing here at
0:44:18 the city of Twin Falls and that was really by request and some good pushing
0:44:23 by the Environmental Protection Agency. Our current enforcement response plan was
0:44:29 put into place in the 1980s and so as we all know things had changed a bit in the environmental
0:44:36 world sense and so we felt like it was time for us to take a good hard look at how we dealt
0:44:42 with our industrial partners here in town and also update our documentation the way we
0:44:49 go about enforcing the applicable and required environmental regulations that we have here
0:44:56 in the city of Twin Falls.
0:44:57 So through that process and corresponding back and forth
0:45:02 with the EPA, we came up with the documents
0:45:04 that are in the council packet.
0:45:06 And so really what we're looking for tonight
0:45:09 and some of that the public hearing was brought forth
0:45:12 because there are some new fees assessed
0:45:17 with the surcharge program, but also an update
0:45:20 to our administrative fees
0:45:23 with our new enforcement response plans.
0:45:24 So I'll also put in the public notice in the packet as well.
0:45:30 And so I'll answer any questions, but then open up the mic for the public to provide any input.
0:45:38 I will say that we have worked with our industrial partners on this and have received positive feedback,
0:45:46 have tweaked a few, before the EPA reviewed it, tweaked a few things.
0:45:51 There was a few concerns on a couple of time frame types of questions, and so we were able
0:45:58 to massage that out and so again, our national partners have supported this, the ones that
0:46:07 have reached out to me personally, so for that I'll open up questions and then allow questions
0:46:14 that we can discuss.
0:46:16 At the surcharge levels, I mean I try to understand which everything else, yep, above that.
0:46:44 So the way this surcharge works, and it really kind of goes back to our current enforcement
0:46:49 response plan.
0:46:50 In our current enforcement response plan, we consider a minor or major violation.
0:46:58 Minor violations make up about 60% of what we deal with on an administrative basis at the
0:47:05 city in our pre-treatment coordinator.
0:47:08 Lance Nelson, he deals with most of that.
0:47:10 So, looking at what our historical enforcement response plan, we felt like it was important
0:47:18 enough to go back.
0:47:20 We really don't see the minor inflections down at the treatment plan.
0:47:24 They really kind of get, as you get, in a lack of a better term, kind of in the white
0:47:28 noise down at the treatment plan, we really don't see a lot of those.
0:47:32 So, really what the surcharge program is intended is to, we understand that our industrial
0:47:39 partners from time to time have situations where there's a variability in their plants.
0:47:47 And so as they discharge to us that we have to treat that extra capacity down at the treatment
0:47:55 plant.
0:47:56 So the surcharge fees are, you know, the increase is 100% on those only for the simple
0:48:03 fact that they were nonexistent before.
0:48:07 So we use our current billing rate.
0:48:09 So the rate resolution that the finance department
0:48:13 goes through the process every year,
0:48:15 we use that same rate and it has an industrial category in it.
0:48:19 So what we do is use that and have multipliers
0:48:25 based upon the strength of constituents
0:48:28 that are sent to the treatment plant.
0:48:29 And the City of Twin Falls chooses to sample our industries
0:48:33 pretty much every day of the year.
0:48:35 There's with exception Sundays.
0:48:37 and most major holidays, but we have a pretty good idea
0:48:40 of what's being sent to our treatment plant,
0:48:43 and that is by design, and so we can adjust and be flexible.
0:48:47 But again, the rates are really built
0:48:50 to our ability to treat and cost those rates.
0:49:04 And so, if you look at how those are broken down,
0:49:10 pH is a funny thing, it really had,
0:49:12 there's not a lot of variability,
0:49:13 or really no variability in pH.
0:49:15 The permit limits each industrial user has a permit limit that they are legally capable
0:49:22 of going to.
0:49:23 If you look at the federal rules, we've put in their multipliers of 20% and 40% the 40%
0:49:31 is kind of that maximum ceiling.
0:49:33 Anything over that really the EPA considers that a violation and so therefore we have
0:49:37 to consider that a violation of a permit.
0:49:40 So if you look at the surcharge tables, the fees, if you look at that third box down,
0:49:47 it says surcharge levels 1 to 1.2, that's the 20% above their limit, and there's a fee
0:49:54 associated with that.
0:49:55 And if you look at the next box, 1.2 to 1.4, there's a fee associated with that, it's a little
0:50:01 bit more strict.
0:50:04 And then if you look at the surcharge, the last box, it says enforcement limit, that's
0:50:08 really when the violations start kicking in that we have no flexibility in that
0:50:13 point we have to provide a violation and that's what the enforcement
0:50:16 response plan is to help us walk through it's also associated with some of that treatment
0:50:28 sorry that was a long way to know that that was great
0:50:33 any other questions or comments for Jason Christard
0:50:35 general question Jason years ago asking years ago we had some points of our system
0:51:02 So there's always going to be, there's always going to be some of that vulnerability we try to build into and give people options.
0:51:16 We have RV dumps, typically a lot of that comes in from RV dumps.
0:51:20 And so we, the city over the course of time has had RV dumps, there's also other private RV dumps.
0:51:27 But, you know, there's always going to be some vulnerability to somebody trying to get around the system.
0:51:35 We've tried to educate the general public of where you can go, what you can do with some of these types of things.
0:51:42 And I think over the course of time is we inherently understand the impacts of some of these dumping events, motor oil or whatnot.
0:51:53 I think people have educated themselves and it really is harmful.
0:51:58 There's been cases on the state level that other municipalities have gone through with these types.
0:52:04 But we've been fairly successful and we continue.
0:52:08 We try to do community outreach and community involvement type of events
0:52:15 to help people understand how to dispose, work with DEQ.
0:52:19 I know DEQ on hazardous waste, motor oil types of disposals,
0:52:26 where they can go to take care of that.
0:52:28 So a lot of it is an educational component.
0:52:31 I do believe that people get that they need to do something with it.
0:52:36 and I think it's become easier to take our ways to facilities.
0:52:43 We're always gonna probably battle with some people
0:52:45 trying to get around the rules.
0:52:53 Me and Jason, we will button this item
0:53:01 now as your opportunity to please come forward.
0:53:03 First off, I want to community for actually looking
0:53:26 at this because it's something I used to do in a prior life
0:53:29 when we could do that.
0:53:30 It's very difficult, very contentious situation sometimes.
0:53:33 So, nice job, Jason.
0:53:39 What I'd like to talk about a little bit is,
0:53:41 As you can see, you know, 100% increases in fines and those types of things for significant users of the system can add up to fairly large sums very quickly.
0:53:53 And what I want to talk about is budgeting because we knew this was coming, we knew you guys were working on it, but we didn't see a list of what to expect for our last budgeting cycles.
0:54:04 And Jason I have talked about this a little bit, but one of the things that like composers how you start to put this into effect
0:54:11 Because of all sudden you say as of January 1st this comes with an effect and all of my budgets go up
0:54:19 It's going to be $60,000 a month, they hit $120,000 or $80,000 a month, they're going to have a very negative business and we're trying to run
0:54:27 So what I would like to take a look at is as this comes in
0:54:32 It comes in either looking at and saying, okay,
0:54:35 it's gonna start in the third quarter of the year,
0:54:37 or even better yet, as the budgetary year comes down now,
0:54:40 might be to get a company, fiscal year
0:54:42 and calendar year or the same.
0:54:45 So we'll start the budgeting process,
0:54:47 seventh and eighth month of the year,
0:54:48 get ready for next year.
0:54:51 If we're going to go through this,
0:54:52 which I will say is not a bad idea,
0:54:55 but I think we need to be careful
0:54:56 about how we approach our businesses
0:54:59 and how you put this into effect,
0:55:02 that those businesses can budget this and not have a deleterious effect on this fiscal year facility.
0:55:44 Good question. That is probably the most pronounced. And we know it's coming. We can take a look at the models and say historically we've had these types of surcharges or in some accounts.
0:55:59 And the NOV is the CDS look at them slightly different. What's that going to cost us? And we take a look back.
0:56:06 We say okay historically over the last two years, three years, whatever. These are the types of surcharges that we use to pain.
0:56:11 used to paying and that's what we budget on.
0:56:14 So if we go into this,
0:56:17 is all of a sudden a 100% increase in all the year
0:56:19 that we haven't had a chance to adjust those budgets.
0:56:21 And we're not budgeting for NOVs,
0:56:23 we're not budgeting to be,
0:56:24 being absolutely erroneous thought.
0:56:28 Our budgeting for surcharges,
0:56:30 because that's one of the way that you guys do,
0:56:35 is do those surcharges,
0:56:37 which is a very reasonable thing to do.
0:56:39 The question is, is how can we put it in a situation
0:56:42 where we know that doing business costs money?
0:56:45 We know that we know that the disposing of our waste is responsibility and that is reflected upon what we do business we have this year to a couple of $500,000 sitting in the budget somewhere saying, okay, the city wants to increase our surcharges going to the POTW this year and that's going to be within the budgets that we forecast and we have set up in a year.
0:57:17 So I think looking out farther enough and having conversations with your significant
0:57:26 industries and being able to sit down and say what makes sense, what's the easiest way
0:57:31 to put it into it, and how do I not negatively affect facilities that we have to equally affect
0:57:44 those businesses.
0:57:45 We put this in place as probably the best way to keep a really good relationship with the
0:57:52 businesses that you have.
0:57:53 So, to break it down in many businesses,
0:58:02 bonuses that people occur, that particular facility is,
0:58:08 is, is, um,
0:58:10 set within, within the company,
0:58:13 are reflected on making budgets or not making budgets.
0:58:16 And if something comes up like this is out of our control,
0:58:20 it still has a very, very possible effect
0:58:24 on the people that work at that facility too,
0:58:26 because they won't make the key,
0:58:28 key production indicators that they're looking at.
0:58:32 So every month we go and take a look at it.
0:58:35 We say where we at, where we on, do we need to adjust?
0:58:38 But having 100% coming all of a sudden,
0:58:41 you know, that's not in the forecast.
0:58:42 Let me change the level and get your input on this.
0:58:45 So let's get the, can we get the public input first?
0:58:48 And then we can let Jason respond to questions.
0:58:51 I have a question for you.
0:58:53 I'm asking, can you wait to have Jason respond
0:59:03 until after we take the p- understanding of you're trying to understand
0:59:14 you're in this particular situation but realize that these things don't go out by
0:59:20 100% of the other things but you deal with a change in commodity prices almost
0:59:26 on a basis of what you're paying for milk, what you're paying for other supplies,
0:59:34 what you're able to achieve, what cheeses out there so you'd think there would be
0:59:39 some of these some flexibility in your budgets just by the fact that the type
0:59:45 I think the fact that there are areas in our budgets that are hot as tacked down as we'd like them to be
0:59:55 Health prices being one of them makes it a little bit harder to stay within budgeting
1:00:02 However, we are given very strict guidance that you have to stick with in a certain budget
1:00:07 So some and I'm not here to pay
1:00:10 Health prices or anything else, but if that goes up we have to fight somewhere else to offset that, right?
1:00:15 So try and stay on budget if I pay more for this part over here
1:00:20 I'm finding I'm struggling to find where I'm gonna save money over here to offset that
1:00:24 We are helped by the budgets we have for wastewater with you guys for a long time
1:00:35 They're not insignificant. So if that all of a sudden doubles and like I said like a hundred twenty hundred eight thousand dollars a month
1:00:47 I'm going to have to take money out of other parts of my budget that may or may not exist
1:00:53 So I can tell you in the environmental area. I don't have a lot of budget
1:00:56 I don't have a lot of budget to be able to sit down and say I can sit down and take that money because I don't have it
1:01:02 So if I don't have it, I have to go get it. That's fine.
1:01:05 Have this be basically double button, suggesting it's not that it shouldn't happen.
1:01:25 This is the man of that happened.
1:01:28 So we have time to set my budgets up and put it in a forecast, so I'm not surprising the people that I report to.
1:01:34 All the way back up, including to our CEO in Ireland conversation.
1:01:43 I can say, hey, let's get prepared for this. This happens.
1:01:49 It's going to happen on January 1st.
1:01:51 We can put that into next year's budget and that helps me a great deal.
1:01:55 That's my whole point is that we've known this is becoming we've been talking about for a long time.
1:02:01 We have not necessarily the scope.
1:02:09 We started to have those.
1:02:11 And Jason, I have talked about this a bit at one point in time.
1:02:14 We do this in a way that's, like I said, we're not trying to budget for NOVs because we don't run.
1:02:23 Trying to stay within what we have permits to do have surcharges within those two.
1:02:45 To speak on this issue.
1:02:46 Good seeing them and Jason if I'm responding.
1:02:58 So yeah, Dana and I have talked a little bit.
1:03:02 So, excuse me, really the part where we're asking
1:03:08 is the ability to start implementing this program.
1:03:12 When it gets down to reality,
1:03:13 it's gonna take us some time to go
1:03:14 through each individual permit.
1:03:16 We have seven of them to go through
1:03:18 and start revising permits.
1:03:21 The EPA has asked us that we have everything done
1:03:23 September 30th in phone conversations with them that starts some different
1:03:29 reporting requirements for us so we'd like to have all of our permits renewed by
1:03:35 September 30th in talking about the surcharge program all the industries they
1:03:41 end up paying a monthly bill on what they've actually discharged to to to our POTWR
1:03:51 waste water treatment plant. And then so this surcharge really is above and beyond whatever
1:03:57 they're permitted. And so hopefully we're hoping, like I said, we're hoping not to
1:04:03 to radically impact people's budgets. That's really not what we're our intentions are at this
1:04:10 point. And I fully understand what Dane is trying to trying to get across it. If it wasn't a
1:04:16 budget or however things change in their dynamic. We're trying not to be an impact, but this is
1:04:27 going to take some time to implement. I mean it's not going to be, you adopt the resolution tonight.
1:04:33 If you so choose, it's going to take us some time and we won't start enforcing those permits
1:04:38 until the industries have had a chance to look at and review them, see what those new thresholds
1:04:44 are going to be and what that enforcement limit will be.
1:04:48 But we're still trying to be proactive
1:04:50 and maintain relationships with our industries.
1:04:52 There's no ways that we want to hurt those relationships
1:04:56 by trying to keep up.
1:05:04 So we'll still have to end up using the current permit
1:05:17 that's in existence.
1:05:21 It'll fall under our enforcement response plan.
1:05:24 So we'll continue to use that enforcement.
1:05:26 The surcharge is our intention is to implement that over time, but really, like I said,
1:05:33 by September 30th, it EP is asked us to have it up and going.
1:05:40 So, yes, so next week it happens, something happens.
1:05:43 We'll continue using our current billing schedule, and if we want to propose language change,
1:05:52 It's, you know, until new permit is issued to the industrial user, that may be a work
1:05:59 around the situation, but really, we like to be able to start implementing some of these
1:06:07 permits and working with Nate and the other industrial user.
1:06:12 We can still process where they can see the facts and where it came from.
1:07:03 So the, I'll address the appeal, so in our permits, we actually give our industries the
1:07:08 opportunity to come back and work with the city, say, hey, this occurred, this
1:07:12 happened. So there is an appeals process ingrained in the permits and we have that
1:07:18 ability to continue to do that and in the new enforcement response plan we've
1:07:22 always been able to be successful at working with our industrial partners
1:07:28 with if you have a significant fine or what would be considered to your business
1:07:33 a significant fine. Our attention is to try to get that problem solved and so
1:07:38 maybe documenting the process of putting that money back into fixing the problem
1:07:44 and not giving that money directly to the city but we have an
1:07:50 appeals process in health fines or certain things to say let's work
1:07:57 through this process and that for all intents and purposes it will continue to
1:08:02 I don't get into the payment side all that much so I don't know if there's a payment plan or how that works with
1:08:11 with state law on how
1:08:13 Industries pay the city at once I let's we send the the MRs of the monitoring reports with the bill
1:08:20 I let utility billing happen that aspect of it. So I can't really talk about that too much
1:08:27 Yes, it's not good for business
1:08:35 Partners as we have physical years are gonna be different. There's no way you can pick a date
1:08:39 that's going to work for every car fiscal year which would be end of September
1:08:45 October 1st makes sense to me. I make you try to understand all of these fees are
1:08:53 only for violations. It's not like it's a new payment plan. It's only if there is
1:08:59 a violation. It's only if they exceed what their current permit limit is. So we use the
1:09:05 word surcharge. If you get a put enforcement limit that's when the
1:09:09 violation happens. When we what we consider in a violation in the
1:09:13 the environmental world happens after that enforcement limit that was in the documentation.
1:09:19 So the surcharge is the limit, or is the area between what industries are given, is their
1:09:25 permit limits, and what the enforcement action is.
1:09:29 So there's roughly a 40% difference between what their permit limit is.
1:09:36 It can discharge up to 40%.
1:09:38 They're going to get a surcharge.
1:09:41 be associated with that. If they go over that, that's when a violation kicks in.
1:09:45 So we're not changing the base that they're used to paying that they should be budgeting
1:09:50 for. We have to pick a date and time to start enforcing the new guidelines and think you're
1:09:58 on the right track in the direction you're running in my opinion.
1:10:01 Yes, correct. We're not the current billing rate resolution. We're not trying to adjust
1:10:07 that in any way. And so they'll be billed if they're able to stay under their permit limit.
1:10:11 limit they'll be billed as normal and probably more budgeted items on a regular basis for an
1:10:19 industry. Do that too. When they get a new permit can we just say Q4? Because everybody's
1:10:51 going to be very very different. I would never forget the last day which we'll be under the
1:10:57 old building. So I would say if you and then that would have to have the permits ready to go
1:11:09 be able to satisfy its request to have our industrial permits updated with the new program.
1:11:16 So, I'm comfortable with that path forward, if that's what the Council chooses.
1:11:22 The thing I would say is that if the resolution, please state that you're just talking about
1:12:03 different enforcement response plan or stay under the, uh, or versus the old one.
1:12:11 If we're gonna wait, my preference is to continue to work under the enforcement response plan that we currently have
1:12:18 and then adopt the enforcement response plan and the surcharge program at the same time.
1:12:27 But we can add a section to the resolution that the effective date.
1:12:47 The conversations with the months of doing this amounts become,
1:12:58 you've actually had these surcharges in there for at least the last 12 months.
1:13:02 They've had an idea of that these were going to be the surcharge and
1:13:06 the administrative penalty.
1:13:09 So we had, we had a meeting right before we came to council almost a year ago.
1:13:15 And sat down and these were the numbers that we presented.
1:13:18 Actually dated, it given some comments on, maybe adjusting some time, or glamour, I should say glamour, not date specifically, but glamour, and we took those into consideration, but these numbers would have been, the numbers that we would have used, if that's specific.
1:13:35 Did that answer your question?
1:13:41 It does.
1:13:42 Okay.
1:13:44 I guess we're dealing with much of this was known as a potential 12 months ago.
1:13:49 struggling a little bit with the we didn't have to perhaps you could address that
1:14:01 that seemed to be the point of your comment was the need to delay because of
1:14:07 a lack of time to budget for the process has been as they tend to be so when does
1:14:18 I want to say we enjoy a really good relationship with the city and also see
1:14:24 each two of my health and to set my conversations around these things so a
1:14:40 year ago we started talking to say it could look like this not sure I've still got to go to the
1:14:45 EPA, about halfway through the year, well EPA hasn't told us if it's a good matter and
1:14:52 different.
1:14:54 Get to here and all of a sudden, yep, they're going to run with those ones as well.
1:14:56 So I say, well, we need to budget for something that may or may not happen.
1:15:04 They say, okay, well it's not going to happen.
1:15:07 That's just the way it works.
1:15:08 So I guess, you know, what it comes down to in enforcement plans and permits are a wonderful
1:15:17 thing.
1:15:18 And when I talk about, you know, I used to do IPP in fact, I used to work for CH2P and I
1:15:22 was there a environmental person in Florida.
1:15:24 So, I'm all in favor of having the appropriate permits in place because they help protect myself
1:15:39 And the city the whole system works pretty well, but when you're sitting out there and saying well, you know
1:15:49 We're gonna do this a little bit different. We're gonna change what they could be and how much how much you can cost you but
1:15:55 You know we can say it's gonna be about this much, but we don't know we don't know if the EPA is even going to accept this
1:16:01 I'm sitting going well, how do I budget on something?
1:16:06 I don't even know if PEP is going to take it, and I think that your SCO and build into your response plan, that a higher rates take effect on.
1:16:35 I've seen things like that in SUOs before. Here's your new permit, being known on this date, this is going to happen.
1:16:45 It comes down to what the budget on, the budget on something that I know that the city is going to do.
1:16:50 We talked about it, I think the premise is very sound. I think what the city is trying to do is not waiting.
1:16:56 I think that it's a reasonable thing to happen, but I'm not trying to say any of this is bad.
1:17:02 It's all good stuff.
1:17:03 The question is merely in the application of it.
1:17:07 So, if you're talking about October 1, October, November, December, three months.
1:17:12 But that gives me over my line at this.
1:17:17 So, what's happening is I do what I want it to be.
1:17:29 Something that's fair and equitable across all the industries within the city.
1:17:34 The question is in the implementation of that three months, it's really not a very large time period that we're looking at.
1:17:42 Everybody's physical, all that said, all I'm asking is,
1:18:03 so that we can put it through, get a budgeted so that it's not something that sticks out into what we need to have.
1:18:10 I wish you luck, it's a difficult thing at any time, sort of a race change.
1:18:17 It can be a really contentious thing, I think that Jason and the department have done a very good job doing this
1:18:23 Doing this in a manner that is non-disruptive.
1:18:26 Please, I've seen anyone go, Jason, are you saying that if the intent is that this wouldn't go into if I adopted?
1:18:45 Do you think Jason would like you have a resolution in her?
1:19:14 Or 2018-5?
1:19:16 Right, Chris, talking to him second by Chris.
1:19:38 Optor resolution 21st.
1:19:45 Say that, Jason, I do think you've done a outstanding job of working with industry and data.
1:19:57 I appreciate your comments of the transparency and ease of working with the city.
1:20:02 As you said, it's never difficult to make. You think it's important to remember this, which is the protection of the facilities of Squadron Treatment Plant.
1:20:20 It's not to be paddy. Our first work second money has to be with you.
1:20:25 And I would like to thank Lance and Jacobs, now CH2M. They put a lot of time in working with this as well.
1:20:34 I'd like Bert Pierce, Christopher Reed, Chris Hockington, John Berger, Nicki Boy, Suzanne Hawkins, Reg Lanting.
1:20:55 Yes, we should pass this step in the zero. Thank you. Thank you. Nothing else is on the agenda, so the meeting is adjourned.
Download
- Transcript (text) 59 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 76 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 101 KB
- Audio (M4A) 19.2 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, April 30, 2018. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:21:25.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
7020f5b7693f61177c4bd14f9f7d77ef88a08d6eb478e40941d68380b82445e5 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 6f7b30dfeae87bab475c7bd5b98a43fa4f344b89d16d2a131c1f15d2603f2137 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
aedad0ebf515b668626eeaf6dc0e72b735f09a33791df578fbd3228091c48606
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file