City Council meeting
Monday, May 14, 2018
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on file
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:00:03 the council. Six members are participating in the meeting this evening.
0:00:08 Fiverr here in person. Vice mayor Nikki Boyd is joining us on the telephone and
0:00:14 councilmen Chris Stockington is absent this evening. Before we move to the Pledge of
0:00:19 Allegiance I would like to ask everyone to please join us in a moment of silence to
0:00:24 recognize the loss of one of our co-workers here at the city this past
0:00:29 Mr. Roth, whether we have any amendments to our agenda this evening, Mr. Mayor, I'm
0:01:25 going to cancel the
0:01:36 officers memorial, a proclamation by the County and City of Twin Falls, Idaho, declaring
0:01:43 Sunday, May 13th through Saturday, May 19th, 2018, as Police Week, and Tuesday, May 15th,
0:01:50 2018 as Peace Officers Memorial Day, whereas the Congress and President of the United States
0:01:55 have designated the week in which May 15th falls as National Police Week, and whereas
0:02:01 the members of the law enforcement agencies of the County and City of Twin Falls play
0:02:04 an essential role in safeguarding the rights of freedoms of the residents of the county
0:02:09 and city of Twin Falls.
0:02:11 And whereas it is important that all citizens know and understand the duties, responsibilities,
0:02:16 hazards, and sacrifices of their law enforcement agency, and that members of our law enforcement
0:02:21 agency recognize their duty to serve the people by safeguarding life and property, by protecting
0:02:27 them against violence and disorder, and by protecting the innocent against deception and
0:02:32 the week against oppression. And whereas the men and women of the law enforcement agencies
0:02:37 of the county and the city of Twin Falls unceasingly provide a vital public service. Now therefore
0:02:43 we call upon all citizens of the county and city of Twin Falls and upon all patriotic, civic
0:02:48 and educational organizations to observe the week of May 13th through May 19th 2018 as
0:02:54 police week with appropriate ceremonies and observances in which all of our people may
0:02:59 join in commemorating law enforcement officers, past and present, who by their faithful and
0:03:04 loyal devotion to their responsibilities have rendered a dedicated service to their communities,
0:03:09 and in doing so have established for themselves an enviable and enduring reputation for preserving
0:03:16 the rights and security of all citizens. Furthermore, we call upon all citizens to observe May 15, 2018,
0:03:23 as peace officers Memorial Day in honor of those law enforcement officers, who through their courageous
0:03:29 deeds have made the ultimate sacrifice in service to their communities, or have become
0:03:33 disabled in the performance of duty, and let us recognize and pay respect to the survivors
0:03:38 of our fallen heroes. This is signed by both Terry Kramer, Twin Falls County Commissioner,
0:03:42 and myself as the mayor of Twin Falls, and we have, I'm pretty good this tonight, Josh Hayes.
0:03:49 And next we have a proclamation for Salvation Army Week. Whereas since it's founding in
0:05:18 Great Britain in 1865 the Salvation Army has provided humanitarian relief and
0:05:23 spiritual guidance to people throughout the world and whereas its members
0:05:27 continue its compassionate tradition of helping wherever there is hunger, disease,
0:05:32 destitution and spiritual need and whereas their victories result in shelter
0:05:36 for the homeless, food for the hungry, and self-sufficiency for the disabled and
0:05:41 whereas through its welfare and religious institutions in our country the
0:05:45 The Salvation Army has befriended, aided, and given new hope to men, women, and children,
0:05:50 regardless of race, creed, age, gender, or sexual orientation, and whereas the Salvation
0:05:56 Army serves as a symbol of compassion, but more so an active participant in the provision
0:06:01 of services to thousands of Twin Falls men, women, and children, and whereas the Salvation
0:06:05 Army has been providing these services to residents of Twin Falls City for 98 years, and whereas
0:06:11 Last year in Twin Falls, the Salvation Army provided 20,849 meals, thousands of items
0:06:18 of clothing distributed, and energy assistance given to 334 people.
0:06:22 And whereas the City of Twin Falls commends the Salvation Army officers, soldiers, and
0:06:27 those who support this mission, for their continued dedication to helping meet the physical
0:06:32 and spiritual needs of people across the nation.
0:06:35 Now therefore be a result that I, Mayor Sean Berriger, who hereby proclaim May 13th through
0:06:39 May 19th, 2018, as Salvation Army Week.
0:06:43 Call upon the citizens of Twin Falls
0:06:44 to honor the Salvation Army during that week
0:06:47 for its faithful ministry in Twin Falls City for 98 years.
0:06:51 Here to accept this this evening,
0:06:52 I believe we have John Capillares.
0:07:16 And Council, I'm John Capillares.
0:07:18 I'm the Secretary of the Advisory Board
0:07:20 for the Twin Falls Salvation Army Advisory Board.
0:07:24 And thank you for honoring the Salvation Army
0:07:27 with this proclamation.
0:07:29 The Salvation Army strives to do so much good in Twin Falls.
0:07:33 In fact, that's their motto, doing the most good.
0:07:36 From free meals to after school care and even disaster relief, if we need it, they're doing the most good.
0:07:45 Part of that quality of service is the officers that are sent here.
0:07:50 And I regret to inform you that our officers are going to be transferring now to Southern California.
0:07:56 And so now is your chance to take it by today.
0:08:01 We'll receive new officers and the work of helping the marginalized will continue in Twin Falls.
0:08:10 The future of Twin Falls will not be gloomy when we band together behind Salvation Army.
0:08:15 As Winston Churchill said, let us go forward together in our united strength and let us promote the common good.
0:08:22 I thank you for this honor.
0:08:33 Next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input.
0:08:36 If there's anyone who wishes to address the council on an item that does not come the agenda this evening,
0:08:40 now is your opportunity to please come forward.
0:08:43 Council wishes.
0:09:02 The consent calendar as presented.
0:09:07 Mr. Reid, the motion by a student seconded by Christopher Reid to approve the consent calendar for any discussion.
0:09:20 John Pereger.
0:09:30 Yes.
0:09:31 Nikki Boyd.
0:09:32 Yes.
0:09:33 Is Ann Hawkins? Yes, Greg Lanting? Yes, Ruth Pierce? Yes, Christopher Reed? Yes, motion passes 6-0.
0:09:42 Looking around the audience I see there are several people here who are here for special events.
0:09:47 So if you were here for the Magic Island Enforcement Memorial Service request for Saturday,
0:09:54 the Special Olympics 2018 State and Summer Games, the 3rd annual Magic Valley Pride Festival.
0:10:00 Those were all just approved as part of the consent calendar, so you're welcome to stick around for the rest of the show, or you can sneak out.
0:10:07 At next-center items of consideration, the first is a presentation to recognize firefighter Kyle Eldridge for completion of his Twin Falls.
0:10:17 Fire Department firefighter 2, we have Ron Irian, Battalion Chief.
0:10:22 Council, we do appreciate you taking the time to allow us to honor one of our firefighters for his recent accomplishments.
0:10:40 We'd like to welcome Kyle's family as well.
0:10:47 Kyle's here with his wife Paige and his son, Renson.
0:10:50 Did you have?
0:10:51 I swear when I walked in I saw her sit right next to you.
0:11:01 Okay, so Kyle came to us as an EMT from the Magic Valley
0:11:08 paramedics and as an EMT Kyle is probably one of our best EMTs
0:11:14 on the department. I've been on several incidents with him
0:11:17 and he just does a fantastic job.
0:11:20 He's working his way into being just an equal level firefighter.
0:11:27 So some of his accomplishments since Kyle has been here.
0:11:30 He started on the fire department February 1st 2016.
0:11:33 He earned his firefighter one certificate on December 1st 2016.
0:11:39 He became a tender driver on June 29th 2017, a relief engine driver on August 30th 2017.
0:11:48 And now we're here to recognize him for achieving his firefighter level 2.
0:11:52 So he's moving through this stuff really, really quickly and to get to the level that he's at right now in this short amount of time.
0:11:59 He really does deserve some accommodation. He is just an outstanding, outstanding firefighter.
0:12:07 So I'm very proud to be here tonight to present Kyle with his level 2 certificate.
0:12:10 I've asked the chief to come down and actually present him with a certificate witness with the mayor.
0:12:16 On a personal note, Kyle really is a true servant leader of PCs, going to do great things for the city and the fire department. So, congratulations Kyle.
0:12:35 Congratulations Kyle. I thought your son seemed to be enjoying the council meeting.
0:13:16 Buddy, at the beginning, sorry you couldn't stick around.
0:13:22 Next on the agenda is a request to approve the Crazy Days on Main Event on June 2nd, 2018.
0:13:28 and we have Sergeant Justin Nyman with our
0:13:31 False Police Department.
0:13:32 Mayor, members of council.
0:13:40 Virginia Twin Falls has received a special event application
0:13:43 for an event entitled Crazy Days on Maine,
0:13:47 which is the application request to be held on June 2nd, 2018
0:13:52 from 12 o'clock to seven o'clock p.m.
0:13:55 I've actually asked the event organizer,
0:13:58 Hincey Taylor, to come to council tonight
0:14:01 to kind of explain what the event is,
0:14:03 What some of the activities are that are going to take place during the event and then answer any questions you have.
0:14:10 One thing I would add is there may be more public input from others as well following her comments.
0:14:17 Welcome, Kenzie.
0:14:21 Okay, so we want to bring back crazy days.
0:14:35 It was a successful event back in the days like a big sidewalk cell where everybody goes out on the sidewalks, has deals.
0:14:47 Back then they did. It's just right at the part.
0:15:17 What we wanted to do was kind of spin off of western days and kind of tag on to it and make it Saturday of western days to just get more old share of medals.
0:16:43 And so on, Dweix is going to do it on a circle and whoever first loses for kids and adults.
0:17:39 It said that we would have it with serving.
0:18:32 Just for back in the sixties.
0:18:34 I was a kid.
0:18:36 I was a sergeant, I'm an equal counsel on this issue, so if you would like to do so now, sure.
0:19:27 This is on main avenue, Jensen Jewelers.
0:19:46 I'm here in support of this event, it is a long standing, as Councilman Landing said,
0:19:53 it is a long standing, crazy day event that had lost its way for a while. I'm very excited
0:20:00 that someone is picking that back up and making it part of Western days back in the days when
0:20:05 I was on the VID. We did a shoot out in conjunction with Western days downtown Clinton, and I'm
0:20:13 I'm very excited to see that part of it coming back build a better center community
0:20:17 for all of the folks anyone else who wishes to speak on this issue
0:20:25 The West Bank Committee is embracing this in a soft form. I was a former P.I.D. here.
0:20:48 I'm concerned that it's had troubles in the past time of the West Bank and if something happens around town
0:21:02 it falls back in yesterday's same week we caught it. So we've made a real purpose to make sure that
0:21:09 Anybody doesn't outside of it. Don't use the Western day. Keep our clothes clean. Make our art.
0:21:16 We make all of our funds, mostly off the donations to pay for the Davis that we do.
0:21:25 So when they start having stuff around town, you can cut the pie in the smart pieces and hurt us.
0:21:30 They say most of the committee is improving us through the House, but I just wanted to consider,
0:21:35 there's other weekends too. You start putting more shows every weekend, whatever your show has.
0:22:06 I would like to comment that I think it's a grand idea, Kenzie.
0:22:22 I appreciate all your hard work.
0:22:24 It sounds like to me the name is Crazy Days, even though it's got some sort of western theme.
0:22:29 It's going to be Crazy Days like we used to have all the clothes out on the sidewalk, so I would support an event like this.
0:22:39 this.
0:22:40 And you're interested, Zann Hawkins.
0:22:41 Mr. Daze, there's only so much time you can spend on the events that are there and having
0:22:53 another place to go with them and let them take a break from the park and go down and
0:22:58 see the gun shoot out or whatever's happening.
0:23:01 And then go back to the park.
0:23:02 I think it might even drop more of the congestion out of that.
0:23:07 So it's a better fit for everybody.
0:23:10 So, as Ren said, I am in favor of this.
0:23:13 I would just like to add, I do think it's a great way to bring back part of our history
0:23:40 and also try to capitalize on a lot of energy and excitement in town.
0:23:45 I am optimistic that it will not too much of a crowd away from western days,
0:23:50 I think it will bring this part of town and chance to do that.
0:24:00 So if further discussion, do you have anything you wanted to add?
0:24:14 Yes, I whole-heart support with both Ruth and Susanne said I think it's a wonderful addition.
0:24:21 And I'm very excited for it.
0:24:24 Nicky Boyd?
0:24:28 Yes.
0:24:29 Zann Hawkins? Yes.
0:24:31 Greg Lanting? Yes.
0:24:34 Ruth Pierce? Yes.
0:24:36 Christopher Reed? Yes.
0:24:38 Don Bericher? Yes.
0:24:40 Motion passes at 6-0.
0:24:44 Next on the agenda is a request to approve a contract with Pivot North BRS to conduct a feasibility study for a community recreation center.
0:24:53 Now, Wendy Davis, our Parks and Recreation Director.
0:24:56 Good evening, Mayor. Council, it's my pleasure to be back with this request again.
0:25:37 We were here in February and the decision was tabled with a request to bring back some more information regarding the feasibility study in the process.
0:25:48 Subsequently, we set up a meeting with the ad hoc committee and the council to go through
0:25:55 any questions and concerns council may have, give the committee an opportunity to share
0:25:59 some of their enthusiasm for the process and for the feasibility study.
0:26:05 And I think a few things came out of that that we hope to address this evening.
0:26:10 But before I go much further, I'd like to have my committee.
0:26:14 There's several of them here in the audience this evening, so they'd like to stand up
0:26:17 up and way about you. Some of them are speaking, some of them are
0:26:26 cheering and some of them are here to answer questions, whatever you need from them. So
0:26:31 during our meeting we identified several things that seem to be a concern to the
0:26:40 Council. One was the desire to have more information regarding the value of
0:26:45 feasibility study, include a statistically valid survey as part of
0:26:50 of the study, and then clearly identify the phases of the study and assign a cost to each
0:26:57 one of those so that we have a jumping out point at any time so that we can address concerns
0:27:02 and evaluate the process of the study and make decisions as we move forward with that.
0:27:08 And Clint, when he goes through the contract for a minute, we'll cover some of those.
0:27:14 Before I go any further with that, I'd like to talk a little bit about why we think
0:27:19 study is important and some of the things that came up as part of our discussion.
0:27:24 After we developed the RFQ, the committee decided we kind of fun to go around the room
0:27:29 and have everybody talk about what a recreation center meant to them.
0:27:34 And as you can imagine, there's 15 people in the room and not surprisingly, there was
0:27:38 15 different ideas of what it means to have a recreation center or what the spaces within
0:27:45 recreation center ought to be, including aquatic centers, and I bring these pictures
0:27:52 because I want you to look at not only the differences in aquatic centers but the different
0:27:58 ways that they can be developed and done even just within a category.
0:28:06 We also talked about fitness, we talked about indoor tennis courts, we talked about indoor
0:28:12 soccer fields, we talked about baseball fields, we talked about incorporating base jumping,
0:28:19 We talked about classroom space, and I think I went too fast.
0:28:26 We talked about gymnasium space, social spaces, gathering places, senior centers, and all kinds of things.
0:28:35 So, as we started looking around, then we decided to do a little bit of research into some of the surrounding areas.
0:28:44 And now you can kind of take a look at what we found as far as some of the surrounding areas.
0:28:49 So Jerome has a recreation center.
0:28:52 That center is pretty specific to that community.
0:28:55 There is an existing facility that is still the core
0:28:58 of the recreation center, but then they build up
0:29:01 around the center to expand on those facilities offered.
0:29:06 The NEMPA recreation center has five swimming pools inside,
0:29:10 a track, it's attached to the senior center,
0:29:14 completely self-supporting.
0:29:16 The Lehigh Legacy Center,
0:29:18 If you want to take a look at that swimming pool, that's pretty cool.
0:29:23 Outdoor slide that comes down and then goes back into the pool, the South Davis Recreation
0:29:30 Center.
0:29:31 And then we have gypsum, and gypsum was one that is a 5,000, a community of 5,000 with
0:29:39 a recreation district of 11,000.
0:29:40 This one's owned by the city and operated by the district.
0:29:45 It costs about $9 million to build it and it's 50,000 square feet.
0:29:49 It's a ranching community, and the facility that reflected the ranching community was important
0:29:56 to them.
0:29:57 So this is how they address some of their needs.
0:30:01 Morehead is in Aurora, Colorado, it's an Hispanic community.
0:30:07 Luminaries were a big part of importance in that community, and so they tried to incorporate
0:30:13 a luminary look within the building, as well as some of the lighting features throughout
0:30:18 bright colors. This facility also, it's 38,000 square feet. It's a neighborhood recreation center.
0:30:27 It was phased in to include the pool. So the pool was built as an outside facility
0:30:32 with a future need to be closed. And then they went ahead and closed it as part of that project.
0:30:38 Samamish is in Washington. This one didn't have a lot of space, so they stacked it. They put the
0:30:45 the pool on the bottom, put the fitness center and thing on top of it to stack it. The point
0:30:52 of looking at all these lots of multi-use space, lounge areas were really important to
0:30:58 them so they really focused on lounge areas. But what I'm really trying to get out with
0:31:04 this is that there's a big variety out there and there's no such thing as a cookie cutter
0:31:07 approach to building a recreation center. And so what we're hoping we can accomplish
0:31:12 by doing a feasibility study is to define what a recreation center means to Twin Falls.
0:31:21 What does this community need?
0:31:22 How do we address what's important to us and what would it need to look like and how would
0:31:29 it operate?
0:31:31 So I would like to invite Brian Wright to come up and talk to you a little bit about the
0:31:35 value of a feasibility study.
0:31:37 and council members, thank you Wendy, I want to be succinct but also with the idea of why well and let me explain my names bright and right I'm a committee member for the recreation center for Twin Falls and over the months that we've been together we've
0:32:01 Well, very strongly that we want to represent the city of Twin Falls at the highest level
0:32:07 for appropriate levels of voting for the Shrek Center or not. And like Wendy alluded to, the
0:32:14 variety of rec centers you see here are just a scratch on the surface of what's out there.
0:32:21 Tailoring, something as big as a rec center, something as important as that is maybe central
0:32:27 to some cities, maybe even our city, is so important.
0:32:31 And when you tailor something like at Rec Center to the city,
0:32:35 the worst possible thing you could do is, right, guess or stab at it.
0:32:40 And bias is a big mistake.
0:32:44 And in any setting, when you're looking at whether something should be one way or another,
0:32:49 there's a lot of bias, as Wendy talked about, there's about 15 different opinions,
0:32:53 even on the committee, just on what a Rec Center might look like.
0:32:57 And a lot of strong feelings about it.
0:32:59 Some people may feel like they don't want a rec center.
0:33:02 Some people feel like they really want a rec center.
0:33:05 And in formal and formal surveys, I
0:33:07 think we've been able to determine that there are many
0:33:09 people of our community that would strongly desire a rec center.
0:33:13 Maybe in some informal surveys that are some who don't want one.
0:33:17 When the stakes are higher, a feasibility study is the most
0:33:22 important thing.
0:33:23 If the stakes are not that high, you can kind of wing it
0:33:27 with people's biases of taking formal surveys
0:33:29 to send out emails and maybe put something
0:33:31 through a certain survey online or something like that.
0:33:36 When it comes to higher stakes in representing what the people
0:33:39 of the Magic Valley and surrounding areas would want,
0:33:43 the question here today is not whether
0:33:45 or not we should have a rec center.
0:33:46 The question is, is the most logical next step
0:33:49 to have a feasibility study?
0:33:51 Is the ethical thing to do to represent those
0:33:54 that may not want a rec center in our community
0:33:56 to do a feasibility study, I think, for those that don't want it absolutely, is the ethical
0:34:01 thing to do for those that do want a rec center, a feasibility study, I think, without question.
0:34:07 If there is a question to whether or not there should be an unbiased or party, I think there
0:34:14 are a lot of different studies out there that I won't bore you with on tonight, but there
0:34:19 are a lot of studies showing the value of a feasibility study in these settings where
0:34:24 things are higher state. Personally speaking I have business that has multiple clinics
0:34:30 in different areas and I've experienced personally both not doing feasibility studies and performing
0:34:37 them. The clinic that I built on falls of locust is probably one of the best examples of not performing
0:34:44 a feasibility study. We've remodeled it five times in five years and while I'm proud of its current state
0:34:51 It has cost me a lot of money to remodel.
0:34:56 Remodels was substantial, and it cost me a lot.
0:34:59 Part of that was thinking I knew, thinking I knew
0:35:02 what was needed and moving forward
0:35:05 because I was anxious to move the project along
0:35:07 and not in my state, in my immature state back.
0:35:13 And of course not now, the desire to maybe think
0:35:18 that I knew it all.
0:35:21 I was a single board member at the time.
0:35:24 So who else am I going to counsel with?
0:35:27 Still it was a mistake.
0:35:28 The city is not a single council member.
0:35:31 The council is not a single council member.
0:35:32 The committee is not a single council member.
0:35:35 The question at hand here is very important
0:35:38 that we understand that the feasibility study
0:35:40 is the most ethical thing to do more than next step.
0:35:45 In a city that is expressed,
0:35:47 that we look at this with more than just a glance.
0:35:50 And so I fully support a feasibility study
0:35:54 for that reason in my personal experience,
0:35:56 as well as the studies that would represent that.
0:36:00 So, at this time, I'll turn the time over to Trevor Morgan,
0:36:04 who is at large council, our committee member
0:36:06 for our committee.
0:36:15 Thanks, I appreciate being here.
0:36:18 Wendy asked me to touch on how we selected Pivot North
0:36:23 as the one to conduct the feasibility study.
0:36:27 So, I'll just touch on that briefly
0:36:29 before introducing Clint from Pivot North.
0:36:33 We set out a request for qualifications to different firms who could conduct a feasibility study.
0:36:41 And we had five to six responses.
0:36:44 We formed a subcommittee to narrow that down to the top three.
0:36:50 And then we invited those three to meet with the Rec Center Committee and present to us what they had to offer for the city of Twin Falls.
0:37:02 Pivot North, we felt as a committee was the most prepared and they put the most effort
0:37:11 into their presentation. That's not a knock on the other gentlemen, but we felt not only
0:37:20 that Pivot North wanted to do this the most, but that they were also the most qualified.
0:37:27 It was even a super close vote. One of these was on board with Pivot North.
0:37:42 We really liked that Clint falls. He's done a lot of projects here. Very familiar with the area. That was a huge bonus to us.
0:37:53 So we're super excited about Clint and Pivot North. I want to portray that to you.
0:38:00 And also our desire to move along with them and our belief that they'll conduct a very professional accurate survey
0:38:11 and also be able to help get the community involved when the time comes.
0:38:17 So, without further ado, I'd like to introduce Clint Seaters,
0:38:21 and key Mr. Mayor, members of the Council,
0:38:32 and I believe you've had a chance to review your packet materials.
0:38:35 That's what I've got of as well.
0:38:37 And I'm showing just the one-page graphic in the schedule,
0:38:41 because I think it most clearly and simply defines the steps
0:38:45 and what this feasibility study process would look like.
0:38:48 To take a step back, the last fall when the selection was made, and when we started talking about this process and what it would be in this BRS,
0:38:59 the original experts that they are really downloaded, city staff and myself on what this can look like and what is frequently done.
0:39:10 And so using what was in the RFQ and their experience nationwide, we really broadcast a full service.
0:39:20 I think it's obvious, but there's a lot of varying degrees, community sizes, different
0:39:33 needs.
0:39:34 And so that feasibility study can range from very small service to a very large service.
0:39:41 Where we started with this, I think, was a very type service that's consistent with
0:39:48 national averages, other communities that VRS is working with throughout the country.
0:39:54 But I know that as presented to city staff, there's a little bit of reservation with
0:39:59 the amount of money that it was going to cost in this, and so we really took a step back,
0:40:04 all worked together to get in the study, and well at the same time, and so in the letter,
0:40:14 the cover letter that I prepared, and you're where we started, here's how we backed out
0:40:21 some of the time and effort that goes into these studies to save the city so many, so
0:40:26 I think this service is a good premise, I think it's something that you're...
0:40:36 So what I thought I would do is just summarize the steps balance survey that's actually a
0:40:46 consultant to us.
0:40:47 And of course it's a certain question.
0:40:55 So the way we approach this is basically a three-step service.
0:40:59 And I think I'll just to add to begin with what we propose is an hourly not to exceed
0:41:05 type service for the feasibility studies.
0:41:07 So this is something that if right out of the gates for a month or six weeks and there
0:41:13 seems to be some reservation or some red flags that come up we can stop
0:41:19 so on the other side of it if there's a service or a different type of survey or some other thing that we need to
0:41:29 promote so just know that the service is flexible, you're bidding to spending, you'd like to do, just take step one
0:41:41 and see how much value, how much consensus is there, what the program looks like, conversation around
0:41:54 So, step one is, they're organized by committee workshops and open houses, open house, and you've also got an executive team in your committee, and in your leadership plan to meet with us.
0:42:15 So, what's important now to step one, starts to understand what a admission is for the process and if an infarec center frayed for the community, we're going to confirm a program list.
0:42:49 It's simply a space list of what goes into a facility.
0:42:57 Attached quantities and square foot sizes do that.
0:43:01 BRS, I've seen an exercise that they do where it's kind of a fun plane.
0:43:08 There's different sizes of pools, for example.
0:43:14 So you have everything from leisure pool to a five lane competition pool.
0:43:22 You start to understand what pool.
0:43:26 So on and so forth, it works through that with fitness and other parts of the facility.
0:43:38 We get to see adjacencies, how they start to happen.
0:43:43 Still pretty, we can start to get sizes,
0:43:50 we can start to get adjacencies on something like that.
0:43:59 We've started to find out in step one
0:44:01 is what are the challenges, what are the threats,
0:44:04 and what are the strengths.
0:44:06 So we'll start to find out how divided the community is
0:44:10 about its facility and the amenities that go in,
0:44:16 starts to represent itself in a business plan.
0:44:20 So BRS has a specialist, John, on their team,
0:44:24 who does business plans for X-Tenders,
0:44:26 that's his full-time job.
0:44:28 And so what he'll do, as we work through program
0:44:31 and amendment is favorable to the public
0:44:34 and to your committee, he'll start to put that in.
0:44:38 So as we go along, it boils down to what the goals,
0:44:52 if it's subsidized or if it's not agreed,
0:44:57 let's types of things, but through that process
0:44:59 and through his business plan, we'll start to get there.
0:45:02 Let's see what that looks like.
0:45:05 So there's a lot of meetings with that step one.
0:45:08 It's a real place in the process, and it's a good checkpoint, and we do the same thing, a little bit more abbreviated with step two and three, but by then you're starting to learn our detail.
0:45:22 We can start to put some costs to what that size is, not only construction costs, but cost to operate.
0:45:33 And then, of course, step three is to find even further where we have a final business plan this time.
0:45:43 So with that.
0:45:49 So in conclusion staff recommends or committee supports council approving the
0:46:16 request to move forward with this contract to the noise.
0:46:20 We'll have some discussion, Nicky, did you want to weigh in first, should you put that representative to the
0:46:30 committee?
0:46:31 Sure.
0:46:32 Very much for the thorough information that's been provided this evening by Wendy and
0:46:42 and I and I really appreciate all of them and I'm I'm very used with the process of
0:46:53 our and very much forward to a very moving so much you've been working on this and conversations
0:47:28 and expressing yourselves to the council so thank you real quick what is it going to look
0:47:35 like in between each step or step one step two step three is that going to be something
0:47:42 and come back and present between each one.
0:47:46 So as we complete each phase,
0:47:48 we'll come back with a report of what we learned
0:47:51 and what the recommendation is about moving forward with it.
0:47:55 If we have any concerns in the middle of the process,
0:47:57 we can address those as well.
0:47:58 If we feel like there's things we need to add,
0:48:00 but primarily the idea with those three phase step
0:48:04 is to report back after each phase,
0:48:07 what we learned and what happens next.
0:48:12 for this item and where we're going to forget my stamp report.
0:48:35 So we didn't have $10,000 for the committee
0:48:40 and sort of toward the process.
0:48:42 But the expectation is that we would use general fund dollars to,
0:48:49 so it would be general fund dollars that we would use
0:48:57 to supplement the rest of the expense.
0:48:59 So approximately $114,000 is what we're talking about right now
0:49:03 for the study as Clint proposed, including a statistically valid survey.
0:49:10 I'm still struggling a lot with the number on the other. There's so many needs in the city right now, departments and other places.
0:49:19 But I know that the community has reached out on this issue.
0:49:22 It's a personally like torn to make sure we're wise with the dollars we have to spread around much easier to look at.
0:49:38 I don't want to be the negative one up here at the committee's put in so much time, and I appreciate that. I just want to make sure we're being very conscious of every dollar we spend on this project.
0:50:04 So Wendy or Clint, the statistically valid survey you're talking about, I don't recall it being discussed before, and it looks like it falls somewhere between step one and step two.
0:50:19 Can you go into, because I remember the number 98 and now we're at 114, so if you could just go maybe into a little more detail.
0:50:30 Well the Statistic Revalid Survey is about $60,000, so that's what takes the 98,000 up to the 114 approximately.
0:50:38 The idea and the placement of the survey is that I think it's, on BRS' recommendation, it's really difficult to go to the community and ask for their support
0:50:48 their interest until they really know what we're talking about. Like I said, right now
0:50:53 there's 15 ideas of what a recreation center on the committee is, and I bet if we add it
0:50:58 all up here as we could probably have 20. So starting to define what that looks like,
0:51:07 and then we have something that we're really asking the community about, so they kind of
0:51:10 know what we're asking and what they can seek their teeth into rather than just saying,
0:51:14 But I think that was why they recommended placing it after we've done some of the work to identify.
0:51:21 Does that answer your question or is that a little bit more than that?
0:51:25 I got the math. I got the math. I was just the survey is what was kind of a new item.
0:51:30 Do you want to know what type of survey it is?
0:51:32 No, I read what type of survey it was.
0:51:34 Okay, but it was new. So, okay, perfect.
0:51:38 So, just a quick refresher when the City Council and the Committee got together, it was expressed
0:51:46 by the Council, that there were some members of the Council that there was a need to have
0:51:50 a Statistic Value and Survey as a part of this process, and so that's why it was included.
0:51:55 On the S&I apologise, I was one of the ones that was really like to see a survey, several
0:52:11 different reasons, one, two, three, I mean I've certainly had a lot of people, me and talked
0:52:19 me about it. I'm so interested in it, and it is the community. It probably is, but I think a lot of people are
0:52:30 probably like me. I've been a member of a lot of different direct centers, but privately we're
0:52:36 probably facilities. I think I was even a member of some Polk Canyon walls, Brackett Ball
0:52:42 Club at one point, and I'm a member of the goals at one point now. I'm currently a member of the CSI facility.
0:52:52 I see the reason for this, but it also points to me the fact that we do have other things available in the community.
0:53:05 So, we'll be in favor of doing this, especially I like the tiered approach and the survey after the step one.
0:53:15 So that we can, after step one, and if it's just not happening, we choose not to, or we can choose to go forward.
0:53:24 I definitely want the survey, though, for two reasons. I didn't complete my thought.
0:53:30 I thought one did all gauge community sport, but two, gauge whether we can make this feasible
0:53:38 because we already lose, not sure if the exact number, so I'm not really ready to step into a new facility
0:53:51 if it's going to be another grade, and so that's the kind of things I'd like to be able to find out from the
0:53:57 part of the city's mission that makes sense, and then the pool would probably make money if we didn't have the level, so it's kind of a catch there.
0:54:23 The biggest thing is, you know, the rec center, I can out of this, is knowledge of, yes, formation
0:55:19 that knowledge is extremely powerful, go forward, mess up on that, spend this money and find
0:55:36 out either way whatever that knowledge is, that if it's a no, bring to us, if we spend
0:55:42 more time, we can say, you want to know something, we did this feasibility, spend a
0:55:46 number of it, you want the same thing over and you'll get that and say, this is what
0:56:14 is willing to do, or as BRS can bring to this process.
0:56:30 And for me, truth of the business planning and operating,
0:56:37 what does this thing look like in the first place,
0:56:39 and what does that cost and how am I going to pay for it?
0:56:41 I think the expertise of, as I mentioned,
0:56:44 BRS having someone on staff that that's all they do,
0:56:47 is they say, okay, these are the amenities you want,
0:56:49 here's the reality of how that passes.
0:56:52 Those are things that I think we need to make good decisions
0:56:56 There's lots of, if the other thing I would read,
0:57:17 said earlier, thank you all for the time and passion
0:57:20 that I think you've all put into this.
0:57:22 Passion may be, because certainly,
0:57:30 this is a little less about the well-liss component of it,
0:57:34 and it's about the placemaking in our community.
0:57:37 It's the community part of community recreation center,
0:57:42 and less the recreation part of the region center.
0:57:46 Listening to some of the community
0:57:49 or past experiences in other communities
0:57:51 to be able to spend time with their family,
0:57:53 what they're in facilities like this.
0:57:58 I think the value in that helps us to tick off a lot of our expertise
0:58:14 that we can do to us for the points segmented so that we don't get way down the road
0:58:25 and go home like how this thing is either great and let's keep moving
0:58:30 or it's horrible in what we're thinking.
0:58:32 So I look forward to that communication back and forth
0:58:35 and the continuing engagement members because again,
0:58:38 and her passion in this really is helping to drive
0:58:43 I think the excellence from the solvers
0:58:45 from the student that you wanted to have.
0:58:59 I'd be happy to make it.
0:59:05 All righty, to the north and BRS
0:59:17 to conduct the ability, community recreation.
0:59:23 Second.
0:59:25 Motion by, thank you, boys.
0:59:27 Second by Ruth.
0:59:28 I'm pleased to approve the request as presented
0:59:33 as they're from the discussion.
0:59:34 Great landing.
0:59:36 Actually, any other discussion from the dean
0:59:45 then, Sharon, roll call vote, please.
0:59:48 President Hopkins, Ruth Bierce, Christopher Reed, Sean Barrieger, Hickey Boy, yes.
1:00:09 Motion passes 6 to 0. Next on the agenda is a request to waive the nonconforming building
1:00:23 expansion permit process for a residential home located at 219 Lenore Street, Jonathan
1:00:32 Spenceland, Mark Heine, Consuming Director.
1:00:33 What we have here is a residential home that is asking to waive the nonconforming building
1:00:52 expansion process to add essentially a carport or covered parking area on the front of the
1:00:58 house.
1:00:59 Or if it is up, up on the east side, the area in blue is the proposed carport.
1:01:05 What makes the house nonconforming is the side yard setback which is in pink or purple.
1:01:10 The five yard setback in that home was built.
1:01:13 It's approximately two feet away from the property line. There's an eave so it looks like it's right on it
1:01:18 But that it's really bad too what they're asking is to build that carport
1:01:23 Right in line with the approach further into that setback. It's just kind of line straight up with the house
1:01:30 It will also be in the front yard setback
1:01:36 We go closer to the 23rd property line, which is what the zone requires, a waiver of the process through a motion to amend it up council.
1:01:54 We have to waive the non-conforming buildings, and we have to permit process through the residential home located at 219 Lenoir Street.
1:02:07 I think second by Christopher Reed to a process as presented.
1:02:18 Well, this is similar to what we've had. As long as they're not encroaching even more into their place, they're already encroached, and you're not going to make them move to the house at this point.
1:02:33 That's obvious, so as long as they're not getting any farther towards their neighbor, I cannot see the reason
1:02:40 What a good parent discussion. Great landing. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Christopher Reed. Yes. Sean Barricker. Yes. Nicky Boy. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes.
1:03:03 Motion passes 6-0. Thank you, Jonathan. Next is a request to establish a minimum value
1:03:10 for the public auction of real property located at 324 Hanson Street East. We have Mitch Humbler,
1:03:15 Deputy City Manager. Welcome, Mitch. Thanks, process 2. For sale, the Hanson Building
1:03:29 at 324 Hanson Street East. When we did that, the Council approved us to go ahead and proceed
1:03:36 with that. When we talked about the minimum bid value, there was an interest in setting
1:03:42 a minimum bid, but I'm not sure how much for that.
1:03:48 So what we did is since then we've gotten a quick appraisal
1:03:52 of the property, just to kind of give us a better feel
1:03:55 for what that property, basically I didn't give you
1:04:07 the whole praise, it's like 40-some pages,
1:04:09 you just have like the cover letter,
1:04:11 which gives you the estimate of marketing.
1:04:18 So, tonight is kind of set that minimum value,
1:04:22 and then we'll go forward with the notice period,
1:04:26 the hurt, some activity.
1:04:50 That's really all we need is to say.
1:04:52 What year did we find?
1:05:15 We spent some time re-mothing. I want to say we paid them. We also put in doing appraisals back in the time.
1:06:07 And so, yes.
1:06:56 At the market, and I think I would explain.
1:07:26 It has some access issues, especially ADA access issues,
1:08:07 that maybe a new owner could get come to agreement with the restricting that ADA access issues
1:08:16 or causing that ADA access issues, because the access is on their property.
1:08:22 We were
1:08:39 It took us a few years, but we were eventually able to
1:08:41 That was between us and them, that that was necessarily
1:08:44 There certainly is an opportunity
1:08:51 I guess I would also have some of them to go from all the appraisal
1:08:54 Cause I'm like Suzanne, that was
1:09:00 But obviously somebody can choose to pay more than that
1:09:02 As in an in an in an auction
1:09:12 But where it's at, in Flint Falls, we're expecting to just send it right in
1:09:41 We established the minimum value for the public auction
1:09:44 property at three Torvansons Street East to be set at $200,000.
1:09:49 Such a motion by accident how consecutive I read peers to establish the minimum value for
1:09:57 the public auction property located at three twenty four hands the street east of two hundred
1:10:02 and thousand dollars cancel discussion great late.
1:10:05 Well one more thing to add I guess that is somewhat the danger of going out and getting
1:10:10 appraisal when we asked for it we found out it was more than we thought so that was our
1:10:16 We caused that number to be...
1:10:19 Ruth Pierce?
1:10:36 Yes.
1:10:37 Christopher Reed?
1:10:38 Yes.
1:10:39 Sean Berriger?
1:10:40 Yes.
1:10:41 Nicky Boyd?
1:10:42 Yes.
1:10:43 Suzanne Hawkins?
1:10:44 Yes.
1:10:45 Greg Lanting?
1:10:46 Yes.
1:10:47 I should pass it 6-0.
1:10:48 Pimich, next on the agenda is another opportunity for general public input.
1:10:54 If there's anyone here from the public who wishes to address the council now,
1:10:56 should your opportunity please come forward?
1:10:58 Any advisory board reports of the council?
1:11:06 May I miss anything from the city manager's?
1:11:12 I'm Mr. Mayor, I'm Mr. Council just two quick reminders.
1:11:15 One relationship to the officers,
1:11:23 but more ceremony that's going to occur lost at the end.
1:11:33 Obviously, tomorrow is election day,
1:11:34 so please go out and vote for all the national,
1:11:38 state, and county wide motion seats
1:11:42 that are up for your consideration.
1:11:51 We are adjourned.
Download
- Transcript (text) 46 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 59 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 78 KB
- Audio (M4A) 17.0 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, May 14, 2018. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:12:02.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
bb2b97e6047be8fff3cc7b31b2aae5737af26fb83b1255964f1e3dda15a29b11 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 95f1e861a2959d2c957b403c821e59c7f377adcd2aaa9673b24dd81954fcf122 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
ef675d79b86a56da20bdb75b2c93cf25e5b3a51c3d198f619d59a2b9fd120c87
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file