OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, April 15, 2019

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on filePacket on file

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

The audio for this recording isn't posted yet. It's being held back until a privacy review is finished. The transcript below is complete apart from marked passages.

Transcript

0:00:05 Good evening. I would like to call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday, April 15th and confirm that we do have a quorum up the council here, six to seven members are present.

0:00:15 Councilwoman Pierce is excused this evening. Next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. For those of you wishing to join us, please rise.

0:00:23 Next on the agenda are proclamations and we do have a proclamation this evening for telecommunicators week.

0:00:51 April 14th through the 16th 2019, whereas emergencies that require police or fire

0:00:58 services can occur at any time. And whereas when an emergency occurs, the

0:01:03 prompt response of police officers and firefighters is critical to the

0:01:07 protection of life and preservation of property. And whereas the safety of our

0:01:11 police officers and firefighters is dependent upon the quality and accuracy

0:01:15 of information obtained from citizens who contact the City Communication Center.

0:01:20 And whereas public safety emergency communications officers are the first and most critical contact our citizens have with emergency services.

0:01:29 And whereas public safety emergency communications officers are the single vital link for our public safety responders,

0:01:36 I provided them information actively engaging in and monitoring their activities and ensuring their safety.

0:01:43 and whereas public safety emergency communications officers of the City of Twin Falls have contributed

0:01:49 substantially to the apprehension of criminals, suppression of fires and treatment of the injured.

0:01:54 And whereas each emergency communications officer has exhibited compassion, understanding and

0:02:01 professionalism in the performance of their job in the past year, now therefore I, Sean

0:02:06 Berriger, mayor of the City of Twin Falls to be hereby proclaimed telecommunicators week

0:02:11 in Twin Falls, Idaho, and urge all City of Twin Falls citizens to join in this observance.

0:02:17 Here to accept this this evening, we have Tammy Lauden, our Communications Manager.

0:02:21 Good evening.

0:02:59 Good evening.

0:03:02 Thank you for this opportunity to talk about our 9-1-1 Communications Center.

0:03:08 I have a few quotes because that's easier than me talking.

0:03:13 To talk to someone and give them hope and help to get them through a crisis.

0:03:17 To be able to give officers information to keep them safe.

0:03:20 Every single day I make a difference in at least one person's life."

0:03:23 That's a quote from a 911 operator.

0:03:26 Emergency communications is a critical infrastructure to a city.

0:03:31 This is a profession that I find so worthy of our admiration.

0:03:35 The House 911 SAVES Act, which now has a companion Senate bill, is asking for 911 emergency

0:03:41 communications officers to be reclassified as protective class by the federal standards

0:03:47 of occupational classification.

0:03:49 I told them they should yell out, breathe, because I forget to do that when I'm up here.

0:03:57 I'd like to read an excerpt from Representative Normatoras in her announcement of the bill.

0:04:03 The decision that 911 dispatchers make, life-saving decisions made in just a few seconds,

0:04:08 are certainly worthy of considering them first responders.

0:04:11 They are the first in line of defense when crime happens.

0:04:15 All right.

0:04:20 He hard pressed to find administrative staff who are required to undergo the amount of training

0:04:28 and evaluations that is required of a public safety dispatcher.

0:04:31 This is a specialized occupation that requires professionals to think critically and use extensive

0:04:36 skills and training to help first responders stabilize and keep our community safe.

0:04:43 In our center in 2018, we handled almost 100,000 non-emergency calls, 45,901 calls,

0:04:55 3,700 alarms, 58,000 police events,

0:05:01 5,400 fire events, and during all of this,

0:05:04 they have three primary frequencies to take care of.

0:05:07 The daytime hours in our center, 48 to 65 minutes

0:05:11 of talk time will be generated

0:05:13 from the phone calls that they take.

0:05:15 They do all of that while they're talking

0:05:18 on the radio to police and fire code enforcement.

0:05:23 They are extraordinary professionals, and truly are the first of the first responders.

0:05:32 Let's see. Thank you, Tammy.

0:05:38 I guess I would like to ask with our growing community, are we, are we stressed too thin yet, or are we meeting the call with them at a quad response time?

0:05:47 You know what? They do a brilliant job with their call load of meeting their standard times. They really do.

0:05:53 We are always in the process as is every center in the nation is understaffed.

0:06:00 It's a hard place to staff.

0:06:02 So we are constantly working on staffing, but they do a fantastic job.

0:06:11 Nice, your team.

0:06:13 So tonight we have Postrata and Tyler Schreier here with us tonight.

0:06:23 Welcome, thank you for all that you do and for being a part of the city team to help the community.

0:06:33 Next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input. If there's anyone here who wishes to address the council on an item that is not on the agenda this evening, now is your opportunity to please come forward.

0:06:43 Seeing no one, we will move on to the consent calendar. Council wishes. Suzanne Hawkins.

0:07:02 So, before we make a motion on this, I did send Amy an email today, but she is out sick today and made two corrections to the minutes that I'd like to make you work.

0:07:13 She did respond to me and let me know that she would make these tomorrow if we're good with it.

0:07:17 Okay.

0:07:18 So, the first one was on the consent calendar item F. She showed the vote as 6-0-1.

0:07:23 And to my recollection, it should have been 5-1-1 because I believe Councilman talking to the vote to the negative on that.

0:07:30 Correct.

0:07:31 So I asked her to correct that and I also asked her to list that the students from the Commonwealth

0:07:36 School were introduced as well.

0:07:38 Great.

0:07:39 Thank you for those additions.

0:07:40 So, I'd like to make a motion, Susanne.

0:07:41 Sure.

0:07:42 I would move that we approve the consent calendar as presented with the two changes to the minutes

0:07:54 that I just mentioned.

0:07:57 Chris, read.

0:07:58 Second.

0:07:59 Motion by Susanne Hockens and I Christopher Reed to approve the consent calendar with

0:08:03 the noted corrections to the minutes is there for the discussion.

0:08:06 That's when talking to me.

0:08:08 Do you have a?

0:08:09 No.

0:08:11 Lisa Roll call vote, please.

0:08:13 Sean Beriker.

0:08:24 Yes.

0:08:25 Nicky Boyd.

0:08:26 Yes.

0:08:27 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:08:28 Yes.

0:08:29 Greg Lanting.

0:08:30 Yes.

0:08:31 Chris Vareid.

0:08:32 Yes.

0:08:34 Chris Tockington.

0:08:35 Yes.

0:08:36 Motion passes six to zero.

0:08:37 So for reference, the several special event applications that were just on the consent calendar,

0:08:44 So we had the Destadon trail rims at Durkeys Lake Park, the Easter Church gathering at the

0:08:51 City Park, the Canyon Rim Classic Soccer Tournament, the Lights and Lasers at Shoshon Falls, the

0:08:58 events, and also the findings of fact and collusions of law for, so those were all just

0:09:05 approved.

0:09:06 Welcome to Stick around for the rest of the show if you'd like, where you can sneak out.

0:09:13 Next on the agenda under items of consideration, the first is a presentation.

0:09:17 This is a plaque presentation and recognition of service to Cindy Collins Parks and Recreation

0:09:22 Commission.

0:09:23 We have Wendy Davis, our Parks and Recreation Director.

0:09:26 Thank you.

0:09:35 Good evening, Mayor and Council.

0:09:36 It's my pleasure to be here this evening to present this plaque to Cindy Collins.

0:09:42 Cindy came on to the Commission in April of 2016 and served three years on the commission.

0:09:51 The last two years as the chairperson.

0:09:55 She has extensive knowledge of the community through her many years of living here, raising

0:10:05 children here, working in the real estate industry, and just was a really excellent resource for

0:10:14 the committee.

0:10:15 Under her leadership, we've attacked or tackled part of the, I don't know if we attacked it,

0:10:21 of the master plan, Parks and Master Plan started biting that off and identifying what

0:10:28 our goals were as defined through that document and then most recently we've been breaking

0:10:35 it down into parks and starting to identify needs within the parks and so she's been

0:10:42 a great contributor.

0:10:43 I'm really sorry to see her go but I know she's got other things she'd like to do and

0:10:48 So tonight we'd like to recognize her for her three years of service.

0:10:51 Thank you, Cindy.

0:11:29 I'm really going to miss the commission.

0:11:30 I have to tell you, and I love Twin Falls.

0:11:34 And it was so special for me to get to know the other commissioners

0:11:39 and to really know our parks up close and personal.

0:11:43 I love how Wendy helps us with actually not just sitting and making decisions.

0:11:50 But we go out and we visit the parks.

0:11:52 We all had different things, different parks to go look at, and we could look at really

0:11:57 what the needs were.

0:11:59 So to look at it from a different viewpoint was great for me.

0:12:03 And I just loved every minute of it, and even the challenging parts were good.

0:12:09 So thank you so much for the opportunity to serve, and it's just been a real joy for me.

0:12:16 And I told Wendy if she needs to put me on the committee somewhere to just call me, and

0:12:20 I'll jump in.

0:12:21 Thank you.

0:12:22 Thank you, Cindy, for your service.

0:12:24 Thank you.

0:12:25 Cindy, thank you very much.

0:12:26 You've done a lot of things over a lot of years for this community.

0:12:30 But it was fun to serve with you.

0:12:32 And it was really good for the commission.

0:12:34 You're a good chairperson.

0:12:36 And I think everybody learned a lot on that also besides for parks.

0:12:40 Thank you.

0:12:41 Thank you.

0:12:43 And next on the agenda, we have an informational item.

0:12:48 This is an update on the Blue Cross of Idaho Foundation Community Transformation Grant application.

0:12:54 Andy Thompson, our grant and community relations manager,

0:12:58 and then kicked off the show and then I'll add a little bit to that.

0:13:04 Good evening, Mayor, Council. Thank you for having me this evening.

0:13:07 I'm Sean and I just wanted to give you all a quick update on the process.

0:13:12 For those of you who may or for the audience may not be aware of the city applied last fall for a Blue Cross

0:13:19 of Idaho Foundation Community Transformation Grant.

0:13:22 The grant program itself is designed to support community partnerships that focus on improving

0:13:29 the health and wellness of youth in communities around Idaho.

0:13:33 This is the third batch of communities that are receiving these funds.

0:13:42 They've done it every two to three years and each of the communities that have received

0:13:48 these awards have been given the opportunity to take a look at what they're doing within

0:13:55 the confines of city government and local government, but also working with partners

0:13:59 to affect real change in their communities.

0:14:02 So the process included putting together a grant application that I submitted as I said

0:14:07 last fall.

0:14:08 And then we had the pleasure of hosting the executive director of the foundation as well

0:14:17 a couple other staff members here in March. They came and we took them on what we like

0:14:22 to call the wind chill tour of Twin Falls and really tried to showcase not only some

0:14:27 of the things that we're really proud of that we're doing in Twin Falls by means of

0:14:31 wellness and within the community recreation amenities and the such but we also had to

0:14:40 take a few moments to point out those areas that we really could use a little bit of

0:14:45 attention and those areas that we know are falling short of serving the community members

0:14:50 that are living there so it was sort of a highlight tour but then we also wanted to let

0:14:54 them know that we certainly are not done and we have a lot of work to do and so I'll go

0:14:59 ahead and let Sean add to the update.

0:15:03 Great, so thank you Mandy.

0:15:04 So the Blue Cross of Idaho Foundation for Health is also the group that works on the

0:15:09 mayor's school walking challenge that I participated in in the time that I've been mayor and I

0:15:14 know that Mayor Don Hall did as well. So we've been able to receive some smaller

0:15:20 awards. Don came closest and walking way more steps than I did in getting the big

0:15:25 money but we've had a chance to earn some funds from them over time that we've

0:15:29 worked with Parks and Recreation on applying those funds in the community and

0:15:33 also with the school district. In this last year we were able to receive a $10,000

0:15:38 grant from the Blue Cross Idaho Foundation for use. Again we're working

0:15:43 with Parks and Recreation on some distance markers

0:15:46 on the Canyon Room trail system and a chance

0:15:49 to encourage more physical activity and walking.

0:15:53 So I just want to say thanks to Mandy for her work

0:15:56 and helping to put together the application

0:15:58 for this community transformation grant

0:16:02 and certainly a shout out to our partners as well.

0:16:04 We had several letters from other institutions

0:16:07 in the community and then pleased to announce tonight

0:16:10 that we have been named as a recipient of the $250,000 Blue Cross

0:16:15 of Idaho Foundation for Health Community Transformation

0:16:17 Grant, so that was released today.

0:16:20 We'll be getting a new release out on it tomorrow.

0:16:23 It is a three-year grant program, and the first year really

0:16:26 is focused on planning, identifying partnerships

0:16:30 in the community, looking at the needs and the assets

0:16:32 that we have to meet some of the goals

0:16:35 and really tied to our strategic plan.

0:16:36 That was really part of our application process.

0:16:39 And then developing a strategy from that in the first year,

0:16:42 and then phase two would be the funding and execution

0:16:45 of those different strategies and really building

0:16:47 on those other institutions, like the college,

0:16:51 the school district.

0:16:52 We had MavTech, that was part of our windshield tour.

0:16:55 Certainly, I think we'll be seeking others

0:16:57 who are looking to help reach our goals

0:16:59 in our strategic plan and improving the health

0:17:00 of the community, so very exciting news.

0:17:03 I do not know how many other communities we're selected.

0:17:05 I think there were only two or three maybe

0:17:07 who received the Community Transformation Grant in the state, and then several others.

0:17:12 But we'll get the word out on that.

0:17:14 And now the real work will begin of actually working through identifying those partnerships

0:17:19 and opportunities.

0:17:20 So very exciting news tonight.

0:17:22 Chris Stockington.

0:17:24 Many are real pleased to hear about the coordination you'll do with various agencies,

0:17:29 especially in school.

0:17:30 I'd like to relate to you, my wife works in the after-school programs

0:17:34 and in her core schools at Twin Falls,

0:17:37 we have robust areas within the city,

0:17:39 but we have areas where families and the children

0:17:43 have bare efforts.

0:17:46 Food is essentially missing a gradient as well.

0:17:50 Many of these kids that she works with,

0:17:53 though I think it's absolutely essential

0:17:55 that you make the school a primary coordinating factor

0:17:58 or advise some of the potential recipients.

0:18:04 Absolutely, and the school district is 100% on board.

0:18:07 Again, they offered a letter of support for our application

0:18:10 and participated in the tour when we had the foundation staff

0:18:14 down here in March.

0:18:16 And not only is the program focused on wellness and activity,

0:18:21 there is also a component on healthy food.

0:18:24 And I mean, sometimes we had a lot of discussions,

0:18:27 even with the folks from the foundation on how, really,

0:18:30 what is the role of the city in providing access

0:18:32 to healthy and fresh fruits and vegetables,

0:18:35 and sometimes that seems like it might be a bit of a stretch.

0:18:37 But then when you consider that this really

0:18:39 is about partnerships, and it's not just

0:18:41 about what the city can do, but truly it's

0:18:43 about the partnerships that we can create to create opportunities,

0:18:47 especially in those areas that are so vastly underserved.

0:18:50 And so I think I wouldn't hesitate

0:18:53 to say that I think one of our selling points

0:18:55 on what really gave us maybe the leg up on our competition

0:18:59 was the really strong partnerships

0:19:02 that we were able to show, one of which is with our school district.

0:19:06 There are not a lot of communities in Idaho that, I mean,

0:19:09 how I think probably as close to a working relationship as we do.

0:19:12 And so I think that the foundation saw that and appreciated

0:19:15 the synergies that we already have and felt this was a really good

0:19:18 investment of their money.

0:19:20 And then we'll be looking at ways to leverage this money with other

0:19:23 sources, not whether that be within our own budget or within potentially

0:19:28 even other grants from sources to really stretch this money

0:19:31 as far as we possibly can.

0:19:34 Thank you, boy.

0:19:35 I just wanted to say thank you to everybody.

0:19:39 I was in a little bit on the meeting of the planning of the site visit.

0:19:44 It was really educational, and I think that our mayor being so involved with the walking was a big part,

0:19:51 and I really do.

0:19:53 I think that I'm impressed and excited that we have this three-year process,

0:20:01 because the first year is actually coordinating and you execute it, you really know what you're doing, why you're doing, and so I want you guys put together.

0:20:15 I've still told several people it was the strangest grant application I've ever written because we didn't actually propose any projects.

0:20:25 We essentially were again selling ourselves and trying to kind of give them a little bit of a snapshot into what we were hoping to accomplish.

0:20:33 So it was interesting and I would certainly agree that Mayor Berger's participation in the walking challenge in the previously mere halls

0:20:41 you know gave us sort of the

0:20:43 the attention

0:20:46 To see that we really are committed to not only the high five and the walking challenge, but I think wellness in general

0:20:53 Thank you

0:20:55 Thank you, thank you, Mandy and everybody who helped get the grip for us

0:20:59 I'm listening to Councilman talking to just make me think kind of outside the box.

0:21:04 Have we partnered with the U of I Extension office with any of this grant?

0:21:09 So, no.

0:21:11 Honestly, this guy is the limit.

0:21:14 I think it's really about figuring out who should be at the table and then sitting down and creating sort of an action plan of what we really want to do with the money.

0:21:22 and that is their intent with that sort of strange application process was they really

0:21:27 didn't want people coming to the table with a whole list of ideas that they just wanted

0:21:31 money to pay for. They truly want to sit down and try to really get at the meat of the issues

0:21:37 within a community and identify the needs and the resources available so that we can, like

0:21:43 I said before, potentially leverage this money and start it even further but really understand

0:21:50 the best way to go about transforming our community.

0:21:54 I went to a meeting with the Extension Office last week,

0:21:58 and I didn't realize at that time that they have

0:22:00 nutritionalists on staff that are there

0:22:02 to help us with nutrition and foods,

0:22:04 and they already have a lot of the lake work done on it.

0:22:09 I had no idea.

0:22:10 And the gal that does it for her name, Sue,

0:22:12 go figure that just exists out of my mind.

0:22:14 She was wonderful, and she was a wealth of knowledge,

0:22:16 and I just thought I'd throw that tidbit out.

0:22:19 Well, they'll be a press like really scoring out tomorrow.

0:22:21 And we encourage anyone that is interested

0:22:23 and even learning a little bit more about the grant.

0:22:26 And as we start this process, I think the first few

0:22:29 that I understand the first few meeting,

0:22:30 will mostly be listening sessions.

0:22:31 And we'll learn a little bit about how they envision

0:22:34 the process going.

0:22:35 And then we'll start that process of creating partnerships

0:22:38 and kind of identifying some of the areas

0:22:42 that we want to work on.

0:22:44 Maybe you want to just send them a tag so they're aware

0:22:46 because I had no idea what they had to offer.

0:22:48 Absolutely. Thank you for the suggestion.

0:22:50 The Blue Cross folks did mention last year as it was going through some other trainings with them that I think the Extension Agency was part of the U of I study they actually did here on food insecurity in the Twin Falls area.

0:23:02 So I think that could be a simple baseline data for us as well.

0:23:05 So it really is going to be exciting and I think the important thing to remember is it's not necessarily a city of Twin Falls project.

0:23:12 really a community project that we will have some role in but I really will

0:23:17 count on those partners to push it forward.

0:23:20 One more comment if I may and another partner is St. Luke's and they are just finishing up a study on community needs within the community health needs and that

0:23:33 actually supported our application quite nicely in that it really it was

0:23:39 looking at Twin Falls by census tract and it identified several census tracts

0:23:44 within the city that are lacking in several areas and one of which was access

0:23:50 to food, the common food deserts, but also access to amenities and within walking

0:23:59 distance of certain types of you know, gems or community centers. So it

0:24:07 to what we were trying to accomplish, so we would be remiss if I didn't mention St.

0:24:14 Lix as well.

0:24:17 I think you need to have something else here.

0:24:20 Thank you, Mandy.

0:24:21 Thank you.

0:24:26 Next on the agenda is an informational item.

0:24:28 We have Twin Falls Source Water Protection Plan update from Robert Bowling, our water superintendent.

0:24:37 Hello, sir.

0:24:38 Good evening, Mayor and Council.

0:24:40 Hopefully I remember how to do this.

0:24:43 So hopefully you guys were able to look at the packet that we put together for you guys.

0:24:48 What we're wanting to do, we have a source water protection plan that is in need of being updated.

0:24:55 And we would like to move forward with that by putting a committee together.

0:25:00 We don't have to redo the whole source protection plan, but we can do an addendum to it and add things in that we need to.

0:25:10 From the original plan that was adopted in 2003, I'll just give you a quick kind of rundown.

0:25:17 The source water protection plan's mission is to have a document to rely on for protection

0:25:23 of our groundwater sources for future use and development of our community.

0:25:28 City needs to work closely with DEQ, county planning and zoning, and others in areas that

0:25:34 could have potential effects on our groundwater sources.

0:25:37 This plan helps with delineation around, with the wellheads, looks at potential contamination hazards in the area, gives us data for informed land use decisions, produces a susceptibility analysis for the source, and provides a document to answer questions for the public sure by the city of Twin Falls.

0:25:58 benefits of having a source water protection plan or having an idea of potential risk to the system from hazards or contamination and eliminating or reducing them before we have contamination.

0:26:10 Having a water source contaminated can be costly and may require a completely new source to be developed in a completely new or different area to serve the community.

0:26:21 Melinda Nars is also here this evening.

0:26:25 She's from Idaho Road Water and she helps provide technical assistance

0:26:31 and will help with us redoing the addendum to the program.

0:26:37 And we would also like to have a diverse committee of participants

0:26:43 from the area to help update this plan.

0:26:47 So ideally, we'd like to have someone from city staff in the water.

0:26:53 Someone from engineering, city planning and zoning, Twin Falls County, planning and zoning.

0:27:01 Maybe somebody from Jerome, planning and zoning where we have four wells that are in a different county, across county lines.

0:27:10 DQ, and then, you know, a number of local residents that would be interested in up-sitting

0:27:17 on the board.

0:27:18 So, really, we came tonight just to kind of inform you that we're looking at updating

0:27:23 that and to give you input, maybe if someone from the council wants to sit on that board,

0:27:28 also that would be helpful.

0:27:30 So, with that, can you questions or do we anticipate?

0:27:42 Once we get together and go over it, I don't think we should probably then get back together,

0:27:59 back together and the original planet said to get back together and go over by

0:28:04 annually and kind of fell off the table before I there was maybe some conflict

0:28:13 between county planning and zoning and city planning and zoning and also when

0:28:18 you've got wealth in a different county I don't think there was a conversation

0:28:23 somewhere stopped and it's um no drinking water protection plan is a

0:28:31 mandatory so it's not like well if you don't do it you're not gonna get this

0:28:35 But when we do go for grants or funding through DEQ now, that is one thing that they look for

0:28:42 to see if you've got a source water protection plan because it is important.

0:28:46 Chris Stockington.

0:28:50 First of all, I would volunteer.

0:28:52 I always consider water to be the most important function I serve as a council person.

0:29:01 My graduate work is in protection.

0:29:04 Natural resources like water.

0:29:06 but Robert, my your real question is relating to the south wall number five, are we getting ready to punch it?

0:29:13 Yes, we're GABs, working on that right now, getting the information in and coming out of me, seriously, correct me,

0:29:23 but the wells are high in nitrates from any reason to suspect as well,

0:29:31 beginning arsenic, but it's where it is right at, right at the limit with the arsenic nitrates, we're okay.

0:29:44 We are.

0:29:45 So it's our Snickers.

0:29:46 Our Snickers are...

0:29:47 Our Snickers are...

0:29:48 Our Snickers are trending downward, slowly, but they're trending down in ourself as part

0:29:51 of the natural pockets.

0:29:52 Have to share a quick story.

0:29:53 I was reading through the attachment before I read the staff report.

0:30:10 And when I came to the part that said Gary Young was the contact person on there, I thought,

0:30:16 what in the world are they showing us to?

0:30:19 So then I go back and read the staff report and figure it out now. It makes more sense, but it did kind of jump out of me

0:30:27 I'm sure you have all the expertise you need

0:30:30 But I do serve on the environmental committee for the Association of Idaho cities

0:30:34 And we have a good staff board there and resource people that are available

0:30:38 Should that need arise? I'm sure Johanna would be very helpful with anything. So I just like to offer that service as well

0:30:50 So I think a lot of people with a lot of good expertise that can help us go through it and date this like me now.

0:31:04 We have a protection plan that could be this and we have updated that for sure.

0:31:33 Who might as well say my name is Suzanne, I was going to mention that AIC is a possible partner, but also looking at the list of the plant planning team.

0:31:42 It is obvious time for a dog and six of the twelve have passed away.

0:31:46 So, it's time for some fresh blood there, obviously, yep, yep.

0:31:52 So, I think you have a volunteer from the council. There's one spot full.

0:32:00 So, as far as the recruiting other members, I think certainly I would count on your expertise to look for the right kind of,

0:32:14 to be those ones that are kind of targeted at

0:32:16 painting and zoning or county

0:32:18 and it comes to just general, interested residents.

0:32:23 I think certainly just putting the public service announcement and looking for applicants

0:32:29 on that by the council, I'm assuming, at some point.

0:32:37 So once there is a committee recommended

0:32:41 that would be something we would approve. Yeah, so you're going to have to approve

0:32:46 not only the list, but Mitch and I are having a conversation

0:32:50 believe if you look at the heart of the issue this is going to cause changes into

0:32:56 Title 10 potentially and as a result of that we will follow the public meeting

0:33:01 laws at the very beginning of that deliberation and so these would be

0:33:07 televised follow-up of our transparency processes

0:33:14 I'm going to give you a grant.

0:33:37 Do you have enough direction from us?

0:33:44 Next, the agenda is another opportunity for general public input.

0:33:50 There's no one from the public who wishes to address the council on that.

0:33:53 That's not on the agenda.

0:34:03 You at least state your name.

0:34:05 Whether you are a resident or property owner in the city of Twin Falls.

0:34:08 Tammy Billman, I'm a resident and a property owner at I School, Sean. I want to talk to you about Harrison Park, which is a park that...

0:34:21 Is that microphone turned on, by the way?

0:34:23 It is. It's a green light.

0:34:25 It gets on.

0:34:26 Okay.

0:34:30 How's that? Harrison Park seems to be a forgotten park over there. So many people go, where's Harrison Park?

0:34:40 Harrison Park is on Harrison Street, but all of our parks are being updated. I

0:34:49 talked to Wendy. She told me next year it will be updated. I started talking to

0:34:55 Dennis about this and Dennis has been gone four years, five years. I started

0:35:06 talking to him about three or four years before he left about that park. The one

0:35:14 One thing that he did do was he did go in and replace the basketball court because it

0:35:19 was shot.

0:35:22 I have to beg every year to get more than one picnic table over there because they take

0:35:29 all the picnic tables in the winter.

0:35:32 The other parks, picnic tables stay because they have a cement slab there.

0:35:37 They won't do slabs over there for whatever reason.

0:35:42 I don't know.

0:35:44 I got on the website, it said Harrison Park is open Monday through Friday 8 to 5.30, close

0:35:51 Saturday and Sunday.

0:35:54 And I went in and said, nope, it's open 24-7.

0:35:57 You know, Harrison is a nice neighborhood park, it's an older park, um, oh, the 1955,

0:36:12 used to have a recreational building there where you go and you could pick out anything

0:36:17 you wanted to do.

0:36:19 Okay, volleyball, basketball, baseball, you could go in and check all these things out,

0:36:26 you could do it, you could play.

0:36:29 Now you've got, I forgot my phone, you've got some playground equipment that is breaking,

0:36:37 I do have a picture of it on my phone because I don't know how to copy things from my phone,

0:36:43 but it's breaking, where the slide is, it's breaking.

0:36:49 plaque that says when the playground equipment was put up and where it was made is gone.

0:37:00 This playground equipment has not been replaced in over 20 years.

0:37:06 All these other parks have these nice new signs, not yours, and it doesn't even have

0:37:14 a sign that says it's Harrison Park.

0:37:19 Several years it had a port-a-potty.

0:37:22 I asked Wendy here a couple of weeks ago about are we going to have a port-a-potty out there

0:37:26 again and she said, that's up to PSI if they want to put one over there.

0:37:31 That's my tax dollars, it shouldn't be up to PSI.

0:37:35 And I told her I said, there are little kids over there that when they see us there, and

0:37:39 we're talking five, six, seven year old kids, they see us.

0:37:44 So then they go on the other side of the tree because they're hiding from us.

0:37:48 And she said, call the cops on them for urinating in public.

0:37:53 I am not calling the cops on a child when we should be providing a port-a-potty, not

0:38:01 doing it.

0:38:02 So, thank you for the information.

0:38:04 We will follow up with the Parks and Recreation Department on that, so I appreciate you bringing

0:38:10 it to our attention.

0:38:11 We have to understand we do have many parks, so the signs, for example, that's a process

0:38:17 to get signs at every park.

0:38:18 They didn't all go in at once, so that's happening over time.

0:38:21 And I'll ask Wendy about that and we'll get that information and see what's happening with the mark.

0:38:27 Well, my question on that is, I know she told me next year, but I've been told that since Dennis.

0:38:35 Okay, well, we'll see what we can find out for you.

0:38:38 Tammy, you're a good doctor.

0:38:39 The counselor is not better enough to come back and take over the podium.

0:38:43 Good for you.

0:38:44 Thank you.

0:38:46 Thank you.

0:38:47 Good question.

0:38:48 So Tammy, do you know about our new app we have on the city's website that's C, click,

0:38:54 fix, I got your right, see, click, click, I couldn't find it, okay?

0:39:00 So it's if you go to TFID.org, there's a link there, but also like on your phone,

0:39:04 if you go see, click, fix under your app store, you can download it and it'll ask you what city

0:39:10 you're in and you can just put in your zip code. But for those pictures you've got on your phone,

0:39:15 If you can use that app and send them in, then it helps go through the process.

0:39:20 We're trying to get better at that ourselves, so we're staying on top of things and fixing things.

0:39:25 And that's tfid.org.

0:39:28 But I think that's a great application for that new app that we're really trying to get the community to use.

0:39:34 Okay.

0:39:35 Thank you.

0:39:36 Because I couldn't find you, so I'll go back.

0:39:38 So, a couple of things, Tammy, number one, on our website, we have the C-Click Fix,

0:39:43 and you can download the app for good instructions on how to do that,

0:39:46 and if you do that from your cell phone, you'll probably move you right into your link whenever from your use.

0:39:52 Mitch has been kind of, we've recently updated the city's website,

0:39:57 and so we have a brand new website, a lot of information out there.

0:40:01 We're trying to find the hours of operation where that is.

0:40:07 The city parks are open seven days a week. You're absolutely right and they're not twenty hours a day

0:40:12 They they are I think it's from dawn till dusk is

0:40:17 So that's not quite 24 hours

0:40:23 You're right we're trying to find that so if you could share where that is

0:40:31 Wherever you saw that because we were having a heck of time trying to find that

0:40:34 that we would be able to maybe make that adjustment so other people don't

0:40:38 run into that same level of confusion. Okay, I can probably. Okay, thank you, Tammy.

0:40:47 Does anyone else who wishes to address the council on an item that's not on the agenda this evening?

0:40:51 Seeing no one, uh, advisory board reports from the council.

0:40:57 Suzanne? Thank you. Um, we are a month away from the youth council's rally for

0:41:06 teen suicide prevention and awareness. So just a reminder that on Saturday May 18th,

0:41:11 18th. We are holding a rally at the Twin Falls Visitor Center at 9.30 in the morning. Amy

0:41:17 Schudy has graciously agreed to be our speaker and she's going to do a 30-minute rally on

0:41:22 life is worth living. We're looking for adults to come out and stand with our teenagers and

0:41:27 tell them that we care that life is worth living. When we finish the rally, we will be

0:41:32 having a color run walk. You can walk or run and we will be highlighting the five steps

0:41:38 to teen suicide prevention.

0:41:41 If you pre-register on the city's website,

0:41:43 which is on the Parks and Rec page

0:41:45 under Register for Activities,

0:41:48 it's $10 for adults, $5 for students.

0:41:51 You'll get a t-shirt.

0:41:53 If you don't pre-register and you just want to come be out there,

0:41:56 that's great.

0:41:57 You just won't get a t-shirt.

0:42:00 Thank you.

0:42:01 Councilman Talkington.

0:42:03 I'd like to give an important update on what's happening at the airport.

0:42:07 Some of those I know the councils were, some of those were

0:42:10 repeating or telling you, for the first time we are looking

0:42:14 for new air service route from Twin Falls to Denver.

0:42:18 But we'll eventually establish the year around the excursion.

0:42:25 It'll really help the businesses like Shabani and Columbia.

0:42:29 But right now we're just trying to get enough interest

0:42:33 to establish it probably on a seasonal basis.

0:42:36 I think there's a 50-50 chance we can eventually have that.

0:42:40 He's coast connection.

0:42:42 Another important thing that has been undertaken right now is the study of the drone threats

0:42:48 at smaller airports.

0:42:50 The news has almost weekly occurrence of drones intruding on commercial airspace,

0:42:59 where they have no business.

0:43:01 and sooner or later we're going to have a major catastrophe unless there, unfortunately, is not better regulation

0:43:07 at drone usage around airports.

0:43:11 Third item as we are in active planning already for the 2023 air show, we are re-vamping and reorganizing under our 501c3 organization

0:43:23 from the previous airshow is going to be a biggie and as things get flushed out even though it's four

0:43:30 years away it's going to be well worth attending and we're going to have tens of thousands of people

0:43:38 bugging the streets and restaurants of Twin Falls and for your frequent flyers please also be

0:43:44 aware that we are looking into a pre-check screening for frequent flyers where you can skip

0:44:22 6 p.m. and since we're a little bit early, we will go ahead and recess for 15 minutes and we will reconvene at 6 p.m. for the two public hearings that are scheduled.

0:44:32 I would like to reconvene the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday, April 15th. We have two public hearings scheduled this evening and looking at the sign-in sheet.

0:45:41 I am relatively confident that most, if not all of the folks are signed up for what is listed as item 8A.

0:45:48 Because item 8B is very brief, I'm going to flip-flop the two hearings, and we're going to do the

0:45:55 request of BK Platt of the Eastlands within Canyon Parks Subdivision, located at the

0:46:00 2000 block of Nielsen Point Place on behalf of Geronimo LLC, first, and then we will have the hearing on the second request

0:46:08 to put my cheaters on, because this one's like a six, the same.

0:46:14 So, I do want to review the process for the public hearings this evening so the council

0:46:20 will follow these steps for each request.

0:46:23 I listed them the public hearing portion of the agenda.

0:46:26 First, the city staff will present the request analysis.

0:46:29 Second, the applicant will then present their request.

0:46:32 Third, the council will ask questions of the applicant or staff.

0:46:37 After questions have been asked, excuse me, the public hearing will then be opened.

0:46:42 In that time, anyone in attendance has given the opportunity to comment or ask questions

0:46:46 about the request being considered.

0:46:49 When giving testimony, please step up to the podium, state your name and address, then present

0:46:53 your comments or concerns.

0:46:55 And after giving your testimony, if you didn't sign in on the sign-in sheet on your way in,

0:47:00 there is one in the lobby where we would appreciate your name and address for the record.

0:47:05 After public comments are concluded, the applicant will be invited to answer any questions and

0:47:09 make a closing statement.

0:47:10 Staff will then answer or clarify any comments as needed.

0:47:14 After the closing statements, the public hearing will be closed, no further testimony or comments

0:47:19 from the applicant or the audience will be allowed.

0:47:22 The council will then have an open discussion and take action on the request.

0:47:28 So, again, the first item we will deal with then is the request to vacate platadhesements

0:47:33 within Canyon Park, subdivision located at the 2000 block of Nielsen Point Place on

0:47:38 on behalf of Geronimo LLC and care of EHM engineers,

0:47:42 and we will have our staff report first from Steve O'Connor.

0:47:46 Thank you, Mr. Mayor, House members.

0:47:48 What you have before you is a request

0:47:50 of AKA a Plated Public Utility Easement

0:47:53 to reroute those utilities outside of the proposed

0:47:56 building pad to make way for future development.

0:48:01 The city does not have any building plans submitted

0:48:03 as to what is there yet, and the applicant has provided

0:48:07 all the required letters of approval from various utility owners and all have agreed

0:48:11 to the vacation. However, if the utility company has existing utilities, they have indicated

0:48:16 that they would like a new easement as well as their utilities moved prior to accepting

0:48:24 the change. Below is a list of the existing utilities. So, Cable 1, CenturyLink, I know

0:48:30 Power, Intermount Gas, and PMT. So, on March 12th, 2019, the Planning and Zoning Commission

0:48:36 did hear this item and they did approve it,

0:48:40 Sierra 4 to 0 to 1.

0:48:41 There was one extension from the commission.

0:48:46 Little bit of history, the subject easement

0:48:49 is part of Lot 6 in the Canyon Park subdivision plot

0:48:52 in which was recorded in December 2013.

0:48:55 The comprehensive plan designates this area

0:48:57 as mixed use on a vacation of this easement

0:48:59 will allow for commercial development to take place,

0:49:01 and therefore staff determines request

0:49:03 is in compliance with the 2016 comprehensive plan.

0:49:07 regulatory impacts of this vacation will allow for future development to take place and all

0:49:13 the entitlements from the easement will then go away and the base zone will apply at that

0:49:21 point.

0:49:23 So in conclusion, the council is tasked with approving the conditions, approving with conditions

0:49:28 or denying the request or you may table for more information should the council approve

0:49:33 the request staff recommends the following conditions.

0:49:36 subject to the recordation of a new utility easements for all existing utilities prior

0:49:40 to official vacation of the platied easements and I will stand for any questions after the

0:49:45 applicant.

0:49:47 Steve, are there any questions from the council?

0:49:50 Seeing none, we will invite the applicant forward to accept their information.

0:49:57 Good evening Mr. Mayor.

0:49:59 Members of the council, my name is David Tebow with EHM Engineers at 621 North College Road

0:50:03 here in Twin Falls.

0:50:04 I'm representing Geronimo LLC in this request.

0:50:07 As Steve mentioned, we're working on a project here

0:50:11 for hospitality hotel service.

0:50:14 The existing utility easements are in conflict

0:50:19 with the proposed building footprint.

0:50:21 We've reached out to each of those owners

0:50:23 and utility jurisdictions.

0:50:25 They've agreed to relinquish their easements

0:50:27 on the condition that we reroute the utilities

0:50:29 out and around our proposed footprint.

0:50:32 Pretty straightforward request.

0:50:33 Idaho Power does have some proprietary processes that we have to go through.

0:50:38 We understand staff's condition that the new easement and installation of those utilities

0:50:42 be completed prior to a relinquishment of these easements and we believe we can work

0:50:47 through that without any problems through the building process and construction process.

0:50:51 So with that, we're here to request your approval to vacate the planet easements in accordance

0:50:57 with the city code and procedures to do so.

0:51:01 I can stand for any questions that you may have.

0:51:03 Other question?

0:51:07 Yes, talking to him.

0:51:08 No, Steve.

0:51:09 His point were the make-a-dideas was would go.

0:51:13 So we will work with each utility owner to design those new alignments, Councilman Talkington.

0:51:19 And at that time they would issue us an approval so Idaho Power does their own designs,

0:51:25 so they'll design around our site once we develop the site plan for the hotel and similar

0:51:30 with Intermountain Gas Company.

0:51:31 PMT, Cable 1, and CenturyLink also will do their own proprietary designs.

0:51:36 On that, we will provide them space and alternates and coordinate with them, but ultimately they will provide those designs.

0:51:42 Thank you. Any further questions for them?

0:51:47 Thank you. We will open it up now for public testimony on this item.

0:51:57 If there's anyone who wishes to speak in favor of this request, now's your opportunity to please come forward.

0:52:07 There's anyone who wishes to speak against the request.

0:52:10 Now, is your opportunity to please come forward?

0:52:13 There's anybody who would just like to comment

0:52:15 on the request.

0:52:16 Now, is your opportunity to please come forward?

0:52:20 I think no one for this item, I will close the public input

0:52:22 portion of the public hearing, and applicant is good

0:52:27 with no closing statements.

0:52:29 So, turn it over to Council for Council wishes.

0:52:32 Great, Manton.

0:52:37 Mayor, I move that we approve the process with conditions.

0:52:46 Number one that was mentioned by staff to vacate these reutilities areas as long as they record

0:52:55 new ones and work with the current utilities for movement.

0:53:00 Motion by Greg Lanting, second by Mr. Fereed to approve the request of AKA the platted easlands

0:53:11 with these staff recommendations as presented as their further discussion.

0:53:14 Please, I roll call vote please.

0:53:20 Nicky Boyd?

0:53:21 Yes.

0:53:22 Suzanne Hawkins?

0:53:23 Yes. Reg Lanting. Yes. Christopher Reed. Yes. Chris Dockington. Yes. John

0:53:28 Berriger. Yes. Motion passes 6-0. Thank you, Dave. Right. And now we will move to the

0:53:45 other public hearings. So this is an action item. This is a request for a special

0:53:49 use permit to operate a home occupation at property located at 1333 Bitter

0:53:54 Roof Drive. On behalf of Carlene M. Duncan and again we will have our city

0:54:00 staff report from Steve O'Connor. All right. Thank you again, Mr. Mayor.

0:54:04 council members. So this is a request to establish a home occupation for massage therapy at 1333

0:54:10 Bitterroot Drive. The home is accessed via a shared driveway from Bitterroot that out. So here's

0:54:18 Bitterroot Drive. The shared access is this lot, lot 19 and it's shared with 1333 as well as 1323,

0:54:27 1331 and 1305 bitter root. They all share those four share that shared access. The

0:54:35 shared, excuse me, the applicant stated that she only sees four to five clients in

0:54:40 a day and there is a 30-minute plus break in between to accommodate customer

0:54:44 parking. The driveway is rather large and is able to handle an extra vehicle to

0:54:49 prevent any conflicts with the neighbors. A little bit of history, this was plotted,

0:54:55 I apologize. Also on March 12th, this is not in the staff report, but it is in the meeting minutes in your packet, the Planning and Zoning Commission did hear this item on March 12th as well, and it was denied on a vote of 2-4-2 against in one extension, so it failed to pass.

0:55:16 A little bit more history.

0:55:18 The property was plotted in 1998 and developed and encouraged shortly thereafter.

0:55:23 The comprehensive plan has this area as town neighborhood and the request meets that request

0:55:28 or meets that designation as there is really not a change to the primary use of the property.

0:55:35 So town neighborhood and the residential use meets that home occupation is listed as a

0:55:40 residential use within our zoning codes.

0:55:43 Some potential impacts.

0:55:45 So the applicant and staff do not anticipate any significant increase in Dutch metal impacts

0:55:49 from this request on the surrounding properties, however, parking at times may pose a problem.

0:55:55 So in conclusion, if the Council approves this request as presented, then staff recommends

0:55:59 the following conditions.

0:56:01 One, subject to a continued compliance with all local, state, and federal code requirements

0:56:05 and other standards as applicable, and two, subject to customers parking only on Lot 20

0:56:10 and no parking on Lot 19 of the Grove State's subdivision.

0:56:13 I will say it for any questions of that because do you have any questions for Steve?

0:56:19 Not seeing these, so we will turn it over to the applicant for presentation.

0:56:29 My name is Harleen Duncan. I have had a solo therapeutic massage practice for 16 years.

0:57:01 I have been a massage instructor for the Twin Falls Institute of the Listic Studies for 15 years.

0:57:06 I have located my business in various commercial offices around Twin Falls over the last 16 years.

0:57:12 I maintain a regular clientele base that have been referred by friends or existing clients

0:57:17 over my 16-year career and the majority of my clients are in the 50-94 year age bracket

0:57:24 and mostly comprised of local business professionals and business owners.

0:57:29 In the near future, I would like to relocate my solo office practice into my residence at

0:57:34 1333 Bitterroot Drive to save on overhead expenses.

0:57:38 As you are aware from the presentation at the planning and zoning meeting last month,

0:57:42 I have incurred significant changes in the last seven months to my livelihood, causing quite

0:57:47 an impact on my financial situation.

0:57:50 I usually see four to five clients per day, Monday through Friday, and I leave thirty plus

0:57:54 minutes in between appointments so there should be no more than one vehicle parked in my driveway

0:57:59 at a time throughout most of the workday.

0:58:03 My house is located on a dead end street in a private cul-de-sac, with a three cart garage

0:58:08 and ample cement driveway as you can see in the picture provided.

0:58:11 There's three full-size vehicles and still quite a large area of cement pad.

0:58:29 With the three full-size vehicles in the driveway, there's still plenty of extra cement and I

0:58:33 park in the garage.

0:58:36 At the March meeting with planning and zoning, I have several neighbors speak against my application

0:58:40 for a professional overlay permit as I feared an increase in traffic to the neighborhood

0:58:46 and possible damage to the landscaping and green utility boxes and the cost for the cul-de-sac

0:58:51 fog ceiling every few years.

0:58:54 There will be no external signage on my house nor in my yard, and I do not advertise for clients,

0:59:01 so these are clients that are either related to my existing clientele or somebody that they

0:59:07 know personally.

0:59:09 Their reputable people is not just go off the street.

0:59:16 I explained that the, their other concern was the voids in the grass, and I explained that

0:59:22 the grass was being run over by the newspaper delivery people in the middle of the night.

0:59:27 And I admitted that my husband prior to his death had indeed backed into the green utility

0:59:31 box at the end of my driveway and that's why there's reflectors planted around it now.

0:59:37 At that meeting I also agreed that I would be willing to pay more than my share of the

0:59:42 fog ceiling cost when it becomes necessary to recode the private cul-de-sac.

0:59:47 The neighbor in front of the express concern of my clients being able to see in their back

0:59:51 windows. And as you can see by the next two pictures provided that the back porch and windows

0:59:57 are mostly obscured by vineage trees and are provided. This is from mid-side walk and the

1:00:05 other one is from my front porch. That's not why my clients would be there anyway. As to

1:00:16 the concern about my business increasing traffic in the neighborhood, I can assure you that it

1:00:21 will be less traffic than I currently incur in my driveway as my daughter or son-in-law

1:00:27 or myself are having to go back and forth several times a day just to let my dogs in and out.

1:00:33 Recently, I requested information from planning and zoning as to how many home occupation permits

1:00:38 have been applied for in the last year. In the last 15 months since January of 2018,

1:00:44 there have only been six applications made. Of those, three were approved, one denied,

1:00:50 into were withdrawn. I was shocked to learn that only six people had applied for a home

1:00:55 occupational professional overlay permit, as we all know that more people than that have

1:01:00 started new home-based businesses during the past year, doing computer work, bookkeeping,

1:01:05 hair, nails, eyebrows, daycare, music lessons, etc. The difference between those people and

1:01:12 the six applicants and myself is that we went about this illegal way by making application

1:01:18 to the city. We weren't trying to hide anything from the neighbors or any governing bodies.

1:01:25 I would like to also draw your attention to the fact that this permit falls within the

1:01:29 guidelines and as in compliance with the 2016 comprehensive grow with us plan. I approach

1:01:38 the situation legally, responsibly and professionally. I have always taken pride in my honesty, integrity

1:01:45 and professionalism and these qualities clearly have been perceived by my clients as demonstrated

1:01:51 in the letters that I supplied to you earlier today. I thank you for your time

1:01:56 in hearing this matter and I appreciate your thoughtful consideration and

1:01:59 approving this permit on my behalf. Thank you. I'm going to talk to you and ask that question.

1:02:06 What would your hours of operation be? Pardon? Hours of operation. I don't start

1:02:13 before 10 a.m. and I'm usually done by 5.6 p.m. at the latest. Are you willing to

1:02:19 put a yes cut up on the end of the day yes I am I'm willing to negotiate however

1:02:25 I need to one last question would you have any external equipment associated with the

1:02:31 business that you're running to reach outside or placement or no and ask no no sounds no

1:02:42 smells no big landing how currently how many vehicles are typically during the

1:02:48 This is a parked outside on the parking area you showed us.

1:02:52 There are typically one vehicle, two vehicles.

1:02:55 You show us for either of us.

1:02:57 Say, how many of you are?

1:02:58 My kids were over visiting us now in the picture.

1:03:01 So during the day.

1:03:02 During the day, how many are typically there?

1:03:04 Now.

1:03:05 Now.

1:03:06 I think that's why parking the driveway

1:03:08 or parking the garage.

1:03:10 That was my question.

1:03:11 Thank you.

1:03:12 Any other questions for the applicant?

1:03:18 Not seeing any so.

1:03:19 Thank you.

1:03:21 We will open up the public hearing, and we are going to do this, uh, having all those in favor speak first, and then all those opposed speak next in a batch, and then anybody with other comments.

1:03:34 So, there's anyone, uh, who would like to speak in favor of this?

1:03:39 Now, please come forward.

1:03:41 If you sign the sheet, I will tick you off, and if you didn't sign the sheet, you can sign on the outside there.

1:03:47 Mr. Mayor, I've got some letters that I'm going to be scrolling through as well.

1:03:51 [Muted for privacy: street address]

1:03:58 [Muted for privacy: street address]

1:04:04 [Muted for privacy: street address]

1:04:05 I am one of her patrons that do like to go and have massage therapy from her.

1:04:10 And the reason why I'm in support of this is like she did speak about as the integrity

1:04:15 of her neighborhood, but primarily when my thoughts were why would I in my own neighborhood

1:04:20 be okay with someone bringing a business in, such as this.

1:04:23 And the thing is, when I go, I would be another washful eye for that cul-de-sac for that neighborhood.

1:04:29 I know some of the people that live there.

1:04:32 There's single people dwelling people there that are maybe needing a washful eye.

1:04:38 I think there is a safety issue there for us to do it.

1:04:40 It's not a lot of cars that come.

1:04:42 It's just one.

1:04:43 Like Carleen said, she comes reasonable hours and willing to be respectful of her neighbors.

1:04:49 Also, along with being safety, I also want to be supportive of not putting her in a position

1:04:57 of losing her home or her means of making a living.

1:05:00 She did lose her husband, therefore she's lost some income, emotional support, along

1:05:06 with financial support.

1:05:07 I'd hate to see her have to lose her home, which, you know, we're not in control of

1:05:11 who would buy a home, such as at that size, Katie Barr, the door of their teenagers, like

1:05:16 come into those driveways.

1:05:17 So I'm very much in support of her.

1:05:20 Thank you.

1:05:21 The Mayor and Council.

1:05:28 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:05:29 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:05:32 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:05:37 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:05:40 for the city.

1:05:41 Had I not been for Carlene, I probably wouldn't be moving as good as I am because I sustained

1:05:48 a lot of damage to my neck and shoulder.

1:05:51 She is a very professional business woman and I can assure any of the neighbors that

1:05:57 I am a responsible driver, I won't be driving on the lawn, I will come at my appointed time

1:06:04 and I will be very respectful of their neighborhood.

1:06:08 I hope that you can support Carleen because she has had a change in her life and this

1:06:12 is her livelihood and I know that there are other home businesses in the city and I hope

1:06:19 that you can all support her and know that I will do my part as her client to do whatever

1:06:24 I need to do. Thank you.

1:06:26 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:06:28 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:06:46 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:06:51 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:06:57 state of Idaho. They worked very hard to become licensed. They worked through the Bureau of Occupational

1:07:05 Licensing. So that in itself speaks volumes about the fact that they want to do the right thing. If

1:07:15 they were still unlicensed, none of us would be here. They would just be doing that in their home.

1:07:22 No questions asked.

1:07:24 Harleen is very professional.

1:07:26 I've gone to her for years.

1:07:28 In fact, she worked for me in the very, very beginning.

1:07:32 Her integrity is outstanding.

1:07:34 And she will not do anything to bring harm into that neighborhood.

1:07:38 So that's all I have for tonight.

1:07:41 Thank you.

1:07:42 Thank you.

1:07:43 And if you wouldn't mind, I'm here.

1:07:44 Wait out.

1:07:45 If you would please be sure to sign the sheet so we have their address on the other one.

1:07:49 I don't have you on this one, so you must be on the other one.

1:07:51 Thank you.

1:07:52 Welcome.

1:08:02 My name is Susan Harris.

1:08:03 I live in 2024.

1:08:04 I live here in Dwin.

1:08:05 I've lived there for 40 plus years.

1:08:08 I'm here to speak in Carlene's behalf.

1:08:12 I've been a client of hers for over 10 years.

1:08:17 I was referred to her by a former co-worker of mine and several of my former co-workers

1:08:25 have also been clients of Carlene.

1:08:29 I'm not directly impacted by the concerns of her direct neighbors.

1:08:35 I am within walking distance of her home.

1:08:39 I know that ever since I've been a client of Carleen's, her goal has been to move her

1:08:46 business into a home.

1:08:50 And when she bought this new home, right down her from her old street, she was very excited

1:08:57 about the prospect, made sure that the zoning was such that she could request a SUP. And

1:09:08 so was trying to go through the steps accordingly. From a personal standpoint, I believe that

1:09:15 Carlin's was instrumental in keeping me from having carpal tunnel surgery by going to a

1:09:26 massage every three weeks after my back surgery I believe I recovered much

1:09:32 quicker as a result of her services. She's very professional as she mentioned

1:09:38 she teaches for the school out in filer she attends professional programs in

1:09:48 Utah and does work for that as well and so I hope that since it is in

1:09:56 compliance with the 2016 comprehensive plan that you would see it as such that

1:10:03 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:10:07 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:10:27 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:10:34 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:10:39 Okay.

1:10:40 I spend an ample amount of time within this neighborhood as do my children.

1:10:45 Whether it be a quick visit, a holiday, or the multiple trips I make in and out daily to help care for my mother's dogs.

1:10:51 My children play outside, ride their bikes down the street and play with the other neighborhood children.

1:10:55 We have also resided in this neighborhood at my parents' previous residence, which is on the same street,

1:11:01 but in a different private hold of sec.

1:11:03 It is a nice quiet neighborhood, and I understand the desire to keep it as such.

1:11:07 However, I don't believe that a therapeutic massage business is the big blooming disruption that some seem to think it is.

1:11:13 It is a tranquil quiet and nearly unnoticeable from the outside.

1:11:17 There are no loud noises, large signage, obnoxious music, or any other disruptive entities involved.

1:11:22 If you didn't know it was there, you wouldn't be able to tell it was there.

1:11:26 There are no fellow employees involved. My mother works for herself, Sola, and has for well over a decade.

1:11:32 There are cars. There will be one car driving into the neighborhood at a time,

1:11:36 parking safely and fully within one driveway, staying for the length of

1:11:41 their appointment, and then leaving. There won't be five, ten or twenty vehicles

1:11:44 storming down the roadway all at once. And honestly, because of the way in which

1:11:49 my mother has set up her scheduling, there wouldn't even be an increase in

1:11:52 traffic, let alone a noticeable one. This is because currently, with my dad's

1:11:57 passing and her working outside of the home, myself or my husband are driving into

1:12:02 and out of the neighborhood three to four times a day every day to care for my mother's dogs.

1:12:08 Once allowed to work from her home we will no longer be needing to do so and her very limited

1:12:12 clientele will only be taking the place of the pre-existing traffic volume. Thank you for your time.

1:12:19 Thank you and what else who wishes to speak in favor of the request.

1:12:27 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:12:35 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:12:53 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:12:59 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:13:06 is heartwarming to obviously see friends and clients very supportive of Carleen. The difference

1:13:14 between them and us as we do live on better route drive and we would be affected by any

1:13:19 potential problems. But we are not questioning her character at all. She has been a good neighbor

1:13:26 and we have no reason to question her character. It's simply a matter of whether a business

1:13:31 should be allowed on that street. The growth development is not a typical street design.

1:13:39 Our street itself is a cul-de-sac and smaller cul-de-sac branch office to provide access

1:13:44 clusters of causes. This creates a look we find appealing and a sense of privacy.

1:13:50 However, it limits parking and is a situation where the owners are responsible

1:13:57 for maintaining our own cul-de-sacs. Bitterroot Drive itself has only one

1:14:02 outlet at Locust. In fact, a few years ago the city did put a dead-end sign to

1:14:09 prevent unnecessary traffic. When we moved to Bitterroot Drive, we were

1:14:13 impressed by the unique character and the senior-friendly design. We did not move expecting to see a residential

1:14:20 area become commercial. This change, if granted, can lead to unintended consequences of other owners

1:14:28 wishing to open businesses. You will hear from neighbors opposed to this permit. I hope that in

1:14:35 a democracy, the desire of one will not outweigh the concerns of many. In conclusion, if we were

1:14:41 shopping for a house in an area we looked at had commercial zoning we would not

1:14:46 buy there. Carlene has been a good neighbor but I respectfully ask you to

1:14:50 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:15:21 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:15:31 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:15:36 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:15:41 Because I am a widow, and live alone, as do seven other women in our neighborhood,

1:15:47 I wanted a setting that was quiet, safe, with minimal traffic and not on a through street.

1:15:55 That's what I found on Bitterroot Drive, our cul-de-sac is quiet, safe, and not traffic friendly.

1:16:04 It has a very narrow roadway, with no parking besides the homeowner's driveway and a very

1:16:11 limited turnaround space.

1:16:14 As Picture 1 illustrates, visitors attempting to leave the cul-de-sac have driven across private

1:16:20 property, leaving tire tracks on the lawn, possibly damaging a sprinkler system because

1:16:27 of a limited turnaround space.

1:16:30 It is even more difficult in the winter with snow covering yards and roadways and no one

1:16:37 maintains the shoveling or the snow removal.

1:16:43 Picture 2.

1:16:45 This picture illustrates a small delivery van in Arco, the sack.

1:16:51 In order to leave, he had to back onto a private driveway of another homeowner.

1:16:57 It doesn't matter who drives on the private property, but it does illustrate the challenges

1:17:04 drivers face when attempting to manipulate a turnaround in our very narrow roadway.

1:17:12 As homeowners, we are responsible for maintaining the surface of the cul-de-sac.

1:17:18 Increased traffic will demand increased upkeep and expense.

1:17:24 This is not an attack on Carlene Duncan, personally or professionally.

1:17:31 Last summer, we enjoyed conversations about our travels to Russia, the cliff dwellings

1:17:37 and the Panama Canal.

1:17:39 When Carlene relandscaped her backyard, last summer, she invited us over to see it.

1:17:45 When she got a new car last fall, she shared how much she enjoyed it.

1:17:50 This isn't personal.

1:17:52 I am merely trying to protect my residential neighborhood.

1:17:58 Approving this application will send a message

1:18:01 that all residential neighborhoods are open to businesses

1:18:05 in Twin Falls, Idaho.

1:18:08 I am asking that you respect my request

1:18:11 to continue residing in a small, quiet residential community

1:18:17 and reject this petition for a business and a home.

1:18:20 Thank you for your time.

1:18:22 Thank you.

1:18:34 My name is Dave Newberry, 1311 Bitterroot Drive.

1:18:40 Welcome.

1:18:41 I would say that I was hoping it would not necessary for me to be here after the March 12th planning and zoning meeting.

1:18:49 Also, this is my first public comment since speech class 50 years ago.

1:18:56 So bear with me.

1:18:58 I'm not here where I am here with the history regarding Carly's request for a special use.

1:19:06 special use permit shortly after Carlene and her husband moved to 1333. She mentioned

1:19:15 the idea of moving her business to her home. My wife and a neighbor expressed their concerns

1:19:22 about her idea and also with a subsequent second occasion. On the third occasion, she

1:19:31 said she was taking her petition to the Planning and Zoning Commission, which we attended, which

1:19:37 would have been the fourth occasion that this request was packed on.

1:19:44 And my wife and three other immediate neighbors

1:19:52 boarding our mutual cul-de-sac and other interested neighbors

1:19:57 that are present in their no vote reasons.

1:20:01 Thankfully, the Planning and Zoning Commission

1:20:03 voted no on our request.

1:20:06 And now on the fifth occasion, we are here

1:20:09 for you. I'm hoping for a unanimous no visit, so I can put this issue behind us. Thank you for your

1:20:15 talk. Thank you. Anyone else who wishes to speak against the request? Good evening. I'm

1:20:54 named it Mon Ramirez. I live in 1345, Peter Road Drive. Forgive my accent. I just moved to the

1:21:05 of a subdivision about seven months ago. It took us about two years to find the right place.

1:21:15 We were looking for a safe, private, and quiet place. I remember that we had a doubt about the

1:21:24 property to do how close the houses are. But the previous honor mentioned some of the rules of the

1:21:32 subdivision and how it was more like a place for retired people. This is what attracted us more to

1:21:41 our house. If I know that there was going to be a business behind my house, I would never buy

1:21:51 this property. I have concern about this business opening right in the back of my home as I work

1:22:00 night. My first concern is that it's going to be an extra noise and is going to affect

1:22:09 my sleeping schedule as my room is located in the back of my house which is really close

1:22:16 to the from the door of my neighbor which you can see in the picture. Also the extra traffic

1:22:25 and people driving into my property which has already happened without having extra traffic

1:22:31 from any business. I have learned that our neighbor has lived in two different properties

1:22:38 in the growth subdivision in the past, so she knows about the rules of the subdivision and

1:22:47 the expectations of her neighbors. If she was already thinking about moving her business

1:22:54 to her house within the growth subdivision rules, I don't understand why she bought her

1:23:03 second home in this observation when she knew she was going to have to go through this hassle

1:23:09 and have to challenge all her neighbors to open her business

1:23:13 when she could have

1:23:15 bought a property in a different location where you call half a student her business needs better I

1:23:23 Don't have nothing against her neighbor or her business

1:23:28 or anyone this trying to do better by

1:23:31 hoping a home business but I really don't think this is a place where any type of

1:23:37 business especially when it's going to affect almost every neighbor in some

1:23:43 different way. Thank you. Thank you. Yes. Good evening. I'm Scott Clights. I live in 1472

1:24:05 Bitterroot Drive which is Carleons Old House. We bought that house from her

1:24:13 with the understanding that this subdivision was a residential subdivision

1:24:18 and that it would zone for that and that it would stay that way. It was no

1:24:23 disclosure about the fact that she was not only was she moving up the street

1:24:29 but that she was going to start a business. My major concern is we have a

1:24:37 lot of money tied up in that house. We're not rich so the value of that house

1:24:43 represents a very sizable chunk of our net worth. I'm 59 years old, my wife is

1:24:50 58, we're gonna be looking at retiring soon and we probably will need to sell

1:24:56 the house within a few years and regain some of that equity. So my concern is

1:25:05 One is that this, had I known that this situation was going to occur, we would not have purchased

1:25:16 the house in this neighborhood.

1:25:20 We had many options that were on other parts of the town.

1:25:27 We liked this house because it was brick and it has a lot of square footage.

1:25:32 like the way that it was laid out. Also, and I know that each case is reviewed

1:25:42 individually, but once you let somebody do this, you're setting a precedence. Okay,

1:25:49 and I know how precedents is work. I had my own business when I lived in New Hampshire.

1:25:56 When I started it, I had to move into a house that was zoned, homeowner slash

1:26:04 commercial or residential slash commercial okay so that I wasn't I didn't

1:26:10 have to go through any of this and I was within my rights to run a business

1:26:15 out there I don't know Carly and very well everyone I've talked to speaks well

1:26:22 of her and this is not personal I really think that if we allow this to occur

1:26:36 someone else is already talking about running a dog grooming business in there

1:26:40 you know I mean within five years are we gonna have six or seven businesses in

1:26:45 there and who's going to want to buy a house in there when we need to sell it, when we

1:26:51 need to sell ours, you know, with that going on. That being said, I'd like to just read

1:27:01 a few notes. This is just off of the town website and this is under Title 10 zoning

1:27:13 of Division Regulation, Chapter 1, General Zoning Provisions.

1:27:20 In Section 5, the responsibility of the zoning board we've already been through is to protect

1:27:28 the character of all parts of the municipality, that Section 5 line item, and further Section

1:27:41 line item E to protect and conserve the value of land throughout the

1:27:46 municipality and the value of the buildings. So that's something that I would

1:27:54 ask you to keep in mind in making this decision. Also the fact that everyone

1:27:59 who's spoken for this business are not people who live in the subdivision. It's a

1:28:09 very tiny subdivision. The houses are like 10 feet apart in places. Some are

1:28:14 20 but a lot of them are just 10 feet apart.

1:28:17 Everything everybody does affects everybody else.

1:28:21 And I really would appreciate it if you consider the fact

1:28:31 that there's a lot of us here that are speaking against this.

1:28:37 I haven't talked to anybody in the neighborhood who's for it.

1:28:40 There isn't a single person who lives in the neighborhood

1:28:42 that I know of that is for this.

1:28:48 Lastly, having run my own business,

1:28:51 I'd be happy to sit down with Carleen, go over some numbers with her, try to figure

1:28:58 out an alternative to having this situation.

1:29:02 I think this is a great situation for her.

1:29:05 It's ideal.

1:29:06 It's probably the straightest line to what she wants to do.

1:29:11 But I think there are other options.

1:29:14 If she's doing 100 massages a month, if she raises a price of each one five bucks, she's

1:29:22 going to cover that expense for her overhead that she's talked about. And if

1:29:27 her clients are that happy with her, then they should be willing to do that.

1:29:33 And understanding her situation. I think it's one alternative. Another

1:29:41 alternative would be to sell her home. It would have been there for a year and a

1:29:44 half. That house has accrued equity, as property values have increased, and I'm

1:29:51 sure that she could sell the home for what she paid for, at least after real

1:29:56 state commissions. Like I said, I just, I think there's other alternatives here

1:30:09 that have not been explored. I believe that if she wanted to do this, she

1:30:15 should have moved to a place where she could do it. And yes, that's all I have

1:30:22 to say. I'll see to please consider this and the effect that it will have on

1:30:27 Can you clarify from your address, please again?

1:30:32 Yes, I signed in on the shadow side.

1:30:36 It's 1472, bitter root, working in San Antonio.

1:30:40 Thank you. Is there anyone else who wishes to speak against the request

1:30:50 of this evening? Anyone who has any general comments they would like to make on this item?

1:30:58 Alright, seeing them, we will close the public input portion

1:31:04 of the public hearing and we'll turn it back over to the applicant to respond to

1:31:08 Any of the comments or questions that you heard there?

1:31:23 It's a little hard.

1:31:27 I've said that.

1:31:29 I've taken it very personally, especially when I'm offered to put my house up for sale.

1:31:34 The one thing that I just really need to make sure that all my neighbors understand, I'm not

1:31:42 changing.

1:31:43 I'm not trying to change the zoning on my house.

1:31:48 It is not changing it to a commercial property.

1:31:52 It is not a commercial when it's split.

1:31:59 It's a commercial overlay.

1:32:01 None of that.

1:32:02 It is simply a professional overlay permit to do business within my home.

1:32:12 It's not going to affect any of our property values.

1:32:15 I'm concerned about my property value as well.

1:32:18 If I was going to do anything that was going to hurt my property value,

1:32:21 I'd have a problem with that as well.

1:32:23 There are several neighbors that I've spoken to that don't have a problem with this.

1:32:28 unfortunately they weren't able to make it tonight. I understand their concerns. I understand the

1:32:39 concern of the neighbor that is in front of me. My business doesn't make any outward noise,

1:32:46 or scent, or lighting. It would not be sleeping all for taking here. All sides,

1:33:07 Thank you.

1:33:15 So now is an opportunity for questions of staff and actually Steve, I do have a clarification.

1:33:26 So can you clarify for me?

1:33:29 Because there was a lot of interchanging of terms of commercial zoning, house occupation,

1:33:36 professional overlay.

1:33:37 Can you clarify for me?

1:33:39 Certainly.

1:33:40 What the answer is in question.

1:33:41 Yeah.

1:33:42 The actual request is just for a special use permit.

1:33:44 There's no additional overlay.

1:33:46 There's no rezoning going on.

1:33:49 And this is across the city, any residentially-zoned property, even in the SUY, is allowed through

1:33:58 the Special East Permit to have a home occupation.

1:34:04 There may be some circumstances where CC&Rs don't allow for it, but that is a neighborhood

1:34:10 decision, and that is that that is enforceable only at a civil level, not

1:34:17 through the city. This is also governed by the fallow limited PUD, which directly

1:34:24 references the the zoning. It doesn't make any mention of not allowing

1:34:28 especially for occupations. So directly references the base zoning and the base

1:34:34 So it allows for home occupations through this process,

1:34:38 as much as it is for my process.

1:34:40 And that was the other question I was going to ask

1:34:41 is about there was reference to the rules of the subdivision.

1:34:45 So the PUD, the plan unit development for this property

1:34:49 does not preclude a request for home occupation.

1:34:53 Correct.

1:34:54 Are you aware of their additional CC&Rs on top of that PUD?

1:34:58 I am not aware of any CC&Rs on top of that PUD.

1:35:02 I don't believe I really even looked into it, so I apologize for that.

1:35:05 I will be better prepared next time.

1:35:07 But even if I did see them, we could still do this process.

1:35:13 If you all could still approve an SUP, it would be up to the neighbors to follow up with a civil action to prevent it.

1:35:22 I'll leave those with the only questions that I had for you.

1:35:30 Chris talking to you have a question for Steve following up, but this special use request for home occupation. Are you familiar with any

1:35:38 prohibitions or any conditions in cul-de-sacs in the city that have a loud

1:35:45 Similar request for home occupation. I am not aware of any and the the six that Carlin referenced

1:35:54 Like she said one was withdrawn or two was drawn one was denied

1:35:58 on the other three were approved.

1:36:01 From my memory, the one that was denied,

1:36:04 it was just basically no one came out in support of it,

1:36:07 and there was really some straining waiting circumstances

1:36:11 for that particular one to deny it.

1:36:18 Any further questions for staff?

1:36:21 Vicki Boy.

1:36:23 It's for staff or not, but I'm looking at the staff report

1:36:27 and there's a picture.

1:36:30 It's the overhead that was shown at the very beginning that shows this property and it talks about the public hearing on...

1:36:44 Okay, this one right here.

1:36:49 No, the one that's on the screen now, it's just...

1:36:53 Right, but this one shows...

1:36:57 You can see the raised...

1:37:02 Okay, there is a big squiggle that goes out into the street with two circles drawn on it is

1:37:14 this so that's the that's the driveway that's the shared driveway and that is a a shared ownership

1:37:23 What?

1:37:24 Why does that come way out and not the curve?

1:37:31 Look me.

1:37:32 I think they're...

1:37:33 Oh, you're talking about this right here?

1:37:36 Right.

1:37:37 And then why does it go like that?

1:37:38 Why does it make that dog leg, I guess?

1:37:42 I apologize.

1:37:48 Okay, now make this other picture.

1:37:54 That's a bright one.

1:37:55 No other picture again.

1:37:57 Okay.

1:37:58 Why does it not this area, not this whole piece, this property?

1:38:11 Okay.

1:38:14 That's private property. That's how the neighborhood was planted

1:38:27 And that's where those markings and the template residents showed the markings in the grass

1:38:48 That that is a protrusion that doesn't really make sense

1:38:56 Yeah, exactly

1:39:03 Any further questions for staff?

1:39:06 Yes, Chris Reed.

1:39:11 Special use permits.

1:39:16 What is the process if it was our frustrated?

1:39:19 There are more cars.

1:39:20 We've had that in the past with certain businesses following what they were going to say.

1:39:25 But what's the process to down the road remove a special use permit if it does go first night?

1:39:32 Good question.

1:39:33 So, if the applicant is found to be in violation of any of the conditions of the SUP and or of the zone,

1:39:44 then the residents, the neighbors around can petition the Planning and Zoning Commission to revoke the special instrument.

1:39:53 And at that time, if revoked, she would be required to end operating her for the questions.

1:40:12 Thank you, Steve.

1:40:16 We will now have a hearing is closed, and we will turn it over to Council for Ms. Stockington.

1:40:27 On my 27 years on the Council, I've been familiar with literally dozens, if not almost hundreds,

1:40:39 requests for home occupations, and by and large the applicants, as I recall, have been responsible people

1:40:47 and highly aware that their neighbors were looking for them to do something wrong.

1:40:53 That's sort of quite strict on the management of traffic coming,

1:40:58 going hours of operation, noise, lighting, home occupation.

1:41:05 It's not, again, it's been stated, it's not opening up the commercial occupation operation.

1:41:11 It gives an opportunity for people to live and work out of their home in concurrence with

1:41:20 the needs of the neighbors.

1:41:22 I think it's a compatible zoning request and allowance in the city of Twin Falls, usually

1:41:30 with a few conditions that are appropriate for that area.

1:41:36 As such, I would approve for the 1333

1:41:44 Frederick Drive request to allow the special use permit for the home occupation as described.

1:41:49 A big two the hours of operation to be 10 to 5 p.m. Monday through Friday.

1:41:56 As a clarification would that include the staff recommendations as well?

1:42:02 Yes, yes.

1:42:05 There's a second for that motion.

1:42:13 Great landing motion by Chris Stockton and second by Greg Lanting to approve the request for the special use permit

1:42:20 as presented and with the staff conditions and with the addition of a limitation of operation from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m.

1:42:28 Monday through Friday. Suzanne Hawkins. Thank you. Well, this is really, um,

1:42:34 I think this is one of the toughest presentations we've had since I've been on council.

1:42:40 I always lean towards personal property rights and using your property in a way

1:42:47 that sees fit. Me, the real complication with this one is the location and how

1:42:54 close the neighborhoods are. The gentleman who works nights, I know that

1:42:59 the massage business itself is not noisy, cars and car doors shutting and be noisy

1:43:06 and disruptive to someone else. So then you look at these two property owners who

1:43:10 who both have equal rights to live their life and provide for their families.

1:43:15 And these two are in direct competition with each other.

1:43:20 It's a really tough one to look at.

1:43:23 I live on a semi-cola sack and my neighbor has an in-home business.

1:43:28 And I'm the one who comes home or in the morning has people blocking my driveway

1:43:34 and I can't get in and out because they're trying to get to her home,

1:43:38 which she's a widow, she's supporting herself. We've talked about it as neighbors and worked through

1:43:44 the issues to the best that we can. She can't control her clients 100 percent, she tries.

1:43:51 We have a great relationship and I would never be grudge her the ability to make her living.

1:43:57 But at the same time, not everybody has the ability to work in a neighborhood

1:44:02 where this driveway is so small and so tight and it affects so many properties,

1:44:08 it really makes it hard to elevate anyone against another. I'm struggling, struggling, it's really tough.

1:44:16 I feel for everybody on both sides of this issue, and no matter what way we go, it's going to affect somebody negatively.

1:44:26 I'm struggling. I'd like to hear what other council members think.

1:44:31 Thank you. Great landing.

1:44:33 Well, we've been having a lot of tough on some late, and I'm pretty sure we probably have a split council on this one as well.

1:44:40 Well, I was going to add an amendment that said that they had to be parked on her property,

1:44:50 but the item number two of the staff recommendation is already does X, it says it has to be on

1:44:57 Law 20, it can't be on Law 19, which I'm assuming is where the driveway is.

1:45:02 To Nicky's question, I'm betting that little bulb out there is so if you look at the law

1:45:09 the thirteen forty four five is on how would you meet a city code for a size of

1:45:15 line and have that little bit of evidence for footage I'm not saying that's for sure

1:45:20 it looks like that's a possibility after I look at these each of them individually

1:45:30 each home of the situation they really get here I saw way more of it not my

1:45:34 eight years I'm planning a zony I've ever seen on council for home occupations if

1:45:40 If this was a child care, there would be no doubt in my mind, the answer would be no.

1:45:47 Not a chance because they would generate a lot more traffic than this does.

1:45:51 Just don't see that child care wouldn't work there at all, and there's probably others that wouldn't work as well.

1:45:57 I like Chris' addition of the 10-5, I think, that's down on the amount of time that people are going to be.

1:46:09 And also with traffic, yes, other people are coming home from work and things, then they won't be involved in it.

1:46:15 Um, like Suzanne, I don't like to hear from others. I'm on the fence.

1:46:21 No, they're very determined. I refresh my screen. You're under public hearings. You're not on the actual public hearing item.

1:46:40 That's okay.

1:46:41 I think six o'clock is okay, because if you are working, appointments are half an hour.

1:46:58 There needs to be an opportunity five or six, and I think six o'clock seems reasonable for

1:47:11 somebody who's coming after work, so there would be opportunity after five o'clock.

1:47:20 I'm still wrestling with the having your family come in and check the house and let the dogs

1:47:28 out and let the dogs back in.

1:47:30 That they park on the door, but that's any different than somebody coming over in the

1:47:37 in closing the door each way, whether it's somebody going in for a massage or somebody

1:47:47 going in to let the dogs out. So I don't, and are we for sure that there's no, I know

1:47:54 we don't deal with CCU and that's not a city thing, but I am wondering anybody that lives

1:48:04 in that neighborhood thinks that there are CCU.

1:48:07 What I'm saying is the public hearing was closed, so you're of an information rights.

1:48:18 So as I ask the question, as Steve described, if this is not in compliance with the CCNRs,

1:48:26 then that is a civil action that could be taken to address it, that we wouldn't have an influence on anything.

1:48:32 But according to the planned urban development and city code, both allow for because I, you

1:48:47 know, private property rights say that you have the right to quiet enjoyment of your home.

1:48:53 And so does everybody else.

1:48:56 So, I don't know what is crazy, but I'm going to...

1:49:09 No, I too, not to echo Nicki's comment,

1:49:13 the difference between three to four in and out stops

1:49:18 to deal with the dogs versus four to five people coming in

1:49:23 on a daily basis is to me the same number of trips.

1:49:27 Frankly, at my home with two teenagers and a wife and me,

1:49:32 I mean, we probably take 15 trips in and out of our house

1:49:35 on a daily basis and I too live in a residential neighborhood.

1:49:40 I think it's just the nature of people going into other houses.

1:49:48 Councilman Lanting said too, I think if the requests were for something that was going

1:49:53 to generate a significant number of vehicle trips, I would struggle with this location

1:50:01 for that.

1:50:02 But I don't see this doing that.

1:50:05 The applicant and her presentation again address the traffic issue and also indicated

1:50:14 that she would be willing to pay more for the maintenance

1:50:16 in the upkeep of that piece of the private driveway

1:50:20 since the concern was additional traffic

1:50:22 and disrupting that.

1:50:25 I'm glad we were able to clarify

1:50:28 the correct definitions of the terms of home occupation.

1:50:34 I mean, home is in there.

1:50:35 It's a business you're operating at home.

1:50:37 It's not a home that you have at the living your business.

1:50:40 It's not commercial zoning.

1:50:42 Frankly, part of this cultist act actually

1:50:45 butts actual commercial zoning, car dealership

1:50:49 on probably the most active commercial corridor

1:50:52 and when falls on blue legs.

1:50:55 I too do not think that allowing these kinds

1:50:59 of home occupation uses are detrimental to property values.

1:51:03 I think if that were the case, we wouldn't have a history

1:51:06 of actually having this be a part of our code

1:51:09 being able to address those.

1:51:13 Frankly, I'm supportive of the request.

1:51:16 I understand change causes, fear, and the unknown is a worry, but fear from the presentation

1:51:29 this evening, and truthfully even in the spirit of the tone of the neighbors who are opposing

1:51:36 this, I think if there are weeks that need to be made, you can all figure out how to

1:51:43 work that out.

1:51:44 So personally, I'm supportive of the request of something that's in compliance with our

1:51:49 It's something that we allow in our zoning, something we do on a relatively regular basis.

1:51:54 I think it's a compatible use.

1:51:58 Krisri, do you think this is a really difficult decision?

1:52:04 I wish I was going to add something that was probably going to sway someone.

1:52:08 I personally don't think that this is going to affect the neighbors, but the neighbors have come out and said this is going to affect us.

1:52:18 Those that spoke in favor are clients.

1:52:23 They don't live next next door to this home.

1:52:27 And so I understand the concern also because if you look at the south,

1:52:34 south of it, it is commercial.

1:52:36 The west of it is also commercial when you zoom out.

1:52:39 And so a fear of commercial encroaching out in this very small area.

1:52:44 Girl down just a little bit. That area is all commercial.

1:52:50 And so there is a large concern where they are surrounded to the south

1:52:55 the south and into the west with commercial. I'm struggling with it. Like I said, I don't

1:53:03 think it really is going to affect with the amount of traffic. I mean, I think of my house

1:53:09 in a few years I'm going to have more teenagers than I know what to do with and they don't want

1:53:13 me in that neighborhood then. But it's a small community, a small area. People have purchased

1:53:19 homes right there for that reason. I went just to add, I do think it's important to remember that

1:53:27 This isn't a request to rezone to a career zone.

1:53:31 So I do think that that does muddy the water a little bit

1:53:34 when we worry about the commercial nature of it.

1:53:36 I do say business within a home.

1:53:39 No, I completely, this is a special use permit completely.

1:53:43 But the fear is what's, you know, and I understand that this is,

1:53:48 this will always be a house, right, with a special use permit

1:53:53 to have a business inside of it.

1:53:57 Is that Hawkins?

1:53:58 I guess it's just one last thought.

1:54:00 I'm very much, you know, being a small business owner, like to see people succeed in their business

1:54:06 choices.

1:54:07 I just feel like this street in this neighborhood, the homes are just too close together.

1:54:13 I think when everybody went into this neighborhood, they went in there because of the quietness,

1:54:19 because of the neighborhood, because of the layout, and I think changing it at this part

1:54:24 It's just, I think there's too many neighbors that are opposed to it, and I think it's gonna make for an unhappy neighborhood if it is approved.

1:54:32 So, after listening to more conversation tonight, I will be voting against the motion just because I don't think it's the right neighborhood.

1:54:43 Mr. Stockington.

1:54:48 Well, we talked this to death, but I'll put in another 30 seconds, where if I think you're

1:54:54 overlooking the honorable application by the applicant to follow the rules to make herself

1:55:00 on a water intent is, and by drawing attention to herself, I would bet, dollars to tell

1:55:07 us that she's going to be an exemplary home occupation on her because she knows people

1:55:13 Look, who brought Puff's sickle stick on the ground when they shouldn't, so I think that we need to give her credit, and that she's gonna be an exemplary occupant of the home occupation, have approved.

1:55:28 Chris, wait.

1:55:30 Good question for staff. That's all right.

1:55:32 What's the width of that private driveway? Can two cars pass each other?

1:55:36 No.

1:55:37 It's one in, one out.

1:55:39 Yes.

1:55:40 But I would view it the same.

1:55:50 people coming in and out and know. Also are there other applications in the city

1:55:57 where we need to have

1:55:58 neighbors input, neighbors approval

1:56:01 what we're doing? Well anything, anything that requires special use permit

1:56:07 requires public notice whether or not

1:56:11 those individuals that are notified via mail come and speak

1:56:15 is up to them. This one obviously

1:56:19 the neighbors are obviously concerned and so they are here to voice their

1:56:23 Thank you, yes?

1:56:28 I've also thought a lot about this and we are following rules the applicant has followed and I do think isn't there old exactly?

1:56:56 It's difficult, but I do think...

1:57:07 Maybe I got this information

1:57:22 Need to correct Steve a bit. So it's not 24 feet wide. We don't believe but

1:57:27 If there's at least nine feet, so you have two parking stalls next to each other

1:57:30 You only need about 18 feet to potentially get by if you're only going like two miles an hour, so

1:57:35 It's not 24 feet like a drive out would be but it

1:57:40 Depends why

1:57:42 It's a wider than than 12 and like one lane

1:57:45 We just don't have the actual width, but we know we get a fire truck back there

1:57:49 Thank you.

1:57:51 Any further comments for Council?

1:57:56 We do have a motion on the table from Chris Talkington, seconded by Great Lanting to approve

1:58:04 the special use permit to operate a home occupation or property located at 1333 Bitterroot Drive

1:58:11 as presented with the staff recommendations and with the addition of a condition, the

1:58:17 hours of operation be 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday through Friday.

1:58:20 Please, roll call vote please.

1:58:24 Reg Lanting? Yes. Mr. Perried? No. Mr. Talkington? Yes.

1:58:35 Zann Hawkins? No. McKee Boyd? Yes. Yes. Motion passes 4-2.

1:58:48 But that is the conclusion of the agenda, so the meeting is adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, April 15, 2019. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:59:19.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    1294248a8b56b1a255b3573e67726c7b25e5f8dd087d4b37f630891993b5bec6
  5. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 23 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    aa5be2541620609bc593f21ff1f8cfcdb5a3900db7b1f4e8d3cd5c36643c6175

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file