OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, June 24, 2019

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: b,f

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:00:24 to call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday, June 24th, and confirm

0:00:29 we do have a quorum on the council here. Six of the seven members are present this evening.

0:00:34 Councilwoman Suzanne Hawkins is excused. The first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:00:39 For those of you who wish to join us, please rise. Next on the agenda are proclamations we

0:01:07 have none this evening. So next is an opportunity for general public input. If there's anyone

0:01:12 here from the public who wishes to address the council on an item that is not on the agenda,

0:01:16 not on the agenda this evening, now it's your opportunity to please come forward.

0:01:20 Seeing no consent counts.

0:01:53 So those as you're aware of the city oversaw the downtown comments project,

0:01:59 we oversaw the downtown comments project, we reimbursing the city for those.

0:02:10 Those are the final payments, so what we do is we retain some overall amount,

0:02:17 project is complete, we release the retained, or expect to start.

0:02:23 Those are the three projects within that $156,000, I believe.

0:02:30 So I would like to present calendar one.

0:02:47 Second.

0:02:48 Motion by Chris Togne and second by Ruth Pierce to approve the consent calendar, but the exception of item five be the minutes of last week's meeting and starting discussion.

0:03:07 Great, land take, it's Pierce.

0:03:10 Yes.

0:03:11 Mr. Perried.

0:03:12 Yes.

0:03:13 Motion passes six to zero.

0:03:15 So if you were here for the alcohol license renewals, the fifth annual Vietnam or Veterans

0:03:55 Commemoration Special Event Application, the IRRS event, Special Event Application, or any of the findings of fact or conclusions of law for temple view properties, Maria Silva annexation in the falls of the Preserve.

0:04:10 Those were all just approved balance of our items of consideration.

0:04:18 The first is a presentation of Courtney Kent's promotion to senior inspector and we have Jared Ortey, our building official.

0:04:25 I remember as the council really appreciate the opportunity to recognize Courtney tonight.

0:04:37 It's important for our department to have this position.

0:04:40 It's been really crucial for the function of our department.

0:04:43 It's just a great opportunity to recognize it tonight.

0:04:46 I want to start with a little bit of history.

0:04:48 Courtney hasn't met with the city very long.

0:04:50 She's excelled pretty quickly.

0:04:52 In 2017, we had a position open up for entry level building inspector position.

0:04:56 At the time, Courtney was working for Idaho City as a head inspector.

0:05:00 and decided to apply for the job.

0:05:02 Well after recruitment, we hired her in October 2017.

0:05:09 A few months after she started,

0:05:11 I'll never forget she came in and said,

0:05:14 what I signed up for.

0:05:18 This industry is kind of a silent one,

0:05:20 but it's faced with a lot of challenges.

0:05:22 It's very competitive.

0:05:24 There's lots of demanding things that go on in our industry

0:05:26 and being a female to dominate a male dominated industry

0:05:30 even adds more to it.

0:05:31 She's really excelled and done really well.

0:05:36 After she said that, she was faced with one of her first challenges and she took her first

0:05:40 inspector exam and failed it.

0:05:43 I remember that day she was really frustrated and like all of us in this industry and everything

0:05:49 together, it took her career based with a decision.

0:05:53 And the decision is to quit or work harder and Courtney decided to work harder and really

0:05:58 motivated her to excel and just push on even deeper.

0:06:02 And then she passed all her exams and then we got through that.

0:06:06 She went into her probationary period as an inspector and passed forward to 2019.

0:06:13 Our senior inspector position opened up in Courtney, put her hat in there.

0:06:18 And it was a very competitive process and we selected her and she was promoted senior inspector in April.

0:06:24 She's really excelled quickly in our city.

0:06:28 Been an asset to our department in our city.

0:06:31 I really just want to ask you to join us in congratulating her.

0:06:34 I have a motion she has to say something tonight, so.

0:06:46 I was prepared to like these speech and I just want to say that I appreciate you taking the time.

0:06:54 Next on the agenda we have an action item. This is a presentation of a proposal to create the Twin Falls Public Art Commission.

0:07:28 I have some grant and community relations manager.

0:07:30 Good evening, Marin Council. Thank you for taking the time this evening to listen to a presentation that prepared on

0:08:09 a recommendation to create a Twin Falls Public Art Councilor Commission. As you

0:08:15 all know, public art is becoming or is playing a larger role in the city of

0:08:21 Twin Falls, especially since the opening of the Twin Falls Commons and the

0:08:28 plethora of art that is adorning the Commons, the John Hayes statue, and then

0:08:33 also the kaleidoscope that's on the corner of Hampson and Maine. Public art plays a

0:08:38 a very important role in understanding and in the understanding and enjoyment of a community.

0:08:45 Art is more accessible and more visible when it's displayed in a public area and a key feature

0:08:51 of public art is the importance of integrating art into the fabric of the community in which

0:08:56 it's placed.

0:08:58 Art transforms spaces and makes them a valuable contribution to our appreciation of the city

0:09:04 and the history of that community.

0:09:08 In addition, public art is, um, public art located in public places reflects the unique

0:09:13 environment and the cultural identity of the city to our visitors as well as the residents.

0:09:18 It often provides a link with our history and can contribute to economic development and tourism.

0:09:24 So tonight I just wanted to give you a little bit of background, um, on public art in Twin

0:09:30 Falls and where we envision seeing public, um, the commission going, so every, um, history

0:09:45 of Public Art. In June of 2007, Resolution number 1785 was passed, and this resolution essentially

0:09:53 created the ability of the city to fund public art by establishing an art in public places

0:10:03 program. The resolution established the Magic Art Commission as the advisory commission that

0:10:11 would essentially manage public art for the city. It also created a funding mechanism of

0:10:19 .005% of all capital improvement projects in the general fund for each budget year. I spoke

0:10:25 with Lori Reyes, our CFO today, and that generally adds up to about $6,000 each year.

0:10:31 This resolution was an excellent first step, but unfortunately, because it had an outside

0:10:38 entity as the advisory commission, it really didn't give a whole lot of teeth to the program

0:10:44 itself. It didn't require any regular meeting or any regular planning of public art or public

0:10:51 art policy. It laid out in very brief terms with very little structure what public art

0:10:56 would look like in Twin Falls and the roles and responsibilities and primarily the source

0:11:02 of funding which as I said was that small percentage of our capital improvement projects.

0:11:08 As I mentioned before, the Twin Falls Commons is really going to become the center place of

0:11:12 public art in Twin Falls, at least in the downtown area with the murals that are placed

0:11:17 on the wall, the John Hayes dashes of the kaleidoscope, and I think we can all agree that that is completely

0:11:24 transformed the space and that if we had that space without that art in it, it would have

0:11:29 a completely different feel, and it would not, I think, have the community aspects that

0:11:36 it does.

0:11:37 However, there are aspects of having art in any sort of public venue that we need to

0:11:45 start considering and one of the things that we need to start considering is the maintenance

0:11:49 of those pieces that we have and the cost of changing out those murals, those were meant

0:11:55 to not be permanent but be temporary and the process by which we would go through commissioning

0:12:00 new pieces, having those pieces stretched onto the canvas, so on and so forth.

0:12:07 So there's that, there's the maintenance of the statute,

0:12:11 there's the maintenance of the kaleidoscope.

0:12:13 So just in this very small one block area,

0:12:15 you see that there are a lot of issues

0:12:18 and a lot of things that we need

0:12:19 to start taking into consideration.

0:12:21 Those, all of those projects were also part

0:12:24 of the URA funded program with the main avenue reconstruction.

0:12:29 And they were selected through a sub-committee,

0:12:31 a public art sub-committee of the Herbert or Newell agency.

0:12:34 So that was completely separate from

0:12:36 the Art Public Places program that we have for the city, but again, added to the now existing

0:12:43 public art collection that we have.

0:12:45 I'm going to just put this matrix up here to talk a little bit about, as I've done a lot

0:12:56 of research on the various communities within Idaho and around the country that have public

0:13:00 art policies, have public art commissions, this is fairly common practice and it's a

0:13:06 way to help both local government and the residents participate in and have an

0:13:14 incandest structure to the public art that is created and placed in their

0:13:18 communities. So the first question I thought I would talk a little bit about is

0:13:21 or the first thing I thought I would talk a little bit about is what is public art.

0:13:25 And there's two things that really denote whether you can consider art

0:13:29 public or private and that's really the physical space that it occupies and

0:13:33 and its origins of existence, essentially how it's paid, paid for.

0:13:37 So if you look up on this matrix on that upper left-hand corner you see in the box marked A1,

0:13:45 you see private origin and private placement.

0:13:48 So this is art that's purchased by individuals or corporations

0:13:52 and it's placed inside of private buildings or residences.

0:13:56 There's nothing public about that art.

0:13:58 You all the way diagonal to the other corner, which is C3,

0:14:02 You see the art that is fully public origin,

0:14:07 so meaning it's fully funded by public tax dollars,

0:14:10 and placed in a completely public environment,

0:14:13 whether that be a government building,

0:14:15 or like a park, or a commons,

0:14:17 then you have what you would,

0:14:18 I guess we can consider absolutely to be public art.

0:14:23 So then you kind of can look around this matrix,

0:14:25 and I want to go through each of the boxes,

0:14:27 but it just gives you an idea that you can have public art,

0:14:30 and it doesn't have to necessarily be paid for

0:14:32 with public funding. It can be a public partnership. It can be completely funded, privately, but

0:14:39 displayed in a public venue. And then there's a little bit of wiggle room in the middle,

0:14:44 which is kind of that public, um, partial public placement and partial public, um, origins.

0:14:50 So this is just to kind of give you an idea of the, I guess, the, um, the different aspects

0:14:57 of what makes a public art.

0:14:59 And communities are kind of one of the reasons

0:15:03 that communities adopt public art policy

0:15:05 and have these commissions is because they get to a point

0:15:07 where either there's controversy surrounding a fully

0:15:11 publicly funded art piece of art, that is, again,

0:15:15 it's displayed publicly, but was also paid for

0:15:18 with public funds, and so then there are going to be people

0:15:20 who maybe disagree with the content of the art,

0:15:24 or they feel that maybe it isn't reflective

0:15:26 of their community.

0:15:27 So the idea of having a policy in place is that you have an understanding of what the community

0:15:34 standards are for Twin Falls.

0:15:36 We have a commission that advises the council on what those standards are and can advise

0:15:45 you moving forward on what some of the potential projects are because if an individual comes

0:15:50 to the city and wants to give us a loan as or grant us or give us a piece of art, it

0:15:55 doesn't necessarily fit within the community standards that we've set forward in our public

0:16:00 art policy, we have the ability to potentially, um, lightly decline the gift. So again, it gives

0:16:07 us, um, the council kind of a little bit of an ability to say, no, I'm sorry, but that

0:16:10 doesn't fall within the policies that we haven't docked it.

0:16:15 Public art, um, has many stakeholders, whether that is the government, which obviously would

0:16:19 be the city in this situation. Um, but also the artists. And it's interesting, a lot of the

0:16:26 work, or the research, excuse me, that I did, really talked about how public art is becoming

0:16:33 a new genre in itself, and the artists are becoming more and more aware of what is considered

0:16:38 to be good public art, because something that's considered to be of high artistic value in

0:16:45 a museum in New York City may or may not fly on the court falls.

0:16:53 So, it's really interesting to see how, and I think we see it every April when we have

0:16:58 art and soul in Twin Falls, that you can see a huge variety of artists and what they consider

0:17:05 to be their art, then your, their art genre, and, and medium, and we are able to see those

0:17:12 publicly displayed for, and in some cases, privately displayed in them, side of part, on

0:17:18 businesses, but again, it's that kind of understanding of those artists that are putting those pieces

0:17:24 of work on display that there is, you know, they're understanding what public art is and

0:17:30 what works well for public art.

0:17:33 Another important stakeholder in public art are those art organizations.

0:17:37 So in our case, this certainly would be the Magic Valley Arts Council.

0:17:41 So this is a no way meant to replace the Magic Valley Arts Council.

0:17:44 in fact I think they would have to be a very strong partnership on this commission but again

0:17:49 this just takes the onus of the magic light arts council. We are no longer looking to them

0:17:57 to guide us in all of our decisions as far as public arts concerned in the city. Private

0:18:02 institutions are also a very important stakeholder and by that I mean private businesses, non-profits,

0:18:08 individual, private individuals that perhaps can help with funding of public

0:18:16 arts. So again, you don't have that lower quadrant where it's fully

0:18:21 publicly funded and fully publicly displayed, but I think private institutions, private businesses,

0:18:28 and the like will be a very important partner and stakeholder in our public

0:18:34 art program as we're up because again, as it sits now, we were only looking at

0:18:39 about a $6,000 per year in our annual budget,

0:18:43 so we're going to have to look at different ways

0:18:44 to generate some funding for additional public art

0:18:48 in the community.

0:18:49 And then last but not least, I think actually is the public.

0:18:52 And it's extremely important in everything,

0:18:54 all the research that I've done to make the public,

0:18:57 maybe not in this process, but really involving the public

0:19:03 in what we're doing with the public art program,

0:19:07 one so that people can come to you in public comment

0:19:12 a council meeting and say I didn't know anything about this, I don't like this, this

0:19:15 offends me, but it gives people the opportunity to get involved. When we did

0:19:21 the murals out on comments, that was a great opportunity to get artists involved in

0:19:27 submitting their proposals, their pieces to be considered to not only be put on

0:19:32 the murals, but on the electrical boxes along the main avenue. I know that Jackie

0:19:37 feels while she was still here and has been working with with City with the

0:19:42 traffic engineer to look at various ways to start wrapping the lights at all of the different

0:19:51 intersections that have those intersections. So there's tons of ways to get the public involved,

0:19:57 not just submitting their art, but also getting them involved maybe in a public voting process,

0:20:02 but another way to engage the community and what we're doing here in Twin Falls.

0:20:10 So really the purpose of the commission, I probably have already gone over this, but

0:20:15 but is to establish the policies and guidelines

0:20:17 for the operation, funding, and implementation

0:20:19 of the public art program in Twin Falls.

0:20:21 That would be a commission that is an advisory commission

0:20:24 to the council.

0:20:26 The mission of the program is to support a thriving arts

0:20:29 community through the activation of public spaces.

0:20:31 And this is really critical, I think,

0:20:34 is the idea that we're activating these public spaces.

0:20:36 So this is, I believe, I think this

0:20:41 is the day that we opened the comments.

0:20:43 But regardless of whether or not that was the event,

0:20:45 but you can see that art played a role that day

0:20:49 in the activation of the public space,

0:20:51 not only with the murals that we were introducing

0:20:54 to the community, but the unveiling of the statue,

0:20:57 and just the effect that it had on that space.

0:21:00 But also performance, life performance,

0:21:03 most times public art policy does not include public performances,

0:21:07 but I think it's really important to look

0:21:08 at every aspect of art and understand that,

0:21:12 you know, in live and activating our public spaces certainly is more than just murals and statues.

0:21:18 It's, you know, it's maybe pop-up performances in different ways that we can bring people downtown

0:21:24 or two different areas of the community and have that what's drawing those individuals is art in one

0:21:30 manner or the other. It's also expanding opportunities for our residents to experience art in general

0:21:36 and public places and it'll create obviously a more visually pleasing and culturally rich environment

0:21:42 while expanding their public's knowledge of arts and culture.

0:21:47 So again, I touched on this a little bit before, but why a commission?

0:21:50 Because as I said earlier, the resolution from June of 2007

0:21:55 created the public art and public places program.

0:21:59 But really a commission will inform and advise you the council on a regular basis.

0:22:05 The commission will meet on a regular basis.

0:22:07 I'd like to take a page from the playbook of Moscow, Idaho.

0:22:12 have an entire master plan for public art.

0:22:15 Probably a little ways away from that.

0:22:17 It's been a lot more centrally located,

0:22:19 not only within their strategic planning,

0:22:21 but within their budgeting process.

0:22:23 But I mean, those are things that I think

0:22:24 that the commission could work towards.

0:22:28 It will create and carry out a public art policy,

0:22:31 raise funds for additional public art projects.

0:22:35 And as I said earlier, manage the maintenance

0:22:38 of our existing collection.

0:22:40 Because as we know, we've had the statute out on the canyon

0:22:44 that several years ago we had to invest quite a bit of money

0:22:47 into some just maintenance of that piece of art.

0:22:51 And the idea of a commission would be that, say,

0:22:53 with, for instance, with the hay statute,

0:22:56 when we take on a piece of art, a part of that process

0:23:00 needs to be understanding fully what the maintenance of that

0:23:03 is.

0:23:04 And if we cannot fit that maintenance

0:23:06 in the existing city budget, whether it be Parks and Recreation

0:23:09 or maybe public works, then we would need to make sure

0:23:13 that there was some mechanism, some funding mechanism

0:23:16 in place in order to pay for the maintenance,

0:23:17 whether that be if it were a private donor,

0:23:19 that they include that within the donation,

0:23:22 or if we had to look for maybe somebody to sponsor

0:23:25 the maintenance of a piece of art once it once it's installed.

0:23:30 So I think those essentially are probably the four biggest

0:23:33 reasons why a public art policy is vital to,

0:23:38 I think having a commission is vital to moving forward with a public art program in Twin Falls

0:23:45 is just really just that regularity of the ability to create some additional funding mechanisms

0:23:50 so that we can continue to build on the collection that we have.

0:23:56 So I would ask for any questions and next steps as far as your desire to move forward

0:24:05 with the commission.

0:24:06 Chris talked.

0:24:21 I can't give you an exact figure. I know a very large portion of it, but a large portion of it was recently used to fund the diligent usher, but on the five points.

0:24:32 So part of it is that it would sit for a while and it wouldn't get used and then an idea would come in.

0:24:39 And then part of having an art policy and an art commission is the ability to vet different ideas and have a process by which we select those ideas, those art pieces, and what exactly would go into it.

0:24:58 what exactly would go into a space.

0:25:00 So I think it would give us a little bit easier.

0:25:05 I mean, we would be able to budget a little bit easier

0:25:07 because we have a process by which to select those.

0:25:12 Those pieces.

0:25:17 Presentation, arts, subcommittee.

0:25:31 They have some really good octas of people.

0:25:35 How does this commission use Don?

0:25:53 These are they only?

0:26:02 My understanding, and correct me if I'm wrong,

0:26:05 but it's my understanding that the subcommittee for art,

0:26:08 I mean, is associated with the district

0:26:11 that we, that the government district were in.

0:26:15 And it was part of the main app.

0:26:18 When I was first advising and working

0:26:20 with the committee several years ago

0:26:22 as we were looking for some grant opportunities,

0:26:24 it was my understanding that that was,

0:26:26 their funding was tied to the project.

0:26:28 So that subcommittee will sunset with the district.

0:26:38 But there's nothing to preclude any of those individuals

0:26:41 from applying for being considered, I think, to be on that.

0:26:50 Giddy is using a high school student,

0:26:55 post-secondary, you know, somebody that's enrolled at CSI perhaps, just the variety there.

0:27:03 So the Urban Renewals Subcommittee works specifically with the Urban Renewal Agency on projects,

0:27:20 and it was formed large part to assist with the placement of public art into the downtown commons.

0:27:27 That hasn't really been expanded to other spots and locations prior to that.

0:27:34 imagine because it's a creation that we'll sunset in a few years. If you think about the

0:27:51 other areas that they have, they are largely manufacturing and job creation centers. What

0:28:00 this would do is it would take a look at different make arts or public space outside of just the

0:28:15 downtown. What it would do is to carefully examine some of those gifts that are provided to us

0:28:23 and question does the city have the capacity that it also gives us the

0:28:35 opportunity to take a lot of spaces outside of the downtown core for public

0:28:40 fields retirement one here with us was this opportunity we've been talking about

0:28:48 for a while to traffic signalization boxes that you see those larger

0:28:56 pedestals by by the traffic signals to wrap those with public art that other

0:29:01 communities have done as well. The question becomes who's going to decide because these become assets

0:29:17 felt it was a pro-assist, the greatness, our ability to oversee that and then also to help promote.

0:29:42 I was saying I think that like this approach, all we see in some strategy and some vision

0:29:52 as opposed to the piece of our missions where it's hate this piece was an art and soul. It was a great

0:30:10 We'd love to see this piece in town. It was almost a reaction to this piece showed up.

0:30:14 I like that it helps to drive CSI's campus and the like this could help drive CSI this weekend.

0:30:59 But it's happening.

0:31:14 In additional funds, there are foundations or funders out there that are looking at sort of,

0:31:24 I mean, there's some big money out there for public art, public spaces,

0:31:30 and he actually applied for a grant when we were getting ready to do the main avenue project.

0:31:39 The whole onus of the grant was to kind of, we didn't receive the grant and the funder actually was willing to give

0:31:51 which is, you know, not things that it was, it was in written format.

0:31:57 They stated was that we would sort of take this on, and as we all know, projects that don't have an owner tend to, you know, they're well sometimes.

0:32:17 So I think had commission and a policy and sort of a...

0:32:23 and Chris Reed, seconded by Ruth Pierce, too, so is that enough?

0:33:09 It is, and what we will do is we will construct an ordinance that is framed around the policy statement that was included in your agenda packet in that key part of which is where we have their scope of work.

0:33:48 Greg Lanting?

0:33:49 Yes.

0:33:49 Ruth Pierce?

0:33:50 Yes.

0:33:51 Christopher Reed?

0:33:51 Yes.

0:33:52 Chris talking to Sean Berger?

0:33:54 Yes.

0:33:54 Nicky Boyd?

0:33:55 Yes.

0:33:56 Greg Lanting?

0:33:57 I get all 70.

0:34:03 Did everyone say that's good?

0:34:05 Motion passes 60.

0:34:07 Anything for you?

0:34:09 Thank you for your work in here.

0:34:10 and I do the next steps and next on the agenda is an action item.

0:34:22 This is a discussion with possible action to utilize municipal powers,

0:34:26 outsourced grant funds to provide grant match for a pending small community or service grant proposal

0:34:33 at Bill Carberry, our purganger.

0:34:35 Well, thank you, Mayor, good evening City Council.

0:34:39 Last time we met it was late May, I think it was the Tuesday after Memorial Day.

0:34:44 We talked about the strategic plan for the city, one of the strategic planning goals, and

0:34:49 that was to try to develop new strategies to improve their service in our community.

0:34:54 So we met with SkyWest in April as we discussed at that time.

0:35:00 SkyWest indicated to the group that I went down there with that they were very interested

0:35:05 in pursuing the development of a Denver route from Twin Falls on United to one of their major

0:35:11 hubs at the Denver Airport.

0:35:13 And they encouraged us to apply for a small community air service development grant that

0:35:18 the Department of Transportation offers annually to some small communities like ours.

0:35:23 Those grants have been established to help communities like ours that have limited access

0:35:30 to the air service and the structure around the country that have anti-competitive air

0:35:36 fairs or monopolistic type operations in the community.

0:35:40 So the grant is a good opportunity for us.

0:35:43 It's one that SkyWest supports fully, and we discussed that at that time the council

0:35:49 gave me the go ahead to move ahead with the application and engage our consultant to develop

0:35:55 the proposal.

0:35:56 And I'm here tonight to just talk a little bit about how the proposal is coming along.

0:36:01 In brief, the plan and project is to ask for a $900,000 grant.

0:36:08 the grant, plus the match I'll get into a little bit more that comes from our public

0:36:13 private partnership to institute an airline revenue guarantee to help assist with the startup

0:36:19 costs and the risk associated with the new route to use money also for a modified full

0:36:26 fledged marketing campaign that we'll need to put together as well as some station costs

0:36:32 for infrastructure equipment, computer systems, things like that.

0:36:36 So we reviewed some of the priority considerations the Department of Transportation has and when

0:36:42 they consider a grant application.

0:36:45 And one of those is a public-private partnership established.

0:36:49 And that partnership would certainly seek support letters, provide support letters from a broad

0:36:54 segment of the community as well as match contribution dollars.

0:36:59 And we discussed that there's no set amount of match, but about 12 to 15 percent of match

0:37:04 from the community, both public and private sector, would be something that would be expected

0:37:09 for priority consideration.

0:37:12 So to date, well, we've had a, just to meet back up a little bit, there was a very informative

0:37:18 letter that came out from the Chamber of Commerce to many local governments, as well

0:37:22 as businesses in the private sector that describe our outreach for a public-private partnership,

0:37:28 requested support letters, as well as consideration for financial support for that match.

0:37:34 So I'd like to just read, we've got about 15 support letters to date, and this is growing.

0:37:39 It's a very live topic as we shoot to, but in the application by July 15th.

0:37:44 So just to review some of those organizations and businesses that have committed support letters,

0:37:49 we have the College of Southern Idaho, Twin Falls School District.

0:37:53 Our congressional delegation has provided a letter of two senators and Congressman Simpson.

0:37:59 The Idaho Department of Commerce has written a letter as well.

0:38:02 To one false county, St. Luke's Hospital,

0:38:06 the Transportation Security Administration,

0:38:08 has provided a support letter outlining their operational readiness

0:38:13 for a new route.

0:38:14 Blambia has written a very interesting letter

0:38:17 that really details just to the extent of their travel.

0:38:20 And it's really eye-opening just how much travel

0:38:23 that organization does on a yearly basis.

0:38:26 Sky West certainly, very important support letter for the service.

0:38:31 See, formerly CEDO, we have a letter.

0:38:34 We anticipate letters from the City of Twin Falls,

0:38:36 Twin Falls Chamber, Business Plus, Idaho Power,

0:38:39 as well as Sculler Organization as well.

0:38:43 So you can see where those support letters are many,

0:38:46 and they're growing, and that's terrific.

0:38:50 In addition, at this time, to remain somewhat anonymous,

0:38:55 but the amount of match contribution coming in from local businesses and trade organizations

0:39:01 and associations is somewhere in the neighborhood of $85,000 today and we anticipate more dollars

0:39:07 coming in as we seek to get somewhere in that $135,000 range.

0:39:12 So a very short time.

0:39:13 We've really had risk participation in that area.

0:39:17 Also, the letter that went out to local governments, we've actually had the city of Hayburn respond

0:39:23 For more information, I'll be traveling to their City Council meeting Wednesday evening to discuss the match dollars and the letters of support with the City of Hayburn.

0:39:32 So we're certainly looking forward to meeting with them and providing them information for their consideration.

0:39:37 So with that in summary, we've looked at the first draft, about 20 pages that the consultant has put together, describing the elements of the grant and what they're looking for, and that's in review.

0:39:50 So that in conjunction with these letters and support we're seeing coming in, we're very

0:39:56 encouraged to how the application is coming together.

0:39:59 So tonight, just in advance of your consideration of AMPOC funds and how you may utilize what

0:40:04 you have remaining, I'd like you to consider possibly using some of those funds for matching

0:40:11 contributions towards the grant.

0:40:13 You have to answer any questions you might have.

0:40:19 They built this one, they understand fully, it would be a United Airlines route to Denver

0:40:25 would be operated by Sky West or would they just, through their agent, would it be a separate

0:40:33 entity at the airport, how does that work?

0:40:35 It would be operated by Sky West at the same station down there, they would have the United

0:40:41 brand as well as the Delta brand and their regional carrier for both of those major airlines.

0:40:47 And this is just a question that may not this particular one, but maybe a question for the future.

0:40:52 Aren't they also a partner with Alaska?

0:40:55 Alaska Horizon, American as well.

0:40:59 I'm wondering if maybe some point of first maybe you look at one to Seattle, which is a hub for Alaska,

0:41:05 especially for international flights and things. Is that a possibility as well?

0:41:09 We certainly can look at all of those types of possibilities.

0:41:12 Some of the discussions we've had in St. George with SkyWest,

0:41:15 They start to articulate the difficulty with Seattle as a connecting hub.

0:41:20 It's a good point to point, maybe good off to Asia from there, maybe West Coast.

0:41:24 But Denver is the one at this point in time, and certainly in the future, other opportunities may present themselves.

0:41:31 But right now, Denver is our primary opportunity and one that they do support.

0:41:36 Thank you very much.

0:41:38 Welcome. Totally supportive of this seed money.

0:41:50 Salt Lake has served as well, but this bill explained

0:41:54 and showed us we have such a growing industrial commercial base

0:41:58 that depends upon the westward.

0:42:05 It's almost as weird as if we help us in the United States

0:42:13 on about three forms of the population

0:42:15 is not being served directly from Jerusalem.

0:42:18 And this would give us an opportunity to make a lot of,

0:42:23 but we have unanticipated advances that we can apply for the small community and air service grant.

0:42:31 I would sure hope that we could put in 5,000 to our thicknesses.

0:42:38 Bill articulated this well in the presentation he gave earlier in the communication that's gone out to the six county plus region, about 75 Boise and Salt Lake.

0:43:24 Because that really is the goal of the grant is to help facilitate the startup of the service.

0:43:30 But what makes the service successful isn't the grant, it's use of the service.

0:43:35 And so I do think this guy West's insight that they were able to share with us when we visited with them about who has been out making.

0:44:23 So Mr. Mayor, Mr. Council, I think just a couple of things I'd add on to Bill's presentation.

0:44:27 Number one, this is clearly articulated in our strategic plan when we take a look at being an accessible community,

0:44:34 So at Prosper's Community, as we're looking to expand

0:44:37 different air connections.

0:44:40 As you recall, this has been a target and a goal of ours

0:44:43 for many, many years.

0:44:46 We started to take a look, and I know that Bill has had

0:44:48 a team actively working on this ever since SkyWest

0:44:54 made a reduction in flights.

0:44:56 We started becoming concerned about the long-term viability

0:44:58 of the airport.

0:45:00 Bill did a great job in having working directly with SkyWest

0:45:04 on the brazilia is being transformed into the RJ's that are servicing our airport now.

0:45:10 And then the goal has always been to looking to expand to other areas other than just flying

0:45:16 to Salt Lake City. It kind of is a fortuitous opportunity because of how the M-HOG process

0:45:27 work this year, there are funds available purposes of assisting outside groups funds that were

0:45:43 because of the applications and because probably in part because of the new process of the City

0:45:49 Council put in with the maximum dollar cap and its direct connection plan. So if the airport

0:45:59 were an outside entity and grateful that feels part of our team, it would have had the opportunity

0:46:08 to apply for MPOG funds, because it would have been able

0:46:12 to clearly demonstrate that it would have had a connection.

0:46:17 It would have had a difference of a $10,000 cap

0:46:19 if it was outside agency, but, again,

0:46:21 that doesn't necessarily apply because you're looking

0:46:23 at just reallocating your fund.

0:46:26 In the spirit of those MPOG dollars, it really does meet.

0:46:29 And so should that action make part of the decision now,

0:46:48 or you can say, thanks, Bill, we're going to next fund,

0:46:52 really, it is your call.

0:46:55 So we'll go ahead and move to the next agenda item

0:46:58 and kind of take these together.

0:47:01 So Bill, thank you for your presentation,

0:47:02 but don't run far,

0:47:04 as there may be further questions for you.

0:47:06 Well, the next item on the agenda is an action item.

0:47:10 This is a request to allocate the remaining municipal

0:47:13 powers outsource grant work.

0:47:22 So, probably Ms. Humber to say we'll allocate

0:47:26 the remaining funds because we have more

0:47:28 than $23,000 remaining.

0:47:30 But as Bill said, the $20,000 that would go

0:47:34 for the match for the AIRPAR grant.

0:47:37 There's sufficient funds remaining in the MPOC as well.

0:47:42 And then the other, when we spoke about this last time,

0:47:47 which was when we, the request Travis had was that,

0:47:55 if any other departments had a MPOC-like project

0:48:00 that they thought might fit within the spirit of MPOC

0:48:04 to let us know.

0:48:05 And the one that I had brought forward that night

0:48:08 will bring forward again is similar. It's not an outside entity. It's obviously a police department,

0:48:15 but if you recall several years ago, a few years ago, we hired a, for the first time, a victim,

0:48:21 witness coordinator. And Kim Burkhalter is finding herself very busy in serving the victims of crime

0:48:29 in our community. And this past spring, we applied for a grant through the state to mostly for training,

0:48:38 for Kim that doesn't fit within the training funds

0:48:41 that the police department had available for her.

0:48:43 But then she also has for a very modest amount of money,

0:48:46 it was $5,000 in total.

0:48:48 That would go towards sort of an emergency stop gap

0:48:54 for those individuals that either don't qualify

0:48:58 for the services that are provided

0:48:59 by our partner, Voices Against Violence.

0:49:03 Or there's just Kim has found over the course

0:49:07 the last few years, times when either they're just unable to help and at that moment or I

0:49:13 mean I've heard stories of officers going to Walmart and buying clothes for children because

0:49:18 they were removed from the home with very little, they've gone and bought meals for families.

0:49:23 So this just gives the opportunity as sort of a stopgap as a way to assist some of these

0:49:31 victims when there are no other assistance available and these wouldn't be long-term

0:49:39 solutions but it would be perhaps if an incident occurred on a Friday night and there's no

0:49:43 room in the shelter it would allow them to perhaps.

0:49:55 And so when we received our grant funding, $3,000 was reduced from the total that we asked

0:50:02 because the state felt that this was a duplication of services that voices against violence provides.

0:50:08 And while I would say yes, it's a duplication, I would tell you that Kim could come up here

0:50:14 and she could give you specific instances of times when she just was not able to.

0:50:21 This is just an ability and is this the opportunity to put that back in?

0:50:25 And perhaps she won't need it or perhaps she might need more.

0:50:30 I'm honest enough for her to start with and it directly is tied to our strategic plan.

0:50:39 So I would say that those are the two programs that are, you know, fall under the...

0:50:47 Like a question I would have my man use as I'm following recent.

0:50:57 I go to the stage to print corner links and it looks like we've been a little bit of what we can do about domestic violence cases in the moment, whether we're going to end up with some more situations from the home.

0:51:16 I think we've worked closely with our county prosecutor and our judges to ruin terms of

0:51:48 a telephonic warrant system for those arrests, and so I anticipate those individuals that

0:51:56 need to have a situation where the parties are not allowed to be around each other for

0:52:02 safety reasons or otherwise that we will be able to act and arrest those persons.

0:52:11 It sounds like this program is almost more for the, and there is no place safe for the

0:52:21 resources that are available for that stop gap.

0:52:44 If you could clarify, this is actually coming out of this fiscal year budget.

0:52:48 So it's really through the end of September that we're allocating three

0:52:53 thousand dollars is that correct so we have an opportunity next year more money

0:53:00 if necessary all right

0:53:02 Chris talking to supportive of the service adjust has to buy Chris talking to second

0:53:55 by Nicky Boyd to allocate three thousand dollars from the remaining

0:53:59 M.P.A.G. funds to the victim services request in $25,000 to these repairs. Yes. Christopher Reed. Yes.

0:54:19 Miss Talkington. Yes. Sean Baraker. Yes. Nicky Boyd. Yes. Greg Lainty. Yes.

0:54:25 Which passes 6 to 0. So Travis, perhaps this is a question for you. So the remaining

0:54:36 remaining funds from the municipal power's

0:54:39 outsourced program we'd share a few comments

0:54:43 meetings ago about eventually uses for those funds

0:54:46 of which this was two of those.

0:54:49 If those funds are not reallocated this year,

0:54:51 will they just roll serves again?

0:54:59 So like we thought so again is that reallocation

0:55:02 as opportunities come up that the council wants to fund

0:55:06 or participate or contribute of these funds council

0:55:17 other needs to be a specific allocation for them because their original purpose and what was intended to spear it into those otherwise they will next on the agenda is an action item this is a request to consider a resolution to join the multi-district litigation or MDL against opioid manufacturers and or distributors and we have Shane, our city council, as you may recall on May 28th, Daniel Mubi, a partner with the New Wayland attorneys out of Boise.

0:56:09 to attorneys out of Boise came and presented to the council,

0:56:12 related to the multi-district litigation in Ohio.

0:56:16 There were a few questions brought up there.

0:56:18 We did reach out to I-Cram.

0:56:19 I'm concerned with the city joining the litigation there.

0:56:23 We also reached out to the attorney general's office

0:56:25 related to the statewide planning

0:56:31 to file a stand speaking with their deputy attorney general.

0:56:41 Over that particular case, they did not have any concerns

0:56:45 or think that it would negatively impact them

0:56:47 or the City of Twin Falls, should the City of Twin Falls choose to join.

0:56:50 I did want to point out it was interesting in that particular complaint, there was one section

0:56:59 that referenced Twin Falls, Idaho, and that was related to the pharmaceutical companies.

0:57:05 In essence, giving a presentation to its sales reps to push these drugs on elderly individuals

0:57:12 and those who have not yet been prescribed opioids.

0:57:17 And so it referenced specifically one of those training sessions or classes going on in Twin Falls.

0:57:23 So we do believe there is, obviously, some problems with regard to opioid crisis specific to Twin Falls.

0:57:30 Judge the council by majority vote.

0:57:33 The resolution that will in essence allow the mayor or authorize the mayor to sign a retainer agreement with.

0:57:42 It should be noted that that particular agreement is contingency-based.

0:57:48 meaning there will be no fee or cost associated to the City of Twin Falls unless there is a recovery by the law firm on our best things.

0:58:14 Just to clarify Shane, if we may incur a cost by out-of-pocket staff time providing the information or whatever might be needed for them,

0:58:25 but the costs over and above that incur by the law are not responsible for.

0:58:32 That's correct. There are a list of duties in the template engagement agreement that they sent to us in that reference to a few areas where some of our staff may need to testimony or be deposed and also gathering information.

0:59:04 I have some kind of a super-pound.

0:59:09 I think attention to the note, and Shane, please correct me.

0:59:33 I apologize, I don't know if that statistics accurate.

0:59:35 I just remember that it was staggering related to even surrounding a county's look of the presentation.

0:59:56 I will say I'm certainly supportive of signing on to this opportunity to doing this simply because we might have some.

1:00:39 Back to the city, it's really to address the broader, passing this resolution.

1:00:55 It is 2019-008.

1:00:58 Seconded by Greg Lanting to adopt 008 is there for the discussion.

1:01:29 Christopher Reed? Yes.

1:01:37 Chris Tockington? Yes.

1:01:38 Sean Bericher? Yes.

1:01:40 Nicki Boyd? Yes.

1:01:41 Greg Lanting? Yes.

1:01:42 Chris Pierce? Yes.

1:01:43 That's the 6-0.

1:01:45 Q, shame for your work.

1:01:54 Next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input.

1:01:57 Again, if there's anyone from the public who wishes to address the council,

1:02:00 now is your opportunity to please come forward.

1:02:02 Please state your honor in the city of Twin Falls.

1:02:18 My voice is just coming back, so my name is Leah Babbai and I'm a resident of Twin Falls.

1:02:31 So I'm here to bring up a point if I could.

1:02:48 A couple of weeks ago the council passed the marriage in a proclamation in regards to it being

1:02:55 dairy month and that's been a really beautiful celebration and I think that after reading that

1:03:02 It was really sad to see that once again, people that are at the core of an industry

1:03:10 that we depend on and at the core of our economic survival here in Twin Falls not far away

1:03:18 at the southern border, but right here, that once again we've glossed over the human beings.

1:03:25 The herds are mentioned, the families are mentioned, it's beautiful, the products are

1:03:30 mentioned, the calories, the nutrition, but very politely again, we've missed being honest

1:03:37 and to represent the tens and thousands of undocumented workers that live here, that contribute

1:03:46 millions of dollars in state taxes right here, that help us thrive, they're the lifeline

1:03:54 of why all of us are able to do business, attract big businesses, build, improve our community.

1:04:01 Once again, we neglected to acknowledge their human value, didn't even mention them.

1:04:08 Like as if these cows are literally milking themselves, clean after themselves, and that's

1:04:16 really shameful.

1:04:17 I think that we could do better than that.

1:04:20 You can mention the people behind a huge industry that leads Idaho in the nation and

1:04:28 really represents in the world.

1:04:30 It's our responsibility as a community to do so, to residents.

1:04:35 There are members of our community, their children go to our schools.

1:04:40 And the reason why I bring this up is because it is in that very fine way that the conversation

1:04:48 continues to hinder and harm and become negative.

1:04:53 Right now, we hear echoes and echoes in our nation

1:04:56 of how criminal and dangerous and a burden undocumented

1:05:01 illegal immigrants are.

1:05:02 But here in Twin Falls, we want to be fancy.

1:05:05 We want to use the word foreign born,

1:05:07 because we don't want to be honest about the type of labor

1:05:11 force we have.

1:05:12 So I think we can step it up.

1:05:14 We can raise a standard.

1:05:15 if we're leading in the state in an industry,

1:05:19 and if in a community we know those are the people

1:05:22 that are contributing for us to succeed in a major way,

1:05:28 then we have a responsibility to use a moment

1:05:31 of a proclamation or any moment to be a teachable moment

1:05:36 because we're a learning community

1:05:38 and be a responsible community by being responsible

1:05:42 to all members of our community.

1:05:45 We can lead in our conversation if we're brave.

1:05:48 We can lead in the conversation of representing undocumented

1:05:53 immigrants in the positive light that we know they contribute

1:05:58 to our well-being.

1:06:00 But we have to be brave and we have to lead.

1:06:03 We can't just keep using political correct language

1:06:07 and issue proclamations and just gloss over the people,

1:06:11 the real human beings who are feeding

1:06:14 all these industries. That's what I have to say. Thank you for anyone else from the public

1:06:30 who wishes to address the council this evening. The advisory board reports from the council

1:06:37 a list here. I wanted to just take a moment to recognize a few items from the Association

1:06:52 of Idaho City's which held their conference last week. I'm going to mention and then we

1:06:58 will mention it again the next time that Suzanne is here but Suzanne Hawkins, our council

1:07:03 was ascended to the Association of Idaho City's President role.

1:07:07 So congratulations to her and I look forward to her leadership

1:07:12 at a statewide level working on issues.

1:07:15 Also to acknowledge a previous AIC president, Greg Lanting,

1:07:20 was recognized with the Harold Hurst Award for Outstanding

1:07:24 Contributions to Idaho City's Very prestigious award.

1:07:28 And I was pleased to see that Greg was recognized

1:07:32 for his work on the City Council and as a previous mayor,

1:07:36 but also just his commitment to community.

1:07:41 The city itself was also recognized

1:07:43 with two achievement awards,

1:07:45 one for community engagement for our C Click Fix app

1:07:51 recently, and also for the youth and the youth council

1:07:56 for their color run and wrap routine suicide prevention

1:08:00 and awareness that was recently held

1:08:02 and wildly successful.

1:08:03 So congratulations to all the folks

1:08:06 We're a part of those teams and launching these great services and this council and part of the city's team

1:08:17 Ravis did I get all the association about the city's items?

1:08:19 I see nothing else but council anything from the city manager's office Travis. There's not much more

1:08:29 No again. We would as staff we would like to also recognize

1:08:35 Greg and we'll certainly take the opportunity to have a conversation with Susanne which is here, but

1:08:40 as a member of the city's team and

1:08:43 and knowing and watching Greg, the members who appointed me to this role,

1:09:01 the city and the freight, voice, thought, and epistrates,

1:09:12 true learning is something that staff is that we always understood.

1:09:27 We're in facilitating positive meaningful relationships.

1:09:31 We appreciate the council, like all of you,

1:09:41 received that award of being very active before.

1:09:46 And then to just prepare you.

1:09:51 Beginning on July 8th, we are going to begin our conversations about the budget, and we

1:09:58 are going to be doing some things very similar to last year, but we also want to try some

1:10:03 new things to build on the success that we had from last year.

1:10:07 That first thing that we want to have a conversation during the process is we had shared that we

1:10:11 were going to be reporting out on the updates of the strategic plan and our overall efforts,

1:10:17 So we're going to take an opportunity, as we're discussing

1:10:20 the different focus areas, to also be sharing

1:10:23 and reporting out the successes that we had

1:10:26 by the department leaders in those focus areas.

1:10:29 And so we will have a key report by all members

1:10:33 of our team to kind of set the stage of the success

1:10:35 that we had, and then to build upon

1:10:37 for upcoming budgets, me speak.

1:10:43 And so, we'll also be members of the members

1:10:51 of the city's leadership teams.

1:10:53 will be all making presentations.

1:10:56 And again, also send out this first call,

1:11:00 as the council has allowed, for the public to engage

1:11:04 in that process and share their thoughts

1:11:07 in this upcoming budget process.

1:11:09 There's probably no more important action

1:11:12 that we take as an organization in the setting

1:11:14 of the budget, which is the delivery of services.

1:11:17 And so we invite the public in that process.

1:11:20 It will conclude last August numbers and as Lori race likes to share it is her happiest time.

1:11:35 Okay Travis, seeing no other items we will be up no public hearing sketch this evening.

1:11:44 So next is a request to adjourn to executive session under Idaho Code 742061B.

1:11:52 Consider the evaluation, dismissal or disciplining of where the hearing complaints were charged as brought.

1:11:58 to public officer employees, staff member or individual agent or public school,

1:12:03 student motion by Chris Tockington, seconded by Nikki Boyd to adjourn to executive session

1:12:11 as stated as their new discussion.

1:12:13 On Chris Tockington.

1:12:23 Yes.

1:12:24 Berger.

1:12:24 Yes.

1:12:25 Nikki Boyd.

1:12:25 Yes.

1:12:26 Right, Lantey.

1:12:26 Yes.

1:12:27 Ruth Pierce.

1:12:28 Yes.

1:12:28 In Christopher Reed.

1:12:29 Yes.

1:12:30 Which passes 6 to 0?

1:12:33 Just to let everyone know, we will not be reconvening following the executive session,

1:12:37 or will we be making the decisions during the executive session, but that the meeting is adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, June 24, 2019. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:12:50.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    945b7a35e8d35739a3d34303af9ef0cf17c1ab68d50ab4d4d2dac2c38fe8335d
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a d17baf466bd23a2150da7d1d515b7aee1cb69be82f8d186c1ed77815f4a9fc77
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    f2496e78b3e7bd94a81ea596b6b3930803c241d4146d3144b998ae985454dbb8

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file