City Council meeting
Monday, July 1, 2019
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: b
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:00:05 Good evening. I would like to call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting from Monday, July 1st and confirm that we do have a quorum of the council here.
0:00:13 Six of the seven members are present this evening. Councilman Tuckington is excused tonight.
0:00:19 Next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. For those of you wishing to join us, please rise.
0:00:23 Next on the agenda are Proclamation. We have none this evening.
0:00:50 So next would be an opportunity for general public input.
0:00:53 There's anyone here from the public who wishes to rest the council on an item that is not on the agenda this evening now
0:00:59 Is your chance to please come forward?
0:01:01 Seeing no one we will move on to the consent calendar
0:01:10 wishes
0:01:37 Second motion by Suzanne how I can second by repairs to approve the consent calendar minus
0:01:43 Council minutes is there any discussion
0:02:01 Yes, motion passes six to zero.
0:02:05 Ritzbuhrs.
0:02:07 I move we approve the minutes, item five a.
0:02:14 Motion by Ritzbuhrs, seconded by Nicki Boyd
0:02:16 to approve the minutes of the June 24th council meeting
0:02:20 is there for their discussion.
0:02:23 I'll call vote please.
0:02:28 Stay, stay, stay, Ritzbuhrs, Mr. Fareed.
0:02:32 Yes, yes, motion passes five to zero with one abstention.
0:02:38 So if you were here for special event applications
0:02:41 for the Particular event on August 11th,
0:02:45 the hearts in the park on July 25th to the 27th,
0:02:49 Rotary Club's 9th annual ice cream,
0:02:51 fun day on Saturday, July 27th,
0:02:55 or for the Parks and Recreation Commission items
0:03:00 for donations and plaques for Zimmerman or Crow,
0:03:05 or for the Parks and Luke contribution
0:03:07 for Cedar Park subdivision number 12.
0:03:09 Those were all just approved on the consent camp.
0:03:18 Next on the agenda, under items of consideration,
0:03:20 the first is an action item.
0:03:22 This is a request to approve the Idaho Transportation Department,
0:03:25 Idaho Child Passenger Safety Grant Program grant application
0:03:30 at Mandy Thompson, our grant and community relations manager.
0:03:38 Good evening, Waring Council.
0:03:40 Just a brief request tonight, but I'll start with some background.
0:03:46 This particular program has been funded in the City of Twin Falls
0:03:50 for over 15 years, but back in 2014, the City of Twin Falls
0:03:54 was asked to take over financial management of the grant
0:03:56 because the previous year was when
0:04:00 safe kids fell under the umbrella of the St. Luke's
0:04:03 healthcare system, and one of the requirements of any grant
0:04:07 that is awarded to St. Luke's is an administrative fee,
0:04:10 and the Idaho Transportation Department's Child
0:04:14 Passenger Sea Grant Program wouldn't,
0:04:17 We're unwilling to grant the funds to stay loose and lose some of those funding to the administrative costs.
0:04:24 So the state came to the city and asked us to take over the grant, which we did.
0:04:30 The grant provides two things when they provide car seats.
0:04:35 These are located in check sites throughout the eight county area of our transportation district.
0:04:41 And including here at the police department.
0:04:46 And those car seats are given away either free of charge or for small donation to anyone who is in need of a child safety restraint for their children.
0:04:58 They are also used in situations where a family is in a car accident.
0:05:02 And as you know, once other car seat is in a car accident, they're suggested that they are destroyed.
0:05:08 And so we have instances where police officers will actually go
0:05:11 into the storage where we have our car seats
0:05:14 and get a car seat for a family if they've
0:05:16 been in a car accident.
0:05:17 And so it's just a great program that we were able to carry
0:05:20 forward.
0:05:23 A couple of years ago, Jennifer Westendorf,
0:05:25 who used to actually be an employee of the city,
0:05:28 took over the executive director position at Safe Kids.
0:05:31 And she's become an fantastic partner in this program.
0:05:35 And essentially what she did was she took over all
0:05:37 of the programmatic responsibilities of this grant
0:05:40 and the city's really has just become sort of a pass through.
0:05:43 So essentially Jennifer does all of the grant applications.
0:05:47 She ranges for all of the car seats to be purchased.
0:05:50 She purchases them.
0:05:51 Essentially I just pay invoices and then submit the reimbursement
0:05:55 request to the state and then we get the money back.
0:05:57 So cash in and cash out.
0:06:00 And so this particular grant application
0:06:02 is for some training for Jennifer, Reston-Dorf,
0:06:04 and another woman in her office.
0:06:06 And then also for Barb Handy, who works in the police department,
0:06:08 she's our certified car seat technician for the city.
0:06:14 And it will be some training that they will attend,
0:06:17 as well as some additional training here locally
0:06:20 to certify additional individuals to be car seat technicians
0:06:23 so that they can actually help families correctly install,
0:06:28 either the car seats they get through the program
0:06:30 or correctly install car seats that maybe they purchase
0:06:33 somewhere else and they just want to make sure
0:06:34 that they've installed them correctly in their cars.
0:06:37 So that's what this grant request is for
0:06:40 in the amount of $10,740 and 22 cents.
0:06:43 Are there any questions?
0:06:45 Any questions from Andy, Greg Lanting.
0:06:51 I don't see any question based department
0:06:56 either who chowled passenger safety grant,
0:06:59 program application, or it is requesting $10,740 and 22 cents.
0:07:08 Motion by Greg Lanting, second by Chris Reed
0:07:10 to approve the request for the idone transportation
0:07:13 Department of Health Passenger Safety Grant Program Grant Application.
0:07:17 Further discussion?
0:07:19 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:07:24 Yes.
0:07:25 Frank Lanting.
0:07:26 Yes.
0:07:27 Ruth Pierce.
0:07:28 Yes.
0:07:29 Christopher Reed.
0:07:30 Yes.
0:07:31 John Pericard.
0:07:32 Yes.
0:07:35 That's a 60-0.
0:07:36 Next on the agenda is an action item.
0:07:37 This is a request to award the Eastland Falls intersection project to PMF, Incorporated of Twin Falls, Idaho, and the amount of $950,211.
0:07:48 to our staff engineer, expert counsel.
0:07:55 So the Eastland Falls Intersection Project
0:07:58 is slated to fully remove and reconstruct
0:08:02 the intersection of Falls Avenue East
0:08:05 and Eastland Drive North to about 200 feet
0:08:09 each side of the intersection.
0:08:11 So North, South, East, and West
0:08:13 and replace it with a concrete section.
0:08:16 The concrete section is intended because, in part,
0:08:20 a lot of trucks drive that route and so the concrete will help with running and last
0:08:25 little longer than the plan we've been so also 40 year design life is opposed to 20
0:08:28 year design life. The project was formally bid last Tuesday but the second
0:08:39 time in a row we only had one bidder. The bidder was PMF located out of Twin
0:08:43 Falls and their bid was $950,211 about 27% over the engineers estimate
0:08:52 Package check, there were no irregularities, it was complete.
0:09:01 And I'm sure there's some concerns of being 27% of the engineer's estimate.
0:09:06 We went back to engineer civil science who put together the engineer's estimate,
0:09:12 also produced maybe an explanation of why perhaps it was higher than their estimate.
0:09:20 When the engineer puts together an estimate for a project,
0:09:24 for the most part they're dealing with, past projects.
0:09:27 And so Civil Science has access to an ITD database that shows unit costs on similar projects, both locally and throughout the state.
0:09:38 And as you can imagine, with each project in each bidder, there's going to be a wide range that you're going to see on a specific bid item.
0:09:45 So I would say more than likely we were kind of down the middle, and for a lot of the bid items, it looks like the contractor was still within, I would say that range, but on the high end.
0:09:56 and on multiple prices, which ended up being when all was sent in $200,000 over when we estimated it would cost.
0:10:06 Nonetheless, I think there are a lot of contractors that are available right now.
0:10:11 I think those that we have are very busy.
0:10:13 That's why, like I say, for the second consecutive project, we've only had one bidder,
0:10:17 and a Troy P-Tect had a Kingspring Road project recently where we had zero bidders.
0:10:22 And so with that being said, it doesn't seem that far out of line to be a good bid in today's market.
0:10:29 One other thing I wanted to let you aware of is on this specific project, there's a big concern for traffic control
0:10:39 and that in order to actually phase the project, I can get the concrete in there and dealing with curing time of the concrete,
0:10:46 it looks like there'll be approximately a two-month detour for traffic coming into town on Falls Avenue.
0:10:56 In other words, traffic that's trying to come in a town on Falls would have to detour usually,
0:11:01 would try and get on Hinkins Road, have them hang a left and hit Flyler Avenue to get into the town,
0:11:08 so it would be no at all westbound traffic through the intersection for a phase.
0:11:12 That's how the engineer has designed the project, the contract to come back.
0:11:17 And if he thinks he can go ahead and still get traffic to go both directions, that's okay.
0:11:22 That's up to him.
0:11:23 But based upon the design, based upon the geometry that just wasn't up for him.
0:11:27 So I wanted you to be aware of that being a concern that we had initially that you're aware of.
0:11:31 So with that, I would recommend that the city or the bid to PMF came out of $950,000.
0:11:41 to a lot of dollars and I can answer any questions that you may have.
0:11:44 Thank you, boy.
0:11:45 A question.
0:11:49 This intersection butts up to the fabulous work that was done traveling north on eastland
0:11:55 that were months but for specific reasons that people understood.
0:12:04 Why wasn't this intersection done at the same time?
0:12:10 I think we're going to just got this kind of all squared away
0:12:17 and everything's working really good.
0:12:18 Traffic's moving nicely and now we're going to tear up that intersection
0:12:23 And there's a lot of falls traveling west every day and getting to sk- I mean when does this start?
0:12:34 So I'm not exactly sure when it would start. That would be up to the contractor.
0:12:40 And it needs to be completed. I want to say it's late October, early November.
0:12:45 So it's going to be completed by...
0:12:46 Back to school is going to be a blast.
0:12:48 Back to school will not be fun.
0:12:50 The intersection is already failing out of the Street Department's worried about lasting
0:12:55 through the winter because it's in such poor condition.
0:12:58 Part of the reason that we separated this portion away from the Eastland project was
0:13:06 because it's a totally different type of construction.
0:13:09 That was mainly a CTV project specialty where we had specially subcontractors coming in with
0:13:15 cement trucks mixing up that cement with the aggregate, and then paving it with
0:13:20 Plimax pavement using a regular paver. And this project is different, whereas we'll build the base
0:13:28 section of the aggregate, but on top of that will be concrete poured in place as opposed to
0:13:33 the plate of the Plimax paving machine. And so it's a different type of construction. The other, I guess,
0:13:38 reason I would say, and John Keaton is with me, if he wants to come and chime in, that's fine,
0:13:42 is I don't think we would have had enough time to consecutively construct
0:13:47 Eastline and then move into the intersection without getting into the
0:13:51 winter months at which point in time it's not fun to construct and have the
0:13:55 concrete cure with blankets and the cold weather and such. So that was I think
0:14:00 part why we we broke it up John you want to mention or add anything to that.
0:14:04 Good question and a lot of people Josh pretty much hit all points yelling at
0:14:11 add to is again another reason that we're using different construction types
0:14:15 here is that in an intersection with the heavy, extremely heavy loads that it
0:14:21 sees you know when you come to a stop shove pavement and so you probably know
0:14:26 what I'm talking about in certain intersections right stop sign you see
0:14:28 that asphalt plant mix come up and that's what happens is it shoves and so that
0:14:35 design of a plant mix that we used on East Limbless specific to its use and its
0:14:44 loading and also specific to what materials there existing and falls has
0:14:49 different materials would have been a different recipe with a different design
0:14:52 for different purposes so we fully intended on constructing the intersection
0:14:57 in concrete you know stringing these projects out longer isn't this isn't
0:15:04 better you gotta pick a phase line at some point and sequence it and this is a
0:15:10 40 year and the 40 year that also
0:15:18 when a year design life it shows the bid schedule
0:15:32 correct relation this was made from civil science if I get this from Jake please let me know but I believe what happened is
0:15:47 PMF did the math correctly and they just forgot to add in that that two hundred
0:15:52 sixteen dollars to their actual bid so their their bid shows it being nine hundred
0:15:58 $149,995, but when you do the math correctly and you add in the
0:16:04 $216 for three mil of sidewalk
0:16:06 Like you should have done it comes out to
0:16:08 950 2011 and we wanted to show that discrepancy from the actual bid versus what it should have been
0:16:14 I mean I would say you know seems like you should be intersection
0:16:53 Here I don't I don't think it's a lack of having companies. I really think it's a lack of
0:17:03 of having their schedules being free enough to put more work on their schedule.
0:17:09 I think they're just that busy.
0:17:21 Just say a name to the record, Jake, South Hook, Civil Science.
0:17:24 We contacted several contractors from western to night forever to club for IMC
0:17:30 and several of them did just what Josh said is we don't have the time or, you know,
0:17:36 club for even said it's not quite in our scope.
0:17:40 to do the small concrete, PMF was one we contacted as well as a REG, REG said, well we'll bright
0:17:48 team up with PMF, but with all of them we contacted, PMF was the only one that even collected
0:17:54 a bit said, reached out to all of them and hopes to process last year how do we get on
0:18:19 their schedules so that we're not dealing with a think of as we can postpone projects,
0:18:27 we can design them and then bid them at the best optimal time and hope that we even can
0:18:33 can get work on bidders, but with that being said, that means in part that we could be
0:18:39 post-poning projects. In this case, six, seven months before we actually let the bid, specifically
0:18:51 with this project, but I think we're trying to do is we had East and last year, big project
0:18:54 in the area. We're trying to get this one done this year, and then recognize that next
0:18:59 year we have scheduled locust falls to North College as a full construction rebuild, and
0:19:06 So we're trying to not have two major projects at the same time they're long-lasting projects.
0:19:13 So, 27% increases.
0:19:19 One of the things I'd add is that it's really hard to get on their schedule without a contract.
0:19:29 So Josh answered it correctly. We'd have to have it designed, bid, and awarded to schedule.
0:19:35 So even a heads-up courtesy, we do that.
0:19:38 They know the kinds of projects we're looking at and considering, they know what zone we're going to be in, have a general con.
0:19:49 So that's one of the challenges.
0:19:51 The other thing I guess I'd point out is really a function
0:19:53 of the market and demand on years.
0:19:57 We get screaming deals, we get lots of hitters,
0:19:59 and then other years, and we have this scenario.
0:20:11 So I guess another question I would have is,
0:20:15 are we going to encounter this some more?
0:20:18 Do we have other glory projects that we're
0:20:20 going to be at the mercy of the contractors
0:20:24 by getting no bids or one bid in 25 plus percent
0:20:30 So as far as big projects this year, I'm unaware of any more, um, Troy is currently working
0:20:39 with the contractor to begin negotiations with the K and Springs Great Road job.
0:20:45 So that's already underway, and it's hard to know what that bid's going to look like.
0:20:50 There's not any shares in S and it's already in place, but we'll see the negotiation leaders.
0:20:54 I'm unaware of any this year.
0:20:56 There may be similar situations like hers next year with Locust and others, but I don't
0:21:01 I don't know if you have any knowledge of other projects, John.
0:21:04 Travis, Aaron Council, I think that you raise a really good point.
0:21:14 We've really tried to go from a budget process that we're going to design and construct in the same year.
0:21:20 And maybe we have to evaluate our process to determine whether or not that remains to be effective.
0:21:25 And we have to be designed in one unit, Josh is right, that changes maybe what that dynamic looks like.
0:21:37 But it may be worth it when you start saving 27%, 25% on the projects, and you're getting
0:21:44 more of a competitive.
0:21:46 We historically know that meeting in the summertime is the worst time to bid because this is when
0:21:51 individuals' plates are full, and so I think it's important for us as a team to look at
0:21:59 our process and to review our process because, organizationally, we can't continue to afford
0:22:05 significant cost overruns on projects because the totality of the projects is significant
0:22:11 So, we as a staff will take a look at that.
0:22:14 It's an acceptable answer to say, well, this is the environment and this is the direction
0:22:18 we'll go.
0:22:22 We'll spend some time on some process.
0:22:23 Any question I would have would be whether or not we have sufficient reserves and streets
0:22:32 to cover this overrun.
0:22:34 And then my other concern is we bid eight, ten months ahead.
0:22:38 We're still going to people, not with a very sharp pencil.
0:22:41 I'm concerned because they're not going to know what their materials cost, maybe.
0:22:45 So I think you run into the same issue there. Maybe not as bad as her, but even against people. So we do have enough funds and
0:22:55 Shout out to all the attractors, but just a clarification point
0:23:07 Maybe this is Shane because of the bit being so much higher than estimated
0:23:12 We do have the option to reject bids
0:23:14 And if we do do we have the option then to do what we did with Troy's project and negotiate directly with one company
0:23:22 And see if we can get a better deal
0:23:26 and reject all of this, and I believe the language is,
0:23:30 there's a finding by the council that it will be
0:23:33 better to go out on the open market.
0:23:43 It's on this deal, but I just wanted to make sure
0:23:45 for my own clarification that that is an option.
0:23:48 That's correct, thank you.
0:23:53 Sounds to me like it's a competitive market.
0:23:55 I don't know if you've looked around
0:23:56 a little bit later in the state,
0:23:58 there's a lot of stuff getting built,
0:23:59 so that certainly makes it challenging
0:24:01 when you're trying to compete for the same number
0:24:03 of folks who are trying to build stuff.
0:24:05 A general comment I would make too about the traffic flow,
0:24:08 So, as someone who will not be able to go through that intersection for a couple of months since that's my way to work,
0:24:14 I will say that the network of roads around that area now with Hankins widened.
0:24:19 If the stoplight at Filer, the stoplight at Addison and Hankins, there are other alternatives that are...
0:24:28 I can't imagine or are going to add much commute time to folks, so it just takes the remembering to go to the right street when you're trying to do that.
0:24:38 Certainly dealt with it in that neighborhood when we're doing easily construction in the past and I think everyone will be able to address that as they go forward and it sounds like the contractor is going to do their best to keep traffic flow going in all directions as much as possible but sometimes that just will be possible.
0:24:55 I'll go ahead and also note that the 2019 Millenly project, I'm a project manager on it as well.
0:25:01 And so it's going to destroy Madison. I'll make sure those projects are coordinated so we're not having major issues with East West coming into town during the two projects.
0:25:12 So FYI. Thank you.
0:25:16 Mayor, I'm ready to move for us to award the Eastland Falls intersection project to PMF in corporate period
0:25:24 to involve Idaho in the amount of $950,211.
0:25:29 Okay, comment before the vote.
0:25:33 We're going to end up letting you get a second for me.
0:25:35 Second.
0:25:38 If you have a motion from Greg Glanting, seconded by Reid Pierce to award it as presented, Mr. Kayton.
0:25:44 You've all been through this several times, so you don't need the reminder, but I'll go ahead and do it anyway.
0:25:49 It's obviously in your authority to reject bids and we can wait until next year and roll
0:25:56 the dice and see if we get better prices and more bidders.
0:26:01 One of the concerns I would have is being responsible for maintenance.
0:26:05 That road intersection is failing pretty fast.
0:26:08 Do I think we can make it through the winter without significant maintenance?
0:26:13 No.
0:26:15 Do we know how to do significant maintenance?
0:26:17 Yes.
0:26:18 it just means we're in the intersection and we're getting some maintenance. So, if someone feels strongly about that, I understand.
0:26:25 Thank you, John. We do have a motion by Greg Lanning, seconded by Ruth Pierce to award the bid as presented to PMF in the amount of $950,211 is there for their discussion.
0:26:40 Amy, roll call vote please.
0:26:44 Greg Lanning?
0:26:48 Yes.
0:26:49 Yes.
0:26:51 Yes.
0:26:52 Mr. Fareed.
0:26:53 Yes.
0:26:54 Don Verger.
0:26:55 Yes.
0:26:56 Nikki Boyd.
0:26:57 Yes.
0:27:00 And Suzanne Hawkins.
0:27:01 No.
0:27:02 Passes 5-2.
0:27:06 We'll give you all for your presentation.
0:27:08 And next on the agenda we have an action item.
0:27:10 This is a request for Council direction regarding scope of response to Council's request to explore options for addressing individuals teaching private lessons at the Twin Falls City Pool.
0:27:21 We have Wendy Davis, our Parks and Recreation Director, as well as Shane Nope, our city attorney.
0:27:26 Thank you Mayor and Council.
0:27:32 I thought I would start out with this back in May.
0:27:35 We were asked by the Council to kind of explore options related to some of the,
0:27:41 actually the fact that individual who are teaching private swim lessons at the city.
0:27:45 Through that process, I went through and explored the issue.
0:27:50 There's kind of two questions that we're looking for, additional scope.
0:27:54 And Wendy's here, I believe John's here to answer questions with related to complaints or other things.
0:28:00 And I believe there are a few instructors actually in the audience here tonight as well.
0:28:04 One, I guess the first question as I was going through,
0:28:08 there's different cities have these blanket code sections that say no goods or services will be offered in parks.
0:28:15 parks, and they've lumped that with their pool as well as their parks generally.
0:28:21 And so we do have scenarios where individuals are offering private lessons, and I guess businesses
0:28:30 offering services using park facilities to perform those services.
0:28:37 And so the question arose, does the council want us to continue just looking specifically
0:28:42 to the swimming pool issue, or would you like us to come back with work product related
0:28:47 to parks and facilities generally speaking?
0:28:53 In part with that question is, I do want to remind the council that this isn't a final,
0:28:58 this is what the city is going to do because we'll have to have certain hearings forward,
0:29:02 but the direction in terms of there's a spectrum of what can be done.
0:29:08 Right now, we don't have anything in place that regulates whatsoever individuals encode individuals
0:29:18 from offering private lessons.
0:29:21 With that said, there's permitting, there's renting space.
0:29:26 For instance, we do rent our pavilions in some of our parks.
0:29:29 There are other agencies that will rent space at their swimming pools.
0:29:33 So you have this area so that it's not the overcrowding tennis courts.
0:29:38 you can use this cord during these times, during these hours.
0:29:42 So that's the second question after Wendy's presentation
0:29:46 of some of the concerns and things that come forward.
0:29:49 What does the council want going forward in terms of the scope
0:29:52 of that policy and regulation?
0:29:56 Because we will have to make some changes to our code,
0:29:58 as well as maybe a resolution related to moving forward.
0:30:02 Any questions for me?
0:30:09 I'm going to talk for Wendy.
0:30:23 Good evening, we're kind of choreographing on the fly here.
0:30:26 So I think what kinds of things that are occurring
0:30:33 is we have instructors teaching the swimming lessons
0:30:36 at the city pool during open swim times.
0:30:40 We have people teaching dargovidians classes in the park.
0:30:45 We have people teaching tennis lessons in our facilities.
0:30:50 It's a fairly broad scope of services that are being offered.
0:30:54 And, you know, it's, my experience has been that most of the cities that I've dealt with
0:31:04 and a lot of the conversations that were going on in Idaho Recreation and Parks Association,
0:31:10 and then as far as the state and national level is that there's a sense that you don't use
0:31:15 public facilities for private gain without having a permit or some sort of profit sharing
0:31:21 kind of thing in place.
0:31:23 We don't have anything like that right now and I think that, you know, I guess I'm inclined
0:31:31 to see what kinds of questions or thoughts you have if I can help add to the discussion
0:31:37 other than the fact that right now we kind of allow any and all of it to occur and there's
0:31:45 really not a mechanism for us to stop it which is I think where it started back in
0:31:51 in February, why are we allowing this?
0:31:53 How can we stop this?
0:31:55 We can't stop it right now, because it's the sense
0:31:59 that it's an interpretation of the use of public facilities.
0:32:03 And it's an interpretation that was in place
0:32:07 of kind of a philosophy that has changed over the years,
0:32:10 but currently this sense is that
0:32:12 as public facility people can use it as they wish.
0:32:15 And because of that, that's what's going on.
0:32:19 and we really don't have a mechanism to regulate,
0:32:22 stop, or do anything with what's going on.
0:32:25 So I guess I'm inclined to stop talking right now
0:32:31 and come back if you have more questions
0:32:34 or want some more clarification.
0:32:36 And just as Shane pointed out, we did invite some
0:32:39 of the instructors from the city pool
0:32:41 that are conducting lessons.
0:32:43 They are in the audience mostly to witness the conversation,
0:32:46 but if you have questions for them,
0:32:48 I think they might be willing to come up and answer questions as well.
0:32:54 Great, thank you.
0:32:55 So Wendy, don't you do far away?
0:32:58 First guys always have.
0:33:00 I'm assuming that they do both of the students are instructing
0:33:05 and themselves have to pay to be in the pool during that time.
0:33:09 They're not getting free entrance.
0:33:12 No, correct.
0:33:13 They come during open swim time,
0:33:16 and that's when it's open to general public,
0:33:19 to do pay the admission fee to enter the facility or their classes.
0:33:23 Okay, and then right.
0:33:24 Instructors and the participants, yes.
0:33:26 I'd like to add one more to that.
0:33:28 One of our city assets, of course, has sometimes the same issue.
0:33:32 I haven't seen it for a few years.
0:33:34 See, he probably has a policy that prevents it, correct?
0:33:37 It's possible since he's leasing it.
0:33:39 Unless you have the added thing, they at least have to apply the balls from him.
0:33:43 You can't just see your own balls down there and open them up.
0:33:46 So that is a little different there.
0:33:48 In the past it's always been kind of a gentleman saying if people could give lessons to their friends, but they couldn't charge for it.
0:33:58 And then the pros usually did not have a concern with that.
0:34:01 Because usually that has meant that they would want a better lesson and they'd go to a pro to get it.
0:34:06 So I think that's probably the reasoning.
0:34:08 But I think there, I don't know if anyone who's been charging to use the facility who's not already an employee of Steeves.
0:34:15 And I think that that's really where the difference becomes, is that it's not just somebody offering a lesson to a friend, it's a business model that's being run through there.
0:34:29 Thank you.
0:34:30 Chris Reed.
0:34:31 So I was just listing a whole bunch of different city owned facilities.
0:34:38 Are we talking soccer fields as well?
0:34:42 fields as well, so if Appits is going to go out there and Appits with them as well, the pool is a little bit easier because it's in a closed area, you're going to know when somebody's in, the enforcement's going to be very difficult unless we're going to have somebody sitting at every park.
0:35:06 Enforcement is one of the issues, especially how in the facilities, how in the parks and things for sure.
0:35:18 Because our trails are the same thing, you know?
0:35:20 Because you do have people, if there's a...
0:35:23 Or if the person that wants to rent spooters on the trail instead of the scooter rental right on the trail.
0:35:33 Or using our trail. Is that how it comes?
0:35:42 So I think a way and sense that the problem was originally brought to me by one of our citizens.
0:35:48 So I know that to go back to the pool, we employ people to teach sworn lessons.
0:35:56 And they can't make as much money as somebody teaching a private lesson in the pool.
0:36:03 And so there's a real discrepancy there.
0:36:06 There's a cost to our facility that, as any business owner, you have a cost to do business.
0:36:13 And when our facilities are being used, they're almost getting free rent on facilities to run
0:36:21 their business.
0:36:22 The tennis courts, for example, we just spent a lot of money paying to repave tennis courts
0:36:29 and to get the lines painted and new dance.
0:36:32 And they have no vested interest besides they're a citizen like us paying the same amount of
0:36:36 money, but yet they're benefiting off it. So I feel like that there's a real fairness issue here
0:36:43 and that if we're going to allow people to use public property for profit, that they need to
0:36:52 step up to the plaintiff's share so that the general taxpayer isn't subsidizing their business
0:36:57 for them, basically. So personally, I'm in favor of blanketing all city property and not for friends,
0:37:05 teaching friends or the general thing or the soccer club going out there and doing
0:37:09 their stuff that's nonprofit but if it's a business that's profiting we need to have
0:37:15 a way to enforce it whether we catch them or not but we need something at least
0:37:19 that we can go back to and say hey this is not allowed or you need a permit or
0:37:24 you need to pay your fair share of the upkeep of this park if you're going to
0:37:28 be utilizing it in that fashion. That's my two cents worth.
0:37:33 Thank you, Ruth Pierce.
0:37:38 Excuse me, I would agree with Suzanne on this. If someone teaching uses a private pool or
0:37:46 a private facility somewhere else, they would pay some sort of fee. And so if they're making
0:37:52 a profit, it seems to me that because of the wear and tear that they should be paying some
0:37:59 fee, I lean towards a fee, facility fee as opposed to profit sharing, profit sharing tends to
0:38:08 be a little convoluted, you're relying on reports from the user as opposed to just having a
0:38:17 link fee, so I would agree that we need to look at everything and I would lean towards
0:38:23 the permitting process.
0:38:30 questions. Sure, please come down and if you'd please state your name for the record.
0:38:38 My name is Jennifer Clough. Just what I'm listening to you talk back and forth for the fees.
0:38:45 My question is, as you teach lessons there, most of them that I teach I do,
0:38:52 we pay to get in and the student pays to get in. Most of them buy summer passes to do this.
0:38:58 Does that mean if you're going to go to this where we need to pay a rental fee?
0:39:02 They don't have to pay to get into the pool during that public swim time because we are
0:39:07 in a way paying to use of facilities versus a tennis court who's not paying anything.
0:39:12 We are paying and the fee is $3.00.
0:39:15 It depends on the age and the past that you have.
0:39:26 So they're paying to get in and some of our parents opted to do a summer pass, some opted to do a daily fee
0:39:34 And then we also, as teachers, are paying that fee,
0:39:37 which should help cover some of the maintenance I would think
0:39:41 of running the pool, but that just so that's in there,
0:39:43 that's kind of a question we had as if they want
0:39:46 to charge us a rental fee, which I understand,
0:39:50 will that negate the fee that our people are,
0:39:52 and that we're paying to get into use of the facility?
0:39:55 My personal opinion was you, as the business owner,
0:40:03 would pay a fee to have the right to teach lessons there,
0:40:06 Yes, all other fees would still apply and I guess I look at you as a direct competition with the city since we offer that service too
0:40:13 So to me that it's again a fairness issue
0:40:17 But we're still early in discussion. That's just my personal
0:40:22 That was my other question and then of course we would look at
0:40:25 If we if we were to take all of our swimmers that were not doing private lessons anymore and say that they
0:40:31 they did decide to go with the city for which they may not with asking them that. Could the city handle that many swimmers with their program be overrun?
0:40:42 Because in the long term, I mean, I just want kids in the hottest way. And if we're running to where, from what I've heard and I don't have any citizens on it yet, we would have to do some research.
0:40:52 the swimming lesson program is getting to is being filled there's some classes that they're
0:40:57 not being able to put kids in. If we stopped all of those, would the city be able to do that
0:41:02 or is it really that we're really taking that much money out from the program would they
0:41:07 be able to handle that many swimmers? Because you're talking from some of our swim team,
0:41:11 from some of our teachers that are here, maybe a hundred kids that they've already taught this
0:41:16 year, could that if we didn't teach that, could the city handle that or would there be
0:41:20 be nothing available for those kids to use.
0:41:23 That's another concern.
0:41:25 Thank you.
0:41:26 Thank you.
0:41:27 So I think those are valid questions.
0:41:29 Again, I don't know that we're down to the crafting policy part of things tonight.
0:41:34 But I think those are legitimate concerns of how if there is indeed a hundred students
0:41:42 that are taking private lessons, perhaps that's an operational issue we need to be looking
0:41:46 Is there value to us adding sessions and teachers and those types of things to accommodate that need?
0:41:52 I think the question of whether there's a fee for use of the facility and then there's a fee for the individuals using that facility.
0:42:03 Again, those details are still to be worked out. I think we're having philosophical discussion here about whether we invest the pool, all facilities and what that looks like.
0:42:15 I'm big on regulating everything, but I do see old does seem to be a little bit different
0:42:27 than some of the others philosophically, maybe not, maybe, but in process and renting space.
0:42:39 If we're just looking at it from the business point of view, anybody in business has to
0:42:44 have a place of operation and if you're going to be using the pool, that is a reasonable.
0:42:57 I know that space is for everybody, but again, it comes down to if you're running a business
0:43:03 that puts it in a whole different category.
0:43:08 I agree with Ruth, the profit-sharing thing doesn't appeal at all, and before you talked
0:43:16 about, could the city handle it, well, we would just hire, those would be, my guess.
0:43:27 We're signing up and we can handle all that we would have to decide to expand our own programs.
0:43:33 Just because it does, she made some good points, sorry I missed your name.
0:43:48 I'm not thinking if there is a fee and it's on top of the other.
0:43:53 It's a minimal fee or we require all the private lessons to get a season pass.
0:44:00 So we kind of know we're there. There's lots of different options.
0:44:03 I'm seeing, I don't think we're proud enough.
0:44:06 I mean, on, right, somebody out of business, because you are a different situation where you're actually paying to be in the pool than the test scores, but the test scores are free.
0:44:15 So, you know, it could be worked out in this, as Powell, Paul, he has been driven here that that fee is minimal, just recognizing that you are utilizing this city's facility.
0:44:30 And so that's, that's my thought.
0:44:33 Yes, please. If anybody else wants to give a comment, let's get the public comments out of the way so that then we can have the conversation amongst the council, so can you please state your name for the record?
0:44:50 When I got this letter from the city, I took a quick survey to 49 of my families.
0:45:02 I received answers from 30 as of last night, two more today, so they're not included in
0:45:08 my info.
0:45:09 But I asked things such as, how many of you have a pool pass?
0:45:13 Eighteen of those families have pool passes, eight, do the punch card, four, pay daily.
0:45:20 Other than swim lessons, how often they come and use the facility, they usually come before and after swim lessons and play.
0:45:29 And then in the summer, maybe once a week, twice a week, I asked if you bought these, the patch cards specifically to do lessons.
0:45:42 And all the two of the families are doing it specifically just because of the lessons.
0:45:48 Otherwise they wouldn't even come and those two families that answered they they didn't by specifically for lessons that they have there
0:45:58 They already had their past because their kids are on the Marlin Swift team
0:46:03 One of the things that came up in the letter was
0:46:08 You know how to
0:46:10 Your parents realize you don't work for the city and a hundred percent of my families have indicated that I have never
0:46:18 Said I work for the city
0:46:20 the other thing was
0:46:23 Have I made it clear to them that they must either pay the daily admission or the punch pass or have a membership to be there?
0:46:31 And again a hundred percent of them said yes, we you've always made that very very clear
0:46:36 They're they understand that we can only come during open swim
0:46:41 I am not opposed to figuring out some kind of a solution so we can continue this
0:46:48 My parents are very concerned that if only me wherever I go they
0:46:59 Again, a hundred percent of them have said they will not take lessons from the city they have in the past.
0:47:05 And it's, there's nothing against the city. I offer a smaller ratio for max at a time.
0:47:14 That's only if they can actually pass a swim test. And it's kind of a pre-team thing.
0:47:18 I had this school year, I had four different classes that were pre-team.
0:47:23 They could be on a swim team, but they don't want that kind of a commitment.
0:47:27 do want to learn the four competitive strokes and flip turns and stuff like that. So what
0:47:34 they want from me is my experience and I mean I've taught for twice as long as these other
0:47:43 teachers they have been alive and it's nothing against these teachers but they're just paying
0:47:49 for that experience. They've tried the group lessons or even private lessons. Some of my
0:47:54 kids have had private lessons through the pool and they just weren't learning at the rate
0:48:01 they wanted to and as a parent myself my kids are no longer in that position but
0:48:05 when I lived in Boise we lived right by the downtown Y. We drove clear 30 minutes to
0:48:11 the West Y because I found a program that worked with my son for swimming and he
0:48:18 would even swim better for me after his lesson and his teachers were like we don't
0:48:21 understand why you're coming or why you're paying somebody else a teacher and I
0:48:25 said because he needs to learn to listen to somebody else and stuff like that I
0:48:29 I don't think you should teach your own kids.
0:48:31 My kids, it works.
0:48:33 Most people say it doesn't.
0:48:35 And also, I don't advertise at all.
0:48:39 This all started off as lessons with friends,
0:48:42 and it has morphed into friends of friends.
0:48:45 And frankly, I teach more than I want to.
0:48:51 But my ultimate goal is, if you're unhappy with a program,
0:48:57 I don't want your kids to not learn how to swim,
0:48:59 because I am passionate about kids learning how to be able to swim.
0:49:05 I had one of my family's contact me getting that soup hot in there.
0:49:13 Little girl got tangled up in a floaty flipped and they weren't close enough at first she
0:49:21 was panicking and then she just stopped and she relaxed and she floated on her back and
0:49:27 her and stuff.
0:49:46 I just want you to know that I'm actually bringing this into the pool that wouldn't come there otherwise of those families and then the two that have his own
0:50:05 Orleans would not, they would cancel their pass or they would finish their punch pass and not come back.
0:50:11 They don't utilize lessons with me.
0:50:16 Comments that anyone wanted to cancel discussion?
0:50:30 Chris Reed, I actually don't have any problem with competition.
0:50:36 I think it's good for us.
0:50:37 I think it makes us better.
0:50:39 If there's a paying for service, a public facility,
0:50:44 I do feel that we should have some type of,
0:50:47 whether it's coaching or instruction permit,
0:50:49 if there's a paying for service,
0:50:52 and it really needs to be across the board,
0:50:55 whether it's the pools, tennis courts, pickle ball,
0:50:58 do we have basketball courts?
0:51:01 Okay, basketball courts, soccer, baseball, trails, golf,
0:51:05 they're teaching their dog obedience,
0:51:08 that needs to be there. You don't say, well, we're swimming, we're going to charge, but
0:51:16 for soccer, we're not going to. You make it something that people, it doesn't affect their
0:51:23 business, but it's across the board if we're going to do it, it's not. We're going to choose
0:51:28 pools and we're not going to do this. We're not going to do that. Coaching instructions,
0:51:34 something is just, when I'm criss I think that when I look at something I think it needs
0:51:55 to be consistent across all of our facilities with the first similar type activities. I guess
0:52:03 When do you indicated this has been a topic with other cities and the State Parks Association,
0:52:10 so are there best practices yet or is everybody across the board on how they address it or
0:52:17 don't address it?
0:52:22 When Shane asked for some input from me when we started to down this road originally, I
0:52:29 went and just pulled city code kind of across him and he's reached out to some of his other
0:52:37 counselors across the state to find out and truly to involves the only city that
0:52:42 doesn't prohibit this kind of thing from happening in the parks. How they address
0:52:47 it and what I saw kind of a common theme was a permit process. So what you do is
0:52:52 you write in the ordinance that is prohibited and then you allow with a permit.
0:52:58 It's one of the things that I saw when I was in Nampa for example it was
0:53:03 prohibited but there wasn't a mechanism to allow it and so it was difficult to
0:53:08 figure out how to do that. I like the idea of some sort of a permitting process but
0:53:12 we haven't, I don't know if we've exactly explored a best practice. I think that
0:53:18 there's not really, it seems like that's kind of in general. I know that at the
0:53:23 federal level it's prohibited without a licensure permit, I'm like a guide
0:53:28 service kind of thing. I think it's the same way at the state. So there's kind of
0:53:34 maybe a common theme more than a best practice.
0:53:37 As something I guess the enforcement piece is complicated though so we have a
0:53:52 whole rules and ordinances that we currently don't have to proactively enforce in
0:54:00 our community of planes and then go but enforcement folks who are chasing
0:54:07 leads and wandering chasing down they're giving a skateboard lesson on the trail
0:54:16 I'm teaching private lessons in my backyard for a while, and then we're going to go golfing
0:54:44 today, and they take them to beauty, they're paying me a hundred bucks for the lesson, but
0:54:48 it's still a private lesson that's happening there.
0:55:00 That's all muddy.
0:55:02 The answer is I'm just kind of talking.
0:55:03 Do you struggle a little bit with let's just address the pool except that it's a confined
0:55:11 space and we can we kind of know what's going on there.
0:55:14 But is that really fair if the philosophy is you shouldn't be using public facilities for
0:55:19 private game without some process?
0:55:21 I guess another question Shane I would have for you on a permit process.
0:55:26 So if we were to issue permits for these types of things, we then go some level with the
0:55:35 We've actually reached out to I-cramped and informed us that permitting doesn't change
0:55:43 the liability from, doesn't shift it really.
0:55:46 I mean, the person who's exercising or offering the service, still, we don't foresee any shifting of life.
0:55:57 Because of a permitting perspective, is that really going to offset wear and tear on facilities?
0:56:22 Who's going to manage a permit process?
0:56:25 Does that mean we have to look at staff? Those kinds of things.
0:56:29 So I think that we have enough information to kind of take the next step.
0:56:39 The purpose of the agenda item has been answered, and is this exclusively a process that we're going to look at just at the pool?
0:56:49 And you've answered that that really it is all public properties.
0:56:55 The second piece that we were coming in asking tonight was, is it, yes, it's allowed or, no, it's not, or is this gray area of a permit, and I think that you've answered that until we'll be able to take some of those pieces and then go back and have additional conversations and look at some other models.
0:57:13 we will again then present kind of what we've found to see if it's starting to
0:57:20 make sense with the council then after that we'll begin that public policy
0:57:25 creation processes should that be the desire of the council. I might just throw
0:57:31 out there if there are folks and learn to the ones who have come here tonight
0:57:34 who are doing these types of things in public facilities with the attitude of
0:57:39 we can find a solution. We have solutions or examples from your peers and colleagues
0:57:44 and other communities as reaching out to us and the Councilor
0:57:48 to the City Manager's Officer Parks and let's talk through what it looks like because
0:57:52 I don't get a sense that we're saying let's not allow this
0:57:56 just flat out but what is that happy medium in the grey area
0:58:01 so have the expertise to connect us with resources.
0:58:06 To the next agenda item now which is an action item, this is a request
0:58:22 to use cash reserves to make up the difference between budgeted project
0:58:26 for Golf Course of Storage Shed, and we have Wendy Davis, our Parks and Recreation Director.
0:58:31 Good evening again, and I apologize. I threw this together on Wednesday night, came in to
0:58:41 finish it, and I did not fix the request. So as you got there, it's not a complete sentence,
0:58:49 and I'm sorry about that. So the real request is to use cash reserves to make up the difference
0:58:55 between a budget item amount and where the bids would probably fall, so it's that difference
0:59:04 piece. But budgeted project amount maybe would be the next word, maybe that's why I didn't
0:59:10 put it in there because I didn't know what to say.
0:59:14 So just a quick recap. The golf course shed replacement project was approved in the FY19
0:59:24 We had an estimate that we used in January of 2018 when we were going through the long-term planning process.
0:59:33 Once we got the budgeted amount approved in October, we hired Loughlin and Ranks,
0:59:39 and just I have Kevin and Colby with me this evening to kind of help talk about this if you have questions.
0:59:45 To design the project, and then we put it up to bid in February.
0:59:50 And I just kind of wanted to like jump up right after Josh got done.
0:59:55 And so we put it out to bid.
0:59:59 We got three bids and the little bid was 182.
1:00:03 And so we chose to reject those bids at the time.
1:00:07 And we went back to the drawing board and tried to look for some cost savings options.
1:00:13 Couldn't get it down.
1:00:15 So I'm back asking for, to use cash reserves to make up the difference between the 120
1:00:22 we have budgeted and where the bids are likely to fall.
1:00:26 I do have an estimate.
1:00:29 I was hesitant to ask for a cap.
1:00:31 I didn't know how you guys wanted to go about this, but we're prepared to talk about the
1:00:38 cost savings if you're interested.
1:00:40 We did look at changing the installation of the building, we're changing the way we're
1:00:47 doing the base.
1:00:48 Originally we were calling for asphalt and we're looking at chip seal.
1:00:54 We were able to get the dirt from North College project.
1:00:59 They've already started hauling it over and they're compacting that for the base.
1:01:04 There's a cost to that but we are changing the way we're doing that to try to cut some
1:01:08 costs.
1:01:09 savings of approximately $17,000 on the installation and the savings of approximately $9,000 in
1:01:20 changing from MassFault to a chip-sill surface and anyway, we'd like to be able to take it
1:01:28 back to bid and I just can't do that without dedicated funds.
1:01:33 So you rejected the initial bids.
1:01:37 You've sharpened the scope of the bid request.
1:01:41 You want to go take it to bid again.
1:01:44 I might need a little more money.
1:01:46 And you're not going to be at 120, but in theory it won't be at 180 to you either.
1:01:51 That's the hope, yes.
1:01:56 Okay.
1:01:58 Yes, Nicky boy.
1:01:59 So don't cap on it.
1:02:02 Well, what I would say is so we can go to bid, we still have to award a bid, correct?
1:02:11 And we can certainly do it that way.
1:02:13 The bid will still come back to us to be awarded, if at that point we say, you know, we still
1:02:18 like this number and we're not going to fund it, then fund it.
1:02:21 So I believe, once it goes over how much, if it goes over 200,000, yes, you would definitely have to award the bid.
1:02:32 If we keep it under 200, you wouldn't need to, but if you would like to say we want to award the bid, then I certainly can bring that process back.
1:02:44 So that would be another way we could do it.
1:02:47 That's the public bid process.
1:02:57 So I can, we can award it in just a moment.
1:03:01 So yes, the state code has a series of different processes and you had a formal bid process on public works construction at $200,000.
1:03:14 That is a fundamentally different process than projects that are under that.
1:03:19 And so we have the ability to do what's called an informal bid process.
1:03:24 We followed an informal bid process, and that's why staff was able to reject the bids last time.
1:03:29 At this been a formal bid process, we would have brought that to you and asked you to consider rejecting those bids as well.
1:03:37 Wendy's asking for is the opportunity to go back out and bid the project, recognizing that she will be more racially allocated
1:03:52 allocated and wanted the council to be aware of that, because it's without having the opportunity
1:04:03 to award the bid should they meet our desired request.
1:04:09 I do have another question, so we could say you're good to go up to 200.
1:04:24 Yes, you can set a count for sure.
1:04:28 And it can come in lower.
1:04:30 I think as interesting is more time has gone by and so before 182C.
1:04:37 but now we're thinking that 182 is get the job done out of it so we're expecting it to come in under 182
1:04:50 that's the hope of 182 yes I have the strategy is for it to come in because the refined estimate is 167 but what what concerned me was to ask from 167 and have it come in at 168 but 8
1:05:10 Chris, we've already answered my question with that.
1:05:19 See, we've taken up 26,000 from yesterday, correct?
1:05:24 With 17,000, that's awesome.
1:05:28 We always think when you're doing math, I've failed you.
1:05:31 OK, so 9,000 is right.
1:05:34 Give me what we've cut out.
1:05:37 What's the new estimate?
1:05:38 So we cut the new estimate as 167.
1:05:42 What's that?
1:05:42 167.
1:05:50 167.107.
1:05:52 And that includes a little bit of a contingency.
1:05:58 That's based on the lowest bit, previous bit.
1:06:01 Mike, there's some things you've taken out.
1:06:05 You're asking for 60 with this bid.
1:06:09 60 or 47,000 in reserve.
1:06:12 Yes, so it would be 47,000 in reserves
1:06:15 above the 120 that's currently budgeted.
1:06:17 Yeah, but we're looking at right now.
1:06:19 Correct.
1:06:20 If it's 60, if it's at the same amount.
1:06:22 Right, yes.
1:06:25 So the question is, do we authorize them
1:06:28 to go back to bed.
1:06:29 I think knowing that it's going to be more than 120.
1:06:33 So moved.
1:06:34 Second.
1:06:39 Motion by everyone.
1:06:42 Peer, second by Chris Reed to authorize staff to go back to bed for the projects.
1:06:48 I did not hear a cap on this council.
1:06:58 What we can do is we can come back and the council can say, um, part of our process is
1:07:03 the entirety of the funds were not allocated.
1:07:05 So the council has to come forward and actually do an allocation of the cash reserves today
1:07:12 We're just getting permission to entertain the use of cash reserves
1:07:16 Should they be necessary? We believe they will be for the completion of the project
1:07:24 So after the pins come back that we're most likely gonna have to get into cash reserves
1:07:32 If it's more than we want to spend we can still say no at that time
1:07:35 I mean, if it comes in at $195, I'm not okay with that, but if it's still under the $200,000 mark, so can we say no at that time?
1:07:48 Yes, you can say no, because it is more than what you've initially allocated for the project.
1:07:56 Yes, and it is more than our current estimates as well, significant.
1:08:00 So, a question for staff, would it be more beneficial if we did have a cap on it now to feel more comfortable approaching the Uber?
1:08:42 Certainly able to place a cap at any point in time and you chair that cap to see, you know,
1:08:49 we don't feel comfortable with this project proceeding above some threshold.
1:08:55 That doesn't take away the fact that we're going to have to bid that project.
1:08:59 And so, say, boy, the cap's 170, as opposed to 172, that's the piece that Wendy's talking about,
1:09:09 about is she's looking for maximum flexibility to accomplish the project
1:09:14 efficiently, recognizing that we're going to bring it back so you have you have
1:09:23 I'll say as to whether or not there's going to be a cap because you have to
1:09:29 abort the project. Okay, so the motion on the floor by Ruth Pierce, second by Chris
1:09:38 Reed, is to authorize staff to go back out to bid for the golf course, storage
1:09:44 Thank you.
1:09:45 And next on the agenda is another opportunity for general public input if there's anyone
1:09:56 here from the public who wishes to address the council and as your opportunity to please
1:09:58 come forward.
1:09:59 Seeing no one, advisory board reports from the council.
1:10:02 I have anything from the city manager's office.
1:10:06 We have a few things.
1:10:11 Next on the agenda is another opportunity for general public input if there's anyone here from the public who wishes to address the council and as your opportunity to please come forward.
1:10:18 Seeing no one advisory board reports from the council.
1:10:24 I have something from the city manager's office.
1:10:31 We have a few things.
1:10:32 The first thing we'd like to do last week we had a great opportunity to celebrate the accomplishments of the youth council and the sea click fix.
1:10:45 click Fix, we've also had the opportunity to celebrate Greg's accomplishment for the
1:10:49 war that he received and our newly elected Association of Idaho City's President was
1:10:55 unable to be with us this weekend or this week or this past week and so you know we
1:11:02 would just all like to extend a hearty congratulations to you for your
1:11:07 election and we look forward to working with you during your terms so
1:11:10 congratulations. Travis while we're on the air seat subject, I also wanted to allow Shane
1:11:22 to know who also received an award unless you have that on your list. That was the next one
1:11:28 we have. And I'll shut my yapper out and let you talk. So Shane, who has kind of gone through the ranks,
1:11:36 he's just completed his term as being the, I think, believe it's the president of the Idaho
1:11:43 and he was awarded by his peers, I believe it's referred to as the upcoming, the upcoming,
1:11:50 what the rising star award. Excellent. Which is really, when you think about those types
1:11:59 of awards, they're really coming from your peers and it talks about the respect that Shane
1:12:06 is realizing in his service, not only to us, but also to the organizations across the state
1:12:14 that participate in the association. So congratulations also to Shane for that award.
1:12:27 We had an amazing weekend with the Criteria of Intem. And I'd like to just give a great shout-out
1:12:37 But again, Cliff Barnes' psychotherapy for really bringing a quality event downtown.
1:12:44 There were probably slightly fewer members of our community inspectors that attended
1:12:50 during the day, but in the evening it seemed to really, really pick up.
1:12:53 So in September we're going to have a debriefing to find ways and new strategies to find ways
1:12:59 to elevate excitement for members of our community to come down.
1:13:03 It was a really, really good racing, and unfortunately there were some spills of some of the riders,
1:13:10 all of which were generally fine afterwards, but nevertheless it was a really fun, exciting
1:13:17 event, and the concert seemed to go fairly well.
1:13:22 Obviously, this Thursday is a pretty important day in our country as we celebrate Independence
1:13:31 Day.
1:13:32 And so the city's business days will be closed and then also that evening we've partnered again with Chibani on the 4th of Chiblai fireworks display.
1:13:44 It's going to be hosted at CSI at 10 p.m. and we would encourage individuals to arrive early as we will begin the road barricading about 9 o'clock.
1:13:54 Lori races here and she will tell you next week begins to solid, straight, beautiful months of budget hearings and conversations.
1:14:06 We will begin those conversations with an overview. We will work through the various focus areas and we will conclude the activity, hopefully with the adoption of a budget on the 26th of August.
1:14:20 State of the city is the 16th of July, and individuals can acquire their tickets now through the chamber.
1:14:27 The event is at the Stone House. It runs from 11.30 to 1 o'clock, and the council is working on their various parts.
1:14:38 As you look at those pieces, and if you need help from the staff with research or additional information, please let us know what we have to assist.
1:14:46 That is all I have.
1:14:51 Thank you Travis, well with that everyone have a safe and sane holiday this week and we'll
1:14:59 look forward to jumping into the budget next week with that the meeting is
1:15:02 adjourned.
Download
- Transcript (text) 63 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 81 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 106 KB
- Audio (M4A) 17.8 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, July 1, 2019. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:15:10.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
883207644cac08b568defaf21ee564711e3ebaad43c4521c06f3993713c12ea3 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 76b0ba034189718e7c9bce3e86fb1f409f86558fc9fe9ffd6a614fad7d218105 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
7c7203ca7c7ce5244cafcf057b74f41f487c6a2c899c8b7a0fc2cc0088f484be
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file