City Council meeting
Monday, November 18, 2019
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: a,c
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
The audio for this recording isn't posted yet. It's being held back until a privacy review is finished. The transcript below is complete apart from marked passages.
Transcript
0:01:23 to call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting from Monday, November 18th
0:01:27 and confirm that we do have quorum and the council all seven members are present
0:01:31 this evening. The agenda next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance for
0:01:36 those of you wishing to join us please rise. On the agenda are proclamations we
0:02:03 have no proclamations this evening and next on the agenda is an opportunity for
0:02:07 general public input. There's anyone in the audience who wishes to address the
0:02:11 council on an item that is not on the agenda this evening now is your
0:02:15 opportunity to please come forward and we'll note we are having discussion and action item
0:02:24 later regarding scope of a potential smoking ordinance and there is one person in the audience
0:02:30 who's requested an opportunity to give some input so we will allow the input and we also
0:02:40 have the public hearing scheduled for later in that so the council the minutes of last
0:03:04 week at Christoganton seconded by great landing to approve the consent calendar except for
0:03:26 The minutes of last week's meeting is there a new discussion.
0:03:40 Mickey Boy.
0:03:41 Yes.
0:03:41 Susanne Hawkins.
0:03:42 Yes.
0:03:43 Greg Lanting.
0:03:44 Yes.
0:03:44 Ruth Pierce.
0:03:45 Yes.
0:03:45 Christopher Reed.
0:03:46 Yes.
0:03:47 St. Chris Dockington.
0:03:47 Yes.
0:03:48 Motion passes 7-0.
0:03:50 Council wishes on the minutes of last week's meeting.
0:03:58 Second.
0:04:00 Lanting second.
0:04:00 I'd rather read Pierce to the minutes of the November 12th City
0:04:04 Council meeting his special meeting.
0:04:11 Mickey Boy.
0:04:13 Yes.
0:04:14 Greg Lanting.
0:04:15 Yes.
0:04:15 Ruth Pierce.
0:04:17 Christopher Reed.
0:04:18 Yes.
0:04:18 Chris Dockington.
0:04:19 Yes.
0:04:20 Chassis 6-0 with 1-1-1-1-1-1. So if you were here for the findings in fact and conclusions
0:04:31 of law for Federation Point LLC, the Special Event Application for the Annual Festival of
0:04:36 White Spray to be held on Friday, December 6th, or the Trust Agreement for Cedar Park
0:04:42 Subdivision No. 12, or Cedar Park of Subdivision No. 12, or items of consideration. The first
0:04:53 is a request to adopt an ordinance for a vacation request for a portion of Bolton Street right
0:04:58 in a way located north of 202 Caswell happening west of me of Jonathan's been loved.
0:05:03 Our Parks and Recreation engine says the Planning and Zoning Director.
0:05:09 Members of the Council, I'm going to pull up the map with this both the street vacation
0:05:23 actually came before. The Council some time ago was almost a year ago.
0:05:27 It's taken some time for the applicant to get the legal descriptions done and their kind of design all.
0:05:32 So I wanted to kind of vault the street and they're just constructed going west
0:05:48 He's indicated with some planning to move forward, which you're going to see, so that's what this original, or this ordinance, is about as vacating that right of way, investing the property to the adjacent property to the ordinance today and have to be placed, ordinance, 2019, 013, um, 3rd and final by suspension of the rules, and we read the title only.
0:06:57 Second.
0:06:58 Great landing.
0:07:00 Second by Ruth Pierce to place ordinance 2019 dash 013 on third and final read and suspension
0:07:06 of three discussion.
0:07:07 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:07:14 Yes.
0:07:15 Great landing.
0:07:16 Yes.
0:07:17 Great Pierce.
0:07:18 Yes.
0:07:19 Christopher Reed.
0:07:20 Yes.
0:07:21 Chris Tocquington.
0:07:22 Yes.
0:07:23 John Berriger.
0:07:24 Yes.
0:07:26 Nicky Boy.
0:07:27 Yes.
0:07:28 Passes seven to zero.
0:07:31 Ordinance of the mayor and the city council of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho.
0:07:34 I'm indicating right of way the real property described below and providing for investing of title to the property so thank you to my Christ, talk and then second by Nicky Boyd to approve ordinance 2019 dash the 013 is there any discussion.
0:07:55 Yes.
0:08:03 Christopher.
0:08:04 Yes.
0:08:05 Yes.
0:08:06 John.
0:08:07 Yes.
0:08:08 Nicky Boyd.
0:08:09 Yes.
0:08:10 And Suzanne Hawkins.
0:08:11 Yes.
0:08:15 Next, on the request to at this rate, zoning district change and zoning map on R4 to R6-CDA blocks of castle against same property and now this ordinance will create that ZDA zoning development agreement, the zoning for that property encompassing the now for this area in Bordenitz, S-01-4, Suzanne Hawkins, Place Ordenitz 2019-014.
0:09:19 Motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by eight,
0:09:26 to suspend the rules and place of ordinance 2019-014-3rd
0:09:30 and final reading by title.
0:09:39 Ruth Pierce?
0:09:40 Yes.
0:09:40 Christopher Reed?
0:09:41 Yes.
0:09:42 Chris Tockington?
0:09:42 Yes.
0:09:43 John Barricow?
0:09:44 Yes.
0:09:44 Nikki Boyd?
0:09:45 Yes.
0:09:46 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:09:46 Yes.
0:09:47 In grapelantic?
0:09:48 Yes.
0:09:48 Motion passes 7-0.
0:09:53 Ordinance 2019-014.
0:09:56 An ordinance of the city council of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho,
0:09:59 rezoning certain real property below described providing the zoning classification therefore
0:10:04 bring the necessary area in the zoning district's map. Second. Second.
0:10:31 Christopher Reeve. Yes. Chris Talkington. Yes. John Berriger. Yes. Nikki Boyd. Dan Hawkins.
0:10:37 Yes. Great landing. Yes. Yes. Great papers. Yes. passes 7-0. Thank you for the parts.
0:10:51 Next on the agenda is the action item. This is a request for further direction on scope
0:10:55 of a potential smoking ordinance and we have our city attorney, Shane Nope,
0:10:59 you may or city council and council in essence a smoke free city falls and in essence the
0:11:23 city council may be specifically to our parks, public spaces, and our trail system and so
0:11:33 this presentation is an effort to just kind of show examples of what other cities I pick
0:11:37 to cities and kind of went through and I say I pick Davis and Stacy McClintock out of parks
0:11:44 I just wanted to highlight a few things for you to maybe get the movement.
0:11:56 So in Idaho there is a Clean Air Act.
0:11:59 It's in its chapter flaws, housed, and it basically makes certain public spaces already smoke free areas.
0:12:10 It does exempt a few areas that can be designated as smoking areas or have smoking areas within those particular ones.
0:12:18 I wanted to point out that in 39-5511 this is where a lot of outstate create cities receive their power
0:12:30 the Constitution and the legislature. This is in that nothing in this chapter shall be interpreted to
0:12:38 prevent money or municipal government ordinances or regular statutes on forced relations to
0:12:55 smoke. Typically, ordinances of other cities, there's four main categories and I'm just going to talk
0:13:02 briefly about each four of those, kind of show you the example from the state code, the examples from
0:13:07 two cities. One in essence, we can add, regulating under those you look at health and safety. One of
0:13:20 of the state code, in essence, talks about all of the dangers of smoking and second-hand
0:13:25 smoke, and there in the last full sentences, the conclusions of public health officials
0:13:30 concerning second-hand tobacco smoke are sufficient to warrant measures that regulate smoking
0:13:34 and public places.
0:13:35 The state code is to, so the two cities that we had examples from Court of Lane, had different
0:13:54 sections.
0:13:55 Maybe as you think, what would you like to be included in an ordinance should the City of
0:13:59 and falls come forward with the draft ordinance, a purpose and intent section, and here are
0:14:05 two examples.
0:14:06 Cordellange is verbatim, quoted the state, a purpose and intent, but condensed what was
0:14:13 said in those two paragraphs and made it a first section.
0:14:22 The second area, there's definition sections in all of these codes, and I just listed a few
0:14:27 you'll see by the ellipses that there are many other words that are defined in the state
0:14:32 code, but two examples are bar, or excuse me, three auditorium bar, in place. The cities
0:14:44 have done to further define some of these areas. So examples in other cities, I know this came
0:14:52 up with four more e-cigarettes. Other cities have addressed that concern with regard to, with
0:15:03 e-cigarettes, as you can see listed in that definition. I did want to point out that in
0:15:09 the code section it does define tobacco products, and it specifically excludes, does not include
0:15:15 any cessation product specifically approved by the United States Food and Drug Administration
0:15:20 for use in treating nicotine or to pack some of those things contained that code specifically
0:15:33 says if it's a cessation tobacco cessation product. I gave these two examples and I put
0:15:44 down on the on your left side the special event zone. This was talked about in previous
0:15:49 council meetings where can you establish zones where they're smoking that's allowed
0:15:54 prohibited, and what this code section does would prohibit it in certain
0:15:59 special event zones. For example, if it's not already
0:16:02 or it's free zone, floor hop, has to be true about in a special event.
0:16:33 Let's say we list a park in you, that's special event in that
0:16:39 a smoke free zone. You could say we have a special event zone where we will allow a smoking area to
0:16:44 the special event process. I believe is that the definition of e-cigarette would cover
0:17:19 but we can write, you'll see a map, of course, a specific area behind their city hall campus.
0:17:34 And they've included ordinance that would take some effort, the drawing.
0:17:40 I personally intend because rotation is where person is standing.
0:17:46 Those are examples that we could section three talks about what is prohibited.
0:17:57 This is the state code which I mentioned before, prohibits smoking in public places, public, excuse me,
0:18:04 but place, publicly owned building or office or at public meeting and so I ask that all
0:18:13 but these specific areas can be designated, bars can be designated as a smoking area in its entirety
0:18:19 or have sections within that establishment for smoking areas.
0:18:23 And I'm an example from the state code and further amendments have come into that state code
0:18:34 they've listed specific with regard to elevators and no smoking on buses and no specific sections
0:18:39 have definitions of all of their own, so getting to some of the examples from other cities,
0:18:48 smoking shops of the city, states the smoking man in that city, and gives specific definitions.
0:19:11 And this might as it relates to paragraph D, have some language that Wooderson has been saying
0:19:25 within designated, especially Vint Zone as defined herein, you may have a smoking area that is,
0:19:32 So again, this is giving you an idea as it relates to penalties, and if I'm under the
0:20:32 The state code in this particular section, just the smoking section alone, is only a $17.50
0:20:39 and it goes as higher price for selling to a minor to get cigarettes as the state penalty.
0:21:02 So the cities that are out there, the ones like on the left side, which it just says $100
0:21:10 plus a court cost, right now a court costs about $57 and when it falls and so if a person
0:21:15 gets an infraction into it and falls, you'll see that again this city is trying to curtail
0:21:26 some of the problems they maybe have. So, in paragraph C, if someone is causing or permitting
0:21:32 or aiding or concealing a violation of this provision will also constitute a violation.
0:21:37 I don't know if that's necessary, but again, which is their paragraph, D, in terms of tying
0:21:46 the fee back to the fraction rules. But as soon as I went to that specific section, it's
0:21:53 no longer in 49. And so that would be a problem. We would have to time the state amends its
0:22:00 So that's an essence, kind of the framework, those four sections, and so my purpose here
0:22:15 is really to just kind of get general ideas to go back to work with if the council wants
0:22:22 to continue forward and have staff spend more time on coordinates to present with another
0:22:31 city council meeting where it relates to the specific coordinates that is drafted, and
0:22:38 I can also wait until the meeting gets up, so we'll do that for us.
0:23:01 I appreciate it. Congratulations Sean on beating me. I just want to address that. I see you guys are looking at it. You're not deciding for sure if you want to do that. My concern is if you're willing to look at whether or not you want to ban smoking, why are we looking at bring everybody's life, liberty, and freedoms, right? You guys aren't willing to look at the abortion law and changing that within the city, but yet you're willing to look at taking away someone's right to smoke within Twin Falls City.
0:23:44 I am a non-smoker, I want to make that very clear.
0:23:46 Have no issue with it one way or the other.
0:23:50 Do I like sitting next to somebody
0:23:51 that's smoking in a public event?
0:23:52 Probably not, and I probably wouldn't like it up and move.
0:23:56 But I don't feel it's our place to infringe upon their rights.
0:24:00 It's not our police department.
0:24:02 They're not supposed to police the people.
0:24:04 They're supposed to be there to serve and protect.
0:24:06 It's not your job to create additional fines
0:24:10 to tax your people or find your people.
0:24:13 You guys are here to do a job for infrastructure, not this.
0:24:17 This does not pertain to your job, and if it does,
0:24:20 I'd like to see where it's written in your oath of office.
0:24:23 I just firmly feel that you guys need to look at other things,
0:24:26 and the money that you spent on this.
0:24:28 That's a lot of money went out that could have been spent
0:24:30 on something to benefit our children and our school
0:24:32 districts, and not on the smoking policy.
0:24:35 That's pretty much all I wanted to say.
0:24:36 Thanks.
0:24:39 Is anyone else from the public who'd like
0:24:42 But on this issue, some discussion here to see that's sort of a fault.
0:26:09 Can't speak, unfortunately. I don't have other cities. I can reach out to them and have that.
0:26:13 Other cities are dual things. Just for example.
0:27:12 When we talk to the creation department and ask them what kind of enforcement issues they've had,
0:27:21 they don't have any problems. In some way, they don't have problems in Oregon Trail.
0:27:26 They haven't had enforcement issues. And that's the staff that makes the
0:27:31 requests because right now it's just a voluntary compliance. I think if they have
0:27:36 any issues it's at Harman where smoking is voluntarily banned in the bleachers
0:27:45 and there's areas around there where people can smoke nearby that there's a
0:27:50 little bit I think they have some more conversations there than anywhere else.
0:27:55 I haven't heard of problems around playgrounds. I haven't heard of any of
0:28:00 those kinds of things. Thank you Mayor and Council recall a few months ago when we first
0:28:14 started this conversation. I was asked by Councilman Ray to do some research on calls
0:28:19 for service at the minimum to one falls PD have had in relation to smoking violations
0:28:26 in these specific to the areas where it's already prohibited and I believe in Councilman Ray
0:28:31 maybe you can help I think we I had a research for one year. Yeah we had zero calls for service
0:28:36 in that one year time. I can't tell you that men and women of Twin Falls Police Department
0:28:42 do occasionally deal with smoking issues at the skate park, but that's generally to underage
0:28:48 kids who are smoking. We get calls for service related to underage children, smoking cigarettes,
0:28:55 and we respond to a few of those. I haven't done the research to see how many, but I just know that
0:29:02 As was said by Mr. Nope, if this were to be a City Ordinance,
0:29:07 obviously we would enforce that that is the job of the Twin Falls Police Department
0:29:11 to enforce City Ordinance, but it definitely would be a low priority if we had a call for service
0:29:17 and Ms. Davis and I were speaking on the hallway before this meeting.
0:29:21 If we had a call for service and somebody wasn't voluntarily leaving a park
0:29:26 or putting out their cigarette, we've certainly tried to free up an officer to respond to that.
0:29:32 But again, it was over 50,000 calls for service handling on it.
0:29:44 So, you know, we generally run somewhere between seven and maybe 14 police officers are working.
0:29:51 Patrol officers are working, yeah, so calls for service and a shift.
0:30:10 I have my questions for Shane.
0:30:12 I'm thinking of a specific event where I see a lot of smoking going on that can be an
0:30:21 I have helped with that concerted effort to clean up all the cigarette butts from those
0:30:34 concerts after the concert needs Wednesday night and with this, my word, we're leading
0:30:41 to my question, let's say, specific city streets, I know we can ban it in the park without any
0:30:49 trouble, could we say all parks, all streets during special events or what is our latitude
0:30:57 With what it said on the, I realize, and this is probably the difference that this particular ordinance at the state level gives us rights to be more restrictive.
0:31:10 Other ones don't give us that right. This one does allow us to be more restrictive than the state code, but it's all been enough to answer your question.
0:31:31 I'm thinking that in the downtown commons area, he probably spends 30 to 40 minutes.
0:32:43 I would guess a day in the morning cleaning up out in the summertime for sure when there's been heavier traffic around there to pick those up.
0:32:52 Or, you know, if you blows it a couple of times a week, but in the downtown comments area at City Park, there's definitely a fairly high incidence of cigarette bus.
0:33:04 Just the comments area park was another area.
0:33:14 There is issue we have more smoking, yes.
0:33:16 We're spending as a city, as significantly not cigarette buts.
0:33:22 Maybe, and I don't, honestly, I don't know if in the turf, if they pick it up, or if they
0:33:32 mow it up.
0:33:34 You know, the problem with the commons is the only way to get them up is to sweep them up
0:33:38 or pick them up or pick them up, but in the grass, I don't, I honestly don't know, I can
0:33:43 look into that and see if I can get a sense of how much I think they spend.
0:33:47 Yeah, I just, excuse, cost associated to cigarette blood on the ground last time there's a safety concern.
0:34:36 Yes, it works.
0:34:37 Yes, and I would say the Canyon Rim Trail as well.
0:34:51 The Canyon, so three areas.
0:34:53 So we could probably burn the Canyon.
0:34:58 So I would, can I?
0:35:01 I guess, yeah.
0:35:02 So I, there's one comment and I know that we talked about this a little bit too, but when we talked about how we can go out this, it seems like we can either ban everything and then permit, or we can ban in certain areas.
0:35:14 and in certain areas, and then permit, then allow events to bat.
0:35:20 So it seems like either way, there's
0:35:24 an opportunity to draw some boundaries
0:35:27 like you were talking about, Councilman Lanting,
0:35:29 where we could, or an event, the downtown concert,
0:35:35 take your example, where they could draw a boundary on a mat
0:35:39 and say, this is the non-smoking zone.
0:35:43 And then enforce it during the event.
0:35:45 and then it would be kind of up to them to enforce.
0:35:49 And I'm assuming, and I don't know,
0:35:51 but it seems like maybe that could be done
0:35:54 and include streets and sidewalks in a way
0:35:56 if we allowed an event ban,
0:36:00 but I don't really know.
0:36:01 I don't know if that's a way to get around that.
0:36:06 You draw a boundary on the map for your event
0:36:08 and this is where I want no smoking
0:36:11 versus trying to deal with that street issue.
0:36:14 I don't know, it seems like we're talking about doing it one way or the other.
0:36:18 It's the easier way to go with that.
0:36:21 So, I get to say we're going to put places and sometimes that's the intent of the mission.
0:36:50 The expectance that says this is harmful to health.
0:37:22 So, great is, we really were passing an ordinance that's going to create more havoc than anything else because,
0:37:54 I understand the health is debating that.
0:37:57 right now we have some signs up if we could just put up signs along the trail
0:38:04 that said please, you know, don't smoke here without creating an
0:38:08 orchard. So if there's areas that we're concerned about fire like agra falls and
0:38:18 along the trail and that there's some some safety risks to it we could still do
0:38:23 that without an ordinance finding a way to protect the children. I'm all in but
0:38:31 I'm just, I'm struggling. I go back and forth on this. I'm not sure where I've been.
0:38:39 That's so, so suppose we put signs in the comments that said, please don't smoke here.
0:38:43 They light subs and smoke so that they concert. So that is the difference of an ordinance for a sign.
0:38:56 Again, I think the place is where it's, and there are places where it's not a problem because it's
0:39:04 expected when you're at the kid's soccer park. And it's a voluntary compliance.
0:39:13 I think the place it is foggy is a place like the commons that at a Wednesday night concert is a very adult menu
0:39:20 and that's not a play what it is.
0:39:26 But instead of an orthospecial use permit address and no smoking zone officers, we're right now p-chance to...
0:39:52 Appreciate that you folks have opinions on this, but this is not a discussion between the audience and the council, so if you could keep your comments down, I'd appreciate it.
0:40:11 I would appreciate if you keep your comments down in this public meeting so that we can have the discussion up here.
0:40:16 Thank you, Ruth Pierce.
0:40:20 So using this flashpad as an example,
0:40:24 if we only, especially used permit,
0:40:29 only addresses that as non-smoking during an event
0:40:32 downtown like the concert, then every day,
0:40:36 somebody could be smoking around the smashpad
0:40:40 without any consequence and it's still a children's playground.
0:40:43 So I personally think in ordinance,
0:40:47 and then using a special used permit to have a smoking section like we do a beer garden
0:40:54 or something like that and I'm not sure $17.50 is punitive enough to stop somebody from smoking.
0:41:23 Social Falls Park, it is prohibited at Durkis, it's prohibited at Rockefeller's Park.
0:41:31 the properties that we acquired of school district and the church. So, are we going to trail in some way?
0:41:41 Yeah, so I don't honestly know the difference between a posted non-smoking sign in the park versus a requested compliance at playgrounds.
0:42:01 We're that difference falls, I'm not exactly sure, but I know that we have a couple of parks that we prohibit smoking at differently than when we ask them not to smoke around the playgrounds, and I don't know differences exactly.
0:42:27 I may be a little more focused on this than others, but I would like to see a span it in the comments.
0:42:51 Because I think we probably, previous things were rebounded and playgrounds in our parks.
0:42:58 I think that probably already should be banned. It should be signed.
0:43:01 Because the splash pad is a playground.
0:43:04 And so I think that probably ought to be banned or we can ban it in the whole park,
0:43:08 which may take some care of some of our issues with cleanup on a daily basis
0:43:13 people are hanging out in the park they might not hang out there if they couldn't smoke.
0:43:17 I'm not sure I'm ready to man in all parks, but I can see if the Parks
0:43:26 recognition team does some parks they think should be included just like Oregon Trail and
0:43:31 the subway soccer complex are banned. I would listen to those as well. I think that kind of goes on
0:43:39 with the self-placing highway that you know we get demanding and everywhere it will be coming
0:43:45 We disbanded in very specific areas people think they can still
0:43:50 Ain't places to park to smoke and so they don't
0:43:54 They shouldn't
0:44:00 Zite like I've been out to block and I see people
0:44:05 Walk way away from everything and
0:44:08 Smokin' I don't think anybody cares
0:44:10 Cause they're way away from the ball times
0:44:12 They're way away from the bleachers
0:44:14 Go to the parking lot
0:44:18 Just basically an open grass area and smoke
0:44:20 And then they come theirself policing like we've talked about
0:44:24 So that's where I'm at as I'm a lot more
0:44:27 I've also cleaned up after the Wednesday concert helping the organizers, 100 cigarette butts.
0:44:45 She added that to our list of playgrounds, at least in that common area of people that
0:44:52 non-sporkers wanted.
0:44:55 Think about it, part of what that other place with bleachers and stuff, the idea is for people
0:45:09 congregating and it's a little harder to move away.
0:45:14 What that other place with bleachers and stuff, the idea is where people are congregating and it's a little harder to move away.
0:45:21 I have to sit in the bleachers or in the comments or maybe think about it that way.
0:45:32 The conversation, my understanding is that we brought that recommendation forward and now we need direction on the ordinance.
0:46:05 Right.
0:46:06 And so what they did research, personal experiences and these kinds of things that came up with some really council,
0:46:36 The council, if I remember not something at certain,
0:47:17 our situation that we've had tonight is the same one
0:47:20 that happens all the time.
0:47:46 It's hard as it is, are we ready to,
0:47:49 and do we want to say there is no smoking on city themselves?
0:48:34 It's our decision, I think.
0:48:35 That's the only decision.
0:48:39 Have it set up where, with the special use permit,
0:48:45 you can have a smoking area to go with the beer garden
0:48:48 or what, because that's, you can get something,
0:48:55 no smoking is what he understands it,
0:49:01 no it's, that's where we're at.
0:49:20 the discussion here tonight is should there be additional places that should be signed
0:49:25 that say you can't smoke. I think there is, I think we already have a middle ground, we don't
0:49:42 ink this notion that about last time and I think there are certain areas where it's more of a fire hazard than it is now.
0:50:08 Places to the huge.
0:50:18 You don't smoke or dare it. Sign of someone who's.
0:50:52 Of course it's based.
0:51:49 It's a city park and it gives a little bit more control over the especially living in a high desert.
0:52:23 It's that small percentage that is costing taxpayers money, so we also do have this one question, Shane.
0:53:57 What boundaries have you said the city park, food, sidewalks, what did that include to the middle of the street?
0:54:06 Can they sit in their car and smoke? So I just want to understand.
0:54:13 We didn't, similar to the slide I showed there with,
0:54:16 written what city hall campus.
0:54:24 The adjacent sidewalks, or pathways,
0:54:53 think about someplace like Shoshun Falls.
0:54:55 Instead of this summer, as incentive,
0:56:36 especially those places we have,
0:57:19 I certainly would be supportive.
0:58:35 The same discussion we've had the last two times,
0:58:41 since it's just need to bring something to us,
0:58:43 and then we can be just able to listen, definitely.
0:59:07 We were just doing really first.
0:59:36 We can excite the two requests as a staff, so we did that.
0:59:41 that period of time to bring back an ordinance and this was the cause of that conversation.
0:59:45 So what I would ask is that actually the council by action instructs staff to go craft
0:59:50 an ordinance next time. So what we'll do is we've had the conversation and we will leave
0:59:56 that with you should you want to craft cause staff to take an action because really the
1:00:04 purpose of tonight was to find out what did you want to do and how do you want to do
1:00:08 If we reach some love and sense us, the staff draft an orden cost after draft
1:00:24 Jordan rather than have us bring that back to you in six months so that we don't
1:00:31 there is a true need and there is a problem that you will this evening upside
1:01:09 side of where I argue lies and if we haven't even a mended to post that we
1:01:19 burdens that they have smoking all property of city owned property in the
1:01:31 city to involves with the exception of the option to
1:01:47 city cigarettes all city I'm not sure that we will end up there gives us a
1:02:07 great starting spot to amend because I think most of us are in general agreement
1:02:13 that most of us but some of us are in general agreement that we that maybe
1:02:18 we shouldn't be smoking in the city and property and if we want to accept some
1:02:25 There's a way we want to add language that's special and it's going to have
1:02:29 smoking areas that can all be done as part of the amendment process
1:02:34 once we have an ordinance. That's my reason for going all and we can work our way back to
1:02:42 I think we can work our way back to a consensus
1:02:49 like in a second
1:03:15 I'm opposed to the motion you made but I am going to vote against it just because
1:03:28 I still feel like we should give our citizens a chance to try it without the ordinance first
1:03:32 And just with signage and self-policing, okay, we'll do it this way too, but I would just prefer to go.
1:03:49 Just read with that as a after six o'clock, it may be scheduled after the normal regular business at six o'clock, but I can't take any of it.
1:04:51 So the motion before us is to drag staff to bring a draft ordinance before us that would prohibit smoking and use of these cigarettes on a city on the property with the exception of the bill.
1:06:37 I think which was a pretty big increase. My actual taxes paid actually went down by $22.
1:06:44 I think that's probably for the fact that I am still under the 200,000.
1:06:48 And so I got full use of the homework exemption increase.
1:06:52 We're actually because of the case that Lisa wasn't in mind this year.
1:07:02 Chris talked to the train like, essentially, when the two set us an imp and it'll be my seven-year-old
1:07:18 counsel, fences, and all right. So with that we do have a public hearing scheduled.
1:07:59 Public hearing, this is a request, appeal of a special use permit to allow a drive-thru
1:08:13 facility with extended hours on property located in 1869 Addison, Heaven and East, Carav Runburns.
1:08:20 On September 24th, 2019, the Planning and Zoning Commission approved the special use permit by
1:08:25 a vote 9-0 and described the hearing procedure, which is slightly different than normal because
1:08:34 this is a somewhat unique, well, all appeals are certainly always allowed.
1:08:39 It's not something we deal with on a regular basis, so I just want to clarify
1:08:42 process for everyone so we understand how this is going to work. So we will hear a
1:08:48 report from the city staff that will present the request and the analysis.
1:08:52 We are then going to allow the person who is appealing this will present their
1:09:02 request, which is the Mr. Burns. I know a loud, general applicant to present to the
1:09:13 council as well request. After that, it's all been taken care of. We will open the
1:09:32 public hearing and we will take public input on this issue this evening. We will
1:09:37 upper person. All that testimony is completed closing statements. Again, that
1:09:52 will be Mr. Burns. We'll close the public hearing.
1:09:56 We'll have to staff do that. Then we'll have the closing statements.
1:10:07 And then we'll close that public hearing.
1:10:13 There's not, but it's sort of like we have two applicants in this process.
1:10:17 We have the original applicant and the input.
1:10:19 So to start our presentation.
1:10:30 Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
1:10:31 So today we have a pill of special use permit PZ-190107, which allowed a drive through facility
1:10:41 and extended retail hours on property at 1869 Addison Avenue East.
1:10:47 During the initial public hearing, Mr. Burns submitted a letter to the Planning Commission outlining his concerns and issues with this project.
1:10:59 His letter was included in the original packet furnace to the Planning Commission and is part of the record for this item.
1:11:08 As a result, Mr. Burns is standing in the case of a uphill.
1:11:13 Mr. Burns approached City staff in the weeks following the planning and zoning commission meeting to discuss a possible appeal.
1:11:22 On October 22nd City staff received his application to appeal it so that he was able to receive an answer within the 15 day appeal period and we scheduled him as promptly as possible with City Council today.
1:11:38 I'm just going to go over what was originally improved with that special use permit, which
1:11:45 is being appealed.
1:11:46 This is right off of Addison Avenue East, within the C1 General Commercial Highway Zone, which
1:12:04 a eating place or restaurant is outright permitted, what is being contested is their use of a drive
1:12:14 through facility, also with extended hours.
1:12:18 Extended hours are any hours outside of 7 a.m. to 10 p.m.
1:12:23 those wishes to operate between the hours of 10 a.m. and being that it's a drive-through facility,
1:12:32 staff has certain standards that need to be met, such as having five car stacking and having
1:12:38 a escape lane that is at least nine feet wide. Being that this is a special use permit, it also
1:12:45 kicks in certain improvements to the overall site. Being that this is a commercial use, which is
1:12:51 directly, which is right here. They are required to put up a screening fence for current city
1:13:01 code. Here's some photos of the subject property. Here's where the proposed drive-through will
1:13:10 be placed. We have the escaped lane. You can see the residences back here. On this way,
1:13:22 this is here. Do you have a section that does not have current screening, which the applicant
1:13:33 with his special use permit currently be approved does need to, we have received both
1:13:44 opposing this appeal and also supporting it, which I have included in your packet.
1:13:49 We also received first today, which I'll post for you, per city code,
1:14:06 which in that we receive afternoon, we are unable to include those persons to please come to this meeting.
1:14:14 To this, it was continued to be of a screening fence, which is already mandated by City Code,
1:14:47 but a wall with context with the original application that was approved when we look at the comprehensive plan designation for this property.
1:15:03 It is neighborhood commercial, which does seek to provide low impact commercial services to surrounding
1:15:09 neighborhoods such as restaurants, drive-athrues, and other similar uses staff believes that this
1:15:17 does conform with that designation. Also, our master transportation plan does indicate Addison
1:15:24 as a arterial roadway, which is a roadway designed to carry the most highest volumes of traffic.
1:15:29 Therefore, we recognize that being right off of that roadway, any additional traffic would be facilitated.
1:15:40 However, regardless, staff does recognize that there will be impacts, close proximity of being surrounded by similar commercial services,
1:16:09 which we do have a drive-through right next door, which is sifts.
1:16:13 We believe that the impacts will be similar.
1:16:16 There may be a- actually be a increase which would be death to the surrounding neighborhood.
1:16:28 Our cells are any questions you may have, and if not, we turn our time over to the applicant.
1:16:34 Does the applicant original applicant to the also local lot that we actually honor to do several right away?
1:16:44 So this property is currently being leased, and they're leasing it from the same property owner,
1:16:49 and the property owner within his lease allows them to use this other law, or traffic flow.
1:16:59 So I have run into the evening. As much as I frequent sips, you think I would know this?
1:17:13 Um, the precise amount of you give us an idea.
1:17:25 It would be a difference. And also with it exiting onto Morningside is their concern.
1:17:32 Especially in the afternoon about school kids walking along there with the extra traffic exiting out.
1:17:38 That is a valid concern. It hasn't been a concern which has been raised with any of the correspondence that staff has received.
1:17:45 However, the primary issue what I believe as far as a nuisance is having these cars drive up and when they drive up
1:17:52 They are facing these residences with their headlight
1:17:56 Also, they know ways and also they drive right past them
1:18:00 Right, the ships head the same direction as a pull in the same way
1:18:03 No, Sips goes in such a way where they come on a morning side
1:18:06 Then they move less word, and then they go southward toward Addison
1:18:10 What's I see?
1:18:13 A website for Sips says they don't mind
1:18:15 Thank you sir
1:18:18 My son used to work for days and Saturdays.
1:18:20 He cooked.
1:18:23 It's still not the extra hours to one of the morning.
1:18:25 It is a sixth of a fence.
1:18:51 It can be contracted out of the multitude.
1:19:01 This body, if you saw it, you could specifically condition a certain material, and also a certain height.
1:19:06 No, after a fence is taller than seven feet.
1:19:09 It does need calculations associated with it.
1:19:14 Being that things get a little windy.
1:19:25 So, that is already provided within City Code.
1:19:28 That has to be shielded.
1:19:29 I have some friends that live on Buchanan, and behind their home is the concrete wall that was put in by Sonic.
1:19:44 And Sonic is open, drive through loudspeakers, everything, and that concrete wall blocks any kind of noise, light, anything.
1:19:54 And I know that they feel really good about what a good neighbor Sonic has been because they went the extra mile.
1:20:01 may have been part of the condition of the specialies, but I wonder if a slatted, chain-link fancy
1:20:08 is protection enough from the noise, even though it could be five cars an hour, I don't
1:20:16 know, but I recognize till one o'clock in the morning could be a little distracting.
1:20:20 I think we should hold those comments until we're having the base questions.
1:20:25 My question was about the concrete.
1:20:27 All of those can be additions to your.
1:20:33 So in conclusion, basically out of three options, you can apply it, you can reaffirm planning and zoning's approval as is, or you can reaffirm with conditions or reverse their decision completely as far as conditions that were originally approved.
1:20:56 They didn't have any specific conditions. Councilwoman Pierce, we only ask that they
1:21:01 be subject to continued compliance with all local state and federal code and other standards
1:21:06 as applicable.
1:21:07 Please just state.
1:21:31 I put that in my letter. I don't want you to miss it either. I'm sure you've got to be
1:26:56 shut in the middle of this place here. Basically, if I prefer this, my request would be that
1:27:19 it's basically not acceptable to treat this if they actually got sent in the lost wall or
1:28:54 I did send every one of my letters. Honestly, I did. I sent every one of all $60 worth. Like Chris mentioned that lighting, they're also the thingy to face their lights, the point about the side that it shines in light.
1:29:42 Other thing I would like to question about since being open and I took around with a close
1:30:25 and I was on Sunday with this.
1:31:34 You can see my main issue is the Madison Stripes pick.
1:31:44 I think these guys stay open to one of them really steeply there.
1:32:00 This is a residential on the back side of this place.
1:32:05 35 years.
1:32:44 I just want to give some clarification about the pickup window.
1:32:47 So for our current city code, we do not have a definition for pickup window.
1:32:52 We don't have a definition for a lot of things.
1:32:55 That's why we are rewriting the entire thing.
1:33:01 original applicants not associated with any menu but it's strictly a customer
1:33:10 we'll call in water online and so I just wanted to provide this city is going to be
1:33:22 [Muted for privacy: street address]
1:33:50 [Muted for privacy: street address]
1:34:05 [Muted for privacy: street address]
1:34:13 I had it posted, that's what's required.
1:34:17 He was talking about before we even looked into that building
1:34:22 and seemed like, because I had talked to him even before.
1:34:25 I submitted my special use of request to go to fence.
1:34:29 And he expressed his concerns to me,
1:34:30 and I tried to leave it, obviously.
1:34:38 I appreciate Brock pointing that out.
1:34:40 We differentiate a pickup window from a drive through.
1:34:44 All orders will be ahead of time.
1:34:46 No loud speaker, no menu board.
1:34:54 pick it up if it's not ready if there's a mistake.
1:35:06 Obviously I'm not in this to create any of my neighbors
1:35:10 over there, Washington Street North.
1:35:26 It's back there, because it's tight corners.
1:35:28 If you know that location, a winter scene,
1:35:33 when I was did sledding in the fence, I have to fix it.
1:35:36 Obviously if something happened similar in the business,
1:35:42 I know Domino's is a big national brand,
1:35:45 international brand I should say,
1:35:46 but this is my wife and my business.
1:35:54 I have full success.
1:35:56 If we have another opportunity to put a location over there,
1:35:59 we can serve Eastern part of town better.
1:36:03 He mentioned Cliff Barre, Joe Bonnie, I use those as just examples.
1:36:08 I have tons of friends especially after the hearing
1:36:12 for the special use permit and it was in the paper.
1:36:14 So many people so excited, the convenience
1:36:17 of the pickup window, but also being on that side of town.
1:36:21 And the pressure on the other store,
1:36:24 if you've ever been there quite busy.
1:36:33 As far as screening goes, you know, I've talked with Brock, obviously that was part of the
1:36:38 plan all along.
1:36:40 Out to whatever is required, big issue, noise, the one resident is right behind us, they
1:36:48 don't have a fence at all.
1:36:50 So we obviously would screen that as it goes down, he has a fantastic fence, but we would
1:36:57 still provide whatever is required.
1:36:58 As far as putting in a mason wall discretion to us, benefits of being, yes, zips is right
1:37:16 there.
1:37:17 They have a traditional drive-through where you order that loud speaker goes.
1:37:21 Our window, our pickup one will be, I would say,
1:37:25 submitted to houses, the back of his house.
1:37:32 We'll be parking back there.
1:37:34 I think most of our customers will park in front.
1:37:38 The people we share the building with,
1:37:41 Magic Valley printing, they close quite early, three o'clock on Friday.
1:37:45 They're not even there on the weekend, so we'll have all those parking spots in the front to use.
1:37:49 That's just to, you know, what we've done with our business, we've used this opportunity, but that's tonight.
1:38:06 Coach soccer, my wife's coach is soccer, lots of stuff in the community, so.
1:38:28 Operation that you're watching.
1:38:34 It's adjacent to resin.
1:38:36 It's quite similar, I would say.
1:38:37 The noise.
1:39:03 As far as, you know, extraneous noise, you know, car alarms.
1:39:09 One of his letters, criminal things like that.
1:39:14 These records have come out to our operation because of unnecessary noise.
1:39:26 It's about 60% delivery for you guys, sir.
1:40:26 The last thing about Pickup Window, it really doesn't increase safety for my crew, because
1:40:32 as we do get to the later, we'll be slower, we won't be able to still serve customers.
1:40:45 Alright, so we are going to open up several folks who have signed up on the signing sheet,
1:41:19 which is great, we're going to start there. If there are others who are here who also wish to address the council,
1:41:24 we'll be welcome to do so.
1:41:26 You just take your name, address,
1:41:29 and a blank sheet after you start off with Janice Stone.
1:41:43 Yes?
1:41:48 I'm going to address this so you get me to come on down to the podium if you would please.
1:41:54 Concerned and assessing.
1:45:19 Next list I have.
1:46:01 Thank you Mr. Mayor.
1:46:14 Mr. Mayor, I was at the public hearing process and planning and zoning when this issue came in form,
1:46:22 and I saw a few weeks ago socially and congratulated him on getting his new location,
1:46:34 location set up and he went within the appeal and he asked for some advice I said well I think it's important.
1:46:50 You have people that are supportive of your efforts show up and testify and he says oh that's great.
1:46:57 You want to do it? I didn't know what I was getting myself into but I am supportive of it.
1:47:02 I don't have, so I get for a number of years I've watched him build a business through hard work and discipline and creativity
1:47:10 And they do a good job.
1:47:13 I think the process allows for drive-throughs, too,
1:47:18 but residential areas.
1:47:22 I mean, unfortunately, that's what happens along blue lakes
1:47:26 and Addison and probably Filer Avenue at some point,
1:47:31 and Washington Street as well.
1:47:34 So the code allows for my special use.
1:47:38 It dictates that there are certain things that should happen
1:47:41 that screen fences, give staff some latitude to add to that, and it's not a perfect scenario
1:47:48 where you have residential and commercial about each other, but we, it's something that we
1:47:53 have to deal with because we have to have those corridors, and so, historically, it's
1:47:57 happened, it's not through this process, and really don't see any reason that we can't
1:48:05 get through this process and do the best we can to protect the residences, but at the
1:48:10 same time allowing the business to survive and I might suggest that the hours of operations
1:48:20 are probably maybe not dictated but through experience the hours of operation they know
1:48:27 when they need to sell those products and there are certainly demand for product Visa
1:48:32 after nine o'clock and suggest that the council doesn't focus on all the different business
1:48:45 models than what's been a while since surviving that business.
1:49:15 I'm very much in favor, Mr. Plaisdale or Pat, my three quarters of a while to the northeast,
1:49:35 and being able to pick up dinner for 300 kids on the way home from work, works perfectly.
1:49:45 I would love to be able to do that.
1:49:50 Sonya are absolutely exemplary citizens, and they support so many videos.
1:49:59 It's rare to be able to be not sponsored by in Pennsylvania, so I know that they're great people that will do the absolute best job that they possibly can.
1:50:11 Thanks for hearing me.
1:50:16 I think it starts with a 2007 something.
1:50:44 That's someone who signed in on the mic.
1:51:15 Perhaps they're in medical school, right Dr. Long?
1:51:19 Adam Chrison. Excellent.
1:51:30 My name is Adam Chrison.
1:51:33 My name is Adversant, 2451, so there's a trail.
1:51:37 I think I can speak to the class sales
1:51:40 excellence in the community.
1:51:41 Obviously I wouldn't be here in support of them
1:51:43 if I didn't think that they would be good stewards
1:51:45 of the area and of their relationship with their neighbors.
1:51:48 I think it's important that my person's assumptions
1:51:51 kind of being made, and I'm a scientist, so I like data.
1:51:54 And I think when we're talking about noise,
1:51:58 the average car at idle is somewhere between 30 to 70
1:52:02 So speaking language is about 60 to 70 to 60
1:52:06 which would be kind of an average 40 is like a whisper, 70 is
1:52:10 louder, maybe louder as loud as I normally speak because I'm kind of a loud person
1:52:14 but an average air, window air conditioner is somewhere between 80 and 90
1:52:18 I think it's reasonable to assume that some of those resonances back there are half air conditioners
1:52:22 so that they're probably going to run in the evening during the summer time
1:52:26 several of them so that that's a compounding noise
1:52:30 So if that noise, again, that's a, you know, that's a humming noise, it's a constant noise.
1:52:34 We're not talking about a car that's at an idle.
1:52:37 We're not talking about cars that are going to be ripping through the driveway
1:52:40 because they're simply, can't allow for that.
1:52:42 If you do that, you're going to rip out the bottom of your car as you exit the egress of this, right?
1:52:47 So the cars are going to be going relatively slowly.
1:52:50 I would say at max 15, even at the end of that driveway, and at that, you're really talking about,
1:52:55 even in like a Dodge Viper, I was kind of looking at an upgrade.
1:52:58 that's 70 decibels at 30 to 50 miles an hour.
1:53:01 Again, that car is not gonna be driving that fast.
1:53:04 So we have to kind of, again, we have to stick
1:53:06 to kind of the data, not just assumptions.
1:53:09 And what are we really talking about
1:53:10 when we're talking about the noise?
1:53:12 I absolutely understand that there's a concern about it,
1:53:15 but we have to be realistic when we think about
1:53:17 what this impact is actually going to be.
1:53:19 And then as far as the fencing,
1:53:21 if all those houses are kind of situated four feet below
1:53:25 the driveway line and we're talking about a six
1:53:27 and now you're talking about a blockade, that's the height of one story of a house, right?
1:53:34 And so I feel that that's a legitimate piece of structure that's going to, again, block
1:53:41 the lighting, block the noise, and then I think all the rest of that is just kind of prick
1:53:46 free car alarms, things like that. Those are all low probability, low risk, someone
1:53:51 hitting the fence. I think, again, the probability of those things occurring while they are present
1:53:56 is very very low so you know there's a lot of things we can do to provide safety
1:54:01 I don't put my child in bubble wrap when I send them out obviously they're gonna
1:54:05 get hurt but because the chances of them getting hurt to that one little thing
1:54:09 that could make we can't protect against all of those things I'm sure you're
1:54:14 absolutely aware of all the things you do in the structure of the city so that's
1:54:18 really all I want to talk about is only a chance of support Pat and Sonia
1:54:44 People have said, by stewards, they are not going to ignore huge problems.
1:55:07 I know that they will work to make sure that the barrier of the fence is going to be effective against light and against some noise.
1:55:14 I also believe that when you're saying it's a pickup, when you're allowed ordering customers, that is a huge thing for their business.
1:55:35 Also, the mom 232 Pierce Street, so just to reiterate what my wife said.
1:55:56 I mean, the ClizDails are great people, great business owners that bring a lot to the community.
1:56:01 They've been great friends, they're very respectful kind people.
1:56:05 And so I know that by allowing them to have this business operation,
1:56:09 it's just going to bring a lot more to the community, to their customers.
1:56:13 I know, I mean, who doesn't get a pizza craving at 1 a.m. sometimes?
1:56:17 Let's be honest.
1:56:18 And they're just providing what the community is wanting.
1:56:21 It's showing that they want this business.
1:56:23 So I think it's a good idea and something that should be supported.
1:56:27 Thanks.
1:56:31 So that is all of the folks who I have who signed up on the sheet to speak.
1:56:34 So if there's anyone else who is just to speak, you can be not have to sign in on the door.
1:56:58 So I'm used to kind of crazy things happening.
1:57:00 I'm also from Washington, D.C.
1:57:02 So I'm used to the world's superman area turning into a significant noises, late pollution as well as convenience.
1:57:18 We start off the hour.
1:57:19 This is here, Gemstone climbing gym, which weeks and the hours of 10 o'clock.
1:57:23 The town is open until 10.
1:57:24 Those are a busy as ours.
1:57:26 6 p.m. to 10 p.m.
1:57:28 It is packed and all this excitement.
1:57:36 The live tales are being done on Jonathan McBride, sometimes known as JJ.
1:58:02 I just wanted to come tonight to speak in favor of this location for Patrick and Sony Quizdale.
1:58:08 I can intimately speak to their conduct as neighbors.
1:58:13 until recently we were neighbors on Ivy Pride Street or Road, excuse me, I've already forgotten.
1:58:19 And there are exemplary neighbors, but there are also great people on multiple occasions.
1:58:25 We had cause to have discussions about the use of our properties, and every single time came out with satisfactory resolutions.
1:58:32 I just can't say enough about Patrick's care for the community, he voiced that tonight for that many times.
1:58:40 So I would say that I'm sure that there is a workable solution here, sounds like we're moving towards one, so thank you for your time and I'm very much in support of this particular business moving forward.
1:58:53 to my bride and sacred avenue directly across the street from mr. birds record I also didn't receive a letter so
1:59:14 the specially used per minute can speak to the best gluten free because my wife is gluten free but
1:59:33 I'm happy that they're they're scanning to have an operation however
1:59:37 uh being that I live right there next location I don't feel that a 10 to 1 a.m. drive-through is
1:59:45 appropriate for that location I'm not sure if any of you are familiar with that location but
1:59:49 But he isn't so much Addison, but coming out there on to Morning Side Drive, where it will be dumping out, I tried to escape on Addison by turning left, which is our street and the next street there to the north are both dead ends.
2:00:15 They're signed. I have a seven-month-old. We like to walk with a stroller. It's an isolated night when he doesn't like to sleep.
2:00:30 Those of you have kids that understand that, like, host that extra traffic back and there's not a very wide area that most street areas can be counted.
2:00:40 Right now, the only one there is SIPs and they're farther back away from our area.
2:00:45 People actually turn in off the morning so I can dump out on Addison. So, I don't think it's much of an issue.
2:00:49 They don't tend to look back around. The concern I have is those cars coming back through our area, especially.
2:00:59 No, the issue hand is not the so much location, but that's not that late light and such.
2:01:16 Voice Mike, perhaps like a Mason, this matter is not a fence with just glasses, not going to be said, you know, they're good stewards and such, but this is the time for the community to have an input for anything.
2:01:42 Because once the approval has been made, I would still, this is the point, but a decision on all of them.
2:02:11 and I live in the vicinity of where that's going to go.
2:02:15 I agree with the people that live back there.
2:02:17 I do believe that we need to have a wall, a cement wall,
2:02:20 not only because of the homes for the quietness,
2:02:23 but they may have animals in the backyard,
2:02:25 and the constant traffic is going to cause barking.
2:02:28 And what do we get called for for our police department?
2:02:31 Barking dogs. People aren't going to appreciate being woke up at one o'clock in the morning with barking dogs.
2:02:36 I, for one, will not. I only live about three blocks from where this is going in.
2:02:40 in. My second concern is entering onto Addison. They have a crosswalk right there in front
2:02:46 of Smiths. If you get your gas at Smiths and try to come out on Addison like he just said,
2:02:51 it can be difficult. I for one will shoot off the side street and do exactly what he just
2:02:56 mentioned. I go down the subdivision, cut back across and jump over to my home versus trying
2:03:02 to make a left hand turn on Addison. So those people in the vicinity where the squares add,
2:03:07 going to go if they turn left out of it and turn right, they're going to go back into
2:03:11 those subdivisions. There's several other areas back in there and there's a lot of houses.
2:03:15 So they're going to be affected till one o'clock in the morning because of it. So I really
2:03:19 think you guys need to look at that. Also, the other problem I had
2:03:23 was where their entrance is. You also have an exit for
2:03:27 SIPs. So you're going to have a traffic issue. People trying to turn
2:03:31 left into their establishment. People trying to come out of SIPs to get
2:03:35 back on to Addison. How many head-on collisions are possible going to happen
2:03:39 with those two entrancees, exeses, right next to each other. That's my only
2:03:45 other concern that I'd really love that you guys look at that and that crosswalking
2:03:49 zone because that's a school crosswalking zone for granted. They're not going to be
2:03:53 there at 10 o'clock at night. They're not going to be there at 1 o'clock in the
2:03:56 morning but you do have a lot of walking in that area going to the grocery store,
2:04:01 going to the gas station so you're still gonna have that crosswalk with cars
2:04:06 coming and going so that's it I support dominoes I currently use the
2:04:09 Washington address when I want pizzas so I'm looking like having it there maybe
2:04:14 I just think you guys need to look at the safety concerns and that's it thanks guys
2:05:08 As a question, prior about what is our screening standard currently, I just wanted to state once
2:07:45 for they need to convince that is at least six feet tall and they can use a variety of different
2:07:55 mediums.
2:07:56 So that's obviously a condition that to be this body sees fit, but we do have that current
2:08:15 standard that is already there.
2:08:18 So please recognize that.
2:08:24 this item that staff can allow you to have an plea discretion to condition this
2:08:30 the decision
2:08:32 you so please
2:08:33 yeah this is the destiny
2:09:08 non-engineer
2:09:09 i don't have a representative here right now
2:09:11 warning side
2:09:12 addison is not here as far as future plan ethics signal or not
2:09:22 can speak to leafless this business was not going to exceed the level of service of any of the roads are adjacent to it
2:09:34 it doesn't go from it
2:09:45 there was no like trap at intersection or anything done as part of this right
2:09:49 Not as part of this is the really key numbers that they said they were generating.
2:09:54 Where somebody's coming to the wonderful city of Twin Falls, I hold the furthest to our findings.
2:10:28 In the last day, a kind of safety mechanism can do the same thing.
2:10:51 Where is this especially used for those discussed and think about this associated with the special use?
2:11:22 More testimony on the Council for...
2:11:30 It has been met by some of our citizenry of the presidential,
2:11:41 not the last or a situation of the subject to the end.
2:12:29 I do Chris Stockington seconded by a great landing to again affirm the commission's initial approval of these special use permit six foot masonry.
2:13:29 He involved in one verse somewhere of this very recently and I know that it plays on his staff on the low keyman and spoke on it to plenty of zoning Dutch Bros moved in.
2:13:58 I'm who likes right next to my condo development, and we actually have the 7-foot masonry fence
2:14:10 behind their business, and then we went in as a condo association, even though it was on their property
2:14:17 we paid for six 20-foot trees, pine trees to be planted on their side of the fence to provide additional sound
2:14:25 barrier. We have found it to be extremely effective. We used to be able to hear
2:14:31 bull legs now we can't because also that provided us the sound barrier from the
2:14:40 plug, stripy and we still occasionally hear a truck or something along that way.
2:14:50 Very supportive of this. I was almost ready to do an amendment to change it to a 7 foot fit
2:14:55 and make sure we're talking about all three of the lots that are east of the
2:15:02 drive in the area there where the fence would be from there fully to those three
2:15:08 lots make sure we're giving protection for all three of those neighbors since they
2:15:15 have control of that obviously they could work with the excellent owner of
2:15:19 that he's property to build that makes sure that I know it's an expense that's
2:15:25 We're concerned about the expanse, but they were willing to know that they because it is a special use for them.
2:15:33 We have the ability to put conditions on that.
2:15:36 I think they have plenty of zoning staff would say that that's maybe something they're looking to it as we do.
2:15:44 Time will stand up.
2:15:45 Maybe that will be the requirement from C1 to residential at some point in the front end future.
2:15:50 So I'm very much in supporting that.
2:15:52 And if there was Council will to move it to 7.
2:15:55 like we talked about, we have found it to be very effective while Mummy not only the noise
2:16:06 from the hoop distance, but the noise from the Walgreens drive through that they have
2:16:11 which is next door to Dutch Bros and the drive through of the businesses on the other side
2:16:17 of Dutch Bros and so I think the neighborhood will find it effective and actually probably
2:16:22 probably block some of the noise that they're hearing now is from SIPs. Addison, read those
2:16:43 can be, I will say, outside of it. So it sounds sick. Six foot, actually seven foot. Always a struggle as a growing community where
2:17:58 business and homeowners are coming together and I feel for the residents of this neighborhood,
2:18:02 but to have a business on Addison that brings a service like this is just I think we're going
2:18:08 to see more and more of it as the city continues to grow. Kind of sad but there's a right off of
2:18:14 of old and Boise, there's a drive-up restaurant, big fun.
2:18:18 That's been loves to go get it.
2:18:21 It's two drive-ins with loudspeakers on both sides
2:18:24 and an outside patio in between,
2:18:27 but until mixed up, which is a resident,
2:18:35 is less than where to protect it.
2:18:41 The neighbors and the restaurant
2:18:42 have learned to work together for the good of the community.
2:18:45 Again, it spills out onto a site,
2:18:47 a site street where there is no traffic signal,
2:18:50 and it's tough to get across overland,
2:18:53 but people who want that food and that service,
2:18:55 they make it work.
2:18:56 They have patients, they get what they want.
2:18:59 As we continue to grow, we're gonna sizzin' home.
2:19:04 I would encourage, like we have with so many other
2:19:07 businesses in this city, that the neighbors
2:19:11 and the business owner get together
2:19:12 and discuss what that fence is gonna look like,
2:19:14 and what that landscape is gonna look like.
2:19:16 And what is in everybody's best interest,
2:19:18 because as Sean said, looking at a brick wall might not.
2:19:22 So I think it's good that we try to go that way,
2:19:27 but I think we need to give some leniencies
2:19:29 for again our citizens who have a lot of common sense in this town to work
2:19:34 together and find a common solution that works for everybody but I am supportive
2:19:38 of having it's an example of some kind of a seven foot wall six foot
2:21:45 a caveat with being them is to make sure that the site triangles are okay at that
2:21:54 intersection of the access point it's from June of 2018
2:22:43 and it's not driving into it.
2:22:45 But the answer to that part, the reason I went with the entire window is I think the big part of it helps
2:23:01 so the machinery wall will be with lighting and as the cars make that turn to come down that lane
2:23:07 they're going to be affecting all three lots there with their lights of their car.
2:23:14 Does a solid cedar fence not also look like?
2:23:17 Not like that machinery wall does.
2:23:20 Look up at the sound, is it noisy?
2:23:33 Diesel trucks did.
2:23:34 Obviously there's one lot in fence, okay?
2:24:13 So, so, not like with slats, like what we're seeing here next to Sibs, is probably
2:24:19 solid-seater fences that already exist.
2:24:27 I would suggest you could- there seems to be disagreement on the-
2:25:53 It's as-
2:25:54 Expedness for Hank, Chris Reed, second of my root, Pierce.
2:25:59 Based on the-
2:26:05 Now I'm stuck in it.
2:26:22 Existing is a six-foot screening thing.
2:26:34 Unsufficient, it might be.
2:26:47 Pass, loot, too.
2:27:31 With slats, that's a little more close.
2:27:33 I don't think any of us think that's enough.
2:27:35 No.
2:27:36 Hold on, this one.
2:27:48 I just- hey, it just doesn't seem like the business owner in it.
2:29:32 Susan Hoggins, Greg Lanting, Pierce?
2:29:37 Yes.
2:29:38 Christopher Reed?
2:29:39 Yes.
2:29:40 And Chris talking to him.
2:29:44 No passes.
2:29:45 I have to choose the amendment.
2:29:54 Motion's.
2:29:58 And then once if you get consensus, if you get...
2:30:47 Us, if that's what was agreed.
2:30:48 Are we saying that's a half-dense?
2:30:58 Some liability to do something in it?
2:31:00 You understand that the person appealing the...
2:31:09 ...space use permit asks for a masonry fence behind his property.
2:31:13 And he's starting to get one with what we're...
2:31:15 ...what we just took out.
2:31:18 I mean, that's what stands right now.
2:31:26 So we can really see what we're doing.
2:31:36 I want to make sure that at least the open part ends up being a fence that is a tight board,
2:31:51 six-foot wood fence, or an equivalent, to opening area.
2:31:58 Now we have an open area, so for something for that, sorry, I'm discussing my motion before I get down with the folks.
2:32:20 My motion was that we, the open area behind the proposed drive-in have at least a six drive-through
2:32:28 have at least a six foot solid fence.
2:32:32 That we're seeing right here, barments, part of those fences, screening requirements.
2:34:52 There is a caveat in that screening, in this instance, there have been times for those owners,
2:35:05 has said it could be satisfied with the notarized type of life.
2:35:18 this we don't have any more information as to the ownership of those we believe
2:35:28 it hasn't said it's a commercial property to satisfy it not residential
2:35:42 to satisfy my estimation it was to be somewhere to what's there I just didn't
2:35:57 want to think you can have a win fence it is offset I would think so
2:36:09 at this point I'm more or I don't know if we're not doing anything but sound
2:36:21 we're at least doing something about chosen I was worried to fence up their
2:36:48 So it doesn't matter
2:39:55 I'll pull it in, I'll pull it in, I'll defer it to you here, here it is.
2:40:04 Okay.
2:40:05 Motion.
2:40:06 So, I'm, I, there's no, no, chain link.
2:40:23 It has to be a something.
2:40:26 I will second that, since I now know that.
2:41:03 I just want to take a little bit of discussion then on the defense thing.
2:41:58 Keep on it.
2:42:14 And Hawkins.
2:42:16 Yes.
2:42:17 Frank Lanting.
2:42:18 Yes.
2:42:19 Bruce Pierce.
2:42:20 Yes.
2:42:21 Christopher Reed.
2:42:22 Yes.
2:42:23 Chris Tockett.
2:42:24 No.
2:42:26 Passes six to one motion is to the decision planning and zoning commission fencing
2:43:08 Rosepiers yes Christopher Reed yes Chris talking to
2:43:23 Sean Burger yes
2:43:40 Process input now I think it's important to mind yourself make a decision that evening say a conversation just like we did
2:44:04 With the Dutch brothers fence
2:44:06 We said to them all parties need to go out
2:44:09 on a solution and present that back.
2:44:14 So just a reminder, when you're going through a public hearing,
2:44:16 your requirement is to go through the public hearing.
2:44:19 If the conclusion of the public hearing,
2:44:20 you can be done for the consequence of that
2:44:24 as you cannot reopen the public posting.
2:44:29 But you also, the benefit is you don't have to try,
2:44:31 guess what the neighbors may or may not.
Download
- Transcript (text) 70 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 91 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 121 KB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, November 18, 2019. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:45:09.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
22129dde2e370f9a04ce744562ef018b7bfa2bbb0cde46285b6bc21f9be1ca1d - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 3 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
68a9776f94fa612fb1619936e45925f625a3f28ba4b9f68fc2560b01dd1b7c1c
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file