OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, November 15, 2021

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: b

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:01:35 Council. At this time I would like to call the meeting to order and confirm that we do have a

0:01:39 Corps of all seven members are here in person this evening. At this time if you would like to

0:01:45 join us please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance. Proclamations this evening so we will move forward

0:02:17 to the consent calendar and I will turn it over to the council. Ruth Pierce. May I move that we

0:02:25 approve the consent calendar as listed. We have a motion from Ruth Pierce seconded by Craig Hawkins

0:02:34 to approve the consent calendar as printed.

0:02:38 Questions? Amy Roll, call vote please.

0:02:44 Hawkins?

0:02:45 Yes.

0:02:46 Christopher Reed?

0:02:47 Yes.

0:02:48 Don Berger?

0:02:49 Yes.

0:02:50 Nicky Boy?

0:02:51 Yes.

0:02:52 Dan Hawkins?

0:02:53 Yes.

0:02:54 Greg Lanting?

0:02:55 Yes.

0:02:56 Yes.

0:02:57 Motion passes 7 to 0.

0:03:01 Aings on motion.

0:03:03 The request to approve the airport ground lease with reader flight service was just approved.

0:03:09 So if you were here for that moving on to items of consideration the first item of this evening is a presentation of the

0:03:22 ESG are

0:03:24 Statement of support and for those who are wondering that is the employer support of the Guard and Reserve

0:03:31 And we have and seen that I say it right all right, please come up and get us started this evening

0:03:39 I believe this is your first presentation

0:03:44 It is my first presentation, so good afternoon, Mayor Hawkins, City Council members.

0:03:52 My name is Anseena Durham, and I am the new organizational development coordinator for

0:03:58 the City, and I just celebrated my one-month anniversary on Veterans Day.

0:04:05 So in the short time, I've had the privilege of working with employees throughout the organization,

0:04:12 And one of the themes, one of the values that has come out has been a commitment, a commitment

0:04:21 to each other.

0:04:23 And that commitment is why I'm actually standing before you today.

0:04:28 I'm going to give you a brief on history before I introduce our guest to you today.

0:04:38 The City of Twin Falls currently has 45 employees that are service members who are veterans that

0:04:48 are employed within the organization of about 45.

0:04:53 Six of those are either deployed or soon to be deployed.

0:04:58 So that's a significant amount.

0:05:02 that the city manager and the employees recognize the guard and the reserve are essential to

0:05:10 the strength of our nation and the well-being of our communities. We are eternally grateful

0:05:17 for the sacrifices that they and their families make every day to defend our freedom. We present

0:05:26 the ESGR Statement of Support in honor of their continued service and commitment to keeping our

0:05:34 nation safe. Please join me in welcoming local ESGR representative Gary Thomas to present the

0:05:44 Statement of Support. Welcome Gary. Thank you very much. Appreciate that introduction. The 1972 when

0:05:56 When our soldiers came home from Vietnam, they expected nothing, and they got nothing.

0:06:03 So the SGR was born as a way to help reintegrate our soldiers and our returning military back

0:06:10 into public working life.

0:06:13 We're seeing the news reports of how poorly our servicemen were treated.

0:06:21 The SGR was bounded determined, so that doesn't happen anymore.

0:06:28 effort is to make sure that our service members, our National Guard and Reserve members, have

0:06:35 their rights under the SARA Act protected, as well as their responsibilities under the

0:06:41 SARA Act taken care of by the service members.

0:06:46 We hope to the non-budsman service to try to take care of issues before they become legal

0:06:54 matters.

0:06:58 We need to try to find a solution.

0:07:04 This GR has outreaches to both military folks as well as employers for education and for recognition.

0:07:12 We have an awards program where military members can nominate their employers for awards.

0:07:20 Some of them are very simple to qualify for.

0:07:25 Some of them take many months and many pages of documentation to qualify for.

0:07:30 I know power I believe was a national or a recipient recently. There's been several in the state of Idaho that takes a very large financial commitment after a realization to qualify for those types of currently the military has one standard of readiness that all of the soldiers have to be ready for.

0:07:55 However, our National Guard and Reserve members are full-time employees of yours, of mine,

0:08:02 and of every of other members of our community, maintain the same readiness level.

0:08:08 So for example, a pilot that is a private citizen, still has to have the same number

0:08:15 of hours in the air as a member of the U.S. Air Force who is on base full-time all day

0:08:22 everyday. That's a real burden on those soldiers to get their additional training

0:08:29 in and they're required. Required trainings and it's the cooperation of

0:08:35 you as employers that help to make that happen. Services are made up about 50

0:08:43 percent active units, active members. The rest of the force is Guard and Reserve.

0:08:49 About half of our military are people who are working full-time jobs as well as

0:08:57 being committed to being battle ready and they're currently on a five-year

0:09:03 rotation. The first year is what we hear about on the TV all the time. One

0:09:11 week in a month, one week a year, go to there and get the field. But the second

0:09:19 year is a little more intense so you'll notice that they're asking for some more

0:09:23 time off on their second year. The third year is even more intense. Fourth year,

0:09:29 they'll often go to a battle simulator in California where they bring in active units

0:09:37 and all their equipment and actually do more games with the home team. And in

0:09:43 the fifth year, they are deployed already for deployment. For the entire year,

0:09:47 employee is unavailable, but at the same time, he's still a kid where he maintains

0:09:54 his seniority, he maintains his, uh, his rights as if he was there. All of that stuff still

0:10:00 accrues for him, even. And that's a real burden on you as employers, to have to replace hopefully

0:10:10 one of your top people, because that's what our military is supposed to be, is the top.

0:10:14 When they're gone, you have to replace him, and when they come back, you have to give

0:10:18 him his job back. So it's a very, very large burden to ask employers to bear, but it's

0:10:24 very important.

0:10:25 Yes, G.R. is.

0:10:28 We all serve.

0:10:29 Personally, I never wore the uniform.

0:10:31 I have bad knees.

0:10:32 They wouldn't let me in.

0:10:34 I have family members who served.

0:10:37 Active service in the military.

0:10:39 But we all serve.

0:10:40 We all make sacrifices.

0:10:42 We all make commitments.

0:10:43 We all have things that we do to support our members.

0:10:46 Some of it is as simple as giving a presentation to the city council.

0:10:52 Some of it is difficult as letting your people go.

0:11:02 So we've been requested to provide a statement of support, which I have here on the table.

0:11:09 This is a document that says that Twin Falls City Council is on board with supporting the

0:11:17 military and the mission of our National Guard and Reserve.

0:11:25 It's really a confirmation that you are an American patriot and that you believe in what

0:11:32 our country and our military has done is for.

0:11:34 We might have some questions or comments for you, so duck away, Greg Landteep.

0:11:45 Thank you.

0:11:46 Well, thank you for the explanation.

0:11:47 I spent 10 years in the cards, and I don't think I was ever that intense during any of that time.

0:11:53 So, I appreciate that getting a little more additional information on what our card reserve members are expected of.

0:12:02 Craig maybe had a little more. He was a little later than I was in it.

0:12:05 But I appreciate that explanation. I spent 10 years between the air guard and the armor guard, so I got a little taste of both, but never was it that much detail, so appreciate it. Thank you.

0:12:17 That training schedule has just been in the last 10 or 12 years that they've limited that five-year cycle of trying to keep the regiment a unit, a group of soldiers ready to deploy at any time.

0:12:32 The one-sixteenth replacement reinforcements for the other question to comment to have Craig

0:12:51 I just wanted to thank you all so as a veteran. I was employed by another state at the time and

0:13:00 Was told then if I re-up that I would never get promoted, so I'm glad to see that things are happening

0:13:06 picture so

0:13:18 Yeah, we could if we could have

0:13:24 The mayor and vice mayor if you'd like to come down and pull a thredgion right in front of the dias with Gary

0:13:30 and then have the rest of council will bunch together on the center.

0:14:52 We to start the e-bar agenda is a request to confirm the appointment of Tim Hayford to the Public Arts Commission.

0:15:08 And I think we have Wendy Davis, we have Sean and myself. Sean, since you've got liaison to you,

0:15:14 I want to take the first stab at it and then I'll weigh in from there.

0:15:17 Sure, I would be happy to thank you.

0:15:20 Commission was established two years ago, time sure flies.

0:15:33 We initially appointed seven members since it was a new commission.

0:15:38 We had staggered terms and a couple of those terms expired just in the last couple of months.

0:15:44 One of the folks who had been serving, Libby Barrett served one year term and it's moved

0:15:50 out of the area so it's not live for reappointments.

0:15:53 We Parks and Recreation Department put information out for applications for the Commission Bank

0:15:59 and see, and we had eight applicants, which was very exciting to see, a very well qualified

0:16:05 group of candidates.

0:16:07 We conducted interviews that included the mayor, myself, and Parks and Recreation Director

0:16:11 Winnie Davis.

0:16:12 I interviewed all eight of those candidates following those interviews.

0:16:17 We are recommending that Tim Hayfur be appointed to fill the Commission opening.

0:16:25 Tim has completed his background check with the Mayor's appointment and the Council's approval.

0:16:31 I would start that term at the next Commission meeting in December.

0:16:35 I would just say Tim certainly shared an enthusiasm and interest in the work of the Public Art Commission.

0:16:41 understanding it's been a little bit of time as we've been establishing a mission vision

0:16:47 sort of some direction for that that group and I think he will be. I just want to add

0:16:58 that we did do all and Tim just brought a different level of enthusiasm and I think this

0:17:07 commission is gonna be pushed a little and stretched a little and I think that's a good

0:17:11 thing and some of his ideas for what he sees as public art in our community were

0:17:17 We're really asking the rest of us to think about some things maybe we hadn't considered before.

0:17:22 And so seeing where this commission goes over the next few years and how this comes together,

0:17:27 I'm excited to watch from the Leachers and see.

0:17:31 And Tim is here this evening, if anybody has any questions or comments for him,

0:17:35 but it was a very robust interview process.

0:17:39 And I think this commission is going to really great things for us.

0:17:49 No one with questions for Tim. So Sean, if you would like to make a motion.

0:17:52 Yes, I would move to the public.

0:18:02 I'll second that.

0:18:03 We have a motion from Sean Berger, seconded by Ruth Pierce,

0:18:07 to confirm the appointment of Tim Berger to the Public Arts Commission.

0:18:12 Andy Roll, call up please.

0:18:14 Christopher Reed.

0:18:16 Yes.

0:18:17 Sean Berger.

0:18:18 Yes.

0:18:18 Icky Boyd.

0:18:19 North.

0:18:20 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:18:21 Yes.

0:18:21 Ray Clanty.

0:18:22 Yes.

0:18:23 Ruth Pierce.

0:18:23 Yes.

0:18:24 Anne Craig Hawkins.

0:18:25 Yes.

0:18:26 Motion passes seven to zero.

0:18:28 Thank you and thank you for your willingness to serve.

0:18:31 And I'm sure Wendy or Sean will be getting you all the information

0:18:35 you need to get you ready for that first meeting.

0:18:37 Thank you.

0:18:38 Next on our agenda is a request to approve an air service consulting

0:18:45 contract with all air aviation and utilize up to $30,000

0:18:50 from unbudgeted airport reserve funds for associated services.

0:18:55 and we have Bill Carvary, our airport manager.

0:18:58 Thank you, Mayor, and good evening, Council.

0:19:02 So recently, SkyWest has decided to reduce

0:19:07 Delta flights to Salt Lake and eliminate the United

0:19:11 Flight to Denver.

0:19:14 So with the economic disruptions and imbalances

0:19:17 created by the pandemic, airlines, SkyWest included.

0:19:24 They've been challenged with the network, their fleets,

0:19:26 and their resources.

0:19:28 The reductions we've seen recently have come as a product of reduced high yields.

0:19:34 They talk about the business travel or not returning the average fares being down.

0:19:40 And also the network capacity demand has been outpacing airline resources.

0:19:45 And what do I mean by that?

0:19:48 You've probably seen in the news the disruptions in airline service,

0:19:52 the displacement of cruise, airplanes, things, reasons being like weather,

0:19:58 air traffic control, you hear the whole menu of ideas of the operational disruptions, but

0:20:04 really one of the underlying things that's happening in the industry is labor shortage

0:20:09 and particularly with airline crews.

0:20:11 So this really creates that imbalance in the system with the demand really outpacing the

0:20:17 resources that can be provided.

0:20:20 One of the things that is probably not well known or hardly understood about our relationship

0:20:27 with our 40-year partnership with SkyWest Airlines, is that they have two business models that

0:20:33 they use.

0:20:34 The majority of their business model with the major airlines like Delta United, American,

0:20:38 Alaska are fixed fee contract flights where the major calls them up says, hey, would you

0:20:45 fly so many routes on a certain schedule to a city will pay for your costs plus a percentage

0:20:51 of profits of its, it's sort of a fixed fee arrangement.

0:20:55 probably 90% of their business model, 10% of their business model, are these at-risk markets

0:21:03 or pro-rate markets where they go out, they put up the risk for the cost benefit reward

0:21:10 of running the route, and we've had that relationship probably for at least 20 years in our community

0:21:16 primarily with Delta.

0:21:18 So you can imagine an environment where you're scratched for resources, where you would go

0:21:24 to look to try to procure resources.

0:21:26 So it's not unusual that we're seeing these drawdowns,

0:21:30 particularly during these times of imbalances

0:21:32 I've tried to describe.

0:21:34 So with that, we've got the one flight on Delta.

0:21:38 We're hearing, we'll get a second flight in the spring,

0:21:40 as things pick up seasonally with the spring.

0:21:43 We certainly hope so for that.

0:21:45 But I think it's time, and I've discussed

0:21:47 with community officials and officials in our organization

0:21:50 about procuring the assistance of air service consultants.

0:21:54 And we've always had a long history of working with consultants on again and off again through

0:22:00 different planning processes and things like that at T-Airport.

0:22:03 The most recent we work with Mark 6, back in 2017 to 2020, where we led up to the winning

0:22:10 application on the small community air service development ground and the rollout of the United

0:22:15 Service, the performers that we did, the business cases that we did that really led

0:22:19 to those excellent opportunities that came our way, unfortunately Mark passed away in Europe

0:22:25 about a year ago. So we're I'm out looking for a different consultant. I've had a dialogue for a

0:22:31 long-term term with this group, Vollari, which is an excellent group in our region and they've got

0:22:38 excellent folks that work for them. So with that, I've gotten with them. They've provided me with a

0:22:44 general contract that has different tasks involved with it and we'll do a

0:22:50 task order type of relationship as we use a menu, a different menu, all a card

0:22:55 approach with their services. So really the first order of business with our

0:23:00 discussions has been to try to approach Delta directly and United

0:23:05 directly to potentially look at our routes, see what they're missing if you

0:23:09 will, to tell our story, give them the pro formers, really make the business

0:23:14 case of why these flights should be increased on the delta side and although

0:23:21 I don't seek Denver coming back overnight perhaps in time a couple of

0:23:25 years goes by the economic climate changes we certainly want to leave a

0:23:29 placeholder for that opportunity to see a return of service to that hub so so

0:23:34 with that I've attached a contract for review you can see it's very simple and

0:23:38 With your approval tonight, I'd like to sign that and also with us being an on-budgeted expense

0:23:45 I'd like to request

0:23:47 30 up to $30,000 for airports or funding to fund that work as we see fit to

0:23:55 Happy to answer any questions

0:24:01 I have two questions for you and this might be a little bit challenging

0:24:06 What are other airports our size doing right now?

0:24:08 Are they going out and trying to seek consultants to figure out what to do, those that have lost

0:24:13 service in their area?

0:24:16 Yes, that's certainly one of the things you can do.

0:24:19 They're looking, communities are looking certainly at the small community air service development program down the road.

0:24:25 Can they get a winning application?

0:24:27 Can they get an airline to sign on?

0:24:29 They're looking at minimum revenue guarantees that their community can generate to support air service.

0:24:35 potentially they're looking at a host of things marketing,

0:24:38 assistance to help ramp up any new service,

0:24:42 and that's certainly something I think our community

0:24:45 has looked at, I know it has looked at it again,

0:24:47 if we do get a new entrant or a new route,

0:24:50 we certainly want to support that.

0:24:51 So those are the types of things they do,

0:24:54 build that business case, visit with them,

0:24:56 have those conversations with the airlines,

0:24:58 those are the old things you try to do,

0:25:01 sort of bring in that service.

0:25:02 and does this hurt our current contract with Sky West

0:25:05 or anybody that worked with?

0:25:07 No, in fact, they've encouraged me

0:25:10 to prepare for those conversations,

0:25:13 have those conversations if Delta calls them

0:25:16 and says, hey, we're thinking of maybe changing the structure

0:25:19 and changing this to a contract route.

0:25:21 I think that would probably fall right in line

0:25:24 with the things that they're a little bit more ambitious

0:25:26 about these days.

0:25:29 Ruth, there's...

0:25:30 So, Bill, the contract that looks as good

0:25:32 through the end of 2022.

0:25:34 What's your expectation on that timeframe?

0:25:39 When might we get some information next?

0:25:43 I think we'll be working on our business case

0:25:46 the next month or two, hoping to get on the calendar

0:25:50 with Delta and United here towards the end of the year.

0:25:53 We're the turn of the new year.

0:25:54 Okay.

0:25:55 We have those conversations.

0:25:56 Thank you.

0:26:05 Yes, Bill.

0:26:07 Who knows we're using this out of a budget

0:26:09 reserve funds. A lot of the funds we use for matches and thanks with federal government

0:26:16 improvements they make most of it comes from passenger fees or we have enough

0:26:20 cushion there and passenger fees to go forth with some of these processes that we would

0:26:25 like to do that the government pays like 93 and we pay the difference. I don't think that these

0:26:32 planning studies this type of work would be eligible for a passenger facility charge you

0:26:38 Okay, so for that or do if we have additional offers from the federal government do we have enough money in the passenger fees that's that's obviously not going to grow like it has I would assume.

0:26:52 Yeah we'll see a decline as we see declining seats in the market we'll see declining passenger facility chargers.

0:26:58 There's certainly some cushion there, and really reserves are sort of a kiss and cousin,

0:27:03 if you will, when it comes to match.

0:27:05 We've gotten some cares funding and things like that that's helped our reserve grow healthier,

0:27:10 so I think it wouldn't be out of line to use those reserve funding for match if that's

0:27:14 how the finances work out at some point.

0:27:18 Right.

0:27:22 Thank you Bill.

0:27:27 Right.

0:27:28 The air service consulting contract with all air, aviation, and utilize up to $30,000 of

0:27:33 budgeted airport reserve funds for associate for associated services.

0:27:39 Second.

0:27:41 I have a motion from Christopher Reed, seconded by Sean Barreker to approve the request as

0:27:48 presented including the funding.

0:27:51 Yes.

0:27:57 Niggans, yes.

0:28:00 Great landing.

0:28:01 Yes.

0:28:02 Ruth Pierce.

0:28:03 Yes.

0:28:04 Great Hawkins.

0:28:05 Yes.

0:28:06 Christopher Reed.

0:28:07 Yes.

0:28:08 Motion passes 7-0.

0:28:09 Thank you.

0:28:12 Thank you, Mayor.

0:28:13 Thank you, Count.

0:28:14 to utilize wastewater reserves for installation of the boiler at the wastewater treatment plant

0:28:21 and we have troy vtech this evening council members for you this evening i'm asking

0:28:33 dropped wastewater treatment plant the existing boilers have been serviced and certainly

0:28:44 it's a very harsh environment on september 13th i came before the call mass to be able to discuss

0:29:01 this with jenkins and install a new voice place analysis and go and actually install this we have

0:29:13 We have to bring them. So the way these boilers goes into them and bugs eat that.

0:29:27 They essentially go to sleep and yes. So it comes originally and safe for everybody

0:30:35 in finance and I reserve the available for any dancer.

0:31:00 That's the project's go. And I understand that things come up and we run into these situations,

0:31:07 but this will caught me off guard when I run it over the weekend.

0:31:12 It caught me off too.

0:31:13 There's no other options. I mean, have we stepped back and looked at this to see,

0:31:18 Is there a way to do this and still meet code and maybe not quite goal for budget on the

0:31:27 side of so far?

0:31:28 So there is additional work in there.

0:31:30 I'm supposed to work in some computer programming in there as well as contingency.

0:31:35 So the height is that large number.

0:31:38 The work itself is estimated by 854,000.

0:31:42 So the total cost per the people in that have some to be necessary to ventilize these things.

0:32:06 The option would be to postpone it, but as you extend over time, we'll continue to have a piece of equipment for us.

0:32:35 The facility is kind of like a house, right?

0:32:50 You can replace the kitchen sink and then you get some plants sheets and don't do this as well.

0:33:19 So, if I understand this correctly, we budgeted 800.

0:33:31 We're looking at a million, just shy of a million four.

0:33:35 You're saying that the some of the additional cost is

0:33:43 different

0:33:44 Is in addition to what we originally thought it was going to be is all right

0:33:57 We've expanded a little bit of that

0:34:21 this year.

0:34:22 I'm going to say, how does that happen?

0:34:24 How does that happen?

0:34:28 How does that happen?

0:34:29 Okay.

0:34:30 And when you say adequate reserves, what do we have left after we do this?

0:34:35 If we were to do this, do we have any idea?

0:34:37 So currently pre-audit, we're sitting on about $16 million in sewer fund reserves.

0:34:43 Thank you.

0:34:44 Great.

0:34:47 Cockheads.

0:34:50 What's the life expectancy on this?

0:34:52 The last one lasted for over 20 years or somewhere?

0:34:55 40 years.

0:34:56 40 years.

0:34:57 I think that how you expect that on this one.

0:35:00 Yes, I would believe the same thing. Jacob's does a fantastic job at managing the waste water treatment plan.

0:35:06 Get to with that. So I would expect about the same.

0:35:09 It seems to me that I'm shocking.

0:35:18 Well, that does equate to 35,000 a year. Over a 40-year period. 1.4 is for each.

0:35:31 I just go over the numbers real quick with you.

0:35:35 Okay, so, started out of $1,800,000, I'm just going off of the numbers in the packet real quick, okay?

0:35:44 The revised estimate is $1,123,550, which includes installation programming,

0:35:55 and then a 10% contingency on that, which that's going to bring us up to $1,392,630.

0:36:06 This is the 1.4 I'm guessing. Yes, okay, but we've purchased the boiler and so that's we're taking that

0:36:17 Which it was two hundred and sixty nine thousand one hundred and fifteen dollars. That's correct. We're subtracting that from that total. Yes, though

0:36:25 budgeted

0:36:27 800,000 when the project's completed is gonna be one million three hundred ninety two thousand

0:36:33 $630 is about $600,000 over.

0:36:38 That's correct.

0:36:48 Appreciate your attention.

0:36:50 I know it's not easy and I know we're all kind of struggling with.

0:36:54 This is not typical for us to have something come back with this kind of a price tag difference.

0:37:00 I think everybody does understand the necessity.

0:37:03 It is a very large amount of money and it is a difficult concept sometimes when these things are brought back to us.

0:37:14 But the next steps for me is if you guys approve this, I would go forward with it and then at that time when we miss, I'll have to give you.

0:37:51 So part of our process was not described during the budget process.

0:37:57 Come to the City Council to ask for the use of cash reserves.

0:38:01 That's what Troy is doing this evening.

0:38:04 As to reserve gives him the assurance that he has the available resources to go out a bit so that we're pitting in good faith

0:38:19 in response a bit to the city council for its approval and that is the ultimate number but basically we're using an

0:38:31 Injuring estimate based upon the probable cause so that Troy is assured that he has

0:38:36 the council supporting going out and pitting.

0:38:38 All things we and what they are today if that comes back at a higher number the

0:38:45 counts still has the right to reject the bid at that point correct that is correct

0:38:49 great did you have another question I'm not sure what the motion would be to be

0:39:00 asked will you I know you thought they'd snap here I move the to you prove that

0:39:05 use of reserve funds from the wastewater account to make up the difference between

0:39:13 the original estimated there are 54,000 eight here one dollars to a possible high

0:39:19 level of the number of 1,300, 19,630, which will come from some that was rolled over as well as some new reserves.

0:39:29 That close enough. I think that covers it.

0:39:40 I have a motion from Gertin, seconded by Craig Hawkins, and I'm going to summarize as to approve the request as presented.

0:39:48 Thank you, Boyd. Yes.

0:39:52 Exact Hawkins. Yes.

0:39:54 Greg Lanting. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes.

0:39:56 Greg Hawkins. Yes. Christopher Reed. Yes.

0:39:59 And Sean Berger. Yes. Well, she passes seven to zero.

0:40:02 Thank you, Troy, for staying on that project.

0:40:05 Next, we have Wendy Davis and Troy BTech coming back to help with the update of the show.

0:40:14 Falls, grade, road. Good evening, Mayor and Council.

0:40:27 So last year, you used some of your council-directed capital funds to conduct a study of the social

0:40:41 and false-grade road, looking at options on what we could do to make some improvements

0:40:46 down there.

0:40:47 That study, I'm really just trying to give you a visual because I don't want you doing

0:41:15 any math.

0:41:16 I want to give you the numbers, so I'm just going to do that.

0:41:22 So we put $300,000 and we were looking at things like the roads narrow, it's difficult

0:41:32 for large vehicles to pass.

0:41:36 We need to do some repairs down there.

0:41:38 That road is failing, the asphalt is failing, there's areas where it's in the shade and

0:41:44 so the freezing and thawing creates potholes.

0:41:49 intersection of Derke's Road and Social Falls Grade where it makes that kind of

0:41:55 why. So if you're coming down, you've got a really difficult merge onto that road

0:42:00 and also looking at some pedestrian options. So we put it out and negotiate a

0:42:09 contract with JUBE to complete the evaluation of the existing Social

0:42:13 Falls Grade and Derke's Lake Road and have them come back with some

0:42:17 recommendations and then develop a construction plan. And so I'm going to

0:42:22 turn it over to Troy and he's going to share with you the progress that they've

0:42:26 made on this project. The streets department, Parks Department myself, just for

0:42:49 reference here, this is the ticket booth at the top end of that county road, so we own

0:42:53 an over to Durkey from Falls Grade. The project, which has have learned

0:43:05 green grades and now shush on Falls Grade, is on the south side of the canyon

0:43:10 winter where there's large amounts of water walk this or drove this and see the

0:43:16 springs that come through here and we're in asphalt and winter situation has no

0:43:24 sum on it doesn't make very well it causes that asphalt to fall pretty

0:43:28 solid type so we walked it and he's nice to pull up but I believe a lot more to as

0:45:35 well as reconstruction that's relevant at the design for this because there is a

0:45:51 connect on this area there's a little draw through there we could essentially connect

0:46:07 most space here, 32 expense of everything here is so we have $300,000

0:46:25 associated with this project this year or something my is on drive before years,

0:46:50 right? So we've tried to personalize out how can we reduce the cost and so

0:46:57 options we have there's a wrong shot to you.

0:48:40 So there's my continue on the current slide. There we go. Okay, so they came back with four

0:48:54 recommendations, four phases actually, which would include the rock removal of that point.

0:49:02 The road rebuild from Shoshone Falls Grade to the ticket booth down to just above the boat ramp.

0:49:08 There was some major improvements done down actually in the parks, so this would be kind

0:49:15 of where that connects, and then the boat ramp is different, so 2.6 million to rebuild

0:49:23 the road.

0:49:24 They gave us a bike pedestrian connectivity phase that's about 342,000, and then the

0:49:34 the Grand Park Road reconstruction, which is that section that goes down into the river

0:49:39 part of the reservoir above the river at 215,000 for a total project estimate of 3.4.

0:49:46 So this year in Long-Term Planning, the $300,000 was allocated for the rock removal, but my concern

0:49:57 was I wasn't sure you've been brought up to speed on the results of this conversation,

0:50:03 And I didn't want to just start blasting the canyon without talking to you to see how you

0:50:08 felt about that.

0:50:09 So that's what we're here tonight to talk about.

0:50:12 So as we talked about the concerns that we had presented in the beginning, the narrow

0:50:17 road, the widening of the road would be accomplished by removing the rock overhang and piping that

0:50:27 ditch along the side.

0:50:30 repairs the rebuild would obviously help with the damage that's occurring

0:50:37 constantly to that road bit as Troy had told me, said it's not going to completely

0:50:41 fix it, it'll help it if we can, but this is kind of a mill and rebuild which

0:50:50 would, if you see it'll close it down for a month or longer, so the particle would

0:50:58 of how to be close for three months,

0:51:00 or at least parts of the access to the facility

0:51:04 to rebuild the road.

0:51:07 We can fix that, difficult intersection, as Troy mentioned,

0:51:11 and we could look at building the pedestrian path

0:51:16 that they were able to find.

0:51:17 And Durkys Road, there's space, you know,

0:51:20 it's not, you don't have cliff on one side

0:51:23 and Canyon Mall on the other as much.

0:51:25 So there's a little more space to add additional

0:51:28 pedestrian paths. I just wanted, I went down today and it was Sunday this morning

0:51:36 but it was in the shadows and then when I went down a little bit later it was cloudy,

0:51:39 but this is the drainage area and I don't know exactly what it would look like but

0:51:48 I just want to kind of give you a visual of what it would, what we're talking about

0:51:52 piping. So this would probably all the green here would probably be gone. You'd

0:51:57 have some sort of a pipe on gravel over the top that would bring it up to the edge and that

0:52:03 includes this area down in here where you've got the waterfall coming down. I don't know

0:52:09 how that would fit into it exactly, but that's kind of the area they're talking about. We

0:52:13 would need to pipe in order to widen the road. The rock to be removed is this jump right

0:52:22 hear that's sticking out. And on the drawing you see that he showed the area to

0:52:30 come off and I had suggested that maybe Troy and I go out there and try to put a

0:52:34 flag there or something to show you about how far back it needs to come and I'm

0:52:38 not exactly sure how much would come off. I took a couple of shots on the road to

0:52:47 see it but then I also went down into the park and just this middle picture is

0:52:52 is the section of Ken and Wall that we're talking about removing to create this access.

0:53:04 Here's the Y in the road, and you can also from this picture kind of see the general condition

0:53:10 of the road, and it's obviously like this all the way down, potholes and patches and

0:53:16 things that just make it kind of a challenge.

0:53:21 So just to kind of give you a visual of what we're talking about, I think some of the things

0:53:26 that we need to consider here is the fact that the total project is 3.4 million and even raising

0:53:34 the price or the vehicle admission or vehicle access fee from $3 to $5, we're not going to

0:53:41 get to 3.4 million very quickly and by the time we get there I don't know what it will

0:53:45 cost but you know this is something we would need to really give some thought to how to

0:53:50 do the full project.

0:53:52 I think if there's a little bit of thinking that needs to be done about what's the ultimate

0:53:57 goal, do we want to repair the road, do we need to widen it, what are we trying to do

0:54:03 here, and obviously there's some pieces of the phased approach we could take a look at,

0:54:10 but I really am looking for some guidance on the $300,000 of this budget this year and whether

0:54:18 that there's support for glassing the canyon wall.

0:54:22 So that's kind of the thought here.

0:54:26 I did give a little bit of thought to alternatives,

0:54:28 and trying I talked a little bit about what we could do.

0:54:31 So if we don't widen the road, right now people

0:54:37 just navigate it, and some people complain,

0:54:39 and most people figured out, and it's a little scary.

0:54:43 We could ban vehicles of a certain size or larger

0:54:47 from traveling down that road.

0:54:49 And, you know, we could figure out kind of what the height

0:54:53 and length ought to be.

0:54:55 And remember that the road was built for Model T's

0:54:57 and not for motor homes and tour buses.

0:55:01 We could control the large vehicle.

0:55:03 And they kind of tried to right now at the ticket booth.

0:55:05 So when they have a big vehicle coming down,

0:55:07 they'll radio down to the security down there

0:55:14 and try to stop their pill traffic

0:55:15 so that the big break can get down.

0:55:17 And you don't have to try to pass.

0:55:19 because if they wind up at that choke point,

0:55:22 it's a difficult pass if you're trying to pass it

0:55:26 to a bus or something.

0:55:29 So we've tried that.

0:55:30 Another thing we could look at is maybe a light.

0:55:32 There's been some discussion about a mirror.

0:55:34 I've heard that mirrors aren't as effective,

0:55:36 but that maybe a light like they do down up the lakes

0:55:39 that we could maybe put a light that gets a green

0:55:41 and a red to stop uphill and downhill traffic.

0:55:46 We can obviously continue to patch the road.

0:55:49 And then as we talked about the 300,000 which was earmarked for the rock removal, we could shift it toward pedestrian improvements right now.

0:56:00 We could use the 300,000 to finish some of the design work that needs to be done on the ADA upgrades that we were doing down at Durkeys last year,

0:56:10 that we weren't able to complete because we didn't have the parking lot and the access road yet.

0:56:15 So, those are kind of the ingredients, and I'm just looking for a little guide to how

0:56:25 you feel about receding, now that you have some recommendations.

0:56:32 And Troy and I are here for questions, we can go back to pictures, back up those numbers

0:56:43 if you want to see the different phase costs.

0:56:46 Please greet at an update to this item, so I'm not sure if you guys are logging in to

0:56:55 talk on the previous item where this one but I have a great name I can see.

0:56:58 Hey Chris.

0:57:06 Like, the honest, that is a good idea.

0:57:36 Maybe this is the only option to have some time to f*** is permanent, you know, good at

0:57:46 those things back up.

0:57:47 It's going to change the look for sure, yeah.

0:57:49 So, right now I'm not comfortable with the honest, there are options where to spend those

0:57:57 funds and maybe other folks have some thoughts on that but-

0:58:02 And that could certainly be some direction that you guys give us that we take a little

0:58:05 deep for dive into what we can do instead.

0:58:07 I'm not in favor of blasting.

0:58:09 So I think when we were initially having some of this discussion, at least in my mind,

0:58:22 I thought that part of this analysis was going to be potentially rerouting the roadway as opposed to

0:58:28 figuring out how to widen.

0:58:30 And while I certainly appreciate their complexities of wetlands and such,

0:58:35 that was some of that away to get rid of.

0:58:46 Maybe that's a question that Troy could speak to.

0:58:49 So they did look at that cross, essentially in this area, there's still a large elevation

0:58:54 difference on this side.

0:58:55 If you're going to bring it down, the reason we're bringing this to you at this time of

0:59:12 year is if due to this sort of fall of a thing, our goal was to have it next year's

0:59:20 busy season happens, and so we projected stuff and get it out close to the peak of

0:59:28 season.

0:59:52 I guess the whole of the presentation tonight, I guess the negation seems to be such a miniscule

1:00:04 piece of the bigger picture that you do maybe doesn't make the greatest sense to me that while that's a chunk we seem to be able to afford and take that by what you solve is one not way this is determined to be the worst point right I mean that's obviously the worst.

1:00:32 And again, I'm not saying that it's not something that needs to be addressed if you have the luxury of 3.4 million dollars to do the whole shoot match, that would be the first thing to do, but to do that, and then say, and will never be able to do any of the other pieces of this seems to be, well then why bother doing that piece.

1:00:49 I guess understanding sort of the way to try to piece this up, if possible.

1:00:54 I would be more enthusiastic about the creation of the pedestrian accessibility.

1:00:59 There's like, or if someone else would like to do funds maybe through the remnants of those notion of connectivity.

1:01:20 Well, some people rumble a complexity of the road with most figure out.

1:01:38 So, certainly could have some safety improvements. It doesn't seem to be posing an extreme hazard

1:01:59 basis. So, it's good to have the big picture. I guess in my mind, I didn't expect it to be cheap.

1:02:10 I also felt that price tag. You would see more up some winners. It creates some widening, but it doesn't

1:02:30 across them thaw cycles, it doesn't eliminate migration into the road.

1:02:41 So if I had to choose inner thousand dollars off of this initially, I'd like to see that 300,000 have we spent with JUVV at this far.

1:03:00 Last year we had 300,000 for the ADA upgrades down at Durkeys, and we probably spent 50,000, 60,000 on sidewalks.

1:03:12 We had an additional 300 that was allocated by you guys last year and that will all get

1:03:24 spent as we complete the study.

1:03:29 This year we budget an additional 300,000 toward the rock foam mitigation is what it was tagged

1:03:36 as.

1:03:37 So the 3,000 for this study?

1:03:41 Yes, the council directed 300,000 out of your...

1:03:45 I'm now paid for this study, 100,000.

1:03:53 Just all of a sudden seems like a lot of money for this.

1:03:57 So, yeah, just trying to wrap my head around it, yeah.

1:04:04 Almost like he should have started with this one and then gone to the...

1:04:08 I was thinking I didn't really like the way he tried it.

1:04:12 I was like wait for him to pump. I was like oh great. I guess it's just a

1:04:19 night of sticker shock for everybody.

1:04:21 It doesn't okay.

1:04:27 Oh uh oh so can we go back to the pipe? It's a picture for a second just a question.

1:04:44 So there and then the next one you can see and that's part where the pipe portion is

1:05:00 projected to be how much?

1:05:01 So that is included on that 2.6. It is part of that roadway portion.

1:05:07 So is it possible to take care of that? We can wear, we can keep reeking in smaller and smaller projects.

1:05:19 I was just thinking if that helped keep the road from being so damaged.

1:05:23 Yes, getting the drainage off of it would be out. Seriously, we haven't broken it up into segments to see how it is.

1:05:30 I just eat your guys' feelings on one project, but do we spend on over several years?

1:05:42 And that cost increase because we're still looking at the best way to provide this is to do it.

1:05:51 I am so ready on the shelf. I mean, this job here, so if there is a grand opportunity that comes up,

1:06:07 it's the best use of the money you have feelings on it.

1:06:15 The years I envisioned there would be a bridge over those wetlands.

1:06:28 I've envisioned that. Is it just so cost prohibitive?

1:06:33 Unfortunately, and then you start talking maintenance is so many bridge over 20 feet you have to go through a process every year

1:06:41 or every years I believe to do inspections on it to make sure it's state standards that cost of it would be considerable.

1:06:51 It isn't the right thing to do for long term. This is a long term asset.

1:06:58 I think it's difficult so the place on the other side is also elevated and then you've got to get from the area.

1:07:08 So, it's not just a bridge, is it?

1:07:15 Is it, does it endanger the wetlands, are we, do we have a, some kind of a...

1:07:22 And you do have to stay out of wetlands.

1:07:24 Right. So, is that the prohibitive piece and what makes the bridge so expensive?

1:07:30 No, it's just the cost of designing and building.

1:07:45 The picture is in the middle. It's just as the wetlands looking back up to that point where we're talking about me.

1:07:53 So that gives you an idea of the elevation change.

1:07:57 Without white you can see is the concrete barrier that's up at the road.

1:08:04 Just for perspective.

1:08:06 Great landing.

1:08:10 I'm a frequent user of the park for real life.

1:08:23 It seems like I'm proud of yours.

1:08:26 We've got 35 trips down there a year.

1:08:29 I'm well acquainted with that quarter.

1:08:33 And believe it or not, it's whiter now than it was on wear kits.

1:08:36 I mean, I'm a bit whiter. It was used to be definitely a one car around that corner. No one can ever think about passing.

1:08:45 I guess I'm more because I've hit a deck corner for 60 years here. I'm more of a line of this. We can make that corner better.

1:08:55 Because I don't see us coming up with 3.4 million to do the rest of the time in the near future

1:09:01 At least we can make that improvement and make it safer. So I'm gonna be an outlier on the use of the rock fault money

1:09:11 I agree with the

1:09:14 The rock fault plus pipe some of that that's turn up the road. I would

1:09:19 see that

1:09:22 helpful because it is a rough ride downer and

1:09:26 I said I've had to go around the corner for my entire life, and I'd say put you

1:09:36 out of your heart every time, and I can't believe we haven't had more. There's been a few vehicles over the year in and up in that wetlands, and I can't

1:09:44 believe we have had more. Of course, a barrier helps, we didn't used to have the barrier. And that's probably when the cars used to go into the wetlands, but that's

1:09:53 I'm aware I'm aware you said the rough out money.

1:09:57 Clarification this evening.

1:10:06 This being just an update.

1:10:08 You're just...

1:10:13 I made it an actual item if you choose...

1:10:17 If you were to come to Consensus and give us some direction.

1:10:21 I wasn't sure how this would go, but...

1:10:33 So we felt it was important to update you,

1:10:37 a project that the council was pretty passionate about early there is a level of

1:10:48 concern over cost, demonstrate tonight but also demonstrate at the staff level when we

1:10:54 were having the conversation and what we shared was internally we have an obligation to share this

1:10:59 with the city council even if it's what we had hoped the numbers would turn out to be decision

1:11:09 this evening because it's listed as an action item does not mean that you should feel compelled

1:11:14 to take an action. A part of that action could be give us some time to think about this. Staff,

1:11:21 why don't you go back and take what you've heard, process that in some period with some potential

1:11:31 alternatives. Either a stopgap solution would be at the traffic signal type light that is at the

1:11:41 Blue X country club. Is that something that, like for us to explore in terms of cost, in terms of

1:11:48 is that something that is just a non-starter?

1:11:52 And you have to come up with those.

1:11:55 I'm just kind of an idea that was different than way

1:12:00 piece of thumb that was presented this evening.

1:12:04 In a position to share anything, and you might say,

1:12:11 give us a little bit digest and process this

1:12:14 and bring this back to us, that is certainly

1:12:20 about $300,000 that has been allocated to the project,

1:12:28 Does not need to be spent on occasion, which is reversed and which it was because she's not too

1:12:51 You guys, almost near Mrs. How many? I know that's a crazy turn, but isn't that just part of the drive going down there?

1:13:04 I think we had one. One.

1:13:07 That's the first one that I've truly gotten that somebody said, Hey, this is dangerous. I was terrified. You need to do something about it.

1:13:19 And that was one last season.

1:13:22 So now that person, the next time they go down there,

1:13:25 they'll be mentally prepared and won't be quite as terrifying.

1:13:29 I don't mean to be callous, but I really feel like that's part of the amenity,

1:13:36 that's part of the asset, that's part of could we make it better?

1:13:39 Yeah, if we have $20 million, we do a lot of really cool stuff down there.

1:13:43 But that's the way it is, and that's the way it's always been improved since great was a kid.

1:13:48 So, yeah, that's quite a while, right, great?

1:13:50 So, I'm trying to figure out why we would spend,

1:13:58 if we had 300,000, why we would spend any money on,

1:14:04 trying to fix that, make that feel safer to certain people

1:14:08 when 100,000 isn't very much money, but it would be a whole lot

1:14:12 if we added it to something else to do, something that's a real change.

1:14:17 So, I don't know, spending money on a study for that or putting in a test light or whatever.

1:14:24 I would be interested in wasting a dime on that.

1:14:28 Does Rock have to come down before the goes in to separate projects?

1:14:50 With the piping in, it's going to protect the road better.

1:14:53 It's not going to solve all the problems, but it's just going to give us...

1:14:59 Probably thinking we all are kind of that excites me, I think we'd excite people in this community

1:15:28 that certainly address the issue with the road.

1:15:36 Obviously, the road is pretty expensive, so I'm just wondering how you can assist them in

1:15:46 Otis, best to be cool.

1:16:07 The number on the trail is like 320.

1:16:23 I guess when we started looking at this in my mind, I envisioned trying to get the road fixed as far as hot holes

1:16:29 and being able to traverse what we have there.

1:16:34 So looking at all these other things is great in my mind.

1:16:37 But if there's ways we can even take some of those really bad sections and do something with the paving too,

1:16:44 get rid of some of those big potholes and patches.

1:16:47 It was the direction I was looking at.

1:16:50 I'm fine with walking trails, but I would rather see the

1:16:54 pavement replaced than blasting rocks and making the corner wider.

1:16:59 Maybe some of those things. I've never had anybody complain to me about that.

1:17:04 Where Durkys Lake and Shishone Falls Road come together, people seem to be able to navigate that

1:17:11 so that's that intersection there.

1:17:13 I would think repairs.

1:17:25 I would like to see some options, thinking that we're not going to spend $2.6 million on a road, whether it's what the priorities are.

1:17:38 I mean, I like the trail idea, I really do.

1:17:41 There could be a partnership with somebody to help pay for that.

1:17:46 Might be an option, grants or whatever's available.

1:17:50 It kind of sounds like to me, the pipe would help, so I'd like to see that considered, and

1:18:02 I think it's the experience driving down that road that kind of makes it fun.

1:18:07 And if, in a sixth sort of way you guys okay, and if you have to limit the size of vehicles or continue to use the radio,

1:18:17 it sounds like it's been okay.

1:18:19 Take just a little bit of time and digest this and think about it. Maybe go down there and see,

1:18:30 you know, I've gone down many times as I'm sure everybody here has, but I don't usually stare at

1:18:35 the wall and think about, you know, what would that do? And if we change this and put piping in here and

1:18:40 all those types of things, maybe go through the intersection, the wire intersection and

1:18:44 how bad is it, really, those types of things. And maybe it is the first of the year we come back,

1:18:52 take some time to offer this by suggestion personally, because there are some very permanent

1:19:01 things we're asking, we're discussing,

1:19:03 increasing it to do that, so we follow it's not a massive amount,

1:19:21 we're not just high speed cornered, it is there, so.

1:19:34 Certainly will change the look if you pipe that drain

1:19:37 and you lose the greenery, it will change kind of that feel

1:19:41 going down there which probably needs to be considered as well.

1:19:45 This expectation, get as much life as possible, but can you also include

1:20:24 what we spent in the last 10 years on maintenance on that road?

1:20:28 about that, understanding that water freezing, thawing, all those types of things, what have we spent on it?

1:20:37 And we spent a couple hundred thousand, but we're going to put 2.6 million into it, and maybe it is something, we just

1:20:45 live with it for a little while.

1:20:47 Information, it's good to be aware of what's happening and what our options are, and we'll trust you guys to keep working on it.

1:21:00 So I just want to recap. So I'm hearing some interest in the bike path, connection piece.

1:21:07 So you'd like us to take a little deeper dive into that one. Look at just repairing the road

1:21:12 and what that would take, as well as maybe what it would take to repair it and do the water,

1:21:24 the drainage ditch. What is that? Okay. We're spending $100,000 a year now,

1:21:43 We want to be aware of those things, but again as Ruth said some of that natural beauty is the appeal of driving down there.

1:22:11 I think that changes that is, it has to be weight too with the cost of every, it is, it is a very unique place and we don't want to change what's in the light right now.

1:22:27 But looked into it, I have no idea what it would cost, but.

1:22:31 There's two or four years there that there's on the blue light screen.

1:22:36 I think that would be become a blue light screen.

1:22:40 That's the best part.

1:22:41 Ext number of cars in this sometimes has some unbelievable numbers.

1:22:44 If you can imagine it when the water flows high, it could be disastrous.

1:22:48 Okay, I'm in good.

1:22:50 Thank you for the box, though. Appreciate it.

1:22:53 Next on our agenda is a chance for general public input.

1:23:05 If there's anyone in the audience that would like to address the council on any items that was not on this evening's agenda,

1:23:12 now is your opportunity to step forward and state your name and address.

1:23:17 We'll give you three minutes this evening.

1:23:19 The Council for Advisory Board announcements.

1:23:29 items from the Parks and Rec, last meeting they spent some time looking at some alternative possibilities for the trailhead there at Hawaii, and Eastland was a little bit more

1:23:51 positive, you know, of any of the ideas for what that park might be, details that are about this plan, but that may be coming to us in the future, or the rest of you guys know, Suzanne and I, and the other one would be that this is a Wednesday, I believe it's still on for Wednesday,

1:24:09 I have a meeting of the recreation, isn't that this Wendy?

1:24:16 That's what I have my calendar with, but there will be another meeting coming forth with the recreation subcommittee for building the recreation center.

1:24:30 And we have been given some possible locations and asked to vote on which ones we would be.

1:24:38 Is it with COVID things can I get slowed down on that a lot of those locations have built off or we have become unavailable so

1:24:46 After you look at possible locations for the right center

1:24:58 For the same managers office

1:25:02 We have no public hearings this evening

1:25:09 but we do have a request to go into Executive Session under Idaho State Code 74-2061B to

1:25:19 consider the evaluation dismissal or disciplining of or to hear complaints or charges brought

1:25:24 against a public officer, employing staff member or individual agent or a public school student.

1:25:32 Second.

1:25:37 We have a motion from Sean Berriger, seconded by Ruth Pierce to adjourn into executive session

1:25:44 as was just read.

1:25:49 Yes.

1:25:50 Right, Lanting?

1:25:51 Yes.

1:25:52 Ruth Pierce?

1:25:53 Yes.

1:25:54 Frank Hawkins?

1:25:55 Yes.

1:25:56 Mr. Fereen?

1:25:57 Yes.

1:25:58 On Berriger?

1:25:59 Yes.

1:26:00 Point.

1:26:01 Yes.

1:26:02 Motion passes 7-0.

1:26:03 We will not be making any decisions this evening in executive sessions and we will not

1:26:05 be reconvening this meeting so we are adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, November 15, 2021. The recording started at 16:58 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:26:18.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    269a9ce33eef7c7a24b6d771cf0b11803c63c90ab8d4ccbc71b7c8b1a3c8d558
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 5265523743f686aacd92078d080dd02fc260975c89bcadd1634b0c25f0dee48d
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    519f00c57373535aad2a5d9ddb1879bcc706f7250a0d82f971a6b0ef29ff269d

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file