OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, March 28, 2022

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on fileExecutive session: c,e,f

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:02:02 Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the March 28th City Council meeting.

0:02:07 I want to confirm we have a quorum.

0:02:10 Today, all seven members are present.

0:02:13 First item on the agenda. If you all wish to join me in the Pledge of Allegiance, please rise.

0:02:28 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:02:38 Thank you. Okay. We have no proclamations tonight, so we will move on to the consent calendar.

0:02:45 Council wishes.

0:02:46 I would like to make a motion.

0:02:55 Madam Mayor to approve the consent calendar.

0:02:58 Thank you.

0:02:59 Do I have a second?

0:03:00 Second.

0:03:01 Thank you.

0:03:02 Motion by Craig Hawkins.

0:03:03 Seconded by Sean Berrigger to approve the consent calendar.

0:03:06 Aaron Roekal, please.

0:03:09 Mayor Paris.

0:03:10 Yes.

0:03:11 Vice Mayor Reed.

0:03:12 Yes.

0:03:13 Sean Berrigger.

0:03:14 Yes.

0:03:15 Nicky Boyd.

0:03:16 Yes.

0:03:17 Craig Hawkins.

0:03:18 Yes.

0:03:19 Jason Brown.

0:03:20 Yes.

0:03:21 carries 7-0. So if you're here for the Parks and Rec,

0:03:28 or Jones-Panzer to place a bench on the Can You Room trail, or the final

0:03:33 platform for Sportsman's warehouse, those have both been approved. Next item on

0:03:38 under items of consideration will be a presentation, swearing-in ceremony for

0:03:45 one new Twin Falls Police Department Police Officer, and I will be administering

0:03:51 the old Chief Kingsbury. Thank you Mayor Pierce, honorable members of the City Council.

0:04:02 Thank you for allowing us to come before you this evening to really recognize and

0:04:09 honor members of the Twin Falls Police Department, our city Twin Falls family,

0:04:13 for some different things within the Police Department. Mayor, with your

0:04:18 permission, I know we have three items listed. I would like to swap number three

0:04:23 and two, if that is okay with you.

0:04:25 Fine with me, thank you.

0:04:26 Thank you very much.

0:04:28 So for starters, we're gonna start

0:04:31 by introducing the city council and our citizens

0:04:34 to our newest Twin Falls police officer,

0:04:38 Michael Sean Perkins.

0:04:40 So Officer Perkins, if you could please come down,

0:04:42 stand by me.

0:04:49 As Mr. Perkins is coming down,

0:04:51 we'll tell you that he's a native of Twin Falls.

0:04:54 That graduated from Twin Falls High School,

0:04:56 so go Bruins, right?

0:04:58 and was a very competitive soccer player in his youth,

0:05:02 went on to Treasure Valley Community College

0:05:04 to play collegiate soccer,

0:05:06 and then went on to Boise State University,

0:05:09 where he graduated with a bachelor's degree

0:05:10 in Criminal Justice,

0:05:12 and shortly upon graduating,

0:05:15 he applied for the Twin Falls Police Department

0:05:17 and is here with us this evening.

0:05:20 Mr. Perkins, as some of his favorite hobbies,

0:05:23 include fishing, camping, hunting, watching, and playing sports.

0:05:27 So obviously, by that, we know he's a Idaho and a Twin Falls native, right?

0:05:32 He likes all the things that we like to do here at Idaho.

0:05:37 He's very dedicated to this community.

0:05:39 And for me, as a chief of police, I always love it when we get the opportunity to swear in

0:05:46 new police officers and recognize them, talk with them a little bit about the journey that

0:05:51 they're about to go on.

0:05:53 Currently, Officer Perkins is attending the law enforcement academy at the college

0:05:57 southern item. He is set to graduate from that academy in May. Upon graduation, he will

0:06:03 then go into his field training program, which will be about a 16-week program give or take,

0:06:09 where he will be paired up with senior officers that are field training officers, and he will

0:06:15 be out and handle calls and learn the hands and outs of policing. And once he successfully

0:06:22 completes that, he will then be placed in the right alone status, where he will work as

0:06:26 police officer answering calls for service and serving and protecting in our great community.

0:06:35 Shawn for you, the City Council has heard me talk about this a lot.

0:06:41 As we're standing here this evening, we're wearing a uniform and you see many members

0:06:45 of the TFPD here in that same uniform.

0:06:49 And there's a lot of symbolism that goes with this uniform that we wear and reasons in which

0:06:54 we wear this uniform.

0:06:56 I want to talk about three pieces of this uniform that mean a lot to all of us in our profession.

0:07:02 First of all, the patch on our sleeve, the patch that represents the Twin Falls, the falls of which our community is named after.

0:07:13 The patch that represents the men and women of the Twin Falls Police Department that have gone before us and protected and served this great community,

0:07:24 including two men who paid the ultimate sacrifice in the thirties and gave their

0:07:30 life for this community, represents all of them, and will also represent those

0:07:36 that come after us, and continue to serve this community. And just a little bit,

0:07:43 Officer Perkins, your grandmother, I think that's awesome he's asked his

0:07:49 grandmother to pin his badge, it's going to pin your badge upon your chest.

0:07:53 This badge is a symbol, a symbol of all things that peace officers represent.

0:08:02 And we know, I know we have Sheriff Carter here, County Sheriff,

0:08:07 Hill Sheriff, thanks for being here.

0:08:08 And we all know that the Deputy Sheriff's, they wear a star as a badge.

0:08:13 Men and women of Twin Falls Police Department, we wear a shield as a badge.

0:08:18 Both have the same meaning.

0:08:21 They represent that law enforcement, represent that being there to help people, serves as

0:08:29 a shield that may be in the days of Roman times, they would take into battle.

0:08:35 But here, as peace officers, we're not in battle.

0:08:40 We work in conjunction with our community to serve and protect and do so with the values

0:08:48 that the city has asked us to continue to serve and protect with honesty and commitment.

0:08:58 All of those things.

0:09:00 This badge represents the centuries of policing in our country, not just in Twin Falls, but

0:09:06 throughout the United States and even before.

0:09:09 And finally, Sean, everybody else here, we were at nameplate.

0:09:14 here says Perkins. I mentioned earlier that Sean's SS's grandmother had been his

0:09:20 badge on. This is probably the most important piece of symbolism that we

0:09:25 wear on our uniform, out of our name, because it doesn't really represent the TF

0:09:34 PD of the past or the other law enforcement of the past. It represents our heritage,

0:09:39 parents or grandparents or ancestors and as I tell many young police officers when

0:09:47 they start their career we give you a lot of authority and the community the

0:09:56 city council gives us a lot of trust and trust is very fragile we can carry that

0:10:02 box of trust around for for years and years and protect it but it just takes one

0:10:08 one thing to ruin that trust. And also just when that happens, you can tarnish your name.

0:10:16 Well, Sean, I want you to think about that when you go into this career and all of the

0:10:21 officers that are here with us today as a reminder that this name represents a lot more

0:10:27 than our profession, but represents who we are, who we were before we came here. Sean

0:10:35 writes about his family being a big part of why he's here as brother

0:10:40 and his parents and so i would like you to take a moment if you step over the

0:10:45 mic and just kind of introduce it everybody this is the hard part right

0:10:49 so if you if you get something wrong uh you know so

0:10:52 introduce your family to share with you tonight oh over here i have

0:10:57 my grandma is putting my badge her name's the land

0:11:00 my grandpa taught my mom and dad kip and jill

0:11:04 Then my sister and I, Amber, made it with my brother back there, Ellen.

0:11:08 Well, thank you.

0:11:13 And to Sean, to your family, I say welcome to the City Twin Falls family.

0:11:18 I'm glad that you all could be here with us this evening.

0:11:23 So, Mayor, at this time, if you could please come down to administer the oath of office.

0:11:30 Mayor, that I will support the invite of all ordinances of the City of Rose and Regulations

0:12:19 so that the Twin Falls police department will be here.

0:12:21 Police Officer badge.

0:13:49 One has his badge number.

0:13:51 Four, two, five, four, twenty-five.

0:13:53 Hope you'll see.

0:14:03 So, we're going to have the council always likes to come down.

0:15:08 But do you want to do it now, mayor?

0:15:10 Do you want to do it all at once with all of our officers?

0:15:13 What would the council prefer?

0:15:15 We'll do it all at once.

0:15:16 Thank you very much.

0:15:17 We'll do that.

0:15:18 Mr. Perkins, if you'll just be seated.

0:15:20 But don't go far.

0:15:21 We'll call you back.

0:15:22 Madam Mayor, members of the council.

0:15:29 As I stated when I came up here, I want to move the item number three up to the second item.

0:15:34 And that item is a presentation of post-certificates.

0:15:42 Now, one of our officers that is listed on the agenda is not able to be here this evening.

0:15:47 So we will only have two post-certificates to present this evening.

0:15:51 We will recognize Mr. Jordan a little bit later in the time.

0:15:55 So I would like to call up Lieutenant Chuck Garner and Justin Diamond to prepare for the presentation of certificates.

0:16:03 Thank you, Chief.

0:16:10 Officer Elijah Badger, please come down.

0:16:14 Madam Mayor, members of the council, thank you for giving me the opportunity tonight to introduce you to Officer Elijah Badger,

0:16:31 who will be receiving his Native Idaho Post Advanced Certificate tonight.

0:16:36 officer manager was hired by the twin false police department on January 9th 2017 as a full-time police officer

0:16:46 officer manager was born and raised in Colorado Springs, Colorado

0:16:50 graduated from James Irwin High School in 2004 following high school officer manager joined the army reserves

0:16:58 Served nine years till 2013 long army reserves. He deployed overseas twice during that time

0:17:06 Officer Badger also managed to further his education by attending Pike's Peak Community College and finishing his associates at CSI once he arrived at Chum Falls.

0:17:17 Officer Badger's law enforcement career began when he left the Army Reserves and became an El Paso County Sheriff's Deputy in Colorado Springs, Colorado in 2013.

0:17:28 Officer Badger and his wife, Lisa Murray, have two boys, Maverick, Angel Levin, and Joshua H.

0:17:35 Officer Badger is proud of the opportunity to serve our community in this family, love the Magic Valley area.

0:18:12 Detective Eric Strassner, come down please.

0:18:23 Members of council, thank you for this opportunity. I have to present Detective Strassner this evening to also receive his post-advanced certificate.

0:18:32 Detective Strassner was born and raised in Connecticut and spent his first 21 years living there.

0:18:39 After that, he joined the United States Marine Corps.

0:18:42 And during his time in the Marine Corps as a radio operator, he was stationed in Camp Pendleton,

0:18:46 in Southern California.

0:18:49 Detective Strassner deployed to both Iraq and Afghanistan while enlisted between 2007 and 2011.

0:18:56 Detective Strassner knew when he got out of the military he either wanted to be a firefighter or a police officer.

0:19:03 Thank goodness he chose police officer.

0:19:05 After his honorable discharge from the military, he moved to Idaho.

0:19:10 He was lucky enough to have a good friend in the military who talked him into

0:19:14 to Idaho with him and he has now lived a little over 11 years

0:19:19 here. And shortly after moving here, Detective Strassner was employed by the

0:19:23 Gooding County Sheriff's Department where he worked for a year and a half.

0:19:27 He later worked for the Twin Falls County Sheriff's Department where he also

0:19:32 worked for a year and a half as a detention deputy.

0:19:35 and during Detective Strassner's employment with the county, he became familiar with the

0:19:41 Twin Falls Police Department and became well known by its officers. Detective Strassner applied

0:19:46 here and started his career with the TFPD in 2014 and he's now approaching eight years with

0:19:52 the department in May of this year. He was a patrol officer for four years and then when the

0:19:58 opportunity came to join the Criminal Investigations Division as a detective, he jumped at that

0:20:04 opportunity and he's he's taken off from there. And Detective Strussner is happy to be here in Idaho

0:20:13 after the military and it's given him the opportunity to have a wonderful wife and two wonderful children, a career and law

0:20:21 enforcement, and for that he's deeply thankful and proud. And Detective Strussner spare time he enjoys searching for and collecting

0:20:29 firewood in the south hills mowing his lawn and other household projects golfing

0:20:36 four-wheeling hunting fishing and watching television and movies and over

0:20:39 the past couple of years he's developed an interest in antique firearms because

0:20:45 of a love for the old Wild West America and this evening it's my pleasure to

0:20:51 present him for his advanced certificate.

0:20:53 Keith, maybe before these two sit down, we could have them introduce their families as well.

0:21:14 Layer, that's a great idea. Detective Strasser, not for a badger. I'm up here by the microphone, so those watching at the monitor.

0:21:23 My wife is working at busy this evening, so my five-year-old son, Kevin, is with me.

0:21:30 All right, Kevin. Both my children are at a baseball practice this evening, so my wife is watching Kevin's son.

0:21:42 All right. Thank you, Chief. Thank you, Mayor, for that, and just further

0:21:50 Those are proof that TFPD, just one family, takes half each other right there.

0:21:55 Exactly.

0:21:57 You know, Mayor and Council, just so you're aware of the people who are maybe watching

0:22:01 here are tuning in.

0:22:03 In Idaho, our licensing is through the Peace Officer Standards and Training.

0:22:08 So we hear the, the academic post, that's what we're referring to.

0:22:13 For police officers, there really are three levels of post certifications.

0:22:18 The first is the basic certificate.

0:22:20 officers awarded that at about their one-year mark upon completing their

0:22:25 academy and their field training. So Officer Perkins will be looking to

0:22:29 receive his basic certificate here in a few months. Now we saw the the advanced

0:22:35 certificates here. An advanced certificate is the highest level for a police

0:22:40 officer to obtain what the police officer ranked if they don't have at least 15

0:22:45 years. As you can see with Officer Battinger and Detective Strusser, these two men

0:22:50 have a lot of experience in policing. I have also have a lot of hours of training to help them to

0:22:57 achieve those certificates. So I just wanted you aware and for people here today that these

0:23:02 are not just handed out officers have to earn these. They apply for them and they are granted

0:23:07 through the post council. So it is a very good accomplishment. So again, congratulations to those two gentlemen.

0:23:12 Thank you, Chief. Well, moving on to item two. Oh, I thought we were going to move everybody.

0:23:22 One more? Yeah. Yep. It's okay. Okay. Moving on to item

0:23:31 5B. Steve, go ahead. Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of council.

0:23:38 Tonight is my honor and privilege to promote a longtime member of the TFPD

0:23:45 to the rank of sergeant. If I could have Officer James, JP O'Donnell, the third step down.

0:23:53 drop office package. This evening we will be promoting Officer O'Donnell to the rank of Sergeant.

0:24:11 I think a lot of us know Officer O'Donnell. He also was a Twin Falls native,

0:24:17 grown up here, graduated of Twin Falls High, right? I thought so, yeah, go, go, go,

0:24:21 roads again. There we go. So, um, Sergeant O'Donnell was actually born on Fort Lewis

0:24:28 into Coma Washington, where when he was know his father, his father was serving

0:24:33 as a veteran in a church pastor. In 1984, they moved back to Twin Falls, Idaho, where

0:24:40 JP attended Old Area Middle School. Graduated from Twin Falls High School and then attended

0:24:45 the College of Southern Idaho. He is married to his wife, Brianna, has four sons, Skylar,

0:24:51 Ryan, Tristan, Quinn, and one beautiful little girl, little daughter that you saw him hand

0:24:56 off their ayla. Prior to coming to the Twin Falls Police Department, Sergeant O'Donnell

0:25:01 Charles started his career as a reserve deputy in 1991 with the Twin Falls County Sheriff's

0:25:06 Office.

0:25:07 Sergeant O'Donnell was hired as the Deputy Sheriff in 1995, where he held the positions

0:25:12 of Patrol Deputy, Air Officer, Field Training Officer, Police Motor Deputy, Marine Deputy,

0:25:19 and SWAT team member.

0:25:21 Sergeant O'Donnell served as a Patrol Officer prior to being assigned here with a Strategic

0:25:28 traffic tax reduction team, the STAR team in 2003. He's been a field training officer

0:25:35 and assigned to information services during 2004 for mobile data computer implementation

0:25:40 and he's also a negotiator on a crisis negotiation unit. He earned his post master certificate,

0:25:47 which is the highest certificate you can get when you don't hold a supervisor position

0:25:53 here in that in 2016. He joined our bomb squad in 2013 and graduated from the FBI's Hazardous

0:26:00 Device School in 2016 and still actively serves as a bomb technician. He's one of those guys

0:26:08 with things might blow up. He actually likes that and puts on the funny suit and walks towards it

0:26:14 when the rest of us walk away, casually, quickly.

0:26:18 Now, that's my place.

0:26:23 So, our General Donald also manages our unmanned aerial system response team, which is part

0:26:29 of a regional team consisting of unmanned aerial systems, our drones, for the Twin Falls Police

0:26:38 Department working along with the Twin Falls Fire Department and the Twin Falls County

0:26:42 Sheriff's Office.

0:26:43 He has been assigned to community outreach since 2015 and has been working towards building

0:26:49 relationships and enhancing communications with our community while making the community

0:26:53 safer and utilizing preventive measures in our social media campaigns.

0:26:59 He leads our community connection officers which currently strategize monthly to stay

0:27:04 in tune with his youth affecting some marginalized groups and communities within the community

0:27:09 of Twin Falls.

0:27:10 With that, it is really my pleasure this evening to promote JP to the rank of sergeant.

0:27:24 In my six years of serving here, I've got to know Officer O'Donnell quite well, and he

0:27:29 really is a man that is involved in many aspects of policing.

0:27:33 He is well known in the community, and he has a servant's heart.

0:27:37 And I think that is what when we look at our leadership team, that is those are the

0:27:42 kind of people that we have leading and that we want to continue to lead to keep

0:27:47 our men and women of the TF pretty safe and to keep our community members safe

0:27:52 that we go about our business so with that I believe you have a lot of

0:27:59 families let's start I'm gonna go grab a badge and why don't you take a few

0:28:02 minutes there just your family and friends.

0:28:05 Thank you I do have a lot of family that's obviously what I believe is obviously

0:28:13 made me who I am today my family not only my direct family but my extended family

0:28:19 which many in here are my father, Jim, Mom, Patty, Silas, Olivia, sorry it's yeah like stage

0:28:36 price sorry I don't remember can you guys introduce yourselves? Gina, sister-in-law, Sarah,

0:28:52 Brother Dan, son Ryan, wife, Brianna, daughter, Ayla,

0:29:03 and Lord Jan, and Lars, Don, Georgina, over time.

0:29:10 Also have Kirby and Vicki, who serve Mike Stanton family with that,

0:29:14 and that part of Mike Stanton family.

0:29:20 As is tradition of the TFPD, the current supervisory team will now present Sergeant O'Donnell

0:30:58 with his Sergeant Stripes.

0:31:00 Do you think you want to say?

0:31:48 First of all, thank you, Chief Kingsbury and staff for obviously an honor to be in the position

0:31:55 I am a monitor to work under you guys, I'm also honored to be in this community, I am.

0:32:01 It's always because of many in here in this room, why I love this community, why many of

0:32:07 us here love the community, what makes it what it is.

0:32:10 Obviously a lot of that back to my father, my dad Jim, I think I've always received a sense

0:32:17 of service from him and I appreciate that. I appreciate my family. I apologize. I went

0:32:24 starstruck and lost a couple of names, but I will make it even. But thank you and thank

0:32:30 you to everybody here. I'm blessed and proud to please and to what falls. So at this point,

0:32:52 If I could have officers Perkins,

0:32:56 manager and detective stressor come forward.

0:33:02 Mayor and council, if you'd like to please congratulate them.

0:34:19 So Mayor, that will conclude our presentation

0:34:22 on behalf of the Twin Falls Police Department again.

0:34:24 Thank you Mayor and council for your time this evening.

0:34:26 Thank you Chief and thank you gentlemen

0:34:28 and congratulations and thank you to all the family members

0:34:33 that we're here today to support our officers.

0:34:36 We appreciate you all very much.

0:34:39 We're going to give you guys a couple minutes to clear the room.

0:34:42 I know some people are anxious to leave.

0:34:47 I wish you weren't so anxious to leave, but we understand.

0:36:38 Thank you very much, everyone.

0:36:40 Moving on to the next item on the agenda and action item.

0:36:44 A request for the city council to provide direction to city staff

0:36:48 regarding potential improvement options for Floral Avenue.

0:36:52 And we have Deputy City Manager Mitch Humboldt.

0:36:55 Welcome, Mitch.

0:37:01 Okay, so a couple of months ago, the council was approached again about the possibilities

0:37:07 of what we can do with 4-11.

0:37:10 And so during the public portion of the meeting, and so you had asked that we come back with

0:37:18 some information for you to consider.

0:37:20 And so that's what tonight is about.

0:37:21 I'm going to give you a little bit of history.

0:37:24 You know, in the past, this was John Keaton talking to you about this stuff.

0:37:29 John's gone, so I said I'd try to fill in for him, but I didn't get here by any means

0:37:35 on my own.

0:37:36 There's a lot of help behind me on this one, and there's some help here tonight.

0:37:39 If you have more technical questions that I can't answer, we'll have maybe Aaron, he'll

0:37:43 pop up here and give you a little more engineering stuff.

0:37:46 But that's kind of what we're doing tonight.

0:37:48 Also just so you know, we did let the business owners along, Floral, know that we're going

0:37:53 to be doing this tonight, so some of them are here too.

0:37:55 Although this isn't a public hearing, it's up to you if you want to hear from others, you're not.

0:38:00 So I thought I would start by just kind of reminding the council the various options that we had talked about the last time this came up, and that would have been last summer.

0:38:12 And we were budgeting for this current fiscal year.

0:38:15 We shared with the council, well, five, one of those options is do nothing option, right?

0:38:21 So other four options.

0:38:24 And what we've done since then is updated their cost.

0:38:27 You all have seen construction costs

0:38:29 go through the roof in the last several months.

0:38:31 And so we updated the construction costs

0:38:33 on each of these four options.

0:38:35 And I'll just go with those real briefly with you.

0:38:38 The first one we shared was the full build out.

0:38:40 So just rebuild the street as a street.

0:38:43 Normally would be built sub-base, asphalt,

0:38:46 curbedder, sidewalk, all that kind of stuff.

0:38:49 estimate it cost is now $3.4 million. It went up from about $2.8 million

0:38:54 eight months ago. Second option was to do a curbing gutter along there to help

0:39:01 control the drainage but not asphalt and instead a base with a double chip. You

0:39:09 might think about the parking lot at Sunway Soccer Complex. It's the kind of

0:39:14 paving surface we're talking about there. Not a full asphalt but kind of a

0:39:18 better than gravel to you. And that option, now that cost is updated to 2.6

0:39:24 million. That would have been about 2.18 months ago. The third option was just

0:39:30 not curb and gutter, but rather like a borrow ditch kind of a system to control

0:39:34 the drainage. That option has gone up also to about 480,000. And then another one

0:39:42 that we added based on the council's request was what if you did borrow

0:39:45 with the double chip, and that's a little bit more,

0:39:50 or it is alone, but not near as much as the paving,

0:39:53 that option is now 639,000 up from about 540,000

0:39:58 eight months ago.

0:40:00 And obviously we still have to do nothing option,

0:40:03 which isn't exactly free, there's no construction cost there,

0:40:08 but there's a maintenance, ongoing maintenance cost,

0:40:10 which I'll talk about in a little bit here.

0:40:12 And so those cost of the things that we talked about last June, they've gone up a little bit.

0:40:20 One of the other things we did since then was we went out and put new counters out to kind of update the traffic counts out there.

0:40:27 So we had two counters that actually were able to get counts for us and this was over a two-week span just about four weeks ago.

0:40:37 So those two counters registered an average daily load of 299 trips on one of them and

0:40:44 514 trips on the other one, the higher one is the one closer to Eastland.

0:40:48 Now the counters are a little tricky because there's more ways in and out of there so it's

0:40:53 possible for a car to get in and out without tripping that.

0:40:56 It's also possible for a car to trip both with one trip and so those aren't exact but

0:41:01 they're just going to give you a feel for the amount of traffic that's out there.

0:41:05 Another thing that I thought was interesting is that 90% of those trips were between the

0:41:08 hours of 7 to 5, so clearly the businesses out there are much driving the traffic to be

0:41:14 going there.

0:41:15 Now, for the sake of comparison, because I think this is one of the primary reasons why

0:41:21 we haven't yet done anything here, this is the bang for your buck, right?

0:41:27 We know we have a limited amount of street dollars, and we know we have lots of projects

0:41:31 that are demanding those street dollars.

0:41:32 So I just grabbed six or so projects that we've been talking about on our long-term planning radar for street money and

0:41:40 Provided you some of those estimated costs along with the estimated traffic counts that that's gonna

0:41:47 impact

0:41:49 So one of those projects would be

0:41:52 Hinkins from stadium to fighter. That's a reconstruction of that sections

0:41:56 estimated at $1.4 million and the traffic load impacted by that is 400 or 4200 average daily

0:42:04 trips. Another one would be Orchard from Blue Lakes to Eastland, another reconstruction

0:42:09 project. That one is $2.7 million with a daily average of 5600 trips. Addison from Juniper

0:42:19 the morning side, another reconstruction, a few point six million dollar estimate, 15,825

0:42:25 daily trips. Washington at the intersection with Filer is a reconstruction estimated at

0:42:33 $1.4 million, 19,920 daily trips. Madrona from Stadium to Bridgeview is another reconstruction

0:42:43 that we're considering estimated $1.8 million, $2,600 daily trips.

0:42:48 And then the last one I provided for you is Elizabeth from Easton to Madrona.

0:42:54 That's just under $1,900,000, $5,000 at $3,074 average daily trips.

0:43:01 A couple of those are old numbers because we haven't put counters out the recently,

0:43:05 that are four or five year old numbers.

0:43:07 on the trip, trip numbers, but I think that that just kind of illustrates, again, the reason

0:43:16 why we have yet to do a floral project because other projects like these with a much more

0:43:24 significant impact on the number of trips that they're affecting. You notice that two

0:43:32 of the projects I talked about earlier, two of the options were this double-chip seal, right?

0:43:39 to want to talk a little bit about double chip.

0:43:42 It's significantly cheaper than a full-on asphalt cross-section, right?

0:43:47 And that's one of the reasons why we've used it in some cases,

0:43:52 not using a property used in the parking lots, right?

0:43:54 That's one of the reasons we talked about it here.

0:43:57 The problem with that is that it's a little bit better than dirt,

0:44:04 in that it's a smoother surface, the dust goes down,

0:44:06 but it's higher in maintenance, right?

0:44:10 And what I mean by that is they do wear out and they do require a lot of maintenance, especially in high traffic areas.

0:44:18 Again, that's not a high traffic area here, but maybe heavy traffic.

0:44:23 And so the maintenance needs of a double ship will be different and more difficult to accomplish on a double ship surface than on a gravel road surface.

0:44:35 the gravel road, you can just go out there and grade it, put some dust guard down every

0:44:40 now and then and it's easy to do and it's predictable and it's less costly than maintenance on a

0:44:48 double chip surface. Although, the double chip surface is certainly less costly than installing

0:44:55 the asphalt surface, right? But given that, or given the maintenance implications of there,

0:45:02 on Caitlin, he was in the position currently, Josh Baird, our new public works director,

0:45:09 city engineer. They all agree that that's not really the best option to use in a roadway

0:45:15 scenario. Parking lots that might be okay. They don't recommend that we do it on a street.

0:45:21 Let's see here. Let me talk a little bit more about the maintenance that we do out there.

0:45:28 It's a gravel road and it requires significantly more maintenance than most streets in town.

0:45:35 Our street department will go out there four or five times a year, grade the road, go out there once a year, put some dust guard down, and there's a cost associated with that, but again it's predictable and it's easy to accomplish.

0:45:50 But they asked to happen a lot more regular than like my neighborhood street does right?

0:45:56 We estimate street departments spend about $24,000 a year providing this maintenance to

0:46:02 You know that length of floral that's on the screen up there

0:46:06 That's a high cost of maintenance, but it's less than the chip seal would be in maintenance

0:46:11 That's why it's that's why it's eyes is the is the the gravel surface right now

0:46:22 We do collect property taxes from these properties.

0:46:26 And that property tax goes to the street department, and of course,

0:46:30 it goes to the street department to help pay for ongoing maintenance.

0:46:34 So I thought one of the things you ought to know is kind of how that financing all works out.

0:46:40 And so on your screen, you can see the map,

0:46:44 and what we've identified with the red boundaries are all the properties that have frontage along floral.

0:46:51 And we've gone through and grabbed the assessed values

0:46:56 from the county assessor's office for each of those properties.

0:47:00 And, you know, figured out what we would be collecting from that,

0:47:05 from those properties in each year in taxes.

0:47:08 The other thing we did was we talked to the county assessor.

0:47:11 The assessor, Brad Pills, any of you know,

0:47:15 provided us some feedback that says that,

0:47:18 in fact, I'll just read his quote.

0:47:20 He said, we use a lower per square foot value because of the lack of a paved roadway.

0:47:25 So these properties are assessed at a lower value than other properties, similar properties

0:47:30 on a paved road because of the lack of paving.

0:47:34 Regardless of that, we do still collect about $71,072,000 in taxes.

0:47:40 That's what we're going to collect this year with our current tax rate based on the current

0:47:45 valuations. Typically, well, I can't say typically because the amount goes up and down every year

0:47:53 on how much of our total tax selection goes to the street fund. But if we look at a five-year

0:47:58 average, it's about 4.8% of total taxes goes to the street fund. If I apply that average to that

0:48:05 $72,000, we collect about $3,400 a year, or we will collect this year about $3,400 from these

0:48:13 properties that'll go to the street fund. In your head you're probably thinking

0:48:17 all the $3,400 or collecting doesn't cover the 24,000 in maintenance and that's true.

0:48:23 It won't. I know that when I was looking into one of the questions I was asking

0:48:35 myself was like how did it get to be like this? Why isn't it paved in the first place?

0:48:40 You know, if this happens today, this would be a paved road.

0:48:45 Our typical development process would be a landowner proposes a subdivision.

0:48:51 They get stuck with a bunch of public improvements that are required in our codes.

0:48:55 One of those being paved roadways, we build them to a city standard,

0:49:00 we reveal them, we inspect them, and then we accept them as a city of infrastructure

0:49:05 for our long-term maintenance.

0:49:07 And how does something like this come to be?

0:49:10 Well, as it turns out, the first plant out there was 1908.

0:49:14 It was not in the city at the time.

0:49:18 The roadway has been a roadway since the early 40s, I want to say.

0:49:22 There's another later plant that came along, again, prior to being in the city,

0:49:26 prior to certainly prior to our current development standards.

0:49:29 This kind of thing doesn't happen today, right?

0:49:31 So this is an existing scenario where, again,

0:49:34 the property owner would subdivide, provide the public improvements, pave the road, and then

0:49:41 dedicate that improvement to the city. And the last thing I want to talk about a little bit was

0:49:49 when we were here two months ago, one of the new guys, and I can't remember which one,

0:49:54 but one of you said, hey, what about an LID? An LID is a local improvement district. It's a financing

0:50:01 tool that's provided to cities, well, it's a public entity, in our case of city, in the

0:50:08 state code. It's basically an option to fund a localized improvement that benefits a specific

0:50:16 set of properties, and then using a special assessment, two of those properties pay for

0:50:23 the benefit that we installed for them.

0:50:28 So, let me see here, we would need to identify a specific need, in this case a roadway, a specific public infrastructure need, we would need to identify a specific boundary or properties that are benefited by that infrastructure.

0:50:53 What I've shown you here on the picture would be properties that have frontage along the roadway

0:50:58 that we're talking about, and then the cost of the improvement cannot be more than the total

0:51:06 assessed value of the properties being impacted by that we did let math go quick.

0:51:11 And that's not the case here, even if you took the full rebuild option at 3.4 million

0:51:21 dollars, the total assessed value of these properties is in the 11 plus million range.

0:51:26 So it's certainly eligible.

0:51:29 The reason you do that is because you set it up as like a lean, basically the council

0:51:34 could work with this to be established, we would go through a big, I mean it's a complicated

0:51:41 process of hearings and notifications and potential protests and super majority votes

0:51:49 by the council and it's a very long complicated process that could get us to the point where

0:51:54 It basically let it lean on the properties.

0:51:56 We get a bond for the improvement.

0:51:57 We would construct the improvement.

0:52:00 And then over a span of time, up to 30 years or less.

0:52:06 If you chose less, you would do a special assessment

0:52:08 on each one of those properties in a proportional allotment

0:52:14 that paid for that improvement.

0:52:17 The code talks about specifically linear adjacency

0:52:21 or square footage, right?

0:52:22 Fort Roadway seems to make sense to me to go linear, right, linear, the frontage of the

0:52:29 lake on the street and then you would proportionally assess each of those properties with frontage

0:52:34 on the street being approved over a period of up to 30 years.

0:52:42 So it would be a special assessment, it's not a property tax necessarily, but it looks

0:52:48 a lot like attacks, and people could pay those off earlier if they wanted to, but you could

0:52:55 build it out or this span of time, and so that is an option. It's complicated and time-consuming.

0:53:04 I'm not aware of, in my time, the 16 years of the city, I don't know that we've done

0:53:12 one of these in this type of a scenario. I've heard stories that one may have been considered

0:53:16 in the past, but didn't ever get an implement, and we couldn't find any records on this,

0:53:19 and we're having done one of these. Travis has experienced in another community of doing

0:53:24 one of these. Again, they're complicated, but they are a mechanism for this kind of

0:53:33 an improvement. So when you have a very localized benefit, you have the benefit paid for by

0:53:38 the localized beneficiaries, right, rather than spreading out across whole city. And so

0:53:43 So with that, yes, I'll just sort of stop talking for now.

0:53:46 Let me ask questions if you have any, then, you know, again, Aaron's here if you have

0:53:51 more technical questions for him on some of those options.

0:53:54 And then we'll just kind of go from there.

0:53:56 Mitch, I do have a quick question on the LID.

0:53:59 If a property is sold, does the LID go with the property as a lean subject to?

0:54:07 That would be my understanding is that it would run with the property, but maybe Shane

0:54:13 Okay, any questions for Mitch or staff?

0:54:25 I think you're going to see the sign-up sheet of people that would like to speak.

0:54:29 We are opening this up here public.

0:54:32 It's not been notified as a public hearing, but it's at your discretion whether you want to talk about it.

0:54:38 Okay, so let's start with council. Any questions? Any discussion? Comments? Jason Brown?

0:54:44 So Mitch, the numbers that were presented, does that include engineering costs as well

0:54:51 or is that just a constructive cost?

0:54:54 That would be engineering and construction, these were prepared by a consulting engineer

0:55:00 for us.

0:55:01 Okay.

0:55:02 And then you also had mentioned that in this, if we do the LID in this particular case, we

0:55:10 It would seem reasonable if we went on a front-edge basis instead of, and so when you said property

0:55:18 owners could pay that off earlier, we would assess that front-edge at a particular price,

0:55:24 and then they could pay that off and then the lead is removed.

0:55:27 Right.

0:55:28 But yes, that's exactly right.

0:55:30 But if we chose to make the length of time, you would take their portion and divide it up

0:55:35 by ten years or fifteen years or whatever that portion of time is.

0:55:39 I just wanted to share with Council the LID feels like an unpalatable option.

0:56:07 Maybe we need more information about it but my first impressions are not great.

0:56:11 With experience in the real construction, I agree with the staff recommendation that double-chip seal is not worth the investment.

0:56:20 It's probably option one or none.

0:56:23 With that, I didn't have a question about option one. This might be an error in question.

0:56:28 Does that include curb sidewalk behind the curb and gutter? Are we required to bend all that money off?

0:56:36 I don't believe it actually includes, I might have said sidewalk because it's just kind of

0:56:40 curb-better sidewalk because it runs off her mouth, but it's probably just curb-and-cutter.

0:56:44 This is an industrial area, we don't actually require sidewalks and industrial areas, so probably

0:56:48 would not include sidewalks. But I think that Aaron's nodding here, so

0:56:52 yeah, all right, great, thank you. Anyone else?

0:56:57 Any questions or comments? I got it, I remembered what I was going to...

0:57:04 Okay, so your question Jason made me think the

0:57:08 The statute actually talks about proportional assessment and it uses the term of a linear

0:57:14 footage or square footage within an improvement, like a street, it seems to me to make sense

0:57:19 of a linear footage, whereas maybe a water line improvement might make more sense for

0:57:24 a square footage.

0:57:25 I think so.

0:57:26 And do either one.

0:57:27 Pick the one that makes the most sense and if we go through that process, we would do that.

0:57:33 Or that one out.

0:57:34 I just think it would be linear footage.

0:57:38 In the projects you presented here are they a project list currently the other six

0:57:48 Yeah, they're in our long-term

0:57:51 Plan we have a long-term planning document that looks out five years for upcoming street projects in each one

0:57:56 There's actually several more I just grabbed the street reconstruction projects that were on there

0:58:01 And so those six are on that list and the next five-year horizon all gonna be needs

0:58:11 other

0:58:13 I don't see any other speakers, so...

0:58:17 So this isn't a public hearing, but I understand there's a couple people that would like to speak.

0:58:25 So we will open up for that. I do would like somebody to time. Are you prepared to time Aaron? Thank you very much.

0:58:33 So when you come up, please state your name and

0:58:38 where you're from.

0:58:40 And you will be allowed two minutes. So first, stay scambo.

0:58:44 Thank you for the time to talk about this one. I wanted to bring up a couple of things after listening to what was just said.

0:58:56 They're spending about $25,000 a year when it sounds like I'm continued maintenance on Floral Avenue.

0:59:02 I wanted to bring a couple of points into play here though.

0:59:06 Freightway has double chip sealed, has been. I met with John Kent several times on this and it stood up very well.

0:59:13 It has improved that for the dust. It has improved the overall stormwater management and it has performed very well.

0:59:21 Well, in regard to the counts, yeah, the numbers are higher on the end with trade in

0:59:26 Eastland because that's where Jacob comes in and out.

0:59:29 He missed all the traffic off the trade street though, and that's how they go in and out.

0:59:34 None of that was counted.

0:59:35 So just to kind of keep that in mind, with the overall cost that was just presented to

0:59:41 you, and the conditions of Freeway and how well that stood up, you know you've got experience

0:59:46 with double-chifs seal, but the remote traffic counts, Freeway's been there a long time,

0:59:50 was a double chip seal and it stood up quite well. I don't think the continued maintenance,

0:59:55 especially with the dust abatement aspects. The mud, it's not gravel. You guys go down there,

1:00:01 you drive on it. You've seen the videos, you've seen what's going on down there. It turns

1:00:05 to mud because even though it's only 600 vehicles that you counted on there, more than

1:00:10 half of those are heavy trucks. 10 wheelers, tractor trailers, heavy trucks, and they just

1:00:17 beat that road to death. The ruts are deep enough that you can literally watch the side

1:00:23 of your tire while disappearing there. And it's on video, it's public, you can see it.

1:00:29 So I'm just asking you guys to consider, do the right thing, do something out there.

1:00:35 An LID seems really askew of what's gone there, even though the taxes that you collect are

1:00:43 $70,000 a year, $77,000 a year, they're from our businesses, well, I think we'd all embrace

1:00:50 the fact that if you improve the street and you collected more taxes and the ratios go up.

1:00:55 Thank you.

1:00:56 You get that?

1:00:57 Thank you, Stays.

1:00:59 Next is Stewart.

1:01:00 I'm sorry, can't read your last name.

1:01:03 Dandel.

1:01:04 Thank you, Stewart.

1:01:06 Thanks for your timing.

1:01:08 Thanks for giving us the opportunity again to be here, who I've been here a few times

1:01:13 before and I appreciate that.

1:01:16 Yeah, it stays pointed out there, but I remember, um, but it's the new, uh, over the Freeway,

1:01:24 but the, uh, previous, uh, the one they're just retired, but, um, he, they chipped so that,

1:01:30 uh, approximately seven years ago on Freeway Street, double chipped so, on just the, I mean,

1:01:36 one day it was gravel, the next day it was double chipped so, and I'm like, hey, they

1:01:39 just pay this, why they pay this, I call him up because, oh, that's a double chipped so

1:01:42 So that thing will only last like a year or two is going to be gone.

1:01:46 It's seven years now and if you watch that street you got the heavy trucks from Commercial

1:01:52 Tire and the diesel truck, a place right there that are constantly turning on that thing,

1:01:58 which is the hardest thing you can do on any road.

1:02:00 You can drive down the road.

1:02:02 It still looks really, really great.

1:02:04 I want to see it doesn't have any places that are dirt and mud coming up, nothing like

1:02:08 that.

1:02:09 because there's so much compassion on that road for so many years that the base is really

1:02:14 good.

1:02:15 So anyway, that's definitely a great option in my opinion.

1:02:18 And this one more thing I just want to bring up is that this road we're all aware is not

1:02:24 going to be the highest travel.

1:02:25 It's never going to be the highest priority.

1:02:28 It's never going to be that.

1:02:29 So we're going to sit here, we'll waste our time over and over and over if we're going

1:02:33 to bring up that issue again and again and again with traffic counts.

1:02:36 It's never going to get there.

1:02:38 But all those other areas that are higher priority are all on pavement right now.

1:02:43 And this road is on mud, dirt, and gravel supposedly.

1:02:48 And so bottom line is this thing is mud and dirt, and the others are still on pavement.

1:02:54 And they're driving on pavement right now. They're not waiting to be paved.

1:02:58 And so there's definitely a priority there in my opinion, but obviously I was trying to opinion about that.

1:03:03 that, but something definitely has got to be done and I think just getting the water

1:03:09 off the road and letting the double chips do it, thank you.

1:03:16 Okay, so, also wishes this is an action item, so we need to direct staff, Sean?

1:03:26 I may or I have a question, I don't know, can answer this, maybe Mark, so the last speaker

1:03:31 was just referencing a freightway street so did we double-chip seal that and do we

1:03:39 maintain that and are his contentions that it was done seven years ago and is

1:03:44 holding up just fine true anymore because maybe you know yeah so we did

1:04:00 do a double-chip seal it was a different type of a double-chip seal it's called

1:04:03 a pass oil chip which is about three times the money of a regular chip seal

1:04:08 So, and it is kind of designed for areas that need a little bit more than regular chip.

1:04:19 But we have had issues with it. There is no way to repair it when it does fall apart.

1:04:26 You can't just go cut a section out and repave it.

1:04:29 It's hard to match a double chip. So, the maintenance is a little bit more.

1:04:33 We have had to do a lockdown on the in-order Kimberly Road, where they come off of Kimberly Road onto that, where the turning movement is.

1:04:40 So we had maintenance in that area.

1:04:45 Thank you.

1:04:46 I mean, again, I appreciate the folks who are out there

1:04:50 on a regular basis and understand your perceptions

1:04:57 and views of how things are working out there.

1:05:00 As I often comment up here about the seven of us sitting up

1:05:04 here trying to pretend we're engineers, I know I'm not.

1:05:09 So I have to depend on the expertise of the staff

1:05:14 to try to give me perspectives and as I continue to see the staff's perspectives on options

1:05:20 for this particular roadway, it seems we're in the 4 million dollar range to make an improvement

1:05:27 that actually fixes the problem that's supposed to happen, the problem will continue to come

1:05:31 to us. So again, I appreciate the update of the numbers and the continued conversation as

1:05:38 we roll into budget timing for priorities for the number of issues we have throughout

1:05:46 the city outside of the 7% of the property taxes that go to streets so I can only say

1:05:56 thank you for the information I don't know that I can get much direction except that I

1:06:00 suppose this is on the laundry list of items throughout the city and if it escalates to

1:06:07 coming through the budget process, I would certainly consider any other dispenser.

1:06:16 Thank you, Mayor. Thanks for pointing out your observations on Freightway Street.

1:06:21 It actually made me think of two things. One, if we don't have to do sidewalk for accessibility reasons,

1:06:28 could we consider doing something similar to Freightway Street without doing any curb and gutter?

1:06:34 And then two, do these estimates include connecting Trade Street, Eddy, Madrona, all the streets

1:06:42 between Kimberly and Floral, haven't it?

1:06:45 I think they're going to look to make sure those side streets are connected to, but I

1:06:51 did.

1:06:52 While the other guys are up here talking, we did look and there's a small piece of sidewalk

1:06:56 included in these estimates on the north side of the road, but there's already some

1:07:02 sidewalk.

1:07:03 There's a little gap that would be connected with sidewalk, otherwise there are no sidewalks

1:07:06 sidewalks and the rest of the projects. So one of the options we talked about was

1:07:14 doing, well okay, in all the options there are some, there's some measure of

1:07:21 or drainage control, right? So whether there's bar dishes or curb and gutter, you put down the

1:07:30 chimp seal, you're going to increase the amount of runoff from the roadway and we'll

1:07:35 need to do something with our storm waters. So doing nothing with storm water would just

1:07:45 amplify the flooding problems out there. So you'd have to do either of the barotages or the

1:07:50 curbing cutter with any kind of improvement to the impervious surface. So here it's telling

1:07:59 me that the estimates do include, um, I guess it'd be, uh, those are included in those estimates as well.

1:08:13 Okay, great. Thank you. Jason Brown.

1:08:19 So, it was mentioned, and you had mentioned it, Mitch. Where were the counters again? You said one was close to Eastland.

1:08:26 And where was the other one?

1:08:28 The other one.

1:08:29 Places between trade and freight. We actually placed four.

1:08:32 Okay.

1:08:33 Two of them got destroyed and didn't actually do any counting.

1:08:37 Okay, so two of them we actually got counts on.

1:08:39 They were between Eastland and trade was the first one between trade and frame.

1:08:44 So did we capture the traffic coming off of trade?

1:08:49 Or we did not? We did.

1:08:51 You would have, okay.

1:08:52 Regardless of which direction you would have caught the trade traffic, but you wouldn't necessarily

1:08:57 Freeway or Eddy or those ones were the counters.

1:09:03 Okay.

1:09:04 And so the other question I have is my little knowledge of roadway design and understanding

1:09:14 is most of what we base our information on is based on traffic counts, is that correct?

1:09:22 doing a signal whether we're doing a soft sign or something like that. Traffic

1:09:29 counts are the standard in which we work off of. Is that correct? Okay. It gets

1:09:37 for me and I get the fact that traffic counts may not be in this area heavy

1:09:45 or may not necessarily ever really get to that point. But if our standard is

1:09:51 to work off of traffic counts and we deviate from that then I think we're

1:09:56 setting ourselves up or opening a door to other situations that we're not

1:10:02 relying on a standard to defend against. I would say that a local improvement

1:10:11 may be an option, may not be the most popular option, but I think if anything

1:10:19 maybe a little bit more investigation of what that I would like to hear if some of the other property owners are out there and listening.

1:10:28 I'd like to hear some of their thoughts as well.

1:10:31 That's what I should probably tell you that in 2019 with less than accounts, we did four counters in 2019 and we had two more further, as you go further West.

1:10:45 and he did actually have counts and as he went further west, the counts got progressively smaller.

1:10:52 We just weren't able to update those counts maybe a couple of weeks ago.

1:10:56 Chris, can you tell me how long the different options would last?

1:11:03 I mean, as we've talked about that double chip skill, I've driven down floral before.

1:11:11 There's a lot of big trucks that drive down floral.

1:11:16 And so, and to do a little bit of guessing, but we have option A where it's a complete build-out.

1:11:22 Estimating how long that would last.

1:11:26 Are we going to, if we decide double chip seals the way to go, whether it's the fancier double chips here or the one that we have over at Sunway,

1:11:34 are we going to be doing that multiple times?

1:11:37 Because we're going to go and do that, and then two years down the road it's going to be worse than it currently is.

1:11:43 And we would have to rip it all up and do it again.

1:11:47 I don't want, if we're going to do something, don't put a bandaid on it and call it good.

1:11:53 It's going to end up costing more money down the road.

1:11:56 Those are great questions, so typically a full rebuild of a road.

1:12:00 The design life of a road is about 20 years, so that's what we're trying to get.

1:12:04 There are things we can do to prolong that.

1:12:06 Ship seal the road, fog seal, different things to prolong it to get it a little farther to 20 years

1:12:11 than the typical design life on a double ship seal.

1:12:15 Mark Thompson might be the best on this, but I would guess on a normal roadway, five years?

1:12:23 Gosh, between five and seven years, I'd be what I would guess.

1:12:27 So right now in the City of Tofas, we have a maintenance program.

1:12:30 Zone maintenance will be around all eight zones, so every eight years it would get re-head for some kind of maintenance.

1:12:37 Did I answer your questions?

1:12:39 Besides Freeway, do we have any other streets that are done with the Chifxiel or the Chifxiel

1:12:48 that you called that is on Freeway?

1:12:52 Passoil, that's about what you said three times more expensive.

1:13:02 And everybody's wanting you to come down to speak on the microphone, sorry.

1:13:07 That way, Mark, we can get you on.

1:13:10 Yes, it's called Passoil, it's a treatment that's designed by ASI out of Utah.

1:13:16 We have tried it on another road on Jim, which is over by where PSI comes out, we've had

1:13:24 decent luck with it, except where the turning movements are, and we've had to go in, and

1:13:30 we've paired just about every couple of years, and you said that's triple, the cost.

1:13:38 That's a lot more expensive.

1:13:40 Thank you.

1:13:45 So, again, this is an action item we need to give staff direction on what we want to see

1:13:52 I see a question in your mind.

1:13:56 So is that the updated price of the chip seal is the 639?

1:14:04 And so we would triple that?

1:14:06 6 times 3? Is that what we're looking at?

1:14:09 These cost estimates were not the pass oil version that Mark was just talking about, so you would...

1:14:14 Correct. So, so borrow ditches, control access with chip seal?

1:14:19 You wouldn't necessarily triple the borrow ditch portion of it,

1:14:22 But you'd triple the paving portion of it, and I don't know what the difference is there.

1:14:26 It would be probably two thirds of that amount, so if you look at alternative 4 at $640,000 estimate,

1:14:36 you'd probably take 200,000 off of that for the drainage stuff, then maybe it's 1.2 on top of that, so 1.4 total would be totally shooting from the up here.

1:14:49 And there's better mathematicians here than me.

1:14:53 That's close enough. Over a million bucks, my sure.

1:14:56 So I appreciate this as an action item. I'm not sure what action we're supposed to be doing.

1:15:05 Keep it in the queue or thanks for the interesting information. Should we vote on that? I mean, I don't know what the action is.

1:15:16 So we labeled it as an action item so the council could take an action. Staff doesn't have a particular action for you.

1:15:24 You've asked for a report, we presented the report, and so now it really is up to the Council

1:15:32 to decide on what the path forward would be possible.

1:15:37 Actions for you to include would be to do nothing if there's more information that you believe

1:15:46 you need before you make a decision.

1:15:49 You can instruct staff to provide additional information, but we would ask for you to be

1:15:54 We think that we've covered all of your thoughts and your questions so far so if there are more things that you'd like to know from us

1:16:02 To help you make a decision we can do that the other would be to fund one of those options

1:16:10 As part of the FY 23 budget process as you know

1:16:14 Long-term planning is recently concluded their works will be coming to the city council as a staff to gap their

1:16:21 council projects

1:16:23 in mid to end of April and then we'll use those to formulate and complete the final budget moving forward.

1:16:30 One question, so the LID seems to get kind of some mixed reactions.

1:16:40 Is anybody else, I'm kind of interested in hearing more about it,

1:16:45 but if it's not something that anybody else is interested,

1:16:48 I'm not interested in being the lone wolf either.

1:16:52 I don't know enough about it too.

1:16:55 I was going to say, I'm interested, I mean, the group from Floral has been here multiple times.

1:17:03 And there's some mixed reviews on alternative 3 and 4 as far as chip ceiling and all of those things.

1:17:10 I personally don't want to do something that's going to cause more frustration and cost a lot of money.

1:17:15 So looking at that as an option, it might come back and people say, that's not what we want.

1:17:22 I would like to look at it, because I don't want to put a bandaid on something that ultimately is going to cost a lot of money,

1:17:28 that then have to go and do something else.

1:17:30 So, that means my suggestion is have staff go back and look at what that would cost,

1:17:37 communicate with the individuals, the business owners.

1:17:40 They're talking the LID.

1:17:42 LID, what that would cost at that point in time as an option.

1:17:48 to question, but I'll answer the LID.

1:17:55 I think it's worth looking at.

1:18:00 The other question I mentioned, you said you reached out,

1:18:02 did you reach out, did the city staff,

1:18:05 did they reach out to all of the property owners,

1:18:07 or did we get response from anybody from written response?

1:18:14 So we prepared like a little flyer saying,

1:18:16 okay, we're gonna have this conversation tonight

1:18:18 and the street department delivered it

1:18:20 to the businesses all up and down the floor.

1:18:22 I thought everybody got a notice, they got a notice that we were going to have a conversation

1:18:27 tonight.

1:18:28 So, okay.

1:18:29 Because I think it's important to know, obviously we have business owners, property owners here,

1:18:37 but I think it's important to also see what the other property owners and business owners,

1:18:44 if they're willing to talk and speak up or at least try a letter or something.

1:18:49 And I think we get that through the LID process.

1:18:51 But absolutely do. There's actually, if you complete the process to its conclusion, there's two different

1:18:59 notify public hearings. We're inviting them to come in at two different stages in the process.

1:19:07 And whether they actually come in jail or not is up to them,

1:19:12 have two different formally notified opportunities for that to happen, and for those folks to file protests.

1:19:20 The other thing that I keep hearing is, is a drainage, have we looked at the drainage system at all in this process and what what condition the drainage system is kind of?

1:19:30 Obviously, I'm coming a little late to some of the historical conversations. What is, what is the condition of the drainage system?

1:19:41 That's another great question. So, as part of the design that the engineer had to do, they looked at the existing drainage system and actually the street department after the first conversation back in.

1:19:55 They went out there and installed the catch basin at the low point, fixed a pipe that

1:20:02 had been clogged up.

1:20:03 So they've done some with that, but the design would also look specifically at the drainage

1:20:08 to make sure that the capacity and the pipes work.

1:20:12 Okay.

1:20:16 Mayor?

1:20:17 Yes.

1:20:18 I'd like to ask an mention question.

1:20:19 So in the past, we have had a lot of the property owners out there.

1:20:26 The ones that we're having now are kind of like the front men for the project that we have heard, I mean it might have been two years ago at this point.

1:20:34 We've heard from more than just these two.

1:20:36 Yes, we've heard from quite a few of them. I think the LID is an interesting point that is good for us to learn about.

1:20:47 But I also think, based on the question I asked about the special oil, I think Turnitive 4 has held up for seven years, not where the trucks turn, but where the rest of it, weak spot would be maybe brave street.

1:21:19 Other than that, that's a pretty chunk that would weather the storm for maybe seven years.

1:21:26 And three times that money, we get a real street, and it lasts 20 years or maybe a little bit more.

1:21:38 I'm looking at the length of, I mean, it lasts for the money spent. That kind of comes out.

1:21:46 Similar.

1:21:47 Similar in my brain. Is that...

1:21:49 That's what I was headed to.

1:21:50 Yeah, and so I'm thinking that, number four, with the special oil, now, perhaps, has more.

1:22:03 And then the question I have is, if we look into that and our timing is right, would this then go into the 23 budget, so like nothing is happening on that right now?

1:22:17 but it's actually scheduled for next year.

1:22:21 We could proceed with a project in the funding

1:22:26 when we do our budget for fiscal year 23.

1:22:30 Right now there's no money in the budget to do anything of this. So we're going through our budget creation process.

1:22:34 You're starting just like in a week and

1:22:38 we'll be coming back here in July and August with presentation and all that kind of stuff.

1:22:42 And then in October if we were to include a project like an option for

1:22:46 option for or maybe a maybe an option for a

1:22:50 that has the different kind of oil we

1:22:53 could find that in the coming year

1:22:55 that was the direction the council wanted us to go

1:22:58 I thought it was interesting to learn

1:22:59 that the people who are out there

1:23:03 wanting a road think Freighway is that

1:23:07 was an interesting piece of information I

1:23:10 thought. Great cockness.

1:23:15 I guess this is a tough one I think for

1:23:19 If we all want to see this completed, as much as the property owners do, I'd like to know more about the LID.

1:23:29 I don't really understand fully of it. I'd like to know what the consensus would be from the property owners regarding that.

1:23:37 We just had enough money to do. I think a little more information would be prudent to do.

1:23:51 Yes, I just want to point out a couple of things. One, an LID process begins by what's called an initiation

1:23:59 that could either be from the city or from the property owners. In either event,

1:24:04 we have to come back to the council with the resolution that would include

1:24:09 what we believe the costs are going to be, where it's going to be funded, what portion by the city will be funded.

1:24:14 So, we can give more information on that, but to your point, if

1:24:19 60% of the residential property owners, those who have their primary place of business at

1:24:27 the location are going to be benefited or actually live there, sign that they want this

1:24:32 initiated, they can come forward with specific terms of the description of the properties

1:24:38 to be benefited, and the improvements they are requesting be made, at that point we could

1:24:45 craft a resolution that would hear kind of those suggestions. The alternative is

1:24:51 primary place of business is not located on the benefited area. It's two-thirds of

1:24:57 the property owners. And so if you just own property there but it's not your

1:25:00 primary residence or it's not your primary location business, then you need

1:25:04 two-thirds of those individuals that point to initiate a resolution. So

1:25:11 So, unfortunately that still leaves that question of all or some of that money provided by the city to do one of the four options.

1:25:23 And so it really does kind of multiply the options before you.

1:25:27 I know that's not very helpful, but that at least gives you description of how the process could go forward.

1:25:33 That makes sense.

1:25:34 Thank you.

1:25:36 So, let's, we need to wrap this up, so the, um, what I'm kind of hearing is maybe everybody's

1:25:43 interested in hearing more about the OID process is that what I'm hearing, Sean.

1:25:49 I would be interested in the LID.

1:25:51 I would like to see it both for frontage and square footage because there are so many pieces

1:25:56 of these properties that have very small frontages but large persons.

1:26:00 Does stuff good with that?

1:26:06 I am interested in the LID, but not at the exclusion or the giving up on alternative.

1:26:24 So then what I'm hearing is you're asking for more updated information based on the

1:26:31 purple oil option, is that where you're asking?

1:26:36 And for an exact cost or I mean an estimated cost.

1:26:46 So again, we're getting close to the budget process, and so I don't know, timing-wise,

1:26:53 how this all is going to work out, Travis, do you have any thoughts?

1:27:02 So it would be staff's option to have this completed before the budgetary process, unless

1:27:08 the council were to say, allocate the $770,000 that we typically reserve annually for council

1:27:17 capital.

1:27:19 So we will come back eight today because I think that there's an effort involved and

1:27:29 there's also another other workload going on but we will spend some time huddling tomorrow

1:27:37 finding what that window looks like will communicate with the property owners.

1:27:42 I think it's also important to gauge their interest in an LID because there are two ways

1:27:48 to do it, the one way is to have them approach you, the other is to have the councils move forward.

1:27:56 And I think that what we're trying to do is am I completely find a solution? And I don't

1:28:02 think the council, at least in my experience with the council would want to force an option

1:28:08 that was not well supported by the properties.

1:28:10 Yeah, thank you. So I see three people up. Are you all wanting to talk? Or did you forget

1:28:16 forget that's all I, you good? Okay, that's it. Thank you. Um, yeah, I haven't heard anybody say

1:28:24 it real explicitly so I just wanted to say it out loud and make sure I'm understanding right, but

1:28:30 with an LID really the city's borrowing money. In this case, depending on what option it could be

1:28:38 a little over half a million or three and a half million and the property owners have to pay that

1:28:43 back essentially and I would hate to have staff spend a lot of money working on

1:28:48 that because I'm fairly certain a lot of property owners are not interested in

1:28:53 ain't that a mount back that being said as councilwoman Boyd mentioned if

1:29:00 alternative for or a version of that would take care of this problem for a

1:29:07 number of years down the road it might be worth getting more information you know

1:29:11 pass oil is going to cost a lot more than chips heel. However, this cost is not just the chips heel,

1:29:16 it's also excavation based prep and things. So it's not the bottom line that we see times three,

1:29:23 it's a portion of that times three. I think it's important to recognize that all of the options

1:29:34 could be used for the LID portion. It wouldn't be just the payment option, and so that's

1:29:44 why I think it's going to take some time. It might just be a simple Excel spreadsheet

1:29:47 formula, but we really want to understand both the linear foot as well as the square

1:29:53 foot, put those options in a spreadsheet, and then also spit out what the cost for

1:30:01 the different options would be as they are laid out here.

1:30:04 And to remember, we would also have to guess

1:30:07 what would use a market-based interest rate

1:30:11 as well as a series of different terms

1:30:17 that could be moved forward.

1:30:19 We would want to compile that information

1:30:22 and share that with the property owners

1:30:24 to see if that was palatable.

1:30:27 And then share that information with you as well.

1:30:31 Okay, thank you, Travis.

1:30:32 One of their clarification, I think it's a small nuance, but I think it's important.

1:30:37 The city is not borrowing money for this.

1:30:41 For an LID, you would create a district that district would be borrowing the money, not the city.

1:30:46 The city would be kind of the mechanism, and we'd be the ones billing it out and that kind of stuff.

1:30:51 But it's actually the district that is the borrower, not the city.

1:30:56 Thank you.

1:30:59 Okay.

1:31:00 Thank you, everyone.

1:31:02 moving on to the next item. Action item to approve an agreement between the city of

1:31:17 Twin Falls, Twin Falls County and Sky West Airlines for a 400,000 minimum

1:31:23 revenue guarantee for one daily Delta flight between Magic Valley Regional

1:31:28 Airport and Salt Lake City International Airport. We have our airport manager Bill

1:31:34 Carberry. Welcome Bill. Thank you very good evening council members. I thought I

1:31:40 indulge you in about a 10-minute PowerPoint presentation. I think there's

1:31:45 a lot of misunderstanding with the public about this agenda item. So let's open

1:31:50 a step through it and provide some points as I go along before we have

1:31:56 questions and things of that nature. I will be giving the same presentation

1:32:01 tomorrow to the county commissioners in the morning. This is also an agenda item for the county as well.

1:32:06 So I just wanted to go back in history as painful as this might be recent history.

1:32:13 I reviewed some of the conditions leading up to where we are today and really I could have gone further back but

1:32:20 I just thought I'd go back a couple of years. So if I remember correctly I think it was about two years ago

1:32:26 ago, our former CFO, Lori race, we were sometime in the spring of 20, early summer, trying to

1:32:34 figure out probably forecasts for the next year. She said, COVID is driving the train and it's really

1:32:39 hard to forecast economic conditions with COVID and that nature, everything that was happening at

1:32:45 that time. So just bored a few headlines to flash in front of you and really the one in the lower

1:32:51 number one is really how the airlines responded. They were decimated, people weren't flying,

1:32:56 they were parking hundreds of airplanes in the desert waiting for better days. So they

1:33:02 were hit and the whole country was hit in turmoil back just a couple of years back.

1:33:11 So with that there was government action through 20 and 21 to help provide aid in the form

1:33:18 of bailout dollars, loans, those things to the airlines

1:33:24 in the United States to assist them

1:33:26 through this troubled period.

1:33:28 So that's something we saw through both the Trump administration

1:33:33 and by administration, I think, to our three rounds.

1:33:36 I think total dollars that were afforded

1:33:38 the airline industry were in excess of $50 billion

1:33:41 during that period.

1:33:44 So with that, we started to see symptoms

1:33:47 of a problem, payroll protection helped keep some employees

1:33:52 certainly, but it didn't do anything for those

1:33:54 that decided to retire.

1:33:56 There were sort of offered packages moved out

1:33:59 of the industry and retired.

1:34:01 So there was, as we've seen, the great quit

1:34:03 and the great resignation.

1:34:05 This was certainly affected the airline industry.

1:34:08 So you saw, especially in the major airlines,

1:34:12 you saw the more veteran crews for whatever reason

1:34:16 decide to move on from that profession.

1:34:19 And what we've seen has really been a trickle effect

1:34:22 down to the regional airlines.

1:34:24 We're regional airlines, they're moving those pilots up

1:34:26 to fly our main routes with the major.

1:34:29 So there's been a tremendous struggle

1:34:32 with the regional airlines.

1:34:34 And SkyWest is one of the largest regional airlines.

1:34:37 And those are the things we heard,

1:34:39 Sean Barrigge, Travis Rothweiler,

1:34:42 when we went down to talk to SkyWest.

1:34:45 Last fall, it really wasn't the unfrun issue that really we all kind of suspected.

1:34:51 We heard about lack of average fares and financial performance in the market, but this

1:34:56 was really an underlying drum beat with the industry and their problems.

1:35:01 And I think especially as we turned into last Christmas season, the holidays, you saw the

1:35:05 miserable conditions that people had to put up with flight cancellation, lack of flight

1:35:10 crews and all of those sort of things.

1:35:12 Now, this is no longer in denial, and it's really out in front of everybody.

1:35:18 So with constraints on your labor and your resources, you start to have to cut your supply

1:35:25 that you're putting out there for sale.

1:35:28 So these are recent headlines really from just March of this year, but there were many

1:35:32 that go back to last fall about cutting capacity, cutting flights, those types of things.

1:35:38 So, SkyWest being one of the major regionals they've done just recently, we've seen them

1:35:43 pull out of 29 regional airport markets that are essential air service, and I'll get more

1:35:48 into that as we move along, but we've seen on the United side, and certainly in concert

1:35:55 with the United, there's been a collaborative agreement to move out of these communities.

1:36:00 They were all on the United side.

1:36:02 We haven't seen this mass exodus on the Delta side at this time.

1:36:07 So I thought I'd just review that.

1:36:11 And this gets a little bit wordy,

1:36:14 but I think I want to read through this for those at home

1:36:17 and may not even see the screen.

1:36:18 But I think it's important to talk about SkyWest business

1:36:22 model and how they operate and the risks that

1:36:26 are inherent with those types of operations.

1:36:29 So the first one, I coined it as a no risk type of relationship

1:36:33 that they have, where they operate the company's store,

1:36:36 They do the ticket and branding for the major airlines.

1:36:39 They receive their fees for all of their costs,

1:36:42 plus a percentage of profit.

1:36:44 So there's really no risk.

1:36:45 They fly five people.

1:36:46 They fly 100 people.

1:36:48 They make money on those routes.

1:36:50 And that's my and large, the largest percentage

1:36:53 of their business model.

1:36:55 And the airlines they do that for United Delta,

1:36:57 Alaska and American, those airlines,

1:36:59 they serve feeder traffic into those hubs.

1:37:03 The next group, and I mentioned essential air service,

1:37:05 So if we go back to deregulation in the late 70s, when the industry just went strictly

1:37:12 to market forces and was privatized, there was no routes handed out by Department of Transportation.

1:37:18 So there was great competition and there was fear that little communities would be forgotten.

1:37:23 So what happened in Congress that created the Central Air Service Program in the late

1:37:28 70s where small communities were guaranteed some level of service, small regionals bid

1:37:34 on those routes and they receive subsidies.

1:37:36 So that program remains until today.

1:37:39 It was capped about 10 years ago to those communities

1:37:42 that were receiving those subsidies in that service.

1:37:45 We are not, and we'll get into our relationship

1:37:47 and there is a smile as to everyone,

1:37:49 but so we're seeing some things happen

1:37:52 and they're pulling out, they're giving notice

1:37:54 that they're leaving essentially our service markets.

1:37:56 Some hold orders, they're supposed to wait

1:37:59 until someone else bids

1:38:00 and other services provided to that community.

1:38:03 But we'll see how that pans out.

1:38:05 There's a spurry of activity right now

1:38:07 with smaller airlines trying to bid on some of these routes

1:38:10 that SkyWest is pulling out of.

1:38:13 I could see a lot of 50-seat jet markets going to 9-seat

1:38:17 props and things like that.

1:38:19 So we'll see how that works out.

1:38:21 But those were little risk because of the subsidy.

1:38:24 If they didn't bid on it properly,

1:38:25 they might have some problems.

1:38:28 But really, I think it's clear the reason

1:38:31 they're leaving these markets, it's the lack of those pilot crews to fly those routes.

1:38:37 And officials with United in particular have voiced that to Congress recently.

1:38:43 We fall into this last at-risk group, and this is, I think I've heard of it, as a franchise

1:38:49 type of relationship that they have with the major, where what they do is they get the

1:38:54 ticket and baggage relationship, they brand with the major airline, they go into a market,

1:39:01 And once again, this is a small part of their business model, and we've been there for decades.

1:39:06 And they take that segment from Twin Falls into the hub at Salt Lake, and on their dime,

1:39:12 it's their site of the ledger, their cost, and historically over time it's been profitable

1:39:17 for them, and many times during the good times, much higher margins from places like Twin

1:39:23 Falls than the essential air service or the contract routes were a fixed percentage.

1:39:31 that with that risk during downturns or other complications with like a pilot shortage or

1:39:37 their ability to provide service, those risks increase.

1:39:41 And I think we're in those waters now, we're seeing the effects of their labor constraints.

1:39:47 And really what's happened, and this will turn us to this agreement, is they're looking

1:39:52 to abate any risk even for the shortest period of time.

1:39:58 So what is a minimum revenue guarantee?

1:40:01 Why do they want that?

1:40:02 So really simply a revenue guarantee is a way for a community to abate any potential financial losses to the area for a period of time while operating that route.

1:40:12 The agreement that's proposed for us to look out here tonight is an agreement with the SkyWest as a party in the city and county as a party collectively.

1:40:22 The city and county, they're both owners and operators of just a field.

1:40:26 And the agreement includes a $400,000 minimum revenue guarantee for a calendar year 22.

1:40:32 And that's the cap, the $400,000 on the agreement.

1:40:38 Some of the mechanics, it calls for quarterly reporting from the airlines.

1:40:43 Going back to Q1 here in 22, the calculations based on the airports operating costs for the flight versus total ticket revenue.

1:40:52 During quarters where revenue falls above the cost,

1:40:56 there's no payment to, won't receive an invoice for that.

1:41:00 Conversely, if the revenue falls below costs in any quarter,

1:41:04 we'll see a payment requested for that quarter.

1:41:07 And that's where the $400,000 acts

1:41:10 as a sort of an insulation as we move

1:41:12 through these quarters in 2022.

1:41:17 Other terms, I mentioned there's a $400,000 cap.

1:41:20 That's shared equally by both the city and county,

1:41:23 the co-owners and operators of the airport, the agreement covers from January 1st through

1:41:29 December 31st of this year. All parties in City County or SkyWest have a 60-day right

1:41:37 to terminate. So any party airline in City County that can terminate this agreement with

1:41:45 a 60-day notice. SkyWest will provide one daily nonstop flight on a 50-seat regional jet. Currently

1:41:52 we have this afternoon turn. Also if there's some good news I might want to

1:41:57 underline in the agreement it talks about prioritizing early morning flight

1:42:01 and a late evening arrival so that would be the best schedule you can have if you

1:42:08 have just one flight. Notable we've seen that change in the May schedule I'm

1:42:13 hoping as we move along early April we'll see that June schedule come out and

1:42:20 Hopefully you'll also see that schedule as well with the early departure.

1:42:24 I think our business folks that like to fly out, fly back the same night,

1:42:28 they can do that. Or folks flying out of town and just trying to get back.

1:42:32 Sometimes you won't get that mid-day flight from the east coast is troubling.

1:42:36 So I think it's a little bit better schedule for

1:42:40 recently you may have been reading about some other neighboring communities

1:42:47 that are looking at agreements just like the one you're looking at tonight.

1:42:52 Skyo Pocatello approved a revenue guarantee with SkyoS, I think it was St. Patrick's Day, they met on a Thursday.

1:43:01 This was $800,000 for an annual period.

1:43:05 Williston, I think back in the fall, they have a $1.1 million agreement to bring Delta back.

1:43:12 Elco City Council voted this winner to renew a contract with SkyoS for a minimum revenue guarantee.

1:43:20 The CASPER community, the STARTS for Tribune there, I think it dates back to the fall as well,

1:43:27 and they have an $800,000 guarantee that they're looking at it and they approve that as well.

1:43:32 So we're not in this struggle alone. It's certainly not where we want to be, but we're not alone.

1:43:42 So a few summary points to consider.

1:43:47 SkyWest has clearly said without the requested revenue guarantee,

1:43:52 they would begin planning termination of the service to our community within the next few months.

1:43:58 Will the current metrics in the industry suggest it would be extremely difficult,

1:44:04 period ahead of us to recruit new air service?

1:44:07 Any attempts to require that type of service after losing it may be far more expensive

1:44:12 expensive than this proposed agreement may be, once again, there's a 60-day termination

1:44:17 right for old parties and we can certainly, if concern, and I think we would do it just

1:44:24 right out the bat, we want to monitor the financial performance.

1:44:28 I have a relationship with the planners down there.

1:44:30 They should be able to give me a 60-day forecast of how things are selling, how it looks, you

1:44:36 We on the mark, certainly with the summer season, coming up I would anticipate that we

1:44:43 should be doing very well.

1:44:46 Just anecdotally for you, our loads are very good at your port, there was a few seats through

1:44:53 the spring break period, but we're usually in those 45 seats, 48 seats on a 50-seater

1:44:59 on a daily basis.

1:45:01 A few more points, approval of the agreement will help preserve existing air service and the associated infrastructure and this is a critical point.

1:45:14 These are the services and the people. So TSA operations, fueling, car rental, restaurant services, the jobs out there, and I think that's a conservative number, total somewhere about 50 jobs.

1:45:25 TSA operations in particular would, if we were to trap a loss of air service where they were

1:45:32 no longer there, the ability to garner those services back from TSA would be difficult.

1:45:38 They wouldn't just be snapped right back, so that infrastructure for security screening

1:45:43 is critical to maintain. The possibility is that Salt Lake Service becomes self-sustaining

1:45:51 as we look ahead over the next year or so. So with our continued effort, and this is

1:45:56 This is really what we're trying to do.

1:45:58 We've had video meetings with Deltas recently.

1:46:01 It's January.

1:46:02 We'd like them to take over the route as a contract route, get out of this risk profile

1:46:07 with the at-risk and become a contract at route.

1:46:10 We wear SkyWest looks at the segment revenue between here and Salt Lake.

1:46:15 Delta looks at the network revenue, what we contribute.

1:46:18 I think last estimates, 2019 was somewhere around $25 million, which looking at other communities out there,

1:46:25 we see others that don't produce that much revenue that are under a contract relationship.

1:46:30 So I think we were invited to check back with Delta and Atlanta in the May time frame, so

1:46:36 we'll certainly check in with them along the way fairly regularly.

1:46:42 I think right now they're contemplating, I think we were received well with our meeting

1:46:46 with their planners, but in deference to some of the struggles with their regional partners,

1:46:51 I think right now they're being very careful about flipping routes and taking over the contract route, so we'll try to sort of loosen up that possibility with them.

1:47:01 So with that, finally I'd just like to recommend that the city prove that their service agreement with Skywest Airlines and authorize the mayor to sign the agreement, and I'm happy to stand for any questions you might have.

1:47:14 Thank you Bill. Questions for Bill today? Jason?

1:47:18 And I think you mentioned it, so we're even with the afternoon fly schedule we have now,

1:47:27 we're putting bodies in seats pretty consistently with that route, and we're doing pretty well

1:47:34 with passengers.

1:47:35 Yes, I think our load factors have been very good, you know, some conversations with neighboring

1:47:41 communities.

1:47:42 I think we're doing fairly well.

1:47:45 I've heard amongst their at-risk markets were right up there with St. George as the best performing.

1:47:51 I think they've only got about seven, maybe eight. So it's not a whole batch of us, but we are performing fairly well.

1:47:59 And so if we agree or approve this agreement with SkyWest, we're pretty confident that we can put bodies and seats moving forward and minimize as much as possible.

1:48:16 Yes, I am confident that, you know, we've gone from two hubs, four flights a day, just

1:48:26 a matter of six months ago.

1:48:28 Now we have a supply of 50 seats, right?

1:48:30 So some would argue maybe the Denver flight was a little premature.

1:48:34 We should have deferred that.

1:48:35 They were still trying to bring up average fares.

1:48:37 You know, there's a bad conversation.

1:48:40 But regardless of the Denver flight and that's worst flight, you know, having 150 seats

1:48:45 a day to Salt Lake and now having 50.

1:48:48 I would tend to think, you know, with the man we have, we should be able to maintain.

1:48:52 Certainly, I know those average fares are going to creep up.

1:48:55 Sure, I'm not going to play with that.

1:48:57 I'm just kind of looking at it and trying to make sure, and I believe we are.

1:49:03 I don't know a lot about the airport, but obviously learning as much as I can and being involved.

1:49:09 But yeah, thank you.

1:49:10 I appreciate it.

1:49:12 Thank you, Jason.

1:49:13 Thank you, Boyd.

1:49:14 They'll think very much that PowerPoint was, I really appreciated it, that, you know, pictures are always great, and I hope that people are listening, because this is a lot to absorb, and it's not a favorite position to be in for anybody, but we are navigating some tough waters, and I think, I think we have a great airport here, and I think we'll get through this.

1:49:43 And like you said, everybody said this together.

1:49:48 And the shortage of pilots is something that we've known.

1:49:52 There's certain things there is zero control over,

1:49:55 and you have to kind of roll with these are businesses,

1:49:58 and they're modeling their business

1:50:01 to get through the times.

1:50:03 And I appreciate the work that everybody's put into this.

1:50:07 Sean and Travis and everybody, there's

1:50:10 been a lot of people that have worked really hard on this.

1:50:13 appreciate that. Thank you. Thank you. Great Hawkins.

1:50:18 Bill, I just want to make sure I understand this right, but it'll be on a quarterly basis.

1:50:25 So if you were down and save the first part of this first quarter, and then the next quarter,

1:50:31 they show a real good profit. They don't average those two out. This just goes by a quarterly

1:50:35 basis. Correct. Okay. Thank you.

1:50:40 And then following up on that question, then do you know where we are here to date?

1:50:46 Because we're going to be hitting the end of the first quarter, you know, Thursday, right?

1:50:54 Conversations were January, which is typically slower.

1:50:57 They saw a loss of about 50, 55,000.

1:51:00 I think it was somewhere around 13 to 15,000.

1:51:03 They were estimating for February.

1:51:05 However, I'm hoping for a strong march with spring break and those things.

1:51:10 So hopefully we can maybe dilute some of those losses, but the first quarter may show a payment.

1:51:17 Okay, and then secondly, even though this is a 400,000 minimum guarantee, we're in this jointly with the county.

1:51:25 So it's technically 200,000 a piece, correct?

1:51:29 That's correct.

1:51:30 Craig Hawkins, do you?

1:51:33 John Berger.

1:51:36 Thank you, Mayor. So I just want to echo that I think this is a difficult situation to be in.

1:51:43 And I think we've found ourselves in challenging times

1:51:46 with air service over the past many years.

1:51:50 But this certainly feels like the most stinging conversation

1:51:55 I think to have.

1:51:56 I guess I look at this as less about the revenue guarantee,

1:52:01 which I think has a, feels distasteful to some folks,

1:52:06 because again, it has a private business.

1:52:08 I look at it more as the maintenance of air service.

1:52:11 So I've made the comment the last couple of weeks that the two fliches that come to mind are don't throw the baby out with the bathwater.

1:52:20 And a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush.

1:52:23 So knowing that we have current air service as challenging as it may be, I'm pleased to see the maze schedule already loaded as their early out late return.

1:52:37 which is a better connection whether you're traveling for leisure or business that was pretty difficult to get just at any place in the middle of the day.

1:52:45 That says to me there's a level of commitment from the Midwest as a provider here.

1:52:54 So as we've said in the past when we've looked at expansion of service or new flights like the United Service,

1:53:04 At the end of the day, it is applied to man, so we all have a responsibility that if we

1:53:11 are going to travel, a benefit means our needs to do our best to travel from Twin Falls.

1:53:17 And to those point, we went from 150 seats a day, just several months ago to 50 now.

1:53:25 So I would be hopeful we can fill those plain seats up on a regular basis, and those fairs

1:53:31 the cost provisions of Sky West and we will not have to worry about cutting any kind of a check for minimum revenue guarantees moving forward.

1:53:42 But again, I view this more as about preserving some level of service as minimal as it may be is better than the alternative of nothing.

1:53:53 Thank you, Sean.

1:53:55 Nicky Boyd.

1:53:56 I was going to make a motion if it weren't anybody else.

1:54:02 Okay, go ahead, Nicky.

1:54:04 Thank you.

1:54:05 Mayor, I move that we approve the agreement between the City of Twin Falls and Twin Falls

1:54:10 County and Skye West Airlines for a 400.

1:54:13 You can't read it.

1:54:16 You just put...

1:54:17 He has put the big thing over when I was reading.

1:54:22 Of a four hundred thousand minimum revenue guaranteed one daily delta flight between

1:54:30 When falls in Salt Lake City

1:54:37 International Airport is that what else is in that okay?

1:54:43 Authorize the mayor to sign. Thank you Nick. Yes, there's a second. Oh second

1:54:48 Who did that?

1:54:49 Jason Brown. Thank you Jason

1:54:51 Everybody in motion made by Nikki Boyd seconded by Jason Brown to approve the agreement

1:54:59 Between the city and the county and sky west for 400,000 minimum revenue guaranteed for one daily flight

1:55:07 Between Twin Falls and Salt Lake to be signed by the mayor Aaron roll call vote, please

1:55:14 Vice mayor read yes Sean Vericher. Yes, Nikki Boyd. Yes Craig Hawkins. Yes Jason Brown

1:55:21 Yes.

1:55:22 Mr. Cutler.

1:55:23 Yes.

1:55:24 Mr. Pierce.

1:55:25 Yes.

1:55:26 Thank you.

1:55:27 Motion carries seven to zero.

1:55:30 Okay.

1:55:31 Thank you.

1:55:32 Thank you.

1:55:33 Very much.

1:55:34 Okay.

1:55:36 Next item on the agenda is the time for public input.

1:55:40 This is a time for anyone from the public who wishes to come down to the podium and speak

1:55:47 on something that was any items that were not on the agenda.

1:55:55 no one advisory board reports. Anyone have an advisory board report any comments? Jason Brown?

1:56:03 I went to the Greater Twin Falls Transportation meeting at the beginning of the month and they also had a special meeting over in Burley talking about the third bridge option and some of those issues surrounding that.

1:56:24 I thought it was interesting that they're now looking or considering maybe another option

1:56:30 that they hadn't looked at.

1:56:32 So I think Commissioner Reiki said this morning on the radio, I think we make sure the public

1:56:38 is aware that that's going on and be involved.

1:56:42 Obviously it's a big part or it can have a big impact on the community.

1:56:47 So I think that's the update and just keep our eyes and ears open for that information.

1:56:55 Thank you, Jason.

1:56:58 City Manager's Office.

1:56:59 So just on that note that Councilman Brown just

1:57:04 talked about city staff has not seen or seen any official plans

1:57:11 or heard rumblings of what they may be.

1:57:15 They were meeting as a staff with representatives of ITD

1:57:21 later this week.

1:57:26 are intent that they share those information publicly,

1:57:30 whatever that plan may be,

1:57:32 and one possible that you will be the city council chambers.

1:57:37 We recognize that IITD does not report

1:57:41 to the city of Twin Falls.

1:57:43 However, significant roadway projects within our community,

1:57:48 hopefully will meet our approval

1:57:51 as we wanna continue a good partnership

1:57:55 with our transportation friends.

1:57:58 Yes, thank you very much, Travis.

1:58:01 They were here before, and I agree.

1:58:04 We need to hear them.

1:58:06 Anybody else?

1:58:07 Aye.

1:58:09 Next item on the agenda is a move to public,

1:58:13 or excuse me, executive session.

1:58:15 We have three executive session code sections

1:58:20 Code sections to consider Executive Session 24-2061-C to acquire interest in real property,

1:58:29 not owned by a public agency. Executive Session 74-2061-E to consider

1:58:36 preliminary negotiations involving matters of trade or commerce in which the governing

1:58:41 body is in competition with governing bodies in other states or nation and C.

1:58:46 Executive Session 74-206-1F to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency to

1:58:54 discuss the legal ramifications of and legal options for pending litigation or controversies

1:59:00 not yet being litigated but imminently likely to be litigated.

1:59:05 The mere presence of legal counsel at an executive session does not satisfy this requirement.

1:59:12 Council wishes to adjourn to executive session as stated.

1:59:18 Thank you.

1:59:19 Second.

1:59:20 Motion by Chris Reed.

1:59:21 Second by Sean Berrigger to move into executive session under these three sections.

1:59:27 Aaron Rokavo, please.

1:59:28 Sean Berrigger.

1:59:29 Yes.

1:59:30 Nicky Boyd.

1:59:31 Yes.

1:59:32 Craig Hawkins.

1:59:33 Yes.

1:59:34 Jason Brown.

1:59:35 Yes.

1:59:36 Spencer Keller.

1:59:37 Yes.

1:59:38 Mayor Pierce.

1:59:39 Yes.

1:59:41 Vice-Mayor Reed.

1:59:42 Yes.

1:59:43 I let everybody know that we will not be making any decisions in executive session, nor will

1:59:51 we be returning here afterwards, so thank you all.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, March 28, 2022. The recording started at 16:58 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:00:02.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    d11f5ed6328f822707a346d1f7f6deced5e0e22d69aa28c4c37b739ef9a8e0ba
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 9350e859feed9df1fdef9a3f91f88cb3b2c854ca9424977efd1413367a053218
    part02.m4a 7725b977dda2c72de06984dbcc8b2566ea1d98186c81bb4a2b0fd4bc53264125
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    b2d2562a19e4e7ebabe32f99b398600cd7a0d876c354fe1c564d7fc7879eacb9

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file