City Council meeting
Monday, August 1, 2022
Special meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: b
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:01:14 Okay, it's four o'clock.
0:01:16 Welcome everyone to the August 1st, 2022 City Council meeting.
0:01:24 I will confirm we have a quorum five of the six or seven members are present in chambers,
0:01:34 but that is a quorum.
0:01:37 First item on the agenda is executive session.
0:01:41 We will be moving into executive session under 74-206-1B
0:01:48 to consider evaluation, dismissal, or disciplining
0:01:51 of or to hear complaints or charges brought
0:01:54 against any public officer employee, staff member,
0:01:57 individual agent, or public student.
0:02:01 Council wishes.
0:02:03 So motion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Nicky Boyd to approve moving into executive session.
0:02:12 Aaron, roll call vote, please.
0:02:13 Mayor Pears?
0:02:16 Yes.
0:02:17 Vice-Mayor Reed?
0:02:18 Yes.
0:02:18 Nicky Boyd?
0:02:19 Yes.
0:02:19 Craig Hawkins?
0:02:20 Yes.
0:02:21 Jason Brown?
0:02:22 Yes.
0:02:23 Thank you.
0:02:23 Motion passes 5 to 0.
0:02:26 So we will be moving into executive session for the next hour.
0:02:30 And we'll be back promptly at five, five o'clock to continue regular business.
0:02:37 Thank you.
0:03:17 Good evening, ladies and gentlemen.
0:03:19 And welcome to back to, we're back to the August 1st, 2022 city council meeting.
0:03:28 Um, we, um, met at seven or four o'clock, uh, went into executive session and are
0:03:37 finished.
0:03:37 And now we'll start our regular meeting.
0:03:39 I will again confirm we have a quorum. We have five members present and councilman
0:03:47 color is excused today. So the first item on the agenda if you wish to join me is the
0:03:54 Pledge of Allegiance. There's no proclamations tonight. So the next item on the agenda is the
0:04:23 consent calendar. Council wishes. Craig Hawkins. Thank you, Christopher Reed. Second. Thank
0:04:37 you. Motion by Craig Hawkins. Seconded by Christopher Reed. Approved the consent calendar. Erin
0:04:43 Roekaw, please. Yes. Vice Mayor Reed. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 5 to 0. So if you're
0:04:58 here for this summer's showdown car show and the Edward Byrne Memorial
0:05:04 JAG. Oh that's the grant. So if you're here for the car show it's been approved.
0:05:09 So next item on the agenda is items of consideration. It's a presentation of
0:05:15 post basic certificates to officers Ryan Carlson, Alexandra McLean, Riley
0:05:23 with we widely presentation opposed basic and intermediate certificates to
0:05:29 officer Kevin Warner and post-advanced certificate to officer Salko Leilich
0:05:36 I said that right and we have Chief Kingsbury about tonight but you're
0:05:41 those you're pretty close okay good yeah okay thank you mayor council thank
0:05:48 you for allowing us to come before you this evening and celebrate of the
0:05:53 men and women of the Twin Falls Police Park. Tonight is, it's a great night. We're gonna
0:06:00 recognize several members of our organization through their time and
0:06:07 training have received different levels of IDOPs, officers, standards, and training
0:06:13 certifications. And as we'll explain in more detail from Lieutenant Garter and
0:06:19 Lieutenant Allen, our certifications, our post-certifications, and Idaho are our
0:06:25 license to be peace officers. So we're going to recognize these men and women
0:06:30 who have received these different levels of licensing standards here in the state
0:06:35 of Idaho. So I'd like to have Captain Hicks and Captain Wright come down to
0:06:40 assist and I'm going to turn the presentation over to Lieutenant Chuck
0:06:44 Carter and the tenants of the Gallant are to patrol the tenants of whom these officers
0:06:50 all work under their command. Thank you Chief. Madam Mayor, members of the Council.
0:07:02 Thank you for giving us this opportunity tonight. She recognized these very important career milestones for all these officers.
0:07:11 The State of Idaho Peace Officer stands in training council for poses I would refer to
0:07:18 of the criminal, the seven levels of certification for police officers.
0:07:23 Basic, intermediate, advanced, master, supervisor, management, and executive.
0:07:31 What we'll be recognizing tonight are the first three levels of post certification
0:07:37 to achieve these certificates officers have to have, for instance,
0:07:42 the basic certificate.
0:07:45 Graduation of a post-approved academy,
0:07:48 We should have a field training program in one year of service.
0:07:53 All the way up to an intermediate to an advanced, which oftentimes
0:07:57 depend on your service actually requires college education as well.
0:08:01 Lieutenant Allen, I have the pleasure of awarding four post-based
0:08:07 certificates, one post-intermediate certificate, and one post-advanced certificate.
0:08:13 One of our officers will be receiving the basic and intermediate certificate tonight.
0:08:17 Tonight, I'd like to have officers, Kevin Warner, Ryan Carlson, Riley Whiteley,
0:08:24 Salko Lilik, Emdell, from Unfield Stand, between the Chief and I, Officer Alexander McLean,
0:08:34 and guys, when I read your bio, I think one step forward is to be my body's voice.
0:08:53 Let's go and talk to them.
0:08:55 Officer Alexander McLean grew up in Pule, Idaho, and graduated from Pule High School in 2011.
0:09:07 Alex began working for felony probation and parole in 2014 while attending BSU where she earned her bachelor's degree in criminal justice.
0:09:14 Alex decided to follow her career dreams in 2020 and applied with the TFPD where she was hired in May of 2021.
0:09:22 Alex is completed just over one year with the Twin Falls Police Department and received her post basic certification.
0:09:29 Officer Kevin Warner. Kevin Warner was born and raised in northwest Ohio. He
0:10:03 attended the University of Toledo until 2016. He was hired by the San Diego Police
0:10:08 Department. Kevin enjoyed his time at the San Diego Police Department from
0:10:11 September 2016 until July 2021. In August of 2021, Kevin decided for a change of
0:10:19 lifestyle and he and his girlfriend moved to Twin Falls where we have since
0:10:23 employed tonight. Kevin will be awarded the post-intermediate certificate as well as the
0:10:30 post-based certificate because of all of his training and he received in California as well as
0:10:36 all of his college credits. Kevin actually qualifies for the immediate certificate a little earlier
0:10:41 than the most officers. Officer Salka Lily. Salka Lily was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department
0:11:18 March 14, 2016.
0:11:20 Salka was born in Bosnia in 1991.
0:11:23 The war in Bosnia took place in 1992 through 1995, which made his life very complicated.
0:11:31 Salka lost his father in that war.
0:11:34 Salka, his mother, and one of his sisters came to Twin Falls on February 12, 2002,
0:11:39 joined some ants and uncles who were already living here.
0:11:42 One of his sisters still lives in Bosnia, and another sister lives in Australia.
0:11:49 The SACO graduated from Twin Falls High School, went on to further his education at the College of Southern Idaho,
0:11:54 where he attained associate's degrees in law enforcement and criminal justice.
0:11:58 In 2016, the SACO received his bachelor's degree in criminal justice for Boise State University.
0:12:04 The SACO attended post basic patrol academy session 186 and graduated on June 3, 2016.
0:12:11 He was awarded his post basic patrol certification in November 2016,
0:12:16 and his post intermediate certification in October 2018.
0:12:19 Great pleasure that I present Officer Lillick with this post-advanced certificate.
0:12:27 The certificate he earned, Lillick had his schedule and other officers because of his college degree.
0:12:32 We present the awards, the certifications to the officers who work under us.
0:13:05 That's why we switched.
0:13:06 The three officers just presented work for Lieutenant Gardner and the two all being presenting work for me.
0:13:11 So can I have Ryan? Officer Ryan Carlson, step four, please.
0:13:15 Officer Carlson was born and raised at Twin Falls, Idaho.
0:13:19 After graduating from Twin Falls High School,
0:13:21 he attended Weber State on a track and field scholarship.
0:13:24 Ryan graduated with a Bachelor of Science in Criminal Justice
0:13:28 and a minor in Communications.
0:13:30 After college, Ryan moved back to Twin Falls
0:13:32 and began his career in law enforcement
0:13:34 with the Twin Falls County Sheriff's Department as a jail deputy.
0:13:37 After about two years of working in the jail, he came over
0:13:40 and began working for us as a patrol officer,
0:13:43 which he was happy to do for us.
0:13:45 So today Ryan has completed his one year of the Police Department and he'll be receiving his basic certificate.
0:13:53 But I have Officer Riley Wiley step forward please. Officer Wiley was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department in August of 2021.
0:14:19 Ryan's family relocated to Twin Falls from Logan Utah after he graduated from Utah State University.
0:14:26 Riley grew up in Oakley and was glad to come back to the area.
0:14:30 Riley's completed his year with the police department has also
0:14:33 earned his football. Here's a post basic certificate. That concludes our
0:14:55 certification of certificates for the officers.
0:14:59 Then a mayor members of the council with your permission, I'd like to have
0:15:06 these officers remain standing and go into item two on the agenda please.
0:15:09 Perfect. Thank you. Mayor members of the city council,
0:15:22 everybody here in City Hall and those watching.
0:15:25 It is always an honor, number one, to recognize officers that are
0:15:30 is level of poster certificates, but it's also an honor to promote people to different levels of
0:15:37 supervision within our organization. I'm excited for tonight's promotion for a couple of reasons.
0:15:46 Right now in the sworn side of the police department, we have one female supervisor,
0:15:53 effective tonight we will have to so I would like to ask officer Candace Orr to
0:16:02 come down and stand to my left members counsel Candace Orr was hired by the
0:16:24 Twin Falls Police Department in 2016 in fact Candace was one of the first few
0:16:31 officers hired after I became the police chief she came to us from the
0:16:36 City of Mountain Home where she worked as a police officer there.
0:16:40 Candace was born and raised in Winamuck, Nevada.
0:16:43 She moved to Idaho in 2012 where she attended the College of Southern Idaho.
0:16:48 She enrolled in the law enforcement program and graduated in 2014 with the
0:16:52 Massoches Degree in Criminal Justice and Law Enforcement.
0:16:56 As I mentioned after graduating she went to work for the Mountain Home Police Department.
0:17:01 She was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department in June of 2016.
0:17:05 As I mentioned, one of the first handful of people that hired after I became the Chief
0:17:10 in January of the IU.
0:17:13 Candice is excelled here at the Twin Falls Police Department.
0:17:16 Her experience combined with Mountain Home in Twin Falls, she became a Field Training
0:17:21 Officer early on in her career here with TFPD.
0:17:24 She's also a member of our Honor Guard, where she represents our organization at formal events
0:17:32 and sometimes law enforcement line of duty funerals throughout the Pacific Northwest.
0:17:38 And this currently holds an intermediate certificate from State of Idaho Peace Officer
0:17:43 Standards and Training.
0:17:44 She's also one of our taser instructors, another reason to be nice to her.
0:17:50 Now Candice is in week 11 of her 12 week FMOA for the birth of her first child.
0:18:01 And Remy is here this evening out in the audience, so right over here, I'm leaving her mother's
0:18:09 promotion while her husband is off fighting with fighters.
0:18:16 Now are we FaceTiming live?
0:18:18 Okay, so he's here watching us over FaceTime, so hello.
0:18:25 And he is a BLM firefighter, correct?
0:18:28 So he's more about to see that right now.
0:18:31 Wyoming.
0:18:32 Wildland firefighter out there who see a family of service so we're really glad
0:18:39 that he can be with us over FaceTime. Thank goodness for technology. So Captain
0:18:47 Wright and Captain Tex if you would come forward please and then Sergeant Luke
0:18:53 Coronado if you would come down. Candace has asked Sergeant Coronado to pin her
0:19:02 badge. So I'm going to present the Corporal Badge to Sergeant Coronado, the police officers
0:19:08 badge. So what I'd like to do now, as you probably remember Mayor Council of Tradition
0:19:57 at the TFPD, they have all members of the Supervisors Coalition come down, shake Corporal
0:20:02 Ors Hand and hand her her first set of Corporal Stripes. And they'll also have to be able to
0:20:07 thank and recognize these officers for their certifications. And then when they are done,
0:20:11 I'm going to invite Mayor Council of City Management team to come in and congratulate this group.
0:20:17 A little bit about Canis' family, but could we have the rest of the group introduce their family's fleet?
0:22:30 Mayor, we absolutely can. So we'll just start right on the end with Officer McLean.
0:22:34 My boyfriend Mitch here.
0:22:42 His wife's name is Dean. Mom's I need to end the baby sleeping nylon.
0:23:02 from kiwai my boy leon earth carlman and up in the back corner i've got my wife kayla and my
0:23:39 daughter aliza mayor thank you nice catch i almost forgot i appreciate that as you know
0:23:50 we love being part of the city of twin falls family and of course that comes with all of our
0:23:55 extended family so without further ado i thank you for the time to do this presentation
0:24:01 Congratulations to each and every one of you.
0:24:04 Thank you, Chief, and congratulations all.
0:24:07 So, before we move to the next item on the agenda,
0:24:18 if I know that there will be a group leaving,
0:24:21 we'll give you a minute if you want to get out of here,
0:24:25 or you're welcome to stay. We're doing a really important budget discussion.
0:24:29 Yeah, yeah, I see that.
0:24:35 Yeah.
0:25:38 So next item on the agenda is action item.
0:25:43 It's a request from Southern Idaho Tourism Syndrome 2020
0:25:47 to allocate contingency funds in the amount of $10,000
0:25:52 for the Auger Falls Broken Bridge Project.
0:25:56 And we have Melissa Berry, our Executive Director
0:25:59 from Southern Idaho Tourism, welcome.
0:26:02 Thank you Madam Mayor and Council.
0:26:04 I appreciate your time this evening.
0:26:05 was kind of fun with all the extra action tonight and kiddos and whatnot.
0:26:09 But I was just made aware, so I apologize that the old letter was made in part of your packet,
0:26:15 so there's actually been an updated letter, so I'm not sure what the process will be to get that to you,
0:26:20 but hopefully that will come here in the next little bit.
0:26:24 But just to give you an update, we are looking back at the Auger Falls Broken Bridge project.
0:26:33 We're going to put it up.
0:26:35 Back in 2020, I believe we originally requested $10,000
0:26:39 as part of a grant match piece.
0:26:42 And so we have moved forward since then.
0:26:45 The grant that we applied for was federal.
0:26:48 And based on some of the testing requirements of the water,
0:26:52 there just wasn't the ability to be able to have
0:26:55 those kinds of numbers to fulfill what the federal money's
0:26:59 request was trying to get from us.
0:27:01 So we've moved away from that.
0:27:03 However, Jerome County has seen this
0:27:05 is a very viable project that they want to continue with.
0:27:08 And they've found additional funding
0:27:10 to go ahead and cover the majority of this project.
0:27:13 Because obviously Twin Falls is a big part of it
0:27:16 with half of the bridge connecting onto other falls,
0:27:19 we want to make sure that the city is invested.
0:27:22 We're still requesting the same amount of money, $10,000.
0:27:26 Like I said, Jerome County has put forth
0:27:28 a great deal of the funds.
0:27:30 And fortunately with the revamp,
0:27:32 fortunately and unfortunately with the revamp,
0:27:34 There's been a lot of increases in construction prices and materials, so the bridge itself
0:27:39 is going to look a little bit different, so that's an update.
0:27:43 But for the rest of it, the great part is the additional funds from the drum side will
0:27:48 also go towards fixing the grade, and so vehicle access will be re-established on the north
0:27:55 side of the Canyon for authorized vehicles.
0:27:57 So we're not letting everyone go down there, but they're going to install a gate so that
0:28:01 that way, emergencies, there's an additional exit out
0:28:04 through that Yanks grade side, because right now,
0:28:06 it was washed out, and there's only just pedestrian access.
0:28:11 So that's an additional positive of this new plan.
0:28:15 Otherwise, the one other downfall that I would give
0:28:18 is that it unfortunately will not be able to be used
0:28:20 at high water, but that was part of the previous plan.
0:28:23 I just think this one is probably
0:28:26 at a little bit lower high water, if that makes sense.
0:28:29 So there's still gonna be the ability,
0:28:31 But if it gets to a certain level, then the bridge will need to be shut down.
0:28:34 But otherwise, it will connect both sides of the canyon.
0:28:36 It's pedestrian friendly.
0:28:38 It will kind of start the process of these regional trails.
0:28:42 It's a really great thing for our communities.
0:28:45 Auger Falls itself is a very highly used park with lots of traffic.
0:28:49 And we just see this as an awesome opportunity to help extend not only
0:28:53 Auger Falls trails, but those that would connect to this anchor for Canyon's park.
0:28:58 So that is our request.
0:28:59 I'm not sure exactly what the previous letter said quite on that level.
0:29:04 But if you guys have questions, I would be happy to see them for questions.
0:29:08 Any questions for Melissa, Jason Brown?
0:29:21 So just looking at the letter, not having a lot of time to take a look at it.
0:29:28 There was some mention with the floodway or the floodplain.
0:29:31 Down in there, you were working with the Idaho Department of Water Resource.
0:29:34 Is that correct?
0:29:35 The engineer was working with the Idaho Department of Water Resource to map that and to see what type of impact we had.
0:29:44 So they're still working through all of the exact details, but yes, they've got all of the appropriate agencies involved.
0:29:51 They just don't have quite the specific plans, so they're just making sure that what Gerald has presented will be workable for each agency that's involved, and I believe there are several of them.
0:30:02 Okay, and so that the $10,000 if approved tonight would be a contingency to help pay for the construction or through some of the engineering and getting through some of the department issues.
0:30:18 So most of the engineering was part of the match that was originally in the grant application.
0:30:24 So there's not a lot of costs associated with that, but the cost for the bridge, the estimated cost is about 54,000.
0:30:32 So your 10,000 would be a part of that.
0:30:34 And then the additional funds that Jerome County has
0:30:36 will go towards the improvements on the north side.
0:30:41 Thank you, Board.
0:30:53 Next, I do have an update on that, though.
0:30:56 So the new Southern Idaho Legacy Trails Group
0:30:58 that has established, we are going
0:31:00 to help sponsor their paddle, the Snake event
0:31:03 that they have coming up.
0:31:04 And those funds will be used for this project as well.
0:31:07 So we're still satisfying that part of the match,
0:31:10 even though it's not required anymore.
0:31:12 We felt like this was a good project for not only
0:31:15 I hope tours are going to be part of, but also the new trails organization.
0:31:18 It's a great way to kind of start getting some momentum for them, so I think both on
0:31:24 that level.
0:31:25 And I was asking because they during all this time they are no more, and if you short money,
0:31:33 I was just trying to figure out where this was coming from or whatever, so that's great.
0:31:37 Thank you, Chris.
0:31:39 What's the time frame on the completion of the bridge?
0:31:44 So I don't know if we've gotten quite to that point where we have an exact time frame just
0:31:48 because we're still a little bit in the moving with the different agencies, but I would assume
0:31:53 by next year was when it would probably start because there's a little bit with the BLM also
0:31:56 on the Eagles Nesting, and so that's a consideration that construction has to take in and make
0:32:03 sure that they're not going to disrupt any of the wildlife.
0:32:06 I ask a second question.
0:32:08 Understanding that there's a lot of other agencies that have to sign off on this.
0:32:13 there's an agency that does not what happens to these funds. Do they come back to the city
0:32:18 and this project is no longer? Yes. Okay. So just to be clear we committed $10,000 once before
0:32:29 and you're saying that never was used. Correct. And so this is basically which if it was in the
0:32:35 budget would have carried forward. It wasn't in the budget. It was the length of time from
0:32:43 the council's approval that causes the council to have to reauthorize the use of that $10,000
0:32:50 per our internal budgetary problem policies. Okay. Council wishes, Christopher Reed. I'll
0:32:57 make a motion. I'll send you a second. Okay. I move that we approve the request from Southern
0:33:02 Idaho Tourism and Jerome 2020 to allocate contingency funds in the amount of $10,000
0:33:08 for the Argar Falls Broken Bridge project. Great Hawkins. Thank you.
0:33:13 Motion by Christopher Reed second by Craig Hawkins to approve the request from
0:33:18 Southern Idaho Tourism in Jerome 2020 to allocate contingencies to CFUNs in the
0:33:23 amount of $10,000. Any further discussion? Aaron Roll call vote please.
0:33:32 Vice-Mayor Reed. Yes. Thank you Boyd. Yes. Craig Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Mayor Pierce. Yes.
0:33:40 Thank you motion passes five to zero.
0:33:43 Thank you mayor and council.
0:33:45 Thank you Melissa.
0:33:46 Okay next item on the agenda is an action item request to pass ordinance 2022 dash 014 amending city code to clarify penalty language for certain violations.
0:34:03 And we have Sam views our deputy city prosecutors welcome Sam.
0:34:10 members of the City Council, I'm going to help the summary I provided was clear enough.
0:34:14 Essentially we had a couple of different ordinances that had penalty provisions listed in the City
0:34:20 Code with regards to clean up property, harboring, and vicious dog that provided for a civil
0:34:27 penalty portion as well as a criminal penalty portion.
0:34:31 It wasn't clear at least one judge considering kind of how one of these was drafted said it's
0:34:37 It's not really clear to me, so I'm going to say you can only do an infraction.
0:34:41 Our preference is in particular with property cleanliness, I think our general practice is
0:34:45 that the vast majority of these are a civil penalty issue, but we've had some come upwards.
0:34:50 A repetitive issue, one was over the course of a decade, deeper complaining, property not
0:34:55 getting cleaned up, and a hundred dollar fine, not resolving it ever.
0:34:59 And so then we went to the misdemeanor portion, we were able to gain some traction with that
0:35:03 person to hopefully find some lasting solutions.
0:35:07 So it's, I think it's the intention of the ordinances was always drafted.
0:35:10 We're trying to clear it up so that it's absolutely clear to the judges.
0:35:14 We want both these options available and in an appropriate case, we can pursue the misdemeanor
0:35:18 option as well as stand for questions.
0:35:23 Any questions for Sam?
0:35:27 So it appears that if we do want to act on this today and pass it tonight, we put it
0:35:34 on third and final.
0:35:36 Correct.
0:35:37 Yes, we need five members to approve that and then we could move forward.
0:35:40 Okay, perfect.
0:35:42 Council wishes.
0:35:48 Hickey Boyd.
0:35:49 Air, I visit, we put dash zero, one, four.
0:36:02 Thank you.
0:36:03 Is there a second, Craig Hawkins?
0:36:05 Second.
0:36:06 Motion by Nikki Boyd, seconded by Craig Hawkins to put an ordinance 2022 dash zero, one,
0:36:14 four on third and final reading by title only suspending the rules.
0:36:19 Aaron roll call vote, please.
0:36:26 Yes.
0:36:27 Jason Brown.
0:36:28 Yes.
0:36:29 Mayor Pierce.
0:36:30 Yes.
0:36:31 Vice-Mary.
0:36:32 Yes.
0:36:33 Thank you, motion passes five to zero.
0:36:34 Thank you, Sam.
0:36:35 Thank you.
0:36:38 Okay.
0:36:39 Next item on the agenda.
0:36:40 Oh.
0:36:41 Oh, I'm sorry.
0:36:43 I do that every time.
0:36:45 I'll get there someday.
0:36:50 Sam, I couldn't have excused you.
0:36:52 That's all right.
0:36:53 Happy to be back.
0:36:54 Yeah, ordinance number 2022 dash 014,
0:36:58 an ordinance of the city council of the city of Twin Falls,
0:37:01 Idaho amending titles six and seven of the time,
0:37:05 Twin Falls County, excuse me,
0:37:07 Twin Falls city code clarifying potential penalties
0:37:11 for certain offenses and providing an effective date.
0:37:14 Therefore, council wishes, Jason Brown.
0:37:22 Yeah, there, quick, sorry.
0:37:25 So I move that we approve, move to approve ordinance.
0:37:40 Number 20 22 dash 0 1 4
0:37:43 Many city code to clarify penalty language for certain violations. Thank you cuz we're read
0:37:50 Thank you motion by Jason Brown seconded by Chris Reed
0:37:54 Two pass ordinance 22 dash 0 1 4 amending city code to clarify penalty language for certain violations
0:38:02 Aaron roll call vote please
0:38:07 Yes, Jason Brown. Yes
0:38:09 Yes. Mayor Pierce? Yes. Vice-Mayor Reed? Yes. Nicki Point? Yes. Thank you. Motion passes
0:38:17 five to zero. Now you can sit down. Thank you. A next item on the agenda is again an
0:38:24 action item, acceptance of Sean Barrigar's resignation from the City Council and discussion
0:38:31 on the process to fill the vacancy created by the resignation and we have our city manager
0:38:36 Travis Rothweiler.
0:38:37 Welcome, Madam Mayor, members of the City Council.
0:38:42 So as you're aware of the conclusion of last week's meeting, Sean Berger stepped down from
0:38:52 the City Council in the middle of his term.
0:38:56 And while it is not the first time that it has occurred in our organization, in fact,
0:39:02 There have been a few different occurrences in my tenure as the city manager.
0:39:09 Idaho Code does provide a level of guidance in terms of the process, at least how it is supposed to work.
0:39:19 The process is that the mayor by Idaho Code 50-704 has the authority and the responsibility to candidate to fill the vacancy.
0:39:38 person must be confirmed by the city council. And so it is not just the mayor's choice alone,
0:39:48 because it does require former members of the city council based upon having sex to say that
0:39:54 they agree that choice. And so we have over the last several years did it in a series of
0:40:06 different ways in having conversations with some of you. I don't believe you
0:40:14 would describe how we've done this in the past as the most effective way to
0:40:20 move forward. In fact what we've done in the past is we've had a small committee
0:40:25 of council members review and then make a recommendation and go forward. We had a
0:40:33 a come one and come all, and in which you interviewed, I think it was 1924, 24 individual candidates,
0:40:46 but who was counting, right?
0:40:50 And in both of those processes, I think that the letter of the law was followed, because
0:40:58 at the conclusion of both those processes, the council, the mayor, made an imitation of
0:41:09 the count recommendation, and so the Idaho code was carried out, but in our
0:41:17 always pursuit of training, so you can certainly do that. There is a recent
0:41:26 process that has proven to be very, very effective, and that is our input
0:41:32 process, and so I will share a series of different processes. So number one,
0:41:38 everything that you do must be done transparently and in the light of day.
0:41:43 So this is not a conversation that you are allowed to go into executive session to have private conversations.
0:41:50 The selection of an elected official to fill a vacancy must be done so that the public can view the entirety of the process.
0:42:04 Staff would suggest that a MPOG process could be something to follow in which we would as an organization
0:42:16 work with Josh Palmer, our Public Information Officer,
0:42:20 to make an announcement and ask qualified electors
0:42:26 as defined by Idaho Code.
0:42:29 Submit their letters of interest for your consideration.
0:42:34 And we would leave that period open for about two weeks,
0:42:39 which is very similar to the filing process for,
0:42:44 as a city council person in that filing window. It would submit their letter to you and we would
0:42:51 present all of those letters to the council. The council then has the opportunity to take those
0:42:58 letters and then independently score them. Let's say that you get 24. I might suggest that you
0:43:08 score your top three and you score those top three on a point scale and then what we would do is we
0:43:16 would have you disclose your top three candidates in a ranked numerical order, would then show
0:43:25 what those were, and that you may choose to interview some, maybe it's six, so that could
0:43:43 possibly have your top choice, and it is considered by the entirety of the council.
0:43:50 The point system I would suggest would be one where your number one candidate would
0:43:54 receive say four points. A number two candidate would receive two and a number
0:43:59 three candidate would receive one if you want to do a point of some. Sounds a
0:44:04 little complicated. You could also say come one come all and we could interview
0:44:10 the entirety of the number of people that would come forward. Our job as
0:44:17 staff is in and chained with legal counsel certainly here to answer any
0:44:21 legal questions that you might have, is just to help you through a process that allows you
0:44:28 to select the person that will serve out the balance of the term.
0:44:34 So this person would then be appointed and while the term does end in December, the conclusion
0:44:43 of December of 23, if this was a longer term, they would still have to stand for that re-election
0:44:50 because the Idaho Code is fairly clear in which it states that the person, at the next general election of the city, the person must run to retain the seat.
0:45:00 So with that, I'm happy to stand for any questions.
0:45:04 We're just trying to outline a process that allows you to move forward at the end.
0:45:12 What will happen is, on this process, it would still become the mayor's recommendation.
0:45:20 recommendation it would be a council to vote to confirm and then the person be seated after.
0:45:37 Travis does all of this happen at one meeting so there's a two-week period we get letters
0:45:42 like with him called before the meeting. Yeah we would. And then. No just because we wouldn't
0:45:53 know who to invite for the interview and so what we would do is we would probably take
0:45:57 the letters we would present those letters to you and then we would ask for the following
0:46:03 council meeting to have those individuals come forward. As we're looking at the calendar
0:46:08 right now we want to move relatively expeditiously and so we're looking at potentially having the
0:46:14 interviews August. There is, it is at the conclusion of the budget, but the agenda seems to be
0:46:28 a evening in which you could dedicate considerable timeline forward with the process. The council
0:46:42 That looks good. We open the process up from this evening,
0:46:51 under-receive those letters, would make them available
0:46:57 for make those letters available, score them 20 seconds.
0:47:14 If you wanted to do that process, if you didn't want to do that process,
0:47:28 certainly there is the other process that we used,
0:47:33 which is anyone who submits their letters of interest and is a qualified voter would be somebody
0:47:39 that you would provide time to provide an address to the council as well as the opportunity to
0:47:46 ask questions. Chris Reed, looking over the past appointments to the council, the hider,
0:47:55 I do not remember that one. I was not here, but Lance Brown, Don Hall, on those two, he was very much
0:48:05 more of a, you present your case why you would like to be on the council, everybody listened
0:48:12 to it, it was one evening and then the next week remained the choice and then council approved
0:48:19 again. Personally that I like that, I understand it could potentially be very long, that first
0:48:30 evening meeting those letters and then giving individuals two, three minute whatever time
0:48:39 We a lot just seems a little bit easier not to score this going through the scoring
0:48:46 and fighting for interviews that process.
0:48:49 It's one evening next week just finishing it up.
0:48:54 That's my opinion. I will go along but that one just seems a little bit easier to me.
0:49:02 It may be a little bit longer but it gets to participate in the process.
0:49:09 Anybody else have any comments?
0:49:14 Jason, yes. I do like the fact of actually having having a start date and
0:49:26 date of knowing who having the opportunity to look at the application
0:49:32 resume however you want to put it but I would also I guess my feeling is is
0:49:37 giving the individuals a couple of minutes to do that and the reason I say
0:49:43 that that be for my own personal experience a lot of oftentimes I'm
0:49:49 I'm more comfortable standing in front of people trying to express my feelings than I am writing my feelings.
0:49:56 And I think if we have a culmination of both, setting it out, saying you have to tell this date to write one page submittal, we have a chance to look at them.
0:50:08 And to me we'd be more educated to ask the questions of those individuals at that time.
0:50:15 If you're better at writing, your feelings and opinions are great.
0:50:18 If you're better at communicating those verbally, I think you give people both options to be able to click the song and come up with a question.
0:51:19 That's where everybody just comes on one night and it's all contained in one.
0:51:22 You talk to multiple, it goes on and on.
0:51:32 So there are good nights, there's bad nights, there's everything in between the present.
0:51:42 They should put something in writing. I mean, they're going to put it in when they run.
0:51:53 and they run something and writing is really good and also articulate and show their personality
0:52:06 and I think that's really important. Jason, did you have another comment?
0:52:13 One more thing. I do like the 29th if that works out with the budget and the process.
0:52:19 Having that night, it's a little quicker, counsel leading than giving it in the same amount.
0:52:27 I definitely wouldn't want to extend it any further than that.
0:52:33 Well, thank you for the for the direction what we will do is we will
0:52:41 work with Josh Palmer
0:52:44 Create
0:52:48 Appropriate application on the city's website
0:52:51 Individuals will also be able to submit letters of interest. We will collect those we will present those to the council and then we will
0:52:58 reserve the 29th for
0:53:00 All interested individuals to be able to interview and then from that point
0:53:05 to listen to all the candidates and they'll be the mayor's opportunity to
0:53:12 select the person that is best suited for the council's responsibility to confirm
0:53:22 that appointment. So it looks like thank you very much Travis it looks like we
0:53:29 need to officially accept Sean's resignation Chris Reed. I was gonna say
0:53:36 nice things about Sean during this but he's not here so we don't need to we can
0:53:40 just accept on move on all right that we accept the resignation of Sir Sean
0:54:20 Okay. Excellent. Thank you. Motion passes five to zero. Thank you. Next item on the agenda is a presentation, a presentation on the finances of the City of Twin Falls for the third quarter of fiscal year 2021-22.
0:54:38 And we have our CFO Brianna Howard. Welcome Brianna. I haven't done one of these for a while.
0:54:46 meeting there and council, here's the fun stuff.
0:55:08 So I'm gonna talk about the third quarter of this year,
0:55:11 2022 financial update.
0:55:13 We're gonna talk about the tax-supported funds,
0:55:15 the enterprise funds and a little bit about statistics
0:55:19 and what we're seeing nationwide
0:55:21 and how it relates to the city
0:55:23 and what we're seeing internally.
0:55:27 The first slide here is a recap of the total budget
0:55:31 and major fund composition between fiscal year 2122.
0:55:35 As you can see on this top left of this slide, 41% of our $77, almost $78 million budget is the non-tax supported funds.
0:55:43 So that's like our enterprise funds, water, wastewater, sanitation, and 59% is our tax supported funds, making up $46,403,000.
0:55:54 On the right is our major fund composition.
0:55:57 You can see 41% of our total budget is our general fund.
0:56:02 This is like police fire, those are the bigger parts of our general fund.
0:56:08 The other two top ones are water of 17% and wastewater at 13%.
0:56:15 You'll remember in government funding, we have a zero based budgeting.
0:56:19 So this is our revenues, but our expenses match our revenues.
0:56:22 So whatever is shown here are your revenues in each of the funds and the expenses.
0:56:29 This next slide shows our largest revenue categories providing funds for these sources.
0:56:35 The total revenues and the tax-supported funds only makes up $46 million and six largest revenue sources make up 88%.
0:56:45 Property taxes are right around $25 million at 55%.
0:56:50 Our state's shared revenues is $5.2 million.
0:56:53 transfer, so that's like wastewater water transferring money to the general
0:56:58 charge of the tax-supported funds, $3.6 million. We've got dedicated street
0:57:03 money of $3.5 million and franchise fees of almost $2 million. The largest revenue
0:57:09 sources in that other category are comprised of permits at $1.4 million and
0:57:14 airport revenues of $1.2 million. All others are less than a million dollars. I
0:57:20 I'd like to show the property tax revenues in the last four years.
0:57:28 You can see the graduated increase starting in 2019 of 20 million.
0:57:33 It incrementally goes up to 22, 23, 25, kind of a good in a nutshell for me.
0:57:40 It's just a little over a million to a million and a half is what we increase it each year.
0:57:45 The 2021 numbers has three different bars shown on there.
0:57:50 if you'll remember that's because we opt into Governor Little's CARES Act
0:57:55 sharing where we received $5.2 million from the plan, the CARES money, and then it was
0:58:02 given out to our constituents. But the total money there was still a $23 almost
0:58:07 $24 million. Talked to Becky Pearson at the Twin Falls County Treasurer and she says
0:58:15 collections are at 97.92% through June 30th and she says that's the highest it's
0:58:21 been in the last 21 years. Again, it doesn't mean that we're going to receive more or less but
0:58:28 it's an indicator of how we are in the City of Twin Falls and how how steady our revenue is.
0:58:39 The other components in our tax-supported funds is highway user revenue which is just
0:58:43 over where we budgeted. This is not pro-rata through the year. It's based on when people travel and
0:58:49 how much they are consuming fuels. This includes county road and bridge taxes of just over
0:58:54 a million dollars of the 3.5 and we normally get those in January and July, vehicle registration
0:59:00 fees and state fuel taxes. Our state share revenues, the second one of 5.2 million, is
0:59:08 include sales tax and liquor in a received quarterly. We are capped at a 1% increase
0:59:13 but this year we've received a significant distribution based off of our
0:59:17 pro-rata share because the state of Idaho has received quite a bit more money in
0:59:22 sales tax revenue. The last piece is franchise fees and just as a side note since
0:59:30 we're talking about state revenue sharing and liquor this one is just for
0:59:34 fun. I thought it was interesting I found this chart of gallons per year per adult
0:59:39 ages 21 are over since 2019 as you can see the yellow is 19% whereas the deep
0:59:47 red is 41% I wanted to say way to go Montana and New Hampshire and since our
0:59:53 city manager comes from Montana I was wondering if there was a correlation.
0:59:58 Brand size fees this breaks out the franchise fees you can see most are
1:00:06 pretty consistent with the exception of our electric we have continued to have
1:00:11 record high summers and our franchise fees come in higher each year. If you'll
1:00:17 remember this is the rent that a utility company pays to the City of Twin Falls
1:00:22 for the use of our land. We receive gas payments once a year starting in the
1:00:27 second quarter of our fiscal year and the next slide is expenses. Consistently
1:00:36 through this presentation, similar to the last quarter report that I presented on,
1:00:40 you will see in all of these personnel consistently runs low, significantly low.
1:00:46 Personnel is typically the largest percent of our budget and comes out in
1:00:50 around 64% of the total budget expenditures. The city pays most of its
1:00:55 departments on a bi-weekly pay scale. Instead of a even split per month, we've
1:00:59 had 19 out of 26%, which is just over 73% if you do the calculation as opposed to
1:01:06 what you would consider as a gut check of 75% since we're three quarters of the
1:01:11 way through the year. But also included in this, if you'll remember, we can we cut a
1:01:16 $2,000 check to each employee. So if you actually take that into account, the
1:01:22 70.4% that we're running is much less. So the numbers show that we are
1:01:30 running less than what we budgeted and we're having a difficult time filming our
1:01:34 employees. Our capital improvement fund consists largely of the street fund of
1:01:40 3.7 million which has a 1.5 million dollar budget amount of seal coding
1:01:45 counsel your counsel capital sidewalk projects of 782,000 is in there and
1:01:52 equipment and signal upgrades. Transfers are high because of our annual
1:01:57 transfer from the general fund to the capital improvement fund of three
1:02:02 So I've continued to put in some building permits because it was crazy last year every quarter.
1:02:11 Do you have a question?
1:02:12 I believe that's a question.
1:02:15 Yeah, on the last slide I apologize.
1:02:18 Under the personnel.
1:02:19 Yes.
1:02:20 Over time included in that as well.
1:02:22 Everything.
1:02:23 Yes.
1:02:24 This is right now where that personnel the overtime is starting to skyrocket because of lack of employees.
1:02:29 We are over time is calculating this. That's in our actual numbers. So we don't necessarily budget excessively for over time, but even calculating in our over time, even calculating the $2,000 additional, we're still running at 70.4%. So we are significantly less.
1:02:46 Thank you.
1:02:47 So building permits, I talked about this quite a bit last year. It was fun. It was kind of like this game to keep following in what's going on. And I thought it would be interesting to put up the numbers,
1:03:02 numbers comparatively because we have seen a significant drop off our numbers are are
1:03:06 not what they used to be. We are significantly down from the paracorder of 21, but it's still
1:03:12 reached 80% of what we've budgeted. This is a function of our conservative budgeting. We
1:03:16 are not trying to budget to create something, create revenue to make expenses to pay things.
1:03:22 We're trying to have a conservative budget and it shows that we're at a million dollars
1:03:26 as opposed to last year's 1.615 million in the year before of 1.3.
1:03:32 This next slide shows from 2006 to 2022, so you can see that the 2010-11 crash is, which
1:03:44 was when City of Twin Falls realized the housing crash and how it incrementically goes up and
1:03:50 then until 2021 last year where we get to that high, that astronomical high of 2 million
1:03:57 and the year to date numbers that we're showing right now, the million.
1:04:00 Just for some background numbers to substantiate what we're showing.
1:04:05 In fiscal year 21, we had 417 single family permits here to date,
1:04:11 whereas this year we have only 139 new single family permits.
1:04:16 This corresponds to what we are seeing in the nation.
1:04:19 The last report I read from National Leading Investment Bank report
1:04:22 said the decline in starts was driven primarily by single family homes
1:04:26 for multifamily units rose again.
1:04:28 This is indicative of a rise in demand
1:04:30 for more rental units as more prospective buyers
1:04:33 are being priced out of the market.
1:04:35 I think that matches what we are seeing in Twin Falls.
1:04:38 Any questions on tax-supported funds,
1:04:43 some of the numbers I've gone through right now
1:04:46 before I jump into the next section?
1:04:51 How do we compare? I love to do this,
1:04:53 because we skyrocket.
1:04:55 This is a fun one, financial strengthens,
1:04:57 and I just received the latest one
1:04:59 This one is 3331 of 2022 and Idaho still ranks top in the nation or first in the nation.
1:05:07 This is a relative state quarterly report given out published by Piper Sandler, investment broker.
1:05:14 And you can see we're at 133.2%, or 133.2, I'm sorry, the financial strength index includes
1:05:22 employment information, housing price index, state revenue collections, and pension funding
1:05:27 ratios.
1:05:28 The strength of the western states in this report is said,
1:05:31 reflects the gains in housing prices and tax collections.
1:05:34 The 113.16 point FSI of Idofancial State Index of Idaho
1:05:39 represents the highest level achieved
1:05:41 in the five year backdated review of data connected.
1:05:47 So I wanted to throw out a couple of articles
1:05:49 just because this is fun.
1:05:50 So what is top of mind?
1:05:52 And what I keep reading, when I keep seeing
1:05:55 beyond housing prices, labor shortage, and inflation,
1:05:58 frankly, it's exhausting.
1:06:00 I'm tired of talking about that, and honestly, we're talking about it every week when we
1:06:04 meet and talk about the budget, so skipping that stuff, because nobody knows what's going
1:06:09 to happen, and some people say it's going to crash, other people say it's not going to,
1:06:13 and it's just who has the microphone at what point in time.
1:06:16 So with these four things, I thought I would bring out a couple of articles that have come
1:06:20 to mind that have been intriguing and interesting to me.
1:06:23 Gas prices, mortgage rates, savings rates, and just one brief slide on the Ukraine-Russia
1:06:29 gas prices. This was a graph from gasparty.com. It's a heat map. We all think it's always
1:06:40 interesting to me is how high gas is when we have people across the nation. You can call
1:06:44 your cousin or your uncle or see what their gas is and I thought it was interesting to
1:06:49 throw this up here. Yellow is the highest, greater than 5.5 dollars and 51 cents. Purple
1:06:54 is less than 3.53 cents. California, Oregon and Washington traditionally have higher fuel
1:07:02 costs on the national average due to lack of refineries and pipelines that can pump in
1:07:06 domestic oil, states along the Gulf Coast, including Texas and Louisiana, are among the
1:07:10 states with the cheapest gas because of these factors.
1:07:13 As of July 11, the last report I read, I know is ranked seventh in the nation for gas,
1:07:19 which is frustrating.
1:07:22 According to a JP Morgan Chase, as fuel demand crass during the pandemic, refiners around
1:07:26 the world permanently closed older and less profitable plants.
1:07:30 On three million barrels a day of local refining capacity closed during the pandemic, and one
1:07:36 million barrels of a day of that was in the United States.
1:07:39 That was interesting to me that two-thirds was, or one-third was in the United States.
1:07:44 A Wall Street Journal article quoted Saudi Arabia's energy ministry, or a minister, saying
1:07:50 the world hasn't invested enough in maintaining or adding refineries, leading to huge gaps between
1:07:55 the price of oil and gasoline.
1:07:57 Our finery can take up to 20 years to re-tube the initial investment, making the current
1:08:01 business case for a new plant dam.
1:08:03 We've also seen closures that were exacerbated by a punishing hurricane season in the Gulf
1:08:08 of Mexico, which is the world's largest petrochemical complex that damaged summer fineries there.
1:08:14 So fuels prices surged following Russia's invasion of Ukraine, which disrupted the
1:08:18 global oil market.
1:08:20 And we are seeing here.
1:08:23 Here's another fun little graph.
1:08:26 You may have heard in the news, read things about a gas tax holiday, etc., showing this
1:08:31 shows how unnecessary that would be, how it would really not give us any hope by having
1:08:38 a gas tax holiday.
1:08:40 59% of crude oil just talking about gasoline, or 59% of the price that you pay is gasoline,
1:08:46 refining as a 26% distributed marketing, taxes are only 11%, so on $4.44, he'd be saving
1:08:53 44 cents on each dollar of gas that you pay. Gas prices nationwide. This was intriguing
1:09:01 to me. In Idaho, I just captured up to report that showed me where gas is averaged at. Twin
1:09:07 Falls is the highest. We see Coeur d'Alene, Idaho Falls, Lewis, and Polkatelle. You tell
1:09:12 me why. I don't know, but it's frustrating. Around the world, there's a couple of other
1:09:17 ones I thought I'd put on there. Hong Kong, Greece, Sweden, just a couple of ones that
1:09:20 to hit home, the United States are square in the middle for the most part, with the Middle
1:09:26 Eastern countries way less, Kuwait, so we could move to Kuwait and pay only $1.30.
1:09:36 So what are business is doing? Walmart announced a fuel surcharge and a collect pickup charge.
1:09:42 Amazon added a 5% fuel and inflation surcharge to all items shipped using its fulfillment service.
1:09:48 Kroger is checking prices of every commodity as well as packaging costs to make sure suppliers
1:09:53 price increases are warranted, and it's devoting more resources to run pricing analysis. Target
1:09:58 is doing the same thing. They're trying to re-invest in different products to see what
1:10:03 people are buying. A couple slides on mortgage rates. We hear a lot about the numbers, where
1:10:08 interest rates are, and the numbers, the person, the numbers part of me wanted to see, well,
1:10:12 what does that mean? What does a mortgage rate difference mean? This slide is a 30-year
1:10:21 There is a show since 1974, where mortgage rates have gone, that blue line is the 30-year
1:10:27 race.
1:10:28 And what was interesting is the gray is what is considered a recession.
1:10:33 So in the 80s, in the 90s before my time, so I don't know that I remember it as much
1:10:38 as some of you.
1:10:40 2008, I do remember, and I'm curious to see when the next red line is going to be.
1:10:46 There's an article in the Wall Street Journal that said economists surveyed have dramatically
1:10:50 raised the probability of recession.
1:10:52 putting it at 44% in the next 12 months. Since the journal began asking the question in mid 2005,
1:10:58 a 44% recession probability is seldom seen outside of an actual recession. Forecasters have raised
1:11:04 recession probability due to a number of factors, higher borrowing costs, a blistering pace of inflation,
1:11:11 supply chain problems, and commodity price shocks stemming from the war in Ukraine.
1:11:15 This next slide is what an actual mortgage would cost you with some intrinsic factors
1:11:24 in there.
1:11:25 Some property taxes, gas, homeowners insurance, gas, and then put any HOA fees because a lot
1:11:29 of people don't have that.
1:11:30 I just took the interest rates from before just one year ago until I have 20, 20, 20,
1:11:35 and 2.78%.
1:11:36 And I dropped in the interest rates now, 5.8%, this was before the Fed's increase in
1:11:42 of their 0.75% so Chris can probably talk to what interest rates are today whereas they were just a
1:11:49 couple weeks ago. This is what a mortgage payment is which just blows my mind. In July of 2021,
1:11:55 a monthly mortgage payment would be $1,892. Today, well, before the new 7.75%,
1:12:04 That's a $622 increase month to month that our employees, that our residents, our constituents,
1:12:15 are paying.
1:12:16 That's an interest increase if you take it over three years of $224,000.
1:12:27 And the other thing that interests me is savings rates.
1:12:30 We talk about a lot of this stuff because it's about our employees.
1:12:35 We're 65% of the employee, or labor and wage, race, driven.
1:12:40 That's all we do.
1:12:41 We have a lot of, we have some capital improvements.
1:12:43 We've got some M&O, but we have major league.
1:12:46 We've got salary and wages.
1:12:48 So savings rates, this interests me too.
1:12:51 I had seen some stats in college and I thought I would just jump in and try to see where we're at now.
1:12:55 Personal savings rate is a measure of how much people have left over after spending in taxes.
1:13:00 So this, you can see in this chart, our savings rate fell to 5.4% in May of 2022, below the
1:13:07 average of the last decade and far below the pandemic record in 2020.
1:13:12 I will tell you, and any economist will tell you the record is not good.
1:13:16 That means people are hoarding money, they're not spending money, so it's a significant difference,
1:13:21 but not good.
1:13:23 The decline in savings rate shows that consumers are being forced to spend more of their disposal
1:13:27 income just to get by, which, theoretically, will likely reduce spending on goods and services
1:13:34 and hopefully thereby reducing inflation.
1:13:40 This is an interesting chart, an important article that I read, that I splitted out by
1:13:46 demographics.
1:13:47 41% of employees are living paycheck to paycheck.
1:13:50 Over 36% of workers are making more than 100,000.
1:13:55 That was crazy to me, as opposed to 18%.
1:13:58 This article did note that high-income earners who are living paycheck to paycheck still
1:14:02 have no issue covering expenses, but only 10 to 12% are running into problems paying in
1:14:07 their bills.
1:14:08 But I thought this was interesting.
1:14:10 Male versus female, 38% over 43%, 39%, boomers, 28% are living paycheck to paycheck as opposed
1:14:18 to Gen Z.
1:14:19 By income, less than 50,000, 52%, over 100,000, 36%.
1:14:24 These are staggering statistics.
1:14:26 These are national statistics that we're all experiencing.
1:14:30 And 401K. This is not percy choice, but most people in the city of Twin Falls don't work for the city of Twin Falls.
1:14:40 We have 315 employees. What do people have in their savings account?
1:14:44 Which I firmly believe is actually one of the largest competitive advantages of working in government.
1:14:49 Our assistant finance director, not the assistant, yeah.
1:14:53 No, not finance director. Our deputy city manager will argue that, no.
1:14:57 Sorry. Would you like a new job?
1:15:00 Thank you.
1:15:01 Everybody's hiring.
1:15:03 Everybody's hiring.
1:15:05 So our Deputy City Manager will tell you that it's not a factor for people to come in and work for the City of Twin Falls.
1:15:12 And I actually tend to agree with her.
1:15:14 Working as a CPA in a tax practice.
1:15:17 I was amazed at how people don't care about the retirement and these numbers show it.
1:15:22 show it. So the average median 401k balance, we're talking about people that
1:15:27 don't have Percy, $2,225. What's staggering is 65 and up, $82,000. That's retirement.
1:15:36 Those are people that are getting ready to retire and they don't have
1:15:40 anything that's the median amount that they've got. How many years would that last?
1:15:43 This is one last on, this is kind of complicated but fun. It's a visual
1:15:53 Capital has put this really neat picture of the United States income distribution visualizing
1:15:59 100 homes. The purple is poverty and it gradually goes up to yellow, which is the money, I guess,
1:16:08 good money, over 200,000. The largest cost cluster of homes represents nearly 20% of
1:16:14 all American households and is between the $25,000 and $50,000 income bracket. This article
1:16:19 said the middle class in America has shrunk significantly in the past 50 years.
1:16:24 Going from 61% of adults being middle income in 1971 to 50% in 2021, this
1:16:31 concept just intrigues me that the middle class is shrinking. In last, I just want to
1:16:39 do a little slide on, um, I wanted to try to compile some of the things that I
1:16:42 found I've been reading and what this war in Ukraine means to us. Ukraine has
1:16:48 10% of the global wheat, 14% of corn,
1:16:51 50% of sunflower oil, and their seaports are blocked by Russia.
1:16:56 India is the world's second largest wheat grower,
1:16:58 and they've evoked a ban on wheat exports
1:17:00 to help their domestic prices.
1:17:02 Moscow and Belarus is a crucial global supplier as a fertilizer.
1:17:06 They've stopped exporting fertilizer.
1:17:07 Indonesia, halted exports of certain types of palm oil
1:17:10 to help domestic prices.
1:17:12 Africa, millers ever run on a wheat,
1:17:14 making basic staples disappear.
1:17:17 There's an article in Wall Street Journal that said Russia's invasion of Ukraine has
1:17:20 generated one of the most severe food and energy crisis in recent history, which now threatens
1:17:25 those most vulnerable across the globe.
1:17:27 There's a fortune article that said Russia's ongoing blockade of Ukrainian ports has eliminated
1:17:33 nearly 25 million tons of grain from the global supply chain.
1:17:38 Together, Russia and Ukraine account for one-third of global wheat exports.
1:17:43 Wall Street Journal would say US grocery prices in April were up 10.8% over the past 12 months,
1:17:50 the largest annual increase since November of 1980. That's it that I have in national comparisons
1:17:58 and any questions, comments before I jump into enterprise. This serves as section of our enterprise
1:18:08 funds, which means they are similar to a business without a profit motive. So we charge fees to cover
1:18:15 costs. Users pay specific fees for this service. This graph shows the actual water fund user fees
1:18:22 received for each of the fiscal years through the current. So inside of these numbers, this is water
1:18:28 revenues 10.8 million, 9 million last time last year, including this graph is the 2.3 million mandate
1:18:34 at arsenic charge that was approved last year to start the water line maintenance. And I've included
1:18:39 this amount in the prior years to make it a more accurate comparison. We're up almost 500 accounts,
1:18:47 but it's interesting that our numbers are not increased. We've actually consumed less. If you
1:18:52 think about it, it's because of the very wet spring that we've had. On the expenditure side,
1:18:59 personnel is almost 30% of our total budget expenses. Water has not been fully staffed and
1:19:05 continues to be under budget, just like the tax-supported funds. It's typical for water
1:19:10 water to spend most of their M&O expenses during the summer months using power to pump water.
1:19:15 Water was well under budget around 56%, and as I reported in first quarter, it's still
1:19:20 the same that they are experiencing huge lead times on meters in other parts somewhere,
1:19:26 sometimes 12 weeks or more.
1:19:29 Capital is 58% of the total budget expenditures, with the two largest expenditures being a
1:19:33 the Hydro Excavation Truck of 445,000 and Mainland Replacement of 350,000.
1:19:41 So far we have purchased the Hydro Excavation Truck in those actual numbers.
1:19:46 On the debt side, we paid off one of our bonds last year, 6.4 million, leaving only two bonds
1:19:52 left.
1:19:53 The 2012 one with 355,000 that will be paid off shortly, and the 2017 bond for 2.3 million
1:20:00 left in principle.
1:20:02 significantly reduces the percent that water fund has to pay on debt. The 67,000 in interest
1:20:08 right now is because we only make two principal payments and the one principal payment, we make
1:20:14 two payments March and September. The principal payment is not until September. So in the final
1:20:24 waste water. In this I'm looking at the total residential, industrial, and municipal user fee
1:20:31 budget along with the actual amounts received to date. In August of last year we sold some more
1:20:36 capacity to the city of Kimberly, so as we're seeing a slightly higher revenue for this
1:20:41 fiscal year.
1:20:45 Wastewater, we don't contract most of our service out, so it's not the highest percentage
1:20:50 of personnel, but it still is low comparatively, it's 64.9%, and remember the $2,000 is inside
1:20:57 of the water and wastewater fund as well as the tax-supported funds.
1:21:02 There are $35 million left of bonds, and the $624,000 is interest paid to date with the
1:21:08 principal in September as well. The four largest capital expenditures budgeted are a master plan update,
1:21:14 mainline upgrades, the digester boiler replacement and a sludge truck all around $250,000, the
1:21:22 boiler replacement and the digester too, lining and cleaning have been paid for making up most of the
1:21:28 $1 million expenditures to date. Annotation is very consistent. At $3.7 million,
1:21:41 We have the extra 500 accounts I referred to in the water directly affect sanitation, so we're up just a little bit for sanitation as well.
1:21:49 And on the expenditure side, there's no capital, or there's no capital expenditures or debt, just M&O and transfers and we're right on track through this quarter.
1:22:01 Any questions on enterprise funds?
1:22:04 I have a question back on the wastewater, you kind of skipped over the amino in 88% is that
1:22:14 any particular reason?
1:22:16 So wastewater expenditures are higher because of the cost of inflationary adjustments on there.
1:22:23 It's not necessarily a particular culmination of what they have.
1:22:27 I can go and do a little bit more looking into it and send you the detail though.
1:22:31 So I guess my question is if we're three quarters of the way through and we're at 88%
1:22:36 we expect we'll be over budget on that.
1:22:39 We're not expecting to be over budget. We're expecting to mitigate it out by the end of the year.
1:22:44 But I'll find the detail and send that to you.
1:22:46 Thank you. Madam Mayor, I'm going to be able to help a little bit.
1:22:49 So a lot of the M&O that we have is associated with our contract with Jacobs,
1:22:55 who does our waste water treatment plant. We pay them in advance.
1:23:00 So, in the past we used to pay them at the end of the month and now we paid them at the
1:23:06 be calculated in that, since we would have already kind of moved forward. So our last
1:23:12 payment to them is going to first of most of the bills. We get a quick based upon cost
1:23:31 as well as the profit we were meeting. So as Brianna said,
1:23:41 Thank you. Any other questions for Brianna on enterprise funds?
1:23:48 Does it look like it? So going forward, a couple of things that we're looking at, a couple
1:23:55 more things I wanted to highlight. We are right in the middle of the process which
1:23:59 you're aware of of the state level fiscal recoveries, the ARPA Fund Committee, to
1:24:03 allocate the $8.4 million. We have been, we've been doing extensive
1:24:08 process review throughout the City of Twin Falls. I wanted to highlight a couple
1:24:11 that come to mind to describe what we're doing, what we're looking at because
1:24:15 expenses are significantly higher and funds don't increase. Norm gave a great
1:24:21 presentation to our management group or a supervisor group on field purchases.
1:24:25 He educated us on what premium grade is versus unleaded and what our process is.
1:24:31 He's trying to streamline that to make sure that we're consistent across the city.
1:24:36 We've been looking at land law or tenant responsibilities.
1:24:39 We had an open seminar to open to the public.
1:24:42 We're trying to figure out, does it make sense to bring the council what kind of information
1:24:47 are we going to provide?
1:24:48 Because right now it's costing the city a lot of man labor to go out and turn utilities
1:24:53 on to turn them off.
1:24:54 And what would it do to have the utilities be in the landlord's name?
1:24:59 We're looking at some budget billing level pay.
1:25:02 Is it how many people does it affect?
1:25:04 Is it something the council wants to look at?
1:25:07 How much time does it affect us?
1:25:10 We've had some conversations with PSI.
1:25:13 One of the interesting things I wanted to bring out is they've talked about,
1:25:18 In lieu of increasing fees, can they offer more that will or can they get something from
1:25:23 the city to offer more to their employees, one of which was, can they start earlier?
1:25:28 Can they start at 6 a.m. versus the 7 a.m. that council approved, I don't know, 15 years
1:25:33 ago.
1:25:34 That way they can shift to an internal 410 and not have to worry about increasing costs and
1:25:39 maybe saving some there.
1:25:40 So all across the city, we're looking at processes.
1:25:43 We're looking at what we can do to save money and how we can wait out some of this.
1:25:48 Any questions for Briana though?
1:25:52 Thank you very much. One more thing. Okay. I wanted to share this because it's fun. Okay. This is our moodies
1:25:58 I know you're trying to get rid of me, and I know it's late. I tried to hurry. You're fine
1:26:02 This is our moodies rating. We did a lot of work. It was fun
1:26:05 It was interesting to go through this and this was one of the charts that they put together that I thought was was great
1:26:10 It's Travis mentioned we got a double a rating a a two the highest rating is a triple a
1:26:16 And what I wanted to show is is we actually received AAA ratings in a couple of our spots,
1:26:22 fund balances of percentage of revenue, cash balances of percentage of revenue.
1:26:25 One of our biggest deterrents or detractors that pulled that down, as you can see, that
1:26:30 B rating is a median family income.
1:26:32 We can't change that.
1:26:33 We can't affect that.
1:26:34 And so I thought it was interesting to note that we're doing great as a city with the
1:26:38 funds that we're giving.
1:26:40 Now, any questions?
1:26:42 Now, any questions?
1:26:46 Doesn't look like it. Thank you.
1:26:48 Okay.
1:26:56 Next item on the agenda is a presentation of City Manager's Recommended Budget for Fiscal Year 2022-23.
1:27:04 Raph is Swarthweidner. No Gretchen.
1:27:08 Well, welcome. But he just leave and give it all to you.
1:27:16 Thank you, Aaron.
1:27:36 I hit Astrum. We had sent the PowerPoint to her earlier today,
1:27:39 and so I hit Astrum if she would come over and make sure it queued up for us correctly.
1:27:42 correctly. We had had a couple of issues in a few other sessions. So, thanks again.
1:27:48 Good evening, Council, and I'm very pleased to be here tonight. I thank you very much for
1:27:54 your patience as we go through the introductory slides of the budget message again. I just
1:27:59 want to share the reason why we review these extensively all throughout our budget presentations
1:28:07 are for the people that may not have been here for a previous session. Those that are
1:28:11 joining us online as an educational piece so that they can hear what it is that the city
1:28:17 does as stewards of their property tax money and help them understand how we function as
1:28:23 a governmental unit and where their money goes.
1:28:26 Tonight we'll be focused area eight which is the internal organization and the HR team
1:28:33 as well as the information technology team is here to present once we get to that portion
1:28:38 of the presentation.
1:28:39 I have a question. Do we have a handout tonight? Typically, we have one of the of the slides. We will. We will. Thank you. So, uh, underneath state code, um, there are code sections which describe what the responsibilities are of the city manager and the city council relative to establishing the budget and limitations on the increase in collection of taxes and how that balance needs to be adopted or how that budget needs to be adopted.
1:29:23 how that budget needs to be adopted.
1:29:26 These code sections outline those for you.
1:29:31 Our fiscal year begins on October 1 and ends in September 30th.
1:29:35 This is the last of the internal presentations.
1:29:38 And then next week we'll go through a couple
1:29:40 of different sections for your input and discussion.
1:29:45 Each year we develop the budget with a few goals in mind.
1:29:48 We know that we live in a really dynamic time currently.
1:29:51 The economy, labor force pressures, many of the things
1:29:55 that Brianna just presented to you, require that we be responsive to that and how we develop
1:30:00 the budget.
1:30:02 Those are some of the goals that were crafted by Travis when he put together any directed
1:30:07 department heads to go through and create the budget for him.
1:30:12 As always, the City's 2030 Strategic Plan is a key piece of making sure that the budget
1:30:19 we present furthers the City's goals, reaches objectives, and tries to meet that vision of
1:30:26 community that we've been striving for. We also want to make sure that we are
1:30:32 pursuing an employer of choice in the Magic Valley as Brianna's presentation and
1:30:37 further presentations will show you we know that this is a highly desirable
1:30:41 quality to achieve just because it helps us retain and hire the best people. So
1:30:51 this is the big takeaway slide in which we talk about what the changes are to our
1:30:55 property owners here in the city of Twin Falls. This is as Travis has said to
1:31:00 So you will see that in the 21-22 adopted budget, the current fiscal year that we are in, the tax rate was $6.25 per 1,000 of taxable value.
1:31:11 That equates to the average home price of about $68.75 monthly.
1:31:19 In the recommended budget for $22.23, you'll see that we have a net decrease in our tax rate.
1:31:28 and we are looking at $4.78 per thousand dollars of taxable value and we are looking at then
1:31:41 a decrease of $1.47. Sorry, I just blew it. I just got out of track. So the variance is $24.06
1:31:59 and that the recommended budget will be $92.81 per year. There are no changes to the utility bill
1:32:13 and the water sewer sanitation rates those remain static with no recommended increases
1:32:19 for the upcoming year. As we continue to move forward the preliminary budget and the overall
1:32:30 toxic value of the city you'll see that there is a substantial increase. The increase will go
1:32:39 over in the next slide but the city tax rate is anticipated to decrease by 23.4 percent and
1:32:47 And we believe that this will demonstrate the value of services that our citizens are getting
1:32:54 for the tax rates that they pay.
1:33:01 So we just talked about what the taxable value is and this chart illustrates what the taxable
1:33:06 value for the city has been over the last eight years.
1:33:13 This value is increases $1.5 billion.
1:33:18 And in addition, the URA areas has also increased in the last fiscal year.
1:33:27 The amount of this increase is more than the last four years combined.
1:33:30 So the jump in our property assessments, our tax value, this year has been enormous.
1:33:39 And then as you can see then, the tax rate or property tax that the city will be issuing
1:33:45 this year is substantially lower and probably, well, and is lower than that we have ever
1:33:51 issued.
1:34:00 Some of that is due to what new construction values are coming in as, so you can see as property value goes up,
1:34:05 while Brianna had covered that our property, our building permits, had reduced the value of new construction is increasing.
1:34:13 So we're building less but it's worth more.
1:34:16 We are allowed to take 90% of the property new construction value as it is assessed each year,
1:34:23 and that will result in $554,000 in new revenue.
1:34:29 The prior fiscal year was 626,000 for the current fiscal year that we are in.
1:34:36 Brianna also covered a little bit about building permit revenue.
1:34:47 Absolutely, the challenges of labor and materials and has declined the number of reduced number of building permits that have been issued each year.
1:34:55 We are projecting our revenues as flat in order to be a conservative budgeting entity and not to escalate or not be able to meet what we are expecting.
1:35:04 expecting. Property taxes are assigned to property taxes are assigned based on value
1:35:16 and in the state of Idaho. We also have an exemption which reduces the amount that
1:35:21 a citizen pays on their property. So you can see that back in 2013 property values
1:35:29 indexed and it moved until it was fixed by the legislature in 2016 and it was
1:35:37 fixed eddies of 50% or $100,000 of value, whichever is less. Since then, property values
1:35:45 have continued to increase and in 21, the state legislature increased the maximum consumption
1:35:53 by up to 125,000. By failing to let it index naturally, it artificially then caps what
1:36:02 citizens are able to claim for the exemption and then makes them pay more in terms of
1:36:08 property tax. If that was indexing as it used to before 2016 homeowners would be paying an estimated
1:36:16 $243 less in city property taxes. So this slide illustrates across what we consider to be our
1:36:31 comparable cities what the average homeowner will pay in property taxes and what their tax rates are.
1:36:39 We do not compare against cities which are, don't have a highway or have to have a street
1:36:46 department in operate with a highway district like Aida County Highway District and Boise
1:36:51 and Meridian.
1:36:52 So we exclude those from our comparisons in order to have an apples to apples comparison.
1:36:59 So you can see the citizens of Twin Falls, a lower rate and less in property taxes based
1:37:07 on the medium home values as a result of a big conservative budgeting of the pieces about
1:37:23 the budget that is green I also covered in pretty good detail. We want to make sure that
1:37:31 people understand where our funds are being spent. So this talks about the different types
1:37:35 of funds that enterprise funds those are they're operated like a not a business but not for
1:37:40 profit and then our governmental funds and then how those funds are spent and you can
1:37:46 see the personnel across all funds creates about 43.9% of those costs. We are a service
1:37:54 organization both in our enterprise and our general funds. It takes people to do what we
1:37:58 do. We don't have robo-cops. We don't have fire trucks that are self-automated or drive
1:38:05 old by themselves. We have automated many processes but it still takes people to provide
1:38:12 service. It's totally appropriate that our personnel percentage would be that high.
1:38:17 The second largest piece of that pie is maintenance operations and that's
1:38:22 utilities, travel, uniforms, the durable goods that it takes for us to do the
1:38:28 work that it that we do feel in electricity and then capital then are
1:38:33 the investments that we make in the infrastructure and the items people
1:38:37 need to do their jobs. So if you think that 43% of the entire budget is about personnel,
1:38:51 it makes you ask how many folks are doing the job. And as you look back through this chart,
1:38:56 you can see that we have conservatively but consistently added positions over the years.
1:39:01 This current fiscal year adds a few new positions to bring our total to 325.5 FTEs. The new positions
1:39:11 for consideration are the deputy prosecuting attorney, the engineering traffic technician,
1:39:19 a water operator position, and a deputy fire chief position.
1:39:23 You guys have heard a little bit about each of those positions over the last few weeks.
1:39:29 They are heavily vetted through our internal processes and conversations about whether
1:39:35 or not we fund those are pretty competitive.
1:39:38 We do a lot of process review and we want to make sure that when we're investing in a
1:39:43 position that will go on for 20 years in the organization that it is a true need of the organization
1:39:49 in the community. In addition, the planning and zoning technician, which is previously approved,
1:39:54 will and hired is in the budget as well as for police officers that were part of the
1:40:00 cops' gram. So the maintenance and operation line here, it has a 7.5% increase, $1,375,000.
1:40:16 Now, the MCI, the Municipal Cost Index, is up by 12.5 percent, and when you consider that
1:40:23 ours is up only 7.5 percent, you can see that the kinds of things that the organization
1:40:28 is doing, such as the fleet manager recommending different practices for how we buy fuel.
1:40:33 We are trying to maintain, as best we can, what's happening with the M&O of the organization.
1:40:41 Also includes things like travel, and if you've tried to buy a plane ticket recently, you can see what the cost of travel is doing.
1:40:48 So I think that when you look at what the maintenance operation budget is across all funds, again, trying to be conscious of the public's money and how that is spent across the organization.
1:40:59 The capital expenditures for all budgets this year is up to $18 million.
1:41:08 These are all capital, all of our strategic plan objectives are considered capital dependent.
1:41:14 They are major investments in the community, major investments in infrastructure, capacity,
1:41:19 and our ability to deliver services.
1:41:27 So the next part of the presentation will be focusing on our internal organization, and
1:41:32 I just want to remind you that all of the focus areas that you have learned about so
1:41:36 far all take people to accomplish.
1:41:39 So those folks that are at the center of our organization and in this graph are those that
1:41:45 Deliver the services that we need in order to accomplish the mission of the organization
1:41:49 And with that, I would like to invite Ida Clark your new HR director up to the podium. Thank you, Gretchen. Welcome, Ida
1:42:00 Thank you. Good evening, council members, and I did want to tell Brianna that this is the fun stuff
1:42:07 I was nervous when I was asked to present on the internal organization.
1:42:14 I am new.
1:42:15 I started my sixth week and I was wondering if I was prepared to talk about the foundation
1:42:19 of our organization.
1:42:21 As I was thinking about how to present tonight, I remembered that I am a team member and now
1:42:25 part of the foundation.
1:42:27 I reflected on why I had applied for this position.
1:42:30 It was my previous interactions with my now teammates, the benefits, the compensation,
1:42:35 the fair and equitable treatment that I've observed and development opportunities.
1:42:40 All of those items are part of our foundation and what this budget represents.
1:42:45 I have now met with almost every department and I have been amazed at the passion everyone
1:42:50 has for their jobs and the service minded employees that provide for our community.
1:42:55 I was curious why others also applied to work for the city and I did reach out to a few
1:43:01 in different departments and they replied with wonderful answers and you will
1:43:07 notice the theme and their responses. It is benefits. It's equal treatment and
1:43:12 its development. This budget ensures that we can continue to support and grow the
1:43:18 foundation of our organization. Everything that we do supports the 2030
1:43:25 vision and I'm going to go more in-depth on these items that we have listed here
1:43:29 as I go through the next slide.
1:43:33 At the City of Twin Falls, we do an engagement summary.
1:43:37 And right now, in 2022, we are at 73%.
1:43:42 Right now, you might be asking,
1:43:43 either where are you showing us a survey
1:43:45 where our engagement has gone down?
1:43:47 I wanna give you a little backstory.
1:43:50 So first, the average employee engagement
1:43:53 in organizations is 36%.
1:43:57 36%. At the City of Twin Falls, we are at 73%. Second, in 2020, this survey closed two weeks
1:44:08 before the governor issued the statewide shutdown order. Over that time, we've experienced a
1:44:14 time of unknown and for many significant loss, a massive shift in employment and many have
1:44:21 additional hours to make sure everything is functioning. And now we have more uncertainty
1:44:26 and inflation. So when I see that we're at 73% I see opportunities. The engagement survey
1:44:34 also asks our employees to comment on the good in areas we can continue to improve. So the
1:44:39 good, again, the people, our coworkers, the benefits, and compensation. And areas to continue
1:44:45 to look at this compensation. So in our budget we have asked for a 5% increase, performance
1:44:50 increase. So employees that receive and meets or exceeds expectations will receive a 5% increase
1:44:56 to their salary. We've also asked for a 2% shift in the table, so what that means is when
1:45:02 that table shifts, any employees that fall below the new minimum would be raised to the
1:45:07 new minimum and then it extends out the salary ranges. So for those employees that are more
1:45:12 tenured, it allows them to move in that salary range. We're also asking again, Brianna talked
1:45:18 about this very one time, $2,000 payment, and employees can elect to have that as cash,
1:45:24 into the Percy 401K choice or into the HSA or a combination, so whatever would work best
1:45:30 for them.
1:45:31 We're also asking for the continuation of the Employee Retention Program, and we will continue
1:45:36 to participate in the Northwest Data Exchange Salary Survey to remain at or above the current
1:45:44 market and make any adjustments as needed.
1:45:48 Health Insurance.
1:45:50 we did receive an 11.4% increase in the medical premiums.
1:45:55 We are asking to fully absorb that 11.4% increase.
1:46:00 What this means to employees is that they will not see
1:46:02 any increase in their medical premiums.
1:46:05 Currently, an employee with family coverage
1:46:07 pays $410 a month, whereas the employee would pay $560
1:46:13 if the city does not absorb that increase.
1:46:16 I'm going to jump to the slide here real quick,
1:46:19 And I believe we have seen this right previously, but you'll just know since 2016, we have had an average of 8.8% increase in the family premium, making the change and removing the traditional plan last year essentially bought us three years, so we've made a shift in that increase, that city increase.
1:46:38 So we will continue to research and find ways to keep our medical premiums sustainable for the city and also for our employees.
1:46:47 And going back to staffing levels, they talked a lot about this staffing levels in burnout.
1:46:55 And in every presentation over the last few weeks, it has included recruitment challenges in the vacancies that each department has opened.
1:47:04 I know you experienced this in your business and in your place of work and we're not immune to that here.
1:47:09 The HR department has also experienced a 75% turnover due to some retirement as well, but
1:47:16 we will be working on training in the development of the HR department to continue to provide
1:47:22 guidance, support, and fair and equitable treatment.
1:47:25 We are working diligently with departments to recruit and review positions to ensure
1:47:29 they're properly aligned, and we're also working to find creative ways to advertise
1:47:34 and recruit.
1:47:36 I would like to give this amazing HR team a chance to speak tonight and thank them also
1:47:41 for their support in my short time here.
1:47:43 They have been truly amazing and tonight I'm going to have Kristin, our benefits and
1:47:48 safety coordinator present first followed by Kaylin and Encina wrapping up our presentation
1:47:54 with organizational development and the organizational development position was new at this fiscal
1:47:59 year.
1:48:00 I am going to turn it over to Kristin.
1:48:09 members. Thanks for staying with us so late tonight. I did have a five-minute workout routine
1:48:15 schedule, but we'll go ahead and cancel that. So to start off with, I believe I know all of you,
1:48:21 but for those who may not know me, my name is Kristin Kontauk. I was the former recruitment
1:48:26 coordinator before healing joined our team, and I am now the benefits and safety coordinator taking
1:48:31 over for Katie who retired in December. And on Sunday the 7th, I will have my five-year anniversary
1:48:38 with the city, which is crazy to think, whoops, if I know how to run a slide show.
1:48:45 Tonight I'm just going to briefly summarize some of our benefits and safety goals and information within the city.
1:48:53 So under Benefit Utilization you'll see that we have a high usage for employees and dependents on our plan.
1:49:01 I think this is key for us to realize when I think of benefits I think of employees and do they enroll?
1:49:08 do they do it on time, things like that, but we need to take a step back and look at the family aspect of that.
1:49:14 We're not providing for just our employees, but we're providing for their families and children.
1:49:19 This is key to our recruitment and retention efforts, and it also lends us to being an employer of choice.
1:49:26 Under family bonding leave, you guys might remember that this is a benefit that allows our employees to use six weeks of paid leave to bond with a new child,
1:49:36 either a newborn or an adoption. So we currently have both men and women utilizing
1:49:44 this program and within this current fiscal year 16 of our employees have
1:49:49 utilized it which I think is pretty cool. Since the program went into effect in
1:49:54 October of 2020 we have had 25 employees utilize it. Again I think this is great
1:50:01 and it's another benefit that continues to make us an employer of choice. The
1:50:08 The third bullet I have is mental health.
1:50:11 We've heard a lot about mental health throughout COVID.
1:50:14 I think it's vital that we continue to support our employees.
1:50:19 We've offered various trainings this physical year,
1:50:23 or fiscal year, including mental health first aid,
1:50:26 which was made available to all of our employees
1:50:28 should they choose to do it.
1:50:30 And the police department's recent family academy,
1:50:33 which was well attended,
1:50:35 and the Kevin Gilmerton emotional survival
1:50:37 for first responders, which was also provided
1:50:40 by our police department.
1:50:43 Going forward, I believe it's important
1:50:45 to continue to explore training options,
1:50:48 not just for our employees, but for their spouses
1:50:51 and family members to be able to join us as well.
1:50:53 So I'm hopeful looking at doing some lunch and learns,
1:50:57 catering to departments who work different shifts,
1:50:59 not that just eight to five,
1:51:01 going to our police, fire, public works departments,
1:51:04 and offering those sort of shift and a shift,
1:51:07 and also being able to invite family members to join them.
1:51:11 Because mental health just doesn't affect our employees
1:51:13 at work, it affects our personal lives as well.
1:51:18 The fourth bullet, safety goals.
1:51:21 As an organization, we have a lot of room
1:51:24 to increase our safety approach.
1:51:26 With the additional FTE and CINA coming on board,
1:51:30 it adds capacity to our team that we did not previously have,
1:51:35 and will allow us to begin focusing on creating our safety plan and goals.
1:51:41 To do that, we need to start somewhere, so we need to figure out or begin with an understanding
1:51:48 of what departments are doing or may not be doing and how we can connect them to a larger
1:51:55 organizational effort and support them moving forward.
1:52:00 And the last slide I have is our wellness program.
1:52:03 We continue to offer various opportunities to encourage health and wellness to all of
1:52:07 our employees.
1:52:09 This fiscal year we've offered luncheon learns such as dealing with angry customers, which
1:52:13 we never have to do, and nicotine cessation.
1:52:17 We had about 35 employees join us for the angry customers, luncheon learn, and about
1:52:22 15 for the nicotine cessation.
1:52:26 The angry customers one was for employees only, but the nicotine cessation we opened
1:52:30 up to spouses and family members as well, making that resource available to everyone.
1:52:37 And then we will also continue to offer our wellness reimbursement program where employees
1:52:42 can earn up to $150 for wellness activities such as gym memberships, golf passes, parking,
1:52:49 or park and camping fees, hunting and fishing licenses, et cetera.
1:52:53 Again, just an additional perk that helps set us apart being a player of choice.
1:53:00 conclusion I'm going to transfer over to Kaitlyn our recruitment coordinator.
1:53:06 Good evening Madam Mayor and council members my name is Kaitlyn Gibson and I
1:53:19 am the Human Resources recruitment coordinator. I started as the recruitment
1:53:23 coordinator a year ago tomorrow so I have learned a tremendous amount about the
1:53:31 city in that time specifically what our departments are looking for when they
1:53:35 when they want to hire new employees into their departments.
1:53:39 The recruitment climate has changed drastically in the last couple years.
1:53:44 Positions in the past that have had high numbers of applicants have dropped down into single digits.
1:53:50 It has been challenging to find qualified, quality candidates to fill our many vacancies.
1:53:56 For example, we had a candidate interview in a dirty white tank top during a team's interview.
1:54:02 We had a police candidate show up to his polygraph
1:54:05 in sweatpants, tennis shoes, and uncombed hair.
1:54:07 I was told he looked as if he had just rolled out a bit.
1:54:12 I've had candidates not show up to appointments
1:54:14 that they themselves scheduled in order for them
1:54:18 to continue on in the hiring process.
1:54:22 Candidates who have not shown up to interviews
1:54:25 without any reason why candidates who schedule but then
1:54:29 fail to complete the required assessments for the job
1:54:33 they applied for, and again, without any notice.
1:54:40 So in an effort to get better suited candidates,
1:54:43 we have broadened our recruitment efforts.
1:54:46 We post open positions on numerous websites.
1:54:50 We reach out to our department heads on ideas for,
1:54:54 excuse me, department heads for ideas
1:54:56 on where to post their department's opening.
1:54:58 So specifically, are they, if they're part of an organization,
1:55:02 Then we would post on that platform that would cater to what exactly they're doing in their job.
1:55:11 We have geo-fenced businesses, companies, and colleges in an effort to get in front of more prospective candidates.
1:55:20 College of Southern Idaho is one that we see a fence.
1:55:23 So if Spencer were here tonight, he may have seen some of our ads pop up on his phone or tablet, advertising our jobs.
1:55:30 Sorry, not sorry.
1:55:31 So, and if any of you have been to the movies lately,
1:55:36 then you would have seen our new ads for police
1:55:39 and the other ads showcasing how the city is a desirable workplace.
1:55:43 So I know that our current employees are also great recruiters.
1:55:47 When they share our openings with those that they feel would be a great fit for the position.
1:55:51 It is important to mention that we are also working with Renard Media
1:55:57 on a new police recruiting campaign that I'm excited to see what will generate from that campaign.
1:56:01 So far to date, I have run about 30 recruitments with 32 new hires as of next Monday.
1:56:09 As a result, some departments had multiple openings to fill.
1:56:14 Currently, I have five ongoing recruitments and hope to create great pools of candidates for those positions.
1:56:21 Police and dispatch are ongoing recruitments as well with 10 candidates currently going through the process of police and 3 currently going through for dispatch.
1:56:31 We have also seen our current employees grow with our internal requirements about 10 to 12 of those.
1:56:39 My own department has seen our previous human resources director move to a much deserved position's deputy city manager.
1:56:47 Kristen has grown her talents into her new position and are as our benefits and safety coordinator.
1:56:54 We have seen multiple employees start in one department and grow their careers by accepting positions in other departments.
1:57:02 So with that, I would like to show you a couple of our recruiting ads and then from there, turn it over to Hansina.
1:57:08 Okay, take two that you would see currently right now running in our Ugrudy to go.
1:59:35 Take people that you believe would be a great fit for the City of Twin Falls.
1:59:38 Thank you.
1:59:40 And then with that, I'll turn it over to Hansina.
1:59:42 Thank you.
1:59:51 Good evening, Madam Mayor and Council members. My name is Ancy Naderim and I am the Organizational
1:59:58 Development Coordinator for the City of Twin Falls. I have been here officially nine months,
2:00:03 only three months left to go to make it to my one year anniversary. So prior to working
2:00:10 for the City of Twin Falls, I worked for the College of Southern Idaho in the library for 14
2:00:16 years and I really found myself out there exploring and looking at my personal and professional
2:00:25 development and it was through that exploration that I came across the City of Twin Falls and
2:00:34 I was drawn to the city because of the one city values and your investment in your employees.
2:00:43 So ever since I've been here, I've been drinking the One City Kool-Aid and now I've found myself
2:00:50 invested in making ourselves the employer choice as we move forward.
2:00:57 So in the short time that I've been here, we have accomplished a lot.
2:01:02 In your packet, there is a handout that shows some of the trainings that we have done already
2:01:10 through the year, and the ones coming up, coming forward, and with that, so it's been, it's
2:01:19 been fairly interesting and emfemful, and I wouldn't have made it through without many
2:01:27 of the team members here within the organization.
2:01:32 So as we strive forward, we still, we're always looking at making that connection with those
2:01:38 employees at work here at the city. So one of the things that we have continued to do
2:01:45 is the employee newsletter and the Tuesday tips. I collaborate with Kristin on that. And
2:01:53 so that's one of the ways that we still work to engage with our employees. And other events
2:02:01 include the barbecue that was put on by fleet maintenance and the employee breakfast.
2:02:09 And I just want to thank you for coming and attending those events because that shows your
2:02:16 commitment to us as well. You are part of our story and so I know that the employees really
2:02:22 appreciate that time that you take to come and join us in that in those types of events.
2:02:28 It really, it truly reflects our culture and the way that we do business, and it does.
2:02:36 It creates that trust and breaks down those silos throughout the organization.
2:02:43 So with those trainings, just a little snapshot of what we've been doing, we've been going
2:02:50 pushing forward with employee orientation.
2:02:53 We've been learning and growing and moving forward.
2:02:59 So when you look at the number of people
2:03:01 that have attended so far this year,
2:03:04 that is us going back to 2020,
2:03:08 trying to get those employees that may have came in,
2:03:12 just maybe prior to COVID happening,
2:03:15 and then during COVID as well.
2:03:18 So that for the orientation and the Myers breaks both,
2:03:22 So Meyer Briggs really deals a lot with our leadership
2:03:25 and our educational philosophy.
2:03:28 And then it kind of, it delves into employee preference.
2:03:32 So then the employees learn a lot about themselves
2:03:34 and how they can grow and develop
2:03:37 and be part of that one state team.
2:03:40 We do have an orientation this week
2:03:42 and another Meyer Briggs coming up next week as well.
2:03:48 We've been able this year to partner with others
2:03:52 in the organization, so our active shooter training was put on by our barium, Matt Hicks,
2:03:59 and Brent Wright. We had 76 employees that showed up for that. Leader Cass, they came
2:04:06 in, Sonia from United Way, 17 employees that participated. Mental health first aid, Preston
2:04:17 touched on that earlier.
2:04:19 So even that has city connections with Megan Humble
2:04:23 and our very own dusty Solomon giving over time
2:04:27 to work with our employees.
2:04:29 This year was the first time that iCrimp
2:04:32 has had a supervisor training that was available
2:04:37 to employees and we have 13 take advantage
2:04:40 of that opportunity as well.
2:04:43 One other thing that we have started to put into the core leadership is supervisor competency
2:04:53 trainings and that has been well received and we were trying to connect that back to leadership
2:05:00 moments as well.
2:05:03 So, yeah, you know, it hasn't always been easy.
2:05:07 you can look at the slide and see with the COVID restrictions we started out with some
2:05:13 of our team activities, people wearing masks and gloves.
2:05:17 So we just made those accommodations and we made it work for us.
2:05:24 And then of course, you know, the groups being able to come back together without having
2:05:29 to mask.
2:05:31 And so it's been a fun opportunity, an exciting time to see everyone from across the organization
2:05:40 come together in Peru.
2:05:43 And so with the closing of my portion, I'm going to touch on the one city boot camp.
2:05:51 And with that, I'm going to show a presentation, a short video clip, but the video clip, it
2:06:01 talks about the power of knowing the purpose,
2:06:04 you're why.
2:06:06 And the purpose for us is the essence of public service.
2:06:10 And that's what we're really trying to teach
2:06:13 with the One City Boot Camp.
2:06:26 I know, a lot of people think of the phrase,
2:06:28 I don't know, they always want to put the what behind you.
2:06:30 How do I know what I'm supposed to do?
2:06:33 The question that you really jacks is how do I know why?
2:06:37 I'm here because when you know you're why,
2:06:39 You're what becomes more clear and more impactful, you know, like for instance, people know that I do comedy, but that's what I do.
2:06:49 My why is to inspire people to walk in purpose. So I can do comedy, I can write books, I can be in a movie because all of it is motivated by my why.
2:07:00 In fact, I have a new web series called Michael Jr. Break Time.
2:07:06 We probably just did the sixth episode. It's on YouTube.
2:07:09 And so every single Wednesday at 3 o'clock, we drop a new episode on YouTube of Michael Jr.
2:07:14 Right Time.
2:07:15 What it is is it's me, I travel around the country and I can stand up comedy and get your
2:07:19 note.
2:07:21 And in the middle of my comedy set sometime, I'll stop and just talk to my audience.
2:07:27 And we've been filming this and it's pretty cool.
2:07:31 So we're in Winston, Salem, I'm going to show you a clip from Winston, Salem.
2:07:35 And I'm just talking to this guy in the audience and he tells me that he's a musical writer.
2:07:39 A musical instructor at a school, so I was like alright, you're a musical instructor, you know, can't you sing?
2:07:44 Let me hear you sing this song, so this is what happened at the last episode of Michael's Day this is a break time, second time.
2:07:51 Say musical director, yes sir.
2:07:53 Alright so, let me get a couple, let me get a couple bars, I'm like an amazing great skid dude, first part of that.
2:07:59 Go ahead, sing, oh, sweet.
2:08:06 I can sing, oh, man.
2:08:26 What's you giving a version, is it if, uh, your uncle just got out of jail,
2:08:32 You got shot in the back when you're a kid.
2:08:34 I'm just saying, let me see the hood version real quick.
2:08:37 You know, it's hurting.
2:08:38 I thought about just seeing if that exists.
2:08:40 Let me see what you got.
2:08:41 Max and I say, he knew what he was doing.
2:09:56 Second time, looking towards or in purpose.
2:10:09 And with that, I'll bring out.
2:10:14 Bring out my homies if you have any questions for us before we turn it over to Kathy of IT.
2:10:24 Any questions for HR?
2:10:26 How do you end that?
2:10:31 I don't say no.
2:10:32 How can it happen?
2:10:36 Thank you.
2:10:37 Thank you ladies.
2:10:38 Next is Cathy Marcus IT.
2:10:44 It includes electrical, GIS, and when it comes to IT we have infrastructure switches, fiber optics,
2:11:03 routers, firewalls, servers, computers, tablets, MDCs, printers, copiers, scanners, software operating systems.
2:11:12 And I had some help, operating systems, data, backup, telephones, cell phones, mobile devices,
2:11:26 radios, cameras, security, alarm systems, audio and visual, HVAC, SCADA, and anything technical.
2:11:34 So it's amazing when someone talks to our department, they say, what do you do?
2:11:39 The list just goes on and on and these are the major pieces of what we do.
2:11:45 So for the next fiscal year, what we have budgeted is very limited.
2:11:50 It is basically just the computers and the cradle points to run the computers.
2:11:57 We had not expected to have as many computers in the budget because our goal is to replace
2:12:03 five computers, I mean, 20% of the computers a year, so every five years your computer will
2:12:10 be replaced.
2:12:11 We ran a little bit behind, so this year we are going to replace a few more computers
2:12:16 than we had initially planned.
2:12:19 I'm going to replace 92 computers, which is from the general fund, and then two computers
2:12:39 from the city shop funds, which is a total of 94 computers.
2:12:44 And with this little joke in there that some people want them to replace more than every
2:12:51 five years but our goal is every five years. And then we have, oops, the cradle points,
2:13:01 this is a cradle point I included a picture of it for your information. It's a router that
2:13:06 we put in vehicles. We also use them at the wastewater treatment, different treatment plants
2:13:12 at pump stations. It's a secure way to communicate with those external devices and it allows us
2:13:19 to track data fully through them. So we have cradle points and anything that is outside
2:13:25 of the office and we're in replace 83 of those is what we have the next fiscal year computer wise
2:13:36 and we also have one server replacement we've replaced one server every year and that's $28,000
2:13:43 and an innovation room. Any questions for Kathy? Look like a thank you Kathy. So Madam
2:14:17 members of the council he was also probably one of the decisions that we're going to ask the council
2:14:26 to make it next week.
2:14:35 On your basis, we have been able to place about $770,000
2:14:39 in the budget, and we ask for the Council's assistance
2:14:45 in allocating those dollars and those resources.
2:14:49 The projects that you see on this in the first two columns
2:14:54 were discussed throughout the various focus plan areas.
2:15:00 In addition to that, we've listed all of those items
2:15:03 that we would follow as a category B.
2:15:06 So first, the potential directed capital projects are ones that we did not believe that
2:15:12 we would be able to ordinarily observe or absorb into our budget, and so we ask for
2:15:17 your assistance of picking between those all important projects moving forward.
2:15:23 The second section is going to be the Sidewalk Master Plan Priority Projects.
2:15:28 As you know, Aaron Steele, during Focus Area 5, or excuse me, presented a list of potential
2:15:35 side-walk projects that are included in our sidewalk master plan. These are some of those
2:15:40 additional priorities that you may consider moving forward. Then category B, the normal
2:15:50 capital projects that appear in this budget we would refer to as category A of those project
2:15:56 dollars or those projects that are going to receive first dollar funding. They're completely
2:16:01 outlined in your budget and they're in the packet. Category B is a system that we created at the very
2:16:10 beginning of the COVID pandemic and what it allowed us to do was take a look at potential projects that
2:16:18 we could fund if revenues materialized higher than what we're anticipating. We have not gone
2:16:27 through the process for category B this year because last year the Council elected to fund all
2:16:32 all the category B projects in their entirety.
2:16:36 And so every year at the category B projects
2:16:39 are those projects that did not make it
2:16:42 through the balance budgeting process.
2:16:45 Somewhere along the way, whether it
2:16:47 be through the long-term planning committee
2:16:49 or whether that be at our big budget balancing,
2:16:52 those projects are reduced.
2:16:56 And then we have the category B project
2:16:58 or capital funding projects.
2:17:00 These didn't make it through the process
2:17:03 with long-term planning, these are the projects
2:17:05 that all the permits initially put forward,
2:17:07 and then in the long-term planning of valuation,
2:17:10 where these projects became category works as a priority
2:17:15 to notice some of these projects have been discussed
2:17:17 over the course of the presentations,
2:17:23 so projects that you would want to move forward with.
2:17:27 We handed out for your consideration,
2:17:32 spreadsheet with all of these projects outlined,
2:17:35 And then next week, the council has set aside time to go through and to assign those projects
2:17:44 into this year's budget.
2:17:49 In addition to that, I'll remind you that there is about $8.5 million of CARES funding.
2:17:55 Last week, the charter, who officially approved CARES Committee.
2:18:05 The CARES Committee, because that's what it started with, right?
2:18:08 but it's the SLFRF and what that has to do with,
2:18:13 we received a direct appropriation from the federal government
2:18:16 and that we have the opportunity to allocate those.
2:18:19 The council has elected to get a citizen input
2:18:23 and so we will have three citizens,
2:18:26 we'll have three members of the advisory commission
2:18:30 so that council will be in that process.
2:18:36 We'll start questions to projects in the task
2:18:55 with the care's money, that's going to be down the road as far as the decision is made on that, is how do we look at the budget that we need to deal with that.
2:19:13 So what we would recommend is that you look at that $770,000 and you fund the highest priorities as a council that you believe to move forward
2:19:26 and that you wait to receive the recommendation from the committee.
2:19:30 Remember the committee is going to recommend to the council the complete allocation of that $8.5 million
2:19:37 and so that we're hitting the targets established by the federal government.
2:19:41 It is only a recommendation, very similar to this budget, where the ANDO be the entire council
2:19:48 that votes on what projects to fund and what projects to move forward.
2:19:53 So I would focus on funding those projects that you can fit with under the 770 and then
2:19:59 be a strong advocate for those projects that you support as that recommendation comes forward
2:20:04 for the committee.
2:20:09 We're going to have some staff members here, just in case we have some final and additional
2:20:17 questions for some of these projects, every person whose department appeared on the council
2:20:25 capital category being represented in the audience next week.
2:20:32 Thank you.
2:20:34 We'll have a full house.
2:20:35 I'll follow up just real quick.
2:20:37 Yes.
2:20:38 on that I have received inquiries or quests from citizens on a couple of these
2:20:46 I just wanted to clarify those particularly the sunrise to make sure
2:20:54 that we're going to appear that sidewalk goes all the way past
2:21:00 So, here that Mr. Steele is available to help share that.
2:21:08 Mr. Hurry.
2:21:12 We certainly will.
2:21:16 Yes.
2:21:17 It's the visual.
2:21:19 It's the visual.
2:21:21 I just don't bring it.
2:21:23 Yeah.
2:21:24 Okay.
2:21:27 Anybody else have any questions?
2:21:30 Hey.
2:21:32 So then your charge next week is where, so we often refer to, you know, we had a pre-season
2:21:38 of budgeting in May and June.
2:21:40 We had the regular season of budgeting, which kind of ends tonight.
2:21:44 events tonight and then next week you can start the playoffs budgeting so next
2:21:50 week you're gonna take your first formal action on the budget that is where you
2:21:54 are going to adopt the tentative budget set the tentative budget is the maximum
2:22:04 spending cap it's not a conclusion of the process but what it does set is the
2:22:08 maximum dollar amount that you always go down but you first step then follow
2:22:28 All on the 15th we're going to have a complete review of the entirety of the budget.
2:22:33 Then follow up by on the 22nd we will ask the Council to adopt the budget.
2:22:38 What's great about our process is that it has been open, invited the public to participate
2:22:51 every single step along the way where most organizations give one shot and so I'm really
2:22:56 proud of this Council for really opening that up, being inclusive and encouraging individuals
2:23:02 to share their thoughts and ideas on how we can best allocate our resources.
2:23:07 That'll stand for your questions.
2:23:09 Any questions for Travis? Looks good.
2:23:18 Okay, so now's the time on the agenda for general public input.
2:23:23 If there's anybody in the audience that wishes to comment on anything not on the agenda or comment on the budget,
2:23:33 you're welcome to come down.
2:23:38 when you come down to the podium please state your name and whether you're a
2:23:42 citizen of Twin Falls and will limit your time to two minutes.
2:23:47 I thank you Citizen and thank you Mayor, thank you Council for hearing me out
2:23:54 tonight. My name is Patty. A few weeks back there was a meeting on where the
2:24:02 home owners should pay for their renters utility bill. I apologize but I
2:24:08 I have not heard the results on that.
2:24:10 Has that been voted on?
2:24:11 Has it passed?
2:24:12 Could someone fill me in?
2:24:19 It hasn't been voted on or passed.
2:24:20 I can tell you.
2:24:21 I will answer that.
2:24:21 That I will say, Brent is compiling the information.
2:24:24 He's got some emails.
2:24:25 He's supposed to be getting to council members who review.
2:24:28 And then it will come to council at that point in time.
2:24:33 Thank you.
2:24:34 Thank you.
2:24:37 Anybody else in the audience that wishes
2:24:39 to comment on anything?
2:24:43 OK, see no one advisory board reports.
2:24:47 Anybody?
2:24:48 I'm counsel with report.
2:24:49 The next week, right?
2:24:55 Yeah.
2:24:56 Yeah.
2:24:57 Yep.
2:24:59 Yep.
2:25:06 Did he manage his office?
2:25:07 Okay.
2:25:12 Do you have Kingsbury?
2:25:14 Oh, National night out.
2:25:15 Ooh.
2:25:16 Yeah.
2:25:19 That's my mind.
2:25:20 Just a reminder.
2:25:21 Tomorrow night.
2:25:22 Um, here in the city of Twin Falls, like all across the United States, is National night out.
2:25:26 Um, starting at five p.m.
2:25:28 City Park.
2:25:29 Uh, members of the Twin Falls Police Department, our fire department, our partner agencies.
2:25:33 So, here's a way to come out the entire public that will have representatives from all of the Magic Valley Law Enforcement Public Safety.
2:25:41 So, thank you.
2:25:42 Thank you, Chief.
2:25:43 Bye to eight.
2:25:47 I'm at City Park.
2:25:48 Excellent.
2:25:49 Okay.
2:25:50 There's no public hearings tonight.
2:25:52 So, with that, we are adjourned.
2:25:54 Thank you, everyone.
2:25:55 Everyone.
Download
- Transcript (text) 116 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 149 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 197 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.3 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 13.2 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, August 1, 2022. The recording started at 15:59 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:26:03.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
fd48a1861bcb0954d9d2ec0737a3110fed90634227f3ba283dfc2313f83fc761 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a d04c3c32ac20957603ccafddb37a9a2d88c2f6943303a42cbdabeed3dacdc9d0
part02.m4a 012199e6ec4091688109ca0314ac66d48a42f5a6ab3911ac3cf739e6ea7063cf - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
b699b2c423886fe3e19c319a7397c491adf86daddb59b692aed9083ccee4bf64
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file