OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, August 8, 2022

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: f

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:00:20 Good evening, ladies and gentlemen,

0:00:21 and welcome to the August 8th, 2020, 2022,

0:00:28 I guess city council meeting.

0:00:30 I wanna confirm we have a quorum.

0:00:31 We have six members present in council chambers.

0:00:36 First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:00:38 If you wish to join me, please rise.

0:01:00 We have no proclamations tonight.

0:01:03 So the next item on the agenda

0:01:05 is the consent calendar, council wishes.

0:01:15 I'd like to make a motion to approve the consent calendar.

0:01:18 Thank you.

0:01:19 Do I have a second?

0:01:20 Second.

0:01:22 Thank you.

0:01:23 Motion by Craig Hawkins.

0:01:24 Seconded by Christopher Reed to approve the consent calendar is written.

0:01:30 Aaron Roll call vote please.

0:01:33 Mayor Pierce.

0:01:34 Yes.

0:01:35 Ice mayor Reed.

0:01:36 Yes.

0:01:37 Nikki Boyd.

0:01:38 Yes.

0:01:39 Craig Hawkins.

0:01:40 Yes.

0:01:41 Jason Brown.

0:01:42 Yes.

0:01:43 Spencer Cutler.

0:01:44 Yes.

0:01:45 Thank you.

0:01:46 So if you were here for the IDO Transportation Airport Grant,

0:01:52 the Site Subdivision Number 1 Golden Eagle Subdivision Number 7, all those have been approved.

0:02:00 Okay, so next item under items of consideration is today's the big day.

0:02:06 We adoption of the tentative budget of the City of Twin Falls for the 2022-2023 fiscal year,

0:02:13 in the amount of 78,630,390 dollars in set August 22nd at 6 p.m. as a date and time for the public budget hearing and we have Travis Roth pilot.

0:02:30 So Madam Mayor, members of the City Council for the opportunity to again walk through the budget that we have prepared for you.

0:02:41 This journey for us always starts in February.

0:02:50 It starts in January with the long-term planning team assembling, coming together.

0:02:54 They really do a true diff, true diff, true.

0:03:00 It's getting at this podium all day, I heard it earlier, so here we go.

0:03:07 Their work sets the stage for the budget.

0:03:17 We'll go until the 22nd. Through the budget balancing process,

0:03:23 we then work on this budget.

0:03:30 shared that budget with you several weeks,

0:03:38 first with a larger overview, and then drilling into the focus area.

0:03:44 Tonight, we will again provide a overview and notice many members of the city's organization,

0:03:52 their team here, that are available to answer questions that you have.

0:03:55 We'll also ask for you to be going through the council capital part of the budget,

0:04:02 budget, which is that council directed capital of $770,000.

0:04:08 Each week we shared and we added to that list tonight for some direction, but we will start

0:04:22 our...

0:04:25 So the budget is really built upon a community that is evolving, that is growing and beginning

0:04:31 to experience a level of urbanism that is not something that we've seen previously.

0:04:40 watching our daytime population grow to nearly two times the size of the city of

0:04:47 Twin Falls at the same time that we've watched our housing market values grow

0:04:52 significantly. Labor continues to be a challenge. So the budget that's before you

0:04:59 is built but it's done in accordance with the GFOA best practices as well as

0:05:09 as the collection of state codes that are reflected on the screen.

0:05:14 Our budget is balanced, it is sustainable, and it's a course of action that we believe

0:05:19 that will help us meet the needs of a growing, also at a time of some level of uncertainty.

0:05:28 So we'll cut to the chase, cut to the chase on the final page.

0:05:33 You'll notice that the city's tax rate continues to go down,

0:05:36 but you'll also notice that there's a potential that individual property taxes may go up.

0:05:41 And the reason why is that individual property assessments are growing at a faster rate than

0:05:49 which we are able to cut the tax rate.

0:05:51 And so while the tax rate, as we'll show, is among the lowest that we've ever issued in

0:05:56 the history of the city of Twin Falls, the growth of property values inside the city continues

0:06:01 to help pace that decline.

0:06:04 Those areas that we have complete control, those areas of water, sewer, and sanitation,

0:06:09 notice that there are zero increases recommended and so at the end we're

0:06:14 looking if this median person did exist we're looking at a median

0:06:19 increase of about $24.6 a month in building a budget we spend a lot of time

0:06:32 going through a lot of different factors of the local economy and I know

0:06:38 that members of the city council have sat through many parts of this presentation

0:06:42 over the course of the last several weeks, but again, I think it's important for us to walk through this part of the budget so that people understand the environment in which we're creating the budget.

0:06:54 The first is a significant increase in population.

0:06:59 And these two charts really illustrate that.

0:07:04 The first chart in the corner, which is one that we shared with you, the darker the grain is a higher percent.

0:07:10 and it means it's 2% or more of individuals moving into these states,

0:07:15 but it's 2% growth of individuals who are 65 years old.

0:07:24 This also reflects those areas of the community,

0:07:29 our counties inside of our state,

0:07:32 that have seen an increase in population of 1.6% or more.

0:07:38 And as you can see, the state of Idaho is the only state

0:07:46 illustrated on this map in which it has every single county has experienced.

0:07:56 And so when the governor, when the Idaho Department of Commerce,

0:08:01 the Idaho Department of Labor, and many others say that Idaho continues to be

0:08:06 the fastest growing state, that has been a true statement year over year.

0:08:12 And when you look at the City of Twin Falls, it's not just the growth that we're experiencing,

0:08:18 but it's the growth of all the surrounding communities that we provide services to.

0:08:24 So we shared with you this chart, the growth of the population, census over census, and that area served.

0:08:35 make sense as to why the City of Twin Falls daytime population rose in excess of 100,000 people.

0:08:45 And you can see that in 2019, we did a traffic study that illustrated the 381,700 passenger vehicles

0:08:56 that came into and left the City of Twin Falls to be faces.

0:09:01 Again, those are passenger vehicles.

0:09:03 We were able to exclude tractor trailers and other vehicles from that.

0:09:09 And then you recognize that the City of Twin Falls is the retail, the education, medical center for a geographic area that contains about 260,000 people.

0:09:23 It makes sense to see why our daytime population continues to grow.

0:09:28 How does that impact us?

0:09:30 It impacts us on every facet of public service that we offer.

0:09:34 So, when you take a look at the police department, the police department has 81 sworn officers

0:09:44 that they're allocated, and if they're fully staffed at 52,000 people, our ratio of officers

0:09:52 per 1,000 is right around 1.6, and if you believe ratios, the FBI will tell you that's

0:10:00 a good number. But when you increase the daily influx, our population now becomes somewhere

0:10:10 around that 100 to 105. The number of officers per thousand is cut in half and that is not

0:10:23 a level that is sustainable because if you ever have the opportunity to read the police

0:10:29 reports, you see all they do. Very important piece of discretionary time is lost so that

0:10:45 so that they can go to the calls holding, but it also impacts the dispatch center.

0:10:51 It impacts the fire department.

0:10:54 It impacts the size of the roads in which we have to construct.

0:10:59 So every single aspect of our public works team is gravely impacted as well.

0:11:07 So when we think of the city of Twin Falls, it is often easy to think of our census population,

0:11:12 but hopefully through this conversation and through this budget process,

0:11:16 been able to look at the city of Twin Falls through the lens of the men and women that serve

0:11:21 our community and really it is a community in excess of a hundred thousand. There's no question

0:11:30 that costs continue to go up. Inflation continues to dominate our headlines, but it's also important

0:11:38 to recognize that the cost of business for a municipal organization is growing at a faster

0:11:43 rate than the consumer price index. Our index is referred to as the municipal cost index

0:11:50 and it has gone up as we've shared both 0.24% from the park. And while it has dipped from

0:11:59 its high in April, it is still in the double digits. Housing continues to, the value of

0:12:12 homes continues to increase. While we're starting to see some flattening, what is important to

0:12:18 note is that the median value of a home inside of the City of Twin Falls has grown by 30.8%

0:12:26 in a 12 month. Last year at this point in time, a median home inside of the City of Twin

0:12:38 Falls was $4,000 less than a national average. You can see the national average grew by 13.2%.

0:12:45 And now you can see how we've quickly outpaced that. You can see the median home value in

0:12:52 value in the state of Idaho is $1000 greater than in Twinfals, and what's the scary tale?

0:13:03 If you track our growth in price to the treasure valley, we have been plaguing one, so we believe

0:13:18 that Twinfals has been found, and we believe that there's not enough labor to be able

0:13:24 to construct the homes needed to meet the demand, and we believe that once inflation

0:13:31 It kind of gets in check and you start seeing a return to lower treasury notes and lower

0:13:38 interest rates and lower mortgage rates that you will see additional pressures placed on

0:13:46 the price point of homes.

0:13:47 And part of the reason is that we're not building enough new entry-level homes.

0:13:59 This is information that was provided by the US Census Bureau as well as from Freddie

0:14:03 Mac that illustrates that the number of homes that we constructed in the late 70s and early 80s

0:14:11 was greater than the homes that we constructed in 2020 when you consider an entry-level price

0:14:16 point in the graph and the information reflects that. I don't know a single organization inside

0:14:27 of the city of Twin Falls, public or private, and I don't know a single municipality that is bragging

0:14:36 that they're fully staffed. Labor continues to be one of the challenges that drives our

0:14:44 local economy. And so when you start coupling the cost of housing, inflationary index, and

0:14:52 the importance of retaining quality health, it becomes very easy to understand why the most

0:14:59 important emphasis that I placed onto this budget was preserving our most valuable asset. Those

0:15:06 Those are the people who work with us.

0:15:10 Making sure that we can continue to attract

0:15:15 and fill the vacancies that we have.

0:15:19 Right now, we're close to 10% vacancy rate

0:15:22 in our organization, and about half of those

0:15:25 are at the police department.

0:15:30 We need to continue to make sure

0:15:34 that we are able to attract,

0:15:37 we are able to retain, and as we shared with you,

0:15:46 this isn't a problem that is going to immediately go away.

0:15:51 We believe that this is a demographics problem, and this graph illustrates that there are, or available jobs,

0:15:58 that there are people working. Back to the Idaho Department of Labor has said that if all individuals who were unemployed,

0:16:06 all of a sudden found to still be 27,000 job openings across the state. Any places in which they can...

0:16:27 So those are the actors that when we were creating this budget, we took into account, we tracked those,

0:16:34 you've watched us update those along the way, and it's important that when we're looking at why did we create the budget that we did,

0:16:44 that we provide a glimpse into the logic that we used to present this proposal to you tonight.

0:16:53 of legend. The City of Twin Falls total taxable value grew by nearly $1.6 billion. Our tax rate is

0:17:05 going to decrease from $6.24 per 1,000 to $4.78 per 1,000. That anticipated 23.4% decrease is going

0:17:15 to create the lowest tax rate inside of the city. Let's first talk about growth. This is the value

0:17:22 of the City of Twin Falls. It excludes the growth that's included inside of the urban

0:17:27 or no area. If you add the $814 million, you can see that the City of Twin Falls is now

0:17:35 cresting over $6.3 million in total. Think about that for the City of Twin Falls in 2013

0:17:53 and the rate of value of the City of Twin Falls in this upcoming fiscal year is the equivalent

0:18:02 of the cumulative growth that has occurred in the last six and a half.

0:18:12 We believe that's going to continue as a result. Our tax rate has responded.

0:18:19 Our tax rate has decreased to among the lowest that we believe.

0:18:23 We want to say among the lowest ever, but certainly among

0:18:27 the lowest in the past several decades.

0:18:33 So when you ask why the tax rate is going down,

0:18:37 why would my property taxes be going up?

0:18:42 This complicated graph tries to tell that story.

0:18:47 I believe that if the legislature were to restore indexing,

0:18:52 which I have been told is a non-starter,

0:18:54 it is not a conversation that they're going to take up.

0:18:58 I believe that you would see immediate property tax relief.

0:19:02 So what is indexing?

0:19:04 Indexing is a reflection of the market.

0:19:08 Inside of the state of Idaho, we are

0:19:10 allowed to take 50% or for a period of time that was indexed. Indexing mean that it would

0:19:23 take a look at the the median inside of the state of Idaho and it would say about half

0:19:31 of that would be the cap. We believe the median value, the median value properties would create

0:19:43 a homeowner's exemption of $176,000.

0:19:48 If the $1,000 greater than the homeowner's exemption

0:19:51 that's afforded today,

0:19:57 even citizens would pay less in property taxes,

0:20:05 we'll continue to work hard at the legislative level

0:20:09 to try to re-institute the owner's exemption indexing.

0:20:18 Recognize and appreciate that it's a tax shift,

0:20:22 but I also will tell you that it is a shift

0:20:29 because the residential properties inside of the state of Idaho

0:20:33 have seen the largest rate of growth,

0:20:38 tax category to the associate tax fairs of Idaho.

0:20:44 So what does that mean, and how does Twin Falls compare?

0:20:49 So inside of all of Idaho, property values continue to grow

0:20:53 and continue to climb.

0:20:54 And what we like to do is compare how the city

0:20:57 of Twin Falls stacks up to the major cities

0:21:00 that we compete against.

0:21:01 And you can see that immediate home value

0:21:04 is going to differ in every community.

0:21:05 The tax rate is going to differ in every community,

0:21:08 but it's the best information that we have

0:21:10 and when you take that median home value

0:21:13 and you take it by the prior year's tax rate,

0:21:15 you're able to understand what did citizens

0:21:18 in each of these communities pay

0:21:20 in the form of municipal taxes in the prior year.

0:21:23 Because every city is going to be going through

0:21:25 their budget approval process.

0:21:27 We don't know where they're at, where they're going to land.

0:21:29 So this is where we're looking.

0:21:32 Last year inside of the state of Idaho

0:21:34 these major cities the citizens of Twin Falls pay the smallest city tax out of

0:21:42 the sample major cities of I know you'll notice that we exclude Boise and we exclude

0:21:49 Britain because they have the Ada County Highway District that does all of their

0:21:53 roads where we're responsible for our roads it's not really an apples to apples

0:21:59 comparison and it'll be interesting to see how these will continue to the next so

0:22:11 So our budget this year is $9 million in greater than it was last year.

0:22:16 You can see that about 60% is going to be the tax-supported funds, we refer to as the government

0:22:25 funds, and the 36.9% 37% is going to be at the enterprise funds with those funds that we

0:22:34 operate like independent businesses.

0:22:37 We break our budget down into five categories.

0:22:40 As we deliver services and our services are delivered by human talent, it logically makes

0:22:46 sense that the largest piece of our budget is going to be on the personnel side.

0:22:51 Let's talk about our people.

0:22:56 Right now inside the City of Twin Falls, the Council has allocated 317.5 employees.

0:23:01 We're asking for additional employees in this budget.

0:23:05 However, some of those employees were already included in budget amendments through the

0:23:09 as the four police officers that we receive from the COPS grant, as well as moving or planning

0:23:15 and zoning technician for the CDBG position, are part of those positions that were approved

0:23:22 in the current fiscal year.

0:23:23 We're looking for four new positions to assist, really, with a leadership workload.

0:23:27 We're looking for a deputy prosecuting attorney.

0:23:30 We're looking for a traffic engineer technician.

0:23:34 We're looking for a water ops position, and we're also looking to add a deputy fire chief

0:23:40 You can see that the maintenance operation costs for the City of Twin Falls across all funds is going to go up 7.46%.

0:23:50 If you recall a few slides ago, the Municipal Cost Index was 12%.

0:23:55 And so you can see that our department leaders were able to really look within their budgets and find ways to find savings and efficiencies to the municipal company.

0:24:09 We have a very large and robust capital project list that's detailed throughout the budget while we hit some of those high points in a minute.

0:24:24 But we're looking to spend about 18.2 million dollars. That excludes the fire stations that we'll be moving forward as well.

0:24:36 Those are going to be funded throughout a series of fiscal years and so that amount isn't necessarily included.

0:24:43 And then as you're aware, we issued the certificate of participation and that has officially closed

0:24:48 and so we'll be able to draw that down out of our construction fund.

0:24:55 Any questions on the broad overview of the budget before I dive into the individual focus areas?

0:25:02 Questions for Travis?

0:25:05 Have you seen this before?

0:25:07 Did my sleep last night?

0:25:10 I did too.

0:25:14 So everything that we do is aligned with our strategic plan.

0:25:21 Our strategic plan has a primary focus area, that's how we presented the budget, you'll notice

0:25:27 that everything kind of points to the internal organization which is really a commitment

0:25:31 to our people.

0:25:34 We have money in this year's budget to do a refresh of the city's strategic plan, you

0:25:39 didn't update five years ago, we're going to go through the process, a very community-driven

0:25:44 process to validate that the 2030 vision still is relevant, and there's a lot that has changed

0:25:50 in our community since 2012, and it's important that we go through a pretty significant overhaul.

0:25:56 The Council and the community will be invited to be a part of that as we kind of fiscal year

0:26:02 D3 and calendar. So our first focus area is a healthy community. Really we focus on what

0:26:12 are those aspects that create a quality healthy community. You can see that some of the larger

0:26:17 projects that we had that were really geared around the parks, park creation, parks and recreation

0:26:24 programs that we offer. The second was our library and Tara came in and she shared her projects.

0:26:35 They have the here handling unit. They also have $261,000 in four books. We spent an entire evening

0:26:46 talking about Focus Area 3. You could see we account for the four police officers inside of

0:26:52 the budget, the four patrol cars, improvements to the firing range, which is really a demonstration

0:26:58 of the partnership that we have with the county and how we look at training together,

0:27:03 we utilize shared facilities in that collaborative partnership to ensure that both of us are able

0:27:09 to maximize the scarce resources that we have.

0:27:12 And the additional prosecutor is included in there as well as the deputy fire chief.

0:27:17 Fire stations two and three, which are not necessarily directly included in the budget,

0:27:22 but we noted those capital costs and then also the training facility.

0:27:26 Being an accessible community really talked about the maintenance of our roadways and continuing

0:27:38 to ensure that we're multi-modal, but you also see some airport construction projects that

0:27:44 are down there as well.

0:27:45 The airport is one of those really interesting parts of our organization where it is certainly

0:27:50 transportation.

0:27:51 It helps us get from point A to point B, but as we shared under focus area six, it really

0:27:56 became a part of that prosperous community piece,

0:28:01 where as we have watched the decline

0:28:09 follows with Sky West, the importance of air travel,

0:28:14 and our business community has been one of those reminders

0:28:19 that think is it that the prevalence

0:28:26 at the city of Twin Falls to ensure

0:28:28 that we have that prosperous community.

0:28:33 There's lots of water projects.

0:28:35 In fact, this is probably the single largest collection

0:28:38 of capital projects out of the Water Fund,

0:28:41 And it's a testament to the council that buying off

0:28:44 on the concept that we had,

0:28:45 paying off the debt early,

0:28:48 taking those funds and creating a capital improvement fund.

0:28:51 And the benefit of that is going to be reflected this year

0:28:54 is when you add up all of the capital projects

0:28:57 inside the Water Fund, I believe it exceeds $7 million,

0:29:01 the largest of which is the Hankins' pressurize zone,

0:29:04 which is listed as a single project,

0:29:06 but it's really a collection of 10 to 12 projects

0:29:09 that will really help improve pressure and water availability

0:29:11 in a vital part of our town, who also help us take advantage of great economic opportunities

0:29:17 in the future.

0:29:18 A little bit about the airport, but also this is where our partnership with the Group of

0:29:25 the Old Agency exists.

0:29:26 There are no agency met today, and they're looking at those processes of creating additional

0:29:33 industrial zone areas so we can continue to capitalize on growth and job, but also closing

0:29:39 out this urban or normal area that's downtown and looking at creating an additional one

0:29:44 with the councils of the future to make sure that we can take advantage of the momentum that's

0:29:51 been generated with our downtown improvements and see if we can capitalize and create additional.

0:29:58 Being a responsible community really talks about the processes that we use, but there's also two

0:30:02 pieces of this. Number one is going to be the council directed capital, which you'll be talking

0:30:07 about in a minute. But the second is also going to be the SLFRF funding, also known as CARERS,

0:30:15 also known as PARPA, also known as lots of other names, but really this is the nearly

0:30:24 8.5 million dollars that will be coming into the community council committee

0:30:30 reviewed on the names of the applicants who submitted their credentials, they're

0:30:35 going to work through and they're going to interview on the list of individuals

0:30:39 and then that committee hopes to get running on September 15th, the first of

0:30:54 and then our internal organization. We spent a lot of time talking about our

0:31:01 internal organization. We talked about our benefits, we talked about our programs,

0:31:05 we talked about expanding capacities and really emphasizing our one-sending

0:31:10 program. We talked about the number of improvements that are going and the

0:31:15 different things that we're doing in terms of workplace safety wellness. In

0:31:23 addition to that, there's tools but there's also compensation and we're

0:31:27 asking for a 5% performance adjustment for our employees. We're asking for a

0:31:33 2% table move. We're asking for a one-time payment of $2,000 to every employee,

0:31:38 continuation of our retention program for those who are eligible on their five-year

0:31:45 anniversaries and then absorbing the 11.4% increase in our health insurance cost.

0:31:51 One of the big ones up there is why would you do a one-time payment of $2,000?

0:31:57 And it's a balanced approach. That approach is we recognize that 5% is lower

0:32:04 than the cost of living index that we're all realizing, and yet we don't believe that we

0:32:13 can create a sustainable long-term budget if we were to increase it to that, and so what

0:32:20 we're trying to do is we're trying to temporarily buy down that cost of living that all of our

0:32:25 employees are experiencing by offering a one-time payment that doesn't get built into our based

0:32:32 budgets, but yet, helps our employees at a time of rapid inflation and significant increased

0:32:41 costs.

0:32:42 It's also, hopefully, one of the ways that we could say thank you for being a part of our

0:32:47 team and for working as we're, that's with exception to this.

0:33:05 This is the Council-Directed Capital.

0:33:07 You'll every council member should have a copy of that.

0:33:17 I don't know exactly how you want to go through this, but again, here's the Council Director of Capital Projects.

0:33:23 That's your request.

0:33:25 Her and Steel are Assistant Public Works Director.

0:33:28 He's here and he's able to kind of walk through and talk through the different sideway of the projects.

0:33:34 And so he is available to come up.

0:33:36 and we also have the category of the projects,

0:33:42 those projects that could be funded

0:33:44 over the course of the next fiscal year

0:33:47 should revenues come forward in the past,

0:33:50 the council has elected to fund some of these in advance.

0:33:55 So with that, there's an incredible team behind me

0:33:57 that helped build this budget.

0:33:59 And as you have questions, they will just kind of come up

0:34:03 and they will be able to answer questions

0:34:06 and help you kind of work through this process.

0:34:08 Thank you.

0:34:09 So before Travis sits down, any questions for him?

0:34:13 So first, we're going to tap Aaron, because I know that there are a lot of questions regarding sidewalks and that's in our major focus.

0:34:25 Everybody's OK with that. You start with Aaron. You knew I'd call on you right away.

0:34:30 I was good at eating. I saw the eye.

0:34:34 Yeah, right.

0:34:35 It was the get ready.

0:34:37 So where would you like me to start? I've prepared a little slight presentation before that I can show again and kind of walk you through a couple of

0:34:47 Locations is that where you'd like me to start? Okay? That'd be a great start. Thank you

0:34:53 Just a second to get a little bit up here as usual took lots of classes and call it okay

0:36:13 again

0:36:14 This is in focus area four. I'll scroll through a couple these real quick. So we we gave you a couple locations to look at that

0:36:22 We're on the other sides of the Travis present

0:36:24 location J, H, M, O, and D. So, these location J is right there on

0:36:31 Stadium Boulevard. It's a small little piece. It's about $80,000 in order to complete some sidewalk.

0:36:38 It's just a little piece of missing sidewalk there. And it's just to the east

0:36:42 of Eastland Drive. Just a small little piece that's missing. So that cost is $80,000.

0:36:52 Yes.

0:36:53 So that one, the 80,000, design, completion, everything's built into that 80,000, there's

0:36:59 correct, there's also some contingency associated with that one, but ultimately that one's

0:37:03 that's start, finish, done.

0:37:05 And no right away, acquisition.

0:37:07 No, in a piece that we don't believe there's any right away that we need to.

0:37:11 Thank you.

0:37:14 So the next one is right there on Hanson street, just across street from the library.

0:37:19 On that side, there's no sidewalks and this is another fairly simple project.

0:37:24 There's not much in the way. The property is already, the property of the city of Twin Falls is a park.

0:37:29 So we could go ahead and put the sidewalk along that area, a couple of ADA ramps.

0:37:33 The cost for that one is $271,000 and that one's complete.

0:37:39 Start to finish up. This one we thinks a little bit higher, but we didn't know what the cost was to move some of that equipment.

0:37:45 The play equipment that's there, right? So we added a little bit more there just to make sure we're okay.

0:37:51 location and so this is on south wouldn't have to be completely honest with you

0:37:55 I think I made a mistake when I brought this one for last time and the reason

0:37:59 why is this road right here is Washington Street South which is I TD

0:38:03 jurisdiction there's a piece of sidewalk that's missing along here the hard part

0:38:08 is if we make a connection to Washington Street south people are going to cross

0:38:13 it so I think putting this one in now would not go where well we've not had

0:38:19 any conversations with ITD. It's the general consensus of the public that they

0:38:26 don't like Hawks or the pedestrian hybrid beacons because they're not a full

0:38:30 signal. So I think at this point we'd want to take staff and take this one back

0:38:35 off the list. I apologize that I brought it forward the last time.

0:38:39 All right. Less things to worry about. So we'll withdraw that one.

0:38:43 Okay. So location, oh this is stadium over. This is one that I know we've had quite a

0:38:50 a few questions on. This is one of the projects that Council directed funds paid for for design.

0:38:58 This is current fiscal year. I received an email today from the engineer of record who's

0:39:02 done the design with an accurate, what I feel is an accurate cost estimate, which is going

0:39:08 to change the number that you see on your screen. Because the design is far enough

0:39:13 along that he feels comfortable giving us the assessment. So the estimate that he gave me

0:39:16 just about an hour and a half ago is about $290,000. So $285.47. So I'm rounding up to the

0:39:25 $290 just to keep it a little easier to deal with. But that estimate does contain contingencies

0:39:33 and his construction start to finish for that piece.

0:39:36 And that's on our list, stating all of our sidewalks sunrise to east of Mountain View.

0:39:42 Correct. And again, we're connecting two pieces of existing sidewalk.

0:39:47 And that's instead of 500 on our list, it's 290.

0:39:50 Yep, exactly.

0:39:52 And that was just received just a couple hours ago.

0:39:56 That's location O. Location D is Elizabeth Boulevard,

0:39:59 just right though.

0:40:00 They're down by the YMCA, or the old YMCA,

0:40:03 because it's not that anymore.

0:40:04 And Harman Park, this piece is still under design.

0:40:09 He doesn't have a good feel for what that cost is going to be

0:40:12 quite yet.

0:40:13 So we're still looking at the 632.

0:40:15 I don't think it's going to be that blue.

0:40:16 I don't have a good number for you tonight.

0:40:18 He's still working through some irrigation issues,

0:40:22 some trees and stuff in the way.

0:40:25 So he didn't, he was not comfortable to get me out,

0:40:29 but this was the original one.

0:40:32 So is that design work going to be completed soon?

0:40:37 Yes.

0:40:38 With a better number?

0:40:39 Yes.

0:40:39 We just don't know what that is.

0:40:40 I just don't know when that I don't schedule

0:40:42 for completion this.

0:40:43 For completion by October 1, absolutely.

0:40:47 So those are the locations that we've proposed.

0:40:51 Are there any questions about an individual location or something you'd like to see?

0:40:55 This bullet has been full of audit six-fifths.

0:41:04 It says six-thirties here.

0:41:06 I bet that's kind of an iffy number right now.

0:41:09 I'd really love to give you a better number, but I don't have one yet.

0:41:11 So, at this point, I would still have to say let's do the six-hundred-thirty-two-thousand.

0:41:24 Mason.

0:41:28 Looking at this Hawk pedestrian crossing, a system at Filer, Marie, certainly, can you speak to that or do I need to hold on to that for somebody else to...

0:41:38 I can start the conversation if you'd like.

0:41:40 I don't want to divert from sidewalks because that's what we're kind of talking about.

0:41:43 I've got a sense of a mission to study.

0:41:45 Is there somebody else here that would take it back?

0:41:47 For you too, why don't we let crazy guy's sidewalk question?

0:41:50 That's my question.

0:41:51 And then we could maybe move on to the hub.

0:41:53 Aaron, I just was wondering, is there any study downer information as far as the safety factor?

0:42:01 Do some of these projects have a higher risk or, I guess what I'm trying to say would be,

0:42:08 That's a great question. When we originally did this plan, the way we looked at each one

0:42:17 of these projects was in a relationship to public offices, parks, schools. Those got a

0:42:24 higher prioritization than the rest. And so these ones that have come out that you're

0:42:29 seeing have a higher priority than some of the others that we didn't even present tonight.

0:42:33 But if you're looking at some of these tonight that we're specifically speaking of, these

0:42:39 These are all close to schools or main routes to get kids to schools.

0:42:43 So, to rate one above the other is kind of a washy.

0:42:47 Any other sidewalk questions for Aaron before we talk about the rest of the list?

0:43:01 Who's going to talk about maybe you're going to start?

0:43:08 I can take the hockey over.

0:43:10 I can ask the question.

0:43:12 to come up to answer it, but as I was looking at it and having a child that goes to Twin

0:43:20 Falls High School and walking across there, is there another alternative to the Hock?

0:43:27 I know that there is a current flashing light there.

0:43:30 Is there an alternative that may be a step up from what's currently there that's not

0:43:35 quite a point to Hock?

0:43:37 I know there's some community feeling about what HOC systems can do or what they are,

0:43:42 but in this particular location I was wondering if there's something else on that particular area that's a little bit more than what we do.

0:43:52 There's always different options. I know the reason the HOC came up was when we did the road safety audit from Filer.

0:43:58 One of the crew that was here that was doing the audit specifically mentioned putting a HOC in at that location.

0:44:04 And so because of that, that's why I believe that it wound up in here,

0:44:09 was because that was a recommendation by the Road Safety Audit Group.

0:44:14 There are other options that I believe we could possibly look into,

0:44:18 but I don't have any answers for you about.

0:44:21 I guess my personal feeling would be,

0:44:24 I mean I appreciate the recommendation,

0:44:27 but I would like to see if there's maybe an option that is less expensive than that HOC system.

0:44:32 Maybe not go to that point just yet.

0:44:35 And I can't remember if, you know, what would the recommendation from that safety audit was and why a hawk, why would we go to the hawk right off the bat?

0:44:45 Sure.

0:44:46 You have any...

0:44:47 The hawk is a widely accepted...

0:44:49 Okay.

0:44:52 ...for getting kids across streetry and pedestrians of any sort, right?

0:44:56 It's pretty common to be used.

0:44:58 Oh, Troy's here.

0:45:00 So is it is a hot the same thing that's Washington

0:45:04 Across Washington and

0:45:06 Okay, thank you. Go ahead try. Yeah, I think one of the big

0:45:12 That meeting is it is a pedestrian safety device, right? You push it. You see the flashing

0:45:17 you know red lights

0:45:21 Reticed but the part of the eye took away is the traffic flows there

0:45:24 But with all the kids going to from seminary at all hours throughout the entire day

0:45:29 and really backs up traffic.

0:45:31 The Hawk system, by and over, when the kids push the button, they just don't go automatically.

0:45:37 It actually allows the cars to move.

0:45:42 Stop that congestion on the fire.

0:45:44 It queues up the kids to kind of punch up, and then they walk across the group.

0:45:49 So they really hoard our safety.

0:45:53 They tear off, and then they have a little next time.

0:45:57 The next guy that comes along, he pushes the button, he has to actually wait for 30 seconds.

0:46:01 They have other signals, so it types the kids more than just, you know, you'll see two always walking down.

0:46:10 but they're always brushed off, so 15 minutes every hour.

0:46:14 I'm sure that makes a difference.

0:46:16 They'll just go.

0:46:17 And I bet, again, my personal feeling is I'd

0:46:23 like to see if there's something that maybe has some of those

0:46:27 features that we're not going to the full blown system right

0:46:31 away.

0:46:32 I see the necessity for the one on Washington.

0:46:35 It's significantly bigger to me than

0:46:39 That filer is just trying to get people to and from so the time is important, but here

0:46:46 I would just I guess again my recommendation would be is there an alternative to the HOC system that we could look at Jason Craig Hawkins

0:46:58 Are you good?

0:47:10 I drive seven thirty to four thirty or whatever

0:47:15 It's twenty miles an hour. We did filer and we took out the highland

0:47:21 and I hate the visibility because the bus lane is there.

0:47:27 I have seen nothing but smooth operation.

0:47:31 I've never seen a problem.

0:47:33 The kids are going to walk across the street,

0:47:36 and if they look up, you're blessed.

0:47:39 Must be a good omen from the day or something.

0:47:43 And they're going to do that no matter what.

0:47:53 This just seems like $1,000 to solve a problem.

0:48:00 Doesn't really exist other than some drivers

0:48:05 get impatient when it's a note that it's the high school kids are crossing that

0:48:16 since near Mrs. what I just can't get I can't see what the problem is there I'm

0:48:27 very familiar with the area I watch how drivers behave how pedestrians behave it

0:48:33 seems to be working about as good as it's gonna work we can spend 350 and the kids

0:48:40 are not gonna push buttons and wait much up and cross together they they just

0:48:46 Don't do that. They're not going to do that.

0:48:48 True.

0:48:49 It's just not the end thing.

0:48:52 So it'd have to look up from their phone.

0:48:55 Exactly.

0:48:56 When the road safety autocrew was here, we had a couple people from the state of Washington.

0:49:01 One of the guys wrote the book about road safety audits.

0:49:04 And he was very concerned when he looked at it because traffic had backed up.

0:49:08 Six cars?

0:49:11 It was more than that. It was clear back.

0:49:13 Clear back, past Alteras.

0:49:15 And there was kids walking in the street, trying to cross in between vehicles.

0:49:19 And so that's why this game is where it is, is because he said you can't have this.

0:49:24 Eventually you're going to have an accident, it's just a matter of if Josh did you have something on there.

0:49:29 If you know what's going to happen, it's my understanding of the Hawkeyes, you actually don't have the immediate right-of-way, right?

0:49:37 So if you have a regular beacon out there, the pedestrian pushes the button, and they can pretty much immediately proceed.

0:49:43 The difference with the Hawkeyes is pretty much the traffic is going to have that right away until a signal gives the pedestrians a walking man so you can actually cross.

0:49:51 So, in theory, assuming it's used correctly, it truly would queue up those pedestrians because they can't cross until they're given the signal ago.

0:50:01 And so it's supposed to help the traffic and the pedestrians cross better.

0:50:05 It binds their feet?

0:50:07 No.

0:50:08 If used correctly, right? But I'm just trying to let you know that that is the thought you...

0:50:13 You as a vehicle have the right-of-way in that situation, until the signal changes and loss of pedestrians to go.

0:50:19 But anybody driving there is going to know it's a school zone, and the kids aren't looking,

0:50:25 and the onus falls on us, and nobody wants to get a kid.

0:50:29 I agreed. A big educational piece would have to occur.

0:50:33 I think we'd have to reach out to both a high school and a seminary and say, this is how it works,

0:50:37 this is how it's supposed to work, and a big training, so what it would work.

0:50:41 The whole system on Caswell in Washington is it works, it's huge, it's obnoxious, it's right, it's organ in those homes right there, so that's there for them to look at and deal with all the time.

0:51:02 As you can see, I am not in favor of this at all, but I just wanted to see if there was any other information.

0:51:10 and then it's a good idea and it would be safe and we could maybe teach the kids how to use it.

0:51:16 350,000 could do a lot of good, a lot of places. I just don't see that this is a spot. Thank you,

0:51:25 thank you. Chris Reed. Yes, if that's all right. So starting with the putting down the stadium,

0:51:38 of our sidewalk for 290,000. Also the location Jay Stadium east of East of East London, 80,000,

0:51:50 then location H on Hanson for 271,000. Those three come up to 641,000. Does leave some buffer there.

0:52:02 Understanding that the HAWC system is something that I think we should discuss in other options,

0:52:09 Because that area does need to be looked at as we had that presentation on all of filer.

0:52:16 But those specific areas, the only reason that I had some other things for Elizabeth,

0:52:22 but understanding that we just talked about stadium going from 500,000 to 290,000.

0:52:28 That was a significant drop.

0:52:30 I'm wondering what Elizabeth Street at 650,000 would change to.

0:52:34 That's why I've kind of moved that one until the design's done and we understand.

0:52:40 Absolutely.

0:52:41 Those three, I think, for me, I would like to see the funds go to, understanding there's

0:52:47 some excess funds there too that we could spend money on, but those three are ready

0:52:53 to go and could be completed this year where the design is done with one and start to finish

0:53:01 would be done on the other two.

0:53:04 Thank you, Chris. How is everybody feeling about that? I'm in agreement with those three

0:53:09 items. I think that our focus has been on sidewalks and schools and that really does fit our bill.

0:53:19 It's unfortunate we don't have another 632,000 to make sure Elizabeth's done, but we may be

0:53:27 able to piece that out. Maybe there's a cell of far offense. Do we have to spend it all

0:53:38 Can't you give us 30 seconds to huddle? Like I said, I got really really smart people.

0:53:43 Okay, sure.

0:53:44 I'm trying to find solutions as you are describing funding opportunities, so if you give us like 30 seconds.

0:53:52 Yeah, you're good. Jonathan and Andy might have come up with an additional funding source.

0:53:57 So Spencer, do you want to go ahead while they're headling?

0:54:03 Yeah, thank you, Mayor. I'd like to say I'd rather prioritize sidewalks over the HOC system.

0:54:09 I'm not against it per se, but sidewalks and the hot system are both safety related, so I'd rather prioritize sidewalks.

0:54:16 I'd like Vice Mayor Reed's suggestions.

0:54:21 I'd love to fit the rock park improvements in here somehow.

0:54:26 I might sacrifice some of the other sidewalk master plan priorities if it was all up to me, but that's my thoughts.

0:54:35 Well, Andy, if we didn't give a hundred fifteen, we could give a hundred twenty-nine, which would then make your seven seventy.

0:54:43 Don't have to expend love as a potential complication.

0:54:51 Complication.

0:54:52 Can we use the more work?

0:54:54 We're in the process with our CDBG funds to do an environmental study.

0:54:58 We have to do a study before we can touch the money to do projects, but this area of town is in that study.

0:55:04 The location H at the City Park is a potential to be used for CDBG funds.

0:55:08 use for CDBG funds all at 271 or a version of a sidewalk in that area could be paid

0:55:14 for with that CDBG funds could come off of here and use federal money for it. We just

0:55:19 have to go through a real long process to get that money. We're not done with this.

0:55:23 We couldn't fund it, but we are going through the process right now.

0:55:27 Actually, good news. So what happens if that isn't, I mean, we take that chance,

0:55:38 So do we put it in here and then take that chance that you're going to fund it and then

0:55:41 we do this again and find...

0:55:43 In the end, the City Council is the only one that will direct us on those funds and we

0:55:47 just went through that modification process to allow us to tap the money for it.

0:55:52 This is the one of two low to moderate income areas of Census tracts that we are very highly

0:55:58 confident that it would be fun to do.

0:56:00 And it's a hard decision, that's what you're saying basically.

0:56:02 We would we come back to you with the project in the end to get it through the

0:56:06 HUD process, CDBG process, but we believe this is

0:56:10 one of the higher priorities we have to change it to that downtown funding.

0:56:15 Well then if you take that off for a 370, so we have another 400 to spend.

0:56:19 Here you go. This next fiscal year. We are really trying hard to ease in this next fiscal year if not

0:56:34 it'll be quickly thereafter. But we have a timeline that we need to spend it from a federal standpoint

0:56:41 So we're trying really hard to do that.

0:56:43 So, just for a question, could somebody talk about Thompson Park Trail replacement?

0:56:52 Could you do that?

0:56:53 I was also going to throw in there, whoever comes up to talk about the dog park again,

0:56:59 it just reminds me exactly what the improvements are.

0:57:04 Yes, thank you, Madam Council members.

0:57:09 I can speak to both of those things.

0:57:11 Which one do you want to hear first?

0:57:15 good Thompson part. Okay, so we had a bid that we're of 20-1 for $75,000 to replace that

0:57:26 asphalt pathway. That was just a price, didn't get funded. We didn't really see it as a necessary

0:57:34 priority. I've been back, saw it again. It is getting worse and getting spread with water

0:57:40 continually. So we think that that one could be replaced. We increased the amount because

0:57:47 It's been a year and a half with the price increases, so that came to, what, ninety-three?

0:57:58 Ninety-three hundred, let's, yeah, so that's just a price increase, but that is in collaboration

0:58:03 with the Public Library.

0:58:05 They've already purchased some panels that are going to be like post-signs out there

0:58:12 that can accommodate storybook boards that they can be replaced and put different stories

0:58:19 out there at different times.

0:58:20 So it'd be a storybooked trail using these funds and company libraries already.

0:58:33 So with that, so if I can't measure it, would you stay in the same path as the current trail,

0:58:39 or would you change the configuration with this?

0:58:44 Yeah, so there's no change in the configuration of design except for the elevation.

0:58:49 Okay, so it'd be more to grade right now, I think it has a second coat on it that kind

0:58:55 of rounded it off.

0:58:56 Okay, that's above grade, and so the edges are crumbling away, so this one would be torn

0:59:02 out completely and then replaced instead of a...

0:59:07 And so the library would also help do that interactive process with... are there pedestals

0:59:15 or maybe explain what they're being the additional expense to this 93,000 to help the library get what they need there.

0:59:22 No, so they've funded the panels and they've already shipped them.

0:59:27 Okay, so we've already received those. We can then we can install them in-house if necessary.

0:59:34 There'd be a small expense maybe to have them put in a foundation.

0:59:38 Okay, placed yes, but I think we already have that in our

0:59:42 Provema funds, yeah. The Baxter Dog Park.

0:59:49 So, Baxter's was one that was a, it was not staff driven,

0:59:53 it was community driven. A presentation

0:59:57 was brought forth asking for those funds for improvements

1:00:01 to the park. From the department perspective,

1:00:05 we agree that something can be done out there.

1:00:09 But since those funds were requested without a specific design of project or bid in mind,

1:00:17 we feel like the 150,000 is not an accurate representation of what's really needed out there.

1:00:23 It may be more so what we would recommend is that we fund a portion of that for design for this next year.

1:00:32 And wasn't there a dollar amount attributed to design and estimates?

1:00:40 We didn't, so Madam Mayor, that's a perfect representation of what had occurred and I think

1:00:47 that you have to go back to Baxter's Park when it was initially created.

1:00:51 I think that there was this idea that we had created Dog Park, but there wasn't a lot of

1:00:57 any effort that went into the creation of the Dog Park as a result of that lack of planning.

1:01:04 we are experiencing some of maybe the issues that we have out there today.

1:01:10 The concept would be to fund a master plan.

1:01:14 It would ultimately describe what Baxter's Park would look like

1:01:20 at a full building, much like what Parks and Recreation is doing

1:01:24 on several of their other plans.

1:01:26 Stack Rock is a group that we've been using for a lot of the smaller parks

1:01:30 plans, and they range in place, I believe, between 5,000, depending on

1:01:34 depending on the plexi of the part, we think that this would be slightly more than that

1:01:39 because of the public involvement piece that could be included.

1:01:42 The idea beyond the planning phase was that to be able to actually get some level of initial completion

1:01:50 funded to cure some of the more significant deficiencies that we have in the park in the areas of day

1:02:00 with whatever might be balanced, whatever is left over,

1:02:04 that 150 was a complete stab in the dark if that, but for some what we need to do is build a comprehensive plan towards, but then we can also share.

1:02:31 So given that there may be more community involvement, what would your projection for a master plan cost up to 40,035?

1:02:43 I would say that that would be great.

1:02:51 What?

1:02:53 Janice?

1:02:55 Do you have a...

1:02:56 30 to 35 might be probably a really good number.

1:02:58 Would you want to go to 50?

1:03:01 So, 30 to 35,000 might be really good for a master planning piece of it.

1:03:05 So, a quick question.

1:03:08 So, not advocating this.

1:03:11 Let's say we went to 50,000.

1:03:13 What happens to the money if you don't spend that, I guess, is if we don't spend some of

1:03:18 this money, what happens in next fiscal year or that, down the road?

1:03:22 Yeah, that's a great question. So what the Council will do is they will

1:03:25 allocate funding for a project and if the project is under those funds, do not

1:03:33 automate spend because what's your what the Councils are doing is they're creating a

1:03:40 work plan. Sometimes our work plans underestimate. So we have to come and ask for contingency.

1:03:49 In the cases that we overestimate those dollars

1:03:53 authorized by the council, but it takes specific action to take those savings and apply them.

1:04:01 Or they automatically just revert into cash reserves for future budgets.

1:04:07 Sorry.

1:04:09 Go ahead.

1:04:10 And then I have a question.

1:04:11 Sorry.

1:04:12 So I wanted to follow up with that.

1:04:13 I guess that would be my preference is because I'm just hearing some of the input from the general public,

1:04:21 general public is the dog park appears to be used quite heavily as from what I understand

1:04:29 my my request would be that we do have some type of planning document that helps us direct

1:04:36 some of that funding but also looking is there are there other areas in the city of Twin Falls that

1:04:42 maybe another dog park is warranted or needed for future and really understand what that

1:04:48 So, I would suggest maybe looking at 40,000 knowing that if we can reallocate some money

1:04:58 down the road, take care of that.

1:05:07 So I do have a question.

1:05:09 Thank you.

1:05:10 I think that's probably parks.

1:05:11 Yeah, we're good.

1:05:12 Back to sidewalks for a minute.

1:05:15 Is there any way to partially fund Elizabeth?

1:05:18 I mean, we paid for the, or we're paying for the design phase.

1:05:24 Is there any way to chuck that up?

1:05:29 No pen intended.

1:05:30 That's a fantastic question.

1:05:35 I brought Josh up here to see if he, something triggers his mind too about that.

1:05:39 The Lord Bar is where we don't know what the exact cost is going to be.

1:05:42 How do I chuck that up?

1:05:48 I think there's a way to chuck it.

1:05:50 But at the end of the day, what we would do is change the term in Australia.

1:05:53 It only goes from here to here to here.

1:05:55 And more than likely, we're going to spend more money for the entire project over multiple

1:06:00 that it will be all together, but I think there's a way to say you have

1:06:04 X-summer of dollars to spend on this project, and I know some contracts have been created

1:06:08 where you actually based the contract on the number of dollars you have

1:06:12 and the contractor pretty much says, alright, I can go this far with the project, so

1:06:17 I think it's an option. So given what we've talked about, if we put

1:06:21 out if we put 360,000 words that if we funded the full 40 for the dog park, that gets us

1:06:32 to our 770. But I don't know if that makes sense. Yes.

1:06:44 The two that we've been, the stadium, well, both stadium, both of our, those two areas putting

1:06:55 those down coming to 370,000.

1:07:00 I think we need to do something with Baxter Dog Park, Dog Parks.

1:07:04 But I think that for what we're talking about right now,

1:07:07 where there's a lot of ifs and maybes and possibles

1:07:10 that we just discussed, I think coming back

1:07:12 with a plan of this is who we're going to use

1:07:15 and this is what's going to happen,

1:07:16 and this is the dollar amount would be is the direction

1:07:21 I would like to go, as opposed to set aside 40,000.

1:07:26 and maybe it comes back under, maybe it comes back over,

1:07:29 and just that forward is a complete plan

1:07:32 and take the 400,000 towards Elizabeth Street

1:07:36 and try to get that done with that dollar amount,

1:07:40 whether we potentially use external and some internal

1:07:49 for getting that project done,

1:07:51 but understanding that five years ago,

1:07:53 when we started this, it was for sidewalks

1:07:56 and we have three sidewalk projects

1:07:59 that I feel like we can get pretty far on.

1:08:01 Well, and if by chance, I mean, Stadium came a couple hundred thousand below budget.

1:08:08 If by chance that came a couple hundred thousand below budget, that's close to 400.

1:08:15 I mean, I don't wonder if there's other options for funding a master plan for a dog park other than using council funds.

1:08:33 Or the money.

1:08:36 You have a committee that's going to go through the process.

1:08:38 They may or may not choose that we're not tapping

1:08:43 into our cash reserves because we're extending those

1:08:45 towards the fire stations and so we've asked everyone not to use

1:08:49 that as consideration for the next 18 or so months until we work

1:08:53 through that.

1:08:55 The sure way to fund a master plan for the dog bark is

1:08:59 to do it tonight.

1:09:06 Okay, so anybody, which project, sorry, I just jumped in.

1:09:11 I apologize, Mayor.

1:09:13 Which projects are we talking about because the stadium, both stadiums, correct?

1:09:18 No, Elizabeth Stadium, and then Jay, the other little stadium section.

1:09:28 So the 290,000 and the 80,000, which both I support, I think my feeling is either way,

1:09:46 We're speculating a little bit whether you know we spend 400,000 tours at Lisbon, they're the 40,000 tours

1:09:53 The Baxter dog park I guess my filling my filling would be is

1:10:00 So what we could do is have somebody make a motion

1:10:07 Okay, and then that might get us rolling on

1:10:11 Oh, let me get back to some comments for Mitch

1:10:21 like for maybe Aaron to give you an update on the fiscal year 22 sidewalk projects that

1:10:26 we funded in the current budget, it may at least it's interesting for you to know this.

1:10:33 The interesting stuff tonight, so I believe the project that mentions specifically referencing

1:10:40 is the Wendell Street project that Council had authorized before.

1:10:44 So that project is currently in design right now and we should be through the design month

1:10:50 in the next month or so and have a really good number of what that cost is going to be.

1:10:54 I don't have a number right now, but there's that piece that can be thrown in there.

1:10:58 If you remember, it's that piece from Falls Avenue on the window between Falls and Robbins, which is right next to Robert Stewart Middle School.

1:11:08 And why isn't that on this list?

1:11:12 Because it had been previously funded, and we were still working with, this was the one that kind of blew up on our face, and we had right of way issues, and we've had everything that could go wrong with this project has basically gone wrong.

1:11:24 So, it's now just barely coming back up because we just signed a contract today for the design,

1:11:28 so they're working on that, and we should have a good number too.

1:11:33 It was not put on there because when I originally did this presentation, we didn't have any.

1:11:38 I don't have a final design.

1:11:46 I have the original number that I did before.

1:11:50 I modified the scope a little bit so that numbers not like my ship were very much throwing wrenches.

1:11:59 Yes, you are, too.

1:12:00 I have it in my toolbox and that chips mine.

1:12:02 Okay.

1:12:04 Well, let's start somewhere.

1:12:05 Anybody, Chris Reed.

1:12:07 I can make a motion to see if we want to work with the dog park at 40,000 with the number.

1:12:14 I move that we approve as a potential council directed capital fund of 40,000 to the extra

1:12:24 dog park enhancement design.

1:12:27 How about that's fine.

1:12:31 If you want to do one by one or do we want to make a proposed package?

1:12:35 I just wanted to see this one because that's what we've been kind of debating on.

1:12:40 Okay, motion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Nicky Boyd to of the 770 to authorize 40,000, up to 40,000 for the Baxter Dog Park. Any further discussion?

1:12:57 Okay, yes.

1:13:04 I guess, I'll call on the west side of that park, I believe.

1:13:19 I thought it was in the last.

1:13:25 It's under construction right now, right?

1:13:33 These are scissors are tough.

1:13:34 I think that I'm leaning a little bit more to the sidewalk side of things.

1:13:39 There's a lot of other possibilities down the road, but I think we're all on the sidewalk.

1:13:47 That's a possibility for that, so kind of feel a little bit uneasy.

1:13:52 Any other?

1:13:58 Thank you, Boyd.

1:14:00 It is one of our assets.

1:14:05 People see that, but again, it was pointed out that I love the stem.

1:14:18 It's hard to spend 40,000. I understand when this could do something else, but I think if we don't have a plan

1:14:35 We're not moving forward on this at all and we need parks and rec to

1:14:42 So when people have questions we can say this is what you can say this is what we're doing next

1:14:50 This is though. It's not just oh, yeah

1:14:53 I hear it's not you know we've had so much rain or too much use and there's mud and there's this

1:14:59 That's not

1:15:12 Anybody else have a comment before we take a vote?

1:15:15 Hey, Aaron, roll call vote please.

1:15:19 Vice Mayor Reed?

1:15:22 No.

1:15:23 Hineki Boyd?

1:15:24 Yes.

1:15:25 Craig Hawkins?

1:15:26 Yes.

1:15:27 Jason Brown?

1:15:28 Yes.

1:15:29 Spencer Cutler?

1:15:30 Yes.

1:15:31 Mayor Pierce?

1:15:32 Yes.

1:15:33 Motion passes 5 to 1.

1:15:35 Thank you, everyone.

1:15:38 Okay, so now that we've spent 40 of the 770, we have 730 left.

1:15:44 I promise.

1:15:49 So, okay, sorry, so I feel like when I click the button, it's time to talk.

1:15:57 Well, it is kind of sort of, I have to click and see your name.

1:16:02 Yes, Jason, go ahead, your name.

1:16:05 So, if we're in agreement, I would like to make the motion to move forward with the Sunrise East of Mountain View

1:16:16 designed for 290,000, and then also included that motion, the stadium east of Eastland south of

1:16:25 south side of the road, 230 feet for 80,000. Okay, second that. Thank you, motion by Jason Brown,

1:16:34 seconded by Chris Reed to include Stadium Boulevard sidewalk sunrise to Mountain View for 290

1:16:41 and location Jay Stadium East of Eastland for 80,000. Any further discussion?

1:16:51 Chris Reed did you have some? Aaron Roelkow, please.

1:16:58 Nicky Boyd. Yes. Craig Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes.

1:17:04 Spencer Cutler. Yes. Mayor Pierce. Yes. Vice Mayor Reed. Yes.

1:17:09 Thank you motion passes six to zero so that leaves us

1:17:16 360,000 to spend we're at four ten. So these are something that sorry

1:17:24 I didn't click the button and started talking

1:17:33 Understanding that we have Elizabeth Street

1:17:35 That we're not quite sure about what it's gonna come back at and then Wendell as well

1:17:40 Well, two projects that have been discussed at length, two projects that we want to get

1:17:45 done, two projects that are very close to schools, using these funds, understanding that

1:17:51 we don't know.

1:17:54 Is there a way in which we can do that instead of just taking that and going through and

1:17:59 adding up something to 360,000 to spend it as opposed to those two items are going to

1:18:08 come back at some point in time and using these funds for those items?

1:18:12 That's what I would feel comfortable with.

1:18:14 So, Madam Mayor, Madam Mayor of the City Council, you weave from a budgeting process, budgeted

1:18:22 the revenue as well as the expense.

1:18:26 You're allocating where they would go.

1:18:28 So simply, you're marking them would be a very appropriate step.

1:18:32 So if you want to hear mark them for the two projects that you just described, we can

1:18:36 You continue to work through the estimates and go even as far as receiving the bid or at least sharing the estimate of the FU instruct us which project you'd like to take out.

1:18:50 Thank you.

1:18:51 Given that, anybody have a motion?

1:18:57 I don't have any questions.

1:18:58 You have a question?

1:18:59 Okay.

1:19:00 This room, does that have anything to do with that removed?

1:19:18 The thirty second land trying to listen to this meeting frustrated, try to listen to something and catch everything.

1:19:28 with a leg like that, does that dollar fix that?

1:19:34 Unfortunately no.

1:19:35 So the leg that you see is the video that we're recording

1:19:40 goes from here up into the Civic Clerk site,

1:19:44 and then people view it from the Civic Clerk site.

1:19:46 So that leg is the data moving from here to there.

1:19:49 The money that we had requested for the council chambers

1:19:53 was for the TV display.

1:19:56 So what happens is we're sending it to two.

1:20:00 We send that feed to two different places.

1:20:02 The TV display right now, because our device is so old,

1:20:06 has to be changed from digital to analog.

1:20:10 So we convert the signal from a height,

1:20:12 digital nice picture to an analog signal.

1:20:15 And then, so it just would increase the resolution

1:20:22 of the display only the TV.

1:20:27 Is that Channel 17, Channel 17, that weren't visible or easier to look at, clearer?

1:20:36 Is there a lag on that? I haven't watched that. There's going to be a lag.

1:20:43 No, there's a lag, but the faces are clearer. Correct.

1:20:46 Jason Brown.

1:20:51 I guess I'm in favor of what Councilman Reed has just suggested that if we can hold that money, I think the window project to me is high priority.

1:21:03 If we can hold that money and then see what that turns out to be

1:21:08 The city has been discussing that one for quite some time, and I think that's an important project

1:21:15 So I don't know how to make the motion, but I'm going to attempt to make the motion that we

1:21:21 hold

1:21:25 Motion to earmark the remainder

1:21:29 which is 360,000, 360,000, for a later date when the Wendell and Falls sidewalk project

1:21:40 has more accurate numbers but also the Elizabeth Boulevard project has more accurate numbers.

1:21:48 Second, okay, motion to earmark 360,000 towards Elizabeth Boulevard sidewalk and the Wendell

1:21:58 Street sidewalk motion by Jason Brown a seconded by Chris Reed any discussion

1:22:06 on that thank you Aaron Rokal vote please. Craig Hawkins Jason Brown yes

1:22:16 Hunter Cutler yes mayor Pierce yes vice-married yes thank you boy yes thank

1:22:23 motion passes six to zero. So the next item is the actual action item. Travis, do you want to

1:22:35 re-interate what you would like us to do nicely? Yes, so Madam Mayor, members of the City Council

1:22:46 on the agenda describes the motion that staff needs to have forward and that is to set the

1:22:53 the tentative budget, which again is the maximum spending cap that we would have for fiscal year

1:22:59 22-23. It doesn't mean that our work is done. In fact, you can always lower the budget going

1:23:07 forward, but you cannot increase above the number that you state tonight. What is provided

1:23:16 in your packet is the budget that we have been discussing for the last eight weeks and

1:23:24 staff would recommend budget. He establishes a tentative budget. He set the public hearing

1:23:29 for August 22nd for 6 o'clock PM. Thank you, Travis. Christopher Reed. Make a motion.

1:23:38 Move that we adopt the tentative budget for the City of Twin Falls for the 2022-2023 fiscal

1:23:46 year in the amount of 78 million, $630,390 and set August 22nd 2022 at 6 PM as the

1:23:57 for the public budget hearing.

1:24:00 Thank you.

1:24:01 Craig Hawkins.

1:24:02 Thank you.

1:24:03 Motion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Craig Hawkins to adopt the tentative budget for the City of Twin Falls for the 2022-2023 fiscal year in the Mount of 78,630,390 dollars and set August 22nd as 2022 as at 6pm as a date in time for the public hearing.

1:24:26 Any further discussion?

1:24:28 Erin Roachau, vote please.

1:24:30 Jason Brown.

1:24:33 Yes.

1:24:35 Ben Chercutler.

1:24:36 Yes.

1:24:37 Mayor Pierce.

1:24:38 Yes.

1:24:39 Vice Mayor Reed.

1:24:40 Yes.

1:24:41 Nicki Boyd.

1:24:42 Yes.

1:24:43 Greg Hawkins.

1:24:44 Yes.

1:24:45 Thank you.

1:24:46 Motion passes six to zero.

1:24:47 Thank you, everyone.

1:24:48 Thank you, Travis.

1:24:50 Okay.

1:24:51 So next item on the agenda is a time for general public input.

1:24:57 This is input on items not on the agenda today.

1:25:02 If anybody wishes to address council, please come down.

1:25:08 I will remind you that when you get down here,

1:25:10 please state your name and whether you're a resident

1:25:14 of Twin Falls and you have two minutes.

1:25:19 My name is Patty and I am a resident of Twin Falls.

1:25:23 So, excuse me for the eye not knowing this information,

1:25:27 But if I want to address something that was said tonight,

1:25:30 can I address that next Monday?

1:25:32 When can I address it?

1:25:33 So are you talking about the budget itself?

1:25:35 Do you have something in the budget?

1:25:37 No, I'm talking about Elizabeth and we got two middle school

1:25:47 there and we got elementary school close.

1:25:50 Sorry, we're fine.

1:25:50 Yeah, go ahead.

1:25:51 Go ahead.

1:25:52 They're very close.

1:25:53 And so that street has a lot of kids going back and forth.

1:25:58 It's almost impossible to ride your bike to school.

1:26:01 So I'd really like to see that

1:26:04 taking care of as soon as possible.

1:26:08 Thank you.

1:26:08 Thank you.

1:26:11 Anybody else that wishes to speak?

1:26:16 Okay.

1:26:17 Thank you.

1:26:18 Next item, then advisory board reports.

1:26:22 Anything to report on advisory boards until tomorrow?

1:26:27 Okay.

1:26:30 Manage your office.

1:26:35 Madam Mayor, I just wait.

1:26:39 that the city is receiving applications

1:26:42 for the city council position

1:26:46 as a result of the vacancy against resignation.

1:26:51 The form is live and it has been since last Wednesday.

1:26:59 Wednesday, I believe it's the 17 close.

1:27:09 If it's at the opportunity to make sure

1:27:13 that there are contours inside of the city

1:27:16 of Twin Falls, for I know it'll be presenting

1:27:19 those names to you, the drills who submitted

1:27:24 I might mention that we are having a state of the city breakfast on August 16th, which

1:27:37 is a Tuesday.

1:27:38 There will be more information coming out of public information.

1:27:42 It will be at the Commons area of breakfast at seven, so it should be cooler, and we would

1:27:49 start the program at seven thirty, so anybody out there is welcome to attend.

1:27:55 Okay, so next on the agenda, our public hearings do you guys want to take a break for a minute or are you good to keep going?

1:28:07 Okay, so the first item is an action item, and it's a public hearing on the end rate increases for the city of Twin Falls, and we up around at Howard, our CFO.

1:28:23 I was wondering if I was reading the agenda right?

1:28:32 We're good.

1:28:34 Well, he just wants to be prepared after.

1:28:36 Yeah, welcome Brianna.

1:28:40 Good evening, Mayor and Council.

1:28:45 The City Council must hold a public hearing on the proposed do and increase fees.

1:28:49 Wow, I never have to put that up.

1:28:51 That's awesome.

1:28:54 Because the amounts to be charged are more than 105% of the last fees collected.

1:28:58 After taking public input and comment, the Council will need to vote on the proposal

1:29:02 and it will take a simple majority vote.

1:29:04 So what I have included in your packet is the, like I've done for the last couple of years,

1:29:10 is the master citywide fee schedule in this entirety.

1:29:14 In addition, I've got the proposed changes that we've made, what was published for the 5% increase,

1:29:20 and the footnotes included in it.

1:29:23 I wanted to touch on the fees that were significantly increased,

1:29:29 that were published as well as the new fees, and then open it up for any questions.

1:29:33 questions, and I, and there's people out here to help if there's any questions that I cannot

1:29:38 answer. So, most of the increased costs that you're seeing on this, the fee changes, so

1:29:45 the attachment I'm looking at most, efficiently, is the one that shows just the schedule of

1:29:53 fee changes. So, most of those are increased costs for providing services, but the ones

1:30:00 that are new. The first one is for the airport, and it's a survey and recording fee, which

1:30:06 is applicable for new ground leases. The airport will contract with professional surveyors

1:30:11 to create a legal description and prepare the record of survey. In engineering, there's

1:30:17 a new fee for a PI service installation requesting to establish a flat fee that just to cover

1:30:23 our costs. In police, there was an increase from $10 to $43.25 and that is in reference to

1:30:36 a fingerprinting fee that is reflecting the actual cost to the city. The $10 is the cost

1:30:41 to take the prints and $33.25 is what the state charges. The bulk water usage is in reference

1:30:51 to a bulk filling station by the street department building. The city uses it as well as others

1:30:57 in which the water is metered. There's also a key to unlock it that we issue for $150 deposit.

1:31:02 Currently the process is for commercial drivers to record the metered water going into their

1:31:07 tanks throughout the month and they convey that information to someone in their office

1:31:11 and that person calls utility services once a month to report the usage that is built.

1:31:16 Compliance is very low because the process is cumbersome.

1:31:19 So city staff have researched and discussed putting a camera on the corner of the street

1:31:22 department building and monitoring usage but that cost of the camera and monitoring significantly

1:31:28 outweighs the amount of revenue that comes in so offering unlimited fill-ups would increase

1:31:32 compliance and capture loss revenue for compliance. The rent or deposit fees and attempt to help

1:31:39 recover costs for water usage that goes unpaid and is uncollectible by the city. For 2000 gallons

1:31:46 of consumption the water costs sewer cost and sanitation charge would be $64.02 at a minimum

1:31:52 and the average amount turned over to collections is two hundred four forty one.

1:31:55 The deposit is only applicable to tenet accounts because a proportion of water usage that goes

1:32:00 unpaid is most significantly in relation to these tenet accounts.

1:32:04 We refund the deposits after one year of good payment history.

1:32:09 The returned payment and delinquent fees you'll see in that in the staff report there is a

1:32:14 chart that we have called multiple other cities to try to compare and see what we charge.

1:32:20 We haven't actually increased these fees in over 25 years, and so that is why we're trying

1:32:25 to capture some of the costs in those.

1:32:30 So those, oh, and the meter turnoff fees, that was the last one I wanted to touch on.

1:32:34 These are split out to account for the turn on of water by timely paying citizens an additional

1:32:39 increase to account for the increased staff time to turn on water after turning off or

1:32:43 delinquent payments.

1:32:45 After analyzing water turnoffs, the city staff's opinion that many of these can be avoided altogether.

1:32:50 about 80% of those who have water turned off for non-payment will pay their account balance

1:32:55 and have it back on within 24 hours the rest of the matter of days.

1:32:59 So those are the fees that we would like to increase and a brief description on some of the bigger ones.

1:33:07 Is there any questions on some of those? I've included all the information in the packet beforehand.

1:33:14 Anybody have any questions or comments?

1:33:23 Thank you. I would agree. It seems like some of the rate increases are well below the MCI increase and that's huge to me that we're able to keep it down below that increase.

1:33:46 So, looks good. So, any questions for Biano before we open it up for public input?

1:33:55 So, this is a public hearing and so anybody wishing to speak on this issue, please come

1:34:09 down to the podium, state your name and whether you're a resident or property owner in the

1:34:13 city of Twin Falls.

1:34:15 And at this point in time, comment on specifically the fee increases and you're limited to two

1:34:27 minutes.

1:34:28 So anybody in the audience who wishes to come down and speak on this particular issue?

1:34:33 I don't know what the increase was, but I think it's really important that we have those people go out, shut it off and turn it on

1:34:59 instead of not having them at all and putting that money or the money that goes to the collection or doesn't get paid from the utilities back on the homeowner.

1:35:14 Thank you. Any other comments or on this particular issue? Okay. That closes the public hearing section. Council wishes any further discussion? Motion? Anybody?

1:35:42 Here, I was going to make a motion, but I was making sure I had the wording correct here.

1:35:45 Go for it, Spencer.

1:35:49 to the audience. I saved it and I closed the screen because I maximize the other window.

1:35:56 Okay, so I move that we approve the fee and rate increases as presented on the citywide

1:36:13 master schedule included in our packet.

1:36:16 Thank you, do I have a second? Thank you, Craig.

1:36:21 Emotion by Spencer Cutler, seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the fee and rate increases

1:36:28 as proposed in our packet. Any further discussion?

1:36:34 Aaron Roll call vote please.

1:36:37 Senator Cutler?

1:36:38 Yes.

1:36:39 Mayor Pierce?

1:36:40 Yes.

1:36:41 Vice Mayor Reed?

1:36:42 Yes.

1:36:43 Nikki Boyd?

1:36:44 Yes.

1:36:45 Craig Hawkins?

1:36:46 Yes.

1:36:47 Jason Brown?

1:36:48 Yes.

1:36:49 Thank you. Motion passes six to zero.

1:36:50 Thank you, Breonna.

1:36:54 So next item on the next public hearing is an action item.

1:37:00 It's requests for approval on the annexation and appropriate zoning district of open space

1:37:06 for nine plus or minus acres of property located at

1:37:10 350 blue lakes all of our south

1:37:13 Here the city of Twin Falls and we have Ian Zollinger

1:37:17 City planet

1:37:19 These next two presentations are land use public hearing

1:37:27 Okay, so

1:37:29 individuals wishing to test fire speed before City Councilor Panning's zoning

1:37:41 committee shall wait to be recognized by the Mayor and Chairman following their

1:37:45 statements they should write their names on the report issue. So public hearing

1:37:57 procedures, first city staff will present the request and analysis the

1:38:02 applicant that will then present their request. The Commission will then ask

1:38:07 Council will then ask questions of the applicant or staff after questions have

1:38:12 been answered the public hearing will be opened during that time anyone in

1:38:16 attendance is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions about the

1:38:20 request being considered again when you step up to the podium please state

1:38:25 your name and whether you're resident of Twin Falls and then present your

1:38:29 comments and when you're done please sign the public sheet out in the lobby

1:38:34 and you will be limited to two minutes.

1:38:37 After public comments are concluded,

1:38:39 the applicant will be invited to answer any questions,

1:38:42 make a closing statement, staff will then answer,

1:38:45 clarify any comments as needed.

1:38:47 After the closing statements, the public hearing will be closed,

1:38:51 and then council will have their discussion.

1:38:58 This is request for approval, the annexation,

1:39:01 and appropriate zoning district of open space

1:39:05 For property located at 350 Ulex Boulevard in the south,

1:39:09 care of the city of Twin Falls, we are the applicant for this application.

1:39:13 This is the piece of property located here.

1:39:18 I light it next to the CSI fish hatchery.

1:39:22 The Ulex Boulevard being to the east.

1:39:28 Prior to annexation of unincorporated area, this council shall request

1:39:39 and receive a recommendation from the commission on the proposed plan

1:39:43 and zoning ordinance changes for the unincorporated area.

1:39:46 The Council prior to adoption or amendment or repeal

1:39:50 of the plan or zoning ordinance shall conduct

1:39:52 at least while public hearing this forward to the new time.

1:39:55 The history of this property has historically been used

1:39:59 as open space.

1:40:00 The subject property is currently being utilized

1:40:02 as the natural park land is maintained

1:40:04 by the city parks department.

1:40:06 On July 12th, 2022, the planning and zoning commission

1:40:10 forwarded a recommendation on the appropriate zoning district

1:40:13 of open space by a vote of 4-0.

1:40:17 Comprehensive plan designates this property has open space

1:40:20 and staff is determined that this request complies

1:40:23 with the comprehensive plan.

1:40:25 The applicant is requesting the subject property be annexed

1:40:28 into the city for the purposes of allowing other properties

1:40:31 to be contiguous to city limits.

1:40:33 The applicant is requesting that the zoning designation

1:40:36 will open space when the subject property

1:40:38 is annexed into the city.

1:40:41 On conclusion, should the city council,

1:40:44 the City Council is tasked with deciding whether the subject property should be annexed into

1:40:48 the city with a recommended zoning designation of open space. The Council may approve the

1:40:56 request as presented, approve for the conditions to either request or table the item for additional

1:41:01 information to be provided.

1:41:04 Thank you. Okay, so because we're applicant and staff, any questions for you look like

1:41:21 So then we will open the public hearing anytime when you can, excuse me, when you give testimony, please step up to the podium, state your name, and whether you're a resident of Twin Falls present your comments are concerned.

1:41:43 And again, sign the sheet up in the lobby with your full name so we have it for the record and your comments will be limited to two minutes.

1:41:53 So public hearing is open. Is there anybody who wishes to comment on this item?

1:42:01 Welcome, sir. City of Twin Falls.

1:42:44 Okay, which I believe to be, it's a stepping as a result of that.

1:43:02 The first instance zoning stage of residence along the south side of Park Avenue was not, I think it's defective.

1:43:38 Anybody else that wishes to, for out in the public, in the public, that wishes to make

1:43:44 a comment on this particular item?

1:43:50 Seeing no one, does the applicant wish to address that comment?

1:43:55 Here before us tonight are third two items, but each is its own annexation and independent

1:44:04 applications.

1:44:07 applicant of the next item on the agenda, approach the city and ask the city to annex its own property into the city, so that their property may be continuous to the city limits, annex into the city to receive city services unless you are continuous with city limits.

1:44:30 This application on its own has its stance.

1:44:33 The city has a record of annexing our own property, which we own.

1:44:39 The city owns this property.

1:44:41 The annexing would bring this property under the Incorporated limits of the city and under our regulations and guidelines.

1:44:50 And its own application for notice was given of this annexation.

1:44:58 Anybody else that wishes to address council?

1:45:05 Okay, public hearing will then be closed, so, questions.

1:45:11 Chris Reed?

1:45:12 My question was just to make sure that 8B, this item that we're working on right now,

1:45:18 proper notification was given out and you did address that as yes we did,

1:45:22 notify those in the geographical area, have the signs out that this public hearing was happening

1:45:29 and also with planning and zoning corrects from.

1:45:31 Thank you.

1:45:32 Thank you.

1:45:33 Thank you.

1:45:34 I want some vacation on so, the picture that is up there, basically beautiful open space, happens next, is not the village, it's in that land, it's in the land that's up top, it's not down in the kitchen.

1:46:03 This, this is the property that is highlighted here, it is owned by the city and it is what is being annexed tonight with this application.

1:46:15 It is currently in the area of impact, if the city council is to decide to annex the property and to give it a zoning designation of open space, that is...

1:46:34 necessary comes next because it has to, but or be adjacent to...

1:46:42 or for property to annex into the city, it needs to be adjacent.

1:46:49 By annexing this, it would move the city limits.

1:46:53 Yes, I'm just making sure where that sits. That sits up on...

1:47:04 above the... above what we can.

1:47:08 Open space, nothing is happening with that open space tonight.

1:47:12 If it is approved, it would continue to be open-space.

1:47:22 I wanted to make sure I understood.

1:47:26 Hey, Knicky. Any other questions?

1:47:31 Yes.

1:47:32 Is that the...is that where all the filter has been placed?

1:47:39 There has been, Phil.

1:47:45 We're currently talking about the outline parcel, not Rockard Village right now.

1:47:52 Yeah. Okay.

1:47:56 Any other questions or discussion?

1:47:58 You're still up.

1:48:01 Do you want to make a motion?

1:48:04 I'm sorry.

1:48:10 Okay.

1:48:15 Annex Annexation and Appropriate Zoning District change in zoning map of the 4 ZDA CRO for the 13th.

1:48:23 Oh, boy.

1:48:24 Did I joke they had?

1:48:27 Yes, she did.

1:48:30 8B, yes.

1:48:34 We've got the request for approval on the Annexation and Appropriate Zoning District of Open Space for 9 plus or minus acres of property located at 3rd.

1:48:46 located at 350 Blue Lakes Boulevard, South Carolina.

1:48:51 Thank you.

1:48:53 Is there a second?

1:48:54 Oh, seconded.

1:48:56 Thank you, motion by.

1:48:58 Nicky Boyd, seconded by Christopher Reed to request the approval for annexation in Zoning

1:49:04 District, chained open space, a property located at 350 Blue Lakes Boulevard, South.

1:49:12 Any further discussion?

1:49:15 Aaron Rokal, vote please.

1:49:16 Mayor Pierce?

1:49:18 Yes.

1:49:19 Vice Mayor Reed.

1:49:20 Yes, Nikki Boyd. Yes, Ray Hawkins. Yes, Jason Brown. Yes, Spencer Cutler. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes six to zero. Thank you. But don't go away because I guess you're next, right?

1:49:35 Tweet those again, okay, go on again. Go ahead.

1:49:52 Madam Mayor, this is Madam Mayor City Council. This is a request for an annexation

1:49:56 and appropriate zoning district change in zoning map amendment

1:50:00 from R4 to R4's DBA CRO for 13 plus awareness acres

1:50:04 located at 831 Park Avenue, here at Gravitas Real Estate Holdings,

1:50:10 LLC, fully known as Idaho Development and Company

1:50:14 LLC property outlined, which is south of the property that was previously discussed, is

1:50:24 zoned as R4CRO and Rock Creek Village PD and is within the area of impact. The City Council

1:50:34 approved property to be zoned, or Rock Creek Village PD. The agreement was never signed.

1:50:43 The annexation process began with big big big big big big state being the property owners.

1:50:50 Throughout the ensuing months the property has transferred ownership from bigs to Idaho

1:50:56 developments, a company LLC and then recently to Gravitas real estate holdings LLC.

1:51:03 All required ownership documents have been submitted to city staff.

1:51:14 compared to an annexation of unincorporated area, the council shall request and receive

1:51:21 recommendation from the commission on the proposed plan in Zunborn's changes.

1:51:25 The council prior to the adoption amendment or appeal of plan or zoning ordinance shall

1:51:30 conduct at least one vote here and that's why we're here today.

1:51:34 As zoning development agreement was at the time this application again was required prior

1:51:42 to develop for any property within the canyron overlay.

1:51:46 Zoning development agreements is EVH shall conform

1:51:49 to all sections of Title X unless specifically addressed

1:51:53 within written zoning development agreement

1:51:56 that council may have removed

1:51:57 for modified requirements that deem appropriate.

1:52:02 An annexing this property will affect the regulations

1:52:05 by which the property is enforced,

1:52:09 and it will annex if the annex will fall

1:52:11 the regulatory policies of the City of Twin Falls. Further being the subject

1:52:17 property will be in the corporate boundaries of the city and property will

1:52:22 be eligible to receive city utilities. In accordance with Title 10 Section 6-1

1:52:30 a preliminary presentation was given on this request to the Planning Commission

1:52:35 on June 28th, 2022 at their planning commission held on July 12th the

1:52:42 commission voted 4 to 0 in favor of recommending the proposed CDA to be

1:52:47 an appropriate zoning district for the property. The 2016 comprehensive plan

1:52:53 grow with us as it needs this area as town neighborhood shown here on the

1:52:58 future land use map. Our staff has determined this request isn't the plans

1:53:03 with the 2016 comprehensive plan. The applicant is requesting a zoning development agreement

1:53:09 with the R4 residential and can you remotely zoning district with the deviations to the code.

1:53:16 The applicant is proposing to allow for detached, excuse me, attached dwelling on a zero-law

1:53:25 line town hall of Z and groupings of three or more. The site will contain 20 buildings

1:53:30 including 136 residential units within 13 acres, here is a site plan showing that.

1:53:38 The applicant is requesting to have a minimum plot size of 1000 square feet for each lot

1:53:45 to have 100 percent plot occupancy.

1:53:48 These are the deviations from the R4 zoning district that the applicant is asking for in

1:53:54 their zoning development.

1:53:55 Regarding setbacks, the applicant is requesting that no setback be required for residential locks

1:54:04 and that the dwellings would be able to be constructed up to the property line.

1:54:08 There will be a building setback of 20 feet from the boundary of the development.

1:54:14 The applicant is requesting that a minimum lock widths be 20 feet in a minimum lock width

1:54:20 and a minimum lock widths be of 20 feet, so 20 by 50 foot locks.

1:54:28 All the requirements related to the development and construction of the property are specified

1:54:33 within the Zomi Development Agreement will follow the city code as it applies.

1:54:37 As stated above, the applicant is requesting the Zomi Development Agreement which allows

1:54:42 them to develop in a different way than what is permitted within the city code.

1:54:46 The requested number of dwelling units, 136, is similar in number to the allowed number

1:54:52 of dwellings that could be constructed under the regular R4 zone district, making some

1:54:58 changes to the R4 zoning district, allowing attached dwelling units on smaller lots, or

1:55:04 more effective use, allows for more effective use of the space in productive areas of the

1:55:11 property.

1:55:12 Potential impacts.

1:55:13 With the development of the property along Park Avenue, there may be some potential impacts.

1:55:18 Our cavity was classified as a collector within the Master Transportation Plan.

1:55:23 like the roads are intended to carry traffic from local streets to arterial streets,

1:55:28 they are designed to carry less traffic at a lower speed than arterials and to serve trips

1:55:34 at a shorter length. If the property were to develop as proposed, Parc Avenue, when it proved

1:55:40 with the development, would be able to handle the increased level of service.

1:55:45 In conclusion, the City Council's task of making the final decision on the annexation of the property,

1:55:51 The Council may approve the annexation as requested,

1:55:55 approve conditions denied the annexation or table,

1:55:58 the item for consideration.

1:55:59 If the Council approves this item as presented,

1:56:03 staff recommends the following conditions,

1:56:05 subject to site plan amendments as required

1:56:08 by building and sharing fire and zoning officials

1:56:10 to comply with applicable city codes and standards.

1:56:13 So with this application,

1:56:15 we're making the decision to annex the property

1:56:19 and to annex it with the appropriate zoning district

1:56:22 which the applicant is requesting a zoning development agreement with those changes that I've stated before.

1:56:28 The applicant is here to present and I am having to answer any questions as well.

1:56:34 Any questions for Ian before we ask the applicant to come down?

1:56:38 Yes, Mayor.

1:56:40 Yes.

1:56:41 Where there's a change of owners, we've got the annexation approving as EDA.

1:56:48 I mean, at the timeline straight in my head, I'm concerned about the proper development of Park Avenue.

1:56:58 I guess what other approval processes need to happen and how would the timing of that

1:57:03 happen compared to the build-out of this?

1:57:08 So if the property is annexed into the city and the city council decides that the appropriate

1:57:13 zoning district is the zoning development agreement next step for the need to subdivide the property.

1:57:21 If it's subdivided in the property, they'll make the required improvements such as developing

1:57:27 Park Avenue to collect your whims of these required improvements necessary for them to be able to

1:57:43 subdivide the property. Thank you. One follow-up, so traffic control apparatus at Park and South

1:58:02 Blue Lakes is that likely to be a development cost or that be like an impact cost. One of the properties

1:58:08 plotted, that is something for the planning zoning committee to consider at that time to decide whether

1:58:20 Also, the city engineer is very similar to that.

1:58:54 They suit the limitable lot size.

1:58:57 They are first on the district is 4,000 square foot lots.

1:59:00 And so the number is similar.

1:59:03 How they would be able to fit those lots on the property.

1:59:08 Be less proposing.

1:59:13 Anything else associated with the can.

1:59:20 So it is similar.

1:59:23 These are these are old rentals and they're going to have they're going to.

1:59:31 So share they're going to all share walls.

1:59:33 The applicant intends to plot these as individual logs.

1:59:39 That is not what's on this picture.

1:59:44 Call 2.

1:59:50 The envision of the idea is, and those logs were 20 by 50.

2:00:01 As asking the veer to be able to accommodate assault, assault, separately.

2:00:28 That's what would, if we say yes, they could have this with their request

2:00:36 We're approving a 2x50 flood with its own.

2:00:47 Other questions for staff?

2:01:00 Greg Hawkins.

2:01:01 Yeah, this question here.

2:01:04 That many people could about the sidewalks.

2:01:10 A sidewalks are a required improvement as part of developing them.

2:01:22 And so they would need to construct sidewalks along the front.

2:01:25 Other questions for Ian?

2:01:36 Go ahead, Nicky.

2:01:38 Of course, that's part of the development that doesn't connect to anything.

2:01:41 Is there a sidewalk that keeps going?

2:01:44 And to put a sidewalk in it just doesn't go to anything.

2:01:55 So I think these are intended to be in concept of this type of a development than a single family.

2:02:47 It's actually putting it in the help of me. It's not intended to be affordable housing or low income housing.

2:03:01 Markary housing, but this construction type allows it to be less expensive.

2:03:15 So this is the idea of this and I've done these several places around the country living one in Boise.

2:03:20 They are individual homes with a garage, a stack, they're just more consolidated.

2:03:26 So it's, they're actually really nice to live in.

2:03:35 I like it because I just have more stairs than you would, so.

2:03:38 But the idea is to improve the area for open sites.

2:04:00 So the other thing that this little open space on the site,

2:04:06 so you get common areas.

2:04:07 We have a connected, things like that.

2:04:13 The idea is, yes, we are a little bit farther out of town,

2:04:16 so we don't have connecting sidewalks,

2:04:18 but as the city develops, those people

2:04:20 do this afternoon.

2:04:24 So, overall, these are projects that provide density,

2:04:30 which are sort of the center city, which are any questions.

2:05:04 Exterior finishes are what's gonna actually be

2:05:07 on these buildings.

2:05:10 I think this requires us to follow this.

2:05:17 That's true.

2:05:17 Constantly shares of a project that looks like

2:05:31 teachers have reached my last, sorry, Jonathan,

2:05:41 but I have reached the end of that.

2:05:43 I, it's really unfortunate and so I'm having a hard time believing this self.

2:05:52 Yeah, so the ZDA regreements come under Title 10, Chapter 6. Within there, there's very few

2:05:59 elements that they can change. If they decided to make an example, I would put as if they

2:06:06 went through, you have four different pictures here, four pictures here. So a combination of

2:06:11 of siding wood, I've got wood stuck out.

2:06:15 Some other things, and this one is also a vertical.

2:06:17 It looks like wood.

2:06:19 Mason, Masonry, and all.

2:06:20 There could be some history rock in here.

2:06:22 If we see an element on a building permit

2:06:24 that matches those general things, we're going to go with it.

2:06:27 If it looks exactly like this, I'll say,

2:06:30 I have yet to see one like you.

2:06:32 If someone says this is exactly what I'm going to build,

2:06:34 usually the elements come a little bit different,

2:06:36 but the materials in the color and the general scheme

2:06:39 are that way.

2:06:40 that we use all four, so when they decide to do all stucco or all some kind of siding

2:06:47 and then it's just a wash of siding, that doesn't mean this criteria.

2:06:53 Right, so if we were proposed with this and it came with all the same color of siding,

2:06:58 we would reject it at the building permit level, but this to me does not show that these are

2:07:04 different materials, these would be different colors of siding.

2:07:07 There's no rock, there's no stucco, it's just also-

2:07:09 So if this were an element that came from the building permit, we would accept it as it's one of the elements that was received.

2:07:16 Now if the council wants to be more direct and more specific, we could say, condition it upon these types of elements,

2:07:24 this percentage we're seeing in picture.

2:07:26 I don't know, we need commercial black glass-brained windows on everything.

2:07:31 You know, that's a big, a big ticket item, but, but certainly there has to be a mix.

2:07:37 It cannot just be one solid color of different color siding, right?

2:07:43 Right.

2:07:44 So one of the elements of the CDA is you can't depart from the overall design theme and that

2:07:49 comes down to basically a, it's a judgment call from staff and the planning and zoning

2:07:54 commission, if we have to go back to them to say, we're to the council, is this what you

2:07:58 envisioned.

2:07:59 That happens when we get the building permit when they say okay now

2:08:02 We've done to bid these elements like this particular wood

2:08:09 Isn't available anymore, but we go with more of a vertical

2:08:13 Is that a departure of the overall design team the zoning administrator as part of the job?

2:08:18 It's a still would it just has more vertical look

2:08:21 Probably not a change

2:08:23 that the design of everything, but there has to be, or has to be some interest.

2:08:32 Yes, so.

2:08:34 This is a huge project.

2:08:36 Yes, so a little background about myself.

2:08:40 A architect in voice-out of 25 years, I've actually worked at CSI for since the mid-90s.

2:08:45 I wouldn't be standing here if I was going to do something that was crap.

2:08:50 So what we do, if you look at our website, if you look at our work,

2:08:53 So I'm giving you my word that we will do something that is

2:08:58 just aesthetically pleasing, showing the city of Idaho.

2:09:16 Any other questions for the applicant or staff?

2:09:23 OK, so any other further discussion before we open up the public hearing?

2:09:35 OK, so opening up the public hearing,

2:09:37 if there's anybody in the audience that wishes to comment

2:09:40 on this particular application, please come to the podium,

2:09:46 State your name and whether you're resident of Twin Falls and we'll have two minutes for your presentation

2:09:54 Welcome again, Eagle Mayor, that's going to have two of these visible on, I'd say, two, three hundred feet or more

2:13:57 If you do annexes, that side of park is in the city that there's going to be two hundred or three hundred feet there

2:14:11 that are in the city south side of the center line if indeed that isn't the city but he

2:15:09 else have any comments rather than twin faults maybe I misunderstood but I look

2:15:23 like my counter there was 152 is that wrong

2:15:40 um I was counting that on the picture so maybe I was wrong okay there will be

2:15:47 enough parking for all of these that correct why don't you go ahead and ask

2:15:56 questions and then we'll have okay that was somebody address okay we'll have

2:16:01 somebody answer that for you okay thank you anybody else from the public public

2:16:06 that were wishes to speak okay does either staff or the applicant want to

2:16:12 address any of the issues that have been brought up Jonathan yeah I'll start with

2:16:17 some of the applicant doesn't need an opportunity numbers 136 the zone does

2:16:23 require two parking spaces for every dwelling unit that's in the code and

2:16:26 they're not asking to waive that requirement so yes there'll be two parking

2:16:29 spaces for each unit as required by code to the annexation of the road state code

2:16:37 requires us to annex roads that are already dedicated right now this is

2:16:42 comes under the jurisdiction of the highway district it's not the county but

2:16:47 there an entity like under the county is their jurisdiction for the road if we

2:16:51 annex the only annex the portions that come under ours which to my knowledge what

2:16:57 we can see on here, the Highway District is actually using the easement method here.

2:17:02 Nothing's been dedicated to the Highway District, so we would only be annexing half of it.

2:17:06 Only the property that is owned by the applicant.

2:17:09 There will be no other property annexed with this application.

2:17:12 Only that which the applicant has needed the property too.

2:17:16 So in terms of the South Half-apart, that's not being annexed because that's not dedicated currently.

2:17:20 In terms of working with the other roadway, things to the West, yes, it's not in city limits

2:17:27 still under the jurisdiction of the Twin Falls Highway District, not the city.

2:17:31 We do have some agreements that kind of maintain roads that have these types of

2:17:35 pandering annexation lines and things like that. We would leave our street

2:17:41 department, public works to work through the Twin Falls Highway District

2:17:45 maintenance and roads, etc., etc., as far as the traffic, we can only leave that to the city

2:17:54 engineer in terms of the traffic and or things that can be accommodated as it

2:18:02 was a highway district road typically just can have a one lane each way that's how

2:18:06 they construct roads in the highway or in that county type of area when we

2:18:10 develop it then it comes under our jurisdiction and when they go to plat it

2:18:14 they get the full width as a collector is required for sea lemons questions that

2:18:20 I heard only on the north side of the road will the construction take place

2:18:25 within the boundaries of this subdivision so you're basically saying this includes

2:18:31 part to the center line. Yes, if that's where the property line is, sometimes the

2:18:37 Highway District has the road kind of under through. Then I'll have the applicant answer any of the

2:18:45 questions that they feel like they need to or have a closing statement. Anything from the applicant?

2:18:56 The public hearing is then closed. So if is there any further room staff for the applicant?

2:19:07 Okay. Did he counsel? What would you like to do? Any questions, comments? Nicky Boyd.

2:19:18 This is very large. This is. Right. Original. All rights. Asking. Full. He's not really changing the densities.

2:20:06 Much as the rain though. This is. There's nothing. There's places in town.

2:20:25 Annexed and then. So the annexation part is. This. To the zoning. This.

2:20:44 Okay, Chris, for me.

2:21:01 Move that.

2:21:04 We approve the request for an annexation

2:21:05 appropriate zoning district change

2:21:07 and zoning map amendment R4 to R4 ZDA CRO

2:21:12 for 13 plus or minus acres of property

2:21:16 located at 831 Park Avenue,

2:21:18 Caravatops Real Estate Holdings LLC,

2:21:22 formerly known as Out-of-Home Development Company LLC.

2:21:26 Thank you.

2:21:27 Do I have a second?

2:21:28 I'll second.

2:21:30 I'll second.

2:21:31 Add with staff recommended.

2:21:32 as presented and with staff recommendations.

2:21:35 We second that.

2:21:38 Motion made by CRISPR read to approve the request

2:21:43 and appropriate zoning to change subject

2:21:45 to staff recommendations seconded by Greg Hawkins.

2:21:50 Any further discussion?

2:21:53 Erin Roll call vote please.

2:21:56 Mayor Pierce?

2:21:57 Yes.

2:21:58 Vice-Mary Reed?

2:21:59 Yes.

2:22:00 Nikki Boyd?

2:22:01 Yes.

2:22:01 Greg Hawkins?

2:22:02 Yes.

2:22:03 Jason Brown?

2:22:04 Yes.

2:22:05 Thank you.

2:22:06 Yes.

2:22:07 Did you answer?

2:22:08 Yes.

2:22:09 Motion passes six to zero.

2:22:10 Thank you very much.

2:22:11 So that is the last item on the agenda with the exception of, we will be moving into executive

2:22:28 session under 74-2061F to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency to discuss

2:22:39 legal ramifications of, and legal options for pending litigation or controversies.

2:22:45 Not yet being litigated, but imminently likely to be litigated.

2:22:49 The mere presence of legal counsel in an executive session does not satisfy this requirement.

2:22:56 To move motion by Jason Brown, second by Nikki Boyd, to move into executive session under

2:23:05 774-206-1-F.

2:23:08 Admiral Kavo, please.

2:23:11 Vice Mayor Reed.

2:23:12 Yes.

2:23:13 Nicky Boyd.

2:23:14 Yes.

2:23:15 Greg Hawkins.

2:23:16 Yes.

2:23:17 Jason Brown.

2:23:18 Yes.

2:23:19 Hunter Cutler.

2:23:20 Yes.

2:23:21 Mayor Pears.

2:23:22 Yes.

2:23:23 Motion passes 6-0.

2:23:24 Thank you.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, August 8, 2022. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:23:34.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    3887bd00e54377c667235f5f04bba8faff52a7dd1351a736075d03d1a3645a0d
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 1b4eb13f85d89bcd524d8d7d5876660fd0ceae0b5b4501b33616d10d771d2ada
    part02.m4a b07ff302d0ef3532e995a60496c0aec157e86fc51d6c35829c18aa4c0971f3a2
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    089f6988a92395f93d69152bce670b61f285cd312cce93d2ee9e7698dbe12ae3

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file