City Council meeting
Monday, November 7, 2022
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: b
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:00:41 Ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the November 7th, 2022 City Council meeting.
0:00:47 I want to confirm we have a quorum.
0:00:49 We have six of the seven members here in chambers and councilwoman Nikki Boyd is excused
0:00:56 tonight.
0:00:58 First next item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance and we have some students from
0:01:04 truth 63 that are going to lead us in the pledge today.
0:01:07 If you guys want to come on down please rise.
0:01:20 Nerdy's yourselves, and give us the reason you're here today.
0:01:46 Next on the agenda is the consent calendar.
0:02:11 Council wishes.
0:02:12 Give motion by Allie Scavalle, seconded by Christopher Reed to approve the consent calendar.
0:02:26 Amy Roll, call vote please.
0:02:31 Yes.
0:02:42 So if you were here for the Christmas light display event by First Federal or the Jay Foundation Annual Auction, those of both in approval.
0:02:53 Next on the agenda under items of consideration, we've got a little rearranging going on item D
0:03:00 Which is informational will move to a
0:03:03 First and the rest in order so our first our first item is informational moving to work program
0:03:14 Presentation from sunny Shaw director of the Twin Falls housing authority
0:03:19 Sunny this work as a council once a and so this is my
0:03:51 relationship with this city down the executive to where we are very proud to serve the kind of so just a little bit of history
0:04:09 So you can understand what housing authorities are and what they do
0:04:13 For FDR's new deal is when they first started talking about creating housing authorities
0:04:18 And it was really designed to be workforce housing
0:04:21 To develop for our militaries
0:04:30 37 was created where we were able to build we should be in four
0:04:43 state statute came into place talking about contributed $500 of his own month to
0:05:05 go towards those of pretty soon and so we were able to create in 1940 and built
0:05:15 our first public housing units in 1940 we went right towards it until state
0:05:28 statute 50 were actually written into state statute hours that house which is
0:05:38 pretty incredible statute 50 that's really interesting that's really in
0:05:46 and Chausey Authority can also receive as,
0:06:07 so those are just some interesting powers.
0:06:09 There's a lot of other things that a housing authority
0:06:11 would never go, for example, what do you mean?
0:06:16 Which kind of thing, but it's interesting
0:06:21 that how Devolve Quartz was our first property built
0:06:27 in an actually gained occupancy at night,
0:06:31 it is an elder.
0:06:34 So what I said, some of this is education,
0:06:40 just so you can become, you must be below area,
0:06:46 have recent drugglers, let's say we have a household
0:06:58 that gets an thousand dollars,
0:07:00 they're paying $300 a month towards their rent in Utah.
0:07:12 And so we do also say, well, over there in that public housing complex, so and so is breaking the rules.
0:07:27 And so it's my job to find out if somebody's breaking the rules and we cast out our, that's okay.
0:07:41 I'll take those odds and I'll work on it. So we do serve an important population for our community.
0:07:52 So what is the relationship with the city? We were created by the city council. We were created.
0:07:58 There had to be a resolution first by this body that said we believe that there needs to be a housing authority.
0:08:04 Because we were created, we were independent, but we do have a relationship with you.
0:08:16 And that's really critical and really important.
0:08:18 I've had the opportunity to travel the country.
0:08:20 I have served as the National Association of Housing and Redevelopment Officials, President,
0:08:26 and that position so I served nationally.
0:08:31 So I've had the opportunity to see housing authorities across the country.
0:08:34 And sometimes city councils don't recognize how important a point.
0:08:38 And so we need to go to our visionary and understand because we deal with a lot of board members whom you have appointed and are my members for the joint in mind.
0:08:56 Sometimes you'll hear us jointly with the Jerome Housing Authority.
0:08:58 We are also the management agent for the so I actually answered it two boards.
0:09:05 So you can see who my board members are and we think we just have a spectacular board when housing authorities were created is a requirement of HUD that we have one resident member who represents the voice of the residents.
0:09:20 on that board so that they can be heard of them.
0:09:23 Once they are on that board, they are in equal numbers.
0:09:28 How are we funded?
0:09:29 Well, come to you guys and we don't say,
0:09:31 hey, where's our check, right?
0:09:32 And you guys are grateful because you would say,
0:09:34 hey, guess what, it's not coming.
0:09:36 So we are funded through the operating fund,
0:09:39 which I've explained up there, how it's calculated.
0:09:41 These things are all calculated for us by HUD.
0:09:44 Operating fund is just what you would expect.
0:09:46 It covers operations.
0:09:48 Capital fund is for capital and these types of things.
0:09:58 We can't use a percentage of that cap operations as well.
0:10:06 So that is something that it's ready to do.
0:10:10 We have to have meetings, so we have to have somebody damage as a property when they moved
0:10:29 out.
0:10:30 We're going to build them for those or there's been destruction.
0:10:34 That's going to be a build expense.
0:10:36 And so those are the three way.
0:10:44 We also get some grants.
0:10:46 I've been at the agency for just over a year and in that year we've secured a $234,000 grant
0:10:53 for what we call a resident opportunities
0:10:56 and self-sufficiency grant.
0:10:58 The goal of that grant is to help our seniors
0:11:01 and our disabled population age in place with dignity
0:11:04 so that that way they are not having to move out
0:11:08 and get services, maybe assisted living.
0:11:10 My resident service coordinator also focuses
0:11:15 on self-sufficiency for able-bodied families,
0:11:18 and we're gonna talk about that as we move into,
0:11:19 it's a $234,000 grave in pursuing dollars anywhere
0:11:25 that we can find them.
0:11:26 And so, for example, we were able to secure a $2,000
0:11:31 for emergency safety and security for lighting.
0:11:35 So we're always looking for more grants.
0:11:37 We are compliant, Stravin.
0:11:39 We have, we're a HUD high-performing agency
0:11:43 based on those things listed.
0:11:45 We have had clean audits with no findings
0:11:47 and no material weaknesses.
0:11:49 And recently, we had the HUD inspection
0:11:51 of all of our six properties here locally
0:11:53 and we received in 96.
0:11:55 So you can be assured that you're not gonna be getting
0:11:57 call from HUD saying what's going on at your housing authority, but those are
0:12:01 important things for city council to know because HUD could call you and say
0:12:04 why do you have this board at this housing authority? They're obviously not
0:12:08 doing great oversight, so just be mindful of those numbers and those scores. A quick
0:12:12 showing of where our properties are, what they look like, Duval courts and Terry
0:12:16 courts are elderly disabled properties. I'm Sunnyview in N Pioneer Square,
0:12:21 are also elderly disabled property. For public, for a family housing, we have
0:12:30 Washington Courts, I've removed all of these little things that look like, kind of like
0:12:35 you're driving through a cemetery.
0:12:37 We believe that people know how to not drive on grass without having to have posts up.
0:12:42 So we've removed those and then we also have Elizabeth Courts and so we have family housing
0:12:47 that is 56 units and then that family housing there is in mind.
0:12:55 So the thing that I really wanted to share with you is what we hope to do going forward.
0:13:00 So if you hear of these things, you're going to be able to know, like, oh, I remember
0:13:05 Slenny was there and she talked about that.
0:13:07 So we were recently awarded what's called moving to work status by HUD.
0:13:12 Previously, there were 33 housing authorities in the country, keeping in mind there are
0:13:16 3,300 of us in the country.
0:13:19 33 had moving to work status, and I had really worked with Senator Repo to get him to pressure
0:13:27 to expand what's called the moving to work demonstration. Congress did that,
0:13:31 to expand it by 100. So we were in the final group that made it through, so we
0:13:37 are now a moving to work agency. So what does that mean? The name is a little tricky.
0:13:42 What it really means isn't necessarily that you have to move to work, although
0:13:45 we're going to do some things with that with our able-bodied households. But
0:13:49 mostly what it means is we have flexibilities where we are now going to be
0:13:53 able to create policies that are locally driven instead of deseculation a whole
0:14:01 lot more and so we're going to be taking a look at first and foremost the way we
0:14:05 got into that program which was through asset building so any resident that we
0:14:17 know your mortgage we mortgage on time that helps to build your credit but
0:14:22 renters don't really have that and so we are going to report time into the
0:14:28 credit bureaus so our residents can build their we're going to look at a few
0:14:37 other things like administrative burden, but down the road we're going to look at maybe
0:14:42 some more challenging topics that our community of participants may push back on a little bit
0:14:49 that may have to do with a term limit or may have to do with a stagger grant to encourage
0:14:54 some work practices in our, so those are things down the road.
0:15:01 We actually, because we just got this award, we have one year to create our supplement,
0:15:05 we're going to be getting community.
0:15:07 We are required to have representatives from the Housing Authority on the Board, from the
0:15:12 residents, and we've recently created a non-profit, which is called the Hope Foundation of Idaho,
0:15:22 and it is a joint venture, can falls and lies in for it to the health.
0:15:33 So if we've got somebody in Jerome, so if we're looking to make shortage on housing,
0:15:47 and so we're going to be looking to see not just how to create housing locally for us,
0:15:51 but how to create a fort, making sure that everything that we might talk a lot about moving to work,
0:16:05 kids main goals are federal dog using dollars more efficiently,
0:16:08 how residents become self-sufficient, and increase housing.
0:16:11 So those are really the true mission of our housing authority in and of itself.
0:16:16 If you're going to be hearing more, I try to work really closely with especially
0:16:20 Ian and Jonathan, and have an occasional bugging him with Mr.
0:16:25 Walthweiler.
0:16:26 Like, what can we do, how can we partner, how can we better serve the area in the community?
0:16:31 So I hope to see you each year, but see you possibly in the offices for the city here as I bug these guys some more.
0:16:39 And I want to thank you, Mayor Pierce, for signing the document that said that this MTW application was in compliance.
0:16:48 I'm happy to answer any questions. I tried to talk fastly because I know you don't want to be here for your time.
0:17:05 Right, board. So thank you.
0:17:09 What is your waiting list?
0:17:11 Great question.
0:17:12 Yeah, so our waiting list is dependent upon the unit.
0:17:17 So if you're interested in the studio unit and you're elderly disabled, it's pretty quick.
0:17:21 It's about a four month to a two bedroom or the fee is our longest wait list or bedroom surprisingly.
0:17:35 It's only at 18 the idea as soon as they hear wait. So our longest though is a two bedroom.
0:17:48 I'll touch on it. So thank you.
0:18:06 196 total. So those are family.
0:18:11 140 and I will tell you we do have when I look at that wait list even though it turns pretty quickly for the elderly disabled.
0:18:18 we've got about 70 households on that weight list.
0:18:21 So that tells you it's a pretty substantial.
0:18:24 And so I get to see those numbers quite frequently.
0:18:44 Now in your larger, more populated areas,
0:18:47 oftentimes they have a closed weighting list
0:18:49 because they just believe that if someone applies
0:18:51 in it's five years, then there's just no hope.
0:18:53 I believe a closed weighting list is what causes no hope.
0:18:56 Came from Pocatex months to 12.
0:19:03 And so that kind of gives you an idea
0:19:05 that some of our bedroom sizes, depending,
0:19:07 and so it is more challenging, and we have more public housing.
0:19:12 So we have a longer list with more units, and of course, like I said, your larger areas,
0:19:21 their waiting lists are longer.
0:19:32 So absolutely, that's right now what I've been making the rounds for.
0:19:35 I call it the Sunny Tour, as I'm like, hey, what do you have for land?
0:19:38 Hey, what do you have?
0:19:39 You know, creating this nonprofit, I'm even thinking someday somebody might leave us stuff, right?
0:19:44 So my first effort was getting that nonprofit created, and then from there, seeing what we can garner for land.
0:19:51 Now this, because we are a housing authority, we can take
0:19:54 get land, get it to us from the city or the county.
0:19:57 And I've gone and talked with the county as well about that.
0:20:01 So first it's the land.
0:20:03 I have, I have developed credits.
0:20:08 You've heard tax credits in our area.
0:20:10 They're great.
0:20:11 They serve an inch.
0:20:12 But for them to be truly affordable,
0:20:15 you can't tell me to build a property.
0:20:16 It's affordable if it's a two bedroom that still costs $330,000.
0:20:20 An affordable unit is something that building out
0:20:23 was six years ago, but I was building them for $87,000.
0:20:28 So it's really about knowing how to develop it yourself
0:20:31 without having a develop.
0:20:32 But where we're wishing, wishing,
0:20:36 we're hoping that we're able to get stuff moving,
0:20:38 it's getting all the players in place,
0:20:40 and items in place, yeah.
0:20:41 And I'm also working with Idaho on some of their other
0:20:51 funds that they have available.
0:20:52 So yes, that's gonna, my first thing that I've been focused
0:20:54 on for the last six months was this moving to work piece.
0:20:57 And I think I kind of shook my staff up
0:20:59 because I've only been here a year.
0:21:00 I think that kind of, in fact, my finest person
0:21:02 that I need your goals for the next year.
0:21:05 But yes, yes, we are going to apply for some of those,
0:21:07 absolutely.
0:21:08 And one of the things that's interesting
0:21:10 that may be exploring this community down the road
0:21:13 is I am consulting with Blaine County
0:21:15 on their deed-restricted properties.
0:21:17 And I'm also going to be starting work
0:21:20 with a consultant who's voted to create a house.
0:21:30 Keeping in mind, they will never get public housing.
0:21:32 I think it's what they're all losing consulting for a contract
0:22:07 with PSI changing the starting collection time
0:22:10 for garbage pickup from 7A, and we have Brandhiya.
0:22:14 P.S.I. They expressed a desire to change this time.
0:22:39 I've listed in the staff report those items that were considerations on there.
0:22:45 Considerations that they asked was that they used the hours to start an hour with two crews.
0:23:00 They could, that was an enticement, but the discussions were open.
0:23:21 They also indicated that the restrictions grasped the disruption and the disturbing that they
0:24:02 It was one of their drivers that suggested that if they could construct their route so
0:24:32 that they were out of the school areas, it was fascinating as I see outside the cab,
0:25:00 somebody driving down the road or station for safety.
0:25:27 So it didn't surprise me that this was a suggestion by 37.
0:25:48 Who's here to answer any questions that you might have?
0:27:18 Yeah, so we actually rules that in place
0:27:22 either by 7 a.m. current start time
0:27:29 after that has the potential to get missed
0:27:33 that's why we have these little cans that say
0:27:38 4 or 7 a.m. once it is
0:27:50 there's nothing more scary or life changing
0:28:05 so that's kind of the over-destructs out of the
0:28:09 high population areas
0:28:10 A.m. is now 6 a.m.
0:28:18 Yes, we have a system, our phone system called a call blast
0:28:21 that we can essentially send a call to everybody
0:28:33 So, on the list here that are PSI doing the ones at 6 AM right now, or is this just a culmination of just other, because I was doing 6 o'clock or listed on that list, it sets up at 6 AM.
0:29:57 Mr. Bicers for read seconded by Jason Brown to amend the existing contract with PSI changing
0:30:06 the starting collection time for garbage pickup from 7 a.m. to 6 a.m. Amy Rolkow vote, please.
0:30:15 Yes. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 6-0. Thank you, gentlemen. Next item on the agenda is
0:30:30 an action item. It's a request to adopt ordinance 2022-018, amending City Code Title 7, Chapter
0:30:38 three and eight regarding the residential property owners responsible
0:30:42 being responsible for city utility rental accounts after December 31st 2022 and
0:30:48 again we have brand-eye our system finance director
0:31:05 thank you
0:32:56 dispense the reading rules title seven chapter three responsible for city
0:33:12 After December 3rd, I can't answer my second thank you motion by Christopher Reed said seconded by Spencer cuddler
0:33:28 To put ordinance
0:33:30 2022 dash 018 on 3rd and final reading
0:33:35 By title only and suspending the rules
0:33:39 Amy roll call vote, please
0:33:41 Yes, it should passes 5 to 1 and I will read the ordinance by title and then we can have a motion ordinance number
0:34:02 2022-018, an ordinance of the City, Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, amending
0:34:09 Title VII, Chapters 3 and 8 of Twin Falls City Code, providing that owners of residential
0:34:15 rural property, shall be responsible for payment fees relating to provision for public services
0:34:22 and providing an effective date, therefore, Christopher Reed, Alex, the motion by Christopher
0:34:35 to read 2nd by Alex Kaval to adopt ordinance 2022-018 passes 5 to 0.
0:35:03 Section 5 to 1.
0:35:11 Next item on the agenda is an action item, a request to approve the funding agreement
0:35:16 between the City of Twin Falls and the auto transportation department in the amount of
0:35:23 three million dollars for the operation of a pilot public transit program in Twin Falls.
0:35:28 And we have Mandy Thompson, our assistant to the city manager, welcome Mandy.
0:36:20 Unfortunately, so you can fix your out, um, transportation is microtransit is
0:42:46 cryptocurrency, which is also, um, so hard to serve the, we should just fix your out system that doesn't serve those who need it,
0:51:22 the money, which they need, that system, the option of microtransit is.
0:56:09 So, two separate, you did say one thing, those are you saying that a falls is doing the term option, that's what they started with?
1:02:36 They are, and then they are hired a transit coordinator with the ground funds as well.
1:02:39 And he's been actually glad that we won't see buses barreling down the fact that we know this
1:03:33 some filing bankruptcy and getting to where I don't falls is now.
1:03:37 So we're avoiding some of the mistakes on other people as well.
1:03:43 And I, I, I make an emotion to have a second emotion by Alex and Paul, second by Craig Hawkins,
1:06:02 to approve the funding agreement between the City of Twin Falls and the Idaho Transportation
1:06:07 Department in the amount of three million dollars for the operation of a pilot program,
1:06:12 pilot public transit program into a false and authorize the mayor to sign.
1:06:18 Yes.
1:06:29 Yes.
1:06:33 Yes.
1:06:35 Zero.
1:06:40 Thank you, Mandy.
1:06:41 Next, Simon.
1:06:42 On the agenda is a time for general public input.
1:06:44 If there's anybody in the audience that wishes to address something that is not on today's agenda, please come down.
1:06:52 I want to mention that Thursday at 1230 is 160 main doors to my passport. Spencer, did you have some else you finally showed up?
1:09:29 Okay, so next on the agenda is a German into executive session, it's an action item under
1:09:45 Code Section 74-2061B to consider the evaluation, dismissal or disciplining of or to hear complaints
1:09:53 or charges brought against public officer, employee, staff, member or individual, agent
1:09:58 Our public schools students, Spencer Color.
1:10:01 Ah, no, wasn't he?
1:10:08 Motion by Christopher Reed, second by Alex Kaval.
1:10:12 To move into executive session under 74-2061B.
1:10:17 Roll call, please.
1:10:28 Yes.
1:10:29 Thank you, motion passes, six to zero.
1:10:32 So we will not be reconvening,
1:10:34 so everybody have a good night.
Download
- Transcript (text) 22 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 28 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 38 KB
- Audio (M4A) 16.9 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, November 7, 2022. The recording started at 16:59 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:11:21.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
04f498897103b0b804828fc726fb505ccb14bf1c1346e9a211e8c731002fca84 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 96e9dfdcd02bfa8e240f74c333e85ce1bf3ef6788b20f08a82909dcf3eca6c77 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
2bd0057b32b3390c924c259bd7358493733ca53bc19ab99f05786cdc9f346c55
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file