City Council meeting
Monday, December 5, 2022
Special meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: b
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:00:14 Okay, I want to reconvene the City Council meeting for December 5th 2022 and confirm
0:00:22 we have a quorum.
0:00:24 We have six members present in council chambers and Jason Brown is on his way from Boise and
0:00:30 should be here shortly.
0:00:33 First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.
0:00:35 Anybody wishing to join me please rise.
0:00:57 I would like to take a minute.
0:01:00 I just got word that that school has to weigh today.
0:01:04 And that has been a member of our community for a long, long time,
0:01:09 unless I was CSI or trustee for many, many years.
0:01:13 And so I thought we might just take a few minutes, a minute,
0:01:17 less than a minute to reflect and a moment of silence.
0:01:20 Thank you.
0:01:21 Okay. Thank you.
0:01:36 Next on the agenda is the consent calendar.
0:01:40 I move that we accept that because that calendar is presented.
0:01:48 Craig Hawkins.
0:01:49 Thank you.
0:01:50 Motion by Alex Kaval.
0:01:51 Seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the consent calendar as written.
0:01:57 Amy Rolkow, please.
0:02:00 Chris Reed.
0:02:01 Yes.
0:02:02 Nikki Boyd.
0:02:03 Yes.
0:02:04 Craig Hawkins.
0:02:05 Spencer Kettler.
0:02:06 Yes.
0:02:07 Alex Kaval.
0:02:08 Yes.
0:02:09 And Ruth Pierce.
0:02:10 Yes.
0:02:11 Thank you.
0:02:12 So if you were here for the alcohol license for
0:02:16 and tojo-sederian cafe, that's been approved.
0:02:20 Next on the agenda is items of consideration.
0:02:23 This will be a joint meeting between the county commissioners and city council.
0:02:28 So I would ask that you get Don and where's Brandt? Oh, there he is.
0:02:35 Jack, come on down. So there's two seats over there and Don, there's one over there.
0:02:43 and you guys even get your own mics. At this time we'll call in to call out of
0:03:10 recess the Board of County Commissioners and go into business at
0:03:13 6.505 p.m. Twin Falls City Hall. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, our action item today
0:03:20 is an air service presentation and possible action to consider approving a
0:03:26 renewal of the minimum revenue guarantee contract with SkyWest Airlines for
0:03:32 Delta Airline Service to Salt Lake City, and we'll have several presenters tonight, but
0:03:37 we will start out with Bill Carberry, our airport manager.
0:03:41 There you are.
0:03:42 Welcome, Bill.
0:03:43 Thank you, Mayor, and good evening to you, members of the City Council and members of
0:03:48 the Twin Falls County Board of Commissioners.
0:03:52 It's a rare day to see you all up here, and today we've got some important discussions
0:03:57 to have and certainly make sure you ask questions and get the information that you need as we
0:04:03 consider the contract that is before us. So just as a form of a little background and we've talked
0:04:11 about this several times but for everyone's benefit, we've talked about the airline industry,
0:04:17 particularly regional airlines, having been challenged with recruiting and retaining pilots
0:04:22 the last year or two. Due to this struggle, the airline response has been reduction or
0:04:28 elimination of routes to small communities across the nation. Our community recently
0:04:34 experienced the termination of the SkyWest operated United routes to Denver and the reduction
0:04:40 of SkyWest operated Delta routes to Salt Lake from the three daily round trip flights to
0:04:45 one. So tonight the Council and the Commissioners will be viewing a presentation from our air
0:04:51 Service Consultant Michael Mooney, who's joining us today, and I'll introduce him shortly.
0:04:58 The presentation will review the state of the airline industry and the local condition
0:05:02 here in Twin Falls to include considerations associated with utilizing revenue guarantee
0:05:08 agreements to assist with sustaining our service in a community.
0:05:12 Following the presentation, we will be prepared to answer questions and hear comments.
0:05:17 I wanted to just initially give you a very broad overview if you could put that up there.
0:05:25 Thank you.
0:05:26 Of the minimum revenue guarantee agreement, as it stands this year, we have had an agreement
0:05:35 for the 12 months of calendar 2022.
0:05:40 That agreement came with a $400,000 cap in quarter one of this year back in January, February
0:05:48 We paid $25,000 subsidy in quarter two or three, and we're in a tail end of the fourth
0:05:56 quarter this now for 22, and things are looking okay.
0:06:03 We looked back, we had an afternoon round trip starting the beginning of the year, and
0:06:09 that was changed to an early morning flight in May.
0:06:12 And the one daily flight, we were very excited that it was increased to two daily flights for November and December for the holidays.
0:06:20 So we've had discussions with SkyWest recently and things are looking to turn somewhat for 2023.
0:06:27 So the proposed agreement from SkyWest is for one quarter.
0:06:32 They want to take this for the first quarter, is their first step here.
0:06:36 here January through March for that one quarter, the guaranteed cap would be $200,000, one daily
0:06:44 round trip flight to Delta Salt Lake City hub in Salt Lake.
0:06:49 So some good news here, the early morning late evening arrivals, which people seem to enjoy
0:06:55 most if we're just going to have the one round trip.
0:06:58 As of yesterday, that's been scheduled out now through the calendar 2023 year.
0:07:03 to say that that schedule couldn't change, but it's certainly encouraging to see that
0:07:07 it's booked out for quite some time.
0:07:10 And there's a note there that really I just try to give folks the idea of what a revenue
0:07:14 guarantee is.
0:07:16 It isn't a straight subsidy, but it's an amount of money that's held to insulate any losses
0:07:22 and the difference between ticket revenue and operating costs.
0:07:27 So next I'd like to introduce our guest tonight, Michael Mooney, and let me just bring up the
0:07:35 presentation here.
0:07:45 Just a brief bio that Michael's kind enough to pass on to me as I introduce him.
0:07:50 Mike Mooney behind me, he's one of four managing partners in Voleri Aviation.
0:07:55 Voleri specializes in small and medium sized airport air service consulting, assisting
0:08:01 communities in air service retention, recruitment, marketing, and other associated services.
0:08:07 The firm has approximately 80 active clients in North America at any one time, Mike graduated
0:08:13 from the University of Dubuque and has 27 years of airline experience, and 18 years of
0:08:19 air service consulting experience.
0:08:22 Mike lives in Evergreen, Colorado with his wife, Kelly, tending to two horses, and is
0:08:27 supervised by two house cats.
0:08:30 Mike welcome. Thank you Bill. Good evening city and county officials. Thank you for
0:08:45 your time. I'm going to go through about 20 25 slides and hopefully that'll give
0:08:52 context and information to assist you with the kind of decision options that
0:08:58 you have. So the context I was asked to put this document together by Bill. We
0:09:09 You start with a context document.
0:09:11 The context is that, first of all, the good news, Twin Falls is a solid performer among
0:09:18 your peer group.
0:09:20 For example, Pocatello or cities like that.
0:09:24 Your revenue performance for the airline is very good on the high end of any peer group
0:09:30 that should be measured against.
0:09:32 Everyone understands the service here is operated by SkyWest under the delta brand, and it's somewhat of a franchising exercise.
0:09:42 So in other words, delta enjoys the revenue that connects through Salt Lake City, the passengers ticket revenue.
0:09:50 SkyWest takes the risk of financial performance between Twin Falls and Salt Lake City.
0:09:58 So that in industry, nomenclature is called a pro-rate or an at-risk market.
0:10:05 Sky West, like every airline in the United States, is suffering from a pilot shortage,
0:10:11 and as part of that, they are reducing pro-rate or at-risk services around the country.
0:10:17 They're demanding a significant six-figure mitigation fund from Twin Falls to preserve
0:10:24 one round trip for a year, 23.
0:10:27 Right now, there are no other viable network service options, and network means the type
0:10:35 of air service that can get you into a hub and you can fly to Asia, you can fly to Florida,
0:10:40 you can fly to Maine, you can fly to Arizona, a global network connectivity.
0:10:47 Loss of network service impacts.
0:10:49 First of all, if the service leaves, there is a small loss of employment at the airport,
0:10:55 TSA people, your airline employees.
0:10:59 AIP funding that the federal government provides to the airport would decline from approximately
0:11:06 a million dollars a year to 150,000.
0:11:10 The term I use is damage to the community resume in terms of business retention and recruitment.
0:11:16 We'll go into that in a little more detail.
0:11:20 So the bottom line of the context page is, is there light at the end of the network service
0:11:25 subsidy tunnel?
0:11:27 That's, I want to try and paint a picture for you so you can understand the upside-down
0:11:32 side and risks.
0:11:34 The pilot shortage, that's what's got me here today to visit your beautiful city and
0:11:40 the beautiful Snake River Canyon out there.
0:11:44 Today, the pilot shortage drives route and schedule decisions at every airline in the
0:11:51 United States.
0:11:53 This is especially true on the low end of the latter of the regional carriers.
0:11:58 The major airlines are even short of pilots.
0:12:01 It's illustrated by some of the operational problems that you may have read about that
0:12:05 happen this summer.
0:12:07 The pilot training pipeline is currently not keeping up with the retirement curve of older
0:12:14 pilots as they retire. Congress is considering various measures to band-aid
0:12:21 that type of thing, but we can't count on them right now. Regional pay scales for
0:12:28 pilots that fly the regional jets that come here, they are soaring just to
0:12:33 retain those pilots and the training officers that do their training. Now
0:12:40 Now these soaring pay scales are great news for pilots, they are not bad news for 50
0:12:46 seed RJs, for the economics of the aircraft.
0:12:50 As of October 22, 112 airports in our country have lost at least 33% of their air service.
0:13:02 Several have lost all their service including Dubuque where I went to college and Williams
0:13:07 Support PA, which is actually a client of mine.
0:13:14 This is kind of a busy chart, but it tells you how the airline industry is reacting to
0:13:21 this pilot's shortage.
0:13:23 What you see here is American Airlines, Delta, United, and then the aggregate group.
0:13:29 The number of block hours, block hours are the hours of aircraft time that they're planning
0:13:34 to fly in a given month.
0:13:36 And you see these huge numbers, 209,357 block hours in July for American.
0:13:44 That's mainline, mainline means the 737s, the air buses, the big airplanes.
0:13:49 Dual class means the bigger regional jets, the ones with 76 seats.
0:13:55 And then the 50 seat category is highlighted in red.
0:13:58 That's the type of aircraft that serves Twin Falls.
0:14:02 As you can see for American Delta in United, over the timeframe from July to January, American has slashed 50 seat flying by 31 percent, Delta by 55 percent, United by 21 percent, and then at the aggregate bottom there, 50 seat regional jet flying is down 29 percent in seven months, in only seven months.
0:14:31 must. What is happening is the network airlines see a massive pilot church. What
0:14:37 are you gonna do with the pilots you have? You're gonna put them in bigger
0:14:40 airplanes. If you're short of pilots you're gonna park the smaller planes fly the
0:14:44 bigger ones. That in a simplistic sentence or two is the type of challenge the
0:14:50 industry faces. Airline industry overview just to touch on the industry and I
0:14:56 deliberately made the photograph very chaotic because we had a chaotic summer
0:15:01 in the airline business, if any of you flew and experienced some of the delays and TSA
0:15:07 shortages and ground handling shortages. TSA screening volume, which we measure every
0:15:14 day, the TSA keeps track of everyone they screen. So you have this immediate pulse
0:15:20 of what's going on today, tomorrow, the next day, versus in 2019, before the pandemic.
0:15:27 there's this immediate feedback that we get. TSA volume is just at 2019 levels,
0:15:34 maybe a little bit below, driven by leisure demand, not business travel demand.
0:15:39 Business travel demand has not recovered and the primary reason is Zoom and teams
0:15:45 calls and stuff like that. All of a sudden the road warrior who would take four
0:15:51 trips a month is now taking two trips a month and he or she is the person that
0:15:56 paid $800 round trip to get on the plane, got the first class upgrade the whole thing.
0:16:02 So the industry has seen a dramatic shift in passenger behavior.
0:16:09 We have fuel costs on certainty driven by the Ukrainian war and right now today fuels
0:16:14 down to $77 a barrel I think which is coming down gradually and it's below where it was
0:16:22 when the war started in February.
0:16:24 But there's uncertainty what could happen with OPEC, what could happen with the Saudis.
0:16:32 The economic uncertainty, we have an unparalleled economic environment.
0:16:37 We have record inflation, but an extremely strong job market with labor shortages all
0:16:43 over the place.
0:16:44 So we're going to have hard landing or soft landing.
0:16:46 Air landing executives don't know.
0:16:48 They don't know these things.
0:16:49 They have to guess.
0:16:51 And what's at risk for them is the fortune of their airline organization.
0:16:57 On top of all that, the pilot shortage handcuffs the carriers.
0:17:02 They can't react when demand is strong because they don't have enough pilots.
0:17:07 And the shortage, as I mentioned, drives carriers to put the pilots in bigger aircraft.
0:17:12 If you're going to be short of pilots, fly the biggest planes you've got.
0:17:16 are reporting profits. Profits are being reported. But the pandemic, like many industries in our
0:17:23 country, the airline industry took on huge additional debt when the pandemic occurred.
0:17:31 So now they have to service that debt. So the bottom line profit loss has to then cover
0:17:37 debt payments. Bottom line, the airline industry is extremely risk adverse. That's just the way it
0:17:45 is right now, I deal with the carriers all the time, my partners and my employees do,
0:17:51 and that's the mindset that they have.
0:17:54 Let's talk about SkyWest and Delta.
0:17:58 SkyWest is the largest regional airline in the United States, about 500 aircraft, 14,000
0:18:04 employees, 240 cities.
0:18:06 They're traded on a NASDAQ publicly held company.
0:18:09 Their main business is what we call CPA capacity purchase agreement operations.
0:18:16 Essentially, it's a company store, so they sign a contract to fly for Delta American
0:18:22 United Alaska.
0:18:23 The contract says you will operate 50 aircraft for us.
0:18:29 We will write the schedule, you drive the planes around SkyWest, and we'll send you
0:18:34 a check for every flight you complete.
0:18:36 It's basically renting SkyWest capability.
0:18:40 That's their primary business line.
0:18:42 They have probably 450 aircraft doing that for the major airlines in the United States.
0:18:49 The secondary business that SkyWest has is the pro-rate, the at-risk business that includes
0:18:56 twin falls.
0:18:58 Like all the regional SkyWest has been severely impacted by the pilot shortage, they are withdrawing
0:19:04 this pro-rate or at-risk flying with the current fleet, including essential air service, which
0:19:10 They do some cities in the intermountain west and the at-risk stuff.
0:19:15 They have an intention to create what they call Skywest Charters.
0:19:20 Part 380 is a Department of Transportation regulatory set
0:19:25 that permits the operation of 30-seat aircraft with FAA approval
0:19:32 with simplified pilot qualifications.
0:19:38 So, in other words, that SkyWest Charter Organization would have less of a pilot shortage challenge.
0:19:46 They can use 66, 68-year-old retired pilots.
0:19:52 They can also use young pilots who don't have the full qualification yet for the standard
0:19:59 part 121 operation.
0:20:02 SkyWest has indicated verbally and in a few places that they intend to eventually convert
0:20:13 all of their pro-rate flying to the 30-seat business model.
0:20:18 Their main focus is and will remain flying the big 76-seat RJ's under the CPA contracts.
0:20:29 This is the termination notice, SkyWest is the largest essential air service program
0:20:34 operator in the United States.
0:20:37 Essential air service program, unfortunately, Twin Falls is not eligible for it, but there
0:20:42 is about 110 cities in the United States that are, it was created as part of the deregulation
0:20:48 of the industry in 1978, and it establishes eligibility for federal subsidy at these 110
0:20:58 cities, you have to meet certain criteria, and there are various carriers that specialize
0:21:03 in essential air services. Skywest was the largest EAS carrier until this pivot that they
0:21:10 have just undertaken to pull back the 50-seat flying. They filed a termination notice that
0:21:18 caused the DOT to have a heart attack on one day that filed on 31 cities in March of
0:21:25 this year. Twelve of these cities after they went through the re-bid process went to new
0:21:33 carriers. The others SkyWest intends to put their 30-seat product yet. They will then convert,
0:21:42 at least I am told, their Delta-Pro-rich cities would then be converted. The intention eventually
0:21:48 is for this product to be 45 cities by late 2024. So we're talking a big small
0:21:56 airline here is what they intend to create and again is all driven by the
0:22:01 pilot shortage and the regulatory climate around pilot qualification. Delta
0:22:07 airlines, how many of you have a Delta frequent flyer card? All right I think
0:22:12 in this area in Utah and Idaho you'll probably give your children one when
0:22:16 and they're born, they get a little Delto Fring Flyer Cart.
0:22:20 Delta is a dominant carrier in this region.
0:22:23 Giant global airline, 875 aircraft, 350 regional jets.
0:22:28 They are rapidly eliminating 50-seaters
0:22:31 from their operation.
0:22:33 They're the largest airline by market share in Idaho,
0:22:36 just ahead of Alaska Air.
0:22:38 One of their domestic hubs is Salt Lake City,
0:22:40 which I'm sure you're all familiar with very, very well.
0:22:44 Just to give you a snapshot, Salt Lake City for Delta is 85 domestic nonstop routes.
0:22:51 They average about 220 departures a day.
0:22:54 There's 10 international routes and there's about eight arriving and departing,
0:22:59 connecting banks each day that cities like Twin Falls would connect to.
0:23:03 Idaho Air Service is going to run through this real quick, give you an overview.
0:23:08 This is your traffic fiscal year 2011 through fiscal year 2022 second quarter.
0:23:16 And what it shows is domestic traffic in kind of the blue.
0:23:21 Then at the bottom is the low cost carrier traffic in green international traffic in white.
0:23:28 And just like all over the country, well actually your traffic was growing at a spectacular rate there.
0:23:35 see through 2019. Very, very strong. Idaho is a booming economy and air travel is very
0:23:42 necessary because of your isolation from much of the rest of the country. The pandemic struck
0:23:48 and your recovery has been remarkable here. On a state level, it's been outstanding.
0:23:54 Most states do not see a recovery like you've seen. This is a map of Idaho and I've depicted
0:24:02 the airports that have air service and then the very very small ones like McCall and
0:24:08 and cordolane that could have air service. But you see Lewiston, Idaho Falls, Pocatello,
0:24:15 Sun Valley, Boise, Twin Falls. Top right, here's the bad news piece. Look at the traffic here 2019
0:24:24 versus 12 months, August 2022. Everybody's up except Pocatello and Twin Falls and
0:24:32 they're down in the 60% range. Does that mean your economy is down 60%?
0:24:36 Absolutely not. It means that SkyWest has cut the schedule and you've had to pay
0:24:42 for what you're holding on to. Note at the bottom there, Boise Idol Falls
0:24:49 Lewis and traffic increase is less than capacity increase. So here's the next slide. Same map.
0:24:57 This time we're measuring seat capacity. I want you to note that Idaho falls seat capacities up
0:25:04 94%. Their traffic's up 74%. I guarantee you with a pilot shortage and the uncertainties,
0:25:12 that's not going to last long. The airline industry will pull seats back out of there.
0:25:18 There's too many seats there.
0:25:19 Lewiston traffics up 3%, capacity is up 8%, and they're paying for that capacity.
0:25:27 It's an extra flight to Denver.
0:25:29 They're paying for it.
0:25:30 It's not producing to the level of the seats.
0:25:34 So these other cities that look better, to a certain extent, they're going to have something
0:25:41 come back at them, probably in the near future.
0:25:44 The industry constantly adjusts.
0:25:47 Domestic traffic market share. I'm just telling you what you know. You all got delta frequent flyer cards
0:25:52 Delta is the dominant carrier in Idaho, but not by too much
0:25:57 Southwest and Alaska about the same United and American and then some of the smaller carriers
0:26:04 But you can see that Delta's traffic share has actually gone down in the state
0:26:09 as other carriers have grown
0:26:12 Twin Falls in Sky West Delta
0:26:14 As I mentioned up front, you outperform your peer group, very strong feeder market for the Salt Lake City Hub for decades, you've produced solid traffic for Delta.
0:26:26 Shift from turbo prop aircraft to regional jets occurred in 2015.
0:26:31 For example, in 2019, pre-pandemic, your city, your market, produced almost $25 million in connected ticket revenue for Delta Airlines.
0:26:43 That's after taking out the cut that SkyWest would have gotten to carry the person down
0:26:50 to Salt Lake City and always has been operated under this pro-rate arrangement, this at-risk
0:26:56 arrangement, as has Pocatello, Elko, some of the other cities around Salt Lake City.
0:27:03 Now SkyWest is shifting their strategy.
0:27:05 They're no longer interested in the risk element of pro-rate.
0:27:09 They're going to allocate minimum resources to it because, again, they've got to do
0:27:13 They got these contracts to fly the big RJ's under guaranteed capacity purchase arrangements.
0:27:21 That's where they're going to put their pilots.
0:27:23 It's capitalism.
0:27:24 They have to put their resources where they're going to do the most good for their shareholders.
0:27:29 They are not motivated to generate pro-rate market, network, connect revenue.
0:27:34 They don't care whether Delta sees less passengers or not.
0:27:39 This is a very busy slide you all can look at it later, but it just shows, this is a kind
0:27:45 of slide we show the airlines when we make presentations to them.
0:27:49 This is the kind of geek stuff that we have to show the airline planners and then we
0:27:52 debate back and forth on a slide like this.
0:27:55 I won't spend any time on it.
0:27:57 The bottom line is your market produced very strong gross revenues 2015 through 2020.
0:28:04 I had a positive revenue trend 2016 until pandemic.
0:28:09 I note your average fair 192 post pandemic period,
0:28:13 that was actually very good.
0:28:14 Right now your average fair is much higher,
0:28:17 but your recovery was very strong.
0:28:20 This is Twin Falls Airline Traffic History.
0:28:23 So this is your air traffic total volume
0:28:26 by fiscal year through FY 2022 second quarter.
0:28:31 and it's color-coded. You got the international passengers in blue, the
0:28:36 domestic connect, Boston, Florida, Arizona, in red, and then the local
0:28:41 passengers to Salt Lake City in gray. This is average fare, and you can see
0:28:48 that Twin Falls is the green line, and consistent with who you're being
0:28:54 compared to. If you look on the left side of the chart, that's how it should look.
0:29:01 You're a small city, you're not Boise, you're not Salt Lake City, your fairs can be a little
0:29:07 higher because the alternative is to drive someplace to get air service.
0:29:11 Your fairs were higher.
0:29:12 The pandemic occurred and in the middle of the chart, it's a mess, it's just a mess for
0:29:17 everybody.
0:29:19 On the right side, we're seeing recovery.
0:29:22 Skywest and Delta are certainly making sure that they get average ticket prices up in Twin
0:29:27 Falls.
0:29:28 That's part of their job to do that.
0:29:32 We don't have the leverage to complain about that right now.
0:29:35 So this is just illustrating where you are compared to the option of driving to Salt Lake on an aggregate basis.
0:29:43 This is what Salt Lake looked like for your 2019 traffic.
0:29:49 This is a spider web explosion of all the places that you, Twin Falls people went or people came to Twin Falls from in year 2019.
0:30:01 As you can see Salt Lake City is what we call an omni-directional hub.
0:30:05 It's close enough to you that you can fly there and turn around and go to Seattle and go back over the top of Twin Falls to get to your destination.
0:30:14 Or you can go east or you can go west, you can go south, omni-directional hub.
0:30:19 This is your domestic revenue distribution, this is what we call a bubble map, kind of thing we show the airline when we're trying to illustrate the utility and the value of your market.
0:30:31 So, air service options, I'll close with this, network connectivity service to a network carrier hub.
0:30:40 That's the primary goal of small community air services to link your city to the world.
0:30:47 The further the hub from your little city, the higher the cost and the more pilots required,
0:30:55 longer flight, etc. For hub service, Twin Falls has very few options. Salt Lake City's close,
0:31:01 it's on the direction. Denver is further and to the east. San Francisco LA are too far west,
0:31:08 extremely high cost airports. Phoenix and Seattle are too far south to far north. So in this
0:31:14 This current environment of massive pilot shortages, a recovering economy, but business
0:31:20 travel hasn't quite come back yet.
0:31:23 In that kind of environment, you got to focus on what's closest.
0:31:27 Unfortunately, it is a delta hub and it has to have a delta affiliation, the service
0:31:33 does, in order to be viable to Salt Lake City.
0:31:37 Now we are also recruiting, trying to get a low-faire carrier to come in here and maybe
0:31:43 flight of the LA Basin or flight of Phoenix or Vegas. That doesn't serve the business community,
0:31:50 but it does provide a quality of life enhancement in small town America when you have an opportunity
0:31:56 to go nonstop to Phoenix in the winter. So scenarios and summary, this is what I sketched out and
0:32:05 Bill and I talked about it. If there is a decision not to pay Sky West what they want at this time
0:32:12 for the first quarter, they will exit the market.
0:32:16 I mean, you can try and play Bluff Poker,
0:32:18 but I suspect they will exit the market.
0:32:21 There would be the loss of the AIP funding over time,
0:32:25 the FAA funding, initial negative local economic impact,
0:32:31 loss of some jobs at the airport.
0:32:34 Twin falls falls off the airline map.
0:32:38 There is potential then for a long-term economic impact
0:32:42 in terms of site location, new business, losing in a company in town.
0:32:48 If the pilot shortage ends three years from now, four years from now, well maybe because
0:32:55 you were such an attractive market before, maybe service would come back.
0:32:59 We don't know field prices, we don't know airline economics five years from now.
0:33:04 Maybe pilot shortage is mitigated some way.
0:33:08 In the meantime, should you choose not to keep SkyWest
0:33:11 and they choose to leave, we could continue
0:33:15 to recruit a leisure carrier twice a week
0:33:19 to Los Angeles or something, which would preserve the TSA,
0:33:23 preserve probably your AIP funding with a big airplane.
0:33:28 If you pay SkyWest what they want,
0:33:32 one trip a day for all or part of 2023, total costs,
0:33:37 I'm going to guess a half million to 700,000.
0:33:42 You did extremely well in 2022.
0:33:45 They've raised the price because their crew costs of sword.
0:33:50 The opportunity cost of keeping pilots in the 50-seaters
0:33:55 is killing those guys because they want to move them
0:33:57 all over to bigger planes.
0:33:59 Fuel is an uncertainty.
0:34:02 If you choose to fund at least Q1, it buys time.
0:34:06 We have a process underway to attempt.
0:34:09 We've already spoken to Delta about taking Twin Falls
0:34:14 under their wing and making it a CPA capacity purchase city.
0:34:18 I think it's an extremely strong business case.
0:34:21 I've made that business case to Delta planners.
0:34:24 I'm disappointed in their reaction to it.
0:34:29 I kind of understand it.
0:34:30 I won't go into the details.
0:34:31 But anyway, there is time to invite them to take you under their wing and recognize the contributions you've made to the Delta System for the last 30 years.
0:34:42 We preserve the infrastructure for the leisure carrier.
0:34:48 If SkyWest leaves, it's going to be a little harder to recruit that leisure carrier because all of a sudden, you've got an empty airport.
0:34:55 If things improve, if you opt for the agreement and things improve, perhaps the subsidy declines,
0:35:03 perhaps it ends. If there is no improvement, if it keeps going and going and going, you always
0:35:10 can bail out at a later date. In 2024, as I mentioned up front, SkyWest intends to shift to a 30-seat
0:35:19 product, take out the 50C aircraft. That product, if they were to offer it to you, will probably
0:35:26 require an ongoing subsidy. Just so you understand, that's a 24 or 25 issue, but be aware of that.
0:35:35 This is a partial list of cities around the country that have decided to put money on the table.
0:35:44 Several of these cities are clients of ours. I won't go into enormous detail here.
0:35:50 In the middle there is Wyoming, the state of Wyoming, your neighbor, chooses the state level to have a fund that the smaller cities use in some way, shape, manner, form to essentially pay for the SkyWest United Service to Denver, which is there.
0:36:10 Denver is Wyoming's Salt Lake City, basically it's the big hub to the south, and at the bottom there I've got some examples of cities that used funding to try and get a new service and some of them worked, some of them didn't.
0:36:29 So, summary. You're not alone. What you're going through is happening all over the United States.
0:36:36 Small community air service in too many cases has become pay-to-play, or at least pay-to-play short-term.
0:36:45 Many cities are choosing to pay-to-play. They consider air service important enough for long-term economic outlook to at least initially pay-to-preserve.
0:36:55 In many of these situations, the private sector is stepping up as well.
0:37:00 It's not just government, it's also the private sector.
0:37:04 The small community equation, the economics equation, will someday get better.
0:37:09 It can't get much worse than it is right now in terms of pilot shortage, economic uncertainty and fuel uncertainty.
0:37:17 This is a triple whammy that it shouldn't continue like this at infidel.
0:37:24 So, when and how much better is subject to debate?
0:37:31 And that's the presentation I have for you.
0:37:34 They're going to open up to questions.
0:37:37 Actually, Mike, there are a few questions for you.
0:37:39 I know that if we could do that right now, Chris, read.
0:37:45 Could you go back to slide 27?
0:37:49 Your second point there, total under-paced guy West,
0:37:53 total local cost, 500,700,000.
0:37:56 I just want to make sure we're talking minimum revenue guarantee, so potentially, or are we talking, we're just going to be handing them.
0:38:03 Well, we're talking M.R.G. Yeah, I don't want-
0:38:08 Potentially that dollar amount.
0:38:09 Potentially, yes, absolutely. I don't want to underestimate.
0:38:15 For example, in this year, you had to put forth $200,000 and you only spent $25.
0:38:24 they've raised the price but again it could come in better than five to seven
0:38:30 yes absolutely okay but it's a potential I just want to say total cost I thought
0:38:35 okay yes they're two different things thank you that's a potential okay yeah I
0:38:39 should have had that word there thank you thank you thank you boy thank you
0:38:48 madam mayor mr. Mooney if we could go to slight 10 I had a question on it
0:38:53 Thank you at the bottom. It's talking about the intention is to have a total of 45 cities
0:39:02 with the 30C carrier model no later than 2024. Are we anticipating Twin Falls being one of
0:39:08 those 45 cities nationwide? That has been the verbal indication that we've gotten from SkyWest.
0:39:18 Now things can change in two years. They still don't have DOT approval for this concept that
0:39:24 they wanted to. They have to get certain DOT and FAA approvals, but verbally they indicated
0:39:30 to us in a team's call, or maybe it was when they were here. Yeah, it was when Dan came
0:39:37 up, that is their intention. I think senior management of SkyWest has made very clear.
0:39:45 They don't see the 50-seat airplane as being something they can staff going out into the
0:39:53 future. The 30 seat airplane they can use retired captains and they can use junior
0:39:58 first officers. The 50 seat model they're just not seeing how they can staff. Now
0:40:03 again the world could change but that's what they told us. Madam Mayor I have one
0:40:08 other question if that's okay with council. Is there, have you heard of any
0:40:13 discussion at the federal level? I don't I think one subsidies are there
0:40:18 they're probably not going away of any subsidies for local airports from the federal level
0:40:24 to help keep services in these areas.
0:40:27 Well, the program here, the Central Air Service Program, dates back to deregulation 1978.
0:40:35 That's 110 cities that met certain criteria.
0:40:38 Unfortunately, Twin Falls was never part of it.
0:40:41 It'd be a nice thing to have right now.
0:40:44 But that program's annual cost is exploding, subsidies to serve a community that were $3
0:40:52 million or now $6 million.
0:40:54 They're looking at a half a billion dollar program, probably in 25, and last year it
0:41:01 was $290 million or something like that.
0:41:07 So my sense is that the budget hawks in Congress are not going to permit a Pandora's box opening
0:41:19 on adding cities to the EAS program.
0:41:22 My sense is, quite bluntly, what's going to happen is the DOT is going to look at an exploding
0:41:29 budget and they're going to say, okay, we're going to have to call the herd here and they're
0:41:35 actually going to be cutting some of the underperforming EAS cities if I were to
0:41:39 guess over the next two years because they're not meeting criteria and there's a
0:41:44 variety of criteria they have to meet each year so my guess is we will not see
0:41:51 a federal program to help cities that are not part of the EAS program. I'd love
0:41:58 to be proven wrong but I don't see anyone driving that for us.
0:42:06 Thank you.
0:42:07 Thank you.
0:42:08 Commissioner Hall.
0:42:09 Madam Mayor, I have three things if I could ask you a question for us, are we planning
0:42:12 on taking public comment?
0:42:13 Yes, we are.
0:42:14 Perfect.
0:42:15 I'd really like to hear that.
0:42:16 Mike, I think out of the two terms that you use, I think we need to probably talk
0:42:21 about pay to preserve, not pay to preserve, not pay to play, okay?
0:42:28 Because we're very, very sensitive.
0:42:30 These are tax payer dollars, and that are potentially subsidizing a private industry,
0:42:37 and so we've got to be very careful with how we use those terms.
0:42:41 I know you weren't, but I like that pay to preserve a lot more than to play.
0:42:49 Yeah, that is a much better term.
0:42:52 And also just, I tend to be blunt.
0:42:55 So the reason that we can use less senior pilots and way more senior pilots on the smaller aircraft
0:43:04 is because they're easier to fly, not because it sounds like a safety issue almost to me.
0:43:10 No, this answer, I'll try and make it as brief as I can.
0:43:15 It is not in my opinion a safety issue.
0:43:20 The government has the FAA government safety.
0:43:25 They have a set of regulations called Part 135, which covers really small airplanes,
0:43:31 9-seaters, 19-seaters, 30-seaters.
0:43:35 Above that, you have the Part 121 FAA, which is everything from the 50-seat RJ to a 787
0:43:44 going to Paris.
0:43:46 So there's these two regulatory regimes.
0:43:49 In 2014, the FAA made a somewhat radical increase in pilot qualification on the part
0:44:04 121 side.
0:44:05 The fruit was called First Officer Qualification F.O.Q.
0:44:09 That is the driving force behind our shortage because all of a sudden took the steps out
0:44:15 of the ladder for piles to start with a nine-seater and move up. So what SkyWest is doing is what
0:44:23 several other airlines have done. You go back down to the 30-seat regulations and for example
0:44:31 on the captain's side you have to quit at age 65 flying for America United. Well now you can retire
0:44:40 and go fly a 30-seater and mentor young men and women in the right seat and they'll still pay
0:44:47 140,000 a year to do it and you can fly three days a week. On the first officer's side it takes
0:44:54 the regulation back to where it was pre-2014. 2014 in my opinion and many people's opinion was an
0:45:02 overreach of increasing first officer qualification.
0:45:09 I don't believe it's a safety issue.
0:45:12 The Regional Airline Association
0:45:14 doesn't believe it's a safety issue,
0:45:15 but anyway, the 30 seat regulations have been there
0:45:19 the whole time.
0:45:19 They are not new or anything like that.
0:45:22 Thank you.
0:45:23 Sorry, long answer, tough question.
0:45:25 Thank you.
0:45:26 Alex Kaval.
0:45:27 Mr. Mooney, is it my understanding of what you've been
0:45:30 saying that if we don't go to a capacity agreement with Delta, then we're looking at subsidies indefinitely, whether we're looking at the 50-seater airplanes or this potential 30-seat carrier, if we are one of the 45 shows in for this market.
0:45:44 I would say that the 30-seat airplane, given current cost economics on the aircraft and required pilot salaries,
0:45:57 I would say the 30-seat airplane will require modest subsidy at infidem.
0:46:05 They have yet, I have bugged SkyWest, I've bugged them a lot, show me the economics of the 30-seat model.
0:46:13 I don't think they've defined them yet. I don't think they're withholding. They just haven't really nailed them down yet
0:46:19 But yes, the ultimate goal here in my opinion as an outsider is you want to get on Delta's
0:46:28 CPA list the capacity purchase list have a 65 or 70 seat airplane coming in here twice a day. What you're trying to do is bridge
0:46:37 To that happening now, maybe that's never gonna happen
0:46:41 But I think as I said up front repeatedly, you're strong performing market historically
0:46:50 in their system.
0:46:51 It's a question of moving the needle mat.
0:46:55 But to answer your question, I believe the 30C product would require long-term subsidy.
0:47:02 And one more follow-up question for you.
0:47:04 You were talking about the one option would be to bring in a leisure carrier.
0:47:10 describe what efforts have been made to attract a leisure carrier for the Twin
0:47:14 Falls market today? Well without naming names we have had teams calls with them
0:47:20 we've presented documents to them. We are under consideration by various
0:47:27 carriers. I would prefer not in public to go further than that. And they have
0:47:31 complete. We've done leakage studies, immigration studies, second home ownership
0:47:40 studies, all that is plotted out and presented to these carriers, showing them
0:47:45 opportunity. And is there interest? I would say there is interest, yes. Thank you. Any
0:47:56 other questions down there for Mike? Okay, so next I believe Sean will be
0:48:12 I'm just going to be very brief. I don't quite be too repetitive, but Madam Mayor, members
0:48:19 of the Council and County Commissioners, again, I appreciate that this is not a pleasant conversation
0:48:26 to be having. It is certainly something a little challenging in my first couple of months
0:48:33 on the job to be dealing with, but I would also note that in my previous employment at
0:48:38 the chamber. This is not a new issue for the community. We've been talking about
0:48:44 preservation expansion maintenance of air service for clear back to those 2014
0:48:51 days when we were converting from the prop plants to jets. So I just want to
0:48:57 reemphasize a couple of items here. This isn't unique to us. It's not ideal, but it
0:49:04 It is better than no service.
0:49:06 And I do believe that one of the critical components
0:49:10 of this agreement that has the potential
0:49:13 to allow us some more time to continue our efforts
0:49:16 to find long-term solutions to air service challenges,
0:49:20 to include partners like the state potentially,
0:49:24 federal assistance, the business community,
0:49:27 other partners in town.
0:49:29 We've had history and experience with that in the past.
0:49:33 We do have felt burned by some of those operations,
0:49:36 but we've also had very successful opportunities
0:49:39 to do that in the past.
0:49:40 So again, I appreciate this is a difficult decision
0:49:43 before you, but I do think that we need to be
0:49:48 in the preservation mode to quote Commissioner Hall there.
0:49:52 I think that's an excellent word to be looking at.
0:49:55 I do know there are a number of folks here to visit,
0:49:57 so I'm gonna be quiet and sit down
0:50:00 and appreciate your attention to this.
0:50:02 Thank you, Sean.
0:50:04 Yes.
0:50:04 Let's make my staff make my ass a quick question.
0:50:07 So what's the timeline here again, Sean?
0:50:09 When does the decision need to be made if we make a decision?
0:50:14 So the agreement is for coverage January through March.
0:50:19 So certainly I would anticipate before the end of the year.
0:50:24 Again, this is on the agenda this evening
0:50:26 for potential action by the council
0:50:28 understanding that the commission would need
0:50:30 to take action on that as well.
0:50:32 but we have teed it out for potential action tonight,
0:50:35 or at the meeting on the 12th next week
0:50:38 to take that action, but certainly
0:50:40 with holidays approaching for everyone,
0:50:42 I would think that the sooner a decision
0:50:44 could be made, the better.
0:50:45 I'm just looking for the actual timing
0:50:47 because we may, we haven't really discussed this,
0:50:50 want to take this back, doctor, a few more citizens
0:50:53 before we make our decision.
0:50:54 Just a thought, and so I need a kind of a...
0:50:57 I think Bill was gonna summarize with that,
0:50:59 So maybe Sean, you could tell if you, I have you down as summarizing so.
0:51:07 Yes, I know you're still looking for public comments.
0:51:11 Yes.
0:51:12 But I'll summarize.
0:51:13 And I really couldn't say it better than this month would probably be the best time to do that with an initiating January 1.
0:51:22 So, absolutely.
0:51:23 So, yeah, maybe after public comment I could make a conclusion.
0:51:27 Okay, excellent.
0:51:28 Okay. We have a number of people here tonight. Welcome everyone.
0:51:33 Several people have signed up on the list to speak.
0:51:37 You may not know what you signed up for.
0:51:40 If I read your name and you choose not to come down and speak, that's okay.
0:51:45 And also if you did not sign up, you still will give you guys an opportunity to speak.
0:51:51 You just need to make sure you get your name on the list before you leave for public record.
0:51:56 We'll do two minutes per person tonight, and Amy will be timing.
0:52:04 It should be a timer up on the screen.
0:52:07 If you come down, please state your name and whether you're a resident of Twin Falls.
0:52:13 I might say we have a lot of people here, so as long as we're not repeating the same thing every time,
0:52:20 I would appreciate that and know that we're listening to you when we take your
0:52:26 feedback very very seriously and this is a very important issue to us and we
0:52:32 know it's important to our community. So I'll start with first person is Greg Pike.
0:52:39 Again please state your name and whether you're a resident of Twin Falls.
0:52:57 My name is Greg Pike. I am a resident of Twin Falls with my wife, my wife and I moved here
0:53:13 from Cincinnati a year ago. We moved here to take care of my wife's parents. We sold
0:53:21 our house there, moved here, my wife was able to transfer her job to Salt Lake. We did want
0:53:27 to live in Salt Lake. We wanted to live in Twin. We built a house here. We were just
0:53:37 And at Woodson, now seeing what's going on with the airport.
0:53:41 When we first planned on moving here, those three flights a day, that looked really good.
0:53:47 And even now with one flight, we're able to make that work.
0:53:52 But even we're worried now that because if the flights go, I mean, we wouldn't have
0:53:57 sometimes a pass close, you can't even drive to Salt Lake.
0:54:00 And we're just worried about all that, and we're concerned about it, and we just know
0:54:05 how much we depend on the airport and how much the city will depend on it, it does depend
0:54:11 on it.
0:54:12 Both economically because of businesses, um, land via collect bar, um, Chabani, you know,
0:54:20 more than I do.
0:54:21 And I'm sure there are people who can speak more about that.
0:54:24 But we're just concerned and we just wanted people to know that, um, how much we depend
0:54:29 on the airport and, um, we hope that, um, it'll keep this a viable city, um, because
0:54:35 when you think that if the flights go away, that it's going to hurt us.
0:54:40 We're afraid that people like us might leave, because it's possible that we might even have
0:54:45 to sell our house in another year or two if that happens and drive up here from Seoul to
0:54:51 take care of my wife's parents, which we don't want to do.
0:54:54 We don't want to leave the city, we love it.
0:54:57 We're even more about the people like us that maybe we'll not even ever find out about to
0:55:04 and the businesses that never get a chance to move here
0:55:08 because there's no airline.
0:55:11 Thanks for your time.
0:55:12 Thank you.
0:55:13 Thank you, Greg.
0:55:15 Next on the list is Dan Olmsted.
0:55:22 Welcome, Dan.
0:55:24 Thank you, Madam Mayor, Councilor and County Commissioners.
0:55:27 My name is Dan Olmsted.
0:55:28 I'm a resident of Twin Falls County,
0:55:31 and I'm currently serving on the Twin Falls Airport
0:55:34 Advisory Board, as president, recent past president
0:55:38 of the Southern Idaho Economic Development Organization,
0:55:41 current board chair of Southern Idaho Tourism. Excellent presentations, I think all of that was laid out very well.
0:55:48 I would just for approval of the contract this before you.
0:55:53 Thank you, Dan. Next is Andy Hoelweiler. Andy?
0:55:59 Good evening, Madam Mayor, council members and county commissioners. My name is Andy Hoelweiler and I'm a resident of Twin Falls County.
0:56:15 I want to thank Mr. Mooney for his presentation.
0:56:18 There's one key takeaway that I'd like to reiterate
0:56:20 and that is what a regular and cost-effective service means
0:56:25 to the business community of Twin Falls.
0:56:28 We were fortunate for many, many years to have multiple options
0:56:32 in service both through Salt Lake and Denver.
0:56:35 And while the potential of that coming back to the way used
0:56:39 to be looks awfully bleak, the prospect of having no services
0:56:44 even bleaker.
0:56:44 And so, I encourage all of you to take action to approve the measure in front of you.
0:56:51 I don't take lightly the economic weight that it entails, the potential impact that it has
0:57:00 to both the county and the city, but please believe me and Mr. Muni's presentation
0:57:05 that we have incredible momentum as a community, as a business segment, and that this is one
0:57:11 of the reasons we have that moment and we must continue to foster and support it.
0:57:16 Thank you. Thank you, Andy. Ron Yates. Good evening, Madam Mayor and Council members and
0:57:36 commissioners and fellow citizens of all. My name is Ron Yates. I am a citizen of Twin Falls,
0:57:42 the city, and I'd like to say that I support what I've seen here as a good study in that word
0:57:52 of Commissioner Hall an act of preservation for our service and optimism for the future.
0:58:01 One thing I did hear about the larger aircraft qualifications and smaller aircraft qualifications,
0:58:06 the FFA was it the FFA that made that decision.
0:58:11 Okay as a group we might get a whole of our senators and congressmen and ask them to have
0:58:17 a few hearings that FAA has a suggestion I'm making,
0:58:21 have some hearings to why that is so effective,
0:58:26 perhaps, or non-effective if it's really necessary,
0:58:29 because it's a cost-cutting measure.
0:58:32 I compare this to the water bill that I receive every month,
0:58:35 and I will be receiving at like 10 years
0:58:37 of parts per billion of arsenic.
0:58:41 It shut down the own park water system,
0:58:43 where I live near the private well.
0:58:46 And this is a federal overreach of the FAA.
0:58:49 If we could ask our senators and congressmen
0:58:52 to have a hearing to determine if the FAA will relinquish this,
0:58:57 that was my suggestion.
0:58:58 And again, I will say I really respect the information
0:59:02 I received tonight from the analyst.
0:59:05 And thank you.
0:59:07 Thank you, Ron.
0:59:09 Next is Mark Beings.
0:59:24 Council, Council, Mr. D. Nice.
0:59:26 First of all, I've been here and I'm a little shaky, but I'll do my best.
0:59:30 We don't.
0:59:31 As an owner of a business that I've been in business since 1971, the aircraft carriers
0:59:37 in this flying has been a real favor to us.
0:59:40 As a business owner, we have two conventions we go, and as of most of the time we fly.
0:59:46 Every time we fly out of Twin Falls, it's not two, it's four of us.
0:59:49 So the convenience is there, but I see that we need that to keep not only my business,
0:59:55 But we got all the big businesses that are bigger than me
0:59:57 that need that ability to keep our services working
1:00:01 and twin-folds bringing in the big companies
1:00:04 that help my business as a small guy because we are able
1:00:07 to support them and help them
1:00:08 and when they're building houses,
1:00:10 we're doing whatever they do in our business.
1:00:12 But I think you guys need to re-evaluate it
1:00:14 and vote for it, I really do.
1:00:16 Thank you.
1:00:17 Thank you, Mark.
1:00:18 Next is Patricia Neglery.
1:00:21 And if I watch that, Patricia, I apologize.
1:00:24 Yes, I didn't or I did. Okay. Good evening. My name is Patricia
1:00:31 Millery. I am a resident of Twin Falls County and a business
1:00:35 owner in City of Twin Falls. Madam Mayor, council members,
1:00:40 commissioners, I think the opportunity to speak tonight. I
1:00:43 wanted to speak in favor of approving taking action first,
1:00:47 really, and proving the proposal because you're going to
1:00:51 hear from me as both a parent and family member, but also in my
1:00:54 role as a family law attorney in Twin Falls. It's slightly different business focus from
1:01:00 the other business members that have spoken tonight. Having the opportunity for multiple
1:01:05 flights was fantastic. I agree with what has been stated that thumb is better than none.
1:01:12 It is an act of preservation and as a person who has flown out of Twin Falls for personal
1:01:17 and business and has had family members fly in, it's invaluable. Also in my role as a family
1:01:25 attorney, I have clients that have custody exchanges from all over the place, and
1:01:30 having the option to have a child fly directly into their city is invaluable.
1:01:36 It is not quite cost prohibitive yet, so I would urge that this community take
1:01:43 action to preserve those options for not just families and business travel, but
1:01:48 for the children that are flying in and out for custody exchanges as well. Thank
1:01:52 Thank you.
1:01:56 Sherry Johns.
1:01:57 Okay.
1:01:58 There's always a couple.
1:02:01 So you're all right.
1:02:02 So, I think you're good.
1:02:03 Good evening, Council.
1:02:09 Is that Gregerson?
1:02:10 A citizen of Twin Falls?
1:02:12 Just real quick, I want to speak to something that perhaps hasn't been mentioned as an individual
1:02:20 here.
1:02:21 My family and I have used the Twin Falls airport for decades.
1:02:25 One thing that I wanted to mention is if we don't have these services, we could definitely
1:02:31 use Boise or Salt Lake or some of the others that are closer, but the economic impact coming
1:02:40 back, not so much going, but coming back, will be a strain for our economy. If I were to
1:02:49 on business, travel out of Boise, likely I would have to get a hotel before and or after,
1:02:55 and food and or after before and after as opposed to bringing my money's back to my family and to my fellow citizens here so they can actually thank you.
1:03:08 Okay, well costy Neo. Again I butchered that. Okay. All right. Challenge in.
1:03:19 It is Costello, thank you, Madam Mayor and the City Council members and County Commissioners,
1:03:25 thanks for the time.
1:03:26 I am a resident of Twin Falls County, I work for Lamby and Nutritionals, I'm the Chief Commercial
1:03:34 and Marketing Officer.
1:03:35 We have about 880 employees here in Idaho, over 2,400 globally, and I'm supportive of having
1:03:45 the flights in, I think Mr. Moody's presentation was very well done. I think
1:03:50 just to throw out a couple of numbers back in 2019 we had about 750 flights in
1:03:56 another Twin Falls with our employees and you know obviously the pandemic had an
1:04:01 impact on that. This year year to date we have flown about 789 flights with
1:04:08 about 20% being out of Twin Falls. So the reason why is because we don't have
1:04:14 the availability of the flights. The morning flight helped out considerably, but still there's
1:04:20 a lot of other employees that have to drive to Salt Lake or to Boise. And I think there's
1:04:27 two things. One is, you know, it's not efficient from a cost standpoint of our business. When
1:04:33 I look at the airlines or Sky West, I think that everybody should be allowed to make money,
1:04:37 but they have to be cognizant of. I might have preservation as the word used. I might have
1:04:43 another term but we'll stick with preservation. But I think the other
1:04:50 thing too is we have a non-negotiable in our business which is safety and we
1:04:55 want to make sure our employees get home at night and driving like last
1:05:00 Monday I was driving a Boise on Winter Storm and it's just not right so with
1:05:05 that I think safety and efficiency is the right thing to do to move forward
1:05:10 was something. And I'd like to say a little bit of the SkyWest employees here. I see a lot of the crowd here, great people.
1:05:18 And we want to see that sustained here.
1:05:20 Thank you. Thank you.
1:05:23 Okay. Next is Grayson Stone.
1:05:25 Madam Mayor, members of the Council of County Commissioners. My name is Grayson Stone. I was out here in Twin Falls.
1:05:41 I'm speaking here today in support of proving a renewal of the minimum revenue guarantee contract with SkyWest
1:05:47 for Delta Airline Service at Salt Lake.
1:05:50 Neither of us has native sound of Twin Falls,
1:05:53 but more importantly, my role as the Vice Chair
1:05:55 for the Twin Falls area, Chamber of Commerce.
1:05:58 It's my understanding that Delta Airline
1:06:00 has requested a 200,000 MRG to continue service
1:06:03 from Twin Falls to Salt Lake from January 1st to March 1st.
1:06:06 Those monies are to be contributed
1:06:08 from both the City of Twin Falls and Twin Falls County.
1:06:13 The mission of the Twin Falls area, Chamber of Commerce
1:06:15 is clear. We are tasked with giving our members a strong voice, vision, and focus leadership
1:06:20 to enhance the economic vitality and quality of life in our community. The qualified mic
1:06:25 comments on emphasize two major characteristics of our mission statement, economic vitality
1:06:30 and quality of life. Speaking to economic vitality, I don't know if the economy is strong. I think
1:06:35 we can all agree that the magic power is probably the strongest part of that. As our air service
1:06:40 agreement currently sits, Twin Falls Regional Airport and joins being able to employ TSA
1:06:44 personnel, while joining the rental companies that are associated with the airport, the
1:06:47 injection of dollars in the local economy, from gas cells from radar service, and the
1:06:52 dollars that are passed along the AIP funding, from maintenance and so forth.
1:06:56 A national of the Twin Falls regional airport is a great asset to recruiting no regionally
1:07:00 and nationally-preated companies into the greater Twin Falls area.
1:07:03 So, speaking of the quality of life, where I bring up the investments in Twin Falls more
1:07:08 of the magical I have the convenience of flying out of Twin Falls and not having to make the
1:07:12 to track to Boise or Salt Lake, 2,000 dollars in tax revenue allocated for three months,
1:07:17 whereas it's the time to come up with a viable solution that's not only going to be sustainable,
1:07:22 but also works for all of our community partners. Thanks.
1:07:26 Thank you. Okay, that's it for everybody that signed up. Is there anybody in the audience
1:07:32 that didn't get a chance to sign up that would like to come down and speak?
1:07:37 Thank you, Commissioner Ranky.
1:07:48 Is it possible to have a question for Mr. Mooney?
1:07:51 Are we too late in this process?
1:07:52 No, I think we're...
1:07:53 It would be a couple.
1:07:54 You have another question?
1:07:55 Thank you.
1:07:56 For good, please.
1:07:58 Yes, sir.
1:07:59 Given the track record that SkyWest has observed and participated in here for so many years,
1:08:05 especially in 2022 with a minimum revenue guarantee that we have, and the fact that we've
1:08:12 only had to pay $25,000 in that because of our load capacities, is there any change
1:08:17 in your mind that they could go from a 50 to a 70 seat rather than a 50 to a 30
1:08:23 and maintain that one flight. Yeah unfortunately the 50 seat aircraft are
1:08:32 not really controlled by what are called the scope clauses in other words at the
1:08:38 large airlines the pilots unions that operate the 737s and the air buses.
1:08:45 Part of the ongoing contracts are what are called scope clauses, and the scope clause says
1:08:52 that Delta management, American management, United, whoever you are, you can only have
1:08:58 so many of those big RJ's because they take jobs away from my union.
1:09:04 So Delta American United want a lot of 76-seat airplanes, they are handcuffed by union contract
1:09:12 to a smaller number. Sky West operates those airplanes for those airlines, but those airplanes
1:09:20 are under the CPA, so they're under the control of American Delta United. Sky West does not
1:09:27 have the leverage within their agreement with Delta to take a part 76 seat airplane and put
1:09:36 online Twin Falls Salt Lake City, Delta has to negotiate that with their pilot's
1:09:41 union, so there's a scope class. The 50-seat window, the only way we get the dual
1:09:46 class is with Delta and a conversation with Delta, which we are working on, and
1:09:54 we've already had presentations to them, but that is we need more time. Thank you.
1:10:00 Hey, thank you, mayor, and I think everyone for turning out. I appreciate the comments
1:10:14 We've heard from the public. I think the questions were excellent
1:10:18 Appreciate the presentation by Mike Moody and show us comments as well. So just to conclude a little bit here
1:10:26 As an airport manager, I look at being a facility manager as part of that
1:10:32 We have a lot of businesses that
1:10:34 We work with, as a public sector, we try to get together in the aeronautical world and platform and infrastructure out there that these businesses are successful.
1:10:44 Certainly, air services, these are marquee business that enables us to receive a larger share of federal funding, those types of things, which everyone enjoys out there that operates.
1:10:55 So, in many ways, air service pays the freight.
1:10:58 It enables us to do a lot of good things in preserving
1:11:01 and developing our airport for FedEx, for the BLM,
1:11:05 for a lifeflight activity for agricultural spraying,
1:11:08 just to name a few things that go on out there.
1:11:11 So, some of the things I'm concerned with,
1:11:14 with if we cut off this agreement and the exit of Sky West
1:11:19 and loss of air service.
1:11:20 So, when you have 10,000 inflaments,
1:11:23 which you need with air service.
1:11:24 Your entitled is a million dollars
1:11:27 of capital improvement funding from the FAA.
1:11:30 We've enjoyed that for quite a while.
1:11:32 We've even dipped into discretionary funds.
1:11:35 We've had a very aggressive capital campaign
1:11:38 in developing and preserving the airport.
1:11:42 It would be difficult to lose that funding.
1:11:45 It would be difficult for the community
1:11:47 to maintain the capital needs of the airport into the future.
1:11:51 So that's one of the things that keeps me up at night occasionally as I think about this issue.
1:11:57 The infrastructure that we have out there for air service and even underlined was recent conversations with the TSA Federal Security Director in our state.
1:12:07 If we were to lose air service they would plan, maybe not right away to pull out all their equipment because they have some warehouses with equipment,
1:12:15 But they would remove the personnel, the screeners that we have.
1:12:19 And if we were to re-engage and get air service or a leisure carrier were to come
1:12:23 and need air service, even if it's two, three, four flights a week,
1:12:27 we could not get that personnel back by slipping a switch.
1:12:31 It would be difficult to maintain that infrastructure.
1:12:35 On the revenue side, as we look to maybe move forward with some of these revenue
1:12:40 agreements here. We were fortunate to receive CARES funding, ARPA funding, those types of things
1:12:49 at the airport in the tune of about $3 million, a little over $3 million the last couple of years.
1:12:54 Those are in the airport reserve fund. They're there to subsidize operations should we need them.
1:12:59 So there is funding available to subsidize any of the city and county money that might go for a
1:13:05 So with that, I would ask you to approve the agreement to sustain economic growth, to sustain
1:13:13 infrastructure, to sustain opportunities for our community.
1:13:18 So with that, I ask you to approve this agreement.
1:13:22 If you do make a motion to approve the agreement and then have a vote, that would be contingent
1:13:27 I would recommend on the county commissioners approving the agreement as well.
1:13:32 So those are my concluding remarks.
1:13:34 I'd be happy to answer any questions that you might have.
1:13:37 Any questions for Bill at this point?
1:13:40 Okay, very thorough presentation.
1:13:45 Thank you.
1:13:46 So, commissioners, I'm not exactly sure what you'd like to do.
1:13:51 We're gonna have some discussion.
1:13:53 You'd like to be in on it, listen to it.
1:13:58 But what do you intend to do?
1:14:00 Cause I know you're gonna vote on this
1:14:01 on a lot of later dates.
1:14:03 Yeah, I think that we can take action from our side either to table this or take no action
1:14:10 and re-agenda it for one of our conference meetings.
1:14:13 But I'll leave it up to the board if you want to be part of the mutual discussion, maybe.
1:14:19 Yeah, this is a little funky.
1:14:21 Yes.
1:14:22 Yes.
1:14:23 I've never done this before.
1:14:24 Unprecedented.
1:14:25 I think I want to listen to the discussion because I respect our partners, our city partners,
1:14:31 you're thinking obviously we're kind of hooked at the hip here on the yes we are
1:14:36 my thought and it's up to the three commissioners eventually when we when and
1:14:42 if we make a motion tonight is to I'd like to give it a little more time because
1:14:46 I'd like to reach out to the public a little bit more this is your setting
1:14:50 these are folks that come to the City Council I we haven't had that opportunity
1:14:54 with our constituents in the unincorporated areas I'm very sensitive to the timing so
1:15:01 we'll make sure that we're very sensitive at that timing but that that would be my
1:15:05 desire but I would rather listen to the discussion as well as well I agree with
1:15:10 that done. You're welcome to stay. Okay so input from the council we again we have
1:15:17 two options we can approve this agreement tonight contingent on county
1:15:23 approval or we can table this and wait and put on the agenda for next week. So
1:15:30 So what does everybody think?
1:15:33 Thank you, Board.
1:15:38 Mayor, I would be interested in making a vote tonight if everybody else is, I would
1:15:46 be ready for that.
1:15:48 And I would just like to say thank you and how much I appreciate the thoughtfulness
1:15:55 that went into every one of you who spoke.
1:15:59 I think everything I wanted to say, you said it.
1:16:04 And I am very much in favor of this, it is a pay to preserve.
1:16:10 And I think it is our very best choice right now to give us time.
1:16:17 We have the best community with the best people.
1:16:22 So much.
1:16:23 I serve on the airport board as a liaison.
1:16:26 And I know how much hard work and how many hours have gone into this already.
1:16:33 discussions that are going on and I think I'm very optimistic about the future
1:16:38 because we have the best people on this and we have the best community and we're
1:16:44 gonna come up with the best solution and so I would be in favor of voting for
1:16:48 this. It's time to keep moving forward. Thank you Nikki Spencer Cutler. Thank you
1:16:55 Mayor. I was wondering if it's appropriate for us to approve if we were
1:16:59 to make a motion tonight and it worked to be approved.
1:17:03 Can we do a contingent upon our county commissioner?
1:17:05 Yes, that needs to be.
1:17:07 It must be, yes, yes, Chris Reed.
1:17:11 I won't delay this.
1:17:12 I know there's some people that want to speak after me,
1:17:14 but I'm in favor of this.
1:17:15 I think this is something, again,
1:17:17 the preservation of this service is important.
1:17:21 I don't think anybody likes it last year.
1:17:23 We didn't like this, but it's what we need
1:17:26 to be able to preserve this.
1:17:27 So we do need to do this in hopes that next year we're not having this exact same conversation.
1:17:33 And I know we have individuals who are working behind the scenes.
1:17:36 And we do know the work you're doing and we appreciate it.
1:17:39 So I'm in favor of it.
1:17:40 And thank you.
1:17:42 Thanks, Carl.
1:17:44 I would add that I do, I would support a vote tonight on the issue.
1:17:48 And I think, um, listening to Mr. Carberry, we do have the funds in reserve.
1:17:53 So I do think we can stand a holding pattern for a while.
1:17:56 So I think it's an appropriate step to take, so I would be in favor.
1:18:03 Thank you, Chris Reed.
1:18:05 I mean, Craig Hawkins, you were on there once.
1:18:08 He's better looking out.
1:18:09 He got on again.
1:18:12 I would concur with what's been said tonight.
1:18:14 I think even though this is kind of a dark discouraging thing,
1:18:21 we're having to deal with the result of economic impact
1:18:26 If we didn't move forward with it, it's our worst.
1:18:29 I wouldn't move and be able to agree with having motion tonight.
1:18:36 Thank you.
1:18:37 I might add, I too am in favor of signing this agreement.
1:18:41 I've had several people reach out to me over the last week since this became public.
1:18:47 And I am very concerned about the impact on individuals.
1:18:52 Patricia, you're, I didn't even think about parents and children in custody.
1:18:56 but I've ridden with children in the solvass,
1:18:59 an area that is really important,
1:19:02 but eat from an economic standpoint, economic development
1:19:07 standpoint, but I'm also concerned about the jobs
1:19:11 at the airport.
1:19:12 We've got TSA, we've got control tower,
1:19:15 we've got ground crew, we've got the restaurant,
1:19:18 we've got, and that's a lot of jobs
1:19:21 that we're talking about, and I would
1:19:23 to be responsible for having those go away and maybe not being able to ever get back what
1:19:29 we have right now. So I personally am in favor of this as well. So Chris, this is this is
1:19:37 a count from when I've been on the phone for a little over 35 minutes. So I've been listening
1:19:43 and trying to digest Mr. Mooney's presentation and all this bit of smoke and I wanted to chime
1:19:50 in at this point and let you know that I'm here and that I would also be in favor of
1:19:55 of a motion and again I think everybody said it it's not a pleasant situation I think it's
1:20:03 best for our future of the City of Twin Falls.
1:20:07 Thank you.
1:20:08 Chris Reed.
1:20:09 I'll make a motion.
1:20:11 Mayor I move that we approve a renewal of the minimum revenue guarantee contract with Sky
1:20:17 West Airlines for Delta Airline Service to Salt Lake City contingent on our county commissioners
1:20:23 approval.
1:20:24 Thank you, Alex.
1:20:25 My second.
1:20:26 The motion.
1:20:27 Thank you.
1:20:28 Motion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Alex Kaval to approve a renewal of the minimum revenue
1:20:35 guarantee contract with the West Airlines for Delta Airline Service to Salt Lake contingent
1:20:42 on county commissioners approving as well.
1:20:45 further discussion. Amy Wilk, have you please?
1:20:51 Nikki Boyd? Yes. Craig Hawkins? Yes.
1:20:55 He said Brown? Yeah. Alex Kaval? Yes.
1:20:59 Spencer Cutler? Yes. Ruth Pierce? Yes. And Chris Reed? Yes.
1:21:03 Thank you. Motion passes 7-0.
1:21:08 Thank you everyone for attending. You're welcome to stay.
1:21:12 We have three public hearings now. Yes.
1:21:16 Mayor, sorry, we still need to take some action on our deal.
1:21:19 I'm sorry.
1:21:20 Thank you.
1:21:21 Thank you for everybody leaves.
1:21:25 Sorry, I don't know if we need some discussion before a motion.
1:21:28 I'll turn it over to the Board of County Commissioners.
1:21:30 If there's any discussion, the needs take place before a motion is made.
1:21:36 Well, I was just going to say before our partners left, I wanted to say I'm
1:21:41 that's why I appreciated the testimony tonight.
1:21:44 I'm looking in the audience.
1:21:45 There's friends, there's colleagues.
1:21:47 There's employees of the airport. We appreciate you all being here.
1:21:51 I just think that we need a little more time with our constituents to make sure
1:21:57 that we're making the right decision as well. And on the humor side,
1:22:02 I've never had the city have to wait on us on something,
1:22:05 so I'm taking it as a little bit.
1:22:08 I'm not so sure I'd agree with that.
1:22:12 Commissioner Mikey, anything before a motion?
1:22:14 I'm fine.
1:22:15 I'm ready when Commissioner Hall makes a motion.
1:22:17 Okay, I would just add I'm also very appreciative of inviting us tonight having a joint meeting
1:22:24 and our constituents that are out here hearing from you. I agree with commissioner highland ranking that we do need have a
1:22:31 little time on our side and
1:22:33 Make a decision our chambers on this where we want to proceed from there. So we'll turn it over to the board for a motion at this time
1:22:40 So we generally don't table things, we usually take no action so that it's definitely on
1:22:48 our next agenda, but just out of what folks here are used to, I'm going to make a motion
1:22:55 to table in a minute, that means that we'll definitely be on our agenda, we'll make sure
1:23:00 that that's taking place and I'm looking at Shannon, she'll make sure that.
1:23:03 So what the f*** you're ready for a motion?
1:23:05 for motions. I would note that we table the renewal of the minimum revenue
1:23:11 guarantee contract with SkyWest Airlines for Delta Airlines service to Salt Lake
1:23:16 City. Second. Motion and a second any further discussion. I would just say I'll
1:23:23 just be honest with you I'm pretty positive about this motion or or proving
1:23:28 this but again we just need a little more time with our constituency to make
1:23:32 sure that we're hearing from them as well. This is extremely important to our community,
1:23:40 not just to the city which involves the Magic Valley, frankly, and businesses and leisure
1:23:47 and business. I agree with what you said, Mayor. What was your first name? Patricia, your input
1:23:56 was really powerful as well. I never made that connection. So, again, when it comes to
1:24:04 us, unless I hear something way outside of what I've heard tonight from our community,
1:24:10 I'll be voting to move this forward in the future.
1:24:14 Mr. Ranky, I would agree. I'd also like to say thank you for all those that have read
1:24:18 attendance and comments that were made. I do think it's important for us to reach out
1:24:22 to the rest of the communities in our county as well and I will make sure that those mayors
1:24:27 all get called and invite them to come in the day that's on our agenda, get some additional
1:24:32 feedback as well as advertise that as from the greater county perspective. So I would
1:24:38 be in support of that as well. And likewise, I'm very much in favor of where we're going.
1:24:42 I just think we need a little bit more feedback from the rest of the county residents.
1:24:49 I agree. We're very sensitive to our community's needs, our business needs, commercial.
1:24:54 And there's a lot of citizens that just fly for leisure out of the airport still, and we're considered that.
1:25:01 I agree with the input. I appreciate everybody here in the input we've heard tonight.
1:25:07 And sure to that, is there any further discussion?
1:25:12 All in favor of the motion, aye. Motion passes three to zero. Thank you.
1:25:19 The Board of County Commissioners will be in recess.
1:25:22 Would you let us know when your meeting is so we can make sure if there's anybody here that wants to attend?
1:25:30 Thank you
1:25:37 Now I was just gonna ask Commissioner Johnson as to when he might think this would be appear on a county agenda
1:25:42 I think that this is critical and I think that question was asked so as soon as the county can place this on the agenda
1:25:49 I think that we could all advance and move forward and I would encourage them not to delay
1:25:53 We meet every Monday, Tuesday and Thursday at 10 a.m. I would suspect there's a good chance we might be able to have it looking at Shannon or maybe by next Thursday would give us enough time to reach out to some of the folks to have it in there if we can speed that up.
1:26:11 We'll definitely let you know.
1:26:13 So this Thursday or next?
1:26:15 A week from this Thursday.
1:26:17 The 15th.
1:26:19 We could or or maybe Monday or Tuesday. We'll see. Yeah, as soon as we get that
1:26:24 sent, we'll send it out and get word out to people. Thank you. Thank you, gentlemen.
1:26:31 Okay, next on the agenda before we get to the public hearings is time for
1:26:41 general public input. So this is a term on the agenda for the general public to
1:26:47 speak on anything that wasn't on the agenda. So if there's anybody here in
1:26:52 in chambers which is to comment on something other than the airport and is
1:26:59 not for the public hearing please come down okay see no one advisory board
1:27:08 reports anything going on with mitties right now anything from the city
1:27:17 manager's office just a quick reminder this Friday is the festival light parade
1:27:24 it's also the annual lighting of the city Christmas tree that's going to occur
1:27:28 in the downtown comment. The parade begins at six o'clock and then we'll also have the
1:27:36 opportunity to welcome Santa into the community on a not a horse-drawn
1:27:44 ladder truck but certainly one that is incredibly full of horse power. So look
1:27:50 forward to seeing everyone in the community. It should be a cool night to
1:27:54 So, dress one.
1:27:56 Yes, thank you.
1:27:59 Okay, next, it's time for public hearings.
1:28:04 Does everybody want to take a break or are we good?
1:28:07 Are we good to move on?
1:28:10 Good, yes?
1:28:11 Okay, let's go.
1:28:14 Okay, so we do have three public hearings tonight.
1:28:27 Okay, so tonight we will be having three public hearings.
1:28:32 The rules related to these public hearings, the steps are, the Z staff will present the
1:28:39 request and the analysis.
1:28:42 The applicant will then present their request.
1:28:45 The commission council will then ask questions of the applicant or staff.
1:28:50 After questions have been asked, the public hearing will be opened.
1:28:54 During that time, anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions
1:28:59 about the request being considered.
1:29:02 And when you give testimony, please
1:29:04 talk up to the podium, state your name and address,
1:29:07 and present your comments or concerns.
1:29:10 After giving testimony, please sign the public record
1:29:13 in the sheet located in the lobby with your name and address.
1:29:16 After public comments are included,
1:29:18 the applicant will be invited to answer any questions
1:29:20 and make a closing statement.
1:29:22 Staff will then answer or clarify any comments.
1:29:25 After closing statements of public hearing will be closed.
1:29:29 No more testimony from applicants or audience,
1:29:33 and then the council will then have open discussion
1:29:36 and take action.
1:29:38 So our first is an action item.
1:29:41 It's a request to amend the Magic Valley Mall ZDA
1:29:46 to allow for three multi-tenant signs
1:29:49 to be a maximum of 300 square feet,
1:29:51 and to include 200 square feet of message center signage
1:29:56 as a portion of that property, as a portion of that property located at 1485 Pollain Road
1:30:04 East, Carabrand White on behalf of Woodbury Corporation, PZ22-014, and we have Lisa Strickland,
1:30:12 our City Planning Hello Lisa.
1:30:14 Good evening, Mayor Pierce and Council.
1:30:20 So this is a request to amend the Magic Valley Mall ZDA to allow three multi-tenant signs that
1:30:28 would include 200 square foot of Message Center and a maximum of 300 square foot of signage.
1:30:38 So a portion of that 300 square foot would actually be 200 square foot of Message Center
1:30:46 were property located at 1485 Fullon Road East.
1:30:49 The property is zoned C1, ZDA, and the Magic Valley Mall C1, ZDA,
1:30:54 was approved in April of 2018.
1:30:58 Future land use map has this area designated as mixed use,
1:31:02 which incorporates regional commercial high-intensity
1:31:05 development in a compact environment.
1:31:09 A multi-tenant sign is defined as a sign that is erected
1:31:13 on its own vertical framework consisting of one or more
1:31:15 upright supports by supported by the ground and generally used to identify several commercial
1:31:21 services and or office uses within a single common subdivision or development.
1:31:28 A message center sign is defined as a sign that contains a display that can be changed
1:31:35 by electrical, electronic, and or computerized process provides general public service information
1:31:41 such as time, date, temperature, weather, or messages of interest to the traveling public.
1:31:49 A message center sign may also provide a commercial message related to the use of the property on which the sign is located.
1:31:58 Based on the criteria outlined in the City Code 10-9, this property is allowed three multi-tenant signs located every 300 feet on each street frontage.
1:32:09 According to the amount of frontage the property has for each street, the property would then
1:32:15 be allowed to have a maximum of 9 multi-tenant signs.
1:32:19 Each would also be allowed to be a maximum of 35 feet tall and they could have 80 feet
1:32:27 of the signage be displayed as a message center sign.
1:32:33 The applicant is proposing to reduce the number of allowed multi-tenant signs to 3 located
1:32:39 at or near the main entrance of the development. Each sign would consist of up to 300 square
1:32:44 feet of signage as per code with a maximum height of 25 feet. The proposed exception to
1:32:50 the current agreement and to the city code would be to allow the 80 square feet to now
1:32:57 be 200 square feet of the signage as Message Center. Here are a few samples of a multi-tenant
1:33:05 sign with a message center as part of the structure.
1:33:14 Per City Code 10 617, approval of the ZDA agreement shall be based on following standards.
1:33:21 The proposed use shall not be detrimental to any surrounding uses nor shall they be detrimental
1:33:27 to public health and welfare.
1:33:30 A variation from the underlying zoning district development requirements must be warranted
1:33:35 by the design and amenities incorporated in the conceptual development plan.
1:33:40 The underlining zoning district and the conceptual development plan shall conform to the comprehensive
1:33:46 plan and there must be a consideration of whether existing or proposed streets and utility
1:33:51 services may be suitable and adequate for the purpose of the development.
1:33:56 The applicant is required to present a preliminary review of the request to the Planning and
1:34:01 and zoning commission in which the commission may give suggestions and ask questions of the applicant
1:34:05 about the proposed amendments, followed by the public hearing to forward a recommendation
1:34:10 from the Planning and Zoning Commission to the Council.
1:34:13 The preliminary presentation for this request was held on October 11th,
1:34:18 and the public hearing was held on October 25th.
1:34:21 After hearing the request, taking testimony in consideration of the Planning and Zoning Commission recommendation,
1:34:27 the Council will make the final decision.
1:34:30 approved an ordinance shall be prepared with the ZDM amendment and shall be signed and recorded.
1:34:35 In reviewing the request, the council is tasked with considering whether the proposal would
1:34:41 be detrimental to the surrounding uses, is it warranted by design and amenities incorporated
1:34:46 in the development plan, and if there are services adequate for the proposed change.
1:34:51 The proposal to reduce the number of allowed multi-tenant signs with message centers from
1:34:56 with a height reduction from 35 to 25 and to enlarge the message center portion of the
1:35:02 sign from 80 to 200. By reducing the number of allowed signs to 3, it would reduce the
1:35:09 impact that 9 signs would have on the surrounding properties. The height reduction would make
1:35:15 the signs less intrusive and larger message center signs would provide a safer communication
1:35:20 method for passing traffic.
1:35:24 As this property serves multi-tenants, the ability to advertise and support all the different
1:35:29 businesses within development using a large message center sign would be a benefit to
1:35:33 their large number of tenants as well as the customers.
1:35:37 Staff's analysis if approved amendment is approved would have an impact to the surrounding
1:35:45 area, reduce the amount of signs that is currently allowed and would not be detrimental to the
1:35:50 safety and general welfare of the public. The development is compatible with the
1:35:54 comprehensive plan and services are available to serve the new multi-tenant
1:35:59 signs. Upon conclusion, should the Council approve the request as presented,
1:36:03 staff recommends the following that be approved subject to site plan amendments
1:36:07 as required by building, fire, engineering and zoning to ensure compliance with city
1:36:12 code and requirements. This concludes my presentation. I'll stand for any questions
1:36:17 and the applicant is here to present their request.
1:36:20 Any questions for Lisa?
1:36:24 Lisa, I have a couple questions.
1:36:28 Would that replace the signs that are presently there?
1:36:31 It would replace the freestanding signs that are there.
1:36:35 The only one that would not replace is the one that is located as you're coming to cross
1:36:43 pole line at locust. That one would remain in place. Okay. Any other the other question I had?
1:36:50 And it would also be a the message center sign that's currently there along Blue Lakes North would
1:36:55 be removed. Okay. I've seen some and I'm in favor of the signs. I'm not that bad. I've seen some
1:37:03 signs around town that walk the view for safety for trying to get out on other streets. I don't see
1:37:12 I see that being a problem, but I wanted to make sure that that wouldn't be a safety concern.
1:37:17 And the other thing would be with these signs blocking the present tenants building signs that might be an affair with their promotion of their business.
1:37:29 From what I can tell the answer to that question is no.
1:37:33 per our city code requirement, they must put the sign 10 feet behind curb or front of curb,
1:37:44 and they are also required to make sure that they do not put anything taller than 3 feet
1:37:48 within the site obstruction triangle.
1:37:52 So when the planned site is reviewed, those will be the items they get looked at to ensure
1:37:57 that they don't obstruct view.
1:37:59 Okay, thank you. Any other questions for Lisa? Okay, Ren, welcome up the applicant.
1:38:10 My nice neighbor, members of the commission. First, I congratulate those of you that haven't had a chance to present before,
1:38:45 with and appreciate your service on our council going on 30 years and being in the community.
1:38:52 And what I'm going to say next, I really believe,
1:38:56 we've approached the city about so many things I can't count.
1:39:01 And I've learned over the years that our partnership with you
1:39:05 produces better results.
1:39:08 I can honestly say, and I think this is kind of what
1:39:10 underlies our presentation tonight,
1:39:13 our goal as property owners and operators
1:39:16 of commercial business locations, frankly,
1:39:19 is not simply to maximize our property rights.
1:39:23 property rights sometimes conflict conflict with what's in the bus public
1:39:29 good and it's the mentality of our company and it's kind of what guides a
1:39:35 lot of our decision-making is how do you balance those things because if in the
1:39:39 end if we don't serve the public good we don't even serve ourselves and so
1:39:43 tonight I think you'll see that in and what we're going to talk about first
1:39:48 thing I want to do is just harken back to the ZDA idea for a minute several
1:39:54 years ago I came before the council to request a modification from a PDU data
1:39:58 to ZDA. I'd have been one of the first CDAs in the community and as you see on
1:40:04 this slide the idea of a ZDA was that over time needs change especially in
1:40:09 commercial business and that flexibility and creativity should be guiding ID concepts
1:40:15 behind what is a ZDA for so that over time things can adapt to meet needs as
1:40:21 they change and so that's what we're talking about tonight. So our request,
1:40:29 okay, we're not, there we go. Did I skip one? Let's see. So our request tonight is as
1:40:46 opposed to placing nine signs with nine message centers, which I think it strikes
1:40:51 us all rather intuitively. This isn't great for the public good, yet at the
1:40:58 same time being competitive in our businesses, being able to remain competitive is very, very important.
1:41:04 So how could we meet a balance? And so after consulting with staff for several occasions,
1:41:11 our conclusion was that rather than proposing nine message center signs, some of you have probably seen them
1:41:18 when we have now. It's kind of old and not really functioning great. Time to go. Our proposal is to have
1:41:26 three of those pilot signs with a message center and I'd say just this so I don't
1:41:34 take too much of your time. The sign, the electronics, the digital capacities of
1:41:42 the signs are designed. Message centers have evolved. We've all experienced a
1:41:48 message center blaring so brightly in our eyes that we get distracted
1:41:51 somewhat blinded. These signs are adapted so that like your television they dim
1:41:56 as lights go down in the environment, they come brighter when light, so there's more
1:42:01 light in the environment.
1:42:03 So those kinds of safety, and in order to deliver a good product, those characters
1:42:10 are built into the technology.
1:42:14 And so why 200 square feet?
1:42:16 I'll show you in a few minutes other comparable signs in the state of Idaho, and I think you'll
1:42:22 understand, looking at those, why we think that 200 square feet is an appropriate square
1:42:28 footage for the message component. This gives you a little bit better sense of what the
1:42:34 signs would look like. So, as you see on the left, permitted our nine message center signs.
1:42:46 We're proposing three of the pylon signs have message centers. Each permitted is 300 square
1:42:54 and that is what we're proposing, 300 square feet. Permitted currently is 80 square feet per board.
1:43:01 We're proposing rather than 9, 3 with 200 square feet of the message center component.
1:43:07 The total message center signage that would be permitted under the code is 720 square feet.
1:43:14 We're proposing 600 square feet. And finally, that this particular, these particular signs will
1:43:21 comply with all the other aspects of the code.
1:43:24 I want to mention one other thing.
1:43:27 We do retain the right to have other signage
1:43:31 at the shopping center.
1:43:32 We're not asking that anything else
1:43:34 be modified with respect to that other signage.
1:43:38 We retain the right to apply for other signage in the future,
1:43:42 but we're forfeiting the right to apply for signage
1:43:45 that would have a message center in it.
1:43:48 So we'll have three.
1:43:50 That's it, that's what we're asking for.
1:43:55 Now to give you a sense of what competitive means,
1:43:58 here's a message center.
1:43:59 Some of you may have seen this one.
1:44:01 160 feet tall, 60 feet wide, the shopping center.
1:44:05 It is not as large as magic, though, at all.
1:44:08 This is located in Lehigh, Utah.
1:44:11 Talking about Idaho, this is a property we own in Hammond.
1:44:16 That sign is 50 feet tall by 25 wide.
1:44:20 The shopping center is probably half the size of magic
1:44:24 fellamole.
1:44:27 This is Meridian, the village of Meridian.
1:44:31 Many of you probably know that property.
1:44:33 The height is 55 feet.
1:44:34 We're proposing 30.
1:44:36 The width there is 25.
1:44:38 We're proposing 25.
1:44:40 And this is in NIMPA.
1:44:41 And again, we're proposing a substantially smaller.
1:44:44 And I think it's interesting.
1:44:46 And it's probably important to say,
1:44:47 what have other communities in the state of Idaho concluded
1:44:50 was reasonable when looking at questions like this.
1:44:54 And so we did our homework.
1:44:56 We want to say, what we're doing, is it reasonable?
1:44:59 Does it like-minded people come to similar conclusions,
1:45:03 and we think the answer is yes.
1:45:08 But with this, I'd just like to stand for any questions
1:45:10 that you might have.
1:45:11 Thank you, Grant.
1:45:12 Any questions for Mr. White?
1:45:17 No.
1:45:17 Thank you very much.
1:45:18 Thank you.
1:45:19 Oh, go ahead.
1:45:20 So your understanding is, you're still going to have all your nine signs, but you're swapping out three of them for these message board ones, is that correct?
1:45:29 Let me answer it as carefully as I can.
1:45:32 We are replacing all of the existing signage except the sign that sits by Olive Garden as you enter from Locust, that's simply a monument sign that sits near the ground.
1:45:43 So the other signs, the sign at the corner of the whole line in Blue Lakes, at Bridgeview
1:45:47 and Blue Lakes, and the current electronic mission centers will all be gone.
1:45:52 We're placing then up to three pylon signs with a message board at this time.
1:45:59 We would retain the right to a future pylon sign but never to a message center.
1:46:03 Thank you for clarifying that.
1:46:09 Anyone else?
1:46:10 I'd just like to say, I think, Rand, it makes a lot of sense, and I feel good about it.
1:46:17 I was just wondering, I was looking at that corner by Taco Bell, and that would be blocking
1:46:25 their business at all, but I went by yesterday, there's some pretty big-sized pine trees there also, so...
1:46:32 And let me respond to that.
1:46:35 Under our contracts with all of our tenants, we have an obligation and an authority to place signage,
1:46:42 And I can't tell him how many times he's asked me to cut a tree down.
1:46:47 And I always say, the city wouldn't like me to cut a tree down because there's an ordinance that says I have certain amount of trees.
1:46:53 And so some of the things we do, our tenants would say cut the tree down, don't put it in the sign.
1:46:58 But our commitment is to meet the terms of our agreement with you and do it in a sensible way.
1:47:03 And sometimes our tenants love it and sometimes they don't.
1:47:06 But that's our challenge.
1:47:09 That makes sense.
1:47:10 Thank you.
1:47:12 Any other questions for rent or staff?
1:47:17 We're good.
1:47:19 Okay, then we're going to open up the public hearing.
1:47:23 And again, if you wish to testify,
1:47:27 please come down and state your name
1:47:29 and present your comments or concerns.
1:47:32 Is there anybody here that wishes to address this issue?
1:47:40 They see no one, anything you'd like to add
1:47:44 staff or print anything else. Okay then I will close the public hearing and so
1:47:53 it's time for council discussion. Council wishes and is everybody not you
1:48:00 sure anybody? I just think it's common sense and it sounds appropriate. It's not
1:48:22 taking advantage of a lot more sites which I think could be intrusive. Thank
1:48:26 Thank you. Chris Street.
1:48:28 I'll add to that. I just think that it fits the area.
1:48:31 I don't think that it's something that's out of place. It won't look out of place.
1:48:35 I know across the street there is signs similar to that.
1:48:38 I don't know the height, but I don't think it's going to stick out,
1:48:43 especially with modern technology, those reader boards.
1:48:47 Like I said, it will go well with the environment.
1:48:51 Okay. Thank you.
1:48:53 I would make a motion if you're a committee mayor.
1:48:57 Sure, yes.
1:49:00 Mayor, I move that we grant the request to amend the Magic Valley Mall CDA to allow for
1:49:07 three multi-tenant signs to be a maximum of 300 square feet and to include 200 square feet
1:49:15 of message, center signage, as a portion of that on property located at 1485 Pole Line
1:49:23 in road east, here of grant white on behalf of the Woodbury Corporation.
1:49:28 Thank you, Chris Reed.
1:49:30 Thank you.
1:49:31 Motion by Nikki Boy, seconded by Chris Reed to approve amending the Magic Quality Mall
1:49:37 ZDA for these signs, these three signs.
1:49:42 Any other discussion?
1:49:44 Council?
1:49:47 These turn.
1:49:50 Madam Mayor, I was in looking at the notes from staff.
1:49:53 it look like staff had requested a condition that the site amendment be required.
1:49:58 That's correct.
1:50:00 That is subject to site amendments as required by building fire engineering,
1:50:04 phoning, tundra, voter standards. I didn't hear that the motion.
1:50:08 Yeah. I would like to add that please.
1:50:10 Okay. Okay, good.
1:50:12 Second's fine. Thank you, Alex. I meant to remember that.
1:50:16 Amy Rolkow vote please.
1:50:20 Craig Hawkins. Yes.
1:50:22 Asen Brown, Alex Kaval, yes.
1:50:26 Mentor Cutler, yes. Ruth Pierce, yes.
1:50:29 Chris Reed, yes. Nikki Boyd, yes.
1:50:32 Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero.
1:50:35 Thank you everyone. Okay, next public hearing is an action item also
1:50:45 and it's a request for a rezone of property from C1 CROPUD,
1:50:51 to C1 CRO on property located at 1671 Canyon Place Drive,
1:50:58 here of Tom Schofield on behalf of the North Canyon Medical Center.
1:51:02 And again, we have Lisa Strickland.
1:51:04 Welcome, Lisa, again.
1:51:06 Good evening, Mayor Pierce, Council, once again.
1:51:30 So this is a request to rezone a property from C1 CRO PUD to just C1 CRO.
1:51:39 The future land use map designates this area as mixed use, which incorporates regional
1:51:44 commercial high-intensity development in a compact environment.
1:51:47 In 2014, the property was annexed and rezoned from R1 variable CRO to C1 CRO PUD.
1:51:57 This area was designated as urban infill within the comprehensive plan at the time, which
1:52:03 is similar to the mixed use designation in our current comprehensive plan.
1:52:07 This mixed-use development was approved for the planning unit development agreement process.
1:52:13 The property is located within the Canyon Village PUD and consists of lots 9 and 10
1:52:19 of the Canyon Village subdivision number 3.
1:52:22 These two laws, if approved, would be rezoned from C1 CRO PUD to C1 CRO and would no longer
1:52:31 be subject to the Canyon Village PUD and its specific development criteria.
1:52:36 However, the property will still be subject to any private agreements or CCNRs that were
1:52:41 agreed to by the private parties of the subdivision.
1:52:45 The plan unit development agreement provided a master development plan with reference to
1:52:50 R1 variable CRO and C1 zoning districts of the city code with some modifications to try
1:52:56 and design a plan that would blend well with the neighboring properties and future development.
1:53:02 In the current PUD master plan, there are essentially two development designations.
1:53:07 This other portion of the property is residential, while the northern portion of the property
1:53:11 is planned for commercial.
1:53:14 Since 2014, portions of the PUD have developed as residential with some professional as a
1:53:21 buffer to the commercial area that has not been developed.
1:53:27 If approved, this particular property would no longer be subject to the Canyon Village PUD.
1:53:32 is and its specific development criteria, however the property will still be subject
1:53:39 to any CC&Rs that were agreed upon between the private parties and the subdivision.
1:53:45 And for approval process, the zoning districts and zoning district changes are, and zoning
1:53:53 sub-districts and overlay district shall be amended in the following manner.
1:53:58 So there should be a request for an amendment to this title and it shall be submitted to
1:54:02 Commission which shall evaluate the request and to determine the extent and nature of the
1:54:07 amendment requested. If the request is in accordance with the comprehensive plan, the
1:54:12 Commission makes a recommendation to the City Council and the Council makes final decision.
1:54:17 The Planning and Zoning Commission public hearing took place on October 25th and the
1:54:22 Planning and Zoning Commission recommended approval of the request. After hearing the
1:54:26 request, taking testimony and consideration of the Planning and Zoning Commission recommendation,
1:54:31 The council will make a final decision, and if approved,
1:54:33 an ordinance shall be prepared, signed, and recorded,
1:54:36 followed by a zoning map amendment to reflect the change.
1:54:41 Currently under the PUD agreement,
1:54:42 there are two regulatory items to consider
1:54:45 when making a decision for this request.
1:54:47 The PUD has modified list of land uses permitted
1:54:51 for the area identified as C1
1:54:53 within the master development plan,
1:54:55 and the maximum building height is limited to 35 feet.
1:54:58 These modifications or limitations
1:55:00 were an attempt to maintain similar heights within development and to anticipate the types
1:55:05 of land use that may be proposed for the site. In 2016, the comprehensive plan supports high
1:55:12 density mixed use development that is compact and pedestrian oriented. The subdivision has
1:55:18 gradually developed over the past few years and has demonstrated a mixed use concept with
1:55:22 residential areas to the south and professional offices just north of these homes. The professional
1:55:28 office provides a transitional buffer that will help to minimize the effects of a more
1:55:32 intense commercial use on the neighboring neighborhoods, on the nearby neighborhoods.
1:55:37 The applicant is asking to rezone Lots 9 and 10, a block 4 of the Canyon Village subdivision
1:55:44 number 3, to C1 CRO, removing the lots from the PUD agreement.
1:55:50 The reason for the request is to develop the lots into the C1 CRO zoning district.
1:55:55 For proof, the land use in the C1 zoning district within city code would apply and the maximum
1:56:02 building height allowed would change to 50 feet.
1:56:06 The two lots are adjacent to a major arterial area and are expected to be commercial in
1:56:11 nature.
1:56:12 The C1 zoning designation is appropriate to properties situated along a major arterial
1:56:17 roads and the maximum building height as defined in the C1 zoning district would be taller than
1:56:22 what was originally planned. Staff has reviewed the request. The area has been designated with
1:56:29 the intent of having commercial and other mixed uses along this corridor. Staff does not foresee
1:56:34 any unexpected impacts that would be associated with the approval of the rezone from C1 CRO
1:56:40 PUD to C1 CRO. As for the 35 foot limitation within the CRO Canyon Rim overlay, that was
1:56:48 created to protect the rim from having exceedingly tall buildings within 100 feet of the rim.
1:56:54 These lots are situated over 400 feet from the Snake River Canyon, and a maximum building
1:56:59 height of 50 feet would be allowed with a rezone to the C1CRO, however staff anticipates
1:57:06 this would have very minimal impacts if any on the canyon rim.
1:57:10 Upon conclusion should the Council approve the request, an ordinance shall be prepared,
1:57:14 and recorded, followed by a zoning map and then meant to reflect the changes.
1:57:19 This concludes my presentation.
1:57:21 I'll stand for any questions and the applicant is here.
1:57:23 Thank you.
1:57:24 Any questions for Lisa, before we bring the applicant to him?
1:57:29 Thank you, Lloyd.
1:57:32 Lisa, have I seen, I mean, in the last seven years, somebody pulled out of a PUD or a poll.
1:57:40 Is this something kind of different?
1:57:42 No, it happens all the time.
1:57:45 Okay.
1:57:46 We've had quite a few, um, the Walgreens at the corner of Washington and Poland, um,
1:57:56 Rivista, um, they, they end up pulling it out and creating their own donning of designation.
1:58:08 And that makes sense.
1:58:10 This is for a specific use and so they're going to follow the rules but they're going
1:58:16 to become their own thing.
1:58:18 The chest of it is that we had the kidney rim overlay rezone, zoning title amendment, that
1:58:28 meant that the maximum height allowed within a hundred feet of the rim was 35. The rezone
1:58:35 allows that to go to 50 if you're within 150 feet and it also removes the requirement of
1:58:41 doing a ZDA. So by rezoning, they're no longer required to do a ZDA for these two
1:58:49 lots. Okay, so they're essentially doing the same thing that we've done. It's just
1:58:53 that a ZDA is not required anymore. Okay, simplification. Okay, all right, thank you.
1:58:59 Thank you. Alex, come up. I think that answered my question. It was going to be why,
1:59:04 what was the benefit for doing that other than the height, but it was the ZDA that
1:59:09 that explain us so thank you.
1:59:11 Mr. Cutler.
1:59:12 I realize we're talking about zoning tonight,
1:59:15 not a specific building.
1:59:16 With that being said,
1:59:17 there's a building that's been talked about.
1:59:19 Is it purported to occupy both lots,
1:59:22 or is it only on lot nine or 10, not both?
1:59:25 Does that make sense?
1:59:29 Yes, it does make sense.
1:59:31 I'll have to have the applicant answer that question.
1:59:33 I have looked at the plans that I've looked at so many.
1:59:36 I'm not sure if it covers both nine and 10.
1:59:39 I know there's parking planned for around the building,
1:59:41 and almost positive that that is lot nine,
1:59:46 but the applicant should be able to clarify that.
1:59:50 Thank you.
1:59:51 Perfect.
1:59:52 Why don't we bring down the applicants?
1:59:56 Mr. Schofield, welcome.
2:00:05 Members of the council, my name is Tom Schofield.
2:00:09 I'm with Lombard Conrad Architects, 472 West Washington,
2:00:14 Boise, Idaho,
2:00:16 representing North Canyon Medical Center on behalf of this project with the intent
2:00:23 ultimately of instructing a new 20,000 plus square feet integrated medical office
2:00:31 building on the site. The background on this is a little bit complicated and
2:00:39 probably doesn't deserve the amount of time that it would take to really unspool
2:00:45 of the threat, but suffice it to say, Lisa did a nice job, I think, of clarifying that,
2:00:51 yes, this was zoned a certain way, at some point the ZDA added in your own component,
2:00:59 and then we had the developer came along and put on a PV, and at some point in this process,
2:01:08 we were building a two-story Metavolvis building, and the CEO, now probably through his program,
2:01:15 year. It would be nice as an amenity to be able to do some continuing education or
2:01:22 resources or whatever you want to do on the roof of this thing. That is not a great idea.
2:01:28 So as we started getting into it and looked at putting something up on the roof, what
2:01:33 we discovered very quickly was that the virtue, the nature of trying to provide services to
2:01:41 a community that has health care challenges means they need elevators and just have stairs
2:01:49 up to the roof.
2:01:50 Well, by the time you bring the elevator up there, you probably want a bathroom and maybe
2:01:55 someplace for the elevator to arrive that's dry.
2:01:58 And pretty soon, so we've got this little bump that kind of sticks up into the third floor
2:02:03 and all of a sudden we have the third floor and we'll be on the 35 feet to make a long
2:02:07 story short.
2:02:08 We have two versions of these plans, a two-story and a three-space prepared to move ahead with the two-story, but we wanted to follow this process because we thought ultimately it would clean up the site for the future.
2:02:25 It made sense. It would allow for development to make more sense along that canyon and along
2:02:32 that property. And insofar as development on lot nine or ten, it's really reviewing it as a singular
2:02:41 parcel. So it's got a singular building on it at this point. I mean, that doesn't mean that there
2:02:48 couldn't be a little addition or something or a second building added to it. I don't know.
2:02:53 Thank you. Any questions at all? Okay, with that being done, I will now open up the public hearing.
2:03:05 So anybody in the audience that wishes to address this issue, please come down to the podium and state your name and address and present your comments or concerns.
2:03:17 So is there anybody in the audience that wishes to come down and speak on this question or this issue?
2:03:24 I'll still get too long. I'll see if you have something on the stairs.
2:03:36 Yes, Madam Mayor, City Council, my name is Tyler Ellison.
2:03:40 I own property located at 2195 Village Park Avenue.
2:03:44 This is a dental office located just south of these plots that you're looking at.
2:03:51 I have 10 windows that look out on this.
2:03:54 I'll be honest with you, I'm not okay, so I'm excited for North Canyon to come but I'm not
2:03:59 excited for what they're proposing but I do want you to remember and Mr. Cull, you said
2:04:04 very good, we are talking about zoning not a building so all in motion set aside why we're
2:04:09 happy that North Canyon is coming whether it be to offer more medical for people to offer
2:04:14 competition for St. Luke's whatever you're excited for it about.
2:04:17 My biggest thing is this and I have a couple I got to remember this is a zoning issue if
2:04:23 If we change the zoning on this, you now open it up to allow anything on that property, not
2:04:28 just North Canyon Medical.
2:04:29 It can be anything up to 50 feet tall.
2:04:32 We change that to the PUD.
2:04:34 Now, I'm going to get a little personal on you.
2:04:38 I purchased my lot of the first purchase lot in Canyon Village in 2016, I own the first
2:04:44 lot in here.
2:04:45 I'm well aware of the PUD and everything that goes with it.
2:04:51 I'll throw some dollars at you here when I purchase land and build the building to the
2:04:55 tune of $1.5 million.
2:04:58 I had the idea of what the PUD would be.
2:05:01 What would be around me, what kind of edifices things like that would be around me.
2:05:06 If you go and change this and allow for rezoning, everyone in there is going to be dissatisfied.
2:05:12 And one thing I'm a little concerned about is this would be selective regulation.
2:05:19 You're taking something located within the PUD and now it's not regulated by that PUD.
2:05:25 It literally sits adjacent to everything buildings that are built already existing,
2:05:30 And now they have an exemption.
2:05:36 I want you to remember too that planning and zoning there was an objection planning and zoning
2:05:39 and I hope that she was able to discuss her objection with you or know she was but there
2:05:43 was one lady who did object and understood that it didn't need to come outside the pewdie.
2:05:56 Just to go on that, I'll end, I mean, no matter what I say, I'm just going to influence what
2:06:02 you decide, counsel.
2:06:04 But I want you to know that when I built a building there, I didn't come to you, have
2:06:11 a design and come to you and ask you to modify it to fit what I wanted. I built what I wanted
2:06:19 to conform to what I'd purchased land in, which was a beauty. And I'll tell you right
2:06:26 now, if you do go ahead and approve this to see one, you will have the entire development
2:06:34 demand or request that you rezone the entire thing.
2:06:40 Thank you. Is there anybody else in the audience that wishes to address this issue? Okay. Any
2:06:49 comments from staff or applicant on this issue.
2:06:59 And I'll close the public hearing.
2:07:04 So, excuse me, Council wishes discussion.
2:07:10 Yes.
2:07:11 I just wanted to give comment
2:07:12 to my fellow council members.
2:07:16 First of all, I want to see a lot of competition
2:07:18 against another major healthcare provider.
2:07:21 And so I'm excited for this.
2:07:23 With that being said, I feel like changing the zoning now
2:07:26 where this had been beginning to be developed, properties
2:07:30 are worked on, and then it's changed.
2:07:32 I feel like it's a bit of a rug pull.
2:07:34 If this was a fresh pallet, I would
2:07:36 be all for allowing more allowances.
2:07:42 However, where this ball is already rolling,
2:07:46 people have started to build things there.
2:07:48 And then to change, I just feel like it's too late to do it.
2:07:52 And I hate that I have to say that because, like I said,
2:07:54 I want to see some strong competition against another health
2:07:56 care provider here but those are my feelings and I just want to share them
2:07:59 with the council so thank you very much. Thank you. Anybody else have any
2:08:05 comments? I remember when this PUD was created I remember back into that 14
2:08:18 hours I'm planning and zoning at the time I remember that public hearing it was
2:08:23 probably the first hearing that I had where the entire old council chambers
2:08:27 were completely full and it was the residents who were coming out and were
2:08:34 frustrated because this entire lot was going to be commercial and then they took
2:08:39 it back to the drawing board and then built in that buffer and so it's very
2:08:43 interesting to just see that the residential from the most parts in that
2:08:50 buffer have businesses that are now in the design always had a bigger commercial
2:09:00 property in there. Again, height is different, and we will continue to debate height in Twin
2:09:06 Falls, I think, for the rest of my time on council and all of our time on council. I understand
2:09:13 the frustration 100%. I understand the desire as well. This is challenging. Zoning is always
2:09:23 changing. We've chatted about zoning. If you want the property next to you to stay or have a say on
2:09:32 it, you have to buy it. And I don't like saying that, but we see that monthly here. And so there's
2:09:44 a desire, there's finances behind it. We've made some changes in the past on height in this specific
2:09:51 area, but Mr. Elesson's point, he's purchased it. So there's a balance there, but understanding
2:09:58 that this happens every month. The changes zone. And you don't get to, I mean, we get to make
2:10:05 that say as far as zoning, but you have to come to the council to change that and it changes
2:10:11 all the time.
2:10:14 Thank you.
2:10:15 That's sir.
2:10:17 Yeah, I think this might be a question for staff.
2:10:21 So there's a different Canyon Village subdivisions.
2:10:25 I don't know all the numbers.
2:10:26 The one that's already built where Mr. Eason's property is, was that part of, I guess, this
2:10:32 ZDA or is that like an independent development?
2:10:36 entirety of that acreage is all part of the same type of subdivision. It went through phases.
2:10:46 That Bishop's storehouse was like phase one with the residential and then the professional offices
2:10:51 are a different phase. They all kind of built around the same time frame. Not all the lots were
2:10:57 built before the next phase happened. But this, this building was primarily in there. That was
2:11:06 the driver behind a lot of it the offices end up taking place in here and then the residences and
2:11:12 these two kind of developed at the same time this one I believe was the first one of the first
2:11:17 buildings with the office of the professional offices an engineer question it's all one subdivision
2:11:23 with different phases yes thank you that exactly it I have a follow-up question just um is the
2:11:28 Bishop storehouse does it exceed 35 feet I don't believe it does thank you okay so this is an
2:11:41 action item. I guess okay bring a pause. Chris Reed. I'll make a motion. Thank you.
2:12:06 I move that we approve the rezoning of property from C1, CROPUD, to C1, CRO,
2:12:13 on property located at 1671 Canyon Plaza Drive, care of Tom Schofield on
2:12:21 on behalf of North Canyon Medical Center.
2:12:24 Thank you, Alex.
2:12:25 I would second the motion.
2:12:26 Thank you.
2:12:27 A motion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Alex
2:12:30 to approve the request for a reasonable number of property
2:12:34 from C1, C.R.P.D.
2:12:37 Excuse me, does C1, C.R.L. on property located at 1671 Canyon
2:12:42 Plaza Drive?
2:12:44 Any further discussion?
2:12:47 Yeah, Madam Mayor, this is Councilman Brown.
2:12:50 and maybe I'll hold on to my question just because of the communication difficulties.
2:12:56 So what is, what would be the difference we're going from 35 feet to 50 in height is the
2:13:05 arm of the ZDA?
2:13:06 Yes, Councilman Brown, this is Drake.
2:13:10 I think it's my grip for spin love here.
2:13:12 Re-zoning it out of the PUD makes it just our basic C1 zone, and by virtue of that, the
2:13:19 height goes to 50 feet because that's what the height limit is.
2:13:23 maximum limit is in that C1 zone.
2:13:29 Thank you.
2:13:30 Any further questions or discussion?
2:13:33 Yes, Chris Reed.
2:13:36 So if this property changes hands,
2:13:39 if it goes from North Canyon Medical Center,
2:13:42 and they decide they don't want to do that,
2:13:46 can we put something in there that it goes back into this?
2:13:53 Yeah, that's what makes this,
2:13:56 I can help refocus a little bit.
2:13:58 We are here to determine whether the rezone to the Z-1 CRO meets the comprehensive plan
2:14:04 or not.
2:14:05 You can also debate whether it should come out of the PUD.
2:14:08 Is that what we should allow?
2:14:11 Conditioning the rezone if it does not stay with this current owner and building I think
2:14:17 is probably a stretch to make that condition.
2:14:20 The council could always bring it back on your own to rezone property.
2:14:25 have the authority to zone properties to either make it more restrictive or less restrictive
2:14:32 as a council. There are some legalities behind it that I'll let Shane kind of talk to you about
2:14:37 if there's a, it becomes like a fiscal responsibility of the property owners feels that there's
2:14:43 a limited ability on their property that you may have taken it right away, then that could
2:14:47 be a taking of property right potential. But you can always have the right to rezone property
2:14:55 In this case, I don't know if you could condition this is approval to say it goes back into the PUD I think that would be a bit of a stretch, but Shane might be able to help me on that one.
2:15:05 Who's making a face over there some with like I was thinking face?
2:15:12 Well, it is a difficult question to answer, but I think Jonathan's correct in that the condition on the type of building can't go.
2:15:23 I think there's some level of what I was trying to think through.
2:15:25 I believe there's some level of phasing of construction itself,
2:15:29 but not necessarily type of building that's going in the location that's being rezoned.
2:15:35 I mean, that's just a way of saying we don't think we can condition that thing being built
2:15:41 on the property with the rezoned.
2:15:43 And then here, it can't be by ownership.
2:15:47 I don't believe so.
2:15:50 Thank you.
2:15:51 Alex.
2:15:54 The C1CRO designation, is that consistent with the comprehensive plan?
2:16:01 Staff believes it is consistent with what's desired in the comprehensive plan.
2:16:05 Okay.
2:16:06 Number two.
2:16:07 The change in the designation, does that have a significant impact on traffic in the area
2:16:14 by going off that extra 10 feet?
2:16:16 Or 15 feet, excuse me.
2:16:18 I don't believe that the increase in vehicle trips would be detrimental to the surrounding
2:16:25 roadways, there are terials, Pauline and Eastland, the internal roadways with their own driveways,
2:16:31 so the surrounding public roadways, we don't believe I'll have to measure my impact for
2:16:35 that a little bit extra height that's allowed by going to the base C1 zone.
2:16:39 Okay, thank you, that's all I have.
2:16:42 Okay, any other questions, comments?
2:16:47 Okay, Amy, welcome up, please.
2:16:54 Jason Brown?
2:16:55 No.
2:16:57 Alex Koval?
2:17:01 Yes.
2:17:02 Spencer Kettler?
2:17:03 No. Ruth Pierce? Yes. Ruth Reed? Yes. Nicky Boyd? Craig Hawkins? Yes.
2:17:14 Okay. Motion passes 5-2-2. Thank you. Okay. Next item on the agenda is an action item
2:17:27 and I see that Ian's not here. Ian and you're going to be doing both of those. I just noticed
2:17:33 the informational one as well.
2:17:35 Yes, he fell ill, so.
2:17:37 Okay.
2:17:38 So the next item is an action item, a request to approve the consolidated annual performance
2:17:44 evaluations report, acronym, CAPER, and we have Jonathan Spindlove.
2:17:49 Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of the Council.
2:17:53 I'll be brief mainly because I'm less familiar with this as he was, but the CAPER is a requirement
2:17:59 every year to report on our activities for the CDBG program and what we spent the money on.
2:18:05 Everything is in the staff report in terms of the amounts. The money was primarily spent
2:18:10 on preparing the annual action plan amendment and staff time to train and figure out how
2:18:17 to work a federal government system, which is difficult that's cumbersome, and to prepare
2:18:22 for the project that I'm going to talk to you about after. That's where the primary of our
2:18:28 time has been spent is shifting focus from the annual action plans from before to the new
2:18:35 one that was passed in August. If you remember, all of those dates that we occurred, we shifted
2:18:40 our focus to public infrastructure in our downtown area, which is our only low income
2:18:47 tract in the city is the downtown core, the main town site. So we're going to be focusing
2:18:53 all of our efforts on public infrastructure in those areas, primarily with bathroom and
2:19:00 some other public infrastructure stuff.
2:19:02 So the caper was put out for public comment.
2:19:06 We received no comments from the public to our office.
2:19:09 Tonight, you will need to have a public hearing to receive any comments people may have on
2:19:14 the caper and then note the comments, close it, and then approve the consolidated annual
2:19:22 Annual Performance and Evaluation Report
2:19:24 slash caper for 2021.
2:19:28 You read our conclusion, it says 2020,
2:19:30 and that's my typo that I, too many dates in the past,
2:19:33 and I couldn't get them all right.
2:19:34 Okay.
2:19:35 And that concludes the caper report.
2:19:39 Okay.
2:19:41 So any questions for Donathan on this?
2:19:43 Okay, since we don't have an applicant on this particular item,
2:19:51 I will open this up for a late comment.
2:19:54 Anybody in the audience who wishes to ask a question or address this report, please come down.
2:20:04 Seeing no one, I will close the public hearing.
2:20:09 Council discussion wishes.
2:20:19 When I went through that, we've used 122,000, and 80 of it was for administrative.
2:20:28 So my take, and then so many things had zeros.
2:20:32 This first year was, this isn't really the first year, is it?
2:20:38 We said we'd like to get into this.
2:20:42 In 19, this is 22.
2:20:45 So in 21, we still hadn't done much with it.
2:20:49 Is that what I mean?
2:20:52 Yeah, and it was a lot how to do with COVID.
2:20:54 Right.
2:20:55 Put it behind.
2:20:56 But go ahead, Jonathan.
2:20:57 Yeah, the way that these reports,
2:20:58 so in 19, we said we'd do it.
2:21:00 Our first program year was 20, which we reported on last year.
2:21:04 This is the report for 21.
2:21:06 It's always like a year behind the year we're in, currently,
2:21:10 the calendar-wise.
2:21:11 And we used to spend most of our time
2:21:13 on trying to figure out the system training,
2:21:15 the administration which is planning technician, a little bit of Ian's time, and refocusing
2:21:22 those new annual action plans and paying a consultant to help us with that. That's the
2:21:27 bulk of that dollar amounts from.
2:21:28 So it was 80 on administration and the other piece which we did agree to a consultant on
2:21:35 that. Okay, so this is where we are. Okay, I just wanted to make sure it's very slow, isn't
2:21:44 it?
2:21:46 Yes, federal dollars in COVID Spencer color. Are you ready for a motion? I am
2:21:51 I move that we approve the consolidated annual performance and evaluations report
2:21:56 Thank you, Alex. Thank you motion vice-vincer cutler seconded by Alex Kaval to approve the
2:22:05 2021 consolidated annual performance and evaluations report Amy roll call vote, please
2:22:13 Alex Kaval, yes
2:22:15 Thank you motion passes seven to zero.
2:22:25 Next item on the agenda is actually an informational item.
2:22:32 It's a presentation of the CDBG City Park project.
2:22:37 We have Jonathan's been left.
2:22:40 So, to the not spending the money, this is where we've refocused our efforts.
2:22:48 I will say that we've had numerous city staff from city engineer, public works, money and
2:22:56 zoning, city manager's office, library, and our council liaison to the library, council
2:23:03 and Nikki Boyd to see this plan.
2:23:06 This is where we are focusing our efforts with the CDBG program going forward, spending
2:23:13 the money and the dollars that were afforded in that low income area.
2:23:17 What we have are three projects that we're going to propose and talk about.
2:23:23 One of them being the bathroom to be updated, which is up here in grade that will be part
2:23:29 of the initial phase.
2:23:32 The second phase would be an ADA accessible park area, which is what's going to be an orange.
2:23:39 And then the third phase is sidewalk and plaza in front of the library.
2:23:46 To start this whole drawing, this came from city staff member Chance Munns, who's at the
2:23:52 parks department, and Chance and Wendy and us all collaborated on figuring out how to improve
2:23:59 our city park for it to be continued to be used as a area park for the low-income
2:24:05 tract as downtown. This is one of the only parks in that area. There is a small, I
2:24:11 believe it's called, jewelry park, which is over on Washington. It's right on
2:24:15 Washington. So it's on that western side. This park is still the area park for the
2:24:21 majority of this downtown area and it lacks in being updated in the funding
2:24:27 that takes for that. We can use CDBG funds to do the bathroom, which is a project you have
2:24:34 heard of that's kind of on the books on the shelf, just needs to be funded. The other portions are
2:24:42 CDBG CV, which is COVID money. Separate from the other COVID money we have, it's very specific to
2:24:50 to CDBG things.
2:24:52 The plaza is basically the genesis of the COVID funds
2:24:56 to create an outdoor learning space
2:24:58 for the library to utilize in case of a future pandemic
2:25:01 where you can have social distance learning
2:25:03 or outdoor learning space.
2:25:06 So these are very concrete plans.
2:25:12 But what we have to do is show our idea,
2:25:15 get input on the idea, report back to HUD
2:25:18 that we have gone through this process
2:25:20 to gain public input from the varying levels.
2:25:24 We go through the input from council, the library board.
2:25:29 We'll go through other stakeholders to kind of say,
2:25:30 here's an idea we'd like to do.
2:25:33 We get the input, then we address the input.
2:25:35 All of that is needed before we can actually get
2:25:38 what we call a release of funds,
2:25:41 so we can hire somebody that actually drops plans to do it.
2:25:44 That's the process for us.
2:25:46 So here is one of the first, like actual general public looks
2:25:49 what we're designing or trying to do to revamp this area. We have talked to the
2:25:56 library director and we are going to be going to the library board on December
2:26:00 14th to show them this very plan to get input as well. Some of the things that
2:26:05 they're excited about is some outdoor space that they could utilize for reading
2:26:12 time for the bike rodeo, the things that they usually end up closing this road for
2:26:16 because that's what this actually does is close hands in traffic gets rerouted
2:26:21 down fifth around the block and this ends up being the entrance into the parking
2:26:27 lot we've identified needing to do something in the parking lot to dissuade
2:26:34 people from cutting through the parking lot we think we have an idea on how to
2:26:37 do that fairly minimally and then this area becomes a ADA-friendly plaza with
2:26:44 some surface treatments or redoing the road from a traffic standpoint, Hanson has less
2:26:51 than 400 trips per day. The majority of those go to the library from public works in the
2:26:56 engineering department. I don't believe this is going to be an issue in servicing the area
2:27:01 or maintaining the water line which is enhancing. We actually plan on potentially replacing
2:27:07 the water line while we're in the road anyway so it will gain another 40 to 80 years of life.
2:27:12 Trying to think of everything that's in this report that I remember the sidewalk ends up being a continuous signover from the corner
2:27:21 I'm up by saying heads all the way down handsome street. That was something that we had the council
2:27:27 I was talking about during the budgeting process. We said hold on a second
2:27:30 We have this idea we want to do this is the idea to continue that sidewalk along this roadway and connect it all the way down
2:27:37 Elements the purple part in there the purple triangles are actually some small covered picnic tables
2:27:45 that the Parks Department believes they could utilize in those areas.
2:27:50 This plan, the hopes is to minimize removal of any trees.
2:27:55 That's a big one, trees if you really love trees.
2:27:59 And so he's like, let's not put the sidewalk along here if we can save these trees
2:28:03 because it actually saves about three or four trees along this roadway,
2:28:06 if we can preclude putting it in the park area.
2:28:09 So the idea was to come up with this plaza to have people walk down.
2:28:12 And there's no action, it's really just a comment so we can report back and that's what goes into our report to HUD to address any comments.
2:28:25 One thing the library actually was thinking of doing is I think we can actually work with them on Tara brought up having a book lockers.
2:28:36 to be able to afford, you know, when you go into reserve a book, you go into the library to get it.
2:28:41 I put their research in having book lockers outside that they could actually place those
2:28:47 holds in certain lockers. That actually, I think we can use COVID-19 for it because it becomes a zero
2:28:52 contact transfer of the books. So we can actually use some of the additional money to put the lockers
2:28:57 out somewhere, somewhere outside near the plaza and have it still lit in an area and have some security
2:29:04 on it and afford something that they've wanted to do for a while, am I missing anything else,
2:29:09 Councilwoman Boyd, did I, from that discussion?
2:29:14 Well, no, that, I was just getting, my name didn't come up, I clicked. I, this does a lot
2:29:23 of things on a lot of levels for a lot of people, is what I really like about this. It puts the
2:29:30 sidewalk through. The Plaza idea is an extension of our city part and our
2:29:36 library and they do a lot of outdoor things for kids. They have, you know, and I
2:29:44 just think this is really a wonderful thing. Also, it adds to the walkability
2:29:50 and as the children's museum eventually is going to get built and put. We have
2:29:55 more things to go do see and you can walk to them downtown and that's a benefit for those
2:30:02 who live in that area. Every citizen, this is a, I was really pleased when I saw this,
2:30:10 the locker thing, lots of people come in from our outline areas and if they're in town on
2:30:16 a Saturday or a Sunday because they need to get groceries, they can go pick up their books
2:30:21 and not have to make another trip. And so the locker idea, I think, is a really nice thing to have for a lot of the patrons of the library that don't live here.
2:30:32 Well, and I got to say, redoing those bathrooms is sold for me.
2:30:38 Right there, so.
2:30:39 Are we trying to redo these bathrooms for you?
2:30:41 Yeah, Chris Reed.
2:30:42 I think this is fantastic. One group that I would reach out to is the St. Ed's group working downtown.
2:30:52 When I see they do recess in this park every day,
2:30:56 or they don't have it today, because it's cold,
2:30:59 but they're going to be utilizing that,
2:31:01 so allowing them to have input and talking with them as well.
2:31:04 But I think this is fantastic.
2:31:07 The other one thing that's kind of like a design element,
2:31:10 what it will do is actually helps mainstream
2:31:14 when you're standing at Hanson,
2:31:16 out here in our intersection,
2:31:18 by putting this plaza, you will give the terminus
2:31:21 your view to where the park and the library are. You can actually see the
2:31:24 connection between those two places where it's at the parks not that far. It's a
2:31:28 couple blocks and allows to have some of that connection to downtown. We could maybe
2:31:32 start that kind of area coming from Hanson down Hanson to the main street. So
2:31:38 it's another thing that kind of affords some good urban design if you want to put
2:31:44 So that was another plus to it for us.
2:31:49 Right. Mitch.
2:31:50 I'm just going to add one thing that Jonathan forgot to tell you.
2:31:53 That is that this plan also gets accessibility access to the playground,
2:31:57 which the current playground that's out there just doesn't.
2:32:00 It's not.
2:32:01 That's good.
2:32:02 That's good.
2:32:03 Full ADA playground and access to it.
2:32:06 That was between the library and back and forth.
2:32:09 That's perfect.
2:32:11 Any other questions or comments?
2:32:13 I think that's good.
2:32:14 Okay.
2:32:15 You'll probably see it back.
2:32:16 This doesn't approve the project.
2:32:17 Right.
2:32:18 Just see any contracts or anything coming up.
2:32:19 We are currently trying to finish up the environmental review that we have to do for
2:32:23 the area before we can actually use any money.
2:32:32 So once that gets finished and we start looking towards awarding contracts for the bathroom
2:32:36 or anything else, that all comes back to you.
2:32:39 Thank you.
2:32:41 Thank you all.
2:32:42 So that is the last item on the agenda, the exception of an action item to adjourn into executive session under section 74-2061B to consider the evaluation dismissal or disciplining of or to hear complaints or charges against, brought against public officer, employees, staff member or individual agent or public school student.
2:33:09 Thank you, Alex.
2:33:13 Motion by Alex.
2:33:16 Seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve moving into executive session.
2:33:21 Under 74-2061-B.
2:33:24 Amy Roll, call vote, please.
2:33:26 Spencer Cutler.
2:33:27 Yes.
2:33:28 Ruth Pierce.
2:33:29 Yes.
2:33:30 Chris Reed.
2:33:31 Yes.
2:33:32 Thank you, Boyd.
2:33:33 Yes.
2:33:34 Craig Hawkins.
2:33:35 Jason Brown.
2:33:36 What?
2:33:37 And Alex Kaval.
2:33:38 Yes.
2:33:39 more adjourned.
Download
- Transcript (text) 139 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 181 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 241 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.3 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 15.1 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, December 5, 2022. The recording started at 16:29 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:33:47.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
01c524182964bb701e9a90132891cd856f471d169b592a469bf22a892c7778c3 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a d9834abd4224278dfff38067fe0746b5dcb72325130fd33b81d052e0155cca61
part02.m4a 54071b062c05a4b4273a5bb0907c613e90d7380cd383ec98579a63697041ddb6 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
3f2519ed1437d7ef858f48cb6b38a49c5da4779ff1785c75188140e4214111da
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file